,,volume ,,iv4 ,,works ,,( ,,plot9os4 ,,plot9os ,complete ,works ,9 ,*ronological ,ord]1 ,gr\p$ 9 ,f\r ,p]iods2 ,) ,,biography by ,,porphyry1 ,,eunapius1 ,,suidas1 ,,comm5t>y by ,,porphyry1 ,,illu/rations by ,,jambli*us ,,ammonius1 ,,/udies 9 ,s\rces1 ,developm5t1 ,influ5ce2 ,,index ( ,subjects1 ,?\ghts & ,words4 by ,,k5ne? ,,sylvan ,,gu?rie1 ,pr(essor 9 ,ext5sion1 ,univ]sity ( ! ,s\?1 ,sewanee2 ,a4,m41 ,sewanee1 & ,h>v>d2 ,ph4,d41 ,tulane1 & ,columbia4 ,m4,d41 ,m$ico-,*irurgical ,college1 ,philadelphia4 ,,vol4 ,,iv ,eu/o*ian ,books1 #df-ed2 ,comm5t4 ,,comp>ative ,,lit]ature ,,press ,p4,o4 ,box #db1 ,,alp9e1 ,n4,j41 ,u4,s4,a4 ,copyright1 #aiah1 by ,k5ne? ,sylvan ,gu?rie4 ,all ,rights1 includ+ t ( ,translation1 ,res]v$4 ,ent]$ at ,/ation]s' ,hall1 by ,george ,bell & ,sons1 ,portugal ,/reet1 ,l9coln's ,inn1 ,london4 ,,fir/ ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,f\r4 ,:e!r ,animals ,may ,be ,t]m$ ,happy4#a ,,def9itions ,,( ,,happ9ess4 #a4 ,! 7,ari/otelian7 ideal ( liv+ well & happ9ess are 7practically7 id5tical4 ,%\ld we1 on t acc\nt1 grant ev5 to animals ! privilege ( a*iev+ happ9ess8 ,:y might we n say t !y live well1 if x be grant$ !m1 9 _! lives1 to foll[ ! c\rse ( nature1 )\t ob/acles8 ,= if to live well consi/ ei!r 9 pleasure 7pleasant passions1 z ! ,epicureans taught71 or 9 realiz+ "o's own individual aim 7! ,/oic ideal71 !n ?is liv+ well is1 9 ei!r case1 possible = animals1 :o c bo? enjoy pleasure1 & accompli% _! peculi> aim4 ,?us s++ birds live a life desirable = !m1 if !y enjoy pleasure1 & s+ con=mably to _! nature4 ,if fur!r we %\ld def9e happ9ess z a*iev+ ! supreme purpose t[>ds :i* nature aspires 7! ,/oic ideal71 we %\ld1 ev5 9 ?is case1 admit t animals %>e 9 happ9ess :5 !y accompli% ?is supreme purpose4 ,!n nature ar\ses 9 !m no fur!r desires1 because _! :ole c>e] is complet$1 & _! life is fill$ f beg9n+ to end4 ,,:e!r ,,plants ,,may ,,be ,,t]m$ ,,happy4 ,!re are no d\bt "s :o may object to our admitt+ to happ9ess liv+ be+s o!r ?an man4 ,!y might ev5 po9t out t on ?is basis happ9ess c\ld n be refus$ to ev5 ! l[e/ be+s1 su* z plants3 = !y also live1 _! life also has a purpose1 by :i* !y seek to fulfil _! developm5t4 ,h[ev]1 x w\ld seem r unreasonable to say1 t liv+ be+s o!r ?an humans _c possess happ9ess by ?is m]e reason t to u !y seem pitiable4 ,besides1 x w\ld be q possible to d5y to plants :at may be pr$icat$ ( o!r liv+ be+s1 on ! gr\nds t plants lack emotion4 ,"s might hold !y are capable ( happ9ess1 on ! /r5g? ( _! possess+ life1 = a be+ t lives c live well or badly2 & 9 ?is way we c\ld say t !y possess or lack well-be+1 & be>1 or d n be> fruits4 ,if 7z ,ari/ippus ?\ght71 pleasure is ! goal ( man1 & if to live well is con/itut$ by enjoy+ x1 x w\ld be absurd to claim t no liv+ be+s o!r ?an man c\ld live well4 ,! same argum5t applies if we def9e happ9ess z 7a /ate ( imp]turbable tranquility1 by ,epicurus call$7 at>axy2#b or z 7! ,/oic ideal1#c (7 liv+ con=mably to nature4 ,,liv+ ,,well ,,ne$ ,,n ,,be ,,ext5d$ ,,ev5 ,,to ,,all ,,animals4 #b4 ,^? :o d5y ! privilege ( liv+ well to plants1 because ^! lack s5sation1 are n on t acc\nt oblig$ to grant x to all animals4 ,=1 if s5sation consi/ 9 ! k ( ! exp]i5c$ affection1 ?is affection mu/ already be good be=e ! occurr5ce ( ! k4 ,= in/ance1 ! be+ mu/ be 9 a /ate con=mable to nature ev5 ?\gh ignorant !re(4 ,he mu/ fulfil 8 prop] function ev5 :5 he does n "k x4 ,he mu/ possess pleasure be=e p]ceiv+ x4 ,?us if1 by ! possession ( ?is pleasure1 ! be+ already possesses ! ,good1 he !reby possesses ev5 well-be+4 ,:at ne$ !n is !re to jo9 !reto s5sation1 unless inde$ well-be+ be def9$ z s5sation & k 7( an affection or /ate ( ! s\l7 r ?an 9 ! latt] affection & /ate ( ! s\l itself8 ,,ev5 ,,!y ,,:o ,,def9e ,,happ9ess ,,z ,,s5sation ,,seek ,,high] ,,happ9ess4 ,! ,good w\ld ?us be r$uc$ to no m ?an s5sation1 or ! actualization ( ! s5se-life4 ,9 ?is case1 to possess x1 x is suffici5t to p]ceive irrespective ( ! cont5t ( t p]ception4 ,o!r p]sons might ass]t t goodness results f ! union ( ^! two ?+s3 ( ! /ate ( ! s\l1 & ( ! k ! s\l has ( x4 ,if !n ! ,good consi/ 9 ! p]ception ( "s p>ticul> /ate1 we %all h to ask h[ elem5ts :i*1 by !mselves1 are indiff]5t c\ld1 by _! union1 con/itute ! good4 ,o!r !ories are t ! ,good consi/s 9 "s p>ticul> /ate1 or 9 possession ( "s p>ticul> disposition1 & consci\s enjoym5t ( ! pres5ce ( ! ,good4 ,^! w\ld1 h[ev]1 /ill h to answ] ! "q :e!r1 = good liv+1 x be suffici5t t ! be+ kn[s he possesses ?is /ate2 or mu/ he "k n only t ?is /ate is pleasant1 b also t x is ! ,good8 ,if !n x be necess>y to realize t x is ! ,good1 ! matt] is "o no long] ( ! function ( s5sation1 b ( a faculty high] ?an ! s5ses4 ,to live well1 9 ?is case1 x w no long] be suffici5t to possess pleasure1 b we %all h to "k t pleasure is ! ,good4 ,! cause ( happ9ess w n be ! pres5ce ( pleasure itself1 b ! p[] ( judg+ t pleasure is a good4 ,n[ judgm5t is sup]ior to affection2 x is reason or intellig5ce1 :ile pleasure is only an affection1 & :at is irrational c\ld n be sup]ior to reason4 ,h[ w\ld reason =get itself to recognize z sup]ior :at is posit$ 9 a g5us oppos$ to x8 ,^! m5 :o d5y happ9ess to plants1 :o expla9 x z "s =m ( s5sation1 seems to u1 9 spite ( !mselves1 to be really seek+ happ9ess ( a high] nature1 & to consid] x z ?is bett] ?+ :i* is f\nd only 9 a complet] life4 ,,n ,,ev5 ,,reason ,,is ,a ,,suffici5t ,,explanation ,,( ,,liv+ ,,well4 ,!re is a great] *ance ( be+ "r 9 ! op9ion t happ9ess consi/s 9 ! reasonable life1 in/ead ( m]e life1 ev5 ?\gh unit$ to s5sation4 ,/ill ev5 ?is !ory mu/ expla9 :y happ9ess %\ld be ! privilege ( ! reasonable animal4 ,%\ld we add to ! idea ( an animal ! quality ( be+ reasonable1 because reason is m sagaci\s1 m skilful 9 discov]+1 & 9 procur+ ! objects necess>y to satisfy ! fir/ ne$s ( nature8 ,w\ld y e/eem reason j z highly if x 7 incapable ( discov]+1 or procur+ ^! objects8 ,if we value reason only = ! objects x aids u 9 gett+1 happ9ess might v well belong to ! v irrational be+s1 if !y are1 )\t reason1 able to procure !mselves ! ?+s necess>y to ! satisfaction ( ! fir/ ne$s ( _! nature4 ,9 ?is case1 reason w be no?+ m ?an an in/rum5t4 ,x w n be wor? seek+ out = itself1 & its p]fection1 9 :i* virtue has be5 %[n to consi/1 w be ( little importance4 ,! opposite !ory w\ld be t reason does n owe its value to its ability to procure = u objects necess>y to ! satisfaction ( ! fir/ ne$s ( nature1 b t x des]ves to be s\ght out = itself4 ,b ev5 "h we w\ld h to expla9 its function1 its nature1 & set =? h[ x becomes p]fect4 ,if x 7 to be improvable1 x mu/ n be def9$ z ! contemplation ( s5se-objects1 = its p]fection & ess5ce 7be+7 consi/ 9 a diff]5t 7& high]7 function4 ,x is n among ! fir/ ne$s ( nature1 nor among ! objects necess>y to ! satisfaction ( its ne$s2 x has no?+ to d ) !m1 be+ f> sup]ior4 ,o!rwise1 ^! philosoph]s w\ld be h>d press$ to expla9 its value4 ,until !y discov] "s nature f> sup]ior to ! class ( objects ) :i* !y at pres5t rema91 !y w h to rema9 :]e x suits !m to be1 ignorant ( :at good liv+ is1 & bo? h[ to rea* t goal1 & to :at be+s x is possible4 ,,happ9ess ,,dep5ds ,,exclusively ,,on ,,int]ior ,,*>act]i/ics4 #c4 ,dismiss+ ^! !ories1 we return to our own def9ition ( happ9ess4 ,we d n necess>ily make life synonym\s ) happ9ess by attribut+ happ9ess to a liv+ be+4 ,o!rwise1 we w\ld be imply+ t all liv+ be+s c a*ieve x1 & we w\ld be admitt+ to real complete enjoym5t !re( all ^? :o possess$ t union & id5tity :i* all liv+ be+s are naturally capable ( possess+4 ,f9ally1 x w\ld be difficult to grant ?is privilege to ! reasonable be+1 :ile refus+ x to ! brute2 = bo? equally possess life4 ,!y %\ld1 !re=e1 be capable ( a*iev+ happ9ess--=1 on ?is hypo!sis1 happ9ess c\ld be no m ?an a k9d ( life4 ,consequ5tly1 ! philosoph]s :o make x consi/ 9 ! rational life1 n 9 ! life common to all be+s1 d n p]ceive t !y implicitly suppose t happ9ess is some?+ diff]5t f life4 ,!y are !n oblig$ to say t happ9ess resides 9 a pure quality1 9 ! rational faculty4 ,b ! subject 7to :i* !y %\ld ref] happ9ess7 is ! rational life1 s9ce happ9ess c belong only to ! totality 7( life jo9$ to reason74 ,!y !re=e1 really limit ! life !y speak ( to a c]ta9 k9d ( life2 n t !y h ! "r to consid] ^! two k9ds ( life 7life 9 g5]al1 & rational life7 z be+ rank$ alike1 z bo? memb]s ( a s+le division w\ld be1 b ano!r k9d ( di/9ction might be e/abli%$ betwe5 !m1 su* z :5 we say t "o ?+ is prior1 & ! o!r po/]ior4 ,s9ce life may be und]/ood 9 diff]5t s5ses1 & z x possesses diff]5t degrees1 & s9ce by m]e v]bal simil>ity life may be equally pr$icat$ ( plants & ( irrational animals1 & s9ce its diff]5ces consi/ 9 be+ m or less complete1 analogy dem&s a simil> treatm5t ( liv+ well4 ,if1 by its life1 a be+ be ! image ( "s o!r be+1 by its happ9ess x w also be ! image ( ! happ9ess ( ?is o!r be+4 ,if happ9ess be ! privilege ( complete life1 ! be+ t possesses a complete life w also alone possess happ9ess2 = x possesses :at is be/ s9ce1 9 ! ord] ( ^! exi/5ces1 ! be/ is possession ( ! ess5ce 7be+7 & p]fection ( life4 ,consequ5tly1 ! ,good is n any?+ incid5tal1 = no subject c\ld owe its good to a quality t w\ld be d]iv$ f else:]e4 ,:at inde$ c\ld be add$ to complete life1 to r5d] x excell5t8 ,,! ,,good ,,consi/s ,,9 ,,intellig5ce4 ,our own def9ition ( ! ,good1 int]e/$ z we are n 9 its cause1 b 9 its ess5ce1 is t ! p]fect life1 t is g5u9e & real1 consi/s 9 intellig5ce4 ,! o!r k9ds ( life are imp]fect4 ,!y (f] no m ?an ! image ( life4 ,!y are n ,life 9 its fulness & purity4 ,z we h (t5 said !y are n life1 r ?an its contr>y4 ,9 "o ^w1 s9ce all liv+ be+s are d]iv$ f "o & ! same ,pr9ciple1 & s9ce !y d n possess an equal degree ( life1 ?is pr9ciple mu/ necess>ily be ! prim>y ,life1 & p]fectness4 ,,happ9ess ,,mu/ ,,be ,,some?+ ,,human4 #d4 ,if man be capable ( possess+ p]fect ,life1 he is happy z soon z he possesses x4 ,if x 7 o!rwise1 if ! p]fect life p]ta9$ to ! div9ities alone1 to !m alone also w\ld happ9ess belong4 ,b s9ce we attribute happ9ess to m51 we %all h to set =? 9 :at t :i* procures x consi/s4 ,i repeat1 :at results f our =m] consid]ations1 namely1 t man has p]fect ,life :51 besides ! s5se-life1 he possesses reason & true intellig5ce4 ,b is man z su* /rang] to ! p]fect ,life1 & does he possess x z some?+ ali5 7to 8 ess5tial be+78 ,no1 = no man lacks happ9ess entirely1 ei!r actually or ev5 pot5tially4 ,b %all we consid] happ9ess z a "p ( ! man1 & t he 9 himself is ! p]fect =m ( life8 ,we _h bett] ?9k t he :o is a /rang] to ! p]fect ,life possesses only a "p ( happ9ess1 z he possesses happ9ess only pot5tially2 b t he :o possesses ! p]fect ,life 9 actuality1 & he :o has succe$$ 9 id5tify+ himself ) x1 alone is happy4 ,all ! o!r ?+s1 no m ?an envelope him 7z ! ,/oics w\ld say71 & c\ld n be consid]$ z p>ts ( him1 s9ce !y surr\nd him 9 spite ( himself4 ,!y w\ld belong to him z p>ts ( himself1 if !y 7 jo9$ to him by ! result ( 8 w4 ,:at is ! ,good = a man :o f9ds himself 9 ?is condition8 ,by ! p]fect life :i* he possesses1 he himself is 8 own good4 ,! pr9ciple 7! ,good 9 itself7 :i* is sup]ior 7to ! p]fect ,life7 is ! cause ( ! good :i* is 9 him2 = we mu/ n confuse ! ,good 9 itself--& ! good 9 man4 ,,we ,,"k ,,we ,,h ,,rea*$ ,,happ9ess ,,:5 ,,we ,,no ,,m ,,desire ,,any?+4 ,t ! man :o has a*iev$ p]fect ,life possesses happ9ess is prov$ by 8 no long] desir+ any?+4 ,:at m c\ld he desire8 ,he c\ld n desire any?+ inf]ior2 he is unit$ to ! be/2 he1 !re=e1 has fulness ( life4 ,if he be virtu\s he is fully happy1 & fully possesses ! ,good1 = no good ?+ escapes him4 ,:at he seeks is s\ght only by necessity1 less = him ?an = "s ( ! ?+s :i* belong to him4 ,he seeks x = ! body t is unit$ to him2 & ?\gh ?is body be end[$ ) life1 :at relates to 8 ne$s is n *>act]i/ic ( ! real man4 ,! latt] kn[s x1 & :at he grants to 8 body1 he grants )\t 9 any way dep>t+ f 8 own *>act]i/ic life4 ,8 happ9ess w1 !re=e1 n be dim9i%$ 9 adv]sity1 because he cont9ues to possess v]itable life4 ,if he lose relatives or fri5ds1 he kn[s ! nature ( dea?1 & besides ^? :om x /rikes d[n "k x also if !y 7 virtu\s4 ,?\gh he may all[ himself to be afflict$ by ! fate ( ^! relatives or fri5ds1 ! affliction w n rea* ! intimate "p ( 8 nature2 ! affliction w be felt only by t "p ( ! s\l :i* lacks reason1 & ^: suff]+ ! man w n %>e4 ,,m5 ,,mu/ ,,seek ,,_! ,,happ9ess ,,9 ,,t ,,( ,,ea* ,,( ,,! ,,p>ts ,,( ,,_! ,,nature4 #e4 ,x has (t5 be5 object$ t we %\ld reckon ) ! bodily pa9s1 ! diseases1 ! ob/acles :i* may h9d] action1 cases ( unconsci\sness1 :i* might result f c]ta9 philtres & diseases 7z ! ,p]ipatetics object$#d74 ,"u ^! conditions1 !y say1 ! sage c\ld n live well1 & be happy--)\t ei!r m5tion+ pov]ty & lack ( recognition4 ,all ^! evils1 n =gett+ ! fam\s mis=tunes ( ,priam1#e ju/ify s]i\s objections4 ,inde$1 ev5 if ! sage endur$ all ^! evils 7z inde$ he easily does71 !y w\ld none ! less be contr>y to 8 w2 & happy life mu/ necess>ily be "o t con=ms to our w4 ,! sage is n only a s\l end[$ ) p>ticul> dispositions2 ! body also mu/ be compris$ )9 8 p]sonality 7z also ?\ght ! ,py?agorean ,ar*ytas#f74 ,?is ass]tion seems reasonable s f> z ! passions ( ! body are felt by ! man himself1 & z !y sugge/ desires & av]sions to him4 ,if !n pleasure be an elem5t ( happ9ess1 h[ c\ld ! man afflict$ by ! bl[s ( fate & by pa9s /ill be happy1 ev5 if he 7 virtu\s8 ,to be happy1 ! div9ities ne$ only to enjoy p]fect life2 b m51 hav+ _! s\l unit$ to a l[] "p1 mu/ seek _! happ9ess 9 ! life ( ea* ( ^! two p>ts t compose him1 & n exclusively 9 "o ( ! two1 ev5 ?\gh x 7 ! high]4 ,inde$1 z soon z "o ( !m suff]s1 ! o!r "o1 9 spite ( its sup]iority1 f9ds its actions h9d]$4 ,o!rwise we %all h to reg>d nei!r ! body1 nor ! s5sations t fl[ f x2 & to seek only :at by itself c\ld suffice to procure happ9ess1 indep5d5tly ( ! body4 ,,necess>y ,,?+s ,,are ,,^? ,,^: ,,possession ,,is ,,unconsci\s4 #f4 ,if our exposition ( ! subject _h def9$ happ9ess z exemption f pa91 sickness1 rev]ses1 & great mis=tunes1 7we w\ld h impli$ t7 x w\ld be impossible = u to ta/e happ9ess :ile expos$ to "o ( ^? evils4 ,b if happ9ess consi/ 9 ! possession ( ! real good1 :y %\ld we =get ?is good to consid] its accessories8 ,:y1 9 ! appreciation ( ?is good1 %\ld we seek ?+s :i* are n among ! numb] ( its elem5ts8 ,if x consi/$ 9 a union ( ! true goods ) ^? ?+s :i* alone are necess>y to our ne$s1 or :i* are s call$1 ev5 )\t be+ su*1 we %\ld h to /rive to possess ! latt] also4 ,b z ! goal ( man mu/ be s+le & n manifold--= o!rwise x w\ld be usual to say t he seeks 8 ends1 r ?an ! m common expression1 8 end--we %all h to seek only :at is mo/ high & preci\s1 :at ! s\l someh[ wi%es to include4 ,h] incl9ation & w _c aspire to any?+ :i* is n ! sov]eign good4 ,reason only avoids c]ta9 evils1 & seeks c]ta9 advantages1 because x is provok$ by _! pres5ce2 b x is n s l$ by nature4 ,! pr9cipal t5d5cy ( ! s\l is direct$ t[>ds :at is be/2 :5 %e possesses x1 %e is satisfi$1 & /ops2 only !n does %e enjoy a life really con=mable to h] w4 ,speak+ ( w /rictly1#g & n ) unju/ifiable lic5se1 ! task ( ! w is n to procure ?+s necess>y to our ne$s 787 ,( c\rse we judge t x is suitable to procure ?+s t are necess>y1 z we 9 g5]al avoid evils4 ,b ! avoid+ ( !m is no aim desirable 9 itself2 su* w\ld r be n to ne$ to avoid !m4 ,?is1 = in/ance1 occurs :5 "o possesses heal? & is exempt f suff]+4 ,:i* ( ^! advantages mo/ attracts u8 ,s long z we enjoy heal?1 s long z we d n suff]1 x is little valu$4 ,n[ advantages :i*1 :5 pres5t1 h no attraction = ! s\l1 & add no?+ to h] happ9ess1 & :i*1 :5 abs5t1 are s\ght z causes ( ! suff]+ aris+ f ! pres5ce ( _! contr>ies1 %\ld reasonably be call$ necessity r ?an goods1 & n be reckon$ among ! elem5ts ( our goal4 ,:5 !y are abs5t & replac$ by _! contr>ies1 our goal rema9s j :at x 04 ,,evils ,,:i* ,,! ,,wise ,,man ,,c ,,support ,,)\t ,,di/urbance ,,( ,,8 ,,happ9ess4 #g4 ,:y !n does ! happy man desire to enjoy ! pres5ce ( ^! advantages1 & ! abs5ce ( _! contr>ies8 ,x mu/ be because !y contribute1 n to 8 happ9ess1 b to 8 exi/5ce2 because _! contr>ies t5d to make him lose exi/5ce1 h9d]+ ! enjoym5t ( ! good1 )\t h[ev] remov+ x4 ,besides1 he :o possesses :at is be/ wi%es to possess x purely1 )\t any mixture4 ,nev]!less1 :5 a =eign ob/acle occurs1 ! good /ill p]si/s ev5 9 spite ( ?is ob/acle4 ,9 %ort1 if "s accid5t happ5 to ! happy man aga9/ 8 w1 8 happ9ess is 9 no way affect$ !reby4 ,o!rwise1 he w\ld *ange & lose 8 happ9ess daily2 z if1 = in/ance1 he _h to m\rn a son1 or if he lo/ "s ( 8 possessions4 ,_m ev5ts may occur aga9/ 8 wi% )\t di/urb+ him 9 ! enjoym5t ( ! good he has atta9$4 ,x may be object$ t x is ! great mis=tunes1 & n trifl+ accid5ts 7:i* c di/urb ! happ9ess ( ! wise man74 ,nev]!less1 9 human ?+s1 is !re any great en\gh n to be scorn$ by him :o has climb$ to a pr9ciple sup]ior to all1 & :o no long] dep5ds on l[] ?+s8 ,su* a man w n be able to see any?+ great 9 ! favors ( =tune1 :atev] !y be1 z 9 be+ k+1 9 comm&+ t[ns1 or peoples2 9 f\nd+ or build+ cities1 ev5 ?\gh he himself %\ld receive t glory2 he w atta* no importance to ! loss ( 8 p[]1 or ev5 to ! ru9 ( 8 fa!rl&4 ,if he consid] all t z a great evil1 or ev5 only z an evil1 he w h a ridicul\s op9ion4 ,he w no long] be a virtu\s man2 =1 z ,jupit] is my witness1 he w\ld be highly valu+ m]e wood1 or /ones1 bir?1 or dea?2 :ile he %\ld insi/ on ! inconte/able tru? t dea? is bett] ?an ! corporeal life 7z held by ,h]odotus74 ,ev5 ?\gh he 7 sacrific$1 he w\ld n consid] dea? any worse m]ely because x occurr$ at ! feet ( ! alt>s4 ,be+ buri$ is really ( small importance1 = 8 body w rot z well above z bel[ gr\nd 7z ?\ght ,!odorus ( ,cyr5e74#h ,nei!r w he grieve at be+ buri$ )\t pomp & vulg> o/5tation1 & to h seem$ unwor?y ( be+ plac$ 9 a magnific5t tomb4 ,t w\ld be smallness ( m9d4 ,if he 7 c>ri$ (f z a captive1 he w\ld /ill h a road op5 to leave life1 9 ! case t he %\ld no long] be all[$ to hope = happ9ess4 7,nor w\ld he be tr\bl$ if ! memb]s ( 8 family1 su* z sons 787 & daught]s 7& female relatives87 7 c>ri$ (f into captivity4 ,if he _h arriv$ to ! end ( 8 life )\t see+ su* occurr5ces 7we w\ld inde$ be surpris$74 ,w\ld he leave ?is _w suppos+ t su* ?+s _c happ58 ,su* an op9ion w\ld be absurd4 ,w\ld he n h realiz$ t 8 own k9dr$ 7 expos$ to su* dang]s8 ,! op9ion t su* ?+s c\ld happ5 w n make him any less happy4 ,no1 he w be happy ev5 ) t belief4 ,he w\ld /ill be s ev5 %\ld t occur2 he w inde$ reflect t su* is ! nature ( ?is _w1 t "o mu/ und]go su* accid5ts1 & submit4 ,(t5 p]haps m5 dragg$ into captivity w live bett] 7?an 9 lib]ty72 & besides1 if _! captivity be insupportable1 x is 9 _! p[] to release !mselves4 ,if !y rema91 x is ei!r because _! reason s induces !m--& !n _! lot _c be too h>d2 or x is aga9/ ! dictates ( _! reason1 9 :i* case !y h none b !mselves to blame4 ,! wise man1 !re=e1 w n be unhappy because ( ! folly ( 8 own p2 he w n all[ 8 lot to dep5d on ! happ9ess or mis=tunes ( o!r p4 ,,no ,,mis=tune ,,is ,,too ,,great ,,to ,,be ,,conqu]$ ,,by ,,virtue4 #h4 ,if ! griefs t he himself und]goes are great1 he w support !m z well z he c2 if !y exce$ 8 p[] ( endurance1 !y w c>ry him (f 7z ?\ght ,s5eca#i74 ,9 ei!r case1 he w n1 9 ! mid/ ( 8 suff]+s1 excite any pity3 7ev] ma/] ( 8 reason7 he w n all[ 8 own *>act]i/ic light to be ext+ui%$4 ,?us ! flame 9 ! ligh?\se cont9ues to %9e1 9 spite ( ! rag+ ( ! tempe/1 9 spite ( ! viol5t bl[+ ( ! w9ds4 7,he %\ld n be upset7 ev5 by loss ( consci\sness1 or ev5 if pa9 becomes s /rong t its viol5ce c\ld almo/ annihilate him4 ,if pa9 become m int5se1 he w decide z to :at to d2 =1 "u ^! circum/ances1 fre$om ( w is n necess>ily lo/ 7= suicide rema9s possible1 z ?\ght ,s5eca#aj74 ,besides1 we mu/ realize t ^! suff]+s d n pres5t !mselves to ! wise man1 "u ! same light z to ! common man2 t all ^! ne$ n p5etrate to ! sanctu>y ( ! man's life2 :i* inde$ happ5s ) ! great] "p ( pa9s1 griefs & evils t we see be+ suff]$ by o!rs2 x w\ld be pro( ( weakness to be affect$ !reby4 ,a no less manife/ m>k ( weakness is to consid] x an advantage to ignore all ^! evils1 & to e/eem ourselves happy t !y happ5 only aft] dea?1#aa )\t sympa?iz+ ) ! fate ( o!rs1 & ?9k+ only to sp>e ourselves "s grief4 ,?is w\ld be a weakness t we %\ld elim9ate 9 ourselves1 n all[+ ourselves to be fright5$ by ! fe> ( :at might happ54 ,! objection t x is natural to be afflict$ at ! mis=tunes ( ^? :o surr\nd u1 meets ! answ] t1 to beg9 )1 x is n s ) e p]son2 !n1 t x is "p ( ! duty ( virtue to ameliorate ! common condition ( human nature1 & to raise x to :at is m beautiful1 ris+ above ! op9ions ( ! common p4 ,x is inde$ beautiful n to yield to :at ! common p usually consid] to be evils4 ,we %\ld /ruggle aga9/ ! bl[s ( =tune n by affect$ ignor+ 7( difficulties1 l an o/ri*71 b z a skilful a?lete :o kn[s t ! dang]s he is incurr+ are fe>$ by c]ta9 natures1 ?\gh a nature su* z 8 be>s !m easily1 see+ 9 !m no?+ t]rible1 or at lea/ consid]+ !m t]rify+ only to *ildr54 ,c]ta9ly1 ! wise man w\ld n h invit$ ^! evils2 b on be+ ov]tak5 by !m he opposes to !m ! virtue :i* r5d]s ! s\l un%akable & impassible4 ,,wisdom ,,is ,,none ,,! ,,less ,,happy ,,= ,,be+ ,,unconsci\s ,,( ,,itself4 #i4 ,x may fur!r be object$ t ! wise man might lose consci\sness1 if ov]:elm$ by disease1 or ! malice ( magic4 ,w\ld he /ill rema9 happy8 ,ei!r he w rema9 virtu\s1 be+ only fall5 asleep2 9 :i* case he might cont9ue to be happy1 s9ce no "o claims he mu/ lose happ9ess because ( sleep1 inasmu* z no reckon+ ( ! "t sp5t 9 ?is condition is kept1 & z he is none ! less consid]$ happy = life4 ,on ! o!r h&1 if unconsci\sness be held to t]m9ate virtue1 ! "q at issue is giv5 up2 =1 suppos+ t he cont9ues to be virtu\s1 ! "q at issue 01 :e!r he rema9 happy s long z he rema9s virtu\s4 ,x might inde$ /ill be object$ t he _c be happy if he rema9 virtu\s )\t feel+ x1 )\t act+ 9 con=mity ) virtue4 ,our answ] is t a man w\ld n be any less h&some or heal?y = be+ s unconsci\sly4 ,likewise1 he w\ld n be any less wise m]ely = lack ( consci\sness !re(4 ,,?\gh ,,happ9ess ,,is ,,actualiz$ ,,wisdom ,,we ,,d ,,n ,,lose ,,x ,,:5 ,,unconsci\s4 ,,we ,,d ,,n ,,lose ,,x ,,because ,,we ,,ourselves ,,are ,,actualizations ,,( ,,intellig5ce4 ,once m x may be object$ t x is ess5tial to wisdom to be self-consci\s1 = happ9ess resides only 9 actualiz$ wisdom4 ,?is objection w\ld hold if reason & wisdom 7 incid5tals4 ,b if ! hypo/atic sub/ance ( wisdom consi/ 9 an ess5ce 7be+71 or r1 9 be+ itself1 & if ?is be+ d n p]i% dur+ sleep1 nor dur+ unconsci\sness1 if consequ5tly ! activity ( be+ cont9ue to subsi/ 9 him2 if by its v nature ?is 7be+7 ceaselessly wat*1 !n ! virtu\s man mu/ ev5 9 ?is /ate 7( sleep or unconsci\sness71 cont9ue to ex]cise 8 activity4 ,besides1 ?is activity is ignor$ only by "o "p ( himself1 & n by himself entirely4 ,?us dur+ ! op]ation ( ! actualization ( gr[?1#ab ! p]ception ( its activity is n by 8 s5sibility transmitt$ to ! re/ ( ! man4 ,if our p]sonality 7 con/itut$ by ?is actualization ( gr[?1 we w\ld act simultane\sly ) x2 b we are n ?is actualization1 b t ( ! intellectual pr9ciple1 & t is :y we are active simultane\sly ) ?is 7div9e intellectual activity74 ,,intellig5ce ,,is ,,n ,,dep5d5t ,,on ,,consci\sness4 #aj4 ,! reason t intellig5ce rema9s hidd5 is j because x is n felt2 only by ! means ( ?is feel+ c ?is activity be felt2 b :y %\ld intellig5ce cease to act 7m]ely because x 0 n felt78 ,on ! o!r h&1 :y c\ld ! s\l n h turn$ h] activity t[>ds intellig5ce be=e hav+ felt or p]ceiv$ x8 ,s9ce 7= intellig5ce7 ?9k+ & exi/5ce are id5tical1 p]ception mu/ h be5 prec$$ by "s actualization4 ,x seems impossible = p]ception to arise except :5 ?\ght reflects ^u itself1 & :5 ! pr9ciple ^: activity con/itutes ! life ( ! s\l1 s to speak1 turns backw>ds1 & reflects1 z ! image ( an object plac$ be=e a brilliant poli%$ mirror reflects itself !re94 ,likewise1 if ! mirror be plac$ opposite ! object1 !re is no m image2 & if ! mirror be )drawn or badly adju/$1 !re is no m image1 ?\gh ! lum9\s object cont9ue to act4 ,likewise1 :5 t faculty ( ! s\l :i* repres5ts to u ! images ( discursive reason & ( intellig5ce is 9 a suitable condition ( calm1 we get an intuition--t is1 a some:at s5sual p]ception !re(--) ! prior k ( ! activity ( ! intellig5ce1 & ( discursive reason4 ,:51 h[ev]1 ?is image is tr\bl$ by an agitation 9 ! mutual h>mony ( ! organs1 ! discursive reason1 & ! intellig5ce cont9ue to act )\t any image1 & ! ?\ght does n reflect 9 ! imag9ation4 ,!re=e we %all h to insi/ t ?\ght is accompani$ by an image )\t1 nev]!less1 be+ "o itself4 ,:ile we are awake1 x (t5 happ5s to u to p]=m praisewor?y ?+s1 to m$itate & to act1 )\t be+ consci\s ( ^! op]ations at ! mom5t t we produce !m4 ,:5 = in/ance we read some?+1 we are n necess>ily self-consci\s t we are read+1 especially if our att5tion be fully c5t]$ on :at we read4 ,nei!r is a brave man :o is p]=m+ a c\rage\s de$1 self-consci\s ( 8 brav]y4 ,!re are _m o!r su* cases4 ,x w\ld !re=e seem t ! consci\sness ( any de$ weak5s its en]gy1 & t :5 ! action is alone 7)\t t consci\sness7 x is 9 a pur]1 liveli] & m vital condition4 ,:5 virtu\s m5 are 9 t condition 7( abs5ce ( self-consci\sness71 _! life is m int5se because x conc5trates 9 itself in/ead ( m+l+ ) feel+4 ,,! ,,only ,,object ,,( ,,! ,,virtu\s ,,w ,,is ,,! ,,conv]sion ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,t[>ds ,,h]self4 #aa4 ,x has sometimes be5 said t a man 9 su* a condition does n really live4 7,if su* be _! hone/ op9ion71 !y mu/ be told t he does live1 ev5 if !y be incapable ( und]/&+ 8 happ9ess & 8 life4 ,if ?is seem to !m incr$ible1 !y %\ld reflect :e!r _! own admission t su* a man lives & is virtu\s1 does n imply t "u ^? circum/ances he is happy4 ,nei!r %\ld !y beg9 by suppos+ t he is annihilat$1 only lat] to consid] :e!r he be happy4 ,nei!r %\ld !y conf9e !mselves to ext]nalities aft] hav+ admitt$ t he turns 8 :ole att5tion on ?+s t he be>s )9 himself2 9 %ort1 n to believe t ! goal ( 8 w inh]es 9 ext]nal objects4 ,inde$1 su* consid]+ ( ext]nal objects z ! goal ( ! w ( ! virtu\s man1 w\ld be tantam\nt to a d5ial ( ! v ess5ce 7be+7 ( happ9ess2 likewise1 insi/+ t ^? are ! objects he desires4 ,8 wi% w\ld und\bt$ly be t all m5 %\ld be happy1 & t none ( !m %\ld suff] any evil2 b1 nev]!less1 he is none ! less happy :5 t does n happ54 ,o!r p1 aga91 w\ld say t x 0 unreasonable = ! virtu\s man to =m su* an 7impossible7 wi%1 s9ce elim9ation ( evils "h bel[ is out ( ! "q4#ac ,?is1 h[ev]1 w\ld con/itute an admission ( our belief t ! only goal ( ! virtu\s man's w is ! conv]sion ( ! s\l t[>ds h]self4#ad ,,! ,,pleasures ,,claim$ ,,= ,,! ,,virtu\s ,,man ,,are ,,( ,a ,,high] ,,k9d4 #ab4 ,we grant1 h[ev]1 t ! pleasures claim$ = ! virtu\s man are nei!r ^? s\ght by debau*ees1 nor ^? enjoy$ by ! body4 ,^? pleasures c\ld n be pr$icat$ ( him )\t degrad+ 8 felicity4 ,nor c we claim = him raptures ( delight--= :at w\ld be _! use8 ,x is suffici5t to suppose t ! virtu\s man ta/es ! pleasures atta*$ to ! pres5ce ( goods1 pleasures :i* mu/ consi/ nei!r 9 motions1 nor be accid5tal4 ,he enjoys ! pres5ce ( ^? 7high]7 goods because he is pres5t to himself2 f t "t on he l+]s 9 a /ate ( sweet s]5ity4 ,! virtu\s man1 !re=e1 is always s]5e1 calm1 & satisfi$4 ,if he be really virtu\s1 8 /ate _c be tr\bl$ by any ( ! ?+s t we call evils4 ,^? :o 9 ! virtu\s life are seek+ = pleasures ( ano!r k9d are actually seek+ some?+ else ?an ! virtu\s life4 ,,9 ,,! ,,virtu\s ,,man ,,! ,,"p ,,t ,,suff]s ,,is ,,! ,,high]2 ,,!re=e ,,he ,,really ,,does ,,n ,,suff] ,,z ,,d ,,^? ,,:o ,,suff] ,,*iefly ,,physically4 #ac4 ,! actions ( ! virtu\s man c\ld n be h9d]$ by =tune1 b !y may v>y ) ! fluctuations ( =tune4 ,all w be equally beautiful1 &1 p]haps1 s mu* ! m beautiful z ! virtu\s man w f9d himself plac$ amid/ m critical circum/ances4 ,any acts t conc]n contemplation1 :i* relate to p>ticul> ?+s1 w be su* t ! wise man w be able to produce !m1 aft] hav+ c>efully s\ght & consid]$ :at he is to d4 ,)9 himself he f9ds ! mo/ infallible ( ! rules ( conduct1 a rule t w nev] fail him1 ev5 7 he )9 ! (t-discuss$ bull ( ,phal>is4 ,x is useless = ! vulg> man to repeat1 ev5 twice or ?rice1#ae t su* a fate is sweet2 = if a man 7 to utt] ^? words1 !y are utt]$ by t v 7animal7 "p t und]goes ^? tortures4 ,on ! contr>y1 9 ! virtu\s man1 ! "p t suff]s is diff]5t f t :i* dwells )9 itself1 & :i*1 :ile necess>ily resid+ )9 itself1 is nev] depriv$ ( ! contemplation ( ! univ]sal ,good4 ,,man ,,becomes ,,wise ,,by ,,e/abli%+ ,a ,,spiritual ,,prepond]ance4 #ad4 ,man1 & specially ! virtu\s man1 is con/itut$ n by ! composite ( s\l & body1#af z is prov$ by ! s\l's p[] to sep>ate h]self f ! body1#ag & to scorn :at usually are call$ goods4 ,x w\ld be ridicul\s to relate happ9ess to ! animal "p ( man1 s9ce happ9ess consi/s 9 liv+ well1 & liv+ well1 be+ an actualization1 belongs to ! s\l1 exclusively4 ,n ev5 does x ext5d to ! entire s\l1 = happ9ess does n ext5d to t "p ( ! s\l conc]n$ ) gr[?1 hav+ no?+ 9 common ) ! body1 nei!r z to its size1 nor its possible good condition4 ,nor does x dep5d on ! p]fection ( ! s5ses1 because _! developm5t1 z well z t ( ! organs1 weights man d[n1 & makes him e>?y4 ,do+ good w be made easi] by e/abli%+ a sort ( c\nt]-weight1 weak5+ ! body1 & tam+ its motions1 s z to %[ h[ mu* ! real man diff]s f ! =eign ?+s t 7to speak z d ! ,/oics71 surr\nd him4 ,h[ev] mu* ! 7e>?y7 common man enjoy beauty1 greatness1 weal?1 comm& ov] o!r m51 & e>?ly luxuries1 he %\ld n be envi$ = ! deceptive pleasure he takes 9 all ^! advantages4 ,to beg9 )1 ! wise man w probably n possess !m2 b if he d possess !m1 he w volunt>ily dim9i% !m1 if he take due c>e ( himself4 ,by volunt>y neglig5ce he w weak5 & disfigure ! advantages ( 8 body4 ,he w abdicate f dignities4 ,:ile pres]v+ ! heal? ( 8 body1 he w n desire to be entirely exempt f disease & suff]+s4 ,if he nev] exp]i5c$ ^! evils1 he w wi% to make a trial ( !m dur+ 8 y\?4 ,b :5 he has arriv$ at old age1 he w no long] wi% to be tr\bl$ ei!r by pa9s1 or pleasures1 or any?+ sad or agreeable t relates to ! body2 s z n to be =c$ to give x 8 att5tion4 ,he w oppose ! suff]+s he w h to und]go ) a firmness t w nev] =sake him4 ,he w n believe t 8 happ9ess is increas$ by pleasures1 heal? or re/1 nor de/roy$ nor dim9i%$ by _! contr>ies4 ,z ! =m] advantages d n augm5t 8 felicity1 h[ c\ld _! loss dim9i% x8 ,,two ,,wise ,,m5 ,,w ,,be ,,equally ,,happy1 ,,9 ,,spite ,,( ,,diff]5ces ,,( ,,=tune4 #ae4 ,let u n[ imag9e two wise m51 ! fir/ ( :om possesses ev]y?+ t he>t c wi% =1 :ile ! o!r is 9 a contr>y position4 ,%all !y be said to be equally happy8 ,yes1 if !y be equally wise4 ,ev5 if ! "o possess$ physical beauty1 & all ! o!r advantages t d n relate ei!r to wisdom1 virtue1 contemplation ( ! good1 or p]fect life2 :at w\ld be ! use ( all t s9ce he :o possesses all ^! advantages is n consid]$ z really be+ happi] ?an he :o lacks !m8 ,su* weal? w\ld n ev5 help a flute-play] to accompli% 8 object6 ,we1 h[ev]1 consid] ! happy man only f ! /&po9t ( ! weakness ( our m9d1 consid]+ z s]i\s & frightful :at ! really happy man consid]s indiff]5t4 ,= ! man c\ld n be wise1 nor consequ5tly happy1 s long z he has n succe$$ 9 gett+ rid ( all ^! va9 ideas1 s long z he has n entirely trans=m$ himself1 s long z he does n )9 himself conta9 ! confid5ce t he is %elt]$ f all evil4 ,only !n w he live )\t be+ tr\bl$ by any fe>4 ,! only ?+ t %\ld affect him1 w\ld be ! fe> t he is n an exp]t 9 wisdom1 t he is only p>tly wise4 ,z to un=ese5 fe>s t might get ! bett] ( him be=e he _h _h ! "t to reflect1 dur+ a mom5t ( ab/raction ( att5tion1 ! wise man w ha/5 to turn !m away1 treat+ t :i* )9 himself becomes agitat$ z a *ild t has lo/ its way ?r\gh pa94 ,he w tranquilize x ei!r by reason1 or ev5 by a ?reat1 ?\gh utt]$ )\t passion4 ,?us ! m]e sight ( a wor?y p]son suffices to calm a *ild4 ,besides1 ! wise man w n hold alo( ei!r f fri5d%ip nor gratitude4 ,he w treat 8 own p z he treats himself2 giv+ to 8 fri5ds z mu* z to 8 own p]son2 & he w give himself up to fri5d%ip1 )\t ceas+ to ex]cise intellig5ce !re94 ,,! ,,wise ,,man ,,rema9s ,,unatta*$4 #af4 ,if ! virtu\s man 7 n locat$ 9 ?is elevat$ life ( intellig5ce2 if on ! contr>y he 7 suppos$ to be subject to ! bl[s ( fate1 & if we fe>$ t !y w\ld ov]take him1 our ideal w\ld no long] be t ( ! virtu\s man su* z we outl9e x2 we w\ld be consid]+ a vulg> man1 m+l$ ) good & evil1 ( :om a life equally m+l$ ) good & evil w\ld be pr$icat$4 ,ev5 su* a man might n easily be met )1 & besides1 if we did meet him1 he w\ld n des]ve to be call$ a wise man2 = !re w\ld be no?+ great ab\t him1 nei!r ! dignity ( wisdom1 nor ! purity ( good4 ,happ9ess1 !re=e1 is n locat$ 9 ! life ( ! common man4 ,plato rightly says t y h to leave ! e>? to asc5d to ! good1 & t to become wise & happy1 "o %\ld turn "o's look t[>ds ! only ,good1 try+ to acquire resemblance to ,him1 & to live a life con=mable to ,him4#ah ,t inde$ mu/ suffice ! wise man to rea* 8 goal4 ,to ! rema9d] he %\ld atta* no m value ?an to *anges ( location1 none ( :i* c add to 8 happ9ess4 ,if inde$ he pay any att5tion to ext]nal ?+s scatt]$ "h & !re ar\nd him1 x is to satisfy ! ne$s ( 8 body s f> z he c4 ,b z he is some?+ entirely diff]5t f ! body1 he is nev] di/urb$ at hav+ to leave x2 & he w ab&on x :5ev] nature w h indicat$ ! "t4 ,besides1 he always res]ves to himself ! "r to delib]ate ab\t ?is 7"t to leave ! _w by suicide74#ai ,a*ievem5t ( happ9ess w inde$ be 8 *ief goal2 nev]!less1 he w also act1 n only 9 view ( 8 ultimate goal1 or himself1 b on ! body to :i* he is unit$4 ,he w c>e = ?is body1 & w su/a9 x z long z possible4 ,?us a musician uses 8 lyre s long z he c2 b z soon z x is beyond us+1 he repairs x1 or ab&ons play+ ! lyre1 because he n[ c d )\t x4 ,leav+ x on ! gr\nd1 he w look at x almo/ ) scorn1 & w s+ )\t its accompanim5t4 ,nev]!less x w n h be5 9 va9 t ?is lyre w h be5 orig9ally giv5 to him2 = he w (t5 h pr(it$ by its use4 ,,?ird ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,two4 ,( ,provid5ce4#bj ,,epicurus ,,taught ,,*ance ,,& ,,! ,,gno/ics ,,an ,,evil ,,creator4 #a4 ,:5 ,epicurus#ba d]ives ! exi/5ce & con/itution ( ! univ]se f automatism & *ance1 he commits an absurdity1 & /ultifies himself4 ,t is self-evid5t1 ?\gh ! matt] h else:]e be5 ?or\ghly demon/rat$4#bb ,b 7if ! _w d n owe its orig9 to *ance7 we w be compell$ to furni% an adequate reason = ! exi/5ce & creation ( all ^! be+s4 ,?is 7teleological7 "q des]ves ! mo/ c>eful consid]ation4 ,?+s t seem evil d inde$ exi/1 & !y d sugge/ d\bts ab\t univ]sal ,provid5ce2 s t "s 7l ,epicurus#bc7 insi/ !re is no provid5ce1 :ile o!rs 7l ! ,gno/ics#bd71 hold t ! demiurgic creator is evil4 ,! subject1 !re=e1 dem&s ?or\gh inve/igation ( its fir/ pr9ciples4 ,,p>ticul> ,,& ,,univ]sal ,,provid5ce ,,assum$ ,,z ,,premises4 ,let u leave aside ?is individual provid5ce1 :i* consi/s 9 delib]at+ be=e an action1 & 9 exam9+ :e!r we %\ld or %\ld n d some?+1 or :e!r we %\ld give or n give x4 ,we %all also assume ! exi/5ce ( ! univ]sal ,provid5ce1 & f ?is pr9ciple we %all d$uce ! consequ5ces4 ,,provid5ce ,,is ,,n ,,p>ticul> ,,because ,,! ,,_w ,,_h ,,no ,,beg9n+4 ,we w\ld ackn[l$ge ! exi/5ce ( a p>ticul> ,provid5ce1 su* z we m5tion$ above1 if we ?\ght t ! _w _h _h a beg9n+ ( exi/5ce1 & _h n exi/$ s9ce all et]nity4 ,by ?is p>ticul> ,provid5ce we mean a recognition1 9 ! div9ity1 ( a k9d ( prevision & reason+ 7simil> to ! reason+ & prevision ( ! arti/ :o1 be=e c>ry+ out a "w1 delib]ates on ea* ( ! p>ts t compose x#be74 ,we w\ld suppose t ?is prevision & reason+ 7 necess>y to det]m9e h[ ! univ]se c\ld h be5 made1 & on :at conditions x %\ld h be5 ! be/ possible4 ,b z we hold t ! _w's exi/5ce _h no beg9n+1 & t x has exi/$ s9ce all "t1 we c1 9 h>mony ) reason & our own views1 affirm t univ]sal ,provid5ce consi/s 9 ?is t ! univ]se is con=m$ to ,intellig5ce1 & t ,intellig5ce is prior to ! univ]se1 n inde$ 9 "t--= ! exi/5ce ( ! ,intellig5ce did n tempor>ily prec$e t ( ! univ]se--b 79 ! ord] ( ?+s71 because1 by its nature1 ,intellig5ce prec$es ! _w t proce$s f x1 ( :i* x is ! cause1 type#bf & model1 & cause ( un*ang$ p]petual p]si/5ce4 ,,h[ ,,intellig5ce ,,cont9ues ,,to ,,make ,,! ,,_w ,,subsi/4 ,?is is h[ ,intellig5ce cont9ues to make ! _w subsi/4 ,pure ,intellig5ce & ,be+ 9 itself con/itute ! g5u9e 7intelligible7 ,_w t is prior to ev]y?+1 :i* has no ext5sion1 :i* is weak5$ by no division1 :i* has no imp]fection1 ev5 9 its p>ts1 = none ( its p>ts are sep>at$ f its totality4 ,?is _w is ! univ]sal ,life & ,intellig5ce4 ,its unity is bo? liv+ & intellig5t4 ,9 x ea* "p reproduces ! :ole1 its totality consi/s ( a p]fect h>mony1 because no?+ )9 x is sep>ate1 indep5d5t1 or isolat$ f any?+ else4 ,consequ5tly1 ev5 if !re 7 mutual opposition1 !re w\ld be no /ruggle4 ,be+ ev]y:]e "o & p]fect1 ! intelligible ,_w is p]man5t & immutable1 = x conta9s no int]nal reaction ( "o opposite on ano!r4 ,h[ c\ld su* a reaction take place 9 ?is _w1 s9ce no?+ is lack+ 9 x8 ,:y %\ld ,reason produce ano!r ,reason )9 x1 & ,intellig5ce produce ano!r ,intellig5ce#bg m]ely because x 0 capable ( do+ s8 ,if s1 x w\ld n1 be=e hav+ produc$1 h be5 9 a p]fect condition2 x w\ld produce & ent] 9 motion because x conta9$ some?+ inf]ior4#bh ,b blissful be+s are satisfi$ to rema9 )9 !mselves1 p]si/+ )9 _! ess5ce4 ,a multiple action compromises him :o acts by =c+ him to issue f himself4 ,! intelligible ,_w is s blissful t ev5 :ile do+ no?+ x accompli%es great ?+s1 & :ile rema9+ )9 itself x produces important op]ations4 ,,! ,,s5se-,,_w ,,creat$ ,,n ,,by ,,reflection1 ,,b ,,by ,,self-,,necessity4 #b4 ,! s5se-_w draws its exi/5ce f t intelligible ,_w4 ,! s5se-_w1 h[ev]1 is n really unit>y2 x is inde$ multiple1 & divid$ into a plurality ( p>ts :i* are sep>at$ f ea* o!r1 & are mutually =eign4 ,n love reigns !re1 b hate1 produc$ by ! sep>ation ( ?+s :i* _! /ate ( imp]fection r5d]s mutually inimical4 ,none ( its p>ts suffices to itself4 ,pres]v$ by some?+ else1 x is none ! less an enemy ( ! pres]v+ ,p[]4 ,! s5se-_w has be5 creat$1 n because ! div9ity reflect$ on ! necessity ( creat+1 b because 79 ! nature ( ?+s7 x 0 unavoidable t !re be a nature inf]ior to ! intelligible ,_w1 :i*1 be+ p]fect1 c\ld n h be5 ! la/ degree ( exi/5ce4#bi ,x occupi$ ! fir/ rank1 x _h great p[]1 t 0 univ]sal & capable ( creat+ )\t delib]ation4 ,if x _h _h to delib]ate1 x w\ld n1 by itself1 h express$ ! p[] ( creation4 ,x w\ld n h possess$ x ess5tially4 ,x w\ld h resembl$ an artisan1 :o1 himself1 does n h ! p[] ( creat+1 b :o acquires x by le>n+ h[ to "w4 ,by giv+ some?+ ( itself to matt]1 ,intellig5ce produc$ ev]y?+ )\t issu+ f its re/ or quietness4 ,t :i* x gives is ,reason1 because reason is ! emanation ( ,intellig5ce1 an emanation t is z durable z ! v exi/5ce ( ,intellig5ce4 ,9 a sem9al reason all ! p>ts exi/ 9 an unit$ condition1 )\t any ( !m /ruggl+ ) ano!r1 )\t disagreem5t or h9drance4 ,?is ,reason !n causes some?+ ( itself to pass into ! corporeal mass1 :]e ! p>ts are sep>at$ f ea* o!r1 & h9d] ea* o!r1 & de/roy ea* o!r4 ,likewise1 f ?is unit>y ,intellig5ce1 & f ! ,reason t proce$s !nce1 issues ?is univ]se ^: p>ts are sep>ate & di/9ct f ea* o!r1 "s ( ! p>ts be+ fri5dly & alli$1 :ile "s are sep>ate & inimical4 ,!y1 !re=e1 de/roy ea* o!r1 ei!r volunt>ily or involunt>ily1 & ?r\gh ?is de/ruction _! g5]ation is mutually op]at$4 ,9 su* a way did ! div9ity arrange _! actions & exp]i5ces t all concur 9 ! =mation ( a s+le h>mony1#cj 9 :i* ea* utt]s its individual note because1 9 ! :ole1 ! ,reason t dom9ates !m produces ord] & h>mony4 ,! s5se-_w does n enjoy ! p]fection ( ,intellig5ce & ,reason3 x only p>ticipates !re94 ,consequ5tly1 ! s5se-_w ne$$ h>mony1 because x 0 =m$ by ! concurr5ce ( ,intellig5ce & necessity4#ca ,necessity drives ! s5se-_w to evil1 & to :at is irrational1 because necessity itself is irrational2 b ,intellig5ce dom9ates necessity4 ,! intelligible ,_w is pure reason2 none o!r c\ld be su*4 ,! _w1 :i* is born ( x1 _h to be inf]ior to x1 & be nei!r pure reason1 nor m]e matt]2 = ord] w\ld h be5 impossible 9 unm+l$ matt]4 ,! s5se-_w1 !re=e1 is a mixture ( matt] & ,reason2 ^? are ! elem5ts ( :i* x is compos$4 ,! pr9ciple f :i* ?is mixture proce$s1 & :i* presides ov] ! mixture1 is ! ,s\l4 ,nei!r mu/ we imag9e t ?is presid+ ov] ! mixture con/itutes an ef=t = ! ,s\l2 = %e easily adm9i/]s ! univ]se1 by h] pres5ce4#cb ,,! ,,_w ,,%\ld ,,n ,,be ,,blam$ ,,= ,,its ,,imp]fections4 #c4 ,= n be+ beautiful ?is _w %\ld n be blam$2 nei!r = n be+ ! be/ ( corporeal worlds2 nor %\ld ! ,cause1 f :i* x d]ives its exi/5ce1 be accus$4 ,to beg9 )1 ?is _w exi/s necess>ily4 ,x is n ! "w ( a reflect+ det]m9ation4 ,x exi/s because a sup]ior ,be+ naturally begets x 9 ,8 own lik5ess4 ,ev5 if its creation 7 ! result ( reflective det]m9ation1 x c\ld n %ame its au?or2 = ! div9ity made ! univ]se beautiful1 complete & h>moni\s4 ,betwe5 ! great] & less] p>ts ,he introduc$ a =tunate accord4 ,a p]son :o w\ld blame ! totality ( ! _w f consid]ation ( its p>ts is !re=e unju/4 ,he %\ld exam9e ! p>ts 9 _! relation to ! totality1 & see :e!r !y be 9 accord & 9 h>mony ) x4 ,!n ! /udy ( ! :ole %\ld cont9ue d[n to t ( ! lea/ details4 ,o!rwise criticism does n apply to ! _w z a :ole1 b only to "s ( its p>ts4 ,= in/ance1 we well "k h[ admirable1 z a :ole1 is man2 yet we grant t !re w\ld be ju/ification = criticism ( a sep>ate hair1 or toe1 or "s ( ! vile/ animals1 or ,!rsites1 z a specim5 ( humanity4 ,,! ,,_w',s ,,te/imony ,,to ,,its ,,creator4 ,s9ce ! "w "u consid]ation is ! entire _w1 we w\ld1 7 our intellig5ce att5tively to li/5 to its voice1 he> x exclaim z foll[s3 ,x is a div9ity :o has made ,me1 & f ! div9ity's h&s ,i issu$ complete1 includ+ all animat$ be+s1 entire & self-suffici5t1 /&+ 9 ne$ ( no?+1 s9ce ev]y?+ is conta9$ )9 ,me2 plants1 animals1 ! :ole ( ,nature1 ! multitude ( ! div9ities1 ! tr\pe ( gu>dians1 excell5t s\ls1 & ! m5 :o are happy because ( virtue4 ,?is ref]s n only to ! e>?1 :i* is ri* 9 plants & animals ( all k9ds2 ! p[] ( ! ,s\l ext5ds also to ! sea4 ,nor are ! air & entire heav5 inanimate4 ,!y are ! seat ( all ! excell5t ,s\ls1 :i* communicate life to ! />s1 & :i* preside ov] ! circul> revolution ( ! heav51 a revolution t is et]nal & full ( h>mony1 :i* imitates ! movem5t ( ,intellig5ce by ! et]nal & regul> movem5t ( ! />s ar\nd "o & ! same c5tre1 because heav5 has no ne$ to seek any?+ outside ( itself4 ,all ! be+s ,i conta9 aspire to ! ,good2 all a*ieve ,him1 ea* accord+ to its pot5tiality4 ,inde$1 f ! ,good dep5ds ! entire heav51#cc my :ole ,s\l1 ! div9ities t inhabit my v>i\s p>ts1 all ! animals1 all ! plants1 & all my app>5tly inanimate be+s4 ,9 ?is aggregation ( be+s "s seem to p>ticipate only 9 exi/5ce1 o!rs 9 life1 o!rs 9 s5sation1 o!rs 9 intellig5ce1 :ile /ill o!rs seem to p>ticipate 9 all ! p[]s ( life at "o "t2#cd = we mu/ n expect equal faculties = unequal ?+s1 z = in/ance sight = ! f+]s1 z x is suitable to ! eye2 :ile ! f+] ne$s some?+ else2 x ne$s its own =m1 & has to fulfil its function4 ,,opposition ,,among ,,inanimate ,,be+s4 #d4 ,we %\ld n be surpris$ at wat] ext+ui%+ fire1 or at fire de/roy+ "s o!r elem5t4 ,ev5 ?is elem5t 0 introduc$ to exi/5ce by "s o!r elem5t1 & x is n surpris+ t x %\ld be de/roy$1 s9ce x did n produce itself1 & 0 introduc$ to exi/5ce only by ! de/ruction ( "s o!r elem5t 7z ?\ght ,h]aclitus & ! ,/oics#ce74 ,besides1 ! ext+ui%$ fire is replac$ by ano!r active fire4 ,9 ! incorporeal heav51 ev]y?+ is p]man5t2 9 ! visible heav51 ! totality1 z well z ! m important & ! mo/ ess5tial p>ts1 are et]nal4 ,! s\ls1 on pass+ ?r\gh diff]5t bodies1 7by virtue ( _! disposition#cf71 !mselves *ange on assum+ "s p>ticul> =m2 b1 :5 !y c d s1 !y /& outside ( g5]ation1 rema9+ unit$ to ! univ]sal ,s\l4 ,! bodies are alive by _! =m1 & by ! :ole t ea* ( !m con/itutes 7by its union ) a s\l71 s9ce !y are animals1 & s9ce !y n\ri% !mselves2 = 9 ! s5se-_w life is mobile1 b 9 ! intelligible _w x is immobile4 ,immobility necess>ily begat movem5t1 self-conta9$ life 0 compell$ to produce o!r life1 & calm be+ naturally exhal$ vibrat+ _s4 ,,opposition ,,among ,,animals4 ,mutual /ruggle & de/ruction among animals is necess>y1 because !y are n born immortal4 ,_! orig9 is due to ,reason's embrac+ all ( matt]1 & because ?is ,reason possess$ )9 itself all ! ?+s t subsi/ 9 ! intelligible ,_w4 ,f :at o!r s\rce w\ld !y h aris58 ,,opposition ,,among ,,humans4 ,! mutual wrongs ( human be+s may h[ev] v easily all be caus$ by ! desire ( ! ,good 7z _h be5 ?\ght by ,democritus#cg74 ,b1 hav+ /ray$ because ( _! inability to rea* ,him1 !y turn$ aga9/ ea* o!r4 ,!y are puni%$ = x by ! degradation ^! evil actions introduc$ )9 _! s\ls1 &1 aft] dea?1 !y are driv5 into a l[] place1 = none c escape ! ,ord] e/abli%$ by ! ,law ( ! univ]se 7or1 ! law ( ,adra/ea#ch74 ,ord] does n1 z "s w\ld ?9k1 exi/ because ( disord]1 nor law on acc\nt ( lawlessness2 9 g5]al1 x is n ! bett] t exi/s on acc\nt ( ! worse4 ,on ! contr>y1 disord] exi/s only on acc\nt ( ord]1 lawlessness on acc\nt ( law1 irrationality on acc\nt ( reason1 because ord]1 law & reason1 su* z !y are "h bel[1 are only imitations 7or1 borr[+s74 ,x is n t ! bett] produc$ ! worse1 b t ! ?+s :i* ne$ p>ticipation 9 ! bett] are h9d]$ !refrom1 ei!r by _! nature1 by accid5t1 or by "s o!r ob/acle 7z ,*rysippus ?\ght t evils happ5 by consequ5ce or concomitance74 ,inde$1 t :i* succe$s only 9 acquir+ a borr[$ ord]1 may easily fail to a*ieve x1 ei!r because ( "s fault inh]5t 9 its own nature1 or by "s =eign ob/acle4 ,?+s h9d] ea* o!r un9t5tionally1 by foll[+ diff]5t goals4 ,animals ^: actions are free incl9e sometimes t[>ds good1 sometimes t[>ds evil 7z ! two horses 9 ,plato's ,pha$rus74#ci ,d\btless1 !y d n beg9 by incl9+ t[>ds evil2 b z soon z !re is ! lea/ deviation at ! orig91 ! fur!r ! advance 9 ! wrong road1 ! great] & m s]i\s does ! div]g5ce become4 ,besides1 ! s\l is unit$ to a body1 & f ?is union necess>ily arises appetite4 ,:5 some?+ impresses u at fir/ sight1 or unexpect$ly1 & if we d n imm$iately repress ! motion :i* is produc$ )9 u1 we all[ ourselves to be c>ri$ away by ! object t[>ds :i* our incl9ation drew u4 ,b ! puni%m5t foll[s ! fault1 & x is n unju/ t ! s\l t has contract$ "s p>ticul> nature %\ld und]go ! consequ5ces ( h] disposition 7by pass+ into a body :i* con=ms !reto74 ,happ9ess ne$ n be expect$ = ^? :o h done no?+ to des]ve x4 ,! good alone obta9 x2 & t is :y ! div9ities enjoy x4 ,,lack ,,( ,,happ9ess ,,%\ld ,,be ,,blam$ ,,on ,,! ,,s\l ,,t ,,does ,,n ,,des]ve ,,x4 #e4 ,if !n1 ev5 "h bel[1 s\ls enjoy ! faculty ( arriv+ at happ9ess1 we %\ld n accuse ! con/itution ( ! univ]se because "s s\ls are n happy2 ! fault r lies ) _! weakness1 :i* h9d]s !m f /ruggl+ c\rage\sly en\gh 9 ! c>e] :]e prizes are (f]$ to virtue4 ,:y inde$ %\ld we be a/oni%$ t ! spirits :i* h n made !mselves div9e %\ld n enjoy div9e life8 ,pov]ty & diseases are ( no importance to ! good1 & !y are useful to ! evil 7z ?\ght ,!ognis74#dj ,besides1 we are necess>ily subject to diseases1 because we h a body4 ,!n all ^! accid5ts are n useless = ! ord] & exi/5ce ( ! univ]se4 ,inde$1 :5 a be+ is dissolv$ into its elem5ts1 ! ,reason ( ! univ]se uses x to beget o!r be+s1 = ! univ]sal ,reason embraces ev]y?+ )9 its sph]e ( activity4 ,?us :5 ! body is disorganiz$1 & ! s\l is s(t5$ by h] passions1 !n ! body1 ov]come by sickness1 & ! s\l1 ov]come by vice1 are introduc$ into ano!r s]ies & ord]4 ,!re are ?+s1 l pov]ty & sickness1 :i* b5efit ! p]sons :o und]go !m4 ,ev5 vice contributes to ! p]fection ( ! univ]se1 because x furni%es opportunity = ! ex]cise ( ! div9e ju/ice4 ,x s]ves o!r purposes also2 = in/ance1 x increases ! vigilance ( s\ls1 & excites ! m9d & intellig5ce to avoid ! pa?s ( p]dition2 x also emphasizes ! value ( virtue by contra/ ) ! evils t ov]take ! wick$4 ,( c\rse1 su* utilities are n ! cause ( ! exi/5ce ( evils2 we only mean t1 s9ce evils exi/1 ! div9ity made use ( !m to accompli% ,8 purposes4 ,x w\ld be ! *>act]i/ic ( a great p[] to make ev5 evils promote ! fulfilm5t ( its purposes1 to cause =mless ?+s to assi/ 9 ! production ( =ms4 ,9 %ort1 we ass]t t evil is only an omission or failure ( good4 ,n[ a com+ %ort ( good mu/ necess>ily exi/ 9 ! be+s "h bel[1 because 9 !m good is m+l$ ) o!r ?+s2 = ?is ?+ to :i* ! good is alli$ diff]s f ! good1 & ?us produces ! lack ( good4 ,t is :y x is impossible = evil to be de/roy$3#da because ?+s are successively inf]ior1 relatively to ! nature ( ! absolute ,good2 & because1 be+ diff]5t f ! ,good f :i* !y d]ive _! exi/5ce1 !y h become :at !y are by gr[+ m di/ant f _! pr9ciple4 ,,9 ,,spite ,,( ,,app>5t ,,mis=tune ,,to ,,! ,,good ,,no ,,h>m ,,c ,,happ5 ,,to ,,!m4 #f4 ,x is con/antly object$ t =tune maltreats ! good1 & favors ! evil 9 opposition to ! agreem5t t ought to exi/ betwe5 virtue & happ9ess4 ,! true answ] to ?is is t no h>m c happ5 to ! righte\s man1 & no good to ! vici\s man4#db ,o!r objectors ask :y "o man is expos$ to :at is contr>y to nature1 :ile ! o!r obta9s :at con=ms !reto4 ,h[ c di/ributive ju/ice be said to obta9 9 ?is _w8 ,if1 h[ev]1 ! obta9+ ( :at con=ms to nature d n increase ! happ9ess ( ! virtu\s man1 & if be+ expos$ to :at is contr>y to nature d n dim9i% ! wick$ness ( ! vici\s man1 ( :at importance 7z ?\ght ,plato#dc71 are ei!r ( ^! conditions8 ,nei!r w x matt] if ! vici\s man be h&some1 or ! virtu\s man ugly4 ,,! ,,slav]y ,,( ,,! ,,good ,,& ,,victory ,,( ,,! ,,evil ,,seem ,,to ,,accuse ,,provid5ce4 ,fur!r objections ass]t t propriety1 ord] & ju/ice dem& ! contr>y ( ! exi/+ /ate ( affairs 9 ! _w1 & t we c\ld expect no less f a ,provid5ce t 0 wise4 ,ev5 if x 7 a matt] ( mom5t to virtue or vice1 x is unsuitable t ! wick$ %\ld be ! ma/]s1 & *iefs ( /ate1 & t ! good %\ld be slaves2 = a bad pr9ce commits ! wor/ crimes4 ,moreov]1 ! wick$ conqu] 9 battles1 & =ce _! prison]s to und]go ! extremities ( torm5ts4 ,h[ c\ld su* facts occur if inde$ a div9e ,provid5ce be 9 control8 ,al?\gh inde$ 9 ! production ( "s "w 7( art71 x be especially ! totality t claims att5tion1 nev]!less1 ! p>ts mu/ also obta9 _! due1 especially :5 !y are animat$1 liv+ & reasonable2 x is j t div9e ,provid5ce %\ld ext5d to ev]y?+1 especially inasmu* z its duty is precisely to neglect no?+4 ,9 view ( ^! objections we %all be =c$ to demon/rate t really ev]y?+ "h bel[ is good1 if we cont9ue to insi/ t ! s5se-_w dep5ds on supreme ,intellig5ce1 & t its p[] p5etrates ev]y:]e4 ,,p]fection ,,mu/ ,,n ,,be ,,s\ght ,,9 ,,?+s ,,m+l$ ,,) ,,matt]4 #g4 ,to beg9 )1 we mu/ rem>k t to %[ t all is good 9 ! ?+s m+l$ ) matt] 7& !re=e ( s5se71 we mu/ n expect to f9d 9 !m ! :ole p]fection ( ! ,_w :i* is n soil$ by matt]1 & is intelligible2 nor %\ld we expect to f9d 9 t :i* holds ! second rank *>act]i/ics ( t :i* is ( ! fir/4 ,s9ce ! _w has a body1 we mu/ grant t ?is body w h influ5ce on ! totality1 & expect no m ?an t ,reason w give x t :i* ?is mix$ nature 0 capable ( receiv+4 ,= in/ance1 if we 7 to contemplate ! mo/ beautiful man "h bel[1 we w\ld be wrong 9 believ+ t he 0 id5tical ) ! intelligible ,man1 & inasmu* z he 0 made ( fle%1 muscles & bones1 we w\ld h to be satisfi$ ) 8 hav+ receiv$ f 8 creator all ! p]fection t c\ld be communicat$ to him to embelli% ^! bones1 muscles & fle%1 & to make ! 7sem9al7 reason 9 him pr$om9ate ov] ! matt] )9 him4 ,,evil ,,is ,,only ,a ,,l[] ,,=m ,,( ,,good4 ,grant+ ^! premises1 we may />t out on an explanation ( ! above m5tion$ difficulties4 ,= 9 ! _w we w f9d rem>kable traces ( ! ,provid5ce & div9e ,p[] f :i* x proce$s4 ,let u take fir/1 ! actions ( s\ls :o d evil volunt>ily2 ! actions ( ! wick$ :o1 = in/ance1 h>m virtu\s m51 or o!r m5 equally evil4 ,provid5ce ne$ n be held responsible = ! wick$ness ( ^! s\ls4 ,! cause %\ld be s\ght 9 ! volunt>y det]m9ations ( ^? s\ls !mselves4 ,= we h prov$ t ! s\ls h *>act]i/ic motions1 & t :ile "h bel[ !y are n pure1 b r are animals 7z w\ld naturally be ! case ) s\ls unit$ to bodies74#dd ,n[1 x is n surpris+ t1 f9d+ !mselves 9 su* a condition1 !y w\ld live con=mably to t condition4#de ,inde$1 x is n ! =mation ( ! _w t made !m desc5d "h bel[4 ,ev5 be=e ! _w exi/$1 !y 7 already dispos$ to =m "p ( x1 to busy !mselves ) x1 to infuse x ) life1 to adm9i/] x1 & 9 x to ex]t _! p[] 9 a *>act]i/ic mann]1 ei!r by presid+ ov] its 7issues71 & by communicat+ to x some?+ ( _! p[]1 or by desc5d+ into x1 or by act+ 9 respect to ! _w ea* 9 its individual mann]4#df ,! latt] "q1 h[ev]1 does n ref] to ! subject we are n[ consid]+2 "h x w be suffici5t to %[ t1 h[ev] ^! circum/ances occur1 ,provid5ce is n to be blam$4 ,,x ,,is ,a ,,matt] ,,( ,,fai? ,,t ,,provid5ce ,,embraces ,,ev]y?+ ,,"h ,,bel[1 ,,ev5 ,,! ,,mis=tunes ,,( ,,! ,,j4 ,b h[ %all we expla9 ! diff]5ce t is obs]v$ betwe5 ! lot ( ! good & ! evil8 ,h[ c x occur t ! =m] are poor1 :ile o!rs are ri*1 & possess m ?an necess>y to satisfy _! ne$s1 be+ ev5 p[]ful1 & gov]n+ cities & nations8 7,! ,gno/ics & ,mani*eans7 ?9k t ! sph]e ( activity ( ,provid5ce does n ext5d d[n to ! e>?4#dg ,no6 ,= all ( ! re/ 7( ?is _w7 con=ms to 7univ]sal7 ,reason1 inasmu* z animals & plants p>ticipate 9 ,reason1 ,life & ,s\l4 7,! ,gno/ic7 w answ] t if ,provid5ce d ext5d to ?is e>?1 x does n pr$om9ate !re94 ,z ! _w is b a s+le organism1 to advance su* an objection is ! "p ( somebody :o w\ld ass]t t ! head & face ( man 7 produc$ by ,nature1 & t reason dom9at$ !re91 :ile ! o!r memb]s 7 =m$ by o!r causes1 su* z *ance or necessity1 & t !y 7 evil ei!r on ?is acc\nt1 or because ( ! importance ( ,nature4 ,wisdom & piety1 h[ev]1 w\ld =bid ! admission t "h bel[ n ev]y?+ 0 well1 blam+ ! op]ation ( ,provid5ce4 ,,h[ ,,s5se-,,objects ,,are ,,n ,,evil4 #h4 ,x rema9s = u to expla9 h[ s5se-objects are good & p>ticipate 9 ! 7cosmic7 ,ord]2 or at lea/1 t !y are n evil4 ,9 e animal1 ! high] p>ts1 su* z ! face & head1 are ! mo/ beautiful1 & are n equall$ by ! middle or l[] p>ts4 ,n[ m5 occupy ! middle & l[] region ( ! univ]se4 ,9 ! high] region we f9d ! heav5 conta9+ ! div9ities2 x is !y t fill ! great] "p ( ! _w1 ) ! va/ sph]e :]e !y reside4 ,! e>? occupies ! c5tre & seems to be "o ( ! />s4 ,we are surpris$ at see+ inju/ice reign+ "h bel[ *iefly because man is reg>d$ z ! mo/ v5]able & wise/ be+ 9 ! univ]se4 ,nev]!less1 ?is be+ t is s wise occupies b ! middle place betwe5 div9ities & animals1 at diff]5t times incl9+ t[>ds ! =m] or ! latt]4 ,"s m5 resemble ! div9ities1 & o!rs resemble animals2 b ! great] "p cont9ue midway betwe5 !m4 ,,! ,,good ,,may ,,neglect ,,natural ,,laws ,,:i* ,,c>ry ,,rew>ds4 ,x is ^? m5 :o occupy ?is middle place :o are =c$ to und]go ! rap9e & viol5ce ( deprav$ m51 :o resemble wild bea/s4 ,?\gh ! =m] are bett] ?an ^? ^: viol5ce !y suff]1 !y are1 nev]!less1 dom9at$ by !m because ( inf]iority 9 o!r respects1 lack+ c\rage1 or prep>$ness4#dh ,x w\ld be no m ?an a laugh+ matt] if *ildr5 :o _h /r5g!n$ _! bodies by ex]cise1 :ile leav+ _! s\ls inviolate 9 ignorance1 %\ld 9 physical /ruggle conqu] ^? ( _! companions1 :o _h ex]cis$ nei!r body nor s\l2 if !y /ole _! food or s(t clo?+4 ,no legislator c\ld h9d] ! vanqui%$ f be>+ ! puni%m5t ( _! c[>dl9ess & effem9acy1 if1 neglect+ ! gymna/ic ex]cises :i* _h be5 taught !m1 !y did n1 by _! in]tia1 effem9acy & laz9ess1 fe> becom+ fatt5$ %eep fit to be ! prey ( wolves8 ,!y :o commit ?is rap9e & viol5ce are puni%$ !re= fir/ because !y !reby become wolves & noxi\s bea/s1 & lat] because 79 ?is or "s subsequ5t exi/5ce7 !y necess>ily und]go ! consequ5ces ( _! evil actions 7z ?\ght ,plato#di74 ,= m5 :o "h bel[ h be5 evil d n die entirely 7:5 _! s\l is sep>at$ f _! bodies74 ,n[ 9 ! ?+s t are regulat$ by ,nature & ,reason1 t :i* foll[s is always ! result ( t :i* prec$es2 evil begets evil1 j z good begets good4 ,b ! ar5a ( life diff]s f a gymnasium1 :]e ! /ruggles are only games4 ,!re=e1 ! above-m5tion$ *ildr5 :i* we divid$ into two classes1 aft] hav+ gr[n up 9 ignorance1 mu/ prep>e to fight1 & take up arms1 an display m en]gy ?an 9 ! ex]cises ( ! gymnasium4 ,z "s1 h[ev]1 are well arm$1 :ile ! o!rs are n1 ! fir/ mu/ inevitably triumph4 ,! div9ity mu/ n fight = ! c[>dly2 = ! 7cosmic7 law decrees t 9 w> life is sav$ by valor1 & n by pray]s4#ej ,nor is x by pray]s t ! fruits ( ! e>? are obta9$2 !y are produc$ only by labor4 ,nor c "o h good heal? )\t tak+ c>e ( x4 ,if ! evil cultivate ! e>? bett]1 we %\ld n compla9 ( _! reap+ a bett] h>ve/4#ea ,besides1 9 ! ord9>y conduct ( life1 x is ridicul\s to li/5 only to "o's own caprice1 do+ no?+ t is prescrib$ by ! div9ities1 limit+ oneself exclusively to dem&+ "o's cons]vation1 )\t c>ry+ out any ( ! actions on :i* 7! div9ities7 will$ t our pres]vation %\ld dep5d4 ,,dea? ,,is ,,bett] ,,?an ,,di%>mony ,,) ,,! ,,laws ,,( ,,! ,,univ]se4 ,inde$ x w\ld be bett] to be dead ?an to live ?us 9 contradiction ) ! laws t rule ! univ]se4 ,if1 :5 m5 are 9 opposition to ^! laws1 div9e ,provid5ce pres]v$ peace 9 ! mid/ ( all follies & vices1 x w\ld des]ve ! *>ge ( neglig5ce 9 all[+ ! preval5ce ( evil4 ,! evil rule only because ( ! c[>dice ( ^? :o obey !m2 ?is is ju/] ?an if x 7 o!rwise4 ,,provid5ce ,,%\ld ,,n ,,be ,,ext5d$ ,,to ,,! ,,po9t ,,( ,,suppress+ ,,our ,,own ,,initiative4 #i4 ,nor %\ld ! sph]e ( ,provid5ce be ext5d$ to ! po9t ( suppress+ our own action4 ,= if ,provid5ce did ev]y?+1 & ,provid5ce alone exi/$1 x w\ld !reby be annihilat$4 ,to :at1 inde$1 w\ld x apply8 ,!re w\ld be no?+ b div9ity6 ,x is inde$ inconte/able t div9ity exi/s1 & t its sph]e ext5ds ov] o!r be+s--b div9ity does n suppress ! latt]4 ,= in/ance1 div9ity approa*es man1 & pres]ves 9 him :at con/itutes humanity2 t is1 div9ity makes him live 9 con=mity to ! law ( ,provid5ce1 & makes him fulfil ! comm&m5ts ( t law4 ,n[1 ?is law decrees t ! life ( m5 :o h become virtu\s %\ld be good bo? "h bel[ & aft] _! dea?2 & t ! evil %\ld meet an opposite fate4 ,x w\ld be unreasonable to expect ! exi/5ce ( m5 :o =get !mselves to come & save ! evil1 ev5 if ! latt] address$ pray]s to ! div9ity4 ,nei!r %\ld we expect ! div9ities to r5\nce _! blissful exi/5ce to come & adm9i/] our affairs2 nor t ! virtu\s m51 ^: life is holy & sup]ior to human conditions1 %\ld be will+ to gov]n ! wick$4 ,! latt] nev] busy !mselves ) promot+ ! good to ! gov]n+ ( o!r m51 & !mselves to be good 7z ?\ght ,plato#eb74 ,!y are ev5 jeal\s ( ! man :o is good by himself2 !re w\ld inde$ be m good p if virtu\s m5 7 *os5 z *iefs4 ,,?\gh ,,m5 ,,are ,,only ,,m$iocre ,,!y ,,are ,,nev] ,,ab&on$ ,,by ,,provid5ce4 ,man is !re=e n ! be/ be+ 9 ! univ]se2 accord+ to 8 *oice he occupies an int]m$iate rank4 ,9 ! place he occupies1 h[ev]1 he is n ab&on$ by ,provid5ce1 :i* ev] leads him back to div9e ?+s by ! num]\s means x possesses to cause ! triumph ( virtue4 ,t is ! reason :y m5 h nev] lo/ rationality1 & :y1 to "s degree1 !y always p>ticipate 9 wisdom1 intellig5ce1 art1 & ! ju/ice t regulates _! mutual relations4 ,ev5 :5 "o wrongs ano!r1 he is /ill giv5 cr$it = act+ 9 ju/ice to himself1 & he is treat$ accord+ to 8 des]ts4#ec ,besides1 man1 z a creature1 is h&some1 z h&some z possible1 &1 by ! "p he plays 9 ! univ]se1 he is sup]ior to all ! animals t dwell "h bel[4 ,,x ,,is ,,ridicul\s ,,to ,,compla9 ,,( ,,! ,,l[] ,,nature ,,( ,,animals4 ,no "o 9 8 s5ses w\ld compla9 ( ! exi/5ce ( animals inf]ior to man1 if1 besides1 !y contribute t[>ds ! embelli%m5t ( ! univ]se4 ,w\ld x n be ridicul\s to compla9 t "s ( !m bite m51 z if ! latt] _h an imprescriptible "r to complete security8 ,! exi/5ce ( ^! animals is necess>y2 x procures u advantages bo? evid5t & /ill unkn[n1 b :i* w be reveal$ 9 ! c\rse ( "t4 ,?us !re is no?+ useless 9 animals1 ei!r 9 respect to !mselves1 or to man4#ed ,x is1 besides1 ridicul\s to compla9 because _m animals are wild1 :5 !re are ev5 m5 :o are su*2 :at %\ld surprise u mo/ is t _m animals are n submissive to man1 & def5d !mselves aga9/ him4#ee ,,if ,,unju/ ,,acts ,,are ,,produc$ ,,a/rologically ,,!n ,,div9e ,,reason ,,is ,,to ,,blame4 #aj4 ,b if m5 be evil only 9 spite ( !mselves1 & involunt>ily1 x w\ld be impossible to say t ^? :o commit inju/ices1 & ^? :o suff] !m are responsible 7! =m] = _! f]ocity1 & ! latt] = _! c[>dice4#ef ,to ?is we answ] t if ! wick$ness ( ! =m] 7z well z ! c[>dice ( ! latt]7 be1 necess>ily1 produc$ by ! c\rse ( ! />s1 or by ! action ( a pr9ciple ( :i* x is only ! effect1 !n x is expla9$ by physical reasons4 ,b if x be ! v ,reason ( ! univ]se t produces su* ?+s1 h[ does x n !reby commit an inju/ice8 ,,ev5 ,,involunt>9ess ,,does ,,n ,,affect ,,spontaneity ,,t ,,is ,,responsible4 ,unju/ actions are involunt>y only 9 ?is s5se t "o does n h ! w to commit a fault2 b ?is circum/ance does n h9d] ! spontaneity ( ! action4 ,h[ev]1 :5 "o acts spontane\sly1 "o is responsible = ! fault2 "o w\ld avoid responsibility = ! fault only if "o 7 n ! au?or ( ! action4 ,to say t ! wick$ are su* necess>ily1 does n mean t !y und]go an ext]nal con/ra9t1 b t _! "* is con/itut$ by wick$ness4 ,! influ5ce ( ! c\rse ( ! />s does n de/roy our lib]ty1 =1 if e action 9 u 7 det]m9$ by ! ext]ior influ5ce ( su* ag5ts1 ev]y?+ w\ld g on z ^! ag5ts desir$ x2 consequ5tly1 m5 w\ld n commit any actions contr>y to ! w ( ^! ag5ts4 ,if ! div9ities alone 7 ! au?ors ( all our actions1 !re w\ld be no impi\s p]sons2 !re=e1 impiety is due to m54 ,x is true t1 once ! cause is giv51 ! effects w foll[1 if only ! :ole s]ies ( causes be giv54 ,b man himself is "o ( ^! causes2 he !re=e does good by 8 own nature1 & he is a free cause4 ,,ev5 ,,! ,,%ad[s ,,are ,,necess>y ,,to ,,! ,,p]fection ,,( ,a ,,picture4 #aa4 ,is x true t all ?+s are produc$ by necessity1 & by ! natural concat5ation ( causes & effects1 & t1 ?us1 !y are z good z possible8 ,no6 ,x is ! ,reason :i*1 gov]n+ ! _w1 produces all ?+s 79 ?is s5se t x conta9s all ! sem9al reasons71 & :i* decrees t !y %all be :at !y are4 ,x is ,reason t1 9 con=mity ) its rational nature1 produces :at are call$ evils1 because x does n wi% ev]y?+ to be equally good4 ,an arti/ w\ld n cov] ! body ( a pictur$ animal ) eyes4#eg ,likewise1 ,reason did n limit itself to ! creation ( div9ities2 x produc$ b5ea? !m gu>dians1 !n m51 !n animals1 n by envy 7z ,plato rem>ks#eh72 b because its rational ess5ce conta9s an intellectual v>iety 7t is1 conta9s ! sem9al reasons ( all diff]5t be+s74 ,we resemble su* m5 z "k little ( pa9t+1 & :o w\ld blame an arti/ = hav+ put %ad[s 9 8 picture2 nev]!less1 he has only prop]ly dispos$ ! contra/s ( light4 ,likewise1 well-regulat$ /ates are n compos$ ( equal ord]s4 ,fur!r1 "o w\ld n condemn a trag$y1 because x pres5ts p]sonages o!r ?an h]oes1 su* z slaves or peasants :o speak incorrectly4#gh ,to cut out ^! inf]ior p]sonages1 & all ! p>ts 9 :i* !y appe>1 w\ld be to injure ! beauty ( ! composition4#ei ,,x ,,is ,,reasonable ,,= ,,! ,,reason ,,to ,,assign ,,s\ls ,,to ,,diff]5t ,,ranks ,,9 ,,! ,,univ]se4 #ab4 ,s9ce x is ! ,reason 7( ! _w7 :i* produc$ all ?+s by an alliance ) matt]1 & by pres]v+ its peculi> nature1 :i* is to be compos$ ( diff]5t p>ts1 & to be det]m9$ by ! pr9ciple f :i* x proce$s 7t is1 by ,intellig5ce71 ! "w produc$ by ,reason "u ^! conditions c\ld n be improv$ 9 beauty4 ,inde$1 ! ,reason 7( ! _w7 c\ld n be compos$ ( homog5e\s & simil> p>ts2 x mu/1 !re=e1 n be accus$1 because x is all ?+s1 & because all its p>ts diff] f o!rs4 ,if x _h introduc$ into ! _w ?+s :i* x _h n previ\sly conta9$1 z = in/ance1 s\ls1 & _h =c$ !m to ent] into ! ord] ( ! _w )\t consid]+ _! nature1 & if x _h made _m become degrad$1 ,reason w\ld c]ta9ly be to blame4 ,!re=e1 we mu/ ackn[l$ge t ! s\ls are p>ts ( ,reason1 & t ,reason h>monizes !m ) ! _w )\t caus+ _! degradation1 assign+ to ea* t /ation :i* is suitable to h]4 ,,div9e ,,ju/ice ,,ext5ds ,,also ,,into ,,pa/ ,,& ,,future4 #ac4 ,!re is a fur!r consid]ation t %\ld n be ov]look$1 namely3 t if y desire to discov] ! ex]cise ( ! di/ributive ,ju/ice ( ! div9ity1 x is n suffici5t to exam9e only ! pres5t2 ! pa/ & future mu/ also be consid]$4 ,^? :o1 9 a =m] life1 7 slave-own]s1 if !y abus$ _! p[]1 w be enslav$2 & ?is *ange w\ld be useful to !m4 ,x impov]i%es ^? :o h badly us$ _! weal?2 = pov]ty is ( s]vice ev5 to virtu\s p4 ,likewise1 ^? :o kill w 9 _! turn be kill$2 he :o commits homicide acts unju/ly1 b he :o is its victim suff]s ju/ly4 ,?us arises a h>mony betwe5 ! disposition ( ! man :o is maltreat$1 & ! disposition ( him :o maltreats him z he des]v$4 ,x is n by *ance t a man becomes a slave1 is made prison]1 or is di%onor$4 ,he 7mu/ himself7 h committ$ ! viol5ce :i* he 9 turn und]goes4 ,he :o kills 8 "m w be kill$ by 8 son2 he :o has violat$ a woman w 9 turn become a woman 9 ord] to become ! victim ( a rape4 ,h5ce1 ! div9e ,^w#hj call$ ,adra/ea4#fj ,! ord]ly sy/em "h m5tion$ really is unescapeable1 truly a ju/ice & an admirable wisdom4 ,f ! ?+s t we see 9 ! univ]se we mu/ conclude t ! ord] :i* reigns 9 x is et]nal1 t x p5etrates ev]y:]e1 ev5 9 ! smalle/ ?+2 & t x reveals an admirable art n only 9 ! div9e ?+s1 b also 9 ^? t might be suppos$ to be b5ea? ! notice ( ,provid5ce1 on acc\nt ( _! m9ut5ess4 ,consequ5tly1 !re is an admirable v>iety ( art 9 ! vile/ animal4 ,x ext5ds ev5 into plants1 ^: fruits & leaves are s di/+ui%$ by ! beauty ( =m1 ^: fl[]s bloom ) s mu* grace1 :i* gr[ s easily1 & :i* (f] s mu* v>iety4 ,^! ?+s 7 n produc$ once = all2 !y are cont9ually produc$ ) v>iety1 because ! />s 9 _! c\rses d n always ex]t ! same influ5ce on ?+s "h bel[4 ,:at is trans=m$ is n trans=m$ & metamorphos$ by *ance1 b accord+ to ! laws ( beauty1 & ! rules ( suitability obs]v$ by div9e p[]s4 ,e div9e ,p[] acts accord+ to its nature1 t is1 9 con=mity ) its ess5ce4 ,n[ its ess5ce is to develop ju/ice & beauty 9 its actualizations2 = if ju/ice & beauty did n exi/ "h1 !y c\ld n exi/ else:]e4 ,,! ,,creator ,,is ,,s ,,wise ,,t ,,all ,,compla9ts ,,am\nt ,,to ,,grotesqu5ess4 #ad4 ,! ord] ( ! univ]se con=ms to div9e ,intellig5ce )\t imply+ t on t acc\nt its au?or ne$$ to g ?r\gh ! process ( reason+4 ,nev]!less1 ?is ord] is s p]fect t he :o be/ kn[s h[ to reason w\ld be a/oni%$ to see t ev5 ) reason+ "o c\ld n discov] a plan wis] ?an t discov]$ z realiz$ 9 p>ticul> natures1 & t ?is plan bett] con=ms to ! laws ( ,intellig5ce ?an any t c\ld result f reason+4 ,x c nev]1 !re=e1 be prop] to f9d fault ) ! ,reason t produces all ?+s because ( any 7alleg$ imp]fections7 ( any natural object1 nor to claim1 = ! be+s ^: exi/5ce has begun1 ! p]fection ( ! be+s ^: exi/5ce _h no beg9n+1 & :i* are et]nal1 bo? 9 ! intelligible ,_w1 & 9 ?is s5se-_w4 ,t w\ld am\nt to wi%+ t e be+ %\ld possess m good ?an x c c>ry1 & to consid] z insuffici5t ! =m x receiv$4 ,x w\ld1 = in/ance1 am\nt to compla9+1 t man does n be> horns1 & to fail to notice t1 if ,reason _h to spread abroad ev]y:]e1 x 0 /ill necess>y = some?+ great to conta9 some?+ less1 t 9 ev]y?+ !re %\ld be p>ts1 & t ^! c\ld n equal ! :ole )\t ceas+ to be p>ts4 ,9 ! intelligible ,_w e ?+ is all2 b "h bel[ ea* ?+ is n all ?+s4 ,! individual man does n h ! same prop]ties z ! univ]sal ,man4 ,= if ! individual be+s _h some?+ :i* 0 n individual1 !n !y w\ld be univ]sal4 ,we %\ld n expect an individual be+ z su* to possess ! highe/ p]fection2 = !n x w\ld no long] be an individual be+4 ,d\btless1 ! beauty ( ! "p is n incompatible ) t ( ! :ole2 = ! m beautiful a "p is1 ! m does x embelli% ! :ole4 ,n[ ! "p becomes m beautiful on becom+ simil> to ! :ole1 or imitat+ its ess5ce1 & 9 con=m+ to its ord]4 ,?us a ray 7( ! supreme ,intellig5ce7 desc5ds "h bel[ ^u man1 & %9es 9 him l a /> 9 ! div9e sky4 ,to imag9e ! univ]se1 "o %\ld imag9e a colossal /atue#gi t 7 p]fectly beautiful1 animat$ or =m$ by ! art ( ,vulcan1 ^: e>s1 face & brea/ w\ld be adorn$ ) %imm]+ />s dispos$ ) m>vel\s skill4#fb ,,objection ,,( ,,int]nec9e ,,w> ,,among ,,animals ,,& ,,m54 #ae4 ,! above consid]ations suffice = ?+s /udi$ ea* 9 itself4 ,! mutual relation1 h[ev]1 betwe5 ?+s already begott51 & ^? t are /ill be+ begott5 f "t to "t1 des]ves to attract att5tion1 & may give rise to "s objections1 su* z ! foll[+3 ,h[ does x happ5 t animals dev\r ea* o!r1 t m5 attack ea* o!r mutually1 & t !y are always 9 ceaseless int]nec9e w>f>e8#fb ,h[ c\ld ! reason 7( ! univ]se7 h con/itut$ su* a /ate ( affairs1 :ile /ill claim+ t all is = ! be/8 ,,responsibility ,,_c ,,be ,,%ift$ ,,f ,,reason ,,:i* ,,is ,,responsible4 ,x does n suffice "h to answ]3#fc ,ev]y?+ is = ! be/ possible4 ,matt] is ! cause t ?+s are 9 a /ate ( inf]iority2 evils c\ld n be de/roy$4 ,x is true en\gh1 inde$1 t ?+s _h to be :at !y are1 = !y are good4 ,x is n matt] :i* has come to dom9ate ! univ]se2 x has be5 introduc$ 9 x s t ! univ]se might be :at x is1 or r1 x is caus$ by reason 7874 ,! pr9ciple ( ?+s is1 !re=e1 ! ,logos1 or ,reason#fd 7( ! univ]se71 :i* is ev]y?+4 ,by x 7 ?+s begott51 by x 7 !y co-ord9at$ 9 g5]ation4 ,,necessity ,,( ,,int]nec9e ,,w>f>e4 ,:at !n 7w x be object$7 is ! necessity ( ?is natural int]nec9e w>f>e ( animals1 & also ( m58 ,fir/1 animals h to dev\r ea* o!r 9 ord] to r5ew !mselves2 !y c\ld n1 inde$1 la/ et]nally1 ev5 if !y 7 n kill$4 ,is !re any reason to compla9 because1 be+ already condemn$ to dea?1 z !y are1 !y %\ld f9d an end :i* is useful to o!r be+s8 ,:at objection c !re be to _! mutually dev\r+ ea* o!r1 9 ord] to be reborn "u o!r =ms8 ,x is z if on ! /age an actor :o is ?\ght to be kill$1 goes to *ange 8 clo?+1 & returns "u ano!r mask4 ,is x object$ t he 0 n really dead8 ,yes inde$1 b dy+ is no m ?an a *ange ( bodies1 j z ! com$ian *anges 8 co/ume1 or if ! body 7 to be entirely despoil$1 ?is is no m ?an :5 an actor1 at ! end ( a drama1 lays aside 8 co/ume1 only to take x up aga9 :5 once m ! drama beg9s4 ,!re=e1 !re is no?+ frightful 9 ! mutual trans=mation ( animals into ea* o!r4 ,is x n bett] = !m to h liv$ "u ?is condition1 ?an nev] to h liv$ at all8 ,life w\ld !n be completely abs5t f ! univ]se1 & life c\ld no long] be communicat$ to o!r be+s4 ,b z ?is univ]se conta9s a multiple life1 x produces & v>ies ev]y?+ dur+ ! c\rse ( its exi/5ce2 z x 7 jok+ ) !m1 x nev] ceases to beget liv+ be+s1 rem>kable by beauty & by ! proportion ( _! =ms4 ,! combats 9 :i* mortal m5 cont9ually fight aga9/ ea* o!r1 ) a regul>ity /rongly rem9d+ ( ! ,pyrrhic dances 7z ?\ght ,plato#fe71 cle>ly %[ h[ all ^! affairs1 t are consid]$ s s]i\s1 are only *ildr5's games1 & t _! dea? 0 no?+ s]i\s4 ,to die e>ly 9 w>s & battles is to prec$e by only a v little "t ! unescapable fate ( old age1 & x is only an e>li] dep>ture = a clos] return4 ,we may be com=t$ = ! loss ( our possessions dur+ our lifetime by obs]v+ t !y h belong$ to o!rs be=e u1 & t1 = ^? :o h depriv$ u !re(1 !y =m b a v fragile possession1 s9ce !y1 9 turn1 w be b]eft !re( by o!rs2 & t1 if !y be n despoil$ ( _! ri*es1 !y w lose /ill m by keep+ !m4#ff ,murd]s1 massacres1 ! tak+ & pillag+ ( t[ns %\ld be consid]$ z 9 ! !atre we consid] *anges ( sc5e & ( p]sonages1 ! te>s & cries ( ! actors4#fg ,,all ,,^! ,,*anges ,,( ,,=tune ,,affect ,,only ,,! ,,out] ,,man ,,9 ,,any ,,case4 ,9 ?is _w1 inde$1 j z 9 ! !atre1 x is n ! s\l1 ! int]ior man1 b 8 %ad[1 ! ext]ior man1 :o gives himself up to lam5tations & groans1 :o on ?is e>? moves ab\t s mu*1 & :o makes ( x ! sc5e ( an imm5se drama ) numb]less diff]5t acts 787 ,su* is ! *>act]i/ic ( ! actions ( a man :o consid]s exclusively ! ?+s plac$ at 8 feet1 & outside ( him1 & :o does n "k t 8 te>s & s]i\s occupations are any m ?an games4#fh ,! really e>ne/ man occupies himself s]i\sly only ) really s]i\s affairs1 :ile ! frivol\s man applies himself to frivol\s ?+s4 ,inde$1 frivol\s ?+s become s]i\s = him :o does n "k really s]i\s occupations1 & :o himself is frivol\s4 ,if1 inde$1 "o _c help be+ mix$ up 9 ?is *ild's play1 x is j z well to "k t he has fall5 into *ild's play :]e "o's real p]sonality is n 9 "q4 ,if ,socrates 7 to m+le 9 ^! games1 x w\ld only be 8 ext]ior man :o w\ld d s4 ,let u add t te>s & groans d n prove t ! evils we are compla9+ ( are v real evils2 = (t5 *ildr5 weep & lam5t ov] imag9>y grievances4 ,,does ,,?is ,,po9t ,,( ,,view ,,de/roy ,,s9 ,,& ,,ju/ice8 #af4 ,if ! above consid]ations be true1 :at ab\t wick$ness1 inju/ice1 & s98 ,= if ev]y?+ be well1 h[ c !re be ag5ts :o are unju/1 & :o s98 ,if no "o be unju/1 or s9ful1 h[ c unhappy m5 exi/8 ,h[ c we say t c]ta9 ?+s con=m to nature1 :ile o!rs are contr>y !reto1 if ev]y?+ t is begott51 or t occurs1 con=ms to nature8 ,la/1 w\ld t po9t ( view n d away entirely ) impiety t[>ds ! div9ity1 if x be ! div9ity t makes ?+s su* z !y are1 if ! div9ity resemble a poet1 :o w\ld 9 8 drama introduce a "* ^: bus9ess x 0 to ridicule & criticize ! au?or8 ,,?is ,,problem ,,solv$ ,,by ,,reason ,,be+ ,,d]iv$ ,,f ,,intellig5ce4 ,let u1 !re=e1 m cle>ly def9e ! ,reason 7( ! univ]se71 & let u demon/rate t x %\ld be :at x is4 ,to rea* our conclusion m quickly1 let u grant ! exi/5ce ( ?is ,reason4 ,?is ,reason 7( ! univ]se7 is n pure1 absolute ,intellig5ce4 ,nei!r is x ! pure ,s\l1 b x dep5ds !refrom4 ,x is a ray ( light t spr+s bo? f ,intellig5ce & f ! ,s\l unit$ to ,intellig5ce4 ,^! two pr9ciples beget ,reason1 t is1 a rational quiet life4#fi ,n[ all life is an actualization1 ev5 t :i* occupies ! l[e/ rank4 ,b ! actualization 7:i* con/itutes ! life ( ,reason7 is n simil> to ! actualization ( fire4 ,! actualization ( ! life 7peculi> to ,reason71 ev5 )\t feel+1 is n a bl9d movem5t4 ,all ?+s t enjoy ! pres5ce ( ,reason1 & :i* p>ticipate !re9 9 any mann] soev]1 imm$iately receive a rational disposition1 t is1 a =m2 = ! actualization :i* con/itutes ! life 7( ! ,reason7 c imp>t its =ms1 & = t actualization motion is to =m be+s4 ,its movem5t1 l t ( a danc]1 is1 !re=e1 full ( art4 ,a danc]1 inde$1 gives u ! image ( t life full ( art2 x is ! art t moves x1 because ! art itself is its life4 ,all ?is is said to expla9 ! nature ( life1 :atev] x be4 ,,! ,,unity ,,( ,,reason ,,is ,,con/itut$ ,,by ,,! ,,contr>ies ,,x ,,conta9s4 ,z reason proce$s f ,intellig5ce & ,life1 :i* possesses bo? fulness & unity1 ,reason does n possess ! unity & fulness ( ,intellig5ce & ,life4 ,consequ5tly1 ,reason does n communicate ! totality & univ]sality ( its ess5ce to ! be+s to :i* x imp>ts itself4 ,x1 !re=e1 opposes its p>ts to ea* o!r1 & creates !m defective2 :]eby1 ,reason con/itutes & begets w> & /ruggle4 ,?us ,reason is ! univ]sal unity1 because x c\ld n be ! absolute unity4 ,?\gh reason imply /ruggle1 because x consi/s ( p>ts1 x also implies unity & h>mony4 ,x resembles ! reason ( a drama1 ^: unity conta9s _m div]sities4 ,9 a drama1 h[ev]1 ! h>mony ( ! :ole results f its compon5t contr>ies be+ co-ord9at$ 9 ! unity ( action1 :ile1 9 univ]sal ,reason1 x is f unity t ! /ruggle ( contr>ies arises4 ,t is :y we may well comp>e univ]sal ,reason to ! h>mony =m$ by contr>y s\nds1 & to exam9e :y ! reasons ( ! be+s also conta9 contr>ies4 ,9 a conc]t1 ^! reasons produce l[ & high s\nds1 &1 by virtue ( ! h>mony1 t con/itutes _! ess5ce1 !y make ^! div]s s\nds contribute to unity1 t is1 to ,h>mony#gj itself1 ! supreme ,reason ( :i* !y are only p>ts4#ga ,9 ! same way we mu/ consid] o!r oppositions 9 ! univ]se1 su* z black & :ite1 heat & cold1 w+$ or walk+ animals1 & reasonable & irrational be+s4 ,all ^! ?+s are p>ts ( ! s+le univ]sal ,organism4 ,n[ if ! p>ts ( ! univ]sal ,organism 7 (t5 9 mutual disagreem5t1 ! univ]sal ,organism1 nev]!less1 rema9s 9 p]fect accord ) itself because x is univ]sal1 & x is univ]sal by ! ,reason t inh]es 9 x4 ,! unity ( ?is ,reason mu/ !re=e be compos$ ( opposite reasons1 because _! v opposition someh[ con/itutes its ess5ce4 ,if ! ,reason 7( ! _w7 7 n multiple1 x w\ld no long] be univ]sal1 & w\ld n ev5 exi/ any long]4 ,s9ce x exi/s1 ,reason mu/1 !re=e1 conta9 )9 itself "s diff]5ce2 & ! greate/ diff]5ce is opposition4 ,n[ if ,reason conta9 a diff]5ce1 & produce diff]5t ?+s1 ! diff]5ce t exi/s 9 ^! ?+s is great] ?an t :i* exi/s 9 ,reason4 ,n[ diff]5ce c>ri$ to ! highe/ degree is opposition4 ,!re=e1 to be p]fect1 ,reason mu/ f its v ess5ce produce ?+s n only diff]5t1 b ev5 oppos$4 ,,! ,,:ole ,,is ,,good ,,?\gh ,,compos$ ,,( ,,good ,,& ,,evil ,,p>ts4 #ag4 ,if ,reason ?us f its ess5ce produce oppos$ ?+s1 ! ?+s x w produce w be s mu* ! m oppos$ z !y are m sep>at$ f ea* o!r4 ,! s5se-_w is less unit>y ?an its ,reason1 & consequ5tly1 x is m manifold1 conta9+ m oppositions4 ,?us1 9 individuals1 ! love ( life has great] =ce2 selfi%ness is m p[]ful 9 !m2 & (t51 by _! avidity1 !y de/roy :at !y love1 :5 !y love :at is p]i%able4 ,! love :i* ea* individual has = himself1 makes him appropriate all he c 9 8 relations ) ! univ]se4 ,?us ! good & evil are l$ to d opposite ?+s by ! ,art t gov]ns ! univ]se2 j z a *oric ballet w\ld be direct$4 ,"o "p is good1 ! o!r poor2 b ! :ole is good4 ,x might be object$ t 9 ?is case no evil p]son w be left4 ,/ill1 no?+ h9d]s ! exi/5ce ( ! evil2 only !y w n be su* z !y w\ld be tak5 by !mselves4 ,besides1 ?is w be a motive ( l5i5cy 9 reg>d to !m1 unless ,reason %\ld decide t ?is l5i5cy be n des]v$1 !reby mak+ x impossible4#gb ,,f\nd$ ,,on ,,! ,,pun ,,on ,,logos1 ,,z ,,"*1 ,,role ,,& ,,reason1 ,,! ,,evils ,,are ,,%[n ,,to ,,play ,,_! ,,"p ,,badly ,,9 ,,! ,,drama ,,( ,,life4 ,besides1 if ?is _w conta9 bo? bad & good p1 & if ! latt] play ! great] "p 9 ! _w1 !re w take place t :i* is se5 9 dramas :]e ! poet1 at times1 imposes 8 ideas on ! actors1 & aga9 at o!rs relies on _! +5uity4 ,! obta9+ ( ! fir/1 second or ?ird rank by an actor does n dep5d on ! poet4 ,! poet only assigns to ea* ! "p he is capable ( fill+1 & assigns to him a suitable place4 ,likewise 79 ! _w71 ea* "o occupies 8 assign$ place1 & ! bad man1 z well z ! good "o1 has ! place t suits him4 ,ea* "o1 accord+ to 8 nature & "*1 comes to occupy ! place t suits him1 & t he _h *os51 & !n speaks & acts ) piety if he be good1 & impi\sly1 if he be evil4 ,be=e ! beg9n+ ( ! drama1 ! actors already _h _! prop] *>act]s2 !y only develop$ x4 ,9 dramas compos$ by m51 x is ! poet :o assigns _! p>ts to ! actors2 & ! latt] are responsible only = ! effici5cy or ineffici5cy ( _! act+2 = !y h no?+ to d b repeat ! words ( ! poet4 ,b 9 ?is drama 7( life71 ( :i* m5 imitate c]ta9 p>ts :5 _! nature is poetic1 x is ! s\l t is ! actor4 ,?is actor receives 8 "p f ! creator1 z /age-actors receive f ! poet _! masks1 g>m5ts1 _! purple robe1 or _! rags4 ,?us 9 ! drama ( ! _w x is n f *ance t ! s\l receives h] "p4 ,,l ,,good ,,& ,,bad ,,actors1 ,,s\ls ,,are ,,puni%$ ,,& ,,rew>d$ ,,by ,,! ,,manag]4 ,inde$1 ! fate ( a s\l con=ms to h] "*1 &1 by go+ ?r\gh ) h] "p prop]ly1 ! s\l fulfils h] "p 9 ! drama manag$ by univ]sal ,reason4 ,! s\l s+s h] "p1 t is1 %e does t :i* is 9 h] nature to d4 ,if h] voice & features be beautiful1 by !mselves1 !y l5d *>m to ! poem1 z w\ld be natural4 ,o!rwise !y introduce a displeas+ elem5t1 b :i* does n alt] ! nature ( ! "w4#gc ,! au?or ( ! drama reprim&s ! bad actor z ! latt] may des]ve x1 & ?us fulfils ! "p ( a good judge4 ,he increases ! dignity ( ! good actor1 &1 if possible1 invites him to play beautiful pieces1 :ile he relegates ! bad actor to inf]ior pieces4 ,likewise1 ! s\l :i* takes "p 9 ! drama ( :i* ! _w is ! !atre1 & :i* has und]tak5 a "p 9 x1 br+s ) h] a disposition to play well or badly4 ,at h] arrival %e is class$ ) ! o!r actors1 & aft] hav+ be5 allott$ to all ! v>i\s gifts ( =tune )\t any reg>d = h] p]sonality or activities1 %e is lat] puni%$ or rew>d$4 ,su* actors h some?+ beyond usual actors2 !y appe> on a great] sc5e2 ! creator ( ! univ]se gives !m "s ( 8 p[]1 & grants !m ! fre$om to *oose betwe5 a great numb] ( places4 ,! puni%m5ts & rew>ds are s det]m9$ t ! s\ls !mselves run to meet !m1 because ea* s\l occupies a place 9 con=mity ) h] "*1 & is ?us 9 h>mony ) ! ,reason ( ! univ]se4#gd ,,! ,,s\l ,,mu/ ,,fit ,,h]self ,,to ,,h] ,,special ,,"p ,,9 ,,! ,,great ,,s*eme4 ,e individual1 !re=e1 occupies1 accord+ to ju/ice1 ! place he des]ves1 j z ea* /r+ ( ! lyre is fix$ to ! place assign$ to x by ! nature ( ! s\nds x is to r5d]4 ,9 ! univ]se ev]y?+ is good & beautiful if e be+ occupy ! place he des]ves1 if1 = in/ance1 he utt] discordant s\nds :5 9 d>kness & ,t>t>us2 = su* s\nds fit t place4 ,if ! univ]se is to be beautiful1 ! individual mu/ n behave l a /one 9 x2 he mu/ contribute to ! unity ( ! univ]sal h>mony by utt]+ ! s\nd suitable to him 7z ?\ght ,epictetus#ge74 ,! s\nd t ! individual utt]s is ! life he leads1 a life :i* is inf]ior 9 greatness1 goodness & p[] 7to t ( ! univ]se74 ,! %eph]d's pipe utt]s sev]al s\nds1 & ! weake/ ( !m1 nev]!less1 contributes to ! total ,h>mony1 because ?is h>mony is compos$ ( unequal s\nds ^: totality con/itutes a p]fect h>mony4 ,likewise1 univ]sal ,reason ?\gh "o1 conta9s unequal p>ts4 ,consequ5tly1 ! univ]se conta9s diff]5t places1 "s bett]1 & "s worse1 & _! inequality corresponds to ! inequality ( ! s\l4 ,inde$1 z bo? places & s\ls are diff]5t1 ! s\ls t are diff]5t f9d ! places t are unequal1 l ! unequal p>ts ( ! pipe1 or any o!r musical in/rum5t4 ,!y inhabit diff]5t places1 & ea* utt]s s\nds prop] to ! place :]e !y are1 & to ! univ]se4 ,?us :at is bad = ! individual may be good = ! totality2 :at is aga9/ nature 9 ! individual agrees ) ! nature 9 ! :ole4 ,a s\nd t is feeble does n *ange ! h>mony ( ! univ]se1 z--to use ano!r example--"o bad citiz5 does n *ange ! nature ( a well-regulat$ city2 = (t5 !re is ne$ ( su* a man 9 a city2 he !re=e fits x well4 ,,univ]sal ,,reason ,,tries ,,to ,,pat* ,,up ,,gags ,,by ,,undiscipl9$ ,,actors4 #ah4 ,! diff]5ce t exi/s betwe5 s\ls 9 respect to vice & virtue has sev]al causes2 among o!rs1 ! inequality t exi/s betwe5 s\ls f ! v beg9n+4 ,?is inequality con=ms to ! ess5ce ( univ]sal ,reason1 ( :i* !y are unequal p>ts1 because !y diff] f ea* o!r4 ,we mu/ inde$ rememb] t s\ls h ?ree ranks 7! intellectual1 rational1 & s5se lives71 & t ! same s\l does n always ex]cise ! same faculties4 ,b1 to expla9 our mean+1 let u return to our =m] illu/ration4 ,let u imag9e actors :o utt] words n writt5 by ! poet2 z if ! drama 7 incomplete1 !y !mselves supply :at is lack+1 & fill omissions made by ! poet4 ,!y seem less l actors ?an l p>ts ( ! poet1 :o =esaw :at !y 7 to say1 s z to reatta* ! rema9d] s f> z x 0 9 8 p[]4#gf ,9 ! univ]se1 inde$1 all ?+s t are ! consequ5ces & results ( bad de$s are produc$ by reasons1 & con=m to ! univ]sal ,reason4 ,?us1 f an illicit union1 or f a rape1 may be born natural *ildr5 t may become v di/+ui%$ m52 likewise1 f cities de/roy$ by p]v]se individuals1 may rise o!r fl\ri%+ cities4 ,,?is ,,illu/ration ,,( ,,drama ,,all[s ,,bo? ,,good ,,& ,,evil ,,to ,,be ,,ascrib$ ,,to ,,reason4 ,x might inde$ be object$ t x is absurd to introduce into ! _w s\ls "s ( :i* d good1 & o!rs evil2 = :5 we absolve univ]sal ,reason f ! responsibility ( evil1 we are also simultane\sly tak+ f x ! m]it = ! good4 ,:at1 h[ev]1 h9d]s u f consid]+ de$s done by actors z p>ts ( a drama1 9 ! univ]se z well z on ! /age1 & ?us to d]ive f univ]sal ,reason bo? ! good & ! evil t are done "h bel[8 ,= univ]sal ,reason ex]cises its influ5ce on ea* ( ! actors ) s mu* ! great] =ce z ! drama is m p]fect1 & z ev]y?+ dep5ds on x4#gg ,,introduction ,,to ,,! ,,next ,,book4 ,b :y %\ld we at all impute evil de$s to univ]sal ,reason8 ,! s\ls conta9$ 9 ! univ]se w n be any m div9e = t4 ,!y w /ill rema9 p>ts ( ! univ]sal ,reason 7& consequ5tly1 rema9 s\ls73 = we %all h to ackn[l$ge t all reasons are s\ls4 ,o!rwise if ! ,reason ( ! univ]se be a ,s\l1 :y %\ld c]ta9 reasons be s\ls1 & o!rs only 7sem9al7 reasons8 ,,?ird ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,?ree4 ,cont9uation ( ,t on ,provid5ce4 ,,s\ls ,,%[ ,,k9%ip ,,to ,,_w-,,s\l ,,by ,,fidelity ,,to ,,_! ,,own ,,nature4 #a4 ,! "q 7:y "s reasons are s\ls1 :ile o!rs are reasons m]ely1 :5 at ! same "t univ]sal ,reason is a c]ta9 ,s\l71 may be answ]$ z foll[s4 ,univ]sal ,reason 7:i* proce$s f ! univ]sal ,s\l7 embraces bo? good & bad ?+s1 :i* equally belong to its p>ts2 x does n eng5d] !m1 b exi/s ) !m 9 its univ]sality4 ,9 fact1 ^! logoses 7or reasons7 7or1 p>ticul> s\ls71 are ! acts ( ! univ]sal ,s\l2 & ^! reasons be+ p>ts 7( ! univ]sal ,s\l7 h p>ts 7( ! op]ations7 z _! acts 7or en]gies74 ,!re=e1 j z ! univ]sal ,s\l1 :i* is "o1 has diff]5t p>ts1 s ?is diff]5ce occurs aga9 9 ! reasons & 9 ! op]ations !y effect4 ,j z _! works 7h>monize71 s d ! s\ls !mselves mutually h>monize2 !y h>monize 9 ?is1 t _! v div]sity1 or ev5 opposition1 =ms an unity4 ,by a natural necessity does ev]y?+ proce$ f1 & return to unity2 ?us creatures :i* are diff]5t1 or ev5 oppos$1 are n any ! less co-ord9at$ 9 ! same sy/em1 & t because !y proce$ f ! same pr9ciple4 ,?us horses or human be+s are subsum$ "u ! unity ( ! animal species1 ev5 ?\gh animals ( any k9d1 su* z horses1 = example1 bite ea* o!r1 & /ruggle aga9/ ea* o!r ) a jeal\sy :i* rises to fury2 & ?\gh animals ( ei!r species1 includ+ man1 d z mu*4 ,likewise1 ) inanimate ?+s2 !y =m div]s species1 & %\ld likewise be subsum$ "u ! g5us ( inanimate ?+s2 &1 if y g fur!r1 to ess5ce1 & fur!r /ill1 to sup]-,ess5ce 7! ,"o74 ,hav+ ?us relat$ or subsum$ ev]y?+ to ?is pr9ciple1 let u aga9 desc5d1 by divid+ x4 ,we %all see unity splitt+1 z x p5etrates & embraces ev]y?+ simultane\sly 9 a unique 7or all-embrac+ sy/em74 ,?us divid$1 ! unity con/itutes a multiple organism2 ea* ( its con/itu5t p>ts acts accord+ to its nature1 )\t ceas+ to =m "p ( ! univ]sal ,be+2 ?us is x t ! fire burns1 ! horse behaves z a horse %\ld1 & m5 p]=m de$s z v>i\s z _! *>act]s4 ,9 %ort1 e be+ acts1 lives well or badly1 accord+ to its own nature4 ,,app>5t ,,*ance ,,really ,,is ,,! ,,plan ,,( ,a ,,div9e ,,g5]al ,,provid5ce4 #b4 ,circum/ances1 !re=e1 are n decisive ( human =tune2 !y !mselves only d]ive naturally f sup]ior pr9ciples1 & result f ! mutual concat5ation ( all ?+s4 ,?is concat5ation1 h[ev]1 d]ives f ! 7,/oic7 pr$om9ant 7elem5t 9 ! univ]se71 & e be+ contributes to x accord+ to its nature2 j z1 9 an army1 ! g5]al comm&s1 & ! soldi]s c>ry out 8 ord]s coop]atively4 ,9 ! univ]se1 9 fact1 ev]y?+ has be5 /rategically ord]$ by ,provid5ce1 l a g5]al1 :o consid]s ev]y?+1 bo? actions & exp]i5ces1#ha victuals & dr9k1 weapons & implem5ts1 arrang+ ev]y?+ s t e detail f9ds its suitable location4 ,?us no?+ happ5s :i* fails to ent] into ! g5]al's plan1 al?\gh 8 oppon5ts' do+s rema9 =eign to 8 influ5ce1 & ?\gh he _c comm& _! army4 ,if inde$1 ,provid5ce 7#hb ! great ,*ief ov] all1 to :om ! univ]se is subord9at$1 :at c\ld h dis>rang$ ,8 plans1 & c\ld h fail$ to be intimately associat$ !re)8 ,,we ,,_c ,,"q ,,our ,,ord] ,,9 ,,! ,,hi]>*y ,,( ,,nature4 #c4 ,al?\gh ,i am able to make any desir$ decision1 nev]!less my decision ent]s into ! plan ( ! univ]se1 because my nature has n be5 introduc$ into ?is plan subsequ5tly2 b x includes me & my "*4 ,b :5ce orig9ates my "*8 ,?is includes two po9ts3 is ! cause ( any man's "* to be locat$ 9 ,him :o =m$ him1 or 9 t man himself8 ,mu/ we1 on ! o!r h&1 give up seek+ its cause8 ,surely3 j z x is hopeless to ask :y plants h no s5sation1 or :y animals are n m52 x w\ld be ! same z ask+ :y m5 are n gods4 ,:y %\ld we compla9 t m5 d n h a m p]fect nature1 if 9 ! case ( plants & animals nobody que/ions or accuses ei!r ^! be+s !mselves1 nor ! p[] :i* has made !m8 7,?is w\ld be s5seless1 = two reasons73 if we say t !y might h be5 bett]1 we are ei!r speak+ ( ! qualities :i* ea* ( !m is capable ( acquir+ by himself2 & 9 ?is case we %\ld blame only him :o has n acquir$ !m--or1 we are speak+ ( ^? qualities :i* he %\ld d]ive n f himself1 b f ! ,creator1 9 :i* case x w\ld be z absurd to claim = man m qualities ?an he has receiv$1 ?an x w\ld be to d s 9 ! case ( plants or animals4 ,:at we %\ld exam9e is n if "o be+ be inf]ior to ano!r1 b if x be complete )9 its own sph]e2 = evid5tly natural inequalities are unavoidable4 ,?is aga9 dep5ds on con=mity to nature1 n t inequalities dep5d on ! w ( ! pr9ciple :i* has regulat$ all ?+s4 ,,! ,,cause ,,( ,,our ,,imp]fections ,,is ,,di/ance ,,f ,,! ,,supreme4 ,! ,reason ( ! ,univ]se1 inde$1 proce$s f ! univ]sal ,s\l2 & ! latt]1 9 turn1 proce$s f ,intellig5ce4 ,intellig5ce1 h[ev]1 is n a p>ticul> be+2 x consi/s ( all 7intelligible be+s71#hc & all ! be+s =m a plurality4 ,n[1 a plurality ( be+ implies mutual diff]5ces betwe5 !m1 consi/+ ( fir/1 second & ?ird ranks4 ,consequ5tly1 ! s\ls ( eng5d]$ animals are r degradations ( s\ls1 seem+ to h gr[n weak] by _! procession4 ,! 