,transcrib$ f ! #ahhc8 ,elliot ,/ock    
edition by ,david ,price1 email         
ccx#jgdpglaf4org                        
,,! ,,new ,,dep>ture2                   
,,or1                        ,?\ghts =  
,loyal ,*ur*m54                         
99 99 99 99 99                          
,,by ,,!                                
,,rev4 ,e4 ,,ho>e1              ,,vic>  
,,( ,,tr9ity1 ,,tunbridge ,,wells1 ,,&  
,,honor>y ,,canon                       
,,( ,,cant]bury4                        
99 99 99 99 99                          
7,repr9t$ f 8,! ,*ur*man407             
99 99 99 99 99                          
,,london3                      ,,elliot 
,,/ock1 #fb1 ,,pat]no/] ,,r[4           
,price ,"o ,p5ny4                       
99 99 99 99 99          ,,! ,,new       
,,dep>ture2  ,,or1  ,,?\ghts ,,= ,,loyal
 ,,*ur*m54      ,,x is "o ( !           
difficulties ( p]fect fairness 9        
controv]sy t we  are (t5 unable to      
asc]ta9 ) accuracy ! real op9ions ( any 
consid]able bodies ( m54  ,?is is       

especially ! case :5 p are  n unit$ z a 
corporate body1 & !re=e !re is no       
dogmatic or  au?oritative /atem5t ( _!  
op9ions4  ,if1 = example1 we are  br\ght
 into discussion ) ^? :o t]m !mselves   
8,! ,bre?r510 we  may be p]fectly       
satisfi$ t we are giv+ a fair & fai?ful 
repres5tation ( :at we believe to be _! 
tea*+2 b /ill we  _c prove our /atem5ts 
by au?ority2 = !re are no au?oritative  
docum5ts1 & :at "o 8bro!r0 admits1 ano!r
 may d5y4  ,x 01  d\btless1 ?is         
difficulty t l$ to ! peculi> language ( 
! #ca/  ,article4  ,! ,c\ncil ( ,tr5t   
did n def9e ! doctr9e (  propitiatory   
sacrifice 9 ! mass until ! ye> ,a4,d4   
#aefb1 &  consequ5tly 9 ,a4,d4 #aeeb1 :5
 ! ,article 0 drawn up1 ! fram]s (  x   
c\ld n ref] to any au?oritative docum5t1
 b c\ld only condemn  :at !y knew to be 
! curr5t tea*+ ( ! ,*ur* ( ,rome4  ,!y  
!re=e us$ ! expression1 89 :i* x 0      
commonly said40    ,!re has be5 j ! same
 difficulty ) ref]5ce to t rem>kable    
movem5t :i* orig9at$ at ,ox=d ab\t fifty

 ye>s ago1 beg9n+ )  ,tract>ianism1 & n[
 develop$ into ,ritualism4  ,x has all  
along  pr(ess$ to be an ef=t = ! revival
 ( ,*ur* ,pr9ciples1 & z  su* has be5   
he>tily support$ by a consid]able numb] 
( loyal &  true-he>t$ ,*ur*m54  ,by     
8,*ur* ,pr9ciples0 !y h und]/ood !  real
 pr9ciples ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&2 &1 z     
loyal ,*ur*m51 !y  h welcom$ ! movem5t1 
believ+ x to be an ef=t to recomm5d &   
develop ^? pr9ciples4  ,9 ?is !y h be5  
enc\rag$ by ! use  ( ! epi!t 8,high40   
,! ,rituali/ic p>ty call !mselves 8,high
  ,*ur*10 & s d _m ( t l>ge class (     
,*ur*m5 to :om ,i h  j ref]r$4  ,!      
result is t1 al?\gh !y h n altoge!r     
approv$ ( "s ?+s :i* !y h read or se51  
/ill1 on !  great1 broad basis ( ,high  
,*ur*ism !y h consid]$ t !y h  m aff9ity
 ) t movem5t ?an !y h ) ^? :om !y       
designate 8,l[40  ,!y s9c]ely disapprove
 ( _m ?+s said & done  by ,rituali/s1 b 
!y _c q get ov] ! fact t if ,*ur*m5  are
 to be class$ z ei!r ,high or ,l[1 !y & 
! ,rituali/s1 at all  ev5ts1 class      

