,transcrib$ f ! #ahag ,hay & ,turn] edition by ,david ,price1 email ccx#jgdpglaf4org ,picture3 ,public doma9 book cov] ,,! ,,trial ,,& ,,conviction ,,( ,,john ,,*ur*1 ,,! ,prea*] ,,( ,,! ,,surrey ,,tab]nacle1 ,,bor\gh ,,road1 ,,at ,,! ,surrey ,assizes1 at ,croydon1 on ,saturday1 ! #af? ( ,augu/1 #ahag1 ,,= ,,an ,,assault ,,) ,,int5t ,,to ,,commit ,,an ,unnatural ,crime4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,tak5 ,,9 ,,%ort-,,h&1 ,,by ,a ,,b>ri/]4 99 99 99 99 99 ,! pr(its aris+ f ?is ,publication w be giv5 to ! ,prosecutor to assi/ 9 defray+ ! exp5ses ( ! ,prosecution4 99 99 99 99 99 ,london3 ,,pr9t$ ,,& ,,publi%$ ,,by ,,hay ,,& ,,turn]4 #aa1 ,,newca/le ,,/reet1 ,,/r&2 ,,& ,,may ,,be ,,_h ,,( ,w4 ,,wright1 ,,m>%-,,gate1 ,,lambe?1 ,,& ,,all ,,booksell]s ,,9 ,,t[n ,,& ,,c\ntry4 #ahag4 ,price ,two ,%ill+s4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,to ,,! ,,public4 ,,9 pres5t+ to y ! foll[+ acc\nt ( ! ,trial ( ,,john ,,*ur*1 = an attempt to commit "o ( ! f\le/ crimes recogniz$ by ! law ( nature1 ! ,publi%]s h no wi% to e*o ! triumphs ( a p>ty--!y are actuat$ only ) a desire to hold up ! abom9able wret* to g5]al obs]vation1 t innoc5t y\?s may n ungu>d$ly become ! victims ( 8 brutal passion--! occasion calls = sorr[ r ?an joy2 & ! ,*ri/ian ,philan?ropi/ w feel m incl9$ to %$ ! sil5t te>1 ?an indulge 9 exultation1 :ile he p]uses ?is record ( human degradation4 ,9 "s cases1 x appe>s desirable n to suff] trials ( a crim9al nature to appe> 9 pr9t1 p>ticul>ly :5 ! facts are too indec5t1 le/ ! t5d] feel+s ( any %\ld be injur$1 or t in=mation giv5 :i* _h bett] be )held2 b :5 ! subject ( conviction is a creature1 :o pret5ds to be ! guide ( hundr$s 9 ! pa?s ( our ,holy ,religion1 & "u its sacr$ "n1 is n only ru9+ ! bodies1 b ! s\ls ( _m ( 8 he>]s1 ?an sil5ce becomes a crime1 & a full exposure an imp]ative duty4 ,we regret1 t among ! foll[]s ( ?is wret* are to be f\nd _m "y m51 :o n only c\nt5ance 8 cause by _! pres5ce1 b advocate x ) _! tal5ts2--t *>ity1 :i* cov]e? a multitude ( s9s1 leads u to indulge ! hope1 t hi!rto !y h act$ consci5ti\sly & f pr9ciple--t !y h believ$ _! lead] 0 ! object ( cruel p]secution--t he suff]$ = righte\sness sake--& "u ?is impression1 we pity r ?an condemn !m2 b c !y be ( ! same op9ion n[8 ,we reque/ _! att5tive p]usal ( ! foll[+ pages2 we beg ( !m to notice ! evid5ce produc$ = ! prosecution1 p>ticul>ly ! copy ( a lett] to ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 ! orig9al ( :i* 0 artfully suppress$1 & ! admission ( ,*ur* himself1 & !n say1 :e!r ?is conviction does n 8confirm anci5t reports80 ,let !m read ! contradictory evid5ce ( ,?omas1 & ! obs]vations made !reon by ! le>n$ ,judge :o tri$ ! prison]2 let ^? :o 7 pres5t rememb] 8 agitat$ appe>ance 9 ,c\rt1 & ! mann] 9 :i* he unwill+ly confirm$ ! evid5ce ( ! prosecutor's ma/]1 & !n say on :i* side ! tru? appe>s to prepond]ate4 ,if ! he>]s ( ,*ur* d n wilfully close _! eyes1 & p]v]t _! judgm5ts1 !y c h b "o op9ion1 viz4 t ! v]dict ( ! jury is ! v]dict ( e "o :o values ! cause ( religion1 morality1 & virtue4 ,if h[ev]1 ! he>]s ( ?is creature /ill cont9ue to frequ5t ?is 8,tab]nacle ( ,iniquity10 e p]son w naturally believe1 t o!r motives1 & n a desire to be edifi$ by ! m9i/rations ( _! convict$ pa/or1 actuate !m--!y w ev] be look$ ^u ) a suspici\s eye1 & _! "*1 & e ?+ t is de> to !m 9 ?is life1 w be sacrific$ = ev]1 9 ! op9ion ( e good man4 ,x may be expect$ t some?+ %\ld be said ( ! conduct ( ^? females :o h s long patroniz$ ?is deceiv] ( _! s\ls4 ,h[ c !y long] li/5 to a wret* :o mu/ dete/ !m 9 8 he>t1 & no?+ b 8 love ( ga9 makes him c\rt _! fri5d%ip8 ,c !y n[1 9 ! pres5ce ( a disgu/$ public1 ent] ! doors ( 8 8d5 ( ?ieves80--,if !y c1 fri5ds mu/ blu% = ! inconsi/5cy ( _! conduct3 mo/ s9c]ely d we hope t all :o respect _! reputation w nev] approa* 8! ,surrey ,tab]nacle0 until ! pres5t occupi] & all 8 associates h left ! place4 ,mu* praise is due to ^? :o h at la/ br\ght ,,john ,,*ur* to ju/ice3 e ?+ t c\ld be done by brib]y & p]suasion 7 resort$ to by 8 fri5ds2 b !y f\nd ! ,prosecutor1 9 ?is respect1 invuln]able4 ,! y\? has act$ nobly2 & ! praises ( ! ,public are due to him = 8 resi/ance to ! wi%es ( t wret*1 :o w\ld h glori$ 9 be+ ! murd]] ( 8 peace = ev]6 ,"o fact h[ev]1 z x reflects consid]able cr$it on ! respectability ( ! ,def5dant & 8 legal fri5d1 mu/ n be omitt$--! p]son employ$ to def5d ! ,prison] 0 a ,jew ,attorney1 v well kn[n to _m4 ,he appli$ to ! ,prosecutor's fa!r sev]al times1 & t5d]$ 8 s]vices to conduct ! prosecution1 assur+ him he %\ld n expect any pecuni>y remun]ation = 8 ex]tions 9 br++ su* a "* to ju/ice4 ,he advis$ ! ,fa!r1 z he 0 a poor man1 to accept a sum ( money1 if x 7 (f]$1 & compromise ! bus9ess3 ?is proposal 0 indignantly reject$1 & ! man treat$ z he des]v$ to be--) m]it$ contempt4 ,we regret also t a man1 ^: duty is ! appreh5sion ( transgressors aga9/ our laws1 %\ld h int]f]$ mo/ unju/ly to hu% up ! matt]4 ,"s1 p]haps1 may ?9k t too mu* sev]ity appe>s 9 our obs]vations aga9/ ! ,prison]--b1 c ?is be ! case8 ,c any man feel too indignant at ! conduct ( su* miscreants8--,we cordially agree ) ! le>n$ ,c\nsel = ! ,prison]1 t if a wi% w\ld sweep su* *>act]s f ! creation1 t wi% w\ld be imm$iately express$ by e true ,briti% he>t4--,are we too sev]e8 ,rememb] ! conduct ( ! ,almighty1 :o s5t fire & brim/one f ,heav51 & consum$ ! ,,guilty ,inhabitants ( ,sodom & ,gomorrah1 le/ _! fil?y bodies %\ld pollute ! grave4 ,! fri5ds ( ! ,prison] h publicly support$ him 9 8 def5ce by _! ,subscriptions4 ,! ,prosecutor has /ood almo/ alone2 b1 confid5t t ! lib]ality ( ! ,public 0 nev] appeal$ to 9 va9--t !y w always assi/ ! injur$ poor 9 br++ _! oppressors to puni%m5t1 ?is ,publication is submitt$ to !m2 & !y may re/ assur$ t ! pr(its w be devot$ t[>ds defray+ ! exp5ses :i* h be5 necess>ily incurr$ 9 br++ ?is 8,mon/] ( ,iniquity0 to ,ju/ice4 #ba/ ,augu/1 #ahag4 ,,! ,,trial1 c4 c4 ,,! ,,k+ v]sus ,,john ,,*ur*4 ,,! ,indictm5t *>g$1 8,t ! ,def5dant1 late ( ! p>i% ( ,/4 ,m>y1 ,lambe?1 9 ! c\nty ( ,surrey1 on ! #bf? day ( ,septemb]1 9 ! fifty-sev5? ye> ( ! reign ( ,george ! ,?ird1 ) =ce & arms1 at ! p>i% a=esaid1 9 ! c\nty a=esaid1 9 & ^u "o ,adam ,=eman1 9 ! peace ( ,god & our said ,"l ! ,k+1 !n & !re be+1 did make an assault1 & him1 ! said ,adam ,=eman1 !n & !re did beat1 w\nd1 & ill treat1 s t 8 life 0 greatly despair$ (1 ) int5t1 t mo/ horrid1 dete/able1 & sodomitical crime 7among ,*ri/ians n to be nam$7 call$ ,bugg]y1 ) ! said ,adam ,=eman1 aga9/ ! ord] ( nature1 !n1 & !re feloni\sly1 wick$ly1 & devili%ly1 to commit & d1 to ! great displeasure ( ,almighty ,god1 to ! great damage ( ! said ,adam ,=eman1 & aga9/ ! peace40 c4 ,! second c\nt *>g$ a common assault4 ,! ,def5dant plead$--,,n ,,guilty4 ,c\nsel = ! ,prosecution--,mr4 ,,m>ryatt & ,mr4 ,,borl&2 ,solicitor1 ,mr4 ,,h>m]4 ,c\nsel = ! ,def5dant--,mr4 ,,gurney & ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4 ,! ,jury be+ sworn3--,mr4 ,,borl& op5$ ! indictm5t1 z foll[s-- ,may x please y\r ,lord%ip1 ,g5tlem5 ( ! ,jury--,! ,def5dant1 ,john ,*ur*1 /&s indict$ = a misdemean\r4 ,he has plead$ ,n ,guilty1 & y\r *>ge is to enquire :e!r he be ,guilty or ,n ,guilty4 ,he>k5 to ! evid5ce4 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt !n /at$ ! case on ! "p ( ! ,prosecution1 to ! effect foll[+3-- ,may x please y\r ,lord%ip1 ,g5tlem5 ( ! ,jury--,i am extremely sorry to h occasion to /ate to y t ! (f5ce imput$ to ! ,def5dant 7:i* my ,le>n$ ,fri5d1 ,mr4 ,boll&2 simply op5$ z a misdemean\r7 is an assault1 ) ! int5t to commit an unnatural crime2 & ,i am sure1 on an occasion ( ?is nature1 x w\ld be unnecess>y = me to bespeak y\r s]i\s att5tion to a *>ge s s]i\s 9 its consequ5ces to ! ,def5dant4 ,! ,prosecutor 9 ?is case is a y\?1 ab\t eighte5 or n9ete5 ye>s ( age1 ! appr5tice ( a ,pott] at ,vauxhall1 ^: "n is ,patrick4 ,he _h be5 appr5tic$ to him "s "t1 & resid$ 9 8 family4 ,! ,def5dant is a prea*]--n ( ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*1 b ( a ,diss5t+ ,*apel1 n f> di/ant f ,vauxhall1 & ,mr4 ,patrick & 8 family _h be5 9 ! habit ( att5d+ t ,*apel & he>+ ,mr4 ,*ur*'s disc\rses4 ,_! appr5tice us$ frequ5tly to accompany !m to ! ,*apel1 & by t means he became p]fectly acqua9t$ ) ! p]son & voice ( ! ,def5dant1 ,*ur*4 ,he knew him extremely well by "n & description4 ,9 ! mon? ( ,septemb] la/1 ,mr4 ,*ur* compla9$ to ,mr4 ,patrick t he 0 9 ill heal?1 & attribut$ t circum/ance to ! conf9$ situation ( 8 ap>tm5ts ne> to ! ,*apel4 ,be+ ill1 ,mr4 ,patrick1 z a matt] ( civility & att5tion to ! ,prea*] ( ! ,*apel :i* he frequ5t$1 invit$ him to come to ,vauxhall1 :]e he _h a sp>e b$1 mu* at ,mr4 ,*ur*'s s]vice4 ,^u ?is invitation1 ,mr4 ,*ur* came1 & he slept !re on ,monday1 ! #bc;d ( ,septemb]1 = ! fir/ "t4 ,i am n q c]ta9 z to ! precise night he came2 b on ! night ( ! #bf? day ( ,septemb]1 ! transaction occurr$ :i* gave rise to ! pres5t proce$+4 ,mr4 ,patrick _h left t[n on bus9ess1 b n be=e ,mr4 ,*ur* came 9 ! fir/ in/ance2 b dur+ ,*ur*'s /ay he dep>t$ = ! c\ntry4 ,dur+ ! ma/]'s abs5ce1 x became necess>y = ,=eman1 ! appr5tice1 to sleep 9 ! h\se4 ,! only sp>e b$ 0 occupi$ by ,*ur*1 ! ,def5dant1 & !re=e a tempor>y b$ 0 made up = ! appr5tice4 ,he _h a re/+ place made up = him 9 "o ( ! p>l\rs ( ! h\se4 ,x happ5$ t on ! ev5+ :5 ?is transaction took place1 ! ,prosecutor _h be5 /ay+ up to att5d a kiln :i* 0 at "w on ,mr4 ,patrick's premises4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,i am told "o ( y\r witnesses is n[ 9 ,c\rt4 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,i am n aw>e ( t circum/ance4 ,if he is1 he mu/ c]ta9ly g out ( ,c\rt4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,i am told ,mr4 ,patrick is 9 ,c\rt4 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,!n ,i beg he w g out2 & t all ! witnesses w rema9 outside until !y are sev]ally call$4 ,g5tlem51 ,i 0 /at+ to y1 t on ! night 9 "q1 ,mr4 ,patrick w5t out ( t[n on "s bus9ess4 ,an occasional b$ 0 made up = ! appr5tice4 ,mr4 ,*ur* occupi$ ! only sp>e b$-room 9 ! h\se4 ,! appr5tice1 ,i believe1 0 n 9 ! habit ( sleep+ 9 ,mr4 ,patrick's family1 except :5 8 ma/] w5t out ( t[n2 = o!rwise !re w\ld be no occasion to make up a tempor>y b$ = him1 if he 0 9 ! practice ( sleep+ !re4 ,betwe5 twelve & "o o'clock 9 ! morn+1 ! appr5tice retir$ f ! burn+ ( ! kiln1 to take 8 re/ 9 ! b$ ?us assign$ him4 ,he got into b$1 & w5t to sleep almo/ imm$iately2 & at no v great di/ance ( "t1 he 0 awak5$ by ! approa* ( ,mr4 ,*ur* 9 8 b$-room4 ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 n ignorant :]e ! "y man slept & ! mann] 9 :i* he 0 accommodat$4 ,! appr5tice 0 al>m$1 & c]ta9ly _h no d\bt ( :at ,mr4 ,*ur*'s int5tion 0 9 com+ to 8 b$-*amb]4 ,y mu/ he> ! circum/ances f ! witness2 & ,i h v little d\bt t y w be satisfi$ f 8 evid5ce1 & t ( ! o!r witnesses ,i %all h to call1 t ! int5tion ( ! def5dant 0 t imput$ to him by ?is indictm5t4 ,! advances & ov]tures made to ! appr5tice 9 ! way t he w describe to y1 mu/ leave v little d\bt 9 y\r m9d ( ! int5tion ( ! p]son :o w5t into t room4 ,inde$ x w\ld be v difficult to assign any good reason = ,mr4 ,*ur*'s com+ !re4 ,! lad 0 surpris$4 ,he awoke & laid hold ( ! p]son by ! arm1 & call$ out1 8,:o is !re80 ,! ,def5dant said1 9 a feign$ fem99e voice1 8,don't y "k me1 ,adam8 ,i'm y\r mi/ress40--,! lad 0 extremely surpris$ at ?is2 he knew t x 0 n 8 mi/resses voice2 & he knew by hav+ caught hold ( ! %irt sleeve ( ! p]son :o address$ him1 t x 0 n a woman1 b a man4 ,9 consequ5ce ( ?is1 he endeav\r$ to lay hold ( him2 ! ,def5dant h[ev] retir$ f ! room & w5t up /airs4 ,i told y t ! lad _h a tempor>y b$ made up = him 9 ! p>l\r2 & ^u ! def5dant's retir+ f ! room1 ! prosecutor _h a di/9ct opportunity ( see+ 8 p]son2 = x seems t ! door ( ! p>l\r 0 opposite ! fan-light ov] ! /reet door1 ?r\gh :i* a light 0 giv5 by ! lamp 9 ! /reet2 & ^u ! ,def5dant's retir+1 ! prosecutor _h a di/9ct view ( him1 & knew him extremely well to be ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,he h>dly knew h[ to act4 ,he 0 unwill+ to al>m 8 mi/ress at t h\r ( ! night2 n inde$ t x 0 a /ory fit to be m5tion$1 or /at$ to h] at any "t by him4 ,he1 h[ev]1 w5t out ( ! h\se to ! p]son :om he _h left at ! kiln 9 ! pott]y :5 he retir$ to re/4 ,t p]son's "n is ,we/2 & he gave him an acc\nt ( :at _h pass$4 ,we/ 0 = go+ into ! h\se & turn+ ! ,def5dant ,*ur* imm$iately out2 b ! prosecutor said x w\ld occasion an al>m to 8 mi/ress1 & he ?\ght x bett] to po/pone ! bus9ess until ! morn+4 ,accord+ly1 ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 n di/urb$ = t night2 b 9 ! morn+ "s inquiry 0 made by ,mrs4 ,patrick1 :o ask$ :e!r ! prosecutor & ! s]vants _h n be5 di/urb$ 9 ! c\rse ( ! night1 by "s p]sons com+ up or d[n /airs8 ,"s explanation 0 giv5 h] ( ! cause ( ! di/urbance1 b n to ! full ext5t1 x be+ ?\ght adviseable n to expla9 ! :ole to h]1 z ,mr4 ,patrick 0 return+ home t night1 :5 ! prosecutor det]m9$ to detail ! :ole transaction to 8 ma/]4 ,! prosecutor _h giv5 8 mi/ress "s acc\nt ( :at _h occurr$1 b )hold+ f h] t "p :i* he ?\ght improp] = female e>s to he>4 ,mr4 ,patrick h[ev] came home ! next day1 & ! prosecutor told 8 /ory to him2 & on ! foll[+ day sev]al ( ,mr4 ,*ur*'s fri5ds hav+ he>d t ! boy _h told 8 ma/] :at _h occurr$1 came to ,mr4 ,patrick to inquire :at 0 ! ext5t ( ! in=mation he _h receiv$4 ,mr4 ,patrick communicat$ to !m ! :ole ( ! in=mation :i* ! boy _h giv51 & said he ?\ght x necess>y t ,mr4 ,*ur* %\ld expla9 8 conduct4 ,by ?is "t ! ?+ 0 g5]ally kn[n & buzz$ ab\t4 ,"s ( ! congregation 7 desir\s t no proce$+ %\ld be in/itut$ aga9/ ! ,def5dant1 z ! public inve/igation ( su* a transaction w\ld be a disgrace to ! individuals ( ! congregation & to ! cause ( religion itself4 ,:il/ ,mr4 ,patrick & "s ( 8 fri5ds1 :o 7 ( ! same religi\s p]suasion1 7 "s days hesitat+ ab\t :at c\rse to pursue1 ! boy's fa!r came to ! k ( ! transaction2 & he )\t any sort ( c]emony took him be=e a ,magi/rate & laid ! compla9t :i* has giv5 rise to ?is prosecution aga9/ ! ,def5dant1 ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,mu* inquiry has s9ce tak5 place2 & ! ,def5dant has endeav\r$ to expla92 ! transaction z well z he c\ld2 & he has writt5 v>i\s lett]s ^u ! subject4 ,^? lett]s are "h1 & !y are mu* at ,mr4 ,*ur*'s s]vice if he ?9ks !re is any ?+ conta9$ 9 !m :i* w af=d him any def5ce2 because ,i d n ?9k x "r to )hold any ?+ :i* c ?r[ light ^u su* a transaction4 ,among/ o!r ?+s :i* ,mr4 ,*ur* urg$ by way ( explanation1 9 ^! lett]s1 0 a contradiction ( "s ( ! p>ticul>s /at$ ! prosecutor4 ,he said1 t !re 7 "s matt]s 9 ! /atem5t ( ! boy :i* he 0 able to contradict4 ,?is decl>ation ( ,mr4 ,*ur* hav+ come to ! k ( ,mr4 ,patrick1 he 0 induc$ by ! application :i* 0 made to him1 on ! "p ( "s ( ,mr4 ,*ur*'s congregation1 to make "s inquiry ( ,mr4 ,*ur* ^u ! subject4 ,he accord+ly took occasion to h an int]view ) ! def5dant1 = ! purpose ( enabl+ himself1 if he c\ld1 to expla9 8 conduct to ! satisfaction ( ! p]sons :o are 9 ! habit ( att5d+ 8 *apel4 ,at t int]view1 he contradict$ "s ( ! p>ticul>ities /at$ by ! boy1 b :i* are "s ( ! mo/ disgu/+ p>ts ( ! n>rative4 ,he1 h[ev]1 admitt$1 mo/ di/9ctly1 t he _h gone into ! lad's room4 ,n[1 :5 y %all h _h x prov$ 9 evid5ce1 t "p ( ! conduct ascrib$ to him 0 admitt$ by ! def5dant1 ,i %\ld l to "k if he really did g into t b$-room1 = :at possible purpose c\ld he g !re 9 ! middle ( ! night8 ,x w appe>1 /ill fur!r1 t ,*ur* 0 ! only male p]son :o slept 9 ! h\se2 = !re 0 no o!r individual ( ! male sex to take up 8 abode !re t night4 ,! "q1 !n1 w be1 :e!r1 ^u ! evid5ce ,i %all produce1 y c h any reasonable d\bt ( ! def5dant's int5tion to commit ! (f5ce imput$ to him by ?is indictm5t8 ,if y h no d\bt ( ! tru? ( ! boy's /ory--if y h no d\bt t x 0 ! def5dant's int5tion to commit ! atroci\s crime *>g$ ^u him by ?is prosecution1 !n1 h[ev] pa9ful y\r duty may be1 y mu/ n be det]r$ by ! enormity & app>5t impossibility ( su* a crime exi/+ 9 society1 f ! fair & hone/ dis*>ge ( x4 ,!re are two que/ions = y to det]m9e3--,fir/1 :e!r ! def5dant 0 ! p]son :o ent]$ ! prosecutor's room8--&1 ,secondly1 if he did1 :e!r ! atroci\s int5tion1 alleg$ 9 ! indictm5t c cle>ly be inf]r$ f 8 conduct on t occasion8 ,b1 g5tlem51 if y h any reasonable d\bt ^u ei!r ( ^! que/ions1 ,i %\ld n1 z ,c\nsel = ! prosecution1 desire y to pron\nce a v]dict ( guilty4 ,b1 :atev] conclusion y may draw f 8 /atem5t1 submitt$ to y\r consid]ation1 ,i tru/ y w take c>e t y\r indignation aga9/ ! (f5ce itself %all n c>ry y to ! conclusion ( guilt1 unless ! evid5ce ,i %all lay be=e y w>rants ! conviction ( ! def5dant4 ,adam ,=eman1 ! fir/ witness 0 !n call$ & exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,boll&4 ,h[ old are y8--,i %all be tw5ty ! fir/ day ( ,decemb] next4 ,i believe y are an appr5tice to ,mr4 ,patrick1 ! pott]1 ( ,vauxhall8--,yes4 ,h[ long h y be5 ) him8--,ab\t five ye>s4 ,d y "k ! def5dant1 ,john ,*ur*8--,yes1 by sight4 ,h[ long h y kn[n him8--,ab\t two or ?ree ye>s4 ,:at is he8--,a prea*]4 ,h y att5d$ ! congregation 9 ! ,*apel :]e he prea*es8--,yes4 ,& h y (t5 se5 him8--,oh1 yes4 ,d y sleep g5]ally at y\r ma/]s h\se1 or at y\r fa!rs8--,at my fa!r's g5]ally4 ,are !re any occasions ^u :i* y d sleep at y\r ma/]'s h\se8--,yes4 ,:5 is t8--,:5 he goes out ( t[n4 ,:5 y\r ma/] goes out ( t[n1 !n y sleep at 8 h\se8--,yes4 ,:]e did ,*ur* reside8 ,:]e did he live8--,he liv$ by 8 *apel4 ,:]e is t8--,9 ,/4 ,george's ,fields4 ,x comes out ( ! ,bor\gh-road4 ,!re he liv$8--,yes4 ,n[1 did he at any "t come to take up 8 abode at ,mr4 ,patrick's8--,yes4 ,:5 0 t8--,! #be? ( ,septemb]1 he came to sleep !re t night4 ,d y "k :at 0 ! occasion ( 8 com+8 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,t mu/ be ( 8 own k4 ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,mr4 ,patrick w tell u4--,i believe he came-- ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,y mu/ n tell u1 ,sir1 unless y "k x ( y\r own k4 ,h[ev]1 he came to sleep !re8--,yes4 ,did y sleep !re t night8--,yes4 ,0 t ! fir/ night he came8--,i don't "k :e!r he _h be5 !re be=e4 ,i _c say :e!r ,i _h se5 him !re be=e4 ,y "k t he slept !re on ! #be? ( ,septemb]1 & t y 7 !re8--,yes4 ,:]e 0 y\r ma/] t night8--,he 0 out ( t[n2 b :]e1 ,i _c say4 ,:o slept 9 ! h\se t night8--,mr4 ,*ur*1 my mi/ress1 ! *ildr51 & ! two maid s]vants4 ,0 !re any o!r man 9 ! h\se1 except y\rself & ,*ur*8--,no4 ,:]e 0 y\r b$ room8--,! front p>l\r on ! fir/ floor4 ,t is ! gr\nd floor8--,x is ov] ! kit*54 ,is t a b$-room 9 common 9 ! h\se8--,no1 x is n4 ,!n h[ came y to sleep !re8--,because !re 0 n any o!r b$-room t ,i c\ld sleep 94 ,0 a tempor>y b$ !re=e put up = y !re8--,yes4 ,n[1 at :at "t did y retire to re/8--,ne> "o o'clock4 ,:at _h kept y up s late8--,!re 0 a kiln burn+1 & ,i 0 oblig$ to sit up to let ! man into ! kiln :5 he came4 ,0 x necess>y = y to sit up to att5d t kiln8--,yes2 & to give ! key to ! man4 ,:o 0 t man8--,?omas ,we/4 ,& y w5t to b$ ab\t "o o'clock8--,yes4 ,did y g to sleep8--,yes2 directly ,i w5t to b$4 ,aft] y _h be5 asleep1 did any ?