,,auguste ,,rodin ,,the ,,man--,,his ,,ideas--,,his ,,works ,,by ,,camille ,,mauclair ,,author ,,of ,,the ,,great ,,french ,,painters ,,and ,,the ,,evolution ,,of ,,french ,,painting ,,from #ahcj ,,the ,,french ,,impressionists1 ,,etc4 ,,translated ,,by ,,clementina ,,black ,,with ,,forty ,,plates ,,new ,,york ,e4 ,p4 ,,dutton ,,co4 #aije ,,to ,,eug,,ne ,,carri,,re ,,and ,,roger ,,marx ,,my ,,dear ,,friends1 ,one of you is a great painter1 whose art and mind are fraternally akin to ,rodin's4 ,the other is the first ,french ,art critic of our day1 and has nobly defended ,rodin from the outset4 ,for these reasons ,i felt it just and natural to dedicate this book to both of you1 as a testimony of my affection1 given in the presence of the ,english public1 and under the auspices of a name that unites all three of us in the love of beauty4 ,c4 ,m4 ,the photographs used as illustrations to the present volume are kindly lent by ,m4 ,buloz1 art publisher of ,paris1 to whom we offer our sincere thanks2 and for five of them--very remarkable in their effect 7the ,bellona1 the bust of ,hugo1 the two studies of torsos for the ,st4 ,john the ,baptist1 and the ,fair ,woman who was a ,helmet-maker7 we are indebted to ,messrs4 ,haweis and ,coles1 to whom we are no less grateful4 ,the very faithful portrait of ,m4 ,rodin is the work of ,m4 ,eckert1 of ,prague4 ,,preface ,auguste ,rodin is certainly the contemporary ,french artist about whom most has been written1 especially during the last ten years4 ,in addition to innumerable articles in newspapers and reviews1 several books have been devoted to him4 ,in offering the present work to the ,english public ,i think it desirable to define exactly the aim which ,i propose to myself4 ,to begin with1 as my limits of size are somewhat narrow1 ,i shall endeavour to condense into a restricted space as many interesting details as ,i can give1 and to neglect nothing that may contribute to a clear and precise presentment of ,rodin's personality and work4 ,but such details have already been collected in some ,french works2 and if ,i were to content myself with presenting a new version of them to the public ,i should have fulfilled but half of my task and my duty4 ,the other half interests me far more keenly4 ,it seems to me that after having told the reader all that he ought to know about a man1 a critic should then try to make a closer and deeper study of him--come into contact with his ideas and his soul1 form an original judgment of him1 and in short pass from the iconographie or biographic side to the artistic and psychological side of his work4 ,i have tried1 therefore1 to begin where my fellow-workers have left off and to say exactly what they do not appear to me to have said4 ,the things written about ,rodin have been mainly literary compositions1 admiring and lyrical passages1 to which his favourite subjects have served as texts4 ,much less has been heard about his personal ideas upon the technical principles of sculpture1 or about his methods of work4 ,the reason of this is primarily a fear of fatiguing the public1 to whom the technicalities of an art--which involve dry explanations--are less interesting than the results4 ,moreover1 it must be owned that few writers understand these questions4 ,in painting1 as in sculpture1 persons who do not practise these arts1 or who are not sufficiently familiar with the brush and the chisel to understand the secrets of works of art1 even if not to produce them1 generally prefer to avoid these dangerous aspects and keep to literary eulogy4 ,a work is proclaimed great1 and the reader is adjured to believe it so1 but it is infinitely more difficult to give him a clear1 technical explanation of why that work is great4 ,towards that quarter1 therefore1 ,i have chosen to turn1 expecting to find there things to say that cannot be read elsewhere4 ,rodin has not merely created beautiful statues4 ,he is an innovator1 7or rather a renovator71 in his methods of sculpture1 and that fact has called down severe criticism on his head4 ,a long-standing friendship1 which ,i reckon as an honour1 has allowed me to have numerous conversations with him upon the very basis of his art1 upon the manner in which he practises it1 and upon his ideas in relation to his own work and to ancient and modern sculpture4 ,to these ideas the synthetic mind of ,rodin imparts so much vigour that they are the motives of his work and cannot be separated from it4 ,my desire has been to present them2 and instead of giving the public my own opinions1 in passages of more or less brilliancy1 ,i wished to give those--so infinitely more interesting--which have been uttered by the artist himself4 ,often1 in the course of this book1 ,i shall be merely the transcriber while he speaks1 and ,i think my readers will be grateful to me for that4 ,furthermore1 in regard to technical points and to the way in which ,rodin conceives composition and modelling1 ,i may--and even1 in order to inspire a just and necessary confidence1 ,i should--say that when ,rodin exhibited his ,balzac his first innovation in his present manner1 he had so much faith in my friendship and in my critical powers that he entrusted to me the duty of explaining these delicate points in the ,french reviews1#a and in a later lecture given at the ,paris ,exhibition of #aijj1 in the pavilion where he was exhibiting the whole of his works4 ,these explanations1 in their main lines1 ,i have rewritten here4 ,in that portion ,i have endeavoured to do original critical work1 after having satisfied the biographical demands of the reader4 ,i have avoided discussions of too abstract an stheticism2 ,i believe that everything can be said simply and in simple forms2 ,i believe also that even in the most subtle questions of art there is an inner light that renders them accessible to all whose minds are sincere1 and whose hearts are open to emotion4 ,but ,i hope that1 in reading this book1 people will understand very exactly why a statue by ,rodin is different from any other statue1 and why he made it so--a matter which too few writers have explained4 ,it is not so much my business to display abundantly the admiration which ,i feel1 but which1 no more than my friendship1 shall induce me to turn my essay into a hymn of praise4 ,rodin himself is the first man to be wearied by some praises1 and a just observation upon his methods gives him much more pleasure4 ,like every man of high intelligence1 he would rather be understood than praised4 ,i believe myself to be filling a gap and satisfying a wish by giving at the end of this volume some remarks upon the artists whom ,rodin has influenced4 ,he is commonly treated as a force of nature2 an isolated phenomenon2 people affect to consider him as a sort of immense unconscious producer4 ,these are absurd hyperboles4 ,rodin is a man of strong will1 logical1 and conscious of what he is doing1 and strongly linked to the ,greeks and to the ,gothic school2 he has very definite theories1 and several sculptors1 of whom ,rodin's extreme admirers do not speak1 preferring to leave their divinity alone in the clouds1 draw their inspiration from his views4 ,i shall name some men to whom ,rodin is much attached and in whose work he takes pleasure in following the development of his principles1 for he knows what he wishes1 whence he comes and whither he goes1 and has a horror of being thought a visionary--a phenomenon1 as people say in their indiscreet zeal2 on the contrary1 he holds himself to be a real classical artist1 whose example cannot possibly be harmful4 ,i have thought it well1 also1 to conclude by a summary of the principal works or essays dealing with ,rodin1 at least in ,france2 and by a chronological list of his statues--that is to say1 of course1 an approximate list1 for many fragments of this great mass of work have been destroyed by ,rodin himself1 especially in the earlier part of his career1 before #ahgg4 ,no such list has ever been made1 and it may add to the interest of the present volume2 ,i give it under the artist's authorisation1 for ,i made it in his house and according to his advice4 ,it is bad to repeat oneself4 ,yet ,i am anxious to say once more--and my insistence will be understood--that my long friendship and personal admiration for ,auguste ,rodin and my gratitude for the affectionate regard that he shows me count for nothing here4 ,a study is asked of me1 not a panegyric4 ,when ,i have reckoned up the vast quantity of work1 the maker's life1 theories1 talks1 doings1 and influence1 very little room will be left for compliments4 ,it will be for the reader to think them4 ,many people who would have had a difficulty in talking of sculpture have found ,rodin a convenient subject for literary declamations--too many for me to wish to imitate them4 ,such a course would be pleasing neither to the artist nor to the public1 and would content them no more than it would content me4 ,precise details about the man1 the work1 and the iconography2 clear explanations of technicalities and ideas--these form all my ambition4 ,the statement of facts will be enough to arouse love and admiration for ,rodin2 louder than all praises and with a stronger claim speaks the work of thirty years4 ,c4 ,m4 #a ,the ,art of ,rodin1 ,revue des ,revues1 ,paris1 #aeth ,june1 #ahih2 and lecture1 #cast ,july1 #aijj4 ,,contents ,,preface ,i4 ,,youth ,,and ,,early ,,work ,,of ,,rodin--,,his ,,first ,,attempts2 ,,his ,,time ,,at ,,carrier',s--,,his ,,stay ,,in ,,brussels ,,and ,,work ,,there--,,the ,,age ,,of ,,brass ,,at ,,the ,,salon ,,of #ahgg2 ,,the ,,incident ,,arising ,,in ,,regard ,,to ,,it--,,the ,,st4 ,,john ,,the ,,baptist2 ,,beginning ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,reputation ,,ii4 ,,rodin',s ,,studio--,,his ,,works ,,from #ahhj ,,to #ahhi--;,,eve2 ,,some ,,busts2 ,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,victor ,,hugo--,,the ,,gate ,,of ,,hell--,,the ,,danaid--,,the ,,thought--,,the ,,exhibition ,,of ,,claude ,,monet ,,and ,,rodin1 ,,in #ahhi--,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,claude ,,lorraine ,,at ,,nancy 7#ahib7--,,the ,,burghers ,,of ,,calais 7#ahhh-ahie7 ,,iii4 ,,rodin',s ,,work ,,from #ahie ,,to #ahih--,,small ,,groups--,,the ,,statue ,,of ,,balzac--,,the ,,incident ,,of ,,the ,,soci,t ,,des ,,gens ,,de ,,lettres--,,the ,,technique ,,of ,,the ,,balzac--,,rodin',s ,,ideas ,,upon ,,modelling ,,and ,,composition--,,his ,,opinions ,,about ,,the ,,greeks1 ,,the ,,gothic ,,style1 ,,classicism1 ,,and ,,mythological ,,subjects--,,rodin',s ,,antique ,,period ,,iv4 ,,works ,,since ,,the ,,balzac--,,small ,,works ,,in ,,marble--,,plan ,,of ,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,labour--,,drawings ,,and ,,etchings ,v4 ,,rodin',s ,,private ,,life--,,his ,,person1 ,,studio1 ,,and ,,home--,,his ,,influence2 ,,sculptors ,,inspired ,,by ,,his ,,ideas--,,rodin',s ,,place ,,in ,,the ,,french ,,school--,,his ,,present ,,position ,,in ,,respect ,,to ,,academic ,,sculpture ,,vi4 ,,appendix--,,chronological ,,list ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,principal ,,works--,,list ,,of ,,the ,,principal ,,books ,,or ,,articles ,,written ,,about ,,him--,,quotations ,,referring ,,to ,,him--,,an ,,opinion ,,of ,,eug,,ne ,,carri,,re',s2 ,,an ,,opinion ,,of ,,henley',s--,,various ,,notes ,,index #ada ,,list ,,of ,,illustrations ,,eternal ,,spring 7photogravure7 ,frontispiece ,,the ,,age ,,of ,,brass ,,the ,,age ,,of ,,brass ,,st4 ,,john ,,the ,,baptist ,,preaching ,,eve ,,sketch ,,for ,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,the ,,defenders ,,of ,,the ,,nation ,,ugolino ,,and ,,his ,,children ,,bellona ,,bellona ,,victor ,,hugo 7dry-point7 ,,victor ,,hugo 7dry-point7 ,,bust ,,of ,,victor ,,hugo ,,monument ,,to ,,victor ,,hugo 7fragment7 ,,victor ,,hugo 7fragment7 ,,nereids 7group at base of the ,victor ,hugo monument7 ,,shades 7for the top of ,the ,gate of ,hell7 ,,the ,,thinker ,,danaid ,,danaid ,,thought ,,the ,,fair ,,helmet-,,maker ,a ,,nymph 7bronze7 ,,puvis ,,de ,,chavannes ,,jean ,,paul ,,laurens ,,bust ,,of ,,madame ,v4 ,,the ,,burghers ,,of ,,calais ,a ,,burgher ,,of ,,calais ,a ,,burgher ,,of ,,calais ,a ,,burgher ,,of ,,calais ,,balzac ,,balzac ,,primitive ,,man ,,young ,,woman ,,between ,,good ,,and ,,evil ,,counsel ,,iris ,,nude ,,study ,,auguste ,,rodin ,,corner ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,studio ,,at ,,meudon ,,corner ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,studio ,,at ,,meudon ,,study ,,in ,,bronze ,,for ,,the ,,balzac ,,nude ,,figure 7photographed in the open air1 at twilight1 in the garden in ,meudon7 ,,auguste ,,rodin ,i ,,youth ,,and ,,early ,,work ,,of ,,rodin--,,his ,,first ,,attempts2 ,,his ,,time ,,at ,,carrier',s--,,his ,,stay ,,in ,,brussels ,,and ,,work ,,there--,,the ,,age ,,of ,,brass ,,at ,,the ,,salon ,,of #ahgg2 ,,the ,,incident ,,arising ,,in ,,regard ,,to ,,it--,,the ,,st4 ,,john ,,the ,,baptist2 ,,beginning ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,reputation ,auguste ,rodin was born in ,paris1 in the ,val de ,grce quarter1 on the #adth of ,november1 #ahdj1 of a family of humble employs4 ,the child at first attended a day-school in the ,rue ,saint ,jacques1 then went to a boarding-school at ,beauvais1 kept by his uncle4 ,at fourteen he returned to ,paris and entered the school of art in the ,rue de l'cole de ,mdecine4 ,a period of desperate industry at once set in for him4 ,in addition to the lessons of this little school1 where from eight to twelve young ,rodin learned the elements of drawing1 and later on of modelling1 copied drawings in crayons and reliefs in the ,louis ,,xvi4 style1 he went twice a week to ,barye's classes at the ,jardin des ,plantes2 ,barye1 he says1 did not teach us much2 he was always worried and tired when he came1 and always told us that it was very good4 ,but ,rodin1 together with ,barye's son and some other lads1 had arranged a sort of studio for themselves in a cellar of the museum1 making seats of tree-trunks1 and already attempting sculpture4 ,at six in the morning he used to go to draw animals1 then he copied the anatomical objects in the ,museum4 ,he remembers that1 being too poor to buy an anatomy of the horse1 he copied it piece by piece4 ,after ,barye's class1 or the classes of the ,rue de l'cole de ,mdecine1 he would lunch on a bit of bread and some chocolate and hasten to the ,louvre1 and in the evenings he would go to draw and study at the ,gobelins4 ,then he worked for a maker of ornaments1 since it was necessary to earn a living4 ,from fourteen to seventeen years old ,rodin led this fevered existence4 ,in those three years1 he has often repeated to me1 ,i came to understand the meaning of a drawing from the life1 the synthesis of my art1 and the rhythm of animals4 ,i remember that a companion of those days1#a of whom ,i have since lost sight1 made me see1 in a couple of hours1 on a very true and simple principle1 an observation of the necessary equilibria of movement not taught in the schools1 the secret of the plans of a figure4 ,that lesson has influenced my whole life4 ,as for the ornament-maker1 in whose workshop ,i earned a scanty wage1 ,i long deplored being constrained to do so1 but ,i have since thought with affection of it1 understanding that there are as many sources of beauty in ornament as in the face4 ,his work at the ornament-maker's allowed ,rodin to earn his living as an art-worker and as a strenuous and silent student2 and he vegetated in this manner until he attained his twenty-fourth year1 never ceasing1 in spite of his poverty and of his daily labour1 to work at sculpture4 ,then he offered himself as an assistant and pupil at the studio of ,carrier-,belleuse4 ,carrier-,belleuse was then at the full height of his reputation as an elegant sculptor1 whose real gifts of spontaneous invention were being rendered insipid by his desire to please4 ,rodin remained six years at ,carrier-,belleuse's1 and worked there without gaining much instruction4 ,but he meditated and taught himself4 ,from his twenty-fourth year dates the head known as ,the ,man with the ,broken ,nose1 which is a masterly work1 strongly inspired by the antique1 and already foreshadowing all his future4 ,this clay head1 which the young man sent to the ,salon of #ahfd1 was refused4 ,from time to time ,rodin tried to compete for admission to the cole des ,beaux ,arts2 he was thrice refused4 ,this disgusted him with the usual career upon which his lack of any income invited him to enter4 ,his ideas1 his independent temper1 his presentiments1 and his love of an art personal to himself1 showed him that he would never gain anything1 and never have the academic discipline necessary to succeed4 ,he took advantage of an opportunity4 ,carrier-,belleuse had a commission at ,brussels and did not care to execute it2 ,rodin got permission from his master1 who esteemed him1 to undertake it in his name1 and1 after having spent six years in the fashionable sculptor's studio1 he went to ,brussels1 where ,rude had already spent a considerable time4 ,he was destined to remain there until #ahgg1 working with the ,belgian sculptor1 ,van ,rasbourg1 at the pediment of the ,bourse1 where his sign manual may still be seen1 as it may upon some caryatids of a house on the ,boulevard d',anspach and upon some other works4 ,of this exile at ,brussels we know that the artist retains only kindly memories1 but he is too sparing of personal details to enable us to analyse with any certainty this part of the life of a tenacious1 concentrated man who1 entirely occupied with his dreams1 with indefatigable study1 the anxieties of poverty1 and his lonely pride1 had no desire to be known4 ,i worked very hard over there1 he says1 to sum up the matter4 ,it is certain that ,rodin was at this time already in possession of that formidable will which led to his success1 and also of that disdainful obstinacy which prefers obscurity and lack of success to any compromise4 ,he speaks little or not at all of the drama that was being worked out in him at this time1 or of the way in which he refined and cultivated his perceptions1 nor of the painting lessons that he took of ,lecoq de ,boisbaudron1 in company of ,alphonse ,legros1 who became his intimate friend2 but this influence of ,lecoq de ,boisbaudron must not pass unnoted4 ,it does great honour to that master teacher who has formed so many eminent modern artists4 ,his seven years' stay at ,brussels allowed ,rodin to live modestly but decently1 amid quiet surroundings1 to reflect1 and to shape himself intellectually2 it was a sort of spiritual retreat that did him good1 apart from the fact that he gained a thorough knowledge of the ,flemish ,primitives and of the ,gothic masters who were so strongly to influence him4 ,no biography1 however1 could render comprehensible the way in which1 for example1 the brain of a low-born and poor child was able1 amid poverty and incessant manual labour1 to grow into the wide and deep brain of a thinker familiar with the synthesis of art2 these things are the secrets of personality4 ,illustration3 ,,the ,,age ,,of ,,brass ,rodin was destined to emerge suddenly from obscurity at the age of thirty-seven1 that is to say1 at a time of life when many men think themselves hopelessly sacrificed1 and when he had already produced much and suffered much2 for it may be said that the whole of his work from #ahee-ge is unknown and lost1 and yet what labour it represents6 ,except ,the ,man with the ,broken ,nose1 none of it is ever mentioned2 the pediment of the ,bourse at ,brussels is crumbling away1 time is devouring ,rodin's work upon it no less than ,van ,rasbourg's2 he will not speak of the many figures that he made to the order of ,carrier-,belleuse and interpreted according to his own free inspiration2 and he only occasionally alludes to a large figure that was broken in a household removal1 and was1 in his opinion1 one of the best he ever made in his life4 ,in #ahgf ,the ,man with the ,broken ,nose1 in marble1 was admitted to the ,salon4 ,this determined ,rodin in #ahgg to send in his statue1 ,the ,age of ,brass1 and this gave rise to an incident1 the very injustice of which was to bring him into notice4 ,the jury1#b astonished by this work1 admitted it1 but accused the artist of having taken a cast from life1 so perfect was the modelling4 ,the practice of taking a cast from the life is unhappily frequent1 and we know he praised academicians who employ this artistic fraud without any scruple4 ,rodin protested4 ,he had had a ,belgian soldier for his model in ,brussels3 he had photographs taken of him and sent them to the jury1 who did not even open the packet1 and persisted in the allegations4 ,three sculptors1 however1 ,desbois1 ,fagel1 and ,lefvre1 who thenceforward became ,rodin's friends1 protested in his favour1 some critics spoke of the affair1 and ,rodin's work made so much impression that the secretary of the ,fine ,arts1 ,turquet1 bought ,the ,age of ,brass 7which stood for a long time in the ,luxembourg ,gardens and is now in the museum74 ,rodin waited until #ahhj to exhibit ,st4 ,john the ,baptist4 ,meanwhile ,turquet had conceived a friendship for him and wished to wipe out the unjust accusation brought against ,the ,age of ,brass4 ,the inspectors of the ,fine ,arts department disowned the purchase of that work and declared it cast from life4 ,rodin1 discouraged1 remained silent2 a chance saved him4 ,as he was continuing to look for work in order to support his young wife and himself1 and to defray the expenses of his art1 he chanced to be executing a group of children in a composition for the sculptor ,boucher4 ,his facility was prodigious2 ,boucher saw him improvise the group in a few hours and went1 thunderstruck1 to tell some of his friends4 ,he had the honesty to declare that such a man1 having done thus before his own eyes1 was capable of making ,the ,age of ,brass4 ,chapu1 ,thomas1 ,falguire1 ,delaplanche1 ,chaplin1 ,carrier-,belleuse1 and ,paul ,dubois insisted loyally1 and ,rodin's cause was won4 ,turquet1 delighted1 and free to act1 bought the ,st4 ,john the ,baptist and gave ,rodin a commission4 ,then the artist answered3 ,i am ready to fulfil it4 ,but to prove surely that ,i do not take casts from the life ,i will make little bas-reliefs--an immense work with small figures1 and ,i think of taking the subject from ,dante4 ,this was the origin of that celebrated ,gate of ,hell1 which is not yet completed1 and which1 continually handled afresh1 has finally become the central motive of all ,rodin's dreams1 the storehouse of his ideas and researches4 ,illustration3 ,,the ,,age ,,of ,,brass ,from that time forward 7#ahhj7 ,rodin was what he is to-day2 he had emerged1 once for all1 from obscurity1 and went on to display without interruption and without hesitation the succession of works that have rendered him celebrated4 ,he knew his path1 his method1 his field of thought4 ,from the age of sixteen to that of forty he had1 by unknown persistent labour1 been ripening his individuality4 ,and his work1 from ,the ,age of ,brass to the ,balzac1 is but a visible development of that hidden period4 ,the period from the ,balzac to our own day testifies to a new theory that he has framed4 ,but one may say that the ,rodin of the years from #ahgg to #ahig was entirely contained in the unknown man of the preceding period4 ,it was1 indeed1 that slow preparation that gave to the revelation of the works that appearance of certainty1 of sudden mastery1 which so struck people's minds4 ,we are accustomed to see artists make youthful successes with works of brilliant promise1 then we follow their course and see them growing greater4 ,rodin came to light in