,,present ,,status ,,and ,,prospects ,,of ,,the ,,peace ,,movement4 ,,by ,,baroness ,,bertha ,,von ,s,,ttner4 ,letters of condolence and of cynicism come to my desk in these latter days in increasing number4 ,there is a note of triumph and of mockery in one group3 8,what has become of the famous ,peace idea8 ,the ,south ,african war1 following immediately upon the close of the ,peace ,conference at ,the ,hague1 has not yet reached its end1 and already the horizon in ,eastern ,asia is lurid with the glare of a world-war4 ,are you convinced now of the absurdity of your claims1 ye dreamers of peace80 ,through the second group runs an undertone of commiseration3 8,what suffering must have come to you1 honored madame1 and to your friends1 in seeing your beautiful illusion shattered4 ,sad1 sad2 but thus it is4 ,war is an historic law1 and your ideals are simply--ideals4 ,you will have to reef your sails in the face of such a storm of facts40 ,it is true that a feebly manned boat cannot battle against storm and surf4 ,but the simile ill fits the effort to establish peace4 ,that is no boat2 it is a rock4 ,the waves may top it with their wrathful spume1 but naught can affect its granite permanence4 ,let me set aside metaphor and reply to my correspondents4 ,let me endeavor to show them the point of view from which the advocates of peace regard the present condition of the world1 and the nature of the duties and prospects1 the hopes and self-denials to be descried therefrom4 ,in the first place1 we admit candidly that we have been mistaken2 not1 however1 in the principles we have enunciated1 but in our estimate of present culture4 ,we had regarded public conscience as being permeated by a longing for international right and by an abhorrence of despotism to a greater degree than the facts of the case warrant4 ,the warlike events that surge about us and threaten us furnish no proof against the principles of the peace movement4 ,they merely prove that these principles have not yet entered fully into the conscience of nations and of their leaders2 that the movement is not yet sufficiently advanced in its spread1 its organization1 its methods of action1 to verify the hopes fostered by the conference at ,the ,hague for an early eradication of old1 deeply-rooted institutions of brute force4 ,in other words1 we have been mistaken1 not in the fundamental statements we have made1 but in the conception that they were more widely accepted than they have proved to be4 ,these truths remain3 7#a47 ,culture is synonymous with the repression of brute force2 7#b47 ,nations are oppressed by their brazen breast-plate1 and1 if its weight increases1 they will be crushed by it2 7#c47 ,right relations are as possible between nations as they have gradually been proven to be between individuals1 tribes1 boroughs1 cities and provinces2 7#d47 ,the abolition of war as a legal institution of human society1 when such abolition is made a matter of principle1 will result in undreamed-of increase of material wealth and moral elevation4 ,all these truths1 and many theories begotten of them1 have not lost an iota of their logical content and of their blessed potentiality from the fact that foolish humanity1 through its most powerful agents1 government1 church and press1 still emphasizes dogmas opposed to them4 ,the advocates of peace maintain their principles4 ,not only so2 they do not rest from their labors2 they will not allow the results thus far obtained to slip from their grasp4 ,the institutions created at ,the ,hague1 despite the resistance of bellicose ,powers1 are faithfully guarded by those who helped to create them4 ,the ,interparliamentary ,union1 now in session at ,paris1 has assumed the task of popularizing1 developing and executing the ,articles of ,the ,hague4 ,their co-operators in ,england continue to protest against the ,south ,african war and the subjugation of the ,boers1 in spite of the supercilious jingoism of government and of the hypnosis of the masses4 ,the ,social ,democrats1 the ,ethicists--men of independent tendencies1 all of them--lift up warning voices against the fever of ,imperialism in general1 and specifically against the reckless love of adventure which first scents loot and then seeks revenge in expeditions against a country with four hundred million peace-loving inhabitants4 ,to save1 to save1 to avert universal war--that is the purpose for which the enemies of war will strive untiringly until the very last moment4 ,if their strength be insufficient1 where shall we place the blame8 ,the fault is not theirs4 ,it rests with the millions of their contemporaries1 who1 though at heart they desire the same result1 yet turn away in contempt or apathy from those who are laboring for it1 instead of aiding these labors by the weight that lies in the consensus of the masses4 ,with those who ignore1 suspect and belittle the work of peace--even in cases where that work has brought about positive results1 where it has matured practical propositions--instead of co-operating with sincere workers in their elaborations of these propositions and enforcing them with opponents--with those must the fault lie4 ,great changes come to pass slowly1 but in times like the