,,iv #aag? ,,congress #a/ ,session ,h4 ,,res4 #bgi ,,9 ,,! ,,h\se ,,( ,,repres5tatives ,m>* #bf1 #bjba,mr4 ,grijalva 7= himself1 ,ms4 ,plaskett1 ,mr4 ,sablan1 ,mr4 ,san ,nicolas1 ,miss ,gonzlez-,coln1 ,ms4 ,velzquez1 ,mr4 ,g>ca ( ,ill9ois1 & ,mr4 ,torres ( ,new ,york7 submitt$ ! foll[+ resolution2 :i* 0 ref]r$ to ! ,committee on ! ,judici>y1 & 9 addition to ! ,committee on ,natural ,res\rces1 = a p]iod to be subsequ5tly det]m9$ by ! ,speak]1 9 ea* case = consid]ation ( su* provisions z fall )9 ! jurisdiction ( ! committee conc]n$ ,,resolution ,ackn[l$g+ t ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,supreme ,c\rt's decisions 9 ! ,insul> ,cases & ! t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e are contr>y to ! text & hi/ory ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,con/itution1 re/ on racial views & /]eotypes f ! era ( ,plessy v4 ,f]guson t h long be5 reject$1 are contr>y to our ,nation's mo/ basic con/itutional & democratic pr9ciples1 & %\ld be reject$ z hav+ no place 9 ,unit$ ,/ates con/itutional law4 ,:]eas t]ritories h be5 an important "p ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates s9ce ! beg9n+ ( our ,nation1 />t+ ) ! ,nor?we/ ,t]ritory 9 #aghg1 ) ,*ief ,ju/ice ,john ,m>%all writ+ = ! ,supreme ,c\rt 9 #ahbj t ! ,unit$ ,/ates is ! "n giv5 to our great republic1 :i* is compos$ ( ,/ates & t]ritories 7,l\ghbor\gh v4 ,blake1 #ah ,u4,s4 7#e ,:eat47 #cag1 #cai 7#ahbj772 ,:]eas today ! ,unit$ ,/ates has #e populat$ t]ritories1 ,am]ican ,samoa1 ! ,commonweal? ( ! ,nor!rn ,m>iana ,isl&s1 ,guam1 ,pu]to ,rico1 & ! ,virg9 ,isl&s ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 :i* toge!r h a population ( ov] #c1ejj1jjj resid5ts1 equal to ! population ( ! #e smalle/ ,/ates comb9$1 m ?an #ie p]c5t ( :om are racial or e?nic m9orities2 ,:]eas ,pu]to ,rico & ,guam h n[ be5 a "p ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates s9ce #ahih1 ,am]ican ,samoa s9ce #aijj1 ! ,virg9 ,isl&s ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates s9ce #aiag1 & ! ,commonweal? ( ! ,nor!rn ,m>iana ,isl&s s9ce #aihf2 ,:]eas until ! ,insul> ,cases 7 decid$ 9 ! e>ly #aijjs1 ! ,supreme ,c\rt long recogniz$ t ,congress' p[]s ov] ! t]ritories1 :ile broad1 7 n absolute & unlimit$1 b r subject to su* re/rictions z are express$ 9 ! ,con/itution 7,murphy v4 ,ramsey1 #aad ,u4,s4 #ae1 #dd 7#ahhe772 ,:]eas foll[+ ! acquisition ( ,hawaii1 ,pu]to ,rico1 ,guam1 & o!r ov]seas t]ritories 9 #ahih1 ! ,supreme ,c\rt's decisions 9 ! ,insul> ,cases broke f its prior prec$5t to e/abli% a doctr9e ( t]ritorial incorporation1 creat+ = ! fir/ "t a di/9ction betwe5 s-call$ incorporat$ t]ritories1 :]e ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,con/itution applies 9 full1 & un9corporat$ t]ritories1 :]e ! ,con/itution applies only 9 "p 7,b\m$i5e v4 ,bu%1 #eec ,u4,s4 #gbc1 #geg 7#bjjh772 ,:]eas ! judgm5t ( ! ,c\rt 9 ,d[nes v4 ,bidwell 7#ahb ,u4,s4 #bdd 7#aija771 ! mo/ prom95t ( ! ,insul> ,cases1 0 deliv]$ by ,ju/ice ,h5ry ,bill+s ,br[n1 ! au?or ( ,plessy v4 ,f]guson's doctr9e ( sep>ate b equal1 :o wrote t ,am]ica's newly acquir$ ov]seas t]ritories 7 inhabit$ by ali5 races1 diff]+ f u 9 religion1 cu/oms1 ''' & modes ( ?