twenty-four hours4 ,he was thought to be a young beginner2 his past struggle was unknown2 people were aware of him only when he had done with scruples and had1 as he says1 made peace with himself4 ,from this fact came his prestige4 ,from it came also his well-defined attitude in regard to academic art4 ,illustration3 ,,st4 ,,john ,,the ,,baptist ,,preaching ,we need to recall the graceful1 effeminate1 and conventional statuary of the generation from #ahfe to #ahge in order to comprehend fully what ,the ,age of ,brass and ,st4 ,john the ,baptist brought into the exhibitions when they made their appearance there4 ,rough truth1 a sense of movement1 an intense realism1 an absolute scorn of the pleasing1 a lofty style1 a deep feeling of organic life1 power due to the eager love of form1 of muscular formation and physical activity2 all these things inevitably shocked the gentle sculptors who were enamoured of the academic style and of mythology4 ,moreover1 ,rodin was unknown2 he had no claim1 knew nobody1 had never asked for anything1 and was a son of the people4 ,that ,carrier-,belleuse's former workman should take upon himself to make statues all by himself aroused scorn4 ,his technical skill was so great that there could be no possibility of denying it4 ,therefore1 in spite1 the accusation of casting from the life was invented4 ,the accusers did not reflect upon the splendid testimonial that would be given to the artist if he should succeed in proving that his skill alone had created this perfection4 ,the amusing thing is that the same people who declared this skill too great to be anything but a reproduction1 accused ,rodin1 twenty years later1 over his ,balzac1 of not knowing his craft6 ,apart from this question of fact1 and these professional jealousies1 the style of these works could not fail to displease4 ,in them there was already a sort of symbolic and savage beauty1 which has become a characteristic of ,rodin's art4 ,the pained1 awakening movement of the man in ,the ,age of ,brass1 the gesture of ,st4 ,john the ,baptist1 and still more his wild face with its open mouth1 were so much outside the usual conventions as to make everybody feel that here was an artist resolved to take no account of the cole and its principles4 ,these two splendid studies of the nude already contained a very special thought4 ,rodin1 therefore1 was hated in the first place as a man who would be revolutionary4 ,he was hated because he was powerful1 because he emerged suddenly from obscurity1 and because he was felt to possess an obstinate individuality4 ,it was also for these very reasons that warm sympathies went out to ,rodin from among artists opposed to the spirit of the cole1 and from independent writers who divined in him a man capable of expressing in his art thoughts and emotions that had ceased to be found in art4 ,illustration3 ,,eve4 #a ,this unknown student was called ,constant ,simon4 ,rodin remembers him as a remarkable man4 #b ,the hanging committee of the ,salon is called a jury4--,,trans4 ,,ii ,,rodin',s ,,studio--,,his ,,works ,,from #ahhj ,,to #ahhi--;,,eve2 ,,some ,,busts2 ,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,victor ,,hugo--,,the ,,gate ,,of ,,hell--,,the ,,danaid--,,the ,,thought--,,the ,,exhibition ,,of ,,claude ,,monet ,,and ,,rodin1 ,,in #ahhi--,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,claude ,,lorraine ,,at ,,nancy 7#ahib7--,,the ,,burghers ,,of ,,calais 7#ahhh-ahie7 ,rodin's previous works1 from #ahha to #ahhi1 had been produced in modest abodes in the ,rue des ,fourneaux and the ,boulevard de ,vaugirard1 and later1 in a little studio1 granted by the ,government1 at the ,dpt des ,marbres1 in the ,rue de l',universit1 where a certain number of studios are given to sculptors4 ,from #ahhi onwards the ,government granted ,rodin two larger studios there1 which he still occupies4 ,at a later date he also had1 at his own expense1 a studio in an odd corner of the ,boulevard d',italie1 at a place called the ,clos ,payen1 besides a house at ,svres1 and eventually one at ,meudon1 in which he still lives and of which ,i shall speak again4 ,among these were distributed his studies and his finished works3 ,the ,gate of ,hell was sketched in at the ,rue de l',universit1 and there1 too1 ,rodin's assistants are at work upon his present groups4 ,illustration3 ,,sketch ,,for ,a ,,competition4 ,,monument ,,to ,,the ,,defenders ,,of ,,the ,,country ,from #ahgi ,rodin worked at ,svres1 having been introduced by ,carrier-,belleuse1 and a vase decorated by him may be seen there4 ,in #ahhj he made a fine competitive design for the ,monument to the ,defenders of the ,nation1 which was not accepted4 ,in #ahha he made a figure of ,adam1 which he destroyed1 and an ,eve1 which must be reckoned among his noblest creations--an ,eve ashamed of her faults1 bowed down by terror1 vaguely tormented less by remorse for her sin than by the idea of having created beings for future sorrow4 ,this ,eve is a bronze of formidable appearance and all ,rodin breathes in it4 ,as in the ,st4 ,john the ,baptist1 we feel the effect of a definite conception of sculpture1 but here the design is more spiritual and the scheme of modelling simpler and larger4 ,from that time onward we shall find the artist producing regularly1 putting forth a peaceful power1 and working in complete possession of himself1 not free certainly from doubts and searchings1 but allowing nothing of the sort to be seen4 ,rodin's way of working is very peculiar2 he does not begin one piece of work1 carry it to its conclusion1 and then devote himself to another4 ,he has had from the outset a certain number of thoughts that correspond to forms1 and although he has only shown his works one after another1 he has nevertheless elaborated them side by side1 working at them simultaneously and modifying them one by another4 ,thus ,the ,gate of ,hell has been made and remade for more than twenty years2 thus the monument to ,hugo1 not yet handed over1 goes back1 by the sketches for it1 to #ahhf2 while the studies for ,the ,burghers of ,calais date from #ahhh1 though the monument was only completed in #ahie2 thus1 too1 among the little groups on which ,rodin is still at work1 are many that have grown out of rough sketches made fifteen years ago4 ,rodin has a store of ideas and emotions dear to him1 upon which he has patiently meditated1 which he has promised himself to execute1 and which he brings to ripeness in silence1 remaining throughout long years without appearing to concern himself with them4 ,strength and patience might be his characteristic motto4 ,like all great artists1 he thought out the essential lines of his work at once1 lines that ,i shall define at the end of this book4 ,his is a synthetic and generalising mind1 which can only begin its active course after slow meditation1 and conceives no isolated thing2 spontaneous and at the same time prudent4 ,he had that time of meditation at ,brussels1 not hastening to produce1 not permitting himself to express an idea until he had prepared in detail the technical expression1 the necessities of the craftsman4 ,illustration3 ,,ugolino ,,and ,,his ,,children ,the ,ugolino1 a cast1 of which ,rodin exhibited the first sketch in #ahhb1 is the first sign of that preoccupation with ,dante1 which was to be shown in all his later work4 ,he has read comparatively few things1 and that designedly2 he attaches himself strongly to a few great and profound works1 and meditates upon them indefatigably4 ,his whole symbolic imagination has been fed by ,dante and his whole sensuous imagination by ,baudelaire4 ,these two gloomy poets have impressed him1 and it may be said that he has absorbed them4 ,almost all ,rodin's great symbolic figures refer to the ,inferno1 and all his little groups of lovers have the neurotic subtlety1 the refined1 homesick melancholy of the ,fleurs du ,mal4 ,he has a constant need to evolve from realism to general ideas1 from thought to delight or sorrow1 and the ideal of ,dante or of ,baudelaire is strangely mingled in him with love of the antique and worship of mythology4 ,it is1 indeed1 this quite individual fusion that forms the basis of his personality4 ,the ,ugolino1 which was exhibited1 first alone and then with his dying children1 over whom he is crouching1 haggard and already almost like a wild beast1 is a tragic and powerful work4 ,the same year ,rodin produced the bust of ,alphonse ,legros1 which has taken so high a place in ,england in the opinion of the best judges1 and in that of the lamented ,w4 ,e4 ,henley1 whose penetrating criticism paid homage from the first to our sculptor's art4 ,illustration3 ,,bellona ,page #ag ,illustration3 ,,bellona ,the ,genius of ,war1 the ,monument to ,general ,lynch1 and the very curious ,bellona1 date from #ahhc2 the ,president ,vicunha#a and a ,bust of a ,young ,woman1 from #ahhd4 ,this was rather a period of groping than of production2 ,rodin was continuing his studies1 and becoming more confirmed in his technical methods4 ,we must go on to the year #ahhe to reach the revelation of three of his finest sculptures--the three busts of ,dalou1 ,victor ,hugo1 and ,antonin ,proust1 which powerfully declare his personality4 ,these are works that are not disputable1 that cannot be accused of having a literary intention1 mere bits of sculpture giving evidence of mastery and showing surfaces1 planes1 and high lights worthy of the very finest busts of the ,french school4 ,as time goes by1 the ideas1 the philosophy1 the symbolism1 the dramatisation of ,rodin's compositions may come to be disputed1 or exact comprehension of them may be lost2 but works like these will always1 by their mere professional worth1 bear witness for him4 ,life1 thought1 strength1 and character are carried as far as is possible4 ,the bust of ,hugo was the outcome of some few studies that the artist was able to make from the life4 ,hugo declared ,david of ,angers to have made so good a bust of him that he considered it unnecessary ever to sit again4 ,rodin wished to obtain sittings1 but failed2 the poet admitted him to his table1 and merely said to him1 ,come when you like1 observe me 444 and do what you can4 ,at table ,rodin took sketches of ,hugo in cigarette-paper books2 he had a stand and some clay in the ante-room1 and from time to time he would run in to note down anything that had just struck him4 ,,victor ,,hugo4 7,,dry ,,point7 ,,victor ,,hugo4 7,,dry-,,point7 ,in this manner was that admirable bust completed1 which 7with the two etchings here reproduced7 was the only material of which ,rodin could make use for the ,hugo with the bowed head of his future monument1 the commission for which was given him by the ,government after the death of the national poet in #ahhc1 and which is on the eve of completion4 ,the next year 7#ahhf7 ,rodin exhibited the scheme of the monument itself1 which has since undergone several variations1 but of which the central theme is always as follows3 ,hugo1 naked and half-draped1 like a god1 is seated on a rock at the edge of the sea4 ,with his outstretched left arm he makes a silencing gesture towards the sea and the ,nereids1 and thus begs them to let him listen to the ,muse of his ,inner ,voice1 who rises1 pensively1 behind him1 and to the ,muse of ,anger1 who1 crouched on a rock above his head1 seems ready to fly up into the sky4 ,this ,muse may also be interpreted as an ,ins1 the messenger of the voices of the elements1 and the ,muse of the ,inner ,voice is also called ,meditation4 ,she is of the greatest beauty2 hers is one of the figures in which1 before the ,balzac1 ,rodin indicates his new method of amplifying the relief and systematically altering the proportions1 in order--according to an idea which ,i shall analyse in detail in the next chapter--to secure a decorative effect4 ,nothing can be more expressive and more supernatural than the harmonious sadness of this great drooping shape2 it is really a soul incarnated in a movement of modesty and secret contemplation that disturbs and moves us as we gaze4 ,the ,hugo himself is truly ,olympian in the majesty of his gesture1 the vastness of his heroic nudity1 and the magic of the shadow that bathes his face bowed partly down over his breast2 and the monument as a whole is of magnificent decorative unity4 ,there are to be two monuments to ,victor ,hugo1 one for the ,pantheon1 the other for the ,luxembourg ,gardens1 and they are to have slight variations1 not in the attitude of ,hugo himself1 but in the significance and style of the adjacent figures4 ,these two monuments1 however1 have not been accepted without great difficulties caused by the very nature of ,rodin's conception2 and the fact that they are accepted has not prevented the ,place ,victor ,hugo from being disfigured by a hideous and gigantic monument1 the work of ,barrias1 which fills the place of those that ,rodin had not completed4 ,rodin's slowness1 which arises from the scrupulous circumspection of his mind--never satisfied with itself--and from his habit of working simultaneously at several subjects1 has always contributed towards driving away official commissions from him2 while the jealousy of his fellows and the exceptional character of his work have further helped to bring about strained relations between him and the official circle4 ,rodin does not care about pleasing or about being understood by everybody1 and he has no idea of concessions4 ,thus almost all his important works have given rise to incidents likely to disturb his peace and hinder his work4 ,illustration3 ,,bust ,,of ,,victor ,,hugo4 ,illustration3 ,,victor ,,hugo ,,monument4 7,a ,,fragment7 ,illustration3 ,,victor ,,hugo4 7,a ,,fragment7 ,together with the sketch of the ,hugo monument1 a bust of ,henry ,becque1 and a curious etching made from it1 ,rodin exhibited in #ahhf the first drawings belonging to ,the ,gate of ,hell1 or at least to the work which people have agreed to call by that title4 ,i have already related the origin of that ,government commission4 ,in the beginning ,rodin had been asked to make a door in high-relief1 intended for the ,muse des ,arts ,dcoratifs4 ,but the sculptor's imagination1 beset by ideas of ,dante1 soon deviated from the original scheme4 ,the door really exists in the studio of the ,rue de l',universit1 under the aspect of a vast rough model in plaster and beams1 in the very simple shape of a two-leaved door #ai feet high1 with a frieze1 a tympanum1 and two lateral capitals4 ,it was1 at first1 to have been surmounted by the two figures of ,adam and ,eve1 but ,rodin gave them up4 ,he now seems determined to place the ,shades1 here reproduced1 in the highest plane4#b ,on the uppermost beam ,the ,thinker is to be seated4 ,in the panels of the door and upon the wide uprights are enshrined figures--to the number of over a hundred--detached in high-relief1 exactly as upon the gates of the ,baptistery in ,florence1 which ,rodin has1 quite simply1 taken as his model4 ,these figures were1 at first1 direct interpretations from ,dante1 in particular ,paolo and ,francesca da ,rimini and divers inhabitants of the ,inferno4 ,then ,rodin intermingled figures due solely to his inspirations from ,baudelaire and to his own sharp perception of tragic perversity4 ,he enlarged ,dante's conception as he modernised it1 and has ended by making this door into what he smilingly calls my ,noah's ,ark4 ,that means that he is continually putting in little figures which replace others2 there1 plastered into the niches left by unfinished figures1 he places everything that he improvises1 everything that seems to him to correspond in character and subject with that vast confusion of human passions4 ,the size of these figures is greatly restricted2 the largest scarcely exceed thirty-nine inches in height4 ,the dimensions of the final rendering1 however1 still remain to be fixed4 ,the splendid figure called ,the ,thinker is carried out in bronze larger than life1 and ,rodin is credited with an intention of bringing up all the other figures to the same dimensions1 which would represent an unheard-of outlay and a gate nearly a hundred feet high--a ,cyclopean work indeed6 ,the ,thinker1 who has been so called on account of the likeness between his attitude and that of ,michael ,angelo's ,pensieroso1 is much more truly an image1 with his stunted body and a primitive man's face1 of the cave-dweller1 the prognathous savage beholding the crimes and passions of his progeny unroll themselves below him4 ,immediately beneath him may be seen the most celebrated characters of the ,dante cycle1 notably the lovers of ,rimini entwined and falling into hell4#c ,then as we descend towards the ground the figures become more independent of the subject1 more personally invented by the artist1 and at the foot we find women damned1 such as ,baudelaire conceived1 amid characters from heathen mythology4 ,illustration3 ,,nereids 7,group at the base of the ,victor ,hugo monument47 ,it may thus be said that1 although1 perhaps1 the celebrated doorway may never be finished1 it is a storehouse of ,rodin's creations4 ,it stands by him as a theme for inspirations1 and he brings into it a whole category of thoughts and works1 never troubling himself about the architecture or the actual scheme4 ,he will be for ever improvising some little figure1 shaping the notation of some feeling1 idea1 or form1 and this he plants in his door1 studies it against the other figures1 then takes it out again1 and if need be1 breaks it up and uses the fragments for other attempts4 ,many of these little figures have developed into important separate groups4 ,rodin is ruled primarily by the need to create and to satisfy an irresistible vocation2 he cares little what may be the ultimate transformation of his inventions1 and his sculpture is1 furthermore1 so conceived that it may be executed on a large scale or a small2 this is indeed so much the case that it is often impossible to judge from a photograph what are the dimensions4 ,illustration3 ,,shades 7,for the top of ,the ,gate of ,hell47 ,the ,gate of ,hell might therefore better be called the ,pandemonium1 or some quite other name4 ,if it were to be carried out it could not contain all the figures destined for it by the artist4 ,there they stand1 innumerable1 ranged on shelves beside the rough model of the door1 representing the entire evolution of ,rodin's inspiration1 and forming what ,i call1 with his consent1 the diary of his life as a sculptor4 ,to enumerate these figures and groups would take too long2 suffice to say that the larger part of ,rodin's small marbles and bronzes are but completions of these sketches1 and that on account of the essentially decorative character of the outlines and the intense originality of the proportion and balance of the figures1 they can be conceived either as statuettes or as lifesized works4 ,such as it is1 ,the ,gate of ,hell is the plan of a piece of work unique in the sculpture of modern days1 a plan slowly elaborated1 and of which every detail has been foreseen and analysed for years4 ,no one has dared to undertake so audacious an assemblage of figures upon such a scheme1 and the scheme is present to ,rodin in its entirety4 ,he by no means forgets the decorative effect nor the harmonious aspects1 the concords that the gate should have1 and if ever ,government should require him to deliver his work he would be able to do so without delay4 ,twenty years in the studio have matured it in his mind4 ,the work that ,dante inspired has assumed a more general significance4 ,low-relief1 high-relief1 figures standing free1 groups1 single figures1 all the styles of sculpture are gathered into the symphony of a throng1 lost amid whirling mists of hell and converging towards the figure of the ,thinker4 ,the conception embraces centuries4 ,ugolino is there1 and so are centaurs1 female fauns1 satyrs1 and creatures dreamed of by ,baudelaire1 abstract personifications of vices--in particular1 there is the extraordinary group of the miser dying of hunger over his treasure beside a prostitute 7,avarice and ,lewdness74 ,the ,thinker1 in his austere nudity and pensive strength1 is at one and the same time the alarmed ,adam1 the implacable ,dante1 and the compassionate ,virgil of this frightful unrestrained humanity1 but he is1 above all1 the ancestor1 the first man1 simple and unconscious1 looking down on what he has begotten4 ,the symbolism and philosophy of the artist are independent of any religious doctrine2 his spiritual ardour excels in setting free the symbols of the various creeds1 and he is supported mainly by deep and incessant consultation of nature1 and by his exceptional sense of expression in movements4 ,he attains the decorative harmony of his work not by additions1 but by systematic suppressions1 as the ,gothic artists and those of the ,renascence did4 ,illustration3 ,,the ,,thinker ,the ,gate of ,hell is the outcome of studies made by ,rodin from the ,gothic sculptors1 during his stay in ,brussels4 ,in this1 and in ,the ,burghers of ,calais1 he resumes the deep influence that he there underwent4 ,as to the influence that the antique had upon him1 that only showed itself later1 in his smaller works in marble1 and especially in the ,balzac and recent productions4 ,the ,gate corresponds to the period in which ,rodin's great aim was to create1 through intensity of movement and originality of attitude and outline1 a new system of the dramatic in his art1 which the taste of the day had frozen into a false neo-,greek nobility1 obtained by immobility1 by inertia of outline1 and by a fear of seeing too living a movement break the general harmony4 ,to seek a fresh harmony in the very study of movement1 to create1 side by side with static art1 a dynamic art1 such1 in a brief formula1 was ,rodin's idea4 ,he was shortly to exhibit a work which was still more significant of the thoughts with which he was busy4 ,for1 though ,i have spoken at once of that famous ,gate1 which is the leit-motiv of ,rodin's art1 it must be remembered that in #ahhf nothing was known of it but drawings4 ,only by degrees have groups and fragments of it been seen1 and the work itself has never left the studio in the ,rue de l',universit4 ,it was ,the ,burghers of ,calais which revealed most clearly to the public ,rodin's capabilities in the way of style and of composing a whole work1 and ,i will speak of the ,burghers in this chapter1 although the work was not completed until #ahib and was not set up in ,calais until #ahie4 ,illustration3 ,,danaid ,illustration3 ,,danaid ,illustration3 ,,thought ,in #ahhg we may note ,perseus and the ,gorgon1 and a marble ,head of the beheaded ,st4 ,john1 which belongs to the ,marchioness of ,carcano4 ,in #ahhh was exhibited the exquisite ,danaid1 one of the most tender female figures that were ever lovingly moulded by this sculptor of the energetic1 and one which has a subtle delicacy of soul that seems strangely placed between two works of power4 ,at the same time a naked figure was also shown at the ,exposition des ,beaux ,arts1 in ,brussels--a ,man ,walking1 which was no other than one of the ,burghers1 and of which the robust execution made an impression4 ,the year #ahhi marked an increase of the artist's activity4 ,he was busy upon preparatory work for the monument of ,claude ,lorraine1 which he had been commissioned to make for ,nancy4 ,he was going on with ,the ,gate of ,hell4 ,he completed a statue of ,bastien-,lepage for the cemetery of ,damvilliers4 ,he began upon the busts of the art critics1 ,octave ,mirbeau and ,roger ,marx1 finished an admirable little ,dream-,group in marble1 in which a young man is lying back and trying to hold fast a sphinx-woman who takes flight1 