,,sir ,,christopher ,,wren ,illustration3 ,,country ,,life ,illustration3 ,,the ,,chief ,,works ,,of ,,wren4 ,a tribute by ,c4 ,r4 ,cockerell1 ,r4,a4 ,,sir ,,christopher ,,wren ,,scientist1 ,,scholar ,,and ,,architect ,,by ,,sir ,,lawrence ,,weaver ,k4,b4,e41 ,f4,s4,a41 ,,hon4 ,a4,r4,i4,b4,a4 ,,london ,,published ,,at ,,the ,,offices ,,of 8,,country ,,life10 ,,ltd41 #bj1 ,,tavistock ,,street1 ,,covent ,,garden1 ,w4,c4 #b1 ,,and ,,by ,,george ,,newnes1 ,,ltd41 #h-aa1 ,,southampton ,,street1 ,,strand1 ,w4,c4 #b4 ,,new ,,york3 ,,charles ,,scribner',s ,,sons ,,mcmxxiii ,,printed ,,in ,,great ,,britain ,,preface ,this little book pretends to be neither a ,life of ,wren nor a detailed record of his achievement4 ,his working years were more than seventy4 ,at fifteen the inventor of a weather-clock and the author of a ,theory of ,trigonometry which delighted ,sir ,charles ,scarborough1 he died in his ninety-first year1 not indeed in professional harness1 but still working at the multitudinous problems to which his life had been devoted4 ,when the definitive 8,life and ,works0 comes to be written1 it will itself be someone's life-work1 if it is to be adequate4 ,i attempt no more than to give impressions of the many sides of a great ,englishman1 and have taken the liberty to ignore the chronological order which is fitting in a biography4 ,my old friend ,henry ,wheatley pleased himself with the notion that people who write get a grossly unfair share of the world's praise1 for the relative greatness of men is judged by what writers say of them1 and writers are obsessed by the importance of their own craft4 ,it is also true that architecture has been in ,england an inarticulate trade1 and one regarded in our generation as a technical mystery with which we are little concerned4 ,the greatness of ,wren has been obscured by the modesty which checked any inclination he may have had to enshrine his thought in writing1 save in few and disjointed but admirable fragments on science and architecture3 in any case his prodigious output of building left little time for his pen4 ,it is because ,sir ,christopher ,wren brought to his superb architectural accomplishment the equipment of a mathematician1 of a master of natural science1 and of a scholar1 that it is what it is4 ,he has been called the ,english ,leonardo4 ,the praise1 though great1 is not excessive1 but the parallel falls short of completeness4 ,leonardo was poet and mystic as well as painter1 sculptor1 scientist1 and philosopher4 ,but if ,wren did not carry his head in the clouds1 he was still something more than our architect of greatest achievement4 ,he was a man of scientific and intellectual stature worthy to be measured with our best4 ,he was1 above all1 a great ,english gentleman4 ,his contemporaries knew his quality3 it were very shame if we ignored it4 ,the ,bicentenary ,celebrations have given us opportunity to pay the homage due4 ,february #be1 #aibc4 7,two hundredth anniversary of the death of ,wren47 ,,authorities ,,and ,,acknowledgments ,the ,parentalia or ,memoirs of the ,wrens1 by ,christopher1 the son of ,sir ,christopher1 is the main source of information about the great architect4 ,it is as ill-constructed a book as one may meet1 yet it possesses a charm of its own4 ,christopher's idea of a biography seems to have been to print notes1 letters1 and discourses as they came to his hand1 without any thread of text to give coherence to very diverse material4 ,the result is a rather forbidding publication1 which demands of the reader no little resolution4 ,the ,parentalia deals not only with ,sir ,christopher1 but with his father1 ,dean ,christopher1 and his uncle1 ,bishop ,matthew4 ,the father1 as ,registrar of the ,order of the ,garter and ,dean of ,windsor1 and the uncle1 as ,bishop of ,ely1 filled no small parts in the ,church history of their day2 but we are little concerned with them here1 except as they came into ,sir ,christopher's life4 ,this ill-compiled miscellany when completed by the younger ,christopher1 who died in #agdg1 was published by his son ,stephen in #agej4 ,it served as a mine for the ,lives by ,elmes1 ,miss ,phillimore1 and ,miss ,milman1 and has necessarily been consulted freely by all who have made ,wren the subject of their pens4 ,in #aijc that part of the ,parentalia which referred to ,sir ,christopher was reprinted by ,mr4 ,c4 ,r4 ,ashbee at the ,essex ,house ,press1 and twenty fine drawings of ,wren's churches by ,e4 ,h4 ,new were reproduced4 ,it is finely printed1 and ,mr4 ,ernest ,j4 ,enthoven's editing ensured an accurate transcript of the original edition as published by ,stephen ,wren4 ,to the kindness of ,mr4 ,new and ,mr4 ,enthoven ,i owe the permission to reproduce here some of the former's drawings4 ,stephen ,wren was unmarried1 but contrived to beget a daughter1 ,margaret1 who took the name of ,wren4 ,for her a copy of the ,parentalia was bound sumptuously in red leather1 tooled and gilt4 ,it bears the initials 8,m4 ,w40 and ,margaret's autograph appears on the title-page4 ,interleaved in this delightful and unique volume are many manuscripts1 autograph letters1 and engravings4 ,some are in connection with the ,dean and the ,bishop1 but most have to do with ,sir ,christopher4 ,about #aijh ,i became acquainted with ,mrs4 ,pigott1 ne ,catherine ,wren-,hoskyns1 the last surviving direct descendant of ,sir ,christopher4 ,she was then old and in ill-health1 and contemplated bequeathing the heirloom copy to a distant collateral4 ,i persuaded her to allow me to collect a suitable sum of money which she might bequeath instead1 and the story of that piece of mendicancy1 with a list of the people who generously backed me1 is deposited with the heirloom copy in the ,library of the ,royal ,institute of ,british ,architects4 ,amongst the manuscripts of the heirloom ,parentalia is a chronological ,series ,vit et ,actorum ,domini ,christophori ,wren in four pages4 ,this is a copy1 perhaps even may be the draft1 of the list in the ,lansdowne ,manuscript at the ,british ,museum1 which was initialed by ,sir ,christopher himself about a year before he died4 ,i am bound to say1 however1 that even a list so apparently authentic gives me no confidence4 ,wren was the last man to be interested in materials for his own biography1 and he was ninety when he checked the list4 ,his son was incurably casual and inaccurate1 and the ,elmes1 ,phillimore1 and ,milman ,lives were based on it blindly1 except in the case of ,miss ,milman1 who used her own judgment somewhat4 ,elmes was laborious1 and had access to a lot of material such as ,state ,papers1 some of which mysteriously got into his own possession2 but he was almost blind1 and he dated his dedication to ,sir ,humphry ,davy exactly a hundred years before ,i date this1 at a period when biography was no exact science4 ,the time has come for someone to go back to all the originals1 including many which have come to light since his day4 ,i hope this work will not linger until ,february #be1 #bjbc4 ,for light on ,wren as a scientist ,i make very grateful acknowledgments to my friend ,sir ,daniel ,hall1 ,k4,c4,b41 ,f4,r4,s41 an expert in the outlook of the philosophers of ,wren's day4 ,he will recognise as his own a shamelessly large number of sentences in ,chapter ,,iv4 ,professor ,hinks1 ,f4,r4,s41 the present ,gresham ,professor of ,astronomy1 has helped me with notes on that aspect of his great predecessor's activities4 ,mr4 ,wells1 the reigning ,warden of ,wadham1 has kindly checked my chapter on ,wren's ,oxford days4 ,there is a common phrase for men of encyclopdic knowledge1 that they have forgotten more than other men ever knew4 ,it would be true of my old friend1 ,mr4 ,arthur ,bolton1 ,curator of ,sir ,john ,soane's ,museum1 but--he has not forgotten4 ,he has been so helpful and full of suggestions that it would be more honest if his name were with mine on the title-page4 ,but he shares ,wren's gift of modesty as well as learning1 and ,i need only express an admiring gratitude4 ,i am indebted to the ,duke of ,portland1 to the ,warden of ,wadham1 and to the ,editor of ,architecture for permission to reproduce portraits4 ,i have attempted no bibliography1 in which ,longman's ,three ,cathedrals would have a prominent place4 ,that task and a schedule of ,wren's drawings1 with reproductions of those that can be definitely attributed to him1 will be amongst the fitting works of the projected ,wren ,society4 ,,contents ,,chapter ,,page ,,preface v ,,authorities ,,and ,,acknowledgments vii ,i4 ,,parentage ,,and ,,childhood #a ,,ii4 ,,oxford ,,career ,,and ,,early ,,inventions #i ,,iii4 ,,family ,,life #ah ,,iv4 ,,astronomer1 ,,mathematician1 ,,and ,,natural ,,scientist #bh ,v4 ,,beginnings ,,of ,,architecture ,,and ,,visit ,,to ,,paris #dc ,,vi4 ,,town-,,planning #ec ,,vii4 ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,cathedral #ei ,,viii4 ,,the ,,city ,,churches #gh ,,ix4 ,,chelsea1 ,,hampton ,,court1 ,,and ,,greenwich #ig ,x4 ,,other ,,buildings3 ,,public ,,and ,,domestic #ajd ,,xi4 ,,wren ,,and ,,his ,,contemporaries3 ,,last ,,years #aab ,,xii4 ,,the ,,professional ,,man #abc ,,xiii4 ,,student ,,and ,,scholar #acb ,,xiv4 8,,the ,,architect ,,of ,,adventure0 #add ,,appendix ,i43 ,a ,,note ,,in ,,amplification ,,of ,,the ,,reference ,,in ,,chapter ,,iv4 ,,to ,,pascal',s ,,problem #aeh ,,appendix ,,ii43 ,,an ,,attempt ,,at ,a ,,wren ,,chronology #afj ,,appendix ,,iii43 ,a ,,note ,,on ,,some ,,portraits ,,of ,,wren #afd ,,index #afg ,,list ,,of ,,illustrations ,,plates ,,plate ,i4 ,,the ,,chief ,,works ,,of ,,wren ,frontispiece ,,facing ,,page ,,ii4 ,,wren ,,as ,a ,,man ,,of ,,forty #ej ,,iii4 ,,wren',s ,,plan ,,of ,,london #ed ,,iv4 ,,the ,,welbeck ,,portrait #fj ,v4 ,,bust ,,by ,,edward ,,pearce ,,at ,,the ,,ashmolean #gj ,,vi4 ,,the ,,west ,,front ,,of ,,st4 ,,paul',s #gb ,,vii4 ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,under ,,the ,,dome #gd ,,viii4 ,,st4 ,,stephen',s ,,walbrook #hh ,,ix4 ,,chelsea ,,hospital3 ,,the ,,main ,,portico #ih ,x4 ,,hampton ,,court3 ,,wren',s ,,two ,,fronts #ajj ,,xi4 ,,greenwich ,,hospital ,,and ,,its ,,two ,,domes #ajb ,,xii4 ,,trinity ,,college ,,library1 ,,cambridge3 ,,river ,,front #ajh ,,xiii4 ,,the ,,wadham ,,portrait ,,of ,,wren #aad ,,xiv4 ,,the ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,deanery ,,portrait #abj ,,xv4 ,,the ,,central ,,portion ,,of ,,the ,,chiaroscuro ,,engraving #abf ,,xvi4 ,,wren ,,medal ,,at ,,wadham ,,college #adh ,,in ,,the ,,text ,,page ,,st4 ,,peter',s xv1 xvi ,,st4 ,,augustin',s #ee ,,st4 ,,martin',s ,,and ,,st4 ,,paul',s #ef ,,the ,,second ,,design ,,for ,,st4 ,,paul',s #fd ,,plan ,,of ,,the 8,,rejected ,,design0 #ff ,,west ,,elevation ,,of ,,the 8,,warrant ,,design0 #fh ,,plan ,,of ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,as ,,built #gb ,,st4 ,,vedast #gi ,,st4 ,,alban #hj ,,st4 ,,dunstan',s #hb ,,st4 ,,magnus #he ,,st4 ,,margaret',s ,,pattens #hf ,,st4 ,,bride',s #hg ,,st4 ,,mildred1 ,,bread ,,street #ia ,,st4 ,,bride',s #ib ,,st4 ,,mary-,,le-,,bow #adf ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,peter',s ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,peter',s ,,sir ,,christopher ,,wren ,,scientist1 ,,scholar1 ,,and ,,architect ,,chapter ,i ,,parentage ,,and ,,childhood ,on the #bjth ,october1 #afcb1 ,christopher ,wren was born in the ,rectory at ,east ,knoyle in ,wiltshire4 ,his father1 also ,dr4 ,christopher ,wren1 is said to have descended from an ancient ,english family of ,danish origin which settled in the county of ,durham2 but ,i can find no authority for the ,danish story except ,parentalia4 ,in ,j4 ,w4 ,rylands' ,records of ,wroxall ,abbey there is a pedigree which shows ,sir ,christopher's grandfather1 ,francis ,wren1 ,citizen and ,mercer of ,london1 who lived from #aeeb to #afbd4 ,his father was ,cuthbert and his grandfather ,william ,wren1 of ,sherborn ,house1 ,durham1 who died in #aeci4 ,this ,william is described as brother to a ,christopher ,wren1 of ,wythebroke1 ,warwick1 who died in #aedb1 but the authority is doubtful4 ,if it is accurate1 however1 it may be an added reason for ,sir ,christopher's purchase of the ,warwickshire estate of ,wroxall for his son1 who settled down there as a country gentleman4 ,sir ,christopher's mother was ,mary1 daughter and heiress of ,robert ,cox1 of ,fonthill1 ,wiltshire4 ,so on both sides ,christopher was well born4 ,he was an only son1 with seven sisters1 but one of them only is important in ,wren's story4 ,she married1 in #afdj1 ,dr4 ,william ,holder1 of ,blechington1 ,oxford4 ,we know nothing of ,christopher's mother except her name1 but his father cut some figure in ,charles ,i4's reign4 ,a loyalist of loyalists1 he succeeded his more distinguished brother1 ,bishop ,matthew ,wren1 in #afce1 as ,dean of ,windsor and ,registrar of the ,order of the ,garter4 ,when ,st4 ,george's ,chapel was plundered by the ,cromwellian troops1 the spoils included the three ,registers of the ,garter ,knights1 but by making a heavy payment the ,dean got them back again1 and cherished them until his death in #afeh4 ,they then passed into the safe keeping of ,christopher1 who soon after the ,restoration handed them over to ,dr4 ,bruno ,ryves1 then the ,registrar of the ,garter4 ,dean ,christopher was educated at ,merchant ,taylors' ,school and ,st4 ,john's1 ,oxford1 and his son's scientific attainments were inherited4 ,he was a man of delightful character1 and evidently there was between father and son the closest affection1 which shines even through the formal phrases used in those days by children when writing to their fathers4 ,that he added skill in architecture to his wide literary and mathematical knowledge is clear from the fact that he was employed in #afcd to design a building at ,windsor for ,charles ,i4's ,queen1 and a detailed estimate prepared by the ,dean has survived4 ,as the building was to cost over #ac1jjj1 it must have been an ambitious undertaking1 but it never took shape owing to the disturbances of the time4 ,it was of great importance to ,wren that his early training should have been given to him by so able a father1 especially as he was1 in childhood1 exceedingly delicate4 ,the ,rev4 ,william ,shepheard helped the ,dean as domestic tutor1 and the boy's mathematics were looked after by ,dr4 ,william ,holder4 ,aubrey1 in his ,lives of ,eminent ,men1 says of ,holder that 8he was very helpful in the education of his brother-in-law1 a youth of prodigious inventive wit1 to whom he was as tender as if he had been his own child4 ,he gave him his instructions in geometry and arithmetic1 and when he was a young scholar at the ,university of ,oxford was a very necessary and kind friend40 ,amongst the manuscripts in the heirloom ,parentalia is a letter in ,latin1 dated 8,e ,muso meo1 ,calendis ,januarii1 #afda10 from ,wren to his father1 beautifully written1 and expressing filial gratitude in a high degree1 and below is a ,latin verse with its ,english translation4 ,at the foot the delighted father has written1 8,scripto hoc1 ,ao tatis su ,decimo ab octobris #bjo elapso40 ,it was certainly a remarkable accomplishment for a boy of nine4 ,also amongst the ,parentalia ,,mss4 is a versified paraphrase of the first to the fourteenth verses of the first chapter of ,st4 ,john's ,gospel4 ,the penmanship of this is also admirable1 and ,wren maintained this merit of legibility until the end of his life4 ,wren went in due course to ,westminster1 and worked under the redoubtable ,dr4 ,busby4 ,his father's choice of the school was doubtless due to the vehemently loyalist attitude of the great headmaster1 but it may also have been influenced by the fact that ,busby1 though a notable classic1 did not frown upon mathematical and scientific studies4 ,christopher was a ,town ,boy1 and never entered the ,college proper4 ,possibly it was at ,westminster that ,wren first met ,robert ,hooke1 with whom he was to be so closely associated in after life1 though this guess is a little doubtful1 for ,hooke was older by three years2 but he was also a ,town ,boy1 and boarded in ,busby's house1 going but little into school4 ,john ,sargeaunt thought that ,hooke studied mathematics apart1 and that this liberty was probably shared by young ,christopher4 ,it is likely that owing to ,christopher's delicate health he left ,westminster early and pursued his studies under the eye of ,sir ,charles ,scarborough1 a young but famous physician who had developed a marked genius for mathematics and science4 ,if ,wren had remained at ,westminster1 he would almost certainly have proceeded in the ordinary course1 like most ,westminster boys1 either to ,christ ,church1 ,oxford1 or ,trinity ,college1 ,cambridge3 the choice of ,wadham was no doubt dictated by his friendship with the ,warden4 ,evidently1 however1 ,wren retained an affection for his old school1 because he took much trouble over the design of a new dormitory which led to a great deal of wrangling1 and the work of building was postponed again and again4 ,when1 ultimately1 the policy of rebuilding was settled in #agba1 ,wren was ninety1 and no longer in practice4 ,his design1 therefore1 was put aside1 and the ,earl of ,burlington produced what purported to be a new one1 but was1 in fact1 ,wren's1 with some slight modifications4 ,the existing building1 in fact1 which looks out on the quiet ,abbey ,garden1 may be regarded as a work of ,wren1 though technically the amateur ,burlington was responsible for it4 ,if we are to believe ,elmes1 it was not until #afdg1 when ,christopher was in his fifteenth year1 that he became acquainted with ,sir ,charles ,scarborough1 but it seems more reasonable to ascribe to the ,scarborough period1 following ,wren's retirement from ,westminster1 a manuscript letter in ,latin verse to his father1 dated ,september #ac1 #afde1 dedicating to him an instrument called ,suum ,panorganum ,astronomicum1 and a tract ,de ,ortu ,fluminum4 ,on that assumption ,christopher left ,westminster before he had completed his thirteenth year4 ,there is very little to show that ,wren was much interested in the graphic arts1 but on the sheet in the heirloom ,parentalia which contains the ,latin letter is an ink sketch of a woman holding up a dial-shaped object1 which is possibly the ,panorganum4 ,possibly1 however1 this may be the sketch for a design on the ceiling of a room which he did when he was sixteen4 ,it included 8two figures1 representing ,astronomy and ,geometry and their ,attributes1 artfully drawn with his pen40 ,i cannot affirm that the lady in the heirloom copy is a piece of his 8artful0 drawing1 but it is likely4 ,what seems to fix the start of ,wren's studies with ,scarborough as roughly contemporary with his ,panorganum letter is the fact that the boy in #afdg was engaged in translating into ,latin1 at ,sir ,charles' request1 ,oughtred's ,clavis ,mathematic4 ,in the same year he had a patent granted him for a diplographic instrument for writing with two pens4 ,christopher describes his invention at length4 ,an instrument of the kind must have then seemed very important1 because ,sir ,william ,petty patented a similar contrivance in the same year4 ,about three years later someone stole ,wren's invention4 ,he was exceedingly annoyed1 and wrote a letter in which he refers to the fact that ,oliver ,cromwell's attention had been directed to it4 ,without claiming anything great for the invention itself1 he wanted to clear himself from the aspersion of having annexed somebody else's device4 ,in later years there were to be many examples of people picking up an idea of ,wren's1 developing it to their own great credit1 and failing to acknowledge the man without whose idea they never would have started on their enterprise4 ,whenever it was that ,wren began working under ,sir ,charles ,scarborough1 it was not until his fifteenth year that he informed his father that he was acting as a demonstrating assistant to the physician who lectured on anatomy at ,surgeons' ,hall4 ,the story of his activities is set out in a dignified ,latin letter1 which refers not only to the ,scarborough activities1 but to ,wren's invention of a weather-clock1 of an instrument to write with in the dark1 and of a treatise on spherical trigonometry4 ,very impressive also is a long metrical ,latin essay on the ,reformation of the ,zodiac1 which runs to nearly fifteen quarto pages1 in an appendix to ,elmes' ,life4 ,he was sixteen when he wrote 7again in ,latin7 to ,mr4 ,oughtred1 whose important essay on geometry he had translated into ,latin4 ,we may agree with ,elmes that 8these juvenile essays prove the fecundity1 the ripeness1 and the highly cultivated state of his mind1 his zeal1 and his ardent enthusiasm in the pursuit of knowledge and literary honours40 ,but the weather-clock was destined to develop from the stage of a 8juvenile essay40 ,when he wrote to his father in #afdg that he was enjoying ,scarborough's society1 he added that he had imparted to him 8one of these inventions of mine1 a weather-clock--namely1 with revolving cylinder1 by means of which a record can be kept through the night40 ,of this ,scarborough thought well enough to ask the lad to have one constructed in brass at his expense4 ,i find in ,birch's ,history of the ,royal ,society1 vol4 i41 under date ,december #i1 #affc3 8,dr4 ,wren's description of his weather-clock consisting of two wings that may be added to a pendulum clock was read40 ,the engraving published by ,birch shows a far simpler arrangement than that of the drawing among the heirloom ,,mss4 ,the printed ,parentalia gives a description of a device more complicated than ,birch's description of ,wren's communication of #affc1 and refers to a circular thermometer designed to correct the error caused by the weight of liquid4 ,this does not appear in the drawing2 the thermometer is of the ordinary air type4 ,the printed ,parentalia refers to ,robert ,hooke's improvements on ,wren's design1 but they only partly appear in the drawing1 which would seem to show an intermediate development between ,wren's original device and ,hooke's latest achievements4 ,the thing itself is of no importance now1 but is worth remembering1 as showing not only the early blossoming of ,wren's scientific achievement1 but also his patience and persistence in developing an idea over a period of years4 ,all this was a good prelude to his life at ,oxford1 which began when he was young to be an undergraduate1 by our standards1 but older than we have been led to believe4 ,,chapter ,,ii ,,oxford ,,career ,,and ,,early ,,inventions ,the question as to when ,wren started his ,university career presents considerable difficulties1 but it is worth exploring1 because his youth at ,oxford had an enduring effect on the development of the man4 ,parentalia is explicit3 8,in the year #afdf and ,fourteenth of his ,age1 ,mr4 ,wren was admitted a ,gentleman-,commoner at ,wadham ,college 444 where he soon attracted the ,friendship and esteem of the two most celebrated ,virtuosi and ,mathematicians of their ,time1 ,dr4 ,john ,wilkins1 ,warden of ,wadham1 and ,dr4 ,seth ,ward44440 ,this date is confirmed by the ,lansdowne ,chronology ,,ms41 prepared by ,wren's son1 and initialed by ,sir ,christopher himself two years before his death4 ,the ,,ms4 states3 8#afdf4 ,admissus in ,collegio de ,wodham40 ,but it is necessary to consider other evidence4 ,r4 ,b4 ,gardiner1 in ,registers of ,wadham ,college1 notes that ,wren's caution money as ,fellow ,commoner was received on ,june #be1 #afdi or #afej4 ,sir ,thomas ,g4 ,jackson gives #afdi as the year when ,wren entered the college as ,fellow ,commoner4 ,wilkins did not become ,warden1 in place of ,dr4 ,pitt1 expelled by the ,parliamentary ,visitors1 until ,april #ac1 #afdh1 when his name was entered in the ,buttery ,book4 ,on ,may #e1 #afdh1 ,wilkins had a dispensation for twelve months from the full performance of his duties in consequence of his attendance on the ,prince ,elector1 whose ,chaplain he was4 ,it was not impossible that ,wren should have gone to ,wadham at fourteen--the profligate ,rochester matriculated at twelve and was ,m4,a4 before he was fourteen--but it is unlikely4 ,wren was exceedingly delicate as a boy1 there was no ,wilkins at ,wadham to attract him there when he was fourteen or for two years after1 and he was1 even in #afdi1 the first ,fellow ,commoner entered during ,wilkins' wardenship4 ,if ,wilkins took the year's leave granted him1 and if ,june #be1 #afdi1 be taken as the correct date for the payment of ,wren's caution money1 he went there a month after the ,warden settled down in his post4 ,if ,wren had proceeded direct to ,oxford at fourteen from being under ,busby at ,westminster1 he would almost certainly have gone to ,christ ,church1 not to ,wadham4 ,moreover1 it is certain that during his sixteenth year1 and perhaps later1 he was very busy with mathematics and science under ,sir ,charles ,scarborough in ,london4 ,it is just conceivable that he entered at ,wadham soon after ,oxford surrendered to the ,parliament in #afdf1 and that he did not come into residence until #afdi or #afej1 but no document has ever suggested that1 and the theory can be dismissed4 ,it is the opinion of ,mr4 ,wells1 the reigning ,warden1 that if ,wren only matriculated in #afej he could not have proceeded to his ,b4,a4 in #afea1 as in fact he did4 ,but the year #afdi1 accepted by ,sir ,thomas ,jackson1 is feasible on the basis of ,wren's notable precocity and the then readiness of the ,university not to insist on three years1 as is seen by ,rochester's case4 ,it is1 however1 fair to add that the entry of ,wren's #e in the ,wadham book is undated1 but it comes at the foot of a page headed #afej1 on which the preceding entry is dated ,june #be1 and the three previous names are registered by ,gardiner as #afej4 ,it may be1 however1 that as the ,wren entry is undated1 it was added later4 ,on the other hand1 if he had gone to ,oxford in #afdf he could scarcely have occupied the then unheard-of time of five years before taking his ,b4,a41 ,march #ah1 #afej-ea4 ,i attach no importance to the ,,ms4 prepared by ,wren's son ,christopher1 or1 indeed1 to any of his documents1 and prefer to rest on the ,college records4 ,miss ,phillimore followed the ,,ms41 but ,miss ,milman1 without setting down any evidence1 assumed that ,wren spent three years in ,london between ,dr4 ,busby and ,oxford4 ,i think she did wisely1 and on all the evidence1 obscure and conflicting as it is1 ,i accept #afdi as the year when ,wren began his ,oxford career4 ,the rest of the dates can be cleared off shortly4 ,he became ,m4,a4 ,december #aa1 #afec1 having been elected a ,probationer ,fellow of ,all ,souls in ,november of the same year1 and was made ,d4,c4,l4 at ,all ,souls on ,september #ab1 #affa4 ,wren was fortunate in the influence of the ,warden of ,wadham1 which was so powerful during the formation of ,wren's character that it is necessary to form some picture of the man4 ,john ,wilkins reigned beneficently over the college from #afdh to #afei1 and was described by ,aubrey as 8no great-read man1 but one of much and deepe thinking2 and a prudent man as well as ingeniose40 ,as the late ,dr4 ,wright ,henderson1 the biographer of ,wilkins1 wrote of him1 8his greatness fell short of genius1 for it was the effect of ordinary qualities1 rarely combined and tempered into one character2 but more effective for useful work in the world than genius without sanity40 ,soon after the ,civil ,war broke out1 ,wilkins was living in ,london as the chaplain of ,charles ,lewis1 ,prince ,elector ,palatine1 with whom ,christopher renewed a childish acquaintance4 ,mr4 ,wright ,henderson thinks that ,wilkins became the leader1 as he was certainly the friend1 of the group of students of natural philosophy who afterwards formed the ,royal ,society4 ,it seems obvious that ,wren was entered at ,wadham in order that he might be under ,wilkins4 ,it is certain that he became the ,warden's favourite pupil4 ,it is evident from the amazing 8,catalogue of ,new ,theories1 ,inventions1 ,experiments1 and ,mechanick ,improvements10 exhibited by ,mr4 ,wren at the 8,first ,assemblies at ,wadham ,college in ,oxford for ,advancement of ,natural and ,experimental ,knowledge0 which is printed in ,parentalia that ,wren took all knowledge for his province4 ,there are fifty-three items1 ranging from such solemnities as the 8,hypothesis of the ,moon's ,libration1 in ,solid0 and 8,to find whether the earth moves0 through the uncertainties of 8,probable ,ways for making ,fresh ,water at ,sea10 and the largeness of 8,divers ,improvements in the ,art of ,husbandry0 down to the pleasant simplicity of 8,a ,way of ,imbroidery for ,beds1 ,hangings1 cheap and fair40 ,we are reminded of the association between architecture and military engineering during the height of the ,italian ,renaissance1 by 8,to build in the ,sea1 ,forts1 ,moles1 etc40 and 8,secure and ,speedier ,ways of attacking ,forts than by ,approaches and ,galleries40 ,sanmicheli had invented the pentagonal bastion3 ,inigo ,jones had fortified ,basing ,house against the ,parliament's attack1 and had been one of the defenders4 ,we would give much to learn something of ,wren's invention for 8,ways of ,submarine ,navigation40 ,if he had developed 8,easier ,ways of ,whale-fishing10 it would have given material for another chapter in ,moby ,dick4 ,eheu fugaces6 ,there is a hint of the coming gramophone in 8,a speaking ,organ1 articulating ,sounds10 and 8,divers new ,musical ,instruments0 helps to explain ,wren's devotion to his daughter ,jane1 whose monument in the crypt of ,st4 ,paul's--she died at the age of twenty-six--shows her in ,francis ,bird's rather heavy-handed sculpture as seated at an organ4 ,the technique of writing always interested ,wren1 so it is natural to find in the catalogue 8,to write in the ,dark0 and 8,to write ,double by an ,instrument10 the latter a dodge he developed to the point of patenting it4 ,the tools of his future profession already attracted him4 8,a ,scenographical ,instrument1 to survey at one ,station0 is followed by 8,a ,perspective ,box1 to survey with it10 and there is a ring of ,bacon and ,wotton in the compendious phrase 8,new ,designs tending to ,strength1 ,convenience1 and ,beauty in ,building40 ,there is certainly no more rightly prophetic entry in the whole astonishing list4 8,several new ,ways of graving and etching0 gives a certain colour to the story--though it must be discredited--that ,wren introduced mezzotint4 8,new ,ways of ,intelligence1 new ,cyphers0 marks his early attachment to an amusement which he shared with others of his day1 though without the need to use the art to conceal roguish passages in what he wrote1 as was the case with ,pepys' shorthand4 ,his later excursions into veterinary surgery and the transfusion of human blood are heralded by the memorandum 8,to purge or vomit1 or alter the ,mass by ,injection into the ,blood1 by ,plaisters1 by various dressing a ,fontanell40 ,we have a glimpse of the experiments connected with the working out of 8,a ,pavement harder1 fairer1 and cheaper than ,marble10 as well as into the social side of these ,wadham assemblies1 through ,john ,evelyn's glasses4 ,on ,july #ac1 #afed1 he was at ,dr4 ,wilkins'1 at ,wadham1 and saw3 8,variety of shadows1 dyals1 perspectives1 and many other mathematical and magical curiosities1 a way-wiser1 a thermometer1 a monstrous magnet1 conic and other sections1 a ballance on a demi-circle1 most of them of his own and that prodigious young scholar ,mr4 ,chr4 ,wren1 who presented me with a piece of white marble1 which he had stain'd with a lively red1 very deepe1 as beautiful as if it had been natural40 ,two days before ,evelyn had visited after dinner 8that miracle of a youth40 ,there is no need to fill out the ,wadham catalogue of inventions3 we can accept ,evelyn's valuation1 and he never changed his mind4 ,but the list from which ,i have quoted does not complete the story of ,wren's early essays in the scientific field1 essays1 be it noted1 which are overwhelmingly practical4 ,wren was a devotee not of pure but of applied science4 ,it is probably at ,wadham that ,wren concerned himself with what he calls ,cheirologia4 ,in the heirloom ,parentalia is a sheet with pictures of two hands1 and on the next page1 another hand and various notes showing the working of the deaf and dumb language invented by ,sir ,christopher4 ,though more complicated than the system now in use1 it is another evidence of the agility of ,wren's mind1 and of his unwearying interest in varying problems4 ,but his time was not wholly spent in the laboratory4 ,a curious incident at ,oxford in #afej gave occasion for ,wren's poetic gift4 ,a girl condemned for murdering her illegitimate infant was hanged1 but revived later under the care of ,dr4 ,petty and ,thomas ,willis4 ,it is an extraordinary story told with a wealth of unpleasant detail in a pamphlet called ,news from the ,dead4 ,following the narrative are some dozens of 8,ingenious poems on the subject by the ,prime ,wits0 of the ,university1 including one by ,wren4 ,it is in a pompous vein1 and cites ,orpheus1 ,eurydice1 the ,fates1 and sculapius in the fashion of the time4 ,morgan reprinted the pamphlet and poems in ,phnix ,britannicus1 where they may be found by the curious4 ,wren's effusion is only worth mention as showing him in the full current of ,oxford life3 it is likely enough that he had some slight part with ,petty and ,willis in the long business of resuscitating the young woman4 ,his fellowship at ,all ,souls did not divorce him from ,wadham4 ,in ,october1 #affc1 he was paying rent for the chamber over ,wadham ,gateway which had once been part of the ,warden's lodging4 ,that he long held in affection the scene of his early scientific labours is shown by his having designed and presented to the ,college a clock1 the face of which appears on the outside of the chapel4 ,the works were only recently replaced1 but the old mechanism is preserved in the chapel4 ,in the upper corners of the face are two armorial devices1 one of which appears to be the charges from ,wren's coat-of-arms4 ,there is also amongst the college silver a fine sugar castor with an inscription which states that it was given by ,wren in #afec4 ,as1 however1 the maker's mark dates the piece as being actually of #agbj1 it is likely that1 as often happened1 the old inscription on the #afec piece was transferred to what in #agbj seemed a more modish design4 ,at ,oxford he must have stayed off and on1 after his marriage in #affi1 because he retained the ,savilian ,professorship of ,astronomy until ,april1 #afgc1 when he finally settled in ,london4 ,,chapter ,,iii ,,family ,,life ,of ,wren's mother nothing is known1 not even the date of her death4 ,of his seven sisters 7the number given in ,rylands' pedigree71 the only one to survive was ,susan1 who became ,mrs4 ,holder1 and wisely used her great skill in nursing during her brother's delicate childhood4 ,she was five years his senior1 and had no children of her own4 ,christopher's boyhood must have been clouded not a little by the misfortunes of his stout-hearted uncle1 ,matthew ,wren1 ,bishop of ,ely1 whose son1 another ,matthew1 was a faithful cousin to ,christopher in later years4 ,this is no place to tell the story of the ,bishop who1 with eleven of his brethren1 was impeached for resisting the ,parliament in #afda1 and went to the ,tower4 ,after a short freedom in #afdb he was imprisoned again1 and1 being charged with ,catholic practices1 languished there while ,laud was tried and beheaded1 and1 himself never brought to trial1 remained a close prisoner until he was released by ,monk's warrant on ,march #ae1 #affj4 ,broken though he was by domestic bereavements during his eighteen years of captivity1 the brave old man took up again his episcopal duties at the age of seventy-five4 ,that he remained a prisoner so long was due to his refusal to bow the knee to the new order4 ,it does not appear that ,christopher ever saw his uncle in the ,tower1 save on one great occasion1 when he made an unsuccessful effort to secure his release4 ,wren was twenty-four when he became professor of astronomy at ,gresham ,college1 and made the acquaintance of ,richard ,claypole1 husband of ,cromwell's favourite daughter1 ,elizabeth4 ,at their dinner table ,wren became a frequent guest1 the more welcome because ,elizabeth ,claypole remained a devout ,church of ,england woman4 ,one day ,cromwell strode in and sat down to dinner1 and fixing his eye on ,christopher1 said3 8,your uncle has been long confined to the ,tower40 ,to ,wren's reply1 8,he has so1 sir1 but he bears his afflictions with great patience and resignation10 the ,protector made the astonishing reply3 8,he may come out an he will40 ,when ,christopher asked if he might take that message to ,bishop ,matthew from the ,lord ,protector's own mouth1 he got the answer3 8,yes1 you may40 ,but when the young man hurried off to the ,tower with his message1 the ,bishop roundly refused to deal with the usurper on terms which meant submission1 and preferred to tarry the ,lord's leisure and owe his deliverance to ,him alone4 ,a loyal race1 the ,wrens4 ,in #afef1 not long before this incident1 ,dean ,wren had died at ,bletchingdon1 where his son-in-law1 ,dr4 ,holder1 had been parson for some years1 and was buried in the chancel of the church4 ,it was there that ,christopher must have met ,faith1 daughter of ,sir ,thomas ,coghill of ,bletchingdon1 ,oxon4 ,born in #afcf1 she was four years younger than ,wren1 who is likely to have known her since his childhood4 ,we know extremely little of the intimate side of ,wren's life4 ,the only document1 but that a very precious one1 is the autograph love-letter in the heirloom ,parentalia written by him to ,faith4 ,it is as follows3 ,,madam1 ,the ,artificer having never before mett with a drowned watch2 like an ignorant physician has been soe long about the cure1 that he hath made me very unquiet that your comands should be soe long deferred3 however ,i have sent the watch at last1 and envie the felicity of it1 that it should be soe neer your side1 and soe often enjoy your ,eye1 and be consulted by you how your time shall passe while you employ your hand in your excellent workes4 ,but have a care of it1 for ,i have put such a ,spell into it2 that every ,beating of the ,ballance will tell you1 'tis the pulse of my ,heart1 which labours as much to serve you and more trewly than the watch2 for the watch ,i believe will sometimes lie1 and sometimes perhaps be idle and unwilling to goe1 having received soe much injury by being drenched in that briny bath1 that ,i dispair it should ever be a trew ,servant to you more3 ,but as for me 7unless you drown me too in my teares7 you may be confident ,i shall never cease to be ,your most affectionate humble servant ,,chr3 ,,wren4 ,june #ad4 ,i have put the watch in a ,box that it might take noe harme1 and wrapt it about with a little leather1 and that it might not jog1 ,i was fain to fill up a few shavings of wast paper4 ,the letter is dated ,june #ad1 but there is nothing to show whether it was written soon or long before ,wren's marriage to ,faith4 ,his subscription is hardly passionate1 and we know from the enchanting letters of ,dorothy ,osborne that even in ,puritan days such letters were signed1 8,i am perfectly yours40 ,wren's marriage to ,faith ,coghill took place on ,december #g1 #affi1 at the ,temple ,church1 but most of his domestic events thereafter are connected with ,st4 ,martin's-in-the-,fields1 which was his parish church4 ,his first son1 ,gilbert1 died an infant4 ,his second1 ,christopher1 was born in ,february1 #afgd-e1 and baptized at ,st4 ,martin's4 ,this first marriage only lasted a few years1 for ,faith ,wren was buried at ,st4 ,martin's on ,september #d1 #afge4 ,wren soon consoled himself1 for he was married on ,february #bd1 #afgf-g1 at the ,chapel ,royal1 ,st4 ,james's ,palace1 to ,jane1 daughter of ,william ,lord ,fitzwilliam of ,lifford4 ,by this marriage ,wren had a beloved daughter1 ,jane1 who was baptized in ,november1 #afgg1 at ,st4 ,martin's1 and a son1 ,william1 born in ,june1 #afgi4 ,but ,wren was soon again to become a widower4 ,his second wife was buried at ,st4 ,martin's on ,october #f1 #afhj4 ,it is rather surprising that there is no monument to either of ,sir ,christopher's wives at ,st4 ,martin's1 although some tablets from the pre-,gibbs ,church are preserved in the crypt4 ,jane ,wren was1 by tradition1 ,sir ,christopher's favourite child1 and when she died at the age of twenty-six ,wren suffered the greatest sorrow of his life4 ,of his son ,christopher's boyhood we know little1 but ,sir ,christopher wrote to him in ,france1 probably in #afih1 when the young man was twenty-three1 a very charming parental letter1 which has been preserved in the heirloom ,parentalia4 ,it runs as follows3 ,,my ,,dear ,,son1 ,i hope by this time you are pretty well satisfied of the condition of the ,climat you are in3 if not1 ,i believe you will ere ,lent be over1 and will learne to dine upon ,sallad4444 ,if you thinke you can dine better cheape in ,italy you may trie1 but ,i thinke the passing the ,alpes and other dangers of disbanded armies and abominable ,lodgings will ballance that advantage3 but the seeing of fine buildings ,i perceive temptes you1 and your companion ,mr4 ,strong1 whose inclination and interest leades him1 by neither of which ,i can find you are moved2 but how doth it concerne you8 ,you would have it to say hereafter that you have seen ,rome1 ,naples and other fine places1 a hundred others can say as much and more2 calculate whether this be worth the expence and hazard as to any advantage at youre returne4 ,i sent you to ,france at a time of businesse and when you might make your observations and find acquaintance who might hereafter be usefull to you in the future concernes of your life3 if this be your ayme ,i willingly let you proceed1 provided you will soon returne1 for these reasons1 the little ,i have to leave you is unfortunately involved in trouble1 and your presence would be a comfort to me to assist me1 not only for my sake1 but your own that you might understand your affaires1 before it shall please ,god to take me from you1 which if suddenly will leave you in perplexity and losse4 ,i do not say all this out of parsimony1 for what you spend will be out of what will1 in short time1 be your owne1 but ,i would have you be a man of businesse as early as you can bring your thoughts to it4 ,i hope1 by your next you will give me account of the reception of our ambassador2 of the intrigues at this time between the two nations1 of the establishment of the commerce1 and of anything that may be innocently talked of without danger and reflection1 that ,i may perceive whither you look about you or noe and penetrate into what occurres1 or whither the world passes like a pleasant dream1 or the amusement of fine scenes in a play without considering the plot4 ,if you have in ten weeks spent half your bill of exchange besides your gold1 ,i confesse your money will not hold out1 either abroad for yourself or for us at home to supply you1 especially if you goe for ,italy1 which voyage forward and backward will take up more than twenty weekes3 thinke well of it1 and let me hear more from you1 for though ,i would advise you1 ,i will not discontent you4 ,mr4 ,strong hath profered credit by the same merchant he uses for his son1 and ,i will thinke of it1 but before ,i change1 you must make up your account with your merchant1 and send it to me4 ,my hearty service to young ,mr4 ,strong and tell him ,i am obliged to him for your sake4 ,i bless ,god for your health and pray for the continuance of it through all adventures till it pleases ,him to restore you to me and your ,sister and friends who wish the same as doth ,your most affectionate ,father ,,chr4 ,,wren4 ,poor ,billy continues in his indisposition and ,i fear is lost to me and the world to my great discomfort and your future trouble4 ,it would seem that young ,strong1 the son of ,wren's famous master-builder1 was the boy's bear-leader4 ,wren is rather fretful with his son1 and rather melancholy as to his own health1 but he was then only sixty-six1 and was to live until past ninety4 ,in a different tone is the letter to young ,christopher from his father1 dated ,october #aa1 #agje1 the original of which is also in the heirloom ,parentalia4 ,there is no longer the note of rebuke which followed the young man's extravagance in ,paris4 ,his taste had changed1 and ,holland wooed him rather to the buying of good books1 a traffic the old man cannot disapprove4 ,poor ,billy managed to live another forty years1 despite ,wren's desponding postscript4 ,john ,evelyn stood godfather on ,june #ag1 #afgi1 8to a sonn of ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 surveyor of ,his ,majesty's buildings1 that most excellent and learned person 7,evelyn never misses a chance of praising ,wren71 with ,sir ,william ,fermor1 and my ,lady ,viscountess ,newport1 wife of the ,treasurer of the ,household40 ,this was poor ,billy1 whose sponsors show that his father was the intimate friend of ,court personages4 ,william seems to have been very delicate1 if not defective4 ,when ,sir ,christopher died he did not bequeath anything to ,william1 but left him in the charge of ,christopher4 ,william lived on until ,march1 #agch-i1 and was thus close on sixty when he died4 ,his elder brother1 ,christopher1 survived until ,august #bd1 #agdg1 when he was seventy-two4 ,that ,wren lived on affectionate terms with his son ,christopher may be assumed not only from the terms of his will1 but from his having sunk most of his fortune in an estate for ,christopher's benefit4 ,his own connection with ,wroxall ,abbey1 ,warwickshire1 can be set out in few words4 ,on ,august #bi1 #agac1 he bought the estate for #ai1fjj from the trustees of ,sir ,john ,burgoyne1 ,bart41 who had died in #agji4 ,sir ,john's son1 ,sir ,roger1 died in #agaa1 leaving a widow1 ,constance1 daughter of ,sir ,thomas ,middleton4 ,she was one of the signatories of the deed of sale1 and the younger ,christopher1 then a widower1 married her in #agae4 ,probably the ,wrens and the ,burgoynes were old friends1 and as ,sir ,roger ,burgoyne had left the estate encumbered1 the sale to ,wren was doubtless to clear off the mortgages4 ,the estate consisted of a fine ,elizabethan brick house 7since ,wren's time very badly remodelled7 and #a1hej acres1 all of which ,wren conveyed to trustees in ,march1 #agae1 bringing them into the settlement made on the first marriage of his son ,christopher1 who then became sole owner4 ,that the architect ever visited the estate we do not know1 but it is a tradition that he designed a delightful garden wall planned in a series of semi-circles4 ,certainly he never lived there4 ,a succession of ,christophers owned the place until #ahbh1 when it went to the daughter of the last of them1 who married ,chandos ,hoskyns1 a descendant of the ,sir ,john ,hoskyns who was ,vice-,president of the ,royal ,society when ,sir ,christopher filled the chair4 ,catherine1 the eldest daughter of ,chandos ,wren-,hoskyns1 became in time ,mrs4 ,corbett ,pigott1 and died in #aiaa4 ,from her ,i secured the heirloom copy of the ,parentalia for the ,r4,i4,b4,a41 and she gave me a copy of the rare ,kirkall engraved portrait of ,wren1 which had come to her from ,margaret ,wren1 daughter of ,sir ,christopher's grandson1 ,stephen4 ,i had hoped that ,sir ,christopher's will would include some personal expressions about his family1 but it is an uninteresting document1 as anyone who examines it 7,p4,c4,c4 ,richmond #fe7 may discover4 ,he characteristically provided that his body should be decently buried without pomp1 and for the rest one sheet of paper was enough to set out his dispositions4 ,after reference to the trust made at his son ,christopher's first marriage1 he leaves everything to him1 desiring him 8to take particular care that my son ,william ,wren be comfortably maintained supported and lookt after during his life40 ,the will was dated ,april #ad1 #agac1 and proved at ,london on ,march #bg1 #agbc4 ,i consulted the will of the son ,christopher 7,p4,c4,c4 ,potter #bbj7 in the hope that it might make some reference to the disposition of chattels1 such as drawings1 that had belonged to his father1 but it is short and uninforming4 ,,chapter ,,iv ,,astronomer1 ,,mathematician1 ,,and ,,natural ,,scientist ,the sketch of ,wren's activities at ,wadham 7in ,chapter ,,ii7 shows the variousness of his mind1 but clearly his many inventions1 though they make an astonishing list1 were juvenilia4 ,his contemporary ,hooke said of him1 8,since the time of ,archimedes there scarce ever met in one man in so great perfection such a mechanical hand and so philosophical a mind02 and he describes a method of determining the parallax of comets 8invented by that incomparable mathematician ,dr4 ,christopher ,wren40 ,in estimating the value of such an opinion1 one of very many1 ,i am bound to rely on the judgment of scientific friends who have generously helped me with this chapter1 because ,i can only repeat ,professor ,lethaby's comment on the same text3 8,these things are beyond my knowledge1 but ,i know that they represent wonderful powers40 ,we shall only understand the part played by ,wren in the development of natural science if we see that development as the work of a team rather than of individuals4 ,wilkins1 ,boyle1 ,lawrence ,rooke1 ,hooke1 ,seth ,ward1 ,wallis1 ,scarborough1 ,oughtred1 ,wren and many another shared a common enthusiasm for the advancement of knowledge which showed itself in common effort4 ,wren was the man to whom his associates turned for help in solving their individual problems1 because of his extraordinary ingenuity in inventing apparatus which would establish or dispel the truth of some scientific idea1 and still more because of his ready kindness and modesty4 ,during the early days of the ,royal ,society he was not only in an especial manner the cement which kept together the whole fabric1 but the inspirer of much work which was carried to fruition by others4 ,in #afde1 the year when ,wren invented1 as a boy of thirteen1 a new astronomical instrument1 the first meetings took place at which was sown the seed from which the ,royal ,society sprang4 ,dr4 ,wallis1 the mathematician1 ,dr4 ,goddard1 ,wilkins1 later ,warden of ,wadham1 and ,sir ,christopher's father1 ,dr4 ,wren1 were amongst the attendants at weekly gatherings1 when philosophy and especially natural science were discussed4 ,when ,wallis1 ,wilkins1 and ,goddard went to ,oxford in #afdh-di1 the ,london meetings continued1 but new meetings were held also at ,oxford1 first in ,dr4 ,petty's rooms and afterwards at the apartments of ,wilkins at ,wadham4 ,when ,wilkins went to ,trinity1 ,cambridge1 the ,oxford men enjoyed the hospitality of ,robert ,boyle4 ,the ,london meetings were held often at ,gresham ,college and1 when ,wren was fulfilling his duties as ,professor of ,astronomy at the ,college1 after his ,wednesday lectures and after ,rooke's ,thursday lectures4 ,lord ,brouncker1 the friend of ,pepys1 ,john ,evelyn and others were frequently at the meetings1 and the ,royal ,society took formal shape1 after one of ,wren's lectures1 on ,november #bh1 #affj1 when ,brouncker1 ,robert ,boyle1 ,rooke1 ,wilkins and others withdrew to ,wren's private room and decided to constitute themselves formally as a college or society4 ,it was after ,wren's next lecture on ,december #e1 #affj1 that ,sir ,robert ,moray notified to the meeting the ,king's pleasure at the constitution of the society and his promise of encouragement4 ,the ,society of ,philosophers into which the young ,wren found himself plunged owed its inspiration above all to the writings of ,bacon4 ,bacon was not himself a man of science in the sense that ,galileo or even ,descartes was1 for he made no observations and arrived at no discoveries in any particular branch of science4 ,but he summed up all the ,renaissance revolt against ,scholasticism1 and had set forth in a noble literary form a definite system of knowledge that could be opposed to the so-called ,aristotelianism which hitherto had held sway over the minds of men4 ,bacon's guiding principle was the appeal to experiment1 for his famous 8method of induction0 amounts to that4 ,the ,scholastic writers worked by deduction4 ,they laid down their premisses1 they worked out the laws of formal logic by which they could draw deductions from them1 and they accepted the conclusions without enquiring whether the premisses could bear the weight of the superstructure built upon them4 ,bacon opposed to this his dictum1 8hypotheses non fingo20 the business of the man of science is to collect the facts without any preconceived theory1 and to let the facts themselves reveal the law which binds them together4 ,actually1 scientific discovery does not proceed in this way4 ,without a guiding hypothesis the mind is lost in a wilderness of facts1 but the value of the hypothesis must be checked continually by its capacity to embrace the known facts and to predict new ones4 ,none the less1 ,bacon's method was at the time a necessary summons to experiment1 and under its stimulus the young men of the day attacked the problem of the natural world about them with the enthusiasm of crusaders4 ,for as a corollary to his method ,bacon had insisted upon the necessity of studying the common arts and crafts hitherto regarded as beneath the dignity of philosophy4 ,in the operations of the mechanic or the smelter1 and in the growth of crops1 were to be found the materials of science4 ,so the new philosophers were universally curious and their curiosity about things was the note of the society in which ,wren grew up and the dominant feature of his own mind until he settled down to architecture4 ,wren's scientific equipment was primarily that of a mathematician1 and to this he added an inventive turn of mind1 which developed first in the construction of apparatus and was afterwards so nobly turned to account in his building4 ,as a man of science he touched everything and adorned it1 but he cannot be regarded as a supreme pioneer in any particular direction1 nor is his name associated with any fundamental discovery4 ,as mathematician he was abreast of all the knowledge of the day2 he contributed to the advancement of knowledge therein as in his discussions of the cycloid1 but even in that particular subject his work lacks the luminous intuition displayed by ,pascal4 ,nor did he break fresh ground and conceive new methods which afterwards developed into part of the fundamental texture of mathematics1 as ,wallis did with his theory of infinitesimals1 or as ,newton did a few years later in a larger field4 ,wren's activity at the ,royal ,society in the multifarious problems which its members examined must not be allowed to obscure the fact that1 professionally1 he was an astronomer4 ,gresham ,professor at twenty-five1 and ,savilian ,professor at twenty-eight1 he achieved little that has survived4 ,the world and his own nimble mind called him to an excess of enterprises4 ,in #affb1 his indulgent friend ,sprat wrote1 8,the ,vice-,chancellor of ,oxford ,university did yesterday send for me to enquire where the ,astronomy ,professor was1 and the reason of his absence so long after the beginning of term4444 ,he most terribly told me that he took it very ill you had not all this while given him any account of what hindered you in the discharge of your office40 ,sprat stoutly defended ,wren and urged on the angry ,vice-,chancellor that the rebuilding of ,st4 ,paul's and the fortifying of ,tangier 7,wren toyed with the latter but refused it7 were of greater 8concernment for the benefit of ,christendom0 than 8the drawing of lines in ,sir ,harry ,savill's school40 ,it was not until #afgc1 however1 that ,wren officially turned his back on astronomy by resigning the ,savilian professorship4 ,the chief document of his astronomical career is his inaugural ,gresham lecture in #afeg1 of which ,latin and ,english versions are printed in ,parentalia4 ,a manuscript lecture1 ,de corpore ,saturni ejusque phasibus ,hypothesis1 flits irritatingly by us as having been possessed by one ,william ,jones1 ,esquire1 but after that--silence4 ,the ,gresham oration was a little pompous and for the 8politer genii0 whom he espied in his audience4 8,a time would come when men would be able to stretch out their eyes as snails do 7,wren worked with a thirty-six foot glass at ,oxford7 and extend them to fifty feet in length1 by which means they should be able to discover ten thousand times as many stars as we can40 ,of this ,professor ,hinks says1 8,rather poor stuff1 suddenly rising into this most interesting conclusion--#8and find the ,galaxy to be myriads of them1 and every nebulous star appearing as if it were the ,firmament of some other world 444 bury'd in the vast abyss of intermundious vacuum4' ,what would we not give ,professor ,hinks continues for fuller knowledge of what was in ,wren's mind when he wrote this passage so strangely before its time1 so strongly suggestive of the island universe theory of spiral nebul to-day40 ,there was also the matter of the method for constructing solar eclipses4 ,the lay reader may be spared bibliographical details1 into which ,i have dived1 but ,professor ,hinks makes this significant comment3 8,wren was the first to discover the graphical method of computing eclipses that1 with some modifications due to much improved tables1 remains by far the most instructive1 though not the most numerically accurate way of calculating 444 and is in use to-day for the graphical prediction of occultations40 ,it was a practical thought of ,wren that the ,monument should be used as a gigantic telescope1 and members of the ,royal ,society tried so to use it1 but failed1 because passing coaches caused vibrations4 ,he had a like idea for the great south staircase at ,st4 ,paul's1 but again1 for practical reasons1 it broke down4 ,the biographers of ,wren have made great play with a story taken from a manuscript bound up in the heirloom ,parentalia4 ,miss ,milman referred to 8the problem which ,pascal1 444 under the pseudonym of ,jean de ,montfert1 challenged the mathematicians of ,england to answer by a certain day4 ,he accompanied the challenge with a promise of a prize of twenty pistoles to the successful competitor4 ,christopher ,wren solved the problem1 but for some unexplained reason never received the prize1 while the problem from ,kepler which he set in return seems never to have been solved40 ,the facts are rather different4 ,in ,june1 #afeh1 ,pascal put out a challenge to all mathematicians 7not ,english alone7 to find a solution for certain problems connected with a cycloid1 the curve described by a point on the circumference of a circle when that circle rolls along a straight line--e4g41 a nail on the rim of a carriage-wheel4 ,in an appendix ,i set out the story as it has been given me by ,sir ,daniel ,hall4 ,it is rather technical1 but may be summed up simply4 ,pascal received both attempts at solutions and replies which merely discussed germane matters4 ,wren sent a partial but admirable contribution1 unfortunately 8without demonstration40 ,it was original as far as it went1 but not the complete solution for which ,pascal had asked4 ,cavarci1 the umpire in this high contest1 wrote that ,wren had merely solved the easy part of it4 ,it appears clear that in withholding the prize ,pascal wronged neither ,wren nor the other contestants4 ,the suggestion that ,wren was the master mathematician of ,europe will not do4 ,it is enough to affirm of him that he was an ingenious geometrician who made several minor advances in that science4 ,he left no evidence of mathematical genius1 a quality which ought to be reserved to the authors of far-reaching and fruitful conceptions4 ,the true significance of ,wren's mathematics lies in the fine way in which he applied them in his buildings4 ,no one is a better representative of applied science as compared with pure or fundamental science4 ,too much has also been made of ,wren's work on the barometer4 ,some enthusiasts have1 indeed1 tried to transfer to him the credit which belongs to ,torricelli and ,pascal4 ,wren repeated ,torricelli's experiment at the top and bottom of a hill1 and finding that the mercury column stood at a lower height on the top of the hill1 argued that the mercury was really balanced by the weight of the air1 or1 as we now say1 measured its pressure4 ,but in this experiment ,wren was anticipated by ,pascal2 his experiment was regarded by his contemporaries as made independently1 but it would be hard to say that the experiment was really ,wren's own device1 so much was the question a matter of discussion among the men of science of the time4 ,the enunciation of the laws of impact was made practically simultaneously by ,wallis1 ,wren1 and ,huygens4 ,wren's may be regarded as the most elegant demonstration1 but it was ,huygens alone who perceived that when the colliding bodies are perfectly elastic the energy of the system1 i4e41 the sum of the products of the mass of each of the bodies multiplied by the square of its velocity1 remains unchanged--one of the generalisations at the base of modern science4 ,similarly1 although ,wren became ,professor of ,astronomy both at ,gresham ,college and then at ,oxford1 no outstanding observation or fundamental discovery remains attached to his name4 ,speaking broadly and generally we can say that ,wren was universally accomplished in all the science of the time1 that in several directions he showed a quality of mind that was only short of the highest1 and that finally he abandoned the pursuit of pure science too soon to have accomplished in any branch such a mass of work as would mark him as one of the founders of that science4 ,it must always be remembered that ,wren took to architecture when he was just over thirty1 and was immersed in a huge practice when he was thirty-five4 ,but perhaps ,wren also was too universal4 ,perhaps the very ingenuity of his mind led to distractions in too many directions4 ,it may be1 too1 that his inclinations towards the practical fusion of art1 science1 and administration1 which found full expression as an architect1 had always tended to draw him away from the pursuit of abstract science4 ,we may notice that even in the early days of ,oxford he was always the demonstrator and the contriver of experiments at the meetings of the philosophers1 and later1 in the early history of the ,royal ,society1 we find that it was to ,wren that the ,society continually turned for the solution of almost any problem that came under discussion4 ,a letter he wrote to ,lord ,brouncker in #affc1 as to an appropriate show when the ,king visited the ,society1 suggests he was already distrusting his own skill and pleasure in experiment4 8,sciographical ,knacks 7of which an hundred sorts may be given7 are so easy in the invention1 that now they are cheap40 ,the extracts from the ,minute ,books of the ,royal ,society show the confidence of its members in ,wren's universality of mind and constructive ability4 ,at the second meeting of the ,society on ,december #e1 #affj1 when ,sir ,robert ,moray brought the ,king's approval1 8,mr4 ,wren was desired to prepare against the next meeting for the pendulum experiment40 ,a fortnight later the record states 8that ,dr4 ,petty and ,mr4 ,wren were desired to consider the philosophy of shipping 444 and that ,mr4 ,wren bring in his account of the pendulum experiment40 ,wren was at ,oxford in