,i #aadth ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,r4 #fahc ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,september #bg1 #bjaf,mr4 ,pascrell 7for himself and ,mr4 ,jones7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,ways and ,means ,a ,,bill ,to neutralize the discriminatory effect of any country that employs indirect taxes and grants rebates of the same upon export if ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment are not met4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,border ,tax ,equity ,act of #bjaf4 #b4 ,findings and declarations of policy 7a7 ,findings ,congress makes the following findings3 7#a7 ,the ,united ,states largely relies on a direct tax system1 whereas #afd countries currently employ one particular form of indirect tax known as value-added taxes 7,,vat7 as well as direct taxes4 ,the worldwide ,,vat average in #bjae was #ae percent1 and in countries of the ,european ,union it was #ba percent4 7#b7 ,under the rules of the ,world ,trade ,organization 7,,wto71 direct taxes1 such as corporate income taxes1 if rebated or refunded upon the export of goods1 are viewed as export subsidies and prohibited on most goods and are at least potentially actionable on all goods4 ,however1 indirect taxes1 such as sales taxes and ,,vat1 may be rebated or refunded upon the export of goods and such rebate or refund is not defined as constituting a subsidy and hence is not actionable under ,,wto rules4 7#c7 ,at present1 there are no ,,wto rules on subsidies as applied to trade in services4 ,however1 a number of countries currently impose taxes on the import of services and exempt or rebate or refund taxes upon the export of services1 to the disadvantage of ,united ,states service providers4 7#d7 ,the disparate treatment of border taxes detrimentally affects ,united ,states agricultural producers1 manufacturers1 and service providers in that-- 7,a7 refunds of indirect taxes effectively act as export subsidies to foreign exporters2 and 7,b7 ,united ,states exporters are subject to double taxation1 by paying direct taxes on domestic production in the ,united ,states and having their exported product or service face a border tax in the importing country consisting of indirect taxes4 7#e7 ,as one example1 governments of member states of the ,european ,union1 with an average ,,vat of #ba percent in #bjae and total exports to the ,united ,states of #dbg4e billion1 paid their producers an estimated #ia4i billion of ,,vat rebates on goods exported to the ,united ,states in #bjae4 ,these governments collected from ,united ,states producers an estimated #bh4g billion of ,,vat-equivalent taxes on their imported goods4 ,for services1 these governments paid their producers an estimated #dg4f billion of ,,vat-equivalent taxes on services exported to the ,united ,states and collected from ,united ,states producers an estimated #cf4c billion of ,,vat-equivalent taxes on services imported from the ,united ,states4 ,the combined goods and services disadvantage in #bjae was #bjd billion4 7#f7 ,for more than #de years1 ,united ,states businesses have complained of border tax inequity and1 since #aifh1 prior ,united ,states administrations and ,congresses have sought to resolve it4 7#g7 ,congress has repeatedly recognized the prejudicial effect of the disparate treatment of border taxes with respect to goods and has directed the ,united ,states to seek a negotiated solution3 7,a7 ,in passing the ,trade ,act of #aigd 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #baja et seq471 ,congress sought revision of ,,gatt articles with respect to the treatment of border adjustments for international taxes to redress the disadvantage to countries relying primarily on direct rather than indirect taxes for revenue needs44 7,b7 ,in section #aaja7;b77#af7 of the ,omnibus ,trade and ,competitiveness ,act of #aihh 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #bija7;b77#af771 section #bajb7;b77#ae7 of ,bipartisan ,trade ,promotion ,authority ,act of #bjjb 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #chjb7;b77#ae771 and section #ajb7;b77#ah7 of the ,bipartisan ,congressional ,trade ,priorities and ,accountability ,act of #bjae 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #dbja7;b77#ah77 ,congress declared that a principal trade negotiating objective of the ,united ,states is to obtain a revision of ,,wto rules with respect to the treatment of border adjustments for internal taxes to redress the disadvantage to countries relying primarily on direct taxes for revenue rather than indirect taxes4 7#h7 ,the disparate treatment of border taxes is arbitrary1 inequitable1 causes economic distortions based only on the type of tax system used by a country1 and is a primary obstacle to more balanced trade relations between the ,united ,states and its major trading partners4 7b7 ,declarations of policy ,congress declares the following3 7#a7 ,it is critically necessary that the issue of border taxes be addressed and resolved during current and future ,,wto negotiations4 7#b7 ,if such ,,wto negotiations fail to achieve the ,united ,states trade negotiating objective of revising rules with respect to the treatment of border taxes in order to redress the disadvantage to countries relying primarily on direct taxes for revenue rather than indirect taxes1 then effective action through legislation is warranted given the massive and inequitable distortions to trade that ,united ,states agricultural producers1 manufacturers1 and service providers face as a result of border taxes4 #c4 ,reports on results of ,,wto negotiations to revise ,,wto rules regarding