,i #aaith ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,r4 #hbhc ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,april #ae1 #bjbf,mr4 ,huizenga 7for himself and ,mr4 ,moolenaar7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,foreign ,affairs ,a ,,bill ,to prevent foreign adversaries from threatening the national security of the ,united ,states by extracting key technical features of closed-source1 ,american-owned artificial intelligence models1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as ,deterring ,american ,,ai ,model ,theft ,act of #bjbf4 #b4 ,sense of ,congress ,it is the sense of ,congress that-- 7#a7 artificial intelligence 7,,ai7 models owned by ,united ,states private sector companies are essential for advancing ,united ,states economic and national security interests2 7#b7 many of the most advanced ,,ai models owned by ,united ,states companies are closed-source models whose unique technical characteristics are not openly shared or published2 7#c7 the unauthorized acquisition of model capabilities1 such as model weights1 model architectures1 and other technical characteristics of closed-source ,,ai models by entities of concern through model extraction attacks represents a threat to the national security and foreign policy interests of the ,united ,states1 as well as the intellectual property rights and economic competitiveness of ,united ,states companies2 7#d7 the ,united ,states ,government1 in cooperation with private owners of closed-source ,,ai models1 should take steps to identify1 punish1 and deter model extraction attacks on the protected capabilities of closed-source models by entities of concern2 7#e7 model extraction attacks against ,american closed-source ,,ai models allow foreign adversaries a short cut to acquiring advanced ,,ai capabilities2 and 7#f7 authorized model training practices that adhere to the terms of service or are otherwise consistent with contractual terms set by the owners of closed-source ,,ai models are a legitimate research method that play an important role in ,,ai research and are fundamentally distinct from model extraction attacks defined in this ,act4 #c4 ,definitions ,in this ,act3 7#a7 ,appropriate congressional committees ,the term appropriate congressional committees means-- 7,a7 the ,committee on ,foreign ,affairs of the ,house of ,representatives2 and 7,b7 the ,committee on ,banking1 ,housing1 and ,urban ,affairs in the ,senate4 7#b7 ,closed-source ,,ai model ,the term closed-source ,,ai model means any artificial intelligence model with the following characteristics3 7,a7 ,proprietary key technical information such as underlying model weights that are necessary to reproduce and independently recreate the model that are not willingly shared with third parties or otherwise made publicly available by the owner of the model4 7,b7 ,access and use governed by terms of service or contractual agreements that are established by the owner of the model4 7,c7 ,access that is provided via an ,application ,program ,interface 7,,api7 or other consumer-facing1 owner-controlled interfaces without enabling third parties to obtain1 modify1 or host the closed-source ,,ai model on their own data servers or other technology unless specifically authorized by the owner of the closed-source ,,ai model4 7#c7 ,country of concern ,the term country of concern means-- 7,a7 the ,people's ,republic of ,china1 including the ,hong ,kong and ,macau ,special ,administrative ,regions2 7,b7 the ,russian ,federation2 and 7,c7 any other foreign country-- 7i7 listed in ,country ,group ,d3#e under ,supplement ,no4 #a to part #gdj of the ,export ,administration ,regulations1 as published on ,january #a1 #bjbf1 that is designated by the ,secretary of ,state as a country of concern for purposes of this section and for which notice of such designation has been published in the ,federal ,register2 and 7ii7 designated by the ,secretary of ,state pursuant to the assessment described in subsection 7b7 or 7e7 of section #d of this ,act4 7#d7 ,entity of concern ,the term entity of concern means any foreign person or entity that-- 7,a7 is located or headquartered in1 or the ultimate parent company of which is headquartered in1 a country of concern2 7,b7 is operating under the direction or control of any entity located or headquartered in1 or the ultimate parent company of which is headquartered in1 a country of concern2 or 7,c7 is conducting or attempting to conduct a model extraction attack against closed-source ,,ai models owned by ,united ,states persons and outside of authorized model training practices4 7#e7 ,export ,the term export has the meaning given that term in section #agdb7c7 of the ,export ,control ,reform ,act of #bjah 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #dhja7c774 7#f7 ,foreign person ,the term foreign person means a person that is not a ,united ,states person4 7#g7 ,fraudulent account network provider 7,a7 ,in general ,the term fraudulent account network provider means any foreign entity that knowingly and intentionally creates1 obtains1 maintains1 sells1 brokers1 or otherwise provides access to accounts that allow entities of concern to access closed-source ,,ai models that they would otherwise be prohibited from accessing due to location restrictions in the terms of service or contractual agreements created by the owner of the closed-source ,,ai model4 7,b7 ,exception ,an entity that creates or transmits location information to enable persons within countries of concern to access the internet for purposes of freedom of expression is not considered1 on the basis of this activity alone1 a fraudulent account network provider4 7#h7 ,good ,the term good has the meaning given that term in section #af of the ,export ,administration ,act of #aigi 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 ,app4 #bdae77;as continued in effect pursuant to the ,international ,emergency ,economic ,powers ,act 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #agja et seq4774 7#i7 ,in-country transfer ,the term in-country transfer has the meaning given that term in section #agdb7f7 of the ,export ,control ,reform ,act of #bjah 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #dhja7f774 7#aj7 ,item ,the term item has the meaning given that term in section #agdb7g7 of the ,export ,control ,reform ,act of #bjah 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #dhja7g774 7#aa7 ,model extraction attack 7,a7 ,in general ,the term model extraction attack means the unauthorized extracting of a closed-source ,,ai model's capabilities to replicate1 develop1 train1 or improve another ,,ai model1 where such querying-- 7i7 circumvents technical1 contractual1 or other access controls1 identity verification requirements1 or geographic access restrictions implemented by the model's owner2 7ii7 is conducted through fraudulent1 misrepresented1 or unauthorized credentials2 or 7iii7 violates the terms1 conditions1 or restrictions governing access to or use of the model1 as established by the owner or authorized provider1 that specifically prohibit the use of model outputs or interactions to replicate1 develop1 train1 or improve another ,,ai model4 7,b7 ,inference of purpose ,for purposes of subparagraph 7,a71 the purpose of querying may be inferred from the totality of circumstances1 including-- 7i7 the volume1 structure1 pattern1 coordination1 or timing of the querying activity2 7ii7 the concentration of queries on specific model capabilities2 7iii7 the use of multiple accounts in a coordinated matter2 or 7iv7 the correlation of querying activity within the development timeline of another ,,ai model4 7,c7 ,exclusion ,model training activities conducted in compliance with the terms1 conditions1 and restrictions governing access to and use of the closed-source ,,ai model1 or otherwise conducted within a permitted exception or the express authorization of the owner of the closed-source ,,ai model1 are not model extraction attacks4 7#ab7 ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy ,the term ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy means the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy referred to in section #agfc7;c7 of the ,export ,control ,reform ,act of #bjah 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #dhbb7;c774 7#ac7 ,owner ,the term owner means1 with respect to a closed-source ,,ai model1 the person or entity that-- 7,a7 holds intellectual property rights 7including trade secret1 copyright1 patent1 or other proprietary rights71 contractual rights1 or a combination thereof1 sufficient to authorize or restrict third-party access to1 use of1 extraction from1 or reproduction of such closed-source ,,ai model1 or any version1 instance1 or deployment thereof1 whether such rights were obtained through development1 acquisition1 assignment1 license1 or otherwise2 and 7,b7 is a ,united ,states person4 7#ad7 ,reexport ,the term reexport has the meaning given that term in section #agdb7i7 of the ,export ,control ,reform ,act of #bjah 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #dhja7i774 #d4 ,assessment of model extraction attacks and fraudulent account network providers 7a7 ,in general ,not later than #ahj days after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 the ,secretary of ,state1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall complete an assessment to determine-- 7#a7 which1 if any1 entities of concern have conducted or are currently conducting model extraction attacks against closed-source ,,ai models owned by ,united ,states entities2 and 7#b7 which1 if any1 entities of concern are