,i #aaith ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,r4 #ajbeh ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,september #c1 #bjbf,mr4 ,doggett 7for himself and ,ms4 ,sewell7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,ways and ,means ,a ,,bill ,to amend the ,internal ,revenue ,code of #aihf to clarify due process rights in the case of an action to terminate tax exempt status4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,protecting the ,rights of ,organizations ,fairly ,act of #bjbf or the ,,proof ,act4 #b4 ,process for examination of certain tax exempt entities 7a7 ,in general ,subchapter ,a of chapter #gh is amended by inserting after section #gfaa the following new section3 #gfaa;,a4 ,process for examination of certain tax exempt entities 7a7 ,in general 7#a7 ,examination ,in the case of an organization exempt from tax under section #eja7;a7 7other than a church7 the ,secretary may begin a tax exempt examination only if the notice requirements of subsection 7b7 are met4 7#b7 ,revocation of status ,the ,secretary may make an adverse determination with respect to an organization's status as exempt from tax under section #eja7;a7 only if-- 7,a7 an examination begun pursuant to paragraph 7#a71 or in the case of a church1 section #gfaa7;b71 sufficiently supports such determination1 and 7,b7 the due process requirements of subsection 7c7 are met4 7b7 ,notice requirements 7#a7 ,in general ,the notice requirements of this subsection shall be treated as met with respect to an examination if the ,secretary provides written notice to the organization of the examination that includes in clear and sufficient detail the following3 7,a7 ,a statement that the organization has been selected for examination of whether the organization is exempt from tax under section #eja7;a74 7,b7 ,a statement that identifies the general subject matter and issue areas that are the basis for the examination and the provisions of this title1 and any related ,treasury ,regulations1 which authorize such examination or which may be otherwise involved in such examination4 7,c7 ,identification of the tax periods subject to examination4 7,d7 ,the name and contact information of the individual assigned to the examination and the individual's supervisor4 7,e7 ,an explanation of the organization's rights during the examination1 including the right to representation by legal counsel or an authorized representative and the right to request a supervisory conference pursuant to subsection 7c77#d74 7,f7 ,an offer to consider a response or have an opening conference between the organization and the ,secretary to seek to resolve concerns relating to such examination4 7#b7 ,expanded scope of examination ,in the case of any issue not identified in the notice prescribed by paragraph 7#a71 the notice requirements of this subsection shall not be treated as met with respect to any examination of such issue unless the ,secretary provides a subsequent written notice to the organization that meets the requirements of paragraph 7#a7 with respect to the issue4 7c7 ,due process requirements 7#a7 ,in general ,the due process requirements of this subsection shall be treated as met with respect to an examination if the ,secretary-- 7,a7 generates and maintains a record of the examination that meets the requirements of paragraph 7#b7 and that constitutes prima facie evidence for the conclusion reached1 7,b7 makes requests for information and documentation only as provided in paragraph 7#c71 7,c7 affords the organization the opportunity for conferences as provided in paragraphs 7#d7 and 7#e71 and 7,d7 notifies the organization of any adverse decision made1 and any rights to protest or appeal such decision1 as provided in paragraph 7#f74 7#b7 ,record 7,a7 ,in general ,the requirements of this paragraph shall be treated as met with respect to a record of the examination if such record includes-- 7i7 documentation of-- 7,i7 the basis for the examination1 7,,ii7 each information or document request made to the organization1 7,,iii7 the organization's responses to any notices1 inquiries1 requests1 or other communications1 7,,iv7 the examiner's analysis of the applicable facts and law1 and 7,v7 the basis for any proposed determination1 and 7ii7 a date-specific case chronology reflecting all significant contacts1 decisions1 and actions taken during the examination1 7,b7 ,required disclosure 7i7 ,in general ,after completion of the record of the examination1 or after submission of a protest or appeal by the organization of the proposed adverse determination under paragraph 7#f71 whichever is earlier1 on written request from the organization1 the ,secretary shall not later than #cj days after such request disclose to the organization the contents of the record described in subparagraph 7,a74 7ii7 ,exception for privileged communications ,clause 7i7 shall not apply to any privileged communications1 except that if any contents of the record described in subparagraph 7,a7 are otherwise contained solely within a privileged communication1 the disclosure under clause 7i7 shall include a summary of such contents in sufficient detail to apprise the organization of such contents as so described4 7#c7 ,information document requests 7,a7 ,in general ,all requests by the ,secretary seeking information or documentation from the organization shall include the following3 7i7 ,a description of the documents or other information sought sufficient in detail to allow the organization to identify and produce responsive materials4 7ii7 ,an explanation of the connection between the request and the subject matter of the examination4 7,b7 ,period for response ,the deadline for response by an organization to any such request shall not be less than #cj days from the date of such request4 7,c7 ,deficient requests ,failure by the organization to respond to an examination request that does not meet the requirements of this paragraph shall not be treated as a basis for an adverse determination