,transcrib$ f ! #ahgj ,macmillan & ,co4 edition by ,david ,price4 ,,d>w9ism4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,! ,,noa*ian ,,flood4 ,a ,,lecture ,,deliv]$ ,,be=e ,,! ,,torquay ,,natural ,,hi/ory ,,society1 ,,jan4 #ca,,/1 #ahgj1 99 99 99 99 99 ,,by ,,?omas ,r4 ,r4 ,,/ebb+1 ,m4,a41 ,late ,fell[ & ,tutor ( ,worce/] ,college1 ,ox=d4 99 99 99 99 99 ,london ,,macmillan ,,& ,,co4 #ahgj4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,ox=d3 ,,by ,t4 ,,combe1 ,m4,a41 ,e4 ,b4 ,,g>dn]1 ,e4 ,p4 ,,hall1 ,,& ,h4 ,,la?am1 ,m4,a41 ,,pr9t]s ,,to ,,! ,,univ]sity4 ,,! ,,noa*ian ,,flood4 ,,d>w9ism implies almo/ ?r\gh\t t no univ]sal ,deluge has dr[n$ our globe1 ei!r )9 ! la/ t5 ?\s& ye>s1 or ev5 )9 a p]iod indef9itely long]4 ,let u speak ) due respect ( ! contr>y belief4 ,x seems to re/ ^u ! te/imony ( a ,volume ! mo/ preci\s 9 ! _w4 ,x 0 tak5 = grant$ till a few ye>s back z mu* 9 sci5ce z 9 religion4 ,= a :ile1 ! argum5ts t began to be rais$ aga9/ x 7 met by c\nt]-argum5ts s plausible1 & ! objectors diff]$ s widely among !mselves1 t unsci5tific op9ion _h a k9d ( "r & prud5ce 9 adh]+ to t :i* _h be5 taught = c5turies1 & 0 /ill taught )\t deviation 9 nurs]y1 & s*ool1 & pulpit4 ,we %\ld h ass]t$ a bett] "r & %[n a high] prud5ce1 _h we wait$1 9 a matt] :i* conc]n$ sci5ce full z mu* z x conc]n$ religion1 till1 by le>n+ facts & weigh+ argum5ts1 we _h become able to =m an op9ion no long] unsci5tific1 or1 at ! v lea/1 to appreciate ! difficulties involv$ 9 ! anci5t belief4 ,we are =c$ to take a controv]sy ( ?is k9d z x /&s2 o!rwise1 !re is a simple pr9ciple :i* ought to make all controv]sy on ! subject ne$less4 ,all au?ors end[$ ) common s5se1 let alone div9e inspiration1 use language :i* _! int5d$ read]s may be expect$ to und]/&1 & language appropriate to ! scope & design ( _! writ+s4 ,unless1 !re=e1 we suppose t ! ,old ,te/am5t writ]s propos$ to tea* natural sci5ce to ! ,hebrew nation1 we ought to expect f !m :at we actually f9d3 z to natural ph5om5a1 pa/ & pres5t1 !y use ! language n ( f>-advanc$ k & m9ute p>ticul> rese>*1 b simply ! language curr5t 9 _! own day & nation4 ,b1 sett+ aside ! g5]al pr9ciple1 9 ! pres5t in/ance !re is a second possibility ( qua%+ ! controv]sy1 if x c be %[n or made probable t ! au?or1 ^: n>rative is 9 "q1 nev] meant to imply t :i* = ?\s&s ( ye>s has be5 held to be 8 mean+4 ,! :ole po9t at issue is ! univ]sality ( ! ,noa*ian ,deluge1 & ! n>rative has be5 ?\ght to be uncompromis+ 9 its decl>ations t all ! e>?1 to ! v m\nta9-tops1 0 inde$ envelop$ 9 wat]1 &1 except+ ! h&ful rescu$ 9 ! ark1 t all m5 & cattle & creep+ ?+s & f[ls ( ! air 7 inexorably de/roy$4 ,b to ?is view ( ! n>rative !re is m ?an "o objection ^u ! v surface ( ! n>rative itself4 ,&1 by way ( preface1 let x be rem>k$ h[ vague & indef9ite is ! use 9 ord9>y language ( su* t]ms z #8all' & #8e' & #8univ]sal4' ,= in/ance1 if a popul> lady gives a kettl$rum1 we say1 #8all ! _w 0 at x1' al?\gh #ejj p]sons c\ld n h be5 squeez$ into ! rooms )\t be+ suffocat$2 or we say1 #8s & s is a ?+ :i* e s*ool-boy kn[s1' :5 we only mean t a good _m lads ( a p>ticul> age1 9 a p>ticul> rank ( life1 & belong+ to "o p>ticul> c\ntry1 h mo/ probably be5 taught x4 ,& aga9 we say1 #8smok+ is univ]sal ) ! ,dut*1' )\t imply+ t e baby 9 ,holl& has a pipe in/ead ( a rattle4 ,y are n to suppose t ?is is a view ( language inv5t$ = ! occasion1 frivol\sly expla9+ grave & sacr$ composition by ! trivialities ( common spee*4 ,on ! contr>y1 x is precisely to ! unque/ion$ preval5ce ( su* phraseology1 9 all b ! mo/ exact sci5tific writ+1 t ! late ,dr4 ,m#8,caul appeal$1 & appeal$ successfully1 aga9/ m ?an "o ( ! objections to ! au?ority ( ! ,p5tateu*1 :i* 7 rais$ "s "t ago by ! well-kn[n & +5i\s ari?metician :o presides ov] ! see ( ,natal4 ,:5 we read t #8!re w5t out a decree f ,cs> ,augu/us t all ! _w %\ld be tax$3 & all w5t to be tax$1 e "o into 8 own city1' are we to inf] ei!r t ! clev] practical ,roman decre$ ! taxation ( b>b>ians ov] :om he _h n ! fa9te/ %ad[ ( control1 or t e ,israelite1 )\t exception1 f\nd & visit$ 8 ance/ral home 9 ,pale/9e--m]*ants f ,gades & ,ophir & ,t>%i%1 slaves & prison]s1 suck+ *ildr51 b$-ridd5 old m51 dy+ suff]]s8 ,we %all n1 if we are wise1 %ut up ei!r ,cs> ,augu/us or ! ,evangeli/ ,/4 ,luke to s prepo/]\s a mean+4 ,9 ?is & t5 ?\s& o!r in/ances1 our g5]al k ( ! att5dant circum/ances1 or :at we call #8! nature ( ! case1' supplies ! necess>y exceptions4 ,to h !m all drawn out 9 detail w\ld be t$i\s & tr\blesome4 ,suppose a glori\s comet is ab\t to make its appe>ance1 & "s a/ronom] publicly advises e "o to be on ! look-out = x on a c]ta9 night1 h[ ridicul\s w\ld he appe> if he made express exception ( p]sons on ! o!r side ( ! globe1 ( p]sons immur$ 9 dungeons1 ( p]sons n yet born1 ( p]sons :o 7 bl9d1 ( p]sons :o 7 dead6 ,yet an au?or1 writ+ "s ?ree or f\r ?