,i #aahth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,r4 #agda ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,march #bc1 #bjbc ,mr4 ,bowman 7for himself1 ,ms4 ,wilson of ,florida1 ,ms4 ,ocasio-,cortez1 ,ms4 ,brown1 ,mr4 ,espaillat1 ,mrs4 ,ramirez1 ,mr4 ,casar1 ,mr4 ,payne1 ,ms4 ,velzquez1 ,ms4 ,jayapal1 ,mrs4 ,cherfilus-,mc,cormick1 ,ms4 ,tlaib1 ,ms4 ,jackson ,lee1 ,ms4 ,norton1 ,ms4 ,pressley1 ,ms4 ,crockett1 ,ms4 ,lee of ,pennsylvania1 ,ms4 ,williams of ,georgia1 and ,mr4 ,frost7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,education and the ,workforce ,a ,,bill ,to amend the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife to decrease the frequency of standardized tests administered to students in grades #c through #ab1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,more ,teaching ,less ,testing ,act of #bjbc4 #b4 ,findings ,congress finds the following3 7#a7 ,an overwhelming body of research evidence demonstrates that-- 7,a7 standardized testing scores are highly correlated with the socioeconomic status of a student2 and 7,b7 test-based accountability has not improved equity in public schools4 7#b7 ,according to the ,national ,education ,association1 there is a nationwide shortage of #cjj1jjj teachers and school staff4 7#c7 ,according to the #bjbb report of the ,american ,federation of ,teachers ,teacher and ,school ,staff ,shortage ,task ,force titled ,here ,today1 ,gone ,tomorrow81 reducing the frequency of standardized testing and empowering teachers to use authentic assessments that measure what students know and can do is a critical component to addressing the nationwide teacher shortage4 7#d7 ,research published by the ,national ,academies ,press shows that summative assessments are appropriate for curriculum and in-school accountability but are not appropriate when used as a dominant factor in making high-stakes decisions and can undermine the quality of education and equality of opportunity4 7#e7 ,the peer-reviewed ,research in ,middle ,level ,education ,journal published a study in #bjag showing that ,state standardized test results are strongly influenced by non-school factors and that standardized test results cannot capture the complexities of the influence of middle level administrators may have on the lives of students4 ,nevertheless1 the use of ,state standardized test results drove school administrator evaluations in more than #dj ,states4 7#f7 ,more than #a1ahe accredited1 four-year colleges and universities removed ,,act and ,,sat test score requirements for prospective applicants for the ,fall #bjbb semester4 7#g7 ,according to a sum of mean science1 reading1 and mathematics scores from the ,,oecd ,programme for ,international ,student ,assessment 7in this ,act referred to as ,,pisa7 results for #bjah1 the ,united ,states ranked #bbnd out of participating countries4 ,in mathematics1 the ,united ,states ranked #cfth out of the #gi participating countries and regions1 which was below the international average4 ,throughout the high-stakes accountability era1 standardized test scores in the ,united ,states have remained flat4 7#h7 ,even before the ,,covid-#ai pandemic began1 progress had stalled on the main measure of academic well-being in the ,united ,states1 the ,national ,assessment of ,educational ,progress 7in this ,act referred to as ,,naep74 ,according to the #bjai ,,naep1 the average performance of ,american fourth-and eighth-graders in math and reading has declined since the #bjag ,,naep4 7#i7 ,according to the ,national ,center for ,education ,statistics1 students demonstrating the lowest performance in reading have made no progress since the first ,,naep was conducted almost #cj years ago4 7#aj7 ,according to the #bjae survey from the ,council of the ,great ,city ,schools titled ,student ,testing in ,america's ,great ,city ,schools3 ,an ,inventory and ,preliminary ,analysis1 there is no correlation between the amount of mandated testing time and the reading and mathematics scores in grades four and eight on the ,,naep4 7#aa7 ,in the same survey from the ,council of the ,great ,city ,schools1 #ci percent of school districts reported having to wait between two and four months before final ,state test results were available at the school level1 minimizing the utility of these tests for instructional purposes4 7#ab7 ,in #bjae1 a typical ,american student took #aab mandated standardized tests across the length of their elementary and secondary education years1 including both federally mandated summative assessments and non-federally mandated summative assessments4 ,countries that outperform the ,united ,states on the ,,pisa only test their students three times throughout the kindergarten through twelfth-grade years4 7#ac7 ,research has shown that current testing volumes narrow curriculum to the tested topics1 particularly when exams are high stakes4 ,other important subjects1 such as art1 music1 finance1 foreign languages1 social studies1 civics1 and physical education are downplayed or ignored4 7#ad7 ,studies show that standardized testing leads to the narrowing of instruction and classroom curriculum even within assessed subjects4 7#ae7 ,the negative impact of standardized testing extends to students1 their families1 and the economic well-being of their communities4 ,the mass availability of school ratings based on standardized test scores has accelerated divergence in housing values1 income distributions1 and education levels as