,,iv #aai? ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,,res4 #aege ,,9 ,,! ,,h\se ,,( ,,repres5tatives ,septemb] #bd1 #bjbf,mr4 ,coh5 submitt$ ! foll[+ resolution2 :i* 0 ref]r$ to ! ,committee on ! ,judici>y ,,resolution ,impea*+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 ,presid5t ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 = high crimes & misdemeanors4 ,t ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 ,presid5t ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 is impea*$ = high crimes & misdemeanors1 & t ! foll[+ articles ( impea*m5t be exhibit$ to ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,s5ate3 ,articles ( impea*m5t exhibit$ by ! ,h\se ( ,repres5tatives ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica 9 ! "n ( itself & ( ! p ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica1 aga9/ ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 ,presid5t ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica1 9 ma9t5ance & support ( its impea*m5t aga9/ him = high crimes & misdemeanors4 ,article ,i3 ,und]m9+ ,democracy--,s[+ ,d\bt 9 ,elections ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? to fai?fully execute ! (fice ( ,presid5t & to pres]ve1 protect1 & def5d ! ,con/itution ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates by repeat$ly & kn[+ly spread+ false claims t ! #bjbj presid5tial election 0 /ol51 solicit+ & pressur+ election (ficials to unlawfully alt] election results 9 8 favor1 & by baselessly ca/+ d\bt on ! security & accuracy ( ! #bjbf midt]m elections4 ,9 s do+1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump int5tionally und]m9$ public confid5ce 9 ,unit$ ,/ates self-gov]nm5t & endeavor$ to delegitimize any unfavorable electoral outcome4 ,^! ef=ts 7 int5d$ to uncon/itutionally ma9ta9 elect$ (fice & unlawfully ex]cise gov]nm5tal au?ority4 ,^! p]si/5t & delib]ate ef=ts con/itute a patt]n ( conduct4 ,"t & "t aga91 ,f$]al ag5cies h indep5d5tly conclud$ t ! #bjbj election 0 secure1 p]haps ! mo/ secure 9 ,unit$ ,/ates hi/ory4 ,no cr$ible evid5ce %[s t =eign int]f]5ce ) election sy/ems1 or any irregul>ities or misconduct1 compromis$ ! integrity ( ! election & its results4 ,r1 evid5ce f ,special ,c\nsel ,jack ,smi?'s inve/igation demon/rat$ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump 0 told directly1 by 8 own s5ior advisors1 & ,/ate & ,f$]al election (ficials1 t 8 repeat$ claims ( a /ol5 election 7 false4 ,special ,c\nsel ,jack ,smi?'s evid5ce demon/rates ,donald ,j4 ,trump knew ^! claims 7 false4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump cont9u$ 8 campaign ( delegitimization by mock+ & ?reat5+ ^? :o expos$ 8 baseless ef=ts to und]m9e confid5ce 9 ! core infra/ructure ( our democracy4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,july #af1 #bjbf1 9 an unprec$5t$ address f ! ,ea/ ,room ( ! ,:ite ,h\se1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump deliv]$ rem>ks to ! ,nation :i* 7 design$ to revive unsub/antiat$ claims t ! #bjbj election 0 /ol5 & ca/ d\bt on ! security ( ! upcom+ midt]m elections4 ,cit+ purport$ %ock+ vuln]abilities 9 our election infra/ructure1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump declassifi$ & releas$ docum5ts alongside ! spee*4 ,^? docum5ts did n support 8 claims1 & indep5d5t fact-*eck]s f\nd he (f]$ no evid5ce ( ! widespread fraud he alleg$4 7#b7 ,dur+ t same address1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump ?reat5$ t broadca/]s :o decl9$ to air 8 rem>ks %\ld lose _! lic5ses1 fur!r demon/rat+ t ! spee* 0 n a good-fai? ex]cise 9 election security1 b r an ef=t to co]ce favorable cov]age1 amplify falsehoods1 & s[ di/ru/ 9 ! integrity ( our elections4 7#c7 ,9 repeat+ su* false claims1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump kn[+ly p]petuates h>assm5t1 ?reats1 & viol5ce direct$ aga9/ election (ficials4 ,s9ce #bjaf1 :5 ,donald ,j4 ,trump fir/ appe>$ on ! ballot = ,presid5t ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates & began alleg+ t elections 7 rigg$ aga9/ him1 attacks on election (ficials & work]s h gr[n m>k$ly4 ,a #bjbf survey by ! ,br5nan ,c5t] = ,ju/ice f\nd t a ?ird ( local election (ficials knew a colleague :o _h resign$ at lea/ 9 "p out ( fe> = _! safety or because ( ?reats or intimidation1 t a majority fe>$ politically motivat$ int]f]5ce ) _! "w1 & t ne>ly half 7 conc]n$ ab\t politically motivat$ inve/igations ( !mselves or _! pe]s4 ,su* conduct has *as$ exp]i5c$1 nonp>tisan election adm9i/rators f _! po/s & driv5 away civically m9d$ volunte]s alike1 degrad+ ! electoral infra/ructure t ,donald ,j4 ,trump claims he is try+ to protect4 7#d7 ,on ,janu>y #bh1 #bjbf1 at ,donald ,j4 ,trump's direction1 ! ,f$]al ,bureau ( ,inve/igation 7,,fbi7 execut$ a se>* w>rant at ! ,fulton ,c\nty1 ,georgia ,election ,hub & ,op]ation ,c5t] 9 ,union ,city1 seiz+ physical ballots1 ballot images1 tabulator tapes1 & vot] rolls f ! #bjbj election 9 a c\nty he lo/ & _h baselessly accus$ ( fraud = m ?an #e ye>s4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump dispat*$ ,director ( ,national ,intellig5ce ,tulsi ,gabb>d1 an (ficial /atutorily b>r$ f p>ticipat+ 9 dome/ic law en=cem5t1 ^: (fice exi/s to coord9ate & analyze =eign intellig5ce & c\nt]9tellig5ce1 n to police ,unit$ ,/ates ballot boxes1 to ,atlanta to p]sonally ov]see ! se>* w>rant execution4 ,9 t episode1 ,gabb>d us$ h] p]sonal cellphone to call ,donald ,j4 ,trump directly s t he c\ld speak to ! ag5ts by speak]phone & p]sonally ?ank !m = _! "w4 ,by turn+ an in/rum5tality ( national security1 "o /atutorily committ$ exclusively to =eign intellig5ce & c\nt]9tellig5ce "w1 t[>d ! dome/ic seizure ( ballots f a five-ye>-old1 twice-c]tifi$ election1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump demon/rat$ 8 will+ness to turn ! ma*9]y ( ,f$]al intellig5ce & law en=cem5t aga9/ ! ballot box itself :5ev] he refuses to accept a result4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump has und]m9$ ! peaceful transf] ( p[] t is ! f\ndation ( ,unit$ ,/ates con/itutional democracy1 s[n di/ru/ 9 ! electoral process )\t factual basis1 direct$ ! in/rum5ts ( ,f$]al law en=cem5t & intellig5ce t[>d ! physical seizure ( ballots f an election already settl$ = half a decade1 & laid ! rhetorical & op]ational gr\ndwork to conte/ any electoral outcome unfavorable to 8 p>ty 9 advance ( ! #bjbf midt]m elections1 all 9 contrav5tion ( ! republican /ructure ( gov]nm5t at ! core ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,con/itution t ,donald ,j4 ,trump swore to protect & uphold4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,ii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,wag+ ,w> on ,iran ,)\t ,congressional ,approval ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ,article ,i ( ! ,con/itution1 :i* ve/s 9 ,congress alone ! p[] to decl>e w>1 by ord]+ repeat$ milit>y /rikes aga9/ ,iran )\t congressional au?orization1 9 defiance ( ! ,w> ,p[]s ,resolution & ,congress' votes direct+ ! )drawal ( =ces f ho/ilities ) ,iran4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,june #ba to #bb1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump ord]$ coord9at$ /rikes by ,b-#b bomb]s & cruise missiles aga9/ #c major ,iranian nucle> sites 7,=d[1 ,natanz1 & ,isfahan7 )\t fir/ seek+ or obta9+ congressional au?orization = ! use ( milit>y =ce1 & )\t ! #fj day notice-&-au?orization process requir$ by ! ,w> ,p[]s ,resolution4 7#b7 ,9 response1 bip>tisan majorities 9 bo? ! ,h\se ( ,repres5tatives & ! ,s5ate pass$ ,w> ,p[]s ,resolutions 9 ,june #bjbf1 direct+ ! removal ( ,unit$ ,/ates ,arm$ ,=ces f ho/ilities aga9/ ,iran abs5t explicit congressional au?orization4 ,?is m>k$ ! fir/ "t bo? *amb]s ev] pass$ su* a resolution direct+ a ,presid5t to )draw =ces f a w> zone "u ! ,act4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump disreg>d$ ?is unprec$5t$ bicam]al1 bip>tisan rebuke1 & 9 s do+ usurp$ ,congress' w>-mak+ au?ority4 7#c7 ,aft] a brief pause 9 active ho/ilities1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump resum$ /rikes aga9/ ,iran on ,july #g1 #bjbf1 notify+ ,congress only aft] ! fact & ass]t+ t ! #fj day clock re/>t$ ) ea* new r\nd ( /rikes4 ,?is flaw$ & dis+5u\s int]pretation 0 design$ to p]mit indef9ite unilat]al w>f>e :ile nom9ally comply+ ) ! ,act's notice requirem5t4 ,! patt]n 0 int5d$ to evade compliance1 n respect ! ,con/itution's /ructure or ,f$]al law4 7#d7 ,article ,i1 section #h ( ! ,con/itution ve/s ! p[] to decl>e w> 9 ,congress alone1 & no /atute ext5ds to /rikes on ,iranian nucle> facilities or ! su/a9$ bomb+ campaign t foll[$4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump refus$ to id5tify any specific congressional au?orization = ! ,june #bjbe /rikes or _! ,july #bjbf resumption1 rely+ in/ead on 8 ass]tion t ,article ,,ii provides au?ority to commit ! ,nation to w>4 ,su* a read+ purposefully disreg>ds ! pla9 words ( ! ,con/itution & c5turies ( con/itutional practice t ,donald ,j4 ,trump swore to protect & uphold4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump has arrogat$ to himself ! p[] to initiate & cont9ue w> aga9/ a =eign nation1 a p[] ! ,fram]s delib]ately )held f a s+le individual & ve/$ exclusively 9 ,congress1 & has disreg>d$ ! consid]$ judgm5t ( bo? *amb]s ( ,congress t ho/ilities %\ld end4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,iii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,extrajudicial ,kill+s 9 ,int]national ,wat]s ( ,v5ezuela ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! laws ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates by ord]+ & direct+ ! ,unit$ ,/ates milit>y to conduct doz5s ( le?al /rikes aga9/ small vessels 9 int]national wat]s1 kill+ well ov] #ajj p )\t *>ge1 trial1 or any judicial process1 bas$ on ! ,presid5t's own unilat]al & l>gely unv]ifi$ ass]tions t ! occupants 7 drug traffick]s or n>cot]rori/s4 ,z ,presid5t ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump is b\nd by ! ,con/itution & laws ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates & int]national treaty obligations1 includ+ ! "r to due process1 ,congress' au?ority to regulate ! milit>y1 & ! law ( w>4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,beg9n+ ,septemb] #b1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump ord]$ a /rike t kill$ all #aa p abo>d a vessel he describ$ on ,tru? ,social z c>ry+ n>cot]rori/s4 ,ov] ! foll[+ mon?s1 ! ,adm9i/ration c>ri$ out doz5s ( additional /rikes 9 ! ,c>ibbean & ,ea/]n ,pacific1 kill+ m ?an #ajj p1 )\t any ( ! victims hav+ be5 *>g$ ) a crime1 br\ght be=e a c\rt1 or af=d$ any opportunity to conte/ ! ,gov]nm5t's *>act]ization ( !m1 ! hallm>ks ( due process4 7#b7 ,^! /rikes con/itut$ extrajudicial kill+s1 9 direct contrav5tion ( int]national & dome/ic law1 c>ri$ out aga9/ unid5tifi$ individuals 9 int]national wat]s1 )\t any imm95t ?reat to ! ,unit$ ,/ates or its ,arm$ ,=ces1 )\t w>n+ or opportunity to surr5d]1 & )\t any subsequ5t judicial or indep5d5t review ( ! ,gov]nm5t's basis = ! kill+s4 ,! ,presid5t's only public ju/ification consi/$ ( repeat+ 8 own prior ass]tions1 n evid5ce subject to ! scrut9y ! ,con/itution requires4 7#c7 ,a s5ior ,:ite ,h\se (ficial publicly ackn[l$g$ t ! /rikes 7 also int5d$ to help topple ! gov]nm5t ( ,v5ezuelan ,presid5t ,nicolas ,maduro1 contradict+ ! ,adm9i/ration's (ficial ju/ification t ! /rikes 7 a n>r[ anti-n>cotics op]ation & confirm+ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump us$ le?al milit>y =ce z an in/rum5t ( w> )\t congressional au?orization4 7#d7 ,?is campaign ( extrajudicial kill+ culm9at$ 9 ! ,janu>y #c1 #bjbf1 seizure ( ,maduro himself f 8 resid5ce 9 ,c>acas & 8 =cible transport to ,new ,york to face trial1 an op]ation conduct$ entirely on ! ,presid5t's unilat]al au?ority1 )\t any congressional debate or au?orization = ! use ( =ce inside sov]eign ,v5ezuelan t]ritory4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump has claim$ = himself ! p[] to ord] ! dea? ( individuals1 ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s & =eign alike1 bas$ solely on 8 own say-s1 )\t *>ge or judicial process4 ,su* au?ority to unilat]ally deprive an individual ( life is fundam5tally incompatible ) ! con/itutional gu>antee t no p]son %all be depriv$ ( life )\t due process ( law4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,iv3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,deploy+ ,milit>y ,=ces ,aga9/ ,unit$ ,/ates ,cities ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by deploy+ ,national ,gu>d troops & active-duty ,m>9es into ,los ,angeles1 ,*icago1 ,wa%+ton1 ,,dc1 & o!r ,unit$ ,/ates cities ov] ! objection ( _! elect$ gov]nors & mayors1 unlawfully us+ ! milit>y z a dome/ic police =ce aga9/ ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s 9 s]vice ( 8 political ag5da4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,9 ,june #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump f$]aliz$ ,cali=nia's ,national ,gu>d & deploy$ approximately #d1jjj troops & #gjj ,m>9es