,note3 ,images ( ! orig9al pages are available ?r\gh ,int]net ,ar*ive4 ,see https3_/_/ar*ive4org_/details_/mak+(man# jjleej ,,! ,,mak+ ,,( ,a ,,man by ,,rev4 ,j4 ,w4 ,,lee1 ,d4 ,d4 ,new ,york ,cassell ,publi%+ ,company #ajd #ajf ,f\r? ,av5ue ,copyright1 #ahib1 by ,cassell ,publi%+ ,company4 ,all rights res]v$4 ,! ,m]%on ,company ,press1 ,rahway1 ,n4 ,j4 ,,cont5ts4 ,,page ,,introduction1 #c ,i4 ,,bread4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,physical ,,nature ,,( ,,man1 #ci ,,ii4 ,,p[]4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,social ,,nature ,,( ,,man1 #hc ,,iii4 ,,tru?4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,intellectual ,,nature ,,( ,,man1 #acg ,,iv4 ,,righte\sness4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,moral ,,nature ,,( ,,man1 #bjc ,v4 ,,beauty4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,/hetic ,,nature ,,( ,,man1 #bec ,,vi4 ,,love4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,spiritual ,,nature ,,( ,,man1 #bic ,,vii4 ,,immortality4 ,,! ,,p]man5ce ,,( ,,! ,,complet$ ,,life ,,( ,,man1 #cce ,,introduction4 8,my ,god1 ,i he>d ?is day ,t none do? build a /ately habitation ,b he t means to dwell !re94 ,:at h\se m /ately ha? !re be51 ,or c be1 ?an is ,man8 to ^: creation ,all ?+s are 9 decay4 8,man is all symmetry ,full ( proportions1 "o limb to ano!r1 ,& all to all ! _w besides2 ,ea* "p may call ! f>!/ bro!r1 ,= head ) foot ha? private amity1 ,& bo? ) moons & tides4 8,= u ! w9ds d bl[1 ,! e>? do? re/1 heav5 move1 & f\nta9s fl[3 ,no?+ we see b means our good ,z our delight or z our treasure1 ,! :ole is ei!r our cupbo>d ( food1 ,or cab9et ( pleasure4 8,s9ce !n1 my ,god1 ?\ ha/ ,s brave a palace built4 ,oh1 dwell 9 x1 ,t x may dwell ) !e at la/6 ,till !n af=d u s mu* wit ,t z ! _w s]ves u1 we may s]ve !e ,& bo? ?y s]vants be40 ,,nature ,,& ,,man4 ,! mean+ ( creation is n und]/ood till du/ /&s erect 9 a liv+ man4 ,t a great purpose 0 pres5t f ! beg9n+1 direct+ & controll+1 !re c be no d\bt4 ,x presid$ ov] ! fir/ nebul\s mi/ t float$ out to take =m 9 ! f\ndations ( ! e>?4 ,x measur$ & weigh$ ! matt] & =ce necess>y to =m ! globe4 ,x det]m9$ ! elem5ts requir$ to d ! "w ly+ ?r\gh ! ye>s be=e x4 ,x assign$ to !m _! laws1 specific gravities & aff9ities1 & appo9t$1 be=eh&1 ! comb9ations & collocations !y 7 capable ( mak+4 ,b n till ! atoms ?robb$ 9 a human bra9 & beat 9 a human he>t1 did ! purpose1 :i* _h ?r\gh ! ages run1 /& out1 def9$ & ju/ifi$4 ,!n x 0 t ! int5tion und]nea? ! drift ( ! ages spell$ itself out 9 ! unity ( ?\ght1 ! fre$om ( *oice1 & ! capacity = love1 pot5tial 9 ! intellect1 w1 & he>t ( ! fir/ man4 ,he 0 ! realization ( an ideal1 :i* gave mean+ to ! long p]iods ( prep>ation4 ,z ! f9al expression ( ! creative process1 he 0 at once ! int]pret] & ! int]pretation ( all t _h gone be=e4 ,i4 ,writ]s ( a c]ta9 s*ool h s\ght to m9ify man's place 9 nature4 ,!y say1 z ,dr4 ,joseph ,leconte well decl>es1 t he is v closely connect$ )1 & =ms a mo/ insignificant "p (1 nature--t he has no k+dom ( 8 own1 b belongs to ! animal k+dom2 t 9 ! animal k+dom he has no dep>tm5t ( 8 own1 b belongs to ! dep>tm5t ( ! v]tebrates--along ) birds1 reptiles1 & fi%es2 t 9 ! dep>tm5t ( ! v]tebrates he has no privileg$ class ( 8 own1 b belongs to ! class ( ! mammals1 along ) f\r-foot$ bea/s2 t 9 ! class ( mammals he has no titl$ ord] ( 8 own1 b belongs to ! ord] ( primates1 along ) monkeys & baboons4 ,8 consci5ce is b ! resultant ( fe> & in/9ct1 sl[ly deposit$ ?r\gh ! ye>s ( 8 evolution4 ,its imp]i\sness is self-con/itut$4 ,its scept] x has usurp$1 &1 f ! exhalations ( its own ris+ c[>dice1 x has wov5 ! purple robes :i* con/itute ! badge ( its au?ority4 ,8 morality consi/s ( rules impos$ by 8 own prud5ce1 & :i* h no sanctions beyond ! op9ions ( 8 class or tribe4 ,8 religion is det]m9$ by ! physical conditions :i* surr\nd 8 life--8 geographical situation1 ! nature & configuration ( 8 soil1 8 climate1 & 8 food4 ,?us man is simply a natural product1 :ile ! civilization :i* he has produc$ is z mu* det]m9$ by ! physical conditions surr\nd+ 8 life1 z ! leaves & dates ( ! palm are det]m9$ by ! physical conditions surr\nd+ t tropical tree4 ,! hopes & ! trials1 ! c\rage & ! sacrifice ( ! be/ m51 z well z ! ambitions & motives ( ! wor/1 are put on a level ) ! damps & w9ds4 ,! "o class is entitl$ to no m cr$it = :at is noble & h]oic1 ?an is ra9 = n\ri%+ ! crops2 :ile ! o!r des]ves no m rebuke = :at is base & ignoble1 ?an ! lightn+ = /rik+ ! ,*ur* & kill+ ! p4 ,! love :i* expresses itself 9 monum5ts to commemorate ! de$s ( ! good & ! great1 & ! condemnation :i* lifts itself into jails to conf9e ! crim9al & ! outlaw1 h1 9 ! la/ analysis1 ! same mean+4 ,!re is no sacr$ significance or obligations root$ 9 div9e sanctions1 9 ei!r ! monum5ts or ! jails4 ,bo? are b fickle phases ( ! pass+ _s4 ,! convictions ( ,moses1 reproduc+ !mselves 9 ! gov]nm5t1 laws1 lit]ature1 morality1 & religion ( a great p1 cons]v+ !m ?r\gh ! ages z examples ( ord] & heal?1 h no m mean+ ?an ! sap :i* rises 9 "s mon>* ( ! =e/1 to express itself 9 leaves & fruit4 ,! conceptions ( duty1 :i* n]v$ ! he>t & inspir$ ! c\rage ( ! ,apo/le ,paul1 lead+ him to plant *ur*es 9 ,asia ,m9or1 to become ! se$s ( mod]n civilization1 7 z completely natural z ! ris+ ( ! wat]s ( "s m\nta9 spr+1 to fl[ ov] silv] s&s to ! sea4 ,! music ( ,bee?ov51 ! visions ( ,raphael1 7 b z ! vapor 9 ! light ( ! morn+ sun1 beautiful1 p]haps1 z ! ra9b[1 b go+ out ) ! sett+ day4 ,:atev] ( emotion or consci5ce !y embodi$1 signifi$ no m ?an ! colors ( ! pea* bloom1 or ! notes ( ! fall+ cascade4 ,h[ev] e/eem$ ! valor t risk$ life to break ! reign ( oppression & murd]1 x 0 b a v>y+ =m ( ! he>tless ambition t s\ght 9 /r5g? to make x prevail4 ,! patriotism ( ,leonidas1 giv+ up 8 life to save 8 c\ntry1 & ! insane act ( ,n]o1 swa?+ ,*ri/ians 9 t> to light 8 fea/1 7 =w>d & rev]se movem5ts ( ! same human _s2 bo? natural1 & bo? z unmoral z ! electricity t n[ /rikes to de/roy1 & n[ burns ! mal>ia to save4 ,no diff]5ce is made betwe5 poison 9 ! fangs ( snakes1 & m]cy 9 ! he>ts ( m54 ,back ( nature !re is no purpose1 & 9 its manifold comb9ations & adaptations !re is no design4 ,x is only a va/ aggregate ( unre/+ atoms1 /rik+ "o ^u ano!r1 & )\t int5tion & )\t purpose1 =m+ pairs1 clu/]s1 & gr\ps1 & ?us assum+ ! %apes we see4 ,:y !re happ5s to be ord] in/ead ( *aos hangs on ! unc]ta9 turn ( luck4 ,,ii4 ,if !re is m9d 9 ! univ]se1 & if !re is purpose 9 ! ord] & movem5ts ( ! e>?1 !n man is ! culm9ation ( t purpose1 & ) ref]5ce to him 0 ! ord] con/itut$ & ! movem5ts det]m9$4 ,if !re is naught b matt] & =ce1 & ^! exi/ )\t any direct+ or co-ord9at+ m9d1 !n all ?+s are )\t int5tion & )\t reason4 ,!re is no?+ good or bad4 ,no?+ is "r or wrong4 ,all ?+s are r$uc$ to a mean+less level ( indiff]5ce4 ,b matt] & =ce be> witness to m9d4 ,matt] is "h we "k2 & matt] has n only =m1 ext5sion1 imp5etrability1 = its qualities1 b inde/ructibility4 ,take ! matt] t ent]s into ! composition ( ! e>?4 ,! am\nt ( x is fix$ & def9ite4 ,x may be express$ 9 p\nds weight4 ,s9ce ! beg9n+1 n an atom has be5 add$ to x1 or tak5 f x4 ,its pres5ce "h is to be acc\nt$ =4 ,x ei!r det]m9$ its own exi/5ce1 & ! exact am\nt1 9 p\nds weight ( t exi/5ce1 or x 0 det]m9$ by "s pr9ciple or p[] outside ( itself1 or )9 itself1 call$ m9d4 ,if x det]m9$ itself to be1 !n x is intellig5t1 = self-det]m9ation & self-action are ! ess5tial *>act]i/ics ( m9d4 ,!n intellig5ce is reta9$ by be+ transf]r$ f some?+ call$ m9d to some?+ call$ matt]4 ,b x has nev] be5 claim$ t matt] is intellig5t4 ,!n x is n self-active or self-det]m9+1 & waits on m9d = its exi/5ce & its movem5ts4 ,matt] z pla9ly be>s te/imony ( ! exi/5ce ( m9d1 z to ! exi/5ce ( itself4 ,x is easi] to believe t ! e>? has tak5 ! globul> =m & ! circul> motion by ! det]m9ations ( m9d1 ?an to believe t ?r\gh its own det]m9ations x has assum$ a circumf]5ce ( tw5ty-five ?\s& miles1 & ! regul> task ( :eel+ on its axis e tw5ty-f\r h\rs4 ,n only is x impossible to acc\nt = ! exact am\nt ( matt] mak+ up ! e>?'s size & weight1 )\t assum+ ! p[] ( a co-ord9at+1 det]m9+ m9d2 b a /ill great] task is ^u u1 to acc\nt = ! sixty odd orig9al elem5ts1 out ( :i* all ?+s 9 nature are =m$ )\t m9d4 ,^! elem5ts diff] 9 quantity1 quality1 specific gravity1 & aff9ity4 ,:at det]m9$ _! numb]1 _! t5d5cies1 & aff9ities8 ,:y some?+ m ?an sixty2 no m1 no less8 ,:y s mu* ( "s1 s little ( o!rs8 ,we mu/ ei!r conclude t !y det]m9$ !mselves--t !y held a conv5tion be=e !y exi/$1 & resolv$ ^u tak+ =m & motion1 or else we mu/ believe t !y 7 det]m9$ by "s p[]1 o!r ?an !mselves--by m9d4 ,if by _! own motion1 oxyg51 & iron1 & gold are :at !y are2 !n ! elem5ts h ! p[] ( self-action & self-det]m9ation1 & are !re=e intellig5t4 ,! collocations ^! elem5ts =m are m difficult /ill to be acc\nt$ = )\t ! ag5cy ( m9d4 ,figures pil$ up to ! sun are n able to express ! possible comb9ations !y are capable ( assum+4 ,! possible comb9ations ( ev5 tw5ty-f\r lett]s ( ! alphabet c\ld n be express$ 9 lit]ature1 fill+ ! _w ) books4 ,mu* great] mu/ be ! numb] ( comb9ations ( ! orig9al elem5ts--! alphabet ( creation4 ,x is to be rememb]$1 too1 t !y disagree on m ( _! sides ?an !y agree4 ,!y are by no means equally cong5ial4 ,fri5d%ips & unions betwe5 !m are =m$ 9 accordance ) ! mo/ exact rule & aff9ity4 ,does x n seem1 !n1 t comb9ations =m$ by *ance w\ld be mutually incompatible1 neutraliz+1 & de/ructive8 ,w\ld !y n =ev] f]m5t 9 ungov]n$ *aos8 ,yet we see !m dwell+ toge!r 9 ! utmo/ unity1 l seek+ l1 & 9 ! bonds ( law & h>mony1 unit+ 9 comp\nd1 m9]al1 vegetable1 animal1 & ! body ( man himself4 ,7 !re z _m ( ! lett] a1 z !re are atoms ( oxyg52 & z _m ( ! lett] b1 z !re are atoms ( hydrog52 & 7 ! lett]s ( ! alphabet to be increas$ 9 proportion to _! use1 until !y %\ld equal ! atoms ( all ! elem5ts :i* ent] into ! composition ( ! globe2 h[ long w\ld x take ^! lett]s1 /irr$ by "s =ce l ! w9ds1 to assume ! =m ( su* a poem z ,p>adise ,lo/8 ,we _c believe t all ^! lett]s1 /irr$ by an unse5 =ce ?r\gh inf9ite ages1 w\ld ev] =m a s5sible v]se ( poetry1 or a rational v]se ( prose4 ,x is z difficult to und]/& h[ ! lett]s ( ! alphabet c\ld ev] get into ! rhy?m ( ,p>adise ,lo/1 )\t ,milton's m9d1 z to und]/& h[ unconsci\s elem5ts took ! =m ( m\nta91 sea1 grove1 & globe2 r\nd1 articulate1 & law abid+1 )\t a great co-ord9at+ m9d4 ,! physical =ces & en]gies be> indubitable te/imony to ! exi/5ce ( m9d1 n only outside ( !mselves1 b 9 !mselves & ?r\gh !mselves4 ,we h ! =ce ( gravitation1 ! p[] :i* bodies h ( attract+ "o ano!r 9 proportion to _! mass1 & inv]sely z ! squ>es ( _! di/ance2 9 o!r words1 t p[] :i* bodies h ( gett+ up mutually aggregative motion1 unless prev5t$ by "s o!r p[] ( an opposite nature4 ,a body susp5d$ 9 ! air is attract$ t[>d ! e>? by ! =ce ( gravitation4 ,a lump ( sug> held ov] a cup ( tea1 attracts into itself ! wat] ( ! tea cup4 ,?is is done by ! =ce kn[n z capill>ity4 ,a piece ( iron left expos$ attracts ! p>ticles ( oxyg5 9 ! atmosph]e4 ,?is is done by ! =ce kn[n z *emical aff9ity4 ,:y d bodies attract "o ano!r 9 proportion to _! mass & inv]sely z ! squ>es ( _! di/ance8 ,:y does a lump ( sug>1 held close ov] a cup ( wat]1 attract ! p>ticles ( wat] into itself8 ,:y does a piece ( iron 9 ! atmosph]e attract to itself ! oxyg58 ,we are told x is because ( gravitation1 capill>ity1 & *emical aff9ity4 ,h[ happ5s x t ^! =ces h me?ods ( action kn[n z gravitation1 capill>ity1 & *emical aff9ity8 ,!y ei!r det]m9$ !mselves to h !m & to act 9 accordance ) !m1 or else "s p[] o!r ?an !mselves det]m9$ ^! me?ods ( action = !m4 ,! tru? is1 gravitation1 capill>ity1 & *emical aff9ity are b t]ms we use to def9e ! op]ations ( m9d4 ,to "n a =ce & to f9d ! =mula 9 accordance ) :i* x works1 is n to det]m9e ! orig9 ( its s\rce4 ,& because we h1 by obs]vation & exp]im5t1 f\nd out ! me?ods & ! measures ( ! m9d's work+1 is no good reason :y we %\ld read m9d out ( ! process altoge!r4 ,?is is to mi/ake names = causes2 & to suppose :5 "o le>ns h[ a =ce acts1 t he has also le>n$ :at x is t acts4 ,a contempor>y ( ,%aksp]e might h obs]v$ ! poet s closely 9 8 home at ,/rat=d-^u-,avon1 z to be able to give to ! _w a detail$ & exact acc\nt ( 8 habits ( ?\ght & h\rs ( /udy2 b ?is w\ld n h kept ! intellig5t "p ( mank9d f believ+ t a great m9d _h embodi$ itself 9 ! immortal plays ( ,%aksp]e4 ,heat1 electricity1 light1 & magnetism mu/ also be expressions ( m9d1 = ! same reason t matt] is an expression ( m9d4 ,to believe !m self-det]m9$1 is to believe !m rational & intellig5t4 ,?is has nev] be5 claim$1 h5ce our only way ( acc\nt+ = _! exi/5ce is to reg>d !m z ! det]m9ations ( m9d4 ,we see !m1 day by day1 l5d+ !mselves to ! uses & devices ( man's ?\ght1 & expressions ( ?\ght !y mu/ be4 ,,iii4 ,?is :ole subject resolves itself into ! "q1 ,:i* is fundam5tal & prior1 m9d or matt]8 ,if m9d is fundam5tal & prior1 !n !re is design1 int5tion1 & purpose 9 nature4 ,if matt] is fir/ & fundam5tal1 !re is no su* ?+ z design1 int5tion1 or purpose any:]e4 ,if m9d is fir/ & fundam5tal1 !n man is ! end & aim ( creation1 = 9 him ! m9d t =m$ ! e>? f9ds a companion & an int]pret]4 ,if matt] is fir/ & fundam5tal1 !n ! e>? is z mu* = crocodiles & wolves1 z = m51 & ! life ( a human be+ is no bett] ?an t ( a liz>d4 ,if matt] is fundam5tal1 x 7 bett] to be a crocodile or an elephant ?an to be a man1 = !y h m ( ! fundam5tal /uff ( ! univ]se 9 _! bodies2 & _! bra9s g5]ate none ( t subtle some?+ call$ m9d1 :i* p]petually asks que/ions t h no answ]1 & *]i%es beliefs t h no f\ndation4 ,if matt] is fundam5tal1 !n we %\ld tru/ our faculties1 9 proportion z !y are animal1 & d5y !m 9 proportion z !y are m5tal4 ,!n ! ,n]os & ! ,caligulas 7 m rational 9 _! s9s1 ?an ! ,lu!rs & ! ,wesleys 9 _! virtues4 ,by foll[+ _! lu/s1 ! =m] f\nd pleasure1 ( a l[ ord] ( c\rse1 b 9 ! realm ( ! real2 ! latt]1 foll[+ _! convictions1 f\nd pleasure1 ( a high] ord] x may be1 b x 0 9 a false & unreal doma94 ,x 7 bett] to be true to ! facts on ! pla9 ( ! appetites1 ?an to be ! silly victims ( fraud on ! pla9 ( ! consci5ce & ! affections4 ,b x is impossible t m5 h be5 true z !y h be5 degrad$1 & false z !y h be5 pure4 ,! design & purpose :i* has be5 app>5t 9 nature1 & :i* m5 h felt 9 consci5ce approv+ ! "r & condemn+ ! wrong1 mu/ be !re4 ,to elim9ate !m1 or to reason !m away1 is to br+ m5tal confusion1 & to take f ! conviction & ?\ght1 :i* h made civilization1 ! pr9ciples on :i* !y repos$1 & by :i* !y 7 inspir$4 ,,iv4 ,man has no deep] & sur] impression ?an t ! _w belongs to him & 0 made = him4 ,x is deep5$ ye> by ye>1 too1 z he sees ! relations he su/a9s to x increase4 ,no m c]ta9ly are ! walls1 ro(1 & floor ( a h\se relat$ to ! com=t & protection ( ! family1 ?an are ! elem5ts1 =ces1 & seasons ( nature relat$ to ! well-be+ & civilization ( man4 ,m\nta9 & sky1 mead[ & =e/1 ! pa/ & ! pres5t are p]meat$ ) ! ?\ght1 or idea1 ( man1 :e!r 9 ! fir/ /ages ( progress1 keep+ bea/s at bay ) sl+ or /one1 or at a m advanc$ p]iod1 tunnel+ ! riv]s & digg+ d[n ! m\nta9s4 ,"y or old1 *ild or man1 nature /&s ready to s]ve him4 ,wat] f h] skies fl[s ?r\gh 8 ve9s to & f 8 beat+ he>t4 ,trees & %rubs & h]bs m9i/] to 8 pleasure & 8 ills4 ,rocks1 & timb]1 & /eel l5d !mselves to 8 s]vice = h\se1 hat*et1 or *isel4 ,:5 he asc5ds suffici5tly 9 ! grade ( civilization to give expression to 8 conceptions ( beauty1 he f9ds ! colors 9 ! ores "u 8 feet to embody 8 visions4 ,w\ld he illum9ate 8 humble home at night1 !re is ! p9e ) its light-giv+ t>4 ,does he live amid ! pla9s1 :]e ! p9e does n gr[1 !re is ! ox ) 8 tall[ ready to be made into c&les4 ,does he live on ! coa/1 away f ! ox or ! p9e1 !re is ! :ale ) 8 oil4 ,does he want a bett] light ?an p9e1 or tall[1 or oil c give1 !re are ! coal b$s1 ) _! sun%9e laid up = 8 use = ?\s&s ( ages4 ,does he wi% to turn night into day1 & make 8 /reets gl[ ) ! radiance ( ! />s1 !re is electricity to be drawn f its wide1 my/]i\s fields1 to s]ve 8 gr[+ desire4 ,w\ld he cross ! sea1 ! w9ds lie ready to fill 8 canvas & draw him f cont95t to cont95t4 ,are ! w9ds too sl[1 !re is ! heat1 /or$ 9 ! m\nta9s1 ready to move 8 eng9e & drive 8 :eel4 ,does he wi% to make himself ubiquit\s1 & s5d a message across ! sea1 be=e a %ip c\ld get out ( port1 !re waits on him aga9 ! my/]i\s lightn+4 ,nature teems ) elem5ts & =ces to wait on man's e ?\ght1 to gratify 8 e desire1 & to respond to 8 e aspiration4 ,) all h] weal? %e surr\nds him1 & 9 t5 ?\s& ways invites him to use x4 ,! naturali/ ,guyot said ! h& ( man prefigures 8 de/9y z an intellig5t work]4 ,s ! =m ( all cont95ts & isl&s1 ! outl9es ( all seas & coa/s1 conta9 ! idea ( ! human family4 ,at a "t1 geologically ab\t ! same1 ! surface conditions ( ! e>? 7 prep>$ = ! adv5t ( man4 ,! great ,himalaya ,m\nta9 range 0 lift$ up to prep>e an embosom+ pla9 to s]ve z a cradle = ! human race4 ,! long *a9 ( m\nta9s runn+ ?r\gh ! :ole l5g? ( ! ,nor? & ,s\? ,am]ican cont95ts 0 rais$ to prep>e ! way = civilization on ?is side ( ! sea4 ,:5 ! ocean b$s 7 dug out & ! wat]s call$ (f f a "p ( ! e>?'s surface2 :5 ! mighty peaks & ! maje/ic turrets ( ! m\nta9 *a9s 7 lift$ into ! sky2 :5 ! encompass+ atmosph]e 0 fill$ ) all life-repl5i%+ elem5ts & wrapp$ ab\t all oceans & %ores2 :5 ! poison\s =ces de/ructive ( man's life 7 lock$ up 9 soils & rocks2 :5 ! mead[s 7 s[n ) grasses1 & ! hospitable arms ( ! trees 7 load$ ) fruit1 !n1 ^u ! e>?1 adorn$ & ready = 8 com+1 man appe>$4 ,v4 ,consid]$ z an embodim5t ( ?\ght1 man is ! only creature :o c int]pret ,nature4 ,! ideas & pr9ciples t fill 8 great books 7 ga!r$ f a /udy ( h] secrets & processes4 ,! fir/ books on geology1 giv+ ! hi/ory ( ! e>?1 its upheavals1 *anges1 & trans=mations1 7 writt5 9 ! rocks1 s&s1 coal-b$s1 & %ells ( ! primal ages4 ,! fir/ books on *emi/ry 7 writt5 9 ! %ape1 sizes1 aff9ities1 & specific gravities ( ! atoms :i* ent] into ! composition ( all natural bodies4 ,! fir/ books on ari?metic1 by ! k ( :i* man le>ns to divide & conqu] nature1 7 writt5 9 ! qualitative relations & movem5ts ( matt]4 ,! fir/ books on a/ronomy 7 writt5 9 ! orbits & movem5ts ( ! heav5ly bodies4 ,! fir/ books on zology 7 writt5 9 ! /ructure & habits ( ! l[] animals4 ,! books t fill our libr>ies are b transcripts f ! orig9al volumes writt5 9 rocks1 seas1 fl[]s1 & skies4 ,man is ! only be+ :o c read & transcribe ^! wond]ful volumes4 ,!y lie unop5$ & unkn[n till 8 int]e/ is provok$4 ,_! language c>ries no mean+ till he comes to f9d x & to pond] x4 ,! h]ds t l[ amid ! ,alp9e e*oes see1 z well z ! di/+ui%$ ,tyndall1 ! great glaci]s1 z !y press ) sl[ & measur$ pace d[n ! m\nta9 side2 b _! mean+1 & ! law by :i* !y move1 is n kn[n till ! man ( sci5ce comes4 ,to him1 !y speak 9 awful & maje/ic t]ms4 ,to ! %eep 9 ! mead[1 ! grass means no?+ b food2 to man1 h[ev]1 e blade has a message1 poetic & beautiful4 ,consid]$ z a home1 ?is _w 0 made = man2 9 a ?\s& s5ses1 x 0 n made = any o!r creature4 ,x is ! home ( ! oy/]1 b its wants are met by a little bas9 9 ! sea4 ,x is ! home ( ! elephant1 b a few acres ( ,asiatic jungle furni% ! food & ! conditions necess>y to its life4 ,x is ! home ( ! bird1 b give x a tree & a worm1 & a small circle ( sky to fly ar\nd1 & x ne$s no m4 ,b man ne$s x all4 ,= 8 hung]1 ! foods & ! fruits ( its cont95ts1 oceans1 & skies4 ,= 8 ?ir/1 ! wat]s ( its ?\s& rills4 ,= 8 %elt] & protection1 all its woods4 ,= 8 ?\ght1 all its ord] & law4 ,= 8 ills1 ! t5d] m9i/ry ( all its m9]als & plants4 ,he is relat$ to x all1 & to be completely furni%$ mu/ be able to use x all4 ,consid]$ z a place ( discipl9e1 ! e>? is = man1 = he is ! only creature help$ & advanc$ by discipl9e4 ,! beav] cuts 8 tree & builds 8 dam to-day j z ! beav] did 9 ! fir/ ye> ( 8 exi/5ce4 ,he has _h ! discipl9e t comes ?r\gh "w1 b x has n improv$ him nor elevat$ him4 ,9 ord] t ! bee may live1 he mu/ ga!r 8 honey & build 8 cell4 ,?is is discipl9e4 ,b he nev] improves4 ,he nev] gr[s 9 culture or skill4 ,! bee t built 8 cell 9 ! trees ( p>adise1 & ga!r$ 8 honey f ! fl[]s t grew 9 ! g>d5 ( ,ed51 knew z well h[ to con/ruct a cell accord+ to ma!matical pr9ciples1 & to pack x ) honey1 z ! ,italian bee ( ! n9ete5? c5tury1 :o /ores 8 honey 9 a pa9t$ gum prep>$ = him by man4 ,monkeys 9 ,s\? ,am]ica cross riv]s by twi/+ _! tails1 ?us mak+ bridges ( !mselves4 ,?is is discipl9e & ex]cise ( a complex & m>vel\s sort1 b !y devise no new ways ( build+ bridges4 ,!y d n increase 9 k or skill by _! "w4 ,t he may ga9 ! means ( subsi/5ce1 man is "u ! necessity ( "w too4 ,b 8 "w is to him a means ( gr[? & k4 ,8 "w has help$ him =w>d1 & secur$ to him culture & skill4 ,sugge/ions come to him1 z he fells ! =e/1 z he pl[s ! field1 z he plants ! se$1 & z he r[s 8 dug-out4 ,^! sugge/ions he turns to acc\nt4 ,he builds !m into bett] axes = cutt+ ! trees1 into bett] pl[-/ocks = break+ ! l&1 & into bett] boats = cross+ ! sea4 ,by turn+ ! sugge/ions he has receiv$ into bett] me?ods1 into improv$ tools & ma*9]y1 he has come f ! dug-out to ! ocean /eam]2 f ! pack-mule to ! palace c>2 f ! scy!-blade to ! m[] & reap]2 f ! /one & sl+ to ! improv$ army gun2 f ! sp9n+-:eel to ! cotton-factory2 & f ! foam+ /e$ ( ! fly+ mess5g] to ! electric telegraph4 ,because ( ! gr[? & improvem5t he has receiv$ ?r\gh "w1 ! tom-tom has long giv5 place to ! piano1 & ! t5t to ! mod]n home4 ,?r\gh /ruggle ) nature1 he has be5 piqu$ into a det]m9ation to conqu] h]1 to f]ret out h] secrets1 & ma/] h] processes4 ,! =ces t oppose him he makes to s]ve him4 ,! riv] curr5t1 :i* =bids him to cross1 he utilizes to f]ry him ov]4 ,he sets 8 sail 9 ! w9d bl[+ ea/w>d & avails himself ( its p[] to c>ry him we/w>d4 ,! waves t rise to engulf him he turns into /eam to outride !m4 ,! w9ds draw 8 wat]1 ! riv] saws 8 plank4 ,! tail ( ! beav] is adju/$ by nature to ! mud he ne$s to cem5t 8 dam2 8 too? is already adju/$ to ! h>dness ( ! tree1 s t he cuts x d[n by in/9ct & )\t ?\ght4 ,! eagle f9ds ! air already "u 8 w+s :5 he w\ld fly1 & 8 talons already prep>$ to hold 8 food1 or to grasp a limb 9 ! =e/4 ,! fi% f9ds itself 9 ! beg9n+ ( its exi/5ce 9 an elem5t ready to respond to its f9s1 & 9 ! pres5ce ( food adapt$ to its life4 ,! l[] animals f9d !mselves at ! />t 9 a _w imm$iately adju/$ to _! ne$s1 s t !y h only to use _! feet1 _! tee?1 _! horns1 _! claws1 _! w+s1 & _! f9s1 to conqu] _! enemies & f9d _! food4 ,! animal is :olly gov]n$ by natural law1 & h5ce has no hi/ory4 ,he moves on nature's level1 & is adju/$ to h] pla9s1 h] =e/s1 h] seas1 & h] skies1 )\t 8 ?\ght or 8 device4 ,man is n relat$ 9 ! same outw>d1 imm$iate way to clo?+1 food1 & fuel4 ,8 und]/&+1 x is true1 corresponds to ! s*eme ( nature1 b he mu/ gr[ into ?is by /udy1 by insight1 by h9ts1 by ! use ( faculties ! l[] animals d n possess4 ,z long z he rema9s on ! pla9 ( ! tig] & pan!r1 & emulates _! /eal?y /ep to creep ^u 8 prey1 or 8 human foe1 l !m1 he has no hi/ory4 ,! savage1 p]haps1 did ma/] ! my/]y ( ! dug-out & ! bir*-b>k canoe1 b he _h no place = 8 ar*ives b a hole 9 ! gr\nd1 & no exp]i5ce b su* z di$ ) him4 ,man's hi/ory beg9s ) ! attempt to conqu] ,nature4 ,! contribution t ,nature makes to human civilization is t %e sets h]self aga9/ 8 inw>d en]gies1 z if to call !m out4 ,%e puts limitations ab\t him1 t he may be prompt$ to rise above !m4 ,! fury & /orm ( ! sea provokes 8 +5uity to express itself 9 ! /eam%ip4 ,! p]il to life & =tune conta9$ 9 ! lightn+'s fla%1 begets ! /eel rod t dis>ms x4 ,! di/ance betwe5 ! :eat t gr[s 9 "o "p ( ! globe & ! ne$ = bread 9 ano!r1 leads to ! discov]y ( a me?od ( transportation t oblit]ates x4 ,civilization is ! expression t man has made ( himself 9 8 attempts1 ?r\gh ?\ght & w1 to effect ! conque/ ( ,nature4 ,?is witnesses to ! peculi> & magnific5t place :i* alone belongs to him 9 nature4 ,x may be true t he has no k+dom ( 8 own1 no privileg$ class ( 8 own1 & no titl$ ord] ( 8 own2 b x c h>dly be disput$ t he has a hi/ory ( 8 own4 ,?is hi/ory1 writt5 9 ! dim glories ( va/ empires1 9 ! ru% ( spl5did cities1 9 ! age-long conflict betwe5 good & evil1 9 ! undy+ cre$ ( m>tyr$ fai?1 9 ! hope1 fidelity1 trial1 agony1 triumph1 & self-sacrifice ( ! human race1 be>s witness to ! fact1 ei!r t ! e>? 0 made = man1 or else t he is ! only creature ^u x capable ( subdu+ x1 trans=m+ x1 recreat+ x1 & appropriat+ x4 ,if man is only a natural product1 ! p[]s h c]ta9ly be5 engag$ 9 a m>vel\sly intellig5t & complicat$ sort ( conspiracy to advance 8 int]e/s & to s]ve 8 dom9ion4 ,no?+ b :at we h be5 accu/om$ to reg>d z design1 int5tion1 purpose1 is suffici5t to acc\nt = ! fact1 t ! s*eme ( nature s completely corresponds to ! und]/&+ ( man z to make x possible = him to comm& & claim all h] possessions = 8 own4 ,m5 w nev] accept su* a happy co9cid5ce z ! "w ( *ance4 ,!y w1 by ! v /ructure ( _! m9ds1 believe t ! s*eme & ! und]/&+1 :i*1 ?r\gh ! process ( /ruggle & trial1 gr[s into x1 7 int5d$1 by ! ,great ,au?or ( bo?1 ! "o = ! o!r4 ,,bread4 8,! p[] t ,greece _h to ?r[ out light is m>vel\s1 ev5 n[ t we h ! example ( ,france4 ,greece did n colonize )\t civiliz+--an example t m ?an "o mod]n nation might foll[3 to buy & sell is n all4 8,tyre b\ght & sold3 ,b]ytus b\ght & sold3 ,sidon b\ght & sold3 ,s>epta b\ght & sold4 ,:]e are ^! cities8 ,a!ns taught2 & %e is to ?is h\r "o ( ! capitals ( human ?\ght4 8,! grass is gr[+ on ! six /eps ( ! tribune :]e spoke ,demo/h5es3 ! ,c]amicus is a rav9e1 half-*ok$ ) ! m>ble du/ :i* 0 once ! palace ( ,cecrops3 ! ,odeon ( ,h]od ,atticus1 at ! foot ( ! ,acropolis1 is n[ b a ru9 on :i* falls at c]ta9 h\rs ! imp]fect %ad[ ( ! ,p>!non3 ! temple ( ,!seus belongs to ! swall[s3 ! goats br[se on ! ,pnyx4 ,/ill ! ,greek _s lives3 /ill ,greece is que53 /ill ,greece is goddess4 ,a c\nt+ h\se passes away3 a s*ool rema9s40 ,,*apt] ,i4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,physical ,,nature ,,( ,,man4 ,9 ! =m ( bread1 us+ ! t]m 9 a wide g5]ic s5se1 matt] passes into ! s]vice ( man on ! plane ( human life4 ,by regul> /eps x is lift$ & ref9$ & adju/$ to correspond5ce ) human ne$ & com=t4 ,9 its raw & individual /ate1 x is controll$ by physical =ce4 ,f ?is crude condition x is c>ri$ by *emical =ce to ! ord] ( ! m9]al k+dom4 ,f ?is plane1 x passes up ?r\gh ! ag5cy ( vital =ce to ! vegetable k+dom4 ,?r\gh ! p[] ( vital =ce ( a high] k9d1 x is advanc$ to ! animal k+dom4 ,"h x is ready = man1 & yields itself to ! uses ( 8 life4 ,f ! "t t vital =ce ent]s ! realm ( nature1 a process ( assimilation beg9s4 ,! plant assimilates ! m9]al1 ! animal assimilates ! plant1 & man assimilates ! animal4 ,?r\gh regul> gradations1 matt] passes up f ! bottom ( nature into ! s]vice ( man1 :o /&s at ! top4 ,) ea* move upw>d x gets associat$ ) =ce ( a high] k9d4 ,) ea* advance its range gets wid] & its movem5ts fre]4 ,9 ! =m ( bread1 x is suffici5tly ref9$ & sublimat$ to be appropriat$ & utiliz$ = food1 = %elt]1 = raim5t1 by ! immortal _s ( man4 ,! necessity = food1 = clo?+1 = %elt]1 creates comm]ce1 & comm]ce accompli%es results f> m important ?an ! production & di/ribution ( ! temporal necessities ( human life4 ,x br+s m5 toge!r2 x e/abli%es relations4 ,x is ! wond]ful in/itution :i*1 e>ly 9 ! hi/ory ( ! race1 began z a loom to cat* up ! sep>ate ?reads ( individual life1 to weave !m into t m>vel\s fabric call$ humanity4 ,ends ( an inf9itely high] ord] are realiz$ by ! production & ex*ange ( ! elem5ts ( trade1 ?an ! satisfy+ ( hung] ) bread1 or ! furni%+ man ) clo?+ & %elt]4 ,! high] ends are ! ess5tial & orda9$ ends4 ,t we may und]/& :at an important "p ! necessity = food has play$ 9 ! progress ( man1 x w be well to consid] ! significance ( ! relations x fir/ help$ to e/abli%4 ,i4 ,all p[] :atev]1 t di/+ui%es man f ! brute1 t 9 any respect contributes to 8 comm]cial1 m5tal1 moral1 or human value1 is due to union1 relation1 action & int]action among individuals4 ,9 nature we may f9d illu/rations ( ?is tru?4 ,s\nd1 electricity1 heat1 & light1 are =ms ( =ce :i* owe _! exi/5ce to action1 relation1 int]action among mat]ial p>ticles4 ,!y w\ld nev] arise 9 a univ]se ( unrelat$ elem5ts4 ,_! diff]5ce is due1 n to ! vibration ( diff]5t elem5ts1 b to diff]5t rates ( vibration among ! same elem5ts4 ,consequ5t ^u c]ta9 t]ms ( =mal & quiet social int]c\rse among ! molecules1 !re is s\nd4 ,:5 !y int]m+le m actively & intimately1 !re is electricity4 ,) a slight *ange 9 ! me?od1 b no decrease 9 ! velocity ) :i* !y move1 !re is heat4 ,:5 !y g at ! top ( _! spe$1 waltz+ & sw++ corn]s at an un?9kable rate1 !re is light4 ,f v>y+ relations & actions among mat]ial p>ticles1 we get ! music :i* *>ms u1 ! means ( communication :i* unite u1 ! p[] to d "w :i* s]ves u1 & ! beauty :i* ref9es u4 ,! unceas+ play ( ^! simple unse5 elem5ts made ! fame ( ,bee?ov51 :o ?rew _! vibrations into symphonies2 & ( ,morse1 :o utiliz$ _! spe$ to c>ry ! news2 & ( ,watt1 :o hit*$ _! radiations to ! fly+ tra92 & ( ,dagu]re1 :o put _! undulations to pa9t+ pictures4 ,all =ms ( physical =ce may be trac$ to ! union1 relation1 & vibration ( mat]ial p>ticles4 ,! di/ance f atoms to m5 is well-nigh inf9ite1 b ! po9ts ( resemblance betwe5 ! g5esis ( physical =ce & ! g5esis ( social =ce are suffici5tly /rik+ to make x p]missible to trace ! analogy betwe5 !m4 ,by social =ce is und]/ood all ^? =ms ( en]gy :i* m5 f9d !mselves to possess by virtue ( _! relations to "o ano!r 9 organiz$ social life4 ,comm]ce insures ! union1 & br+s ab\t ! relations t make ?is =ce possible4 ,x furni%es ! conditions )\t :i* x c\ld n be4 ,a self-conta9$1 self-includ$1 insulat$ p]son does c>ry )9 ! dep?s ( 8 be+ ! organs ( ! civiliz$ man1 b !y are z completely out ( sight & out ( use z ! h>ve/s t sleep )9 ! k]nels ( ! mummy :eat4 ,if x 7 possible = an individual to come to ye>s ( maturity1 out ( relations ) 8 fell[s1 he w\ld be m de/itute ?an a brute4 ,su* an "o1 gr[+ up 9 ! woods or on an isl&1 ) no associates b ! squirrels & ! birds1 w\ld n h ! p]sonal furni%m5ts ( ! monkey or ! fox4 ,we c und]/&1 too1 by consid]+ :at man owes to 8 relations1 h[ widely & completely he is sep>at$ f ! l[] animals4 ,a ?\s& blackbirds1 liv+ toge!r 9 relation1 are n diff]5t f a ?\s& blackbirds liv+ ap>t & out ( relation4 ,a squirrel ga9s no elem5t ( squirrelhood by companion%ip1 & loses no elem5t ( x 9 isolation4 ,he may be tak5 f 8 ne/ z soon z he is born & nev] be p]mitt$ to see ano!r squirrel1 b he w be j z mu* ( a squirrel1 & "k z well h[ to get ! meat out ( a nut1 z if free 9 ! =e/s ) o!rs ( 8 k9d4 ,a mock+ bird comes to ! p[] ( song z well 9 a cage1 sep>at$ f o!r birds1 z :5 f$ & tra9$ 9 ! or*>d by ! "m-bird4 ,! *ords 9 8 ?roat 7 set to music1 & )\t tea*] or praise1 at a c]ta9 p]iod ( 8 gr[?1 8 song w r+ ?r\gh ! h\se4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 a man br\ght up 9 "s lone woods1 out ( all relation ) m51 & "o br\ght up 9 a civiliz$ community1 is inf9ite4 ,! l[] animals get all !y ev] get by bir?4 ,no new gifts or p[]s come to !m ?r\gh companion%ip4 ,!y g un]r+ly to a c]ta9 de/9$ end1 :e!r !y move 9 flocks or h]ds1 or alone z individuals4 ,m51 on ! o!r h&1 f9d !mselves by com+ toge!r4 ,_! organs sleep till wak$ by relation4 ,by bir? !y c get no?+ b ! g]ms1 ! m]e nak$ elem5ts ( :at !y are to become4 ,bir? w\ld be no bless+1 b a deep5+ curse1 b = :at comes to ! *ild ?r\gh relation4 ,bir?right alone is n wor? a mess ( pottage4 ,m5 (t5 congratulate !mselves on :at !y are pleas$ to t]m _! individual rights & p]sonal fre$om4 ,:ile m5 d h individual rights & p]sonal fre$om1 x is always to be rememb]$ t ^! belong to !m because ( ! relations wov5 ar\nd !m by ! in/itutions ( social life4 ,! civiliz$ man diff]s m f ! savage1 ?an ! savage diff]s f ! highe/ animal4 ,yet ! l[e/ savage is inf9itely remov$ f ! highe/ animal1 b solely 9 ! possession ( ! g]ms ( ! atta9m5ts & ! accompli%m5ts :i* may be provok$ & ma9ta9$ by relation4 ,society alone furni%es ! soil 9 :i* ^! g]ms c gr[4 ,! savage1 alone 9 ! woods1 might secure = himself a cov]+ ( sk9s1 b ! clo? 9 :i* ! civiliz$ man clo!s himself is possible only 9 social relations4 ,) ! comm5cem5t ( human relations1 ! outl9es ( an absolutely new _w come into view4 ,dim & vague at ! outset1 z ! relations are simple & l[4 ,b z ^! increase 9 numb]1 range1 & degree1 n only ! outl9es1 b ! f>-rea*+ surface1 ! m\nta9s1 ! riv]s1 ! products1 ! sky1 & ! climate ( a new _w /& out cle>1 def9ite1 & unmi/akable4 ,?is new realm we "n civilization4 ,x is sup]-impos$ ^u ! physical _w1 b is z di/9ct f x z ?