,,iv #aaith ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,,res4 #dae ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,may #ae1 #bjbe,mr4 ,green of ,texas submitted the following resolution2 which was referred to the ,committee on the ,judiciary ,,resolution ,impeaching ,donald ,john ,trump1 ,president of the ,united ,states1 of high crimes and misdemeanors4 ,that ,donald ,john ,trump1 ,president of the ,united ,states1 is unfit to be ,president1 unfit to represent the ,american values of decency and morality1 respectability and civility1 honesty and propriety1 reputability and integrity1 is unfit to defend the ideals that have made ,america great1 is unfit to defend liberty and justice for all as extolled in the ,pledge of ,allegiance1 is unfit to defend the ,american ideal of all persons being created equal as exalted in the ,declaration of ,independence1 is unfit to ensure domestic tranquility1 promote the general welfare and to ensure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity as lauded in the preamble to the ,united ,states ,constitution1 is unfit to protect government of the people1 by the people1 for the people as elucidated in the ,gettysburg ,address1 and is impeached for high crimes and misdemeanors1 that the following ,article of ,impeachment be exhibited to the ,united ,states ,senate3 ,article of ,impeachment exhibited by the ,house of ,representatives of the ,united ,states of ,america1 in the name of itself1 and of the people of the ,united ,states of ,america1 against ,donald ,john ,trump1 ,president of the ,united ,states of ,america1 in maintenance and support of its impeachment against him for high crimes and misdemeanors committed as ,president of the ,united ,states constituting harm to ,american society to the manifest injury of the people of the ,united ,states of ,america4 ,,article ,i ,devolving democracy within the ,united ,states into authoritarianism with himself 7,donald ,john ,trump7 as an authoritarian ,president4 ,merriam-,webster defines authoritarianism as1 relating to1 or favoring a concentration of power in a leader or an elite not constitutionally responsible to the people4 ,the ,constitution provides that the ,house of ,representatives 8shall have the sole ,power of ,impeachment0 and that the ,president shall be removed from ,office on ,impeachment for1 and ,conviction of1 ,treason1 ,bribery1 or other high ,crimes and ,misdemeanors4 ,in his conduct while ,president of the ,united ,states--and in violation of his constitutional oath faithfully to execute the office of ,president of the ,united ,states and1 to the best of his ability1 preserve1 protect1 and defend the ,constitution of the ,united ,states1 and in violation of his constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed--,donald ,john ,trump engaged in high ,crimes and ,misdemeanors1 causing the devolution of democracy within the ,united ,states of ,america into authoritarianism with himself as an authoritarian ,president4 ,early in his campaign1 ,president ,trump indicated his dictatorial_/authoritarian intentions4 ,on ,december #e1 #bjbc1 ,fox ,news aired a town hall interview hosted by ,sean ,hannity with then-candidate1 ,donald ,trump1 where he was asked1 ,under no circumstances1 you are promising ,america tonight1 you would never abuse power as retribution against anybody1 to which1 ,trump replied1 ,except for day one4 ,in speaking to the audience1 ,trump1 referring to ,hannity1 said1 ,we love this guy4 ,he says you're not going to be a dictator1 are you8 ,i said1 no1 no1 no4 ,other than day one4 ,we're closing the border and we're drilling1 drilling1 drilling4 ,after that1 ,i'm not a dictator4 ,okay8 ,unfortunately1 ,president ,trump's authoritarianism did not end on day one1 but instead continued through condoning the undermining of the judicial independence of the ,federal judiciary1 disregarding the separation of powers1 violating the due process clause in the ,fifth ,amendment of the ,united ,states ,constitution1 denigrating ,federal judges1 condoning the flouting of orders of ,united ,states ,federal ,courts1 including orders of the ,united ,states ,supreme ,court1 in that3 ,on ,wednesday1 ,april #af1 #bjbe1 ,james ,e4 ,boasberg1 ,chief ,judge ,united ,states ,district ,court for the ,district of ,columbia found that probable cause existed to hold the ,trump ,administration defendants in contempt for a willful disregard for its order4 ,the relevant part of the ,memorandum ,opinion stated as follows3 7#a7 ,on the evening of ,saturday1 ,march #ae1 #bjbe1 this ,court issued a written ,temporary ,restraining ,order ,,tro barring the ,government from transferring certain individuals into foreign custody pursuant to the ,alien ,enemies ,act4 ,at the time the ,order issued1 those individuals were on planes being flown overseas1 having been spirited out of the ,united ,states by the ,government before they could vindicate their due-process rights by contesting their removability in a ,federal court1 as the law requires 4 4 4 ,rather than comply with the ,court's ,order1 the ,government continued