+ happ5 to y8--,yes4 ,/ate :at x 08--,i _h n be5 asleep m ?an half an h\r1 be=e ,i 0 awoke by "s "o putt+ 8 h&s "u ! b$ clo!s1 & lay+ hold ( my private p>ts4 ,9 :at way8--,laid hold ( me v tight4 ,did y say any ?+1 or did ! p]son1 :oev] x 01 say any ?+ to y8--,yes4 ,i put my h& out ( ! b$ clo!s1 & caught hold ( him1 & ask$ him :o he 08 ,:at did y say8--,i ask$ him :o he 0--,i said :o are y8 ,& y say y laid hold ( him8--,yes4 ,by :at "p did y lay hold ( him8--,z ne> z ,i c guess x 0 ! upp] "p ( 8 arm4 ,^u lay+ hold ( him1 :at obs]vation did y make8 ,:at did y asc]ta9 f lay+ hold ( ! p]son8 ,c\ld y tell :e!r x 0 a man or a woman8--,i laid hold ( 8 arm1 & felt l[] d[n1 & f\nd by ! sleeve t he _h got a man's %irt on4 ,h[ f> did y feel l[] d[n8--,i _h a hold ( him by ! upp] "p ( ! arm1 & runn+ my h& d[n to ! wri/1 ,i f\nd he _h a man's %irt on4 ,c\ld y tell :e!r ! wri/ 0 button$8--,yes4 ,0 x button$8--,x 04 ,c\ld y tell at all by ! feel ( ! arm itself1 :e!r x 0 ! arm ( a man or a woman8--,i knew v well x 0 a man4 ,c\ld y tell t f ! feel ( ! fle%8--,i c\ld n tell t4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y knew x 0 a man--,by :at circum/ance8--,because he _h got a man's %irt on4 ,y knew x 0 a man by ! %irt8--,yes4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,did ! p]son say any ?+ to y 9 answ] to :at y said8--,he answ]$--8,adam1 don't y "k me8 ,i am y\r mi/ress10 9 a fa9t voice1 l a woman4 ,& 0 x ! voice ( y\r mi/ress1 ,mrs4 ,patrick8--,oh6 no1 sir6 ,c\ld y tell ^: voice x 08--,yes2 ,i knew ! voice directly ,i he>d x4 ,^: voice 0 x8--,mr4 ,*ur*'s4 ,:at did y d aft]w>ds1 & :at did he d8--,he fl$ f ! room directly4 ,:5 y use ! ^w fl$1 :at d y mean by t8--,he w5t out ( ! room4 ,! ^w fl$ indicates m ?an m]ely go+ out ( ! room2 did he g out 9 a hurri$ mann]8--,he w5t out 9 a hurri$ /ep4 ,^u 8 go+ out :at did y d8--,i got out ( b$1 & put on my small clo!s & %oes1 & w5t to ! man up at ! kiln4 ,:at did y d fir/--:5 he w5t out ( ! room--:at did y fir/ d8--,i got out ( b$1 & put on my small clo!s & %oes4 ,did y see him g out ( ! room8--,yes4 ,z he op5$ ! door ,i saw by ! lamp t x 0 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & he _h only 8 %irt on4 ,:]e is t lamp t enabl$ y to see ! p]son ( ,*ur*8--,outside ( ! door4 ,:at door d y mean8--,outside ( ! front /reet door4 ,9 ! /reet8--,yes2 on ! ,t]race4 ,& t lamp ?r[s a light ?r\gh ! fan-light ( ! hall door8--,yes4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,! lamp is at ! /reet door8--,yes1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,is x a gas light or a p>i% light8--,x is a p>i% lamp4 ,x is n "o ( ! new lights8--,no4 ,x is n a gas light8--,no4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,:]e 7 y /&+ at ! "t8--,i 0 gett+ up1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,did y g out ( y\r room8--,yes1 ,i did4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y say t :5 he w5t out ( ! room1 y saw x 0 ,*ur*1 by ! lamp3 :at lamp d y mean8--,! lamp at ! door4 ,:at door8--,! /reet door4 ,:]e 7 y :5 y saw ,*ur* at t "t by ! light ( ! lamp8--,9 b$1 sitt+ up4 ,i _h n !n left my b$4 ,y mu/ h op5$ y\r door8--,no1 my ,"l2 ,*ur* did t4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,:oev] ! p]son 01 he left ! door op51 & y saw him g out ?r\gh t door2 & !n y obs]v$ t he _h a %irt on8--,yes4 ,! %irt or dress ( a man is mu* %ort] ?an t ( a woman1 & !re=e y mu/ h se5 :e!r x 0 a %irt or a %ift8--,x 0 ! %irt ( a man1 ,i am sure4 ,did y see 8 face at all8--,no1 ,i did n4 ,8 back 0 to me4 ,:5 he 0 gone1 :at did y d8--,i !n got up & put my small clo!s on1 & %oes1 & w5t into ! pott]y4 ,:at =8--,to get ! man to come up to ! h\se4 ,did y in=m any body ( :at _h happ5$8--,yes2 ,i told ,?omas ,we/ ( x4 ,by ,,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,he 0 9 ! pott]y8--,yes4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,0 t ! ,?omas ,we/ t 0 9 ! pott]y be=e y w5t to b$8--,yes4 ,cross-exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,gurney4 ,! p]son1 :oev] x 01 y say left ! door op5 beh9d him8--,no2 he op5$ ! door & w5t out4 ,did he %ut ! door aft] him8--,yes4 ,is t s8--,yes4 ,!n1 if he %ut ! door aft] him1 h[ did t enable y to see any ?+ by ! light8--,:5 he op5$ ! door ,i saw him4 ,!re 0 no light 9 ! room8--,no4 ,! light1 z y say1 came f a lamp on ! ,t]race8--,yes4 ,h[ f> is t lamp f ! door8--,betwe5 five & six y>ds f ! door on ! ,t]race4 ,! ,t]race on :i* y\r ma/]'s h\se is situat$1 is a r[ ( h\ses rais$ above ! road8--,yes4 ,& ! lamp is ^u ! ,t]race opposite ! door4--,yes4 ,& ab\t five or six y>ds f ! door8--,yes4 ,! light :i* x giv5 to y\r passage is1 ,i suppose1 ?r\gh ! fan-light ov] ! door8--,yes4 ,!n y mean to say t ! light :i* came ?r\gh t fan-light into y\r passage enabl$ y to see :o x 01 be=e ! p]son _h left ! room8--,:5 he op5$ ! door & w5t out ,i saw him4 ,y say t ! p]son1 :oev] he 01 %ut ! door imm$iately aft]w>ds8--,yes2 b ,i c\ld see him :5 he op5$ ! door4 ,did y see ! face ( ! p]son8--,no4 ,h[ !n c y pret5d to say t y knew :o t p]son 08--,i saw t ! p]son _h a %irt on4 ,d y mean to say t y c di/+ui% a %irt f a %ift or a b$-g[n8--,i saw t x 0 a %irt4 ,i %\ld imag9e t on an occasion ( ?is sort y 7 a little fright5$8--,yes1 ,i 0 r al>m$4 ,wak$ out ( y\r sleep 9 ?is way1 y 7 ( c\rse r al>m$4--,did x n take place all 9 a m9ute8--,yes1 x 0 n long ab\t4 ,did x n take place almo/ in/antane\sly8--,i don't "k h[ long he _h be5 !re be=e ,i awoke4 ,f ! mom5t y awoke1 did x n take place z fa/ z possible8--,yes4 ,n[1 y say y w5t directly to ,we/8--,yes4 ,we/ & y directly came & se>*$ ! h\se = ?ieves8--,yes4 ,we did n "k :e!r any body _h got 9 or n4 ,& w5t & look$ at e *amb] door 9 ! h\se8--,yes2 except ,mr4 ,*ur*'s & my mi/ress's4 ,did y n look at ! door ( ,mr4 ,*ur* & t ( y\r mi/ress8--,yes2 b we did n op5 !m4 ,i suppose !re=e !y 7 bo? ( !m %ut8--,yes4 ,did y f9d any door op58--,no4 ,y look$ at all ! doors 9 ! h\se & f\nd !m all %ut8--,yes2 ! s]vant's door 0 on ! j>4 ,y mean ! maid s]vant's door8--,yes4 ,! o!r doors ( ! h\se 7 all %ut8--,all ! o!r doors 7 %ut4 ,& aft] y & he se>*$ ! h\se all ov]1 y w5t to b$ & he w5t back to ! pott]y8--,no2 he /opp$ :ile ,i put on ! rema9d] ( my clo!s1 & ,i w5t back ) him to ! pott]y1 aft] hav+ lock$ ! door4 ,y w5t ) him to ! pott]y8--,yes4 ,& y say t y told ,we/ ?is /ory directly8--,yes1 ,i told him t ,mr4 ,*ur* came d[n into my room & behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann]4 ,y told him1 ,i take = grant$1 t ,*ur* _h be5 !re1 & laid hold ( y\r private p>ts8--,yes4 ,y told him t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h laid hold ( y\r private p>ts8--,yes4 ,h[ came t to be a reason = y & be se>*+ ! h\se = ?ieves8--,i did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves 9 p>ticul>2 b to se>* if any body 0 9 any ( ! rooms4 ,b ,i ask$ y be=e :e!r y did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves2 & y answ]$ 8,yes40--,are y "r or wrong 9 t8--,i ask$ y be=e :e!r y & he did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves1 & y told me t y did8--,we se>*$ ! h\se3 we look$ all ov] x1 to see if !re 0 any body 9 any ( ! rooms4 ,& !re=e ,i ask$ y expressly :e!r y & he did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves8 & did y n say expressly t y & he _h se>*$ ! h\se = ?ieves8--,we se>*$ ! h\se2 b n = ?ieves 9 p>ticul>4 ,!n y did n ?9k ( ?ieves8--,i did n ?9k ( ?ieves1 because ,i knew :o x 04 ,y did n g into ! maid s]vant's room8--,no1 we look$ 94 ,y did n g 98--,no2 we f\nd ! door op51 & look$ 94 ,!y 71 ( c\rse1 9 b$8--,yes2 "o 0 my si/]4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did ! two maids sleep 9 t room8--,yes1 my ,"l2 "o is my si/]4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,! door be+ aj>1 y pu%$ x 9 a little1 & y saw !y 7 ab$8--,yes4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y speak to !m8--,no4 ,re-exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,boll>d4 ,y say y did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves8--,no2 n = ?ieves4 ,because y knew :o ! p]son 08--,yes4 ,0 ! reason ( y\r se>*+ ! h\se because y wi%$ to be q "r be=e y made ! accusation aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,& y f\nd t !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se8--,we f\nd !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se b ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,0 !re any door or w9d[ op5 at :i* any o!r man c\ld h come 98--,no4 ,n[ ?is light f ! t]race1 did t /rike ?r\gh ! fan-light or w9d[ ov] ! door8--,yes4 ,does x give a pretty fair light to ! hall8--,yes2 x %ews a little light up ! /airs4 ,& at ! "t ! p]son op5$ ! door & w5t out1 0 x at t "t y got ?is view ( 8 p]son8--,yes4 ,exam9$ by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4 ,n[1 y say t he came into ! room--,did y he> him :5 he fir/ came into ! room8--,no4 ,y 7 awak5$1 z ,i und]/& y1 by ! application ( 8 h& to y\r p]son8--,yes4 ,0 he on ! b$1 or /&+ by ! side ( ! b$ on ! floor8--,he 0 /&+ ^u ! floor4 ,:5 he assum$ a feign$ voice1 & said1 8,i am y\r mi/ress10 & :5 y obs]v$ x to be a feign$ voice 9 :i* he 0 speak+1 did y n speak to him by "n1 & say1 8,x is y1 ,mr4 ,*ur*0--7,! ,witness seem$ to hesitate1 z if he _h n und]/ood ! "q7--,h y any difficulty 9 he>+8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,y did n call to him by "n1 or give him to und]/& t y knew :o he 08--,no4 ,did y see any "p ( 8 p]son or any "p ( 8 face f :i* y knew1 9 addition to ! k y d]iv$ at he>+ 8 voice1 t x 0 ! ,def5dant1 ,*ur*8--,yes1 ,i did4 ,:at "p ( 8 p]son did y see t l$ y to believe x 0 ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i saw 8 back z he w5t out ( ! room4 ,did x appe> to be ! height ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,:at height is he8--,i _c say4 ,:at _h he ^u 8 head3 _h he a night-cap8--,he _h a night-cap4 ,0 x a man's night-cap8--,i _c exactly say :e!r x 0 or no2 ,i ?9k x 0 a h&k]*ief ti$ r\nd 8 head4 ,:at sort ( a h&k]*ief 0 x2 0 x a col\r$ h&k]*ief8--,i c\ld n tell t4 ,:5 y & ,we/ se>*$ ! h\se & exam9$ ! diff]5t doors1 did y g to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s door8--,yes2 b we did n t\* x1 nor did we g 94 ,:y did y n call to ,mr4 ,*ur*2 &1 z y 7 ) ,we/1 :y did y n require t ,mr4 ,*ur* %\ld appe>1 9 ord] t y might1 by an imm$iate view1 asc]ta9 :e!r he 0 ! p]son :o _h ent]$ y\r room1 & act$ 9 ! way y h describ$8--,we/ want$ to g into ! room & pull him out4 ,!n1 :5 ,we/ want$ to pull him out1 :y did y n1 at lea/1 call to him8--,because ,i 0 afraid ( di/urb+ my mi/ress2 %e w\ld h be5 v mu* al>m$4 ,_h he ev] any conv]sation ) y1 or did he ev] make any ov]ture ( ?is sort to y be=e ?is "t8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,!re 0 no?+ p>ticul> 9 8 mann] or 9 8 conduct t[>ds y be=e ?is "t8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,!re 0 no?+ p>ticul> 9 8 mann] or conduct t[>ds y be=e ?is "t8--,no4 ,h[ soon did y see him aft] ?is to speak to him8--,i h n spok5 to him at all s9ce4 ,h y nev] spok5 to him s9ce8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,has he n att5d$ be=e a ,magi/rate ) y8--,yes4 ,!re y spoke 9 8 pres5ce1 b n imm$iately to him8--,i spoke 9 8 pres5ce1 b n to him4 ,^u he>+ him at ! ,(fice be=e ! ,magi/rate1 did t confirm ! op9ion y ent]ta9$ ( 8 be+ ! p]son :o ent]$ y\r room8--,i did n he> him speak be=e ! ,magi/rate4 ,y did n he> him speak be=e ! ,magi/rate8--,he did n speak at all be=e ! ,magi/rate4 ,did y give ! same acc\nt be=e ! ,magi/rate t y h n[ done "h8--,yes1 my ,"l4 ,y d n "k :e!r x 0 a h&k]*ief or a night-cap t 0 ^u 8 head8--,i don't "k :e!r x 0 a h&k]*ief or a night-cap4 ,are !re any o!r circum/ances f :i* y c\ld collect t x 0 a man8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,did ! h& cont9ue ^u y\r p]son = any l5g? ( "t1 & = h[ long8--,n aft] ,i wak$ at all4 ,! h& 0 )drawn !n8--,yes4 ,& did ! p]son say any ?+ to y8--,he said t he 0 my mi/ress4 ,by ! height ( ! p]son y saw1 y c\ld asc]ta9 :e!r x 0 or 0 n ! height ( y\r mi/ress1 or any ( ! female "p ( ! h\se8--,yes2 ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 a great deal bigg] ?an any body !re4 ,:at is ! size ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i don't ?9k he is q six foot to my k4 ,is he a tall man or a %ort man8--,he is a talli% /\t man4 ,0 !re light en\gh by ! lamp t y h spok5 ( to see ! outl9e ( ! man s z to be able to say t he 0 a tall p]son8--,yes4 ,:at sort ( a p]son is ,mrs4 ,patrick8--,%e is a v little woman4 ,q a diff]5t p]son f ! p]son y saw 9 ! room8--,o yes1 my ,"l1 q s4 ,! maid1 :o slept 9 ! room ) y\r si/]1 :at 0 h] p]son & size8--,%e 0 ab\t at tall z ,i am--7,! ,witness 0 ab\t five feet sev57--n q s tall4 ,y are sure x 0 n h]8--,o yes1 my ,"l4--,! ,witness )drew4 ,,?omas ,,we/ 0 next sworn4 ,exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4 ,are y workman to ,mr4 ,patrick1 ! ,pott]8--,yes4 ,did y1 on ! morn+ ( ! #bf? ,septemb] la/ relieve ,adam ,=eman at ! kiln8--,i did4 ,ab\t :at "t ( t morn+ did y relieve him8--,ab\t half-pa/ twelve o'clock4 ,y w5t to ! ,pott]y to relieve him8--,yes4 ,did he leave y %ortly aft]w>ds = ! purpose ( go+ to b$8--,yes1 he did4 ,h[ long _h he left y be=e y saw him aga98--,ab\t an h\r4 ,:5 y saw him aga91 0 he dress$ or only "p dress$8--,only "p4 ,:at "p ( 8 dress _h he on8--,he _h 8 small-clo!s1 8 %oes1 & "o /ock+4 ,:5 he came to y 9 t condition1 did he /ate to y any ?+ t _h pass$ s9ce he left y8--,he came to me 9 a v great fright1 & bid me light my c&le2 he appe>$ v mu* al>m$1 & bid me light my c&le1 & come along ) him4 ,:]e 7 y to g ) him8--,up to ! h\se4 ,:at did he /ate to y t _h pass$8--,he told me1 z we 7 go+ along ! g>d51 t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h be5 to him & behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann]4 ,did he expla9 h[8--,no1 he did n4 ,did y g into ! h\se ) him8--,yes2 he unlock$ ! door1 & we w5t 94 ,! door ( :at8--,! back door1 :]e we w5t into ! h\se4 ,! out] door8--,yes4 ,! g>d5 door8--,yes4 ,:5 y got to ! h\se1 :at did y & he d8--,he w5t & put ! rema9d] ( 8 clo!s on4 ,well2 :at did y & he d8--,we w5t & se>*$ e room 9 ! h\se1 beg9n+ at ! bottom1 & go+ on upw>ds to ! top1 except my mi/ress's room & ,mr4 ,*ur*'s4 ,did y g into all ! o!r rooms2 did y op5 !m all8--,we w5t into all ! rooms except ,mr4 ,*ur*'s & ,mrs4 ,patrick's4 ,y did n g into ,mr4 ,*ur*'s room1 or into t ( y\r mi/ress8--,no4 ,did y op5 ! doors ( ^? two rooms8--,we did n op5 ! door ( ei!r ( ^? two rooms4 ,:5 y came to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s door1 did y say any ?