\ght f ! molecules ( ! bra94 ,nature furni%es ! basis1 b social relations furni% ! conditions ( ! human en]gy t has lift$ itself into ! mighty edifice we call civilization4 ,all g5]a & species & families & individuals are s _m =ms 9 :i* ! radiant en]gy ( ! sun has deposit$ itself4 ,play+ ) its heat & its light ^u soil1 sea1 & sky1 ! sun has built ! myriad organic =ms we see4 ,s all objects1 int]e/s1 & laws embrac$ )9 ! range ( civilization are ! =ms 9 :i* social =ce1 aris+ ?r\gh relations1 has deposit$ itself4 ,human language itself is an embodim5t ( social =ce4 ,! gramm>s ( diff]5t languages actually adv]tise ! social /atus & condition ( ! peoples :o us$ !m4 ,9 ! ,*9ese language we h no di/9ction z to p>ts ( spee*1 ?us %[+ t ! national consci\sness 0 arre/$ at ! /age ( pat]nalism 9 gov]nm5t4 ,! anci5t ,romans put enorm\s /ress ^u ! w4 ,!y =mulat$ ! laws by :i* m5 are /ill regulat$ 9 civiliz$ social life4 ,a h9t ( ?is we get 9 ! ,lat9 language1 by ! small use made ( ! pron\n4 ,ideas1 too1 are expressions ( translat$ social en]gy4 ,no?+ seems to be m insulat$ ?an ! human bra91 by ! aid ( :i* ! m9d does its ?9k+4 ,out ( sight & out ( t\*1 )9 ! d>k dep?s ( its own my/]i\s home1 x w\ld appe> to be %ut up to absolute solitude4 ,"h1 at lea/1 we w\ld expect to f9d individual1 indep5d5t "w4 ,b n s4 ,no individual bra9 c ?9k1 only z x uses ! bra9s ( o!rs 9 ! process4 ,hom]'s ,iliad is a poetic =mulation ( :at all ,greece felt4 ,! elem5ts ( my?1 ?\ght1 passion1 :i* x conta9s1 7 all 9 ! contempor>y ,greek m9d4 ,9 committ+ ?is poem to memory1 ! ,greeks 7 b /or+ up _! own ?\ghts4 ,hegel1 9 ?9k+ out 8 rem>kable sy/em ( philosophy1 us$ ! bra9s ( all ! m5 :o _h prec$$ him 9 ! difficult "w ( solv+ ! problems ( exi/5ce4 ,d>w9 saw mu* 9 nature1 because1 ?r\gh relation1 he 0 able to look ?r\gh ! eyes ( all naturali/s4 ,all values1 :e!r 9 soil1 wat]falls1 preci\s /ones1 or money1 are =ms ( social =ce4 ,l& 9 a great city sells = two ?\s& doll>s a front foot1 because millions ( p1 drawn by ! p[]s ( comm]ce1 h come into fell[%ip ^u x4 ,rob9son ,crusoe w\ld h giv5 all ! money he _h on ! %ip = a loaf ( bread4 ,! heaps ( gold & silv] 9 ,wall ,/reet are s valuable1 because sev5ty millions ( p are circulat+ ar\nd !m4 ,moral laws are social products4 ,!y are n empirical1 b fundam5tal1 et]nal1 & ess5tial4 ,!y inh]e 9 ! con/itution ( man4 ,b x is only ?r\gh relation t man comes to ! recognition ( !m1 z b9d+ = conduct4 ,light & heat h _! laws1 def9ite & unfail+1 b if natural p>ticles nev] vibrat$ at a rate suffici5t to create ^! =ces1 ! laws w\ld n appe>4 ,!y arise along ) ! =ces1 & ! same conditions :i* give rise to ! =ces1 give rise to ! laws4 ,s moral laws accompany a c]ta9 degree ( atta9m5t & culture1 only possible ?r\gh relation4 ,religion itself1 ! highe/ & mo/ sacr$ deposit ( human life1 is a product ( social =ce4 ,:e!r we reg>d x z 8modes ( emotion10 z ,lecky2 or ! 8recognition ( all our duties z div9e comm&s10 z ,kant2 or z 8awe 9 ! pres5ce ( ! my/]y ( an inscrutable p[] 9 ! univ]se10 z ,sp5c]2 or z 8! inf9ite nature ( duty10 z ,mill2 or z 8! imm$iate feel+ ( ! dep5d5ce ( man on ,god10 z ,s*lei]ma*]1 x nev] arises outside ! range ( relation4 ,/ill1 religion is some?+ con/itutional1 inali5able1 div9e2 b man w\ld nev] be ?rill$ by its hopes1 or soo!d by its peace1 did he n /& 9 vital relation to 8 fell[s4 ,! elem5ts & raw mat]ial ( religion are et]nally pres5t1 b relation calls into ex]cise ! susceptibilities & faculties :i* appropriate ^! elem5ts & raw mat]ial1 turn+ !m into hymns1 !ologies1 pray]s1 sacrifices1 liturgies1 & c]emonies4 ,comm]ce1 by br++ m5 toge!r "u ! necessities ( f9d+ food1 clo?+1 %elt]1 enables !m to f9d _! intellects & :at !y c "k1 _! he>ts & :at !y c love1 & _! wills & :at !y c d4 ,?us we trace ! g5esis ( social =ce1 ) ! expressions :i* x makes ( itself1 9 prop]ty1 lit]ature1 law1 art1 & religion1 to mutual human relations1 = ! e/abli%m5t ( :i*1 among m51 ,comm]ce seems to h be5 orda9$4 ,if m5 c\ld1 )\t trad+1 h f\nd ! means ( subsi/5ce1 z d ! foxes & ! lions2 !n no relations 9 ! high s5se ( ! t]m w\ld h be5 e/abli%$ among !m2 & l ! foxes & ! lions1 !y w\ld h rema9$ on ! e>? )\t progress & )\t hi/ory4 ,! sun mu/ be mak+ trem5d\s drafts ^u "s unse5 s\rces ( p[]1 to be able to make1 ?r\gh\t ! sol> realm1 su* ample exp5ditures ( en]gy )\t bankruptcy4 ,! location ( ! va/ depositories ( p[]1 ^u :i* he draws s lib]ally1 we are n to inquire "h4 ,we d "k t ! =ce :i* builds ! =e/1 flu%es ! mead[s ) gre51 braids ! v9es into fe/oons1 & peoples ! plant-_w1 comes f ! sun4 ,:]ev] ! mat]ials :i* keep ! sun's fires burn+ come f1 !y mu/ pass up to t c5t] be=e !y are available = s]vice on ?is globe4 ,! /amp & sup]scription ( ! sun mu/ be ^u !m be=e !y c take ! =m ( grass1 or leaf1 or bird on ! e>?4 ,9 ?is s5se /& human relations betwe5 ! =ce conta9$ 9 ! individual1 unrelat$ life1 & ! =ce :i* takes =m 9 ! objects ( civilization4 ,! crude & in>ticulate =ce 9 ! individuals ( ! tribe1 or ! nomads :o only t\* = w> or passion1 mu/ be ref9$ ?r\gh moral1 political1 & spiritual relations be=e x is ready to take ! =m ( poem1 an!m1 temple1 or ,plato4 ,,ii4 ,we wi% to det]m9e ! pr9ciple 9 accordance ) :i* ! production & di/ribution ( food1 %elt]1 & clo?+ are to be regulat$4 ,^! =ms ( value are embodim5ts ( social en]gy1 g5]at$ ?r\gh relations =m$ above nature by intellig5ce & volition4 ,9 nature1 !n1 we are n to f9d ! law t is to regulate !m4 ,bees build _! cells1 & birds _! ne/s1 & beav]s _! dams1 n by intellig5ce & w1 call$ into exi/5ce aft] bir? ?r\gh companion%ip1 b by :at is 9-wr\ght into ! v fib]s ( _! be+ irrespective ( companion%ip4 ,birds1 bees1 & beav]s h be5 9 ! _w ?\s&s ( ye>s1 yet ! fir/ bird1 bee1 or beav] ev] creat$ _h z mu* s5se z ! la/4 ,a s+le bee has z mu* s5se z all ! bees 9 ! _w put toge!r4 ,among all l[] animals ea* individual inh]its ! s5se ( ! species4 ,h5ce ! law 8( ! /ruggle = exi/5ce10 result+ 9 8! survival ( ! fitte/10 said to be a regulat+ pr9ciple 9 ! plant & animal k+doms1 is n sev]e1 reg>d$ ) ref]5ce to ! individuals :i* inhabit !m4 ,b to reg>d ! op]ations ( ?is law z b5efic5t ^u ! plane ( human life1 z does ,mr4 ,sp5c]1 is altoge!r to ov]look ! obligations m5 are "u to "o ano!r1 because ( _! mutual relations4 ,! life ( ea* man1 x mu/ be rememb]$1 9 s f> z x is above t ( ! unrelat$ savage1 is conta9$ 9 ! life ( e o!r man4 ,9 s f> z x is com=table1 intellig5t1 & free1 x has be5 br\ght to him1 & made ov] to him by 8 fell[-man4 ,! law :i* is to det]m9e ! regulation ( ! elem5ts ( comm]ce1 :i* are b expressions ( ! en]gy aris+ ?r\gh mutual human relations1 mu/ be z elevat$ z ! relations :i* comm]ce begets1 & :i* 9 turn make comm]ce possible4 ,we mu/ n g d[n among ! tig]s & ! hy5as1 :o owe no?+ b b>e bir? to companion%ip1 :]e ! pr9ciple ( 8! survival ( ! fitte/ 9 ! /ruggle = exi/5ce0 does prevail1 to get ! law :i* is to regulate ! production & di/ribution ( products possible only ?r\gh companion%ip4 ,ea* individual1 be he weak or /rong1 has contribut$ some?+ to ! social body4 ,! /r5g? ( ! "o may h contribut$ c\rage1 ! weakness ( ! o!r may h call$ =? pity2 b bo? pity & c\rage are virtues possible only 9 relation4 ,a regulat+ pr9ciple t kills (f ! feeble ones1 & drives ! weak ones to ! wall1 may d = brutes1 :o owe no?+ to relation%ips2 b n = m51 :o owe ev]y?+ to !m4 ,! attempt to regulate =ms ( value 9 accordance ) ! law ( 8! survival ( ! fitte/ 9 ! /ruggle = exi/5ce0 does n h suffici5t reg>d = ! contribution ea* individual has made1 by ! v fact ( 8 exi/5ce1 to make ^! values possible4 ,! lead+ political economi/s ( ! times h come to see t ! law ( extreme individualism1 ( 8e man = himself & ! devil take ! h9dmo/10 mu/ be sub/itut$ by "s m b5efic5t pr9ciple--by "s law t pays m respect to ! me?ods by :i* values h be5 creat$4 ,! prov9ce ( comm]ce1 z an in/itution1 is to br+ m5 toge!r1 n m]ely t ! b\nd>ies ( comm]ce may be ext5d$ & its volume increas$1 b t m5 may le>n ! mutual obligations !y are "u to "o ano!r1 t _! sympa?y = "o ano!r may be enl>g$1 & t respect = "o ano!r may be eng5d]$4 ,x is only 9 an atmosph]e ( mutual tru/1 sympa?y1 & respect t m5 c gr[4 ,! ne$ = bread1 = protection1 = raim5t1 prompts m5 to ! ex*ange ( products1 t ea* may %>e into ! "w ( all4 ,b 9 ! process ( ex*ang+ products1 relations are e/abli%$1 ?r\gh ! influ5ce & p[] ( :i* an ord] ( man comes ! m]e mat]ial com=ts ( life _c supply4 ,! significance ( comm]ce1 !n1 is n und]/ood1 if x is consid]$ simply ) ref]5ce to its imm$iate ends4 ,^! ends are met :5 m5 are suppli$ ) ! mat]ial com=ts ( life4 ,ends1 h[ev]1 are m$iat$ ?r\gh x ( a k9d diff]5t 9 ord] & degree4 ,^! we consid] ! ess5tial & ultimate ends ( ! relations :i* are e/abli%$ ?r\gh ! ex*ange ( products4 ,:at1 !n1 is ! ultimate end & object ( human relations8 ,x is man4 ,man come to himself1 consci\s ( himself1 9 possession ( himself4 ,x is human life1 enri*$1 p]fect$1 complet$4 ,x is man1 /rong1 free1 holy4 ,x is man1 n lo/ 9 ! social texture1 nor swamp$ 9 ! social organism2 b1 f9d+ 8 individuality & 8 peculi>1 natural1 simple self ?r\gh !m4 ,! m>vel\s fabric ! social loom 0 set to weav+ is man4 ,! highe/ end ( social relations is a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+ man1 ?9k+ ! true1 will+ ! "r1 lov+ ! good4 ,^! relations con/itute ! organism out ( :i* alone he c be born into symmetrical1 well r\nd$ life4 ,! l[] animals come f natural bir? into ! _w entire & complete4 ,! "y eaglet is correlat$ to ! sky be=e he leaves ! egg4 ,b man moves on a plane l[] ?an ! brutes1 if he is n caught at bir? & c>ri$ by relation to 8 prop] place4 ,z man is ! highe/ product ( social relations1 x foll[s t ! highe/ product is ! ultimate product4 ,an apple tree may be us$ = fire wood1 or sawn into planks1 b apples are ! ultimate reasons = ! exi/5ce ( ! apple tree4 ,t[>d an apple ! g]m />t$ :5 x bur/ ! sod & /ood a little sprig above ! gr\nd4 ,beyond ! apple1 ! tree goes no fur!r4 ,x ?r[s its roots into ! e>? & its bran*es into ! atmosph]e1 & p]petually acts & reacts ^u its environm5t1 b all = ! purpose ( turn+ soil1 & sun%9e1 & ra9 into apples4 ,z we h se51 a "p ( ! social en]gy aris+ ?r\gh mutual human relations is to be conv]t$ into language1 values1 lit]ature1 morality1 & religion1 z a "p ( ! capital inve/$ 9 a sew+ ma*9e factory goes into tools4 ,b man is great] ?an language1 values1 lit]ature1 morality1 or religion2 z ! sew+ ma*9e is great] ?an ! tools by :i* x is made4 ,human relations create language1 values1 art1 morality1 & religion1 t !y may be us$ to advance & p]fect ! ma9 "w !y 7 orda9$ to p]=m1 8! mak+ ( a man40 ,:5 ! p ( a nation come to reg>d ! elem5ts ( weal?1 lit]ature1 art1 or ev5 religion1 z ends to be enjoy$ r ?an z means to make man1 !y h miss$ ! purpose ( creation1 & w&] amid ! mazes ( /upidity & bl9dness4 ,z f> z outw>d spl5dor & weal? 7 conc]n$1 ,babylon _h no rival among ! nations ( anci5t times4 ,%e 0 a va/ & ri* empire4 ,%e embrac$ ! mo/ f]tile portion ( ! globe4 ,%e _h a capital t eclips$ all o!rs 9 magnific5ce4 ,h] hang+ g>d5s 7 ! wond] ( ! _w2 b h] p /ood n ^u _! t]races to obs]ve ! />s1 or to rea* a high] civilization ?r\gh ! realization ( ! nobl] ends ( _! be+4 ,^! 7 us$ z places ( revelry & s5sual enjoym5t4 ,?us ! only "w ( art t made !m fam\s 0 us$ to make !m /upid & deprav$4 ,( h] weal? %e made an end4 ,putt+ no e/imate ^u m51 ?r\gh ! relations ( :om h] weal? 0 creat$1 %e f\nd at la/ t among all h] p %e _h produc$ no man amply end[$ en\gh to give p]man5t m5tal sett+ to h] civilization & h] fai?4 ,h] he>t ?robs1 :atev] !y 71 got expla9$ 9 no hi/ory1 int]pret$ 9 no philosophy1 & liv$ 9 no life4 ,= k ( h]1 we are dep5d5t ^u h] ru9s1 h] pott]y1 h] brok5 columns4 ,into oblivion has fall5 all t bejewel$ & pamp]$ life t revel$ 9 h] palaces & amid h] f>-fam$ hang+ g>d5s4 ,among none ( h] luxuri\s inhabitants did %e develop a man to commit ! keep+ ( h] secrets & ! record ( h] progress4 ,ov] h] hi/ory has settl$ ! /illness ( ! des]t & ! gloom ( et]nal night4 ,on ! o!r h&1 h[ secure is ! ,greece1 t fl[]$ 9 h] great m56 ,x 0 9 ! two c5turies betwe5 #ejj & #cjj ,b4 ,c41 :5 %e emphasiz$ m5 m ?an ! ?+s !y creat$1 t %e produc$ ! m5 :o h be5 ! tea*]s ( ! human race4 ,%e has be5 despoil$ ( h] art treasures1 h] temples h fall51 h] ,p>!non is 9 ru9s2 b ! two hundr$ ye>s ( h] life1 :i* %e deposit$ 9 h] great m51 are immortal4 ,no too? ( "t1 no w>'s bloody h&1 no deva/ation ( ! ye>s1 c take f h] ! glory :i* %e lift$ & lock$ 9 ! g5ius ( h] g5]als1 h] /atesm51 h] orators1 & h] philosoph]s4 ,epam9ondas & ,p]icles /ill fight = h]1 & gu>d ) sleepless vigilance h] fair "n4 ,plato & ,ari/otle /ill int]pret h] problems ( de/9y4 ,sophocles & ,p9d> /ill s+ h] glory4 ,h]odotus & ,?ucydides /ill keep ! record ( h] victories4 ,demo/h5es & s*9es /ill give imp]i%able expression to h] conceptions ( =m & symmetry4 ,%e deposit$ h] ri*es 9 ! spirits ( h] great m51 & !y are =ev] secure4 ,no ?ief c /eal !m1 no ru/ c corrupt !m4 ,! unfold+ c5turies may look 9 ^u !m & enjoy !m1 b !y _c arre/ !m4 ,! spirits ( great m51 l immortal %ips1 sail ! ocean ( "t1 be>+ ! treasures ( ! civilizations :i* gave !m bir?4 ,!y outride ! fury ( all ! /orms1 & w sail on1 till ,! />s gr[ old1 ,! sun gr[s cold1 ,& ! leaves ( ! ,judgm5t book unfold4 ,b :5 ,greece came to ?9k m ( ! results ?an ( ! liv+ m51 %e lo/ n only ! p[] to produce ! m51 b ! capacity to appreciate ! results :i* _h be5 creat$ by !m4 ,?9k+ m ( ! temple ?an ! build]1 %e soon _h no ar*itect to conceive1 & no son to und]/& ! temple4 ,turn+ h] national p[] into ! spirits ( h] liv+ m51 %e utiliz$ ! m\nta9s & ! m9es 9 ! s]vice ( beauty4 ,b :5 life got *eap] ?an art1 %e no long] _h p[] to create new art1 or to protect f v&alism ! old4 ,by remov+ ! emphasis f m5 to ?+s1 %e desc5d$ f ! ,crsus to ! paup] ( civilization4 ,z long z ,israel exp5d$ h] national en]gy 9 ! production ( m51 %e _h ,moses1 great] ?an ! ,tab]nacle2 ,david1 great] ?an 8 h>p2 & ,isaiah1 great] ?an 8 song4 ,b :5 ! =ms ( h] wor%ip 7 emphasiz$ beyond ! spirits ( h] p %e lo/ ! devotion :i* creat$ h] *ur* & ! manhood t guid$ x4 ,! m5 :o =mulat$ ! laws t made ,rome ! mi/ress ( ! _w1 grew at a p]iod :5 a ,roman 0 ! c5t] ( int]e/ 9 ! empire4 ,b :5 h] laws 7 /ress$ to ! oblit]ation ( h] m51 %e _h !m /ill1 )\t ! ability to make m laws1 or to execute ! ones %e _h4 ,religion 9 ,india is emphasiz$ m ?an "*2 h5ce h] m5 are lo/ 9 a wanton & luxuri\s surr5d] to a modeless1 transc5d5tal1 pure be+1 & %e is practically )\t a hi/ory4 ,,iii4 ,! ultimate reasons1 !n1 = ! exi/5ce ( social relations1 br\ght ab\t among human be+s by ex*ange ( products1 is n ! satisfaction ( hung]1 or ! enri*m5t ( individuals 9 mat]ial weal?1 b ! mak+ ( m54 ,?is be+ s1 we are able to det]m9e ! law by :i* ! production & di/ribution ( comm]cial products are to be regulat$4 ,x mu/ be a law t does n put ! emphasis on ! products1 b ^u ! m5 :o are to be elevat$ ?r\gh _! ex*ange4 ,x mu/ n be a law lean+ to extreme individualism on ! "o side1 or to extreme socialism on ! o!r4 ,x mu/ h prop] respect to ! individual1 & to ! social organism to :i* he is indebt$ = :atev] ( p[] he possesses4 ,t law has already be5 =mulat$ = u4 ,x is ?is3 8,?\ %alt love ?y neighbor z ?yself40 ,?is is ! coord9ation ( self-love & good-w4 ,z has be5 well said1 ?is saves = u ! /r5g? ( private ent]prise1 & individual initiative1 ! vigor ( ! self-reg>d+ motives2 yet en?rones by _! side z co-equal & co-reg5t p[]s1 ! pr9ciple ( b5evol5ce1 ! obligation to promote ! common weal4 ,self-support1 self-help1 self-reliance1 are /ill c>d9al virtues1 b philan?ropy is giv5 co-ord9ate au?ority ) !m 9 ! comm]cial _w4 ,?is is ! law mo/ favorable to ! gr[? ( m54 ,"u its b5ign reign1 m5 c come to !mselves4 ,?r\gh ! op]ation ( ?is law1 !re w be no curtailm5t ( ! volume or ! ext5t ( comm]ce2 b ! emphasis w be kept 9 ! "r place1 & m5 w n be lo/ 9 ! process ( secur+ ! elem5ts ( food & %elt]4 ,comm]ce w be ! means ( m$iat+ to m5 _! high] nature4 ,surr\nd$ by conditions eng5d]$ by ! op]ation ( a law l ?is1 life w rea* ?r\gh relation high] & high] ranges ( hope & insight4 ,! elem5ts ( poems1 symphonies1 philosophies1 temples1 & pictures w fl[ 9 ! blood4 ,! fi]ce competition we see 9 ! comm]cial _w to-day is ! attempt to re-enact1 9 bus9ess life1 ! pr9ciple ( natural selection1 or 8! survival ( ! fitte/ 9 ! /ruggle = exi/5ce40 ,?is is ! law ( ! jungle1 b n ( ! social realm4 ,?is is d\btless ! law among trees1 det]m9+ _! numb]1 v>iety1 & /ructure2 = "o tree ga9s no?+ f association ) o!r trees4 ,?is law d\btless op]ates 9 ! sea1 among ! fi%1 & 9 ! sky among ! birds1 = fi% & birds are :at !y are by bir? & n by association4 ,mr4 ,sp5c] reg>ds ! op]ation ( ?is law z b5efic5t4 ,x kills (f ! unsuccessful memb]s ( society1 x drives ! weak ones to ! wall4 ,^? :o survive 9 ! /ruggle are ! fitte/4 ,! ,greeks1 :o put ,socrates to dea?1 71 accord+ to ?is s-call$ b5efic5t pr9ciple1 ! fitte/ to survive4 ,?is law is reg>d$ z b5efic5t z x op]ates among m5 to control _! products1 ^u ! supposition t man is an animal & a "p & p>cel ( nature1 z are ! be>s & ! wolves4 ,! ?+s :i* elevate m5 & civilize !m1 h[ev]1 d n come f nature1 b are eng5d]$ ?r\gh companion%ip & association4 ,h5ce1 f ! s5se ( obligation m5 are "u to "o ano!r = ! be/ & highe/ ?+s ( life1 ! law is to be d$uc$ :i* is to regulate _! comm]ce & to det]m9e ! "* ( _! actions4 ,?is law is1 8,?\ %alt love ?y neighbor z ?yself40 ,?us bus9ess looks to "*4 ,! discipl9e x insures is wor? m ?an ! money x br+s4 ,! highe/ product ( trade is man himself4 ,if 9 bus9ess su* me?ods are practic$1 if su* aims are foll[$ z de/roy ! man1 h[ev] great ! returns 9 money1 x is a ?\s& fold worse ?an a failure4 ,! man x 0 design$ to make1 x has de/roy$4 ,,iv4 ,! disposition to accumulate1 :i* is "r & praisewor?y1 %\ld always be modifi$ by "r k ( ! uses ( prop]ty1 & ! me?ods by :i* x is amass$4 ,no?+ is m pitiable ?an = a p]son to h m prop]ty ?an he has manhood4 ,?is indicates t ! /ress has be5 on ! wrong side ( ! weal?4 ,su* a man is "u ! sad necessity ( tak+ 8 significance f ! money he has accumulat$1 r ?an ! noble elem5ts ( life he %\ld h secur$ 9 ! process ( obta9+ x4 ,) su* a man1 ! end ( bus9ess has be5 lo/4 ,he has consum$ ! end 9 ! means4 ,in/ead ( turn+ ! elem5ts ( trade into manhood1 manhood has be5 lo/ amid ! maze & *aos ( ?+s4 ,! ord] ( progress has be5 violat$1 & ! man1 in/ead ( mov+ on ?r\gh bus9ess c>es to immortal "*1 turns back to ! e>?1 & seeks to sub/itute ! t5d5cy to move f x1 by ! disposition to settle p]man5tly ^u x4 ,! desire to get ri* has gr[n s abnormal & p]v]t$1 t x seeks to satisfy itself by ! abundance ( m]e ?+s4 ,!re are a great numb] ( m[]s & reap]s1 eng9es & cotton-g9s1 hats & %oes1 p9s & buttons2 b a man has be5 lo/ 9 ! mak+ ( !m4 ,?is is m ?an all ! m[]s & reap]s1 cotton-g9s & /eam eng9es1 p9s & buttons ev] made are wor?4 ,x is n mete t m5 %\ld be sacrific$ to ! beauty & p]fection ( ma*9]y1 or to ?+s ma*9]y turns out4 ,x is n necess>y ei!r4 ,:at we ga9 is n wor? :at we give4 ,! ma*9]y %\ld be s manipulat$ z to get ! ?+s1 & at ! same "t secure ! p]fection ( m5 ?r\gh ! process4 ,x is n necess>y = ! pa9t] to lose himself 9 8 art1 & sacrifice 8 manhood to make 8 vision gl[ on ! canvas4 ,a prop] reg>d = ! me?ods & uses ( art w result 9 leav+ 9 ! liv+ _s a picture m p]fect ?an any pa9t$ by ! bru%4 ,john ,bunyan did n lose 8 manhood 9 portray+ ! hi/ory ( a human s\l 9 its attempts to get f e>? to heav54 ,:ile conduct+ 8 pilgrim safely ?r\gh ! sorr[ & temptations ( life1 to a home 9 a bett] _w1 he op5$ ! pe>ly gates to 8 own s\l4 ,8 "w transfigur$ 8 life1 & 0 ! means ( sanctify+ x4 ,all bus9ess & all "w %\ld lift up1 & n hold d[n2 x %\ld make free1 & n enslave2 x %\ld ennoble & n degrade4 ,x is z honorable to make %oes or an*ors z to pa9t pictures or write books4 ,! %oemak] %\ld le>n ! secret ?r\gh 8 "w ( f9d+ ! s&als ( manhood = 8 own feet4 ,! blacksmi? %\ld le>n1 ?r\gh ! mak+ ( an*ors = ! great %ips1 to f9d ! an*or t is to hold 8 own s\l to ! tru?1 amid ! /orms ( life4 ,v4 ,if ?r\gh trade only ! mat]ial result is s\ght1 ! ends x 7 int5d$ to subs]ve are miss$4 ,its bulk may be l>ge1 ! ma*9]y ?r\gh :i* x is c>ri$ on manifold & complicat$1 b ) ! emphasis on ! money side ( x1 no manhood w be rea*$ ?r\gh x4 ,! man side ( a button ma*9e is inf9itely m important ?an ! button side4 ,! buttons :i* fall on "o side may con=m precisely to an approv$ & an exquisite patt]n1 b if ! p]son :o /&s on ! o!r side does n1 ?r\gh ! process ( mak+ buttons1 get a man out ( himself1 ! :ole ?+ is a disa/r\s failure4 ,human spirits are too valuable to be us$ up 9 mak+ buttons4 ,m respect is to be _h to ! human side ( ! loom ?an to ! clo? side4 ,! mo/ beautiful patt]n ( silk ev] wov5 loses its p[] to please ! eye :5 x is rememb]$ t ! s\l ( a woman has be5 drawn into its ?reads & colors4 ,! sacrifice ( individual life is impressive & noble1 if ! object = :i* x is made is wor?y4 ,?is k9d ( sacrifice is n ! means ( los+ life1 b ( ga9+ x4 ,b no mat]ial result to be us$ up 9 ! pass+ season ( fa%ion is wor? su* co/ly sacrifice4 ,?r\gh =ces we "n capill>ity1 cohesion1 & gravitation1 matt] accompli%es ! purposes ( ?\ght4 ,!y are b manife/ations ( ! p[] ( m9d work+ ?r\gh !m1 to build up ! m9]al1 vegetable1 & animal k+doms4 ,!y look beyond !mselves4 ,!y "w = high] ends4 ,?us all ! indu/ries we see 9 nature look to lift+ & ref9+ matt]1 & =ce high en\gh to s]ve ! uses ( human life4 ,s ! indu/ries e/abli%$ on ! plane ( human life are to elevate man ano!r /ep 9 ! scale ( be+4 ,?r\gh s[+ & reap+1 ?r\gh gr9d+ & saw+1 ?r\gh sp9n+ & weav+1 ?r\gh buy+ & sell+1 ?r\gh build+ & furni%+1 he is to be c>ri$ on 9 ! m>* ( progress4 ,! hi/ory ( ! physical univ]se culm9ates 9 man1 f9ds its int]pret] & its int]pretation 9 him4 ,nev] 0 ! ?\ght ( him abs5t f h] movem5ts ?r\gh ,plioc5e1 ,mioc5e1 ,eoc5e1 ,cretace\s1 ,jurassic1 ,triassic1 ,c>bonif]\s1 ,devonian1 ,silurian1 or ,cambrian ages4 ,9 all h] awful cosmic emotion to rea* ord] & =m1 x 0 ! anticipation ( man t mov$ h]1 = he x is at la/ t comes ( x4 ,s1 ?r\gh all ! c\rse ( h] tumultu\s hi/ory1 nature 0 pregnant ) man4 ,! />s :i* sang toge!r 9 ! e>ly morn+ ( ! _w1 caught ! inspiration :i* gave melody to _! song f ! ?\ght ( him4 ,comm]ce1 if x is to be p]man5t & heal?y & progressive1 mu/ fall into l9e ) ! purpose nature 0 put ^u its p]il\s c\rse to subs]ve4 ,h] c\ntless =ms ( indu/ry e/abli%$ by ! law ( supply & dem&2 h] c>s1 ru%+ hi!r & ?i!r all r\nd ! _w2 h] great /eam%ips on e sea2 h] great furnaces1 ^: *imneys lift !mselves aga9/ ! sky1 mu/ get _! mean+ & ! reason = _! exi/5ce f ! fact t !y are putt+ 9 _! contribution to ! mak+ ( a man4 ,h] :eels are to fly1 h] sp9dles are to :irl1 h] paddles are to spla%1 & h] hamm]s are to r+1 mak+ music amid x all1 9 anticipation ( 8 increas+ wor?1 8 gr[+ ?\ght1 8 enl>g+ hope4 ,h] c\ntless :eels ( indu/ry w be ?r[+ out axes1 wagons1 pl[-/ocks1 h&-saws1 & reap]s z !y fly2 b ^! w be only s _m means us$ to discipl9e ! preci\s life committ$ = a :ile to h] tra9+4 ,:at *emical aff9ity did 9 lift+ ! orig9al elem5ts to ! m9]al k+dom1 & :at ! animal did to lift ! plant to ! animal k+dom1 s ! trades & indu/ries ( comm]ce are to d 9 lift+ human life f its individual1 unrelat$ /ate to its social & frat]nal /ate4 ,! elem5ts ( comm]ce are to be ! means to help human "* out ( human nature4 ,two k9ds ( raw mat]ial are to be ref9$4 ,! iron 9 ! m\nta9 is to be turn$ into razor blades & caligraphs2 ! re$s 9 ! swamps & ! woods 9 ! =e/s are to be turn$ into ! notes ( organ & piano2 & 9 ! process ( ref9+ ^!1 man is to be discipl9$ 9 ! use ( himself1 9 ! possession ( himself1 & 9 ! comm& ( himself4 ,,p[]4 8,excessive devotion to ! mat]ial is ! evil ( our epo*2 h5ce a c]ta9 sluggi%ness4 8,! great problem is to re/ore to ! human m9d some?+ ( ! ideal4 ,:5ce %all we draw ! ideal8 ,:]ev] x is to be f\nd4 ,! poets1 ! philosoph]s1 ! ?9k]s1 are its urns4 8,! ideal is 9 s*ylus1 9 ,isaiah1 9 ,juv5al1 9 ,alighi]i1 9 ,%aksp]e4 ,?r[ s*ylus1 ?r[ ,isaiah1 ?r[ ,juv5al1 ?r[ ,dante1 ?r[ ,%aksp]e into ! deep s\l ( ! human race4 8,p\r ,job1 ,solomon1 ,p9d>1 ,ezekiel1 ,sophocles1 ,euripides1 ,h]odotus1 ,!ocritus1 ,plautus1 ,lucretius1 ,virgil1 ,t]5ce1 ,horace1 ,catulus1 ,tacitus1 ,sa9t ,paul1 ,sa9t ,augu/9e1 ,t]tullian1 ,petr>*1 ,pascal1 ,milton1 ,desc>tes1 ,corneille1 ,la ,fonta9e1 ,montesquieu1 ,did]ot1 ,beaum>*ais1 ,s$a9e1 ,&r ,*5i]1 ,kant1 ,s*ill]--p\r all ^! s\ls into man40 ,,*apt] ,,ii4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,social ,,nature ,,( ,,man4 ,i4 ,man has a body & a _s4 ,by ! "o1 he is individual2 by ! o!r1 he is social4 ,z individual1 he ne$s bread2 z social1 he ne$s p[]4 ,z body1 he is born f ! lo9s2 z _s1 he is born f ! social organism4 ,9 ! process ( f9d+ food1 clo?+1 %elt]1 to meet ! ne$s ( himself z individual1 he discov]s t illimitable social side ( himself ! mat]ial necessities ( life d n supply4 ,"h he f9ds p[]1 a m subtle & univ]sal elem5t1 ready to s]ve 8 high] ne$4 ,?is is ! provision = ! social side ( man's nature2 =1 z individual1 he does n ne$ x1 & c\ld n appropriate & use x if he did4 ,z an individual1 he c only avail himself ( ! use ( p[]1 ?r\gh ! attempt ( ! social :ole ( :i* he =ms a memb]4 ,9 ! primitive1 unrelat$1 unorganiz$ /ate1 man is satisfi$ if he c secure food to satisfy 8 hung]1 & a cave to %elt] him f ! /orm4 ,he does n ev5 utilize ! w9ds to draw 8 boat1 until1 ?r\gh int]dep5d5ce & mutual relations1 he has rea*$ a high degree ( social life4 ,! s]vants ( man1 on 8 individual side1 are ! foods ( ! field1 ! wat]s ( ! spr+1 ! woods ( ! =e/1 ! fruits ( ! or*>d1 & ! wool on ! %eep's back4 ,! s]vants ( man1 on 8 social side1 are ! driv+ p[] ( ! w9ds1 ! transport+ p[] ( heat1 & ! ?\ght-defy+ p[] ( ! lightn+4 ,z individual1 he is a citiz5 ( ! community :]e he fir/ sees ! light4 ,z social1 he is a citiz5 ( ! _w4 ,?r\gh 8 body1 he is naturally relat$ to 8 ance/ors2 ?r\gh 8 _s1 he is relat$ to ! human race4 ,! rude elem5ts ( food1 clo?+1 & %elt]1 he might secure z individual2 b p[]1 :i* waits to s]ve 8 high]1 nobl] nature1 he c only secure ?r\gh society4 ,z individual1 he is n>r[1 meag]1 local4 ,z social1 he is broad1 ri*1 univ]sal4 ,on 8 individual side1 he is c5tripetal2 on 8 social side1 c5trifugal4 ,self-c5t]$1 self-conta9$1 & self-includ$1 on ! "o side2 :ile1 ^u ! o!r1 he is possess$ ( ! conviction t private "r mu/ be subord9at$ to public good4 ,te!r$ to ! e>? on ! "o side1 l9k$ ) ! imm5sities on ! o!r4 ,on ! "o side1 8 outlook is h>d & lit]al & l[2 on ! o!r1 he seeks1 ?r\gh intellect1 to transc5d ! inf9ite 9 "t & space & tru?4 ,on ! side ( himself1 z individual1 he kn[s no "r or wrong4 ,on ! side ( himself1 z social1 he recognizes ! inf9ite 9 duty1 & seeks h>mony ?r\gh ! inf9ite 9 love4 ,,ii4 ,yet ?is limit$ & unlimit$ self2 transitory1 p]i%able1 & f9ite on ! "o side2 ev]la/+1 imp]i%able1 & inf9ite on ! o!r1 are b\nd toge!r 9 ! same p]son4 ,! fall ( ! "o is accompani$ by ! desc5t ( ! o!r1 & ! rise ( ! "o is accompani$ by ! asc5t ( ! o!r4 ,_! union involves p]petual conflict1 & !re waits on ! turn ( ! battle1 ! depression ( remorse1 or ! exultation ( triumph4 ,on ! individual side ( himself1 man w\ld take up ) ! pres5t1 ! imm$iate1 ) t :i* allures ! s5se1 &1 ) unholy inc5se1 regales ! imag9ation4 ,on ! social side ( himself1 he w\ld despise ! imm$iate1 & give ! ca/+ vote 9 favor ( ! unbias$1 immeasurable good4 ,9 su* a be+ z man1 conflict 7 inevitable4 ,) a horizon measur$ by ! edge ( ! pla9 :]e he /&s on ! "o side1 & a horizon melt+ into ! inf9ite /> dep?s on ! o!r1 x 7 b to be expect$ t a conte/ w\ld arise betwe5 ! l>g] & ! less] outlook4 ,on ! "o side1 he w\ld possess ! field1 conc5trate 8 att5tion ^u its grasses & its fruits1 & lose himself 9 its products4 ,on ! o!r1 he w\ld g =? to see :]e ! />s are1 to consid] ! s\rces ( _! light1 & to travel ) !m along _! sil5t pa?s4 ,) a view measur$ by ! h\r t %uts him r\nd on ! "o side1 & ) a view measur$ by ! organic pulsations ( ! _w on ! o!r2 ! "q w\ld be1 :e!r to give himself to ! imm$iate pleasures ( ! h\r2 or to elongate ! p5dulum ( 8 timepiece till x %\ld embrace ! ages1 & regulate 8 life by an et]nal measure4 ,) appetites on "o side1 clamor+ = ! ?+s 9 sight1 & ) consci5ce on ! o!r1 call+ = h>mony ) ?+s high & remote2 ! "q w\ld be1 :e!r to give ! cons5t ( ! w to ! dem& ( ! appetites1 or to ! appeal ( ! consci5ce4 ,,iii4 ,kn[+ ! side ( himself ( :i* a man takes c\nsel--! individual1 or ! social--y are prep>$ to fix 8 grade 9 ! scale ( be+4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 ,b5$ict ,arnold & ,george ,wa%+ton 0 j ?is3 9 ! case ( ! "o ! individual side 0 dom9ant2 9 ! case ( ! o!r ! social side held sway4 ,?is is ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! mis]1 despis$ ( all1 & ! philan?ropi/1 honor$ ( all4 ,?is is ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! debau*e & ! sa9t1 betwe5 ! man :o lives = 8 ,god & 8 race1 & ! man :o p\rs himself out on 8 lu/ & 8 passion4 ,if ! prompt+s ( ! individual side ( man's nature are to be di/ru/$ & wat*$1 :ile lib]al & un/9t$ recognition is to be giv5 to ! social side1 x is well to inquire into ! mean+ & (fice ( ?is l>g] fact ( 8 life4 ,let x be grant$ t on ! individual side ( himself man has no k+dom ( 8 own1 no dep>tm5t ( 8 own1 no privileg$ class ( 8 own1 & no titl$ ord] ( 8 own4 ,let ?is side ( him be left to ! naturali/1 to be class$ ) ! v]tebrates1 ! mammals1 or ! primates4 ,b :at conclusion are we to rea* conc]n+ ! social side ( himself1 t has f\nd embodim5t 9 t va/ & complicat$ movem5t we call civilization8 ,?r\gh ?is age-long hi/oric process man has be5 seek+ to realize ! capacities ( 8 l>g] nature4 ,l a magnific5t temple1 civilization has be5 ris+ ?r\gh ! c5turies4 ,its walls h sil5tly come up f ! e>?1 l ,solomon's ,temple1 )\t cl9k ( tr[el or s\nd ( hamm]4 ,x is built ( granite1 cut f ! ,ge?semanes ( hi/ory4 ,leonidas & 8 brave ?ree hundr$ at ! pass ( ,!rmopyl c>v$ "s ( ! blocks ( ?is great edifice1 into ^: walls m5 h gone d[n z ! liv+ /ones4 ,! brave ,britons1 at ! wat]s ( ,solway1 lift$ to place "s ( ! ri*ly foliag$ pill>s t /& ^u its floors4 ,william ! ,sil5t1 :ile organiz+ ! =ces & a*iev+ ! victories ( ! ,ne!rl&s1 0 at ! same "t turn+ "s ( its ar*es & re/+ 9 place "s ( its ar*itraves4 ,! ,m>tyrs1 :o w5t to undy+ fame & honor ?r\gh fires ( ,smi?field1 furni% !mes = ! music :i* res\nds ?r\gh its corridors4 ,x is ! triumph ( ! social nature ( man1 & /&s ^u ! soil :i* has be5 made by ! crumbl+ du/ ( all g5]ations ( brave m54 ,its p9nacles & t[]s pi]ce ! skies1 & decl>e to ! immeasurable heights1 ! =ce1 ! fai?1 ! s5tim5t1 & ! love ( man4 ,x defies ! elem5ts ( dis9tegration & *ange1 & ar\nd ! tops ( its l(ty pill>s !re clu/] ! buds ( et]nal spr+4 ,! gigantic trunks1 ^: ar*$ bran*es support ! ro( ( ?is great /ructure1 express !mselves 9 nev] )]+ fl[]s1 &1 :]e ! b\ghs int]lace at ! summit ( ! ar*es1 !re comes ! light ( heav5 to color & illum9e4 ,yet )9 its doors we are 9 no =e/ ( /one1 :]e ?\ghts ( m5 h be5 *isel$ into semblance ) ! trees4 ,its f\ndations are built ( convictions1 its pill>s ( hope1 its vault+ ( l(ty purpose1 & its w9d[s ( fai?4 ,its cem5t is ! blood ( suff]+1 & its decoration ! loves ( h]oes4 ,x is ! edifice man has built 9 :i* to h\se ! social side ( 8 nature4 ,x conta9s & w cons]ve all contributions ev] made to human weal4 ,9 walk+ ! /reets ( ,rome1 "o has a /range & melan*oly s5se ( ! traditions & memories :i* clu/] ab\t e ru9 & e spot4 ,b ar\nd ! myriad facts & =ces ( civilization !re hang associations m pa!tic /ill4 ,"h we walk1 n amid ! ru9s ( ! pa/1 b amid ! a*ievem5ts1 ! victories1 & ! glories ( ! pa/4 ,a*ievem5ts1 victories1 & glories n associat$ ) brok5 columns1 defac$ monum5ts & mold]+ ru9s1 b ) ! laws & in/itutions ( liv+ m54 ,we h "h1 9 t5 ?\s& embodi$ =ms1 ! travails ( ! s\ls ( our fa!rs4 ,_! spirits live 9 ! words we use1 _! consci5ces b9d 9 ! laws we obs]ve1 _! visions bless 9 ! pictures we see1 & _! devotion sanctifies 9 ! religion we love4 ,all ! blood ev] %$ 9 sacrifice1 all ! eloqu5ce t ev] ?rill$ s5ates & peoples 9 def5se ( ! "r1 all ! prote/s ev] 9 sil5ce felt or 9 public utt]$ aga9/ ! wrong1 are "h held 9 ev]la/+ =m4 ,are we to reg>d civilization1 ! manifold & complicat$ sum 9 :i* man's social nature has express$ itself1 z no?+ m ?an a natural product8 ,are we to acc\nt = ?is by ! same physical pr9ciples 9 accordance ) :i* ! bee builds 8 cell1 ! monkey hangs 8 bridge1 & ! beav] erects 8 dam8 ,does ?is /ately projection ( man's social nature mean no m ?an "s l(ty ,alp9e ,matt]horn1 pu%$ into ! heav5s by ! unconsci\s fires 9 ! e>?'s bosom8 ,is ?is only l "s mighty ,giants' ,causeway1 lift$ up by ! same physical =ces & by ! same natural processes8 ,if ?is is s1 :y is x t :5 we turn away f civilization z a :ole1 to view x 9 "s ( its national =ms1 we see ! spiritual ups & d[ns ( hi/ory 9 su* /rik+ contra/ ) ! uni=m face :i* nature we>s8 ,if ! radiant civilization ( ,greece1 t fill$ ! e>? ) ! eloqu5ce ( ?\ght & ! melody ( song1 ) ! ,republic ( ,plato & ! ,e?ics ( ,ari/otle1 t clo!d itself 9 ! ,p>!non ( ,phidias & ! ,iliad ( ,hom]1 0 z natural among ! nations z ! upris+ ( ,gibralt> among ! m\nta9s1 :y is x t ,gibralt> /ill /&s z ! solemn s5t9el ( ! ,ocean & ! ,sea1 :ile ! civilization ( ,greece is b a memory ( ! pa/8 ,! same sky & e>?1 & ,m>'s ,hill are !re4 ,ar\nd h] classic coa/ !re /ill murmurs ! same heav+ sea4 ,b :ile %ips may /ill sail to ,gibralt>1 nev] m c !y draw up to ! ,piru ( wor?y repres5tatives ( ,plato & ,ari/otle4 ,n aga9 d m51 ) noble br[s1 deep eyes1 & nev] dy+ ?