,,ii #aaith ,,congress #b;d ,session ,s4 #ejgg ,,in ,,the ,,senate ,,of ,,the ,,united ,,states ,july #bb1 #bjbf,mr4 ,bennet 7for himself and ,ms4 ,blunt ,rochester7 introduced the following bill2 which was read twice and referred to the ,committee on ,health1 ,education1 ,labor1 and ,pensions ,a ,,bill ,to authorize workforce development innovation grants for the implementation1 expansion1 and evaluation of evidence-based workforce programs1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,better ,jobs through ,evidence and ,innovation ,act4 #b4 ,evaluations and research 7a7 ,in general ,section #afi of the ,workforce ,innovation and ,opportunity ,act 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #cbbd7 is amended-- 7#a7 by redesignating subsection 7c7 as subsection 7d72 and 7#b7 by inserting after subsection 7b7 the following3 7c7 ,workforce development innovation fund 7#a7 ,program authorized 7,a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary may1 on a competitive basis and in accordance with subparagraph 7,b71 award workforce development innovation grants described in subparagraph 7,c7 to eligible entities to enable such entities to-- 7i7 establish1 implement1 replicate1 or take to scale evidence-based1 field-initiated innovation programs or services for improving the design and delivery of employment and training services-- 7,i7 that generate demonstrated sustained improvements in earnings and employment outcomes for participants 7including participants who are individuals with barriers to employment72 and 7,,ii7 that may demonstrate improvements in-- 7aa7 the performance or impact of the workforce development system with respect to the purposes of this ,act described in section #b 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #caja71 such as increasing access to and opportunities for employment1 education1 training1 and support services for individuals with barriers to employment2 7bb7 addressing employer and labor market needs2 or 7cc7 the cost-effectiveness of such innovation programs or services1 particularly for participants and communities not sufficiently served by existing models such as participants and communities in rural areas2 and 7ii7 except with respect to an expansion grant described in subparagraph 7,c77iii7 for which the ,secretary waives an evaluation because the ,secretary determines there are multiple compelling examples of high-level evidence1 perform-- 7,i7 a well-designed1 well-implemented1 and rigorous impact evaluation1 through a partnership with a third-party research organization or a third-party researcher1 of such innovation programs or services that-- 7aa7 assesses for effectiveness in achieving any demonstrated long-term improvements in earnings and employment outcomes for participants and for improvements in other relevant outcomes1 such as the outcomes described in item 7aa71 7bb71 and 7cc7 of clause 7i77,,ii72 and 7bb7 is accompanied by a process or implementation evaluation for the purpose of programmatic improvement and supporting scale-up2 or 7,,ii7 in the case of an early-phase grant described in subparagraph 7,c77i71 an early-stage evaluation 7such as a feasibility study1 pilot1 or rapid-cycle evaluation7 that prepares the innovation program or service for an evaluation described in subclause 7,i7 for a potential subsequent grant4 7,b7 ,grant awards 7i7 ,in general ,the ,secretary-- 7,i7 shall award grants under subparagraph 7,a7 on the primary basis of-- 7aa7 reliable evidence presented with respect to potential achievements of the innovation program or service proposed by the eligible entity with respect to demonstrated1 long-term improvements in an outcome described in subclause 7,i7 or 7,,ii7 of subparagraph 7,a77i72 7bb7 the anticipated cost of the program or service relative to anticipated earnings and employment outcomes for participants2 7cc7 the anticipated contribution of the evaluation of the program or service to the overall evidence base1 including evidence on cost-effectiveness2 and 7dd7 the existence of supporting projects in geographically diverse sites1 including rural areas1 or that serve populations with diverse needs2 and 7,,ii7 may award1 under subparagraph 7,a71 different types of grants described under subparagraph 7,c7 to an eligible entity for separate innovation programs or services that meet the relevant criteria for such different types of grants4 7ii7 ,duration of award ,a grant awarded under subparagraph 7,a7 shall be awarded for a period determined appropriate by the ,secretary4 7iii7 ,amount of award ,the ,secretary shall ensure that any grants awarded under subparagraph 7,a7 shall include sufficient funding for the cost of the evaluation and program implementation4 7iv7 ,use of award ,an eligible entity that receives a grant awarded under subparagraph 7,a7 shall use not less than #fj percent of such award for direct program implementation4 7,c7 ,description of grants ,the grants described in subparagraph 7,a7 shall1 to the extent feasible1 include-- 7i7 early-phase grants for an innovation program or service supported by any level of evidence described in clause 7i71 7ii71 or 7iii7 of subparagraph 7,d71 for the purposes of funding the development1 implementation1 and evaluation of such program or service2 7ii7 mid-phase grants for an innovation program or service supported by a moderate level of evidence or a high level of evidence 7as described in clause 7ii7 or 7iii7 of subparagraph 7,d71 respectively7 for the purposes of funding the operation1 refinement1 expansion1 and continued evaluation 7as described in subparagraph 7,a77ii77,i77 of such innovation program or service at a single site that would1 if successful1 prepare the program or service for a subsequent expansion grant2 and 7iii7 expansion grants for an innovation program or service supported by a high level of evidence1 as described in subparagraph 7,d77iii71 for the purposes of-- 7,i7 funding the operation of such innovation program or service at an existing site2 7,,ii7 expansion or such innovation program or service to another site2 7,,iii7 implementation of a multi-site experimental rigorous impact evaluation of such innovation program or service2 and 7,,iv7 if necessary1 continued refinement and adaption of the program or service model to address new contexts or needs4 7,d7 ,level of evidence standards ,the levels of evidence described in this subparagraph are the following3 7i7 ,low level of evidence ,an innovation program or service is supported by a low level of evidence if such program or service has demonstrated1 through a reasonable hypothesis and credible research findings 7such as a correlational study with statistical controls for selection bias71 a descriptive study 7such as a case study71 or evidence review and needs assessment1 the-- 7,i7 ability to achieve positive