+8--,yes2 ,i said1 8,i'll g & pull him out2 %all ,i80 ,! lad said1 8,no10 = fe> ( di/urb+ 8 mi/ress4 ,^u t obs]vation ( ! lad's ab\t di/urb+ 8 mi/ress1 did y =be> go+ into ! room8--,yes1 ,i did4 ,:at became ( ,=eman = ! re/ ( ! night8--,he came along ) me into ! ,pott]y2 he came d[n /airs1 lock$ ! back door1 & /aid ) me ! :ole ( ! rema9d] ( ! night2 he return$ ) me to ! ,pott]y1 & /aid 'til ! morn+4 ,n[1 = :at purpose did y se>* 9 all ! rooms ( ! h\se8--,to see if !re 0 any o!r p]son 9 ! place4 ,did y f9d any w9d[ or door op51 at :i* any body c\ld h got into ! h\se8--,no2 ,i saw !m all close & fa/5$4 ,cross-exam9$ by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4 ,:5 he came to y1 he told y t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h be5 !re2 b did n expla9 :at he _h done8--,no4 ,t y are q sure (8--,yes4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,:at words did he use8--,he only told me t ,*ur* _h behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann] to him4 ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,y _h nev] any intimation t !re 7 ?ieves 9 ! h\se8 ,y did n g to se>* = ?ieves 9 ! h\se8--,:5 he told me t ,*ur* behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann] to him1 ,i w5t to see if !re 0 any o!r p]son 9 ! place4 ,did he n tell y he believ$ !re 7 ?ieves 9 ! h\se8--,no4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,i ?9k y are misl$ by :at ! witness1 ,=eman1 said4 ,x is a m]e =m ( expression4 ,y are go+ ^u a wrong sc5t4 ,! witness did n say1 9 t]ms1 t he believ$ !re 7 ?ieves 9 ! h\se4 ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,t 0 p>ticul>ly m5tion$ by ,=eman 9 8 exam9ation4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,he might h us$ ! ^w ?ieves2 b x is v unimportant4 ,x is giv+ a consequ5ce to a phraze t is 9 v common use1 & means v little4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,i put ! "q to him 9 t]ms1 :e!r he did n g to se>* = ?ieves 9 ! h\se4 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,he adopt$ ! :ole ( ! s5t5ce c]ta9ly1 9 ! answ] he gave to ! "q4 ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,!re 7 two propositions 9 ! "q1 :i* 01 :e!r ,we/ & ! witness did n g directly 9 se>* ( ?ieves8 & ! answ] appli$ to ! fir/ "p ( ! "q--8z to go+ toge!r40 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,x is a v common expression1 & no consequ5ce ought to be atta*$ to x4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,we _h he>d be=e t he _h made use ( t phrase1 & !re=e we 7 desir\s ( que/ion+ him ab\t x4 ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,y are q sure he did n expla9 9 :at way ?is man behav$ to him8--,no4 ,did he say any ?+ l ?is3--8,t he came to 8 b$-side1 & laid 8 h& ^u 8 private p>ts80--,no1 ,sir4 ,?is 0 on ! night ( ! #be? ( ,septemb]8--,yes4 ,y1 ,i believe1 aft]w>ds w5t be=e ! ,magi/rate1 at ! same "t ) ,=eman ! appr5tice8--,yes4 ,to ,union ,hall8--,yes4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did he n 9 ! c\rse ( ! morn+1 :5 /ay+ ) y1 & aft] y _h be5 to ! h\se1 tell y :at ,*ur* _h done to him1 & t he _h laid 8 h& ^u 8 private p>ts8--,no4 ,nev]1 f fir/ to la/8--,no4 ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,pray1 at :at "t 0 x t y w5t be=e ! ,magi/rate ) ?is "y man8 ,0 x at all e>li] ?an ! #ab? ( ,novemb] foll[+8--,i _c say ! day ( ! mon?4 ,0 x n six or sev5 weeks aft]w>ds8--,x 0 "s "t aft]w>ds4 ,0 x n six or sev5 weeks aft]8--,i believe x 04 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,did ! lad !n g ) 8 fa!r8--,yes4 ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,! lad g5]ally slept at home at 8 fa!r's8--,yes4 ,n[1 h[ f> 0 8 fa!r's (f f 8 ma/]'s8--,ab\t a qu>t] ( a mile4 ,did he n sleep at 8 fa!r's ! next night8--,! next b "o he did4 ,& yet x 0 n till ab\t six or sev5 weeks aft] t1 y w5t to ! ju/ice8--,no4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y communicate ) ,mr4 ,patrick ^u ! subject be=e y w5t to ! ,ju/ice4--,no1 my ,"l4 ,mr4 ,patrick sworn4 ,exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,boll&4 ,y are a pott] at ,vauxhall8--,yes4 ,h[ long 0 ! boy1 ,=eman1 ) y8--,ev] s9ce ,i h be5 9 ! pott]y bus9ess1 betwe5 five & six ye>s4 ,did he sleep 9 y\r h\se8--,only occasionally4 ,^u :at occasion is x t he does sleep 9 y\r h\se8 ,:5ev] ,i leave t[n2 & !n he has ! key ( ! pott]y1 !re be+ no o!r male 9 ! h\se4 ,7 y abs5t f home on ! #be? ,septemb] la/8--,yes4 ,0 ! boy on t occasion to sleep 9 y\r h\se8--,yes4 ,:]e _h ! b$ be5 put up = him8--,x 0 a *air-b$ 9 ! front p>l\r2 a tempor>y b$ = a nurse occasionally4 ,d y "k ! def5dant1 ,john ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,:at is he1 & :5 did y become acqua9t$ ) him8--,he is a ,bapti/ prea*]2 & ,i fir/ became acqua9t$ ) him :5 ,i came to ,vauxhall4 ,did y att5d 8 *apel8--,yes4 ,& y s became acqua9t$ ) him8--,yes4 ,:]e 0 8 resid5ce8--,adjo9+ ! *apel4 ,n[1 9 ! mon? ( ,septemb]1 ^u any occasion1 & :at1 did he come to sleep at y\r h\se1 & did y put a b$ up = him8--,yes4 ,on :at occasion 0 x8--,he _h compla9$ ( ill heal? occasionally2 & ?9k+ t he 0 ill1 ,i ask$ him out ( fri5d%ip to take a b$ at my h\se1 suppos+ t ! air w\ld be ( s]vice to him4 ,y live ne> ! riv]8--,no2 n v close4 ,y say y 7 out f home on ! #be? ( ,septemb]4 ,:5 did y return8--,on ! ev5+ ( ! #bf?4 ,^u y\r return1 did ! boy1 ,=eman1 make any communication to y8--,he did ! next morn+ :5 ,i saw him4 ,i return$ on ! ev5+ ( ! #bf?4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,!n x 0 ! day b "o aft]1 namely1 ! morn+ ( ! #bg? t ! boy made ! communication to y8--,yes1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,did y see ,=eman on ! night ( y\r return8--,n to speak ) him4 ,b on ! morn+ ( ! #bg? he made ! communication to y8--,yes4 ,respect+ ?is transaction8--,yes1 respect+ ?is transaction4 ,:at did y d ^u ! boy's mak+ t communication8--,i told him ,i 0 extremely sorry = :at _h happ5$4 ,y ne$ n tell u :at y told him4 ,did y make x kn[n8--,i _h _m applications f ! ,congregation1 to :om ,i made x kn[n4 ,did ! communication come fir/ f y1 or did !y apply to y = in=mation8--,9 consequ5ce ( ! in=mation !y _h receiv$ f g5]al report1 !y appli$ to me = au!ntic in=mation4 ,sev]al ( ! ,congregation made ^? applications8--,yes4 ,:at reque/ 0 made to y1 & 9 consequ5ce ( t reque/ 0 !re any meet+ ^u ! subject8--,yes4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,unless ,*ur* 0 pres5t1 ?is _c be receiv$ z evid5ce4 ,! ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,& ev5 if he 0 pres5t ,i appreh5d x _c be receiv$1 unless x is evid5ce ( a fact4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,x is no evid5ce ( a fact2 b 9 consequ5ce ( some?+ said by ! ,congregation respect+ ?is subject1 ! witness did some?+4 ,! "q may be put 9 t %ape4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,if my le>n$ ,fri5d goes to t1 ,i h no objection to t "q4 ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,i 0 go+ on to put t "q1 if ,i _h n be5 /opt by my le>n$ ,fri5d4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,9 consequ5ce ( applications made to y f ! ,congregation1 did y g to ! ,def5dant1 ,*ur*8--,i did4 ,:at did y /ate to ,*ur*2 & :5 did y g to him ^u ?is subject8--,i ?9k x 0 on ! #i? ( ,octob]4 ,_h !re n be=e t be5 a meet+ ( ! ,congregation1 at :i* y 7 pres5t8--,no4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y take any /eps betwe5 ! #bg? ( ,septemb]1 to see ,*ur*1 & ! #i? ( ,octob]1 ^u ?is subject8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,t 0 ! fir/ communication y _h ) ,*ur* ^u ?is subject8--,yes4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,:at did y say to him1 or he to y1 ^u y\r go+ to him8--,he took x extremely k9d ( me 9 call+ ^u him4 ,i told him he might take x z he pleas$2 t ,i did n come will+ly1 b t "s ( 8 ,congregation ?\ght t ,i ought to see him on ! bus9ess4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did he appe> to be appriz$ ( ! subject be=e y began8--,i _c say t1 my ,"l1 exactly4 ,b ,i believe he 0 appriz$ f :at aft]w>ds occurr$4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,:at pass$ on t occasion betwe5 y & him8--,i told him ,i wait$ ^u him1 hav+ se5 a lett] :]e9 he d5i$ ?ree p>ticul> po9ts ( ! boy's /atem5t2 & ,i wi%$ to "k :at ^? po9ts 74 ,y told him y _h se5 a lett] t he _h writt5 ^u ! subject8--,yes4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y told him y _h se5 a lett] ^u ! subject1 9 :i* he d5i$ ?ree p>ticul> po9ts ( ! boy's /atem5t8--,yes4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,:at did he say to t8--,he said t he d5i$ hav+ hold ( ! boy1 or ! boy hav+ hold ( him2 or he1 ,*ur*1 say+1 t he 0 ! boy's mi/ress4 ,he d5i$ ! boy hav+ hold ( him1 or t he1 ,*ur*1 hav+ said t he 0 ! boy's mi/ress8--,yes4 ,did he say :e!r or n he 0 9 ! room8--,he admitt$ t fact4 ,b d5i$ ! lay+ hold ( ! boy's private p>ts8--,yes4 ,he d5i$ ! lay+ hold4 ,did he /ate any reason = be+ 9 ! room8--,n at all4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,:5 y say t he admitt$ be+ 9 ! room1 w y1 z f> z y c1 /ate ! words3 /ate :at he said8--,he said t he d5i$ ?ree p>ticul> po9ts1 two ( :i* ,i h already nam$4 ,! o!r 0 some?+ t did n occur to me to be important1 & :i* ,i did n take any notice (1 & consequ5tly ,i d n rememb] x4 ,i told him t ( ^! two po9ts1 t ,i h m5tion$1 ! boy 0 positive1 & ,i _h no reason to d\bt any ?+ t ! boy _h said1 z ,i _h nev] kn[n him to tell a lie4 ,he said t he 0 sorry = x1 because t confirm$ anci5t reports4 ,i told him x did s2 & ( c\rse ,i told him t n[ ,i %\ld believe all t ,i _h he>d h]et(ore2 & ,i wi%$ him a good morn+4 ,n[ did y see him at any "t aft]w>ds8--,n to speak to him4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y h se5 him1 b n spok5 to him s9ce8--,i h n spok5 to him s9ce1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,:at lett] 0 x t y _h se5 :i* y spoke to him ab\t8--,a lett] dat$ ! #f? ( ,octob]1 address$ to a ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 ,i took an exact copy ( x4 ,mr4 ,h>m] has x4 ,is t ! copy8 7,a pap] put into ! witness's h&47 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,i _c see h[ ?is c be evid5ce1 until !y prove ! orig9al to be de/roy$4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,?is is only a provisional "q4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,is t ! copy8--,yes1 x is an exact copy4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y read t copy ( ! lett] to him8--,no1 my ,"l1 ,i _h n ! copy at t "t4 ,by ,mr4 ,,borl&4--,:at did y /ate to him respect+ ! lett]8--,i told him ,i wi%$ to "k :at ! ?ree ?+s 7 :i* he c\ld d5y1 z ass]t$ by ! boy8 ,y don't recollect ! ?ird po9t8--,no4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y say x is n mat]ial8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,& y say he admitt$ be+ 9 ! room1 b d5i$ ! lay+ hold8--,yes4 ,9 :at t]ms did he admit t he 0 9 ! room8--,he said1 8,i 0 9 ! room2 b ,i did n lay hold ( ! boy40 ,by ,,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did he say :y he 0 9 ! room8--,no1 my ,"l4 ,:at did y d ) ! lett] ( ! #f? ( ,octob]8--,i return$ x to ,mrs4 ,hunt]4 ,f :om did y get x8--,f ,mrs4 ,hunt]4 ,& to ,mrs4 ,hunt] y return$ x8--,yes4 ,cross-exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,gurney4 ,y mean to say t he said di/9ctly to y t he 0 9 ! room8--,yes4 ,did y m5tion to any p]son aft] y _h se5 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 t he 0 n implicat$ 9 ! affair at all8--,no4--,t ,i said he 0 n implicat$8--,no6 ,i nev] said any su* ?+4 ,did y give any p]son an acc\nt ( ! conv]sation y _h ) him1 & accompany t acc\nt ) ?is obs]vation1 8,he is n at all implicat$08--,nev]4 ,n to any p]son8--,no2 n to any p]son4 ,did any p]son g ) y to ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,mr4 ,?omas w5t to ! door ) me4 ,is he a fri5d ( y\r's8--,he is no fri5d ( m9e4 ,i _h only se5 him at ! door4 ,x 0 8 wife & m9e t wi%$ me to make ! application to ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,!n ,mr4 ,?omas w5t ) y z f> z ! door1 b did n g 9 ) y8--,no4 ,d y recollect hav+ any conv]sation ) ,mr4 ,?omas1 9 :i* y told him :at _h tak5 place betwe5 y & ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i told him briefly :at _h transpir$2 x 0 v %ort :at did transpire4 ,& y told ,mr4 ,?omas :at _h transpir$ at ! int]view ) ,mr4 ,*ur*1 :5 y came out8--,yes4 ,!n did y tell ,mr4 ,?omas t ,mr4 ,*ur* admitt$ hav+ be5 9 ! room8--,i ?9k ,i did2 b ,i am n v positive z to t po9t4 ,i "k ,i told him t ,mr4 ,*ur* said t he did n lay hold ( ! boy4 ,! "q ,i wi% to put to y is ?is--:e!r ,mr4 ,?omas did n ask y ?is "q1 8,well1 is !re any ?+ aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*1 or n80--& :e!r y did n answ]1 8,no1 he is n at all implicat$80--,i nev] made any su* answ] to him4 ,nei!r t1 nor any ?+ convey+ t mean+8--,nev]4 ,by ,,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y nev] did tell him1 directly or indirectly1 t !re 0 no?+ to implicate ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,no1 nev]4 ,by ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,did y ei!r tell ,mr4 ,?omas1 or any o!r p]son t y w\ld prosecute ,mr4 ,*ur*1 because he _h said disgraceful ?+s ( y\r wife8--,i did2 b n = ?is crime1 b = defamation ( my wife's "*4 ,by ,,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y told ,mr4 ,?omas t y int5d$ to prosecute ,mr4 ,*ur* = defam+ y\r wife's "*8--,i don't "k t ,i ev] told ,mr4 ,?omas2 b ,i believe ,i h said t1 or words to t effect1 to o!r p]sons4 ,by ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,did y n tell ,mr4 ,?omas t y 7 det]m9$ to prosecute ,*ur* = hav+ said disrespectful ?+s ( y\r wife8--,i may h told him among/ o!r p]sons4 ,did y n m5tion t1 among/ o!r ?+s1 on t v morn+ t y _h ! int]view ) ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,no2 c]ta9ly n4 ,"s o!r "t ,i might4 ,by ,,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,0 x aft] t morn+8--,yes1 my ,"l1 x mu/ h be5 a consid]able "t aft] t4 ,re-exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,boll&4 ,:at did y in=m him t y int5d$ to in/itute a prosecution aga9/ ,*ur* =8--,= defamation ( my wife's "*4 ,,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,t ,i suppose is y\r case8 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,no1 my ,"l1 ,i am go+ to call ,mrs4 ,hunt]4 ,mrs4 ,,hunt] sworn4 ,exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4 ,i believe y are an att5dant among/ ! congregation1 & a he>] ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,did he at any "t write to y1 e>ly 9 ! mon? ( ,octob] la/8--,i receiv$ a lett] 9 ! beg9n+ ( ! mon? ( ,octob]1 b !re 0 no "n to x4 ,!re 0 no place ( abode giv51 or any ?+ except ! day ( ! mon?8--,no4 ,did y "k f :om x came8--,i _c tell4 ,did y put t lett] into ! h&s ( ,mr4 ,patrick8--,i gave x to ,mr4 ,patrick's daught]1 :o gave x to h] fa!r4 ,0 t lett] return$ to y aga98--,x 02 b ,i took no f>!r notice ( x4 ,0 t lett] return$ to y aga98--,yes4 ,y _h a subpna duces tecum to produce x8--,i _h b x is impossible to produce x4 ,:y is x impossible to produce x8--,i w tell y :y4 ,aft] ! lett] 0 return$ to me1 ,i took no fur!r notice ( x4 ,i put x into a draw]2 b ,i "k no m ?an 8 ,lord%ip :at is become ( x2 ,i look$ = x on ! ,?ursday morn+ be=e ,i came1 b ,i c\ld f9d no scraps ( x4 ,i 0 n able to f9d x4 ,!n y 7 :olly unable to f9d x8--,i 04 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y se>* dilig5tly to f9d x8--,i did1 inde$1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,are y conv9c$ !re 0 no "n to x8--,i am4 ,are y acqua9t$ ) ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h& writ+8--,i h se5 8 writ+1 & ,i h se5 x writt5 9 a diff]5t h&3 n always alike1 b sometimes v diff]5t3 n to say exactly two diff]5t h&s1 b su* a diff]5ce 9 ! same h& writ+1 t y w\ld h>dly ?9k x 0 ! same4 ,i h se5 x s diff]5t1 at times1 t ,i %\ld n at all times ?9k x 0 ! same4 ,^u receiv+ ! lett] 9 "q1 ^: h& writ+ did y believe x to be1 & /ate x to be8 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,i submit to y\r ,lord%ip1 t ?is is n a legal "q4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,x is n evid5ce ( ! fact3 b x is a prop] "q to refre% h] recollection1 z to :e!r %e did n receive a lett] :i* %e believ$ to be ! h& writ+ ( ! def5dant4 ,by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,^: h& writ+ did y ?9k t lett] to be8--,i r ?9k x 0 ,mr4 ,*ur*'s1 b ,i c\ld n be positive1 z !re 0 no "n to x4 ,d y n[ believe t lett] to be ,mr4 ,*ur*'s writ+4--,i _c say :e!r x 0 or 0 n4 ,x is n 9 my p[]4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y are n ask$ :e!r x 0 or 0 n3 b :at y\r belief 0 !n1 & :at x is n[8--,i believ$ at t "t1 ,i mu/ own1 t x 0 8 h& writ+1 & ,i /ill believe ! same4 ,by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,did y n !n believe x to be ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h& writ+8--,i did r ?9k x 04 ,did y1 or n1 believe x 08--,is !re any diff]5ce betwe5 ?9k+ & believ+8 ,t is a phrase we sometimes use 9 c\rts ( ju/ice4 ,i c\ld n be positive2 b ,i r ?9k x 0 8 h& writ+4 ,:5 y op5$ x1 did y read x z a lett] com+ f him8--,i 0 v mu* /ruck ) ! simil>ity1 = x _h v mu* ! appe>ance ( 8 h& writ+2 b1 z no "n 0 subscrib$ at ! bottom1 ,i c\ld n be c]ta94 ,x _h ! appe>ance ( 8 h& writ+4 ,is x y\r belief n[1 t x 0 or 0 n1 8 h& writ+8--,x is exactly ! same z x 0 !n4 ,& x is n[ y\r belief t x 0 8 h& writ+8--,i _c say ,i firmly believe x1 because x 0 n sign$4 ,y are only ask$ :e!r y s act$ z if x 0 8 h& writ+8--,i did n communicate x to anybody b ,mr4 ,patrick4 ,did y communicate to ,mr4 ,patrick t y _h receiv$ a lett] f ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i did4 ,cross-exam9$ by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4 ,! se>* :i* y made = ?is lett] 0 n until la/ ,?ursday8--,exactly s4 ,= any ?