\s& ye>s back1 & borr[+ p]haps f picture-records1 c]ta9ly f ! traditions1 h[ev] deliv]$1 ( an age long ant]ior to 8 own1 :5 language 0 f> less ample & precise ?an x has s9ce become1 is treat$ z ?\gh e ^w mu/ be> ! full & exact =ce :i* x w\ld h 9 a c>efully-writt5 treatise ^u logic 9 ! pres5t day4 ,we may assume t ! au?or ei!r _h s\nd & accurate in=mation 9 ! ord9>y c\rse ( human tradition1 or else t he 0 end[$ ) a sup]human k ( ! hi/orical ev5ts 9 "q4 ,b1 on ei!r assumption1 :at conceivable w>rant h we = imag9+ t he 0 depriv$ ( common s5se8 ,ei!r he knew ! contradictions :i* natural sci5ce (f]s to ! belief 9 a rec5t univ]sal deluge1 or he did n "k !m4 ,if he knew !m1 we may inf] f 8 sil5ce t 8 n>rative 0 n op5 to ^? contradictions2 9 o!r words1 t ! deluge ( :i* he speaks 0 n univ]sal4 ,if he did n "k !m1 8 ignorance po9ts to ! same conclusion3 o!rwise1 we %all h a div9e miracle1 int5d$ = ! w>n+ & ! b5efit ( ! human race1 yet s contriv$ t all its mo/ surpris+ circum/ances %\ld be absolutely unkn[n to "o half ( mank9d1 & z absolutely incr$ible to ! o!r half4 ,! hi/orical acc\nt in=ms u t #8! wat]s prevail$ exce$+ly ^u ! e>?2 & all ! high hills t 7 "u ! :ole heav5 7 cov]$4 ,fifte5 cubits upw>d did ! wat]s prevail2 & ! m\nta9s 7 cov]$4' ,b ,europe possesses m\nta9s ris+ to a height ( m ?an #aj1jjj cubits or #ae1jjj feet--"o peak 9 ,asia is #bi1jjj feet above ! level ( ! sea--s t1 on ! common int]pretation1 ! wat]s ( ! flood mu/ h ris5 to a ?ickness above ! ord9>y sea-level ( ne>ly #cj1jjj feet ov] ! :ole ( ! globe4 ,b1 on ?is supposition1 ! n>rative is n only bewild]+ & morally impossible1 b positively untru?ful1 = x decl>es ! physical means employ$ 9 ! production ( ! flood to be ! f\nta9s ( ! great deep & ! ra9 f heav5--means entirely suffici5t to produce a p>tial flood ov] a limit$ area1 b utt]ly & ludicr\sly inadequate to produce a total deluge envelop+ #8all ! high hills "u ! :ole heav54' ,! notion is self-contradictory t ! ocean c be employ$ to raise its own level1 or t its g5]al height c be increas$ by ! ra9 :i* x is its own "p to supply4 ,nor is !re any indication af=d$ t a sup]natural supply ( wat] 0 add$ to our planet1 to ! ext5t ( sev]al hundr$ millions ( cubic miles ( liquid1 :i* w\ld h be5 requir$ = ! purpose ( dr[n+ ! ,caucasus & ! ,alps & ,t5]iffe & ,popocatapetl & ,*imil>i4 ,we mu/ consid] also ! difficulty ( brea?+1 & ! int5se cold t w\ld h be5 exp]i5c$ at t /up5d\s altitude4 ,!re is ! old "q ( space 9 ! ark2 !re is ! old "q ( ! food-supply1 suffici5t & appropriate1 to be /or$ & sort$ = its v>i\s occupants1 c>nivor\s & h]bivor\s1 bea/s ( prey1 c>rion-birds1 & amphibi\s mon/]s4 ,b :at are ^! comp>$ ) ! "q h[ life c\ld be su/a9$ 9 ! bitt] freez+ atmosph]e1 ?\s&s ( feet above ! l9e ( p]petual sn[1 by creatures accu/om$ to ! l[l&s ( ! tropics8 ,suppos+1 h[ev]1 ! atmosph]e to h be5 completely w>m$ by ! rise ( ! ocean1 or ev5 if ! air )9 ! ark 0 kept w>m by its enorm\s cr[d ( d5iz5s1 we are confront$ by a new difficulty1 "o t might seem laughable & improp] to m5tion b = its va/ & press+ importance 9 our own days1 ?w>t+ ! physician1 p]plex+ ! /atesman1 baffl+ ! *emi/ & ! eng9e]4 ,to ?is suppos$ epitome ( ! _w's inhabitants1 %ut up = mon?s )9 ! ark1 :o 7 ! scav5g]s8 ,b suppose e "o ( ^! problems to be solv$ by a miracle1 al?\gh ( su* miracles n a h9t is giv51 !re /ill rema9s ! /atem5t to be dealt )1 t #8,god made a w9d to pass ov] ! e>?1 & ! wat]s assuag$4' ,surely ?is1 if no?+ else1 is conclusive t ! writ] _h all along be5 describ+ a local & p>tial deluge ^u :i* a w9d c\ld h "s s5sible effect1 n an univ]sal flood wrapp+ all ! m\nta9s ( ! globe 9 wat]1 9 :i* case ! mightie/ w9d t ev] 01 or c\ld be dream$ (1 c\ld only h laid b>e ! surface ( ! l& by pil+ up great hills & precipices ( wat] ^u ! ocean4 ,:5 we wi% to expose ! miracles ( a false religion or ( a sup]/iti\s ab]rant cre$1 we po9t out1 z ! case may be1 t !y are frivol\s1 useless1 unmean+1 devoid ( adequate motive1 ! end a*iev$ & ! means employ$ be>+ no reasonable proportion2 or we %[ t ! te/imony 9 _! fav\r is inconsi/5t ) itself1 or t ! consequ5ces :i* %\ld h fl[$ f ! miracle1 _h x be5 g5u9e1 are c]ta9ly want+1 unless1 to bol/] up "o extreme improbability1 a hundr$ o!rs are inv5t$ & swall[$4 ,to e "o ( ^! imputations ! common !ory ( ! ,noa*ian ,deluge lies op54 ,b conc$e a few gra9s ( common s5se to ! n>rator2 read 8 n>rative 9 ! _s 9 :i* su* a p]son mu/ h writt5 x2 rememb] t he is n writ+ a sci5tific treatise1 nor us+ ! phraseology ( mod]n ,europe2 be> 9 m9d t he is speak+ 9 an idiom no long] or n[ b seldom us$1 yet a j & noble idiom1 :i* ascribes to ,god all t is done ^u e>?1 :e!r good or evil1 ! works ( man & ! common processes ( nature1 z well z ?