\ght1 look into ! gean f t memorable meet+ place ( ! _w's %ips4 ,if ! hi/ory ( ,israel1 f ! "t ( ,abraham to ! com+ ( ,john ! ,bapti/1 0 b a natural product1 z easy to be acc\nt$ = z ! m\nta9s r\nd ab\t ,j]usalem2 :y is x t ! m\nta9s /ill encompass ! holy city2 :ile we f9d no m m5 l ,moses1 ,david1 & ,isaiah to lead1 to rule1 & to prophesy8 ,!re are ! same ,judean hills & valleys4 ,!re rapidly fl[s ! same hi/oric ,jordan4 ,!re gr[ ! same grapes1 ! figs1 & olives4 ,!re are ! same holy m\nta9s4 ,!re are ! same dang]\s rocks 9 ! sea at ,joppa4 ,! physical conditions t made ! corn & ! honey & ! cattle are !re2 & !re /ill are f\nd ! corn1 ! honey1 & ! cattle4 ,b no massive man l ,moses ev] m climbs ,s9ai to get law on tables ( /one1 or ,pisgah1 to see ! promis$ l& & die4 ,no man aft] ,god's own he>t1 l ,david1 any m m9ds %eep1 wat*es ! />s1 & writes poetry !re4 ,nev] m d we f9d !re a man l ,isaiah1 /ruggl+ on 8 knees 9 pray] t he may rise up to give 8 p ! oracles ( ,god4 ,a %all[1 deg5]ate & fickle p dwell amid ! groves & ! v9es :]e once liv$ ! great race :i* gave to m5 _! e?ics & ! outl9es ( true religion4 ,if ! civilization ( ,rome1 t rea*$ su* volume & =ce z to make h] ! mi/ress ( ! _w1 0 z natural z ! ris+ & fall+ ( ! tides1 :y is x t ,rome is 9 ru9s1 :ile ! tides cont9ue to rise & fall8 ,) no o!r aid ?an su* z is af=d$ by natural law & physical =ce1 we _c solve ?is problem4 ,:]e monkeys grew once1 monkeys gr[ to-day2 :]e lions roam$ once1 lions roam to-day2 :]e figs grew once1 figs gr[ to-day4 ,! same physical conditions1 ! same configuration ( soil1 ! same degree ( climate1 produce uni=m natural results f age to age4 ,^! may be c\nt$ on ) ! c]ta9ty ( a com+ eclipse1 condition$ on v>y+ conjunctions ( ! heav5ly bodies4 ,b we mu/ pass f ! level & range ( soil1 sky1 climate1 & physical conditions1 to acc\nt = ! fact t a c\ntry 9 "o p]iod ( its hi/ory produces a ,p]icles1 &1 9 ano!r1 a muddy-head$ numskull2 9 "o age an ari/ocracy ( poets1 arti/s1 /atesm51 philosoph]s1 & orators2 & 9 ano!r1 a li/less sw>m ( /upid & secul> cumb]]s ( ! gr\nd4 ,,iv4 ,! explanation ( ?is "q is to be f\nd 9 ! fact t man has a dual nature1 a body & a _s1 by virtue ( :i* he is individual & social4 ,:5 ! c5t] ( gravity is on ! social side ( human nature1 ! =tunes ( man g up2 :5 ! c5t] ( gravity is on ! individual side1 ! =tunes ( man g d[n4 ,on ! individual side1 he is ! subject ( physical law4 ,on ! social side1 ( moral law4 ,t man 0 int5d$ to express ! =ce ( 8 life ?r\gh ! social side ( himself & 9 accordance ) moral law1 in/ead ( ?r\gh ! individual side ( himself & 9 accordance ) physical law1 is pla91 f ! fact t x is only :5 he gives social expression to 8 life t he rea*es any degree ( comm&+ & p]man5t influ5ce4 ,! unrival$ place :i* ! ,greece ( ,p]icles holds 9 hi/ory is due to ! fact t he liv$ at a "t :5 ! emphasis 0 altoge!r on ! social side ( h] p4 ,! individual side 0 completely subord9at$ to ! life ( ! :ole4 ,x is d\btless true t %e press$ a "r to rule too f>1 & /ress$ ! citiz5 too mu*1 & consid]$ ! claims ( ! individual too little4 ,a prop] balance is to be pres]v$ betwe5 ! individual & ! social man4 ,b x is true t 9 m]g+ ! life ( ! individual into t ( ! /ate1 ,greece did prep>e a soil compact & ri* en\gh to gr[ ! mo/ ample h>ve/ ( lit]ature1 art1 poetry1 philosophy1 & m51 ! _w ev] saw4 ,z soon z ! emphasis pass$ ov] f ! social to ! individual side1 ! process ( pulv]ization began1 & ! cont9uities ( ?\ght & aspiration 7 brok5 up4 ,national unity 0 dissolv$1 & ! conditions ( great m5 & great results 7 no long] pres5t4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 ! ,greece ( #cjj ,b4 ,c4 & ! ,greece ( to-day1 is ! diff]5ce betwe5 giv+ ! national life a social & an individual expression4 ,! ,greece ( #cjj ,b4 ,c4 0 a compact :ole1 made s by ea* man putt+ 9 8 individual life z a contribution to ! life ( ! /ate4 ,! ,greece ( to-day is an aggregate ( self-c5t]$ units1 held toge!r l s _m potatoes 9 a basket1 by outw>d =ce & b>ri]s1 r ?an by loyalty1 patriotism1 fidelity1 & ! cl+ ( man to man4 ,9 ! ,greece ( #cjj ,b4 ,c4 ea* man1 :ile giv+ 8 individual life to 8 fell[s1 ga!r$ into 8 own be+ all ! life !y _h to give4 ,h5ce 9 ,socrates we _h a reproduction ( all ,greece4 ,9 ,hom]1 all h] poetic passion1 & expression4 ,9 ! orations ( ,demo/h5es1 all ! aspirations ( h] he>t & all h] love ( lib]ty4 ,9 ! ,greece ( to-day1 we h n ! same intimacy ( companion%ip1 or ! same network ( relation%ips4 ,ea* man1 ?9k+ m ( himself z individual ?an ( himself z social1 f9ds x no long] possible to make levies on ! lives ( 8 fell[s1 to ?9k 8 ?\ght1 conceive 8 temple1 deliv] 8 oration1 or write 8 poem4 ,s x foll[s1 !y no long] ?9k great ?\ghts1 conceive great temples1 deliv] great orations1 or write great poems4 ,ea* man1 9 ! high s5se1 be+ a sep>ate s&1 !y h a social soil z b>r5 z a des]t4 ,rome won h] victories1 wrote h] laws1 & laid ! f\ndations ( h] _w-wide empire1 :5 h] p gave social r ?an individual expression to ! =ce ( _! lives4 ,a typical illu/ration we h ( ?is 9 ! fidelity ( ,regulus4 ,a prison] at ,c>?age1 he is p]mitt$ to g to ,rome to induce 8 c\ntrym5 to make peace ) ! ,c>?ag9ians4 ,he pl$g$ 8 ^w to return if he fail$4 ,on rea*+ ,rome1 h[ev]1 in/ead ( seek+ to p]suade 8 p to make peace1 he appeal$ to !m to cont9ue ! w>4 ,! social side ( himself belong$ to ,rome2 speak+ ?r\gh t1 he call$ ^u h] to prosecute ! w>4 ,! individual side ( himself 0 p]sonal2 act+ ?r\gh t1 he w5t back to ,c>?age 9 honor ( 8 pl$ge1 to be cruelly put to dea? by 8 captors4 ,?is s+le incid5t is suffici5t to help u und]/& :y1 f h] sev5 hills1 ,rome conqu]$ & = a long "t rul$ ! _w4 ,! individual 0 sunk 9 ! ,roman4 ,n1 z 9 ! case ( ,greece1 t 8 p]sonal id5tity might be swall[$ up 9 ! mass1 b t he might f9d a p]sonal id5tity z great z ! empire1 ( ^: social life he 0 ! embodim5t4 ,regulus 0 an epitome ( ,rome4 ,9 him 0 all h] indomitable w1 h] moral /urd9ess1 h] iron probity4 ,9 him %e _h a son1 9 ! dep? ( ^: _s all ! glory %e _h won 9 w>1 & all ! control %e _h f\nd 9 sacrifice1 0 safe4 ,regulus _h ! advantage ( ! ,c>?ag9ians1 9 t ! l>g]1 nobl] side ( himself 0 safe f _! hate4 ,! ,roman1 ! social ,regulus1 0 z et]nal z ! maje/y1 & fame1 & my/]y ( ! ,roman empire4 ,! doom ( ,rome1 z a nation1 0 nev] seal$ till ! /ress 0 remov$ f ! social to ! individual side ( h] p4 ,%e might h liv$ on among ! nations1 z fix$ z h] own et]nal hills1 if ! temptations to self-indulg5ce & self-gratification _h be5 resi/$4 ,h] d[nfall 0 n due to physical causes1 b to h] s9s4 ,obs]vance ( ! moral laws1 :i* made h] great1 w\ld h kept h] great4 ,:5 %e ?rew h] l>g]1 social self into ! fires ( h] individual lu/ & passion1 %e burn$ ! f\ndations ( h] dom9ion1 & a mighty wreck ( %apeless ru9s 0 all t 0 left ( ! once pr\d mi/ress ( ! _w4 ,v4 ,:at is ! correlate to ! social side ( man's nature8 ,:]e is ! doma9 t mat*es x8 ,:]e is ! va/ realm1 l>ge en\gh to furni% suffici5t scope = all ! possibilities :i* seem to lie fold$ )9 x8 ,a /udy ( ! eye reveals ! fact t ! light ( ! sun is necess>y to furni% an elem5t wide & e!real en\gh = ! ex]cise ( its functions4 ,by a /udy ( ! e>1 we le>n t x is relat$ to s\nd ) all its possibilities ( h>mony4 ,! f9 ( ! fi% is relat$ to ! wat]s ( ! sea4 ,! bird's w+ is a prophecy ( ! sky4 ,! migrat+ in/9ct ( ! wild goose is relat$ to ! ,s\?1 ) its s(t skies & balmy air4 ,9 ! calculations ( ,adams1 9 ,engl&1 & ( ,lev]ri]1 9 ,france1 ! p]turbations ( ! planet ,uranus 7 9 correspond5ce ) ! planet ,neptune4 ,on ! side ( himself z individual1 z we h se51 man is relat$ to ! e>? ) all x conta9s to satisfy ! ne$s ( ! body4 ,we wi% also to det]m9e ! nature & dim5sions ( ! sph]e to :i* he is relat$ z social4 ,we h se5 t1 ev5 )9 national b\nd>ies1 human life comes to be f]tile 9 great m51 great de$s1 & great art1 :5 ! expression ( x is social1 r ?an individual4 ,) su* disposition ( h] national life =ce1 ,greece rea*$ an unp>allel$ height ( gr&eur & influ5ce4 ,b all outside ( ,greece 7 e/eem$ z b>b>ians4 ,! b>b>ian hordes ar\nd h] /ate 7 l s _m walls1 :i* kept ! waves ( national life f pass+ out into any _w-wide sea4 ,! limits 7 soon rea*$1 !n ! waves rec$$1 to be ?r[n back aga9 9 quick succession aga9/ ! encompass+ walls4 ,0 ?is n 9 violation ( ! law & nature ( ! expression :i* ! social side ( man1 by its v /ructure1 is incl9$ to give ( itself8 ,is x n1 by its nature1 dispos$ to pass out 9 accordance ) moral laws1 :i* h no b\nd>ies & limits8 ,& 7 n ! walls !y p]mitt$ _! hate to build ( ! b>b>ians on ! outside to arre/ ! outw>d fl[ ( _! national life1 ! evid5ce ( a tacit treaty ) _! selfi%ness8 ,did ^! n1 aft] all1 be> witness to a hamp]$ & halt$ surr5d] to ! nobl] side ( _! nature8 ,did !y n %[ t ! ,greeks 7 only will+ to give social expression to _! national life1 z f> z ! b\nd>y l9es ( ,a*ai8 ,too noble to p]mit ! emphasis to re/ on ! individual side ( h] p1 z sep>ate memb]s ( ! /ate1 %e lift$ n>r[ness & selfi%ness into great] place by giv+ !m national =m4 ,too great ( bread? to be individually selfi%1 %e 0 n great en\gh to be nationally unselfi%4 ,! individual sides ( !mselves h] p sacrific$ on ! alt>s ( ! /ate to h] national unity1 %e transmut$ into contempt & hatr$ ( o!r nations4 ,selfi%ness only pass$ f ! individual to ! /ate4 ,reta9$ by ! /ate1 x work$ itself back into ! individuals aga91 :5 ! unity ( ! /ate 0 dis9tegrat$4 ,d we n h 9 ! limitations :i* ,greece attempt$ to put on ! expression :i* ! social nature ( man w\ld give ( itself1 ! real secret ( _! d[nfall8 ,if1 :ile giv+ ev5 limit$ social expression to h] national life1 ,greece develop$ a civilization s ri*1 h[ mu* great] might h be5 h] contribution to human progress _h n ! se$s ( dis9tegration be5 s[n among h] p ?r\gh national enmity & hate4 ,9 ! two hundr$ ye>s :i* embrac$ ! mo/ f]tile portion ( h] hi/ory %e laid ! f\ndation ( ?\ght4 ,b x 0 only ?r\gh ?\ght t %e s\ght to solve ! problems ( life & de/9y4 ,! social life ( ! ,jews f\nd only limit$ expression = itself4 ,x 0 work$ out into religi\s l9es t 7 unlimit$ & all embrac+1 b ?is 0 9 spite ( _! prejudices4 ,_! compact social life1 ! va/ dep? & vigor ( _! social vitality1 ! t5acity ) :i* !y clung toge!r1 made x possible = !m to lay ! f\ndation ( a religion & an e?ics l>g] ?an !y dream$4 ,_! scriptures1 _! prophets1 & _! sa9ts 7 n possible 9 a soil less socially ri*4 ,_! devotion1 _! loyalty1 _! volunt>y subord9ation ( private to public int]e/s1 _! religi\s fidelity fitt$ !m to become ! *ildr5 ( ,god4 ,! summit ( civilization !y rea*$ enabl$ !m to see & to transcribe ! outl9es ( ! k+dom ( heav54 ,!y asc5d$ high en\gh ! m\nt ( be+ to recognize ! laws necess>y to regulate human conduct4 ,b !y p]mitt$ _! n>r[ness & prejudice to build ( ! ,g5tiles ab\t !m1 walls to limit ! outfl[ ( _! national life4 ,hate = ! un=tunate p )\t1 c\ld n be )\t its influ5ce on ! lives ( ^? )94 ,! selfi%ness :i*1 z a nation1 !y *]i%$ t[>d o!r p1 reproduc$ itself at l5g? 9 _! own lives4 ,f ! *ildr5 ( ,god !y desc5d$ until !y became ! *ildr5 ( ! devil4 ,! visions ( _! nobl] m5 7 disc\nt$ & despis$4 ,! selfi%ness t put !m aga9/ ! ,g5tiles1 f9ally put !m aga9/ "o ano!r2 & :ile !y kept toge!r 9 a c]ta9 s5se1 9 spite ( ! upp] & ne!r mill /ones ( hi/ory1 x 0 r 9 memory ( :at !y _h be51 ?an ( :at !y 74 ,9 ! civilization ( ,rome1 aga91 limitations 7 put on ! expression ( ! social side ( man's nature4 ,)9 ! prec9cts ( ,rome1 "u h] eagles & )9 h] roads1 !re 0 a s9k+ ( ! individual & an expression ( ! social side1 t has be5 r>ely equal$ 9 hi/ory4 ,x 0 ?is m]g+ ( ! individual units into ! social :ole ( ,rome1 t made x possible = h] to =mulate ! legal measures & provisions :i* cont9ue to protect human life & prop]ty4 ,b sacrifice1 companion%ip1 social cohesion on ! inside1 c\ld n1 = _m c5turies1 be accompani$ ) fi]ce opposition & cruel hate = o!rs on ! outside4 ,x 0 inevitable t soon] or lat] ! disposition on ! outside w\ld get di/ribut$ among ! individuals on ! inside4 ,,vi4 ,! realm1 !n1 to :i* man on ! social side ( himself is relat$1 is l>g] ?an t encompass$ by any national b\nd>ies4 ,! ,greek1 on ! social side ( himself1 0 l>g] ?an ,a*ai1 ! ,jew ?an ,pale/9e1 & ! ,roman ?an ! ,empire4 ,! ,greek develop$ ?\ght1 ! ,jew produc$ religion1 & ! ,roman =mulat$ law4 ,b ! l>g] side ( man's nature is n met by ?\ght simply1 or by religion simply1 or by law simply1 b by ! comb9ation ( ^! 9 "r proportions4 ,man1 on ! social side ( himself1 is correlat$ ?r\gh reciprocal relations to ! human race4 ,to limit ! social expression ( man's life is to contract its nature1 & to violate ! moral laws 9 accordance ) :i* x mu/ act4 ,! und]/&+ _c re/ 9 unrelat$ ph5om5a4 ,?r\gh sci5ce x r$uces ! =ces ( nature to "o =ce1 its en]gies to "o en]gy1 & its matt] to its con/itu5t elem5ts4 ,s ! social nature mu/ f9d h>mony 9 ! union & cohesion ( scatt]$1 sep>at$ human be+s4 ,x mu/ h companion%ip1 su* z ! relations ( all m5 help to make4 ,x mu/ h a range z wide z ! _w4 ,because ( ! cont9uities ( life & ?\ght secur$ ?r\gh univ]sal social cohesion1 x mu/ be able to pass & repass ?r\gh ! l5g? & bread? ( human life4 ,if man's social nature is to f9d its correlate1 ! race mu/ be s completely "o1 s compact & contigu\s 9 ! _s ( frat]nity & good w1 z to make x possible = ea* man to %>e 9 ! "w1 ?\ght1 & virtue ( all m54 ,individuals mu/ be ga!r$ into ! network ( social relations1 s t1 in/ead ( sep>ate & isolat$ units1 !y %all be kn[n z f>m]s1 m]*ants1 blacksmi?s1 me*anics1 %oemak]s1 lawy]s1 doctors1 editors1 & m9i/]s4 ,! call+ ( ea* mu/ relate to ! well-be+ ( all4 ,e man mu/ make = o!rs & receive 9 return = ! supply ( 8 own wants some?+ ( all ! o!rs make4 ,into ! multiplex fl[ ( ex*anges ! %oemak] may put 9 simply "o pair ( %oes p] day1 z 8 p]sonal contribution4 ,to t ext5t he mu/ be able to make levies on ! contributions ( all ! re/4 ,no "o w be indep5d5t 9 an unrelat$ s5se4 ,all w be dep5d5t1 & ea* indep5d5t1 ?r\gh dep5d5ce on ! re/4 ,! race1 z civil society1 w be at "w "u all climes1 & on all soils1 produc+ ! inf9ite v>iety ( goods = ! _w's m>ket4 ,by ! specialization & division ( labor1 we w h great increase ( skill & ! multiplication ( all products4 ,p w be at "w rais+ c(fee & drugs 9 ,brazil1 tea 9 ,*9a1 creat+ a myriad ( manufactures 9 ,engl&1 ,france1 & ,g]many1 gr[+ fruits on ! ,m$it]ranean ,isl&s2 ^! !n w be ga!r$ by v>i\s means ( transportation & load$ on %ips & c>s1 to be c>ri$ to e place on e>?2 t ev]yone may h ! :ole e>? to s]ve him1 :ile on 8 "p he r5d]s s]vice to all4 ,,vii4 ,! univ]sal organization ( ! human race into "o social :ole has be5 ! gr&1 f>-(f ev5t1 t[>d :i* ! :ole creation & ! :ole process ( hi/ory has mov$4 ,t[>d ?is ! race has be5 mov+ ?r\gh all ! fi]ce antagonisms & bloody w>s ( ! pa/4 ,pe/il5ces1 :i* h decimat$ ! ranks ( m51 & e>?quakes1 :i* h swall[$ up great cities1 h contribut$ t[>d ?is consummation4 ,! g5ius ( m5 l ,alex&] ! ,great has be5 us$ to break up ! n>r[ & prov9cial gr\p+s into :i* m5 _h settl$1 t a way might be op5$ = ! di/ribution ( products & ! circulation ( ideas4 ,9 ! e>ly hi/ory ( ! race1 ! process ( organization began4 ,e great man & e great movem5t help$ t[>d its enl>gem5t4 ,abraham1 gett+ up f ,ur ( ! ,*aldees1 & mov+ ) 8 family & 8 h]ds across ! pla9s ( ,syria1 to plant a gov]nm5t 9 ,pale/9e1 wid5$ its sph]e4 ,phnicia1 ! /ronge/ m>itime p[] ( anci5t times1 :ile %e _h no motive b ga9 = cr[d+ e port ) h] %ips1 & = turn+ ! _w into an ex*ange1 did augm5t ! k ( m5 & increase ! relations ( m54 ,! ,jews1 by _! compact1 social organization1 lift$ _! national life into a great civilization4 ,?is civilization !y s\ght to make prov9cial2 !y s\ght to f5ce !mselves (f1 ) all !y _h accumulat$ ( devotion & law & lit]ature1 f ! re/ ( mank9d4 ,b _! social pulv]ization1 due to _! s9s1 help$ =w>d univ]sal companion%ip4 ,!y mov$ out into o!r p>ts ( ! _w4 ,!y settl$ along ! ,black ,sea & ! ,caspian ,sea4 ,!y w5t into ,asia ,m9or & back into ,syria4 ,!y took up _! abode 9 ,alex&ria & along ! ,m$it]ranean coa/4 ,:]ev] !y w5t1 !y c>ri$ _! civilization2 _! synagogue1 9 :i* to tea* _! k ( ! "o ,god2 _! ,moses1 to guide by 8 law _! conduct2 & _! ,david1 to soo!1 ) 8 songs1 _! sorr[4 ,! m>vel\s productions ( ,grecian ?\ght & skill 7 kept1 = a "t1 f ! b>b>ians4 ,!y attempt$ a monopoly ( beauty4 ,b ! break+ up ( _! ,commonweal? ha/5$ ! com+ ( univ]sal frat]nity4 ,!y plant$ _! civilization 9 ,asia ,m9or4 ,!y w5t ov] to ,syria1 d[n to ,alex&ria1 & ar\nd ! ,m$it]ranean ,sea4 ,:]ev] !y w5t !y c>ri$ _! language & _! philosophy4 ,! ,romans broke d[n ! walls betwe5 diff]5t tribes1 & br\ght !m "u "o law4 ,!y built roads into all p>ts ( ! civiliz$ _w1 & ?us prep>$ ! fir/ great highways ( travel4 ,look+ f ?is di/ance1 back ^u ! movem5ts ( ^! great peoples1 x seems z if !y might h be51 on set purpose1 devis+ s*emes & lay+ plans = br++ ! _w ( mank9d toge!r4 ,x really looks z if all peoples above ! grade ( ! savage _h be5 unconsci\sly & 9 spite ( !mselves work+ = ! unity ( ! race4 ,! v walls t h be5 rais$ to keep m5 ap>t h be5 batt]$ d[n & us$ to make roads to br+ !m toge!r4 ,! m\nta9s1 t s]v$ z b>ri]s to sep>ate !m1 h be5 tunnel$ to unite !m4 ,! oceans1 t seem$ absolutely to insure isolation1 are n[ ! favorite means ( communication4 ,all inv5tions & discov]ies h help$ to ! practical on5ess ( ! race4 ,! m>9]'s compass1 gunp[d]1 ! pr9t+ press1 ! /eam eng9e1 ! electric telegraph1 ! sew+ ma*9e1 ! spectroscope1 ! electric light1 ! telephone1 ) ! phonograph & microphone1 h wr\ght = ?is end4 ,! discov]y ( ! sun's place 9 ! heav5s1 & ( ! %ape & movem5ts ( ! e>?2 ! discov]y ( ,am]ica & ( ! law ( gravitation2 ! discov]y ( ! circulation ( ! blood & ( ! wond]ful rem$ies 9 nature :i* relieve ! ills ( ! body1 h all r$uc$ diff]5ces & augm5t$ unity4 ,!ologies1 :i* h divid$ m5 into religi\s p>tisans1 fom5t+ /rife1 & produc+ w>s2 :i* h sep>at$ m5 into p>ties bitt] & rev5geful2 h gr[n k9d] & human] z ! ye>s h pass$1 & t5d n[ to unite m51 r ?an to divide !m4 ,philosophies1 :i* kept m5 ap>t "u ! heads ( nom9ali/ & reali/1 s5sationali/ & ideali/1 are n[ d$uc$ f a broad] survey ( ! facts1 & t5d to h>mony r ?an conflict4 ,f ! beg9n+ nature & human ef=t h wr\ght toge!r = univ]sal good w & social organization4 ,lapses h be5 frequ5t & ! net ga9 ( frat]nity small1 b f age to age1 )\t cessation & )\t int]mission1 9 volume & sweep1 x has be5 increas+4 ,,viii4 ,because ( ! limit$ k m5 _h ( ! uses ( p[] 9 ! pa/1 ! gr[? ( univ]sal social organization has be5 sl[4 ,me?ods ( int]communication betwe5 nations wide ap>t 7 meag]1 h5ce ! p 9 "o division ( ! globe c\ld "k b little ( ! p :o liv$ 9 ano!r4 ,any "p ( ! e>? n und]/ood 0 c\nt$ z des]t1 & any p n kn[n 7 consid]$ b>b>ian4 ,b ) ! new uses & applications ( p[]1 all ?is is *ang$4 ,! _w n[ lies op5 to all4 ,! antipodes are neighbors4 ,by hit*+ ! sun's heat to ! fly+ tra91 & ! canvas to ! favor+ w9ds1 & ! lightn+ to human ?\ght1 all races on ! globe /& face to face4 ,! _w is be+ encompass$1 & no natural ob/acles are n[ p]mitt$ to /& 9 ! way ( railway l9es1 or ( subm>9e cables4 ,all m\nta9 *a9s are be+ tunnel$1 all *asms spann$1 all oceans trav]s$1 & all /raits bridg$4 ,! cont95ts ( ! e>? are n[ connect$ by #abe1jjj miles ( subm>9e electric cable1 & c\ntries are cross$ by ?\s&s ( miles ( railroad l9es4 ,) an abid+ & irrepressible1 ev5 if unconsci\s s5se1 t on ! social side ( himself he is relat$ to ! :ole human race1 man has well-nigh subdu$ ! e>?1 & remov$ ! ob/acles t oppos$ ! realization ( 8 l>g] nature4 ,already great ent]prises are be+ contemplat$1 :i* look to ! spe$y removal ( :atev] rema9+ ob/acles !re are to _w-wide companion%ip among m54 ,"s ( ! great ent]prises already project$ :i* are to help t[>d univ]sal bro!rhood1 h be5 not$ by ,mr4 ,*>les ,hallock4 ,a railway is to be built f ,joppa to ,j]usalem 9 ,pale/9e1 & a bridge across ! ,/raits ( ,dov] ne> ,folke/one4 ,! ,mombasa & ,nyanza ,railway 9 ,africa is to connect ! ,nile ) ! int]ior lakes & ) ! coa/4 ,a railway is to be con/ruct$ across ,sib]ia1 f ,/4 ,pet]sburg to ,behr+ ,/rait4 ,^u ?is side a railway is to be built across ,alaska to ,behr+ ,/rait1 :ile ,behr+ ,/rait is to be bridg$ or f]ri$4 ,a canal is to be cut across ! ,i/hmus ( ,cor9? 9 ,greece1 to connect ! gean ,sea ) ! ,gulf ( ,cor9?4 ,!re is to be a %ip canal ar\nd ,niag>a ,falls1 & a railroad f ,quebec to ,belle ,isle 9 ,labrador1 ) connect+ ocean /eam%ip l9es to ,m$=d 9 ,wales4 ,!re is to be an ocean cable f ,clew ,bay1 ,irel&1 to ,gre5y ,isl&1 ,/rait ( ,belle ,isle1 #aijj miles long4 ,& a railroad f ,w9nipeg1 ,manitoba1 to ,hudson ,bay1 & /eam%ip l9e !nce to ,liv]pool4 ,a railway is contemplat$ f ,w9nipeg to ! ,saskat*ewan ,riv]1 across ! ,nor?we/ ,t]ritory4 ,a tunnel is to be cut "u ! ,hudson ,riv] at ,new ,york1 & a tunnel "u ! ,/4 ,clair ,riv]1 betwe5 ,s>nia & ,port ,huron1 ,mi*4 ,t ! ,panama & ,nic>agua canals h be5 project$ & p>tially complet$ is kn[n ! _w ov]4 ,a tunnel is to be made ?r\gh ! ,atlas ,m\nta9s 9 ,russia1 & ! great ,nor!rn ,railroad ,company is to make "o ?r\gh ! ,rocky ,m\nta9s 9 ,montana1 & ano!r is to be cut ?r\gh ! ,si]ras f ,truckee ,riv]1 ,nevada1 into ,cali=nia4 ,!re is to be a canal f ,knoxville1 ,t5n41 ?r\gh ,alabama to ! ,gulf ( ,mexico1 & "o f ,*icago to ! ,mississippi ,riv]1 :i* is to co/ #be1jjj1jjj4 ,a %ip railway #fj miles long is to be complet$ f ,georgian ,bay to ,lake ,ont>io1 connect+ ! ,great ,lakes & ! ,/4 ,lawr5ce ,riv]1 co/+ #ab1jjj1jjj4 ,a canal is contemplat$ f ,*icago to ! ,gulf ( ,mexico1 & also a %ip railway ar\nd ! ,dalles ( ! ,columbia ,riv]4 ,!re is to be a %ip canal across ,new ,j]sey to ! ,atlantic ,ocean1 #fj miles long1 & a %ip railway to connect ! ,gulf ( ,/ ,lawr5ce ) ! ,bay ( ,fundy1 #ab miles long1 to co/ #ab1jjj1jjj4 ,!re are to be /eam l9es f ,tampa1 ,fla41 to all p>ts ( ! ,we/ ,indies1 a longitud9al railway ?r\gh ! axis ( ,nor? & ,s\? ,am]ica1 f ,*icago to ! ,arg5t9e ,republic2 /eam l9es f ,vanc\v] 9 ,briti% ,columbia1 to ,japan & ,au/ralia1 & /eam l9es f ,new ,york to ! ,c>ribbees & ! ,w9dw>d ,isl&s4 ,!re are to be /eam l9es f ,scotl& to ! ,nor? ,cape & ! ,ant>ctic ,ocean2 /at$ voyages betwe5 ,sitka1 ,alaska1 & ,po9t ,b>r[ 9 ! ,arctic ,ocean1 & /eamboat navigation ( all ! great lakes & riv]s ( ,sib]ia1 ,briti% ,am]ica1 & ,c5tral ,africa4 ,ports ( entry are to be e/abli%$ 9 all c\ntries to furni% t]m9al facilities = ^! f> rea*+ l9es ( transportation4 ,we are to h f$]ation among ! nations1 z we n[ h x among ! ,/ates ( ! ,am]ican ,union4 ,! social cohesion1 once national1 is to be int]national4 ,all are to ?9k = ea*1 & ea* is to ?9k = all4 ,all are to "w = ea*1 & ea* is to "w = all4 ,all are to plan = ! good ( ea*1 & ea* is to plan = ! good ( all4 ,?us ! inequalities ( life are to be r$uc$1 & ! littl5ess ( life is to be r$ress$4 ,z all ! p[] 9 ! v9e & its bran*es to make grapes is exp5d$ 9 ! r\nd+ & sweet5+ ( ea* grape1 s all ! p[] 9 ! social :ole to make m5 w be reproduc$ 9 ea* man4 ,all ! ju/ice 9 ! race w regulate ea* man's w1 all ! ?\ght 9 ! race w repl5i% ea* man's m9d1 & all ! love 9 ! race w fe$ ea* man's he>t4 ,no?+ less ?an ?is social :ole1 9 :i* are b\nd toge!r 9 "o organic body ! lives1 ! welf>e1 & ! hopes ( all1 is ! correlate ( ! social nature ( man4 ,t[>d su* a _w-wide organism1 ea* liv+ 9 ! :ole & ! :ole liv+ 9 ea*1 8 social nature rea*es out & is nev] at home until x is f\nd4 ,su* univ]sal bro!rhood w\ld be impossible )\t p[] 9 all its manifold =ms4 ,?is s]ves ! social body z bread s]ves ! individual body4 ,p[]1 z ! s]vant ( ! social body1 waits on ea* man ?r\gh 8 relations ) ! social :ole4 ,a city builds gas works & f9ds x possible to let d[n ! price 9 proportion to ! numb] ( ^? :o use x4 ,a railroad company c l[] ! rate on pass5g]s & freight 9 proportion to ! numb] ( m5 :o travel & ! volume ( freight transport$4 ,! price ( a newspap] goes up or d[n z ! numb] ( subscrib]s increases or dim9i%es4 ,mr4 ,edison expects to get electricity f ! di/urb$ conditions ( ! air1 )\t ! use ( fuel4 ,?is w make ! conditions ( life easi] by "o-half2 & !n1 z ! numb] ( p increases :o avail !mselves ( ! uses ( p[]1 ! conditions ( liv+ w /ill be easi]4 ,n only w ! unity :i* comes ?r\gh social organization l[] ! rate ( insurance & ! price ( ! necessities ( life1 b ?is increas$ =ce ( ! social :ole w t5d to ! moral heal? ( ! p 9 ! same degree4 ,heal? 9 "o "p ( ! body w be br\ght to be> to correct disease 9 ano!r "p4 ,! consci5ce ( ! :ole w be turn$ into ! degrad$ sections ( our great cities1 & ! sympa?y & love ( all w be call$ out to reclaim !m4 ,/>vation 9 "o "p ( ! globe w be met by ! ov]-supply ( bread 9 ano!r4 ,oppression & tyranny 9 "o nation w be oppos$ by ! s5se ( fairness & ov]come by ! love ( fre$om 9 all ! re/4 ,z climatic conditions are made fri5dly to life by ! circulation ( oceanic & atmosph]ic curr5ts1 s moral heal? w be pres]v$ by ! circulation ( ! curr5ts ( consci5ce & ju/ice4 ,,ix4 ,! emphasis is to be kept on ! social r ?an ! individual side ( human nature2 n t p]sonality may be lo/1 b t x may be ga9$4 ,! social mass t con/ricts & squeezes ! s+le life until ! virility ( self-ass]tion & ! "r ( private initiative are de/roy$1 is no improvem5t on ,b$\9 isolation4 ,! latt] brutalizes life1 :ile ! =m] evisc]ates x4 ,! eye does n lose its capacity = sight1 & its place ( peculi> responsibility by be+ br\ght into reciprocal relations along ) o!r organs 9 ! same body4 ,x w\ld h no mean+ & no p[] ( vision ap>t f relations ) o!r organs4 ,! e> is n disc\nt$1 nor are its wond]ful functions belittl$ amid ! manifold memb]s :i* "w toge!r 9 ! same human frame4 ,its position ( honor is secur$ to x by ! organic relations x su/a9s to ! o!r memb]s4 ,! foot1 ! h&1 & ! tongue f9d !mselves & _! uses z !y unite toge!r 9 "o liv+ :ole4 ,! lone ,b$\91 ) no laws & no relations1 seems to h all lib]ty1 b 9 reality he has none4 ,he is z completely )\t mean+ z w\ld be ! f+] sep>at$ f ! h&4 ,! man ( :om nature is a prophecy is n ! be+ 9 ! woods ^: home is a cave & ^: food is wild meat2 b x is ! man 9 society1 ^: home all woods & metals & /ones h help$ to build1 & ^: food all soils & skies & seas h help$ to produce4 ,! emphasis is to be kept on ! social side ( human nature1 because x is ?r\gh t side ( himself t man is to pass into ! _w-wide "w & ! glori\s de/9y = :i* he is fitt$4 ,?r\gh t side ( himself he moves out into ord]1 & /r5g?1 & fre$om4 ,all m5 ^: names are *]i%$ 9 hi/ory1 pass$ into place1 influ5ce1 & honor ?r\gh ! social side ( human nature4 ,9 pass+ ?r\gh ! social side ( himself1 ! life man f9ds is a million times l>g] & ri*] ?an ! life he loses4 ,t m5 might f9d ! life t belong$ to !m1 ! only life wor? liv+1 ! t5d5cy f ! fir/ has be5 t[>d ! solid>ity ( ! race4 ,! relations gr[+ out ( su* solid>ity are con/itutive ( ! be+ ( ea* man4 ,! important prop]ties ( an acid _c be kn[n1 :5 x is consid]$ out ( relation ) an alkali4 ,:at a ?+ is = ano!r1 t x is 9 itself4 ,s :at a man is ?r\gh relations ) o!rs1 t he is 9 himself4 ,b :at he is 9 himself _c be kn[n until he comes into relations ) o!rs4 ,solid>ity is n to swamp s+le lives1 b s+le lives are to come to all t is peculi> & high 9 !mselves ?r\gh solid>ity4 ,! univ]se is to pres]ve relations ) ea* private _s4 ,by ! organization ( m5 into "o social :ole1 provision is made = ea* man to p>ticipate 9 ! life ( humanity4 ,x is int5d$ t all ! oceans ( life %all rea*1 ?r\gh _! waves1 ! %ores ( ea* man's be+1 & leave deposits ( all _! weal? 9 ea* man's _s4 ,:5 we speak ( ! horse1 ! eagle1 ! :ale1 x is und]/ood t we are us+ g5]ic t]ms1 & are int5d$ to ref] to no p>ticul> horse or eagle or :ale4 ,yet 9 ea* horse ! species is reproduc$1 & 9 ea* eagle ! species is epitomiz$1 & 9 ea* :ale ! :ole :ale type is summ>iz$4 ,?is is done 9 ! case ( ! l[] animals1 )\t _! ?\ght or volition4 ,no univ]sal relations are necess>y among :ales1 = ea* :ale to h )9 itself all ! peculi>ities & furni%m5ts possess$ by all :ales4 ,! species are to be realiz$ 9 ea* man1 too2 b ?is is to be accompli%$ ?r\gh social relations among all m54 ,all ! m5 9 ! _w mu/ t\* ea* man1 to call =? ! capacities :i* lie fold$ )9 8 life4 ,humanity1 z p>cell$ out 9 nations1 g5]ations1 epo*s1 mu/ lift itself into ! be+ ( ea* man2 z ! ocean1 p>cell$ out 9 ,atlantics1 ,pacifics1 ,indians1 ,arctics1 ,ant>ctics1 lifts itself into ea* wave4 ,p[]1 p>cell$ out 9 gravitation1 heat1 & electricity surr\nd+ ! globe2 adv]tis$ 9 e apple's fall1 decl>$ 9 e fla% f ! cl\ds1 & pres5t 9 e sunbeam2 /&s ready to make univ]sal bro!rhood1 n simply an ideal1 runn+ ?r\gh ! dreams ( poets & prophets1 b an actual fact4 ,! recognition ( p[]1 z ! provision made = ! social nature ( man1 is enabl+ u to realize ! dreams ( prophets & poets4 ,,tru?4 8,a c5tury is a =mula2 an epo* is an express$ ?\ght4 ,"o su* ?\ght-express$ civilization passes to ano!r4 ,! c5turies are ! phrases ( civilization2 :at %e says "h %e does n repeat !re4 ,b ^! my/]i\s phrases are l9k$ toge!r3 logic--! logos--is )9 !m1 & _! s]ies con/itutes progress4 ,9 all ^!1 phrase expressions ( a s+le ?\ght1 ! div9e ?\ght1 we are sl[ly deciph]+ ! ^w frat]nity4 8,all light is at "s po9t cond5s$ into a flame2 likewise e epo* is cond5s$ 9 a man4 ,! man dead1 ! epo* is conclud$3 ,god turns ov] ! leaf4 ,dante dead1 a p]iod is plac$ at ! end ( ! ?irte5? c5tury3 ,john ,huss may come4 ,%aksp]e dead1 a p]iod is plac$ at ! end ( ! sixte5? c5tury4 ,aft] ?is "p1 :o conta9s & epitomizes all philosophy1 may come ! philosoph]s--,pascal1 ,desc>tes1 ,molire1 ,le ,sage1 ,montesquieu1 ,did]ot1 ,beaum>*ais40 ,,*apt] ,,iii4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,intellectual ,,nature ,,( ,,man4 ,tru? & reality /& = ! same ?+4 ,reality is tru? out ( ! m9d1 & tru? is reality 9 ! m9d4 ,reality is objective tru?1 & tru? is subjective reality4 ,b all reality is 9 relation to m9d2 objective reality to ! div9e m9d1 & subjective reality to ! human m9d4 ,objective reality is ! realiz$ ?\ght ( ,god2 subjective reality is ! realiz$ ?\ght ( man4 ,! correspond5ce ( ?\ghts to ?+s is call$ sci5tific tru?4 ,objective reality is tru?1 because x corresponds to ! ?\ght ( ,god4 ,k 9 ! human m9d is tru? :5 x corresponds to objective reality or ! express$ ?\ght ( ,god4 ,:5 words & conduct correspond to k1 we h tru? 9 ! doma9 ( morals4 ,9 say+ t objective reality is ! realiz$ ?\ght ( ,god1 we d5ote its unity4 ,?is is n to de/roy ! p>ticul>s ( :i* x is compos$1 or to swamp _! individuality 9 an in>ticulate mass1 b simply to indicate _! on5ess4 ,:5 ! obs]v] looks out into ! univ]se1 :i* includes & %uts him r\nd1 he is impress$ by ! inf9ite v>ieties & div]sities :i* ev]y:]e meet 8 gaze4 ,no two ?+s are alike4 ,no two leaves1 no two drops ( wat]1 no two sn[flakes1 no two apples1 no two faces4 ,e p>ticul> ?+ seems to be p]si/5tly det]m9$ to diff]1 9 "s respect at lea/1 f ev]y?+ else4 ,! hi/ory ( true k beg9s1 h[ev]1 ) ! obs]vation ( resemblance & simil>ity--j b5ea? ! surface ( diff]5ce & v>iety4 ,! lightn+ t appe>s on ! bosom ( ! cl\d1 l ! writ+ ( "s awful fi5d1 is se5 to be ! same ) ! g5tle sp>ks emitt$ :5 a tag ( silk5 ribbon is drawn briskly betwe5 ! f+]s4 ,! p[] t pulls ! ball to ! gr\nd is se5 to be ! same z t :i* keeps ! sun 9 8 place4 ,! plant lifts itself up z b a sum ( organiz$ v>ieties2 b e "p1 corolla1 petal1 & /am51 is kn[n to be only modifi$ leaf4 ,keep+ to _! sil5t & lonely r\nds s9ce ! dawn ( "t1 are ! />s 9 ! heav5s1 diff]+ 9 color1 orbit1 & size1 b we n[ "k t to und]/& ! elem5ts ( :i* !y are compos$1 we h only to lift our foot & see :at ! con/itu5t p>ts ( ! e>? b5ea? x are4 ,7 objective reality "o amorph\s mass1 x w\ld n be intelligible4 ,x is "o & _m1 p>ticul> & univ]sal1 s+ul> & manifold1 concrete & discrete4 ,all ?+s coh]e 9 a c5trality t includes & comm&s !m4 ,s true is x t unity und]lies all diff]5ce1 t no s+le v>iety c be und]/ood1 only z x is consid]$ 9 relation ) ! :ole ( :i* x =ms a "p4 ,no "o c\ld ev] get a correct notion ( a p>ticul> /> by direct+ 8 entire att5tion to ! /udy ( t />4 ,to und]/& x1 he mu/ /udy x ?r\gh ! sy/em ( :i* x =ms a memb]1 & 9 connection ) all laws & =ces relat$ to x4 ,oxyg5 sep>ate & di/9ct f o!r elem5ts has no mean+4 ,x gets its def9ition & significance f ! ?+s to :i* x is relat$4 ,:at x is = rocks & wat] & trees & globes1 t x is 9 itself4 ,b x mu/ be se5 9 connection ) ^! be=e we c "k :at x is 9 itself4 ,:at an acid is = an alkali & = o!r ?+s1 t x is 9 itself4 ,alone1 out ( relation1 we c\ld "k absolutely no?+ ( x4 ,society is ! organism t reveals to ea* p]son ! nature ( 8 own life4 ,out ( contact & t\* ) o!r human be+s1 no "o w\ld ev] "k any?