!mselves toge!r z ,high4    ,b _m among/
 u h = a long "t be5 pr(\ndly conv9c$ t 
! ,*ur* pr9ciples ( ! loyal1            
consci5ti\s1 traditional ,high  ,*ur*man
 are totally diff]5t f ! ,*ur* pr9ciples
 ( !  ,rituali/2 & t ! epi!t 8,high0    
means 9 ! language ( ! two  classes two 
totally diff]5t ?+s4  ,9 ! "o x means a 
fai?ful  adhesion to ! ,pray] ,book &   
its pr9ciples2 b 9 ! o!r a              
dissatisfaction ) ! ,pray] ,book1 & a   
crav+ aft] some?+  beyond3 9 ! "o a ris+
 to x1 & 9 ! o!r a dep>ture f x4  ,to _m
 among/ u ?is has be5 p]fectly pla9 =   
ye>s4  ,b /ill x  has be5 impossible to 
prove x1 = !re h be5 no au?oritative    
docum5ts2 &1 ev5 if !re _h be5 any !y   
w\ld n h be5  likely to conta9 any su*  
av[al4  ,x has be5 se5 p]fectly cle>ly 9
  s]mons1 9 pamphlets1 9 books1 & 9 !   
c]emonial imitation ( ,rome4  ,b /ill1  
individual words & actions c\ld only be 
reg>d$ z pro(s  ( individual op9ions1 & 
!re=e1 al?\gh !y left no d\bt on !  m9ds
 ( obs]v]s1 !y c\ld n be accept$ z      

absolute pro(s (  disloyalty aga9/ any (
 ^? :o 7 n !mselves guilty (  disloyal  
acts4    ,b a great *ange has n[ tak5   
place1 & we are br\ght into  altoge!r a 
new position4  ,aft] ! ,*ur* ,congress  
at ,d]by !re c  no long] be any d\bt on 
! subject1 = we _h !re :at 0 z  ne>ly an
 au?oritative /atem5t z "u !            
circum/ances x is  possible to expect4  
,x is ne$less to speak ( t well-kn[n    
body1 !  ,engli% ,*ur* ,union4  ,!      
,e4,c4,u4 0 =m$ z a c5tre = !           
,rituali/ic movem5t1 & x has ev] s9ce   
ma9ta9$ its position z  ! mo/ widely    
ext5d$ & influ5tial organization 9      
exi/5ce =  ! ma9t5ance ( ,rituali/ic    
pr9ciples4    ,i believe1 also1 t x has 
be5 consid]$ ! mo/ mod]ate ( !  v>i\s   
k9dr$ associations1 s t x embraces      
sev]al :o1 z !y  express !mselves1 are n
 prep>$ to g to extremes4  ,n[1 at !    
,d]by ,*ur* ,congress we _h ! advantage 
( he>+ a mo/ important  av[al f !       
,presid5t ( ?is influ5tial organization4
  ,( c\rse1  we :o d n belong to !      

,union h no means ( kn[+ h[ f> he  spoke
 z ! m\?piece ( ! ,c\ncil1 or simply    
gave expression to 8  own p]sonal       
op9ion2 b all mu/ admit t :5 ! ,presid5t
 ( !  ,union1 on su* a great occasion1  
deliv]$ a c>efully prep>$ writt5  pap]  
at ! reque/ ( ! ,bi%op ( ! ,diocese1 we 
may reg>d t  pap] z approa*+ z ne>ly z  
possible to an au?oritative  decl>ation 
( ! pr9ciples & purposes ( ! ,union4    
,:at1 !n1 did ! ,presid5t ( ! ,engli%   
,*ur* ,union say8  ,:at l9e  did he     
pursue8  ,! subject ( discussion 0      
8,proposals = ,liturgical  ,improvem5t10
 & ,canon ,v5ables accord+ly made sev]al
 important  practical sugge/ions :i* he 
?\ght might t5d )\t ! slighte/          
alt]ation ( pr9ciple to increase !      
int]e/ ( our ,liturgical  wor%ip4  ,b ! 
,presid5t ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* ,union did  
no?+ (  ! k9d4  ,he made "o proposal1 & 
"o only1 namely1 t ^? :o  wi%$ to d s   
%\ld be at lib]ty to ab&on our pres5t   
,pray] ,book  altoge!r1 & adopt 9 its   
place ! ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4  ,8  

words 73 8,9 discuss+ ! "q ( ,liturgical
 ,improvem5t1 !  proposal ,i h to make  
aims n s mu* at any *ange 9 our exi/+   
,pray] ,book1 z at ! alt]native use     
along ) x ( ! ,fir/ ,pray]  ,book (     
,edw>d ,,vi40  ,nor 0 ?is all1 = almo/  
imm$iately aft]w>ds  he aw[$ 8 pref]5ce 
= ! unre=m$ liturgies1 & ! ,use (       
,s>um1 above our ,engli% ,pray] ,book4  
,he said1 8,^? :o are at all  acqua9t$ )
 ! unre=m$ ,s]vice books ( ! ,engli%    
,*ur* mu/  (t5 h wond]$ h[ x came to    
pass t f a revision ( orig9als  s ri* & 
v>i$ z ! ,s>um ,brevi>y1 & ! great      
,engli% rite (  ,s4 ,osmund1 !re %\ld h 
result$ any?+ s meagre 9 comp>ison  ) !m
 z our exi/+ daily ,(fices & ,liturgy40 
,!re is no  mi/ak+ ^! pla9 & outspok5   
words4  ,!re is ! di/9ct av[al  ( a     
pref]5ce = ! unre=m$ ,s]vice books1 :ile
 our own ,pray]  ,book is describ$ z be+
 s meagre 9 companion ) !m t x is a     
wond] h[ x c\ld h be5 d]iv$ f su* ri* & 
v>i$ s\rces4  ,nor is ?is an isolat$    
s5t5ce4  ,9 ano!r passage1 he says1 8,9 

