,,ii #aaf? ,,congress #a/ ,session ,s4 #agde ,,9 ,,! ,,s5ate ,,( ,,! ,,unit$ ,,/ates ,june #e1 #bjai,mr4 ,b5net 7= himself1 ,mr4 ,:iteh\se1 ,mr4 ,van ,holl51 ,ms4 ,h>ris1 ,mr4 ,c>d91 ,mrs4 ,fe9/e91 ,mr4 ,m]kley1 ,mr4 ,wyd51 ,ms4 ,smi?1 ,mr4 ,c>p]1 ,mrs4 ,gillibr&1 ,ms4 ,hirono1 ,ms4 ,klobu*>1 ,mr4 ,s*atz1 ,mr4 ,m>key1 ,mr4 ,he9ri*1 & ,ms4 ,cortez ,ma/o7 introduc$ ! foll[+ bill2 :i* 0 read twice & ref]r$ to ! ,committee on ,environm5t & ,public ,works ,a ,,bill ,to e/abli% a co/ ( gre5h\se gases = c>bon dioxide1 me?ane1 & nitr\s oxide to be us$ by ,f$]al ag5cies1 & = o!r purposes4 #a4 ,%ort title ,?is ,act may be cit$ z ! ,c>bon ,pollution ,transp>5cy ,act4 #b4 ,f9d+s ,congress f9ds t-- 7#a7 s\nd economic & policy analyses require t ! economic b5efits ( r$uc+ climate *ange be consid]$ toge!r ) ! co/s ( policies & measures to r$uce gre5h\se gas emissions2 7#b7 climate *ange1 if n address$1 is project$ to inflict sub/antial damage on ! economy & p ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates2 7#c7 accord+ to ! ,congressional ,budget ,(fice1 ! ,gov]nm5t ,acc\ntability ,(fice1 & ! ,(fice ( ,managem5t & ,budget1 ! impacts ( climate *ange are-- 7,a7 co/+ ,unit$ ,/ates taxpay]s billions ( doll>s annually2 & 7,b7 putt+ pressure on ! ,f$]al budget2 7#d7 ! exp5ditures by ! ,f$]al ,gov]nm5t result+ f ! effects ( climate *ange are project$ to increase1 & r$uc+ gre5h\se gas emissions pres5ts an opportunity to m9imize ^? exp5ditures2 7#e7 betwe5 cal5d> ye>s #bjjh & #bjae1 ! ,unit$ ,/ates r$uc$ c>bon pollution f ! en]gy sector by ne>ly #aj p]c5t1 :ile ! economy grew m ?an #aj p]c5t2 7#f7 m ?an #a1bjj companies are tak+ ! co/ ( climate *ange into consid]ation 9 bus9ess decisions2 7#g7 e/imates ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases provide a me?od & measure1 gr\nd$ 9 sci5tific & economic rese>*1 = monetiz+-- 7,a7 ! co/s ( gre5h\se gas emissions2 & 7,b7 ! b5efits ( r$uc+ gre5h\se gas emissions2 7#h7 ! ,national ,academies ( ,sci5ces1 ,eng9e]+1 & ,m$ic9e has provid$ detail$ recomm5dations = improv+ ! e/imate ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases = ! purpose ( regulatory analysis2 7#i7 ! r$uction ( gre5h\se gas emissions by o!r c\ntries b5efits ! ,unit$ ,/ates by r$uc+ climate risks to ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 & ! r$uction ( gre5h\se gas emissions by ! ,unit$ ,/ates b5efits o!r c\ntries2 7#aj7 9 light ( ! global nature ( ! problem ( gre5h\se gas emissions1 ! int]e/s ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates w\ld be maximiz$ if ! ,unit$ ,/ates 7 to use a calculation me?od ( ! co/ ( climate pollution t reflects global damages2 7#aa7 due to ! nature ( climate *ange risks1 ! returns on mitigation may pay (f 9 p]iods t w\ld o!rwise involve sub/antial losses2 7#ab7 economic !ory & evid5ce sugge/s t1 = actions ) int]g5]ational consequ5ces su* z ! consequ5ces ( climate *ange1 a disc\nt rate approximately equal to or less ?an ! long-t]m yield on ! debt ( ! ,treasury ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates may be appropriate2 & 