the ,spring of #affa1 and things did not go well without him4 ,on ,may #h we find a resolution that a letter be sent him charging him in the ,king's name to make a globe of the moon and likewise to continue the description of several insects that he had begun4 ,sir ,robert ,moray transmitted the royal command in a very affectionate letter4 ,the moon was duly delivered to the ,king at ,whitehall1 who received it with great satisfaction4 ,on ,september #d there is reported some correspondence with ,sir ,kenelm ,digby and ,monsieur ,frenicle concerning ,wren's hypothesis about ,saturn's rings4 ,later there is a letter of ,wren's which records that1 although in #afeh he had made a model to illustrate his theory of ,saturn's rings1 he had withdrawn this hypothesis as soon as he had learnt of ,huygen's more convincing explanation4 ,on ,january #a1 #affb1 8,mr4 ,wren was requested to prosecute his design of trying by several round pasteboards their velocity in falling40 ,on the #hth ,dr4 ,wren brought in a scheme of a weather-clock4 ,on ,january #bb the pendulum experiment is described at length together with ,lord ,brouncker's calculation of the velocity of fall1 and at the same meeting it is recorded that 8,dr4 ,wren showed his experiment of filling a vessel with water which emptied itself when filled at a certain height40 ,on ,february #e 8,dr4 ,wren was desired to think of an easy way for a universal measure different from that of a pendulum40 ,this was a question of devising an absolute standard of length dependent upon some natural phenomenon1 which finally found expression in the metre and again in a standard of length derived by physicists from the wave-length of light4 ,on ,february #ab 8,dr4 ,wren proposed blacklead as a better means than oil for preserving the pivots of the wheels of watches and clocks from grating or wearing out40 ,on ,march #e 8the amanuensis was ordered to attend ,dr4 ,wren to take directions concerning the experiment of water in the long tube40 ,this means the setting up of a water barometer1 with water in place of the mercury of ,torricelli's experiment4 ,on ,september #c1 #affb1 it is recorded that 8it was referred to ,dr4 ,wren to take care of making the several experiments mentioned at the last meetings concerning the aqu salientes10 by which we are to understand the earliest experiments on the rise of liquids in capillary tubes4 ,the record goes on to say1 8,the request of the ,society made at the last meeting to ,dr4 ,wren about comparing the ,earl of ,sandwich's experiments was continued but it being a business of difficulty and much calculation required more time than he could yet obtain from his other employments40 ,none the less1 a week later 8,dr4 ,wren was reminded of promoting ,mr4 ,rooke's observations concerning motions of the satellites of ,jupiter10 and a fortnight later still1 8,dr4 ,wren presented some cuts done by himself in a new way of etching whereby he said he could almost as soon do a piece on a plate of glass as another could draw it with a crayon on paper40 ,at the same meeting1 too1 8,dr4 ,wren proposed the experiment of forcing up water in different pieces of different diameter and different altitudes 444 and was desired to bring a description of this experiment at the next meeting44440 ,on ,october #h of the same year 8,dr4 ,wren offered an experiment about the undulation of quicksilver in a crooked tube which he suggested was for the velocity of it proportional to the vibration of a pendulum4 ,he was desired to prosecute the experiment and to give in an account of it40 ,sprat1 in his ,history of the ,royal ,society1 lays especial stress on a scheme of work devised by ,wren in the interests of agriculture4 8,the second work 7the first was the ,doctrine of ,motion7 which he has advanced1 is the ,history of ,seasons2 which will be of admirable benefit to mankind1 if it shall be constantly pursued1 and derived down to posterity4 ,his proposal therefore was1 to comprehend a diary of wind1 weather1 and other conditions of the air1 as to heat1 cold1 and weight2 and also a general description of the year1 whether contagious or healthful to men or beasts2 with an account of epidemical diseases1 of blasts1 mildews1 and other accidents1 belonging to grain1 cattle1 fish1 fowl1 and insects40 ,nor must we forget ,wren's anatomical and surgical experiments4 ,in his early ,oxford days he devised instruments 7fully described by ,boyle7 for making injections into the blood of a dog1 which he tried very successfully 7for everyone but the dog74 ,he also skilfully removed the spleen of another dog which 8in less than a fortnight grew not only well1 but as sportive and wanton as before40 ,bound up in the heirloom ,parentalia is a most careful drawing by ,wren's hand of the anatomy of the river eel4 ,instances of his versatility over the whole field of science can be multiplied almost indefinitely4 ,from the end of #affb ,wren's name began to appear less frequently in the records of the ,royal ,society4 ,his increasing preoccupation with architecture and1 later1 his journey to ,paris provide the reason4 ,but these extracts do make clear that1 even when he was preoccupied with science1 ,wren's energies were to some extent dissipated by the universality of his interests and his practical skill as an experimenter4 ,they can be accepted as explaining why he did not become supreme in any one branch of science1 although any loss in this direction was1 perhaps1 more than compensated for by the richness of the experience and the breadth of mind that he was thereby enabled to turn to the service of architecture4 ,though architecture became an exacting mistress1 he always kept in touch with the ,royal ,society and1 after a period as ,vice-,president when he was often in the ,chair1 served as ,president in #afhj4 ,he could not give the time to experiment1 but he was an effective stimulus in the organisation of scientific thought1 and took an exceedingly active part in discussions which ranged from comets to the making of jessamine-scented gloves with daffodils1 from ,mr4 ,mercator's new projection of maps to the conclusion that 8all wholesome food should have oils0 7which smacks of vitamines71 from the structure of peat to the contrivance of an azimuth compass4 ,the incredible boy of ,wadham days had become the tireless ,president at fifty1 immersed in the greatest architectural practice of his century1 but still the enthusiastic scientist4 ,i find it all very astonishing4 ,,chapter ,v ,,beginnings ,,of ,,architecture ,,and ,,visit ,,to ,,paris ,wren's work as an architect seems to have begun in #affa1 when1 at the instance of ,john ,evelyn1 the ,king sent for him to come from ,oxford to serve as assistant to ,sir ,john ,denham1 ,surveyor-,general to ,his ,majesty's ,works4 ,denham was a moderate poet1 but no architect1 and his appointment was merely an excuse for giving him a salary4 ,john ,webb1 8,inigo ,jones's man10 had been serving ,denham as an assistant and was naturally distressed at the interposition of ,wren4 ,this is no place to attempt to estimate ,webb's place in ,english architecture4 ,he is put very high by some critics1 but ,evelyn's description of him as 8,inigo ,jones's man0 is probably fair4 ,he had attempted unsuccessfully to obtain the succession to ,inigo ,jones1 and1 on this second failure1 he seems to have retired from practice4 ,the neglect of him in ,wren's favour may have been a personal hardship1 but nobody will believe that ,english architecture was the sufferer4 ,webb belonged to another generation1 and the indolent ,charles had a right perception when he summoned the scientist to shape the architecture of the new era of the ,restoration4 ,in relation to ,wren's later and definitive appointment as ,surveyor-,general1 there is a reference in ,pepys' ,diary which ,i never read without a sense of personal relief4 ,on ,march #bast1 #affh-i1 ,pepys met ,hugh ,may1 very grieved that he had failed to secure the reversion of the ,surveyorship of the ,king's ,works1 on the recent death of ,sir ,john ,denham1 8by the unkindness of the ,duke of ,buckingham1 who hath brought in ,dr4 ,wren1 though1 he tells me1 he hath been his servant for twenty years together10 and so on1 8and yet the ,duke is so ungrateful as to put him by1 which is an ill thing1 though ,dr4 ,wren is a worthy man40 ,it was a lucky escape for ,english architecture1 but it is difficult to believe that ,buckingham1 or indeed anybody1 even in such venal times1 would have denied to ,wren the post which he filled so perfectly1 in favour of so sorry a fellow as ,hugh ,may4 ,it is worth noting that when ,may died in ,february1 #afhc-d1 his post as ,controller of the ,works at ,windsor ,castle fell to ,wren4 ,if ,may had never been in charge at ,windsor that ,castle might have been spared the indignity of the ,upper ,bailey1 which he designed of an ugliness so surpassing that ,wyattville's remodelling1 dreary as it is1 was a vast improvement4 ,how ,may saw the duties and opportunities of ,surveyor-,general of the ,king's ,works is shown by his consoling thoughts recorded by ,pepys4 ,the ,king was kind to ,may and promised him a pension of #cjj out of the ,works 7presumably an euphemism for out of ,wren's emoluments71 and that would be better than the place1 because1 owing to the lack of money1 he would have had to disoblige most people1 being not able to do what they desire to their lodgings4 ,there are many documents to show that ,wren dealt assiduously and successfully with the daily task of 8lodgings0 and other trivialities belonging to the interminable routine of his post1 but it is evident that ,hugh ,may would have done that and no more4 ,it was an escape4 ,for the first two years of ,wren's new appointment as ,denham's assistant1 he received no commissions for public works1 and when the ,king1 at the close of the war for ,tangier1 offered him the task of designing the mole and fortifications he wisely declined on grounds of health4 ,the letter of invitation was1 it is worth noting1 written by his cousin1 ,matthew ,wren1 the bishop's son1 who was secretary to ,hyde1 the ,lord ,chancellor4 ,wren's decision lost him a good salary and risked the reversion of ,sir ,john ,denham's post of ,surveyor-,general1 which was promised him if he would go to ,tangier2 but we may be thankful that he resisted even so honourable an exile1 and he seems not to have suffered by it4 ,his early labours at old ,st4 ,paul's will be described in the proper chapter1 but his first original work in architecture dates from early in #affc1 if we except a doorway at ,ely ,cathedral1 of the same year4 ,on ,april #bi he submitted to the ,royal ,society his model for a theatre to be built at ,oxford for the public acts of the ,university4 ,the ,sheldonian struck a note that was to become typical of ,wren's work1 for he was not afraid to adventure on a flat ceiling with a span of no less than #fh feet4 ,it was a cunning piece of construction and covered in a chamber of great interest but of uncertain design4 ,in the same year1 #affc1 was begun the ,chapel of ,pembroke ,college1 ,cambridge1 a thank-offering made by his uncle1 ,bishop ,matthew ,wren1 for coming safely through his long imprisonment4 ,pembroke ,chapel is a fine achievement of much greater artistic interest than the ,sheldonian1 and1 being completed long before the theatre1 was no doubt the model to which people turned1 in ,wren's early days of architecture1 as the proof of his real capacity in his new profession4 ,in #affe he was called in by ,trinity ,college1 ,oxford1 to design a new inner court with the definite instruction that he was to build a quadrangle4 ,wren protested that this idea was wrong1 but showed his skill in dealing with troublesome clients thus early4 ,writing to ,dr4 ,bathurst1 then ,president of ,trinity1 he said3 8,i am convinced with ,machiavel1 or some unlucky fellow1 'tis no matter whether ,i quote true1 that the world is generally governed by words4 ,i perceive the name of a quadrangle will carry with it those whom you say may possibly be your benefactors1 though it be much the worse situation for the chambers1 and the beauty of the college1 and of the particular pile of building 444 but1 to be sober1 if any body1 as you say1 will pay for a quadrangle1 there is no dispute to be made2 let them have a quadrangle1 though a lame one1 somewhat like a three-legged table40 ,wren had his way3 the ,trinity court is three-sided4 ,elmes1 in his ,life of ,wren1 says that the additions to ,trinity ,college1 ,cambridge1 were going on at the same time1 but this is a characteristic and obvious blunder1 for the letter from ,wren to the authorities of ,trinity1 quoted by ,elmes1 refers to the filling of the library arches with 8relieves of stone1 of which ,i have seen the effect abroad in good buildings40 ,wren's journey abroad did not take place until the summer of #affe1 and occupied about eight months4 ,he started for ,paris in the first week of ,july1 bearing a letter to the ,earl of ,st4 ,albans1 who represented ,english virtuosity in the ,french capital4 ,so much we know from the reprint in ,parentalia of a letter which returned thanks to a friend for getting him the introduction2 but the chief value of it for us is that ,wren took the opportunity to record some of his impressions4 ,he was enchanted with the collections of rarities that he saw1 and no doubt pleased himself with infinite conversations about science and philosophy with the scores of distinguished men he must have met4 ,but1 unhappily1 he was too busy to keep a diary or to write home at length1 and we have to be content with a few1 albeit precious1 obiter dicta4 8444 ,i hope ,i shall give you a very good ,account of all the best ,artists of ,france2 my ,business now is to pry into ,trades and ,arts1 ,i put myself into all ,shapes to humour them2 'tis a ,comedy to me1 and tho' sometimes expenceful1 ,i am loth yet to leave it40 ,wren had a delightful and fruitful visit4 8,i have10 he wrote1 8busied myself in surveying the most esteem'd ,fabricks of ,paris1 and the ,country round2 the ,louvre for a while was my daily ,object1 where no less than a thousand ,hands are constantly employ'd in the ,works2 some in laying mighty ,foundations1 some in raising the ,stories1 ,columns1 ,entablements1 etc41 with vast ,stones1 by great and useful ,engines2 others in ,carving1 ,inlaying of ,marbles1 ,plaistering1 ,painting1 ,gilding1 etc41 ,which altogether make a ,school of ,architecture1 the best probably1 at this ,day in ,europe4 ,the ,college of ,the four ,nations is usually admir'd1 but the ,artist hath purposely set it ill-favouredly that he might shew his ,wit in struggling with an inconvenient ,situation40 ,this last is a shrewd bit of criticism which did not apply to ,wren's own work1 for he always made the best of his opportunities4 ,it was the ,abb ,charles who introduced him to ,bernini1 8who shew'd me his ,designs for the ,louvre and of the ,king's ,statue 444 his design of the ,louvre ,i would have given my skin for1 but the old reserv'd ,italian gave me but a few ,minutes view2 it was five little ,designs in ,paper1 for which he hath receiv'd as many thousand ,pistoles2 ,i had only ,time to copy it in my ,fancy and ,memory2 ,i shall be able by ,discourse1 and a ,crayon1 to give you a tolerable account of it40 ,he had evidently planned to spend at least six months in studying ,french architecture1 for he wrote3 8,my ,lord ,berkley returns to ,england at ,christmas1 when ,i propose to take the ,opportunity of his ,company1 and by that ,time1 to perfect what ,i have on the ,anvil3 ,observations of the present ,state of ,architecture1 ,arts and ,manufactures in ,france40 ,unhappily1 his sight-seeing seems to have absorbed all his time in ,paris1 and when he got back the torrent of work carried him along and made impossible the fulfilment of the final promise of this letter4 ,wren had an easy pen1 and it is sad to think that what he had 8on the ,anvil0 never got into the muddled mass of manuscript from which his son compiled the ,parentalia4 ,what would we not give for more portraits of ,french architects and artists like his thumb-nail sketch of ,bernini1 that 8old reserv'd ,italian0 whose plans for the ,louvre never went any further8 ,in the result1 we have lost the observations which would have been a great addition to the literature of architecture4 ,he did not confine himself to the buildings of ,paris4 8,the ,palace1 or if you please1 the ,cabinet of ,versailles call'd me twice to view it2 the ,mixtures of ,brick1 ,stone1 blue ,tile and ,gold make it look like a rich ,livery3 ,not an ,inch within but is crowded with little ,curiosities of ,ornaments3 the ,women1 as they make here the ,language and ,fashions1 and meddle with ,politicks and ,philosophy1 so they sway also in ,architecture2 ,works of ,filgrand1 and little ,knacks are in great ,vogue2 but ,building certainty ought to have the ,attribute of eternal1 and therefore1 the only ,thing uncapable of new ,fashions4 ,the masculine ,furniture of ,palais ,mazarine pleas'd me much better where is a great and noble ,collection of antique ,statues and ,bustos40 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,ii ,,wren ,,as ,a ,,man ,,of ,,forty4 ,probably ,wren had little sympathy with the efforts of that typical ,frenchman ,philibert de l',orme to invent new ,orders a century earlier2 and is there a finer epigram of architecture than the phrase in italics8 ,but his travels took him wider than ,versailles4 8,after the incomparable ,villas of ,vaux and ,maisons1 ,i shall but name ,ruel1 ,courances1 ,chilly1 ,essoane1 ,st4 ,maur1 ,st4 ,mande1 ,issy1 ,meudon1 ,rincy1 ,chantilly1 ,verneul1 ,lioncour1 all which1 and ,i might add many others1 ,i have survey'd2 and that ,i might not lose the ,impressions of them1 ,i shall bring you almost all ,france in ,paper1 which ,i found by some or other ready design'd to my ,hand1 in which ,i have spent both ,labour and some ,money40 ,would that ,wren's collections and drawings had been preserved with something of the faithfulness which makes the ,adam collection at ,sir ,john ,soane's ,museum such a mine of information on one of ,wren's greatest successors4 ,one reference is helpful as showing the source of much of ,wren's detail1 though the work itself is informing without his note3 8,i have purchas'd a great deal of ,taille-douce1 that ,i might give our ,country-men ,examples of ,ornaments and ,grotesks1 in which the ,italians themselves confess the ,french to excel40 ,it would have been better if ,wren had relied more on ,english decorative motives4 ,unfortunately there is silence in the letter on the purpose of the jaunt abroad4 ,was the stay in ,paris the prelude to an intended visit to ,italy1 or was it an end in itself8 ,it is odd that he should not have followed the example of ,inigo ,jones and studied the ,renaissance at its source1 but there is no written evidence that he ever projected an extension of his journey southwards4 ,the effect of the ,paris journey was to give a ,french accent to ,wren's work throughout his life1 and to dilute the current of ,palladian influence1 which was not fully renewed in ,england until the ,earl of ,burlington1 ,william ,kent1 and others returned to ,inigo ,jones and his ,italian master as the fountains of inspiration4 ,it is useless to speculate as to how ,wren would have developed on a fuller ,italian basis4 ,his art would have been more informed3 he would almost certainly have avoided the technical uncertainties that mar some of his finest achievements3 but he could hardly have lost the freedom and inventiveness which make him one of the most individual of ,english architects4 ,one of the results of ,wren's ,french orientation might have been that of becoming a follower of ,vignola rather than ,palladio4 ,in spite1 however1 of ,mansard's work at ,maisons and ,blois1 ,wren1 probably from the influence of his great predecessor1 ,inigo ,jones1 remained on the whole faithful to ,palladio and the ,ancients4 ,as we shall see1 the two-order system of the exterior of ,st4 ,paul's was a practical necessity1 and not an artistic preference4 ,there is evidence enough from his work that he did not regard architecture as bound up with the application of ,orders to building1 or as the only means of salvation4 ,,chapter ,,vi ,,town-,,planning ,perhaps the most pregnant thing that ,wren learnt in ,france was the value of planning on spacious lines4 ,england was1 in #affe1 a country of medival cities4 ,such classical buildings as marked the change of taste were set down amidst surroundings of picturesque confusion4 ,if ,inigo ,jones had been able to create the great ,palace of ,whitehall1 of which the ,banqueting ,hall is but a symbolic fragment1 the ,grand ,manner would have been established in the land1 but when ,wren returned from ,france early in ,march1 #afff1 there was nothing to stimulate him except the ,piazza of ,covent ,garden and ,lincoln's ,inn ,fields laid out by ,inigo ,jones1 and his memory of the ,place des ,vosges of ,henri ,quatre4 ,perhaps ,bernini spoke of his great lay-out in front of ,st4 ,peter's4 ,the ,great ,fire of #afff gave him the opportunity4 ,by command of the ,king1 inspired doubtless by ,john ,evelyn1 who was himself an amateur town-planner of skill1 ,wren 8took an ,exact ,survey of the whole ,area and ,confines of the ,burning1 having traced over with great ,trouble and ,hazard1 the great ,plain of ,ashes and ,ruins2 and designed a ,plan or ,model of a new ,city1 in which the ,deformity and ,inconveniences of the old ,town were remedied44440 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,iii ,,wren',s ,,plan ,,of ,,london4 ,the outlines of his plan are seen in ,plate ,,iii4 ,they provided that the ,royal ,exchange should stand in a great piazza from which ten streets were to radiate2 three were to run to the river1 the midmost to ,london ,bridge1 and the river was to be embanked from ,blackfriars to the ,tower4 ,round the ,exchange1 on the islands formed by the radiating streets1 were to be built the halls of the ,goldsmiths' ,company 7the ,insurance ,office71 the ,mint1 and the ,post and ,excise ,offices4 ,from the ,exchange and running westwards were to be two great streets1 one passing the ,guildhall1 surrounded by the halls of the twelve great companies1 and another leading to ,st4 ,paul's4 ,the ,cathedral was to stand in a great triangular piazza at the junction of the street from the ,royal ,exchange and another running eastwards through two great octagonal or round piazzas to ,tower ,hill4 ,westwards of the ,cathedral ,wren devised a circular piazza from which radiated eight streets4 ,it was a gallant scheme which avoided all acute angles1 and set the parish churches on sites 8conspicuous and insular40 ,the streets were to be of three magnitudes--the three greatest1 which ran east and west1 and the two chief cross streets #ij feet wide1 secondary streets #fj feet1 and no lanes less than #cj feet4 ,a great canal was to run from the ,thames up ,bridewell northwards under ,holborn ,bridge1 and all offensive trades and those that used great fires were to be banished out of the ,city4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,augustin',s ,the ,king approved the plan1 as well he might1 and then the trouble began4 ,wren worked out a scheme whereby the freeholders of the ,city were to surrender their properties temporarily to ,commissioners4 ,their areas and frontages were to be noted1 and new sites given to them on the new alinement of streets with equal advantages as to area and frontage1 and1 needless to say1 vastly greater advantages in amenity and ultimate value4 ,no proprietor would have been seated exactly on his own site1 but none at any considerable distance from it1 and the intelligent grouping of trades would have been of advantage to everyone4 ,but the individualism of the ,londoner overbore every advantage that ,wren offered him4 ,he was content to lose the chance of being citizen of the most convenient if not the most magnificent ,city the world had seen1 and incidentally of benefiting his pocket enormously1 if only he could build again on the odd-shaped sites that he had inherited from his forefathers4 ,but we must not blame the seventeenth-century ,londoner too much4 ,wren was an honest man1 but the citizens might well be suspicious lest his town-planning schemes developed into a typical piece of ,caroline jobbery4 ,there was the little affair of a vast sum of money voted for a noble monument to ,charles the ,first4 ,wren designed it1 as bidden1 and the money was forthcoming1 but the monument remained on paper1 to the benefit of ,charles the ,second's pocket4 ,wren was an apostle of town-planning born out of due time1 and his vision faded4 ,we are constrained as the years go by to spend millions in re-creating small scraps of his scheme in the name of street improvements4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,martin',s ,s,t ,,paul',s ,but the labour he gave to his great plan was not all wasted4 ,he perceived that the ,cathedral and the parish churches were architecturally the keys of the situation1 and when he came to the rebuilding of both he saw ,london as a ,city marked by its churches4 ,foiled in his attempt to set them as elements in long vistas of noble streets of uniform houses1 he at least could determine that they should give a beautiful skyline1 and that the parish churches should be grouped justly in relation to the great bulk of the domed ,cathedral4 ,the picture of ,london from the ,thames which ,canaletto drew in #agfg shows what we have lost with the destruction of so many of ,wren's towers and spires and the blotting out of many others by the hideous incubus of ,cannon ,street ,station and rows of ten-storied warehouses4 ,wren travelled much by the highway we neglect1 in a boat on the ,thames1 and he must have thought much of the skyline as he passed from ,hampton ,court to ,st4 ,paul's1 and watched the ,city growing under his hand4 ,it seems clear that1 defeated in his major design1 ,wren determined on the next best policy of renewing the skyline of the old ,city4 ,generally speaking1 he rebuilt a tower where a tower only had stood and provided a spire where one had been before4 ,it is only from the lantern of ,st4 ,paul's or from the gallery of the ,monument that we can now get an idea of how entrancing ,london's skyline was when ,wren died1 but there is still enough to be seen to mark him as a great town-planner and to make the student breathe ineffectual sighs that the ,london of #afff was not worthy of him4 ,,chapter ,,vii ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,cathedral ,turner said of ,wren's ,cathedral that 8the dome of ,st4 ,paul's makes ,london10 but the same shrewd appreciation fell in better phrase from the lips of a friend of mine aged seven4 ,he had been taken by his father to ,st4 ,paul's1 and on his return home was observed to be drawing industriously4 ,when questioned as to his task1 he held up a rudimentary sketch of the ,cathedral1 in which the crowning feature of ,wren's achievement loomed unduly large1 and replied3 8,i've drawn the ,dome of ,london40 ,i have met no better phrase of architectural criticism in more than thirty years of reading4 ,the monument of ,italian ,unity has shifted the architectural command of ,rome from the dome of ,st4 ,peter's to the ,capitoline ,hill1 but ,st4 ,paul's still crowns ,london with ,wren's dome4 ,sir ,christopher's connection with the ,cathedral dates from #affc1 when the derelict state of the old church drove the ,king to appoint a ,commission to consider its restoration4 ,it is not certain1 though it is likely1 that both ,wren and ,evelyn served as ,commissioners2 but little was done save casual repairs until about ,may1 #afff1 when ,wren laid before the ,commission a report descriptive of the state of the fabric with recommendations as to what should be done4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,iv ,,the ,,welbeck ,,portrait4 ,there were two parties on the ,commission3 one for mere patching and mending1 another1 with ,wren as protagonist1 for a substantial reconstruction on classical lines4 ,inigo ,jones1 when he added the great western portico1 had refaced the outside of the church with big stones1 part of a general scheme by which the cathedral would have been re-fronted1 as happened to so many of the older churches of ,france and ,italy4 ,wren's policy was to do the same to the interior1 8and it will be as easy to perform it after a good ,roman manner as to follow the ,gothick ,rudeness of the old ,design40 ,he favoured a new vault and cupola1 not of lead-covered timber1 but of 8brick1 if it be plaistered with ,stucco1 which is a harder plaister40 ,the essence of his proposals was1 to remodel the tower and crossing4 ,he was1 in fact1 proposing to remove the four great piers of the old crossing1 as ,alan of ,walsingham had done at ,ely1 where the old central tower had collapsed4 ,as ,wren's uncle was ,bishop of ,ely1 he was familiar with this bold idea4 8,i cannot propose a better remedy than by cutting off the inner corners of the ,cross1 to reduce this middle part into a spacious ,dome or ,rotundo1 with a ,cupola or hemispherical roof1 and upon the ,cupola a ,lantern with a spring top1 to rise proportionably4 ,by this means the ,church will be rendered spacious in the middle1 which may be a very proper place for a vast auditory40 ,here was the germ of the ,st4 ,paul's which we know4 ,on ,august #bg1 #afff1 there was a lively meeting of the ,commission when ,evelyn1 as we learn from his ,diary1 backed ,wren's proposals against ,chichele and ,pratt1 who were against any new-fangled notions1 and wanted merely to repair the steeple on its old foundation4 8,but we10 writes ,evelyn1 8totally rejected it and persisted that it required a new foundation1 not only in regard of the necessity1 but for that the shape of what stood was very mean and we had a mind to build it with a noble cupola1 a form of church building not as yet known in ,england but of wonderful grace40 ,it is difficult to guess why ,pratt1 as a pupil of ,inigo ,jones1 resisted the idea of extending to the interior what the elder master had done outside4 ,perhaps ,pratt resented the intrusion of ,wren on some personal grounds4 ,alternatively it is conceivable that the ,jones school were more impressed with the merits of medival architecture than is commonly supposed4 ,as it turned out1 ,chichele and ,pratt were right about the solidity of the old central piers4 ,contrary to experience outside ,london they proved very difficult to demolish4 ,it may be that some tradition of the old ,roman secret remained in ,london1 where old walls are a byword for resistance to removal4 ,if ,wren had known as much about mortars as the old builders1 much of the trouble with his ,st4 ,paul's would have been avoided4 ,after much argument it was agreed the innovators should produce a plan and estimate4 ,this design is preserved at ,all ,souls1 and shows an inner and outer dome surmounted by a lantern crowned with a huge openwork pineapple #fh feet high1 of what ,sir ,reginald ,blomfield justly calls 8a monstrous and horrible design40 ,but the scheme went no further4 ,on ,sunday1 ,september #bnd1 within a week of the ,commission meeting1 the ,great ,fire broke out4 ,by the #gth ,pepys saw the 8miserable sight of ,paul's ,church1 with all the roof fallen and the body of the quire fallen into ,st4 ,faith's40 ,evelyn was there the same day and infinitely concerned3 8,thus lay in ashes that most venerable ,church40 ,the destruction was complete4 ,very soon after the ,fire1 ,wren was appointed principal architect for rebuilding the whole ,city1 and set about fitting part of ,st4 ,paul's ruins for temporary use