+s sup]human & miracul\s2 &1 ) ^! consid]ations be=e u1 we %all save ! v5]able record f e imputation1 ei!r ( folly or ( falsehood4 ,t :i* we h describ$ to u is a va/ p5al cata/rophe sweep+ away "s great c5tre ( civilization by means ( a t]rible inundation4 ,along "s ocean-bord] ! f>-/ret*+ pla9s 7 dott$ ?ickly ) t[ns & villages4 ,!re 7 fields wav+ ) corn2 ! v9e & ! olive1 ! orange & ! palm ab\nd$2 !re 7 cattle fe$+ 9 gre5 pa/ures beside ! /ill wat]s2 !re 7 popul\s tribes & nations c>ry+ on all ! bus9ess & revelry ( life2 !y b\ght1 !y sold1 !y build$1 !y plant$1 !y 7 m>ry+ & giv+ 9 m>riage1 :5 sudd5ly ! f\nta9s ( ! great deep 7 brok5 up1 & ! e>?quake wave roll$ 9 ^u !m1 & swept all ! beauty & ! glory & ! s9 remorselessly away4 ,at ! same "t1 ! angry heav5s 7 ov]ca/1 & ! floodgates ( ! cl\ds p\r$ d[n _! volumes ( ceaselessly-desc5d+ ra94 ,! di/ant m\nta9s 7 torn f ! sight2 nay1 e high hill "u ! :ole heav5 0 itself cov]$ & enfold$ 9 a liquid veil1 = e rill 0 n[ a torr5t1 e t9y silv] ?read ( a cascade n[ a d>k unbrok5 avalan*e ( wat]s4 ,"o family alone1 alone ob$i5t to ! w>n+ :i* all _h receiv$1 7 sav$ amid/ ?is univ]sal ru91 & took ) !m into ! ark ( _! refuge specim5s ( e bird & bea/ & creep+ ?+ t _! own c\ntry produc$1 & t 0 9 any way s]viceable to man4 ,:5 cl\d & mi/ _h roll$ away f ! m\nta9-tops1 :5 ! face ( ! gr\nd 0 once m dry--) ^! creatures !y /ock$ _! new settlem5t4 ,! well-wat]$ pla9 0 spe$ily repl5i%$2 ! v9e fl\ri%$2 ! cattle br\ght =? abundantly2 ! *ildr5 ( ! patri>* multipli$ rapidly & spread f> & wide ov] _! ri* & undisput$ inh]itance4 ,su* is ! n>rative z x glimm]s ?r\gh ! haze ( =ty c5turies1 only told 9 ! orig9al ) unrivall$ simplicity & =ce1 gr&] ?an any description by =be>+ to describe1 told z "o w\ld tell x1 :o 9 t convulsion ( nature _h lo/ k9dr$1 fri5ds & c\ntrym51 z "o :o _h se5 ! :ole _w1 s f> z he knew x or c>$ = x1 f\nd]+ 9 ! waves1 & yet _h liv$ on ?r\gh all ! unutt]able calamity to see himself once m surr\nd$ by fruitful fields & smil+ home/eads1 & all t might make :at 0 to him emphatically a new _w ! c\nt]p>t ( ! old4 ,"s may p]mit !mselves = a mom5t to set aside ! limitation we h sugge/$ to ! numb] ( animals 9 ! ark z fanciful & unw>rant$4 ,x w be prop] !re=e to draw out ! consequ5ces atta*+ to ! old op9ion4 ,we f9d f ! words ( ! n>rative1 t ! patri>* ,noah 0 intru/$ ) ! task ( collection4 ,to a*ieve x1 !n1 he mu/ h gone 9 p]son1 or s5t exp$itions1 to ,au/ralia = ! kang>oo & ! wombat1 to ! froz5 ,nor? = ! ,pol> be>1 to ,africa = ! gorilla & ! *impanzee2 ! hippopotamus ( ! ,nile1 ! elk1 ! bison1 ! dodo1 ! apt]yx1 ! emeu & ! cass[>y mu/ h be5 br\ght toge!r by va/ ef=ts f di/ant qu>t]s4 ,! patri>* or 8 ag5ts mu/ h be5 end[$ ) a sup]natural k ( natural hi/ory f> surpass+ ,solomon's or t ( our own times1 t !y might prop]ly di/+ui% v>ieties & species1 s t no species might be omitt$ & none repres5t$ by m ?an "o v>iety4 ,to accompli% ?is ) ! m9ute/ insects1 !y mu/ h be5 provid$ ) p[]ful microscopes4 ,e portion ( ! dry l& ( ! globe mu/ h be5 accessible to !m2 e jungle1 cav]n1 & rav9e4 ,! little isl&s t lose !mselves 9 mid-ocean mu/ all h be5 ransack$2 ! se>*1 too1 t might n neglect any acre ( gr\nd 9 all ! cont95ts ( ! _w1 w\ld be di/ract$ ) ! mo/ v>i$ & incongru\s pursuits4 ,%eep1 game1 cat]pill>s1 bea/s ( prey1 snails1 eagles1 fleas & titmice1 mu/ all h _! %>e ( att5tion4 ,unusual pa9s mu/ be employ$ to secure !m un9jur$4 ,!y mu/ be f$ & c>$ = dur+ a j\rney1 p]haps1 ( ?\s&s ( miles1 till !y rea* ! ark2 !y mu/ be h9d]$ f dev\r+ "o ano!r :ile ! se>* is cont9u$ = rats & bats & vip]s & toads & scorpions1 & o!r animals :i* a patri>*1 specially s+l$ out z j & upright & a lov] ( peace1 w\ld naturally wi% & naturally be select$ to transmit z a boon to 8 fav\r$ desc5dants4 ,x might be ask$ h[1 ) ! sup]natural k requisite = collect+ all ! t]re/rial animals ( ! globe1 & ! unique opportunity = obs]vation af=d$ by a resid5ce ( "s mon?s ) !m 9 ! ark1 no m sci5tific classification 0 arriv$ at ?an t into birds & bea/s & creep+ ?