border taxes and free trade agreements regarding border taxes 7a7 ,report on results of ,,wto negotiations ,to revise ,,wto rules regarding border taxes 7#a7 ,report required ,not later than #fj days after the completion of ,,wto negotiations1 or by ,january #a1 #bjah1 whichever occurs first1 the ,united ,states ,trade ,representative shall submit to ,congress a report certifying whether or not each of the ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment1 as specified in paragraph 7#b71 has been met as a result of such negotiations4 7#b7 ,u4,s4 trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment specified ,the ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment specified in this paragraph are the following3 7,a7 ,with respect to trade in goods1 the revision of ,,wto rules with respect to the treatment of border adjustments for internal taxes to redress the disadvantage to countries relying primarily on direct taxes for revenue rather than indirect taxes1 as provided for in section #ajb7;b77#ah7 of the ,bipartisan ,congressional ,trade ,priorities and ,accountability ,act of #bjae 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #dbja7;b77#ah774 7,b7 ,with respect to trade in services-- 7i7 the elimination of the disadvantage in trade in services that exists for countries relying primarily on direct taxes that are not adjusted at the border rather than indirect taxes that are adjusted at the border2 and 7ii7 the revision of ,,wto rules regarding trade in services to ensure that such rules do not result in disparate treatment of border adjustments for internal taxes based on the direct or indirect nature of such taxes4 7#c7 ,definition ,in this subsection1 the terms ,,wto negotiations and negotiations mean any ,world ,trade ,organization negotiations that may result in revisions to ,,wto rules to meet the ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment1 as specified in paragraph 7#b74 7b7 ,report on free trade agreements regarding border taxes 7#a7 ,report required ,not later than one year after the date of the enactment of this ,act1 the ,united ,states ,trade ,representative shall submit to ,congress a report certifying whether or not each covered country that is a party to a multilateral1 bilateral1 and regional trade agreement that has entered into force on or before such date of enactment with respect to the ,united ,states and such covered country is taking or has taken the actions regarding border tax treatment1 as specified in paragraph 7#b74 7#b7 ,actions regarding border tax treatment specified ,the actions regarding border tax treatment specified in this paragraph are the following3 7,a7 ,with respect to trade in goods1 the revision of laws of the covered country with respect to the treatment of border adjustments for internal taxes to redress the disadvantage to countries relying primarily on direct taxes for revenue rather than indirect taxes4 7,b7 ,with respect to trade in services-- 7i7 the elimination of the disadvantage in trade in services that exists for countries relying primarily on direct taxes that are not adjusted at the border rather than indirect taxes that are adjusted at the border2 and 7ii7 the revision of laws of the covered country regarding trade in services to ensure that such laws do not result in disparate treatment of border adjustments for internal taxes based on the direct or indirect nature of such taxes4 7#c7 ,definition ,in this subsection1 the term covered country means a country that relies primarily on indirect taxes that are adjusted at the border rather than direct taxes that are not adjusted at the border4 #d4 ,tax on imports from foreign countries with an indirect tax system 7a7 ,in general ,subtitle ,d of chapter #cf of the ,internal ,revenue ,code 7#bf ,u4,s4,c4 #ddfa et seq47 is amended by adding at the end the following new subchapter3 ,e ,tax on ,imports ,from ,foreign ,countries ,with ,an ,indirect ,tax ,system ,sec4 #ddia4 ,imposition of tax4 #ddia4 ,imposition of tax 7a7 ,general rule ,there is hereby imposed a tax on imports of goods and services from any foreign country that employs an indirect tax system and grants rebates of indirect taxes paid on goods or services exported from that country4 7b7 ,amount of tax ,the amount of the tax imposed by subsection 7a7 on an imported good or service shall be an amount equal to the excess of-- 7#a7 the indirect taxes that are rebated or not paid on the good or service upon its export1 over 7#b7 any indirect taxes imposed on the good or service at the border of the ,united ,states4 7c7 ,liability and time of imposition of tax 7#a7 ,liability ,the tax imposed by subsection 7a7 on a good or service shall be paid by the importer of such good or service4 7#b7 ,time of imposition ,the tax imposed by subsection 7a7 shall be imposed on imports at the time of entry4 7d7 ,period of ,applicability ,the tax imposed by subsection 7a7 shall apply during the period beginning as prescribed in section #f7a7 of the ,border ,tax ,equity ,act of #bjaf and ending on the date on which the ,united ,states ,trade ,representative certifies to ,congress that the ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives of equitable border tax treatment have been met4 7e7 ,special account ,the tax on imports under subsection 7a7 shall be collected by ,u4,s4 ,customs and ,border ,protection and deposited into a special account4 ,this special account shall be the source of payments to qualified ,united ,states exporters under section #cad of the ,tariff ,act of #aicj4 7f7 ,definitions ,for purposes of this subchapter-- 7#a7 ,importer ,the term importer means-- 