the hurried removal operation4 ,early on ,sunday morning--hours after the ,order issued--it transferred two planeloads of passengers protected by the ,,tro into a ,salvadoran mega-prison4 7#b7 ,as this ,opinion will detail1 the ,court ultimately determines that the ,government's actions on that day ,march #af1 #bjbe demonstrate a willful disregard for its ,order1 sufficient for the ,court to conclude that probable cause exists to find the ,government in criminal contempt4 ,the ,court does not reach such conclusion lightly or hastily2 indeed1 it has given ,defendants ample opportunity to rectify or explain their actions4 ,none of their responses has been satisfactory4 7#c7 ,one might nonetheless ask how this inquiry into compliance is able to proceed at all given that the ,supreme ,court vacated the ,,tro after the events in question4 ,that ,court's later determination that the ,,tro suffered from a legal defect1 however1 does not excuse the ,government's violation4 ,instead1 it is a foundational legal precept that every judicial order must be obeyed--no matter how erroneous it may be--until a court reverses it4 7#d7 ,if a party chooses to disobey the order--rather than wait for it to be reversed through the judicial process--such disobedience is punishable as contempt1 notwithstanding any later-revealed deficiencies in the order ''' ,that foundational #8rule of law' answers not just how this compliance inquiry can proceed1 but why it must4 7#e7 ,the rule reflects a belief that in the fair administration of justice no man can be judge in his own case1 no matter how exalted his station or righteous his motives4 7#f7 ,the ,constitution does not tolerate willful disobedience of judicial orders--especially by officials of a coordinate branch who have sworn an oath to uphold it4 ,to permit such officials to freely annul the judgments of the courts of the ,united ,states would not just destroy the rights acquired under those judgments2 it would make a solemn mockery of the constitution itself4 7#g7 ,so fatal a result must be deprecated by all4 7#h7 ,for the foregoing reasons1 the ,court will find probable cause that ,defendants' actions constitute contempt4 ,it will provide them an opportunity to purge such contempt4 ,if they opt not to do so1 the ,court will proceed to identify the contemnor7s7 and refer the matter for prosecution4 ,a separate ,order so stating will issue this day4 ,on ,march #ah1 #bjbe1 ,president ,trump published a statement denigrating and calling for the impeachment of a judge4 ,in relevant part1 the statement averred as follows3 7#a7 ,this ,radical ,left ,lunatic of a ,judge1 a troublemaker and agitator who was sadly appointed by ,barack ,hussein ,obama1 was not elected ,president4 7#b7 ,this judge1 like many of the ,crooked ,judges' ,i am forced to appear before1 should be ,,impeached ,on ,march #ah1 #bjbe1 ,,npr published an article related to the ,president of the ,united ,states of ,america1 reporting on the ,president's call for a judge to be impeached4 ,in relevant part1 the article stated as follows3 7#a7 ,without naming ,james ,boasberg1 the chief judge of the district court of ,washington1 ,,dc1 ,trump said1 ,this judge1 like many of the ,crooked ,judges' ,i am forced to appear before1 should be ,,impeached' ,he also called ,boasberg a #8,radical ,left ,lunatic of a ,judge1 a troublemaker and agitator who was sadly appointed by ,barack ,hussein ,obama4 7#b7 ,reacting to the ,president's social media post1 ,chief ,justice ,john ,roberts issued a written statement of his own3 ,for more than two centuries it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreements concerning a judicial decision4 ,the normal appellate review process exists for that purpose4 ,on ,april #aj1 #bjbe1 the ,supreme ,court issued opinion ,no4 #bd;,a#idi regarding the ,trump ,administration's request to vacate an injunction issued by the ,u4,s4 ,district ,court for the ,district of ,maryland4 ,the court's unanimous judgment and reasoning in opinion ,no4 #bd;,a#idi 7available for perusal71 in relevant part1 stated3 7#a7 ,on ,march #ae1 #bjbe1 the ,united ,states removed ,kilmar ,armando ,abrego ,garcia from the ,united ,states to ,el ,salvador1 where he is currently detained in the ,center for ,terrorism ,confinement 7,,cecot74 ,the ,united ,states acknowledges that ,abrego ,garcia was subject to a withholding order forbidding his removal to ,el ,salvador1 and that the removal to ,el ,salvador was therefore illegal4 ,the ,united ,states represents that the removal to ,el ,salvador was the result of an administrative error4 7#b7 ,the ,united ,states ,district ,court for the ,district of ,maryland's order properly requires the ,government to facilitate ,abrego ,garcia's release from custody in ,el ,salvador and to ensure that his case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to ,el ,salvador4 ,further in the statement of ,justice ,sotomayor1 with whom ,justice ,kagan and ,justice ,jackson join1 respecting the ,court's disposition of the application averred that3 7#a7 ,the ,united ,states ,government arrested ,kilmar ,armando ,abrego ,garcia in ,maryland and flew him to a #8terrorism confinement center' in ,el ,salvador1 where he has been detained for #bf days and counting4 ,to this day1 the ,government has cited no basis in law for ,abrego ,garcia's warrantless arrest1 his removal to ,el ,salvador1 or his confinement in a ,salvadoran prison4 ,nor could it4 ,the ,government remains bound by an ,immigration ,judge's #bjai order expressly prohibiting ,abrego ,garcia's removal to ,el ,salvador because he faced a clear probability of future persecution there and demonstrated that ,el ,salvador's authorities were and would be unable or unwilling to protect him4 7#b7 ,the ,government has not challenged the validity of that order4 ,instead of hastening to correct its egregious error1 the ,government dismissed it as an oversight4 7#c7 ,the ,government's argument1 moreover1 implies that it could deport and incarcerate any person1 including ,u4,s4 citizens1 without legal consequence1 so long as it does so before a court can intervene4 ,on ,april #ad1 #bjbe1 days after the ,supreme ,court issued the above opinion ,no4 #bd;,a#idi1 in a meeting with ,president ,nayib ,bukele of ,el ,salvador1 ,attorney ,general ,pamela ,bondi1 ,secretary of ,state ,marco ,rubio1 and ,white ,house ,deputy ,chief of ,staff ,stephen ,miller--,president ,donald ,trump was present and condoned their untruthful statements opposing the courts opinion related to ,abrego ,garcia's removal from the ,united ,states and the ,supreme ,court's order to facilitate his return4 ,the meeting was recorded by ,c-,,span4 ,in the meeting1 ,president ,trump condoned and defended the untruths that undermine the ,fifth ,amendment mandate of due process prior to the removal of citizens and non-citizens from the ,united ,states of ,america4 ,c-,,span reported the following3 8,president ,trump ,meets with ,president of ,el ,salvador3 ,during an ,oval ,office meeting with ,salvadoran ,president ,nayib ,bukele1 ,president ,donald ,trump and members of his administration argued they were not required to return deported ,salvadoran citizen ,kilmar ,abrego ,garcia to the ,united ,states1 in spite of the ,supreme ,court ruling in favor of facilitating his return4 ,president ,bukele himself said that he was not authorized to return ,mr4 ,garcia1 who was legally present in the ,u4,s4 before being deported in ,march4 ,the ,trump administration alleged that he was a member of the ,,ms-#ac gang1 but it previously admitted that the deportation was an #8administrative error4'0 ,on ,april #ag1 #bjbe1 days after the ,white ,house meeting referenced above1 the ,united ,states ,court of ,appeals for the ,fourth ,circuit rendered an order exposing1 with meticulous explication1 the untruths utilized--by ,attorney ,general ,pamela ,bondi1 ,secretary of ,state ,marco ,rubio1 ,white ,house ,deputy ,chief of ,staff ,stephen ,miller1 and condoned by ,president ,donald ,trump--to deny due process mandated in the ,fifth ,amendment of the ,constitution4 ,wilkinson1 ,circuit ,judge of the ,united ,states ,court of ,appeals for the ,fourth ,circuit1 with whom ,circuit ,judges ,king and ,thacker join1 stated in relevant part as follows3 7#a7 ,it is difficult in some cases to get to the very heart of the matter4 ,but in this case1 it is not hard at all4 ,the government is asserting a right to stash away residents of this country in foreign prisons without the semblance of due process that is the foundation of our constitutional order4 ,further1 it claims in essence that because it has rid itself of custody that there is nothing that can be done4 ,this should be shocking not only to judges1 but to the intuitive sense of liberty that ,americans far removed from courthouses still hold dear4 ,the government asserts that ,abrego ,garcia is a terrorist and a member of ,,ms-#ac4 ,perhaps1 but perhaps not4 ,regardless1 he is still entitled to due process4 ,if the government is confident of its position1 it should be assured that position will prevail in proceedings to terminate the withholding of removal order 4 4 4 ,moreover1 the government has conceded that ,abrego ,garcia was wrongly or #8mistakenly' deported4 ,why then should it not make what was wrong1 right8 7#b7 ,the ,supreme ,court's decision does not1 however1 allow the government to do essentially nothing4 ,it requires the government to facilitate ,abrego ,garcia's release from custody in ,el ,salvador and to ensure that his case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to ,el ,salvador4''' ,facilitate is an active verb4 ,it requires that steps be taken as the ,supreme ,court has made perfectly clear4 7#c7 ,facilitation does not permit the admittedly erroneous deportation of an individual to the one country's prisons that the withholding order forbids and1 further1 to do so in disregard of a court order that the government not so subtly spurns4 ,facilitation does not sanction the abrogation of habeas corpus through the transfer of custody to foreign detention centers in the manner attempted here4 ,allowing all this would facilitate foreign detention more than it would