wild and fateful4 ,an impressionist sketch of ,hecuba1 crouching down and shrieking1 and ,thought1 in marble1 completed the record of this well-filled year4 ,thought1 a proud1 sweet head rising from a block1 is one of ,rodin's best known works and the very symbol of his art4 ,it occupies a place in the ,museum of the ,luxembourg1 where it is in company with ,the ,danaid1 the ,st4 ,john1 ,the ,kiss1 a masterly female bust1 and a bronze statuette4 ,the ,fair ,helmet-,maker1 from ,villon's poem1 is a work on a very small scale1 but containing the depth and strength of tragedy--the whole drama of a human body's ruin4 ,illustration3 ,,the ,,fair ,,helmet-,,maker ,in #ahhi ,rodin and ,claude ,monet together held1 in the ,george ,petit gallery1 an exhibition which has remained famous and which united our two greatest artists4 ,rodin sent to it the ,women ,damned1 the ,beheaded ,st4 ,john1 some ,fauns and ,bacchantes1 ,bastien-,lepage1 in all some thirty works1 among which was ,the ,burghers of ,calais1 shown complete for the first time4 ,the sensation produced was immense4 ,rodin now tasted unmistakable fame1 and his reputation spread all over the world4 ,this fame1 however1 did not disarm the official circle1 and not until the last three or four years have the critics been unanimous in their praise of the great ,french sculptor1 whose every important work has given occasion to a battle1 because its beauty arose from principles opposed to the whole system taught in the schools4 ,the five following years were marked by various works which did not1 however1 interfere with the threefold parallel continuation of the ,victor ,hugo1 ,the ,burghers of ,calais1 and ,the ,gate of ,hell1 which were exhibited in various states in the ,salon4 ,rodin considers it his duty1 indeed1 to submit to the public the phases of his work1 rough attempts1 clay1 marbles1 or bronzes1 before the final completion2 and understanding very well that his style is1 or seems to be difficult1 he thus explains himself to the public in the exhibitions1 and allows people to follow the stages through which his thought passes4 ,in addition to these works may be noted1 for the year #ahij1 the bust of a young woman1 in silver1 ,brother and ,sister1 bronze1 and the ,torso of ,st4 ,john the ,baptist4 ,in #ahia1 ,the ,caryatid1 a marble figure of a young woman with a stone upon her shoulder1 the group of ,the ,young ,mother 7first bronze and then marble71 and ,a ,nymph4 ,in #ahib1 the busts of ,rochefort and of ,puvis de ,chavannes1 which1 with those of ,dalou1 ,jean ,paul ,laurens1 ,hugo1 and ,falguire1 form an incomparable series from ,rodin's hand of portraits that surpass all modern ,french sculpture1 and are admirable alike in execution and expression4 ,the ,puvis de ,chavannes is perhaps the finest2 it is a work that does not pall even beside ,donatello himself4 ,in #ahib the ,burghers and the ,claude ,lorraine were completed4 ,the ,burghers waited three years for their setting up1 but the monument to ,lorraine was inaugurated immediately1 thanks to the devoted efforts of that great art-worker in glass1 mile ,gall1 and of ,roger ,marx1 who by his writings and his incessant activity has had a most noble effect upon modern ,french art4 ,these two eminent men1 both natives of ,nancy1 enforced the acceptance of the work4 ,the monument consists of a statue of ,lorraine1 standing1 palette in hand1 his head raised eagerly towards the east1 and of a pedestal from which ,apollo and his rearing horses stand out in splendid high-relief4 ,thus did ,rodin seek to pay homage to the master-painter who adored movement in light1 by acclaiming both these in his turn4 ,fault has been found with the importance of the pedestal in comparison with the statue1 the objectors failing to understand that this allegory of ,apollo incarnated the very soul of the great artist whose effigy towered over the whole work1 and that this whole could not be dissevered4 ,the idea animating this composition was criticised by the authorities4 ,here1 once more1 ,rodin with his symbolic vision1 his tendency to bold simplifications of the general1 synthetic idea1 was found disturbing4 ,he was asked for the sculptured portrait of a man1 and he preferred to give prominence to a symbol that expressed the dream and the essential genius of that man1 the sun-painter--an idea which was logical1 but which ran counter to the received prejudice as to portrait statues4 ,the propagandist persistence of ,gall and ,roger ,marx1 however1 convinced the people of ,nancy1 who are now very proud of their monument4 ,the horses and the ,apollo are the most living1 palpitating1 and lyrical things that ,rodin has produced4 ,illustration3 ,,puvis ,,de ,,chavannes ,illustration3 ,,jean-,,paul ,,laurens ,in #ahic ,rodin made the bust of ,madame ,sverine1 the medallion of ,csar ,franck1 and several works in marble2 ,galatea1 ,the ,death of ,adonis1 ,the ,education of ,achilles1 and ,the ,wave4 ,from #ahid date the ,eternal ,spring1 one of his tenderest and purest works1 besides an ,orpheus and ,eurydice1 an ,adonis and ,venus1 and finally ,christ and the ,magdalen4 ,for1 by degrees1 he was returning to religious and mythological subjects1 after having expressed only general symbols or pieces of pure realism2 and ,i shall have to call attention at a later point to the original manner in which ,rodin was bold enough to interpret these subjects which the academic classicism seemed to have worn out and left insipid for ever4 ,the year #ahie at last beheld the inauguration1 on the #crd of ,june1 of ,the ,burghers of ,calais at ,calais4 ,to the same year belongs another fine work in marble3 ,illusion1 the ,daughter of ,icarus1 besides a vigorous bronze1 ,the ,crouching ,man1 a medallion of ,octave ,mirbeau1 and--at this early date--some nude studies for the ,balzac1 for the ,balzac was studied minutely in the nude1 a point of which many people know nothing1 before appearing draped in the famous dressing-gown which was destined1 in #ahih1 to arouse so much clamour4 ,illustration3 ,,bust ,,of ,,madame ,v4 ,the ,burghers were set up1 by subscription1 in a square in ,calais4#d ,the monument is one in which ,rodin has deliberately departed from all the rules of official art4 ,these require that the effect should be pursued primarily by a compact grouping1 the same thought being translated by the same gesture from all the persons4 ,rodin1 on the contrary1 desired to leave their full individuality to his six burghers going in their shirts and with halters on their necks to surrender themselves to ,king ,edward1 and he has isolated them on their one base4 ,these six men are walking1 one behind the other1 two by two1 half naked and miserable1 with their emaciated faces--men besieged1 sacrificed4 ,one devotion unites them in the name of their town's salvation1 but their characters and their thoughts remain distinct1 and in each may be read a different drama of the conscience4 ,they have not the factitious enthusiasm and the declamatory gesture with which an ordinary sculptor would have thought well to furnish them2 they are simply citizens who have resolved to fulfil a fatal duty1 and are going to perform it without cowardice1 but nevertheless were1 yesterday1 trades-people and family-men with no pretensions to the heroic4 ,they bear with them their regrets1 their inner heartbreak1 and are not thinking of striking an attitude in the eyes of history4 ,they are the unknown1 obscure heroes of a fatality such as often arose in their rough times2 and of how many dead men1 devoted like them1 has history forgotten the deeds and names6 ,there is ,eustace de ,st4 ,pierre1 with his shaven magistrate's face1 stiff and controlled1 carrying the key of the town2 behind him ,andrieux d',andres1 with his hands clenched over his sobbing face1 turns back1 this last time1 towards the city4 ,jean de ,fiennes1 with his rough beard and weak1 old man's shoulders1 is listening to ,jean d',aire1 who1 younger than he1 is murmuring words that perhaps confide to him his horror of death1 and entreat from the old man encouragement in renunciation4 ,but in front of all the others the two brothers1 ,jacques and ,pierre de ,wissant1 advance resolutely2 and one turns back to hasten his friends1 while one exhorts them1 pointing with a restrained gesture towards heaven4 ,illustration3 ,,the ,,burghers ,,of ,,calais ,the entire reality of these figures is no less striking than their ideality1 just as is the case in the beautiful creations of the ,primitives4 ,these are men whose absolutely real nakedness reveals itself beneath the coarse sacks that clothe them1 a nakedness not harmonised into any style1 but shown in all its veracity by an artist who has chosen models suitable to his characters without any care to arrange them or to give them that pretended beauty which would be merely a falsehood and an enfeeblement4 ,these are six wretched men1 shivering with cold and anguish4 ,the scene is as close as possible to history1 and the faces are real--ugly or ordinary4 ,but an idea transfigures them4 ,the tragedy of their sacrifice gives them a strange greatness1 and they become fine because their soul is fine4 ,we guess the gradation of their reflections3 none faces his fate just like another1 and the reason is that1 though what they will is one1 what they leave is different for each1 and everything in them speaks1 from their faces down to the least attitude of their limbs4 ,their expression is sober2 a heavy silence enwraps them2 we follow them with our eyes as the dwellers in ,calais must have done from the heights of their walls2 and they are so grouped that from every point we see them separately1 presenting a distinct aspect1 and yet the one base unites and uplifts them4 ,this is a marvel of psychological composition4 ,technical skill assists this composition2 we find the power of the ,st4 ,john1 but more simplification4 ,only the essential lines attract the eye1 the details are subsidiary to the whole4 ,admirable bits of flesh modelling are only noticed after long examination2 the substance is scarcely thought of1 so much is the mind held at first by the intellectual drama1 and this was what ,rodin desired4 ,these six beings1 side by side1 are august in their sorrow1 and they move us by means of their simplicity and by the absence of any theatrical gesture4 ,we feel the bodies under the shirts1 for ,rodin made six complete models in the nude before he threw upon them these rags of stuff and knotted ropes4 ,the feet are strongly attached to the earth2 we guess that their limbs are heavy1 because1 though their will bids them walk1 every step leads towards death4 ,the impression is extraordinary and such as perhaps no sculpture ever gave before4 ,this is a reality of all time3 the epic of the sacrifice of the humble4 ,as for the style1 it recalls the ,gothic sculptors by the rugged power of the moulding1 the asceticism of the heads1 and the strength of the knotty limbs4 ,we are compelled to think of the ,flemish primitives1 and especially of those genial ,burgundian sculptors and image-makers of genius who produced the immortal figures of ,philippe ,pot's tomb in the ,louvre4 ,there is the same desire for expression in sculpture1 which seeks beauty solely in intensity of character1 and finds style in the sincere study of reality--all these things concurring towards the greater synthesis of the work's general thought4 ,rodin there shows himself an essentially ,french and northern artist1 alien from all that the academies1 hypnotised by the ,italianism of the second ,renascence1 have chosen to invent as dogmas of beauty4 ,the ,burghers of ,calais is a work of the true ,french classic tradition--of the national classicality which has nothing in common with that classicality imported from ,italy in #aeej by which our indigenous artists have so long been oppressed1 thanks to the cole de ,rome4 ,standing before such a creation we recognise this truth sharply--this truth which is the secret of ,rodin's genius and of the enthusiasm that he aroused4 ,better than ,rude1 better than ,barye1 better even than ,carpeaux1 has he found the way to free himself1 and to go back1 by power of thought and mastery1 to our true national lineage4 ,illustration3 ,a ,,burgher ,,of ,,calais ,illustration3 ,a ,,burgher ,,of ,,calais ,illustration3 ,a ,,burgher ,,of ,,calais ,the ,burghers ought1 according to ,rodin's idea1 to be placed in front of the old ,hotel de ,ville of ,calais1 facing the sea2 and he wished the group to be placed on a very high pedestal1 so that the figures should stand out against the open sky1 or else1 on the other hand1 almost on the level1 so that everyone could walk round them1 live with them1 almost elbow them4 ,a bad site has been chosen and a pedestal of moderate height and ordinary appearance4 ,the ,burghers are very fine all the same1 and are certainly the most powerful piece of sculpture of the epoch4 ,i have promised to be sober in my praises of ,rodin1 but ,i do not see why in speaking of such a work as this ,i should hide my convictions4 ,those who have seen it cannot fail to consider it1 as ,i do1 the work of a thinker and of an artist of genius4 #a ,it ,is curious to recollect that the very fine equestrian statue of ,general ,lynch and the monument to ,president ,vicunha1 sent to ,america by ,rodin1 were never paid for1 and that1 owing to revolutions1 they actually disappeared1 so that these works may be considered lost4 ,only the spoiled rough models and some photographs remain4 #b ,these ,shades are a symbolic representation of men who are just dead1 and who are bending down with folded hands in misery and terror gazing at the hellish crowd into which they are about to fall4 #c ,the final version of this group has been treated by ,rodin separately1 and is known by the name of ,the ,kiss4 ,the marble group is in the ,museum of the ,luxembourg4 #d ,a statue of ,eustace de ,st4 ,pierre had been asked for4 ,rodin sent the six effigies of burghers1 and this gave rise to fresh difficulties with the authorities4 ,,iii ,,rodin',s ,,work ,,from #ahie ,,to #ahih--,,small ,,groups--,,the ,,statue ,,of ,,balzac --,,the ,,incident ,,of ,,the ,,soci,t ,,des ,,gens ,,de ,,lettres--,,the ,,technique ,,of ,,the ,,balzac--,,rodin',s ,,ideas ,,upon ,,modelling ,,and ,,composition--,,his ,,opinions ,,about ,,the ,,greeks1 ,,the ,,gothic ,,style1 ,,classicism1 ,,and ,,mythological ,,subjects--,,rodin',s ,,antique ,,period4 ,the year #ahif was occupied by the continuation of work for the ,hugo monument4 ,the ,muse of ,anger and the ,muse of the ,inna' ,voice were brought to their full completion4 ,in addition to these ,rodin made a very fine head of ,minerva1 in marble1 with a silver helmet2 a statue of a ,conqueror1 holding a statue of ,victory2 and two groups--,the ,poet and the ,life of ,contemplation 7for ,m4 ,fenaille1 the faithful admirer1 who was1 at a later date1 to publish his sketches7 and ,the ,eternal ,idol1 a marvel of inspiration4 ,a young naked woman is in a half-sitting posture1 her head bent1 her gaze lost in a dream4 ,a man kneeling before her1 his arms behind him and his desire restrained1 puts his head gently forward and kisses the idol beneath the left breast over the heart1 with mute fervour1 and with a mystic1 amorous concentration of his whole being4 ,rarely does sculpture allow of so much pulsating life and so much psychological emotion united to plastic perfection and originality of arrangement4 ,from #ahig date the marble group of the ,women ,bathing1 the last studies for the ,balzac1 and the studies for the ,monument to ,president ,sarmiento1 a statue upon a pedestal in high-relief4 ,small groups in marble and in bronze are a form of which ,rodin is fond4 ,he has been led to devote himself largely to them on account of ,the ,gate of ,hell1 the dimensions of which necessitated small figures4 ,moreover1 ,rodin reserves this form of art for certain categories of works that have a character of passion and intimacy4 ,it should be possible to pass easily round them1 to lean over them1 almost to touch them and move them about2 one should be able to live with them1 as one cannot do with large figures meant to be looked at from below4 ,the happy form of the small sculptured block1 which the eighteenth century had employed to so much advantage1 allows this constant communion of the spectator and the work of art4 ,rodin1 who executes his bigger figures in so large a style1 reserves for these a style that is minute but never mannered4 ,the outlines remain large1 so much so1 indeed1 that the work would always bear an enlarged scale2 but the modelling is wrought with an almost caressing touch and with a strange love of form4 ,here the rough sculptor1 so ,gothic in his austerity1 fingers the marble with the care and the delicacy of a lover2 he reveals himself as a fervent adorer of smooth1 womanly flesh2 he plays with the subtlest variations of light upon the inflexion of marble surfaces1 and the man who is reproached with caring for nothing but character and with despising beauty creates arms1 necks1 knees1 and bosoms of exquisite perfection4 ,his favourite type of woman is the long1 delicately made woman1 with a small bust1 largely curved hips1 and a face full of will1 the nervous1 feline1 voluptuous woman1 of head rather than of heart1 such as ,baudelaire and ,rops have imagined4 ,the characteristic feature of ,rodin's small groups is the seeking after new combinations of movement4 ,i have said already that his essential idea was the production of dynamic art2 that is to say that1 finding himself face to face with an academic school that had grown inert owing to its care for pseudo-harmony1 he had determined to draw sculpture out of this blind alley and to show1 before all things1 how the expression of movement might lead to an entirely new conception of decorative outline4 ,from this endeavour arose those little groups of lovers in which the attitudes are so infinitely varied1 those curious presentments in which the arms and legs are placed as freely as in a painting4 ,but the painting has the help of shadow1 of backgrounds1 and of values1 which allow the light to be concentrated on a single point and the rest to be blurred4 ,rodin has attempted so to compose his most audacious movements that1 in walking round1 a new aspect of them is constantly presented1 whereas ordinary sculpture1 meant to be seen from a single point1 does not allow the spectator to pass behind it4 ,this difficulty and this main idea have led ,rodin to treat modelling and composition in a way upon which ,i shall dwell more fully later on1 and to invent a style of statuary which borrows some of the laws of painting4 ,these thoughts had long been ripening in ,rodin when at last he resolved to apply them to his ,balzac1 which was really not his first attempt in this direction1 but the first that was seen in public4 ,when this statue appeared in the ,salon of #ahih1 it created such a commotion that for a week the public forgot1 over it1 the events of that vast serial story1 the ,dreyfus affair4 ,the clamour was extraordinary2 some people raged at what they considered a scandalous practical joke1 others warmly defended the new work4 ,the ,socit des ,gens de ,lettres1 already irritated by ,rodin's delays in finishing the statue1 declared plainly that it refused the ,balzac1 a decision which led to the resignation of the committee4 ,rodin might have brought an action and won it1 for1 strictly speaking1 his agreement required the society to accept the work such as he delivered it4 ,he preferred to withdraw his work without claiming its price or discussing the matter4 ,once again his art encountered violent opposition from the official camp--but to struggle is repugnant to his temper4 ,inflexible in his will as a producer1 he is timid and proud in his attitude towards contradictions4 ,opportunity1 moreover1 offered him a roguish and witty revenge4 ,falguire was commissioned to make a ,balzac4 ,this put ,falguire in a very awkward position2 after all the fuss made about ,rodin's statue1 he must needs produce something finer1 or at the very least equally interesting4 ,he was certain of a bad reception at the hands of ,rodin's admirers and he was bound to please the others4 ,falguire only succeeded in producing a mediocre work4 ,the ,balzac that may be seen at the present time in the ,avenue de ,friedland is nothing but a half-hearted imitation of ,rodin's2 it is ,rodin's ,balzac seated1 and without character or interest4 ,this work appeared in #aijj1 at a time when opinion was already beginning to recognise the injustice done to ,rodin1 and it pleased nobody4 ,then ,rodin1 to show that the incident had in no way altered his friendly relations with ,falguire1#a made an admirable bust of his fellow-worker1 which was as fine as the second ,balzac was poor1 and thus gave to ,falguire and to the public1 also1 a silent and ironical lesson4 ,what1 then1 was this ,balzac which was so much detested1 and about which the most abusive and extraordinary things were written8 ,merely the image of the great writer1 draped in a dressing-gown1 with empty1 hanging sleeves2 he has risen in the night and is walking up and down1 disturbed and sleepless1 pursuing an idea that has suddenly presented itself4 ,he is bent forward1 his head thrown back1 the eyes deep-set1 and the mouth contracted in a smile of challenge4 ,the powerful neck--the neck indeed of a bull--emerges from the open wrapper4 ,rodin made use of various daguerreotypes1 and especially of a celebrated portrait of ,balzac1 that shows him in shirt-sleeves with one brace1 and folded arms4 ,the enormous proportions of the head1 the amazing strength of the thorax1 the monstrous and leonine character of the face are all exact4 ,his was the countenance of an element1 said ,lamartine of ,balzac1 with a torso that was joined to the head by an enormous neck1 short legs1 and short arms4 ,these words absolutely justify the statue4 ,rodin had made studies for it in the nude 7there are some fine clay models of the subject in his studio71 then he clothed it with a gown 7or to be more exact1 with a bath-wrap1 for that is what ,balzac's famous monk's robe was71 and proceeded to simplify the folds until he had left only the two or three essential ones4 ,the result thus obtained1 with the disproportion of body and legs1 led ,rodin to hide the short1 ugly1 useless arms under the drapery1 and the figure thus assumed pretty much the appearance of a mummy1 of a sort of monolith1 from which nothing stood out but the one point of interest1 the savage and magnificent animality of the head1 with its darkened gaze and the bitterly curved mouth1 of which ,rodin had made a separate small study in bronze4 ,a great heave of the shoulders throws the body slightly backward1 causing it to rest upon one leg1 which is apparently bent1 while the other is moved forward to walk4 ,illustration3 ,,balzac ,the whole work gives the impression of a menhir1 a pagan dedicatory stone4 ,interest is concentrated solely upon the head4 ,rodin considered that the representation of a celebrated figure offered no corporeal interest4 ,it is evident that a great error prevails on this subject4 ,the ancients have transmitted to us naked or draped statues4 ,it must be remembered that this homage was almost always paid to warriors1 athletes1 or courtesans2 to represent these at full length was to express their fame4 ,their beautiful shape received fit homage4 ,the gods were conceived as incarnations of moral beauty in physical beauty4 ,but as time and morality have gradually brought us to honour men who are great in thought1 the bodily representation of them has strayed