,i #aahth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,r4 #fjib ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,october #bf1 #bjbc,mr4 ,lieu 7for himself1 ,ms4 ,jackson ,lee1 ,ms4 ,clarke of ,new ,york1 ,mr4 ,gomez1 ,mr4 ,ivey1 and ,mr4 ,veasey7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on the ,judiciary1 and in addition to the ,committee on ,science1 ,space1 and ,technology1 for a period to be subsequently determined by the ,speaker1 in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned ,a ,,bill ,to regulate law enforcement use of facial recognition technology1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,facial ,recognition ,act of #bjbc4 #b4 ,ineligibility for certain funds ,in the case of a ,state or unit of local government that received a grant award under subpart #a of part ,e of title ,i of the ,omnibus ,crime ,control and ,safe ,streets ,act of #aifh 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #cgej et seq471 if the ,state or unit of local government fails to substantially to comply with the requirements under this ,act for a fiscal year1 the ,attorney ,general shall reduce the amount that would otherwise be awarded to that ,state or unit of local government under such grant program in the following fiscal year by #ae percent4 #c4 ,definitions ,in this ,act3 7#a7 ,arrest photo database ,the term arrest photo database means a database populated primarily by booking or arrest photographs or photographs of persons encountered by an investigative or law enforcement officer4 7#b7 ,candidate list ,the term candidate list means the top images that a facial recognition system determines to most closely match a probe image4 7#c7 ,derived ,the term derived means that a ,federal or ,state government would not have possessed the information or evidence but for the use of facial recognition1 regardless of any claim that the information or evidence is attenuated from such recognition1 and would inevitably have been discovered or obtained the information or evidence through other means4 7#d7 ,facial recognition ,the term facial recognition means an automated or semi-automated process that assists in identifying or verifying an individual or captures information about an individual based on the physical characteristics of an individual's face1 head or body1 or that uses characteristics of an individual's face1 head or body1 to infer emotion1 associations1 activities1 or the location of an individual4 7#e7 ,face surveillance ,the term face surveillance means the use of facial recognition with real-time or stored video footage to track1 observe1 or analyze the movements1 behavior1 data1 or actions of an individual or groups of individuals4 7#f7 ,illegitimately obtained information ,the term illegitimately obtained information means personal data or information that was obtained-- 7,a7 in a manner that violates ,federal1 ,state1 or ,tribal law2 7,b7 in a manner that violates a service agreement between a provider of an electronic communication service to the public or a provider of a remote computing service and customers or subscribers of that provider2 7,c7 in a manner that is inconsistent with the privacy policy of a provider described in subparagraph 7,b71 if applicable2 7,d7 by deceiving a person whose information was obtained2 7,e7 through the unauthorized access of an electronic device or online account2 7,f7 in violation of a contract1 court settlement1 or other binding legal agreement2 or 7,g7 from unlawful or unconstitutional practices by any government official or entity4 7#g7 ,investigative or law enforcement officer ,the term investigative or law enforcement officer means-- 7,a7 any officer of a ,state or a political subdivision thereof1 or of the ,united ,states1 who is empowered by law to conduct investigations of or to make arrests for civil or criminal offenses or violations of ,federal or ,state law and any attorney authorized by law to prosecute or participate in the prosecution of such offenses2 and 7,b7 does not include any officer1 employee1 or contractor of a ,state department of motor vehicles4 7#h7 ,law enforcement agency ,the term law enforcement agency means any agency of the ,united ,states authorized to engage in or supervise the prevention1 detection1 investigation1 or prosecution of any violation of civil or criminal law4 7#i7 ,probe image ,the term probe image means an image of a person that is searched against a database of known1 identified persons or an unsolved photo file4 7#aj7 ,prosecutor ,the term prosecutor means the principal prosecuting attorney of a ,state or any political subdivision thereof and any attorney for the ,government 7as such term is defined for the purposes of the ,federal ,rules of ,criminal ,procedure74 7#aa7 ,operational testing ,the term operational testing means testing that evaluates a complete facial recognition system as it is used in the field1 including measuring false positive and false