?is  respect x is impossible to d5y t   
our exi/+ ,communion ,(fice is  op5 to  
grave exception40  ,! "o object ( ! :ole
 pap]1 inde$1 is  to give su* evid5ce ( 
! inf]iority ( our exi/+ ,liturgy z may 
induce ! ,bi%ops to give p]mission 7:i*1
 ( c\rse1 !y h no  p[] to d7 = !        
sub/itution "u c]ta9 circum/ances (     
ano!r  book4    ,x is ( no use1 !re=e1  
any long] to ma9ta9 ! delusion t !      
movem5ts ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* ,union are   
prompt$ by any love = !  ,engli% ,pray] 
,book4  ,t book is condemn$ z 8meagre10 
& 8op5 to  grave exceptions40  ,!       
pref]5ce is giv5 to ! unre=m$ s]vices1  
& especially to ! ,use ( ,s>um2 & x mu/ 
be pla9ly und]/ood  t if any?+ is       
sugge/$ z a via m$ia or a modus viv5di1 
!  two p>ties betwe5 :om x mu/ be a via 
m$ia are on ! "o h&  ^? :o av[ _!       
pref]5ce = ! ,use ( ,s>um1 & on ! o!r   
^? :o ) _! :ole he>t delight 9 ! re=m$  
wor%ip ( our  de> old ,*ur* ( ,engl&4   
,b ,i h he>d x said t ! ,use ( ,s>um 0  
itself a re=m$  s]vice1 & free f _m ( ! 

abuses ( ,rome4  ,?us ,mr4 ,wood calls  
x 8,! great ,engli% rite ( ,s4 ,osmund40
  ,b surely he 0 mi/ak5 9  t expression1
 =1 ?\gh us$ 9 ,engl&1 x 0 n an ,engli% 
rite4  ,osmund 0 a ,norman ,c\nt1 & hav+
 f\ght 9 ! army ( ,william !  ,conqu]or1
 01 z a rew>d = 8 s]vices1 fir/ creat$  
,e>l (  ,dorset1 & !n appo9t$ ,bi%op (  
,salisbury4  ,at ! "t ( 8  appo9tm5t !re
 0 great religi\s diss5sion 9 ! c\ntry  
occasion$ by ! introduction ( !         
,gallican liturgy by ,william !         
,conqu]or1 :i* 0 resi/$ by ! ,engli%2 & 
,osmund compil$ ! ,use  ( ,s>um 9 ord]1 
if possible1 to h>monize all p>ties4  ,8
 *ief  "w1 !re=e1 0 to introduce1 z f> z
 possible1 ! ,gallican  elem5t2 & 9 no  
s5se :atev] c t use be call$ 8,! great  
,engli% rite ( ,s4 ,osmund40    ,b its  
orig9 is ( little importance z comp>$ ) 
its cont5ts4  ,! great "q is1 8,:at is !
 real "* ( ! book :i* is  ?us pref]r$ to
 our #8meagre' ,engli% ,pray] ,book80   
,& x w\ld be an  important contribution 
to ! pres5t controv]sy if any ( ^? :o   

exalt its excell5ce w\ld in=m u ( any "o
 p>ticul> 9 :i* x  diff]s 9 pr9ciple f !
 ,romi% ,missal & ,brevi>y4  ,!re is n  
space 9 su* a pap] z ?is = !            
inve/igation ( its id5tity 9  all       
important po9ts ) ! liturgies ( ,rome2 b
 x w\ld be  extremely int]e/+ to "k 9   
:at t ri*ness consi/s ( :i* we  he>d s  
high an encomium at ! ,d]by ,*ur*       
,congress4    ,?ree ?+s may be briefly  
m5tion$3    7#a47  ,! ,use ( ,s>um 0    
c]ta9ly ri* 9 ,leg5ds1 & t to !         
exclusion ( ,scripture4  ,on su* a      
subject we surely _c h a bett]  au?ority
 ?an ! preface to t ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d
 ,,vi41 :i* is n[  s /rongly recomm5d$4 
,9 t ,preface x is said3        8,^! _m 
ye>s pa/ ?is godly & dec5t ord] ( !     
anci5t      fa!rs ha? be5 s alt]$1      
brok51 & neglect$ by plant+ 9           
unc]ta9 /ories1 leg5ds1 responds1 v]ses1
 va9 repetitions1      commemorations1 &
 synodals1 t commonly1 :5 any book ( !  
,bible 0 begun1 be=e ?ree or f\r *apt]s 
are read out1 all !      re/ 7 unread40 