in ,divine ,service4 ,on ,january #ae1 #affg1 the ,king made order to that effect1 and on ,march #e a sub-committee was set up to do something4 ,they seem to have been lamentable dullards1 for they still harped on the idea of patching up the ruins1 and attempted to do so1 despite ,wren's protests4 ,he seems to have followed the wise course of leaving them to their tinkerings and to the ,nemesis of a tottering fabric1 with good and inevitable results4 ,after the shattering experience of the ,fire1 the new facing of large stones could not be secured properly to the old walls4 ,a year and some money had been wasted before ,dean ,sancroft wrote to ,wren1 then at ,oxford1 on ,april #be1 #affh1 to say3 8,what you whispered in my ear1 at your last coming hither1 is come to pass4 ,our work at the west end of ,st4 ,paul's is fallen about our ears40 ,sancroft expected worse would follow1 confessed that they were helpless without ,wren1 and begged him to come to ,london4 ,it would appear that ,wren was not satisfied as to their change of heart1 and thought it wiser to let them muddle along into worse trouble before he went to their aid4 ,they still went on patching until things got quite hopeless1 when ,wren received a peremptory order from the ,archbishop and the other ,commissioners to attend with all speed4 ,in one thing ,sancroft seems to have been wiser than ,wren4 ,he was all for the planning of a 8design1 handsome and noble1 and suitable to all the ends of it1 and to the reputation of the city and the nation1 and to take it for granted that money will be had to accomplish it40 ,wren wanted to know what money they would provide before he set about a design1 and to delay action until men's minds were less distracted with all the troubles that followed the ,fire4 ,after more argument ,wren convinced everyone that the first business was to give up all ideas of patching and to sweep the site clear of the ruins4 ,this task lasted until ,april1 #afgd4 ,illustration3 ,,the ,,second ,,design ,,for ,,st4 ,,paul',s1 ,,also ,,known ,,as ,,the 8,,rejected ,,design0 ,,and ,,the 8,,model ,,design40 ,the story of ,wren's many designs for the new ,cathedral is confusing and need not be followed here in detail4 ,the ,first ,design1 made before the ,fire1 has been mentioned4 ,the ,second ,design1 also known as the 8,rejected ,design0 and the 8,model ,design10 was an attempt to gratify 8the taste of the ,conoisseurs and ,criticks with something coloss and beautiful1 conformable to the best stile of the ,greek and ,roman architecture40 ,this was one of several submitted to the ,king1 and was approved by ,royal ,warrant of ,november #ab1 #afgc4 ,a model of it was made1 now in the ,south ,kensington ,museum1 and its plan and perspective are reproduced here4 ,it represented a great break from traditional ,cathedral treatment4 ,planned as a ,greek cross1 to which a short western arm 7a vestibule or narthex7 was added later1 a central space #abj feet in diameter was formed by eight great piers carrying a dome1 and the ambulatory included four shallow domes4 ,the octagonal church of ,santa ,maria della ,salute gives perhaps as good an idea as any of the general scope of the scheme1 which ,sir ,charles ,barry thought might supply a hint for ,english church building4 ,the western vestibule was roofed with a smaller dome and finished with a colonnaded portico4 ,it was a noble idea1 but the clergy thought it unsuitable for services1 and the absence of chapels annoyed the ,duke of ,york1 who1 with his supporters1 still hoped for a restoration of the old religion4 ,wren had to abandon the scheme1 not1 it is said1 without actual tears4 ,it is recorded in ,parentalia that 8the ,surveyor1 in private ,conversation1 always seem'd to set a higher value on this ,design1 than any he had made before or since2 as what was laboured with more ,study and ,success2 and 7had he not been over-rul'd by those1 whom it was his ,duty to ,obey7 what he would have put into ,execution with more ,chearfulness and ,satisfaction to himself than the latter40 ,illustration3 ,,plan ,,of ,,the 8,,rejected ,,design40 ,about eighteen months passed before the ,third ,design was submitted to the ,king and approved by warrant dated ,may #ad1 #afge4 ,it is known as the ,warrant ,design4 ,so unworthy is it of ,wren's genius that his apologists have been ingenious in explaining it away4 ,miss ,phillimore thought it the result of overwork and worry4 ,loftie believed that ,wren was 8in the nearest thing to a bad temper of which his meek and quiet spirit was capable10 and pitched it at ,charles as a joke1 thinking that the ,king might as well sign the silliest design he could produce as he had rejected a sound scheme4 ,be that as it may--and it is not very like ,wren to play the fool--,charles passed this preposterous design as 8very artificial proper and useful10 giving ,wren 8liberty in the prosecution of his work1 to make some ,variations1 rather ,ornamental than ,essential1 as from time to time he should see proper1 and to leave the ,whole to his management40 ,the design now reproduced carries its own condemnation on its face4 ,the western towers and the portico with its single skinny ,order were exceedingly feeble1 and the crowning of the dome by a kind of parody of ,st4 ,bride's steeple is a feature that is best passed over in silence4 ,but if it were not simply a lark1 it might have been the result of a demand for a spire that should remind ,london of the glory of ,st4 ,paul's old spire1 which had been the highest in ,europe4 ,illustration3 ,,west ,,elevation ,,of ,,the 8,,warrant ,,design40 ,happily ,wren interpreted his permission for ornamental variations by drastic changes in essentials in the elevations1 but he did not greatly change the 8warrant0 plan4 ,his frame of mind may well be judged by the note1 which follows the recital of the #afge ,warrant1 in ,parentalia3 8,from that time1 the ,surveyor resolved to make no more ,models1 or publickly expose his ,drawings1 which 7as he had found by ,experience7 did but lose ,time1 and subjected his ,business1 many ,times1 to incompetent ,judges40 ,therefore1 just as the present ,houses of ,parliament grew out of the castle design1 done by ,barry in #ahcf1 by his twenty years of thought and work1 so the grandeur of ,st4 ,paul's developed with the mind of ,wren incessantly occupied in its creation for nearly double that time4 ,no one could help him in this gradual evolution of his thought1 but many could1 and did1 obstruct its execution4 ,the taking down of the vast ruins of the old ,cathedral made a heavy task1 and ,wren took to gunpowder for demolishing the piers of the old central tower4 ,this worked well1 but on its second employment by a subordinate1 when ,wren was out of town1 too much gunpowder was used and a stone was blown into a neighbouring house4 ,no bones were broken1 but ,wren was told to find less desperate methods and achieved his end with 8that ancient ,engine in ,war1 the ,battering-ram40 ,wren's troubles with the foundations made a long and too technical story for so slight a sketch as this1 but it is fair to his memory to set down that though some early trouble was experienced from settlements which young ,edward ,strong1 the son of ,wren's master-mason1 was called in to repair1 the present troubles are due more to the draining of the subsoil by recent engineering works1 such as great sewers1 and to the use of rubble inside a casing of ashlar1 than to any defect in the foundation design4 ,one notable change in the design of the ,west ,front must be emphasised because it marks the influence1 in this case the overmastering influence1 of material over design4 ,wren devised the front with a single great ,order 7as ,inigo ,jones had done in the portico he added71 therein following the scheme of ,st4 ,peter's at ,rome4 ,bramante had quarried at ,tivoli pieces big enough for the drums of his columns1 but had to spoil his cornices for lack of stones of adequate size4 ,wren was defeated in his hope of securing drums big enough from the ,portland1 ,rock ,abbey1 and other quarries1 and 8for these ,reasons the ,surveyor concluded upon ,portland-stone1 and was able to use two ,orders and by that ,means to keep the just ,proportions of his ,cornices2 otherwise he must have fallen short of the ,heighth of the ,fabrick1 which now exerts itself over all the ,country1 as well as ,city1 as it did of old1 when that ,structure1 tho' rude1 was lofty and majestick40 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,v ,,bust ,,by ,,edward ,,pearce ,,at ,,the ,,ashmolean1 ,,done ,,about #afgc1 ,,and ,,showing ,,wren ,,as ,a ,,man ,,of ,,forty-,,one4 ,the first stone of the new church was laid in #afge1 and during thirty-five years1 from the forty-third to the seventy-eighth of the architect's life1 ,st4 ,paul's was his constant preoccupation4 ,troubles were many4 ,the #afge plan was without the two western chapels 7that now used by the ,order of ,st4 ,michael and ,st4 ,george and its fellow on the north side74 ,they were introduced into the scheme by the insistence of the ,duke of ,york4 ,but the fundamental novelty of ,st4 ,paul's1 the double dome1 was present in his pre-,fire design1 and whatever else was changed1 that remained4 ,persons of ,revival ,gothic mind have been much troubled in conscience by the 8falsity0 of this treatment1 though it has the admitted result of giving an absolutely right effect inside and out1 and has been followed in nearly all the subsequent domes of this scale4 ,the provision of an inner and an outer dome is held nowadays to be justified abundantly by the result4 ,the brick cone that triumphantly carries the lantern1 which is as high and large as many a church tower1 is one of the many evidences of ,wren's engineering skill4 ,the architect was fortunate in the men who carried out his work4 ,edward ,strong1 the master-mason1 and ,richard ,jennings1 the master-carpenter1 were faithful servants in carrying out the bones of the great structure2 and such artists as ,grinling ,gibbons in the choir stalls1 and ,tijou in the wonderful iron screens served ,wren's turn to perfection4 ,at ,st4 ,paul's there is none of that carelessness of detail which defaces many of the ,city churches4 ,there is little doubt that ,wren was constantly on the works1 watching everything in detail1 revising and directing on the spot the great fabric as it grew under his hand4 ,illustration3 ,,plan ,,of ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,as ,,built4 ,the dotted lines show the alinement of railings as intended by ,wren4 ,the cost of rebuilding was borne by the 8coal-money10 a duty of #as4 #f;d4 a chaldron on all coal imported into ,london1 of which four-fifths were allocated to ,st4 ,paul's4 ,even so the works were often in danger for lack of funds1 and money had to be borrowed in advance of the coal-money receipts4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,vi ,,the ,,west ,,front ,,of ,,st4 ,,paul',s4 ,the funds received from all sources1 including borrowings1 amounted in #agjj to #a1afg1dgd1 but part of this went in interest paid out and in repaying loans and part in acquiring neighbouring property4 ,the net cost is given by ,longman as #gdf1ffa4 ,the choir was opened for ,divine ,service on ,december #b1 #afig1 on the ,thanksgiving ,day for the ,peace on the ,treaty of ,ryswick4 ,by #agjh the dome was ready to be covered4 ,the ,committee wanted copper to be used4 ,wren held out for lead1 and lead it was and is4 ,in #agaj young ,christopher ,wren was deputed by his father to lay the top-stone of the lantern which surmounts the dome1 and did it in the presence of ,sir ,christopher and ,edward ,strong and other workmen who had been engaged on the building4 ,it was a proud day for the old man of seventy-eight who had carried through a unique task despite every difficulty4 ,he was treated with incredible meanness4 ,from the start of the work he had received the meagre salary of #bjj a year1 and in #afif-g an ,act 8for the completing and adorning the ,cathedral ,church0 was passed which included the miserable provision 8to suspend a moiety of the ,surveyor's salary until the said ,church should be finished1 thereby the better to encourage him to finish the same with the utmost diligence and expedition40 ,it was a spiteful business1 which ,wren bitterly resented1 and not until ,christmas1 #agaa1 did he secure the payment of the arrears of half-pay on the passing of an ,act which certified the ,cathedral was finished4 ,but even then much remained to be done1 and in the doing of it ,wren was hampered and thwarted at every turn by the narrow-minded ,commissioners4 ,it is a miserable story and hardly worth telling but that ,wren's reputation needs to be defended as to some features of ,st4 ,paul's which he resisted ineffectually4 ,the squabble about the enclosing railings is no longer interesting because they have disappeared1 but the painting of the inner dome by ,thornhill with opaque masses of figures instead of the mosaic ,wren had intended was a severe trouble to him4 ,still worse was the insistence of the ,commissioners on the balustrade which crowns the upper cornice4 ,wren's letter to them in ,october1 #agag1 was a vigorous protest for a man of eighty-five4 8,i take leave1 first1 to declare that ,i never designed a balustrade4 ,persons of little skill in architecture did expect1 ,i believe1 to see something they had been used to in ,gothic structures1 and ladies think nothing well without an edging4 ,i should gladly have complied with the vulgar taste1 but ,i suspended for the reasons following40 ,the reasons were good and many1 but the ,commissioners preferred to be lady-like1 and the balustrade was put up4 ,this was in #agag4 ,in #agah ,king ,george the ,first superseded ,wren as ,surveyor-,general in favour of a rascal called ,william ,benson1 so incompetent that he was dismissed ignominiously a year later4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,vii ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,under ,,the ,,dome4 ,from an old engraving dedicated to ,bishop ,van ,mildert by ,josiah ,taylor4 ,in ,wren's own writing there appears in the ,,ms4 chronology of his life and works an entry in ,greek which runs1 translated3 ,april #bf1 #agah4 ,and there arose a king that knew not ,joseph4 ,and ,gallio cared for none of these things4 ,he retired to his house at ,hampton ,court observing 8,nunc me jubet ,fortuna expeditius philosophari0 and1 in a strain of piety1 which was as truly characteristic as the ,stoic note1 8,if ,i glory1 it is in the singular mercy of ,god1 who has enabled me to begin and finish my great work1 so conformable to the ancient model40 ,after more than two hundred years we rejoice to add1 in the words of the ,bicentenary ,service1 8,we render ,thee thanks1 ,o ,lord1 for the singular gifts which ,thou didst bestow upon ,thy servant1 ,christopher ,wren40 ,the malevolence of his masters at the ,cathedral pursued him to the grave1 but it gave his son the opportunity of inventing an immortal epitaph4 ,sir ,christopher was buried in the crypt1 but the suggestion of a monument was rejected by the authorities4 ,so the younger ,christopher1 seeking to explain the absence of a fitting memorial in the place of his father's greatest triumph1 wrote on the plain tablet which marks his resting-place1 as the closing words of his epitaph1 8,,si ,,monumentum ,,requiris3 ,,circumspice40 ,but the fatuous proceedings of ,commissioners and ,king alike have faded into their proper perspective1 and ,st4 ,paul's remains the supreme monument of the genius of a single architect4 ,what1 in fact1 did ,wren achieve in the building of ,st4 ,paul's8 ,much can be written of his handling of the ,orders1 of his structure of the dome1 of the details of the plan1 and so forth2 but there are broader issues involved4 ,st4 ,paul's gave the first opportunity since the ,middle ,ages for the creation of a ,cathedral in ,england1 and ,wren's task was a ,protestant ,cathedral4 ,hitherto the ,cathedral builder had made two churches under one roof1 a choir for ,canons1 whether secular or regular1 or for monks1 and a nave for the laity1 the two divided by a solid screen which prevented nave worshippers from seeing the high altar4 ,wren's plan was a half-way house between the medival type and the idea of ,st4 ,peter's with the high altar as the central feature under the dome4 ,it was a classical translation of the plan of his uncle's ,cathedral of ,ely1 in so far as it retained the aisle vistas by supporting the dome on eight piers instead of four4 ,it was ,english in that it set the altar in a ritual choir well to the east of the crossing4 ,it was ,protestant and characteristic of ,wren's views in its provision of an admirable 8auditory40 ,st4 ,paul's ,cathedral may fairly be called the apogee of ,english ,baroque1 because it is the finest ,english expression of what ,mr4 ,geoffrey ,scott calls the ,architecture of ,humanism4 ,it represents with peculiar faithfulness the outlook of the best minds of the last half of the seventeenth century1 for ,wren was one of them1 and had the power to give it expression4 ,st4 ,peter's1 the only church with which it is not unnaturally compared1 was a pasticcio of many minds brought to bear in succession on a far larger but not sthetically more difficult problem1 and it suffers from a consequent confusion1 as well as from its abnormal scale4 ,st4 ,paul's was the work of one commanding personality1 who developed indeed in the course of its building--the difference between the warrant plan and the church itself is proof enough of that--but he did so consistently and with a single aim4 ,westminster ,abbey is the supreme flower of ,gothic art in ,england1 if not in the world1 and the perfect expression of the ,age of ,faith4 ,st4 ,paul's is a no less perfect emblem of what ,england could make of humanistic ideals in art joined with robust ,english ,churchmanship expressed through so sincere an ,anglican as was ,sir ,christopher ,wren4 ,st4 ,paul's is incomparable--the word is used advisedly--as a piece of architecture1 and it is prodigiously ,english4 ,,chapter ,,viii ,,the ,,city ,,churches ,the parish churches of ,sir ,christopher ,wren once numbered fifty-three4 ,of these1 ,st4 ,andrew ,holborn1 ,st4 ,clement ,danes1 and ,st4 ,james ,piccadilly1 cannot rightly be included amongst the ,city churches1 as they are outside 8the square mile40 ,of the remaining fifty1 ,st4 ,dunstan-in-the-,east1 ,st4 ,mary ,aldermary1 ,st4 ,sepulchre1 and the destroyed ,st4 ,christopher1 were only repaired by ,wren4 ,fifteen have been wholly destroyed1 and of ,st4 ,mary ,somerset only the tower remains4 ,only thirty therefore remain in the ,city1 and of these many have been so modernised that their value has in part disappeared4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,vedast ,many devout admirers of ,wren have done his memory a serious disservice by indiscriminate praise4 ,it is no doubt an amiable fault1 but it does much to confuse serious public issues1 such as the question of 8the nineteen doomed churches0 which has lately agitated the public mind and will do so again4 ,i will not discuss here whether it is ever permissible to remove any church1 but if destruction can in any circumstances be allowed1 discussion must revolve round the quality of what is doomed4 ,it is common form for disputants to talk as though all city churches were ,wren churches1 and all ,wren churches perfect churches4 ,in point of fact thirteen of the nineteen were by ,wren4 ,of the six that were not1 ,st4 ,mary ,woolnoth1 by ,hawksmoor1 is of as great importance as a ,wren church1 and much more interesting than many4 ,of the 8doomed0 thirteen by ,wren1 ,st4 ,vedast ,foster ,lane1 is said now to be out of danger3 the steeple is superb1 the nave merely a restoration with some good fittings left4 ,the leaded lantern on the tower of ,st4 ,nicholas ,cole ,abbey1 is exceedingly valuable1 and its removal would be a crime1 but it would be a waste of tears to shed them on the modernized nave4 ,st4 ,stephen's1 ,coleman ,street1 also has a pleasant little lantern1 but if anyone supposes the interior is typical ,wren he cannot detect the more glaring feats of the restorer4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,alban ,in the case of ,st4 ,michael ,paternoster ,royal1 ,st4 ,michael ,cornhill1 ,st4 ,mary ,aldermanbury1 ,st4 ,anne and ,st4 ,agnes1 ,st4 ,alban ,wood ,street1 and ,all ,hallows ,lombard ,street1 there is enough of characteristic ,wren in tower or church1 or both1 to justify retention2 but it is difficult to be enthusiastic about ,st4 ,clement ,eastcheap1 now1 and it cannot have been easy before the church was modernized4 ,if a hand were laid on a stone of ,st4 ,magnus ,london ,bridge1 it would be an abomination4 ,the tower of ,st4 ,dunstan-in-the-,east is unique for its date1 and of quite extraordinary interest3 any idea of removing it should be resisted with vehemence4 ,but why anyone should be the least concerned at the disappearance of the body of the church is known only to those who detect beauty in the ,gothic adventures of ,messrs4 ,laing and ,tite in the year #ahaj4 ,of ,st4 ,mary-at-,hill the ugly #aghj tower replaced a medival tower which escaped the fire1 and the interior has been somewhat havocked in latter days4 ,st4 ,clement ,eastcheap has some good fittings1 but1 always small and unimportant1 its quality has been greatly modified by the restorer4 ,these notes are set down in the hope that the case for the maintenance forever of the nobler works of ,wren will not be vitiated1 confused1 and1 in the minds of plain men1 made ridiculous by hysterical praise of his meanest buildings from which such small quality as they once possessed has been removed by modern vandalisms4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,dunstan',s ,the achievement of ,sir ,christopher ,wren was vast1 and for that very reason there must be discrimination between those buildings on which he lavished his utmost personal care and those which1 in the press of a huge practice1 were designed mainly by assistants and carried out probably with the slenderest supervision by the master4 ,a glance at the ,chronology ,i print in an appendix will show the sort of pressure at which ,wren worked during the ten years following the ,fire4 ,examination of the ,accounts of the ,city ,churches reveals that payments began to be made in #afgj to the builders of seventeen churches1 and six years later the number had grown to twenty-eight4 ,actual work on practically the whole of the fifty-three had been completed by #afij4 ,none was begun after #afhf and payments were made on eight only between #afij and #afie4 ,wren did comparatively little after #agjj except the completion of ,st4 ,paul's and ,greenwich4 ,this means that the great majority of his vast bulk of achievement was done within about thirty years4 ,is it any wonder that some of his churches show signs of haste and want of thought8 ,can we suppose anything but that some of them were left largely to assistants8 ,the year of his first marriage was his annus mirabilis1 for during #affi he must have been working on the plans for the seventeen churches which began to be built in #afgj1 and he was developing the design of ,st4 ,paul's at the same time4 ,evelyn's word prodigious seems to meet the case4 ,i have already referred to the towers and spires as showing ,wren's sure touch as a tower-planner1 but the amazing variety of their treatment is notable evidence of ,wren being1 par excellence1 the architect of adventure4 ,as ,i wrote many years ago in a detailed examination,a of the leaded spires1 8he created within the square mile of the city more forms of steeples than all the architects of the ,middle ,ages1 and if1 as was inevitable1 some pay the penalty of rash experiment1 others made an assured success40 ,twenty-eight of the towers are crowned with either spire or lantern1 nine of stone1 and nineteen of leaded timber4 ,some are true spires1 others spire-form steeples1 and the rest lanterns3 this classification is loose and arbitrary1 but 8,wren's masterful way of playing with architectural elements and combining them in astonishing ways makes havoc of any orderly description40 ,the preponderance of leaded spires may be attributed partly to his affection for the most characteristic ,english metal--he chose it for ,st4 ,paul's dome after considering copper--and partly to their cheapness as compared with stone4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,magnus ,st4 ,swithin's ,cannon ,street has a spire of ,gothic type1 and ,wren stepped from the square of the tower to the octagon of the spire by trimming the tower angles to a splay1 a short cut no medival builder would have employed4 ,at ,st4 ,margaret's ,pattens ,rood ,lane1 the tower finishes normally with pinnacles at the corners1 and the spire1 instead of being leaded with vertical rolls as at ,st4 ,swithin's1 is treated with a series of sunk panels1 a beautiful and ingenious method3 ,st4 ,margaret's spire is indeed a faultless work4 ,wren did nothing in stone to match the form of these two4 ,exquisite in its delicacy is the leaded needle spire of ,st4 ,martin ,ludgate1 set on an arcaded lantern which grows in turn out of an ogee roof1 and the latter break is marked by a railed balcony4 ,obelisks take the place of a spire at ,st4 ,margaret ,lothbury1 a steeple of miraculous simplicity1 and at ,st4 ,mildred's ,bread ,street4 ,the tower of ,st4 ,lawrence ,jewry is crowned by a more massive composition1 and the outline of ,st4 ,augustine's ,watling ,street is a little uncertain4 ,at ,st4 ,benet ,paul's ,wharf the combination of dome and lantern is perfect in its little way4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,margaret',s ,,pattens ,amongst the stone steeples ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow and ,st4 ,bride's ,fleet ,street will always have champions to argue which is the greater4 ,bow ,tower has a romantic1 almost ,jacobean1 quality which contrasts strongly with the austere outline of ,st4 ,bride's4 ,it may be significant of a special importance attached to it by ,wren that it is the only tower which has a bill of account1 separate from that of the church1 in the full priced accounts which ,i have dealt with in detail elsewhere4 ,it cost #g1chh and the church #h1jga1 whereas ,st4 ,bride's altogether accounted only for #aa1dcj4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,bride',s ,the question of the money spent on the ,city churches is of considerable interest4 ,the total paid out was #bfc1ghf #ajs4 #d;d41 and the amounts entered up against each church were corrected to farthings4 ,these figures exclude most of the internal fittings1 which must have been the gift of pious parishioners4 ,the ,,ms4 accounts in the ,bodleian are abstracted in my ,archologia paper1,b and give the names of every mason1 bricklayer1 plumber1 painter1 etc41 employed1 with the amounts he 7or sometimes she7 received4 ,i transcribed the complete bills for ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow with ,bow ,tower and for ,st4 ,stephen's ,walbrook4 ,the latter cost #g1feb #acs4 #h;d41 and only six churches exceeded that sum4 ,in some ways it is the most notable of them all1 for ,wren contrived to give the effect of nave1 aisles and crossing to a plain room by his ingenuity in carrying a circular dome on eight arches which rest on an entablature supported by twelve columns4 ,east of the dome is one groined bay1 and west of it two groined bays divided by four more columns3 the side aisles have flat ceilings4 ,the plan is thus an oblong room with sixteen free columns1 but so cleverly disposed as to produce the variety of effect described above4 ,sir ,reginald ,blomfield justly says of the details that they are 8coarse and irrelevant10 but the interior is a masterpiece of scenic planning1 and the dome a not unworthy trial piece for what followed at ,st4 ,paul's4 ,a melancholy remodelling in #ahdg-h1 the plans of which are preserved at the ,r4,i4,b4,a41 destroyed some of the character of the church1 but the accompanying illustration shows it in the 8unimproved0 state as ,wren left it4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,viii ,,st4 ,,stephen',s1 ,,walbrook4 ,st4 ,lawrence ,jewry is another of the churches in which the architect was not pinched for funds4 ,it cost #aa1hgj1 but is on a somewhat uninteresting plan--oblong1 with an aisle on one side only4 ,here1 as in almost every church he built1 ,wren was a determined economist of space1 and with good reason4 ,about eighty churches had been destroyed in the ,fire1 only fifty were rebuilt1 and every sitting was of importance4 ,so he did not square up his building if the site was irregular1 but made the best1 usually a very ingenious best1 of whatever odd shape he had to cover in4 ,and there was another consideration4 ,it is obvious from the sums paid for many of the churches1 as well as from the evidence of the fabrics1 that ,wren did not pull down an old wall if he could mend it and save it4 ,there is1 therefore1 all the more reason to respect these ,city churches1 which retain so much history in their walls1 going back even to the earliest times4 ,always practical and always an opportunist of the right sort1 he made the best job he could with the materials and money he had at disposal4 ,a more general realisation of this would prevent criticism of details1 which ought to be addressed rather to parsimonious clients than to the architect4 ,sometimes1 however1 he made a brilliant excursion to meet the needs of an odd-shaped site as at ,st4 ,benet ,fink1 which he planned as a decagon4 ,this enchanting church stood behind the ,royal ,exchange and had a beautiful little dome and lantern on its tower3 the late ,mr4 ,peabody now sits in bronze on the site4 ,at ,st4 ,antholin's1 a church in ,watling ,street1 with a superb stone tower and spire1 all swept away in circumstances of infamy1 he got over a swerve in the street alinement by splaying the plan at the west end4 ,at ,st4 ,mary ,abchurch and ,st4 ,swithin's1 he had short1 broad1 and slightly irregular sites to deal with1 and covered in a square with a dome and let the rest work out as it would4 ,st4 ,mildred ,bread ,street is a longer oblong which ,wren treated very delightfully by covering the middle with a dome and the ends with round arches4 ,the need to house large congregations led him to provide galleries at ,christ ,church ,newgate ,street1 ,st4 ,james ,piccadilly1 ,st4 ,bride's1 ,st4 ,andrew-in-the-,wardrobe1 and elsewhere4 ,wren's outlook on the whole problem of parish-church design was indicated with his usual clarity in a letter which he wrote to guide his fellow ,commissioners in the task of building fifty new churches in ,queen ,anne's reign4 ,written when he was nearing eighty1 the letter sums up the experience of an amazing lifetime of church building4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,mildred,,bread ,s,t ,he is strongly against burials in churches and commends the idea of cemeteries on the outskirts of the towns which will 8bound the excessive growth of the ,city with a graceful border1 which is now encircled with scavengers' dung stalls40 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,bride',s ,in the siting of churches1 ,wren is against too nice an observation of 8east and west in the position1 unless it falls out properly10 and wants to see them brought as forward as possible into the larger and more open streets4 8,such fronts as shall happen to lie most open to view should be adorned with porticoes1 both for beauty and convenience2 which together with handsome spires or lanterns rising in good proportion above the neighbouring houses 7of which ,i have given several examples