into an extremely false path4 ,dress and physical exterior ceased to be of plastic interest1 but the manner of our homage remained the same4 ,busts with pedestals commemorating in writing the deeds or the works would have been the right form of celebration4 ,but this1 the only intelligent form1 appeared to our modern statue-maniac ages too scanty4 ,this heretical opinion has given birth to the gentlemen in frock-coats who disfigure our present towns and are hoisted upon pedestals in our public squares4 ,to this absurd point have we come3 in order to honour the soul we reproduce its husk1 the body1 which is destined to the nothingness of the grave1 and we represent the shoes and coats as exactly as the head4 ,we attempt in our pious regard for the essence of a thinker to represent that part of him which was transitory4 ,the result is photography in bronze1 a wretched artistic contradiction4 ,nevertheless1 if we are to bow to custom and represent a man at full length of whom the head is the only important fact1 we must indeed give him a body that is like reality2 but the artist should try to concentrate interest as much as possible on the face4 ,so illogical is this style in itself that the bodies and clothes are copied from chance models2 the head of the person to be glorified is stuck on to them1 and it is the merest bit of luck if it has been possible to shape this head itself from actual evidence6 ,for plenty of statues represent individuals who never looked like them1 and of whom no authentic likeness exists1 which is the height of absurdity and the very burlesque of an honour4#b ,illustration3 ,,balzac ,in such cases an allegorical monument should be a matter of necessity2 yet we behold hundreds of such statues1 all the same1 and our prejudice in favour of verisimilitude requires us to contemplate the embroidery of their doublets or the trimming of their coats4 ,rodin1 for his part1 to whom such ideas1 which degrade his art to the lowest level1 are revolting1 believes that composition and expression should be so arranged as to make the spectator forget the plastique of the body4 ,in his busts he neglects the inevitable linen collar1 coat-collar1 and necktie4 ,the graceful dress of ,claude ,lorraine1 the shirt and rope of ,the ,burghers of ,calais1 had served his purpose well1 and in the statues of ,general ,lynch and ,bastien-,lepage he had reduced the modern dress to large bronze reliefs without precise details4 ,especially in the image of a thinker he seeks to annul the costume4 ,the ,olympian character of ,hugo allowed of the nude2 for the massive deformity of ,balzac the dressing-gown was appropriate4 ,the majority of those who mocked did not even know that this careless costume was habitual to the author1 and that ,rodin chose to surprise him in his home and in the fever of work1 instead of showing him in the street with a hat and stick1 as they would no doubt have expected4 ,the ,balzac1 then1 presents the aspect of a sheath of stone pushed out by a few twisting folds1 which give it the appearance from behind of an upright sarcophagus4 ,the size of the head1 the abnormal largeness of the chest and neck1 which have aroused mockery1 are historic4 ,apart from these points1 one honestly wonders what it is that can have shocked people in this bold and sincere work4 ,the face is admirable in its pride1 its strength of will1 its haughty irony1 and penetrating power of thought4 ,the modelling and the leading lines are masterly4 ,the rather ghostly look of the clay disappears in the bronze1 as may be seen from the little head in that material1 of which the monument was to be made4 ,it is the freedom1 the spontaneity1 the life of the statue1 which1 as in the case of the ,burghers1 gave a shock to the conventions of the official world and disturbed the ideas of the public at large4 ,it is true1 nevertheless1 and is generally admitted even by its most active adversaries that this great figure possesses a strange haunting power2 when one had seen it in the ,salon one could see nothing else after it1 and could not succeed in getting away from it4 ,people returned to it1 in order to attack it1 but they did return to it inevitably4 ,the same official sculptors who in #ahgg had accused ,the ,age of ,brass of being cast from life because the figure was so exact did not shrink from accusing this same ,rodin1 matured by twenty years of work1 of not knowing the figure and hiding his ,balzac under a robe out of weakness4 ,besides these reproaches1 which were made in bad faith1 reproaches arose which exclaimed at ,rodin's madness or hypocritically regretted that a man of so much talent should have made so great a mistake4 ,but one thing which the ,bahac never encountered was indifference2 what was the spell which compelled everybody to regard it as an irritating puzzle1 as a challenge1 as a work out of the ordinary run8 ,plenty of hostile faces were to be seen1 but many of them showed a secret fear of being in the wrong1 of misunderstanding a fine thing1 a work which was a forerunner4 ,this same fear might have been read as early as #ahfg upon the faces of the detractors who stood in a ring around ,manet's first works4 ,the spell lay in the extreme simplification1 the reduction of the elements to a powerful unity1 according to a scheme with which ,rodin had made experiments in silence and which he now revealed4 ,and at this point ,i am led to a brief explanation of ,rodin's ideas upon the technical part of his art4 ,at the time of the ,balzac's appearance ,i gave an account of the way by which ,rodin had been led to a new conception of sculpture4 ,this was in an article#c that has been reproduced more or less everywhere1 and that ,rodin has been good enough to consider as the emanation and direct expression of his artistic wishes4 ,i cannot enter into all the details4 ,the scale of this book would not allow of that1 but the following are the principal points of that evolution4 ,rodin's is above all a temperament inclined to the expression of passionate and tragic character4 ,thence comes his constant study of movement4 ,as ,i said before1 that study has led him to give unlooked-for values to the general outline and to produce works which may be viewed on all sides and which continually show a fresh and balanced aspect that explains the other aspects3 otherwise the daring gestures and the bold combinations of the limbs would have given an air of absurdity to the groups4 ,rodin is at the same time very reflective and very instinctive4 ,he matures a thought slowly1 but he often passes by chance from that thought to its realisation4 ,this is the predominant feature of his nature1 and it explains his entire art4 ,rodin often appears unconscious1 astonished at what he had in him and at what he has brought into existence1 to such a degree that he explains it badly enough4 ,he sees his thought in the whole of nature and finds it there again2 that thought1 indeed1 is fed by general ideas1 and is1 if ,i may say so1 almost elemental4 ,from this point of view ,rodin's genius is independent of his talent as a sculptor4 ,it sometimes happens to him to see a block of marble or a knob of wood1 and the form of such an object will show him what he will make and the movement of the figure4 ,he adapts to it one of the ideas which he always has in reserve3 the aspect of the wood or the marble determines the passage of the thought to the material which will incarnate it4 ,i said one day to ,rodin3 ,one would say that you knew there was a figure in that block1 and that you do nothing beyond breaking away the stone that hides it from us4 ,he answered that that was exactly his feeling as he worked4 ,upon the naked figure ,rodin has ideas that are peculiar to his nature as a mystic and a realist4 ,he considers the body with its four limbs as a cypher1 of which the combinations are infinite4 ,that is an old idea that was held by primitive theologians of the ,eastern religions4 ,and it is the fact that ,rodin has invented an immense series of attitudes and combinations that one would not have thought possible3 he attaches little groups to the side of a block of marble with the freedom of a painter throwing a figure upon a background4 ,he makes his people light1 he makes them soar1 he entwines them in surprising positions4 ,it was therefore absolutely essential that he should find means to constitute a logical harmony on every side of his works4 ,scholastic statuary is opposed to this principle4 ,its tendency is to treat groups as bas-reliefs4 ,the spectator must stand in front1 at a certain spot1 and whatever is behind is accessory3 the decorative line produces its effect only from that point4 ,so true is this that statues are very often so placed in public squares that people cannot pass round them4 ,the academic sculptors treat a piece of sculpture like a picture2 it has a right side and a wrong side4 ,rodin1 shocked at this method1 began by working in quite a different way4 ,he made successive sketches of all the faces of his works1 going constantly round them so as to obtain a series of views connected in a ring4 ,travels in ,italy had led him to think that the ancients proceeded in this manner and that their great endeavour was to get the design of the outline by means of movement1 which continually modifies the anatomy4 ,anatomy1 indispensable to the artist1 becomes the source of all the academic errors if once we forget that it is but inertia1 the state of non-action1 and consequently incapable of expressly teaching us about life and about the modifications that thought imposes upon flesh4 ,the real value of a living figure is given by profiles studied successively in a full light4 ,rodin was delighted by this way of working4 ,but his pictorial inclinations1 his ideas about the possible formation of a background in sculpture as in painting1 were not satisfied4 ,when the academic school wishes to make use of a background to a figure it confines itself to a hollow or a relief4 ,rodin desired that a statue should stand free and should bear looking at from any point1 but he desired nevertheless that it should remain in relation with light and with the surrounding atmosphere4 ,he was struck by the hard1 cut-out aspect of ordinary statues1 and asked himself how an atmosphere might be given to them4 ,painting has two means to this end3 of which the first is values4 ,values are independent of colour4 ,values1 an element common to both arts1 are in painting and sculpture the relations as to opacity or transparence of an object and the background against which it is seen4 ,they may be dark on a light ground1 light on a dark ground1 or light upon a ground that is likewise light2 but they are always the very life of the outline1 and the important point is to fix that outline first of all4 ,when we see a person placed between the sun and ourselves1 against the light1 we do not at first perceive the details within the outline1 but we do see the general mass of the body1 and that mass is filled with more or less intense colour1 in which we presently distinguish details4 ,our perception at the moment is as much sculptural as pictorial4 ,rodin1 struck by the importance of this idea1 devoted himself to obtaining1 at once and together1 the volume2 that is to say1 the equivalent in sculpture of the value1 and the design of successive views of one movement4 ,but the second means in painting is the employment of intermediate tones encircling the figure and combining with the background4 ,how could an equivalent be found for that8 ,logic led ,rodin on to a step which alarmed him3 he made experiments after examining the antiques very closely4 ,he took fragments of his statues and began to raise them in certain places by layers of clay1 intensifying the modelling and enlarging the lines4 ,he observed that the light now played better upon these enlarged lines2 the refraction of light upon these amplified surfaces was softer1 the hardness of the cut-out outline vanished1 and a radiant zone shaped itself around his figures and united them gradually with the atmosphere4 ,in this way1 therefore1 by means of this systematic accentuation of the outlines1 an intermediate tone1 a radiancy of the forms1 was produced4 ,rodin understood at once that he had found his way to the deepest secret of his art2 that is to say1 to the ideal limit where through its hidden laws a plastic art touches the other arts in a negation of all that is merely materialistic4 ,the intermediate tones in painting1 the radiating surfaces in sculpture1 are the same principle as the nervous radiations noted in photographing a hand1 where it may be seen that the fingers are prolonged by emanations4 ,nothing is fixed1 limited1 or finished in nature1 and the radiating state is the only real one4 ,but this was a dangerous discovery for a sculptor1 since people would immediately exclaim upon the deformation of what was seen1 the alteration of the fact1 the falsification of anatomy4 ,therefore ,rodin proceeded in silence and with very great prudence4 ,the point was not1 of course1 to enlarge all surfaces equally1 for that would have produced only an increase of scale4 ,the thing was to amplify1 with tact1 certain parts of the modelling1 the edges of which were swept by the light1 so as to give a halo to the outline4 ,at the same time1 ,rodin experimented in a series of drawings made on purpose1 forbidding himself to give any detail1 tracing only the outlines of bodies filled in with one wash of water-colour that gave the value4 ,i shall return to these sketches4 ,they cannot be understood without a knowledge of their original purpose4 ,this theory1 to which ,rodin approved of my giving the name of deliberate amplification of surfaces1 is simply the critical principle of ,greek sculpture1 which has been entirely misunderstood by the academic school4 ,that school1 which is supposed to honour the ,greeks1 is really false to their spirit and their teaching4 ,moreover1 this principle1 which belongs to all the primitive statuary that was made for the open air1 is to be found among the ,egyptians and the ,assyrians4 ,it calls in question the academic tradition whereby exactitude is confounded with truth4 ,in reality it may be said to be a profoundly classic principle which has been denied by the academic school4 ,here1 as in painting1 classicism is opposed to the academic4 ,hence it should be concluded that in reality ,rodin is by no means an innovator opposing himself to a school that retains classic traditions1 but1 speaking precisely1 a classic1 returning to nature1 replacing himself in the state of mind of a ,greek before his model1 and opposing himself to a school that has overloaded art with methods1 formulas1 and expedients that change the character of antique and ,gothic art4 ,rodin has a horror of what is called originality1 and an even greater horror of what is called inspiration4 ,he only trusts completely to work and to minute1 sincere observation of nature4 ,slowness is a beauty1 he often says4 ,he has the greatest antipathy for sculpture with literary meanings1 and has often been galled1 without saying so1 by certain praises1 in which writers1 reeling off pages of description about his works1 have thought to please him by dwelling on the idea and not on the execution4 ,i invent nothing1 he says2 ,i rediscover4 ,and the thing seems new because people have generally lost sight of the aim and the means of art2 they take that for an innovation which is nothing but a return to the laws of the great sculpture of long ago4 ,obviously1 ,i think2 ,i like certain symbols1 ,i see things in a synthetic way1 but it is nature that gives me all that4 ,i do not imitate the ,greeks2 ,i try to put myself in the spiritual state of the men who have left us the antique statues4 ,the 'cole' copies their works2 the thing that signifies is to recover their method4 ,i began by showing close studies from nature like ,the ,age of ,brass4 ,afterwards ,i came to understand that art required a little more largeness1 a little exaggeration1 and my whole aim1 from the time of the ,burghers1 was to find a method of exaggerating logically3 that method consists in the deliberate amplification of the modelling4 ,it consists also in the constant reduction of the figure to a geometrical figure1 and in the determination to sacrifice any part of a figure to the synthesis of its aspect4 ,see what the ,gothic sculptors did4 ,look at the cathedral of ,chartres2 one of the towers is massive and without ornament3 they sacrificed it to give value to the exquisite delicacy of the other tower4 ,in sculpture the projection of the muscular fasciculi must be accentuated1 the foreshortening forced1 the hollows deepened2 sculpture is the art of the hole and the lump1 not of clear1 well-smoothed1 unmodelled figures4 ,ignorant people1 when they see close-knitted true surfaces1 say that 'it is not finished4' ,no notion is falser than that of finish unless it be that of elegance2 by means of these two ideas people would kill our art4 ,the way to obtain solidity and life is by work carried out to the fullest1 not in the direction of achievement and of copying details1 but in that of truth in the successive schemes4 ,the public1 perverted by academic prejudices1 confounds art with neatness4 ,the simplicity of the 'cole' is a painted cardboard ideal4 ,a cast from life is a copy1 the exactest possible copy1 and yet it has neither motion nor eloquence4 ,art intervenes to exaggerate certain surfaces1 and also to fine down others4 ,in sculpture everything depends upon the way in which the modelling is carried out with a constant thought of the main line of the scheme1 upon the rendering of the hollows1 of the projections and of their connections2 thus it is that one may get fine lights1 and especially fine shadows that are not opaque4 ,everything should be emphasised according to the accent that it is desired to render1 and the degree of amplification is personal1 according to the tact and the temperament of each sculptor2 and for this reason there is no transmissible process1 no studio recipe1 but only a true law4 ,i see it in the antique and in ,michael ,angelo4 ,to work by the profiles1 in depth not by surfaces1 always thinking of the few geometrical forms from which all nature proceeds1 and to make these eternal forms perceptible in the individual case of the object studied1 that is my criterion4 ,that is not idealism1 it is a part of the handicraft4 ,my ideas have nothing to do with it but for that method2 my ,danaids and my ,dante figures would be weak1 bad things4 ,from the large design that ,i get your mind deduces ideas4 ,rodin1 then1 is convinced that he is classical1 and rebels against the cole which claims to be so4 ,he has the greatest admiration for the ,renascence1 but declares that he does not so clearly understand the genius of the ,gothic sculptors4 ,he admires it1 but has not thoroughly penetrated it4 ,i feel it1 but ,i cannot express it1 he says4 ,i cannot analyse the ,celtic genius to my own satisfaction4 ,in the ,middle ,ages art came from groups1 not from individuals4 ,it was anonymous2 the sculptors of cathedrals no more put their names to their works than our workmen put theirs on the pavement that they lay4 ,ah6 what an admirable scorn of notoriety6 ,the signature is what destroys us4 ,we do portraits1 but what we do is not so great4 ,these kings and queens1 on the cathedrals1 were not portraits4 ,the fellow-workers stood for one another1 and they interpreted2 they did not copy4 ,they made clothed figures2 the nude and portraiture only date from the ,renascence4 ,and then those fellows cut with the tool's end into the block1 that is why they were called sculptors4 ,as for us1 we are modellers4 ,and what a disgraceful thing that casting from life is1 which so many well-known sculptors do not blush to use6 ,it is a mere swindling in art4 ,art was a vital function to the image-makers of the thirteenth century2 they would have laughed at the idea of signing what they did1 and never dreamed of honours and titles4 ,when once their work was finished1 they said no more about it1 or else they talked among themselves4 ,how curious it would have been to hear them1 to be present at their gatherings1 where they must have discussed in amusing phrases1 and with simple1 deep ideas6444 ,whenever the cathedrals disappear civilisation will go down one step4 ,and even now we no longer understand them1 we no longer know how to read their silent language4 ,we need to make excavations not in the earth1 but towards heaven4444 ,an admirable saying that ,rodin has often repeated to me and that ,i have never heard without deep emotion6 ,he has the secret of these true formulas1 and his words1 which are not eloquent1 but1 rather1 obscure1 are suddenly lighted up by them4 ,his speech1 like his sculpture1 is born from sincere contact with the essence of nature4 ,in regard to the ,renascence and ,michael ,angelo1 he reports that he received no decisive lesson from either until after a journey to ,italy in #ahge4 ,i believed before that1 he says1 that movement was the whole secret of this art1 and ,i put my models into positions like those of ,michael ,angelo4 ,but as ,i went on observing the free attitudes of my models ,i perceived that they possessed these naturally1 and that ,michael ,angelo had not preconceived them1 but merely transcribed them according to the personal inspiration of human beings moved by the need of action4 ,i went to ,rome to look for what may be found everywhere3 the latent heroic in every natural movement4 #d ,then ,i gathered the elements of what people call my symbolism4 ,i do not understand anything about long words and theories4 ,but ,i am willing to be a symbolist1 if that defines the ideas that ,michael ,angelo gave me1 namely that the essence of sculpture is the modelling1 the general scheme which alone enables us to render the intensity1 the supple variety of movement and character4 ,if we can imagine the thought of ,god in creating the world1 ,he thought first of the construction1 which is the sole principle of nature1 of living things and perhaps of the planets4 ,michael ,angelo seems to me rather to derive from ,donatello than from the ancients2 ,raphael proceeds from them4 ,he understood that an architecture can be built up with the human body1 and that1 in order to possess volume and harmony1 a statue or a group ought to be contained in a cube1 a pyramid2 or some simple figure4 ,let us look at a ,dutch interior and at an interior painted by an artist of the present day4 ,the latter no longer touches us1 because it does not possess the qualities of depth and volume1 the science of distances4 ,the artist who paints it does not know how to reproduce a cube4 ,an interior by ,van der ,meer is a cubic painting4 ,the atmosphere is in it and the exact volume of the objects2 the place of these objects has been respected1 the modern painter places them1 arranges them as models4 ,the ,dutchmen did not touch them1 but set themselves to render the distances that separated them1 that is1 the depth4 ,and then1 if ,i go so far as to say that cubic truth1 not appearance1 is the mistress of things1 if ,i add that the sight of the plains and woods and country views gives me the principle of the plans that ,i employ on my statues1 that ,i feel cubic truth everywhere1 and that plan and volume appear to me as laws of all life and all beauty1 will it be said that ,i am a symbolist1 that ,i generalise1 that ,i am a metaphysician8 ,it seems to me that ,i have remained a sculptor and a realist4 ,unity oppresses and haunts me4 ,what1 says ,rodin again1 is the principle of my figures1 and what is it that people