,& ( ^! ,leg5ds1 etc41 ! same preface   
adds1 8,"s be untrue1 "s  unc]ta91 "s   
va9 & sup]/iti\s40  ,if x is ! omission 
( su*  ,leg5ds z ^! t makes our ,pray]  
,book 8meagre10 all ,i c say is1  ,let u
 ?ank ,god = its meagr5ess4    7#b47    
,!n1 aga91 ! ,use ( ,s>um 0 ri* 9       
complicat$ & s5seless  c]emonial4  ,!   
,preface already quot$ says ( ^!        
c]emonies3        8,"s at ! fir/ 7 (    
godly int5t & purpose devis$1 & yet1    
at l5g?1 turn$ to vanity & sup]/ition2  
"s 4 4 4 because !y      7 w9k$ at 9 !  
beg9n+1 !y grew daily to m & m          
abuses1 :i*1 n only = _! unpr(itabl5ess1
 b also because      !y h mu* bl9d$ ! p 
& obscur$ ! glory ( ,god1 are      wor?y
 to be cut away & clean reject$40    ,x 
may be well1 p]haps1 to give "o         
illu/ration f ! ,s>um ,missal3  8,"h let
 ! prie/ uncov] ! cup1 & make ! sign ( !
 cross )  ! ho/ five times--fir/ beyond 
! cup on e side1 secondly ev5  ) ! cup1 
?irdly )9 ! cup1 f\r?ly z ! fir/1 fif?ly
  be=e ! cup40  ,?is is giv5 simply z a 

specim51 & "s may say  t !re is no h>m 9
 x4  ,b ,i c sc>cely believe x possible 
t  anyone w hesitate to apply to x !    
language ( ! ,preface1 8,?is  excessive 
multitude ( c]emonies 0 s great1 & _m ( 
!m s d>k1  t1 !y did m conf\nd & d>k5   
?an decl>e & set =?  ,*ri/'s b5efits    
unto u40    7#c47  ,! ,use ( ,s>um 0 ri*
 9 sa9t wor%ip4  ,= example1 9 !        
,missal ! prie/ did n confess to ,god   
alone 7,i suppose t w\ld h  be5 meagre71
 b 0 direct$ to say1 8,i confess to     
,god1 to bless$  ,m>y1 to all ! sa9ts1 &
 to y2 because ,i h s9n$ too mu* by     
?\ght1 ^w1 & de$ by my fault3 ,i pray   
holy ,m>y1 all ! sa9ts (  ,god1 & y to  
pray = me40  ,aga91 9 ! ,litany1 ! ,use 
( ,s>um 0  f> 9 excess ( ! mod]n ,*ur* (
 ,rome4  ,9 ! mod]n ,romi% ,litany  ,i  
c\nt only =ty-sev5 p]sons to :om pray]  
is address$1 includ+  ! ,virg91 two     
ar*-angels1 & ! twelve apo/les2 b 9 !   
,use (  ,s>um accord+ to ,bi%op ,%ort1  
#h !re 7 no less ?an #aaf p]sons        
address$4  ,possibly "s ,gallican sa9ts 

may h be5 add$ by ,s4  ,osmund4  ,on t  
po9t ,i am n prep>$ to speak2 b ( ?is ,i
 am  c]ta91 t 9 reg>d to ! wor%ip (     
sa9ts1 all true ,engli%  ,*ur*m5 w      
rejoice 9 ! meagr5ess ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&
 ,pray]  ,book1 & h no desire = !       
ri*ness ( ! ,use ( ,s>um4    ,n[ ?is is 
! book :i*1 be=e ! assembl$ ,*ur*       
,congress at  ,d]by1 0 av[$ly pref]r$ to
 our ,engli% ,pray] ,book4  ,:51  !re=e1
 x is said t !re is a cle> pref]5ce = ! 
wor%ip (  ,rome1 no "o c any long] reg>d
 x z a calumni\s or unf\nd$  accusation4
  ,we h ! op51 pla91 & undisguis$ av[al 
( !  ,presid5t ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* ,union1
 t ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book is  8meagre10 
& ! ,use ( ,s>um ri*2 ! ,engli%         
,communion ,(fice op5 to  grave         
objections1 & ! unre=m$ liturgies s     
sup]ior1 t x is a  wond] h[ any?+ s     
inf]ior z ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book c\ld h 
be5 compil$ f su* ri* mat]ials4  ,let no
 "o1 !re=e1 f ?is  day =w>d1 suppose t x
 is ! object ( ! ,union to uphold !     
,re=m$ ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 or to ma9ta9 its 

