,transcrib$ f ! #ahda ,j4 ,s4 ,g[+ edition by ,david ,price4 ,a ,,lett] ,,to ,,! ,,rev4 ,,*>les ,n4 ,,wodeh\se1 ,,canon ,,( ,,norwi*1 ,,occasion$ ,,by ,,8 ,,rec5t ,,publication1 ,,entitl$1 8,,:at ,,is ,,! ,,mean+ ,,( ,,subscription80 ,,) ,a ,,few ,,obs]vations ,,on ,,! ,,spee* c4 ,,( ,,! ,,"l ,,bi%op ,,( ,,norwi*1 ,,on ,,subscription4 ,,by ,,! ,,rev4 ,,*>les ,,campbell1 ,,vic> ,,( ,,weas5ham4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,london3 ,j4 ,g4 ,,& ,f4 ,,riv+ton4 ,,mat*ett1 ,,/ev5son1 ,,& ,,mat*ett1 ,,norwi*2 ,,& ,j4 ,s4 ,,g[+1 ,,swaffham4 #ahda4 ,price ,two ,%ill+s4 99 99 99 99 99 8,! ,liturgy ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& ha? advantages1 s _m & s consid]able1 z n only to raise itself above ! devotions ( o!r ,*ur*es1 b to ende> ! affections ( all good p to be 9 love ) ,liturgies 9 g5]al 4 4 4 ,! ,rubrics ( x 7 wrote 9 ! blood ( "s ( ! compil]s1 m5 fam\s 9 _! g5]ation1 ^: reputation & glory ( m>tyrdom1 ha? made x immode/ = ! be/ ( m5 n[ to comp>e !mselves ) !m4 ,& its composure is s admirable1 t ! mo/ indu/ri\s arts ( its enemies c sc>ce f9d out an objection ( value en\gh to make a d\bt1 or sc>ce a scruple 9 a s]i\s _s 4 4 4 ,!re are also 9 ! ,(fices =ms ( solemn ,absolution & ,b5$iction1 & if !y be n highly consid]able1 !re is no?+ sacr$ 9 ! ,evangelical ,m9i/ry1 b ! ,alt>s !mselves are made ( unhall[$ turf40 ,bi%op ,j]emy ,taylor4 ,a ,,lett]1 ,,etc4 ,,de> ,,sir1 ,x 0 hop$ t ! little excitem5t occasion$ by ! debate ( la/ ,session on a petition to ! ,h\se ( ,lords = "s alt]ation ( our ,articles & ,liturgy1 _h be5 suff]$ to subside2 & x 0 ) regret we receiv$ ! ann\ncem5t ( y\r rec5t publication1 entitl$ 8,:at is ! mean+ ( ,subscription80 ,i am n aw>e t any ( ! cl]gy ( ?is ,diocese1 dur+ ! la/ n9e ye>s1 t is f ! date ( y\r fir/ publication on ?is subject1 namely1 8,a ,petition to ! ,h\se ( ,lords = ,ecclesia/ical ,improvem5ts ) ,explanations10 h %ewn any disposition to int]m$dle ) y\r proce$+s1 or to 8condemn y = do+ ! be/ y c\ld 9 y\r own cause10 s+ul> z !y may h ?\ght1 & s+ul> z y admit to h be5 8! mode adopt$ by y to obta9 y\r object40 #a ,:atev] !y may h ?\ght1 !y h hi!rto be5 sil5t1 influ5c$ ,i am p]suad$ m by feel+s ( respect = y\r p]sonal "*1 ?an f conviction ( ! /r5g? ( y\r position & ! consequ5t weakness ( _! own4 ,i c answ] = myself1 & ,i am satisfi$ t ,i am speak+ ! g5]al s5se ( ! cl]gy ( ! ,diocese1 9 say+ t !y n only c\ld1 b _h x be5 f any circum/ances necess>y1 w\ld h borne _! ready & will+ te/imony to ! tru? & fai?fulness ( ! eulogy pron\nc$ by y\r ,diocesan on y\r 8"* & conduct z a cl]gyman & a g5tleman40 ,!y mu/ naturally !re=e be ! m incl9$ to wi% t x _h consi/$ ) y\r views to /op %ort ( a public av[al t y c\ld n ) any reg>d = 8tru? & hone/y10 make ! decl>ation to :i* !y hesitate n ex animo to subscribe4 ,ri*>d ,baxt] has said1 8t _m are apt to ?9k t ?is is "r1 because ! be/ & /ricte/ p are ( ?is m9d40 #b;a ,) 8_m0 !re=e1 y\r op9ions w h _! weight2 & if ! ,subscription ( ! cl]gy is to be judg$ by y\r views ( x1 _! situation w\ld seem to be any ?+ b an enviable "o4 ,& z ^! y\r views mu/ seem to be /rongly corroborat$ by ! cong5ial s5tim5ts ( our ,diocesan2 %\ld ,i 9 ! c\rse ( ! foll[+ obs]vations1 :i* ,i take ! lib]ty ( address+ to y1 haz>d also a few rem>ks ^u 8 ,lord%ip's reasons = deem+ an ,expansion ( ,subscription desirable2 ,i tru/ ,i %all f9d t ,i h n be5 misl$ by y\r example1 b t to me also1 8x may be all[$ to diff] f my sup]iors )\t disrespect or (f5ce40 #b;b ,all[ me !n1 to express my regret1 t 8res dura et regni novitas10 z y may apply ! royal excuse to y\r own novel position1 %\ld h compell$ y to resort 9 y\r own case to a c\rse y s decid$ly object to 9 o!rs2 m especially z y appe> to h _h y\r misgiv+s1 to h =ese5 ! possibility ( 8h>m accru+ f x10 & v ju/ly to h anticipat$ t ! p]usal ( a publication writt5 ) ! object y appe> to h _h 9 view1 w\ld 8call =? a pa9ful feel+ 9 ! m9ds ( ,*ri/ians & ,*ur*m540 #c;a 8,no "o10 y say1 8c object m decid$ly ?an y\rself to ! common practice ( publi%+ correspond5ce betwe5 individuals on matt]s relat+ m]ely to !mselves40 #c;b ,b ! practice is usually resort$ to by o!rs1 z x seems to h be5 by y\rself1 "u an impression t ! publication is 9 "s way or o!r 8important to _! own def5ce40 #c;c ,y w\ld h[ev]1 & naturally en\gh1 p]suade y\rself t y\rs is 8a v diff]5t case10 a case 8relat+ /rictly to a public "q1 "o affect+ ! :ole ,*ur*1 & inde$ all ,*ri/ians 9 ! nation40 #c;d ,i w n /ay to enquire :e!r view+ x 9 ?is light1 ! voice ( ! ,*ur* ought n to h be5 he>d above y\r own4 ,b ,i mu/ ?9k t some?+ m ?an y h advanc$ is requisite to con/itute a public "q1 & enable u to see ! diff]5ce betwe5 y\r own case & t ( o!rs1 8:o publi% correspond5ce on matt]s relat+ m]ely to !mselves40 ,x is true t y\r case has be5 publicly discuss$ 9 p>liam5t1 & s has ! case ( _m ano!r individual2 b ,i mu/ ?9k a di/9ction is to be drawn betwe5 a p]son dragg+ 8 own affairs be=e ! public & a public affair2 & any weight t y w\ld atta* to ! discussion y allude to1 z giv+ to y\r case ! "* & importance ( a public "q1 may p]haps be less5$ by a consid]ation ( ! mann] 9 :i* t discussion 0 br\ght ab\t4 ,! ,bi%op ( ,l9coln rose1 n to ! "q1 b 8at ! p>ticul> desire ( ! ,rev4 ,mr4 ,wodeh\se10 wi%+ to h 8 case br\ght into notice2 ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* said t he 8%\ld n h ris51 _h n ! "n ( ! ,rev4 ,mr4 ,wodeh\se be5 introduc$20 & ! ,bi%op ( ,london 8w\ld n h ent]$ into ! discussion1 _h x n be5 = "s obs]vations :i* _h escap$ f ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi*40 ,no temporal ,pe] rose4 ,/rictly relat+ !n z y w\ld consid] y\r case to be a public "q1 !re appe>$ b little indication ( its be+ s consid]$ by ! ,h\se ( ,lords1 & z to ! op9ion ( ! cl]gy1 ! ,bi%op ( ,l9coln obs]v$1 8,i am n aw>e t any g5]al desire = su* alt]ations exi/s1 on ! contr>y1 ,i believe1 t nev] did ! great body ( ! cl]gy deprecate m /rongly any *ange 9 ! ,articles & ,liturgy ?an at ! pres5t mom5t40 ,! discussion h[ev] seems n a little to h disquiet$ y--b hav+ rais$ ! :irlw9d1 ?\gh y h fail$ to guide x--ought y n to h be5 less impati5t ( ! /orm8 ,l5it] ex m]ito quicquid pati>e f]5dum e/4 ,x is difficult to believe t on calm] reflection1 a m9d l y\rs w exp]i5ce no uneas9ess at ! recollection ( hav+ endeav\r$ to turn an int5d$ k9dness to ! prejudice ( ^? :o _h conf]r$ x1 & 9 t light all mu/ view ! evid5t wi% on ! p>ts ( ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury1 & ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 to resolve y\r d\bts1 & z f> z _! private op9ions c\ld avail--re/ore peace to y\r m9d4 ,i allude to ! use y h made ( private conv]sations1 ,i say private1 = up to a c]ta9 "t y appe> to h s consid]$ ! op9ions t 7 !n giv5 y4 8,i h be5 fav\r$10 y say 9 a lett] to "o ( ! ,bi%ops1 8) ! private op9ions ( _m p]sons ,i am b\nd to respect40 #e;a ,i admit t = y\r fur!r satisfaction y receiv$ p]mission to m5tion1 or z y say 8make kn[n :at pass$ at ^! int]views40--,/ill1 al?\gh x w\ld h made no diff]5ce z to ! p]mission grant$1 _h !y ev5 contemplat$ su* a circum/ance2 ,i suspect t ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury & ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 mu/ h felt a little surpris$ to f9d t _! e ^w _h /raitly be5 obs]v$-- ,set 9 a note book1 conn'd & got by rote1 ,to ca/ into _! tee?--elev5 ye>s aft]w>ds6 ,yet1 by ! aid alone ( ^! communications1 y h endeav\r$ to fix ^u ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury & ! ,bi%op ( ,london ! foll[+ *>ge1 namely1 8t 9 ! debate ( ! #bf? ( ,may1 #ahdj1 8 ,grace ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury & ! ,bi%op ( ,london m decid$ly endeav\r$ to cru% ! v idea ( ! same latitude1 :i* !y _h on o!r occasions mo/ unequivocally all[$ & approv$40 #e;b ,i hesitate n = a mom5t to say t x is a *>ge unsupport$ ev5 by ! %ad[ ( a pro(4 ,& let u fir/ exam9e y\r evid5ce z x be>s ^u ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury4 ,! po9ts to :i* y direct our att5tion 9 sub/antiation ( y\r *>ge are ^!3--,8 ,grace's conv]sation 9 ,may1 #ahbi--;8 lett]s ( ,may #ab1 #ahcj--;& ,m>* #ah1 #ahdj--;& 8 spee* 9 ! debate on ! ,petition4 ,9 8 lett] ( ,m>* #ah1 #ahdj1 8 ,grace says1 8,i %all be mu* surpris$ if expressions are f\nd 9 any lett] ( m9e1 :i* c be consid]$ z an int5d$ ju/ification ( y\r op9ions10 an obs]vation at v>iance1 z y h p]suad$ y\rself ) 8 lett] ( #ahcj1 & 8 conv]sation ) y 9 #ahbi4 ,9 ! fir/ place ,i w\ld submit t a di/9ction obta9s betwe5 n condemn+ an op9ion & int5d+ to ju/ify x4 ,x is possible t 8 ,grace may take high] views ( ! p[] committ$ to ! /ew>ds ( ! my/]ies ( ,god ?an y d4 ,b agree+ p]haps ) y t 8! p[] ( ! keys0 _c z y h else:]e obs]v$1 be 8beyond a d\bt def9$40 #f;a ,8 ,grace might be unwill+ to condemn y\r l[] views1 b y c\ld sc>cely h con/ru$ ?is into an int5d$ ju/ification ( !m4 ,he _h besides told y 8t ! abs5ce ( c5sure did n imply a tacit acquiesc5ce 9 y\r op9ions40 #f;b ,b :at 0 ! latitude :i* 8 ,grace ?\ght fairly all[able1 & h[ f> w x ju/ify y 9 say+ t 9 8 spee* he endeav\r$ to cru% ! v idea ( t same latitude be+ all[$8 ,y\r conv]sation ) 8 ,grace seems to h turn$ on ! ?ree po9ts m5tion$ 9 y\r petition1--! ,a?anasian ,cre$1 ! ,absolution1 & ! words us$ 9 a "p ( ! ,ord9ation ,s]vice4 ,^u y\r m5tion+ ! diff]5t op9ions giv5 by v>i\s em95t writ]s ( our *ur* z to ! ,a?anasian ,cre$ & its condemnatory clauses1 8 ,grace obs]v$1 8,well--none ( ^! op9ions has be5 condemn$1 take :i*ev] suits y\r own views1 & be satisfi$40 #g;a ,b y _c be satisfi$1 & al?\gh repeat$ly told by 8 ,grace1 & also by ! ,bi%op ( ,l9coln1 t y c\ld n1 s long z ,convocation rema9$ 9 abeyance1 obta9 ! au?oritative s5se ( ! ,*ur* on ^! po9ts1 y p]si/ 9 press+ = x4 ,to a reque/ to ?is effect convey$ 9 a lett] to 8 ,grace1 y aga9 ref] to ! subject ( y\r conv]sation4 ,to ?is 8 ,grace replies1 8,) respect to ! subject ( y\r lett]1 ,i h only to ref] y to our =m] conv]sation1 9 :i* ,i express$ an op9ion t1 on po9ts :]e writ]s ( em95ce h diff]$ )\t slur on _! or?odoxy1 a c]ta9 latitude ( int]pretation is fairly all[able4 ,b ) respect to ! au?oritative s5se ( ! ,*ur* on ! po9ts m5tion$ 9 y\r petition1 no individual has a "r to decl>e x1 if x is a matt] ( d\bt3 & if1 dur+ a long succession ( ye>s1 "s diff]5ce ( op9ion is f\nd among writ]s em95t = le>n+ & piety1 ! sil5ce ( ! ,*ur*1 "u su* circum/ances1 may be tak5 z an indication ( h] unwill+ness to abridge ! lib]ty ( h] memb]s on ^! po9ts40 #g;b ,i c see no?+ "h l an int5d$ ju/ification ( y\r op9ions4 ,8 ,grace w\ld give y x appe>s no decision 9 private1 he n[h]e l$ y to inf] t he ev5 approv$ ( y\r op9ions1 & c\ld h>dly h int5d$ y to conclude t he meant to ju/ify !m4 ,he tells y 8he c\ld n see h[ y\r position w\ld be m5d$ by an op5 decl>ation ( 8 op9ion1 ev5 if fav\rable to t exposition :i* w\ld suit y\r views10 #h :i* seems at lea/ to imply a d\bt1 & :]e !re is a d\bt1 ! judge usually directs ! jury to give ! prison] ! b5efit ( x1 b ?is does n involve ! judge's approval or int5d$ ju/ification ( ! prison]'s case4 ,yet ?is is all t 8 ,grace admitt$1--& to :at _h ?is admission a ref]5ce8 ,to a c]ta9 latitude ( int]pretation all[able "u c]ta9 circum/ances4 ,& ,i ?9k ,i c safely defy y to po9t out a solit>y expression 9 8 ,grace's spee* on ! #bf? ( ,may1 #ahdj1 9 :i* he attempts to evade ?is admission1 or1 9 ! language ( y\r accusation1 8endeav\rs to cru% ! v idea ( ! same latitude :i* on o!r occasions he _h unequivocally all[$ & approv$40 ,8 ,grace's approval h[ev] is n[h]e app>5t4 ,8 ,grace addresses himself 9 8 spee* to ! pray] ( ! petition1 8:i* he appreh5ds _! ,lord%ips w n c\nt5ance 9 ! lea/ degree40 ,& :at is ! pray]8 8,x prays1 among/ o!r ?+s1 y\r ,lord%ips to consid] :at measures ought to be adopt$ to make ! ,pray] ,book & ! ,subscription ( ! ,liturgy consonant ) ! practice ( ! cl]gy1 & ! ackn[l$g$ mean+ ( ! ,articles ( ! *ur*40 ,& :at is ! imput$ practice ( ! cl]gy8 ,accord+ to ! /atem5t ( ! petition]s x is _! 