like in them8 ,it is the very pivot of art1 it is balance2 that is to say1 the oppositions of volume produced by movement4 ,that is the striking1 material fact in art1 with all due deference to those persons who conceive art as distinct from 'brutal' reality4 ,art is like love4 ,for many people it is a dream1 a psychological complication1 a palace1 a perfume1 a stage scene2 but nothing of the sort6 ,the essential of love is the pairing2 all the rest is only detail1 charming1 and full of passion1 but detail4 ,it is the same in art3 people come and praise my symbols and my expressions to me2 but ,i know that the plans are the essential thing4 ,respect the plan1 make it exact from every point2 movement intervenes1 displaces these volumes and creates a fresh balance4 ,the human body is like a walking temple1 and like a temple it has a central point around which the volumes place and spread themselves4 ,when one understands that1 one has everything4 ,it is simple1 but it must be seen1 and academism refuses to see it4 ,instead of recognising that that is the key to my method they prefer to say that ,i am a poet4 ,that expression signifies that people feel1 confusedly1 the difference between an art resting on conventions and one derived from truth2 only they think that the 'poetic' art is the conventional one4 ,they call that inspiration4 ,that is the belief that has led to the theory of genius being madness4 ,but men of genius are just those who1 by their trade-skill1 carry the essential thing to perfection4 ,people say that my sculpture is that of an 'exalt4'#e ,i do not deny that there is exaltation in my works2 but that exaltation existed not in me1 but in nature1 in movement4 ,the divine work is naturally exalted4 ,as for me1 all ,i do is to be true2 my temperament is not 'exalted'2 it is patient4 ,i am not a dreamer1 but a mathematician2 and if my sculpture is good it is because it is geometrical4 ,from these fragments of conversation the reader will conceive how ,rodin's generalising spirit leads him from the realism of his daily work to the synthesis of a sort of ideo-realistic metaphysical system4 ,he has the sense 7belonging only to genius7 of the continuity of the universe1 and he certainly had it at a time when1 unlettered as he was1 he would not have known how to explain it specifically to himself4 ,he constantly formulates this metaphysical system1 as ,i have seen it formulated by ,stphane ,mallarm1 who could never see anything without instantly bringing together two ideas or images that no one would ever have thought of connecting4 ,spontaneous analogy is the mark of genius and the secret of all real poetry4 ,this is why ,i consider ,rodin as a very great poet--not in the sense that he dislikes1 but on the contrary1 by giving to the word poet its deep etymological significance according to the ,greek1 that of making1 creating1 vivifying4 ,we may understand1 too1 in how great a degree an intellectuality of this kind offers a living challenge to the ideas of the cole4 ,the man who thinks thus is necessarily isolated and has struggled all his life1 never making a concession and saying nobly1 ,the artist1 like the woman1 has an honour to preserve4 ,i will further quote from ,rodin the following reflection#f3 ,where you follow nature1 you get everything4 ,when ,i have a beautiful woman's body for a model the drawings that ,i make from it give me images of insects1 birds1 and fishes4 ,that seems improbable1 and ,i had no suspicion of it myself4 ,formerly ,i used to be seeking shapes for vases1 either to use them at ,svres1 where ,i used to work1 or elsewhere4444 ,i never succeeding in finding a beauty of proportions and lines such as ,i had the feeling of1 because ,i only founded my attempts upon imagination4 ,since that time ,i have drawn women's bodies1 and one of these bodies gave me1 in the synthesis of it1 a magnificent shape for a vase1 with true and harmonious lines4 ,the point is not to create4 ,creation and improvisation are useless words4 ,genius only comes to the man who understands with his eye and his brain4 ,everything is in the things about us4 ,manufacture and ornamental art want reforming according to these ideas4 ,i should have liked to see that4 ,everything-is contained in nature4 ,there is an harmonious1 continual1 uninterrupted movement4 ,a woman1 a mountain1 a horse1 in conception they are all the same thing1 they are made on the same principles4 ,young artists compose instead of following their models and understanding that therein lies infinity4 ,here ,rodin directly touches a scientific truth--the relative monotony of ,nature's productive forms4 ,nature does everything with very few forms3 the variations are so infinite that there are no two leaves alike1 but the nerves of a leaf1 the lines of a vein1 an artery1 a bird's wing1 a fishbone1 a nerve-cell1 are identical2 multiplicity derives from identity and returns to it1 so that everything is reduced to a fundamental geometry which perhaps is but the effect of a single cellular generation4 ,in this respect the laws of art and of science are the same1 even as among all the arts there is a synthesis of common laws1 an identity where we seem to behold a difference4 ,recent work in science1 by establishing the existence of states of radiation 7,crookes1 ,rntgen1 ,hertz7 is busy undermining our old conception of matter1 showing us the identity of it with the immaterial1 and thereby abolishing our preconceptions about the idea and the fact1 music and sculpture1 considered as different manifestations4 ,i remember that ,i one day kept ,rodin's curiosity excited for a long time by explaining the details of this theory to him2 he was not acquainted with it1 and listened to me as to a writer in love with general ideas4 ,but it was clear that in his mere province as a sculptor he knew far better and had penetrated far more deeply into this enthralling problem of identity4 ,his is a luminous mind1 of the same kind as the electric rays2 it rather penetrates than surrounds what is obscure to it4 ,on that day he was disturbed1 and ,i was irritated by certain declamations which had been written about his philosophy1 and of which the author had assuredly not comprehended the logical consequences2 and we came to the conclusion that it would be much better for ,rodin's peace of mind to keep silent upon these points1 for his philosophy could only be made comprehensible to those who could understand the method of his sculpture4 ,it is time1 however1 to pause in this path and to return simply to the question of sculpture4 ,nor was it my purpose to tire the reader by these abstractions when ,i began to say a few words about ,rodin's opinions concerning the antique4 ,it must be understood1 then1 that the ,balzac and even the ,hugo1 as well as some figures1 were the result of all these preceding reflections4 ,when ,i saw my ,balzac brought into the yard from the storehouse of the statues in order to go to the ,salon1 says ,rodin1 ,i had it purposely placed beside ,the ,kiss1 which had been finished rather earlier4 ,i was not dissatisfied with the simplified vigour of that group1 to which ,i had already applied these experiments4 ,but ,i saw that it looked slack1 that it did not hold its place beside the ,balzac as ,michael ,angelo's torso does beside a fine antique1 and then ,i understood that ,i was in the right path4 ,i have had hesitations1 you know1 pangs that ,i do not speak of4 ,and then1 little by little1 as ,i looked at nature1 as ,i came to understand it better and to throw aside my prejudices more frankly1 ,i took courage4 ,it seemed to me that ,i was doing better4 ,when ,i began ,i did skilful things1 things that were smartly done1 but they were thin and dry1 but ,i felt there was something beyond1 and that something is amplification4 ,i only ventured on it when ,i was over fifty years old1 but do you not think ,i have a right now to disregard the objections of the mob and the newspapers8 ,i have taken time to know why ,i was doing as ,i did4 ,the essential things of my modelling are there1 and they would be there in less degree if ,i 'finished' more4 ,as to polishing or repolishing a toe or a curl1 ,i find no interest in it2 it impairs the large line1 the soul of what ,i desired to do1 and ,i have nothing more to say to the public on that point4 ,there the line of demarcation comes between the confidence that the public ought to have in me and the concessions that ,i ought not to make to the public4 ,to this firm and discreet resolution ,rodin has kept in all the works wrought out by him since #ahih4 ,illustration3 ,,primitive ,,man4 ,i cannot better set forth his opinions about the antique than by quoting the following fragments from two articles that he wrote for the ,muse1 a review of ancient art1 in ,january and ,february1 #aijd2 for ,rodin sometimes writes1 quite unpretentiously1 but with the same lucidity of thought that he shows in his familiar conversation4 ,one of these articles refers to a ,greek statuette in the ,museum of ,naples1 the other to the lesson that the ancients give us4 ,in the first place1 the ,antique is ,life itself4 ,nothing is more alive1 and no style in the world has rendered life as it has4 ,the ancients were the greatest1 most serious1 and most admirable observers of nature who have ever existed4 ,the antique was able to render life because the ancients saw the essential thing in it--large blocks4 ,they confined themselves to the large shadows cast by these large blocks1 and as truth itself lies in that1 their figures being so made could never be feeble4 ,moreover1 the antique is simple1 and that gives it astonishing energy4 ,and then there is much more study in it than appears2 that was brought home to me once4 ,when ,i had finished my ,age of ,brass1 ,i went to ,italy and ,i found an ,apollo whose leg was in exactly the same position as one in ,the ,age of ,brass that had taken me six months' work4 ,then ,i saw that though on the surface everything seems to be done at a stroke1 in reality all the muscles are built up and one sees the details come to light one by one4 ,that is because the ancients studied everything in its successive profiles1 because in any figure and every part of a figure no profile is like another2 when each has been studied separately the whole appears simple and alive4 ,the great error of the neo-,greek school is really this3 it is not type that is antique1 but modelling4 ,for want of having understood that1 the neo-,greek school has produced nothing but papier-mch4 ,it is bad to put the antique before beginners2 one should end1 not begin with it4 ,if you wanted to teach someone to eat1 you would give him fresh food1 that he might learn to chew2 it would never occur to you to give him food already triturated to exercise his teeth upon4 ,well1 when you want to teach sculpture to anyone1 set him face to face with nature1 and when he has gained plenty of power to deal with nature1 then say to him3 ',now1 here is what the antique has done4' ,and that will give him a new source of energy4 ,whereas if you give the antique to the beginner who has never struggled with nature1 he does not understand anything about it1 and loses his individuality over it4 ,you make a plagiarist of him1 and instead of making his own prayer to nature he will repeat the prayer of the antique without understanding the words of it4 ,he will die an old pupil2 he will not die a man4 ,to teach the antique at the outset of a man's studies is to render the antique incomprehensible4 ,in the first place1 no one can teach the antique1 it is not possible2 that art of truth and simplicity cannot be taught4 ,the sculptor works from nature1 and afterwards he goes to look1 in the galleries1 and see how the antique rendered what he has been trying for from the life4 ,but if he goes straight to the antique1 shutting his eyes to nature1 as the antique has always been done from nature1 our sculptor will only be able to carry that vision into his own work in a factitious way2 he will be neither antique nor modern1 but bad4 ,a man may do antique work in our day1 not in the false sense of producing the antique type1 but in the true sense of modelling like the antique4 ,such a man 7painter1 etcher1 or sculptor7 will take nature1 and if he has the power of the antique he will produce antique work1 which will entirely disagree with what is taught as such1 but will agree with that in the museums4 ,the 'cole' begins at the end2 when a man begins with nature1 he may go on to the most improbable inventions2 the antiques themselves show that4 ,do you know of anything more impossible than the centaur8 ,but is there anything finer in ,olympia8 ,the ancients knew nature so well that they became her fellow-workers and created1 not phantoms1 but beings that were alive in spite of physical impossibilities4 ,to my mind it would be better not to study the antique than to study it wrong4 ,it is not the artist's alphabet1 but the reward of his work4 ,the command which it gives us is not to copy it1 but to do like it4 ,illustration3 ,,young ,,woman ,,between ,,good ,,and ,,evil ,,council4 ,to say that the antiques1 which portray the plain marvel of life1 are beautiful is a superficial sort of praise4 ,beauty is not the starting-point1 but the point of arrival2 a thing can only be beautiful if it is true4 ,truth itself is only a complete harmony1 and harmony is finally only a bundle of utilities4 ,the miracle of life could not be perpetuated but for the constant renewal of universal balance4 ,the ancients felt that vast rhythm1 and their art1 being modelled upon it1 appears to us as a natural and sublime expression of beauty4444 ,one of the ancients made a statue4 ,how did he set about it8 ,it is useless to bring in rules that only grew up in the brains of commentators dissecting a series of works1 centuries afterwards4 ,the antique remains uncomprehended because we have not a simple enough spirit4 ,it is not by studying the antique that we shall learn its secret2 in order to understand1 not its nomenclature1 but its spirit1 we must begin by studying nature4 ,rembrandt cannot be understood by copying him at the ,louvre1 he can only be understood when we travel through nature to him4 ,well1 nature is always there1 waiting patiently for antiques to be made afresh2 the model is there waiting for someone to come at last1 no matter whence4 ,for it is an error to think the antique comes from the south3 it comes from everywhere4 ,the antique can be produced from a ,dutch woman or an ,american woman2 the type is nothing1 the modelling is everything4 ,what makes the strength of the antique is the plan1 the connection of all the profiles4 ,the neo-,greeks say3 ',the antiques are line1 and their works1 in which all the lines1 except two1 dance about1 show their error4 ,the antiques1 we will say1 are lines or rather plan4 ,look at an antique2 you can guess the full face from the profile4 ,the eye cannot grasp the shape on the opposite side to that which it beholds1 but it deduces it from this side3 walk round1 and the study of the profiles will afford you an irrefragable proof by rule of three4 ,the sculptor swells the half-tones by slight exaggerations1 so as to heighten the light by a tone4 ,the drapery lives2 like the body that it hides1 it receives life from that body without needing the subterfuge of wetted drapery4'#g ,there is in the antiques an astonishing mystery of life which causes all idea of dimension to disappear4 ,a figure an inch or two high might just as well be life-size2 when a thing is well organised1 the greatness is in the modelling and not in the size4 ,if one were to photograph a ,tanagra figure and the ,eiffel ,tower1 and were to show the two photographs to some person unacquainted with either object1 ,i am sure he would declare the ,tanagra figure to be larger than the tower4 ,a pear or an apple1 from the point of view of modelling1 is as large as the celestial sphere4 ,thus the splendour of truth is such that finding no word to render it1 we have called it ',ideal4' ,these quotations will suffice1 ,i hope1 to show ,rodin's inmost thought4 ,these judgments are implicit condemnations of the cole2 they are also definitions of his classical art1 which is by no means literary1 and which is governed1 even in its lyrical and tragic developments1 by good sense1 that is to say1 by an inborn taste for balance in the midst of boldness4 ,if ,i am anxious to insist so strongly upon ,rodin's profound normality1 this is1 ,i repeat1 in order to forewarn the public against the declamations of some of his untoward admirers1 who reckon one of his merits to be an originality which they confound with that exaggeration1 that emphasis and eccentricity that never mark the great artist4 ,whatever tragic or passionate subject a great artist may treat1 to whatever height of strangeness his imagination may rise1 beauty of form will1 if he is1 like ,rodin1 a master of technique1 confer upon t him an exalted and permanent serenity4 ,rembrandt and ,delacroix come from the depth of their vastly differing worlds to meet ,raphael and ,watteau in that conciliatory region where we admire the great masters--and ,rodin is already placed in that region4 #a ,rodin has never forgotten ,falguire's loyalty at the time of ,the ,age of ,brass affair4 #b ,a recent example in ,paris is the double statue of the chemists who invented quinine4 ,when will people understand that a discovery of this kind1 however honourable1 is nevertheless quite incapable of being associated with any plastic idea8 ,the same thing is true of the statues of ,chappe and ,lavoisier1 flanked by instruments of telegraphy and chemistry4 ,these are ridiculous signboards1 melancholy compliments translated by a tradesman's art that renders our streets hideous4 #c ,revue des ,revues 7of ,paris71 ,june #aeth1 #ahih4 #d ,i find myself underlining-3 it is not ,rodin whose voice makes this emphasis4 ,but ,i am attempting to mark out in this way the formulas which spring up in his conversation1 and which1 collected together1 will give the public an idea of his instinctive synthesis1 deduced from life4 #e ,the word exalt has in this use no precise equivalent in ,english4 ,enthusiast1 as the eighteenth century knew the word--that is1 with the infusion of a touch of lunacy--conies perhaps nearest4--,,trans4 #f ,an observation noted by ,mlle4 ,judith ,cladel in her curious volume1 ,rodin1 drawn from life4 7ditions de ,la ,plume1 #aijc47 #g ,loe ,fuller has obtained1 by means of stuffs not wetted1 the effects that the 'cole' loves1 because her plastic dance is logically derived from nature4 ,,iv ,,works ,,since ,,the ,,balzac--,,small ,,works ,,in ,,marble--,,plan ,,of ,,the ,,monument ,,to ,,labour--,,drawings ,,and ,,etchings ,i shun father and mother and wife and brother1 when my genius calls me4 ,i would write on the lintels of the door-post1 ,whim4 ,i hope it is somewhat better than whim at last1 but we cannot spend the day in explanation4444 ,whoso would be a man must be a nonconformist 444 must not be hindered by the name of goodness1 but must inquire if it be goodness4 ,nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of our own mind4 ,absolve you to yourself1 and you shall have the suffrage of the world4 ,i quoted these high-minded words of ,emerson's to ,rodin at the time of the ,balzac incident4 ,they are1 ,i said to him1 the very epigraph of your whole life4 ,nor have they ceased to epitomise the man and the artist4 ,from the time of the ,balzac ,rodin's work has proceeded very regularly and on the same principles4 ,the ,victor ,hugo is being finished in marble1 in its two versions1 in the studio of the ,rue de l',universit4 ,the group in which ,hugo1 his extended arm commanding silence of the waves1 sits surrounded by ,muses is almost ready2 the other1 in which ,hugo1 dreamily listening to the counsels of ,iris1 stands on the edge of a rock washed by waves1 amid which ,nereids are entwined1 is not quite so far advanced4 ,the ,gate of ,hell is ready to receive its finally chosen and ordered figures4 ,in the ,salon of #aijb ,rodin exhibited the three ,shades from its summit1 inspired by the celebrated ,lasciate ogni speransa4 ,in #aijj ,rodin only showed two or three old productions at the ,universal ,exhibition1 because his work was collected in a special pavilion at the ,rond-point de l',alma1 the concession of which pavilion was made uncomfortable for him by his colleagues1 so much so that the artist was obliged to remove on the very day of closing1 with less delay and consideration allowed to him than to the most unimportant industrial exhibitor4 ,this special exhibition was1 nevertheless1 a great international success for ,rodin1 and the amazing development of his fame may be said to date from it4 ,before #aijj ,rodin stood in the position of an exceptional artist1 celebrated but envied1 isolated and challenged1 whose relations with the ,government were strained1 whom a minority upheld1 but on whom the official world looked coldly4 ,since that time his eminence is so firmly established that he now holds the rank that ,puvis de ,chavannes held in the estimation of all artists4 ,his triumphant journey to ,prague 7#aija-b71 ,london's enthusiastic reception1 and ,rodin's recent election to be ,president of the ,society over which ,whistler presided1 have finally given him the acknowledgment so long looked for4 ,in #aijc his marble bust of ,hugo aroused enthusiasm1 and at the ,salon of #aijd the colossal bronze ,thinker had a most flattering reception1 and disarmed the last of his former detractors4 ,a woman's bust accompanied ,the ,thinker to the ,salon4 ,rodin1 who does portraits now and again1 had previously made an admirable one of ,mme4 ,fenaille1 wife of the art-patron who had been of such great service to him2 and he is attempting a curious variation of it4 ,he has just finished a bust of a helmeted ,minerva1 as impressive as a ,donatello1 and this1 too1 is a portrait4 ,various works have been produced by ,rodin since the ,balzac1 in addition to the ,monument of ,president ,sarmiento1 which shows an admirable bas-relief of a radiant ,apollo4 ,these works are nearly all in marble1 and small4 ,it is almost impossible to describe and classify them2 a much larger book would be required1 and my main purpose here has been to give a general idea of ,rodin's art and an explanation of principles4 ,i have spoken about some of his poems of the flesh1 especially that ,eternal ,idol1 which will be the glory of thought in modern sculpture4 ,rodin's recent works in marble have the same inspiration4 ,some demand special notice3 ,the ,hand of ,god1 a gigantic hand1 between the fingers of which1 and amid a handful of clay1 two beings are tenderly embracing2 ,icarus1 falling from the sky to be crushed on the earth amid his whirling wings2 several groups of lovers1 entwined1 and breathing immeasurable tenderness1 the most celebrated of which is ,spring or ,love and ,psyche4 ,another ,psyche1 alone1 is discovering ,love asleep1 with extraordinary restrained emotion2 and there are several attempts at ,poets and ,muses1 embracing or consoling one another1 as well as a splendid sketch of the ,magdalen wiping ,christ's ,body with her ,hair4 ,rodin has thus sometimes touched religious subjects1 but with an undogmatic symbolism1 philosophic and wide4 ,we may also enumerate another version in marble of the ,nereids of the ,hugo monument1 a winged ,inspiration coming to breathe upon the sleeping poet1 and holding back the tips of her wings with one hand lest she should make a sound in closing them2 a faun drawing towards him a nymph1 who struggles in silent1 fierce resistance2 two