,i #aagth ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,r4 #idgg ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,december #h1 #bjbb,mr4 ,lowenthal 7for himself1 ,ms4 ,mace1 ,ms4 ,pingree1 and ,ms4 ,brownley7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,natural ,resources1 and in addition to the ,committee on ,education and ,labor1 for a period to be subsequently determined by the ,speaker1 in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned ,a ,,bill ,to authorize studies and pilot programs related to the development and production of aquaculture in the exclusive economic zone of the ,united ,states1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,science-based ,equitable ,aquaculture ,food ,act or the ,s,e,afood ,act4 #b4 ,definitions ,in this ,act3 7#a7 ,adjacent coastal jurisdiction ,the term adjacent coastal jurisdiction means with respect to any activity proposed1 conducted1 or approved by the ,administrator under section #e7;a71 any coastal ,state land-- 7,a7 that is used1 or is scheduled to be used1 as a support base for such activity2 or 7,b7 in which there is a reasonable probability of significant effect on land or water uses from such activity4 7#b7 ,administrator ,the term ,administrator means the ,administrator of the ,national ,oceanographic and ,atmospheric ,administration4 7#c7 ,appropriate committees of ,congress ,the term appropriate committees of ,congress means the ,committees on-- 7,a7 ,natural ,resources of the ,house of ,representatives2 7,b7 ,agriculture of the ,house of ,representatives2 7,c7 ,transportation and ,infrastructure of the ,house of ,representatives2 7,d7 ,commerce1 ,science1 and ,transportation of the ,senate2 7,e7 ,environment and ,public ,works of the ,senate2 and 7,f7 ,agriculture1 ,nutrition1 and ,forestry of the ,senate4 7#d7 ,environmental justice community ,the term environmental justice community means a community with significant representation of any of the following3 7,a7 ,individuals who reside in a census block group in which #cj-percent or more of the population are individuals with an annual household income that does not exceed the greater of-- 7i7 an amount equal to #hj-percent of the median income of the area in which the household is located1 as reported by the ,secretary of ,housing and ,urban ,development2 or 7ii7 #bjj-percent of the ,federal poverty line4 7,b7 ,individuals who reside in a geographically distinct area in which the population of any of the following categories of individuals is higher than the average population of that category for the ,state in which the community is located3 7i7 ,black4 7ii7 ,african ,american4 7iii7 ,asian4 7iv7 ,pacific ,islander4 7v7 ,other non-,white race4 7vi7 ,hispanic4 7vii7 ,latino4 7viii7 ,linguistically isolated4 7,c7 ,tribal or ,indigenous communities4 7#e7 ,escape ,the term escape means the escape of juvenile- or adult-farmed organisms1 viable gametes1 or fertilized eggs spawned by farmed organisms from aquaculture facilities4 7#f7 ,exclusive economic zone ,the term exclusive economic zone has the meaning given such term in section #c7aa7 of the ,magnuson ,stevens ,fishery ,conservation and ,management ,act 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #ahjb7aa774 7#g7 ,indian ,tribe ,the term ,indian ,tribe has the meaning given such term in section #d of the ,indian ,self-,determination and ,education ,assistance ,act 7#be ,u4,s4,c4 #ecjd74 7#h7 ,offshore aquaculture ,the term offshore aquaculture means aquaculture conducted in the exclusive economic zone4 7#i7 ,pilot project ,the term pilot project means an aquaculture project approved under section #e4 7#aj7 ,state ,the term ,state means each of the several ,states1 the ,district of ,columbia1 each commonwealth1 territory1 or possession of the ,united ,states1 and each ,indian ,tribe4 7#aa7 ,tribal or ,indigenous community ,the term ,tribal or ,indigenous community means a population of people who are-- 7,a7 enrolled members of an ,indian ,tribe2 7,b7 members of an ,alaska ,native or ,native ,hawaiian community or organization2 or 7,c7 members of any other community of ,indigenous people located in a ,state4 7#ab7 ,underserved communities 7,a7 ,in general ,the term underserved communities means women and individuals belonging to communities that have been denied consistent and systematic fair1 just1 and impartial treatment and have been systematically denied a full opportunity to participate in all aspects of economic1 social1 and civic life1 including ,black1 ,latino1 ,indigenous and ,native ,american persons1 ,asian ,americans and ,pacific ,islanders and other persons of color4 7,b7 ,inclusion ,in the context of the aquaculture industry1 the term underserved communities1 within fishing communities1 may include-- 7i7 subsistence fishery participants and their dependents2 7ii7 fishing vessel crews1 and fish processor and distribution workers2 and 7iii7 territorial fishing communities 7including those in ,american ,samoa1 ,guam1 the ,commonwealth of the ,northern ,mariana ,islands1 ,puerto ,rico1 and the ,united ,states ,virgin ,islands74 7#ac7 ,veteran ,the term veteran has the meaning given such term in section #aja of title #ch1 ,united ,states ,code4 #c4 ,,gao study 7a7 ,in general ,not later than #b years after the date of the enactment of this section1 the ,comptroller ,general shall submit a report to the appropriate committees of ,congress examining aquaculture permitting1 monitoring1 and regulation during the #ae-year period ending on the date of enactment of this section based on the available literature1 case studies1 and stakeholder input4 7b7 ,contents of study ,the study required under subsection 7a7 shall-- 7#a7 consider the feasibility and potential positive and negative implications of designating a lead agency to issue aquaculture permits in a timely manner2 7#b7 identify lessons learned during such period with respect to-- 7,a7 the implications of aquaculture type1 location1 and regulatory framework on project success2 7,b7 the degree of involvement of coastal or adjacent ,states1 ,tribal groups1 underserved communities1 or environmental justice communities in consultation1 planning1 or operations of such aquaculture operations2 7,c7 safety protocols and risk mitigation measures for the permit and oversight processes1 including-- 7i7 escape prevention measures2 7ii7 emergency event response planning2 7iii7 compliance monitoring1 particularly in remote locations2 7iv7 compliance with ,federal laws2 7v7 reporting mechanisms to appropriate ,federal authorities1 and 7vi7 vessel navigation aids to ensure navigational safety2 7,d7 the effect of incentives to reduce adverse effects or disparate impacts from aquaculture operations2 7,e7 building and optimizing synergies between aquaculture and wild-caught fishing activities1 or offshore1 nearshore1 and onshore aquaculture activities1 including market development1 increasing seafood consumption1 and shared infrastructure2 7,f7 the environmental effects of marine aquaculture operations1 including mechanisms to prevent harm to the environment1 wildlife1 or human well-being2 7,g7 net economic and social benefits of the aquaculture projects1 particularly for nearby communities 7including underserved and environmental justice communities71 based on project size1 regulatory structures1 and financing structures2 7,h7 the impact of introducing aquaculture products to the marketplace on supply and demand for wild-capture fisheries products and methods for ensuring resiliency and growth for both aquaculture and wild-capture fisheries products2 7,i7 mechanisms to enhance capital investment1 workforce development1 and equitable opportunity requirements or assistance programs in the permit process1 or to diversify permit applicants2 7,j7 outstanding needs for continued research1 development1 education activities1 programs1 and funding regarding offshore aquaculture projects and development of the domestic workforce and entrepreneurship related to offshore aquaculture2 and 7,k7 the economic potential for both large- and small-scale aquaculture operations to generate a positive return on investment under various regulatory and financing structures2 and 7#c7 make recommendations with respect to future offshore aquaculture operations1 including-- 7,a7 regulatory processes necessary for permitting1 monitoring1 and oversight1 including processes and techniques related to siting1 deployment1 operations1 and decommissioning2 7,b7 potential safeguards1 data collection1 or monitoring required to minimize disparate impacts on environmental justice communities1 local economies1 marine environments1 and existing domestic economic sectors2 7,c7 mechanisms for optimizing the efficiency and coordination among ,federal agencies with a role in permitting aquaculture in offshore waters without compromising the goals of such permitting2 7,d7 methods for effectively involving stakeholders1 including-- 7i7 adjacent jurisdictions2 7ii7 local communities2 7iii7 regional offshore waters users and management groups 7including regional fishery management councils72 and 7iv7 users of local1 ,state1 and ,federal waters and coastal resources1 including underserved communities1 and environmental justice communities2 7,e7 best practices for incorporating local knowledge1 including from ,tribal or ,indigenous communities2 7,f7 ,federal agency capabilities that are necessary for effective regulation of the sector2 and 7,g7 how creating private rights of action or waiving sovereign immunity would facilitate or hinder the development of offshore aquaculture projects and their acceptance by nearshore and offshore waters user groups and coastal communities4 #d4 ,study of aquaculture permitting standards 7a7 ,study required ,not later than #cj months after the date of enactment of this ,act1 the ,ocean ,studies ,board of the ,national ,academies of ,sciences1 ,engineering1 and ,medicine shall complete a study to develop the scientific basis for efficient and effective regulation of offshore aquaculture4 7b7 ,considerations ,the study required by subsection 