8g5]al practice to deviate f ! au?oris$ =ms & positive obligations ( ! ,*ur*10--:5 ) ref]5ce to y\r own case1 ! ?ree po9ts on :i* y consult$ 8 ,grace1 y c prove t to deviate f or omit ! ,a?anasian ,cre$--! ,absolution--& ! words us$ at ! ,imposition ( ,h&s--is ! same latitude1 :i* ) ref]5ce to _! int]pretation1 he _h ?\ght fairly all[able4--,y may !n boa/ t y h convict$ ! ,spiritual ,head ( ! ,*ur* ( inconsi/5cy & duplicity1 & no "o w attempt to controv]t y\r ins9uation t 8 ,grace 8has "o op9ion at ,lambe?1 & ano!r 9 ! ,h\se ( ,lords40 #i;a ,y\r *>ge z x affects ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 re/s on simil> evid5ce4 ,8 ,lord%ip's conv]sation 9 #ahbi--;a lett] ( #ahcj--;& 8 spee* 9 #ahdj4 ,y consult$ 8 ,lord%ip 9 #ahbi on ! same subjects1 & receiv$ 9 sub/ance ! same reply z _h be5 giv5 to y by ! ,ar*bi%op4 ,& ,i c z confid5tly defy y to po9t out 9 8 ,lord%ip's spee* 9 #ahdj1 a passage t c give any col\r+ ( ju/ice to y\r *>ge2 unless y c %ew t to deprecate an alt]ation ( our ,articles & ,liturgy is ! same ?+ z to admit t c]ta9 p>ts ( !m may be> a diff]5ce ( int]pretation1 or %[ t !re is no diff]5ce betwe5 an exi/+ 8ela/icity0 & a fur!r 8expansion40 ,y\r evid5ce !n1 if any:]e1 mu/ be f\nd 9 8 ,lord%ip's lett] ( #ahcj4 ,! lett] ( :i* y compla9 to ! ,ar*bi%op z 8unk9d & inconsi/5t ) =m] advice40 #i;b ,b z y seem to me to h conv]s$ ) 8 ,lord%ip on "o subject1 & to h writt5 to him1 ! foll[+ ye>1 ^u ano!r1 ,i d n see h[ y make x appe> t 8 ,lord%ip's lett] 0 inconsi/5t ) 8 =m] advice4 ,x does n appe> t y _h ask$ 8 ,lord%ip 89 :at s5se y w\ld be expect$ to subscribe0 9 future1 b :e!r hav+ subscrib$1 c]ta9 op9ions :i* y _h tak5 up1 7 consi/5t ) y\r ,subscription4 ,8 ,lord%ip ?\ght t !y 74 ,b n9e mon?s aft]w>ds1 on be+ call$ ^u to r5ew y\r ,subscription1 y in=m 8 ,lord%ip t y _h det]m9$ n to make x aga9 b ) a sort ( prote/4--,by ,subscription1 y are call$ ^u to decl>e t 8! ,book ( ,common ,pray] & ( ord]+ ,bi%ops1 ,prie/s1 & ,deacons1 conta9e? 9 x no?+ contr>y to ! ^w ( ,god1 & t ! ,articles are agreeable to x30 b to ?is y w n ass5t1 unless y may at ! same "t be p]mitt$ to decl>e t y d n believe x4 ,y mu/ expla91 y tell 8 ,lord%ip1 ! s5se 9 :i* y %all h no objection to subscribe1 & t ?r\gh ! m$ium ( a petition to p>liam5t4 ,n[ !re appe>s no?+ 9 y\r report ( ! conv]sation to lead to ! inf]5ce1 nor c ,i easily br+ myself to ?9k t 8 ,lord%ip c\ld h l$ y to inf] t a qualifi$ ,subscription 0 admissible ei!r f c&idates = ord]s1 or o!r cl]gym54 ,a diff]5t exposition ( ! g5]al doctr9e laid d[n 9 sev]al ( our ,articles1 may be fairly all[able2 ! lett] ( our ,liturgy may 9 sev]al p>ts admit ( a diff]5t int]pretation1 & if tak+ our own views ( ^! po9ts1 believ+ !m n inconsi/5t ) an all[able int]pretation ( ! words1 we c unres]v$ly subscribe1 well & good--b = my own "p1 ,i %\ld sc>cely expect x ( a ,bi%op to receive a qualifi$ ,subscription f me1 ! prec$5t ,i mu/ ?9k w\ld be a bad "o1 & ! practice subv]sive ( ! v object ( ,subscription1 indep5d5t ( ! awkw>d ackn[l$gem5t x involves1 t our ,*ur* exacts f h] memb]s a =m ( ,subscription1 :i* _c be made )\t a salvo4 ,y sc>cely c\ld h inf]r$ f 8 ,lord%ip's advice1 t he 8unequivocally all[$ & approv$ ( ?is latitude40 ,b z he _h told y t he ?\ght y\r int]pretation ( c]ta9 po9ts admissible1 & t y might op5ly hold y\r op9ions1 y might h inf]r$ t he also consid]$ !m consi/5t ) an 8unres]v$ ,subscription1 & t accord+ to ! lit]al s5se ( ! words0--= ! "q is1 w n ! lit]al s5se ( ! words be> a diff]5t application8 ,y subscribe unres]v$ly1 at lea/ y h giv5 u no reason to suppose o!rwise1 to ! ,apo/les' ,cre$1 9 :i* we are told t ,*ri/ sitte? at ! "r h& ( ,god1 b ! lit]al mean+ ( ! words is at v>iance ) ! tru?1 t 8,god is )\t body1 p>ts1 or passions40 #aa ,i mu/ ?9k t y h conjur$ up a great] difficulty on ! score ( ,subscription ?an 9 reality obta9s4 ,at all ev5ts y mu/ detail "s fur!r p>ticul>s ( 8 ,lord%ip's conv]sation1 be=e y w enable u to detect its discrepancy ) ! subject ( 8 subsequ5t lett]4 ,b if 8 ,lord%ip's private op9ion on ! all[able int]pretation ( ! po9ts on :i* y consult$ him1 fail$ to remove y\r d\bts & scruples1 & y 7 aft] all fully p]suad$ 9 y\r own m9d t ! words 9 "q c\ld by no possibility be> ! only int]pretation ) :i* y c\ld consci5ti\sly subscribe to !m2 ,i _c see h[ ! op5 sanction ( ! ,*ur* c\ld affect y to ! 8eas+ ( y\r consci5ce40 ,= surely if ! words w n be> a c]ta9 s5se1 ! ,*ur* _c make !m--! sanction ( all ! ,bi%ops 9 ,*ri/5dom c\ld nev] make black mean :ite4 ,if y are ( op9ion t x c\ld1 = a ,prote/ant y mu/ ent]ta9 r high views ( ! p[] ( ! ,*ur*--& yet su* w\ld seem to be y\r op9ion1 = 9 ! 8,circul>0 :i* y s5t a day or two be=e ! pres5tation ( ! petition la/ ye>1 to 8all ! ,pe]s ^: ,london resid5ces c\ld be asc]ta9$20 aft] allud+ to ^! op9ions :i* y _h receiv$ f ! ,ar*bi%op & ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 y say1 8my answ] 01 if su* be ! case1 let ^! /atem5ts be op5ly sanction$1 & ,i am cont5t4 ,b ,i _c ) tru? & hone/y subscribe1 n accord+ to ! lit]al mean+ ( ! words1 unless su* latitude be au?oris$ by ! ,*ur*40 ,n[ if ! ,subscription is /ill to be made to ! same =m ( words1 x is v difficult to see h[ ! au?ority ( ! ,*ur* c imp>t to !m a mean+1 to :i* )\t t au?ority tru? & hone/y w\ld =bid y to subscribe4 ,if y d n take c>e1 ! ,editors ( ! ,ox=d ,tracts w m>k y = _! own1 9 spite ( y\rself4 ,b 9 :at position d y n[ /&8 ,y h done :at y in=m$ ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 y c\ld 8n be com=table )\t do+40 ,y h made kn[n to ! _w1 & t by ! means y propos$ to y\rself1 namely1 a petition to p>liam5t1 :at y\r op9ions are1 & ! _w int]f]es n ) !m1 nor does ! ,*ur* condemn !m2 y h only !re=e to arrange ! matt] ) y\r own consci5ce--if t condemns y1 y\r c\rse is a cle> "o4 ,b :y %\ld x condemn y m = ! next f\rte5 ye>s1 ?an x w\ld seem to h done = ! la/ f\rte58 ,dur+ t "t y h held y\r pref]m5t ) y\r op9ions1 & :y %\ld y n cont9ue to hold y\r op9ions ) y\r pref]m5t8 ,y tell u t y\r object 0 elev5 ye>s ago to 8asc]ta9 ) c]ta9ty :e!r y held any op9ion :i* ! ,*ur* condemn$40 #ac ,y 7 in=m$ t ! au?oritative s5se ( ! ,*ur* on ! po9ts y wi%$ = in=mation c\ld n 9 ! abeyance ( ,convocation be obta9$2 b y 7 at ! same "t told1 & t1 by _m ^: op9ions probably w\ld h _h great weight 9 ,convocation _h x be5 imm$iately conv5$ = y\r satisfaction1 t !y consid]$ y\r op9ions all[able1 t ! ,*ur* did n condemn !m2 & ,i ?9k x w\ld h be5 a reasonable inf]5ce ) :i* to h quiet$ y\r consci5ce1 t _h ! ,convocation be5 assembl$1 ! au?oritative s5se ( ! ,*ur* w\ld n h be5 aga9/ y4 ,& c]ta9 passages 9 y\r m9i/]ial c>e] _h l$ u to hope & to inf] t y _h come to t conclusion1 t hav+ unbur!n$ y\r m9d1 y 7 at re/4 ,= 9 #ahcf1 y pres5t$ a second petition to ! ,h\se ( ,lords1 b f t "t1 z f> at lea/ z we c\ld judge f y\r proce$+s1 y seem$ to h giv5 up y\r pursuit1 at all ev5ts1 x appe>s t y re/$ ^u y\r o>s till #ahdj4 ,& 9 ! int]im1 9 ! ye> #ahcg1 aft] hav+ ab/a9$ = "s ye>s1 & 9 consequ5ce z x 0 suppos$ ( y\r scruples1 we saw y aga9 volunt>ily com+ =w>d1 & 9 y\r "* ( a ,presbyt]1 (ficiat+ at ! c]emony ( ! ,imposition ( ,h&s1 co-op]at+ ) ! ,bi%op dur+ ! recital ( ! v words at :i* y\r consci5ce _h tak5 su* al>m1 & ) respect to :i* 9 y\r =m] petition1 8y _h humbly & e>ne/ly pray$ t su* /eps might be tak5 z %\ld seem good to _! ,lord%ips1 9 ord] to effect ^? alt]ations 9 ! ,liturgy :i* w\ld relieve ! consci5ce ( _! petition]40 #ad;a ,& we _h also subsequ5tly read ! resolution y _h come to1 & delib]ately publi%$ 9 #ahch4 ,9 a note to a s]mon :i* y publi%$ 9 t ye>1 y say1 8,9 ! abs5ce ( all au?oritative c5sure1 ,i conclude z _m o!rs d1 t a sil5t *ange has tak5 place1 #8f ! div]sity ( times & m5's mann]s4' ,9 t conclusion ,i abide1 repeat+ :at ,i h (t5 said1 t :5ev] ,i am pron\nc$ wrong on au?ority1 ,i am ready to meet ! consequ5ces40 #ad;b ,i c myself say1 & ,i am sure t all :o h _h any opportunity ( kn[+ y1 w say x ) ! same s9c]ity1 9 t conclusion we mo/ he>tily wi% t y w\ld abide--t y w\ld cont9ue to dis*>ge y\r pa/oral duties1 y\r delib]ate & solemnly accept$ engagem5ts to ! 8,*ief ,%eph]d0 9 ! same exempl>y mann] t has m>k$ y\r hi!rto c>e]1 until y are pron\nc$ wrong on au?ority--or call$ f y\r /ew>d%ip to r5d] up y\r acc\nt ) joy4 ,9 :at e/imation y may hold ! op9ions ( y\r bro!r petition]s1 ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 ,i "k n1 b !y say1 8,our cl]gy _c leave ! ,*ur*--_! ord9ation v[s are ^u !m40 ,& besides1 my de> sir1 to ru% ^u m>tyrdom 9 ! abs5ce ( all p]secution1 or1 z f> z ! public c see1 any app>5t necessity1 w at be/ obta9 = y b an ,emp$oclean sort ( fame4 ,& z no?+ has occurr$ s9ce y publi%$ y\r resolution 9 #ahch1 to affect y\r situation diff]5tly f :at x _h be5 = n9e or t5 ye>s be=e1 save ! failure ( ano!r petition2 %\ld y resign 9 consequ5ce ( t circum/ance1 x w\ld look almo/ z if y resign$ m]ely to spite ! ,ar*bi%op4 ,b "u ! little difficulty t exi/s ( asc]ta9+ ) any c]ta9ty :at y\r int5tions h be51 or ev5 n[ are1 we e>ne/ly tru/ !y may n result 9 ! alt]native ( a resignation1 to :i* 9 ! c\rse ( y\r correspond5ce y h made su* frequ5t allusions4 8,an alt]native10 :i* z ,bi%op ,heb] says1 8x is easy to sugge/ 9 ! case ( a bro!r1 b :i* e man 9 8 own case receives ) difficulty40 #ae;a ,a few days be=e ! pres5tation ( ! la/ petition y wrote to 8 ,grace ?us1 8,if ,i fail on ?is occasion 4 4 4 ,i consid] myself pl$g$ to resign my pref]m5t40 #ae;b ,! result ( t petition 0 unfav\rable4 ,b t5 mon?s aft]w>ds1 t is1 9 y\r la/ publication1 y call ^u 8 ,grace to pron\nce t judgm5t :i* he _h told y he 80 unwill+ to pron\nce on scruples :i* he hop$ "t might remove10 #ae;c--8& %\ld t judgm5t require su* a /ep1 y w ) ,god's p]mission resign next ,decemb]1 unless a cle> expression ( public op9ion %\ld int]v5e appeal+ aga9/ ! judgm5t pron\nc$40 #ae;d ,let u hope !n t y w abide 9 ?is y\r late/ resolution1 = ,i ?9k f ! evid5ce ) :i* y h furni%$ u1 we may v5ture to conclude t no su* judgm5t w be pron\nc$ z %all call = any expression ( public op9ion4 ,i %all n[ proce$ to haz>d a few obs]vations on ! reasons assign$ by ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* 9 fav\r ( an ,expansion ( ,subscription1 see+ t !y are consid]$ by _m s /rongly to confirm ! correctness ( y\r own views1 & z y h told u t y _c consi/5tly ) tru? & hone/y make ! requir$ ,subscription1 we _c b appreh5d t 9 ! proportion t ^? views are believ$ to be sub/antial & correct1 ! "* ( ! cl]gy mu/ be prejudic$1 at all ev5ts 9 ! eyes ( ^?1 :o unwill+ or unable to inve/igate ! matt] = !mselves1 take up ! op9ions ( o!rs1 & arriv+ ?r\gh !m at a coroll>y ( _! own1 hesitate n to g z f> z to decl>e t 8all ! cl]gy are p]jur$40 ,z ,i c devise no bett]1 ,i %all pursue ! plan y h adopt$ ) respect to ! spee* ( ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 t is1 giv+ su* extracts f 8 ,lord%ip's spee* z be> ^u ! subject ( ,subscription1 ) a runn+ comm5t ( my own4 ,i w n h[ev]1 introduce my rem>ks ) ! preface y h affix$ to y\r 8pla9 /ory10--giv+ u to und]/& t x is int5d$ to be 8a refutation ( almo/ e /atem5t 9 ! ,bi%op ( ,london's spee*40 #af ,le/ hav+ l$ my read]s to exclaim ,quid dignum tanto f]et hic promissor hiatu4 ,i %\ld leave !m to conclude t ,i _h be5 lab\r+ "u :at ! faculty1 ,i believe1 t]m 8a false conception40 ,8 ,lord%ip's fir/ reason = wi%+ = a m exp&$ ,subscription1 is t-- 8,,if x be true t !re is any?