+ conc]n+ himself4 ,objective reality embraces manifold v>iety1 b x is ! unity t presides ov] x t makes x intelligible4 ,diff]5ce provokes que/ions & unity answ]s !m4 ,9 call+ objective reality tru?1 we tacitly assume ! laws & relations con/itutive ( x4 ,we c\ld n speak ( ! tru? ( ! globe1 _h !re be5 no me?od 9 its =mation1 no ord] 9 its developm5t1 no sy/em 9 its p>ts1 & no relations betwe5 its con/itu5t elem5ts4 ,to speak ( ! tru? ( x1 is to imply ! ?\ght ( x1 ! intelligibility ( x4 ,7 x n ! expression ( m9d1 man's reason c\ld f9d no tru? 9 x4 ,s*ol>s h be5 able1 aft] long & pa9/ak+ /udy1 to und]/& ! mean+ ( ,egyptian & ,assyrian hi]oglyphics1 b !y nev] c\ld h f\nd ?\ght 9 !m1 _h !y conta9$ no ?\ght4 ,! orig9al elem5ts :i* make up ! matt] ( ! globe1 h come into su* relations ) "o ano!r z t !y make up ! soil1 rocks1 wat]1 trees1 & animals we see4 ,?\ght1 !n1 is ! result ( ! int]nal relations ( ! p>ticles :i* compose x4 ,^! int]nal relations1 too1 con/itute its intelligibility4 ,! globe t :eels on its axis is objective4 ,?is may be tak5 into ! m9d1 & by its syn!siz+1 organiz+ activity conv]t$ into a subjective globe4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 ! objective & ! subjective globe w be1 t "o w be ?\ght & ! o!r w be ?+4 ,b ! same int]nal relations f\nd 9 ! objective globe w be pres]v$ 9 ! subjective1 & ! transcript ( ! globe t is held 9 ?\ght w be tru? 9 exact proportion z x corresponds to ! mat]ial globe t rolls out ( ! m9d4 ,t an objective globe1 :i* is a ?+1 may become a subjective globe1 :i* is a ?\ght & n a ?+1 implies t !re is some?+ 9 common betwe5 ?\ghts & ?+s2 t is1 ! m9d1 by its con/itution1 is capable ( appreh5d+ & tak+ into itself ! con/itution & relations ( ?+s4 ,?is is its capacity = tru?1 & %[s t tru? is n =eign to x1 b "o ) itself4 ,! sides & angles ( a "r angle triangle h c]ta9 relations to "o ano!r4 ,! squ>e describ$ on ! hypot5use ( su* an angle is equal to ! squ>es describ$ on ! o!r two sides4 ,?is may be demon/rat$ on a piece ( blank pap]1 or ! m9d may conceive a "r angle triangle1 & prove ! proposition )\t mak+ any m>ks at all4 ,! con/itutional relations :i* 7 9 ! nature ( a "r angle triangle are ! same1 :e!r x be drawn on pap] or conceiv$ by ! imag9ation4 ,! relations ( ! triangle make x intelligible1 because !y con/itute its tru?4 ,i4 ,to tru? ! intellect is relat$1 z is ! eye to light1 & ! e> to s\nd4 ,if ! eye 7 de/roy$1 ! sun w\ld n cease to %9e4 ,8 light w\ld /ill come ^u hill & pla9 to fe$ ! fl[]s & to disclose _! beauty1 b )\t ! organ ( vision no creature 9 ! univ]se w\ld be able to see ! ?+s :i* 8 light reveals4 ,! e> does n create s\nd4 ,let x be =ev] seal$1 & ! ,niag>as w\ld /ill cont9ue to fall & ! ?und]s to %ake ! heav5s1 b !y w\ld n be he>d4 ,! intellect does n create tru?1 b x is ! only faculty ) :i* man is end[$ by :i* he is able to discov] x4 ,x 0 ! error ( ! ideali/s t !y made ! ord]1 laws1 & relations ( ?+s z s _m pr9ciples project$ out ( ! obs]v]'s own m9d into ! univ]se ab\t him4 ,:at he seem$ to see 9 ?+s1 7 b modifications ( 8 own m5tal /ates4 ,! only ord] ?+s _h 0 9 ! obs]v]'s own m9d4 ,x 0 reg>d$ n only z ! pivot ^u :i* ! univ]se turn$1 b also z ! creative pr9ciple f :i* ! univ]se took =m4 ,app>5tly ?is 0 a great ga9 to m9d1 b x 0 at ! exp5se ( any real _w = ! m9d to contemplate4 ,x seem$ to w9 a victory = ! intellig5ce absolute & entire1 b x 0 by %utt+ x up to its own %ad[y ab/ractions1 & ab&on+ x 9 a %oreless & bottomless void to its own va9 mus+s4 ,! p]sonal pron\n ,i 0 ext5d$ p]p5dicul>ly & horizontally1 till topways & sideways ! :ole ( space & "t 0 fill$ ) x4 ,no solid e>?1 no burn+ sun1 no roll+ orbs 7 left4 ,a great1 illimitable1 irresponsible ego became ! sole occupant ( all t is4 ,?is extreme idealism is 9 direct contra/ to ! realism ( ! e>ly ?9k]s4 ,!y taught t ?+s dep5d$ on man nei!r = _! exi/5ce nor _! intelligibility4 ,t ea* ?+ c>ri$ ! real intelligible ess5ce z an ultimate fact 9 itself4 ,?\ght 9 man 0 b ! reflection ( ?is intelligible ess5ce 9 ! ?+1 z ! light 9 ! mirror is b ! reflection ( ! light ( ! lamp4 ,( ! two sy/ems1 extreme idealism is pref]able to extreme realism4 ,all m9d & no matt]1 is bett] ?an all matt] & no m9d4 ,?\ght ) no place to /&1 is bett] ?an a place to /& & no ?\ght4 ,! eye ) no?+ to see1 is bett] ?an some?+ to see & no eye4 ,! solution :i* realism gave ( ! problem ( exi/5ce1 left no place = m9d1 ! solution :i* idealism gave ( x left no place = matt]4 ,b bo? ! ext]nal _w1 ^u :i* realism 0 f\nd$1 & ! intellig5ce1 ^u :i* idealism 0 f\nd$1 are expressions ( m9d4 ,! "o z intelligible cont5t1 ! o!r z comb9+ active capacity & ! intelligibility ( ! cont5t1 exactly corresponds to ! active grasp ( ! capacity4 ,,ii4 ,b x mu/ be rememb]$ t ! intellect :i* is ! organ ( tru?1 & objective reality :i* is ab/ract tru?1 d n come toge!r to =m k 9 any accid5tal way4 ,a basket may be said to h capacity = hold+ potatoes1 & potatoes may l5d !mselves z cont5t to fill up ! basket4 ,b ! union ( potatoes & basket2 ! "o z cont5t1 ! o!r z capacity1 is only me*anical4 ,! basket w\ld s]ve z well to hold onions1 or muskad9es1 or *9quep9s1 z potatoes1 & ! potatoes c\ld be c>ri$ z well 9 a wood5 box or 9 a t9 pan1 z 9 a basket4 ,no necessity inh]es 9 ! nature ( a basket to conta9 potatoes1 & no necessity is 9 ! nature ( potatoes to get into a basket4 ,tru? & ! intellect1 h[ev]1 are int5d$ ! "o = ! o!r4 ,tru? is correlat$ to ! intellect z ! bird's w+ is to ! atmosph]e4 ,no?+ c take hold ( ! tru? b ! intellect1 & no?+ c satisfy & furni% ! intellect b tru?4 ,ab/ract tru?1 or objective reality1 is conv]t$ by ! comb9+ organiz+ activity ( ! m9d into k1 & :5 ?is k corresponds to ! reality x is tru? 9 ! realm ( ?\ght4 ,be=e k is possible1 !n1 !re mu/ be an intellig5ce capable ( kn[+1 & an object capable ( be+ kn[n4 ,h[ ! intellig5ce & ! kn[able object get toge!r to =m k is ! mo/ important "q 9 philosophy4 ,^u ! "r settlem5t ( x1 ev]y?+ dep5ds4 ,?is has be5 ! po9t ab\t :i* ! battle ( ?\ght1 9 mod]n times1 has be5 mo/ fi]cely wag$4 ,if ! m9d firmly grasps ! mean+ ( ?is problem & settles x "r1 x is almo/ sure to ?9k "r on o!r que/ions4 ,if x is wrong "h1 x is sure to be wrong ev]y:]e else4 ,mi/ake "h is z fatal to ! correct solution ( ! "q we are consid]+1 z w\ld be ! mi/ake t two & two make five to ! correct solution ( a sum 9 ari?metic4 ,,iii4 ,! di/ance ( a "q f ord9>y ?\ght does n r5d] x any ! less important1 ev5 = ord9>y ?9k+4 ,h[ ! kn[+ intellig5ce & ! kn[able object get toge!r to =m k is ! mo/ important problem to-day be=e ! human m9d4 ,if writ]s w\ld only take _! be>+s f ! only rational solution t c be giv5 to x1 !y w\ld f9d half ! books !y are writ+ on ! inspiration ( ! ,scriptures1 ! exi/5ce ( ,god1 ! div9ity ( ,jesus ,*ri/1 agno/icism & mat]ialism1 unnecess>y4 ,agno/icism & mat]ialism pass away ) a correct !ory ( kn[+4 ,labor & pa9/ak+ ?\ght are involv$ 9 ! task ( gett+ a "r !ory ( k1 b agno/icism & mat]ialism are 9 l9e ) ignorance & indol5ce4 ,s1 :ile few m5 ev] ask !mselves h[ ! kn[+ intellig5ce & ! kn[able object get toge!r to =m k1 millions ( m5 are affect$1 ev5 9 _! practical life1 by ! answ] :i* is giv5 to ! "q4 ,someone has said t n m ?an six m5 9 any "o age ev] read ,plato or und]/& him4 ,yet = ! six m5 ,plato comes d[n ?r\gh ! ages4 ,! six m5 :o und]/& him translate him into ! v]nacul> ( ! "o hundr$ m5 :o live on ! next plane ( ?\ght bel[ !m4 ,! "o hundr$ translate him into ! common language ( "o ?\s& bel[ !m4 ,^!1 9 turn1 translate ,plato into ! ord9>y ?\ght ( ! millions bel[ !m4 ,s x happ5s at l5g? t ,plato gets s univ]sally kn[n1 t n a labor] 9 ! field b we>s 8 hat aft] "o /yle1 r ?an ano!r1 because ,plato wrote4 ,d\btless x w\ld h be5 consid]$ a v unimportant "q two hundr$ ye>s ago1 z to :e!r heat 7 an igne\s fluid or a mode ( motion4 ,p]haps n m ?an two or ?ree m5 wre/l$ ) ! "q = c5turies be=e x 0 settl$4 ,by ! masses ( ! p !y 7 reg>d$ z wa/+ _! "t 9 va9 & idle speculation4 ,by an exp]im5t made by ,c\nt ,rum=d1 x 0 put beyond ! possibility ( d\bt t heat 0 n an igne\s fluid1 b a mode ( motion4 ,0 ?is a "q t conc]n$ ! multitudes1 t two or ?ree m5 sp5t a hundr$ ye>s talk+ ab\t & tortur+ _! bra9s to und]/&8 ,!re is n a s+le human be+ 9 ! civiliz$ _w to-day ^: int]e/s & welf>e h n be5 t\*$ by ! settlem5t ( x4 ,!re are millions ( peasants 9 ,russia :o nev] he>d ( ,c\nt ,rum=d1 or ( an igne\s fluid1 or ( caloric1 :o h ?is pres5t ye> be5 f$ by fl\r s5t !m by ! we/]n mill]s & transport$ on ! /r5g? ( ! conclusion t heat is n an igne\s fluid1 b a mode ( motion4 ,e /eam-c> t crosses ! cont95t1 & e /eamboat t crosses ! ocean1 moves 9 ! wake ( ?is same conclusion4 ,at fir/ we see "s algebraic =mulas1 an array ( curves & figures1 t practical p said _h no?+ to d ) ev]yday life4 ,aft] a :ile we see ! ab/ract conclusions rea*$ by aid ( ! algebraic signs1 & settl$ by ! te/ ( exp]im5t1 translat$ into /eam eng9es1 & transport+ ev5 ! peasants ( ,india & ,mexico f "o end ( ! c\ntry to ! o!r4 ,we see ! ab/ract conclusions ( ! few ?9k]s turn$ into /eam to sp9 ! p's clo!s & gr9d ! p's bread4 ,9 #afcb !re 0 born at ,wr+ton1 ,som]set%ire1 ,engl&1 a boy1 :o 0 educat$ at ! ,univ]sity ( ,ox=d4 ,9 ! e/eem ( 8 contempor>ies he devot$ 8 "t to ! consid]ation ( subjects ( no practical value4 ,9 ! c\rse ( ev5ts he put ! results ( 8 /udy into a book kn[n z 8,! ,essay on ! ,human ,und]/&+40 ,few p read x4 ,b ! few :o did read x />t$ ! ideas ( x to circulat+4 ,!y 7 translat$ into ,fr5* & ,lat91 & 7 soon pot5t influ5ces 9 ! intellectual life ( ,europe4 ,7 !y practical & did !y conc]n ! ord9>y affairs ( m58 ,!y creat$ ! ,encyclop$i/s ( ,france4 ,^! le>n$ m5 7 ! au?ors ( ! radical op9ions :i* cut ! p f ! moor+s ( traditional & age-long ?\ght4 ,! fire & ! blood ( ! ,revolution 7 ! legitimate expressions ( ! speculative essay ( ,john ,locke t n "o 9 t5 ?\s& ev] read4 ,! p]sons ^: heads 7 cut (f 9 ! ,reign ( ,t]ror mu/ h ?\ght ! ideas exce$+ly practical t l$ to ! de/ruction ( social & political in/itutions1 t took =m 9 a movem5t :i* respect$ nei!r law nor prop]ty nor life4 ,! speculative op9ions ( ,john ,locke n only help$ to create ! ,fr5* ,revolution1 b !y l$ to ! idealism ( ,bi%op ,b]keley1 & ?is 9 turn to ! skeptical philosophy ( ,david ,hume4 ,! mod]n successors ( ,hume are ,john ,/u>t ,mill1 ,h]b]t ,sp5c]1 ,leslie ,/eph51 ,fr$]ic ,h>rison1 & ,pr(essor ,huxley1 ^: contributions h be5 giv5 to ! popul> reviews1 & :i* h be5 read by all intellig5t p4 ,e man 9 ,europe & ,am]ica has be5 influ5c$ bo? 9 conduct & "* by ! speculative 8,essay on ! ,human ,und]/&+40 ,locke's speculative philosophy pass$ ?r\gh ,b]keley to ,hume1 & ?r\gh ,hume rea*$ ,kant1 ! great ,g]man ?9k]1 & result$ 9 ! 8,critique ( ,pure ,reason40 ,?is l$ to ,fi*te & ,s*ell+1 & f9ally to ,hegel4 ,?is l$ to ,heidelb]g & ! ,tb+5 s*ool1 to ,bau] & ,dewette1 to extreme idealism & rationalism1 translat$ into books & reviews & newspap]s1 & read by all ! p1 affect+ _! ?\ght & life4 ,ev5 p :o nev] read1 :o nev] op5 a book or a newspap]1 h be5 influ5c$ by ! subtle piece ( speculative reason+ giv5 to ! _w by ! great s5sational philosoph] ( ,engl&4 ,! _s ( utilit>ianism & secul>ism preval5t ?r\gh\t ! _w at ! pres5t "t is easily traceable to x4 ,,iv4 ,be=e we c possibly "k t tru? is ! provision = ! intellectual nature ( man1 we mu/ det]m9e :e!r ! kn[+ faculties1 :i* he f9ds himself to possess1 are capable ( grasp+ tru? & turn+ x into k4 ,! fight ( skepticism 9 mod]n times has be5 made ^u ! kn[+ faculties4 ,x is useless to talk ab\t ! exi/5ce ( ,god1 ! inspiration ( ! ,scriptures1 ! div9ity ( ,*ri/1 or ! immortality ( ! s\l1 if ! human intellect is1 by its limitations1 d5i$ ! possibility ( kn[+ any?+ :atsoev] conc]n+ ^! ?+s4 ,x is a wa/e ( "t = me to attempt to dip wat] out ( ! ocean ) a bucket ) no bottom to x4 ,:at is ! relation ( ! intellig5ce to ! out] _w8 ,does ! outside _w create k 9 ! m9d by ! impressions x makes ^u x1 or does ! m9d br+ some?+ to ! outside _w :i* conv]ts ?is raw mat]ial into k8 ,is k a reflection ( ! out]1 or a creation ( ! inn]8 ,does nature "w x 9 u1 or is !re "s spontane\s1 creative1 organiz+1 m5tal activity )9 u t takes ! mat]ial pres5t$ by nature1 turn+ x into a rational sy/em ( k8 ,:at is ! relation betwe5 ! be+ t kn[s & ! object kn[n8 ,h[ mu* ( ! creative factor ( k does nature supply8 ,h[ mu* does man supply8 ,c a man ) d]ang$ faculties get ord] out ( a rational _w8 ,c a man ( sane m9d get ord] out ( an irrational _w8 ,if !re is to be a rational sy/em ( k built up 9 ! m9d1 mu/ !re n be reason 9 ! ?9k] & reason 9 ! outside _w1 com+ into organic relations1 ! "o ) ! o!r8 ,z to h[ we reg>d ?is "q w det]m9e h[ we reg>d tru?1 & :e!r or n x is possible = u to "k x4 ,v4 ,! human m9d has nev] be5 able to resi/ ! conviction t !re is su* a ?+ z tru?4 ,?\gh baffl$ & defeat$ a ?\s& times1 9 e age1 9 its attempt to =mulate tru?1 x has nev] be5 able to cons5t to give up ! se>* = x4 ,int]e/ 9 tru? has kept alive & fo/]$ ! belief t ! m9d has p[] to und]/& x4 ,! m9d's passion = tru? has deep5$ its confid5ce 9 ! faculties ) :i* x is ev] try+ to discov] x4 ,! ev]la/+ long+ to "k tru? has be5 tak5 z implicit capacity to f9d x4 ,philosophic sy/ems h be5 only s _m devices & creations ( ! m9d ) :i* to take hold ( tru?4 ,! me?ods propos$1 9 ! fir/ /ages ( philosophic ?9k+1 = gett+ at ! tru? 7 crude1 z ! fir/ in/rum5ts devis$ = cultivat+ ! soil & gett+ out ( x :at !re 0 9 x = food1 7 crude4 ,?ales1 ,py?agoras1 & ,anaxim&] fir/ attempt$ to p5etrate objective reality1 to "k its cause1 to br+ its multiplicity to unity1 & to r$uce its v>iety to law4 ,! ev]-*ang+ ph5om5a by :i* !y 7 surr\nd$ necess>ily elud$ ! meag] !ories ) :i* !y attempt$ to r$uce !m to ord]4 ,!y prep>$ ! way1 h[ev]1 = sy/ems :i* accommodat$ a great] numb] ( facts4 ,!y made possible ,plato & ,ari/otle1 :o1 ) hypo!ses m complicat$ & m consonant ) ! reality !y s\ght to grasp1 f\nd tru? en\gh to keep ! human race ?9k+ = two ?\s& ye>s4 ,! blocks ( tru? !y qu>ri$ f ! m9es ( objective reality 7 us$ to c>ry up ! !ological & speculative temples ( ! ,middle ,ages4 ,aft] ! failure ( s*ola/icism1 :i* d5otes a p]iod 9 human ?\ght r ?an a p>ticul> sy/em ( philosophy1 ,"l ,bacon propos$ ! me?od ( mat]ial induction to br+ ! m9d into relations ( k ) tru?4 ,he emphasiz$ ! /udy ( ! outw>d facts1 _! classification & organization4 ,9 8 e/eem1 tru? 0 to be rea*$ by ! consid]ation ( actual1 tangible ?+s4 ,man 0 ! int]pret] ( nature1 & n necess>ily its int]pretation4 ,tru? 9 ! m9d 0 ! image ( objective tru?4 ,x diff]$ f tru? out ( ! m9d1 z ! direct f ! reflect$ ray4 ,he fail$ f lack ( adequate recognition ( "o ( ! important factors 9 ! problem ( tru?4 ,desc>tes' me?od 0 m successful1 because l>g] & complet] recognition 0 tak5 ( man4 ,he began by d\bt+ ev]y?+ t c\ld be d\bt$4 ,heir to ! beliefs ( all ! ages1 he det]m9$ to summon ^!1 "o by "o1 be=e ! b> ( reason1 & =ce !m to %[ cause = _! exi/5ce4 ,ev]yone 0 to be call$ into c\rt & put out t c\ld be d\bt$4 ,! exi/5ce ( a ,god 0 call$ up & d\bt$1 condemn$1 & put out4 ,! exi/5ce ( an ext]nal _w 0 call$ up1 d\bt$1 condemn$1 & put out4 ,9 ! same summ>y & %or?& way1 man & m9d 7 d\bt$ & put out4 ,all positive beliefs 7 d\bt$4 ,aft] 8 process ( elim9ation1 he f\nd himself )\t ,god1 )\t man1 )\t m9d1 )\t a p]man5t ext]nal _w4 ,all t rema9$ aft] empty+ himself ( all m5tal furni%m5ts & beliefs 0 ! fact t he d\bt$4 ,b he c\ld n d\bt )\t ?9k+4 ,9 ! v act ( d\bt+1 he ?\ght4 ,if "o ?9ks1 he mu/ ?9k some?+4 ,! ne>e/ some?+ to ! ?9k+ subject is 8 own p]sonal be+4 ,s he ?\ght himself & conclud$1 8,i ?9k1 !re=e1 ,i am40 ,b he 0 n always2 he began to be4 ,s he mu/ ?9k ( a be+ t caus$ him4 ,! be+ t caus$ him mu/ himself be uncaus$4 ,moreov]1 !re c\ld n be an uncaus$ cause1 )\t an effect4 ,creation1 !n1 ) :i* he /ood face to face1 0 ! effect ( ! great fir/ cause4 ,?us ,desc>tes' me?od1 bas$ ^u ! ?\ght und]ly+ d\bt1 l$ him1 necess>ily1 to himself1 ! object ( 8 ?\ght2 & to ,god1 ! cause ( himself2 & to creation1 ! effect ( ! great fir/ cause or ,god4 ,?r\gh 8 process ( com+ at ! problem1 he 0 able1 rationally1 to believe 9 ! exi/5ce ( himself1 ! out] _w1 & ,god1 ! cause ( bo?4 ,desc>tes1 z a ?9k]1 0 affirmative1 positive1 con/ructive4 ,he only d\bt$ d[n to ! po9t :]e he c\ld d\bt no long]1 t he might h a sure f\ndation ^u :i* to build4 ,8 contribution gave fre% c\rage & inspiration to ! human m9d4 ,he fail$ to det]m9e ! b\nd>y l9e betwe5 ! self & ! n-self1 betwe5 m9d & matt]1 betwe5 ! ?9k] & ! creation ) :i* he /ood face to face4 ,?is 0 ! "w ,sp9oza propos$ = himself1 & 9 ! celebrat$ ,e?ics1 publi%$ to ! _w at ! p]il ( 8 life & s\l1 imag9$ ! task ma!matically p]=m$4 ,! two poles ( ,desc>tes' philosophy1 ! self & ! n-self1 he unit$ 9 ,desc>tes' cause1 & nam$ ! :ole sum sub/ance4 ,! self & ! n-self reappe>$ z attributes ( sub/ance1 :i* ,sp9oza nam$ ?\ght & ext5sion4 ,all ! ph5om5a 9 ! univ]se1 m5tal or mat]ial1 7 b modes ( ! inf9ite sub/ance4 ,! result ( 8 ?9k+ 0 pure pan!ism4 ,he rea*$ a sort ( me*anical unity1 b he left no place = ! affirmation ( di/9ctions4 ,8 ,e?ics 0 l>ge en\gh to accommodate ev]y?+1 b 9 su* a way z to pres]ve ! individuality ( no?+4 ,a ?\ght is valuable 9 proportion to its capacity to take hold ( ?+s z !y are4 ,! old op9ion t heat 0 caloric1 s]v$ z a work+ hypo!sis = ! m9d a long "t4 ,9 ! view ( ^? :o held x1 x 0 satisfactory & adequate4 ,b x nev] really got hold ( heat1 because x contradict$ ! nature ( heat4 ,! a/ronom]s ?\ght1 = a long "t1 t !y _h come into relations ( k ) ! />s ?r\gh ! ,ptolemaic conception ( ! heav5ly bodies4 ,!y 7 mi/ak51 h[ev]4 ,_! !ory did n fit ! real cele/ial ord] at all4 ,z a "w ( g5ius1 ,sp9oza's ,e?ics is "o ( ! mo/ rem>kable productions ev] =mulat$ by ! human intellect1 b x conduct$ ! m9d away f tru?1 r ?an into relations ) x4 ,locke began 8 "w z a philosoph]1 z ,desc>tes began 81 by look+ into 8 own m9d4 ,desc>tes began by ca/+ out ev]y?+ t c\ld be d\bt$4 ,locke began by mak+ an inv5tory ( :at 8 m9d conta9$4 ,desc>tes want$ to f9d out h[ mu* he c\ld "k1 z measur$ by :at rema9$ aft] ?r[+ out ev]y?+ t c\ld be d\bt$4 ,locke s\ght to see h[ little he c\ld "k1 by putt+ ! s5sations & impressions he f\nd 9 8 m9d on ! witness /&1 & gett+ !m to tell h[ !y came to be !re1 & :]e !y came f4 ,desc>tes began by a /udy ( ! intellig5ce1 ! in/rum5t ( k4 ,locke began by a /udy ( ! facts :i*1 by "s means or o!r1 _h f\nd _! way into 8 intellig5ce4 ,desc>tes got rid ( e belief t c\ld be d\bt$4 ,locke ran e idea out ( 8 m9d t _h be5 import$ f ! outside _w1 9 ord] t he might see if ! m9d _h any con/itutional p[] to produce any4 ,desc>tes1 hav+ dislodg$ all inh]it$ beliefs1 su* z took = grant$ ! exi/5ce ( ,god1 man1 m9d1 & out] _w1 f\nd "s m5tal laws1 capabilities1 & t5d5cies left1 :i* compell$ a man1 if he ?\ght at all1 to ?9k 9 a giv5 way2 & if he ?\ght on giv5 l9es1 to ?9k to a giv5 conclusion4 ,n be+ able to get ^! laws out ( ! m9d1 he call$ !m innate ideas4 ,!y 7 9 ! m9d by /ructure & con/itution4 ,aft] ,locke _h c>efully exam9$ ! cont5ts ( 8 m9d1 he decl>$ !y 7 all import$ f an outside realm4 ,no?+ he f\nd 9 ! m9d 0 indig5\s to ! soil4 ,:5 all =eign importations 7 remov$1 no?+ rema9$ b an empty vessel4 ,! m9d 0 no?+ b a receptacle1 into :i* ! s5ses dump$ su* objects z !y happ5$ to f9d ly+ r\nd loose 9 ! outside _w4 ,x _h no m p[] to und]/& or turn into ?\ght :at 0 br\ght 9 ?an a piece ( :ite pap] _h to read & int]pret :at 0 writt5 ^u x2 or ?an a kettle to recognize ! liquid mak+ up its cont5ts z wat]4 ,x is l a table ( wax2 any sort ( lett]s may be grav5 ^u x1 b ! table _c read !m4 ,locke propos$ to f9d out :at ! m9d c\ld "k by c\nt+ & tabulat+ ! ?+s he f\nd 9 8 own intellig5ce4 ,?is is v mu* l try+ to und]/& ! nature ( light1 by consid]+ ! blue ?+s & gre5 ?+s & r$ ?+s ! light discloses4 ,all bodies1 x is said1 :i* ! light enables u to see1 attract ea* o!r 9 proportion to _! mass1 & inv]sely z ! squ>es ( _! di/ance4 ,! law ( gravity1 :i* regulates ! bodies light reveals to u1 is n ! law ( light4 ,we c nev] und]/& ! nature ( light1 or ! laws ( light1 by ! /udy ( ?+s :i* light enables u to see4 ,if all k is b ! sum ( ! impressions :i* ! ext]nal _w has made on ! m9d1 !n ! cause ( k is matt]1 & k is b ! image or reflection ( mat]ial ?+s4 ,k1 !n1 w\ld su/a9 ! same relation to ! outside _w1 t ! %ad[ ( a tree does to ! tree4 ,"o w\ld come z ne> lift+ up ! tree by its own %ad[ z lift+ up ! tru? by ,locke's sy/em ( s5sational philosophy4 ,impressions are simple1 atomic4 ,!y come into ! m9d1 "o aft] ano!r4 ,!y coh]e 9 no unity4 ,!y are held toge!r by no necess>y relation4 ,!y are sep>ate1 "o f ! o!r4 ,if !re is no prim>y1 innate faculty2 no abid+ & indwell+ m5tal activity1 t lies beh9d1 & det]m9es & co-ord9ates ! objects :i* nature supplies ?r\gh ! s5ses1 conv]t+ !m into rational1 ord]ly k1 !n we c nev] get hold ( tru?4 ,we are %ut up to hopeless ignorance4 ,,vi4 ,b]keley1 9 ord] to escape ! mat]ialism to :i* ,locke's philosophy l$1 accept$ 8 !ory ( k1 b de/roy$ 8 outw>d1 mat]ial _w4 ,9 8 view1 !re 0 no matt]1 no?+ b ideas4 ,! impressions convey$ ?r\gh ! s5ses into our m9ds are b reflections ( ! ideas ( ,god4 ,9 ,hume1 ! empirical !ory ( kn[+ f\nd a disciple :o did n hesitate to affirm all t 0 involv$ 9 x4 ,locke said !re 0 an outw>d _w1 & k 0 its image4 ,b]keley said !re 0 no mat]ial _w2 t k 0 ! reflection ( ,god's ideas4 ,hume said !re 0 nei!r out] _w nor inn]2 t !re 0 no?+ b impressions1 s5sations1 ideas1 9 p]petual fl[ & flux4 ,he claim$ t all ideas :i* c\ld n be resolv$ into impressions 7 false4 ,he decl>$ we c\ld h no ideas ( sub/ance1 because1 if p]ceiv$ by ! eye1 x mu/ be a color2 if by ! e>1 a s\nd2 if by ! palate1 a ta/e4 ,& because we c\ld n ?9k ( sub/ance z a color or a s\nd or a ta/e1 we c\ld !re=e h no idea ( x :atev]4 ,belief 9 a p]man5t ext]nal _w 0 r5d]$ irrational by 8 !ory ( k4 ,no?+ is m vital & irrepressible ?an belief 9 "o's own exi/5ce1 b ev5 ?is c\ld n be reta9$ 9 accordance ) ! tea*+s ( ,hume's philosophy4 8,:5ce10 says he1 8c\ld ! impression ( ! idea ( self be d]iv$8 ,:at impression c\ld create ?is idea8 ,?is "q x is impossible to answ] )\t a manife/ contradiction & absurdity1 & yet x is a "q t mu/ necess>ily be answ]$4 ,= my "p1 :5 ,i ent] mo/ intimately into :at ,i call myself1 ,i always /umble ^u "s p]ception or o!r2 heat or cold1 light or %ade1 pa9 or pleasure4 ,i _c cat* myself at any "t )\t a p]ception1 or obs]ve any?+ b a p]ception4 ,:5 my p]ceptions are remov$ at any "t1 z by s\nd sleep1 s long am ,i ins5sible ( myself1 & may be said truly n to exi/40 ,! s5sational philosophy :i* promis$ s mu*1 :i* appe>$ s em95tly practical1 t took to itself su* an air ( common s5se z x got ab\t oblit]at+ innate ideas1 0 se5 at l5g? to be utt]ly impot5t4 ,x correspond$ ) absolutely no?+ 9 heav5 or 9 e>?4 ,! v impressions x admitt$1 pass$ ?r\gh x l drops ( wat] out ( a fi%]man's net4 ,:]e ! impressions came f or :]e !y w5t to1 x furni%$ no means ( kn[+4 ,god & _w & cause & law & self might be1 b ! human m9d c\ld nev] "k :e!r !y 7 or n4 ,! human obs]v] /ood be=e a procession ( images1 s5sations1 p]ceptions go+ by l an un5d+ circus tr\pe4 ,9 ,hume may be trac$ ! entire breakd[n ( empirical philosophy z a me?od = gett+ at ! tru?4 ,he recogniz$ ?is himself4 8,:5 ,i turn my eye inw>d10 he says1 8,i f9d no?+ b d\bt & ignorance40 8,! und]/&+1 :5 x acts alone1 & accord+ to its mo/ g5]al pr9ciples1 entirely subv]ts itself1 & leaves n ! l[e/ degree ( evid5ce 9 any proposition1 ei!r 9 philosophy or common life40 8,we h1 !re=e1 no *oice left1 b betwixt a false reason & none at all40 ,,vii4 ,! mo/ rem>kable ?+ 9 ! :ole se>* = tru?1 is t anybody aft] ,hume %\ld h attempt$ to f9d x ) ,hume's pr9ciples4 ,yet ! two be/ kn[n writ]s :o h liv$ 9 ,engl& s9ce ,hume's day1 h re/$ _! dogmatic doctr9es on ! f\ndations laid by ! s5sational philosoph]s4 ,hume's impressions & ideas became ,john ,/u>t ,mill's p]man5t possibilities ( s5sation & feel+1 & ,h]b]t ,sp5c]'s vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[able4 ,9 our "t ,h]b]t ,sp5c] has und]tak5 ! h]culean task ( expla9+ matt] & m9d1 "t & space1 society & morals2 ( %[+ :at !y are & :at !y are n1 by ! same pr9ciples :i* ,hume himself demon/rat$ to be incapable ( expla9+ any?+4 ,sp5c]'s units ( k are vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! ,unkn[n4 ,h[ ! unkn[able rema9s unkn[n1 aft] vividly & fa9tly manife/+ itself1 we are n told4 ,mr4 ,sp5c]'s vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[n are old acqua9tances ) new names4 ,locke knew !m z impressions & s5sations4 ,b]keley recogniz$ !m z ideas ( s5se & imag9ation4 ,john ,/u>t ,mill 0 on speak+ t]ms ) !m z p]man5t possibilities ( s5sation & feel+4 ,mr4 ,sp5c] gives !m ano!r baptism & ano!r "n4 ,he calls !m vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[able4 ,:ile !y h be5 *ang$ 9 "n1 h[ev]1 x mu/ n be suppos$ t !y h und]gone any *ange 9 nature or "*4 ,!y /& ap>t1 ! "o f ! o!r1 j ! same z ev]4 ,!y are j z =eign to ! m9d1 :]e !y vividly & fa9tly manife/ !mselves1 z 7 ! impressions ( ,john ,locke4 ,!y fl>e & flick]1 rise & fall1 l ! jack-o'-lant]n lights ( leg5d & tale4 ,"o light is n ( a piece ) any o!r light4 ,! lights foll[ "o ano!r 9 su* quick succession1 fir/ vivid1 !n fa9t1 t "o _c tell f ! mom5t>y flames & fla%es :at is int5d$ to be adv]tis$4 ,t some?+ is try+1 by v>i\s pyrote*nic displays1 to get itself reveal$ seems to be evid5t4 ,b !re is su* hurry on ! "p ( ! some?+ t makes ! manife/ations1 su* a disord]ly :irl & *ang+ ( lights1 t ! obs]v] is totally bewild]$2 &1 be+ "u ! necessity ( mak+ "s acc\nt to himself z to _! mean+1 concludes t !y are vivid & fa9t illum9ations ( ! unkn[able4 ,hume's procession ( s5sations & ideas has by ,sp5c] be5 conv]t$ into ! fire-works ( ! unkn[able4 ,) ,hume's physiological !ory1 ! m9d c\ld "k no?+ b its own s5sations4 ,sp5c]'s vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[able are equally z incapable ( furni%+ any rational basis = belief 9 m9d or matt]1 law or cause1 self or ,god4 ,to ask ! human m9d to believe ! encyclop$ic1 dogmatic sy/em ( philosophy he address$ to x1 aft] insi/+ t all our k is b ! sum ( vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[able1 is z irrational z try+ to build a ca!dral on a ,london fog bank4 ,und]nea? e "o ( ,sp5c]'s g5]al t]ms1 ! inde/ructibility ( matt]1 ! cont9uity ( motion1 ! p]si/5ce ( =ce1 !re is no?+ b s5sations1 vivid or fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[n4 8,! doctr9e ( ! inde/ructibility ( matt]10 he says1 8has n[ become a commonplace40 8,matt] nev] ei!r comes into exi/5ce1 or ceases to exi/40 ,h[ are we to "k ?is1 ) m9ds incapable ( any o!r k except su* z is made up ( vivid & fa9t manife/ations ( ! unkn[n8 ,:o ev] _h a s5sation or a manife/ation ( ! inde/ructibility ( matt]8 ,?is is an idea involv+ all pa/ "t & all future "t1 & all ! laws & =ces by :i* matt] is regulat$ & cons]v$4 ,h[ c\ld an image ( ! inde/ructibility ( matt] be photograph$ on ! s5sitive plate ( ! m9d8 ,to d ?is x w\ld be necess>y to compress all pa/ "t & all future "t into "o mom5t1 & all matt] into "o s+le squ>e in* or squ>e y>d ( space1 s t ! impression ( x c\ld be made4 ,to believe 9 ! inde/ructibility ( matt]1 ) ,mr4 ,sp5c]'s !ory ( ! m9d's capacity to "k1 is delirium & insanity4 ,x is to believe 9 some?+ t ! m9d1 by its v nature1 _c ev5 get an impression (4 ,x is believ+ t ! ocean c be c>ri$ 9 a ?imble )\t any bottom4 ,any man :o %\ld utt] ?is publicly1 & s9c]ely1 w\ld be put 9 ! insane asylum4 ,he says aga91 8! v nature ( ! intellig5ce negatives ! supposition t motion c be conceiv$ 7mu* less kn[n7 ei!r to comm5ce or to cease40 ,! nature ( ! intellig5ce is su* t all ! k x possesses is made up ( s5sations & manife/ations ( ! unkn[n4 ,h[ c ! cont9uity ( motion be conceiv$8 ,to d ?is1 we mu/ h a conception ( all pa/ "t & all future "t4 ,x is an idea z transc5d5t z ! idea ( ,god4 ,mr4 ,sp5c] claims t ! p[] ! univ]se manife/s to u is utt]ly inscrutable2 t space & "t are :olly incompreh5sible2 t matt]1 9 its ultimate nature1 is z absolutely incompreh5sible z space & "t2 t all ef=ts to und]/& ! ess5tial nature ( motion d b br+ u to alt]native absurdities ( ?\ght2 t x is impossible to =m any idea ( =ce 9 itself1 & equally impossible to compreh5d ei!r its mode ( ex]cise or its law ( v>iation2 t we are unable to believe or to conceive t ! duration ( consci\sness is inf9ite1 & equally unable to "k x z f9ite1 or to conceive x z f9ite2 & t ! p]sonality ( :i* we are ea* consci\s1 & ( :i* ! exi/5ce is to ea* a fact beyond all o!rs ! mo/ c]ta91 yet is a ?+ :i* _c tru?fully be kn[n at all3 k ( x is =bidd5 by ! v nature ( ?\ght4 ,all ?is is p]fectly consi/5t ) 8 !ory ( k4 ,?is is ! po9t to :i* ,david ,hume1 8 ma/]1 conduct$ ! human m9d 9 its se>* = tru?4 ,b ,sp5c] is n logical2 he _h a !ory ( be+ t contradict$ 8 !ory ( kn[+4 ,s he reasons fir/ "o way & !n ano!r4 ,he says1 else:]e 9 8 ,fir/ ,pr9ciples1 t common s5se ass]ts ! exi/5ce ( a reality2 t objective sci5ce proves t ?is reality _c be :at we ?9k x2 t subjective sci5ce %[s :y we _c ?9k ( x z x is1 & yet are compell$ to ?9k ( x z exi/+2 & t 9 ?is ass]tion ( a reality utt]ly inscrutable 9 nature1 religion f9ds an ass]tion ess5tially co9cid+ ) h] own4 ,t we are compell$ to reg>d e ph5om5on z a manife/ation ( "s p[] by :i* we are act$ ^u4 ,t ?\gh omnipres5ce is un?9kable1 yet z exp]i5ce discloses no b\nds to ! diffusion ( ph5om5a1 we are unable to ?9k ( limits to ! pres5ce ( ?is p[]1 :ile ! criticisms ( sci5ce tea* u t ?is p[] is incompreh5sible4 ,analyz+ ! above decl>ations1 we f9d t ,mr4 ,sp5c] kn[s !re is an ultimate reality4 ,!n x has be+4 ,x acts ^u u4 ,!n x has ! attribute ( action4 ,all ph5om5a are manife/ations ( x4 ,!n x has p[]4 ,all ph5om5a are manife/ations ( an inscrutable p[]1 by :i* we are act$ ^u4 ,!n x has causal en]gy4 ,we are unable to ?9k ( limits to ! pres5ce ( ?is p[]4 ,!n x is omnipres5t4 ,s ! unkn[able1 inscrutable some?+ has be+1 p[]1 activity1 causal en]gy1 & omnipres5ce4 ,b h[ are we to grasp ^! univ]sal1 transc5d5tal attributes ( ! unkn[able1 ) an intellig5ce incapable ( receiv+ any?+ b simple1 sep>ate1 unrelat$1 brok5 impressions & manife/ations8 ,x takes z mu* m9d to believe 9 ! unkn[able1 ) ! attributes ( p[]1 activity1 be+1 causal en]gy1 & omnipres5ce1 z to believe 9 a self-exi/5t ,god1 ) ! attributes ( p[]1 wisdom1 ju/ice1 tru?1 & love4 ,sp5c]'s !ory ( kn[+ is de/ructive1 :ile 8 !ory ( be+ is con/ructive & transc5d5tal4 ,,viii4 ,! intellig5ce1 z ! organ ( tru?1 mu/ be l>ge en\gh to f9d tru? & conta9 tru?4 ,no sane man w\ld und]take to dig d[n a m\nta9 ) a too?pick4 ,mr4 ,sp5c] devot$ page aft] page to ! discussion ( cause1 "t1 space1 =ce1 & ultimate reality1 :ile hold+ a !ory ( k t made ! v ?\ght ( ^! inconceivable4 ,! v ?+s t he label$ z kn[able conta9$ a sub/rate ! m9d c\ld nev] get at4 ,kn[able ?+s1 !n1 c\ld n be kn[n z !y 72 h5ce if !y 7 kn[n at all1 mu/ be kn[n z !y 7 n1 :i* made ! m9d's k error4 ,all :o accept ,mr4 ,sp5c]'s !ory ( k are %ut up to absolute ignorance or absolute error4 ,if we are to "k ! tru? ( reality1 ( m9d1 ( ext]nal exi/5ce1 we mu/ h kn[+ faculties up to ! /yle ( ! tru? we are to "k4 ,if we are to "k light1 we mu/ h eyes capable ( tak+ 9 ! light1 ( analyz+ x1 & turn+ x into vision4 ,! disposition to limit our p[] to "k1 by tell+ u1 on ! /r5g? ( ,mansel & ,hamilton & ,kant1 t all our k is relative1 is innoc5t en\gh :5 /ripp$ ( its seem+ wisdom4 ,x is true t we c "k no m ?an our kn[+ faculties p]mit u4 ,we _c "k m ?an we c "k4 ,we are n absolute & omnisci5t z to our capacity to "k4 ,all we c see is :at we c see ) our eyes4 ,we _c see ) our f+]s or ) ! back ( our heads4 ,all we c he> is :at we c he> ) our e>s4 ,we h no o!r organs ) :i* to he>4 ,all s\nds t vibrate at ! rate ( sixte5 times to ! second up to ?irty-eight ?\s& times to ! second1 we c he>4 ,:atsoev] s\nds vibrate at a l[] rate ?an sixte5 times to ! second or at a high] rate ?an ?irty-eight ?\s& times to ! second1 we _c he>1 because su* s\nds are n relat$ to ! e>4 ,b ! eye1 be+ adju/$ to & relat$ to mu* f9] wave l5g?s ?an ! e>1 c see waves t vibrate up z high z sev5 hundr$ & tw5ty-sev5 trillion times to ! second4 ,! eye _c see waves %ort] ?an sev5 hundr$ & tw5ty-sev5 trillion vibrations to ! second1 because su* waves are n adju/$ to ! eye4 ,! waves ! e> _c he> are n s\nd waves4 ,! waves ! eye _c see are n light waves4 ,!re are no s\nd waves 9 ! univ]se ! e> _c he>1 provid$ !y are ne> en\gh to come into contact ) x4 ,!re are no light waves 9 ! univ]se t ! eye _c turn into vision1 if !y /rike ! ret9a4 ,are we go+ to fall out ) ! eye1 & discr$it ! beauty x does see1 because x is n z l>ge z ! rim ( imm5sity1 & _c see ev]y?