negative error rates for field uses of the system on operational or operationally representative data and under the environmental conditions and technical product settings and configurations typically used1 as well as assessing the variability of system use by different users4 7#ab7 ,reference photo database ,the term reference photo database means a database populated with photos of individuals that have been identified1 including databases composed of driver's licenses1 passports1 or other documents made or issued by or under the authority of the ,united ,states ,government1 a ,state1 a political subdivision thereof1 databases operated by third parties1 and arrest photo databases4 7#ac7 ,state ,the term ,state means each ,state of the ,united ,states1 the ,district of ,columbia1 the ,commonwealth of ,puerto ,rico1 the ,virgin ,islands1 ,american ,samoa1 ,guam1 and the ,northern ,mariana ,islands4 ,i ,use of facial recognition by ,law ,enforcement #aja4 ,facial recognition 7a7 ,reference photo databases 7#a7 ,in general ,an investigative or law enforcement officer may only use or request facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database pursuant to an order issued under subsection 7b7 and the emergencies and exceptions under subsection 7c74 7#b7 ,maintenance 7,a7 ,in general ,beginning on #ahj days after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 and every six months thereafter1 with respect to an arrest photo database used in conjunction with facial recognition1 the custodian of such arrest photo database shall remove from such database all photos of each person who-- 7i7 has not attained #ah years of age2 7ii7 has been released without a charge2 7iii7 has been released after charges are dropped or dismissed2 or 7iv7 was acquitted of the charged offense4 7,b7 ,rule of construction ,nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to prohibit an investigative or law enforcement officer from using a database for other investigative procedures1 such as finger printing1 and shall only apply to the use of a reference photo database for the use of facial recognition4 7#c7 ,procedures ,any agency responsible for maintaining and operating an arrest photo database shall establish procedures to ensure compliance with paragraph 7#c74 7b7 ,orders 7#a7 ,approval ,an application for a warrant to use a reference photo database may not be submitted for consideration by a court unless the head of a law enforcement agency 7or a designee7 approves such an application4 7#b7 ,authority ,except as provided by subsection 7d71 the principal prosecutor of a ,state or any political subdivision thereof and any attorney for the ,government 7as such term is defined for the purposes of the ,federal ,rules of ,criminal ,procedure71 may make an application to a court of competent jurisdiction for1 in conformity with paragraph 7#c71 an order authorizing the use of facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database within the jurisdiction of that judge4 7#c7 ,application ,except as provided in subsection 7c71 a court of competent jurisdiction may issue an order authorizing the use of facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database if a prosecutor submits an application to that court that establishes the following3 7,a7 ,the identity of the investigative or law enforcement officer making the application1 and the officer authorizing the application4 7,b7 ,as full and complete a description as possible of the person that the officer seeks to identify4 7,c7 ,the photos or video portraying the person that will be used to search the reference photo database4 7,d7 ,any details regarding other investigative measures taken to identify such person and an explanation for why such measures failed or are reasonably unlikely to succeed4 7,e7 ,any other investigative procedures to identify such person have been tried and failed or are reasonably unlikely to succeed4 7,f7 ,probable cause to believe that such person has committed or is committing a particular offense or offenses enumerated in section #ceei7;c77#b77;,f7 of title #ah1 ,united ,states ,code4 7#d7 ,contents of order ,the order described in this paragraph shall include the following3 7,a7 ,all information required to be included in the application pursuant to such paragraph 7#c74 7,b7 ,a prohibition on the use1 for purposes of a search of a reference photo database1 other than pursuant to another order under this ,act1 of any photo or video not specifically listed in the order4 7,c7 ,a time period within which the search shall be made not more than #g days1 and after which no such search may be made1 except pursuant to another order under this ,act4 7,d7 ,the authority under which the search is to be made4 7#e7 ,notice to the ,public 7,a7 ,in general ,each ,state department of motor vehicles shall post notices in conspicuous locations at each department office1 make written information available to all applicants