7a7 shall1 with respect to offshore aquaculture-- 7#a7 identify-- 7,a7 optimal methods of operation of aquaculture facilities to promote high yields and limit adverse effects on the environment1 wildlife1 and human well-being1 including-- 7i7 considerations to guide siting decisions of such facilities2 and 7ii7 appropriate stocking densities2 7,b7 a science-based definition of sustainable aquaculture feed or other inputs2 7,c7 potential adverse effects on the environment1 wildlife1 and human well-being1 including from-- 7i7 the use of antibiotics and other pharmaceuticals by aquaculture facilities1 including analyses necessary to establish acceptable rates1 impact levels1 and risk thresholds1 such as organism antibiotic consumption or metabolization versus excretion to the surrounding environment2 7ii7 assimilation of pollution originating from such facilities on marine organisms2 7iii7 the risk posed by misplaced or damaged equipment2 7iv7 the risk of wildlife entanglements2 7v7 interbreeding or the spread of disease2 7vi7 the source and sustainability of brood stock for offshore aquaculture operations and impacts of hatcheries and prestocking rearing operations that are specific to offshore aquaculture2 7vii7 large-scale cultivation of filter-feed bivalve organisms and seaweed on the marine food webs2 7viii7 aquaculture facilities acting as aggregating devices and increasing the vulnerability of wild fisheries and wildlife populations to fishing or other sources of mortality2 and 7ix7 the use of nonsustainable sources of feed or other inputs2 7,d7 potential methods and technologies to mitigate adverse effects1 including those identified under subparagraph 7,c72 7,e7 potential conflicts and solutions to mitigate such conflicts between offshore aquaculture facilities and other users of the offshore environment2 7,f7 the types of data and qualitative information necessary for the optimal operation of such facilities and appropriate methods of procuring such data information1 including from citizen science 7as defined in section #djb of the ,crowdsourcing and ,citizen ,science ,act 7#ae ,u4,s4,c4 #cgbd7 and the traditional aquaculture knowledge of ,tribal and ,indigenous communities2 7,g7 the applicability and sufficiency of existing regulatory systems on offshore aquaculture2 7,h7 existing local1 ,state1 ,federal1 and foreign regulatory standards that may serve as models for efficient and effective regulation of offshore aquaculture2 and 7,i7 the considerations necessary to account for the effects of climate change predictive assessments on the siting and operation of offshore aquaculture facilities2 and 7#b7 provide legislative and regulatory recommendations with respect to-- 7,a7 promoting the methods of operation identified under paragraph 7#a77;,a72 7,b7 mitigating adverse effects identified under paragraph 7#b77;,b72 7,c7 environmental standards1 control rules1 or reference points that build upon the existing public and private standards for aquaculture sustainability2 and 7,d7 ensuring that operators of offshore aquaculture facilities adhere to international standards for social responsibility1 public health1 and equitable labor practices1 including with respect to sourcing inputs for such facilities4 #e4 ,assessment program for offshore aquaculture 7a7 ,establishment ,not later than #fj days after the date of enactment of this ,act1 the ,administrator shall establish an assessment program to evaluate the following with respect to offshore aquaculture3 7#a7 ,the ability of different commercial-scale facility designs and operational methods to-- 7,a7 survive various atmospheric and ocean conditions1 including high wind speeds or high-energy ocean conditions associated with severe weather1 without-- 7i7 allowing escapes of cultivated organisms2 7ii7 loss of infrastructure2 or 7iii7 wildlife entanglement resulting from loss or damaged infrastructure2 7,b7 prevent adverse wildlife impacts1 including entanglements of large whales1 sea turtles1 and other species protected under the ,endangered ,species ,act of #aigc 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #aeca et seq47 and the ,marine ,mammal ,protection ,act of #aigb 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #acfa et seq472 7,c7 prevent adverse impacts on the marine environment1 including impacts to habitat1 water chemistry1 and wildlife2 and 7,d7 avoid adverse impacts on navigation and safety to existing ocean users due to aquaculture facilities1 including requirements for operations1 navigation1 and transit associated with such facilities4 7#b7 ,the ability for different technologies to provide reliable and timely data on offshore aquaculture facilities 7including visual data and other relevant data types7 to enable the ,administrator to monitor-- 7,a7 project compliance with the requirements of subsection 7b72 7,b7 impacts on the marine environment2 and 7,c7 interference with existing uses of the water body in which the project is located4 7#c7 ,the relative risks1 benefits1 and cost of various types