+ disclos$ by ! light ( suns & />s at once8 ,are we to hold ! e> 9 contempt aft] x takes 9 ! h>monies ( ,bee?ov5 & ,moz>t1 because x _c he> all ! music ! />s are mak+ z !y move ?r\gh ! heav5s8 ,:atev] is real & true ! m9d c "k1 because ! m9d is correlat$ to ! real & ! true4 ,x _c "k :at is unreal & untrue4 ,x _c "k t two & two make five1 because t is unreal & untrue4 ,x _c "k t a crook$ l9e is ! %orte/ di/ance betwe5 two po9ts1 because t is unkn[able4 ,x _c "k t x is m rational to tell a lie ?an to tell ! tru?1 because t is unkn[able & untrue4 ,!re is mu* t is unkn[able1 b :atev] is1 we may be sure is irrational & unreal4 ,:atev] is true 9 be+1 cause1 "t1 space1 m9d1 matt]1 =ce1 motion may be kn[n4 ,! f9ite m9d _c "k x at once1 & c nev]1 ?r\gh\t all inf9ite "t1 directly take x into ! intellig5ce2 b x is kn[able1 because ! und]ly+1 fundam5tal1 prior ?+ 9 ! univ]se is m9d1 ! m9d ( ! absolute & et]nal ,"o4 ,all ?+s are set 9 ord] & reason4 ,! ext]nal univ]se is ! expression ( m9d1 & is !re=e intelligible4 ,! human intellig5ce is ! expression ( ! same m9d1 & is !re=e capable ( grasp+ & turn+ into ?\ght ! intelligible ord] )\t4 ,accord+ to ! !ory ( ,locke1 ,b]keley1 ,hume1 ,mill1 & ,sp5c]1 any k :atsoev] is impossible4 ,if ! kn[+ subject & ! kn[able object1 ! two factors ( k1 c only come toge!r 9 a me*anical way1 z basket & potatoes1 kettle & wat]1 pap] & lett]s1 !n ! v conditions ( k are d5i$1 & we are %ut up to blank1 squ>e ignorance4 ,?+s come toge!r to =m k1 z ?+s come toge!r to =m a tree1 & n z h\se1 calico1 p9s1 lace1 %oes1 & blankets come toge!r to =m a /ore4 ,an acorn is a liv+ some?+4 ,x is n a tree1 b )9 itself are ! g]ms ( a tree4 ,:5 gr[n1 x may be said to h =ms1 z root1 trunk1 & bran*es4 ,^! 7 pot5tially & ideally conta9$ 9 ! acorn4 ,b _! realization & active expression involv$ a process1 9 :i* ! ideal =ms1 t5d5cies1 & =ces conta9$ 9 g]m 9 ! acorn met & unit$ ) ! elem5ts ( ! outside _w4 ,suppose we consid] ! acorn ! subject1 & ! p>ticles 9 soil & ra9 & atmosph]e capable ( mak+ a tree z ! object4 ,:at happ5s :5 an oak ) all its beauty /&s out ^u ! hillside8 ,?is subject & object h come toge!r 9 unity1 9 an organism4 ,suppose ,locke %\ld h und]tak5 ! "w ( und]/&+ h[ a tree came to be1 in/ead ( h[ k came to be4 ,we w say he began by analyz+ a full gr[n tree4 ,aft] ?or\gh exam9ation ( its cont5ts1 he f9ds t all ! p>ts ( ! tree1 c>bon1 wat]1 etc41 are f\nd outside ( x 9 ! ext]nal _w4 ,he f9ds t ! tree is compos$ ( v>i\s atoms1 all ( :i* may be f\nd 9 ! soil & 9 ! atmosph]e4 ,he concludes1 !n1 t ^! atoms f soil & atmosph]e1 began to move up to & d[n to ! acorn4 ,! acorn1 passive mean:ile1 lets !m fall on x4 ,s1 ( _! own free w & accord1 ! atoms kept pil+ !mselves ^u ! acorn1 until 9 ! process ( a hundr$ ye>s !re 0 a tree4 ,n[ a brick column might be c>ri$ up aft] ?is fa%ion1 b n a tree4 ,! prior & fundam5tal ?+ 9 an oak tree is ! acorn4 ,x conta9s an active1 organiz+ life pr9ciple4 ,fall+ into ! soil1 ?is fold$ life p[] beg9s to /ir4 ,x lays hold ^u ! elem5ts ab\t x1 dige/s !m1 assimilates !m1 & turns !m into an oak4 ,! m9d is to ! raw mat]ial ( k1 :at ! acorn is to ! raw mat]ial ( oak4 ,?r\gh ! s5ses ! raw mat]ial is convey$ into ! m9d4 ,x is !n appropriat$1 assimilat$1 dige/$1 & turn$ into k4 ,! active1 organiz+1 comb9+ p[] t turns ! raw mat]ial pres5t$ by ! s5ses into k1 does n come f ! outside _w4 ,x is con/itutional1 fundam5tal1 orig9al4 ,j z ! organic =ces ( ! plant take up ! elem5ts f ! outside environm5t ^u :i* x subsi/s1 s ! syn!siz+1 liv+ p[] ( ! m9d takes ! matt] ( s5sation & turns x into ! :ole call$ k4 ,k is a unify+ process4 ,x comb9es ! manifold into "o4 ,x r$uces multiplicity to unity4 ,all t is real & all t is true 9 ! heav5s above or 9 ! e>? bel[1 9 m9d or 9 matt]1 9 "t or 9 space1 9 man or 9 ext]nal _w1 are capable ( be+ r$uc$ to unity 9 k4 ,k is ! subjective unity 9 ! f9ite m9d t corresponds to ! objective unity t lies )9 ! inf9ite m9d4 ,no?+ less ?an a univ]sal syn!sis satisfies ! f9ite m9d1 because x is a copy ( ! inf9ite m9d4 ,! f9ite self-consci\sness is a copy ( ! inf9ite self-consci\sness4 ,! inf9ite m9d kn[s all ?+s at once2 ! f9ite m9d comes to k ?r\gh a gradual process4 ,x c nev]1 ?r\gh all et]nity1 "k all ! inf9ite m9d kn[s1 b x c et]nally advance 9 k1 & com=t itself at e /age ( ! process ) ! ?\ght t no?+ 9 ! m9d ( ! inf9ite & absolute "o is =eign to x1 or 9 contradiction ) its capacity to "k4 ,9 ?9k+1 ! f9ite m9d is at home 9 its fa!r's realm1 & because ?is realm /ret*es out illimitably e way %\ld n oppress u or disc\rage u4 ,= ?is ! f9ite m9d c "k1 t ?r\gh\t ! limitless doma9 ( ,god !re is ord] & tru? & reality4 ,?us /&+ face to face ) tru?1 & be+ end[$ ) intellectual capacities capable ( recogniz+ x1 grasp+ x1 9 its unity & 9 its p>ticul>s1 x is prop] to inquire ! object & ! purpose ( x4 ,x is ! revelation :i* ! inf9ite m9d has made to ! f9ite4 ,x is ! language ( ,god1 9 :i* he has embodi$ 8 ?\ght4 ,x is ! ^w ( ! univ]sal _s4 ,man is a _s1 & he is to gr[ & come to ! full realization ( himself by p>tak+ ( ! ^w ( ,god4 ,tru? has be5 reveal$ = no o!r purpose ?an to make m54 ,sir ,william ,hamilton repres5ts tru? z game1 & ! me?od ( gett+ tru? to a *ase4 ,he says ! ex]cise ( our p[]s involv$ 9 ! process ( gett+ tru? is bett] ?an ! game we seek4 ,less+s says1 8,if ! ,almighty1 hold+ 9 "o h& tru?1 & 9 ! o!r se>* aft] tru?1 pres5t$ !m to me & ask$ me :i* ,i w\ld *oose1 ) all humility1 b )\t hesitation1 ,i %\ld say1 give me se>* aft] tru?40 ,mallbran*e says3 8,if ,i held tru? captive1 l a bird 9 my h&1 ,i w\ld let x g aga91 t ,i might *ase & capture x40 ,mll] says3 8,tru? is ! prop]ty ( ,god alone4 ,se>* aft] tru? belongs to man40 ,su* s5tim5ts indicate t ! m5 :o utt]$ !m _h no correct idea ( ! real nature ( tru?1 or ( man's intellectual nature1 ! necess>y food ( :i* is tru?4 ,x is true t ! se>* aft] tru? gives ex]cise & pleasure to ! intellectual faculties1 z se>* aft] bread gives ex]cise & heal? to ! physical p[]s4 ,b an et]nal se>* = bread is n suffici5t to keep man's body robu/ & /rong4 ,! v condition ^u :i* he w be able to keep up ! se>* = x is1 t he regul>ly & /eadily p>take ( x4 ,a tree1 _h x intellig5ce & emotion1 w\ld1 d\btless1 enjoy wre/l+ ) ! /orms1 & ?r[+ its roots into ! e>? & its bran*es into ! heav5s1 mak+ levies ^u e>? & sky = its own n\ri%m5t2 b if x did n con/antly turn ! elem5ts x f\nd into its trunk & bran*es1 x w\ld n be able to wre/le long ) ! /orms1 or =age long ^u ! e>? & sky4 ,to claim t ! intellectual faculties are always to se>* = tru?1 & t ! se>* is bett] ?an ! tru?1 is tacitly to assume t tru? is n = !m2 or1 if = !m1 & %\ld ev] be f\nd1 w\ld be z useless z a poor1 tir$1 half-dead fox ov]tak5 by ! hunt]s 9 ! *ase4 ,se>*+ = tru? is do+2 p>tak+ ( tru? is be+4 ,! se>* gives agility & skill2 ! p>tak+ ( tru? gives weal? ( "*4 ,to hunt game ) no o!r object ?an t :i* comes f ! sport ( ! *ase is degrad+4 ,to %oot birds only = ! purpose ( see+ !m fall is mean & wick$4 ,s1 to se>* = tru? ) no o!r purpose ?an t :i* comes f ! ex]cise ( ! se>*1 is unwor?y ! intellect t 0 giv51 n only to f9d tru?1 b to gr[ ri* & ,god-l by p>tak+ ( ! tru?4 ,man's ne$ = bread1 we saw1 l$ to ! e/abli%m5t ( comm]ce1 & comm]ce did f> m ?an secure to man food & clo?+ & %elt]4 ,x br\ght m5 toge!r & discov]$ !mselves to !mselves4 ,p[] l5t itself to ! uses ( man's social nature1 awak5$ & develop$ by comm]ce1 & made x possible = m5 to come into relations ) "o ano!r1 n simply 9 /ates & nations1 b on all ! e>?4 ,! ne$ = bread help$ to ! =mation ( society1 ! nature ( p[] & ! applications to :i* x l5t itself wid5$ ! social doma9 into a univ]sal bro!rhood1 to :i* man1 z a _s1 0 correlat$4 ,b _m saw bread only 9 its relations to hung]1 & p[] only 9 its relations to weal? & worldly dom9ion4 ,s1 _m see 9 tru? no purpose except ! practical & mat]ial ends to :i* x c be put4 ,9 ! e/eem ( ! utilit>ians1 x 0 well en\gh t le>n$ m5 consecrat$ _! g5ius & _! indu/ry to ! /udy ( ! subtle subject ( heat4 ,x 0 well t !y discov]$ ! real nature ( heat1 & saw t x 0 n caloric1 b a mode ( motion4 ,because ?is op5$ ! way = our railroads & /eamboats & quick me?ods ( transportation1 :i* h contribut$ s mu* to ! _w's weal?4 ,x 0 well t ! impracticable & !oretical m51 :o _h no?+ bett] to d1 sp5t ages /udy+ ! nature ( electricity1 & f9ally discov]$ t !re 7 c]ta9 metals = :i* x _h aff9ity1 & t x _h spe$ equal to ?\ght itself4 ,= ^! /udies h enabl$ ! practical & sub/antial m5 to ord] _! corn & meat by telegraph1 & ! practical h\sewives to ord] _! roa/ beef by telephone4 ,x is well t p :o _h no practical turn ( m9d sp5t ye>s 9 consid]+ ! /ructure ( ! human frame1 & ! plants & m9]als capable ( m9i/]+ to x1 = 9 ?is way ! doctors h got ideas by :i* !y are enabl$ to keep u practical m5 alive1 s t we c trade long]1 & build m factories & eat m victuals4 ,n[ x is true t ! k ! intellig5ce comes to by insight into ! relations & nature & tru? ( ?+s1 c be turn$ to practical acc\nt4 ,b ! tru? ! m9d f9ds by /udy 0 n prim>ily int5d$ to op5 ! way = /eam c>s & telegraphs & ! production ( weal?4 ,^! ?+s are incid5tal4 ,tru? is ! provision ,god has made = ! intellect4 ,! k ( ! />s has help$ man to sail ! sea & to take 8 be>+s on any "p ( its surface4 ,b ! practical acc\nt to :i* ?is k has be5 turn$ is n to be comp>$1 9 value1 to ! effect x 0 int5d$ to h on ! human m9d1 /r5g!n+ x1 ennobl+ x1 & h>moniz+ x ) ! div9e m9d4 ,,righte\sness4 8,:ile smitt5 ) ! fatal wanness ( approa*+ doom1 ! flamboyant pleiad ( ! m5 ( viol5ce desc5ds ! /eep slope to ! gulf ( dev\r+ "t3 lo6 at ! o!r extremity ( space1 :5 ! la/ cl\d has b n[ fad$ 9 ! deep sky ( ! future1 azure =ev]more1 rises respl5d5t ! sacr$ galaxy ( ! true />s--,orpheus1 ,h]mes1 ,job1 ,hom]1 s*ylus1 ,isaiah1 ,ezekiel1 ,hippocrates1 ,phidias1 ,socrates1 ,sophocles1 ,plato1 ,ari/otle1 ,ar*im$es1 ,euclid1 ,py?agoras1 ,lucretius1 ,plautus1 ,juv5al1 ,tacitus1 ,sa9t ,paul1 ,john ( ,patmos1 ,t]tullian1 ,pelagius1 ,dante1 ,gut5b]g1 ,joan ( ,arc1 ,*ri/oph] ,columbus1 ,lu!r1 ,mi*ael ,angelo1 ,cop]nicus1 ,galileo1 ,rabelais1 ,cald]on1 ,c]vantes1 ,%aksp]e1 ,rembr&t1 ,kepl]1 ,milton1 ,molire1 ,newton1 ,desc>tes1 ,kant1 ,piranesi1 ,becc>i1 ,did]ot1 ,bee?ov51 ,fulton1 ,montgolfi]1 ,wa%+ton3 & ! m>vel\s con/ellations1 bright] f mom5t to mom5t1 radiant z a ti>a ( cele/ial diamonds1 %9e 9 ! cle> horizon1 &1 z x rises1 bl5ds1 ) ! b\ndless dawn ( ,jesus ,*ri/40 ,,*apt] ,,iv4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,moral ,,nature ,,( ,,man4 ,two elem5ts are ess5tial to ! process ( ?9k+1 ! intellect & ! tru?4 ,"o is )91 ! o!r is )\t4 ,! "o is subjective1 ! o!r is objective4 ,two elem5ts are also ess5tial to ! process ( volition1 ! w & ! "r4 ,! "o )91 ! o!r )\t4 ,! "o subjective1 ! o!r objective4 ,be=e sight is possible1 !re mu/ be an eye & !re mu/ be light4 ,! "o is )91 ! o!r is )\t4 ,! "o is subjective1 ! o!r is objective4 ,be=e he>+1 !re mu/ be an e> & !re mu/ be s\nd4 ,! "o is )91 ! o!r is )\t4 ,! "o is subjective1 ! o!r is objective4 ,be=e brea?+ !re mu/ be lungs & !re mu/ be atmosph]e4 ,! "o is )91 ! o!r is )\t4 ,! "o is subjective1 ! o!r is objective4 ,no def9ition ( man is l>ge en\gh to accommodate ! facts ( 8 nature1 t does n embrace :at he is )\t z well z :at he is )91 :at he is objectively z well z :at he is subjectively4 ,x mu/ n only embrace ! intellect1 b ! tru? :i* x ?9ks2 n only ! w1 b ! "r :i* corresponds to x2 n only ! eye1 b ! light :i* gives x mean+2 n only ! e>1 b ! s\nd :i* mat*es x2 n only ! lungs1 b ! atmosph]e to :i* !y are correlat$4 ,human nature is dually con/itut$1 s t ! l>g] half ( itself is outside ( itself4 ,illu/rations ( ! same duality ( con/itution may be f\nd on a limit$ scale 9 ! organic & 9 ! inorganic worlds4 ,! great] half ( ! oak is n 9 ! life g]m ( ! acorn1 b 9 ! elem5ts ( ! soil & ! sky :i* environ x4 ,! l>g] "p ( ! fi% is 9 ! ocean :i* surr\nds x4 ,mo/ ( ! fuel :i* makes ! heat 9 ! grate is n 9 ! c>bon ( ! coal1 b 9 ! oxyg5 ( ! air :i* fills ! room4 ,i4 ,! possession ( a w & ! capacity = *oice make man a moral be+4 ,man's w is b\nd$ on e side by ! laws ( ,god4 ,^! laws are only ano!r "n = ,god's w4 ,man is made 9 ,god's image & has a w1 z f> z x goes1 j l ,god's w4 ,by *oos+ to act & to move along ! l9es ( law :i* ga!r f e :i!r ab\t 8 w1 he f9ds he c g some:]e1 t he c leave ! n>r[1 prov9cial1 & local neighborhood ( ease & s5se & subjection1 & f9d 8 life 9 t broad realm ( fre$om1 t belongs to him z a ?9k+ & will+ be+4 ,at ! t]m9i ( "s railroads !re are huge contrivances call$ turntables4 ,!y are con/ruct$ ( imm5se timb]s & balanc$ on pivots4 ,!y are l>ge en\gh to accommodate ! full l5g? ( a /eam eng9e4 ,iron rails are laid across ^! tables1 ( ! same size & ! same di/ance ap>t z ! rails :i* make up ! l9es ( ! ma9 track4 ,:5 ! tra9 comes 9 f ! f> int]ior1 ! eng9e is run out on "o ( ^! tables & turn$ r\nd1 s t ! headlight faces ! ma9 track aga94 ,be=e ! eng9e is ready to leave ! %ort track1 h[ev]1 ! rails on ! turntable mu/ exactly correspond to ! rails on ! ma9 road4 ,!n ! eng9e] pulls ! ?rottle1 & ! great locomotive rolls pa/ ! circumf]5ce ( its pivot$ & tempor>y re/+ place into comm]ce ) ! railways ( ! globe4 ,imag9e railway l9es com+ toge!r ab\t su* a revolv+ table f all ! e>?1 s t an eng9e c\ld pass f ?is circul> plat=m t[>d any qu>t] ( ! globe1 ! only condition be+ t ! %ort track on ! table correspond to ! rails ( ! long track on :i* x 0 propos$ = ! eng9e to run1 & y h an illu/ration1 :i* 9 "s degree helps u to und]/& ! relation ( man's w to ! laws ( ,god4 ,%\ld ! eng9e] und]take to get ! eng9e f ! table )\t ref]5ce to ! l9es ^u :i* x 0 int5d$ to run1 we "k v well :at ! consequ5ces w\ld be4 ,he w\ld n g f>1 & ev5 ! little di/ance he %\ld manage to make w\ld be att5d$ ) trem5d\s bump+ & friction4 ,all movem5t w\ld be 9 ! direction ( *aos & confusion4 ,h[ev] great ! exp5diture ( en]gy1 no po9t w\ld be rea*$1 & ! end ( ! und]tak+ w\ld be wa/e & failure4 ,if1 on ! o!r h&1 we %\ld imag9e an eng9e on su* a revolv+ plane1 capable ( mak+ fifty miles an h\r1 ) no tracks leav+ x1 we "k x c\ld n g any:]e1 & besides !re w\ld be no reason = its be+4 ,x w\ld be )\t mean+4 ,be=e ! di/ance betwe5 "o po9t & ano!r c be pass$ by a tra91 two ?+s are necess>y1 an eng9e & a railroad4 ,! "o may be call$ subjective1 ! o!r objective4 ,! "o implies ! o!r4 ,!y are ! necess>y elem5ts ( transportation4 ,z long z ! tra9 keeps to ! iron rails laid = x1 x moves )\t friction4 ,x is only :5 ! subjective elem5t jumps ! track & essays to det]m9e its own objective direction1 t tr\ble comes4 ,!n x is t c>s are dit*$ & p kill$ or crippl$4 ,! laws ( ,god run to & fro ?r\gh\t ! :ole e>?4 ,!y cross & recross e realm4 ,!y pass ?r\gh e doma91 physical1 m5tal1 & moral4 ,!y g /raight ?r\gh matt] & /raight ?r\gh m9d4 ,!y lead "u ! sea & ov] ! sea & ?r\gh ! sea4 ,d[n ?r\gh ! e>? & up ?r\gh ! air !y may be not$1 embrac+ ) _! invisible tracks e squ>e in* ( soil & sky4 ,!y insure ! ord] ( ! univ]se1 visible & invisible1 tangible & intangible4 ,!y rea* f globe to globe & make possible ! comm]ce ( ! sph]es4 ,!y run out into ! inf9itely great & back into ! inf9itely small1 & b9d 9 unity ! atoms & ! />s4 ,:5 man1 by ! aid ( 8 reason1 discov]s ! tru? ( ?+s1 :i* is ! provision = 8 intellect1 ^! laws appe> z provision = 8 w4 ,s tru? & law1 reality & righte\sness1 expressions ( ! ?\ght & w ( ,god1 are ! ev]la/+ facts to :i* man is to adju/ 8 intellect & w1 if he is to cross ! oceans1 travel ! cont95ts1 & claim ! possessions :i* 9 ! univ]se belong to him4 ,if he misreads ! facts1 he w ( c\rse misread ! laws :i* gov]n ! facts1 & w ?us be unable to get facts or laws to s]ve him4 ,b cle>ly see+ ! tru? ( ?+s1 he is able to avail himself ( ! laws ( ?+s4 ,z long z he only saw ?+s 9 ! lump1 & look$ ^u ! _w z s mu* air & e>? & fire & wat]1 he miss$ ! subtle laws :i* regulate ! atomic & molecul> /ructure ( bodies1 & fail$ to make !m 8 s]vants4 ,:51 by ! aid ( obs]vation & exp]im5t1 he r$uc$ ! e>? to its ultimate p>ticles & came to su* k ( x z correspond$ to ! facts ( x2 :5 he came to see ! laws & drift ( ?+s1 ! t5d5cies & aff9ities ( ?+s2 he _h only to put ! productions ( 8 w 9 l9e ) ! way ?+s 7 go+1 to h !m s]ve him4 ,see+ t =ces h p[] to d "w 9 proportion to _! en]gy ( position1 & apply+ ?is insight to ! riv] ) =ty feet fall1 he builds 8 mill beside x & ?us utilizes x to gr9d 8 :eat4 ,see+ :at soil & sunlight & ra9 c d :5 !y comb9e to unwrap ! life 9 a se$1 he commits 8 :eat to _! b5evol5t t5d5cies & gets a h>ve/ ( tw5ty bu%els = e "o he seems to lose4 ,he /udies fire4 ,he sees x wrap 9 flame & level 9 an h\r =tunes x took a lifetime to accumulate4 ,he le>ns :at a furi\s & awful =ce x is4 ,he gets insight into its real nature4 ,he gets k ( x t corresponds to ! reality ( x4 ,he sees t x is only a flam+ & lurid me?od ( movem5t4 ,) ! tru? ( x he gets ! law ( x4 ,s by ! aid ( volition1 put =? 9 accordance ) intellig5ce1 he contrives a ma*9e correspond+ to ! laws ( heat1 z a mode ( motion4 ,9 ?is way he utilizes ! heat t burn$ up 8 cities1 to transport him 9 ease & com=t ov] ! c\ntry4 ,he /udies ! />s until 8 k ( !m corresponds to !m z !y are2 along ) ?is k1 he comes to an und]/&+ ( _! laws1 _! uni=m me?ods ( action4 ,!n he builds 8 great %ips & commits !m to ! wild & /orm-toss$ sea1 sure t 8 p[] to guide !m w nev] fail z long z law & ord] rema9 9 ! heav5s4 ,t !re is a natural ord]1 ) c]ta9 inh]+ laws1 m5 readily accept4 ,t ?is ord] has ! consi/5cy ( be+ develop$ 9 "o way2 t !re is a dip to ?+s t mu/ be foll[$2 t !re is a clew1 9 accordance ) :i* ?+s may be work$2 t !re is a tr5d1 drift1 & law ( ?+s t mu/ be accept$ & foll[$2 all ?is1 m5 readily ass5t to4 ,!y d n attempt to f>m ! ,sah>a ,des]t1 = !y "k ! conditions ( h>ve/s are n !re4 ,!y d n put out orange groves 9 ,m9nesota1 nor plant cotton 9 ,canada1 nor s[ rice 9 ,briti% ,columbia4 ,!y d n expect ! soil t spews up ! ice to produce wat]melons at ! same "t4 ,!y d n pret5d to navigate %ips ov] ! cont95ts1 & to lay _! railway l9es on ! surface ( ! sea4 ,!y fix _! telegraph wires to poles by means ( little glass contrivances1 & nev] attempt to s5d electricity ?r\gh ! grape v9e4 ,natural laws !y "k inh]e 9 ! facts ( nature1 & are n read into e>? & rock & riv] & atmosph]e4 ,!y "k t necess>y laws reside 9 ! facts ( condition1 & t !y mu/ /udy ^! laws to "k ! l9e ( practical "w !y require4 ,9 build+ a h\se ( /one !y "k x is necess>y to def] to ! law ( gravity1 t ?is law _c be ignor$ or set aside1 s !y c>ry up ! edifice 9 su* con=mity to rule & l9e z t ! c5t] ( gravity falls 9 a l9e inside ! base4 ,!y might pref] a h\se built ) ref]5ce to a diff]5t ord] ( ?+s1 "o 9 :i* ! c5t] ( gravity w\ld fall 9 a l9e outside ! base4 ,b x is v well und]/ood among m5 t ! law ( gravity mu/ be respect$4 ,ev5 an>*i/s & nihili/s1 :o seem to h irrepressible antipa?y = all anci5t ord]s & laws & e/abli%m5ts1 d condesc5d suffici5tly to respect ! "t-honor$1 ev5 if slightly belat$1 laws ( gravity4 ,,ii4 ,! "t 0 :5 m5 accept$ ! exi/5ce ( a moral ord] ) ! same implicit1 unque/ion$ confid5ce1 t all m5 to-day accept ! exi/5ce ( a natural ord]4 ,9 ,hom]'s ,!mi/es we h an illu/ration ( ?is confid5ce4 ,! v ^w by :i* ! decision ( a judge is describ$ attributes x to ,!mis1 ! invisible embodim5t ( ju/ice4 ,?us ! judge is b ! *annel ?r\gh :i* ! decision passes f ! unse5 moral ord] into ! ,greek c\rt ( ju/ice4 ,! judge is n respect$ because he has au?ority to make ! decision1 b because 8 vocation makes him ! vehicle ?r\gh :i* ! decision ( a high] p[] is r5d]$4 ,moses said to ! p ( ,israel1 8,?\ %alt n lie10 8,?\ %alt n /eal10 8,?\ %alt n commit adult]y10 b ^! 7 n 8 words simply1 b ! words ?r\gh :i* a moral ord] 0 int]pret$4 ,! solemn & awful import giv5 to ^! comm&s did n arise f ! vehicle ?r\gh :i* !y pass$ into ! ,hebrew social ord]1 b f ! fact t !y inh]$ 9 ! v con/itution ( man z a social be+1 & :5 !y 7 utt]$1 !y 7 felt to come f ! ,god :o fa%ion$ man's life & set him 9 communities & /ates4 ,!y _h ! same sort ( au?ority 9 ! moral realm t ! decl>ations ( ,newton1 conc]n+ ! p[] ( gravity1 _h 9 ! natural4 ,newton did n conceive 9 8 own bra9 ! laws ( gravity1 he saw !m & =mulat$ !m4 ,nor did ,moses create ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts1 he saw !m & int]pret$ !m4 ,! laws ( gravity 7 transcripts f ! w ( ,god conc]n+ matt]1 ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts 7 transcripts f ! w ( ,god conc]n+ m54 ,:5 natural bodies come toge!r1 x w\ld be f\nd t !y always attract$ ea* o!r 9 proportion to _! mass & inv]sely z ! squ>es ( _! di/ance4 ,:5 m5 come toge!r1 x w\ld always be f\nd1 t if !y 7 to live toge!r 9 h>mony & heal?2 if !y 7 to advance & get above ! planes ( ! brutes & ! savages2 !y mu/ ab/a9 f ly+1 & /eal+1 & adult]y1 & ?us be tru?ful1 & hone/1 & virtu\s4 ,! laws ( gravity 7 n arbitr>y rules1 orda9$ to oppress suns & sy/ems )\t rhyme or reason4 ,ord] ( "s sort _h to be pres]v$ among ! millions ( blaz+1 roll+ worlds4 ,nor 7 ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts arbitr>y l9es ( conduct impos$ ^u m5 at ! pleasure ( a great1 omnipot5t tyrant4 ,m5 c\ld n live ap>t1 out ( t\* & contact ) "o ano!r4 ,?us liv+1 !y 7 l[] ?an ! bea/s t p]i%4 ,!y c\ld n live toge!r )\t rules ( "s sort to regulate _! lives4 ,& laws :i* look$ to ! pres]vation ( tru?fulness1 hone/y1 & virtue1 7 ?\ght bett] ?an laws :i* look$ to ! production ( ly+1 di%one/y1 & adult]y4 ,because ( ! impetus giv5 to ! /udies ( mat]ial sci5ce )9 rec5t ye>s1 by ! discov]ies ( s*ol>s1 ! att5tion ( m5 has be5 direct$ to ! objects ( ! natural _w & ! laws :i* regulate !m4 ,discov]ies into ! nature ( heat1 light1 etc41 has _h ! same effect ^u ! human m9d t ! discov]ies ( ! gold fields 9 ! ,we/ _h ^u ! p ( ,am]ica 9 ! e>ly days4 ,p ab&on$ fields & %ops & /ores & w5t 9 se>* = gold4 ,! att5tion ( ! civiliz$ _w has 9 ?is g5]ation be5 direct$ to ! consid]ation ( outw>d facts4 ,!re has be5 promise "h ( e>?ly =tune4 ,conviction z to ! exi/5ce ( a moral ord] ) its rew>ds & p5alties is n s deep & abid+ z x once 0 among ,engli% speak+ p4 ,b x is well to rememb] t ! moral laws ( ! univ]se h n 9 ! meantime be5 susp5d$1 because m5 h n se5 prop] to consid] !m & to act ) ref]5ce to !m4 ,!y are j z real & z unfail+ z ev]4 ,:5 accept$ & foll[$1 _! pres5ce is se5 9 heal?1 9 political /ability1 9 intellectual progress4 ,:5 ignor$ & =gott51 _! pres5ce is se5 9 disease1 9 political corruption1 9 m5tal /upidity1 9 %am & empt9ess4 ,9 "o way or ano!r !y always manage to get 9 _! "w4 ,!y nev] sleep1 !y nev] tire1 !y are et]nally pres5t to bless or to curse1 to lift up or to ca/ d[n4 ,!y get r\nd to e man's home1 & soon] or lat] to e man's life1 be>+ honor or di%onor1 legitimate rew>d or righte\s infamy4 ,!y are n to be brib$1 :itewa%$1 or bulldoz$2 !y come clean1 unv>ni%$1 & unv5e]$ to posit _! labels on e man's "*2 & :atev] is read on ! label1 absolutely def9es ! cont5t4 ,irrespective ( money1 titles1 place1 or rank1 !y come4 ,! presid5t 9 8 seat1 ! judge on 8 b5*1 ! prea*] 9 8 pulpit1 _c escape4 ,if ! presid5t gets label$ pigmy1 pigmy he is4 ,if ! judge gets classifi$ fraud1 fraud he is4 ,if ! prea*] gets d[n z trimm] & %am1 trimm] & %am he is4 ,,iii4 ,h[ are we to f9d moral laws8 ,j z we f9d natural laws4 ,:5 we f9d ! tru? ( natural bodies1 reason sees ! laws :i* inh]e 9 !m1 & prud5ce dictates su* action on our "p z ^! laws require4 ,:5 we come to tru?1 on ! moral plane1 or to su* k ( ! facts z corresponds to ! tru?1 reason1 unless p]v]t$1 sees ! laws t reside 9 !m1 & consci5ce dictates t ^! laws %\ld be obey$4 ,consci5ce un]r+ly & infallibly approves ! "r4 ,by ! aid ( ! light :i* is ?r[n ^u x :5 ! intellect comes into relations ( k ) moral tru?1 x recognizes ! laws ! w ought to foll[4 ,^! laws make up a "p ( ! tru?4 ,be=e ! "r c be recogniz$1 ! tru? mu/ be se54 ,:5 t :i* ! intellig5ce takes = tru? is n ! tru?1 ! consci5ce w recognize laws = ! w to foll[ t d n correspond to ! laws ( ,god4 ,x has (t5 happ5$ t :at ! intellig5ce took = tru? did n correspond to objective reality1 & h5ce 0 n ! tru?2 h5ce ! consci5ce has (t5 approv$ & sugge/$ l9es ( action t 7 at v>iance ) t :i* 0 ess5tially & et]nally "r4 ,^? :o foll[$ ! dictates ( consci5ce1 h[ev]1 "u su* conditions1 did1 "u ! circum/ances1 "r4 ,to h refus$ to foll[ consci5ce w\ld h increas$ _! confusion4 ,a man 9 ! bog1 ) ! c]ta9ty ( dea? be=e him1 ought to foll[ ! guide t appe>s1 ev5 ?\gh he %\ld n "k h[ to lead him out ( ! swamp4 ,consci5ce nev] fails to come z ne> recogniz+ ! "r z ! intellect comes to discov]+ ! tru?4 ,:5 t :i* ! intellect appreh5ds z tru? corresponds to objective reality1 we may be sure t ! laws :i* inh]e 9 x1 & :i* consci5ce sugge/s z ! ones ! w ought to foll[1 correspond to ! laws ( ,god4 ,"o's consci5ce may lead him wrong1 b only :5 ! intellect has l$ him wrong4 ,/4 ,paul's consci5ce l$ him wrong :5 x impell$ him to p]secute ! ,*ri/ians ( ! e>ly *ur*1 b x 0 because t :i* he held = tru? did n tally ) ! outw>d facts1 & h5ce 0 n ! tru?4 ,_h ! suppos$ tru? :i* he held :ile p]secut+ ! ,*ri/ians be5 real tru?1 !n 9 p]secut+ ! ,*ri/ians he w\ld h done "r4 ,! rev]sal ( consci5ce result$ f ! incom+ ( new tru?1 or su* k z 0 su/a9$ by ! outw>d facts4 ,! consci5ce ( ! ,h9doo "m t leads h] to ?r[ h] *ild into ! ,riv] ,ganges is z good z ! consci5ce ( ! ,*ri/ian "m t leads h] to c>ry h] *ild to ! ,sunday s*ool4 ,! tr\ble ) ! ,h9doo "m is n ) h] consci5ce1 b ) h] religi\s k2 x does n correspond to ! facts ( ! ord] ( ! moral & spiritual univ]se4 ,we are to det]m9e ! value ( ! affirmations ( consci5ce by det]m9+ ! value ( ! k out ( :i* ^? affirmations gr[4 ,k is valuable 9 proportion to its correspond5ce ) t :i* is real4 ,z (t5 z ! intellect grasps ! tru?1 ! consci5ce w sugge/ ! "r t accompanies x4 ,!re is no tru? ( a moral nature t has n its att5dant "r4 ,,iv4 ,we "k ! moral tru? z we "k mat]ial tru?1 ?r\gh its relations4 ,relation makes ! diff]5ce betwe5 *aos & cosmos4 ,to def9e any natural object is to place x 9 its relations4 ,we c\ld n def9e oxyg5 )\t nam+ ! elem5ts to :i* x is relat$4 ,to take x out ( relation is to take f x any mean+4 ,error is wrong relation4 ,:5 ! m9d assigns a place to an object o!r ?an t :i* really belongs to x1 9 ! ord] ( :i* x =ms a "p1 we call ?is error4 ,if1 see+ ! p>ts ( a h\se scatt]$ ov] a field by a /orm1 we %\ld conf\nd a sleep] ) a raft]1 we %\ld take x f its prop] place & take away its mean+ z a "p ( ! build+4 ,all ( our k is ( relations & n ( s5sations1 z ,hume taught4 ,s5sations set ! m9d to classify+ & comp>+1 & ! k x comes to is ( relations4 ,take ! s5sations ! m9d has :5 a r$ object is pres5t$ to ! eye4 ,does n ! m9d beg9 at once to di/+ui% ?is s5sation z "o ( r$ness f o!r s5sations t are ( diff]5t colors8 ,is n its reality z a p>ticul> color con/itut$ = u by its relation to colors1 by its place 9 ! scale ( colors8 ,if !re 0 b "o color1 & t color ! "o we n[ "k z r$1 h[ c\ld we "k x z su*8 ,h[ c\ld we call x r$ unless to di/+ui% x f "s o!r color ) :i* we1 = ! "t be+1 comp>$ x or contra/$ x8 ,s true is x t reality is con/itut$ = u by ! sum ( its relations1 t if ! relations ( ?+s are ma9ta9$1 no increase or dim9ution ( ! quantity ( ?+s relat$ w be detect$ 9 our k ( !m4 ,if ! e>? 7 compress$ into a sph]e no l>g] ?an a m>ble1 no "o c\ld "k x if ! relations among ! objects :i* make x up 7 ! same4 ,aga91 ! e>? might be enl>g$ until x %\ld be a billion times l>g] ?an :at x is2 yet ?is c\ld n be kn[n z long z m5 & gates & spoons & sauc]s & h\ses & cuff-buttons 7 enl>g$ 9 ! same proportion4 ,! leaf ( a man's d9+ table might be t5 miles squ>e1 & ! ball ( butt] on 8 table z big z ! ,/one ,m\nta9 9 ,georgia2 yet if cook1 & cat1 & /ove1 & wat]-bucket 7 increas$ 9 ! same ratio1 he w\ld n recognize any diff]5ce4 ,v4 ,we ent] ! _w ( humanity1 :i* is ! realm ( morality1 ?r\gh ! family4 ,"h we op5 our eyes to ! light1 & "h we h ! fir/ intimations ( tru?1 :i* is provision = ! intellect1 & ( righte\sness1 :i* is provision = ! w4 ,! tru? ( ! family is ! sum ( ! relations :i* subsi/ among ! memb]s ( x4 ,! family consi/s1 we w say1 ( fa!r & "m1 & *ildr54 ,"h is a man & a woman1 !n1 b\nd toge!r by ! relation ( m>riage4 ,! *ildr5 are relat$ to ! p>5ts z (fspr+4 ,! *ildr5 are relat$ to "o ano!r z bro!rs & si/]s4 ,altoge!r !y are "o & !y are _m4 ,!re is unity & !re is diff]5ce4 ,9 ! relations impli$ 9 ! names husb& & wife1 fa!r & "m1 p>5ts & *ildr51 bro!rs & si/]s1 we h ! tru? ( ! family4 ,we "k ! family & c only "k ! family ?r\gh ^! relations4 ,take ! relations away1 & y take ! family away4 ,!re _c be a husb& )\t a wife1 a fa!r )\t a "m1 p>5ts )\t *ildr51 & *ildr5 )\t a fa!r & a "m4 ,abid+ 9 ^! relations1 :i* make up ! tru? ( ! family1 wrapt up ) !m & gr[+ out ( !m1 are ! laws ( "r :i* ! w is to obey4 ,! relation ( m>riage is accompani$ by c]ta9 obligations & duties :i* husb& & wife are to obs]ve4 ,^! obligations & duties are div9e laws1 because m>riage is a div9e relation4 ,! relations involv$ 9 ! t]m p>5ts1 are att5d$ by c]ta9 necess>y laws ! fa!r & ! "m are to obs]ve ) ref]5ce to *ildr54 ,! names ( *ild1 bro!r1 si/]1 imply relations t 9 turn imply laws ! *ild is to foll[ ) ref]5ce to p>5ts1 & bro!rs & si/]s are to reg>d ) ref]5ce to "o ano!r4 ,^! laws1 :i* gr[ out ( ! relations :i* con/itute ! family1 are n arbitr>y1 artificial1 or accid5tal4 ,!y h n be5 =m$ by ! op9ions ( m51 nor =mulat$ 9 ! legislative assemblies ( m54 ,legislative bodies h1 p]haps1 confirm$ !m & reproduc$ !m 9 /atutes1 b ?is 0 n to create1 b to transcribe :at 0 already pres5t4 ,! laws ) ref]5ce to :i* ! memb]s ( a family f9d !mselves plac$ are z ess5tial & con/itutional z ! laws gov]n+ natural objects1 :i* we def9e :5 we say bodies attract ea* o!r 9 proportion to _! mass & inv]sely z ! squ>es ( _! di/ance4 ,^! are subtle & invisible pr9ciples :i* _c be read out ( rocks & logs & moons & suns4 ,displace rocks & logs & suns & moons1 & ! app>5t p[] ( ^! laws w\ld n be se51 b ^u ! appe>ance ( ! natural objects1 !y w\ld be imm$iately grasp$ & dom9at$ by ! p[] ( ! laws4 ,we pass f ! family into ! s*ool4 ,"h aga9 we f9d laws already laid = ! w to foll[4 ,!y gr[ out ( ! tru?1 con/itutive ( ! s*ool1 & ?is tru? is made up ( ! relations subsi/+ among ! memb]s ( ! s*ool4 ,!re are tea*]s1 ^: duty x is to control & to in/ruct4 ,!re are *ildr51 ^: duty x is to le>n & obey4 ,! s*ool is an in/itution1 ! object ( :i* is to lead "y m9ds into a k ( ! e>?1 its cont95ts1 seas1 riv]s1 & m\nta9s2 into a k ( language1 its /ructure1 uses1 & ! mean+ ( its t]ms2 into a k ( humanity1 its races1 gov]nm5ts1 & religions4 ,if *ildr5 are to %>e 9 ! b5efits ( ! object = :i* ! s*ool is e/abli%$1 !y mu/ obs]ve ! laws :i* inh]e 9 ! v con/itution ( x4 ,!y mu/ obey ! tea*]1 !y mu/ /udy ! books1 !y mu/ be polite1 =be>+ & k9d to "o ano!r4 ,x (t5 happ5s t a *ild ent]s ! s*ool & refuses to foll[ ! laws t reside 9 ! /ructure & purpose ( ! s*ool4 ,he is willful & conceit$1 & ?9ks 8 own way bett] ?an ! necess>y & ess5tial way orda9$ = him4 ,he has ! same sort ( exp]i5ce ! eng9e] has :o attempts to run 8 eng9e f ! turntable1 )\t ref]5ce to ! railway l9es laid = x4 ,!re is friction & tr\ble4 ,v>i\s me?ods ( puni%m5t are resort$ to ) ! view to get 8 w to move along ! l9es laid = x4 ,if rebuke & puni%m5t fail1 !n he is turn$ out1 to attempt ! /upid & insane exp]im5t ( gett+ himself ?r\gh ! _w )\t ref]5ce to ! laws fix$ = 8 w to obey4 ,( c\rse he does n g f>4 ,he turns up soon] or lat] 9 ! jail1 ! hospital1 ! p5it5ti>y1 or ! poorh\se4 ,leav+ ! s*ool1 we f9d ourselves citiz5s ( ! /ate1 memb]s ( society4 ,b we d n g into society l an ax-man 9 a fronti] =e/ to cle> a place = 8 h\se1 8 f5ce1 & 8 field4 ,me?ods ( conduct are already prescrib$1 l9es ( action are already fix$1 & ! laws :i* claim our ob$i5ce are already =mulat$4 ,society is an organism ( mutually dep5d5t memb]s2 ! object ( x is ! equity ( all1 ! welf>e ( all1 & ! lib]ty ( all4 ,equity1 lib]ty1 welf>e d n come by accid5t4 ,m5 _c rea* !m out ( t\* & contact ) "o ano!r4 ,!y are only possible to m5 liv+ toge!r1 & only possible 9 con=mity ) c]ta9 conditions1 & 9 ! obs]vance ( c]ta9 laws4 ,^! laws lie fold$ 9 ! nature ( m5 z social be+s4 ,!y are fundam5tal1 & ,ari/otle saw !m :5 he said1 8man is by nature a political animal40 ,! g]ms ( gov]nm5t & law are 9 ! dep?s ( e man's be+1 z ! g]ms ( ! oak are 9 ! acorn4 ,wise m51 liv+ 9 society1 h se5 ! tru? ( society1 made up ( ! relations subsi/+ among p liv+ toge!r4 ,accompany+ ^! relations1 & c\nt]p>ts ( !m1 !y h discov]$ ! laws necess>y to insure ! equity1 lib]ty1 & welf>e ( all4 ,^! laws h be5 embodi$ 9 con/itutions1 enactm5ts1 & /atutes4 ,to c>ry out ^! laws & to make !m prevail1 c]ta9 in/itutions h be5 e/abli%$1 a body ( m5 ^: duty x is to execute ! laws1 a ,judici>y1 ^: duty x is to int]pret & exp\nd ! laws1 & a legislative body1 ^: duty x is to repeal old laws t did n "w well1 & to frame new laws to meet ! exig5cies ( new conditions4 ,to protect ! rights ( all1 c]ta9 p5alties h be5 made to accompany ! violations ( laws4 ,to make ^! p5alties real1 & to inflict !m ^u ! prop] p>ties1 c\rts & jails & p5it5ti>ies h be5 e/abli%$4 ,s we see1 z ! acorn _c gr[ )\t appropriat+ ! elem5ts already prep>$ = x 9 ! soil & ! sky2 & z ! c>bon _c burn )\t lay+ hold ( ! oxyg5 already exi/+ = x 9 ! atmosph]e ( ! room2 & z ! fi% _c swim )\t utiliz+ ! wat] already adju/$ to its f9s2 s man _c fill out ! possibilities ( 8 be+ )\t obey+ ! laws he f9ds already orda9$ = 8 w1 :5 he comes into ! _w4 ,^! laws conv]ge ab\t 8 w 9 ! home :]e he fir/ sees ! light1 & are always d$ucible f ! p>ticul> relations 9 :i*1 at any "t1 8 moral life is plac$4 ,!y are z real z ! laws ( heat & motion & gravity4 ,!y run out f ! home ?r\gh ! s*ool1 & f ! s*ool ?r\gh all ! cont95ts ( ! social realm4 ,!y gr[ out ( ! tru? ( ! facts ( ! family1 ! s*ool1 & society4 ,!y are z fundam5tal1 necess>y1 & div9e z ! family1 ! s*ool1 & society4 ,by obs]v+ !m1 man is able to turn into 8 "* ! t5d]ness ( ! home1 ! le>n+ ( ! s*ool1 & ! res\rces ( society4 ,,vi4 ,! au?ority ( ! laws :i* gov]n society is n f\nd 9 ! fact t ! laws h be5 made by ! w ( ! majority1 or ! w ( ! m9ority1 or by ! w ( a k+1 or by ! wills ( any or all ( ! p2 b because !y are f\nd$ 9 ! con/itution ( human nature4 ,! basis = ! con/itution ( human nature is ! m9d ( ,god1 :o creat$ man 9 8 own image4 ,social laws h au?ority1 !n1 because !y are consonant ) ! nature ( man1 & h _! s\rce 9 ! w ( ,god4 ,x is easy to %[1 h[ev]1 f ! records ( hi/ory1 t nations h (t5 liv$ "u laws impos$ ^u !m t contradict$ e pr9ciple ( human nature4 ,m5 7 accu/om$ once to f9d ! laws ( society z well z ! laws ( nature1 n f ! /udy ( m51 or f ! /udy ( ! objects ( nature1 b 9 ! dep?s ( _! own imag9ations4 ,9 =m] times m5 met 9 conv5tion & c\ncil & det]m9$ by resolution ! %ape ( ! e>? & ! sun's me?od ( movem5t4 ,!y also subject$ !mselves to ! criticism ( po/]ity by cutt+ ! heads ( ! p (f :o did n agree ) !m4 ,b x gradually dawn$ on ! human m9d t to f9d out = c]ta9 ! %ape ( ! e>? x might be well to devote a little /udy to ! e>? itself4 ,?us x happ5$ t 9 ! c\rse ( ev5ts m5 ceas$ to read laws into ,god's mat]ial univ]se f ! b\ndless realms ( _! fancy & conceit1 & fell ^u ! m rational habit ( tak+ ! laws t 7 already !re4 ,h]e9 is ! diff]5ce betwe5 m$ival & mod]n times4 ,! disposition to read laws into nature1 )\t ref]5ce to ! facts ( nature1 0 9 l9e ) ! programme to read laws into ! social realm )\t ref]5ce to ! facts ( human nature4 ,! laws ( a/ronomy to-day are su* z h be5 f\nd by a /udy ( ! />s4 ,! laws ( *emi/ry are su* z h be5 f\nd by a /udy ( ! atomic /ructures ( bodies4 ,"o might fall out n[ ) ! cele/ial laws ( ,ptolemy1 & head a movem5t to set !m aside4 ,b x is n rational to fall out ) ! a/ronomical laws ( ,norman ,locky]1 = t is to buck aga9/ ! sun1 & to make faces at ! />s4 ,locky]'s laws came /raight to him f ! skies1 & f9d _! value & v]ification 9 ! close calculation ( e /eam] t sails on ! wide1 re/less sea4 ,! laws ( civiliz$ nations to-day are su* z h be5 f\nd by a /udy ( ! facts ( human nature4 ,to qu>rel ) !m is to set "o's self aga9/ ! way man is built4 ,x w\ld n d to say t ! social laws ( civiliz$ peoples to-day are exact transcripts f ! w ( ,god conc]n+ ! conduct ( social life4 ,m5 d n n[1 & p]haps w n = a long "t1 read aright ! facts ( human nature4 ,"o ?