7g5]at+7 reason ( ! animal1 inde$1 al?\gh x be animat$1 is a s\l o!r ?an t f :i* proce$s univ]sal ,reason4 ,?is ,reason itself loses excell5ce 9 ! degree t x ha/5s d[n to ent] into matt]1 & :at x produces is less p]fect4 ,nev]!less1 we may well consid] h[ admirable a "w is ! creature1 al?\gh x be s f> di/ant f ! creator4 ,we %\ld1 !re=e1 n attribute to ! creator ! 7imp]fections ( !7 creature2 = any pr9ciple is sup]ior to its product4 ,s we may ass]t t 7! pr9ciple ev5 ( imp]fect ?+s7 is p]fect2 &1 7in/ead ( compla9+71 we %\ld r admire ,8 communication ( "s traits ( ,8 p[] to be+s dep5d5t f ,him4 ,we h ev5 reason to be m ?an grateful = ,8 hav+ giv5 gifts great] ?an !y c receive or assimilate2 & z ! gifts ( ,provid5ce are sup]abundant1 we c f9d ! cause 7( imp]fection7 only 9 ! creatures !mselves4 ,,d\bl5ess ,,( ,,s\l1 ,,reasons ,,& ,,provid5ce4 #d4 ,if man 7 simple--t is1 if he 7 no m ?an :at he _h be5 creat$1 & if all 8 actions & passions d]iv$ f ! same pr9ciple--we w\ld no m ex]cise our reason to compla9 = 8 beho( ?an we h to compla9 = t ( o!r animals4 ,b we d h some?+ to blame 9 ! man1 & t 9 ! p]v]t$ man4 ,we h good gr\nds = ?is blame1 because man is n only t :i* he 0 creat$1 b has1 besides1 ano!r pr9ciple :i* is free 7intellig5ce1 ) reason74 ,?is free pr9ciple1 h[ev]1 is n outside ( ,provid5ce1 & ! ,reason ( ! univ]se1 any m ?an x w\ld be reasonable to suppose t ! ?+s above dep5d$ on ! ?+s "h bel[4 ,on ! contr>y1 x is sup]ior ?+s :i* %$ _! radiance on inf]ior ones1 & ?is is ! cause ( ! p]fection ( ,provid5ce4 ,z to ! ,reason ( ! univ]se1 x itself is d\ble also2 "o produces ?+s1 :ile ! o!r unites g5]at$ ?+s to intelligible ones4 ,?us are con/itut$ two provid5ces3 a sup]ior "o1 f above 7intellectual ,reason1 ! pr9cipal p[] ( ! s\l#hd71 & an inf]ior "o1 ! 7natural & g5]ative p[]1 call$7 reason1 :i* d]ives f ! fir/2 & f bo? results ! concat5ation ( ?+s1 & univ]sal ,provid5ce 7or1 ,provid5ce1 & de/9y74 ,,m5',s ,,bett] ,,nature ,,is ,,n ,,dom9ant ,,because ,,( ,,_! ,,sub-,,consci\s ,,nature4 ,m5 7!re=e1 n be+ only :at !y 7 made7 possess ano!r pr9ciple 7free intellig5ce ) reason72 b n all make use ( all ! pr9ciples !y possess2 "s make use ( ! "o pr9ciple 7_! intellig5ce71 :ile o!rs make use ( ! o!r 7pr9ciple ( reason71 or ev5 ( ! l[] pr9ciple 7( imag9ation & s5sation74#he ,all ^! pr9ciples are pres5t 9 ! man1 ev5 :5 !y d n react on him2 & ev5 9 ?is case1 !y are n in]t2 ea* fulfils its peculi> (fice2 only !y d n all act simultane\sly ^u him 7or1 are n p]ceiv$ by 8 consci\sness74 ,x may seem difficult to und]/& h[ ?is may be ! case ) all ( !m pres5t1 & x might seem easi] to consid] !m abs5t2 b !y are pres5t 9 u1 9 ! s5se t we lack none ( !m2 al?\gh we might consid] !m abs5t 9 ! s5se t a pr9ciple t does n react on a man might be consid]$ abs5t f him4 ,x might be ask$ :y ^! pr9ciples d n react on all m51 s9ce !y are "p ( !m8 ,we might1 ref]r+ *iefly to ?is 7free1 intellig5t1 reasonable7 pr9ciple1 say t fir/1 x does n belong to animals2 second1 x is n ev5 7practic$7 by all m54 ,if x be n pres5t 9 all m51 s mu* ! m is x n alone 9 !m1 because ! be+ 9 :om ?is pr9ciple alone is pres5t lives accord+ to ?is pr9ciple1 & lives accord+ to o!r pr9ciples only s f> z he is compell$ by necessity4 ,! cause 7:i* h9d]s intellig5ce & reason f dom9at+ u7 w h to be s\ght 9 ! 7,/oic7 sub/rate ( ! man1 ei!r because our corporeal con/itution tr\bles ! sup]ior pr9ciple 7( reason & intellig5ce71 or because ( ! pr$om9ance ( our passions4 7,aft] all71 we h n yet rea*$ any conclusion1 because ?is sub/rate ( man is compos$ ( two elem5ts3 ! 7sem9al7 reason1#hf & matt]2 7& ei!r ( !m might be ! cause74 ,at fir/ blu%1 x w\ld seem t ! cause 7( ! pr$om9ance ( our l[] natures7 mu/ be s\ght 9 matt]1 r ?an 9 ! 7sem9al7 reason2 & t :i* dom9ates 9 u is n 7sem9al7 reason1 b matt] & organiz$ sub/rate4 ,?is1 h[ev]1 is n ! case4 ,:at plays ! "p ( sub/rate 9 respect ( ! sup]ior pr9ciple 7( free intellig5ce & reason71 is bo? ! 7sem9al7 reason1 & t :i* is g5]at$ !reby1 con=m+ to t reason2 consequ5tly1 ! pr$om9ant elem5t 9 u is n matt]1 any m ?an our corporeal con/itution4 ,,human ,,"* ,,may ,,be ,,result ,,( ,,=m] ,,lives4 ,besides1 our individual *>act]s might be d]iv$ f pre-exi/5ces4 ,9 ?is case we w\ld say t our 7sem9al7 reason has deg5]at$ z a result ( our antec$5ts1 t our s\l has lo/ h] =ce by irradiat+ :at 0 bel[ h]4 ,besides1 our 7sem9al7 reason conta9s )9 itself ! v reason ( our con/itu5t matt]1 a matt] :i* x discov]$1 or con=m$ to its own nature4#hg ,9 fact1 ! 7sem9al7 reason ( an ox resides 9 no matt] o!r ?an t ( an ox4 ,?us1 z said 7,plato#hh71 ! s\l f9ds h]self de/9$ to pass into ! bodies ( animals o!r ?an m51 because1 j l ! 7sem9al7 reason1 %e has alt]$1 & has become su* z to animate an ox1 in/ead ( a man4 ,by ?is decree ( div9e ju/ice %e becomes /ill worse ?an %e 04 ,,causes ,,( ,,det]ioration4 ,b :y did ! s\l ev] lose h] way1 or det]iorate8 ,we h (t5 said t n all s\ls belong to ! fir/ rank2 "s belong to a second1 or ev5 ?ird rank1 & :o1 consequ5tly1 are inf]ior to ^? ( ! fir/4 ,fur!r1 leav+ ! "r road may be caus$ by a trifl+ div]g5ce4 ,?ird1 ! approximation ( two diff]+ ?+s produces a comb9ation :i* may be consid]$ a ?ird some:at1 diff]5t f ! o!r two compon5ts4 7,?us ev5 9 ?is new elem5t1 or habituation7 ! be+ does n lose ! qualities he receiv$ ) 8 exi/5ce2 if he be inf]ior1 he has be5 creat$ inf]ior f ! v orig92 x is :at he 0 creat$1 he is inf]ior by ! v virtue ( 8 nature2 if he suff] ! consequ5ces !re(1 he suff]s !m ju/ly4 ,f\r?1 we mu/ all[ = our ant]ior exi/5ce1 because ev]y?+ t happ5s to u to-day results f our antec$5ts4 ,,?is ,,provid5ce ,,is ,,! ,,normative1 ,,curative1 ,,sanative ,,elem5t ,,( ,,life4 #e4 ,f fir/ to la/ ,provid5ce desc5ds f on high1 communicat+ its gifts n accord+ to ! law ( an equality t w\ld be num]ic1 b proportionate1 v>y+ its op]ations accord+ to locality 7or occasion74 ,s1 9 ! organization ( an animal1 f beg9n+ to end1 ev]y?+ is relat$2 e memb] has its peculi> function1 sup]ior or inf]ior1 accord+ to ! rank x occupies2 x has also its peculi> passions1 passions :i* are 9 h>mony ) its nature1 & ! place x occupies 9 ! sy/em ( ?+s4 ,s1 = in/ance1 a bl[ excites responses t diff] accord+ to ! organ t receiv$ x2 ! vocal organ w produce a s\nd2 ano!r organ w suff] 9 sil5ce1 or execute a movem5t resultant f t passion2 n[1 all s\nds1 actions & passions =m 9 ! animal ! unity ( s\nd1 life & exi/5ce4#hi ,! p>ts1 be+ v>i\s1 play diff]5t roles2 ?us !re are diff]+ functions = ! feet1 ! eyes1 discursive reason1 & intellig5ce4 ,b all ?+s =m "o unity1 relat+ to a s+le ,provid5ce1 s t de/9y gov]ns :at is bel[1 & provid5ce reigns alone 9 :at is on high4 ,9 fact1 all t lies 9 ! intelligible _w is ei!r rational or sup]-rational1 namely3 ,intellig5ce & pure ,s\l4 ,:at d]ives !refrom con/itutes ,provid5ce1 z f> z x d]ives !refrom1 z x is 9 pure ,s\l1 & !nce passes into ! animals4 ,!nce arises 7univ]sal7 ,reason1 :i*1 be+ di/ribut$ 9 unequal p>ts1 produces ?+s unequal1 su* z ! memb]s ( an animal4 ,z consequ5ces f ,provid5ce are d]iv$ ! human de$s :i* are agreeable to ! div9ity4 ,all su* actions are relat$ 7to ! plan ( ,provid5ce72 !y are n done by ,provid5ce2 b :5 a man1 or ano!r animate or inanimate be+ p]=ms "s de$s1 ^!1 if !re be any good 9 !m1 ent] into ! plan ( ,provid5ce1 :i* ev]y:]e e/abli%es virtue1 & am5ds or corrects errors4 ,?us does e animal ma9ta9 its bodily heal? by ! k9d ( provid5ce )9 him2 on ! occasion ( a cut or w\nd ! 7sem9al7 reason :i* adm9i/]s ! body ( ?is animal imm$iately draws 7! tissues7 toge!r1 & =ms sc>s ov] ! fle%1 re-e/abli%es heal?1 & invigorates ! memb]s t h suff]$4 ,,! ,,plans ,,( ,,provid5ce ,,lik5$ ,,to ,,! ,,=ekn[l$ge ,,( ,a ,,physician4 ,consequ5tly1 our evils are ! consequ5ces 7( our actions72 !y are its necess>y effects1 n t we are c>ri$ away by ,provid5ce1 b 9 ! s5se t we obey an impulsion ^: pr9ciple is 9 ourselves4 ,we ourselves !n inde$ try to reatta* our acts to ! plan ( ,provid5ce1 b we _c con=m _! consequ5ces to its w2 our acts1 !re=e1 con=m ei!r to our w1 or to o!r ?+s 9 ! univ]se1 :i*1 act+ on u1 d n produce 9 u an affection con=m$ to ! int5tions ( ,provid5ce4 ,9 fact1 ! same cause does n act id5tically on diff]5t be+s1 = ! effects exp]i5c$ by ea* diff] accord+ to _! nature4 ,?us ,hel5a causes emotions 9 ,p>is :i* diff] f ^? ( ,idum5eus4#ij ,likewise1 ! h&some man produces on a h&some man an effect diff]5t f t ( ! intemp]ate man on ! intemp]ate2 ! h&some & temp]ate man acts diff]5tly on ! h&some & temp]ate man ?an on ! intemp]ate2 & ?an ! intemp]ate on himself4 ,! de$ done by ! intemp]ate man is done nei!r by ,provid5ce1 nor accord+ to ,provid5ce4#ia ,nei!r is ! de$ done by ! temp]ate man done by ,provid5ce2 s9ce he does x himself2 b x con=ms to ,provid5ce1 because x con=ms to ! ,reason 7( ! univ]se74 ,?us1 :5 a man has done some?+ good = 8 heal?1 x is he himself :o has done x1 b he !reby con=ms to ! reason ( ! physician2 = x is ! physician :o tea*es him1 by means ( 8 art1 :at ?+s are heal?y or unheal?y2 b :5 a man has done some?+ injuri\s to 8 heal?1 x is he himself :o has done x1 & he does x aga9/ ! provid5ce ( ! physician4 ,,pr$iction ,,does ,,n ,,"w ,,by ,,provid5ce1 ,,b ,,by ,,analogy4 #f4 ,if !n 7! bad ?+s d n con=m to ,provid5ce71 ! div9]s & a/rolog]s pr$ict evil ?+s only by ! concat5ation :i* occurs betwe5 contr>ies1 betwe5 =m & matt]1 = in/ance1 9 a composite be+4 ,?us 9 contemplat+ ! =m & 7sem9al7 reason "o is really contemplat+ ! be+ :i* receives ! =m2 = "o does n contemplate 9 ! same way ! intelligible animal1 & ! composite animal2 :at "o contemplates 9 ! composite animal is ! 7sem9al7 reason :i* gives =m to :at is inf]ior4 ,!re=e1 s9ce ! _w is an animal1 :5 "o contemplates its occurr5ces1 "o is really contemplat+ ! causes t make !m arise1 ! ,provid5ce :i* presides ov] !m1 & ^: action ext5ds 9 an ord]ly mann] to all be+s & ev5ts2 t is1 to all animals1 _! actions & dispositions1 :i* are dom9at$ by ,reason & m+l$ ) necessity4 ,we ?us contemplate :at has be5 m+l$ s9ce ! beg9n+1 & :at is /ill cont9ually m+l$4 ,9 ?is mixture1 consequ5tly1 x is impossible to di/+ui% ,provid5ce f :at con=ms !reto1 nor :at d]ives f ! sub/rate 7t is1 f matt]1 & :i*1 consequ5tly1 is de=m$1 & evil74 ,?is is n a human task1 n ev5 ( a man :o might be wise or div9e2 su* a privilege c be ascrib$ only to ,god4 ,,facts ,,( ,,life ,,are ,,lett]s ,,t ,,c ,,be ,,read4 ,9 fact1 ! function ( ! div9] is n to di/+ui% ! cause1 b ! fact2 8 art consi/s 9 read+ ! *>act]s trac$ by nature1 & :i* inv>iably indicate ! ord] & concat5ation ( facts2 or r1 9 /udy+ ! signs ( ! univ]sal movem5t1 :i* designate ! "* ( ea* be+ be=e its revelation 9 himself4 ,all be+s1 9 fact1 ex]cise ^u ea* o!r a reciprocal influ5ce1 & concur toge!r 9 ! con/itution & p]petuity ( ! _w4#ib ,to him :o /udies1 analogy reveals ! m>* ( ev5ts1 because all k9ds ( div9ation are f\nd$ on its laws2 = ?+s 7 n to dep5d on ea* o!r1 b to h relations f\nd$ on _! resemblance4#ic ,?is no d\bt is t :i*#id is meant by ! expression t analogy embraces ev]y?+4 ,,analogy ,,dem&$ ,,by ,,! ,,unity ,,( ,,god4 ,n[1 :at is ?is analogy8 ,x is a relation betwe5 ! worse & ! worse1 ! bett] & ! bett]1 "o eye & ! o!r1 "o foot & ! o!r1 virtue & ju/ice1 vice & inju/ice4 ,! analogy :i* reigns 9 ! univ]se is !n t :i* makes div9ation possible4 ,! influ5ce :i* "o be+ ex]cises on ano!r con=ms to ! laws ( influ5ce :i* ! memb]s ( ! univ]sal ,organism mu/ ex]cise ^u ea* o!r4 ,! "o does n produce ! o!r2 = all are g5]at$ toge!r2 b ea* is affect$ accord+ to its nature1 ea* 9 its own mann]4 ,?is con/itutes ! unity ( ! ,reason ( ! univ]se4 ,,evil ,,is ,,insep>able ,,f ,,! ,,good4 #g4 ,x is only because !re are good ?+s 9 ! _w1 t !re are worse ones4 ,grant+ ! conception ( v>iety1 h[ c\ld ! worse exi/ )\t ! bett]1 or ! bett] )\t ! worse8 ,we %\ld n1 !re=e1 accuse ! bett] because ( ! exi/5ce ( ! worse2 b r we %\ld rejoice 9 ! pres5ce ( ! bett]1 because x communicates a little ( its p]fection to ! worse4 ,to wi% to annihilate ! worse 9 ! _w is tantam\nt to annihilat+ ,provid5ce itself2#ie = if we annihilate ! worse1 to :at c\ld ,provid5ce be appli$8 ,nei!r to itself1 nor to ! bett]2 = :5 we speak ( supreme ,provid5ce1 we call x supreme 9 contra/ ) t :i* is inf]ior to x4 ,,! ,,p>able ,,( ,,! ,,v9e ,,& ,,! ,,bran*es4 ,inde$1 ! 7supreme7 ,pr9ciple is t to :i* all o!r ?+s relate1 t 9 :i* !y all simultane\sly exi/1 ?us con/itut+ ! totality4 ,all ?+s proce$ f ! ,pr9ciple1 :ile x rema9s wrapt 9 itself4 ,?us1 f a s+le root1 :i* rema9s wrapt 9 itself1 issue a ho/ ( p>ts1 ea* ( :i* (f]s ! image ( _! root "u a diff]5t =m4 ,"s ( !m t\* ! root2 o!rs tr5d away f x1 divid+ & subdivid+ d[n to ! bran*es1 twigs1 leaves & fruits2 "s abide p]man5tly 7l ! bran*es72 o!rs swirl 9 a p]petual flux1 l ! leaves & fruits4 ,^! latt] p>ts :i* swirl 9 a p]petual flux conta9 )9 !mselves ! 7sem9al7 reasons ( ! p>ts f :i* !y proce$ 7& :i* abide p]man5tly72 !y !mselves seem dispos$ to be little m9iature trees2 if !y eng5d]$ be=e p]i%+1 !y w\ld eng5d] only t :i* is ne>e/ to !m4 ,z to ! p>ts 7:i* abide p]man5tly71 & :i* are holl[1 su* z ! bran*es1 !y receive f ! root ! sap :i* is to fill !m2 = !y h a nature diff]5t 7f t ( ! leaves1 fl[]s1 & fruits74 ,consequ5tly1 x is ! bran*es' extremities t exp]i5ce passions 7or modifications7 :i* !y seem to d]ive only f ! contigu\s p>ts4 ,! p>ts contigu\s to ! ,root are passive on "o end1 & active on ! o!r2 b ! ,pr9ciple itself is relat$ to all4 ,al?\gh all ! p>ts issue f ! same ,pr9ciple1#if yet !y diff] f ea* o!r m z !y are m di/ant f ! root4 ,su* w\ld be ! mutual relations ( two bro!rs :o resemble ea* o!r because !y are born f ! same p>5ts4 ,,fif? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,?ree4 ,! ,self-,consci\snesses1 & ,:at is ,above ,!m4#ig ,,is ,,k ,,dep5d5t ,,on ,,! ,,composit5ess ,,( ,,! ,,kn[]8 #a4 ,mu/ ?\ght1 & self-consci\sness imply be+ compos$ ( diff]5t p>ts1 & on _! mutual contemplation8 ,mu/ t :i* is absolutely simple be unable to turn t[>ds itself1 to "k itself8 ls x1 on ! contr>y1 possible t = t :i* is n composite to "k itself8 ,self-consci\sness1 inde$1 does n necess>ily result f a ?+'s kn[+ itself because x is composite1 & t "o ( its p>ts grasps ! o!r2 z1 = in/ance1 by s5sation we p]ceive ! =m & nature ( our body4 ,9 ?is case ! :ole w n be kn[n1 unless ! "p t kn[s ! o!rs to :i* x is unit$ also kn[s itself2 o!rwise1 we w\ld f9d ! k ( "o entity1 ?r\gh ano!r1 in/ead ( "o entity ?r\gh itself4 ,a ,,simple ,,pr9ciple ,,c ,,h ,,self-,,consci\sness4 ,:ile1 !re=e1 ass]t+ t a simple pr9ciple does "k itself1 we mu/ exam9e into ! possibility ( ?is4#ih ,o!rwise1 we w\ld h to give up hope ( real self-k4 ,b to resign ?is w\ld imply _m absurdities2 = if x be absurd to d5y t ! s\l possesses self-k1 x w\ld be /ill m absurd to d5y x ( intellig5ce4 ,h[ c\ld intellig5ce h k ( o!r be+s1 if x did n possess ! k & sci5ce ( itself8 ,inde$1 ext]ior ?+s are p]ceiv$ by s5sation1 & ev51 if y insi/1 by discursive reason & op9ion2 b n by intellig5ce4 ,x is inde$ wor? exam9+ :e!r intellig5ce does1 or does n h k ( su* ext]nal ?+s4 ,evid5tly1 intelligible entities are kn[n by intellig5ce4 ,does intellig5ce limit itself to k ( ^! entities1 or does x1 :ile kn[+ intelligible entities1 also "k itself8 ,9 ?is case1 does x "k t x kn[s only intelligible entities1 )\t be+ able to "k :at itself is8 ,:ile kn[+ t x kn[s :at belongs to x1 is x unable to "k :at itself1 ! kn[]1 is8 ,or c x at ! same "t "k :at belongs to x1 & also "k itself8 ,!n h[ does ?is k op]ate1 & h[ f> does x g8 ,?is is :at we mu/ exam9e4 ,,! ,,s5se-,,p[] ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,deals ,,only ,,) ,,ext]ior ,,?+s4 #b4 ,let u beg9 by a consid]ation ( ! s\l4 ,does %e possess self-consci\sness8 ,by :at faculty8 ,& h[ does %e acquire x8 ,x is natural = ! s5se-p[] to deal only ) ext]ior objects2 = ev5 9 ! case 9 :i* x feels occurr5ces 9 ! body1 x is /ill p]ceiv+ ?+s t are ext]nal to x1 s9ce x p]ceives passions exp]i5c$ by ! body ov] :i* x presides4#ii ,,functions ,,( ,,! ,,discursive ,,reason ,,( ,,! ,,s\l4 ,besides ! above1 ! s\l possesses ! discursive reason1 :i* judges ( s5se-repres5tations1 comb9+ & divid+ !m4 ,"u ! =m ( images1 %e also consid]s ! conceptions receiv$ f intellig5ce1 & op]ates on ^! images z on images furni%$ by s5sation4 ,f9ally1 %e /ill is ! p[] ( und]/&+1 s9ce %e di/+ui%es ! new images f ! old1 & h>monizes !m by comp>+ !m2 :5ce1 inde$1 our rem9isc5ces are d]iv$4 ,,c ,,discursive ,,reason ,,turn ,,^u ,,itself8 ,t is ! limit ( ! intellectual p[] ( ! s\l4 ,is x1 besides1 capable ( turn+ ^u itself1 & cogniz+ itself1 or mu/ ?is k be s\ght = only )9 intellig5ce8 ,if we assign ?is k to ! intellectual "p ( ! s\l2 we w be mak+ an intellig5ce out ( x2 & we w !n h to /udy 9 :at x diff]s f ! sup]ior ,intellig5ce4 ,if aga91 we refuse ?is k to ?is "p ( ! s\l1 we w1 by reason1 rise to ,intellig5ce1 & we w h to exam9e ! nature ( self-consci\sness4 ,fur!r1 if we attribute ?is k bo? to ! inf]ior & to ! sup]ior intellig5ces1 we %all h to di/+ui% self-consci\sness accord+ z x belongs to ! "o or to ! o!r2 = if !re 7 no diff]5ce betwe5 ^! two k9ds ( intellig5ce1 discursive reason w\ld be id5tical ) pure ,intellig5ce4 ,does discursive reason1 !re=e1 turn ^u itself8 ,or does x limit itself to ! compreh5sion ( ! types receiv$ f bo? 7s5se & intellig5ce72 &1 9 ! latt] case1 h[ does x a*ieve su* compreh5sion8 ,?is latt] "q is ! "o to be exam9$ "h4 ,,! ,,highe/ ,,"p ,,( ,,discursive ,,reason ,,receives ,,impressions ,,f ,,intellig5ce4 #c4 ,n[ let u suppose t ! s5ses h p]ceiv$ a man1 & h furni%$ an appropriate image !re( to discursive reason4 ,:at w ! latt] say8 ,x may say no?+1 limit+ itself to tak+ notice ( him4 ,h[ev]1 x may also ask itself :o ?is man is2 &1 hav+ already met him1 ) ! aid ( memory1 decide t he is ,socrates4 ,if !n discursive reason develop ! image ( ,socrates1 !n x divides :at imag9ation has furni%$4 ,if discursive reason add t ,socrates is good1 x /ill deals ) ?+s kn[n by ! s5ses2 b t :i* x ass]ts !re(1 namely1 8 goodness1 x has drawn f itself1 because )9 itself x possesses ! rule ( goodness4 ,b h[ does x1 )9 itself1 possess goodness8 ,because x con=ms to ! ,good1 & receives ! notion ( x f ! ,intellig5ce t enlight5s itself2 = 7discursive reason71 ?is "p ( ! s\l1 is pure1 & receives impressions f ,intellig5ce4#aja ,,:y ,,discursive ,,reason ,,%\ld ,,belong ,,to ,,! ,,s\l ,,r ,,?an ,,to ,,intellig5ce4 ,b :y %\ld ?is :ole 7s\l-7 "p t is sup]ior to s5sation be assign$ to ! s\l r ?an to intellig5ce8 ,because ! p[] ( ! s\l consi/s 9 reason+1 & because all ^! op]ations belong to ! discursive reason4 ,b :y c we n simply assign to x1 9 addition1 self-consci\sness1 :i* w\ld imm$iately cle> up ?is inquiry8 ,because ! nature ( discursive reason consi/s 9 consid]+ ext]ior ?+s1 & 9 scrut9iz+ _! div]sity1 :ile to intellig5ce we attribute ! privilege ( contemplat+ itself1 & ( contemplat+ its own cont5ts4 ,b :at h9d]s discursive reason1 by "s o!r faculty ( ! s\l1 f consid]+ :at belongs to x8 ,because1 9 ?is case1 in/ead ( discursive reason & reason+1 we w\ld h pure ,intellig5ce4 ,b :at !n h9d]s ! pres5ce ( pure ,intellig5ce )9 ! s\l8 ,no?+1 inde$4 ,%all we !n h a "r to say t pure ,intellig5ce is a "p ( ! s\l8 ,no inde$2 b /ill we w\ld h ! "r to call x ours4 ,x is diff]5t f1 & high] ?an discursive reason2 & /ill x is ours1 al?\gh we _c c\nt x among ! p>ts ( ! s\l4 ,9 "o respect x is ours1 & 9 ano!r1 is n ours2 = at times we make use ( x1 & at o!r times we make use ( discursive reason2 consequ5tly1 intellig5ce is ours :5 we make use ( x2 & x is n ours :5 we d n make use ( x4 ,b :at is ! mean+ ( mak+ use ( intellig5ce8 ,does x mean becom+ intellig5ce1 & speak+ 9 t "*1 or does x mean speak+ 9 con=mity ) intellig5ce8 ,= we are n intellig5ce2 we speak 9 con=mity ) intellig5ce by ! fir/ "p ( discursive reason1 ! "p t receives impressions f ,intellig5ce4 ,we feel ?r\gh s5sation1 & x is we :o feel4 ,is x also we :o conceive & :o simultane\sly are conceiv$8 ,or is x we :o reason1 & :o conceive ! intellectual notions :i* enlight5 discursive reason8 ,we are inde$ ess5tially con/itut$ by discursive reason4 ,! actualizations ( ,intellig5ce are sup]ior to u1 :ile ^? ( s5sation are inf]ior2 z to u1 we are ! pr9cipal "p ( ! s\l1 ! "p t =ms a middle p[] betwe5 ^! two extremes1 n[ l[]+ ourselves t[>ds s5sation1 n[ ris+ t[>ds ,intellig5ce4#ajb ,we ackn[l$ge s5sibility to be ours because we are cont9ually feel+4 ,x is n z evid5t t intellig5ce is ours1 because we d n make use ( x cont9u\sly1 & because x is sep>at$1 9 ?is s5se1 t x is n intellig5ce t incl9es t[>ds u1 b r we :o raise our glances t[>ds intellig5ce4 ,s5sation is our mess5g]1 ,intellig5ce is our k+4#ii ,,we ,,c ,,?9k ,,9 ,,con=mity ,,) ,,intellig5ce ,,9 ,,two ,,ways4 #d4 ,we ourselves are k+s :5 we ?9k 9 con=mity ) intellig5ce4 ,?is1 h[ev]1 c take place 9 two ways4 ,ei!r we h receiv$ f intellig5ce ! impressions & rules :i* are1 z x 71 engrav$ )9 u1 s t we are1 s to speak1 fill$ ) intellig5ce2 or we c h ! p]ception & intuition ( x1 because x is pres5t ) u4 ,:5 we see intellig5ce1 we recognize t by contemplation ( x we ourselves are grasp+ o!r intelligible entities4 ,?is may occur 9 two ways2 ei!r because1 by ! help ( ?is v p[]1 we grasp ! p[] :i* cognizes intelligible entities2 or because we ourselves become intellig5ce4 ,! man :o ?us kn[s himself is d\ble4 ,ei!r he kn[s discursive reason1 :i* is *>act]i/ic ( ! s\l1 or1 ris+ to a sup]ior condition1 he cognizes himself & is unit$ ) intellig5ce4 ,!n1 by intellig5ce1 t man ?9ks himself2 no m inde$ z be+ man1 b z hav+ become sup]ior to man1 z hav+ be5 transport$ into ! intelligible ,reason1 & draw+ ?i!r ) himself ! be/ "p ( ! s\l1 ! "o :i* alone is capable ( tak+ flight t[>ds ?\ght1 & ( receiv+ ! fund ( k result+ f 8 intuition4 ,b does discursive reason n "k t x is discursive reason1 & t its doma9 is ! compreh5sion ( ext]nal objects8 ,does x n1 :ile do+ s1 "k t x judges8 ,does x n "k t x is judg+ by means ( ! rules d]iv$ f intellig5ce1 :i* itself conta9s8 ,does x n "k t above x is a pr9ciple :i* possesses intelligible entities1 in/ead ( seek+ 7m]ely7 to "k !m8 ,b :at w\ld ?is faculty be if x did n "k :at x is1 & :at its functions are8 ,x kn[s1 !re=e1 t x dep5ds on intellig5ce1 t x is inf]ior to intellig5ce1 & t x is ! image ( intellig5ce1 t x conta9s ! rules ( intellig5ce z x 7 engrav$ )9 itself1 su* z intellig5ce engraves !m1 or r1 has engrav$ !m on x4 ,,man ,,is ,,self-,,consci\s ,,by ,,becom+ ,,intellig5ce4 ,w he :o ?us kn[s himself cont5t himself !re)8 ,surely n4 ,ex]cis+ a fur!r faculty1 we w h ! intuition ( ! intellig5ce t kn[s itself2 or1 seiz+ x1 inasmu* z x is ours & we are its1 we w ?us cognize intellig5ce1 & "k ourselves4 ,?is is necess>y = our k ( :at1 )9 intellig5ce1 self-consci\sness is4 ,! man becomes intellig5ce :51 ab&on+ 8 o!r faculties1 he by intellig5ce sees ,intellig5ce1 & he sees himself 9 ! same mann] t ,intellig5ce sees itself4 ,,intellig5ce ,,is ,,n ,,divisible2 ,,&1 ,,9 ,,its ,,exi/5ce1 ,,is ,,id5tical ,,) ,,?\ght4 #e4 ,does pure ,intellig5ce "k itself by contemplat+ "o ( its p>ts by means ( ano!r "p8 ,!n "o "p w be ! subject1 & ano!r "p w be ! object ( contemplation2 intellig5ce w n "k itself4 ,x may be object$ t if intellig5ce be a :ole compos$ ( absolutely simil> p>ts1 s t ! subject & ! object ( contemplation w n diff] f ea* o!r2 !n1 by ! virtue ( ?is similitude1 on see+ "o ( its p>ts ) :i* x is id5tical1 intellig5ce w see itself2 =1 9 ?is case1 ! subject does n diff] f ! object4 ,to beg9 )1 x is absurd to suppose t intellig5ce is divid$ into sev]al p>ts4 ,h[1 inde$1 w\ld su* a division be c>ri$ out8 ,n by *ance1 surely4 ,:o w c>ry x out8 ,w x be ! subject or object8 ,!n1 h[ w\ld ! subject "k itself if1 9 contemplation1 x locat$ itself 9 ! object1 s9ce contemplation does n belong to t :i* is ! object8 ,w x "k itself z object r ?an z subject8 ,9 t case x w n "k itself completely & 9 its totality 7z subject & object72 = :at x sees is ! object1 & n ! subject ( contemplation2 x sees n itself1 b ano!r4 ,9 ord] to atta9 complete k ( itself x w1 besides1 h to see itself z subject2 n[1 if x see itself z subject1 x w1 at ! same "t1 h to see ! contemplat$ ?+s4 ,b is x ! 7,/oic#ajd7 types 7or impressions7 ( ?+s1 or ! ?+s !mselves1 t are conta9$ 9 ! actualization ( contemplation8 ,if x be ^! impressions1 we d n possess ! ?+s !mselves4 ,if we d possess ^! ?+s1 x is n because we sep>ate ourselves 7into subject & object74 ,be=e divid+ ourselves 9 ?is way1 we already saw & possess$ ^! ?+s4 ,consequ5tly1 contemplation mu/ be id5tical ) t :i* is contemplat$1 & intellig5ce mu/ be id5tical ) ! intelligible4 ,)\t ?is id5tity1 we w nev] possess ! tru?4 ,in/ead ( possess+ realities1 we w nev] possess any m ?an _! impressions1 :i* w diff] f ! realities2 consequ5tly1 ?is w n be ! tru?4 ,tru?1 !re=e1 mu/ n diff] f its object2 x mu/ be :at x ass]ts4 ,,?\ght ,,is ,,id5tical ,,) ,,! ,,intelligible ,,:i* ,,is ,,an ,,actualization4 ,on "o h&1 !re=e1 intellig5ce1 & on ! o!r ! intelligible & exi/5ce =m b "o & ! same ?+1 namely1 ! prim>y exi/5ce & prim>y ,intellig5ce1 :i* possesses realities1 or r1 :i* is id5tical ) !m4 ,b if ! ?\ght-object & ! ?\ght toge!r =m b a s+le entity1 h[ w ! ?9k+ object ?us be able to ?9k itself8 ,evid5tly ?\ght w embrace ! intelligible1 or w be id5tical !re)2 b we /ill d n see h[ intellig5ce is to ?9k itself4 ,"h we are3 ?\ght & ! intelligible fuse into "o because ! intelligible is an actualization & n a simple p[]2 because life is nei!r ali5 nor incid5tal to x2 because ?\ght is n an accid5t = x1 z x w\ld be = a brute body1 z = in/ance1 = a /one2 &1 f9ally1 because ! intelligible is prim>y be+4 ,n[1 if ! intelligible be an actualization1 x is ! prim>y actualization1 ! mo/ p]fect ?\ght1 or1 sub/antial ?\ght4 ,n[1 z ?is ?\ght is supremely true1 z x is prim>y ,?\ght1 z x possesses exi/5ce 9 ! highe/ degree1 x is prim>y ,intellig5ce4 ,x is n1 !re=e1 m]e pot5tial intellig5ce2 !re is no ne$ to di/+ui% )9 x ! pot5tiality f ! actualization ( ?\ght2 o!rwise1 its sub/antiality w\ld be m]ely pot5tial4 ,n[ s9ce intellig5ce is an actualization1 & z its be+ also is an actualization1 x mu/ fuse ) its actualization4 ,b exi/5ce & ! intelligible also fuse ) _! actualization4 ,!re=e#aje intellig5ce1 ! intelligible1 & ?\ght w =m b "o & ! same entity4 ,s9ce ! ?\ght ( ! intelligible is ! intelligible1 & z ! intelligible is intellig5ce1 intellig5ce w ?us ?9k itself4 ,intellig5ce w ?9k1 by ! actualization ( ! ?\ght to :i* x is id5tical1 ! intelligible to :i* x also is id5tical4 ,x w ?9k itself1 s f> z x is ?\ght2 & 9 s f> z x is ! intelligible :i* x ?9ks by ! ?\ght to :i* x is id5tical4#ajf ,,self-,,consci\sness ,,m ,,p]fect ,,9 ,,intellig5ce ,,?an ,,9 ,,! ,,s\l4 #f4 ,reason1 !re=e1 demon/rates t !re is a pr9ciple :i* mu/ ess5tially "k itself4 ,b ?is self-consci\sness is m p]fect 9 intellig5ce ?an 9 ! s\l4 ,! s\l kn[s h]self 9 s f> z %e kn[s t %e dep5ds on ano!r p[]2 :ile intellig5ce1 by m]ely turn+ t[>ds itself1 naturally cognizes its exi/5ce & be+4 ,by contemplat+ realities1 x contemplates itself2 ?is contemplation is an actualization1 & ?is actualization is intellig5ce2 = intellig5ce & ?\ght#ajg =m b a s+le entity4 ,! entire intellig5ce sees itself entire1 in/ead ( see+ "o ( its p>ts by ano!r ( its p>ts4 ,is x 9 ! nature ( intellig5ce1 su* z reason conceives ( x1 to produce )9 u a simple conviction8 ,no4 ,intellig5ce necess>ily implies 7c]titude71 & n m]e p]suasion2 = necessity is *>act]i/ic ( intellig5ce1 :ile p]suasion is *>act]i/ic ( ! s\l4 ,"h bel[1 x is true1 we r seek to be p]suad$1 ?an to see tru? by pure ,intellig5ce4 ,:5 we 7 9 ! sup]ior region1 satisfi$ ) intellig5ce1 we us$ to ?9k1 & to contemplate ! intelligible1 r$uc+ ev]y?+ to unity4 ,x 0 ,intellig5ce :i* ?\ght & spoke ab\t itself2 ! s\l re/$1 & all[$ ,intellig5ce free scope to act4 ,b s9ce we h desc5d$ "h bel[1 we seek to produce p]suasion 9 ! s\l1 because we wi% to contemplate ! model 9 its image4 ,,! ,,s\l ,,mu/ ,,be ,,taught ,,self-,,consci\sness ,,by ,,conv]sion4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 tea* our s\l h[ ,intellig5ce contemplates itself4 ,?is has to be taught to t "p ( our s\l :i*1 because ( its intellectual "*1 we call reason1 or discursive intellig5ce1 to indicate t x is a k9d ( intellig5ce1 t x possesses its p[] by intellig5ce1 & t x d]ives x f intellig5ce4 ,?is "p ( ! s\l mu/1 !re=e1 "k t x kn[s :at x sees1 t x kn[s :at x expresses1 & t1 if x 7 id5tical ) :at x describes1 x w\ld !reby "k itself4 ,b s9ce intelligible entities come to x f ! same pr9ciple f :i* x itself comes1 s9ce x is a reason1 & z x receives f intellig5ce entities t are k9dr$1 by comp>+ !m ) ! traces ( intellig5ce x conta9s1 x mu/ "k itself4 ,?is image x conta9s mu/1 !re=e1 be rais$ to true ,intellig5ce1 :i* is id5tical ) ! true intelligible entities1 t is1 to ! prim>y & really true ,be+s2 = x is impossible t ?is intellig5ce %\ld orig9ate f itself4 ,if !n intellig5ce rema9 9 itself & ) itself1 if x be :at x is 79 its nature7 to be1 t is1 intellig5ce--= intellig5ce c nev] be un9tellig5t--x mu/ conta9 )9 x ! k ( itself1 s9ce x does n issue f itself1 & s9ce its function & its be+ 7or1 true nature7 consi/ 9 be+ no m ?an intellig5ce4#ajf ,x is n an intellig5ce t devotes itself to practical action1 oblig$ to consid] :at is ext]nal to x1 & to issue f itself to become cognizant ( ext]ior ?+s2 = x is n necess>y t an intellig5ce :i* devotes itself to action %\ld "k itself4 ,z x does n give itself to action--=1 be+ pure1 x has no?+ to desire--x op]ates a conv]sion t[>ds itself1 by virtue ( :i* x is n only probable1 b ev5 necess>y = x to "k itself4 ,o!rwise1 :at w\ld its life consi/ (1 inasmu* z x does n devote itself to action1 & z x rema9s )9 itself8 ,,:atev] ,,intellig5ce ,,may ,,be ,,?\ght ,,to ,,d1 ,,x ,,mu/ ,,"k ,,itself4 #g4 ,x may be object$ t ! ,intellig5ce contemplates ! div9ity4 ,if1 h[ev]1 x be grant$1 t ! ,intellig5ce kn[s ! div9ity1 "o is !reby =c$ to admit t x also kn[s itself2 = x w "k :at x d]ives f ! div9ity1 :at x has receiv$ f ,him1 & :at x /ill may hope to receive f ,him4 ,by kn[+ ?is1 x w "k itself1 s9ce x is "o ( ! entities giv5 by ! div9ity2 or r1 s9ce x is all t is giv5 by ! div9ity4 ,if !n1 x "k ! div9ity1 x kn[s also ! p[]s ( ! div9ity1 x kn[s t itself proce$s f ! div9ity1 & t itself d]ives its p[]s f ! div9ity4 ,if ,intellig5ce _c h a cle> intuition ( ! div9ity1 because ! subject & object ( an intuition mu/ be ! same1 ?is w turn out to be a reason :y ,intellig5ce w "k itself1 & w see itself1 s9ce see+ is be+ :at is se54 ,:at else inde$ c\ld we attribute to ,intellig5ce8 ,re/1 = in/ance8 ,= ,intellig5ce1 re/ does n consi/ 9 be+ remov$ f itself1 b r to act )\t be+ di/urb$ by any?+ t is ali54 ,! ?+s t are n tr\bl$ by any?+ ali5 ne$ only to produce _! own actualization1 especially :5 !y are 9 actualization1 & n m]ely pot5tial4 ,t :i* is 9 actualization1 & :i* _c be 9 actualization = any?+ =eign1 mu/ be 9 actualization = itself4 ,:5 ?9k+ itself1 ,intellig5ce rema9s turn$ t[>ds itself1 ref]r+ its actualization to itself4 ,if any?+ proce$ f x1 x is precisely because x rema9s turn$ t[>ds itself t x rema9s 9 itself4 ,x _h1 inde$1 to apply itself to itself1 be=e apply+ itself to any?+ else1 or produc+ some?+ else t resembl$ x2 ?us fire mu/ fir/ be fire 9 itself1 & be fire 9 actualization1 9 ord] lat] to imp>t "s traces ( its nature to o!r ?+s4 ,intellig5ce1 9 itself1 !re=e1 is an actualization4 ,! s\l1 on turn+ h]self t[>ds ,intellig5ce1 rema9s )9 h]self2 on issu+ f ,intellig5ce1 ! s\l turns t[>ds ext]nal ?+s4 ,on turn+ t[>ds ,intellig5ce1 %e becomes simil> to ! p[] f :i* %e proce$s2 on issu+ f ,intellig5ce1 %e becomes diff]5t f h]self4 ,nev]!less1 %e /ill pres]ves "s resemblance to ,intellig5ce1 bo? 9 h] activity & productiv5ess4 ,:5 active1 ! s\l /ill contemplates ,intellig5ce2 :5 productive1 ! s\l produces =ms1 :i* resemble di/ant ?\ghts1 & are traces ( ?\ght & ,intellig5ce1 traces t con=m to _! ar*etype2 & :i* reveal a fai?ful imitation !re(1 or :i*1 at lea/1 /ill pres]ve a weak5$ image !re(1 ev5 if !y d occupy only ! la/ rank ( be+s4 ,,:at ,,intellig5ce ,,looks ,,l ,,9 ,,! ,,intelligible4 #h4 ,:at qualities does ,intellig5ce display 9 ! intelligible _w8 ,:at qualities does x discov] 9 itself by contemplation8 ,to beg9 )1 we mu/ n =m ( ,intellig5ce a conception %[+ a figure1 or colors1 l bodies4 ,intellig5ce exi/$ be=e bodies4 ,! sem9al reasons :i* produce figure & color are n id5tical ) !m2 = sem9al reasons are invisible4 ,s mu* ! m are intelligible entities invisible2 _! nature is id5tical ) t ( ! pr9ciples 9 :i* !y reside1 j z sem9al reasons are id5tical ) ! s\l t conta9s !m4 ,b ! s\l does n see ! entities %e conta9s1 because %e has n begott5 !m2 ev5 %e h]self1 j l ! reasons1 is no m ?an an image 7( ,intellig5ce74 ,! pr9ciple f :i* %e comes possesses an evid5t exi/5ce1 t is g5u9e1 & prim>y2 consequ5tly1 t pr9ciple exi/s ( & 9 itself4 ,b ?is image 7:i* is 9 ! s\l7 is n ev5 p]man5t unless x belong to some?+ else1 & reside !re94 ,inde$1 ! *>act]i/ic ( an image is t x resides 9 some?+ else1 s9ce x belongs to some?+ else1 unless x rema9 atta*$ to its pr9ciple4 ,consequ5tly1 ?is image does n contemplate1 because x does n possess a light t is suffici5t2 & ev5 if x %\ld contemplate1 z x f9ds its p]fection 9 some?+ else1 x w\ld be contemplat+ some?+ else1 in/ead ( contemplat+ itself4 ,! same case does n obta9 9 ,intellig5ce2 !re ! contemplat$ entity & contemplation co-exi/1 & are id5tical4 ,:o is x1 !re=e1 t decl>es ! nature ( ! intelligible8 ,! p[] t contemplates x1 namely1 ,intellig5ce itself4 ,"h bel[ our eyes see ! light because our vision itself is light1 or r because x is unit$ to light2 = x is ! colors t our vision beholds4 ,on ! contr>y1 ,intellig5ce does n see ?r\gh some?+ else1 b ?r\gh itself1 because :at x sees is n outside ( itself4 ,x sees a light ) ano!r light1 & n by ano!r light2 x1 is !re=e1 a light t sees ano!r2 &1 consequ5tly1 x sees itself4 ,?is light1 on %9+ 9 ! s\l1 illum9ates h]2 t is1 intellectualizes h]2 assimilates h] to ! sup]ior light 7namely1 9 ,intellig5ce74 ,if1 by ! ray ) :i* ?is light enlight5s ! s\l1 we judge ( ! nature ( ?is light & conceive ( x z /ill great]1 m beautiful1 & m brilliant1 we w inde$ be approa*+ ,intellig5ce & ! intelligible _w2 =1 by enlight5+ ! s\l1 ,intellig5ce imp>ts to h] a cle>] life4 ,?is life is n g5]ative1 because ,intellig5ce conv]ts ! s\l t[>ds ,intellig5ce2 &1 in/ead ( all[+ ! s\l to divide1 causes ! s\l to love ! spl5dor ) :i* %e is %9+4 ,nei!r is ?is life "o ( ! s5ses1 = ?\gh ! s5ses apply !mselves to :at is ext]ior1 !y d n1 on t acc\nt1 le>n any?+ beyond 7!mselves74 ,he :o sees t sup]ior light ( ! v]ities sees mu* bett] ?+s t are visible1 ?\gh 9 a diff]5t mann]4 ,x rema9s1 !re=e1 t ! ,intellig5ce imp>ts to ! s\l ! intellectual life1 :i* is a trace ( h] own life2 = ,intellig5ce possesses ! realities4 ,x is 9 ! life & ! actualization :i* are *>act]i/ic ( ,intellig5ce t "h consi/s ! prim>y ,light1 :i* f ! beg9n+1#ajh illum9es itself1 :i* reflects on itself1 because x is simultane\sly enlight5] & enlight5$2 x is also ! true intelligible entity1 because x is also at ! same "t ?9k] & ?\ght4 ,x sees itself by itself1 )\t hav+ ne$ ( any?+ else2 x sees itself 9 an absolute mann]1 because1 )9 x1 ! kn[n is id5tical ) ! kn[]4 ,x is n o!rwise 9 u2 x is by ,intellig5ce t we "k intellig5ce4 ,o!rwise1 h[ c\ld we speak ( x8 ,h[ c\ld we say t x 0 capable ( cle>ly grasp+ itself1 & t1 by x1 we und]/& ourselves8 ,h[ c\ld we1 by ^! reason+s1 to ,intellig5ce r$uce our s\l :i* recognizes t x is ! image ( ,intellig5ce1 :i* consid]s its life a fai?ful imitation ( ! life ( ,intellig5ce1 :i* ?9ks t1 :5 x ?9ks1 x assumes an intellectual & div9e =m8 ,%\ld "o wi% to "k :i* is ?is ,intellig5ce t is p]fect1 univ]sal & prim>y1 :i* kn[s itself ess5tially1 ! s\l has to be r$uc$ to ,intellig5ce2 or1 at lea/1 ! s\l has to recognize t ! actualization by :i* ! s\l conceives ! entities ( :i* ! s\l has ! rem9isc5ce is d]iv$ f ,intellig5ce4 ,only by plac+ h]self 9 t condition1 does ! s\l become able to demon/rate t inasmu* z %e is ! image ( ,intellig5ce %e1 ! s\l1 c by h]self1 see x2 t is1 by ^? ( h] p[]s :i* mo/ exactly resemble ,intellig5ce 7namely1 by pure ?\ght72 :i* resembles ,intellig5ce 9 ! degree t a "p ( ! s\l c be assimilat$ to x4 ,,we ,,c ,,rea* ,a ,,conception ,,( ,,intellig5ce ,,by ,,/ripp+ ,,! ,,s\l ,,( ,,e ,,faculty ,,except ,,h] ,,intellectual ,,"p4 #i4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 contemplate ! s\l & h] div9e/ "p 9 ord] to discov] ! nature ( ,intellig5ce4 ,?is is h[ we may accompli% x3 ,f man1 t is f y\rself1 /rip (f ! body2 !n t p[] ( ! s\l t fa%ions ! body2 !n s5sation1 appetite1 & ang]1 & all ! l[] passions t incl9e y t[>ds ! e>?4 ,:at !n rema9s ( ! s\l is :at we call ! image ( intellig5ce1 an image t radiates f ,intellig5ce1 z f ! imm5se globe ( ! sun radiates ! surr\nd+ lum9>y sph]e4 ,( c\rse1 we w\ld n say t all ! light t radiates f ! sun rema9s )9 itself ar\nd ! sun2 only a "p ( ?is light rema9s ar\nd ! sun f :i* x emanates2 ano!r "p1 spread+ by relays1 desc5ds to u on ! e>?4 ,b we consid] light1 ev5 t :i* surr\nds ! sun1 z locat$ 9 some?+ else1 s z n to be =c$ to consid] ! :ole space betwe5 ! sun & u z empty ( all bodies4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! s\l is a light :i* rema9s atta*$ to ,intellig5ce1 & %e is n locat$ 9 any space because ,intellig5ce itself is n spatially locat$4 ,:ile ! light ( ! sun is 9 ! air1 on ! contr>y ! s\l1 9 ! /ate 9 :i* we consid] h] "h1 is s pure t %e c be se5 9 h]self by h]self1 & by any o!r s\l t is 9 ! same condition4 ,! s\l ne$s to reason1 9 ord] to conceive ( ! nature ( ,intellig5ce accord+ to h] own nature2 b ,intellig5ce conceives ( itself )\t reason+ because x is always pres5t to itself4 ,we1 on ! contr>y1 are pres5t bo? to ourselves & to ,intellig5ce :5 we turn t[>ds x1 because our life is divid$ into sev]al lives4 ,on ! contr>y1 ,intellig5ce has no ne$ ( any o!r life1 nor ( any?+ else2 :at ,intellig5ce gives is n giv5 to itself1 b to o!r ?+s2 nei!r does ,intellig5ce h any ne$ ( :at is inf]ior to x2 nor c\ld ,intellig5ce give itself any?+ inf]ior1 s9ce ,intellig5ce possesses all ?+s2 in/ead ( possess+ 9 itself ! prim>y images ( ?+s 7z 9 ! case ( ! s\l71 ,intellig5ce is ^! ?+s !mselves4 ,,elevation ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,may ,,be ,,gradual1 ,,if ,,unable ,,to ,,atta9 ,,imm$iate ,,elevation4 ,if "o %\ld f9d himself unable to rise imm$iately to pure ?\ght1 :i* is ! highe/1 or fir/1 "p ( ! s\l1 he may beg9 by op9ion1 & f x rise to ,intellig5ce4 ,if ev5 op9ion be out ( ! rea* ( 8 ability1 he may beg9 ) s5sation1 :i* already repres5ts g5]al =ms2 = s5sation :i* conta9s ! =ms pot5tially may possess !m ev5 9 actualization4 ,if1 on ! contr>y1 ! be/ he c d is to desc5d1 let him desc5d to ! g5]ative p[]1 & to ! ?+s x produces2 !n1 f ! la/ =ms1 "o may rise aga9 to ! high] =ms1 & s on to ! prim>y =ms4 ,,! ,,transc5d5t ,,fir/ ,,pr9ciple ,,has ,,no ,,ne$ ,,( ,,see+ ,,itself4 #aj4 ,b en\gh ( ?is4 ,if ! 7=ms7 conta9$ by ,intellig5ce are n creat$ =ms--o!rwise ! =ms conta9$ 9 u w\ld no long]1 z !y %\ld1 occupy ! l[e/ rank--if ^! =ms 9 intellig5ce really be creative & prim>y1 !n ei!r ^! creative =ms & ! creative pr9ciple fuse into "o s+le entity1 or intellig5ce ne$s "s o!r pr9ciple4 ,b does ! transc5d5t ,pr9ciple1 t is sup]ior to ,intellig5ce 7! ,"o71 itself also ne$ "s o!r fur!r pr9ciple8 ,no1 because x is only ,intellig5ce t /&s 9 ne$ ( su* an "o4 ,does ! ,pr9ciple sup]ior to ,intellig5ce 7! transc5d5t ,"o7 n see ,himself8 ,no4 ,he does n ne$ to see ,himself4 ,?is we %all /udy else:]e4 ,,! ,,contemplation ,,( ,,intellig5ce ,,dem&s ,a ,,high] ,,transc5d+ ,,unity4 ,let u n[ return to our mo/ important problem4 ,intellig5ce ne$s to contemplate itself1 or r1 x cont9ually possesses ?is contemplation4 ,x fir/ sees t x is manifold1 & !n t x implies a diff]5ce1 & fur!r1 t x ne$s to contemplate1 to contemplate ! intelligible1 & t its v ess5ce is to contemplate4 ,inde$1 e contemplation implies an object2 o!rwise1 x is empty4 ,to make contemplation possible !re mu/ be m ?an an unity2 contemplation mu/ be appli$ to an object1 & ?is object mu/ be manifold2 = :at is simple has no object on :i* x c\ld apply its action1 & sil5tly rema9s )drawn 9 its solitude4 ,action implies "s sort ( diff]5ce4 ,o!rwise1 to :at w\ld action apply itself8 ,:at w\ld be its object8 ,! active pr9ciple1 mu/1 !re=e1 direct its action on some?+ else ?an itself1 or mu/ itself be manifold to direct its action on itself4 ,if1 inde$1 x direct its action on no?+1 x w be at re/2 & if at re/1 x w n be ?9k+4 ,! ?9k+ pr9ciple1 !re=e1 :5 ?9k+1 implies duality4 ,:e!r ! two t]ms be "o ext]ior to ! o!r1 or unit$1 ?\ght always implies bo? id5tity & diff]5ce4 ,9 g5]al1 intelligible entities mu/ simultane\sly be id5tical ) ,intellig5ce1 & diff]5t f ,intellig5ce4 ,besides1 ea* ( !m mu/ also conta9 )9 itself id5tity & diff]5ce4 ,o!rwise1 if ! intelligible does n conta9 any div]sity1 :at w\ld be ! object ( ?\ght8 ,if y insi/ t ea* intelligible entity resembles a 7sem9al7 reason1 x mu/ be manifold4 ,e intelligible entity1 !re=e1 kn[s itself to be a comp\nd1 & _m-color$ eye4 ,if intellig5ce appli$ itself to some?+ s+le & absolutely simple1 x c\ld n ?9k4 ,:at w\ld x say8 ,:at w\ld x und]/&8 ,if ! indivisible ass]t$ itself x ought fir/ to ass]t :at x is n2 & s1 9 ord] to be s+le x w\ld h to be manifold4 ,if x said1 ,i am ?is1 & if x did n ass]t t ?is 0 diff]5t f itself1 x w\ld be utt]+ untru?4 ,if x ass]t$ x z an accid5t ( itself1 x w\ld ass]t ( itself a multitude4 ,if x says1 ,i am2 ,i am2 myself2 myself2 !n nei!r ^! two ?+s w be simple1 & ea* ( !m w be able to say1 me2 or !re w be manifoldness1 &1 consequ5tly1 a diff]5ce2 &1 consequ5tly1 numb] & div]sity4 ,! ?9k+ subject mu/1 !re=e1 conta9 a diff]5ce1 j z ! object ?\ght mu/ also reveal a div]sity1 because x is divid$ by ?\ght4 ,o!rwise1 !re w be no o!r ?\ght ( ! intelligible1 b a k9d ( t\*1 ( unspeakable & inconceivable contact1 prior to intellig5ce1 s9ce intellig5ce is n yet suppos$ to exi/1 & z ! possessor ( ?is contact does n ?9k4 ,! ?9k+ subject1 !re=e1 mu/ n rema9 simple1 especially1 :5 x ?9ks itself2 x mu/ split itself1 ev5 7 ! compreh5sion ( itself sil5t4 ,la/1 t :i* is simple 7! ,"o7 has no ne$ ( occupy+ itself ) itself4 ,:at w\ld x le>n by ?9k+8 ,is x n :at x is be=e ?9k+ itself8 ,besides1 k implies t "s "o desires1 t "s "o seeks1 & t "s "o f9ds4 ,t :i* does n )9 itself conta9 any diff]5ce1 :5 turn$ t[>ds itself1 re/s )\t seek+ any?+ )9 itself2 b t :i* develops1 is manifold4 ,,h[ ,,intellig5ce ,,became ,,manifold4 #aa4 ,intellig5ce1 !re=e1 becomes manifold :5 x wi%es to ?9k ! ,pr9ciple sup]ior to x4 ,by wi%+ to grasp ,him 9 8 simplicity1 x ab&ons ?is simplicity1 because x cont9ues to receive )9 itself ?is diff]5tiat$ & multipli$ nature4 ,x 0 n yet ,intellig5ce :5 x issu$ f ,unity2 x f\nd itself 9 ! /ate ( sight :5 n yet actualiz$4 ,:5 emanat+ f ,unity1 x conta9$ already :at made x manifold4 ,x vaguely aspir$ to an object o!r ?an itself1 :ile simultane\sly conta9+ a repres5tation ( ?is object4 ,x ?us conta9$ some?+ t x made manifold2 = x conta9$ a sort ( impress produc$ by ! contemplation 7( ! ,"o72 o!rwise x w\ld n receive ! ,"o )9 itself4 ,?us ,intellig5ce1 on be+ born ( ,unity1 became manifold1 & z x possess$ k1 x contemplat$ itself4 ,x !n became actualiz$ sight4 ,intellig5ce is really intellig5ce only :5 x possesses its object1 & :5 x possesses x z intellig5ce4 ,=m]ly1 x 0 only an aspiration1 only an indi/9ct vision4 ,on apply+ itself to ! ,"o1 & grasp+ ! ,"o1 x becomes intellig5ce4 ,n[ its receptivity to ,unity is cont9u\s1 & x is cont9u\sly intellig5ce1 be+1 ?\ght1 f ! v mom5t x beg9s to ?9k4 ,be=e t1 x is n yet ?\ght1 s9ce x does n possess ! intelligible1 & is n yet ,intellig5ce1 s9ce x does n ?9k4 ,,! ,,"o ,,is ,,! ,,pr9ciple ,,( ,,all ,,)\t ,,be+ ,,limit$ ,,!reby4 ,t :i* is above ^! ?+s is _! pr9ciple1 )\t be+ inh]5t 9 !m4 ,! pr9ciple f :i* ^! ?+s proce$ _c be inh]5t 9 !m2 t is true only ( ! elem5ts t con/itute !m4 ,! pr9ciple f :i* all ?+s proce$ 7! ,"o7 is n any ( !m2 x diff]s f all ( !m4 ,! ,"o1 !re=e1 is n any ( !m2 x diff]s f all ( !m4 ,! ,"o1 !re=e1 is n any ( ! ?+s ( ! univ]se3 ,he prec$es all ^! ?+s1 & consequ5tly1 ,he prec$es ,intellig5ce1 s9ce ! latt] embraces all ?+s 9 its univ]sality4 ,on ! o!r h&1 z ! ?+s t are po/]ior to ,unity are univ]sal1 & z ,unity ?us is ant]ior to univ]sal ?+s1 x _c be any "o ( !m4 ,!re=e1 x %\ld n be call$ ei!r intellig5ce or good1 if by good y mean any object compris$ )9 ! univ]se2 ?is "n suits x only1 if x indicate t x is ant]ior to ev]y?+4 ,if ,intellig5ce be intellig5ce only because x is manifold2 if ?\ght1 ?\gh f\nd )9 ,intellig5ce1 be simil>ly manifold1 !n ! ,fir/1 ! ,pr9ciple t is absolutely simple1 w be above ,intellig5ce2 = if ,he ?9k1 ,he w\ld be ,intellig5ce2 & if ,he be ,intellig5ce1 ,he w\ld be manifold4 ,,no ,,manifoldness ,,( ,,any ,,k9d ,,c ,,exi/ ,,9 ,,! ,,fir/4 #ab4 ,x may be object$1 t no?+ w\ld h9d] ! exi/5ce ( manifoldness 9 ! actualization ( ! ,fir/1 s long z ! be+1 or nature1 rema9 unit>y4 ,t pr9ciple w\ld n be r5d]$ composite by any numb] ( actualizations4 ,?is is n ! case = two reasons4 ,ei!r ^! actualizations are di/9ct f its nature 7be+71 & ! ,fir/ w\ld pass f pot5tiality to actuality2 9 :i* case1 )\t d\bt1 ! ,fir/ is n manifold1 b ,8 nature w\ld n become p]fect )\t actualization4 ,or ! nature 7be+7 is1 )9 ,him id5tical to ,8 actualization2 9 :i* case1 z ! actualization is manifold1 ! nature w\ld be su* also4 ,n[ we d inde$ grant t ,intellig5ce is manifold1 s9ce x ?9ks itself2 b we c\ld n grant t ! ,pr9ciple ( all ?+s %\ld also be manifold4 ,unity mu/ exi/ be=e ! manifold1 ! reason ( ^: exi/5ce is f\nd 9 unity2 = unity prec$es all numb]4 ,x may be object$ t ?is is true en\gh = numb]s :i* foll[ unity1 because !y are composite2 b :at is ! ne$ ( a unit>y pr9ciple f :i* manifoldness %\ld proce$ :5 ref]r+ 7n to num]als1 b7 to be+s8 ,?is ne$ is t1 )\t ! ,"o1 all ?+s w\ld be 9 a disp]s$ condition1 & _! comb9ations w\ld be no m ?an a *aos4 ,,p]man5t ,,actualizations ,,are ,,hypo/ases4 ,ano!r objection is1 t f an intellig5ce t is simple1 manifold actualizations c surely proce$4 ,?is !n admits ! exi/5ce ( some?+ simple be=e ! actualizations4 ,lat]1 z ^! actualizations become p]man5t1 !y =m hypo/atic =ms ( exi/5ce4 ,be+ su*1 !y w h to diff] f ! ,pr9ciple f :i* !y proce$1 s9ce ! ,pr9ciple rema9s simple1 & t :i* is born ( x mu/ 9 itself be manifold1 & be dep5d5t !reon4 ,ev5 if ^! actualizations exi/ only because ! ,pr9ciple act$ a s+le "t1 ?is already con/itutes manifoldness4 ,?\gh ^! actualizations be ! fir/ ones1 if !y con/itute second-rank 7nature71 ! fir/ rank w belong to ! ,pr9ciple t prec$es ^! actualizations2 ?is ,pr9ciple abides 9 itself1 :ile ^! actualizations con/itute t :i* is ( second rank1 & is compos$ ( actualizations4 ,! ,fir/ diff]s f ! actualizations ,he begets1 because ,he begets !m )\t activity2 o!rwise1 ,intellig5ce w\ld n be ! fir/ actualization4 ,nor %\ld we ?9k t ! ,"o fir/ desir$ to beget ,intellig5ce1 & lat] begat x1 s t ?is desire 0 an int]m$i>y betwe5 ! g5]at+ pr9ciple & ! g5]at$ entity4 ,! ,"o c\ld n h desir$ any?+2 = if ,he _h desir$ any?+1 ,he w\ld h be5 imp]fect1 s9ce ,he w\ld n yet h possess$ :at ,he desir$4 ,nor c\ld we suppose t ! ,"o lack$ any?+2 = !re 0 no?+ t[>ds :i* ,he c\ld h mov$4 ,!re=e1 ! hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce :i* is b5ea? ,him receiv$ exi/5ce f ,him1 )\t ceas+ to p]si/ 9 its own condition4 ,!re=e1 if !re is to be a hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce b5ea? ,him ,he mu/ h rema9$ )9 ,himself 9 p]fect tranquility2 o!rwise1 ,he w\ld h initiat$ movem5t2 & we w\ld h to conceive ( a movem5t be=e ! fir/ movem5t1 a ?\ght be=e ! fir/ ?\ght1 & its fir/ actualization w\ld be imp]fect1 consi/+ 9 no m ?an a m]e t5d5cy4 ,b t[>ds :at c ! fir/ actualization ( ! ,"o t5d1 & atta91 if1 accord+ to ! dictates ( reason1 we conceive ( t actualization orig9at+ f ,him z light emanates f ! sun8 ,?is actualization1 !re=e1 w h to be consid]$ z a light t embraces ! :ole intelligible _w2 at ! summit ( :i* we %all h to posit1 & ov] ^: ?rone we %all h to conceive ! rule ( ! immovable ,"o1 )\t sep>at+ ,him f ! ,light t radiates f ,him4 ,o!rwise1 above ?is ,light we w\ld h to posit ano!r "o1 :i*1 :ile rema9+ immovable1 %\ld enlight5 ! intelligible4 ,inde$ ! actualization t emanates f ! ,"o1 )\t be+ sep>at$ f ,him1 nev]!less1 diff]s f ,him4 ,nei!r is its nature non-ess5tial1 or bl9d2 x1 !re=e1 contemplates itself1 & kn[s itself2 x is1 consequ5tly1 ! fir/ kn[+ pr9ciple4 ,z ! ,"o is above ,intellig5ce1 x is also above consci\sness2 z x ne$s no?+1 nei!r has x any ne$ ( kn[+ any?+4 ,cognition 7or1 consci\sness71 !re=e1 belongs only to ! second-rank nature4 ,consci\sness is only an individual unity1 :ile ! ,"o is absolute unity2 inde$ individual unity is n absolute ,unity1 because ! absolute is 7or1 9 & = itself71 prec$es ! 7someh[ det]m9$1 or7 individual4 ,,! ,,supreme ,,is ,,absolutely ,,ineffable4 #ac4 ,?is ,pr9ciple1 !re=e1 is really indescribable4 ,we are individualiz+ x 9 any /atem5t ab\t x4 ,t :i* is above ev]y?+1 ev5 above ! v5]able ,intellig5ce1 really has no "n1 & all t we c /ate ab\t ,him is1 t ,he is n any?+4 ,nor c ,he be giv5 any "n1 s9ce we _c ass]t any?+ ab\t ,him4 ,we ref] to ,him only z be/ we c4 ,9 our unc]ta9ty we say1 ,:at does ,he n feel8 is ,he n self-consci\s8 does ,he n "k ,himself8 ,!n we mu/ reflect t by speak+ ?us we are ?9k+ ( ?+s1 t are oppos$ to ,him ( :om we are n[ ?9k+4 ,:5 we suppose t ,he c be kn[n1 or t ,he possesses self-consci\sness1 we are already mak+ ,him manifold4 ,7 we to attribute to ,him ?\ght1 x w\ld appe> t ,he ne$$ ?is ?\ght4 ,if we imag9e ?\ght z be+ )9 ,him1 ?\ght seems to be sup]flu\s4 ,= ( :at does ?\ght consi/8 ,( ! consci\sness ( ! totality =m$ by ! two t]ms t contribute to ! act ( ?\ght1 & :i* fuse !re94 ,t is ?9k+ oneself1 & ?9k+ oneself is real ?9k+2 = ea* ( ! two elem5ts ( ?\ght is itself an unity to :i* no?+ is lack+4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! ?\ght ( objects ext]ior 7to ,intellig5ce7 is n p]fect1 & is n true ?\ght4 ,t :i* is supremely simple & supremely absolute /&s 9 ne$ ( no?+4 ,! absolute t occupies ! second rank ne$s itself1 &1 consequ5tly1 ne$s to ?9k itself4 ,inde$1 s9ce ,intellig5ce ne$s some?+ relatively to itself1 x succe$s 9 satisfy+ ?is ne$1 & consequ5tly1 9 be+ absolute1 only by possess+ itself entirely4 ,x suffices itself only by unit+ all ! elem5ts con/itut+ its nature 7be+71 only by dwell+ )9 itself1 only by rema9+ turn$ t[>ds itself :ile ?9k+2 = consci\sness is ! s5sation ( manifoldness1 z is indicat$ by ! etymology ( ! ^w con-sci\s-ness1 or1 consci5ce4 ,if supreme ,?\ght occur by ! conv]sion ( ,intellig5ce t[>ds itself1 x evid5tly is manifold4 ,ev5 if x said no m ?an ,i am exi/5ce1 ,intellig5ce w\ld say x z if mak+ a discov]y1 & ,intellig5ce w\ld be "r1 because exi/5ce is manifold4 ,ev5 ?\gh x %\ld apply itself to some?+ simple1 & %\ld say1 ,i am exi/5ce1 ?is w\ld n imply successful grasp ( itself or exi/5ce4 ,inde$1 :5 ,intellig5ce speaks ( exi/5ce 9 con=mity ) reality1 intellig5ce does n speak ( x z ( a /one1 b1 m]ely1 9 a s+le ^w expresses some?+ manifold4 ,! exi/5ce t really & ess5tially des]ves ! "n ( exi/5ce1 in/ead ( hav+ ( x only a trace :i* w\ld n be exi/5ce1 & :i* w\ld be only an image ( x1 su* exi/5ce is a multiple entity4 ,w n ea* "o ( ! elem5ts ( ?is multiple entity be ?\ght8 ,no d\bt y w n be able to ?9k x if y take x alone & sep>at$ f ! o!rs2 b exi/5ce itself is 9 itself some?+ manifold4 ,:atev] object y "n1 x possesses exi/5ce4 ,consequ5tly1 ,he :o is supremely simple _c ?9k ,himself2 if ,he did1 ,he w\ld be some:]e1 7:i* is n ! case74 ,!re=e ,he does n ?9k1 & ,he _c be grasp$ by ?\ght4 ,,we ,,come ,,suffici5tly ,,ne> ,,to ,,him ,,to ,,talk ,,ab\t ,,him4 #ad4 ,h[ !n d we speak ( ,him8 ,because we c ass]t some?+ ab\t ,him1 ?\gh we _c express ,him by spee*4 ,we c\ld n "k ,him1 nor grasp ,him by ?\ght4 ,h[ !n d we speak ( ,him1 if we _c grasp ,him8 ,because ?\gh ,he does escape our k1 ,he does n escape u completely4 ,we grasp ,him en\gh to ass]t some?+ ab\t ,him )\t express+ ,him himself1 to say :at ,he is n1 )\t say+ :at ,he is2 t is :y 9 speak+ ( ,him we use t]ms t are suitable to designate only l[] ?+s4 ,besides we c embrace ,him )\t be+ capable ( express+ ,him1 l m5 :o1 transport$ by a div9e en?usiasm1 feel t !y conta9 some?+ sup]ior )\t be+ able to acc\nt = x4 ,!y speak ( :at agitates !m1 & !y ?us h "s feel+ ( ,him :o moves !m1 ?\gh !y diff] !refrom4 ,su* is our relation ) ,him2 :5 we rise to ,him by us+ our pure intellig5ce1 we feel t ,he is ! f\ndation ( our intellig5ce1 ! pr9ciple t furni%es be+ & o!r ?+s ( ! k9d2 we feel t ,he is bett]1 great]1 & m elevat$ ?an we1 because ,he is sup]ior to reason1 to intellig5ce1 & to ! s5ses1 because ,he gives ^! ?+s )\t be+ :at !y are4 ,,radiation ,,( ,,multiple ,,unity4 #ae4 ,h[ does ,he give !m8 ,is x because ,he possesses !m1 or because ,he does n possess !m8 ,if x be because ,he does n possess !m1 h[ does ,he give :at ,he does n possess8 ,if x be because ,he does possess !m1 ,he is no long] simple4 ,if ,he give :at ,he does n possess1 h[ is multiplicity born ( ,him8 ,x w\ld seem z if only "o s+le ?+ c\ld proce$ f ,him1 unity2 & ev5 s "o might wond] h[ any?+ :atev] c\ld be born ( t :i* is absolutely "o4 ,we answ]1 9 ! same way z f a light radiates a lum9\s sph]e 7or1 fulguration#aji74 ,b h[ c ! manifold be born f ! ,"o8 ,because ! ?+ t proce$s f ,him mu/ n be equal to ,him1 & s mu* ! less1 sup]ior2 = :at is sup]ior to unity1 or bett] ?an ,him8 ,x mu/1 !re=e1 be inf]ior to ,him1 &1 consequ5tly1 be less p]fect4 ,n[ x _c be less p]fect1 except on condition ( be+ less unit>y1 t is1 m manifold4 ,b z x mu/ aspire to unity1 x w be ! manifold "o4 ,x is by t :i* is s+le t t :i* is n s+le is pres]v$1 & is :at x is2 = t :i* is n "o1 ?\gh composite1 _c receive ! "n ( exi/5ce4 ,if x be possible to say :at ea* ?+ is1 x is only because x is "o & id5tical4 ,:at is n manifold is n "o by p>ticipation1 b is absolute unity2 x does n d]ive its unity f any o!r pr9ciple2 on ! contr>y x is ! pr9ciple to :i* o!r ?+s owe t !y are m or less s+le1 accord+ z !y are m or less close to x4 ,s9ce ! *>act]i/ic ( t :i* is ne>e/ to unity is id5tity1 & is po/]ior to unity1 evid5tly ! manifoldness conta9$ !re91 mu/ be ! totality ( ?+s t are s+le4 ,= s9ce manifoldness is !re9 unit$ ) manifoldness1 x does n conta9 p>ts sep>at$ f ea* o!r1 & all subsi/ toge!r4 ,ea* ( ! ?+s1 t proce$ !refrom1 are manifold unity1 because !y _c be univ]sal unity4 ,univ]sal unity is *>act]i/ic only ( _! pr9ciple 7! intelligible ,be+71 because itself proce$s f a great ,pr9ciple :i* is "o1 ess5tially1 & g5u9ely4 ,t :i*1 by its exub]ant fruitfulness1 begets1 is all2 on ! o!r h&1 z ?is totality p>ticipates 9 unity1 x is s+le2 &1 consequ5tly1 x is s+le totality 7univ]sal unity74 ,,! ,,supreme ,,produces ,,manifoldness ,,because ,,( ,,its ,,categories4 ,we h se5 t exi/5ce is all ^! ?+s2 n[1 :at are !y8 ,all ^? ( :i* ! ,"o is ! pr9ciple4 ,b h[ c ! ,"o be ! pr9ciple ( all ?+s8 ,because ! ,"o pres]ves _! exi/5ce :ile effect+ ! individuality ( ea* ( !m4 ,is x also because ,he gives !m exi/5ce8 ,& if s1 does ,he d s by possess+ !m8 ,9 ?is case1 ! ,"o w\ld be manifold4 ,no1 x is by conta9+ !m )\t any di/9ction yet hav+ aris5 among !m4 ,on ! contr>y1 9 ! second pr9ciple !y are di/+ui%$ by reason2 t is1 !y are logically di/+ui%$1 because ?is second pr9ciple is an actualization1 :ile ! fir/ ,pr9ciple is ! p[]-pot5tiality#ajg ( all ?+s2 n 9 ! s5se 9 :i* we say t matt] is pot5tial 9 t x receives1 or suff]s1 b 9 ! opposite s5se t ! ,"o produces4 ,h[ !n c ! ,"o produce :at x does n possess1 s9ce unity produces t nei!r by *ance nor by reflection8 ,we h already said t :at proce$s f unity mu/ diff] f x2 &1 consequ5tly1 _c be absolutely "o2 t x mu/ be duality1 &1 consequ5tly1 multitude1 s9ce x w conta9 7! categories1 su* z7 id5tity1 & diff]5ce1 quality1 & s =?4#aaj ,we h demon/rat$ t t :i* is born ( ! ,"o is n absolutely "o4 ,x n[ rema9s = u to inquire :e!r x w be manifold1 su* z x is se5 to be 9 :at proce$s f ! ,"o4 ,we %all also h to consid] :y x necess>ily proce$s f ! ,"o4 ,,! ,,good ,,mu/ ,,be ,,sup]ior ,,to ,,intellig5ce ,,& ,,life4 #af4 ,we h %[n else:]e t some?+ mu/ foll[ ! ,"o1 & t ! ,"o is a p[]1 & is inexhau/ible2 & ?is is s1 because ev5 ! la/-rank entities possess ! p[] ( begett+4 ,= ! pres5t we may notice t ! g5]ation ( ?+s reveals a desc5d+ procession1 9 :i*1 ! fur!r we g1 ! m does manifoldness increase2 & t ! pr9ciple is always simpl] ?an ! ?+s x produces4#aaa ,!re=e1 t :i* has produc$ ! s5se _w is n ! s5se-_w itself1 b ,intellig5ce & ! intelligible _w2 & t :i* has begott5 ,intellig5ce & ! intelligible _w is nei!r ,intellig5ce nor ! intelligible _w1 b some?+ simpl] ?an !m4 ,manifoldness is n born ( manifoldness1 b ( some?+ t is n manifold4 ,if ,t :i* 0 sup]ior to ,intellig5ce 7 manifold1 x w\ld no long] be ! 7supreme7 ,pr9ciple1 & we w\ld h to asc5d fur!r4 ,ev]y?+ mu/1 !re=e1 be r$uc$ to t :i* is ess5tially "o1 :i* is outside ( all manifoldness2 & ^: simplicity is ! greate/ possible4 ,b h[ c manifold & univ]sal ,reason be born ( ! ,"o1 :5 v evid5tly ! ,"o is n a reason8 ,z x is n a reason1 h[ c x beget ,reason8 ,h[ c ! ,good beget a hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce1 :i* w\ld be good 9 =m8 ,:at does ?is hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce possess8 ,is x id5tity8 ,b :at is ! relation betwe5 id5tity & goodness8 ,because z soon z we possess ! ,good1 we seek id5tity & p]man5ce2 & because ! ,good is ! pr9ciple f :i* we mu/ n sep>ate2 = if x 7 n ! ,good1 x w\ld be bett] to give x up4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 wi% to rema9 unit$ to ! ,good4 ,s9ce t is ! mo/ desirable = ,intellig5ce1 x ne$ seek no?+ beyond1 & its p]man5ce indicates its satisfaction ) ! entities x possesses4 ,enjoy+1 z x does1 _! pres5ce 9 a mann] su* t x fuses ) !m1 x mu/ !n consid] life z ! mo/ preci\s entity ( all4 ,z ,intellig5ce possesses life 9 its univ]sality & fulness1 ?is life is ! fulness & univ]sality ( ! ,s\l & ,intellig5ce4 ,intellig5ce1 !re=e1 is self-suffici5t1 & desires no?+2 x conta9s :at x w\ld h desir$ if x _h n already possess$ su* desirable object4 ,x possesses ! good t consi/s 9 life & intellig5ce1 z we h said1 or 9 "s "o ( ! connect$ entities4 ,if ,life & ,intellig5ce 7 ! absolute ,good1 !re w\ld be no?+ above !m4 ,b if ! absolute ,good be above !m1 ! good ( ,intellig5ce is ?is ,life1 :i* relates to ! absolute ,good1 :i* connects ) x1 :i* receives exi/5ce f x1 & rises t[>ds x1 because x is its pr9ciple4 ,! ,good1 !re=e1 mu/ be sup]ior to ,life & ,intellig5ce4 ,on ?is condition only does ! life ( ,intellig5ce1 ! image ( ,him f :om all life proce$s1 turn t[>ds ,him2 on ?is condition only does ,intellig5ce1 ! imitation ( ! cont5ts ( ! ,"o1 :atev] be ,8 nature1 turn t[>ds ,him4 ,,! ,,supreme ,,z ,,sup]ess5tial ,,& ,,sup]exi/5t4 #ag4 ,:at bett] ?+ is !re !n ?an ?is supremely wise ,life1 exempt f all fault or error8 ,:at is !re bett] ?an ! ,intellig5ce t embraces ev]y?+8 ,9 "o ^w1 :at is !re bett] ?an univ]sal ,life & univ]sal ,intellig5ce8 ,if we answ] t :at is bett] ?an ^! ?+s is ! ,pr9ciple t begat !m1 if we cont5t ourselves ) expla9+ h[ x begat !m1 & to %[ t "o _c discov] any?+ bett]1 we %all1 in/ead ( progress+ 9 ?is discussion1 ev] rema9 at ! same po9t4 ,nev]!less1 we ne$ to rise high]4 ,we are p>ticul>ly oblig$ to d ?is1 :5 we consid] t ! pr9ciple t we seek mu/ be consid]$ z ! ,self-suffici5t supremely indep5d5t ( all ?+s2 = no entity is able to be self-suffici5t1 & all h p>ticipat$ 9 ! ,"o2 & s9ce !y h done s1 none ( !m c be ! ,"o4 ,:i* !n is ?is pr9ciple 9 :i* all p>ticipate1 :i* makes ,intellig5ce exi/1 & is all ?+s8 ,s9ce x makes ,intellig5ce exi/1 & s9ce x is all ?+s1 s9ce x makes its conta9$ manifoldness self-suffici5t by ! pres5ce ( unity1 & s9ce x is ?us ! creative pr9ciple ( be+ & self-suffici5cy1 x mu/1 in/ead ( be+ be+1 be sup]-be+ & sup]-exi/5ce4 ,,ec/asy ,,is ,,intellectual ,,contact ,,) ,,sudd5 ,,light4 ,h we said en\gh1 & c we /op "h8 ,or does our s\l /ill feel ! pa9s ( p>turition8 ,let h]1 !re=e1 produce 7activity71 ru%+ t[>ds ! ,"o1 driv5 by ! pa9s t agitate h]4 ,no1 let u r seek to calm h] by "s magic *>m1 if any rem$y !re= exi/4 ,b to *>m ! s\l1 x may p]haps be suffici5t to repeat :at we h already said4 ,to :at o!r *>m1 inde$1 w\ld x suffice to h rec\rse8 ,ris+ above all ! tru?s 9 :i* we p>ticipate1 ?is en*antm5t evanesces ! mom5t we speak1 or ev5 ?9k4 ,=1 9 ord] to express some?+1 discursive reason is oblig$ to g f "o ?+ to ano!r1 & successively to run ?r\gh e elem5t ( its object4 ,n[ :at c be successively scrut9iz$ 9 t :i* is absolutely simple8 ,x is1 !re=e1 suffici5t to rea* ,him by a sort ( intellectual contact4 ,n[ at ! mom5t ( t\*+ ! ,"o1 we %\ld nei!r be able to say any?+ ab\t ,him1 nor h ! leisure to speak ( ,him2 only lat] is x possible to argue ab\t ,him4 ,we %\ld believe t we h se5 ,him :5 a sudd5 light has enlight5$ ! s\l2 = ?is light comes f ,him1 & is ,himself4 ,we %\ld believe t ,he is pres5t :51 z ano!r 7l[]7 div9ity1 ,he illum9es ! h\se ( him :o calls on ?is div9ity1#aab = x rema9s obscure )\t ! illum9ation ( ! div9ity4 ,! s\l1 !re=e1 is )\t light :5 %e is depriv$ ( ! pres5ce ( ?is div9ity1 :5 illum9$ by ?is div9ity1 %e has :at %e s\ght4 ,! true purpose ( ! s\l is to be 9 contact ) ?is light1 to see ?is light 9 ! radiance ( ?is light itself1 )\t ! assi/ance ( any =eign light1 to see ?is pr9ciple by ! help ( :i* %e sees4 ,inde$1 x is ! pr9ciple by :i* %e is enlight5$ t %e mu/ contemplate z "o gazes at ! sun only ?r\gh its own light4 ,b h[ %all we succe$ 9 ?is8 ,by cutt+ (f ev]y?+ else4#aac ,,?ird ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,five4#aad ,( ,love1 or ,eros4 ,,love ,,z ,,god1 ,,gu>dian ,,& ,,passion4 #a4 ,is ,love a div9ity1 a gu>dian1 or a passion ( ! human s\l8 ,or is x all ?ree "u diff]5t po9ts ( view8 ,9 ?is case1 :at is x "u ea* ( ^! po9ts ( view8 ,^! are ! que/ions we are to consid]1 consult+ ! op9ions ( m51 b *iefly ^? ( ! philosoph]s4 ,! div9e ,plato1 :o has writt5 mu* ab\t love1 "h des]ves p>ticul> att5tion4 ,he says t x is n only a passion capable ( be+ born 9 s\ls1 b he calls x also a gu>dian1 & he gives _m details ab\t its bir? & p>5ts4#aae ,,passional ,,love ,,is ,,tw(old4 ,to beg9 ) passion1 x is a matt] ( common k t ! passion designat$ z love is born 9 ! s\ls :i* desire to unite !mselves to a beautiful object4 ,b its object may be ei!r a %ameful practice1 or "o 7wor?y to be pursu$ by7 temp]ate m51 :o are famili> ) beauty4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 inve/igate 9 a philosophical mann] :at is ! orig9 ( bo? k9ds ( love4 ,,love ,,is ,,recognition ,,( ,,hidd5 ,,aff9ity4 ,! real cause ( love is f\rfold3 ! desire ( beauty2 our s\l's innate notion ( beauty2 our s\l's aff9ity ) beauty1 & our s\l's in/9ctive s5tim5t ( ?is aff9ity4#aaf 7,!re=e z beauty lies at ! root ( love1 s7 ugl9ess is contr>y to nature & div9ity4 ,9 fact1 :5 ,nature wants to create1 %e contemplates :at is beautiful1 det]m9ate1 & compreh5d$ )9 ! 7,py?agorean7 sph]e ( ! ,good4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! 7,py?agorean7 indet]m9ate#aae is ugly1 & belongs to ! o!r sy/em4#aag ,besides1 ,nature h]self owes h] orig9 to ! ,good1 &1 !re=e1 also to ! ,beautiful4 ,n[1 z soon z "o is attract$ by an object1 because "o is unit$ to x by a secret aff9ity1 he exp]i5ces = ! images ( ?is object a s5tim5t ( sympa?y4 ,we c\ld n expla9 its orig91 or assign its cause on any o!r hypo!sis1 ev5 7 we to limit ourselves to ! consid]ation ( physical love4 ,ev5 ?is k9d ( love is a desire to procreate beauty1#aah = x w\ld be absurd to insi/ t t ,nature1 :i* aspires to create beautiful ?+s1 %\ld aspire to procreate t :i* is ugly4 ,,e>?ly ,,beauty ,,is ,,an ,,image ,,( ,,intelligible ,,beauty4 ,( c\rse1 ^? :o1 "h bel[1 desire to procreate are satisfi$ 9 atta9+ t :i* is beautiful "h bel[3 namely1 ! beauty :i* %9es 9 images & bodies2 = !y d n possess t intelligible ,beauty :i*1 nev]!less1 inspires !m ) t v love :i* !y be> to visible beauty4 ,t is ! reason :y ^? :o asc5d to ! rem9isc5ce ( intelligible ,beauty love t :i* !y behold "h bel[ only because x is an image ( ! o!r4#aai ,z to ^? :o fail to rise to ! rem9isc5ce ( ! intelligible ,beauty1 because !y d n "k ! cause ( _! passion1 !y mi/ake visible beauty = t v]itable ,beauty1 & !y may ev5 love x *a/ely1 if !y be temp]ate3 b to g z f> z a c>nal union is an error1 9 any case4 ,h5ce1 x happ5s t only he :o is inspir$ by a pure love = ! beautiful really loves beauty1 :e!r or n he h ar\s$ 8 rem9isc5ce ( intelligible ,beauty4 ,,beauty ,,is ,,immortal4 ,!y :o jo9 to ?is passion z mu* ( a desire = immortality z our mortal nature admits1 seek beauty 9 ! p]petuity ( ! procreation :i* r5d]s man imp]i%able4 ,!y det]m9e to procreate & produce beauty accord+ to nature2 procreat+ because _! object is p]petuity2 & procreat+ beautifully because !y possess aff9ity ) x4 ,9 fact1 p]petuity does be> aff9ity to beauty2 p]petual nature is beauty itself2 & su* also are all its d]ivatives4 ,,passional ,,love ,,may ,,be ,,elevat+1 ,,?\gh ,,op5 ,,to ,,mislead+ ,,temptations4 ,?us he :o does n desire to procreate seems to aspire to ! possession ( ! beautiful 9 a high] degree4 ,he :o desires to procreate does no d\bt desire to procreate ! beautiful2 b 8 desire indicates 9 him ! pres5ce ( ne$1 & dissatisfaction ) m]e possession ( beauty2 ,he ?9ks he w be procreat+ beauty1 if he begets on t :i* is beautiful4 ,!y :o wi% to satisfy physical love aga9/ human laws1 & nature1 no d\bt h a natural incl9ation z pr9ciple ( a triple passion2 b !y lose _! way /ray+ f ! "r road = lack ( k ( ! end to :i* love 0 impell+ !m1 ( ! goal ( ! aspiration 7r\s$ by7 ! desire ( g5]ation1 & ( ! prop] use ( ! image ( beauty4#abj ,!y really d ignore ,beauty itself4 ,!y :o love beautiful bodies )\t desir+ to unite !mselves to !m1 love !m = _! beauty only4 ,^? :o love ! beauty ( wom51 & desire union ) !m1 love bo? beauty & p]petuity1 s long z ?is object is n lo/ f sight4 ,bo? ( ^! are temp]ate1 b !y :o love bodies = _! beauty only are ! m virtu\s4 ,! =m] admire s5sual beauty1 & are cont5t !re)2 ! latt] recall intelligible beauty1 b1 )\t scorn+ visible beauty1 reg>d x z an effect & image ( ! intelligible ,beauty4#aba ,bo?1 !re=e1 love beauty )\t ev] ne$+ to blu%4 ,b1 z to ^? 7:o violate laws human & div9e71 love ( beauty misleads !m to fall+ into ugl9ess2 = ! desire ( good may (t5 mislead to a fall into evil4 ,su* is love consid]$ z a passion ( ! s\l4 ,,! ,,platonic ,,my? ,,( ,,love4 #b4 ,n[ let u speak ( ! ,love :i* is consid]$ a deity n only by m5 9 g5]al1 b also by ! 7,orphic7 !ologians1 & by ,plato4 ,! latt] (t5 speaks ( ,love1 son ( ,v5us1 attribut+ to him ! mission ( be+ ! *ief ( ! beautiful *ildr5 7or1 boys72 & to direct s\ls to ! contemplation ( intelligible ,beauty1 or1 if already pres5t1 to int5sify ! in/9ct to seek x4 ,9 8 ,banquet ,plato says t ,love is born 7n ( ,v5us1 b7 ( ,abundance & ,ne$1#abb 444 on "s bir?day 787 ( ,v5us4 ,,int]pretation ,,( ,,! ,,platonic ,,my?4 ,to expla9 if ,love be born ( ,v5us1 or if he 7 only born contemporane\sly ) 8 "m1 we %all h to /udy some?+ ab\t ,v5us4 ,:at is ,v5us8 ,is %e ! "m ( ,love1 or only 8 contempor>y8 ,z answ] h]eto we %all obs]ve t !re are two ,v5uses4#abc ,! second 7or ,popul> ,v5us7 is daught] ( ,jupit] & ,dione1 & %e presides ov] e>?ly m>riages4 ,! fir/ ,v5us1 ! cele/ial "o1 daught] ( ,uranus 7by ,plato1 9 8 ,cratylus1 int]pret$ to mean contemplation ( ?+s above71 has no "m1 & does n preside ov] m>riages1 = ! reason t !re are none 9 heav54 ,! ,cele/ial ,v5us1 !re=e1 daught] ( ,kronos1#abd t is1 ( ,intellig5ce1 is ! div9e ,s\l1 :i* is born pure ( pure ,intellig5ce1 & :i* dwells above4#abe ,z h] nature does n admit ( incl9+ e>?w>d1 %e nei!r c nor w desc5d "h bel[4 ,%e is1 !re=e1 a =m ( exi/5ce 7or1 an hypo/asis71 sep>at$ f matt]1 n p>ticipat+ 9 its nature4 ,?is is ! significance ( ! allegory t %e _h no "m4 ,r ?an a gu>dian1 !re=e1 %e %\ld be consid]$ a deity1 z %e is pure ,be+ unm+l$ 7) matt]71 & abid+ )9 h]self4 ,,love1 ,,l ,,high] ,,s\l1 ,,or ,,light1 ,,is ,,insep>able ,,f ,,its ,,s\rce4 ,9 fact1 t :i* is imm$iately born ( ,intellig5ce is pure 9 itself1 because1 by its v proximity to ,intellig5ce1 x has m innate =ce1 desir+ to unite itself firmly to ! pr9ciple t begat x1 & :i* c reta9 x !re on high4 ,! s\l :i* is ?us susp5d$ to ,intellig5ce c\ld n fall d[n1 any m ?an ! light :i* %9es ar\nd ! sun c\ld sep>ate f ! body f :i* x radiates1 & to :i* x is atta*$4 ,,:o ,,cele/ial ,,v5us ,,is4 ,cele/ial ,v5us 7! univ]sal ,s\l1 ! ?ird pr9ciple or hypo/asis#abf71 !re=e1 atta*es h]self to ,kronos 7div9e ,intellig5ce1 ! second pr9ciple71 or1 if y pref] to ,uranos 7! ,"o1 ! ,good1 ! fir/ ,pr9ciple71 ! fa!r ( ,kronos4 ,?us ,v5us turns t[>ds ,uranos1 & unites h]self to him2 & 9 ! act ( lov+ him1 %e procreates ,love1 ) :i* %e contemplates ,uranus4 ,h] activity ?us effects a hypo/asis & be+4 ,bo? ( !m !re=e fix _! gaze on ,uranus1 bo? ! "m & ! fair *ild1 ^: nature x is to be a hypo/asis ev] turn$ t[>ds ano!r beauty1 an int]m$i>y ess5ce betwe5 ! lov] & ! belov$ object4 ,9 fact1 ,love is ! eye by :i* ! lov] sees ! belov$ object2 anticipat+ h]1 s to speak2 & be=e giv+ h] ! faculty ( see+ by ! organ :i* he ?us con/itutes1 he himself is already full ( ! spectacle (f]$ to 8 contemplation4 ,?\gh he ?us anticipates h]1 he does n contemplate ! intelligible 9 ! same mann] z %e does1 9 t he (f]s h] ! spectacle ( ! intelligible1 & t he himself enjoys ! vision ( ! beautiful1 a vision t passes by him 7or1 t coruscates ar\nd him1 z an aureole74 ,,love ,,possesses ,,div9e ,,be+4 #c4 ,we are !re=e =c$ to ackn[l$ge t ,love is a hypo/asis & is be+1 :i* no d\bt is inf]ior to ! ,be+ f :i* x 7emanates1 t is1 f cele/ial ,v5us1 or ! cele/ial ,s\l71 b :i*1 nev]!less1 /ill possesses be+4 ,9 fact1 t cele/ial ,s\l is a be+ born ( ! activity :i* is sup]ior to h] 7! prim>y ,be+71 a liv+ ,be+1 emanat+ f ! prim>y ,be+1 & atta*$ to ! contemplation !re(4 ,9 x %e discov]s ! fir/ object ( h] contemplation1 %e fixes h] glance on x1 z h] good2 & f9ds 9 ?is view a s\rce ( joy4 ,! se5 object attracts h] att5tion s t1 by ! joy %e feels1 by ! ard5t att5tion *>act]iz+ h] contemplation ( its object1 %e h]self begets some?+ wor?y ( h] & ( ! spectacle %e enjoys4 ,?us is ,love born f ! att5tion ) :i* ! s\l applies h]self to ! contemplation ( its object1 & f ! v emanation ( ?is object2 & s ,love is an eye full ( ! object x contemplates1 a vision unit$ to ! image :i* x =ms4 ,?us ,love 7,eros7 seems to owe its "n to its d]iv+ its exi/5ce f vision4#abg ,ev5 :5 consid]$ z passion does ,love owe its "n to ! same fact1 = ,love-t-is-a-be+ is ant]ior to ,love-t-is-n-a-be+4 ,h[ev] mu* we may expla9 passion z love1 x is1 nev]!less1 ev] ! love ( "s object1 & is n love 9 an absolute s5se4 ,,cele/ial ,,love ,,mu/ ,,abide ,,9 ,,! ,,intelligible ,,) ,,! ,,cele/ial ,,s\l4 ,su* is ! love t *>act]izes ! sup]ior ,s\l 7! cele/ial ,s\l74 ,x contemplates ! intelligible _w ) x1 because ,love is ! ,s\l's companion1 be+ born ( ! ,s\l1 & abid+ 9 ! ,s\l1 & ) h] enjoys contemplation ( ! div9ities4 ,n[ z we consid] ! ,s\l :i* fir/ radiates its light on heav5 z sep>ate f matt]1 we mu/ admit t ! love :i* is connect$ ) h]1 is likewise sep>ate f matt]4 ,if we say t ?is pure ,s\l really resides 9 heav51 x is 9 ! s5se 9 :i* we say t t :i* is mo/ preci\s 9 u 7! reasonable s\l7 resides 9 our body1 &1 nev]!less1 is sep>ate f matt]4 ,?is love mu/1 !re=e1 reside only !re :]e resides ?is pure ,s\l4 ,,!re ,,is ,a ,,l[] ,,love1 ,,correspond+ ,,to ,,! ,,_w-,,s\l4 ,b z x 0 simil>ly necess>y t b5ea? ! cele/ial ,s\l !re %\ld exi/ ! _w-,s\l1#abh !re mu/ exi/ ) x ano!r love1 born ( h] desire1 & be+ h] eye4#abi ,z ?is ,v5us belongs to ?is _w1 & z x is n ! pure s\l1 nor s\l 9 an absolute s5se1 x has begott5 ! ,love :i* reigns "h bel[1 & :i*1 ) h]1 presides ov] m>riages4 ,z f> z ?is ,love himself feels ! desire = ! intelligible1 he turns t[>ds ! intelligible ! s\ls ( ! "y p1 & he elevates ! s\l to :i* he may be unit$1 z f> z x is naturally dispos$ to h rem9isc5ce ( ! intelligible4 ,e s\l1 inde$1 aspires to ! ,good1 ev5 t s\l t is m+l$ ) matt]1 & t is ! s\l ( "s p>ticul> be+2 = x is atta*$ to ! sup]ior ,s\l1 & proce$s !refrom4 ,,all ,,s\ls ,,h ,,_! ,,love1 ,,:i* ,,is ,,_! ,,gu>dian4 #d4 ,does ea* s\l include su* a love 9 h] be+1 & possess x z a hypo/atic 7=m ( exi/5ce78 ,s9ce ! _w-,s\l possesses1 z hypo/asis 7=m ( exi/5ce71 ! ,love :i* is inh]5t 9 h] be+1 our s\l %\ld also simil>ly possess1 z hypo/atic 7=m ( exi/5ce71 a love equally inh]5t 9 our be+4 ,:y %\ld ! same n obta9 ev5 ) animals8 ,?is love inh]5t to ! be+ ( e s\l is ! gu>dian consid]$ to be atta*$ to ea* individual4#acj ,x inspires ea* s\l ) ! desires natural = h] to exp]i5ce2 =1 accord+ to h] nature1 ea* s\l begets a love :i* h>monizes ) h] dignity & be+4 ,z ! univ]sal ,s\l possesses univ]sal ,love1 s d individual s\ls ea* possess h] individual love4 ,b z ! individual s\ls are n sep>at$ f ! univ]sal ,s\l1 & are s conta9$ )9 h] t _! totality =ms b a s+le s\l1#aca s are individual loves conta9$ )9 ! univ]sal ,love4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ea* individual love is unit$ to an individual s\l1 z univ]sal ,love is unit$ to ! univ]sal ,s\l4 ,! latt] exi/s entire ev]y:]e 9 ! univ]se1 & s h] unity seems multiple2 %e appe>s any:]e 9 ! univ]se t %e pleases1 "u ! v>i\s =ms suitable to h] p>ts1 & %e reveals h]self1 at w1 "u "s visible =m4 ,,! ,,high] ,,love ,,is ,,deity1 ,,! ,,l[] ,,is ,a ,,gu>dian4 ,we %all h to assume also a multiplicity ( ,v5uses1 :i*1 born ) ,love1 occupy ! rank ( gu>dians4 ,!y orig9ate f ! univ]sal ,v5us1 f :i* d]ive all ! individual v5uses1 ) ! loves peculi> to ea*4 ,9 fact1 ! s\l is ! "m ( love2 n[ ,v5us is ! ,s\l1 & ,love is ! ,s\l's activity 9 desir+ ! ,good4 ,! love :i* leads ea* s\l to ! nature ( ! ,good1 & :i* belongs to h] mo/ exalt$ "p1 mu/ also be consid]$ a deity1 inasmu* z x unites ! s\l to ! ,good4 ,! love :i* belongs to ! s\l m+l$ 7) matt]71 is to be consid]$ a ,gu>dian only4 ,,x ,,is ,,an ,,error ,,to ,,consid] ,,! ,,love ,,z ,,id5tical ,,) ,,! ,,_w4 #e4 ,:at is ! nature ( ?is ,gu>dian1 & :at is1 9 g5]al1 ! nature ( gu>dians1 accord+ to 7,plato's treatm5t ( ! subject 97 8 ,banquet8 ,:at is ! nature ( gu>dians8 ,:at is ! nature ( ! ,love born ( ,ne$ 7,p5ia7 & ,abundance 7,poros71 son ( ,prud5ce 7,metis71 at ! bir? ( ,v5us8#acb 7,plut>*7#acc held t ,plato1 by ,love1 meant ! _w4 ,he %\ld h /at$ t ,love is "p ( ! _w1 & 0 born 9 x4 ,8 op9ion is errone\s1 z may be demon/rat$ by sev]al pro(s4 ,fir/1 7,plato7 calls ! _w a bless$ deity1 t is self-suffici5t2 h[ev]1 he nev] attributes ^! *>act]i/ics to ,love1 :i* he always calls a ne$y be+4 ,fur!r1 ! _w is compos$ ( a body & a ,s\l1 ! latt] be+ ,v5us2 consequ5tly1 ,v5us w\ld be ! direct+ "p ( ,love2 or1 if we take ! _w to mean ! _w-,s\l1 j z we (t5 say man :5 we mean ! human s\l1#acd ,love w\ld be id5tical ) ,v5us4 ,?ird1 if ,love1 :i* is a ,gu>dian1 is ! _w1 :y %\ld n ! o!r ,gu>dians 7:o evid5tly are ( ! same nature7 n also be ! _w8 ,9 ?is case1 ! _w w\ld be compos$ ( ,gu>dians4 ,f\r?1 h[ c\ld we apply to ! _w t :i* 7,plato7 says ( ,love1 t x is ! gu>dian ( fair *ildr58 ,la/1 ,plato describes ,love z lack+ clo?+1 %oes1 & lodg+4 ,?is c\ld n be appli$ to ! _w )\t absurdity or ridicule4 ,,all ,,gu>dians ,,are ,,born ,,( ,,ne$ ,,& ,,abundance4 #f4 ,to expla9 ! nature & bir? ( ,love1 we %all h to exp\nd ! significance ( 8 "m ,ne$ to 8 fa!r ,abundance1 & to %[ h[ su* p>5ts suit him4 ,we %all also h to %[ h[ su* p>5ts suit ! o!r ,gu>dians1 = all ,gu>dians1 by virtue ( _! be+ ,gu>dians1 mu/ h ! same nature1 unless1 inde$1 ,gu>dians h only t "n 9 common4 ,,diff]5ce ,,betwe5 ,,deities ,,& ,,gu>dians4 ,fir/1 we %all h to consid] ! diff]5ce betwe5 deities & gu>dians4 ,al?\gh x be common to call ,gu>dians deities1 we are "h us+ ! ^w 9 t s5se x be>s :5 "o says t ,gu>dians & deities belong to diff]5t species4 ,! deities are impassible1 :ile ! ,gu>dians1 ?\gh et]nal1 c exp]i5ce passions2 plac$ b5ea? ! deities1 b next to u1 !y occupy ! middle place betwe5 deities & m54#ace ,a ,,gu>dian ,,is ,,! ,,ve/ige ,,( ,a ,,s\l ,,desc5d$ ,,into ,,! ,,_w4 ,b h[ did ! ,gu>dians n rema9 impassible8 ,h[ did !y desc5d to an inf]ior nature8 ,?is surely is a "q des]v+ consid]ation4 ,we %\ld also inquire :e!r !re be any ,gu>dian 9 ! intelligible _w1 :e!r !re be ,gu>dians only "h bel[1 & if deities exi/ only 9 ! intelligible _w4 7,we %all answ] z foll[s47 ,!re are deities also "h bel[2 & ! _w is1 z we habitually say1 a deity ( ! ?ird rank1 inasmu* z e supra-lun> be+ is a div9ity4 ,next1 x w\ld be bett] n to call any be+ belong+ to ! intelligible _w a ,gu>dian2 & if we locate ! *ief ,gu>dian 7! ,gu>dian himself7 9 ! intelligible _w1 we _h bett] consid] him a deity4 ,9 ! _w ( s5se1 all ! visible supra-lun> deities %\ld be call$ second-rank deities1 9 t !y are plac$ bel[ ! intelligible deities1 & dep5d on !m z ! rays ( light f ! /> f :i* !y radiate4 ,la/1 a ,gu>dian %\ld be def9$ z ! ve/ige ( a s\l t _h desc5d$ into ! _w4 ,! latt] condition is necess>y because e pure s\l begets a deity1 & we h already said#acf t ! love ( su* a s\l is a deity4 ,,:y ,,all ,,gu>dians ,,are ,,n ,,loves4 ,b :y are n all ! ,gu>dians ,loves8 ,fur!r1 :y are !y n completely pure f all matt]8 ,among ,gu>dians1 ^? are ,loves1 :i* owe _! exi/5ce to a s\l's desire = ! good & ! beautiful2 !re=e1 all s\ls t h ent]$ into ?is _w ea* g5]ate a ,love ( ?is k9d4 ,z to ! o!r ,gu>dians1 :i* are n born ( human s\ls1 !y are eng5d]$ by ! diff]5t p[]s ( ! univ]sal ,s\l1 = ! utility ( ! ,all2 !y complete & adm9i/] all ?+s = ! g5]al good4 ,! univ]sal ,s\l1 9 fact1 0 b\nd to meet ! ne$s ( ! univ]se by begett+ ,gu>dian p[]s :i* w\ld suit ! ,all ( :i* %e is ! s\l4 ,,:y ,,! ,,gu>dians ,,are ,,n ,,free ,,f ,,matt]4 ,h[ d ,gu>dians p>ticipate 9 matt]1 & ( :at matt] are !y =m$8 ,?is _! matt] is n corporeal1 o!rwise !y w\ld be animals ) s5sation4 ,9 fact1 :e!r !y h a]ial or fire-l bodies1#acg !y mu/ h _h a nature primitively diff]5t 7f pure ,intellig5ce7 to h ultimately unit$ ea* ) 8 own body1 = t :i* is entirely pure c\ld n h imm$iately unit$ ) a body1 al?\gh _m philosoph]s ?9k t ! be+ ( e ,gu>dian1 z gu>dian1 is unit$ to an air-l or fire-l body4 ,b :y is ! be+ ( e ,gu>dian m+l$ ) a body1 :ile ! be+ ( e deity is pure1 unless 9 ! fir/ case !re be a cause :i* produces ! m+l+ 7) matt]78 ,?is cause mu/ be ! exi/5ce ( an intelligible matt]1#ach s t :atev] p>ticipates 9 x might1 by its means1 come to unite ) s5se-matt]4 ,,s\l ,,is ,a ,,mixture ,,( ,,reason ,,& ,,indet]m9ation4 #g4 ,plato's acc\nt ( ! bir? ( ,love#acb is t ,abundance intoxicat$ himself ) nect>1 ?is happ5+ be=e ! day ( w9e1 :i* implies t ,love 0 born be=e ! s5se-_w's exi/5ce4 ,!n ,ne$1 ! "m ( ,love1 mu/ h p>ticipat$ 9 ! intelligible nature itself1 & n 9 a simple image ( ! intelligible nature2 %e1 !re=e1 approa*$ 7! intelligible nature7 & f\nd h]self to be a mixture ( =m & indet]m9at5ess 7or1 intelligible matt]74#aci ,! s\l1 9 fact1 conta9+ a c]ta9 indet]m9at5ess be=e %e _h rea*$ ! ,good1 b feel+ a premonition ( h] exi/5ce1 =m$ = h]self a confus$ & indet]m9ate image1 :i* became ! v hypo/asis 7or1 =m ( exi/5ce7 ( ,love4 ,?us1 z "h1 reason m+les ) ! unreasonable1 ) an indet]m9ate desire1 ) an indi/9ct 7fa9t or obscure7 hypo/atic 7=m ( exi/5ce74 ,:at 0 born 0 nei!r p]fect nor complete2 x 0 some?+ ne$y1 because x 0 born f an indet]m9ate desire1 & a complete reason4 ,z to 7,love1 :i* is7 ! ?us begott5 reason1 x is n pure1 s9ce x conta9s a desire t is indet]m9ate1 unreasonable1 indef9ite2 nor w x ev] be satisfi$ s long z x conta9s ! nature ( indet]m9ation4 ,x dep5ds on ! s\l1 :i* is its g5]at+ pr9ciple2 x is a mixture effect$ by a reason :i*1 in/ead ( rema9+ )9 itself1 is m+l$ ) indet]m9ation4 ,besides1 x is n ,reason itself1 b its emanation :i* m+les ) indet]m9ation4 ,,love ,,is ,a ,,gadfly4 ,love1 !re=e1 is simil> to a gad-fly2#adj ne$y by nature1 x /ill rema9s ne$y1 :atev] x may obta92 x c\ld nev] be satisfi$1 = ?is w\ld be impossible = a be+ t is a mixture2 no be+ c\ld ev] be fully satisfi$ if by its nature x be incapable ( atta9+ fulness2 ev5 7 x satisfi$ = a mom5t1 x c\ld n reta9 any?+ if its nature made x cont9ue to desire4 ,consequ5tly1 on "o side1 ,love is depriv$ ( all res\rces#ada because ( its ne$9ess2 & on ! o!r1 x possesses ! faculty ( acquisition1 because ( ! reason t ent]s into its con/itution4 ,,gu>dians1 ,,z ,,well ,,z ,,m51 ,,are ,,urg$ ,,by ,,div9e ,,discont5t4 ,all o!r ,gu>dians h a simil> con/itution4 ,ea* ( !m desires1 & causes ! acquisition ( ! good he is de/9$ to procure2 t is ! *>act]i/ic !y h 9 common ) ,love4 ,nei!r c\ld !y ev] atta9 satisfaction2 !y /ill desire "s p>ticul> good4 ,! result ( ?is is t ! m5 :o "h bel[ are good are inspir$ by ! love ( ! true1 absolute ,good1 & n by ! love ( su* & su* a p>ticul> good4#adb ,^? :o are subord9at$ to div]s ,gu>dians are successively subord9at$ to su* or su* a ,gu>dian2 !y let ! simple & pure love ( ! absolute ,good re/ )9 !mselves1 :ile !y see to x t _! actions are presid$ ov] by ano!r ,gu>dian1 t is1 ano!r p[] ( _! s\l1 :i* is imm$iately sup]ior to t :i* directs !m1 or is active )9 !m4#adc ,z to ! m5 :o1 driv5 by evil impulses1 desire evil ?+s1 !y seem to h *a9$ d[n all ! loves 9 _! s\ls1 j z1 by false op9ions1 !y d>k5 ! "r reason :i* is innate )9 !m4 ,?us all ! loves implant$ 9 u by nature1 & :i* con=m to nature1 are all good2 ^? t belong to ! inf]ior "p ( ! s\l are inf]ior 9 rank & p[]2 ^? t belong to ! sup]ior "p are sup]ior2 all belong to ! be+ ( ! s\l4 ,z to ! loves :i* are contr>y to nature1 !y are ! passions ( /ray$ s\ls1 hav+ no?+ ess5tial or sub/antial2 = !y are n eng5d]$ by ! pure ,s\l2 !y are ! fruits ( ! faults ( ! s\l :i* produces !m accord+ to h] vici\s habits & dispositions4 ,,"r ,,?\ghts ,,possess ,,real ,,exi/5ce4 ,9 g5]al1 we might admit t ! true goods :i* are possess$ by ! s\l :5 %e acts con=mably to h] nature1 by apply+ h]self to ?+s det]m9$ 7by reason71 con/itute real be+2 t ! o!rs1 on ! contr>y1 are n eng5d]$ by ! v action ( ! s\l1 & are only passions4#add ,likewise1 false intellections lack real be+1 su* z belongs to true intellections1 :i* are et]nal & det]m9ate1 possess+ simultane\sly ! intellectual act1 ! intelligible exi/5ce & ess5ce2 & ?is latt] n only 9 g5]al1 b 9 ea* real intelligible be+ 7manife/+87 ,intellig5ce 9 ea* idea4 ,z to u1 we mu/ ackn[l$ge t we possess only intellection & ! intelligible2 we d n possess !m toge!r 7or completely71 b only 9 g5]al2 & h5ce comes our love = g5]alities4 ,our conceptions1 inde$1 usually tr5d t[>ds ! g5]al4 ,x is only by accid5t t we conceive some?+ p>ticul>2 :51 = in/ance1 we conceive t "s p>ticul> triangle's angles am\nt to two "r angles1 x is only z a result ( fir/ hav+ conceiv$ t ! triangle 9 g5]al possesses ?is prop]ty4 ,,jupit]1 ,,! ,,great ,,*ief1 ,,or ,,?ird ,,god1 ,,is ,,! ,,s\l1 ,,or ,,v5us4 #h4 ,f9ally1 :o is ?is ,jupit] into ^: g>d5s 7,plato said t7 ,abundance ent]$8 ,:at are ^! g>d5s8 ,z we h already agre$1 ,v5us is ! ,s\l1 & ,abundance is ! ,reason ( all ?+s4 ,we /ill h to expla9 ! significance ( ,jupit] & 8 g>d5s4 ,jupit] _c well signify any?+ else ?an ! s\l1 s9ce we h already admitt$ t ! s\l 0 ,v5us4 ,we mu/ "h consid] ,jupit] z t deity :i* ,plato1 9 8 ,pha$rus1 calls ! ,great ,*ief2#ade &1 else:]e1 z ,i ?9k1 ! ,?ird ,god4 ,he expla9s himself m cle>ly 9 ?is respect 9 ! ,philebus1#adf :]e he says t ,jupit] has a royal s\l1 a royal intellig5ce4 ,s9ce ,jupit] is1 !re=e1 bo? an intellig5ce & a s\l1 s9ce he =ms "p ( ! ord] ( causes1 s9ce we mu/ assign him 8 rank accord+ to :at is be/ 9 him2 & = sev]al reasons1 *iefly because he is a cause1 a royal & direct+ cause1 he mu/ be consid]$ z ! ,intellig5ce4 ,v5us 7t is1 ,aphrodite7 :i* belongs to him1 :i* proce$s f him1 & accompanies him1 occupies ! rank ( a s\l1 = %e repres5ts 9 ! s\l t :i* is beautiful1 brilliant1 pure1 & delicate 7abron72 & t is :y %e is call$ ,aphrodite4#adg ,9 fact1 if we ref] ! male deities to ! intellect1 & if we consid] ! female deities z s\ls--because a s\l is atta*$ to ea* intellig5ce--we %all h "o m reason to relate ,v5us to ,jupit]4 ,our views ^u ?is po9t are confirm$ by ! tea*+s ( ! prie/s & ! 7,orphic7 ,!ologians1 :o always id5tify ,v5us & ,juno1 & :o call ! ev5+ />1 or ,/> ( ,v5us1 ! ,/> ( ,juno4#adh ,,jupit]',s ,,g>d5 ,,is ,,! ,,fruitful ,,reason ,,t ,,begets ,,e ,,object4 #i4 ,abundance1 be+ ! reason ( ! ?+s t exi/ 9 ,intellig5ce & 9 ! intelligible _w--,i mean ! reason :i* p\rs itself out & develops--tr5ds t[>ds ! s\l1 & exi/s !re94 ,inde$1 ! 7,be+7 :i* rema9s unit$ 9 ,intellig5ce does n emanate f a =eign pr9ciple1 :ile ! intoxication ( ,abundance is only a factiti\s fulness4 ,b :at is t :i* is intoxicat$ ) nect>8 ,x is ,reason t desc5ds f ! sup]ior pr9ciple to ! inf]ior2 ! ,s\l receives x f ,intellig5ce at ! mom5t ( ! bir? ( ,v5us2 t is :y x is said t ! nect> fl[s 9 ! g>d5 ( ,jupit]4 ,?is :ole g>d5 is ! glory & spl5dor ( ! weal? 7( ,intellig5ce72#adi ?is glory orig9ates 9 ! reason ( ,jupit]2 ?is spl5dor is ! light :i* ! intellig5ce ( ?is ,deity %$s on ! s\l4 ,:at else b ! beauties & spl5dors ( ?is deity c\ld ! g>d5s ( ,jupit] signify8 ,on ! o!r h&1 :at else c ! beauties & spl5dors ( ,jupit] be1 if n ! reasons#aej t emanate f him8 ,at ! same "t1 ^! reasons are call$ ,abundance 7,poros1 or euporia71 ! weal? ( ! beauties :i* manife/2 t is ! nect> :i* intoxicates ,abundance4#aea ,= inde$ :at else is ! nect> among ! deities1 b t :i* ea* ( !m receives8 ,n[ ,reason is t :i* is receiv$ f ,intellig5ce by its next inf]ior pr9ciple4 ,intellig5ce possesses itself fully2 yet ?is self-possession does n intoxicate x1 z x possesses no?+ =eign !reto4 ,on ! contr>y1 ,reason is eng5d]$ by ,intellig5ce4 ,z x exi/s b5ea? ,intellig5ce1 & does n1 z ,intellig5ce does1 belong to itself1 x exi/s 9 ano!r pr9ciple2 consequ5tly1 we say t ,abundance is ly+ d[n 9 ! g>d5 ( ,jupit]1 & t at ! v mom5t :5 ,v5us1 be+ born1 takes h] place among liv+ be+s4 ,,! ,,object ,,( ,,my?s ,,is ,,to ,,analyse2 ,,& ,,to ,,di/+ui%4 #aj4 ,if my?s are to e>n _! "n 7( some?+ res]v$1 or sil5t7 !y mu/ necess>ily develop _! /ories "u ! category ( "t1 & pres5t z sep>ate _m ?+s1 t are simultane\s1 ?\gh diff]5t 9 rank or p[]4 ,t is ! reason !y s (t5 m5tion ! g5]ation ( ung5]at$ ?+s1 & t !y s (t5 sep>ate simultane\s ?