in the ,city of different forms7 may be of sufficient ornament to the town1 without a great expense for enriching the outward walls of the churches1 in which plainness and duration ought principally1 if not wholly1 to be studied44440 ,a long paragraph is devoted to the question of materials4 ,he complains bitterly of the badness of the available bricks1 despite the fact that ,london earth will yield a brick more durable than 8any stone our island affords40 ,wren is all for ,portland-stone for windows and doors1 and likes oak for roofs 8because it will bear some negligence4 ,the churchwardens' care may be defective in speedy mending drips3 they usually whitewash the church1 and set up their names1 but neglect to preserve the roof over their heads40 ,there is an oddly topical flavour in the note that 8the wars in the ,north ,sea make timber at present of excessive price10 and a prophecy of ,imperial trading in3 8,i suppose1 ere long1 we must have recourse to the ,west ,indies1 where most excellent timber may be had for cutting and fetching40 ,as to roof coverings1 8our tiles are ill-made and our slates not good3 lead is certainly the best and lightest covering1 and being of our own growth and manufacture1 and lasting1 if properly made1 for many hundred years1 is1 without question1 the most preferable2 though ,i will not deny but an excellent tile may be made to be very durable3 our artisans are not yet instructed in it1 and it is not soon done to inform them44440 ,if the ,gothic ,revivalists had worked on ,wren's lines1 the ,church would not now be saddled with a legacy of badly built ,kentish rag and rubble churches and spires1 thinly roofed with ,welsh slates1 an endless anxiety to parishes unable to find money to remedy original defects of construction4 ,wren's next point is of the essence of the problem which he was facing1 how to provide the accommodation required for the people4 ,even if the new fifty churches were to hold #b1jjj apiece1 there would not be room enough4 8,the churches1 therefore1 must be large1 but still1 in our reformed religion1 it should seem vain to make a parish church larger than that all who are present can both hear and see4 ,the ,romanists1 indeed1 may build larger churches2 it is enough if they hear the murmur of the ,mass1 and see the elevation of the ,host2 but ours are to be fitted for auditories40 ,wren then quotes his ,st4 ,james's ,piccadilly as the most practicable model of 8a single room so capacious1 with pews and galleries1 as to hold above #b1jjj persons1 and all to hear the service and both to hear distinctly and see the preacher40 ,he claims for ,st4 ,james's that it is a beautiful and convenient form1 with 8no walls of a second order1 nor lanterns nor buttresses1 but the whole roof rests upon the pillars1 as do also the galleries 444 the cheapest of any form ,i could invent40 ,st4 ,james's ,piccadilly cost #h1ejj1 so its accommodation for #b1jjj persons worked out at #d #es4 a seat4 ,this church is really in the line of development of the old ,english timber ,hall so far as its constructive idea is concerned4 ,it lent itself to the passing need of galleries1 but they are not essential to the idea1 as is sometimes supposed4 ,in discussing the place for the pulpit ,wren has some shrewd things to say about the enunciation of ,english parsons1 which hold good to-day3 8,a ,frenchman is heard further than an ,english preacher because he raises his voice and sinks not his last words 444 an insufferable fault in the pronunciation of some of our otherwise excellent preachers40 ,wren would have appreciated the similar advice of a modern bishop to a class of candidates for ordination1 that they should not drop their voices at the end of a sentence 8lest the congregation might suppose1 however erroneously1 that they had lost something40 ,on the vexed question of seating the people1 our architect has some shrewd words3 8,a church should not be so filled with pews1 but that the poor may have room enough to stand and sit in the alleys3 for to them equally is the ,gospel preached40 ,we may guess that ,wren would have been all for the rush-bottomed chair if it had been invented in his day3 8,it were to be wished there were to be no pews1 but benches3 but there is no stemming the tide of profit1 and the advantage of pew-keepers40 ,i have quoted at length from this letter in order to mark the massive common sense which ,wren brought to the solution of his problems4 ,mr4 ,arthur ,bolton gives me the interesting parallel of #ahah1 when ,sir ,john ,soane reported to the ,government on the national church building scheme4 ,his recommendations show that he worked on his great predecessor's report and he even sent to ,st4 ,james's and measured it as a typical instance4 ,as1 however1 the year #ahah preferred numbers to quality1 the results fell far below those of the earlier century4 ,it was ,wren's quality of common sense as much as the genius of the artist that made his ,city churches what they are1 practical solutions of practical difficulties and instinct with the ,english spirit of compromise1 but none the less the greatest group of churches created in any country by the genius and practical wisdom of one man4 ,,chapter ,,ix ,,chelsea1 ,,hampton ,,court1 ,,and ,,greenwich ,mr4 ,basil ,champneys has recorded a notable observation by ,thomas ,carlyle on ,chelsea ,hospital3 8,i had passed it1 almost daily1 for many years without thinking much about it1 and one day ,i began to reflect that it had always been a pleasure to me to see it1 and ,i looked at it more attentively1 and saw that it was quiet and dignified and the work of a gentleman40 ,this was evidently a favourite theme with ,carlyle1 for ,william ,allingham's ,diary for ,june #be1 #ahgd1 records a similar phrase with the addition that the ,hospital was 8admirably adapted for its uses40 ,carlyle's devotion to ,wren's memory had an odd repercussion4 ,when ,william ,de ,morgan called on the ,sage to beg him on behalf of ,william ,morris to join the ,anti-,scrape ,society1 ,carlyle was cold at first1 but a reference to the dealings of the ,ecclesiastical ,commissioners with ,wren's churches set him alight4 ,he ended a panegyric on ,wren with 8he was a very great man1 of extraordinary patience with fools10 and glared round at the company reproachfully4 ,morris rather winced when ,carlyle1 in a letter accepting membership of the ,anti-,scrape1 referred to the ,city churches as 8marvellous works1 the like of which we shall never see again10 and his hatred of the ,renaissance never ceased to blind him to ,wren's genius4 ,it would have been well if the ,society had been more active1 in the past1 in defence of ,wren's churches4 ,the narrow medivalism of the latter half of the nineteenth century wrought havoc even where it failed to destroy4 ,stained glass and other alien trappings have prejudiced far too many of his fine interiors4 ,one church architect of the type responsible for these things was finely reproved with the reminder that ,wren was just as good a ,high ,churchman as he was4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,ix ,,chelsea ,,hospital3 ,,the ,,main ,,portico4 ,the site of ,chelsea ,hospital had been given by the ,king to the ,royal ,society soon after its foundation1 but it was an inconvenient possession1 and the ,society sold it back to the ,king for the foundation of a ,royal ,hospital for disabled soldiers4 ,sir ,stephen ,fox1 a retired army contractor1 supplemented the ,king's benefactions1 and on ,may #be1 #afhb1 the inevitable ,evelyn went with ,fox and ,wren to ,lambeth to secure the ,archbishop of ,canterbury's approval to the plot and design or1 as we should say1 plan and elevations4 ,ten weeks later ,evelyn was at ,chelsea with ,fox to see the foundations started4 ,wren was a good deal more than architect to the ,hospital4 ,it was during his ,presidency of the ,royal ,society that the land was re-conveyed to the ,king3 he carried the business through with characteristic despatch1 and the statutes governing the charity were of his drafting4 ,the buildings were completed in #afib1 and no better praise of them than ,carlyle's can be invented4 ,wren shows himself in one of his characteristic moods as a sane economist where the purpose of the building makes economy an sthetic as well as a practical virtue4 ,the ,hospital is a liberal education in the handling of ,london brickwork4 ,when ,sir ,john ,soane1 in the days of ,nash stucco1 had to add an ,infirmary building1 he was careful to design in brick and content to despise the abuse it evoked at that time4 ,at ,hampton ,court ,wren had a very different problem3 he was housing not pensioners but a ,king and ,queen4 ,his original scheme had a quality of immensity4 ,our ,dutch monarch who had so successfully countered the statesmanship of ,louis ,,xiv4 doubtless wanted to follow1 at some distance1 his building exploits at ,versailles and elsewhere4 ,queen ,mary had a great liking for the situation of ,hampton ,court4 ,wren was bidden to prepare a scheme for a complete rebuilding and did so4 ,part of the old fabric was taken down and ,wren's two great suites of apartments for ,king and ,queen rose in its place4 ,the work went forward vigorously from #afhi to #afid1 and then the ,queen's death caused the completion of the plan to be abandoned4 ,the execution of the partial scheme drifted on until #agjj4 ,there was a chance then of the ,king proceeding to the finishing of the complete plan1 but ,william's death finally killed it4 ,to these accidents of mortality we owe it that part of ,wolsey's palace has remained4 ,if ,wren had had his way1 not a brick of the ,tudors would have survived4 ,the architect was happy in only one of his royal clients4 ,mary was amiable and reasonable1 but ,william's temper and his habit of interference tried ,wren very high4 ,the ,king1 however1 was fair enough to say that the insufficient headroom of the cloisters must be ascribed to his express orders which overbore ,wren's wishes4 ,despite this1 the ,fountain ,court is one of the successful features of the ,palace1 which reveals ,wren's sanity and dignity and ,englishness in a most convincing way4 ,it is enough to look at ,chatsworth1 in the light of ,hampton ,court1 to realize the difference between pedantry and genius4 ,norman ,shaw so greatly admired ,hampton ,court1 that he would have followed it in ,whitehall1 if he had been entrusted with the ,government offices4 ,the weakest part of the ,palace is the pedimented garden front1 where a sense of display1 due perhaps to ,royal ,command1 contrasts with the greater simplicity of the return faade towards the ,tudor garden4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,x ,,hampton ,,court3 ,,wren',s ,,two ,,fronts4 ,hampton ,court1 for all its size1 is a gentleman's house rather than a palace1 and ,wren's treatment of the smaller rooms fills a marked place in the development of the ,english interior4 ,left more to himself1 ,wren would have been more ,english in the height of his rooms4 ,he had a sense of fitness which is of the essence of good architecture4 ,wren was unlucky at ,hampton ,court in more than in one of his clients4 ,his ,comptroller 7or1 as we should say1 ,clerk7 of the ,works was ,william ,talman1 who accused him of having passed bad work4 ,some masonry showed cracks1 and enough stir was created to lead the ,house of ,lords to order an enquiry4 ,wren was exonerated1 and with characteristic generosity he did not call1 as he might well have done1 for the dismissal of a disloyal assistant4 ,time has revenged him4 ,chatsworth shows ,talman to have been a heavy-handed fellow1 but he is also remembered as a bad colleague in other things than the ,hampton ,court accusation4 ,if visitors to the ,palace should feel that ,wren failed in giving a suitable approach to the ,state apartments1 they should remember that they are in the presence of an incomplete scheme1 and that he left a design of notable splendour for wings with colonnades at the north side4 ,the incidental furnishings of avenues took shape in the chestnuts of ,bushey ,park1 but the rest remained on paper4 ,in one detail of the gardens ,wren must have taken special pleasure4 ,the marvellous iron screens by ,tijou have been moved from their original position1 but they remain to show ,wren's skill in the choice of his craftsmen4 ,the third of his great secular buildings1 ,greenwich ,hospital1 had the same charitable purpose as ,chelsea1 but exceeded ,hampton ,court in magnificence4 ,charles ,i4 had employed ,inigo ,jones to build1 at some distance from the ,thames1 a house for his ,queen1 ,henrietta ,maria4 ,soon after the accession of ,charles ,,ii41 ,john ,webb1 as ghost for ,sir ,john ,denham1 had begun the great building by the shore for which ,inigo ,jones may have left designs2 but money ran short and work was suspended after only a small part had been done4 ,this wing is on well-known ,palladian lines1 but is hampered by a heavy attic1 so ill-adjusted as to discredit whoever was responsible for it4 ,when ,william and ,mary succeeded ,james ,,ii41 the ,queen wished to emulate her uncle ,charles in making provision for disabled seamen as he had done for soldiers4 ,once more ,wren and ,evelyn were to be colleagues4 ,on ,may #e1 #afie1 the ,royal ,commission1 consisting of these two1 the ,archbishop of ,canterbury1 and other bigwigs1 had its first meeting at the ,london ,guildhall1 and sixteen days later the two friends and three others went1 as a ,committee1 to survey the site4 ,evelyn's task was to raise subscriptions1 and he made an interesting choice of a secretary in ,mr4 ,vanbrugh1 afterwards ,sir ,john4 ,about a year was spent in preparing plans1 and on ,june #d1 #afif1 the ,committee met at ,wren's house in ,whitehall to make agreements for materials and workmen and to give orders for the foundations to be begun4 ,on the last day of ,june a select committee of thirteen dined together at ,greenwich1 and precisely at five o'clock 7,mr4 ,flamsteed1 the ,king's ,astronomer1 8observing the punctual time by instruments07 ,wren and ,evelyn jointly laid the foundation stone4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,xi ,,greenwich ,,hospital ,,and ,,its ,,two ,,domes4 ,queen ,mary wanted the old ,queen's ,house and the ,charles ,,ii4 wing to be integral parts of the new scheme--a rather hampering condition4 ,wren took the former as the closing feature of a vista from the river1 between his two new blocks named after ,william and ,mary and his ,queen ,anne block1 which balances and exactly follows the ,jones-,webb block of ,charles ,,ii4 ,wren's contribution to ,greenwich was1 therefore1 the two superb quadrangular blocks with open sides adorned with colonnades and the big idea of planning which pulled together the work of four reigns into a coherent and superb whole4 ,the duality of the domes is a most notable feature1 and their individual design is beautifully differentiated from the grander scale of ,st4 ,paul's4 ,they are domestic1 rather than church-like1 in conception4 ,that ,hawksmoor in his capacity as ,deputy-,surveyor had a somewhat free hand in designing part of the work after #agje1 that ,vanbrugh succeeded ,wren as ,surveyor in #agaf1 that ,colin ,campbell took up the task ten years later1 and that ,ripley superseded him in #agbi1 does not deprive ,wren of the title of architect of the ,hospital4 ,in so far as they departed from his original designs the buildings suffered1 especially from the baldness of the ,campbell elements and the heavy-handedness of the ex-carpenter ,ripley4 ,wren's planning1 his domes and his colonnades1 make ,greenwich the noblest of ,english public buildings in the ,grand ,manner4 ,the view of the ,palace from the ,thames is magnificent and has been an inspiration to artists ever since4 ,abroad1 it would be an objective to all travellers4 ,,chapter ,x ,,other ,,buildings3 ,,public ,,and ,,domestic ,this volume has no claim to be a biography of ,wren3 still less is it a catalogue raisonn of his buildings4 ,familiar students of his work will be merciful if they find a bare reference1 or none1 to something they may regard as peculiarly satisfying and notably ,wrennish4 ,i can but plead the limitations of a little book4 ,but some of his buildings not included in earlier chapters must be at least mentioned1 if shortly and in a disjointed list4 ,amongst public works the ,monument takes a prominent if rather unsatisfactory place4 ,the design was subjected to a good deal of interference1 for ,hawksmoor records that the flaming urn was substituted as a crowning feature for the intended statue of ,charles contra architecti intentionem4 ,amongst the pedestals of equestrian statues in ,london1 there is none to compare with that of ,charles ,i4 at ,charing ,cross1 which was probably of ,wren's designing1 but it has been attributed also to ,grinling ,gibbons4 ,temple ,bar was an interesting archway which now adorns ,theobald's ,park and is commemorated on its old site in ,fleet ,street by a melancholy monument4 ,there seems a good case for the return of ,temple ,bar to some site in ,london4 ,the neighbouring entrance to the ,middle ,temple is one of ,wren's most charming achievements4 ,his use of brickwork here in conjunction with a stone base and pilasters is of an ideal modesty and simplicity1 matched within the ,temple by the cloister of ,hare ,court and rubbed brick doorways in ,king's ,bench ,walk4 ,of these works as of ,kensington ,palace ,coventry ,patmore's words were abundantly true3 8,sir ,christopher ,wren could not build a common brick house without impressing his own character upon it40 ,he might have added that it needs a considerable artist to give character to a common brick house1 for the palette is limited4 ,wren's work at ,kensington has been a good deal modified by later hands1 but the ,queen's staircase and the ,gallery remain very typical4 ,the exterior suffers greatly from the clumsy additions of ,william ,kent1 which are too often accepted as part of the original house4 ,the lay-out should be restored1 and the great alcove be brought back from its present stupid position near the fountain4 ,the ,orangery is a masterpiece of simplicity and reserve1 and shows ,wren exercising the consummate taste which cannot in honesty be regarded as a continuous characteristic4 ,the attribution of various houses to ,wren rests either upon vague tradition or upon imaginary internal evidence4 ,the belief that he designed ,belton is persistent but unsupported by documents4 ,the notable contributions made to its decoration by ,grinling ,gibbons may have strengthened the tradition4 ,certainly ,belton is worthy of ,wren4 ,the same may be said of two houses in ,chichester1 ,pallant ,house and another which has long been called ,wren's ,house4 ,miss ,milman in her ,life printed a chronological list of works1 and starred those for which there was no documentary authority4 ,but her stars must be increased4 ,the ,chichester houses are cases in point4 ,it is unfortunate that ,marlborough ,house has been so mishandled since ,wren's day3 the attic storey is a clumsy addition4 ,as he planned it1 the disposition of the rooms showed no advance on the planning of ,inigo ,jones and ,webb4 ,the main rooms were en suite without any corridor behind them1 a march of convenience which ,vanbrugh developed at ,blenheim1 not otherwise a mirror of perfection4 ,sarah1 ,duchess1 must have been a client calling for all ,wren's skill in handling people4 ,when she quarrelled with ,vanbrugh about his fees for ,blenheim1 she quoted ,wren as a pattern of moderation 8content to be dragged up in a basket1 three or four times a week1 to the top of ,st4 ,paul's1 and at great hazard1 for #bjj a year40 ,groombridge ,place1 ,kent1 is another house of infinite charm which has been attributed to ,wren4 ,the ,all ,souls ,collection of his drawings includes some sketch elevations of houses4 ,one sheet in particular gives two alternative treatments for the same plan1 but neither is up to ,wren's best form1 and it seems reasonable to assume that the smaller domestic work for private clients had to be ignored in the main because of his heavy public employments4 ,amongst his works which have disappeared altogether are the ,custom ,house1 the ,armoury and ,mint in the ,tower of ,london 7where his ,storehouse has survived71 ,christ's ,hospital1 and the ,college of ,physicians in ,warwick ,lane4 ,not the least interesting of an architect's designs are those which are never carried to full fruition4 ,the most notable of these was a great ,palace at ,winchester1 begun for ,charles ,,ii4 ,not much of it was built1 for the ,king died before it was finished1 and his successors did not like ,winchester4 ,the uncompleted core was later adapted so drastically for use as barracks that it ceased to have any ,wren significance4 ,the ,tomb of ,charles ,i41 for which ,parliament voted #gj1jjj1 was designed by ,wren in #afgh4 ,the drawings preserved at ,all ,souls show a domed structure1 which was to have stood at the east end of ,st4 ,george's ,chapel1 ,windsor4 ,within was to be a statue of the ,martyr ,king standing on a shield upheld by four allegorical figures4 ,alternative treatments are shown for this group in marble and bronze4 ,grinling ,gibbons would no doubt have been the sculptor1 but1 as ,wren's title of the drawings notes1 it was eheu conditionem temporum1 nondum extructum4 ,the nondum gives a hint that ,wren hoped that it might later be done1 but the #gj1jjj found less worthy employment4 ,wren's careful detailed estimates for the work are printed in ,sir ,william ,st4 ,john ,hope's monumental ,windsor ,castle1 with reproductions of the drawings4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,xii ,,trinity ,,college ,,library1 ,,cambridge3 ,,river ,,front4 ,noble as this design was1 ,i confess ,i take more pleasure from ,wren's design for a monument 7also in ,all ,souls ,library7 which ,sir ,reginald ,blomfield reproduces,c with the note that it was probably drawn by ,grinling ,gibbons4 ,it shows a lady reclining on a couch1 not unlike ,raggi's ,lady ,cheyne in ,chelsea ,old ,church1 but she points with a lively gesture to cherubs flying above her in a burst of rays and clouds4 ,it shows ,wren in his most baroque mood1 and is perhaps his reminiscence of old ,bernini's monumental manner4 ,in ,scotland he did nothing2 but the ,royal ,hospital at ,kilmainham1 near ,dublin1 is attributed to him with some reason4 ,in #afgi he was ordered to view the site1 but no record remains of his visit1 and this ,irish variant of ,chelsea ,hospital is not claimed by his son in the list of works4 ,the building is simple and dignified with open cloisters round a big quadrangle4 ,probably ,wren did designs for it and left some assistant or local architect to supervise its building4 ,the best evidence for his authorship is that there was no architect in ,ireland who could have produced such a design1 with the possible exception of the designer of ,beaulieu1 near ,drogheda4 ,another charitable foundation1 ,morden ,college1 ,blackheath1 is certainly ,wren's4 ,it is an enchanting piece of brickwork with a pedimented centre-piece and lantern4 ,as ,cambridge was the locus of his first completed work of importance1 ,pembroke ,chapel 7the ,sheldonian is called in the ,parentalia 8the first publick ,performance of the ,surveyor10 but it was finished later than the chapel72 it also gave him the opportunity for one of his greatest achievements1 the ,library of ,trinity4 ,his first design was for a circular building with a domed roof1 but this soon gave place to the scheme that was carried out4 ,a long memorandum by ,wren explains his reasons for the design1 which was limited by the need of joining the new ,library to the extension of ,neville's ,court1 a junction which was not very happily achieved4 ,the governing consideration of the elevation to the ,court was the maintenance of the ,library floor on the same level as the adjoining chambers4 ,unfortunately ,wren would use two ,orders despite the fact that the structure of the work was in conflict4 ,evidently he was forcing a design1 naturally of a ,palladian type1 of a piano nobile on a lower storey which would be the podium of an ,order4 ,it is a case where his ingenuity overbore his artistic sense1 and he resorted to the doubtful expedient of a range of arches1 the tympana of which are filled in solid4 ,the river front has been criticised on the grounds of an undue austerity1 but ,i find it difficult to follow this3 it is surely a miracle of dignity4 ,for the interior of the ,library there can be nothing but praise4 ,ideal in dignity and ideal in convenience1 ,wren's book presses have the additional merit of showing ,gibbons carving of peculiar excellence1 and he must not be charged with the overcrowding of the floor by smaller cases needed by modern accessions of books4 ,wren was less happy in his chapel and cloister at ,emmanuel ,college4 ,the breaking of the pediment of the central feature by the lantern turret is not in his usual vein1 but the lantern itself is a very charming composition4 ,another related work is the ,honywood ,library and ,cloister at ,lincoln ,cathedral1 but the ,library itself is a rather low and not specially distinguished apartment4 ,i bring this slight catalogue of ,wren's miscellaneous works to a close with a return to ,oxford4 ,it is difficult to determine how far he was responsible for the ,library at ,queen's ,college 7#afic7 because ,hawksmoor was mixed up with him there1 but the whole ,college must be regarded as a ,wren building4 ,there is nothing of ,hawksmoor's more faithful to his old master's ideas1 and less influenced by ,sir ,john ,vanbrugh's1 the two poles between which the lesser man was always oscillating4 ,sir ,reginald ,blomfield is strongly against attributing the ,ashmolean to ,wren1 but it is difficult to believe that such a building at such a time could have been entrusted to anyone else4 ,similarly ,trinity ,college ,chapel 7#afid7 is somewhat of a mystery4 ,it has been said that ,dean ,aldrich was the architect and that ,wren was only called in to advise4 ,the quality of the design suggests that ,wren was the senior partner in the combination4 ,there is no confusion with regard to ,tom ,tower4 ,dr4 ,fell1 ,dean of ,christ ,church1 commissioned him to build a tower over ,wolsey's gateway4 ,the result is something certainly not ,tudor1 but quite certainly a picturesque composition of a high order4 ,wren's detail is little like that of the sixteenth century below it1 but he did the one thing needful3 he provided a dignified and picturesque portal for the ,college1 and it is folly to rebuke a late seventeenth-century architect for not entering into the spirit of his predecessors of the early sixteenth4 ,the study of the spirit of ,gothic work1 alike systematic and sympathetic1 is a growth of less than a hundred years4 ,wren was of his age4 ,,chapter ,,xi ,,wren ,,and ,,his ,,contemporaries3 ,,last ,,years ,the appreciation a man may win in his own day and generation is no sure guide to his quality as an artist1 as witness the cases of ,mr4 ,martin ,tupper and many ,past ,presidents of the ,royal ,academy2 but when the chorus of praise persists during something like eighty years and comes from men in every walk of life1 it is at least evidence of notable character4 ,such praise was ,wren's in a marked degree1 and it helps to explain the way he held his own under the fickle ,king ,charles1 the cantankerous ,king ,william1 and the casual ,queen ,anne4 ,under ,king ,george ,i41 when ,wren was a very old man1 he lost his appointment1 but only as the culmination of a discreditable campaign against him by futile people who lacked the wit to appreciate the greatness of the man against whom they plotted their dishonest little persecutions4 ,in so far as ,wren's advancement as an architect may be attributed to any one man1 it is clear that ,john ,evelyn the diarist must have the credit4 ,whether he met ,wren before #afed does not appear2 but he was in ,oxford on ,july #aa of that year1 ,wren being then twenty-two years old1 and after dinner he visited 8that miracle of a youth10 and had further dealings with him two days later1 as is noted in an earlier chapter4 ,by #affd1 when ,wren showed ,evelyn the model of the ,sheldonian1 he had become 8that incomparable genius10 and ,evelyn went to ,oxford in #affi for the celebrations which marked the completion of the theatre4 ,wren's appointment as ,surveyor-,general of ,his ,majesty's ,works was due to ,evelyn's great influence with ,charles ,,ii41 to whom he seems to have acted in some sort as an architectural adviser4 ,how greatly ,evelyn valued ,wren's judgment in ordinary matters is shown by a letter in #affe in which the diarist asks ,wren to recommend a tutor for his boy4 ,in the same letter ,evelyn mentions his translation of ,frart's ,parallels1 a book on architecture which had been very successful in ,france and sold very largely in ,england in ,evelyn's edition4 ,the first issue was dedicated to ,sir ,john ,denham1 but it is interesting to find that in ,february1 #afif-g1 ,evelyn wrote to ,wren saying that he would dedicate to him the new edition he was then producing1 and so he did with many flourishes4 ,there is a characteristic outburst in the ,diary for ,may #e1 #afha1 when ,sir ,w4 ,fermor dined with him and ,wren3 8,a wonderful genius had this incomparable person10 an echo of what he had written seventeen years before when ,wren showed him the model of the ,sheldonian--8that incomparable genius40 ,the last ,wren entry in the ,diary was forty-four years later than the first4 ,wren went down to ,says ,court with 8,mr4 ,london1 his gardener10 to render ,evelyn the service of estimating the damage done to the house and gardens during its occupation by ,peter the ,great1 who had comported himself in a manner which justly disgusted ,evelyn4 ,wren outlived his old and faithful friend by more than twenty years4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,xiii ,,the ,,wadham ,,portrait ,,of ,,wren4 ,an #ahbe copy by ,john ,smith of ,oxford based on the ,sheldonian portrait1 to which ,dallaway attached the unlikely attribution of ,thornhill1 8painted in conjunction with ,verrio and ,kneller40 ,although a quiet1 modest1 and always overworked person1 ,wren seems to have liked social relaxation4 ,he was at ,lord ,brouncker's in ,february1 #afff-g1 with ,samuel ,pepys1 who refers to the music that their host had provided4 ,there were two eunuchs1 so tall as to move ,sir ,t4 ,harvey to some physiological imaginings1 and one woman 8very well dressed and handsome enough1 but would not be kissed10 at least so ,mr4 ,killigrew informed ,mr4 ,pepys4 ,not long afterwards ,pepys met ,wren at ,streeter's1 8with several virtuosos10 looking at the paintings which were being made for the new theatre at ,oxford4 ,it must have been a pleasant occasion on ,february #i1 #afga1 when ,wren and ,pepys dined with ,evelyn at ,says ,court1 and all of them went afterwards to see the 8,crucifixion0 which ,grinling ,gibbons had carved4 ,a few weeks later the ,king and ,queen indicated their wish to see this work1 at ,evelyn's suggestion1 and it was taken to ,whitehall for their inspection4 ,evelyn records the anger he felt at the ,queen ignoring the merits of the wonderful carving because a 8,french pedling woman0 had run it down1 but he had the compensation that 8,mr4 ,wren faithfully promised me to employ him40 ,how faithfully that promise was fulfilled is proved by the choir stalls of ,st4 ,paul's and work at many another ,wren building4 ,in ,february1 #afgf1 ,evelyn and ,wren1 with other notable ,fellows of the ,royal ,society1 dined with ,sir ,john ,williamson1 and in ,november in the following year the same inseparable