high-reliefs of ,summer and ,autumn in stone2 tall women with children1 intended for the town of ,evian1 where ,baron ,vitta is accumulating treasures of modern art2 ,pygmalion beholding his statue come to life1 who1 as soon as she feels herself live1 turns from him with a surprising movement of coquetry and aversion4 ,such works as these cannot be described in words4 ,in them ,rodin has excelled to an unparalleled degree in rendering the profoundest psychological complexities1 refined intentions1 and the hesitations of feeling4 ,i will further note a sketch of ,sappho1 seated at rest1 with her arms leaning upon two little naked women1 which is a work inspired equally by the ,greeks and by the eighteenth century2 it bears witness to the artist's wish of avoiding the massive1 and making as many holes as possible within the general block1 so as to give lightness and to allow a circulation of light1 as the ,greeks did in works that were meant to stand against a background of sea or of sky4 ,many studies of men and women crouching1 or squatting1 in curious attitudes1 recall the art of the ,japanese bronzes1 which ,rodin immensely admires4 ,we must further note some groups of ,women ,damned1 in which ,rodin's art attains the highest point of voluptuous tension1 audacious suggestiveness1 and tragic eagerness of the flesh aspiring to impossible delight4 ,this whole world of figures is ruled by the same lyrical and poetic imagination1 the same symbolism incarnated in impeccable forms4 ,everywhere we find the same nervous art1 agitating1 sad1 and ardent in its voluptuous character1 expressing the insatiability of human souls2 the aspiration of a troubled time towards an ideality which would deliver it from the solicitations of pessimism2 the hope of escape by the way of desire2 and love sought for in the over-excitement of neurosis4 ,rodin1 gloomy psychologist of passion1 understands the disease of the age1 and at the same time pities it2 a true thinker1 he extracts its mournful beauty without ceasing to retain faith1 admiration1 and affection for the human creature4 ,bending over life and over his work1 he is himself his own ,thinker1 attentive and reverent before an unknown and terrible divinity4 ,never did any other sculptor attempt to vivify his art with such intellectual superiority and by such meditations1 and ,rodin is at once the most realistic and most metaphysical of poets in stone and bronze4 ,illustration3 ,,isis ,two or three works of more important dimensions stand out from his recent productions2 besides a nude female torso 7in bronze7 of startling truthfulness1 and two plaster studies that astonished at the ,salons1 and besides ,the ,christian ,martyr1 so masterly in its modelling1 ,rodin has continued to work at his ,ugolino1 taken out of ,the ,gate of ,hell1 and has put the finishing touch to two plans4 ,one of these is the ,monument to ,labour1 a grand conception1 which one may dream of seeing carried out and rising up in some square of busy ,paris1 but which want of money will prevent from ever being realised4 ,it is a column upon a vast rectangular base1 with a crypt in it4 ,two colossal figures of ,night and ,day would stand at the entrance4 ,in the crypt would be shown1 in bas-relief1 different subterranean works--mining1 etc4 ,around the column would run a covered spiral staircase1 and upon the column itself would be figured in bas-reliefs all the various manifestations of labour1 so that as one ascended the stairs all the divers phases of human genius could be successively studied4 ,on the top would hover the ,benedictions1 two--winged spirits1 descended from heaven1 which are already executed in marble on a small scale1 and are among ,rodin's finest conceptions4 ,this colossal project was conceived as long ago as #ahig4 ,the rough model is in the studio at ,meudon-,val-,fleury4 ,illustration3 ,,nude ,,study ,the monument to ,puvis de ,chavannes was entrusted to his friend ,rodin1 and is already finished4 ,rodin conceived it in an original and charming way4 ,instead of making the customary statue1 he considered the purely ,greek quality of ,puvis' genius and chose to pay homage to him in a form reproduced from the antique4 ,the bust of the great painter is placed on a plain table1 as the ancients placed those of their dead upon little domestic altars4 ,a fine tree loaded with fruit bends over and shades the head4 ,leaning on the table behind the bust is a beautiful naked youth1 who sits dreaming in a well-chosen supple attitude4 ,the whole design is intimate1 gentle1 and pure4 ,placed on the ground in a garden this votive monument would show how much delicacy and caressing lightness sometimes lies in ,rodin's sombre and pathetic thoughts4 ,another important group is that of ,orpheus and ,eurydice4 ,orpheus has fallen on one knee and is lifting his great lyre towards the gods whom he has just implored4 ,above him1 almost on his back1 suspended in a way that would appear to contradict the laws of equilibrium and the material conditions of sculpture1 soars ,eurydice1 compassionate and almost vaporous1 truly an immaterial shade1 with a smile of despair4 ,i regret that the unfinished condition of this model does not allow me to publish a photograph of it1 for nothing would give a clearer impression of ,rodin's originality in the matter of contour and in the mutual relation of figures4 ,the extreme freedom of his attitudes and his caprices of balance are1 indeed1 the newest features that he has brought into his art and are not to be found in anyone else in any country or time4 ,in these is his true signature1 and by them his work might be recognised among a hundred statues of all periods4 ,as to the expressive beauty of the faces and bodies1 that is supreme4 ,no one has better comprehended than ,rodin all that can be rendered by the naked human body and all the intellectual significations that it can hide4 ,the nude is to ,rodin a whole language4 ,in his latest spiritualised works there is something ,correggio-like in the vibration of light upon the softened forms and amplified surfaces4 ,they suggest the ,antiope1 at once soft and muscular1 and ,rodin often speaks of morbidezza as a quality which he no longer distrusts1 whereas he formerly banished it from his ascetic1 sinewy1 and dry figures4 ,he gives his women the pulpy flesh of fruits4 ,the lines of landscape seem to him to correspond to the planes of the body2 he lately said to me that since he has lived at ,meudon1 opposite the flowing ,seine1 the wooded hills and the fields1 he has found useful resemblances between the modelling of the body and that of a horizon4 ,i have even once suggested to him the title of ,the ,hill for the body of a young man reclining1 the outline of which did in truth resemble the undulations of a hill1 and he retained the name and the analogy1 for he delights in everything that binds the human being to the earth1 and1 like a true metaphysician1 conceives of nothing isolated or distinct in nature4 ,i come now to ,rodin's drawings1 drawings which were not made to be shown1 but which1 having nevertheless become known1 have surprised and puzzled people4 ,rodin's drawings1 like some other drawings by sculptors1 are not themselves works of art2 they are thoughts noted down1 and are not comprehensible unless they are seen with the statues of which they indicate the first idea1 or some variation4 ,rodin has published some of his sketches2 and has produced some dry-points 7in particular the ,ronde1#a ,antonin ,proust1 the three portraits of ,henry ,becque1 full face and two profiles upon the same sheet1 and two heads of ,hugo71 some drawings for books by ,m4 ,mirbeau and ,m4 ,bergerat1 and a complete set of illustrations of the ,fleurs du ,mal1 in the form of marginal drawings for a unique copy belonging to ,m4 ,gallimard4 ,many drawings in black or colour have been published 7by the clever lithographer ,clot71 and ,m4 ,fenaille has superintended an admirable edition de luxe of #adb drawings by ,rodin4#b ,notwithstanding this partial publicity1 these works must be considered as standing apart2 and to consider them by themselves would actually be to injure ,rodin with the public at large1 since they form an integral part of his statues4 ,for this reason ,i have not chosen to reproduce any of them here1 studies so purely professional not seeming to fall within the scope of a work intended to give a general idea of an artist's work4 ,having said so much1 ,i wish to dwell upon the great beauty of these drawings--a special and terrible beauty4 ,many deal with ,dante4 ,rodin did some painting under ,lecoq de ,boisbaudron1 landscapes1 a portrait of his father1 and sketches after ,rubens2 but there has never been any danger of painting intruding upon his vocation1 and his sketches rapidly became nothing but notes for sculpture4 ,the objective reality of his ,dantesque figures is vague1 if their subjective reality is intense4 ,rodin1 anxious to note down his impressions1 and not to illustrate1 made his sketches into a sort of passionate writing1 only devoting himself to the scheme and to the contrasts of black and white1 and neglecting every detail4 ,in these violent washes1 these pencillings and pen-scribbles1 the spectator who is not forewarned sees nothing1 but the lover of art1 who knows beforehand what to seek1 follows the creative thought4 ,nothing can be less like what is generally known as a drawing4 ,after the regular drawings1 the painter's drawings of his first period1 which have but a restricted interest1 and which are no longer known1 those of his second manner are confusions of light and shadow1 and show fantastically4 ,i will quote at this point a passage from an essay by ,m4 ,clment ,jasmin1 a discerning critic1 whose noisy rivals do not give him his due place1 and who has described these works excellently4 ,these sketches are altogether the work of a sculptor1 even in their colour1 which seems to have sunk into plaster or clay1 and especially in the firmness of their modelling1 which is imparted by shaded touches of body-colour1 on grey paper1 or rendered by spaces left white4 ,these blanks1 these white spaces1 are the extreme point of the modelling1 the 'high light' of some projection1 which lower down is wrapped in half-tints that carry the eye to the shadows of the inflections or the hollows4 ,there is a constant relation between the contour and the interior modelling4 ,a thrill is communicated by the fantastic lighting of some sketches4 ,rodin adds further strength to this dramatic distribution of lights and shadows by one or two tones that accentuate the impression or fix a plan4 ,often his ink will become blue or yellow1 7water-colours1 sepia1 or coloured inks being employed71 in order to settle a value or intensify a feeling4 ,such is the case in the ,fenaille publication1 with the gloomy red in the face of the ,ugolino1 of the ,dantesque ,mahomet1 whose entrails are hanging out1 and of some other figures dashed in1 in black1 on a violet background4 ,one plainly feels the material in which the work1 of which the sketch is the first idea1 will be executed4 ,it is always a sculptor who is at work1 even when he exchanges the chisel for the pen or the brush4 ,painters would scorn these drawings4 ,they commonly believe that sculptors cannot express upon a plane surface the mass and movement of a body4 ,in reality a painter's sketch and a sculptor's sketch differ in intention and execution4 ,rodin's are translations of movements1 in no way decorative and not attempting to express either modelling or detail1 but1 if we may say so1 the abstract geometry1 the thought that commands the movement4 ,the use of coloured inks1 which are solely meant to modify certain values that black or white would not express to ,rodin's mind1 has given rise to mistakes4 ,these colours are not there to express real tints1 as is the case in ordinary drawings thus touched up2 inaccurate things have been said about these colourings1 and about the fantastic and almost ,japanese appearance of some of the plates4 ,rodin is certainly not thinking of prints in colour4 ,he makes these notes instinctively1 and displays not so much a deliberate thought as a natural faculty of transcription4 ,in his early drawings ,rodin refers to--for ,i must insist upon the point that the drawings do not represent things--many of ,dante's persons and many fanciful animals1 and later1 to his statues4 ,now he does not draw at all from literary impressions1 but solely from the living model4 ,he uses ordinary cheap paper1 a pencil or a pen2 he makes his model take some transitory1 absolutely free position1 often in the rest between two sittings1 and rapidly draws contour without taking his eyes from the model and without looking at his sketch4 ,sometimes the stroke will fall upon emptiness1 the sheet of paper will be too small1 a head or a limb will fail to find its place4 ,naturally this instantaneous sketch will be deformed in the most unexpected way2 the proportions are false1 but the scheme of the contour and the modelling of each piece are true4 ,often the hurrying pencil will miss the curve of a breast or a leg4 ,then the artist will return to that point with hasty1 intermingled1 impatient strokes that play around the true line4 ,his only concern is to fix the first view1 the absolutely living impression4 ,afterwards1 in tracing his sketch1 he rectifies1 but his chief aim is to amplify the impression of the life1 taken spontaneously1 according to his principle of enlarging the form1 in order to place it better in the atmosphere 7about in the proportion of #e_/d instead of #d_/d74 ,then he connects the contours and further enlarges the modelling1 filling the outline with a wash of burnt-sienna1 which gives the general value1 or sometimes with blue or red water-colour4 ,rodin likes this practice in catching movements1 and he has in his studio hundreds of drawings of this kind that differ from his early ones4 ,those aimed at the imaginative transcription of tragic and literary elements under strange illuminations1 and were almost like the drawings of ,odilon ,redon2 the later ones are merely graphic notes of movements1 and are incapable of having any direct aim or meaning4 ,i must add a few words upon a delicate point of which ,i should not have spoken if others had not spoken mistakenly upon the subject4 ,rodin's drawings1 especially those of the present time1 have shocked some people who have seen them by their licentious character4 ,why should we assume embarrassment in explaining this8 ,in all ,rodin's work there is a profound and violent sense of the voluptuous1 and the stern painter of the vices and damnations of hell does not need to think of prudery4 ,the elevation and dramatic character of his conceptions clothe the most daring attitudes with the severe chastity of the beautiful4 ,in his sketches1 made for himself alone1 and in the privacy of his studio1 ,rodin no more fears erotic positions than did ,hokusai4 ,beneath the original animality he perceives nature2 and feminine sexuality1 its movements1 and impulses interest him1 because therein woman is psychologically revealed4 ,everything1 in physical desire1 that exalts1 maddens1 contorts1 and fevers the human body is1 for the sculptor1 the object of an intensely interested study that he does not communicate to the general public2 nor is he the only one among the great artists of form whom the erotic has interested from this point of view4 ,only mediocre minds and minds capable of low intentions see anything low in the movements of life4 ,rodin's studies from the model1 naked and free1 without spectators1 in the serious presence of work1 never sully his grand and melancholy inspiration2 and his daring art is assuredly that which most leads away the beholder from erotic ideas1 because it notes in every human being the melancholy of the insatiable1 and makes the pleasure of the senses a suffering of the flesh and the spirit4 ,by this point he touches the profound morality of art1 and his consciousness is free from any equivocation4 ,the recent drawings in which he catches the animal attitudes of the model are thus no more questionable1 from the delicate point of view of which ,i am speaking1 than anatomical plates1 or the sad immodesties of a post-mortem examination4 ,he adds to them the power of expressing passion with which he is endowed1 but since he only shows these drawings to friends and artists in whom nudity does not arouse silly thoughts1 this concerns no one else4 ,a comparison cannot even be ventured between these drawings and the masterly etchings of ,rops1 which are deliberate illustrations of licentious subjects1 relieved only by beauty of execution1 and which should only be shown with express reservations4 ,rodin admires certain bronzes in the secret museum at ,naples1 and certain ,japanese prints1 because in these1 too1 art has done its work by expressing a secret and essential spring of the nervous and psychological life of humanity2 a fierce and serious subject which only fools consider laughable or indecent1 because their minds approach it with indecorum and ridicule4 ,but ,i do not know that ,rodin ever even yielded to the fancy of modelling one of these subjects for himself1 as ,rubens and many others did not forbid themselves to do4 ,it is time1 therefore1 to have done with this question in regard to the great ,french sculptor4 ,i do not know for whom he intends these recent drawings1 a whole framed collection of which occupies one of the storerooms of his country house4 ,perhaps he will have them destroyed2 in any case1 they are but studies of movements and masses1 and in no way direct representations of life4 ,rodin's drawings are rough drafts to be compared with those of a writer4 ,some are very impressive1 and all constitute precious evidence of his psychological preoccupations and of his desire for simplification4 ,but they remain on the margin of his work1 and neither the public nor the critics have those rights over them that belong to biographers and friends4 ,that is a point to be plainly specified1 and ,i desire to repeat that that is the reason this book contains none of them4 #a ,this word may mean either a certain sort of dance1 or the round of a patrol4--,,trans4 #b ,album of #adb sketches1 reproduced in heliogravure by ,m4 ,manzi and published by ,goupil1 #ahig4 ,these sketches in wash or colour have been selected according to the advice of ,m4 ,fenaille1 their owner1 who lent them1 from the most imaginative of ,rodin's drawings in his second manner4 ,v4 ,,rodin',s ,,private ,,life--,,his ,,person1 ,,studio1 ,,and ,,home--,,his ,,influence2 ,,sculptors ,,inspired ,,by ,,his ,,ideas--,,rodin',s ,,place ,,in ,,the ,,french ,,school--,,his ,,present ,,position ,,in ,,respect ,,to ,,academic ,,sculpture ,auguste ,rodin is in person a man of middle height1 with an enormous head upon a massive torso4 ,at first sight one sees nothing of him but this leonine bust1 the head with its strong nose1 flowing grey beard1 and small1 keen1 light-coloured eyes1 slightly veiled by short sight and by a gentle irony4 ,the impression of power is accentuated by the rolling gait1 the rocky aspect of the troubled brow under the rough brush of hair1 the bony thickness of the aquiline nose and the ample curls of beard4 ,but the first impression is partly contradicted by the reticent line of the mouth1 the quick look1 penetrating1 simple1 and arch1 7one of the most composite glances ,i have ever seen71 and especially by the voice1 which is hollow1 not easily modulated1 with deep inflections and sudden returns to a dental pronunciation1 and of which the meaning and intention are further modified by certain very expressive tossings of the head4 ,he appears simple1 precise1 reserved1 courteous1 and cordial1 without liveliness4 ,little by little his shyness gives place to a calm and remarkable tone of authority4 ,he is neither emphatic nor awkward1 and would seem rather dispirited than inspired4 ,an immense energy breathes in his sober and measured gestures4 ,the slowness and apparent embarrassment of his speech and the pauses in his conversation give especial significance to what he says2 moreover1 ,rodin has acquired of late years a genuine case as a talker and even as a writer1 which previously he did not possess4 ,i was intimately acquainted with ,stphane ,mallarm1 who1 measured by ,rodin1 was incomparably eloquent1 and ,i often associate these two men in my thoughts4 ,the voices were alike1 and ,rodin1 too1 with his improvised phrases1 has the same veiled circumspect way of speech1 hitting suddenly upon words that illuminate the idea4 ,illustration3 ,,auguste ,,rodin ,rodin1 in speaking of any work of his1 has a way of explaining it that is very elliptical1 but very clear1 and which has caused some brilliant chatterers to say1 because he did not offer a prolix commentary1 that he did not know what he had done4 ,in reality he utters the essential1 and his gesture1 which seems to model his thought in space1 completes his words4 ,he looks lovingly on his creations1 and sometimes seems to meditate in astonishment at the idea of having created them2 he speaks of them as though they existed apart from himself4 ,gradually1 beneath ,rodin's essential simplicity1 one discovers features that were at first hidden2 he is ironical1 sensuous1 nervous1 proud4 ,he contains as possibilities all the passions that he expresses with so vibrating a magnificence1 and one begins to perceive the secret links between this calm1 almost cheerful man and the art that he reveals4 ,at certain moments his clear and rather vague eyes become full of phosphorescent points1 the face grows sardonic and almost faunlike2 at others it saddens and discloses a sickness for infinity4 ,this man is the comrade of his dumb white creatures2 he loves them1 follows their abstract life1 has moral obligations towards them4 ,fundamentally the one thing with which ,rodin is really concerned is the life of permanent forms4 ,of late celebrity1 age1 and experience have disposed him to become an adviser1 a master1 and he has begun to talk aesthetics4 ,but his ideas and opinions are restricted4 ,he perceives human beings only very summarily1 his cordiality is a way of fulfilling his social duties hastily4 ,he has1 if ,i may venture the expression1 very fine moral antennae1 and they serve to recognise the persons whom he will like4 ,very capable of friendship1 ,rodin reduces friendship to tacit agreements upon the essential subjects of thought1 and it is only if one meets him upon one of these points that one takes a place in his remembrance or his liking4 ,he does not put his faith in individuals1 but in general ideas4 ,he loves nothing but his work1 and endures everything else with civil boredom4 ,he has a horror of debates and disturbances4 ,i have never heard him speak ill of bad artists2 he neglects1 but does not criticise4 ,he has a silent humour which leads him to make busts of official and mediocre sculptors1 with an amusing good grace4 ,uncompromising in everything that touches his art1 ,rodin has throughout his whole career endured severe struggles and grave injustices1 and1 too proud to dispute1 has never shown his secret revolts4 ,at the time when the ,balzac was refused all ,rodin's friends said to him3 ,resist1 force your work upon them2 you ought1 for the work's sake1 and a court would surely decide for you1 for your agreement is definitely in your favour4 ,he listened and thanked them1 always good-tempered1 and then withdrew his statue without saying anything4 ,it is not weakness1 for ,rodin has had an excessively hard life and is strong and patient2 it is dignity of the inner life and