Skip to contentSkip to Braille Studio
ALB Wiki

Maurice Jarre quote hoax

The Maurice Jarre quote hoax was a deliberate experiment in misinformation that succeeded beyond its author's expectations: within hours of composer Maurice Jarre's death in March 2009, a Dublin student planted invented quotes in his Wikipedia biography — and watched as obituaries in major newspapers around the world repeated them as fact. It remains the cleanest demonstration of the citogenesis mechanism: Wikipedia's errors don't stay on Wikipedia; they flow into sources that then cite themselves back.[1]

The experiment

When the Oscar-winning composer died on 28 March 2009, Shane Fitzgerald — a sociology student at University College Dublin — added fabricated quotes to his Wikipedia biography within hours: lyrical reflections on music and mortality of precisely the kind obituary writers reach for. He left them deliberately uncited. His hypothesis: journalists on deadline would copy them.

They did. Within days, the invented Jarre quotes appeared in obituaries published by newspapers of record across three continents — the Guardian, the Irish Times, and others — laundered through the professional press into the permanent historical record. Some outlets, caught later, had to publish corrections to their own obituaries.

The reveal

Fitzgerald exposed his own experiment roughly a week later, telling the Irish Times what he had done and why — a student demonstration of how the modern news cycle amplifies unverified material. The episode was widely covered as a media-ethics case study: the journalists blamed Wikipedia for hosting the quotes; Wikipedia's defenders noted that the quotes were uncited, and that professional obituary writers had skipped the verification they were paid to perform. Both things were true.

Significance

Jarre is the canonical counterpoint to "Wikipedia is self-correcting." Self-correction had, in fact, failed — the quotes survived long enough to metastasize. But the deeper finding is about the loop: journalists copying Wikipedia, Wikipedia citing journalists, each laundering the other. Later hoaxes — the Brazilian aardvark, Alan MacMasters — would demonstrate the same machinery at longer timescales and greater cost. The experiment is now standard curriculum in journalism schools, the single most-quoted case of "where did this fact come from?" having the answer a student's prank.[2]

See also

References

  1. Irish Times — Fitzgerald's self-exposure and the paper's own correction (April 2009).
  2. The Guardian — corrected obituary and editorial commentary on the hoax (2009).
  3. BBC / wire coverage of the experiment's media-ethics fallout (April 2009).

Footnotes

  1. ↑ List of Wikipedia controversies
  2. ↑ Criticism of Wikipedia
Categories: History · Internet · Reference · Wiki
This page was last edited 2026-11-22 22:09:04 UTC by ALB Team. What links here