wor%ip2 b let x be  cle>ly & di/9ctly   
und]/ood1 t ! pref]5ce has be5 publicly 
giv5 to ! ,use ( ,s>um & ! unre=m$      
liturgies4    ,b ! av[al ( a pref]5ce1 x
 may be said1 is n a proposal2 & if  we 
_h no?+ m ?an su* an av[al1 x might be  
suppos$ t !re  0 no int5tion ( any      
practical action4  ,su* a supposition1  
h[ev]1  is r5d]$ impossible by !        
proposal :i* foll[$1 viz41 t !re  %\ld  
be ! alt]native use ( ! ,fir/ ,pray]    
,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4    ,n[ let anyone  
look = a mom5t at ! l9e ( argum5t1 & !  
mean+  ( ?is proposal is self-evid5t4   
,! argum5t is1 t because ! unre=m$      
liturgies & ! ,use (  ,s>um are sup]ior 
to our ,engli% ,pray] ,book1 !re=e we   
are to give  ! lib]ty to make use ( !   
,fir/ ,book in/ead ( our own4  ,is x n  
obvi\s t ! :ole =ce ( ! argum5t dep5ds  
on ! fact t !  ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d     
approximates to ^! unre=m$ liturgies m  
ne>ly ?an does our pres5t book8  ,x is  
pref]r$ because x is m 9  accordance ) t
 :i* is consid]$ ! be/1 viz41 ! ,use (  

,s>um4  ,?is proposal1 :5 reg>d$ 9      
connection ) ! av[$  pref]5ce1 c>ries ) 
x its own condemnation1 & ought at once 
to  put all true ,*ur*m5 on _! gu>d4    
,we are br\ght to exactly ! same        
conclusion by ! hi/orical position  ( ! 
book4  ,! ,re=mation 0 n a sudd5 act1 & 
our ,engli%  ,pray] ,book 0 n born 9 a  
day4  ,! "w began ) ! ,k+'s ,prim]  9   
,a4,d4 #aede1 :i* 0 foll[$ 9 ,a4,d4     
#aedh by ! fir/ ,communion  ,s]vice--!  
*ief object ( :i* 0 ! re/oration ( ! cup
 to !  laity2 b ! fir/ re=m$ ,liturgy = 
morn+ & ev5+ wor%ip 0  ! ,fir/ ,book (  
,edw>d ,,vi41 9 ,a4,d4 #aedi4  ,n[ let  
no "o und]value1  = "o mom5t1 !         
greatness1 or importance1 ( ! "w :i* 0  
accompli%$ 9 ! publication ( ?is book4  
,! compil]s cle>$ away  su* a va/ am\nt 
( ,romi% sup]/ition & error t x is      
impossible  n to admire ! c\rage &      
wisdom ) :i* !y act$4  ,!y 7  p]fectly  
ju/ifi$1 !re=e1 9 describ+ x z a godly  
book1 & 9  ascrib+ _! success to !      
graci\s help ( ! ,holy ,_s ,himself2    

nev]!less1 :5 ! book 0 publi%$ x 0 f\nd 
t !re 7  "s p>ts 9 x :i* /ill requir$   
alt]ation1 & a revision became          
necess>y4  ,!re 7 c]ta9 ?+s /ill left   
:i* requir$ removal1  s t :5 any fur!r  
*ange 0 object$ to by ! ,papi/s x 0     
answ]$3 8,t x 0 no wond] t ! corruptions
 :i* !y _h be5  introduc+ = above a ?\s&
 ye>s 7 n all discov]$ & ?r[n  out at   
once0 7,bi%op ,burnet74  ,besides :i*1  
!re 7 c]ta9  expressions :i* x 0 j      
possible to und]/& 9 ! ,romi% s5se4  #aj
  ,x 0 cle>ly ( ! utmo/ importance to   
avoid ! possibility (  any su* d\bt or  
misappreh5sion2 & z ! ,re=m]s _h no     
desire  t _! trumpet %\ld give an       
unc]ta9 s\nd1 ! book 0 c>efully  revis$4
  ,9 ! ,act ( ,p>liam5t :i* sanction$ ! 
revision !  reason 0 giv5 z foll[s3--   
8,t !re _h be5 div]s d\bts rak$ ab\t !  
mann] ( !      m9i/ration ( ! ,s]vice1 r
 by ! curiosity ( ! m9i/]s      &       
mi/ak]s ?an ( any o!r wor?y cause2 & t =
 ! bett]      explanation ( t1 & = !    
great] p]fection ( ! ,s]vice is      "s 