7,a7 as such term relates to imports of goods1 one of the parties eligible to file the required customs entry documentation or information pursuant to section #dhd7;a77#b77;,b7 of the ,tariff ,act of #aicj 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #adhd7;a77#b77;,b771 and 7,b7 as such term relates to imports of services1 the importer of the service as defined by the ,secretary in rules and regulations promulgated under this subchapter4 7#b7 ,time of entry ,the term time of entry means-- 7,a7 as relates to imports of goods1 the time generally specified in section #dhd7;a77#b77;,a7 of the ,tariff ,act of #aicj 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #adhd7;a77#b77;,a77 and prescribed in regulations 7#ai ,c4,f4,r4 #ada4fh71 and 7,b7 as relates to imports of services1 the time specified by the ,secretary in rules and regulations promulgated under this subchapter4 7#c7 ,indirect tax system and grants rebates of indirect taxes ,a foreign country employs an indirect tax system and grants rebates of indirect taxes paid on goods or services exported from that country if such country imposes indirect taxes 7including sales taxes and value-added taxes 7,,vat77 on goods or services1 and permits a rebate of such indirect taxes paid on goods or services exported from such country4 7#d7 ,value-added taxes 7vat7 ,the term value-added taxes means an indirect general consumption tax that is levied by the exporting country on the value added to goods and services in that country at multiple stages of the production and supply chain4 ,this type of tax is also referred to as a goods and services tax 7,,gst74 7g7 ,regulations ,the ,secretary may prescribe such rules and regulations as are necessary to carry out this section4 4 7b7 ,clerical amendment ,the table of subchapters for subtitle ,d of chapter #cf of such ,code is amended by adding at the end of the following new item3 ,subchapter ,e4 ,tax on ,imports ,from ,foreign ,countries ,with an ,indirect ,tax ,system 4 #e4 ,payments to ,united ,states exporters to neutralize discriminatory effect of border taxes imposed by importing countries ,part ,,ii of title ,,iii of the ,tariff ,act of #aicj 7#ai ,u4,s4,c4 #acje et seq47 is amended by inserting after section #cac the following3 #cad4 ,payments to ,united ,states exporters to neutralize discriminatory effect of border taxes imposed by importing countries 7a7 ,payments required 7#a7 ,in general ,upon exportation of goods or services from the ,united ,states to any foreign country that employs an indirect tax system and imposes or applies indirect taxes on imports of goods or services at the border1 the ,secretary of the ,treasury1 acting through the ,commissioner of ,u4,s4 ,customs and ,border ,protection1 shall1 if requested by the exporter1 pay to the exporter an amount equal to the amount of indirect taxes that the importing foreign country imposes or applies at the border to such goods or services1 minus any ,united ,states taxes paid on such goods or services that have been rebated or funded upon exportation4 7#b7 ,information to be included in request ,an exporter who requests a payment under paragraph 7#a7 shall1 in such request1 identify the indirect taxes imposed by the importing foreign country and present proof of the payment of such taxes to the importing foreign country's authorities within a reasonable period of time after exportation of the goods or services4 7b7 ,special account ,the payments required under subsection 7a7 shall be paid from amounts contained in the special account authorized under section #ddia7;e7 of the ,internal ,revenue ,code of #aihf4 7c7 ,period of ,applicability ,the requirement to make payments under subsection 7a7 shall apply during the period beginning as prescribed in section #f7b7 of the ,border ,tax ,equity ,act of #bjaf and ending on the date on which the ,united ,states ,trade ,representative certifies to ,congress that each of the ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment have been met4 7d7 ,regulations ,the ,secretary of the ,treasury is authorized to prescribe such rules and regulations as are necessary to carry out the provisions of this section4 7e7 ,definitions ,in this section3 7#a7 ,indirect tax system and imposes or applies indirect taxes on imports of goods or services at the border ,a foreign country employs an indirect tax system and imposes or applies indirect taxes on imports of goods or services at the border if such country imposes indirect taxes 7including sales tax and value-added taxes 7,,vat77 on goods or services1 and imposes or applies such indirect taxes on imports of goods or services at the border4 7#b7 ,value-added taxes 7vat7 ,the term value-added taxes means an indirect general consumption tax that is levied by the exporting country on the value added to goods and services in that country at multiple stages of the production and supply chain4 ,this type of tax is also referred to as a goods and services tax 7,,gst74 4 #f4 ,effective dates ,if1 pursuant to subsection 7a77#a7 of section #c of this ,act1 the ,united ,states ,trade ,representative fails to certify to ,congress by the date specified in such subsection that each of the ,united ,states trade negotiating objectives regarding border tax treatment described in section 7a77#b7 of such section has been met as a result of ,,wto negotiations1 then-- 7#a7 section #ddia of the ,internal ,revenue ,code of #aihf1 as added by section #d of this ,act1 shall take effect #ij days after such date2 and 7#b7 section #cad of the ,tariff ,act of #aicj1 as added by section #e of this ,act1 shall take effect #abj days after such date4