+ approa*+ to ! appe>ance ( ins9c]ity on ! "p ( ^? mak+ ! ,subscription1 if we seem to confess ) our lips t we d n confess & believe 9 our he>ts we give our oppon5ts a vantage gr\nd ( :i* !y w n be sl[ to avail !mselves40 ,!re is said to be mu* virtue 9 an ,,if1 & e virtute nos involvissemus1 _h n 8 ,lord%ip torn ! cov]+ away1 & 8left u nak$ to our enemies10--self-convict$ ( 8confess+ ) our lips t we d n confess & believe 9 our he>ts40 ,= says 8 ,lord%ip-- 8,,9 ,,fact1 ) respect to ,subscription1 ,i h nev] yet met ) a s+le cl]gyman 7& ,i h spok5 ) almo/ numb]less individuals on ! subject71 :o ev] all[$ t he agre$ 9 e po9t1 9 e iota to ! ,subscription :i* he took at ord9ation40 ,x w\ld n be treat+ 8 ,lord%ip ) c&\r to give to 8 obs]vation an (f5sive mean+1 :i* x 0 n int5d$ to convey4 ,x is m ) ref]5ce to ! mal-con/ruction & malici\s use ( x by our oppon5ts1 t we are l$ to wi% t x _h n be5 made4 ,s9ce 8 ,lord%ip's subsequ5t pamphlet1 f :i* we collect ! s5se 9 :i* he 0 view+ ,subscription1 :5 he made ! obs]vation1 a s5se 9 :i*1 = in/ance ) ref]5ce to ^? clauses ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$1 :i* are commonly1 & unju/ly1 call$ damnatory1 few ,i suspect d subscribe1 be+1 9 my op9ion1 9 no wise b\nd to an application ( ! clauses1 s manife/ly at v>iance ) ! _s 9 :i* ! =mul>y 0 impos$ on u by our ,re=m]s2--s9ce ,i say1 ?is pamphlet c obta9 b a v small "p ( ! circulation ( ! spee* itself1 :]e ! obs]vation /&s unqualifi$2 ! g5]al impression ( 8 ,lord%ip's mean+ mu/ be t ! cl]gy subscribe ex animo1 to t :i* ex animo !y d n believe4 ,at ! same "t ,i h nev] se5 ! necessity ( respond+ to ^? appeals ?r\gh :i* ! cl]gy ( ?is ,diocese h be5 call$ ^u to take "s public /ep1 to repel ! obs]vation z an impli$ libel ^u !m4 ,i w\ld r x %\ld be rememb]$ t 8 ,lord%ip1 comp>atively speak+1 has be5 b a %ort "t among/ u1 & t = any?+ we c tell1 ! enquiries ( :i* he speaks may h be5 *iefly made among/ ! cl]gy ( ano!r ,diocese1 7inde$1 consid]+ t x is n a likely "q = a ,bi%op to put to c&idates = ,ord]s1 or 8 cl]gy g5]ally1 ! inf]5ce mu/ be t !y 771 & if _! 8)]s %\ld be gall$10 let !m respond to ^! appeals1 8ours are unwrung40 ,x mu/1 h[ev]1 be admitt$ t any ins9c]ity 9 ! matt] ( ,subscription1 w\ld des]v$ly expose u to ! contempt ( our oppon5ts4--,b a g5]\s m9d w\ld %r9k in/9ctively f inf]r+ ins9c]ity f any ?+ approa*+ only to its appe>ance4 ,decipimur specie ought to hold ) respect to evil n less ?an good4 ,/ill1 alas6 to ! jaundic$ eye e object pres5ts itself 9 col\rs n its own4 ,& ,i fe> t ! op9ion :i* 8 ,lord%ip w\ld seem to ent]ta9 ( ! actuat+ _s ( our oppon5ts1 is b too well f\nd$1 & amply ju/ifies 8 appreh5sion t !y w\ld n be sl[ to avail !mselves ( ! appe>ance1 c>+ little to dissipate ! 8m5tis gratissimus error10 by asc]ta9+ !mselves ( ! non-exi/5ce ( ! reality4 ,t accompli%$1 b embitt]$ infidel1 ! hi/orian ,gibbon1 did n scruple to decl>e t ! cl]gy1 "o & all ( !m1 made _! ,subscription ei!r 8) a sigh or a smile20 b ,i tru/ t ! cl]gy1 z a body1 c af=d to leave su* oppon5ts 9 ! unmole/$ possession ( _! imag9>y vantage gr\nd4 ,until ,mordecai 0 remov$ f 8 seat at ! gate1 ! s\l ( ,haman c\ld n be quiet$ )9 him--nor w ! s\ls ( our oppon5ts1 until ! ,*ur* is br\ght d[n to a level ) _! own sects4 8,if x 7,subscription7 is to be und]/ood 9 ! lit]al1 mo/ /rict1 & mo/ /r+5t s5se1 x w\ld create difficulties1 :i* mu/ weigh heavily ^u scrupul\s & t5d] consci5ces40 ,b ev5 suppos+ ?is--:]e !re is no compulsion1 !re no viol5ce c be done to ! consci5ce1 & no "o is compell$ to 8ent] ! *ur*10 & 9 us+ ! expression1 ,i confess ,i _c p]ceive ) ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 t x is r$ol5t 8( a v popi% error10 x c]ta9ly means1 z !y obs]ve1 8tak+ ord]s20 & ,i %\ld ?9k t ! la/ p]sons likely to pres5t !mselves to a ,bi%op = t purpose1 w\ld be ^? ^: consci5ces 7 already ov]borne by ! pressure ( _! scruples4 8,t5d]ness ( consci5ce10 says ,bi%op ,j]emy ,taylor1 8is an equivocal t]m1 & does n always signify 9 a good s5se40 #ai ,i am f> f mean+ to impea* ! s9c]ity ( ! petition]s1 b if 8 ,lord%ip appli$ ! t]m 9 any o!r ?an a good s5se1 he might seem to h paid !m b an equivocal complim5t1 & if he us$ x 9 a good s5se ) respect to !m1 ! great body ( ! cl]gy :o h subscrib$1 & felt no pang1 might suspect 8 ,lord%ip ( mean+ to imply t !y 7 gift$ ) consci5ces ( a some:at t\gh] texture ?an is altoge!r to be envi$4 ,"s h *os5 to draw ?is inf]5ce2 ,i w n h[ev] believe t !y h done 8 ,lord%ip's delib]ate s5tim5ts ju/ice 9 s do+4 8,& by cont9u+ ^! difficulties 7( ,subscription7 we %\ld leave ! way op5 only to ^? ^: consci5ces h no scruples1 & :o w\ld ent] ! ,*ur* only ) a view to ! pr(its & secul> advantages40 ,i w\ld submit t a man may ent] ! ,*ur* ) a view to its secul> advantages1 )\t be+ ju/ly involv$ 9 ! suspicion ( ins9c]ity1 or ( necessity1 lay+ himself op5 to ! imputation ( ent]+ x only ) a view to its pr(its4 ,= in/ance1 %\ld a g5tleman h 9 8 gift :at is commonly call$ a family liv+1 he may design x z a provision = a y\ng] son1 :o ent]s ^u a c\rse ( /udy & tra9s himself = ! m9i/ry1 & t )\t necess>ily disc>d+ all view to ! secul> advantages ( 8 pr(ession1 kn[+ t 8!y :i* prea* ! gospel %\ld live ( ! gospel30 b s f> f its foll[+ t he ent]s ! ,*ur* ) no o!r or high] motive2 h[ frequ5tly d we f9d x ! case ) ^? ^: lot has ?us be5 ca/1 z x 71 = !m1 t !y prove n m]ely exempl>y p>i% prie/s1 b ev5tually rise to adorn ! ,episcopal ,b5*4 ,8 ,lord%ip w n object to my adduc+ 8 own successful c>e] z a case 9 po9t4 ,b if su* *>act]s z 8 ,lord%ip speaks (1 c ev5 n[ 9 ! tee? ( all ! imput$ difficulties1 ent] ! *ur*1 if !y be s dispos$1 ,i d n cle>ly see h[ remov+ ^! difficulties w mitigate ! evil--h[ wid5+ ! portal w t5d to ob/ruct ! entrance4 ,nor1 al?\gh x /&s s record$ 9 8 ,lord%ip's spee*1 w ,i believe x to be1 8 delib]ate op9ion1 t by leav+ ! matt] ( ,subscription z x n[ /&s1 we leave ! way op5 only to ^? ^: consci5ces c feel no scruples4 ,if ^! expressions ( 8 ,lord%ip are to be tak5 only 9 a good s5se1 ,i tru/ = ! cr$it ( ! ,*ur* t 8 ,lord%ip is n ! only exception to ! g5]al rule4 ,! ,messrs4 ,hull1 9 _! animadv]sions on ! ,bi%op ( ,london's spee*1 draw a nice di/9ction betwe5 8op5+ ! door10 & 8leav+ x op540 ,9 cases ( burgl>y ,i believe ! di/9ction involves a diff]5ce2 we may v5ture !re=e to haz>d a guess to :i* ( ! bro!rs1 ! lawy] or ! div9e1 we may attribute t contribution to ! jo9t /ock pamphlet4 #ba 8,b !re is an answ] commonly giv51 & a weighty "o1 to ?is objection4 ,! ,*ur* has a sort ( ela/icity :i* all[s & graduates ! diff]5ces t exi/40 ,yet on ! use ( ! ^w 8ela/icity0 by ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 y say1 8,i confess myself entirely unable to di/+ui% betwe5 ! #8expansion' ( ! "o prelate or ! #8ela/icity' ( ! o!r40 #bb;a ,if !re is no diff]5ce betwe5 ! exi/+ ela/icity & ! expansion plead$ =1 = :at boon did ! petition]s pray8 ,i anticipate y\r answ]1 & w reply to x pres5tly4 8,x does n become ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 a ,*ur* f\nd$ on lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t1 to say t !re %all n be a c]ta9 latitude ( op9ion40 ,?is obs]vation has be5 ! !me = mu* discussion4 ,x has be5 pretty r\ndly ins9uat$ t 8 ,lord%ip's mean+ _h be5 wilfully misappreh5d$ by ! ,bi%op ( ,london4 ,i see myself b little gr\nd = ! ins9uation4 ,x w at all ev5ts be admitt$ t 8 ,lord%ip did n qualify or def9e ! s5se 9 :i* he us$ ! obs]vation4 ,he has h[ev] expla9$ 8 mean+ & ! ext5t to :i* he appli$ x 9 8 pamphlet1 or z y t]m x 8brief def5ce0 ( 8 spee*4 ,aft] quot+ ! 8pass+ rem>ks ( a c\ntry newspap]10 z elucidatory ( 8 ,lord%ip's mean+1 y say1 8,i _c believe ! ,bi%op ( ,london c\ld be bl9d to a di/9ction s obvi\s40 #bb;b ,= ! pres5t1 be x s4 ,9 ! same page 9 :i* ?is expression ( y\r incr$ulity z to 8 ,lord%ip's bl9dness occurs1 y quote ano!r passage f 8 spee*1 t 9 :i* he obs]ves ( ,subscription1--8x is n requir$ f all memb]s ( ! ,*ur*1 b only f ! m9i/]s ( ! ,*ur*1 z a security aga9/ a great] evil1 c40 ,^u :i* y exclaim1 8c we =get t all graduates at ! univ]sities are requir$ to subscribe1 t ^! are all laym580 ,n v easily1 ,i admit4 ,& :i* w\ld y wi% u to suppose8 ,t 8 ,lord%ip _h =gott5 x1 or t he 0 ignorant ( x1 or t he int5d$ to palm ^u ! audi5ce be=e :i* he spake su* an ass]tion z a lit]al fact8 ,z ,i am incl9$ to ?9k t y suppose nei!r "o nor ! o!r1 ,i mu/ say1 8,i _c believe t y c\ld be bl9d to 8 ,lord%ip's mean+10 & c\ld n help exclaim+ on read+ y\r ready imputation aga9/ ! ,bi%op ( ,london--8,physician6 heal ?yself40 ,b :il/ s _m explanations h s9ce be5 giv5 ( ! mean+ 9 :i* ?is obs]vation 0 made by ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi*1 & s _m ins9uations levell$ at ! ,bi%op ( ,london = n *oos+ to see x1 ,i am dispos$ to ?9k t 8 ,lord%ip did n feel himself call$ ^u to dive into ! ?\ghts ( ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi*1 b int5d+ to give a direct negative to an unqualifi$ affirmative1 meant to re-repudiate ! notion t 8! *ur* ( ,engl&1 0 f\nd$ on lib]ty ( consci5ce1 & ! "r ( private judgm5t10 & to ass]t ) ref]5ce to ! well-kn[n fruits ( su* a pr9ciple1 t ! ,*ur* 0 f\nd$ on 8tru?40 ,b ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* cont5ds t ! expression is an 8incorrect0 "o1 & t _h he be5 speak+ ( 8! only true f\ndation ( ! true ,ca?olic ,*ur* itself10 he %\ld h said t x 0 8f\nd$ on ! ,apo/les & ,prophets1 ,jesus ,*ri/ himself be+ ! *ief corn] /one40 #bd;a ,! ,bi%op ( ,london c\ld sc>cely h ?\ght ! p]iphrasis necess>y1 consid]+ be=e :om he 0 speak+1 he w\ld probably reply to ! imput$ incorrectness ( ! expression1 t he always consid]$ ! f\ndation ( :i* ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* "h speaks1 to be 8tru?10 & t ! ,*ur* 0 ! int]pret] ( ! ,apo/les1 & ,prophets1 & ,jesus ,*ri/1 or 9 o!r words ( ! ,gospel ( ,*ri/4 ,he meant also ,i %\ld suppose1 to repudiate ! notion1 t ! ,re=mation ( ! ,*ur* proce$$ on su* a pr9ciple1 & 9 effect to affirm t f ! days ( ,ar*bi%op ,cranm] to ^! ( ,ar*bi%op ,h[ley1 no su* pr9ciple _h ev] be5 recogniz$ by ! ,*ur*1 z t ( admitt+ 8lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t10 to h any directive influ5ce 9 ,*ur* affairs2 a fact1 :i* if n suffici5tly prov$ by ! m&ate ( ,edw>d ! ,six?1 en=c+ "u ! p5alties ( 8seque/ration1 susp5sion1 excommunication1 & su* o!r co]cion1 z to ord9>ies or o!rs hav+ ecclesia/ical jurisdiction1 %all seem conv5i5t1 /raitly *>g+ & comm&+ 8 lov+ subjects to obs]ve ! injunctions ( #aedg10 #bd;b--w\ld be amply e/abli%$ by y\r own obs]vations respect+ ,bi%op ,hoop]1 = ! s5d+ ( ! good old man to prison 9 ! matt] ( ! ve/m5ts1 & t by ! ,re=m]s !mselves1 w\ld seem b little to fav\r ! notion t our re=m$ ,*ur* 0 f\nd$ on 8lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t40 ,b t ,i may n also be accus$ ( misappreh5d+ 8 ,lord%ip's mean+1 ,i w "h quote 8 explanation ( ! s5se 9 :i* ! obs]vation 0 made-- 8,x is ( c\rse pla9 t ,i 0 nei!r speak+ ( ! ,ca?olic ,*ur* at all1 nor ev5 ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 except 9 its "* ( a ,re=m$ ,*ur*1 f\nd$ z su* on ! pr9ciples ( ! ,re=mation1 :i* ,i aga9 delib]ately ass]t to be lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t1 9 opposition to t ,*ur* f :5ce x sep>at$1 9 :i* ! au?ority ( ,popes1 ,c\ncils1 & ,prie/s1 sup]s$$ all appeal to ! scriptures !mselves1 & by :i* ( c\rse fre$om ( judgm5t 0 /rictly prohibit$40 #be;a ,n t x be>s ^u 8 ,lord%ip's argum5t1 /ill ,i w\ld respectfully submit :e!r our alleg$ sep>ation "h f ! ,*ur* ( ,rome be /rictly correct2 we ?rew (f our allegiance to ! usurp$ au?ority1 temporal & spiritual1 ( ! ,pope2 we re=m$ ! abuses ( our own ,*ur*1 b we sep>at$ f no "m ,*ur*4 ,! episcopal ,*ur* 9 ,engl& exi/$ long be=e ! ,pope ca/ 8 eye ^u x4--8,9 ! acts ( ! ,c\ncil ( ,arles1 :i* 0 held ,a4,d4 #cad1 we f9d ! ,subscriptions ( ?ree ,briti% ,bi%ops40 #be;b ,b ,i w\ld fur!r "q :e!r 9 8 ,lord%ip's qualifi$ s5se ( ! obs]vation x c ) any /rictness be said1 t our re=m$ ,*ur* 0 f\nd$ on ! pr9ciple he cont5ds =4 ,x w1 ,i ?9k1 be admitt$ t :atev] 0 done ) ref]5ce to ! ,*ur* by t 8,po/ilion ( ! ,re=mation10 z ,burnet calls him1 ! ,papi/ ,h5ry1 0 done by him m ) a view 8to cudgel ! ,pope into a compliance ) :at he desir$10 #bf;a ?an f any desire to re=m our religion4 ,at all ev5ts1 we mu/ give up any attempt to reconcile 8 8six acts0 ) 8lib]ty ( consci5ce40 ,! re=mation ( our religion _h its comm5cem5t 9 ! reign ( 8 successor4 ,"h1 if any :]e1 we mu/ look = ! pr9ciple 9 "q4 ,b c x be said t our religion 0 re=m$ 89 opposition to ! au?ority ( ,popes & ,c\ncils10 :5 x is s well kn[n1 t 8! ,bi%op ( ,rome's usurp$ p[] & jurisdiction 0 ( mo/ j causes tak5 away & aboli%$10 #bf;b 9 ! prec$+ reign8 ,nei!r c x1 ,i ?9k1 9 /rictness be said1 ( t "t1 t ! ,prie/s sup]s$$ all appeal to ! scriptures1 see+ t x 0 by ! ,bi%ops !mselves t ! scriptures 7 *iefly caus$ to be circulat$4 ,i am speak+ n ( ! ,g]man ,prote/ant ,*ur*1 b t ( :i* 8 ,lord%ip speaks1 8! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 9 its "* ( a re=m$ ,*ur*40 ,& ,i h be=e %ewn on y\r own au?ority 9 ! matt] ( ,hoop]1 t %e recognis$ no?+ s little z ! pr9ciple ( 8lib]ty ( consci5ce40 ,t sect>ism or sep>ation f ! ,*ur* is f\nd$ on ?is pr9ciple1 w be admitt$4 ,x has always appe>$ to me1 t ! hackni$ phrase1 8lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t10 appli$ to an associat$ body1 is a pure fallacy1 ,i _h almo/ said1 a cobweb to cat* ! fly popul>ity1 q z valuable z an appeal1 8ad capt&um vulgus10 z ! cry--8,nolumus leges ,angli mut>i10 to :i* 8cat*-^w10 8 ,lord%ip attributes ! defeat ( ! attempt to revise ! ,liturgy 9 #afhi4 ,y also attribute ?is defeat to 8! viol5ce ( p>ty20 b !re are ^?1 & ! late pi\s & excell5t ,bi%op ,jebb among/ ! numb]1 :o ascribe x to ! 8special int]f]5ce ( ,provid5ce40 8,b ! special int]f]5ce ( ,provid5ce did n t]m9ate ) ! fir/ e/abli%m5t ( our ,liturgy 4 4 4 ,ev5 )9 ! ,*ur* itself1 "s 7 f\nd ^: integrity _c be impea*$1 :o 7 on ! po9t ( introduc+ alt]ations :i* c\ld n h fail$ to prove equally injuri\s to ! cause ( tru? & piety40 #bg;a ,ev5 ,bi%op ,burnet1 "o ( ! ,commission]s1 ) ref]5ce to ! probable result ( ^? contemplat$ alt]ations ( #afhi1 imputes ! failure ( ! attempt to a 8v happy direction ( ! provid5ce ( ,god obs]v$ 9 ! matt]40 #bg;b ,! ,*ur*1 h[ev]1 co]ces ! consci5ce ( no man1 e "o is at lib]ty to take 8 own religi\s c\rse1 & ,i confess ,i _c see :y t :i* is conc$$ to all o!r societies %\ld be d5i$ to ! ,*ur*--! "r ( be+ gov]n$ by h] own con/itutions1 & ! "r also ( judg+ :at con/itutions are mo/ conducive to ! welf>e & good ord] ( h] community4 ,if ,i c\ld n consci5ti\sly con=m to ! doctr9es & discipl9e ( ! ,bapti/ or ! ,indep5d5t1 ,i "q if !y w\ld all[ me to give my consci5ce ! lib]ty to act among/ !m accord+ to its dictates4 ,!y w\ld no m d5y ?an we d ourselves1 ! ab/ract pr9ciple1 nei!r w\ld !y 8f9e10 nor put me 9 8! pillory10 b ,i suspect !y w\ld 8exclude0 me1 & ) v good reason1 f _! m9i/ry4 ,to talk ( conc$+ ! ab/ract "r ( private judgm5t1 has always appe>$ to me a good deal l talk+ ( conc$+ to a p]son ) s\nd lungs ! privilege ( brea?+4 ,b to cont5d = ! pr9ciple & talk ( c]ta9 latitudes & limits1 seems to me to involve a contradiction--once assign any limits to ! 8"r10 & y de/roy ! pr9ciple4 ,b al?\gh 8 ,lord%ip pleads = ! pr9ciple be+1 z he cont5ds1 t on :i* our ,*ur* is f\nd$1 & ought to be act$ ^u1 he w\ld circumscribe x )9 8a c]ta9 latitude ( op9ion40 ,he w\ld n h x tr5* ^u 8! di/+ui%+ features & ess5tial doctr9es ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*40 ,b :o is to be ! judge ( ^! doctr9es8 ,two ( ! petition]s1 ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 repudiate ! v idea ( ! ,*ur* be+ ! au?oriz$ int]pret] ( ! tru?4 8,if10 say ^! bro!rs1 9 allusion to a rem>k by ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 8! ^w #8au?oris$' be> its usual signification1 su* a rem>k w\ld inde$ be inconsi/5t ) lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t40 #bh;a ,aga91 argu+ f ! abuse ( ,subscription by 8unconsci5ti\s & unscrupul\s m510 !y say1 8x is on t acc\nt t ! simple/ ,cre$1 & ! tru? to :i* ! t]m #8necess>y' is directly appli$ 9 our bible1 are en\gh to ju/ify a call into ! m9i/ry40 #bh;b ,b let any "o comp>e ! foll[+ passage1 f ,mr4 ,bel%am's fir/ lett] to a =m] ,bi%op ( ,london1 ) 8 exposition ( ! ,unit>ians' ,cre$1 z x is giv5 at ! end ( t lucus a non luc5do--8 8,calm ,inquiry40 8,t ! ,unit>ians believe ev]y?+ t is ess5tial to salvation is evid5t f ! unequivocal te/imony ( ! ,apo/le ,paul himself1 :o 9 ! ,epi/le to ! ,romans1 x4 #i1 expressly tea*es t if we confess ) our m\? ! ,"l ,jesus1 & believe 9 our he>t t ,god ha? rais$ him f ! dead1 we %all be sav$40 ,"h !n we h a pr(ess$ believ] 9 ! simple/ cre$--b w x 8ju/ify 8 call into ! m9i/ry80 ,take aga9 ! case ( ! ,bapti/1 agree+ ) u ,i believe on all ! ess5tial doctr9es ( ,*ri/ianity1 admitt+ ! necessity ( ,baptism1 b diff]+ f u only on a "q ( "t4 ,) our views on ,infant ,baptism %\ld we be ju/ifi$ 9 admitt+ him into ! m9i/ry8 & if n1 :at becomes ( lib]ty ( consci5ce & ! "r ( private judgm5t8 ,might n ! pr(ess$ believ] 9 ?is simple cre$ & ! ,bapti/1 "u ! contemplat$ re/rictions ( ! pr9ciple compla9 ) y 8t ! same invasion ( ,*ri/ian lib]ty rema9s8 ,f9es1 & imprisonm5t1 & ! pillory1 h vani%$2 exclusion rema9s 7to !m7 9 ! same unabat$ =ce40 #bi ,let u !n remove ! corrective rem$y ( ,subscription to ,articles ( ,fai?1 & :]e %all we /ay ! progress ( ! gangr5e8 ,h[ %all we exclude 8! naughty s$uc]s80 8,i consid] t by 9 any way exp&+ ! s5se & mean+ ( ,subscription1 a boon w\ld be grant$1 & a great b5efit conf]r$ ^u ! scrupul\s & t5d] consci5ces ( ^? :o are among0--x might be ask$ h[ !y came !re--8or may become ! brighte/ ornam5ts ( ! e/abli%m5t40 ,b if ^! ornam5ts c only be secur$ at ! risk1 ,i d n say ) ! 8int5tion0 ( lett+ into ! m9i/ry toge!r ) !m1 m5 :o hold ?+s contr>y to s\nd doctr9e1 h[ev] exempl>y may be _! lives1 h[ev] brilliant _! acquirem5ts1 /ill %\ld !y be 9 error conc]n+ ! ,fai?1 %all we n h pur*as$ !m at too high a price8 ,bright] ornam5ts we may nev] hope to see ?an t army ( m>tyrs1 ^? pr(\ndly le>n$ & em95tly pi\s m51 ! sanctity ( ^: lives1 ! f]v\r ( ^: holy zeal 9 ! cause ( ,*ri/ h %$ an undy+ lu/re on ! religion !y pr(ess$ :5 liv+1 & :o be+ dead yet speak--& 9 ! acc5ts ( enc\ragem5t to ! t5d]e/ consci5ce1 seem to brea! a cr$e nobis1--! ,*ur* 9 ! holy communion ( :i* ,,we liv$ & di$1 pr(f]s no?+ to be receiv$ z an article ( fai?1 t is 8n agreeable to ! ^w ( ,god10 no?+ z a po9t ( discipl9e 8t is contr>y to x40 8,i w\ld remove e ob/acle 9 ! way ( ,subscription1 by :i* t5d] consci5ces ( unque/ionable or?odoxy1 agree+ on e po9t ess5tial to ,*ri/ianity1 might be reliev$ f difficulties1 :i* ,i "k weigh mu* ) m5 ( hon\rable & high feel+40 ,b :5 ,subscription is object$ to z x is by ! petition]s1 because !y ?9k x pl$ges !m to an ass5t to ?+s unscriptural1 z = in/ance 8! unscriptural "* ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$10 z x is view$ by ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 & ! non-agreem5t ( x1 & o!r matt]s 9 ! scripture z !y are view$ by y\rself--:5 ! alt]native is to give ass5t to matt]s t are contr>y to scripture1 or to sacrifice 8tru? & hone/y10--surely ! expression ( a t5d] consci5ce is incorrectly appli$ to m5 l ^!4 ,= :at mu/ be ! t\ghness ( !irs :o c\ld submit to ! alt]native8 ,b al?\gh ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* w\ld n all[ 8lib]ty ( consci5ce0 to ext5d s f> z to tr5* ^u ! 8ess5tial doctr9es ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*40 ,nev]!less1 hav+ allud$ 9 8 spee* to ! difficult circum/ances 9 :i* ! re=m]s 7 plac$1 & 9 consequ5ce ( :i* 8! ,articles ( ! ,*ur* 7 fram$ on a ref]5ce to ! op9ions ( a v wide body :o diff]$ among !mselves on _m important po9ts40 ,8 ,lord%ip cont5ds 9 ! 8brief def5ce0 ( 8 spee*1 8t x only requires ! full c>ry+ out ( ?is pr9ciple into practice1 to meet ! difficulties ( ! pres5t case40 #ca ,! radical re=m] ( ! ,/ate cont5ds t x only requires ! full c>ry+ out ( ! pr9ciple ( ! ,re=m ,bill1 to give univ]sal suffrage & univ]sal satisfaction to ! p1 & ,i am incl9$ to ?9k t ! result 9 ei!r case w\ld be pretty mu* ! same--equally disa/r\s to ! ,*ur* z to ! ,/ate4 ,b x has be5 cont5d$ dur+ ! pres5t movem5t1 t if alt]ations be made 9 our ,liturgy to meet "o t5d] consci5ce1 a simil> boon %\ld be ext5d$ to all4 ,^u ?is objection 8 ,lord%ip argues1 8if ?is be true1 x is mu* m true t if no latitude is to be all[$ 9 any subord9ate po9t1 we _c make exceptions 9 "o case m ?an ano!r40 ,b ?is appe>s to me to be a petitio pr9cipii1 x is assum+ t !re is no exi/+ 8ela/icity10 no dep>ture f an iota admissible1 no latitude 9 any po9t1 subord9ate or o!rwise already recogniz$1 & if s1 see+ t on mo/ ( ! po9ts on :i* y\r objections h+e1 8 ,lord%ip w\ld seem1 f 8 pamphlet1 to co9cide ) y 9 y\r views1 x might n unreasonably be ask$1--h[ ,dr4 ,/anley came to be at ?is mom5t1 ,bi%op ( ,norwi*4 ,/ill1 ,i ?9k x may reasonably be ask$1 z x is1 if ?is pr9ciple ( concession 9 consid]ation to t5d] consci5ces be once admitt$1 :]e are ! probable dem&s ^u x likely to f9d a limit8 ,! "q w\ld seem !n to resolve itself into a *oice ( evils1 & e malis m9imum1 we mu/ ask !re=e1 :i* w\ld be mo/ conducive to ! welf>e & respectability ( ! ,*ur*1 to require ,subscription to be made unres]v$ly & accord+ to ! lit]al mean+ ( ! words & s5se 9 :i* !y 7 impos$1 or to all[ su* a latitude z may enable e "o to subscribe 9 :at s5se he please8--8,quicunque vult1 is an ill preface to a law40 ,a proposition simil> to ! la/ has be5 /at$ & canvass$ by ,bi%op ,j]emy ,taylor1 & he says ( x--8,?is is ! la/ rem$y1 b x is ! wor/1 x ha? 9 x some?+ ( craft1 b v little ( +5uity1 & if x s]ve ! ends ( peace or ext]nal *>ity1 or a fanta/ic concord1 yet x _c s]ve ! ends ( tru? & hol9ess1 & *ri/ian simplicity40 #cb ,h[ f> ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* may be dispos$ to g 9 c>ry+ out 8 b5evol5t object 7& ,i speak x 9 p]fect s9c]ity1 = ,i believe 8 ,lord%ip to be actuat$ by ! v be/ int5tions71 ( giv+ relief to t5d] consci5ces & promot+ peace & unity among/ ,*ri/ians1 ,i pret5d n to say--= 8 ,lord%ip's pamphlet leaves ! matt] m d\btful ?an 8 spee*1 inasmu* z among/ ^? ^: s5tim5ts 8 ,lord%ip quotes z be+ mo/ 9 accordance ) 8 own1 & ) ref]5ce to :om 8comp>$ ) _m ( _! mod]n oppon5ts10 he says-- ,mallem magis cum ,platone err>e quam cum i/is rect s5tire4 ,8 ,lord%ip quotes ! op9ion ( ,bi%op ,w>burton1 namely1 t 8s*ism :i* all mu/ admit to be an evil1 is "o :i* no?+ b ! ,*ur* wid5+ h] communion1 c prev5t or cure40 #cc ,i confess ,i c\ld nev] cle>ly see h[ ! ,*ur* c consci5ti\sly wid5 h] communion4 ,:at are ! pleas = sep>ation8 ,!y h+e n on lett]s & iotas1 nor on ?is or t p>ticul> passage 9 our ,liturgy1 !y resolve !mselves into two--our ,doctr9es & our ,*ur* ,gov]nm5t4 ,"o or o!r ( ^! is ! plea alleg$ by e d5om9ation ( sep>ati/s1 f ! frigid ,soc9ian1 to ! fanatical ,jump]4 ,giv+ ^! sep>ati/s !re=e cr$it = sec$+ or keep+ alo( ( u on ^! gr\nds1 &1 t = consci5ce sake--we c only expect to 8prev5t s*ism10 by leav+ ! div9ity ( our ,savi\r 8an op5 "q10 & aboli%+ ,episcopacy altoge!r4 ,b may we n ask1 if t5d]ness ( consci5ce is to be respect$ :5 x takes (f5ce at non-ess5tials1 :y is x to be disreg>d$ :5 x /umbles at ! f> m important matt]s1 ! ess5tials ( ,*ri/ianity1 ! 8di/+ui%+ features ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*80 & is n ,episcopacy a di/+ui%+ feature8 ,b ) ! exception ( ! ,roman ,ca?olic1 !re is n a sep>ati/ 9 ! ?ree k+doms :o is agre$ ) u on t po9t4 ,are ! div9ity ( ,*ri/ & ! atonem5t ess5tial doctr9es8 ,b ! s call$ ,unit>ian1 9 ! ex]cise ( 8 private judgm5t1 pron\nces !m to be falsehoods4 ,is ,infant ,baptism a di/+ui%+ feature8 ,b ! ,bapti/1 z he /yles himself1 condemns x z a s5seless & unscriptural rite1 nor w ! lib]ty 9 :i* he indulges 8 consci5ce p]mit him to hold communion ) any ,*ur* t practises x4 ,is ! ,sacram5t ( ! ,"l's ,supp] a di/+ui%+ feature8 ,b ! t5d] consci5ce ( ! ,quak] riot+ 9 ! lib]ty :]e) ,*ri/ ha? made him free1 w n deign to return to ^! 8begg>ly elem5ts10--8! policy ( ,satan busy+ p ) outw>d signs40 #cd;a ,s9ce !n we mu/ give up ! pleas+ hope ( br++ s*ismatics back to ! fold1 we may n>r[ ! "q1 & limit ! propos$ revision ( our ,articles & ,liturgy1 to ! removal ( e 8cause ( uneas9ess0 to ! t5d] consci5ces ( our bre?r5 )9 ! pale4 8,?is10 z y ju/ly obs]ve1 8w\ld probably occasion "s tr\ble & difficulty10 #cd;b n t ?is ought to be object$ if ! *>itable object c\ld be effect$ by any reasonable sacrifice4 ,y admit t already 8m is propos$ t is ei!r necess>y or desirable40 #cd;c ,! ,bi%op ( ,london #cd;d 8w\ld n be dispos$ to g z f> z y10 :il/ "s p]haps ) ! mode/y ( old ,ri*>d ,baxt]1 might propose to put ! unclean ?