of aquaculture1 including different species of finfish in different geographies and under varying climactic and ecological conditions4 7#d7 ,the development of performance standards for offshore aquaculture operations4 7b7 ,pilot project selection 7#a7 ,solicitation ,the ,administrator shall solicit and accept applications for participation in the assessment program from projects that would advance the objectives of subsection 7a71 including-- 7,a7 objective analyses of data from commercial-scale and other demonstration projects existing or carried out in offshore waters of the ,united ,states or other countries within the past #ae years2 or 7,b7 pilot projects proposed to be operated in the exclusive economic zone4 7#b7 ,publication ,the ,administrator shall publish in the ,federal ,register a notice summarizing each application received under this section and invite and consider public comments regarding the pilot projects proposed under those applications for their inclusion in the assessment program4 7#c7 ,designation of adjacent coastal jurisdictions ,the ,administrator shall promulgate a mechanism for identifying and designating1 with respect to each pilot project application received under paragraph 7#a71 the nearest adjacent coastal jurisdiction or jurisdictions4 7#d7 ,notice ,the ,administrator shall provide a copy of each pilot project application to each adjacent coastal jurisdiction designated under paragraph 7#c74 7#e7 ,denial at the request of adjacent coastal jurisdiction ,if1 in the #fj-;day period after receiving notice of a pilot project application under paragraph 7#d71 an adjacent coastal jurisdiction requests that the ,secretary rejects such application1 the ,secretary shall reject such application4 7#f7 ,pilot project approval ,not later than #a year after the date of the enactment of this section1 the ,administrator shall approve not less than #a and not more than #d applications for aquaculture pilot projects that-- 7,a7 cultivate species that pose minimal threat of harm to wildlife and the ecosystem in which the project is located2 7,b7 incorporate design and operational characteristics that minimize the risk of escape1 wildlife entanglement1 and adverse pollution impacts2 7,c7 have developed and are able to implement an escape response and infrastructure loss or damage plan that minimizes the impact of any escapes or infrastructure loss or damage on the marine environment and on other uses of the water body in which the project is located2 7,d7 comply with all applicable requirements of the ,clean ,water ,act 7#cc ,u4,s4,c4 #ahea et seq471 the ,endangered ,species ,act of #aigc 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #aeca et seq471 the ,marine ,mammal ,protection ,act of #aigb 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #acfa et seq471 and the ,national ,environmental ,policy ,act of #aifi 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #dcba et seq472 7,e7 are compatible with1 and prevent or minimize displacement of1 existing uses and users of the marine environment in which it is located2 7,f7 will conform to best practices to avoid or minimize the use of antibiotics and other pharmaceuticals and minimize the release of such pharmaceuticals into the environment2 and 7,g7 will be conducted over a period of #e years4 7#g7 ,aquaculture ,opportunity ,area ,the ,administrator may elect to site a project approved under this section in an ,aquaculture ,opportunity ,area4 7#h7 ,permit ,the ,administrator shall issue the appropriate permits to allow each pilot project approved under paragraph 7#f7 to conduct offshore aquaculture activities in the exclusive economic zone in accordance with this ,act4 7c7 ,priority consideration ,in considering pilot project applications1 the ,administrator shall give priority consideration to pilot projects owned or operated by-- 7#a7 veterans1 or entities in which a veteran or veterans have a majority ownership interest2 7#b7 members of an environmental justice community or underserved community1 or entities in which a member or members of an environmental justice community or underserved community have a majority ownership interest2 7#c7 entities that primarily serve or employ members of an environmental justice community or underserved community2 or 7#d7 applicants who can demonstrate that the pilot project will directly benefit individuals who are already participating in the agricultural1 wild-caught fishery1 and aquaculture industries who have been negatively impacted by the ,,covid-#ai pandemic1 natural disasters1 or disaster declarations4 7d7 ,interim final rule ,the ,administrator may make an interim final rule to implement the requirements under this section4 7e7 ,assessment program participant reporting 7#a7 ,data and monitoring ,the owner or operator of each commercial-scale demonstration project or pilot project approved for inclusion in the assessment program under this section shall submit such documentation1 in such time1 place1 and manner as the ,administrator determines appropriate1 