Biographies of living persons
Biographies of living persons — BLP — is the most important single policy on Wikipedia: the rule that contentious material about living people must be impeccably sourced or removed immediately, no discussion needed, with violations treated more severely than almost any other content problem. It exists because of one scandal — the Seigenthaler incident — and it remains the most aggressively enforced rule the site has.[1]
What it requires
The policy inverts the burden of proof for the riskiest content on the site. Where a normal claim requires a source to be cited, a BLP claim about a living person — anything contentious, negative, or potentially defamatory — requires an impeccable source, and unsourced or poorly sourced contentious material must be removed on sight, not tagged for discussion or left for consensus. Three consequences follow:
- Immediate removal — BLP violations can be removed without the usual three-revert-rule limits on edit-warring; removing them is not just permitted but required.
- Sourcing at the highest bar — "reliable source" means high-quality here: mainstream outlets, academic works, primary documents. Self-published material, blogs, and tabloid innuendo don't qualify, and contentious claims need multiple corroborating sources.
- Protection mechanisms — biographies can be locked under higher-tier protection; the Oversight tool exists largely to suppress BLP violations from history; and unregistered users can't create articles at all (a rule that itself dates to the post-Seigenthaler reforms).
Why it matters beyond the rulebook
BLP is the model's clearest admission that "anyone can edit" has a floor — and that the floor is human cost. Before BLP, the system tolerated the risk that a biography could carry false defamatory content for months, because the correction machinery assumed someone would eventually notice. Seigenthaler proved that assumption could be wrong in the most damaging way possible — and that the victim, not the site, absorbs the cost in the meantime. The policy is, in effect, Wikipedia's acknowledgment that on living people, "eventually" isn't good enough.
The limits
BLP is also the most-frequently-cited limit of the model's self-image. It works well on watched biographies — the famous get their articles policed within minutes — and badly on the same long tail everything else fails on: the unremarkable, the private, the forgotten. A BLP violation on an obscure person's biography is the same invisible vandalism as a hoax on an obscure historical article — the difference is that the person defamed is real and findable, and the harm is personal rather than encyclopedic. The policy reduced the rate of the worst failures; it did not eliminate the structural vulnerability that produced them.[2]
See also
- Seigenthaler incident — the scandal that created it
- Criticism of Wikipedia · Reliability of Wikipedia · List of Wikipedia controversies
- Oversight tool · Flagged revisions — the technical machinery behind it
- Edit war · Arbitration Committee
References
- Wikipedia — the Biographies of living persons policy page; primary source material.
- Seigenthaler, John — the USA Today op-ed and the subsequent policy discussions (2005).
- Wikipedia community records — the post-2005 rule evolution; primary source material.
Footnotes
- ↑ Wikipedia BLP policy
- ↑ Reliability of Wikipedia