with respect to an organization's status as an organization exempt from tax under section #eja7;a74 7#d7 ,right to supervisory conference during examination ,in the case of a request by the organization during the examination for a conference with the examining agent's supervisor regarding any issue in dispute between the organization and the examining agent1 the ,secretary shall-- 7,a7 not later than #aj business days after such request is made1 acknowledge such request1 7,b7 not later than #cj days after such request is made1 or such longer period as may be agreed upon1 hold such requested conference1 at which the organization may present its position on any issue in dispute1 7,c7 not later than #ae business days after such conference1 provide a written summary of the conference that includes a description of any decisions made with respect to an issue in dispute4 7#e7 ,closing conference ,in the case of an examination from which an adverse decision is made with respect to the organization's tax exempt status under section #eja7;a71 prior to issuing a proposed adverse determination letter with respect to such decision1 the ,secretary shall-- 7,a7 make available a conference1 at which there shall be provided with respect to the adverse decision-- 7i7 a summary of the examination findings1 7ii7 the legal and factual basis for the adverse decision1 including the specific legal authority and conclusions from the record of the examination that support the decision1 and 7iii7 an explanation of the organization's appeal rights and applicable deadlines1 and 7,b7 provide a written summary of such conference not later than #ae business days thereafter4 7#f7 ,proposed adverse determination letter 7,a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary shall not issue a final adverse determination letter in the case of an adverse decision with respect to the organization's tax exempt status under section #eja7;a71 unless1 and in no case earlier than #cj days after1 the ,secretary provides a proposed adverse determination letter to the organization4 7,b7 ,contents ,such proposed adverse determination letter shall include the following3 7i7 ,a prominent statement of how the ,secretary is proposing to revoke1 modify1 or adversely affect the organization's tax-exempt status under section #eja7;a74 7ii7 ,a summary of the examination findings and the legal and factual basis for the determination1 including the specific legal authority and conclusions from the record of the examination that support the determination4 7iii7 ,a statement of the proposed effective date of the determination4 7iv7 ,an explanation of the organization's protest and appeal rights1 including submitting to the ,secretary a protest of the proposed adverse determination letter1 administrative appeal and requesting a conference with the ,internal ,revenue ,service ,independent ,office of ,appeals for consideration of the proposed adverse determination1 and initiating a judicial proceeding under section #gdbh4 7v7 ,an explanation of the applicable deadlines for such protests and appeals1 and the legal consequences of exercising 7or failing to exercise7 such rights4 7vi7 ,a statement of the date on which the ,secretary may issue a final adverse determination letter in the absence of a protest or appeal4 7,c7 ,cross-reference ,for rights with respect appeal and requested conference with the ,internal ,revenue ,service ,independent ,office of ,appeals1 see section #ghjc7;e77#h74 4 7b7 ,coordination with current restrictions on church tax examinations 7#a7 ,contents of notice of examination ,section #gfaa7;b77#c77;,a7 of such ,code is amended by redesignating clauses 7iii7 and 7iv7 as clauses 7iv7 and 7v71 respectively1 and by inserting after clause 7ii7 the following new clause3 7iii7 an explanation of the church's rights during the examination1 including the right to representation by legal counsel or an authorized representative and the right to request a supervisory conference pursuant to section #gfaa;,a7c77#d71 4 7#b7 ,consideration of response to notice of examination ,section #gbaa7;b77#c77;,a77iv7 of such ,code1 as redesignated by paragraph 7#a71 is amended by inserting an offer to consider a response and before an offer to have a conference4 7#c7 ,expansion of scope ,section #gfaa7;b77#d7 of such ,code is amended by inserting before the period at the end the following3 and the ,secretary provides the church a supplementary written notice that includes a description of any such church records and activities which the ,secretary seeks to examine4 7c7 ,independent ,office of ,appeals ,section #ghjc7;e7 of such ,code is amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph3 7#h7 ,appeal of proposed adverse determination letter with respect to organization's tax exempt status 7,a7 ,in general ,in the case of a proposed adverse determination letter with respect to an organization's tax exempt status under section #eja7;a71 the resolution process described in paragraph 7#c7 shall be available to the organization1 and a conference shall be provided1 with respect to such proposed adverse determination if requested by the organization not later than #cj days after the date of the proposed adverse determination letter4 7,b7 ,deadlines ,in the case of such a timely request by the organization1 the ,internal ,revenue ,service ,independent ,office of ,appeals shall-- 7i7 not later than #aj business days after receipt of such request1 acknowledge such request1 and 7ii7 in the case of a request for a conference1 not later than #ij days after receipt of such request1 schedule and hold such conference4 4 7d7 ,clerical amendment ,the table of sections for subchapter ,a of chapter #gh of such ,code is amended by inserting after the item relating to section #gfaa the following new item3 ,sec4 #gfaa;,a4 ,process for examination of certain tax exempt entities4 4 7e7 ,effective date ,the amendments made by this section shall apply to examinations begun after ,december #ca1 #bjbd4