+s8 ,b lett+ ?is pass1 or scatt]+ x & o!r objections to ! w9ds by inv5t+ a miracle to expla9 ! ga!r+ toge!r ( ! animals1 we %all !n h to give "s acc\nt ( _! re-di/ribution4 ,in/ead ( worry+ ourselves ) ! problem1 %all we at once solve x by ass]t+ t !y 7 miracul\sly re-transf]r$ to ! habitations f :i* !y came8 ,?is w be a highly satisfactory plan1 if only x w /op ! m\?s ( ^? inquisitive p]sons :o nev] "k :5 !y are beat5 9 an argum5t4 ,b "o cavil may easily be =ese51 requir+ a new miracle to satisfy x2 = _m ( ! animals mu/ ei!r h be5 miracul\sly suppli$ ) provisions1 or miracul\sly enabl$ to d )\t !m2 or else1 to take a s+le in/ance1 two spid]s w\ld h be5 limit$ to a c\ple ( flies1 & :5 ! flies _h become ext9ct1 because dev\r$ by ! spid]s1 ! spid]s also w\ld h become ext9ct ?r\gh hav+ no m flies to dev\r2 & ?us _! pres]vation 9 ! ark1 at ! exp5se ( a great _m unrecord$ & highly improbable miracles1 w\ld h be5 utt]ly useless4 ,suppose1 h[ev]1 t !y 7 spread ov] ! e>? aga9 by ! sl[ process ( natural di/ribution4 ,c]ta9 p]plexities1 inde$1 may h aris5 :5 !y fir/ issu$ f ! ark1 :5 ! cobra & ! rattlesnake1 ! hungry wolf & ! rel5tless tig] 7 let loose ^u ! impov]i%$ _w & its def5celess inhabitants4 ,= at t conjuncture to h de/roy$ ev5 "o cruel & v5om\s bea/ might h blott$ out a :ole species4 ,x is surely a little rem>kable t rav5\s bea/s & birds ( prey %\ld h be5 limit$1 ev5 :ile 9 ! ark1 to fe$+ ^u animals 9 a c]emonial or ecclesia/ical s5se clean2 b if1 aft] !y _h left ! ark1 & _h once m to provide = !mselves1 ! wily pan!r & ! trea*]\s hy5a mu/ be imag9$ debat+ be=e e meal :e!r _! victim belong$ to ! sev5s ( ! clean or ! c\ples ( ! unclean animals1 %all we n turn 9 pity & vexation f any view t involves & admits s mon/r\s a supposition8 ,b we w conc$e t e creature bore a *>m$ life1 t x might n p]i% by fam9e or viol5ce till x _h propagat$ its k9d4 ,we %\ld !n expect to obs]ve t species _h di/ribut$ !mselves ov] ! globe 9 l9es ei!r tortu\s or direct1 s+le or bran*+1 broad or n>r[1 b all div]g+ f a common c5tre4 ,yet no?+ ( ! k9d is f\nd4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! species ( ! new _w diff] f ^? ( ! old1 ! species ( "o cont95t f ^? ( ano!r4 #af ,! m>supials ( ,au/ralia & ,polynesia are g5]ically di/9ct f all o!r animals on ! globe except ! opossum4 ,! elephant ( ,africa is n ! same species z ! elephant ( ,india3 s ) ! lion1 s ) ! rh9oc]os4 ,! apes & baboons ( ! old _w are n[h]e to be f\nd 9 ,am]ica1 nor ! ,am]ican monkeys any:]e 9 ! old _w4 ,9 ,madagasc>1 sep>at$ f ,africa by less ?an ! bread? ( ,engl&1 all ! species except "o1 & ne>ly all ! g5]a1 are peculi>4 #ag ,ev]y:]e species are f\nd limit$ 9 _! range by natural b>ri]s1 su* z climate1 riv]s1 m\nta9s1 oceans4 ,are we to suppose t ! prison]s c\ld scramble into _! prisons1 & !n sudd5ly became incapable ( scrambl+ out aga98 ,ev]y:]e1 z a rule1 ?is range is consi/5t ) ! hypo!sis ( an orig9 c5tral to ! range1 inconsi/5t ) t ( an orig9 di/ant f x4 ,:]e1 z on m\nta9 ranges1 we f9d1 contr>y to ! g5]al rule1 ! same species 9 diff]5t localities1 ! migration f ! door ( ! ark loses all semblance ( probability1 unless we are pleas$ to imag9e t creatures1 n[ )\t ! in/9ct ( migration1 = a long "t possess$ x1 & roam$ ab\t ! _w ?r\gh _m a sultry pla9 to pick out a hill-side "h & !re ) a temp]ature suit$ to _! con/itutions4 ,b ! exceptional ph5om5on1 o!rwise s h>d to acc\nt =1 ,d>w9 has admirably expla9$1 by po9t+ out t species adapt$ to a l[ temp]ature w\ld naturally h occupi$ l[l&s 9 ! ,glacial ,p]iod1 f :i*1 z ! cold gradually grew less & less int5se1 !y w\ld z naturally h retir$1 "s ( !m nor?w>ds1 o!rs to ! cool heights ( v>i\s m\nta9s4 ,t !re 0 a ,glacial ,p]iod1 :5 great iceb]gs travell$ ov] ,engl&1 a p]iod geologically z b ( ye/]day1 ?\gh enorm\sly m remote ?an any hi/orical dates1 is n[ beyond all "q4 ,equally beyond "q is x t c\ntless ages & g5]ations ( liv+ be+s on ! e>? prec$$ t ,glacial ,p]iod4 ,&1 add$ to ?is1 we f9d t !re are =ms ( life j :]e !y w\ld h be5 left by ! effect ( t p]iod1 _h !re be5 an unbrok5 succession f t "t to ?is1 & j :]e x is mo/ unlikely !y %\ld be f\nd1 _h !y be5 =c$ to travel to ^? habitations f ! door ( ! ark )9 ! practically insignificant p]iod ( #dcjj ye>s4 ,b /ill fur!r1 we may comp>e ! _w ( life be=e ! ,flood ) ! _w ( life s9ce4 ,& "h surely x ne$s n ! g5ius ( ,d>w9 or ,lyell or ,ow5 to p]ceive ! conclusiv5ess ( ! argum5t :i* _! g5ius has po9t$ out & en=c$4 ,= in/ance1 :]e ! m>supials n[ live1 !re liv$ m>supials 9 ages long be=e ,noah1 z ! fossil rema9s te/ify4 ,! fossils are fossil m>supials1 b m>supials ( species n[ ext9ct4 ,s t ! #8door ( ! ark' !ory requires u to believe t ! m>supials f\nd _! way to ,au/ralia1 leav+ no traces ( _! r\te on l&1 cross+ seas :i* !y nev] subsequ5tly re-cross$1 & plant+ !mselves precisely 9 t region :i* o!r m>supials1 g5]ically ! same b specifically diff]5t1 _h occupi$ be=e !m4 ,we