,i #aacth ,,congress #ast ,session ,h4 ,r4 #cccb ,,in ,,the ,,house ,,of ,,representatives ,october #bc1 #bjac,mr4 ,nadler 7for himself1 ,mr4 ,petri1 ,mr4 ,conyers1 ,mr4 ,de,fazio1 ,mr4 ,holt1 ,ms4 ,lee of ,california1 ,mr4 ,van ,hollen1 ,ms4 ,lofgren1 and ,mr4 ,mc,clintock7 introduced the following bill2 which was referred to the ,committee on the ,judiciary ,a ,,bill ,to provide safe1 fair1 and responsible procedures and standards for resolving claims of state secret privilege4 #a4 ,short title ,this ,act may be cited as the ,state ,secrets ,protection ,act4 #b4 ,state secret privilege ,in any civil action brought in ,federal or ,state court1 the ,government has a privilege to refuse to give information and to prevent any person from giving information only if the ,government shows that public disclosure of the information that the ,government seeks to protect would be reasonably likely to cause significant harm to the national defense or the diplomatic relations of the ,united ,states4 #c4 ,protection of secrets 7a7 ,in general ,the court shall take steps to protect sensitive information that comes before the court in connection with proceedings under this ,act4 ,these steps may include reviewing evidence or pleadings and hearing arguments ex parte1 issuing protective orders1 placing material under seal1 and applying security procedures established under the ,classified ,information ,procedures ,act for classified information to protect the sensitive information4 7b7 ,in camera proceedings ,all hearings and other proceedings under this ,act may be conducted in camera1 as needed to protect information that may be subject to the privilege4 7c7 ,participation of counsel ,participation of counsel in proceedings under this ,act may be limited if the court determines that the limitation is a necessary step to protect information the ,government asserts is protected by the privilege or that supports the claim of privilege4 7d7 ,guardian ad litem ,where counsel is excluded from a proceeding1 the court shall have discretion to appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the absent litigant's interests1 drawing1 in consultation with the excluded nongovernmental party1 from a previously generated list of attorneys who have been granted required security clearances in the past and have agreed to serve in this capacity4 ,the guardian ad litem shall not discuss the information claimed as privileged or its content with any nongovernmental party or nongovernmental party's counsel4 7e7 ,production of adequate substitute pending resolution of the claim of privilege ,if1 at any point during its consideration of the ,government's claim1 the court determines that disclosure of information to a party or counsel1 or disclosure of information by a party that already possesses it1 presents a risk of a harm described in subsection 7a7 that cannot be addressed through less restrictive means provided in this subsection1 the court may require the ,government to produce an adequate substitute1 such as a redacted version1 summary of the information1 or stipulation regarding the relevant facts1 if the court deems such a substitute feasible4 ,the substitute must be reviewed and approved by the court and must provide counsel with a substantially equivalent opportunity to assess and challenge the ,government's claim of privilege as would the protected information4 #d4 ,assertion of the privilege 7a7 ,in general ,the ,government may assert the privilege in connection with any claim in a civil action to which it is a party or may intervene in a civil action to which it is not a party to do so4 7b7 ,supporting affidavits ,if the ,government asserts the privilege1 the ,government shall provide the court with an affidavit signed by the head of the executive branch agency with responsibility for1 and control over1 the information asserted to be subject to the privilege4 ,in the affidavit1 the head of the agency shall explain the factual basis for the claim of privilege4 ,the ,government shall make public an unclassified version of the affidavit4 #e4 ,preliminary proceedings 7a7 ,preliminary review by court ,once the ,government has asserted the privilege1 and before the court makes any determinations under section #f1 the court shall undertake a preliminary review of the information the ,government asserts is protected by the privilege and provide the ,government an opportunity to seek protective measures under this ,act4 ,after any initial protective measures are in place1 the court shall proceed to the consideration of additional preliminary matters under this section4 7b7 ,consideration of whether ,to appoint special master or expert witness ,the court shall consider whether the appointment of a special