fraudulent account network providers4 7b7 ,matters ,to be included ,the assessment required by subsection 7a7 shall include the following3 7#a7 ,a determination of which entities of concern-- 7,a7 have either previously or are currently engaging in model extraction attacks2 or 7,b7 are fraudulent account network providers4 7#b7 ,a determination of which1 if any1 countries model extraction attacks have originated from and where fraudulent account network providers exist4 7#c7 ,an identification of which1 if any1 agencies or instrumentalities of governments of countries of concern have provided or are providing material assistance to entities identified pursuant to paragraph 7#a74 7#d7 ,an analysis of the methods employed by entities of concern identified pursuant to paragraph 7#a71 including-- 7,a7 the role of fraudulent account network providers in model extraction attacks1 including1 to the extent possible1 the physical location of fraudulent account network provider offices and data centers2 and 7,b7 a determination1 to the extent possible1 of the number of attempted model extraction attacks that occurred in the previous two calendar years from the date on which the ,secretary of ,state begins the assessment pursuant to subsection 7a77#a74 7#e7 ,an examination of the strengths and weaknesses of various detection approaches that can be used to determine whether a model extraction attack has occurred or is occurring4 7#f7 ,an assessment of the economic and national security consequences of successful model extraction attacks by entities of concern that occurred in the previous two calendar years from the date on which the ,secretary of ,state begins the assessment pursuant to subsection 7a77#a74 7#g7 ,steps detailing how the ,united ,states ,government is assisting owners of closed-source ,,ai models that have been the target or victim of model extraction attacks in detecting model extraction attacks1 deterring future model extraction attacks1 and punishing entities of concern that engage in model extraction attacks or are fraudulent account network providers4 7#h7 ,a diplomatic strategy to leverage ,united ,states allies and partners in detecting and preventing model extraction attacks by entities of concern4 7c7 ,public consultation ,in conducting the assessment required by subsection 7a71 the ,secretary of ,commerce1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall consult with owners of closed-source ,,ai models that have been the targets or victims of model extraction attacks1 whose participation in this consultation shall be voluntary1 other companies1 academic experts1 industry fora1 and other appropriate entities to-- 7#a7 identify patterns of attacker behavior and methods to better inform ,united ,states ,government and private sector efforts to detect model extraction attacks2 7#b7 develop best practices for defending against model extraction attacks2 and 7#c7 develop best practices for identifying fraudulent account network provider activities that facilitate model extraction attacks4 7d7 ,report 7#a7 ,in general ,not later than #baj days after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 the ,secretary of ,commerce1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees a report that contains the findings of the assessment4 ,the ,secretary of ,commerce shall1 annually for #c years1 submit to the appropriate congressional committees an updated report with any additional entities of concern identified pursuant to subsection 7b77#a74 7#b7 ,form ,the report required by this subsection shall be submitted in unclassified form1 but may contain a classified annex4 7e7 ,routine assessment ,the ,secretary of ,commerce1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall routinely assess for-- 7#a7 model extraction attacks directed against owners of closed-source ,,ai models that occur after the date of completion of the assessment required by this section2 7#b7 fraudulent account network providers that facilitate model extraction attacks after the date of completion of the assessment required by this section2 and 7#c7 any material changes related to other matters specified in subsection 7b74 7f7 ,industry coordination ,the ,secretary of ,commerce1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall establish an information sharing mechanism that allows owners of closed-source ,,ai models to voluntarily1 quickly1 and confidentially share information about model extraction attacks and fraudulent account network providers with the ,department of ,commerce4 7g7 ,,ai model extraction attackers list 7#a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary of ,state1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall-- 7,a7 maintain a list1 to be known as the ,,ai ,model ,extraction ,attackers ,list1 that displays information