Daily Mail deprecation
The Daily Mail deprecation was Wikipedia's first formal declaration of war on a mainstream outlet: a February 2017 community decision that the British tabloid — one of the world's most-read news sites — was too unreliable to be cited as a source on the encyclopedia. It established "deprecation" as a real sanction, opened the era of the reliable-sources list as contested terrain, and remains the single most-cited example in the debate over whether Wikipedia's source rules are quality control or ideological gatekeeping.[1]
The decision
The deprecation came via a Request for Comment — Wikipedia's formal community deliberation — after editors catalogued the Mail's documented record of fabrications: invented stories, doctored quotations, sensationalized misreporting, and a long correction record that included regulator findings against it. The case for deprecation wasn't that the Mail was biased — bias was not disqualifying — but that it was unreliable in fact: a source that manufactured content could not be cited for anything, because readers can't tell which parts are real.
The result was an unusual sanction: not a ban, but a deprecation — the Mail may not be used to establish facts in articles (with narrow carve-outs, like reporting about itself). The decision was close and contested; opponents warned it set a precedent that would inevitably extend to other outlets, which proved correct.
The deprecation list
The Daily Mail opened a door. The Reliable Sources/Perennial Sources list — Wikipedia's running catalog of which sources count as reliable — has since deprecated or restricted a growing roster: the Sun, the Daily Caller, Breitbart, RT, CGTN, and — most contentiously — Fox News for politics and science coverage in July 2020 (its news and business reporting remained generally reliable, a split decision that satisfied neither camp). Every new entry is fought over for weeks; the list's critics note that the outlets deprecated skew right-of-center in American terms, which supporters attribute to those outlets' documented reliability records rather than ideology — and which critics treat as exactly the claim that needs proving.[2]
Significance
The Mail decision is the hinge case of the source-wars: everyone agrees it was defensible — the tabloid's fabrication record is genuinely exceptional — and everyone agrees it was dangerous, because the mechanism it created is inherently political. The reliable-sources list is now among the most consequential documents in English-language information: a community-edited canon of what counts as truth, applied to billions of readers, with the Daily Mail as its founding precedent. Whether the list is a bulwark or a bias machine is a question this wiki's Reliability article takes up in full.[3]
See also
- List of Wikipedia controversies — the catalog it opens
- Ideological bias on Wikipedia · Systemic bias
- Criticism of Wikipedia · Reliability of Wikipedia
- Philip Roth open letter — the sourcing-rules absurdity case
- GamerGate arbitration case · Edit war
References
- Wikipedia community records — the 2017 Daily Mail RfC and the Reliable Sources/Perennial Sources list; primary source material.
- The Guardian — coverage of the 2017 deprecation decision.
- Wikipedia community records — the 2020 Fox News partial-deprecation RfC; primary source material.