into ,los ,angeles ov] ! objection ( ,gov]nor ,gav9 ,newsom1 9 response to prote/s aga9/ immigration en=cem5t4 ,a ,f$]al judge ultimately ord]$ control ( ! ,cali=nia ,national ,gu>d return$ to ,gov]nor ,newsom1 & a ,f$]al appellate c\rt upheld t rul+1 confirm+ t ! deploym5t exce$$ ! ,presid5t's lawful au?ority4 7#b7 ,donald ,j4 ,trump s\ght to exp& ^! deploym5ts to ,*icago & ,portl&1 prompt+ ! ,supreme ,c\rt1 9 a rul+ issu$ dur+ ,*ri/mas week 9 #bjbe1 to d5y 8 reque/ to imm$iately deploy ! ,national ,gu>d to ,*icago1 a rebuke t ! ,presid5t none!less *>act]iz$ publicly z no imp$im5t to 8 broad] ag5da ( us+ ,unit$ ,/ates cities z :at he sep>ately describ$ z tra9+ gr\nds = ! milit>y4 7#c7 ,9 ,wa%+ton1 ,,dc1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump exploit$ ! ,di/rict's unique ,f$]al /atus to keep approximately #b1fjj ,national ,gu>d troops patroll+ city /reets ?r\gh ! end ( #bjbf1 an occupation t co/ taxpay]s hundr$s ( millions ( doll>s &1 accord+ to ! ,congressional ,budget ,(fice1 total$ r\ghly #dif1jjj1jjj across all city deploym5ts ?r\gh ,decemb] #bjbe alone4 7#d7 ,^! deploym5ts h _h deadly consequ5ces4 ,two ,we/ ,virg9ia ,national ,gu>d memb]s deploy$ to ,wa%+ton1 ,,dc1 "u ,donald ,j4 ,trump's ord] 7 %ot ne> ! ,:ite ,h\se ! day be=e ,?anksgiv+ #bjbe & "o ( !m1 ,speciali/ ,s>ah ,beck/rom1 age #bj1 di$ ( h] injuries4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump has us$ ! ,arm$ ,=ces ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates z an in/rum5t ( dome/ic political control1 9 contrav5tion ( our laws & ! traditions ( our democracy1 deploy+ troops into ,unit$ ,/ates cities aga9/ ! wi%es ( _! elect$ lead]s1 at grave co/ to taxpay]s &1 9 at lea/ #a case1 at ! co/ ( a soldi]'s life4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,v3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,! ,bir?right ,citiz5%ip ,executive ,ord] ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? to pres]ve1 protect1 & def5d ! ,con/itution by issu+1 on 8 fir/ day 9 (fice1 an ,executive ord] purport+ to /rip citiz5%ip f *ildr5 born 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates to p>5ts :o are undocum5t$ or pres5t on a tempor>y basis1 9 direct contrav5tion ( ! pla9 text ( ! #ad? ,am5dm5t's citiz5%ip clause & m ?an a c5tury ( settl$ con/itutional und]/&+4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,janu>y #bj1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ an ,executive ord] decl>+ t *ildr5 born 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates to p>5ts unlawfully or tempor>ily pres5t are n subject to ! jurisdiction ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates & !re=e n entitl$ to bir?right citiz5%ip1 not)/&+ t ! #ad? ,am5dm5t /ates pla9ly t all p]sons born or naturaliz$ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 & subject to ! jurisdiction !re(1 are citiz5s ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 7#b7 ,)9 days1 ,f$]al c\rts across ! c\ntry 9 ,wa%+ton1 ,m>yl&1 & ,new ,hamp%ire among o!r jurisdictions issu$ em]g5cy ord]s block+ ! directive z inconsi/5t ) ! #ad? ,am5dm5t4 ,! fir/ c\rt to rule on ! ord] f\nd x to be a blatant violation ( ! ,con/itution4 ,! ord] nev] took effect any:]e 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates at any po9t dur+ ! ye> & a half betwe5 its issuance & ! ,supreme ,c\rt's f9al rul+1 because x 0 enjo9$ by e s+le c\rt t exam9$ x4 ,su* an unbrok51 unanim\s judicial record1 across multiple ,f$]al di/ricts & e level ( ! ,f$]al judici>y up ?r\gh ! ,supreme ,c\rt itself1 demon/rates t ! ord] 0 cle>ly unlawful f its inception4 ,despite ?is1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump int5tionally & uncon/itutionally us$ ! executive au?ority ( ! ,presid5t 9 an attempt to ov]ride ! ,con/itution he swore to uphold4 7#c7 ,on ,june #cj1 #bjbf1 ! ,supreme ,c\rt1 9 ,trump v4 ,b>b>a1 /ruck d[n ! ,executive ord] by a #f to #c vote1 ) ,*ief ,ju/ice ,rob]ts writ+ = ! majority t *ildr5 born 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates to p>5ts unlawfully or tempor>ily pres5t are citiz5s at bir? "u ! #ad? ,am5dm5t4 ,ev5 ,ju/ice ,kavanaugh1 :o diss5t$ f ! con/itutional hold+1 agre$ t ! ord] violat$ ,f$]al law4 7#d7 ,r ?an accept ?is l&m>k defeat z confirmation t 8 ord] 0 unlawful f its inception1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ #b new ,executive ord]s on ,augu/ #f1 #bjbf1 "o purport+ to exclude fur!r categories ( *ildr5 born 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates f automatic citiz5%ip1 & a second direct+ ! ,secret>ies ( ,/ate & ,homel& ,security to d5y visas & entry to individuals suspect$ ( travel+ to ! ,unit$ ,/ates = ! purpose ( giv+ bir? ea* describ$ by ! ,adm9i/ration z protect+ ! mean+ & value ( ,am]ican citiz5%ip4 ,ask$ :e!r ! new ord]s w\ld survive ! con/itutional scrut9y ! fir/ _h n1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump said only1 ,i ?9k x w1 not)/&+ t ! ,supreme ,c\rt's decision #f weeks e>li] _h already held t unilat]al executive fiat _c n>r[ ! #ad? ,am5dm5t's gu>antee1 & t any n>r[+ ( t gu>antee is a legislative & judicial function1 n an executive "o4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump attempt$ to rewrite by executive decree a con/itutional gu>antee t has def9$ ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5%ip s9ce ! ratification ( ! #ad? ,am5dm5t1 & pursu$ t ef=t = a ye> & a half aft] be+ told by e c\rt to exam9e x t 8 ord] 0 uncon/itutional1 & !n1 )9 weeks ( a unanim\s rebuke f ! ,nation's highe/ c\rt1 attempt$ ! same maneuv] aga94 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,vi3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,cancel+ ,f$]al ,grants to ,puni% ,/ates = ,_! ,votes ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa?1 ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t's protection ( political rights1 & ! equal protection gu>antees ( ! ,fif? ,am5dm5t by direct+ ,f$]al ag5cies to cancel billions ( doll>s 9 congressionally appropriat$ grants & disa/] & public safety fund+ bas$ solely on :e!r a ,/ate's electoral votes w5t to 8 #bjbd oppon5t4 ,9 s do+1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump attempt$ to usurp ,congress' sp5d+ au?ority & weaponize ! ma*9]y ( ,f$]al sp5d+ aga9/ ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s bas$ solely on _! political affiliation1 ! v association & expression ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t exi/s to protect4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,octob] #a1 #bjbe1 ,(fice ( ,managem5t & ,budget ,director ,russell ,v\ght ann\nc$ on social m$ia t ! ,adm9i/ration w\ld cancel clean-en]gy grants 9 #af ,/ates t _h vot$ = ,kamala ,h>ris 9 #bjbd1 & ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,en]gy w5t on to t]m9ate #bhd grants wor? approximately #g1ejj1jjj1jjj4 ,9 sworn c\rt fil+s1 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,en]gy lat] admitt$ ! t]m9ations 7 bas$ solely on ! political id5tity ( ! grant recipi5t's ,/ate & t comp>able grants 9 ,/ates t vot$ = ,donald ,j4 ,trump 7 n t]m9at$4 7#b7 ,on ,janu>y #ab1 #bjbf1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,amit ,mehta rul$ t ?is s*eme violat$ ! ,fif? ,am5dm5t's equal protection gu>antee1 hold+ t ! ,adm9i/ration's own admitt$ basis = ! t]m9ations ! political composition ( a ,/ate's congressional delegation be>s no rational relation%ip to any legitimate gov]nm5tal purpose1 & t ! equal protection compon5t ( ! ,fif? ,am5dm5t's ,due ,process ,clause =bids ! executive bran* f di/ribut+ congressionally appropriat$ funds accord+ to a citiz5ry's vot+ behavior4 7#c7 ,! ,dep>tm5t ( ,homel& ,security sep>ately ann\nc$ x w\ld )hold #bj p]c5t ( ,f$]al disa/] & public safety grants1 & ! ,f$]al ,em]g5cy ,managem5t ,ag5cy ann\nc$ x w\ld )hold t]rorism-prev5tion fund+1 f ,/ates t decl9$ to h& ov] unr$act$ vot] rolls to ! ,adm9i/ration condition+ public safety fund+ = millions ( ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s on ,/ates' submission to an unrelat$1 politically motivat$ dem&4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump direct$ ! corruption ( ! ,f$]al grantmak+ process into an in/rum5t ( political retribution aga9/ entire ,/ates & ! millions ( ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s :o live 9 !m1 condition+ ! receipt ( ,f$]al funds ,congress appropriat$ = ! public b5efit on :e!r a ,/ate's electorate vot$ = him4 ,su* use ( public funds is s egregi\s & caprici\s t a ,f$]al c\rt has already f\nd x uncon/itutional1 ) no legitimate gov]nm5tal purpose o!r ?an puni%+ citiz5s = h[ _! neighbors vot$4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,vii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,impos+ ,loyalty ,te/s on ! ,f$]al ,work=ce ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by fir+ ,f$]al employees = ! p]ception ( disloyalty or = hav+ work$ on disfavor$ activities1 includ+ inve/igat+ or prosecut+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own prior conduct4 ,fur!r1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump direct$ ! reclassification ( ?\s&s ( c>e] civil s]vants z at-w employees subject to removal = insuffici5t p]sonal loyalty1 & direct$ ,f$]al job applicants to answ] que/ions demon/rat+ fealty to 8 adm9i/ration's policies1 und]m9+ ! nonp>tisan civil s]vice t ,congress e/abli%$ by law to protect ! gov]nm5t f political patronage4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,janu>y #ca1 #bjbe1 at ! direction ( ,act+ ,deputy ,attorney ,g5]al ,emil ,bove1 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice fir$ approximately #dj prosecutors 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorney's ,(fice = ! ,di/rict ( ,columbia1 :o _h work$ on cases aris+ f ! ,janu>y #f1 #bjba1 attack on ! ,capitol1 & dem&$ t ! ,,fbi supply ! names ( pot5tially ?\s&s ( ag5ts & employees :o _h support$ ^? inve/igations4 ,days lat]1 ,act+ ,deputy ,attorney ,g5]al ,bove ord]$ m ?an a half-doz5 s5ior ,,fbi executives to retire or be fir$1 & ,donald ,j4 ,trump publicly /at$ t ag5ts :o _h work$ on ! ,janu>y #f? inve/igations or on ! crim9al cases previ\sly br\ght aga9/ him w\ld be fir$1 ass]t+ )\t evid5ce t !y 7 corrupt & pl$g+ ! fir+s w\ld be done quickly & v surgically4 ,n9e ,,fbi ag5ts su$ to block release ( ! li/1 argu+ t fir+ employees = ! cases to :i* !y _h be5 assign$ w\ld be unlawful & retaliatory4 7#b7 ,on ,febru>y #g1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump fir$ ,hampton ,dell+]1 ! ,s5ate-confirm$ head ( ! ,(fice ( ,special ,c\nsel ! indep5d5t ag5cy *>g$ ) protect+ ,f$]al employees & :i/lebl[]s f unlawful p]sonnel actions1 not)/&+ t ,f$]al law p]mits 8 removal only = ineffici5cy1 neglect ( duty1 or malfeasance 9 (fice1 none ( :i* ! ,adm9i/ration ass]t$4 ,ar\nd ! same "t1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump remov$ ,ca?y ,h>ris1 a ,democratic memb] ( ! ,m]it ,sy/ems ,protection ,bo>d1 ! body ) exclusive jurisdiction ov] ,f$]al employees' appeals ( unlawful fir+s1 leav+ ! ,bo>d )\t ! quorum x ne$$ to function4 ,a ,f$]al di/rict c\rt f\nd ,dell+]'s removal unlawful & ord]$ him re9/at$1 b ! ,u4,s4 ,c\rt ( ,appeals = ! ,di/rict ( ,columbia ,circuit /ay$ t rul+ & p]mitt$ ! removal to take effect :ile litigation cont9u$1 disabl+1 9 ! int]im1 ! v in/itutions ,congress creat$ to *eck ! unlawful fir+ ( ,f$]al employees ,donald ,j4 ,trump 0 simultane\sly c>ry+ out gov]nm5t-wide4 7#c7 ,9 ! fir/ weeks ( 8 second t]m1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice gave a gr\p ( s5ior c>e] attorneys1 includ+ section *iefs f ! ,environm5t & ,natural ,res\rces ,division & s5ior lead]s ( ! ,civil ,rights & ,national ,security ,divisions1 an ultimatum to resign1 or accept reassignm5t to a newly creat$ ,sanctu>y ,cities ,en=cem5t ,work+ ,gr\p ) no litigation au?ority & no sub/antive legal "w4 ,! reassignm5ts 7 execut$ be=e ,attorney ,g5]al ,pam ,bondi's confirmation specifically to avoid a ,f$]al e?ics guidel9e requir+ a #abj-;day moratorium on su* transf]s aft] new ag5cy lead]%ip takes (fice4 ,attorneys assign$ to ! gr\p 7 giv5 only m5ial rese>* tasks & 7 n p]mitt$ to communicate ) ! lawy]s actually litigat+ sanctu>y-city cases4 ,e attorney assign$ to ! gr\p ultimately resign$1 "o =m] section *ief describ+ ! assignm5t z a %am 9 :i* we did v little4 7#d7 ,on ,june #c1 #bjbf1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ an ,executive ord] /ripp+ job protections f an e/imat$ #h1jjj s5ior ,f$]al employees1 conv]t+ !m into a new ,s*$ule ,policy_/,c>e] category ( at-w work]s :o c be fir$ )\t cause1 a revival ( ! ,s*$ule ,f s*eme fir/ propos$ 9 8 fir/ t]m1 "u :i* employees may be remov$ = decl9+ to c>ry out ! ,presid5t's p]sonal directives r ?an = any defici5cy 9 ! p]=mance ( _! /atutory duties4 7#e7 ,! ,adm9i/ration's own ,(fice ( ,p]sonnel ,managem5t director ackn[l$g$ 9 public rem>ks t ! new category exi/s precisely s employees :o d n c>ry out ! ,presid5t's directives c be remov$ effectively at-w4 7#f7 ,9 ,june #bjbe1 ! ,adm9i/ration unveil$ a new ,m]it ,hir+ ,plan = ,f$]al job applicants t includ$ essay que/ions ask+ c&idates to id5tify _! favorite ,donald ,j4 ,trump policy or ,executive ord]1 a scre5+ crit]ion be>+ no relation%ip to ! m]it-bas$ qualifications ! civil s]vice laws require1 & "o design$ in/ead to measure an applicant's p]sonal fealty to ! ,presid5t be=e t applicant is ev] p]mitt$ to take ! oa? ( (fice1 :i* by law runs to ! ,con/itution alone4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump s\ght to conv]t a pr(essional1 nonp>tisan civil s]vice acc\ntable to law into a corps ( political loyali/s acc\ntable to him p]sonally1 contr>y to ! m]it sy/em ,congress e/abli%$ m ?an a c5tury ago precisely to prev5t ?is =m ( executive abuse4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,viii3 ,disreg>d ( ,c\rts--,! ,ali5 ,enemies ,act & ! ,case ( ,kilm> ,abrego ,g>cia ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & defi$ b9d+ ord]s ( ! ,f$]al judici>y1 includ+ a unanim\s ,supreme ,c\rt ord]1 by invok+ ! ,ali5 ,enemies ,act ( #agih to deport hundr$s ( individuals to a ,salvadoran prison )\t due process1 & by refus+ = mon?s to facilitate ! return ( ,kilm> ,abrego ,g>cia1 a ,m>yl& man ! gov]nm5t itself admitt$ 0 deport$ 9 error4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,m>* #ae1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump invok$ ! ,ali5 ,enemies ,act1 a w>time /atute la/ us$ to ju/ify ! int]nm5t ( ,japanese1 ,g]man1 & ,italian nationals dur+ ,_w ,w> ,,ii1 to deport #acg ,v5ezuelan nationals to ,el ,salvador's ,t]rorism ,conf9em5t ,c5t]1 kn[n z ,,cecot1 along ) #aja o!r ,v5ezuelans & ,kilm> ,abrego ,g>cia1 a ,salvadoran man ) a /&+ immigration c\rt ord] b>r+ 8 removal to t c\ntry4 ,?is occurr$ 9 direct opposition to a ,f$]al judge's cle> ord] to halt ! deportation flights &1 if necess>y1 turn ! airplanes ar\nd :ile /ill 9 ! air4 ,! ,adm9i/ration proce$$ reg>dless4 7#b7 ,! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice conc$$ 9 c\rt fil+s t ,abrego ,g>cia's deportation 0 ! result ( an adm9i/rative error1 yet ! ,adm9i/ration refus$ = mon?s to facilitate 8 return despite a di/rict c\rt ord] & a unanim\s ,supreme ,c\rt rul+ direct+ x to d s4 ,! ,adm9i/ration's litigat+ position t once a p]son has be5 remov$ f ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 no c\rt reta9s p[] to ord] ! correction ( an admitt$ly errone\s removal w\ld1 if accept$1 p]mit ! executive bran* to place any p]son1 includ+ a ,unit$ ,/ates citiz51 beyond ! rea* ( judicial review simply by act+ be=e a c\rt c int]v5e4 7#c7 ,evid5ce ga!r$ by j\rnali/s & advocacy organizations lat] %[$ t mo/ ( ! m5 s5t to ,,cecot "u ! ,ali5 ,enemies ,act proce$+ fac$ no specific allegations ( gang memb]%ip or crim9al activity1 & t m5 held !re 7 held entirely incommunicado1 )\t access to lawy]s or family1 = mon?s4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump us$ a w>time /atute int5d$ = actual =eign combatants to /rip hundr$s ( p1 includ+ at lea/ #a man 8 own ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice admitt$ 0 innoc5t ( any wrongdo+1 ( due process protections gu>ante$ by ! ,con/itution1 & !n defi$ ! ord]s ( ! v c\rts *>g$ ) correct+ ! error4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,ix3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,cruel & ,unusual ,puni%m5t at ,,cecot ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,eigh? ,am5dm5t's prohibition on cruel & unusual puni%m5t by kn[+ly consign+ hundr$s ( deportees1 includ+ individuals ) no crim9al record1 to indef9ite & incommunicado det5tion 9 ,el ,salvador's ,t]rorism ,conf9em5t ,c5t]1 a facility notori\s = abuse1 & by pay+ ! ,gov]nm5t ( ,el ,salvador millions ( doll>s to hold !m beyond ! rea* ( ,unit$ ,/ates c\rts4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,! ,unit$ ,/ates ,gov]nm5t paid ! ,gov]nm5t ( ,el ,salvador approximately #f1jjj1jjj to deta9 deportees at ,,cecot1 a mega-prison built specifically to hold suspect$ gang memb]s "u a /ate ( em]g5cy t has susp5d$ ord9>y due process protections )9 ,el ,salvador itself4 7#b7 ,sworn c\rt fil+s submitt$ on behalf ( ,kilm> ,abrego ,g>cia's family describ$ sev]e physical abuse he suff]$ :ile held at ,,cecot1 & report+ f\nd t m5 s5t !re 7 held ) no access to lawy]s1 family memb]s1 or ! outside _w = mon?s1 ) writs ( habeas corpus fil$ on _! behalf 9 ,salvadoran c\rts go+ unansw]$4 7#c7 ,! arrangem5t 0 design$1 & ,adm9i/ration (ficials ackn[l$g$ z mu* 9 litigation1 specifically to place deportees beyond ! jurisdiction ( ,unit$ ,/ates c\rts z an explicit /rategy to evade ! con/itutional protections aga9/ arbitr>y & indef9ite det5tion t apply to any p]son )9 ! cu/ody or control ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,gov]nm5t1 reg>dless ( :]e t cu/ody is physically locat$4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump kn[+ly subject$ human be+s1 includ+ p 8 own adm9i/ration admitt$ 7 wrongfully deport$1 to indef9ite det5tion )\t *>ge 9 a =eign prison notori\s = abuse1 f9anc$ ) ,unit$ ,/ates taxpay] doll>s & design$ specifically to place !m beyond ! protection ( ,unit$ ,/ates law4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,x3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,unlawful ,)hold+ ( ,appropriat$ ,funds & ,dismantl+ ( ,congressionally ,e/abli%$ ,programs ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? to take c>e t ! laws be fai?fully execut$ by direct+ ,f$]al ag5cies1 across doz5s ( programs1 to )hold1 delay1 or refuse to sp5d funds t ,congress _h lawfully appropriat$1 & by unilat]ally dismantl+ ,gov]nm5t functions & programs t only ,congress has ! au?ority to elim9ate4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,janu>y #bj1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ an ,executive ord] e/abli%+ ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,dep>tm5t ( ,gov]nm5t ,effici5cy 7,,doge7 ,s]vice )9 ! ,executive ,(fice ( ! ,presid5t1 an entity ) no basis 9 any /atute ,congress enact$1 & direct$ x to access ! paym5t & data sy/ems (1 & imp\nd funds appropriat$ to1 ag5cies across ! ,f$]al ,gov]nm5t4 ,,doge mov$ )9 weeks to %ut d[n ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,ag5cy = ,int]national ,developm5t 7,,usaid7 entirely1 freez+ all ( its disbursem5ts1 plac+ ?\s&s ( employees on leave1 & attempt+ to fold its rema9+ functions into ! ,/ate ,dep>tm5t )\t any congressional action au?oriz+ ! ag5cy's elim9ation4 ,a ,f$]al judge f\nd ! %utd[n likely unlawful1 & ! ,supreme ,c\rt ultimately ord]$ billions ( doll>s 9 froz5 ,,usaid paym5ts releas$ to contractors ow$ ! money4 ,,doge p]sonnel sep>ately seiz$ access to ! int]nal sy/ems ( ! ,consum] ,f9ancial ,protection ,bureau1 an indep5d5t ag5cy creat$ by ,congress1 aft] ! ag5cy's act+ director halt$ its fund+ & ord]$ /aff to /op p]=m+ any "w tasks1 an attempt to %utt] by adm9i/rative fiat an ag5cy t only ,congress has ! p[] to elim9ate4 ,,doge und]took simil> actions aga9/ ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,african ,developm5t ,f\ndation & ! ,int]-,am]ican ,f\ndation1 bo? creat$ by ,congress1 cancell+ grants & contracts & r$uc+ ! =m] ag5cy's /aff to a s+le employee4 7#b7 ,! nonp>tisan ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice repeat$ly f\nd ! ,adm9i/ration 9 violation ( ! ,imp\ndm5t ,control ,act ( #aigd across multiple ag5cies & programs1 includ+ a ,may #bjbe f9d+ t ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,transportation illegally delay$ sp5d+ on electric-vehicle *>g+ infra/ructure requir$ by law1 & a ,july #bjbe f9d+ t ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,en]gy illegally )held fund+ = ! ,r5ew ,am]ica's ,s*ools ,program b5efit+ ,k9d]g>t5 ?r\gh #ab? grade s*ools nationwide4 7#c7 ,! ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice simil>ly f\nd t ! ,f$]al ,em]g5cy ,managem5t ,ag5cy violat$ ! ,imp\ndm5t ,control ,act by improp]ly )hold+ or delay+ congressionally appropriat$ disa/]-prep>$ness fund+ funds ,congress _h already det]m9$ %\ld rea* ,unit$ ,/ates communities prep>+ = ! next em]g5cy1 )held in/ead bas$ on ! ,adm9i/ration's disagreem5t ) ,congress' sp5d+ priorities r ?an any /atutory basis = delay4 7#d7 ,indep5d5t budget analysis f\nd t by ,july #bjbe1 ! ,adm9i/ration _h significantly delay$ sp5d+ across #bd ,f$]al acc\nts well beyond ! specific programs x _h =mally propos$ = rescission1 conc5trat$ precisely 9 ! programs ! ,adm9i/ration _h sep>ately t>get$ = elim9ation evid5ce ( a delib]ate /rategy to />ve disfavor$ programs ( funds ,congress _h already appropriat$ r ?an seek+ ,congress' approval to cut !m4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sub/itut$ 8 own budget>y pref]5ces = ! consid]$ judgm5t ( ,congress1 d5y+ ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s s]vices & protections t _! elect$ repres5tatives _h fund$ ?r\gh ! con/itutionally prescrib$ appropriations process1 & did s repeat$ly ev5 aft] nonp>tisan inve/igators f\nd ! practice unlawful4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xi3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,ob/ruct+ ! ,lawful ,appo9tm5t ( ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorneys ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! sep>ation ( p[]s by eng9e]+ a s]ies ( maneuv]s to in/all 8 p]sonal loyali/s z ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorneys 9 defiance ( ! appo9tm5ts clause & ! ,f$]al ,vacancies ,re=m ,act1 aft] ,f$]al judges ex]cis$ _! /atutory au?ority to decl9e ext5d+ ^? loyali/s' int]im t]ms4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,9 ,new ,j]sey1 aft] ,f$]al judges decl9$ to ext5d int]im ,u4,s4 ,attorney ,al9a ,habba's 7,habba7 t]m & in/ead select$ c>e] prosecutor ,desiree ,leigh ,grace1 ,attorney ,g5]al ,pam ,bondi fir$ ,grace )9 h\rs1 & ! ,adm9i/ration execut$ a multi-/ep maneuv] )draw+ ,habba's ,s5ate nom9ation1 hav+ h] resign1 & !n reappo9t+ h] z a ,special ,attorney1 specifically design$ to evade ! judges' decision & ! ,s5ate confirmation process altoge!r4 7#b7 ,on ,decemb] #a1 #bjbe1 ! ,?ird ,circuit ,c\rt ( ,appeals unanim\sly upheld a rul+ disqualify+ ,habba1 f9d+ t ! ,adm9i/ration's maneuv] 0 pla9ly prohibit$ by ,f$]al law & w\ld1 if p]mitt$1 all[ any ,special ,attorney to avoid ! gauntlet ( presid5tial appo9tm5t & ,s5ate confirmation & s]ve z ! de facto ,u4,s4 ,attorney indef9itely4 ,! c\rt obs]v$ t ! ,adm9i/ration's approa* effectively w\ld p]mit anyone to fill ! ,u4,s4 ,attorney role indef9itely4 7#c7 ,! same unlawful appo9tm5t me*anism 0 us$ 9 ! ,ea/]n ,di/rict ( ,virg9ia to in/all ,l9dsey ,halligan1 a =m] ,donald ,j4 ,trump p]sonal lawy] ) no prosecutorial exp]i5ce1 z int]im ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorney aft] ! sitt+ ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorney resign$ "u pressure = que/ion+ ! suffici5cy ( ! evid5ce aga9/ =m] ,,fbi ,director ,james ,comey & ,new ,york ,attorney ,g5]al ,letitia ,james4 ,a ,f$]al judge subsequ5tly dismiss$ ! indictm5ts ,halligan _h obta9$1 rul+ t %e _h no lawful au?ority to pres5t ! indictm5t4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump repeat$ly circumv5t$ ! con/itutional & /atutory processes gov]n+ ! appo9tm5t ( ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorneys 9 ord] to in/all p]sonally loyal prosecutors1 includ+ 8 own =m] p]sonal lawy]s1 9 positions ( prosecutorial p[] ov] 8 political adv]s>ies1 defy+ ,f$]al c\rts ea* "t !y int]v5$ to en=ce ! law4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,defy+ ,c\rt ,ord]s 9 ,immigration ,en=cem5t ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by direct+ ,f$]al (ficials to disreg>d b9d+ ord]s ( ,f$]al c\rts 9 ! conduct ( immigration en=cem5t4 ,"u ,article ,,iii ( ! ,con/itution1 ! judici>y alone possesses ! p[] to say :at ! law is 9 a case or controv]sy prop]ly be=e x1 & a ,f$]al c\rt's judgm5t1 once ent]$1 is f9al & b9d+ on ! p>ties1 includ+ ! executive bran*1 unless & until x is rev]s$ on appeal by a high] c\rt4 ,! executive bran* possesses no con/itutional au?ority to disreg>d1 evade1 or outrun a ,f$]al c\rt's ord] because compliance is inconv5i5t or because ! gov]nm5t disagrees ) ! c\rt's reason+4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,m>* #ae1 #bjbe1 ev5 aft] ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,james ,boasb]g orally ord]$ t deportation flights b\nd = ,el ,salvador be turn$ ar\nd :ile /ill 9 ! air1 ! ,adm9i/ration all[$ ! flights to proce$ & complete ! deportations1 & ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice appeal$ ! und]ly+ ord] ! same day r ?an comply+ ) x4 ,on ,april #af1 #bjbe1 9 a #df page ord]1 ,judge ,boasb]g f\nd probable cause to hold ! ,gov]nm5t 9 crim9al contempt1 writ+ t ! ,gov]nm5t's actions on t day demon/rate a willful disreg>d = its ,ord]1 suffici5t = ! ,c\rt to conclude t probable cause exi/s to f9d ! ,gov]nm5t 9 crim9al contempt1 & add+ t he did n rea* t conclusion lightly or ha/ily1 hav+ giv5 ! ,gov]nm5t ample opportunity to rectify or expla9 its actions1 none ( :i* _h be5 satisfactory4 ,judge ,boasb]g1 an appo9tee ( ,presid5t ,obama1 :o _h e>li] be5 nom9at$ to ! local ,,dc c\rts by ,presid5t ,george ,w4 ,bu%1 wrote directly to ! con/itutional /akes ( ! ,gov]nm5t's conduct3 ,! ,con/itution does n tol]ate willful disob$i5ce ( judicial ord]s1 especially by (ficials ( a coord9ate bran* :o h sworn an oa? to uphold x4 7#b7 ,9 ! relat$ case ( ,kilm> ,abrego ,g>cia1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,paula ,x9is f\nd t ! ,adm9i/ration's response to h] discov]y ord]s fil$ aft] ! ,supreme ,c\rt _h unanim\sly direct$ ! ,gov]nm5t to facilitate 8 return1 reflects a delib]ate evasion ( _! fundam5tal discov]y obligations1 & t ! ,gov]nm5t's failure to respond c only be view$ z willful & int5tional noncompliance1 cit+ a willful & bad fai? refusal to comply ) discov]y obligations4 ,judge ,x9is fur!r f\nd t ! ,adm9i/ration _h engag$ 9 a cont9u$ mis*>act]ization ( ! ,supreme ,c\rt's ,ord] by claim+1 contr>y to ! ,ord]'s pla9 t]ms1 t x _h n be5 direct$ to facilitate ,abrego ,g>cia's release f ,salvadoran cu/ody4 7#c7 ,:5 ! ,adm9i/ration s\ght em]g5cy appellate relief f ,judge ,x9is' ord]s1 a unanim\s #c judge panel ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,c\rt ( ,appeals = ! ,f\r? ,circuit1 includ+ a ,reagan appo9tee writ+ = a panel t also includ$ appo9tees ( ,presid5ts ,cl9ton & ,obama1 reject$ ! ,gov]nm5t's position 9 t]ms r>ely us$ by a ,f$]al appellate c\rt ab\t ! conduct ( ! executive bran*4 ,! panel wrote t ! ,gov]nm5t 0 ass]t+ a "r to /a% away resid5ts ( ?is c\ntry 9 =eign prisons )\t ! semblance ( due process t is ! f\ndation ( our con/itutional ord]1 & t its position1 t hav+ rid itself ( cu/ody !re 0 no?