places :]e x 0 fit to make ! ,pray] &   
fa%ion (      ,s]vice m e>ne/1 & fit to 
/ir ,*ri/ian p to ! true      hon\r+ (  
,almighty ,god1 !re=e x _h be5 by !     
comm& (      ! ,k+ & ,p>liam5t p]us$1   
expla9$1 & made m p]fect40    ,! ,second
 ,pray] ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 0 ! result 
( t revision2  &1 al?\gh x 0 subsequ5tly
 bo? slightly alt]$ & add$ to 9  #aefj &
 #afjd till x rea*$ its pres5t =m 9     
#affb1 we mu/ reg>d  t ,second ,book z !
 completion ( ! great "w ( ! ,re=mation 
s ably1 b /ill imp]fectly1 comm5c$ 9 !  
,fir/4  ,! hi/ory1  !re=e1 places !     
,fir/ ,book 9 exactly ! same position z 
t 9  :i* x 0 plac$ 9 ! argum5t ( ,mr4   
,wood1 viz41 an int]m$iate  position    
betwe5 ! ,use ( ,s>um & ! pres5t ,engli%
 ,pray] ,book4  ,x 0 a great & noble    
ef=t b yet n complete4  ,x 0 a great    
movem5t 9 ! "r direction1 b !re 7 /ill 9
 x c]ta9 mo/  s]i\s defects2 & :at 0 m  
important1 x conta9$ c]ta9  passages :i*
 ^? :o 7 to dispos$ might mis9t]pret 9 !
  ,romi% s5se4    ,yet ?is is ! book to 

:i* we are n[ invit$ to return2 & x is  
only reasonable t we %\ld ask ! reason  
:y4  ,we are cont5t )  our belov$ old   
,engli% ,pray] ,book1 9 :i*1 ev] s9ce we
 began to  wor%ip at all1 we h p\r$ out 
our he>ts 9 holy communion ) ,god4  ,:y 
%\ld we ei!r =sake x1 or ?r[ ! :ole     
,*ur* into confusion  by ! admission (  
an alt]native s]vice8    ,c]ta9ly n     
because ! ,fir/ ,book is less 8meagre0  
?an ! second2  =1 beyond all controv]sy1
 x 0 ! m meagre ( ! two4  ,morn+  & ev5+
 pray] began 9 x ) ! ,"l's ,pray]1 &    
!re=e  conta9$ nei!r texts1 address1    
confession1 nor absolution4  ,!y also   
end$ ) ! ?ird ,collect1 & !re=e conta9$ 
none ( ! pray]s  = ! ,que51 ,royal      
,family1 c4  ,! 8,pray]s & ,?anksgiv+s  
on  sev]al occasions0 7 n includ$1 s t !
 famili> words ( !  8,pray] = all       
,conditions ( ,m510 z well z ! 8,g5]al  
,?anksgiv+10 7 n 9 x4  ,! ,comm&m5ts 7 n
 !re2 & !  ,cate*ism conta9$ no?+ ab\t !
 ,sacram5ts4  ,& :at has become (  "s   
importance s9ce ! subject has be5 moot$1

 !re 0 no  ,ord9ation ,s]vice4  ,x is   
well to be> ?is 9 m9d1 because x is !   
fa%ion ) "s p]sons to quote ! #cf?      
,article z giv+ a sanction  to ! ,fir/  
,book4  ,& ,mr4 ,wood said1 9 8 address 
at ,d]by1 t 8at  ?is v mom5t x #aa has !
 direct sanction & approval ( ! #cf?    
,article40  ,b he mu/ h ei!r =gott5 or  
ignor$ ! fact t !  ord9al to :i* ! #cf? 
,article ref]s 0 publi%$ q  indep5d5tly 
( ! book1 & 0 nev] made a "p ( x4  ,9   
#aeeb !  ord9al1 ) c]ta9 *anges1 0      
introduc$ into ! ,second ,book2 b  x 0  
nev] made a "p ( ! ,fir/4  ,! ,article1 
!re=e1 has no  ref]5ce ( any k9d :atev] 
to ! ,fir/ ,book1 & 9 t book !re  0 no  
,ord9ation ,s]vice4    ,x mu/ be cle>1  
!re=e1 to ! mo/ sup]ficial obs]v]1 t !  
attraction ( ! ,fir/ ,book does n consi/
 9 its ri*ness4  ,if our  own ,pray]    
,book is 8meagre10 ! ,fir/ ,book is mu* 
m s4  ,! *anges  subsequ5tly made h be5 
*iefly 9 ! direction ( addition1 &  !re 
mu/ be "s o!r reason :i* r5d]s x s      
attractive4  ,& :at  is t reason8  ,!re 