\ght1 mak+ x impossible to gov]n accord+ to ,anglo-,saxon pr9ciples2 ,:]eas ,ju/ice ,edw>d ,:ite1 :o 9 a sep>ate #c-;,ju/ice plurality develop$ ! t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e 9 ,d[nes1 express$ conc]ns ov] ! evils ( admitt+ millions ( inhabitants ( unkn[n isl&s1 peopl$ ) an unciviliz$ race1 :o he believ$ w\ld be absolutely unfit = citiz5%ip2 ,:]eas #d ,ju/ices diss5t$ 9 ,d[nes1 ) ,*ief ,ju/ice ,melville ,full] comm5t+ t great /ress is ?r[n ^u ! ^w incorporation1 z if possess$ ( "s occult mean+1 & ,ju/ice ,john ,m>%all ,h>lan express+ t ! idea ( incorporation 4 4 4 is envelop$ 9 "s my/]y :i* ,i am unable to unravel2 ,:]eas ,ju/ice ,h>lan1 :o p5n$ ! lone diss5t to ,plessy v4 ,f]guson1 also wrote a s]ies ( p[]ful diss5ts to ! ,insul> ,cases1 decl>+ 9 ,d[nes t the idea t ?is c\ntry may acquire t]ritories any:]e ^u ! e>?1 by conque/ or treaty1 & hold !m z m]e colonies or prov9ces--! p inhabit+ !m to enjoy only su* rights z ,congress *ooses to accord to !m--is :olly inconsi/5t ) ! _s & g5ius1 z well z ) ! words1 ( ! ,con/itution2 ,:]eas ! ,insul> ,cases & ! t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e h long receiv$ significant criticism f ! ,supreme ,c\rt & a broad range ( juri/s & legal s*ol>s2 ,:]eas1 9 #bjjh1 ! ,supreme ,c\rt /at$ t the ,con/itution grants ,congress & ! ,presid5t ! p[] to acquire1 dispose (1 & gov]n t]ritory1 n ! p[] to decide :5 & :]e its t]ms apply1 express+ fur!r t ov] "t ! ties betwe5 ! ,unit$ ,/ates & any ( its un9corporat$ ,t]ritories may /r5g!n 9 ways t are ( con/itutional significance 7,b\m$i5e v4 ,bu%1 #eec ,u4,s4 at #geh1 #gfe 7#bjjh772 ,:]eas1 9 #bjbj1 ! ,supreme ,c\rt que/ion$ ! cont9u$ validity ( ! ,insul> ,cases1 indicat+ t ! ,insul> ,cases %\ld n be fur!r ext5d$ 7,f94 ,ov]sight ,mgmt4 ,bd4 = ,p4,r4 v4 ,aurelius ,inv41 #adj ,s4,ct4 #afdi1 #affe 7#bjbj772 ,:]eas ,judge ,juan ,torruella1 :o s]v$ on ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,c\rt ( ,appeals = ! ,fir/ ,circuit f #aihd until 8 dea? 9 #bjbj1 label$ ! t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e a doctr9e ( sep>ate & unequal1 writ+ t ! ,insul> ,cases repres5t classic ,plessy v4 ,f]guson legal doctr9e & ?\ght t %\ld be eradicat$ f pres5t-day con/itutional reason+ because !y run contr>y to ! mo/ basic precept = :i* ?is nation /&s3 ! equality be=e ! law ( all its citiz5s2 ,:]eas ,*ief ,judge ,gu/avo ,gelp1 :o has s]v$ on ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,di/rict ,c\rt = ! ,di/rict ( ,pu]to ,rico s9ce #bjjf1 has call$ ! ,insul> ,cases' t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e a doctr9e ( pure judicial inv5tion1 ) absolutely no basis 9 ! ,con/itution & "o t is contr>y to all judicial prec$5t & t]ritorial practice2 ,:]eas legal s*ol>s ) a wide range ( views h criticiz$ ! ,insul> ,cases & ! t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e1 ) prom95t orig9ali/ legal s*ol> ,g>y ,lawson writ+ t !re is no?+ 9 ! ,con/itution t ev5 intimates t express con/itutional limitations on national p[] apply diff]5tly to diff]5t t]ritories1 & lead+ ,con/itutional ,law ,pr(essor ,san=d ,lev9son call+ ! ,insul> ,cases c5tral docum5ts 9 ! hi/ory ( ,am]ican racism2 ,:]eas ! t]ritorial incorporation doctr9e e/abli%$ by ! ,insul> ,cases is /ill us$ to p]petuate ! second-class treatm5t ( ,am]icans liv+ 9 ! t]ritories1 f ! d5ial ( citiz5%ip1 to ! d5ial ( vot+ rights1 to ! d5ial ( equality 9 ,f$]al b5efits programs2 & ,:]eas ! "t has come to expressly reject ! ,insul> ,cases z bo? contr>y to ! ,con/itution's text & hi/ory & z incompatible ) our ,nation's core values3 ,n[1 !re=e1 be x ,t ! ,h\se ( ,repres5tatives-- 7#a7 recognizes t ,am]ica's con/itutional & democratic pr9ciples apply ?r\gh\t ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 includ+ bo? ,/ates & t]ritories2 7#b7 ackn[l$ges t ! ,insul> ,cases are contr>y to ! text & hi/ory ( ! ,con/itution2 7#c7 ackn[l$ges t ! ,insul> ,cases are relics ( ! racial views ( an e>li] era t h no place 9 our ,nation today2 & 7#d7 rejects ! ,insul> ,cases & _! application to all pres5t & future cases & controv]sies involv+ ! application ( ! ,con/itution 9 ,unit$ ,/ates t]ritories4