+ y "k1 might x n be 9 y\r h\se n[8--,i h no reason to believe t x is1 = ,i did n leave a draw] or place unse>*$4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,z f> z evid5ce c g ( ! loss ( an orig9al lett]1 to let 9 ! copy1 we h x 9 ?is case2 = ,i ask$ h] :e!r %e made dilig5t se>* aft] ! orig9al1 & %e says1 %e has made dilig5t se>*4 ,mr4 ,patrick exam9$ aga9 by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4 ,7 y acqua9t$ 9 ,octob] la/ ) ! h&-writ+ ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,y told u y made ?is copy f ! lett] y _h f ,mrs4 ,hunt]4 ,0 ! lett] f :i* y made ?is copy1 & :i* y return$ to ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 9 y\r belief1 ! h&-writ+ ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,x 04 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,n[1 my ,"l1 ,i propose read+ ?is copy ( ! lett] 9 "q4 ,! foll[+ lett] 0 !n read 9 evid5ce3-- 8,octob] #f1 #ahaf4 8,,de> ,,mrs4 ,,hunt]1 8,my he>t is already too mu* affect$4 ,y\r lett] only adds affliction to my bonds4 ,b ,i =be>4 ,i w\ld h call$ on y ?is morn+1 b ,i 0 too l[ 9 m9d to speak to any fri5d b ,jesus6 ,!re ,i am truly com=table4 ,p>don me2 b ,i make no rem>ks on :at y h be5 told4 ,i mu/ be> x1 ?\gh ,i am able to contradict ?ree ?+s ,i w\ld r n4 ,mr4 & ,mrs4 ,patrick h always dealt k9dly to me4 ,i am only griev$ t de> ,mrs4 ,p4 :om ,i really lov$1 t %e %\ld try to injure me 9 ! e/imation ( ^? :o are real fri5ds to my de> *ildr54 ,! ?\ght affects me4 ,:y hurt my poor family8 ,b ,i am too mu* depress$ to enl>ge4 ,i %all nev] =get _! k9dness4 ,god w rew>d !m1 z he has _m :o h dealt well to me4 ,b he w res5t cruelty 9 ^? :o h & are /ill try+ to degrade me4 ,mrs4 ,p4 w live to see x4 ,de> ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 ,i am griev$ at he>t ,i _c relieve y\r m9d4 ,i am truly sorry to lose y z a he>]1 because y\r s\l has be5 ble/2 & y "k bo? ! plague ( ! he>t & ! value ( ,jesus4 ,may he be increas+ly pres5t to y 9 8 p]son1 love1 & grace6 ,f>ewell1 my de> k9d fri5d6 ,! ,"l ,jesus w rew>d y = y\r love to me1 & y\r k9dness to m9e4 ,god is n unrighte\s to =get y\r "w ( fai? & lab\r ( love4 ,) _m te>s ,i write ?is4 ,may we meet 9 glory1 :5 no enemy %all di/ress my m9d1 nor s9 nor dea? %all "p u m6 ,i ne$ n rem9d my de> fri5d t ,i am a ,*ild ( ,peculi> ,provid5ce2 & t he>t ( et]nal love1 & t arm ( inv9cible p[] has protect$ me--has call$ me to himself2 & = e act ( /ray+1 w correct me ) 8 own h&1 b w res5t e o!r h&1 soon] or lat]4 ,?is y w live to see4 8,adieu1 de> fri5d1 accept ! />t+ te>1 8,& ! be/ wi%es ( a he>t s9c]e4 8,y\r's1 truly1 8,till we %all meet above40 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4--,my ,"l1 t is ! case on ! "p ( ! prosecution4 ,,def5ce4 ,mr4 ,,gurney !n address$ ! ,jury on ! "p ( ! def5dant1 z foll[s3-- ,may x please y\r ,lord%ip-- ,g5tlem5 ( ! ,jury--,g5tlem51 ,i mu/ agree ) my ,le>n$ ,fri5d1 9 entreat+ y to be/[ y\r mo/ s]i\s att5tion ^u ?is case1 & 9 reque/+ y to consid] 7:i*1 inde$1 my ,le>n$ ,fri5d fairly confess$ y ought to be> 9 m9d71 t z ! *>ge is heavy ! pro( ought to be cle>2 & t y w take c>e t y\r indignation aga9/ ! crime %all h no influ5ce ^u y\r judgm5t respect+ ! p]son accus$4 ,t is a duty1 ,g5tlem51 :i* is "o ( ! mo/ important1 = a ,juryman to att5d to 9 ?is species ( case1 b x 9 "o ( mo/ difficult p]=mance2 = su* is1 & su* ,i tru/ ev] w be1 ! feel+ ( abhorr5ce :i* ,engli%m5 ent]ta9 aga9/ ?is dete/able crime1 t x is extremely difficult inde$1 :5 a p]son is accus$ ( x1 to consid] ! case :i* 9 laid be=e u1 9 t dispassionate & unprejudic$ mann]1 :i* is ess5tial to ! adm9i/ration ( ju/ice4 ,we all wi% t no su* occurr5ces c\ld exi/2 & if a wi% c\ld blot !m out ( exi/5ce1 we %\ld be almo/ tempt$ to =m t wi%3 b1 ,g5tlem51 :5 ^! cases d come be=e u1 !y claim our v s]i\s att5tion2 & m p>ticul>ly on ?is acc\nt1 t x is a *>ge :i*1 :5ev] made ^u an individual1 dep5ds almo/ always ^u ! te/imony ( "o witness1 & :]e !re is b "o witness to make ! accusation1--,i mean "o witness to ! fact *>g$1 s t ! p]son accus$ c h no witness 9 8 def5ce2--t1 h[ev] innoc5t a man may be :o is accus$ ( ?is crime1 provid$ ! p>ty is 9 a situation 9 :i* he _c %ew t he 0 fifty miles (f at ! "t1 x is q impossible = him to h a witness to negative ! fact4 ,x mu/ /& or fall ^u ! te/imony ( ! pr9cipal witness1 ^: te/imony1 h[ev]1 ,i ne$ n tell y1 is to be wat*$ mo/ scrupul\sly1 & to be comp>$ ) ! evid5ce ( o!r witnesses2 & if f\nd inconsi/5t ) ! te/imony ( o!r witnesses1 x is h>dly !n to be c>ri$ to ! ext5t ( full cr$5ce & ( conviction4 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 ! /ory :i* ?is "y man has told y1 is1 ^u 8 /atem5t1 a v extraord9>y "o1 ( ! attack made ^u him4 ,7 any attack made ^u him by ,mr4 ,*ur*1 x w\ld inde$ be mo/ extraord9>y "u ! circum/ances :i* he has /at$4 ,he repres5ts himself to h be5 previ\sly acqua9t$ ) him--t he _h be5 "o ( 8 he>]s--& yet f ! h\r ( t acqua9tance comm5c+1 to ! mom5t ( ?is suppos$ abom9able attack1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h nev]1 ei!r by ^w or ge/ure1 made any indec5t ov]ture to him ( any k9d1 signify+ 8 int5tion1 or _h done any ?+ :atev] to asc]ta9 if he1 ! prosecutor1 0 ready to gratify any brutal ( unnatural passion he might =m4 ,n[1 x is a v extraord9>y ?+1 t x %\ld be suppos$1 t a p]son %\ld get out ( 8 own b$1 & g to ! b$ ( ano!r1 & comm5ce ! attack ) ! indec5cies describ$ by ! witness1 )\t any prep>ation ( any k9d :atev]1 )\t hav+ any reason to believe1 t ! object ( 8 attack w\ld acc$e to 8 base1 & unnatural purposes1 ) ! full k1 7"o %\ld ?9k17 t he 0 enc\nt]+ c]ta9 detection & puni%m5t1 by ! resi/ance t e man w\ld be likely to make1 to su* an abom9able attack2 & x is1 to be sure1 mo/ extraord9>y to obs]ve 9 :at mann] ?is is done4 ,! "y man /ates t he did n see ! face ( ! p]son--t he felt ! arm1 & f\nd t x 0 a %irt sleeve2 b he did n feel any "p ( ! fle%1 s z to make any di/9ction betwe5 male und female2 b he concludes t x 0 ! %irt ( a man1 because ! arm 0 cov]$ d[n to ! wri/4 ,& :5 my ,le>n$ ,fri5d1 ,mr4 ,m>ryatt1 suppos$ t females are n cov]$ d[n bel[ ! elb[1 ,i h only to say1 t ,i c]ta9ly always ?\ght t females 9 _! night clo!s 7 cov]$ d[n to _! wri/s4 ,i ev] und]/ood t 0 ! case2 & !re=e a p]son awak5$ out ( sleep1 9 ! fright t su* a circum/ance 0 likely to produce1 & f9d+ ! arm ( ! p]son mak+ ! attack cov]$ d[n to ! wri/1 w\ld n1 ,i ?9k1 be v well able to say :e!r x 0 ! sleeve ( a %irt or t ( a woman's b$-g[n2 & t is all ! means ( k :i* ! witness has1 z f> z reg>ds feel+ ! p]son4 ,n[ ,i g on to ! next evid5ce ( id5tity4 ,! next is ! voice ( ! p]son :o1 he tells u1 said 9 a feign$ female voice1 8,don't y "k me1 ,adam8 ,i am y\r mi/ress40 ,n[1 recollect1 ,g5tlem51 ! voice1 x is ?\ght1 is a female voice2 & :e!r x be feign$ or n1 dep5ds ^u 8 judgm5t & capacity ( =m+ an op9ion at a mom5t :5 he 0 9 ! greate/ al>m & agitation2 because if x 0 a female voice1 !n ! voice 0 n feign$1 & x c\ld n be ,mr4 ,*ur* :o 0 9 ! room4 ,n[1 ,i don't mean to sugge/ 7f> be x f me7 t x 0 ,mrs4 ,patrick2 b x is r extraord9>y & some:at rem>kable1 consid]+ ! indu/ry & ! acrimony ) :i* ?is case has be5 got up aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*1 t !y %\ld n h produc$ ,mrs4 ,patrick z a witness1 & t !y %\ld ?9k x "r to )hold f y\r obs]vation ! o!r maid s]vant1 :o slept ) ,adam ,=eman's si/]4 ,i ?9k x is r rem>kable1 t consid]+ ! indu/ry ) :i* ,i "k ?is case 0 got up1 !y h n ?\ght fit to produce t o!r female be=e y z a witness 9 ord] to say1 8,i 0 n out ( my b$ room t night1 & ,i did n g into ! appr5tices b$ room40 ,n[1 ,i ?9k1 t consid]+ t ! ,prosecutors mu/ h be5 aw>e ( ! p[]ful effect ( su* evid5ce1 x is mo/ surpris+ t !y did n call =w>d ! o!r p]sons 9 ! h\se t night z witnesses1 = ! purpose ( %ew+1 by _! te/imony1 t !y rema9$ 9 _! b$s dur+ ! :ole ( t night1 & = ! purpose ( giv+ "s col\r ( probability to ?is v extraord9>y & incr$ible /ory4 ,b1 no1 ,g5tlem51 !y *oose to leave ! case to ! te/imony ( a fright5$ "y man1 wak5$ out ( 8 s\nd sleep1 & :o1 )\t see+ ! face ( ,mr4 ,*ur*1 v5tures to swe> t ! feign$ female voice :i* he he>d 0 t ( ! ,def5dant4 ,i ?9k1 ,g5tlem51 9 a case 9 :i* e ?+ dep5ds1 n s mu* ^u 8 v]acity1 b ^u ! accuracy ( 8 judgm5t 9 ! c\rse ( 8 obs]vation ^u circum/ances1 ) respect to :i* he 0 v little likely to draw any v accurate conclusions1 t t s]vant ought to h be5 produc$ "h1 ! m especially :5 ! "y man f ! ,pott]y1 go+ aft]w>ds ?r\gh ! h\se = ! purpose ( see+ :o 0 !re1 did f9d ! female s]vant's door aj>2 a circum/ance n obs]vable ) respect to any o!r room 9 ! h\se4 ,n[1 ,i come to ! next obs]vation ( id5tity2 & ,i d ?9k x is a mo/ extraord9>y "o4 ,!re is a lamp1 x seems1 9 ! footpa? ( ! t]race1 five or six y>ds f ! door4 ,my ,le>n$ ,fri5d1 ,mr4 ,boll&1 inquir$ :at sort ( a lamp x 0--:e!r x 0 a p>i% lamp1 or a gas light8 ,& he f\nd by ! answ]1 t x 0 ! wor/ k9d ( lamp 9 ! ,metropolis--a p>i% lamp4 ,well1 !n1 !re is a dull p>i% lamp1 five or six y>ds f ! door1 :i* gives a light ?r\gh a l>ge w9d[--,no1 ?r\gh a fan-light6 & ! p]son1 :oev] x is1 op5s ! door to g out1 &1 z ! door is op5$ ! ,lad sees t ! p]son has a %irt on4 ,n[1 ,i beg to ask y1 z m5 ( s5se & ( exp]i5ce 9 ! _w1 :e!r x 0 possible = him to see :e!r t g>m5t 0 a %irt1 a %ift1 or a b$-g[n--0 x possible8 ,recollect1 ! light is n 9 ! room--!re is "s light 9 ! passage4 ,! back ( ! p]son is t[>ds him2 & he is to tell y t x is ,mr4 ,*ur*1 al?\gh he only saw 8 back6 ,b !n ! next obs]vation aft] ! %irt1 is z to ! height ( ! p]son4 ,:y1 ,g5tlem51 no?+ magnifies m ?an fright3 no?+6 ,we1 all ( u1 h (t5 he>d ! descriptions ( p]sons 9 great fright4 ,!y always magnify ! objects !y see4 ,if a p]son is robb$1 ! ?ief is a mon/r\s tall man6 ,:y1 ,g5tlem51 fright does magnify e object2 &1 !re=e1 we mu/ make all[ances = ! situation 9 :i* ?is "y man 0 plac$ at ! "t4 ,he is di/urb$ 9 8 sleep--! ?+ happ5s 9 a mom5t--& he sits up 9 8 b$ 9 a great fright--& he tells y x is ,mr4 ,*ur*1 because ( ! height ( ! p]son he saw4 ,n[ if y c say t a p]son 9 t /ation is capable ( di/+ui%+ betwe5 a tall & a %ort p]son1 ,i ?9k x is a great deal too mu* 9 a case ( ?is sort4 ,b :at has ! p]son on 8 head8 ,my ,"l ,ell5bor\gh ask$ ! "q1 :e!r x 0 a man's or woman's night-cap8 & he says1 8,i _c tell :e!r x 0 a night-cap or a h&k]*ief40 ,& ^u be+ ask$ ! col\r1 he says1 8,i _c tell40 ,& !re does n seem to be light en\gh to di/+ui% :e!r x 0 :ite or col\r$4 ,f ?is circum/ance1 !re=e1 ,g5tlem51 y w judge :at sort ( light !re 0 to di/+ui% objects4 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 we come to ! confirmation ( ?is extraord9>y /ory1 p>ticul>ly by ,mr4 ,patrick4 ,x is q cle> t ,mr4 ,patrick has conceiv$ "s great ang] aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*1 on acc\nt ( suppos$ sl&] ( ! "* ( 8 wife4 ,mr4 ,patrick himself is q satisfi$ t 8 wife is n guilty1 any m ?an ! maid s]vant4 ,b ,mr4 ,patrick is angry1 because he says1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* has sl&]$ ! "* ( 8 wife4 ,:y !n1 ,mr4 ,patrick goes to ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & he has "s conv]sation ) him4 ,he tells him t he has se5 "s lett]1 b he does n m5tion :at lett]--he has se5 "s lett] 9 :i* he1 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 has said t he c\ld d5y ?ree po9ts 9 ! boy's /ory3 & he puts que/ions to him1 & he /ates to y1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* hav+ di/9ctly d5i$ ! indec5t attack ^u ! boy1 yet t he nev]!less admitt$ t he 0 9 ! room4 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 ^u t subject ,i mu/ necess>ily give y "s evid5ce1 z well z ^u ano!r "p ( ?is case2 = ,i und]/& t ,mr4 ,patrick di/9ctly /at$ to ,mr4 ,?omas1 :o accompani$ him z f> z ! h\se ( ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & :om he jo9$ directly aft] he came out1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 n at all implicat$2 = on t occasion ,mr4 ,?omas said to him1 8,well1 is !re any ?+ aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*80 ,^u :i* ,mr4 ,patrick answ]$ 8,no3 ,mr4 ,*ur* is n all implicat$40 ,mr4 ,patrick has d5i$ x4 ,i am told t ,mr4 ,?omas w positively /ate t to h occurr$4 ,i am told s4 ,!n1 ,g5tlem51 if ,mr4 ,patrick be contradict$ 9 t mo/ mat]ial circum/ance--if y discr$it him ^u t "p ( ! case1 h[ c y give him cr$it 9 t "p ^u :i* my lead$ fri5d fa/5$1 z ! confirmation ( ! /ory ( ! boy--8t he admitt$ to ,mr4 ,patrick1 t he _h be5 9 ! boy's room40 ,b ! contradiction w n end !re1 ,g5tlem54 ,y h already "o v important contradiction 9 ! case2 = ! boy w5t directly to ! ,pott]y1 & he made a communication to ,we/2 & ,i ask$ him di/9ctly1 & m ?an once1 :e!r he /at$ to ,mr4 ,we/ t ! p]son :o attack$ him 9 ! mann] he _h describ$1 _h 8 h& ^u 8 private p>ts8 & he said t he _h di/9ctly told ,mr4 ,we/1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h laid 8 h& on 8 private p>ts3 b1 :5 ,we/ came to be exam9$1 he told u t ! boy did tell him t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann] to him3 b t he nev]1 be=e ! se>* 0 made1 nor 9 ! c\rse ( ! night1 nor f fir/ to la/1 said a ^w to him ab\t t circum/ance4 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 t is a v /rong contradiction ( ! /ory told y to-day by ?is man2 & if t induces y to disbelieve him1 or to d\bt respect+ 8 evid5ce1 x w be impossible = y to f9d ! ,def5dant guilty ( ?is *>ge4 ,g5tlem51 ,i ask$ ! boy at fir/1 :e!r1 in/ead ( go+ to se>* 9 reque/ ( ,mr4 ,*ur*1 he & ! pott]1 ,we/1 _h n gone to se>* = ?ieves8 & he answ]$ me1 8,yes40 ,b aft]w>ds1 he gave u "s explanation1 & said1 8t he did n se>* ! h\se p>ticul>ly = ?ieves1 b made a se>* to f9d if any body 0 ab\t40 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 ^u ?is subject ,i am also enabl$ to give y "s evid5ce1 because ,i und]/& t bo? ! boy & ,we/ di/9ctly /at$1 :5 !y 7 be=e ! ,magi/rate1 t !y did g & se>* ! h\se = ?ieves1 & t !y made no o!r se>* b = ?ieves4 ,n[1 if !re 0 any se>* made = ?ieves--if !re 0 any notion 9 ! m9d ( ?is boy t ?ieves 7 9 ! h\se1 x w\ld be q impossible t he c\ld be correct 9 ! /ory he has told y to-day4 ,& :e!r he has n magnifi$ ! ?+--:e!r some?+ :i* he has suppos$ to h happ5$ betwe5 sleep+ & awake t nev] happ5$--:e!r he has n be5 giv+ y a connect$ acc\nt n[ ( :at he _h a confus$ notion !n--is = y\r consid]ation4 ,b !re is ano!r circum/ance respect+ ! case :i* is v important4 ,! transaction1 if x ev] did take place1 took place 9 ! night ( ! #be? ( ,septemb]4 ,on ! #i? ( ,octob]1 & n until ! n9? ( ,octob]1 does ,mr4 ,patrick g to ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,!re is a lapse ( a =tnight4 ,! witness :om ,i %all call to y w /ate1 t aft] com+ out f ,mr4 ,*ur*'s1 ,mr4 ,patrick express$ himself satisfi$ t ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 n implicat$4 ,n[ let u try t by ! conduct ( ,mr4 ,patrick & ( ?is boy4 ,?is is ! #i? ( ,octob]1 & until ! #ab? ( ,novemb] no *>ge be=e a ,magi/rate is made4 ,i beg to ask y :e!r ! conduct ( ,mr4 ,patrick1 9 =be>+ to make any *>ge be=e a ,magi/rate until ! #ab? ( ,novemb]1 is n ! /ronge/ evid5ce t :at my witness w /ate to y is true8 ,t he 0 !n satisfi$ t ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 n implicat$ 9 ?is abom9able1 odi\s1 & unnatural transaction4 ,g5tlem51 su* *>ges ought nev] to be slept ^u4 ,no1 n = an h\r4 ,if !re be su* a *>ge z t1 & if x be really true t su* ?