+ away altoge!r1 & to sub/itute a new & mu* improv$ ,liturgy ( _! own4 ,let u once op5 ! commission1 in/itute ?is ,c\rt ( ,relief = t5d] consci5ces1 & we %all h no lack ( appellants4 ,utor p]misso--caudque pilos ut equ91 ,paulatim vello--demo unum1 demo etiam unum1 ,dum cadat elusus ratione ru5tis ac]vi4 #cf;a ,! difficulties ( ! subject seem to be confess$ by all1 except x may be by ! ,bro!rs ,hull1 :o seem to see none or v few4 ,b ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* obs]ves1 8,i agree t !re are :at to "s may be deem$ almo/ insup]able difficulties 9 ! way ( any *ange 9 ! ,liturgy1 & p]haps 9 ! ,articles40 ,nor w\ld ^! difficulties seem to be less5$1 if 8 ,lord%ip's view ( ! pres5t /ate ( ! ,*ur* be correct1 x be+ 8 op9ion 8t !re nev] 0 a p]iod p]haps ( our ,*ur* ,hi/ory ) s little h>mony )9 ! pale1 & s fe>ful a prospect ( fi]c] & wid] diss5tion40 #cf;b 8,!re is a lion 9 ! way0--& = my own "p ,i am crav5 en\gh to say !re let him lie--c\*ant he is likely to be less tr\blesome ?an rampant4 ,& ! bett] "p ( val\r is discretion4 ,& z 8 ,lord%ip tells u t 8he believes ! ,cl]gy z a body w\ld n cons5t to any *ange0 9 ! ,liturgy4 ,we may inf] t t abs5ce ( h>mony to :i* 8 ,lord%ip alludes1 f :atev] o!r causes x may arise1 orig9ates 9 no want ( unanimity 9 ! ,*ur* on ! score ( ,subscription1 & t !re w\ld seem b little necessity1 = ! sake ( peace1 to emb>k ^u ! dang]\s exp]im5t ( a revision4 ,x be+ !n admitt$ t 8! ,cl]gy z a body w\ld n cons5t to any *ange 9 ! ,liturgy or ,articles10 we mu/ presume t !y c unres]v$ly make ! ,subscription 9 its pres5t =m4 ,& putt+ aside y\r own peculi> case1 we mu/ also presume ( ^? p]sons :o rec5tly petition$ p>liam5t1 9 ! "* ( ,cl]gym5 ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 t al?\gh !y might ?9k "s ,expansion ( ,subscription desirable1 9 consid]ation to o!rs1 did nev]!less make _! own ) a safe consci5ce & ) ! hone/ int5tion ( fulfill+ _! engagem5ts1 by a g5]al con=mity to ! prescrib$ ,s]vices ( our ,*ur*4 ,!y subscrib$1 we mu/ presume1 ) no su* latitude ( op9ion z w\ld admit ( an habitual deviation f1 ei!r by alt]ation or a summ>y omission1 ( su* p>ts ( our ,s]vices1 z !y c\ld n satisfactorily reconcile ) _! own private op9ions4 ,mr4 ,maty1 a =m] sec$] f our e/abli%m5t1 c\ld n consid] su* a latitude ( ! con/ruction ( 8 ,subscription compatible ) 8 hone/y4 ,9 a lett] to ,mr4 ,l9dsey1 he says1 8f9ally1 ,i c nei!r submit to acquiesce 9 sil5ce1 aft] hav+ made my objections kn[n1 nor take ^u me to alt] ! ,s]vice ( ! ,*ur* z long z ,i cont9ue to pr(ess myself a m9i/] ( x40 #cg ,prop]ly appreciat+ ?is s5tim5t1 we mu/ conclude t ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* und]/ood ! pray] ( ! petition]s ) no ref]5ce to su* a practice z ,mr4 ,maty "h condemns1 :5 he repres5t$ !m z pray+ 8t t :i* is cons5t$ to & all[$ privately1 may be ! av[$ & ackn[l$g$ s5tim5ts ( ! ,*ur* at l>ge40 ,yet 9 _! 8explanation ( ! /atem5ts ( ! petition10 & ! object :i* !y _h 9 view1 ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 enum]ate among/ ^! deviations f ! au?oriz$ =ms & positive obligations ( ! ,*ur*1 sanction$ z !y ass]t by g5]al practice2 ! omission ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$1 ! *ange or omission ( c]ta9 s5t5ces 9 ! ,burial ,s]vice1 & ! sub/itution ( o!r lessons ?an ^? appo9t$ by ! ,*ur*4 ,n[ ,i mu/ ?9k1 t if a compla9t 7 pref]r$ aga9/ a ,cl]gyman to 8 ,diocesan = habitually & advis$ly deviat+ ?us f 8 positive obligations1 ! compla9ants w\ld sc>cely be told t su* ?+s 7 cons5t$ to & all[$ privately by ! ,*ur*4 ,if s1 = consi/5cy's sake x might be z well to expunge 9 future f ! ,*ur*w>d5s' ,articles ( ,enquiry exhibit$ at ,episcopal ,visitations1 any su* qu]y z ! foll[+1 8,do? ! ,incumb5t or ,curate regul>ly read s]vice ) ! ,litany & ,cre$s1 exactly accord+ to ! ,rubric ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 )\t omission1 addition1 or alt]ation80 #ch ,y repres5t ! petition]s 8z hav+ pres5t$ to p>liam5t ! s\nd & reasonable pray]1 t ! law & ! practice %\ld be assimilat$40 ,y mean1 ,i presume1 t "s reg>d %\ld be _h to ! nature ( ! ?+ practis$1 o!rwise ,i mu/ ?9k y\r pr9ciple a v uns\nd "o4 ,= in/ance1 x is to be fe>$ t a habit prevails sadly too mu* among/ bo? high & l[1 ( neglect+ ! obs]vance ( ! sabba? day & keep+ x any?+ b holy4 ,b ,i w\ld n !re=e assimilate ! law to ?is practice & g to p>liam5t = an act to legalize sabba? break+4 ,& ev5 9 respect to ! pray] ( ! petition]s1 ,i %\ld say t ! ,ar*bi%op's proposition t /eps %\ld be tak5 to assimilate ! practice to ! law1 0 ! s\nd] "o ( ! two4 ,b ! ,messrs4 ,hull 9 _! view ( ! matt]1 repres5t ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi*--8z plead+ /rongly = t privilege :i* %\ld be conc$$ to e +5u\s m9d1 to mean :at x says1 & to say :at x means40 ,a =m ( ,subscription su* z w\ld admit ( e "o say+ :at he means1 seems to h be5 ! view :i* ! ,bi%op ( ,london took ( ! object ( ! petition]s1 & call$ x v truly1--8expansion ) a v5geance40 ,b y w\ld make u1 by our pres5t ,subscription1 say mu* m ?an we mean1 & mean mu* m ?an we say1 = in/ance1 y w\ld cont5d t we decl>e by ,subscription1 8t e ^w ( ! ,homilies1 is agreeable to ! ^w ( ,god10 ! laity1 y say 8feel n :at x is to subscribe lit]ally to e ^w ( ! ,homilies1 ,rites1 & ,c]emonies10 #ci;a & aga91 8if a ,subscription to ! ,liturgy z agreeable to ! ^w ( ,god is /ill ma9ta9$ to be indisp5sable10 #ci;b & fur!r1 ! petition /ates1 t ! ,cl]gy are 8commonly und]/ood to be b\nd to ! obs]vance ( all ! ,canons40 #ci;c ,n[1 ,i _c ?9k t y give q a correct view ( ,subscription4 ,among/ y\r illu/rations1 y say1 8our ,subscription lit]ally tak5 calls ^u a p]son to decl>e t ! deliv]y ( a m>riage r+ & ! ,apo/les' ,cre$ are equally agreeable to scripture60 #dj ,b ! v lett] ( our ,subscription is oppos$ to ?is view ( x4--,we "k ( no?+ 9 scripture agreeable to or agree+ ) any "p ( our m>riage c]emony1 unless x be a supp]2 nei!r h we any 8scripture w>rant0 = our cu/om ( kneel+ :5 receiv+ ! sacram5t1 none = sign+ ) ! sign ( ! cross1 no direct w>rant baptiz+ infants1 9 %ort1 lit]ally we d n subscribe to ! ,liturgy z be+ agreeable to ! ^w ( ,god1 b conta9+ no?+ contr>y to x4 ,nei!r d we 8subscribe lit]ally & to e ^w ( ! ,homilies0 z be+ agreeable to ! ^w ( ,god4 ,i c\ld produce y _m a qua9t passage f _! exhortations1 to :i* we %\ld be puzzl$ to f9d any?+ agreeable 9 scripture1 ?\gh no?+ p]haps contr>y to ! _s ( !m4 ,& z to ! ,canons1 s f> f feel+ ourselves b\nd to a volunt>y obs]vance ( !m all1 ,i h no recollection ( pl$g+ myself by any ,subscription at my ord9ation to ! obs]vance ( any ( !m4 8,z to ! ,canons10 says ,ar*deacon ,%>pe1 8to :i* we are n b\nd by any =mal promise1 b only by virtue ( _! own au?ority4 ,i believe no "o w say t we are b\nd to pay ob$i5ce to !m all1 accord+ to ! lett] ( !m40 ,say !n1 t !re are among/ !m "s1 :i* z ! petition]s allege 8c\ld n 9 ^! days be act$ ^u10 if s1 !y are ! less likely to cause !m any grievance4 ,& z to ! alleg$ inexp$i5cy ( act+ ^u o!rs1 let u leave t to be judg$ ( by our sup]iors1 :om we are b\nd to obey1 at lea/ s ,i und]/ood my ord9ation v[s4 ,b our objection to a revision ( our ,laws ,ecclesia/ical arises f no ov]-wean+ affection = ^! inop]ative canons1 b f a desire r to 8 4 4 4 be> ! ills we h ,?an fly to o!rs1 t we "k n (40 ,b to ! obs]vance ( ! ,rubric1 we are unque/ionably pl$g$4 ,& x is pref]r$ by ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 8z a *>ge aga9/ ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury & ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 t at _! ord9ation !y pl$g$ !mselves to obs]ve ! ,rubric1 & s to confirm 9 a giv5 way4 ,b !y d n confirm 9 t way1 & d confirm 9 ano!r10 ergo valet consequ5tia4 ,b1 aft] m5tion+ 9 ! /ronge/ t]ms our obligations to a /rict obs]vance ( ! ,rubric1 ,ar*deacon ,%>pe says1 8?is inde$ we mu/ always take along ) u1 t our obligations to obs]ve ! ,rubric1 h[ indisp5sable soev]1 are subject to ?is proviso--namely1 t ! ?+ prescrib$ be a ?+ practicable40 ,& z ! ,messrs4 ,hull admit t 8! ,bi%ops f ! multitudes ( c&idates1 c\ld n confirm accord+ to ! ,rubric10 we w leave ! ,bi%ops to settle ?is matt] ) _! own consci5ces1 believ+ t _! *>act]s are n s f> compromis$ by ! deviation1 z to r5d] x imp]ative ^u !m1 to plunge at all haz>ds into a revision4 ,our ,articles 7 agre$ ^u1 z y obs]ve1 8= avoid+ div]sities ( op9ions1 & = ! /abli%+ cons5t t\*+ true religion40 ,9 accompli%+ ?is1 y seem to ?9k t !y h signally fail$4 ,9 ^? cases1 h[ev]1 :]e ! ,article has advis$ly be5 drawn up = ! purpose ( admitt+ m5 hold+ c]ta9 diff]5ces ( op9ion on ! g5]al doctr9e conta9$ 9 x1 ! contemplat$ result c sc>cely be look$ ^u z indicative ( any failure ( ! object4 ,b ,i _c see t ! exi/5ce ( "o evil 9 a sy/em1 if ! ext5t to :i* ?is latitude goes be "o1 :i* ,i d n admit1 is a s\nd argum5t = ! br++ 9 ( _m m4 8,if10 says ,dr4 ,r&olph1 8! be/ me?od we c ?9k ( to avoid div]sities ( op9ion & e/abli% cons5t t\*+ true religion1 has ?r\gh ! p]v]s5ess & corruption ( mank9d a contr>y effect1 surely n we1 b ^! hypocrites1 are to blame4 ,b we _c ?9k x a good reason = ?r[+ d[n all ! f5ces ( our v9ey>d1 because "s wild bo>s w sometimes break ?r\gh !m40 #db ,x appe>s1 h[ev]1 t y w\ld only leave a few gaps 9 ! f5ce1 ! ?irty-n9e ,articles y w\ld aboli% at "o fell swoop1 & f ! pass+ ( y\r propos$ ,,bill = ! consolidat+ ! laws ( religi\s te/s1 or ,subscriptions1 c4 8y w\ld h x enact$1 t no?+ be requir$ b ass5t to ! doctr9es set =? 9 ! ?ree ,cre$s1 z agreeable to scripture2 ass5t to ! tru? ( ! scriptures !mselves2 & t !y conta9 all ?+s necess>y to salvation40 ,i p]ceive1 h[ev]1 t y w\ld /ill h a 8decl>ation ( con=mity to ! ,liturgy ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 z x is n[ by law e/abli%$40--,by n[1 ,i presume y are speak+ ( ! ,liturgy1 z x %all be set =? h]eaft]1 :5 e pebble ( (f5ce %all be tak5 away1 & 8e cause ( uneas9ess remov$40 ,b hic labor1 hoc opus e/--take = in/ance ! ,a?anasian ,cre$1 y might be cont5t$ ) ! proposition ( #afhi respect+ x2 b y\r bro!r petition]s ! ,messrs4 ,hull exclaim1 8let ,subscription h5ce=w>d apply to a ,pray] ,book :i* does n conta9 ! ,a?anasian ,cre$40 #dc;a ,n[1 if ?is 8erroris expulsio10 z x has be5 t]m$1 0 consid]$ indisp5sable to ! exclusion ( ! ,arian 8wolves10 ev5 aft] ! imposition ( ! ,nic5e ,cre$1--are ^! wolves ext]m9at$8 ,or is _! nature s *ang$ t !y w\ld h>mlessly lie d[n ) ! lambs ( our fold1 7 x n = ^? invidi\s f5ces t prev5t _! approa*1 nor s$uce !m f ! fold1 ev5 7 x f5celess8 ,b1 argue ! ,messrs4 ,hull1 f5ces are ( no use1 = a wolf once ^u a "t got ?r\gh "o1 mean+ ,bi%op ,hoadley4 ,b !y =get t l t trea*]\s "o we read ( 9 ! nurs]y leg5d1 ! 