,i #aagth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,r4 #eebj ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,october #h1 #bjba,mr4 ,jacobs of ,new ,york introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,energy and ,commerce ,a ,,bill ,to amend the ,public ,health ,service ,act to increase due process and transparency at the ,national ,library of ,medicine in listing and delisting journals in ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices71 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee ,reform ,act of #bjba4 #b4 ,journal collection of ,national ,library of ,medicine ,title ,,iv of the ,public ,health ,service ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #bha et seq47 is amended by inserting after section #dfg of such ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #bhf;a-#a7 the following new section3 #dfh4 ,journal collection 7a7 ,in general ,in acquiring1 preserving1 organizing1 publishing1 and disseminating journals through the ,national ,library of ,medicine1 including through the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 and ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices71 the ,secretary shall comply with the requirements of this section4 7b7 ,review metrics and methodologies 7#a7 ,specification of objective metric requirement ,the ,secretary shall require the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 to evaluate the scientific and editorial character and quality of a journal based only on an objective scoring rubric4 7#b7 ,metrics and methodologies used to include and remove journals from collections ,the ,secretary shall specify and make publicly available the objective metrics and methodologies pursuant to which the ,library lists and removes journals in the ,library's collections1 including-- 7,a7 all rubrics and other guidance documents used in carrying out a journal review2 7,b7 the specific metrics used in determining the outcome of a journal review1 including those related to a journal's-- 7i7 scope and coverage2 7ii7 editorial policies and processes2 7iii7 scientific and methodological rigor2 7iv7 production and administration2 7v7 impact2 and 7vi7 any other issues taken into account in determining the review outcome2 and 7,c7 the methodology for determining the outcome of a journal review and for ensuring that the outcome is objective4 7#c7 ,initial specification ,the ,secretary shall comply with this subsection beginning not later than #fj days after the date of enactment of this section4 7c7 ,processes for and standards of review ,the ,secretary shall specify and make publicly available the processes for and standards of review of journals1 including-- 7#a7 the scope of review2 7#b7 a timeline including detailed steps of the review2 7#c7 any other guidelines used to ensure the objectivity of reviews2 and 7#d7 the process used to ensure journals selected for reevaluation are provided-- 7,a7 notice2 7,b7 a clear description of why the journal was selected for reevaluation2 and 7,c7 an opportunity for the journal to address identified concerns prior to formal submission for reevaluation4 7d7 ,ensuring independent advice and expertise ,regarding the members of the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7and any successor committee73 7#a7 ,independence ,the ,secretary shall appoint the members without regard to political affiliation or political campaign activity4 7#b7 ,process ,the ,secretary shall-- 7,a7 not less than annually1 solicit nominations for potential members2 and 7,b7 before making an appointment-- 7i7 provide a publicly accessible mechanism for interested persons to comment on the potential member2 and 7ii7 take such comments into consideration4 7e7 ,reevaluation process 7#a7 ,notification of intent to reevaluate ,before selecting a journal for reevaluation for ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices71 the ,secretary shall-- 7,a7 notify the journal in writing of the ,secretary's intention to refer the journal to the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 for review2 7,b7 provide the journal a list of concerns that form the basis for such referral2 7,c7 provide the journal a period of #fj days1 beginning on the date of such notification1 to respond to the concerns forming the basis for the referral to the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 for review2 and 7,d7 provide for an independent review process that considers the concerns and the journal's response and determines whether the concerns were resolved4 7#b7 ,concerns not resolved ,if a journal fails during the #fj-;day period described in paragraph 7#a77;,c7 to resolve to the ,secretary's satisfaction the concerns forming the basis for the referral to the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 for review1 the ,secretary shall-- 7,a7 provide a detailed explanation to the journal of the initial concerns and why the journal has not satisfactorily resolved such concerns2 7,b7 provide the journal a reasonable opportunity to meet and discuss such concerns and the explanation required by subparagraph 7,a72 and 7,c7 after providing such explanation and opportunity to meet1 issue a determination about whether the journal is to be referred to the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or a successor committee7 for reevaluation4 7#c7 ,right to supplement application ,a journal selected for reevaluation pursuant to the process described under this subsection shall have the right to supplement its ,,medline application through the provision of additional information and statements1 which shall be presented to the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or a successor committee7 during its consideration of the journal4 7#d7 ,right to be present ,a journal being reviewed by the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or a successor committee7 pursuant to a referral under paragraph 7#b77;,c7 shall have the right to be present at such review4 7#e7 ,right to an explanation2 period for appeal 7,a7 ,in general ,if1 upon review pursuant to this section1 the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 recommends that a journal be removed from ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices71 and the ,secretary agrees with such recommendation and issues a decision to remove the journal1 the journal shall have-- 7i7 the right to receive detailed information regarding each reviewer's objective score1 any subsequent ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 discussion1 and a detailed explanation of the decision so the journal may address the concerns raised in subsequent applications2 and 7ii7 a period of #fj days to appeal the ,secretary's decision4 7,b7 ,no change to status during appeal ,during the #fj-;day period under subparagraph 7,a7 and during an appeal under paragraph 7#f71 the ,secretary shall not make any change in the journal's status with ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices74 7#f7 ,appeals 7,a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary shall establish and make publicly available a standardized process for journals to appeal a decision described in paragraph 7#e77;,a74 7,b7 ,meeting ,pursuant to the process established under subparagraph 7,a71 the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 shall determine1 at the ,committee's next meeting that takes place at least #cj days after an appeal is filed1 whether to recommend that the ,secretary's decision to remove the journal involved should be reversed4 ,prior to the ,committee making such a determination1 the journal shall be afforded an opportunity to-- 7i7 attend such meeting2 7ii7 present its appeal in person or1 if it so chooses1 in writing2 and 7iii7 submit supplemental material in support of its appeal1 which shall be provided to the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 for its review and consideration4 7,c7 ,final recommendation ,after meeting pursuant to subparagraph 7,b7 with respect to a decision to remove a journal1 the ,literature ,selection ,technical ,review ,committee 7or any successor committee7 shall-- 7i7 make a final recommendation with respect such removal2 and 7ii7 concurrently with the transmission of such final recommendation to the ,secretary1 notify the journal of such final recommendation4 7,d7 ,final decision ,not later than #cj days after receiving a final recommendation pursuant to subparagraph 7,c71 the ,secretary shall-- 7i7 make a final decision as to whether the journal should be removed from ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices72 and 7ii7 notify the journal of such decision1 including by providing a detailed explanation of such decision4 7,e7 ,post-decision period ,if the ,secretary decides pursuant to subparagraph 7,d7 to remove a journal1 the ,secretary shall-- 7i7 notify the journal in writing and provide the journal a period of #cj days from the date of such notice to inform its authors1 subscribers1 and other relevant parties that the journal will no longer be listed on ,,medline2 and 7ii7 refrain from removing the journal until the conclusion of such #cj-;day period4 7,f7 ,right to reapply ,any journal that is removed pursuant to this section from ,,medline 7or any other current or successor databases or indices7 shall1 beginning on the date that is one year after the date of its removal1 have the right to reapply1 but not more than once each year1 to be re-listed in ,,medline 7or any successor databases or indices74 7#g7 ,previously delisted journals ,any journal that was removed from ,,medline on or after ,january #a1 #bjaf1 and before the date of enactment of this section1 shall be given an opportunity during the #fj-;day period following such date of enactment to appeal the removal decision4 ,any such appeal shall be resolved pursuant to the process described in paragraph 7#f74 4