+s h tak5 place1 no man ought to re/ on x = a s+le h\r4--,! *>ge ought to be made directly4 ,b1 :at excuse is urg$ = ?is delay8 8,oh10 says my le>n$ fri5d1 8,at la/ ! transaction rea*$ ! e>s ( ! appr5tice's fa!r40 ,:y1 y wont suppose t ! appr5tice's fa!r _h j return$ f an ,ea/-,india ,voyage1 & t ! transaction com+ to 8 e>s on ! #aa? ( ,novemb]1 he br\ght =w>d ! *>ge4 ,g5tlem51 !re is no pret5ce = su* an excuse4 ,! boy slept at 8 fa!r's4 ,he did n sleep at 8 ma/]'s4 ,did he return to 8 fa!r's h\se8 ,8 fa!r liv$ )9 a qu>t] ( a mile ( ,mr4 ,patrick1 & he 0 9 daily int]c\rse ) 8 fa!r1 & _h abundant opportunities ( conf]r+ ) him ^u ! subject2 & yet1 = six weeks1 no /eps :atev] are tak5 to br+ ,mr4 ,*ur* be=e a ,magi/rate4 ,my le>n$ fri5d !n told y t ! fa!r 0 ! p]son :o made ! *>ge3 b he has n call$ ! fa!r4 ,! only p]son :o appe>s "h z ! prosecutor is ,mr4 ,patrick1 & n ! fa!r2 & !y h n v5tur$ to call ! fa!r z a witness2 & !re is no pret5ce made = ! delay ( ?is *>ge1 unless x 0 t at ?is int]view ) ,mr4 ,*ur*1 ! prosecutor1 ,mr4 ,patrick1 0 satisfi$1 z ,i am told he express$ himself to be to ! p]son :o accompani$ him1 & wait$ at ! door till he came out1 t !re 0 no gr\nd = implicat+ ! ,def5dant 9 ?is *>ge3 &1 ,g5tlem51 ,i say t 8 sleep+ on ! *>ge = upw>ds ( a mon? aft] t int]view ) ,mr4 ,*ur*1 is ! /ronge/ evid5ce t at t "t he 0 satisfi$ ( 8 innoc5ce1 & t ?is *>ge is br\ght =w>d on acc\nt ( "s ang]1 or "s suppos$ decl>ation respect+ ,mr4 ,patrick's wife1 :i* w\ld make him extremely angry4 ,if y f9d1 ,g5tlem51 t !re 7 no o!r motives ?an ?is to induce a *>ge ( ?is k9d1 ,i h no d\bt y w imm$iately acquit ! ,def5dant4 ,g5tlem51 ,i h no fur!r obs]vations to make4 ,! *>ge is mo/ odi\s4 ,! crime is mo/ odi\s2 & if x c be m attroci\s 9 "o p]son ?an ano!r1 x is 9 a p]son :o is a public tea*] ( religion4 ,if su* a p]son1 9 defiance ( e law human & div9e4 ,9 contrav5tion ( ^? ,sacr$ ,scriptures1 :i* x is 8 duty to read & exp\nd1 & hav+ read & exp\nd$ !m he c be f\nd s f> to =get e law ( human nature & e pr9ciple ( virtue1 by ! commission ( ?is crime1 he mu/ be ! mo/ mon/r\s & attroci\s ( ! human race1 & no puni%m5t c be adequate to 8 (f5ces4 ,b ! puni%m5t :i* mu/ await him1 w\ld be inf9itely worse ?an /&+ 9 ! ,c\rt bel[ to receive s5t5ce = ! completion ( ?is attroci\s crime2 because ,i ?9k t comp>$ ) in/ant dea? = ! consummation ( ! crime1 ! be+ doom$ to live ! object ( scorn1 ( hatr$1 & abhorr5ce by e human be+1 mu/ be a puni%m5t inf9itely worse4 ,g5tlem51 t is n too great = su* mon/]s3 b be=e y f9d ! ,def5dant to be su*1 be satisfi$ by ! :ole ( ! evid5ce ( 8 guilt4 ,comp>e ! evid5ce on "o side & on ! o!r2 & if x raises a d\bt 9 y\r m9d1 ! ,def5dant is entitl$ to ! b5efit ( t d\bt1 & y w f9d him n guilty4 ,mr4 ,john ,?omas 0 ! fir/ witness call$ = ! ,def5dant1 & be+ sworn1 0 exam9$ by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4 ,is y\r "n ,john ,?omas8--,yes4 ,:]e d y live8--,9 ,prospect-place1 ,we/'s-squ>e1 ,/4 ,george's-fields4 ,9 :at way ( bus9ess are y8--,an apprais] & und]tak]4 ,h y kn[n ,mr4 ,*ur* long8--,yes4 ,7 y "o ( 8 he>]s8--,yes4 ,7 y acqua9t$ ) ,mr4 ,patrick8--,n till ! report 0 made respect+ ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,did y "k him z "o ( ! congregation att5d+ ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,no1 ,i _c say ,i did4 ,7 y ) ,mr4 ,patrick on any day t he w5t to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se--,i mean on ! #i? ( ,octob]8--,yes1 a few days aft] ! report4 ,did y g into ! h\se ) him8--,no1 ,i did n4 ,y 7 at ! door8--,i /aid outside4 ,_h y le>nt f ,mr4 ,patrick t he 0 go+ to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s ^u ! subject ( ?is bus9ess8--,yes4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did he tell y t he _h a lett]1 & 0 go+ to make inquiries ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,he call$ ^u me at my h\se to g ) him4 ,by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,& told y he 0 go+ to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s ^u ! bus9ess ( ?is inquiry8--,yes2 inde$ x 0 my reque/ t he %\ld4 ,mr4 ,?omas w5t to speak to 8 wife2 & x 0 at my wife's reque/ & ,mrs4 ,patrick's ,i believe t he w5t4 ,y\r wife jo9$ 9 h] reque/8--,yes4 ,h[ long might 8 int]view ) ,mr4 ,*ur* la/--h[ long 0 he 9 ! h\se8--,he seem$ to be a long :ile2 n mu* less ?an an h\r4 ,z ne> z y c\ld guess1 ! "t1 0 x ne> an h\r8--,yes4 ,:5 he came out did y put any que/ions to him respect+ :at _h pass$ betwe52 him & ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,:at que/ions did y put8--,i ask$ him :at ,mr4 ,*ur* _h said4 ,:at answ] did he give y8--,he said t ,mr4 ,*ur* did n say any ?+4 ,he said ,mr4 ,*ur* seem$ v mu* conf\nd$ on acc\nt ( ! cause1 he suppos$1 b he said no?+ ab\t x2 t x w\ld be injuri\s to ! cause ( ,god4 ,he did n say ! cause ( ,god1 b ,i only suppos$ he meant ! cause ( ,god4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did he use ! words 8cause ( ,god80--,no1 he said ,mr4 ,*ur* seem$ v mu* conf\nd$ or confus$4 ,!n ! re/ is all imag9ation ( y\r's8--,we bo? imag9$ alike4 ,i don't "k t ^! 7 exactly ! words1 = ,i _c call to my m9d :at he did say2 b x 0 conjectur$ ! cause ( ,god1 & :i* we he>d aft]w>ds 0 abus$ abroad4 ,y are n[ call$1 ,sir1 = ! purpose ( contradiction4 ,y are recollect+ ! effect1 y "k1 ( a conv]sation & communication ) ,mr4 ,patrick1 & y mu/ say truly :at pass$1 if y c recollect x4--,i don't recollect all t pass$4 ,by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,:5 y 7 /opt 9 y\r acc\nt ( :at pass$1 y 7 go+ to say some?+4 ,y 7 ask$ :e!r ,mr4 ,*ur* _h said any ?+ to ,mr4 ,patrick :i* ,mr4 ,patrick relat$ to y4 ,:at did he say8--,he said1 ,no4 ,he said ,mr4 ,*ur* seem$ v mu* confus$4 ,:at did y ask ,mr4 ,patrick next8--8,:y10 said ,i1 8:at d y mean4 ,:y1 if y "k any ?+ aga9/ ! man1 did y n *>ge him ) x8 ,i w\ld h be5 v fai?ful ) him1 & *>g$ him ) x40 ,:at answ] did ,mr4 ,patrick make to t8--,he said he did n "k2 he 0 n ! p]son4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,repeat t 9 ,mr4 ,patrick's own words4 ,att5d1 & wait to he> ! "q4 ,be s good z to suppose t y 7 n>rat+ ! conv]sation z x occurr$ ) ,mr4 ,patrick4 ,in/ead ( say+1 ,he1 say ,i4 ,att5d n[4 ,by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,:at fur!r did he say8 & give 8 own words4--,he said1 8,i don't "k3 ,i am n s prop] a p]son z y10 or words to ! same effect4 ,i said to him1 8,:at did he 7mean+ ,*ur*7 say respect+ ! report80 ,:at _h ! report ref]5ce to t y spoke (8--,! report respect+ ?is transaction4 ,:at answ] did ,patrick make to t8 ,:at did ,patrick say to y :5 y put ! "q1 z to :at ,*ur* _h said respect+ ! report8--,i said to ,mr4 ,patrick1 says ,i1 8:at did he say respect+ ! ackn[l$g+ ! report0--t is1 :at did ,mr4 ,*ur* say to ,mr4 ,patrick ab\t ackn[l$g+ ! report t _h gone abroad respect+ him4 ,he said1 8,x 0 false40 ,d y mean t ,*ur* said x 0 false8--,i mean t ,patrick said t ! report 0 false4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,t is n ! answ] to ! "q put by ! ,g5tleman4 ,did ,*ur* say t x 0 false8--,i nev] saw ,*ur* ^u ! subject4 ,by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,:5 ,patrick made y an answ]1 did y und]/& t answ] to be1 t ,*ur* _h said ! report 0 false1 or t ,patrick himself said ! report 0 false8--,patrick himself4 ,patrick himself said t ! report 0 false8--,c]ta9ly4 ,did y !n put any o!r "q to ,mr4 ,patrick8--,i did4 ,:at o!r "q did y put8--,i said1 :at answ] did ,mr4 ,*ur* give respect+ its hav+ be5 report$ t he 0 9 liquor--t he made an excuse t he 0 9 liquor8 ,:at answ] did ,mr4 ,patrick give to t8--,he said x 0 false4 ,he said !re _h be5 a great deal ( exagg]ation4 ,did y aft] ?is put any "q to ,mr4 ,patrick1 :e!r he1 ,mr4 ,patrick1 ?\ght t ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 implicat$ 9 ! transaction or n8 ,did y put any su* "q to him8 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y use ^? words1 or words to ! same effect8--,no1 ,i did n ,i put ^! words to him--8,:y10 says ,i1 8y did no?+6 ,did ,mr4 ,*ur* ackn[l$ge no?+ to y80 8,no1 ,sir10 says he1 8he did n40 ,!n he said ,mr4 ,*ur* _h n m5tion$ a ^w ab\t x4 ,did y make any obs]vation to him1 or he to y8--,i don't recollect any ?+ 9 p>ticul>4 ,i said1 says ,i1 8,z y c br+ no?+ aga9/ him1 let u pray = him1 & if he _h ! lea/ idea ( su* a ?+2 & z y say y _c br+ any ?+ home to him1 & c't prove any ?+1 t is all we c d4 ,let u pray t he may n be guilty ( su* s940 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y say1 pray = him1 if he 0 "u any su* temptation8--,yes2 pray = him1 if 0 "u any su* temptation4 ,,! ,,common ,,s]jeant4--,did ,mr4 ,patrick aft] t deliv] any op9ion to y :e!r he ?\ght ,*ur* 0 implicat$ 9 ! transaction or n8--,no1 he did n4 ,did y at any o!r "t see him1 & he> him say any ?+ ab\t ?is transaction8--,no4 ,did any ?+ m pass at ?is meet+ ?an :at y h told u8 ,no4--,yes1 ,sir4 ,i ask p>don3 ,i met him 9 ,june la/1 com+ ov] ,wat]loo-bridge4 ,i did n at fir/ "k him2 & he spoke to me1 & he said1 8,my "n is ,patrick40 ,i said1 8,mr4 ,patrick1 :y :at are y do+ ) ,mr4 ,*ur*80 8,:y10 says ,i1 8,i he> y h br\ght some?+ else aga9/ him3 :at is t80 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,!re is no contradiction ( ,mr4 ,patrick 9 ?is4 ,he 0 n ask$ to ?is 7cont9uation ( ! answ]74 8,:y10 says he1 8,sir1 ,i %\ld n h done x1 b t ,mr4 ,*ur* has spok5 m disrespectful ?+s respect+ ,mrs4 ,patrick40 ,he said he %\ld n h done x1 b t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h said _m disrespectful ?+s ( ,mrs4 ,patrick4 ,cross-exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4 ,0 x ! ,sabba? aft] ! #bg? ( ,septemb] t y fir/ he>d ( ?is8--,i believe x 04 ,x 0 )9 two or ?ree days aft]4 ,i ?9k we h le>nt t ^u ! ,?ursday night ,mr4 ,patrick came home1 & t on ! ,friday morn+ ! boy communicat$ to him :at _h happ5$4 ,n[ on ! ,saturday1 0 n ?is matt] curr5tly talk$ ( ab\t ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,no1 ,i believe n4 ,y mean t y he>d ( ! report two or ?ree days aft] ! ?+ happ5$8--,yes4 ,y !n he>d ( ! report8--,yes4 ,y told u t y 7 desir\s t ,mr4 ,patrick %\ld call on ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,yes4 ,!n he did s1 at y\r desire8--,yes4 ,did ,mr4 ,patrick br+ ! boy to y1 & (f] to h him br\ght face to face ) ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i believe he did4 ,mr4 ,patrick said ! boy 0 outside8--,mr4 ,patrick call$ at my h\se 9 ! c\rse ( ! morn+1 & he s5t him1 & he said ! boy 0 outside4 ,did he wi% y to see ! boy8--,n p>ticul>ly1 ,i believe4 ,= :at purpose did he br+ ! boy8--,to g to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s8--,i suppos$ s4 ,to g ) y or ) him1 or ) bo? ( y to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s8--,i 0 to g ) him1 & !re=e ! boy foll[$4 ,did ! boy g ) him into ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se8--,he /aid outside ! door4 ,he walk$ on ! o!r side ( ! way1 opposite to :]e ,i 04 ,b he wait$ :il/ y wait$8--,yes3 we bo? wait$ outside4 ,ready to g 9 to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s :5 y 7 want$8--,yes3 ,mr4 ,patrick 0 to g 9 & he> :at ,mr4 ,*ur* _h to say2 & !n we 7 to g 91 too4 ,& he took ! boy ) him1 9 ord] t he might be tak5 9 & see ,mr4 ,*ur* face to face8--,he br\ght ! boy ) him1 & ,i suppose t 0 8 int5tion4 ,did y decl9e introduc+ ! boy to ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i _h no p>ticul> acqua9tance ) ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,i 0 only "o ( 8 he>]s1 & ,i ?\ght x w\ld be too great a lib]ty = me to g to him4 ,mr4 ,patrick want$ me to g 9 alone to ,mr4 ,*ur*1 fir/4 ,did he n invite y to take ! boy 9 ) y8--,he said no?+ ab\t t2 ,i don't recollect any ?+ t he did4 ,:y did y tell me1 !n1 t y suppos$ ! purpose ( br++ ! boy 0 t he %\ld be introduc$ to ,mr4 ,*ur*8--,no d\bt ab\t t4 ,i don't "k any o!r reason he _h ?an t1 = br++ ! boy4 ,did he say s8--,i don't "k t he said t t 0 8 reason4 ,he said he _h ! boy !re4 ,d y rememb] y\r decl9+ to g 9 ) ,mr4 ,patrick to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s8--,i told him ,i _h no p>ticul> int]e/ 9 ! bus9ess4 ,i _h no intimacy ) ,mr4 ,*ur*1 except he>+ him4 ,i ?\ght ,i _h no bus9ess to be int]e/$ 9 ! k ( ! fact1 be+ only a he>]4 ,i ?\ght !re=e t my visit w\ld be obtrusive4 ,because y _h no p>ticul> int]e/ 9 ! bus9ess8--,:y1 ,i c]ta9ly _h no int]e/ 9 x4 ,& !re=e y decl9$ go+ 9 & tak+ ! boy ) y8--,i saw no necessity ( s do+1 z he did n ackn[l$ge himself guilty ( any ?+ bad4 ,by ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4 ,b ! boy be+ !re1 _h y n ! curiosity to exam9e ! boy8--,i did n1 x be+ delicate subject4 ,did y n ?9k x important to come at ! tru? ^u ! subject1 z ! boy 0 !re & y might h exam9$ him y\rself8--,if ,mr4 ,*ur* _h confess$ any ?+1 ,i %\ld h ?\ght x my duty to take ! boy & h !m face to face4 ,b ,i %\ld h ?\ght t ! circum/ance ( 8 n confess+ w\ld be ! reason :y y w\ld take !m face to face2 or else :y %\ld y take ! boy at all4 ,b ,mr4 ,*ur* n hav+ confess$ any ?+1 y !re=e w\ld n exam9e ! boy4--,0 t y\r reason = n exam9+ ! boy8--,yes1 my ,"l4 ,by ,mr4 ,,boll&4--,b if he confess$ any ?+1 y w\ld h tak5 ! boy to h !m face to face8--,yes4 ,y\r object 0 to take ! boy & h !m face to face1 if ,mr4 ,*ur* ackn[l$g$ ! crime8--,yes4 ,b surely :5 y f\nd t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h ackn[l$g$ 8 fault1 !n !re w\ld be no reason = tak+ ! boy to h !m face to face8--,i %\ld h ?\ght x prop] to take ! boy 91 if ,mr4 ,*ur* ackn[l$g$ 8 crime4 ,i wi%$ ! boy 9 fact to come 9 ) u2 b :5 ,mr4 ,patrick came out & said t ,mr4 ,*ur* did n ackn[l$ge any ?+ ( x1 ,i did n ?9k x necess>y to h !m face to face4 ,!n y did n ?9k x "r to h ! boy 98--,i nev] spoke to ! boy4 ,y nev] ask$ ! boy ab\t ?is transaction8--,no4 ,mr4 ,patrick nev] gave any op9ion :e!r ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 implicat$ 9 ! transaction2 b 9 answ] to a p>ticul> "p ( ! transaction1 he said t ,mr4 ,*ur* ass]t$ t x 0 false8--,yes4 ,did y see ! lett] s5t to ,mrs4 ,hunt]8--,no4 ,i mean ! lett] ab\t ! ?ree po9ts ( ! boy's /atem5t :i* ,mr4 ,*ur* said he 0 able to contradict8--,no4 ,mr4 ,,james ,,reeves sworn4 ,exam9$ by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4 ,7 y ! ,cl]k att5d+ ! ,magi/rate :5 ! *>ge 0 made be=e him2--,i 04 ,:o 0 ! ,magi/rate8--,i mu/ ref] to ! book--7,witness produc$ a book47 ,t is y\r m9ute book 9 :i* y ent] ! proce$+s ( ! day8--,yes4 ,:o 0 ! sitt+ ,magi/rate on t day8--,mr4 ,s]jeant ,sellon appe>s to h be5 ! ,magi/rate on ! #ai? ( ,novemb]1 z x appe>s by ! book4 ,?is be+ a *>ge ( misdemeanor1 d y f9d by y\r book t any acc\nt 0 committ$ to writ+ ( :at ! witnesses said8--,no2 x 0 n4 ,x is m]ely a note1 or entry ( ! names1 z foll[s3 8,w>rant = a misdemeanor1 p>ties appe>$ by ! ,(fic]1 & ord]$ to f9d bail40 ,cross-exam9$ by ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt4 ,0 t ! ,magi/rate by :om ! w>rant 0 grant$8--,yes4 ,0 ! oa? adm9i/]$ be=e ! w>rant 0 grant$8--,yes2 !re _h be5 an ex-p>te exam9ation to grant ! w>rant on ! oa? ( ! p>ty4 ,t is 9 ano!r book8--,x is2 t is left beh9d2 ,i d n "k any ?+ ( x4 ,b !re is a deposition on oa? prior to ! grant+ ( ! w>rant8--,yes4 ,re-exam9$ by ! ,,common ,,s]jeant4 ,! depositions 9 cases ( misdemean\r y don't take 9 detail8--,no4 ,7 ! depositions tak5 9 writ+ 9 any book :i* y h n "h8--,i am n aw>e ( t4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,y 7 n told to br+ x8--,no4 ,0 t ! only in=mation ^u :i* ! w>rant 0 grant$8--,!re 0 no?+ tak5 d[n 9 writ+ :5 all ! p>ties 7 be=e ! ,magi/rate4 ,7 ! depositions tak5 d[n be=e ! w>rant 0 grant$8--,yes4 ,!n1 aft] ! w>rant 0 execut$1 & at ! "t ( ! exam9ation :5 ! ,def5dant 0 !re1 y took no m9utes8--,no f>!r ?an ! names ( ! p>ties2 & :at ,i h "h4 ,mr4 ,,wood sworn4 ,exam9$ by ,mr4 ,gurney4 ,7 y pres5t at ! exam9ation ( ,mr4 ,*ur* be=e ! ,magi/rate8--,i 04 ,:at are y8--,a hatt]1 ne> ! ,elephant & ,ca/le1 9 ,/4 ,george's ,fields4 ,"l ,,ell5bor\gh4--,did y take ! te/imony ( ! witnesses d[n 9 writ+8--,no4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,did ,=eman1 ! boy1 9 ! acc\nt he gave be=e ! ,magi/rate1 say = :at purpose he se>*$ ! h\se8--,he said t he w5t out to ! ,pott] & told ! ,pott] t !re 7 ?ieves 9 ! h\se1 & t ! ,pott] & he came to se>* ! h\se4 ,he 0 ask$ a "q by ,mr4 ,sellon1 :e!r or no he se>*$ ! room :]e ,mr4 ,*ur* slept4 ,he said1 ,no1 he did n se>* t room4 ,mr4 ,sellon said1 8,:y n se>* t room80 ,:at answ] did he give to t8--,! answ] he gave 0 t ! ,pott] wi%$ to break ! door op54 ,mr4 ,sellon said1 8,did y try ! door to see :e!r x 0 op51 be=e ! ,pott] talk$ ( break+ x op580 ,he said1 ,no3 he did n wi% to di/urb 8 mi/ress4 ,:il/ ! ,pott] 0 exam9$1 did he say :at 0 ! al>m t ,=eman gave to him2 did he say :at 0 ! al>m8--,i _c *>ge my memory z to t4 ,mr4 ,,gurney4--,my ,"l1 ?is is ! case ( ! ,def5dant4 ,mr4 ,,m>ryatt !n repli$ to ! ,def5dant's case1 z foll[s3-- ,may x please y\r ,lord%ip1 ,g5tlem5 ( ! ,jury--,my le>n$ ,fri5d has almo/ admitt$ ! case on ! "p ( ! ,prosecution1 9 ! nature ( 8 address to y1 by say+1 9 effect1 t if y believ$ ,mr4 ,*ur* to h gone into ! boy's *amb] at t unseasonable h\r ( ! morn+1 he c\ld h>dly come !re = any purpose b t ascrib$ to him by ?is ,indictm5t4 ,at lea/1 if my ,le>n$ ,fri5d did n make t confession 9 t]ms s explicitly z ,i h giv5 !m1 c]ta9ly he has n (f]$ 9 8 address to y ! smalle/ explanation ( s v suspici\s a purpose4 ,& al?