+s4#aeb ,b aft] hav+ ?us 7by ?is analysis7 yield$ u all ! in/ruction possible to !m1 ^! my?s leave x to ! read] to make a syn!sis !re(4 ,ours is ! foll[+3 ,,significance ,,( ,,! ,,platonic ,,my? ,,( ,,! ,,g>d5 ,,( ,,jupit]4 ,v5us is ! ,s\l :i* coexi/s ) ,intellig5ce1 & subsi/s by ,intellig5ce4 ,%e receives f ,intellig5ce ! reasons#aej :i* fill h]1#aec & embelli%es h]1 & ^: abundance makes u see 9 ! ,s\l ! spl5dor & image ( all beauties4 ,! reasons :i* subsi/ 9 ! ,s\l are ,abundance#aed ( ! nect> :i* fl[s d[n f above4 ,_! spl5dors :i* %9e 9 ! ,s\l1 z 9 life1 repres5t ! ,g>d5 ( ,jupit]4 ,abundance falls asleep 9 ?is g>d51 because he is weight$ d[n by ! fulness conta9$ )9 him4 ,z life manife/s & ev] exi/s 9 ! ord] ( be+s1 7,plato7 says t ! deities are seat$ at a fea/1 because !y ev] enjoy ?is beatitude4 ,,significance ,,( ,,! ,,platonic ,,my? ,,( ,,! ,,bir? ,,( ,,love4 ,s9ce ! ,s\l h]self exi/s1 ,love also mu/ necess>ily exi/1 & x owes its exi/5ce to ! desire ( ! ,s\l :i* aspires to ! bett] & ! ,good4 ,love is a mix$ be+3 x p>ticipates 9 ne$1 because x ne$s satisfaction2 x also p>ticipates 9 abundance1 because x /ruggles to acquire good :i* x yet lacks1 inasmu* z only t :i* lack$ good entirely w\ld cease to seek x4 ,x is1 !re=e1 correct to call ,love ! son ( ,abundance & ,ne$1 :i* are con/itut$ by lack1 desire1 & rem9isc5ce ( ! reasons--or ideas--:i*1 reunit$ 9 ! s\l1 h !re9 eng5d]$ t aspiration t[>ds ! good :i* con/itutes love4 ,its "m is ,ne$1 because desire belongs only to ne$1 & ne$ signifies matt]1 :i* is entire ne$4#aee ,ev5 indet]m9ation1 :i* *>act]izes ! desire ( ! good1 makes ! be+ :i* desires ! ,good play ! "p ( matt]--s9ce su* a be+ w\ld h nei!r =m nor reason1 consid]$ only f its desir+4 ,x is a =m only inasmu* z x rema9s )9 itself4 ,z soon z x desires to atta9 a new p]fection1 x is matt] relatively to ! be+ f :om x desires to receive some:at4 ,,love ,,is ,,bo? ,,mat]ial ,,& ,a ,,gu>dian4 ,t is :y ,love is bo? a be+ :i* p>ticipates 9 matt]1 & is also a ,gu>dian born ( ! s\l2 x is ! =m]1 inasmu* z x does n completely possess ! good2 x is ! latt]1 inasmu* z x desires ! ,good f ! v mom5t ( its bir?4 ,,fir/ ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,eight4 ,( ! ,nature & ,orig9 ( ,evils4#aef ,,que/ions ,,to ,,be ,,discuss$4 #a4 ,/udy+ ! orig9 ( evils t might affect all be+s 9 g5]al1 or "s "o class 9 p>ticul>1 x is reasonable to beg9 by def9+ evil1 f a consid]ation ( its nature4 ,t w\ld be ! be/ way to discov] :5ce x arises1 :]e x resides1 to :om x may happ51 & 9 g5]al to decide if x be some?+ real4 ,:i* "o ( our faculties !n c in=m u ( ! nature ( evil8 ,?is "q is n easy to solve1 because !re mu/ be an analogy betwe5 ! kn[] & ! kn[n4#aeg ,! ,intellig5ce & ! ,s\l may inde$ cognize =ms & fix _! desires on !m1 because !y !mselves are =ms2 b evil1 :i* consi/s 9 ! abs5ce ( all goods1 c\ld n be describ$ z a =m4#aeh ,b inasmu* z !re c be b "o s+le sci5ce1 to embrace ev5 contr>ies1 & z ! evil is ! contr>y ( ! good1 k ( ! good implies t ( evil4 ,!re=e1 to det]m9e ! nature ( evil1 we %all fir/ h to det]m9e t ( good1 = ! high] ?+s mu/ prec$e ! l[]1 z "s are =ms & o!rs are n1 be+ r a privation ( ! good4 ,j 9 :at s5se evil is ! contr>y ( ! good mu/ also be det]m9$2 z = in/ance1 if ! ,"o be ! fir/1 & matt] ! la/2#aei or :e!r ! ,"o be =m1 & matt] be its abs5ce4 ,( ?is fur!r4#afj ,a4 ,,prim>y ,,& ,,second>y ,,evil4 ,a ,,def9ition ,,( ,,evil ,,by ,,contra/ ,,) ,,! ,,good4 #b4 ,let u n[ det]m9e ! nature ( ! ,good1 at lea/ s f> z is dem&$ by ! pres5t discussion4 ,! ,good is ! pr9ciple on :i* all dep5ds1 to :i* ev]y?+ aspires1 f :i* ev]y?+ issues1 & ( :i* ev]y?+ has ne$4 ,z to ,him1 ,he suffices to himself1 be+ complete1 s ,he /&s 9 ne$ ( no?+2 ,he is ! measure#afa & ! end ( all ?+s2 & f ,him spr+ intellig5ce1 be+1 s\l1 life1 & intellectual contemplation4 ,,nature ,,( ,,div9e ,,intellig5ce4 ,all ^! beautiful ?+s exi/ z f> z ,he does2 b ,he is ! "o ,pr9ciple t possesses supreme beauty1 a pr9ciple t is sup]ior to ! ?+s t are be/4 ,he reigns royally1#afb 9 ! intelligible _w1 be+ ,intellig5ce itself1 v diff]5tly f :at we call human intellig5ces4 ,! latt] inde$ are all occupi$ ) propositions1 discussions ab\t ! mean+s ( words1 reason+s1 exam9ations ( ! validity ( conclusions1 obs]v+ ! concat5ation ( causes1 be+ incapable ( possess+ tru? a priori1 & ?\gh !y be intellig5ces1 be+ devoid ( all ideas be=e hav+ be5 in/ruct$ by exp]i5ce2 ?\gh !y1 nev]!less1 7 intellig5ces4 ,su* is n ! prim>y ,intellig5ce4 ,on ! contr>y1 x possesses all ?+s4 ,?\gh rema9+ )9 itself1 x is all ?+s2 x possesses all ?+s1 )\t possess+ !m 79 ! usual acceptation ( t t]m72 ! ?+s t subsi/ 9 x n diff]+ f x1 & n be+ sep>at$ f ea* o!r4 ,ea* "o ( !m is all ! o!rs1#afc is ev]y?+ & ev]y:]e1 al?\gh n conf\nd$ ) o!r ?+s1 & rema9+ di/9ct !refrom4 ,,nature ,,( ,,! ,,univ]sal ,,s\l4 ,! p[] :i* p>ticipates 9 ,intellig5ce 7! univ]sal ,s\l7 does n p>ticipate 9 x 9 a mann] su* z to be equal to x1 b only 9 ! measure ( h] ability to p>ticipate !re94 ,%e is ! fir/ actualization ( ,intellig5ce1 ! fir/ be+ t ,intellig5ce1 ?\gh rema9+ )9 itself1 begets4 ,%e directs h] :ole activity t[>ds supreme ,intellig5ce1 & lives exclusively !reby4 ,mov+ f outside ,intellig5ce1 & ar\nd x1 accord+ to ! laws ( h>mony1#afd ! univ]sal ,s\l fixes h] glance ^u x4 ,by contemplation p5etrat+ into its inmo/ dep?s1 ?r\gh ,intellig5ce %e sees ! div9ity ,himself4 ,su* is ! nature ( ! s]5e & blissful exi/5ce ( ! div9ities1 a life :]e evil has no place4 ,,evil ,,exi/s ,,z ,a ,,consequ5ce ,,( ,,! ,,d]ivative ,,goods ,,( ,,! ,,?ird ,,rank4 ,if ev]y?+ /opp$ !re 7& if !re 7 no?+ beyond ! ?ree pr9ciples "h describ$71 evil w\ld n exi/ 7& !re w\ld be no?+ b goods74 ,b !re are goods ( ! fir/1 second & ?ird ranks4 ,?\gh all relate to ! ,k+ ( all ?+s1#afe :o is _! au?or1 & f :om !y d]ive _! goodness1 yet ! goods ( ! second rank relate m specially to ! second pr9ciple2 & to ! ?ird pr9ciple1 ! goods ( ! ?ird rank4 ,,nature ,,( ,,evil4 #c4 ,z ^! are real be+s1 & z ! fir/ ,pr9ciple is _! sup]ior1 evil c\ld n exi/ 9 su* be+s1 & /ill less 9 ,him1 :o is sup]ior to !m2 = all ^! ?+s are good4 ,evil !n mu/ be locat$ 9 non-be+1 & mu/1 s to speak1 be its =m1 ref]r+ to ! ?+s t m+le ) x1 or h "s community ) x4 ,?is non-be+1 h[ev]1 is n absolute non-be+4#aff ,its diff]5ce f be+ resembles ! diff]5ce betwe5 be+ & movem5t or re/2 b only z its image1 or some?+ /ill m di/ant f reality4 ,)9 ?is non-be+ are compris$ all s5se-objects1 & all _! passive modifications2 or1 evil may be some?+ /ill m inf]ior1 l _! accid5t or pr9ciple1 or "o ( ! ?+s t contribute to its con/itution4 ,to ga9 "s conception ( evil x may be repres5t$ by ! contra/ betwe5 measure & incomm5surability2 betwe5 indet]m9ation & its goal2 betwe5 lack ( =m & ! creat+ pr9ciple ( =m2 betwe5 lack & self-suffici5cy2 z ! p]petual unlimit$ & *angeabl5ess2 z passivity1 insatiabl5ess1 & absolute pov]ty4#afg ,^? are n ! m]e accid5ts ( evil1 b its v ess5ce2 all ( t c be discov]$ :5 any "p ( evil is exam9$4 ,! o!r objects1 :5 !y p>ticipate 9 ! evil & resemble x1 become evil )\t h[ev] be+ absolute ,evil4 ,,evil ,,possesses ,a ,,l[] ,,=m ,,( ,,be+4 ,all ^! ?+s p>ticipate 9 a be+2 !y d n diff] f x1 !y are id5tical ) x1 & con/itute x4 ,= if evil be an accid5t 9 some?+1 !n evil1 ?\gh n be+ a real be+1 mu/ be some?+ by itself4 ,j z1 = ! good1 !re is ! ,good 9 itself1 & ! good consid]$ z an attribute ( a =eign subject1 likewise1 = evil1 "o may di/+ui% ,evil 9 itself1 & evil z accid5t4 ,,evil ,,z ,,inf9ite ,,& ,,=mlessness ,,9 ,,itself4 ,x might be object$ t x is impossible to conceive ( indet]m9ation outside ( ! indet]m9ate1 any m ?an det]m9ation outside ( ! det]m9ate2 or measure outside ( ! measur$4 7,we %all h to answ] t7 j z det]m9ation does n reside 9 ! det]m9$ 7or measure 9 ! measur$71 s indet]m9ation _c exi/ )9 ! indet]m9ate4 ,if x c exi/ 9 some?+ o!r ?an itself1 x w be ei!r 9 ! indet]m9ate1 or 9 ! det]m9ate4 ,if 9 ! indet]m9ate1 x is evid5t t x itself is indet]m9ate1 & ne$s no indet]m9ation to become su*4 ,if1 on ! o!r h& 7x be claim$ t indet]m9ation exi/71 9 ! det]m9ate1 7x is evid5t t7 ! det]m9ate _c admit indet]m9ation4 ,?is1 !re=e1 dem&s ! exi/5ce ( some?+ inf9ite 9 itself1 & =mless 9 itself1 :i* w\ld comb9e all ! *>act]i/ics m5tion$ above z ! *>act]i/ics ( evil4#afh ,z to evil ?+s1 !y are su* because evil is m+l$ ) !m1 ei!r because !y contemplate evil1 or because !y fulfil x4 ,,! ,,prim>y ,,evil ,,is ,,evil ,,9 ,,itself4 ,reason1 !re=e1 =ces u to recognize z ! prim>y evil1 ,evil 9 itself4#afi 7,?is is matt] :i* is7 ! subject ( figure1 =m1 det]m9ation1 & limitation2 :i* owes its ornam5ts to o!rs1 :i* has no?+ good 9 itself1 :i* is b a va9 image by comp>ison ) ! real be+s--9 o!r ^w1 ! ess5ce ( evil1 if su* an ess5ce c exi/4 ,,matt] ,,z ,,! ,,second>y ,,evil4 #d4 ,s f> z ! nature ( bodies p>ticipates 9 matt]1 x is an evil2 yet x c\ld n be ! prim>y ,evil1 = x has a c]ta9 =m4 ,nev]!less1 ?is =m possesses no reality1 & is1 besides1 depriv$ ( life 7872 = bodies corrupt ea* o!r mutually4 ,be+ agitat$ by an unregulat$ movem5t1 !y h9d] ! s\l f c>ry+ out h] prop] movem5t4 ,!y are 9 a p]petual flux1 contr>y to ! immutable nature ( ess5ces2 !re=e1 !y con/itute ! second>y evil4 ,,! ,,s\l ,,is ,,n ,,evil ,,by ,,h]self1 ,,b ,,may ,,deg5]ate ,,by ,,look+ ,,at ,,d>kness4 ,by h]self1 ! s\l is n evil1 & n e s\l is evil4 ,:at s\l des]ves to be s consid]$8 ,t ( ! man :o1 accord+ to ! expression ( ,plato1#agj is a slave to ! body4 ,9 ?is man x is natural = ! s\l to be evil4 ,x is inde$ ! irrational "p ( ! s\l :i* h>bors all t con/itutes evil3 indet]m9ation1 excess1 & ne$1 f :i* are d]iv$ intemp]ance1 c[>dl9ess1 & all ! vices ( ! s\l1 ! involunt>y passions1 mo!rs ( false op9ions1 :i* lead u to consid] ! ?+s we seek or avoid z goods or evils4 ,b :at produces ?is evil8 ,h[ %all we make a cause or a pr9ciple ( x8 ,to beg9 )1 ! s\l is nei!r indep5d5t ( matt]1 nor1 by h]self1 p]v]se4 ,by virtue ( h] union ) ! body1 :i* is mat]ial1 %e is m+l$ ) indet]m9ation1 & s1 to a c]ta9 po9t1 depriv$ ( ! =m :i* embelli%es & :i* supplies measure4 ,fur!r1 t reason %\ld be h9d]$ 9 its op]ations1 & _c see well1 mu/ be due to ! s\l's be+ h9d]$ by passions1 & obscur$ by ! d>kness ) :i* matt] surr\nds h]4 ,! s\l incl9es#aga t[>ds matt]4 ,?us ! s\l fixes h] glance1 n on :at is ess5ce1 b on :at is simple g5]ation4#agb ,n[ ! pr9ciple ( g5]ation is matt]1 ^: nature is s bad t matt] communicates x to ! be+s :i*1 ev5 )\t be+ unit$ !reto1 m]ely look at x4 ,be+ ! privation ( good1 matt] conta9s none ( x1 & assimilates to itself all t t\*es x4 ,!re=e1 ! p]fect ,s\l1 be+ turn$ t[>ds ev] pure ,intellig5ce1 repels matt]1 indet]m9at5ess1 ! lack ( measure1 & 9 %ort1 evil4 ,! p]fect ,s\l does n approa* to x1 does n l[] h] looks2 %e rema9s pure & det]m9$ by ,intellig5ce4 ,! s\l :i* does n rema9 9 ?is /ate1 & :i* issues f h]self 7to unite ) ! body71 n be+ det]m9$ by ! ,fir/1 ! ,p]fect1 is no m ?an an image ( ! p]fect ,s\l because %e lacks 7good71 & is fill$ ) indet]m9ation4 ,! s\l sees no?+ b d>kness4 ,! s\l already conta9s matt] because %e looks at :at %e _c see2 or1 9 ! e-day expression1 because ! s\l looks at d>kness4#agc ,,prim>y ,,& ,,second>y ,,evil ,,= ,,! ,,s\l4 #e4 ,s9ce ! lack ( good is ! cause t ! s\l looks at d>kness1 & m+les !re)1 ! lack ( good & d>kness is prim>y ,evil = ! s\l4 ,! second>y evil w be ! d>kness1 & ! nature ( evil1 consid]$ n 9 matt]1 b be=e matt]4 ,evil consi/s n 9 ! lack ( any p>ticul> ?+1 b ( ev]y?+ 9 g5]al4 ,no?+ is evil m]ely because x lacks a little ( be+ good2 its nature might /ill be p]fect4 ,b :at1 l matt]1 lacks good entirely1 is ess5tially evil1 & possesses no?+ good8 ,nature1 inde$1 does n possess ess5ce1 or x w\ld p>ticipate 9 ! good2 only by v]bal simil>ity c we say t matt] is1 :ile we c truly say t matt] is absolute non5tity4 ,a m]e lack 7( good7 !re=e1 may be *>act]iz$ z n be+ good2 b complete lack is evil2 :ile a lack ( m$ium int5sity consi/s 9 ! possibility ( fall+ into evil1 & is already an evil4 ,evil1 !re=e1 is n any p>ticul> evil1 z inju/ice1 or any special vice2 evil is t :i* is n yet any?+ ( t1 be+ no?+ def9ite4 ,inju/ice & ! o!r vices mu/ be consid]$ z k9ds ( evil1 di/+ui%$ f ea* o!r by m]e accid5ts2 z = in/ance1 :at occurs by malice4 ,besides1 ! diff]5t k9ds ( evil diff] among ea* o!r ei!r by ! matt] 9 :i* evil resides1 or by ! p>ts ( ! s\l to :i* x ref]s1 z sight1 desire1 & passion4 ,,relation ,,betwe5 ,,ext]nal ,,& ,,int]nal ,,evil4 ,if we grant ! exi/5ce ( evils ext]nal to ! s\l1 we %all be =c$ to decide ab\t _! relation to sickness1 ugl9ess1 or pov]ty4 ,sickness has be5 expla9$ z a lack or excess ( mat]ial bodies :i* fail to support ord] or measure4 ,! cause ( ugl9ess1 also1 has be5 giv5 z defici5t adju/m5t ( matt] to =m4 ,pov]ty has be5 describ$ z ! ne$ or lack ( objects necess>y to life z a result ( our union ) matt]1 ^: nature is 7! ,h]aclitian & ,/oic7 indig5ce4 ,f su* def9itions x w\ld foll[ t we are n ! pr9ciple ( evil1 & are n evil 9 ourselves1 = ^! evils exi/$ be=e u4 ,only 9 spite ( !mselves w\ld m5 yield to vice4 ,! evils ( ! s\l are avoidable1 b n all m5 possess ! necess>y firmness4 ,evil1 !re=e1 is caus$ by ! pres5ce ( matt] 9 s5se-objects1 & is n id5tical ) ! wick$ness ( m54 ,= wick$ness does n exi/ 9 all m52 "s triumph ov] wick$ness1 :ile !y :o d n ev5 ne$ to triumph ov] x1 are /ill bett]4 ,9 all cases m5 triumph ov] evil by ^? ( _! faculties t are n engag$ 9 matt]4 ,,9 ,,:at ,,s5se ,,evils ,,are ,,univ]sal ,,& ,,unavoidable4 #f4 ,let u exam9e ! significance ( ! doctr9e#agd t evils _c be de/roy$1 t !y are necess>y1 t !y d n exi/ among ! div9ities1 b t !y ev] besiege our mortal nature1 & ! place 9 :i* we dwell4#age ,surely heav5 is free f all evil because x moves et]nally ) regul>ity1 9 p]fect ord]2 because 9 ! />s is nei!r inju/ice nor any o!r k9d ( evil1 because !y d n conflict ) ea* o!r 9 _! c\rses2 & because _! revolutions are presid$ ov] by ! mo/ beautiful h>mony4#afd ,on ! contr>y1 ! e>? reveals inju/ice & disord]1 7*iefly7 because our nature is mortal1 & we dwell 9 a l[] place4 ,b :5 ,plato1#agf says1 t we mu/ flee f "h bel[1 he does n mean t we %\ld leave ! e>?1 b1 :ile rema9+ !re91 practice ju/ice1 piety1 & wisdom4 ,x is wick$ness t mu/ be fl$ f1 because wick$ness & its consequ5ces are ! evil ( man4 ,,evil ,,is ,,n ,,good',s ,,qualitative1 ,,b ,,only ,,figurative ,,antagoni/4 ,:5#agf 7,!odor7 tells 7,socrates7 t evils w\ld be annihilat$ if m5 practis$ 7,socrates'7 tea*+s1 ! latt] answ]s t t is impossible1 = evil is necess>y ev5 if only z ! contr>y ( good4 ,b h[ !n c wick$ness1 :i* is ! evil ( man1 be ! contr>y ( good8 ,because x is ! contr>y ( virtue4 ,n[ virtue1 )\t be+ ,good 9 itself1 is /ill a good1 a good :i* makes u dom9ate matt]4 ,b h[ c ,good 9 itself1 :i* is n a quality1 h a contr>y8 ,besides1 :y ne$ ! exi/5ce ( "o ?+ imply its contr>y8 ,?\gh we may grant t !re is a possibility ( ! exi/5ce ( ! contr>y ( "s ?+s--z = in/ance1 t a man 9 good heal? might become sick--!re is no su* necessity4 ,nor does ,plato ass]t t ! exi/5ce ( ea* ?+ ( ?is k9d necess>ily implies t ( its contr>y2 he makes ?is /atem5t exclusively ( ! ,good4 ,b h[ c !re be a contr>y to good1 if ! good be be+1 let alone above be+8#agg ,evid5tly1 9 ref]5ce to p>ticul> be+s1 !re c be no?+ contr>y to be+4 ,?is is prov$ by induction2 b ! proposition has n be5 demon/rat$ z reg>ds univ]sal ,be+4 ,:at !n is ! contr>y ( univ]sal ,be+1 & fir/ pr9ciples 9 g5]al8 ,! contr>y ( be+ mu/ be non5tity2 ! contr>y ( ! nature ( ! ,good is ! nature & pr9ciple ( ,evil4 ,^! two natures are inde$ respectively ! pr9ciples ( goods & ( evils4 ,all _! elem5ts are mutually oppos$1 s t bo? ^! natures1 consid]$ 9 _! totality1 are /ill m oppos$ ?an ! o!r contr>ies4 ,! latt]1 inde$1 belong to ! same =m1 to ! same k9d1 & !y h some?+ 9 common 9 :atev] subjects !y may be4 ,z to ! ,contr>ies t are ess5tially di/+ui%$ f ea* o!r1 ^: nature is con/itut$ ( elem5ts oppos$ to ! con/itutive elem5ts ( ! o!r1 ^? ,contr>ies are absolutely oppos$ to ea* o!r1 s9ce ! connotation ( t ^w implies ?+s z opposite to ea* o!r z possible4 ,measure1 det]m9ation1 & ! o!r *>act]i/ics ( ! div9e nature#agh are ! opposites ( incomm5surability1 indef9it5ess1 & ! o!r contr>y ?+s t con/itute ! nature ( evil4 ,ea* "o ( ^! :oles1 !re=e1 is ! contr>y ( ! o!r4 ,! be+ ( ! "o is t :i* is ess5tially & absolutely false2 t ( ! o!r is g5u9e ,be+2 ! fals5ess ( ! "o is1 !re=e1 ! contr>y ( ! tru? ( ! o!r4 ,likewise :at p]ta9s to ! be+ ( ! "o is ! contr>y ( :at belongs to ! be+ ( ! o!r4 ,we also see t x is n always true to say t !re is no contr>y to be+1 = we ackn[l$ge t wat] & fire are contr>ies1 ev5 if !y did n conta9 ! common elem5t ( matt]1 ( :i* heat & cold1 humidity & dryness1 are accid5ts4 ,if !y exi/$ alone by !mselves1 if _! be+ 7 complete )\t any common subject1 !re w\ld /ill be an opposition1 & an opposition ( be+4 ,!re=e ! ?+s t are completely sep>ate1 :i* h no?+ 9 common1 :i* are z di/ant z possible1 are by nature contr>y4 ,?is is n an opposition ( quality1 nor ( any k9ds ( be+s2 x is an opposition result+ f extreme di/ance1 & f be+ compos$ ( contr>ies1 !reby communicat+ ?is *>act]i/ic to _! elem5ts4 ,,good ,,implies ,,evil ,,because ,,matt] ,,is ,,necess>y ,,to ,,! ,,_w4 #g4 ,:y is ! exi/5ce ( bo? good & evil necess>y8 ,because matt] is necess>y to ! exi/5ce ( ! _w4 ,! latt] is necess>ily compos$ ( contr>ies1 &1 consequ5tly1 x c\ld n exi/ )\t matt]4 ,9 ?is case ! nature ( ?is _w is a mixture ( intellig5ce & necessity4#agi ,:at x receives f div9ity are goods2 its evils d]ive f ! primordial nature1#ahj ! t]m us$ 7by ,plato7 to designate matt] z a simple sub/ance yet unadorn$ by a div9ity4 ,b :at does he mean by mortal nature8 ,:5 he says t evils besiege ?is region "h bel[1 he means ! univ]se1 z appe>s f ! foll[+ quotations#aha3 ,s9ce y are born1 y are n immortal1 b by my help y %all n p]i%4 ,9 ?is case x is "r to say t evils _c be annihilat$4 ,h[ !n c "o flee f !m8#ahb ,n by *ang+ "o's locality1 7z ,plato7 says1 b by acquir+ virtue1 & by sep>at+ f ! body1 :i*1 simultane\sly1 is sep>ation f matt]2 = be+ atta*$ to ! body is also atta*m5t to matt]4 ,x is 9 ! same s5se t 7,plato7 expla9s be+ sep>at$ f ! body1 or n be+ sep>at$ f x4 ,by dwell+ ) ! div9ities he means be+ unit$ to ! intelligible objects2 = x is 9 !m t inh]es immortality4 ,,exi/5ce ,,( ,,evil ,,is ,,necess>y ,,z ,,la/ ,,mat]ial ,,degree ,,( ,,be+4 ,"h foll[s /ill ano!r demon/ration ( ! necessity ( evil4 ,s9ce good does n rema9 alone1 evil mu/ necess>ily exi/ by issu+ f ! good4#ahc ,we might express ?is diff]5tly1 z ! degradation & exhau/ion 7( ! div9e p[]1 :i*1 9 ! :ole hi]>*ic s]ies ( successive emanations weak5s f degree to degree74 ,!re mu/1 !re=e1 be a la/ degree ( be+1 beyond :i* no?+ fur!r c be begott51 & t is evil4 ,j z ! exi/5ce ( some?+ aft] a fir/ 7,good7 is necess>y1 s mu/ also a la/ degree 7( be+7 be necess>y4 ,n[ ! la/ degree is matt]1 & conta9s no?+ m ( ! ,fir/2 7&1 z matt] & evil are id5tical17 ! exi/5ce ( evil is necess>y4 ,,matt] ,,is ,,cause ,,( ,,evil1 ,,ev5 ,,if ,,corporeal4 #h4 ,x may /ill be object$ t x is n matt] t makes u wick$2 = x is n matt] t produces ignorance & p]v]t$ appetites4 ,if1 inde$1 ^! appetites mislead u to evil z a result ( ! p]v]sity ( ! body1 we mu/ seek its cause1 n 9 matt]1 b 9 =m 79 ! qualities ( ! bodies74 ,^!1 = in/ance1 are heat1 cold1 bitt]ness1 pung5cy1 & ! o!r qualities ( ! bodily secretions2 or1 ! atonic condition or inflammation ( c]ta9 organs2 or1 c]ta9 dispositions :i* produce ! diff]5ce ( appetites2 &1 if y please1 false op9ions4 ,evil1 !re=e1 is =m r ?an matt]4 ,ev5 "u ?is 7mi/ak57 hypo!sis we are none ! less driv5 to ackn[l$ge t matt] is ! evil4 ,a quality does n always produce ! same results )9 or outside ( matt]2 ?us ! =m ( ! axe )\t iron does n cut4 ,! =ms t inh]e 9 matt] are n always :at !y w\ld be if !y 7 outside ( x4 ,! 7sem9al7 reasons :5 inh]+ 9 matt] are by x corrupt$ & fill$ ) its nature4 ,z fire1 :5 sep>ate f matt]1 does n burn2 s =m1 :5 rema9+ by itself1 effects :at x w\ld if x 7 9 matt]4 ,matt] dom9ates any pr9ciple t appe>s )9 x1 alt]s x1 & corrupts x by imp>t+ !reto its own nature1 :i* is contr>y to ! ,good4 ,x does n inde$ sub/itute cold = heat1 b x adds to ! =m--z1 = in/ance1 to ! =m ( fire--its =mless sub/ance2 to figure add+ its %apelessness2 to measure1 its excess & lack1 proce$+ ?us until x has degrad$ ?+s1 transub/antiat+ !m into its own nature4 ,t is ! reason t1 9 ! nutrition ( animals1 :at has be5 +e/$ does n rema9 :at x 0 be=e4 ,! foods t ent] into ! body ( a dog1 = in/ance1 are by assimilation trans=m$ into blood & can9e secretions1 &1 9 g5]al1 are trans=m$ accord+ to ! animal t receives !m4 ,?us ev5 "u ! hypo!sis t evils are ref]r$ to ! body1 matt] is ! cause ( evils4 ,,ma/]y ,,( ,,^! ,,corporeal ,,dispositions ,,is ,,n ,,easy4 ,x may be object$ t "o ought to ma/] ^! dispositions ( ! body4 ,b ! pr9ciple t c\ld triumph ov] !m is pure only if x flee f "h bel[4 ,! appetites :i* ex]cise ! greate/ =ce come f a c]ta9 complexion ( ! body1 & diff] accord+ to its nature4 ,consequ5tly1 x is n easy to ma/] !m4 ,!re are m5 :o h no judgm5t1 because !y are cold & heavy on acc\nt ( _! bad con/itution4 ,on ! contr>y1 !re are o!rs :o1 because ( _! temp]am5t1 are light & incon/ant4 ,?is is prov$ by ! diff]5ce ( our own successive dispositions4 ,:5 we are gorg$1 we h appetites & ?\ghts t diff] f ^? we exp]i5ce :5 />v$2 & our dispositions v>y ev5 accord+ to ! degrees ( satiety4 ,,def9ition ,,( ,,prim>y ,,& ,,second>y ,,evil4 ,9 %ort1 ! prim>y ,evil is t :i* by itself lacks measure4 ,! second>y evil is t :i* accid5tally becomes =mless1 ei!r by assimilation or p>ticipation4 ,9 ! front rank is ! d>kness2 9 ! second t :i* has become obscur$4 ,?us vice1 be+ 9 ! s\l ! result ( ignorance & =mlessness1 is ( second>y rank4 ,x is n absolute ,evil1 because1 on its side1 virtue is n absolute ,good2 x is good only by its assimilation & p>ticipation ) ! ,good4 ,b4 ,,by ,,:at ,,"p ,,( ,,our ,,nature ,,we ,,come ,,to ,,"k ,,evil4 ,,h[ ,,! ,,s\l ,,comes ,,to ,,"k ,,vice4#ahd #i4 ,h[ d we get to "k vice & virtue8 ,z to virtue1 we "k x by ! v intellig5ce & by wisdom2 = wisdom kn[s itself4 ,b h[ c we "k vice8 ,j z we obs]ve t an object is n 9 itself /raight1 by apply+ a rule1 s we disc]n vice by ?is *>act]i/ic1 t x does n comport itself ) virtue4 ,b d we1 or d we n h direct intuition !re(8 ,we d n h ! intuition ( absolute vice1 because x is indet]m9ate4 ,we "k x1 !re=e1 by a k9d ( ab/raction1 obs]v+ t virtue is entirely lack+4 ,we cognize relative vice by notic+ t x lacks "s "p ( virtue4 ,we see a "p ( virtue1 &1 by ?is "p1 judg+ :at is lack+ 9 ord] completely to con/itute ! =m 7( virtue71 we call vice :at is lack+ to x2 def9+ z ! indet]m9ate 7evil7 :at is depriv$ ( virtue4 ,simil>ly ) matt]4 ,if1 = in/ance1 we notice a figure t is ugly because its 7sem9al7 reason1 be+ unable to dom9ate matt]1 has be5 unable to hide its de=mity1 we notice ugl9ess by :at is lack+ to =m4 ,,h[ ,,to ,,see ,,matt]3 ,,by ,,dialectic ,,ab/raction4 ,b h[ d we "k t :i* is absolutely =mless 7matt]78 ,we make ab/raction ( all k9ds ( =m1 & :at rema9s we call matt]4 ,we all[ ourselves to be p5etrat$ by a k9d ( %apelessness by ! m]e fact t we make ab/raction ( all %ape 9 ord] to be able to repres5t matt] 7by a ba/>d reason+74#ahe ,consequ5tly1 intellig5ce becomes alt]$1 & ceases to be g5u9e intellig5ce :5 x d>es 9 ?is way to look at :at does n belong to its doma94#ahf ,x resembles ! eye1 :i* )draws f light to see d>kness1 & :i* on t v acc\nt does n see4 ,?us1 9 n see+1 ! eye sees d>kness s f> z x is naturally capable ( see+ x4 ,?us intellig5ce :i* hides light )9 itself1 & :i*1 s to speak1 issues f itself1 by advanc+ t[>ds ?+s ali5 to its nature1 )\t br++ along its own light1 places itself 9 a /ate contr>y to its be+ to cognize a nature contr>y to its own4#afe ,b en\gh ( ?is4 ,,matt] ,,is ,,bo? ,,)\t ,,qualities ,,& ,,evil4 #aj4 ,x may well be ask$ 7by ,/oics7 h[ matt] c be evil1 z x is )\t quality8#ahg ,t matt] possesses no qualities c be said 9 ! s5se t by itself x has none ( ! qualities x is to receive1 or to :i* matt] is to s]ve z sub/rate2 b _c be said 9 ! s5se t x w possess no nature4 ,n[1 if x h a nature1 :at h9d]s ?is nature f be+ bad1 )\t ?is be+ bad be+ a quality8 ,no?+ inde$ is a quality b :at s]ves to qualify some?+ diff]5t f itself2 a quality is1 !re=e1 an accid5t2 a quality is t :i* c be m5tion$ z ! attribute ( a subject o!r ?an itself4#ahh ,b matt] is n ! attribute ( some?+ ali52 x is ! subject to :i* accid5ts are relat$4 ,!re=e1 s9ce e quality is an accid5t1 matt]1 ^: nature is n to be an accid5t1 is )\t quality4#ahi ,if1 besides1 quality 7tak5 9 g5]al71 itself be )\t quality1 h[ c\ld "o say ( matt]1 s f> z x has n yet receiv$ any quality1 t x is 9 "s mann] qualifi$8 ,x is1 !re=e1 possible to ass]t ( matt] t1 x bo? has no quality1 & yet is evil4 ,matt] is n evil because x has a quality1 b j because x has none4 ,if1 inde$1 matt] possess$ a =m1 x might inde$ be bad2 b x w\ld n be a nature contr>y to all =m4 ,,matt] ,,z ,,deprivation ,,is ,,/ill ,,)\t ,,qualities4 #aa4 ,x may be fur!r object$ t nature1 indep5d5t ( all =m1 is deprivation4 ,n[ deprivation is always ! attribute ( "s hypo/atic sub/ance1 in/ead ( itself be+ sub/ance4 ,if !n evil consi/ 9 privation1 x is ! attribute ( ! sub/rate depriv$ ( =m2 & on t acc\nt x c\ld n exi/ by itself4 ,if x be 9 ! s\l t we consid] evil1 privation 9 ! s\l w con/itute vice & wick$ness1 & !re w be no ne$ to h rec\rse to any?+ ext]nal to expla9 x4 ,,matt] ,,may ,,exi/ ,,& ,,yet ,,be ,,evil4 ,else:]e#aij x is object$ t matt] does n exi/2 "h ! attempt is to %[ t matt] is n evil 9 s f> z x exi/s4 7,if ?is 7 ! case71 we %\ld n seek ! orig9 ( evil outside ( ! s\l1 b x w\ld be locat$ )9 ! s\l h]self2 !re evil consi/s 9 ! abs5ce ( good4 ,b1 evid5tly1 ! s\l w\ld h no?+ good on ! hypo!sis t privation ( =m is an accid5t ( ! be+1 :i* desires to receive =m2 t1 consequ5tly1 ! privation ( good is an accid5t ( ! s\l2 & t ! latt] produces )9 h]self wick$ness by h] 7sem9al7 reason4 ,ano!r result w\ld be t ! s\l w\ld h no life1 & be inanimate2 :i* w\ld lead to ! absurdity t ! s\l is no s\l4 ,,! ,,s\l ,,_c ,,possess ,,evil ,,)9 ,,h]self4 ,we are ?us =c$ to ass]t1 t ! s\l possesses life by virtue ( h] 7sem9al7 reason1 s t %e does n1 by h]self1 possess privation ( good4 ,!n %e mu/ f intellig5ce d]ive a trace ( good1 & h ! =m ( good4 ,! s\l1 !re=e1 _c by h]self be evil4 ,consequ5tly1 %e is n ! fir/ ,evil1 nor does %e conta9 x z an accid5t1 s9ce %e is n absolutely depriv$ ( good4 ,,relative ,,privation ,,is ,,impossible4 #ab4 ,to ! objection t 9 ! s\l wick$ness & evil are n an absolute privation1 b only a relative privation ( good1 x may be answ]$ t 9 ?is case1 if ! s\l simultane\sly1 conta9 possession & privation ( ! good1 %e w h possess$ a feel+ m+l$ ( good & evil1 & n ( unm+l$ evil4 ,we w /ill n h f\nd ! fir/ evil1 ! absolute ,evil4 ,! good ( ! s\l w reside 9 h] ess5ce 7be+72 evil w only be an accid5t !re(4 ,,evil ,,z ,,an ,,ob/acle ,,to ,,! ,,s\l4 #ac4 ,ano!r hypo!sis is t evil owes its "* only to its be+ an ob/acle = ! s\l1 z c]ta9 objects are bad = ! eye1 because !y h9d] x f see+4 ,9 ?is case1 ! evil ( ! s\l w\ld be ! cause t produces ! evil1 & x w\ld produce x )\t be+ absolute ,evil4 ,if1 !n1 vice be an ob/acle = ! s\l1 x w n be absolute ,evil1 b ! cause ( evil1 z virtue is n ! good1 & only contributes to acquir+ x4 ,if virtue be n good1 & vice be n evil1 ! result is t s9ce virtue is nei!r absolute beauty nor goodness1 vice is nei!r absolute ugl9ess nor evil4 ,we hold t virtue is nei!r absolute beauty1 nor absolute goodness1 because above & be=e x is absolute ,beauty & ,goodness4 ,only because ! s\l p>ticipates 9 ^!1 is virtue or beauty consid]$ a good4 ,n[ z ! s\l1 by ris+ above virtue1 meets absolute ,beauty & ,goodness1 ?us 9 desc5d+ bel[ wick$ness ! s\l discov]s absolute ,evil4 ,to arrive at ! intuition ( evil ! s\l1 !re=e1 />ts f wick$ness1 if inde$ an intuition ( evil be at all possible4 ,f9ally1 :5 ! s\l desc5ds1 %e p>ticipates 9 evil4 ,%e ru%es completely into ! region ( div]sity1#aia &1 plung+ d[nw>ds %e falls into a murky mire4 ,if %e fell into absolute wick$ness1 h] *>act]i/ic w\ld no long] be wick$ness1 & %e w\ld ex*ange x = a /ill l[] nature4 ,ev5 ?\gh m+l$ ) a contr>y nature1 wick$ness1 inde$1 /ill reta9s some?+ human4 ,! vici\s man1 !re=e1 dies s f> z a s\l c die4 ,n[ :51 9 connection ) ! s\l1 we speak ( dy+1 we mean t :ile %e is engag$ 9 ! body1 %e p5etrates 7fur!r7 into matt]1 & becomes saturat$ ) x4 ,!n1 :5 ! s\l has left ! body1 %e once m falls into ! same mud until %e h manag$ to return into ! intelligible _w1 & wean$ h] glance f ?is mire4 ,s long z %e rema9s !re91 %e may be said to h desc5d$ into hell1 & to be slumb]+ !re4#aib ,,weakness ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,z ,,an ,,explanation ,,( ,,evil4 #ad4 ,wick$ness is by "s expla9$ z weakness ( ! s\l1 because ! wick$ s\l is impressionable1 mobile1 easy to lead to evil1 dispos$ to li/5 to h] passions1 & equally likely to become angry1 & to be reconcil$2 %e yields inconsid]ately to va9 ideas1 l ! weake/ works ( art & ( nature1 :i* are easily de/roy$ by w9ds & /orms4 ,?is !ory 7is attractive1 b implies a totally new conception1 t ( weakness ( s\l1 & x w\ld h7 to expla9 ?is weakness1 & :5ce x is d]iv$2 = weakness 9 a s\l is v diff]5t f weakness 9 a body1 b j z 9 ! body weakness consi/s 9 inability to fulfil a function1 9 be+ too impressionable1 ! same fault 9 ! s\l might1 by analogy1 be call$ by ! same "n1 unless matt] be equally ! cause ( bo? weaknesses4 ,reason1 h[ev]1 w h to explore ! problem fur!r1 & seek ! cause ( ! s\l-fault "h call$ weakness4 ,,weakness ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,occurs ,,*iefly ,,9 ,,s\ls ,,fall5 ,,into ,,matt]4 ,9 ! s\l weakness does n d]ive f an excess ( d5sity or r>efaction ( leanness or /\tness1 nor ( any sickness su* z fev]4 ,x mu/ be met 9 s\ls :i* are ei!r entirely sep>at$ f matt]1 or 9 ^? jo9$ to matt]1 or 9 bo? simultane\sly4 ,n[1 z x does n occur 9 s\ls sep>at$ f matt]1 :i* are entirely pure1 & w+$1#aic & :i*1 z p]fect1 c>ry out _! functions )\t any ob/acle2 x rema9s1 t ?is weakness occurs 9 fall5 s\ls1 :i* are nei!r pure nor purifi$4 ,= !m weakness consi/s n 9 ! privation ( any?+1 b 9 ! pres5ce ( some?+ ali51 j z1 = in/ance1 weakness ( ! body consi/s 9 ! pres5ce ( slime or bile4 ,we %all1 !re=e1 be able to und]/& cle>ly ! weakness ( ! s\l by f]ret+ out ! cause ( ! fall ( ! s\l4 ,,! ,,fall ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,z ,,desc5t ,,into ,,matt]4 ,j z mu* z ! s\l1 matt] is includ$ )9 ! ord] ( be+s4 ,= bo?1 s to speak1 !re is b a s+le locality2 = x w\ld be an error to imag9e two diff]5t localities1 "o = matt]1 & ! o!r = ! s\l2 su* z1 = in/ance1 e>? might be = matt]1 & air = ! s\l4 ,! expression t s\l occupies a locality diff]5t f matt] means only t ! s\l is n 9 matt]2 t is1 t ! s\l is n unit$ to matt]2 t ! s\l does n toge!r ) matt] con/itute some?+ unit>y2 & t = ! s\l matt] is n a sub/rate t c\ld conta9 ! s\l4 ,t is h[ ! s\l is sep>at$ f matt]4 ,b ! s\l possesses sev]al p[]s1 s9ce %e conta9s ! pr9ciple 7intellig5ce71 ! m$ium 7! discursive reason71 & ! goal 7! p[] ( s5sation7 7unit$ to ! g5]ative & gr[+ p[]s74 ,n[1 j l ! begg> :o pres5ts himself at ! door ( ! banquet-hall1 & ) importunity asks to be admitt$1#aid matt] tries to p5etrate into ! place occupi$ by ! s\l4 ,b e place is sacr$1 because no?+ 9 x is depriv$ ( ! pres5ce ( ! s\l4 ,matt]1 on expos+ itself to its rays is illum9at$ by x1 b x _c h>bor ! pr9ciple t illum9ates h] 7! s\l74 ,! latt] inde$1 does n su/a9 matt]1#aie al?\gh %e be pres5t1 & does n ev5 see x1 because x is evil4 ,matt] obscures1 weak5s ! light t %9es d[n ^u h]1 by m+l+ its d>kness ) h]4 ,to ! s\l1 matt] af=ds ! opportunity ( produc+ g5]ation1 by cle>+ free access t[>ds matt]2 = if matt] 7 n pres5t1 ! s\l w\ld n approa* x4 ,! fall ( ! s\l is1 !re=e1 a desc5t into matt]2 h5ce comes h] weakness1 :i* means1 t n all ( ! s\l's faculties are ex]cis$2 because matt] h9d]s _! action1 intrud+ on ! place occupi$ by ! s\l & =c+ h]1 s to speak1 to retr5*4 ,until ! s\l c manage to accompli% h] return into ! intelligible _w1 matt] degrades :at x has succe$$ 9 ab/ract+ f ! s\l4 ,= ! s\l1 !re=e1 matt] is a cause ( weakness & vice4 ,!re=e1 by h]self1 ! s\l is primitively evil1 & is ! fir/ evil4 ,by its pres5ce1 matt] is ! cause ( ! s\l's ex]t+ h] g5]ative p[]s1 & be+ ?us l$ to suff]+2 x is matt] t causes ! s\l to ent] into deal+s ) matt]1 & ?us to become evil4 ,! s\l1 inde$1 w\ld nev] h approa*$ matt] unless ! latt]'s pres5ce _h n af=d$ ! s\l an opportunity to produce g5]ation4 ,,no ,,m ,,?an ,,! ,,exi/5ce ,,( ,,! ,,good ,,c ,,t ,,( ,,matt] ,,be ,,d5i$4 #ae4 ,^? :o claim t matt] does n exi/1 w h to be ref]r$ to our ext5d$ discussion#aif :]e we h demon/rat$ ! necessity ( its hypo/atic exi/5ce4 ,^? :o w\ld ass]t t evil does n belong among be+s w\ld1 if logical1 !reby also d5y ! exi/5ce ( ! good1 & ( any?+ t 0 desirable2 !reby annihilat+ desire1 z well z av]sion1 & ev5 ?\ght2 = ev]ybody %>es desire = ! good1 & av]sion = ! evil4 ,?\ght & k1 simultane\sly1 apply to good & evil2 ?\ght itself is a good4 ,,explanation ,,( ,,! ,,evil ,,( ,,! ,,s\l4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 ackn[l$ge ! exi/5ce fir/ ( ,good1 unmix$1 & !n ! nature m+l$ ( good & evil2 b :at mo/ p>ticipates 9 evil !reby tr5ds t[>ds absolute ,evil2 & :at p>ticipates 9 x to a less degree !reby tr5ds t[>ds good4 ,= :at is evil to s\l8 ,x is be+ 9 contact ) inf]ior nature2 o!rwise ! s\l w\ld n h any appetite1 pa91 or fe>4 ,inde$ fe> is felt by u only = ! composite 7( s\l & body71 fe>+ its dissolution1 :i* ?us is ! cause ( our pa9s & suff]+s4 ,! end ( e appetite is to put aside :at tr\bles x1 or to =e/all :at might d s4 ,z to s5se-repres5tations 7fancy#aig71 x is ! impression made by an ext]ior object on ! irrational "p ( ! s\l1 a "p :i* c receive ?is impression only because x is n indivisible4 ,false op9ion rises )9 ! s\l because x is no long] )9 tru?1 & ?is occurs because ! s\l is no long] pure4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! desire ( ! intelligible leads ! s\l to unite intimately ) intellig5ce1 z %e %\ld1 & !re rema9 solidly entr5*$1 )\t decl9+ t[>ds any?+ inf]ior4 ,x is only because ( ! nature & p[] ( ! ,good t evil does n rema9 pure ,evil4 7,matt]1 :i* is synonym\s ) evil7 is l a captive :i* beauty cov]s ) gold5 *a9s1 s t ! div9ities might n see its nak$ness1 & t m5 might n be intrud$ on by x2 or t m51 if !y mu/ see x1 %all be rem9d$ ( beauty on obs]v+ an ev5 weak5$ image !re(4 ,,second ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,?ree4 ,:e!r ,a/rology is ( any ,value4#aih ,,( ,,! ,,influ5ce ,,( ,,! ,,/>s4 #a4 ,x has be5 said#aii t ! c\rse ( ! />s indicates :at is to happ5 to ea* be+2 ?\gh1 x does n1 z _m p]sons ?9k1 cause e ev5t4 ,to ! support+ pro(s h]e( we are to add n[ m precise demon/rations1 & new consid]ations1 = ! op9ion held ab\t ?is matt] is no trifle4 ,,v>i\s ,,pret5sions ,,( ,,a/rology4 ,"s p hold t1 by _! movem5ts1 ! planets produce n only pov]ty & weal?1 heal? & sickness1 b ev5 beauty & ugl9ess2 &1 :at is m1 vices & virtues4 ,at e mom5t ! />s1 z if !y 7 irritat$ aga9/ m51 7are said to7 =ce !m to commit actions conc]n+ :i* no blame atta*es to ! m5 :o commit !m1 s9ce !y are compell$ !reto by ! influ5ce ( ! planets4 ,x is ev5 believ$ t ! cause ( ! planets' do+ u evil or good is n t !y love or hate u2 b t _! dispositions t[>ds u is good or evil accord+ to ! localities ?r\gh :i* !y travel4 ,t[>ds u !y *ange _! disposition accord+ z !y are on ! c>d9al po9ts or 9 decl9ation !refrom4 ,x is ev5 held t :ile c]ta9 />s are malefic5t1 o!rs are b5efic5t1 & t1 nev]!less1 ! =m] frequ5tly grant u b5efits1 :ile ! latt] (t5 become h>mful4 ,_! effects diff] accord+ to _! be+ 9 opposition1#bjj j z if !y 7 n self-suffici5t1 & z if _! quality dep5d$ on :e!r or n !y look$ at ea* o!r4 ,?us a />'s 7influ5ce7 may be good s long z x reg>ds ano!r1 & evil :5 x does s no long]4 ,a /> may ev5 consid] ano!r 9 diff]5t mann]s1#bja :5 x is 9 su* or su* an aspect4#bjb ,moreov]1 ! totality ( ! />s ex]cises a m+l$ influ5ce :i* diff]s f ! individual influ5ces1 j z sev]al liquors may =m a comp\nd possess+ qualities diff]+ f ei!r ( ! compon5t elem5ts4 ,z ^! & simil> ass]tions are freely made1 x becomes important to exam9e ea* "o sep>ately4 ,?is w\ld =m a prop] beg9n+ = our inve/igation4 ,,are ,,/>s ,,inanimate8 #b4 ,%\ld we consid] ! />s to be animat$1 or n8 ,if !y be inanimate1 !y w be able to communicate only cold & heat2 t is1 if#bjc we grant ! exi/5ce ( cold influ5ces4 ,9 ?is case1 !y w limit !mselves to modify+ ! nature ( our body1 ex]cis+ on u a m]ely corporeal influ5ce4 ,!y w n produce a great div]sity among ! bodies1 s9ce ea* ( !m ex]cises ! same influ5ce1 & s9ce1 on ! e>?1 _! div]se actions are bl5d$ into a s+le "o1 :i* v>ies only by ! div]sity ( locality1 or by ! proximity or di/ance ( ! objects4 ,! same argum5t w\ld hold on ! hypo!sis t ! />s spread cold4 ,b ,i c\ld n und]/& h[ !y c\ld r5d] "s le>n$1 o!rs ignorant1 mak+ ( "s gramm>ians1 o!rs orators1 musicians or exp]ts 9 v>i\s arts4 ,h[ c\ld !y ex]cise an action :i* w\ld h no relation to ! con/itution ( ! bodies1 su* z giv+ u a fa!r1 a bro!r1 a son1 or a wife ( su* or su* *>act]i/ics1 or to make u successful1 or make ( u g5]als or k+s8#bjd ,,are ,,/>s ,,animat$8 ,on ! contr>y hypo!sis1 t ! />s are animat$1 & act ) reflection1 :at h we done to !m t !y %\ld desire to h>m u8 ,are !y n dwell]s ( a div9e region8 ,are !y n !mselves div9e8 ,nor are !y subject$ to ! influ5ces t make m5 good or evil1 nor c\ld !y exp]i5ce good or evil z a result ( our prosp]ity or our mis=tunes4 ,,c\ld ,,c>d9al ,,po9ts ,,or ,,decl9ations ,,possess ,,any ,,influ5ce8 #c4 ,9 case1 h[ev]1 t ! />s injure u only involunt>ily1 !y are con/ra9$ !reunto by ! aspects1#bje & _! localities4 ,if s1 !y %\ld1 all ( !m1 produce ! same effects :5 !y f9d !mselves 9 ! same localities or aspects4 ,b :at diff]5ce c occur 9 a planet accord+ to its location 9 ! zodiac8 ,:at does ! zodiac itself exp]i5ce8 ,9 fact1 ! planets are n locat$ 9 ! zodiac itself1 b above or bel[ x1 at great di/ances4 ,besides1 9 :atev] location !y are1 !y all are ev] 9 ! heav54 ,n[ x w\ld be ridicul\s to pret5d t _! effects diff]$ accord+ to _! location 9 ! heav51 & t !y h an action diff]+ accord+ z !y rise1 culm9ate1 or decl9e4 ,x w\ld be incr$ible t su* a planet w\ld feel joy :5 x culm9ates1 sadness or feebl5ess :5 decl9+1 ang] at ! ris+ ( "s o!r planet1 or satisfaction at ! latt]'s sett+4 ,c a /> be bett] :5 x decl9es8 ,n[ a /> culm9ates = "s simultane\sly ) its decl9ation = o!rs2 & x c\ld n at ! same "t exp]i5ce joy & sadness1 ang] & b5evol5ce4 ,x is %e] absurdity to ass]t t a /> feels joy at its ris+1 :ile ano!r feels ! same at its sett+2 = ?is w\ld really mean t ! />s felt simultane\s joy & sadness4 ,besides1 :y %\ld _! sadness injure u8 ,nor c we admit t !y are 9 turn joy\s & sad1 = !y ev] rema9 tranquil1 cont5t ) ! goods !y enjoy1 & ! objects ( _! contemplation4 ,ea* ( !m lives = itself1 f9d+ its welf>e 9 its own activity1 )\t ent]+ into relations ) u4 ,z !y h no deal+ ) u1 ! />s ex]t _! influ5ce on u only incid5tally1 n z _! *ief purpose2 r1 !y be> no relation :atev] to u2 !y ann\nce ! future only by co9cid5ce1 z birds ann\nce x to ! augurs4 ,,absurdity ,,( ,,aspects1 ,,& ,,h\ses4 #d4 ,nor is x any m reasonable to ass]t t ! aspect ( "o planet makes "o joy\s1 or ! o!r sad4 ,:at animosity c\ld obta9 betwixt ! />s8 ,:at c\ld be its reason8 ,:y %\ld _! condition be diff]5t :5 !y are 9 tr9e aspect1 or 9 opposition1 or 9 quadrature8 ,:at reason h we to suppose t "o /> reg>ds ! o!r :5 x is 9 "s p>ticul> aspect to x1 or t x no m reg>ds x :5 x is 9 ! next zodiacal sign1 ?\gh ?us really clos] to x8 ,besides1 :at is ! mann] 9 :i* ! planets ex]t ! influ5ce attribut$ to !m8 ,h[ does ea* ex]cise its own p>ticul> influ5ce8 ,h[ d !y all1 9 comb9ation1 ex]t an influ5ce t diff]s f ?is 7p>ticul> influ5ce78 ,9 fact1 !y d n hold delib]ations to c>ry out _! decisions on u1 ea* ( !m yield+ a little ( its individual influ5ce4 ,! "o does n viol5tly h9d] ! action ( ! o!r1 nor does x condesc5d+ly make concessions to x4 ,to say t ! "o is joy\s :5 x is 9 ! h\se ( ! o!r1 & t ! latt] is sad :5 x is 9 h\se ( ! =m]1 am\nts to say+ t two m5 are unit$ by mutual fri5d%ip1 ?\gh ! =m] love ! latt]1 :ile ! latt] hate ! =m]4 ,,! ,,relations ,,( ,,saturn ,,& ,,m>s ,,q ,,illogical4 #e4 ,! cold planet 7,saturn7 is said to be m b5efic5t = u :5 x is di/ant1 because ! evil t x produces on u is said to consi/ ( its cold efflu5ce2 9 :i* case our good %\ld consi/ 9 ! zodiacal signs opposite to u4 ,x is also ass]t$ t :5 ! cold planet 7,saturn7 is 9 opposition to ! w>m planet 7,m>s71 bo? become h>mful2 yet x w\ld seem t _! influ5ces %\ld neutralize ea* o!r4 ,besides1 x is held t 7,saturn7 likes ! day1 ^: heat r5d]s x favorable to m51 :ile 7,m>s7 likes ! night1 because x is fi]y1 z if 9 heav5 !re did n reign a p]petual day1 t is1 a cont9ual light2 or z if a /> c\ld be plung$ into ! %ad[ 7project$ by ! e>?7 :5 x is v di/ant f ! e>?4 ,,fabul\s ,,influ5ces ,,( ,,! ,,moon4 ,x is said t ! moon1 9 conjunction ) 7,saturn7 is favorable :5 full1 b h>mful :5 o!rwise4 ,! opposite1 h[ev]1 ought to be ! tru? if ! moon possess any influ5ce4 ,9 fact1 :5 x pres5ts a full face1 x pres5ts its d>k face to ! planet above x 7,saturn or ,m>s72 :5 its disk decreases on our side1 x increases on ! o!r2 !re=e1 x ought to ex]t a contr>y influ5ce :5 x decreases on our side1 & :5 x increases on ! side ( ! planet above x4 ,^! phases are ( no importance = ! moon1 inasmu* z "o ( its sides is always lit4 ,no?+ c result f x b = ! planet :i* receives heat f x 7,saturn72 n[ ?is "o w be heat$ :5ev] ! moon turns t[>ds u its d>k side4 ,!re=e1 ! moon is good = ?is planet :5 x is full t[>ds x1 b d>k t[>ds u4 ,besides1 ?is obscurity ( ! moon = u c be ( importance only = t]re/rial ?+s1 n = ! cele/ial#bjc 444 787#bjf 444 b if1 because ( its di/ance1 x does n support ! moon1 !n x mu/ be 9 a worse pr$icam5t2 :5 ! moon is full1 x is suffici5t = t]re/rial ?+s1 ev5 :5 ! moon is di/ant4444 ,f9ally1 :5 ! moon pres5ts its obscure side to ! fi]y planet 7,m>s71 x seems b5efic5t t[>ds u2 = ! p[] ( ?is planet1 m fi]y ?an 7,saturn71 is !n suffici5t by itself4 ,,jupit]1 ,,v5us1 ,,& ,,m]cury ,,also ,,consid]$ ,,a/rologically4 ,besides1 ! bodies ( ! animat$ be+s :i* move 9 ! heav5 may be ( diff]5t degrees ( heat2 none ( !m is cold1 z is witness$ to by _! location4 ,! planet nam$ ,jupit] is a suitable mixture ( fire2 likewise ) ,v5us4 ,t is :y !y seem to move h>moni\sly4 ,z to ! fi]y planet ,m>s1 x contributes its %>e to ! mixture 7( ! g5]al action ( ! />s74 ,z to ,saturn1 its case is diff]5t1 because ( its di/ance4 ,m]cury is indiff]5t1 because x assimilates itself easily to all4 ,,! ,,univ]se ,,z ,a ,,s+le ,,h>mony4#bjg ,all ^! planets contribute to ! ,:ole4 ,_! mutual relation1 !re=e1 is "o suitable to ! univ]se1 j z ! organs ( an animal are %ap$ to take "p 9 ! organism !y con/itute4#bjh ,take1 = in/ance1 a "p ( ! body1 su* z ! bile1 :i* s]ves bo? ! :ole animal t conta9s x1 & its special organ1 inasmu* z x 0 necess>y to ar\se c\rage1 & to oppose ! injury ( bo? ! :ole body1 & its special organ4 ,!re _h to be some?+ simil> 7to bile7 9 ! univ]se2 t some?+ sweet %\ld s(t5 x1 t !re be p>ts t w\ld play ! role ( eyes1 & t all ?+s %\ld possess mutual sympa?y by _! irrational life4#bji ,?us only is ! univ]se "o1 & ?us only is x con/itut$ by a s+le h>mony4 ,h[ !n c\ld x be d5i$ t all ^! ?+s might be signs1 result+ f ! laws ( analogy8 ,,absurdity ,,( ,,v>i\s ,,a/rological ,,!ories4 #f4 ,is x n unreasonable to ass]t t ,m>s1 or ,v5us1 9 a c]ta9 position1 %\ld produce adult]ies8 ,su* a /atem5t attributes to !m incont95ce su* z occurs only among man1 & human passion to satisfy unwor?y impulses4 ,or aga91 h[ c\ld we believe t ! aspects ( planets is favorable :5 !y reg>d ea* o!r 9 a c]ta9 mann]8 ,h[ c we avoid believ+ t _! nature is det]m9ate8 ,:at sort ( an exi/5ce w\ld be l$ by ! planets if !y occupi$ !mselves ) ea* s+le "o ( ! innum]able ev]-aris+ & pass+ be+s1 giv+ !m ea* glory1 weal?1 pov]ty1 or incont95ce1 & impell+ all _! actions8 ,h[ c\ld ! s+le planets effect s _m simultane\s results8 ,nor is x any m rational to suppose t ! planets' actions await ! asc5sions ( ! signs1 nor to say t ! asc5sion ( a sign conta9s z _m ye>s z !re are degrees ( asc5sion 9 x4 ,absurd also is ! !ory t ! planets calculate1 z x 7 on _! f+]s1 ! p]iod ( "t :5 !y are to accompli% some?+1 :i* be=e 0 =bidd54 ,besides1 x is an error n to trace to a s+le pr9ciple ! gov]nm5t ( ! univ]se1 attribut+ ev]y?+ to ! />s1 z if !re 7 n a s+le ,*ief f :i* dep5ds ! univ]se1 & :o di/ributes to e be+ a "p & functions suitable to its nature4 ,to fail to recognize ,him1 is to de/roy ! ord] ( :i* we =m a "p1 x is to ignore ! nature ( ! _w1 :i* presupposes a prim>y cause1 a pr9ciple by ^: activity ev]y?+ is int]p5etrat$4#baa ,,! ,,/>s ,,are ,,*ang+ ,,signs ,,betray+ ,,! ,,univ]sal ,,conspiracy ,,( ,,purpose4 #g4 ,9 fact1 we w\ld /ill h to ask ourselves = ! cause ( ! ev5ts 79 our _w7 ev5 if ! />s1 l _m o!r ?+s1 really progno/icat$ future ev5ts4 ,we w\ld /ill h to wond] at ! ma9t5ance ( ! ord] )\t :i* no ev5ts c\ld be prefigur$4 ,we might1 !re=e1 lik5 ! />s to lett]s1 at e mom5t flung along ! heav5s1 & :i*1 aft] hav+ be5 display$1 cont9u$ 9 ceaseless motion1 s t1 :ile ex]cis+ ano!r function 9 ! univ]se1 !y w\ld /ill possess significance4#bab ,?us 9 a be+ animat$ by a s+le pr9ciple x is possible to judge "o "p by ano!r2 z x is possible1 by ! /udy ( ! eyes or "s o!r organ ( an individual1 to conclude z to 8 *>act]s1 to ! dang]s to :i* he is expos$1 & h[ he may escape !m4 ,j z our memb]s are p>ts ( our bodies1 s are we ourselves p>ts ( ! univ]se4 ,?+s1 !re=e1 are made = ea* o!r4 ,ev]y?+ is significant1 & ! wise man c conclude f "o ?+ to ano!r4 ,inde$ _m habitual occurr5ces are =ese5 by m5 g5]ally4 ,9 ! univ]se ev]y?+ is r$uc$ to a s+le sy/em4#bac ,to ?is co-ord9ation is due ! possibility ( birds furni%+ u ) om5s1 & o!r animals furni%+ u ) presages4 ,all ?+s mutually dep5d f ea* o!r4 ,ev]y?+ conspires to a s+le purpose1#bad n only 9 ea* individual1 ^: p>ts are p]fectly relat$2 b also 9 ! univ]se1 & t 9 a high] degree1 & f> e>li]4 ,?is multiple be+ c\ld be turn$ into a s+le univ]sal ,liv+ organism only by a s+le pr9ciple4 ,z 9 ! human body e organ has its individual function1 likewise 9 ! univ]se ea* be+ plays its individual "p2 s mu* ! m t !y n only =m "p ( ! univ]se1 b t !y !mselves also =m univ]ses n )\t importance4#bae ,all ?+s1 !re=e1 proce$ f a s+le pr9ciple1 ea* plays its individual "p1 & l5ds ea* o!r mutual assi/ance4 ,nei!r are !y sep>ate f ! univ]se1 b !y act & react on ea* o!r1 ea* assi/+ or h9d]+ ! o!r4 ,b _! progress is n =tuit\s1 nor is x ! result ( *ance4 ,!y =m a s]ies1 :]e ea*1 by a natural bond1 is ! effect ( ! prec$+ "o1 & ! cause ( ! foll[+ "o4#baf ,,!re ,,is ,a ,,natural ,,law ,,:i* ,,directs ,,! ,,s\l4 #h4 ,:5 ! s\l applies h]self to c>ry out h] prop] function#bag--;= ! s\l effects ev]y?+1 z f> z %e plays ! "p ( a pr9ciple--%e foll[s ! /raight road2#bah :5 %e loses h] way#bai ! div9e ju/ice subjugates h] to ! physical ord] :i* reigns 9 ! univ]se1#bbj unless ! s\l succe$ 9 lib]at+ h]self4 ,! div9e ju/ice#bba reigns ev]1 because ! univ]se is direct$ by ! ord] & p[] ( ! dom9at+ pr9ciple 7! univ]sal ,s\l74#bbb ,to ?is is jo9$ ! co-op]ation ( ! planets :i* are important p>ts ( ! heav51 ei!r by embelli%+ x1 or by s]v+ z signs4 ,n[ !y s]ve z signs = all ?+s t occur 9 ! s5se-_w4 ,z to _! pot5cy1 !y %\ld be cr$it$ only ) :at !y effect indisputably4 ,,weal?1 ,,pov]ty1 ,,& ,,vices ,,are ,,! ,,result ,,( ,,ext]nal ,,circum/ances4 ,z to u1 we fill ! functions ( ! s\l 9 accordance ) nature :5 we d n /ray into ! multiplicity conta9$ 9 ! univ]se4 ,:5 we d /ray !re91 we are puni%$ = x bo? by ! /ray+ itself1 & by a less happy fate !reaft]4 ,weal? & pov]ty1 !re=e1 happ5 to u z effects ( ! op]ation ( ext]ior ?+s4 ,z to ! virtues & vices1 virtues are d]iv$ f ! primitive nature ( ! s\l1 :ile ! vices result f deal+s ( ! s\l ) ext]ior ?+s4 ,b ?is has be5 treat$ ( else:]e4#bbc ,,significance ,,( ,,! ,,sp9dle ,,( ,,! ,,fates4 #i4 ,?is br+s u to a consid]ation ( ! sp9dle1 :i*1 accord+ to ! anci5ts1 is turn$ by ! ,fates1 & by :i* ,plato signifies#bbd t :i*1 9 ! evolution ( ! _w1 moves1 & t :i* is immovable4 ,accord+ to 7,plato71 x is ! ,fates1 & _! "m ,necessity1 :i* turn ?is sp9dle1 & :i* impress x ) a rot>y motion 9 ! g5]ation ( ea* be+4 ,x is by ?is motion t begott5 be+s arrive at g5]ation4 ,9 ! ,timaeus#bbe ! 7,intellig5ce1 or7 div9ity :i* has creat$ ! univ]se gives ! 7immortal7 pr9ciple ( ! s\l1 7! reasonable s\l71 & ! deities :i* revolve 9 ! heav5 add 7to ! immortal pr9ciple ( ! s\l7 ! viol5t passions :i* subject u to ,necessity1 namely1 ang]s1 desires1 suff]+s1 & pleasures2 9 %ort1 !y furni% u ) t o!r k9d ( s\l 7! animal nature1 or vegetable s\l7 f :i* !y d]ive ^! passions4 ,plato ?us seems to subject u to ! />s1 by h9t+ t we receive f !m our s\ls1#bbg subord9at+ to ! sway ( ,necessity :5 we desc5d "h bel[1 bo? ourselves & our morals1 & ?r\gh ^!1 ! actions & passions#bbh :i* are d]iv$ f ! passional habit#bae ( ! s\l 7! animal nature74#bbi ,,:i* ,,( ,,our ,,two ,,s\ls ,,is ,,! ,,g5u9e ,,individuality8 ,our g5u9e selves are :at is ess5tially u2 we are ! pr9ciple to :i* ,nature has giv5 ! p[] to triumph ov] ! passions4 ,=1 if we be surr\nd$ by evils because ( ! body1 nev]!less1 ! div9ity has giv5 u virtue1 :i* kn[s ( no ma/]#bbc 7is n subject to any compulsion74 ,inde$ we ne$ virtue n s mu* :5 we are 9 a calm /ate1 b :5 its abs5ce exposes u to evils4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 flee f "h bel[2#bcj we mu/ divorce ourselves f ! body add$ to u 9 g5]ation1 & apply ourselves to ! ef=t to cease be+ ?is animal1 ?is composite 9 :i* ! pr$om9ant elem5t is ! nature ( ! body1 a nature :i* is only a trace ( ! s\l1 & :i* causes animal life#bca to p]ta9 *iefly to ! body4 ,inde$1 all t relates to ?is life is corporeal4 ,! o!r s\l 7! reasonable s\l1 :i* is sup]ior to ! vegetative s\l71 is n 9 ! body2 %e rises to ! beautiful1 to ! div9e1 & to all ! intelligible ?+s1 :i* dep5d on no?+ else4 ,%e !n seeks to id5tify h]self ) !m1 & lives con=mably to ! div9ity :5 retir$ )9 h]self 79 contemplation74 ,:oev] is depriv$ ( ?is s\l 7t is1 :oev] does n ex]cise ! faculties ( ! reasonable s\l71 lives 9 subjection to fatality4#bbb ,!n ! actions ( su* a be+ are n only indicat$ by ! />s1 b he himself becomes a "p ( ! _w1 & he dep5ds on ! _w ( :i* he =ms a "p4 ,e man is d\ble1#bcb = e man conta9s bo? ! composite 7organism71 & ! real man 7:i* con/itutes ! reasonable s\l74 ,,num5ian ,,d\bl5ess1 ,,mixture1 ,,& ,,divisible ,,s\l4 ,likewise ! univ]se is a comp\nd ( a body & ( a ,s\l intimately unit$ to x1 & ( ! univ]sal ,s\l1 :i* is n 9 ! ,body1 & :i* irradiates ! ,s\l unit$ to ! ,body4#bcc ,!re is a simil> d\bl5ess 9 ! sun & ! o!r />s1 7hav+ a s\l unit$ to _! body1 & a s\l indep5d5t !re(74 ,!y d no?+ t is %ameful = ! pure s\l4 ,! ?+s !y produce are p>ts ( ! univ]se1 inasmu* z !y !mselves are p>ts ( ! univ]se1 & inasmu* z !y h a body1 & a s\l unit$ to ?is body2 b _! w & _! real s\l apply !mselves to ! contemplation ( ! good ,pr9ciple4 ,x is f ?is ,pr9ciple1 or r f t :i* surr\nds x1 t o!r ?+s dep5d1 j z ! fire radiates its heat 9 all directions1 & z ! sup]ior ,s\l 7( ! univ]se7 infuses some:at ( h] pot5cy into ! l[] connect$ s\l4 ,! evil ?+s "h bel[ orig9ate 9 ! mixture inh]+ 9 ! nature ( ?is _w4 ,aft] sep>at+ ! univ]sal ,s\l out ( ! univ]se1 ! rema9d] w\ld be wor?less4 ,!re=e1 ! univ]se is a deity if ! ,s\l t is sep>able f x be includ$ )9 its sub/ance4 ,! rema9d] con/itutes ! gu>dian :i* 7,plato7 names ! ,great ,gu>dian1#bcd & :i*1 besides1 possesses all ! passions prop] to gu>dians4 ,,/>s ,,ann\nce ,,ev5ts ,,because ,,( ,,! ,,s\l',s ,,_m ,,imp]fections1 ,,& ,,accid5ts4 #aj4 ,"u ^! circum/ances1 we mu/ ackn[l$ge t ev5ts are1 by ! />s1 ann\nc$1 ?\gh n produc$1 n ev5 by _! 7l[]7 corporeal s\l4 ,by _! l[] "p1 _! body1#bce !y produce only ! ?+s :i* are passions ( ! univ]se4 ,besides1 we %all h to ackn[l$ge1 t ! s\l1 ev5 be=e ent]+ into g5]ation1 :ile desc5d+ "h bel[1 br+s some?+ :i* %e has by h]self2 = %e w\ld n ent] into a body unless %e _h a great disposition to suff]4#bcf ,we mu/ also admit t :ile pass+ into a body ! s\l is expos$ to accid5ts1 inasmu* z %e is subject$ to ! c\rse ( ! univ]se1 & z ?is v c\rse contributes to ! production ( :at ! univ]se is to accompli%2 = ! ?+s :i* are compris$ 9 ! c\rse ( ! univ]se act z its p>ts4 ,,! ,,influ5ces ,,( ,,! ,,/>s ,,deg5]ate ,,z ,,!y ,,rea* ,,u4 #aa4 ,we mu/ also reflect t ! impressions :i* we d]ive f ! />s d n rea* u 9 ! same condition 9 :i* !y leave !m4 ,j z fire 9 u is mu* deg5]at$ f t 9 ! heav51 s sympa?y1 deg5]at+ )9 ! receiv+ p]son1 begets an unwor?y affection4 ,c\rage produces 9 ^? :o d n possess x 9 ! prop] proportions1 ei!r viol5ce or c[>dl9ess4 ,love ( ! beautiful & good ?us becomes ! se>* = :at only appe>s s4 ,disc]nm5t1 9 und]go+ ?is degradation1 becomes ! trick9ess :i* seeks to equal x1 )\t succe$+ 9 do+ s4 ,?us all ^! qualities become evil 9 u1 )\t be+ su* 9 ! />s4 ,all ! impressions we receive !re( are 9 u n su* z !y are 9 ! />s2 besides !y are /ill fur!r degrad$ by m+l+ ) ! bodies1 ) matt]1 & ) ea* o!r4#bcg ,,m+l$ ,,/> ,,action ,,only ,,promotes ,,or ,,ret>ds ,,processes ,,already ,,natural4 #ab4 ,! influ5ces proce$+ f ! />s comm+le2 & ?is mixture modifies all g5]at$ ?+s1 det]m9+ _! nature & qualities4#bch ,x is n ! cele/ial influ5ce :i* produces ! horse1 x is limit$ to ex]cis+ an influ5ce ^u him2 =1#bci ! horse is begott5 f horse1 man f man2 ! sun c only contribute to _! =mation4 ,man is born f ! 7sem9al logos71 or reason ( man2 b ! circum/ances may be favorable or unfavorable to him4 ,9 fact1 a son resembles ! fa!r1 ?\gh he may be =m$ bett] or worse2 b nev] does he entirely deta* himself f matt]4 ,sometimes1 h[ev]1 ! matt] s prevails ov] nature t ! be+ is imp]fect because ! =m does n dom9ate4#bdj ,,di/9ction ,,betwe5 ,,:at ,,is ,,& ,,:at ,,is ,,n ,,produc$ ,,by ,,! ,,/>s4 #ac4 ,we mu/ n[ di/+ui%1 decide & express ! orig9 ( v>i\s ?+s1 inasmu* z !re are "s ?+s t are produc$ by ! c\rse ( ! />s1 & o!rs t are n4 ,our pr9ciple is t ! ,s\l gov]ns ! univ]se by ,reason1 j z ea* animal is gov]n$ by ! pr9ciple 7! reason7 :i* fa%ions 8 organs1 & h>monizes !m ) ! :ole ( :i* !y are p>ts2#bda n[ ! ,all conta9s ev]y?+1 :ile ! p>ts conta9 only :at is individual to !m4 ,z to ext]ior influ5ces1 "s assi/1 :ile o!rs oppose ! t5d5cy ( nature4 ,all ?+s are subord9at$ to ! ,all because !y are p>ts ( x2 by _! co-op]ation1 ea* ) its own nature & _! p>ticul> t5d5cies !y =m ! total life ( ! univ]se4#bdb ,! inanimate be+s s]ve z in/rum5ts = ! o!rs t set !m 9 motion by a me*anical impulse4 ,irrational animat$ be+s move indet]m9ately2 su* z horses atta*$ to a *>iot be=e ! driv] indicates :i* direction !y are to foll[2 = !y ne$ ! :ip to be direct$4 ,! nature ( ! reasonable animal conta9s ! direct+ driv]2#bdc if ! driv] be skilful1 x foll[s ! /raight road1 in/ead ( go+ bl9dly at *ance1 z (t5 happ5s4 ,be+s gift$ ) reason & ^? t lack x are bo? conta9$ )9 ! univ]se1 & contribute to ! =mation ( ! :ole4 ,^? :i* are m p[]ful1 & :i* occupy a m elevat$ rank d _m important ?+s1 & co-op]ate 9 ! life ( ! univ]se :]e _! "p is active1 r ?an passive4 ,! passive ones act b little4 ,^? ( int]m$i>y rank are passive 9 reg>d to "s1 & (t5 active 9 reg>d to o!rs1 because !y !mselves possess ! p[] ( action & production 7! />s1 ! brutes1 & m54#bdd74 ,,! ,,/>s ,,z ,,! ,,foll[]s ,,( ,,! ,,univ]sal ,,k+4 ,! univ]se leads an univ]sal & p]fect life1 because ! good pr9ciples 7! />-,s\ls7 produce excell5cy1 t is1 ! m excell5t "p 9 e object4#bde ,^! pr9ciples are subord9ate to ! ,s\l t gov]ns ! univ]se1 z soldi]s are to _! g5]al2 consequ5tly1 7,plato7 describes ?is by ! figure ( ! att5dants ( ,jupit] 7! univ]sal ,s\l7 advanc+ to ! contemplation ( ! intelligible _w4 ,,m5 ,,z ,,s\ls ,,( ,,! ,,second ,,rank4 ,! be+s :i* possess a nature inf]ior to ! />-,s\ls1 t is1 m51 occupy ! second rank 9 ! univ]se1 & play 9 x ! same "p play$ 9 u by ! second p[] ( ! s\l 7! discursive reason74 ,! o!r be+s1 t is1 ! animals1 occupy ab\t ! same rank occupi$ 9 u by ! l[e/ 7or vegetative7 p[] ( ! s\l2 = all ^! p[]s 9 u are n ( equal rank4#bdf ,consequ5tly1 all ! be+s :i* are 9 ! heav51 or :i* are di/ribut$ 9 ! univ]se are animat$ be+s1 & d]ive _! life f ! total ,reason ( ! univ]se 7because x conta9s ! sem9al reasons ( all liv+ be+s74 ,none ( ! p>ts ( ! univ]se1 :atev] be its greatness1 possesses ! p[] ( alt]+ ! reasons1 nor ! be+s eng5d]$ ) ! co-op]ation ( ^! reasons4 ,x may improve or degrade ^! be+s1 b _c deprive !m ( _! individual nature4 ,x degrades !m by injur+ ei!r _! body or _! s\l2 :i* occurs :5 an accid5t becomes a cause ( vice = ! s\l :i* p>takes ( ! passions ( ! body 7! s5sitive & vegetative s\l7 & :i* is giv5 ov] to ! inf]ior pr9ciple 7to ! animal7 by ! sup]ior pr9ciple 7! reasonable s\l72 or :5 ! body1 by its poor organization1 h9d]s ! actions 9 :i* ! s\l ne$s its co-op]ation2 !n x resembles a badly attun$ lyre1 :i* is incapable ( produc+ s\nds :i* c\ld =m a p]fect h>mony4#bdg ,,any ,,occurr5ce ,,may ,,be ,,due ,,to ,,_m ,,diff]5t ,,causes4 #ad4 ,pov]ty1 weal?1 glory1 & au?oritative positions may h _m diff]5t causes4 ,if a man d]ive 8 weal? f 8 p>5ts1 ! />s h only ann\nc$ t he w\ld be ri*2 & !y w\ld h only ann\nc$ 8 nobility if he ow$ 8 weal? to 8 bir?4 ,if a man acquire weal? by 8 m]it1 9 "s way 9 :i* 8 body contribut$ !reto1 ! causes ( 8 bodily vigor co-op]at$ 9 8 =tune2 fir/ 8 p>5ts1 !n 8 fa!rl&1 if x be possess$ ( a good climate1 & la/ ! f]tility ( ! soil4#bdh ,if ?is man owe 8 weal? to virtue1 ?is s\rce %\ld be consid]$ exclusive2 & likewise ) ! transitory advantages he may by div9e favor possess4 ,ev5 if 8 weal? be d]iv$ f virtu\s p]sons1 /ill1 9 ano!r way1 8 =tune is due to virtue4 ,if 8 weal? 7 d]iv$ f evil m51 ?\gh by a j means1 yet ! weal? proce$s f a good pr9ciple :i* 0 active 9 !m4 ,f9ally1 if a man :o has amass$ weal? be evil1 ! cause ( 8 =tune is ?is v wick$ness1 & ! pr9ciple f :i* x d]ives2 ev5 ^? :o may h giv5 him money mu/ be includ$ 9 ! ord] ( its causes4 ,if a man owe 8 weal? to labor1 su* z agricultural "w1 ! causes ( ! weal? include ! c>e ( ! pl\ghman & ! co-op]ation ( ext]ior circum/ances4 ,ev5 if he f\nd a treasure1 x is some?+ 9 ! univ]se :i* contribut$ !reto4 ,besides1 ?is discov]y may h be5 =etold2 = all ?+s concat5ate ) ev]y?+ else1 &1 consequ5tly1 ann\nce ea* o!r4 ,if a man scatt] 8 weal?1 he is ! cause ( _! loss2 if 8 weal? be tak5 f him1 ! cause is ! man :o takes x4 ,_m are ! contributory causes ( a %ipwreck4 ,glory may be acquir$ ju/ly or unju/ly4 ,j glory is due to s]vices r5d]$1 or to ! e/eem ( o!r p4 ,unju/ glory is caus$ by ! inju/ice ( ^? :o glorify t man4 ,des]v$ p[] is due to ! good s5se ( ! electors1 or to ! activity ( ! man :o acquir$ x by ! co-op]ation ( 8 fri5ds1 or to any o!r circum/ance4 ,a m>riage is det]m9$ by a pref]5ce1 or by "s accid5tal circum/ance1 or by ! co-op]ation ( sev]al circum/ances4 ,! procreation ( *ildr5 is "o ( its consequ5ces2 x occurs 9 accordance ) ! 7sem9al7 reason1 9 case x meet no ob/acle2 if x be defective1 !re mu/ be "s int]ior defect 9 ! pregnant "m1 or ! fault lies 9 ! impot5ce ( ! fa!r4 ,a ,,s\l',s ,,de/9y ,,dep5ds ,,on ,,! ,,condition ,,( ,,! ,,univ]se ,,at ,,bir?4 #ae4 ,plato#bdi speaks ( ! lots1 & conditions *os5 by "o turn ( ! sp9dle 7( ,clo?o72 he speaks also ( a gu>dian :o helps ea* man to fulfil 8 de/9y4 ,^! conditions are ! disposition ( ! univ]se at ! "t ( ! s\l's entrance into ! body1 ! nature ( _! body1 p>5ts & fa!rl&2 9 %ort1 ! aggregate ( ext]nal circum/ances4 ,evid5tly all ^! ?+s1 9 detail z well z 9 totality1 are simultane\sly produc$ & relat$ by "o ( ! ,fates1 namely ,clo?o4 ,la*esis !n pres5ts ! conditions to ! s\ls4 ,f9ally ,atropos r5d]s ! accompli%m5t ( all ! circum/ances ( ea* de/9y irrevocable4 ,,h[ ,,"s ,,m5 ,,may ,,ma/] ,,_! ,,fate3 ,,by ,,self-,,victory4 ,"s m51 fasc9at$ by ! univ]se & ext]ior objects1 completely or p>tially abdicate _! fre$om4#bej ,o!rs1 dom9at+ _! environm5t1 raise _! head to ! sky1 & free+ !mselves f ext]ior circum/ances1 release t bett] "p ( _! s\ls :i* =ms _! primitive be+4 ,z to ! latt] po9t1 x w\ld be wrong to ?9k t ! nature ( ! s\l 0 det]m9$ by ! passions ar\s$ 9 h] by ext]nal objects1 & t %e did n possess h] own individual nature4 ,on ! contr>y1 z %e plays ! "p ( a pr9ciple1 %e possesses1 mu* m ?an o!r ?+s1 faculties suitable to accompli% actions suitable to h] nature4 ,s9ce %e is a be+1 ! s\l necess>ily possesses appetites1 active faculties1 & ! p[] ( liv+ well4#bea ,! aggregate 7( ! s\l & body1 ! organism7 dep5ds on ! nature :i* =m$ x1 & f x receives its qualities & actions4 ,if ! s\l sep>ate f ! body1 %e produces actions :i* are suitable to h] nature1 & :i* d n dep5d f ! body2 %e does n appropriate ! cr$it = ! passions ( ! body1 because %e recognizes ! diff]5ce ( h] nature4#beb ,,exact ,,psy*ology ,,at ,,! ,,root ,,( ,,philosophy4 #af4 ,:at is ! m+l$1 & :at is ! pure "p ( ! s\l8 ,:at "p ( ! s\l is sep>able8 ,:at "p is n sep>able s long z ! s\l is 9 a body8 ,:at is ! animal8 ,?is subject w h to be /udi$ else:]e1#bec = !re is practically no agreem5t on ! subject4 ,= ! pres5t1 let u expla9 9 :i* s5se we above said t ! s\l gov]ns ! univ]se by ,reason4 ,,is ,,! ,,univ]sal ,,s\l ,,creative1 ,,b ,,n ,,pres]vative8 ,does ! univ]sal ,s\l =m all ! be+s successively1 fir/ man1 !n ! horse1 !n "s o!r animal1 & la/ ! wild bea/s8#bed ,does %e beg9 by produc+ e>? & fire2 !n1 see+ ! co-op]ation ( all ^! ?+s :i* mutually de/roy or assi/ ea* o!r1 does %e consid] only _! totality & _! connections1 )\t reg>d+ ! accid5ts :i* occur to !m lat]8 ,does %e limit h]self to ! reproduction ( prec$+ g5]ations ( animals1 & does %e leave ^! expos$ to ! passions ) :i* !y inspire ea* o!r8 ,,det]m9ism ,,implies ,,deg5]ation ,,( ,,races4 ,does ! reason ( ea* individual conta9 bo? 8 actions & reactions#bae 9 a way su* t ^! are nei!r accid5tal nor =tuit\s1 b necess>y8#bee ,are ^! produc$ by ! reasons8 ,or d ! reasons "k !m1 )\t produc+ !m8 ,or does ! s\l1 :i* conta9s ! g5]ative reasons1#bef "k ! effects ( all h] works by reason+ accord+ to ! foll[+ pr9ciple1 t ! conc\rse ( ! same circum/ances mu/ evid5tly produce ! same effects8 ,if s1 ! s\l1 und]/&+ or =esee+ ! effects ( h] works1 by !m det]m9es & concat5ates all ! ev5ts t are to happ54 ,%e1 !re=e1 consid]s all ! antec$5ts & consequ5ts1 & =esees :at is to foll[ f :at prec$es4#beg ,x is 7because ! be+s ?us proce$ f ea* o!r7 t ! races cont9ually deg5]ate4 ,= in/ance1 m5 deg5]ate because 9 dep>t+ cont9ually & unavoidably 7f ! primitive type7 ! 7sem9al7 reasons yield to ! passions ( matt]4#beh ,,! ,,s\l ,,does ,,n ,,cause ,,passions1 ,,:i* ,,arise ,,f ,,! ,,sem9al ,,reasons4 ,is ! s\l ! cause ( ^! passions1 because %e begets ! be+s t produce !m8 ,does ! s\l !n consid] ! :ole sequ5ce ( ev5ts1 & does %e pass h] exi/5ce wat*+ ! passions exp]i5c$ by h] works8 ,does %e nev] cease ?9k+ ( ! latt]1 does %e nev] put on !m ! f9i%+ t\*1 regulat+ !m s t !y %\ld always g well8#bei ,does %e resemble "s f>m] :o1 in/ead ( limit+ himself to s[+ & plant+1 %\ld ceaselessly labor to repair ! damage caus$ by ! ra9s1 ! w9ds1 & ! /orms8 ,unless ?is hypo!sis be absurd1 x mu/ be admitt$ t ! s\l kn[s 9 advance1 or ev5 t ! 7sem9al7#bfj reasons conta9 accid5ts :i* happ5 to begott5 be+s1 t is1 _! de/ruction & all ! effects ( _! faults4#bfa ,9 ?is case1 we are oblig$ to say t ! faults are d]iv$ f ! 7sem9al7 reasons1 al?\gh ! arts & _! reasons conta9 nei!r error1 fault1 nor de/ruction ( a "w ( art4#bfb ,,! ,,univ]se ,,is ,,h>mony1#bjg ,,9 ,,spite ,,( ,,! ,,faults ,,9 ,,! ,,details4 ,x might "h be object$ t !re c\ld n be 9 ! univ]se any?+ bad or contr>y to nature2 & x mu/ be ackn[l$g$ t ev5 :at seems less good /ill has its utility4 ,if ?is seem to admit t ?+s t are less good contribute to ! p]fection ( ! univ]se1 & t !re is no necessity t all ?+s be beautiful1#bfc x is only because ! v contr>ies contribute to ! p]fection ( ! univ]se1 & s ! _w c\ld n exi/ )\t !m4 ,x is likewise ) all liv+ be+s4 ,! 7sem9al7 reason necess>ily produces & =ms :at is bett]2 :at is less good is conta9$ 9 ! pot5tiality ( ! reasons1 & actualiz$ 9 ! begott5 be+s4 ,! 7univ]sal7 ,s\l has1 !re=e1 no ne$ to busy h]self !re)1 nor to cause ! reasons to become active4 ,= ! reasons successfully subdue matt] to :at is bett] 7! =ms71 ev5 ?\gh matt] alt]s :at x receives by imp>t+ a %ock to ! reasons t proce$ f ! high] pr9ciples4 ,all ?+s1 !re=e1 =m a h>moni\s totality because !y simultane\sly proce$ f matt]1 & ! reasons :i* beget !m4 ,,! ,,me?od ,,( ,,creation4 #ag4 ,let u exam9e if ! reasons conta9$ 9 ! ,s\l are ?\ghts4 ,h[ c\ld ! ,s\l produce by ?\ghts8 ,x is ! ,reason :i* produces 9 matt]2 b ! pr9ciple t produces naturally is nei!r a ?\ght nor an intuition1 b a p[] t fa%ions matt] unconsci\sly1 j z a circle gives wat] a circul> figure & impression4 ,inde$1 ! natural g5]ative p[] has ! function ( production2 b x ne$s ! co-op]ation ( ! gov]n+ 7pr9ciple7 ( ! ,s\l1 :i* =ms & :i* causes ! activity ( ! g5]ative s\l engag$ 9 matt]4 ,if ! gov]n+ p[] ( ! ,s\l =m ! g5]ative s\l by reason+1 x w be consid]+ ei!r ano!r object1 or :at x possesses 9 h]self4 ,if ! latt] be ! case1 %e has no ne$ ( reason+1#bfd = x is n by reason+ t ! ,s\l fa%ions matt]1 b by ! p[] :i* conta9s ! reasons1 ! p[] :i* alone is effective1 & capable ( production4 ,! ,s\l1 !re=e1 produces by ! =ms4 ,! =ms %e transmits are by h] receiv$ f ! ,intellig5ce4 ,?is ,intellig5ce1 h[ev]1 gives ! =ms to ! univ]sal ,s\l :i* is locat$ imm$iately bel[ h]1 & ! univ]sal ,s\l transmits !m to ! inf]ior s\l 7! natural g5]ative p[]71 fa%ion+ & illum9at+ h]4 ,! inf]ior s\l !n produces1 at "o "t )\t meet+ any ob/acles1 at o!rs1 :5 do+ s1 al?\gh1 9 ! latt] case1 %e produces ?+s less p]fect4 ,z %e has receiv$ ! p[] ( production1 & z %e conta9s ! reasons :i* are n ! fir/ 7! sem9al reasons1 :i* are inf]ior to ! ,ideas7 n only does %e1 by virtue ( :at %e has receiv$1 produce1 b %e also draws f h]self some?+ :i* is evid5tly inf]ior 7matt]74#bfe ,x d\btless produces a liv+ be+ 7! univ]se71 b a liv+ be+ :i* is less p]fect1 & :i* enjoys life mu* less1 because x occupies ! la/ rank1 because x is co>se & h>d to manage1 because ! matt] :i* composes x is1 z x 71 ! bitt]ness or ! sup]ior pr9ciples1 because x spreads its bitt]ness ar\nd h]1 & communicates "s ( x to ! univ]se4 ,,evils ,,are ,,necess>y ,,to ,,! ,,p]fection ,,( ,,! ,,univ]se4 #ah4 ,mu/ ! evils 9 ! univ]se be consid]$ z necess>y1#bff because !y are ! consequ5ces ( ! sup]ior pr9ciples8 ,yes1 = )\t !m ! univ]se w\ld be imp]fect4 ,! great] numb] ( evils1 if n all ( !m1 are useful to ! univ]se2 su* z ! v5om\s animals2 ?\gh !y (t5 ignore _! real utility4 ,ev5 wick$ness is useful 9 c]ta9 respects1 & c produce _m beautiful ?+s2 = example1 x leads to f9e inv5tions1 x =ces m5 to prud5ce1 & does n let !m fall asleep 9 an indol5t security4#bfg ,,picture ,,( ,,! ,,/ructure ,,( ,,! ,,univ]se4 ,"u ^! circum/ances1 x is pla9 t ! univ]sal ,s\l ev] contemplates ! bett] pr9ciples1 because x is turn$ t[>ds ! intelligible _w1 & t[>ds ! div9ity4 ,z %e fills h]self ) ,god1 & is fill$ ) ,god1 %e1 z x 71 ov]fl[s ov] h] image1 namely1 ! p[] :i* holds ! la/ rank 7! natural g5]ative p[]71 & :i*1 consequ5tly1 is ! la/ creative p[]4 ,above ?is creative p[] is ! p[] ( ! ,s\l :i* imm$iately receives ! =ms f ! ,intellig5ce4 ,above all is ! ,intellig5ce1 ! ,demiurge1 :o gives ! =ms to ! univ]sal ,s\l1 & ! latt] impresses its traces on ! ?ird-rank p[] 7! natural g5]ative p[]74#bfh ,?is _w1 !re=e1 is v]itably a picture :i* p]petually pictures itself4 ,! two fir/ pr9ciples are immovable2 ! ?ird is also immovable 79 ess5ce72 b x is engag$ 9 matt]1 & becomes immovable 7only7 by accid5t4 ,z long z ! ,intellig5ce & ! ,s\l subsi/1 ! reasons fl[ d[n into ?is image ( ! ,s\l 7! natural g5]ative p[]72 likewise1 s long z ! sun subsi/s1 all light emanates !refrom4#bfi ,,fir/ ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,"o4 ,! ,organism & ! ,self4#bgj ,,psy*ologic ,,di/9ctions ,,9 ,,s\l4 #a4 ,to :at "p ( our nature d pleasure & grief1 fe> & boldness desire & av]sion1 &1 la/1 pa91 belong8 ,is x to ! s\l 7h]self71#bga or to ! s\l :5 %e uses ! body z an in/rum5t1#bgb or to "s ?ird 7comb9ation7 ( bo?8 ,ev5 ! latt] might be conceiv$ ( 9 a d\ble s5se3 x might be ei!r ! simple mixture ( ! s\l & ! body1#bgc or "s diff]5t product result+ !refrom4#bgd ,! same unc]ta9ty obta9s ab\t ! products ( ! above m5tion$ exp]i5ces3 namely1 passions1#bge actions1 & op9ions4 ,= example1 we may ask :e!r ratioc9ation#bgf & op9ion bo?1 belong to ! same pr9ciple z ! passions2 or :e!r only "o ( !m does2 9 :i* case ! o!r w\ld belong to "s o!r pr9ciple4 ,we %\ld also inquire conc]n+ ! nature & classification ( ?\ght4#bgg ,la/ we %\ld /udy ! pr9ciple t und]takes ?is inquiry & :i* comes to "s conclusion ab\t x4 ,b1 fir/ ( all1 :o is ! ag5t1 :o feels8 ,?is is ! real />t+ po9t3 = ev5 passions are modes ( feel+1 or at lea/ !y d n exi/ )\t x4#bgh ,,! ,,s\l ,,z ,a ,,composite ,,aggregate4 #b4 ,let u fir/ exam9e ! s\l 7h]self74 ,is !re any diff]5ce betwe5 ! s\l & ! s\l-ess5ce8 ,if !re be a diff]5ce1 ! s\l mu/ be a composite aggregate3 & x %\ld no long] be a matt] ( surprise t bo? %e & h] ess5ce1 at lea/ s f> z %e admits !re(1 toge!r exp]i5ce ! above m5tion$ passions1 & 9 g5]al ! habits1 & bett] or worse dispositions4 ,b1 on ! contr>y1 if1 s\l & s\l-ess5ce be id5tical1 !n ! s\l %\ld be a =m :i* w\ld be unreceptive = all ^! en]gies ( ess5ce1 :i* on ! contr>y %e imp>ts to o!r ?+s1 possess+ 9 h]self a connate en]gy :i* our reason reveals 9 h]4 ,9 ?is case we mu/ ackn[l$ge t %e is immortal1 inasmu* z ! immortal & undecay+ mu/ be impassible1 giv+ to o!rs )\t receiv+ any?+ 9 return f !m2 or at lea/1 d]iv+ no?+ b f ! sup]ior 7or ant]ior7 pr9ciples1 f :i* %e is n cut (f1 inasmu* z !y are bett]4 ,,! ,,s\l ,,is ,,n ,,ess5ce4 ,a be+ t 7 s unreceptive to any?+ ext]nal w\ld h no gr\nd = fe> ( any?+ ext]nal4 ,fe> might inde$ be natural to some?+4 ,nei!r w\ld %e be bold1 = ?is s5tim5t1 implies %elt] f :at is t]rify+4 ,z to su* desires :i* are satisfi$ by ! empty+ or fill+ ( ! body1 !y belong only to "s nature =eign en\gh to be empti$ or fill$4 ,h[ c\ld %e p>ticipate 9 a mixture1 inasmu* z ! ess5tial is unm+l$8 ,fur!r %e w\ld n wi% to h any?+ introduc$ 79 h]self71 = ?is w\ld imply /riv+ to become some?+ =eign to h]self4 ,%e w\ld also be f> f suff]+1 = h[ c\ld %e grieve1 & ab\t :at8 ,= t :i* is ( simple be+ is self-suffici5t1 9 t %e rema9s 9 h] own be+4 ,nei!r w %e rejoice at any increase1 z n ev5 ! good c\ld happ5 to h]4 ,:at %e is1 %e ev] w be4 ,nor c\ld we attribute to ! pure s\l s5sation1 ratioc9ation or op9ion2 = s5sation is ! p]ception1 ( a =m or ( an impassible body2 & besides ratioc9ation & op9ion 7dep5d7 on s5sation4 ,we %all1 h[ev]1 h to exam9e :e!r or no we %\ld attribute to ! s\l ?\ght2 also1 :e!r pure pleasure c affect a s\l :ile %e rema9s alone4#bgi ,,! ,,s\l ,,uses ,,! ,,body ,,z ,,tool4 #c4 ,:e!r ! s\l1 accord+ to h] be+1 be locat$ 9 ! body1 above or )9 ?is latt]1 ! s\l =ms ) ! body an entity call$ 7a liv+ be+ or7 organism4#bhj ,9 ?is case1 ! s\l us+ ! body z a tool is n =c$ to p>ticipate 9 its passions1 any m ?an workm5 p>ticipate 9 ! exp]i5ces ( _! tools4 ,z to s5sations1 ( c\rse1 ! s\l mu/ p]ceive !m1 s9ce 9 ord] to use h] in/rum5t1 ! s\l mu/1 by means ( s5sation1 cognize ! modifications t ?is in/rum5t may receive f )\t4 ,?us see+ consi/s ( us+ ! eyes2 & ! s\l at ! same "t feels ! evils :i* may affect ! sight4 ,simil> is ! case ) griefs1 pa9s & any corporeal exig5cy2 also ) ! desires :i* arise f ! s\l's ne$ to take rec\rse to ! m9i/ry ( ! body4 ,b h[ d passions f ! body p5etrate into ! s\l8 ,= a body c\ld communicate h] own prop]ties to "s o!r body2 b h[ c\ld %e d s to a s\l8 ,,sep>ation ,,( ,,s\l ,,f ,,body4 ,su* a process w\ld imply t "o individual suff]s :5 an entirely diff]5t individual is affect$4 ,!re mu/ be a di/9ction betwe5 !m s long z we consid] ! =m] ! us]1 & ! latt] ! us$2 & x is philosophy1#bha t produces ?is sep>ation by giv+ to ! s\l ! p[] ( us+ ! body z a tool4 ,,primitive ,,relation ,,betwe5 ,,s\l ,,& ,,body4 ,b :at 0 ! condition ( ! s\l be=e h] sep>ation f ! body by philosophy8 ,0 %e m+l$ ) ! body8 ,if %e 7 m+l$ ) x1 %e mu/ ei!r h be5 =m$#bhb by mix+2#bga or %e 0 spread all ov] ! body2 or %e 0#bhc a =m int]wov5 ) ! body2 or %e 0 a =m gov]n+ ! body#bhd z a pilot gov]ns ! %ip2#bhe or#bhf 0 p>tly m+l$ )1 & p>tly sep>at$ f1 ! body4 7,9 ! latt] case7 ,i w\ld call ! indep5d5t "p t :i* uses ! body z a tool1 :ile ! m+l$ "p is t :i* l[]s itself to ! classification or rank ( in/rum5t4 ,n[ philosophy raises ! latt] to ! rank ( ! =m]2 & ! deta*$ "p turns h] away1 z f> z our ne$s all[1 f ! body %e uses1 s t %e may n always h to use ! body4 ,,consequ5ces ,,( ,,mixture ,,( ,,s\l ,,& ,,body4 #d4 ,n[ let u suppose ! s\l is m+l$ ) ! body4 ,9 ?is mixture1 ! worse "p1 or body1 w ga91 :ile ! s\l w lose4 ,! body w improve by p>ticipation ) ! s\l2 & ! s\l w det]iorate by association ) dea? & irrationality4 ,well1 does ! s\l1 9 some:at los+ life1 ga9 ! accession ( s5sation8 ,on ! o!r h&1 w\ld n ! body1 by p>ticipation 9 life1 ga9 s5sation & its d]iv$ passions8 ,x is ! latt]1 !n1 :i* w desire1 inasmu* z x w enjoy ! desir$ objects1 & w feel fe> ab\t !m4 ,x is ! latt] :i* may be expos$ to ! escape ( ! objects ( its desire1 & to decay4#bhg ,,mixture ,,( ,,s\l ,,& ,,body4 ,we w set aside z impossible ! mixture ( two incomm5surables1 su* z a l9e & ! color call$ :ite4 ,a mixture ( ! s\l & body1 :i* mu/ imply _! comm5surability1 w\ld dem& explanation4 ,ev5 if ! s\l int]p5etrate ! body1 ! s\l ne$ n %>e ! body's passions1 = ! int]p5etrat+ m$ium may rema9 impassible2 z light1 :i* rema9s su* 9 spite ( its diffusion4#bhh ,?us ! s\l might rema9 a /rang] to ! body's passions1 ?\gh diffus$ ?r\gh x1 & ne$ n necess>ily und]go its passions4 ,,ari/otelian ,,hypo!sis ,,consid]$4 ,%\ld we say t ! s\l is 9 ! body1 z =m 9 matt]8 ,9 ?is case1 %e is be+1 & %e w\ld be a sep>able =m4 ,if !n#bhi %e be 9 ! body z1 9 ! case ( ! axe1 ! s*ematic figure is 9 ! iron1 s z by h] own prop] virtue1 to =m ! p[] ( do+ :at iron ?us =m$ accompli%es1 we w h all ! m reason to attribute ! common passions to ! body1 :i* is#bij an organiz$ physical tool possess+ pot5tial life4 ,= if z 7,plato7 says#bia x be absurd to suppose t x is ! s\l t weaves1 x is n any m reasonable to attribute ! desires & griefs to ! s\l2 r1 by f>1 to ! liv+ organism4 ,,! ,,liv+ ,,organism4 #e4 ,! liv+ organism mu/ mean ei!r ! ?us organiz$ body1 or ! common mixture ( s\l & body1 or "s ?ird ?+ :i* proce$s f ! two fir/4 ,9 ei!r ( ^! ?ree cases ! s\l w h to be consid]$ impassible1 :ile ! p[] ( exp]i5c+ passions w inh]e 9 some?+ else2 or ! s\l w h to %>e ! body's passions1 9 :i* case ! s\l w h to exp]i5ce passions ei!r id5tical or analog\s to ^? ( ! body1 s t to a desire ( ! animal !re w correspond an act or a passion ( ! concupiscible appetite4 ,,refutation ,,( ,,! 7,,james-,,lange7 ,,!ory ,,( ,,emotions4 ,we %all lat] on consid] ! organiz$ body2 "h we mu/ f9d h[ ! conjunction ( s\l & body c\ld exp]i5ce suff]+4 ,! !ory t ! affection ( ! body modifies x s z to produce a s5sation :i* itself w\ld end 9 ! s\l1 leaves unexpla9$ ! orig9 ( s5sation4 ,to ! !ory t suff]+ has its pr9ciple 9 ?is op9ion or judgm5t1 t a mis=tune is happ5+ to ourselves or "s "o relat$ to u1 :5ce results disagreeable emotion fir/ 9 ! body1 & !n 9 ! :ole liv+ organism1#bib !re is ?is objection1 t x is yet unc]ta9 to :i* op9ion belongs2 to ! s\l1 or to ! conjunction ( s\l & body4 ,besides1 ! op9ion ( ! pres5ce ( an evil does n always entail suff]+2 x is possible t1 9 spite ( su* an op9ion1 "o feels no affliction2 z1 = in/ance1 "o may n become irritat$ at believ+ oneself scorn$2 or 9 exp]i5c+ no desire ev5 9 ! expectation ( "s good4 ,,n ,,all ,,affections ,,common ,,to ,,s\l ,,& ,,body4 ,h[ !n arise ^! affections common to ! s\l & ! body8 ,%all we !n say t desire d]ives f ! desire-appetite1#bic ang] f ! ang]-appetite1 or 9 %ort1 e emotion or affliction f ! correspond+ appetite8 ,b ev5 s1 !y w n be common1 & !y w belong exclusively to ! s\l1 or to ! body4 ,!re are "s ^: orig9 ne$s ! excitation ( blood & bile1 & t ! body be 9 "s c]ta9 /ate :i* excites desire1 z 9 physical love4 ,on ! contr>y1 h[ev]1 ! desire ( goodness is no common affection2 x is an affection peculi> to ! s\l1 z are sev]al o!rs4 ,reason1 !re=e1 does n all[ u to consid] all affections z common to s\l & body4 ,,desire1 ,,n ,,simultane\s ,,) ,,appetite4 ,is x possible1 h[ev]1 t = example1 9 physical love1 ! man#bid may exp]i5ce a desire simultane\sly ) ! correspond+ appetite8 ,?is is impossible1 = two reasons4 ,if we say t ! man beg9s to exp]i5ce ! desire1 :ile ! correspond+ appetite cont9ues x1 x is pla9 ! man _c exp]i5ce a desire )\t ! activity ( ! appetite4 ,if on ! o!r h& x be ! appetite t beg9s1 x is cle> t x _c beg9 be+ excit$ unless ! body fir/ f9d itself 9 suitable circum/ances1 :i* is unreasonable4 ,,s\l ,,& ,,body1 ,,by ,,unit+1 ,,=m ,,an ,,individual ,,aggregate4 #f4 ,x w\ld1 h[ev]1 probably be bett] to put ! matt] ?us3 by _! pres5ce1 ! faculties ( ! s\l cause reaction 9 ! organs :i* possess !m1 s t :ile !y !mselves rema9 unmov$1 !y give !m ! p[] to ent] into movem5t4#bie ,9 ?is case1 h[ev]1 :5 ! liv+ organism exp]i5ces suff]+1 ! life-imp>t+ cause mu/ itself rema9 impassible1 :ile ! passions & en]gies belong :olly to t :i* receives life4 ,9 ?is case1 !re=e1 ! life w n belong exclusively to ! s\l1 b to ! conjunction ( ! s\l & body2 or1 at lea/1 ! latt]'s life w n be id5tical ) ! s\l's1 nor w x be ! faculty ( s5sation1 :i* w feel1 b ! be+ 9 :om t faculty inh]es4 ,,s5sation ,,implies ,,feel+ ,,s\l4 ,if1 h[ev]1 s5sation1 :i* is no m ?an a corporeal emotion1 f9ds its t]m 9 ! s\l1 ! s\l mu/ surely feel s5sation2 !re=e x does n occur z an effect ( ! pres5ce ( ! faculty ( s5sation1 = ?is ignores ! feel+ ag5t back ( x4 ,nor is x ! conjunction ( s\l & body1 = unless ! faculty ( s5sation op]ate1 t aggregate c\ld n feel1 & x w\ld !n no long] include z elem5ts ei!r ! s\l1 or ! faculty ( s5sation4 ,,s\l-,,light ,,=ms ,,animal ,,nature4 #g4 ,! aggregate results f ! pres5ce ( ! s\l1 n inde$ t ! s\l ent]s into ! aggregate1 or con/itutes "o ( its elem5ts4 ,out ( ?is organiz$ body1 & ( a k9d ( light furni%$ by h]self1 ! s\l =ms ! animal nature1 :i* diff]s bo? f s\l & body1 & to :i* belongs s5sation1 z well z all ! passions attribut$ to ! animal4#bif ,,relation ,,( ,,animal ,,to ,,human ,,nature4 ,if n[ we %\ld be ask$ h[ x happ5$ t we feel1 we answ]3 ,we are n sep>at$ f ! organism1 al?\gh )9 u exi/ pr9ciples#big ( a high] k9d :i* concur 9 =m+ ! manifold complex ( human nature4 ,,ext]nal ,,& ,,int]nal ,,s5sation4 ,z to ! faculty ( s5sation :i* is peculi> to ! s\l1 x _c be ! p[] ( p]ceiv+ ! s5se-objects !mselves1 b only _! typical =ms1 impress$ on ! animal by s5sation4 ,^! h already some:at ( ! intelligible nature2 ! ext]ior s5sation peculi> to ! animal is only ! image ( ! s5sation peculi> to ! s\l2 :i*1 by its v ess5ce is tru] & m real1 s9ce x consi/s only 9 contemplat+ images :ile rema9+ impassible4#bih ,ratioc9ation1 op9ion & ?\ght1 :i* pr9cipally con/itute u1#bii deal exclusively ) ^! images1 by :i* ! s\l has ! p[] ( direct+ ! organism4 ,,di/9ction ,,9 ,,! ,,:ole ,,organism4 ,no d\bt ^! faculties are ours1 b we are ! sup]ior pr9ciple :i*1 f above1 directs ! organis+ b 9 ?is :ole we %all h to di/+ui% an inf]ior "p1 m+l$ ) ! body1 & a sup]ior "p1 :i* is ! true man4 ,! =m] 7irrational s\l7 con/itutes ! bea/1 z = in/ance1 ! lion2 ! latt] is ! rational s\l1 :i* con/itutes man4 ,9 e ratioc9ation1 x is we :o reason1 because ratioc9ation is ! peculi> activity 7or1 en]gy7 ( ! s\l4#cjj ,,individual ,,relation ,,) ,,cosmic ,,intellect4 #h4 ,:at is our relation ) ! ,intellig5ce8 ,i mean n ! habit imp>t$ to ! s\l by ! intellect1 b ! absolute ,intellig5ce2#cja :i*1 ?\gh above u1 is also common to all m51 or peculi> to ea* ( !m2 9 o!r words1 is simultane\sly common & individual4 ,common because x is indivisible1 "o & ev]y:]e ! same2 p>ticul> because ea* s\l possesses x entirely 9 ! fir/ or rational s\l4 ,likewise1 we possess ! ideas 9 a d\ble mann]2 9 ! s\l !y appe> develop$ & sep>ate2 9 ! intellig5ce !y exi/ all toge!r4#cjb ,,individual ,,relation ,,) ,,god ,,& ,,cosmic ,,s\l4 ,:at is our relation ) ,god8 ,he hov]s ov] ! intelligible nature1 & real be+2 :ile we1 be+ on ! ?ird rank z c\nt$ f !nce1 are ( ! undivid$ univ]sal ,s\l1 :i*#cjc is indivisible because %e =ms "p ( ! upp] _w1 :ile %e is divisible 9 reg>d to ! bodies4 ,%e is inde$ divisible 9 reg>d to ! bodies1 s9ce %e p]meates ea* ( !m z f> z !y live2 b at ! same "t %e is indivisible because %e is "o 9 ! univ]se4 ,,s\l ,,gives ,,life ,,to ,,psy*ologic ,,elem5ts4 ,%e seems to be pres5t 9 ! bodies1 & illum9ates !m1 mak+ liv+ be+s out ( !m4 ,?is occurs n z a mixture ( h]self & bodies1 b by rema9+ individual1 giv+ out images ( h]self1#cjd j z a s+le face 9 sev]al mirrors4 ,( ^!1 ! fir/ is s5sation1 :i* resides 9 ! common "p1 ! organism2 !n come all ! o!r =ms ( ! s\l--=ms :i* successively d]ive ea* f ! o!r1 d[n to ! faculties ( g5]ation & increase1 & g5]ally1 ! p[] ( produc+ & fa%ion+ t :i* is diff]5t f self--:i* inde$ ! s\l does z soon z %e turns t[>ds ! object %e fa%ions4#cje ,,orig9 ,,( ,,evils1 ,,s9s1 ,,& ,,errors4 #i4 ,9 ?is conception ( ! s\l1 %e w be =eign to ! cause ( ! evils :i* ! man does & suff]s4 ,^! ref] to ! organism1 t common "p1 und]/ood z above4 ,al?\gh op9ion be deceptive1 & makes u commit mu* evil1 & al?\gh op9ion & ratioc9ation bo? belong to ! s\l1 yet ! s\l may be s9less1 inasmu* z we are only ma/]$ by ! worse "p ( our nature4#cjf ,(t51 inde$1 we yield to appetite1 to ang]1 & we are ! dupes ( "s imp]fect image4 ,! conception ( false ?+s1 ! imag9ation#cjg does n await ! judgm5t ( discursive reason4 ,!re are /ill o!r cases :]e we yield to ! l[] "p ( ourselves2 9 s5sation1 = in/ance1 we see ?+s t d n exi/1 because we rely on ! common s5sation ( s\l & body1 be=e hav+ disc]n$ its objects by discursive reason4 ,,intellect ,,did ,,n ,,grasp ,,! ,,object ,,itself4 ,9 ?is case did ! intellect grasp ! object itself8 ,c]ta9ly n2 &1 !re=e1 x is n ! intellect t is responsible = ! error4 ,we say z mu* = ! we1 accord+ z we w or w n h p]ceiv$ ! object1 ei!r 9 ! intellect1 or 9 ourselves2--= x is possible to possess an object )\t hav+ x actually pres5t4 ,,true ,,conception ,,act ,,( ,,intuition4 ,we h di/+ui%$ f ?+s common to s\l & body1 ^? peculi> to ! s\l4 ,! =m] are corporeal1 & _c be produc$ )\t ! organs1 :ile ! latt]'s occurr5ce is indep5d5t ( ! body4 ,ratioc9ation#bgf is ! ess5tial & con/itutive faculty ( ! real s\l1 because x det]m9es ! typical =ms d]iv$ f s5sation1 x looks1 x someh[ feels ! images1 & really is ! dom9at+ "p ( ! s\l4 ,! conception ( true ?+s is ! act ( intuitive ?\ghts4 ,,modifications ,,d]ive ,,f ,,=eign ,,s\rces4 ,!re is (t5 a resemblance & community betwe5 ext]ior & int]ior ?+s2 9 ?is case ! s\l w n any ! less ex]cise h]self on h]self1 w n any ! less rema9 )9 h]self1 )\t feel+ any passive modification4 ,z to ! modifications & tr\bles :i* may arise 9 u1 !y d]ive f =eign elem5ts1 atta*$ to ! s\l1 z well z f passions exp]i5c$ by ! above describ$ common "p4 ,,di/9ctions ,,9 ,,we ,,& ,,! ,,real ,,man4 #aj4 ,b if we are ! s\l1 we mu/ admit t :5 we exp]i5ce passions1 ! s\l exp]i5ces !m also2 t :5 we act1 ! s\l acts4 ,we may ev5 say t ! common "p is also ours1 especially be=e philosophy sep>at$ ! s\l f ! body2#cjh 9 fact1 we ev5 say we suff]1 :5 our body suff]s4 ,we is1 !re=e1 tak5 9 a d\ble s5se3 ei!r ! s\l ) ! animal "p1 or liv+ body2 or simply ! upp] "p2 :ile ! vivifi$ body is a wild bea/4 ,,real ,,man ,,diff]s ,,f ,,body4 ,! real ,man diff]s f ! body2 pure f e passion1 he possesses ! intellectual virtues1 virtues :i* reside 9 ! s\l1 ei!r :5 %e is sep>at$ f ! body1 or :5 %e is--z usually "h bel[--only sep>able by philosophy2 = ev5 :5 %e seems to u entirely sep>at$1 ! s\l is1 9 ?is life1 ev] accompani$ by a l[]#cji s5sitive "p1 or "p ( gr[?1 :i* %e illum9ates4#caj ,,function ,,( ,,! ,,common ,,"p4 ,z to ! virtues :i* consi/ n 9 wisdom1 b 9 e?ical habits & au/]ities1 !y belong to ! common "p4 ,to x alone1 also1 are vices to be imput$1 inasmu* z x exclusively exp]i5ces envy1 jeal\sy & c[>dly pity4 ,fri5d%ips1 h[ev]1 %\ld be ref]r$ "s to ! common "p1 & o!rs to ! pure ,s\l or inn] ,man4 ,9 *ildhood1 ! faculties ( ! composite common "p are ex]cis$1 b r>ely is x illum9at$ f above4 ,:5 ?is sup]ior pr9ciple seems inactive 9 relation to u1 x is actively engag$ t[>ds ! upp] intelligible _w2 & x only beg9s to be active t[>ds u :5 x advances z f> z#caa 7fancy or repres5tation71 ! middle "p ( our be+4 ,,! ,,sup]ior ,,pr9ciple ,,n ,,always ,,utiliz$4 ,b is ! sup]ior pr9ciple n ours also8 ,surely1 b only :5 we are consci\s !re(2 = we d n always utilize our possessions4 ,?is utilization1 h[ev]1 takes place :5 we direct ?is middle "p ( our be+ t[>ds ei!r ! upp] or l[] worlds1 & :5 we actualize into en]gies :at be=e 0 only an 7,ari/otelian7 pot5tiality or a 7,/oic7 habit4 ,,! ,,animat+ ,,pr9ciple ,,( ,,animals4 ,we might def9e ! animat+ pr9ciple ( animals4 ,if x be true1 accord+ to common op9ion1 t animal bodies conta9 human s\ls t h s9n$1 ! sep>able "p ( ^! s\ls does n prop]ly belong to ^! bodies2 al?\gh ^! s\ls assi/ ^! bodies1 ! s\ls are n actually pres5t to !m4#cab ,9 !m ! s5sation is common to ! image ( ! s\l & to ! body2--b to ! latt] only 9 s f> z x is organiz$ & fa%ion$ by ! image ( ! s\l4 ,z to ! animals into ^: bodies no human s\l ent]$1 !y are produc$ by an illum9ation ( ! univ]sal ,s\l4 ,,! ,,s\l ,,bo? ,,impassible ,,& ,,puni%able4 #ab4 ,!re is a contradiction betwe5 our own =m] op9ion t ! s\l _c s91 & ! univ]sally admitt$ belief t ! s\l commits s9s1 expiates !m1 und]goes puni%m5ts 9 ,hades1 & t %e passes into new bodies4 ,al?\gh we seem to be 9 a dilemma1 =c+ u to *oose betwe5 !m1 x might be possible to %[ !y are n incompatible4 ,,philosophic ,,sep>ation ,,ref]s ,,n ,,only ,,to ,,body1 ,,b ,,to ,,passible ,,accretions4 ,:5 we attribute infallibility to ! s\l1 we are suppos+ h] to be "o & simple1 id5tify+ ! s\l ) s\l ess5ce4 ,:51 h[ev]1 we consid] h] capable ( s91 we are look+ at h] z a complex1 ( h] ess5ce & ( ano!r k9d ( s\l :i* c exp]i5ce brutal passions4 ,! s\l1 ?us1 is a comb9ation ( v>i\s elem5ts2 & x is n ! pure s\l1 b ?is comb9ation1 :i* exp]i5ces passions1 commits s9s1 & und]goes puni%m5ts4 ,x 0 ?is conception ( ! s\l ,plato 0 ref]r+ to :5 he said3#cac ,we see ! s\l z we see ,glaucus1 ! m>9e deity1 & he adds1 ,he :o w\ld "k ! nature ( ! s\l h]self %\ld1 aft] /ripp+ h] ( all t is =eign to h]1 9 h]1 especially consid] h] philosophic love = tru?2 & see to :at ?+s %e atta*es h]self1 & by virtue ( ^: aff9ities %e is :at %e is4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 diff]5tiate ! s\l's life acts f t :i* is puni%$1 & :5 we speak ( philosophy's sep>ation ( ! s\l1 we mean a deta*+ n only f ! body1 b also f :at has be5 add$ to ! s\l4 ,,h[ ,,! ,,animal ,,nature ,,is ,,g5]at$4 ,?is addition occurs dur+ h] g5]ation1 or r 9 ! g5]ation ( ano!r ideal =m ( s\l1 ! animal nature4 ,else:]e#cad ?is g5]ation has be5 expla9$ ?us4 ,:5 ! s\l desc5ds1 at ! v mom5t :5 %e incl9es t[>ds ! body1 %e produces an image ( h]self4 ,! s\l1 h[ev]1 mu/ n be blam$ = s5d+ ?is image into ! body4 ,= ! s\l to incl9e t[>ds ! body is = ! s\l to %$ light on :at is bel[ h]2 & ?is is no m s9ful ?an to produce a %ad[4 ,t :i* is blamable is ! illum9at$ object2 = if x did n exi/1 !re w\ld be no?+ to illum9ate4 ,! desc5t ( ! s\l1 or h] incl9ation to ! body1 means only t %e communicates life to :at %e illum9ates4 ,%e drives away h] image1 or lets x vani%1 if no?+ receptive is 9 its vic9ity2 ! s\l lets ! image vani%1 n because %e is sep>at$--= to speak accurately1 %e is n sep>at$ f ! body--b because %e is no long] "h bel[2 & %e is no long] bel[ :5 %e is entirely occupi$ 9 contemplat+ ! intelligible _w4 ,,! ,,d\ble ,,h]cules ,,symbolizes ,,! ,,s\l4 7,hom]7 seems to admit ?is di/9ction 9 speak+ ( ,h]cules1 :5 he s5ds ! image ( ?is h]o into ,hades1 & /ill he locates him )9 ! abode ( ! deities#cae2--;x is at lea/ ! idea impli$ 9 ?is d\ble ass]tion t ,h]cules is 9 ,hades & t he is 9 ,olympus4 ,! poet1 !re=e1 di/+ui%$ 9 him two elem5ts4 ,we might p]haps exp\nd ! passage z foll[s3 ,h]cules _h an active virtue1 & because ( 8 great qualities 0 judg$ wor?y ( be+ classifi$ ) ! deities1 b z he possess$ only ! active virtue1 & n ! contemplative virtue1 he c\ld n be admitt$ into ,heav5 entirely2 :ile he is 9 heav51 !re is some?