Flagged revisions
Flagged revisions — pending changes on English Wikipedia — is the mechanism that splits editing from publishing: on articles where it is enabled, edits from new or unregistered accounts don't go live immediately but sit in a queue until a trusted reviewer approves them. It is the clearest technical expression of the model's central compromise — anyone can edit, but not everything gets published immediately — and it was born, like most of Wikipedia's guardrails, in the aftermath of the Seigenthaler incident.[1]
How it works
On a pending-changes article, the reader sees the last approved version — the version a reviewer has checked — not the raw latest edit. New edits wait in a review queue where volunteer "pending changes reviewers" inspect them: obvious vandalism is rejected; constructive edits are approved and go live. The result is a two-tier publication system: trusted editors' changes appear instantly, newcomers' changes wait for a gate.
Why it's rarer on English
Pending changes exists on English Wikipedia but is applied selectively — its broad deployment was debated for years, and the English edition settled on using it primarily on BLP-sensitive articles and persistent vandalism targets rather than universally. The German Wikipedia and several other language editions adopted it far more broadly — flagged revisions on every article — becoming the standing counter-example to the claim that review-gating would kill the collaborative model. The different adoption levels are a natural experiment in the trade-off: more review, less immediacy; less review, more risk.
Significance
Flagged revisions is the technical solution to the problem BLP solves legally: the model's vulnerability to harmful content that looks fine at first glance. It doesn't eliminate the risk — a determined vandal can craft edits that pass review — but it closes the most obvious hole: the instant-live edit that sits unexamined for months. Its existence is the reason "anyone can edit" needs an asterisk in 2025: anyone can propose an edit; the project's reviewers decide when it publishes.[2]
See also
- Biographies of living persons · Oversight tool — the protective machinery it sits alongside
- Seigenthaler incident — the crisis that created the need
- List of Wikipedia controversies · Reliability of Wikipedia · Criticism of Wikipedia
- Edit war · Wikipedia editor decline
References
- Wikipedia — the pending-changes/flagged-revisions documentation; primary source material.
- Wikipedia community records — the English edition's adoption debates and the German Wikipedia's universal deployment.
Footnotes
- ↑ Wikipedia pending-changes documentation
- ↑ Reliability of Wikipedia