\gh ,i invit$ him1 :5 ,i fir/ _h ! opportunity ( /at+ ?is case1 to assign any possible reason1 except t :i* is imput$ to ! ,def5dant z matt] ( crime1 :y he %\ld be 9 ! ,boy's room "u su* circum/ances1 we h _h no motive assign$1 nor any sugge/ion ( apology or excuse (f]$ = su* conduct4 ,!re is an improbability 9 ?is case x is cont5d$2 because !re _h be5 no ov]ture ( ! same description made to ! lad be=e ?is p]iod1 nor any circum/ance1 by :i* an indication ( ! ,def5dant's unnatural prop5sities1 prior to ?is transaction1 c\ld be inf]r$4 ,g5tlem51 we h liv$ "s "t 9 ! _w1 & we h se5 t m51 ) ^! diabolical passions1 make ^? ov]tures1 n unfrequ5tly1 to p]sons !y nev] saw 9 ! :ole c\rse ( _! lives1 until "s occasional meet+--sometimes 9 ! ,p>ks--nay1 sometimes1 ev5 at public assemblies2 & yet s extraord9>y is ! phr5zy ) :i* m5 ( ^! prop5sities are hurri$1 !re is no acc\nt+ = _! conduct on ^! occasions3 c]ta9ly !re is no am\nt+ = ! conduct ( ?is ,def5dant 9 go+ into ! boy's *amb]1 except t :i* 8 abom9able & unnatural lu/s c sugge/1 & :i* are imput$ to him by ?is indictm5t4 ,g5tlem51 9 ! fir/ place1 0 he !re8 ,:y x is sugge/$ t ! boy's fright _h magnifi$ ! p[]s ( 8 vision1 & t he mu/ h mi/ak5 ! ,def5dant = 8 mi/ress1 or = ! maid s]vant1 :o slept ) 8 si/]4 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 we h x 9 evid5ce t ,mr4 ,*ur* is a man ne> six feet high3 a man ( consid]able size1 & di/+ui%able f ! boy's mi/ress1 :o is a little fem9ate figure2 & also v di/+ui%able f ! maid s]vant1 :om my le>n$ fri5d1 ,mr4 ,gurney1 wi%es y to inf] 0 ! p]son :o ent]$ ! prosecutor's room1 because ! maid's *amb] door 0 n %ut2 al?\gh !re 0 no "q ask$ by ! ,def5dant's ,c\nsel1 z to ! intimacy ( ?is "y man ) t s]vant maid4 ,i admit t ! s]vant's door 0 n fa/2 b my ,le>n$ ,fri5d did n inquire :e!r ! s]vant's door _h be5 left op5 or fa/5$1 :5 ! s]vants w5t to b$2 nor 0 any inquiry made :e!r ! lock ( t door 0 defective1 z sometimes happ5s to be ! case ) ! s]vant's rooms 9 a g5tleman's h\se2 = defici5cies ( t description are n s imm$iately rem$i$ z 9 ! m pref]able rooms ( ! h\se4 ,g5tlem51 c\ld ! "y man by any possibility mi/ake ! female figure ( ! maid s]vants or ( 8 mi/ress1 = ! man he describ$--a man t is ( consid]able size--ne> six feet high1 & a v /rik+ object 9 po9t ( height8 ,mo/ unque/ionably !re is no pret5ce = suppos+1 t !re c\ld be any body else b ,mr4 ,*ur* 9 ! room at t "t4 ,n[ :at is ! conduct ( ! "y lad on t occasion8 ,he goes d[n to ,we/1 ! pott]1 imm$iately1 & /ates to him1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h behav$ indec5tly4 ,i admit t1 9 ! c\rse ( conv]sation1 he m5tion$ "s ( ! p>ticul>s ( :at occurr$1 :i* ! pott] says he does n recollect4 ,! boy goes on fur!r1 & /ates p>ticul>s t he _h relat$ to ! man1 :i* ! latt] says _h n be5 m5tion$ to him2 & :at is m probable1 ?an t 9 giv+ an acc\nt ( a conv]sation :i* took place s long ago z ! mon? ( ,septemb] la/1 t ! "o may add half a s5t5ce :i* ! o!r does n rememb]8 ,b 0 n ! /atem5t t ! lad made at ! "t to ! second witness1 ,we/1 7?\gh ! latt] does n recollect ! :ole ( :at pass$7 t ,*ur* came into 8 *amb]1 & conduct$ himself ) indec5cy t[>ds him8 ,!y !n return to ! h\se2 ! lad & he exam9e ! h\se = ! purpose ( asc]ta9+ :e!r any body else is !re2 no o!r male p]son sleep+ 9 ! h\se2 & !y f9d all secure & safe2 & yet x is to suppos$1 t !y w5t 9 se>* = ?ieves6 ,:y ! result ( ! se>* w\ld decide :e!r ! object ( ! se>* 0 to see :e!r !re 7 any ?ieves 9 ! h\se--= nei!r a door nor a w9d[ _h be5 op5$1 nor 0 !re any ap]ture at :i* a ?ief c\ld ga9 admittance4 ,x is cle>1 !re=e1 t !re 0 no o!r male 9 ! h\se except ,*ur*1 ! p>ty indict$2 nor is !re n[ any col\r = suppos+ t !re 0 any body else !re ( 8 sex b himself4 ,b1 x is said _! object 0 to se>* = ?ieves1 & t ! al>m 0 = ?ieves1 & t ! ,boy1 :5 he w5t be=e ! ,magi/rate1 gave "s acc\nt ab\t se>*+ = ?ieves4 ,:y1 9 8 exam9ation "h to-day1 :5 he 0 ask$ :e!r he & ,we/ did n g back toge!r to ! h\se & se>* = ?ieves1 he v naturally said1 8,yes1 ,sir30 b :y did he give t answ]8--,because !re 0 ano!r proposition put to him1 :i* appe>$ z mat]ial z t ) respect to ! se>* = ?ieves1 & accord+ly he answ]$ 9 ! affirmative4 ,x is true t he did admit at fir/1 t he w5t to se>* = ?ieves2 b :5 he came to give ! explanation to ! answ]1 he /ates t he did n p>ticul>ly se>* = ?ieves2 & aft] a little cross-exam9ation by ! same ,le>n$ ,c\nsel1 x appe>$ t ! object 0 n to se>* = ?ieves1 b m]ely to asc]ta9 t !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se t c\ld possibly commit ?is indec5cy1 ?is outrage aga9/ religion1 morality1 & nature4 ,b ! man :o 0 call$ la/1 nam$ ,wood1 is call$ to /ate some?+ t pass$ be=e ! ,magi/rate2 &1 accord+ to 8 repres5tation1 !re 0 some?+ said ab\t go+ to se>* = ?ieves4 ,x is obs]vable1 h[ev]1 t he did n take up ! :ole /ory told 9 ! te/imony ( ! lad1 nor did my ,le>n$ ,fri5d exam9e him z to ! ant]ior "p ( 8 /atem5t3 & f ?is x mu/ fairly be inf]r$1 t ! mo/ mat]ial "p ( ! boy's te/imony giv5 to-day1 & t giv5 be=e ! ,magi/rate1 0 consi/5t1 & n to be %ak54 ,= y may be q c]ta91 ,g5tlem51 t :5 my ,le>n$ ,fri5ds on ! o!r side cont5t !mselves ) cat*+ at ! smalle/ v>iance 9 ! te/imony ( ! witness f 8 orig9al /atem5t2 x is a decid$ pro( t ! mo/ important "p ( ! case is n to be %ak51 & is incapable ( contradiction4 ,! mat]ial "p ( ! evid5ce rema9s unt\*$ by any %ad[ ( d\bt z to its cr$ibility4 ,my ,le>n$ ,fri5d re/s satisfi$ ) ! contradiction ^u ! subject ( :at pass$ betwe5 ! ,pott] & ! ,boy1 b :i*1 ,i say1 is :olly immat]ial z x affects 8 cr$it2 & ! only fur!r objection he makes to 8 te/imony is1 t 8 evid5ce ( to-day does n correspond1 9 "s m9ute p>ticul>1 ) 8 exam9ation be=e ! ,magi/rate4 ,= ! reasons1 h[ev]1 :i* ,i h giv5 y1 ,g5tlem51 y w dismiss ^! trifl+ matt]s f y\r s]i\s consid]ation4 ,b x seems t ,mr4 ,patrick has be5 guilty ( "s mis-/atem5t z to :at occurr$ 9 ! e>ly /age ( ?is proce$+2 & we h ,mr4 ,?omas call$1 z x is said1 = ! purpose ( contradict+ him1 z to ! result ( "s conv]sation :i* pass$ betwe5 !m aft] ! int]view at ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se4 ,g5tlem51 x is "s :at s+ul> t ,mr4 ,?omas1 :o 0 "o ( ! ,def5dant's he>]s1 & int]e/$ himself s mu* 9 ?is case1 t :5 ! boy is br\ght to give him in=mation z to ! compla9t :i* he _h to make aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*1 he does n make ! lea/ inquiry into ! lad's acc\nt ( ! transaction1 nor does he express any desire t ! lad %\ld be introduc$ to ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,we h x 9 evid5ce f himself1 t on ! day :5 ,mr4 ,patrick call$ ^u ,mr4 ,*ur*1 he wait$ ) ! lad on ! outside ( ! h\se2 & al?\gh ,mr4 ,patrick br\ght ! boy = ! express purpose ( hav+ him confront$ face to face ) ! ,def5dant1 /ill ,mr4 ,?omas does n ask a s+le "q ( ! lad1 nor does he g into any exam9ation ^u ! subject4 ,g5tlem51 t ?is case 0 imm$iately blazon$ ab\t v e>ly is cle>1 ?\gh x 0 n c>ri$ be=e ! magi/rate s soon2 because we f9d t :5 ,mr4 ,patrick came home on ! ,?ursday night1 ?\gh he did n speak to ! boy until ! next day1 ! ,friday1 yet ! subject 0 g5]ally m5tion$ to 8 wife be=e he return$1 & !re=e ! matt] might h got w9d be=e x 0 fully expla9$ by ! boy to 8 ma/] on ! ,friday morn+4 ,x is q cle> t x 0 kn[n to ! congregation on ! foll[+ sabba?1 & accord+ to t lett] :i* has be5 read to y1 7^u :i* ,i make no comm5ts1 except s f> z x be>s on ,mr4 ,patrick's te/imony71 ! ,def5dant1 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 _h writt5 on ! #f? ( ,octob] to ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 ,mrs4 ,hunt] hav+ previ\sly writt5 to him on ! subject1 = he beg9s by ref]r+ to ! lett] :i* ,mrs4 ,hunt] _h address$ to & expresses regret t he %all lose h] z a he>] 9 future3 s t ,mrs4 ,hunt] !re=e1 among/ o!r p]sons1 0 acqua9t$ ) ! rum\rs1 because f him ?is lett] comes1 f :i* x appe>s t %e _h writt5 to him be=e2 = x beg9s by /at+--8,my he>t is already too mu* affect$3 y\r lett] only add$ affliction to my bonds40--,g5tlem51 ,i only dwell ^u ?is circum/ance 9 confirmation ( ,mr4 ,patrick's /atem5t1 t ,mr4 ,*ur* c\ld contradict1 n ! :ole ( ! report1 b ?ree po9ts ( ! boy's /atem5t4 ,?is lett] hav+ come to ! k ( ,mr4 ,patrick1 9 :i* ^! ?ree po9ts are allud$ to1 & be+ desir$ by "s ( ! congregation to pay ! ,def5dant a visit1 he accord+ly resolves to call ^u him4 ,on t occasion he introduces himself by /at+1 z ! apology = 8 call+1 t he _h se5 a lett] f ! ,def5dant1 9 :i* he /at$ t he c\ld contradict c]ta9 po9ts ( ! boy's /ory4 ,! ,def5dant y w obs]ve does n contradict ! fact ( 8 hav+ writt5 su* a lett]1 b he goes into an explanation ) ! witness z to :at are ! po9ts ( contradiction2 & !n he /ates t s f> z 8 hav+ laid hold ( ! boy1 & 8 hav+ told ! lad t ! p]son :o address$ him 0 8 mi/ress1 ! :ole 0 a mis-/atem5t2 & ^!1 ,g5tlem51 are ! only po9ts ( d5ial ^u :i* ! ,def5dant re/$ 9 8 int]view ) ,mr4 ,patrick1 to :om1 h[ev]1 he admitt$ di/9ctly t he 0 9 ! boy's *amb]1 ?\gh he d5ies ! subsequ5t "p ( ! transaction1 :i* ! boy to-day has solemnly sworn to h tak5 place4 ,n[1 g5tlem51 ,i ask aga91 if he 0 9 ! boy's *amb]1 = :at reason or prop] purpose c\ld he by possibility g !re8 ,& if he 0 9 t room1 c y h any d\bt ( ! tru? ( all ! circum/ances :i* ! boy has positively sworn8--,if x 0 a p]son ( ! male sex :o ent]$ t ap>tm5t1 x mu/ cle>ly h be5 ! def5dant2 = !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se4 ,x appe>+ di/9ctly t ,mr4 ,patrick 0 abs5t f home on t night4 ,!n ,i ask y1 :e!r !re is any gr\nd = disbeliev+ ! boy's /ory1 :o1 imm$iately aft] ! disgu/+ sc5e he has describ$1 goes to ! pott]y1 tells 8 /ory to ! workman1 & /ays !re ! rema9d] ( ! night1 *us+ r to lose 8 re/ ?an /ay 9 ! h\se ) ,mr4 ,*ur*1 "u ! liability ( a fur!r enc\nt] = ! same dete/able purpose4 ,! reason :i* ! boy has giv5 = n al>m+ ! h\se1 is n an unnatural "o4 ,we h x 9 evid5ce t ,mr4 ,we/1 feel+ a manly indignation at :at _h happ5$1 manife/$ a disposition to pull ! unnatural (f5d] out ( 8 b$1 & turn him into ! /reet4 ,b ! boy1 appreh5sive t su* an occurr5ce might give an al>m to 8 mi/ress1 p]suad$ ! pott] to ab/a9 f 8 purpose1 & !y accord+ly did n ent] ! def5dant's door4 ,?us1 g5tlem51 ! te/imony ( ! prosecutor is consi/5t 9 all its p>ts2 = al?\gh ,*ur* d5i$ "s circum/ances ( ! transaction z /at$ 9 8 lett] read to-day1 yet e ma9 & important feature ( ! transaction is confirm$ by collat]al circum/ances4 ,mr4 ,patrick's evid5ce is a direct corroboration ( ! boy's /ory1 f ! mom5t t ! transaction fir/ took place d[n to 8 exam9ation ( to-day4 ,b if1 g5tlem51 z ,i said be=e1 y feel any reasonable d\bt ( ! purpose = :i* ! def5dant came into ! boy's room1 x is y\r duty to acquit him2 b1 on ! o!r h&1 if all ! circum/ances ( ! case conspire to impr9t ^u y\r m9d t ! def5dant _h cle>ly no o!r purpose1 b a guilty & unnatural "o :5 he ent]$ t ap>tm5t1 x is y\r b\nd5 duty1 disgu/+ z x may be1 to pron\nce a s5t5ce ( condemnation1 :atev] consequ5ces may result to ! def5dant 9 ! judgm5t :i* he %all h]eaft] receive4 ,,! ,,*>ge4 ,"l ,ell5bor\gh deliv]$ 8 *>ge to ! jury z foll[s3 ,g5tlem5 ( ! ,jury--,?is is an indictm5t aga9/ ,john ,*ur* = an assault ^u ! p]son ( ,adam ,=eman1 ) int5t to commit an unnatural crime ) him4 ,!re has be5 a consid]able body ( evid5ce laid be=e y1 aga9/ him z well z = him3 & x is = y to say 9 ! result1 aft] giv+ t evid5ce due consid]ation1 :e!r ! def5dant has committ$ ! assault ) int5t to p]petrate ! atroci\s crime imput$ to him by ! indictm5t4 ,n[1 assum+ ! fact to be t ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 9 ! room at ! "t ?is (f5ce 0 suppos$ to h be5 committ$1 t alone imposes ^u him ! necessity ( giv+ "s explanation = ! occasion :i* br\ght him !re4 ,if1 9 addition to ! fact ( be+ !re1 :i* he admits1 himself1 to be true1 y %\ld believe ! boy fur!r 9 8 /atem5t t su* an ov]ture 0 made to him1 & t ! h& ( a man 0 put ^u 8 private p>ts 9 b$1 y w h to say ) :at o!r purpose ?an z an inducem5t to ! commission ( an unnatural crime1 x _h be5 plac$ !re4 ,t is1 suppos+ y believe ! facts z /at$ by ! "y man4 ,i %\ld appreh5d t no reason c be sugge/$ = su* an indec5t int]c\rse 7suppos+ x did take place7 ) ?is man's p]son unless x 0 a prelude or inducem5t to ! committ+ ( ! crime imput$ to ! def5dant4 ,n[ ! ma9 "q = y\r consid]ation w be1 :e!r t :i* is sworn by ,=eman1 & confirm$ by ,mr4 ,patrick1 is truly sworn4 ,i ?9k too mu* /ress has be5 laid ^u ! circum/ance1 /at$ ab\t ! se>*+ = ?ieves1 :i* x is said1 on ! "p ( ! def5dant1 0 ! av[$ object ( ,=eman 9 return+ to ! h\se4 ,x 0 v natural & highly probable :5 he appreh5d$1 if he did truly appreh5d1 t a male p]son _h come into 8 room & _h acco/$ him 9 ! mann] he /at$1 t he %\ld be cle>ly satisfi$ be=e he w5t f>!r 9 communicat+ to ! pott] ! indec5cies (f]$ to 8 p]son1 t !re 0 no o!r male 9 ! h\se1 & see+ t no o!r male c\ld come into ! h\se at t "t ( night1 unless he came = ?is purpose & no o!r4 ,9 ?is po9t ( view1 ,i ?9k x is n at all unnatural or improbable 9 8 conduct1 ev5 if he _h said t he _h gone 9 se>* = ?ieves2 &1 if y recollect1 8 evid5ce 01 8t he _h se>*$ ! h\se1 n = ?ieves 9 p>ticul>1 b to see if !re 0 any body 9 any ( ! rooms40 8,i did n ?9k ( ?ieves10 says he1 8because ,i knew :o x 010 & s on4 ,he n[ says1 t at t "t he knew x 0 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & !re=e he did n ?9k ( se>*+ = ?ieves1 8 object be+1 9 se>*+ ! h\se1 to asc]ta9 :e!r !re 0 any o!r male 9 ! h\se besides ! "o to :om he atta*es ! crime imput$ by ?is indictm5t4 ,g5tleman1 ,i %all n[ proce$ to /ate to y ! evid5ce z x has be5 giv5 on bo? sides4 ,adam ,=eman1 ! fir/ witness1 /ates1 t he %all be tw5ty ye>s ( age ! fir/ day ( ,decemb] next4 8,i am an appr5tice to1 ,mr4 ,patrick1 ! pott]1 ( ,vauxhall2 ,i h be5 ) him ab\t five ye>s4 ,i h kn[n ! def5dant1 ,john ,*ur*1 by sight ab\t two or ?ree ye>s4 ,he is a prea*]1 & ,i h att5d$ z "o ( ! congregation 9 ! *apel :]e he prea*es2 ,i h (t5 se5 him4 ,i sleep g5]ally at my fa!r's h\se1 b :5 my ma/] goes out ( t[n ,i sleep at 8 h\se4 ,! def5dant ,*ur* lives ne> 8 *apel 9 ,/4 ,george's ,fields4 ,! def5dant came to sleep at my ma/]'s on ! #be? ( ,septemb] la/40 ,x seems1 ,g5tlem51 he came !re by invitation f ,mr4 ,patrick1 hav+ weak heal?1 & x be+ m conv5i5t = him to sleep 9 bett] air4 8,he slept !re on ! night ( ! #be? ,septemb]2 ,i slept !re also1 t night4 ,i don't "k :e!r ! def5dant _h be5 !re be=e2 ,i _c say :e!r ,i _h se5 him !re be=e4 ,my ma/] 0 out ( t[n t night1 b :]e ,i _c say4 ,! p]sons :o slept 9 ! h\se t night 7 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 my mi/ress1 ! *ildr51 & ! two maid-s]vants2 !