are to believe ?is ( c\ntless o!r species 9 all p>ts ( ! _w4 ,we are to believe t !y sl[ly & 9 _m g5]ations work$ _! way back to ^! quasi-ance/ral homes1 & yet neglect$ to occupy va/ tracts equally or ev5 bett] adapt$ to _! wants4 ,we mu/ believe also t "s ( ! fleete/1 /ronge/1 & mo/ sagaci\s animals1 z ! horse & ! elephant1 fail$ to trace out ! abodes ( _! anci5t repres5tatives1 s9ce ,am]ica1 :5 discov]$ a few ye>s ago1 possess$ ^! quadrup$s only 9 fossil & 9 no liv+ species4 #ai ,!re is inde$ "o animal1 ^: p[]s ( contrivance w\ld acc\nt = its di/ribution ov] ! globe1 ev5 suppos+ x to h begun ) a s+le family1 n m ?an #dcjj ye>s ago1 & to h rang$ f a s+le c5tre4 ,man is t animal4 ,yet1 if all ! o!r facts t be> on ! univ]sality ( ! ,noa*ian ,deluge 7 9 an agreem5t ) x z entire z _! irreconcileability is utt] & complete1 /ill ! circum/ances ( ! human race alone w\ld disable u f believ+ t ! ,flood ( ,noah's epo* ext5d$ ov] all ! globe4 ,) o!r animals x might be advanc$ t ! diff]5t species & ma9 v>ieties _h be5 repres5t$ 9 ! ark & 7 !nce dissem9at$2 b 9 ! case ( man we are preclud$ f su* an explanatory device by ! express t]ms ( ! diluvian record4 ,if ! ,noa*ian ,flood 0 univ]sal1 !n f ,noah alone mu/ be desc5d$ all ! races ( man n[ ^u ! e>?3 all ! great & curi\s v>iations !y display mu/ h be5 evolv$1 n 9 c\ntless g5]ations z ,d>w9ism supposes1 b 9 "s two or ?ree hundr$ or less4 ,f ,noah alone mu/ h sprung )9 a m]e h&ful ( c5turies races s widely unlike "o ano!r z ,greeks & ,negroes1 ,jews & ,egyptians1 ,saxons & ,ojibbeways1 ,caffirs & ,hott5tots1 ,fuegians & ,patagonians1 ,cali=nians & ,*9ese1 ,arabs & ,esquimaux4 ,9 ! same ar*ipelago we h ! ,malay1 ! ,papuan1 & ! dw>f snub-nos$ ,negrito4 #bj ,to give ! contra/ betwe5 ! two =m] 9 ! words ( ,mr4 ,wallace3--#8,! ,malay is ( %ort /ature1 br[n-sk9n$1 /raight-hair$1 be>dless1 & smoo?-bodi$4 ,! ,papuan is tall]1 is black-sk9n$1 frizzly-hair$1 be>d$1 & hairy-bodi$4 ,! =m] is broad-fac$1 has a small nose & flat eyebr[s2 ! latt] is long-fac$1 has a l>ge & prom95t nose1 & project+ eyebr[s4 ,! ,malay is ba%ful1 cold1 undemon/rative & quiet2 ! ,papuan is bold1 impetu\s1 excitable & noisy4 ,! =m] is grave & seldom laughs2 ! latt] is joy\s & laught]-lov+1--! "o conceals 8 emotions1 ! o!r displays !m4' ,su* is ! description & contra/ ( two types ( mank9d geographically sep>at$ f "o ano!r by an int]val ( n m ?an #cjj miles2 yet ! l9e :i* sep>ates ^! two races ( ! human family is almo/ exactly co9cid5t ) t deep-sea l9e :i* =ms ! b\nd>y betwe5 two great zoological prov9ces4 ,ei!r1 !n1 9 ^! two di/9ct b neighb\r+ localities1 ! :ole multitude ( species1 man includ$1 mu/ h be5 und]go+ v>iation simultane\sly = t5s ( ?\s&s ( ye>s1 or else ! diff]5ces 9 ! :ole multitude1 man includ$1 mu/ h be5 already e/abli%$1 or ne>ly s1 :5 fir/ !y /epp$ =? 9 s+ul> procession f ! door ( ! ark4 ,b ! =m] alt]native1 :i* is ! ,d>w9ian1 is consi/5t ) ! record ( ! ,noa*ian ,flood 9 imply+ t ! inundation 0 only p>tial2 :ile ! latt] alt]native contradicts ! record 9 an ess5tial po9t on :i* x is p]fectly explicit1 by necessitat+ ! pres5ce 9 ! ark ( m ?an "o human family4 ,z long z we are cont5t to speak ( #djjj ye>s or s1 "s "o might be tempt$ to fancy1 h[ev] errone\sly1 t su* a p]iod w\ld be adequate to produce ! exi/+ v>ieties ( mank9d1 because !re is "s evid5ce ( comp>atively rapid *anges ( col\r hav+ tak5 place "u ! influ5ce ( climate1 & because new types ( features appe>s to be =m+ ) a noticeable progress "u ! absolutely unique circum/ances :i* h gov]n$ ! rec5t colonization ( ,nor? ,am]ica4 ,unique ^? circum/ances are1 because nev] be=e has !re be5 s mu* m+l+ ( ! blood ( diff]5t nations & races 9 a new & unoccupi$ field1 ) mu* to /imulate & no?+ to curb or repress v>iation4 ,nev] be=e h m5's m9ds & bodies 9 e faculty be5 s tax$ & /ra9$ to activity by ! v sup]abundance ( _! res\rces1 ! virg9 soil ( a new c\ntry1 an inh]it$ civilization1 enorm\s & ev]-enl>g+ facilities = do+1 = liv+1 mov+1 & le>n+--facilities sometimes t _c be decl9$ or escap$ f1 ?\gh !y #8fret ! pigmy body to decay1 & o'er-in=m ! t5em5t ( clay4' ,b1 9 tru?1 !re is no "q ( #djjj ye>s 9 ! matt]2 = !re 7 black p 9 ! "t ( ,h]odotus & 9 ! "t ( ,solomon4 ,already 9 ! "t ( ,moses !re exi/$ a race 9 ,pale/9e s diff]5t f ! ,israelites1 t ! fir/ ,hebrew explor]s 7 daunt$ by ! sight ( !m1 al?