friends dined in the company of ,prince ,rupert and other learned men at the ,lord ,treasurer's4 ,wren had achieved that useful measure of friendship with ,prince ,rupert which caused his name to figure on a list of intimates to whom the ,prince sent every year a gift of choicest wine from his estates on the ,rhine4 ,in ,august1 #afhj1 ,evelyn was deputed by the ,royal ,society to make a visit of ceremony to ,monsieur ,chardine1 a famous ,french traveller who had come to ,london1 and characteristically he took ,wren with him4 ,wren must have been good company at dinner4 ,in #affi ,sir ,john ,clayton wrote to a friend3 8,saturday last ,i went with the ,duke of ,buckingham to ,denham 444 on our return home we dined at ,uxbridge1 and never in all my life did ,i pass my day away with such gusto1 our company being his ,grace1 ,mr4 ,weller1 ,mr4 ,surveyor ,wren and myself3 nothing but quintessence of wit and most excellent discourse40 ,as to whether ,wren enjoyed wide hospitalities in his alleged character of ,freemason it is impossible to say1 but there is a tradition that he was ,grand ,master of a lodge which was intimately associated with ,st4 ,paul's and became in due time what is known as the ,antiquity ,lodge4 ,some candlesticks1 and a mallet bearing an inscription which suggests that it was used at a ,st4 ,paul's ceremonial1 remain in possession of the ,antiquity ,lodge4 ,it is necessary1 however1 to add that ,gould in his ,history of ,freemasonry gives it as his opinion1 after careful investigation of the architect's connection with the craft1 that the evidence points to ,wren not having belonged to a lodge1 nor to a society which was not in existence until #agag1 and he goes on to allege that there are three misstatements on the mallet inscription4 ,i have no knowledge of these matters1 but assume that ,gould's opinion is competent4 ,there is no reference to ,freemasonry in any ,wren document or in ,parentalia1 but so far as the latter is concerned the omission means nothing4 ,i have indicated very slightly1 and with the diffidence of one who knows nothing of science but a few of its fairy tales1 the large range of ,wren's scientific labours4 ,it may be that they were curious rather than important1 but it is necessary to set down the considered opinion of ,dr4 ,sprat1 the first historian of the ,royal ,society4 ,it is a notable tribute3 8,in the whole progress of this narration1 ,i have been cautious to forbear commending the labours of any ,private ,fellows of the ,society4 ,for this1 ,i need not make any apology to them2 feeling it would have been an inconsiderable honour1 to be praised by so mean a writer3 ,but now ,i must break this law1 in the particular case of ,dr4 ,christopher ,wren3 ,for doing so1 ,i will not alledge the excuse of my friendship to him2 though that perhaps were sufficient2 and it might well be allowed me to take this occasion of ,publishing it3 ,but ,i only do it on the mere consideration of justice3 ,for in turning over the ,registers of the ,society1 ,i perceived that many excellent things1 whose first invention ought to be ascribed to him1 were casually omitted3 ,this moves me to do him right by himself1 and to give this separate account of his endeavours1 in promoting the design of the ,royal ,society1 in the small time wherein he has had the opportunity of attending it40 ,dr4 ,sprat then recites some of ,wren's achievements in the fields of natural science1 astronomy1 etc41 and continues thus3 8,this is a short account of the principal discoveries which ,dr4 ,wren has presented or suggested to this assembly4 ,i know very well1 that some of them he did only start and design2 and that they have been since carried on to perfection1 by the industry of other hands4 ,i purpose not to rob them of their share in the honour3 ,yet it is but reasonable1 that the original invention should be ascribed to the true author1 rather than the finishers4 ,nor do ,i fear that this will be thought too much1 which ,i have said concerning him3 ,for there is a peculiar reverence due to so much excellence covered with so much modesty4 ,and it is not flattery but honesty1 to give him his just praise2 who is so far from usurping the fame of other men that he endeavours with all care to conceal his own40 ,a man could not ask a better epitaph than 8so much excellence covered with so much modesty40 ,it may be that ,sprat was carried away by his affection for ,wren and overstated the case1 but that amiable reason can hardly apply to all his contemporaries4 ,robert ,boyle1 who had witnessed some of ,wren's experiments1 testified that his knowledge of ,wren's extraordinary sagacity made him very desirous to try what he proposed4 ,the evidence of ,sir ,isaac ,newton cannot be ignored4 ,his ,preface to the second edition of the ,principia groups ,wren with ,wallis and ,huygens as 8hujus tatis geometrarum facile principes10 and gives to them the first credit for a true conception of the laws governing the impacts and reactions of two bodies in collision4 ,praise from ,newton is praise indeed4 ,thomas ,hearne carried it a little further4 8,i heard an eminent mathematician say that he could mention another equal in mathematics to ,sir ,isaac ,newton1 though he had not published 444 ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 who was1 indeed1 a very extraordinary man40 ,when ,isaac ,barrow succeeded to the ,gresham ,professorship of ,geometry1 he took occasion1 in his inaugural oration1 to refer to ,wren in this fashion3 8,one there is1 whose name common gratitude forbids me to pass over1 whom ,i know not whether to admire for his divine genius or for the sweetness of his disposition 444 it will suffice if ,i name the great and good ,christopher ,wren1 of whom ,i will say no more since his merit attracts the eyes of the whole world0 444 and so on1 with the inevitable references to ,wren's modesty4 ,in nothing did the sweetness of ,wren's nature so clearly appear as in his relations with ,robert ,hooke1 a sour philosopher and1 it would seem1 a disloyal fellow4 ,hooke was at ,westminster just before ,wren and ran second to him all his life4 ,if ,elmes' view of the case be true1 ,hooke picked up ,wren's ideas1 developed them and tried to take all the credit of them1 and was a bad colleague generally4 ,he quarrelled with ,newton1 disputed with ,flamsteed1 and was snubbed by the ,royal ,society when he did a design1 unasked1 for their home which was promptly rejected and ,wren asked to do it instead4 ,he was always in hot water and incurably unpopular1 but ,wren stuck to him4 ,when an assistant was needed in the great labours which followed the ,fire1 ,wren appointed ,hooke to measure and set out the ground of all the 8private street houses10 but was wise enough to keep the ,public ,works in his own hands4 ,wren was delightfully loyal to the contractors whom he employed4 ,he must have been on intimate terms with ,edward ,strong1 master mason at ,st4 ,paul's and elsewhere1 for he sent young ,christopher abroad in charge of ,strong's son4 ,he gave the buildings he liked best to the few men he most trusted4 ,strong and ,christopher ,kempster did ,st4 ,stephen's ,walbrook2 ,strong did the delightful brickwork at ,st4 ,benet ,paul's ,wharf1 ,st4 ,augustine's1 ,st4 ,mildred's1 and several others4 ,on the fifty churches only thirteen joiners and ten plasterers received contracts4 ,all the coppersmith work1 except at two churches1 was done by one ,robert ,bird4 ,my publication of the accounts of the ,city churches destroyed all manner of vain fancies as to the employment of ,dutch joiners and ,italian plasterers in their building4 ,when ,wren found a good ,english workman he employed him steadily1 and only went to a foreigner like ,tijou for the miraculous ironwork at ,st4 ,paul's1 ,hampton ,court1 and elsewhere when he was a notable artist and far superior to his ,english colleagues4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,xiv ,,the ,,st4 ,,paul',s ,,deanery ,,portrait4 ,a copy of the ,kneller in the ,national ,portrait ,gallery4 ,as an example of the way ,wren was trusted1 it is worth noting that when ,flamsteed was bickering by letter with ,cassini1 the ,french astronomer1 and accusing ,halley of disingenuous practices and praying ,god to make ,halley sensible of his faults1 the peaceful ,wren was called in as umpire4 ,i could wish that some ,parliamentary contemporary had put on record his impressions of ,wren as an ,m4,p41 an unlikely trade for a man of his temperament4 ,elected for ,new ,windsor in ,william's first ,parliament1 he was unseated on a technicality1 but immediately re-elected4 ,in #agjj he was returned for the ,borough of ,weymouth and ,melcombe ,regis1 but1 as ,elmes gravely observes1 8notwithstanding this additional occupation1 he found time to write a dissertation on the ascension of the sap in trees1 and a paper on the superfice of the terraqueous globe40 ,doubtless he found these employments prettier relaxations from architecture than attendance at the ,house of ,commons4 ,wren seems to have got on well with ,charles ,,ii41 who knighted him at ,whitehall on ,november #bj1 #afgb4 ,indeed1 the ,king might well have been grateful to the man who so notably gave lustre to his reign4 ,wren stood to ,charles in something the same relation as ,phidias to ,pericles4 ,king ,william was an awkward client1 and interfered with ,wren in the design of ,hampton ,court2 but ,queen ,mary liked to talk to him about architecture and gardening1 and to watch the progress of the works 8on which she often offered her own judgment1 which was allowed to be exquisite40 ,for ,wren's sake1 we hope it was4 ,queen ,anne was invoked by ,wren to take a hand in his quarrels with the ,commissioners of ,st4 ,paul's4 ,he had a shrewd dig at them in one formal petition to ,her ,majesty1 in which he was able to show that they were making a mess of the railings round her own statue1 and throwing over ,tijou's design1 as approved by ,wren1 in favour of some model of their own4 ,what action ,anne took does not appear1 but then or at some time she gave ,wren a delightful chest of drawers1 which remained an heirloom in the ,wren family until ,mrs4 ,pigott's death1 and a calendar watch that reposes in ,sir ,john ,soane's ,museum with a walking-stick1 which conceals drawing instruments4 ,i have dealt with ,wren's dismissal from office in the chapter on ,st4 ,paul's4 ,he was then in the eighty-sixth year of his age and the forty-ninth of his ,surveyorship4 ,the remainder of his life was spent in retirement1 8in which ,recess1 free from worldly affairs1 he passed the greatest part of the five last following years of his life in contemplation and studies and principally in the consolation of the holy scriptures3 cheerful in solitude and as well pleased to die in the shade as in the light40 ,the manner of ,wren's passing is told by ,miss ,phillimore1 and is1 ,i imagine1 a family tradition derived from ,mrs4 ,pigott3 8,once a year it was his habit to be driven to ,london1 and to sit for a while under the dome of his own ,cathedral4 ,on one of these journeys he caught a cold and soon afterwards1 on ,february #be1 #agbc1 his servant1 thinking ,sir ,christopher slept longer after dinner than was his wont1 came into the room and found his master dead in his chair1 with an expression of perfect peace on the calm features40 ,so died a great artist1 a great ,christian1 and a great gentleman1 who lived1 as his epitaph says1 more than ninety years1 not for himself1 but for the good of the ,state4 ,,chapter ,,xii ,,the ,,professional ,,man ,it is of some interest to attempt to form a picture of ,wren1 not as a great artist in building1 but as a professional architect dealing with clients who were often awkward and sometimes dishonest1 like the ,st4 ,paul's authorities in his later years1 carrying out a vast amount of detail work which is now regarded as the task of the surveyor rather than the architect1 making arrangements for the settlement of disputes1 boundary lines1 frontages1 and for compliance with ,royal ,proclamations and ,acts of ,parliament1 negotiating with clients as to fees1 and generally dealing with the financial and business side of his profession4 ,all his biographers have emphasised the undoubted fact that ,wren was not a self-seeking man1 but ,i think they have a little overdone the suggestion of altruism4 ,it is said in ,parentalia and elsewhere that ,wren's salary of #bjj a year for the work of designing and superintending ,st4 ,paul's was a very modest sum4 ,that is true1 but it must be remembered that the salary ran from #afge1 when he was appointed ,surveyor-,general and ,architect of ,st4 ,paul's1 until #agaa1 when the ,house of ,commons determined that the ,cathedral was completed4 ,he1 therefore received #g1bjj in respect of ,st4 ,paul's4 ,it is also stated in ,parentalia that he received #ajj a year for work on the ,city churches4 ,but this seems to be wholly untrue1 for ,wren was paid on exactly the same basis as an architect of to-day--i4e41 by a commission on the value of the work executed4 ,until #aiai1 when it was raised to #f per cent41 the customary remuneration of an architect in ,england was #e per cent42 and a manuscript account1 covering the period from ,july1 #afgj1 to ,march1 #afgc1 quoted by ,wyatt ,papworth1 shows that twelve-pence in the pound for all monies received and paid was disbursed 8for allowances for rebuilding the ,churches to the ,officers of ,works for the management of the whole40 ,this is #e per cent41 out of which ,wren no doubt paid for his office staff4 ,as the total expenditure on the ,city churches was #bfc1ghf1 ,wren must have received over #ac1jjj4 ,in addition1 the ,city authorities would now and again give to him 7or in one case to ,lady ,wren7 a lump sum by way of expressing their gratitude for his services4 ,in the capacity of ,surveyor-,general of ,his ,majesty's ,works1 he was receiving1 in #afge1 #acs4 #b;d4 a day and 8availes0 of #hj per quarter1 which meant another #cbj a year1 by way of retaining fee2 and ,papworth presumes1 ,i think with reason1 that he also received specific payment in respect of each service performed4 ,by the year #agae1 his salary and 8riding charges0 had dropped to #acf a year1 but it is also to be remembered that all this time he had an official residence in ,whitehall consisting of sixteen rooms and a cellar1 which he occupied for about fifty years without cost to himself4 ,in respect of ,chelsea ,hospital he received a fee of #a1jjj1 but there are many examples of his refusing payment altogether4 ,he insisted on doing all the work at ,greenwich ,hospital without payment1 saying1 8,let me have some share in an act of charity and mercy40 ,when he came to design the ,library of ,trinity at ,cambridge1 for which the ,master had some difficulty in getting enough subscriptions1 ,wren's contribution was the value of his own work1 for which he made no charge2 and1 similarly1 he received nothing in respect of his work at ,st4 ,clement ,danes4 ,these are acts of generosity of which we happen to have definite record1 and ,i do not doubt that there were many other examples of the same sort not recorded1 for ,wren's generosity was equalled only by his modesty4 ,he was not above a trifling piece of nepotism2 for his son ,christopher became ,deputy ,clerk ,engrosser in the ,office of ,works in #afid and ,clerk of ,works in #agjb1 succeeding ,dickenson4 ,this appointment was confirmed by ,george ,i4 in #agae4 ,but when ,sir ,christopher fell from favour his son was also dismissed1 and from the younger ,christopher's casual proceedings in the compilation of the material of ,parentalia1 ,i cannot believe that the ,state suffered greatly from his disappearance4 ,during thirty-two years of ,wren's professional career1 ,nicholas ,hawksmoor was his domestic clerk1 which we may take to mean that he was in charge of ,wren's office and his right-hand man1 both in designing and in the financial supervision of the works4 ,it would appear that he performed a good many of the duties which now fall to the separate profession of quantity surveyor4 ,i suspect that1 for example1 the payments to the various contractors for the ,city churches1 and possibly also for ,st4 ,paul's1 were certified by ,wren after the value of the work done had been examined by ,hawksmoor4 ,it seems certain that the very elaborate accounts of the ,city churches1 with which ,i have dealt fully in ,archologia1 were actually written out by ,hawksmoor himself4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,xv ,,the ,,central ,,portion ,,of ,,the ,,chiaroscuro ,,engraving ,,by ,,elisha ,,kirkall1 ,,after ,,klosterman4 ,by ,wren's time1 the practice of architecture had been organised generally on lines which were developed notably by the brothers ,adam1 very competent business men1 and have been elaborated in very modern times4 ,but substantially the methods remain the same except that contracting has equally been developed so that separate tradesmen are now merged in a general contractor in ,england4 ,in ,scotland ,wren's way still prevails to a large extent4 ,there was nothing slapdash about ,wren's methods3 everything was recorded in the most orderly and detailed manner4 ,if materials delivered to ,st4 ,paul's were for any reason transferred to one of the ,city churches1 most careful entry was made in the accounts of the quantities and values1 and the necessary debits and credits were taken into account when the contractors' bills were settled4 ,wren was as efficient in business details as he was in design4 ,if my memory does not deceive me 7and some thieving friend has made it impossible for me to verify my reference71 it was ,mr4 ,g4 ,k4 ,chesterton1 in ,biography for ,beginners1 who made moving comment on an imaginative picture of ,wren in the act of being helped into a fur coat by an obsequious flunkey1 as follows3 ,sir ,christopher ,wren ,went to dine with some men4 8,if any body calls ,say ,i'm designing ,st4 ,paul's40 ,perhaps the major part of his long life of work was taken up by far less attractive tasks1 for he was ,his ,majesty's ,office of ,works and ,his ,majesty's ,office of ,woods and ,forests of his day rolled into one4 ,the ,privy ,council called on him for reports on questions of all kinds4 ,elmes ploughed through a manuscript book of the ,council's transactions on almost every page of which ,wren's name appears4 ,one ,mr4 ,berkehead wanted to build a house and brew-house at ,knightsbridge4 ,was this in contravention of ,his ,majesty's proclamation8 ,no1 it was too far out of town1 and ,mr4 ,berkehead may proceed4 ,may ,mr4 ,sleymaker build on an old foundation in ,brick ,lane8 ,he gets his permission4 ,sir ,richard ,stydolfe had improperly started building at the rear of ,st4 ,giles's ,church leading from thence to ,piccadilly4 ,may he go on8 ,the ,surveyor-,general goes off to ,st4 ,giles's1 examines the whole matter and reports that he should be so licensed 8provided the said ,sir ,richard ,stydolfe build regularly1 according to direction and according to a design to which his said licence may refer2 that he be obliged to build with brick1 with party walls1 with sufficient scantlings1 good paving in the streets1 and sufficient sewers and conveyances for the water 4440 and so forth and so on4 ,the ,colonel ,panton who gave his name to ,panton ,street was in similar trouble1 but ,wren found that the ,colonel's building scheme would 8cure the noysomeness of the place0 and 8the design of the building shewn to me may be very usefull to the publique40 ,wren was constructive in everything he did1 and did not merely deal with the current business that was referred to him4 ,some builders in ,soe ,hoe 87surely a pleasanter spelling than ,soho70 were building small and mean habitations1 8receptacles for the poorer sort and the offensive trades0 and rendering the government of these parts more unmanageable4 ,his ,majesty's ,sergeant ,plumber was much upset about the manifest decay of the waters in the expenseful drains and conduits of ,whitehall ,palace which resulted from these nefarious proceedings in ,soe ,hoe1 and ,wren supported him with a petition4 ,soe ,hoe had gone too far4 ,his ,majesty in person1 ,his ,majesty's royal brother and ,prince ,rupert1 and the ,archbishop of ,canterbury and others in full council1 looked into the matter1 met more than once about it4 ,wren was ordered to see that obedience be given to ,his ,majesty's proclamation3 failing which1 he was to imprison the workmen for contempt4 ,lord ,rochester asks him to examine the bills for repairing the ,royal stables1 and ,wren goes through them and finds 8the particular prices very reasonable1 one thing with another40 ,but sometimes ,wren must have been bored4 ,finding lodgings for ,mr4 ,ronchi at ,st4 ,james's was hardly a task for the creator of ,st4 ,paul's1 but he found them4 ,in #afgi he was in professional touch with the troubles that followed the finding of ,sir ,edmondsbury ,godfrey dead in a ditch4 ,papists' plots were in the air4 ,the ,spanish ,ambassador became highly unpopular1 and the ,lords' ,committee appointed to look into 8the late horrid conspiracy0 ordered ,sir ,christopher ,wren and ,edward ,warcup1 ,esq41 to put padlocks on all such doors as open out of ,mr4 ,weld's house into the ,ambassador's house4 ,so 8we repaired to ,wild-house and having viewed the dores 444 we affixed padlocks 4440 and much more to the same effect1 8all which we humbly submit40 ,i am glad to add that ,his ,excellency showed great civility to ,wren in the character of locksmith4 ,in all these proceedings1 as ,elmes justly remarks1 8the honour1 integrity and public spirit of ,wren appear transcendent40 ,i must add a word about ,wren as a draughtsman4 ,the drawings which can with certainty be attributed to his own hand show him to have been a competent but not a good performer4 ,a man so immersed in multifarious work had no time for the niceties of the drawing-board1 and it is probable that his details were drawn roughly in the shops of his contractors or 8on the job10 as the work progressed4 ,the idea was complete in his own mind1 and with workmen used to his words and wishes verbal instructions on his frequent visits would forward the work without the elaborated drawings and details of a modern contract4 ,differences were adjusted by the simple methods of trade measurement in use4 ,but that he attached great importance to drawing as an element in a liberal education is shown by a reference in ,christ's ,hospital ,committee ,book1 and it is delightful to find here once more the association of ,wren and ,pepys4 8,at a committee of the ,schooles in ,christ's ,hospitall1 the #cjth ,november1 #afib1 444 ,mr4 ,treasurer acquainted the committee that he had two letters one from ,sir ,christo4 ,wren and the other from ,esq4 ,pepys declaring their opinions concerning the introducing the art of drawing among the ,boyes40 ,wren's letter1 which ,mr4 ,nathaniel ,hawes read aloud to the ,committee1 is as follows3 8,nov4 #bdth1 #afib4 8,,sir1 8444 ,it was observed by somebody there present at his house that our ,english ,artists are dull enough at invention but when once a foreigne patterne is sett they imitate soe well that commonly they exceed the ,originall1 ,i confess the observation is generally true1 but this showes that our natives want not a ,genius but education in that wch is the foundation of all ,mechanick ,arts1 a practice in designing or drawing1 to wch everybody in ,italy1 ,france and the ,low ,countries pretends more or less4 ,i cannot imagine that next to good writing anything could be more usefully taught your children especially such as will naturally take to it1 and many such you will find amongst your ,numbers who will have a naturall genius to it1 which it is a pity should be stifled4444 ,it is not ,painters1 ,sculptors1 ,gravers1 only that will find an advantage in such ,boyes1 but many other ,artificers too long to enumerate4 ,noe ,art but will be mended and improved2 by which not only your ,charity of the ,house will be enlarged but the ,nation advantaged4444 8,your affectionate friend and humble servant1 8,,chr4 ,,wren40 ,this is a strong plea for the teaching of drawing in schools1 but there is1 as always1 the same practical comment4 ,draughtsmanship is of value as the foundation of the 8mechanick arts10 but it comes next to 8good writing40 ,,chapter ,,xiii ,,student ,,and ,,scholar ,before attempting some sketch of ,wren's position in the world of ,english ,architecture1 in which will be set down his own outlook on his art1 mainly in his own words1 it seems reasonable to describe his attitude towards the past and the views of others4 ,the liveliness and modernity of his mind did not blind him to the lessons of antiquity1 and his essays in the 8restoration0 of classical buildings show him to have been an earnest antiquary4 ,criticism of his conclusions must carry with it the remembrance that the apparatus criticus was exceedingly limited in his day1 when the book was everything4 ,the spade had not yet revealed a superior authority and opened out a vast prospect of boundless antiquity and tradition4 ,one of the most interesting features of the interleaved documents in the heirloom ,parentalia is the sketch of ,wren's conjectural restoration of the ,mausoleum of ,halicarnassus4,d ,the last note of the printed ,parentalia is headed1 8,of the ,sepulchre of ,mausolus1 ,king of ,caria40 ,it ends with the words1 8,the plate of the above is omitted1 on account of the drawing being imperfect40 ,this imperfect drawing is pasted on the last page of the ,discourse in the heirloom copy1 and shows ,wren to be less careful as an archologist than might have been anticipated4 8,the ,sepulchre10 he writes1 8is so well described by ,pliny that ,i have attempted to design it accordingly1 and also very open1 conformable to the ,description in ,martial1 ,aere vacuo ,pendentia ,mausolea1 and yet it wanted not the solidity of the ,dorick order20 and he goes on to say1 on very insufficient grounds1 8,i conclude this work must be the exactest ,form of the ,dorick40 ,the odd thing is that ,wren had not noticed the statement of ,vitruvius that ,pythios1 the architect of the ,mausoleum and the sculptor of the chariot group1 gave up the ,doric order because of the incongruous arrangements which arose in its use4 ,wren's great blunder1 however1 was in the misreading of one word in ,pliny's description1 8,pteron40 ,he says it is an unusual term4 ,russell ,sturgis gives its meaning as 8that which forms a side or flank1 as the row of columns along the side of a temple1 or the side wall itself40 ,it is the more odd that ,wren boggled over the word ,pteron1 seeing that he used the word ,dipteron in his description of the ,temple of ,diana at ,ephesus4 ,at ,ephesus there was no question in his mind of an 8,attick order rising above the cornice10 but he takes the ,pteron at ,halicarnassus to have that meaning1 and to be 8a word of ,greek ,authors of ,architecture now lost40 ,anyhow1 it pleasantly exemplifies on how insubstantial a foundation can rest a piece of architectural criticism which is based on literary evidence alone4 ,his mistake naturally vitiates the whole restoration1 apart from the fact that the ,mausoleum was of the ,ionic order4 ,the consideration of ,wren's restoration will send the student to ,professor ,lethaby's illuminating monographs on 8,greek ,buildings represented by fragments in the ,british ,museum40 ,they must make him realise again1 and more sensitively1 the importance of going to the stones1 and setting aside even ,pliny 7or1 perhaps1 especially ,pliny7 if he does not confirm their evidence4 ,on the wall of the ,mausoleum ,room at the ,british ,museum is a drawing lettered 8,design by ,sir ,c4 ,wren from ,pliny's description of the ,tomb of ,mausolus1 copied from ,wren's book1 the ,parentalia10 and signed 8,j4 ,e4 ,goodchild1 #ahic40 ,goodchild was a pupil of ,cockerell1 who also made a restoration represented at the ,british ,museum both by a drawing and a model4 ,in the ,,ms4 of the ,parentalia at the ,royal ,society is a sheet with a rough sketch-plan1 doubtless from ,wren's hand4 ,from it and from ,wren's description1 ,goodchild presumably made his drawing4 ,the sketch elevation in the heirloom copy gives an infinitely better-proportioned and more reasonable building than ,goodchild's4 ,there is the possibility that the imperfect drawing referred to in the ,parentalia is the sketch-plan bound up with the ,,ms41 but ,i feel sure the elevation in the heirloom copy is indicated4 ,goodchild's description on the drawing suggests that he had merely copied from the ,parentalia4 ,it would have been more correct had he said 8based on indications in the ,parentalia40 ,a word may be added about ,wren's description 7printed in the ,parentalia7 of the ,artemision at ,ephesus4 ,there are bound1 in the ordinary copies of the book1 engravings of a plan and elevation of the ,temple1 and also a plan and elevation of ,wren's conjectural restoration of the shrine of the goddess4 ,the odd feature of this restoration is again ,wren's reliance on ,pliny's figures1 which would have made what ,professor ,lethaby calls a temple of 8enormous and impossible size40 ,in order to fit in ,pliny's #abg columns1 ,wren has to make the fronts decastyle4 ,to absorb the odd number of columns he invents a quite enchanting shrine which has small claim to credibility1 and rather recalls the garden temples of the eighteenth century4 ,he again neglects the safer guidance of ,vitruvius1 who states that the temple was octastyle4 ,his observations on the ,temple of ,peace built by ,vespasian include some charming phrases3 8,each ,deity had a peculiar ,gesture1 ,face1 and ,dress hieroglyphically proper to it2 as then ,stories were but ,morals involved3 and not only their ,altars and ,sacrifices were mystical1 but the very ,forms of their ,temples4 ,no ,language1 no ,poetry can so describe ,peace1 and the ,effects of it in ,men's ,minds1 as the ,design of the ,temple naturally paints it1 without any affectation of the ,allegory4 ,it is easy of ,access1 and open1 carries an humble ,front1 but embraces wide1 is luminous and pleasant1 and content with an internal ,greatness1 despises an invidious ,appearance of all that ,heighth it might otherwise justly boast of1 but rather fortifying itself on every ,side1 rests secure on a ,square and ample ,basis40 ,but devotion to the antiquities of ,greece did not hinder ,wren from digging deeply into the history of ,roman ,britain1 and his conclusions as to the ,london of the ,romans are quoted with respect by the archologists of to-day4 ,amongst the criticisms directed against ,wren as an antiquary are those which are concerned with his ,gothic exercises4 ,one otherwise devout admirer says of ,st4 ,dunstan-in-the-,east1 ,st4 ,mary's1 ,aldermary1 and ,st4 ,michael's1 ,cornhill3 8,whether ,wren made these designs under pressure1 or merely as academical exercises for the entertainment of his friends is unknown1 but it is very evident that he had not the least sympathy with ,gothic architecture1 or taken any trouble to master its most rudimentary features40 ,without going into the reasons for these ,gothic adventures beyond dismissing the idea that ,wren made such solid entertainment for his friends1 it is at least safe to reply that ,wren understood the nature of ,gothic very well4 ,that is not to say that he could reproduce it1 but the informed student of any phase of art is not necessarily the person to create it4 ,in #affi he made a survey of ,salisbury ,cathedral for his old friend ,bishop ,seth ,ward1 and wrote a report which shows a true critical appreciation of the problems of the medival architect1 of where he failed but also of where he succeeded4 ,there is none