including-- 7,a7 production data2 7,b7 interactions with wild species1 mitigation measures taken1 and the result2 7,c7 technology and operational practices used to measure and monitor effluent1 integrity of cage materials and other gear1 and health of the cultivated species2 7,d7 environmental and ecosystem impacts2 7,e7 data necessary to assess the considerations described in section #d7;b72 7,f7 information necessary for the ,secretary to make a revocation or modification determination under subsection 7f72 7,g7 owner1 operator1 and employee demographic data and other relevant data as determined by the ,administrator for purposes of assessing the pilot project's direct benefits to environmental justice communities and the economic and social benefits for nearby coastal communities2 7,h7 navigation and safety impacts to existing ocean users2 and 7,i7 such additional information as the ,administrator requires to fulfill the goals and objectives of the assessment program4 7#b7 ,technical assistance ,the ,administrator shall1 upon request1 provide technical assistance to owners and operators of commercial-scale demonstration projects and pilot projects to comply with the reporting requirements of this section4 7#c7 ,emergency reporting ,the ,administrator shall establish an emergency reporting process for each owner or operator of an aquaculture pilot project approved under this section to immediately report suspected or known interactions between pilot project facilities or vessels and protected wild species4 7f7 ,authority ,to revoke or modify pilot project participation ,the ,administrator may require modifications to1 or terminate pilot project participation under this section1 and order the removal of an offshore aquaculture facility authorized to operate under this section if-- 7#a7 the project incurs an incident involving a death or serious personal injury1 and the ,administrator determines that project operator negligence was the cause or a contributing factor to such incident2 7#b7 operation of the project results in a violation of the ,endangered ,species ,act of #aigc 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #aeca et seq47 or the ,marine ,mammal ,protection ,act of #aigb 7#af ,u4,s4,c4 #acfa et seq472 7#c7 the pilot project owner or operator fails to comply with all of the terms and conditions of the pilot program approval or modifications required by the ,administrator under this subsection2 or 7#d7 the ,administrator determines that continued participation in the pilot program by the project would be unsafe or result in unacceptable negative impacts to the marine environment or nearby communities1 or other users of the water body in which the project is located4 7g7 ,reports 7#a7 ,annual reports ,not later than #b years after the date of enactment of this ,act and annually thereafter for the duration of the assessment program1 the ,administrator shall publish1 make available to the public1 and submit to aquaculture stakeholders 7including each adjacent coastal jurisdiction and each affected ,tribal or ,indigenous community1 regional fishery management council1 interstate fisheries commission1 conservation organization1 and fisheries association7 a report that includes the following information3 7,a7 ,a description of each approved pilot project4 7,b7 ,in the first report1 documentation supporting selection of each approved pilot project4 7,c7 ,a summary of the information reported to the ,administrator under subsection 7e7 for each approved pilot project4 7,d7 a description of the progress made toward meeting the goals described in subsection 7a74 7#b7 ,final report ,not later than #a year after the date of the completion of the assessment program1 the ,administrator shall submit to the appropriate committees of ,congress a report describing the results of the pilot program that includes the following information3 7,a7 ,an evaluation based on data from the assessment program of the opportunities and risks of offshore aquaculture regarding-- 7i7 marine ecosystems2 7ii7 other users of the exclusive economic zone2 7iii7 other ecosystems goods and services2 7iv7 social and economic impacts to nearby communities1 including cumulative impacts and impacts on environmental justice communities1 low-income communities1 and communities of color2 7v7 best practices to mitigate risks2 and 7vi7 best practices to prevent disparate impacts4 7,b7 ,any recommendations of the ,administrator for amendments to statutes or regulations and the establishment of performance standards for offshore aquaculture siting and operations1 that-- 7i7 would minimize risks posed by aquaculture operations to marine ecosystems2 7ii7 would enhance the safe operation of aquaculture facilities1 service vessels1 and associated activities2 7iii7 prevent displacement of existing uses and users2 and 7iv7 are technically1 operationally1 and economically feasible4 #f4 ,aquaculture centers of excellence 7a7 ,minority aquaculture research and entrepreneurship grants 7#a7 ,in general ,not later than #a year after