well as the racial and ethnic composition across communities4 7#af7 ,african ,americans1 especially boys1 are disproportionately placed or misplaced in special education1 frequently based on standardized test results4 7#ag7 ,a reduction in the administration of and preparation for mandated summative assessments would afford more time and resources for other learning opportunities that-- 7,a7 incorporate a diverse array of high-quality assessment methods1 including formative assessments embedded within instruction1 performance-based assessment1 and methods to assess understanding and skill development through project-based learning2 and 7,b7 promote deeper learning1 positive cognitive development1 and the skills needed for the #bast century workforce4 #c4 ,sense of ,congress relating to appropriate uses of summative assessments ,it is the sense of ,congress that-- 7#a7 to support a love of learning that fosters joy1 curiosity1 creativity1 rigor1 collaborative problem solving1 and the development of #bast century skills1 public elementary and secondary schools need more capacity and resources for meaningful educational experiences2 7#b7 the requirement for ,states to administer annual standardized tests to receive ,federal funds under title ,i of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife limits classroom instruction1 promotes memorization over critical thinking1 and prioritizes multiple choice tests over balanced assessment systems using multiple measures that promote high-quality teaching and learning2 7#c7 a robust body of research demonstrates that the overuse of standardized testing takes a negative toll on students1 teachers1 and the classroom environment2 7#d7 ,states should be supported in developing and implementing innovative1 evidence-based1 and standards-based assessment systems that support high-quality teaching and learning and the ability to meaningfully measure performance rather than using commercial assessment products that are limited to demonstrating proficiency to a standardized test2 and 7#e7 ,state assessment and accountability systems should-- 7,a7 focus on1 not hinder1 critical thinking2 7,b7 reflect principles of reciprocity1 such that identified needs and areas for growth result in the allocation of both resources and capacity building opportunities to support improvement2 and 7,c7 promote equitable opportunities for high-quality teaching and deep learning on a range of academic1 socioemotional1 and #bast century skills4 #d4 ,decreasing standardized testing frequency for students in grades #c through #ab 7a7 ,expansion of ,state educational assessment options ,section #haja of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ghja7 is amended by adding at the end the following3 7#ec7 ,combination testing ,the term combination testing means an educational assessment system in which a ,state administers grade-span testing using-- 7,a7 representative sampling2 or 7,b7 matrix sampling4 7#ed7 ,grade-span testing ,the term grade-span testing means an educational assessment system in which a ,state administers each of the assessments described in section #aaaa7;b77#b77;,a7 once during-- 7,a7 grades #c through #e2 7,b7 grades #f through #i2 and 7,c7 grades #aj through #ab4 7#ee7 ,matrix sampling ,the term matrix sampling means an educational assessment administration method in which a ,state-- 7,a7 divides the total number of questions on an educational assessment into groups that are comprised of an equal number of questions2 7,b7 divides the students enrolled at an elementary or secondary school who will receive such educational assessment into groups that are comprised of-- 7i7 an equal number of students2 and 7ii7 with respect to each subgroup of students 7described in section #aaaa7;b77#b77;,b77xi771 a number of students belonging to such subgroup that is equal to the proportion of-- 7,i7 the total number of students enrolled at such school belonging to such subgroup2 to 7,,ii7 the total number of students enrolled at such school2 and 7,c7 administers such groups of questions to such groups of students in a manner determined by the ,secretary to be appropriate4 7#ef7 ,representative sampling 7,a7 ,in general ,the term representative sampling means an educational assessment administration method in which a ,state-- 7i7 administers1 in accordance with subparagraph 7,b71 math1 reading or language arts1 and science assessments to a representative sample of students from a sample of public elementary and secondary schools in the ,state2 and 7ii7 is able to draw from such sampling valid and reliable inferences about the performance of students-- 7,i7 in the ,state and in local educational agencies served by the ,state2 and 7,,ii7 in the elementary and secondary schools selected for such sampling4 7,b7 ,sample requirements ,a ,state shall ensure that-- 7i7 each assessment described in subparagraph 7,a77i7 is administered to a different representative sample of students2 and 7ii7 the composition of each such representative sample of students enables results to be disaggregated in accordance with section #aaaa7;b77#b77;,b77xi74 4 7b7 ,state discretion concerning the frequency of standardized testing ,section #aaaa7;b77#b77;,b7 of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcaa7;b77#b77;,b77 is amended-- 7#a7 in clause 7i77,,ii7-- 7,a7 by inserting 1 in accordance with clause 7v71 after administered2 and 7,b7 by striking all2 7#b7 in clause 7v7-- 7,a7 by