8,little ,r$ ,rid+ ,hood10--he disguis$ himself to effect 8 purpose4 ,we h lately read ( a *imney sweep] ins9uat+ himself into h] ,maje/y's private ap>tm5ts1 b we h n he>d 9 consequ5ce ( ! abolition ( ! police =ce4 ,b let x be admitt$ t our ,liturgy1 8t admirable book1 next to ! bible1 ! treasure & glory & safegu>d ( our re=m$ ,*ur*10 #dc;b is n faultless2 /ill1 :o :5 he looks ^u ! het]og5e\s mass ( s call$ improvem5ts t h be5 already sugge/$1 w\ld n exclaim--8,let u b h our ,liturgy cont9u$ to u z x is1 until ! m5 are born :o %all be able to m5d x or make x bett]1 & we desire no great] security aga9/ ei!r alt]+ ?is or introduc+ ano!r40 #dc;c ,b z ! subsid5ce ( ! dissidia mutuasque suspiciones1 is a consummation m dev\tly to be wi%$1 ?an1 ,i fe>1 9 ^! times1 to be look$ =2 ,i w 9 conclusion make a few obs]vations 9 def5ce ( ! ,subscription ( ! ,cl]gy g5]ally1 to ^? ?ree po9ts :i* y e/eem s 8indef5sible20 b z my obs]vations h already ext5d$ f> beyond ! limit ,i _h contemplat$1 ,i mu/ ( necessity1 be m brief ?an ,i c\ld wi%1 or ?an ju/ice to su* subjects might seem to require--& fir/ ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$4 8,full ( in=mation10 z ,hook] obs]ves1 8conc]n+ t fai? :i* ,arianism did s mightily impugn1 & :i* 0 bo? 9 ! ea/ & we/ ,*ur*es accept$ z a treasure ( ine/imable price1 by z _m z _h n giv5 up ev5 ! v gho/ ( belief40 #dd;a ,b my ,diocesan tells me1 t 8lit]ally und]/ood ?is ,cre$ makes no di/9ctions1 no cont+5cies1 b unconditionally & unequivocally ass]ts t all :o receive x n1 are doom$ to irretrievable p]dition40 #dd;b ,god =bid6 ,b if x be s1 lit]ally ! ,savi\r ( mank9d has pron\nc$ ! same uncont+5t1 undi/+ui%+1 unequivocal doom1 ^u all :o believe n ! gospel4 8,he t believe? n %all be damn$1 #dd;c :osoev] believe? on him %all n p]i%1 b h ev]la/+ life10 #dd;d ! conv]se is1 :osoev] believe? n %all p]i% ev]la/+ly2 = 8he t believe? n %all n see life1 b ! wra? ( ,god abide? on him1 #dd;e !y all %all be damn$1 :o believe n ,,! tru?40 #dd;f ,b we _c br+ ourselves to ?9k t x c consi/ ) ! goodness ( ,him 8^: t5d] m]cies are ov] all ,8 works10 to doom to 8irretrievable p]dition10 millions ( ,8 creatures = ! non-p]=mance ( an impossibility4 ,we consequ5tly limit ?is awful s5t5ce aga9/ ^? :o 8love unrighte\sness10 & wilfully reject ! (f] ( salvation4 ,! context =ces u to ?is application ( ! ana!ma4 ,b ,i am n ask+ 9 :at s5se we are to und]/& ! ?reat ( scripture1 b apply+ to x ! same reason+ ?r\gh :i* ! ,a?anasian ,cre$ is attack$2 & ,i ass]t t lit]ally und]/ood1 ! texts :i* ,i h quot$1 z undi/+ui%+ly doom to p]dition all :o d n believe ! gospel1 z does ! ,a?anasian ,cre$ all :o d n hold ! ,ca?olic ,fai?4 ,b if we are to asc]ta9 ! s5se ( scripture by comp>+ x ) scripture1 ! text ) ! context1 :y are we to be deb>r$ f asc]ta9+ ! s5se & mean+ ( our ,*ur* =mul>ies1 by ! application ( ! same canon ( int]pretation8 ,:y are s invidi\s objections to be conjur$ up & bruit$ abroad aga9/ our ,*ur*1 by ty+ u d[n to ! lett] ( h] =ms1 to ! utt] disreg>d ( _! mean+1 & ! _s 9 :i* !y h be5 impos$8 ,i _c express my own view ( ^! monitory clauses1 bett] ?an 9 ! language ( a contempor>y div9e1 8_! connection & relative =ce is ?is3 :osoev] desires to be sav$ x is necess>y t he hold ! ,ca?olic ,fai?1 & if he :o has ?is fai? keep x n1 = he _c keep x except he has fir/ _h x or held x1 he _c be sav$1 b )\t d\bt %all p]i% ev]la/+ly4 ,! w>n+1 !re=e1 is direct$ to him only :o keeps n ! fai? :i* he has be5 taught1 :i* has be5 put into 8 h&s1 :i* he has _h hold (40 #de ,b my ,diocesan affirms1 & al?\gh x is y\r own op9ion also1 ,i take ! lib]ty ( canvass+ x 9 8 ,lord%ip's /atem5t1 feel+ t ! s5tim5ts ( ! ,spiritual ,head ( ! ,*ur* 9 ?is ,diocese1 mu/ c>ry ) !m ev5 great] weight ?an y\r own4 ,8 ,lord%ip says1 8grant+ 7?\gh ! ,cre$ makes no su* concession7 t five hundr$ millions & upw>ds ( ,pagans & ,hea!ns1 out ( eight hundr$ millions inhabitants ( our globe1 are n meant to be includ$ 9 ?is sweep+ ana!ma1 x %\ld be rememb]$ t ! :ole ,greek ,*ur*1 pr(ess$ ,*ri/ians z !y are1 mu/ ( necessity be includ$1 z its memb]s aft] mature consid]ation are at v>iance ) o!r ,*ur*es respect+ ! procession ( ! ,holy ,gho/40 #df;a ,z a po9t ( doctr9e ,i am mu* dispos$ to "q ! 8mature consid]ation10 ,i %\ld r impute ! s*ism to ! imp]i\s & unb5d+ dispositions ( ! respective p>ties1 ! ,patri>* v]sus ! ,pontiff4 ,b be t z x may1--,i w\ld exon]ate our ,*ur* f ! odium ( gratuit\sly condemn+ to irretrievable p]dition1 ^? :o 9 h] own op9ion sub/antially diff] no?+ f h] 9 ?is respect1 b d keep undefil$ ! ,ca?olic ,fai?4 8,!y d n10 says ,ar*bi%op ,bramhall1 8add ! ^w filioque to ! ,cre$1 & yet !y ackn[l$ge t ! ,holy ,gho/ is ! ,_s ( ! ,son1 :i* is ! v same ?+ 9 s5se40 #df;b ,& aga9--8,pet] ,lomb>d1 ,?omas ,jesu1 ,c>d9al ,tolet1 & _m o!rs1 d make ! "q ab\t ! procession ( ! ,holy ,gho/ to be v]bal only1 )\t reality1 & t ! ,grecian expressions ( ,spiritus ,filii & p] ,filium1 d signify z mu* z our ,filioque40 #dg;a ,bi%op ,pe>son1 ,bi%op ,bev]idge1 ,dr4 ,wat]l&1 & _m o!rs ( our own div9es are ( ! same op9ion4 ,9 explication ( ! doctr9e ( ! ,p]sonality ( ! ,holy ,gho/1 ! ,a?anasian ,cre$ says--8! ,holy ,gho/ is ( ! ,fa!r & ( ! ,son10 ! ,greek ,*ur* holds t :i* z ,bi%op ,pe>son says1 pla9ly conta9s ?is tru?1 t ! ,_s is ( ,god ! ,fa!r1 & ( ,god ! ,son4 ,! ,cre$ says1 8nei!r made1 nor creat$1 nor begott51 b proce$+10 & beyond a procession1 di/+ui%+ ,him f ! ,fa!r & ! ,son1 b :e!r ?is procession be temporal1 et]nal1 or bo?--:e!r f ! ,fa!r & ! ,son1 or f ! ,fa!r only1 ! ,cre$ det]m9es no?+--& ! di/+ui%+ prop]ty ascrib$ by ! ,greek ,*ur* to ! ,holy ,gho/1 is a procession1 4 #dg;b 8,! ,greek ,*ur*10 says ,dr4 ,b5net1 8does unanim\sly ma9ta9 ! temporal procession ( ! ,holy ,gho/1 f bo? ! ,fa!r & ! ,son4 ,& s9ce ?is ,cre$ may be und]/ood 9 t s5se1 !re=e 9 ! use ( x we d necess>ily decl>e no m ?an :at ! ,greek ,*ur* does z cordially pr(ess & cont5d = z ourselves40 8,?\gh ! di/9ction10 says ! same writ]1 80 s well kn[n to all our ,re=m]s 9 ?is nation1 yet _! prud5ce & mod]ation w\ld n suff] !m to take notice ( x 9 any public & au!ntic mann]4 ,!y w\ld n rec$e f ,rome any fur!r ?an 0 necess>y1 ^u ! acc\nt ( ! ,roman corruptions1 & !re=e !y did n reject ! filioque f ! ,nic5e ,cre$ or ! ,cre$ ( ,/4 ,a?anasius1 nor did !y decl>e !mselves aga9/ ! ,greek ,*ur* by add+ any su* t]m1 z mu/ necess>ily det]m9e 9 :at s5se !y und]/ood ! procession40 #dh;a ,lit]ally tak51 !re=e1 ! ,greek ,*ur* is n ( necessity includ$ 9 ?is sweep+ ana!ma1 & z 8 ,lord%ip /ates x1 8exclud$ f ! m]its ( ! ,r$eem]'s dea? h]eaft]10 any m ?an five hundr$ millions ( ,hea!ns are condemn$ to irretrievable p]dition by ! lit]al acceptation ( ,m>k xvi4 #af4 ,to affirm ! necessity ( ! ,ca?olic ,fai? to salvation1 is simply to say :at our ,"l himself says1 9 ! above text4 ,to affirm t he :o hav+ _h ! ,ca?olic ,fai? rejects x1 is to say no m ?an is said1 ,heb4 vi4 #d1 ,luke ix4 #fb1 ,matt x4 #ac1 & #b ,pet] ii4 #ba1 ) _m o!r l places4 ,x w\ld appe> !n f page #ea ( y\r pamphlet1 t we diff] no?+ 9 our application ( ^! clauses2 ! only diff]5ce betwe5 u is1 t tak+ ?is view ( x1 ,i c unres]v$ly make my ,subscription1 & consci5ti\sly hold ) our eigh? ,article1 t ?is ,cre$ 8ought ?or\ghly to be receiv$ & believ$40 ,b if 9 my consci5ce ,i believ$ t su* an application ( !m 0 unt5able1 ,i confess ,i c\ld n s easily lay aside my scruples1 z x w\ld appe> y 7 ready to d1 provid$ y c\ld obta9 ! 8sanction ( ! op9ion ( ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury10 an op9ion :i* be+ n ex ca!dra1 b private & p]sonal1 8 ,grace w\ld n p]mit y to consid] z 8( great] value ?an t ( any o!r individual1 :o may possess 9 an equal degree ! qualifications ( a compet5t judge 9 su* a matt]40 #dh;b ,b y ask 8:e!r :5 we read ,m>k xvi4 #af1 we c f9d 9 t awful ?reat aga9/ ^? :o d n receive ! ,,gospel1 a sanction = ! ev5 m appall+ ?reat conta9$ 9 ! ,cre$40 #di;a ,9 :at s5se x is m appall+ y h left u to discov]4 ,b by ?is obs]vation1 y w\ld seem to aim at "s di/9ction betwe5 n receiv+ ! ,gospel & reject+ ! 8v ess5tials ( ,*ri/ianity40 8,! ,cre$10 y say1 8consi/s ( a s]ies ( propositions d$uc$ by fallible man40 ,?is ( necessity w\ld be ! case1 s9ce ! tru? 0 by ! wisdom ( ,god committ$ to ! keep+ ( fallible man1 & ) x1 ! comm& to 8take he$ to ,,! doctr9e40 ,b ! "q is are !y correct d$uctions f ! infallible ^w ( ,god8 ,y admit t !y are1 all 8mu/ admire10 y say1 8! extraord9>y subtlety & acut5ess ) :i* errone\s !ories are reject$1 & ! correct d$uctions f scripture are ma9ta9$10 #di;b & aga9 8! matt]s treat$ ( 9 ?is ,cre$ are ( su* fundam5tal importance & s includ+ ! v ess5tials ( ,*ri/ianity40 #di;c ,if s1 if ! d$uctions be scriptural1 ! _s ( ! clauses _c be o!rwise1 = 8he t believe? n %all be damn$10 & ,i presume t by believ+ y w\ld cont5d = ! necessity ( a s\nd fai?--8! tru? z x is 9 ,jesus40 8,y are n10 y say1 8s fev]i%ly s5sitive z _m good m5 ( our ,*ur* z to ,tr9it>ian def9itions1 e/eem+ a lively #8fai? work+ by love1' ! gr& desid]atum ( ! gospel10 #di;d & s no d\bt 9 a "r s5se x is4 ,b ,s\? draws a di/9ction betwe5 a lively & a liv+ fai?1 8our fai? mu/ n only be liv+ b lively too40 ,admitt+ ?is di/9ction1 h[ f> beh9d y does ! ,unit>ian 7or r ,humanit>ian1 if sects w\ld b assume _! mo/ appropriate designation71 fall 9 ! pr(ession ( a l fai?8 ,he holds aft] a fa%ion1 ,/4 ,paul's 8^w ( fai?10 ,rom4 x4 #i1 & 9 works ( k9dness to 8 fell[ creatures & morality1 falls no?+ beh9d ! mo/ or?odox ,tr9it>ian4 ,9 ?is s5se 8 fai? is lively1 & artlessness & simplicity are ! boa/$ *>act]i/ics ( 8 ,cre$4 ,he 8confesses ) 8 m\? ! ,"l ,jesus0--b !n x is t he 80 a man con/itut$ 9 all respects l o!r m51 subject to ! same infirmities1 ! same ignorance1 prejudices1 & frailties1 t he suff]$ dea?1 n to appease ! wra? ( ,god1 n z a satisfaction to div9e ju/ice1 n to exhibit ! evil ( s91 nor 9 any s5se :atev] to make atonem5t to ,god = x2 = ?is doctr9e1 9 e s5se1 & accord+ to e explanation !y explode z irrational1 unscriptural1 & d]ogatory f ! div9e p]fections1 b z a m>tyr to ! tru?1 & z a necess>y prelim9>y to 8 resurrection40 #ej ,!y confess ,jesus ) ! m\?1 b !y d5y ! gospel ( ,jesus ,*ri/ our ,r$eem]4 ,& is ?is believ+ to ! sav+ ( ! s\l8 is ?is a 8confession unto salvation80 ,is ?is ,,! doctr9e8 ,b ! rul]s ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur* are to *>ge "s t !y tea* no o!r doctr9e1 ?an ! doctr9e :i* is accord+ to godl9ess1 & great is ! my/]y ( godl9ess4 ,!y are to rebuke %>ply t m5 be s\nd 9 ! fai?4 ,we mu/ 9 %ort tea* ! tru? z x is 9 ,jesus1--,,! fai? & n ,a fai?2 & woe to u if f any mi/ak5 notions ( ,*ri/ian *>ity1 ( t *>ity :i* 8rejoice? 9 ! tru?10 we hesitate to decl>e t to reject 8! v ess5tials ( ,*ri/ianity10 is a 8draw+ back unto p]dition40 ,at ! same "t :5 9 ! fulfilm5t ( our b\nd5 duty1 our positive obligations1 we decl>e ! ?reat ( scripture1 = we decl>e no m1 we might hope at all ev5ts f ^? ^: e s5tim5t w\ld seem to brea! ( ,*ri/ian b5evol5ce1 to h cr$it = decl>+ x 9 ! _s ( t *>ity :i* 8hope? all ?+s40 ,( ! =m ( absolution 9 ! ,s]vice = ,visit+ ! ,sick1 y say1 8no small h>m is done to our reputation by sanction+ t :i* 9 pla9 hone/ language _c be def5d$40 #ea;a ,! ,roman ,ca?olic w tell y t y _c 9 pla9 hone/ language def5d any con/ruction ( ! words 8?is is my body10 b _! own4 ,y put1 h[ev]1 a diff]5t con/ruction ^u !m1 & ) no h>m done to y\r reputation4 ,! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* says ( ?is =m1 8,i h he>d _m ,cl]gym5 express ! pa9 !y felt 9 utt]+ x1 %r9k+1 z consci5ti\s m9ds ev] mu/1 f ! assumption ( a p[] ( s awful a "*1 :ile o!rs f equally consci5ti\s motives1 ab/a9 altoge!r f pron\nc+ x40 #ea;b ,i hope ,i d n misappreh5d 8 ,lord%ip2 b ! impression ( 8 op9ion left on my m9d by ?is passage1 is1 t no consci5ti\s m9d c comply ) our ord9ation v[s b ) pa9 to itself4 ,) :at pa9 & reluctance !n mu/ 8 ,lord%ip cause ^! solemn v[s to be adm9i/]$1 & tru/+ t !y are consci5ti\sly made1 h[ f consci5ti\s motives a man c ab/a9 f ! obs]vance ( !m1 ,i confess ,i _c cle>ly see4 ,nor1 c ,i ?9k x q j to ! great body ( 8 ,cl]gy to take a weak consci5ce z ! /&>d by :i* to measure ! integrity (1 p]haps1 a bett] in=m$ "o4 ,b if 8 ,lord%ip s con/rues our =mul>ies1 z imply+ an assumption on ! "p ( ! ,m9i/]1 ( a p[]1 ! arrogat+ ( :i* c fall no?