at each office1 and provide information on the department website regarding ,state investigative or law enforcement officers' searches of driver's license and ,,id photos through facial recognition4 ,the notices1 written information1 and online information must describe how officers use and access facial recognition in criminal investigations4 7,b7 ,language requirement ,notices required under subparagraph 7,a7 shall be posted1 as necessary and reasonable1 in ,spanish or any language common to a significant portion of the department's customers1 if they are not fluent in ,english4 ,the department shall provide translations of the poster and an electronic link that leads to the department's website upon request4 7#f7 ,conforming ,amendments ,section #bgba of title #ah1 ,united ,states ,code1 is amended-- 7,a7 in subsection 7a7-- 7i7 in paragraph 7#a71 by striking the or at the end2 7ii7 in paragraph 7#b71 by striking the period at the end and inserting 2 or2 and 7iii7 by inserting after paragraph 7#b7 the following3 7#c7 a department operated facial recognition system1 except as provided in subsection 7f7 of this section4 2 7,b7 in subsection 7b77#a71 by inserting before the period at the end the following3 but if the personal information or highly restricted personal information to be disclosed is a person's photograph to be used or enrolled in a law enforcement facial recognition system1 only on a case-by-case basis that does not involve the bulk transfer of persons' photographs to a ,state or ,federal law enforcement agency or a qualified third party entity that will allow law enforcement to access those photographs for the purposes of facial recognition2 and 7,c7 by adding at the end the following3 7f7 ,law enforcement access to facial recognition systems ,a ,state department of motor vehicles1 and any officer1 employee1 or contractor thereof1 may make available a department-operated facial recognition system to a ,state or ,federal law enforcement agency1 or perform searches of such a system on behalf of the agency1 only pursuant to an order issued under section #aja of the ,facial ,recognition ,act of #bjbc4 4 7c7 ,emergencies and exceptions 7#a7 ,initial use ,notwithstanding subsections 7a7 and 7b71 an investigative or law enforcement officer may use or request facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database-- 7,a7 to assist in identifying any person who is deceased1 incapacitated or otherwise physically unable of identifying himself1 or the victim of a crime1 whom the officer determines1 in good faith1 cannot be identified through other means2 7,b7 to assist in identifying a person whom the officer believes1 in good faith1 is the subject of an alert through an ,,amber ,alert communications network1 as that term is used in section #cja of the ,prosecutorial ,remedies and ,other ,tools to end the ,exploitation of ,children ,today ,act of #bjjc 7#cd ,u4,s4,c4 #bjeja72 7,c7 to assist in identifying any person who has been lawfully arrested1 during the process of booking that person after an arrest or during that person's custodial detention2 or 7,d7 to assist in identifying any person-- 7i7 if the appropriate prosecutor determines that an emergency situation exists-- 7,i7 that involves immediate danger of death or serious physical injury to any person2 or 7,,ii7 that requires the use of facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database to occur before an order authorizing such use can1 with due diligence1 be obtained2 and 7ii7 there are grounds upon which an order could be entered under this section to authorize such use4 7#b7 ,subsequent authorization ,if an investigative or law enforcement officer uses facial recognition pursuant to paragraph 7#a77;,d71 the prosecutor shall apply for an order approving the use under subsection 7b7 within #ab hours after the use occurred4 ,the use shall immediately terminate when the application for approval is denied1 or in the absence of an application1 within #ab hours4 ,in cases where an order is not obtained or denied1 the officer shall destroy all information obtained as a result of the search4 7#c7 ,affidavit required ,with respect to use of facial recognition pursuant to paragraph 7#a77;,d71 an appropriate prosecutor shall submit an affidavit to the court identifying specific details on why they believe that an emergency situation under clause 7i7 exists4 7d7 ,state law preserved ,the authorities provided by subsections 7b7 and 7c7 do not authorize access reference photo databases maintained by a ,state1 or a political subdivision of a ,state1 unless ,state law expressly and unambiguously authorizes an investigative or law enforcement officer to-- 7#a7 access driver's license and identification document photos2 and 7#b7 use facial recognition to conduct searches of those photos4 #ajb4 ,civil rights and civil liberties 7a7 ,in general ,an investigative or law enforcement officer may not-- 7#a7 use facial recognition