,,ii #aadth ,,congress #ast ,session ,s4 #bada ,,in ,,the ,,senate ,,of ,,the ,,united ,,states ,october #f1 #bjae ,mr4 ,cassidy 7for himself and ,mr4 ,whitehouse7 introduced the following bill2 which was read twice and referred to the ,committee on ,health1 ,education1 ,labor1 and ,pensions ,a ,,bill ,to amend the ,public ,health ,service ,act with respect to health information technology4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,transparent ,ratings on ,usability and ,security to ,transform ,information ,technology ,act of #bjae or the ,,trust ,,it ,act4 #b4 ,definitions ,section #cjjj of the ,public ,health ,service ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #cjj;jj7 is amended-- 7#a7 by redesignating paragraphs 7#aj7 through 7#ad7 as paragraphs 7#ab7 through 7#af71 respectively2 and 7#b7 by inserting after paragraph 7#i7 the following3 7#aj7 ,information blocking ,the term information blocking means1 with respect to the development1 configuration1 implementation1 and use of qualified electronic health records and other health information technology1 business1 technical1 and organizational practices that-- 7,a7 except as required by law1 prevent or materially discourage the access1 exchange1 or use of electronic health information2 and 7,b7 the person knows or should know 7as defined in section #aabh;,a7i77#g7 of the ,social ,security ,act7 are likely to interfere with the access1 exchange1 or use of electronic health information4 7#aa7 ,interoperability ,the term interoperability means the ability of #b or more health information systems or components to exchange clinical and other information and to use the information that has been exchanged using common standards to provide access to longitudinal or requested information to health care providers1 patients1 and other authorized users when such persons need such information in order to facilitate coordinated care and improved patient outcomes4 4 #c4 ,enhancements to testing and certification ,section #cjja7;c77#e7 of the ,public ,health ,service ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #cjj;jj-#aa7 is amended-- 7#a7 in subparagraph 7,a7-- 7,a7 by striking ,the ,national ,coordinator and inserting the following3 7i7 ,voluntary certification program ,the ,national ,coordinator 2 and 7,b7 by adding at the end the following3 7ii7 ,transparency of program 7,i7 ,in general ,to enhance transparency in the compliance of health information technology with certification criteria adopted under this subtitle1 the ,national ,coordinator1 in coordination with authorized certification bodies1 may make information demonstrating how health information technology meets such certification criteria publicly available4 ,such information may include summaries1 screenshots1 video demonstrations1 or any other information the ,national ,coordinator determines appropriate4 7,,ii7 ,protection of proprietary information ,nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to require the release of trade secrets or any other protected intellectual property4 2 7#b7 in subparagraph 7,b71 by adding at the end the following3 ,beginning #ah months after reporting criteria are finalized under section #cjji;,a1 certification criteria shall include1 in addition to criteria to establish that the technology meets such standards and implementation specifications1 criteria consistent with section #cjji;,a7b7 to establish that technology meets applicable security requirements1 incorporates user-centered design1 and achieves interoperability42 and 7#c7 by adding at the end the following3 7,c7 ,conditions of certification ,beginning #a year after the date of enactment of the ,,trust ,,it ,act1 the ,secretary shall require that each vendor of health information technology and entity seeking certification of health information technology1 as a condition of certification and maintenance of certification of such technology1 provide to the ,secretary an attestation that-- 7i7 the vendor or entity1 unless for a legitimate purpose specified by the ,secretary1 has not taken and will not take any action that constitutes information blocking with respect to health information technology2 7ii7 the vendor or entity will not engage in business practices or impose binding business relationship obligations that seek to intentionally limit communication between health information technology users and an authorized certification body regarding the usability1 interoperability1 security1 business practices1 or other relevant information about the health information technology or users' experience with the health information technology2 and 7iii7 health information from such technology may be exchanged1 accessed1 and used through the use of application programming interfaces and other standards without special effort1 as authorized under applicable law4 7,d7 ,inspector general authority 7i7 ,in general ,the ,inspector ,general of the ,department of ,health and ,human ,services may investigate any claim that-- 7,i7 a vendor of1 or other entity offering1 certified health information technology-- 7aa7 violated an attestation made under subparagraph 7,c72 or 7bb7 engaged in information blocking with respect to the use of such health information technology by a health care provider1 unless for a legitimate purpose specified by the ,secretary2 7,,ii7 a health care provider engaged in information blocking with respect to the use of certified health information technology1 unless for a legitimate purpose specified by the ,secretary2 7,,iii7 a health information system provider engaged in information blocking with respect to the use of such certified health information technology1 unless for a legitimate purpose specified by the ,secretary4 7ii7 ,penalty ,any person or entity determined by the ,inspector ,general to have committed an act described in subclause 7,i71 7,,ii71 or 7,,iii7 of