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se except ,*ur* & myself4 ,my b$-room 0 ! front p>l\r on ! fir/ floor1 ov] ! kit*54 ,x 0 n usually a b$-room1 b ,i slept !re because !re 0 no o!r b$-room t ,i c\ld sleep 94 ,a tempor>y b$ 0 put up !re = me4 ,i w5t to b$ at ne> "o o'clock4 ,!re 0 a kiln burn+1 & ,i 0 oblig$ to sit up to let ! man 9 to ! kiln :5 he came4 ,x 0 necess>y = me to sit up to att5d t kiln1 & to give ! man ! key4 ,t man's "n is ,?omas ,we/4 ,i w5t to sleep directly ,i w5t to b$4 ,i _h n be5 asleep m ?an half an h\r1 be=e ,i 0 awoke by "s "o putt+ 8 h&s "u ! b$ clo!s1 & lay+ hold ( my private p>ts4 ,he laid hold ( me v tight4 ,i put my h& out ( ! b$ clo!s & caught hold ( him1 & ask$ him :o he 04 ,i said1 :o are y8 ,i laid hold ( him1 z ne> z ,i c guess1 by ! upp] "p ( ! arm2 & ,i felt l[] d[n1 & f\nd by ! sleeve t he _h got a man's %irt on4 ,i _h a hold ( him by ! upp] "p ( ! arm1 & runn+ my h& d[n to ! wri/1 ,i f\nd he _h a man's %irt on4 ,! wri/ 0 button$4 ,i knew v well x 0 man1 because he _h got a man's %irt on4 ,! p]son1 :oev] x 01 said1 9 a fe9t voice l a woman1 8,adam1 don't y "k me8 ,i am y\r mi/ress40 ,x 0 n ,mrs4 ,patrick's voice4 ,i knew ! voice directly ,i he>d x to be ,mr4 ,*ur*'s4 ,he fl$ f ! room directly2 he w5t out ( ! room 9 a hurri$ /ep4 ,i got out ( b$ & put on my small clo!s & %oes1 & w5t out to ! door4 ,z ! man op5$ ! door1 ,i saw by ! lamp t x 0 ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & he _h only 8 %irt on4 ,! lamp is outside ( ! /reet door1 on ! ,t]race1 & ?r[s a light ?r\gh ! fan-light ( ! hall door4 ,x is a p>i% lamp4 ,at ! "t ,i saw ,*ur* by ! light ( ! lamp ,i 0 sitt+ up 9 b$3 ,i _h n !n left my b$4 ,i saw t ! p]son :o w5t out ?r\gh ! door _h a man's %irt on4 ,i did n see 8 face at all2 8 back 0 to me4 ,i !n got up & put my small-clo!s on & %oes1 & w5t to ! pott]y to get ! man to come up to ! h\se4 ,i told ,?omas ,we/ :at _h happ5$4 ,he 0 9 ! pott]y1 & 0 !re ,i be=e w5t to b$4 ,! p]son :o w5t out at ! door %ut x aft] him4 ,i saw him by ! light ( ! lamp :5 he op5$ ! door4 ,!re 0 no light 9 ! room2 ! light came f a lamp on ! t]race4 ,t lamp is ab\t five or six y>ds f ! door ( ! h\se on ! t]race4 ,! t]race1 on :i* my ma/]'s h\se is situat$1 is a r[ ( h\ses rais$ above ! road4 ,! lamp is ^u ! t]race opposite to ! door4 ,! light f ! lamp is giv5 to ! passage ?r\gh ! fan-light ov] ! door4 ,:5 ! man op5$ ! door & w5t out1 ,i saw him by ! light f ! lamp4 ,i c\ld n see ! face ( ! p]son1 b ,i saw t he _h a %irt on4 ,i 0 r al>m$4 ,x all took place 9 a m9ute4 ,x 0 n long ab\t4 ,i don't "k h[ long he _h be5 !re be=e ,i awoke4 ,f ! mom5t ,i awoke x took place z fa/ z possible4 ,i imm$iately w5t to ,we/4 ,we did n "k :e!r any body _h got 9 or n4 ,we/ & ,i directly came & se>*$ ! h\se = ?ieves4 ,we w5t & look$ at e *amb] door 9 ! home except ,mr4 ,*ur*'s & my mi/ress's4 ,we look$ at ! door ( ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & t ( my mi/ress4 ,!y 7 bo? %ut4 ,we f\nd all ! doors 9 ! h\se %ut except ! s]vant's1 :i* we f\nd on ! j>40 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 great /ress is laid by ! le>n$ c\nsel = ! ,def5dant ^u ?is circum/ance4 ,x is sugge/$ t x might be ,mrs4 ,patrick1 or "o ( ! maid s]vants :o ent]$ ! room4 ,x appe>s t "o ( ! s]vants 0 ! prosecutor's own si/]1 & x 0 n likely to be h] t w5t 94 ,x is said ! prosecutor's c\nsel ought to h call$ ! maid s]vant & ,mrs4 ,patrick to negative ! suppos$ circum/ance ( _! hav+ gone into ! room4 ,n[1 ?is obs]vation is to be made1 t x 0 op5 to ! "o side or to ! o!r to h call$ ! maid s]vant1 & h propos$ t "q to h]4 ,x 0 cle>ly op5 to ! ,def5dant1 if he *ose to call ! maid1 & to h ask$ h] t "q2 & x 0 equally op5 to ! c\nsel = ! prosecution4 ,x 0 also op5 to bo? sides to h call$ ,mrs4 ,patrick4 ,x is probable t ! prosecutor's c\nsel did n l to expose h] to ! pa9 ( an unnecess>y exam9ation1 because ! ,def5dant might h call$ h] z a witness = himself4 8,i w5t & told ,we/ t ,mr4 ,*ur* came d[n into my room1 & behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann]4 ,i told him t ,*ur* _h be5 !re & laid hold ( my private p>ts4 ,i did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves 9 p>ticul>1 b to se>* if any body 0 9 any ( ! rooms4 ,we se>*$ ! h\se4 ,we look$ all ov] x to see if !re 0 anybody 9 any ( ! rooms4 ,we se>*$ ! h\se1 b n = ?ieves 9 p>ticul>4 ,i did n ?9k ( ?ieves1 because ,i knew :o x 04 ,we did n g into ! maid s]vant's room2 we only look$ 94 ,we f\nd ! door op5 & look$ 94 ,! maids 7 9 b$4 ,"o 0 my si/]4 ,! door be+ a-j>1 we pu%$ a little1 & we saw t !y 7 a-b$4 ,we did n speak to !m4 ,we did n se>* ! h\se = ?ieves1 because ,i knew :o ! p]son 04 ,! reason ( my se>*+ ! h\se 0 because ,i wi%$ to be q "r be=e ,i made ! accusation aga9/ ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,we f\nd t !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se b ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,!re 0 no door1 no w9d[ op51 at :i* any o!r man c\ld h come 94 ,! light f ! ,t]race came ?r\gh ! fan-light ov] ! door4 ,! lamp gives a pretty fair light to ! hall1 & %ews a little light up ! /airs4 ,! "t :5 ! p]son op5$ ! door & w5t out1 0 ! "t t ,i got a view ( 8 p]son4 ,i did n he> him :5 he fir/ came into ! room4 ,i 0 awak5$ by ! application ( 8 h& to my p]son4 ,he 0 /&+ by ! b$-side on ! floor4 ,i did n call to him by "n1 or give him to und]/& t ,i knew :o he 04 ,i did n see any "p ( 8 face1 b ,i saw 8 back z he w5t out ( ! room4 ,he 0 a p]son t appe>$ to be ! height ( ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,i _c say :at height he is4 ,i _c say exactly :e!r he _h a night-cap on4 ,i ?9k x 0 a h&k]*ief ti$ r\nd 8 head4 ,i c\ld n tell :at sort ( a h&k]*ief x 01 :e!r col\r$ or n40 ,he does n say positively :e!r x 0 a light or a col\r$ h&k]*ief1 b he says he c\ld n tell4 ,he did n see :e!r x 0 col\r$ or n4 8,we w5t to ,*ur*'s door1 b we did n t\* x1 nor did we g 94 ,we/ want$ to g into ! room & pull him out40 ,t is confirm$ by ! te/imony ( ,we/ himself4 8,i object$ to ,we/'s pull+ him out1 because ,i 0 afraid ( di/urb+ my mi/ress4 ,%e w\ld h be5 v mu* al>m$40 ,t 0 ! acc\nt he gave 9 8 orig9al exam9ation be=e ! magi/rate1 z ! reason = 8 n go+ into ! room4 8,*ur* nev] _h any conv]sation ) me1 nor did he ev] make any ov]ture ( ?is sort to me be=e ?is "t4 ,!re 0 no?+ p>ticul> 9 8 mann] or 9 8 conduct t[>ds me be=e ?is "t4 ,i h nev] spok5 to him at all s9ce4 ,i saw him att5d be=e ! magi/rate4 ,!re ,i spoke 9 8 pres5ce1 b n imm$iately to him4 ,i did n he> him speak be=e ! magi/rate4 ,i h giv5 ! same acc\nt be=e ! magi/rate t ,i h n[ done "h4 ,i "k no o!r circum/ances f :i* ,i c\ld collect t x 0 a man4 ,! h& 0 )drawn :5 ,i awoke4 ,by ! height ( ! p]son ,i saw1 ,i c\ld asc]ta9 :e!r x 0 or 0 n ! height ( my mi/ress or any ( ! female "p ( ! h\se4 ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 a great deal bigg] ?an any body !re4 ,i don't ?9k he is q six foot4 ,he is a tall & /\t man4 ,!re 0 light en\gh by ! lamp to see ! outl9e ( ! man1 s z to be able to say t he 0 a tall p]son4 ,mrs4 ,patrick is q a little woman1 %e is q diff]5t p]son f ! p]son ,i saw 9 ! room4 ,i am q cle> ( t4 ,! maid :o slept 9 ! room ) my si/]1 is ab\t z tall z ,i am2 n q s tall4 ,i am q sure x 0 n h]4 ,!re 0 no o!r maid 9 ! h\se40 ,?is is ! evid5ce ( ! fir/ witness2 & y obs]ve he says1 he is q sure x 0 n any ( ! females ( ! h\se :o came into 8 room2 & he is q sure t !re 0 no o!r male p]son 9 ! h\se besides himself & ! ,def5dant ,*ur*2 & he is c]ta9 t x 0 n ! maid nor 8 mi/ress4 ,! next witness exam9$ is ,?omas ,we/4 ,he says1 8,i am workm5 to ,mr4 ,patrick1 ! pott]4 ,on ! morn+ ( ! #bf? ( ,septemb] la/1 ,i reliev$ ,adam ,=eman at ! ,kiln4 ,i reliev$ him ab\t half pa/ twelve o'clock 9 ! morn+3 he left me %ortly aft]w>ds = ! purpose ( go+ to b$4 ,i saw him aga9 9 ab\t half an h\r4 ,he 0 only "p dress$4 ,he _h 8 small clo!s1 8 %oes1 & "o /ock+ on4 ,he came to me 9 a v great fright1 & bid me light my c&le4 ,he appe>$ v mu* al>m$1 & bid me light my c&le & come along ) him up to ! h\se4 ,he told me1 z we 7 go+ along ! g>d51 t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h be5 to him1 & behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann]4 ,he did n expla9 h[4 ,he unlock$ ! door1 & we w5t into ! h\se toge!r4 ,:5 we got into ! h\se he put ! rema9d] ( 8 clo!s on4 ,we !n w5t & se>*$ e room 9 ! h\se1 beg9n+ at ! bottom & go+ upw>ds to ! top1 except my mi/ress's room & ,mr4 ,*ur*'s4 ,we w5t into all ! rooms except ,mr4 ,*ur*'s & ,mrs4 ,patrick's4 ,we did n g into ,mr4 ,*ur*'s room or t ( my mi/ress4 ,we did n op5 ! door ( ei!r ( ^? two rooms4 ,:5 we came to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s door1 ,i said1 8,i'll g & pull him out2 %all ,i80 ,! ,lad said1 8,no1 = fe> ( di/urb+ my mi/ress40 ,9 consequ5ce ( t obs]vation ( ! lad's1 ,i =ebore go+ into ! room4 ,=eman !n came along ) me into ! ,pott]y4 ,he came d[n /airs2 lock$ ! back door1 & /aid ) me ! :ole ( ! rema9d] ( ! night at ! ,pott]y 'till ! morn+4 ,we se>*$ 9 all ! rooms ( ! h\se = ! purpose ( see+ if !re 0 any o!r p]son 9 ! place4 ,we f\nd no w9d[ or door op5 at :i* any body c\ld h got into ! h\se4 ,i saw !m all secure & fa/5$4 ,:5 ,=eman came to me1 he did n expla9 :at ,*ur* _h done to him2 he only told me t ,*ur* _h behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann] to him4 ,i did g to se>* = ?ieves 9 ! h\se4 ,:5 he told me t ,*ur* _h behav$ 9 a v indec5t mann] to him1 ,i w5t to see if !re 0 any o!r p]son 9 ! place4 ,=eman did n tell me he believ$ t !re 0 ?ieves 9 ! h\se4 ,i am q sure he did n expla9 9 :at way ,*ur* behav$ to him4 ,he did n tell me t ,*ur* came to 8 b$ side1 & laid 8 h& ^u 8 private p>ts2 he nev] f fir/ to ! la/1 ei!r 9 ! c\rse ( ! morn+ :5 /ay+ ) me1 or aft] we _h be5 to ! h\se1 tell me :at ,*ur* _h done1 & t he _h laid 8 h& ^u 8 private p>ts4 ,i w5t be=e ! ,magi/rate "s "t aft] ?is2 ,i believe x 0 six or sev5 weeks40 ,g5tlem51 !re w\ld be a great deal 9 ! obs]vation ^u ! circum/ance ( ! p>ties n go+ be=e ! ,magi/rate until six or sev5 weeks aft]w>ds1 if ! matt] _h be5 kept a secret4 ,b x is n kept a secret2 s f> f t1 x 0 q notori\s4 ,& "h is a lett]1 9 ! h&-writ+ ( ! ,def5dant himself1 dat$ ! #f? ( ,octob]1 9 answ] to a lett] ( ,mrs4 ,hunt]2 & x appe>s t ! subject _h be5 v5tilat$ & circulat$1 = "s days be=e1 & _h become ! topic ( g5]al discussion among/ ! ,def5dant's congregation2 because x appe>s t ,mrs4 ,hunt] _h writt5 a lett] h]self to ! ,def5dant ^u x4 ,!re is no?+1 !re=e1 9 ! obs]vation ( ! ,le>n$ ,c\nsel = ! ,def5dant z to ! t>d9ess ( go+ be=e ! ,magi/rate4 ,he says1 8,! ,lad !n w5t ) 8 fa!r4 ,! ,lad g5]ally slept at home at 8 fa!r's h\se4 ,! fa!r lives ab\t a qu>t] ( a mile f ,mr4 ,patrick's4 ,! ,boy did n sleep at 8 fa!r's ! next night2 b he did ! next night aft] t4 ,we did n g to ! ,ju/ices until ab\t six or sev5 weeks aft]w>ds4 ,i did n communicate ) ,mr4 ,patrick ^u ! subject be=e ,i w5t to ! ,ju/ice40 ,! next witness call$ is ,mr4 ,patrick4 ,he says1 ,i am a ,pott]1 at ,vauxhall2 ! boy1 ,=eman1 liv$ ) me all ! "t ,i h be5 9 ! pott]y bus9ess2 t is1 betwe5 five & six ye>s4 ,he slept 9 my h\se only occasionally1 & t 0 :5ev] ,i w5t out ( t[n4 ,z !re 0 no o!r male 9 ! h\se on ^? occasions1 he us$ to sleep !re = ! purpose ( giv+ ! key to ! ,pott] 9 ! morn+4 ,i 0 abs5t f home on ! #be? ( ,septemb]2 & on t occasion ! ,boy slept 9 my h\se2 he slept ^u a *air b$ 9 ! front p>l\r2 x 0 a tempor>y b$ = a nurse occasionally4 ,i knew ! ,def5dant1 ,john ,*ur*2 ,i fir/ became acqua9t$ ) him :5 ,i came to reside at ,vauxhall2 he is a ,bapti/ ,prea*]1 & ,i att5d$ 8 *apel2 & t 0 ! way ,i became acqua9t$ ) him4 ,8 resid5ce is adjo9+ to ! ,*apel4 ,9 ! mon? ( ,septemb]1 ! ,def5dant came to sleep at my h\se4 ,he compla9$ occasionally ( ill heal?2 & ?9k+ t he 0 ill1 ,i ask$ him1 out ( fri5d%ip1 to take a b$ at my h\se1 z ,i ?\ght ! air w\ld be ( s]vice to him4 ,i return$ home on ! ev5+ ( ! #bf? ( ,septemb]1 & on ! morn+ ( ! #bg? ! ,boy made a communication to me respect+ ?is transaction4 ,s t y see1 ,g5tlem51 ! ,boy makes ?is communication to 8 ma/] at ! e>lie/ mom5t he has an opportunity ( speak+ to him4 8,sev]al ( ! congregation aft]w>ds appli$ to me1 & at _! reque/ ,i w5t to ,mr4 ,*ur* on ! #i? ( ,octob]40 ,b1 ,g5tlem51 ! #i? ( ,octob] is n ! fir/ "t t ?is matt] 0 m5tion$2 = x appe>s to h be5 9 circulation at ! "t t ,mr4 ,*ur* wrote ! lett] :i* has be5 giv5 9 evid5ce4 8,t 0 ! fir/ communication ,i _h ) ,mr4 ,*ur* on ! subject4 ,*ur* said he took x extremely k9d ( me 9 call+ ^u him4 ,i said he might take x z he pleas$1 z ,i did n come will+ly1 b t "s ( 8 congregation ?\ght t ,i ought to see him on ! bus9ess40 ,y obs]ve1 ,g5tlem51 t x 0 at ! reque/ ( "s ( ! congregation t he w5t2 &1 9 a subsequ5t "p ( ! evid5ce1 x appe>s t ,mr4 ,?omas1 "o ( ! congregation1 _h expressly desir$ him to call ^u ! ,def5dant4 8,i told him1 ,i wait$ ^u him1 hav+ se5 a lett]1 :]e9 he d5i$ ?ree p>ticul> po9ts 9 ! ,boy's /atem5t4 ,he !n d5i$1 9 ! fleet place1 hav+ tak5 hold ( ! ,boy1 & 9 ! second1 8 hav+ said to ! ,boy t he 0 8 mi/ress4 ,! ?ird po9t ,i didn't p>ticul>ly recollect2 b 9 ! c\rse ( conv]sation he admitt$ t he _h be5 9 ! ,boy's room4 ,he d5i$ t he _h _h hold ( ! ,boy1 & t he _h told ! ,boy t he 0 8 mi/ress4 ,i told him t ( ^! two po9ts ! ,boy 0 positive1 & ,i _h no reason to d\bt any ?+ t he said4 ,! ,def5dant said #8t he 0 v sorry = x2 ! wor/ ( x 01 x confirm$ anci5t reports4'0 ,g5tlem51 ?is is ! language ( ,*ur* himself4 ,:at ^? anti5t reports 7 we h n he>d2 we are only left to guess at :at ! expression allud$ to4 ,^u :i* ,mr4 ,patrick said1 8,x did s1 & ( c\rse10 says he1 8,i told him t ,i %\ld believe all t ,i _h he>d h]et(ore3 & ,i wi%$ him a good morn+4 ,i h nev] spok5 to him s9ce2 b ,i h se5 him4--,?is is an exact copy ( ! lett] dat$ ! #f? ( ,octob]1 address$ to ,mrs4 ,hunt]40 ,g5tlem51 ?is lett] is aft]w>ds read 9 evid5ce4 ,mrs4 ,hunt] be+ call$ z a witness1 %e /at$ t %e believ$1 f ! k t %e _h ( ! "* ( ! ,def5dant's h&-writ+1 %e believes ! orig9al f :i* ?is copy is tak51 0 writt5 by him2 & ,mr4 ,patrick swe>s t ! lett] f :i* he took ?is copy 01 9 8 belief1 9 8! h&-writ+ ( ! ,def5dant40 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 ^u read+ ?is lett]1 "o is v mu* /ruck1 n by :at x conta9s1 absurd z x is 9 "s respects1 & conta9+ some?+ l a pr(ane use ( ! sacr$ "n ( ! ,savi\r1 b at ! abs5ce ( :at "o c]ta9ly might naturally expect to f9d 9 ! lett] ( a p]son writ+ to a fri5d1 & "o ( 8 own congregation1 ^u ?is subject4 ,:at is s natural z t he %\ld mo/ explicitly & p]emptorily d5y ! :ole accusation & *>ge1 & re/ ) confid5ce ^u 8 own innoc5ce & ! "* :i* he bore among/ 8 congregation4 ,b in/ead ( t1 he envelopes ! matt] 9 a sanctifi$ discussion1 su* z has be5 read to y1 dwell+ ^u ! sacr$ "n ( our ,savi\r 9 a v indec5t mann]4 ,i %all read ?is lett] to y aga92 & if y f9d any ?+ 9 x :i* c be con/ru$ into an express d5ial ( ! circum/ances *>g$ aga9/ him1 ,i am sure x w make a prop] impression ^u y\r m9ds4 ,i confess ,i c f9d no su* d5ial4 ,he says1 8,i am able to contradict ?ree ?+s0--"o ( :i* is lay+ hold ( ! boy's p]son1 & ! o!r ! speak+ ( 8 mi/ress4 ,! ?ird po9t1 ,mr4 ,patrick does n recollect4 ,b1 y w obs]ve1 he did n d5y be+ 9 ! room3 t seems to be a fact n[ undisput$4 ,! lett] is 9 ^! words3-- ,oct4 #f1 #ahaf4 8,de> ,mrs4 ,hunt]--,my he>t is already too mu* affect$4 ,y\r lett] only add$ affliction to my bonds2 b ,i =be>4 ,i w\ld h call$ on y ?is morn+1 b ,i 0 too l[ 9 m9d to speak to any fri5d b ,jesus4 ,!re ,i am truly com=table4 ,p>don me4 ,b ,i make no rem>ks on :at y h be5 told4 ,i mu/ be> x4 ,?\gh ,i am able to contradict ^! ?+s1 ,i w\ld r n4 ,mr4 & ,mrs4 ,patrick h always dealt k9dly to me4 ,i am only griev$ t de> ,mrs4 ,p4 :om ,i really love1 t %e %\ld try to injure me 9 ! e/imation ( ^? :o are real fri5ds to my de> *ildr54 ,! ?\ght affects me1 ,:y hurt my poor family8 ,b ,i am too mu* depress$ to enl>ge4 ,i %all nev] =get _! k9dness4 ,god w rew>d !m1 z he has _m :o h dealt well to me4 ,b he w res5t cruelty 9 ^? :o h & are /ill try+ to degrade me4 ,mrs4 ,p4 w live to see x4 ,de> ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 ,i am griev$ at he>t4 ,i c n relieve y\r m9d4 ,i am truly sorry to lose y z a he>]1 because y\r s\l has be5 bless$1 & y "k bo? ! plague ( ! he>t & ! value ( ,jesus4 ,may he be increas+ly preci\s to y6--9 8 p]son1 love1 & grave4 ,f>ewell1 my de> k9d fri5d4 ,! ,"l ,jesus w rew>d y = y\r love to me & k9dness to m9e4 ,god is n unrighte\s to =get y\r "w ( fai? & lab\r ( love4 ,) _m te>s ,i write ?is4 ,may we meet 9 glory1 :5 no enemy %all di/ress my m9d1 nor s91 nor dea? %all "p u m4 ,i ne$ n rem9d my de> fri5d t ,i am a *ild ( peculi> ,provid5ce40 ,?is is v extraord9>y4 ,:e!r he consid]s himself z privileg$ above ! re/ ( mank9d1 ,i "k n3 b x %\ld seem t he does4 ,he says3 8,i am a *ild ( peculi> provid5ce3 & t ,he>t ( ,et]nal ,love1 & t ,arm ( ,inv9cible ,p[]1 has protect$ me--has call$ me to himself--& = e act ( /ray+1 w correct me40 ,!re=e1 he admits t he is subject to ! puni%m5t ( ! ,div9e ,be+4 ,:e!r he is exempt f ! temporal jurisdiction = 8 crimes or n1 seems to be a matt] ( d\bt ) him3 = he says1-- 8,9 e act ( /ray+1 ,god w correct me ) 8 own h&2 b w res5t e o!r h& soon] or lat]40 ,s t he admits t = 8 (f5ces1 or 8 8acts ( /ray+10 z he is pleas$ to call !m1 ,god w puni% him ) 8 own h&2 b t no o!r h& w puni% him4 ,! lett] concludes-- 8,?is y w live to see4 ,adieu1 de> fri5d3 accept ! />t+ te>1 & ! be/ wi%es ( an he>t s9c]e4 8,y\r's1 truly1 8,till we %all meet above40 ,g5tlem51 ?is is 8 lett]4 ,if x _h be5 a full & explicit d5ial ( ! :ole *>ge1 x w\ld h be5 m fav\rable to him4 ,"o is sorry to see ! "n ( ! ,div9e ,be+ mix$ up ) s indec5t & abom9able a /ory4 ,mr4 ,patrick goes on to /ate t he d5i$ hav+ _h hold ( ! boy1 b he admitt$ t he 0 9 ! room2 ^u 8 say+ to ! ,def5dant t z to ! two po9ts 9 "q1 ! boy 0 positive1 & t he _h no reason to d\bt any ?+ t ! boy said1 ! def5dant repli$ t he 0 sorry = x1 because x confirm$ anci5t reports4 ,! witness said1 8x did s20 & he told him t he %\ld n[ believe all t he _h he>d h]et(ore1 & he wi%$ him a good morn+4 ,he says1 8,i nev] saw him aft]w>ds to speak to him4 ,?is is an exact copy ( ! lett] dat$ #f? ,octob]1 #ahaf1 address$ to ,mrs4 ,hunt]4 ,i took an exact copy ( x myself4 ,i did n read ! copy ( ! lett] to ! ,def5dant1 = ,i _h n ! copy ) me at t "t4 ,) respect to ! lett] ,i told him t ,i wi%$ to "k :at ! ?ree ?