present1 when upheavals are fierce and dangers lie near1 it might be hoped that swifter advances should be made in the conflict between the new and the old4 ,just as1 immediately before the vote was taken on the ,heinze law1 a group of devoted men was formed to oppose that measure1 which succeeded in defeating it1 so1 in the face of the present conspicuous and overwhelming manifestation of the principle of brute force1 the friends of right might resolutely band themselves together1 and1 with shields upraised1 declare a crusade for the liberation of politics from the thraldom of that immoral tradition4 ,possibly the hope that such a step could be taken might again involve an over-estimate of our contemporaries4 ,what matters it8 ,kant said3 8,man cannot think too highly of man10 and it is better to have erred in this direction than1 by lukewarm doubt1 to have condoned the fault of those here criticised4 ,what we see happening to-day furnishes proof1 furnishes wonderfully objective illustrations and experimental demonstrations1 not against1 but in favor of our doctrines4 ,in the first place1 let us consider the war in the ,transvaal4 ,true1 it broke out immediately after the conference at ,the ,hague1 and in despite of the principles of arbitration and of mediation there announced1 and subscribed to even by ,england herself4 ,yet it was no triumph for the dogma of the necessity of war2 it was rather a triumph for the advocates of war4 ,for our opponents1 in giving voice to the slogan1 8,the ,south ,african war and the ,chinese horrors were the direct result of the conference10 commit--purposely1 without a doubt--the blunder of confusing sequence in time with sequence of cause and effect4 ,it is the familiar1 senseless1 exploded1 8,post hoc1 ergo propter hoc40 ,seeds which lay slumbering in the world's soil long before the conference at ,the ,hague sprouted in these two instances4 ,for all that the conference itself could achieve was not in the nature of a harvest1 but merely a sowing of seed4 ,the newly created institutions are not yet in operation1 their spirit has not yet become incarnate in the flesh and blood of the nations1 of potentates1 of the press4 ,and ,mr4 ,chamberlain was able to accomplish his purpose1 in spite of the pleading of ,krger for arbitration1 even unto the last minute4 ,every intermediation was refused1 and none was honestly and earnestly considered4 ,several ,european rulers1 who1 as their panegyrists maintain1 are soldiers1 body and soul1 had no desire to restrain the arm of ,england2 they wished ,queen ,victoria success and noted the progress of the war with semi-joyous interest4 ,but with the people of non-,english countries there was pronounced opposition to this war2 there was a manifestation of the very thing whereof we dream as a foundation of an alliance of ,european ,states1 namely1 a ,european conscience4 ,this conscience rose in rebellion against the fact that a war of conquest should be waged in this our day2 that a great country should seek to subjugate small1 free republics4 ,from every side came protests1 petitions1 actions of various sorts1 to move the ,english to call a halt in this war4 ,in ,england itself the peace party untiringly made remonstrances in this direction4 ,the deeply rooted sentiment1 8,my country1 right or wrong10 had to give way to a sense of justice deeper still1 and1 as boldly as ,zola and ,picquart entered the lists against the ,general ,staff1 even so boldly did noted ,englishmen battle against the imperialistic ministry of their native land4 ,ten years ago these things would not have happened4 ,neither ,europe nor ,america would have opposed this war so determinedly2 still less possibility would there have been of so powerful a counter-current as arose in ,england itself4 ,all these things are symptoms of the new spirit4 ,but1 in spite of the sentiment of the nations1 the various governments have refrained from any peace-making intervention2 and in ,london this attitude has been regarded as the correct one4 ,but it was correct according to ancient standards only2 it was in direct contravention to the new lines officially marked out at ,the ,hague4 ,the progress of the war in the ,transvaal has shown1 forcibly and terribly1 what a false relation the possible advantages of war bear to its positive disadvantages4 ,fifty thousand of her youth1 healthy and vigorous youth1 has ,england lost in the past ten months2 sixty-one million pounds sterling of her national wealth have been wasted2 the respect and sympathy of the world have been recklessly sacrificed2 the character of the nation has been brutalized by the passions aroused1 and freedom1 the pride of the ,british people1 freedom of speech1 as well as freedom of the individual1 has been imperilled1 for even now the spectre of conscription is raising its head4 ,the fruits of half a century of national education have been destroyed in this one attack of war-fever4 ,and in place of the great1 submarine ,channel-tunnel already planned1 the fortification of ,dover has been begun4 ,india is devastated by a famine1 and the money wasted in ,south ,africa for the destruction of human life might have saved the famished ones4 ,and the end1 the 8bitter