+ is c]ta91 h[ev]3 9 ! mak+ ( laws among civiliz$1 republican peoples1 ref]5ce is _h to ! facts ( human nature1 & n to ! fancy ( ^? :o wi% to gov]n4 ,x _c be disput$ t ! "r facts are consid]$ f :i* to make d$uctions4 ,?is means a complete *ange ( front 9 ! mod]n _w ov] ! ages pa/4 ,!re are d\btless _m m9or laws on ! /atute books ( ! lib]al & progressive nations ( ! e>? to-day :i* are n 9 accordance ) ! nature ( man2 b x seems t any rational p]son is compell$ to admit t ! great legal trunk-l9es con=m to ! ess5tial laws ( human nature4 ,take ! ,con/itution ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates4 ,"s "o has said t ! apple f :i* ,newton d$uc$ ! laws ( gravity 0 two ?\s& ye>s fall+4 ,he w\ld h be5 ne>] ! tru? if he _h said six ?\s& ye>s4 ,! ,con/itution ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates is z cle>ly a d$uction f ! facts ( human nature1 z 7 ! laws ( gravity f a /udy ( fall+ bodies4 ,! conv5tion t met 9 ,philadelphia to frame ! ,con/itution ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 9 #aghg1 0 call$ to ord] on ! top ( ! c5turies4 ,! memb]s _h su* advantage ( position z made x possible = !m to look all d[n ! ages4 ,!y 7 9 a position to see all sides ( human nature1 "u all =ms ( gov]nm5t4 ,9 ! preamble to ! ,con/itution1 !y specifi$ c]ta9 objects = :i*1 9 _! e/eem1 ?is gov]nm5t %\ld be =m$--union1 dome/ic tranquillity1 ju/ice1 lib]ty1 welf>e4 ,any gov]nm5t con/itut$ by a docum5t l t has = ! basis ( its exi/5ce ! facts ( human nature1 z really z ! law ( gravity has = ! basis ( its exi/5ce ! facts ( ! />s4 ,,vii4 ,if x is necess>y t man grasp ! tru? ( ?+s be=e he c det]m9e ! laws ( ?+s1 we _c fail to see h[ important x is t he h a prop] !ory ( k4 ,man's idea ( law w correspond to 8 !ory ( k4 ,:5 ! ,fr5* p accept$ ,locke's !ory ( kn[+ !y imm$iately appli$ x to ! laws1 e/abli%m5ts1 & in/itutions ( ! nation4 ,!y conclud$ logically1 if all k is ( s5sations1 !n !re c be no au?ority = ! belief 9 ,god1 ! immortality ( ! s\l1 or ! div9ity ( law4 ,^! are univ]sal & transc5d5t facts1 b ! m9d has no capacity to "k univ]sal or transc5d5t facts4 ,s society 0 to be dissolv$ into its con/itu5t atoms1 9 ord] t individuals c\ld arrange _! lives on a univ]sal1 g-z-y-please pr9ciple4 ,all exi/+ laws & in/itutions 7 to be oblit]at$4 ,ev]y?+ t 0 up 0 to be put d[n4 ,!re are to-day1 scatt]$ ?r\gh ! civiliz$ /ates ( ,europe & 9 "s p>ts ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 m5 :o want to emancipate ! p f ! dom9ion ( all au?ority4 ,all ?is gr[s out ( ! fa%ionable & s5sational !ory ( k taught fir/ by ,john ,locke & ,david ,hume1 & )9 rec5t ye>s by ,john ,/u>t ,mill & ,h]b]t ,sp5c]4 ,"h is ! s\rce ( an>*y4 ,!re is n an influ5tial an>*i/ 9 ! _w1 b is "o ^u ! basis ( ! physiological !ory ( k4 ,!re is no objective reality1 b su* z is compos$ ( mat]ial atoms4 ,^! h got _! arrangem5t & collocations )\t ! ag5cy ( any great co-ord9at+ m9d4 ,!y come toge!r 9 pairs & clu/]s & gr\ps1 by ! aid ( no p[] b su* z issues f ! unkn[able4 ,a man is no m a crim9al = kill+ p ?an is ! ,mississippi ,riv] = ov]fl[+ its banks & dr[n+ p4 ,m5 are m]e products ( nature1 & _! ?\ghts are only secretions ( ! bra94 ,laws & in/itutions are j ! bra9 deposits ( animals we call m51 z dams across riv]s & cells 9 gums are ! deposits ( ! bra9s ( beav]s & bees4 ,9 a docum5t f\nd on ! p]son ( a rec5t an>*i/ arre/$ by ! au?orities 9 ,engl&1 x is ass]t$ t ! purpose ( ! an>*i/s is to put d[n all political1 religi\s1 & milit>y au?ority2 to burn all *ur*es1 palaces1 soldi]-b>racks1 =tresses1 provisions1 & to de/roy all t has liv$ till n[ by bus9ess-"w )\t contribut+ to x4 ,f su* docum5ts we are to und]/& t ! an>*i/s take x = grant$ t all laws & in/itutions among civiliz$ peoples h be5 impos$ arbitr>ily by ^? :o gov]n ^u ^? :o are gov]n$2 t ! p>ties to be gov]n$ h z mu* "r to ignore !m z ! gov]n+ p>ties _h to make !m2 t !re is 9 ! univ]se no moral ord] to :i* ! political & social ord]s among m5 correspond2 t e man has ! privilege ( sett+ up 8 own ord]2 t e eng9e] has ! "r to ignore ! rails laid = ! flanges ( 8 :eels on ! long roads lead+ out f ! turntable1 & ! ine/imable subjective lib]ty ( pull+ op5 ! ?rottle valve & runn+ out into ! c\ntry accord+ to 8 own sweet w4 ,suppose all ! an>*i/s 9 ! _w %\ld be s5t to "s great isl& s t !y c\ld te/ _! own !ories1 w\ld !y n be "u ! necessity ( f\nd+ "s sort ( a gov]nm5t8 ,!y w\ld h to con/ruct roads1 devise ways & means = lights1 wat]1 & = protection aga9/ individual viol5ce4 ,w\ld !y n h to b9d !mselves toge!r by "s k9d ( social contract1 or compact8 ,if a numb] ( m5 %\ld unite !mselves into a syndicate = ! purpose ( build+ h\ses )\t ref]5ce to ! laws ( gravity1 if !y %\ld decl>e x z _! set purpose to s build h\ses z t ! c5t] ( gravity %\ld fall 9 a l9e outside ! base1 ! :ole company w\ld be tri$ = lunacy & conf9$ 9 ! insane asylum4 ,s ! mo/ summ>y & /raight=w>d me?ods %\ld be adopt$ = ridd+ society ( all t class ( m5 :o propose to manage human affairs )\t ref]5ce to ! facts ( man's nature & ! laws ( ! univ]se4 ,x is a "q :e!r !y %\ld be put into an insane asylum or into a jail1 = x is h>d to det]m9e :i* !y h ! mo/ (3 insane /upidity or insane meanness4 ,society has made great advances1 b e increm5t ( progress has be5 along ! l9es ( ! et]nal laws ( ! univ]se4 ,^? laws 7 "h be=e man appe>$ ^u ! /age ( action2 !y w be "h :5 he is gone4 ,m5 may doctor !mselves ) error ab\t tru?1 & error ab\t "r1 until !y come to be great imbeciles2 b ! tru? & ! "r w rema9 cle> & immortal = ! intellect & ! w ( ! wise & ! good4 ,,viii4 ,x is important1 z nev] be=e1 = ^? :o see ! tru? & recognize ! "r to decl>e ! same ) all au?ority4 ,x is said t ! ,emp]or ,h5ry ,,iv4 /ood %iv]+ two :ole days & nights 9 ! sn[s ( ! c\rty>d ( ,canossa ,ca/le1 su+ pite\sly = p]mission to ?r[ himself1 9 agoniz$ submission1 at ! feet ( ,hildebr&4 ,t he 0 %unn$ by 8 subjects m absolutely because ( ! ban t 0 ^u him ?an he w\ld h be5 _h he be5 afflict$ ) ! smallpox4 ,?is incid5t illu/rates = u ! au?ority wield$ by ! ,*ur* ( ! ,middle ,ages4 ,! ,*ur* 0 !n felt to be 9 t\* ) trem5d\s p[]4 ,its fulm9ations c>ri$ t]ror to ! he>ts ( k+s & subjects4 ,:at ! ,*ur* decl>$ %\ld be done1 or %\ld be left undone1 ! p felt c\ld only be disreg>d$ at ! p]il ( all hope = "t & et]nity4 ,x n only decl>$ ! duties m5 7 "u ! necessity ( obs]v+ 9 ord] to save _! s\ls1 b ! k9d ( ?\ghts m5 7 "u ! necessity ( ?9k+ conc]n+ ! %ape ( ! e>?1 ! movem5ts ( ! />s1 & ! /ructure ( ! human body1 9 ord] to save !mselves f ! odium ( h]esy4 ,! ,*ur* reign$ )\t a rival 9 all ! civiliz$ _w4 ,%e 0 n expect$ to give any reason = h] actions or h] utt]ances4 ,:5 %e det]m9$ :at ! ord] ( ! sol> sy/em 01 ! bra9s ( m5 7 compell$1 )\t "q1 to acquiesce4 ,ev5 to d\bt 0 to d5y ! fai?4 ,! ,*ur* dictat$ ! policy ( ! />s )\t be+ at ! tr\ble ( /udy+ ! />s2 & no o!r sid]eal op9ions 7 tol]at$ b su* z %e =mulat$ & publi%$4 ,b ! m9ds ( s*ol>s & /ud5ts1 9 diff]5t p>ts ( ,europe1 began to rea* o!r conclusions conc]n+ ! nature & ord] ( ?+s ?an su* z _h be5 ecclesia/ically settl$ = !m4 ,cop]nicus saw t ! heav5ly bodies did n move 9 accordance ) ! tea*+s ( ! ,*ur*4 ,& :5 ! ,v5etian s*ol>s look$ ?r\gh ! telescope ( ,galileo at ,padua1 & saw ,jupit] & 8 satellites1 a c5tral sun & revolv+ planets1 ! au?ority ( ! ,*ur* on ! subject ( a/ronomy 0 gone4 ,9 ?is way ! ,*ur* has be5 =c$ to give up "o position aft] ano!r4 ,! p1 see+ %e _h no f\ndation = ! op9ions %e held conc]n+ nature1 began to "q ! value ( h] op9ions conc]n+ ,god1 & heav5 & hell1 & "r & wrong4 ,n[ ! ,*ur* mu/ rega9 h] note ( au?ority4 ,%e mu/ d ?is by see+ :at ! laws are :i* gr[ out ( ! facts ( condition4 ,! laws ( ! family are to be d$uc$ f ! tru?s ( relation :i* con/itute ! family4 ,^! w be se5 to co9cide ) ! old laws utt]$ f ,s9ai4 ,! laws ( society are to be d$uc$ f ! tru?s ( relation :i* con/itute society4 ,^!1 x w be se51 are summ$ up z 0 said ( old 9 ! =mula1 8,?\ %alt love ?y neighbor z ?yself40 ,:5 m5 get ?r\gh fram+ laws = ! regulation ( human conduct1 f a /udy ( ! facts ( human nature1 !y w f9d to _! amazem5t t !y h re9/at$ ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts1 & t ,s9ai is n a burnt out volcano4 ,!y w f9d t ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts are /ill ! f\ndations ( social heal?1 & h>mony1 & progress4 ,god wrote !m = ,moses on tables ( /one because he _h already writt5 !m 9 ! nature ( man4 ,! laws ( gravity c no m be read out ( ! _w ( space ?an ! ,et]nal ,decalogue c be read out ( ! _w ( human life4 ,s ! man ( law %\ld speak ) ! same au?ority z ! man ( sci5ce1 )\t apology & )\t misgiv+s4 ,,beauty4 8,if ! endeavor to analyze ! _w is a trifle1 x is because ! _w is su*4 ,! sum ( ?+s c h no second int5tion1 nor c x be *>act]iz$ by any trait t is n includ$ 9 itself4 ,"s ?+s are sweet1 b :at is our s5se :i* p]ceives !m2 "s ?+s are good1 b :at is our consci5ce :i* judges !m2 "s ?+s are true1 b :at is our intellect :i* argues !m2 "s ?+s are deep1 b :at is our reason :i* fa?oms !m8 ,ev]yone :o ?9ks deeply1 mu/ h reflect$ t1 if ! purposes & results ( man's practice are vanity1 s also mu/ be ^? ( 8 speculation4 ,goe! said1 t !re 0 no refuge f virtues t 7 n our own1 b 9 lov+ !m2 & ,ecclesia/es1 t !re 0 none f ! vanity ( life1 b 9 fe>+ & obey+ ,god4 ,s1 also1 f ! vanity ( speculation !re is no refuge b 9 acquiesc+ 9 its relative nature1 & accept+ tru? = :at x is40 ,,*apt] ,v4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,/hetic ,,nature ,,( ,,man4 ,! glory ( ! m9d is ! possession ( two eyes1 ! eye ( s5se & ! eye ( reason4 ,?r\gh ! "o1 x looks out ^u ! _w ( matt] & fact4 ,?r\gh ! o!r1 x beholds ! _w ( idea & relation4 ,! _w ( matt] & fact1 se5 ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se1 is lift$ & transfigur$ & multipli$ a ?\s&fold :5 contemplat$ ?r\gh ! eye ( reason4 ,:5 ! lit]al _w is transf]r$ to ! ideal _w1 x takes on hues & dim5sions 9 accordance ) ! univ]sal & illimitable nature ( man4 ,! _w :i* ! s5se sees1 & ! _w :i* ! reason sees1 are bo? real1 & ?r\gh ! m9d comm]ce is kept up betwe5 !m4 ,along ?is m5tal highway facts make a pilgrimage to ! holy l& ( reason2 !re !y are *ang$ into ideas4 ,/>s are turn$ into a/ronomy1 atoms into *emi/ry1 rocks into geology1 plants into botany1 colors into beauty & s\nds into h>mony4 ,ov] ! same royal road1 ideas pass to ! _w ( s5se4 ,!re !y are *ang$ aga9 into facts4 ,ideas ( beauty1 di/ill$ 9 ! alembic ( ! imag9ation f ! sev5 prismatic colors1 are turn$ into pa9t+1 & ,raphael's 8,transfiguration0 blesses ! _w4 ,ideas ( h>mony1 =m$ by ! p[] ( ! imag9ation f ! notes ( ! musical scale1 are turn$ into song1 & ,h&el's 8,messiah0 agitates ! ?\ghts & feel+s ( m5 ) ! melody ( ! skies4 ,ideas ( =m1 d$uc$ f ! contemplation ( ! %apes ( ?+s1 are turn$ into sculpture1 & ,mi*ael ,angelo's 8,moses0 augm5ts ! _w's fund ( conviction & c\rage4 ,by *ang+ facts into ideas1 ! m9d gives u sci5ce4 ,by *ang+ ideas back to facts1 x gives u art4 ,)\t sci5ce1 life w\ld be )\t bread2 )\t art1 x w\ld be )\t ideals4 ,sci5ce m9i/]s to ! body1 art to ! _s4 ,m5 :o g f ?+s to ideas are practical2 ^? :o g f ideas back to ?+s are ! se]s4 ,practical m5 cons]ve1 b nev] v5ture4 ,se]s ?r[ ! light ( _! g5ius into ! d>k beyond1 disclos+ new worlds = m54 ,!y are ! lead]s1 !y are 9 ! vangu>d ( human progress4 ,by ! possession ( two eyes1 ! eye ( s5se & ! eye ( reason1 man is plac$ into relation ) two worlds4 ,! _w he sees by ! eye ( s5se is meag]1 limit$1 pov]ty-/rick54 ,!re are only a few h\ses 9 x1 a little clump ( trees1 a little pat* ( mead[1 a horizon h\nd$ by ! curl ( 8 cab9 smoke4 ,! _w he sees by ! eye ( reason /ret*es f> d[n into ! twilight ( ! pa/1 embrac+ all ages1 all /ages ( progress1 all empires & republics1 all lit]ature & peoples4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( s5se1 he sees a _w ( h>d limitation & fact4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( reason1 a univ]se ( ideas1 visions1 relations4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( s5se1 he sees a c&le1 ) its flick]+ & pass+ flame4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( reason1 he sees a k+dom ( light1 ) tru? & beauty1 & love bill[+ away to inf9ity4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( s5se he sees a little m\nta9 spr+ rise f ! gr\nd1 to lose itself 9 ! deep5+ %ad[s ( ! trees4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( reason he sees a riv]1 cle> z cry/al1 fl[+ =ev] f "u ! ?rone ( ,god4 ,a few violets & butt]cups1 cov]+ ) _! blue & _! beauty a little /rip ( mead[1 he sees ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se4 ,! hills ( day1 numb]less & immeasurable1 cov]$ ) fl[]s1 ^: leaves nev] )] & ^: beauty nev] fades1 he sees ?r\gh ! eye ( reason4 ,x is ! conceit ( ^? ^: habit ( m9d is to look ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se alone1 t !y see m 9 ! actual tangible _w ?an ^? :o are accu/om$ to look ?r\gh ! eye ( reason z well z ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se4 ,!re nev] 0 a great] mi/ake4 ,^? :o see mo/ 9 ! _w ( m\nta9 & sea & sky1 are ^? :o look mo/ ?r\gh ! eye ( reason into ! _w ( idea1 pr9ciple1 & relation4 ,adams 9 ,engl&1 & ,lev]ri] 9 ,france1 discov]$ ,neptune1 n by sweep+ ! heav5s ) _! telescopes1 b by c>eful ciph]+ 9 _! /udies4 8,mr4 ,turn]10 said a fri5d to him "o day1 8,i nev] see 9 nature ! gl[s & colors y put into y\r pictures40 8,ah6 don't y wi% y c\ld1 ?\gh10 0 ! pa9t]'s reply4 ,9 an apple's fall ,newton sees ! law ( gravitation4 ,goe! sees 9 ! sections ( a de]'s skull ! sp9al column modifi$4 ,em]son s+s3 8,let me g :]e'er ,i w1 ,i he> a sky-born music /ill4 ',tis n 9 ! />s alone1 ,nor 9 ! cups ( budd+ fl[]s1 ,nor 9 ! r$-brea/'s yell[ tone1 ,nor 9 ! b[ t smiles 9 %[]s2 ,b 9 ! mud & scum ( ?+s1 ,!re always1 always some?+ s+s40 ,humboldt habitually dwelt 9 ! realm ( pr9ciples & ideas4 ,he sp5t only five ye>s 9 ,am]ica1 & x took twelve qu>tos1 & sixte5 folios1 & half a doz5 help]s1 & _m ye>s to put on record :at he saw4 8,! poem hangs on ! b]ry bu%1 ,:5 comes ! poet's eye1 ,& ! /reet is "o long masqu]ade ,:5 ,%aksp]e passes by40 ,i4 ,yet ! m9d mu/ fir/ see ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se1 be=e x is capable ( see+ ?r\gh ! eye ( reason4 ,! univ]se1 t really belongs to ! m9d1 ! eye ( s5se nev] sees1 b x sees some?+ t sugge/s x4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( s5se man takes 9 a few colors1 b ^! sugge/ to ,rub5s ! magnific5t visions :i* illum9ate ! art gall]ies ( ,europe4 ,?r\gh ! s5se man he>s a few notes1 b ^! are tak5 & multipli$ into ! symphonies ( ,bee?ov54 ,?r\gh ! eye ( s5se1 ,columbus sees a few pieces ( driftwood br\ght to ! %ore by ! waves ( ! ev]-re/less sea2 b ^! help him1 ?r\gh ! eye ( reason1 to see a new _w ) its virg9 =e/s1 its wide-rea*+ pla9s & its maje/ic m\nta9 ranges4 ,agassiz sees ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se an ind5tation on a rock 9 ! ,/ate ( ,ma9e4 ,?is gives him a sugge/ion :i* helps him to see1 ?r\gh ! eye ( reason1 ! iceb]gs & ! glaci]s1 :i*1 9 ! e>ly ages1 gr\nd _! way to ! s\?4 ,! man ( sci5ce sees ?r\gh ! eye ( s5se1 only a bit ( *alk2 b f ?is a sugge/ion comes to him1 :i* enables him to see ?r\gh ! eye ( reason ! oozy b$ ^u :i* ! subm>9e cable re/s2 & ! life t sport$ 9 ! va/ oceans :5 ! ,dov] ,cliffs 7 be+ =m$4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( s5se ,cuvi] sees an imm5se too?1 l>g] ?an any kn[n at ! pres5t4 ,?r\gh ! eye ( reason he sees ! huge animal 9 ^: jaw x 0 set4 ,^u ! compreh5sive1 active p[] ( reason1 man relies to det]m9e = him ! elem5ts good = food1 ! p[] :i* s]ves 8 social nature1 ! tru? :i* furni%es 8 intellect1 ! "r :i* mat*es 8 w1 & ! beauty :i* corresponds ) 8 /hetic nature4 ,! univ]se l5ds itself 9 its totality to ! scale & ! dip ( ! p>ticul> capacity or p[] ?r\gh :i* man1 = ! "t be+1 seeks to appropriate x4 ,x /&s be=e ! s5se ( hung] 9 t]ms ( bread4 ,x /&s be=e ! social nature 9 t]ms ( p[]4 ,x /&s be=e ! intellect 9 t]ms ( tru?4 ,x /&s be=e ! w 9 t]ms ( law4 ,x /&s be=e ! /hetic nature 9 t]ms ( beauty4 ,! p]son :o has relat$ himself to ! _w ?r\gh all ! p[]s ( 8 nature1 f9ds x capable1 by turns1 ( fe$+ e faculty ) :i* he is end[$4 ,! univ]se is n[ all bread1 n[ all p[]1 n[ all tru?1 n[ all law1 & n[ all beauty4 ,x w be any or all ( ^!1 accord+ to ! side1 or sides1 ( himself ?r\gh :i* he addresses x4 ,"o ( ! great discov]ies ( mod]n times is ! correlation ( =ces4 ,! p]si/5t =ce may express itself 9 heat1 or light1 or electricity1 or magnetism4 ,^! are only diff]5t =ms ( ! same ?+1 & any "o may pass to any ( ! o!rs4 ,9 ! _w1 z a :ole1 we f9d ! s5se ( correlation inh]es1 z x relates itself to ! diff]5t faculties man has = tak+ hold ( x4 ,z ! correlate ( hung]1 x is all bread2 z ! correlate ( ! social nature1 x is all p[]2 z ! correlate ( ! intellect1 x is all tru?2 z ! correlate ( ! w1 x is all law1 & z ! correlate ( ! /hetic s5se1 x is all beauty4 ,objective reality is address$ to ! _m sides ( human life1 9 ord] t ! :ole ( x may be us$ up = ! purpose ( mak+ a man4 ,x is all to be drawn into manhood4 ,z all riv]s meet 9 ! ocean1 & all colors meet 9 ! :ite ray ( light2 s objective reality1 9 all t x is = food1 = p[]1 = tru?1 = "r1 = beauty2 is to meet 9 human life1 = nutrim5t1 = furni%m5t1 & = ! completion ( manhood4 ,if y want to "k :at ! objective self ( ! fi% is1 look at ! ocean4 ,if y want to "k :at ! objective self ( ! eagle is1 look at ! sky4 ,if y want to "k :at ! objective self ( ! elephant is1 look at ! ,asiatic jungle4 ,if y want to "k :at ! objective self ( man is1 look at ! conditions ( food1 p[]1 tru?1 law1 & beauty :i* environ him4 ,! fi% gets ! wat]1 ! bird gets ! air1 & ! elephant gets ! jungle2 b man1 ) a nature illimitable1 ) capacities inexhau/ible1 ) hung] deep z tru?1 ) aspirations z wide z "r1 & ) an ideal z unfa?omable z beauty1 is ! *ild ( ! et]nal ,god1 & is to get ! fullness ( 8 nature 9 no?+ less ?an ! entire expression :i* ,god has made ( himself 9 objective reality4 ,,ii4 ,all tru?1 z we h be=e /at$1 :i* man has tri$ to express1 is b a transcript ( div9e tru?4 ,! tru? ( a/ronomy is a transcript f ! reality ( ! />s4 ,! tru? ( botany is a transcript f ! reality ( plants4 ,! tru? ( geology is a transcript f ! reality ( ! e>?'s /ructure4 ,all "r1 :i* man has s\ght to embody 9 /atutes1 9 con/itutions1 9 enactm5ts1 is b a transcript f ! w ( ,god4 ,s all beauty1 :i* man has attempt$ to symbolize1 is conta9$ 9 ! nature ( ?+s1 & has its s\rce 9 ,god4 ,! beauty man has se5 has tak5 9 ! process ( hi/ory _m =ms4 ,x is se5 9 ar*itecture1 sculpture1 poetry1 pa9t+1 & music4 ,^! are diff]5t =ms ( ! same ?+4 ,z ! p]si/5t physical =ce expresses itself 9 heat1 light1 electricity1 & magnetism1 s g5ius is ! p]si/5t m5tal =ce :i* expresses itself 9 art4 ,sometimes ! p]si/5t m5tal =ce comes to su* unity & fullness 9 "s massive s\l t f him x goes out into all ! f9e arts4 ,mi*ael ,angelo 0 by turns poet1 pa9t]1 sculptor1 & ar*itect4 ,_h he liv$ 9 ,g]many 9 ! "t ( ,bee?ov5 he w\ld h add$ to 8 o!r accompli%m5ts t ( music4 ,! noble/ specim5s ( music are only great ca!drals con/ruct$ out ( s\nd1 z ,mi*ael ,angelo's 8,moses0 0 a great epic poem wr\ght 9 /one4 ,we wi% to consid] beauty 9 its relation to ! /hetic s5se1 9 two aspects ( itself4 ,! mo/ important =ms ( beauty h z ! physical conditions ( _! exi/5ce light & s\nd1 & z ! ideal conditions ( _! exi/5ce space & "t4 ,! names man gives to ^! =ms ( beauty1 :5 he expresses !m1 or re-expresses !m1 are pa9t+ & music4 ,= no elem5t ( man's nature has m m>vel\s provision be5 made ?an = ! /hetic elem5t4 ,! objective conditions ( ! beauty1 :i* correspond to ! subjective /hetic s5se1 are conta9$ 9 s\nd & light4 ,s\nd & light are ! invisible physical =ces :i* play ^u ! objects ( nature1 & call f !m ! responses ( melody & vision :i* ! /hetic nature appropriates = ec/asy & delight4 ,capacity = s\nd is lodg$ 9 well-nigh all creat$ objects4 ,m9]als1 woods1 gases1 & liquids ev51 conta9 ! notes ( ! musical scale4 ,build]s ( pianos1 h>ps1 put no notes 9 ! elem5ts !y use 9 ! con/ruction ( ^! in/rum5ts4 ,!y simply comply ) conditions necess>y to br+ !m out4 ,! music we get out ( wood & /eel & brass1 z we f9d !m arrang$ 9 ! piano1 ! organ1 ! h>p1 by /rik+ !m at regul> int]vals1 is ! melody brea!d into !m :5 !y 7 creat$4 ,bee?ov51 ,h&el1 & ,moz>t creat$ no music4 ,_! g5ius 0 manife/$ simply 9 ! p[] to br+ out ( =e/ & m9e & cane-brake :at ,god put into !m4 ,z to :at note a body %all give up "u t5sion & pressure1 is ow+ to its ultimate /ructure1 & ! elem5ts :i* compose x2 & also ! note lat5t 9 ! object by :i* x is /ruck1 or press$4 ,s+ into a piano & ! same notes respond :i* are us$ 9 ! execution ( ! song4 ,a /orm1 h[l+ ?r\gh a =e/1 makes a l\d noise1 b no music4 ,its notes d n syn*ronize ) ^? conta9$ 9 ! limbs & leaves ( ! trees4 ,b :5 ! l[1 sad murmur ( ! ev5+ w9ds g5tly /rike ! ne$les ( ! long-leaf p9e !re is music4 ,! notes ( ! "o are relat$ to ! notes ( ! o!r4 ,z all ?+s h capacity = s\nd1 s well-nigh all creat$ ?+s h capacity = color4 ,! color :i* an object takes on 9 ! pres5ce ( light is det]m9$ also by its ultimate /ructure & ! elem5ts :i* con/itute x4 ,ne>ly e object absorbs a portion ( ! light & ?r[s back to ! eye ( ! behold] a portion4 ,bodies absorb ^? rays :i* are syn*ron\s ) _! con/itu5t elem5ts4 ,:5 ! p>ticles :i* compose a body are n capable ( vibrat+ at ! rate ( any portion ( ! light p>ticles1 !n !y are all ?r[n back1 & ! body is pron\nc$ :ite4 ,x is to be obs]v$ t no body has color or s\nd ( its own1 b only ! capacity = ^!4 ,! note ( a body is discov]$ by /rik+ x1 & its color by /imulat+ x ) a light ray4 ,ano!r int]e/+ fact is to be not$ "h--t is ! analogy betwe5 s\nd & light1 or music & pa9t+4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 a s\nd wave & a light wave is only a diff]5ce ( l5g?4 ,! pr9ciples und]ly+ !m are ! same1 & ! me?ods by :i* !y are produc$ are ! same4 ,s\nd waves1 to be he>d1 mu/ vibrate at lea/ z (t5 z sixte5 beats to ! second4 ,light waves1 9 ord] to pass ?r\gh ! organ ( vision1 & rea* ! ret9a ( ! eye1 mu/ n vibrate at a less rate ?an f\r hundr$ trillions ( times to ! second4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 ! eye & ! e> is1 "o is m ref9$ ?an ! o!r4 ,a pa9t+ is a sil5t piece ( music1 & a piece ( music is an audible picture4 ,! notes ( ! musical scale & ! colors ( ! prismatic scale are analog\s4 ,! di/ance betwe5 ,c & ,a ( ! musical scale is ! same z ! di/ance betwe5 r$ & orange ( ! prismatic scale4 ,! notes ( ! "o scale may be translat$ into ! colors ( ! o!r4 ,h>mony ( colors 9 a silk dress1 w\ld1 if translat$ into _! analog\s notes1 produce a piece ( music t w\ld be equally z pleas+ to ! e> z ! colors are to ! eye4 ,pa9t+ is only a m ref9$ =m ( music4 ,?is is n fancy2 x is ma!matics & sci5ce4 ,all ?+s ab\t u are capable ( music1 sil5t or audible4 ,notes belong+ to "s "p ( a great song are lodg$ 9 all creat$ objects4 ,?+s are n measur$ (f 9 cont95ts1 oceans1 isl&s1 m\nta9s1 =e/s1 & m9es only1 b also 9 octaves4 ,! music ( ! sph]es is no long] a dream ( ! poets1 b 9 accordance ) exact sci5ce4 ,! mat]ial sy/em into :i* we are born is capable1 !n1 n only ( furni%+ u food to eat & clo!s to we>1 b music & pa9t+ = ! s5se ( ! beautiful4 ,a m]e utilit>ian1 bread-&-butt] philosophy does n exhau/ ! possibilities ( ev5 ! mat]ial _w4 ,9 its v con/ruction respect to man's high] nature 0 _h1 z well z to 8 l[]4 ,by s mu* z music & h>mony ( color surpass 9 _! subtlety & ref9em5t ! co>s] elem5ts necess>y to su/a9 ! l[] nature2 by s mu* has ,god emphasiz$ ! value ( ! high] nature4 ,_h ,god int5d$ 8 *ildr5 = no high] plane ?an t ^u :i* ! animals live1 & no great] future = !m ?an t :i* belongs to 8! bea/s t p]i%10 d\btless ! beauty w\ld h be5 left out4 ,m5 h be5 told1 by "o hav+ au?ority1 n to ca/ _! pe>ls be=e sw9e4 ,! beauty t 0 flung at ! feet ( man conta9$ a message to a side ( himself key$ to a radiant & imp]i%able realm4 ,:o does n feel1 "u ! *>m ( music1 or ! influ5ce ( a great pa9t+1 reasons = high liv+ :i* no words c express8 ,! te> :i* (t5 ga!rs 9 ! eye ( ! mo/ ab&on$1 h>d5$ man1 "u ! p[] ( song1 bespeaks ! fact t *ords h be5 t\*$ :i* vibrate responsive to no e>?ly int]e/ or relation4 ,,iii4 ,! melody 9 s\nd & ! h>mony 9 color are correlat$ to ! /hetic nature ( man ?r\gh ! e> & ! eye4 ,9 ! e> is f\nd ! musical scale1 & 9 ! eye ! prismatic scale4 ,notes are 9 ! e> :i* correspond ) ! ,c ,d ,e ,f ,g ,a ,b ( ! musical scale1 & p>ts are 9 ! eye :i* correspond to ! r$1 orange1 yell[1 gre51 blue1 indigo1 & violet ( ! prismatic scale4 ,x is only ?r\gh ,d 9 ! e> t ,d out ( ! e> c be he>d1 & x is ) ,c 9 ! e> t ,c out ( ! e> is he>d4 ,if !re 7 no notes 9 ! e> except ,d1 & all o!r notes 9 nature 7 de/roy$1 ! e> c\ld he> no notes at all4 ,a he>s ,a1 & ,b he>s ,b1 & ,c he>s ,c4 ,:at ,a he>s1 ,b does n he>1 & :at ,c he>s1 ,a does n he>4 ,:at is true ( ! e> is true ( ! eye4 ,! p>ts ( ! eye ) :i* r$ is se5 are n ! p>ts ) :i* gre5 is se54 ,r$ 9 ! eye sees r$ out ( ! eye4 ,blue 9 ! eye sees blue out ( ! eye1 & gre5 9 ! eye sees gre5 out ( ! eye4 ,if !re 0 9 ! prismatic scale locat$ 9 ! eye only ! "p ) :i* blue is se51 no color 9 ! _w w\ld be visible except ! blue4 ,! notes lat5t 9 all natural objects are address$ to ! /hetic s5se1 ?r\gh ! correspond+ notes lat5t 9 ! e>2 & ! sev5 colors1 capacity = :i* is lat5t 9 all e>?ly objects1 address !mselves to ! /hetic nature ?r\gh ! correspond+ capacities = color conta9$ 9 ! eye4 ,t man is relat$ to ! k+dom ( beauty 9 a s5se :i* m>ks him (f f ! animals bel[ him1 is prov5 by ! fact t he c take ! elem5ts ( ?is k+dom into 8 imag9ation & s5d !m back to ! realms ( s5se1 9 oratorios & pa9t+s4 ,! ma/]s h giv5 all hi/ory ideal & p]man5t sett+ by means ( s\nd & light4 ,man _c only see ! tru?1 b repeat x2 n only recognize ! "r1 b con=m to x1 & n only appreciate beauty1 b express x4 ,9 ?is he has ! evid5ce ( 8 k9%ip ) ! au?or ( ! true1 ! good1 & ! beautiful4 ,! l[] animals1 z f> z we "k1 may be ?rill$ ) t :i* is beautiful2 we d "k !y nev] repeat ! beautiful4 ,9 ! art gall]ies & cons]vatories ( ! _w all ! pa/ is br\ght to life aga9 & /&s be=e ! eye & ! e>1 "u ! ideal =ms ( "t & space4 ,moses is n only immortal 9 ! laws :i* he wrote1 & 9 ! race :i* he civiliz$1 b1 ?r\gh ,mi*ael ,angelo's g5ius1 he has be5 made et]nal 9 ! k+dom ( beauty4 ,?us1 ?r\gh 8 /hetic side1 man n only receives1 b he gives4 ,! melody ( s\nd & ! h>mony ( color n only come to him1 b g f him2 & f him1 too1 *>g$ & %ot ?r\gh ) all ! suff]+1 temptation1 s91 & sacrifice he has kn[n4 ,,iv4 ,! empirical philosophy1 :i* r$uces k to s5sations & morality to laws impos$ by prud5ce1 & man himself to ! same plane ( life occupi$ by ! l[] animals1 invades ! doma9 ( /hetics1 & makes ( beauty a m]e matt] ( individual feel+1 local conv5tion1 & arbitr>y fa%ion4 ,?is philosophy ( ! dirt d5ies to m9d any inh]5t1 creative activity1 9 ! region ( k1 morals1 or art4 ,n[1 x is d\btless true1 t food & p[] & beauty ( color & tone are address$ to ! l[] animals2 suffici5tly1 at lea/1 = !m to get ! means ( subsi/5ce1 & "s l[ sort ( pleasure f !m4 ,!y d ?is1 h[ev]1 n by reason1 b by in/9ct4 ,! bee is det]m9$ by its nature to build 8 cell 9 accordance ) ma!matical pr9ciples1 & to /ore x ) honey f ! leaves & ! fl[]s4 ,! bee does ?is z naturally z wat] runs d[n-hill4 ,!re is no calculation 9 x1 & ! bee does n recognize itself 9 ! process ( ?is "w4 ,! bird may be det]m9$ 9 ! selection ( its mate by brilliant plumage1 or joy\s song1 b ?is x does j z a rock turn$ loose f ! top ( a h\se falls to ! gr\nd4 ,! evid5ce ( a comb9+1 m5tal activity 9 man1 to :i* ?+s 9 ! outside _w are address$1 9 a peculi> & di/9ct s5se1 is f\nd 9 ! fact t man n only receives ! ?+s t come to him1 b s5ds !m f him 9 ! =ms ( 8 own ?\ght4 ,! bee appropriates ! honeydew t cov]s ! surface ( ! leaves1 /ores x 9 8 cell1 & eats x 9 ! w9t]2 b :o ev] knew bees to plant out trees 9 ord] t !re might be leaves f :i* to secure honeydew8 ,man f9ds ! bananas t gr[ 9 ! tropics1 & ! b]ries t gr[ 9 ! temp]ate zones1 & eats !m2 b he sees h[ bananas & b]ries gr[1 & s cle>s fields & h$ges1 to insure a m abundant crop4 ,! monkey he>s ! ?und] & sees ! lightn+ z well z ! man1 b man inve/igates ! nature ( lightn+2 he sees ! pr9ciple und]ly+ its weird movem5ts1 ! ?+s = :i* x has aff9ity4 ,s he contrives v>i\s me?ods = utiliz+ x4 ,! m9d )9 him be+ ! same 9 k9d z ! m9d :i* s5ds ! lightn+1 he sees h[ lightn+ is s5t1 & s5ds x4 ,he n only sees ?und]-/orms1 b h[ !y are made4 ,s ! pr(essor creates !m 9 glass j>s = ! b5efit ( 8 class4 ,nature pres5ts h]self to man "u uni=m me?ods ( action4 ,ev]y:]e is regul>ity & ord]l9ess4 ,he reproduces ?is ord] 9 political & social life4 ,! laws )\t him k9dle into expression ! moral magaz9e ( volition )9 him4 ,nature pres5ts h]self to man z unity4 ,?is implies m9d4 ,unity is impossible )\t m9d4 ,! m9d und]nea? ! unity1 )\t him1 speaks to ! m9d )9 him4 ,!n by 8 own m9d he recreates ! univ]se 9 lit]ature4 ,he he>s ! caw+ ( rooks1 ! coo+ ( doves1 ! purl+ ( brooks1 & ! ro> ( tempe/s4 ,^!1 ) all o!r s\nds 9 nature1 are caught & comb9$ 9 ! m>vel\s creation ( ,moz>t & ,bee?ov54 ,mu* is said by ! le>n$ m5 :o are ev] seek+ to m9ify man's place 9 nature1 ab\t ! reason & memory1 & intellig5ce1 & ev5 consci5ce ( ! l[] animals4 ,x is almo/ en\gh to make "o wi% he 7 a dog or a horse :5 he reads h[ mu* s5se & h[ mu* consci5ce dogs & horses h4 ,n mu* weight1 h[ev]1 w ev] be giv5 to ^! long treatises on ! intellig5ce ( ! l[] animals1 until "s bee %all give u a book on ma!matics1 or until "s horse %all tell ?r\gh "o ( our agricultural j\rnals ! be/ "t to s[ clov]2 or "s dog %all give u ! philosophy ( ! *ase4 ,we see ! capacity ( ! human m9d 9 ,%aksp]e's plays4 ,s "o picture pa9t$ by a cat1 "o poem writt5 by a mule1 "o philosophical diss]tation compos$ by an owl1 or "o cocoanut plantation plant$ by ! monkeys1 w\ld e/abli% beyond "q t ! high claims made = ! m5tal capabilities ( ^! humble memb]s ( ! animal creation are ju/ifi$4 ,man gr[s :eat by ! use ( ! m9d )9 him1 :i* sees h[ ! m9d )\t him has made ! gr[? ( :eat possible4 ,man utilizes p[]1 by ! use ( ! m9d )9 him1 :i* recognizes h[ p[] is produc$ & controll$ by ! m9d )\t him4 ,man sees tru?1 because ! m9d )9 him is l ! m9d )\t him1 :i* expresses itself 9 tru?4 ,man sees law1 because ! m9d )9 him is l ! m9d )\t him :i* orda9$ law4 ,s man sees beauty1 because ! m9d )9 him is l ! m9d )\t him1 :i* expresses itself 9 beauty4 ,food1 & tru?1 & law1 & beauty1 _c be reproduc$ by man1 except by ! laws ( m9d act+ 9 him z ! laws ( m9d d )\t him4 ,v4 ,:at is ! use ( beauty8 ,l tru? & law1 x looks beyond itself4 ,x is to help realize ! purpose = :i* ! e>? 