clause 7i7 shall be subject to a civil monetary penalty of not more than #aj1jjj for each such act4 ,the provisions of section #aabh;,a of the ,social ,security ,act 7other than subsections 7a7 and 7b77 shall apply to a civil money penalty applied under this subsection in the same manner as such provisions apply to a civil money penalty or proceeding under section #aabh;,a7a74 4 #d4 ,health information technology rating program ,subtitle ,a of title ,,xxx of the ,public ,health ,service ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #cjj;jj-#aa et seq47 is amended by adding at the end the following3 #cjji;,a4 ,health information technology rating program 7a7 ,establishment ,not later than #ahj days after the date of enactment of the ,,trust ,,it ,act1 the ,secretary shall recognize a development council made up of one representative from each of the accredited certifying bodies accredited by the ,office and the testing laboratories accredited under section #acbja7;b7 of the ,health ,information ,technology for ,economic and ,clinical ,health ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #agiaa7;b771 and one representative from the ,office of the ,national ,coordinator1 for the purpose of establishing a health information technology rating program to evaluate1 based on the methodology established under subsection 7d71 the field performance of certified health information technology with regard to interoperability1 usability1 and security1 in accordance with the following3 7#a7 #a star rating ,certified health information technology shall receive a #a star rating if an authorized certification body determines that the health information technology is less than satisfactory4 7#b7 #b star rating ,certified health information technology shall receive a #b star rating if the authorized certification body determines that the health information technology is satisfactory4 7#c7 #c star rating ,certified health information technology shall receive a #c star rating if the authorized certification body determines that the health information technology is excellent4 7b7 ,reporting criteria 7#a7 ,not later than #a year after the date of enactment of the ,,trust ,,it ,act1 the ,secretary1 in consultation with the development council described in subsection 7a71 shall convene stakeholders as described in paragraph 7#b7 for the purpose of developing the reporting criteria in accordance with paragraph 7#c74 7#b7 ,development of reporting criteria ,the reporting criteria under this subsection shall be developed through a public1 transparent process that reflects input from relevant stakeholders1 including-- 7,a7 primary care and specialty care health care professionals2 7,b7 hospitals2 7,c7 health information technology vendors2 7,d7 advocates for patients or consumers2 7,e7 data sharing networks1 such as health information exchanges2 7,f7 authorized certification bodies and testing laboratories2 7,g7 security experts2 and 7,h7 other entities or persons1 as the ,secretary1 in consultation with the development council1 determines appropriate4 7#c7 ,considerations for reporting criteria ,the reporting criteria developed under this subsection-- 7,a7 may include measures that reflect categories including1 with respect to the technology-- 7i7 security2 7ii7 usability and user-centered design2 7iii7 interoperability2 7iv7 conformance to certification testing2 and 7v7 other categories as appropriate to measure the performance of health information technology2 7,b7 may include measures such as-- 7i7 enabling the user to order and view the results of laboratory tests1 imaging tests1 and other diagnostic tests2 7ii7 submitting1 editing1 and retrieving data from registries for quality of care1 such as physician registries2 7iii7 accessing and exchanging information and data from medical devices2 7iv7 accessing and exchanging information and data held by ,federal1 ,state1 and local agencies and other applicable entities useful to a health care provider or other applicable user in the furtherance of patient care2 7v7 accessing and exchanging information from other health care providers or applicable users2 7vi7 accessing and exchanging patient generated information2 7vii7 providing the patient with a complete copy of their electronic record in a computable format2 and 7viii7 other appropriate functionalities2 and 7,c7 shall be designed to ensure that small and start up vendors of health information technology are not unduly disadvantaged by the reporting criteria or rating scale methodology4 7#d7 ,public comment ,the ,secretary shall conduct a #fj-;day public comment period during which any member of the public may provide comments on the proposed reporting criteria and the methodology for authorized certification bodies to use in determining the star ratings4 ,the ,secretary shall provide timely responses to such comments before issuing a final rule4 7#e7 ,modifications ,after the reporting criteria have been established1 the ,secretary1 in consultation with the development council1 may convene stakeholders and conduct a public reporting period for the purpose of modifying the reporting criteria developed in this subsection and methodology for determining the star ratings proposed under subsection 7d74 7#f7 ,consideration of development council recommendations ,in promulgating final rules under this subsection1 including modifications to such rules under paragraph 7#e71 the ,secretary may accept or reject the recommendations of the development council1 but may not promulgate a rule that does not represent a complete recommendation of such council4 7c7 ,collection of feedback ,the ,secretary1 in consultation with the development council1 shall establish a process for authorized certification bodies to collect and verify confidential feedback from-- 7#a7 health care providers1 patients1 and other users of health information technology