+ %ort ( blasphemy1 namely1 t 8unless we z ,m9i/]s ( ! ,*ur*1 #8d =give' & #8absolve1' ! s9s ( a dy+ man mu/ desc5d ) him to ! grave1 ) all _! fe>ful pressure2 & t if we *oose to reta9 !m1 he _c escape _! consequ5ces10 #eb;a--9 o!r words1 assum+ a p[] l ! false ,prophets ( old1 8to slay ! s\ls t %\ld n die1 & save ! s\ls alive t %\ld n live10 #eb;b--if su* be 8 ,lord%ip's view ( our =ms1 a man ne$ n be gift$ ) an ov]-s5sitive consci5ce to %udd] at ! arrogance1 ! use ( !m mu/ involve4 ,yet 9 su* a s5se1 8 ,lord%ip w\ld seem to say1 t our ,*ur*'s absolution 0 view$ & 8believ$ by _m ( our e>lie/ ,re=m]s40 ,let u !n try ! ,s]vice 9 "q1 n by its iotas1 b by its obvi\s s5se & mean+4 ,let x be made its own int]pret]1 & we mu/ at once be conv9c$ t su* 0 n ! _s 9 :i* x 0 impos$ by our ,re=m]s1 t !y contemplat$ no su* con/ruction ( its words1 z t ( imply+ a p[]1 ( 8loos+ ( ! debt ( et]nal dea?10--or z ,bi%op ,burnet says1 to 8p>don ) relation to ,god40 ,= if s1 :y rem9d ! sick p]son1 t 8aft] ?is life !re is an acc\nt to be giv5 to ! righte\s ,judge1 by :om all mu/ be judg$ )\t respect ( p]sons40 #ec;a ,does ! =m object$ to imply any su* arrogant assumption on ! "p ( ! ,m9i/]8 ,on ! contr>y1 is n ! comm5cem5t ( x precatory8 to ! effect t ,*ri/1 n ! ,prie/1 8w\ld ( 8 great m]cy =give ! p5it5t 8 (f5ces40 ,does ! ,prie/ pron\nce ! absolution 9 8 own "n8 ,on ! contr>y1 he pron\nces x 9 ! "n ( ,him :o s5t him to decl>e ! =giv5ess ( s9s4 ,does he decl>e x on any o!r ?an ! gospel t]ms8 ,he decl>es x only to ^? :o 8truly rep5t & believe 9 ,*ri/40 ,b c he see ! he>t8 ,h[ !n c x be suppos$ t he %\ld himself believe1 or :at dang] is incurr$ ( deceiv+ ! dy+ p]son into ! fond hope1 t he %all1 9 virtue ( ! ,prie/'s absolution1 be cle> :5 he is judg$ h]eaft]8 ,or if = a mom5t1 ! dy+ p]son _h s deceiv$ himself1 mu/ n ! delusion be dissipat$1 on he>+ ! ,m9i/] aft] he _h pron\nc$ 8 absolution1 put up to ! ?rone ( m]cy t e>ne/ & affect+ petition1 9 behalf ( him 8:o mo/ e>ne/ly desire? p>don & =giv5ess0--b to :at purpose1 if he believ$ t he _h b ! mom5t be=e =giv5 him8 :at c be m utt]ly at v>iance ?an ?is pray]1 ) ! imput$ arrogance ( ! =m ( absolution8 8,! tru? is1 t 9 ! ,prie/'s absolution1 !re is ! true p[] & virtue ( =giv5ess :i* w mo/ c]ta9ly take effect--nisi ponitur obex--z 9 ,baptism40 #ec;b 8,b :o10 y ask1 8%all v5ture to put ^! words into ! m\? ( fallible m51 & au?orize !m 9 any s5se to apply !m40 #ed;a 8,y believe u10 y say1 8to be 9 ! fulle/ s5se ambassadors ( ,*ri/1 *>g$ ) a message ( reconciliation40 #ed;b ,b say t y 7 deliv]+ ?is message at ! b$ ( a dy+ p]son1 & he repli$ to x1 yes sir1 s ,i read 9 my bible4 ,h[ w\ld y lead him to believe t y\r ambassadorial decl>ation ( 8 =giv5ess1 0 likely to be ( m avail to him1 ?an 8 read+ ! message = himself8 8,s910 says ,hook]1 8is n help$ unless x be assur$ ( p>don40 #ed;c ,b :at assurance c y give ! p5it5t1 beyond t he c read = himself1 unless y h au?ority to decl>e 8 p>don 9 virtue ( y\r (ficial "*8 ,if x be n s1 ! di/ribution ( ! bible may be consid]$ z hav+ 9 a great measure sup]s$$ ! fur!r necessity ( a ,*ri/ian ,m9i/ry1 & r5d]$ our ,savi\r's in/itutions ( none effect4 8,b :y10 y ask1 8assume to execute our commission 9 t]ms :i* "u any con/ruction are presumptu\s40 ,"u _! prop] con/ruction ,i w\ld submit t !y argue no assumption or presumption :atsoev]4 ,let u say t y _h rec5tly be5 s5t out z 8an ambassador 9 ! fulle/ s5se10 to ,canada1 9 p>don+ ! rebels 9 accordance ) y\r in/ructions1 & a compliance on _! p>ts ) ! t]ms1 %\ld y h deem$ x a di/9ction involv+ any important diff]5ce1 implicat+ y 9 an act ( presumption1 or d]ogat+ any ?+ f ! pr]ogative ( y\r sov]eign1--_h y said1 ,i remit y y\r outlawry1 & absolve y f all y\r (f5ces4 ,b ,i %\ld mu* "q1 suppos+ ! rebels _h by "s means possess$ !mselves ( y\r in/ructions1 & hav+ asc]ta9$ f !m ! t]ms on :i* p>don 0 (f]$ to !m1 :e!r !y w\ld h consid]$ read+ ?is docum5t to ea* o!r1 ! same ?+ z hav+ ! graci\s message ( p>don deliv]$ to !m on au?ority4 ,! =m] is ! pr9ciple ( sect>ism4 ,b if y believe t !re is any virtue 9 y\r (fice1 if y believe t y are emp[]$ to decl>e ! message ( reconciliation ) m effect ?an a layman1 def9e y\r position ) reg>d to y\r heav5ly ,ma/]1 ass]t y\r delegat$ au?ority1 t ( be+ 9 ! 8fulle/ s5se an ambassador ( ,*ri/20 prove t x means some?+1 or give up y\r claim to an empty title4 ,if !re is no?+ analog\s 9 ! (fice1 :y assume to be an ambassador8 or :y %\ld ! ,apo/les h l$ u to inf] a delegat$ p[]1 by decl>+ !mselves to be ambassadors1 m9i/]s ( ! gospel1 & /ew>ds ( ! my/]ies ( ,god8 ,b = a weak & fallible man to assume a p[] 9 any s5se1 to remit or reta9 ! s9s ( ano!r1 h[ %all we dive/ su* a notion ( presumption1 or reconcile x ) ! enlight5$ & enquir+ _s ( ! n9ete5? c5tury8 ,we are baptiz$1 z ,i h always und]/ood1 = ! remission ( s9s4 ,say !n1 t a p]son desir$ baptism at y\r h&s1 b t on exam9ation y ?\ght y _h f\nd him want+ 9 ! necess>y qualifications1 t he _h n fai?4 ,w\ld y baptize him8 ,b if "p ( ! grace ( ,baptism be ! remission ( s9s pa/1 by )hold+ f him ! sacram5tal means :]eby !y are remitt$1 d y n reta9 !m8 ,& "u su* circum/ances1 w\ld n ! virtue ( y\r commission--! 8p[] ( ! keys10 be br\ght home to y8 ,& consid]+ ! life-giv+ effect ( ,baptism1 if y are tempt$ to measure ,god's ways by our ways1 mu/ x n /rike y z ! v height ( presumption1 to say z y d--,i baptize !e8 ,b z ! remission ( s9s is a result ( ,baptism1 & z we h n accord+ to ! old puritanical objection1 any 8scripture w>rant0 = ! words ) :i* we adm9i/] t my/]y1 w\ld x argue great] presumption to say 9 words t mean no m1 8,i absolve !e ( all ?y pa/ (f5ces80 ,! ,greek ,*ur* seems to h view$ ! matt] 9 ?is light1 = z we le>n f ,b+ham1 !y p]=m ! rite 9 ! optative =m4 8,baptizetur s]vus ,*ri/i 9 nom9e ,patris1 c4--let ! s]vant ( ,*ri/ be baptiz$1 c40 #ef ,b say1 t y _h mi/ak5 ! ?\ghts ( ! he>t ( ! w\ld be conv]t1 w\ld n 8! trem5d\s responsibility0 ( :i* 8 ,lord%ip speaks be neutraliz$ z x respect$ bo? ! conv]t & y\rself1 by ! com=t+ consid]ation t !re is an aft] appeal to ,"o t judge? righte\sly1 at ^: tribunal ! act or s5t5ce ( ,8 (ficial on e>? w be rev]s$1 if pron\nc$ 9 error1 b ev]la/+ly confirm$ if o!rwise8 ,is absolution !re=e a matt] ( indiff]5ce8 ,:y !n 0 ! ,*ri/ian m9i/ry orda9$1 & its au?ority seal$ by ! assurance ( its div9e ,f\nd]1--8he t despise? y despise? me1 & he t despise? me despise? ,him t s5t me80 ,y\r ?ird objection lies aga9/ ! words1 8,receive ye ! ,holy ,gho/10 z !y are us$ 9 our ,ord9ation ,s]vice4 ,! old cavil1 z x is m5tion$ by ,hook]1 0 8,! ,holy ,gho/ we _c give1 & !re=e we fooli%ly bid m5 receive x40 #eg;a ,y\r objection to ! use ( ^! words w\ld seem to be1 t 9 _! lit]al s5se !y imply a p[] ( comm&+ 8 gifts4 ,b surely !re is a wide di/9ction betwe5 ! disp5s] ( a spiritual gift1 & ! giv] ( x4 8,god10 says ,j]emy ,taylor1 8is ! f\nta9 ( ! p[]1 man conveys x by an ext]nal rite 4 4 4 ,god is ! consecrator1 man is ! m9i/]2 ! sep>ation is my/]i\s & wond]ful1 ! p[] great & secret40 #eg;b ,n[1 if a ,bi%op really believes t ! ,imposition ( ,h&s is a div9ely in/itut$ rite1 ! means orda9$ by inspiration ( ,*ri/1 & us$ by 8 ,apo/les1 :]eby ! gift ( ! ,holy ,gho/ is convey$ & receiv$1 = ! m9i/ration ( ! my/]ies ( ! gospel disp5sation3--if he believe t he is a m9i/] ( ! ,_s1 an apo/olically appo9t$ /ew>d ( ^! my/]ies1 ,i c see no?+ 8fooli%10 no?+ presumptu\s 9 8 say+ at ! v mom5t t he believes t he is disp5s+ ! gift--8,receive ye ! ,holy ,gho/ = ! (fice & "w ( a ,prie/ 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,god1 n[ committ$ unto y by ! ,imposition ( our ,h&s40 ,x w\ld1 at lea/1 t5d to %[ t he _h fai? 9 ! efficacy ( 8 m9i/ration4 ,b to imitate ! significant act ( our ,savi\r & 8 ,apo/les1 ev] p]=m$ by !m ) a specific object1 & ev] result+ 9 a bless+1 9 ! communication ( "s spiritual gift1 to h rec\rse to ! sign1 ) no fai? 9 ! ?+ signifi$1 e/eem+ x b a b>r5 c]emony1--w\ld seem to me to be b little %ort ( an 8indef5sible0 mock]y ( an ext]nal rite1 hall[$ to spiritual purposes by ! au?ority ( inspiration4 ,if y c believe 9 ! my/]y ( ! sacram5ts1 if y c believe t 8! bread :i* we break1 ! cup ( bless+ :i* we bless10 d1 by ! pray] & solemn invocation ( ! ,prie/1 become1 9 "s inexplicable & my/]i\s mann]1 ! 8,communion ( ! body & blood ( ,*ri/1 :i* are v]ily & inde$ tak5 & receiv$ by ! fai?ful 9 ! ,"l's ,supp]30 if1 9 ?is fai?1 y hesitate n to give ! consecrat$ elem5ts to ! communicants1 manife/+ ! signification ( ! rite1 by ! words1 ! 8body & blood ( ,*ri/1 take1 eat--dr9k30--,i c see b little reason :y y %\ld /umble1 at ! n m my/]i\s communication ( ! spiritual gift = ! (fice m9i/]ial1 by ! ,imposition ( ,h&s4 ,!y are my/]ies2 b ! :ole gospel disp5sation is a my/]y3--we mu/ become z 8little *ildr50 or we _c receive !m--= no soon] d we gr[ wise en\gh to ask 8h[ ^! ?+s c be10 ?an we are c]ta9 to reject !m z 8fooli%ness40 ,"s boldly1 l ! ,soc9ian1 z requir+ a 8pro/ration ( intellect10 too humiliat+ to be submitt$ to--o!rs hid+ f !mselves _! want ( fai?1 "u ! g>b ( humility1 "u :i* g>b1 ,i wi%1 t frequ5tly some?+ m ( rationalism may n lurk1 ?an its we>] w\ld ei!r will+ly suspect or ackn[l$ge4 ,b y reque/ ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury1 8t x may be all[$ by 8 ,grace's au?ority or sanction$ by 8 op9ion1 t 9 ?is =m1 all t relates to ! gift ( ! ,_s0 7! m9i/ration ( x r1 s9ce ! ,bi%op is n ! f\nta9 ( ! p[]--n ! giv]71 8may be consid]$ precatory40 #ei;a--,precatory6--8! great my/]ies ( our religion are all by way ( solemn pray]40 8,! =m ( words10 says ,j]emy ,taylor1 8do? n alt] ! case1 = ,ego b5$ico1 & ,deus b5$icat is ! same1 & 0 no m1 :5 ,god comm&$ ! ,prie/ 9 express t]ms to bless ! p40 #ei;b ,b :at is !re 9 ! words1 8receive ye ! ,holy ,gho/10 to prev5t y\r tak+ !m 9 ! s5se :i* w\ld seem 8to suit y\r own views80 ,y take1 ,i d\bt n ! =m1 9 :i* ! bread & w9e 9 ! sacram5t are adm9i/]$ 9 a precatory s5se4--8,! body ( our ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/ :i* 0 giv5 = !e1 pres]ve ?y body10 c4--b 9 ! abs5ce ( any auxili>y v]b1 y mu/ imply ! precatory s5se--y might m5tally sub/itute %all or w1 = may1 = any?+ t !re is 9 ! =m itself to prev5t y4 ,b y object also to ! words z be+ an innovation1 & cont5d t ! use ( !m 0 unkn[n 9 ! pur] ages ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,?is1 h[ev]1 y mu/ p]mit me to say1 y h signally fail$ 9 y\r attempt to prove4 ,! au?orities y adduce1 are ^? ( ,mor9us & ,bi%op ,burnet4 ,on ^! au?orities 8y hope to make x appe> beyond all d\bt t no su* =m ( ord9ation 0 ev] ?\ght (1 nor any resembl+ x = elev5 c5turies aft] ! publication ( ,*ri/ianity40 #ei;c 8,pray] & ! ,imposition ( ,h&s1 7 ! only rites we f9d practis$ by ! ,apo/les10 says ! ,bi%op4 ,b !y 7 two di/9ct rites3 8:5 !y _h pray$1 !y laid _! h&s on !m40 #fj;a ,b !y h left u no =m ( pray] us$ by !m ^u ! occasion--h[ !n d we "k :at =m !y us$8 ,& are we to suppose t ! ,imposition ( ,h&s 0 giv5 9 sil5ce1 unaccompani$ by any words to indicate its signification to ! p]son orda9$1 or to ! fai?ful :o 7 pres5t8 ,b no?+ is left on record4 ,h[ !n c y und]take to say t !y us$ n1 z !y mo/ probably w\ld1 ! v =m ( ! primitive commission8 ,*ri/ 0 designat$ = 8 m9i/ry by ! visible desc5t ( ! ,holy ,gho/1 & by an efflux ( ! ,_s3 ,he1 hav+ receiv$ ! gift )\t measure1 9 l mann] designat$ 8 ,apo/les = !irs--8,z my ,fa!r ha? s5t me1 ev5 s s5d ,i y0--,receive ye ! ,holy ,gho/4 ,& !re c be no d\bt1 t ! ,apo/les 9 orda9+ o!rs1 w\ld decl>e bo? by ^w & de$3 8,z ,*ri/ ha? s5t u1 s s5d we y40 8,/ir up ! gift ( ,god t is 9 y by ! putt+ on ( my h&s40 #fj;b ,b ,mor9us is to set ?is "q at re/4 8,8 au?ority mu/1 y suppose1 be consid]$ conclusive on ?is po9t40 #fj;c ,b to :at does x am\nt8 ,8 collect$ ,,ms4 =ms ( ,ord9ation take y back to ab\t ! middle ( ! eigh? c5tury2 & ^! y adduce z conclusive evid5ce ( ! practice ( ! primitive ,*ur*4 ,n[ admitt+1 z 9 c&\r we mu/1 t 8 e>lie/ au?ority is a pro( ( /ill e>li] usage1--/ill1 z to any evid5ce ( ! practice ( ! primitive ,*ur*1 he leaves y ) a yawn+ & some:at unmanageable hiatus ^u y\r h&s4 ,c\ld no writt5 summ>y ( ! ,*ri/ian fai?1 or any traces ( su* summ>y be discov]$1 ant]ior to ! date ( t ( ,nice2 y w\ld h>dly argue t = ! ?ree prec$+ c5turies ! ,*ur* _h always us$ ! ,nic5e ,cre$3--! inf]5ce w\ld be t no human explication ( ! 8^w ( fai?10 _h be5 f\nd necess>y3--& 9 l mann]1 ! abs5ce ( any pro( to ! contr>y1 af=ds a /rong presumption1 t ! primitive ,*ur* _h adh]$ to ! use ( ! words ( ! primitive commission4 ,at all ev5ts1 be=e y und]take to in=m u :at =m 0 n us$ 9 ! ord9ations ( ! primitive ,*ur*2 x is incumb5t on y to %[ :at =m x did use4--8,b10 says ,b+ham1 :om y quote ?us f>1--8! solemnity 9 giv+ sup]ior ord]s1 0 always p]=m$ by ! ,imposition ( ,h&s & pray]40 ,?is has nev] be5 disput$1 b he also obs]ves--8,x is n to be imag9$ t "o & ! same =m 0 us$ 9 all ,*ur*es1 = e ,bi%op hav+ lib]ty to frame 8 own ,liturgy1 z !re 7 diff]5t ,liturgies 9 diff]5t ,*ur*es1 s x is reasonable to suppose ! ,primates or ,metropolitans _h diff]5t =ms ( consecration1 ?