,i #aahth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,r4 #bghb ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,april #bj1 #bjbc,ms4 ,porter 7for herself1 ,mr4 ,nadler1 ,mr4 ,cicilline1 and ,ms4 ,jayapal7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on the ,judiciary ,a ,,bill ,to specify the standards governing claims of consciously parallel pricing coordination in civil actions under the ,sherman ,act1 and to clarify the meaning of contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under the ,sherman ,act4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,competitive ,prices ,act4 #b4 ,purpose ,the purpose of this ,act is to clarify and amend the law with respect to-- 7#a7 the illegality of consciously parallel pricing coordination under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #a1 #c7;a772 and 7#b7 the concerted-action requirement for claimed violations of section #a or #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act4 #c4 ,findings 7a7 ,consciously parallel pricing coordination 7#a7 ,the ,american economy is built on the foundations of open markets and fair competition4 ,these core principles of economic freedom are what stimulate innovation1 improve the quality of products and services1 and ensure that prices are competitive4 7#b7 ,the antitrust laws are designed to ensure ,american consumers and businesses are afforded the benefits of competition throughout the economy4 ,the supreme evil of antitrust law is1 accordingly1 collusion among market rivals4 ,such collusion undermines competitive markets1 stifles innovation1 and results in degraded quality and prices that are dictated by competitors' agreement rather than competitors' rivalry4 7#c7 ,sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #a1 #c7;a77 categorically prohibit--as the most pernicious types of contracts1 combinations in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracies1 in restraint of trade or commerce--naked agreements among actual or potential competitors to fix prices1 rig bids1 or allocate markets4 ,an agreement to fix the quantity of products or services bought or sold is a form of agreement to fix prices4 ,these agreements are per se unlawful4 7#d7 ,courts have been unduly hostile to claims of price fixing that are based on tacit agreement among competitors4 ,they have1 at times1 declined to recognize tacit agreement as a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy2 they have held that allegations or evidence1 taken as a whole1 that are as consistent with conscious parallelism as with agreement are generally insufficient to survive a motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment2 and they have concluded a claimant must offer allegations or evidence tending to exclude the possibility of independent action4 ,see1 e4g41 ,brooke ,grp4 ,ltd4 v4 ,brown ,williamson ,tobacco ,corp41 #eji ,u4,s4 #bji1 #bbg 7#aiic72 ,matsushita ,elec4 ,indus4 ,co4 v4 ,zenith ,radio ,corp41 #dge ,u4,s4 #egd1 #ehh 7#aihf72 ,monsanto ,co4 v4 ,spray-,rite ,serv4 ,corp41 #dfe ,u4,s4 #geb1 #gfd 7#aihd74 7#e7 ,section #d of this ,act rejects the judicial decisions that have prevented meritorious price-fixing cases from advancing to trial and judgment4 ,it does so by providing that1 in civil actions1 consciously parallel pricing coordination--as defined by this ,act--is a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy1 in restraint of trade or commerce under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act4 7#f7 ,section #d of this ,act does not supersede the law governing price fixing4 ,it instead supplements and complements that law4 ,it does not apply to criminal prosecutions4 7b7 ,concerted action 7#a7 ,the words contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy in sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act require some form of agreement between two or more persons1 but that agreement need not be expressly made4 ,a tacit agreement also qualifies4 ,accordingly1 the words contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy encompass both express and tacit agreements4 7#b7 ,although consciously parallel behavior alone does not constitute a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act1 consciously parallel behavior can be evidence of an agreement4 ,and once the consciously parallel behavior crosses the line into consciously parallel coordination1 the behavior qualifies as tacit agreement--that is1 a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy4 7#c7 ,in ,bell ,atlantic ,corp4 v4 ,twombly1 #eej ,u4,s4 #edd1 #edh-di1 #eec-eg1 #efd-gj 7#bjjg71 the ,supreme ,court held that a complaint alleging that competitors engaged in parallel1 anticompetitive conduct did not do enough to exclude the possibility that the competitors engaged in independent action and therefore failed to plausibly plead the existence of a conspiracy under section #a of the ,sherman ,act4 ,in so holding1 the ,court understated the significance of consciously parallel behavior as evidence of agreement and left little or no room for tacit agreements in the meaning of contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy4 7#d7 ,section #e of this ,act rejects the ,twombly ,court's cramped reading of the ,sherman ,act's language1 clarifies that the words contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy encompass tacit agreements1 and specifies the standards for pleading and proving a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act4 #d4 ,consciously parallel pricing coordination 7a7 ,definitions 7#a7 ,the term consciously parallel pricing coordination means a tacit agreement among two or more persons to raise1 lower1 change1 maintain1 or manipulate pricing for the purchase or sale of reasonably interchangeable products or services4 7#b7 ,the term person has the meaning given the term in