Skip to contentSkip to Braille Studio
ALB Wiki

MyWikiBiz

MyWikiBiz was the first openly commercial Wikipedia editing service, and its 2006 ban was the opening shot in a conflict over paid editing that the encyclopedia is still fighting. Founded by market researcher Gregory Kohs, the service offered a simple product — a properly formatted, source-cited Wikipedia article about your business, for $49–$99 — and was shut down personally by Jimmy Wales within months, making Kohs the first test case of a rule that didn't yet formally exist.[1]

The service and the ban

Kohs's pitch was deliberately transparent: unlike covert PR editing, MyWikiBiz would write articles openly, follow Wikipedia's formatting and sourcing conventions, and post them under disclosed usernames. He argued this was strictly better than the covert alternative — companies would pay for Wikipedia presence whether it was permitted or not, so the honest version deserved to exist.

Wales disagreed categorically. In August 2006, citing conflict of interest, he blocked Kohs and barred MyWikiBiz content. The compromise floated afterward — MyWikiBiz could draft articles in its own userspace, where uninvolved volunteers could review and move them to article space if they met standards — collapsed almost immediately, and Kohs's accounts remained banned.

The dissident

What distinguished MyWikiBiz from every later paid-editing scandal was what Kohs did next: rather than slinking away, he became Wikipedia's most persistent critic from the left of the issue — arguing that the encyclopedia's stated openness was a sham if outsiders couldn't honestly declare an interest and participate. He ran Wikipedia-criticism forums (including the Wikipedia Review successor communities), documented paid-editing hypocrisies, and repeatedly demonstrated that undisclosed paid editing thrived precisely because the honest version had been banned. The Wiki-PR and Orangemoody operations — covert, sockpuppet-driven, dishonest by design — were, in his framing, the market the ban had created.

Legacy

MyWikiBiz fixed the terms of the debate that ran for the next decade: is paid editing inherently corrupt, or is undisclosed paid editing the actual problem? Wikipedia's eventual answer — the 2014 Terms of Use amendment requiring disclosure, not prohibition — was closer to Kohs's position than to the 2006 ban's spirit, a vindication he has not been slow to claim. The incident is the genealogy's first entry: every paid-editing policy on the site descends from the argument Kohs lost.[2]

See also

References

  1. Associated Press / contemporary press — coverage of the MyWikiBiz ban (August 2006).
  2. Kohs, Gregory — public statements and Wikipedia Review discussions documenting the dispute (2006 onward).
  3. Wikipedia community records — the block log and the Jimmy Wales–Kohs exchange; primary source material.

Footnotes

  1. ↑ List of Wikipedia controversies
  2. ↑ Criticism of Wikipedia
Categories: History · Internet · Reference · Wiki
This page was last edited 2026-11-22 22:09:04 UTC by ALB Team. What links here