profound indifference for the life about him4 ,rodin is a high dignitary of the ,legion of ,honour1 a president of the judges of sculpture of an important society of artists 7the ,socit ,nationale71 he is honoured all over ,europe1 has been received in ,england as a genius1 and has succeeded ,whistler as the head of a chosen band of artists2 but he remains the man that he was when he was unknown and poor in his solitude at ,brussels4 ,he likes few things1 but likes those thoroughly4 ,he reads little1 but what he reads strikes home to him as to no one else2 ,baudelaire and ,rousseau1 in whom he delights1 are instances4 ,he is passionately fond of music1 especially of ,gluck1 but seldom speaks of it4 ,he simplifies everything1 sees only the main lines in morality as in art1 lives by two or three principles1 and has an aversion for everything that is not essential4 ,illustration3 ,a ,,corner ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,studio ,,at ,,meudon ,when one knows ,rodin well one ceases to be able to separate him from his work4 ,he can no longer think otherwise than symbolically by slow deposits of accumulated sensation which work on in the deep strata of his consciousness and suddenly blossom and take a name4 ,his statues are states of the soul4 ,he is himself a representative being1 surprised at his own immanence1 and his intelligence is outdone by his instinct4 ,that is how it comes about that he does not always know how to name the beings that he has discovered1 as we discover1 by means of pain1 corners of our consciousness that we had not suspected4 ,in the same way that ,rodin seems to break away the fragments of a block from around an already existing statue hidden in it1 he is himself a sort of rock concealing shapes within it and embracing in its secret recesses immense crystallised arborescences4 ,with a simple enough personal psychology he expresses infinite shades and inflexions of emotion4 ,his thought is like the monad of ,leibnitz2 it seems1 when one sees the man1 to have no window to the outer world4 ,rodin's opinions upon social life are vague4 ,he contents himself with repeating that work lovingly done is the secret of all order and all happiness4 ,to love life and natural forms1 and to attempt nothing disobedient to ,nature or her aims1 that is his whole morality4 ,he sees very few people and visits nobody4 ,he would baffle visitors accustomed to elegant1 literary1 well-informed1 brilliant artists4 ,his studio in the ,rue de l',universit1 at the end of an old yard encumbered by blocks of marble and shaded by aged chestnut trees1 is like the work-place of a poor beginner4 ,neither a carpet nor an ornament is to be seen2 the stone floor1 the bare walls1 a few rush chairs1 some modelling stands1 some cloths1 a shabby deal table loaded with papers1 sketches piled up on shelves1 blouses hanging on nails1 a cast-iron stove--these and nothing more are found by the many foreign admirers who come to see ,rodin1 and whom he receives with invariable amiability amid his assistants at work upon the ,hugo monument or upon some smaller piece of marble4 ,illustration3 ,a ,,corner ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,studio ,,at ,,meudon ,setting aside his journeys to ,london and ,prague and his travels in ,germany and ,italy1 ,rodin leads an extremely retired life in ,paris1 and is rarely to be met4 ,he invariably lunches at his own house at ,meudon1 then goes to the ,rue de ,l',universit to work1 and goes home again to dinner4 ,formerly1 before he had his house at ,meudon1 he used to lunch at a caf in the ,place de ,l',alma1 where he was to be seen for twenty years1 and to which people used to go to see him1 rather as people go to see ,ibsen in ,christiania4 ,the house1 of a sixteenth-century style1 that ,rodin has inhabited at ,meudon since #aijj1 is situated amid vineyards1 and stands alone at the end of a sort of cliff1 overlooking all ,paris1 the ,seine1 and the ,bois de ,boulogne1 and facing the wooded heights of ,saint ,cloud and ,bellevue4 ,the site is open and fine2 ,rodin enjoys immense expanses of sky1 sunsets1 storms1 and moonlight nights that delight him4 ,the house is spacious1 light1 furnished with extreme simplicity1 and adorned by a few pictures1 the works of friends 7in particular his portraits by ,sargent and ,legros74 ,rodin has added to it the pavilion in iron and glass1 in which he exhibited all his work1 at the ,rond-point de l',alma1 in the exhibition of #aijj4 ,this pavilion1 rebuilt and full of brilliant sunlight1 contains all the artist's statuary4 ,there are also several small studios1 in which ,rodin has his marble rough-hewn1 keeps the casts of his statues or accumulates the collections of bronzes1 marbles1 antique or ,gothic1 and fragments which he is never tired of finding out and buying4 ,in this place1 which1 after a life of difficulties and worries1 ,rodin has been able to purchase1 he leads a life that fully suits his tastes1 among beautiful trees and flowers1 with a majestic landscape before him4 ,it is touching to see the man1 here1 amid the enormous mass of his work1 a whole world of statues1 with which he lives and which sums up all his labours and all his existence4 ,a photograph which ,i am able to add to the illustrations of this volume will give a partial idea of that surprising and imposing cohort of figures in clay1 marble1 and bronze--that impassioned or tragic throng4 ,rodin receives very few visitors at ,meudon--hardly any but old friends1 and he spends his mornings in his garden or in his light and cheerful studio drawing or superintending his workmen4 ,it is chiefly at ,meudon that he prepares his rough drafts1 the main lines of his compositions2 and in order to see an effect he will often hastily put together with clay some of the plaster limbs that he keeps in a number of glass cases--quite an anatomical museum in fact1 filling a whole storey1 and containing hundreds of pieces and of attitudes piled together4 ,illustration3 ,,study 7,,in ,,bronze7 ,,for ,,the ,,balzac ,rodin appears to stand alone in his own time2 first1 by his genius2 and secondly1 by the special character of his artistic conception4 ,this solitude1 however1 is only apparent4 ,rodin's ideas1 as opposed to the teaching of the cole1 form a body of logical principles which are slowly attracting the adhesion of young artists4 ,the long struggle of impressionism against academism has now entered upon its last phase3 the return to the ,french tradition1 to national affiliation in opposition to the ,roman neo-classicism4 ,that idea1 which is the programme of all independent and interesting critical intelligence in our country1 finds in ,rodin its perfect demonstration1 and the only one afforded by contemporary sculpture4 ,until now ,rodin has preached only by example1 and we know how slow the critics and the public are in extracting from a work the ideas that it contains4 ,but the extraction is now begun1 and ,rodin himself speaks with undisputed authority4 ,since the exhibition of #aijj his moral position stands ten times higher4 ,youth greets him as a chieftain and his detractors are silent4 ,while the synthetic and symbolic mind of ,rodin arouses the enthusiasm and inspires the thoughts of writers1 the theory of the amplification of the modelling is making its way in the studios of sculptors4 ,rodin has opened a large window in the pale house of contemporary sculpture1 declares ,pierre ,roche1 the sculptor2 out of the timid and much impaired craft that was before his day he has shown that a bold art full of hope can be made4 ,this opinion of one of the most delicate artists of our generation is precisely that of many independent sculptors4 ,among these we must quote ,emile ,bourdelle1 ,rodin's pupil and friend1 an impassioned1 vibrating1 and generous artist1 whose works are among those first looked for in each ,salon4 ,others are the two brothers ,gaston and ,lucien ,schnegg1 the latter of whom exhibited in the ,salon of #aijd so beautiful a head of ,aphrodite1 almost worthy in the mysterious and vaporous beauty of its planes1 of the ancients1 and of ,rodin2 ,jules ,desbois1 of the first rank in technical skill and of a violently original temperament2 ,alexandre ,charpentier1 a former collaborator of ,rodin's1 whose success in applied art has not turned him aside from his expressive and vigorous work in statuary2 ,mlle4 ,camille ,claudel1 ,rodin's pupil1 who is the first woman sculptor of existing-art in ,france1 and whose name has appeared upon admirable works2 and finally1 ,pierre ,roche1 although his supple and decorative fancy denies itself the expression of the tragic4 ,the ,swiss sculptor ,niederhausern-,rodo1 ,george ,minne1 the sculptor of ,ghent1 who has a powerful creative genius1 not understood1 and the ,italian sculptor ,rosso1 are also partisans of ,rodin's art1 and so is the ,englishman ,bartlett4 ,in another direction it is very interesting to note the curious reciprocal influence of ,auguste ,rodin and ,eugne ,carrire1 who are united by friendship and by the same aesthetic creed4 ,eugne ,carrire1 the most profound painter of the inner life existing in the ,french school of to-day1 has great analogies with ,rodin1 both as a man and as an artist4 ,he1 too1 reduces his art to essentials1 to the main lines and the deliberate amplification of surfaces4 ,thus his figures1 bathed in shadow1 are akin to ,rodin's statues1 while the latter1 bathed with dewy light1 seem to be pictures by ,carrire4 ,the painter becomes massive and powerful1 the sculptor becomes vaporous4 ,rodin seeks the bland1 half-shadows of ,correggio1 and ,carrire desires that his figures should have the powerful relief of bronze4 ,the painter sacrifices colour to the sole study of values1 and by his black-and-white comes back to sculpture4 ,very curious is this point of junction between two great artists4 ,rodin is beginning to explain himself with the pen2 and ,eugne ,carrire has1 for some years past1 been writing--too rarely--passages upon art of which the style is admirable and the concentration of thought astonishing1 passages which recall ,mallarm and ,baudelaire1 and leave far behind the commonplaces of journalistic criticism4 ,rodin and ,carrire have their school1 their circle of chosen admirers1 and their double influence may soon be the most decisive1 if not the most brilliant and the noisiest1 in ,french art of to-day4 ,,nude ,,figure 7,,photographed ,,in ,,the ,,open ,,air ,,at ,,twilight ,,in ,,the ,,garden ,,at ,,meudon7 ,the prevailing note of opinion about ,rodin among his friends and his detractors is that he is like no one else1 and that no statue can1 in a manner1 be looked at beside his1 so individual is the conception from which they spring4 ,by the mere fact that they exist1 they compel us to choose between them and the others4 ,their silhouettes1 their planes1 the quality of their shadows1 and their lights1 make them technically works apart4 ,if such a man understands sculpture thus1 either he is right1 against everybody1 or he is totally mistaken2 we cannot like him and also approve of ordinary statuary4 ,his psychological and tragic genius conquers the admiration even of those who oppose his material execution4 ,rodin does not set himself up as a chief1 nor recognise followers2 yet he is a chief by his very work4 ,he is the greatest living ,french artist1 and one of the most complex and powerful movers of thought in modern art4 ,he does not found a school1 but he influences the soul of a generation4 ,he remains alone1 not susceptible of imitation2 but if he did not exist sculpture would be deprived of its greatest regenerator4#a ,by inscribing passions in symbols1 he touches the sensibilities of all1 and is a master to poets as much as to sculptors1 because his subjects are moral1 affecting1 never commanded by an anecdote1 bathed in the universally lyric4 ,attempts have been made to blame him because of the admiration of writers2 it has been said1 with an inflexion of scorn 7especially in the circles of his fellow-artists71 he is a littraire4 ,an injustice easily committed at a time when the intellect of painters and sculptors seems to blush at itself1 and when they make it a sort of false merit to show that their eye and hand are separate from their brain4 ,rodin's splendid technical power annuls the reproach and retains the praise4 ,resting firmly upon nature1 his symbols may rise high4 ,rodin delights poets because he makes the infinite emanate from the most finite of arts4 ,everything has been patiently meditated by him4 ,he dares1 but is never overbold2 his balance and his taste are those of a classic1 despite the uncomprehending astonishment of the academic sculptors1 hypnotised by the sophistry of finish and elegance1 and confusing the exact with the true4 ,there is a synthesized form1 that corresponds to reality synthesized in symbols1 a second truth2 and that proportion is observed by very few artists4 ,most of them1 contenting themselves with an immediate1 momentary1 anecdotic truth1 translate it by picturesque observation1 or by minutely detailed copying4 ,this attempt of a sterile cleverness to transcribe the instantaneous is the very contrary of art1 the first character of which is to display the laws of vital permanence underlying fugitive aspects4 ,herein lies the reason why sculptors become uneasy over ,rodin1 while writers1 more familiar with general ideas1 become enthusiastic4 ,the impressionist crisis--the study1 that is to say1 of instantaneous lights and actions--hardly got over1 he brings in this second truth1 the transcription of general and permanent feelings into a form that speaks as much to the mind as to the senses4 ,such a man dominates impressionism as much as he does academism4 ,a whole order of curious and fundamental relations between nervous sensibility and thought has arisen out of his work4 ,rodin's personality is specially representative in the line of ,french sculptors4 ,he goes back1 as ,i have said1 to the ,egyptians and the ,greeks in the matter of technical ideas4 ,in his tragic feeling he proceeds directly from the ,gothic artists4 ,it is from them that he descends1 and especially from the sculptors of the ,french ,renascence1 in particular ,germain ,pilon2 and he blends his ,greek remembrances1 passed through an ,italian influence1 with a conception altogether national1 vigorous1 and decorative4 ,rodin's actual part is to take up sculpture exactly at the moment of the ,french evolution4#b ,since that time we have had some great masters2 native genius has been triumphantly upheld1 in opposition to the false school that came from the ,alps1 by ,coysevox1 ,houdon1 ,puget1 ,pajou1 ,pigalle1 ,clodion1 ,falconet1 ,couston1 ,rude1 ,carpeaux1 and ,barye1 a line of splendid inventors of shapes1 all of whom1 in contradistinction to the official school1 have represented the inmost qualities of their race4 ,all these men ,rodin emulates by the importance of his work2 perhaps the future may regard him as the magnificent outcome of their efforts carried on through three centuries4 ,in this succession of artists1 ,puget1 ,rude1 and ,barye are those with whom his technical relations are closest4#c ,but he has been less decorative than ,puget and less hampered by the themes imposed upon him2 he has gone further than the great ,rude in the expression of inward emotion1 and he surpasses even ,barye in power of modelling and boldness of silhouette4 ,he has created a world which is fully his own1 a feeling and a pathos not to be found elsewhere1 which are the very soul of his time4 ,rodin1 then1 can be set only beside ,puget and ,rude4 ,like ,puget1 he is overflowing with vitality and with passionate frenzy2 he worships power and heroic beings2 but his are sad1 and nearer to ,gothic asceticism and to the nervous derangement of ,baudelaire than to the resplendent pomp of the seventeenth century1 into which ,puget transposed his heroes of ,rome and of ,corneille4 ,like ,rude1 he is attracted by deep things1 by soul tragedies2 but he is more abstract than the creator of the ,napoleon ,awakening to ,immortality1 the ,joan of ,arc1 or the ,marseillaise4 ,rodin is more general1 more synthetic2 he turns his mind to permanent symbols1 outside of ages and races4 ,taking up1 as if in challenge1 the mythological subjects that the cole had most spoiled1 he has shown how a great mind can renew all things and impress upon them the magic of its vision4 ,he is the most symbolic of our men of genius2 and if the modelling of the ,greeks1 ,gothic austerity1 the strength of ,puget and of ,rude1 have helped ,rodin to make up his personality1 the fusion of these elements and the addition of a personal imagination and an extraordinary contemplative faculty have enabled him1 like ,wagner1 who descended from ,bach1 ,beethoven1 and ,liszt1 to create1 after and apart from all of them1 work that resumes them and forgets them1 to become in its turn an initiator4 ,the point in which ,rodin is inimitable is the expression of the voluptuous with all its latent woes2 and this point strongly recalls to memory ,tristan and ,isolde1 which is such a paroxysm as might touch the most perilous region of exceptional art2 but ,rodin is kept within the bounds of the normal1 and protected from the audacities of his strange and troubled imagination1 by his imperturbable technical certainty and by his admiration for some few masters4 ,as was the case with ,baudelaire and with ,poe1 his purity and grandeur of form save him2 like ,dante1 this lover of gloomy beauty hangs over the verge of passion's hell without falling into it4 ,rodin's art is healthy because it feeds upon natural truth and general logic4 ,he is the supreme painter of man bowed by intense1 melancholic1 feverish1 constricting thought2 but also1 with a candid tenderness unknown to ,wagner1 he is the caressing creator of women in love1 the poet of youth1 embracing and radiant4 ,only a genius can have the diversity of mind that produces ,the ,burghers of ,calais1 ascetic and medival1 the spasmodic ,hell1 the almost abstract ,balzac1 the bronze busts worthy of ,donatello1 and the images of women carved in the radiant and golden marble of ,attica by a sensuous and subtle enthusiast who has rediscovered the soul of ,hellenic beauty4 ,this union of technical skill1 evolved according to the secrets of the antique with a power of expressing all human sentiments from gentleness to lewdness1 from the mystic to the pathetic1 from nervous disorganisation to carnal frankness1 this union of contraries and this universality are not to be found in any of our forerunners4 ,not ,puget1 nor ,rude1 nor any of our masters has had such intellectual ubiquity1 such strength of condensation2 in these points it is allowable1 even in our own day1 to acknowledge ,rodin as supreme in the rich ,french school1 and thus to anticipate the judgment of the future1 in whose eyes he will loom yet larger4 ,in any case it was high time he should appear2 he has been as useful as was ,manet by his intervention in ,french art4 ,in spite of ,dalou1 sculpture had fallen very low after the death of ,carpeaux and ,barye2 the deplorable school of the ,second ,empire had brought it into degeneracy1 and we could reckon no one in sculpture to correspond to the great impressionists4 ,such men as ,dujalbert1 ,chapu1 ,merci1 ,frmiet1 ,saint ,marceaux1 and ,falguire1 are but sham great sculptors1 nothing of whose work will last2 the cole group1 from ,paul ,dubois to ,barrias1 ,aube and ,guillaume1 is a mere example of pretentious insignificance4 ,the few vigorous temperaments1 or workers of genuine technical merit1 like ,denys ,puech1 ,jean ,dampt1 ,gardet1 ,camille ,lefvre1 ,devillez1 and ,jean ,bassier1 did not know how to put together their efforts in such a way as to found a real school4 ,they produced without attaining a cohesion of thought capable of guiding a fresh generation4 ,bartholom1 thoughtful1 pure1 dreamy1 and proud1 stands apart4 ,mme4 ,besnard and ,m4 ,thodore ,rivire are charming1 but without influence4 ,i have spoken of the group that has spontaneously placed itself around ,rodin4 ,amid this interesting1 unequal1 and scattered sculpture he appeared with the authority of a master and a prophet2 his work set the question upon its true basis again1 showing whence we came1 what was to be avoided1 and whither we were to go2 and all this with such clearness of evidence that the appearance of ,rodin becomes1 in like degree with that of ,goujon and that of ,puget1 a capital date in the history of the ,french school1 ,i declared in the ,preface my intention to avoid any extravagant eulogy of ,rodin1 and have uttered my dislike of the idolatry by which some people think it necessary publicly to emphasise their admiration1 with its snobbish accretions4 ,but ,i should fall into the opposite fault if ,i did not declare the truth and the importance of what such an artist brings to his art1 and did not mark his exact place in the line of his country's sculpture4 ,henley has called ,rodin the ,michael ,angelo of the modern world4 ,that opinion of a foreign critic1 a critic justly esteemed one of the most upright in contemporary literature1 ,france may justly make her own1 far from extravagant and puerile praises1 and in the face of the work accomplished4 ,i shall be but too happy if ,i have contributed to make clearer to the public certain secret reasons1 certain inner frameworks1 of that logical and beautiful work4 #a ,a vehement but indiscriminating critic1 ,m4 ,octave ,mirbeau1 has seen good to write1 by way of affirming that ,rodin's art moved him strongly3 ,a style takes rise from him4 ,i have neither the space nor the wish to recriminate2 but it would be dangerous to let such artistic heresies pass without protest4 ,rodin is an admirable example1 but to say that a style arises from him is to say that he may become the creator of a perishable formula1 and to understand nothing about his art4 #b ,some surprise may be felt at my having failed to insist upon the name of ,michael ,angelo4 ,everybody has hit upon the obvious comparison4 ,it is the exceeding obviousness that leads me to distrust it4 ,rodin is much nearer to ,puget than to ,michael ,angelo1 who is muscular strength carried to heroic proportions4 ,rodin1 like ,puget1 and more than ,puget1 is nervous strength4 ,rodin appears much more akin to ,michael ,angelo than he really is4 ,careful study causes us more and more to leave behind that preliminary likeness which has sufficed so many critics4 #c ,we might perhaps say the same in regard to the great ,carpeaux1 too1 who carried the art of movement and expression to so high a degree1 and who did the same liberal work against the cole as ,rodin was to do at a later time4 ,but their visions1 aims1 and minds differ profoundly4 ,,vi ,,appendix--,,chronological ,,list ,,of ,,rodin',s ,,principal ,,works--,,list ,,of ,,the ,,principal ,,books ,,or ,,articles ,,written ,,about ,,him--,,quotations ,,referring ,,to ,,him--,,an ,,opinion ,,of ,,eug,,ne ,,carri,,re',s2 ,,an ,,opinion ,,of ,,henley',s--,,various ,,notes ,chronological catalogue of ,rodin's works is almost impossible to draw up4 ,i do not think ,rodin himself could do it4 ,it must be remembered that before #ahgg he made a quantity of studies which he destroyed1 and such a producer as he is willing to neglect things of which others would keep count4 ,in his poor and wandering days ,rodin must have abandoned many things4 ,how would it be possible to recount the figures that were retouched or even executed at ,carrier-,belleuse's1 the earliest independent works1 the characters executed by him at ,brussels1 the statues that were planned and left unfinished