+ fur!r x c\ld d1 %\ld be %ock+ n only to judges1 b to ! intuitive s5se ( lib]ty t ,am]icans f> remov$ f c\r?\ses /ill hold de>4 7#d7 ,! patt]n across ^! cases proce$+ ) deportations :ile a c\rt's ord] to halt !m 0 /ill p5d+1 & ass]t+ t removal f ! c\ntry moots any judicial p[] to ord] return1 reflects a consid]$ litigat+ /rategy1 repeat$ across multiple cases & multiple c\rts1 ( treat+ compliance ) judicial ord]s z optional :5ev] spe$ c place ! ,gov]nm5t's action beyond ! c\rt's practical ability to undo x4 ,t ?is /rategy has drawn f9d+s ( willful disreg>d1 bad fai?1 & delib]ate evasion f ,f$]al judges appo9t$ by presid5ts ( bo? p>ties1 & a rebuke f a unanim\s1 ideologically mix$ appellate panel1 confirms t ?is is n a case ( good-fai? legal disagreem5t ab\t ! scope ( a c\rt's au?ority1 b a delib]ate c\rse ( conduct 9 defiance ( x4 7#e7 ,! ,adm9i/ration's po/ure 9 ^! cases ass]t+ t once a p]son has be5 remov$ f ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 c\rts lack p[] to ord] _! return reg>dless ( ! legality ( ! removal1 w\ld1 if accept$1 p]mit ! executive bran* to place any p]son1 includ+ an ,unit$ ,/ates citiz51 beyond ! rea* ( judicial review simply by act+ quickly en\gh4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump has treat$ ! ord]s ( ,article ,,iii z optional con/ra9ts to be evad$ ?r\gh spe$ & proc$ural gamesman%ip r ?an z b9d+ law1 conduct t ,f$]al judges appo9t$ by ,presid5ts ( bo? p>ties h f\nd1 9 _! own b9d+ rul+s1 to be willful1 made 9 bad fai?1 & und]tak5 ) delib]ate int5t to evade compliance4 ,?is is n a case 9 :i* ! ,h\se ( ,repres5tatives mu/ *>act]ize ! ,adm9i/ration's conduct z defiance1 ! c\rts ve/$ ) ! con/itutional au?ority to make t det]m9ation h already made x1 repeat$ly1 & ! ,adm9i/ration's response has be5 to cont9ue ! conduct ^? c\rts condemn$4 ,x /rikes at ! fundam5tal premise ( a gov]nm5t ( sep>at$ p[]s 9 :i* no bran*1 includ+ ! executive1 is ! f9al judge ( its own au?ority4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xiii3 ,aboli%+ a ,congressionally ,m&at$ ,ag5cy--,! ,dep>tm5t ( ,education ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by direct+ ! ,secret>y ( ,education to dismantle ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,education1 an ag5cy creat$ by ,congress 9 #aigi1 not)/&+ t only ,congress possesses ! au?ority to aboli% a ,f$]al dep>tm5t x has e/abli%$ by /atute4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,m>* #bj1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ an ,executive ord] direct+ ,secret>y ( ,education ,l9da ,mc,mahon to take all necess>y /eps to facilitate ! closure ( ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,education1 /at+ at ! sign+ c]emony t he hop$ %e w\ld be our la/ ,secret>y ( ,education & t 8 adm9i/ration w\ld take all lawful /eps to %ut d[n ! ,dep>tm5t4 7#b7 ,! ,dep>tm5t ( ,education 0 creat$ by ,congress ?r\gh ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,education ,organization ,act ( #aigi1 a /atute duly enact$ ?r\gh bicam]alism & pres5tm5t1 z a matt] ( basic con/itutional /ructure1 an ag5cy creat$ by an ,act ( ,congress c be aboli%$ only by ano!r ,act ( ,congress1 s9ce ! ,presid5t's unilat]al au?ority ext5ds to ! execution ( ! laws1 n _! repeal4 ,no su* repeal+ legislation 0 ev] enact$4 ,! ,s5ate nev] took up1 let alone pass$1 legislation aboli%+ ! ,dep>tm5t4 7#c7 ,not)/&+ ?is settl$ con/itutional limitation1 ! ,adm9i/ration proce$$ to r$i/ribute ! ,dep>tm5t's core functions1 includ+ ,f$]al /ud5t loan adm9i/ration & special-education s]vices1 to o!r ag5cies su* z ! ,small ,bus9ess ,adm9i/ration & ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,heal? & ,human ,s]vices1 effectively a*iev+ ?r\gh ,executive fiat mu* ( :at ,congress alone is emp[]$ to accompli% ?r\gh legislation4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump s\ght to elim9ate1 by 8 own h&1 a cab9et dep>tm5t t ,congress creat$ & t only ,congress c lawfully aboli%1 sub/itut+ unilat]al executive action = ! legislative process ! ,con/itution requires = ! elim9ation ( in/itutions ,congress has e/abli%$4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xiv3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,unlawful ,mass ,t]m9ation ( ,inspectors ,g5]al ,)\t ,/atutory ,notice to ,congress ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,inspector ,g5]al ,act ( #aigh1 z am5d$1 by summ>ily fir+ at lea/ #ag ,s5ate-confirm$ ,inspectors ,g5]al across ! ,f$]al ,gov]nm5t on 8 fif? day 9 (fice1 )\t ! #cj days advance notice to ,congress or ! case-specific reasons = removal t ,f$]al law requires1 disabl+1 be=e 8 adm9i/ration _h complet$ its second week1 ! indep5d5t wat*dogs ,congress creat$ specifically to detect wa/e1 fraud1 & abuse )9 ! v ag5cies ,donald ,j4 ,trump n[ controls4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ! night ( ,janu>y #bd1 #bjbe1 ! ,:ite ,h\se ,presid5tial ,p]sonnel ,(fice notifi$ at lea/ #ag1 & by "s c\nts #ah1 ,inspectors ,g5]al across major cab9et dep>tm5ts & ag5cies includ+ ! ,dep>tm5ts ( ,def5se1 ,heal? & ,human ,s]vices1 ,/ate1 & ,vet]ans ,affairs1 t !y 7 t]m9at$ effective imm$iately4 ,! ,inspector ,g5]al ,act ( #aigh1 z am5d$ by ! ,secur+ ,inspector ,g5]al ,indep5d5ce ,act ( #bjbb1 requires ! ,presid5t to communicate to ,congress1 9 writ+1 #cj days be=e remov+ or transf]r+ an ,inspector ,g5]al1 a sub/antive rationale includ+ detail$1 case-specific reasons = ! removal4 ,no su* notice 0 giv5 to ,congress1 & no case-specific reason 0 giv5 to any ( ! ,inspectors ,g5]al remov$4 7#b7 ,hannibal ,mike ,w>e1 ! ,inspector ,g5]al = ! ,small ,bus9ess ,adm9i/ration & *airp]son ( ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,inspectors ,g5]al on ,integrity & ,effici5cy1 wrote to ! ,:ite ,h\se t same night w>n+ t ! removals appe>$ unlawful because ! requir$ notice p]iod _h be5 ignor$1 & recomm5d+ t ! ,:ite ,h\se consult its own c\nsel be=e proce$+4 ,! removals proce$$ reg>dless4 7#c7 ,on ,janu>y #bh1 #bjbe1 ,s5ator ,*uck ,grassley ( ,i[a1 ! ,republican *airman ( ! ,s5ate ,judici>y ,committee1 & ,s5ator ,ri*>d ,durb9 ( ,ill9ois1 ! ,committee's ,democratic rank+ memb]1 jo9tly wrote to ,donald ,j4 ,trump dem&+ ! legally requir$ explanation = ! fir+s1 /at+ t ! communication to ,congress mu/ conta9 m ?an j broad & vague /atem5ts & mu/ assure ,congress & ! public t ! t]m9ation is due to real conc]ns ab\t ! ,inspector ,g5]al's ability to c>ry out _! mission4 ,no adequate response 0 ev] provid$4 ,?is bip>tisan dem& issu$ by ! *airman & rank+ memb] ( ! committee ) direct jurisdiction ov] ! fir+s1 )9 days ( ! t]m9ations1 /&s z a contemporane\s1 =mal record t bo? p>ties 9 ,congress recogniz$ ! fir+s z a violation ( law at ! "t !y occurr$1 n m]ely 9 retrospect4 7#d7 ,eight ( ! fir$ ,inspectors ,g5]al su$ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,c\rt = ! ,di/rict ( ,columbia4 ,on ,septemb] #bd1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,ana ,c4 ,reyes rul$ t ! fir+s violat$ ! ,inspector ,g5]al ,act's notice requirem5t & 7 !re=e unlawful1 ?\gh %e decl9$ to ord] ! ,inspectors ,g5]al re9/at$1 reason+ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump reta9$ ! und]ly+ p[] to remove !m & w\ld likely simply fire !m aga9 aft] belat$ly provid+ ! legally requir$ notice a rul+ t confirm$ ! illegality ( ,donald ,j4 ,trump's conduct :ile illu/rat+ ! practical difficulty ( en=c+ ,congress' ov]sight pr]ogatives aga9/ a ,presid5t det]m9$ to evade !m4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump gutt$1 9 a s+le night & )\t any ( ! process ,congress requir$1 ! indep5d5t ov]sight app>atus t exi/s specifically to detect & report wa/e1 fraud1 & abuse )9 ! ag5cies ( ! executive bran*1 disabl+1 at ! v outset ( 8 t]m1 ! me*anism by :i* ,congress & ! public w\ld o!rwise h be5 position$ to le>n ( ! misconduct catalogu$ ?r\gh\t ! o!r articles ( ?is resolution1 & do+ s ov] ! contemporane\s1 bip>tisan objection ( ! *airman & rank+ memb] ( ! ,s5ate committee *>g$ ) ov]see+ exactly ?is conduct4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xv3 ,unlawfully & ,unilat]ally ,tax+ ,unit$ ,/ates ,citiz5s ,?r\gh ,em]g5cy ,p[]s ,t>iffs ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ,article ,i ( ! ,con/itution1 :i* ve/s ! p[] to lay & collect taxes & duties exclusively 9 ,congress1 by impos+ sweep+ t>iffs on ne>ly all goods import$ into ! ,unit$ ,/ates "u ! ,int]national ,em]g5cy ,economic ,p[]s ,act :i* does n au?orize ! ,presid5t to impose t>iffs at all4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,beg9n+ ,febru>y #a1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump invok$ ! ,int]national ,em]g5cy ,economic ,p[]s ,act to impose t>iffs on imports f ,canada1 ,mexico1 & ,*9a1 & on ,april #b1 #bjbe1 a day ! ,adm9i/ration itself dubb$ ,lib]ation ,day1 decl>$ a fur!r em]g5cy to impose sweep+ reciprocal t>iffs on goods f ne>ly e c\ntry 9 ! _w1 not)/&+ t 9 ne>ly #ej ye>s1 no presid5t _h ev] invok$ t /atute to impose a t>iff4 7#b7 ,on ,febru>y #bj1 #bjbf1 ! ,supreme ,c\rt1 9 ,le>n+ ,res\rces1 ,inc4 v4 ,trump1 rul$ #f to #c t ! ,int]national ,em]g5cy ,economic ,p[]s ,act does n au?orize ! ,presid5t to impose t>iffs at all4 ,writ+ = ! ,c\rt1 ,*ief ,ju/ice ,rob]ts expla9$ t accept+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's int]pretation w\ld give ! ,presid5t p[] to unilat]ally impose unb\nd$ t>iffs1 uncon/ra9$ by any ( ! proc$ural limits ,congress built into ! ,nation's actual t>iff /atutes4 7#c7 ,indep5d5t economi/s e/imat$ t ! invalidat$ t>iffs _h already extract$ betwe5 #age1jjj1jjj1jjj & #agi1jjj1jjj1jjj f ,unit$ ,/ates bus9esses & consum]s a sum exce$+ ! comb9$ annual budgets ( ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,transportation & ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice1 collect$ )\t a s+le vote ( ! ,congress 9 :i* ! ,con/itution ve/s ! tax+ p[]4 7#d7 ,r ?an accept ! ,supreme ,c\rt's rul+ z a rebuke1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 )9 h\rs ( ! decision1 proclaim$ a new #aj p]c5t global t>iff "u a diff]5t /atute & ann\nc$ 8 int5tion to raise x fur!r )9 days1 demon/rat+ t 8 t>iff program 0 nev] a response to a g5u9e em]g5cy b a /&+ ass]tion ( a tax+ p[] ! ,con/itution does n give him4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump impos$ :at am\nt$ to a nationwide tax increase on ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s )\t ! cons5t ( _! elect$ repres5tatives 9 ,congress1 us+ an em]g5cy /atute t ! ,nation's highe/ c\rt unanim\sly agre$ does n au?orize taxation1 & p]si/$ 9 ass]t+ t same tax+ p[] ?r\gh new /atutory pretexts imm$iately aft] be+ told by ! ,supreme ,c\rt t he did n h x4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xvi3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,political ,prosecutions ( ,comey1 ,james1 & ,s*iff ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by direct+ ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice to pursue crim9al prosecutions aga9/ =m] ,,fbi ,director ,james ,comey 7,comey71 ,new ,york ,attorney ,g5]al ,letitia ,james 7,james71 & ,s5ator ,adam ,s*iff 7,s*iff71 #c ( 8 mo/ prom95t political adv]s>ies1 9 a mann] s factually dubi\s t a gr& jury itself refus$ to approve ! full indictm5t pres5t$ aga9/ ,comey1 =c+ ! prosecutor to circumv5t t refusal r ?an accept x1 & s legally defici5t & proc$urally irregul> t ! result+ indictm5ts 7 dismiss$ by ! c\rts4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,septemb] #bj1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump po/$ publicly dem&+ t ,attorney ,g5]al ,pam ,bondi prosecute ,comey1 ,james1 & ,s*iff by "n4 ,days lat]1 ,erik ,sieb]t1 ! sitt+ int]im ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorney = ! ,ea/]n ,di/rict ( ,virg9ia1 resign$ "u pressure aft] conclud+ ! evid5ce aga9/ ,comey & ,james 0 insuffici5t to *>ge4 ,! ,adm9i/ration !n in/all$ ,l9dsey ,halligan1 a =m] ,donald ,j4 ,trump p]sonal lawy]1 :o obta9$ ! indictm5ts ,sieb]t _h decl9$ to seek4 7#b7 ,on ,septemb] #be1 #bjbe1 ! gr& jury consid]+ ! case aga9/ ,comey reject$ #a ( ! #c c\nts ,halligan _h pres5t$4 ,r ?an pres5t a revis$ indictm5t to ! full gr& jury = its vote1 ,halligan simply repr9t$ an alt]$1 #b c\nt v]sion ( ! docum5t & br\ght x to ! gr& jury =ep]son alone to sign1 )\t ! rema9+ gr& jurors ev] review+ or vot+ on ! indictm5t 9 ! =m t 0 actually fil$4 ,prosecutors confirm$ ?is sequ5ce ( ev5ts 9 op5 c\rt #b mon?s lat]1 prompt+ ,comey's attorneys to move to dismiss ! indictm5t on ! gr\nd t no valid gr& jury _h ev] approv$ x4 7#c7 ,a ,f$]al judge dismiss$ ! indictm5ts aga9/ bo? ,comey & ,james aft] f9d+ t ,halligan's own appo9tm5t z int]im ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorney 0 unlawful1 & fur!r criticiz$ ! prosecution = :at ! c\rt call$ a di/urb+ patt]n ( pr(\nd inve/igative mis/eps4 7#d7 ,9 ! p>allel inve/igation ( ,s5ator ,s*iff1 prosecutors 9 ! ,m>yl& ,unit$ ,/ates ,attorney's ,(fice aft] mon?s ( inve/igation prompt$ by ,donald ,j4 ,trump's public dem&s1 conclud$ !y lack$ suffici5t evid5ce to br+ *>ges1 & ! ,ju/ice ,dep>tm5t's own ,inspector ,g5]al subsequ5tly op5$ an inve/igation into :e!r individuals _h imp]sonat$ ,f$]al ag5ts :ile pursu+ ! mortgage-fraud !ory ! ,adm9i/ration _h promot$ aga9/ ,s*iff4 7#e7 ,all #c individuals t>get$ by "n 9 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's public dem& = prosecution1 ,comey1 ,james1 & ,s*iff1 7 prom95t critics ( ,donald ,j4 ,trump :o _h ea* play$ a c5tral role 9 inve/igat+ him or hold+ him acc\ntable dur+ 8 fir/ t]m1 ) ,comey z ,,fbi ,director dur+ ! inve/igation into ,russian int]f]5ce 9 ! #bjaf election1 ,james z ! ,new ,york ,attorney ,g5]al :o obta9$ a civil fraud judgm5t aga9/ ! ,trump ,organization1 & ,s*iff z ! lead ,h\se manag] 9 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's fir/ impea*m5t trial4 ,! selection ( ^! #c specific individuals = prosecution1 foll[+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own public id5tification ( !m by "n1 evid5ces a prosecutorial decision driv5 by p]sonal & political enmity r ?an by ! indep5d5t judgm5t ( c>e] law en=cem5t1 :i* 9 ea* in/ance _h itself conclud$ t prosecution 0 n w>rant$4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump direct$ ! ma*9]y ( ,f$]al law en=cem5t aga9/ nam$ political adv]s>ies by public dem&1 in/all$ unlawfully appo9t$ prosecutors to pursue cases 8 own dep>tm5t's c>e] attorneys _h decl9$1 tol]at$ a prosecutor's circumv5tion ( a gr& jury's own refusal to approve ! *>ges z pres5t$1 & pursu$ indictm5ts t c\rts f\nd 7 built on manufactur$ au?ority r ?an evid5ce4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xvii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,! ,,irs ,settlem5t & ! ,corruption ( ! ,judgm5t ,fund ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & us$ 8 (fice = p]sonal & political ga9 by direct+ 8 own ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice to settle a lawsuit he _h p]sonally fil$ aga9/ ! ,int]nal ,rev5ue ,s]vice 7,,irs7 on t]ms t grant$ him & 8 family p]man5t immunity f tax exam9ation & creat$ a taxpay]-fund$ comp5sation fund = 8 political allies4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,9 ,febru>y #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump fil$ a #aj1jjj1jjj1jjj lawsuit aga9/ ! ,,irs an ag5cy )9 ! executive bran* he leads1 ov] ! #bjbb leak ( 8 tax returns by a =m] ,,irs contractor :o _h already be5 crim9ally prosecut$1 convict$1 & imprison$ = t conduct4 7#b7 ,9 ,may #bjbf1 8 own ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice agre$ to settle t suit by creat+ a #a1ggf1jjj1jjj fund1 drawn f ! ,treasury ,dep>tm5t's ,judgm5t ,fund1 to comp5sate individuals1 pot5tially includ+ ,janu>y #f? def5dants1 :o claim$ to h be5 wrongfully t>get$ by ! prior adm9i/ration1 ) commission memb]s ov]see+ ! fund removable by ,donald ,j4 ,trump )\t cause4 ,no /atute au?orizes ! ,presid5t or 8 ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice to create a comp5sation fund ( ?is k9d or to draw on ! ,judgm5t ,fund1 :i* exi/s to pay c\rt judgm5ts & settlem5ts ( actual legal claims aga9/ ! gov]nm5t1 = ! purpose ( rew>d+ a self-select$ class ( ! ,presid5t's political allies4 7#c7 ,! same settlem5t includ$ a provision1 releas$ by ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own ,ju/ice ,dep>tm5t1 t w\ld h p]man5tly & =ev] b>r$ ! ,,irs f conduct+ any exam9ation ( ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 8 family memb]s1 or affiliat$ bus9esses a p]sonal tax %ield secur$ ?r\gh a lawsuit he br\ght aga9/ ! v gov]nm5t he heads4 7#d7 ,only aft] ,republican ,s5ators ,?om ,tillis & ,john ,cornyn ?reat5$ to )hold _! votes on ! nom9ation ( ,todd ,blan*e = ,attorney ,g5]al did ! ,adm9i/ration agree to resc9d ! #a1hjj1jjj1jjj political comp5sation fund4 7#e7 ,on ,july #ac1 #bjbf1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,ka?le5 ,williams void$ ! settlem5t 9 its entirety1 f9d+ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump's lawsuit _h nev] be5 a g5u9e adv]s>ial proce$+1 because ,donald ,j4 ,trump controll$ bo? ! pla9tiffs & ! def5dants & ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice & ! ,,irs be+ ag5cies ( 8 own adm9i/ration1 !re 0 nev] adv]s5ess betwe5 ! ,p>ties2 !re 0 nev] a case or controv]sy2 & !re 0 nev] a "q z to :o w\ld prevail4 ,! c\rt f\nd t ,donald ,j4 ,trump & 8 sons1 :o jo9$ ! suit z copla9tiffs1 _h act$ 9 bad fai? & _h br\ght ! case = an improp] purpose1 to ga9 ! imprimatur ( judicial legitimacy = a settlem5t ) no basis 9 law or fact1 & ref]r$ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's attorneys1 includ+ ,act+ ,attorney ,g5]al ,todd ,blan*e1 = possible pr(essional discipl9e4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump us$ ! ma*9]y ( 8 own ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice to conv]t a lawsuit he fil$ aga9/ 8 own gov]nm5t into a me*anism = bo? p]sonal f9ancial protection & ! di/ribution ( taxpay] funds to 8 political allies4 ,9 sub/ance1 ! p]man5t b> on any ,,irs exam9ation ( himself1 8 family1 & 8 bus9esses function$ z a self-grant$ p>don f future tax acc\ntability1 obta9$ n ?r\gh ! con/itutional p>don p[] b ?r\gh a collusive lawsuit aga9/ an ag5cy he controls1 an ass]tion t ! ,presid5t & 8 family /& above ! law t a ,f$]al c\rt has s9ce f\nd 0 nev] a g5u9e legal proce$+ at all4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xviii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,! ,corrupt ,use ( ! ,p>don ,p[] ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by us+ ! p>don p[] to rew>d weal?y donors1 bus9ess p>tn]s1 & political allies ^: clem5cy applications 7 ti$ to f9ancial b5efits fl[+ to ,donald ,j4 ,trump p]sonally or to bus9esses own$ by 8 family1 r ?an to any traditional /&>d ( ju/ice1 remorse1 or rehabilitation4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,octob] #ba1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump p>don$ ,*angp5g ,zhao1 f\nd] ( ! cryptocurr5cy ex*ange ,b9ance1 :o _h plead$ guilty to a felony violation ( ! ,bank ,secrecy ,act aft] 8 company admitt$ all[+ m ?an a million & a half transactions t violat$ ,unit$ ,/ates sanctions & facilitat$ money fl[s to t]rori/s & *ild abus]s4 ,! p>don came aft] ,b9ance's /ableco9 p>tn] complet$ a #b1jjj1jjj1jjj inve/m5t 9 ! ,trump family's own crypto v5ture1 ,_w ,lib]ty ,f9ancial1 & aft] a lobbyi/ p]sonally press$ ,donald ,j4 ,trump on ,zhao's p>don dur+ an ,oval ,(fice meet+4 7#b7 ,9 ,decemb] #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump p>don$ ,timo?y ,leiweke1 =m] ,,ceo ( ,oak ,view ,gr\p1 aft] 8 company _h donat$ #bej1jjj to ! ,trump inaugural committee & 8 attorney a ,donald ,j4 ,trump ally p]sonally lobbi$ ! ,presid5t = l5i5cy dur+ a r\nd ( golf at ,m>-a-,lago4 7#c7 ,9 ,janu>y #bjbf1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump p>don$ ,julio ,h]r]a ,velut9i1 a =eign billionaire fac+ brib]y *>ges relat$ to ,pu]to ,rico's gov]nor1 aft] ,h]r]a ,velut9i's tw5ty-five-ye>-old daught]1 ^: only prior political donation on record 0 #bj doll>s1 contribut$ #c1ejj1jjj to a ,donald ,j4 ,trump-align$ sup] ,,pac4 7#d7 ,! proximity & sequ5ce ( ^! ev5ts a bus9ess relation%ip or f9ancial b5efit to ,donald ,j4 ,trump or 8 family1 foll[$ by clem5cy = ! v individual :o provid$ x recurr$ across multiple p>dons 9 a patt]n inconsi/5t ) ! traditional /&>ds ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice applies to clem5cy petitions1 :i* exam9e ! applicant's acceptance ( responsibility1 conduct s9ce conviction1 & ! int]e/s ( ju/ice1 n ! applicant's f9ancial relation%ip to ! ,presid5t grant+ ! p>don4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump trans=m$ ! con/itutional p>don p[]1 int5d$ z an in/rum5t ( m]cy & ju/ice1 into a m>ketplace 9 :i* weal?y donors1 bus9ess p>tn]s1 & allies c\ld pur*ase clem5cy ?r\gh political contributions & f9ancial arrangem5ts b5efit+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump & 8 family p]sonally4 ,! impli$ ex*ange ( f9ancial b5efit & political support = a p>don1 effectively creat+1 = ! individual :o pays = x1 a p]sonal exception to ! crim9al law & to ! ord9>y processes ( ju/ice1 is itself corrupt1 & und]m9es ! ,con/itution's protections ( political fre$om & equal ju/ice "u ! law4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xix3 ,attacks on a ,free ,press--,bani%+ ,report]s f ! ,:ite ,h\se = ,disfavor$ ,cov]age ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t's gu>antee ( a free press by repeat$ly /ripp+ news organizations ( access to ! ,:ite ,h\se1 ! press pool1 & ! brief+ room because ( ! cont5t ( _! cov]age1 & by seiz+ control ( ! me*anism t det]m9es h[ & :i* j\rnali/s may access ! ,:ite ,h\se1 not)/&+ ! ,con/itution's express limits on viewpo9t discrim9ation 9 gov]nm5tal action4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,janu>y #bj1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ an ,executive ord] r5am+ ! ,gulf ( ,mexico ! ,gulf ( ,am]ica4 ,:5 ! ,associat$ ,press ann\nc$ x w\ld cont9ue ref]r+ to ! ,gulf ( ,mexico 9 its own report+1 ! ,:ite ,h\se b>r$ ,,ap report]s f ! ,oval ,(fice1 ,air ,=ce ,"o1 & o!r re/rict$ press spaces beg9n+ 9 ,febru>y #bjbe4 ,u4,s4 ,di/rict ,judge ,trevor ,mc,fadden f\nd t ! exclusion seems pretty cle>ly viewpo9t discrim9ation &1 on ,april #h1 #bjbe1 issu$ a prelim9>y injunction ord]+ ,,ap's access re/or$2 ! adm9i/ration appeal$1 & ! ,d4,c4 ,circuit /ay$ t rul+ on ,june #f1 #bjbe1 & upheld ! /ay on ,july #bb1 #bjbe1 leav+ ! ban 9 effect p5d+ fur!r litigation4 7#b7 ,on ,febru>y #be-bf1 #bjbe1 ! ,:ite ,h\se ann\nc$ x w\ld unilat]ally seize control ( ! press pool f ! ,:ite ,h\se ,correspond5ts' ,association1 :i* _h det]m9$ pool composition & que/ion+ ord] = decades "u e prior adm9i/ration ( bo? p>ties4 ,press ,secret>y ,k>ol9e ,leavitt decl>$ n any m1 & ,donald ,j4 ,trump himself /at$1 we're go+ to be n[ call+ ! %ots4 ,,:ca ,presid5t ,eug5e ,daniels w>n$ t ! move meant ! gov]nm5t w *oose ! j\rnali/s :o cov] ! presid5t1 & t 9 a free c\ntry1 lead]s mu/ n be able to *oose _! own press corps4 7#c7 ,9 ,octob] #bjbe1 ,secret>y ( ,def5se ,pete ,hegse? impos$ new ,p5tagon cr$5tial+ rules requir+ report]s to obta9 prior gov]nm5t au?orization be=e seek+ in=mation f def5se p]sonnel1 on pa9 ( los+ _! press badges4 ,r ?an accept a rule t ,milit>y ,times & ,def5se ,news w>n$ w\ld puni% report]s :o ask legitimate que/ions1 at lea/ ?irty major news organizations includ+ ,,abc ,news1 ,,nbc ,news1 ,,cbs ,news1 ,fox ,news1 ,,cnn1 ,! ,new ,york ,times1 ,! ,wa%+ton ,po/1 ,reut]s1 ! ,associat$ ,press1 & ,,npr =feit$ _! ,p5tagon cr$5tials 9 a unifi$ act ( pr(essional consci5ce1 leav+ only outlets align$ ) ! adm9i/ration inside ! build+4 ,u4,s4 ,di/rict ,judge ,paul ,l4 ,fri$man /ruck ! policy d[n z uncon/itutional on ,m>* #bj1 #bjbf1 & p]man5tly enjo9$ x2 ! ,p5tagon's second attempt to impose mat]ially simil> re/rictions 0 block$ 9 ,april #bjbf4 7#d7 ,on ! week5d ( ,septemb] #ai-bj1 #bjbf1 ! ,:ite ,h\se revok$ ! press cr$5tials ( ,,cnn1 ,,ms ,,n[1 & ,politico )\t notice or process1 remov+ ,,cnn f ! pool rotation entirely & elim9at+ video cov]age ( ! ,presid5t = millions ( ,am]icans4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump /at$ ! outlets 7 exclud$ because !y only write negatively ab\t him & %\ld n be all[$ access4 ,,cnn1 ,,ms ,,n[1 & ,politico su$ on ,septemb] #ba1 #bjbf1 alleg+ retaliatory