+ ( him 9 ,hades4#caf ,,relation ,,( ,,! ,,we ,,& ,,! ,,s\l4 #ac4 ,is x we or ! s\l :i* makes ^! rese>*es8 ,x is we1 by means ( ! s\l4 ,! cause ( ?is is1 n we :o consid] ! s\l because we possess h]1 b t ! s\l consid]s h]self4 ,?is ne$ n imply motion1 z x is g5]ally und]/ood1 b a motion entirely diff]5t f t ( ! bodies1 & :i* is its own life4 ,,intellig5ce ,,n ,,ours1 ,,b ,,we4 ,intellig5ce#bgg also is ours1 b only 9 ! s5se t ! s\l is intellig5t2 = u1 ! 7high]7 life consi/s 9 a bett] ?9k+4 ,! s\l enjoys ?is life ei!r :5 %e ?9ks intelligible objects1 or :5 ! intellect is bo? a "p ( ourselves1 & some?+ sup]ior t[>ds :i* we asc5d4 ,,fir/ ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,sev54 ,( ! ,fir/ ,good1 & ( ! ,o!r ,goods4#cag ,,! ,,supreme ,,good ,,z ,,end ,,( ,,all ,,o!r ,,goods4 #a4 ,c\ld any "o say t !re 01 = any be+1 any good b ! activity ( liv+ accord+ to nature8#cah ,= a be+ compos$ ( sev]al p>ts1 h[ev]1 ! good w consi/ 9 ! activity ( its be/ "p1 an action :i* is peculi>1 natural1 & unfail+4 ,fur!r3 z ! s\l is an excell5t be+1 & directs h] activity t[>ds some?+ excell5t1 ?is excell5t aim is n m]ely excell5t relatively to ! s\l1 b is ! absolute ,good4 ,if !n !re be a pr9ciple :i* does n direct its action t[>ds any o!r ?+1 because x is ! be/ ( be+s1 be+ above !m all1 x c be ?is only because all o!r be+s tr5d t[>ds x4 ,?is !n1 evid5tly1 is ! absolute ,good by virtue ( :i* all o!r be+s p>ticipate !re94 ,,p>ticipation ,,9 ,,good4 ,,two ,,me?ods4 ,n[ !re are two me?ods ( p>ticipation 9 ! ,good3 ! fir/1 is to become simil> to x2 ! second is to direct "o's activity t[>ds x4 ,if !n ! direction ( "o's desire & "o's action t[>ds ! bett] pr9ciple be a good1 !n c ! absolute good itself nei!r reg>d nor desire any o!r ?+1 rema9+ 9 abid+ re/1 be+ ! s\rce & pr9ciple ( all actions con=m+ to nature1 giv+ to o!r ?+s ! =m ( ! ,good1 )\t act+ on !m1 z !y1 on ! contr>y1 direct _! actions !reto4 ,,p]man5ce ,,! ,,*ief ,,note ,,( ,,absolute ,,good4 ,only by p]man5ce--n by action1 nor ev5 by ?\ght--is ?is pr9ciple ! ,good4 ,= if x be sup]-,be+1 x mu/ also be sup]-,activity1 sup]-,intellig5ce1 & ,?\ght4 ,! pr9ciple f :i* ev]y?+ dep5ds1 :ile itself dep5d+ on no?+ else1 mu/1 !re=e1 be recogniz$ z ! ,good4 7,?is div9ity7 mu/1 !re=e1 p]si/ 9 ,8 condition1 :ile ev]y?+ turns t[>ds ,him1 j z1 9 a circle1 all ! radii meet 9 ! c5tre4 ,an example ( ?is is ! sun1 :i* is a c5tre ( ! light t is1 z x 71 susp5d$ f t planet4 ,! light accompanies ! sun ev]y:]e1 & nev] p>ts f x2 & ev5 if y wi%$ to sep>ate x on "o side1 x w\ld n any ! less rema9 conc5trat$ ar\nd x4 ,,all ,,?+s ,,dep5d ,,on ,,! ,,good ,,by ,,unity1 ,,ess5ce1 ,,& ,,quality4 #b4 ,let u /udy ! dep5d5ce ( ev]y?+ on ! ,good4 ,! inanimate tr5ds t[>d ! ,s\l1 :ile ! animate ,s\l tr5ds t[>ds ! ,good ?r\gh ,intellig5ce4 ,z f> z any?+ possesses unity1 ess5ce or =m1 x p>ticipates 9 ! ,good4 ,by its p>ticipation 9 unity1 ess5ce & =m ea* be+ p>ticipates 9 ! ,good1 ev5 ?\gh ! latt] be only an image1 = ! ?+s 9 :i* x p>ticipates are only images ( unity1 ess5ce1 & =m4 ,= ! 7fir/7 ,s\l#cai z %e approa*es ,intellig5ce1 %e acquires a life :i* approa*es clos] to tru?2 & %e owes ?is to ,intellig5ce2 ?us 7by virtue ( ,intellig5ce7 %e possesses ! =m ( ! ,good4 ,to possess ! latt]1 all %e ne$s to d is to turn h] looks t[>ds x2 = ,intellig5ce is ! next aft] ! ,good4 ,!re=e1 to ^? to :om x is grant$ to live1 life is ! good4 ,likewise1 = ^? :o p>ticipate 9 intellig5ce1 ,intellig5ce is ! good4 ,consequ5tly1 su* 7a be+ z7 jo9s intellig5ce to life possesses a d\ble good4 ,,!re ,,is ,,no ,,unalloy$ ,,evil ,,= ,,! ,,liv+ ,,be+4 #c4 ,?\gh life be a good1 x does n belong to all be+s4 ,life is incomplete = ! evil p]son1 z = an eye t does n see di/9ctly2 nei!r accompli% _! purpose4 ,if1 = u1 life1 ?\gh m+l$ z x is1 be a good1 ev5 if an imp]fect "o1 h[ %all we cont9ue to ass]t t dea? is n an evil8 ,b = :om w\ld x be an evil8 ,?is we mu/ ask because evil mu/ necess>ily be an attribute ( somebody4 ,n[ !re is no m evil = a be+ :i*1 ?\gh ev5 exi/+1 is depriv$ ( life1 any m ?an = a /one 7z !y say74 ,b if1 aft] dea?1 ! be+ /ill live1 if x be /ill animate1 x w possess good1 & s mu* ! m z x ex]cises its faculties )\t ! body4 ,if x be unit$ to ! univ]sal ,s\l1 evid5tly !re c be no evil = x1 any m ?an = ! gods :o possess good unm+l$ ) evil4 ,simil> is ! case ( ! s\l :i* pres]ves h] purity1 inasmu* z he :o loses h] f9ds t life1 & n dea?1 is ! real ,evil4 ,if !re be *a/isem5ts 9 ,hades1 aga9 is life an evil = ! s\l1 because %e is n pure4 ,if1 fur!r1 we def9e life z ! union ( ! s\l ) ! body1 & dea? z _! sep>ation1 ! s\l c pass ?r\gh bo? ^! conditions 7)\t1 on t acc\nt1 be+ unhappy1 or los+ h] hold on ! ,good74 ,,by ,,virtue1 ,,life ,,*anges ,,f ,,an ,,evil ,,to ,a ,,good4 ,h[ is dea? n an evil1 if life be a good8 ,c]ta9ly life is a good = su* z possess ! ,good1 7x is a good7 n because ! s\l is unit$ to ! body1 b because %e repels evil by virtue4 7,)\t ! latt]7 dea? w\ld r be a good 7because x deliv]s u f ! body#cbj74 ,to resume3 by itself1 life 9 a body is evil2 b1 by virtue1 ! s\l locates h]self 9 ! good1 n by p]petuat+ ! exi/+ corporeal union1 b by sep>at+ h]self f ! body4 ,,porphyry1 ,,comm5t>ies ,,or ,,outl9es ,,( ,,! ,,enneads ,,( ,,plot9os4 ,,psy*ological ,,fragm5ts ,,by ,,porphyry1 ,,jambli*us1 ,,nemesius1 ,,& ,,ammonius ,,saccas4 ,,concordance ,,( ,,! ,,numb]s ,,( ,,! #dd ,,p>agraphs ,,( ,,porphyry',s ,,pr9ciples ,,( ,,! ,,!ory ,,( ,,intelligibles ,,9 ,,! ,,editions ,,( ,,b\illet1 ,,creuz]1 ,,& ,,hol/5ius ,b\illet4 ,creuz]4 ,hol/5ius4 #a #cd #cd #b #h #h #c #i #i #d #bg #bh #e #bj #bj #f #ah #ah #g #bd #be #h #ai #ai #i #g #g #aa #bb #bc #ab #aj #aj #ac #ab #ab #ad #bf #bg #ae #a #a #af #b #b #ag #c #c #ah #d #d #ai #e #e #bj #f #f #ba #bh #bi #bb #bi #cj #bc #bb #bc #bd #ag #ag #be #af #af #bf #aa #aa #bg #be #bf #bh #ad #ad #bi #ac #ac #cj #cj #ca #ca #db #dc #cb #dd #de #cc #ae #ae #cd #bc #bd #ce #dc #dd #cf #ce #ce #cg #cf #cg #ch #cg #ch #ci #ci #dj #dj #dj #da #da #cc #cf #db #ch #ci #dc #ca #cb #dd #da #db ,! ord] ( ,b\illet has be5 left1 because ! o!r ord]s diff] anyway1 & because ?is is ! "o t ,porphyry introduc$ into ! works ( ,plot9os4 ,x mu/1 !re=e1 h be5 ( mo/ significance to him4 ,,pr9ciples ,,( ,,! ,,!ory ,,( ,,! ,,intelligibles1 ,,by ,,porphyry4#cba ,,fir/ ,,ennead1#cbb ,,book ,,two4 ,( ,virtues4 ,i4--,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 ! virtues ( ! citiz51 ^? ( ! man :o essays to rise to contemplation1 & :o1 on ?is acc\nt1 is said to possess a contemplative m9d2 ^? ( him :o contemplates intellig5ce2 & f9ally ^? ( pure ,intellig5ce1 :i* is completely sep>at$ f ! s\l4 #a4 ,! civil virtues consi/ ( mod]ation 9 passions1 & 9 lett+ "o's actions foll[ ! rational laws ( duty4 ,! object ( ^! virtues be+ to make u b5evol5t 9 our deal+s ) our fell[-human be+s1 !y are call$ civil virtues because !y mutually unite citiz5s4 ,prud5ce ref]s to ! rational "p ( our s\l2 c\rage1 to t "p ( ! s\l subject to ang]2 temp]ance consi/s 9 ! agreem5t & h>mony ( appetite & reason2 f9ally ju/ice1 consi/s 9 ! accompli%m5t1 by all ^! faculties1 ( ! function prop] to ea* ( !m1 ei!r to comm&1 or to obey4 #b4 ,! virtues ( ! man :o tries to rise to contemplation consi/ 9 deta*+ oneself f ?+s "h bel[2 t is :y !y are call$ purifications4#cbc ,!y comm& u to ab/a9 f activities :i* inn]vate ! organs1 & :i* excite ! affections t relate to ! body4 ,! object ( ^! virtues is to raise ! s\l to g5u9e exi/5ce4 ,:ile ! civil virtues are ! ornam5t ( mortal life1 & prep>e ! s\l = ! purificatory virtues1 ! latt] direct ! man :om !y adorn to ab/a9 f activities 9 :i* ! body pr$om9ates4 ,?us1 9 ! purificatory virtues1 prud5ce consi/s 9 n =m+ op9ions 9 h>mony ) ! body1 b 9 act+ by oneself1 :i* is ! "w ( pure ?\ght4 ,temp]ance consi/s 9 n %>+ ! passions ( ! body2 c\rage1 9 n fe>+ sep>ation !refrom1 z if dea? drove man into empt9ess & annihilation2 :ile ju/ice exacts t reason & intellig5ce comm& & be obey$4 ,! civil virtues mod]ate ! passions2 _! object is to tea* u to live 9 con=mity ) ! laws ( human nature4 ,! contemplative virtues oblit]ate ! passions f ! s\l2 _! object is to assimilate man to ! div9ity4 ,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 purify+ oneself1 & be+ pure4 ,consequ5tly ! purificatory virtues may1 l purification itself1 be consid]$ 9 two lights2 !y purify ! s\l1 & !y adorn ! purifi$ s\l1 because ! object ( purification is purity4 ,b s9ce purification & purity consi/ 9 be+ sep>at$ f e =eign entity1 ! good is some?+ diff]5t f ! s\l t purifies itself4 ,if ! s\l t purifies h]self _h possess$ ! good be=e los+ h] purity1 x w\ld be suffici5t = ! s\l to purify h]self2 b 9 ?is v case1 :at w\ld rema9 to h] aft] ! purification w\ld be ! good1 b n ! purification4 ,b ! s\l is n ! good2 %e c only p>ticipate !re91 & h its =m2 o!rwise ! s\l w\ld n h fall5 into evil4 ,= ! s\l1 good consi/s 9 be+ unit$ to h] au?or1 & h] evil is to unite ) l[] ?+s4#cbd ,( evil1 !re are two k9ds2 ! "o1 is to unite ) l[] ?+s2 ! o!r is to ab&on oneself to ! passions4 ,! civil virtues owe _! "n ( virtues & _! value to _! releas+ ! s\l f "o ( ^! two k9ds ( evil 7( ! passions74 ,! purificatory virtues are sup]ior to ! =m]1 9 t !y free ! s\l f h] *>act]i/ic =m ( evil 7t is1 union ) l[] ?+s74 ,!re=e1 :5 ! s\l is pure1 %e mu/ be unit$ to h] au?or2 h] virtue1 aft] h] conv]sion1 consi/s 9 h] k & sci5ce ( v]itable exi/5ce2 n t ! s\l lacks ?is k1 b because )\t h] sup]ior pr9ciple1 )\t intellig5ce1 %e does n see :at %e possesses4#cbe #c4 ,!re is a ?ird k9d ( virtues1 :i* are sup]ior to ! civil & purificatory virtues1 ! virtues ( ! s\l t contemplates intellig5ce4 ,"h prud5ce & wisdom consi/ 9 contemplat+ ! be+s or ess5ces conta9$ by intellig5ce2 ju/ice consi/s 9 ! s\l's fulfill+ ( h] *>act]i/ic function2 t is1 9 atta*+ h]self to intellig5ce & to direct h] activity ?i!r4 ,temp]ance is ! intimate conv]sion ( ! s\l t[>ds ,intellig5ce1 :ile c\rage is ! impassibility by :i* ! s\l becomes assimilat$ to :at %e contemplates1 s9ce ! s\l's nature is to be impassible4#cbf ,^! virtues are z intimately concat5at$ z ! o!r 7l[] =ms74 #d4 ,!re is a f\r? k9d ( virtues1 ! exempl>y virtues1 :i* reside )9 intellig5ce4 ,_! sup]iority to ! virtues ( ! s\l is ! same z t ( ! type to ! image2 = intellig5ce conta9s simultane\sly all ! be+s or ess5ces :i* are ! types ( l[] ?+s4 ,)9 intellig5ce1 prud5ce is ! sci5ce2 wisdom is ! ?\ght1 temp]ance is ! conv]sion t[>ds oneself2 ju/ice is ! accompli%m5t ( "o's *>act]i/ic function2 c\rage is ! id5tity ( intellig5ce1 its p]sev]ance 9 purity1 conc5trat$ )9 itself1 9 virtue ( its sup]iority4#cbg ,we ?us h f\r k9ds ( virtues3 #a1 ! exempl>y virtues1 *>act]i/ic ( intellig5ce1 & ( ! be+ or nature to :i* !y belong2 #b1 ! virtues ( ! s\l turn$ t[>ds intellig5ce1 & fill$ ) h] contemplation2 #c1 ! virtues ( ! s\l t purifies h]self1 or :i* has purifi$ h]self f ! brutal passions *>act]i/ic ( ! body2 #d1 ! virtues t adorn ! man by re/ra9+ )9 n>r[ limits ! action ( ! irrational "p1 & by mod]at+ ! passions4 ,he :o possesses ! virtues ( ! sup]ior ord] necess>ily 7pot5tially7 possesses ! inf]ior virtues4 ,b ! conv]se does n occur4#cbh ,he :o possesses ! sup]ior virtues w n pref] to practice ! l[] virtues because ( ! m]e possession !re(2 he w practice !m only :5 circum/ances w invite 7x74 ,! objects1 inde$1 diff] ) ! k9d ( virtues4 ,! object ( ! civil virtues is to mod]ate our passions s z to con=m our conduct to ! laws ( human nature4 ,t ( ! purificatory virtues is to deta* ! s\l completely f ! passions4 ,t ( ! contemplative virtues is to apply ! s\l to intellectual op]ations1 ev5 to ! ext5t ( no long] hav+ to ?9k ( ! ne$ ( free+ oneself f ! passions4 ,la/1 t ( ! exempl>y virtues is simil> to t ( ! o!r virtues4 ,?us ! practical virtues make man virtu\s2 ! purificatory virtues make man div9e1 or make ( ! good man1 a protect+ deity2 ! contemplative virtues deify2 :ile ! exempl>y virtues make a man ! p>5t ( div9ities4 ,we %\ld specially apply ourselves to purificatory virtues believ+ t we c acquire !m ev5 9 ?is life2 & t possession ( !m leads to sup]ior virtues4 ,we mu/ pu% purification z f> z possible1 z x consi/s 9 sep>at+ 7! s\l7 f ! body1 & 9 free+ oneself f any passional movem5t ( ! irrational "p4 ,b h[ c "o purify ! s\l8 ,to :at limit may purification be pu%$8 ,^! are two que/ions t dem& exam9ation4 ,to beg9 )1 ! f\ndation ( purification is to "k oneself1 to realize t he is a s\l b\nd to a =eign be+1 ( a diff]5t nature 7or1 be+74 ,fur!r1 :5 "o is conv9c$ ( ?is tru?1 "o %\ld ga!r oneself toge!r )9 himself1 deta*+ himself f ! body1 & free+ himself entirely f ! passions4 ,he :o makes use ( 8 s5ses too (t51 ?\gh x be done )\t devotion or pleasure1 is1 nev]!less1 di/ract$ by ! c>e ( ! body1 & is *a9$ !reto by s5sation4 ,! pa9s & ! pleasures produc$ by s5se-objects ex]cise a great influ5ce on ! s\l1 & inspire ! s\l ) an incl9ation = ! body4 ,x is important to remove su* a disposition f ! s\l4 ,to a*ieve ?is purpose1 ! s\l w all[ ! body only necess>y pleasures1 t s]ve to cure h] ( h] suff]+s1 to refre% h] f h] exhau/ions1 to h9d] h] f be+ importunate4 ,! s\l w free h]self f pa9s2#cbg if ?is be beyond h] p[]s1 ! s\l w support !m pati5tly1 & w dim9i% !m1 :ile refus+ to %>e !m4 ,! s\l w appease ang] s f> z possible2 %e w ev5 try to suppress !m entirely2 at lea/1 if t be impossible1 %e w n volunt>ily p>ticipate !re91 leav+ ! non-reflective excitem5t to ano!r 7animal7 nature1 r$uc+ ! involunt>y motions z f> z possible4 ,! s\l w be inaccessible to fe>--hav+ no?+ fur!r to risk2 ev5 s1 %e w re/ra9 e sudd5 movem5t2 %e w pay att5tion to fe> only ins(> z x may be nature's w>n+ at ! approa* ( dang]4 ,absolutely no?+ %ameful w be desir$2 9 eat+ & dr9k+1 %e w seek only ! satisfaction ( a ne$1 :ile rema9+ ess5tially ali5 !reto4 ,! pleasures ( love w n ev5 involunt>ily be ta/$1 at lea/1 %e w n all[ h]self to be drawn beyond ! flights ( fancy t occur 9 dreams4 ,9 ! purifi$ man1 ! intellectual "p ( ! s\l w be pure ( all ^! passions4 ,%e w ev5 desire t ! "p t exp]i5ces ! irrational passions ( ! body %\ld take notice ( !m )\t be+ agitat$ !reby1 & )\t yield+ to !m4 ,9 ?is way1 if ! irrational "p %\ld itself happ5 to exp]i5ce emotions1 ! latt] w be promptly calm$ by ! pres5ce ( reason4 ,/ruggles w h be5 left beh9d be=e any headway w h be5 made to purification4 ,! pres5ce ( reason w suffice2 ! inf]ior pr9ciple1 inde$1 w respect ! high] "o to ! ext5t ( be+ angry ) itself1 & reproa*+ itself = weakness1 9 case x feels any agitation t di/urbs its ma/]'s re/4 ,s long z ! s\l exp]i5ces ev5 mod]ate passions1 ! s\l's progress t[>ds impassibility rema9s 9 ne$ ( improvem5t4 ,! s\l is impassible only :5 %e has entirely ceas$ to p>ticipate 9 ! passions ( ! body4 ,inde$1 t :i* p]mitt$ ! passions to rule 0 t reason relax$ ! re9s z a result ( h] own incl9ation4 ,,fir/ ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,n9e4 ,( ,suicide4 ,,( ,,! ,,sep>ation ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,& ,,body4 #b4 ,nature releases :at nature has b\nd4 ,! s\l releases :at ! s\l has b\nd4 ,nature b9ds ! body to ! s\l1 b x is ! s\l h]self t has b\nd h]self to ! body4 ,x1 !re=e1 belongs to nature to deta* ! body f ! s\l1 :ile x is ! s\l h]self t deta*es h]self f ! body4 #c4 ,!re is a d\ble dea?4 ,"o1 kn[n by all m51 consi/s 9 ! sep>ation ( ! body ) ! s\l2 ! o!r1 *>act]i/ic ( philosoph]s1 results 9 ! sep>ation ( ! s\l f ! body4 ,! latt] is consequ5ce ( ! =m]4 ,,second ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,f\r4 ,( ,matt]4 ,,( ,,! ,,conception ,,( ,,matt] 7#aj74 #d4 ,:ile sep>at+ ourselves f exi/5ce we by ?\ght beget non5tity 7matt]74 ,:ile rema9+ unit$ ) exi/5ce1 we also conceive ( non5tity 7! "o74 ,consequ5tly1 :5 we sep>ate ourselves f exi/5ce1 we d n conceive ( ! non5tity :i* is above exi/5ce 7! "o71 b we beget by ?\ght some?+ t is deceptive1 & we put ourselves 9 ! condition 7( indet]m9ation7 9 :i* "o is :5 outside ( oneself4 ,j z ea* "o c really1 & by himself1 raise himself to ! non-exi/5ce :i* is above exi/5ce 7! ,"o72 s 7by sep>at+ oneself f exi/5ce by ?\ght71 we may rea* ! non5tity b5ea? exi/5ce4 ,,?ird ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,six4 ,( ! ,impassibility ( ,incorporeal ,?+s4 ,,( ,,! ,,incorporeal 7#c74 #e4 ,! "n incorporeal does n designate "o & ! same g5us1 z does ! ^w body4 ,incorporeal entities d]ive _! "n f ! fact t !y are conceiv$ ( by ab/raction f ! body4 ,consequ5tly1 "s ( !m 7l intellig5ce & discursive reason7 are g5u9e be+s1 exi/+ z well )\t z )9 ! body1 subsi/+ by !mselves1 by !mselves be+ actualizations & lives2 o!r be+s 7su* z matt]1 s5se-=m )\t matt]1 place1 "t1 & s =?71 d n con/itute real be+s1 b are unit$ to ! body1 & dep5d !refrom1 live ?r\gh o!rs1 possess only a relative life1 & exi/ only ?r\gh c]ta9 actualizations4 ,inde$1 :5 we apply to !m ! "n ( incorporeal entities 7x is m]ely a negative designation71 indicat+ only :at !y are n1 b n :at !y are4 ,,( ,,! ,,impassibility ,,( ,,! ,,s\l4 #f4 7#a7 ,! s\l is a be+ or ess5ce1 )\t ext5sion1 immat]ial & incorruptible2 h] nature consi/s 9 a life :i* is life 9 itself4 #g4 7#c1 end7 ,:5 ! exi/5ce ( "s be+ is life itself1 & :5 ! passions are lives1 its dea? consi/s 9 a life ( a c]ta9 nature1 & n 9 entire privation ( life2 = ! passion exp]i5c$ by ?is be+ or ess5ce1 does n =ce x into complete loss ( life4 #h4 7#b1 #c7 ,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 ! affections ( ! bodies1 & ^? ( incorporeal ?+s4 ,! affection ( bodies consi/s 9 *ange4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! affections & exp]i5ces *>act]i/ic ( ! s\l are actualizations t h no?+ 9 common ) ! cool+ or heat+ up ( ! bodies4 ,consequ5tly if1 = bodies1 an affection ev] implies a *ange1 we may say t all incorporeal 7be+s7 are impassible4 ,inde$1 immat]ial & incorporeal be+s are always id5tical 9 _! actualization2 b ^? t imp+e on matt] & bodies1 ?\gh 9 !mselves impassible1 all[ ! subjects 9 :i* !y reside to be affect$4 ,s :5 an animal feels1 ! s\l resembles a h>mony sep>at$ f its in/rum5t1 :i* itself causes ! vibration ( ! /r+s t h be5 tun$ to unison h]e)2 :ile ! body resembles a h>mony insep>able f ! /r+s4 ,! reason :y ! s\l moves ! liv+ be+ is t ! latt] is animat$4 ,we1 !re=e1 f9d an analogy betwe5 ! s\l & ! musician :o causes 8 in/rum5t to produce s\nds because he himself conta9s a h>monic p[]4 ,! body1 /ruck by a s5se-impression1 resembles /r+s tun$ 9 unison4 ,9 ! production ( s\nd1 x is n ! h>mony itself b ! /r+ t is affect$4 ,! musician causes x to res\nd because he conta9s a h>monic p[]4 ,nev]!less1 9 spite ( ! w ( ! musician1 ! in/rum5t w\ld produce no h>monies t con=m$ to ! laws ( music1 unless h>mony itself dictat$ !m4 #i4 7#e7 ,! s\l b9ds h]self to ! body by a conv]sion t[>d ! affections exp]i5c$ by ! body4 ,%e deta*es h]self f ! body by apa?y1 7turn+ away f ! body's affections47 ,,( ,,! ,,impassibility ,,( ,,matt]4 #aj4 7#g7 ,accord+ to ! anci5t 7sages7 su* are ! prop]ties ( matt]4 ,matt] is incorporeal because x diff]s f bodies4 ,matt] is n lifeless1 because x is nei!r intellig5ce1 nor s\l1 nor any?+ t lives by itself4 ,x is =mless1 v>iable1 inf9ite1 impot5t2 consequ5tly1 matt] _c be exi/5ce1 b non5tity4 ,( c\rse x is n non5tity 9 ! same way t movem5t is non5tity2 matt] is non5tity really4 ,x is an image & a phantom ( ext5sion1 because x is ! prim>y sub/rate ( ext5sion4 ,x is impot5ce1 & ! desire = exi/5ce4 ,! only reason t x p]si/s is n re/ 7b *ange72 x always seems to conta9 contr>ies1 ! great & small1 ! less & m1 lack & excess4 ,x is always becom+1 )\t ev] p]si/+ 9 its condition1 or be+ able to come out ( x4 ,matt] is ! lack ( all exi/5ce2 &1 consequ5tly1 :at matt] seems to be is a deception4 ,if1 = in/ance1 matt] seems to be l>ge1 x really is small2 l a m]e phantom1 x escapes & evanesces into non5tity1 n by any *ange ( place1 b by its lack ( reality4 ,consequ5tly1 ! sub/rate ( ! images 9 matt] consi/s ( a l[] image4 ,t 9 :i* objects pres5t appe>ances t diff] accord+ to _! positions is a mirror1 a mirror t seems cr[d$1 ?\gh x possesses no?+1 & :i* yet seems to be ev]y?+4 ,,( ,,! ,,passibility ,,( ,,! ,,body 7#h-ai74 #aa4 ,passions 7or1 affections7 ref] to some?+ de/ructible2 = x is passion t leads to de/ruction2 x is ! same sort ( be+ t c be affect$1 & c be de/roy$4 ,incorporeal entities1 h[ev]1 are n subject to de/ruction2 !y ei!r exi/ or n2 9 ei!r case !y are non-affectible4 ,t :i* c be affect$ ne$ n h ?is impassible nature1 b mu/ be subject to alt]ation or de/ruction by ! qualities ( ?+s t ent] into x & affect x2 = t :i* 9 x subsi/s is n alt]$ by ! fir/ *ance entity4 ,consequ5tly1 matt] is impassible1 z by itself x possesses no quality4 ,! =ms t ent] into & issue f matt] 7z a sub/rate7 are equally impassible4 ,t :i* is affect$ is ! composite ( =m & matt]1 ^: exi/5ce consi/s 9 ! union ( ^! two elem5ts2 = x is evid5tly subject to ! action ( contr>y p[]s1 & ( ! qualities ( ?+s :i* ent] into x1 & affect x4 ,t is :y ! be+s t d]ive _! exi/5ce f some?+ else1 in/ead ( possess+ x by !mselves1 c likewise by virtue ( _! passivity1 ei!r live or n4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! be+s ^: exi/5ce consi/s 9 an impassible life necess>ily live p]man5tly2 likewise ! ?+s t d n live are equally impassible inasmu* z !y d n live4 ,consequ5tly1 be+ *ang$ & be+ affect$ ref] only to ! composite ( =m & matt]1 to ! body1 & n to matt]4 ,likewise1 to receive life & to lose x1 to feel passions t are its consequ5ce1 c ref] only to ! composite ( s\l & body4 ,no?+ simil> c\ld happ5 to ! s\l2 = %e is n some?+ comp\nd$ out ( life & lifelessness2 %e is life itself1 because h] be+ or nature is simple1 & is automatic4 ,,?ird ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,eight4 ,( ,nature1 ,contemplation1 & ( ! ,"o4 ,,( ,,?\ght4 #ab4 7#a7 ,?\ght is n ! same ev]y:]e2 x diff]s accord+ to ! nature ( e be+4 ,9 intellig5ce1 x is intellectual2 9 ! s\l x is rational2 9 ! plant x is sem9al2 la/1 x is sup]ior to intellig5ce & exi/5ce 9 ! pr9ciple t surpasses all ^!4 ,,( ,,life4 #ac4 7#g7 ,! ^w body is n ! only "o t may be tak5 9 diff]5t s5ses2 su* is also ! case ) life4 ,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 ! life ( ! plant1 ( ! animal1 ( ! s\l1 ( intellig5ce1 & ( sup]-intellig5ce4 ,inde$1 intelligible entities are alive ?\gh ! ?+s t proce$ !refrom d n possess a life simil> to !irs4 ,,( ,,! ,,"o4 #ad4 7#h7 ,by 7us+ "o's7 intellig5ce "o may say _m ?+s ab\t ! sup]-intellectual 7pr9ciple74 ,b x c be mu* bett] view$ by an abs5ce ( ?\ght1 ?an by ?\ght4 ,?is is v mu* ! same case z t ( sleep1 ( :i* "o c speak1 up to a c]ta9 po9t1 dur+ ! condition ( wakefulness2 b ( :i* no k ( p]ception c be acquir$ except by sleep+4 ,inde$1 l is kn[n only by l2 ! condition ( all k is = ! subject to be assimilat$ to ! subject4#ccj ,,f\r? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,two4 ,( ! ,nature ( ! ,s\l4 #ae4 7#a7 ,e body is 9 a place2 ! incorporeal 9 itself is n 9 a place1 any m ?an ! ?+s :i* h ! same nature z x4 #af4 7#a7 ,! incorporeal 9 itself1 by ! m]e fact ( its be+ sup]ior to e body & to e place1 is pres5t ev]y:]e )\t occupy+ ext5sion1 9 an indivisible mann]4 #ag4 7#a7 ,! incorporeal 9 itself1 n be+ pres5t to ! body 9 a local mann]1 is pres5t to ! body :5ev] x pleases1 t is1 by incl9+ t[>ds x s f> z x is )9 its nature to d s4 ,n be+ pres5t to ! body 9 a local mann]1 x is pres5t to ! body by its disposition4 #ah4 7#a7 ,! incorporeal 9 itself does n become pres5t to ! body 9 be+ nor 9 hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce4 ,x does n m+le ) ! body4 ,nev]!less1 by its incl9ation to ! body1 x begets & communicates to x a pot5tiality capable ( unit+ ) ! body4 ,inde$ ! incl9ation ( ! incorporeal con/itutes a second nature 7! irrational s\l71 :i* unites ) ! body4 #ai4 7#a7 ,! s\l has a nature int]m$i>y betwe5 ! be+ t is indivisible1 & ! be+ t is divisible by its union ) ! bodies4 ,intellig5ce is a be+ absolutely indivisible2 ! bodies alone are divisible2 b ! qualities & ! =ms engag$ 9 matt] are divisible by _! union ) ! bodies4 #bj4 7#b7 ,! ?+s t act ^u o!rs d n act by approximation & by contact4 ,x is only accid5tally :5 ?is occurs 7t !y act by proximity & contact74 ,,f\r? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,?ree4 ,problems ,ab\t ! ,s\l4 ,,union ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,& ,,! ,,body4 #ba4 7#bj7 ,! hypo/atic sub/ance ( ! body does n h9d] ! incorporeal 9 itself f be+ :]e & z x wi%es2 = j z t :i* is non-ext5d$ _c be conta9$ by ! body1 s also t :i* has ext5sion =ms no ob/acle = ! incorporeal1 & 9 relation to x is z non5tity4 ,! incorporeal does n transport itself :]e x wi%es by a *ange ( place2 = only ext5d$ sub/ance occupies a place4 ,nei!r is ! incorporeal compress$ by ! body2 = only t :i* is ext5d$ c be compress$ & displac$4 ,t :i* has nei!r ext5sion nor magnitude1 c\ld n be h9d]$ by t :i* has ext5sion1 nor be expos$ to a *ange ( place4 ,be+ ev]y:]e & n[h]e1 ! incorporeal1 :]ev] x happ5s to be1 betrays its pres5ce only by a c]ta9 k9d ( disposition4 ,x is by ?is disposition t x rises above heav51 or desc5ds into a corn] ( ! _w4 ,n ev5 ?is resid5ce makes x visible to our eyes4 ,x is only by its works t x manife/s its pres5ce4 #bb4 7#ba-bd7 ,if ! incorporeal be conta9$ )9 ! body1 x is n conta9$ )9 x l an animal 9 a zological g>d52 = x c nei!r be includ$ )91 nor embrac$ by ! body4 ,nor is x1 compress$ l wat] or air 9 a bag ( sk9s4 ,x produces pot5tialities :i* f )9 its unity 787 radiate outw>ds2 x is by !m t x desc5ds into ! body & p5etrates x4#cca ,x is by ?is indescribable ext5sion ( itself t x ent]s into ! body1 & %uts itself up )9 x4 ,except itself no?+ reta9s x4 ,x is n ! body t releases ! incorporeal z result ( a lesion1 or ( its decay2 x is ! incorporeal t deta*es itself by turn+ away f ! passions ( ! body4 ,,( ,,! ,,desc5t ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,into ,,! ,,body1 ,,& ,,( ,,! ,,_s4 #bc4 7#i7 ,j z be+ on ! e>?1 = ! s\l1 is n to tread on ! gr\nd1 z does ! body1 b only to preside ov] ! body t treads on ! gr\nd2 likewise1 to be 9 hell = ! s\l1 is to preside ov] an image ^: nature is to be 9 a place1 & to h an obscure hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce4 ,t is :y if ! subt]ranean hell be a d>k place1 ! s\l1 )\t sep>at+ f exi/5ce1 desc5ds into hell :5 %e atta*es h]self to "s image4 ,inde$1 :5 ! s\l ab&ons ! solid body ov] :i* %e presid$ %e rema9s unit$ to ! _s :i* %e has receiv$ f ! cele/ial sph]es4 ,s9ce1 z a result ( h] affection = matt]1 %e has develop$ p>ticul> faculties by virtue ( :i* %e _h a sympa!tic habit = "s p>ticul> body dur+ life1 z a result ( ?is disposition1 %e impresses a =m on ! _s by ! p[] ( h] imag9ation1 & ?us %e acquires an image4 ,! s\l is said to be 9 hell because ! _s t surr\nds h] also happ5s to h a =mless & obscure nature2 & z ! heavy & moi/5$ _s desc5ds d[n into subt]ranean localities1 ! s\l is said to desc5d und]gr\nd4 ,n inde$ t ! v be+ ( ! s\l *anges place1 or is 9 a locality1 b because %e contracts ! habits ( ! bodies ^: nature x is to *ange location1 & to be locat$ some:]e4 ,t is :y ! s\l accord+ to h] disposition1 acquires "s "o body r ?an "s o!r2 = ! rank & ! special *>act]i/ics ( ! body into :i* %e ent]s dep5d on h] disposition4 ,!re=e1 :5 9 a condition ( sup]ior purity1 %e unites ) a body t is close to immat]ial nature1 t is1 an e!real body4 ,:5 %e desc5ds f ! developm5t ( reason to t ( ! imag9ation1 %e receives a sol> body4 ,if %e becomes effem9ate1 & falls 9 love ) =ms1 %e puts on a lun> body4 ,f9ally1 :5 %e falls into ! t]re/rial bodies1 :i*1 resembl+ h] %apeless "*1 are compos$ ( moi/ vapors1 !re results = h] a complete ignorance ( exi/5ce1 a sort ( eclipse1 & a v]itable *ildhood4 ,:5 ! s\l leaves an e>?ly body1 hav+ h] _s /ill tr\bl$ by ^! moi/ vapors1 %e develops a %ad[ t weights h] d[n2 = a _s ( ?is k9d naturally t5ds to desc5d into ! dep?s ( ! e>?1 unless x be held up & rais$ by a high] cause4 ,j z ! s\l is atta*$ to ! e>? by h] e>?ly ve/ure1 s ! moi/ _s7ual body7 to :i* ! s\l is unit$ makes h] drag aft] h] an image :i* weights d[n ! s\l4 ,! s\l surr\nds h]self ) moi/ vapors :5 %e m+les ) a nature t 9 its op]ations is moi/ or subt]ranean4 ,b if ! s\l sep>ate f ?is nature1 imm$iately ar\nd h] %9es a dry light1 )\t %ade or %ad[4 ,9 fact x is humidity :i* =ms cl\ds 9 ! air2 ! dryness ( ! atmosph]e produces a dry & s]5e cle>ness4 ,,f\r? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,six4 ,( ,s5sation & ,memory4 ,,( ,,s5sation4 #bd4 7#c7 ,! s\l conta9s ! reasons ( all ?+s4 ,! s\l op]ates accord+ to ^! reasons1 :e!r incit$ to activity by "s ext]ior object1 or :e!r ! s\l be turn$ t[>ds ^! reasons by fold+ back on h]self4 ,:5 ! s\l is incit$ to ?is activity by "s ext]ior object1 %e applies h] s5ses !reto2 :5 %e folds back on h]self1 %e applies h]self to ?\ghts4 ,x might be object$ t ! result is t !re is nei!r s5sation nor ?\ght )\t imag9ation2 = j z 9 ! animal "p1 no s5sation occurs )\t an impression produc$ on ! organs ( s5se2 likewise !re is no ?\ght )\t imag9ation4 ,c]ta9ly1 an analogy obta9s betwe5 bo? cases4 ,j z ! s5se-image 7type7 results f ! impression exp]i5c$ by s5sation1 likewise ! intellectual image 7phantasm7 results f ?\ght4 ,,( ,,memory4 #be4 7#b7 ,memory does n consi/ 9 pres]v+ images4 ,x is ! faculty ( reproduc+ ! conceptions ) :i* our s\l has be5 occupi$4 ,,fif? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,two4 ,( ,g5]ation & ( ! ,ord] ( ,?+s t ,foll[ ! ,fir/4 ,,( ,,! ,,procession ,,( ,,be+s4 #bf4 ,:5 incorporeal hypo/atic sub/ances desc5d1 !y split up & multiply1 _! p[] weak5+ z !y apply !mselves to ! individual4 ,:51 on ! contr>y1 !y rise1 !y simplify1 unite1 & _! p[] int5sifies4 #bg4 ,9 ! life ( incorporeal entities1 ! procession op]ates 9 a mann] su* t ! sup]ior pr9ciple rema9s firm & sub/antial 9 its nature1 imp>t+ its exi/5ce to :at is bel[ x1 )\t los+ any?+1 or trans=m+ itself into any?+4 ,?us t :i* receives exi/5ce does n receive exi/5ce ) decay or alt]ation2 x is n begott5 l g5]ation 7t is1 ! be+ ( s5se71 :i* p>ticipates 9 decay & *ange4 ,x is1 !re=e1 non-begott5 & incorruptible1 because x is produc$ )\t g5]ation or corruption4 #bh4 ,e begott5 ?+ d]ives ! cause ( its g5]ation f "s o!r 7be+72 = no?+ is begott5 causelessly4 ,b1 among begott5 ?+s1 ^? :i* owe _! be+ to a union ( elem5ts are on t v acc\nt p]i%able4 ,z to ^? :i*1 n be+ composite1 owe _! be+ to ! simplicity ( _! hypo/atic sub/ances1 !y are imp]i%able1 inasmu* z !y are indissoluble4 ,:5 we say t !y are begott51 we d n mean t !y are composite1 b only t !y dep5d on "s cause4 ,?us bodies are begott5 d\bly1 fir/ because !y dep5d on a cause1 & !n because !y are composite4 ,s\ls & intellig5ce1 inde$1 are begott5 9 ! respect t !y dep5d on a cause2 b n 9 ! respect t !y are composite4 ,!re=e1 bodies1 be+ d\bly begott51 are dissoluble & p]i%able4 ,! ,s\l & ,intellig5ce1 be+ unbegott5 9 ! s5se t !y are n composite1 are indissoluble & imp]i%able2 = !y are begott5 only 9 ! s5se t !y dep5d on a cause4 #bi4 ,e pr9ciple t g5]ates1 by virtue ( its be+1 is sup]ior to ! product x g5]ates4 ,e g5]at$ be+ naturally turns t[>ds its g5]at+ pr9ciple4 ,( ! g5]at+ pr9ciples1 "s 7! univ]sal & p]fect sub/ances7 d n turn t[>ds _! product2 :ile o!rs 7! sub/ances t are individual1 & subject to conv]sion t[>ds ! manifold7 p>tly turn t[>ds _! product1 & rema9 p>tly turn$ t[>ds !mselves2 :ile o!rs entirely turn t[>ds _! product1 & d n turn at all t[>ds !mselves4 ,,( ,,! ,,return ,,( ,,be+s ,,to ,,! ,,fir/4 #cj4 ,( ! univ]sal & p]fect hypo/atic sub/ances1 none turns t[>ds its product4 ,all p]fect hypo/atic sub/ances return to ! pr9ciples t g5]at$ !m4 ,! v body ( ! _w1 by ! m]e fact ( its p]fection1 is conv]t$ to ! intellig5t ,s\l1 & t is ! cause ( its motion be+ circul>4 ,! ,s\l ( ! _w is conv]t$ to ,intellig5ce1 & ?is to ! ,fir/4#ccb ,all be+s1 !re=e1 aspire to ! ,fir/1 ea* 9 ! measure ( its ability1 f ! v l[e/ 9 ! ranks ( ! univ]se up4 ,?is anagogical return ( be+s to ! ,fir/ is necess>y1 :e!r x be m$iate or imm$iate4 ,s we may say t be+s n only aspire to ! ,fir/1 b t ea* be+ enjoys ! ,fir/ accord+ to its capacity4#ccc ,! individual hypo/atic sub/ances1 h[ev]1 t are subject to decl9+ t[>ds manifoldness1 naturally turn n only t[>ds _! au?or1 b also t[>ds _! product4 ,t is ! cause ( 7any subsequ5t7 fall & unfai?fulness4 ,matt] p]v]ts !m because !y possess ! possibility ( incl9+ t[>ds x1 ?\gh !y are also able to turn t[>ds ! div9ity4 ,t is h[ p]fection makes second rank be+s be born ( ! fir/ pr9ciples1 & !n be conv]t$ t[>ds !m4 ,x is1 on ! contr>y1 ! result ( imp]fection1 to turn high] entities to l[] ?+s1 inspir+ !m ) love = t :i*1 be=e !m1 )drew f ! fir/ pr9ciples 79 favor ( matt]74 ,,fif? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,?ree4 ,( ! ,hypo/ases t ,m$iate ,k1 & ( ! ,sup]ior ,pr9ciple4 ,,intellig5ce ,,kn[s ,,itself ,,by ,a ,,conv]sion ,,to ,,h]self4 #ca4 7#a7 ,:5 "o be+ subsi/s by dep5d5ce on any o!r1 & n by self-dep5d5ce & )drawal f any o!r1 x c\ld n turn itself t[>ds itself to "k itself by sep>at+ f 7! sub/rate7 by :i* x subsi/s4 ,by )draw+ f its own exi/5ce x w\ld alt] & p]i%4 ,b :5 "o be+ cognizes itself by )drawal f t to :i* x is unit$1 :5 x grasps itself z indep5d5t ( t be+1 & succe$s 9 do+ s )\t expos+ itself to de/ruction1 x evid5tly does n d]ive its be+ or nature f ! be+ f :i* x c1 )\t p]i%+1 )draw1 to face itself1 & "k itself indep5d5tly4 ,if sight1 & 9 g5]al all s5sation d n feel itself1 nor p]ceive itself on sep>at+ f ! body1 & d n subsi/ by itself2 if1 on ! contr>y1 intellig5ce ?9k bett] by sep>at+ f ! body1 & c be conv]t$ to itself )\t p]i%+1 evid5tly s5se-faculties are actualiz$ only by help ( ! body1 :ile intellig5ce actualizes & exi/s by itself1 & n by ! body4 ,,! ,,actualization ,,( ,,intellig5ce ,,is ,,et]nal ,,& ,,indivisible4 #cb4 7#c1 #e-g7 ,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 intellig5ce & ! intelligible1 betwe5 s5sation & t :i* c be s5s$4 ,! intelligible is unit$ to intellig5ce z t :i* c be s5s$ is connect$ ) s5sation4 ,b s5sation _c p]ceive itself4444 ,z ! intelligible is unit$ to ,intellig5ce1 x is grasp$ by intellig5ce & n by s5sation4 ,b intellig5ce is intelligible = intellig5ce4 ,s9ce !n intellig5ce is intelligible = intellig5ce1 intellig5ce is its own object4 ,if intellig5ce be intelligible1 b n s5sible1 x is an intelligible object4 ,be+ intelligible by intellig5ce1 b n by s5sation1 x w be intellig5t4 ,intellig5ce1 !re=e1 is simultane\sly ?9k] & ?\ght1 all t ?9ks & all t is ?\ght4 ,its op]ation1 besides1 is n t ( an object t rubs & is rubb$3 ,x is n a subject 9 "s "o "p ( itself1 & 9 "s o!r1 object ( ?\ght2 x is simple1 x is entirely intelligible = itself z a :ole4#ccd ,! :ole ( intellig5ce excludes any idea ( un9tellig5ce4 ,x does n conta9 "o "p t ?9ks1 :ile ano!r w\ld n ?9k2 = !n1 9 s f> z x w\ld n ?9k1 x w\ld be un9tellig5t4 ,x does n ab&on "o object to ?9k ( ano!r2 = x w\ld cease to ?9k ! object x ab&on$4 ,if1 !re=e1 intellig5ce d n successively pass f "o object to ano!r1 x ?9ks simultane\sly2 x does n ?9k fir/ "o 7?\ght7 & !n ano!r2 x ?9ks ev]y?+ z 9 ! pres5t1 & z always4444 ,if intellig5ce ?9k ev]y?+ z at pres5t1 if x "k no pa/ nor future1 its ?\ght is a simple actualization1 :i* excludes e int]val ( "t4 ,x1 !re=e1 conta9s ev]y?+ toge!r1 9 respect to "t4 ,intellig5ce1 !re=e1 ?9ks1 all ?+s accord+ to unity1 & 9 unity1 )\t any?+ fall+ 9 9 "t or 9 space4 ,if s1 intellig5ce is n discursive1 & is n 7l ! s\l7 9 motion2 x is an actualization1 :i* is accord+ to unity1 & 9 unity1 :i* %uns all *ance developm5t & e discursive op]ation4#cce ,if1 9 intellig5ce1 manifoldness be r$uc$ to unity1 & if ! intellectual actualization be indivisible1 & fall n )9 "t1 we %all h to attribute to su* a be+ et]nal exi/5ce 9 unity4 ,n[ t happ5s to be aeonial or ev]la/+ exi/5ce4#ccf ,!re=e1 et]nity con/itutes ! v be+ 7or nature7 ( intellig5ce4 ,! o!r k9d ( intellig5ce1 t does n ?9k accord+ to unity1 & 9 unity1 :i* falls into *ange1 & into movem5t1 :i* ab&ons "o object to ?9k ano!r1 :i* divides1 & gives itself up to a discursive action1 has "t z be+ 7or nature74 ,! di/9ction ( pa/ & future suits its action4 ,:5 pass+ f "o object to ano!r1 ! s\l *anges ?\ghts2 n inde$ t ! =m] p]i%1 or t ! latt] sudd5ly issue f "s o!r s\rce2 b ! =m]1 :ile seem+ to h disappe>$1 rema9 9 ! s\l2 & ! latt]1 :ile seem+ to come f some:]e else1 d n really d s1 b are born f )9 ! s\l1 :i* moves only f "o object to ano!r1 & :i* successively directs h] gaze f "o to ano!r "p ( :at %e possesses4 ,%e resembles a spr+ :i*1 in/ead ( fl[+ outside1 fl[s back into itself 9 a circle4 ,x is ?is 7circul>7 movem5t ( ! s\l t con/itutes "t1 j z ! p]man5ce ( intellig5ce 9 itself con/itutes 7aeonial7 et]nity4 ,intellig5ce is n sep>at$ f et]nity1 any m ?an ! s\l is f "t4 ,intellig5ce & et]nity =m b a s+le hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce4 ,t :i* moves simulates et]nity by ! indef9ite p]petuity ( its movem5t1 & t :i* rema9s immovable1 simulates "t by seem+ to multiply its cont9ual pres5t1 9 ! measure t "t passes4 ,t is :y "s h believ$ t "t manife/$ 9 re/ z well z 9 movem5t1 & t et]nity 0 no m ?an ! inf9ity ( "t4 ,to ea* ( ^! two 7diff]5t ?+s7 ! attributes ( ! o!r 7 mi/ak5ly attribut$4 ,! reason ( ?is is t any?+ t ev] p]si/s 9 an id5tical movem5t gives a good illu/ration ( et]nity by ! cont9u\sness ( its movem5t2 :ile t :i* p]si/s 9 an id5tical actualization repres5ts "t by ! p]man5ce ( its actualization4 ,besides1 9 s5se-objects1 duration diff]s accord+ to ea* ( !m4 ,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 ! duration ( ! c\rse ( ! sun1 & t ( ! moon1 z well z t ( ,v5us1 & s on4 ,!re is a diff]5ce betwe5 ! sol> ye>1 & ! ye> ( ea* ( ^! />s4 ,diff]5t1 fur!r1 is ! ye> t embraces all ! o!r ye>s1 & :i* con=ms to ! movem5t ( ! s\l1 accord+ to :i* ! />s regulate _! movem5ts4 ,z ! movem5t ( ! s\l diff]s f ! movem5t ( ! />s1 s also does its "t diff] f t ( ! />s2 = ! divisions ( ?is latt] k9d ( "t correspond to ! spaces travell$ by ea* />1 & by its successive passages 9 diff]5t places4 ,,intellig5ce ,,is ,,manifold4 #cc4 7#aj-ab7 ,intellig5ce is n ! pr9ciple ( all ?+s2 = x is manifold4 ,n[ ! manifold presupposes ! ,"o4 ,evid5tly1 x is intellig5ce t is manifold2 ! intelligibles t x ?9ks d n =m unity1 b manifoldness1 & !y are id5tical !re)4 ,!re=e1 s9ce intellig5ce & ! intelligible entities are id5tical1 & z ! intelligible entities =m a manifoldness1 intellig5ce itself is manifold4 ,! id5tity ( intellig5ce & ( intelligible entities may be demon/rat$ z foll[s4 ,! object t intellig5ce contemplates mu/ be 9 x1 or exi/ outside ( itself4 ,x is1 besides1 evid5t1 t intellig5ce contemplates2 s9ce1 = intellig5ce1 to ?9k is to be intellig5ce1#ccg !re=e1 to ab/ract its ?\ght w\ld be to deprive x ( its be+4 ,?is be+ grant$1 we mu/ det]m9e 9 :at mann] intellig5ce contemplates its object4 ,we %all accompli% ?is by exam9+ ! diff]5t faculties by :i* we acquire v>i\s k9ds ( k1 namely1 s5sation1 imag9ation & intellig5ce4 ,! pr9ciple :i* makes use ( ! s5ses contemplates only by grasp+ ext]ior ?+s1 & f> f unit+ itself to ! objects ( its contemplation1 f ?is p]ception x ga!rs no m ?an an image4 ,!re=e :5 ! eye sees ! visible object1 x _c id5tify itself ) ?is object2 = x w\ld n see x1 unless x 7 at a c]ta9 di/ance !refrom4 ,likewise if ! object ( t\* confus$ itself ) ! organ t t\*es x1 x w\ld disappe>4 ,!re=e ! s5ses1 & ! pr9ciple t makes use ( ! s5ses1 apply !mselves to :at is outside ( !m to p]ceive ?is s5se-object4 ,likewise imag9ation applies its att5tion to :at is outside ( x to =m = itself an image ( x2 x is by ?is v att5tion to :at is outside ( x t x repres5ts to itself ! object ( :i* x =ms an image z ext]ior4 ,t is h[ s5sation & imag9ation p]ceive _! objects4 ,nei!r ( ^! two faculties folds itself back on itself1 nor conc5trates on itself1 :e!r ! object ( _! p]ception be a corporeal or incorporeal =m4 ,n 9 ?is mann] is intellig5ce p]ceiv$2 ?is c occur only by turn+ t[>ds itself1 & by contemplat+ itself4 ,if x left ! contemplation ( its own actualizations1 if x ceas$ to be _! contemplation 7or1 intuition71 x w\ld no long] ?9k any?+4 ,intellig5ce p]ceives ! intelligible entity z s5sation p]ceives ! s5se-object1 by intuition4 ,b 9 ord] to contemplate ! s5se-object1 s5sation applies to :at is outside ( x1 because its object is mat]ial4 ,on ! contr>y1 9 ord] to contemplate ! intelligible entity1 intellig5ce conc5trates 9 itself1 in/ead ( apply+ itself to :at is outside ( x4 ,t is :y "s philosoph]s h ?\ght t !re 0 only a nom9al diff]5ce betwe5 intellig5ce & imag9ation2 = !y believ$ t intellig5ce 0 ! imag9ation ( ! reasonable animal2 z !y insi/$ t ev]y?+ %\ld dep5d on matt] & on corporeal nature1 !y naturally _h to make intellig5ce also dep5d !refrom4 ,b our intellig5ce contemplates natures 7or1 be+s74 ,!re=e1 7accord+ to ! hypo!sis ( ^! philosoph]s7 our intellig5ce w contemplate ^! natures z locat$ 9 "s place4 ,b ^! natures are outside ( matt]2 consequ5tly1 !y c\ld n be locat$ 9 any place4 ,x is !re=e evid5t t ! intelligible entities _h to be posit$ z )9 intellig5ce4 ,if ! intelligible entities be )9 intellig5ce1 intellig5ce w contemplate intelligible entities & w contemplate itself :ile contemplat+ !m2 by und]/&+ itself1 x w ?9k1 because x w und]/& intelligible entities4 ,n[ intelligible entities =m a multitude1 =#cch intellig5ce ?9ks a multitude ( intelligible entities1 & n a unity2 !re=e1 intellig5ce is manifold4 ,b manifoldness presupposes unity2 consequ5tly1 above intellig5ce1 ! exi/5ce ( unity w be necess>y4 #cd4 7#e7 ,intellectual be+ is compos$ ( simil> p>ts1 s t exi/+ be+s exi/ bo? 9 individual intellig5ce1 & 9 univ]sal ,intellig5ce4 ,b1 9 univ]sal ,intellig5ce1 individual 7entities7 are !mselves conceiv$ univ]sally2 :ile 9 individual intellig5ce1 univ]sal be+s z well z individual be+s are conceiv$ individually4 ,,six? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,f\r4 ,! ,"o & ,id5tical ,be+ ,is ,ev]y:]e ,pres5t ,z a ,:ole4 ,,( ,,! ,,incorporeal4 #ce4 ,! incorporeal is t :i* is conceiv$ ( by ab/raction ( ! body2 t is ! d]ivation ( its "n4 ,to ?is g5us1 accord+ to anci5t sages1 belong matt]1 s5se-=m1 :5 conceiv$ ( ap>t f matt]1 natures1 faculties1 place1 "t1 & surface4 ,all ^! entities1 inde$1 are call$ incorporeal because !y are n bodies4 ,!re are o!r ?+s t are call$ incorporeal by a wrong use ( ! ^w1 n because !y are n bodies1 b because !y _c beget bodies4 ,?us ! incorporeal fir/ m5tion$ above subsi/s )9 ! body1 :ile ! incorporeal ( ! second k9d is completely sep>at$ f ! body1 & f ! incorporeal t subsi/s )9 ! body4 ,! body1 inde$1 occupies a place1 & ! surface does n exi/ outside ( ! body4 ,b intellig5ce & intellectual reason 7discursive reason71 d n occupy any place1 d n subsi/ 9 ! body1 d n con/itute any body1 & d n dep5d on ! body1 nor on any ( ! ?+s t are call$ incorporeal by ab/raction ( ! body4 ,on ! o!r h&1 if we conceive ( ! void z incorporeal1 intellig5ce _c exi/ )9 ! void4 ,! void1 inde$1 may receive a body1 b x _c conta9 ! actualization ( intellig5ce1 nor s]ve z location = t actualization4 ,( ! two k9ds ( ! incorporeal ( :i* we h j spok51 ! foll[]s ( ,z5o reject ! "o 7! incorporeal t exi/s outside ( ! body7 & insi/ on ! o!r 7! incorporeal t is sep>at$ f ! body by ab/raction1 & :i* has no exi/5ce outside ( ! body72 n see+ t ! fir/ k9d ( incorporeality is n simil> to ! second1 !y refuse all reality to ! =m]1 ?\gh !y ought1 nev]!less1 to ackn[l$ge t ! incorporeal 7:i* subsi/s outside ( ! body71 is ( ano!r k9d 7?an ! incorporeal t does n subsi/ outside ( ! body71 & n to believe t1 because "o k9d ( incorporeality has no reality1 nei!r c ! o!r h any4 ,,relation ,,betwe5 ,,! ,,incorporeal ,,& ,,! ,,corporeal4 #cd4 7#b1 #c1 #d7 ,ev]y?+1 if x be some:]e1 is !re 9 "s mann] t con=ms to its nature4 ,= a body t is compos$ ( matt]1 & possesses volume1 to be some:]e1 means t x is locat$ 9 "s place4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! intelligible _w1 & 9 g5]al ! exi/5ce t is immat]ial1 & incorporeal 9 itself1 does n occupy any place1 s t ! ubiquity ( ! incorporeal is n a local pres5ce4 ,x does n h "o "p "h1 & ano!r !re2 =1 if s1 x w\ld n be outside ( all place1 nor be )\t ext5sion2 :]ev] x is1 x is entire2 x is n pres5t "h & abs5t !re2 = 9 ?is way x w\ld be conta9$ 9 "s "o place1 & exclud$ f "s o!r4 ,nor is x ne>] "o place1 & fur!r f "s o!r1 = only ?+s t occupy place /& 9 relations ( di/ance4 ,consequ5tly1 ! s5se-_w is pres5t to ! intelligible 9 space2 b ! intelligible is pres5t to ! s5se-_w 9 space2 b ! intelligible is pres5t to ! s5se-_w )\t hav+ any p>ts1 nor be+ 9 space4 ,:5 ! indivisible is pres5t 9 ! divisible1 x is entire 9 ea* "p1 id5tically & num]ically "o4 ,if simple & indivisible exi/5ce become ext5d$ & manifold1 x is n 9 respect to ! ext5d$ & manifold exi/5ce :i* possesses x1 n su* z x really is1 b 9 ! mann] 9 :i* 7simple exi/5ce7 c possess 7manifold exi/5ce74 ,ext5d$ & manifold exi/5ce has to become unext5d$ & simple 9 its relation ) naturally ext5d$ & simple exi/5ce1 to enjoy its pres5ce4 ,9 o!r t]ms1 x is con=mable to its nature1 )\t divid+1 nor multiply+1 nor occupy+ space1 t intelligible exi/5ce is pres5t to exi/5ce t is naturally divisible1 manifold1 & conta9$ )9 a locality2 b x is 9 a manifold1 divisible & local mann] t a locat$ exi/5ce is pres5t to ! exi/5ce t has no relation to space4 ,9 our speculations on corporeal & incorporeal exi/5ce1 !re=e1 we mu/ n confuse _! *>act]i/ics1 pres]v+ ! respective nature ( ea*1 tak+ good c>e n to let our imag9ation or op9ion attribute to ! incorporeal c]ta9 corporeal qualities4 ,nobody attributes to bodies incorporeal *>act]i/ics1 because ev]ybody lives 9 daily t\* ) bodies2 b z x is s difficult to cognize incorporeal natures 7be+s71 only vague conceptions are =m$ ( x1 & !y _c be grasp$ s long z "o lets oneself be guid$ by imag9ation4 ,"o has to say to oneself1 a be+ kn[n by ! s5ses is locat$ 9 space1 & is outside ( itself because x has a volume2 ! intelligible be+ is n locat$ 9 space1 b 9 itself1 because x has no volume4 ,! "o is a copy1 ! o!r is an ar*etype2 ! "o d]ives its exi/5ce f ! intelligible1 ! o!r f9ds x 9 itself2 = e image is an image ( intellig5ce4 ,! prop]ties ( ! corporeal & ! incorporeal mu/ be cle>ly kept 9 m9d s z to avoid surprise at _! diff]5ce1 9 spite ( _! union1 if inde$ x be p]missible to apply ! t]m union to _! mutual relation2 = we mu/ n ?9k ( ! union ( corporeal sub/ances1 b ( ! union ( sub/ances ^: prop]ties are completely incompatible1 accord+ to ! individuality ( _! hypo/atic =m ( exi/5ce4 ,su* union diff]s entirely f t ( homo\sian sub/ances ( ! same nature2 consequ5tly1 x is nei!r a bl5d1 nor a mixture1 nor a real union1 nor a m]e collocation4 ,! relation betwe5 ! corporeal & ! incorporeal is e/abli%$ 9 a diff]5t mann]1 :i* manife/s 9 ! communication ( homo\sian sub/ances ( ! s5se nature1 ( :i*1 h[ev]1 no corporeal op]ation c give any idea4 ,! incorporeal be+ is :olly )\t ext5sion 9 all ! p>ts ( ! ext5d$ be+1 ev5 ?\gh ! numb] ( ^! p>ts 7 inf9ite4 ,x is pres5t 9 an indivisible mann]1 )\t e/abli%+ a correspond5ce betwe5 ea* ( its p>ts ) ! p>ts ( ! ext5d$ be+2 x does n become manifold m]ely because1 9 a manifold mann]1 x is pres5t to a multitude ( p>ts4 ,! :ole ( x is entire 9 all ! p>ts ( ! ext5d$ be+1 9 ea* ( !m1 & 9 ! :ole mass1 )\t divid+ or becom+ manifold to ent] into relations ) ! manifold1 pres]v+ its num]ical id5tity4#cci ,x is only to be+s ^: p[] is disp]s$ t x belongs to possess ! intelligible by p>ts & by fractions4 ,(t5 ^! be+s1 on *ang+ f _! nature1 imitate intelligible be+s by a deceptive appe>ance1 & we are 9 d\bt ab\t _! nature 7be+71 = !y seem to h ex*ang$ x = t ( incorporeal be+1 or ess5ce4 ,,! ,,incorporeal ,,has ,,no ,,ext5sion4 #cg4 7#e7 ,t :i* really exi/s has nei!r great nor small4 ,greatness & smallness are attributes ( corporeal mass4 ,by its id5tity & num]ical unity1 real exi/5ce is nei!r great nor small1 nei!r v l>ge nor v small1 ?\gh x cause ev5 greate/ & smalle/ to p>ticipate 9 its nature4 ,x mu/ n1 !re=e1 be repres5t$ z great1 = 9 t case we c\ld n conceive h[ x c\ld be locat$ 9 ! smalle/ space )\t be+ dim9i%$ or cond5s$4 ,nor %\ld x be repres5t$ z small1 :i* conception ( x w\ld h9d] our und]/&+ h[ x c\ld be pres5t 9 a :ole l>ge body )\t be+ increas$ or ext5d$4 ,we mu/ try to ga9 a simultane\s conception ( bo? t :i* is v l>ge & v small1 & realize real exi/5ce z pres]v+ its id5tity & its indwell+ 9 itself 9 any *ance body :atev]1 along ) an inf9ity ( o!r bodies ( diff]5t sizes4 ,x is unit$ to ! ext5sion ( ! _w1 )\t ext5d+ itself1 or unit+1 & x exce$s ! ext5sion ( ! _w z well z t ( its p>ts1 by embrac+ !m )9 its unity4 ,likewise1 ! _w unites ) real exi/5ce by all its p>ts1 s f> z its nature all[s x to d s1 ?\gh x _c1 h[ev]1 embrace x entirely1 nor conta9 its :ole p[]4 ,real exi/5ce is inf9ite & incompreh5sible = ! _w because1 among o!r attributes1 x possesses t ( hav+ no ext5sion4 #ch4 ,great#cdj magnitude is a h9drance = a body1 if1 in/ead ( comp>+ x to ?+s ( ! same k9d1 x is consid]$ 9 relation ) ?+s ( a diff]5t nature2 = volume is1 z x 71 a k9d ( procession ( exi/5ce outside ( itself1 & a break+ up ( its p[]4 ,t :i* possesses a sup]ior p[] is ali5 to all ext5sion2 = pot5tiality does n succe$ 9 realiz+ its fulness until x conc5trates )9 itself2 x ne$s to =tify itself to acquire all its en]gy4 ,consequ5tly ! body1 by ext5d+ into space1 loses its en]gy1 & )draws f ! pot5cy t belongs to real & incorporeal exi/5ce2 b real exi/5ce does n weak5 9 ext5sion1 because1 hav+ no ext5sion1 x pres]ves ! greatness ( its pot5cy4 ,j z1 9 relation to ! body1 real exi/5ce has nei!r ext5sion nor volume1 likewise corporeal exi/5ce1 9 relation to real exi/5ce1 is weak & impot5t4 ,! exi/5ce t possesses ! greate/ p[] does n occupy any ext5sion4 ,consequ5tly1 ?\gh ! _w fill space1 ?\gh x be ev]y:]e unit$ to real ext5sion1 x c\ld n1 nev]!less1 embrace ! greatness ( its pot5cy4 ,x is unit$ to real exi/5ce1 n by p>ts1 b 9 an indivisible & indef9ite mann]4 ,!re=e1 ! incorporeal is pres5t to ! body1 n 9 a local mann]1 b by assimilation1 s f> z ! body is capable ( be+ assimilat$ to ! incorporeal1 & z ! incorporeal c manife/ 9 x4 ,! incorporeal is n pres5t to ! mat]ial1 9 s f> z ! mat]ial is incapable ( be+ assimilat$ to a completely immat]ial pr9ciple2 h[ev]1 ! incorporeal is pres5t to ! corporeal 9 s f> z ! corporeal c be assimilat$ !reto4 ,nor is ! incorporeal pres5t to ! mat]ial by receptivity 79 ! s5se t "o ( ^! two sub/ances w\ld receive some?+ f ! o!r72 o!rwise ! mat]ial & ! immat]ial w\ld be alt]$2 ! =m]1 on receiv+ ! immat]ial1 into :i* x w\ld be trans=m$1 & ! latt]1 on becom+ mat]ial4 ,!re=e1 :5 a relation is e/abli%$ betwe5 two sub/ances t are z diff]5t z ! corporeal & ! incorporeal1 an assimilation & p>ticipation t is reciprocal to ! p[] ( ! "o1 & ! impot5ce ( ! o!r1 occurs4 ,t is :y ! _w always rema9s v di/ant f ! p[] ( real exi/5ce1 & ! latt] f ! impot5ce ( mat]ial nature4 ,b t :i* occupies ! middle1 t :i* simultane\sly assimilates & is assimilat$1 t :i* unites ! extremes1 becomes a cause ( error 9 respect to !m1 because ! sub/ances x br+s toge!r by assimilation are v diff]5t4 ,,relation ,,( ,,individual ,,s\ls ,,to ,,! ,,univ]sal ,,s\l4 #ci4 ,x#cda w\ld be wrong to suppose t ! manifoldness ( s\ls 0 d]iv$ f ! manifoldness ( bodies4 ,! individual s\ls1 z well z ! univ]sal ,s\l1 subsi/ indep5d5tly ( ! bodies1 )\t ! unity ( ! univ]sal ,s\l absorb+ ! manifoldness ( individual s\ls1 & )\t ! manifoldness ( ! latt] splitt+ up ! unity ( ! univ]sal ,s\l4 ,individual s\ls are di/9ct )\t be+ sep>at$ f ea* o!r1 & )\t divid+ ! univ]sal ,s\l into a numb] ( p>ts2 !y are unit$ to ea* o!r )\t becom+ confus$1 & )\t mak+ ! univ]sal ,s\l a m]e total2 = !y are n sep>at$ by limits1 & !y are n confus$ ) ea* o!r2 !y are z di/9ct f ea* o!r z diff]5t sci5ces 9 a s+le s\l4 ,fur!r1 individual s\ls are n conta9$ 9 ! univ]sal ,s\l z if !y 7 bodies1 t is1 l really diff]5t sub/ances 7871 = !y are qualitative actualizations ( ! s\l4 ,inde$1 ! p[] ( ! univ]sal ,s\l is inf9ite1 & all t p>ticipates 9 h] is s\l2 all ! s\ls =m ! univ]sal ,s\l1 &1 nev]!less1 ! univ]sal ,s\l exi/s indep5d5tly ( all individual s\ls4 ,j z "o does n arrive at ! incorporeal by inf9ite division ( bodies1 see+ t su* a division w\ld modify !m only 9 respect to magnitude1 likewise1 on inf9itely divid+ ! s\l1 :i* is a liv+ =m1 we rea* no?+ b species 7n individuals72 = ! ,s\l conta9s specific diff]5ces1 & %e exi/s entire ) !m z well z )\t !m4 ,inde$1 ?\gh ! ,s\l %\ld be divid$ )9 h]self1 h] div]sity does n de/roy h] id5tity4 ,if ! unity ( bodies1 9 :i* manifoldness prevails ov] id5tity1 is n brok5 up by _! union ) an incorporeal pr9ciple2 if1 on ! contr>y1 all ( !m possess ! unity ( be+ or sub/ance1 & are divid$ only by qualities & o!r =ms2 :at %all we say or ?9k ( ! species ( incorporeal life1 :]e id5tity prevails ov] manifoldness1 & :]e !re is no sub/rate ali5 to =m1 & f :i* bodies might d]ive _! unity8 ,! unity ( ! ,s\l c\ld n be split up by h] union ) a body1 ?\gh ! body (t5 h9d] h] op]ations4 ,be+ id5tical1 ! ,s\l discov]s ev]y?+ by h]self1 because h] actualizations are species1 h[ev] f> ! division be c>ri$4 ,:5 ! ,s\l is sep>at$ f bodies1 ea* ( h] p>ts possesses all ! p[]s possess$ by ! ,s\l h]self1 j z an individual se$ has ! same prop]ties z ! univ]sal ,se$ 7sem9al reason74 ,z an individual se$1 be+ unit$ to matt]1 pres]ves ! prop]ties ( ! univ]sal ,se$ 7sem9al reason71 & z1 on ! o!r h&1 univ]sal ,se$ possesses all ! prop]ties ( ! individual se$s disp]s$ )9 matt]1 ?us ! p>ts :i* we conceive ( 9 ! 7univ]sal7 ,s\l t is sep>at$ f matt]1 possess all ! p[]s ( ! univ]sal ,s\l4#cdb ,! individual s\l1 :i* decl9es t[>ds matt]1 is b\nd to ! matt] by ! =m :i* h] disposition has made h] *oose2 b %e pres]ves ! p[]s ( ! univ]sal ,s\l1 & %e unites ) h] :5 ! 7individual s\l7 turns away f ! body1 to conc5trate )9 h]self4 ,n[ z 9 ! c\rse ( h] decl9ation t[>ds matt]1 ! s\l is /ripp$ entirely b>e by ! total exhau/ion ( h] own faculties2 & z1 on ! contr>y1 on ris+ t[>ds intellig5ce1 %e recov]s ! fulness ( ! p[]s ( ! univ]sal ,s\l1#cdc ! anci5t philosoph]s 7 "r1 9 _! my/ic phras+1 to describe ^! two opposite conditions ( ! ,s\l by ! names ( ,p5ia & ,poros1 7,weal? & ,pov]ty74#cdd ,,six? ,,ennead1 ,,book ,,five4 ,! ,"o & ,id5tical ,be+ is ,ev]y:]e ,pres5t ,9 ,its ,entirety4#cde ,,! ,,incorporeal ,,be+ ,,is ,,entire ,,9 ,,ev]y?+4 #dj4 ,bett]#cdf to express ! special nature ( incorporeal exi/5ce ! anci5t philosoph]s1 p>ticul>ly ,p>m5ides1#cdg d n cont5t !mselves ) say+ x is "o1 b !y also add & all1 j z a s5se-object is a :ole4 ,b z ?is unity ( ! s5se-object conta9s a div]sity 7= 9 ! s5se-object ! total unity is n all ?+s 9 s f> z x is "o1 & z all ?+s con/itute ! total unity74 ,! anci5t philosoph]s also add1 9 s f> z x is "o4 ,?is 0 to prev5t p f imag9+ a collective :ole & to indicate t ! real be+ is all1 only by virtue ( its indivisible unity4 ,aft] hav+ said1 x is ev]y:]e1 !y add1 x is n[h]e4 ,!n1 aft] hav+ said1 x is 9 all1 t is1 9 all individual ?+s ^: disposition enables !m to receive x1 !y /ill add1 z an entire :ole4 ,!y repres5t x ?us simultane\sly "u ! mo/ opposite attributes1 s z to elim9ate all ! false imag9ations :i* are drawn f ! natures ( ! bodies1 & :i* w only obscure ! g5u9e idea ( real exi/5ce4 ,,diff]5ce ,,betwe5 ,,! ,,intelligible ,,be+1 ,,& ,,! ,,be+ ,,( ,,s5sation4 #da4 ,su*#cdh are ! g5u9e *>act]i/ics ( ! s5sual & mat]ial2 x is ext5d$1 mutable1 always diff]5t f :at x 01 & composite2 x does n subsi/ by itself1 x is locat$ 9 a place1 & has volume1 & s =?4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! real be+ t is self-subsi/+1 is f\nd$ on itself1 & is always id5tical2 its nature 7be+7 is id5tity1 x is ess5tially immutable1 simple1 indissoluble1 )\t ext5sion1 & outside ( all place2 x is nei!r born1 nor does x p]i%4 ,s let u def9e ^! *>act]i/ics ( ! s5sual & v]itable exi/5ce1 & let u put aside all o!r attributes4 #db4 ,real#cdi exi/5ce is said to be manifold1 )\t its really be+ diff]5t 9 space1 volume1 numb]1 figure1 or ext5sion ( p>ts2 its division is a div]sity )\t matt]1 volume1 or real manifoldness4 ,consequ5tly1 ! real be+ is "o4 ,its unity does n resemble t ( a body1 ( a place1 ( a volume1 ( a multitude4 ,x possesses div]sity 9 unity4 ,its div]sity implies bo? division & union2 = x is nei!r ext]ior nor incid5tal2 real exi/5ce is n manifold by p>ticipation 9 "s o!r 7nature71 b by itself4 ,x rema9s "o by ex]cis+ all its p[]s1 because x holds its div]sity f its v id5tity1 & n by an assemblage ( het]og5e\s p>ts1 su* z bodies4 ,! latt] possess unity 9 div]sity2 =1 9 !m1 x is div]sity t dom9ates1 ! unity be+ ext]ior & incid5tal4 ,9 real exi/5ce1 on ! contr>y1 x is unity t dom9ates ) id5tity2 div]sity is born ( ! developm5t ( ! p[] ( unity4 ,consequ5tly1 real exi/5ce pres]ves its indivisibility by multiply+ itself2 :ile ! body pres]ves its volume & multiplicity by unify+ itself4 ,real exi/5ce is f\nd$ on itself1 because x is "o by itself4 ,! body is nev] f\nd$ ^u itself1 because x subsi/s only by its ext5sion4 ,real exi/5ce is1 !re=e1 a fruitful unity1 & ! body is a unifi$ multitude4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 exactly det]m9e h[ real exi/5ce is bo? "o & manifold1 h[ ! body is bo? manifold & "o1 & we mu/ gu>d f confus+ ! attributes ( ei!r4 ,,! ,,div9ity ,,is ,,ev]y:]e ,,& ,,n[h]e4 #dc4 ,! div9ity#cej is ev]y:]e because x is n[h]e4 ,s also ) intellig5ce & ! s\l4 ,b x is 9 relation to all be+s t x surpasses1 t ! div9ity is ev]y:]e & n[h]e2 its pres5ce & its abs5ce dep5d entirely on its nature & its w4#cea ,intellig5ce is 9 ! div9ity1 b x is only 9 relation to ! ?+s t are subord9at$ to x1 t intellig5ce is ev]y:]e & n[h]e 7874 ,! body is )9 ! s\l & 9 div9ity4 ,all ?+s t possess or d n possess exi/5ce proce$ f div9ity1 & are )9 div9ity2 b ! div9ity is none ( !m1 nor 9 any ( !m4 ,if ! div9ity 7 only pres5t ev]y:]e1 x w\ld be all ?+s1 & 9 all ?+s2 b1 on ! o!r h&1 x is n[h]e2 ev]y?+1 !re=e1 is begott5 9 x & by x1 because x is ev]y:]e1 b no?+ becomes confus$ ) x1 because x is n[h]e4 ,likewise if intellig5ce be ! pr9ciple ( ! s\ls & ( ! ?+s t come aft] ! s\ls1 x is because x is ev]y:]e & n[h]e2 because x is nei!r s\l1 nor any ( ! ?+s t come aft] ! s\l1 nor 9 any ( !m2 x is because x is n only ev]y:]e1 b also n[h]e 9 respect to ! be+s t are inf]ior to x4 ,simil>ly ! s\l is nei!r a body1 nor 9 ! body1 b is only ! cause ( ! body1 because %e is simultane\sly ev]y:]e & n[h]e 9 ! body4 ,s !re is procession 9 ! univ]se 7f :at is ev]y:]e & n[h]e71 d[n to :at c nei!r simultane\sly be ev]y:]e & n[h]e1 & :i* limits itself to p>ticipat+ 9 ?is d\ble prop]ty4 ,,! ,,human ,,s\l ,,is ,,unit$ ,,to ,,univ]sal ,,be+ ,,by ,,its ,,nature4 #dd4 ,:5#ceb y h conceiv$ ( ! inexhau/ible & inf9ite p[] ( exi/5ce 9 itself1 & :5 y beg9 to realize its incessant & indefatigable nature1 :i* completely suffices itself1 :i* has ! privilege ( be+ ! pure/ life1 ( possess+ itself fully1 ( be+ f\nd$ ^u itself1 ( nei!r desir+ nor seek+ any?+ outside ( itself1 y %\ld n attribute to x any special det]m9ation1 or any relation2 = :5 y limit y\rself by "s consid]ation ( space or relation1 y d\btlessly d n limit exi/5ce 9 itself1 b y turn away f x1 ext5d+ ! veil ( imag9ation ov] y\r ?\ght4 ,y c nei!r transgress1 nor fix1 nor det]m9e1 nor cond5se )9 n>r[ limits1 ! nature ( exi/5ce 9 itself1 z if x _h no?+ fur!r to give beyond 7c]ta9 limits71 exhau/+ itself gradually4 ,x is ! mo/ inexhau/ible spr+ ( :i* y c =m a notion4 ,:5 y w h a*iev$ 787 t nature1 & :5 y w h become assimilat$ to et]nal exi/5ce1 seek no?+ beyond4 ,o!rwise1 y w be go+ away f x1 y w be direct+ y\r glances on some?+ else4 ,if y d n seek any?+ beyond1 if y %r9k )9 y\rself & into y\r own nature1 y w become assimilat$ to univ]sal ,exi/5ce1 & y w n halt at any?+ inf]ior to x4 ,d n say1 ,t is :at ,i am4 ,=gett+ :at y are 7871 y w become univ]sal ,exi/5ce4 ,y 7 already univ]sal ,exi/5ce1 b y _h some?+ besides2 by t m]e fact y 7 inf]ior1 because t possession ( y\rs t 0 beyond univ]sal ,exi/5ce 0 d]iv$ f non5tity4 ,no?+ c be add$ to univ]sal ,exi/5ce4 ,:5 we add to x some?+ d]iv$ f non5tity1 we fall into pov]ty & into complete deprivation4 ,!re=e1 ab&on non5tity1 & y w fully possess y\rself1 79 t y w acquire univ]sal exi/5ce by putt+ all else aside2 =1 s long z "o rema9s ) ! rema9d]1 exi/5ce does n manife/2 & does n grant its pres5ce74 ,exi/5ce is discov]$ by putt+ aside ev]y?+ t degrades & dim9i%es x1 ceas+ to confuse x ) inf]ior objects1 & ceas+ to =m a false idea ( x4 ,o!rwise "o dep>ts bo? f exi/5ce & f oneself4 ,inde$1 :5 "o is pres5t to oneself1 he possesses ! exi/5ce t is pres5t ev]y:]e2 :5 "o dep>ts f himself1 he also dep>ts f x4 ,s important is x = ! s\l to acqua9t h]self ) :at is 9 h]1 & to )draw f :at is outside ( h]2 = exi/5ce is )9 u1 & non5tity is outside ( u4 ,n[ exi/5ce is pres5t )9 u1 :5 we are n di/ract$ f x by o!r ?+s4 ,x does n come ne> u to make u enjoy its pres5ce4 ,x is we :o )draw f x1 :5 x is n pres5t ) u4 ,is !re any?+ surpris+ 9 ?is8 ,to be ne> exi/5ce1 y d n ne$ to )draw f y\rselves2 = y are bo? f> f exi/5ce & ne> x1 9 ?is s5se t x is y :o come ne> to x1 & y :o )draw f x1 :51 in/ead ( consid]+ y\rselves1 y consid] t :i* is =eign to y4 ,if !n y are ne> exi/5ce :ile be+ f> f x2 if1 by ! m]e fact ( y\r be+ ignorant ( y\rselves1 y "k all ?+s to :i* y are pres5t1 & :i* are di/ant f y1 r ?an y\rself :o is naturally ne> y1 is !re any?+ surpris+ 9 t1 t :i* is n ne> y %\ld rema9 =eign to y1 s9ce y )draw f x :5 y )draw f y\rself8 ,?\gh y %\ld always be ne> y\rself1 & ?\gh y _c )draw f x1 y mu/ be pres5t ) y\rself to enjoy ! pres5ce ( ! be+ f :i* y are s sub/antially insep>able z f y\rself4 ,9 t way x is giv5 y to "k :at exi/s ne> exi/5ce1 & :at is di/ant f x1 ?\gh itself be pres5t ev]y:]e & n[h]e4 ,he :o by ?\ght c p5etrate )9 8 own sub/ance1 & c ?us acquire k ( x1 f9ds himself 9 ?is actualization ( k & consci\sness1 :]e ! sub/rate t kn[s is id5tical ) ! object t is kn[n4 ,n[ :5 a man ?us possesses himself1 he also possesses exi/5ce4 ,he :o goes out ( himself to atta* himself to ext]nal objects1 )draws also f exi/5ce1 :5 )draw+ also f himself4 ,x is natural to u to e/abli% ourselves )9 ourselves1 :]e we enjoy ! :ole weal? ( our own res\rces1 & n to turn ourselves away f ourselves t[>ds :at is =eign to ourselves1 & :]e we f9d no?+ b ! mo/ complete pov]ty4 ,o!rwise1 we are )draw+ f exi/5ce1 ?\gh x be ne> u2 = x is nei!r space1 nor be+ 7sub/ance71 nor any ob/acle t sep>ates u f exi/5ce2 x is our rev]sion t[>ds non5tity4 ,our ali5ation f ourselves1 & our ignorance are ?us a j puni%m5t ( our )drawal f exi/5ce4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! love t ! s\l has = h]self leads h] to self-k & communion ) ! div9ity4 ,consequ5tly1 x has rightly be5 said t man "h bel[ is 9 a prison1 because he has fl$ f heav5#cec 444 & because he tries to break 8 bonds2 =1 :5 he turns t[>ds ?+s "h bel[1 he has ab&on$ himself1 & has )drawn f 8 div9e orig94 ,x is1 7z ,emp$ocles says71 a fugitive :o has des]t$ 8 heav5ly fa!rl&4#ced ,t is :y ! life ( a vici\s man is a life t is s]vile1 impi\s1 & unju/1 & 8 _s is full ( impiety & inju/ice4#cee ,on ! contr>y1 ju/ice1 z has be5 rightly said1 consi/s 9 ea* "o fulfill+ 8 function 7874 ,to di/ribute to ea* p]son 8 due is g5u9e ju/ice4 ,,psy*ological ,,fragm5ts4 ,a4 ,on ! ,faculties ( ! ,s\l1 by ,porphyry4#cef ,,object ,,( ,,! ,,book4 ,we propose to describe ! faculties ( ! s\l1 & to set =? ! v>i\s op9ions on ! subject held by bo? anci5t & mod]n ?9k]s4 ,,diff]5ce ,,betwe5 ,,s5sation ,,& ,,intellig5ce4 ,ari/o 7!re 7 two philosoph]s by ?is "n1 "o a ,/oic1 ! o!r an ,ari/otelian7 attributes to ! s\l a p]ceptive faculty1 :i* he divides into two p>ts4 ,accord+ to him1 ! fir/1 call$ s5sibility1 ! pr9ciple & orig9 ( s5sations1 is usually kept active by "s "o ( ! s5se-organs4 ,! o!r1 :i* subsi/s by itself1 & )\t organs1 does n be> any special "n 9 be+s devoid ( reason1 9 :om reason does n manife/1 or at lea/ manife/s only 9 a feeble or obscure mann]2 h[ev]1 x is call$ intellig5ce 9 be+s end[$ ) reason1 among :om alone x manife/s cle>ly4 ,ari/o holds t s5sibility acts only ) ! help ( ! s5se-organs1 & t intellig5ce does n ne$ !m to ent] into activity4 ,:y !n does he subord9ate bo? ( ^! to a s+le g5us1 call$ ! p]ceptive faculty8 ,bo? d\btless p]ceive1 b ! "o p]ceives ! s5se-=m ( be+s1 :ile ! o!r p]ceives _! ess5ce4 ,inde$1 s5sibility does n p]ceive ! ess5ce1 b ! s5se-=m1 & ! figure2 x is intellig5ce t p]ceives :e!r ! object be a man or a horse4 ,!re are1 !re=e1 two k9ds ( p]ception t are v diff]5t f ea* o!r2 s5se-p]ception receives an impression1 & applies itself to an ext]ior object2 on ! contr>y1 intellectual p]ception does n receive any impression4 ,!re h be5 philosoph]s :o sep>at$ ^! two p>ts2 !y call$ intellig5ce or discursive reason ! und]/&+ :i* is ex]cis$ )\t imag9ation & s5sation2 & op9ion1 ! und]/&+ :i* is ex]cis$ ) imag9ation & s5sation4 ,o!rs1 on ! contr>y1 consid]$ rational be+1 or nature1 a simple ess5ce1 & attribut$ to x op]ations ^: nature is entirely diff]5t4 ,n[ x is unreasonable to ref] to ! same ess5ce faculties :i* diff] completely 9 nature2 = ?\ght & s5sation c\ld n dep5d on ! same ess5tial pr9ciple2 & if we 7 to call ! op]ation ( intellig5ce a p]ception1 we w\ld only be juggl+ ) words4 ,we mu/1 !re=e1 e/abli% a p]fectly cle> di/9ction betwe5 ^! two entities1 intellig5ce & s5sibility4 ,on ! "o h&1 intellig5ce possesses a q peculi> nature1 z is also ! case ) discursive reason1 :i* is next bel[ x4 ,! function ( ! =m] is intuitive ?\ght1 :ile t ( ! latt] is discursive ?\ght4 ,on ! o!r h&1 s5sibility diff]s entirely f intellig5ce1 act+ ) or )\t ! help ( organs2 9 ! =m] case1 x is call$ s5sation2 9 ! latt]1 imag9ation4 ,nev]!less1 s5sation & imag9ation belong to ! same g5us4 ,9 und]/&+1 intuitive intellig5ce is sup]ior to op9ion1 :i* applies to s5sation or imag9ation2 ?is latt] k9d ( ?\ght1 :e!r call$ discursive ?\ght1 or any?+ else 7su* z op9ion71 is sup]ior to s5sation & imag9ation1 b inf]ior to intuitive ?\ght4 ,,( ,,ass5t4 ,num5ius1 :o tea*es t ! faculty ( ass5t 7or1 comb9+ faculty7 is capable ( produc+ v>i\s op]ations1 says t repres5tation 7fancy7 is an accessory ( ?is faculty1 t x does n1 h[ev]1 con/itute ei!r an op]ation or function ( x1 b a consequ5ce ( x4 ,! ,/oics1 on ! contr>y1 n only make s5sation consi/ 9 repres5tation1 b ev5 r$uce repres5tation to 7comb9+7 ass5t4 ,accord+ to !m s5se-imag9ation 7or s5se-fancy7 is ass5t1 or ! s5sation ( ! det]m9ation ( ass5t4 ,long9us1 h[ev]1 does n ackn[l$ge any faculty ( ass5t4 ,! philosoph]s ( ! anci5t ,academy 7! ,platoni/s7 believe t s5sation does n comprise s5se-repres5tation1 & t1 consequ5tly1 x does n h any orig9al prop]ty1 s9ce x does n p>ticipate 9 ass5t4 ,if s5se repres5tation consi/$ ( ass5t add$ to s5sation1 s5sation1 by itself1 w h no virtue1 s9ce x is n ! ass5t giv5 to ! ?+s we possess4 ,,( ,,! ,,p>ts ,,( ,,! ,,s\l4 ,x is n only ab\t ! faculties t ! anci5t philosoph]s disagree4444 ,!y are besides 9 radical disagreem5t ab\t ! foll[+ que/ions3 ,:at are ! p>ts ( ! s\l2 :at is a "p2 :at is a faculty2 :at diff]5ce is !re betwe5 a "p & a faculty8 ,! ,/oics divide ! s\l into eight p>ts3 ! five s5ses1 spee*1 sex-p[]1 & ! direct+ 7pr$om9at+7 pr9ciple1 :i* is s]v$ by ! o!r faculties1 s t ! s\l is compos$ ( a faculty t comm&s1 & faculties t obey4 ,9 _! writ+ ab\t e?ics1 ,plato & ,ari/otle divide ! s\l into ?ree p>ts4 ,?is division has be5 adopt$ by ! great] "p ( lat] philosoph]s2 b ^! h n und]/ood t ! object ( ?is def9ition 0 to classify & def9e ! virtues 7,plato3 reason1 ang] & appetite2 ,ari/otle3 locomotion1 appetite & und]/&+74 ,inde$1 if ?is classification be c>efully scrut9iz$1 x w be se5 t x fails to acc\nt = all ! faculties ( ! s\l2 x neglects imag9ation1 s5sibility1 intellig5ce1 & ! natural faculties 7! g5]ative & nutritive p[]s74 ,o!r philosoph]s1 su* z ,num5ius1 d n tea* "o s\l 9 ?ree p>ts1 l ! prec$+1 nor 9 two1 su* z ! rational & irrational p>ts4 ,!y believe t we h two s\ls1 "o rational1 ! o!r irrational4 ,"s among !m attribute immortality to bo? ( ! s\ls2 o!rs attribute x only to ! rational s\l1 & ?9k t dea? n only susp5ds ! ex]cise ( ! faculties t belong to ! irrational s\l1 b ev5 dissolves its be+ or ess5ce4 ,la/1 !re are "s t believe1 t by virtue ( ! union ( ! two s\ls1 _! movem5ts are d\ble1 because ea* ( !m feels ! passions ( ! o!r4 ,,( ,,! ,,diff]5ce ,,( ,,! ,,p>ts1 ,,& ,,( ,,! ,,faculties ,,( ,,! ,,s\l4 ,we %all n[ expla9 ! diff]5ce obta9+ betwe5 a "p & a faculty ( ! s\l4 ,"o "p diff]s f ano!r by ! *>act]i/ics ( its g5us 7or1 k9d72 :ile diff]5t faculties may relate to a common g5us4 ,t is :y ,ari/otle did n all[ t ! s\l conta9$ p>ts1 ?\gh grant+ t x conta9$ faculties4 ,inde$1 ! introduction ( a new "p *anges ! nature ( ! subject1 :ile ! div]sity ( faculties does n alt] its unity4 ,long9us did n all[ 9 ! animal 7or1 liv+ be+7 = sev]al p>ts1 b only = sev]al faculties4 ,9 ?is respect1 he foll[$ ! doctr9e ( ,plato1 accord+ to :om ! s\l1 9 h]self indivisible1 is divid$ )9 bodies4 ,besides1 t ! s\l does n h sev]al p>ts does n necess>ily imply t %e has only a s+le faculty2 = t :i* has no p>ts may /ill possess sev]al faculties4 ,to conclude ?is confus$ discussion1 we %all h to lay d[n a pr9ciple ( def9ition :i* w help to det]m9e ! ess5tial diff]5ces & resemblances t exi/ ei!r betwe5 ! p>ts ( a same subject1 or betwe5 its faculties1 or betwe5 its p>ts & its faculties4 ,?is w cle>ly reveal :e!r 9 ! organism ! s\l really has sev]al p>ts1 or m]ely sev]al faculties1 & :at op9ion ab\t !m %\ld be adopt$4 7,= !re are two special types ( ^!47 ,! "o attributes to man a s+le s\l1 g5u9ely compos$ ( sev]al p>ts1 ei!r by itself1 or 9 relation to ! body4 ,! o!r "o sees 9 man a union ( sev]al s\ls1 look+ on ! man z on a *oir1 ! h>mony ( ^: p>ts con/itutes its unity1 s t we f9d sev]al ess5tially diff]5t p>ts contribut+ to ! =mation ( a s+le be+4 ,fir/ we %all h to /udy )9 ! s\l ! diff]5tials betwe5 ! "p1 ! faculty & ! disposition4 ,a "p always diff]s f ano!r by ! sub/rate1 g5us1 & function4 ,a disposition 9 a special aptitude ( "s "o "p to c>ry out ! "p assign$ to x by nature4 ,a faculty is ! habit ( a disposition1 ! p[] inh]5t 9 "s "p to d ! ?+ = :i* x has a disposition4 ,!re 0 no great inconv5i5ce 9 confus+ faculty & disposition2 b !re is an ess5tial diff]5ce betwe5 "p & faculty4 ,:atev] ! numb] ( faculties1 !y c exi/ )9 a s+le be+1 or nature1 )\t occupy+ any p>ticul> po9t 9 ! ext5sion ( ! sub/rate1 :ile ! p>ts some:at p>ticipate 9 its ext5sion1 occupy+ !re9 a p>ticul> po9t4 ,?us all ! prop]ties ( an apple are ga!r$ )9 a s+le sub/rate1 b ! diff]5t p>ts t compose x are sep>ate f ea* o!r4 ,! notion ( a "p implies ! idea ( quantity 9 respect to ! totality ( ! subject4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! notion ( a faculty implies ! idea ( totality4 ,t is :y ! faculties rema9 indivisible1 because !y p5etrate ! :ole sub/rate1 :ile ! p>ts are sep>ate f ea* o!r because !y h a quantity4 ,h[ !n may we say t a s\l is indivisible1 :ile hav+ ?ree p>ts8 ,= :5 we he> x ass]t$ t %e conta9s ?ree p>ts 9 respect to quantity1 x is reasonable to ask h[ ! s\l c simultane\sly be indivisible1 & yet h ?ree p>ts4 ,?is difficulty may be solv$ z foll[s3 ! s\l is indivisible 9 s f> z %e is consid]$ )9 h] be+1 & 9 h]self2 & t %e has ?ree p>ts 9 s f> z %e is unit$ to a divisible body1 & t %e ex]cises h] diff]5t faculties 9 ! diff]5t p>ts ( ! body4 ,inde$1 x is n ! same faculty t resides 9 ! head1 9 ! brea/1 or 9 ! liv]2#ceg 7! seats ( reason1 ( ang] & appetite74 ,!re=e1 :5 ! s\l has be5 divid$ into sev]al p>ts1 x is 9 ?is s5se t h] diff]5t functions are ex]cis$ )9 diff]5t p>ts ( ! body4 ,ni*olas 7( ,damascus#ceh71 9 8 book ,on ! ,s\l1 us$ to say t ! division ( ! s\l 0 n f\nd$ on quantity1 b on quality1 l ! division ( an art or a sci5ce4 ,inde$1 :5 we consid] an ext5sion1 we see t ! :ole is a sum ( its p>ts1 & t x increases or dim9i%es accord+ z a "p is add$ or subtract$4 ,n[ x is n 9 ?is s5se t we attribute p>ts to ! s\l2 %e is n ! sum ( h] p>ts1 because %e is nei!r an ext5sion nor a multitude4 ,! p>ts ( ! s\l resemble ^? ( an art4 ,!re is1 h[ev]1 ?is diff]5ce1 t an art is incomplete or imp]fect if x lack "s "p1 :ile e s\l is p]fect1 & :ile e organism t has n a*iev$ ! goal ( its nature is an imp]fect be+4 ,?us by p>ts ( ! s\l ,ni*olas means ! diff]5t faculties ( ! organism4 ,inde$1 ! organism1 &1 9 g5]al1 ! animat$ be+1 by ! m]e fact ( possess+ a s\l1 possesses sev]al faculties1 su* z life1 feel+1 movem5t1 ?\ght1 desire1 & ! cause & pr9ciple ( all ( !m is ! s\l4 ,^?1 !re=e1 :o di/+ui% p>ts 9 ! s\l !reby mean ! faculties by :i* ! animat$ be+ c produce actualizations1 or exp]i5ce affections4 ,:ile ! s\l h]self is said to be indivisible1 no?+ h9d]s h] functions f be+ divid$4 ,! organism1 !re=e1 is divisible1 if we introduce )9 ! notion ( ! s\l t ( ! body2 = ! vital functions by ! s\l communicat$ to ! body mu/ !reby necess>ily be divid$ by ! div]sity ( ! organs1 & x is ?is division ( vital functions t has caus$ p>ts to be ascrib$ to ! s\l h]self4 ,z ! s\l c be conceiv$ ( 9 two diff]5t conditions1 accord+ z %e lives )9 h]self1 or z %e decl9es t[>ds ! body1#cei x is only :5 %e decl9es t[>ds ! body t %e splits up into p>ts4 ,:5 a se$ ( corn is s[$1 & produces an e>1 we see 9 ?is e> ( corn ! appe>ance ( p>ts1 ?\gh ! :ole x =ms be indivisible1#cfj & ^! indivisible p>ts !mselves lat] return to an indivisible unity2 likewise1 :5 ! s\l1 :i* by h]self is indivisible1 f9ds h]self unit$ to ! body1 p>ts are se5 to appe>4 ,we mu/ /ill exam9e :i* are ! faculties t ! s\l develops by h]self 7intellig5ce & discursive reason71 & :i* ! s\l develops by ! animal 7s5sation74 ,?is w be ! true means ( illu/rat+ ! diff]5ce betwe5 ^! two natures 7be+s71 & ! necessity ( r$uc+ to ! s\l h]self ^? p>ts ( h] be+ :i* h be5 enclos$ )9 ! p>ts ( ! body4#cfa ,b4 ,jambli*us4#cfb ,plato1 ,ar*ytas1 & ! o!r ,py?agoreans divide ! s\l into ?ree p>ts1 reason1 ang]1 & appetite1 :i* !y consid] to be necess>y to =m ! gr\nd-"w = ! virtues4 ,!y assign to ! s\l z faculties ! natural 7g5]ative7 p[]1 s5sibility1 imag9ation1 locomotion1 love ( ! good & beautiful1 & la/1 intellig5ce4 ,c4 ,nemesius4#cfc ,ari/otle says1 9 8 ,physics1#cfd t ! s\l has five faculties1 ! p[] ( gr[?1 s5sation1 locomotion1 appetite1 & und]/&+4 ,b1 9 8 ,e?ics1 he divides ! s\l into two pr9cipal p>ts1 :i* are rational "p1 & ! irrational "p2 !n ,ari/otle subdivides ! latt] into ! "p t is subject to reason1 & ! "p n subject to reason4 ,d4 ,jambli*us4#cfe ,! ,platoni/s hold diff]5t op9ions4 ,"s1 l ,plot9os & ,porphyry1 r$uce to a s+le ord] & idea ! diff]5t functions & faculties ( life2 o!rs1 l ,num5ius1 imag9e !m to be oppos$1 z if 9 a /ruggle2 :ile o!rs1 l ,atticus & ,plut>*1 br+ h>mony out ( ! /ruggle4 ,e4 ,ammonius ,saccas4 ,a4 ,,f ,,nemesius4#cff ,,on ,,! ,,immat]iality ,,( ,,! ,,s\l4 ,x w suffice to oppose ! argum5ts ( ,ammonius1 tea*] ( ,plot9os1 & ^? ( ,num5ius ! ,py?agorean1 to t ( all ^? :o claim t ! s\l is mat]ial4 ,^! are ! reasons3 ,bodies1 conta9+ no?+ un*angeable1 are naturally subject to *ange1 to dissolution1 & to inf9ite divisions4 ,!y inevitably ne$ "s pr9ciple t may conta9 !m1 t may b9d & /r5g!n _! p>ts2 ?is is ! unify+ pr9ciple t we call s\l4 ,b if ! s\l also be mat]ial1 h[ev] subtle be ! matt] ( :i* %e may be compos$1 :at c\ld conta9 ! s\l h]self1 s9ce we h j se5 t all matt] ne$s "s pr9ciple to conta9 x8 ,! same process w g on cont9u\sly to inf9ity until we arrive at an immat]ial sub/ance4 ,,union ,,( ,,! ,,s\l ,,& ,,! ,,body4 ,ammonius1 tea*] ( ,plot9os1 ?us expla9$ ! pres5t problem 7! union ( s\l & body73 ,! intelligible is ( a nature su* t x unites ) :atev] is able to receive x1 z intimately z ! union ( ?+s1 t mutually alt] ea* o!r 9 unit+1 ?\gh1 at ! same "t1 x rema9s pure & incorruptible1 z d ?+s t m]ely coexi/4#cfg ,inde$1 9 ! case ( bodies1 union alt]s ! p>ts t meet1 s9ce !y =m new bodies2 t is h[ elem5ts *ange into composite bodies1 food into blood1 blood into fle%1 & o!r p>ts ( ! body4 ,b1 z to ! intelligible1 ! union occurs )\t any alt]ation2 = x is repugnant to ! nature ( ! intelligible to und]go an alt]ation 9 its ess5tial nature4 ,x disappe>s1 or x ceases to be1 b x is n susceptible ( *ange4 ,n[ ! intelligible _c be annihilat$2 o!rwise x w\ld n be immortal2 & z ! s\l is life1 if x *ang$ 9 its union ) ! body1 x w\ld become some?+ diff]5t1 & w\ld no long] be life4 ,:at w\ld ! s\l af=d to ! body1 if n life8 ,9 h] union 7) ! body1 !re=e71 ! s\l und]goes no alt]ation4 ,s9ce x has be5 demon/rat$ t1 9 its ess5tial nature1 ! intelligible is immutable1 ! necess>y result mu/ be t x does n alt] at ! same "t z ! entities to :i* x is unit$4 ,! s\l1 !re=e1 is unit$ to ! body1 b %e does n =m a mixture ) x4#cfh ,! sympa?y t exi/s betwe5 !m %[s t !y are unit$2 = ! entirely animat$ be+ is a :ole t is sympa!tic to itself1 & t is consequ5tly really "o4#cfi ,:at proves t ! s\l does n =m a mixture ) ! body1 is ! s\l's p[] to sep>ate f ! body dur+ sleep2 leav+ ! body z x 7 inanimate1 ) only a brea? ( life1 to keep x f dy+ entirely2 us+ h] own activity only 9 dreams1 to =esee ! future1 & to live 9 ! intelligible _w4 ,?is appe>s aga9 :5 ! s\l ga!rs h]self toge!r to devote h]self to h] ?\ghts2 = !n %e sep>ates f ! body s f> z %e c1 & retires )9 h]self bett] to be able to apply h]self to ! consid]ation ( intelligible ?+s4 ,inde$1 be+ incorporeal1 %e unites ) ! body z closely z ! union ( ?+s :i* by comb9+ toge!r p]i% because ( ea* o!r1 7?us giv+ bir? to a mixture72 at ! same "t1 %e rema9s )\t alt]ation1 z two ?+s t are only plac$ by ea* o!rs' side2 & %e pres]ves h] unity4 ,?us1 accord+ to h] own life1 %e modifies t to :i* %e is unit$1 b %e is n modifi$ !reby4 ,j z ! sun1 by its pres5ce1 makes ! air lum9\s1 )\t itself *ang+ 9 any way1 & ?us1 s to speak1 m+les itself !re)1 )\t m+l+ itself 79 reality71 s ! s\l1 ?\gh unit$ ) ! body1 rema9s q di/9ct !refrom4 ,b !re is ?is diff]5ce1 t ! sun1 be+ a body1 & consequ5tly be+ circumscrib$ )9 a c]ta9 space1 is n ev]y:]e :]e is its light2 j z ! fire dwells 9 ! wood1 or 9 ! wick ( ! lamp1 z if enclos$ )9 a locality2 b ! s\l1 be+ incorporeal1 & n be+ subject$ to any local limitation1 exi/s z a :ole ev]y:]e :]e h] light is2 & !re is no "p ( ! body t is illum9at$ by ! s\l 9 :i* ! s\l is n entirely pres5t4 ,x is n ! body t comm&s ! s\l2 x is ! s\l1 on ! contr>y1 t comm&s ! body4 ,%e is n 9 ! body z if 9 a vase or a g\rd2 x is r ! body t is 9 ! s\l4#cgj ,! intelligible1 !re=e1 is n imprison$ )9 ! body2 x spreads 9 all ! body's p>ts1 x p5etrates !m1 x goes ?r\gh !m1 & c\ld n be enclos$ 9 any place2 = by virtue ( its nature1 x resides 9 ! intelligible _w2 x has no locality o!r ?an itself1 or ?an an intelligible situat$ /ill high]4 ,?us ! s\l is )9 h]self :5 %e reasons1 & 9 intellig5ce :5 %e yields h]self to contemplation4 ,:5 x is ass]t$ t ! s\l is 9 ! body1 x is n meant t ! s\l is 9 x z 9 a locality2 x is only meant t ! s\l is 9 a habitual relation ) ! body2 & t ! s\l is pres5t !re1 z we say t ,god is 9 u4 ,= we ?9k t ! s\l is unit$ to ! body1 n 9 a corporeal & local mann]1 b by ! s\l's habitual relations1 h] incl9ation & disposition1 z a lov] is atta*$ to 8 belov$4 ,besides1 z ! affection ( ! s\l has nei!r ext5sion1 nor weight1 nor p>ts1 %e c\ld n be circumscrib$ by local limitations4 ,)9 :at place c\ld t :i* has no p>ts be conta9$8 ,= place & corporeal ext5sion are insep>able2 ! place is limit$ space 9 :i* ! conta9] conta9s ! conta9$4 ,b if we 7 to say1 ,my s\l is !n 9 ,alex&ria1 9 ,rome1 & ev]y:]e else2 we w\ld be /ill speak+ ( space c>elessly1 s9ce be+ 9 ,alex&ria1 or 9 g5]al1 be+ some:]e1 is be+ 9 a place2 n[ ! s\l is absolutely 9 no place2 %e c only be 9 "s relation ) "s place1 s9ce x has be5 demon/rat$ t %e c\ld n be conta9$ )9 a place4 ,if !n an intelligible entity be 9 relation ) a place1 or ) some?+ locat$ 9 a place1 we say1 9 a figurative mann]1 t ?is intelligible entity is 9 ?is place1 because x t5ds ?i!r by its activity2 & we take ! location = ! incl9ation or = ! activity :i* leads x ?i!r4 ,if we 7 to say1 ,t is :]e ! s\l acts1 we w\ld be say+1 ,! s\l is !re4 ,b4 ,,notice ,,( ,,ammonius ,,by ,,hi]ocles4#cga ,!n %one ! wisdom ( ,ammonius1 :o is fam\s "u ! "n ( ,inspir$ by ! ,div9ity4 ,x 0 he1 9 fact1 :o1 purify+ ! op9ions ( ! anci5t philosoph]s1 & dissipat+ ! fancies wov5 "h & !re1 e/abli%$ h>mony betwe5 ! tea*+ ( ,plato1 & t ( ,ari/otle1 9 t :i* 0 mo/ ess5tial & fundam5tal4444 ,x 0 ,ammonius ( ,alex&ria1 ! ,inspir$ by ! ,div9ity1 :o1 devot+ himself en?usia/ically to ! tru? 9 philosophy1 & ris+ above ! popul> notions t made ( philosophy an object ( scorn1 cle>ly und]/ood ! doctr9e ( ,plato & ( ,ari/otle1 ga!r$ !m into a s+le ideal1 & ?us peacefully h&$ philosophy d[n to 8 disciples ,plot9os1 ! 7pagan7 ,orig51 & _! successors4 ,,plot9ic ,,/udies ,,9 ,,s\rces1 ,,developm5t ,,& ,,influ5ce4 ,i4 ,,developm5t ,,9 ,,! ,,tea*+s ,,( ,,plot9os4 ,x 0 only ?r\gh long h>d "w t ! writ] arriv$ at conclusions :i* ! read] may be dispos$ to accept z v natural1 "u ! circum/ances4 ,x is possible t ! read] may1 nev]!less1 be int]e/$ 9 ! mann] 9 :i* ! sugge/ion "h advanc$ 0 rea*$4 ,! writ] _h = sev]al ye>s be5 work+ at ! premi] edition ( ! fragm5ts ( ,num5ius1 9 reasonably complete =m1 ) translation & outl9e4 ,aft] ransack+ ! accessible s\rces ( fragm5ts1 !re rema9$ yet an alleg$ treatise ( ,num5ius on ,matt]1 9 ! libr>y ( ! ,escoreal1 ne> ,madrid4 ,?is _h be5 kn[n to savants 9 ,g]many = _m ye>s2 & ,pr(4 ,uz5]1 ( ,bonn1 9 8 criticism ( ,!d+a's p>tial collection ( fragm5ts1 _h express$ a /rong desire t x be inve/igat$2 x _h also be5 notic$ by ,zell]1 & ,b\illet1 z well z ,*aignet4 ,if !n ,i hop$ to publi% a comp>atively reliable collection ( ! fragm5ts ( ,num5ius1 x 0 my duty1 ?\gh hail+ f f> ,am]ica1 & ?\gh no ,european _h %[n en\gh int]e/ !re9 to s5d = a photographic copy1 to g !re1 & get "o1 :i* ,i did 9 ,july1 #aiac4 ,i bore ! preci\s fragm5t to ,ro/ock & ,pr(4 ,!d+a 9 ,hag51 :]e1 h[ev]1 we discov]$ t x 0 no m ?an a section ( ,plot9os's ,enneads1 iii4 #f4f to end4 ,! manuscript did1 inde$1 %[ an erasure ( ! "n ( ,plot9os1 & ! sub/itution ( t ( ,num5ius4 ,aft] ! fir/ disappo9tm5t1 x became unavoidable to ask ! "q :y ! monk %\ld h done t4 ,_h he any reason to suppose t ?is repres5t$ ,num5ian doctr9e1 ev5 if x 0 n writt5 by ,num5ius8 ,hav+ no ext]nal data to g by1 x became necess>y to resort to int]nal criticism1 to comp>e ?is ,plot9ian treatm5t ( matt] ) o!r ,plot9ian treatm5ts1 9 o!r portions ( ! ,enneads4 ,?is !n inevitably l$ to a close scrut9y ( ,plot9os's v>i\s treatm5ts ( ! subject1 ) results t 7 v mu* unlook$ =4 ,?is "p t we might well h _h reason to ascribe to ,num5ian influ5ce1 on ! contr>y1 turn$ out to be by f> m ,plot9ian ?an o!r sections t we w\ld at fir/ h unhesitat+ly consid]$ ,plot9ian1 &1 z w be se5 else:]e1 ! really d\btful portions occur 9 ! v la/ works ( ,plot9os's life1 :]e x w\ld h be5 m natural to expect ! mo/ g5u9e4 ,h[ev]1 ! result 0 a demon/ration ( a progress 9 doctr9es 9 ! c>e] ( ,plot9os1 & aft] a c>eful /udy !re(1 ! read] w agree t we h 9 ?is case e elem5t ( probability 9 favor ( su* a developm5t2 inde$1 x w seem s natural t ! unbias$ read] w ask himself :y ?is idea has n be=e ?is be5 ! g5]al view ( ! matt]4 99 99 99 99 99 ,fir/ a few words ab\t ! di/9ction ( p]iods 9 g5]al4 ,among unreflect+ p1 = c5turies1 x has be5 cu/om>y to settle disputes by appeals to ! ,bible z a :ole4 ,?is 0 always satisfactory1 until somebody else came along :o held totally diff]5t views1 :i* he support$ j z satisfactorily f ! same au?ority4 ,! result 0 ! c5tury-long bloody w>s ( ! ,re=mation1 ev]y:]e leav+ 9 t p>ticul> place1 z ! or?odox1 ! /rong]4 ,s9ce ?irty ye>s1 h[ev]1 ! situation has *ang$4 ,! contradictions ( ! ,bible1 s long ! ammunition ( sc(f]s ( ! type ( ,+]soll1 became ! pa?f9d]s ( ! ,high] ,criticism1 :i* has solv$ ! o!rwise insoluble difficulties by %[+ !m to re/ on p>allel docum5ts1 & diff]5t au?ors4 ,x is no long] suffici5t to appeal to ,isaiah2 we mu/ n[ specify :i* ,isaiah we mean2 & we may no long] ref] to ! book ( ,g5esis1 b to ! ,jehovi/ic or ,elohi/ic docum5ts4 ,?is me?od ( criticism is sl[ly ga9+ gr\nd ) o!r works4 ,! writ]1 = in/ance1 appli$ x ) success to ! ,ga?as1 or hymns ( ,zoroa/]4 ,^! appe> 9 ! ,yasnas 9 two sections :i* h ev] giv5 ! editors mu* tr\ble4 ,ei!r !y 7 pr9t$ 9 ! mean+less traditional ord]1 or !y 7 mix$ confus$ly accord+ to ! editor's fancy1 result+ ( c\rse 9 a fancy picture4 ,! writ]1 h[ev]1 discov]$ !y 7 duplicate lives ( ,zoroa/]1 & pr9t+ !m on opposite pages1 he has %[n p>allel developm5t1 r$uc+ ! age-long difficulties to p]fectly reasonable1 & mutually confirm+ ord]4 ,ano!r case is t ( ,plato4 ,x is /ill consid]$ all[able to quote ! au?ority ( ,plato1 z su*2 b 9 sci5tific matt]s we mu/ always /ate :i* p]iod ( ,plato's activities1 ! ,plato ( ! ,republic1 or ! m cons]vative ,plato ( ! ,laws1 & ! evil ,_w-s\l1 is meant4 ,ano!r philosoph] 9 ! same case is ,s*ell+1 among ^: views ! text-books di/+ui% z _m z five diff]5t p]iods4 ,?is is no indication ( m5tal in/ability1 b r a pro( t he rema9$ awake z long z he liv$4 ,no man c inde$ cont9ue to ?9k ) g5u95ess )\t *ang+ 8 views2 & only m5 z great z ,bacon or ,em]son h _h ! tem]ity to discr$it consi/5cy :5 x is no m ?an m5tal in]tia4 ,!re are _m o!r fam\s m5 :o *ang$ _! views4 ,prom95t among !m is ,goe!1 ^: ,second ,fau/1 f9i%$ 9 old age1 /rongly contra/$ ) ! ,fir/ ,"p4 ,:at !n w\ld be inh]5tly unlikely 9 ,plot9os's *ang+ 8 views dur+ ! c\rse ( half a c5tury ( philosophical activity8 ,on ! contr>y1 x w\ld be a mu* great] m>vel _h he n done s2 & ! burd5 ( pro( really lies ) ! p>tisans ( un*ang+ op9ions4 ,= example3 9 ii4 #d we f9d ,plot9os discuss+ ! doctr9e ( two matt]s1 ! physical & ! intelligible4 ,9 ! v next book1 ( ! same ,ennead1 9 ii4 #e4c1 we f9d him discr$it+ ?is same intelligible matt]4 ,moreov]1 9 i4 #h4g1 he approves ( ! _w z mixture2 9 ii4 #d4g he disapproves ( x4 ,:at d ^! contradictions mean8 ,t ,plot9os 0 unreliable8 ,t he 0 m5tally incoh]5t8 ,no1 some?+ mu* simpl]4 ,by consult+ ! tables ( ,porphyry1 we discov] ( ! fir/ two1 t ! fir/ /atem5t 0 made dur+ ! ,amelian p]iod1 & ! latt] dur+ ! ,porphyrian4 ,ano!r case ( su* contradiction is 8 ass]tion ( positive evil 7i4 #h7 & 8 d5ial !re( 7ii4 #i74 ,! latt] ass]tion is ( ! ,porphyrian p]iod1 ! =m] is ,eu/o*ian2 :ile ( ! latt] two1 ! fir/ 0 ,eu/o*ian2 & ! second ,amelian4 ,x is simply a case ( developm5t ( doctr9es at diff]5t p]iods ( 8 life4 99 99 99 99 99 ,let u n[ exam9e ,plot9os's v>i\s treatm5ts ( ! subject ( matt]4 ,! fir/ treatm5t ( matt] occurs 9 ! fir/ ,ennead1 & x may be describ$ z ?or\ghly ,num5ian1 be+ treat$ 9 conjunction ) ! subject ( evil4 ,fir/1 we h ! expression ( ! ,supreme hov]+ ov] ,be+4#cgb ,!n we h ! s\l d\ble1#cgc rem9d+ u ( ,num5ius's view ( ! d\ble ,second ,div9ity#cgd & ! d\ble s\l4#cge ,!n we h positive evil occurr+ 9 ! abs5ce ( good4#cgf ,plot9os#cgg opposes ! ,/oic d5ial ( evil1 = he says1 if ?is 7 all1 !re 7 no evil4 ,we f9d a ?reefold division ( ! univ]se )\t ! ,/oic t]m hypo/asis1 :i* occurs 9 ! treatm5t ( ! same topic else:]e4#cgh ,simil> to ,num5ius is ! ,k+ ( all1#cgi ! blissful life ( ! div9ities ar\nd him1#chj & ! division ( ! univ]se into ?ree4#cha ,plot9os#chb ackn[l$ges evil ?+s 9 ! _w1 some?+ d5i$ by ! ,/oics1#chc b taught by ,num5ius1 z is also orig9al1 prim>y exi/5ce ( evil1 9 itself4 ,evil is "h said to be a hypo/asis 9 itself1 & imp>ts evil qualities to o!r ?