is an expression 9  #gdc ( ,bi%op       
,%ort's  8,hi/ory ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&10  
:i* answ]s ! "q4  ,!  ,bi%op !re says3  
8,on ! :ole1 ?is book =ms a connect+ l9k
  betwe5 ! ,missal & ! ,pray] ,book40   
,n[1 if ?is be ! case1 x is  no wond] if
 ^? :o pref] ! ,missal desire !         
sub/itution ( ?is  book = our pres5t    
,pray] ,book4  ,! "t may n be come = !  
introduction ( ! ,missal itself2 b t may
 foll[ 9 "t1 if !y  c n[ secure !       
connect+ l9k4  ,if ?is be ! case1 !     
reasons  :i* lead m5 n[ to desire x are 
precisely ^? :i* l$ !  ,re=m]s to re=m  
x4  ,x is ne>] ,rome ?an our ,engli%    
,pray] ,book4  ,!re=e x 0 t ! ,re=m]s   
re=m$ x1 & !re=e x is t  !y :o pref] 8! 
unre=m$ liturgies0 desire to return to  
x4  ,?is  may be se5 v cle>ly 9 ,mr4    
,wood's address4  ,he enum]ates sev]al (
  ! advantages t he consid]s w\ld be    
ga9$ by a return to x1 su*  is a clos]  
con=mity to ! ord] ( 8! canon0 ( !      
,mass2 !  omission ( ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts1 &
 ! 8,de>ly ,belov$20 8!  res]vation = ! 

sick20 8! unction ( ! sick20 & pray] = !
  dead4    ,to ^! he might h add$ !     
re/oration ( an alt> 9 place ( 8!       
table0 ) its 8fair :ite l95 clo?20 & ( !
 "n 8,! ,mass0 9  addition to ! 8,holy  
,communion20 ! sanction = auricul>      
confession  9 ! ,communion ,s]vice1     
comb9$ ) ! omission ( ! ,g5]al          
,confession 9 ! ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]2 !
 omission f ! words  ( adm9i/ration ( ! 
clause1 8,take & eat ?is 9 remembrance t
  ,*ri/ di$ = !e1 & fe$ on ,him 9 ?9e   
he>t by fai? )  ?anksgiv+0 & ! pres5ce (
 c]ta9 o!r expressions :i* x 0  j       
possible = 8mi/ak]s0 to und]/& z tea*+ !
 localization  9 ! consecrat$ elem5ts ( 
! actual human p]son ( our bless$       
,r$eem] n[ seat$ at ! "r h& ( ,god4     
,b !re is "o o!r result ( a return to ! 
,fir/ ,book :i* is (  supreme           
importance1 ?\gh ,i h n yet se5 any     
notice ( x 9 !  rec5t discussion1 viz41 
t by return+ to ! ,fir/ ,book we %\ld   
get beh9d ! date ( ! ,articles4  ,!     
,articles 7 n drawn up till  ! ye>      

,a4,d4 #aeeb1 s t by adopt+ ! ,fir/     
,book we %\ld g back  to a date at :i* !
 ,articles did n exi/1 at :i*1 9 fact1 !
  ,*ur* ( ,engl& _h drawn up no =mal    
dogmatic prote/ aga9/ !  errors ( ,rome4
  ,! ,re=mation began ) ! re=m ( !      
,liturgy1  be=e !re 0 any au?oritative  
/atem5t ( di/9ctive tru?1 &  :5 ! m9ds (
 m5 7 pass+ ?r\gh a rapid transition4   
,to ?is  transition p]iod ! ,fir/ ,book 
belongs2 & if we 7 to decide on  adopt+ 
! ,liturgy ( ! transition !re w\ld be a 
manife/  inconsi/5cy 9 comb9+ ) x ^?    
def9ite /atem5ts ( tru?  :i* 7 c>efully 
drawn up aft]w>ds :5 ! great gulf 0 pa/1
  & ! "w ( ! ,re=mation 9 ess5tial po9ts
 complete4    ,) all ^! facts be=e u1 x 
is impossible to mi/ake ! "*  ( !       
proposal made4  ,:e!r we look at !      
hi/ory or ! cont5ts (  ! book1 we are   
br\ght to ! same conclusion4  ,x is n a 
proposal to  improve our ,pray] ,book or
 to adapt x to ! special dem&s ( ! day4 
,x is a proposal to dep>t f ! ,pray]    
,book altoge!r1 & to return  to !       

transition /ate ?r\gh :i* ! ,*ur* (     
,engl& pass$ 9 !  transition days ( !   
,re=mation4  ,! ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d    
bore j  ! same relation%ip to ! ,use (  
,s>um t ,bas+/oke does to !  city (     
,salisbury4  ,! ,re=m]s halt$ a:ile !re 
on ! up l9e1 b  !y c\ld n re/1 s !y soon
 left x to complete _! j\rney4  ,we  are
 n[ invit$ to return !re2 b is !re any  
?9k+ man :o c  suppose = "o mom5t t we  
are int5d$ to rema9 !re1 :5 we h  !     
public av[al ( ! und5i$ pref]5ce = 8!   
unre=m$  liturgies0 & ! ,use ( ,s>um8   
,is x n p]fectly cle> t !  attraction to
 ! ,fir/ ,book is simply ?is1 t x is a  
/ation = !  express tra9 on ! direct d[n
 l9e to ,s>um8    ,& n[1 h[ w ?is       
proposal be receiv$8 or r1 h[ w x be    
receiv$ by t l>ge body ( m5 :o wi% to be
 consid]$ 8,high  ,*ur*m510 & :o mean by
 t expression t !y ent]ta9 a loyal1     
lov+1 & fai?ful allegiance to ! gr& old 
,*ur* ( ,engl&1 into  :i* !y 7 receiv$  
at _! baptism1 & ( :i* ^? :o are        
cl]gym5 h be5 its appo9t$ (fic]s ev]    