7#ac7 x is imp]ative t ! academic community cont9ue rese>* on ! co/ ( gre5h\se gases4 #c4 ,def9itions ,9 ?is ,act3 7#a7 ,calculation me?od ,! t]m calculation me?od means ! me?od by :i* ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases are calculat$ 9 accordance ) subsections 7a71 7b71 & 7c7 ( section #d1 respectively4 7#b7 ,committee ,! t]m ,committee means ! ,co/s ( ,gre5h\se ,gases ,sci5tific ,review ,committee e/abli%$ "u section #g7;a74 7#c7 ,co/s ( gre5h\se gases 7,a7 ,9 g5]al ,! t]m co/s ( gre5h\se gases means ! monetiz$ pres5t disc\nt$ values1 9 doll>s1 ( ! curr5t & future net co/s to society t result f-- 7i7 #a ton ( emissions ( a specific gre5h\se gas 9 a specific ye>1 includ+1 b n limit$ to1 damage relat+ to-- 7,i7 a *ange 9 net agricultural productivity2 7,,ii7 en]gy use2 7,,iii7 human heal?2 7,,iv7 prop]ty damage f increas$ flood risk & sea level rise2 & 7,v7 to ! maximum ext5t practicable1 ! value ( ! effect on ecosy/em s]vices due to climate *ange2 & 7ii7 ! monetiz$ pres5t disc\nt$ values ( ! curr5t & future net b5efits to society f a #a-ton r$uction ( emissions ( a specific gre5h\se gas 9 a specific ye>1 includ+ a r$uction 9 any damage describ$ 9 clause 7i74 7,b7 ,inclusions ,! t]m co/s ( gre5h\se gases includes-- 7i7 ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide2 7ii7 ! co/ ( me?ane2 7iii7 ! co/ ( nitr\s oxide2 & 7iv7 ! co/ ( any o!r gre5h\se gas e/imat$ by ! ,work+ ,gr\p4 7#d7 ,work+ ,gr\p ,! t]m ,work+ ,gr\p means ! ,int]ag5cy ,work+ ,gr\p on ! ,co/s ( ,gre5h\se ,gases e/abli%$ "u section #e7;a74 #d4 ,co/ ( c>bon dioxide1 co/ ( me?ane1 & co/ ( nitr\s oxide 7a7 ,co/ ( c>bon dioxide ,9 develop+ any rulemak+ t requires a regulatory impact analysis1 mak+ any sub/antial procurem5t decision = :i* ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide is n appli$ be=e ! date on :i* a revis$ v]sion ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases is f9aliz$1 ! head ( any ,f$]al ag5cy %all consid] & docum5t ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide 9 accordance ) ! am\nts specifi$ 9 ! foll[+ table3 ,co/ ( ,c>bon ,dioxide1 #bjaj ,?r\gh #bjej 79 #bjjg ,doll>s p] ,metric ,ton ( ,c>bon ,dioxide71 ,disc\nt ,rate & ,statistic,year#e ,p]c5t ,av]age#c ,p]c5t ,av]age#b4e ,p]c5t ,average,high ,impact 7#ie? ,p]c5tile at #c ,p]c5t ,disc\nt ,rate7 #bjajajcaejhfbjaaaacbeaijbjabaaccecicbja caacdedigbjadaaceeeajabjaeaacfefajebjafa achegajhbjagaacieiaabbjahabdjfjaafbjaiab dafaabjbjbjabdbfbabcbjbaabdbfcabfbjbbacd cfdabibjbcacddfeacbbjbdacdeffacebjbeaddf fhachbjbfaddgfiadabjbgaedhgjadcbjbhaedig aadfbjbiaedigbadibjcjafejgcaebbjcaafeagd aeebjcbagebgeaehbjccagecgfafabjcdahedgga fdbjceaheeghafhbjcfaiefgiagabjcgaieghaag dbjchbjehhbaggbjcibjeihcahjbjdjbafjhdahc bjdabafaheahfbjdbbbfahfahibjdcbbfbhgaibb jddbcfchhaidbjdebcfdhiaigbjdfbdfeijbjjbj dgbdffibbjcbjdhbefgicbjfbjdibefhidbjibje jbffiiebab 7b7 ,co/ ( me?ane ,9 develop+ any rulemak+ t requires a regulatory impact analysis1 mak+ any sub/antial procurem5t decision = :i* ! co/ ( me?ane is n appli$ be=e ! date on :i* a revis$ v]sion ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases is f9aliz$1 ! head ( any ,f$]al ag5cy %all consid] & docum5t ! co/ ( me?ane 9 accordance ) ! am\nts specifi$ 9 ! foll[+ table3 ,co/ ( ,me?ane1 #bjaj ,?r\gh #bjej 79 #bjjg ,doll>s p] ,metric ,ton ( ,me?ane71 ,disc\nt ,rate & ,statistic,year#e ,p]c5t ,av]age#c ,p]c5t ,av]age#b4e ,p]c5t ,average,high ,impact 7#ie? ,p]c5tile at #c ,p]c5t ,disc\nt ,rate7#bjajcgjhgja1bjjb1djjbjaachjiaja1b jjb1ejjbjabdjjidja1cjjb1fjjbjacdbjigja1c jjb1gjjbjadddja1jjja1cjjb1gjjbjaedeja1jj ja1djjb1hjjbjafdgja1ajja1djjb1ijjbjagdij a1ajja1ejjc1jjjbjaheaja1ajja1ejjc1jjjbja iebja1bjja1ejjc1ajjbjbjedja1bjja1fjjc1bj jbjbaefja1bjja1fjjc1cjjbjbbeija1cjja1gjj c1djjbjbcfaja1cjja1gjjc1ejjbjbdfcja1djja 1hjjc1fjjbjbefeja1djja1hjjc1gjjbjbffgja1 djja1ijjc1hjjbjbggjja1ejja1ijjc1ijjbjbhg bja1ejjb1jjjd1jjjbjbigdja1fjjb1jjjd1ajjb jcjgfja1fjjb1jjjd1bjjbjcagija1fjjb1ajjd1 cjjbjcbhbja1gjjb1ajjd1ejjbjccheja1gjjb1b jjd1fjjbjcdhhja1hjjb1bjjd1gjjbjceijja1hj jb1cjjd1ijjbjcficja1ijjb1djje1jjjbjcgifj a1ijjb1djje1ajjbjchiijb1jjjb1ejje1bjjbjc ia1jjjb1jjjb1ejje1djjbjdja1jjjb1jjjb1fjj e1ejjbjdaa1ajjb1ajjb1fjje1fjjbjdba1ajjb1 ajjb1gjje1gjjbjdca1ajjb1bjjb1gjje1hjjbjd da1bjjb1bjjb1hjje1ijjbjdea1bjjb1cjjb1hjj f1ajjbjdfa1bjjb1cjjb1ijjf1bjjbjdga1cjjb1 djjb1ijjf1cjjbjdha1cjjb1djjc1jjjf1djjbjd ia1cjjb1ejjc1jjjf1ejjbjeja1cjjb1ejjc1ajj f1gjj 7c7 ,co/ ( nitr\s oxide ,9 develop+ any rulemak+ t requires a regulatory impact analysis1 mak+ any sub/antial procurem5t decision = :i* ! co/ ( nitr\s oxide is n appli$ be=e ! date on :i* a revis$ v]sion ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases is f9aliz$1 ! head ( any ,f$]al ag5cy %all consid] & docum5t ! co/ ( nitr\s oxide 9 accordance ) ! am\nts specifi$ 9 ! foll[+ table3 ,co/ ( ,nitr\s ,oxide1 #bjaj ,?r\gh #bjej 79 #bjjg ,doll>s p] ,metric ,ton ( ,nitr\s ,oxide71 ,disc\nt ,rate & ,statistic,year#e ,p]c5t ,av]age#c ,p]c5t ,av]age#b4e ,p]c5t ,average,high ,impact 7#ie? ,p]c5tile at #c ,p]c5t ,disc\nt ,rate7#bjajc1djjab1jjjah1jjjca1jjjbjaac1 ejjab1jjjah1jjjcb1jjjbjabc1gjjab1jjjai1j jjcc1jjjbjacc1hjjac1jjjai1jjjcd1jjjbjadc 1ijjac1jjjbj1jjjcd1jjjbjaed1jjjac1jjjbj1 jjjce1jjjbjafd1bjjad1jjjbj1jjjcf1jjjbjag d1cjjad1jjjba1jjjcg1jjjbjahd1djjad1jjjba 1jjjch1jjjbjaid1fjjae1jjjbb1jjjch1jjjbjb jd1gjjae1jjjbb1jjjci1jjjbjbad1ijjae1jjjb c1jjjdj1jjjbjbbe1jjjaf1jjjbc1jjjda1jjjbj bce1bjjaf1jjjbc1jjjdb1jjjbjbde1djjaf1jjj bd1jjjdc1jjjbjbee1ejjag1jjjbd1jjjdd1jjjb jbfe1gjjag1jjjbe1jjjde1jjjbjbge1ijjag1jj jbe1jjjdf1jjjbjbhf1jjjah1jjjbf1jjjdg1jjj bjbif1bjjah1jjjbf1jjjdh1jjjbjcjf1cjjai1j jjbg1jjjdi1jjjbjcaf1ejjai1jjjbg1jjjej1jj jbjcbf1hjjai1jjjbh1jjjea1jjjbjccg1jjjbj1 jjjbh1jjjeb1jjjbjcdg1bjjbj1jjjbi1jjjed1j jjbjceg1djjba1jjjbi1jjjee1jjjbjcfg1fjjba 1jjjcj1jjjef1jjjbjcgg1hjjba1jjjcj1jjjeg1 jjjbjchh1jjjbb1jjjca1jjjeh1jjjbjcih1bjjb b1jjjca1jjjei1jjjbjdjh1djjbc1jjjcb1jjjfj 1jjjbjdah1fjjbc1jjjcb1jjjfa1jjjbjdbh1hjj bc1jjjcc1jjjfb1jjjbjdci1ajjbd1jjjcc1jjjf d1jjjbjddi1cjjbd1jjjcd1jjjfe1jjjbjdei1ej jbe1jjjcd1jjjff1jjjbjdfi1hjjbe1jjjce1jjj fg1jjjbjdgaj1jjjbf1jjjce1jjjfh1jjjbjdhaj 1jjjbf1jjjcf1jjjfi1jjjbjdiaj1jjjbf1jjjcf 