of the contemptuous violence used by the virtuous ,evelyn when he refers to ,gothic1 which led the way for ,ruskin's later vehemence about the 8foul torrent of the ,renaissance40 ,wren merely remarks1 8,this ,form of ,churches has been rejected by modern ,architects abroad1 who use the better and ,roman ,art of ,architecture10 and commends the proportions of the nave and aisles3 8,the ,mouldings are decently mixed with large ,planes1 without an ,affectation of filling every ,corner with ,ornaments1 444 the ,architect trusted to a stately and rich plainness40 ,wren's criticisms are directed to the foundations1 the low level of the floor1 the insufficient size of the pillars1 and the bracing of the walls with iron4 ,he also objected1 with some justice1 to the poise of the aisle vaulting1 supported from without by buttresses but not within save by the pillars themselves4 ,it happened that ,wren had to concern himself intimately with other 8congestions of heavy dark melancholy and monkish piles1 without any just proportion1 use or beauty0 7the phrase is ,evelyn's71 such as ,westminster ,abbey4 ,for twenty-five years he was ,surveyor to the ,abbey1 and wrote a ,report on it in #agac4 ,we may pass over his historical paragraphs1 which show shrewdness of observation1 for his obiter dicta on ,gothic methods4 ,he disliked the 8flutter of archbuttresses10 as they 8occasion the ,ruin of ,cathedrals1 being so much exposed to the ,air and ,weather10 but is tolerant of ,henry ,,vii4's ,chapel1 8a nice embroidered ,work40 ,we have learnt by dire experience the heavy burden of repairs incident to the medival system of external supports by flying arches1 pinnacles1 and buttresses in our climate4 ,he goes on to specify necessary repairs1 some done1 and others needed1 and to plead for the finishing of the ,west ,front and the completion of the ,central ,tower with the addition of a spire1 which 8will give a proper ,grace to the whole ,fabrick1 and the ,west ,end of the ,city1 which seems to want it40 ,sir ,charles ,barry was later to be equally concerned with the idea of completing the outline of the ,abbey1 as his last designs show4 ,wren's common sense and real respect for ,gothic are alike shown by his proposal for the spire3 8,i have made a ,design1 which will not be very expensive but light1 and still in the ,gothic form1 and of a ,style with the rest of the ,structure1 which ,i would strictly adhere to1 throughout the whole ,intention3 to deviate from the old ,form would be to run into a disagreeable ,mixture3 which no ,person of a good ,taste could relish40 ,he went on to talk of the north window1 then stopped with plaster to prevent its total ruin1 and said his models for the new work were 8such as ,i conceive may agree with the original scheme of the old ,architect1 without any modern mixtures to shew my own ,inventions40 ,his ,north ,transept ,front was swept away by ,pearson1 not to everyone's satisfaction1 and though the ,gothic grammar of it was inevitably at fault1 because he was trying to do something against the current of the times1 the failure was not due to any lack of appreciation of ,gothic4 ,the existing western towers were not built in ,wren's lifetime and he need not be charged with the defects of their execution by the introduction of definitely classical cornices and other details of a type which ,wren would not have used4 ,so much for ,wren as a student of ,gothic4 ,i come now to an example of the use he made of other men's writings4 ,in the library of ,shirburn ,castle there is a copy of ,wotton's ,elements of ,architecture1 first edition1 #afbd1 annotated by the hand of ,sir ,christopher himself4 ,it is worth while quoting from these notes in some detail1 because they show that ,wren was a careful reader and that he was quick to mark every kind of practical application of what he read4 ,the page references are to the first edition of the ,elements4 ,where ,wotton says of staircases 7on p4 #eh7 that 8the breadth of every single step should never be less than one foot1 nor more than eighteen inches10 ,wren adds 8nor so much as eighteen inches at any time1 for if a step exceed twelve1 those who have but short legs must tread twice upon the same step1 especially in descent1 which1 to women especially1 is troublesome1 and dangerous to the hasty40 ,james ,wyatt1 in the circular staircase of ,devonshire ,house1 erred in this way1 with exactly the effect that ,wren describes4 ,one bears in mind in this connection that ,wren himself was of short stature4 ,on p4 #ee ,wotton discourses of the advantage of luminous rooms3 8,indeed1 ,i must confess that a frank light can misbecome no edifice whatsoever1 temples only excepted1 which were anciently dark1 as they are likewise at this day in some proportion1 devotion more requiring collected than defused spirits10 on which ,wren makes the comment that ,christ ,church in ,london was practically nothing but window1 and was fitter for a stage than for a church1 8although for the kind of building it is a thorough piece of work40 ,on gardens and their treatment with aqueducts1 walks1 etc41 ,wren makes the note1 8,and for disposing the current of a river to a mighty length in a little space ,i invented the ,serpentine1 a form admirably convoying the current in circular and yet contrary motions upon one and the same level1 with walks and retirements between to the advantage of all purposes1 either of gardenings1 plantings1 or banquetings 444 far beyond the bungarly 6 invention at ,hatfield so much liked for pleasure40 ,up and down the book there are scattered all manner of other interesting notes4 ,there is a practical thought in ,wren's reference to the very small chimneys in use in ,spain1 where charcoal was sold by weight4 ,he has evidently had difficulty with smoky chimneys1 for to ,wotton's observation1 8,then there is a repulsion of the fume by some higher hill or fabrique that shall overtop the chimney10 he makes the significant comment1 8,as in our buildings here40 ,in connection with terracing any story 7by which ,wotton seems to have meant the making of loggias71 ,wren remarks3 8,terracing is most commended in hotter climates1 and in our country must serve mostly for summer rooms40 ,to ,wotton's general reflection that 8various colours on the out-walls of buildings have always in them more delight than dignity10 ,wren adds the criticism in ,latin that in this particular the noble building of ,lord ,exeter at ,wimbledon also offends4 ,he seems1 however1 to have been friendly to the use of mosaic1 for he says3 8,herein excels that excellent cave at ,bodington wherein stands the brazen hydra with seven springs out of seven heads40 ,with regard to the art of the plasterer1 ,wotton had said3 8,plastique is not only under sculpture1 but indeed very sculpture itself1 with this difference that the plasterer doth make his figures by addition1 and the carver by subtraction40 ,wren makes short work of this with1 8,this proposition can never hold true to the name of sculpture40 ,at the end of the ,elements ,wotton promises another work1 8,a ,philosophical ,survey of ,education1 which is indeed a ,second ,building or ,repairing of ,nature1 and1 as ,i may term it1 a kind of moral architecture40 ,wren must have taken considerable pleasure from the ,elements1 for in the margin he has written3 8,oh that we might see that1 so long expected40 ,there are bits of detailed criticism in his first ,tract which might have been used in recent comments on a great ,london building3 8,fronts ought to be elevated in the ,middle1 not the ,corners2 because the ,middle is the place of greatest ,dignity and first arrests the ,eye2 and rather projecting forward in the ,middle1 than hollow4 ,for these ,reasons1 ,pavilions at the ,corners are naught2 because they make both ,faults1 a hollow and depressed ,front4444 ,no ,roof can have ,dignity enough to appear above a ,cornice1 but the ,circular3 in private ,buildings it is excusable40 ,we know little about the amount of ,wren's general reading1 but he was certainly a student of ,elyot's ,governour4 ,some years ago ,i was the means of placing in the ,r4,i4,b4,a4 ,library the #aedf edition of this once famous but now almost forgotten book4 ,its chief interest lies in the fact that it bears the autographs on the title-page of ,sir ,christopher's father1 ,dean ,christopher ,wren1 and of ,sir ,christopher himself4 ,the other writings scribbled on the margins are the work of much earlier owners of the volume1 which was nearly a century old when the ,dean acquired it4 ,there is some little evidence that the architect studied the book with care4 ,sir ,thomas ,elyot was concerned to set out the whole behaviour of a knightly gentleman1 and among other things gives some warnings against the use of oaths4 ,when ,sir ,christopher was building ,st4 ,paul's ,cathedral he was distressed by the profanity of the workmen1 and posted up a notice directed against bad language4 ,it is possible that he consulted the ,governour before drafting this notice1 for the page references in the index under the heading 8othes0 has been corrected from #agj to #afj1 and this was possibly done by ,wren when he sought for what ,elyot had to say about oaths4 ,,chapter ,,xiv 8,,the ,,architect ,,of ,,adventure0 ,in trying to estimate with any precision what is ,wren's position in the history of ,british ,architecture1 the immediate and obvious comparison is with ,inigo ,jones4 ,i refer to ,wren in my ,preface as our architect of greatest achievement1 because ,i hesitate to use the simpler words--our greatest architect4 ,in my own mind the latter is a true description1 but the enthusiasts for ,inigo ,jones would dispute it4 ,none1 however1 can cavil at the statement that ,wren achieved more than any other ,english architect1 whatever nice distinctions may be drawn as to the relative greatness of his art and that of ,inigo ,jones4 ,the two men are not strictly comparable1 and represent in their work and outlook two different currents in the history of architecture4 ,inigo ,jones was essentially academic and1 in his relationship to the traditional methods of building which he found1 the forerunner of the modern professional architect4 ,he had trained himself by much foreign travel and by close study of the facts of building before he embarked on his career4 ,wren1 on the other hand1 was essentially an amateur1 if the word be understood in its most favourable sense and not in the least contemptuously4 ,inigo ,jones was not an inventor4 ,he took the ,palladio tradition as his model and adhered to it with faithfulness4 ,wren does not seem to have had any particular hero amongst the great ,italian architects4 ,he kept throughout his career a free mind1 open to the suggestions of his own inventiveness1 ready to accept existing conditions1 rather than academic rules1 as the guides to his treatment of a problem1 and eager to try new structural ideas4 ,it must plainly be said that ,wren suffered frequent lapses of taste1 and it does no service to his great memory to gloss over these faults4 ,as a result of them it happened that practically no work of ,wren1 however noble in its conception1 however magnificent its solution of difficult problems1 can be freed from criticism in detail4 ,he did not produce the complete unity against which no criticism can lie4 ,of ,inigo ,jones at ,st4 ,paul's1 ,covent ,garden 7as it was before it was rebuilt71 and again at the ,banqueting ,hall1 of ,robert ,adam in the hall at ,syon1 and of ,sir ,charles ,barry at the ,reform ,club1 it can be said that they made no mistakes4 ,each achievement is complete and perfect in its kind4 ,but it is impossible to say that even of ,st4 ,paul's ,cathedral3 there are elements in its design which are weak and confused4 ,even in the steeple of ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow1 which is very nearly perfect1 the diameter of the cylinder enclosed by the ring of columns is hardly right4 ,this sort of criticism is even more true of the majority of the ,city churches4 ,the cause for this lack of perfection is not difficult to find4 ,wren was an amateur1 not only by the cast of his mind1 but by the circumstances of his entry into architecture3 he was imperfectly trained for his work4 ,illustration3 ,s,t ,,mary-,,le-,,bow ,if he had followed the example of ,inigo ,jones and studied the ,italian ,renaissance on the spot1 not only in respect of design1 but also of the facts of building1 he would have avoided many pitfalls4 ,great as is the part which the knowledge of mathematics and geometry plays in his art1 nothing did and nothing could take the place of the practical knowledge of the art of building which ,jones possessed and ,wren lacked1 at least until his later years4 ,it is possible1 for example1 that the present trouble at ,st4 ,paul's ,cathedral would have been avoided if ,wren1 whose whole admiration was for the ,roman manner of building1 had gone to ,rome to see what1 in fact1 ,roman building was4 ,he would then have learnt that ,roman builders did not carry immense weights on piers which consisted1 as at ,st4 ,paul's1 of a core of rubble cased in by finely jointed ashlar4 ,he would have found that it was advisable to build them either of ashlar throughout1 or1 if he had decided on a rubble core with an ashlar casing1 to interrupt the rubble core at reasonable intervals by courses of hard tiles or bricks4 ,these would have prevented the perpendicular settlement of the rubble that has now disturbed the relation between the rubble and the ashlar casing4 ,the professional ,inigo ,jones would not have made that mistake4 ,the amateur ,wren did4 ,and there is little excuse for this fault4 ,in his ,report on ,st4 ,paul's1 written before the ,fire1 ,wren is very contemptuous of his ,gothic predecessor3 8,the work was both ill design'd and ill built from the ,beginning3 ill design'd1 because the ,architect gave not ,butment enough to counterpoise and resist the weight of the ,roof from spreading the ,walls2 for the ,eye alone will discover to any man that those ,pillars1 as vast as they are1 even eleven ,foot diameter1 are bent outwards at least six inches from their first position4 ,this bending of the ,pillars was facilitated by their ill ,building1 for they are only cased without1 and that with small stones1 not one greater than a ,man's ,burden2 but within it is nothing but a ,core of small ,rubbish-stone1 and much mortar1 which easily crushes and yields to the weight40 ,when the time came for ,wren to build the piers that carry his dome1 he fell into exactly the same blunder4 ,he was similarly defeated sometimes by problems of design for lack of knowledge of the history of his art1 and by too great a reliance on his own invention4 ,in trying at ,st4 ,paul's to marry the idea of a great central dome to the ,gothic cruciform plan with a determination to preserve the long vista down the aisles1 he involved himself in difficulties in the support of the dome which he could not safely overcome without clumsy elements of design1 to be discussed later4 ,illustration3 ,,plate ,,xvi ,,wren ,,medal ,,at ,,wadham ,,college4 ,cast and chased about #aghc by ,g4 ,d4 ,gaale4 ,yet1 in spite of all his technical ignorance1 he succeeded because of the essential greatness of his mind4 ,in succeeding1 he carried architecture forward1 not by a normal development1 but by leaps and bounds1 so far indeed1 that there was found no one to follow him in that line of development4 ,hawksmoor was an exceedingly capable architect who had benefited1 so far as his capacity would allow1 by thirty-two years of close association with the master2 but1 as ,sir ,reginald ,blomfield has said1 he was always trying to interpret ,vanbrugh in terms of ,wren4 ,while he was under the influence of ,wren he designed like ,wren1 when he came under the influence of ,vanbrugh he designed like ,vanbrugh4 ,of ,wren's own outlook on his art we fortunately possess illuminating notes1 not only in his printed ,tracts1 but in a ,,ms4 bound up with the heirloom ,parentalia4 ,it was printed by ,miss ,phillimore1 and forms the text of ,professor ,lethaby's enchanting essay on 8,the ,architecture of ,adventure10,e from which ,i have borrowed the heading of this chapter--an acknowledgment1 trivial though it be1 of the debt ,i owe to its author4 ,wren's paper is no more than a fragment1 but it is a noble fragment and begins thus3 8,whatever a man's sentiments are upon mature deliberation1 it will still be necessary for him in a conspicuous ,work to preserve his ,undertaking from general censure1 and so for him to accommodate his ,designs to the gust of the ,age he lives in1 tho' it appears to him less rational4 ,i have found no little difficulty to bring ,persons1 of otherwise a good genius1 to think anything in ,architecture would be better than what they had heard commended by others1 and what they had view'd themselves4 ,many good ,gothick forms of ,cathedrals were to be seen in our ,country1 and many had been seen abroad1 which they liked the better for being not much different from ours in ,england3 this humour with many is not yet eradicated1 and1 therefore1 ,i judge it not improper to endeavour to reform the ,generality to a truer taste in ,architecture by giving a larger ,idea of the whole ,art1 beginning with the reasons and progress of it1 from the most remote ,antiquity2 and that in short touching chiefly on some things which have not been remarked by others4 ,the ,project of ,building is as natural to ,mankind as to ,birds2 and was practised before the ,flood40 ,and then ,wren goes off into musings on the construction of the ,ark1 the ,tower of ,babel1 the ,pyramids1 and the ,sepulchre of ,porsenna as described by ,pliny1 finishing with this luminous phrase3 8,i have been the longer in this ,description1 because the ,fabrick was in the ,age of ,pythagoras and his ,school1 when the ,world began to be fond of ,geometry and ,arithmetick40 ,this was the core of ,wren's claim as an architect1 the reliance upon scientific rather than traditional elements in design4 ,he develops the idea in his first ,tract printed in ,parentalia3 8,beauty is a ,harmony of ,objects1 begetting ,pleasure by the ,eye4 ,there are two ,causes of ,beauty--natural and customary4 ,natural is from ,geometry1 consisting in ,uniformity 7that is equality7 and ,proportion4 ,customary ,beauty is begotten by the ,use of our ,senses to those ,objects which are usually pleasing to us for other ,causes1 as ,familiarity or particular ,inclination breeds a ,love to ,things not in themselves lovely4 ,here lies the great ,occasion of ,errors1 here is tried the ,architects ,judgment1 but always the true ,test is natural or geometrical ,beauty4 ,geometrical ,figures are naturally more beautiful than other irregular2 in this all consent as to a ,law of ,nature4 ,of geometrical ,figures1 the ,square and the ,circle are most beautiful2 next the ,parallelogram and the ,oval4 ,straight ,lines are more beautiful than ,curve4444 ,there are only two beautiful ,positions of strait ,lines1 perpendicular and horizontal2 this is from ,nature and consequently ,necessity1 no other than upright being firm40 ,wren's acute judgment noted the great part played by such factors as historical association1 one of the 8other causes10 in the public appreciation of architecture4 ,earlier in the ,tract he makes obeisance to the three principles which had been laid down by earlier writers1 but with a characteristic rider3 8,beauty1 ,firmness and ,convenience are the ,principles3 the two first depend upon geometrical ,reasons of ,opticks and ,staticks2 the third only makes the ,variety40 ,scholarly though ,wren was in his art1 he took nothing for granted1 but examined the common-places with a desire to establish reasons for them or reject them3 8,modern authors who have treated of ,architecture seem generally to have little more in view1 but to set down the ,proportions of ,columns1 ,architraves and ,cornices in the several ,orders1 as they are distinguished into ,dorick1 ,ionick1 ,corinthian1 and ,composite1 and in these ,proportions finding them in the ancient ,fabricks of the ,greeks and ,romans 7though more arbitrarily used than they care to acknowledge7 they have reduced them into ,rules1 too strict and pedantick1 and so as not to be transgressed1 without the ,crime of ,barbarity1 though in their own ,nature they are but the ,modes and ,fashions of those ages wherein they were used40 ,there is a very modern ring about the following moralising3 8,although ,architecture contains many excellent ,parts1 besides the ranging of ,pillars1 yet ,curiosity may lead us to consider whence this ,affectation arose originally1 so as to judge nothing beautiful but what was adorned with ,columns1 even where there was no real use of them4444 ,it will be to the purpose1 therefore1 to examine whence proceeded this ,affectation of a ,mode which hath continued now at least #c1jjj years1 and the rather1 because it may lead us to the ,grounds of ,architecture and by what ,steps this ,humour of ,colonades came into ,practice in all ,ages40 ,but for all his contempt of the pedantry of rules of proportion1 which the greatest architects of antiquity did not observe unless it suited them1 he saw in the ,orders themselves something eternal3 8,architecture aims at ,eternity2 and therefore the only thing uncapable of ,modes and ,fashions in its ,principals1 the ,orders4 ,the ,orders are not only ,roman and ,greek1 but ,phnician1 ,hebrew1 and ,assyrian1 being founded upon the ,experience of all ,ages1 promoted by the vast ,treasures of all the great ,monarchs1 and skill of the greatest ,artists and ,geometricians1 every one emulating each other40 ,wren rises to his greatest height in the opening of his first ,tract1 and shows that if his life had fallen out otherwise1 he might have left a reputation as a writer3 8,architecture has its political ,use2 ,public ,buildings being the ,ornament of a ,country2 it establishes a ,nation1 draws ,people and ,commerce2 makes the ,people love their native ,country1 which ,passion is the ,original of all great ,actions in a ,commonwealth4 ,the ,emulation of the ,cities of ,greece was the true ,cause of their ,greatness4 ,the obstinate ,valour of the ,jews1 occasioned by the ,love of their ,temple1 was a ,cement that held together that ,people1 for many ,ages1 through infinite ,changes40 ,i have quoted at what may seem to be inordinate length1 but ,wren is justified alike by the content of his thought and the aptness of his phrase1 and ,i am concerned rather to reveal the man than my idea of him4 ,in all ,wren's writings he shows an acute perception of the fact that architecture has had an immensely long evolution4 ,he had1 of course1 no suspicion as to how far back its origins were to be sought1 but clearly he was approaching the idea that forms1 once constructive1 pass into decoration and become part of the language of architecture4 ,this is the final and1 as ,i believe1 the effective reply to the puritan theorist1 who cries aloud for the discarding of traditional features in art4 ,sir ,joshua ,reynolds warned his students that the business of a painter is to paint a fine picture1 and that he is not to be cheated of his materials by specious arguments4 ,wren was clear-sighted enough to see that the ,orders have a definite beauty value3 his only trouble was that he was not fully equipped to bend them wholly to his will4 ,the western front of ,st4 ,paul's may be taken as an instance4 ,as a ,whole it is a magnificent composition1 and a source of inspiration to everyone with any feeling for architecture1 but can it be pretended that the segmental vault of the upper portico does not belie the entablature and pediment in front of it8 ,wren could cut away architrave and frieze inside for the benefit of his great arches1 and refer his critics to the ,temple of ,peace 7now the ,basilica of ,maxentius7 at ,rome for his authority1 but he lacked the insight or the courage to deal with the external problem in the same fashion4 ,the fact is that the great architect of any age is both leader and led1 and cannot wholly escape the limitations of his time4 ,but there are valid compensations4 ,his work could not be justly representative of the age1 one of the significant values of architecture1 if he could entirely dissociate himself from his age4 ,when it is remembered that ,sir ,william ,chambers can actually say in his ,civil ,architecture 7#agei7 that every time he passes ,st4 ,paul's he regrets that the pilasters have no entasis--probably few know it--we can form an idea of the limitations of thought that ,wren would have to encounter4 ,vitruvius1,f with all his imperfections1 was still enthroned1 and few1 if any1 had yet divined the real relation of that retired military engineer to the arts of ,greece and ,rome4 ,wren had the true spirit of ,bacon1 and1 with further travel1 might have seen further through the idols of his market-place4 ,he seems to have realised the trouble in which he had involved himself in the arches of the octagon that supports his mighty dome4 ,every architectural student since his day has sat and speculated as to what the solution might have or should have been4 ,wren left a sufficiently feeble suggestion of curtains and seated apostles1 occupying the tribunes 7three in each presumably71 as a means of veiling the defect4 ,but the difficulty goes deeper than that3 the octagon is peculiarly troublesome to handle in terms of the ,orders1 as a number of failures exist to show4 ,wren's work was always improving4 ,the last1 and westernmost1 bay of ,st4 ,paul's inside shows more breadth and grandeur1 but the carving of the spandrels is so strange that one wonders if it can really be original4 ,this brings us to a characteristic of ,wren which probably accounts for some of his lapses of taste4 ,it seems likely that he was not hard-hearted enough with the people who worked under him1 that he was too generous1 too ready to accept things on his assistants' and craftsmen's assurance that they were the best that could be produced4 ,he may thus have been led into an occasional acquiescence1 both in design and construction1 in things which he must have well known were not really right4 ,confronted with every sort of difficulty1 and none too well backed1 he must have been desperately anxious to avoid delays4 ,his very ingenuity1 moreover1 would lead him to make the most of what was available4 ,unfortunately in works of eternity--architecture aims at eternity--such compromises meet with a stern ,nemesis4 ,in the two centuries that have elapsed since his death ,wren has been admired and followed from very different points of view4 ,it has been justly said that he has been in fashion and out of fashion and is now above fashion4 ,any doubt as to the reality and massive quality of his genius can easily be dissipated by a consideration of what imitators have done4 ,no domed church on the lines of ,st4 ,paul's has achieved equal beauty and grandeur1 nor have any of the innumerable steeples1 based on his inventions1 been of the same rank4 ,in domestic buildings1 his special character remains pre-eminent and informs the best work of to-day--a certain graciousness that in others degenerated often into heaviness4 ,there is a vast gap between ,wren at ,hampton ,court and ,talman at ,chatsworth4 ,thus it is that in this ,bicentenary ,year there is the same feeling that caused ,sir ,john ,vanbrugh to refuse the succession to his office 8out of tenderness for ,sir ,christopher ,wren10 and that led the ,spectator to publish a noble tribute repudiating the ingratitude of his dismissal4 ,the lovers of architecture everywhere will feel that in honouring ,wren they have honoured the ,art to which a man of such amazing gifts and nobility of character was content to devote the flower of his life4 ,sir ,christopher ,wren was the very fulfilment of ,wotton's prophecy--8,architecture can want no commendation1 where there are ,noble ,men or ,noble mindes40 ,,appendix ,i ,a ,,note ,,in ,,amplification ,,of ,,the ,,reference ,,in ,,chapter ,,iv4 ,,to ,,pascal',s ,,problem ,mathematicians who wished to answer ,pascal's challenge were given until ,october #a1 #afeh1 for a solution1 and an umpire1 ,m4 de ,cavarci1 was nominated1 and the prizes were #dj doubloons or pistoles and for the second1 #bj4 ,in a letter of ,october #aj ,pascal says he has received both attempts at solutions of the problems set and also a number of discussions of matters connected with the cycloid which did not pretend to be solutions of his problem3 8,mais entre tous les crits qu'on a recues de cette sorte1 il n'y a rien de plus beau que ce qui a t envoy par ,m4 ,wren2 car outre la belle manire qu'il donne de mesurer le plan de la roulette 7cycloid71 il a donn la comparaison de la ligne courbe mme et ses parties1 avec la ligne droit3 sa proposition est que la ligne de la roulette est quadruple de son axe1 dont il a envoy l'nonciation sans dmonstration4 ,et comme il est le premier qui l'a produite1 c'est sans doute a lui que l'honneur de la premire invention en appartient40 ,summing up his history of the cycloid1 he concluded that the first to remark that curve in nature was ,p4 ,mersenne1 that ,m4 de ,roberval first worked out some of its properties1 8que le premier qui en a mesur la ligne courbe a t ,m4 ,wren40 ,the story is then taken up by a letter of ,cavarci 7dated ,december #aj1 #afeh71 the umpire1 to ,pascal 7now masquerading under a new pseudonym--,a4 ,dettonville an anagram of ,louis de ,montalte71 in which he recites the nature of the problems set--i4e41 to find the dimensions and centres of gravity of the solids generated by the revolution of the cycloid4 ,he goes on to say that there were sent solutions of the more easy problems--8savoir3 le centre de gravit de la ligne courbe et la dimension des solides1 lequelle ,m4 ,wren nous envoya dans ses lettres du #ab ,octobre0--but concludes that of the challenge problem no solutions had been sent4 ,pascal replied to this letter with a series of letters setting out a general method for dealing with such problems and the actual solutions of the problems he had proposed4 ,the real quarrel as to whether the problems had been solved or not was with ,wallis and not with ,wren4 ,wallis appears to have sent a solution and followed it up by various letters offering corrections4 ,however1 he was adjudged wrong in principle 7see ,rcit de l',examen pour les prix sur la ,roulette74 ,the prizes were not awarded4 ,wallis afterwards 7#afei7 published a 8,tractatus de ,cycloide10 in which are included four propositions on the cycloid which ,wren had given to ,wallis4 ,turning now to ,wren's counter problem4 ,it is not directly connected with the cycloid1 but with one of the properties of the ellipse1 and it had previously been suggested by ,kepler4 ,it appears to have been confused with ,pascal's cycloid problems because ,pascal showed in his general method that various cycloid problems could be referred to the ellipse4 ,pascal has a chapter1 8,l'galit entre les lignes courbes de toutes sortes de ,roulettes et les lignes elliptiques10 in the course of which he remarks1 8,cette admirable galit de la courbe de la roulette simple une droite straight line que ,m4 ,wren a trouve1 n'tait1 pour aussi dire1 q'une galit par accident1 qui vient de ce qu'en ce cas l'ellipse se trouv rduite une droite40 ,wren's challenge seems to have remained unnoticed4 ,,appendix ,,ii ,,an ,,attempt ,,at ,a ,,wren ,,chronology ,the dates of ,wren's work have been set down so wildly that ,i prefer the omission of some buildings to the repetition of blunders4 ,even so ,i have no doubt repeated many old mistakes and made some fresh ones4 ,an accurate chronology of ,wren would be of great comfort to the student4 ,i have checked