s9ce _! ord9ation8  ,w !y1 or w !y n1 be
 prep>$ = ?is new dep>ture8  ,are  !y   
prep>$ to ab&on all ! hi/orical loyalty 
( _! p>ty2 to  give up _! belov$ ,pray] 
,book z 8meagre0 & 8op5 to grave        
objections20 to ?r[ ov]bo>d _! ,articles
 & ! latt] "p (  _! ,cate*ism2 & to g   
boldly back to ! p]iod ( transition1 :5 
mu*1 we fully admit1 0 improv$1 b no?+  
def9$2 :5 great  ?+s 7 done1 b :5 mu*   
/ill rema9$ to be done2 & :5  no?+ 0    
matur$ or consolidat$ z we n[ h x 9 our 
,articles &  ,liturgy8  ,if !y are      
prep>$ = su* a movem5t1 x w c]ta9ly be  
a new phase 9 ! "* ( ! hi/orical1 loyal1
 & influ5tial  ,high ,*ur*man%ip (      
,engl&4                                 
,e4 ,,ho>e4                             
,picture3 ,decorative graphic           
,,works ,,by ,,! ,,rev4 ,,canon ,,ho>e4 
,,rome1 ,,turkey1 ,,& ,,j]usalem4  #ag? 
,?\s&4  #afmo4 clo?1 #as4 #f;d2 pap]    
cov]1 #as4    ,,pale/9e ,,& ,,russia4   
#e? ,?\s&4  #afmo4 clo?1 #as4 #f;d2 pap]
 cov]1  #as4    ,,r$emption4  ,a        

,companion ,volume to ,sanctification4  
,9 squ>e fcap4  #hvo4 #bs4 #f;d4        
,,sanctification4  ,?ird edition4  ,9   
squ>e fcap4 #hvo4 #bs4 #f;d4            
,,doctr9e ,,( ,,! ,,"l',s ,,supp]1 z    
taught by ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4  ,fcap4     
#hvo4 sew$1 #f;d4    ,,con=mity ,,to ,,!
 ,,_w4  ,new edition1 revis$4  #afmo4   
clo?1 #as4 #f;d42  pap] cov]1 #as4      
,,inspiration3 ,,its ,,nature ,,&       
,,ext5t4  ,new edition1 revis$4  #afmo4 
clo?1  #as4 #f;d42 pap] cov]1 #as4      
,,! ,,communion ,,& ,,communicant4  ,new
 *eap edition1 revis$ & enl>g$4  #ahmo4 
sew$1 #c;d42 or #bs4 #f;d4              
99 99 99 99 99          ,,by ,,! ,,late 
,,mrs4 ,e4 ,,ho>e4      ,,! ,,*ri/ian   
,,"m2 or1 ,,notes ,,= ,,mo!rs' ,,meet+s4
  #bnd edition4  #as4                   
99 99 99 99 99          ,,footnotes4    
#h  8,hi/ory ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&10  #gdd4
    #aj  ,!re 0 a passage1 = example1   
quot$ 9 ! ,gu>dian (  ,decemb] #f?1     
#ahhb1 9 :i* ,g>d9] is report$ to h     
said3 8,wille?  *ildr5 to be taught t !y

 receive ) _! bodily m\? ! body  & blood
 ( ,*ri/1 :i* ,i allege1 because x w    
appe> x is a  tea*+ set =? among u (    
late1 z ha? be5 also & is by ! ,book  ( 
,common ,pray]1 be+ ! mo/ true ,ca?olic 
doctr9e ( ! sub/ance  ( ! sacram5t 9 t  
is !re s ,ca?olicity spok5 (40  ,i d n  
say t ,g>d9] 0 "r 9 ?is /atem5t1 b ,i d 
say t if !re  0 any?+ to ju/ify 8       
ass]tion1 x 0 mo/ desirable t z soon  z 
possible x %\ld be remov$4    #aa       
,gu>dian1 ,oct4 #aa4  ,i obs]ve t !     
words 8,z reg>ds !  ,communion ,(fice0 h
 be5 add$ 9 ! au?oris$ report4