1jjjga1jjjbjejaa1jjjbg1jjjcg1jjjgb1jjj 7d7 ,adju/m5t = inflation ,! head ( a ,f$]al ag5cy may adju/ ! co/s describ$ 9 ! tables conta9$ 9 subsections 7a7 ?r\gh 7c7 = inflation4 #e4 ,int]ag5cy ,work+ ,gr\p on ! ,co/s ( ,gre5h\se ,gases 7a7 ,e/abli%m5t ,! ,director ( ! ,(fice ( ,managem5t & ,budget1 ! ,director ( ! ,(fice ( ,sci5ce & ,te*nology ,policy1 & ! ,*air ( ! ,c\ncil ( ,economic ,advis]s %all e/abli% an int]ag5cy work+ gr\p1 to be kn[n z ! ,int]ag5cy ,work+ ,gr\p on ! ,co/s ( ,gre5h\se ,gases to c>ry out ! calculation me?od revision evaluation describ$ 9 section #f4 7b7 ,memb]%ip ,! ,work+ ,gr\p %all consi/ ( memb]s f-- 7#a7 ! ,c\ncil ( ,economic ,advis]s2 7#b7 ! ,(fice ( ,sci5ce & ,te*nology ,policy2 7#c7 ! ,national ,security ,c\ncil2 7#d7 ! ,national ,economic ,c\ncil2 7#e7 ! ,c\ncil on ,environm5tal ,quality2 7#f7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,agriculture2 7#g7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,comm]ce2 7#h7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,en]gy2 7#i7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ! ,int]ior2 7#aj7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,transportation2 7#aa7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ! ,treasury2 7#ab7 ! ,dep>tm5t ( ,heal? & ,human ,s]vices2 7#ac7 ! ,environm5tal ,protection ,ag5cy2 7#ad7 ! ,national ,oceanic & ,atmosph]ic ,adm9i/ration2 7#ae7 ! ,f$]al ,en]gy ,regulatory ,commission2 7#af7 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,global ,*ange ,rese>* ,program2 & 7#ag7 ! ,corps ( ,eng9e]s4 #f4 ,calculation me?od revision 7a7 ,revision evaluation 7#a7 ,9 g5]al ,n lat] ?an #e ye>s aft] ! date ( enactm5t ( ?is ,act1 & n less frequ5tly ?an once e #e ye>s !reaft]1 ! ,work+ ,gr\p %all c>ry out a revision evaluation = ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide1 co/ ( me?ane1 & co/ ( nitr\s oxide to det]m9e :e!r a revision ( ! calculation me?od ( ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide1 co/ ( me?ane1 or co/ ( nitr\s oxide is necess>y4 7#b7 ,consid]ations ,9 c>ry+ out a revision evaluation "u p>agraph 7#a7 or a revision "u subsection 7b71 ! ,work+ ,gr\p %all-- 7,a7 consid]-- 7i7 ! f9d+s ( ! ,national ,academies ( ,sci5ces1 ,eng9e]+1 & ,m$ic9e relat+ to approa*es to e/imat+ ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases2 7ii7 ! f9d+s ( ! ,committee "u section #g7;a77#c72 7iii7 advancem5ts 9 sci5tific & economic rese>* relat+ to ! impacts ( climate *ange & ! e/imation ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases2 7iv7 new dome/ic & int]national f9d+s2 7v7 ! qualitative co/s to society z a result ( ! categories ( damage describ$ 9 section #c7c77;,a7 t _c be monetiz$ & ! impact on environm5tal ju/ice communities2 & 7vi7 all h>m caus$ by gre5h\se gas emissions2 7,b7 assess any propos$ revision ( ! calculation me?od ) respect to-- 7i7 consi/5cy ) ! /ate ( sci5tific k1 z reflect$ by curr5t1 pe]-review$ lit]ature2 & 7ii7 ! adequacy ) :i* ! propos$ calculation me?od id5tifies & repres5ts key unc]ta9ties & s5sitivities2 