+s 7 t he c\ld d5y4 ,i d n recollect ! ?ird po9t2 x is n mat]ial1 he admitt$ be+ 9 ! room1 b d5i$ ! lay+ hold40 ,he is ask$ 9 :at t]ms ! ,def5dant admitt$ t he 0 9 ! room1 & he said ! ,def5dant said1 8,i 0 9 ! room1 b ,i did n lay hold ( ! boy40 ,he did n say :y he 0 9 ! room4 8,i return$ ! lett] ( ! #f? ( ,octob] to ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 f :om ,i receiv$ x40 ,on 8 cross-exam9ation he says3--8,i mean to say t ! ,def5dant said di/9ctly t he 0 9 ! room4 ,i nev] said to any p]son aft] ,i _h se5 ,mr4 ,*ur* t ,i ?\ght he 0 n implicat$ at all 9 ! *>ge4 ,i gave a p]son nam$ ,?omas an acc\nt ( ! conv]sation ,i _h ) ! ,def5dant1 b ,i nev] accompani$ t acc\nt ) ! obs]vation 8he is n implicat$0--nor to any p]son4 ,mr4 ,?omas w5t ) me to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se1 b he did n g 94 ,mr4 ,?omas is n a fri5d ( m9e4 ,mr4 ,?omas walk$ ) me to ! door4 ,x 0 8 wife's wi% & my wife's t ,i %\ld make ! application to ! ,def5dant4 ,mr4 ,?omas walk$ ) me z f> z ! door ( ! ,def5dant1 b he did n g 94 ,aft] ,i came out f ,mr4 ,*ur*'s ,i _h "s conv]sation ) ,mr4 ,?omas1 & ,i told him p>tly :at _h transpir$4 ,x 0 v %ort :at did transpire4 ,i ?9k ,i told ,mr4 ,?omas t ! ,def5dant admitt$ 8 hav+ be5 9 ! boy's room1 b ,i am n v positive z to t po9t4 ,i "k ,i told him t ,mr4 ,*ur* said he did n lay hold ( him4 ,i nev] made any su* answ] to ,mr4 ,?omas z t ,i ?\ght ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 n at all implicat$0--nor any ?+ convey+ t mean+4 ,i nev] told him directly or indirectly t !re 0 no?+ to implicate ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,i nev] told ,mr4 ,?omas or any o!r p]son t ,i w\ld prosecute ,mr4 ,*ur* = ?is crime1 because he _h said disrespectful ?+s ( my wife3 b ,i ?9k ,i told ,mr4 ,i w\ld prosecute ! ,def5dant = ! defamation ( my wife's "*4 ,b ?is 0 a consid]able "t aft] ! transaction 9 "q4 ,i ?9k ,i did in=m ,mr4 ,?omas t ,i w\ld prosecute ! ,def5dant = ! defamation ( my wife's "*4 ,! next witness call$ is ,mrs4 ,hunt]1 & %e says--8,i am "o ( ! congregation & a he>] ( ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,i receiv$ a lett]1 dat$ ! #f? ( ,octob]1 b x _h no "n subscrib$ to x4 ,i _c tell f :om x came4 ,x _h no place ( abode or signature1 except ! day ( ! mon?4 ,i put t lett] into ! h&s ( ,mr4 ,patrick1 at lea/ ,i gave x to ,mr4 ,patrick's daught]1 :o gave x to h] fa!r4 ,t lett] 0 return$ to me1 b ,i took no fur!r notice ( x4 ,aft] ! lett] 0 return$ to me1 ,i put x into a draw]1 & ,i d n "k :at is become ( x4 ,i look$ = x on ! ,?ursday morn+ be=e ,i came "h1 b ,i 0 unable to f9d x4 ,i se>*$ dilig5tly = x1 b ,i c\ld f9d no trace ( x40 ,"u su* circum/ances1 ,g5tlem51 ! orig9al lett] hav+ be5 se>*$ =1 & n be+ to be f\nd1 t1 9 po9t ( law1 lets 9 ! copy ( x1 :i* c\ld n be admitt$ z evid5ce z x exi/$4 ,%e is !n ask$ :e!r ! lett] receiv$ 0 9 ! h& writ+ ( ,mr4 ,*ur*8 & %e says1 8,i h se5 8 writ+4 ,i h se5 him write 9 diff]5t h&s4 ,he does n write always ! same4 ,i don't mean to say exactly t he wrote 9 diff]5t h&s2 b !re 0 su* a diff]5ce 9 ! same h&-writ+ t "o w\ld h>dly ?9k x 0 ! same4 ,i r ?9k t lett] 0 9 ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h&-writ+1 b ,i c\ld n be positive z !re 0 no "n to x4 ,i _c say positively :e!r x 0 or 0 n 8 h&-writ+4 ,i believ$ !n x 0 8 h&-writ+1 & ,i /ill believe ! same4 ,i did n communicate ! lett] to any body b ,mr4 ,patrick1 & ,i told him t ,i _h receiv$ a lett] f ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,! se>* ,i made = ! lett] 0 la/ ,?ursday4 ,i "k no?+ ( x1 & ,i h no reason to believe t x is n[ 9 exi/5ce4 ,i did n leave a draw] or a place unse>*$40 ,mr4 ,patrick is aga9 call$1 & says t he knew ! h& writ+ ( ! ,def5dant 9 ,octob] la/4 8,i copi$ ?is lett] f ! lett] ,i _h f ,mrs4 ,hunt]4 ,i believe t ! lett] f :i* ,i made ?is copy 0 9 ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h& writ+40 ,g5tlem5 y h _h t lett] read to y2 & ?is is ! ,case on ! "p ( ! ,prosecution4 ,on ! "p ( ! ,def5dant1 ,g5tlem51 x is obs]v$ z matt] ( surprise t ! ,prosecutor's ,c\nsel h n call$ ! female s]vant z a witness4 ,x is v true %e 0 n call$1 b x 0 op5 to ! ,def5dant to h call$ h]1 & und\bt$ly if 8 ,c\nsel ?\ght t any exam9ation ( h]s w\ld h be5 b5eficial to him1 we mu/ presume t %e w\ld h be5 call$4 ,! ,b$-room door ( ! s]vants1 x is obs]v$1 0 aj>2 & x is cont5d$ t "o ( ! s]vants might h be5 ! p]son :o w5t d[n /airs to ! "y man's room3 & x is fur!r cont5d$ t !re 0 su* a defici5cy ( light t x 0 impossible = ! ,prosecutor to id5tify ) c]ta9ty ! p]son :o ent]$ 8 ap>tm5t4 ,n[ :e!r !re is any ?+ 9 ! obs]vation z to ! defici5cy ( ! light1 x = y to judge2 b ?is rem>k fairly arises f ! circum/ance ( ! maid's ,b$-room door be+ a-j>4 ,x is mo/ likely t if ei!r ( !m came out ( ! room = any improp] purpose1 %e w\ld h %ut ! door aft] h]3 & x is to be recollect$ t "o ( ! s]vants 0 ! ,boy's own ,si/]4 ,x is obs]v$ likewise z matt] ( surprise1 t ,mrs4 ,patrick is n call$4 ,g5tlem51 x w\ld be v disrespectful to ,mrs4 ,patrick to put su* a "q to h]1 z :e!r %e (f]$ ^! indec5cies to ! ,boy2 b if ! ,def5dant's ,c\nsel ?\ght t %e c\ld n h /ood t exam9ation1 z ,i h repeat$ly told y1 !y might h call$ h]4 ,on ! "p ( ! def5dant1 !y call$ ,mr4 ,?omas1 & he says1 8,i live 9 ,prospect ,place1 ,we/ ,squ>e1 ,/4 ,george's ,fields4 ,i am by bus9ess1 an apprais] & und]tak]4 ,i "k ! def5dant ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,i 0 "o ( 8 he>]s4 ,i 0 acqua9t$ ) ,mr4 ,patrick1 b n until ! report 0 made respect+ ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,i c't say t ,i h ev] se5 him att5d+ ,mr4 ,*ur*1 z "o ( ! congregation4 ,i w5t ) ,mr4 ,patrick ! day he w5t to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se4 ,x 0 ! #i? ( ,octob]1 a few days aft] ! report4 ,i did n g into ! h\se ) him4 ,i /ood outside ! door4 ,i le>n$ f ,mr4 ,patrick1 t he 0 go+ to ,mr4 ,*ur* ^u ! subject ( ?is bus9ess4 ,he told me he _h a lett] ( ,mr4 ,*ur*'s1 & 0 go+ to him to make inquiries4 ,he call$ ^u me at my h\se too ) him1 & he told me he 0 go+ ^u ! bus9ess ( ?is inquiry4 ,inde$1 x 0 at my reque/ t he %\ld40 ,s t y see1 ,g5tlem51 x 0 n ! volunt>y intrusion ( ,mr4 ,patrick ^u ,mr4 ,*ur*1 :5 he w5t to 8 h\se2 b x is 9 compliance ) ! reque/ ( "s ( ! ,congregation4 ,he says 8,mrs4 ,?omas w5t to speak to 8 wife1 & x 0 at my wife's & 8 wife's reque/ t he w5t4--,! int]view ) ,mr4 ,*ur* la/$ ne> an h\r4 ,x seem$ to be a long :ile1 n mu* less ?an an h\r1 z ne> z ,i c guess ! "t4 ,:5 he came out ,i put "s que/ions to him respect+ :at _h pass$ betwe5 him & ,mr4 ,*ur*3--,i ask$ him :at ,mr4 ,*ur* _h said8 & he repli$ t ,mr4 ,*ur* did n say any?+40 ,n[1 ,g5tlem51 x is impossible t ,*ur* c\ld h said no?+1 = x is n v likely t ,mr4 ,patrick w\ld be occupi$ = an h\r he>+ himself4 8,he said ,mr4 ,*ur* seem$ v mu* conf\nd$ on acc\nt ( ! cause1 b said not+40 ,c]ta9ly1 ,mr4 ,?omas1 f ! nature ( ?+s1 mu/ be incorrect1 = x is impossible t ,mr4 ,patrick c\ld be an h\r 9 conv]sation ) ,mr4 ,*ur*1 & t ! latt] %\ld say no?+4 ,mr4 ,patrick c\ld n be an h\r 9 conv]sation ) himself4 8,he said ,mr4 ,*ur* seem$ v mu* conf\nd$ on acc\nt ( ! cause4 ,he 7,patrick7 seem$ to ins9uate t x w\ld be injuri\s to ! cause ,god4 ,he did n say1 8! cause10 b ,i only suppose he meant ! cause ( ,god4 ,i ask$ :e!r ,*ur* _h said any ?+1 & ,patrick said 8,no40 ,he said he seem$ v mu* confus$4 ,i said1 :at d y mean8 ,if !re is any ?+ aga9/ ! man1 d y ?9k ,i w\ld n h be5 fai?ful to him & h *>g$ him ) x8 ,mr4 ,patrick said1 he did n "k any ?+ ab\t t1 & t he 0 n ! prop] p]son4 ,he said1 8,i don't "k1--,i am n s prop] z y40 ,i said to him1 8:at did he say respect+ ! report80 ,he said x 0 false4--,patrick himself said ! report 0 false4 ,i !n said1 8:at did ,mr4 ,*ur* /ate respect+ its hav+ be5 report$ t he 0 9 liquor80 ,mr4 ,patrick repli$1 8t t 0 false1 & t !re _h be5 a great deal ( exagg]ation4 ,i nev] put ! "q to ,mr4 ,patrick1 8:e!r he ?\ght t ,*ur* 0 implicat$ 9 ! transaction or n80 ,i nev] us$ ^! words or any to ! same effect4 ,i put ^! words to him1 8,:y10 says ,i1 8,y did no?+4 ,did ,mr4 ,*ur* ackn[l$ge no?+ to y80 8,no1 ,sir10 says he1 8he did n40 ,i said1 8z y c br+ no?+ aga9/ him1 let u pray = him1 if he 0 "u any su* temptation40 ,! phrase :i* ! witness uses seems to signify t ! ,def5dant's disposition 0 n v prop]4 ,:at occasion 0 !re to pray = him n to be guilty ( su* an (f5ce8 ,:at temptation c\ld !re be to a moral man to excite him to ! commission ( s unnatural a crime8 8,mr4 ,patrick nev] deliv]$ any op9ion to me1 :e!r he ?\ght ,*ur* 0 implicat$ 9 ! transaction or n4 ,no?+ m pass$ at ! meet+40 ,on 8 cross-exam9ation he said1 8,i he>d ( ?is bus9ess two or ?ree days aft] x happ5$4 ,my wife & ,i 7 desir\s t ,mr4 ,patrick %\ld g to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s4 ,mr4 ,patrick br\ght ! boy to me1 9 ord] to h him br\ght face to face ) ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,mr4 ,patrick said t ! boy 0 outside4 ,he did n p>ticul>ly wi% me to see ! boy2 b ,i c]ta9ly suppos$ t he br\ght ! boy = ! purpose ( go+ to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se4 ,mr4 ,patrick & ,i w5t toge!r1 & ! boy foll[$4 ,! boy did n g 9 ) ,mr4 ,patrick4 ,he /aid outside ! door4 ,he walk$ on ! o!r side ( ! way4 ,he wait$ :il/ ,i wait$4 ,we bo? wait$ outside40 ,n[1 g5tlem51 !re is some?+ 9 ! mann] 9 :i* ?is p]son gave 8 evid5ce1 :i* leads me to conclude t he has n giv5 a correct repres5tation ( all t _h pass$ betwe5 him & ,mr4 ,patrick2 9 ! fir/ place he says1 t ,mr4 ,patrick told him t ,mr4 ,*ur* n[ said no?+4 ,n[ t is mo/ extraord9>y4 ,c x be believ$ t ,mr4 ,*ur* _h said no?+1 or t ,patrick _h told ! witness s8 ,well1 !n1 z to ! re/ ( 8 conduct1 ,mr4 ,patrick _h br\ght ! s\rce ( 8 own in=mation1 namely ! boy1 to ! witness1 9 ord] t ! p]son :o br\ght =w>d ! accusation might by exam9$ by ,mr4 ,?omas himself1 if he *ose to inquire into ! subject4 ,mr4 ,patrick br\ght him to g to ,mr4 ,*ur*'s1 & ! boy & ,mr4 ,?omas 7 left outside ! door2 = he says1 8,he & ,i wait$ outside ( ! door30 b ,mr4 ,?omas nev] ?9ks x wor? 8 :ile to ask ! boy a s+le "q4 ,he nev] tr\bles himself to exam9e into ! ext5t ( ! *>ge1 or inquire into ! f\ndation ( x4 ,b he says1 8,mr4 ,patrick 0 to g 9 & le>n :at ,mr4 ,*ur* said2 & !n ! boy & ,i 7 to g 9 too4 ,mr4 ,patrick took ! boy ) him1 9 ord] t he might be tak5 9 to see ,mr4 ,*ur* face to face4 ,he br\ght ! boy ) him1 & ,i suppose t 0 8 int5tion4 ,i decl9$ introduc+ ! boy to ,mr4 ,*ur*1 because ,i _h no p>ticul> acqua9tance ) ,mr4 ,*ur*4 ,i 0 only "o ( 8 he>]s2 & ,i ?\ght x 0 too great a lib]ty = me to speak to him ^u ! subject4 ,mr4 ,patrick want$ me to g into ,mr4 ,*ur* fir/40 ,:y1 ,g5tlem51 :o 0 m prop] to inquire into su* a subject1 ?an a p]son :o att5d$ ! def5dant 9 ! celebration ( div9e wor%ip8 ,b ,mr4 ,?omas says1 he ?\ght x w\ld be an obtrusion = him to g into ,mr4 ,*ur*'s h\se4 ,:at obtrusion c\ld x be 9 a case ( su* mom5t\s consequ5ce1 :]e ! "* & hon\r ( 8 spiritual tea*] 7 at /ake8 ,:y s5d ,mr4 ,patrick if x 0 an obtrusion1 & if ! matt] 0 ( s delicate a nature8 ,well1--he goes on to say1 8,i suppose ! purpose ( br++ ! boy 01 t he %\ld be introduc$ to ,mr4 ,*ur*--,i h no d\bt ab\t x4 ,i don't "k any o!r reason = 8 be+ br\ght--,i don't "k t ,mr4 ,patrick said t 0 8 reason4 ,i don't "k t he said any ?+ ab\t invit+ me to g to ) ! boy--,i don't recollect t he did4 ,i don't rememb] decl9+ to g 9 ) ,mr4 ,patrick4 ,i _h told him t ,i _h no p>ticul> int]e/ 9 ! bus9ess4 ,i _h no m intimacy ) ,mr4 ,*ur* except he>+ him--,i ?\ght t be+ only a he>]1 my visit w\ld be obtrusive4 ,i _h no p>ticul> int]e/ 9 ! affair1 & !re=e ,i decl9$ go+ 91 or tak+ ! boy ) me4 ,i saw no necessity1 if ! def5dant did n ackn[l$ge himself guilty ( any ?+ bad4 ,?\gh ! boy 0 !re1 ,i _h n ! curiosity to exam9e him1 x be+ a delicate subject4 ,i did n see ! importance ( com+ at ! tru? ( ! case1 z ,mr4 ,*ur* did n confess any ?+2 b if ,mr4 ,*ur* _h confess$ any ?+1 ,i %\ld h ?\ght x my duty to take ! boy 91 & h !m face to face40 ,?is1 ,g5tlem51 is a mo/ extraord9>y acc\nt :i* ,mr4 ,?omas gives ( himself4 ,if he f\nd ,mr4 ,*ur* guilty1 he w\ld h confront$ ! boy ) him6 ,b if he d5i$ 8 guilt1 he w\ld n ?9k x necess>y to exam9e ! boy6 ,"o w\ld h ?\ght t a s5se ( ju/ice to ! def5dant1 9 su* a case1 w\ld h prompt$ him to enquire :e!r ! *>ge 0 n f\nd$ 9 malice4 ,b no2 ) ! opportunity ( que/ion+ ! boy on ! spot1 he leaves ! matt] unt\*$4 ,he says1 8,:5 ,mr4 ,patrick came out & said t ,mr4 ,*ur* did n ackn[l$ge any ?+ ( x1 he did n ?9k x necess>y !n to h ! boy 940 ,he says1 8,i nev] spoke to ! boy2 ,i nev] ask$ ,mr4 ,patrick1 nor did he give any op9ion ab\t :e!r ,mr4 ,*ur* 0 implicat$ 9 ! transaction2 b 9 answ] to p>ticul> p>ts ( ! transaction1 he said ,mr4 ,*ur* ass]t$ t x 0 false4 ,i nev] saw ! lett] s5t to ,mrs4 ,hunt] ab\t ! ?ree po9ts ( d5ial40 ,! next witness call$ is ,james ,reeves2 & he says1 8,i 0 ! ,cl]k att5d+ ! ,magi/rate :5 ?is *>ge 0 made at ,union ,hall4 ,! ,magi/rate 0 ,mr4 ,s]jeant ,sellon4 ,! exam9ation took place on ! #ai? ,novemb]4 ,?is be+ a *>ge ( misdemean\r1 no acc\nt 0 committ$ to writ+ ( :at ! witnesses said4 ,x 0 m]ely an entry ( ! names ( ! p>ties & ! result4 ,9 ! fir/ in/ance1 ! depositions 7 tak5 d[n ^u :i* ! w>rant 0 grant$1 b ,i _h no in/ructions to br+ ! book 9 :i* t exam9ation appe>s4 ,!re 0 an exam9ation aft]w>ds1 :5 ! def5dant 0 ord]$ to f9d bail1 b ! evid5ce 0 n !n tak5 d[n40 ,mr4 ,wood is ! la/ witness1 & he says1 8,i 0 pres5t at ! exam9ation ( ,*ur* be=e ! magi/rate1 ,i am a hatt] ne> ! ,elephant & ,ca/le4 ,i did n take d[n ! te/imony ( ! witness 9 writ+4 ,freemantle's boy said t he w5t into ! ,pott]y & told ! ,pott] t !re 7 ?ieves 9 ! h\se2 & ! ,pott] & he came to se>* ! h\se4 ,he 0 ask$ by ,mr4 ,sellon :e!r or no he se>*$ ! room :]e ,mr4 ,*ur* slept1 & he said no1 he did n se>* t room4 ,mr4 ,sellon said 8:y n se>* ! room80 & ! answ] he gave 0 8t ! ,pott] wi%$ to break ! door op540 ,mr4 ,sellon said 8did y try ! door to see :e!r x 0 op5 be=e y talk$ ( break+ x op580 he said 8no1 he did n wi% to di/urb 8 ,mi/ress40 ,i _c *>ge my memory :e!r1 :il/ ! ,pott] 0 exam9$1 he said any ?+ ab\t :at ! al>m 01 t ! boy ,=eman gave him40 ,n[1 g5tlem51 ?is is ! :ole ( ! evid5ce on bo? sides1 if y don't f9d any mat]ial inroad 9 ! exam9ation ( ei!r ! boy or ,mr4 ,patrick1 y w h to say :e!r ! ,def5dant be or be n guilty1 ^u _! evid5ce y w h to say :e!r y believe ! boy's /atem5t1 :i* is 9 sub/ance ?is1--t :5 he 0 asleep he 0 awak5$ by ! indec5t application to 8 p]son & 8 private p>ts1 ( "s p]son's h&1 :o said1 9 a feign$ female voice1 8,adam don't y "k me1 ,i am y\r ,mi/ress40 ,! boy swe>s mo/ positively t ! voice 0 t ( ! def5dant1 & he also swe>s to 8 p]son1--tak+ ?is along ) y1 t !re 0 no o!r male 9 ! h\se4 ,! po9t = y\r consid]ation is1 suppos+ ?is attack to be made ^u 8 p]son1 0 x made ) ! abom9able int5tion *>g$ 9 ?is ,indictm5t8 ,if y are ( op9ion t ! p]son :o made ?is attempt made x ) an int5tion to commit ! crime all$g$1 !n ! next "q = y\r consid]ation is1--0 x made by ! def5dant ,mr4 ,*ur*8 ,! prosecutor says1 t he _h an opportunity ( obs]v+ ! p]son :o ent]$ ! room3 he 0 a man ( ! def5dant's size2 x 0 n ! p]son ( ,mrs4 ,patrick nor ( ! maid1 & !re 0 no o!r man 9 ! h\se4 ,! o!r mat]ial evid5ce is1 t ( ,mr4 ,patrick1 :o /ates ! communication :i* he _h ) ! def5dant--he says1 ! def5dant contradict$ ?ree p>ticul>s ( ! boy's /atem5t3 b1 ! contradiction does n g to ! fact ( 8 hav+ be5 9 ! room4 ,he admits t he 0 9 ! room4 ,!n if he 0 9 ! room = :at purpose 0 he !re8 ,:at excuse is !re to be f\nd = 8 be+ 9 ! room8 ,if he 0 9 t room1 = :at o!r object c\ld he be !re ?an t :i* ?is boy /ates8--,c y suppose t ! boy's /ory is ! m]e inv5tion ( 8 own bra91 or ! creature ( 8 own imag9ation8 ,if y f9d ! fact admitt$ on all h&s1 t ! def5dant 0 !re1 = :at e>?ly purpose c\ld he be !re1 ?an t imput$ to him8 ,g5tlem51 ! :ole is = y\r consid]ation4 ,i h no d\bt y h paid great att5tion to ! pro(s bo? on ! "p ( ! prosecution & t ( ! def5ce4 ,y w lay y\r heads toge!r1 & ,i am p]suad$1 y w pron\nce t v]dict1 :i* y\r consci5ce dictates1 & ! evid5ce requires4 ,! ,jury imm$iately f\nd ! ,def5dant ,,guilty4 99 99 99 99 99 ,j publi%$1 price ,f\rp5ce 7ent]$ at ,/ation]s' ,hall71 ,,hay ,,& ,,turn]',s ,,g5u9e ,,edition ,,( ,,! ,,infam\s ,,life ,,( ,,john ,,*ur*1 ! ,/4 ,george's ,fields ,prea*]1 f 8 ,infancy up to 8 ,trial & ,conviction4 ,) ,,8 ,,confession1 s5t 9 a lett] to ! ,rev4 ,mr4 ,l--1 two days aft] 8 ,attack on ,adam ,=eman1 at ,vauxhall2 ) ,rem>ks on x1 by ! same ,g5tleman4 ,to :i* are add$1 ,,8 ,,love ,,epi/les ,,to ,e-- ,b--2 ) v>i\s o!r ,lett]s1 p>ticul>ly "o to ,cook1 ( ,v]e-/reet ,notoriety6 ,pr9t$ & publi%$ by ,hay & ,turn]1 ,no4 #aa1 ,newca/le-/reet1 ,/r&2 & may be _h ( all ,booksell]s4--,none are ,g5u9e b ^? publi%$ by ,hay & ,turn]1 !y hav+ ! ,orig9al ,lett]s 9 _! possession4 99 99 99 99 99 ,hay & ,turn]1 ,pr9t]s1 ,newca/le-,/reet ,/r&4