viewpo9t discrim9ation 9 violation ( ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t & a d5ial ( due process "u ! ,fif? ,am5dm5t1 /at+ t )\t notice or process1 ! ,:ite ,h\se revok$ our j\rnali/s' cr$5tials because x object$ to our report+4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump has1 ov] ! c\rse ( ne>ly two ye>s & aga9/ outlets spann+ ! ideological spectrum ( ! ma9/ream press1 conv]t$ control ov] physical access to ! presid5cy into a tool = puni%+ unfavorable cov]age1 a practice ,f$]al c\rts h repeat$ly & explicitly f\nd uncon/itutional1 & "o t /rikes directly at ! /ructural function a free press s]ves 9 a con/itutional democracy3 report+ on ! gov]nm5t to ! p x gov]ns1 )\t ! gov]nm5t's p]mission z to :at x may say4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t & trial1 & removal f (fice & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xx3 ,attacks on a ,free ,press--,co]c+ ,,cbs & ,,abc to ,*ange ,editorial ,cont5t ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t's gu>antee ( a free press ?r\gh #b relat$ c\rses ( conduct1 includ+ fil+ a legally weak lawsuit aga9/ ,,cbs ,news ov] ord9>y editorial judgm5t & us+ 8 adm9i/ration's control ov] a p5d+ multibillion-doll> m]g] to co]ce a f9ancial settlem5t f ! network's p>5t company1 & direct+ ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice to subpo5a j\rnali/s & _! phone records 9 an ef=t to unmask ! confid5tial s\rces beh9d news cov]age ! ,adm9i/ration f\nd emb>rass+ or unflatt]+4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,donald ,j4 ,trump fil$ a #bj1jjj1jjj1jjj lawsuit aga9/ ,,cbs ,news alleg+ t its edit+ ( a #fj ,m9utes int]view ) !n ,vice ,presid5t ,kamala ,h>ris 0 unlawful4 ,! gravam5 ( ! compla9t 0 an ord9>y editorial *oice1 :i* ( two responses to ! same "q to air1 a decision ( ! k9d news organizations make daily & t has nev] be=e be5 treat$ z actionable outside ! defamation context1 :i* ! compla9t did n plead4 7#b7 ,at ! same "t ?is lawsuit 0 p5d+1 ,,cbs's p>5t company1 ,p>am\nt ,global1 requir$ approval f ! ,f$]al ,communications ,commission 7,,fcc7 !n *air$ by a ,donald ,j4 ,trump appo9tee = its multibillion-doll> m]g] ) ,skydance ,m$ia4 ,on ,july #b1 #bjbe1 ,p>am\nt agre$ to pay #af1jjj1jjj t[>d ,donald ,j4 ,trump's future presid5tial libr>y to settle ! suit1 a settlem5t ,p>am\nt's own co-,,ceo /at$ 0 made to avoid jeop>diz+ ! p5d+ m]g]4 7#c7 ,! ,,fcc1 "u its ,donald ,j4 ,trump-appo9t$ *airman1 op5$ a =mal broadca/ news di/ortion inve/igation into ,,cbs ov] ! same int]view und]ly+ ! lawsuit :ile ! m]g] review rema9$ p5d+1 & approv$ ! m]g] %ortly aft] ! settlem5t us+ ! ,commission's lic5s+ au?ority ov] ! same set ( facts und]ly+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's p]sonal lawsuit1 9 a mann] t plac$ a ,f$]al ag5cy's regulatory lev]age & ! ,presid5t's p]sonal litigation aga9/ ! same company on ! same timel9e4 7#d7 ,p>am\nt nev] p]mitt$ a c\rt to rule on :e!r ,donald ,j4 ,trump's lawsuit or ! ,,fcc's inve/igation 7 lawful4 ,r1 x settl$ be=e ! m]its ( ! case 7 *all5g$ :ile its m]g] rema9$ p5d+ be=e ! v ag5cies conduct+ !m4 ,t a company1 :ile seek+ regulatory approval = a major transaction1 decid$ n to pay #af1jjj1jjj & make editorial concessions ov] respond+ to a dubi\s legal claim reveals ! co]cive weight ( ! regulatory lev]age ,donald ,j4 ,trump's adm9i/ration held4 ,! editorial *anges demon/rate ! exact *ill+ effect on press fre$om ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t exi/s to prev5t4 7#e7 ,9 ,septemb] #bjbe1 ,,fcc ,*airman ,br5dan ,c>r1 a ,donald ,j4 ,trump appo9tee1 publicly ?reat5$ ,,abc & its network affiliates ov] com$ian ,jimmy ,kimmel's on-air rem>ks ab\t ! kill+ ( ,*>lie ,kirk1 call+ ! rem>ks "s ( ! sicke/ conduct possible & w>n+ broadca/]s1 we c d ?is ! easy way or ! h>d way1 :ile sugge/+ !re w\ld be additional "w = ! ,,fcc if ! network did n act4 ,)9 h\rs1 ,,abc affiliate own]s ,nex/> ,m$ia ,gr\p & ,s9clair ,broadca/ ,gr\p bo? ( :i* _h bus9ess p5d+ be=e ! ,commission ann\nc$ !y w\ld preempt ,jimmy ,kimmel ,live61 & ,,abc itself susp5d$ ! %[ indef9itely t same day4 ,c>r lat] d5i$ t 8 ?reat _h any?+ to d ) ! susp5sion1 a d5ial ,donald ,j4 ,trump publicly e*o$1 not)/&+ t ,c>r's rem>ks1 invok+ 8 au?ority ov] ! same broadca/]s' lic5ses1 directly prec$$ ,,abc's decision by h\rs4 7#f7 ,9 ,april #bjbf1 ! ,,fcc ord]$ ,disney's ,,abc-own$ television /ations to file _! broadca/ lic5se r5ewals ahead ( ! normal s*$ule1 do+ s amid an ongo+ inve/igation into p]ceiv$ bias on ! ,,abc program ,! ,view & a sep>ate inquiry into ,disney's div]sity1 equity1 & inclusion practices1 & :ile m ?an #aej1jjj public comm5ts _m organiz$ ?r\gh campaigns enc\rag+ ! ,,fcc to d5y ! lic5ses ov] ! network's news cov]age flood$ ! result+ docket4 ,on ,augu/ #ah1 #bjbf1 ,disney & ,,abc su$ ! ,,fcc1 alleg+ t ! e>ly lic5se review & ! div]sity1 equity1 & inclusion practices & ,! ,view inve/igations am\nt$ to retaliation = ,kimmel's susp5sion & ,,abc's news cov]age 9 violation ( ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t "o ( ! mo/ direct legal *all5ges any m$ia company has br\ght aga9/ ! ,adm9i/ration's use ( lic5s+ au?ority to pressure broadca/]s ov] cont5t4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump us$ ! ma*9]y ( litigation1 ! regulatory au?ority ( an ag5cy he controls1 & ! subpo5a p[] ( 8 own ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice to extract a multimillion-doll> paym5t b5efit+ himself p]sonally1 =ce a late-night ho/ (f ! air1 place a major broadca/]'s lic5ses 9 jeop>dy ov] disfavor$ comm5t>y1 & pressure news organizations ov] disfavor$ editorial cov]age1 a su/a9$ campaign1 spann+ multiple news organizations & multiple c\rts1 t *ills ! fre$om ( ! press ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t 0 writt5 to protect1 & t 9 e in/ance :]e a c\rt 0 p]mitt$ to rule on ! und]ly+ subpo5as1 result$ 9 ! gov]nm5t ab&on+ !m r ?an def5d _! legality4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xxi3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,free ,spee* & ,retaliatory ,executive ,ord]s ,aga9/ ,law ,firms ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t by issu+ a s]ies ( ,executive ord]s t>get+ major ,unit$ ,/ates law firms = retaliation1 by /ripp+ security cle>ances1 t]m9at+ ,f$]al contracts1 & b>r+ firm employees f ,f$]al build+s1 because ^? firms _h repres5t$ 8 political adv]s>ies or _h employ$ lawy]s he p]ceiv$ z enemies4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,m>* #f1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ an ,executive ord] t>get+ ,p]k9s ,coie ,,llp1 susp5d+ ! security cle>ances ( ! entire firm's employees1 t]m9at+ ,f$]al contracts ) its cli5ts1 & b>r+ its lawy]s f ,f$]al build+s1 because ! firm _h repres5t$ ,hill>y ,cl9ton's #bjaf campaign & hir$ ! rese>* firm connect$ to ! ,/eele dossi]4 7#b7 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ ne>ly id5tical ord]s aga9/ ,paul1 ,weiss1 ,rifk9d1 ,:>ton & ,g>rison on ,m>* #ad1 #bjbe1 t>get+ a p>tn] :o _h ov]se5 a ,manhattan inve/igation into ,donald ,j4 ,trump's bus9ess practices aga9/ ,j5n] & ,block on ,m>* #be1 #bjbe1 & aga9/ ,wilmer,hale on ,m>* #bg1 #bjbe1 because ( t firm's association ) =m] ,special ,c\nsel ,rob]t ,muell]4 7#c7 ,on ,may #b1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,b]yl ,h[ell1 an appo9tee ( ,presid5t ,obama1 p]man5tly /ruck d[n ! ,p]k9s ,coie ord] 9 a #ajb page op9ion1 hold+ t ! ord] violat$ ! firm's ,fir/ ,am5dm5t rights ( spee* & association & con/itut$ unlawful retaliation = its cli5ts' protect$ advocacy1 & writ+ t settl+ p]sonal v5dettas by t>get+ a dislik$ bus9ess or individual = punitive gov]nm5t action is n a legitimate use ( ! p[]s ( ! ,u4,s4 ,gov]nm5t or an ,am]ican presid5t4 7#d7 ,e o!r firm t *ose to litigate r ?an capitulate won an id5tical result4 ,on ,may #bc1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,john ,bates1 an appo9tee ( ,presid5t ,george ,w4 ,bu%1 /ruck d[n ! ord] aga9/ ,j5n] & ,block z uncon/itutional1 hold+ t x t>get$ ! firm = :at x has said & !reby attempts to damp5 :at x might yet say4 ,on ,may #bg1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,ri*>d ,leon also a ,bu% appo9tee /ruck d[n ! ord] aga9/ ,wilmer,hale1 hold+ t x unlawfully us$ co]cion to suppress ,wilmer,hale's repres5tation ( disfavor$ causes & cli5ts & t all[+ x to /& w\ld be unfai?ful to ! judgm5t & vision ( ! ,f\nd+ ,fa!rs4 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,lor5 ,ali,khan1 an appo9tee ( ,presid5t ,bid51 rul$ ! same way 9 ! case br\ght by ,susman ,godfrey4 7#e7 ,f\r diff]5t firms su$ & #d diff]5t judges1 #b appo9t$ by ,republican presid5ts1 #b by ,democratic presid5ts1 rul$ unanim\sly t ! ord]s 7 uncon/itutional4 ,r ?an pursue fur!r appeals ( ?is unbrok5 record1 ! ,adm9i/ration =mally dismiss$ its p5d+ appeals 9 all #d cases1 an affirmative concession t no c\rt1 ( any composition1 0 prep>$ to su/a9 ! ord]s' con/itutionality4 7#f7 ,ea* ( ^! ord]s foll[$ ! same patt]n1 id5tify a firm associat$ ) a specific piece ( protect$ advocacy or repres5tation ! ,presid5t f\nd p]sonally objectionable1 & impose sanctions1 loss ( security cle>ances1 loss ( ,f$]al contracts1 & d5ial ( access to ,f$]al build+s1 calibrat$ to ?reat5 ! firm's ability to cont9ue op]at+1 r ?an any sanction ti$ to a specific violation ( pr(essional conduct rules ?r\gh ! discipl9>y processes t normally gov]n attorney conduct & 9 :i* ! ,presid5t has no con/itutional role4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump attempt$ to use ! co]cive p[] ( ! presid5cy to puni% lawy]s = repres5t+ cli5ts he disfavor$ & to intimidate ! legal pr(ession g5]ally into decl9+ to *all5ge 8 adm9i/ration1 an assault on ! "r to c\nsel & ! fre$om ( association t #d ,f$]al judges1 appo9t$ by ,presid5ts ( bo? p>ties1 unanim\sly f\nd uncon/itutional1 a judicial v]dict s "o-sid$ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice ultimately conc$$ x r ?an pursue fur!r review4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xxii3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,free ,spee* & ,co]c+ ,univ]sities ,?r\gh ,)held ,f$]al ,funds ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t by direct+ ,f$]al ag5cies to freeze billions ( doll>s 9 ,f$]al rese>* fund+ = univ]sities1 includ+ ,h>v>d ,univ]sity1 z retaliation = ^? in/itutions' protect$ spee* & _! refusal to submit to ideological dem&s reg>d+ curriculum1 hir+1 & /ud5t discipl9e4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,beg9n+ 9 ! spr+ ( #bjbe1 ! ,adm9i/ration ann\nc$ x 0 review+ & !n froze m ?an #b1bjj1jjj1jjj 9 ,f$]al rese>* grants & #fj1jjj1jjj 9 contracts ) ,h>v>d ,univ]sity1 purport$ly ov] conc]ns ab\t campus antisemitism1 :ile simultane\sly dem&+ sweep+ *anges to ! univ]sity's gov]nance1 hir+ practices1 & admissions scre5+ ( int]national applicants bas$ on _! political viewpo9ts reg>d+ ! ,israeli-,pale/9ian conflict4 7#b7 ,on ,septemb] #c1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,allison ,burr\ghs rul$ t ! fund+ freeze 0 uncon/itutional1 f9d+ t x con/itut$ retaliation1 uncon/itutional conditions1 & uncon/itutional co]cion 9 violation ( ! ,fir/ ,am5dm5t4 ,! c\rt f\nd t ! fund+ freeze 0 n tailor$ to any specific1 individualiz$ f9d+ ( civil-rights violations by ,h>v>d b 0 in/ead us$ z lev]age to compel sweep+ *anges to ! univ]sity's gov]nance1 hir+1 & admissions practices unrelat$ to any adjudicat$ violation ( law4 7#c7 ,fac+ ! same pressure campaign1 sev]al o!r univ]sities includ+ ! ,univ]sity ( ,p5nsylvania1 ,columbia ,univ]sity1 ,cornell ,univ]sity1 ,nor?we/]n ,univ]sity1 & ,br[n ,univ]sity ent]$ into settlem5t agreem5ts ) ! ,adm9i/ration to re/ore _! rese>* fund+1 ) ,columbia alone agree+ to pay #bbj1jjj1jjj1 demon/rat+ t ! )hold+ ( lawfully appropriat$ rese>* funds function$ z lev]age to extract ideological & f9ancial concessions f ,unit$ ,/ates academic in/itutions4 7#d7 ,! ,adm9i/ration ext5d$ ?is campaign to public univ]sities z well4 ,9 ,july #bjbe1 ! ,national ,in/itutes ( ,heal? & ,national ,sci5ce ,f\ndation froze m ?an #ejj1jjj1jjj 9 rese>* grants to ! ,univ]sity ( ,cali=nia1 ,los ,angeles1 & ! ,adm9i/ration propos$ a #a1jjj1jjj1jjj settlem5t to resolve claims t ,,ucla tol]at$ antisemitism & engag$ 9 race-bas$ admissions an arrangem5t ,gov]nor ,gav9 ,newsom's adm9i/ration publicly *>act]iz$ z extortion4 ,,ucla decl9$ to settle1 & on ,septemb] #bb1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,rita ,l9 f\nd ! fund+ freeze likely violat$ ! ,adm9i/rative ,proc$ure ,act & ord]$ ! ,gov]nm5t to re/ore approximately #ejj1jjj1jjj 9 grants1 a rul+ t1 toge!r ) ! ,h>v>d decision1 ext5d$ ! same con/itutional f9d+ to a public univ]sity sy/em4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump direct$ ! )hold+ ( billions ( doll>s 9 congressionally appropriat$ rese>* fund+ = canc] rese>* & o!r "w b5efit+ ! ,unit$ ,/ates public1 z a co]cive tool to puni% univ]sities = con/itutionally protect$ spee* & to compel ideological con=mity1 conduct a ,f$]al c\rt has already rul$ uncon/itutional4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xxiii3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,demoli%+ ! ,:ite ,h\se ,ea/ ,w+ ,)\t ,congressional ,approval ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & 8 duty z /ew>d1 n own]1 ( ! ,:ite ,h\se by unilat]ally demoli%+ ! hi/oric ,ea/ ,w+ ( ! ,:ite ,h\se to con/ruct a private ballroom1 )\t seek+ ! congressional approval & indep5d5t commission review hi/orically requir$ = major alt]ations to ! executive mansion4 ,! ,con/itution ve/s 9 ,congress alone ! p[] to dispose ( & make all ne$ful rules respect+ prop]ty belong+ to ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 & ! ,:ite ,h\se1 built ) & ma9ta9$ by public funds s9ce #ahjj1 is su* prop]ty4 ,no ,presid5t possesses indep5d5t con/itutional au?ority to demoli% "p ( x & con/ruct a replacem5t ( 8 own design m]ely because he has arrang$ to pay = ! con/ruction himself4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,beg9n+ 9 ,octob] #bjbe1 demolition crews raz$ ! ,ea/ ,w+ ( ! ,:ite ,h\se1 ! traditional (fice ( ! ,fir/ ,lady & a compon5t ( ! executive mansion = m ?an a c5tury1 )\t fir/ submitt+ con/ruction plans to ! ,national ,capital ,plann+ ,commission or seek+ congressional approval1 not)/&+ t no improvem5t or alt]ation ( ?is magnitude to ! ,:ite ,h\se _h occurr$ 9 m ?an #gj ye>s4 7#b7 ,! ,national ,tru/ = ,hi/oric ,pres]vation su$ to halt ! project1 alleg+ t ! ,adm9i/ration skipp$ ! legally m&at$ review processes & fail$ to seek congressional approval be=e beg9n+ demolition4 ,on ,m>* #ca1 #bjbf1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,ri*>d ,leon ord]$ a halt to fur!r above-gr\nd con/ruction abs5t congressional au?orization1 rul+ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump is a /ew>d ( ! ,:ite ,h\se = future g5]ations1 n its own]1 & t no /atute comes close to giv+ ! ,presid5t ! au?ority he claims to h4 ,judge ,leon p]mitt$ con/ruction to cont9ue only ins(> z necess>y = ! safety & security ( ! ,:ite ,h\se1 a c>ve-out t encompass$ ! und]gr\nd bunk] ! ,adm9i/ration 0 simultane\sly build+ b5ea? ! site not)/&+ t ! ,:ite ,h\se complex has includ$ a h>d5$ security bunk]1 ! ,presid5tial ,em]g5cy ,op]ations ,c5t]1 s9ce x 0 fir/ built dur+ ! ,second ,_w ,w> & sub/antially exp&$ aft] #bjja1 rais+ ! "q ( :at additional security necessity a second1 newly built bunk] 0 int5d$ to s]ve4 7#c7 ,despite t judicial ord]1 ! ,national ,capital ,plann+ ,commission *air$ by ,w ,s*>f1 a ,donald ,j4 ,trump aide :om ! ,presid5t _h appo9t$ to head ! ,commission 9 ,july #bjbe aft] fir+ sev]al ( its prior memb]s1 proce$$ to grant f9al approval ( ! ballroom project days lat]1 9 a maneuv] design$ to evade r ?an comply ) ! c\rt's rul+4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump nam$ ,s*>f ,:ite ,h\se ,c\nsel 9 ,augu/ #bjbf1 elevat+ to ! position responsible = advis+ ! ,presid5t on ! legality ( 8 own conduct ! same aide :o _h head$ ! commission t approv$ ! ballroom project ov] ! di/rict c\rt's objection4 7#d7 ,! co/ ( ! project1 initially e/imat$ at #bej1jjj1jjj1 grew to an e/imat$ #djj1jjj1jjj &1 accord+ to lat] report+ on contractor invoices1 may exce$ #fjj1jjj1jjj1 z ,donald ,j4 ,trump repeat$ly enl>g$ its scope1 ) ! ,:ite ,h\se itself ackn[l$g+ t public funds are be+ us$ = und]gr\nd bunk]s & security upgrades ev5 z ! ,presid5t has claim$ ! project is entirely privately f9anc$4 ,congress refus$ ! ,adm9i/ration's reque/ = #a1jjj1jjj1jjj 9 public fund+ = ! project 9 ,may #bjbf1 & ,democratic memb]s ( ,congress w>n$ ! foll[+ mon? t #cej1jjj1jjj 9 funds f an unrelat$ tax law appe>$ to h be5 r$irect$ to pay = con/ruction reg>dless4 7#e7 ,on ,augu/ #g1 #bjbf1 a divid$ panel ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,c\rt ( ,appeals = ! ,di/rict ( ,columbia ,circuit affirm$ ,judge ,leon's injunction1 ord]+ t above-gr\nd con/ruction rema9 halt$ until ,congress au?orizes ! project4 ,! c\rt wrote t ea* ,presid5t is a tempor>y t5ant1 n ! own]1 ( ! ,:ite ,h\se1 & reject$ ! ,adm9i/ration's invocation ( national-security ju/ifications to excuse ! demolition & con/ruction1 writ+ t su* argum5ts are n an automatic get-out-(-law-free c>d & t ! bold ass]tion t ! ,executive c act ) utt] lawlessness1 de/roy+ treasur$ national l&m>ks & h>m+ ! int]e/s ( individuals1 & t no c\rt c /op x fl\ts our con/itutional ord]4 ,! c\rt fur!r held t :e!r or n a massive ballroom %\ld be con/ruct$ is = ,congress to decide & is n a matt] = ,executive self-help4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump unilat]ally de/roy$ a hi/oric compon5t ( ! ,:ite ,h\se held 9 tru/ = ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s1 evad$ ! review processes & congressional approval hi/orically requir$ = su* alt]ations1 us$ commissions ( 8 own appo9tees to ratify ! fait accompli aft] a ,f$]al c\rt _h ord]$ con/ruction halt$1 & !n elevat$ ! v aide :o *air$ t commission to ! position ( ,:ite ,h\se ,c\nsel4 ,bo? ! di/rict c\rt &1 on appeal1 a divid$ panel ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,c\rt ( ,appeals = ! ,d4,c4 ,circuit h n[ held t ! project _c proce$ )\t congressional au?orization ,donald ,j4 ,trump has nev] s\ght4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xxiv3 ,violation ( ,oa?--,! ,illegal ,imp\ndm5t ( ,appropriat$ ,funds ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ,article ,i's ve/+ ( ! p[] ( ! purse 9 ,congress by direct+ 8 ,(fice ( ,managem5t & ,budget to )hold billions ( doll>s 9 appropriat$ funds ?r\gh bo? =mal rescission proposals & in=mal delay1 9 defiance ( ! ,imp\ndm5t ,control ,act ( #aigd4 ,?is conduct 0 n m]ely flagg$ by ! ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice z a legislative-bran* legal op9ion1 b a ,f$]al di/rict c\rt1 apply+ ! same /atutes1 indep5d5tly rea*$ ! m]its & held ! )hold+ unlawful4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,9 ,augu/ #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's ,(fice ( ,managem5t & ,budget1 "u ,director ,russell ,v\ght1 propos$ a s-call$ pocket rescission )hold+ funds f obligation s close to ! end ( ! fiscal ye> t ! funds w\ld expire be=e ,congress c\ld act on ! proposal1 !reby a*iev+ ! cancellation ( ! sp5d+ )\t ev] obta9+ ! affirmative congressional approval ! ,imp\ndm5t ,control ,act requires = a rescission to take effect4 7#b7 ,on ,septemb] #c1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,amir ,ali rul$ on ! m]its t ! ,adm9i/ration's )hold+ ( r\ghly #aj1ejj1jjj1jjj 9 appropriat$ =eign-assi/ance fund+ 0 unlawful1 writ+ t t"h is n a plausible int]pretation ( ! /atutes t w\ld ju/ify ! billions ( doll>s !y plan to )hold1 & ent]$ a prelim9>y injunction ord]+ ! funds obligat$ be=e !y expir$4 ,! ,unit$ ,/ates ,c\rt ( ,appeals = ! ,di/rict ( ,columbia ,circuit d5i$ ! ,adm9i/ration's reque/ to /ay t injunction p5d+ appeal1 leav+ ! di/rict c\rt's f9d+ ( illegality intact at e level ( judicial review t rea*$ ! m]its4 7#c7 ,! ,adm9i/ration !n s\ght em]g5cy relief f ! ,supreme ,c\rt1 & on ,septemb] #bf1 #bjbe1 ,*ief ,ju/ice ,rob]ts grant$ a /ay ( ! di/rict c\rt's injunction b ! ,c\rt's ord] expressly /at$ t x reflect$ only ! ,c\rt's prelim9>y view1 consi/5t ) ! /&>ds = int]im relief1 & t x %\ld n be read z a f9al det]m9ation on ! m]its4 ,no c\rt1 at any /age ( ?is litigation1 ev] held on ! m]its t ! )hold+ 0 lawful4 ,! only judge to rea* ! m]its held t x 0 n4 7#d7 ,! ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice rea*$ ! same legal conclusion z ,judge ,ali ?r\gh its own /atutory review process1 f9d+ pocket rescissions ( ?is k9d inconsi/5t ) ! ,imp\ndm5t ,control ,act's legislative hi/ory & ! con/itutional sep>ation ( p[]s1 & not+ t no adm9i/ration 9 ne>ly #ej ye>s _h attempt$ to execute "o includ+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own fir/-t]m ,,omb1 :i* consid]$ & reject$ ! tactic 9 #bjah & #bjai aft] ! ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice f\nd x unlawful4 7#e7 ,! s*eme drew *all5ges f across ! political spectrum specifically because x inv]t$ ! con/itutional design1 r ?an seek+ ,congress' approval to cancel sp5d+ x disfavor$1 z ! ,imp\ndm5t ,control ,act requires1 ! ,adm9i/ration us$ ! m]e passage ( "t to accompli% a de facto l9e-item veto ! v device ! ,supreme ,c\rt held uncon/itutional 9 ,cl9ton v4 ,city ( ,new ,york4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump ass]t$ a p[] ! ,con/itution res]ves to ,congress alone1 ! p[] to det]m9e h[ appropriat$ funds are sp5t1 & did s ?r\gh a maneuv] t ! #a c\rt to rea* ! m]its held unlawful1 t no c\rt ev] upheld on ! m]its1 & t ! ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice1 apply+ ! same /atutory text1 indep5d5tly conclud$ violat$ ! law ( ! l&4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xxv3 ,abuse ( ,p[]--,self-,aggr&izem5t ,?r\gh ! ,r5am+ ( ,public ,in/itutions1 ,seizure ( ,cultural & ,civic ,prop]ty1 & ,p]sonal ,appropriation ( ,national ,curr5cy ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? by us+ ! p[]s ( 8 (fice to atta* 8 own "n1 lik5ess1 & p]sona to in/itutions & prop]ty belong+ to ! ,unit$ ,/ates p includ+1 an indep5d5t congressionally *>t]$ peace in/itute1 ! ,nation's =emo/ public p]=m+ arts c5t]1 ! circulat+ curr5cy ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 &1 z detail$ sep>ately 9 ,article ,,xxii1 ! ,:ite ,h\se itself1 9 a su/a9$ patt]n ( self-commemoration )\t prec$5t among 8 pr$ecessors & squ>ely at odds ) ! republican tradition ( res]v+ su* honors1 if any1 = ! dead & = in/itutions ,congress alone may "n4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,on ,febru>y #ai1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sign$ ,executive ,ord] #adbag decl>+ ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,in/itute ( ,peace 7,in/itute71 an indep5d5t nonpr(it corporation creat$ by ,congress 9 #aihd specifically to insulate peacebuild+ "w f p>tisan politics1 unnecess>y1 & direct$ ! t]m9ation ( its entire bo>d1 its presid5t1 & mo/ ( its /aff4 ,:5 ! ,in/itute's lead]%ip refus$ to recognize ! legitimacy ( ! takeov]1 p]sonnel f ! ,,doge1 accompani$ by ag5ts ( ! ,,fbi & ! ,,dc4 ,metropolitan ,police1 =c$ _! way into ! ,in/itute's headqu>t]s 9 ,m>* #bjbe1 to physically seize ! build+4 ,on ,may #ai1 #bjbe1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,b]yl ,h[ell1 ! same judge :o w\ld lat] /rike d[n ,donald ,j4 ,trump's retaliatory ord] aga9/ ,p]k9s ,coie1 describ$ 9 ,article ,,xx1 rul$ t ! takeov] _h be5 c>ri$ out by illegitimately-in/all$ lead]s & decl>$ x1 along ) ! purport$ transf] ( ! ,in/itute's build+1 null & void4 ,not)/&+ t rul+1 ! ,adm9i/ration proce$$ to transf] control ( ! build+ to ! ,/ate ,dep>tm5t1 & 9 ,decemb] #bjbe1 r5am$ x ! ,donald ,j4 ,trump ,in/itute ( ,peace1 affix+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's "n 9 l>ge metal lett]s above ! build+'s orig9al sign1 a *ange ! ,adm9i/ration's own spokesp]son said 0 int5d$ to reflect ! greate/ dealmak] 9 our ,nation's hi/ory1 & us$ ! build+ days lat] to ho/ a =eign peace-deal sign+ c]emony4 7#b7 ,on ,febru>y #ab1 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump dismiss$ ! ,bid5-appo9t$ tru/ees ( ! ,john ,f4 ,k5n$y ,c5t] = ! ,p]=m+ ,arts1 a national cultural in/itution ,congress creat$ by /atute 9 #aieh4 ,! rema9+1 newly ,donald ,j4 ,trump-appo9t$ bo>d !n elect$ ,donald ,j4 ,trump himself z *airman1 ! fir/ "t 9 ! ,c5t]'s hi/ory t a sitt+ presid5t _h held t position1 & fir$ ! ,c5t]'s presid5t ( #aa ye>s1 in/all+ a ,donald ,j4 ,trump loyali/ 9 h] place4 ,9 ,decemb] #bjbe1 ! bo>d vot$ to r5ame ! in/itution itself ,! ,donald ,j4 ,trump & ,john ,f4 ,k5n$y ,memorial ,c5t] = ! ,p]=m+ ,arts1 not)/&+ t ! ,c5t]'s e/abli%+ /atute is itself an ,act ( ,congress & t only ,congress possesses ! au?ority to r5ame a national memorial x has creat$4 ,a memb] ( ,congress pres5t = ! vote /at$ aft]w>d t %e _h be5 prev5t$ f speak+ be=e x 0 =c$ ?r\gh4 ,republicans ( ! ,h\se ( ,repres5tatives sep>ately advanc$ a proposal1 approv$ 9 committee1 to r5ame ! ,c5t]'s ,op]a ,h\se aft] ,fir/ ,lady ,melania ,trump4 7#c7 ,repres5tative ,joyce ,beatty ( ,ohio1 an ex (ficio tru/ee ( ! ,c5t]1 su$ ,donald ,j4 ,trump & ! ,c5t]'s bo>d on ,decemb] #bb1 #bjbe1 argu+ t only ,congress c\ld r5ame an in/itution x _h creat$ by /atute4 ,on ,may #bi1 #bjbf1 ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,judge ,*ri/oph] ,coop] agre$1 rul+ 9 a #id page op9ion issu$ on ,presid5t ,k5n$y's bir?day t ! ,c5t]'s organic /atute makes cry/al cle> t ! ,c5t] is to be nam$ = ,presid5t ,k5n$y1 & x _c be> any o!r =mal "n or public memorial bas$ on ! ,bo>d's unilat]al say-s1 & t ,congress gave ! ,k5n$y ,c5t] its "n1 & only ,congress c *ange x4 ,judge ,coop] ord]$ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's "n remov$ f ! build+'s facade1 its website1 & all o!r signage1 & sep>ately re/or$ ,repres5tative ,beatty's vot+ rights z a tru/ee1 :i* ! bo>d _h /ripp$ f h]4 ,r ?an comply1 ! bo>d initially cov]$ ! lett]+ ) a t>p1 & only remov$ ! individual lett]s spell+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's "n on ,june #ab & #ac1 #bjbf1 aft] a ,f$]al appeals c\rt decl9$ to /ay ! ord]4 ,weeks lat]1 ! bo>d vot$ aga9 ?is "t to add ! inscription ,re/or$ & ,r5ovat$ by ,presid5t ,donald ,j4 ,trump b5ea? ! ,c5t]'s "n1 prompt+ ,repres5tative ,beatty to file a second em]g5cy motion to block x4 ,9 an ,augu/ #bjbf fil+ oppos+ t motion1 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice w>n$ t if ,donald ,j4 ,trump 7 n p]mitt$ to atta* 8 "n to ! ,c5t] 9 "s =m1 ! build+ w\ld be left to det]iorate fur!r into an unsafe1 decrepit /ructure t w be requir$ to be tak5 d[n4 ,! ,adm9i/ration also publicly sugge/$ t x might demoli% ! ,k5n$y ,c5t] itself r ?an complete a r5ovation t did n be> ,donald ,j4 ,trump's "n4 7#d7 ,beg9n+ 9 #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump direct$ a s]ies ( ef=ts to place 8 own image & "n on ! circulat+ curr5cy & co9age ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 an honor traditionally res]v$ = ! deceas$4 ,9 ,septemb] #bjbf1 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,m9t began circulat+ a gold-color$ #a co9 be>+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's portrait1 ! fir/ depiction ( a sitt+ presid5t on circulat+ ,unit$ ,/ates curr5cy 9 a c5tury1 & only ! second 9 ! ,nation's hi/ory4 ,! ,adm9i/ration ju/ifi$ ! co9 "u a #bjbj /atute au?oriz+ special semiqu9c5t5nial co9 designs1 not)/&+ t ! same /atute b>s ! portrait ( any liv+ p]son f appe>+ on ! co9's rev]se4 ,! ,adm9i/ration's response 0 to place ,donald ,j4 ,trump's portrait on ! co9's obv]se in/ead1 a placem5t "o con/itutional law s*ol> describ$ z fail+ to *ange ! fact t ! law prohibits1 curr5tly1 on curr5cy1 ! lik5ess ( any p]son1 n j ! ,presid5t1 :o is alive4 ,sep>ately1 ! ,treasury ,dep>tm5t ann\nc$ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own signature w\ld appe> on pap] curr5cy = ! fir/ "t by a sitt+ presid5t1 & ,treasury ,dep>tm5t (ficials prep>$ design mock-ups ( a #bej bill be>+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's portrait & signature1 not)/&+ an #ahff law1 enact$ aft] a ne>ly id5tical controv]sy involv+ a ,treasury ,dep>tm5t (ficial's portrait on a #e-;c5t note1 t flatly b>s any liv+ p]son's lik5ess f appe>+ on ,unit$ ,/ates curr5cy4 ,t bill has n be5 au?oriz$ or issu$4 ,a memb] ( ,congress has introduc$ legislation to ov]ride ! #ahff law = ! specific purpose ( p]mitt+ x4 7#e7 ,z detail$ 9 ,article ,,xxii1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump sep>ately direct$ ! demolition ( ! ,:ite ,h\se's hi/oric ,ea/ ,w+ to con/ruct a ballroom ( 8 own design1 a project #b ,f$]al c\rts h n[ held _c proce$ )\t ! congressional au?orization he has nev] s\ght4 ,consid]$ toge!r ) ! seizure & r5am+ ( ! ,in/itute ( ,peace1 ! capture & r5am+ ( ! ,k5n$y ,c5t]1 & ! campaign to place 8 lik5ess on ! ,nation's money1 ! ,ea/ ,w+ demolition is n an isolat$ act ( poor judgm5t ab\t hi/oric pres]vation b #a m in/ance ( ! same und]ly+ patt]n1 ! sub/itution ( ,donald ,j4 ,trump's p]sonal "n1 image1 & pref]5ces = ! in/itutions1 prop]ty1 & money t belong to ,unit$ ,/ates citiz5s & t ! ,con/itution & ,congress1 n ! ,presid5t alone1 are entru/$ to "n1 gov]n1 & pres]ve4 7#f7 ,congress creat$ ! ,commission ( ,f9e ,arts 9 #aiaj1 & ! ,national ,capital ,plann+ ,commission 9 #aieb1 = ! specific purpose ( subject+ major *anges to ! design ( ! ,nation's capital to dis9t]e/$1 exp]t review1 insulat$ f ! pref]5ces ( any s+le (ficehold]4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump defeat$ t purpose n by ignor+ ! review process outright b by fir/ /aff+ bo? bodies entirely ) 8 own appo9tees1 s t ! indep5d5t review ,congress int5d$ became1 9 sub/ance1 advisory to himself4 ,beg9n+ 9 ,octob] #bjbe1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump propos$ a #bej-;foot ,triumphal ,ar*1 model$ on ! ,arc de ,triomphe & tall] ?an ! ,l9coln ,memorial1 to be built at ,memorial ,circle betwe5 ! ,l9coln ,memorial & ,arl+ton ,national ,cemet]y1 on a sightl9e ,congress & ! ,national ,p>k ,s]vice h pres]v$ = m ?an a c5tury to honor ! ,nation's ,civil ,w> dead4 ,8 own appo9tees on ! ,commission ( ,f9e ,arts approv$ ! ar*'s design 9 ,may #bjbf1 not)/&+ t m ?an #ii p]c5t ( ! r\ghly #a1jjj public comm5ts ! ,commission receiv$ oppos$ ! project1 & 8 own appo9tees on ! ,national ,capital ,plann+ ,commission grant$ prelim9>y approval 9 ,july #bjbf1 not)/&+ a ,national ,p>k ,s]vice f9d+ t ! ar* w\ld disrupt ! hi/oric sightl9es connect+ ,arl+ton ,national ,cemet]y1 ,arl+ton ,h\se1 ,memorial ,bridge1 & ! ,l9coln ,memorial4 ,?ree ,vietnam ,w> vet]ans & an ar*itectural hi/orian su$ 9 #bjbf1 argu+ t a commemorative "w ( ?is scale requires ! au?orization ( ,congress itself "u ! ,commemorative ,works ,act1 9 addition to review by ! ,commission & ! ,plann+ ,commission1 & t no su* congressional au?orization 0 ev] s\ght or obta9$4 ,! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice mov$ to dismiss ! suit1 & 9 ,septemb] #bjbf1 ) t motion /ill p5d+1 ! ,secret>y ( ! ,int]ior ann\nc$ t excavation w\ld beg9 )9 #b weeks reg>dless4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump us$ ! p[]s ( ! presid5cy to inscribe 8 own "n & lik5ess onto an indep5d5t peace in/itute1 ! ,nation's premi] cultural in/itution1 ! circulat+ curr5cy ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 & ! ,:ite ,h\se itself1 do+ s ov] ! express rul+ ( a ,f$]al c\rt 9 #a in/ance & 9 defiance ( /atutes enact$ by ,congress 9 two o!rs1 9 a su/a9$ project ( self-commemoration t no prior ,presid5t ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates has und]tak5 & t is fundam5tally at odds ) ! republican "* ( ! (fice ,donald ,j4 ,trump swore to uphold4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,article ,,xxvi3 ,emolum5ts ,violations--,pr(it+ ,p]sonally & ,directly f ! ,presid5cy ,donald ,j4 ,trump violat$ 8 con/itutional oa? & ! ,con/itution's ,=eign & ,dome/ic ,emolum5ts ,clauses by us+ ! (fice ( ! presid5cy to enri* himself & 8 family p]sonally1 directly1 & on an unprec$5t$ scale1 ?r\gh a network ( cryptocurr5cy v5tures t accept$ billions ( doll>s 9 inve/m5t f =eign gov]nm5ts & entities ) direct bus9ess be=e 8 adm9i/ration4 ,?is conduct includes ! foll[+3 7#a7 ,accord+ to ,donald ,j4 ,trump's own m&atory f9ancial disclosure1 releas$ 9 mid-#bjbf1 he p]sonally e>n$ m ?an #a1djj1jjj1jjj f 8 family's cryptocurr5cy v5tures 9 a s+le ye>1 includ+ #fce1jjj1jjj 9 royalties f ,donald ,j4 ,trump-br&$ meme co9s & #eij1jjj1jjj f ,_w ,lib]ty ,f9ancial1 a crypto bus9ess co-f\nd$ by ! ,presid5t & 8 sons ,eric & ,donald1 ,jr4 :ile he held (fice4 7#b7 ,9 ,may #bjbe1 a company controll$ by ! ,gov]nm5t ( ,abu ,dhabi us$ ,_w ,lib]ty ,f9ancial's own /ableco9 to complete a #b1jjj1jjj1jjj inve/m5t 9 ,b9ance1 ! cryptocurr5cy ex*ange ^: f\nd] ,donald ,j4 ,trump !n p>don$ #e mon?s lat]1 an arrangem5t 9 :i* a =eign sov]eign inve/m5t vehicle direct$ billions ( doll>s into a bus9ess be>+ ,donald ,j4 ,trump's "n & p]sonally enri*+ him1 9 a transaction entangl$ ) 8 own ex]cise ( ! p>don p[]4 7#c7 ,! ,judici>y ,committee ( ! ,h\se ( ,repres5tatives' rank+ memb] releas$ a /aff report 9 ,novemb] #bjbe1 docum5t+ t ! ,trump family's cryptocurr5cy network 0 entangl$ ) =eign gov]nm5ts1 corporate allies1 & crim9al actors1 ev5 z 8 adm9i/ration simultane\sly dismantl$ ! regulatory protections meant to %ield ord9>y ,unit$ ,/ates inve/ors f ! v products enri*+ 8 family4 7#d7 ,none ( ! =eign or dome/ic paym5ts fl[+ to ,donald ,j4 ,trump & 8 family ?r\gh ^! v5tures 7 disclos$ to or approv$ by ,congress1 not)/&+ t ! ,con/itution requires su* cons5t be=e any (fic] ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates may accept an emolum5t f a =eign /ate1 & not)/&+ t ! scale ( ^! p]sonal pr(its exce$+ #b1jjj1jjj1jjj doll>s 9 a s+le ye> accord+ to 8 own disclosure1 dw>fs any prior presid5t's f9ancial entanglem5t ) ! (fice he holds4 7#e7 ,break+ ) ! practice ( e presid5t s9ce ,ronald ,reagan1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump decl9$ to place 8 assets 9 a bl9d tru/ or to dive/ 8 hold+s1 & beg9n+ 9 ,janu>y #bjbf1 8 p]sonal brok]age acc\nts began actively trad+ individual /ocks 9 companies ) direct & sub/antial bus9ess be=e 8 own adm9i/ration4 ,8 ,may #bjbf disclosure alone report$ #c1fdb individual trades 9 ! fir/ qu>t] ( ! ye>1 includ+ l>ge positions 9 ,micros(t1 ,boe+1 ,amazon1 & ,alphabet1 all major ,f$]al contractors1 z well z def5se contractors ,lockhe$ ,m>t91 ,g5]al ,dynamics1 & ,nor?rop ,grumman1 pur*as$ :ile ,donald ,j4 ,trump 0 direct+ milit>y /rikes on ,iran t pr$ictably mov$ ! value ( ^? v companies' /ock4 7#f7 ,betwe5 ,janu>y & ,m>* #bjbf1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's acc\nts made at lea/ #i pur*ases ( /ock 9 ,palantir ,te*nologies1 a company hold+ a #a1cjj1jjj1jjj ,p5tagon contract to develop ! artificial-intellig5ce sy/ems t help or*e/rate ,unit$ ,/ates milit>y /rikes1 total+ z mu* z #fcj1jjj4 ,weeks aft] ^! pur*ases1 9 ,april #bjbf1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump po/$ on ,tru? ,social nam+ ! company's /ock tick]1 t ,palantir ,te*nologies has prov5 to h great w>-fight+ capabilities & equipm5t1 a public endorsem5t ( a /ock he p]sonally own$ by a presid5t ^: own adm9i/ration det]m9es ! size ( t company's def5se contracts4 7#g7 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's acc\nts likewise pur*as$ /ock 9 ,axon ,ent]prise days be=e ,u4,s4 ,immigration & ,cu/oms ,en=cem5t1 an ag5cy )9 8 own adm9i/ration1 ann\nc$ its int5t to buy #bbj1jjj1jjj 9 ,axon security equipm5t1 a pur*ase t s5t ,axon's %>e price up #cd p]c5t4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's acc\nts pur*as$ & sold %>es ( ! ,,geo ,gr\p1 #a ( #b private companies t op]ate ,u4,s4 ,immigration & ,cu/oms ,en=cem5t det5tion facilities1 wor? up to #fbe1jjj 9 a ye>1 ! company t\t$ ! l>ge/ volume ( new gov]nm5t bus9ess 9 its hi/ory4 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's acc\nts pur*as$ at lea/ #a1jjj1jjj ( ,dell /ock 9 ! mon?s aft] ,dell pl$g$ a #f1bjj1jjj1jjj commitm5t to a ,trump-br&$ inve/m5t initiative1 %ortly be=e ,donald ,j4 ,trump us$ a ,:ite ,h\se ev5t to p]sonally urge ! public to g out & buy a ,dell comput] & be=e ,dell receiv$ a #i1gjj1jjj1jjj ,f$]al contract4 7#h7 ,donald ,j4 ,trump's acc\nts also pur*as$ %>es ( ,p>am\nt ,skydance & ,w>n] ,bros4 ,discov]y1 wor? t5s ( ?\s&s ( doll>s1 & ,comca/1 wor? m ?an a million doll>s1 :ile bo? ,p>am\nt's ho/ile takeov] bid = ,w>n] ,bros4 ,discov]y & its e>li] m]g] ) ,skydance rema9$ subject to review & approval by ! ,,fcc & ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,ju/ice ag5cies ( 8 own adm9i/ration1 & :ile ,donald ,j4 ,trump 0 simultane\sly mak+ public /atem5ts ab\t ! ,p>am\nt-,w>n] ,bros4 ,discov]y conte/ & prais+ ,p>am\nt's *ief executive4 7#i7 ,a ,:ite ,h\se spokesman claim$ t ,donald ,j4 ,trump's assets are held 9 a tru/ manag$ by 8 *ildr5 ) no conflicts ( int]e/1 :ile a ,trump ,organization spokesp]son sep>ately claim$ ! acc\nts are indep5d5tly manag$ by ?ird-p>ty f9ancial in/itutions t provide ! ,presid5t no advance notice ( trades1 two mutually inconsi/5t explanations (f]$ to ! press )9 ! same report+ cycle1 nei!r ( :i* 0 accompani$ by any indep5d5t v]ification1 & nei!r ( :i* expla9s :y a suppos$ly bl9d & indep5d5tly manag$ acc\nt w\ld repeat$ly pur*ase %>es 9 ! exact companies ,donald ,j4 ,trump 0 simultane\sly regulat+1 contract+ )1 or publicly promot+4 7#aj7 ,ev5 accept+ ! ,adm9i/ration's own acc\nt t ,donald ,j4 ,trump's *ildr5 or ?ird-p>ty advisors1 r ?an ,donald ,j4 ,trump p]sonally1 select$ ^! trades1 t delegation does n cure ! conflict ( int]e/4 ,! b5eficial own] ( ! ga9s is ,donald ,j4 ,trump himself1 & x is ,donald ,j4 ,trump himself1 n 8 *ildr5 or 8 brok]s1 :o possesses & ex]cises ! presid5tial p[]s ( regulation1 contract+1 & public endorsem5t t move ! value ( ! assets held = 8 b5efit4 ,an arrangem5t 9 :i* ! ,presid5t's family pr(its f decisions ! ,presid5t makes is n a bl9d tru/ 9 any s5se recogniz$ by prior practice or by ! e?ics rules requir+ true indep5d5ce & dive/iture1 x is1 at mo/1 a tru/ t is bl9d to ! trad] b n to ! b5efici>y1 & ! conflict runs ?r\gh ! (fice reg>dless ( ^: h& executes ! trade4 ,?r\gh ?is conduct1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump conv]t$ ! presid5cy into a p]sonal & family f9ancial ent]prise by accept+ billions ( doll>s 9 value f dome/ic & =eign s\rces ) direct bus9ess be=e 8 adm9i/ration & trad+1 :e!r p]sonally or ?r\gh family memb]s & advisors act+ = 8 b5efit1 9 ! securities ( companies 8 own gov]nm5t regulates1 contracts )1 & ^: /ock price 8 own public /atem5ts & policy decisions c move1 all 9 violation ( ! con/itutional prohibition on any (fic] ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates accept+ emolum5ts f =eign /ates )\t ! cons5t ( ,congress1 & 9 betrayal ( ! public tru/ repos$ 9 ! (fice he holds4 ,:]e=e1 ,donald ,j4 ,trump1 by su* conduct1 w>rants impea*m5t1 trial1 removal f (fice1 & disqualification to hold & enjoy any (fice ( honor1 tru/1 or pr(it "u ! ,unit$ ,/ates4