0 creat$1 ! purpose :i* f9ds its consummation 9 a p]fect man4 ,beauty comes to man1 be>+ intimations ( 8 high orig9 & also ( 8 glori\s de/9y4 ,"u ! magic spell :i* beauty ?r[s ar\nd him1 he =gets = ! "t be+ 8 limitations1 8 fe>s1 8 d\bts4 ,he is lift$ into a realm ( univ]sal fre$om1 :]e all difficulties disappe>1 :]e all conflicts are elim9at$4 ,! /hetic nature is n at all seclusive & ari/ocratic4 ,x receives ! melody1 & symmetry1 & h>mony :i* reason f9ds 9 ! tones1 & =ms1 & colors ( ! outside _w1 & turns ov] to x4 ,^! ri* gifts are !n %>$ ) all o!r human p[]s & faculties4 ,hung] is s]v$ ) food set 9 pa9t$ *9a4 ,ar\nd ! table1 :]e man satisfies 8 appetite1 pictures are hung1 & ! beef m>ket & ! mill are built & arrang$ 9 accordance ) ! dictates ( symmetry & ta/e4 ,! college1 :]e tru? is taught1 & ! c\r?\se1 :]e law is adm9i/]$1 are inve/$ ) all ! beauty ( ! ar*itect's g5ius4 ,?us beauty1 high1 heav5-born1 & refre%+1 is drawn into all ! relations1 & ?r[n ar\nd all ! in/itutions ( life4 ,x r$uces friction1 r$resses littl5ess1 & adds to life good *e] & dep?4 ,x smoo!s ! r\gh places1 r\nds ! %>p corn]s1 & hangs ! b[ ( hope on ! d>k cl\d ( com+ trial4 ,! /hetic s5se1 nurtur$ on beauty1 keeps be=e ! m9ds ( m5 & nations a prop] ideal ( life4 ,:5 ! ideal held be=e ! m9d at "o p]iod ( advancem5t is rea*$1 ! /hetic s5se has already lift$ ano!r & a nobl]1 z f> ahead ( ! actual z ! fir/4 ,9 pres5t+ to ! liv+ _s ideals always 9 advance ( actual atta9m5t1 ! /hetic nature op5s ! un5d+ pa? ( progress4 ,x is incorrect to suppose t ! ideal is work$ out only 9 pa9t+1 symphony1 or ca!dral4 ,its pres5ce is manife/ 9 ! useful1 z well z ! f9e arts4 ,! ideal (t5 gets itself translat$ into ! heel ( a %oe1 into ! cr[n ( a hat1 into ! :eel ( a wagon1 into ! f5ce ar\nd ! field1 & into ! /ructure ( ! m[] & ! reap]4 ,x curves 9 ! ar*es ( bridges1 e*oes 9 ! s\nd ( ! hamm]1 & breaks ov] ! hills 9 ! :i/le ( ! eng9e4 ,! progress ( beauty 9 mod]n times has n be5 9 ! direction ( =m or color+ or symmetry1 simply1 b t[>d wid] di/ribution4 ,9 e>ly times1 its m9i/ry 0 to k+s & s*ol>s2 x has advanc$ by exp&+4 ,! pyramid ( ,gizeh1 ! mo/ exp5sive monum5t ev] se51 0 re>$ to p]petuate ! memory ( a great ,egyptian k+4 ,a c\ntry 0 dra9$ ( rev5ue & ( life to regale ! pride ( "o man4 ,! ,p>!non m9i/]$ to a few great m5 9 ,greece4 ,! ca!drals ( ! middle ages ble/ & help$ a wid] circle4 ,b x 0 left to ! "t :i* is ours to build *ur*es & *apels1 z broad 9 _! aims & m9i/ry z ! life ( humanity4 ,! e>ly poetry conc]n$ itself ab\t ! w>s ( gods & ! cont5tions ( k+s4 ,b z ! sacr$ness ( human life came to be se5 m & m1 did x t5d to cat* )9 ! sweep ( its rhy?m ! incid5ts & traditions & loves ( ! common p4 ,! ideal 9 our day is be+ work$ out 9 fields ( wav+ gra91 into ! cattle ^u ! hills1 into ! homes ( ! p4 ,x is be+ turn$ into or*>ds & v9ey>ds4 ,x is be+ trac$ 9 v9es & fl[]s ov] ! poor man's cottage4 ,! ideals 7 once h\s$ & conf9$ 9 ! museums2 n[ !y are be+ turn$ out into ! /reet4 ,x 0 once ! cu/om to br+ ,v5us & ,diana1 by ! aid ( ! *isel1 f r\gh m>ble4 ,! t5d5cy n[ is to put ! beauty ( ,v5us & ! ent]prise ( ,diana into ! spirits ( our wom54 ,sublime conceptions 7 once ma9ly realiz$ 9 temples & ca!drals1 b n[ we w\ld see !m di/ribut$ into dwell+s = families1 into s*ools = *ildr51 & into *ur*es = ! true wor%ip ( ,god4 ,we w\ld see !m 9 bridges spann+ all ! riv]s1 9 mills gr9d+ ! p's bread1 9 factories sp9n+ _! clo!s1 & 9 railroads transport+ _! products4 ,we w\ld see !m lift$ into an asylum = ! bl9d1 a %elt] = ! orphan1 & a home = ! ag$ & infirm4 ,we w\ld he> !m 9 ! :irl ( ! sp9dle1 9 ! r+ ( ! hamm]1 9 ! spla% ( ! paddle1 & 9 ! s\nd ( ! fly+ tra94 ,we w\ld he> !m 9 ! /eady m>* ( progress1 & 9 ! pulse-beats ( ! happy pl[man4 ,beauty is to be us$ to /imulate human c\rage1 to embelli% human _s1 & to enl>ge human ?\ght4 ,life's %ad[s are to be *as$ by ! light ( et]nity's day1 & its tumult hu%$ by ! repose ( et]nity's h>mony4 ,! /hetic elem5t 9 man's nature 0 appo9t$ to receive ! beauty provid$ = x4 ,b x 0 to be ,god's almon]2 hav+ receiv$ x1 also freely to give x4 ,?us x 0 to be ! p[] ^: function %\ld be to put ! :ole ( life into t]ms ( h>mony4 ,b]n>d ,palissy put 8 ideal into a :ite enamel = 8 pott]y2 ,columbus work$ 8 ideal into a new _w2 ,morse left 8 9 ! electric telegraph2 ,cyrus ,w4 ,field turn$ 8 into ! subm>9e cable2 & ,?omas ,a4 ,edison has giv5 8 to ! _w 9 ! telephone4 ,x is n to be inf]r$1 h[ev]1 t ^? :o "w _! ideals out 9 ! useful arts contribute m to ! mak+ ( m5 ?an ^? :o express _! ideals 9 poetry1 pa9t+1 sculpture1 or music4 ,! t5d5cy ( beauty to get d[n into ! ord9>y "w & relations ( life is an intimation t all life %\ld be beautiful 9 itself1 & 9 all expressions :i* x makes ( itself4 ,! /hetic s5se is ! badge ( man's royalty4 ,a tutor 0 once employ$ to tea* ! son ( a k+4 ,! "y pr9ce 0 sometimes disob$i5t4 ,b 9 ! e/eem ( ! tutor1 x 0 n q prop] to :ip ! son ( a k+ ) a common swit*4 ,s to ! lapel ( ! boy's coat ! tea*] p9n$ a piece ( purple ribbon4 ,:5 ! "y pr9ce manife/$ a disposition to defy au?ority1 ! in/ructor po9t$ ) ! end ( ! rod to ! purple ribbon on 8 coat4 ,?is 0 an appeal to 8 royal blood4 ,n a fl[] ga!rs on ! limbs ( a rose bu% b addresses ! high & purple nature ( ev]yone :o beholds x4 ,9 ,mexico1 :]e ! av]age ( life is s l[1 ! fl[]s :i* gr[ 9 su* pr(usion are ab\t all t is left to keep ! p rem9d$ t !y are ! *ildr5 ( ,god1 ! au?or ( all beauty4 ,! highe/ evid5ce ( ! rema9+ wor? ( ! ,mexican p is f\nd 9 ! fact t !y love fl[]s ) a deep & unfail+ passion4 ,,vi4 ,beauty is to fe$ en?usiasm4 ,tones & colors are to be us$ to jo/le ! elem5ts ( m9d1 & w1 & emotion into h>mony ) ! high & holy life ( our ,fa!r :o art 9 ,heav54 ,beauty is to n]ve ! soldi] = ! battle1 ! m>tyr = ! /ake1 & ! h]o = 8 "w4 ,!re is a height ( developm5t to :i* ! human _s aspires1 t ! logical und]/&+ is unable to rea*4 ,"h1 !n1 :]e tru? 9 logical =m fails1 beauty comes1 & helps ! human _s to dis5tangle itself f ! sph]e ( contradictions & antagonisms4 ,tru? & "r comm& ! _s by an ext]nal necessity2 beauty moves x by an int]nal necessity & />ts x to vibrat+ 9 ! v c5t]s ( its be+1 9 consonance ) itself4 ,beauty lifts x to a p9nacle :]e ! horizon quadrates ) its irrepressible long+s2 & :]e ! :ole ( life is r\nd$ into an orb f :i* all /rife is elim9at$1 & all discord extract$4 ,m5 seek artificial /imulants & n>cotics1 because ( ! abid+ conviction !y h1 t _! lives 7 key$ to "s ideal realm ( unity & fre$om4 ,:at intoxicants d to ! detrim5t ( ! _s1 beauty accompli%es to its heal? & vigor4 ,x is c>ri$ by beauty into no l& ( vague dream1 & unreal delirium1 b into a radiant region :]e ! environ+ conditions exactly mat* its undy+ hopes4 ,,love4 8,!re are inde$ m5 ^: s\ls are l ! sea4 ,^? bill[s t ebb & flood1 t inexorable go+ & com+1 t noise ( all ! w9ds1 t blackness & t transluc5cy1 t vegetation peculi> to ! deep1 t democracy ( cl\ds 9 full hurricane1 ^? eagles fleck$ ) foam1 ^? wond]ful />-ris+s reflect$ 9 my/]i\s agitation by millions ( lum9\s wavetops1 confus$ heads ( ! multitud9\s sea--! errant lightn+s1 :i* seem to wat*2 ^? prodigi\s sobb+s1 ^? half-se5 mon/]s1 ^? nights ( d>kness brok5 by h[l+s1 ^? furies1 ^? fr5zies1 ^? torm5ts1 ^? rocks1 ^? %ipwrecks1 ^? fleets cru%+ ea* o!r2 !n t *>m1 t mildness1 ^? fe/ivals1 ^? gay :ite sails1 ^? fi%+ boats1 ^? songs amid ! upro>1 ^? %9+ ports1 ^? mi/s ris+ f ! %ore2 ^? wra?s & ^? appeasem5ts1 t all 9 "o1 ! un=ese5 amid ! *angeless1 ! va/ m>vel ( inexhau/ibly v>i$ monotony--all ?is may exi/ 9 a m9d1 & t m9d is call$ g5ius1 & y h s*ylus1 y h ,isaiah1 y h ,dante1 y h ,mi*ael ,angelo1 y h ,%aksp]e40 ,,*apt] ,,vi4 ,,! ,,provision ,,= ,,! ,,spiritual ,,nature ,,( ,,man4 ,9 speak+ ( ! spiritual nature ( man1 ref]5ce is n _h to a side or faculty or p[] ( himself1 b to 8 real1 ess5tial life4 ,man is a _s4 ,all faculties & p[]s exi/ = him z su*4 ,! hung]1 & ! food provid$ = x1 are to s]ve man z _s4 ,! social elem5t1 & ! p[] provid$ = x1 are to s]ve him z _s4 ,! intellect & tru?1 ! w & "r1 ! /hetic s5se & beauty1 are all to s]ve him z _s4 ,! correlate ( man z _s1 on "o side ( himself1 we h se5 to be ! life ( humanity--! correlate ( man z _s1 on ! o!r side ( himself1 is ! life ( ,god4 ,man's spiritual nature is m$iat$ to him on "o side by ! family1 by ! s*ool1 by ! in/itutions ( ! /ate1 by ! e/abli%m5ts ( trade1 by ! newspap]1 by lit]ature1 by art1 by hi/ory4 ,man's spiritual nature is m$iat$ to him on ! o!r side by love1 embodi$ 9 ! "o ,m$iator betwe5 ,god & man4 ,! mud-philosophy ( ,locke1 & ,hume1 & ,mill1 & ,sp5c] dissolves _s1 because x dissolves ! idea ( a m9d1 an ego1 or an ext]nal _w4 ,if ! m9d c "k no?+ b a succession ( ?+s 9 "t1 if no?+ b a con/ant fl[ & flux ( s5sations2 ( c\rse x _c "k itself1 only z a s5sation 9 ! p]petual procession ( s5sations always pass+ by4 ,b h[ is x possible = ! m9d to "k a succession ( ?+s 9 "t1 & a procession ( ?+s 9 space1 unless x is itself out ( & ap>t f ! succession & ! procession4 ,"o s5sation1 say ( ! self1 9 a fl[ ( s5sations1 c\ld n "k itself z a "p ( su* a fl[1 )\t kn[+ itself z relat$ to a be=e & an aft] 9 ! process4 ,to "k ev5 a procession ( s5sations1 we mu/ h a _s t /&s /ill & does n pass on ) ! procession4 ,! _s1 !n1 mu/ be out ( "t to "k succession1 & out ( space to "k procession1 & self-consci\s1 s z to di/+ui% itself f ! succession & ! procession4 ,! human _s is some?+ 9 ! mid/ ( "t1 yet passes n ) ! tides ( "t4 ,x is to ! succession ( ?+s ev] pass+ ?r\gh x1 & to ! procession ( s5sations ev] pass+ be=e x1 l "s mighty ,t5]iffe ) its peak ( ,teyde 9 ! mid/ ( ! sea1 pu%+ its pr\d head up #ab1jjj feet above ! sea1 & contra/+ ) its ev] *ang+ waves1 ! immutability ( et]nity4 ,man1 z a _s1 is aft] ,god1 ! mo/ univ]sal ( all facts4 ,he is illimitable 9 m ways ?an space1 rema9+ :5 all ! ev5ts ( "t h pass$1 & ) a nature dipp+ into ! et]nal _s ( ,god4 ,! respect 9 :i* man is made 9 ! image ( ,god1 is1 t he is end[$ ) self-consci\sness1 & self-det]m9ation4 ,self-consci\sness & self-det]m9ation are ! univ]sal =ms ( spiritual activity4 ,man1 z a self-consci\s & self-det]m9+ _s1 is n indep5d5t4 ,he mu/ f9d 8 true self beyond himself4 ,he is dep5d5t ^u ! absolute self-consci\sness & self-det]m9ation ( ,god4 ,he is ! *ild ( ,god1 & z !re _c be an absolute )\t a relative1 he is ! relativity ( ! absolute4 ,god's nature is ! gr\nd ( man's nature1 & 9 ,god he is mirror$ to himself4 ,9 ,god man lives & moves & has 8 be+4 ,9 f9d+ ,god1 man f9ds himself4 ,9 ! revelation ( ,god is ! revelation ( man4 ,god is a _s & man is a _s2 b man1 z a relative _s1 comes to himself 9 ,god1 ! absolute _s2 z ! life-g]m ( ! acorn comes to itself 9 ! natural conditions ( soil & sky :i* environ x4 ,i4 ,z man is ess5tially _s1 he c nev] come to unity1 only z he comes to x 9 himself z a _s4 ,z long z he ab&ons himself to m]e bread1 or p[]1 or k1 or law1 or beauty1 !re is contradiction4 ,n 9 any "o ( ^! c he f9d full-orb$ life4 ,^! all br+ nutrim5t to him1 z a _s1 f ! sev]al sph]es to :i* !y are v>i\sly correlat$4 ,b provision is made n only = ! sides & faculties ( himself1 b = ! ess5tial nature ( himself4 ,we h se5 h[ hung] 0 met by bread1 ! ne$s ( ! social nature by p[]1 intellect by tru?1 w by law1 & ! /hetic s5se by beauty2 b "h we come to life1 & f9d t love1 timeless & illimitable love1 alone corresponds to x4 ,b love c only f9d its embodim5t & its expression 9 life4 ,!re=e1 love has tak5 ! =m ( life to meet ! ne$s ( man z a _s4 ,we d n propose to discuss ?is subject dogmatically4 ,! writ] believes 9 dogmatism2 b 9 ?is "w ! attempt has be5 to treat man1 & ! ?+s provid$ = him1 sci5tifically4 ,we h tak5 no?+ = grant$1 & h int5d$ to say no?+ b :at 0 w>rant$ by ! facts4 ,t man is a _s1 & relat$ to an unse5 realm1 is atte/$ by ! fact t all r\nd ?is _w temples & mosques1 & synagogues & *ur*es lift !mselves sublimely1 or mode/ly1 to ! sky4 ,t !re is some?+ 9 man t seeks provision f beyond ! range ( s5se & sight1 no "o 9 8 s5ses c d5y4 ,?is deep & fundam5tal & irrepressible ne$ ( man's nature f9ds its correlate 9 love4 ,speak+ out ( ! dep?s ( 8 life1 x is an ev]la/+ call = sympa?y1 = reconciliation1 = p>don1 = peace4 ,love gives sympa?y1 insures reconciliation1 grants p>don1 & secures peace4 ,b love c only come f ! unse5 & et]nal 9 ! =m ( life4 ,let u see h[ ! love express$ 9 ! life & sacrifice & dea? ( ,jesus ,*ri/1 z ! embodim5t ( div9e love1 is set ov] aga9/ ! spiritual nature ( man1 z its correlate2 z completely z bread is set ov] aga9/ hung]1 or ! tru? aga9/ ! intellect1 or z beauty is set ov] aga9/ ! /hetic s5se4 ,we believe ?is is s 9 ! nature ( ?+s1 & w f9ally be taught z tru?1 z absolute & unfail+ z ! multiplication table4 ,m5 w come to x1 aft] a :ile1 n only z a dogmatic doctr9e taught by ! *ur*es1 b also z absolute doctr9e1 taught by ! con/itution & ne$s ( human nature4 ,! "t w come :5 to d\bt ?is w n simply be to write "o's self d[n z mean1 b z m5tally unbalanc$4 ,if ,jesus ,*ri/1 z love1 is ! correlate ( ! spiritual ne$s ( ! human race1 !n 8 life is peculi> & unique4 ,x _c be class$ ) any o!r life4 ,x _c be measur$ by any rule us$ to measure o!r ?+s or o!r lives4 ,we propose to te/ ?is life by a pr9ciple said1 by sci5tific m51 to h univ]sal application 9 ?is "t4 ,,ii4 ,! doctr9e ( ! correlation1 equival5ce1 p]si/5ce1 transmutability & inde/ructibility ( =ce1 or ! cons]vation ( en]gy has _h va/ influ5ce ^u ! ?\ght & life ( our "t4 ,x has furni%$ a new op5+ ?r\gh :i* to behold ! nature ( ?+s4 ,x has giv5 to m5 a new work+ hypo!sis & ri*] views & conceptions ( ! univ]se & its au?or4 ,! trem5d\s advancem5t made 9 ! mat]ial civilization ( ! pres5t is due m to ?is ?an any o!r sci5tific doctr9e or pr9ciple4 ,accord+ to ,pr(essor ,balf\r ,/ew>t1 !re are eight =ms ( en]gy or =ce4 ,! en]gy ( visible motion1 visible en]gy ( position1 heat motion1 molecul> sep>ation1 atomic or *emical sep>ation1 electrical sep>ation1 electricity 9 motion1 & radiant en]gy4 ,n[ tak+ ?is e>? z a complete :ole1 conta9+ )9 itself all ^! =ms ( en]gy1 & s isolat$ f ! re/ ( ! univ]se z to receive no?+ f x & to add no?+ to x1 !n ! pr9ciple ( ! correlation ( =ces ass]ts t ! sum ( all ^! =ces is con/ant4 8,?is does n ass]t t ea* is con/ant 9 itself1 or any o!r ( ! =ms ( =ce enum]at$1 = 9 tru? !y are always *ang+ ab\t into ea* o!r--n[ "s visible en]gy be+ *ang$ into heat or electricity1 & heat or electricity be+ *ang$ back aga9 into visible en]gy2 b x only means t ! sum ( all ! en]gies tak5 toge!r is con/ant4 ,!re are eight v>iable quantities1 & x is only ass]t$ t _! sum is con/ant1 n by any means t !y are con/ant !mselves40 ,= ! purpose ( elucidat+ our pr9ciple 9 ! realm ( nature1 we w consid] x z x applies to "s ( ! useful =ces ^: effects we c measure & ^: orig9 we c trace & det]m9e4 ,!re is ! =ce ( cons]v$ fuel4 ,away back 9 ! c>bonif]\s p]iod ( ! _w's hi/ory1 !re grew imm5se =e/s1 :i* 9 succe$+ ages 7 turn$ "u ! e>?1 &1 9 ! process ( ! ye>s1 7 *ang$ into coal & oil & gas4 ,^! h be5 treasur$ = untold ages 9 ! m\nta9s & 9 ! b[els ( ! e>?4 ,n[ !y are br\ght =? by ! appli$ intellig5ce ( man1 to turn 8 :eel1 draw 8 c>1 cook 8 food1 propel 8 pl[1 & to light 8 home & 8 /reet4 ,! =ce 9 "o ton ( coal is capable ( accompli%+ m "w 9 a few h\rs ?an "o man c\ld 9 a lifetime4 ,all ?is =ce1 z well z t conta9$ 9 ! gr[+ =e/s ( to-day1 orig9at$ 9 ! sun4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ =ce ( food4 ,?is is f\nd prim>ily 9 ! grass1 ! :eat1 ! rice1 ! fruit1 :i* gr[ 9 our fields & or*>ds4 ,! l[] animals fe$ on ^!1 & ?r\gh ! process ( dige/ion & assimilation1 !y are transmut$ into blood & bone & muscle--?us furni%+ man1 :o /&s at ! top & ! end ( ! creative process1 ) a m ref9$ high] =m ( food4 ,b :e!r 9 ! %ape ( grass1 rice1 :eat1 or 9 ! m ref9$ =m ( animal fle%1 ^! v>i\s elem5ts ( food are only s mu* transmut$ sun%9e4 ,be=e !y ev] adorn$ ! surface ( our fields1 or mov$ 9 ! l[+ h]d ov] ! mead[1 !y 7 held 9 solution 9 ! sun%9e4 ,! food1 ! fuel1 & ! animal life ( our e>? are all traceable to ! sun4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ =ce ( fl[+ wat]4 ,?is turns ! :eel1 sp9s ! ?read1 g9s ! cotton1 weaves ! clo?1 & gr9ds ! corn4 ,all ! =ce t wat] possesses = ! p]=mance ( "w1 comes f ! sun4 ,! w>m rays ( ! sun1 com+ d[n on s\!rn seas & riv]s1 causes ! wat]s !re( to evaporate1 & !n x is c>ri$ on ! w+s ( nor?-b\nd w9ds to a cold] clime4 ,!re ! diffus$ wat]s ga!r !mselves into cl\ds & fall 9 ra9 to fl[ d[n ! riv]s1 ?us ex*ang+ _! en]gy ( position1 :i* !y h obta9$ f ! sun1 = ! actual en]gy ( ! turn+ :eel4 ,!re is also ! cons]v$ =ce ( mov+ w9ds4 ,by ! aid ( ?is %ips spread _! sails1 & pass f cont95t to cont95t ) ! products ( ! e>?4 ,aga9 all ! =ce ! w9ds possess = ! accompli%m5t ( "w comes f ! sun4 ,! rays ( ! sun come d[n ) great int5sity ^u c]ta9 p>ts ( ! e>? & heat ! atmosph]e4 ,into ^! heat$ places come ! w9ds f cold] regions4 ,?us curr5ts & c\nt]-curr5ts are creat$4 ,by putt+ ! :eel ( ! w9dmill into ^! curr5ts ?is =ce is conv]t$ into ! gr\nd :eat & ! drawn wat]4 ,?us all ! diff]5t =ms ( =ce display$ 9 ! gr[+ =e/s1 ! wav+ h>ve/ fields1 ! fly+ birds1 ! l[+ h]ds1 ! ru%+ railway tra91 ! :ir ( ! sp9dle1 ! r+ ( ! hamm]1 & ! pulsat+ blood come directly f ! sun4 ,! =ce1 too1 se5 9 all ^! physical1 vegetable1 animal1 comm]cial realms1 is ! exact equival5t ( :at 0 p\r$ into !m f ! sun4 ,! e>? conta9s no o!r =ce capital ?an :at 0 paid ov] to x by ! sun4 ,x has issu$ no curr5cy ( its own1 n ev5 en\gh to run a wat*1 or to s5d ! blood once ar\nd ! body1 or ev5 to transport a piece ( bread to a />v+ man4 ,all ! =ce our e>? possesses is borr[$1 & if we 7 to cease to borr[1 we w\ld be bankrupt 9 a s+le day4 ,we are to rememb]1 too1 t by s mu* =ce z ! sun has p>t$ ) to our e>?1 & to o!r worlds :i* look to x = supplies1 by s mu* has its own =ce be5 decreas$4 ,if we knew h[ mu* =ce ! sun _h 9 ! beg9n+1 & w\ld subtract f ?is am\nt all t x has giv5 away to ! pres5t "t1 we might be able to =m "s e/imate ( its assets to-day4 ,we "k n :at ! sun's res\rces are4 ,we "k n by :at me?ods x has be5 repl5i%+ its supplies ( light & heat = ages pa/2 :e!r by *emical comb9ation1 meteoric impact1 or cond5sation2 we only "k by s mu* z x has 9 ! ages pa/ p>t$ )1 by s mu* less =ce x has to-day4 ,t x has be5 able to supply our _w & o!rs l x1 h[ev]1 ) heat & light & physical life = ages1 is n at all /range :5 we rememb] :at an imm5se ball ( fire ! sun is4 ,x has a diamet] ( a million miles1 9 r\nd numb]s4 ,/orms1 :i* travel across our _w at ! rate ( sixty miles an h\r1 w\ld move across ! surface ( ! sun at ! rate ( tw5ty ?\s& miles an h\r4 ,! flames ( a burn+ =e/1 :i* on our _w w\ld rise "o hundr$ feet 9 ! air1 on ! sun w\ld rise to ! height ( two hundr$ ?\s& miles4 ,! sun1 too1 has en\gh =ce on h& to supply our e>? & o!rs ) heat = untold ages yet to come1 b unless its supply is repl5i%$1 ! "t w come :5 x w be bankrupt & no?+ b a burnt out *> 9 ! heav5s4 ,?is is s1 because ! sun is ! c5t] ( t great natural realm1 ! univ]sal law ( :i* is ! law ( exclusiv5ess4 ,9 accordance ) ?is law :at ! sun has 9 ! way ( =ce ! o!r planets d n h1 & :at o!r planets obta9 f ! sun t body has =ev] lo/4 ,?is is only ano!r "n = ! law ( ! correlation ( =ces4 ,?is law applies n only to ! =ce ( ! sun1 b to all =ces on ?is e>? :i* come f t body4 ,:at "o tree ga!rs into itself is at ! exp5se ( ! g5]al fund ( =ce :i* goes to make trees4 ,:at "o bird takes into 8 body is at ! exp5se ( all =ce :i* goes to make birds4 ,:at "o man takes into 8 physical frame is at ! exp5se ( ! g5]al fund ( =ce :i* goes to make human bodies4 ,:atev] am\nt ( =ce is conta9$ 9 ! cl\d1 9 cons]v$ wat] to turn ! :eel1 or 9 cons]v$ electricity to c>ry ! message1 is at ! exp5se ( ! g5]al fund ( =ce4 ,accord+ to ! doctr9e ( ! correlation ( =ces1 ! ris+ up ( =ce 9 "o place involves ! subsid5ce ( =ce 9 ano!r place4 ,! am\nt ris+ up1 too1 is ! exact equival5t ( ! am\nt subsid+4 ,:5 a rock falls f a *ur* /eeple ! e>? rises z mu* to meet ! rock1 9 proportion to its mass1 z ! rock falls to meet ! e>?1 9 proportion to its mass4 ,:5 a man %oots a rifle ball f a gun1 z mu* =ce goes back aga9/ 8 %\ld] z goes out ?r\gh ! muzzle ( ! gun4 ,:at ! gun lacks 9 velocity x makes up 9 mass1 & :at ! ball lacks 9 mass x makes up 9 velocity4 ,:5 a p9e tree is cut d[n & split into small pieces & put into an eng9e1 j ! same am\nt ( heat is ga!r$ f x t 0 g>n]$ f ! sun 9 ! fifty ye>s ( its gr[?4 ,?is heat is also conv]t$ into an equival5t ( /eam1 & ?is /eam into an equival5t am\nt ( me*anical motion4 ,! sun%9e1 ! p9e tree1 ! heat1 ! /eam1 ! me*anical motion1 are only diff]5t =ms ( ! same ?+4 ,sci5ti/s ( ! mat]iali/ic s*ool claim t ?is law holds good n only 9 ! realm ( ! natural _w1 b 9 ! m5tal & moral1 z well4 ,pr(4 ,?omas ,h4 ,huxley said1 9 a celebrat$ address 9 ?is c\ntry once1 t a spee* 0 only s mu* transmut$ mutton4 ,accord+ to ,pr(4 ,alex&] ,ba91 !re are five *ief p[]s1 or =ces 9 nature3 "o me*anical or mol>1 ! mom5tum ( mov+ matt]2 ! o!rs1 molecul>1 are embodi$ 9 ! molecules1 also suppos$ 9 motion--^! are light1 heat1 *emical =ce1 electricity4 ,"o memb] ( vital en]gies1 ! n]ve =ce1 alli$ to electricity1 fully des]ves to rank 9 ! correlation4 ,accord+ to ?is same di/+ui%$ au?ority1 m9d is only a ref9$ & sublimat$ =m ( physical =ce4 ,9 ?is view ! great poems1 pa9t+s1 & lit]ature ( ! _w w\ld be only s mu* transmut$ sun%9e--a high] =m ( ! same =ce we see manife/$ 9 ! fly+ railway tra94 ,9 ! "o case ! solidifi$ sun%9e conta9$ 9 ! coal is transmut$ ?r\gh ! furnace ( ! eng9e into me*anical motion2 9 ! o!r1 ! heat conta9$ 9 food is transmut$ ?r\gh ! human bra9 into lit]ature & art4 ,p]haps x might n be at wide v>iance f ! tru? to assume t ! =ce1 m5tal or o!rwise1 exp5d$ by m5 :o sp5d _! lives "u ! dom9ion ( ! natural law ( exclusiv5ess1 may be acc\nt$ = 9 accordance ) ! doctr9e ( ! correlation ( =ces4 ,ev5 m9d1 :5 e>?ly & l[1 is subject to ! be>+ ( ! law ( s9 & dea?1 :i* is ! scriptural "n = ! law ( exclusiv5ess4 ,,iii4 ,x might be plausibly cont5d$ t ! religi\s movem5t ( ! prophet ,mohamm$ c\ld be acc\nt$ = 9 accordance ) ! doctr9e ( ! correlation ( =ces4 ,x is to be rememb]$ t ! p]sonality ( ,mohamm$ is no m ! equival5t ( ! va/ movem5t :i* has exi/$ & exi/s to-day "u 8 "n1 ?an ! acorn is ! quantitative equival5t ( ! imm5se oak tree :i* has gr[n f x4 ,! acorn1 plus all ! oxyg51 c>bon1 hydrog51 nitrog51 & o!r =ces ( sky & e>? :i* x caught & organiz$1 is ! equival5t ( ! oak tree4 ,! soil & ! sky conta9 oaks 9 solution4 ,?r\gh acorns ^! are precipitat$ into trees4 ,! m5tal1 political1 & social atmosph]e ( ,turkey conta9$ ! ,mohamm$an movem5t 9 solution be=e ,mohamm$ 0 born4 ,?r\gh him x 0 precipitat$ into ,koran1 mosque1 pray]1 & wor%ip4 ,mohamm$ reli$ = success ^u ! me?ods ) :i* m5 ord9>ily succe$4 ,he appeal$ to m5's love ( fame1 ( pleasure1 ( conque/1 ( p[]1 ( ri*es4 ,he simply organiz$ ! lat5t aspirations1 & hopes1 & fe>s ( 8 c\ntrym5 into a great k+dom1 ess5tially secul> & s5sual4 ,9 accordance ) ! pr9ciple ( ! correlation ( =ces1 x might be possible to acc\nt = ! success ( ,buddha1 ,confucius1 ,cs>1 & ,bonap>te4 ,:at we wi% n[1 is to apply ?is doctr9e1 :i* ! mat]iali/s claim is capable ( measur+ ev]y?+1 f an atom to ,milton's 8,p>adise ,lo/10 to ! life & "w ( ,*ri/4 ,grant+1 z we mu/1 t all physical =ce may be e/imat$ by x1 & ev5 t ! "w & ?\ght ( m51 9 s f> z !y live "u ! natural law ( selfi%ness or exclusiv5ess1 may be e/imat$ by x4 ,:at we desire to inquire is1 if ! life & "w ( ,*ri/ =m no exception to its op]ation1 z ord9>ily reg>d$4 ,c we1 9 accordance ) ?is pr9ciple1 acc\nt = ! life & influ5ce ( ,*ri/ on ! assumption t he 0 only a man8 ,has no m =ce issu$ f ! p]son ( ,*ri/ ?an subsid$ :5 only a man nam$ ,jesus 0 crucifi$8 ,we h se5 h[ ! =ms ( physical =ce 9 ! %ape ( fuel1 food1 mov+ wat]s1 & w9ds may be trac$ directly to ! sun4 ,let u also consid] "s ( ! =ms ( spiritual =ce :i* are traceable directly to ! life ( ,*ri/1 & inquire if !y may be acc\nt$ = z ! =ce :i* comes f ! sun may be1 by ! pr9ciple ( ! conv]tibility ( =ce4 ,,iv4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ spiritual =ce ( ,*ri/ian lit]ature4 ,?is is /or$ up 9 ! ,bibles ( ! _w1 9 comm5t>ies ^u its text1 9 expositions ( its pr9ciples1 9 books illu/rat+ its mean+4 ,if all ! ,bibles ( ! _w1 books writt5 ab\t ! ,bible--9 favor ( x or aga9/ x--& all ! books :i* h be5 inspir$ by "s tru? or precept taught 9 ! ,bible1 & all ! books :i* owe _! exi/5ce directly or indirectly to ! ,bible1 7 burn$ up1 ,*ri/5dom w\ld be well-nigh )\t lit]ature4 ,all ,bibles & all books & lit]ature :i* h gr[n out ( ! ,bible owe _! exi/5ce directly to ,*ri/4 ,!y h come z /raight f him z ! coal 9 ! m\nta9 has come f ! sun4 ,mu* =ce has be5 exp5d$ 9 ! writ+ ( all ^! books & 9 pr9t+ !m1 b9d+ !m1 circulat+ !m4 ,!y repres5t millions ( doll>s1 ages ( pa9ful1 pati5t ?\ght4 ,into !m a m>vel\s am\nt ( =ce has lift$ itself--physical =ce1 money =ce1 ?\ght =ce4 ,we are to f9d its equival5t4 ,all ! =ce t has aris5 9 ,*ri/ian lit]ature has subsid$ at "s po9t1 & ! am\nt t subsid$ is ! exact equival5t ( t :i* has aris54 ,x mu/ be rememb]$1 too1 t di/9ctly ,*ri/ian lit]ature has n made its way 9 ! _w1 z h ! writ+s ( ,hom] & ,plato1 by _! aff9ity ) man's fancy4 ,! wond]ful int]e/ :i* has ev] c5t]$ ar\nd ! ,bible is totally diff]5t 9 k9d & degree f t :i* c5t]s ar\nd ! works ( ,%aksp]e4 ,:atev] !re is ( lit]>y m]it1 ( philosophic ?\ght1 or ( poetic dep? 9 ! ,bible is incid5tal4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ spiritual =ce ( ,*ri/ian art4 ,! ma/]pieces 9 pa9t+1 sculpture1 music1 poetry1 & ar*itecture are ,*ri/ian4 ,! inspiration :i* produc$ ,milton's 8,p>adise ,lo/10 ,h&el's 8,messiah10 ,p[]s' 8,eve10 & ,/4 ,pet]'s at ,rome1 has all come f ,*ri/4 ,9 ! conception & production ( ^! an imm5se am\nt ( ! mo/ subtle1 ref9$ =ce has be5 exp5d$4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ =ce ( ,*ri/ian money4 ,?is has tak5 ! =m ( *ur* build+s1 build+s = education1 = orphans1 = ! sick1 = ! wret*$ & ! poor4 ,!re is n a great city 9 ! _w to-day )\t a ,*ri/ian *ur* edifice4 ,!y are ! expressions ( a great =ce1 ( :i* we are seek+ to f9d ! equival5t4 ,!y owe _! exi/5ce directly to ! p]son ( ,*ri/4 ,! millions ( money :i* h be5 sp5t 9 _! erection h be5 because ( love to him4 ,!y are z directly relat$ to him z ! oak tree is to ! sun4 ,if all ^! *ur*es 7 burn$ d[n to-day1 m5 w\ld beg9 at once ! erection ( bett] ones to take _! places4 ,! cons]v$ =ce ( ,*ri/ian money1 !n1 :i* t5ds to lift itself into *ur* edifices1 is n exhau/$ 9 ^? :i* already /& ^u ! e>?2 b j z mu* z has lift$ itself into brick & m>ble1 & w9d[1 & dome1 & p9nacle is ready to take ! same =ms if ! necessity = !m 7 laid ^u ! ,*ri/ian _w4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ =ce ( ,*ri/ian home life4 ,! =ce "h ref]r$ to is n manife/ 9 ! life itself1 b 9 ! =m :i* family life has tak5 9 ! ,*ri/ian _w4 ,!re is h>dly a home 9 ,*ri/5dom to-day1 b has be5 =m$ directly or indirectly ) ref]5ce to ,*ri/4 ,into ^? places :]e "* is =m$1 :]e revolutions are />t$1 :]e ,wesleys & ,glad/ones are develop$1 :]e et]nal issues p5d1 ,*ri/ has come quietly & sil5tly to regulate1 to dom9ate & control4 ,to ?us influ5ce1 regulate1 & vitally t\* homes1 to ?us det]m9e _! =m1 appo9tm5t1 & "*1 requires a great deal ( =ce4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ =ce impli$ 9 ! inception & p]petuation ( ! ,*ri/ian ,cal5d>4 ,infidels1 mat]iali/s1 & a!i/s1 9 dat+ _! lett]s1 pay tribute to ! "* ( ,*ri/ 9 ! fact t !y recognize he has u%]$ 9 a new era4 ,*ri/ has claim$ & held ?r\gh ne>ly two ?\s& ye>s "o day out ( e week to be devot$ to 8 s]vice4 ,! day ^u :i* he 0 born is celebrat$ 9 ! he>ts ( m5 & 9 ! arts ( m54 ,to *ange ! _w's cal5d>1 to inaugurate & make p]man5t a new date1 to impel ! _w to set ap>t a day = 8 wor%ip1 to furni% ! _w ) new fe/ivals & holidays1 has requir$1 c]ta9ly1 a va/ am\nt ( =ce4 ,?is we are to trace & det]m9e1 & we are also to f9d its equival5t4 ,!re is ! cons]v$ ,*ri/ian =ce impli$ 9 ! fact t ,*ri/ has won ! he>ts ( m54 ,to w9 ! dis9t]e/$ love ( "o man takes mu* =ce1 m ?an mo/ m5 h4 ,to w9 ! love ( a /ate takes m4 ,b to w9 & to hold1 ?r\gh ! p]turbations & revolutions ( k+doms & republics1 ! undy+ love ( ! be/ & pure/ m5 on e>? requires an inf9ite am\nt ( =ce4 ,?is po9t 9 ,*ri/'s "* greatly impress$ ! fir/ ,napoleon4 ,said he1 8,i "k m54 ,*ri/ is n a man4 ,i h se5 ! "t :5 ,i c\ld inspire ?\s&s to die = me1 b x took ! inspiration ( my pres5ce & ! p[] ( my ^w4 ,s9ce ,i am away f m51 a prison] on ,hel5a1 no "o w die = me4 ,*ri/1 on ! o!r h&1 has be5 away f ! _w ne>ly two ?\s& ye>s1 & yet !re are millions :o w\ld die = him4 ,i tell y1 ,*ri/ is n a man4 ,i "k m540 ,v4 ,x w\ld be impossible to rec\nt all ! in/itutions1 books1 civilizations1 laws1 discov]ies1 inv5tions1 homes & he>ts1 into :i* ! =ce ( ,*ri/'s life has = ! pa/ n9ete5 hundr$ ye>s be5 lift+ itself4 ,z ! sun expresses itself 9 ! mead[1 & lifts itself into ! trees ( ! =e/s1 s ,*ri/ has be5 embody+ himself 9 ! in/itutions1 homes1 & ?\ghts ( m54 ,! sci5ti/s say all =ce c be acc\nt$ =4 ,:5 =ce has ris5 up at "o po9t x has subsid$ at ano!r3 ! am\nt ris+ up be+ ! exact equival5t ( t subsid+4 ,^u ?is pr9ciple we are seek+ to acc\nt = all ?is =ce t1 com+ f ,*ri/1 has express$ itself 9 ! dome/ic1 social1 political1 & ecclesia/ical in/itutions ( m54 ,m has ris5 ?an c be comput$ by human ari?metic1 or compass$ by human imag9ation1 or compreh5d$ by human ?\ght4 ,:]e did x come f8 ,:]e did x subside8 ,at :at po9t did x disappe> to rise aga9 9 su* ov]:elm+ volume1 & su* sweep+ & f>-rea*+ influ5ce8 ,we g back ?r\gh eighte5 hundr$ ye>s4 ,we are /&+ 9 ,j]usalem4 ,we he> conflict+ reports ( a /range1 d>+ "y man4 ,at l5g? he is po9t$ out to u4 ,!re is no?+ rem>kable ab\t 8 appe>ance4 ,he is a ,jew4 ,he 0 born among ! poor4 ,he is n not$ = culture4 ,he has no social position4 ,he has no money4 ,he has no political p[] or pre/ige4 ,he has no army at 8 comm&4 ,he has no philosophical sy/em4 ,he is connect$ ) no academy4 ,he is only ?irty-?ree ye>s old4 ,8 words are conta9$ 9 no books4 ,!y are simply 9 ! memory ( 8 disciples4 ,he is misund]/ood4 ,8 own disciples d n "k :at to make ( him4 ,f9ally he is arre/$1 & tri$1 & condemn$1 & crucifi$4 ,he dies betwe5 two ?ieves1 scorn$1 sc(f$1 buffet$1 & fri5dless4 ,keep 9 m9d ! pr9ciple we are consid]+4 ,all =ce c be measur$4 ,no m =ce rises up ?an subsides4 ,action & reaction are equal4 ,we are seek+ to acc\nt1 9 accordance ) ?is pr9ciple1 = ! va/ am\nt ( =ce ,*ri/ has p\r$ into ! in/itutions & ?\ghts ( humanity4 ,is ?is "y man's life1 seem+ly s insignificant & weak1 ! exact equival5t ( all ! *ur*es1 s*ools1 colleges1 arts1 lit]ature1 homes1 gov]nm5ts1 sacrifice1 h]oism1 good works1 m>tyrdom1 pati5ce1 love1 & hope t h by g5]al cons5t result$ f 8 exi/5ce 9 ! _w8 ,if s1 0 he only a man8 ,multiply ?irty-?ree ye>s by pov]ty1 toil1 contempt1 sorr[1 & crucifixion1 & y h "o product4 ,multiply n9ete5 hundr$ ye>s by millions ( *ur*es1 s*ools1 & homes2 by millions ( books1 pa9t+s1 & poems2 by social position1 weal?1 & p[]2 by success1 triumph1 & conque/2 by love1 m]cy1 & tru?2 by a hold ^u humanity unequal$1 & by an influ5ce on home & ?