master with appropriate expertise or an expert witness1 or both1 would facilitate the court's duties under this ,act4 7c7 ,index of materials ,the court may order the ,government to provide a manageable index of the information that the ,government asserts is subject to the privilege4 ,the index must correlate statements made in the affidavit required under this ,act with portions of the information the ,government asserts is subject to the privilege4 ,the index shall be specific enough to afford the court an adequate foundation to review the basis of the assertion of the privilege by the ,government4 7d7 ,prehearing conferences ,after the preliminary review1 the court shall hold one or more conferences with the parties to-- 7#a7 determine any steps needed to protect sensitive information2 7#b7 define the issues presented by the ,government's claim of privilege1 including whether it is possible to allow the parties to complete nonprivileged discovery before determining whether the claim of privilege is valid2 7#c7 order disclosure to the court of anything needed to assess the claim1 including all information the ,government asserts is protected by the privilege and other material related to the ,government's claim2 7#d7 resolve any disputes regarding participation of counsel or parties in proceedings relating to the claim1 including access to the ,government's evidence and arguments2 7#e7 set a schedule for completion of discovery related to the ,government's claim2 and 7#f7 take other steps as needed1 such as ordering counsel or parties to obtain security clearances4 #f4 ,procedures and standard for assessing the privilege claim 7a7 ,hearing ,the court shall conduct a hearing to determine whether the privilege claim is valid4 7b7 ,basis for ruling 7#a7 ,generally ,the court may not determine that the privilege is valid until the court has reviewed-- 7,a7 except as provided in paragraph 7#b71 all of the information that the ,government asserts is privileged2 7,b7 the affidavits1 evidence1 memoranda and other filings submitted by the parties related to the privilege claim2 and 7,c7 any other evidence that the court determines it needs to rule on the privilege4 7#b7 ,sampling in certain cases ,where the volume of information the ,government asserts is privileged precludes a timely review1 or the court otherwise determines a review of all of that information is not feasible1 the court may substitute a sufficient sampling of the information if the court determines that there is no reasonable possibility that review of the additional information would change the court's determination on the privilege claim and the information reviewed is sufficient to enable the court to make the independent assessment required by this section4 7c7 ,standard ,in ruling on the validity of the privilege1 the court shall make an independent assessment of whether the harm identified by the ,government1 as required by section #b1 is reasonably likely to occur should the privilege not be upheld4 ,the court shall weigh testimony from ,government experts in the same manner as it does1 and along with1 any other expert testimony4 7d7 ,burden of proof ,the ,government shall have the burden of proof as to the nature of the harm and as to the likelihood of its occurrence4 #g4 ,effect of court determination 7a7 ,in general ,if the court determines that the privilege is not validly asserted1 the court shall issue appropriate orders regarding the disclosure of the information to a nongovernmental party and its admission at trial1 subject to the other rules of evidence1 with the right to interlocutory appeal as provided in section #h for any such orders4 ,if the court determines that the privilege is validly asserted1 that information shall not be disclosed to a nongovernmental party or the public4 7b7 ,nonprivileged substitute 7#a7 ,court consideration of substitute ,if the court finds that the privilege is validly asserted and it is possible to craft a nonprivileged substitute1 such as those described in section #c7;e71 for the privileged information that would provide the parties a substantially equivalent opportunity to litigate the case1 the court shall order the ,government to produce the substitute to the satisfaction of the court4 7#b7 ,refusal to provide ,in a civil action brought against the ,government1 if the court orders the ,government to provide a nonprivileged substitute for information and the ,government fails to comply1 in addition to any other appropriate sanctions1 the court shall find against the ,government on the factual or legal issue to which the privileged information is relevant4 ,if the action is not brought against the ,government1 the court shall weigh the equities and make appropriate