7,c7 evaluate ! h>m caus$ by gre5h\se gas emissions = ! p]iod beg9n+ on ! date on :i* ! applicable revision evaluation comm5ces & end+ on a date 9 ! future t w\ld all[ e/imation ( ! va/ majority ( disc\nt$ climate damages2 7,d7 apply #a or m disc\nt rates1 :i* %all-- 7i7 acc\nt = ! int]g5]ational nature ( ! h>m caus$ by climate *ange2 & 7ii7 be consi/5t ) ! int]e/ rate ( consumption us$ by ,f$]al ag5cies to reflect climate risk2 7,e7 include values t acc\nt = global damages f gre5h\se gas emissions2 7,f7 docum5t ! calculation me?od & pres5t results 9 a mann] adequate = ! sci5tific community to und]/& & assess ! calculation me?od2 & 7,g7 make available to rese>*]s ! model code = review1 use1 & modification4 7b7 ,revision 7#a7 ,calculation me?od ,if ! ,work+ ,gr\p makes a det]m9ation "u subsection 7a77#a7 t revision ( ! calculation me?od is necess>y1 ! ,work+ ,gr\p %all draft a propos$ revision ( ! calculation me?od4 7#b7 ,public notification & comm5t p]iod ,any propos$ revision ( ! calculation me?od %all be publi%$ 9 ! ,f$]al ,regi/] = a p]iod ( public comm5t ( n few] ?an #ij days & include consultation ) indu/ry gr\ps4 7#c7 ,effect ( revisions by ,work+ ,gr\p ,any revis$ calculation me?od ( ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide1 ! co/ ( me?ane1 or ! co/ ( nitr\s oxide develop$ by ! ,work+ ,gr\p "u p>agraph 7#a7 & publi%$ "u p>agraph 7#b7 %all sup]s$e ! applicable disc\nt rate value ( ! co/ ( c>bon dioxide1 ! co/ ( me?ane1 or ! co/ ( nitr\s oxide "u section #d4 #g4 ,co/s ( ,gre5h\se ,gases ,sci5tific ,review ,committee 7a7 ,e/abli%m5t 7#a7 ,9 g5]al ,n lat] ?an ,janu>y #a1 #bjba1 & n less frequ5tly ?an once e #e ye>s !reaft]1 ! ,director ( ! ,(fice ( ,managem5t & ,budget1 9 consultation ) ! ,director ( ! ,(fice ( ,sci5ce & ,te*nology ,policy & ! ,*air ( ! ,c\ncil ( ,economic ,advis]s1 %all e/abli% a committee1 to be kn[n z ! ,co/s ( ,gre5h\se ,gases ,sci5tific ,review ,committee4 7#b7 ,memb]%ip ,! memb]%ip ( ! ,committee %all consi/ ( n few] ?an #aj memb]s1 select$ by ! presid5ts ( ! ,national ,academies ( ,sci5ces1 ,eng9e]+1 & ,m$ic9e1 :o %all repres5t sci5tific fields relevant to ! e/imation ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases1 includ+-- 7,a7 climate sci5ce2 7,b7 climate economics2 & 7,c7 decision analysis4 7#c7 ,duties ,! ,committee %all publi% a report 9 :i* ! ,committee %all-- 7,a7 make a recomm5dation to ! ,work+ ,gr\p reg>d+ :e!r a revision ( ! calculation me?od is necess>y2 7,b7 if ! ,committee det]m9es t a revision is necess>y1 recomm5d sci5tific data & models to be us$ by ! ,work+ ,gr\p 9 ! revision ( ! calculation me?od2 7,c7 provide sci5tific advice to ! ,work+ ,gr\p on ! revision2 & 7,d7 provide guidance to ! ,u4,s4 ,global ,*ange ,rese>* ,program ) respect to ! rese>* necess>y to advance ! e/imation ( ! co/s ( gre5h\se gases4 7b7 ,t]m9ation ,on ! completion ( ! revision evaluation = :i* ! ,committee is e/abli%$1 ! ,committee %all t]m9ate4 7c7 ,au?orization ( appropriations ,!re are au?oriz$ to be appropriat$ su* sums z are necess>y to adm9i/] ! ,committee4