effects on earnings and employment outcomes for participants 7including participants who are individuals with barriers to employment7 and earnings for employers2 or 7,,ii7 potential to achieve such effect on such outcomes4 7ii7 ,moderate level of evidence ,an innovation program or service is supported by a moderate level of evidence if such program or service has demonstrated the ability to achieve sizable1 but not yet conclusive1 positive effects on earnings and employment outcomes for participants 7including participants who are individuals with barriers to employment7 and earnings for employers1 through-- 7,i7 a well-designed and well-implemented experimental study of such program or service1 such as a randomized controlled trial2 or 7,,ii7 a rigorous quasi-experimental study of such program or service capable of drawing causal conclusions about the effectiveness of such program or service4 7iii7 ,high level of evidence ,an innovation program or service is supported by a high level of evidence if such program or service has demonstrated1 through replication of studies1 the ability to achieve a substantial and statistically significant1 positive impact on earnings and employment outcomes for participants 7including participants who are individuals with barriers to employment7 and earnings for employers1 through-- 7,i7 #b or more well-designed and well-implemented experimental studies of such program or service conducted at different implementation sites2 or 7,,ii7 through a well-designed and well-implemented large1 multi-site1 experimental study4 7,e7 ,funding allocation ,of the funds made available to carry out this subsection for a fiscal year1 the ,secretary shall1 except when determined that there is not a sufficient number of qualifying applications to do so1 use-- 7i7 not less than #ej percent of such funds to award expansion grants described in subparagraph 7,c77iii72 and 7ii7 not more than #be percent of such funds to award early-phase grants described in subparagraph 7,c77i74 7#b7 ,technical assistance and evaluation research ,of the funds made available to carry out this subsection for a fiscal year1 the ,secretary shall reserve not more than #aj percent of the funds to-- 7,a7 provide technical assistance to eligible entities1 which may include preapplication workshops1 web-based seminars1 support for conducting feasibility studies and other planning activities1 assistance with methods and requirements for purposes of evaluation research under subparagraph 7,d71 and support for improving grant implementation and the quality and effectiveness of activities and services funded by grants awarded under paragraph 7#a77;,a71 including the use of administrative data and information to improve outcomes for participants2 7,b7 disseminate information on low-1 moderate-1 and high-evidence-based practices2 7,c7 fund staffing and other costs related to such activities2 and 7,d7 conduct evaluation research regarding activities or services funded by grants awarded under subparagraph 7,a74 7#c7 ,definitions ,in this subsection3 7,a7 ,eligible entity ,the term eligible entity means an entity that is any of the following3 7i7 ,a ,state workforce development board established under section #aja 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #caaa74 7ii7 ,a local workforce development board established under section #ajg 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #cabb74 7iii7 ,an ,indian tribe1 tribal organization1 ,alaska ,native entity1 ,indian-controlled organization serving ,indians1 or ,native ,hawaiian organization that is eligible to receive an award under section #aff 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #cbba74 7iv7 ,an institution of higher education 7as defined in section #aja of the ,higher ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ajja774 7v7 ,a ,state workforce agency4 7vi7 ,an organization-- 7,i7 that-- 7aa7 is a community-based organization1 a nonprofit organization1 or a nongovernment organization1 including a labor organization 7as defined in section #b of the ,national ,labor ,relations ,act 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #aeb772 and 7bb7 serves an underserved population2 or 7,,ii7 that is a national or regional organization that intends to use funds awarded under this ,act to make direct grants to an organization described in subclause 7,i74 7vii7 ,a consortium of any entities described in clause 7i7 through 7vi74 7,b7 ,field-initiated ,the term field-initiated1 with respect to a program or service1 means a program or service in which the elements of the program or service have been developed by practitioners or researchers in the policy area1 including such a program or service model that is-- 7i7 a sectoral employment program2 7ii7 an employment social enterprise or other revenue-generating workforce program serving people overcoming barriers to employment2 7iii7 a registered apprenticeship2 7iv7 a re-entry initiative2 7v7 a career pathway model2 7vi7 an industry and sector partnership2 or 7vii7 on-the-job or incumbent worker training4 7,c7 ,innovation program or service ,the term innovation program or service means a program or service designed to demonstrate innovative and cost-effective ways to augment and improve employment1 licensure1 or training services4 7,d7 ,well-designed and well-implemented experimental study ,the term well-designed and well-implemented experimental study means a study that-- 7i7 is replicable2 7ii7 uses programmatic and control groups that are representative of the type of population served by the program or service that is subject to the study1 including by avoiding over-selection of participants who are highly skilled prior to participation for such programmatic group2 7iii7 uses controls for aggregate shifts that might affect baseline numbers2 7iv7 does not have problems with attrition of participants from the study2 7v7 is conducted in a manner that is consistent with applicable evaluation1 data1 and privacy standards and practices described in the ,foundations for ,evidence-,based ,policymaking ,act of #bjah 7,public ,law #aae-dce2 #acb ,stat4 #eebi7 and the amendments made by that ,act2 and 7vi7 to the extent feasible1 is aligned with the standards for experimental studies conducted pursuant to the education innovation and research program under section #dfaa of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #gbfa74 7#d7 ,authorization of appropriations ,there are authorized to be appropriated to carry out this subsection1 such sums as may be necessary for each of the fiscal years #bjbg through #bjca4 4 7b7 ,conforming amendment ,section #acb7;a77#b77;,a7 of the ,workforce ,innovation and ,opportunity ,act 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #cagb7;a77#b77;,a77 is amended by striking #afi7;c7 and inserting #afi7;d74