orders as provided in subsection 7d74 7c7 ,opportunity ,to complete discovery ,the court shall not resolve any issue or claim and shall not grant a motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment based on the state secrets privilege and adversely to any party against whom the ,government's privilege claim has been upheld until that party has had a full opportunity to complete nonprivileged discovery and to litigate the issue or claim to which the privileged information is relevant without regard to that privileged information4 7d7 ,appropriate orders in the interest of justice ,after reviewing all available evidence1 and only after determining that privileged information1 for which it is impossible to create a nonprivileged substitute1 is necessary to decide a factual or legal issue or claim1 the court shall weigh the equities and make appropriate orders in the interest of justice1 such as striking the testimony of a witness1 finding in favor of or against a party on a factual or legal issue to which the information is relevant1 or dismissing a claim or counterclaim4 ,this paragraph does not permit an award of money damages against a party based in whole or in part on privileged information that was not disclosed to that party4 #h4 ,interlocutory appeal 7a7 ,in general ,the courts of appeal shall have jurisdiction of an appeal from a decision or order of a district court determining that the state secrets privilege is not validly asserted1 sanctioning a refusal to provide an adequate or nonprivileged substitute required under this ,act1 or refusing protective steps sought by the ,government under this ,act pending the resolution of the claim of state secrets privilege4 7b7 ,appeal 7#a7 ,in general ,an appeal taken under this section either before or during trial shall be expedited by the court of appeals4 7#b7 ,during trial ,if an appeal is taken during trial1 the district court shall adjourn the trial until the appeal is resolved and the court of appeals-- 7,a7 shall hear argument on appeal as expeditiously as possible after adjournment of the trial by the district court2 7,b7 may dispense with written briefs other than the supporting materials previously submitted to the trial court2 7,c7 shall render its decision as expeditiously as possible after argument on appeal2 and 7,d7 may dispense with the issuance of a written opinion in rendering its decision4 #i4 ,reporting 7a7 ,in general ,consistent with applicable authorities and duties1 including those conferred by the ,constitution of the ,united ,states upon the executive and legislative branches1 the ,attorney ,general shall report in writing to the ,permanent ,select ,committee on ,intelligence of the ,house of ,representatives1 the ,select ,committee on ,intelligence of the ,senate1 and the chairmen and ranking minority members of the ,committees on the ,judiciary of the ,house of ,representatives and ,senate on any case in which the ,government invokes a state secrets privilege1 not later than #cj calendar days after the date of such assertion4 ,each report submitted under this subsection shall include all affidavits filed under this ,act by the ,government4 7b7 ,operation and effectiveness 7#a7 ,in general ,the ,attorney ,general shall deliver to the committees of ,congress described in subsection 7a7 a report concerning the operation and effectiveness of this ,act and including suggested amendments to the ,act4 7#b7 ,deadline ,the ,attorney ,general shall submit this report not later than #a year after the date of enactment of this ,act1 and every year thereafter until the date that is #c years after that date of enactment4 ,after the date that is #c years after that date of enactment1 the ,attorney ,general shall submit a report under paragraph 7#a7 as necessary4 #aj4 ,rule of construction ,this ,act provides the only privilege that may be asserted in civil cases based on state secrets and the standards and procedures set forth in this ,act apply to any assertion of the privilege4 #aa4 ,application ,this ,act applies to claims pending on or after the date of enactment of this ,act4 ,a court also may relieve a party or its legal representative from a final judgment1 order1 or proceeding that was based1 in whole or in part1 on the state secrets privilege if-- 7#a7 the motion for relief is filed with the rendering court within one year of the date of enactment of this ,act2 7#b7 the underlying judgment1 order1 or proceeding from which the party seeks relief was entered after ,january #a1 #bjjb2 and 7#c7 the claim on which the judgement1 order1 or proceeding is based is-- 7,a7 against the ,government2 or 7,b7 arises out of conduct by persons acting in the capacity of a ,government officer1 employee1 or agent4