end10 of this campaign is not yet4 ,there are no more decisive battles fought nowadays1 even where one side has overwhelming force4 ,there is nothing now save mutual extermination of the troops in the field1 devastation of the land in which the combat takes place1 cessation of commerce1 danger of further complications and the carrying of infectious diseases into other lands4 ,the reports of ,mr4 ,burdett-,coutts in the ,house of ,commons in reference to the horrible condition of the sick and wounded in ,south ,africa are a confirmation of what the advocates of peace have constantly voiced1 namely1 that1 with our present means of destruction and our present methods of warfare1 sanitation is an illusion4 ,and then came the news of the insurrection of the ,boxers and the massacres of the missionaries in ,china4 ,this1 too1 is the harvest of seed sown in ,europe in these latter years4 ,apart from the fact that hatred of strangers is a barbarism1 concerning which we lack the right to grow indignant so long as the story of anti-,semitic riots and expulsion of foreigners has a place upon ,european annals1 everything was done by ,europeans in ,china to arouse a righteous hatred of foreigners there4 ,dogmas and wares have been thrust upon the ,chinese2 there has been contemptuous treatment1 appropriation of territory1 open declarations as to the partition of ,china1 backed by plans for the building of fleets4 ,and running side by side with these things1 in constant confirmation of mercenary greed and of militarism1 with an inherent1 blind tendency to expansion1 the peaceable1 non-military ,empire was supplied with guns and cannons from our own factories and with instructors from our barracks4 ,well1 what matters it8 ,no one cares to bother with the intricately interwoven network of origins and causes back of it all4 ,here were we faced by facts--a country in wild uproar1 the government overthrown or in league with the rebels against foreigners1 the legations bombarded1 ,ketteler murdered--such facts require action4 ,here the opponents of the peace movement seem to be in the right4 ,surely1 it is impossible to quietly look on while such things are happening2 there is no opportunity for arbitration4 ,what is there left but war8 ,is not that in some cases the only resource1 the 8ultima ratio80 ,now1 are ye convinced1 ye dreamers1 that conditions may at any time arise which will force upon men a resort to arms8 ,therefore there must be no cessation of armaments1 no relaxation in the cultivation of a warlike spirit4 ,confess that you are beaten1 that you have no answer4 ,nay1 but we do answer4 ,as a well-ordered ,state maintains a police force to execute the decrees of its judges1 to secure robbers and maniacs1 to overpower mobs that throw stones and apply torches1 to protect those who are persecuted by violence1 so would an alliance of ,culture-,states1 such as we contemplate1 require an armed force to serve international right as an executive power4 ,power in the service of the right differs essentially from the power which pronounces all its decisions and purposes to be right4 ,the individuals of a community are not as yet so virtuous1 so rational1 and so reliable as to render unnecessary every kind of protection and punishment4 ,it is the same with nations4 ,the nations of the earth are not as yet so cultured and so peaceable that a union of nations could exist without a tribunal or an armed force4 ,what has come to pass before our eyes8 ,spontaneously1 without previous agreement1 all nations decided to hurry their ships and troops to the relief of those whose lives were in danger2 to punish the criminals1 to restore order in the convulsed ,empire of ,china2 to re-establish organized government there4 ,and since such an enterprise can succeed only when it is undertaken unanimously1 there was suddenly formed a 8world army10 a confraternity of previously antagonistic nations1 to battle side by side in the name of civilization against an outburst of barbarism4 ,thus has the impulse of events begun the realization of that fundamental requirement urged by the advocates of the peace movement from the very first--unanimity among the ,culture-,states1 a comradeship of co-operation1 a setting aside of conflicting individual rights in the service of a higher solidarity of interest4 ,this solidarity of interest has now been recognized in the face of the ,chinese danger4 ,we recognized it long ago in the face of the danger of militarism4 ,the threatened world-war1 the ruin that impended1 seemed to us such an abomination of barbarism1 and the prevention of that calamity so imperative a duty of civilization1 that conflicts of interest and all little bickerings and minor contentions might well be set aside4 ,a campaign carried on with a common mind and for a common purpose1 such as that undertaken in ,china1 would not have been prevented if it had been preceded by a cessation of further armaments1 as suggested by ,russia at ,the ,hague1 or even by a decided reduction of the standing armies4 ,for--let my readers note carefully this fact--the 8,culture-,army10 the police of international civilization1 needs but be composed of a small but representative section of