,,iv  #aac? ,,congress  #a/ ,session    
,h4 ,,res4 #aec  ,,9 ,,! ,,h\se ,,(     
,,repres5tatives  ,april #ab1 #bjac ,mr4
 ,franks ( ,arizona 7= himself1 ,mr4    
,gohm]t1 ,mr4 ,salmon1 ,mr4 ,/ockman1   
,mr4 ,bonn]1 ,mr4 ,coble1 ,mr4 ,pitts1  
,mr4 ,mc,clintock1 ,mr4 ,%imkus1 ,mr4   
,campbell1 ,mr4 ,flem+1 ,mr4 ,we/morel&1
 ,mr4 ,smi? ( ,new ,j]sey1 ,mr4         
,williams1 ,mrs4 ,ba*mann1 ,mr4 ,g>rett1
 ,mr4 ,c>t]1 ,mr4 ,sam ,johnson (       
,texas1 ,mr4 ,s*weik]t1 & ,mr4 ,issa7   
submitt$ ! foll[+ resolution2 :i* 0     
ref]r$ to ! ,committee on ,ways & ,means
  ,,resolution  ,express+ ! s5se ( !    
,h\se ( ,repres5tatives t ! ,pati5t     
,protection & ,af=dable ,c>e ,act (     
#bjji violates article ,i1 section #g1  
clause #a ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,con/itution
 because x 0 a ,bill = rais+ ,rev5ue t  
did n orig9ate 9 ! ,h\se (              
,repres5tatives4  ,:]eas article ,i1    
section #g1 clause #a ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates 
,con/itution provides t1 ,all ,bills =  
rais+ ,rev5ue %all orig9ate 9 ! ,h\se ( 

,repres5tatives2 ,:]eas1 on ,june #bh1  
#bjab1 a majority ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates     
,supreme ,c\rt held t ! individual m&ate
 provision ( ! ,pati5t ,protection &    
,af=dable ,c>e ,act ( #bjji _c be upheld
 z an ex]cise ( ,congress's p[] "u !    
,comm]ce ,clause b 0 )9 ,congress's p[] 
to tax2 ,:]eas ! ,pati5t ,protection &  
,af=dable ,c>e ,act ( #bjji 0 orig9ally 
introduc$ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ,congress by
 its sponsor z ! ,s5ate heal? c>e bill 9
 ! =m ( a ,s5ate ,am5dm5t to ,h4,r4     
#ceij1 :i* _h pass$ ! ,h\se (           
,repres5tatives by a vote ( #daf-j z !  
,s]vice ,memb]s ,home ,own]%ip ,tax ,act
 ( #bjji2 ,:]eas !re is ample evid5ce t 
! sponsors ( ! ,s5ate heal? c>e bill n  
only contemplat$ ! possibility (        
sub/antial excess rev5ues1 b explicitly 
ann\nc$ on its ,s5ate introduction t1   
,?is bill w cut ! deficit by #acj       
billion2 ,:]eas section #aefc ( ! ,s5ate
 am5d$ ,h4,r4 #ceij explicitly /at$ t x 
0 ! ,s5se ( ! ,s5ate t ?is ,act w r$uce 
! ,f$]al deficit betwe5 #bjaj & #bjai1 &

 ?is ,act w cont9ue to r$uce budget     
deficits aft] #bjai42 & ,:]eas ! ,s5ate 
heal? c>e bill t ! ,presid5t ultimately 
sign$ z ,h4,r4 #ceij conta9s #ag numb]$ 
,rev5ue ,provisions1 none ( :i* are     
g]mane to ! subject matt] ( ! orig9al   
,h4,r4 #ceij1 & no?+ else 9 ! ,s5ate    
heal? c>e bill 0 g]mane to ! subject    
matt] ( ,h4,r4 #ceij3 ,n[1 !re=e1 be x  
,t x is ! s5se ( ! ,h\se (              
,repres5tatives t--  7#a7 ! ,pati5t     
,protection & ,af=dable ,c>e ,act (     
#bjji 0 a ,bill = rais+ ,rev5ue z ^?    
words 7 int5d$ to be und]/ood 9 article 
,i1 section #g1 clause #a ( ! ,unit$    
,/ates ,con/itution2 &  7#b7 ! ,pati5t  
,protection & ,af=dable ,c>e ,act (     
#bjji did n orig9ate 9 ! ,h\se (        
,repres5tatives4