domestic return4 ,it would reduce the rule of law to lawlessness and tarnish the very values for which ,americans of diverse views and persuasions have always stood4 7#d7 ,if today the ,executive claims the right to deport without due process and in disregard of court orders1 what assurance will there be tomorrow that it will not deport ,american citizens and then disclaim responsibility to bring them home8 ,and what assurance shall there be that the ,executive will not train its broad discretionary powers upon its political enemies8 ,the threat1 even if not the actuality1 would always be present1 and the ,executive's obligation to take ,care that the ,laws be faithfully executed would lose its meaning4 7#e7 ,today1 both the ,united ,states and the ,el ,salvadoran governments disclaim any authority and_/or responsibility to return ,abrego ,garcia4 ,see ,president ,trump ,participates in a ,bilateral ,meeting with the ,president of ,el ,salvador1 ,,white ,,house 7,apr4 #ad1 #bjbe74 ,we are told that neither government has the power to act4 ,the result will be to leave matters generally and ,abrego ,garcia specifically in an interminable limbo without recourse to law of any sort4 7#f7 ,now the branches come too close to grinding irrevocably against one another in a conflict that promises to diminish both4 ,this is a losing proposition all around4 ,the ,judiciary will lose much from the constant intimations of its illegitimacy1 to which by dent of custom and detachment we can only sparingly reply4 ,the ,executive will lose much from a public perception of its lawlessness and all of its attendant contagions4 ,the ,executive may succeed for a time in weakening the courts1 but over time history will script the tragic gap between what was and all that might have been1 and law in time will sign its epitaph4 ,on ,april #bi1 #bjbe1 in an interview with ,,abc ,news1 while discussing the continued detention of ,kilmar ,armando ,abrego ,garcia in ,el ,salvador1 the interviewer said1 ,you could get him back4 ,there's a phone on this desk4 ,president ,donald ,john ,trump replied1 ,i could4 ,notwithstanding all that has been presented above1 the ,trump ,administration continues to flout the ,supreme ,court's ,april #aj1 #bjbe1 order1 to facilitate ,abrego ,garcia's release from custody in ,el ,salvador and to ensure that his case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to ,el ,salvador4 ,on ,may #b1 #bjbe1 ,reuters reported that ,u4,s4 ,supreme ,court ,justice ,ketanji ,brown ,jackson addressed ,president ,donald ,trump's attacks on the judiciary4 ,in relevant part1 the article stated as follows3 7#a7 ,u4,s4 ,supreme ,court ,justice ,ketanji ,brown ,jackson said on ,thursday attacks by ,republican ,president ,donald ,trump and his allies on judges were not random and seemed designed to intimidate the judiciary4 7#b7 ,particularly1 ,u4,s4 ,supreme ,court ,justice ,jackson remarked that1 ,the attacks are not random4 ,they seem designed to intimidate those of us who serve in this critical capacity4 7#c7 ,justice ,jackson added1 ,the threats and harassment are attacks on our democracy1 on our system of government4 ,and they ultimately risk undermining our ,constitution and the rule of law4 ,on ,may #d1 #bjbe1 when asked1 ,president ,trump did not affirm his duty to uphold the ,constitution1 despite his presidential oath to1 faithfully execute the ,office of ,president of the ,united ,states1 and ''' to the best of his ability1 preserve1 protect and defend the ,constitution of the ,united ,states4 ,in an ,,nbc ,news ,meet the ,press interview1 when discussing the facilitation of ,abrego ,garcia's return1 ,president ,trump was asked1 ,the ,constitution says every person1 citizens and non-citizens1 deserve due process ''' ,don't you need to uphold the ,constitution of the ,united ,states as ,president8 to which he responded by saying1 ,i don't know4 ,in all this1 ,president ,donald ,john ,trump gravely endangered the separation of powers within the government and its institutions4 ,he threatened the integrity of the democratic system by condoning the undermining of the judicial independence of the ,federal judiciary1 violating the due process clause in the ,fifth ,amendment of the ,united ,states ,constitution1 denigrating ,federal judges1 ignoring the separation of powers1 condoning the flouting of orders of ,united ,states ,federal ,courts 7including orders of the ,united ,states ,supreme ,court7--all of which have caused the devolution of democracy within the ,united ,states of ,america into authoritarianism with himself as an authoritarian ,president4 ,he thereby betrayed his trust as ,president1 to the manifest injury of the people of the ,united ,states4 ,wherefore1 authoritarian ,president ,donald ,john ,trump1 by such conduct1 has demonstrated that he will remain a threat to democracy and the ,constitution if allowed to remain in office1 and has acted in a manner grossly incompatible with self-governance and the rule of law4 ,donald ,john ,trump thus warrants impeachment1 trial and removal from office1 as he is unfit to be ,president4