,i #aagth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,r4 #dcch ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,july #a1 #bjba,ms4 ,sherrill 7for herself and ,mr4 ,mc,kinley7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,education and ,labor ,a ,,bill ,to establish a fund to provide grants for the operation and expansion of evidence-based workforce development and post-secondary education programs and to support evaluations of these programs1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,expanding ,pathways to ,employment ,act4 #b4 ,workforce development and post-secondary education grant program 7a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary1 in consultation with the ,board1 shall make grants in accordance with this section to provide long-term funding commitments for eligible workforce development programs and eligible post-secondary education programs as follows3 7#a7 ,workforce development programs supported by strong evidence ,of the total amount appropriated under section #f1 the ,secretary shall use #ej percent of such amount to make grants for eligible workforce development programs that have demonstrated a substantial1 statistically significant positive impact on worker earnings through one or more well-designed and well-implemented randomized control experimental studies4 ,a grant awarded under this paragraph shall be used for the cost of operating and expanding such program1 and may also be used1 at the discretion of the grantee1 for the cost of conducting a new randomized control experimental study with respect to such program4 7#b7 ,workforce development programs supported by moderate and promising evidence ,of the total amount appropriated under section #f1 the ,secretary shall use #be percent of such amount to make grants for eligible workforce development programs that have demonstrated a substantial1 statistically significant positive impact on worker earnings through one or more well-designed and well-implemented quasi-experimental studies or correlational studies4 ,a grant awarded under this paragraph shall be used-- 7,a7 for the cost of conducting randomized control experimental studies with respect to such program2 and 7,b7 for the cost of operating and expanding such program 7but only if a grant under subclause 7,a7 has been concurrently awarded for such program74 7#c7 ,discretionary amount ,of the total amount appropriated under section #f1 the ,secretary shall use #bj percent of such amount at the discretion of the ,secretary-- 7,a7 to make additional grants as described in paragraph 7#a72 7,b7 to make additional grants as described in paragraph 7#b72 and 7,c7 to make grants for eligible post-secondary education programs that have demonstrated a substantial1 statistically significant positive impact on student graduation and degree completion through one or more well-designed and well-implemented randomized control experimental studies1 quasi-experimental studies1 or correlational studies1 to be used-- 7i7 in the case of programs that have demonstrated such positive impact through one or more randomized control experimental studies1 for the cost of operating and expanding such program1 and1 at the discretion of the grantee1 for the cost of conducting a new randomized control experimental study with respect to such program2 and 7ii7 in the case of programs that have demonstrated such positive impact through one or more quasi-experimental studies or correlational studies-- 7,i7 for the cost of conducting randomized control experimental studies with respect to such program2 and 7,,ii7 for the cost of operating and expanding such program 7but only if a grant under subclause 7,i7 has been concurrently awarded for such program74 7#d7 ,technical assistance ,of the total amount appropriated under section #f1 the ,secretary shall use #e percent-- 7,a7 to provide technical assistance for eligible workforce development programs and eligible post-secondary education programs1 including technical assistance related to the use of administrative data to improve program performance2 7,b7 to conduct feasibility studies and other planning activities2 7,c7 to disseminate best practices2 and 7,d7 for staff and other costs related to such activities4 7b7 ,eligible applicants ,applicants for a grant under subsection 7a7 may include-- 7#a7 ,state1 local1 territorial1 or tribal governments1 but only if the application includes one or more clearly designated nonprofit organizations1 institutions of higher education1 or post-secondary vocational institutions that will implement the program using such grant funds2 and 7#b7 nonprofit organizations1 institutions of higher education1 or post-secondary vocational institutions1 but only if the application-- 7,a7 is supported by a ,state1 local1 territorial1 or tribal government2 and 7,b7 includes a plan to partner with that government1 a sustainability plan to ensure the program continues to be delivered after the end of the grant award1 and a clearly designated place or places where the program will be administered4 7c7 ,matching requirement ,the ,secretary shall not award any grant under paragraph 7#a7 or paragraph 7#c77;,a7 of subsection 7a7 to an entity unless the entity provides matching funds from ,federal or non-,federal sources in an amount equal to not less than #ej percent of such grant1 except that the ,secretary may1 at the request of an applicant or a grantee1 