\gh1 9 fact1 !y 7 look+ on a race no long] 9 its prime1 b "o t 0 dy+ out4 ,egyptian monum5ts1 dat+ back to ! same p]iod & e>li]1 give repres5tations ( ,africans1 ,asiatics & ,europeans1 ) _! physical *>act]i/ics !n z n[ unmi/akeably di/9ct2 !y portray ! ,negro z ! ,negro /ill is bo? 9 col\r & 9 features4 #bc ,if x took only #hjj ye>s1 !n1 :i* is ! int]val betwe5 ! ,flood & ! bir? ( ,moses1 to orig9ate & e/abli% types s di/9ct z ,jews1 ,egyptians1 ,negroes1 & ,anakim1 all ga!r$ toge!r 9 a little corn] ( ! _w1 might n ,nature1 hav+ done s mu* 9 s %ort a "t = ! highe/ animal1 d a little m 9 a long] "t = l[] animals1 & s supply t orig9 ( species by v>iation = :i* ,mr4 ,d>w9 cont5ds8 ,w\ld n ! obvi\s inf]5ce be t ,nature _h done s1 if x 7 n fanci$ t su* an orig9 ( species 0 /ill m repugnant to ! ,book ( ,g5esis ?an ev5 a limitation ( ! area cov]$ by ! ,flood8 ,b ! ,d>w9ian !ory1 happily = itself1 is n dep5d5t ^u any supposition s incr$ible z "o :i* w\ld w>rant u 9 expect+ among ! desc5dants1 = example1 ( ,william ! ,conqu]or1 p z little l "o ano!r z ,john ,bull & ,john ,*9aman1 ,uncle ,sambo & ! la/ ( ! ,mohicans4 ,!re are circum/ances ( imm5se weight to conv9ce u t c]ta9 m>k$ divisions ( mank9d orig9at$ 9 ! regions :i* !y are n[ occupy+4 ,!re are o!r circum/ances prepond]at+ = ! common orig9 ( mank9d4 ,d>w9ism has at l5g? %[n h[ ^! ph5om5a c be reconcil$1 by simply connect+ ! hi/ory ( man ) t va/ duration ( life ^u ! globe :i* geological sci5ce has unveil$4 ,! lik5esses among races ( m5 dem& a common p>5tage = all ^? races2 ! unlik5esses c only be acc\nt$ = on ! view ( an isolation imm5sely protract$ ( "o race f ano!r4 ,?us ! prim>y orig9 is common to all2 ! second>y orig9 is peculi> to ea*3 b n[ t ! prim>y orig9 has be5 prov$ to be s va/ly m remote ?an 0 once suppos$1 ! second>y orig9 rec$es ( itself into a f> di/ant pa/1 to give "t = diff]5ces to arise & develope1 s9ce1 if ! actually exi/+ unlik5esses 7 only sk9 deep1 in/ead ( affect+1 z !y d1 ! bones ( ! skeleton & ! :ole fibre ( ! m9d1 !y w\ld /ill be too great to admit a common d]ivation ( ! :ole human family f ! patri>* ,noah4 ,:at ,geology tea*es to demon/ration is1 t all p>ts ( ! dry l& h be5 n once only b _m times "u ! wat]s ( ! ocean2 b x tea*es likewise to demon/ration t at lea/ = _m & _m an age1 almo/ beyond our p[]s ( conceiv+ duration ( "t1 !re has be5 no total subm]g5ce ( ! l&4 ,t int]*ange ( lake & sea ) isle & cont95t :i* is n[ go+ on "u our eyes1 has be5 go+ on = ages innum]able4 ,by ?is & k9dr$ means human be+s1 l all k9ds ( animals & all k9ds ( plants1 h at int]vals exp]i5c$ sev]ance into gr\ps & isolation4 ,?us has mank9d be5 brok5 up into di/9ct families1 at fir/ ) no l9e ( dem>cation except ! geographical1 b gradually 9 successive g5]ations becom+ m & m unlike 9 mann]s1 morals1 language1 features1 intellig5ce1 & civilization4 ,b s9ce ! era ( ! ,noa*ian ,deluge nei!r has !re be5 "t = ,nature1 ) h] sl[ ?\gh c]ta9 processes1 to effect s great a recon/ruction ( b>ri]s z to break up ! human family1 if till !n cont9u\s & unit$2 nor1 if !re _h be5 "t = ! geographical sev]ance1 w\ld !re h be5 "t = ! con/itutional *anges4 ,among ! anci5ts "s believ$ t ! sun1 moon1 & />s 7 9 reality ab\t ! size :i* !y appe> to ! unassi/$ eyesight2 o!rs suppos$ ! vault ( ! sky to be a revolv+ dome ( solid cry/al pi]c$ ) little holes ?r\gh :i* m5 saw 9 />ry %apes ! fire ( ! e!real region beyond x4 ,p]sons ) su* ideas ( space & physical sci5ce might n readily h accept$ on ! mom5t ! ,cop]nican sy/em ( a/ronomy4 ,9 ! same way p]sons ) a n>r[ & limit$ view ( ! duration ( "t may f9d a difficulty 9 receiv+ argum5ts bas$ on or imply+ ! enorm\s ext5t ( x1 :i* all sci5ces are n[ comb9+ to demon/rate4 ,b ?is m5tal incapacity1 ! result ( false education & e>ly prejudice1 may be defi$ to resi/ any real inve/igation ( ! facts or /udy ( :at has be5 writt5 ^u !m4 ,let any man ( mature m9d & av]age intellect read ?r\gh ,sir ,john ,lubbock's #8,prehi/oric ,times1' ,mr4 ,d>w9's #8,orig9 ( ,species1' & ,sir ,*>les ,lyell's #8,pr9ciples ( ,geology1' & reta9 if he c ! op9ion t our globe 0 fir/ peopl$ ab\t #fjjj ye>s ago1 & subsequ5tly all b depopulat$ by an univ]sal ,flood4 ,let him see1 inde$1 :e!r he c read ,sir ,*>les ,lyell's acc\nt ( ! progress ( op9ion & controv]sy on ^! subjects & refra9 f blu%+4 ,he w recognize 9 t acc\nt a turmoil & clam\r ( fools & philosoph]s1 ( laym5 & div9es4 ,he w h to set to ! cr$it ( intellig5t humanity & enlight5$ ,*ri/5dom a long tissue ( pi\s frauds1 ,jesuitical def5ces1 argum5ts bas$ on imag9>y facts1 & facts p]v]t$ by imag9ation1 till he comes d[n to ! pres5t "t & f9ds a great multitude ( all classes at l5g? agre$ 9 affirm+ t life has endur$ on ! globe ) unbrok5 cont9uity ?r\gh a pa/ z yet unfa?omable4 ,8 own m9d1 he w p]ceive1 has actually rea*$ maturity )\t hav+ admitt$ ! voice ( ?is multitude1 al?