+s4 ,x is an image ( be+1 & a g5u9e nature ( evil4 ,plot9os describes#chd matt] z fl[+ et]nally1 :i* rem9ds u unmi/akably ( ,num5ius's image#che ( matt] z a swiftly fl[+ /ream1 unlimit$ & inf9ite 9 dep?1 bread?1 & l5g?4 ,evil inh]es 9 ! mat]ial "p ( ! body1#chf & is se5 z actual1 positive1 d>kness1 :i* is ,num5ian1 z f> z x means a def9ite pr9ciple4#chg ,plot9os also#chh insi/s on ! in]adicability ( evil1 9 almo/ ! same t]ms z ,num5ius1#chi :o calls on ,h]aclitus & ,hom] z support]s4 ,plot9os#cij z reason = ?is assigns ! fact t ! _w is a mixture1 :i* is ! v pro( advanc$ by ,num5ius 9 #ab4 ,plot9os1 moreov]1#cia def9es matt] z t :i* rema9s aft] all qualities are ab/ract$2 ?is is ?or\ghly ,num5ian4#cib ,9 ! f\r? book ( ! ,second ,ennead ! treatm5t ( matt] is orig9al1 & is bas$ on comp>ative /udies4 ,evil has disappe>$ f ! horizon2 & ! long treatm5t ( ! controv]sy ) ! ,gno/ics#cic is devot$ to expla9+ away evil z misund]/ood good4 ,al?\gh he beg9s by f9d+ fault ) ,/oic mat]ialism1#cid he ass]ts two matt]s1 ! intelligible & ! physical4 ,intelligible matt]#cie is et]nal1 & possesses ess5ce4 ,plot9os goes on#cif to argue = ! necessity ( an intelligible1 z well z a physical sub/rate 7hypokeim5on74 ,9 ! next p>agraph#cig ,plot9os seems to und]take a hi/orical polemic1 aga9/ ?ree traditional tea*]s 7,emp$ocles1 ,anaxagoras1 & ,democritus7 "u ^: names he 0 surely f9d+ fault ) _! disciples3 ! ,/oics1 ,num5ius1 & possibly su* ?9k]s z ,lucretius4 ,emp$ocles is held responsible = ! view t elem5ts are mat]ial1 evid5tly a ,/oical view4 ,anaxagoras is held responsible = ?ree views1 :i* are di/9ctly ,num5ian3 t ! _w is a mixture1#cih t x is all 9 all1#cii & t x is inf9ite4#djj ,we might1 9 pass+1 notice ano!r ,plot9ian contradiction 9 "h condemn+ ! _w z mixture1 approv$ 9 ! =m] passage4#dja ,z to ! atomism ( ,democritus1 x is n cle> ) :i* contempor>ies he 0 f9d+ fault4 ,intelligible matt] reappe>s#djb :]e we also f9d aga9 ! idea ( d\bl5ess ( ev]y?+4 ,z to ! t]ms us$ by ! way1 we f9d ! ,/oic categories ( ,o!rness or ,v>iety#djc & ,motion2 ! conceptual sem9al logoi1 & ! ,ko9 ousia ( matt]2 b 9 8 psy*ology he uses logos & nosis1 in/ead ( n\s & phronesis1 :i* are f\nd 9 ! ,escorial section1 & :i* are m ,/oical4 ,we also f9d ! ,ari/otelian category ( en]gy1 or pot5tiality4 ,9 ! v next book ( ! same ,ennead1#djd we f9d ano!r treatm5t ( matt]1 on an entirely diff]5t basis1 acc5t$ by a rejection ( intelligible matt]4#dje ,"h ! :ole basis ( ! treatm5t ( matt] is ! ,ari/otelian category ( en]geia & dunamis1 or pot5tiality & actuality1 ,al?\gh we f9d ! ,/oic t]m hypo/asis1 ! book seems to be m ,num5ian1 = matt] is aga9 a positive lie1 & ! div9ity is describ$ by ! ,num5ian d\ble "n#djf ( ,be+ & ,ess5ce 7ousia & to on74 ,we n[ come to ! ,escorial section4#djg ,?is is by f> ! mo/ ext5sive treatm5t ( matt]1 & z we are *iefly int]e/$ 9 x 9 connection ) its be>+ ! "n ( ,num5ius at ! ,escorial1 we %all analyze x = & aga9/ ?is ,num5ian au?or%ip1 m]ely not+ t ! *ief purpose is to describe ! impassibility ( matt]1 a ,/oic idea4 ,= ,num5ius z au?or we note3 a4 ,a great anxiety to pres]ve agreem5t ) ,plato1 ev5 to ! po9t ( /ret*+ def9itions4#djh b4 ,plato's idea ( p>ticipation1 useless to moni/ic ,/oics1 is repeat$ly us$4#dji ,num5ius _h gone s f> z to ass]t a p>ticipation1 ev5 9 ! intelligibles4#daj c4 ,matt] appe>s z ! curse ( all exi/5t objects4#daa ,x also appe>s z "m4#dab d4 ,try z he may1 ! au?or ( ?is section _c escape ! dualism s prom95t 9 ,num5ius2#dac ! acrobatic nature ( 8 ef=ts 9 ?is direction are po9t$ out else:]e4 ,we f9d "h a ?or\ghgo+ di/9ction betwe5 s\l & body1 :i* is q ,num5ian1 & duali/ic4#dad e4 ,matt] is passive1 possess+ no resili5cy4#dae f4 ,we f9d an argum5t direct$#daf aga9/ ^? :o posit be+ 9 matt]4 ,^! mu/ be ! ,/oics1 ) :om ,num5ius is ev] 9 feud4 g4 ,( ,num5ian t]ms1 we f9d st]ia1#dag ,god ! ,fa!r4#dah ,also ! d\ble ,num5ian "n = ! ,div9ity1 ,be+ & ,ess5ce4#dai ,aga9/ ,num5ius z au?or1 we note3 a4 ,! g5]al =m ( ! section1 :i* is t ( ! ,enneads1 n ! dialogue ( ,num5ius's ,treatise on ! ,good4 ,we f9d also ! usual ,plot9ic int]ject$ que/ions4 b4 ,un-,num5ian1 at lea/1 is matt] z a mirror1#dbj & evil z m]ely negative1 m]ely unaffectability to good4#dba ,:ile ,num5ius speaks ( matt] z nurse & fe$]1 "h we read nurse & receptacle4 c4 ,/oic1 is ! *ief subject ( ! section1 namely ! affectibility ( matt]4 ,also1 ! allegoric int]pretation ( ! my?s1 ( ! i?yphallic ,h]mes1 & ! ,univ]sal ,"m1 :i* are l ! o!r ,plot9ic my?s1 ( ! d\ble ,h]cules1 ,poros1 ,p5ia1 & ,koros4 ,we f9d#dbb ! ,/oic idea ( passibility & impassibility1 al?\gh n exactly t ( passion & action4 ,we f9d#dbc connect$ ! t]ms n\s & phronsis1 also ana/asis4 ,! t]m hypo/asis1 ?\gh us$ undogmatically1 z m]e explanation ( ?\ght1 is f\nd4#dbd ,frequ5t#dbe are ! conceptual logoi ( ! div9e ,m9d 7! sem9al logoi7 :i* ent] into matt] to clo! !mselves ) x1 to produce objects4 ,we also h ! ,/oic category het]ots1#dbf & ! application ( sex z explanation ( ! diff]5ces ( ! _w4#dbg d4 ,ari/otelian1 are ! en]geia & dunamis4#dbh e4 ,plot9ic1 are ! latt] ideas1 = !y are us$ 9 ! same connection4#dbi ,also ! my?s ( ,poros1 ,p5ia & ,koros1 :i* are f\nd else:]e 9 simil> relations4#dcj ,on ! :ole1 !re=e1 ! ,plot9ic au?or%ip is mu* m /rongly indicat$ ?an ! ,num5ian4 ,! next treatm5t ( matt] 9 ! ,f\r? ,ennead1 is semi-/oical4#dca ,! opposite aspects ( ! ,univ]se appe> aga9 z phronesis & phusis4 ,we f9d "h ! ,/oic do+ & suff]+1 &#dcb hypo/asis4 ,nev]!less1 ! *ief process illu/rat$ is /ill ! ,platonic image reproduc$ less & less cle>ly 9 successively m degrad$ sph]es ( be+4 ,plot9os seems to put himself out ( ! ,num5ian sph]e ( ?\ght1 ref]r+ to x 9 ab/ract hi/orical mann]1 z belong+ to ! successors ( ,py?agoras & ,ph]ecydes1 :o treat$ ( matt] z ! elem5t t di/+ui%$ objects 9 ! intelligible _w4 ,! la/ treatm5t ( matt]#dcc seems to h rea*$ ! extreme di/ance ( ,num5ianism4 ,in/ead ( a dualism1 ) matt] an orig9al1 positive pr9ciple1 ,plot9os closes 8 discussion by /at+ t p]haps =m & matt] may n come f ! same orig91 z !re is "s diff]5ce betwe5 !m4 ,he has j said t ,be+ is common to bo? =m & matt]1 z to quality1 ?\gh n z to quantity4 ,a little above ?is he insi/s t matt] is n some?+ orig9al1 z x is lat] ?an _m e>?ly1 & ?an all intelligible objects4 ,z to ! ,num5ian d\ble "n ( ! ,div9ity1 ,be+ & ,ess5ce1 he _h tak5 f ,ari/otelianism ! conceptions ( en]geia & dunamis1 & add$ !m z ! supreme hypo/asis1 s z to =m 9 !ological dialect ! triad he1 foll[+ ,num5ius & ,plato1 _h always ass]t$ cosmologically 7good1 intellect1 & s\l73 ,! develop$ en]gy#dcd assumes hypo/asis1 z if f a great1 nay1 z f ! greate/ hypo/asis ( all2 & s x jo9s ,ess5ce & ,be+4 ,review+ ^! v>i\s treatm5ts ( matt] we might call ! fir/#dce ,num5ian2 ! next#dcf ,platonic 7z mo/ indep5d5t1 & hi/orically treat$72 ! next#dcg z ,ari/otelian2 ! ,escorial ,section z semi-,/oic2#dch z also ano!r %ort notice4#dci ,! la/ treatm5t ( matt]1 9 vi4 #c4g1 is fully ,/oic1 9 its d5ial ( ! evil ( matt]4 ,h[ !n %all we expla9 ^! diff]5ces8 ,*iefly by /udy+ ! p]iods 9 :i* !y are writt51 & :i* !y !re=e expla94 99 99 99 99 99 ,:5 we try to /udy ! p]iods 9 ,plot9os's ?\ght1 z %[n 9 8 books1 we are met ) great difficulties1 :i* are *iefly due to ,porphyry4 ,exactly foll[+ ! contempor>y me?ods ( ! compil]s ( ! ,bible1 he undisc]n+ly confus$ ! writ+s ( ! v>i\s p]iods1 s z to make up an an?ology1 gr\p$ by six gr\ps ( n9e books ea*1 accord+ to subjects1 consi/+ fir/ ( e?ical disquisitions2 second1 ( physical que/ions2 ?ird1 ( cosmic consid]ations2 f\r?1 ( psy*ological discussions2 fif?1 ( transc5d5tal lucubrations2 & six?1 ( metaphysics & !ology4#ddj ,z ! read] might guess f ! ov]symmetrical gr\p+1 & ?is pretty classification1 ! app>5t ord] is only illusory1 z he may h conclud$ f ! fact t ! discussions ( matt] analyz$ above are scatt]$ ?r\gh\t ! :ole range ( ?is an?ology4 ,! result ( ?is ,procru/ean arrangem5t 0 ! same z ) ! ,bible3 a confusion ( mosaic1 out ( :i* pretty ne>ly any?+ c\ld be prov$1 & into :i* almo/ ev]y?+ has be5 read4 ,comp>e ! outl9es ( ! doctr9es ( ,plot9os by ,ritt]1 ,zell]1 ,ueb]weg1 ,*aignet1 ,mead1 ,gu?rie1 & ,drews1 & x w be se5 t !re is v little agreem5t betwe5 !m1 :ile none ( !m all[ = ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! v>i\s p>ts ( ! ,enneads4 ,h[ fe>ful ! confusion is1 w be/ be realiz$ f ! foll[+ two tables1 made up f ! indications giv5 9 ,porphyry's ,life ( ,plot9os4 ,porphyry gives ?ree li/s ( ! works ( ! v>i\s p]iods4 ,id5tify+ ^! 9 ! pres5t ,ennead arrangem5t1 !y are to be f\nd z foll[s3 ,! works ( ! ,amelian p]iod are n[ i4 #f2 iv4 #g2 iii4 #a2 iv4 #b2 v4 #i2 iv4 #h2 iv4 #d2 iv4 #i2 vi4 #i2 v4 #a2 v4 #b2 ii4 #d2 iii4 #i2 ii4 #b2 iii4 #d2 i4 #i2 ii4 #f2 v4 #g2 i4 #b2 i4 #c2 i4 #h4 ,! works ( ! ,porphyrian p]iod are n[ vi4 #e1 #f2 v4 #f2 ii4 #e2 iii4 #f2 iv4 #c-e2 iii4 #h2 v4 #h2 v4 #e2 ii4 #i2 vi4 #f2 ii4 #h2 i4 #e2 ii4 #g2 vi4 #g2 vi4 #h2 ii4 #a2 iv4 #f2 vi4 #a-c2 iii4 #g4 ,! works ( ! late/ or ,eu/o*ian p]iod are3 i4 #d2 iii4 #b1 #c2 v4 #c2 iii4 #e2 i4 #h2 ii4 #c2 i4 #a2 i4 #g4 7,= ,eu/o*ius1 see ,s*olion to ,enn4 iv4 #d4bi1 ii4 #g4hf1 ,creuz4 #a1 #cja ,kir*h(47 ,a m conv5i5t table w be ! conv]se arrangem5t4 ,foll[+ ! pres5t normal ord] ( ! books 9 ,enneads1 we w describe its p]iod by a lett]1 ref]r+ to ! ,amelian p]iod by ,a1 to ! ,porphyrian by ,p1 & ! ,eu/o*ian by ,e4 ,i3 ,,eaaepaeaa4 ,,ii3 ,,paeapappp4 ,,iii3 ,,aeeaeappa4 ,,iv3 ,,aappppaaa4 ,v3 ,,aaeappapa4 ,,vi3 ,,ppppppppa4 ,?is artificial arrangem5t into ,enneads %\ld !re=e be ab&on$1 & 9 a new ,engli% translation t ! writ] has 9 m9d1 ! books w\ld appe> 9 ! ord] ( _! p]iods1 :ile an index w\ld all[ easy ref]5ce by ! old numb]s4 ,!n only w we be able to /udy ! successive *anges ( ,plot9os's ?\ght1 9 _! normal mutual relation2 & x is n difficult to prophesy t important results w\ld foll[4 99 99 99 99 99 ,hav+ ?us a*iev$ int]nal pro( ( developm5t ( doctr9es 9 ,plot9os1 by exam9ation ( 8 views ab\t ,matt]1 we may ) "s confid5ce /ate t ! ext]nally kn[n facts ( ! life ( no philosoph] l5d !mselves to su* a progress ( op9ions m readily ?an t ( ,plot9os4 ,8 biograph]1 ,porphyry1 z we h se51 _h already giv5 u a li/ ( ! works ( ?ree easily *>act]iz$ p]iods 9 ,plot9os's life3 ! p]iod be=e ,porphyry came to him1 ! p]iod :ile ,porphyry /aid ) him1 & ! lat] p]iod :5 ,plot9os 0 alone1 & ,porphyry 0 9 retirem5t 7or bani%m5t87 9 ,sicily4 ,an ext]nal division into p]iods is !re=e op5ly ackn[l$g$2 b x rema9s = u to recall its significance4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 ! read] w ask himself1 h[ does x come ab\t t ,plot9os is s dep5d5t on ,porphyry1 & be=e him1 on ,amelius8 ,! answ] is t ,plot9os himself 0 evid5tly some:at defici5t 9 ! details ( elem5t>y education1 h[ev] mu* pr(ici5cy 9 m g5]al philosophical /udies1 & 9 indep5d5t ?\ght1 & p]sonal magnetic t\* ) pupils he may h a*iev$4 ,8 pronunciation 0 defective1 & 9 writ+ he 0 c>eless1 s mu* s t he usually fail$ to affix prop] head+s or notice ( def9ite au?or%ip4#dda ,^! peculi>ities w\ld to "s ext5t put him 9 ! p[]1 & "u ! influ5ce ( 8 editors1 & ?is expla9s :y he 0 dep5d5t on ,porphyry lat]1 & ,amelius e>li]4#ddb ,^! editors might easily h ex]t$ pot5t1 ev5 if unconsci\s or m]ely sugge/ive influ5ce2 b we "k t ,porphyry did n scruple to add glosses ( 8 own1#ddc n to speak ( hidd5 ,/oic & ,ari/otelian pieces1#ddd = he reli$ on ,ari/otle's ,metaphysics4 ,besides1 ,plot9os 0 s g5]ally accus$ ( plum+ himself on writ+s ( ,num5ius1 falsely pass$ (f z 8 own1 t x became necess>y = ,amelius to write a book on ! diff]5ces betwe5 ,num5ius & ,plot9os1 & = ,porphyry to def5d 8 ma/]1 z well z to quote a lett] ( ,long9us on ! subject2#dde b ,porphyry does n d5y t among ! writ+s ( ! ,platoni/s ,kronius1 ,caius1 & ,attikus1 & ! ,p]ipatetics ,aspasius1 ,alex&] & ,adra/us1 ! writ+s ( ,num5ius also 7 us$ z texts 9 ! s*ool ( ,plot9os 7#ad74 ,hav+ ?us %[n ! influ5ce ( ! editors ( ,plot9os1 we mu/ exam9e :o & :at !y 74 ,let u h[ev] fir/ /udy ! g5]al tr5d ( ! ,plot9ic c>e]4 ,8 la/ p]iod 0 ,/oic practise1 = s zeal\sly did he practise au/]ities t 8 dea? 01 at lea/1 ha/5$ !reby4#ddf ,x is unlikely t he w\ld h foll[$ ,/oic precepts )\t "s sympa?y =1 or acqua9tance ) _! philosophical doctr9es2 & z we saw above1 ,porphyry ackn[l$ges ,plot9os's writ+s conta9 hidd5 ,/oic pieces4#ddg ,!n1 ,plot9os sp5t ! la/ p]iod ( 8 life 9 ,rome1 :]e rul$1 9 philosophical circles1 ! traditions ( ,cic]o1 ,s5eca1 ,epictetus1 & ,m>cus ,aurelius4 ,t ^! ,/oic practices became fatal to him is significant :5 we rememb] t ?is occurr$ dur+ ! f9al abs5ce ( ,porphyry1 :o may1 dur+ 8 pres5ce1 h ex]t$ a fri5dly re/ra9t on ! zeal\s ma/]4 ,at any rate1 x 0 dur+ ,porphyry's regime t ! *ief works ( ,plot9os 7 writt51 includ+ a bitt] diatribe aga9/ ! ,gno/ics1 :o rema9$ ! *ief protagoni/s ( dualism & belief 9 positive evil4 ,prophyry's "w1 ,de ,ab/95tia1 proves cle>ly en\gh 8 ,/oic sympa?ies4 ,su* aggressive enmity is too positive to be acc\nt$ = by ! m]e removal to ,rome f ,alex&ria1 & sugge/s a break ( "s sort ) =m] fri5ds4 ,indications ( su* a break d exi/1 namely1 ! p]man5t dep>ture to 8 e>li] home1 ,apamea1 ( 8 =m] editor1 ,amelius4 ,we he>#ddh ( an incid5t 9 :i* ,amelius invit$ ,plot9os to come & take "p 9 ! ,new ,moon celebrations#ddi ( ! my/]ies4 ,plot9os1 h[ev]1 refus$1 on ! gr\nds t ,!y mu/ come to me1 n ,i g to !m4 ,!n we he>#dej ( bad blood betwe5 ?is ,amelius & ,porphyry1 a long1 bitt] controv]sy1 pat*$ up1 inde$1 b :i* _c h fail$ to leave its m>k4 ,!n ?is ,amelius writes a book on ! ,diff]5ces betwe5 ,plot9os & ,num5ius1 :i*1 9 a long lett]1 he inscribes to ,porphyry1#dea z if ! latt] 7 ! *ief "o int]e/$ 9 ^! di/9ctions4 ,lat]1 ,amelius1 :o be=e ?is seems to h be5 ! *ief disciple & editor ( ,plot9os1 dep>ts1 nev] to return1 8 place be+ tak5 by ,porphyry4 ,x is n necess>y to possess a vivid imag9ation to read betwe5 ! l9es1 especially :5 ,plot9os1 9 ! la/ "w ( ?is p]iod1 aga9/ ! ,gno/ics1 section #aj1 seems to ref] to fri5ds ( 8 :o /ill held to o!r doctr9es4 ,n[ 9 ord] to und]/& ! nature ( ! p]iod :5 ,amelius 0 ! *ief disciple ( ,plot9os1 we mu/ recall :o ,amelius 04 ,9 ! fir/ place1 he hail$ f ! home-t[n ( ,num5ius1 ,apamea 9 ,syria4 ,he _h adopt$ z son ,ho/ilianus-,hesy*ius1 :o also hail$ f ,apamea4 ,& x 0 to ,apamea t ,amelius )drew1 aft] he left ,plot9os4 ,we are !re=e n surpris$ to le>n t he _h writt5 out almo/ all ! books ( ,num5ius1 t he _h ga!r$ !m toge!r1 & le>n$ mo/ ( !m by he>t4#deb ,!n we le>n f ,proclus 7see ,zell]'s acc\nt7 t ,amelius taught ! tr9e division ( ! div9e creator1 exactly z did ,num5ius4 ,is x any wond]1 !n1 t he wrote a book on ! diff]5ces betwe5 ,plot9os & ,num5ius at a lat] date1 :5 ,porphyry _h />t$ a polemic ) him8 ,dur+ 8 p]iod z disciple ( ,plot9os1 tw5ty-f\r ye>s 9 duration1 ,plot9os w\ld naturally h be5 "u ,num5ian influ5ce ( "s k9d1 & we _c be v f> wrong 9 ?9k+ t ?is *ange ( editors mu/ h left "s sort ( impress on ! dreamy ?9k]1 ,plot9os1 ev] seek+ to exp]i5ce an ec/asy4 99 99 99 99 99 ,9 ?is acc\nt ( ! matt] we h re/ra9$ ourselves f m5tion+ "o ( ! /range/ co9cid5ces 9 lit]ature1 :i* w\ld h emphasiz$ ! nature ( ! break ( ,amelius ) ,plot9os1 = ! reason t x may be no m ?an a *ance pun2 b t ev5 z su* x mu/ h be5 pres5t to ! actors 9 t drama1 !re is no d\bt4 ,we read above t ,amelius invit$ ,plot9os to accompany him to att5d p]sonally ! my/]y-celebrations at ! n\mnia1 a "t sacr$ to su* celebrations4#dec ,b ?is 0 practically ! "n ( ,num5ius1 & ! text might well h be5 translat$ t ,amelius invit$ him to visit ! celebrations z ,num5ius w\ld h done2 & inde$1 f all we "k ( ,num5ius1 ) 8 initiation at ,eleusis & 9 ,egypt1 t is j ( :at we might h suppos$ he w\ld h approv$4 ,9 o!r words1 we w\ld discov] ,amelius 9 ! pa9ful act ( *oice betwe5 ! two great influ5ces ( 8 life1 ,num5ius1 & ,plot9os4 ,moreov]1 t ! incid5t 0 important is reveal$ by ,porphyry's call+ ,plot9os's answ] a great ^w1 :i* 0 mu* comm5t$ on1 & long rememb]$4 99 99 99 99 99 ,9 ?us divid+ ! c>e] ( ,plot9os 9 ! ,amelian1 ! ,porphyrian1 & ,eu/o*ian 7#ih7 we meet h[ev] "o v int]e/+ difficulty4 ,! ,plot9ic writ+s by ,porphyry assign$ to ! la/ or ,eu/o*ian p]iod are ^? :i* int]nal criticism w\ld lead u to assign to 8 v e>lie/ philosophis+2 & 9 our /udy ( ! developm5t ( ! ,plot9ic views ab\t ,matt]1 we h tak5 ! lib]ty ( consid]+ !m z ! e>lie/4 ,we are h[ev] consol$ 9 our regret at hav+ to be s radical1 by notic+ t ,porphyry1 to :om we are indebt$ = our k ( ! p]iods ( ! works1 has done ! same ?+4 ,he says t he has assign$ ! e>lie/ place 9 ea* ,ennead to ! easi] & simpl] discussions2#ded yet ^! late/-issu$ works ( ,plot9os are assign$ to ! v beg9n+ ( ea* ,ennead1 f\r go+ to ! ,fir/ ,ennead1 "o to ! ,second1 ?ree to ! ,?ird1 & "o only to ! ,fif?4 ,if ^! _h be5 ! cr[n+ works ( ! ,ma/]'s life1 especially ! treatise on ! ,fir/ ,god & ,happ9ess1 x w\ld h be5 by him plac$ at ! v end ( all1 & n at ! beg9n+4 ,porphyry mu/ !re=e h possess$ "s ext]nal k :i* w\ld agree ) ! conclusions ( our int]nal criticism1 :i* foll[s4 ,^! ,eu/o*ian works make ! lea/ use ( ,/oic1 or ev5 ,ari/otelian t]ms1 mo/ closely foll[+ ev5 ! actual words ( ,num5ius4 ,= in/ance1 we may glance at ! v fir/ book ( ! ,fir/ ,ennead1 :i* ?\gh ( ! late/ p]iod1 is ?or\ghly ,num5ian4 ,! fir/ important po9t is ! ,fir/ ,div9ity hov]+ ov] ,be+1#dee us+ ! same ^w z ,num5ius4#def ,?is 0 sugge/$ by ,pr(4 ,!d+a4 ,h[ev]1 he appli$ ! words he says to ,num5ius2 b ?is _c be ! case1 z a ,platonic quotation imm$iately4 ,! :ole subject ( ! ,book is ! composite s\l1 & ?is is ?or\ghly ,num5ian4#deg ,!n we h ! giv+ )\t return4#deh ,!n we f9d ! pilot-simile z illu/ration = ! relation ( s\l to body1#dei al?\gh 9 ,num5ius x appe>s ( ! ,logos & ! _w4 ,we f9d ! animal divid$ 9 two s\ls1 ! irrational & ! rational1#dfj :i* rem9ds u ( ,num5ius's division into two s\ls4#dfa ,! s\l consi/s ( a peculi> k9d ( motion1 :i* h[ev] is entirely diff]5t f t ( o!r bodies1 :i* is its own life4#dfb ,?is rem9ds u ( ,num5ius's /ill-/&+ ( ! ,supreme1 :i* h[ev] is simultane\sly innate motion4#dfc ,ref]r+ to ! problem1 discuss$ else:]e1 t ^! ,plot9ic works ( ! late/ or ,eu/o*ian p]iod1 are ! mo/ ,num5ian1 :i* we w\ld be mo/ likely to attribute to 8 e>ly or =mative /age1 r ?an to ! la/ or p]fect$ p]iod1 x is int]e/+ to notice t ^! works seem to imply o!r works ( ! ,amelian or ,porphyrian p]iods1 by ! words1#dfd ,x has be5 said1 or treat$ (1 ref]r+ evid5tly to sev]al passages4#dfe ,/ill ?is ne$ n necess>ily ref] to ?is lat] "w1 x may ev5 ref] to ,plato1 or ev5 to ,num5ius's allegory ( ! ,cave ( ! ,nymphs1#dgj :]e ! desc5t ( ! s\ls is mo/ def9itely /udi$4 ,or x might ev5 ref] to ,num4 #ce;a1 :]e bir? or g5esis is ref]r$ to z ! wett+ ( ! s\ls 9 ! matt] ( bodies4 ,moreov]1 !y conta9 an ackn[l$gm5t1 & a /udy ( positive evil1 some?+ :i* w\ld be v unlikely aft] 8 elaborate expla9+ away ( evil 9 8 treatise aga9/ ! ,gno/ics1 ( ! ,porphyrian p]iod1 & 8 la/ treatm5t ( ,matt]1 :]e he is ev5 will+ to grant ! possibility ( matt] possess+ ,be+4 ,! natural process = any ?9k] mu/ ev] be to beg9 ) comp>ative imitation ( 8 ma/]1 & !n to progress to indep5d5t treatm5t ( ! subject4 ,b = ! process to be rev]s$ is h>dly likely4 ,moreov]1 :5 we exam9e ^! ,eu/o*ian works 9 detail1 !y h>dly seem to be su* z w\ld be ! expressions ( ! la/ ye>s ( an ec/atic1 suff]+ int5se agony at times1 8 int]e/ already direct$ heav5w>ds4 ,! discussion ( a/rology mu/ date f ! e>lie/ association ) ,gno/ics1 9 ,alex&ria1 :o also might h inspir$ or dem&$ a special treatm5t ( ! nature ( evil1 :i* lat] he consi/5tly d5i$4 ,!n !re is an amateuri% treatm5t ( an?ropology 9 g5]al1 :i* ! cumulatively-arrang+ ,porphyry puts at ! v beg9n+ ( ! ,fir/ ,book4 ,! treatise on ! ,fir/ ,good & ,happ9ess1 is n unlike a beg9n]'s fir/ attempt at writ+ out 8 body ( div9ity1 z ,george ,h]b]t said1 & ,porphyry also puts x at ! beg9n+4 ,! ,eros-article is only an amplification ( ,platonic my?s1 inde$ mak+ subtl] di/9ctions1 /ill n ris+ to ! heights ( pure1 subjective speculation4 ,^! g5]al consid]ations may be supplem5t$ by a few m def9ite indications4 ,x is 9 ! ,eros-article t we f9d ! ,platonic my? ( ,poros & ,p5ia4 ,yet ^! reappe> 9 ! e>lie/ ,amelian treatm5t ( matt] 7ii4 #d71 z a sort ( e*o1 m5tion$ only by ! way1 z if !y _h be5 e>li] ?or\ghly ?re%$ out4 ,"h also we f9d only a /ray1 incid5tal use ( ! t]m hypo/asis1 :]eas ! ,/oic language 9 o!r ,amelian & ,porphyrian treatises has already be5 po9t$ out4 ,we are !re=e driv5 to ! foll[+1 v human & natural conclusion4 ,plot9os's fir/ attempts at philosophical writ+ _h consi/$ ( *iefly ,num5ian disquisitions1 :i* w\ld be natural 9 ,alex&ria1 :]e ,num5ius _h probably resid$1 & _h left fri5ds & successors among ! ,gno/ics4 ,:5 ,plot9os w5t to ,rome1 he took ^! writ+s ) him1 b 0 too absorb$ 9 new orig9al ,amelian treatises to resurrect 8 y\?ful ,num5ian attempts1 :i* he probably did n value highly1 z be+ ! lea/ orig9al1 & because !y taught doctr9es he _h left beh9d 9 8 ,ari/otelian & ,/oic progress4 ,he laid !m aside4 ,only :5 ,porphyry _h left him1 & he felt ! increas+ feebl5ess due to old age & ,/oic au/]ities1 did 8 att5dant ,eu/o*ius urge him to pres]ve ^! e>ly works4 ,plot9os 0 will+1 & s5t !m to ,sicily :]e ,porphyry _h retir$4 ,& s x happ5$ ) ,plot9os1 z x has happ5$ ) _m ano!r writ]1 t ! la/ ?+s became fir/1 & ! fir/ became la/4 99 99 99 99 99 ,! idea ( classify+ ! works ( ,plot9os *ronologically1 !re=e1 has s mu* ext]nal pro(1 z well z int]nal indications1 to support x1 t1 no d\bt1 9 ! future no ref]5ce w be made to ,plot9os )\t specify+ to :i* p]iod x ref]s2 & we may expect t future editions ( 8 works w undo ! griev\s confusion introduc$ by ,porphyry1 & ?us r5d] ,plot9os's works comp>atively accessible to rational /udy4 ,!re are besides _m o!r m9or pro(s ( ! *ronological ord] ( ! writ+s ( ,plot9os1 mo/ ( :i* are notic$ at ! head+ ( ea* succe$+ book2 b ! mo/ />tl+ human ref]5ces are ^? to ,amelius's dep>ture z a false fri5d2#dff to ,porphyry's desire to suicide at 8 dep>ture1#dfg & to 8 own imp5d+ dissolution1#dfh ea* ( ^! occurr+ at ! exact "t ( ! ev5t *ronologically1 b c]ta9ly n accord+ to ! traditional ord]4 ,,ii4 ,,platonism3 ,,significance1 ,,progress ,,& ,,results4 ,( all feti%es :i* h misl$ humanity1 p]haps none is responsible = m error ?an t ( orig9ality4 ,z if any?+ c\ld be new t 0 true1 or true t 0 new6 ,! only possible l9es along :i* novelty or progress c lie are our reports1 comb9ations1 & expressions4 ,"s p ?9k !y h done = a poet if !y h %[n t he made use ( suitable mat]ials 9 ! con/ruction ( 8 poem6 ,s ,%akespe>e has be5 %[n to h us$ :ole sc5es f e>li] writ]s4 ,s ,virgil1 by ,macrobius1 has be5 %[n to h laid "u contribution e writ] !n kn[n to be wor? ransack+4 ,dante has also be5 %[n to h re-edit$ contempor>y apocalypses4 ,s ,hom]1 ev51 has be5 %[n to re-tell /ories ga!r$ f _m s\rces4 ,! result is t p g5]ally consid] ,%akespe>e1 ,virgil1 or ,hom] great 9 spite ( _! borr[+s1 :51 on ! contr>y1 ! /atem5t %\ld be t !y 7 great because ( _! rootage 9 ! be/ ( _! p]iod4 ,9 o!r words1 !y are great n because ( _! own p]sonality 7:i* 9 _m cases has dropp$ out ( ! k5 ( hi/ory71 b because !y m fai?fully1 completely1 & h>moni\sly repres5t _! p]iods ?an o!r n[ =gott5 writ]s4 ,!re9 alone lay _! cosmic value1 & _! assurance ( immortality4 ,!y are ! voices ( _! ages1 & we are int]e/$ 9 ! significance ( _! age1 n 9 !m p]sonally4 ,x is f ?is /&po9t t we mu/ approa* ,plato4 ,( 8 p]sonality :at details are kn[n are ( no sot]iologic significance2 & ! reason :y ! _w has n be5 able to get away f him1 & probably nev] w1 is t he sums up prior ,greek philosophy 9 z coh]5t a =m z is possible )\t do+ too great ,procru/ean viol5ce to ! elem5ts 9 "q4 ,?is means t ,plato did n fuse !m all into "o absolutely1 rigid1 coh]5t1 consi/5t sy/em1 9 :i* case 8 utility w\ld h be5 v mu* curtail$4 ,! v =m ( 8 writ+s1 ! dialogue1 left ea* elem5t 9 ! natural liv+ condition to survive on its m]its1 n z an au?oritative oracle1 or ,platonic pronunciam5to1 or cre$4 ,= details1 ! read] is ref]r$ to ,zell]'s full] acc\nt ( ^! pre-,platonic elem5ts4#dga ,b we may summ>ize z foll[s3 ! physical elem5ts to :i* ! ,hylici/s _h 9 turn attribut$ f9ality ,plato unit$ into ,py?agorean matt]1 :i* rema9$ z an elem5t ( ,dualism4 ,! _w ( nature became ! becom+ ( ,h]aclitus4 ,above t he plac$ ! ,be+ ( ,p>m5ides1 9 :i* ! concepts ( ,socrates f\nd place z ideas4 ,^! he id5tifi$ ) ! numb]s & h>monies ( ,py?agoras1 & unit$ !m 9 an ,eleatic unity ( _m1 z an intelligible _w1 or reason1 :i* he ow$ to ,anaxagoras4 ,! *ief idea1 t ( ! ,good1 0 ,meg>o-,socratic4 ,8 cosmology 0 t ( ,timaeus4 ,8 psy*ology 0 bas$ on ,anaxagoras1 z m9d2 on ,py?agoras1 z immortal4 ,8 e?ics are ,socratic1 8 politics are ,py?agorean4 ,:o !re=e w\ld fl\t ,plato1 has all e>li] ,greek philosophy to combat2 & :oev] recognizes ! a*ievem5ts ( ! ,hell5ic m9d w f9d some?+ to praise 9 ,plato4 ,:51 !re=e1 we are /udy+ ,platonism1 we are only /udy+ a bl5d+ ( ! rays ( ,greece1 & we are *iefly int]e/$ 9 ,greece z "o ( ! late/1 cle>e/1 & mo/ k9dr$ expressions ( human ?\ght4 ,if h[ev] we %\ld seek "s "o special ,platonic elem5t1 x w\ld be t g5u95ess ( reflection1 t s9c]ity ( ?\ght1 t makes ( 8 dialogues no cut & dri$ lit]>y figm5ts1 b s\l-trag$ies1 ) liv+1 brea?+1 int]e/ & emotion4 ,plato ?us practis$ 8 doctr9e ( ! d\ble self1#dgb ! high] & ! l[] selves1 ( :i* ! high] might be describ$ z sup]ior to oneself4 ,9 8 lat] p]iod1 t ( ! ,laws1 he appli$ ?is d\ble psy*ology to cosmology1 !reby produc+ d\bl5ess 9 ! _w-,s\l3 besides ! good "o1 appe>s ! evil "o1 :i* introduces ev5 into heav5 ?+s t are n good4 ,x 0 only a /ep f ?is to ! logical d$uction ( ,x5ocrates t ^! ?+s 9 heav5 7 spirits or gu>dians1 bo? good & evil1 assi/+ 9 ! adm9i/ration ( human affairs4#dgc ,su* is ! result ( d\bl5ess introduc$ into an?ropology2 introduc$ into cosmology1 x e/abli%es ,py?agorean indef9ite duality z ! pr9ciple oppos+ ! unity ( goodness4 ,! next /ep 0 tak5 by ,plut>*4 ,! evil demons1 _h1 9 ,/oic phraseology1 be5 call$ physical2 & s1 9 reg>d to matt]1 !y came to /& 9 ! relation ( s\l to body4 ,orig9al matt]1 !re=e1 became two-fold2 matt] itself1 & its mov+ pr9ciple1 ! s\l ( matt]4 ,?is 0 id5tifi$ ) ! worse ,_w-s\l by a developm5t1 or hi/orical ev5t1 :i* 0 ! ord]+ ( ! cosmos1 or1 creation4 ,?is !n 0 ! /ate ( affairs at ! adv5t ( ,num5ius4 ,al?\gh 8 *ief int]e/ lay 9 practical comp>ative religion1 he tri$1 philosophically1 to return to a my?ical orig9al ,platonism or ,py?agoreanism4 ,:at ,plato did = e>li] ,greek speculation1 ,num5ius did = po/-,platonic developm5t4 ,he h>k$ back to ! latt] ,platonic /age1 :i* taught ! evil _w-,s\l4 ,he includ$ ! a*ievem5ts ( ,plut>*1 ! s\l ( matt]1 & ! tr9e division ( a sep>ate pr9ciple1 su* z ,provid5ce4 ,to ! a*ievem5t ( ,x5ocrates he 0 drawn by two p[]ful int]e/s1 ! ,egyptian1 ,h]metic1 ,s]api/ic1 9 connection ) ! evil demons2 & ! ,py?agorean1 9 connection ) ! ,indef9ite-duality4 ,?us ,num5ius's ,hi/ory ( ! ,platonic ,succession is n a delusion2 ,num5ius really did sum up ! positive ,platonic progress1 n omitt+ ev5 ,maximus ( ,tyre's philosophical hi]>*ic explanation ( ! emanative or p>ticipative /ream+ =? ( ! ,div9e4 ,b ,num5ius 0 n m]ely a philosoph]3 ( ?is ga!r+ ( ,platonic a*ievem5ts he made a religion4 ,9 ?is he 0 also foll[+ ! foot/eps ( ,py?agoras1 :o limit$ 8 doctr9es to a gr\p ( /ud5ts4 ,b ,num5ius did n m]ely copy ,py?agoras4 ,num5ius mod]niz$ him1 connect+ up ! ,platonic doctr9al aggregate ) ! my/]y-rites curr5t 9 8 own day4 ,nor did ,num5ius %irk any unpleasant responsibilities ( a re/or] ( ,platonism3 he cont9u$ ! traditional ,academico-,/oical feud4 ,/range to say1 ! la/ great ,/oic philosoph]1 ,posidonius 7,a4,d4 #ace-aea7 hail$ f ,num5ius's home-t[n1 ,apamea1 s t ?is ,/oic feud may h be5 =c$ on ,num5ius f home p]sonalities or conditions4 ,x w\ld seem t 9 ,num5ius & ,posidonius we h a re-enactm5t ( ! trag$y ( ,greek philosophy on a ,syrian !atre1 :]e dogmatic ,/oicism di$1 & ,platonism admitt$ ,ori5tal ideas4 ,apamea1 h[ev]1 _h n yet end$ its role 9 ! developm5t ( ?\ght4 ,num5ius's pupil1 ,amelius1 _h ga!r$1 copi$1 & le>n$ by he>t 8 ma/]'s works4 ,x 0 9 ,apamea t he adopt$ z son ,ho/ilianius-,hesy*ius4 ,aft] a tw5ty-f\r ye>s' soj\rn 9 ,rome he return$ to ,apamea1 & 0 dwell+ !re /ill at ! "t ( ! dea? ( ,plot9os1 ) :om he _h sp5t t qu>t] ( a c5tury4 ,"h !n we h a hi/orical basis = a connection betwe5 ,num5ius & ,plot9os1 :i* we h else:]e endeavor$ to demon/rate f inn] gr\nds4 ,x 0 h[ev] by ,amelius t philosophy is drawn into ! mael/rom ( ! _w-city4 ,plot9os1 9 8 e>ly p]iods a ,num5ian ,platoni/1 w lat] g ov] to ,/oicism1 & conduct a polemic ) ! ,gno/ics1 ! ,alex&rian heirs ( ,platonic dualism1 "u ! influ5ce ( ! ,/oic ,porphyry4 ,h[ev]1 ,plot9os w n publicly ab&on ,platonism2 he w fuse ! two /reams ( ?\ght1 & int]pret 9 ,/oic t]ms ! fundam5tals ( ,platonism1 produc+ some?+ :i*1 :5 translat$ into ,lat91 he w leave z inh]itance to all ! ages4 ,n 9 va91 !re=e1 did ,amelius transport ! tor* ( philosophy to ! ,capital4 99 99 99 99 99 ,let u 9 a few words dispose ( ! g5]al outl9es ( ! fate ( ! ,platonic movem5t4 ,plot9os 0 no religi\s lead]2 he 0 be=e ev]y?+ else a philosoph]1 ev5 if he c5tr$ 8 ef=ts on ! practical aspects ( ! ec/atic union ) ,god4 ,inde$1 ,porphyry relates to u ! incid5t 9 :i* ?is matt] 0 objectively exemplifi$4 ,at ! ,new ,moon1 ,amelius invit$ him to jo9 9 a visit to ! my/]y celebrations4 ,plot9os refus$1 say+ t !y w\ld h to come to him1 n he g ov] to !m4 ,?is !n is ! *ief diff]5ce betwe5 ,num5ius & ,plot9os1 & ! result w\ld be a recrudesc5ce ( pure philosophic cont5tions1 z ^? ( ,plot9os aga9/ ! ,gno/ics4 ,z to ! g5]al significance ( ,plot9os1 we mu/ "h resume :at we h else:]e detail$3 t ) ! *ange ( editors1 f ,amelius to ,porphyry1 ,plot9os *ang$ f ,num5ian or ,py?agorean dualism to ,/oic monism1 9 :i* ! philosophic feud 0 no long] ) ! ,/oics1 b ) ! ,alex&rian desc5dants ( ,num5ian dualism1 ! ,gno/ics4 ,ev5 ?\gh ,plot9os %[$ practical religi\s aspects 9 8 /udy+ & exp]i5c+ ! ec/asy1 !re is no record ( any ( 8 pupils be+ enc\rag$ to d s1 & !re=e ,plot9os rema9s *iefly a philosoph]4 ,! successors ( ,plot9os c\ld n rema9 on ?is purely philosophic /&po9t4 ,in/ead ( practis+ ! ec/asy1 !y foll[$ ! ,gno/ics 9 !oriz+ ab\t practical religi\s reality 9 _! cosmology & !ology1 :i* took on1 m or less1 ! %ape ( magic1 n inconsid]ably aid$ by ,/oic allegoric int]pretations ( my?s1 z 9 ,porphyry's ,cave ( ! ,nymphs4 ,:at ,plato did = e>ly ,greek philosophy1 :at ,num5ius did = po/-,platonic ?\ght1 t ,proclus ,diado*us1 ! ,successor1 did = ,plot9os & 8 foll[]s4 ,= ! fir/ "t s9ce ,num5ius we f9d aga9 a comp>ative me?od4 ,by ?is "t religion & philosophy h fus$ 9 magic1 & s1 in/ead ( a comp>ative religion1 we h a comp>ative philosophy4 ,proclus 0 ! fir/ g5u9e comm5tator1 quot+ au?orities on all sides4 ,he 0 suffici5t ( a philosoph] to grasp ,neoplatonism z a s*ool ( ?\ght2 & f> f pay+ any att5tion to ,ammonius1 z rec5t philosophy has done1 z s\rce ( ,neoplatonism1 he traces ! movem5t z f> z ,plut>*1 call+ him ! fa!r ( u all1 inasmu* z he introduc$ ! conception ( hypo/asis4 ,evid5tly1 ,proclus look$ ^u ?is z ! c5tre ( ,neoplatonic developm5t1 & !re=e we %all be ju/ifi$ 9 a clos] /udy ( ?is conception2 & we may ev5 say t its hi/oric de/9y 0 a cont9uation ( ! ma9 /ream ( creative ,greek philosophy2 or1 if y pref]1 ( ,platonism1 or ,n\m5ianism1 or ev5 ,plot9ian ?\ght4 ,did ,greek philosophy die ) ,proclus8 ,! political *anges ( ! "t =c$ alt]ation ( dialect & position2 b ! accumulations ( m5tal a*ievem5ts c\ld n p]i%4 ,?is aga9 we owe to ,proclus4 ,besides be+ ! fir/ great comm5tator he precipitat$ 8 mo/ valuable a*ievem5ts 9 logical =m1 9 analytic arrangem5t1 9 ! =m ( cry/al-cle> propositions1 !orems1 demon/rations1 & coroll>ies4 ,su* a highly ab/ract =m 0 inevitable1 inasmu* z ,num5ius _h turn$ away f ,ari/otelian obs]vation ( nature4 ,j l ! ,hebrew ?9k]s1 :o f9ally became comm5tators & ab/ract !oriz]s1 no?+ else 0 left = a philosophy )\t connection ) exp]im5t1 :5 :ittl$ d[n by ! ke5e/ intellects ( ! times4 ,?is ab/ract me?od1 /ill famili>ly us$ by geometry1 reappe>$ among ! ,s*ool-m51 notably 9 ,?omas ,aqu9as4 ,lat] x p]si/$ ) ,sp9oza & ,desc>tes4 ,h[ev]1 ris+ exp]im5talism has gradually t]m9at$ x1 its la/ =m appe>+ 9 ,kant & ,hegel4 ,kant's ,d+ 9 si*1 rea*$ aft] ab/ract+ all qualities1 is only a re-/atem5t ( ,num5ius & ,plot9os's subject1 or1 def9ition ( matt]2 & ,hegel's dialectic1 beg9n+ ) ,be+ & ,n-be+1 m def9itely proclaim$ by ,plot9os1 goes z f> back z ! ,eleatics & ,h]aclitus1 n to m5tion ,plato4 ,h[ev]1 ,kant & ,hegel are ! great ma/]s ( mod]n ?\ght2 & al?\gh at "o "t ! ris+ tide ( mat]ialism & crud] =ms ( evolution ?reat5$ to obscure x1 ,k>l ,pe>son's ,gramm> ( ,sci5ce1 g5]\s z x is 9 invective aga9/ ,kant & ,hegel1 9 mod]n t]ms cl9*es ,b]keley's & ,kant's demon/ration ( ! reality ( ! sup]-s5sual1 ?us v9dicat+ ,plot9os1 &1 be=e him1 ,num5ius4 ,x mu/ n be suppos$ t 9 ?us trac+ ! spr+s ( our mod]n ?\ght we necess>ily approve ( all ! ?\ght ( ,plot9os1 ,num5ius or ,plato4 ,on ! contr>y1 !y 7 f> m likely to h committ$ logical errors ?an we are1 because !y 7 hypnotiz$ by ! glamor ( ! t]ms !y us$1 :i* to u are m]e laboratory tools4 ,! be/ way to prove ?is w be to appraise at its logical value = u ,plot9os's discussion ( ,matt]1 else:]e /udi$ 9 its value = u4 ,,iii4 ,,plot9os',s ,,view ,,( ,,matt]4 ,we h else:]e po9t$ out ! hopelessness ( escap+ ei!r aspect ( ! problem ( ! ,"o & ! ,_m2 & t ! attempt ( ! ,/oics to avoid ! ,platonic dualism by a mat]iali/ic monism 0 m]ely a *ange ( names1 ! sub/ance ( ! dualism rema9+ z ! opposition ( ! contr>ies1 su* z active & passive1 male & female1 ! pr$om9ant elem5ts1#dgd etc4 ,plot9os1 9 8 ab&onm5t ( ,num5ian dualism1 & *ampion+ ( ,/oicism1 und]tak+ ! feud ) ! ,gno/ics1 ! successors ( ,num5ius1 mu/ !re=e h inh]it$ ! same difficulties ( ?\ght1 & we %all see h[ 9 spite ( 8 m5tal agility he is caught 9 ! same traditional me%es1 & t ^! irr$ucible difficulties occur 9 ea* "o ( 8 ?ree p]iods ( life1 ! ,eu/o*ian1 ! ,amelian1 & ! ,porphyrian4 ,9 ! ,amelian1 he tea*es two matt]s1 ! physical & ! intelligible1 by :i* device he seeks to avoid ! difficulties ( dualism1 cr$it+ to intelligible matt] any necess>y =m ( ,be+1 ?us pu%+ physical matt] into ! out] d>kness ( non-be+4 ,s intelligible matt] is /ill a =m ( ,be+1 & we /ill hold to monism2 z intelligible matt] may p>ticipate 9 ! good2 :ile matt] physical rema9s evil1 be+ a deprivation ( good1 n possess+ x4 ,?is1 ( c\rse is dualism2 & he ?us has a conv5i5t pun on ! ^w matt]1 by :i* he c be moni/ or duali/1 z ! fancy takes him1 or z exig5cies dem&4 ,?is p>ticipation1 !re=e1 does n elim9ate ! dualism1 :ile =mally pr(ess+ monism4 ,!re=e ,plot9os tries to *oose betwe5 monism & dualism by surreptiti\sly accept+ bo?4 ,9 ! ,porphyrian p]iod1 he reject$ ! idea ( intelligible matt]4#dge ,=c$ to fa%ion entirely new argum5ts1 he seizes z tool ! ,ari/otelian di/9ction betwe5 pot5tiality & actuality1 or en]gy z dynamic accompli%m5t4#dgf ,b no logical device c help a man to pull himself up by 8 boot-/raps4 ,if by ,be+ y mean exi/5ce1 !n its opposite mu/ be negative1 & to speak ( real non-be+1 z some?+ t %>es be+1 is an evasion4 ,to say t matt] rema9s non-be+1 :ile hav+ ! possibility ( future ,be+1 :i* h[ev] c nev] be actualiz$1 is m]e juggl+ ) words4 ,ev5 if matt] is no m ?an a weak1 confus$ image1 x is n non-be+4 ,if x is a positive lie1 x is n non-be+4 ,to talk ( a high] degree ( ,non-be+1 t is real non-be+1 is simply to confuse ! actuality int5d$ ) ! ?\ght ( non-be+1 :i* ( c\rse is a ?\ght z actually exi/+ z any o!r4 ,moreov] if matt] is imp]i%able1 x _c be non-be+2 & if x possesses ,be+ pot5tially1 x c]ta9ly is n non-exi/5ce4 ,! ,ari/otelian pot5tiality c\ld help to create ?is evasion1 b did n remove its real nature2 x m]ely suppli$ ,plot9os ) an intellectual device to *>act]ize some?+ t w\ld n be actually exi/+ z /ill hav+ ! possibility ( exi/5ce2 b ?is is n non-exi/5ce4 ,9 ano!r writ+#dgg ( ?is p]iod ,plot9os cont9ues 8 evasions ab\t ! orig9 & nature ( matt]4 ,fir/1 he grants t x is some?+ t is n orig9al1 be+ lat] ?an _m e>?ly1 & all intelligible objects2 al?\gh1 if he _h return$ to ! conception ( intelligible matt]1 he w\ld h be5 at lib]ty to ass]t ! orig9ality ( ! latt]4 ,!n he holds t ,be+ is common to bo? =m & matt]1 z to quality1 b n z to quantity4 ,la/1 he closes ! p>agraph by say+ t p]haps =m & matt] d n come f ! same orig91 z !re is a diff]5ce betwe5 !m4 ,9 ,plot9os's ?ird1 or ,eu/o*ian p]iod1 ! same evasions occur4 ,= in/ance#dgh he limits ,be+ to goodness4 ,!n he ackn[l$ges ! exi/5ce ( evil ?+s1 & d]ives _! evil quality f a prim>y evil1 ! image ( ess5ce1 ! ,be+ ( evil4 ,t he is consci\s ( hav+ /ra9$ a po9t is evid5t f ! fact t he adds ! clause1 if !re c be a ,be+ ( evil4 ,likewise1#dgi :ile discuss+ evil1 :i* is g5]ally recogniz$ because 9 our daily lives !re is positive pa91 & s5sations ( pa91 he def9es evil z lack ( qualities4 ,to say t evil is n su* z to =m1 b z to nature is opposite to =m is nons5se1 inasmu* z life is full ( positive evils1 z ,num5ius br\ght out 9 #af1 & ,plot9os ackn[l$g$ ev5 9 spite ( 8 polemic aga9/ ! ,gno/ics4 ,f9ally ,plot9os takes refuge 9 a miracle#dhj z explanation ( unp>ticipat+ p>ticipation4 ,?is is comm5t>y en\gh2 x %[s he realiz$ ! futility ( any argum5ts4 ,b ,plot9os 0 n alone 9 despair+ ( e/abli%+ an ironclad sy/em2 be=e him ,num5ius _h1 j z pa!tically1 despair$ ( a logical dualism1 & he ackn[l$g$ 9 fragm5t #af t ,py?agoras's argum5ts1 h[ev] true1 7 wond]ful & oppos$ to ! belief ( a majority ( humanity4 ,9 o!r words1 monism is z unsatisfactory to reason z dualism4 ,?is 0 ! *ief po9t ( agreem5t betwe5 ,py?agoras & ! ,/oics2 & ,pragmatism has 9 mod]n times attempt$ to %[ a way out by a high] sanction ( ano!r k9d4 ,p]haps ! read] may be int]e/$ 9 a side-light on ?is subject4 ,drews is int]e/$ 9 ,plot9os only because ,plot9os's sup]-rational div9ity furni%es a hi/orical f\ndation = ,ed\>d ,h>tmann's philosophy ( ! ,unconsci\s4 ,x w\ld seem1 h[ev]1 to be a mi/ake to use ! latt] t]m1 = x is true only z a d\btful coroll>y4 ,if ! ,supreme is sup]-consci\s1 x is possible to describe ?is logically z unconsci\s4 ,b g5]ally1 h[ev]1 unconsci\sness is a t]m us$ to d5ote ! sub-consci\s1 r ?an ! sup]-consci\s1 & ! use ( t t]m mu/ inevitably entail misund]/&+s4 ,x w\ld be bett] !n to foll[ ,pragmatism into ! sup]-consci\s1 r ?an to s9k ) ,h>tmann into ! sub-consci\s4 ,x 0 directly f ,plot9os#dha t ,h>tmann took 8 expression beyond good & evil4 ,hav+ wat*$ ,num5ius1 = ,platonic dualism2 & ,plot9os = ,/oic monism1 bo? appeal to a miracle z c\rt ( la/ resort1 we may n[ return to t result ( ,platonism :i* has left ! mo/ vital impress on our civilization1 its conception ( ! div9e4 ,,iv4 ,,plot9os',s ,,creation ,,( ,,! ,,tr9ity4 ,else:]e we h se5 h[ ,num5ius wag$ ! traditional ,academic feud ) ! ,/oics bravely1 b uselessly1 inasmu* z x 0 *iefly a diff]5ce ( dialects t sep>at$ !m4 ,9 ! c\rse ( ?is /ruggle1 ,num5ius _h made c]ta9 di/9ctions )9 ! div9ity1 :i* 7 foll[$ by ,amelius1 b are difficult to trace 9 ,plot9os because1 z a matt] ( pr9ciple1 ,plot9os#dhb 0 av]se to ?us divid+ ! div9ity4 ,:y s8 ,because he 0 wag+ a /ruggle ) ! ,gno/ics1 :o _h foll[$ 9 ! foot/eps ( ! ,h]metic writ+s 7) _! ,demiurge & ,sev5 ,gov]nors72 ,philo ,judaeus 7) 8 five ,subord9ate ,p[]s72 ,num5ius & ,amelius 7) _! triply divid$ ,fir/ & ,second gods72--aft] :i* we come to ,basilides 7) 8 sev5 ,p[]s72 ,saturn9us 7) 8 ,sev5 ,angels72 & ,val5t9us 7) 8 #cc ,aeons74 ,?is new feud betwe5 ,plot9os & ! ,gno/ics is h[ev] j z illusory z ! e>li] "o betwe5 ,num5ius & ! ,/oics4 ,x 0 m]ely a matt] ( dialects4 ,plot9os inde$ f\nd fault ) ! ,gno/ics = mak+ divisions )9 ! ,div9ity2 b :]ev] he himself is consid]+ ! div9ity m9utely1 he1 j z mu* z ! ,gno/ics1 is compell$ to draw di/9ctions1 ev5 ?\gh he avoid$ ackn[l$g$ divisions by borr[+ f ,plut>* a new1 non-,platonic1 non-,num5ian1 b ,ari/otelian1 ,/oic 7,cornutus & ,sextus7 & /ill ,alex&rian 7,philo1 ,septuag9t1 ,lucian7 t]m hypo/asis4 ,! diff]5ce he pret5d$ to f9d betwe5 ! ,gno/ic di/9ctions )9 ! ,div9ity & 8 new t]m hypo/asis 0 t ! =m] introduc$ manifoldness into ! div9ity1 by splitt+ ,him1#dhc ?us all[+ ! influ5ce ( matt] to p]vade ! pure realm ( ,be+4 ,hypo/asis1 on ! contr>y1 :olly exi/$ )9 ! realm ( pure ,be+1 & 0 no m ?an a tr5d1 a direction1 a *>act]ization1 a function1 a face1 or ori5tation ( activity ( ! unaffect$ unity ( ,be+4 ,?us ! div9ity reta9$ its unity1 & /ill c\ld be active 9 sev]al directions1 )\t admixture ( :at philosophy _h till !n recogniz$ z con/itut+ manifoldness4 ,b reflection %[s t ?is is a m]e quibble1 an evasion1 a p>alogism1 a quat]nio t]m9orum1 a pun4 ,h[ x came ab\t we %all attempt to %[ bel[4 ,9 ?us a*iev+ a manifoldness 9 ! div9ity )\t divisions1 ,plot9os did inde$ keep out ( ! div9ity ! splitt+ influ5ce ( matt]1 :i* x 0 n[ possible to bani% to ! realm ( unreality1 z a negation1 & a lie4 ,monism 0 ?us a*iev$ 444 b at ! co/ ( two errors3 d5ial ( ! common-s5se reality ( ! ph5om5al _w1#dhd & t quibble ab\t ?ree hypo/ases )\t manifoldness1 g5u9ely a di/9ction )\t a diff]5ce4 ,?is intellectual di%one/y mu/ n h[ev] be foi/$ on ,ari/otle#dhe or ,plut>*4 ,! latt]1 = in/ance1#dhf adopt$ ?is t]m only to d5ote ! prim>y & orig9al *>act]i/ics 7or di/9ctions )97 exi/+ ?+s1 f a comp>ative /udy ( ,ari/otle's de ,anima1 & ,plato's ,pha$o4#dhg ,^! five hypo/ases 7 ! div9ity1 m9d1 s\l1 =ms imman5t 9 inorganic nature1 hexis1 9 ,/oic dialect1 & to matt]1 z ap>t f ^! =ms4 ,s important to ,neoplatonism did ?is t]m seem to ,proclus1 t he did n hesitate to say t ,plut>*1 by ! use !re(1 became our fir/ =efa!r4 ,he !re=e develops x fur!r4 ,among ! hidd5 & intelligible gods are ?ree hypo/ases4 ,! fir/ is *>act]iz$ by ! ,good2 x ?9ks ! ,good itself1 & dwells ) ! pat]nal ,monad4 ,! second is *>act]iz$ by k1 & resides 9 ! fir/ ?\ght2 :ile ! ?ird is *>act]iz$ by beauty1 & dwells ) ! mo/ beautiful ( ! intelligible4 ,!y are ! causes f :i* proce$ ?ree monads :i* are self-exi/5t b "u ! =m ( a unity1 & z 9 a g]m1 9 _! cause4 ,:]e !y manife/1 !y take a di/9ct =m3 fai?1 tru?1 & love 7,c\s9's title3 ,du ,vrai1 du ,beau1 et du ,bi574 ,?is tr9ity p]vades all ! div9e worlds4 ,9 ord] to und]/& ! attitude ( ,plot9os on ! subject1 we mu/ try to put ourselves 9 8 position4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 on ,porphyry's own admission1 he _h add$ to ,platonism ,p]ipatetic & ,/oic views4 ,f ,ari/otle 8 *ief borr[+s 7 ! categories ( =m & matt]1 & ! di/9ction betwe5 pot5tiality & actuality1#dhh z well z ! ,ari/otelian psy*ology ( v>i\s s\ls4 ,to ! ,/oics he 0 drawn by _! monism1 :i* l$ him to drop ! traditional ,academico-,/oic feud1 or r to take ! side ( ! ,/oics aga9/ ,num5ius ! ,platoni/ duali/ & ! duali/ic successors1 ! ,gno/ics4 ,b !re 0 a diff]5ce betwe5 ! ,/oics & ,plot9os4 ,! ,/oics assimilat$ _s to matt]1 :ile ,plot9os1 rem9isc5t ( ,plato1 pref]r$ to assimilate matt] to _s4 ,/ill1 he us$ _! t]m9ology1 & categories1 includ+ ! conception ( a hypo/asis1 or =m ( exi/5ce4 ,) ?is equipm5t1 he held to ! traditional ,platonic tr9ity ( ! ,lett]s1 ! ,k+1 ! intellect1 & ! s\l4 ,philosophically1 h[ev]1 he _h receiv$ f ,num5ius ! inh]itance ( a d\ble "n ( ! ,div9ity1 ,be+ & ,ess5ce4 ,z a ?9k]1 he 0 !re=e =c$ to accommodate ,num5ius to ,plato1 & by add+ to ,num5ius's "n ( ! div9ity1 to complete ,num5ius's !ology by ,num5ius's own cosmology4 ,?is !n he did by add+ z ?ird hypo/asis ! ,ari/otelian dynamic en]gy4 ,b z ,intellect is p]man5t1 h[ c ,en]gy arise !refrom8 ,"h ?is et]nal puzzle is solv$ by di/+ui%+ en]gy into indwell+ & out-fl[+4 ,z indwell+1 ,en]gy con/itutes ,intellect2 b its en]getic nature c\ld n be demon/rat$ except by out-fl[+1 :i* produces a di/9ction4 ,simil>ly1 !re are two k9ds ( heat1 t ( ! fire itself1 & t emitt$ by ! fire1 s t ! fire may rema9 itself :ile ex]t+ its influ5ce )\t4 ,x is ?us also !re3 9 t x rema9s itself 9 its inmo/ be+1 & f its own inh]5t p]fection1 & en]gy1 ! develop$ en]gy assumes hypo/asis1 z if f a ,dynamis t is great1 nay1 greate/2 & s x jo9s ! ,ess5ce & ! ,be+4 ,= t 0 beyond all ,be+1 & t 0 ! ,dynamis ( all ?+s1 & already 0 all ?+s4 ,if !n x is all1 x mu/ be above all2 consequ5tly also above ,be+4 ,& if ?is is all1 !n ! ,"o is be=e all2 n ( an ess5ce equal to all1 & ?is mu/ be above ,be+1 z ?is is above intellect2 = !re is some?+ above intellect4#dhi ,?is is ! mo/ def9ite /atem5t ( ,plot9os's solution ( ! problem2 o!r ref]5ces !reto are abundant4 ,s we h a tr9ity ( en]gy1 be+ & ess5ce1#dij & ea* ( u1 l ! _w-,s\l has an ,eros :i* is ess5ce & hypo/asis4#dia ,reason is a hypo/asis aft] ! n\s1 & ,aphrodite ga9s an hypo/asis 9 ! ,ousia4#dib ,! ,"o is intellect1 ! intelligible1 & ousia2 or1 en]gy1 be+1 & ! intelligible 7ess5ce74#dic ,! s\l is activity4#did ,! s\l is ! ?ird ,god1#die we are ! ?ird rank proce$+ f ! upp] undivid$ ,nature1#dif ! :ole be+ ,god1 n\s1 & ess5ce4 ,! ,n\s is activity1 & ! ,fir/ ess5ce4 ,!re are ?ree /ages ( ! ,good3 ! ,k+1 ! n\s1 & ! s\l4#dig ,we f9d en]gy1#dih ?9k+ & be+1 !n#dii ! s\l1 ! n\s1 & ! ,"o4 ,we f9d ,provid5ce ?reefold 7z 9 ,plut>*7#ejj & ?ree ranks ( ,gods1 demons & _w-life4#eja ,else:]e1 un!ologically1 or1 r1 m]ely philosophically1 he speaks ( ! hypo/asis ( wisdom4#ejb ,*aignet's summ>y ( ?is is#ejc t#ejd ,plot9os holds t e =ce 9 ! intelligible is bo? ,be+ & ,sub/ance simultane\sly2 & reciprocally t no ,be+1 c\ld be conceiv$ )\t hypo/asis1 or direct$ =ce4 ,aga91#eje ! _w1 ! univ]se ( ?+s1 conta9s ?ree natures or div9e hypo/ases1 s\l1 m9d & unity2 :i* inde$ are f\nd 9 our own nature1 & ( :i* ! div9e/ is unity or div9ity4 ,let u n[ try to und]/& ! matt]4 ,:y %\ld ! ^w hypo/asis1 :i* unque/ionably 9 e>li] times meant sub/ance1 h lat] come to mean di/9ctions )9 ! div9ity8 ,= sub/ance1 on ! contr>y1 repres5ts to our m9d an unity1 ! und]ly+ unity1 & n individual =ms ( exi/5ce4 ,h[ did ! *ange occur8 ,n[ ,plot9os1 z we rememb]1 f\nd fault ) ! ,gno/ics 9 t !y taught di/9ctions )9 ! div9ity4#ejf ,he w\ld !re=e be dispos$ to remove f )9 ! div9ity ^? di/9ctions ( ,plot9ic1 ,plut>*ian1 ,num5ian1 or ,gno/ic !ology2 al?\gh he himself 9 e>ly times did n scruple to speak ( a hypo/asis ( wisdom1 or ( ,eros1 or o!r matt] he might be consid]+4 ,su* t]ms ( ,num5ius or ,amelius z he seems to ignore are ! v>i\s ,demiurges2 ! ?ree ,plut>*ian ,provid5ces he himself /ill uses4 ,/ill1 all ^! t]ms he w\ld be dispos$ to eradicate f )9 ! div9ity4 ,z a con/ructive metaphysician1 h[ev]1 he c\ld n well get along )\t "s titles = ! diff]5t phases ( ! div9ity2 & ev5 if he disp5s$ ) ! old names1 !re w\ld /ill rema9 z _! und]ly+ support ! reality or sub/ance ( ! di/9ction4 ,s he remov$ ! (f5sive1 aggressive1 hi/orically kn[n & recogniz$ t]ms1 :ile leav+ _! und]ly+ sub/ances1 or supports4 ,n[ sub/ance _h become sub/ances1 & to diff]5tiate ^! x 0 necess>y to int]pret !m z diff]+ =ms ( exi/5ce4 ,! *ange 0 mo/ def9itely made by ,a?anasius1 :o at a synod 9 ,alex&ria1 9 ,a4,d4 #cfb1ejg fa/5$ on ! *ur*1 z synonym\s ) hypo/asis ! popul> t]m prosopon or face4 ,t ?is 0 an innovation appe>s f ! fact t ! ,nic5e ,c\ncil _h /at$ t x 0 h]etical to say t ,*ri/ 0 ( a hypo/asis diff]5t f t ( ! ,fa!r1 9 :i* case ! ^w evid5tly meant /ill ! orig9al und]ly+ 7s+ul>7 sub/ance4 ,) ?is (ficial def9ition 9 vogue1 ! orig9al 7s+ul>7 sub/ance became =gott51 & x became possible to speak 9 ! plural1 ( ?ree faces1 z inde$ ,plot9os _h done4 ,9 o!r words1 s necess>y 7 di/9ctions 9 ! div9ity1 t ! popul> m9d suppli$ o!r individual names to designate ! di/9ctions ,plot9os _h successfully bani%$1 = ,demiurges & ,provid5ces no long] return4 ,?us m manifold diff]5ces re-ent]$ into ! div9ity1 ?an ,plot9os _h ev] empti$ out ( x1 al?\gh "u a "n :i* ! pov]ty ( ! ,lat9 language r5d]$ z p]sons1 :i* repres5ts to u individual consci\sness ( a f> m di/9ctive k9d ?an 0 ev] impli$ 9 ?ree phases ( ,provid5ce1 or ( ! ,demiurge4 ,?us ! translation into ,lat9 cl9*$ ! illicit l+ui/ic process1 & ! result ( ,plot9os's attempt to di/+ui% 9 ! ,div9ity phases s subtle z n to dem& or all[ ( manifoldness1 result$ 9 ! mo/ pron\nc$ diff]5ces ( p]sonality4 ,?is 0 f9ally cl9*$ by ,plot9os's illu/ration ( ! ?ree faces ar\nd a s+le head1#ejh :i* e/abli%$ ! idea ( ?ree p]sons 7masks1 f p]-son>e7 9 "o ,god4 ,n only 9 ! ab/ract realm ( ,metaphysics1 !re=e1 is ! _w indebt$ to ,greek ?\ght2 b ev5 9 ! realm ( religion a ,/oic re9t]pretation ( ,platonism1 itself re9t]pret$ 9 a diff]5t language has giv5 a la/+ inh]itance to ! spiritual aspirations ( ! ages4 ,v4 ,,resemblances ,,to ,,*ri/ianity4 ,,tr9it>ian ,,significance ,,( ,,plot9os4 ,plot9os's date be+ ab\t ,a4,d4 #bfb1 he /&s midway betwe5 ! ,*ri/ian writ+s ( ! ,new ,te/am5t1 & ! ,c\ncil ( ,nicaea1 ,a4,d4 #cbe4 ,z a philosoph] deal+ ) ! k9dr$ topics--! s\l & its salvation1--& d]iv+ t]m9ology & inspiration f ! same s\rces1 ,platonism & ,/oicism1 we w\ld expect ext5sive p>allelism & correspond5ce4 ,?\gh ,plot9os does n m5tion any contemporane\s writ+s1 we w surely be able to detect indirect ref]5ces to ,old & ,new ,te/am5ts4 ,b :at w be ( mo/ vital int]e/ w be 8 anticipations ( ,nic5e =mulations1 or reflection ( curr5t expressions ( ,*ri/ian philosophic comm5t4 ,:ile we _c positively ass]t ?is ,*ri/ian developm5t 0 exclusively ,plot9ian1 we are ju/ifi$ 9 say+ t ! developm5t ( ,*ri/ian philosophy 0 n due exclusively to ! ,alex&rian cate*etical s*ool2 t :at lat] appe>s z ,*ri/ian !ology 0 only e>li] curr5t ,neoplatonic metaphysics1 )\t any exclusive dogmatic connection ) ! di/9ctively ,*ri/ian biography4 ,?is avoids ! flat ass]tion ( ,drews t ! ,*ri/ian doctr9e ( ! ,tr9ity 0 dep5d5t on ,plot9os1 al?\gh x admits ,b\illet's m cauti\s /atem5t t ,plot9os 0 ! rationaliz] ( ! doctr9e ( ! ,tr9ity4#eji ,?is mu* is c]ta91 t no o!r contemporane\s discussion ( ! tr9ity has surviv$1 if any ev] exi/$2 & we mu/ rememb] t x 0 n until ! c\ncil ( ,con/ant9ople 9 ,a4,d4 #cha1 t ! ,nic5e ,cre$1 by ! addition ( ! ,filioque clause1 became tr9it>ian 9 a ?or\ghgo+ way2 & n until fifty ye>s lat] t ,augu/9e1 aga9 9 ! ,we/1 fully express$ a philosophy & psy*ology ( ! tr9ity4 ,to ,plot9os !re=e is due ! hi/orical position ( protagoni/ ( tr9it>ian philosophy4 ,,non-,,*ri/ian ,,orig9 ,,( ,,p>alellisms ,,to ,,*ri/ianity4 ,*ri/ian p>allelisms 9 ,plot9os h a hi/orical orig9 9 ,*ri/ian p>allelisms 9 8 s\rces1 namely1 ,/oicism1 ,num5ius & ,plato4 ,to ,*ri/ian orig9s 9 ,plato nev] has ju/ice be5 done1 n ev5 by ,bigg4 ,8 sugge/ion ( ! crucifixion ( ! j man1 8 ref]5ce to ! son ( ,god are only common-places1 to :i* %\ld be add$ _m m9or ref]5ces4 ,! ,*ri/ian orig9s 9 ,num5ius are q explicit2 m5tion ( ! ,hebrews z among ! races ^: scriptures are important1 ( ,moses among ! great religi\s tea*]s1 ( ! ,_s hov]+ ov] ! wat]s1 ( ! names ( ! ,egyptian magicians :i*1 toge!r ) ,pl9y1 he h&s d[n to po/]ity4 ,he also 0 said to h told _m /ories ab\t ,jesus1 9 an allegorical mann]4 ,! ,*ri/ian orig9s 9 ,/oicism h be5 widely discuss$2 = in/ance1 by ,*aignet4 ,b x is likely t ?is influ5ce affect$ ,*ri/ianity indirectly ?r\gh ,plot9os1 along ) ! o!r ,*ri/ian ideas we %all lat] f9d4 ,at any rate ,plot9os is ! philosoph] :o uses ! t]m spiritual body mo/ l ! ,*ri/ians4#eaj ,! s\l is a slave to ! body1#eaa & has a cele/ial body#eab z well z a spiritual body4#eac ,)9 u are two m5 oppos+ ea* o!r1#ead ! bett] "p (t5 be+ ma/]$ by ! worse "p1 z ?\ght ,/4 ,paul1#eae 9 ! /ruggle betwe5 ! inn] & out] man4#eaf ,) ,plot9os ! idea ( procession is n only cosmic b psy*ological4 ,9 o!r words1 :5 ,plot9os speaks ( ! procession ( ! ,god-head1 he is n1 z 9 ,*ri/ian doctr9e1 depict+ some?+ unique1 :i* has no connection ) ! _w4 ,he is only ref]r+ to ! cosmic aspect ( an evolution :i*1 9 ! s\l1 appe>s z educational developm5t4#eag ,z ! opposite ( ! s\l's procession upw>ds1 !re is ! s\l's desc5t into hell1#eah or1 9 o!r words1 ! s\l's desc5t & asc5sion4#eai ,?is d\ble aspect ( man's fate upw>d or d[nw>d is ref]r$ to by ,plot9os 9 ! regul> ,*ri/ian t]m s91 z consi/+ 9 miss+ "o's aim4#ebj ,! s\l rep5ts1#eba & its duty is conv]sion4#ebb ,z a result ( ?is conv]sion comes =giv5ess4#ebc ,,old ,,te/am5t ,,ref]5ces4 ,! fam\s t]rors ( ,j]emiah#ebd might h come m$iately ?r\gh ! ,gno/ics1 :o inde$ may h be5 ! p]sons ref]r$ to z ,*ri/ians4#ebe ,m direct no d\bt 0 ,god admir+ 8 h&iwork#ebf & ! s\l brea?+ ! _s ( life into animals4#ebg ,god is call$ bo? ! ,i am :at ,i am#ebh & ,he is :at ,he ought to be4#ebh ,he sits above ! _w1#ebi z ! k+ ( k+s4#ecj ,,new ,,te/am5t ,,ref]5ces4 ,plot9os says t x w\ld be a poor arti/ :o w\ld conceive ( an animal z all cov]$ ) eyes4 ,!re is h>dly su* a ref]5ce outside ( ,revelations1#eca to :i* we mu/ also look = a new heav5 & a new e>?4#ecb ,!n we h practically a quotation ( ! ,johann9e prologue ,9 ! beg9n+ 0 ! ,logos1 & by him 7 all ?+s made4#ecc ,light 0 9 ! beg9n+4#ecd ,we are told n to leave ! _w1 b n to be ( x4#ece ,! div9ity prep>es mansions 9 heav5 = good s\ls4#ecf ,paul9e ref]5ces seem to be t s9 exi/s because ( ! law4#ecg ,god is above all height or dep?4#ech ,! vulg> :o att5d my/]y-banquets only to gorge are condemn$4#eci ,!re are sev]al heav5s4#edj ,! begg>ly pr9ciples & elem5ts t[>ds :i* "s turn1 are m5tion$4#eda ,! g5ealogies ( ! ,gno/ics are held up to ridicule4#edb ,g5]al ref]5ces are num]\s4 ,diseases are caus$ by evil spirits4#edc ,we mu/ cut (f any (f5d+ memb]4#edd ,?us we are sav$4#ede ,9 him we brea! & move & h our be+4#edf ,! high] div9ity begets a ,son1 "o among _m bre?r54#edg ,z ! fa!r ( intellig5ce1 ,god is ! fa!r ( lights4#edh ,h[ev]1 ! mo/ int]e/+ incid5t is t scriptural text :i*1 to ! reflect+1 is always s mu* ( a puzzle3 ,if ! light t is 9 !m be d>kness1 etc4#edi ,?is is expla9$ by ! ,platonic !ory#eej t we see because ( a special light t is )9 ! eye4 ,,!ological ,,ref]5ces4 ,g5]al !ological ref]5ces may be gr\p$ "u ?ree heads3 ! s\l's salvation1 ! procession ( ! div9ity1 & ! tr9ity4 ,z to ! s\l's salvation1 ,god is ! opposite ( ! evil ( be+s1#eea :i*1 :5 creat$ 9 honor ( ! div9ity#eeb is ! image ( ! ,^w1 ! int]pret] ( ! ,"o1#eec & is compos$ ( sev]al elem5ts2#eed b x is a fall f ,god1#eee & its fate is connect$ ) ! p>\sia4#eef ,?is go+ =? ( ! s\l f ,god1 :5 consid]$ cosmically1 becomes ! procession ( ! s\l4#eeg ,?is is ! et]nal g5]ation1#eeh :]eby ! ,son is begott5 f et]nity1#eei s t !re c\ld be no 7,arian7 n hote ouk n1 or1 "t :5 he 0 n4#efj ,?is is express$ z light ( light1#efa & expla9$ by ! ,a?anasian light & ray simile4#efb ,we f9d ev5 ! ,johann9e & ,philonic di/9ction betwe5 ,god & ! ,good4#efc ,! _w is ! fir/-begott51#efd & ! ,intellig5ce is ! logos ( ! fir/ ,god1#efe z ! hypo/asis ( wisdom is ousia1 or be+1#eff & x is ! univ]sal reason4#efg ,z to ! tr9ity1 ,plot9os is ! fir/ & *ief rationaliz] ( ! cosmic tr9ity1 :i* he cont9u\sly & at l5g? discusses4#efh ,god is fa!r & son1#efi & !y are homo\sian1 or consub/antial4#egj ,! human s\l 7z image ( ! cosmic div9ity71 is "o nature 9 ?ree p[]s4#ega ,else:]e we h discuss$ ! hi/ory ( ! t]m p]sons1 b we may und]/& ! result ( t process be/ by ,plot9os's simile ( ! tr9ity z "o head ) ?ree faces1#egb 9 :i* ! p]sons be> out _! orig9al mean+ ( masks1 p]son>e4 ,h5ce=w>d ! tr9ity 0 an objective idea4 ,,note ,al?\gh m5tion$ above1 special att5tion %\ld be giv5 to ! p>able ( ! v9e & ! bran*es 7iii4 #c4g4--dh1 #ajhh ) ,jno4 xv4 #a-h71 & ! div9ity's begett+ a ,son 7v4 #h4ab--ca1 #ega74 ,! significant aspect ( ?is is t x is repres5t$ z be+ ! cont5t ( ! supreme ec/atic vision2 :at y might call ! cr[n ( ,plot9os' message4 ,he tells u t he has se5 ! div9ity beget an (fspr+ ( an incomp>able beauty1 produc+ ev]y?+ 9 ,himself1 & )\t pa9 pres]v+ )9 ,himself :at ,he has begott54444 ,8 ,son has manife/$ ,himself ext]nally4 ,by ,him1 z by an image 7,col4 i4 #ae71 y may judge ( ! greatness ( ,8 ,fa!r 444 enjoy+ ! privilege ( be+ ! image ( ,8 et]nity4 ,,vii4 ,,plot9os',s ,,indebt$ness ,,to ,,num5ius4 #a4 ,,hi/orical ,,relations ,,betwe5 ,,num5ius ,,& ,,plot9os4 ,we h1 else:]e1 po9t$ out ! hi/oric connections betwe5 ,num5ius & ,plot9os4 ,"h1 x may be suffici5t to recall t ,amelius1 native ( ,num5ius's home-t[n ( ,apamea1 & :o _h copi$ & le>n$ by he>t all ! works ( ,num5ius1 & :o lat] return$ to ,apamea to sp5d 8 decl9+ days1 bequea?+ 8 copy ( ,num5ius's works to 8 adopt$ son ,g5tilianus ,hesy*ius1 0 ! companion & fri5d ( ,plot9os dur+ 8 e>lie/ p]iod1 edit+ all ,plot9os's books1 until displac$ by ,porphyry4 ,we rememb] also t ,porphyry 0 ,amelius's disciple1 be=e 8 spectacul> qu>rel ) ,amelius1 lat] supplant+ him z editor ( ! works ( ,plot9os4 ,plot9os also came f ,alex&ria1 :]e ,num5ius _h be5 c>efully /udi$ & quot$ by ,orig5 & ,clem5t ( ,alex&ria4 ,fur!r1 ,porphyry records twice t accusations 7 popul>ly made aga9/ ,plot9os1 t he _h plagi>iz$ f ,num5ius4 ,9 view ( all ?is hi/orical backgr\nd1 we h ! prima-facie "r to consid] ,plot9os *iefly z a lat] re-/at] ( ! views ( ,num5ius1 at lea/ dur+ 8 e>li] or ,amelian p]iod4 ,su* a conception ( ! /ate ( affairs mu/ h be5 9 ! m9d ( t monk :o1 9 ! ,escoreal manuscript1 sub/itut$ ! "n ( ,num5ius = t ( ,plot9os on t fragm5t#egc ab\t matt]1 :i* beg9s directly ) ,num5ius's "n ( ! div9ity1 be+ & ess5ce4#egd #b4 ,,num5ius ,,z ,,fa!r ,,( ,,neo-,,platonism4 ,let u comp>e ) ?is hi/orical evid5ce1 t :i* supports ! univ]sally admitt$ dep5d5ce ( ,plot9os on 8 tea*] ,ammonius4 ,we h only two witnesses3 ,hi]ocles & ,nemesius2 & ! latt] attributes ! argum5t = ! immat]iality ( ! s\l to ,ammonius & ,num5ius jo9tly4 ,no d\bt1 ,ammonius may h taught ,plot9os 9 8 y\?2 b s no d\bt did o!r tea*]s2 & ( ,ammonius ! only survivals are a few pages pres]v$ by ,nemesius4 ,! te/imony = ,plot9os's dep5d5ce on ,num5ius is !re=e mu* m hi/orical1 z well z significant1 9 view ( ,num5ius hav+ left writt5 records t 7 widely quot$4 ,! title ( ,fa!r ( ,neo-platonism1 !re=e1 if x mu/ at all be aw>d$1 %\ld g to ,num5ius1 :o _h writt5 a ,hi/ory ( ! ,platonic ,succession1 :]e9 he attempts to re/ore orig9al ,platonism4 ,?is fits ! title ,neo-platonism1 :]eas ! philosophy ( ,ammonius1 w\ld be bett] describ$ z an eclectic syn!sis ( ,platonism & ,ari/otelianism4 #c4 ,,contra/ ,,betwe5 ,,!m4 ,( c\rse we %all admit t !re are diff]5ces betwe5 ,plot9os & ,num5ius1 at lea/ dur+ 8 ,porphyrian p]iod2 ?is 0 inevitable :ile dismiss+ 8 ,num5ian secret>y ,amelius1#ege a fri5d :o _h become imbu$ ) su* doctr9es be=e becom+ ! fri5d ( ,plot9os1 :o p]sev]$ 9 !m1 & wrote 9 ju/ification !re(4 ,we f9d t ! book *ronologically prec$+ ?is "o is v4 #e1 on ! v subject at issue betwe5 ,amelius & ,porphyry4 ,plot9os took 8 /& ) ! latt]1 & !re=e aga9/ ! =m]1 & ?r\gh him1 aga9/ ,num5ius2 & inde$ we f9d him oppos+ sev]al ,gno/ic op9ions :i* c be sub/antiat$ 9 ,num5ius3 ! creation by illum9ation or emanation1#egf ! ?reefoldness ( ! creator1#egg & ! pilot's =gett+ himself 9 8 "w4#egh ,b1 aft] all1 ^! po9ts are n z important z !y might seem2 = 9 a v little :ile we f9d ,plot9os himself admitt+ ! sub/ance ( all ( ^! ideas1 except ! v]biage2 he himself uses ! light & ray simile1 ! light ( light2#egi he himself di/+ui%es v>i\s phases ( ! alleg$ly s+le intellig5ce1#ehj & ! s\l1 z pilot ( ! body inc>nates by ! v =getfulness by :i* ! creator creat$4#eha ,fur!r1 z we %all %[1 dur+ 8 la/ or ,eu/o*ian p]iod aft] ,porphyry _h tak5 a trip to ,sicily to avoid suicide1 he himself 0 to return to ,num5ian /&po9ts4 ,?is may be %[n 9 a g5]al way z foll[s4 ,( ! n9e ,eu/o*ian essays#ehb only two#ehc betray no simil>ities to ,num5ian ideas1 :ile sev5#ehd d4 ,on ! contr>y1 9 ! ,amelio-,porphyrian p]iod1#ehe writt5 imm$iately on ,amelius's dismissal1 only six#ehf are ,num5ian1 & six#ehg are non-,num5ian4 ,9 ! succe$+ :olly ,porphyrian p]iod1#ehh we h ! same equal numb] ( ,num5ian#ehi & non-,num5ian#eij books4 ,an explanation ( ?is rev]sion to ,num5ian ideas has be5 attempt$ 9 ! /udy ( ! developm5t 9 ,plot9os's views4 ,on ! :ole1 !re=e1 ,plot9os's opposition to ,num5ius may be consid]$ no m ?an episodic4 #d4 ,,direct ,,indebt$ness ,,( ,,plot9os ,,to ,,num5ius4 ,z ,plot9os 0 9 ! habit ( n ev5 putt+ 8 "n to 8 own notes2 z ev5 9 ! times ( ,porphyry ! actual au?or%ip ( mu* t he wrote 0 already disput$2 z ev5 ,porphyry ackn[l$ges pr9ciples & quotations 7 borr[$1 we mu/ discov] ,num5ian passages by _! cont5t1 r ?an by any ext]nal indications4 ,z ! great majority ( ,num5ius's works are irretrievably lo/1 we may nev] hope to arrive at a f9al solution ( ! matt]2 & we %all h to re/rict ourselves to t :i*1 9 ,plot9os1 may be id5tifi$ by :at ,num5ian fragm5ts rema94 ,:at little we c ?us trace def9itely w give u a "r to draw ! conclusion to mu* m1 & to ! op9ion t1 especially 9 8 ,amelian p]iod1 ,plot9os 0 *iefly indebt$ to ,num5ian inspiration4 ,we c consid]#eia ! m5tion ( ,py?agoreans :o _h treat$ ( ! intelligible z apply+ to ,num5ius1 ^: *ief "w 0 ,on ! ,good1 & on ! ,immat]iality ( ! ,s\l4 ,! fir/ class ( passages w be su* z be> explicit ref]5ce to quotation f an anci5t s\rce4 ,( su* we h five3 ,t is :y ! ,py?agoreans 71 among ea* o!r1 accu/om$ to ref] to ?is pr9ciple 9 a symbolic mann]1 call+ him ',a-pollo1' :i* "n means a d5ial ( manifoldness4#eib ,t is ! reason ( ! say+1 ',! ideas & numb]s are born f ! indef9ite d\bl5ess1 & ! ,"o2' = ?is is intellig5ce4#eic ,t is :y ! anci5ts said t ideas are ess5ces & be+s4#eid ,let u exam9e ! 7g5]al7 view t evils _c be de/roy$1 b are necess>y4#eie ,! ,div9ity is above be+4#eif ,a six? case is1 ,h[ manifoldness is d]iv$ f ! ,fir/4#eig ,a sev5? case is ! :ole passage on ! triunity ( ! div9ity1 includ+ ! t]m ,fa!r4#eih ,among doctr9es said to be h&$ d[n f ! anci5t philosoph]s#eii are ! asc5ts & desc5ts ( s\ls#fjj & ! migrations ( s\ls into bodies o!r ?an human4#fja ,! s\l is a numb]4#fjb ,moreov]1 ,plot9os wrote a book on ! ,incorruptibility ( ! s\l1#fjc z ,num5ius _h done2#fjd & bo? au?ors discuss ! incorporeity ( qualities4#fje ,besides ^! passages :]e !re is a def9ite expression ( dep5d5ce on e>li] s\rces1 !re are two 9 :i* ! v]bal simil>ity#fjf is /rik+ en\gh to ju/ify _! be+ consid]$ ref]5ces3 ,besides1 no body c\ld subsi/ )\t ! p[] ( ! univ]sal ,s\l4 ,because bodies1 accord+ to _! own nature1 are *angeable1 incon/ant1 & inf9itely divisible1 & no?+ un*angeable rema9s 9 !m1 !re is evid5tly ne$ ( a pr9ciple t w\ld lead !m1 ga!r !m1 & b9d !m fa/ toge!r2 & ?is we "n s\l4#fjg ,?is simil>ity is s /rik+ t x _h already be5 obs]v$ & not$ by ,b\illet4 ,comp>e ,we consid] t all ?+s call$ ess5ces are composite1 & t n a s+le "o ( !m is simple1 ) ,num5ius1 :o believes t ev]y?+ is ?or\ghly m+l$ toge!r1 & t no?+ is simple4#fjh #e4 ,,unc]ta9 ,,indebt$ness ,,( ,,plot9os4 ,z ,plot9os does n give exact quotations & ref]5ces1 x is difficult always to give _! und\bt$ s\rce4 ,z probably ,platonic we may m5tion ! passage ab\t ! univ]sal ,s\l tak+ c>e ( all t is inanimate2#fji & ,:5 "o has arriv$ at individuals1 !y mu/ be ab&on$ to inf9ity4#faj ,also o!r quotations4#faa ,! l9e ,x might be said t virtues are actualizations1#fab might be ,ari/otelian4 ,we also f9d3#fac ,?us1 accord+ to ! anci5t maxim1 ',c\rage1 temp]ance1 all ! virtues1 ev5 prud5ce1 are b purifications4' ,t is ! reason t x is "r to say t ! 's\l's welf>e & beauty lie 9 assimilat+ h]self to ! div9ity4' ,?is s\nds ,platonic1 b might be ,num5ian4 ,9 ?is connection x might n be un9t]e/+ to note passages 9 ,num5ius :i* are attribut$ to ,plato1 b :i* are n to be id5tifi$3 ,o ,m51 ! ,m9d :i* y dimly p]ceive is n ! ,fir/ ,m9d2 b be=e ?is ,m9d is ano!r "o1 :i* is old] & div9]4 ,t ! ,good is ,"o4#fad ,we turn n[ to ?\ghts f\nd id5tically 9 ,plot9os & ,num5ius1 al?\gh no textual id5tity is to be not$4 ,we may gr\p ^! accord+ to ! subject1 ! univ]se1 & ! s\l4 #f4 ,,p>ticul> ,,simil>ities4 ,god is supreme k+4#fae ,et]nity is n[1 b nei!r pa/ nor future4#faf ,! ,k+ 9 heav5 is surr\nd$ by leisure4#fag ,! ,good is above ,be+2#fah ! div9ity is ! unity above ! ,be+ & ,ess5ce2#fai & connect$ ) ?is is ! unit>y int]pretation ( ! "n ,a-pollo1#fbj foll[+ 9 ! foot/eps ( ,plut>*4 ,nev]!less1 ! inf]ior div9ity trav]ses ! heav5s1#fba 9 a circul> motion4#fbb ,:ile ,num5ius does n specify ?is motion z circul>1#fbc x is impli$1 inasmu* z ! creator's pass+ ?r\gh ! heav5s mu/ h foll[$ _! circul> c\rse4 ,) ?is p]fect motion is connect$ ! peculi> ,num5ian doctr9e ( inexhau/ible giv+1#fbd :i* gave a philosophical basis = ! old simile ( radiation ( light1#fbe s t irradiation is ! me?od ( creation1#fbf & ?is is n f> remov$ f emanationism4 ,?is process consi/s ( ! desc5t ( ! intelligible into ! mat]ial1 or1 z ,num5ius puts x1 t bo? ! intelligible & ! p]ceptible p>ticipate 9 ! ideas4#fbg ,?us intellig5ce is ! unit+ pr9ciple t holds toge!r ! bodies ^: t5d5cy is to split up1 & scatt]1#fbh mak+ a leakage or wa/e1#fbi :i* process invades ev5 ! div9ity4#fcj ,?is unit+ ( scatt]+ elem5ts produces a mixture or m+l+1#fjh ( matt] & reason1#fca :i*1 h[ev]1 is limit$ to ! en]gies ( ! exi/5t1 n to ! exi/5t itself4#fcb ,all ?+s are 9 a fl[1#fcc & ! :ole all is 9 all4#fcd ,! div9ity creates by glanc+ at ! intellig5ce above1#fce z a pilot4#fcf ,! div9ity is split by ov]-att5tion to its *>ges4#fcg ,?is leads u ov] to consid]ation ( ! s\l4 ,! *ief ef=t ( ,num5ius is a polemic aga9/ ! mat]ialism ( ! ,/oics1 & to x ,plot9os devotes a :ole book4#fch ,all s\ls1 ev5 ! l[e/1 are immortal4#fci ,ev5 qualities are incorporeal4#fdj ,! s\l1 !re=e1 rema9s incorporeal4#fda ,! s\l1 h[ev]1 is divisible4#fdb ,?is expla9s ! report t ,num5ius taught n v>i\s p>ts ( ! s\l1#fdc b two s\ls1 :i* w\ld be oppos$ by ,plot9os 9 8 polemic aga9/ ! ,/oics1#fdd b taught 9 ano!r place4#fde ,su* divisibility is inde$ impli$ 9 ! =mation ( pres5tation z a by-product1#fdf or a common "p4#fdg ,moreov]1 ! s\l has to *oose its own demon1 or gu>dian div9ity4#fdh ,salvation z a goal appe>s 9 ,num5ius1#fdi b n 9 ,plot9os1 :o opposes ! ,gno/ic idea ( ! sav$ s\ls1#fej ?\gh else:]e he speaks ( ! pa?s ( ! musician1#fea lov]#feb & philosoph]#fec 9 rea*+ ec/asy4#fed ,/ill bo? ,gno/ics & ,plot9os insi/$ on ! ne$ ( a savior4#fee ,memory is actualization ( ! s\l4#fef ,9 ! highe/ ec/asy ! s\l is alone ) ! alone4#feg #g4 ,,simil>ities ,,appli$ ,,diff]5tly4 ,?is comp>ison ( philosophy w\ld h be5 mu* /rong] _h we add$ !reto ! foll[+ po9ts 9 :i* we f9d simil> t]ms & ideas1 b :i* are appli$ diff]5tly4 ,! s\l is indissolubly unit$ to intellig5ce accord+ to ,plot9os1 b to its s\rce ) ,num5ius4#feh ,plot9os makes discord ! result ( _! fall1 :ile ) ,num5ius x is its cause4#fei ,guilt is ! cause ( ! fall ( s\ls1 ) ,plot9os1#ffj b ) ,num5ius x is impulsive passion4 ,! great evolution or _w-process is by ,plot9os call$ ! et]nal procession1 :ile ) ,num5ius x is progress4#ffa ,! simile ( ! pilot is by ,plot9os appli$ to ! s\l )9 ! body2 :ile ) ,num5ius1 x ref]s to ! logos1 or creator 9 ! univ]se1#ffb :ile 9 bo? cases ! cause1--( creation = ! creator1#ffc & inc>nation = ! s\l#ffd--;is =getfulness4 ,!re is practically no diff]5ce "h1 h[ev]4 ,d\bl5ess is1 by ,plot9os1 pr$icat$ ( ! sun & />s1 b by ,num5ius1 ( ! demiurge himself1#ffe :i* ,plot9os opposes z a ,gno/ic tea*+4#fff ,! ,philonic t]m legislator is1 by ,plot9os1 appli$ to intellig5ce1 :ile ,num5ius applies x to ! ?ird div9ity1 & n ! second4#ffg ,plot9os ext5ds immortality to animals1 b ,num5ius ev5 to ! inorganic realm1 includ+ ev]y?+4#ffh ,:ile ,num5ius seems to believe 9 ! ,s]api/ic & ,gno/ic demons1#ffi ,plot9os opposes !m1#fgj al?\gh 9 8 biography#fga he is repres5t$ z tak+ "p 9 ! evocation ( 8 gu>dian _s 9 a temple ( ,isis4 ,we ?us f9d a tol]ably complete body ( philosophy %>$ by ,plot9os & ,num5ius1 out ( ! few fragm5ts ( ! latt] t h come d[n to u4 ,x w\ld !re=e be reasonable to suppose t if ,num5ius's complete works _h surviv$ we c\ld make out a /ill f> /rong] case = ,plot9os's dep5d5ce on ,num5ius4 ,at any rate1 ! ,dom9ican scribe at ! ,escoreal :o ins]t$ ! "n ( ,num5ius 9 ! place ( t ( ,plot9os 9 ! head+ (#fgb ! fragm5t ab\t matt]1 mu/ h felt a /rong confusion betwe5 ! two au?ors4 #h4 ,,philosophical ,,relations ,,betwe5 ,,num5ius ,,& ,,plot9os4 ,to beg9 )1 we h ! controv]sy ) ! ,/oics1 :i*1 ?\gh x appe>s 9 ! works ( bo?1 be>s 9 ea* a diff]5t significance4 ,:ile ) ,num5ius x absorb$ 8 *ief controv]sial ef=ts1#fgc ) ,plot9os#fgd x occupi$ only "o ( 8 _m sph]es ( int]e/2 & inde$1 he _h borr[$ f !m _m t]ms1 su* z pneuma1 ! spiritual body1 & o!rs1 set =? else:]e4 ,notable1 h[ev]1 0 ! t]m hexis1 habituation1 or =m ( inorganic objects1#fge & ! phantasia1 or s5se-pres5tation4#fgf ,l1 !m1 ! "n ,a-pollo is int]pret$ z a d5ial ( manifoldness4#fgg ,next 9 importance1 z a l&m>k1 is ,num5ius's *ief secret1 ! "n ( ! div9ity1 z be+ & ess5ce1 :i* reappe>s 9 ,plot9os 9 numb]less places4#fgh ,connect$ ) ?is is ! idea t ess5ce is intellig5ce4#fgi #i4 ,,py?agorean ,,simil>ities4 ,x is a common-place t ,num5ius 0 a ,py?agorean1 or at lea/ 0 kn[n z su*1 = ?\gh he rev]5c$ ,py?agoras1 he conceiv$ ( himself z a re/or] ( true ,platonism4 ,x w1 !re=e1 be all ! m int]e/+ to obs]ve :at "p numb]s play 9 _! sy/em1 especially 9 t ( ,plot9os1 :o made no special claim to be a ,py?agorean disciple4 ,fir/1 we f9d t numb]s & ! div9e ideas are closely relat$4#fhj ,numb]s actually split ! unity ( ! div9ity4#fha ,! s\l also is consid]$ z a numb]1#fhb & 9 connection ) ?is we f9d ! ,py?agorean sacr$ tetraktys4#fhc ,?us numb]s split up ! div9ity1#fhd ?\gh x is no m ?an fair to add t else:]e ,plot9os contradicts ?is1 & /ates t ! multiplicity ( ! div9ity is n atta9$ by division2#fhe /ill1 ?is is n ! only case 9 :i* we w be =c$ to array ,plot9os aga9/ himself4 ,! fir/ effect ( ! splitt+ influ5ce ( numb]s w be d\bl5ess1#fhf :i*1 ?\gh pres5t 9 intellig5ce1#fhg nev]!less *iefly appe>s 9 matt]1#fhh z ! ,py?agorean indef9ite dyad4#fhi ,/ill1 ev5 ! ,supreme is d\ble4#fij ,s we mu/ n be surpris$ if ,he is con/itut$ by a tr9ity1#fia 9 connection ) :i* ! ,supreme appe>s z gr&fa!r4#fib ,if !n bo? ,num5ius & ,plot9os are really "u ! spell ( ,py?agoras1 x is pretty sure !y w n be mat]iali/1 !y w believe 9 ! incorporeality ( ! div9ity1#fic ( qualities2#fid & ( ! s\l#fie :i* w be invisible#fif & possess no ext5sion4#fig ,a result ( ?is w be t ! s\l w n be locat$ 9 ! body1 or 9 space1 b r ! body 9 ! s\l4#fih ,f ?is incorporeal exi/5ce1#fii !re is only a %ort /ep to un*angeable exi/5ce1#gjj or et]nity4#gja ,?is1 to ! s\l1 means immortality1#gjb "o !ory ( :i* is re9c>nation4#gjc ,to ! univ]se1 h[ev]1 ?is means h>mony4#gjd ,!re are /ill o!r ,py?agorean traces 9 common betwe5 ,num5ius & ,plot9os4 ,! cause t ! indet]m9ate dyad split (f f ! div9ity is tolma1 ra%ness1 or boldness4#gje ,ev]y?+ outside ( ! div9ity is 9 a cont9ual /ate ( flux4#gjf ,evil is !n t :i* is oppos$ to good4#gjg ,x also is !re=e unavoidable1 inasmu* z suppression ( its cosmic function w\ld entail cosmic collapse4#gjh ,! _w /&s ?us z an insep>able comb9ation ( intellig5ce & necessity1 or *ance4#gji #aj4 ,,platonic ,,traces4 ,platonic traces1 !re w\ld naturally be2 b x w be notic$ t !y are f> less num]\s ?an ! ,py?agorean4 ,to beg9 )1 we f9d ! rev]5t _s t[>ds ! div9ities1 :i* prays = _! bless+ at ! inception ( all tasks4#gaj ,to u :o live 9 ^! latt] days1 su* a pray] seems out ( place 9 philosophy2 b t is only because we h divorc$ philosophy f !ology2 9 o!r words1 because our !ology has left ! realm ( liv+ ?\ght1 &1 be+ fix$ once = all1 we are all[$ to pursue any !ory ( exi/5ce we please z if x _h no?+ :atev] to d ) any reality2 9 o!r words1 we are deceiv+ ourselves4 ,on ! contr>y1 9 ^? days1 e philosophical speculation 0 a g5u9e adv5ture 9 ! spiritual _w1 a magical op]ation t might unexpect$ly lead to ! ?re%old ( ! cosmic sanctu>y4 ,wise1 inde$1 !re=e1 0 he :o began x by pray]4 ,( o!r te*nical ,platonic t]ms !re are q a few4 ,! l[] is always ! image ( ! high]4#gaa ,s ! _w might be consid]$ ! /atue ( ! ,div9ity4#gab ,! ideas are 9 a realm above ! _w4#gac ,! s\l "h bel[ is z 9 a prison4#gad ,!re is a div9ity high] ?an ! "o g5]ally kn[n4#gae ,! div9ity is 9 a /ability resultant ( firmness & p]fect motion4#gaf ,! p]fect movem5t1 !re=e1 is circul>4#gag ,?is int]-communion ( ! univ]se !re=e results 9 matt] appe>+ 9 ! intelligible _w z intelligible matt]4#gah ,by dialectics1 also call$ ba/>d reason+1#gai we ab/ract ev]y?+#gbj till we rea* ! ?+-9-itself1#gba or1 9 o!r words1 matt] z a sub/rate ( ! _w4#gbb ,?us we metaphysically rea* ineffable solitude4#gbc ,! same goal is rea*$ psy*ologically1 h[ev]1 9 ! ec/asy4#gbd ,?is idea occurr$ 9 ,plato only z a poetic expression ( metaphysical atta9m5t2 & 9 ! case ( ,plot9os at lea/ may h be5 us$ z a practical exp]i5ce *iefly to expla9 8 epileptic attacks2 & ?is w\ld be all ! m likely z ?is disease 0 g5]ally call$ ! sacr$ disease4 ,:e!r ,num5ius also 0 an epileptic1 we are n told2 x is m likely he took ! idea f ,philo1 or ,philo's ori5tal s\rces2 at lea/ ,num5ius seems to claim no p]sonal ec/atic exp]i5ces su* z ^? ( ,plot9os4 ,we h ent]$ ! realm ( psy*ology2 & ?is tea*es u t t 9 :i* ,num5ius & ,plot9os diff] f ,plato & ,philo is *iefly _! psy*ological or exp]im5tal application ( pure philosophy4 ,no body c\ld subsi/ )\t ! s\l to keep x toge!r4#gbe ,v>i\s attempts are made to describe ! nature ( ! s\l2 x is ! ext5t or relation ( circumf]5ce to circle4#gbf ,or x is l a l9e & its div]g5ce4#gbg ,9 any case1 ! div9ity & ! s\l move ar\nd ! heav5s1#gbh & ?is may expla9 ! o!rwise problematical progress or evolution 7prosodos or /olos7 ( ours4#gbi #aa4 ,,v>i\s ,,simil>ities4 ,!re are _m o!r unclassifiable ,num5ian traces 9 ,plot9os4 ,two ( !m1 h[ev]1 are comp>atively important4 ,fir/1 is a reaffirmation ( ! anci5t ,greek connection betwe5 g5]ation1 f]tility ( bir? ( s\ls & wetness1#gcj :i* is lat] reaffirm$ by ,porphyry 9 8 ,cave ( ! ,nymphs4 ,plot9os1 h[ev]1 lat] d5ies ?is4#gca ,!n we come to a g5u9e innovation ( ,num5ius's2 8 !ory ( div9e or intelligible giv+4 ,plato _h1 ( c\rse1 9 8 g5ial1 casual way1 sket*$ out a :ole organic sy/em ( div9e creation & adm9i/ration ( ?is _w4 ,! conceptions he ne$$ he _h *e]fully borr[$ f e>li] ,greek philosophy )\t any rigid sy/ematization1 s t he nev] notic$ t ! h+e on :i* all 0 suppos$ to turn 0 m]ely ! make%ift ( an assumption4 ,?is capital error 0 notic$ by ,num5ius1 :o s\ght to supply x by a psy*ological obs]vation1 namely1 t k may be imp>t$ )\t dim9ution4 ,plot9os1 ) 8 w9n+ way ( disp5s+ ) quotation-m>ks1 appropriat$ ?is1#gcb z also ! idea t life /reams out ^u ! _w 9 ! glance ( ! div9ity1 & z quickly leaves x1 :5 ! ,div9ity turns away ,8 glance4#gcc ,o!r less important po9ts ( contact are3 ! ,egyptian %ip ( s\ls2#gcd ! ,philonic di/9ction betwe5 ! ,god z supreme1 & god z subord9ate2#gce ! ho>y equivocation on kosmos2#gcf & ! illu/ration ( ! div9e ,logos z ! pilot ( ! _w4#gcg ,,value ,,( ,,plot9os4 ,,importance ,,9 ,,! ,,pa/4 ,we mu/ focus our obs]vations on ,plot9os z a philosoph]4 ,to beg9 )1 we %\ld review 8 successors1 ,porphyry1 ,jambli*us1 ,sallu/1 ,proclus1 ,hi]ocles1 ,simplicius2#gch ,macrobius2#gci ,priscus2 ,olympicdorus & ,john ,philoponus4#gdj ,among ! ,arabian philosoph]s t foll[ 9 8 /eps are ,maimonides & ,ibn ,gebirol4#gda ,( ! ,*ri/ian fa!rs we fir/ h two :o p>aphras$1 r ?an quot$ him4 ,/4 ,augu/9e by "n quotes i4 #f2 iii4 #b2 iv4 #c1 & v4 #a2 he p>aphrases p>ts ( i4 #b2 ii4 #a2 iii4 #f1 #g2 iv4 #b1 #g2 vi4 #e1 #f4gdb ,/4 ,basil s closely p>aphrases p>ts ( ,plot9os 9 8 treatise on ! ,holy ,_s1#gdc 8 lett] on ! ,mona/ic ,life1#gdd & 8 ,hexam]on1#gde t ,b\illet pr9ts ! passage 9 "q 9 deadly p>allel4 ,o!r ,*ri/ian ,plotonic /ud5ts 7 ,gregory ( ,nyssa1 ,synesius1 ,dionysius ! ,areopagite1 ,!odorus1 ,a5eas ( ,gaza1 ,g5nadius2#gdf ,victor9us2#gdg ,nicephorus ,*umnus2#gdh & ,cassiodorus4#gdi ,?omas ,aqu9as also 0 mu* indebt$ to ,plot9os2 & aft] him came ,boe?ius1 ,fnlon1 ,bossnet & ,leibnitz 7all quot$ 9 ,b\illet's "w74 ,we h frequ5tly po9t$ out t ,plot9os' ba/>d reason+ process ( rea*+ ! intelligible 0 practically p>aphras$ by ,kant's dialectical pa? to ! ?+-9-itself4 ,?is dialetic1 ( c\rse1 0 capitaliz$ by ,hegel4 ,drews has %[n t ,ed\>d von ,h>tmann us$ ,plot9os' semi-devotional ec/asy z a metaphysical basis = 8 philosophy ( ! ,unconsci\s4 ,x is1 ( c\rse1 among my/ics t ,plot9os has be5 accord$ ! great] honor4 ,8 practical influ5ce desc5d$ ?r\gh ! visions & ec/asies ( ! sa9ts d[n to ,sw$5borg1 :o attempt$ to write ! !ology ( ! ec/asy2 & ! relation betwe5 ^! two1 ,sw$5borg & ,plot9os %\ld prove a f]tile field = inve/igation4 ,,cultural ,,importance4 ,summ>iz+1 he =m$ a bridge betwe5 ! pagan _w1 ) its ,greco-,roman civilization1 & ! mod]n _w1 9 ?ree dep>tm5ts3 ,*ri/ianity1 philosophy1 & my/icism4 ,s long z ! traditional ,platonico-,/oical feud p]si/$ !re 0 no hope ( progress2 because x kept ap>t two elem5ts t 7 to fuse into ! ,*ri/ian philosophy4 ,num5ius 0 ! la/ ,platoni/1 z ,posidonius 0 ! la/ ,/oic combatant4 ,h[ev]1 if reports are to be tru/$1 ,ammonius 0 an eclectici/1 :o prid$ himself on comb9+ ,plato ) ,ari/otle4 ,if ,plot9os 0 inde$ 8 disciple1 x 0 ! !ory eclecticism t he took f 8 reput$ tea*]4 ,practically he 0 to accompli% x by 8 dep5d5ce on ! ,num5ian ,amelius1 ! ,/oic ,porphyry1 & ! negative ,eu/o*ius4 ,x w be se5 !re=e t 8 *ief importance 0 n 9 spite ( 8 weakness1 b mo/ because ( x4 ,by repeat$ly box+ ! compass he ?or\ghly assimilat$ ! be/ ( ! conflict+ s*ools1 & became ( int]e/ to a suffici5cy ( diff]5t gr\ps 7,*ri/ian1 philosophical & my/ical7 to insure pres]vation1 /udy & quotation4 ,8 habit ( omitt+ cr$it to any b anci5t ?9k]s left 8 own "w1 to ! un9=m$--:o con/itut$ all b a m9imal numb]--z a body ( orig9al ?\ght4 ,?us he rema9s to u ! la/ light ( ,greece1 speak+ a language ) :i* we are famili>1 & leav+ u quotations t are imp]i%able4 ,,p]sonal ,,value4 ,:ile !re=e provid5tially ,plot9os has ev] be5 ( great importance !ologically1 philosophically & my/ically1 we _c leave him )\t hone/ly fac+ ! "q ( 8 value z an orig9al ?9k]4 ,x is evid5t t 8 success 0 9 inv]se ratio to orig9ality2 b we c also see t he c\ld n h held toge!r ^? ?ree sph]es ( int]e/ )\t ! mom5tum ( a wond]ful p]sonality4 ,?is w be evid5t at a glance to any read] ( 8 biography4 ,b aft] all we are "h conc]n$ n s mu* ) 8 p]sonality z ) 8 value z an orig9al ?9k]4 ,?is "q is moot$ by1 & _c be laid aside because ( its decisive influ5ce on ! problem ( 8 dep5d5ce ( ,num5ius4 ,! great] "p ( ! latt]'s works be+ irretrievably lo/1 we c judge only f :at we h2 & z to ! re/1 we mu/ ask ourselves1 0 ,plot9os ! k9d ( a man :o w\ld h dep5d$ on "s o!r man's ?\ghts8 ,is he likely to h sket*$ out a great s*eme & fill$ x 92 or r1 0 he likely to dep5d on p]sonal sugge/ion1 & embroid] on x1 s to speak4 ,else:]e we h demon/rat$ a developm5t ( 8 op9ions1 = in/ance1 ab\t matt]4 ,0 ?is due to progressiv5ess1 or to indef9it5ess8 ,! read] mu/ judge = himself4 ,,p]sonal ,,limitations4 ,8 epilepsy naturally creat$ an opportunity =1 & ne$ ( a doctr9e ( ec/asy2 :i* = normal p %\ld be no m ?an a doctr9e1 or at lea/ be limit$ to consci\s exp]i5ces4 ,ev5 8 admir]1 ,porphyry1 ackn[l$ges t he spell$ & pron\nc$ incorrectly4#gej ,he ackn[l$g$ t )\t ,porphyry's objections he w\ld h no?+ to say4 ,he refra9$ f quot+ 8 au?orities1 & ,porphyry ackn[l$g$ t 8 writ+s conta9$ _m ,/oic & ,ari/otelian doctr9es4 ,x 0 g5]ally bruit$ ar\nd t 8 doctr9es 7 borr[$ f ,num5ius1#gea to ! ext5t t 8 disciples held controv]sies1 & wrote books on ! subject4 ,8 /yle is enigmatic1 & ! difficulty ( und]/&+ him 0 discuss$ ev5 9 8 own day4 ,he 0 dep5d5t on secret>ies or editors2 fir/ on ,amelius1 lat] on ,porphyry1 :o does n scruple to ackn[l$ge he add$ _m explanations4#geb ,lat]1 ,plot9os s5t 8 books to ,porphyry 9 ,sicily to edit4 ,no d\bt ! defectiv5ess ( 8 eyesight made bo? read+ & writ+ difficult1 & expla9s 8 failure to put titles to 8 works2 ?\gh1 z 9 ! case ( ,virgil1 su* hesitation may h be5 ! result ( a secret consci\sness ( 8 indebt$ness to o!rs4 ,,reliance ,,on ,,punn+4 ,punn+ has ( c\rse a ho>y antiquity1 & ev5 ! rev]$ ,plato 0 an adept at x--z we see 9 8 ,cratylos4 ,moreov]1 n till a man's "w is translat$ c we uncov] all ! unconsci\s cases ( undi/ribut$ middle4 ,nev]!less1 9 an inquiry z to ! p]man5t objective validity ( a tra9 ( reason+1 we are compell$ to note ext5t & scope ( 8 t5d5cy4 ,s he puns on aeons2#gec on sci5ce & k2#ged on agalmata2#gee on ,aphrodite1 z delicate2#gef on ,be+2#geg on koros1 z creation or adornm5t2#geh on diff]5ce 9 o!rs2#gei on idea2#gfj on heav51 _w1 univ]se1 animal & all2#gfa on ,ve/a1 & /&+2#gfb on ,hexis2#gfc on incl9ation2#gfd on doxa2#gfe on love & vision2#gff on e9ai & h5os2#gfg on m\s1 nosis1 & to nofon2#gfh on pas*e92#gfi on ,poros2#ggj on ,prome!us & ,provid5ce2#gga on reason & *>act]i/ic2#ggb on s*esis & s*ema2#ggc & soma & soze/hai2#ggd on suff]+2#gge on ?9k+1 ?9kable1 & intellection2#ggf on timely & sov]eign4#ggg ,x w be not$ t ^! puns ref] to "s ( ! mo/ important conceptions1 & are f\nd 9 all p]iods ( 8 life4 ,we mu/ !re=e conclude t 8 0 n a cle> ?9k+ ability2 t he dep5d$ on accid5tal circum/ances1 & may n always h be5 fully consci\s h[ f> he 0 foll[+ o!rs4 ,?is popul> judgm5t t he 0 revamp+ ,num5ius's "w may !n n h be5 entirely unf\nd$1 z we inde$ h %[n4 ,nev]!less1 he a*iev$ "s p]man5t "w1 t w nev] be =gott52 = in/ance3 #a4 ,8 description ( ! ec/atic /ate4 #b4 ,8 polemic aga9/ ! ,ari/otelian & ,/oic categories4 #c4 ,8 e/abli%m5t ( 8 own categories4 #d4 ,8 allegoric treatm5t ( ! bir? ( love1 ! sev]al ,eroses1 ,poros & ,p5ia1 & o!r my?s4 #e4 ,8 build+ ( a ,tr9it>ian philosophy4 #f4 ,8 ?reefold sph]es ( exi/5ce1 und]ly+ ,sw$5borgian int]pretation4 #g4 ,8 ae/hetic !ories4 #h4 ,8 e?ical /udies ( virtues & happ9ess4 #i4 ,8 re/atem5t ( ,num5ius's argum5ts = ! immat]iality ( ! s\l4 ,,select$ ,,maxims ,! read] may be int]e/$ 9 a few maxims select$ f ,plot9os' works :i* may be ( g5]al int]e/4 #a4 ,we develop t[>d ec/asy by simplification ( ,s\l4 #b4 ,we rise by ! flight ( ! ,s+le to ! ,s+le1 face to face4 #c4 ,we conta9 some?+ ( ! ,supreme4 #d4 ,! ,s\l becomes :at %e rememb]s & sees4 #e4 ,ev]y?+ has a secret p[]4 #f4 ,! be/ m5 are ^? :o h mo/ intimacy ) !mselves4 #g4 ,! t\* ( ! good man is ! greate/ ?+ 9 ! _w4 #h4 ,e be+ is its be/1 n :5 great or num]\s1 b :5 x belongs to itself4 #i4 ,!re are two m5 9 u1 ! bett] & ! worse4 #aj4 ,! secret ( life is to live simultane\sly ) o!rs & y\rself4 #aa4 ,god is ! au?or ( lib]ty4 #ab4 ,conc]n+ :at w\ld x be mo/ wor? :ile to speak1 except ! ,s\l8 ,let u !re=e "k ourselves4 #ac4 ,)\t virtue1 ,god is b a "n4 #ad4 ,! object ( virtue is to sep>ate ! s\l f ! body4 #ae4 ,we c nev] become p]fect1 because he :o ?9ks himself s has already =gott5 ! supreme div9ity t[>ds :i* he mu/ ha/54 #af4 ,! _w 0 creat$ by a concurr5ce ( intellig5ce & necessity4 #ag4 ,! ,s\l is ! image1 ^w1 & int]pret] ( ! ,"o4 #ah4 ,! div9ities ?\gh pres5t to _m human be+s (t5 reveal !mselves only to "s "o p]son1 because he alone is able to contemplate !m4 #ai4 ,to act )\t suff]+ is ! sign ( a great p[]4 #bj4 ,only virtue is indep5d5t4 #ba4 ,we are beautiful :5 we "k ourselves4 #bb4 ,! ,s\l is ! *ild ( ! univ]sal ,fa!r4 #bc4 ,true happ9ess is be+ wise1 & ex]cis+ ?is )9 oneself4 #bd4 ,to become aga9 :at "o 0 orig9ally is to live 9 ! ,sup]ior _w4 #be4 ,! desir$ goal is n to cease fail+1 b to gr[ div9e4 #bf4 ,virtue dem&s prelim9>y purification4 #bg4 ,our ef=t at assimilation %\ld be direct$ n at m]e respectability1 b at ! gods !mselves4 #bh4 ,"o %\ld /udy ma!matics 9 ord] to accu/om oneself to ?9k ( incorporeal ?+s1 & to believe 9 _! exi/5ce4 #bi4 ,s\l is n 9 body1 b body 9 ,s\l4 #cj4 ,! ,s\l's high] "p rema9s 9 heav54 #ca4 ,we %\ld n leave ! e>?1 b n be ( x4 #cb4 ,! object ( life is n to avoid evil1 or copy ! good1 b to become good4 #cc4 ,dy+1 to ,eu/o*ius3 ,i am await+ y1 9 ord] to draw ! div9e 9 me to ! div9e 9 all4 ,,footnotes3 #a ,x is significant t ! subject ( ! fir/ treatise ( ,plot9os1 aft] ! dep>ture ( ,porphyry1 %\ld treat ( happ9ess z ! object ( life4 ,^! may h be5 ! argum5ts he advanc$ to p]suade ,porphyry to ab/a9 f suicide 7to :i* he ref]s 9 sections #h1 #af71 &1 r1 to take a trip to ,sicily1 ! l& ( natural beauty4 ,he also speaks ( los+ fri5ds1 9 section #h4 ,! next book1 on ,provid5ce1 may also h be5 inspir$ by reflections on ?is unt[>d & unexpect$ circum/ance4 ,we see also a *ange f ab/ract speculation to 8 m y\?ful fancy & comp>ative le>n+ & culture4 #b ,diog4 ,la]t4 x42 ,cic]o1 de ,f94 i4 #ad1 #df4 #c ,cic]o1 de ,f94 #aa1 #bf4 #d ,see ,ari/4 ,nic4 ,e?4 vii4 #ac2 ,sextus ,empiricus1 ,hypotyp4 ,pyrrhon1 iii4 #ahj2 ,/ob4 ,ecl4 ii4 #g4 #e ,ari/4 ,nic4 ,e?4 i4 #aj1 #ad4 #f ,/ob4 ,floril4 i4 #gf4 #g ,see vi4 #h4 #h ,9 ,plut>*1 ( ,wick$ness1 & 9 ,s5eca1 de ,tranquil1 ,animi1 #ad4 #i ,de ,provid5tia1 #c4 #aj ,de ,provid4 #e4 #aa ,aes*ylus1 ,sev5 ,aga9/ ,!bes1 #cbg4 #ab ,! vegetative s\l1 ! p[] t presides ov] ! nutrition & gr[? ( ! body2 see iv4 #c4bc4 #ac ,see i4 #h2 also ,num5ius1 #af4 #ad i4 #b4d4 #ae ,cic]o1 ,tusculans4 ii4 #g4 #af ,! animal2 see i4 #a4aj4 #ag ,see i4 #a4h1 #aj4 #ah ,see ! ,!ataetus1 p4 #agf4 ,c>v4 #hd2 ! ,pha$o4 p4 #fi1 ,c>y1 #cg2 ! ,republic1 vi4 p4 #eji2 ,c>y1 #ai2 x4 p4 #fac1 ,c>y1 #ab2 ! ,laws1 iv4 p4 #gaf1 ,c>y1 #h2 also ,plot9os i4 #b4a4 #ai ,see i4 #i4 #bj ,a ,/oic confutation ( ,epicurus & ! ,gno/ics4 ,z soon z ,porphyry has left him1 ,plot9os h>ks back to ,amelius1 on ^: leav+ he _h writt5 aga9/ ! ,gno/ics4 ,he also returns to ,num5ian ?\ghts4 ,b\illet notices t "h ,plot9os f\nd$ himself on ,*rysippus1 ,m>cus ,aurelius1 & ,epictetus1 & 0 foll[$ by ,nemesius4 ,?is new f\ndation enabl$ him to assume a r indep5d5t attitude4 ,aga9/ ,plato1 he taught t matt] d]iv$ exi/5ce f ,god1 & t ! union ( ! s\l & body is n necess>ily evil4 ,aga9/ ,ari/otle1 he taught t ,god is n only ! f9al1 b also ! effici5t cause ( ! univ]se4 ,aga9/ ! ,/oics1 he taught t ! human s\l is free1 & is a cause1 indep5d5t ( ! ,_w ,s\l f :i* %e proce$$4 ,aga9/ ! ,gno/ics1 he insi/$ t ! creator is good1 ! _w is ! be/ possible1 & ,provid5ce ext5ds to mundane affairs4 ,aga9/ ! ,mani*eans1 he taught t ! evil is n positive1 b negative1 & is no effici5t cause1 s t !re is no dualism4 #ba ,diog4 ,la]t4 x4 #acc4 #bb ,see iv4 #b4d2 vi4 #g2 see ,plato1 ,philebus1 p4 #cj1 ,c>y1 #ef2 ,philo1 ,leg4 ,alleg1 vi4 #g4 #bc ,lactantius1 de ,ira ,dei1 #ac4 #bd ,ir5eus1 ,ref4 ,h]4 ii4 #c4 #be ,z 9 vi4 #g4a4 #bf ,philo1 de ,creatione ,mundi1 #f4 #bg ,z ! ,gno/ics taught2 see ii4 #i4a4 #bh ,z 0 held by ! ,gno/ics1 :o )9 ! div9ity di/+ui%$ pot5tiality & actuality1 z we see 9 ii4 #i4a4 #bi ,see ii4 #i4c4 #h4 #cj ,num5ius1 #cb4 #ca ,plato1 ,timaeus1 p4 #dh1 ,c>y1 #ba4 ,/atesman1 p4 #bgc1 ,c>y1 #af2 ,laws1 x4 p4 #ijd1 ,c>y1 #ab4 #cb ,see ii4 #i4b4 #cc ,f ,ari/otle1 de ,anima1 #b4 #cd ,?is is ! ,ari/otelian psy*ological s*eme4 #ce ,clem4 ,al42 ,/rom4 v4 p4 #gab2 ,/obaeus1 ,ecl4 ,phys4 i4 p4 #cgb1 #ddf4 #cf iv4 #h4ab2 ,plato1 ,tim4 p4 #da4 #fi2 ,c>y1 #af1 #dd4 #cg ,/ob4 ,ecl4 ,e?4 ii4 #g4 #ch iii4 #b4ac4 #ci p4 #bec2 ,c>y1 #gd4 #dj ,s54 #ebf4 #da ,accord+ to ,plato's ,!aetetus1 p4 #agf1 ,c>y1 #hc2 ,num5ius1#af4 #db ,s5eca1 de ,provid4 #b4 #dc ,9 8 ,republic1 ix4 p4 #ehe1 ,c>y1 #aj4 #dd ,see iii4 #a4i4 #de ,see iv4 #c4ab4 #df ,see iv4 #c4e4 #dg ,gregory ( ,nyssa1 ,cate*4 ,orat4 #g4 #dh ,z ?\ght ,sallu/1 ,consp4 ,cat4 #eb4 #di ,republic x4 p4 #fbj2 ,c>y1 #af2 ,num5ius1 #eg4 #ej ,z said ,sallu/1 ,conspiration ( ,catil9e1 #eb4 #ea ,z ?\ght ,epictetus1 ,manual1 #ca4 #eb ,9 8 ,republic1 vi4 p4 #dhh2 ,c>y1 #d4 #ec ,m>cus ,aurelius4 ,?\ghts1 xi4 #ah4 #ed ,z ?\ght ,cic]o1 de ,nat4 ,deor4 iii4 #fc4 #fd4 #ee ,z ?