grant a waiver reducing this requirement for the purposes of increasing the accessibility or equity of the program design1 or in the case of grants awarded to an eligible entity with limited resources4 #c4 ,amount of grants and criteria for awarding grants 7a7 ,in general ,the amount of a grant awarded for an eligible workforce development program or post-secondary education program under section #b shall be determined by the ,secretary1 in consultation with the ,board1 based on the following3 7#a7 ,the program's impact on participant earnings or participant graduation and degree completion rates relative to costs 7as determined under guidance issued pursuant to subsection 7b774 7#b7 ,whether the program was evaluated through a randomized control experimental study1 a quasi-experimental study1 or a correlational study1 and the overall quality of the evidence behind the program1 including the sample size and number of evaluations1 the statistical quality of the evaluations1 the magnitude of the impacts detected1 and the strength of the causal connection between the program and key economic outcomes measured4 7#c7 ,the number of additional participants that the program expects to enroll as a result of receiving such grant4 7#d7 ,whether the program has been demonstrated to improve equity1 in particular for populations of individuals or communities 7which may include rural communities7 historically held furthest from opportunity4 7b7 ,impact relative to costs standard ,the ,board shall devise and publish a minimum impact relative to costs standard comparing the impact on worker earnings or student graduation and degree completion rates as a result of an eligible workforce development program or post-secondary education program and the annual cost per participant under such program4 ,such standard shall-- 7#a7 set forth a minimum required demonstrable increase in earnings or graduation and degree completion rates over time 7based on previous evaluations7 per dollar of program cost per participant2 and 7#b7 allow for additional flexibility for programs that specifically or primarily serve individuals with barriers to employment 7as defined in section #c7bd7 of the ,workforce ,innovation and ,opportunity ,act 7#bi ,u4,s4,c4 #cajb7bd77 or post-secondary education1 individuals in communities that have historically or currently been underserved by workforce development and post-secondary education programs1 and individuals in rural areas4 #d4 ,independent board 7a7 ,establishment of independent board ,there is established an independent board 7in this ,act referred to as the ,board7 consisting of #e members appointed by the ,secretary in accordance with subsection 7c74 7b7 ,duties ,the ,board shall review applications for grants under this ,act and make recommendations to the ,secretary with respect to the awarding of such grants4 ,the ,board shall1 in their recommendation to the ,secretary regarding program selection1 prioritize programs that have demonstrated a larger impact relative to costs 7as determined under guidance issued pursuant to subsection 7b771 that have been evaluated by more well-designed and well-implemented studies1 and that have been evaluated by randomized control experimental studies rather than quasi-experimental studies or correlational studies4 ,the ,board shall1 in their recommendation to the ,secretary regarding grant size1 prioritize higher funding levels to programs that have demonstrated a larger impact relative to costs 7as so determined71 that have been evaluated by more well-designed and well-implemented studies1 that have been evaluated by randomized control experimental studies rather than quasi-experimental studies or correlational studies1 and that expect to enroll more participants as a result of receiving such grant4 ,for the purposes of these recommendations1 the ,board shall devise a quality standard for evaluations to determine which evaluations are more well-designed and well-implemented compared to others4 7c7 ,appointment ,the ,secretary shall appoint individuals to serve on the ,board who meet the qualifications described in subsection 7d74 ,in making such appointments1 the ,secretary shall consult and receive recommendations from the ,commission of ,social ,impact ,partnerships established under section #bjeg of the ,social ,security ,act4 7d7 ,qualifications of members ,an individual who meets the qualifications described in this subsection is an individual who is an academic1 nonprofit1 or executive agency official with expertise in workforce development programs or post-secondary education programs and experience in running rigorous evaluations4 ,such an individual shall-- 7#a7 be an expert in program evaluation and evidence-based policy1 including evaluation methodologies that are appropriately rigorous and reliant upon independent data2 7#b7 have relevant professional or personal experience in a field related to one or more of the outcomes listed in this division2 or 7#c7 have relevant lived or professional experience with underserved communities and under-resourced families that this ,act is intended to serve4 7e7 ,staffing ,in administering the program under this ,act1 the ,secretary may hire such staff as necessary1 including by using placement authorities under the ,intergovernmental ,personnel ,act of #aigj1 and any other direct hire authorities available to the ,secretary for any other purpose4 ,in