\gh to apply almo/ lit]ally ! words ( 8 great ,ma/]1 #8,if ^! %\ld hold _! peace1 ! /ones w\ld cry out4' #bf;a ,! _w & its wond]s are ( no mu%room gr[?1 al?\gh ev5 ! mu%room1 :i* is commonly suppos$ to spr+ up 9 a s+le night1 requires a mu* long] p]iod1 (t5 _m weeks1 = its production4 #bf;b ,! ,book ( ,g5esis itself mo/ cle>ly w>ns any c>eful read] aga9/ attempt+ to build a *ronology ^u ! brief memor&a ( names & dates :i* = o!r reasons are ins]t$ 9 x4 ,=1 tak+ !m simply z !y /&1 ,%em1 ! son ( ,noah1 is repres5t$ z long surviv+ ! bir? ( ,isaac1 :ile ,abraham1 ! fa!r ( ,isaac1 appe>s z ! contempor>y ( a va/ numb] ( diff]5t & /range tribes & nations1 ,egyptians1 ,phili/9es1 ,canaanites1 ,syrians1 & _m m1 besides ! ,*aldeans1 f among :om he came4 ,to f9d a p>allel to all ?is1 we %\ld imag9e our own ,edw>d ,,iii1 in/ead ( dy+ 9 #acgg z he did1 liv+ on & on to ! pres5t day1 a =gott5 old man1 n notic$ 9 ! page ( hi/ory ?r\gh\t #ejj ev5tful ye>s1 dur+ :i* ! :ole ( ,europe 0 becom+ peopl$ ) desc5dants ( himself & 8 fa!r1 m5 speak+ languages mutually un9telligible1 hold+ cre$s mutually abhorr5t1 ) /range div]sities 9 dress1 mann]s & gov]nm5t1 & "s prev5t$ by national cu/om f ev5 eat+ at ! same table ) gue/s ( ano!r neighb\r+ & k9dr$ tribe4 ,9 va9 %\ld we se>* ?r\gh hi/ory = any actual p>allel1 = any in/ance ( developm5ts s extraord9>y1 & e/rangem5ts s complete1 occurr+ )9 a space ( only #ejj ye>s4 ,if all ! nations spok5 ( z contempor>y ) ,abraham 7 only #ejj ye>s di/ant f ! ,flood1 z ! ,book ( ,g5esis %[s !m to h be51 we may be c]ta9 t !y c\ld trace back _! l9eage1 indep5d5tly ( ,noah & 8 family1 f> beyond ! era ( ! ,deluge4 ,! monum5tal evid5ce ( ,egyptian *ronology c>ries u back to a ,ph>aoh reign+ "s ?ree or f\r hundr$ ye>s be=e t date4 #bg;a ,! ,book ( ,g5esis introduces u to ano!r ,ph>aoh reign+ "s #djj ye>s aft] x4 ,are we to set aside ! monum5tal evid5ce1 & make ?is lat] ,ph>aoh a desc5dant ( ,noah1 reign+ z a p[]ful mon>*1 :ile ,abraham1 ! rightful heir ( a patri>*al mon>*y ov] all ! e>?1 0 no?+ b a w&]+ %eph]d8 ,religion1 morals1 civilization1 z f> z we "k any?+ ab\t !m 9 ^? ages1 :e!r we reg>d _! advancem5t 9 "s qu>t]s or _! decay 9 o!rs1 all prote/ aga9/ hav+ _! progress cramp$ into ^? f\r or five hundr$ ye>s4 ,!y prote/ aga9/ be+ ascrib$ ) all _! conspicu\s div]sities to ! (fspr+ ( "o man1 ^: son1 gr&son1 great-gr&son & great-great-gr&son1 ,%em1 ,arphaxad1 ,salah1 & ,eb]1 7 actually /ill liv+ dur+ all ^! suppos$ revolutions4 #bg;b ,inde$1 if we g back f our #djj to our #djjj ye>s1 ! prote/s on ^! po9ts are almo/ equally =cible4 ,9 ! matt] ( language1 e/imate h[ _m g5]ations mu/ h pass$ away be=e ! *ildr5 ( a common p>5t came to v>y 9 spee* z mu* z ,*9ese1 ,russians1 ,engli%m51 & cluck+ ,hott5tots4 ,=m "s e/imate ( ! "t requir$ = ! rise & gr[? ( civilization1 n only 9 ! old-_w c5tres ( ,n9eveh & ,babylon & ,egyptian ,!bes1 b 9 ! sep>ate & indep5d5t c5tres ( ,mexico & ,p]u4 ,expla91 moreov]1 :at1 on ! hypo!sis ( a common ,noa*ian desc5t1 mu/ be call$ ! rise & gr[? ( b>b>ism4 ,%[1 if x be possible1 h[1 amid/ ! rapid /rides ( civilization1 side by side ) ! advancem5t ( ta/e1 lit]ature & sci5ce1 ! desc5dants ( ,noah 9 "s cases deg5]at$ f all culture1 sank away f all morality1 lo/ all religion1 =got all useful arts1 ev5 ^? mo/ ess5tial to ! l[e/ degree ( com=t1 ! k9dl+ ( fire1 ! use ( metals1 ! con/ruction ( dwell+s1 :ile !y le>n$ ! habits1 & acquir$ some?+ m ?an ! innoc5t %amelessness ( brutes--le>n$ to pref] ! fle% ( _! own species to any o!r1 le>n$ to make a duty 9 "s regions ( putt+ _! p>5ts to dea?1 9 o!rs1 ( eat+ _! dead bodies4 #bh ,su* cu/oms we h on record f\r c5turies be=e ,*ri/1 su* cu/oms on record z exi/+ n9ete5 c5turies aft]4 ,w any "o attempt to p]suade u t ! savages ( ,&aman & ! ,feejee ,isl&s are c\s9s1 ?r\gh an ance/or no m remote ?an ,noah1 ( ,*a?am & ,wilb]=ce1 & ,lesseps & ,brunel8 ,traditions ( a ,deluge1 x is true1 are f\nd almo/ ev]y:]e4 ,! reason d\btless is t almo/ ev]y:]e "s trem5d\s calamity ( ?is description has at "o "t or ano!r occurr$4 ,inundations on a small scale are common & frequ5t1 b on a scale great en\gh to surprise ! imag9ation & become traditional 9 ! memories ( a p1 !y w\ld naturally be r>e & infrequ5t 9 ! extreme1 s t ! fact ( su* an exp]i5ce belong+ to ! hi/ory ( s _m diff]5t races1 is b ano!r pro(1 or at lea/ ano!r indication1 ( ! antiquity ( man4 ,if /ress is to be laid on ! po9ts ( simil>ity betwe5 ! traditions1 z prov+ t e l& has be5 ravag$ by ! wat]s ( a flood1 equal /ress may 9 fairness be laid on ! po9ts ( diff]5ce1 z prov+ t n "o common univ]sal ,deluge is spok5 (1 b _m sep>ate & p>tial floods1 di/9ct 9 "t1 9 place1 & 9 results4 ,if /ress aga9 is to be laid on ! tradition because x is common to s _m tribes1 let equal importance be grant$ to ! traditions ( "t among ! ,*aldeans & ! ,egyptians1 ! ,*9ese & ! ,h9dus1 :o reckon ! ye>s ( _! un9t]rupt$ hi/ories by t5s ( ?