only forty-seven of ,miss ,milman's dates1 but found forty-five of them wrong1 by from one to twenty-five years4 ,the ,city churches are given under the year during which the first payment to the builders was made3 the dates in brackets mark the last of such payments1 which may well have been some years after the buildings were completed4 ,wren seems to have settled final accounts in batches4 ,l4 ,w4 #afcb4 ,birth of ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 ,october #bj4 #afdb4 ,entered ,westminster ,school4 #afdg4 ,invention of weather-clock4 #afdi4 ,entered ,wadham ,college4 #afea4 ,b4,a4 #afec4 ,m4,a4 and ,fellow of ,all ,souls4 #afed4 ,meets ,john ,evelyn at ,oxford4 #afeg4 ,appointed ,gresham ,professor of ,astronomy4 #afeh4 ,attempt to solve ,pascal's problem4 #affj4 ,royal ,society founded in ,wren's room at ,gresham ,college4 #affa4 ,appointed ,savilian ,professor of ,astronomy4 ,d4,c4,l41 ,oxford and ,cambridge4 ,appointed ,assistant to ,sir ,john ,denham1 ,surveyor-,general4 #affb4 ,offer of ,tangier surveyorship refused4 ,appointed to survey old ,st4 ,paul's4 #affc4 ,doorway1 ,ely ,cathedral4 ,pembroke ,chapel1 ,cambridge1 begun4 ,sheldonian ,theatre1 ,oxford4 #affe4 ,trinity ,college1 ,oxford3 new court4 ,visit to ,paris 7,july74 #afff4 ,return from ,paris 7,march74 ,report on old ,st4 ,paul's 7,may71 and ,first ,design for dome over crossing4 ,the ,great ,fire 7,september74 ,prepared new ,plan of ,london4 ,appointed ,surveyor-,general and ,principal ,architect for repairing ,st4 ,paul's1 the ,city churches1 and other public buildings4 #affh4 ,emmanuel ,chapel1 ,cambridge 7#afgg74 ,repairs to ,salisbury ,cathedral ,spire4 #affi4 ,first ,marriage3 to ,faith ,coghill1 ,december #g4 ,appointed ,surveyor-,general of the ,king's ,works4 #afgj4 ,st4 ,olave's1 ,jewry 7#afgi74 ,st4 ,dunstan's-in-the-,east 7#afga74 ,st4 ,michael's ,wood ,street 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,mary ,aldermanbury 7#afhf74 ,st4 ,mary-at-,hill 7#afgf74 ,st4 ,christopher's 7#afge74 ,st4 ,vedast ,fosters 7#afgc74 ,st4 ,sepulchre's 7#afgg74 ,st4 ,mary ,woolnoth 7#afgg73 the pre-,hawksmoor church4 ,st4 ,mildred ,poultry 7#afgi74 ,st4 ,benet ,fink 7#afha74 ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow 7#afhj74 ,st4 ,lawrence ,jewry 7#afhf74 ,st4 ,bride's 7#afhd74 ,st4 ,dionis ,backchurch 7#afhf74 ,st4 ,michael's ,cornhill 7#afgg74 ,st4 ,edmund the ,king 7#afgi74 ,st4 ,sepulchre's 7#afgg74 8,rejected ,design0 for ,st4 ,paul's4 ,temple ,bar4 #afga4 ,st4 ,nicholas ,cole ,abbey 7#afha74 ,st4 ,george ,botolph 7#afgi74 ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow ,steeple 7#afhc74 ,st4 ,magnus 7#afhg74 ,the ,monument4 ,wren meets ,grinling ,gibbons4 #afgb4 ,st4 ,stephen's ,walbrook 7#afhg74 ,wren knighted 7or possibly #afgd74 #afgc4 ,st4 ,paul's3 8,model ,design0 approved by ,king 7afterwards rejected74 ,trinity ,college ,library1 ,cambridge4 #afgd4 ,st4 ,bartholomew ,exchange 7#afhf74 ,st4 ,stephen's ,coleman ,street 7#afha72 ,st4 ,james ,garlickhithe 7#afhg74 ,honywood ,library1 ,lincoln ,cathedral4 #afge4 ,st4 ,paul's3 8,warrant ,design0 approved by ,king and first stone laid4 ,birth of son ,christopher4 ,death of first wife4 ,greenwich ,observatory4 #afgf4 ,st4 ,anne and ,st4 ,agnes 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,michael's ,queenhithe 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,michael ,bassishaw 7#afhb74 #afgg4 ,christ ,church 7#afia74 ,st4 ,peter's ,cornhill 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,benet ,paul's ,wharf 7#afhe74 ,st4 ,martin's ,ludgate 7#afhg74 ,all ,hallows the ,great 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,swithin's 7#afhg74 ,all ,hallows ,bread ,street 7#afhg74 ,second marriage3 to ,jane ,fitzwilliam1 ,february #bd4 ,birth of daughter ,jane1 ,november4 #afgh4 ,st4 ,antholin's 7#afia74 ,design of ,charles ,i4's tomb4 #afgi4 ,kilmainham ,hospital1 ,dublin4 ,birth of son ,william4 #afhj4 ,st4 ,austin's 7#afhg74 ,death of second wife1 ,october4 ,st4 ,clement ,danes4 #afha4 ,st4 ,mildred ,bread ,street 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,benet's ,gracechurch 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,mary ,abchurch 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,matthew's ,friday ,street 7#afhg74 ,tom ,tower1 ,christ ,church1 ,oxford4 ,sworn in as ,president of the ,royal ,society1 ,january #ab4 #afhb4 ,st4 ,alban's ,wood ,street 7#afhg74 ,chelsea ,hospital begun4 ,latin ,school1 ,christ's ,hospital4 #afhc4 ,st4 ,james ,piccadilly4 ,st4 ,mary ,magdalen ,old ,fish ,street 7#afhg74 ,st4 ,clement's ,eastcheap 7#afhg74 ,palace at ,winchester begun but not completed4 #afhd4 ,st4 ,margaret ,pattens 7#afhi74 ,st4 ,michael's ,crooked ,lane 7#afid74 ,appointed ,controller of ,works1 ,windsor ,castle4 ,middle ,temple ,gateway4 ,repairs to ,chichester ,cathedral ,spire4 #afhe4 ,st4 ,andrew's ,wardrobe 7#afie74 #afhf4 ,st4 ,margaret's ,lothbury 7#afic74 ,st4 ,mary ,somerset 7#afid74 ,all ,hallows ,lombard ,street 7#afid74 ,st4 ,michael's ,royal 7#afid74 #afhh4 ,town ,hall1 ,windsor4 #afhi4 ,m4,p4 for ,windsor4 #afij4 ,hampton ,court begun4 #afij4 ,kensington ,palace4 #afia4 ,chapel1 ,trinity ,college1 ,oxford4 #afic4 ,library1 ,queen's ,college1 ,oxford4 #afid4 ,chapel1 ,trinity ,college1 ,oxford4 #afie4 ,greenwich ,hospital begun4 ,morden ,college1 ,blackheath4 #afig4 ,st4 ,paul's3 ,choir opened for service1 ,december #b4 #afih4 ,marlborough ,house1 ,london4 ,north ,transept front1 ,westminster ,abbey4 #agjj4 ,m4,p4 for ,weymouth4 #agjc4 ,death of daughter ,jane4 #agjd4 ,orangery1 ,kensington ,palace4 #agaj4 ,st4 ,paul's3 top-stone of ,lantern laid4 #agaa4 ,st4 ,paul's3 nominal completion4 #agag4 ,st4 ,paul's3 ,wren's complaint to ,commissioners against the ,balustrade4 #agah4 ,dismissed from ,surveyorship4 #agbc4 ,death of ,wren1 ,february #be4 ,,appendix ,,iii ,a ,,note ,,on ,,some ,,portraits ,,of ,,wren ,the following brief particulars of several portraits of ,wren1 some of which are reproduced in the preceding pages1 may lead to more precise information being disinterred3 7a7 ,wren as a ,man of ,forty 7,plate ,,ii474--,when ,i saw this1 it was in the possession of the late ,mrs4 ,catherine ,pigott4 ,it is now1 ,i believe1 in the possession of the ,bishop of ,southwell1 to whom it passed on ,mrs4 ,pigott's death4 ,it is unsigned1 and there is no record as to its authorship4 ,it shows ,wren as a young man1 and ,i had thought it represented him while in the twenties4 ,mr4 ,richard ,w4 ,goulding1 ,f4,s4,a41 dates the cravat about #afge1 which would make ,wren forty-three4 ,the modelling of the face is not unlike that of the ,pearce bust1 which tends to confirm the age as about forty4 7b7 ,the ,wadham ,college ,portrait 7,plate ,,xiii474--,this is in itself a poor piece of painting1 and has a vague history4 ,it is an #ahbe copy by ,john ,smith1 of ,oxford1 deriving ultimately1 it is said1 from a ,kneller portrait at ,lambeth ,palace1 which1 ,i am informed1 has disappeared4 ,it seems rather to be based on the ,sheldonian portrait1 which was attributed by ,dallaway to ,thornhill1 8painted in conjunction with ,verrio and ,kneller40 ,i give the unlikely story of its authorship as it is told1 adding only that as the plan in ,wren's hand shows the ,st4 ,paul's of the ,warrant ,design or later1 it must be after #afge1 and therefore ,wren is depicted as a man of forty-three or more1 probably a good deal more1 for he is markedly older than in the last mentioned4 7c7 ,bust by ,edward ,pearce at the ,ashmolean 7,plate ,v474--,this beautiful work has been dated #afgc1 by a letter written by ,christopher1 the architect's son1 and quoted by ,mr4 ,lionel ,cust4 ,it may well be ,wren as a man of forty-one1 and the younger ,christopher's date can be accepted1 but he was very casual in his chronologies4 7d7 ,the ,royal ,society ,portrait4--,the legend on the frame says this picture is by ,michael ,wright1 but ,mr4 ,collins ,baker attributes it1 on the ground of style1 to ,riley and ,closterman in collaboration4 ,he claims that it is the basis of the ,kirkall engraving 7see next note74 ,if so1 ,kirkall turned the face the other way4 ,the view of ,st4 ,paul's shows a transitional design between the ,warrant ,design with its nightmare steeple and the dome as built4 ,the clock towers are almost exactly like the intermediate design preserved at ,all ,souls4 ,i suggest it shows a man of seventy4 7e7 ,the ,kirkall ,engraving after ,closterman 7,plate ,,xv474--,this rare portrait was given to me by ,mrs4 ,pigott shortly before her death1 and apart from its having been1 as she told me1 an heirloom in the ,wren family1 it has an interest as showing ,elisha ,kirkall's 8chiaroscuro0 style of engraving interpreting ,closterman's portrait4 7f7 ,the ,st4 ,paul's ,deanery ,portrait 7,plate ,,xiv474--,this is a copy of the best known portrait of all1 the ,kneller at the ,national ,portrait ,gallery1 and an inferior copy1 for it reveals a man of far less distinction1 both in character and feature1 than the ,national portrait4 ,the latter is attributed to the year #agaa1 and is therefore of ,wren when he was nearly eighty4 7g7 ,the ,welbeck ,portrait 7,plate ,,iv474--,the picture is a small whole length on panel4 ,the architect wears a red dressing-gown with white lining1 white stockings1 and red shoes2 his right hand is placed on his hip1 and in his left hand he holds a drawing of the elevation of the faade of ,st4 ,paul's4 ,on the left side of the picture there is a lurid sky indicative of the burning of the ,city2 in the right-hand top corner is a bust of ,charles ,,ii41 flanked by an amorino weighing the insignia of royalty 7crown1 sceptre1 etc471 against four shields of arms 7,england1 ,france1 ,scotland1 and ,ireland71 and round the waist of the amorino is a scroll lettered 8,justum est40 ,this picture was acquired by the fifth ,duke of ,portland in #ahfa4 ,it was then attributed to ,h4 ,gascar1 who is stated to have been in ,england circa #afgd-hj1 and who might consequently have painted ,sir ,christopher soon after he made his design for the new ,cathedral4 ,the ,west ,front is shown in the picture with the single ,order1 an early stage of the design4 ,the architect looks very young for a man of about forty-two years of age1 but in the case of painted portraits it is often difficult to reconcile the actual age of a sitter with his apparent age4 7h7 ,the ,queen's ,college ,bust4--,this posthumous portrait has been attributed to ,rysbrack2 it is certainly worthy of him4 ,wren is shown as a very old man4 7k7 ,the ,medal at ,wadham ,college 7,plate ,,xvi474--,as it is commonly said that this medal was struck to celebrate the completion of ,st4 ,paul's1 it is a little unkind to have to set down the fact that it was cast and chased 7not struck7 by ,g4 ,d4 ,gaale1 a ,german1 about the year #aghc1 when he exhibited it in ,london1 sixty years after ,wren's death in #agbc4 7l7 ,art ,union of ,london ,medal4--,a medal was issued in #ahdf3 obverse1 with bust of ,wren1 signed ,h4 ,wilson1 ,sc42 reverse1 ,st4 ,paul's1 signed ,b4 ,wyon4 ,i hope the above notes may lead people better informed than myself to bring out facts which will enable a full and correct catalogue of ,wren portraits to be prepared4 ,their publication in the ,bicentenary issue of ,architecture brought ,mr4 ,richard ,w4 ,goulding to my aid in correcting some mistakes ,i then made1 and he has added the facts about the ,welbeck portrait4 ,a list of engravings after the ,kneller portrait is given in ,mr4 ,f4 ,o',donoghue's 8,catalogue of ,engraved ,english ,portraits in the ,british ,museum40 ,,index ,abbey1 ,westminster1 ,wren and1 #acg1 #ach1 #aci ,aims of architecture1 ,wren on the1 #aec ,all ,hallows1 ,lombard ,street1 ,church of1 #ha ,armoury and ,mint at the ,tower of ,london1 #ajg ,ashmolean ,museum1 ,oxford1 #aaj ,association between architecture and military engineering1 #ac ,astronomy1 ,wren as a ,professor of1 #ai1 #cf ,bacon1 influence on ,wren of1 #cj1 #ca ,barometer3 ,torricelli's work on the1 #cf ,wren's work on the1 #cf ,belton ,house1 #aje ,benson1 ,william1 ,surveyor-,general1 #gd ,bernini3 ,lay-out in front of ,st4 ,peter's1 ,rome1 #ec1 #ajh2 meeting with ,wren1 #dh1 #di2 referred to1 #ajh ,bird1 ,robert1 coppersmith1 #abj ,birth of ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 #a ,building materials1 ,wren's views on1 #ic1 #id ,busby1 ,dr41 of ,westminster ,school1 #d1 #aj1 #aa ,cambridge3 ,pembroke ,college ,chapel1 #aji ,trinity ,college ,library1 #df1 #dg1 #aji1 #aaj1 #abe ,campbell1 ,colin1 work at ,greenwich ,hospital by1 #ajc ,carlyle1 ,thomas1 on the ,city churches1 #ig1 #ih2 on ,chelsea ,hospital1 #ig ,cathedrals3 ,lincoln1 ,honywood ,chapel at1 #aaj ,st4 ,paul's1 ,london4 ,see ,st4 ,paul's ,cathedral ,salisbury1 #acg ,chapels3 ,pembroke ,college1 ,cambridge1 #df1 #aji ,trinity ,college1 ,oxford1 #aaj ,wadham ,college1 ,oxford1 #af1 #ag ,charles ,i41 design for the tomb of1 #ajg1 #ajh2 pedestal for statue of1 ,charing ,cross1 #ajd ,chelsea ,hospital1 #ig1 #ih1 #ii1 #ajh1 #abe ,childhood of ,wren1 #a1 #b1 #c1 #d1 #e1 #f1 #g1 #h ,christ ,church3 ,newgate ,street1 #ij ,oxford1 ,college1 #aaa ,christ's ,hospital1 ,london1 #ajg1 #acj ,chronology1 an attempt at a ,wren1 #afj ,church3 ,st4 ,andrew1 ,holborn1 #hg ,st4 ,clement ,danes1 ,strand1 #gh1 #abe ,st4 ,james1 ,piccadilly1 #gh1 #ij1 #id1 #ie ,st4 ,martin's-in-the-,fields1 #ba1 #bb ,temple ,church1 #ba ,churches1 ,city3 ,christ ,church1 ,newgate ,street1 #ij ,st4 ,alban1 ,wood ,street1 #hj1 #ha ,st4 ,andrew-in-the-,wardrobe1 #ij ,st4 ,anne and ,st4 ,agnes1 #ha ,st4 ,antholin1 ,watling ,street1 #ij ,st4 ,augustine1 ,watling ,street1 #ee1 #hf1 #aai1 #abf ,st4 ,benet1 ,paul's ,wharf1 #hf1 #aai ,st4 ,benet ,fink1 #ij ,st4 ,bride1 ,fleet ,street1 #hg1 #hh1 #ij1 #ib ,st4 ,clement1 ,eastcheap1 #ha ,st4 ,dunstan-in-the-,east1 #gh1 #ha1 #hb1 #acf ,st4 ,lawrence ,jewry1 #hf1 #hi ,st4 ,magnus1 ,london ,bridge1 #ha1 #he ,st4 ,margaret1 ,lothbury1 #hf ,st4 ,margaret's ,pattens1 ,rood ,lane1 #hd1 #he1 #hf ,st4 ,martin1 ,ludgate1 #ef1 #he ,st4 ,mary ,abchurch1 #ij ,st4 ,mary1 ,aldermanbury1 #ha ,st4 ,mary ,aldermary1 #gf1 #acf ,st4 ,mary-at-,hill1 #ha ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow ,cheapside1 #hg1 #hh1 #ade1 #adf ,st4 ,mary ,somerset1 #gh ,st4 ,mary ,woolnoth 7by ,hawksmoor71 #gi ,st4 ,michael1 ,cornhill1 #acf ,st4 ,michael ,paternoster ,royal1 #ha ,st4 ,mildred1 ,bread ,street1 #hf1 #ij1 #ia1 #abj ,st4 ,nicholas ,cole ,abbey1 #hj ,st4 ,sepulchre1 #gh ,st4 ,stephen1 ,coleman ,street1 #ha ,st4 ,stephen1 ,walbrook1 #ha1 #hh1 #hi1 #aai ,st4 ,swithin1 ,cannon ,street1 #hd1 #ij ,st4 ,vedast1 ,foster ,lane1 #gi1 #hj ,city ,churches1 referred to1 #ig1 #ih1 #aai1 #abj1 #abd1 #abf1 #acf1 #ade1 #adf1 #afj ,coghill1 ,faith1 ,wren's first wife1 #bj1 #ba ,college3 ,all ,souls1 ,oxford1 #aa1 #ab ,christ ,church1 ,oxford1 #aaa ,emmanuel1 ,cambridge1 #aaj ,morden1 ,blackheath1 #ajh1 #aji ,pembroke1 ,cambridge1 #df1 #aji of ,physicians1 ,warwick ,lane1 #ajg ,queen's1 ,oxford1 #aaj ,trinity1 ,cambridge1 #df1 #dg1 #aji1 #aaj1 #abe ,wadham1 ,oxford1 #d1 #i1 #aj1 #aa1 #ab1 #af ,cox1 ,mary1 mother of ,wren1 #b ,custom ,house1 ,london1 #ajg ,de l',orme1 ,philibert1 referred to1 #ej ,denham1 ,sir ,john1 ,surveyor-,general1 #dc1 #aja 8,dome of ,london1 ,the10 #ei ,draughtsman1 ,wren as a1 #abi1 #acj ,east ,knoyle ,rectory1 ,wilts1 ,wren's birthplace1 #a ,emmanuel ,college1 ,cambridge1 chapel and cloister at1 #aaj ,etching on glass1 ,wren's experiments in1 #dj ,evelyn1 ,john1 #ae1 #bd1 #be1 #dc1 #ec1 #fj1 #fb1 #ih1 #ajb1 #aab1 #aac1 #aad1 #aae1 #acg ,family life of ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 #ah1 #ai1 #bj1 #ba1 #bb1 #bc1 #bd1 #be1 #bf1 #bg ,fitzwilliam1 ,jane1 ,wren's second wife1 #ba1 #bb ,fitzwilliam of ,lifford1 ,lord1 father of ,wren's second wife1 #ba ,france1 ,wren's travels in1 #da1 #dg1 #dh1 #di1 #ej1 #ea ,gibbons1 ,grinling1 #ga1 #ajd1 #ajf1 #ajg1 #ajh1 #aad1 #aae ,gothic ,architecture1 ,wren and1 #ach1 #aci ,greenwich ,hospital1 #hc1 #aja1 #ajb1 #ajc1 #abe ,groombridge ,place1 ,kent1 #ajf ,hampton ,court ,palace1 #ii1 #ajj1 #aja1 #aba1 #aef ,hawksmoor1 ,nicholas1 #gi1 #ajc1 #ajd1 #aaj1 #abf1 #adi ,holder1 ,dr4 ,william1 a tutor and brother-in-law of ,wren1 #c1 #bj ,honywood ,library and ,cloister1 ,lincoln ,cathedral1 #aaj ,hooke1 ,robert1 #d1 #h ,hospital3 ,chelsea1 #ig1 #ih1 #ii1 #ajh1 #abe ,christ's1 ,london1 #ajg1 #acj ,greenwich1 #aja1 #ajb1 #ajc1 #abe ,kilmainham1 ,dublin1 #ajh ,houses by1 or attributed to1 ,wren3 ,belton1 #aje2 ,groombridge ,place1 ,kent1 #ajf2 ,hampton ,court ,palace1 #ii1 #ajj1 #aja1 #aba1 #aef2 ,kensington ,palace1 #aje2 ,marlborough ,house1 ,london1 #ajf2 ,pallant ,house1 ,chichester1 #ajf2 ,winchester ,palace1 #ajg2 ,wren's ,house1 ,chichester1 #ajf ,inventions of ,wren1 #i1 #aj1 #aa1 #ab1 #ac1 #ad1 #ae1 #af1 #ag ,jennings1 ,richard1 master-carpenter1 #ga ,jones1 ,inigo1 referred to1 #ac1 #dc1 #ea1 #eb1 #ec1 #gj1 #aja1 #ajf1 #add1 #ade1 #adf1 #adg ,kempster1 ,christopher1 #aai ,kensington ,palace1 #aje ,kent1 ,william1 and ,kensington ,palace1 #aje ,kilmainham1 ,dublin1 ,royal ,hospital at1 #ajh ,knighting of ,wren1 #aba ,lansdowne ,chronology1 ,,ms4 by ,christopher ,wren junior1 #i ,letter of ,wren to his son1 #bb1 #bc1 #bd ,library3 ,honywood1 ,lincoln ,cathedral1 #aaj ,trinity ,college1 ,cambridge1 #aji1 #aaj1 #abe ,love-letter from ,wren to ,faith ,coghill1 #bj1 #ba ,marlborough ,house1 ,london1 #ajf ,mathematics1 ,wren's study of1 #d1 #ca ,mausoleum of ,halicarnassus1 ,wren's conjectural restoration of the1 #acb1 #acc1 #acd ,middleton1 ,constance1 wife of ,christopher ,wren junior1 #be ,mint1 the1 in the ,tower of ,london1 #ajg ,monument1 the1 ,london1 #cd1 #ajd ,morden ,college1 ,blackheath1 #ajh1 #aji ,morris1 ,william1 and the ,city churches1 #ig1 #ih ,museum1 ,ashmolean1 ,oxford1 #aaj 8,news from the ,dead10 pamphlet by ,wren1 referred to1 #af ,oughtred1 ,mr41 ,wren's letter to1 #g ,oxford3 ,ashmolean ,museum1 #aaj ,christ ,church ,college1 #aaa ,incident at1 #af ,queen's ,college1 #aaj ,sheldonian ,theatre1 #de1 #df ,trinity ,college ,chapel at1 #aaj ,wren's education at1 #h1 #i1 #aj1 #aa1 #ab1 #ac1 #ad1 #ae1 #af1 #ag ,palace3 ,hampton ,court1 #ii1 #ajj1 #aja1 #aba1 #aef ,kensington1 #aje ,winchester1 #ajg ,palladio's influence on ,wren1 #eb ,pallant ,house1 ,chichester1 #ajf ,parentage and pedigree of ,wren1 #a1 #b1 #c1 #d1 #e1 #f1 #g1 #h ,parentalia1 the1 #a1 #c1 #e1 #h1 #i1 #ac1 #ae1 #bb1 #bd1 #bf1 #cd1 #da1 #fe1 #aji1 #abd1 #abe1 #acb1 #adi ,paris1 ,wren's journey to1 referred to1 #da1 #dg1 #dh1 #di1 #ej1 #ea ,parliament1 ,wren as a member of1 #abj1 #aba ,pascal's problem and ,wren's solution of it1 #cd1 #ce1 #cf1 #aeh1 #aei ,pedestal of the ,charles ,i4 statue1 ,charing ,cross1 #ajd ,pembroke ,college ,chapel1 ,cambridge1 #df1 #aji ,pepys1 ,samuel1 #ad1 #aad1 #acj ,physicians1 ,college of1 ,warwick ,lane1 #ajg ,pigott1 ,mrs4 ,corbett1 #bf ,plan for rebuilding ,london after the ,great ,fire1 ,wren's1 #ec1 #ed1 #ee1 #ef1 #eg1 #eh ,portraits of ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 some1 #afd1 #afe1 #aff ,pulpits and pews1 ,wren's views on1 #ie ,queen's ,college1 ,oxford1 #aaj ,ripley1 ,thomas1 and ,greenwich ,hospital1 #ajc ,royal ,society1 ,wren and the1 #ab1 #cg1 #ch1 #ci1 #dj1 #da1 #db ,ruskin1 ,john1 and ,renaissance ,architecture1 #acg ,ryland's pedigree of the ,wren family1 #ah ,st4 ,alban1 ,wood ,street1 #ha ,st4 ,andrew1 ,holborn1 #gh ,st4 ,andrew-in-the-,wardrobe1 #ij ,st4 ,anne and ,st4 ,agnes1 #ha ,st4 ,antholin1 ,watling ,street1 #ij ,st4 ,augustine1 ,watling ,street1 #ee1 #hf1 #aai1 #abf ,st4 ,benet1 ,paul's ,wharf1 #hf1 #aai ,st4 ,benet ,fink1 #ij ,st4 ,bride1 ,fleet ,street1 #hg1 #hg1 #hh1 #ij1 #ib ,st4 ,clement ,danes1 ,strand1 #gh1 #abe ,st4 ,clement1 ,eastcheap1 #ha ,st4 ,dunstan-in-the-,east1 #gh1 #ha1 #hb1 #acf ,st4 ,james1 ,piccadilly1 #gh1 #ij1 #id1 #ie ,st4 ,lawrence ,jewry1 #hf1 #hi ,st4 ,magnus1 ,london ,bridge1 #ha1 #he ,st4 ,margaret1 ,lothbury1 #hf ,st4 ,margaret ,pattens1 ,rood ,lane1 #hd1 #he1 #hf ,st4 ,martin1 ,ludgate1 #ef1 #he ,st4 ,martin's-in-the-,fields1 #ba1 #bb ,st4 ,mary ,abchurch1 #ij ,st4 ,mary1 ,aldermanbury1 #ha ,st4 ,mary ,aldermary1 #gh1 #acf ,st4 ,mary-at-,hill1 #ha ,st4 ,mary-le-,bow ,cheapside1 #hg1 #hh1 #ade ,st4 ,mary ,somerset1 #gh ,st4 ,mary ,woolnoth1 #gi ,st4 ,michael1 ,cornhill1 #acf ,st4 ,michael ,paternoster ,royal1 #ha ,st4 ,mildred1 ,bread ,street1 #hf1 #ij1 #ia1 #abj ,st4 ,nicholas ,cole ,abbey1 #hj ,st4 ,paul's3 ,old1 ,wren's plans for the restoration of1 #ef1 #ei1 #fj1 #fa2 ,cathedral1 ,london1 balustrade on the upper cornice of1 #gd2 cost of1 #gc2 dome of1 #ee1 #ef1 #ei1 #ga1 #ajc2 first design for1 #fc2 mean treatment of ,wren over1 #gc1 #gd2 opening of1 #gc2 8rejected0 or 8model0 second design for1 #fc1 #fd1 #fd1 #fe1 #ff1 #ff2 ,south ,staircase of1 referred to1 #cd2 third or 8warrant0 design for1 #fg1 #fh2 ,wren's achievement in1 #gf1 #gg2 reference to1 #hc1 #aaf1 #aba1 #abb1 #abf1 #adc1 #ade1 #adg1 #adh1 #aed1 #aee1 #aef ,st4 ,peter's1 ,rome1 #ec ,st4 ,sepulchre1 #gh ,st4 ,stephen1 ,coleman ,street1 #ha ,st4 ,stephen1 ,walbrook1 #ha1 #hh1 #hi1 #aai ,st4 ,swithin1 ,cannon ,street1 #hd1 #ij ,st4 ,vedast1 ,foster ,lane1 #gi1 #hj ,salisbury ,cathedral1 #acg ,scarborough1 ,sir ,charles1 a tutor of ,wren1 #d1 #e1 #f1 #g1 #aj ,shaw1 ,norman1 and ,hampton ,court ,palace1 #ajj ,shepheard1 ,rev4 ,william1 a tutor of ,wren1 #c ,sheldonian ,theatre at ,oxford1 #de1 #df ,soane ,museum1 ,wren relics at1 #aba ,sir ,john1 #ii ,sons of ,sir ,christopher ,wren1 #be ,spires1 ,city church1 by ,wren1 #hd ,strong1 ,edward1 master-mason1 #bb1 #bc1 #bd1 #fi1 #ga1 #gc1 #aai1 #abj ,talman1 ,william1 architect1 #aja1 #aef ,temple ,bar1 #ajd1 #aje ,temple ,church1 #ba ,thermometer designed by ,wren1 #h ,thornhill1 ,sir ,james1 paintings in ,st4 ,paul's by1 #gd ,tijou1 ,jean1 metal-worker1 #ga1 #aja1 #abj1 #aba ,tomb1 ,wren's design for a1 #ajh ,tom ,tower1 the1 ,oxford1 #aaa ,torricelli1 his work on the barometer1 #cf ,tower of ,london1 #ajg ,town-planning1 ,wren and1 #ec ,trinity ,college1 ,cambridge1 ,library of1 #df1 #dg1 #aji1 #aaj1 #abe ,trinity ,college1 ,oxford1 ,chapel at1 #aaj ,university degrees1 ,wren's1 #aa1 #ab ,vanbrugh1 ,sir ,john1 #ajc1 #ajf1 #aaj1 #adi1 #aeg ,ward1 ,dr4 ,seth1 #i ,webb1 ,john1 #dc1 #aja1 #ajf ,wilkins1 ,john1 ,warden of ,wadham1 #i1 #ab1 #ac ,winchester ,palace1 #ajg ,wotton1 ,sir ,henry1 #aci1 #adj1 #ada1 #adb1 #aeg ,wren1 ,sir ,christopher3 ,family and relations3 ,father1 #a2 mother1 #b2 sisters1 #ah2 grandfather1 #a2 great-grandfather1 #a2 sons1 #ba1 #bb1 #bc2 daughter1 #ac2 brother-in-law1 #b2 uncle1 #b1 #ah2 cousin1 #ah ,education and ,studies3 ,studies at home1 #c2 at ,westminster ,school1 #d2 under ,sir ,charles ,scarborough1 #e2 ,assistant at the ,surgeon's ,hall1 #g2 at ,oxford1 #i1 #aj1 #aa1 #ab1 #ac1 #ad1 #ae1 #af1 #ag2 matriculation of1 #aa2 ,university degrees of1 #aa1 #ab2 ,fellowship of ,all ,souls1 #af ,personal3 ,critical mind1 #ach1 #aci1 #adj1 #ada1 #adb2 death1 #abb2 epitaph of1 #ge2 health of1 #d1 #aj1 #ah2 heirlooms at ,soane ,museum1 #aba2 ,kirkall engraved portrait1 #bf2 legible penmanship1 #d2 letter to his son1 ,christopher1 #bb1 #bc1 #bd2 letter in ,latin to his father1 #e2 love-letter to ,faith ,coghill1 #bj2 marriage1 first1 to ,faith ,coghill1 #ba2 marriage1 second1 to ,jane ,fitzwilliam1 #ba2 patience of1 #h2 poetic gift of1 #af2 portraits of1 #afd1 #afe1 #aff2 retirement1 #ge2 social relaxations1 #aad1 #aae1 #aaf2 theories of beauty1 #aej1 #aea2 will1 #be1 #bf1 #bg ,scientific ,studies and ,achievements3 ,as an astronomer1 #cb1 #cc1 #cd1 #cg2 as a classical archologist1 #acb1 #acc1 #acd2 as a student and scholar1 #acb1 #acc1 #acd1 #ace1 #acf1 #acg1 #ach1 #aci1 #adj1 #ada1 #adb1 #adc2 essays1 #ae2 experiments in etching on glass1 #dj2 experiments in natural science1 #ch1 #ci1 #dj1 #da2 inventions of1 #f1 #g1 #i1 #aj1 #aa1 #ab1 #ac1 #ad1 #ae1 #af1 #ag2 part in the development of natural science1 #bh1 #bi2 place as a mathematician1 #cd1 #ce1 #cf2 scientific labors of #aaf1 #aag1 #aah2 solution of ,pascal's problem1 #cd1 #ce1 #cf1 #aeh1 #aei2 transactions with the ,royal ,society1 #cg1 #ch1 #ci1 #dj1 #da1 #db ,professional and ,public3 8,architect of ,adventure1 ,the10 #add1 #ade1 #adf1 #adg1 #adh1 #adi1 #aej1 #aea1 #aeb1 #aec1 #aed1 #aeg2 as a ,member of ,parliament1 #abj1 #aba2 as a professional man1 #abc1 #abd1 #abe1 #abf1 #abg1 #abh1 #abi1 #acj1 #aca2 influence of ,inigo ,jones1 #ea1 #eb2 influence of ,palladio1 #eb2 introduction to ,bernini1 #dh2 knighting of1 #aba2 plan for rebuilding ,london1 #ec1 #ed1 #ee1 #ef1 #eg1 #eh2 remuneration and fees1 #abd1 #abe2 ,surveyor-,general of ,his ,majesty's ,works1 #dc1 #abd1 #abe1 #abg1 #abh1 #abi2 travels in ,france1 #da1 #dg1 #dh1 #di1 #ej1 #ea ,wren1 ,dean ,christopher 7father71 #a1 #b1 #c1 #bj1 #adb ,wren1 ,christopher 7second son7 #ba1 #bb1 #bc1 #bd1 #be1 #bf1 #bg1 #aai1 #abe ,constance 7daughter-in-law71 #be ,cuthbert 7great-grandfather71 #a ,faith 7mother71 #b1 #ah ,francis 7grandfather71 #a ,gilbert 7eldest son1 died in infancy71 #ba ,jane 7daughter71 #ac1 #ba1 #bb ,margaret 7great-granddaughter71 #bf ,matthew1 ,bishop of ,ely 7uncle71 #b1 #ah ,matthew 7cousin71 #ah ,stephen 7grandson71 #bf ,william 7great-great-grandfather71 #a ,william 7third son71 #bb1 #bd1 #be1 #bg ,wren chronology1 an attempt at a1 #afj ,wren's ,house1 ,chichester1 #ajf ,,printed ,,in ,,great ,,britain ,,by ,,billing ,,and ,,sons1 ,,ltd41 ,,guildford ,,and ,,esher ,,footnotes3 ,a ,english ,leadwork3 ,its ,art and ,history1 chapter vi4 ,b 8,the ,complete ,building ,accounts of the ,city ,churches 7,parochial7 designed by ,sir ,christopher ,wren10 ,archologia1 vol4 lxvi4 ,c ,a ,history of ,renaissance ,architecture in ,england4 ,d ,i dealt with this subject in detail some years ago in the ,architectural ,review4 ,e ,in ,form in ,civilization 7,oxford ,university ,press71 #aibb1 a volume to be read by everyone1 for it contains the ripe judgment on many matters of a very stimulating critic of the part played by architecture in thought and life4 ,f ,in ,wren's petty cash accounts is the entry3 8,for a booke on ,vitruvius for the use of ye office--#c40 ,the 8,country ,life0 ,library ,,english ,,homes ,,by ,h4 ,,avray ,,tipping1 ,m4,a41 ,f4,s4,a4 ,a ,monumental ,work on the ,country ,homes of ,england1 divided into the following distinctive ,chronological and ,dynastic ,periods3 ,i4 ,,norman ,,and ,,plantagenet #ajff-adhe 7,now ,ready7 ,,ii4 ,,early ,,tudor #adhe-aeeh 7,ready ,autumn1 #aibc7 ,,iii4 ,,late ,,tudor ,,and ,,early ,,stuart #aeeh-afdi 7,now ,ready7 ,,iv4 ,,late ,,stuart #afdi-agad 7,now ,ready7 ,v4 ,,early ,,georgian #agad-agfj 7,now ,ready7 ,,vi4 ,,late ,,georgian #agfj-ahbj 7,in ,preparation7 ,it is the aim of this great work to be for ,english ,domestic ,architecture and ,life what the 8,dictionary of ,national ,biography0 and the 8,new ,english ,dictionary0 are for our other heritages of ,history and ,language4 ,that it may worthily take the place which is its undoubted due beside these works in every ,reference ,library1 private or public1 no effort has been spared in dealing with the splendid subject4 ,in the six volumes here announced is systematically and sympathetically set forth in all its fascinating fullness that building up of homes and home life which has been so closely influenced by1 and has in its turn so strongly impressed1 the minds and ideas of the generations who have made our ,england4 ,,each ,,volume ,,contains ,,from #djj ,,to #ejj ,,superb ,,illustrations ,,and ,,plans ,price ,three ,guineas net each ,,published ,,at ,,the ,,offices ,,of 8,,country ,,life0 ,,the ,,architecture ,,of ,,robert ,,and ,,james ,,adam 7#ageh-agid7 ,by ,,arthur ,t4 ,,bolton1 ,f4,s4,a41 ,f4,r4,i4,b4,a4 ,in two large folio volumes1 containing about #gjj splendid illustrations1 plans1 and drawings4 ,full gilt edges4 #h #hs4 net2 by post #h #ajs4 ,this important work forms a complete survey of the ,architecture1 ,decoration1 and ,furniture of the famous ,adelphi ,brethren1 and constitutes a monumental record of the ,adam style4 ,although during the ,greek and ,gothic ,revivals ,adam architecture was freely destroyed1 there still remains1 as these volumes prove1 a marvelous wealth of work1 much of which is complete with the actual ,furniture1 ,carpets1 and ,hangings made to his designs4 ,no country in the world can show equivalent instances of such historical preservation as are illustrated in these magnificent volumes4 ,,twenty-,,five ,,great ,,houses ,,of ,,france ,by ,,sir ,,theodore ,,andrea ,,cook1 ,m4,a41 ,f4,s4,a4 ,,with ,,an ,,introductory ,,chapter ,,outlining ,,the ,,development ,,of ,,french ,,domestic ,,architecture ,,by ,w4 ,h4 ,,ward1 ,m4,a41 ,f4,r4,i4,b4,a4 ,illustrations by ,,frederick ,h4 ,,evans4 ,large folio1 containing over #djj superb illustrations1 plans and diagrams1 with a map of ,france showing the position of each ,chateau4 ,half-bound in buckram1 #b #abs4 #f;d4 net2 in half morocco1 #c #bs4 #f;d4 net2 postage #as4 extra4 ,in this volume ,sir ,theodore ,cook presents a pageant of the great figures who surrounded the throne of such kings as ,franois ,premier and ,louis ,quatorze4 ,louis of ,orleans at ,pierrefonds1 the ,duke of ,guise at ,blois1 ,fouquet at ,vaux le ,vicomte and ,cond at ,chantilly--these are typical of the story that the author unfolds1 with a grasp so sure that the men and women live again1 while their great houses are depicted with a wealth of illustration never before achieved or attempted4 ,,garden ,,ornament ,by ,,gertrude ,,jekyll4 ,large folio1 with over #fjj matchless ,illustrations and charming coloured frontispiece1 #c #cs4 net2 by post1 #c #ds4 ,in half-levant grain1 #c #aes4 net2 by post1 #c #afs4 ,examples are furnished1 from the finest gardens in the country1 of beautiful ,balustrading2 graceful ,gates1 ,urns1 ,vases and ,sculptured ,ornaments2 ,stone paved ,courts1 ,paved ,ways and ,garden ,seats1 ,loggias1 ,orangeries1 ,garden ,houses and ,dovecotes1 ,parterres1 ,sundials1 ,topiary ,work1 ,pergolas and ,treillage1 ,canals1 ,ponds and ,water ,gardens1 ,bridges1 ,fountains and ,dipping ,wells1 ,flower ,borders1 ,wall ,gardening and ,japanese ,gardens4 ,,the ,,gardens ,,of ,,italy ,with ,historical and ,descriptive ,notes by ,e4 ,,march ,,phillipps4 ,edited and thoroughly revised1 with copious additions and reproductions of valuable old plans4 ,by ,,arthur ,t4 ,,bolton1 ,f4,s4,a41 ,f4,r4,i4,b4,a4 ,large folio1 containing over #djj ,illustrations1 in one volume1 #c #cs4 net2 by post1 #c #ds4 ,in half-levant grain1 #c #aes4 net2 by post1 #c #afs4 ,the ,gardens illustrated are grouped by districts1 beginning in the ,south with ,rome1 followed by the neighbourhood of the ,eternal ,city--as ,tivoli and ,frascati1 ,bagnaia and ,caprarola4 ,proceeding northwards the reader comes to ,florence1 famous for the ,villas and ,gardens in the neighbourhood of the ,city4 ,then follows ,venetia1 with the celebrated ,malcontenta1 ,stra and ,maser4 ,the ,lake ,district succeeds1 with ,balbianello and the ,borromenian ,islands2 and finally the inexhaustible regions of ,italian art at ,genoa1 renowned for superb examples of palatial architecture and gardening art4 ,a complete ,catalogue of books in the 8,country ,life0 ,library will be sent post free on application to ,,the ,,manager1 8,,country ,,life10 ,,ltd41 #bj1 ,,tavistock ,,street1 ,,covent ,,garden1 ,w4,c4 #b4 ,,transcriber',s ,,notes3 ,italicized text is surrounded by underscores3 italics4 ,emboldened characters are surrounded by equals signs3 bold4 ,superscripted text is preceded by a caret character3 ,s,t or wch4 ,obvious typographical errors have been corrected4 ,inconsistencies in hyphenation have been standardized4 ,archaic or variant spelling has been retained4 ,emboldened page numbers in the ,index indicate illustrations4