the various nations4 ,the entire available force of ,europe1 ,america and ,japan could not be sent to ,china at present1 at any rate4 ,when arms are used in the service of right only1 the power of such police1 or1 instead of police--for the word has an unpleasant sound--let us say of such a knighthood of culture1 would be overwhelming4 ,for crime--within the limits of a civilized community this holds true as well--is usually committed by single individuals or small bands4 ,it is the same among nations4 ,if questions of common morals arose1 whose validity is recognized as of interest to all1 every single disturber of the peace1 every single tyrant1 every single land-grabber would be resisted in the execution of his purpose and would be punished by all4 ,had all civilized nations hastened to the aid of the ,armenians1#a had they all advised ,spain to relinquish ,cuba1 or hindered ,america in its desire to subjugate the ,philippines2 had they all insisted that ,england must listen to ,krger's proposals for arbitration1 the cruelties and conflicts of the latest slaughters of multitudes could have been avoided4 ,different nations can advance with united purpose against a common danger1 and they can do so by means of the very elements that otherwise support and foster antagonism1 namely1 by means of their armies4 ,twice has this been demonstrated2 once not long ago in ,crete1 and now in ,china4 ,the ,german ,kaiser could command the troops he sent to ,eastern ,asia to fight shoulder to shoulder with ,frenchmen1 ,russians and ,japanese4 ,and it has been possible to appoint one general for this international army4 ,footnote #a3 ,let it not be objected that a 8man's house is his castle10 and that interference with internal affairs is excluded with nations as it is with individuals4 ,massacres are not internal affairs4 ,if one man throws down another in my neighbor's house and is preparing to kill him1 and the victim's cries reach my ears1 it is not a breach of the peace if ,i hasten to help him or call the police4 ,the possibility that all ,culture-,states can enter into an alliance1 though contested by our opponents1 has been proven in fact4 ,humanity is forced into solidarity by normal evolution along the lines of natural law4 ,what the force of circumstances has brought about could have been accomplished by free will and design1 and1 so accomplished1 it would have been more systematically done1 and would have rested upon more secure foundations4 ,and now1 no one has faith in the present casual and transient coalition1 and many prophesy that the ,powers will quarrel over ,china1 and that the long-dreaded world-conflict will arise in consequence4 ,this1 too1 is used as an argument against us4 8,a concert8 ,unanimity8 ,the slightest disturbance unhinges it all4 ,rivalry is aroused4 ,no one ,power is willing to grant the other a privilege or an advantage4 ,when the coalition campaign has reached its end1 or even before that1 conflicting interests will assert themselves and the ,european war will be upon us40 ,true1 that war will break out1 if there be no forum for the settlement of chance contentions1 a forum which1 by common agreement1 would adjust all differences4 ,everything goes to prove how necessary such a forum is4 ,the sad fact that it is not as yet in operation surely does not militate1 in the least1 against the possibility or the utility of the establishment of such a tribunal4 ,the foundation of it was laid at ,the ,hague4 ,that it is generally ignored demonstrates the fact that militarism struggles against an institution which would undermine war4 ,the question1 8,how in the world do you propose to prevent war in the face of the present upheaval in ,china80 has been thus answered by ,dr4 ,benjamin ,f4 ,trueblood1 ,corresponding ,secretary of the ,american ,peace ,society3 8,we have been asked how we would have settled the present trouble in ,china without war4 ,that is as if one were to ask how we would prevent a fire when the flames were already bursting from all the windows4 ,the settlement of the trouble by us without war would have required1 first of all1 that it be turned over to us for settlement1 or that the powers involved in it would agree conscientiously to follow1 in their efforts at adjustment1 the principles and methods which we might suggest4 ,the utter impossibility of either of these contingencies in the case of the trouble with ,china shows the thoughtlessness of the question4 8,the time to have begun the pacific settlement of the difficulty was many years ago4 ,given certain conditions1 practices and beliefs1 such as have for a long time existed in the relations of the other countries to ,china1 and war or something like it was inevitable4 ,no advocate of peace has ever been simple enough to imagine that war can be avoided when every condition leading to good understanding and peace has been neglected or trampled under foot40 ,another point steadily maintained by the advocates of peace and denied by their adversaries has come clearly to light in these latter days1 namely1 that wars are instigated and brought to their culmination by certain influential men without the slightest reference to the people1 to parliaments or to