,i #aaeth ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,r4 #fcfa ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,july #ab1 #bjah,mr4 ,pocan 7for himself1 ,ms4 ,jayapal1 ,mr4 ,espaillat1 ,mr4 ,serrano1 ,mr4 ,blumenauer1 ,mr4 ,mc,govern1 ,mr4 ,smith of ,washington1 ,ms4 ,velzquez1 and ,ms4 ,clarke of ,new ,york7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on the ,judiciary1 and in addition to the ,committees on ,ways and ,means1 and ,homeland ,security1 for a period to be subsequently determined by the ,speaker1 in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned ,a ,,bill ,to establish a ,commission tasked with establishing a humane immigration enforcement system1 terminate ,immigration and ,customs ,enforcement1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,establishing a ,humane ,immigration ,enforcement ,system ,act 4 #b4 ,findings ,congress finds the following3 7#a7 ,in #bjjc1 under the ,bush ,administration1 critical immigration enforcement functions were transferred away from the ,department of ,justice to the newly created ,u4,s4 ,immigration ,customs and ,enforcement 7,,ice7 under the guise of national security4 ,at the same time1 a separate agency1 ,customs and ,border ,patrol1 was also established with prime responsibility for border security activities4 7#b7 ,in #bjjd1 the ,department of ,justice stated1 ,the primary mission of ,,ice is to prevent acts of terrorism by targeting the people1 money1 and materials that support terrorist and criminal activities4 7#c7 ,only a fraction of ,,ice resources and personnel are dedicated to ,,ice's original mission of tracking terrorism and transnational crime syndicates domestically and internationally1 creating serious challenges for national security4 ,the ,homeland ,security ,investigations 7,,hsi7 division of ,,ice1 which fights human trafficking1 drug smuggling and trade fraud and is critical to national security1 has been deprioritized4 7#d7 ,in ,june #bjah1 #ai ,,ice ,homeland ,security ,investigations ,division 7,,hsi7 employees1 including a majority of special agents in charge of ,,hsi1 called on ,,dhs ,secretary ,nielsen to remove ,,hsi from ,,ice to improve ,,hsi's ability to function effectively and to stop ,,ice's reprogramming of ,,hsi funds for ,enforcement and ,removal ,operations4 ,the letter also stated that ,,hsi's work is compromised by the reluctance among ,state and local law enforcement to collaborate with ,,hsi given ,,ice's civil immigration enforcement focus4 7#e7 ,,ice's work has radically shifted from its primary mission of preventing acts of terrorism1 as articulated by the ,department of ,justice in #bjjd1 to carrying out detention and deportation activities as its core focus4 ,nearly #fj percent of ,,ice's #g4a billion budget goes to detention and removal operations4 ,such removal operations tend to focus on individuals who are being prosecuted simply for illegal entry or re-entry1 have no other criminal history and pose no threat to national security4 ,these removal operations have torn apart families and communities and disrupted businesses throughout the country4 7#f7 ,,ice contracts out billions of taxpayer dollars every year to private1 for-profit prison companies that have eschewed transparency and accountability1 and operate at significantly higher expense to taxpayers than lower-cost alternatives to detention4 ,as of ,august #bjaf1 nearly three-quarters of the average daily population in immigration detention were held in facilities operated by private prison companies4 7#g7 ,numerous ,federal oversight bodies1 including the ,government ,accountability ,office and the ,,dhs ,office of the ,inspector ,general1 have documented a disregard for congressional oversight and substandard conditions and inhumane treatment of those in ,,ice detention1 which contravene ,,ice's own standards and ,federal and international legal protections4 ,in addition1 other credible reports indicate violations of due process1 and noncompliance with international and domestic legal protections4 ,,ice detention facilities fail to meet ,,ice's own standards and have no meaningful oversight4 7#h7 ,the ,department of ,homeland ,security's ,office of ,inspector ,general issued a ,december #bjag report cataloguing violations of compliance with ,,ice detention standards regarding conditions for detainees that undermine the protection of detainees' rights1 their humane treatment1 and the provision of a safe and healthy environment4 7#i7 ,a ,june #bjah report by the ,,dhs ,,oig titled1 ,,ice's ,inspections and ,monitoring of ,detention ,facilities ,do ,not ,lead to ,sustained ,compliance or ,systemic ,improvements found that neither the inspections nor the onsite monitoring ensure consistent compliance with detention standards1 nor do they promote comprehensive deficiency corrections and that ,,ice does not adequately follow up on identified deficiencies or consistently hold facilities accountable for correcting them1 which further diminishes the usefulness of inspections4 7#aj7 ,according to an independent analysis by medical experts1 more than half of the detainee death reviews published by ,,ice from ,december #bjae to ,april #bjag show that inadequate medical care contributed or led to the person's death in ,,ice detention4 7#aa7 ,sexual and physical abuse is rampant in ,,ice custody4 ,independent analysis of #a1bbd complaints of sexual and physical abuse in ,,ice custody filed between #bjaj and ,september #bjag found that over half reported an officer or private detention contractor as the perpetrator of alleged abuses and that the ,office of ,inspector ,general investigated only #cj of these complaints4 ,data on sexual assault in ,,ice detention found that ,,lgbt people were #ig times more likely to be sexually victimized than the general population4 7#ab7 ,,ice has taken measures to destroy records of immigrant abuse in its custody4 ,in ,july #bjag1 ,,ice requested that the ,national ,archives and ,records ,administration approve its timetable for destroying records related to sexual assaults1 solitary confinement and deaths of people in its custody4 7#ac7 ,,ice subjects asylum seekers to cruel and inhumane conditions4 ,in a ,november #bjad report1 the ,united ,nations ,committee ,against ,torture expressed concern over ,united ,states practices of mandatory detention to automatically hold asylum seekers and other immigrants on arrival in prison-like detention facilities1 and reports of substandard conditions of detention in immigration facilities and use of solitary confinement1 