\s&s4 #bi ,f9ally1 we may ask1 :]e are ! traces ( s trem5d\s & unp>allel$ a convulsion z "o t c\ld wrap ! :ole globe 9 wat]1 & hold all its ddal beauty = _m mon?s 9 t dr[n$ condition1 till a tempe/ /ill m furi\s & unp>allel$ drave heav5 & e>?1 ! cl\ds & ocean1 once m asund]8 ,we "k h[ ! little trilobite 9 ! ,devonian seas behav$ 9 its h\r ( p]il millions ( ye>s back2 we "k :at food m5 ate long ages be=e ! ,flood1 :at weapons !y us$1 :at h\ses !y built1 :at animals !y tam$2 b :at became ( man & bea/ & bird & =e/ 9 ! suppos$ univ]sal ,deluge no "o kn[s4 ,! signs & natural monum5ts ( ! cata/rophe1 :i* %\ld h be5 visible or discov]able on e side1 c n[h]e be asc]ta9$1--?+s t ! wat]s %\ld h swept away or torn d[n !y h left undi/urb$1 %ell-m\nds & glaci] mora9es & b\ld]/ones on ! m\nta9side2 :ile ! great museum ( ! dead :i* !y %\ld h =m$1 "o w\ld ?9k1 ov] all ! e>?1 to con/itute "o /rik+ & indisputable geological date1 z well z a _w-wide monum5t ( religion1 is n[h]e to be f\nd4 ,:at became ( fl[] & h]b1 ( creatures t live betwe5 ! zones ( high & l[ wat]1 ( mollusk & coral & fi% t require an appropriate dep? & a fitt+ temp]ature 9 _! liquid homes1 x w be useless to speculate1 if1 aft] all t has be5 urg$ ^u o!r po9ts1 !re are "s :o /ill ?9k t ! description 9 ,g5esis is ! description ( a ,flood t prevail$ ov] all ! _w1 & int5d /ill to believe 9 su* a ,flood1 & to tea* x z a "p ( religi\s doctr9e1 not)/&+ any argum5t or sci5tific pro( to ! contr>y4 ,= !m we c d no m ?an comm5d to _! daily reflection a few l9es f ! lives ( two fam\s m53--#8,9 spite1' says ,dr4 ,wilson1' alike ( ! sci5ce & ! dev\t religi\s _s ( ,columbus1 ! ,salamanca div9es pron\nc$ ! idea ( ! e>?'s sph]ical =m het]odox1 & a belief 9 antipodes incompatible ) ! hi/orical traditions ( our fai?3 s9ce to ass]t t !re 7 inhabit$ l&s on ! opposite side ( ! globe1 w\ld be to ma9ta9 t !re 7 nations n desc5d$ f ,adam1 x be+ impossible = !m to h pass$ ! int]v5+ ocean4 ,?is w\ld !re=e be to discr$it ! ,bible1 :i* expressly decl>es t all m5 are desc5d$ f "o common p>5t4' #ca;a ,& ?us ano!r au?or describes a well-kn[n incid5t 9 ! life ( ,galileo3--#8,clad 9 a p5it5t's sackclo?1 ! mighty1 self-rely+ philosoph] & g5ius fell ^u 8 knees1 &1 ) 8 h&s laid on ! ,holy ,evangeli/s1 decl>$ t he abjur$1 dete/$1 & w\ld nev] aga9 tea* ! doctr9e ( ! sun's /ability & ! e>?'s motion4 ,hav+ confirm$ 8 oa? 9 writ+1 & promis$ to p]=m ! enjo9$ p5ance1 he rose f 8 knees a p>don$ man2 & turn+ ab\t to "o ( 8 fri5ds1 /amp$ on ! gr\nd & pron\nc$ 9 an emphatic :isp]1 8,eppure si muove10 #ca;b--b /ill x does move4' ,z ! antipodes exi/1 z ! e>? goes r\nd ! sun1 & z ! ,bible cont9ues to be true1 9 spite ( ! !ologians & inquisitors at ,salamanca & at ,rome1 s w x cont9ue to be true & full ( tru?1 :5 at l5g? x %all be ackn[l$g$1 z x w be1 t !re is no?+ univ]sal ab\t ! ,noa*ian ,deluge except ! disbelief 9 its univ]sality4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,by ,,! ,,rev4 ,t4 ,r4 ,r4 ,,/ebb+4 ,,d>w9ism3 ,a ,lecture deliv]$ be=e ! ,torquay ,natural ,hi/ory ,society1 ,feb4 #a/1 #ahfi4 ,london3 ,simpk91 ,m>%all & ,co4 ,ox=d3 ,t4 & ,g4 ,%rimpton4 ,torquay3 ,e4 ,cockrem1 #aj1 ,/r&4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,long9us ,,on ,,! ,,sublime4 ,a ,translation4 ,) ,illu/rative ,passages f ,engli% ,au?ors4 ,ox=d3 ,t & ,g4 ,%rimpton4 ,london3 ,:ittak] & ,co4 ,cambridge3 ,hall & ,son4 ,price #es4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,ev5tide3 ,a ,book ( ,pray] = ! ,s*oolroom4 ,london3 ,bell & ,daldy4 ,,footnotes4 #af ,lyell1 ,pr9ciples ( ,geology1 ii4 #ccb4 #ag ,lyell1 ii #cdd4 #ai ,lyell1 ii4 #ccf4 #bj #8,! ,malay ,ar*ipelago1' vol4 ii4 p4 #ddh4 #bc #8,g5esis ( ! ,e>? & ( ,man1' p4 #aag2 quot$ 9 ,sir ,j4 ,lubbock's #8,prehi/oric ,times1' p4 #cad4 #bf;a ,a religi\s & supremely or?odox poet ( ! la/ c5tury enquires1 #8,:]e is ! du/ t has n be5 alive8'--,"y1 #8,night ,?\ghts1' ,night ,,ix4 l4 #hg4 #bf;b #8,mu%rooms & ,toad/ools4'--,wor?+ton ,e4 ,smi?1 p4 #ag4 #bg;a #8,g5esis ( ! ,e>? & ( ,man1' pp4 #aac1 #aad4 #bg;b ,g5esis1 *ap4 xi4 #bh ,sir ,john ,lubbock1 #8,prehi/oric ,times1' pp4 #cch1 #cdf1 #deb2 ,h]odotus1 iv4 #bf4 #bi ,see ,mill's #8,hi/ory ( ,briti% ,india1' book ii4 *4 i4 & notes4 #ca;a #8,prehi/oric ,man1' ,dr4 ,daniel ,wilson1 p4 #aja4 #ca;b #8,! ,daught] ( ,galileo1' by ! au?or ( #8,m>y ,p[ell1' p4 #bhc4