,,iv #aadth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,,res4 #ede ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,december #b1 #bjae ,mr4 ,franks of ,arizona 7for himself1 ,mr4 ,aderholt1 ,mr4 ,culberson1 ,mr4 ,wilson of ,south ,carolina1 ,mr4 ,gibbs1 ,mr4 ,walberg1 ,mr4 ,posey1 ,mr4 ,mulvaney1 ,mr4 ,gosar1 ,mr4 ,salmon1 ,mr4 ,pitts1 ,mrs4 ,blackburn1 ,mr4 ,cramer1 and ,mr4 ,smith of ,texas7 submitted the following resolution2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,rules ,,resolution ,calling for an end to the abuse of the ,standing ,rules of the ,senate and to improve the debate and consideration of legislative matters4 ,whereas the failure to pass critical1 overwhelmingly popular legislation in the ,united ,states ,senate has resulted from the current ,senate cloture rule and the practices of the ,senate related to debate2 ,whereas supermajority provisions of the ,senate cloture rule 7paragraphs #b and #c of rule ,,xxii71 commonly known as the ,senate filibuster rule1 are not contemplated by the ,united ,states ,constitution2 ,whereas the ,senate cloture rule and the practices of the ,senate related to starting and ending debate have evolved over time1 and resulted in the ,senate routinely being unable to reach a fair1 up or down vote on important matters1 even when a majority of the body wishes to do so2 ,whereas in the present day1 the ,senate has become debilitated by its rules1 practices1 and the operation of cloture2 ,whereas nearly all legislation today that cannot obtain unanimous consent faces a multistep procedural process gauntlet1 before ever having a chance for a real up or down vote2 ,whereas most significant legislation in the ,senate is called up and made pending before the ,senate only after cloture is invoked on a motion to proceed to consider it1 and subsequently1 another cloture motion must be filed to end debate on the legislation itself1 which means most legislation in the ,senate is subject to not one1 but at least two1 filibusters2 ,whereas the ,senate no longer only filibusters publicly 7by holding the floor in a traditional filibuster71 but it also does so1 privately1 by ,senators noticing with their leadership threats to filibuster1 which in effect invokes a secret or anonymous hold out of sight of the ,american people2 ,whereas it has become an increasingly common practice for ,senators to place anonymous holds on important business and threaten to filibuster without being required to physically and openly do so on the ,senate floor2 ,whereas even if a secret hold is resolved1 ,senate business can still be further delayed by a single ,senator openly objecting to a request to consider business on the ,senate floor in addition to other dilatory tactics or subsequent filibuster2 ,whereas in the early years of the ,senate there was no cloture rule or the concept of an anonymous hold1 as it conducted legislative business through serious consideration and accommodation for all ,senators1 before putting any matter to a vote2 ,whereas delaying legislative matters by use of the traditional hold the floor--standing ,senate filibuster--and other dilatory tactics--were not routinely used during the early years1 but eventually became common features used by ,senators to delay or prevent a vote on consequential legislation2 ,whereas in #aiag1 after a long series of deliberations in the ,senate by a group of ,senators that killed a bill that would have allowed ,president ,woodrow ,wilson to defend against ,german submarine warfare1 in the period leading up to ,united ,states involvement in ,world ,war ,i1 the ,democrat-controlled ,senate adopted the ,martin ,resolution1 the original cloture rule 7paragraph #b of rule ,,xxii71 permitting two-thirds of ,senators voting 7with a quorum present7 to bring debate to a close and proceed to a vote2 ,whereas in the lead-up to the establishment of the rule in #aiag1 ,president ,woodrow ,wilson responded and in his statement said1 ''' ,the ,senate of the ,united ,states is the only legislative body in the world which cannot act when its majority is ready for action4 ,a little group of willful men1 representing no opinion but their own1 have rendered the great ,government of the ,united ,states helpless and contemptible4 ,the remedy8 ,there is but one remedy4 ,the only remedy is that the rules of the ,senate shall be so altered that it can act4 ,the country can be relied upon to draw the