the date of the enactment of this section1 the ,administrator shall establish the ,aquaculture ,centers of ,excellence program to award grants to covered institutions to assist in establishing or enhancing an aquaculture curriculum for undergraduate or graduate courses of study at such covered institutions4 7#b7 ,applications ,to be eligible for a grant under this section1 a covered institution shall submit to the ,administrator an application in such form1 at such time1 and containing such information as the ,administrator determines appropriate1 including any plans to partner with other institutions of higher education pursuant to paragraph 7#d74 7#c7 ,grant uses ,a covered institution receiving a grant under this section-- 7,a7 shall use such grant funds to establish or enhance an aquaculture curriculum for undergraduate or graduate studies that includes-- 7i7 training in various skill sets needed by successful aquaculture entrepreneurs1 including-- 7,i7 business management1 strategic planning1 business plan development1 capital financing and fundraising1 financial management and accounting1 market analysis and competitive analysis1 and market entry and strategy execution2 and 7,,ii7 any other skill sets specific to the needs of the student population and the surrounding community1 including social and environmental sustainability1 as determined by the institution2 7ii7 natural and social science research programs in aquaculture and natural fisheries1 including offshore aquaculture2 7iii7 development of extension programs 7or cooperation with existing extension programs7 that educate and engage community members1 including elementary and secondary school students1 on aquaculture and aquaculture career pathways that transfer newly developed techniques and research information developed or collated at the covered institution to aquaculture practitioners2 and 7iv7 career development1 such as the establishment of cooperatives1 apprenticeships1 mentorships1 accelerators1 or grant competitions2 and 7,b7 may only use such grant funds for expenses directly related to the implementation of the curriculum or activities authorized by this section4 7#d7 ,partnerships ,in applying for and carrying out activities with grants under this section1 a covered institution may partner with other institutions of higher education with established aquaculture programs1 including institutions of higher education not otherwise eligible for grants under this section1 to facilitate the sharing of resources and knowledge necessary for aquaculture curriculum development or enhancement at the covered institution4 7#e7 ,grant limitations ,a grant awarded under this section may only be used for expenses directly related to the implementation of the curriculum or activities authorized by this section4 7#f7 ,authorization of ,appropriations ,there is authorized to be appropriated to carry out this section #be1jjj1jjj to remain available until expended1 for each of fiscal years #bjbc through #bjbg4 7b7 ,definitions ,in this section3 7#a7 ,covered institution ,the term covered institution means-- 7,a7 a minority-serving institution2 7,b7 a historically ,black college or university2 or 7,c7 a ,tribal ,college or ,university4 7#b7 ,historically ,black college or university ,the term historically ,black college or university has the meaning given the term part ,b institution in section #cbb of the ,higher ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ajfa74 7#c7 ,institution of higher education ,the term institution of higher education has the meaning given such term in section #aja of the ,higher ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ajja74 7#d7 ,minority-serving institution ,the term minority-serving institution means an eligible institution described in paragraphs 7#b71 7#d71 7#e71 7#f71 and 7#g7 of section #cga7;a7 of the ,higher ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ajfgq7a774 7#e7 ,tribal ,college or ,university ,the term ,tribal ,college or ,university means and institution described in section #caf7;b77#c7 of the ,higher ,education ,act of #aife 7#bj ,u4,s4,c4 #ajei;c7b77 that is chartered under the sovereign authority of its respective ,tribal ,nation or by the ,federal ,government4 #g4 ,rule of construction ,any requirement in this ,act to identify or consider an impact or effect on human health1 the environment1 or the climate shall include a requirement to make such identification or consideration while taking into account-- 7#a7 the cumulative impact of such impact or effect in the context of all sources of emissions1 discharges1 or releases from any source1 past1 present1 or in the reasonably foreseeable future1 on the affected environment and population2 7#b7 any characteristics of such environment and population that may heighten vulnerability to environmental pollution and related health risks2 and 7#c7 any action or practice that1 even if appearing neutral1 has the effect of subjecting individuals to discrimination on the basis of race1 color1 or national origin4