on the usability1 security1 and interoperability of health information technology products2 and 7#b7 vendors or other entities offering health information technology on practices of health information technology users that may inhibit interoperability4 7d7 ,methodology ,the ,secretary1 in consultation with the development council1 shall develop a methodology for authorized certification bodies to use to calculate the star ratings for certified health information technology described in subsection 7a74 ,the methodology shall use the reporting criteria developed in subsection 7b7 and confidential feedback collected under subsection 7c74 7e7 ,participation ,each vendor of1 or entity offering1 health information technology that is certified under section #cjja7;c77#e7 of the ,public ,health ,service ,act after the date of enactment of the ,,trust ,,it ,act shall report on the criteria developed under subsection 7b7 on the date that is #b years after such certification and every #b years thereafter4 7f7 ,one star rating ,each vendor of1 or entity offering1 health information technology that receives a #a star rating shall take action1 through a corrective action plan developed with the authorized certification body and approved by the ,secretary1 to improve the health information technology rating within a timeframe that the ,secretary determines appropriate4 7g7 ,enforcement authorities 7#a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary may assess fines on any vendor of1 or entity offering1 certified health information technology and decertify health information technology in accordance with paragraphs 7#b7 and 7#c74 7#b7 ,fines 7,a7 ,in general ,the ,secretary may assess fines against such a vendor or entity if the vendor or entity-- 7i7 does not meet the requirements of the corrective action plan described in subsection 7f72 7ii7 does not improve from a one star rating in accordance with subsection 7f72 or 7iii7 does not report on criteria in accordance with subsection 7e74 7,b7 ,fine amounts ,not later than #a year after the date of enactment of the ,,trust ,,it ,act1 the ,secretary shall establish fine amounts for violations of clauses 7i71 7ii71 and 7iii7 of subparagraph 7,a74 ,in setting such amounts1 the ,secretary shall consider the amounts necessary to reimburse1 in part or in full1 the users of decertified health information technology for the amounts invested in purchasing new certified health information technology1 as applicable4 7#c7 ,decertification ,the ,secretary may decertify health information technology if-- 7,a7 the health information technology does not improve from a one star rating within the timeframe established under subsection 7f72 7,b7 does not report on criteria in accordance with subsection 7b72 or 7,c7 in other circumstances1 as the ,secretary determines appropriate4 7h7 ,,gao reports ,the ,comptroller ,general of the ,united ,states shall submit to ,congress a report every #d years on the rating scale methodology developed pursuant to subsection 7b71 providing observations on the appropriateness of the current methodology and recommendations for changes to the methodology4 7i7 ,internet ,website ,the ,secretary shall publish the star rating for each certified health information technology and methodology to determine the star rating on the ,internet website of the ,office of the ,national ,coordinator4 ,following the biannual reporting described in subsection 7e71 authorized certified bodies shall have #cj days to calculate and submit updated ratings to the ,secretary1 and updated ratings shall be published on such ,internet website not later than #cj days following such submission4 7j7 ,user compensation fund ,the ,secretary shall establish a revolving user compensation fund in which amounts collected under subsection 7g77#b7 shall be directed and used to assist users of health information technology that are decertified under subsection 7g77#c7 to reimburse users for the costs of purchasing new certified health information technology products4 7k7 ,hardship exemption ,the ,secretary shall1 on a case-by-case basis1 exempt an eligible professional1 eligible hospital1 or critical access hospital from the application of the payment adjustment under the ,meaningful ,use of ,certified ,,ehr ,technology program under sections #ahdh7;a77#g77;,a71 #ahhf7;b77#c77;,b77ix77,i71 and #ahad7l77#d71 respectively1 of the ,social ,security ,act for #a year if the eligible professional1 eligible hospital1 or critical access hospital uses health information technology that becomes decertified under subsection 7g77#c71 to help such eligible professional1 eligible hospital1 or critical access hospital transition to a new certified electronic health record technology4 7l7 ,appeals ,the ,secretary shall establish a process whereby any vendor of1 or entity offering1 health information technology can appeal-- 7#a7 the health information technology product's star rating2 or 7#b7 the ,secretary's decision to decertify a product1 as applicable4 4 #e4 ,updating information on accessing personal health information ,subtitle ,a of title ,,xxx of the ,public ,health ,service ,act 7#db ,u4,s4,c4 #cjj;jj-#aa et seq471 as amended by section #d1 is further amended by adding at the end the following3 #cjji;,b4 ,updating information on accessing personal health information ,the ,national ,coordinator1 in consultation with the ,director of the ,office of ,civil ,rights1 shall1 as appropriate1 update the ,internet website of the ,office with information to assist individuals in understanding their rights to access and protect their personal health information under the ,health ,insurance ,portability and ,accountability ,act of #aiif 7,public ,law #ajd-aia71 including best practices for requesting their personal health information in a computable format and using patient portals1 among other information4 4