moral4 ,i believe that the ,senate can be relied on to supply the means of action and save the country from disaster4 7#ee ,congressional ,record #bj72 ,whereas from #aiag-aifc1 totaling a span of #df years1 the ,senate managed to invoke cloture on only five occasions1 consequently during such time the ,senate filibuster and cloture rules were used to prevent the ,senate from passing critical bills that pertained to civil rights1 such as prohibiting lynching and poll taxes2 ,whereas in #aidf1 the ,senate failed to invoke cloture to abolish the poll tax--which maliciously required a tax to be paid in order to vote--when a large group of ,senate ,democrats 7#bf71 joined by #g ,senate ,republicans1 opposed ending debate2 ,whereas if the cloture rule had a threshold of simple majority for those ,senators voting and present1 the #aidf bill to end the poll tax would have been considered for a vote2 ,whereas in #aibb1 #aice1 and #aich1 the ,senate filibuster was used by a group of ,southern ,senators to defeat anti-lynching bills that centered on stopping horrific extrajudicial executions2 ,whereas in #aidi1 the ,democrat-controlled ,senate revised the cloture rule1 allowing the ,senate to invoke cloture on any measure or motion only if two-thirds of ,senators chosen and sworn voted in favor2 ,whereas the #aidi amendment meant that #b_/c or #fd ,senators affirming would be required to invoke cloture1 since there were a total of #if ,senators2 ,whereas while filibustering to deny rights to minority groups1 ,southern ,democrat ,senators used the ,senate filibuster1 arguing that it was a tool to protect minority rights2 ,whereas in #aiei1 the ,democrat ,majority ,leader1 ,senator ,lyndon ,b4 ,johnson of ,texas1 sponsored an amendment to paragraphs #b and #c of rule ,,xxii that reimplemented the requirement for two-thirds of ,senators voting 7with a quorum present7 to close debate2 ,whereas in #aige1 the ,democrat-controlled ,senate adopted the current cloture threshold1 lowering the #b_/c vote to a #c_/e vote of the full ,senate1 normally #fj1 to end debate2 ,whereas in #aigf1 the ,democrat-controlled ,senate amended the second sentence of the final paragraph of section #b of rule ,,xxii that regulated post-cloture consideration of amendments2 ,whereas in #aigi1 the ,democrat ,majority ,leader1 ,robert ,c4 ,byrd1 secured adoption of an amendment to paragraph #b of ,senate rule ,,xxii that further regulated post-cloture consideration of matters2 ,whereas in #aihf1 for the first time1 the ,republican-controlled ,senate adopted a resolution to govern the public broadcast of the chamber floor proceedings that reduced the time permitted for post cloture consideration of a measure or matter from #ajj hours to #cj hours2 ,whereas in the #aacth ,congress1 the ,democratic-controlled ,senate used the so-called nuclear option1 voting #eb-dh1 with all ,republicans and #c ,democrats voting against1 to reinterpret ,senate rule ,,xxii to provide for majority cloture on executive branch and judicial nominees other than to the ,supreme ,court2 ,whereas the #aiag cloture rule adoption1 its amendments in #aidi1 #aiei1 #aige1 and the new precedent1 the nuclear option in #bjac1 were engineered by ,senate ,democrats when they held the ,senate majority2 ,whereas in the #aadth ,congress1 the failure to invoke cloture and the ,senate's informal practice related to debate have stalemated the legislative process1 tabling the consideration of critical issues affecting the constitutional and national security of the ,nation2 ,whereas this year the failure to invoke cloture has delayed measures in the ,senate from reaching a fair1 up or down vote on matters of economic development and job growth1 securing the ,united ,states border1 protecting innocent life1 national security bills1 and the most important national security issue of our time1 the ,iranian ,nuclear ,deal2 ,whereas if the cloture rule had a threshold of a simple majority to start or end debate--#ea votes of the total ,senate--for those ,senators duly sworn and chosen1 legislation of the #aadth ,congress that passed the ,house of ,representatives1 which is supported by a majority of ,congress and an overwhelming majority of the ,american people1 would have reached a final vote in the ,senate2 ,whereas the ,american people are largely unaware of the esoteric practice of requiring the supermajority to allow a vote and therefore are unable to