\ght unrival$1 & y h ano!r product4 ,! "q is3 does "o ( ^! products seem to be ! equival5t ( ! o!r8 ,does n ! outcome surpass by an inf9ite degree ! income8 ,is n ! evolution out ( all proportion to ! involution8 ,has n a great deal m =ce ris5 up ?an seem+ly subsid$8 ,is !re n mu* m p[] seem+ly on ?is side ! ,cross ?an !re 0 on ! o!r8 ,manife/ly & cle>ly ,*ri/'s life & "w _c be acc\nt$ = by ! pr9ciple ( ! correlation ( =ces4 ,mohamm$'s success & disciples we c und]/&4 ,he succe$$ by ! ord9>y me?ods by :i* m5 succe$4 ,he appeal$ to m5's love ( fame1 conque/1 weal?1 p[]1 pleasure4 ,he (f]$ m51 z a rew>d = _! fealty to him1 a great e>?ly k+dom1 & su* a heav5 beyond ! grave z w\ld regale ! s5ses1 please ! fancy1 & gratify ! appetites4 ,he simply organiz$ & appli$ ! lat5t e>?ly =ces already exi/+ 9 8 c\ntrym54 ,8 success is 9 l9e ) t ( ,cs> & ,bonap>te4 ,! k+dom :i* he propos$ to e/abli% 0 m]ely an e>?ly1 s5sual k+dom4 ,8 me?ods 7 c>nal1 ! motives to :i* he appeal$ 7 s5sual1 & ! hopes :i* he inspir$ 7 c>nal4 ,*ri/1 on ! o!r h&1 condemn$ m5's love ( conque/1 p[]1 fame1 ri*es1 & pleasure4 ,he made ! conditions ( disciple%ip to consi/ 9 ! d5ial ( self & 9 ! rel9qui%m5t ( all e>?ly hopes1 gratifications1 & prospects4 8,if y f9d y\r life 9 my k+dom10 said he1 8y mu/ lose x 9 ?is40 ,he propos$ to build up a k+dom z wide z ! _w1 & z la/+ z et]nity1 )\t adopt+ a s+le me?od or utiliz+ any ( ! means ord9>ily reli$ on = success4 ,n only did he propose a new k+dom1 b to populate x ) new m51 motives1 hopes1 conceptions1 & op9ions4 ,h5ce1 to come into 8 k+dom1 m5 7 to be made ov]4 ,!y 7 to die to self1 to ! _w1 to pleasure4 ,s ,*ri/'s "w & influ5ce 9 ! _w n only =ms an exception to ! pr9ciple ( ! correlation ( =ces1 b "h we h an unp>allel$ am\nt ( =ce ris+ up :51 to all human appe>ances1 none subsid$ at all4 ,,vi4 ,a poor "y c>p5t] dies4 ,he goes d[n 9 ignom9y4 ,amid ! je]s & contempt ( ! multitude1 he goes d[n into ! grave4 ,b f t mom5t1 commotion beg9s4 ,=giv5ess ( s9 9 ! "n ( ,*ri/ is prea*$2 disciples are won2 books are writt52 civilizations are t\*$2 movem5ts are inaugurat$2 p]secutions1 bloody & rel5tless1 are wag$4 ,! fires ( hate are k9dl$2 /orms f all r\nd ! social1 political1 & religi\s sky ga!r1 & h[l1 & empty _! fury ^u ! new movem5t4 ,no?+ imp$es x2 fire _c h9d] x2 p]secution int5sifies x2 dea? does n al>m x4 ,n[1 we submit1 does n su* a movem5t1 />t+ f su* a s\rce1 & mov+ out ) su* vigor1 & becom+ int5s] & deep] z x is ext5d$1 =m a rem>kable & s+ul> exception to ! pr9ciple we are consid]+8 ,is !re any rule among m5 by :i* x may be e/imat$ & classifi$ & label$8 ,c any human1 or logical1 or philosophical =mula or pr9ciple measure ! multi=m & widely div]sifi$ facts 9 ?is case8 ,does x n =m an exception to all rules & human me?ods ( measurem5ts8 ,d we n augm5t ! difficulties ( acc\nt+ = ! "w ( ,*ri/ by m9ify+ him1 & call+ him a m]e man8 ,is n ! easi] way to acc\nt = ,*ri/'s "w1 to accord to him all t he claims = himself & all t 8 disciples claim$ = him4 ,he said1 8,all p[] is giv5 to me 9 heav5 & 9 e>?40 ,if we accept ?is z true1 we c acc\nt = 8 "w4 ,b 9 ?is view1 we w see t 8 life 0 div9e & "o ) ! ,fa!r ( u all4 ,!n we w see t he 0 ! ,son ( ,god1 ! ,^w made fle%1 ! inc>nation ( ! div9e m9d & wisdom & p[]4 ,x is impossible to acc\nt = ! life & "w ( ,*ri/ by ! pr9ciples ) :i* physical =ce & m]ely human =ce & ?\ght are measur$4 ,! sun is ! c5t] ( ! sy/em ( nature1 a sy/em de/9$ to end4 ,any sy/em1 ! c5t] ( :i* is gradually los+ its =ce1 _c la/4 ,*ri/ is ! c5t] ( a spiritual sy/em totally diff]5t f ! sy/em ( nature4 ,by all ! =ce ! sun p>ts ) to ! worlds ab\t x1 by s mu* less has x4 ,x is gradually los+ itself1 to f9d itself no m =ev]4 ,*ri/ is p\r+ 8 =ce into ! sy/em ( :i* he is ! c5t]1 b by su* a process he is n los+ 8 =ce1 b increas+ x4 ,by los+ himself he f9ds himself4 ,! univ]sal law ( ! sy/em ( :i* he is ! c5t]1 is ! law ( communion4 ,! =ce he gives away comes back to him augm5t$ by ! p]sonality ( all :o p>take ( x4 ,in/ead ( becom+ poor] by giv+1 he becomes ri*]4 ,?is great tru? ,/4 ,paul saw :5 he said3 8,all ?+s are y\rs1 :e!r ,paul1 or ,apollos1 or ,cephas1 or ! _w1 or life1 or dea?1 or ?+s pres5t1 or ?+s to come1 all are y\rs1 & ye are ,*ri/'s2 & ,*ri/ is ,god's40 ,,vii4 ,"o life has appe>$ among m51 !n1 t 0 all love4 ,jesus ,*ri/ is ! only orig9al1 absolutely unselfi% life t has be5 liv$ on e>?4 ,! sa9ts h f\nd ! secret1 & /r5g?1 & inspiration ( _! unselfi%ness & love 9 him4 ,! love :i* mat*es & meets ! illimitable nature ( ! human _s is embodi$ 9 a life t _c be measur$ by ! ord9>y rules & /&>ds ( m54 ,! object ( :i* hung] is ! subject1 is bread2 ! object ( :i* intellect is ! subject1 is tru?2 ! object ( :i* w is ! subject1 is law2 ! object ( :i* ! /hetic s5se is ! subject1 is beauty2 ! object ( :i* ! spiritual nature is ! subject1 is ,jesus ,*ri/4 ,! _s ( man :i* has = its correlate 9 "t1 ! race1 has = its correlate 9 et]nity1 ! life ( "o 9 :i* is summ$ up all p[]1 all tru?1 all law1 all beauty1 & all love4 ,z ! embodim5t ( love ! human _s f9ds 9 ,*ri/ ! climate & ! conditions exactly adapt$ to its own realization4 ,! plan & patt]n1 ! invisible framework & ideal ( e man's life is ,*ri/ian4 ,to be an oak is to be a p]fect acorn1 to be an apple is to be a complete fl[]1 to be a ,*ri/ian is to be a complete man4 ,,immortality4 8,h[ does ! rivulet f9d its way8 ,h[ does ! fl[]et "k its day ,& op5 its cup to cat* ! ray8 8,i see ! g]m to ! sunlight rea*1 ,& ! ne/l+ kn[s ! old bird's spee*4 ,i d n "k :o is !re to tea*4 8,i see ! h>e ?r\gh ! ?icket glide1 ,& ! />s ?r\gh ! trackless spaces ride4 ,i d n see :o is !re to guide4 8,he is eyes = all1 :o is eyes = ! mole1 ,see motion goes to ! rightful goal4 ,o ,god6 ,i c tru/ = ! human s\l40 ,,*apt] ,,vii4 ,,! ,,p]man5ce ,,( ,,! ,,complet$ ,,life ,,( ,,man4 ,back ( ! movem5t :i* began 9 creation & culm9at$ 9 man1 we posit$ ! m9d ( a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 self-active1 p]sonal ,god4 ,necessity 0 ^u u to assume a fir/ pr9ciple ( "s k9d1 & x seem$ prop] to h "o l>ge en\gh to acc\nt = ! facts we 7 ab\t to consid]4 ,! fir/ pr9ciple ,?ales set up 0 wat]4 ,9 wat] he saw ! orig9 ( all & ! end ( all4 ,b all t came out ( wat] mu/1 9 ! end1 f9d its dea? 9 wat]4 ,) no?+ b a va/ ocean to />t )1 we %all f9d1 at ! conclusion1 no?+ m articulate & rational ?an an inf9ite expanse ( wat] to end )4 ,h]b]t ,sp5c]1 8! heir ( all ! ages 9 ! =emo/ files ( "t10 took z ! />t+ po9t ( 8 philosophy ! unkn[able4 ,9 ! selection ( a fir/ pr9ciple1 h[ev]1 we ?9k ,?ales1 ?\gh ! fir/ philosoph] :o ev] liv$1 _h ! advantage ( him4 ,wat] is a def9ite & positive some:at2 ! unkn[able is an indef9ite & in>ticulate vacuity4 ,) wat] = a fir/ pr9ciple1 ! prospect is c]ta9 de/ruction 9 a g5]al deluge4 ,) ! unkn[able = a fir/ pr9ciple1 ! prospect is sure imbecility 9 univ]sal ignorance4 ,x is bett] to be dr[n$ 9 wat] ?an to h ! light ( intellig5ce put out 9 ev]la/+ night4 ,mr4 ,sp5c]'s unkn[able 0 a conv5i5t receptacle into :i* to dump difficulties & tr\blesome problems2 b1 z a work+ hypo!sis1 x 0 n suffici5t ev5 to build ! univ]se ,mr4 ,sp5c] saw4 ,9 ! process ( con/ruct+ 8 sy/em1 ,mr4 ,sp5c] gave to 8 unkn[able ne>ly all ! attributes :i* !ologians give to a p]sonal ,god4 ,z we h already se51 :5 ,mr4 ,sp5c] got ?r\gh ) draw+ f 8 unkn[able all t he _h to h to give 8 sy/em ! ord] & %[ ( reason1 x 0 f\nd t ! unkn[able "p ( ! unkn[able _h ab\t be5 scatt]$ 9 ! light ( k4 ,= ?is same unkn[able 0 f\nd to h ,be+1 ,p[]1 ,activity1 ,causal ,en]gy1 & ,omnipres5ce = attributes4 ,no?+ m c come out ( a fir/ pr9ciple ?an :at is conta9$ 9 x4 ,out ( wat]1 no?+ b wat] comes1 & out ( ! unkn[able1 no?+ b ! unkn[able comes4 ,"o c posit an acorn1 "u c]ta9 conditions ( soil & sky1 & get an oak2 b ! g]m ( ! oak mu/ be 9 ! acorn1 & ! nutrim5t ( ! oak mu/ be 9 ! conditions be=e any oak c come out4 ,x is ! old truism1 t 8out ( no?+1 no?+ comes40 ,no "o ev] attempts to acc\nt = any?+ )\t a fir/ pr9ciple4 ,! te/ ( ! reality & value ( a fir/ pr9ciple w be det]m9$ solely by its capacity to acc\nt = ! facts :i* come out ( x4 ,x is because ! unkn[able fails to acc\nt = ! facts ( nature1 & = self-consci\sness1 self-det]m9ation1 & self-activity 9 man1 :o /&s z ! complete consummation & realization ( nature1 t x is n accept$ z an adequate fir/ pr9ciple4 ,mat!w ,arnold1 9 ord] to escape ! objections :i* he _h to tak+ a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 p]sonal ,god = a fir/ pr9ciple1 sub/itut$ 8,! ,/ream ( ,t5d5cy1 n ourselves1 t makes = righte\sness40 ,b ?is s5t5ce1 :5 analyz$1 reveals ! fact t ,mat!w ,arnold's ,/ream has ab\t ! same ess5tial elem5ts ! !ologian supposes to reside 9 ,god4 ,a /ream has a s\rce1 a direction1 & an end4 ,"h1 !n1 we h cause1 means1 & ultimate object4 ,x is also said t ! /ream makes = some?+2 "h is self-det]m9ation4 ,x is said to make = righte\sness2 "h is ! attribute ( ,ju/ice1 & ju/ice c only be pr$icat$ ( a p]son4 ,giv5 nature1 ) its elem5ts1 laws1 & unity1 & man z ! be+ 9 :om ! :ole ( nature is summ$ up1 ) self-consci\sness1 self-det]m9ation1 & self-activity2 ! only fir/ pr9ciple suffici5t to acc\nt = ! facts is a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 self-active p]sonal ,god4 ,x is only su* a fir/ pr9ciple t is l>ge en\gh to acc\nt = ! numb]1 & ord]1 & drift1 & collocations ( ! facts2 & to su* a fir/ pr9ciple ! numb]1 & ord]1 & drift1 & collocations ( ! facts may be trac$4 ,if we see r$ & violet & blue colors appe>+ 9 ! c>pet on "o side ( ! loom1 we are w>rant$ 9 assum+ t r$ & violet & blue ?reads are ent]+ ! c>pet on ! o!r side ( ! loom4 ,nature is a m>vel\s loom4 ,at fir/ !re are simple elem5ts1 !n !re are comp\nds1 !n !re are plants1 !n !re are animals4 ,at la/ all ! elem5ts1 z s _m /r&s1 ) _! manifold hues & v>iegat$ colors1 appe> 9 ! life ( man4 ,man is ! h>bor :]e all ! freight1 />t$ on its /ormy c\rse at creation1 comes to %ore4 ,its matt] takes maje/ic =m 9 8 body1 its p[] l5ds itself z w9d to 8 sail1 z heat to 8 eng9e1 z light to 8 /reet3 its tru? is arrang$ by ! intellect into lit]ature & sci5ce3 its law is =mulat$ into /atutes1 enactm5ts1 & con/itutions3 its beauty is built into oratorios & spread 9 radiant visions3 its love is accept$ & turn$ into t5d]ness1 & sacrifice1 & hope4 ,inf9ite p]sonality at ! beg9n+1 self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 & self-active4 ,f9ite p]sonality at ! conclusion1 self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 & self-active4 ,if y call ! process evolution1 !n no m has be5 evolv$ ?an 0 involv$4 ,if y pref] direct creation1 !n no?+ is se5 9 ! creature t 0 n built into him by ! ,creator4 ,ei!r way1 if a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 & self-active man appe>s on "o side ( nature1 a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 & self-active p]sonal ,god is1 we may "k1 on ! o!r4 ,i4 ,! importance ( a correct fir/ pr9ciple1 & ( a "r idea ( ! nature ( t fir/ pr9ciple1 _c be urg$ too /rongly4 ,9 ! "r solution ( ! "q we are consid]+1 ev]y?+ dep5ds on x4 ,if we />t ) wat]1 z ,?ales did1 we w be =c$ to conclude t individual lives1 l bubbles1 w ev5tually fall back & m+le ) ! waves ( ! sea4 ,if we />t ) ! unkn[able1 z ,sp5c] did1 we %all be l$ to see t human spirits w lose !mselves at dea?1 z c&les lose _! light :5 ! wicks are consum$4 ,x is n left u1 h[ev]1 arbitr>ily to assume su* a fir/ pr9ciple z comports ) ! p>ticul> !ory ( life x is our purpose to e/abli%4 ,! fir/ pr9ciple t corresponds to reality is already implicit 9 ! facts1 ! orig91 & purpose1 & end ( :i* we wi% to "k4 ,! law ( gravity is implicit 9 fall+ bodies1 & 9 ! revolv+ />s4 ,! sunbeam is implicit 9 ! gr[+ tree4 ,all t happ5s :5 "o posits a fir/ pr9ciple t is n implicit 9 ! facts he is consid]+1 is t 8 fir/ pr9ciple w fail to acc\nt = ! facts4 ,mat!w ,arnold _h a p]fect "r to assume z a fir/ pr9ciple1 8,! ,/ream ( ,t5d5cy1 n ourselves1 t makes = righte\sness40 ,?is look$ poetic & imp]sonal1 & 9 8 e/eem s]v$ him z a work+ hypo!sis4 ,x nev] seem$ to occur to him t 8 pr9ciple impli$ ! same elem5ts & attributes ! !ologians reg>d$ z unit+ 9 ,god2 ! elem5ts & attributes he 0 s anxi\s to get rid (4 ,h]b]t ,sp5c]1 ) a !ory to "w out1 & a p>ticul> sy/em to buttress & bol/]1 devis$ & adopt$ a fir/ pr9ciple t seem$ to promise mo/ to 8 peculi> views4 ,?is he _h a "r to d4 ,b he _h no "r to take z a fir/ pr9ciple ! unkn[able1 ) :i* to de/roy ! ,*ri/ian's ,god2 & j z soon z he _h accompli%$ ?is to 8 entire satisfaction1 to turn delib]ately & take ne>ly e attribute ( ! ,*ri/ian's ,god to be/[ ^u 8 unkn[able4 ,x is h>dly to be suppos$ t ,mr4 ,sp5c]1 ) malice a=e?\ght plann$ ! dea? ( ,god 9 ord] to /eal 8 attributes4 ,! m *>itable view is to suppose t at ! outset 8 int5tion 0 to erect an absolutely new philosophic edifice1 ^u a new & orig9al f\ndation4 ,to d ?is1 x 0 necess>y to cle> ! gr\nd ( ev]y?+ 9 sight4 ,s 9 a high mom5t ( philosophic self-confid5ce1 he det]m9$ on ! oblit]ation ( all previ\s & "t-honor$ fir/ pr9ciples1 t he might posit "o ( 8 own mak+ & to 8 own lik+4 ,?is 0 ! de/ructive /age ( 8 m5tal movem5t1 & x did n occur to him t _m ( ! elem5ts he 0 cle>+ away 9 su* :olesale fa%ion w\ld be necess>y to c>ry up 8 new philosophic temple4 ,:5 he got ?r\gh ) ! p]iod ( prep>ation1 he _h no?+ to />t ) b a pla91 simple1 empty1 unkn[able4 ,b x soon became evid5t t ! unkn[able mu/ h "s cont5t1 9 ord] to support a dec5t & ord]ly /ructure4 ,at ?is po9t he took ! attributes ( ! ,*ri/ian's ,god1 ,be+1 ,p[]1 ,activity1 ,causal ,en]gy1 ,omnipres5ce1 & fill$ up 8 empty unkn[able ) !m4 ,!n he proce$$ ) 8 "w4 ,,ii4 ,9 />t+ ) a self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+ & p]sonal ,god1 !n1 z a fir/ pr9ciple t accommodates & insures ! immortality ( ! individual _s1 we are only beg9n+ ) :at is implicit 9 ! facts ( nature & human life4 ,let x be cle>ly appreh5d$ t ! gr\nd ( ! self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 p]sonal ,god is ?\ght4 ,t ! fundam5tal & fir/ ?+ 9 ?is univ]se is m9d4 ,t ! be+ ( ,god is second>y to ! m9d1 or ?\ght ( ,god4 ,god has be+1 because he has ?\ght1 & n ?\ght1 because he has be+4 ,! tr\ble ) ! pan!i/ic sy/em ( ,sp9oza 0 t he look$ ^u ,god1 fir/ z inf9ite sub/ance or be+1 :ile ?\ght 0 only "o ( ! modes ( ?is be+1 & ext5sion 0 ! o!r4 ,! root ( all d\bt & skepticism is to be trac$ to a confus$ notion ( ! nature ( ,god4 ,_m speak ( ,god z ! ,supreme ,be+1 & adv]tise by _! language t 9 _! e/eem ,god is diffus$ nebulosity1 or univ]sally ext5d$ ext]nality4 ,!re nev] 0 a skeptic 9 ! _w :o _h come to ! rational & t5able position1 t ,god is prim>ily1 & fundam5tally1 & ess5tially ?\ght4 ,we may prop]ly speak ( 8 be+1 8 wisdom1 8 ju/ice1 8 tru?1 8 love2 b ^! are diff]5t det]m9ations ( 8 ?\ght4 ,god's be+ is ! ext]nality ( 8 ?\ght4 ,8 wisdom is 8 ?\ght devis+ means to ends4 ,8 ju/ice is 8 ?\ght balanc+ & regulat+4 ,8 tru? is 8 ?\ght 9 realization4 ,8 love is 8 ?\ght 9 sacrifice4 8,9 ! beg9n+ 0 ! ,^w40 ,a ^w is an express$ ?\ght4 8,! ,^w 0 ) ,god40 ,! realiz$ ?\ght or ^w 0 ) ,god1 ! ,et]nal ,?9k]1 or ,?\ght4 8,god said1 ,let !re be light1 & !re 0 light40 ,light 0 ?us ! expression ( ?\ght4 ,ne>ly all mat]ialism & pan!ism look ^u ?+s z an emanation f some?+4 ,vapor emanates f ! surface ( a riv]1 & is only ! riv] 9 diffusion4 ,b ! univ]se does n emanate f ,god2 x is ! direct creation & expression ( 8 ?\ght4 ,pot5tially ! univ]se 0 always 9 ! ?\ght ( ,god4 ,,iii4 ,we h dwelt at l5g? on ! self-consci\sness & self-det]m9ation ( ,god1 z ^! unite 9 him z an absolute p]sonality1 = ! reason t ! immortality ( ! human _s f9ds its condition & its security "h4 ,if ,god is a p]son1 & self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 & self-active1 man is immortal1 = 9 him ! elem5ts :i* con/itute ! ess5tial nature ( ,god appe>4 ,man is a p]son & a _s1 made 9 ! lik5ess & image ( ,god4 ,he is1 !re=e1 z imp]i%able & inde/ructible z ,god is4 ,he has ?\ght & is !re=e self-consci\s2 he has a w1 & is !re=e self-det]m9+2 he has p[]1 & is !re=e self-active2 he ma9ta9s 8 id5tity ?r\gh *ange1 & is !re=e a p]son4 ,b ! f9ite p]son f9ds 8 life ?r\gh ! inf9ite ,p]son4 ,he f9ds 8 k by p>tak+ ( tru?1 ! realiz$ ?\ght ( ,god2 he f9ds 8 fre$om by ! obs]vance ( law1 ! express$ w ( ,god2 he f9ds 8 peace by p>tak+ ( ! life t 0 9 ,*ri/1 ! manife/$ love ( ,god4 ,z ! fundam5tal & prior ?+ 9 ! be+ ( ,god is ?\ght1 s ! fundam5tal & prior ?+ 9 ! be+ ( man is ?\ght4 ,8 progress 9 ! practical matt]s ( life w be 9 proportion to 8 ?\ght4 ,8 political /atus w be 9 proportion to 8 ?\ght2 8 religi\s atta9m5t w be 9 proportion to 8 ?\ght4 ,s*lei]ma*] said 8,feel+ is ! s\rce ( religion--a feel+ ( dep5d5ce40 ,b "o _c h a feel+ ( dep5d5ce )\t hav+ ! ?\ght ( dep5d5ce4 ,"o _c feel t he dep5ds unless he ?9ks ( himself z dep5d5t4 ,mat!w ,arnold said t religion 0 morality t\*$ by emotion4 ,b !re _c be morality )\t ! ?\ght ( "s rule by :i* conduct ought to be guid$4 ,ev5 ! ,african savage1 :o wor%ips a snake1 ?9ks !re is some?+ 9 ! snake entitl$ to 8 adoration4 ,?\ght is ! cle>e/ self-explication ( ! human _s4 ,9 ?\ght x comes to itself & kn[s itself4 ,take ?\ght out ( ! _s ( man1 & y take out its ess5tial nature4 ,its immortality1 ev5 7 x possible1 w\ld !n n be wor? cont5d+ =4 ,"o _h z well be blott$ out1 z to lose ! only elem5t ( 8 _s by :i* he is able to recognize himself z su*4 ,look+ ^u ?\ght z ! c5t] & k]nel ( ! human _s1 we see t to d5y ! immortality ( ! human _s is to assume t ?\ght is de/ructible2 & ?is is a flat contradiction1 = de/ruction has no mean+1 except 9 relation to ?\ght4 ,x is ( ! v nature ( ?\ght to be et]nal4 ,no ?\ght ev] dies1 or c die4 ,all ! det]m9ations ( ,god's ?\ght are et]nal4 ,! m9d ( ,god has )9 x all det]m9ations ( ?\ght2 ^? pa/1 ^? pres5t1 & ^? to come4 ,"s ( ^! det]m9ations ( ! div9e ?\ght h tak5 ! =m ( objects 9 ! inorganic _w1 "s h tak5 ! =m ( objects 9 ! vegetable k+dom1 & "s h tak5 ! =m ( objects 9 ! animal k+dom4 ,! det]m9ations ( ?\ght1 ( :i* inorganic ?+s1 trees1 & animals 7 ! expressions1 are all et]nal4 ,x is ( ! nature ( ! ?+s 9 :i* ! det]m9ations ( ?\ght took =m to *ange & pass away4 ,b ! ideal patt]ns1 ( :i* !y 7 only ! tempor>y =ms1 are held 9 ! m9d ( ,god =ev]4 ,! h\se :i* expresses ! ar*itect's ideal may be bl[n away1 or burn$ up1 b ! ideal 9 ! ?\ght ( ! ar*itect _c be bl[n away or burn$ up4 ,n[ 9 man ! det]m9ation ( ,god's ?\ght is n express$ 9 a ?+1 b 9 a ?\ght4 ,man1 z ,god's *ild1 inh]its1 or comes ?r\gh creation into ! possession ( ?\ght1 ( m9d1 s t he is able to set up ?9k+--9 8 own behalf1 & by ! self-det]m9+1 self-consci\s1 & self-active p[] ( 8 own m9d4 ,god z ?\ght is 8 own object & 8 own subject1 & man z ?\ght is 8 own object & 8 own subject4 ,god has set him up to h\sekeep+ 9 ! republic ( ?\ght4 ,9 ! *anges :i* take place 9 mat]ial objects1 !re is pres]vation ( ! species1 b ! loss ( ! individual4 ,! object is an elem5t & n a self4 ,:5 x *anges1 x is by some?+ ext]nal to itself1 & 9 *ang+1 realizes its nature4 ,x is indiff]5t to *ange1 z !re is no c5tral self t reta9s its ess5tial id5tity 9 ! mid/ ( all *ange4 ,! tree belongs to a high] ord] ( exi/5ce ?an a rock4 ,x is ! expression ( unconsci\s life4 ,! animal belongs to a /ill high] plane ?an ! tree4 ,besides appropriat+ food f its environm5t1 z does ! tree1 x takes 9 ! images ( ?+s1 & lives a l[ ord] ( s5ti5t life4 ,b 9 ord] t animals may take 9 ! images ( ?+s ?r\gh ! s5ses1 ! ?+s mu/ be pres5t be=e !m4 ,:5 ! ?+ is gone1 ! image fades4 ,! objects :i* /& ar\nd man 9 8 environm5t pass into 8 consci\sness ?r\gh ! s5ses4 ,b :5 ! environm5t *anges & ! objects are tak5 away1 ! impressions made by ! objects rema94 ,9 ?is way man re-creates ! univ]se = 8 own ?\ght4 ,! gurgl+ ( brooks1 ! murmur ( ! sea1 ! sigh+ ( ! w9ds1 ! coo+ ( doves1 he he>s j z ! animal does4 ,b away f brooks1 & seas1 & w9ds1 & doves1 ,bee?ov5 ?r[s into "o ( 8 symphonies all ! notes t 7 ev] on sea or l&4 ,he has )9 him ! same k9d ( m9d t express$ itself 9 all ! notes ( music1 & he n only he>s ^! notes1 b he re-comb9es & reorganizes !m 9 8 great compositions4 ,,iv4 ,! _s ( man is simple4 ,x is an ultimate & indivisible unity4 ,dea? divides1 breaks up1 & dis9tegrates4 ,! nature ( ! human _s is su*1 h[ev]1 t x _c be divid$1 brok5 up1 or dis9tegrat$4 ,we see x ma9ta9 its id5tity ?r\gh ! /orms & mutations ( eighty ye>s4 ,all ?+s *ange ab\t x4 ,! v body t con/itutes its tempor>y abid+ place is torn d[n & rebuilt _m times 9 ! c\rse ( a long life4 ,x advances 9 k & exp]i5ce2 gr[s l>g] & ri*] 9 hope & love1 b all its accumulations ( ?\ght & increas+ weal? ( life are /or$ 9 ! same self-consci\s1 self-det]m9+1 p]sonal _s4 ,9 ! ev5+ ( life ! old man sits 9 ! mid/ ( 8 gr&*ildr5 & rec\nts ! sc5es ( 8 boyhood days4 ,all ! waves ( "t conta9$ )9 ! sweep ( ?ree score ye>s & t5 h left _! labels ( drift & /orm on ! %ores ( 8 life4 ,b !y h n worn1 or wa/$1 or alt]$ 8 _s4 ,a rock we>s away1 or is crumbl$ to du/1 :5 x is a rock no long]4 ,a tree is cut d[n & split into cord wood & burn$ 9 ! eng9e1 & x is a tree no long]4 ,9 ! furnace x is turn$ back into its orig9al elem5ts4 ,9 ! fire x is alt]$ or o!r$4 ,! o!r ( a tree is oxyg51 hydrog51 etc4 ,! bird 9 ! ?icket is %ot by ! he>tless sportsman4 ,x falls to ! gr\nd & its little he>t ceases to beat4 ,soon its body is *ang$ back into e>? & air4 ,! o!r ( a bird is n a bird1 b ! p>ticles :i* 7 organiz$ "u ! process ( natural law to =m its body4 ,! images :i* fell on its vision 9 ! grove1 fad$ away :5 ! objects :i* caus$ !m 7 remov$4 ,! s\nds :i* came to its e>s f "h & !re 9 ! =e/ pass$ f its s5se :5 ! air t caus$ !m ceas$ to vibrate4 ,9 ! bird !re 0 no inn] self1 abid+1 self-consci\s1 det]m9+1 & active1 t 0 capable ( grasp+ & hold+ & recreat+ ! visions & ! notes :i* came to x4 ,x may h _h a sort ( s5ti5t consci\sness1 b x 0 n mu* above ! consci\sness ( ! sea1 :i* holds ! images ( ! />s 9 its d>k blue waves1 z long z !y /& above x4 ,by comp>+ man ) ! classes ( individuals bel[ him1 we may see ! respects 9 :i* he rises inf9itely above !m4 ,& we may see1 too1 by ?is comp>ison1 t immortality is n some?+ to :i* man is to come beyond dea?1 b some?+ t he has already 9 ! v con/itution ( ! p]sonal _s4 ,! same may be said ( man's body1 t is said ( ! bodies ( trees & birds1 its o!r is ! orig9al elem5ts :i* compose x4 ,! life 9 a tree _c o!r itself1 because x is n consci\s4 ,! life 9 a bird _c o!r itself because its consci\sness is n self-consci\sness4 ,b 9 man's body !re resides a _s t c o!r itself4 ,man1 z a p]sonal _s1 c project himself out ( himself1 & reason ) himself & commune ) himself4 ,! self he projects out ( himself is ano!r self1 b n a diff]5t self4 ,! o!r ( man's _s1 !n1 is n some?+ else1 b x is ! same _s4 ,man is subject & object1 active & passive1 det]m9] & det]m9$4 ,man1 z subject1 may ext]nalize himself1 & ?us make ( himself 8 own object1 & by ?is self-sep>ation enri* himself & advance )9 himself4 ,bee?ov51 z a ?9k+ subject1 objectifi$ 8 ?\ght 9 ! symphonies1 & ?us regal$ & ?rill$ 8 own _s4 ,by putt+ 8 own ?\ght into ! =m ( s\nd waves1 x came back to him 9 ! ra91 & /orm1 & ?und]1 & sigh1 & murmur ( music4 ,z a ?9k+ subject ,raphael objectifi$ 8 own ?\ght 9 ! transfiguration1 & ?us _h x come back to him 9 a vision z immortal z ! _s t creat$ x4 ,mi*ael ,angelo objectifi$ 8 own ?\ght 9 ! ,la/ ,judgm5t1 & by ?is self-sep>ation ( 8 _s1 adv]tis$ its inde/ructibility4 ,hom]1 z a ?9k+ subject1 objectifi$ 8 ?\ght into ! ,iliad4 ,?is great epic poem has already liv$1 ev5 on ?is side ( ! grave1 :]e ! ord] is *ange & decay1 ne>ly ?ree ?\s& ye>s4 ,are we to conclude t a p]sonal _s t c\ld deposit itself 9 numb]s nev] to die1 0 itself subject to dissolution8 ,?is w\ld be to h an effect great] ?an ! cause4 ,! sunbeam may deposit itself 9 a tree1 & ?us secure to itself life 9 embodi$ =m = hundr$s ( ye>s4 ,b 9 ord] t ?is may be1 ! sun mu/ s5d 8 beams to w>m & n\ri% ! tree all ! days ( its life4 ,! ,iliad has liv$1 h[ev]1 ne>ly ?ree ?\s& ye>s1 )\t ! daily m9i/rations ( ,hom]'s _s4 ,= a bubble on ! sea ( life to lift itself into imp]i%able =m & !n fall back to m+le ) ! waves & ! wat]s1 is to contradict ! pr9ciple ( ! correlation ( =ces1 :i* decl>es t action & reaction mu/ always be equal4 ,! expression a _s makes ( itself _c be m endur+ ?an ! _s itself4 8,! %ip may s9k & ,i may dr9k ,a ha/y dea? 9 ! bitt] sea2 ,b all t ,i leave 9 ! ocean grave ,may be slipp$ & sp>$1 & no loss to me4 8,:at c>e ,i1 ?\gh falls ! sky1 ,& ! %rivel$ e>? to a c9d] turn8 ,no fires ( doom c ev] consume ,:at nev] 0 made nor meant to burn4 8,let g ! brea?6 ,!re is no dea? ,= ! liv+ s\l1 nor loss nor h>m4 ,nor ( ! clod is ! life ( ,god2 ,let x m\nt1 z x w1 f =m to =m40 ,:5 a tra9 ( c>s /ops sudd5ly at ! depot1 ! en]gy t caus$ x to fly along ! track is n lo/1 x is only trans=m$4 ,:5 a tree is cut d[n1 ! en]gy t express$ itself 9 its trunk & bran*es is n lo/1 x w only take o!r =ms4 ,:5 a horse dies1 ! en]gy ( :i* its life 0 ! expression is n lo/1 x is trans=m$4 ,:5 a tree or a horse passes f ! liv+ _w into ! _w ( inorganic ?+s1 ! exact am\nt ( en]gy 9 ! body ( ! liv+ tree or horse takes o!r =ms4 ,! am\nt on ! side ( dea? is equal to ! am\nt on ! side ( life4 ,if we consid] man only z a physical organism1 ! same may be said ( him4 ,! am\nt trans=m$ into e>? & air1 w be ! equival5t ( ! organiz$ fund ( bone1 & s9ew1 & muscle1 turn$ ov] to dea?4 ,if we ?us e/imate man1 h[ev]1 z we d a tree or a horse1 h we tak5 into acc\nt ! entire sum ( assets t 7 9 8 possession dur+ life8 ,:at ( 8 ?\ght1 affection1 & volition8 ,:5 ,kepl] di$1 :at became ( ! intellig5ce t discov]$ ! 8,?ree ,laws10 :i* con/itute ! ar*es ( ! sublime bridge t spans ! va/ *asm betwe5 ,ptolemaic & mod]n a/ronomy8 ,:5 ,laplace di$1 :at became ( ! _s t solv$ ! problems ( ! ,mcanique ,cle/e1 by ! aid ( :i* ! irregul>ities ( ! heav5ly bodies 7 r$uc$ to ord]8 ,:5 ,adams di$1 :at became ( ! massive _s t built 9 ! dep?s ( 8 own /udy ! planet ,neptune1 ) no o!r raw mat]ial to "w f ?an ! p]turbations ( ,uranus8 ,:5 ,moses di$1 :at became ( ! affection t express$ itself 9 ! tra9+ & civilization ( a race8 ,:5 ,jesus ,*ri/ di$1 :at became ( ! love t sacrific$ itself = a s9ful _w8 ,:5 we beg9 to talk ab\t human life1 we f9d all t has made civilization is n physical4 ,9 ! dea? ( human be+s1 ! en]gies ( ?\ght1 & affection1 & volition are n repres5t$ 9 ! trans=mations :i* take place ) ref]5ce to _! bodies4 ,yet all ! en]gies man has put =? t give any evid5ce ( 8 record on ! e>? are su* z come f ?\ght1 & affection1 & volition4 ,z ^! en]gies are n trans=m$ at dea?1 z are ! =ces ( ! body1 !y mu/ cont9ue4 ,= to suppose !y ceas$ at dea? w\ld be to break ! law ( ! correlation & ! cons]vation ( =ces4 ,if !y are n trans=m$ at dea?1 along ) ! =ces ( ! body1 !y mu/ reside 9 ano!r ?an ! mat]ial _w1 & mu/ n1 !re=e1 be subject to its *anges4 ,v4 ,! p]sonal _s1 by its v nature1 & t5d5cies1 & possibilities1 seems to be address$ to ano!r ?an ! tangible1 local1 & physical realm 9 :i* x f9ds itself :ile resid+ 9 ! body4 ,an irrepressible & wide-rea*+ some?+ 9 ! _s ( ea* man seems to impel him to triumph ov] space1 & "t1 & *ange4 ,9 ! accumulation ( prop]ty1 he w\ld own ! :ole _w4 ,a v small portion ( l& w\ld be adequate to 8 physical ne$s4 ,b he w\ld add acre to acre1 till 8 private doma9 compass$ ! surface ( ! :ole e>?4 ,alex&]1 weep+ because !re 0 n ano!r _w he c\ld get to conqu]1 adv]tises ! imm5sity & illimitability ( ! human _s4 ,by ! aid ( in/rum5ts by :i* man has augm5t$ & l5g!n$ 8 p[] ( vision1 he has come ^u />s roll+ 9 ! imm5sity ( space to ! circle ( ! ?irte5? magnitude4 ,he has n be5 cont5t to look ^u ! />s 9 ! va/ dep?s ( space1 b he has photograph$ !m1 s z to behold _! faces 9 8 /udy4 ,back beyond ! dim dawn ( "t1 comm5surate ) ! appe>ance ( human life on e>?1 he has gone1 to return ) ! *emical1 physical1 & /ratigraphical hi/ory ( ! globe4 ,by ! aid ( /eam1 he has made himself a cosmopolite1 & ?r\gh ! application ( electricity1 he has made himself ubiquit\s4 ,mu/ we n posit a _s correlat$ to ! univ]sal to acc\nt = ?is disposition to compass all ?+s1 to "k all ?+s1 & to be ev]y:]e8 ,! t5d5cy ( ! human _s to compass & possess univ]sality is se51 too1 by its capacity to create language1 9 :i* x embodies all ?+s & ?r\gh :i* x expresses its ?\ght ( all ?+s4 ,if !re _h to be sep>ate words = all individual ?+s any b ! mo/ limit$ k w\ld be impossible1 & su* k alone !re w\ld be if man 0 %ut up to atomic s5sations = ! data ( k4 ,b ! m9d1 by its creative1 comb9+ p[]1 & its active spontane\s insight1 =ms words :i* repres5t n only individual ?+s1 b classes & species ( ?+s4 ,man devises ! ^w oak1 & lets x /& = all ! oaks 9 ! _w4 ,he creates ! ^w humanity1 & puts into x ! :ole human race4 ,he co9s ! ^w vegetable1 & uses x to def9e ! :ole k+dom ( plants4 ,?us he n only goes ov] ! _w & sees x directly1 b he produces language manifold & complicat$1 & ela/ic en\gh to accommodate & conta9 ! _w1 ) all t is 9 x4 ,?is makes x possible = him to g r\nd ! _w & see all its wond]s1 )\t leav+ ! place ( 8 bir?4 ,he n only builds = himself ! univ]se 9 language1 s t he c contemplate its moons1 & measure its suns1 & sail its oceans1 & climb its m\nta9s 9 ! sil5t prec9cts ( 8 /udy1 b he avails himself ( s\nd & light1 also1 to give expression to univ]sal ideas4 ,he takes a few notes1 & s comb9es & mixes !m z to be able to t\* all ! *ords ( ! univ]sal human he>t 9 "o song4 ,mi*ael ,angelo put all ! !ology ( all ! books into ! ,la/ ,judgm5t4 ,?r\gh\t ! l5g? & bread? ( nature1 !re is economy ( faculty & res\rce until we come to man4 ,! fi% has n a gill nor a f9 too _m1 & !re is n 9 ! wat] :]e he lives any surplus or m>g9 ^u :i* he does n make levies = 8 life4 ,! w+s & tail & bones ( ! bird are all necess>y to 8 poise & circle 9 ! sky4 ,! same economy is f\nd 9 ! atmosph]e ?r\gh :i* ! bird flies4 ,x is none too heavy & none too light4 ,b :5 we come to man1 we f9d t m>g9 & surplus is ! rule4 ,he has a surplus ( faculty & a surplus ( res\rce1 a surplus ( end[m5t & a surplus ( environm5t4 ,he f9ds x necess>y to make levies on h>dly any ( himself to get along 9 ?is _w1 at lea/ z f> z 8 natural wants are conc]n$4 ,:at w\ld be ! use = a c>p5t] to h all ! tools necess>y to build ,/4 ,pet]'s at ,rome1 if 8 only "w 0 to put up a t5t = a week's camp+ excursion 9 ! woods8 ,:y h an eng9e ) a million horse p[] to run a flutt] mill8 ,) ! animal !re is *ang+ end[m5t & *ang+ environm5t4 ,limitations are cle> & di/9ct )9 & )\t4 ,b ) man !re is inf9ite environm5t4 ,)9 he has a self-det]m9+ _s1 subject & object1 b\nd toge!r 9 a simple & indissoluble unity4 ,surr\nd+ ?is _s1 inf9ite 9 /ructure & capacity1 is inf9ite tru?1 inf9ite law1 & inf9ite love4 ,ev5 ,h]b]t ,sp5c] said 8,p]fect correspond5ce w\ld be p]fect life4 ,7 !re no *anges 9 ! environm5t b su* z ! organism _h adapt$ *anges to meet1 & 7 x nev] to fail 9 ! effici5cy ) :i* x met !m1 !re w\ld be et]nal exi/5ce1 & et]nal k40 ,9 ! p]sonal _s & ! elem5ts :i* surr\nd x1 we h ! two et]nal t]ms ( et]nal correspond5ce4 ,a self-det]m9+ _s is ess5tially1 /ructurally1 & con/itutionally imp]i%able4 ,x o!rs itself only ?r\gh its own act4 ,& ! o!r ( itself is itself4 ,x is its own subject & its own object4 ,:5 x goes out ( itself1 x is itself t goes out4 ,x is a complete circle1 an absolute & inde/ructible individuation4 ,x is ! f9al expression ( ,god's creative p[]4 ,?r\gh all ! revolutions & mutations ( "t1 ?is 0 ! de/9$ goal4 ,! de/ruction ( a human _s w\ld regi/] ! dea? ( ,god4 ,x is ! direct expression ( ! _s ( ,god1 & be>s 8 own lik5ess & image1 & has = ! gu>antee ( its p]man5ce ! p]son ( ! et]nal ,god himself4 ,,vi4 ,rev4 ,edw>d ,:ite ( ,engl&1 ,dr4 ,e4 ,petavel ( ,france1 & ,dr4 ,lyman ,abbott ( ,am]ica1 h d5i$ :at ,dr4 ,abbott is pleas$ to call facultative immortality4 ,immortality1 9 _! e/eem1 is an importation f )\t4 ,x is ! claim ( ,locke1 & ,hume1 & ,mill1 & ,sp5c]1 t k is an importation f ! realm ( s5sation4 ,_! w> 0 ^u ! kn[+ faculties4 ,f ! doma9 ( philosophy ! conflict has pass$ up to ! plane ( religion1 & we n[ h ! attack made ^u ! self-det]m9+ _s4 ,9 ! s5sational philosophy1 we h se5 all ?+s dissolv$4 ,x n only makes x impossible to rationally believe 9 ,god1 b also 9 m9d1 & self1 & ext]nal _w4 ,! s5sational philosophy got ! object ( k by a process t de/roy$ ! subject ( k1 s ?is irrational !ory ( ,dr4 ,lyman ,abbot w\ld secure ! object ( life by ! de/ruction ( ! subject ( life4 ,we "k t ! raw mat]ial ( k is f\nd 9 ! objective _w1 b unless ! m9d has ! inh]5t comb9+1 active p[] to take ?is raw mat]ial & organize x into an ord]ly sy/em1 !n ! individual c nev] "k any?+4 ,!re be+ 9 ! m9d no ma/] ( c]emonies1 no director & ref]ee1 ! tramp & vagabond s5sations may w&] 9 & w&] out at _! sweet w4 ,!y w\ld come 9 ) _! own op9ions & g out ) _! own op9ions4 ,!re be+ no head ( ! h\se )91 ! tramps c\ld h x all _! own way4 ,k1 beg9n+ out ( ! m9d1 w\ld h its cause & end out ( ! m9d4 ,beg9n+ ) matt]1 k c\ld be resolv$ back into matt]4 ,we believe ! life 9 :i* ! human _s is to realize its nature fully & h>moni\sly 0 embodi$ 9 ,jesus ,*ri/1 :o 0 ! ^w made fle%4 ,b x is because ! _s ( man is ess5tially inde/ructible1 t x has p[] to take hold ( ?is life & assimilate x4 ,if x refuses ?is div9e embodim5t ( life1 x br+s disord]1 & confusion1 & ev]la/+ sorr[ to itself1 b n de/ruction4 ,! self-det]m9+ _s is 9 its /ructure & con/itution up to ! /yle ( life (f]$ x 9 ! ,son ( ,man & ! ,son ( ,god4 ,9 f9d+ ! life t 0 9 ,*ri/1 x f9ds its own life1 & ent]s ! pa? ( ev]la/+ progress4