,i #aadth ,,congress #b;d ,session ,h4 ,r4 #dgcg ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,march #ad1 #bjaf ,mr4 ,mulvaney introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on ,financial ,services ,a ,,bill ,to protect ,state and ,tribal sovereignty from unwarranted infringement by an independent agency of the ,federal ,government by requiring the ,bureau of ,consumer ,financial ,protection to justify certain proposals to preempt ,state and ,tribal law1 and for other purposes4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,state and ,tribal ,government ,sovereignty ,protection ,act of #bjaf4 #b4 ,findings ,the ,congress finds the following3 7#a7 ,the people of the ,states created the national government when they delegated to it those enumerated governmental powers relating to matters beyond the competence of the individual ,states4 ,all other sovereign powers1 save those expressly prohibited the ,states by the ,constitution1 are reserved to the ,states or the people4 7#b7 ,in most areas of governmental concern1 the ,states uniquely possess the constitutional authority1 the resources1 and the competence to discern the sentiments of the people and to govern accordingly4 7#c7 ,our constitutional system encourages a healthy diversity in the public policies adopted by the people of the several ,states according to their own conditions1 needs1 and desires4 ,individual ,states and communities are free to experiment with a variety of approaches to public issues4 ,one-size-fits-all approaches to public policy problems can inhibit the creation of effective solutions to problems4 7#d7 ,federal action limiting the policymaking discretion of the ,states should be taken only where constitutional and statutory authority for the action is clear and certain and the national activity is necessitated by the presence of a problem of national scope4 7#e7 ,federal agencies must recognize the distinction between problems of national scope 7which may justify ,federal action7 and problems that are merely common to the ,states 7which will not justify ,federal action because individual ,states1 acting individually or together1 can effectively deal with them74 7#f7 ,on ,march #bf1 #bjae1 the ,bureau of ,consumer ,financial ,protection released an outline of proposals under consideration for potential rulemakings for payday1 vehicle title1 and similar loans4 7#g7 ,the ,bureau acknowledged that markets for payday1 vehicle title1 and similar loans are regulated by a variety of state laws1 as well as some tribal and municipal laws4 ,the ,bureau specifically acknowledged that ,some jurisdictions have imposed usury limits that prohibit lenders from offering high-cost credit4 ,in other jurisdictions1 certain products are specifically authorized by state laws1 often crafted as exceptions to general state credit regulation1 including consumer loan laws and general usury limits4 ,some of the states authorizing these products have sought to regulate loan structures and lender practices in a variety of ways1 including limiting permissible costs1 restricting reborrowing in certain circumstances1 or setting a maximum ratio for the amount of debt on such loans to gross monthly income4 ,states1 tribes1 and local governments also impose a variety of licensure requirements on lenders engaged in payday and vehicle title lending44 ,this variation in ,state1 local1 and tribal law suggests a healthy1 dynamic1 legal environment in which the democratically elected representatives in each jurisdiction respond appropriately to the particular conditions1 needs1 and desires of their constituents4 7#h7 ,notwithstanding the foregoing1 the ,director of the ,bureau seeks to establish a federal floor for consumer protection for covered loans1 thus substituting the ,director's own judgment for that of ,state1 tribal1 and local governments4 7#i7 ,the ,bureau made no showing that any ,state or tribal government lacks the legal authority to enact laws or regulations that are substantially similar to the ,bureau's outline of proposals4 7#aj7 ,the ,bureau made no showing that any ,state or tribal government is incapable of protecting its citizens from potential risks associated with using payday1 vehicle title1 and similar loans4 7#aa7 ,the ,bureau's proposals1 if implemented1 would be an unwarranted infringement of ,state and tribal sovereignty and a violation of fundamental federalist principles designed to secure the liberty of the ,american people4 #c4 ,moratorium 7a7 ,prohibition on payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 and other similar loan regulations ,the ,bureau of ,consumer ,financial ,protection may not issue or enforce any rule or regulation with respect to payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 or other similar loans during the #bd-month period beginning on the date of enactment of this ,act4 7b7 ,payday loan ,for purposes of this section the term payday loan means a loan described under section #ajbd7;a77#a77;,e7 of the ,consumer ,financial ,protection ,act of #bjaj 7#ab ,u4,s4,c4 #eead7;a77#a77;,e774 #d4 ,protecting ,state and tribal government sovereignty ,section #ajbb7;b7 of the ,consumer ,financial ,protection ,act of #bjaj 7#ab ,u4,s4,c4 #eeab7;b77 is amended by adding at the end the following3 7#e7 ,protecting ,state and tribal government sovereignty with respect to payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 and other similar loans 7,a7 ,in general ,notwithstanding any other provision of law1 the ,bureau may not issue any final rule or regulation to regulate payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 or other similar loans1 unless the ,bureau first-- 7i7 consults with appropriate ,state1 tribal1 and local officials in each jurisdiction that may be affected by the rule regarding the effect of the rule on ,state1 tribal1 or local sovereignty1 laws1 regulations1 and citizens2 7ii7 carries out a study that-- 7,i7 examines the ,bureau's constitutional and statutory authority to preempt ,state1 tribal1 and local laws and regulations2 7,,ii7 examines the effect the rule or regulation will have on the laws and regulations of individual ,states1 federally recognized ,indian tribes1 and municipalities2 and 7,,iii7 identifies alternative proposals to mitigate potential risks associated with using payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 and other similar loans without infringing upon ,state and tribal sovereignty or preempting ,state and tribal laws and regulations2 and 7iii7 issues a public report that-- 7,i7 contains all findings and determinations made by the ,bureau in carrying out such study2 7,,ii7 addresses all comments and advice received during consultation with ,state1 tribal1 and local officials2 7,,iii7 lists each ,state1 tribal1 or local law and regulation 7or any portion thereof7 the ,bureau proposes to preempt by rule or regulation2 7,,iv7 identifies by name any ,state or federally recognized ,indian tribe that lacks the legal authority to enact laws or regulations that are substantially similar to the rule or regulation1 and states the basis for why the ,bureau has determined that the ,state or federally recognized ,indian tribe lacks such authority2 and 7,v7 identifies by name any ,state or federally recognized ,indian tribe the ,director believes is incapable of protecting its citizens from potential risks associated with using payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 and other similar loans1 and states the basis for why the ,bureau has determined that the ,state or federally recognized ,indian tribe is incapable of such protection4 7,b7 ,waiver for ,state and tribal governments 7i7 ,in general ,with respect to a final rule or regulation issued by the ,bureau to regulate payday loans1 vehicle title loans1 or other similar loans1 if a ,state or a federally recognized ,indian tribe requests1 in writing1 for the ,bureau to provide the ,state or tribe with a waiver from such rule or regulation1 the ,director shall grant a #e-year waiver to such ,state or tribe1 during which such rule or regulation shall not apply within such ,state or land held in trust for the benefit of such federally recognized ,indian tribe4 7ii7 ,right to renew waiver ,a ,state or federally recognized ,indian tribe granted a waiver under clause 7i7 shall have the right to renew such waiver at the end of each #e-year waiver period4 4