ascertain which parties or individuals are responsible for the actions or inactions of the ,senate and consequently accountability becomes dramatically reduced2 ,whereas the ,senate's cloture rule and practices related to debate have been the culpable restraints on any significant actions by this ,congress even when the majority wishes to act2 ,whereas the overall effect of the required supermajority for cloture is to shield from voter accountability actions or inactions in both the legislative and executive branches of ,government2 ,whereas the original intent of the adoption of the cloture rule in #aiag was to prevent unreasonable delay1 today it is used to actually create extended or permanent delay2 this violates the historical and original intent for the rule and in fact exacerbates the very problem it was originally intended to address2 and ,whereas the current cloture rule and the ,senate's informal and formal practices related to debate have ultimately subordinated the ,constitution of the ,united ,states itself3 ,now1 therefore1 be it ,that-- 7#a7 it is the sense of the ,house of ,representatives that the ,standing ,rules of the ,senate and debate practices should not be abused for the purpose of debilitating the ,senate and indefinitely blocking debate or a fair1 up or down vote on legislative matters2 7#b7 the ,house of ,representatives urges the ,senate to adopt a new precedent that would end the abuse of the ,standing ,rules of the ,senate and arduous practices related to debate in order to restore the daily workings of the ,senate1 in keeping with accountable debate such as the classic standing and talking filibuster2 7#c7 it is the sense of the ,house of ,representatives that after the ,senate sets a new precedent to restore its workings1 the ,senate should negotiate and adopt1 under its existing rules of a supermajority vote to invoke cloture1 a parliamentarian procedure to replace the cloture motion to call up legislation and make it pending before the ,senate1 with a non debatable motion to proceed to consider that allows for the minority to offer a reasonable number of germane amendments1 subject to debate1 once the measure is pending for consideration2 7#d7 the ,house of ,representatives further encourages the ,senate to forbid threats of a filibuster derived from an anonymous hold1 and in its place reinvigorate the traditional standing filibuster or hold the floor mechanism of dissent1 with a time allocation of up to #ajj hours and the ability to truncate debate only by a petition of #fj ,senators2 7#e7 it is the sense of the ,house of ,representatives that the proposed number of germane amendments and debate hours and mechanism to truncate debate described in paragraphs 7#c7 and 7#d71 respectively1 could be decreased or increased at the time that the rule change is negotiated and adopted1 ensuring the appropriate center between sufficient adversarial debate and the prevention of chronic stalemate is both a ,senate majority and minority determination2 7#f7 the ,house of ,representatives believes that these proposed changes to the ,standing ,rules of the ,senate and debate practices shall-- 7,a7 reestablish deliberation in the world's most deliberative body1 as intended by the ,united ,states of ,america's founding fathers2 7,b7 allow the ,senate to meet its constitutional responsibilities in a timely fashion and effectively respond to national needs2 7,c7 enhance our democratic system and the attending processes that clearly1 specifically and accurately assign official actions of representatives and parties accordingly so that accountability is clearly delineated2 and 7,d7 encompasses a strong incentive to reach consensus in the ,senate and still preserve the minority's opportunity to have enhanced objection and reasonable leverage against any overreach on the part of the majority or if the minority feels further debate and clarity on a given agenda item is particularly important to the country2 and 7#g7 it is the sense of the ,house of ,representatives that nothing in this resolution-- 7,a7 shall be construed as the ,house of ,representatives advocating a wholesale abolishment of a ,senate filibuster mechanism or supermajority cloture requirement2 or 7,b7 shall be construed as the ,house of ,representatives calling for the classic standing and talking ,senate filibuster to be abolished2 on the contrary1 the ,house believes it should be reinvigorated4