\ght ,philo1 de ,prov4 9 ,eus4 ,prep4 ,ev4 viii4 #ad4 #ef ,accord+ to ,plato1 9 ! ,sophi/ & ,protagoras1 & ! ,/oics1 z 9 ,m>cus ,aurelius4 ,m$itations1 vii4 #fc4 #eg ,z did ! writ] ( ,revelation1 iv4 #f4 #eh ,9 8 ,timaeus1 p4 #bi;e1 ,c>y1 #aj4 #ei ,z said ,*rysippus 9 ,plut>*1 de ,comm4 ,n4 adv4 ,/oicos1 #ac4 #fj ,m5tion$ by ,plato 9 8 ,pha$rus1 p4 #bdh1 ,c>y1 #ei2 ,republ4 v4 p4 #dea1 ,c>y1 #b2 & 9 ! fam\s hymn ( ,clean!s1 ,/obaeus ,ecl4 ,phys4 i4 #c4 #fa ,l ! figure ( ! angel ,mi?ra2 see ,franck1 ,la,kabbale1 p4 #cff4 #fb ,z ,hi]ocles wond]$1 de ,prov4 p4 #hb1 ,london ,ed4 #fc ,9 ! words ( ,plato's ,timaeus p4 #dh2 ,c>y1 #ba2 & ,!aetetus1 p4 #agf2 ,c>y1 #hd2 ,num5ius1 #af4 #fd ,almo/ ! words ( ,john i4 #a4 #fe ,9 ! ,laws1 vii4 p4 #gif1 ,c>y1 #f2 p4 #hae1 ,c>y1 #ah2 & ,philo1 de ,prov4 9 ,eus4 ,prep4 ,ev4 viii4 #ad4 #ff ,z ?\ght ,epictetus 9 8 ,manual1 #b1 #f4 #fg ,9 8 ,philebus1 p4 #dh1 ,c>y1 #ajf4 #fh ,z ?\ght ,epictetus 9 8 ,manual4 #h4 #fi ,see iii4 #h4 #gj ,num5ius1 #cb4 #ga ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #ahg1 ,c>y1 #ad4 #gb ,m>cus ,aurelius1 ,m$it4 ii4 #ac4 #gc ,z ?\ght ,m>cus ,aurelius1 9 8 ,?\ghts1 xii4 #db4 #gd ,see iv4 #c4bd4 #ge ,9 8 ,manual1 #cg4 #gf ,see iv4 #a4i-ab4 #gg ,m>cus ,aurelius1 ,m$it4 vii4 #i2 ,s5eca1 ,epi/4 #id4 #gh ,num5ius1 iii4 #g4 #gi ,?is image 0 lat] adopt$ by ,sw$5borg 9 8 cele/ial man4 #hj ,9 close proximity to note #de1 ano!r di/9ctly ,johann9e expression4 #ha ,/oic ideas4 #hb ,z ,plato said 9 8 ,pha$rus1 p4 #bdg1 ,c>y1 #ef4 #hc ,see i4 #h4b4 #hd ,see ii4 #c4ag4 #he ,see ii4 #c4ac4 ,fic9us's translation4 #hf ,a ,/oic t]m4 #hg ,plato1 ,timaeus1 p4 #db1 ,c>y1 #ag2 see also ,enn4 ii4 #c4aj4 #aa1 #ae1 #af4 #hh ,timaeus1 p4 #db1 #ia1 ,c>y1 #ag1 #gb1 #gc4 #hi ,see ii4 #c4ac4 #ij ,alc9\s1 de ,doctr9a ,platonica1 #bf4 #ia ,gregory ( ,nyssa1 ,cate*4 ,oratio1 #g2 ,dionysius ,areopagite1 ,div9e ,names1 #d4 #ib ,see ii4 #c4g4 #ic ,see iii4 #b4f4 #id ,plato1 ,timaeus1 p4 #ca;c1 ,c>y1 #aa4 #ie ,see ,num5ius4 #ad4 #if ,clem4 ,al4 ,/rom4 v4 #fhi4 #ig ,9 ?is book we no long] f9d detail$ /udy ( ,plato1 ,ari/otle & ! ,epicureans1 z we did 9 ! works ( ! ,porphyrian p]iod4 ,well inde$ did ,plot9os say t )\t ,porphyry's objections he might h _h little to say4 #ih ,porphyry1 ,pr9ciples ( ! !ory ( ! ,intelligibles1 #ca4 #ii ,olympiodorus1 9 ,pha$onem1 ,c\s91 ,fragm5ts1 p4 #djd4 #ajj ,ib41 p4 #dcb4 #aja ,ib41 p4 #dah4 #ajb ,ib41 p4 #dca4 #ajc ,john ,philoponus1 ,comm4 9 ,ari/41 de ,anima1 i4 #a4 #ajd ,see iii4 #f4a4 #aje ,by a triple pun1 on n\s1 nosis1 & to noton4 #ajf ,porphyry1 ,pr9ciples1 #cb4 #ajg ,by a pun4 #ajh ,see ,john i4 #d1 #i4 #aji ,?is anticipates ,a?anasius's explanations ( ! div9e process4 #aaj ,see v4 #a4d4 #aaa ,porphyry1 ,pr9ciples1 #bf4 #aab ,! ,eleusynian ,my/]ies1 ,hymn to ,c]es1 #bgi2 see vi4 #i4aa4 #aac ,see v4 #c4ad4 #aad ,9 ?is book ,plot9os h>ks back to ! fir/ book he _h writt51 i4 #f1 to ,plato's ,banquet & ,cratylos4 ,porphyry lat] agre$ ) "s ( x4 ,l ,/4 ,john1 ,plot9os returns to ,god z love1 9 8 old age4 ,8 =m] book _h also be5 a re-/atem5t ( e>li] ?\ghts4 #aae ,see iii4 #e4f4 #aaf ,see i4 #f4b1 #c4 #aag ,see i4 #f4c1 #g4 #aah ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #bjf-bjh1 ,c>y1 #ca1 #cb4 #aai ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #baj1 ,c>y1 #cd1 sqq4 #abj ,porphyry1 ,biography ( ,plot9os1 #ae4 #aba ,see i4 #c4b4 #abb ,see sect4 #e1 #f4 #abc ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #ahe1 ,c>y1 #ab1 #ac4 #abd ,by ,plato1 9 8 ,cratylus1 p4 #cif1 ,c>y1 #bi1 #cj2 int]pret$ to mean pure ,intellig5ce4 #abe ,?is is ! pr9cipal p[] ( ! s\l2 see ii4 #c4ag4 #abf ,see v4 #h4ab1 #ac4 #abg ,plot9os ?us d]ives eros f orasis1 :i*1 h[ev] f>-fet*$ a d]ivation1 is less s ?an t ( ,plato1 f esros1 mean+ to fl[ into1 ,cratylos1 p4 #dbj1 ,c>y1 #gi1 #hj4 #abh ,= ?is di/9ction1 see ii4 #c4ag1 #ah4 #abi ,= ! two ,loves1 see v4 #h4ac1 & vi4 #i4i4 #acj ,see iii4 #d4 #aca ,see iv4 #i4 #acb ,plato1 ,banq4 #bjc3 ,c>y1 #bi4 #acc ,9 8 ,isis & ,osiris1 p4 #cgb1 #cgd4 #acd ,see i4 #a4 #ace ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #bjb1 ,c>y1 #bg1 #bh2 ,porphyry1 de ,ab/4 ii4 #cg1 sqq4 #acf ,9 section #d4 #acg ,plato1 ,ep9omis1 p4 #ihd1 ,c>y1 #h2 ,porphyry1 de ,ab/4 ii4 #cg-db4 #ach ,see ii4 #d4c4 #aci ,see ii4 #d4c4 #adj ,an expression (t5 us$ by ! ,platoni/s2 see ! ,lexicon ,platonicum1 by ! gramm>ian ,timaeus1 sub voce oi/ra4 #ada ,see ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #bjc1 ,c>y1 #bi4 #adb ,see iii4 #d4f4 #adc ,see iii4 #d4c4 #add ,a ,/oic di/9ction4 #ade ,p4 #bdf1 ,c>y1 #ef4 #adf ,p4 #bh1 ,c>y1 #ej4 #adg ,didymus1 ,etym4 ,magn4 p4 #agi1 ,heidelb4 p4 #afb1 ,lips4 #adh ,timaeus ,locrius1 ( ! ,s\l ( ! ,_w1 p4 #eej1 ed4 ,gale1 ,c>y1 #d4 #adi ,orig51 c4 ,cels41 iv4 p4 #ecc4 #aej logoi4 #aea ,proclus1 ,!ology ( ,plato1 vi4 #bc4 #aeb ,z ! g5]ation ( ! _w1 9 ,plato's ,timaeus1 p4 #bh1 #bi1 ,c>y1 #i2 & ! erect+ into sep>ate ,gods v>i\s p[]s ( ! same div9ity1 z ,proclus said1 9 8 comm5t>y !reon1 9 ,p>m4 i4 #cj4 #aec ii4 #c4ag2 ii4 #i4b4 #aed ,pun on ,poros & euporia4 #aee ,see ii4 #d4af4 #aef ,see books ii4 #c2 ii4 #i2 iii4 #a1 #b1 #c1 #d1 = ! f\ndations on :i* ?is summ>y ( ,plot9os's doctr9e ( evil is conta9$4 ,to d ?is1 he 0 compell$ to return to ,plato1 ^: ,!aetetus1 ,/atesman1 ,timaeus & ,laws he consult$4 ,ari/otle seems to h be5 m int]e/$ 9 natural ph5om5a & human virtue ?an 9 ! root-que/ions ( ! de/9y ( ! univ]se1 & ! nature ( ! div9ity2 s ,plot9os /udies him little "h4 ,b x w be se5 t "h ,plot9os entirely returns to ! lat] ,plato1 ?r\gh ,num5ius4 #aeg ,z ?\ght ,emp$ocles1 #cah-cbj4 #aeh i4 #f4b4 #aei i4 #h4g4 #afj i4 #h4c4 #afa ,z ?\ght ,plato 9 8 ,laws1 iv4 p4 #gaf2 ,c>y1 #g1 #h4 #afb ,z ?\ght ,plato 9 8 ,philebus1 p4 #bh2 ,c>y #di1 #ej4 #afc ,see v4 #a2 vi4 #i4b4 #afd ,num5ius1 fr4 #cb4 #afe ,z said ,plato1 9 8 second ,lett]1 #b4cab4 #aff ,see iii4 #h4i2 iv4 #g4ad2 vi4 #d4b2 vi4 #i4b4 #afg ,z held by ,plato 9 ! ,p>m5ides & ,fir/ ,alcibiades4 #afh ,see ii4 #d4h-af4 #afi ,x is notewor?y t ,plot9os 9 8 old age "h f9ally recognizes ,evil 9 itself1 j z ,plato 9 8 lat] "w1 ! ,laws 7x4 p4 #hig2 ,c>y1 #h7 adds to ! good ,_w-s\l1 an evil "o4 ,?is1 = ,plot9os1 0 h>k+ back to ,num5ius's evil _w-s\l1 fr4 #af4 #agj ,9 8 ,fir/ ,alcibiades1 p4 #abb2 ,c>y1 #cg4 #aga ,see i4 #a4ab4 #agb ,?is means creat$ ?+s1 :i* are cont+5t & p]i%able2 see ii4 #d4e1 #f4 #agc ,see ii4 #d4aj-ab4 ,?is idea ( irradiation is practically emanationism2 & besides ,plot9os's int]e/ 9 ori5talism 7,porphyry ,biography1 #c71 x h>ks back to ,num5ius1 fr4 #bf4c2 #bg;a4#aj4 #agd ,held by ,plato 9 8 ,!aetetus1 p4 #agf2 ,c>y1 #hd1 #he2 & ,republic1 ii4 #bgi2 ,c>y1 #ah1 & ( ,num5ius1 fr4 #af4 #age ,see i4 #b4a4 #agf ,9 ! ,!aetetus1 p4 #agf2 ,c>y1 #hd1 #he4 #agg ,num5ius1 fr4 #aj2 ,plato1 ,rep4 vi4 p4 #eji;b2 ,c>y1 #ai4 #agh ,z ,plato sugge/$ 9 8 ,philebus1 p4 #bc2 ,c>y1 #ce-cg4 #agi ,num5ius1 fr4 #ag4 #ahj ,m5tion$ by ,plato 9 ! ,timaeus1 pp4 #bh1 #cj1 #ch2 ,c>y1 #i1 #aj1 #ad4 #aha ,f ! ,timaeus1 p4 #da2 ,c>y1 #af1 #ag4 #ahb ,see i4 #b4a2 i4 #f4h4 #ahc ,t is1 ! relative inf]iority ( be+s :i*1 proce$+ f ea* o!r1 become m & m di/ant f ! good2 see ii4 #e4e2 ii4 #i4h1 #ac2 v4 #a2 ,philo1 ,leg4 ,alleg4 ii4 p4 #gd4 #ahd ,see i4 #h4a4 #ahe ii4 #d4ab4 #ahf ,num5ius1 fr4 #bf4c4 #ahg ,diog4 ,la]tes vii4 #ahh ,see ii4 #f4 #ahi ii4 #d4ac4 #aij i4 #h4ae4 #aia ,z ?\ght ,plato 9 8 ,banquet1 p4 #baa2 ,c>y1 #ce4 #aib ,z said ,plato1 ,republic1 vii4 p4 #ecd2 ,c>y1 #ad4 #aic ,z ,plato says 9 8 ,pha$rus1 p4 #bdf2 ,c>y1 #ed1 #ef4 #aid ,z wrote ,plato 9 8 ,banquet1 p4 #bjc2 ,c>y1 #bh1 #bi1 & see iii4 #g4ad & iii4 #e4i z well z iii4 #f4ad4 #aie ,accord+ to ! int]pretation ( ,fic9us4 #aif ,see ii4 #d4 ,?is is an add$ confirmation ( ! *ronological ord]2 9 ! ,enneadic ord] ?is book is lat]1 n e>li]4 #aig ,aga9 a t]m discuss$ by ,num5ius1 fr4 ii4 #h1 #ac2 & iii2 see i4 #a4i2 iv4 #c4c1 #cj1 #ca2 i4 #d4aj4 #aih ,we notice h[ ^! latt] /udies ( ,plot9os d n take up any new problems1 *iefly review+ subjects t\*$ on be=e4 ,?is acc\nts = ,porphyry's attempt to gr\p ! ,plot9ic writ+s1 sy/ematically4 ,?is rem9ds u ( ! sugge/ion 9 ! ,biography1 t except = ! objections ( ,porphyry1 ,plot9os w\ld h no?+ to write4 ,notice also ! sy/em ( ! la/ ,porphyrian treatises1 contra/$ ) ! m lit]>y treatm5t ( ! lat]4 ,all ?is supports ,porphyry's table ( *ronological arrangem5t ( ! /udies ( ,plot9os4 ,?is book is closely connect$ ) ! prec$+ /udies ( ,fate & ,provid5ce1 iii4 #a-c2 = he is "h really oppos+ n ! ,gno/ics he antagoniz$ :5 dismiss+ ,amelius1 b ! ,/oic !ories on ,provid5ce & ,fate4 #aii ,see iii4 #a4e1 #f2 iii4 #f2 iv4 #d4cj-dd4 #bjj ,macrob9s4 ,9 ,somn4 ,scipionis4 #bja ,cic]o1 de ,div9atione1 i4 #ci4 #bjb ,julius ,firmicus ,mat]nus1 ,a/rol4 ii4 #bc4 #bjc ,) ,ptolemy's ,tetrabiblion1 i4 p4 #ag4 #bjd ,see iv4 #d4ca4 #bje ,discuss$ 9 p>4 #d4 #bjf ,?is incompreh5sibility 0 no d\bt due to ,plot9os's advanc+ bl9dness & r5al affection4 #bjg ,num5ius1 fr4 #cb4 #bjh ,cic]o1 de ,nat4 ,deorum1 ii4 #df4 #bji ,see iv4 #d4cb4 #baj ,accord+ to ! ,/oics3 ,alex4 ,aphrod4 de ,mixtione1 p4 #ada2 ,cic]o1 de ,nat4 ,deorum1 ii4 #cb4 #baa ,see iii4 #a4d1 #g-aj4 #bab ,see iii4 #a4f4 #bac ,see iv4 #d4cc4 #bad ,see iv4 #d4ce2 accord+ to ! ,/oics1 see ,diog5es ,la]tes4 vii4 #adj4 #bae ,see iv4 #d4cb4 #baf ,s5eca1 ,que/4 ,nat4 i4 #a4 #bag ,see iii4 #d4b1 #d4 #bah ,see ii4 #c4ac4 #bai ,see iii4 #d4c4 #bbj ,see iii4 #a4h-aj4 #bba ,! law ( ,adra/ea2 see iii4 #d4b2 iv4 #d4d1 #e4 #bbb ,plato1 ,pha$rus1 p4 #bdd-bea2 ,c>y1 #dg-ff4 #bbc ,see i4 #h2 ii4 #aa2 iii4 #a2 vi4 #h4 #bbd ,plato1 ,rep4 x4 p4 #fag2 ,c>y1 #ad4 #bbe p4 #da-db2 ,c>y1 #af1 #ag4 #bbf ,see i4 #a4g-aj4 #bbg ,see ii4 #a4e4 #bbh ,/oic t]ms4 #bbi ,see ii4 #a4h-aj4 #bcj ,see i4 #b4a2 vi4 #h4 #bca ,see i4 #a4g-ab2 iv4 #c4ai-bc4 #bcb ,?is is ! exact doctr9e ( ,num5ius1 fr4 #ec2 x logically agrees ) ! d\bl5ess ( matt]1 ,num4 #ad2 ( ! ,creator1 ,num4 #cf2 & ! _w-,s\l1 fr4 #af4 ,see note #ga4 #bcc ,see p>4 #ah4 #bcd ,plato1 ,banquet1 p4 #bjb2 ,c>y1 #bh2 ,timaeus1 p4 #ij2 ,c>y1 #ga4 #bce ,see iii4 #a4b4 #bcf ,t is1 to %>e ! passions ( ! bodies3 see iii4 #a4b4 #bcg ,see iv4 #d4ch-dj4 #bch ,s5eca1 ,nat4 ,que/4 ii4 #cb4 #bci ,accord+ to ,ari/otle1 ,met4 xii4 #c4 #bdj ,see iii4 #a4f4 #bda ,see ,cic]o1 de ,nat4 ,deor4 ii4 #cd4 #bdb ,see iv4 #d4ci1 #dj4 #bdc ,plato1 ,pha$rus1 p4 #bdh2 ,c>y1 #ei4fj4 #bdd ,see iii4 #a4h-aj4 #bde ,see iv4 #d4ci4 #bdf ,see iii4 #d4c4 #bdg ,see iii4 #a4aj4 #bdh ,see iii4 #a4e4 #bdi ,rep4 x4 p4 #faf2 ,c>y1 #ad2 ,enn4 iii4 #d4 #bej ,see iv4 #d4cj1 #dj1 #dc1 #dd4 #bea ,see i4 #d4 #beb ,see i4 #b4e4 #bec ,9 i4 #a2 pro( ( ! *ronological ord]4 #bed ,see ii4 #i4ab2 iv4 #c4i1 #aj2 negatively4 #bee ,see iii4 #c4a1 #b2 see ,s5eca1 de ,provid4 #e4 #bef ,see ii4 #c4ag2 iii4 #h4 #beg ,see iv4 #d4i-ab4 #beh ,see ii4 #d2 ,s5eca1 de ,provid4 #e4 #bei ,see ii4 #i4b2 iii4 #b1 #c4 ,s5eca1 de ,provid4 #e4 #bfj ,or g5]ative reasons1 a ,/oic t]m1 ,s5eca1 ,que/4 ,nat4 iii4 #bi2 see iii4 #c4a1 #b1 #g4 #bfa ,plot9os is "h h>k+ back to 8 v e>lie/ writ+1 #a4f1 :]e1 be=e 8 moni/ic adv5ture ) ,porphyry1 he _h1 "u ! ,num5ian influ5ce ( ,amelius1 con/ruct$ 8 sy/em out ( a comb9ation ( ! doctr9es ( ,plato 7ab\t ! ideas71 ,ari/otle 7! di/9ctions ( =m & matt] & ( pot5tiality & actualization71 & ! ,/oic 7! reasons1 sem9al reasons1 action & passions1 & hexis1 or habit1 ! inorganic in=m+ pr9ciple74 ,( ^!1 ,num5ius seems to h lack$ ! ,ari/otelian doctr9es1 al?\gh he left ,plato's s+le triple-function$ s\l = ,ari/otle's comb9ation ( s\ls ( v>i\s degrees 7fr4 #ec74 ,plot9os1 !re=e1 seems to h di/+ui%$ 9 e object two elem5ts1 matt] & =m 7ii4 #d4a2 ii4 #e4b74 ,matt] inh]es pot5tially 9 all be+s 7ii4 #e4c1 #d7 & !re=e is non-be+1 ugl9ess1 & evil 7i4 #f4f74 ,=m is ! actualization 7,k4 ,/e9h>t's ,melemata ,plot9iana1 p4 #ca2 ii4 #e4b72 t is1 ! ess5ce & p[] 7vi4 #d4i71 :i* are insep>able4 ,=m alone possesses real exi/5ce1 beauty & goodness4 ,=m has f\r degrees3 idea1 reason1 nature & habit2 :i* degrees are ! same z ^? ( ?\ght & life 7,porphyry1 ,pr9ciples #ab1 #ac1 #ad74 ,! idea is di/+ui%$ into idea or intelligible ,=m1 or eidos1 pr9ciple ( human intellectual life4 ,reason is #a1 div9e 7!ios logos1 i4 #f1 #b2 ! reason t comes f ! univ]sal ,s\l1 iv4 #c4aj71 #b1 human 7pr9ciple ( ! rational life1 see ,fic9us on ii4 #f4b72 #c1 ! sem9al or g5]ative reason 7pr9ciple ( ! life ( s5sation1 :i* imp>ts to ! body ! s5se-=m1 morph1 #c4ab-;end2 ,b\illet1 i4 #cfe74 ,n[ reasons reside 9 ! s\l 7ii4 #d4ab71 & are simultane\sly ess5ces & p[]s 7vi4 #d4i71 & z p[]s produce ! nature1 & z ess5ces1 ! habits4 ,n[ nature 7physis7 is ! pr9ciple ( ! vegetative life1 & habit1 hexis1 ,num5ius1 fr4 #ee1 see ii4 #d4af1 is ! pr9ciple ( unity ( inorganic ?+s4 #bfb ,z ?\ght ,ari/otle1 ,met4 xii1 #c4 #bfc ,see ii4 #i4ac4 #bfd ,see iv4 #d4i-ac4 #bfe ,see iii4 #d4a4 #bff ,?is is ,num5ius' doctr9e1 fr4 #af4 #bfg ,see iii4 #c4e1 #aa4 #bfh ,plot9os "h makes 9 ! _w-,s\l a di/9ction analog\s to t obta9+ 9 ! human "o 7:]e !re is a reasonable s\l1 & its image1 ! vegetative s\l1 see i4 #a4h-ab2 iv4 #d4 #ac1 #ad74 ,"h he ass]ts t !re are two s\ls2 ! sup]ior s\l 7! pr9cipal p[] ( ! s\l1 :i* receives ! =ms f ,intellig5ce 7see iv4 #d4i-ab1 #ce71 & ! inf]ior s\l 7nature1 or ! g5]ative p[]71 :i* transmits !m to matt]1 s z to fa%ion x by sem9al reasons 7see iii4 #d4ac1 #ad1 #bb1 #bg74 ,b\illet1 no d\bt rememb]+ ,plot9os's own e>li] invectives aga9/ ^? :o divid$ ! _w-s\l 7ii4 #i4f71 evid5tly direct$ aga9/ ,amelius & ! ,num5ian influ5ce1 :i* till !n he _h foll[$--tries to m9imize x1 claim+ t ?is does n mean two diff]5t hypo/ases1 b only two functions ( "o & ! same hypo/asis4 ,b he ackn[l$ges t ?is gave ! f\ndation = ,plot9os's successors' di/9ction betwe5 ! sup]mundane & ! mundane s\ls 7hyp]kosmios1 & egkosmios74 ,plot9os 0 !re=e return+ to ,num5ius's two _w-s\ls 7fr4 #af71 :i* 0 a necess>y logical consequ5ce ( 8 belief 9 two human s\ls 7fr4 #ec71 z he himself _h taught 9 iii4 #h4e4 ,plot9os objectifies ?is d\bl5ess ( ! s\l 9 ! my? ( ! two ,h]cules1 9 ! next book1 i4 #a4ab4 #bfi ,see ii4 #i4b4 #bgj ,! subject ann\nc$ 9 ! prec$+ book1 ii4 #c4af2 ano!r pro( ( ! *ronological ord]4 ,?is is a v obscure book1 dep5d+ on iv4 #c & #d3 & vi4 #g2 on ! !ory ( ! ?ree div9e hypo/ases1 on 8 psy*ology1 ! s\l's relation to1 & sep>ation f ! body1 & metempsy*osis4 ,8 doctr9es ( self & ( ! emotions are /rik+ly mod]n4 #bga ,see sect4 #b4 #bgb ,see sect4 #c4 #bgc ,see sect4 #d4 #bgd ,see sect4 #g1 #aa4 #bge ,?is mo/ direct translation ( pa?os1 is defective 9 t x means r an exp]i5ce1 a passive /ate1 or modification ( ! s\l4 ,x is a ,/oic t]m4 #bgf ,dianoia is d]iv$ f dia n\1 & indicates t ! discursive ?\ght is ex]cis$ by means ( ! intellig5ce1 receiv+ its notions1 & develop+ !m by ratioc9ation1 see v4 #c4c4 ,x is ! actualization ( discursive reason to dianotikon1 or ( ! reasonable s\l 7psy* logik71 :i* conceives1 judges1 & reasons 7dianoei1 krnei1 logizetai74 #bgg ,nosis means intuitive ?\ght1 ! actualization ( intellig5ce4 #bgh ,see sect4 #g4 #bgi ,see ,porphyry1 ,faculties ( ! ,s\l1 & ,fic9us1 comm5t>y on ?is book4 #bhj ,9 ,greek1 to zoon1 to syn!ton1 to synamphot]on1 to ko9on1 to eidlon4 #bha ,see i4 #b4e4 #bhb ,accord+ to ! ,/oics4 #bhc ,accord+ to ,alex&] ( ,aphrodisia4 #bhd ,z ?\ght ,ari/otle1 de ,anima #b4a2 see #d4c4ba1 & ,num5ius1 #cb4 #bhe ,a fam\s comp>ison1 f\nd 9 ,ari/otle1 de ,anima1 ii4 #a2 ,plato1 ,laws1 x4 p4 #ijf2 ,c>y1 #ad2 & especially ,num5ius1 #cb4 #bhf ,z ,plot9os ?9ks4 #bhg iv4 #d4bj4 #bhh iv4 #c4bj4 #bhi ,ari/41 de ,anim4 #b4a4 #bij ,accord+ to ,ari/otle4 #bia ,pha$o1 p4 #hg2 ,c>y1 #hb4 #bib ,simil> to ! mod]n ,james-,lange !ory ( bodily emotions4 #bic ,see iv4 #d4bj1 #bh4 #bid ,see sect4 #g1 #i1 #aj4 #bie ,see iv4 #c4bb1 #bc4 #bif ,porphyry & ,ammonius 9 ,b\illet1 i4 ,intr4 p4 #fj1 #fc1 #fd1 #ge1 #gi1 #ic1 #if1 #ih1 & note on p4 #cfb to #cgg4 #big ,namely1 intellig5ce & ! reasonable s\l4 #bih ,see ,b\illet1 i4 p4 #cbe1 #ccb4 #bii ,b\illet1 ,intr4 p4 lxxviii4 #cjj ,see ,b\illet1 i41 note1 p4 #cbg1 #cda4 #cja ,"o ( ! ?ree hypo/ases4 #cjb ,see ,b\illet1 i4 p4 lxxiii4 #cdd-ceb4 #cjc ,plato1 ,timaeus1 p4 #ce2 ,c>y1 #ab4 #cjd ,^! images ( ! univ]sal ,s\l are ! faculties ( ! s\l1 s5se-p[]1 vegetative p[]1 g5]ative p[] or nature2 see iv4 #d4ac1 #ad4 #cje ,turn+ means "h to incl9e4 #cjf ,see ,/4 ,paul1 ,rom4 = phantasy1 or imag9ation2 vii4 #g-be4 #cjg ,see iv4 #c4bi-ca1 also i4 #a4i2 ,num5ius1 fr4 ii4 #h1 #ai2 iii4 ,see section #aj4 #cjh ,see i4 #b4e4 #cji iv4 #c4ai1 #bc4 #caj ,see ii4 #i4c1 #d1 #aa1 #ab4 #caa ,fancy or repres5tation1 i4 #d4aj2 iv4 #c4c1 #cj1 #ca4 #cab ,see #d4c4ai1 #bc2 #f4g4f4g4 #cac ,plato1 ,rep4 x4 p4 #faa2 ,c>y1 #aa4 #cad ,= ?is see #d4c4ab1 #ah2 #d4h4 #cae ,odyss4 xi4 #fjb1 #e2 see #d4c4bg4 #caf ,we f9d "h a reass]tion ( ,num5ius's doctr9e ( two s\ls 9 man1 fr4 #ec4 #cag ,b\illet obs]ves t ?is book is only a feeble outl9e ( "s ( ! ideas develop$ 9 vi4 #g1 #h1 & #i4 ,! biographical significance ( ?is might be z foll[s4 ,z 9 ! imm$iately prec$+ books ,plot9os 0 h>k+ back to ,num5ius's doctr9es1 he may h wi%$ to reconcile ! two div]g5t p]iods1 ! ,porphyrian monism ( vi4 #g & #h1 ) ! e>li] ,amelian dualism ( vi4 #i4 ,?is 0 no?+ d]ogatory to him2 = x is well kn[n t !re 0 a diff]5ce betwe5 ! eclectic monism ( ! "y ,plato ( ! ,republic1 & ! m logical dualism ( ! old] ,plato ( ! ,laws4 ,?is latt] 0 repres5t$ by ,num5ius & ,amelius2 ! =m]--comb9$ ) ,ari/otelian & ,/oic elem5ts--by ,porphyry4 ,:]e ,plato c\ld n decide1 :y %\ld we expect ,plot9os to d s8 ,&1 z a matt] ( fact1 ! _w also has nev] be5 able to decide1 s long z x rema9$ s9c]e1 & did n deceive itself ) sophi/ries1 z did ,hegel4 ,kant also _h 8 ?+-9-itself--inde$1 he did little m ?an to develop ! "w ( ,plot9os4 #cah ,z ! ,/oics w\ld say4 #cai ,:i* is "o ( ! ?ree hypo/ases1 ii4 #i4a & v4 #a4 #cbj ,we see "h ,plot9os feel+ ! approa* ( ?is imp5d+ dissolution4 #cba ,arrang$ by ,b\illet 9 ! ord] ( ! ,enneads !y summ>ize4 #cbb ,passages 9 quotation m>ks are f ! text ( ,plot9os4 #cbc ,see i4 #b4c4 #cbd ,see i4 #b4d4 #cbe ,see i4 #b4d4 #cbf ,see i4 #b4f4 #cbg ,see i4 #b4g4 #cbh ,see i4 #b4g4 #cbi ,see i4 #b4e4 #ccj ,see i4 #h4a4 #cca ,see #cf4ch4 #ccb ,^! are ! ?ree div9e hypo/ases1 i4 #h4b2 ii4 #i4a4 #ccc ,see ii4 #b4b4 #ccd ,see v4 #c4f4 #cce ,see iii4 #g4b4 #ccf ,see iii4 #g4b4 #ccg ,a pun on noe9 & n\s4 #cch ,see v4 #c4aj-ab4 #cci ,see v4 #f4aa1 #ab1 #ac4 #cdj ,see v4 #d4c1 #b1 #ab4 #cda ,see v4 #d4d1 #i4 #cdb ,see vi4 #d4i4 #cdc ,see vi4 #d4af4 #cdd ,see iii4 #e4g-i4 f ,plato4 #cde ,see vi4 #b2 vi4 #e4 #cdf ,see vi4 #e4a4 #cdg ,see vi4 #d4d4 #cdh ,see vi4 #e4b4 #cdi ,see vi4 #e4c1 #f4 #cej ,see vi4 #e4d4 #cea ,see vi4 #h4d4 #ceb ,see vi4 #e4ab4 #cec ,see iv4 #h4a4 #ced ,see iv4 #h4a4 #cee ,see #bc4 #cef ,/obaeus1 ,ecl4 ,phys41 i4 #eb1 ed4 ,he]54 #ceg ,see iv4 #c4bc4 #ceh ,9 8 book ,on ! ,s\l4 #cei ,see i4 #a4ab4 #cfj ,see ii4 #f4a4 #cfa ,see ,ennead1 i4 #a4 #cfb ,/obaeus1 ,ecl4 ,physicae1 i4 #eb1 p4 #hgh4 #cfc ,( ,human ,nature1 xv4 #cfd de ,anima1 ii4 #c4 #cfe ,/obaeus1 ,eclogae ,physicae1 i4 #eb4 p4 #hid4 #cff ,on ,human ,nature1 #b4 #cfg ,see ,plot9os1 ii4 #g4a2 ,porphyry1 ,pr9ciples1 #ag1 #ah1 #ba1 #bb1 #cf1 #ch4 #cfh ,see iv4 #c4bj4 #cfi ,see ii4 #c4e4 #cgj ,see iv4 #c4bj4 #cga ,9 8 treatise on ,provid5ce2 ,photius1 ,biblioteca1 #abg1 #dfa4 #cgb i4 #a4h2 ,num4 #aj4 #cgc i4 #a4aj4 #cgd #be4d4;a4 #cge #ch2 #ec4 #cgf i4 #h4a2 ,num4 #af4 #cgg i4 #h4b4 #cgh 9 v4 #e4a4 #cgi ,num4 #bg4;a4#h4 #chj #bg4;b4#aj4 #cha ,num4 #cf1;a4 #chb ,9 i4 #h4c4 #chc ,num4 #af4 #chd i4 #h4d4 #che #aa4 #chf ,num4 #af4 #chg ,num4 #ae4af4 #chh i4 #h4f4 #chi #af4 #cij i4 #h4g4 #cia #a4h4aj4 #cib #ah4 #cic ii4 #i4 #cid ii4 #d4a4 #cie ii4 #d4e4 #cif ii4 #d4f4 #cig ii4 #d4g4 #cih ,num4 #cb1 #ah4 #cii ,num4 #dh4 #djj ,num4 #ad4 #dja i4 #h4g1 ) ii4 #d4g4 #djb ,9 ii4 #d4ae1 #af4 #djc het]ots4 #djd ii4 #e4 #dje ,9 ii4 #e4c4 #djf ,num4 #bj4 #djg iii4 #f4f to end4 #djh iii4 #f4ab4 #dji iii4 #f4aa1 #ab4 #daj #cc4 #daa iii4 #h4ac4 #dab iii4 #f4ai4 #dac iii4 #f4aa4 #dad iii4 #f4i4 #dae iii4 #f4g1 #ah2 ) ,num4 #ab1 #ae1 #ag4 #daf iii4 #f4f4 #dag iii4 #f4ac2 ,num4 #ab2 #cj4 #dah iii4 #f4ah2 v4 #a4a1 etc4 #dai iii4 #f4f1 #ac2 see ii4 #e4c1 #e4 #dbj iii4 #f4ad4 #dba iii4 #f4aa1 z aga9/ ,num4 #ad1 #af4 #dbb ,9 iii4 #f4f1 #h1 #aj4 #dbc ,9 iii4 #f4f4 #dbd iii4 #f4g1 #ac2 see ii4 #e4e4 #dbe iii4 #f4ac1 #f1 #af1 #ag1 #ah4 #dbf iii4 #f4ae4 #dbg iii4 #f4ai4 #dbh iii4 #f4ae4 #dbi ,9 ii4 #e4e4 #dcj v4 #a4g2 iii4 #e4f4 #dca iv4 #d4ac4 #dcb ,9 iv4 #d4ae4 #dcc vi4 #c4g4 #dcd v4 #a4g4 #dce i4 #h4 #dcf ii4 #d4 #dcg ii4 #e4 #dch iii4 #f4 #dci ,9 iv4 #d4ac4 #ddj ,life ( ,plot9os1 #bd1 #be4 #dda ,vit4 ,plot4 #d1 #e1 #ac1 #ag4 #ddb ,ib4 #f4 #ddc #bf4 #ddd #ad4 #dde #ag1 #ah1 #ba4 #ddf #a1 #b1 #g4 #ddg #ad4 #ddh #aj4 #ddi ,see ,d>emb]g1 s4 v4 #dej #ah4 #dea #ag4 #deb #c4 #dec ,z may be se5 9 ,d>emb]g's ,diction>y ( ,antiquities1 s4 v4 #ded ,ib4 #bd4 #dee ,9 c4 #h4 #def c4 #aj4 #deg #dh4 ,plot4 i4 #a4b1 #ab1 etc4 #deh ,enn4 i4 #a4b2 ,num4 #bi2 i4 #a4g4 #dei i4 #a4c2 see ,num4 #cb4 #dfj i4 #a4g1 #ab4 #dfa #ec4 #dfb i4 #a4ac4 #dfc #cj4ba4 #dfd i4 #a4ab4 #dfe iv4 #h1 or ev5 iv4 #c4ab-ah4 #dff #b4i4aj4 #dfg #a4d4h1 #af4 #dfh #a4g4c4 #dfi ,porphyry1 ,biography #b4 #dgj ,cave ( ! ,nymphs1 #ed4 #dga ,plato1 p4 #adg4 #dgb ,rep4 iv4 #i4 #dgc ,plut4 ,def4 ,or4 #ag4 #dgd ,to hegemonikon4 ,enn4 ii4 #d4b4 #dge ii4 #e4c4 #dgf ii4 #e4e4 #dgg vi4 #c4g4 #dgh ,9 i4 #h4c4 #dgi ,9 i4 #h4aj4 #dhj #c4f1 #ad4 #dha #a4h1 #ac4 #dhb #b4i4b4 #dhc ,num4 #bf4 #dhd ,enn4 iii4 #f4f1 #g4 #dhe de ,mund4 iv4 #ba4 #dhf ,*aignet1 ,h4 ,ps4 d4 ,g41 v4 #ach4 #dhg ,proclus1 9 ,p>m4 vi4 #bg4 #dhh ,en]geia & dynamis4 #dhi #e4a4g1 #ai4 #dij iii4 #e4c4 #dia ,ib4 #d4g4 #dib ,ib4 #i4 #dic v4 #c4e4 #did i4 #d4ad4 #die iii4 #e4f4 #dif #a4a4h4 #dig i4 #h4b4 #dih ,9 i4 #d4aj4 #dii ,9 ii4 #i4a4 #ejj iii4 #c4d4 #eja iii4 #b4aa4 #ejb i4 #d4i4 #ejc ,h4 ,ps4 d4 ,gr4 iv4 #bdd4 #ejd ,enn4 vi4 #d4i4 #eje ,*aignet1 ib41 iv4 #ccg2 ,enn4 v4 #a4g1 #aj4 #ejf ii4 #i4a1 #b4 #ejg ,see ,mc,clintock & ,/rong1 ,b4 ,t4 ,e4 ,encyclop$ia1 s4 v4 #ejh ,enn4 vi1 #e4g4 #eji vi4 #b4h1 #i4 #eaj ,see iv4 #d4bf2 vi4 #g4ab1 #ac4 #eaa ,see i4 #h4d4 #eab ,see iv4 #b4ae4 #eac ,see iv4 #c4i4 #ead ,see vi4 #d4ad2 vi4 #e4f2 i4 #a4i4 #eae ,rom4 vii4 #g4be4 #eaf ,see v4 #a4aj4 #eag ,see iv4 #h4e1 #f1 & iv4 #g4ac1 #ad1 & iii4 #f4ad4 #eah ,see i4 #h4ac #eai iv4 #c4aa4 #ebj vi4 #a4aj4 #eba ii4 #a4d4 #ebb v4 #a4a1 v4 #d4b1 v4 #h4aa1 i4 #d4aa1 v4 #a4g1 vi4 #h4d1 iv4 #h4d4 #ebc i4 #a4i & #ab4 #ebd x4 #b1 ,enn4 ii4 #i4ac4 #ebe ,biography1 #af4 #ebf ,see v4 #h4h4 #ebg ,see viii4 #e4ab4 #ebh ,see vi4 #h4i4 #ebi ,see vi4 #g4ag4 #ecj ,see v4 #e4c4 #eca ,rev4 iv4 #f2 see iii4 #b4aa4 #ecb ,see ii4 #i4e2 ,rev4 xxi4 #a4 #ecc ,see iii4 #b4ae4 #ecd ,see v4 #c4h4 #ece ,see i4 #h4f4 #ecf ,see iv4 #c4f2 ,jno4 xiv4 #b4 #ecg ,see iii4 #b4d1 & ,rom4 iii4 #bj4 #ech ,see vi4 #h4ae1 & ,rom4 viii4 #ci4 #eci ,see v4 #e4aa1 & #a ,cor4 xi4 #bb4 #edj ,see ii4 #a4d1 & #b ,cor4 xii4 #b4 #eda ,see vi4 #b1 & ,gal4 iv4 #i4 #edb ,see ii4 #i4f1 & i4 ,tim4 #a4d4 #edc ,see ii4 #i4ad1 & ,m>k vi4 #g4 #edd ,see v4 #c4ag1 & ,mk4 ix4 #dc1 #de4 #ede ,see v4 #i4e1 & ,mt4 xxiv4 #ac4 #edf ,see vi4 #i4i2 vi4 #e4ab1 & ,acts xvii4 #bh4 #edg ,see v4 #h4ab1 & ,heb4 ii4 #aa-ag #edh ,see vi4 #g4bi1 & ,jas4 i4 #ag4 #edi ,luke xi4 #ac4 #eej ,see i4 #f4i2 ii4 #d4e4 #eea v4 #e4ac4 #eeb ii4 #i4d4 #eec iv4 #c4aa4 #eed ii4 #i4e4 #eee iv4 #h4i4 #eef v4 #i4d4 #eeg ,see iii4 #h4d2 iv4 #b4a2 vi4 #g4h4 #eeh ,see ii4 #d4e2 v4 #g4c2 vi4 #h4bj4 #eei ,see vi4 #f4aa4 #efj ,see vi4 #h4bj4 #efa ,see iv4 #c4ag2 vi4 #d4i4 #efb ,see v4 #c4ae4 #efc ,see vi4 #g4a4 #efd ,see v4 #b4a4 #efe ,see v4 #a4f4 #eff ,see i4 #d4i4 #efg ,see iii4 #h4c4 #efh ,see vi4 #b4h1 #i4 #efi ,see iii4 #h4aj2 ii4 #i4b4 #egj ,see iv4 #g4aj2 v4 #a4d2 vi4 #g4b4 #ega ,see ii4 #i4b4 #egb ,see vi4 #e4g4 #egc iii4 #f4f to end4 #egd ,n4 #bj4f4 #ege ii4 #i4aj4 #egf i4 #h4d2 ii4 #i4b1 #aj2 vi4 #g4e1 ) ,n4 #bf4c4 #egg ii4 #i4f1 ) ,n4 #cf4 #egh iv4 #c4ag1 ) ,n4 #bf4c4 #egi v4 #c4i2 v4 #e4g2 vi4 #e4e4 #ehj ii4 #i4a2 b see ii4 #i4h2 iv4 #h4c1 etc4 #eha iv4 #c4ag4 #ehb #df-ed4 #ehc #di1 #ej2 or1 #bb4 #ehd #df-dh1 #ea-ed2 or1 #hh4 #ehe #bb-cc1 #ab books4 #ehf #bc1 #bf1 #bg1 #ca1 #cb1 #cc2 or1 #ej4 #ehg #bb1 #bd1 #be1 #bh1 #bi1 #cj2 or1 #ej4 #ehh #cc-de1 #ab books4 #ehi #cd1 #cg1 #ch1 #ci1 #dc1 #dd4 #eij #ce1 #cf1 #dj1 #da1 #db1 #de4 #eia v4 #a4i4 #eib v4 #e4f2 ,n4 #db1 #fg4 #eic v4 #d4b & ,n4 #ae-ag4 #eid v4 #h4e2 v4 #i4c2 vi4 #f4i2 & ,n4 #bj4 #eie i4 #h4f2 i4 #d4aa2 iii4 #c4g2 & ,n4 #af1 #ag4 #eif vi4 #h4ai2 & ,n4 #aj2 #cb4 #eig v4 #a4f2 ) ,n4 #ad4 #eih v4 #a4i2 ) ,n4 #cf1 #ci4 #eii vi4 #d4af2 iv4 #c4aa4 #fjj ,n4 #ed4 #fja ,n4 #di;a4 #fjb vi4 #e4i2 & ,n4 #df4 #fjc iii4 #f4 #fjd ,n4 #dd4 #fje ii4 #g4b2 vi4 #a4bi2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fjf ,9 mean+ at lea/4 #fjg iv4 #g4b1 #c2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fjh iv4 #g4b1 #c2 v4 #i4c2 ,n4 #dj4 #fji ,philebus1 9 iv4 #c4a4 #faj vi4 #b4ba4 #faa i4 #b4f2 v4 #c4ag2 iii4 #d4 #fab vi4 #c4af4 #fac i4 #f4f4 #fad ,n4 #ca4bb2 #cc4h4 #fae iv4 #h4b2 i4 #h4b2 v4 #e4c2 vi4 #g4db2 & ,n4 #bg;a4 #h4 #faf v4 #a4d1 & ,n4 #ai4 #fag v4 #h4c2 ii4 #i4c1 #h4 #fah i4 #h4f & ,n4 #aj4 #fai vi4 #b4b & ,n4 #ad4 #fbj vi4 #e4f & ,n4 #db1 #fg4 #fba v4 #h4c2 iii4 #d4b2 ,n4 #bg;a4 #h4 #fbb iii4 #h4h2 iv4 #c4a1 #h2 vi4 #h4g2 & ,n4 #bg;b4 #i4 #fbc ,/ill1 see #cj4 #fbd iv4 #h4b2 vi4 #i4i2 ,n4 #bi4 #fbe iii4 #b4d2 v4 #a4f2 v4 #e4g2 & ,n4 #bi4ah4 #fbf i4 #h4d2 ii4 #i4b1 #aj2 vi4 #g4e & ,n4 #bf4c2 #bg;a4 #aj4 #fbg vi4 #e4f2 & ,n4 #cg1 #fc4 #fbh iv4 #g4a2 vi4 #e4aj2 & ,n4 #ab4h4 #fbi vi4 #d4aj2 vi4 #e4c2 ii4 #i4g2 ) ,n4 #ab1 #bb4 #fcj v4 #h4ac2 & ,n4 #bf4c4 #fca iii4 #b4b2 ) ,n4 #af1 #ag4 #fcb iii4 #a4bb2 iv4 #b4a1 #b2 iv4 #g4b2 & ,n4 #ch4 #fcc ii4 #i4g2 v4 #f4f2 vi4 #e4c2 & ,n4 #ab1 #ae1 #bb1 #bf4c4 #fcd iv4 #c4h2 vi4 #g4c2 & ,n4 #dh4 #fce iv4 #c4aa2 ) ,n4 #cb4 #fcf iv4 #c4ag1 #ba2 ) ,n4 #cb4 #fcg iv4 #c4ag2 ) ,n4 #bf4c4 #fch iv4 #g2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fci ,n4 #ee4 #fdj ii4 #g4b2 vi4 #a4bi2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fda iv4 #g4c2 vi4 #c4af2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fdb ii4 #c4i2 iii4 #d4f2 & ,n4 #df1 #eb1 #ef4 #fdc ,/ill1 see i4 #a4i2 iv4 #c4ca2 vi4 #d4ae2 & ,n4 #ec4 #fdd i4 #a4ab2 ii4 #c4i2 ii4 #i4b2 iv4 #c4ca2 iv4 #b4b2 & ,n4 #ec4 #fde iv4 #c4ca2 ) ,n4 #cb4 #fdf ,n4 #eb4 #fdg i4 #a4aj2 iv4 #g4h2 v4 #h4c4 #fdh iii4 #d4d2 & ,n4 #ae4 #fdi ,n4 #ae4 #fej ii4 #i4e4 #fea i4 #c4a4 #feb i4 #c4b4 #fec i4 #c4c4 #fed v4 #i4a4 #fee iv4 #d4aj2 ) ,n4 #ab4 #fef iv4 #c4be2 ) ,n4 #be4 #feg ii4 #i4aa2 i4 #f4g2 vi4 #g4cd2 vi4 #i4aa2 ) ,n4 #aj4 #feh iv4 #h4h2 & ,n4 #ea4 #fei iv4 #h4a2 & ,n4 #fb;a4 #ffj iv4 #h4a2 quot+ ,emp$ocles2 ,n4 #dc4 #ffa iv4 #b4b2 & ,n4 #bg;b4 #ffb iv4 #c4ba2 & ,n4 #cb1 #cf1 #af4 #ffc ,n4 #bf4 #ffd iv4 #c4ag4 #ffe ii4 #c4h2 iii4 #c4d2 ,n4 #cf1 #ec4 #fff ii4 #i4f4 #ffg v4 #i4e2 & ,n4 #bh4 #ffh iv4 #g4ad2 & ,n4 #ee1 #ef4 #ffi #fa1 #fb;a4 #fgj ii4 #i4ad4 #fga #aj4 #fgb iii4 #f4f to end4 #fgc #ad1 #ae1 #af1 #ag1 #dd4 #fgd vi4 #a1 & passim4 #fge ii4 #c4af2 ii4 #d4af2 ii4 #e4b2 & ,n4 #ee4 #fgf i4 #h4ae2 i4 #a4i2 i4 #d4aj2 iv4 #c4c1 #cj4ca2 vi4 #h4c2 iv4 #g4h2 & ,n4 #b1 #c1 #d4g & #bd4 #fgg vi4 #e4f2 & ,n4 #db1 #fg4 #fgh ,all ( ii4 #f2 iii4 #f4f2 iii4 #g4e2 iii4 #h4i2 iv4 #c4i2 iv4 #c4bd2 v4 #c4f1 #ae1 #ag2 v4 #d4a1 #b2 v4 #e4aj1 #ac1 #ee2 v4 #h4e1 #f2 v4 #i4c2 vi4 #b4b1 #e1 #f1 #h1 #i1 #ac2 vi4 #c4f1 #af2 vi4 #f4aj1 #ac1 #af2 vi4 #g4da2 vi4 #i4b1 #c4 #fgi v4 #i4c2 & ,n4 #ba1 #bb4 #fhj v4 #d4b2 & ,n4 #aj2 vi4 #f4i2 & ,n4 #cd4 #fha vi4 #f4i2 ,n4 #aj1 #ba4 #fhb v4 #a4e2 vi4 #e4i2 vi4 #f4af2 & ,n4 #df4 #fhc vi4 #f4af2 & ,n4 #fj4 #fhd vi4 #b4i2 & ,n4 #bf4 #fhe vi4 #d4b4 #fhf ii4 #d4e2 iv4 #h4g2 v4 #e4d2 & ,n4 #cf;b4 #fhg iv4 #c4a2 v4 #d4b2 & ,n4 #cf;c8 #fhh ii4 #e4c2 & ,n4 #ad1 #af1 #bf4 #fhi v4 #d4b2 v4 #e4d2 & ,n4 #ad4 #fij ii4 #i4a2 & ,n4 #be4 #fia iii4 #h4i2 iii4 #i4a2 v4 #a4h2 & ,n4 #cf1 #ci4 #fib v4 #e4c2 & ,n4 #cf1 #ci4 #fic i4 #c4d2 & ,n4 #aj1 #ac4 #fid ii4 #d4i2 ii4 #g4b2 vi4 #a4bi2 vi4 #c4af2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fie iv4 #i4d2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fif iii4 #d4a2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fig iv4 #f4g2 & ,n4 #dd4 #fih iv4 #c4bj2 & ,n4 #ab1 #dd4 #fii ,n4 #bj4 #gjj ,n4 #ba4 #gja iii4 #g4c1 #e2 & ,n4 #ai4 #gjb ,n4 #ee1 #ef2 #eg4 #gjc iii4 #d4b2 & ,n4 #eg4 #gjd i4 #h4b2 iii4 #b4af2 iv4 #g4ad2 vi4 #f4af2 vi4 #g4f2 & ,n4 #cb4 #gje v4 #a4a2 & ,n4 #ag1 #bf4 #gjf vi4 #e4c2 vi4 #g4ca2 & ,n4 #aa1 #ae1 #af1 #ag1 #ab4g1 #bb1 #bf4 #gjg i4 #h4c2 v4 #e4ac2 & ,n4 #ae1 #af1 #di;b4 #gjh i4 #d4aa2 i4 #h4f1 #g2 ii4 #c4ah2 iii4 #b4e1 #ae2 iii4 #h4i2 & ,n4 #af1 #ag1 #ah4 #gji i4 #h4g2 iii4 #b4b1 ,n4 #ae1 #ag4 ,alex&] ( ,aphrodisia taught ?is _w 0 a mixture2 ii4 #g4a2 iv4 #g4ac4 #gaj iv4 #i4d2 v4 #af2 & ,n4 #bf4 #gaa ,plot9os passim2 ,n4 #be4 #gab vi4 #a4bc2 & ,n4 #ah4 ,also vi4 #i4aj1 #aa4 #gac ,passim2 ,n4 #aj1 #cg1 #fc4 #gad v4 #h4a2 & ,n4 #dc4 #gae iii4 #i4c2 & ,n4 #ca4 #gaf vi4 #b4g2 vi4 #c4bg2 & ,n4 #ai4d1 #bj2 #bg;a2 #cj4 #gag iii4 #g4c2 iv4 #d4cc2 & ,n4 #cj4 #gah ii4 #d4b-e2 ii4 #e4c2 v4 #d4b2 & ,n4 #bf4 #gai ii4 #d4ab2 etc4 #gbj ii4 #d4f2 & ,n4 #aa1 #ah4 #gba ii4 #f4b2 & ,n4 #ab4h2 #ah4 #gbb ii4 #d4aj2 & ,n4 #ab1 #af1 #ag4 #gbc v4 #a4f2 vi4 #i4aj1 #aa2 & ,n4 #aj4 #gbd vi4 #d4b2 vi4 #i4c2 & ,n4 #aj4 #gbe iv4 #g4c2 & ,n4 #ac1 #bg1 #dd4 #gbf iv4 #d4af2 & ,n4 #df4 #gbg ,might x mean an angle1 & "o ( its sides8 #gbh iii4 #d4b2 & ,n4 #bg4 #gbi iv4 #h4e1 #f2 & ,n4 #bg;b4 #gcj v4 #i4f2 & ,n4 #bc4 #gca v4 #a4e4 #gcb vi4 #g4ag1 #cf2 vi4 #i4i2 & ,n4 #bi4 #gcc iii4 #d4b2 iv4 #c4aa2 v4 #h4c2 v4 #a4b2 & ,n4 #bg;b4 #gcd iii4 #d4f2 & ,n4 #ce;a4 #gce vi4 #g4a2 & ,n4 #bg;a1 b4 #gcf ,creation or adornm5t1 ii4 #d4d1 #f2 iv4 #c4ad2 & ,n4 #ad1 #ah4 #gcg i4 #a4c2 iv4 #c4ag1 #ba2 & ,n #cb4 #gch ,b\illet ii4 #ebj4 #gci ib4 ii4 #ehd4 #gdj ib4 ii4 #fjg4 #gda ib4 ii4 #eig4 #gdb ib4 ii4 #efa4 #gdc ,b4 iii4 #fch-fej4 #gdd ib4 #fea-fec4 #gde ib4 #fed-fef4 #gdf ,b\illet ii4 #ebj4 #gdg ib4 ii4 #efb4 #gdh ib4 ii4 #ehe4 #gdi ib4 ii4 #ehh4 #gej ,biog4 #h1 #ac4 #gea ,biog4 #ag1 #ah4 #geb ,biog4 #bd4 #gec iii4 #g4a1 #d4 #ged v4 #h4d4 #gee v4 #h4e1 #f4 #gef iii4 #e4h4 #geg vi4 #c4h4 #geh i4 #h4g2 ii4 #d4d2 iii4 #h4aa2 iv4 #h4ac2 v4 #i4h4 #d4d2 iii4 #h4aa2 v4 #h4ac2 v4 #i4h4 #a4aa4 #gfb v4 #e4e4 #gfc vi4 #a4bc4 #gfd ii4 #i4d4 #gfe v4 #e4a4 #gff iii4 #e4c4 #gfg v4 #e4e4 #gfh v4 #c4e1 #f4 #gfi vi4 #a4ae4 #ggj iii4 #e4i1 #aj4 #gga iv4 #c4ad4 #ggb iv4 #g4d2 ii4 #f4b2 iii4 #b4ag4 #ggc iv4 #d4bi4 #ggd v4 #i4e4 #gge iv4 #i4c4 #ggf vi4 #a4ah4 #ggg vi4 #h4ah4 ,,concordance ,,to ,,plot9os4 ,( ! two numb]s 9 ! p>5!sis1 ! fir/ is ! *ronological book numb]1 ! second is ! ref]5ce's page 9 ?is translation4 ,a ,ab&onm5t by ,provid5ce1 ev5 ( ! m$iocre1 impossible1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajeh74 ,ability or desire is ! limit ( man's union ) ! div9ity1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,absolute ,beauty is a =mless %ape1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,absolute ,evil is ! goal ( ! deg5]ate s\l1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafc74 ,absolute ,exi/5t is prec$$ by cont+5t1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hha74 ,ab/raction is me?od ( rea*+ div9ity1 vi4 #h4ba 7#ci-haa74 ,ab/raction ( qualities ends 9 ?+-9-itself1 ii4 #d4aj 7#ab-bjg74 ,ab/raction ( ! =m produces ?\ght ( inf9ite1 vi4 #f4c 7#cd-fdf74 ,abundance & ,ne$1 my? (1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cge74 ,abundance 7,poros71 my? (1 iii4 #e4b-aj 7#ej-aabe to #aadj74 ,academy1 vi4 #a4ad1 #cj 7#db-hfc1 #hhh74 ,accid5ts are receiv$ by ! s\l f matt]1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aag74 ,accid5ts1 is ! fif? physical category ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,accompli%m5ts are only tempor>y crut*es = developm5t1 i4 #d4af 7#df-ajdj74 ,accretion1 =eign1 is ! nature ( ugl9ess1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dh74 ,accretions to s\l1 & body1 are remov$ f s\l by philosophic sep>ation1 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjd74 ,action & exp]i5ce does n include pr$iction ) its responsiv5ess1 & is und]lay$ by transmission1 reception1 & relation1 vi4 #a4bb 7#db-hgd74 ,action & exp]i5c+1 ,ari/otelian category1 vi4 #a4ae 7#db-hfc74 ,action & passion iii4 #c4b 7#dh-ajgh74 ,action & reaction =m b a s+le g5us1 vi4 #a4ai 7#db-hgj74 ,action & suff]+ _c be sep>ate categories1 b are subsum$ "u movem5t1 vi4 #a4ag 7#db-hff74 ,action does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4af 7#dc-ibj74 ,action is natural on bo? :oles & p>ts1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhg74 ,action1 uni=m1 is ex]t$ by body & v>i$ by ! s\l1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fb74 ,actions1 "s appe> imp]fect :5 n jo9$ to "t1 vi4 #a4ai 7#db-hfh74 ,actions d n control fre$om ( w & virtue1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-ggi74 ,active life pr$isposes to subjection to en*antm5ts1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,activity ( s\l is triple3 ?\ght1 self-pres]vation & creation1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abe74 ,actors good & bad1 are rew>d$ by ! manag]3 s are s\ls1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajgb74 ,actual1 ev]y?+ is actual 9 ! intelligible _w1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cdf74 ,actual matt] _c be any?+1 z x is non-be+1 ii4 #e4b1 #d 7#be-cdc to #cdg74 ,actuality & pot5tiality1 iii4 #i4h 7#ac-bbe74 ,actuality & pot5tiality are inapplicable to ! div9ity1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fjj74 ,actualization1 cont9u\s1 con/itutes ,intellig5ce1 iv4 #g4ac 7#ah71 7#b-hd72 iv4 #h4f1 #g 7#f-abi1 #acj74 ,actualization is a f> bett] category ?an do+ or act+1 vi4 #a4ae 7#db-hfc74 ,actualization is prior to pot5tiality 7devolution71 iv4 #g4h 7#aa71 7#b-gd74 ,actualization ( s\l 9 life1 is ! sole use ( its exi/5ce1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,actualization1 s+le & simple1 iv4 #g4ab 7#ag71 7#b-hc74 ,actualization :5 appe>+ is h>moniz$ to its sem9al reason1 vi4 #c4af 7#dd-ifj74 ,actualizations are none ( bodies t ent] into a mixture1 iv4 #g4h 7#aj71 7#b-gb74 ,actualizations are ! condition ( ,intellig5ce1 because its ?\ght is id5tical ) its ess5ce1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,actualizations1 p]man5t1 =m ! hypo/asis1 v4 #c4ab 7#di-aaaa74 ,actualizations1 relative1 are s5sations1 n exp]i5ces1 iv4 #f4b 7#da-hca74 ,acut5ess may de/roy excessive ec/atic vision1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,adm9i/ration by ,jupit] does n imply memory1 iv4 #d4i 7#bh-dec74 ,admiration ( 8 h&iwork1 by ! ,creator1 ref]s to ! _w-model1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,admiration ( ! _w1 by ,plato1 supplem5ts 8 hatr$ ( ! body1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcc74 ,adra/ea1 law (1 is ju/ice1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagc72 iii4 #b4d1 #ac 7#dg-ajdi to #ajfb74 ,adult]ies n produc$ by planet-positions1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,adumbrations ( sup]ior pr9ciples1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,advantages result+ f ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,aeon ,jesus1 is unacc\ntable1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fja74 ,aeon1 see et]nity1 ?r\gh\t1 iii4 #g4a sqq 7#de-ihe74 ,ae/hetic s5se appreciates beauty1 i4 #f4b 7#a-db74 ,affection & weaknesses ( man subject him to magic1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-ejh74 ,affection ( matt]1 def9ition ( s\l2 if su*1 :5ce is %e8 iv4 #g4c4;d 7#b-ei74 ,affections are common to s\l & body2 n all are su*1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaig74 ,affections caus$ by incorporeal's affective "p1 iii4 #f4d 7#bf-ceg74 ,affections1 d]ivation ( qualities f !m is ( no importance1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-heg74 ,affections ( s\l1 l a musician play+ a lyre1 iii4 #f4d 7#bf-ceh74 ,affections produc$ by t5sion 9 lyre-/r+s1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-ge74 ,age1 pun on aeons1 iii4 #g4d 7#de-iib74 ,aggregate1 composite1 see comb9ation1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,aggregate individual1 =m$ by unit+ ( s\l & body1 i4 #a4f 7#ec-aaig74 ,aggregate ( molecules c\ld n possess life & intellig5ce1 iv4 #g4b1 #c 7#b-eg74 ,agriculture1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aad74 ,aid to magnitude-p]ception1 is color-diff]5ce1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fha74 ,air & fire1 action (1 n ne$$ by ,heav51 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbf74 ,air conta9$ 9 intelligible _w1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gbj74 ,air n necess>y1 ev5 = he>+1 iv4 #e4e 7#bi-ebc74 ,air1 relation to light1 iv4 #e4f 7#bi-ebd74 ,air1 useless z transmitt+ m$ium1 iv4 #e4c 7#bi-eai74 ,alex&] ( ,aphrodisia's !ory ( mixture1 iv4 #g4b1 #h 7#b-eh1 #gb72 iii4 #a4g 7#c-if74 ,ali5ation1 v4 #a4aj 7#aj-aij74 ,all 9 all1 iii4 #h4h 7#cj-edc72 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djb74 ,all is intellig5ce1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gbi74 ,all ?+s are unit$ by a common s\rce1 vi4 #g4ab 7#ch-gba74 ,all ?+s1 h[ ! same pr9ciple c exi/ 9 !m1 vi4 #d4f 7#bb-bie74 ,all ?+s1 is ! s\l1 iii4 #d4c 7#ae-bcf74 ,all ?+s1 transc5d$ by _! pr9ciple1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,alone ) ! alone1 i4 #f4g 7#a-ej72 vi4 #g4cd 7#ch-geg72 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agb74 ,alon5ess ( ,supreme1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb74 ,alt]ation1 def9ition (1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-igc74 ,alt]ation1 n con/itut$ by composition & decomposition1 vi4 #c4be 7#dd-igh74 ,alt]ation ( s\l1 ,/oic conception1 oppos$1 iii4 #f4c 7#bf-cee74 ,alt]nate liv+ 9 ,intellig5ce & _w1 by s\l1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abf74 ,alt]nate ris+ & fall+ ( s\l :5 9 body1 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,amphibians1 s\ls are1 iv4 #h4dh 7#f-abf74 ,analogy expla9s pr$iction1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhf74 ,analogy only all[s u to attribute physical qualities to ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4h 7#ci-ghe74 ,analysis1 cont+5cy is elim9at$ 91 vi4 #h4ad 7#ci-gih74 ,analyze1 object ( my?s1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aach74 ,ang] localiz$ 9 ! he>t1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbf72 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dha74 ,ang]-"p ( e>?1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhb74 ,ang]-"p ( s\l expla9$1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,ang]-p[]1 does n orig9ate 9 body1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dha74 ,ang]-trace ( ! s\l1 orig9ates 9 gr[? & g5]ative p[]1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dha74 ,animal1 exi/+ is intellig5ce 7,plato7 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bbj74 ,animal nature =m$ by light ( s\l1 i4 #a-g 7#ec-aaih74 ,animal nature1 h[ x is g5]at$1 i4 #a4ab17ec-abje74 ,animal1 relation (1 to human nature1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,animal1 ! liv+1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaif74 ,animal1 :at is x1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,animals1 all are born f ess5ce1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibi74 ,animals1 are !y happy8 i4 #d4a 7#df-ajai74 ,animals1 di/9ction to ! :ole1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,animals1 d !y possess "r to liv+ well1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbj74 ,animals1 f\r k9ds1 se5 9 intellig5ce1 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bba74 ,animals1 individual & univ]sal1 exi/ lat] ?an numb]1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-ffh74 ,animals1 irrational1 mu/ exi/ )9 intellig5ce1 vi4 #g4h 7#ch-gac74 ,animals1 l[] nature (1 ridicul\s to compla9 (1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajei74 ,animals1 _m are n s irrational z diff]5t1 vi4 #g4i 7#ch-gad74 ,animals1 _! animat+ pr9ciple1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjd74 ,animat$1 univ]se 0 always1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-djd74 ,animat+ pr9ciple ( animals1 i4 #a4aa 7#ec-abjd74 ,answ]s1 h[ !y come to pray]s1 iv4 #d4da 7#bh-eje74 ,ante*amb] ( good is intellig5ce1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajd74 ,ant]ior ?+s c be only 9 l[] pr9ciples1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,ant]iority 9 intelligible1 is ord] n "t1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddc74 ,anxiety abs5t f rule ( _w by s\l1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abb74 ,aphrodite1 see ,v5us1 pun on1 iii4 #e4h 7#ej-aacg74 ,apollo1 "n ( ,supreme1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,apo/asy ( s\l f ,god1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc74 ,appe>ance1 by x only does matt] p>ticipate 9 ! intelligible1 iii4 #f4aa 7#bf-cfi74 ,appe>ance1 magnitude is only1 iii4 #f4ah 7#bf-cha74 ,appe>ance1 makes up unreal s5se objects1 iii4 #f4ab 7#bf-cga74 ,appe>ance ( intellig5ce 9 ! intelligible1 v4 #c4h 7#di-aajb74 ,app]ception-unity1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,appetite is ! actualization ( lu/ful desire1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,appetite keeps an affection1 n memory1 iv4 #c4bh 7#bg-dce74 ,appetite locat$ 9 comb9ation ( body & s\l1 iv4 #d4bj 7#bh-dfh74 ,appetite n simultane\s ) desire1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaig74 ,appetite notic$ only :5 p]ceiv$ by reason or int]ior s5se1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,appetite1 :5 sway+ s\l1 leaves x passive1 iii4 #a4i 7#c-ih74 ,apportionm5t ( _s1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,appreciation ( self1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agd74 ,approa*1 h[ ! body approa*es ! s\l1 vi4 #d4ae 7#bb-cji74 ,approa* impossible 9 connection ) non-spatial intelligible light1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehg74 ,approa* ( s\l to good1 by simplification1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,approa* to ,supreme is suffici5t talk ( ,him1 v4 #c4ad 7#di-aaad74 ,approa* to ! ,fir/1 mann] (1 v4 #e4aj 7#cb-eia74 ,approa* to ! s\l1 :i* is l[e/ div9e1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahf74 ,approa*+ ( s\l's rejection ( =m1 proves =mlessness ( ! ,supreme1 vi4 #g4cd 7#ch-gef74 ,ar*etype ( ! _w1 ! intelligible is1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agh74 ,ar*etype1 univ]sal1 conta9$ by intellig5ce1 v4 #i4i 7#e-aab74 ,ar*etypes1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cbb74 ,ari/otelian category ( ,:58 vi4 #a4ac 7#db-hfj74 ,ari/otelian di/9ction1 actuality & pot5tiality1 ii4 #e4a 7#be-cda74 ,ari/otle 0 wrong 9 consid]+ r\gh1 r>e & d5se qualities1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-heg74 ,art intelligible1 creates ! arti/ & lat] nature1 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eeb74 ,art makes a /atue out ( r\gh m>ble1 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eeb74 ,artificial movem5ts1 vi4 #c4bf 7#dd-ihj74 ,arti/ ( ! univ]se is ! s\l1 iv4 #g4ac 7#b-hd74 ,arts1 auxili>y1 :i* help ! progress ( nature1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aae74 ,arts1 dep5d5t on ! s\l1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aah74 ,arts1 mo/ a*ieve _! own ends1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhh74 ,arts1 "s1 m]ely e>?ly1 o!rs m intelligible1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aad74 ,asc5d$ s\l1 n ev51 ne$ be divid$1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,asc5sion ( sign1 absurd1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,asc5sion ( s\l 9 ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,asc5sion to ,div9ity1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-gi74 ,asc5sion t[>ds div9ity1 process ( life1 i4 #f4g 7#a-ej74 ,asc5t _c /op ) ! s\l1 :y8 v4 #i4d 7#e-ajf74 ,asc5t ( life witness$ to disappe>ance ( cont+5cy1 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hja74 ,asc5t ( ! s\l psy*ologically expla9$1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-caj74 ,aspects & h\ses1 absurdity1 ii4 #c4d 7#eb-aafh74 ,assimilation dep5ds on tak+ a sup]ior model1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,assimilation ( matt]1 n complete 9 e>?ly defects1 v4 #i4ab 7#e-aae74 ,assimilation to div9e1 key ( vision to ec/asy1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,assimilation to div9ity1 is flight f _w1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfc74 ,assimilation to div9ity1 is s\l's welf>e & beauty4 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,assimilation to div9ity results only 9 high] virtues1 i4 #b4a 7#ai-bef74 ,assimilation to ,supreme1 by homely virtues1 indirectly1 i4 #b4c 7#ai-bfj74 ,a/rolog]s make cosmic d$uctions f progno/ication1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hi74 ,a/rological influ5ce is m]ely an indication1 iv4 #d4cd 7#bh-did74 ,a/rological influ5ce1 p>tly action1 p>tly significance1 iv4 #d4cd 7#bh-die74 ,a/rological p[] n due to physical s\l1 iv4 #d4ch 7#bh-eja74 ,a/rological sy/em ( fate1 iii4 #a4e 7#c-ib74 ,a/rological !ories absurd1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,a/rological views ( ,v5us1 ,jupit] & ,m]cury1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aafi74 ,a/rologically1 div9e w\ld be blam$ = unju/ acts1 iii4 #b4aj 7#dg-ajei74 ,a/rology confut$1 leaves influ5ce ( _w-s\l1 iv4 #d4cb 7#bh-dij74 ,a/rology replac$ by natural production ( s\ls1 iv4 #d4ch 7#bh-eja74 ,a/rology replac$ by radiation ( good & *>act]i/ic figures1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-dih74 ,a/rology reveals teleology1 ii #c4g 7#eb-aagb74 ,a/rology1 signs only concat5ations f univ]sal reason1 iv4 #d4c 7#bh-ejb74 ,a/rology1 tru? (1 judgem5t ( "o "p by ano!r1 ii4 #c4g 7#eb-aagc74 ,a!ns1 vi4 #a4ad 7#db-hfc74 ,atomism1 does n dem& a m$ium = vision1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eaf74 ,atoms1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,atoms d n expla9 matt]1 ii4 #d4g 7#ab-bjd74 ,atropos1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,atta*m5t to c5tre con/itutes div9ity1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afc74 ,att5tion1 condition ( p]ception1 v4 #a4ab 7#aj-aia74 ,attract+ all ?+s1 does ! p[] & beauty ( ess5ce1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgh74 ,attribute1 f\r? physical category ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,attribut+ qualities to good1 w\ld degrade x1 v4 #e4ac 7#cb-eie74 ,audacity n 9 high] s\l1 see boldness1 i4 #a4b 7#ec-aaib74 ,audacity ! cause ( human apo/asy1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc72 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aie74 ,au?or ( ?is p]fection mu/ be above x1 vi4 #g4cb 7#ch-geb74 ,autocracy ( div9ity1 vi4 #h4ba 7#ci-haj74 ,av]sion = ugl9ess1 expla9s love ( beauty1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dg74 ,avoid magic en*antm5ts1 h[ to1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eaj74 ,avoidance ( passions1 is task ( philosophy1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-ceh74 ,bac*us1 mirror (1 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-dji74 ,ballet1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afe72 vi4 #b4aa 7#dc-iab74 ,ballet danc]1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,ba/>d1 reason goes beyond corporeity1 ii4 #d4ab 7#ab-bab74 ,ba/>d reason+1 is ab/raction rea*+ ?+ 9 itself1 ii4 #d4aj1 #ab 7#ab-bjg1 #bab72 i4 #h4i1 #aj 7#ea-aaef72 vi4 #h4h 7#ci-ghf74 ,ba?-tub1 simile (1 vi #i4h 7#i-afc74 ,beauties1 moral1 m delightful ?an s5se-beauties1 i4 #f4d 7#a-df74 ,beautification1 by desc5t ^u object ( reason f div9e1 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,beautiful1 inf]ior to good1 v4 #e4ab 7#cb-eic74 ,beautiful1 mo/ ?+s1 su* only by p>ticipation1 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,beautiful1 no?+ m c\ld be imag9$ ?an ! _w1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fjf74 ,beautiful1 ! ,supreme1 ( ?ree ranks ( exi/5ce1 vi4 #g4db 7#ch-ggj74 ,beautiful1 :at is its pr9ciple1 i4 #f4a 7#a-da74 ,beauty1 v4 #a4aa 7#aj-ahi74 ,beauty absolute1 is a =mless %ape1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,beauty & good1 id5tical1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ea74 ,beauty & p[] ( ess5ce attracts all ?+s1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgh74 ,beauty appreciat$ by an ae/hetic s5se1 i4 #f4c 7#a-dc74 ,beauty belongs to m51 :5 !y belong to & "k !mselves1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egd74 ,beauty classifi$ along ) ! relatives1 vi4 #c4aa 7#dd-ieb74 ,beauty comes f =m imp>t$ by orig9ator1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eec74 ,beauty consi/s 9 k9%ip to ! s\l1 i4 #f4b 7#a-db74 ,beauty consi/s 9 p>ticipation 9 a =m1 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,beauty does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4ag 7#dc-ibj74 ,beauty does n possess ext5sion1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,beauty1 emotions (1 caus$ by inv9cible s\l1 i4 #f4e 7#a-df74 ,beauty ess5tial is ,supreme1 ! %apeless %ap]1 & ! transc5d5t1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,beauty ext]nal1 appreciation (1 dep5ds on cognition ( int]ior beauty1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eed74 ,beauty ext]nal1 p>tial1 does n m> beauty ( univ]se1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcd74 ,beauty1 highe/ conceivable1 is ! model1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,beauty1 if x is a g5us1 mu/ be "o ( ! po/]ior ones1 vi4 #b4ah 7#dc-ibc74 ,beauty inf]ior to good1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ed74 ,beauty 9 la/ analysis is intelligible1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eee74 ,beauty 9 no?+ if n 9 ,god v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,beauty intelligible1 v4 #h 7#ca74 ,beauty intelligible1 does n %9e m]ely on surface1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,beauty int]ior1 c\ld n be appreciat$1 )\t int]ior model1 i4 #f4d 7#a-de74 ,beauty is creat+ pr9ciple ( prim>y reason1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eee74 ,beauty is immortal1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabd74 ,beauty is inh]5t wisdom1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eed74 ,beauty is symmetry1 acc4 to ,/oics1 oppos$1 i4 #f4a 7#a-da74 ,beauty is unse51 9 supreme fusion1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,beauty1 love =1 expla9$ by av]sion = opposite1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dg74 ,beauty makes be+ desirable1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-efe74 ,beauty model1 is intellig5ce1 h5ce v beautiful1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,beauty n 9 physical *>act]s1 b 9 color =m1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eec74 ,beauty ( body ne$ n imply atta*m5t !reto1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcd74 ,beauty ( daily life review$1 9 sight1 s\nd1 sci5ce & morals1 i4 #f4a 7#a-dj74 ,beauty ( s\l is z ! matt] to ! s\l1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eee72 #f4f 7#a-dc74 ,beauty ( _w1 ev5 add$ to1 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab74 ,beauty prim>y1 *iefly reveal$ 9 virtu\s s\l1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eee74 ,beauty1 %9+1 highe/ appe>ance ( vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,beauty t is p]ceivable is a =m1 b5ea? sup] beautiful1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,beauty transition f s5se to intellectual1 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,beauty visible1 is effect & image ( ! intelligible1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabb74 ,becom+1 v4 #a4i 7#aj-ahg74 ,begett] ( intellig5ce mu/ be simpl] ?an x1 iii4 #h4h 7#cj-edb74 ,begett] ( intellig5ce rea*$ by intuition1 n reason1 iii4 #h4h 7#cj-edc74 ,begett+1 et]nal1 is ! _w1 ii4 #i4c 7#cc-fjd74 ,begett+1 l[] =ms (1 due to sem9al reasons1 iii4 #h4g 7#cj-eda74 ,begett+ ,son1 by ,supreme1 result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,beg9n+1 ,heav5 has none1 proves its immortality1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hah74 ,begott51 no?+ is 9 univ]sal s\l1 vi4 #d4ad 7#bb-cjg74 ,begott5 :at is1 n sem9al reason1 conta9s ord]1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,be+1 v4 #a4e1 #h 7#aj-aha & #ahf74 ,be+1 above intellig5t life1 iii4 #f4f 7#be-cfj74 ,be+1 actualiz$1 less p]fect ?an ess5ce1 ii4 #f4a 7#ag-bde74 ,be+ & actualization1 con/itute self-exi/5t pr9ciple1 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ghd74 ,be+ & ess5ce id5tical ) unity1 vi4 #i4b 7#i-adi74 ,be+ & quiddity e>li] ?an su*ness1 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh74 ,be+ _c be ascrib$ to matt]1 vi4 #c4g 7#dd-idd74 ,be+ _c prec$e su* be+1 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh74 ,be+ conta9s its cause1 vi4 #g4c 7#ch-gjd74 ,be+ desirable because beautiful1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,be+ di/+ui%$ into f\r s5ses1 vi4 #a4b 7#db-hci74 ,be+1 e "o1 is a specializ$ organ ( ! univ]se1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaj74 ,be+ 9 ! intelligible is g5]ation 9 ! s5se-_w1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icc74 ,be+ is v wisdom1 v4 #h4d1 #e 7#ca-eei74 ,be+ loves ess5ce z entire1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbe74 ,be+ l[] =m (1 possess$ by evil1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aade74 ,be+ ( a s\l1 iv4 #a4 7#d-ajj74 ,be+ ( a ?+ display$ by its en]gy1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hg74 ,be+ physical1 is t :i* is n 9 a subject1 vi4 #c4e 7#dd-ida74 ,be+ physical1 pr9ciple ( all o!r ?+s1 vi4 #c4d 7#dd-idj74 ,be+ pres5t ev]y:]e entire1 only solution ( a puzzle1 vi4 #e4c 7#bc-cag74 ,be+ prim>y & second>y1 divid$ by no sub/antial diff]5ces1 vi4 #c4i 7#dd-idi74 ,be+ supra lun>1 is deity1 9 intelligible1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,be+ supreme1 n dep5d5t on x1 !re=e above x1 vi4 #h4ai 7#ci-hjg74 ,be+ ! basis ( judgm5t1 9 ?+s p>ticipat+ 9 be+1 vi4 #e4b 7#bc-cae74 ,be+ univ]sal1 description (1 vi4 #d4b 7#bc-bhf74 ,be+1 univ]sal1 is undividable1 vi4 #d4c 7#bb-bhh74 ,be+s1 all are contemplation1 iii4 #h4g 7#cj-edb74 ,be+s1 all conta9$ by intellig5ce g5]atively1 v4 #i4f 7#e-aji74 ,b5efits are grant$ to m5 ?r\gh ! _w-s\l's m$iation1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,bett] nature ( man1 n dom9ant because ( subconsci\s nature1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha74 ,bewit*$1 gno/ics imag9e intelligible entities c be1 ii4 #i4ad 7#cc-fbg74 ,beyond fir/1 impossible to g1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gia74 ,bile1 fulfils unique role 9 univ]se1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aaga74 ,birds1 ov]weight$ l s5sual m51 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,bir? ( subord9ate deities1 inh]+ 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,bir? ( subord9ate div9ities does n affect p[] ( ,supreme1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-efe74 ,bir? ( "t reveals nature1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,blam$ = its imp]fections1 ! _w %\ld n be1 iii4 #b4c 7#dg-ajdf74 ,blank1 m5tal1 diff]s f impression ( %apeless1 ii4 #d4aj 7#ab-bjh74 ,boa/ ( k9%ip ) div9ities1 :ile n be+ able to leave body1 ridicul\s1 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fcg74 ,bodies add$1 introduce conflict+ motions1 ii4 #b4b 7#ad-bca74 ,bodies1 classification (1 vi4 #c4i 7#dd-idh74 ,bodies classifi$1 n only by =ms & qualities & specific =ms1 vi4 #c4aj 7#dd-iej74 ,bodies c\ld n subsi/ ) p[] ( univ]sal ,s\l iv4 #g4c 7#b-fj74 ,bodies1 diff]5t k9ds (1 :y s\ls take on1 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-daj74 ,bodies1 ev5 simple1 analyz$ into =m & matt]1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,bodies1 human1 m difficult to manage ?an _w-body iv4 #h4b 7#f-aba74 ,bodies ( s\ls1 may be relat$ diff]5tly1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhe74 ,bodies simple1 c\ld n exi/1 )\t _w-s\l iv4 #g4c 7#b-fj74 ,bodies1 s\ls desc5d into1 :y & h[8 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-dja74 ,body1 activat$ only by incorporeal p[]s1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gj74 ,body alone visible1 reason :y s\l is said to be 9 x1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dai74 ,body & s\l1 consequ5ces ( mixture1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaid74 ,body & s\l =ms fusion1 iv4 #d4ah 7#bh-dfe74 ,body & s\l mixture impossible1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaie74 ,body & s\l primitive relation betwe51 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,body & s\l relation betwe5 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,body1 ang]-p[]1 does n orig9ate 9 x1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhj74 ,body z rationaliz$ matt]1 ii4 #g4c 7#cg-fif74 ,body c lose p>ts1 n ! s\l1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,body _c possess virtue1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,body _c ?9k1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,body conta9s "o k9d ( desires1 iv4 #d4bj 7#bh-dfh74 ,body cosmic1 p]fect & self-suffici5t1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abb74 ,body c\ld n h s5sation1 if s\l 7 corporeal1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fe74 ,body diff]s f real man1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjb74 ,body1 does ! ang]-p[] orig9ate 9 x8 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhj74 ,body1 ev5 simple1 compos$ ( =m & matt]1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,body ex]ts a uni=m action2 s\l a v>i$ "o1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fb74 ,body1 eyes (1 to close !m1 me?od to a*ieve1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,body gr[s a little aft] dep>ture ( s\l1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhe74 ,body has s+le motion1 s\l diff]5t ones1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fb74 ,body1 h[ x approa*es ! s\l1 vi4 #d4ae 7#bb-cji74 ,body 9 s\l1 n s\l 9 body1 iii1 #i4c 7#ac-bbb72 iv4 #c4bb 7#bg-dbc74 ,body is composite1 !re=e p]i%able1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,body is in/rum5t ( ! s\l1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,body is n u b ours1 iv4 #d4ah 7#bh-dfe74 ,body "p ( ourselves1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjc72 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,body is proximate transition ( ! s\l1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbj74 ,body is tool & matt] ( s\l1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,body is )9 s\l1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dai74 ,body manag$ by reason+ h5ce imp]fectly1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,body managem5t1 only "o phase ( excursion ( procession1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,body ne$s s\l = life1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,body nev] entirely ent]$ by ! s\l1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,body n a vase = ! s\l1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbj74 ,body n con/itut$ by matt] exclusively1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-fj74 ,body ( demons is air or fire-l1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacc72 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hbc74 ,body ( elem5ts1 common gr\nd (1 makes !m k9dr$1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbd74 ,body p5etrat$ by s\l1 b n by ano!r body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,body relation to s\l1 is passage into _w ( life1 vi4 #d4ab 7#bb-cjd72 ,body1 sep>ation ( s\l f x1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaic74 ,body sick1 s\l devot$ to x1 iv4 #c4d 7#bg-cie74 ,body1 sup]ior & inf]ior ( s\l1 relat$ 9 ?ree ways1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhe74 ,body1 ! s\l uses z tool1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaic74 ,body ?r\gh\t all *anges1 s\l p[]s rema9 ! same1 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djb74 ,body us$ = p]ception makes feel+1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dge72 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,body1 w ( />s1 d n sway e>?ly ev5ts1 iv4 #d4cd 7#bh-did74 ,body's composition dem&s ! sub/rate1 ii4 #d4aa 7#ab-bji74 ,body's elem5ts _c h>monize !mselves1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-ge74 ,body's size no?+ to d ) greatness ( s\l1 vi4 #d4e 7#bb-bic74 ,boldness1 see ,audacity2 i4 #a4b 7#ec-aaib74 ,bond ( ! univ]se is numb]1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-fgj74 ,born philosoph]s alone1 rea* ! high] region1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,bo? m51 we always %\ld be1 b are n1 vi4 #d4ad 7#bb-cjh74 ,b\nd>y ( intelligible1 location ( s\l1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,bra9s1 seat ( s5sation1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbe74 ,bro!rs ( ,jupit] unissu$ yet1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,brutalization or div9ization is fate ( ?ree m5 9 u1 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh74 ,calypso1 i4 #f4h 7#a-ec74 ,capacity1 limits p>ticipation 9 ! "o1 vi4 #d4aa 7#bb-cjb74 ,c>e div9e1 exemption f c]ta9 classes1 he>tless1 ii4 #i4af 7#cc-fca74 ,c>e = individual ?+s1 draws s\l into inc>nation1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abd74 ,c>e] ( ! s\l1 :at hell means = x1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-cab72 ,ca/ration indicates /]ility ( unit>y nature1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che74 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,categories1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj72 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaaf74 ,categories1 ,ari/otelian & ,/oic1 vi4 #a4a 7#db-hcg74 ,categories1 ,ari/otelian neglect intelligible _w1 vi4 #a4a 7#db-hca74 ,categories _c conta9 bo? p[] & lack ( p[]1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-heb74 ,categories cause "o to produce manifoldness1 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaaf74 ,categories1 f\r ( ,/oics1 evaporate1 leav+ matt] z basis1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhe74 ,categories1 if :]e & place are diff]5t categories1 _m m may be add$1 vi4 #a4ad 7#db-hfb74 ,categories1 movem5t & diff]5ce appli$ to intellig5ce1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bjb74 ,categories ( ,plot9os d n toge!r =m quality1 vi4 #b-ad 7#dc-iah74 ,categories ( ,plot9os1 five1 :y none 7 add$1 vi4 #b4i 7#dc-ijg74 ,categories ( ,plot9os1 six1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bjb72 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh72 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj72 vi4 #b4a1 #h1 #i 7#dc-hia1 #ijd74 ,categories ( quality1 v>i\s d]ivatives (1 vi4 #c4ai 7#dd-ifg74 ,categories ( ,/oics enum]at$1 vi4 #a4be 7#db-hgh74 ,categories1 physical1 f\r? & fif?1 ref] to ! fir/ ?ree1 vi4 #c4f 7#dd-idc74 ,categories1 physical1 ( ,plot9os1 enum]at$1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,categories1 sep>ate1 action & suff]+ _c be1 vi4 #a4ag 7#db-hff74 ,categories1 s+le1 c\ld n include intelligible & s5se be+1 vi4 #a4b 7#db-hci74 ,categories1 six1 f :i* all ?+s are d]iv$1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,categories1 s\rces ( *>act]i/ics1 9 intelligible1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,categories1 unity is n "o1 argum5ts aga9/1 vi4 #b4aj 7#dc-iaj74 ,categories f> bett] ?an do+ or act+ actualization1 vi4 #a4ae 7#db-hfc74 ,categories1 hav+ _c be1 because too v>i\s1 vi4 #a4bc 7#db-hgf74 ,categories ( some?+ common is absurd1 vi4 #a4be 7#db-hgh74 ,categories1 :y movem5t is1 vi4 #c4ba 7#dd-iga74 ,cause abs5t1 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,cause co9cides ) nature 9 intelligible1 vi4 #g4ai 7#ch-gce74 ,cause1 ev]y?+ has1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,cause1 is ,supreme1 ( ,h]aclitus1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,cause1 ( affections1 ?\gh corporeal1 iii4 #f4d 7#bf-cef74 ,cause ( procession ( _w f unity1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,cause1 suitability (1 puts ,supreme beyond *ance1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjf74 ,cause ultimate1 is nature1 iii #a4a 7#c-hg74 ,cause :y s\ls are div9e1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,causeless orig91 really is det]m9ism1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,causes1 any ?+ due to sev]al1 ii4 #c4ad 7#eb-aahj74 ,causes = inc>nation are tw(old1 iv4 #h4a1 #e 7#f-aai1 #abh74 ,causes ( det]ioration1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajhc74 ,causes ( ?+s 9 ! _w1 possible !ories1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,causes proximate are unsatisfactory1 dem&+ ! ultimate1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,causes ult]ior always s\ght by sages1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,cave1 ,platonic simile ( _w1 iv4 #h4a1 #d 7#f-abj1 #abf74 ,cele/ial div9ities1 diff]5ce f inf]ior1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eef74 ,cele/ial light n expos$ to any wa/age1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbg74 ,cele/ial ?+s la/ long] ?an t]re/rial ?+s1 ii4 #a4e 7#dj-hai74 ,c5tre is fa!r ( ! circumf]5ce & radii1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjd74 ,c5tre ( s\l & body1 diff]5ce betwe51 ii4 #b4b 7#ad-bcj74 ,c]es1 my? ( s\l ( e>?1 iv4 #d4bg 7#bh-dhj74 ,c]ta91 conception limit+ objects1 vi4 #f4ac 7#cd-ffc74 ,*a9s b9d s\l 9 inc>nation1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abf74 ,*a9s1 gold51 on captive1 z beauty is on matt]1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafc74 ,*a9s t hold d[n ,saturn1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,*ance1 app>5t1 is really ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4b 7#dh-ajgh74 ,*ance bani%$ by =m1 limit & %ape1 vi4 #h4aj 7#ci-ghi74 ,*ance1 cause ( suitability & opportunity1 puts !m beyond x1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjd74 ,*ance c\ld n cause ! c5tre ( circul> ( intellig5ce1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjd74 ,*ance does n produce supreme be+1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gib74 ,*ance is n ! cause ( ! good be+ free1 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ghc74 ,*ance1 m5 escape by int]ior isolation1 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hjj74 ,*ance1 no room = 9 ,supreme1 assi/$ by intellig5ce1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjd74 ,*ance1 ,supreme c\ld n possibly be call$ by any "o :o _h se5 x1 vi4 #h4ai 7#ci-hjg74 ,*ange1 h[ c x be out ( "t1 if movem5t is 9 "t1 vi4 #a4af 7#db-hfd74 ,*ange1 is x ant]ior to movem5t8 vi4 #c4ba 7#dd-igb74 ,*ange mu/ inevitably exi/ 9 ,heav51 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-hac74 ,*angeable1 desires are1 iv4 #d4b 7#bh-dfi74 ,*angeabl5ess1 self-direction ( ?\ght is n1 iv4 #d4b 7#bh-ddd74 ,*anges ( =tune1 affect only ! out] man1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajfg74 ,*anges ( ! body1 d n *ange s\l p[]s1 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djb74 ,*anges1 ours1 _w-s\ls unconsci\s (1 iv4 #d4g 7#bh-dej74 ,*aos1 usual />t+ po9t1 causes puzzle ( orig9 ( ,god1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gib74 ,"*1 human1 result ( =m] lives1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajhc74 ,*>act]i/ic1 c]ta91 a spiritualization ( t]ms1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aig72 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,*>act]i/ic1 if any?+ at all1 is a reason spiritual1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,*>iot1 ,god trav]ses heav5 9 "o1 iv4 #c4g 7#bg-cii74 ,*a/isem5t ( s\ls psy*ologically expla9$1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-caj74 ,*emical mixture describ$1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,*ief1 ! great ,jupit]1 ?ird ,god1 iii4 #e4h 7#ej-aacf74 ,*oir ( virtues 7,/oic71 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,*oos+ is ess5ce ( consci\sness1 iv4 #d4cg 7#bh-ejj74 ,*orus1 see ,ballet1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afe74 ,circe1 i4 #f4h 7#a-ec74 ,circle1 iii4 #h4g 7#cj-edc72 v4 #a4g1 #aa 7#aj-ahd1 #aia74 ,circul> movem5t is t ( s\l1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afb1 #afd72 ii4 #b4a 7#ad-bbg72 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfb74 ,circul> movem5t ( heav5s1 ii4 #b4b 7#ad-bcj74 ,circulat+ ar\nd heav5s1 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bcd74 ,cities haunt$ by div9ities1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-ccb74 ,classification ( purification1 result ( virtue1 i4 #b4d 7#ai-bfj74 ,climate1 a legitimate gov]n+ cause1 iii4 #a4e 7#c-ic74 ,close eyes ( body1 me?od to a*ieve ec/asy1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,clos5ess to div9ity1 p]man5t result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,clo?o1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,coelus1 7,uranus71 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,co-exi/5ce ( unity & multiplicity dem&s organization 9 sy/em1 vi4 #g4aj 7#ch-gaf74 ,cognition1 h[ x op]ates1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-ege74 ,cognition ( intelligible objects1 admits no impression1 iv4 #f4b 7#da-hcb74 ,cold is n me?od ( trans=m+ brea? into s\l1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,collective n\ns prove indep5d5t exi/5ce1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fgb74 ,comb9ation begott5 by ! s\l1 its nature1 vi4 #g4e 7#ch-gjh74 ,comb9ation conta9s "o k9d ( desires1 iv4 #d4bj 7#bh-dfh74 ,comb9ation is a physical category1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,comb9ation ( body & s\l1 appetites locat$ 91 iv4 #d4bj 7#bh-dfh74 ,comb9ation ( s\l & body z mixture1 or z result+ product1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,comb9ation1 see ,aggregate1 #a4aa4 ,comb9ation1 ?ird physical category 7#ec-aaia74 ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,comm&s himself1 ,supreme does1 vi4 #h4bj 7#ci-hji74 ,common elem5t1 gr[? 9 increase & g5]ation1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-ige74 ,common gr\nd ( ! elem5ts make !m k9dr$1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbd74 ,common "p1 function (1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjc74 ,common to s\l & body1 n all affections are1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaig74 ,communion ( ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,communion ) ! div9e1 z ( ,m9os ) ,jupit]1 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afb74 ,comp>ative me?od ( /udy+ "t1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iif74 ,compla9+ ( ! _w1 in/ead ( fit y\rself to x1 ii4 #i4ac 7#cc-fbe74 ,compla9t1 grotesque to wisdom ( creator1 iii4 #b4ad 7#dg-ajfc74 ,compla9t ( l[] nature ( animals ridicul\s1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajei74 ,complem5t ( be+ call$ quality only by c\rtesy1 vi4 #b4ad 7#dc-iah74 ,composite aggregate1 see comb9ation1 i4 #a4b 7#ec-aaia74 ,composite is body1 !re=e p]i%able1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,composite ( =m & matt] is ev]y?+1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,composit5ess n d5i$ by simplicity ( ! intellig5t1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbb74 ,composit5ess ( kn[] n necess>ily impli$ by k1 v4 #c4a 7#di-ajij74 ,composition & decomposition are n alt]ations1 vi4 #c4be 7#dd-igi74 ,composition & decomposition1 explanation (1 vi4 #c4be 7#dd-igh74 ,compris+ _m s\ls makes s\l inf9ite1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bia74 ,compulsory1 memory is n1 iv4 #d4h 7#bh-dea74 ,concat5ation f univ]sal reason are a/rological signs1 iv4 #d4ch 7#bh-eja74 ,concat5ation 9 all ?+s is ! univ]se1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aif74 ,concat5ation ( causes is ,*rysippus's fate1 iii4 #a4b1 #g 7#c-hi1 #if74 ,conceiv+ pr9ciple is ! _w-s\l1 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bba74 ,conc5tricity ( all exi/+ ?+s1 v4 #c4g 7#di-aaja72 v4 #e4i 7#cb-ehg74 ,conception1 true1 is act ( intuition1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abjb74 ,con=mity to ! univ]sal s\l1 impli$ !y d n =m "p ( h]1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-chi74 ,connection betwe5 s5se & intelligible worlds is triple nature ( man1 vi4 #g4g 7#ch-gaa74 ,connection ) inf9ite is ,*rysippus's fate1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hi74 ,consci\sness1 iii4 #i4i 7#ac-bbf74 ,consci\sness1 con/itut$ by timeless memory1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbi74 ,consci\sness dep5ds on *oos+1 iv4 #d4cg 7#bh-ejj74 ,consci\sness1 etymologically1 is s5sation ( manifoldness1 v4 #c4ac 7#di-aaac74 ,consci\sness is n a pre-requisite ( happ9ess or virtue & intellig5ce1 i4 #d4i1 #aj 7#df-ajcc74 ,consci\sness is unit>y1 ?\gh conta9+ ! ?9k]1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fja74 ,consci\sness1 local & :ole1 relation betwe5 n applicable to s\l1 iv4 #c4c 7#bg-cib74 ,consci\sness ( high] s\l-"p dimm$ by pr$om9ance or di/urbance ( l[]1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,consci\sness ( self1 lo/ 9 ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,consci\sness1 unity limits pr9ciples to ?ree1 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjb74 ,consci\sness w\ld be )drawn by diff]5tiat+ reason1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fjb74 ,contemplat+ intellig5ce1 is horizon ( div9e approa*1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehg74 ,contemplat+ ! div9ity1 a ,gno/ic precept1 ii4 #i4ae 7#cc-fcj74 ,contemplation1 v4 #a4b1 #c 7#aj-age1 #agg72 v4 #c4aj 7#di-aajf74 ,contemplation1 aspir$ to1 by ev5 plants1 iii4 #h4a 7#cj-eca74 ,contemplation1 ev]y?+ is1 iii4 #h 7#cj74 ,contemplation1 goal ( all be+s1 iii4 #h4g 7#cj-edj74 ,contemplation1 immovable results 9 nature & reason1 iii4 #h4b 7#cj-ecc74 ,contemplation includes nature & reason1 iii4 #h4b 7#cj-ecc74 ,consequ5ce ( d]ivative goods ( ?ird rank1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd74 ,consequ5ces ( mixture ( s\l & body1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaid74 ,con/itution1 ( univ]se1 hi]>*ical1 vi4 #b4a 7#ac-hib74 ,consub/antial1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,contemplation1 con/itution ( ev5 l[] =ms1 iii4 #h4a 7#cj-eca74 ,contemplation ( intellig5ce1 dem&s a high] transc5d+ unity1 v4 #c4aj 7#di-aajf74 ,contemplation ( itself made ess5ce intellig5ce1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,contemplation only "o phase ( excursion ( procession1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,contemplation ! goal ( all k9ds & grades ( exi/5ce1 iii4 #h4f 7#cj-edj74 ,contemplation's prep>ation is practice1 iii4 #h4e 7#cj-ech74 ,contemporane\s is life ( intellig5ce1 iii4 #g4b 7#de-ihi74 ,contempor>y are matt] & ! in=m+ pr9ciples1 ii4 #d4h 7#ab-bjf74 ,cont+5ce applicable to ,supreme1 "u new def9ition only1 vi4 #h4h 7#ci-ghe74 ,cont+5ce n ev5 applies to ess5ce1 let alone sup]-ess5ce1 vi4 #h4i 7#ci-ghg74 ,cont+5cy1 disappe>ance (1 witness$ to by asc5t ( life1 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hja74 ,cont+5cy illum9at$ 9 analysis1 vi4 #h4ad 7#ci-gih74 ,cont+5t exi/5ce1 prec$es absolute1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hha74 ,cont9uance ne$ n int]f]e ) fluctuation1 ii4 #a4c 7#dj-haf74 ,cont9uity betwe5 nature & elem5ts1 !re is none1 iv4 #d4ad 7#bh-dei74 ,cont9u\s procession1 necess>y to ,supreme1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,contr>ies1 are ^? ?+s t lack res5tm5ts1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-ifh74 ,contr>ies pass+ into ea* o!r1 ,h]aclitus1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aai74 ,contr>ies tea* appreciation1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,contr>9ess is n ! greate/ possible diff]5ce1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-ifh74 ,contr>y conta9$ 9 reason1 con/itute its unity1 iii4 #b4af 7#dg-ajfi74 ,conv]sion effect$ by depreciation ( ! ext]nal & appreciation ( h]self1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agd72 see v4 #a4g4 ,conv]sion ( s\l t[>ds h]self1 only object ( virtue1 i4 #d4aa 7#df-ajce74 ,conv]sion ( s\ls1 iv4 #c4f1 #g 7#bg-cig1 #cii72 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abf74 ,conv]sion ( sup]-abundance1 back t[>ds "o1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,conv]sion produc$ by purification1 i4 #b4d 7#aj-bfa74 ,conv]sion to good & be+ 9 itself dep5ds on intellig5ce1 vi4 #h4d 7#ci-ggh74 ,conv]sion t[>ds div9ity1 result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,co-ord9ation ( univ]se1 tru? ( a/rology1 ii4 #c4g 7#eb-aagc74 ,corporeal1 if s\l is1 body c\ld n possess s5sation1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fe74 ,corporeity is non5tity because ( lack ( unity1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfb74 ,corporeity n 9 matt] ( ?+ itself1 ii4 #d4ab 7#ab-bab74 ,correspond5ce ( s5se-beauty1 ) its idea1 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,cosmic intellect1 relation ) individual1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,c\nt]feit impli$ by true good1 vi4 #g4bf 7#ch-gdc74 ,c\rage is no long] to fe> dea?1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,c\rage ( s\l's ang] "p expla9$1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,creation by div9ity glanc+ at intellig5ce above1 iv4 #c4aa 7#bg-djh74 ,creation by =esight1 n result ( reason+1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fii74 ,creation by m]e illum9ation1 gno/ic1 oppos$1 ii4 #i4aa 7#cc-fba74 ,creation drama1 ! _w-s\l c\ld n h gone ?r\gh1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fje74 ,creation is effusion ( sup]-abundance1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,creation limit$ to _w-s\l because ne>e/ to intelligible _w1 iv4 #c4f 7#bg-cig74 ,creation ( s5se-_w1 n by reflection1 b self-necessity1 iii4 #b4b 7#dg-ajdd74 ,creation ( _w1 h[ x took place1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efb74 ,creation1 :y d5i$ human s\ls1 iv4 #c4f 7#bg-cig74 ,creative is ! univ]sal s\l1 n pres]vative1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahc74 ,creative motives1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fje74 ,creator admires 8 h&iwork1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,creator & pres]v]1 is ! good1 vi4 #g4bc 7#ch-gdj74 ,creator & _w1 are n evil1 ii4 #i 7#cc74 ,creator is outside ( "t1 iii4 #g4e 7#de-iid74 ,creator s wise t all compla9ts are grotesque1 iii4 #b4ad 7#dg-ajfc74 ,creator te/ifi$ to1 by ! _w1 iii4 #b4c 7#dg-ajdg74 ,creator's univ]sality1 ov]came all ob/acles1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efb74 ,creator's wisdom makes compla9ts grotesque1 iii4 #b4ad 7#dg-ajfc74 ,cr$5ce ( intellig5ce 9 itself1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egh74 ,crimes %\ld n be attribut$ to ! influ5ce ( sublun>y div9ities1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhi74 ,criticism ( _w is wrong1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efe74 ,culm9ation1 ii4 #c4c 7#eb-aafe74 ,cup1 cosmic1 9 ,plato1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abg74 ,cupid & ,psy*e1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-aff74 ,curative1 !1 is a prom95t elem5t ( life1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhd74 ,cutt+ (f e ?+ else1 is means ( ec/asy1 v4 #c4g 7#di-aaba74 ,cybele1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che74 ,daemon helps to c>ry out *os5 de/9y1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bci74 ,daemon is next high] faculty ( s\l1 iii4 #d4c 7#ae-bce74 ,daemon is ! love t unites a s\l to matt]1 iii4 #e4d 7#ej-aacj74 ,daemon may rema9 aft] dea? or be *ang$ to ,daemon sup]ior to pr$om9at+ p[]1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bci74 ,daemon ( s\ls is _! love1 iii4 #e4d 7#ej-aacj74 ,daemon's all1 born ( ,ne$ & ,abundance1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aaca74 ,daemons & deities1 diff]5ce betwe51 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aaca74 ,daemons are individual1 iii4 #d 7#ae74 ,daemons bo? relat$ & indep5d5t ( u1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bci74 ,daemons ev5 9 s\ls ent]+ animal bodies1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,daemons foll[ ,supreme1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,daemon's guidance does n h9d] responsibility1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bch74 ,daemons 9 *>ge ( puni%m5t ( s\l1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,dance1 pre>rang$1 simile ( />'s motion1 iv4 #d4cc 7#bh-dib74 ,d>kness1 exi/5ce (1 mu/ be relat$ to ! s\l1 ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbd74 ,d>kness1 look+ at1 cause ( evil ( s\l1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,dea?1 aft]1 colleagues 9 gov]nm5t ( _w1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abe74 ,dea?1 aft]1 discursive reason n us$1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-daf74 ,dea?1 aft]1 judgm5t & expiation1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,dea?1 aft]1 man becomes :at he has liv$1 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bcd74 ,dea?1 aft]1 memory may la/1 if tra9$1 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bcd72 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddh74 ,dea?1 aft]1 rank dep5ds on /ate ( dea?1 i4 #i 7#af74 ,dea?1 aft]1 recognition & memory1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,dea?1 aft]1 s\l goes to retribution1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajef74 ,dea?1 aft]1 :]e does ! s\l g1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj72 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajef74 ,dea?1 at1 memories ( =m] exi/5ces are reproduc$1 iv4 #c4bg 7#bg-dcc74 ,dea? bett] ?an di%>mony1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajeg74 ,dea?1 h[ ! s\l splits up1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bda74 ,dea? is only sep>ation ( s\l f body1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,decl9ation1 ii4 #c4c 7#eb-aafe74 ,decomposible1 s\l is n1 m]ely because x has ?ree p>ts1 iv4 #g4ad 7#b-hd74 ,decomposition & composition are n alt]ation1 vi4 #c4be 7#dd-igi74 ,decomposition & composition1 explanation (1 vi4 #c4be 7#dd-igh74 ,defects1 n 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aag74 ,defects su* z limp+1 d n proce$ f intellig5ce1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,deg5]ation ( races1 impli$ by det]m9ism1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahd74 ,deg5]ation ( s\l is promot$ by look+ at d>kness1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,degrees1 admitt$ (1 by quality1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-igj74 ,degrees1 diff]5t1 ( ! same reality1 are intellig5ce & life1 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gcb74 ,degrees ( ec/asy1 vi4 #g4cf 7#ch-gfj74 ,deities & demons1 diff]5ce betwe51 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aaca74 ,deities1 second rank1 are all visible sup]-lun> deities1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,delib]at+ be=e mak+ s5se-man intellig5ce did n1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fih74 ,delib]ation 9 creat+ ( _w1 gno/ic oppos$1 v4 #h4g1 #ab 7#ca-efa1 #ega74 ,delphi1 at middle ( e>?1 vi4 #a4ad 7#db-hfb74 ,demiurge1 h[ ! gno/ic creat$ x1 ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbc74 ,demon1 *ief1 9 intelligible _w is deity1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,demon is any be+ 9 intelligible _w1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacc74 ,demon is ve/ige ( a s\l desc5d$ into ! _w1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,demon1 ! great1 ,platonic1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,demoniacal possession1 z explanation ( disease wrong1 ii4 #i4ad 7#cc-fbg74 ,demons1 among !m1 ^? are loves t exi/ by a s\l's desire = good1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,demons h bodies ( fire1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hbc72 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacc74 ,demons h no memories1 & grant no pray]s2 9 w> life is sav$ by valor1 n by pray]s1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,demons1 no crimes %\ld be attribut$ to1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhi74 ,demons n born ( s\ls1 g5]at$ by _w-s\l p[]s1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacc74 ,demons1 psy*ology (1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,demons1 :y n all ( !m are loves1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,demons1 :y !y are n free f matt]1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacc74 ,demon/ration abs5t 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,demon/ration ( div9ity defies1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bfi74 ,dep>t f life by seek+ beyond x1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-cca74 ,deprivation1 9 s\l1 is evil1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeh74 ,deprivation is matt]1 & is )\t qualities1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeh74 ,d]ivatives ( category ( quality1 vi4 #c4ai 7#dd-ifg74 ,desc>tes1 ,cogito1 ergo sum1 f ,p>m5ides1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajh74 ,desc5d1 h[ s\ls come to1 iv4 #c4ac 7#bg-daj74 ,desc5d1 intelligible does n1 s5se-_w rises1 iii4 #d4d 7#ae-bcg74 ,desc5t f intelligible into heav5 by s\ls leads to recognition1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,desc5t f ! intelligible _w enables u to /udy "t1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iie74 ,desc5t into body1 does n injure et]nity ( s\l1 iv4 #g4ac 7#b-hc74 ,desc5t ( s\l1 causes1 z giv5 by ,plato1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aba74 ,desc5t ( s\l into body1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbb72 iv4 #h4a 7#f-abj74 ,desc5t ( ! s\l1 is fall into matt]1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafa74 ,desc5t ( ! s\l1 proc$ure1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-caa74 ,desc5t ( ! s\l1 psy*ologically expla9$1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-caa74 ,desc5t1 s\ls n isolat$ f intellig5ce1 dur+1 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-dji74 ,description ( intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeg74 ,description ( univ]sal be+1 vi4 #d4b 7#bb-bhf74 ,desirability ( be+ 9 its beauty v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,desirable 9 itself1 is ! good4 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ghc74 ,desire n simultane\s ) appetite1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaig74 ,desire ( s\l1 liv] seat (1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhj74 ,desire or ability1 only limit ( union ) div9ity1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,desire to live1 satisfaction (1 is n happ9ess1 i4 #e4b 7#cf-fhd74 ,desires are physical1 because *angeable ) h>mony ( body1 iv4 #d4ba 7#bh-dfi74 ,desires1 d\ble1 ( body & ( comb9ation1 iv4 #d4bj 7#bh-dfh74 ,desires1 function1 relation (1 to ! vegetative p[]1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dgj74 ,de/9y *os51 help$ by ,daemon1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bci74 ,de/9y con=m$ to "* ( s\l1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bch74 ,de/9y ( man1 gno/ic1 is demoraliz+1 ii4 #i4ae 7#cc-fbi74 ,de/9y ( s\ls1 dep5d on condition ( bir? ( univ]se1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,de/roy$ w\ld be ! univ]se1 if unity pass$ into ! manifold1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,de/ruction ( s\l elem5ts1 does x imply disappe>ance8 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhd74 ,deta*m5t z simplification ( ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,deta*m5t ( s\l at dea?1 h[ arrang$ naturally1 i4 #i 7#af74 ,deta*m5t ( s\l by dea? volunt>y1 =bidd51 i4 #i 7#af74 ,detail$ fate n sway$ by />s1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhh74 ,details1 fault 91 _c *ange h>mony 9 univ]se1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahe74 ,det]m9ate =m1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd72 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,det]m9at5ess1 impossible ( "o1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,det]m9ation dem&s a motive1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,det]m9ation ( future impli$ by pr$iction1 iii4 #a4c 7#c-ij74 ,det]m9ism implies deg5]ation ( races1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahd74 ,det]m9ism1 really1 "u causeless orig91 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,det]m9ism support$ by mat]iali/s1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,det]ioration1 causes (1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajhc74 ,developm5t natural ( ess5ce to create a s\l1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,deviltry confut$1 leaves influ5ce ( _w-s\l1 iv4 #d4cb 7#bh-dij74 ,devolution 7,platonic _w s*eme1 intellig5ce1 s\l1 nature71 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,diagram ( univ]se1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfb74 ,dialectics1 i4 #c 7#bj-bfi72 ii1 #d4aj 7#ab-bjf72 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icd72 i4 #c4d 7#bj-bgb72 i4 #h4i 7#ea-aaef74 ,dialectics1 cr[n ( v>i\s bran*es ( philosophy1 i4 #c4e 7#bj-bgc74 ,dialectics1 h[ to conceive inf9ite1 vi4 #f4b 7#cd-fdd74 ,dialectics is concat5ation ( ! _w1 i4 #c4d 7#bj-bgb74 ,dialectics neglects op9ion & s5se op9ions1 i4 #c4d 7#bj-bgb74 ,dialectics n m]ely in/rum5t = philosophy 7,ari/otle71 i4 #c4e 7#bj-bgc74 ,dialectics n speculation & ab/ract rules 7,epicurean71 i4 #c4e 7#bj-bgc74 ,dialectics sci5ce ( 7judg+ values1 or7 discov]y1 am\nt ( real be+ 9 ?