about specific individuals and entities of concern1 that the assessment required by subsection 7a7 and routine assessment described in subsection 7e7 identify as having conducted or directed model extraction attacks in the past year2 and 7,b7 publish such list on a publicly available website of the ,department of ,state for up to #e years4 7#b7 ,protection of confidential information ,the ,secretary of ,state may not1 in publishing the list required by paragraph 7#a7 on a publicly available website of the ,department of ,state1 disclose confidential information provided by owners of closed-source ,,ai models without the express permission of said owner4 7h7 ,public guidance ,not later than #baj days after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 the ,secretary of ,commerce1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall publish a report comprising of best practices to detect1 prevent1 and respond to model extraction attacks4 7#a7 ,public access ,the report required by this subsection shall be publicly available4 7#b7 ,protection of confidential information ,in making the report required by this subsection publicly available1 the ,secretary of ,commerce1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,operating ,committee for ,export ,policy1 shall not disclose confidential information provided by owners of closed-source ,,ai models without the express permission of said owner4 #e4 ,deterring model extraction attacks and fraudulent account network providers 7a7 ,addition consideration for ,entity ,list ,not later than #baj days after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 the ,under ,secretary of ,commerce for ,industry and ,security1 in coordination with each agency that is a member of the ,end-,user ,review ,committee1 shall make a determination by majority vote of the ,committee on whether entities identified as having conducted model extraction attacks or having facilitated them via fraudulent account networks after the date of the completion of the assessment required under section #d of this ,act 7identified pursuant to subsection 7e7 of such section71 or any affiliate of such entity 7to be determined by ownership of #ej percent or more in the aggregate1 directly or indirectly71 should be added to the ,entity ,list maintained by the ,bureau of ,industry and ,security of the ,department of ,commerce under ,supplement ,no4 #d to part #gdd of title #ae1 ,code of ,federal ,regulations1 or any successor regulations4 7b7 ,sanctions described 7#a7 ,in general ,the ,president1 acting through the ,secretary of ,state1 may1 pursuant to the ,international ,emergency ,economic ,powers ,act 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #agja et seq471 block and prohibit all transactions in all property and interests in property of entities of concern identified pursuant to subsections 7b77#a7 and 7e7 of section #d if such property and interests in property are in the ,united ,states1 come within the ,united ,states1 or are or come within the possession or control of a ,united ,states person4 7#b7 ,exceptions 7,a7 ,exception to comply with international obligations ,sanctions under this subsection shall not apply with respect to the admission of an alien if admitting or paroling the alien into the ,united ,states is necessary to permit the ,united ,states to comply with the ,agreement regarding the ,headquarters of the ,united ,nations1 signed at ,lake ,success ,june #bf1 #aidg1 and entered into force ,november #ba1 #aidg1 between the ,united ,nations and the ,united ,states1 or other applicable international obligations4 7,b7 ,exception relating to the provision of humanitarian assistance ,sanctions under this subsection may not be imposed with respect to transactions or the facilitation of transactions for-- 7i7 the sale of agricultural commodities1 food1 medicine1 or medical devices2 7ii7 the provision of humanitarian assistance2 7iii7 financial transactions relating to humanitarian assistance2 or 7iv7 transporting goods or services that are necessary to carry out operations relating to humanitarian assistance4 7,c7 ,exception for intelligence1 law enforcement1 and national security activities ,sanctions under this subsection shall not apply to any authorized intelligence1 law enforcement1 or national security activities of the ,united ,states4 7#c7 ,penalties ,a person that violates1 attempts to violate1 conspires to violate1 or causes a violation of this subsection or any regulation1 license1 or order issued to carry out that subsection shall be subject to the penalties set forth in subsections 7b7 and 7c7 of section #bjf of the ,international ,emergency ,economic ,powers ,act 7#ej ,u4,s4,c4 #agje7 to the same extent as a person that commits an unlawful act described in subsection 7a7 of that section4