to create a record describing how any individual exercises rights guaranteed by the ,constitution1 including free assembly1 association1 and speech2 7#b7 rely on actual or perceived race1 ethnicity1 national origin1 religion1 disability1 gender1 gender identity1 or sexual orientation in selecting which person to subject to facial recognition1 except when there is trustworthy information1 relevant to the locality and time frame1 in the context of a particular area and for a particular period of time1 that links a person with a particular characteristic described in this subsection to an identified criminal incident or scheme2 or 7#c7 use facial recognition to enforce the immigration laws of the ,united ,states or share facial recognition data with other agencies for the purposes of enforcing the immigration laws of the ,united ,states4 7b7 ,prohibition on use with body cameras ,any investigative or law enforcement officer may not use or request facial recognition in conjunction with any image obtained from a body camera worn by that or any other officer1 dashboard camera1 or any aircraft camera1 including a drone4 7c7 ,prohibition on certain facial recognition ,any investigative or law enforcement officer may not use or request facial recognition for the purpose of face surveillance4 7d7 ,ensuring corroboration and preventing over reliance on matches ,a facial recognition match may not be the sole basis upon which probable cause is established for a search1 arrest1 or other law enforcement action4 ,any investigative and law enforcement officers using information obtained from the use of facial recognition shall examine results with care and consider the possibility that matches could be inaccurate4 7e7 ,prohibition on illegitimately obtained information ,an investigative or law enforcement office may not use facial recognition in conjunction with a database that contains illegitimately obtained information4 #ajc4 ,logging of searches ,a law enforcement agency whose investigative or law enforcement officers use facial recognition shall log its use of the facial recognition to the extent necessary to comply with the public reporting and audit requirements of sections #ajd and #aje of this ,act4 #ajd4 ,reporting 7a7 ,state reporting required 7#a7 ,state judiciary ,not later than the last day of the first ,january after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 and each ,january thereafter1 each ,state judge who has issued a court order authorizing or approving facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database shall report to a ,state agency 7as determined by the chief executive of the ,state7 the following information3 7,a7 ,the number of orders or extensions was applied for4 7,b7 ,whether the order or extension was issued pursuant to section #aja7;b7 or section #ajb7;c74 7,c7 ,whether the order or extension was granted as applied for1 was modified1 or was denied4 7,d7 ,the offense specified in the order or application1 or extension of an order4 7,e7 ,the identity of the applying investigative or law enforcement officer and agency making the application and the person authorizing the application4 7,f7 ,for orders issued pursuant to section #aja7;c71 the reference photo database that was searched4 7#b7 ,prosecutors ,not later than the last day of the first ,january after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 and each ,january thereafter1 each ,state prosecutor1 or a prosecutor of a political subdivision thereof1 who has requested a court order authorizing or approving facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database shall report to a ,state agency 7as determined by the chief executive of the ,state7 the following information with respect to the use of facial recognition in conjunction with an reference photo database3 7,a7 ,the number of such searches run4 7,b7 ,the offenses that those searches were used to investigate1 and for each offense1 the number of searches run4 7,c7 ,the arrests that such searches contributed to1 and the offenses for which the arrests were made1 disaggregated by race1 ethnicity1 gender1 and age4 7,d7 ,the number of convictions that such searches contributed to and the offenses for which the convictions were obtained1 disaggregated by race1 ethnicity1 gender1 and age4 7,e7 ,the number of motions to suppress made with respect to those searches1 and the number granted or denied4 7,f7 ,the types and names of databases that were used and the number of photos removed with respect to arrest photo databases that were confirmed to have been removed in accordance with this section4 7#c7 ,report to ,bureau of ,justice ,assistance ,not later than #ij days after such report is submitted under paragraph 7#a71 and annually thereafter1 the ,state agency shall report the information collected under paragraph 7#a7 to the ,director of the ,bureau of ,justice ,assistance4 7#d7 ,report to ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts ,not later than #ij days after such report is submitted under paragraph 7#b71 and annually thereafter1 the ,state agency shall report the information collected under paragraph 7#b7 to the ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts4 7b7 ,federal reporting required ,not later than the last day of the first ,january after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 and each ,january thereafter-- 7#a7 each ,federal judge who has issued a court order authorizing or approving facial recognition in conjunction with a reference photo database shall submit to the ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts a report including the information under subparagraphs 7,a7 through 7,f7 of subsection 7a77#a72 and 7#b7 and a ,federal prosecutor who requested such order1 shall submit to the ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts a report including the information under subparagraphs 7,a7 through 7,g7 of subsection 7a77#b74 7c7 ,public reporting ,in ,june of each year the ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts shall release to the public1 post online1 and transmit to the ,congress a full and complete report concerning the use of facial recognition in conjunction with reference photo databases1 including the information reported to the ,director pursuant to subsections 7a7 and 7b74 7d7 ,rules ,the ,director of the ,bureau of ,justice ,assistance and the ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts shall issue rules with respect to the content and form of the reports required to be filed under subsections 7a7 through 7c7 of this section and sections #aje and #ajf of this ,act4 #aje4 ,audits 7a7 ,federal level audit 7#a7 ,in general ,any ,federal law enforcement agency whose investigative or law enforcement officers use facial recognition1 regardless of whether they use a system operated by that agency or another agency1 shall annually submit data with respect to their use of facial recognition for audit by the ,government ,accountability ,office to prevent and identify misuse and to ensure compliance with sections #aja1 #ajb1 and #ajc of this ,act1 including-- 7,a7 a summary of the findings of the audit1 including the number and nature of violations identified2 and 7,b7 information about the procedures used by the law enforcement agency to remove arrest photos from databases in accordance with this ,act4 7#b7 ,suspension 7,a7 ,in general ,if a violation is uncovered by the audit conducted under paragraph 7#a71 the ,federal law enforcement agency shall cease using facial recognition until such time that all violations have been corrected4 7,b7 ,public notice ,if use of facial recognition is suspended pursuant to subparagraph 7,a71 the ,federal law enforcement agency shall notify the public of such suspension4 7b7 ,state level audit 7#a7 ,in general ,any ,state or local law enforcement agency whose investigative or law enforcement officers use facial recognition1 regardless of whether they use a system operated by that agency or another agency1 shall annually submit data with respect to their use of facial recognition to an independent ,state agency 7as determined by the chief executive of the ,state7 to prevent and identify misuse and to ensure compliance with sections #aja1 #ajb1 and #ajc of this ,act4 ,such independent ,state agency shall report-- 7,a7 a summary of the findings of the audit1 including the number and nature of violations identified1 to ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts1 and subsequently release that information to the public and post it online2 7,b7 information about the procedures used by the law enforcement agency to remove arrest photos from databases in accordance with this section2 and 7,c7 any violations identified by the independent ,state agency4 7#b7 ,suspension 7,a7 ,in general ,if a violation is uncovered by the audit conducted under paragraph 7#a71 the ,state or local law enforcement agency shall cease using facial recognition until such time that all violations have been corrected4 7,b7 ,public notice ,if use of facial recognition is suspended pursuant to subparagraph 7,a71 the ,state or local law enforcement agency shall notify the public of such suspension4 7c7 ,disaggregated data ,data collected pursuant to subsection 7a7 or 7b7 shall1 when feasible1 be collected in a manner that allows such data to be disaggregated by race1 ethnicity1 gender1 and age4 #ajf4 ,accuracy and bias testing 7a7 ,benchmark testing ,no investigative or law enforcement officers may use a facial recognition system or information derived from it unless that system is annually submitted to the ,national ,institute of ,standards and ,technology's benchmark facial recognition test for law enforcement to determine-- 7#a7 the accuracy of the system2 and 7#b7 whether the accuracy of the system varies significantly on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender or age4 7b7 ,benchmark