hiring staff to administer such program1 the ,secretary shall ensure that such staff meet the qualifications described in subsection 7d74 7f7 ,reports ,the ,board shall report on progress periodically to the ,federal ,interagency ,council on ,social ,impact ,partnerships established under section #bjef of the ,social ,security ,act1 and shall coordinate policies and decisions with relevance to other ,federal agencies through such ,council4 7g7 ,guidance 7#a7 ,in general ,the ,board1 in consultation with the ,commission of ,social ,impact ,partnerships established under section #bjeg of the ,social ,security ,act1 shall develop and make publicly available guidance regarding best practices for the evaluation of eligible workforce development programs and eligible post-secondary education programs to be used to assess the quality of each evaluation as required under subsection 7b74 ,such guidance shall seek to ensure that-- 7,a7 the evaluation accurately models a participant group population that is representative of the overall population served by the program2 7,b7 aggregate shifts that might affect baseline numbers are controlled for by the evaluation2 and 7,c7 regardless of any other factors1 all possible safeguards are undertaken to avoid statistical creaming1 in which the impact of a program is over measured as recruited participants become more highly skilled prior to participation over time4 7#b7 ,procedure ,in issuing the guidance and performance benchmarks defined above1 the ,board shall release and circulate draft guidance1 regulations1 and performance benchmarks1 which shall be circulated to the ,commission1 and shall not be adopted unless approved by a majority vote of the ,commission at a public meeting1 and the ,commission shall receive proposed draft guidance or performance benchmarks not less than #cj days prior to voting to approve it4 ,the ,board shall use the draft guidance1 regulations1 and performance benchmarks1 once approved by the ,commission1 to review grant applications under this ,act and make recommendations to the ,secretary with respect to the awarding of such grants1 as described in subsection 7b74 #e4 ,definitions ,for purposes of this ,act3 7#a7 ,eligible workforce development program ,the term eligible workforce development program means a program operated by a nonprofit organization that provides skills training and education to existing and potential workers with the objective of increasing the wage level and chance of employment of those workers4 7#b7 ,eligible post-secondary education program ,the term eligible post-secondary education program means a program operated by a nonprofit organization1 an institution of higher education 7as defined in section #aja of the ,higher ,education ,act of #aife71 or a postsecondary vocational institution 7as defined in section #ajb7;c7 of such ,act7 that provides education and support services to post-secondary students with the objective of increasing the rate at which these individuals graduate or obtain a post-secondary credential from the post-secondary program in which they are enrolled4 7#c7 ,randomized control experimental study ,the term randomized control experimental study means a study conducted by an independent organization utilizing a randomized control trial methodology that compares the earnings1 or graduation and degree completion rates1 of participant group and control group members1 and measures the causal impact of an eligible workforce development program1 or eligible post-secondary education program1 on participants' earnings1 or graduation and degree completion rates1 at least two years after participants enroll in the program4 7#d7 ,quasi-experimental study ,the term quasi-experimental study means a study conducted by an independent organization that uses a non-randomized methodology and model to measure the causal impact of an eligible workforce development program1 or eligible post-secondary education program1 on participants' earnings1 or graduation and degree completion rates1 at least two years after participants enroll in the program4 7#e7 ,correlational study ,the term correlational study means a study conducted by an independent organization using a non-randomized methodology with statistical controls for selection bias that has found a correlational impact of an eligible workforce development program1 or eligible post-secondary education program1 on participants' earnings1 or graduation and degree completion rates1 and has demonstrated a rationale based on high-quality research findings that the program is likely to improve those participant outcomes at least two years after participants enroll in the program but has not yet demonstrated a causal relationship4 7#f7 ,well-designed and well-implemented ,the term well-designed and well-implemented1 as applied to a study1 means a study that is replicable1 uses programmatic and control groups that are representative of the type of population served by the program1 uses controls for aggregate shifts that might affect baseline numbers1 does not have problems with attrition from the program1 and takes measures to avoid statistical creaming4 7#g7 ,secretary ,the term ,secretary means the ,secretary of the ,treasury4 #f4 ,funding ,there is appropriated to carry out this ,act1 out of any funds in the ,treasury not otherwise appropriated1 #gjj1jjj1jjj for fiscal year #bjba1 to remain available for #i fiscal years4