amending subclause 7,i7 to read as follows3 7,i7 in the case of mathematics1 reading or language arts1 and science1 be administered using-- 7aa7 combination testing2 7bb7 grade-span testing2 or 7cc7 representative sampling-- 7,,aa7 not more than once in each of grades #c through #h2 and 7,,bb7 at least once in grades #i through #ab2 and 2 7,b7 by striking subclause 7,,ii72 and 7,c7 by redesignating subclause 7,,iii7 as subclause 7,,ii72 and 7#c7 in clause 7vii77,i71 by inserting 1 as applicable after students4 7c7 ,statewide accountability system ,section #aaaa7;c77#d7 of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcaa7;c77#d77 is amended-- 7#a7 in subparagraph 7,a77i77,i77aa71 by striking annual2 and 7#b7 in subclauses 7,i7 and 7,,ii7 of subparagraph 7,b77i71 by striking annual in each place it appears4 #e4 ,public comment period regarding the administration of assessments for each grade ,section #aaaa7;b77#b77,l7 of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcaa7;b77#b77,l77 is amended-- 7#a7 by striking at the sole discretion of such ,state and inserting following a #ij-;day public comment period inviting input from a broad community of local stakeholders1 including educators1 principals1 other school leaders1 parents1 and primary caregivers2 and 7#b7 by inserting 1 and preparation for1 after administration of4 #f4 ,establishing a taskforce to evaluate testing practices and to promote quality teaching 7a7 ,establishment ,there is established a taskforce within the ,national ,center for ,education ,research to be known as the ,taskforce to ,evaluate ,testing ,practices and ,promote ,quality ,teaching 7in this section referred to as the ,taskforce74 7b7 ,duties ,the duties of the ,taskforce shall be to-- 7#a7 identify-- 7,a7 the effect standardized test practices have on student wellness1 learning1 and postsecondary education success2 7,b7 opportunities to promote in elementary and secondary schools performance-based assessment systems that are developmentally appropriate1 promote experiential and project-based learning1 and build technological literacy skills2 7,c7 potential metrics of educational quality and equity that do not rely on standardized assessments1 including opportunity-to-learn data2 and 7,d7 barriers that prevent elementary and secondary schools from establishing innovative assessment systems2 and 7#b7 make recommendations to address such barriers4 7c7 ,membership 7#a7 ,in general ,not later than #a year after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 the ,commissioner for ,education ,research shall appoint to the ,taskforce not fewer than #e1 and not more than #aj1 members4 7#b7 ,inclusion of educational assessment experts ,at least #a member shall be an individual with expertise in education assessment systems1 including performance-based assessments4 7#c7 ,terms ,each member shall be appointed for a term of #b years4 7#d7 ,basic ,pay ,members shall each be paid at a rate equal to the rate of basic pay for level ,,iv of the ,executive ,schedule4 7#e7 ,vacancies ,a vacancy in the ,taskforce shall be filled by an appointment of a new member by the ,director 7as described in subsection 7d77 in consultation with-- 7,a7 public elementary school teachers2 7,b7 public secondary school teachers2 7,c7 public school leaders2 and 7,d7 individuals representing organizations with expertise in education policy4 7d7 ,director of ,taskforce ,the ,taskforce shall have a ,director who shall be appointed by the ,commissioner1 in consultation with-- 7#a7 public elementary school teachers2 7#b7 public secondary school teachers2 7#c7 public school leaders2 7#d7 school-based mental health services providers2 and 7#e7 individuals representing organizations with expertise in education policy4 7e7 ,report ,required ,not later than #b years after the date on which the ,commissioner completes all appointments to the ,taskforce required under subsection 7c77#a71 the ,taskforce shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees a report that includes-- 7#a7 a review1 disaggregated by each ,state1 of assessments administered to students in kindergarten through grade #ab that includes-- 7,a7 a description of each summative assessment the ,state used1 including assessments developed pursuant to the innovative assessment demonstration authority under section #abjd of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcfd72 7,b7 an estimation of the cost of administering each such assessment2 7,c7 an estimation1 for each grade1 of the test administration time allocated each academic year for such assessments2 7,d7 an estimation1 for each grade1 of the classroom instructional time lost each academic year while preparing students for each such assessment2 and 7,e7 a description of how each ,state is using data from such assessments1 including whether such data is used for punitive purposes2 7#b7 an accounting of ,federal1 ,state1 and local funds paid to for-profit entities for the purpose of designing1 developing1 administering1 and scoring summative assessments2 7#c7 a study of the interaction between statewide summative assessment and accountability systems1 as implemented as of the date of the beginning of the report required under this subsection1 and the quality of teaching and learning1 including-- 7,a7 the extent to which statewide summative assessments are aligned to #bast century skill development2 7,b7 the extent to which such assessment and accountability systems