as well as sexual violence by staff and other detainees4 7#ad7 ,,ice has not adopted recommendations made by its ,advisory ,committee on ,family ,residential ,centers1 which suggested in a #bjaf report that immigration enforcement practices should operationalize the presumption that detention is generally neither appropriate nor necessary for families--and that detention or the separation of families for purposes of immigration enforcement or management are never in the best interest of children1 further recommending that the general use of family detention be discontinued4 7#ae7 ,,ice's actions to force ,state and local law enforcement to comply with immigration detainer requests to hold people in custody without a warrant violate the ,fourth ,amendment1 and immigration enforcement actions at sensitive locations1 including courthouses1 hospitals1 churches and schools have undermined public trust in the agency4 7#af7 ,a troubling pattern of ,,ice pursuing immigrant rights advocates working within their ,first ,amendment rights suggests the improper targeting of political opponents and threatens bedrock free speech and due process rights4 7#ag7 ,the ,government ,accountability ,office 7,,gao7 has found a number of inconsistencies and errors in ,,ice's calculations for its congressional budget justifications ''' 4 ,while ,,ice officials stated their budget documents undergo multiple reviews to ensure accuracy1 ,,ice was not able to provide documentation of such reviews4 ,the ,,gao concluded1 ,,ice is not positioned to ensure the credibility of its budget requests4 7#ah7 ,any essential functions carried out by ,,ice that do not violate fundamental due process and human rights can be executed with greater transparency1 public accountability1 and adherence to domestic and international law by other ,federal agencies4 #c4 ,establishment of commission to administer transition of functions 7a7 ,establishment ,within #cj days of the enactment of this ,act1 ,congress shall establish and convene the ,commission to ,study and ,establish a ,fair and ,humane ,system of ,immigration and ,customs ,enforcement 7hereinafter in this ,act referred to as the ,commission74 7b7 ,duties ,the ,commission shall perform the following duties3 7#a7 ,identify all essential functions of ,,ice that uphold the ,constitution and maintain high human rights standards pursuant to the ,protocol ,relating to the ,status of ,refugees of #aifg and the ,international ,covenant on ,civil and ,political ,rights and identify the appropriate ,federal agencies that shall be tasked with executing activities such as combatting financial crimes1 cybercrimes1 trade fraud1 human trafficking and drug smuggling1 as well as a plan to transition any such duties4 7#b7 ,determine the most effective means of ensuring that all immigration enforcement functions transferred to other ,federal agencies maintain strict compliance to the ,constitution1 ,federal laws1 the ,protocol ,relating to the ,status of ,refugees of #aifg and the ,international ,covenant on ,civil and ,political ,rights1 including article #g's prohibition of torture and cruel1 inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment4 7#c7 ,prior to presenting any recommendation for an existing ,federal agency to adopt an immigration-enforcement function deemed essential pursuant to paragraph 7#a71 the ,commission shall evaluate and approve the agency's suitability for that function based on such agency's track record of transparency and compliance with its own directives and policies1 as well as ,federal laws1 statutes1 and treaty obligations outlined in paragraph 7#b72 7#d7 ,identify appropriate means of ensuring that total ,federal employment is not reduced with the abolition of ,,ice1 prioritizing the hiring of personnel to address the legal1 health1 and social-service needs of detained individuals1 those seeking asylum1 and those determined to be most vulnerable within the ,federal immigration system4 7#e7 ,provide recommendations for ensuring that all immigration enforcement carried out by ,federal agencies administer asylum requests in a prompt and timely manner1 and in full compliance with all relevant ,federal statutes and international laws1 such as the ,protocol ,relating to the ,status of ,refugees of #aifg and the ,convention ,against ,torture4 7#f7 ,the ,commission will work with the ,department of ,homeland ,security's ,office of ,inspector ,general to document failures to comply with congressional oversight requirements1 violations of constitutional protections and ,federal laws1 failures to comply with agency policies and directives1 violations of human rights1 and any other longstanding patterns of medical neglect1 solitary confinement1 wrongful death1 and other abuses for which ,,ice is wholly or partially responsible1 and recommend appropriate ways to prevent future violations and educate the ,american public of the ,commission's findings4 7c7 ,report to ,congress ,the ,commission shall submit a written report of its findings and recommendations to the ,congress no later than #ahj days after the date of the first meeting of the ,commission held4 7d7 ,congressional consideration of commission's report ,the ,congress shall consider the ,commission's findings and recommendations in legislating the transfer of essential immigration-enforcement functions to existing ,federal agencies prior to the termination of ,,ice4 #d4 ,membership 7a7 ,number and appointment ,the ,commission shall be composed of #ag members1 who shall be appointed and convene within #cj days after the date of enactment of this ,act1 as follows3 7#a7 ,two members shall be appointed by the ,speaker of the ,house of ,representatives4 7#b7 ,two members shall be appointed by the ,house ,minority ,leader4 7#c7 ,two members shall be appointed by the ,senate ,majority ,leader4 7#d7 ,two members shall be appointed by the ,senate ,minority ,leader4 7#e7 ,nine members shall be selected from the major civil society and immigrants' rights organizations and individuals directly impacted by ,,ice practices4 7b7 ,qualifications ,all members of the ,commission shall be persons who are especially qualified to serve on the ,commission by virtue of their education1 training1 activism or experience1 particularly in the field of human rights1 international law1 and constitutional protections4 #e4 ,termination of the ,u4,s4 ,immigration and ,customs ,enforcement ,on the date no later than #a year after the enactment of this ,act1 the ,u4,s4 ,immigration and ,customs ,enforcement shall terminate4