subsection 7a7 of the first section of the ,clayton ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #ab7;a774 7b7 ,consciously parallel pricing coordination ,in a civil action1 including an action brought by the ,united ,states or by a ,state attorney general1 or by the ,federal ,trade ,commission under section #e of the ,federal ,trade ,commission ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #de71 consciously parallel pricing coordination is a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy1 in restraint of trade or commerce under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #a1 #c7;a774 7c7 ,prima facie case 7#a7 ,a claimant establishes a prima facie case of consciously parallel pricing coordination by demonstrating that two or more persons-- 7,a7 engaged in substantially similar action1 within a substantially similar time period1 with respect to pricing for reasonably interchangeable products or services2 and 7,b7 had a substantially similar motivation to coordinate their efforts to raise1 lower1 change1 maintain1 or manipulate pricing for the purchase or sale of reasonably interchangeable products or services4 7#b7 ,a claimant asserting a claim of consciously parallel pricing coordination in violation of section #a or #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act bears the burden of proving the prima facie case described in paragraph 7#a7 by a preponderance of evidence1 at which point the burden of production shifts to the defending party as set forth in subsection 7d74 7d7 ,burden of rebutting prima facie case ,the defending party bears the burden of rebutting a prima facie case of consciously parallel pricing coordination by producing evidence1 sufficient to raise a genuine dispute of material fact1 that the defending party's action described in paragraph 7#a77;,a7 of subsection 7c7 was motivated by business judgment that is economically rational in the absence of any consciously parallel pricing coordination4 ,evidence of this nature may include1 but is not limited to1 evidence that the defending party acted rationally in response to or in anticipation of changing conditions affecting the market for or the marketability of the products or services concerned4 7e7 ,ultimate burden ,if the defending party rebuts the prima facie case1 the burden shifts back to the claimant to prove1 by a preponderance of the evidence1 that the defending party entered a tacit agreement among two or more persons to raise1 lower1 change1 maintain1 or manipulate pricing for the purchase or sale of reasonably interchangeable products or services4 ,the claimant may do so by means that include1 but are not limited to1 proving that-- 7#a7 the business judgment described in subsection 7d7 was not-- 7,a7 economically rational in the absence of consciously parallel pricing coordination2 or 7,b7 the predominant motivating factor for the defending party's action described in paragraph 7#a77;,a7 of subsection 7c72 7#b7 the defending party1 knowing that coordinated action to raise1 lower1 change1 maintain1 or manipulate pricing for the purchase or sale of reasonably interchangeable products or services was contemplated and invited by a competitor1 adhered to the scheme and participated in it2 or 7#c7 based on circumstantial evidence implying a traditional conspiracy1 it is more likely than not that the defending party entered an agreement among two or more persons to raise1 lower1 change1 maintain1 or manipulate pricing for the purchase or sale of reasonably interchangeable products or services4 7f7 ,affirmative defense ,it is an affirmative defense to a claim of consciously parallel pricing coordination1 on which the defending party bears the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence1 that any affirmative defense to price fixing applies4 #e4 ,clarifying the meaning of contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy 7a7 ,meaning of contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy ,a tacit agreement is a form of contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #a1 #c7;a774 7b7 ,standards of pleading and proof ,in a civil action1 including an action brought by the ,united ,states or by a ,state attorney general1 or by the ,federal ,trade ,commission under section #e of the ,federal ,trade ,commission ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #de7-- 7#a7 a complaint-- 7,a7 plausibly pleads a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act if the complaint contains factual allegations1 which may consist of allegations of consciously parallel conduct1 demonstrating that the existence of the alleged contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy is among the realm of plausible possibilities2 and 7,b7 need not allege facts tending to exclude the possibility of independent action to plausibly plead the existence of a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act2 and 7#b7 a claimant-- 7,a7 demonstrates a genuine dispute of material fact that a defending party entered a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act by offering evidence1 which may be direct or circumstantial1 that is sufficient to allow a trier of fact to reasonably conclude that the defending party entered the contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy2 and 7,b7 need not offer evidence tending to exclude the possibility of independent action to demonstrate a genuine dispute of material fact that a defending party entered a contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy under sections #a and #c7;a7 of the ,sherman ,act2 although1 at trial1 the trier of fact may consider the existence or absence of evidence tending to exclude the possibility of independent action when determining whether a defending party entered the contract1 combination in the form of trust or otherwise1 or conspiracy4