for lack of money1 those that were broken or that failed--all the immense store of work accomplished in the course of twenty years by a man who worked every day8 ,how would it be possible even to enumerate the sketches and varied renderings of different subjects piled up in the studio at ,meudon1 in the ,clos ,payen1 in the ,rue des ,fourneaux1 and at ,vaugirard8 ,it is a whole world4 ,i will confine myself1 therefore1 to a statement of known and exhibited works3 and these1 indeed1 are what is essential4 ,,list ,,of ,,the ,,principal ,,exhibited ,,works #ahfd4 ,the ,man with a ,broken ,nose4 #ahfe-gj4 ,works in the studio of ,carrier-,belleuse4 #ahgb-gg4 ,friezes upon the ,bourse and various works at ,brussels4 #ahgg4 ,the ,primitive ,man 7,the ,age of ,brass74 ,decorative work on the ,trocadro4 #ahgh-hj4 ,saint ,jerome4 ,saint ,john the ,baptist4 ,works in the manufactory of ,svres4 ,competition for the ,national ,defence ,monument4 #ahha4 ,adam 7destroyed74 ,eve4 #ahhb4 ,ugolino 7a sketch taken up again later74 ,busts of ,alphonse ,legros and ,,iv4 ,e4 ,henley4 ,studies for ,the ,gate of ,hell4 #ahhc4 ,bellona4 ,general ,lynch 7equestrian statue74 ,the ,genius of ,war4 #ahhd4 ,monument of ,president ,vicunha4 ,bust of a ,young ,woman4 #ahhe4 ,the ,man and the ,serpent4 ,busts of ,dalou1 ,hugo1 and ,antonin ,proust4 #ahhf4 ,first sketch of the ,hugo monument4 ,drawings dealing with ,the ,gate of ,hell4 ,bust of ,henry ,becque4 ,the ,kiss 7a small group74 #ahhg4 ,perseus and the ,gorgon4 ,head of ,st4 ,john beheaded4 #ahhh4 ,the ,danaid4 ,alan ,walking4 ,nude study for one of the ,burghers of ,calais4 ,several little groups4 #ahhi4 ,studies for the ,gate of ,hell and the monument to ,claude ,lorraine4 ,torso of a ,woman4 ,group of ,the ,dream4 ,the ,dream of ,life4 ,women ,damned 7in marble74 ,hecuba4 ,bust of ,roger ,marx4 ,destitution4 ,thought 7in marble74 #ahij4 ,bust of a ,young ,woman 7in silver74 ,torso of ,saint ,john4 ,brother and ,sister4 #ahia4 ,the ,caryatid4 ,the ,young ,mother4 ,a ,nymph4 #ahib4 ,busts of ,puvis de ,chavannes and ,henri ,rochefort4 ,grief4 ,claude ,lorraine4 ,the ,burghers of ,calais4 #ahic4 ,the ,death of ,adonis4 ,medallion of ,csar ,franck4 ,galatea4 ,bust of ,sverine4 ,the ,crest and the ,wave4 ,resurrection4 ,the ,child ,achilles 7group in clay74 #ahid4 ,eternal ,spring4 ,hope 7a reclining figure in back view47 ,orpheus and ,eurydice 7first version74 ,christ and ,magdalen4 #ahie4 ,inauguration of ,the ,burghers of ,calais4 ,illusion1 the ,daughter of ,icarus4 ,medallion of ,octave ,mirbeau4 ,nude studies for the ,balzac4 ,man ,crouching4 #ahif4 ,the ,inner ,voice4 ,the ,muse of ,anger 7for the ,hugo monument74 ,the ,conqueror4 ,minerva4 ,the ,poet and the ,life of ,contemplation4 ,women ,bathing4 ,studies for the ,balzac4 #ahig4 ,victor ,hugo4 ,balzac4 ,monument of ,president ,sarmiento4 #ahih4 ,statue of ,balzac4 ,bust of a ,young ,american4 ,bust of ,madame ,f4 ,statue of ,sarmiento1 with a high relief of ,apollo in marble4 ,monument of ,labour4 ,the ,benedictions 7marble74 ,twilight4 ,clouds4 ,the ,parc and the ,young ,girl4 #ahii4 ,works for the ,hugo monument4 #aijj4 ,marble groups4 ,exhibition at the ,rond-point de l',alma4 #aija4 ,shades 7for ,the ,gate of ,hell74 #aijb4 ,groups in marble4 ,the ,hand of ,god4 ,busts4 #aijc4 ,bust of ,hugo4 ,the ,poet and the ,muse4 ,various sketches4 ,ugolino 7fresh version74 ,the ,prodigal ,son4 #aijd4 ,the ,thinker1 and various works in marble in process of execution4#a ,the work of ,rodin may thus be estimated at about ten works on a grand scale1 forty groups or statues1 some thirty important busts1 and perhaps two hundred figures or portraits1 without counting sketches1 from #ahgg to #aijd4 ,i come now to the mention of some significant writings that deal with his aesthetic theory or with his work2 and1 as may be supposed1 ,i leave out of question a quantity of valueless articles1 for ,rodin has been directly or indirectly the pretext for a great mass of writings1 and is the modern ,french artist who has been most talked of1 justly or unjustly4 ,the works quoted are such as may be consulted with advantage4 #a ,to these may be added1 in #aije1 a bust of the ,rt4 ,hon4 ,george ,wyndham1 and ,the ,hand of ,god4 ,,articles ,,or ,,books ,,relating ,,to ,,rodin ,balzac and ,rodin1 by ,roger ,marx 7,le ,voltaire1 ,march1 #ahib74 ,claude ,lorraine1 by ,roger ,marx 7,le ,voltaire1 ,june1 #ahib74 7,excellent studies in the criticism of sculpture47 ,auguste ,rodin1 by ,roger ,marx 7,pan1 and ,the ,image1 ,september1 #ahig74 ,drawings by ,rodin1 #abi plates1 containing #adb heliogravures 7,goupil and ,co41 #ahig71 from the suggestions and loans of ,m4 ,fenaille4 ,rodin's ,studio1 by ,edouard ,rod 7,gazette des ,beaux ,arts1 ,may1 #ahih74 ,rodin1 by ,gabriel ,mourey 7,revue illustre1 ,october1 #ahii7 ,exhibition of #aijj3 ,rodin's ,works1 with four prefaces by ,eugne ,carrire1 ,jean ,paul ,laurens1 ,claude ,monet1 and ,albert ,besnard4 ,rodin and ,legros1 by ,arsne ,alexandre 7,figaro1 ,june1 #aijj74 ,the ,gate of ,hell1 by ,anatole ,france 7,figaro1 ,june #ast1 #aijj74 ,la ,revue des ,beaux ,arts et des ,lettres1 ,january #ast1 #aijj4 ,la ,plume1 #aijj4 ,special number4 ,les ,matres ,artistes1 special number1 ,october #aeth1 #aijc4 7,illustrated collections1 containing a certain number of critical studies by various authors47 ,rodin1 by ,lon ,riotor3 a pamphlet1 reproducing in ,french1 ,german1 ,english1 ,italian1 ,spanish1 and ,russian1 a study that appeared in the ,revue populaire des ,beaux ,arts1 ,april #hth1 #ahii4 ,rodin1 the ,sculptor1 a volume of criticism1 illustrated2 by ,lon ,maillard 7,floury72 #ahii4 ,the ,sculptor ,rodin1 drawn from life4 ,a volume by ,mlle4 ,judith ,cladel 7,la ,plume office1 #aijc74 ,rodin1 a study by ,l4 ,brieger-,wasser 7,vogel4 ,strassburg2 #aijc74 ,rodin1 by ,george ,treu 7,jahrbuch der bildenden ,kunst4 ,berlin1 ,marstersteig1 #aijc74 ,rodin1 by ,r4 ,m4 ,rilke 7,berlin1 ,bard1 #aijc74 ,rodin4 ,articles upon1 by ,w4 ,e4 ,henley1 #ahij2 ,d4 ,s4 ,mac,coll1 #aijb2 ,henri ,duhem1 #ahij2 ,karel ,b4 ,made 7,prague72 ,vittorio ,pica 7,rome74 ,of these various writings devoted to ,rodin1 those of ,roger ,marx should be particularly noted1 on account of their technical understanding2 ,lon ,maillard's volume is a sincere1 well-informed1 well-illustrated book1 produced by a man who comprehends4 ,the book by ,mlle4 ,judith ,cladel1 daughter of the distinguished novelist1 is an originally conceived volume1 the only one that relates certain conversations1 and attempts1 with charming acuteness1 to present ,rodin in his private character4 ,it is a work that deserves to be much better known and appreciated1 and of which ,rodin's first panegyrists1 jealous of being the only inventors of the artist1 have been very careful not to speak4 ,the article by the graceful painter1 ,henri ,duhem1 is likewise excellent2 and ,i consider ,mr4 ,mac,coll's very remarkable1 on account of its elevation and precision of judgment4 ,the others have such value as belongs to admiring articles written hurriedly in newspapers3 they express sympathetic feelings1 or comment in a poetical way upon the subjects1 but their critical value is ngligeable1 and there is nothing to be quoted from them for the information of my readers4 ,the ,balzac gave rise to a shoal of newspaper articles4 ,georges1 ,rodenbach1 and ,france1 on that occasion1 said the acute and witty thing's about ,rodin that they say about all manifestations of thought1 and ,m4 ,mirbeau made ,rodin the theme of some of those polemical variations1 conjoining hyperbolical praise with abuse of his adversaries1 which he is accustomed to offer as art-criticisms1 and which have gained him a reputation of a certain kind4 ,there is nothing to note in these pamphlets mixed with eulogistic effusions1 the whole of which do not contain the substance of twenty lines by ,henley or of ,eugne ,carrire's admirable ,preface1 which ,i am desirous of reproducing here because it is a masterpiece of synthetic divination4#a #a ,preface to the ,catalogue of the ,rodin exhibition in the ,pavillon de l',alma1 #aijj4 7,the work mentioned above2 other prefaces by ,claude ,monet1 ,a4 ,besnard1 and ,j4 ,p4 ,laurens47 ,,the ,,art ,,of ,,rodin ,rodin's art comes from the earth and returns to it1 like those giant blocks--rocks or dolmens--which mark deserts1 and in the heroic grandeur of which man recognises himself4 ,the transmission of thought by art1 like the transmission of life1 is the work of passion and of love4 ,passion1 whose obedient servant ,rodin is1 makes him discover the laws that serve to express it2 she it is that gives him the sense of volumes and proportions1 the choice of the expressive prominence4 ,thus the earth projects external apparent forms1 images1 and statues that fill us with a sense of its internal life4 ,these terrestrial forms were the real guides of ,rodin4 ,they have set him free from scholastic traditions1 in them he found his being and the creative instinct of men whom humanity celebrates4 ,trees and plants revealed to him their likeness to those fair women1 with sleek limbs rising1 like delicate columns1 to the moving torso and swelling breast1 above which the head hangs heavily in the company of a strong and supple neck1 even as a fine fruit full of savour weighs down its branch4 ,the massive brow overshadows the eyes1 and the cheek brings the lip softly to the lover's entreaty4 ,forms seek and meet in voluptuous desires of violence and of resignation1 rebellious and obedient to laws from which nothing escapes2 everywhere conscious logic triumphs4 ,the generalising spirit of ,rodin has imposed solitude upon him4 ,it has not been his lot to work upon the cathedral that is not1 but his desire of humanity links him to the eternal forms of nature4 ,after such a passage1 in which every word is significant and eloquent1 and is a great artist's reflection1 everything seems pale4 ,i will not1 however1 confine myself to a mere dry mention of the essay by ,vittorio ,pica1 the great ,italian critic1 who generously arranged for ,rodin's participation in the ,venetian ,exhibition 7,gallery of ,modern ,art1 #ahig71 and ,i should have liked to quote ,anatole ,france's fine article1 and some assertions of ,mr4 ,mac,coll's1 who very logically recalls to our memory the sculptor ,auguste ,prault1 who is too much forgotten1 and who was1 indeed1 a sort of imperfect precursor of ,rodin4 ,i must at least transcribe a few lines from ,w4 ,e4 ,henley1 who was1 from the very beginning1 a clear-sighted admirer of ,rodin1 and who spoke of him with eloquence and passion3-- ,m4 ,dalou 444 has declared that when the century goes out it will remember the aforesaid doors 7i4e4 ,the ,gate of ,hell7 as its heroic achievement in sculpture4 ,and if that be true--as ,i believe it to be true--then where1 between himself and ,michael ,angelo1 is there so lofty a head as ,rodin's8444 ,his busts alone were enough to place him in the future1 the style of them is so complete1 the treatment so large and so distinguished1 the effect so personal1 yet so absolute in art4444 ,here1 if you will1 are a thousand hints of the possibilities of human passion3 from ,paolo and ,francesca melting into each other3 ',la bocca mi bacio tutta tremante' as no man and woman have done in sculpture since sculpture began4444 ,here is sculpture in its essence4444 ,you may read into it as much literature as you please1 or as you can2 but the interpolation is not ,rodin's1 but your own4444 ,it is not literature in relief1 nor literature in the round2 it is sculpture pure and simple4444 ,passion is with him wholly a matter of form and surface and line1 and exists not apart from these4444 ,he is our ,michael ,angelo2 and if he had not been that1 he might have been our ,donatello4 ,and with ,phidias and ,lysippus all these some-and-twenty centuries afar1 what more is left to say of the man of genius whose art is theirs8 ,we see that ,henley's admiration returns to the comparison of ,michael ,angelo and ,rodin4 ,i persist in thinking that the resemblance rather lies in moral identity1 in conception than in technicalities4 ,the muscular enlargement of the ,italian hero is not ,rodin's amplification nor his expressiveness1 which is altogether nervous4 ,it is none the less true that these two men are the only ones who have imagined and realised a sculpturesque conception of so vast a reach4 ,not even ,puget and ,rude1 who came between them1 ventured such wholes as ,the ,tomb of the ,medici or ,the ,gate of ,hell4 ,,museums ,rodin has in the ,luxembourg ,museum 7,paris7 the following works3-- ,the ,age of ,brass1 originally placed in the ,luxembourg ,gardens near the ,school of ,mines4 ,the ,danaid 7marble74 ,thought 7marble74 ,st4 ,john the ,baptist ,preaching 7bronze74 ,the ,fair ,helmet-maker 7bronze74 ,bust of ,jean ,paul ,laurens 7bronze74 ,the ,kiss 7marble74 ,bust of ,mme4 ,v4 7marble74 ,at the ,petit ,palais 7,ville de ,paris71 one work4 ,at ,beziers1 ,cognac1 ,dijon1 ,douai1 ,lille1 and ,lyons1 several works4 ,at ,brussels1 one work4 ,at ,copenhagen1 several works4 ,at ,new ,york1 ,boston1 ,chicago1 and ,philadelphia1 works4 ,at ,helsingfors1 one work4 ,at ,rotterdam1 one work4 ,at ,geneva 7,rath ,museum71 three works4 ,at ,venice1 ,christiania1 ,st4 ,petersburg1 ,stockholm1 ,dsseldorf1 ,munich1 ,weimar1 ,vienna1 ,prague 7town hall71 one work in each town4 ,at ,hamburg1 three works4 ,at ,hagen1 three works4 ,at ,berlin 7new gallery of ,charlottenburg71 five works4 ,at ,crefeld1 two works4 ,at ,buda-,pest1 five works4 ,in ,london 7,victoria and ,albert ,museum71 two works2 7,british ,museum71 one work4 ,at ,glasgow1 one work4 ,museum of ,marseilles1 ,the ,inner ,voice 7clay74 ,the new works in these various museums are originals or casts4 ,,private ,,collections ,m4 ,vever 7,eve1 in marble74 ,m4 ,pontremoli 7the ,national ,defence47 ,m4 ,antony ,roux 7,the ,kiss74 ,m4 ,roger ,marx 7bust1 ,the ,young ,mother74 ,m4 ,blanc 7,the ,eternal ,idol47 ,m4 ,desmarais 7the ,idyll47 ,mme4 ,durand 7,thought1 in marble1 given to the ,luxembourg74 ,m4 ,peytel 7various groups74 ,mme4 ,russell 7,minerva47 ,m4 ,fenaille 7,the ,spring1 ,bust of ,mme4 ,f41 ,the ,poet and the ,life of ,contemplation1 a twisted column with figures1 surmounted by a mask74 ,baron ,vitta 7high-reliefs in stone74 ,the ,marquise de ,carcano 7,head of ,st4 ,john beheaded1 marble74 ,this1 of course1 is a very cursory list1 and includes only collections in ,paris4 ,i must add separately to the works published about ,rodin those for which ,i am responsible3 7#a7 a study1 called ,the ,art of ,m4 ,rodin1 ,revue des ,revues1 #aeth ,june1 #ahih2 this has been approved by the artist1 and very frequently reproduced4 7#b7 ,a lecture delivered on the #cast of ,july1 #aijj1 at the ,rodin exhibition1 and published by ,la ,plume1 with four unpublished drawings4 7#c7 ,an essay upon the surroundings1 personality1 and influence of ,rodin1 which appeared in the ,revue ,universelle in #aija1 and has likewise been reprinted1 particularly in the ,matres ,artistes 7special number1 #aeth ,october1 #aijc74 ,the high price of the work published by ,messrs4 ,goupil 7,a ,hundred and ,fort-two ,drawings by ,rodin7 prevents that fine volume from being accessible to the public4 ,the amateur photographer ,druet has taken photographs of all ,rodin's work1 which are rather misty1 but which render admirably the caressing touch of light on the main planes1 and which in a measure reproduce the artistic atmosphere of the statues4 ,messrs4 ,haweis and ,coles have likewise taken some beautiful and curious proofs4 ,more classic1 but also more definite1 are the fine photographs which the art publisher ,buloz has recently taken1 and which have been employed to illustrate this volume4 ,,portraits ,there is a remarkable portrait of ,rodin by ,mr4 ,john ,sargent 7dating from about twenty years ago74 ,another1 by ,m4 ,alphonse ,legros 7a profile71 is more of a fancy head1 and wears a sort of tiara4 ,a more recent portrait has been produced by ,mr4 ,alexander4 ,there is a very forcible bust by ,mile4 ,camille ,claudel1 as well as a bust by ,j4 ,desbois1 a lithograph by ,eugne ,carrire1 and some amusing studio sketches by ,mile4 ,cladel4 ,an interesting lithograph of ,rodin in his ,studio1 by ,w4 ,rothenstein1 appeared in the ,artist-,engraver1 ,april1 #aijd4 ,a curious photograph1 taken by ,m4 ,steichen2 a poster for the ,rodin exhibition1 containing a portrait1 and drawn by ,carrire2 and some excellent photographs taken at ,prague 7of which the one here reproduced is astonishingly faithful7 complete this list of likenesses4 ,,index ,achilles1 ,the ,education of ,adam 7destroyed7 ,adonis1 ,the ,death of ,age of ,brass1 ,the ,antiope 7of ,correggio71 ,the ,antique1 ,the1 influence of1 on ,rodin ,rodin's analysis of its right use its truth and beauty ,aphrodite 7by ,lucien ,schnegg7 ,apollo1 the two reliefs ,aube ,autumn 7stone7 ,avarice and ,lewdness ,balzac1 ,statue of ,barrias2 his monument to ,hugo ,bartholom ,bartlett ,barye ,bassier1 ,jean ,bastien-,lepage1 ,statue of ,baudelaire ,beauvais ,becque1 ,henry1 ,bust of dry-point portraits of ,bellona ,benedictions1 ,the ,bergerat1 ,m41 ,rodin's drawings for his book ,besnard1 ,mme4 ,boisbaudron1 ,lecoq de ,boucher1 the sculptor ,bourdelle1 ,emile ,broken ,nose1 ,the ,man with the ,brother and ,sister ,brussels ,burghers of ,calais1 ,the ,burgundian sculptors1 #ch ,busts1 ,rodin's portrait1 #ag1 #ah1 #ba1 #bi1 #ca1 #cc1 #hd ,carcano1 ,marchioness of ,carpeaux ,carrier-,belleuse ,carrire1 ,eugne his opinion of ,rodin's art ,caryatid1 ,the ,celtic genius1 ,the ,chaplin ,chappe1 ,a statue of ,chapu ,charpentier1 ,alexandre ,chartres1 ,the cathedral of ,christ and the ,magdalen ,christian ,martyr1 ,the ,cladel1 ,mlle4 ,classicism1 ,rodin's ,clodion ,clot1 lithographer ,conqueror1 ,a1 holding a ,statue of ,victory ,corneille ,correggio ,costume in sculpture1 ,the question of ,couston ,coysevox ,crouching ,man1 ,the ,dalou2 ,rodin's bust of ,dampt1 ,jean ,danaid1 ,the ,dante ,david of ,angers ,devillez ,day ,delacroix ,delaplanche ,desbois ,donatello ,drawings and sketches1 ,rodin's ,dream-,group ,dry-points1 ,rodin's ,dubois1 ,paul ,duhem1 ,henri ,dujalbert ,dutch painting ,egyptian sculpture ,eiffel ,tower ,emerson quoted ,erotic subjects1 ,rodin's treatment of ,etchings1 ,rodin's ,eternal ,idol1 ,the ,eve ,exhibited works ,exhibition with ,claude ,monet1 the ,fagel ,falconet ,falguire his ,balzac ,rodin's bust of ,faun and ,nymph ,fauns and ,bacchantes ,fenaille1 ,bust of ,mme4 ,fenaille1 ,m42 his edition of ,rodin's drawings ,fiennes1 ,jean de1 ,finish1 ,false notions of ,flemish primitives ,fleurs du ,mal1 ,baudelaire's ,rodin's illustrations to ,florence ,baptistery ,gates1 as model of ,the ,gate of ,hell ,france1 ,anatole ,franck1 ,medallion of ,csar ,frmiet ,fuller1 ,loe ,galatea ,gall1 ,emile ,gallimard1 ,m4 ,gardet ,gate of ,hell1 ,the ,genius of ,war1 ,the ,gluck1 #aje ,gothic sculptures1 ,rodin's study of ,goujon ,greek sculpture ,guillaume ,hand of ,god1 ,the ,hecuba ,helmet-maker1 ,the ,fair ,henley1 ,w4 ,e4 his opinion of ,rodin's art ,hokusai ,houdon ,hugo1 ,victor1 ,bust of dry-point portraits of the ,monument to ,icarus ,illusion1 the ,daughter of ,icarus ,inferno1 ,dante's ,inspiration ,iris ,italy1 ,rodin's travels in ,japanese bronzes and prints1 ,rodin's admiration of ,jasmin1 ,clment ,joan of ,arc1 ,rude's ,kiss1 ,the ,labour1 ,monument to ,lamartine ,laurens1 ,jean ,paul1 ,bust of ,lavoisier1 ,a statue of ,lefvre1 ,camille ,legros1 ,alphonse2 bust of ,lorraine1 ,claude1 ,the ,monument to ,louvre1 the ,love and ,psyche ,lovers1 ,groups of ,luxembourg1 ,the ,lynch1 ,statue of ,mac,coll1 ,d4 ,s4 ,magdalen1 ,the ,mahomet 7drawing7 ,mallarm1 ,stphane ,manet ,man ,walking ,man with the ,broken ,nose1 ,the 7clay head7 7marble7 ,marseillaise1 ,rude's ,marx1 ,roger bust of ,meditation ,meudon1 ,rodin's house and studio at ,michael ,angelo ,minerva 7helmeted bust7 7marble and silver7 ,minne1 ,george ,mirbeau1 ,octave bust of medallion of ,rodin's drawings for his books ,monet1 ,claude ,monument to the ,defenders of the ,nation ,morbidezza ,mother1 ,the ,young ,muse of ,anger ,muse of the ,inner ,voice ,museums ,nancy ,naples ,museum ,napoleon ,awakening to ,immortality1 ,rude's ,neo-,greek ,school1 ,errors and defects of ,nereids1 ,the ,niederhausern-,rodo ,night1 ,nude1 ,the ,nymph1 ,a1 ,orpheus and ,eurydice ,paintings1 ,rodin's ,pajou ,pantheon1 ,the ,perseus and the ,gorgon ,pica1 ,vittorio ,pigalle ,pilon1 ,germain ,poe ,poet and the ,life of ,contemplation1 ,the ,poets and ,muses ,prault1 ,auguste ,private ,collections ,proust1 ,antonin1 ,bust of dry-point of ,psyche ,puech1 ,denys ,puget ,puvis de ,chavannes2 bust of monument to ,pygmalion ,raphael ,redon1 ,odilon ,rembrandt ,renascence1 ,rodin's admiration for the1 #fc-e ,rimini1 ,paolo and ,francesca da ,rivire1 ,thodore ,rochefort1 ,bust of ,roche1 ,pierre1 in ,rodin1 ,auguste1 birth1 parentage1 and schooling early art-training under ,barye works for ornament-maker in ,carrier-,belleuse's studio early works in sculpture goes to ,brussels2 work there friendship with ,legros takes painting lessons from ,lecoq de ,boisbaudron accepted at ,salon accused of casting from life his first sale cleared of accusations sudden emergence from obscurity slow development attitude to academic art his originality and power noticed studios granted him by ,government works at ,svres his stay in ,brussels a formative time deeply impressed by ,dante and ,baudelaire 7and see under these names7 monument to ,hugo described impatience of officialism ,gate of ,hell described exhibition with ,claude ,monet in #ahhi monument to ,claude ,lorraine described ,burghers of ,calais described friendship with ,m4 ,fenaille the ,balzac and the controversy it excited visits to ,italy2 articles in the ,muse quoted at length at the ,paris ,exhibition of #aijj visit to ,prague1 #hd2 welcomed in ,london elected ,president of the ,international ,society honours personal appearance portraits of him private life and home house and studios tastes travels as a talker social opinions influence friends and pupils characteristics of his art artistic descent and affinities place in the ,french school lost works paintings dry-points drawings and treatment of voluptuous subjects photographs of his works essentially a poet2 as thinker classicism1 his his symbolism his composition his conception of his art analysed fondness for small groups his treatment of costume his treatment of flesh his principles of portraiture his endeavour to give atmosphere his works treated to be viewed from all sides his modelling his study and power of representing movement dynamic character of his art his synthetic power his veracity his favourite type of woman1 #db2 influence and value of the antique ,ronde1 ,the 7dry-point7 ,rops ,rosso ,rousseau ,rubens ,rude ,st4 ,john ,baptist ,st4 ,john ,baptist 7torso7 ,st4 ,john1 ,head of the ,beheaded 7marble7 ,saint ,marceaux ,st4 ,pierre1 ,eustacede ,salon1 the ,sappho ,sargent ,sarmiento1 ,monument to ,president ,schnegg1 ,gaston and ,lucien ,sverine1 ,bust of ,madame ,svres ,shades1 ,the ,socit des ,gens de ,lettres ,spring1 ,eternal ,spring ,summer ,tanagra figures ,thinker1 ,the ,thomas ,thought1 ,torso 7nude female bronze7 ,turquet ,ugolino 7drawing7 ,values in painting and sculpture ,van der ,meer ,van ,rasbourg ,venus and ,adonis ,vicunha1 ,monument to the ,president ,villon ,wagner1 #aai1 #abj ,watteau1 #ha ,wave1 ,the ,whistler ,wissant1 ,jacques and ,pierre de ,woman1 ,bust of ,woman1 ,bust of a ,young ,woman1 ,bust of a ,young 7silver7 ,women and ,children ,women ,bathing ,women ,damned