lead to a narrowing of curriculum2 and 7,c7 the impact of such assessment and accountability systems on the quality of instruction and opportunities for deeper learning across a variety of subjects and skills2 7#d7 a description of barriers that prevent schools from establishing and implementing innovative assessment systems that promote performance-based assessment2 7#e7 recommendations to overcome such barriers2 and 7#f7 recommendations for innovative assessment systems that-- 7,a7 are created in partnership with teachers and other educators2 7,b7 empower teachers2 7,c7 reduce elementary and secondary school reliance upon summative assessment tools from for-profit third-party vendors2 and 7,d7 create a framework for designing a balanced assessment system that supports equitable opportunities for learning and centers students' needs4 7f7 ,expiration of ,taskforce ,the ,taskforce shall expire on the date that is #cj days after the date of the submission of the report required under subsection 7d74 7g7 ,definitions ,in this section3 7#a7 ,appropriate congressional committees ,the term appropriate congressional committees means-- 7,a7 the ,committees on ,appropriations of the ,senate and ,house of ,representatives2 7,b7 the ,committee on ,health1 ,education1 ,labor1 and ,pensions of the ,senate2 and 7,c7 the ,committee on ,education and the ,workforce of the ,house of ,representatives4 7#b7 ,,esea terms 7,a7 ,the terms elementary school1 school leader1 secondary school1 and ,state have the meanings given such terms in section #haja of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ghja74 7,b7 ,the term innovative assessment system has the meaning given such term in section #abjd7;a7 of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcfd7;a774 7,c7 ,the term school-based mental health services provider has the meaning given such term in section #dajb of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #gaab74 #g4 ,expansion of innovative assessment demonstration authority 7a7 ,expansion of authority ,section #abjd of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife is amended-- 7#a7 in subsection 7a77#a71 by striking an annual and inserting a2 7#b7 in subsection 7b7-- 7,a7 in paragraph 7#b71 by striking #e years and inserting #g years2 and 7,b7 in paragraph 7#c7-- 7i7 in the matter preceding subparagraph 7,a71 by striking #c years and inserting #e years2 and 7ii7 in subparagraph 7,a71 by striking a total number of not more than #g participating ,state educational agencies and inserting a total number of not fewer than #bj participating ,state educational agencies2 7#c7 in subsection 7e77#b77;,a7-- 7,a7 in clause 7x7-- 7i7 by striking an annual1 and inserting a2 7ii7 by inserting assessed in a given subject in a given year after each individual student2 and 7iii7 by striking and at the end2 7,b7 in clause 7xi77,,ii71 by striking the period at the end and inserting 2 and2 and 7,c7 by adding at the end the following3 7xii7 be of equal or greater rigor to the ,state assessments under section #aaaa7;b77#b74 2 7#d7 in subsection 7f77#a77;,b77i71 by striking comparable to the ,state assessments and inserting determined by the ,secretary to be of equal or greater rigor to the ,state assessments2 7#e7 in subsection 7i77#c71 by striking comparable to measures of academic achievement and inserting determined by the ,secretary to be of equal or greater rigor to measures of academic achievement2 and 7#f7 in subsection 7m77#a77;,a77ii71 by striking comparable with statewide assessments and inserting determined by the ,secretary to be of equal or greater rigor to statewide assessments4 7b7 ,authorization of appropriations ,there are authorized to be appropriated to the ,secretary of ,education #ajj1jjj1jjj for the fiscal year in which the date of the enactment of this ,act occurs1 and for each of the #d succeeding fiscal years1 to carry out section #abjd of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcfd74 #h4 ,authorization of appropriations for local educational agency grants ,section #ajjb7;a7 of the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcjb7;a77 is amended to read as follows3 7a7 ,local educational agency grants ,there are authorized to be appropriated #ff1jjj1jjj1jjj for the fiscal year in which the date of the enactment of the ,more ,teaching ,less ,testing ,act of #bjbc occurs1 and for each of the #i succeeding fiscal years1 to carry out the activities described in part ,a4 4 #i4 ,prohibition on use of ,,esea funds for certain purposes ,a ,state receiving funds under the ,elementary and ,secondary ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #fcja et seq47 may not-- 7#a7 consider the summative assessments required under section #aaaa7;b77#b7 of such ,act as a sole or dominant factor when-- 7,a7 implementing grade-retention policies2 7,b7 awarding a student a high school diploma2 or 7,c7 evaluating the performance of teachers or administrators2 7#b7 establish a rating system for elementary schools or local educational agencies that serve such elementary schools based exclusively on the summative assessment scores of students who attend such elementary schools2 or 7#c7 establish a rating system for secondary schools or local educational agencies that serve such secondary schools based exclusively on-- 7,a7 the summative assessment scores of students that attend such secondary schools2 or 7,b7 the graduation rates of students that attend such secondary schools4