\gh !re are n[ no rema9s ( !m 9 be+1 to give u any fur!r in=mation40 #fa;a ,?r[+ y 9 two c5turies & a half beyond y\r e>lie/ au?ority1 ,i d>e n attempt ) ,bi%op ,burnet & y\rself to jump ! rema9+ hiatus1 ) any hope ( rea*+ y\r conclusion1--8t if we ask ( ! anti5t "t :at is be/1 & ( ! latt] "t :at is fitte/1 "s alt]ation ( ! =m ( ord9ation is bo? prop] & exp$i5t40 #fa;b ,our compil]s ?\ght x bo? 8be/ & fitte/0 to adh]e to ! words ( ! primitive commission1 nor attempt to def9e ! my/]y1 or enquire 8h[ c ^! ?+s be30--& !y w\ld probably h repli$ to ! mod]n cavils 9 ! _s ( ,hook]'s obs]vation--8,see+ !re=e t ! same p[] is n[ giv51 :y %\ld ! same =m ( words express+ x1 be ?\ght fooli%80 #fb;a ,to ?is =m ( words ! ,cl]gy d lit]ally & ex animo subscribe1 & not)/&+ y\r objections1 ,i tru/ )\t impea*m5t ei!r ( _! tru? or hone/y4 ,9 a note to y\r ,s]mon publi%$ 9 #ahch1 speak+ ( 8controv]sial publications by ,cl]gym5 9 def5ce ( our ,*ur*10 y obs]ve1 8! occupation is 9 mo/ cases nei!r happy nor improv+40 ,ought n su* a consid]ation to h )held y f *all5g+ y\r bro!r to take s que/ionable a c\rse z y consid] its def5ce1 by publi%+ su* op9ions ( ! ,subscription requir$ & made by ! ,cl]gy1 z mu/1 if correct1 involve !m 9 ! suspicion ( be+ ei!r ignorant ( its mean+1 indiff]5t to its obligations1 or ins9c]e 9 _! acceptance ( !m8--w>n+ !m at "o "t aga9/ ! unhappy occupation ( self-def5ce1 & lead+ y\r read]s at ano!r1 to draw an inf]5ce to _! prejudice1 f _! sil5ce2 = y say ) ref]5ce to 8y\r objections1 no attempt at a refutation ( !m has appe>$1 s f> z y "k1 f any qu>t]10 #fb;b & fur!r1 t our ,diocesan's pamphlet1 9 8def5ce0 ( 8 spee* on ,subscription1 s /rongly corroborative ( y\r own objections 8rema9s unansw]$40 #fb;c ,i mu/1 !re=e1 reque/ ( y to %>e any blame t may atta* to u1 9 consequ5ce ( ! c\rses1 (f5sive & def5sive1 :i* we h respectively tak5 9 ?is matt]4 ,i am fully consci\s ( ! v que/ionable position 9 :i* x places me1 z "o ( 8 subord9ate ,cl]gy1 ) respect to my ,diocesan4 ,& ,i tru/ ,i feel x ) z becom+ a s5se ( ! d\btfulness ( its propriety1 z y mu/ y\r own ) its ref]5ce to our v5]able & univ]sally respect$ ,metropolitan4 ,b :5 8 ,lord%ip is in=m$ ( ! alacrity ) :i* our oppon5ts h avail$ !mselves ( 8 publi%$ op9ions1 to ca/ !m 8unbat$ & env5om$0 aga9/ ! bulw>ks ( our ,zion1 ,i feel assur$ t ! well kn[n lib]ality ( 8 ,lord%ip's s5tim5ts1 w dispose him to make = me e all[ance4 ,i c\ld h wi%$ t ! sil5ce ! ,cl]gy h hi!rto pres]v$1 & :i* has be5 con/ru$ to _! disadvantage1 _h be5 brok5 by "s "o bett] qualifi$ ?an ,i am to d ju/ice to ! subjects ,i h presum$ to h&le2 by "s "o1 ^: "n w\ld h c>ri$ ) x1 f> m weight ?an ,i h ! vanity to imag9e c atta* to my own4 ,inde$1 ,i h sometimes hesitat$ :e!r to affix x to ?is ,lett]1 b z y h %runk f no responsibility by )hold+ y\r own1 f y\r publi%$ objections to our ,subscription1 ,i h felt x due to y n to %elt] myself "u ! irresponsibility ( an anonym\s address4 ,9 p5n+ :i*1 if ,i d n deceive myself1 ,i may hope to /& acquitt$ ( hav+ be5 influ5c$ by any unfri5dly feel+4 ,if 9 any "p ( x my /yle may seem to bord] ^u any?+ sav\r+ ( disc\rtesy--let me hope x may be consid]$ by y z seem+ only4 ,& %\ld ,i h misappreh5d$ y\r s5tim5ts & done y !reby any inju/ice-- ,let my disclaim+ ( a purpos$ evil ,free me s f> 9 y\r mo/ g5]\s ?\ghts1 ,t ,i h %ot m9e arr[ o'er ! h\se ,& hurt my bro!r4-- ,9 :i* light1 z a ,cl]gyman ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 ,i hope long to h ! opportunity to consid] y1 believ+ z ,i d1 t y\r scruples1 ?\gh ! creations ( a consci5ti\s m9d1 are m imag9>y ?an sub/antial--& ) ?is p]suasion & 9 t hope1 ,i beg to subscribe myself1 ,v fai?fully y\rs1 ,,*as4 ,,campbell4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,g[+1 ,,pr9t]1 ,,swaffham4 ,,footnotes4 #a ,mr4 ,wodeh\se's ,lett] to ! ,bp4 ( ,ll&aff1 p4 #fi4 #b;a ,cure ( ,*ur* ,div4 ,direct4 #dh1 ,pt4 #c4 #b;b ,mr4 ,wodeh\se1 p4 #ej4 #c;a p4 #d4 #c;b p4 #ce4 #c;c p4 #d4 #c;d p4 #ce4 #e;a p4 #fg4 #e;b p4 #bf4 #f;a ,petition ) explanations1 p4 #ca1 publi%$ #ahcb4 #f;b p4 #ha4 #g;a p4 #cj4 #g;b p4 #dc4 #h p4 #ed4 #i;a ,lett] to ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury1 p4 #fc4 #i;b p4 #de4 #aa ,article #a4 #ac p4 #da4 #ad;a ,petition ( #ahcc4 #ad;b ,ord9ation ,s]mon1 #ahch4 #ae;a ,heb]'s ,life ( ,j]emy ,taylor1 p4 cv4 #ae;b p4 #hb4 #ae;c p4 #ha4 #ae;d p4 #hd4 #af p4 #d4 #ai ,epi/4 ,d$4 to ,s]mon on ! op5+ ( ,p>liam5t4 #ba ,my read]s may wi% to "k :o ! ,,adelphi are to :om ,i h m ?an once allud$4 ,!y are ! au?ors ( a pamphlet1 entitl$ 8,obs]vations on a ,petition1 7! ,petition ( la/ ,session71 = ! ,revision ( ! ,liturgy1 c4 writt5 by two bro!rs1 a ,cl]gyman & a ,layman40 ,^! bro!rs1 by ! impetuosity ( _! onslaught1 are said to be di/+ui%$ among/ ! petition]s z ! ,,ca/or & ,,pollux ( _! little phalanx4 ,& z !re are 9 _! pamphlet "s ?+s :i* might r5d] que/ionable ! logical acum5 ( ! "o1 & t5d to ca/ a %ad[ ( suspicion on ! or?odoxy ( ! o!r--!y h acquir$ cr$it = no indiff]5t tact 9 putt+ =? ?is ,,siamese sort ( production1 inasmu* z to any s5tim5t :i* might n be ?\ght cr$itable to ! div9e2 ! b>ri/] is ready ) frat]nal consid]ation to ass]t 8 claim1--8,,meus ,,hic s]mo e/10 & t :i* might n be highly e/eem$ = its s\ndness 9 ! le>n$ & hon\rable society ( ,l9coln's ,inn2 ! div9e ) reciprocal affection is at h&1 to exclaim--8,adsum qui feci0--9 %ort1 ! ,b>ri/] w be responsible = ! div9ity1 & ! ,div9e = ! po9ts ( law4 ,diligat et semp] socius te sangu9is illo ,quo pius affectu ,ca/ora frat] amat4 #bb;a p4 #aac4 #bb;b p4 #ajg4 #bd;a ,bi%op ( ,norwi* ,pamph4 p4 #ah4 #bd;b ,sp>r['s ,collection1 c4 p4 #ab4 #be;a ,bp4 ( ,norwi*'s ,pamph4 p4 #ah4 #be;b ,h>t's ,eccl4 ,records1 p4 #b4 #bf;a ,burnet ,pref4 vol4 i4 #bf;b ,sp>r['s ,collection1 c4 p4 #a4 #bg;a ,bi%op ,jebb's ,pa/oral ,in/ructions1 ,disc4 iii4 p4 #fa4 #bg;b ,hi/ory ( 8 ,own ,times1 vol4 ii4 p4 #cc4 #bh;a ,john & ,w4 ,w4 ,hull's obs]vations on ! petition1 p4 #bc4 #bh;b p4 #bi4 #bi p4 #ag4 #ca ,bp4 ( ,norwi*'s ,pamph4 p4 #ad4 #cb ,rule ( ,consci5ce1 b4 iii4 c4 iv4 r4 #bc4 #cc ,bp4 ( ,norwi* ,pamph4 p4 #bi4 #cd;a ,b>clay's ,apol4 p4 #bg4 #cd;b p4 #fg4 #cd;c ,petition ) ,expl4 p4 #dg4 #cd;d ,i h introduc$ ! "n ( ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 z x gives me an opportunity ( do+ full] ju/ice to 8 ,lord%ip's s5tim5ts ) respect to a ,,revision ,,( ,,! ,,liturgy ?an ,i h yet se5 done !m 9 any ( ! publications 9 :i* 8 "n has be5 introduc$ 9 connection ) ! subject4 ,8 ,lord%ip admits1 t s9ce ! ,,liturgy is a human composition1 x falls %ort ( p]fection1 & is consequ5tly 8susceptible ( improvem5t40 8,i %\ld be defici5t 9 c&\r10 says 8 ,lord%ip1 8if ,i did n ackn[l$ge t ,i ?9k ! ,,liturgy susceptible ( improvem5t1 x w\ld be little %ort ( a miracle 7 x o!rwise1 4 4 4 & ,i he>tily pray t ! "t may come :5 ! "q c be look$ at ) calmness & c&\r1 & if ! rec5t conduct ( diss5t]s =bids u to look =w>d ) any sangu9e hope to an ext5sive compreh5sion ( ^? :o diff] f u1 t some?+ may be done = ! satisfaction ( _m :o are s9c]e & zeal\s memb]s ( ! ,*ur*40--,su* is ! sum & sub/ance ( all t 8 ,lord%ip has admitt$ t may seem to fav\r ! views ( ! revis]s1 & "h mo/ ( !m h be5 satisfi$ to /op %ort 9 _! quotations f 8 ,lord%ip's *>ge4 ,f a passage 9 ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi*'s pamphlet1 ,i %\ld be l$ to ?9k t 8 ,lord%ip _h be5 cont5t to take 8 quotation f 8 bro!r ,bi%op's *>ge at second h&1 = aft] quot+ ! above passages1 8 ,lord%ip says1 8,i h only to add1 t _h ! ,"r ,rev4 ,prelate :o express$ ^! 8 delib]ate s5tim5ts 9 #ahcd1 manife/$ 9 8 spee* ( #ahdj1 a disposition to foll[ !m out 9 _! true _s & legitimate results1 ! consci5ti\s m5 :o sign$ ! ,petition1 might h ent]ta9$ a j hope t he w\ld h l5t 8 p[]ful aid 9 support+ its pray]40 #ce;a ,i w take up 8 ,lord%ip's *>ge :]e ! ,bi%op ( ,norwi* & y h left x-- 8,,b10 says 8 ,lord%ip1 8:5 ,i consid] ! circum/ances 9 :i* we are n[ plac$1 & ! advantage :i* w\ld be tak5 f diff]5t qu>t]s1 ( any door :i* might be op5$ to *ange1 ,i am l$ to adopt ! s5tim5t ( a pi\s & sagaci\s man1 #ce;b utt]$ ne>ly =ty ye>s ago3--#8,z to our liturgy1 ,i am f> f ?9k+ x incapable ( am5dm5t2 ?\gh :5 ,i consid] ! temp] & _s ( ! pres5t times1 ,i d>e n wi% t ! improvem5t ( x %\ld be attempt$1 le/ ! rem$y %\ld be worse ?an ! disease4'0 #ce;c ,_h ^! 8 ,lord%ip's s5tim5ts z 8delib]ately express$0 z any o!r "p ( 8 *>ge be5 m g5]ally made kn[n1 ,i mu/ ?9k t ! consci5ti\s m5 :o sign$ ! ,petition1 c\ld h expect$ no?+ s little z 8 ,lord%ip's p[]ful aid 9 support ( its pray]4 ,to ^! s5tim5ts 8 ,lord%ip app5d$ a note support+ 8 own views by ! au?ority ( ,ar*bi%op ,seck] & ( ,dr4 ,balguy4 ,f t note y h quot$ ! well des]v$ t]ms ( praise 9 :i* 8 ,lord%ip speaks (1 8! c&id & *ri/ian _s :i* brea!s ?r\gh\t y\r preface10 to y\r repr9t ( ,dean ,prideaux1 9 :i* praise all :o h read ! "w w readily jo94 ,b z x illu/rates 8 ,lord%ip's views1 we may z well give ! rema9d] ( ! note4 ,! quotation f ,ar*bi%op ,seck] is z foll[s3-- 8,et hc eadem velim sibi 9 memoriam revoc5t1 qui ,liturgiam item rec5s]i re=m>ique flagitant4 ,ornatior quidem1 accuratior1 pl5ior1 brevior1 et ,,pote/ ,,ea ,,fi]i ,,et ,,debet2 s$ mode/a tractatione1 s$ tranquillis hom9um animis2 non tem]>iis1 qualia vidimus et videmus1 ausis1 non int] m$ia dissidia mutuasque suspiciones40 8,"s ( ! faults imput$ to our public s]vice are10 z ,dr4 ,balguy says1 8( su* a nature z to admit ( no alt]ation4 ,9 ^! in/ances we mu/ r5\nce our fai? be=e we c cons5t to re=m our wor%ip2 to re=m x1 ,i mean1 9 ! only way :i* c /op ! compla9ts ( its adv]s>ies40--,disc\rses1 vol4 #a1 p4 #ajc4 #cf;c ,n hav+ arriv$ at y\r conclusion--8,t ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 :o came =w>d z ! pr9cipal oppon5t ( ! ,petition1 is an unfit guide = public op9ion on su* a subject40 #cf;d ,i h ?\ght x b j t ! public %\ld "k :at 8 ,lord%ip's s5tim5ts on ! subject ( a ,revision ( ! ,,liturgy really are4 #ce;a ,bp4 ( ,norwi*'s ,pamp4 p4 #de4 #ce;b ,rev4 ,john ,newton1 ,apologia1 p4 #i4 #ce;c ,bi%op ( ,london's ,*>ge1 #ahcd4 #cf;a ,hor4 ,epi/4 ,,ii4 i4 #de4 #cf;b ,bi%op ( ,norwi*'s ,pamph4 p4 #e4 #cf;c ,bi%op ( ,london's ,*>ge1 ,app5dix ,n4 #cf;d p4 #c4 #cg ,n>es ,bamp4 ,lect4 p4 #dff1 note #c4 #ch ,articles1 c4 9 ! ,prim>y ,visitation ( ,edw>d1 ,bi%op ( ,norwi*1 #ahch4 #ci;a p4 #ah4 #ci;b p4 #ib4 #ci;c ,hull1 #ae4 #dj p4 #ad4 #db ,visitation ,*>ge1 #agga4 #dc;a ,hull1 p4 #ai4 #dc;b ,bi%op ( ,london's ,*>ge1 #ahcd1 p4 #dj4 #dc;c ,s\?'s ,s]m4 vol4 ii4 ,epi/4 ,d$4 to ,univ4 ( ,ox=d4 #dd;a ,eccl4 ,pol4 b4 ,v4 s4 #db4 #dd;b ,bi%op ( ,norwi*'s ,pamph4 p4 #bh4 #dd;c ,m>k xvi4 #ad4 #dd;d ,john iii4 #ae4 #dd;e ,john ix4 #bf4 #dd;f #b ,!ss4 xi4 #ab4 #de ,vogan's ,bampton ,lect4 p4 #cge4 #df;a ,bi%op ( ,norwi*'s ,pamph4 p4 #bh4 #df;b ,j ,v9d4 ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 ,disc4 iii4 #dg;a ,s*ism ,gu>d$1 iv4 ,sect4 x4 #dg;b ,see ,pe>son on ! ,cre$1 ,art4 #h1 note4 #dh;a ,p>aphrase on ,com4 ,pray]1 ,app5d4 ,numb4 #c1 p4 #bib1 second edition4 #dh;b p4 #ed4 #di;a ,pet4 ) ,expl4 #bg4 #di;b ,petition1 c4 p4 #be4 #di;c p4 #bd4 #di;d p4 #bc4 #ej ,bel%am's ,calm ,inquiry1 pp4 #bia1 #bib4 #ea;a ,petition1 c4 p4 #ca4 #ea;b ,bi%op ( ,norwi*'s ,pamphlet1 p4 #cd4 #eb;a ,bp4 ( ,norwi*'s ,pamph4 p4 #cc4 #eb;b ,ezek4 xiii4 #ai4 #ec;a ,s]vice = ,visit+ ! ,sick4 #ec;b ,,ms4 ,note by ,bi%op ,ov]all4 #ed;a ,petition1 c4 p4 #ca4 #ed;b p4 #cc4 #ed;c ,eccl4 ,pol4 ,b4 vi4 #ef ,antiquities1 vol4 viii4 ,app5d4 p4 #bci4 #eg;a ,eccl4 ,pol4 b4 ,v4 s4 #gg4 #eg;b ,div4 ,in/4 ( ,(f4 ,m94 pp4 #bbe1 #bbf4 #ei;a p4 #ea4 #ei;b ,div4 ,in/4 ( ,(f4 ,m94 ,sect4 vii4 #ei;c ,petition1 c4 p4 #cg4 #fj;a ,acts vi4 #f4 #fj;b #a ,tim4 i4 #f4 #fj;c ,petition1 c4 p4 #ch4 #fa;a ,antiquities1 b4 ii4 c4 xi4 sec4 #i4 #fa;b ,petition1 c4 p4 #db #fb;a ,eccl4 ,pol4 b4 ,v4 s4 #gg4 #fb;b p4 #eh4 #fb;c p4 #aje4