testing for new systems ,no investigative or law enforcement officers may begin using a new facial recognition system or information derived from it unless that system is first submitted to independent testing to determine-- 7#a7 the accuracy of the system2 and 7#b7 whether the accuracy of the system varies significantly on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 or age4 7c7 ,prohibition ,any investigative or law enforcement officer may not use facial recognition that has not achieved a sufficiently high level of accuracy1 including in terms of overall accuracy and variance on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 or age1 as determined by the ,national ,institute of ,standards and ,technology1 on its annual benchmark test for law enforcement use4 7d7 ,operational testing ,no investigative or law enforcement agencies may use a facial recognition system or information derived from it unless that system is annually submitted to operational testing conducted by an independent entity1 in accordance with ,national ,institute of ,standards and ,technology's training protocol for operational testing1 to determine-- 7#a7 the accuracy of the system2 7#b7 the impact of human reviewers on system accuracy2 and 7#c7 whether the accuracy of the system varies significantly on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 or age4 7e7 ,reporting ,a summary of the findings of the tests required by subsection 7a7 or 7d7 shall be submitted to the ,director of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts and posted on the internet website of the ,administrative ,office of the ,united ,states ,courts4 7f7 ,rulemaking required ,the ,assistant ,attorney ,general of the ,department of ,justice ,civil ,rights ,division shall issue a rule that establishes what is a sufficiently high level of accuracy for a facial recognition system used by law enforcement1 including in terms of overall accuracy and variance on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 and age4 ,the ,assistant ,attorney ,general of the ,department of ,justice ,civil ,rights ,division shall consult with outside experts in civil rights1 civil liberties1 racial justice1 data privacy1 bioethics1 law enforcement1 public defense1 and forensic science and other relevant areas of expertise in drafting the proposed rule4 7g7 ,effective date ,this section shall take effect #ah months after the date of enactment of this ,act4 #ajg4 ,enforcement 7a7 ,suppression ,in the case that the use of facial recognition has occurred1 no results from the use and no evidence derived therefrom may be received in evidence in any trial1 hearing1 or other proceeding in or before any court1 grand jury1 department1 officer1 agency1 regulatory body1 legislative committee1 or other authority of the ,united ,states1 a ,state1 or a political subdivision thereof if the use of facial recognition violated this ,act or if the use was conducted in an emergency under section #aja and the officer or agency did not subsequently obtain an order for that use as required under such section4 7b7 ,administrative ,discipline ,if a court or law enforcement agency determines that an investigative or law enforcement officer has violated any provision of this ,act1 and the court or agency finds that the circumstances surrounding the violation raise serious questions about whether or not the officer acted intentionally with respect to the violation1 the agency shall promptly initiate a proceeding to determine whether disciplinary action against the officer is warranted4 7c7 ,civil action 7#a7 ,in ,general ,any person who is subject to identification or attempted identification through facial recognition in violation of this ,act may bring a civil action in the appropriate court to recover such relief as may be appropriate from the investigative or law enforcement officer or the ,state or ,federal law enforcement agency which engaged in that violation4 7#b7 ,relief ,in an action under this subsection1 appropriate relief includes-- 7,a7 such preliminary and other equitable or declaratory relief as may be appropriate2 7,b7 damages under paragraph 7#c7 and punitive damages in appropriate cases2 and 7,c7 a reasonable attorney's fee and other litigation costs reasonably incurred4 7#c7 ,computation of ,damages ,the court may assess as damages whichever is the greater of-- 7,a7 any profits made with respect to the violation suffered by the plaintiff2 or 7,b7 #ej1jjj for each violation4 7#d7 ,defense ,a good faith reliance on-- 7,a7 a court warrant or order1 a grand jury subpoena1 a legislative authorization1 or a statutory authorization2 or 7,b7 a good faith determination that section #aja permitted the conduct complained of1 is a complete defense against any civil action brought under this ,act4 7#e7 ,limitation ,a civil action under this section may not be commenced later than two years after the date upon which the claimant first has a reasonable