+s1 i4 #c4d 7#bj-bgc74 ,dialectics /ay+ 9 intelligible1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc74 ,dialectics ?ree pa?s1 philosoph]1 musician & lov]1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bfi74 ,dialectics two fold1 fir/ asc5t to intelligible & !n h[ to rema91 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bfi74 ,dialectics )\t x1 l[] k w\ld be imp]fect1 i4 #c4f 7#bj-bgd74 ,diff]1 s\ls d1 z ! s5sations1 vi4 #d4f 7#bb-bid74 ,diff]5ce & id5tity1 impli$ by triune process ( categories1 vi4 #b4h 7#dc-ije74 ,diff]5ce betwe5 cele/ial & inf]ior div9ities1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eef74 ,diff]5ce betwe5 human & cosmic inc>nation1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abc74 ,diff]5ce1 greate/ possible1 is n contr>9ess1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-ifh74 ,diff]5ce ( ,supreme f second1 is pr(\nd1 v4 #e4c 7#cb-ehj74 ,diff]5ce1 or category1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,diff]5ces1 m9or1 d]iv$ f matt]1 v4 #i4ab 7#e-aae74 ,diff]5ces ( color1 aid to discrim9ate magnitudes1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fha74 ,diff]5ces ( s\l1 reta9$ on diff]5t levels1 iv4 #c4e 7#bg-cif74 ,diff]5ces ( ?+s1 dep5d on _! sem9al reasons1 v4 #g4a 7#ah-beb74 ,diff]5ces1 "s are n qualities1 vi4 #c4ah 7#dd-ife74 ,diff]5tials ( be+s1 are n g5u9e qualities1 vi4 #a4af 7#db-hec74 ,difficulties ( und]/&+1 cle> to intellig5ce1 iv4 #i4e 7#h-adf74 ,dim5sion & numb] are s diff]5t z to sugge/ diff]5t classifications1 vi4 #b4ac 7#dc-iaf74 ,dim9i%$1 ess5ce is n1 ?\gh divisible1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bij74 ,dione1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabf74 ,disappe>ance ( =m1 implies t ( size1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fhb74 ,disappe>ance ( s\l p>ts1 does x imply de/ruction1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhd74 ,discont5t1 div9e1 & trans=ms virtues1 homely into high]1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,discont5t1 div9e1 supplem5t ( homely virtues1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,discord1 cause ( inc>nation1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aai74 ,discursive reason1 v4 #a4aj1 #aa 7#aj-ahi72 v4 #c4ad 7#di-aaae72 v4 #e4a 7#cb-ege72 v4 #i4d 7#e-ajf74 ,discursive reason _c turn ^u itself1 v4 #c4b 7#di-ajia74 ,discursive reason1 its function1 v4 #c4a 7#di-ajij74 ,discursive reason1 :y x belongs to s\l1 n to intellig5ce1 v4 #c4c 7#di-ajic74 ,discursive reason's highe/ "p1 receives impressions f its intellig5ce1 v4 #c4c 7#di-ajib74 ,disease1 z demoniacal possession wrong1 ii4 #i4ad 7#cc-fbg74 ,di%>mony1 vice is1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ceb74 ,di%>mony ) laws ( univ]se1 worse ?an dea?1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajeg74 ,displacem5t1 movem5t is s+le1 vi4 #c4bd 7#dd-igg74 ,disposition1 difficulty ( ma/]+ ^! corporeal dispositions1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaed74 ,di/ance f a unity is multitude & an evil1 vi4 #f4a 7#cd-fdc74 ,di/ance f ! ,supreme1 imp]fection1 iii4 #c4c 7#dh-ajhj74 ,di/9ction betwe5 spiritual1 psy*ic & mat]ial1 due to ignorance ( o!r p's atta9m5ts1 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fcg74 ,di/9ction 9 intelligibles1 7good above beauty71 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,di/+ui%1 object ( my?s1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aach74 ,di/9ction1 ,philonic1 betwe5 ! ,god1 & ,god1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,di/+ui%+ ( be+1 quality & diff]5ces absurd1 vi4 #c4ah 7#dd-ife74 ,di/raction by s5sation1 makes u unconsci\s ( high] "p1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,div]g5ce f ,plato1 =ces ,plot9os to demon/rate categories1 vi4 #b4a 7#dc-hia74 ,div]sity f same p>5ts dep5ds on mann] ( g5]ation1 v4 #g4b 7#ah-bec74 ,div]sity ( relations ( all ?+s connect$ ) ! fir/1 v4 #e4i 7#cb-ehi74 ,divid$1 n ev5 ! asc5d$ s\l ne$ be1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,divid$1 "t _c be )\t s\l's action1 iv4 #d4ae 7#bh-dfj74 ,div9e sph]e1 limit$ by s\l1 d[nw>ds1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahf74 ,div9]1 duty (1 is to read lett] trac$ by nature1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhg74 ,div9ities begott5 by actualization ( intellig5ce1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-afh74 ,div9ities begott5 by sil5t int]c\rse ) ! "o1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-aff74 ,div9ities cele/ial & inf]ior1 diff]5ce betwe51 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eef74 ,div9ities conta9$ 9 ,supreme1 dynamically1 by bir?1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,div9ities haunt ! cities1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-ccb74 ,div9ities hidd5 & visible1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agh74 ,div9ity abs5t only1 = non-successful 9 avoid+ di/raction1 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afa74 ,div9ity & also ! s\l is always "o1 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djj74 ,div9ity con/itut$ by atta*m5t to c5tre1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afc74 ,div9ity di/+ui%$ ,philonically1 ! ,god1 & ,god1 vi4 #g4a 7#ah-bea74 ,div9ity1 resemblance to1 9 s\l's welf>e1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,div9ity )9 u1 s+le & id5tical 9 all1 vi4 #e4a 7#bc-cad74 ,div9ization1 z ,cupid & ,psy*e1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-aff74 ,div9ization ( brutalization1 is fate ( ?ree m5 9 u1 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh74 ,divisible1 all bodies are fully1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,divisible & indivisible c s\l be simultane\sly1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dag74 ,divisible & indivisible is s\l1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bgi74 ,divisible be+s1 exi/5ce (1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgf74 ,divisible intellig5ce is n1 v4 #c4e 7#di-ajif74 ,divisible is ess5ce ?\gh n dim9i%$1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bij74 ,divisible ( s\l1 mixture & d\ble1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,divisible s\l is n unify+ manifold1 s5sation1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fe74 ,divisibility1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd74 ,divisibility1 goal ( s5se1 gr[? & emotion1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,divisibility ( s\l 9 vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,division1 betwe5 univ]sal s\l & s\ls impossible1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-cij74 ,division1 *>act]i/ic ( bodies n ( s\l1 iv4 #b4h 7#ba-bgf74 ,dom9ant1 bett] nature is n1 because ( sub-consci\sness1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha74 ,d\ble cause ( inc>nation1 motive & de$s1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abe74 ,d\ble1 ,h]cules symbolizes ! s\l1 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjf74 ,d\bl5ess ( ev]y?+1 includ+ man1 vi4 #c4d 7#dd-ich74 ,d\bl5ess ( s\l1 reasons & ,provid5ce1 iv4 #f4b 7#da-hcb72 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha74 ,d\bl5ess ( s\ls1 suns1 />s1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aage74 ,d\bl5ess ( wisdom1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,d\bl5ess ( _w s\l1 ii4 #b4c 7#ad-bcc74 ,d\bl5ess1 see pair1 or dyad1 ( e man1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,d\bt ( exi/5ce ( div9ity1 l dream]s :o awake1 to slumb] aga91 v4 #e4aa 7#cb-eib74 ,drama z a :ole1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,drama ( life1 p>ts play$ badly by ! evil1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajgb74 ,drama1 simile (1 all[s = good & evil )9 reason1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajgj74 ,dream ( ! good is =m1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gde74 ,dream ( ! s\l is s5sation1 f :i* we mu/ wake1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfc74 ,dream]s :o wake1 only to return to dreams l d\bt]s ( div9ity1 v4 #e4aa 7#cb-eic74 ,driv] & horses1 simile (1 ,platonic1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,dualism breaks d[n j l monism1 vi4 #a4bg 7#db-hhc74 ,duality 7=m & matt]7 9 all ?+s1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,duality ( e body1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bjj74 ,duration has no?+ to d ) happ9ess1 i4 #e4a 7#cf-fhd74 ,duration increases unhapp9ess1 :y n happ9ess8 i4 #e4f 7#cf-fhf74 ,duration ( happ9ess does n affect its quality1 i4 #e4e 7#cf-fhe74 ,duration ( "t1 z opportunity1 is ( importance to virtue1 i4 #e4aj 7#cf-fhi74 ,dyad1 or d\bl5ess1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,dyad1 see pair1 vi4 #b4aa 7#dc-iad74 ,e>? & fire conta9$ 9 ! />s1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hbb74 ,e>? c feel z well z ! />s1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dga74 ,e>? conta9s all ! o!r elem5ts1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hbc74 ,e>? exi/s 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gah74 ,e>? feels & directs by sympa!tic h>mony1 iv4 #d4bf 7#bh-dgg74 ,e>?1 model ( ! new1 gno/ic1 unreasonable1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjh74 ,e>?1 po/ulat$ by ,plato1 z be+ basis ( life1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbc74 ,e>? s5ses may be diff]5t f ours1 iv4 #d4bf 7#bh-dgh74 ,e>?1 :at passions suitable to x1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dga74 ,e>?ly ev5ts1 n to be attribut$ to />s1 body or w1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-die74 ,e>?'s psy*ology1 iv4 #d4bg 7#bh-dgi74 ,ecliptic's incl9ation to equator1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,ec/asy z div9e spectacle1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,ec/asy z intellectual contact ) sudd5 light1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aabj74 ,ec/asy describ$1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aai74 ,ec/asy ends 9 a report ( see+ ,god beget a ,son1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-ega74 ,ec/asy ends 9 fusion ) div9ity1 & becom+ own object ( contemplation1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,ec/asy ends 9 re/ & ,saturnian realm1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,ec/asy ends 9 vision :i* is n *ance1 vi4 #h4ba 7#ci-hjg74 ,ec/asy1 exp]i5ce (1 i4 #f4g 7#a-ej74 ,ec/asy has two advantages foll[+1 self-consci\sness & possession ( all ?+s1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,ec/asy illu/rat$ by secrecy ( my/]y-rites1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,ec/asy 9 s\l does n ?9k ,god1 because %e doesn't ?9k1 vi4 #g4ce 7#ch-gei74 ,ec/asy is possession by div9ity1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,ec/asy1 l&-m>ks on pa? to1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ed74 ,ec/asy1 me*anism (1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,ec/asy1 p]man5t results1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,ec/asy results 9 begott5 son =m+ a new _w1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-ega74 ,ec/asy1 simplification1 sup] beauty & virtue1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,ec/asy1 ! degrees lead+ to ,god1 vi4 #gcf 7#ch-gfj74 ,ec/asy trance 7en?usiasm71 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,ec/asy1 trap on way to1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,ec/asy1 way to approa*1 fir/ pr9ciple1 v4 #e4aj1 #aa 7#cb-eia74 ,ec/asy1 :5 exp]i5c$1 leads to que/ions1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aai74 ,ec/asy's la/ /age1 vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,ec/asy's me?od1 is to close eyes ( body1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,ec/atic vision ( ,god1 *ief purpose ( life1 i4 #f4g 7#a-ea74 ,ec/atic1 subsequ5t exp]i5ces1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-aij74 ,education & tra9+1 memory ne$s1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hce74 ,effusion ( sup]-abundance is reation1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,effects1 diff]5ces 91 limit$ to intelligibles1 vi4 #c4ag 7#dd-ifd74 ,egyptian hi]oglyphics1 v4 #h4f 7#ca-efj74 ,elem5tal int]m$i>y s\l1 also inadmissible1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjg74 ,elem5tal process dem&s sub/rate1 ii1 #d4f 7#ab-bjc74 ,elem5ts & nature1 !re is cont9uity betwe51 iv4 #d4ad 7#bh-dei74 ,elem5ts are also individual1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hbc74 ,elem5ts are k9dr$1 ?r\gh _! common gr\nd1 ! univ]se body1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbd74 ,elem5ts1 e>? conta9s all1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hba74 ,elem5ts1 pr9ciples ( physici/s1 iii4 #a4c 7#c-hi74 ,elem5ts ( body _c h>monize !mselves1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gd74 ,elem5ts ( ess5ce c be said to be "o only figuratively1 vi4 #b4aj 7#dc-iji74 ,elem5ts ( univ]se1 simultane\sly pr9ciples & g5]al1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hic74 ,elem5ts t]re/rial1 d n degrade ! heav51 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hbc74 ,elevation ( s\l gradual1 v4 #c4i 7#di-aajf74 ,elim9at$1 is cont+5cy 9 analysis1 vi4 #h4ad 7#ci-gih74 ,emanations ( a s+le s\l1 are all s\ls1 iv4 #c 7#bg74 ,emanations ( light f sun1 v4 #c4ab 7#di-aaab74 ,emanations ( univ]sal s\l1 are individual s\ls1 iv4 #c4a 7#bg-chh74 ,emanations1 s5se & gr[? t5d t[>ds divisibility1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,emigration ( s\l %\ld n be =c$1 i4 #i 7#aj74 ,emotion at see+ ,god1 sign ( unification1 vi4 #i4d 7#i-aee74 ,emotions1 ,james ,lange1 !ory ( refut$1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaif74 ,emotions ( beauty caus$ by invisible s\l1 i4 #f4e 7#a-df74 ,en*antm5ts1 an active life1 pr$isposes to subjection to1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,en*antm5ts1 magic1 h[ to avoid !m1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eji74 ,en*antm5ts1 wise m5 escape all1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,end & pr9ciple1 simultane\s 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,end ( all o!r goods is ! ,supreme1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abji74 ,entele*y1 s\l is n1 iv4 #b4a2 iv4 #g4h 7#ba-bgf1 #b-gd-gg74 ,en]gy1 display$1 con/itutes a ?+'s be+1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,ennobl$ & intellectualiz$ is s\l1 scorn+ ev5 ?\ght1 vi4 #g4ce 7#ch-geg74 ,en?usiasm ( ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,entire ess5ce lov$ by be+1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbe74 ,entire ev]y:]e is univ]sal s\l1 vi4 #d4i 7#bb-cjj74 ,entire s\l1 fa%ion$ :ole & individuals1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cbb74 ,entire s\l is ev]y:]e1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,entities e>?ly1 n all h ideas correspond+1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aag74 ,entities incorporeal1 impassibility1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cea74 ,enum]ation ( div9e pr9ciples1 vi4 #g4be 7#ch-gdb74 ,enum]ation1 successive1 inevitable 9 describ+ ! et]nal1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abg74 ,epicurus1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eaf74 ,epime!us1 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab74 ,equator to ,ecliptic1 incl9ation1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,ere*!us1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejh74 ,eros1 ,platonic my? int]pretation (1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabe74 ,eros1 son ( ,v5us1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabe74 ,escape all en*antm5ts1 h[ ! wise m5 d1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,escape1 h[ to1 f ?is _w1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,escoreal fragm5t1 introduction to1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfj74 ,ess5ce alone1 possesses self exi/5ce1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgh74 ,ess5ce & be+1 di/9ction betwe51 ii4 #f4a 7#ag-bde74 ,ess5ce & /ability1 di/9ction betwe54 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijc74 ,ess5ce & unity1 g5u9e relations betwe51 vi4 #b4aa 7#dc-iaa74 ,ess5ce1 by x all ?+s dep5d on ! good1 i4 #g4b 7#ed-abji74 ,ess5ce _c become a g5us s long z x rema9s "o1 vi4 #b4i 7#dc-iji74 ,ess5ce d]ives its diff]5ce f o!r co-ord9ate categories1 vi4 #b4ai 7#dc-ibc74 ,ess5ce divisible if n !reby dim9i%$1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bij74 ,ess5ce elem5ts c be said to be "o only figuratively1 vi4 #b4aj 7#dc-iji74 ,ess5ce entire lov$ by be+1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbe74 ,ess5ce1 ideas & intellig5ce1 v4 #i 7#e-ajb74 ,ess5ce1 indivisible & divisible m$iat$ betwe5 by s\l1 iv4 #b 7#ba-bgf74 ,ess5ce indivisible becomes divisible )9 bodies1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgg74 ,ess5ce indivisible1 description (1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgg74 ,ess5ce intelligible1 is bo? 9 & out ( itself1 vi4 #e4c 7#bc-caf74 ,ess5ce is n cont+5t let alone sup]-ess5ce1 vi4 #h4i 7#ci-ghh74 ,ess5ce is ! orig9 ( all animals1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibh74 ,ess5ce1 location = ! ?+s yet to be produc$1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-feg74 ,ess5ce made intelligible by addition ( et]nity1 vi4 #b4a 7#dc-hib74 ,ess5ce m p]fect ?an actualiz$ be+1 ii4 #f4a 7#ag-bdg74 ,ess5ce mu/ be second 9 ord] to exi/ 9 gr\nd ( fir/1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,ess5ce n /able ?\gh immovable1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aec74 ,ess5ce n synonym\s ) unity1 vi4 #b4i 7#dc-ijh74 ,ess5ce1 numb] foll[s & proce$s f1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fee74 ,ess5ce ( s\l d]ives f its be+1 add+ life to ess5ce1 vi4 #b4f 7#dc-ijj74 ,ess5ce "o & id5tical is ev]y:]e1 entirely pres5t1 vi4 #d 7#bb-bhe74 ,ess5ce relation to be+1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehc74 ,ess5ce unity mu/ be s\ght = 9 x1 vi4 #e4a 7#bc-cad74 ,ess5ce's p[] & beauty1 is to attract all ?+s1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgh74 ,ess5tial numb]1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-feg74 ,et]nal be+1 c>es n = inequality ( ri*es4 ii1 #i4i 7#cc-faf74 ,et]nal g5]ation1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abg72 vi4 #g4c 7#ch-gjc72 vi4 #h4bj 7#ci-hji74 ,et]nal mu/ h be5 ! necessity to illum9ate d>kness1 ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbd74 ,et]nal reveal$ by s5se objects1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-acj74 ,et]nally begott51 is ! _w1 ii4 #i4c 7#cc-fjc74 ,et]nity add$ to ess5ce makes intelligible ess5ce1 vi4 #b4a 7#dc-hib74 ,et]nity & p]petuity1 diff]5ce betwe51 iii4 #g4d 7#de-iia74 ,et]nity & "t1 iii4 #g 7#de-ihe74 ,et]nity z union ( ! five categories1 iii1 #g4b 7#de-ihh74 ,et]nity at re/1 error 9 ?is1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihg74 ,et]nity exi/s p]petually1 iii4 #g4 introd4 7#de-ihe74 ,et]nity1 f1 is provid5ce ! plan ( ! univ]se1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjc74 ,et]nity has no future or pa/1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agi72 iii4 #g4d 7#de-iib74 ,et]nity is immutable 9 unity1 iii4 #g4e 7#de-iic74 ,et]nity is inf9ite1 univ]sal life1 t _c lose any?+1 iii1 #g4d 7#de-iib74 ,et]nity is sempit]nal exi/5ce1 iii4 #g4e 7#de-iic74 ,et]nity is ! model ( its image1 "t1 iii4 #g4 introd4 7#de-ihe74 ,et]nity is to exi/5ce1 z "t is int]ior to ! s\l1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjh74 ,et]nity is to intellig5ce1 :at "t is to ! _w-s\l4 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjg74 ,et]nity k9 to beauty1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabd74 ,et]nity n an accid5t ( ! intelligible1 b an intimate "p ( its nature1 iii4 #g4c 7#de-ihi74 ,et]nity ( s\l1 n affect$ by desc5t into body1 iv4 #g4ac 7#b-hc74 ,et]nity ( s\l prov$ by ?9k+ ! et]nal1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-ha74 ,et]nity1 relation (1 to intelligible be+1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihf74 ,et]nity replaces "t1 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,et]nity1 see ,aeon & pun on ,aeon1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihf74 ,evaporation1 expla9s a !ory ( mixture1 ii4 #g4b 7#cg-fid74 ,evaporation1 bo? ,/oic & ,ari/otelian refut$1 ii1 #g4b 7#cg-fie74 ,ev]y?+ is composite ( =m & matt]1 v4 #i4c 7#e-aje74 ,ev]y:]e & n[h]e is ,supreme1 incl9ation & imm95ce1 vi4 #h4af 7#ci-hja74 ,evil1 absolute1 goal ( deg5]ation ( ! s\l1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafc74 ,evil1 an evil is life )\t virtue1 i4 #g4c 7#ed-abaj74 ,evil are do]s1 :o play _! p>ts badly 9 drama ( life1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,evil z an ob/acle to ! s\l1 i4 #h4ab 7#ea-aaei74 ,evil z inf9ite & =mlessness z itself1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aade74 ,evil _c be possess$ )9 ! s\l1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeh74 ,evil con/itut$ by indet]m9ation1 success & lack1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,evil creator & _w are n1 ii4 #i 7#cc-eii74 ,evil effects ( suicide on s\l itself1 i4 #i 7#af-bdc74 ,evil ev5 is a multitude1 vi4 #f4a 7#cd-fdc74 ,evil ext]nal & int]nal1 relation betwe51 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadi74 ,evil1 h[ s5se-objects are n1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajee74 ,evil impli$ by good1 because matt] is necess>y to ! _w1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,evil 9 itself1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,evil 9 itself is ! prim>y evil1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aadf74 ,evil 9 ! s\l1 expla9$ by virtue z a h>mony1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ceb74 ,evil insep>able f good1 iii4 #c4g 7#dh-ajhh74 ,evil is consequ5ce ( d]ivative goods ( ?ird rank1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd74 ,evil is no "o vice 9 p>ticul>1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadh74 ,evil is s\l's ru%+ into region ( div]sity1 i4 #h4ac 7#ea-aafa74 ,evil is ! abs5ce ( good 9 ! s\l1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeg74 ,evil is weakness ( ! s\l1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafj74 ,evil1 its nature dep5ds on t ( good1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadc74 ,evil1 l[] =m ( good1 iii4 #b4g 7#dg-ajec72 vi4 #g4aj 7#ch-gaf74 ,evil1 nature (1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aadd74 ,evil1 necess>y1 is l[e/ degree ( be+1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,evil1 neutral1 is matt]1 vi1 #g4bh 7#ch-gdf74 ,evil1 none unalloy$ = ! liv+ p1 i4 #g4c 7#ed-abaj74 ,evil ( ! s\l1 explanation1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafc74 ,evil only figurative & antagoni/ ( good1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aaej74 ,evil possesses a l[] =m ( be+1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aade74 ,evil prim>y & second>y def9$1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaee74 ,evil1 prim>y & second>y1 ( s\l1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadh74 ,evil prim>y1 is evil 9 itself1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aadf74 ,evil prim>y is lack ( measure1 7d>kness71 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaed74 ,evil second>y1 is accid5tal =mlessness 7some?+ obscur$71 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaee74 ,evil second>y1 is matt]1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadf74 ,evil triumph$ ov]1 9 faculties n engag$ 9 matt]1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadi74 ,evil univ]sal & unavoidable1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aaej74 ,evil1 victory (1 accuses ,provid5ce1 iii4 #b4f 7#dg-ajeb74 ,evils are necess>y to ! p]fection ( ! univ]se1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahg74 ,evils ev5 if corporeal1 caus$ by matt]1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaec74 ,evil1 nature & orig9 (1 i4 #h 7#ea-aadb74 ,evils1 orig9 (1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abja74 ,evils1 t ! sage c support )\t di/urb+ happ9ess1 i4 #d4g 7#df-ajbi74 ,evolution impossible 7f imp]fect to p]fect71 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gc74 ,exam9ation1 = x only are p>ts ( a manifold unity ap>t1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hig74 ,exam9ation ( self1 i1 #f4i 7#a-ed74 ,exam9ation ( s\l1 body mu/ fir/ be dissociat$1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icd74 ,excursion d[n & up1 is procession ( intellig5ce1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,excursion yields ! s\l's two duties1 body managem5t & contemplation1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,exemption ( c]ta9 classes f div9e c>e1 he>tless1 ii4 #i4af 7#cc-fca74 ,exile1 gno/ic idea (1 oppos$1 ii4 #i4f 7#cc-fji74 ,exi/5ce absolute prec$es cont+5t1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hha74 ,exi/5ce1 all k9ds & grades (1 aim at contemplation1 iii4 #h4f 7#cj-ech74 ,exi/5ce1 category1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,exi/5ce1 desc5d+1 graduations (1 iv4 #c4ag 7#bg-dae74 ,exi/5ce1 h[ inf9ite arriv$ to x1 vi4 #f4c 7#cd-fde74 ,exi/5ce 9 intelligible1 be=e application to multiple be+s1 is reason1 vi4 #f4aa 7#cd-fei74 ,exi/5ce ( d>kness may be relat$ to ! s\l ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbe74 ,exi/5ce ( divisible ?+s1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgf74 ,exi/5ce ( fir/1 necess>y4 v4 #d4a 7#g-acd74 ,exi/5ce ( intellig5ce1 prov$1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,exi/5ce ( manifoldness impossible1 )\t some?+ simple1 ii4 #d4c 7#ab-aih74 ,exi/5ce ( memory alt] dea?1 & ( heav51 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,exi/5ce ( matt] is sure z t ( good1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafb74 ,exi/5ce ( object implies a previ\s model1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-feh74 ,exi/5ce ( o!r ?+s n preclud$ by unity1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bij74 ,exi/5ce1 prim>y1 w conta9 ?\ght1 exi/5ce & life1 ii4 #d4f 7#ab-bjc72 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cci74 ,exi/5ce real possess$ by "r ?\ghts1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacf74 ,exi/5ce sempit]nal is et]nity1 iii4 #g4e 7#de-iic74 ,exi/5ce ! fir/ be+ supra-cogitative1 does n "k itself1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cdj74 ,exi/5ce ?\ght & life conta9$ 9 prim>y exi/5ce1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cch74 ,exi/+ animal ( ,plato diff]s f intellig5ce1 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bbj74 ,exp]i5ce & action1 und]ly+ transmission1 reception1 & relation1 vi4 #a4bb 7#db-hge74 ,exp]i5ce does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4af 7#dc-ibj74 ,exp]i5ce necess>y to s\ls n /rong en\gh to d )\t x1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,exp]i5ce ( ec/asy leads to que/ions1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aai74 ,exp]i5ce ( evil yields k ( good1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,exp]i5ces1 s5sations are n1 b relative actualizations1 iv4 #f4b 7#da-hca74 ,exp]im5t propos$1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcc74 ,expiation is condition ( s\l 9 _w1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,expiations1 "t (1 betwe5 inc>nations1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,ext5sion is m]ely a sign ( p>ticipation into ! ^w ( life1 vi4 #d4ac 7#bb-cjf74 ,ext5sion1 none 9 beauty or ju/ice1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,ext5sion1 none 9 s\l or reason1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,ext5sions1 s\l 0 capable (1 be=e ! exi/5ce ( ! body1 vi4 #d4a 7#bb-bhe74 ,ext]nal & int]nal relation ( evil1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadi74 ,ext]nal circum/ances cause weal?1 pov]ty & vice1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagd74 ,exub]ant fruitfulness ( "o1 7see sup]-abundance71 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaaf74 ,eyes implant$ 9 man by div9e =esight1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,eyes impure c see no?+1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,eyes ( body1 close !m1 is me?od to a*ieve ec/asy1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,face to face1 vision ( ,god1 i4 #f4g 7#a-ej74 ,faces all ar\nd ! head1 simile (1 vi4 #e4g 7#bc-cbj74 ,faculty1 reawak5+ (1 is ! memory1 n an image1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hcc74 ,fai? abs5t 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,fai? 9 intelligible1 h[ a*iev$1 vi4 #i4e 7#i-aef74 ,fai? tea*es ,provid5ce rules ! _w1 iii4 #b4g 7#dg-ajed74 ,fall into g5]ation1 due to division into numb]1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abf74 ,fall into g5]ation may be p>tial & recov]y f1 possible1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddh74 ,fall n volunt>y1 b puni%m5t ( conduct1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,fall ( ! s\l z desc5t into matt]1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafa74 ,fall ( ! s\l due to bo? w & necessity1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,fall ( ! s\l due to guilt1 7,py?agorean71 iv4 #h4a 7#f-abj74 ,fate1 accord+ to ,/oic ,*rysippus1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hi74 ,fate detail$1 does n sway />s1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhi74 ,fate1 ,h]aclitian1 con/itut$ by action & passion1 iii4 #a4d 7#c-ia74 ,fate is unpr$ictable circum/ances1 alt]+ life curr5ts1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdb74 ,fate1 ma/]y (1 victory ov] self1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,fate1 may be ma/]$1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,fate1 obey$ by ! s\l only :5 evil1 iii1 #a4aj 7#c-ih74 ,fate ( ! divisible human s\l1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bda74 ,fate ( ?ree m5 9 u1 is brutalization or div9ization4 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh74 ,fate1 possible !ories ab\t x1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,fate sp9dle1 significance (1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aaga74 ,fate1 ! ,h]aclitian pr9ciple1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,fa!r1 v4 #a4h 7#aj-ahf72 v4 #e4c 7#cb-ehj74 ,fa!r1 dwells 9 heav51 i4 #f4h 7#a-ec74 ,fa!r ( intellig5ce1 "n ( fir/1 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eea74 ,fa!rl&1 heav51 i4 #f4h 7#a-ec74 ,faults are reason's failure to dom9ate matt]1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,faults come n f intellig5ce1 b f ! g5]ation process1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,faults 9 ! details _c *ange h>mony 9 univ]se1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahe74 ,faults ( ! def9ition1 t et]nity is at re/ :ile "t is 9 motion1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihg74 ,faults ( ! s\l1 two possible1 motive & de$s1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,fe> ( dea?1 ov]com+ (1 is c\rage1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,fea/1 div9ities seat$ at1 mean+1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aaci74 ,feel]1 ! s\l impli$ by s5sation i4 #a4f 7#ec-aaih74 ,feel]1 :o is !1 v4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,feel+ is p]ception by use ( body1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dge74 ,feel+s1 modes ( passions1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,fidelity1 k9%ip to "o's own nature1 iii4 #c4a 7#dh-ajgg74 ,field ( tru?1 intellig5ce evolves ov]1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbc74 ,figurative expressions1 reason+ & =esight are only1 vi4 #g4a 7#cg-fii74 ,figure1 sph]ical & intelligible is ! primitive "o1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fge74 ,figures h *>act]i/ic effects1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-dih74 ,figures pre-exi/ 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fge74 ,fire & air1 action (1 n ne$$ by heav51 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbf74 ,fire & e>? conta9$ 9 ! />s1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hba74 ,fire1 & light cele/ial1 nature1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbe74 ,fire conta9$ 9 intelligible _w1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gai74 ,fire image (1 lat5t & radiant1 v4 #a4c 7#aj-agg74 ,fire1 ?\gh an app>5t exception1 con=ms to ?is1 ii4 #a4c 7#dj-hag74 ,fir/ & o!r goods1 #a4g 7#ed-abjh74 ,fir/ does n conta9 any ?+ to be kn[n1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cci74 ,fir/ does n "k itself1 be+ supra-cogitative1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cci74 ,fir/1 exi/5ce (1 necess>y1 v4 #d4a 7#g-acd74 ,fir/ impossible to g beyond x1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gia74 ,fir/ mu/ be "o exclusively1 mak+ ! "o supra-?9k+1 v4 #f4c 7#bd-cdj74 ,fir/ pr9ciple has no ne$ ( see+ itself1 v4 #c4aj 7#di-aajf74 ,fir/ pr9ciple has no pr9ciple1 vi4 #g4cg 7#ch-gfb74 ,fir/ pr9ciple has no ?\ght1 ! fir/ actualization ( a hypo/asis1 vi4 #g4dj 7#ch-gff74 ,fir/ pr9ciple is above ?\ght1 v4 #f4bf 7#bd-cch74 ,fir/ pr9ciple may n ev5 be said to exi/1 is sup]-exi/5ce1 vi4 #g4ch 7#ch-gfc74 ,fit itself1 ! s\l mu/ to its "p 9 ! ske91 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajgb74 ,fit y\rself & und]/& ! _w1 in/ead ( compla9+ ( x1 ii4 #i4ac 7#cc-fbe74 ,five physical categories ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,five ,plot9ic categories1 :y none m c be add$1 vi4 #b4i 7#dc-ijg74 ,flee+ f intellig5ce1 r ?an intellig5ce f s\l1 v4 #e4aj 7#cb-eia74 ,flight f evil1 n by locality b virtue1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,flight f "h bel[1 i4 #b4f 7#ea-aaej72 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aage72 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb72 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,flight f "h bel[1 if prompt1 leaves s\l unh>m$1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,flight f _w is assimilation to div9ity1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfc74 ,flight is simplification or deta*m5t ( ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,fluctuation ne$ n int]f]e ) cont9uance1 ii4 #a4c 7#dj-haf74 ,flux1 heav5 ?\gh 91 p]petuates itself by =m1 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-hac74 ,flux ( all beauties "h bel[1 vi4 #g4ca 7#ch-gea74 ,foll[]s ( ! k+ are univ]sal />s1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,=eign accretion is ugl9ess1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dh74 ,=eign s\rces1 d]iv$ f modification1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abjb74 ,=ekn[l$ge ( physician l plans ( ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,=esight & reason+ are only figurative expressions1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fii74 ,=esight by ,god ( mis=tunes1 n cause ( s5ses 9 man1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,=esight1 eyes implant$ 9 man by x1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,=esight ( creation1 n result ( reason1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fih74 ,=m & light1 two me?ods ( sight1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,=m & matt] 9 all ?+s1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,=m & matt] int]m$i>y betwe51 is s5se-object1 iii4 #f4ag 7#bf-cha74 ,=m z model1 = produc+ pr9ciple1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efb74 ,=m be+ un*angeable1 s is matt]1 iii4 #f4aj 7#bf-cfh74 ,=m diff]5ce ( matt]1 due to t ( _! intelligible s\rces1 vi4 #c4h 7#dd-idf74 ,=m1 disappe>ance (1 implies t ( size1 ii4 #h4b 7#ce-fhb74 ,=m ext]ior is ! ov]%ad[$1 inactive p>ts ( ! s\l1 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bce74 ,=m improves matt]1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gde74 ,=m 9 itself1 none 9 ! good1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gdf74 ,=m is n quality b a reason1 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh74 ,=m is second physical category ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,=m is ! dream ( ! good1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gde74 ,=m ( a ?+ is its good1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gdd74 ,=m ( a ?+ is its :yness1 vi4 #g4b 7#ch-gjb74 ,=m ( =ms1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gca74 ,=m ( good borne by life1 intellig5ce & idea1 vi4 #g4b 7#ch-gcb74 ,=m ( good may exi/ at v>y+ degrees1 vi4 #g4b 7#ch-gcb74 ,=m ( ! body is ! s\l1 iv4 #g4a1 #b 7#b-eg74 ,=m ( unity1 is pr9ciple ( numb]s1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehc74 ,=m ( univ]se1 z s\l is1 w\ld be matt]1 if a prim>y pr9ciple1 iii4 #f4ah 7#bf-chb74 ,=m only 9 ! s5se-_w1 proce$s f intellig5ce1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,=m sub/antial1 ! s\l mu/ be z %e is n simple matt]1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fa74 ,=m] lives cause pres5t "*1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajhc74 ,=mless %ape is absolute beauty1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,=mlessness 9 itself & inf9ite is evil1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aade74 ,=mlessness ( "o1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,=mlessness ( ! ,supreme %[n by approa*+ s\l's rejection ( =m1 vi4 #g4cd 7#ch-gef74 ,=ms ( gov]nm5ts1 v>i\s1 s\l resembles1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfd74 ,=ms rational s5se & vegetative1 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bcd74 ,=ms1 ?\gh la/ degree ( exi/5ce1 are fa9t images1 v4 #c4g 7#di-aajb74 ,=tune1 *anges (1 affect only ! out] man1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajfg74 ,fre$om1 = ! s\l1 lies 9 foll[+ reason1 iii4 #a4i 7#c-ig74 ,fre$om ( w1 & virtue1 are indep5d5t ( actions1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-gge74 ,fre$om ( w1 on :i* psy*ological faculty is x bas$8 vi4 #h4b 7#ci-gge74 ,fri5ds ( ,plot9os1 =m]ly gno/ic1 ii4 #i4aj 7#cc-fbj74 ,functions1 if n localiz$1 s\l w n seem )9 u1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dai74 ,functions1 none 9 ! fir/ pr9ciple1 vi4 #g4cg 7#ch-gfb74 ,fund ( memory1 p>tition$ betwe5 bo? s\ls1 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dci74 ,fusion =ms body & s\l1 iv4 #d4ah 7#bh-dfe74 ,fusion ) ! div9ity1 result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,future det]m9$1 accord+ to pr$iction1 iii4 #a4c 7#c-ij74 ,future necess>y to begott5 ?+s n to ! intelligible1 iii4 #g4c 7#de-iij74 ,gad-fly1 love is1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacd74 ,galli1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che74 ,g>d5 ( ,jupit] is ! reason t begets ev]y?+1 iii4 #e4i 7#ej-aacg74 ,g>d5 ( ,jupit]1 mean+ (1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aach74 ,g5]a & individuals are di/9ct1 z be+ actualizations1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hid74 ,g5]a exi/ bo? 9 subord9ate objects1 & 9 !mselves1 vi4 #b4ab 7#dc-iae74 ,g5]a1 fir/ two1 are be+ & movem5t1 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijb74 ,g5]a ( ess5ce decid$ ab\t by "o & _m puzzle1 vi4 #b4d 7#dc-hih74 ,g5]a ( ! physical are diff]5t f ^? ( ! intelligible1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icc74 ,g5]a1 ,plot9ic five1 are prim>y because no?+ c be affirm$ ( !m1 vi4 #b4i 7#dc-ijf74 ,g5]al1 simile ( ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4b 7#dh-ajgh74 ,g5]ation1 common elem5t ) gr[? & increase1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-ige74 ,g5]ation et]nal1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abg72 vi4 #g4c 7#ch-gjc72 vi4 #h4bj 7#ci-hji74 ,g5]ation fall+ into1 causes tr\ble1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bda74 ,g5]ation 9 ! s5se-_w1 is :at be+ is 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #c4b 7#dd-ice74 ,g5]ation is l light+ fire f refraction1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf74 ,g5]ation is radiation ( an image1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb74 ,g5]ation ( ev]y?+ is regulat$ by a numb]1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-fgj74 ,g5]ation ( matt]1 consequ5ces ( ant]ior pr9ciples1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,g5]ation ( ! ung5]at$1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aach74 ,g5]ation1 f ! good1 is intellig5ce1 v4 #a4h 7#aj-ahf74 ,g5]ation's et]nal resid5ce is matt]1 iii4 #f4ac 7#bf-cgc74 ,g5]atively1 all ?+s conta9$ by intellig5ce1 v4 #i4f 7#e-aji74 ,g5tl5ess1 sign ( naturalness z ( heal? & unconsci\sness ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,g5us1 ano!r1 is /ability1 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijc74 ,g5us divides 9 c]ta9 animals1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,g5us1 !re is m ?an "o1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hie7 ,geometry1 an intelligible art1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aae74 ,geometry /udies quantities1 n qualities1 vi4 #c4ae 7#dd-ieh74 ,giv+ )\t loss 7a ,num5ian idea71 vi4 #i4i 7#i-afe74 ,glutton\s p :o gorge !mselves at ! c]emonies & leave )\t my/]ies1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-eib74 ,gno/ic plann+ ( ! _w by ,god1 refut$1 v4 #h4g1 #ab 7#ca-efa1 #egb74 ,god _c be responsible = our ills1 iv4 #d4ci 7#bh-ejc74 ,god n rememb]$ by _w-s\l cont9u+ to be se51 iv4 #d4g 7#bh-ddi74 ,god's plann+ ( ! _w 7gno/icism7 refut$1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efa74 ,god relation ) individual & s\l1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,gold5 face ( ,ju/ice1 i4 #f4d 7#a-de74 ,good absolute1 p]man5ce *ief *>act]i/ic1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abji74 ,good1 all ?+s dep5d on by unity1 ess5ce & quality1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abji74 ,good & beauty id5tical1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,good & "o1 vi4 #i 7#i-adg74 ,good z consi/+ 9 intellig5ce1 i4 #d4c 7#df-ajbd74 ,good1 z ev]y?+ t5ds t[>d x1 x t5ds t[>d ! "o1 vi4 #b4ab 7#dc-iad74 ,good1 z supra-cogitative1 is also supra-active1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cdj74 ,good z supreme1 nei!r ne$s nor possesses intellection1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edh74 ,good _c be a desire ( ! s\l1 vi4 #g4ai 7#ch-gcd74 ,good _c be pleasure1 :i* is *angeable & re/less1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-ged74 ,good consi/s 9 illum9ation by ! ,supreme1 vi4 #g4bb 7#ch-gcg74 ,good conta9s no ?\ght1 vi4 #g4dj 7#ch-gff74 ,good does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4ag 7#dc-ibb74 ,good1 ev5 if x ?\ght1 !re w\ld be ne$ ( some?+ sup]ior1 vi4 #g4dj 7#ch-gfg74 ,good1 =m (1 borne by life1 intellig5ce & idea1 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gca74 ,good = ! individual is illum9ation1 vi4 #g4bd 7#ch-gdj74 ,good has no ne$ ( beauty1 :ile beauty has ( ! good1 v4 #e4ab 7#cb-eid74 ,good1 if x is a g5us1 mu/ be "o ( ! po/]ior ones1 vi4 #b4ag 7#dc-iba74 ,good1 impli$ by scorn ( life1 vi4 #g4bi 7#ch-gdh74 ,good implies evil because matt] is necess>y to ! _w1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,good1 9 :at does x consi/1 iv4 #a4 ,good1 insep>able f evil1 iii4 #c4g 7#dh-ajhh74 ,good1 intellig5ce & s\l1 are l light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,good is a nature t possesses no k9d ( =m 9 itself1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gdf74 ,good is a simple p]ception ( itself2 a t\*1 vi4 #g4ci 7#ch-gfd74 ,good is creator & pres]v]1 vi4 #g4bc 7#ch-gdj74 ,good is free1 b n m]ely by *ance1 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ghc74 ,good is n = itself1 b = ! natures bel[ x1 vi4 #g4da 7#ch-gfi74 ,good is intellig5ce & prim>y life1 vi4 #g4ba 7#ch-gcg74 ,good1 is x a common label or a common quality8 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gcc74 ,good is n only cause1 b intuition ( be+1 vi4 #g4af 7#ch-gbh74 ,good is su*1 j because x has no attributes wor?y ( x1 v4 #e4ac 7#cb-eie74 ,good is sup]ior to all its possessions1 z result ( its be+ supreme1 v4 #e4ab 7#cb-eie74 ,good is sup]ior to beautiful & is cogniz$ by m9d1 v4 #e4ab 7#cb-eid74 ,good is sup]-?9k+1 v4 #f4e 7#bd-cch74 ,good is sup]-?\ght1 iii4 #i4i 7#ac-bbe74 ,good is supreme1 because ( its supremacy1 vi4 #g4bc 7#ch-gci74 ,good is desirable 9 itself1 vi4 #h4h 7#ci-ghc74 ,good is ! :ole1 ?\gh conta9+ evil p>ts1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajgj74 ,good is l[] =m ( evil1 iii4 #b4g 7#dg-ajec74 ,good leaves ! s\l s]5e1 beauty tr\bles x1 v4 #e4ab 7#cb-eid74 ,good may accompany ! pleasure1 b x is indep5d5t ( x1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gde74 ,good may neglect natural laws t c>ry revolts1 iii1 #b4i 7#dg-ajeg74 ,good1 multitude ( ideas (1 vi4 #g 7#ch-fig74 ,good mu/ be sup]ior to intellig5ce & life1 v4 #c4af 7#di-aaag74 ,good n to be expla9$ by ,ari/otelian intellig5ce1 vi4 #g4bj 7#ch-gcf74 ,good n to be expla9$ by ,py?agorean oppositions1 vi4 #g4bj 7#ch-gce74 ,good n to be expla9$ by ,/oic *>act]i/ic virtue1 vi4 #g4bj 7#ch-gcf74 ,good ( a ?+ is its intimacy ) itself1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gdd74 ,good only antagoni/ic & figurative ( evil1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aaej74 ,good1 ,platonic discuss$1 vi4 #g4be 7#ch-gda74 ,good relat$ to intellig5ce & s\l z light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,good1 self-suffici5t1 does n ne$ self consci\sness1 vi4 #g4ch 7#ch-gfc74 ,good1 slav]y (1 accuses ,provid5ce1 iii4 #b4f 7#dg-ajeb74 ,good1 /udy1 vi4 #g4ae sqq41 7#ch-gbf74 ,good sup]ior to beauty1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ee74 ,good supreme1 ,ari/otelian1 vi4 #g4be 7#ch-gdb74 ,good ! fir/ & o!r goods1 i4 #g 7#ed-abjh74 ,good1 !re=e also supra-active1 v4 #f4e 7#bd-cch74 ,good1 true1 implies c\nt]feit1 vi4 #g4bf 7#ch-gdc74 ,goods1 all1 c be describ$ z a =m1 i4 #h4a 7#ea-aadb72 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,goods1 indep5d5ce f pleasure is temp]ate man1 vi4 #g4bi 7#ch-gdg74 ,goods ( ?ree ranks1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd74 ,goods1 ,plato's op9ion int]pret$ 9 two ways1 vi4 #g4cj 7#ch-gdi74 ,goods1 supreme z end ( all o!r ones1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abjh74 ,gorge ) food1 v4 #e4aa 7#cb-eib74 ,gov]n+ pr9ciple1 ,/oic1 iii4 #a4b1 #d 7#c-hi1 #ia74 ,gov]nm5ts1 s\l resembles all =ms (1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfd74 ,gradations1 desc5d+ ( exi/5ce1 iv4 #c4g 7#bg-dae74 ,grades ( ?\ght & life1 iii4 #h4g 7#cj-edj74 ,gr& ,fa!r supreme1 v4 #e4c 7#cb-eha74 ,grasp m p]fect1 increases happ9ess1 i4 #e4c 7#cf-fhe74 ,gravitation1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eag74 ,greatness ( s\l1 no?+ to d ) size ( body1 vi4 #d4e 7#bb-bic74 ,grotto1 ,emp$oclean simile ( _w1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-abj74 ,gr\p1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,gr\p unites1 all l[]1 adju/$ to supreme unity1 vi4 #f4aa 7#cd-ffj74 ,gr\ps-(-f\r1 or t5s1 ,py?agorean1 vi4 #f4e 7#cd-fdi74 ,gr[?1 common elem5ts ) increase & g5]ation1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-ige74 ,gr[?1 localiz$ 9 liv]1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbf74 ,gr[? p[]1 relation ( to ! desire function1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dgj74 ,gr[?1 s5se & emotions1 t5d t[>ds divisibility1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,gr[?-s\l d]iv$ f _w-s\l1 n ours1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adc74 ,guidance ( ,daemon does n int]f]e ) responsibility1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bch74 ,guilt cause ( fall ( s\ls1 7,py?agorean71 iv4 #h4a 7#f-abj74 ,guilt n incurr$ by s\l 9 tol]ation1 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,gymna/ics1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aad74 ,habit intellectualiz+1 t lib]ates ! s\l1 is virtue1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-ghj74 ,habit1 ,/oic1 ii4 #d4af 7#ab-bah72 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gc74 ,habit1 ,/oic1 z />t ( evolution to s\l1 impossible1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gc74 ,habituation1 ii4 #e4b 7#be-cde74 ,habituation1 active1 imm$iate1 & remote1 di/9ction betwe51 vi4 #a4h 7#db-hdi71 ,habituation or sub/antial act is hypo/asis1 vi4 #a4f 7#db-hde74 ,habituation1 ,/oic1 mu/ be po/]ior to reasons z ar*etypes1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajh74 ,habituations are reasons :i* p>ticipate 9 =m1 vi4 #a4i 7#db-hej74 ,hades1 *a/isem5ts1 i4 #g4c 7#ed-abaj74 ,hades1 :at x means = ! c>e] ( ! s\l1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-cab74 ,happ9ess accord+ to ,ari/otle1 i4 #d4a 7#df-ajai74 ,happ9ess z s5sation1 does n h9d] se>* = high]1 i4 #d4b 7#ajba74 ,happ9ess def9$1 i4 #d4a1 #c 7#df-ajai1 #ajbc74 ,happ9ess dep5d5t ^u int]ior *>act]i/ics1 i4 #d4c 7#df-ajbc74 ,happ9ess1 does x increase ) duration ( "t8 #a4e 7#cf-fhd74 ,happ9ess has no?+ to d ) duration1 i4 #e4a1 #e 7#cf-fhd1 #fhe74 ,happ9ess has no?+ to d ) pleasure1 i4 #e4d 7#cf-fhe74 ,happ9ess 9 goal ( ea* "p ( _! natures1 i4 #d4e 7#df-ajbf74 ,happ9ess increas$ w\ld result only f m grasp1 i4 #e4c 7#cf-fhe74 ,happ9ess is actualiz$ wisdom1 i4 #d4i 7#df-ajcc74 ,happ9ess is desir+ no?+ fur!r1 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbf74 ,happ9ess is human 7mu/ be some?+71 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbe74 ,happ9ess is n ! satisfaction ( desire to live1 i4 #e4b 7#cf-fhd74 ,happ9ess1 lack ( blame on a s\l t does n des]ve x1 iii4 #b4e 7#dg-ajej74 ,happ9ess n increas$ by memories ( ! pa/1 i4 #e4i 7#cf-fhi74 ,happ9ess ( animals1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbj74 ,happ9ess ( plants1 i4 #d4a 7#df-ajai74 ,happ9ess ( sage n dim9i%$ 9 adv]sity1 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbf74 ,happ9ess1 "o %\ld n consid] oneself alone capable ( a*iev+ x1 ii4 #i4aj 7#cc-fai74 ,h>m1 none c happ5 to ! good1 iii4 #b4f 7#dg-ajea74 ,h>mony z a s+le univ]se1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aagj74 ,h>mony _c be reproduc$ f badly tun$ lyre1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,h>mony is univ]se 9 spite ( ! faults 9 ! details1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahe74 ,h>mony po/]ior to body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gd74 ,h>mony presupposes produc+ s\l1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-ge74 ,h>mony 7,py?agorean71 s\l is n1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gd74 ,h>mony sympa!tic1 e>? feels & directs by x1 iv4 #d4bf 7#bh-dgg74 ,hate ( ! body by ,plato1 supplem5t$ by admiration ( ! _w1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcc74 ,hate1 virtue is a1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ceb74 ,hav+ z ,ari/otelian category1 vi4 #a4bc 7#db-hgf74 ,hav+ is too indef9ite & v>i\s to be a category1 vi4 #a4bc 7#db-hgf74 ,head1 seat ( reason1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbe74 ,head1 ) faces all r\nd1 simile (1 vi4 #e4g 7#bc-cbj74 ,heal? is temp]man5t ( corporeal pr9ciples1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-ga74 ,he>+ & vision1 process (1 iv4 #e 7#bi-ead74 ,he>t1 seat ( ang]1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbf74 ,heav51 ii4 #a 7#dj-hac74 ,heav51 accord+ to ,h]aclitus1 oppos$1 ii4 #a4b 7#dj-hae74 ,heav51 exi/5ce (1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eab74 ,heav5 ne$s n ! action ( air or fire1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbf74 ,heav5 possesses s\l & body & supports ,plot9os's view1 ii4 #a4b 7#dj-hae74 ,heav51 s\ls fir/ g into x 9 intelligible1 iv4 #c4ag 7#bg-dae74 ,heav51 !re mu/ inevitably be *ange1 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-hac74 ,heav51 ?\gh influx p]petuates itself by =m1 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-hac74 ,heav5s aft] dea?1 is /> h>moniz+ ) _! pr$om9ant moral p[]1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bci74 ,heav5s d n rema9 /ill1 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-had74 ,heav5's immortality also due to univ]sal s\l's spontane\s motion1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hah74 ,heav5's immortality due to its resid5ce1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hag74 ,heav5's immortality prov$ by hav+ no beg9n+1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hai74 ,hel51 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,hel5a's beauty1 :5ce x came1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eec74 ,hell1 desc5t into1 by s\ls1 i4 #h4ac 7#ea-aafj74 ,hell 9 my/]y tea*+s1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,hell1 :at x means = ! c>e] ( ! s\l1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-cab74 ,hells1 ,platonic int]9c>national judgm5t & expiation1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,hell's torm5ts are re=matory1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eab74 ,help = sub-div9e natures is ?\ght1 vi4 #g4da 7#ch-gfh74 ,help f div9ity1 s\ght to solve difficulties1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb74 ,h]aclidae1 vi4 #a4c 7#db-hdj74 ,h]cules z d\ble1 symbolizes s\l1 i4 #a4ac 7#ec-abjf74 ,h]cules1 symbol ( man1 9 ! hells1 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjf72 iv4 #c4bg1 #ca 7#bg-dcc1 #ddj74 ,h]$ity a legitimate cause1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-id74 ,h]$ity m important ?an /> influ5ce1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-id74 ,h]maphrodite1 or ca/rat$1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che72 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,h]mes1 i?yphallic1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che74 ,hi]>*y 9 univ]se 7see concat5ation71 v4 #d4a 7#g-ace74 ,high]1 or some:at1 a p>ticle t is prefix$ to any ,/atem5t ab\t ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gig74 ,high] "p ( s\l sees vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efi74 ,high] region1 rea*$ only by born philosoph]s1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,high] /ages ( love1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,high] ?+s f !m ! l[] proce$1 i4 #h4a 7#ea-aadb74 ,highe/1 by x s\ls are unit$1 vi #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,highe/ self ( s\l is memory's basis1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hcb74 ,homely virtues are ! civil1 ,platonic f\r1 i4 #b4a 7#ai-beg74 ,homonyms1 or labels1 see ref]5ces to puns2 also1 vi4 #a4b1 #aj1 #aa1 #bc1 #bf2 vi4 #b4aj2 vi4 #c4a1 #e4 ,hone/y escapes magic1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eji74 ,hone/y results f contemplation ( ! intelligible1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eji74 ,horizon ( div9e approa* is contemplat+ intellig5ce1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehf72 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,horoscopes d n acc\nt = simultane\s diff]5ces1 iii4 #a4e 7#c-ic74 ,h\ses & aspects1 absurdity (1 ii4 #c4d 7#eb-aafh74 ,h[ to deta* ! s\l f ! body naturally1 #a4i 7#af-bdc74 ,human be+s add to ! beauty ( ! _w1 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab74 ,human life conta9s happ9ess1 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbe74 ,human nature int]m$iate1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaa74 ,human nature relation to animal1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,human organism /udi$ to expla9 s\l relation1 iv4 #c4c 7#bg-cic74 ,human s\l & _w-s\l diff]5ces betwe51 ii4 #i4g 7#cc-faa74 ,hypo/ases t transmit k 7see ! new title71 v4 #c 7#di-ajij74 ,hypo/asis1 v4 #a4d1 #f 7#aj-ahj to #ahd74 ,hypo/asis are p]man5t actualizations1 v4 #c4ab 7#di-aaaa74 ,hypo/asis z sub/antial act1 iii4 #d4a 7#ae-bcc74 ,hypo/asis is a sub/antial act or habituation1 vi4 #a4f 7#db-hde74 ,hypo/asis n 9 loves contr>y to nature1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacd74 ,hypo/asis ( love1 iii4 #e4b1 #c1 #g 7#ej-aabe1 #aabg1 #aacc74 ,hypo/asis ( ousia1 v4 #e4c 7#cb-eha74 ,hypo/asis ! fir/ actualization ( fir/ pr9ciple has no ?\ght1 vi4 #g4dj 7#ch-gff74 ,hypo/atic exi/5ce1 vi4 #f4i1 #ab 7#cd-fee1 #ffa72 vi4 #h4aj1 #ab 7#ci-gij1 #gic74 ,hypo/atic exi/5ce ( matt] prov$1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafb72 ii4 #d 7#ab-aig74 ,idea nam$ exi/5ce & intellig5ce1 v4 #a4h 7#aj-ahf74 ,ideas & numb]s1 id5tification (1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fef74 ,ideas1 desc5t (1 into individuals1 vi4 #e4f 7#bc-cbj74 ,ideas1 diff]5t1 = tw9s1 bro!rs or "w ( art1 v4 #g4a 7#ah-beb74 ,ideas imply =m & sub/rate1 ii4 #d4d 7#ab-aii74 ,ideas1 intellig5ce & ess5ce1 v4 #i 7#e-ajb74 ,ideas1 multitude (1 ( ! good1 vi4 #g 7#ch-fig74 ,ideas n = all e>?ly entities1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aag74 ,ideas ( individuals1 d !y exi/ v4 #g4a 7#ah-bea74 ,ideas ( individuals1 two possible hypo!ses1 v4 #g4a 7#ah-bea74 ,ideas or reasons possess$ by intellectual life1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibg74 ,ideas p>ticipat$ 9 by matt]1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cba74 ,id5tification1 unreflective1 memory n z high1 iv4 #d4d 7#bh-dde74 ,id5tity & diff]5ce impli$ by triune process ( categories1 vi4 #b4h 7#dc-ije74 ,id5tity1 category1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,id5tity ( ?\ght & exi/5ce makes actualizations ( intellig5ce1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajg74 ,id5tity1 sub/antial1 inconsi/5t ) logical di/9ctness1 ii4 #d4ad 7#ab-bad74 ,ignorance ( div9ity1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc74 ,ignorance illusory because ov]natural g5tl5ess1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,ignores ev]y?+1 does ,god1 be+ above ?\ght1 vi4 #g4ch 7#ch-gfc74 ,illum9ation1 creation by m]e gno/ic1 oppos$1 ii4 #i4aa 7#cc-fbb74 ,illum9ation ( d>kness mu/ h be5 et]nal1 ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbd74 ,illum9ation1 ! good is1 = ! individual1 vi4 #g4bd 7#ch-gdj74 ,illu/rations1 see ,simile4 ,image1 v4 #e4a 7#aj-agd72 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,image b\nd to model by radiation1 vi4 #d4aj 7#bb-cjj74 ,image =m$ by ! univ]sal be+s1 is magnitude1 iii4 #f4ag 7#bf-chj74 ,image 9 mirror1 iv4 #e4g 7#bi-ebh74 ,image ( ar*etype is ,jupit]1 begott5 by ec/asy1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,image ( intellig5ce is only a sample t mu/ be purifi$1 v4 #c4c 7#ca-eee74 ,image ( its model et]nity is "t1 iii4 #a1 introd4 7#de-ihe74 ,image ( "o intellig5ce1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd74 ,images d n rea* eye by influx1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eaf74 ,images ext]nal produce passions1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-ceh74 ,imag9ation1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbh74 ,imag9ation1 bo? k9ds1 impli$ by bo? k9ds ( memory1 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dhc74 ,imag9ation does n entirely pres]ve intellectual conceptions1 iv4 #c4cj 7#bg-dcg74 ,imag9ation is relat$ to op9ion1 z matt] to reason1 iii4 #f4ae 7#bf-cgg74 ,imag9ation1 memory belongs to x1 iv4 #c4bi 7#bg-dcf74 ,imag9ation1 ( ! two1 "o always ov]%ad[s ! o!r1 iv4 #c4c 7#bg-dch74 ,imitation ( ! fir/1 v4 #d4a 7#g-ace74 ,immat]ial natures c\ld n be affect$1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,imman5ce & incl9ation is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4af 7#ci-hja74 ,immortal1 are we1 all ( u1 or only p>ts8 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,immortal z ! ,"o f :om !y proce$1 are s\ls1 vi4 #d4aj 7#bb-cja74 ,immortal s\l1 ev5 on ,/oic hypo!sis1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-hj74 ,immortality does n ext5d to sublun> sph]e1 ii4 #a4e4 ,immortality 9 s\ls ( animals & plants1 iv4 #g4ad 7#b-hd74 ,immortality ( heav5 also due to univ]sal s\l's spontane\s motion1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hah74 ,immortality ( heav5 due to its resid5ce !re1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hag74 ,immortality ( heav5 prov$ by hav+ no beg9n+1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hai74 ,immortality ( s\l1 iv4 #g 7#b-ef74 ,immortality ( s\l prov$ hi/orically1 iv4 #g4ae 7#b-he74 ,immovability ( ,intellig5ce necess>y to make x act z horizon1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,impassible1 & puni%able1 s\l is bo?1 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjd74 ,impassible are _w s\l & />s1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-ejf74 ,impassible z ! s\l is1 ev]y?+ contr>y is figurative1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cea74 ,impassible1 h[ c ! s\l rema91 ?\gh giv5 up to emotion1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cea74 ,impassibility ( incorporeal entities1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cea74 ,impassibility ( matt] dep5ds on diff]5t s5ses ( p>ticipation1 iii4 #f4i 7#bf-cff74 ,impassibility ( ! s\l1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,imp]fection1 cause ( di/ance f ! ,supreme1 iii4 #c4c 7#dh-ajhj74 ,imp]fections are only l[] =ms ( p]fections1 vi4 #g4aj 7#ch-gaf74 ,imp]fections ( _w %\ld n be blam$ on x1 iii4 #b4c 7#dg-ajdf74 ,imp]i%able is _w1 s long z ar*etype subsi/s1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,imp]i%able1 no way ! s\l c\ld p]i%1 iv4 #g4ab 7#b-hb74 ,imp]i%able s\l1 ev5 by inf9ite division1 iv4 #g4ab 7#b-hc74 ,importance to virtue1 n1 duration ( "t1 i4 #e4aj 7#cf-fhi74 ,impossible to g beyond ,fir/1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gia74 ,impression admits no cognition ( intelligible objects1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hcb74 ,impressions on seal ( wax1 s5sations1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-ff74 ,improvem5t ( ! l[1 de/9y to become s\ls1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,improvem5t ( :at is bel[ h]1 "o object ( inc>nation1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,impure eye c see no?+1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,inadequacy ( philosophical language1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gig74 ,inanimate entirely1 no?+ 9 univ]se is1 iv4 #d4cf 7#bh-dii74 ,inc>nation1 diff]5ce betwe5 human & cosmic1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abc74 ,inc>nation ( s\l2 its object is p]fection ( univ]se1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abi74 ,inc>nation ( s\l mann]1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbb74 ,inc>nation ( s\l n cause ( possess+ memory1 iv4 #c4bf 7#bg-dca74 ,inc>nation1 /udy (1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-djc74 ,inc>nation unlikely1 unless s\ls h disposition to suff]1 ii4 #c4aj 7#eb-aagg74 ,inc>nations1 betwe51 hell's judgm5t & expiation1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,inc>nation's purpose is1 self-developm5t & improvem5t1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,incl9ation & imman5ce is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4af 7#ci-hja74 ,incl9ation ( equator to ecliptic1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,incompreh5sible unity approa*$ only by a pres5ce1 vi4 #i4d 7#i-aed74 ,incorporeal entities alone activate body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gj74 ,incorporeal entities1 impossibility (1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,incorporeal matt]1 ii4 #d4b 7#ab-aih74 ,incorporeal objects limit$ to highe/ ?\ghts1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gh74 ,incorporeal1 ! s\l rema9s1 vi4 #c4af 7#dd-ifb74 ,incorporeal qualities1 ii4 #g4b 7#cg-fie72 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhe74 ,incorporeality ( div9ity1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hhj74 ,incorporeality ( intelligible entities1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gh74 ,incorporeality ( matt] & quantity1 ii4 #d4i 7#ab-bjf74 ,incorporeality ( s\l mu/ be /udi$1 iv4 #g4b1 #h 7#b-eg1 #fh74 ,incorporeality ( s\l prov$ by its p5etrat+ body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,incorporeality ( s\l prov$ by k9%ip ) ,div9e1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-gi74 ,incorporeality ( s\l prov$ by priority ( actualization1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-ga74 ,incorporeality ( virtue1 n p]i%able1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,incorruptible matt] exi/s only pot5tially1 ii4 #e4e 7#be-cdh74 ,increase1 common elem5t1 ) gr[? & g5]ation1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-ige74 ,increas$ happ9ess w\ld result only f m grasp1 i4 #e4c 7#cf-fhe74 ,indep5d5t exi/5ce prov$1 by ! use ( collective n\ns1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fgb74 ,indep5d5t good f pleasure is temp]ate man1 vi4 #g4bi 7#ch-gdg74 ,indep5d5t pr9ciple1 ! human s\l1 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,indet]m9at5ess ( s\l n yet rea*$ ! good1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacc74 ,indet]m9ation ( space leads to its measur+ movem5t1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajaa74 ,indig5ce is necess>ily evil1 ii4 #d4af 7#ab-bah74 ,indig5ce ( s\l f connection ) matt]1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafj74 ,indisc]nibles1 ,leitnitz's doctr9e (1 v4 #g4a 7#ah-bed74 ,individual aggregate =m$ by unit+ s\l & body1 i4 #a4f 7#ec-aaig74 ,individual relation ) cosmic intellect1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,individual relation ) ,god & s\l1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,individuality 9 contemplation weak5s s\l1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abe74 ,individuality possess$ by rational s\l1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abd74 ,individuality1 to :i* s\l does x belong8 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aage74 ,individuals1 desc5t ( ideas into1 vi4 #e4f 7#bc-cbj74 ,individuals di/9ct z be+ actualizations1 vi4 #b4b1 7#dc-hid74 ,indivisible1 v4 #c4aj 7#di-aajg74 ,indivisible & divisible is ! s\l1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bgi74 ,indivisible ess5ce becomes divisible )9 bodies1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgg74 ,indivisible ess5ce1 description (1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgg74 ,indivisible is ! univ]sal be+1 vi4 #d4c 7#bb-bhh74 ,indivisibility1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd74 ,indum5eus1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,ineffable is ! ,supreme1 v4 #c4ac 7#di-aaab74 ,inequality ( ri*es1 no mom5t to an et]nal be+1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-faf74 ,in]tia ( matt] air$ by influx ( _w s\l1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,inexhau/ible are />s1 & ne$ no refre%m5t1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbg74 ,inf]ior div9ities1 diff]5ce f cele/ial1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eef74 ,inf]ior nature1 h[ x c p>ticipate 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #e4aa 7#bc-cbi74 ,inf]ior natures are help$ by s\ls desc5d+ to !m1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,inf]iority ( _w to its model1 highe/ criticism we may pass1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efe74 ,influ5ce ( />s is _! natural radiation ( good1 iv4 #d4c 7#bh-dig74 ,influ5ce ( univ]se %\ld be p>tial only1 iv4 #d4cd 7#bh-did74 ,influx movem5t z1 vi4 #c4bf 7#dd-ihj74 ,influx ( _w-s\l1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,inf9ite & =mlessness 9 itself is evil1 i4 #h4c1 7#ea-aade74 ,inf9ite conta9$ by intellig5ce z simultane\s ( "o & _m1 vi4 #g4ad 7#ch-gbe74 ,inf9ite expla9$ z ,god entirely pres5t ev]y:]e1 vi4 #e4d 7#bc-cah74 ,inf9ite1 h[ a numb] c be said to be1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fgc74 ,inf9ite1 h[ x arriv$ to exi/5ce1 vi4 #f4b1 #c 7#cd-fdd1 #fde74 ,inf9ite is conceiv$ by ! ?\ghts mak+ ab/raction ( ! firm1 vi4 #f4c 7#cd-fdf74 ,inf9ite is s\l1 z compris+ _m s\ls1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bia74 ,inf9ite may be ideal or real1 ii4 #d4ae 7#ab-bag74 ,inf9ite1 :at is its numb]1 vi4 #f4b 7#cd-fdd74 ,inf9ity1 h[ x c subsi/ 9 ! intelligible _w1 vi4 #f4b 7#cd-fde74 ,inf9ity ( numb]1 due to impossibility ( increas+ ! greate/1 vs4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgf74 ,inf9ity ( p>ts ( ! ,supreme1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,infra-cele/ial vault ( ,!odore ( ,as9e 7invisible place7 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg72 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aih74 ,inh]+ 9 ,supreme1 is root ( p[] ( div9ities1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,initiative %\ld n be ov]%ad[$ by ,provid5ce1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajeg74 ,insanity ev51 does n ju/ify suicide1 i4 #i 7#af74 ,insep>able f _! be+s are pot5tialities1 vi4 #d4i 7#bb-bih74 ,in/ances ( correspond5ce ( s5se beauty ) its idea1 i4 #f4c 7#a-dd74 ,in/rum5t ( s\l is body1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,intellect1 cosmic relation ) individual1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,intellect did n grasp object itself1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abja74 ,intellection nei!r ne$$ nor possess$ by good1 iii4 #h4aa 7#cj-edi74 ,intellection w\ld be movem5t or actualization on ,ari/otelian pr9ciples1 vi4 #a4ah 7#db-hfg74 ,intellectual diff]5ces betwe5 _w-s\l & />-s\l1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfc74 ,intellectualiz$1 & ennobl$ is s\l1 scorn+ ev5 ?\ght1 vi4 #g4ce 7#ch-geg74 ,intellectualiz+ habit t lib]ates ! s\l is virtue1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-ghj74 ,intellectual life possesses ! reasons or ideas1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibg74 ,intellig5ce1 always d\ble z ?9k+ subject & object ?\ght1 v4 #c4e1 #f 7#di-ajif72 v4 #d4b 7#g-acf72 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccd74 ,intellig5ce & life mus be transc5d$ by good1 v4 #c4af 7#di-aaag74 ,intellig5ce & life only diff]5t degrees ( ! same reality1 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gcb74 ,intellig5ce & s\l conta9$ 9 intelligible _w1 besides ideas1 v4 #i4ac 7#e-aaf74 ,intellig5ce z a composite1 is po/]ior to ! categories1 vi4 #b4ai 7#dc-ibd74 ,intellig5ce z demiurgic creator1 v4 #a4h 7#aj-ahf74 ,intellig5ce z matt] ( intelligible entities1 v4 #d4b 7#g-acf74 ,intellig5ce z vision ( "o1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahe74 ,intellig5ce assi/+ ,supreme1 has no room = *ance1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjd74 ,intellig5ce begets _w-s\ls & individual s\ls1 vi4 #b4bb 7#dc-ibi74 ,intellig5ce _c be fir/1 v4 #d4a 7#g-ace74 ,intellig5ce category1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,intellig5ce conceiv$ ( by /ripp+ ! s\l ( e non-intellectual "p1 v4 #c4i 7#di-aajd74 ,intellig5ce consi/s ( intellig5ce & love1 vi4 #g4ce 7#ch-geh74 ,intellig5ce conta9s all be+s1 g5]atively1 v4 #i4f 7#e-aji74 ,intellig5ce conta9s all intelligible entities1 by its v notion1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egh74 ,intellig5ce conta9s all ?+s con=m$ to ! good1 vi4 #g4af 7#ch-gbg74 ,intellig5ce conta9s ! inf9ite z fri5d%ip1 vi4 #g4ad 7#ch-gbe74 ,intellig5ce conta9s ! inf9ite z simultane\s ( "o & _m1 vi4 #g4ad 7#ch-gbe74 ,intellig5ce conta9s ! univ]sal ar*etype1 v4 #i4i 7#e-aab74 ,intellig5ce conta9s ! :yness ( its =ms1 vi4 #g4b 7#ch-gcb74 ,intellig5ce contemplat+1 is horizon ( div9e approa*1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,intellig5ce c\ld n h be5 ! la/ degree ( exi/5ce1 ii4 #i4h 7#cc-fad74 ,intellig5ce de/roy$ by !ory t tru? is ext]nal to x1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-egf74 ,intellig5ce develops manifoldness j l s\l1 iv4 #c4e 7#bg-cif74 ,intellig5ce did n delib]ate be=e mak+ s5se-man1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fih74 ,intellig5ce diff]5tiat$ into univ]sal & individual1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gbi74 ,intellig5ce1 div9e nature (1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadc74 ,intellig5ce does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4ag 7#dc-iba74 ,intellig5ce dwelt 9 by pure incorporeal s\ls1 iv4 #c4bd 7#bg-dbg74 ,intellig5ce evolves ov] ! field ( tru?1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbc74 ,intellig5ce1 good & s\l relat$ by light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,intellig5ce has conv]sion to good & be+ 9 itself1 vi4 #h4d 7#ci-ggh74 ,intellig5ce1 h[ x makes ! _w subsi/1 iii4 #b4a 7#dg-ajdc74 ,intellig5ce1 h[ ?\gh "o1 produces p>ticul> ?+s1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibf74 ,intellig5ce1 ideas & ess5ce1 v4 #i 7#e-ajb74 ,intellig5ce id5tical ) ?\ght1 z f> z exi/5ce1 v4 #c4e 7#di-ajif74 ,intellig5ce1 image ( "o1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahe74 ,intellig5ce implies aspiration1 z ?\ght is aspiration to ! good1 iii4 #h4aa 7#cj-edh74 ,intellig5ce implies good1 z ?\ght is aspiration !reto1 v4 #f4e 7#bd-cch74 ,intellig5ce 9 actualization1 because its ?\ght is id5tical ) its ess5ce1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajg74 ,intellig5ce 9 relation to good4 i4 #d4c 7#df-ajbd74 ,intellig5ce is all1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gbi74 ,intellig5ce is goal ( purification1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfc74 ,intellig5ce is matt] ( intelligible entities1 v4 #d4b 7#g-acf74 ,intellig5ce is ! pot5tiality ( ! intellig5ces :i* are its actualizations1 vi4 #b4bj 7#dc-ibe74 ,intellig5ce itself is ! sub/rate ( ! intelligible _w1 ii4 #d4d 7#ab-aii74 ,intellig5ce1 life (1 is ev] contemporane\s1 iii4 #g4b 7#de-ihi74 ,intellig5ce1 l circle1 is insep>ably "o & _m1 iii4 #h4h 7#cj-edc74 ,intellig5ce may be d5i$ lib]ty1 if grant$ sup]-lib]ty1 vi4 #h4f 7#ci-ghb74 ,intellig5ce1 multiplicity (1 implies _! mutual diff]5ces1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gcj74 ,intellig5ce mu/ rema9 immovable to act z horizon1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,intellig5ce n a unity1 b its manifold produc$ by a unity1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddc74 ,intellig5ce n con/itut$ by ?+s 9 x1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aif74 ,intellig5ce n ours1 b we1 i4 #a4ac 7#ec-abjf74 ,intellig5ce passes f unity to duality by ?9k+1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,intellig5ce pot5tial & actualiz$ 9 ! s\l1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-ffi74 ,intellig5ce prim>y kn[s itself1 v4 #c4f 7#di-ajii74 ,intellig5ce pro( ( its exi/5ce & nature1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,intellig5ce ranks all else1 v4 #d4b 7#g-acf74 ,intellig5ce relation to intelligible1 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bbj74 ,intellig5ce's exi/5ce prov$ by id5tity ( its ?\ght & ess5ce1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,intellig5ce %9es d[n f ! peak =m$ by unit$ s\ls1 vi4 #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,intellig5ce supreme1 is k+ ( k+s1 v4 #e4c 7#cb-egi74 ,intellig5ce's work+ dem&s a supra-?9k+ pr9ciple1 v4 #f4b 7#bd-ccd74 ,intellig5ce t aspires to =m ( good is n ! supreme1 iii4 #h4aa 7#cj-edh74 ,intellig5ce ?9ks ?+s1 because x possesses !m1 vi4 #f4g 7#cd-fec74 ,intellig5ce unites1 z x rises to ! intelligible1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,intellig5ce1 :i* is free by itself1 end[s s\l ) lib]ty1 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ihc74 ,intellig5ce _w1 9 x ea* be+ is accompani$ by its :yness1 vi4 #g4b 7#ch-gjb74 ,intellig5t life b5ea? be+1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfa74 ,intellig5t animals are di/9ct f ! creat+ image ( !m1 vi4 #g4h 7#ch-gab74 ,intelligible animals are pre-exi/+1 vi4 #g4h 7#ch-gab74 ,intelligible animals d n incl9e t[>ds ! s5se-_w1 vi4 #g4h 7#ch-gab74 ,intelligible beauty1 v4 #h 7#ca-eea74 ,intelligible believ$ 9 by ^? ris+ to ! s\l1 vi4 #i4e 7#i-aef74 ,intelligible conta9s ! e>?1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gah74 ,intelligible does n desc5d2 s5se-_w rises1 iii4 #d4d 7#ae-bcg74 ,intelligible entities are n outside ( ! good1 v4 #e 7#cb-ege74 ,intelligible entities are v]itable numb]s1 vi4 #f4ad 7#cd-ffh74 ,intelligible entities conta9$ by v motion ( intellig5ce1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egh74 ,intelligible entities d n exi/ ap>t f _! matt]1 intellig5ce1 v4 #d4b 7#g-ach74 ,intelligible entities et]nal & immutable1 n corporeal1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,intelligible entities1 gno/ics ?9k !y c be bewit*$1 ii4 #i4ad 7#cc-fbg74 ,intelligible entities high] & l[]1 fir/ & second1 v4 #d4b 7#g-ace74 ,intelligible entities mu/ be bo?1 id5tical ) & diff]5t f intellig5ce1 v4 #c4aj 7#di-aajh74 ,intelligible entities n m]ely images1 b pot5tialities = memory1 iv4 #d4d 7#bh-ddf74 ,intelligible entities pres5ce impli$ by k ( !m1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-ege74 ,intelligible entities return n by memory1 b by fur!r vision1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,intelligible entity :at1 & h[ x is x1 vi4 #f4h 7#cd-fed74 ,intelligible ess5ce1 bo? 9 & out ( itself1 vi4 #e4c 7#bc-caf74 ,intelligible ess5ce =m$ by add+ et]nity to ess5ce1 vi4 #b4a 7#dc-hib74 ,intelligible et]nity 9 n an accid5t (1 b an intimate "p ( its nature1 iii4 #g4c 7#de-ihi74 ,intelligible has et]nity z _w-s\l is to "t1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjg74 ,intelligible1 h[ p>ticipat$ 9 by inf]ior nature1 vi4 #e4aa 7#bc-cbi74 ,intelligible 9 x1 cause co9cides ) nature1 vi4 #g4ai 7#ch-gce74 ,intelligible 9 x1 /ability does n imply /illness1 vi4 #c4bg 7#dd-ihb74 ,intelligible l9e exi/s 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fgd74 ,intelligible l9e po/]ior to numb]1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fgd74 ,intelligible man1 scrut9y (1 dem&$ by philosophy1 vi4 #g4d 7#ch-gje74 ,intelligible matt]1 ii4 #d4a #b 7#ab-aig1 #aih72 iii41 #h4aa 7#cj-edh74 ,intelligible matt] composite ( =m & matt]1 ii4 #d4d 7#ab-bjj74 ,intelligible matt] is n pot5tial1 ii1 #e4c 7#be-cde74 ,intelligible matt] is n %apeless1 ii4 #d4c 7#ab-aih74 ,intelligible matt] is %ap$ real be+1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bja74 ,intelligible matt]1 :y x mu/ be accept$1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,intelligible numb] inf9ite because unmeasur$1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgf74 ,intelligible numb]s1 vi4 #f4f 7#cd-fea74 ,intelligible p>ts ( m5 unite 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbg74 ,intelligible ,py?agorean numb]s discuss$1 vi4 #f4e 7#cd-fdi74 ,intelligible relation to intellig5ce1 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bbj74 ,intelligible rema9s unmov$1 yet p5etrates ! _w1 vi4 #e4aa 7#bc-cbh74 ,intelligible1 %>$ by highe/ p>ts ( all m51 vi4 #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,intelligible1 sph]ical figure ! primitive "o1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fge74 ,intelligible t]ms1 only v]bal simil>ity to physical1 vi4 #c4e 7#dd-ida74 ,intelligible1 to !m is limit$ diff]5ce 9 effects1 vi4 #c4ag 7#dd-ifd74 ,intelligible unity & decad exi/ be=e all numb]s1 vi4 #f4e 7#cd-fej74 ,intelligible1 :at is be+ 9 x is g5]ation 9 ! s5se-_w1 vi4 #c4b 7#dd-ice74 ,intelligible _w & s5se-_w1 connection betwe5 man's triple nature1 vi4 #g4g 7#ch-gaa74 ,intelligible _w ar*etype ( ours1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agh74 ,intelligible _w conta9s air1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gbj74 ,intelligible _w conta9s beside ideas1 s\l & intellig5ce1 v4 #i4ac 7#e-aaf74 ,intelligible _w conta9s e>?1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gah74 ,intelligible _w conta9s fire1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gai74 ,intelligible _w conta9s wat]1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gbj74 ,intelligible _w1 c\ld x conta9 vegetables or metals1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gag74 ,intelligible _w is model ( ?is univ]se1 vi4 #g4ab 7#ch-gbj74 ,intelligible _w1 description (1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeg74 ,intelligible _w has m unity ?an s5se-_w1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbg74 ,intelligible _w1 h[ inf9ity c subsi/ 91 vi4 #f4c 7#cd-fde74 ,intelligible _w1 9 x ev]y?+ is actual1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cdf74 ,intelligible _w is complete model ( ?is univ]se1 vi4 #g4ab 7#ch-gbj74 ,intelligible _w1 man relation to1 vi4 #d4ad 7#bb-cjh74 ,intelligible _w1 />s influ5ce is f contemplation (1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-dif74 ,intelligible _w1 we mu/ desc5d f x to /udy "t1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iie74 ,int]ior *>act]i/ics necess>y to happ9ess1 i4 #d4c 7#df-ajbc74 ,int]ior life1 r ?an ext]ior1 is field ( lib]ty1 vi4 #h4f 7#ci-gha74 ,int]ior man1 v4 #a4aj 7#aj-ahi74 ,int]ior model1 cause ( appreciation ( int]ior beauty1 i4 #f4b 7#a-de74 ,int]ior vision1 h[ tra9$1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,int]m$i>y betwe5 =m & matt]1 are s5se-objects1 iii4 #f4ag 7#bf-cha74 ,int]m$i>y body n necess>y = vision1 iv4 #e4a 7#bi-ead1 #eae74 ,int]m$i>y elem5tal s\l1 also inadmissible1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjg74 ,int]m$i>y ( reason is ! _w-s\l1 iv4 #c4aa 7#bg-djg74 ,int]m$i>y position ( ,saturn1 betwe5 ,uranus & ,jupit]1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,int]m$i>y s5sation1 dem&$ by conceptive ?\ghts1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgb74 ,int]m$iate is human nature1 suff]+ ) :ole1 b act+ on x1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaa74 ,int]m$iate is ! s\l's nature1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acj74 ,int]m$iate s5se %ape on :i* dep5ds s5sation1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,int]nal & ext]nal evil1 relation betwe51 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadi74 ,int]nec9e w> is objection to ,provid5ce1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajfe74 ,int]nec9e w>f>e necess>y1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajfe74 ,int]p5etration ( ev]y?+ 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeg74 ,int]pret] ( reason is ! _w-s\l1 iv4 #c4aa 7#bg-djg74 ,int]relation ( supreme & subord9ate div9ities dynamic 7bir?7 or m]e relation ( p>ts & :ole dynamic8 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,intimacy ( itself is ! good ( a ?+1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gdd74 ,intuition1 omnisci5t1 sup]s$es memory & reason+s1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-deg74 ,intuitionally1 ! s\l c reason1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-dag74 ,intuition's act is true conception1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abjb74 ,involunt>9ess to blame spontaneity1 iii4 #b4aj 7#dg-ajfj74 ,irascible "p ( e>?1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dha74 ,irrational claims ( a/rolog]s1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-ie74 ,isolat$1 pure s\l w\ld rema91 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,james-,lange !ory ( emotions refut$1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaif74 ,james-,lange !ory taught1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhj1 #dha74 ,j>1 resid5ce or location ( g5]ation is matt]1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aig72 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf72 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbj74 ,jeal\sy does n exi/ 9 div9e nature1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,judgm5t & s\l1 passibility (1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,judgm5t1 m5tal1 r$uces multitude to unity1 vi4 #f4ac 7#cd-ffd74 ,judgm5t ( "o "p by ano!r1 tru? ( a/rology1 ii4 #c4g 7#eb-aagb74 ,judgm5t ( s\l & o!r ?