the choicest spirits of the nations4 ,what has been decided upon by the powers that be1 what has been mapped out by 8,cabinets10 is promulgated as an accomplished fact1 approved by the chorus of a servile press1 and1 if it can be made sensational1 cheered by an enthusiastic mob4 ,how necessary that every land should have a ministry of peace1 an official organism representing the interests of peace1 under whose protection that portion of public opinion which is averse to war might make itself heard4 ,how essential an independent1 ethically elevated press1 conscious of the duty growing out of its power1 the duty to guide the people in the way of unity1 of conciliation1 of a just consideration of both sides of a quarrel--in short1 in the way of peace1 the only way worthy of civilization and culture4 ,the opposite is true4 ,the political press1 in a ponderous majority1 is to-day a forge for the heating of the irons of war4 ,current events reveal the fact that our system is not being put in practice1 but they reveal no flaws or contradictions in the system itself1 for it has none4 ,without a flaw or contradiction it harmonizes with the law of evolution4 ,the new age--with its advance in technical inventions 7with especial reference to the possibility of the slaughter of masses71 with its ties of international solidarity1 its reciprocal economic interdependencies1 its sublimated ethical requirements--has outgrown the system of war1 and outgrows it more and more daily4 ,this truth is set forth1 as it were1 in an object-lesson in the rush of action upon the stage of the world's theatre4 ,on the other hand1 take the war in the ,transvaal4 ,what economic losses 7to say nothing of the moral loss7 to ,england and to the rest of the world has it involved2 and the end of the war is not yet in sight1 in spite of the fact that ,england outnumbers her adversaries ten to one4 ,that war and the ,chinese problem both show that the nations are being mechanically driven to the position which the advocates of peace have suggested as the only one that can be taken as a result of the exercise of free will and rationality1 namely1 coalition1 surrender of secondary specific interests and contentions for the sake of a higher common interest1 of culture and humanity1 and the creation of a 8world army40 ,the position into which the ,powers are mechanically forced1 which in its external form seems to adjust itself to the demands of the peace idea1 is not yet permeated by the spirit of the idea2 not yet based upon the firm groundwork of institutions of peace4 ,it is filled with militarism1 confused with military projects and national antagonisms4 ,the contrast between war and culture is more definitely set forth than could be done in volumes of essays and of peace literature in the addresses and newspaper articles which accompany the sending forth of the 8,army of ,humanity40 ,the emphasis placed upon the help of ,god1 upon the religion of love and of tenderness1 and the synchronous emphasis placed upon revenge and threats of horrors1 have never been in so glaring a contrast4 ,a clinging to old ideals of force1 reference to the thought that1 a thousand years hence1 one member of the human family shall tremble before another1 as men did a thousand years ago under the lash of ,attila2 the recommendation on the part of various journals of methods of retaliation savoring of the wildest of savagery1 the slaughter of masses of men1 desecration of sanctuaries and graves1 etc41 and all these proposed as a means of spreading civilization2 all this must needs be recognized by the world at large as strident dissonance4 ,and what has brought the world to this recognition8 ,the principles of the peace movement4 ,denied as they are1 they have sunk deep into the conscience of the age4 ,the community of interests in the world has also had its share in effecting this result4 ,this has reached such a degree that a change from conditions of might to conditions of right has become a positive necessity1 an essential of life4 ,what stands revealed in the peace movement is not the dream of supramundane fancy1 but a manifestation of the instinct of self-preservation in civilization4 ,,bertha ,,von ,s,,ttner4 8,,in ,,terra ,,pax40 ,,by ,g4 ,,leveson ,,gower4 ,war in men's mouths1 peace through the spring-clad land2 ,hate in men's hearts1 and love in ,god's high heaven2 ,yet in the mass already works the leaven1 ,and in the nations some cry1 8,hold your hand1 ,ye ,peoples6 ,turn not ,earth into a hell60 ,already breaks the light when some can see ,the change to come1 the order new to be1 ,and1 seeing evil1 will not say1 8',tis well60 ,o6 for some high tribunal of the world ,where arms are stilled and equal law bears sway1 ,the strong aggressor from his vantage hurled1 ,the wronged upheld in the full light of day6 ,then shall the ,earth at rest yield glad increase1 ,and through all seas and every land be ,peace6 ---------------------------------------- -------------------------------- ,,transcriber',s ,,notes #a4 ,silently corrected obvious typographical errors and variations in spelling4 #b4 ,retained archaic1 non-standard1 and uncertain spellings as printed4 #c4 ,enclosed italics font in underscores4