opportunity to discover the violation4 7d7 ,civil action for disparate impact ,an individual may bring a civil action when use of facial recognition or face surveillance by a law enforcement agency1 or any technological element1 criteria1 method1 or design feature thereof acting individually or in concert1 results in disparate treatment or adverse impact against an individual or class of individuals on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 or age4 #ajh4 ,notice requirement 7a7 ,notice requirement ,a law enforcement agency that uses facial recognition to attempt to identify an individual who is arrested shall1 at minimum1 provide to the individual-- 7#a7 a notice of-- 7,a7 the name the law enforcement agency that operated the facial recognition system used2 and 7,b7 the name of the database1 if any1 that was used to identify the individual2 and 7#b7 a copy of-- 7,a7 the order that authorized the use of facial recognition2 7,b7 accuracy or bias reports required under this ,act2 7,c7 each probe image that was used by the agency2 7,d7 any modifications made to the probe image2 7,e7 the candidate list1 in rank order1 produced by the facial recognition system2 and 7,f7 any other police documentation related to the use of facial recognition in the law enforcement investigation4 7b7 ,language requirement ,the information required under subsection 7a7 shall be provided to such individual in an appropriate language for such individual if the individual is not fluent or literate in ,english4 ,,ii ,certain requirements and limitations on facial recognition systems and research #bja4 ,national ,institute for ,standards and ,technology assistance 7a7 ,in general ,the ,national ,institute of ,standards and ,technology 7hereinafter in this section referred to as ,,nist7 shall-- 7#a7 develop best practices for law enforcement agencies to evaluate the accuracy and fairness of their facial recognition systems2 7#b7 develop and offer an ongoing benchmark facial recognition test for law enforcement that-- 7,a7 conducts evaluations of actual algorithms used by law enforcement agencies2 7,b7 uses the types of probe images1 including in terms of quality1 actually used by law enforcement agencies in its testing2 7,c7 evaluates algorithms on larger databases that reflect the size of databases actually used by law enforcement2 and 7,d7 evaluates whether the accuracy of a facial recognition algorithm varies on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 or age and assessments of bias in facial recognition systems2 7#c7 develop an operational testing protocol that independent testers and law enforcement agencies may implement for annual operational testing to determine-- 7,a7 the accuracy of the facial recognition system2 7,b7 the impact of human reviewers on facial recognition system accuracy2 and 7,c7 whether the accuracy of the facial recognition system varies significantly on the basis of race1 ethnicity1 gender1 or age2 and 7#d7 study and develop training standards for human operators reviewing the results of facial recognition searches to ensure accuracy and prevent bias4 7b7 ,authorization of appropriations ,there is authorized to be appropriated to the ,national ,institute of ,standards and ,technology to carry out subsection 7a7 #e1jjj1jjj for each of the fiscal years #bjbd through #bjbg4 #bjb4 ,rule of construction with respect to ,state and local privacy protections 7a7 ,rule of construction ,nothing in this ,act shall be construed to preempt concurrent or more stringent limitations on the use of facial recognition1 or any other privacy1 civil rights1 and civil liberties laws and rules1 by the ,federal ,government1 a ,state1 or a political subdivision of a ,state4 7b7 ,use of facial recognition ,nothing in this ,act shall be construed to authorize the use of facial recognition by a ,state1 or a political subdivision of a ,state1 unless the laws of that ,state or political subdivision expressly and unambiguously authorizes such use4 #bjc4 ,policy on use of facial recognition systems required ,not later than #ij days after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 each agency covered by this statute shall establish and make publicly available on the internet website of such agency a policy governing the agency's use of facial recognition systems to ensure investigative or law enforcement officer compliance with the requirements of this ,act4 #bjd4 ,limitation on liability ,a ,state shall not be immune under the eleventh amendment to the ,constitution of the ,united ,states from an action in ,federal or ,state court of competent jurisdiction for a violation of this ,act4 ,in any action against a ,state for a violation of the requirements of this ,act1 remedies 7including remedies both at law and in equity7 are available for such a violation to the same extent as such remedies are available for such a violation in an action against any public or private entity other than a ,state4