+s 9 pure/ condition only1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-hj74 ,judgm5t ( s\l condemns h] to re9c>nation1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,judgm5t1 "t (1 betwe5 inc>nations1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,jupit]1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahe72 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eeb72 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh72 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabf72 v4 #e4c 7#cb-ehj72 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh72 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-dji72 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afb74 ,jupit]1 z demiurge1 z _w-s\l1 & z gov]nor1 iv4 #d4aj 7#bh-ded74 ,jupit] life's inf9ity de/roys memory1 iv4 #d4i 7#bh-dec74 ,jupit] ! greate/ *ief1 or ?ird ,god1 is ! s\l1 iii4 #e4h 7#ej-aacf74 ,jupit]1 two-fold1 cele/ial & e>?ly1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabf74 ,jupit]1 ,v5us & ,m]cury1 also consid]$ a/rologically1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aagj74 ,jupit]'s adm9i/ration above memory1 iv4 #d4i 7#bh-dec74 ,jupit]'s g>d5 is ! reason begets ev]y?+1 iii4 #e4i 7#ej-aacg74 ,jupit]1 two-fold1 cele/ial & e>?ly1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabf74 ,ju/ice1 v4 #a4aa 7#aj-aij72 v4 #h4d1 #aj 7#ca-eeg1 #efg72 i4 #f4d 7#a-fa74 ,ju/ice1 absolute1 is indivisible1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,ju/ice does n possess ext5sion1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,ju/ice ext5ds into pa/ & future1 iii4 #b4ac 7#dg-ajfb74 ,ju/ice1 gold5 face (1 vi4 #f4f 7#cd-feb72 i1 #f4d 7#a-fa74 ,ju/ice inc>nate1 is individual1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,ju/ice is no true category1 vi4 #b4ah 7#da-ibc74 ,ju/ice1 l intellectual /atue1 0 born ( itself1 vi4 #f4f 7#cd-feb74 ,ju/ice n de/roy$ by sup]ficiality ( puni%m5ts1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajff74 ,ju/ice ( ,god v9dicat$ by philosophy1 iv4 #d4cj1 #cg 7#bh-dhf1 #ejj74 ,ju/ice seat$ beside ,jupit]1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,juxtaposition1 ii4 #g4a 7#cg-fia72 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,k9ds ( m51 ?ree1 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,k+ ( k+s1 v4 #e4c 7#cb-egi74 ,k+s1 m5 are1 v4 #c4d 7#di-ajid74 ,k+1 univ]sal1 />s foll[]s (1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,k9%ip div9e1 recognition (1 dep5ds on self-k1 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afa74 ,k9%ip ( human s\l ) div9e1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc74 ,k9%ip to _w-s\l %[n by fidelity to "o's own nature1 iii4 #c4a 7#dh-ajgg74 ,k9%ip ) beautiful _w scorn$ by gno/ics1 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fce74 ,k9%ip ) deprav$ m5 accept$1 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fcf74 ,"k ?yself1 iv4 #c4a 7#bg-chg72 vi4 #g4da 7#ch-gfi74 ,k ( bett] ?+s1 cle>$ up by purification1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-hj74 ,k ( good atta9$ exp]i5ce ( evil1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,k ( intelligible entities implies _! pres5ce1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-ege74 ,k1 true1 %[n n by unification1 n revelation ( div9e p[]1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-fag74 ,kronos1 ( ,uranus1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabf74 ,label1 is good1 a common quality or a common label1 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gcc74 ,la*esis1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,l& m>ks on pa? to ec/asy1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ed74 ,la/ degree ( exi/5ce c\ld n h be5 exi/5ce1 ii4 #i4h 7#cc-fad74 ,la/ /age ( s\l-elevation1 is vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,law1 natural directs s\l4 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagc74 ,law ( ! ord] ( ! univ]se1 :y s\ls succumb to x1 iv4 #c4ae 7#bg-dac74 ,laws1 natural1 :i* c>ry rew>ds1 may be neglect$ by good1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajee74 ,leakage 7fl[ ( or escape71 ii4 #a4f1 #h 7#dj-hbb72 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb72 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbg72 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb74 ,leakage1 none 9 radiation ( s\l 7see wa/age71 vi4 #d4e1 #aj 7#bb-bic1 #cja72 vi4 #e4c 7#bc-cag74 ,leakage1 none ) cele/ial light1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-ghd74 ,leave n _w1 b be n ( x1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aaej74 ,leibnitz1 !ory ( indisc]nibles1 v4 #g4b 7#ah-bed74 ,legislator1 intellig5ce1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajh74 ,leisure 9 life ( cele/ial ,gods1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eef74 ,le!1 iv4 #c4bf 7#bg-dcb74 ,lett]s 9 :i* to read nature1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhg74 ,lett]s 9 :i* to read nature1 are />s1 ii4 #c4g 7#eb-aagb72 iii4 #a4f 7#c-ie74 ,lib]ation ( s\l effect$ by virtue z intellectualiz+ habit1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-ggi74 ,lib]ty1 vi4 #h 7#ci-ggc74 ,lib]ty dep5ds on intellig5ce1 vi4 #h4c 7#ci-ggg74 ,lib]ty1 does x belong to ,god only1 or to all o!rs also8 vi4 #h4a 7#ci-ggc74 ,lib]ty lies 9 foll[+ reason1 iii4 #a4i1 #aj 7#c-ig1 #ih74 ,lib]ty may be d5i$ to intellig5ce1 if grant$ sup]-lib]ty1 vi4 #h4f 7#ci-gha74 ,lib]ty mu/ be = m51 if x is = ! div9ities1 vi4 #h4a 7#ci-ghb74 ,lib]ty n = ! deprav$ :o foll[ images1 vi4 #h4c 7#ci-ggg74 ,lib]ty ref]s to ! int]ior life1 r ?an to ! ext]ior1 vi4 #h4f 7#ci-gha74 ,lib]ty w\ld be de/roy$ by a/rology4 iii4 #a4g 7#c-if74 ,life & intellig5ce c\ld n inh]e 9 molecules1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eh74 ,life & ?\ght1 diff]5t grades (1 iii #h4g 7#cj-edj74 ,life *ang$ f an evil to a by virtue1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abjh74 ,life1 drama (1 roles play$ badly by evil1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,life int]p5etrates all1 & kn[s no limits1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-ccj74 ,life is actualization ( intellig5ce1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-afe74 ,life is bel[ good1 iii4 #i4i 7#ac-bbe74 ,life is p]fect :5 intelligible1 i4 #d4c 7#df-ajbd74 ,life is pres5ce ) div9ity1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-afe74 ,life ( intellig5ce is ev] contemporane\s1 iii4 #g4b 7#de-ihi74 ,life1 ?\ght & exi/5ce1 conta9$ 9 prim>y exi/5ce1 ii4 #d4f 7#ab-bjc72 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cci74 ,life's asc5t1 witness to1 is disappe>ance ( cont+5cy1 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hja74 ,light ab&on$ by s\rce does n p]i%1 b is no m !re1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhd72 iv4 #e4g 7#bi-ebf74 ,light & fire cele/ial1 nature (1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbe74 ,light & =m1 two me?ods ( sight1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,light z actualization is incorporeal1 iv4 #e4g 7#bi-ebg74 ,light cele/ial1 n expos$ to any wa/age1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbf74 ,light emanates f sun1 v4 #c4ab 7#di-aaab74 ,light emitt$ by ! s\l =ms animal nature1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaih74 ,light exi/s simultane\sly )9 & )\t1 vi4 #d4g 7#bb-bie74 ,light f sun exi/s ev]y:]e1 vi4 #d4f 7#bb-bif74 ,light 9 eye1 v4#g 7#cb-ehf72 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccd72 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-ejj74 ,light intelligible1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehg74 ,light intelligible is n spatial1 has no relation to place1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehg74 ,light int]m$i>y is unnecess>y1 be+ a h9drance1 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-eba74 ,light is composite ( light 9 eye & light outside1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccd74 ,light1 is x de/roy$ :5 its s\rce is )drawn or does x foll[ x8 iv4 #e4g 7#bi-ebf74 ,light1 objective & visual1 mutual relation (1 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-ebj74 ,light1 objective1 does n transmit by relays1 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-ebb74 ,light1 relation to air1 iv4 #d4e1 #f 7#bi-ebd74 ,light1 visual1 n a m$ium1 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-ebb74 ,light+ fire1 f refraction1 g5]ation illu/rates1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf74 ,limit l[]1 ( div9e ?+s1 ! s\l1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahf74 ,limit ( union ) div9ity1 desire or ability1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,limitless is supreme1 vi4 #g4cb 7#ch-gec74 ,limits1 none kn[n by life1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-ccj74 ,l9e intelligible1 po/]ior to numb]1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fgd74 ,liv]1 location ( gr[?1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbf74 ,liv]1 seat ( s\l's desire1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhj74 ,lives1 =m]1 cause human "*1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajhc74 ,liv+ be+1 no evil is unalloy$ = x1 i4 #g4c 7#ed-abaj74 ,liv+ well n expla9able by reason1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbb74 ,liv+ well n ext5d$ to all animals1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbj74 ,localization ( s\l op5 to metaphysical objections1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dai74 ,location does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4af 7#dc-iai74 ,location = ! ?+s yet to be produc$ is ess5ce1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-feg74 ,location ( =m 7see resid5ce71 iii1 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf74 ,location ( s\l is pr9ciple t is ev]y:]e & n[h]e1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aie74 ,location ( _w is 9 s\l & n s\l 9 body1 iv1 #c4i 7#bg-dje74 ,logos1 int]m$i>y1 also unacc\ntable1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fja74 ,logos1 =m (1 "*1 role & reason1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,lo/ w+s1 has s\l1 9 inc>nation1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafa74 ,love z ,god1 demon & passion1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabb74 ,love z recognition ( hidd5 aff9ity1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabb74 ,love bas$ on unity & sympa?y ( all ?+s1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adb74 ,love causes1 f\r1 div9e1 innate notion1 aff9ity & s5tim5t ( beauty1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabc74 ,love1 cele/ial1 mu/ abide 9 intelligible ) cele/ial s\l1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabh74 ,love1 high]1 is cele/ial1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabh74 ,love1 h[ trans=m$ into progressively high] /ages1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,love is a gad-fly1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacd74 ,love is bo? mat]ial & a demon1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aadj74 ,love is bo? ne$y & acquisitive1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacd74 ,love is n id5tical ) ! _w1 iii4 #e4e 7#ej-aacj74 ,love1 l high] s\l1 insep>able f its s\rce1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabf74 ,love1 l[]1 beauty1 cele/ial1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,love1 l[]1 correspond+ to _w-s\l1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabh74 ,love mu/ exi/ because ! s\l does1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aaci74 ,love1 my? ( bir?1 significance1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aaci74 ,love ( beauty expla9$ by av]sion = ugl9ess1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dg74 ,love possesses div9e be+1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabg74 ,love1 work+ z sympa?y1 affects magic1 iv4 #d4dj 7#bh-ejc74 ,love or ,eros1 iii4 #e 7#ej-aabb74 ,love t unites s\l to good is deity1 iii4 #e4d 7#ej-aacj74 ,love t unites s\l to matt] is demon only1 iii4 #e4d 7#ej-aacj74 ,lov]1 div9e1 waits at ! door1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbe74 ,lov]1 h[ he develops1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,lov]1 h[ he is attract$ by beauty ( s+le body1 i4 #c4b 7#bj-bga74 ,lov]1 h[ he uses to intelligible _w1 i4 #c4b 7#bj-bga74 ,lov]1 simile (1 9 see+ ,god1 vi4 #i4d 7#i-aee74 ,lov]s are ^? :o feel s5tim5ts mo/ ke5ly1 i1 #f4d 7#a-df74 ,lov]'s beauty 9 virtues trans=m$ to intellectual1 i4 #c4b 7#bj-bga74 ,lov]'s beauty trans=m$ into arti/ic & spiritual virtues1 i4 #c4b 7#bj-bga74 ,loves contr>y to nature are passions ( /ray$ s\ls1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aace74 ,loves implant$ by nature are all good1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacf74 ,loves 9 ! evil *>g$ d[n by false op9ions1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacf74 ,l[] =m ( be+ possess$ by evil1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aade74 ,l[] =ms ( contemplation1 iii4 #h4a 7#cj-eca74 ,l[] natures1 good is = !m1 n = itself1 vi4 #g4d 7#ch-gjf74 ,l[] ?+s foll[ high]1 i4 #h4a 7#ea-aadb74 ,l[e/ degree ( be+ is evil1 h5ce necess>y1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aadf74 ,lyceum1 vi4 #a4ad1 #cj 7#db-hfb1 #hhh74 ,lynceus1 ^: ke5 eyes pi]ce all1 symbol ( intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,lyre1 badly tun$1 _c produce h>mony1 vi4 #c4ac 7#dd-ifa72 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,lyre play$ by musician1 l affections ( ! s\l1 iii4 #f4d 7#bf-ceh74 ,lyre1 simile ( /rik+ s+le cord1 vi1 #e4aj 7#bc-cbf74 ,made himself1 div9ity has1 does n cause priority1 vi4 #h4bj 7#ci-hjh74 ,magic1 bas$ on sympa?y1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adb74 ,magic en*antm5ts describ$1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adb74 ,magic1 escap$ by hone/y1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eji74 ,magic occurs by love1 work+ z sympa?y1 iv4 #d4dj 7#bh-ejc74 ,magic p[] ov] hone/y1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eji74 ,magic p[] ov] man by its affections & weakness1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-ejh74 ,magnanimity int]pret$ z purifications1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,magnitude an aid to diff]5ces ( color1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fha74 ,magnitude is an image =m$ by reflection ( univ]sal be+s1 iii4 #f4ag 7#bf-chj74 ,magnitude is only appe>ance1 iii4 #f4ah 7#bf-cha74 ,magnitude ( matt] d]iv$ f sem9al reasons1 iii4 #f4ae 7#bf-cgg74 ,magnitude1 :y c\ld ! s\l h none1 if x fill$ all space1 vi4 #d4a 7#bb-bhe74 ,magnitudes & numb]s are ( diff]5t k9d ( quality1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hdc74 ,man z s\l subsi/+ 9 a special reason1 vi4 #g4e 7#ch-gjg74 ,man 9 himself1 vi4 #g4d 7#ch-gjf74 ,man is def9$ z reasonable s\l1 vi4 #g4d 7#ch-gjf74 ,man is p]fect$ ?r\gh 8 evils1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahg74 ,man produces sem9al reason1 ii4 #c4ab 7#eb-aagh74 ,man1 relation (1 to ! intelligible _w1 vi4 #d4ad 7#bb-cjh74 ,man's triple nature is connection betwe5 s5se & intelligible _w1 vi4 #g4g 7#ch-gaa74 ,managem5t ( body by reason+1 ( _w by intellig5ce1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,manag]1 rew>ds & puni%es1 good & bad actors1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,manag+ "p ( s\l1 discr$it$1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bhj74 ,mani*eans1 w9e divid$ 9 j>s !ory ( reflect$1 iv4 #c4b1 #bj 7#bg-cij74 ,manifold conta9s unity ( mann] ( exi/5ce1 vi4 #d4h 7#bb-bif74 ,manifold c\ld n exi/ )\t some?+ simple1 v4 #f4c 7#bd-ccf74 ,manifold1 h[ intellig5ce became1 v4 #c4aa 7#di-aajh74 ,manifold1 h[ x arises f ! "o ,intellig5ce1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibf74 ,manifold1 if x pass$ into unity1 w\ld de/roy univ]se1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,manifold is unity ( app]ception1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,manifold n expla9$ by supreme unity1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aaaf74 ,manifold1 no?+1 c\ld exi/ )\t some?+ simple1 v4 #f4c 7#ab-ccf74 ,manifold ( intellig5ce produc$ by unity1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddc74 ,manifold unity1 only = exam9ation are its p>ts ap>t1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hig74 ,manifoldness1 v4 #c4af 7#di-aaah74 ,manifoldness conta9$ by univ]sal ess5ce1 vi4 #i4b 7#i-adi74 ,manifoldness develop$ by s\l1 z by intellig5ce1 iv4 #c4f 7#bg-cih74 ,manifoldness mu/ pre-exi/1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hid74 ,manifoldness ( any k9d _c exi/ )9 ! fir/1 v4 #c4ab 7#di-aaaj74 ,manifoldness ( unity1 vi4 #e4f 7#bc-cba74 ,manifoldness produc$ by "o because ( categories1 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaaf74 ,manifoldness1 :y x proce$$ f unity1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,mann] ( exi/5ce det]m9es h[ unity is manifold1 vi4 #d4h 7#bb-bif74 ,_m & "o insep>ably1 is intellig5ce1 iii4 #h4h 7#cj-edc74 ,_m & "o1 puzzle ( decides g5]a ( ess5ce1 vi4 #b4d 7#dc-hih74 ,m>riages1 presid$ ov] by l[] love1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabi74 ,m>s1 relations to ,saturn illogical1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aafi74 ,mass is s\rce ( ugl9ess1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eed74 ,ma/]1 ev5 beyond x1 is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4ab 7#ci-gic74 ,ma/] ( himself p[] is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4aj 7#ci-gij74 ,ma/]s ( ourselves are ev5 we1 h[ mu* m ,supreme1 vi4 #h4ab 7#ci-gic74 ,ma/]y ( ^! corporeal dispositions is n easy1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaed74 ,mat]ial1 gno/ic di/9ction ( m51 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fcg74 ,mat]ialism1 polemic aga9/1 iv4 #g 7#b-ef74 ,mat]iali/s _c und]/& solid ?+s ne> non5tity1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfa74 ,mat]iali/s support det]m9ation1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,ma!matical p>ts n applicable to s\l4 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-chi74 ,matt] acc4 to ,emp$ocles & ,anaxim&]1 ii4 #d4g 7#ab-bjd74 ,matt] alone c\ld n end[ itself ) life1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-fj74 ,matt] an empty mirror t reflects ev]y?+1 iii4 #f4g 7#bf-cfc74 ,matt] & =m 9 all ?+s1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,matt] & =m int]m$i>y betwe5 is s5se object1 iii4 #f4ag 7#bf-cha74 ,matt] z deprivation /ill )\t qualities1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeg74 ,matt] z mirror1 n affect$ by ! object reflect$1 iii4 #f4g 7#bf-cfc74 ,matt] z "m1 nurse1 resid5ce & o!r nature1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-chd74 ,matt] z resid5ce ( g5]ation4 iii4 #f4ac 7#bf-cgc74 ,matt] z sub/rate & resid5ce ( =ms1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aig74 ,matt] z ! inf9ite 9 itself1 ii4 #d4ae 7#ab-baf74 ,matt]1 born ( _w-s\l1 %apeless1 begett+ pr9ciple1 iii4 #d4a 7#ae-bcc74 ,matt]1 bo? k9ds1 relation (1 to ess5ce1 ii4 #d4af 7#ab-bai74 ,matt] _c be affect$1 z _c be de/roy$1 iii4 #f4h 7#bf-cfe74 ,matt] _c be cr$it$ ) be+1 vi4 #c4g 7#dd-idd74 ,matt] _c be ! prim>y pr9ciple1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hha74 ,matt] conta9$ 9 ! s\l f h] look+ at d>kness1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,matt] contempor>ily ) ! in=m+ pr9ciple1 ii4 #d4h 7#ab-bjf74 ,matt]1 corporeal & incorporeal1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aih74 ,matt]1 cult ( implies ignor+ s\l & intellig5ce1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhg74 ,matt] d]ives its be+ f intelligibles1 vi4 #c4g 7#dd-idd74 ,matt]1 desc5t into1 is fall ( ! s\l1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafa74 ,matt]1 diff]5ce f =m1 due to t ( intelligible s\rces1 vi4 #c4h 7#dd-idf74 ,matt] exi/$ f all et]nity1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-acj74 ,matt]1 fir/ physical category ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,matt]1 h[ to see ! =mless1 a ?+ ( itself1 i4 #h4i 7#ea-aaef74 ,matt] 7hypo/atic71 exi/5ce z und5iable z t ( good1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafb74 ,matt]1 if prim>y1 w\ld be =m ( ! univ]se1 iii4 #f4ah 7#bf-chb74 ,matt]1 impassible1 because ( diff]5t s5ses ( p>ticipation1 iii4 #f4i 7#bf-cff74 ,matt]1 incorporeal 7,py?4 ,plato1 ,ari/471 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aih74 ,matt]1 incorruptible1 exi/s only pot5tially1 ii4 #e4e 7#be-cdh74 ,matt]1 intelligible1 ii4 #d4c 7#ab-aih72 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cde72 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacd74 ,matt]1 intelligible1 entities to rea* s5se-matt]1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aaed74 ,matt]1 intelligible1 is n pot5tial1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cde74 ,matt]1 intelligible1 :y x mu/ be accept$1 iii4 #e4f1 #g 7#ej-aacc74 ,matt] is born %apeless1 receives =m :ile turn+ to1 ii4 #d4c 7#ab-aih74 ,matt] is bo? )\t qualities & evil1 i4 #h4aj 7#ea-aaef74 ,matt] is bottom ( ev]y?+1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bja74 ,matt] is cause ( evils1 ev5 if corporeal1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaec74 ,matt] is disposition to become some?+ else1 ii4 #d4ac 7#ab-bad74 ,matt] is improv$ by =m1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gde74 ,matt] is incorporeal1 ii4 #d4i 7#ab-bjf74 ,matt] is non5tity1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadh74 ,matt] is non-ess5tial o!rness1 ii4 #d4af 7#ab-bah74 ,matt] is n a body )\t quality1 b ) magnitude1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hhj74 ,matt] is n be+ & _c be any?+ actual1 ii4 #e4d 7#be-cdg74 ,matt] is n composite1 b simple 9 "o1 ii4 #d4h 7#ab-bje74 ,matt] is n wick$ness1 b neutral evil1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gdf74 ,matt] is no?+ actually1 ii4 #e4b 7#be-cdc74 ,matt] is physical category1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-icg74 ,matt] is real pot5tially1 ii4 #e4e 7#be-cdh74 ,matt] is relative d>kness1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bja74 ,matt] is second>y evil1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aaee74 ,matt] is un*angeable because =m is su*1 iii4 #f4aj 7#bf-cfh74 ,matt] left alone z basis aft] ,/oic categories evaporate1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhf74 ,matt] magnitude d]iv$ f sem9al reason1 iii4 #f4ae 7#bf-cgg74 ,matt] may exi/ yet be evil1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeh74 ,matt]1 modifi$1 is ,/oic ,god1 vi4 #ab4g 7#db-hha74 ,matt] mu/ be possible because its qualities *ange1 iii4 #f4h 7#bf-cff74 ,matt] necess>y to ! _w2 h5ce good implies evil1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,matt] n 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeg74 ,matt] no?+ real actually1 ii4 #e4d 7#be-cdg74 ,matt] ( demons is n corporeal1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aace74 ,matt] p>ticipates 9 exi/5ce1 )\t p>ticipat+ x1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf7 ,matt] p>ticipates 9 ! intelligible1 by appe>ance1 iii4 #f4aa 7#bf-cfi74 ,matt]1 p>ticipation (1 9 ideas1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cba7 ,matt] possesses no quality1 ii4 #d4h 7#ab-bje72 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,matt] qualifi$ z sem9al reasons1 vi4 #a4bi ,matt] rationaliz$ is body1 ii4 #g4c 7#cg-fif74 ,matt] receiv$ =ms until hidd5 by !m1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efb74 ,matt]1 relation (1 to reason1 illu/rates t ( op9ion to imag9ation1 iii4 #f4ae 7#bf-cgg74 ,matt]1 s9ce _c be de/roy$1 _c be affect$1 iii4 #f4h 7#bf-cfe74 ,matt] ?+s m+l$1 conta9 no p]fection1 iii4 #b4g 7#dg-ajec74 ,matt]'s g5]ation1 consequ5ce ( ant]ior pr9ciples1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-acj74 ,matt]'s primitive impot5ce be=e g5]ation1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-acj74 ,me*anism ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,m$ic9e1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aad74 ,m$iocre1 evil m5 ev51 nev] ab&on$ by ,provid5ce1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajeh74 ,m$iation ( s\l betwe5 indivisible & divisible ess5ce1 iv4 #b 7#ba-bgf74 ,m$iation ( _w-s\ls1 ?r\gh x1 b5efits are grant$ to m51 vi4 #d4ab1 #cj 7#bh-deg1 #dhf74 ,m$ium cosmologically necess>y1 b affects sight only slightly1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eag74 ,m$ium ne$$ 9 ,platonism1 ,ari/otelianism1 ,/oicism1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eaf74 ,m$ium n ne$$ 9 ,atomism & ,epicurianism1 iv4 #e4b 7#bi-eaf74 ,m$ium ( sight1 ,ari/otle's unnecess>y iv4 #e4a 7#bi-eae74 ,m$ium1 ?\gh possible1 h9d]s organs ( sight1 iv4 #e4a 7#bi-ead74 ,m$ium1 untr\bl$1 is ! _w-s\l1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acj74 ,m$ium's abs5ce w\ld only de/roy sympa?y1 iv4 #e4c 7#bi-eai74 ,m$ium's affection does n int]f]e ) vision1 iv4 #e4c 7#bi-ebj74 ,memories n ne$$1 unconsci\s pray] answ]$ by ,/>s1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-eje74 ,memories ( ! pa/ d n increase happ9ess1 i4 #e4i 7#cf-fhi74 ,memory1 iv4 7#bg-dbh74 ,memory & reason+1 n impli$ by _w-s\l's wisdom1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-deg74 ,memory & reason+ susp5d$ by omnisci5t intuition1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-deg74 ,memory & s5sation iv4 #f 7#da-hbi74 ,memory & s5sation1 ,/oic doctr9es (1 hang toge!r1 iv4 #f4a 7#da-hbi74 ,memory acts ?r\gh ! sympa?y ( ! s\l's highe/ self1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hcb74 ,memory1 actualization ( ! s\l1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbi74 ,memory belongs to div9e s\l1 & to t d]iv$ f _w-s\l1 iv4 #c4bg 7#bg-dcc74 ,memory belongs to imag9ation1 iv4 #c4bi 7#bg-dcc74 ,memory belongs to ! s\l alone1 iv4 #c4bf 7#bg-dcb74 ,memory1 bo? k9ds1 implies bo? k9ds ( imag9ation1 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dch74 ,memory def9ition dep5ds on :e!r x is animal or human1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbi74 ,memory does n belong to appetite1 iv4 #c4bh 7#bg-dcd74 ,memory does n belong to ! p[] ( p]ception1 iv4 #c4bi 7#bg-dce74 ,memory does n belongs to ! />s1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dda74 ,memory impossible to _w-s\ls to :om !re is no "t b a s+le day1 iv4 #d4g 7#bh-dej74 ,memory inapplicable to any b "t limit$ be+s1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbh74 ,memory is n id5tical ) feel+ or reason+1 iv4 #c4bi 7#bg-dcf74 ,memory limit$ to s\ls t *ange _! condition1 iv4 #d4f 7#bh-ddh74 ,memory may be r$uc$ to s5sation1 iv4 #c4bh 7#bg-dcd74 ,memory ne$s tra9+ & education1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hce74 ,memory1 none 9 />s1 because uni=mly blissful1 iv4 #d4h 7#bh-deb74 ,memory n an image b a reawak5+ ( a faculty1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hcc74 ,memory n z high z unreflective id5tification1 iv4 #d4d 7#bh-dde74 ,memory n1 b an affection1 is kept by appetite1 iv4 #c4bh 7#bg-dcd74 ,memory n compulsory1 iv4 #d4h 7#bh-dea74 ,memory n ex]cis$ by _w-s\ls & />s' s\ls1 iv4 #d4f 7#bh-ddi74 ,memory n intelligible because ( simultaneity1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,memory ( s\l 9 intelligible _w1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,memory peculi> to s\l & body1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-dcj74 ,memory1 possession (1 n caus$ by inc>nation ( s\l1 iv4 #c4bf 7#bg-dca74 ,memory problems dep5d on def9ition1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbi74 ,memory1 timeless1 con/itutes self-consci\sness1 iv4 #c4be 7#bg-dbi74 ,memory :5 beyond1 help$ by tra9+ "h bel[1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,memory w\ld be h9d]$ if s\l's impressions 7 corporeal1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-ff74 ,m5 are k+s1 v4 #c4d 7#di-ajid74 ,m5 bo?1 we are n always z we %\ld be1 vi4 #d4ad 7#bb-cjh74 ,m5 escape *ance by int]ior isolation1 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hjj74 ,m5 non-virtu\s1 d good :5 n h9d]$ by passions1 iii4 #a4aj 7#c-ih74 ,m5 ( ?ree k9ds1 s5sual1 moral & spiritual1 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,m5 seek action :5 too weak = contemplation1 iii4 #h4d 7#cj-ecf74 ,m5 s5se & intelligible1 diff]5ce betwe51 vi4 #g4d 7#ch-gje74 ,m51 ?ree 9 ea* ( u1 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh74 ,m51 ?ree 9 u1 fate ( !m is1 brutalization or div9ization1 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gji74 ,m51 ?ree k9ds (1 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,m]cury1 ,jupit] & ,v5us1 also consid]$ a/rologically1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aafi74 ,metal is to /atue z body to s\l1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gf74 ,mess5g]s ( div9ities are s\ls inc>nat$1 iv4 #c4ab1 #ac 7#bg-dji72 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,metaphorical is all language ab\t ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gie74 ,me?od ( creation1 ii4 #c4ag 7#eb-aahf74 ,me?od ( ec/asy is to close eyes ( body1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,me?ods ( dialectic diff] ) individuals1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bfi74 ,me?ods ( p>ticipation 9 good1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abjh74 ,metis or prud5ce 7my? (71 iii4 #e4e 7#ej-aacj74 ,microcosm1 iv4 #c4aj 7#bg-djf74 ,migrat+ ( s\l psy*ologically expla9$1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-caj74 ,m9]va1 vi4 #e4g 7#bc-cba74 ,m9os1 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afb74 ,miracle1 matt] p>ticipates 9 exi/5ce1 :ile n p>ticipat+ 9 x1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf74 ,mire1 unruly1 s\l falls into1 :5 plung+ d[n1 i4 #h4ac 7#ea-aafj74 ,mirror1 iv4 #c4cj 7#bg-dcg72 iv4 #e4g 7#bi-ebh74 ,mirror empty1 reflects ev]y?+ l matt]1 iii4 #f4g 7#bf-cfc74 ,mirror1 simile (1 i4 #d4aj 7#df-ajcd74 ,mis=tune & puni%m5t1 significance (1 iv4 #c4af 7#bg-dad74 ,mis=tune1 exp]i5ce (1 does n give s5ses to man1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,mis=tune =ese5 by ,god1 n cause ( human s5ses1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,mis=tune none too great to be conqu]$ by virtues1 i4 #d4h 7#df-ajca74 ,mis=tune to ! good only app>5t1 iii4 #b4f 7#dg-ajea74 ,mi?ra1 simile (1 us$1 iii4 #b4ad 7#dg-ajfd74 ,mixture1 consequ5ces ( s\l & body1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaie74 ,mixture1 elem5ts are n1 b arise f a common sy/em1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbd74 ,mixture expla9$ by evaporation 7,/oic71 ii4 #g4b 7#cg-fid74 ,mixture limit$ to en]gies ( ! exi/5t1 iv4 #g4b1 #h 7#b-eh1 #fh74 ,mixture ( intellig5ce & necessity1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,mixture ( s\l & body impossible1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaid74 ,mixture ( s\l divisible1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,mixture ( unequal qualities1 ii4 #g4a 7#cg-fic74 ,mixture t occupies m space ?an elem5ts1 ii4 #g4a 7#cg-fic74 ,mixture1 !ory (1 ( ,alex&] ( ,aphrodisia1 ii4 #g4a 7#cg-fia72 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eh74 ,mixture to ! po9t ( total p5etration1 ii4 #g 7#cg-fia74 ,modality1 %\ld n occupy ev5 ?ird rank ( exi/5ce1 vi4 #a4cj 7#db-hhg74 ,model1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,model = produc+ pr9ciple1 is =m1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efa74 ,model1 image b\nd to x by radiation1 vi4 #d4aj 7#bb-cjj74 ,model1 int]ior1 cause ( appreciation ( int]ior beauties1 i4 #f4d 7#a-de74 ,model ( reason1 is ! univ]sal s\l1 iv4 #c4aa 7#bg-djg74 ,model ( ! old e>?1 gno/ic1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjg74 ,model ( ! univ]se is intelligible _w1 vi4 #g4ab 7#ch-gbj74 ,model1 previ\s1 object's exi/5ce implies1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-feh74 ,model1 sup]ior1 me?od ( produc+ assimilation1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg1 #bfh74 ,mode/y is "p ( goodness1 ii4 #i4i4 7#cc-faf74 ,modification d]iv$ f =eign s\rces1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abjb74 ,modifi$ matt]1 is ,/oic ,god1 vi4 #a4bg 7#db-hha74 ,molecules c\ld n possess life & intellig5ce1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eg74 ,monism ( ! ,/oics breaks d[n j l dualism1 v4 #a4bg 7#db-hhc74 ,moon1 limit ( _w-sph]e1 ii4 #a4e 7#dj-hbj74 ,moon1 sun & light univ]se l1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,moral beauties1 m delightful ?an s5se-beauties1 i4 #f4d 7#a-de74 ,moral m51 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,moral m5 become sup]ficial1 v4 #i4a 7#b-ajb74 ,moralization1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfd74 ,moralization decides gov]nm5t ( s\l1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfd74 ,mortal1 ei!r :ole or "p ( u1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,"m1 nurse1 resid5ce & o!r nature is matt]1 iii4 #f4ah 7#bf-chd74 ,motion1 h[ imp>t$ to l[] exi/5ces1 ii4 #b4b 7#ad-bca74 ,motion is bel[ ! ,"o1 iii4 #i4g 7#ac-bbe74 ,motion ( fire1 is /raight1 ii4 #b4a 7#ad-bbh74 ,motion ( s\l is circul>1 ii4 #b4a 7#ad-bbi74 ,motion1 s+le1 effect$ by body1 & diff]5t ones by s\l1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fb74 ,motion spontane\s1 ( univ]sal s\l1 immortalizes heav51 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hah74 ,motions1 conflict+1 due to pres5ce ( bodies1 ii4 #b4b 7#ad-bca74 ,motions1 diff]5t1 caus$ by s\l1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fb74 ,motive1 ess5tial to det]m9ation1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hg74 ,motives ( creation ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fje74 ,movem5t1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,movem5t & re/1 de/ruction also inapplicable1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fjj74 ,movem5t & /ability exi/ because ?\ght by intellig5ce1 vi4 #b4h 7#dc-ijd74 ,movem5t ano!r k9d ( /ability1 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijc74 ,movem5t _c be r$uc$ to any high] g5us1 vi4 #c4ba 7#dd-iga74 ,movem5t1 circul> ( ! s\l1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfb74 ,movem5t divid$ 9 natural1 artificial & volunt>y1 vi4 #c4bf 7#dd-ihj74 ,movem5t does n beget "t1 b indicates x1 iii4 #g4aa 7#de-ajji74 ,movem5t = s5se objects1 vi4 #c4bc 7#dd-igf74 ,movem5t1 h[ c x be 9 "t if *anges are out ( "t1 vi4 #a4af 7#db-hfd74 ,movem5t is a =m ( p[]1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-igc74 ,movem5t is active =1 & is ! cause ( o!r =ms1 vi4 #c4bb 7#dd-igd74 ,movem5t1 is *ange ant]ior to x8 vi4 #c4ba 7#dd-igb74 ,movem5t measur$ by space because ( its indet]m9ation1 iii4 #g4aa 7#de-ajaa74 ,movem5t measures "t1 & is measur$ by x1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajaa74 ,movem5t ( comb9ation1 vi4 #c4be 7#dd-igh74 ,movem5t ( displacem5t is s+le1 vi4 #c4bd 7#dd-ibg74 ,movem5t1 ( its image "t1 is et]nity1 iii4 #g1 int4 7#de-ihe74 ,movem5t ( ! heav5s1 ii4 #b 7#ad-bbg74 ,movem5t ( ! s\l is attribut$ to ! prim>y movem5t1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ihe74 ,movem5t1 p]si/5t1 & its int]val1 are n "t1 b are )9 x1 iii4 #g4g 7#de-iii74 ,movem5t1 ?ree k9ds1 ii4 #b4a 7#ad-bbg74 ,movem5t1 "u x1 action & suff]+ may be subsum$1 vi4 #a4ag 7#db-hff74 ,movem5t1 :y x is a category1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-iga74 ,multiple unity1 iv4 #i4a 7#h-aci74 ,multiple unity1 radiation (1 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaae74 ,multiplicity c\ld n be conta9$ 9 ! fir/1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gbi74 ,multiplicity dem&s organization 9 sy/em1 vi4 #g4aj 7#ch-gaf74 ,multiplicity ( intellig5ces implies _! natural diff]5ces1 vi4 #g4ag 7#ch-gcj74 ,multitude1 h[ x prec$es f ! ,"o1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aaf72 vi4 #g 7#ch-fig74 ,multitude is di/ance f an unity1 & is an evil1 vi4 #f4a 7#cd-fdc74 ,multitude ( ideas ( ! good1 vi4 #g 7#ch-fig74 ,muses1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efi72 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,music makes ! musician1 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eeb74 ,musician educat$ by recogniz+ tru?s he already possesses1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bgj74 ,musician1 h[ he rises to intelligible _w1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bgj74 ,musician l$ up by beauty1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bgj74 ,mutilation ( ,saturn typifies splitt+ ( unity1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,my/]ies1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aabj74 ,my/]ies1 anci5t1 _! spiritual tru?1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,my/]ies purify & lead to nak$ness 9 sanctu>y1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,my/]y ( d]ivation ( ,second f ,fir/1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-aha74 ,my/]y rites expla9 secrecy ( ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,my/]y tea*+s ( hell1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,my?s expla9$ by body's approa* to ! s\l1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aach74 ,my?s1 object (1 is to analyze & di/+ui%1 iii4 #e4aj 7#ej-aaci74 ,my?s ( i?yphallic ,h]mes1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che74 ,my?s ( ,ne$ & ,abundance1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cge74 ,my?s1 see ,abundance1 ,ne$ (1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cge74 ,nak$ness foll[s purification 9 my/]ies1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,names ( ,supreme approximations1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,n>cissus1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb72 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eed74 ,n>cissus foll[$ va9 %apes1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,natural *>act]i/ics1 d]iv$ f categories 9 intelligible1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,natural law1 by x all pray]s are answ]$1 ev5 ( evil1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-eje74 ,natural movem5ts1 vi4 #c4bf 7#dd-ihj74 ,nature & elem5ts1 !re is cont9uity betwe51 iv4 #d4ad 7#bh-dei74 ,nature1 & orig9 ( evils1 i4 #h 7#ea-aadb74 ,nature z weak] contemplation1 iii4 #h4d 7#cj-ece74 ,nature betray$1 b n affect$ by />s1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-ie74 ,nature1 capable ( p]fection z mu* z we1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjg74 ,nature1 cause co9cides ) x 9 intelligible1 vi4 #g4ai 7#ch-gce74 ,nature contemplation 9 unity1 iii4 #h 7#cj-edb74 ,nature1 contr>y to loves1 are passions ( /ray$ s\ls1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aace74 ,nature dom9ates 9 plants1 b n 9 man1 iii4 #d4a 7#ae-bcc74 ,nature fir/ actualization ( univ]sal s\l1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,nature is immovable z a fall1 b n z comp\nd ( matt] & =m1 iii4 #h4b 7#cj-ecc74 ,nature is ultimate cause1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hg74 ,nature law directs s\l1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagc74 ,nature1 l[e/ 9 ! _w-s\l's wisdom1 iv4 #d4ac 7#bh-deh74 ,nature ( div9e intellig5ce1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadc74 ,nature ( evil1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aadd74 ,nature ( intellig5ce prov$1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,nature ( s\l is int]m$iate1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acj74 ,nature ( ,supreme1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd74 ,nature ( univ]sal s\l1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd74 ,nature po/]ior to intellig5ce1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gh74 ,nature reason is result ( immovable contemplation1 iii4 #h4b 7#cj-ecc74 ,nature1 relation ( animal to human1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,nature /]ility indicat$ by ca/ration1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-chd74 ,nature1 ,/oic "n = g5]ative p[] 9 se$s1 v4 #i4f 7#e-aaj74 ,nature1 to :at "p belongs emotions8 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,nature's "m is univ]sal reason & fa!r ! =mal reasons1 iii4 #h4d 7#cj-ece74 ,nature's progress aid$ by auxili>y arts1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aad74 ,necess>y1 begett+ ( ,second by ,fir/1 v4 #d4a 7#g-ace74 ,necess>y ?+s are ^? ^: possession is unconsci\s1 i4 #d4f 7#df-ajbg74 ,necessity1 *>act]i/ic ( intellig5ce1 v4 #c4f 7#di-aajj74 ,necessity does n include volunt>9ess1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,necessity1 ,h]aclitian1 iii4 #a4d 7#c-ia74 ,necessity m+l$ ) reason1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhj74 ,necessity ( cont9u\s procession to ,supreme1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abi74 ,necessity ( exi/5ce ( ! ,fir/1 v4 #d4a 7#g-acd74 ,necessity ( illum9ation ( d>kness mu/ h be5 et]nal1 ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbc74 ,necessity1 sp9dle (1 ,platonic1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdb72 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aaga74 ,nect>1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacc74 ,nect> is memory ( vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efi74 ,ne$ & ,abundance1 my? (1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cge74 ,ne$1 or ,poros1 iii4 #e4b1 #e1 #f1 #g1 #aj 7#ej-aabe to #aace74 ,negative necess>y to a def9ition1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,neutral evil is matt]1 vi4 #g4bh 7#ch-gdf74 ,new ?+s1 unnotic$1 _! p]ception n =c$1 iv4 #d4h 7#bh-dej74 ,new _w arises out ( ,jupit] begott5 by result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,night objects prove uselessness ( sight m$ium1 iv4 #e4c 7#bi-eai74 ,non-be+ is matt]1 _c be any?+ actual1 ii4 #e4d 7#be-cdg74 ,non5tity has intellig5t life b5ea? be+1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfj74 ,non5tity is matt]1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aaej74 ,normative elem5t ( life1 is ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhd74 ,noses1 pug1 & ,roman1 due to matt]1 v4 #i4ab 7#e-aae74 ,no?+ is conta9$ 9 ,"o2 reason :y ev]y?+ c issue f x1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,notions1 sci5tific1 are bo? prior & po/]ior1 v4 #i4g 7#e-aaj74 ,n[h]e & ev]y:]e is ,supreme1 incl9ation & imm95ce1 vi4 #h4af 7#ci-hja74 ,numb] & unity proce$ f ! ,"o & _m be+s1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-fei74 ,numb] z univ]sal bond ( univ]se1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-fgj74 ,numb] c be said to be inf9ite1 vi4 #f4ai 7#cd-fgd74 ,numb]1 category1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,numb] exi/s = e animal & ! univ]sal animal1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-ffh74 ,numb] foll[s & proce$s f ess5ce1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fee74 ,numb] is n 9 quantity1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hdb74 ,numb]1 po/]ior to1 is intelligible l9e1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fgd74 ,numb]1 :at is x to inf9ite8 vi4 #f4b 7#cd-fdd74 ,numb] )9 is ! numb]1 con/itut$ ) our be+1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fgc74 ,numb]s1 vi4 #f 7#cd-fea74 ,numb]s & dim5sions are s diff]5t z to dem& diff]5t classification1 vi4 #b4ac 7#dc-iaf74 ,numb]s & ideas1 id5tification (1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fef74 ,numb]s & magnitudes1 are ( diff]5t k9ds ( quantity1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hdc74 ,numb]s are n quantity 9 !mselves1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hdb74 ,numb]s =m "p ( ! intelligible _w1 vi4 #f4d 7#cd-fdg74 ,numb]s1 intelligible1 are id5tical ) ?\ght1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-ehb74 ,numb]s intelligible1 difficulties connect$ )1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fga74 ,numb]s mu/ exi/ 9 ! prim>y ess5ce1 vi4 #f4h 7#cd-fed74 ,numb]s p>ticipat$ 9 by objects1 vi4 #f4ad 7#cd-ffg74 ,numb]s1 pr9ciple is unity's =m1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehc74 ,numb]s1 ,py?agorean1 intelligible discuss$1 vi4 #f4e 7#cd-fdi74 ,numb]s1 quantitative1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-ehc74 ,numb]s1 regulat$ g5]ation ( ev]y?+1 vi4 #f4ae 7#cd-fgj74 ,numb]s1 s\l z v4 #a4e 7#aj-ahg72 vi4 #e4i 7#bc-cbd74 ,numb]s split ! unity into plurality1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fef74 ,numb]s1 two k9ds1 ess5tial & unit>y1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-feg74 ,numb]s1 v]itable1 are intelligible entities1 vi4 #f4ad 7#cd-ffh74 ,num5ian "n ( ,div9ity1 ,ess5ce & ,be+1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd72 v4 #h4e 7#ca-efj72 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fef74 ,num]als1 v]itable1 ( ! man 9 himself1 are ess5tial1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fgb74 ,nurse1 "m1 resid5ce & o!r nature is matt]1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-chd74 ,object itself did n grasp intellect1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abja74 ,objective ju/ice & beauty to :i* we are unit$1 v4 #a4aa 7#aj-aij74 ,objective _w subsi/s ev5 :5 we are di/ract$1 v4 #a4ab 7#aj-aia74 ,objects exi/5ce implies a previ\s model1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-feh74 ,objects outside h unit>y exi/5ce1 vi4 #f4ab 7#cd-ffb74 ,objects p>ticipate 9 numb]s1 vi4 #f4ad 7#cd-ffg74 ,ob/acle to div9ity is failure to ab/ract f ,him1 vi4 #h4ba 7#ci-haa74 ,ob/acle to ! s\l is evil1 i4 #h4ab 7#ea-aaei74 ,ob/acles lack+ to creator1 because ( 8 univ]sality1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efb74 ,omnipres5ce expla9$ by possession ( all ?+s1 )\t be+ possess$ by !m1 v4 #e4i 7#cb-ehi74 ,"o1 v4 #d2 v4 #d4b 7#g-acd1 #acf74 ,"o & ,good1 vi4 #i 7#a-dg74 ,"o & _m1 l circle1 is intellig5ce1 iii4 #h4h 7#cj-edc74 ,"o & _m1 puzzle (1 decides g5]a ( ess5ce1 vi4 #b4d 7#dc-hih74 ,"o = ,supreme1 is m]e negation ( manifold1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehe74 ,"o1 indep5d5t ( ! "o outside1 vi4 #f4ab 7#cd-ffa74 ,"o is all ?+s1 b none ( !m1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,"o is ev]y:]e by its p[]1 iii4 #i4d 7#ac-bbd74 ,"o is =mless1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehe74 ,"o is n[h]e1 iii4 #i4d 7#ac-bbd74 ,"o is sup]-re/ & sup]-motion1 iii4 #i4g 7#ac-bbe74 ,"o n absolute1 b ess5tially relat$ to "o exam9$1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hif74 ,"o n ?9k]1 b ?\ght1 itself1 vi4 #i4f 7#i-afj74 ,"o pres5t )\t approa*1 ev]y:]e ?\gh n[h]e1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehg74 ,"o relat$ 9 "s g5]a1 b n 9 o!rs1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hif74 ,"o s f> above g5]a is n to be c\nt$1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hie74 ,"o1 ! s\l1 l div9ity1 always is1 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djb74 ,"o )9 u1 indep5d5t ( ! "o outside1 vi1 #f4ab 7#cd-ffa74 ,op9ion z s5sation1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-egf74 ,op9ion1 9 relation to imag9ation1 illu/rates t ( matt] to reason1 iii4 #f4ae 7#bf-cgg74 ,op9ions1 false1 are daught]s ( involunt>y passions1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,opportunity & suitability1 cause (1 put !m beyond *ange1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjf74 ,opposition1 ii4 #c4d 7#eb-aafh74 ,opposition among inanimate be+s 7animals & matt]71 iii4 #b4d 7#dg-ajdh71 ,optimism "r1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egi74 ,ord]1 cosmic1 is natural1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-djd74 ,ord] exi/s only 9 begott51 n 9 sem9al reason1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,ord] 9 ! hi]>*y ( nature1 ours _c be que/ion$1 iii4 #c4c 7#dh-ajgi74 ,ord] is ant]iority 9 ! intelligible1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddc74 ,ord]1 priority (1 implies conception ( "t1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,organ1 ! univ]se1 e be+ is1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaj74 ,organs alone1 c\ld be affect$1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,orig9 & nature ( evils1 i4 #h 7#ea-aadb74 ,orig91 causeless1 really is det]m9ism1 iii4 #a4a 7#c-hf74 ,orig9 ( ,god1 puzzl+1 by our />t+ f *aos1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gib74 ,orig9s ( evil1 s9s & errors1 i4 #a4i 7#ec-abja74 ,o!rness is *>act]i/ic ( matt]1 ii4 #d4ac 7#ab-bad74 ,ours is n intellig5ce1 b we1 i4 #a4ac 7#ec-abjf74 ,ours1 :y discursive reason is1 v4 #c4c 7#di-ajic74 ,out] man1 only1 affect$ by *anges ( =tune1 iii #b4ae 7#dg-ajfg74 ,pair1 vi4 #g4h2 vi4 #b4aa2 v4 #a4e2 vi4 #g4ci4 ,pair or dyad1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-ehb74 ,p&ora1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cge72 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab74 ,panegyri/s1 :o degrade :at !y wrongly praise1 v4 #e4ac 7#cb-eif74 ,pangs ( *ildbir?1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehe74 ,p>is1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,"p 9 s*eme1 s\l mu/ fit itself to1 iii1 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,p>take ( ! "o accord+ to _! capacities1 vi4 #d4aa 7#bb-cjb74 ,p>tial only %\ld be ! influ5ce ( univ]se1 iv4 #d4cd 7#bh-did74 ,p>ticipation by matt] 9 ! intelligible1 only by appe>ance1 iii4 #f4aa 7#bf-cfi74 ,p>ticipation c be only 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #d4ac 7#bb-cjf74 ,p>ticipation 9 good1 two me?ods (1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abjh74 ,p>ticipation 9 s5se-objects by unity is intelligible1 vi4 #f4ac 7#cd-ffd74 ,p>ticipation 9 ! _w ( life is m]ely a sign ( ext5sion1 vi4 #d4ac 7#bb-cjf74 ,p>ticipation1 me?od (1 inf]ior 9 intelligible1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-cbi74 ,p>ticipation ( matt] 9 exi/5ce & opposite1 iii4 #f4d 7#bf-ceg74 ,p>ticipation ( matt] 9 ideas1 proves simile ( head ) faces1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cba74 ,p>ticipations1 diff]5ce ( s5ses (1 all[s matt] to rema9 impassible1 iii4 #f4i 7#bf-cff74 ,p>tition ( fund ( memory betwe5 ! two s\ls1 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dci74 ,p>ts1 actual division 91 w\ld be d5ial ( ! :ole1 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-cij74 ,p>ts c be lo/ by body1 n by s\l1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,p>ts divisible & indivisible1 9 ! :ole ( a s\l1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dai74 ,p>ts1 9 incorporeal ?+s1 h sev]al s5ses1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-cij74 ,p>ts1 z w9e 9 j>s1 ,mani*ean !ory1 reject$1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dba74 ,p>ts1 ma!matical1 n applicable z a s\l1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-cij74 ,p>ts ( a manifold unity are a "p only1 = exam9ation1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hig74 ,p>ts ( ,supreme1 m]e1 subord9ate div9ities1 d5i$1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-eff74 ,p>ts1 physical1 t]m limit$1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-chi74 ,passage into _w ( life is body's relation to ! s\l1 vi4 #d4ab 7#bb-cjd74 ,passibility ( judgm5t & ( s\l1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,pass+ ( intellig5ce f unity to duality1 by ?9k+1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,passion z category 7see action71 vi4 #a4ag 7#db-hff74 ,passional *anges 9 body1 n 9 passional "p ( s\l1 iii4 #f4c 7#bf-cef74 ,passional love elevat+1 ?\gh op5 to mislead+ temptations1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabd74 ,passionate love tw(old1 s5sual & beautiful1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabb74 ,passions affect s\l diff]5tly f virtue & vice1 iii4 #f4c 7#bf-cef74 ,passions arise f sem9al reasons1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahd74 ,passions felt by s\l1 )\t exp]i5c+ !m1 iv4 #d4ai 7#bh-dff74 ,passions1 h[ !y p5etrate f ! body into ! s\l1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,passions involunt>y are mo!rs ( false op9ions1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,passions1 modes ( feel+1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,passions n caus$ by s\l1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahd74 ,passions ( /ray$ s\ls are loves contr>y to nature1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aace74 ,passions ( univ]se produc$ by body ( />s1 ii4 #c4aj 7#eb-aagg74 ,passions r$uc$ ext]nal images1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-ceh74 ,passions1 ,/oic !ory (1 oppos$1 iii4 #f4c 7#bf-cee7 ,passions1 _! avoidance1 task ( philosophy1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-ceh74 ,passions1 :at suitable to e>?1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dga74 ,passive1 really1 is s\l1 :5 sway$ by appetites1 iii4 #a4i 7#c-ih74 ,pa? ( simplification to unity1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aeb74 ,pa? to ec/asy1 l& m>ks1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ed7 ,p5etration into inn] sanctu>y1 yields possession ( all ?+s1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,p5etration ( body by s\l1 b n by ano!r body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,p5etration ( body by s\l proves ! latt]'s incorporeality1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,p5etration1 total1 impossible 9 mixture ( bodies1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,p5etration1 total1 mixture1 to ! po9t (1 ii4 #g 7#cg-fia74 ,p5ia1 or ne$1 my? (1 iii4 #e4be 7#ej-aacj7 ,p]ception ( new ?+s1 n =c$1 iv4 #d4h 7#bh-dej74 ,p]ception ( ! ,supreme1 its mann]1 v4 #e4aj 7#cb-eia74 ,p]fect happ9ess atta9$ :5 no?+ m is desir$1 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbf74 ,p]fect is prim>y nature 7,plot9ic72 n goal ( evolution 7,/oic71 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gc74 ,p]fect life consi/s 9 intellig5ce1 i4 #d4c 7#df-ajbd74 ,p]fect life1 its possession1 i4 #d4f 7#df-ajbg74 ,p]fection n to be s\ght 91 mat]ial ?+s1 iii4 #b4g 7#dg-ajec74 ,p]fection ( a picture make %ad[s necess>y1 iii4 #b4aa 7#dg-ajfj74 ,p]fection ( ! univ]se1 evils are necess>y1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahg74 ,p]fection ( univ]se1 object ( inc>nation1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,p]fection's au?or mu/ be above x1 vi4 #g4cb 7#ch-geb74 ,p]i%able is body1 because composite1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,p]man5ce1 ! *>act]i/ic ( absolute good1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abji74 ,p]petuates itself by =m1 does heav51 ?r\gh influx1 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-hac74 ,p]petuity & et]nity1 diff]5ce betwe51 iii4 #g4d 7#de-iia74 ,p]si/5ce ( *angeable1 iv4 #g4i 7#b-gh74 ,p]spective1 ii4 #h 7#ce-fhj74 ,p]spective1 v>i\s !ories (1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fhj74 ,p]suasion1 *>act]i/ic ( s\l1 v4 #c4f 7#di-ajii74 ,p]v]sity ( s\l induces judgm5t & puni%m5t1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh7 ,pessimism wrong1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egi74 ,phidias sculpts ,jupit] n f s5se imitation1 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eeb74 ,philonic di/9ction betwe5 ,god1 & ! ,god1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,philosoph]1 be+ already virtu\s1 ne$s only promotion1 i4 #c4c 7#bj-bgb74 ,philosoph]1 h[ he rises to intelligible _w1 i4 #c4c 7#bj-bga74 ,philosoph] is already dis5gag$ & ne$s only a guide1 i4 #c4c 7#bj-bga74 ,philosoph]s born1 alone rea* ! high] region1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,philosoph]s1 h[ !y develop1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,philosoph]s ju/ify ju/ice ( ,god1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,philosoph]'s ma!matics foll[$ by pure dialectics z me?od ( progress1 i4 #c4c 7#bj-bgb74 ,philosoph]'s me?od ( dis5gagem5t is ma!matics z incorporeal sci5ce1 i4 #c4c 7#bj-bga74 ,philosoph]'s op9ions ab\t "t to be /udi$1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iie74 ,philosophy conta9s physics1 e?ics1 i4 #c4e 7#bj-bgc74 ,philosophy exact root ( psy*ology1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahc74 ,philosophy l[] "p ( dialectic1 i4 #c4e 7#bj-bgc74 ,philosophy sep>ates s\l f h] image1 vi4 #d4af 7#bb-caj74 ,philosophy's task is avoidance ( passions1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-ceh74 ,phoebus inspires m5 to int]ior vision1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efi74 ,physical categories are matt]1 =m1 comb9ation1 attributes & accid5ts1 vi4 #c4c 7#dd-ich74 ,physical categories ( ,plot9os1 vi4 #c 7#dd-icc74 ,physical g5]a (1 are diff]5t f ^? ( ! intelligible1 iv4 #c4a 7#bg-chg74 ,physical life1 c x exi/ )\t ! s\l8 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhe74 ,physical1 n m5tal be+1 affect$ by />s1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-ie74 ,physical p[]s d n =m a second>y quality1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-hef74 ,physical qualities appli$ to ,supreme only by analogy1 vi4 #h4h 7#ci-ghe74 ,physical s\l1 production due to1 n a/rological p[]1 iv4 #d4ch 7#bh-eja74 ,physical s\ls1 v>i\s1 h[ !y affect production1 iv4 #d4cg 7#bh-ejj74 ,physical t]ms1 only v]bal simil>ity to intelligible1 vi4 #c4e 7#dd-ida74 ,physical !ories1 absurd1 iii4 #a4c 7#c-hi74 ,physically begun1 spiritual becomes love1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-gee74 ,physician's =e-k1 simile ( ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,picture ( ! /ructure ( ! univ]se1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahg74 ,picture1 p]fection (1 dem&s %ad[1 iii4 #b4aa 7#dg-ajfj74 ,picture t pictures itself is univ]se1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahh74 ,pilgrim s\l is 9 ! _w1 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fce74 ,pilot gov]ns ! %ip1 relation ( s\l to body1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid72 iv4 #c4ba 7#bg-dbb74 ,place has no contr>y1 vi4 #c4ab 7#dd-ied74 ,place or "t d n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4af 7#dc-iai74 ,place or :]e is ,ari/otelian category1 vi4 #a4ad 7#db-hfb74 ,planet calculations1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,plant positions produc+ adult]ies1 absurd1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,plann+ ( ! _w by ,god1 refut$1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efa1 #efc74 ,plants1 d !y admit ( happ9ess1 i4 #d4a1 #b 7#df-ajai to #ajba74 ,plants ev5 aspire to contemplation1 iii4 #h4a 7#cj-eca74 ,plato dep>t$ f1 9 categories1 vi4 #b4a 7#dc-hia74 ,plato n only hates body1 b admires _w1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcc74 ,plato unc]ta9 ab\t "t1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajab74 ,platonic basis ( anti-gno/ic controv]sy1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efa74 ,plato's au?ority1 re/or$1 v4 #a4h 7#aj-ahf74 ,plato's language d\btful1 iii4 #f4ab 7#bf-cgb72 vi4 #g4cj 7#ch-gdi74 ,pleasure an accessory to all goods ( ! s\l1 vi4 #g4cj 7#ch-gdi74 ,pleasure1 because *angeable & re/less1 _c be ! good1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gde7 ,pleasure1 good's indep5d5ce f1 is temp]ate man1 vi4 #g4bi 7#ch-gdg74 ,pleasure may accompany ! good1 b is indep5d5t !re(1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gde74 ,pleasure /rictly1 has no?+ to d ) happ9ess1 i4 #e4d 7#cf-fhe74 ,pleasures ( virtu\s m5 are ( high] k9ds1 i4 #d4ab 7#df-ajcf74 ,plot9os =c$ to demon/ration ( categories by div]g5ce f ,plato1 vi4 #b4a 7#dc-hia74 ,plot9os's g5]a ( s5sual exi/5ce1 iv4 #c 7#bg-chg74 ,poros or ,abundance1 my? (1 iii4 #e4b1 #e 7#ej-aabe to #aaca74 ,possession by div9ity is la/ /age ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efi74 ,possession ( p]fect life1 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbf74 ,possession ( ?+s causes intellig5ce to ?9k !m1 vi4 #f4g 7#cd-fec74 ,pot5tial1 intelligible matt] is n1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cde74 ,pot5tialities are insep>able f _! be+s1 vi4 #d4i 7#bb-bih74 ,pot5tiality & actuality n applicable to div9ity1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-eii74 ,pot5tiality1 def9ition (1 ii4 #e4a 7#be-cda74 ,pot5tiality exi/s only 9 corruptable matt]1 ii4 #e4e 7#be-cdh74 ,pot5tiality expla9s miracle ( se$s conta9+ manifolds1 iv4 #i4e 7#h-adf74 ,pot5tiality produc+1 n becom+1 is ! s\l1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cde74 ,pov]ty caus$ by ext]nal circum/ances1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagd74 ,p[] & beauty ( ess5ce attracts all ?+s1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgh74 ,p[]1 lack (1 _c fall "u same categories z p[]1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-heb74 ,p[]1 ma/] ( himself1 really is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4aj 7#ci-ghh74 ,p[] ( div9ities lies 9 _! inh]+ 9 ! ,supreme1 v4 #h4i 7#ca-efe74 ,p[]s ?\gh secret1 9 ev]y?+1 iv4 #d4cg 7#bh-ejj74 ,practice is only a prep>ation = contemplation1 iii4 #h4f 7#cj-ech74 ,pray$ to1 sun z well z />s may be1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,pray]s1 all made 9 accordance ) natural law1 answ]$1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-ejf74 ,pray]s answ]$ by />s unconsci\sly1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-eje74 ,pray]s1 h[ !y are answ]$1 iv4 #d4da 7#bh-eje74 ,pray]s ( ev5 ! evil are answ]$1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-ejf74 ,pr$ict1 />s d1 because ( s\ls imp]fection1 ii4 #c4aj 7#eb-aagg74 ,pr$iction implies t future is det]m9$1 iii4 #a4c 7#c-ij74 ,pr$iction1 n by works1 b by analogy1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhj74 ,pr$iction1 ) its responsiv5ess1 d n fall "u action & exp]i5ce1 vi4 #a4bb 7#db-hge74 ,pr$isposition ( active life subjection to en*antm5ts1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejh74 ,pr$isposition to magic by affections & weaknesses1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-ejh74 ,pr$om9ant s\l "p active :ile o!rs sleep & 7see manag+ s\l7 appe> ext]ior1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bgi72 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bcd74 ,pr$om9at+ "p1 ,/oic1 iii4 #c4b 7#dh-ajgh74 ,pr$om9at+ pr9ciple directs univ]se1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagc74 ,prep>ation = contemplation is practice1 iii4 #h4f 7#cj-ech74 ,prepond]ance spiritual me?od ( becom+ wise1 i4 #d4ad 7#df-ajcg74 ,pres5ce ( ,god1 ev]y:]e entire1 expla9$ z inf9ite1 vi4 #e4d 7#bc-cah74 ,pres5ce ( intelligible entities impli$ by k ( !m1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-ege74 ,pres5ce ! "o id5tical ess5ce ev]y:]e1 entirely1 vi4 #d 7#bb-bhe74 ,pres5ces1 diff]5t k9ds (1 vi4 #d4aa 7#bb-cjb74 ,pres5t1 et]nal1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agi74 ,pres]vative n1 is univ]sal s\l1 b creative4 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahc74 ,pres]v] & creator is ! good1 vi4 #g4bc 7#ch-gdj74 ,pres]v+1 begott5 ,son1 z result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-ega74 ,priam1 mis=tunes (1 i4 #d4e 7#df-ajbg74 ,pride is folly1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-fah74 ,prim>y ess5ce1 numb]s mu/ exi/ 9 x1 vi4 #f4h 7#cd-fed74 ,prim>y evil is evil 9 itself1 i4 #h4c 7#ea-aadf74 ,prim>y evil is lack ( measure1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaee74 ,prim>y evil ( s\l1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadh74 ,prim>y exi/5ce w conta9 ?\ght1 exi/5ce & life1 ii4 #d4f 7#ab-bjc72 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cci74 ,prim>y movem5t said to und]lie movem5t ( s\l1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajac74 ,primitive "o is a sph]ical figure & intelligible1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fge74 ,primitive relation betwe5 s\l & body1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,pr9ciple1 a supra-?9k+1 necess>y to ! work+ ( intellig5ce1 v4 #f4b 7#bd-ccd74 ,pr9ciple & end simultane\s 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,pr9ciple1 indep5d5t1 is human s\l1 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,pr9ciple ( all1 ?\gh n limit$ !reby1 is ! "o1 v4 #c4aa 7#di-aaji74 ,pr9ciple ( beauty1 :at is x8 i4 #f4a 7#a-dj74 ,pr9ciple "o self-exi/5t con/itut$ by be+ an actualization1 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ghd74 ,pr9ciple1 prim>y1 matt] _c be1 vi4 #a4bf 7#db-hgi47 ,pr9ciple1 simultane\s1 above intellig5ce & exi/5ce1 iii4 #g4b 7#de-ihi74 ,pr9ciple1 sup]-ess5tial1 does n ?9k1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,pr9ciple1 ! fir/1 mu/ be "o exclusively1 :i* w\ld make ?\ght impossible1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-cce74 ,pr9ciple1 ! fir/1 ?9k+1 is ! second pr9ciple1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-cce74 ,pr9ciple1 ! second1 ! fir/ ?9k+ pr9ciple1 is1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-cce74 ,pr9ciples1 div9e1 enum]at$1 vi4 #g4be 7#ch-gda74 ,pr9ciples limit$ to ?ree1 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjb74 ,pr9ciples1 l[]1 conta9 only ant]ior ?+s1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,pr9ciples1 s+le1 ( univ]se1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,priority n appli$ 9 ! div9ity because he made himself1 vi4 #h4bj 7#ci-hjh74 ,prison ( s\l1 is body1 iv4 #h4aa 7#f-abj74 ,priority ( s\l to body1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eh74 ,privation is non5tity1 adds no conceit1 ii4 #d4ad 7#ab-bae74 ,privation ( =m ( matt]1 ii4 #d4ac 7#ab-bac74 ,privation ( qualities2 n a quality1 ii4 #d4ac 7#ab-bac74 ,privation relative is impossible1 i4 #h4ab 7#ea-aaeh74 ,process1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icc72 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,process f unity to duality1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-cch74 ,process1 natural1 only affect$ by />vation1 ii4 #c4ab 7#eb-aagh74 ,process ( purification ( s\l & its sep>ation f body1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-cei74 ,process ( s\l elevation1 v4 #c4i 7#di-aajf74 ,process ( unification1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,process ( vision & he>+1 iv4 #e 7#bi-ead74 ,process ( wak5+ to reality1 v4 #e4aa 7#cb-eib74 ,process1 triune1 also implies id5tity & diff]5ce1 vi4 #i4h 7#dc-ije74 ,processes ( ec/asy by purification1 i4 #f4f1 #h1 #i 7#a-di74 ,procession by x1 s\l connects indivisible & divisible ess5ce1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgf74 ,procession1 cont9u\s1 necess>y to ! ,supreme1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,procession f "o ( :at is aft] x1 v4 #d 7#g-acd74 ,procession is effusion ( sup]-abundance1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,procession is univ]sal1 f fir/ to la/1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aie74 ,procession ( intellig5ce is an excursion d[n & up1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,procession ( s\l1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,procession ( ! _w-s\l1 iii4 #h4e 7#cj-ecg74 ,procession ( _w f unity1 cause4 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,procreation1 he n desir+ x1 aspires to high] beauty1 iii4 #e4a 7#ej-aabc74 ,procreativ5ess inh]5t 7see radiation1 exub]ant1 sup]-abundant71 v4 #d4a 7#g-ace74 ,prodigal1 return1 i4 #f4h 7#a-ec74 ,prodigal son1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc74 ,produc$ by />s1 :i* is & :at is n1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagh74 ,produc+ pot5tiality1 n becom+1 is ! s\l1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cdf74 ,production due to "s physical s\l n a/rological p[]1 iv4 #d4ch 7#bh-eja74 ,production ( ! ?+s locat$ is ess5ce1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-feg74 ,progress possible1 argum5t aga9/ suicide1 i4 #i 7#af-bdc74 ,progressively high] /ages ( love1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajc74 ,progressively1 _w-s\l in=ms all ?+s1 iv4 #c4aj 7#bg-djf74 ,prome!us1 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab74 ,prome!us ( flight leaves s\l unh>m$ f inc>nation1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,pro(s = exi/5ce & nature ( intellig5ce1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,proportion1 ,/oic pr9ciple ( beauty1 n ultimate1 b d]ivative1 i4 #f4a 7#a-da74 ,provid5ce accus$ by slav]y ( good & victory ( evil1 iii4 #b4f 7#dg-ajeb74 ,provid5ce1 *ief ( all1 iii4 #c4b 7#dh-ajgi74 ,provid5ce consi/s ( appo9t$ times 9 life1 %\ld be obs]v$1 i4 #i 7#af-bdc74 ,provid5ce does n ab&on ev5 ! m$iocre1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajeh74 ,provid5ce does n expla9 pr$iction b analogy1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhf74 ,provid5ce1 d\ble1 p>ticul> & univ]sal1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha74 ,provid5ce embraces ev]y?+ bel[1 iii4 #b4g 7#dg-ajed74 ,provid5ce1 =e k (1 l unto a physician1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,provid5ce is normative elem5t ( life1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhd74 ,provid5ce is n p>ticul>1 because _w _h no beg9n+1 iii4 #b4a 7#dg-ajdc74 ,provid5ce is prevision & reason+1 iii1 #b4a 7#dg-ajdb74 ,provid5ce is unpr$ictable circum/ance *ang+ life1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdb74 ,provid5ce may appe> z *ance1 iii4 #c4b 7#dh-ajgh74 ,provid5ce1 objection to by int]nec9e w>1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajfd74 ,provid5ce problems solv$ by d]ivation ( reason f intellig5ce1 iii4 #b4af 7#dg-ajfh74 ,provid5ce %\ld n ov]%ad[ initiative1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajeg74 ,provid5ce1 ! plan ( ! univ]se is f et]nity1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjc74 ,provid5ce1 tw(old1 ex]t$ by tw(old s\l1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abb74 ,prud5ce int]pret$ z purification1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,prud5ce or ,metis1 my? (1 iii4 #e4e 7#ej-aacj74 ,psy*ic1 gno/ic di/9ction ( m51 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fce74 ,psy*ologic elem5ts1 s5sation1 faculties ( g5]ation & increase1 & creative p[]1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,psy*ologic elem5ts1 s\l gives life to1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,psy*ological effect ( vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,psy*ological faculty1 on :i* is ! fre$om ( w bas$1 vi4 #h4b 7#ci-gge74 ,psy*ological que/ions1 iv4 #c 7#bg-chg74 ,psy*ological /udy (1 outl9e1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgf74 ,psy*ological !ory ( quality1 vi4 #a4ab 7#db-heh74 ,psy*ology1 common "p1 its function1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjc74 ,psy*ology1 does ratioc9ation belong to same pr9ciples z passions1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,psy*ology 7e man d\ble71 composite animal1 real man or reasonable s\l1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,psy*ology1 exact root ( philosophy1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahc74 ,psy*ology1 explanation ( ang] p>ts1 c\rage1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,psy*ology1 inquir+ pr9ciple1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,psy*ology obeys ! precept ,"k ?yself1 iv1 #c4a 7#bg-chg74 ,psy*ology ( demons1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,psy*ology ( e>?1 iv4 #d4bg 7#bh-dgi74 ,psy*ology ( s5sation1 iv4 #c4bf 7#bg-dcj74 ,psy*ology ( vegetative "p ( s\l1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dha74 ,psy*ology ?\ght1 its nature & classification1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,pun betwe5 sci5ce & k1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eei74 ,pun on aeon1 z age or et]nity1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihf74 ,pun on agalmata1 v4 #h4e1 #f 7#ca-efj74 ,pun on ,aphrodite1 z delicate1 iii4 #e4h 7#ej-aacg74 ,pun on be+1 intelligible1 vi4 #c4h 7#dd-idg74 ,pun on creation & adornm5t1 ii4 #d4d 7#ab-bad72 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,pun on diff]5ce 9 o!rs1 ii4 #d4ac 7#ab-bad74 ,pun on dii & dik51 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,pun on doxa1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-egh74 ,pun on ,egyptian hi]oglyphics & /atues 7see agalmata74 ,pun on eidos & idea1 v4 #i4h 7#e-aaa72 vi #i4b 7#i-adi74 ,pun on e9ai & h5os1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehd74 ,pun on =ms & /atues1 v4 #h4e 7#ca-efj74 ,pun on heav51 _w1 univ]se1 animal & all1 ii4 #a4a 7#dj-had74 ,pun on ,he/ia1 & /&+1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehd74 ,pun on ,hesis1 vi4 #a4bc 7#db-hgg74 ,pun on idea & eidos1 see eidos4 ,pun on incl9ation1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fje74 ,pun on koros1 iii4 #h4aa 7#cj-eej72 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc72 v4 #i4h 7#e-aaa72 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab72 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,pun on love & vision1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabh74 ,pun on n\s1 noesis1 & to noeton1 v4 #c4e 7#di-ajif to #ajii74 ,pun on pas*e91 exp]i5c+1 suff]+1 react+1 & passion1 vi4 #a4ae 7#db-hfd74 ,pun on ,poros1 iii4 #e4i1 #aj 7#ej-aadj74 ,pun on ,prome!us & ,provid5ce1 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab74 ,pun on reason & *>act]i/ic1 iii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh72 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fa74 ,pun on s*esis & s*ema1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhd74 ,pun on ,soma & soze/hai1 v4 #i4e 7#e-aji74 ,pun on suff]+1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adc74 ,pun on ?9k+1 ?9kable & intellection1 vi4 #a4ah 7#db-hfh74 ,pun on timely & sov]eign1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjf74 ,pun on unadorn$ & creat$1 see koros1 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb74 ,pun on ,ve/a & ,he/ia1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehd74 ,puni%able & impassible1 s\l is bo?4 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjd74 ,puni%m5t foll[s p]v]sity ( s\l1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,puni%m5ts & mis=tunes1 significance (1 iv4 #c4ae 7#bg-dad74 ,pure ?\ghts is t "p ( ! s\l :i* mo/ resembles intellig5ce1 v4 #c4h 7#di-aajb74 ,purification cle>s up m5tal k1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-hj74 ,purification1 cont5t ( virtues1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,purification 9 my/]ies1 leads to nak$ness1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,purification ( s\l l man wa%+ (f mud1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dh74 ,purification produces conv]sion1 & is us$ by virtue1 i4 #b4d 7#ai-bfa74 ,purification ( s\l process involv$1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-cei74 ,purification's goal is second div9ity intellig5ce1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfd74 ,purification limit is t ( ! s\l self-control1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfc74 ,purity1 condition ( rema9+ 9 unity ) ! div9ity1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,purpose ( life1 supreme1 vision ( ,god1 i4 #f4g 7#a-ej74 ,puzzle ( "o & _m decides ( ! g5]a ( ess5ce1 vi4 #b4d 7#dc-hih74 ,puzzle ( orig9 ( ,god due to *aos be+ />t+ po9t1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gib74 ,puzzle ( s\l be+ "o1 yet 9 all1 iv4 #c4d 7#bg-cid74 ,quadrature1 ii4 #c4d 7#eb-aafh74 ,qualities1 sqq4 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-heb74 ,qualities admit ( degrees1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-igj74 ,qualities are accid5tal %apes ( be+1 ii4 #f4c 7#ag-bej74 ,qualities are acts ( be+1 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdi74 ,qualities are incorporeal1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhe74 ,qualities1 because !y *ange1 matt] mu/ be passible1 iii4 #f4h 7#bf-cff74 ,qualities classifi$ z body & ( s\l1 vi4 #c4ag 7#dd-ifc74 ,qualities1 di/9ction betwe5 qualities & complem5ts ( be+1 ii4 #f4a 7#ag-bde74 ,qualities1 g5u9e1 are n diff]5tial be+s1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-hec74 ,qualities1 modal & ess5tial1 di/9ctions betwe51 ii4 #f4a 7#ag-bdf74 ,qualities m ess5tial ?an quantity1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fhj74 ,qualities n all are reasons1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-hed74 ,qualities n =m$ by union ( f\r ,plot9ic categories1 vi4 #b4ae 7#dc-iah74 ,qualities ( s5se1 among !m belong _m o!r conceptions1 vi4 #c4af 7#dd-ifa74 ,qualities1 "s are diff]5ces1 vi4 #c4ah 7#dd-ife74 ,qualities1 "s diff]5ces are n1 vi4 #c4ah 7#dd-iff74 ,qualities1 _! d]ivation f affection is ( no importance1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-heg74 ,qualities1 ugly1 are imp]fect reasons1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-hee74 ,quality1 ii4 #f 7#ag-bde72 iv4 #g4e1 #i1 #aj 7#b-fb to #hj74 ,quality & matt] =m body1 accord+ to ,/oics1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,quality & ?+ qualifi$1 relation betwe51 vi4 #a4ab 7#db-heh74 ,quality1 by x all ?+s dep5d on ! good1 i4 #g4b 7#ed-abji74 ,quality1 by x1 be+ diff]5ces are di/+ui%$1 vi4 #c4ag 7#dd-ifc74 ,quality1 category1 v>i\s d]ivatives (1 vi4 #c4ai 7#dd-ifg74 ,quality consi/s ( a non-ess5tial "*1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-hee74 ,quality diff]5ces _c be di/+ui%$ by s5sation1 vi4 #c4ag 7#dd-ifc74 ,quality1 intelligible & s5se1 diff]5ce betwe51 ii4 #f4c 7#ag-bdi74 ,quality is good1 a common label or common quality1 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gcc74 ,quality is n a p[] b disposition1 =m & "*1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-hed74 ,quality is only figurative "n = complem5t ( be+1 vi4 #b4ad 7#dc-iah74 ,quality none 9 matt]1 ii4 #d4g 7#ab-bjd72 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,quality none 9 matt] :i* is deprivation1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeg74 ,quality n a prim>y g5us1 because po/]ior to be+1 vi4 #b4ad 7#dc-iag74 ,quality n 9 matt] is an accid5t1 i4 #h4aj 7#ea-aaeg74 ,quality1 "o1 p>tak5 ( by capacity & disposition1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-hef74 ,quality1 physical ne$ ( supreme only by analogy1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afd74 ,quality1 psy*ological !ory (1 vi4 #a4ab 7#db-heh74 ,quality1 second>y1 n =m$ by physical p[]s1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-hef74 ,quality1 %ape is n1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-heg74 ,quality1 accord+ to ! ,/oics1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhe74 ,quality1 !re is only "o k9d1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-hef74 ,quality1 v>i\s t]ms express+ x1 vi4 #c4af 7#dd-ifj74 ,quality1 :e!r x alone c be call$ simil> or dissimil>1 vi4 #c4ae 7#dd-iei74 ,quality-less ?+ 9 itself1 rea*$ by ab/raction1 ii4 #d4aj 7#ab-bjg74 ,quantity1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hda74 ,quantity a second>y g5us1 !re=e n a fir/1 vi4 #b4ac 7#dc-iae74 ,quantity admits ( contr>ies1 vi4 #c4aa 7#dd-iec74 ,quantity1 ,ari/otelian criticiz$1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hda74 ,quantity1 z equal & unequal1 does n ref] to ! objects1 vi4 #a4e 7#db-hde74 ,quantity category1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-ahj74 ,quantity1 cont9u\s & def9ite1 h no?+ 9 common4 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hda74 ,quantity1 def9ition (1 includes l>ge & small1 vi4 #c4aa 7#dd-ieb74 ,quantity1 diff]5t k9ds (1 9 magnitudes & numb]s1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hdc74 ,quantity1 discrete1 diff]5t f cont9u\s1 vi4 #c4ac 7#dd-iee74 ,quantity1 elem5ts ( cont9u\s1 vi4 #c4ad 7#dd-iee74 ,quantity1 if "t is1 :y a sep>ate category1 vi4 #a4ac 7#db-hfa74 ,quantity 9 numb]1 b n numb] 9 quantity1 vi4 #a4d 7#db-hdb74 ,quantity 9 quantative numb]1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-ehb74 ,quantity is incorporeal1 ii4 #d4i 7#ab-bjg74 ,quantity is spee*1 #a4e 7#db-hdd74 ,quantity less ess5tial ?an quality1 ii4 #h4a 7#ce-fhj74 ,quantity n qualities /udi$ by geometry1 vi4 #c4ae 7#dd-ieh74 ,quantity1 "t is n1 vi4 #a-e 7#db-hdd74 ,"q1 n to be ask$ by our ord] 9 nature1 iii4 #c4c 7#dh-ajgi74 ,quiddity & be+ e>li] ?an su*ness1 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh74 ,qu9tess5ce1 ii4 #a4b 7#dj-hae72 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cdf74 ,radiation jo9s image to its model1 vi4 #d4aj 7#bb-cjj74 ,radiation ( an image is g5]ation1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb74 ,radiation ( good is creative p[]1 vi4 #g4cg 7#ch-gfa74 ,radiation ( light1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,radiation ( multiple unity1 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaae74 ,radiation ( />s = good1 expla9s _! influ5ce1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-dig74 ,radii c5t]+1 to expla91 s\l unify+ s5sations1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fe74 ,rank1 v4 #d4b 7#g-acf72 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,rank aft] dea?1 dep5ds on /ate at dea?1 h5ce progress mu/ be a*iev$1 i4 #i 7#af-bdc74 ,rank ( s\ls1 iv4 #c4f 7#bg-cig74 ,rank1 s\ls ( ! second1 univ]sal rank1 are m51 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,rank ?ird1 ( exi/5ce1 %\ld n be occupi$ by modality1 vi4 #a4cj 7#db-hhg74 ,rank ?ird ( s\ls1 ii4 #a4h 7#ee-abjj74 ,ranks 9 ! ,univ]se reasonable = s\ls to be assign$ !reto1 iii4 #b4ab 7#dg-ajfa74 ,ranks ( exi/5ce1 ?ree1 ii4 #i4ac 7#cc-fbf72 iii4 #c4c 7#dh-ajgi72 iii4 #e4i 7#ej-aach72 vi4 #d4aa 7#bb-cjb72 vi4 #e4d 7#bc-cah74 ,ranks ( exi/5ce b5ea? ! beautiful1 vi4 #g4db 7#ch-ggj74 ,ratioc9ation1 has no place ev5 9 ! _w-s\l1 iv4 #d4aa 7#bh-dee74 ,ratioc9ation1 s\ls c reason intuitionally )\t1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-daf74 ,rationaliz$ matt]1 body z1 ii4 #g4c 7#cg-fif74 ,reaction or suff]+1 def9ition (1 vi4 #a4ba 7#dc-hgb74 ,reactions1 ne$ n be passive1 b may be active1 vi4 #a4ba 7#db-hgj74 ,real man & we1 di/9ctions betwe51 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjb74 ,real man diff]s f body1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjc74 ,reality1 same diff]5t degrees (1 are intellig5ce & life1 vi4 #g4ah 7#ch-gcb74 ,reason & =m possess$ by ev]y?+1 ii4 #g4c 7#cg-fif74 ,reason z a :ole1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbf74 ,reason z d]iv$ f intellig5ce1 iii4 #b4af 7#dg-ajfh74 ,reason _c be d$uc$ f atoms1 iii4 #a4b 7#c-hh74 ,reason1 diff]5tiat$1 w\ld deprive ! s\l ( consci\sness1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fjb74 ,reason discursive is n us$ dur+ disc>nation1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-daf74 ,reason div9e is to blame1 iv4 #b4aj 7#dg-ajei74 ,reason foll[$1 is secret ( fre$om1 iii4 #a4i 7#c-ig74 ,reason has no ext5sion1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fd74 ,reason 9 head1 n 9 bra91 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbe74 ,reason1 its influ5ce is only sugge/ive1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfd74 ,reason no explanation ( liv+ well1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbb74 ,reason n result$ 9 =esight ( creation1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,reason n suffici5t explanation ( liv+ well1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbb74 ,reason or ideas possess$ by intellectual life1 vi4 #b4ba 7#dc-ibg74 ,reason1 sem9al iv4 #g4b 7#b-eh74 ,reason1 sem9al1 produces man1 ii4 #c4ab 7#eb-aagh74 ,reason t begets ev]y?+ is ,jupit]'s g>d51 iii4 #e4i 7#ej-aacg74 ,reason1 total ( ! univ]se1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagh74 ,reason unites ! s\l divid$ by bodies1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adb74 ,reason1 univ]sal1 is bo? s\l & nature1 iii4 #h4c 7#cj-ecc74 ,reason us$ only :ile h9d]$ by ob/acles ( body1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-daf74 ,reasonable = s\ls to be assign$ to diff]5t ranks1 iii4 #b4ab 7#dg-ajfa74 ,reason+ abs5t 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,reason+ & =esight are only figurative expressions1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fii74 ,reason+ & memory n impli$ by _w-s\l1 wisdom1 iv4 #d-ab 7#bh-deg74 ,reason+ & memory sup]s$$ by _w-s\l's wisdom1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-def74 ,reasons are ! actualization ( ! s\l t begets ! animal1 vi4 #g4e 7#ch-gjg74 ,reasons1 d\ble1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha74 ,reasons1 n all are qualities1 vi4 #a4aj 7#db-hed74 ,reasons1 unity con/itut$ by conta9$ contr>ies1 iii4 #b4af 7#dg-ajfi74 ,reception1 transmission1 relation1 und]lies action & exp]i5ce1 vi4 #a4bb 7#db-hgd74 ,receptivity acc\nts = div9ity's see+ by individuals1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-ccj74 ,receptivity det]m9es p>ticipation 9 ! "o1 vi4 #d4aa 7#bb-cca74 ,receptivity is limit ( p>ticipation 9 div9e1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,reciprocal nature ( all ?+s1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhj74 ,recognition ( div9e k9%ip dep5ds ( self k1 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afc74 ,recognition ( ea* o!r by s\ls1 desc5d+ f intelligibles into heav51 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,r$emption ( _w by _w-s\l1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,r$uction to unity1 v4 #c4f 7#di-ajii74 ,reflection1 n1 b self-necessity1 cause ( creation ( s5se-_w1 iii4 #b4b 7#dg-ajdd74 ,reflects ev]y?+1 does ! empty mirror ( matt]1 iii4 #f4g 7#bf-cfc74 ,re=matory1 are hell's torm5ts1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaa74 ,refraction1 light+ fire f1 illu/rates g5]ation1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf74 ,refre%m5t n ne$$ by />s1 :i* are inexhau/ible1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbg74 ,refutation ( ,james ,lange !ory1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aaif74 ,re9c>nation is result ( s\l-judgm5ts1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,rejection ( =m ( approa*+ s\ls proves =mlessness ( ! ,supreme1 vi4 #g4cd 7#ch-gef74 ,relation1 vi4 #a4f 7#db-hde74 ,relation betwe5 ext]nal & int]nal1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadi74 ,relation is a habit or mann] ( be+1 vi4 #c4bg 7#dd-iha74 ,relation is an app5dage exi/+ only among def9ite objects1 vi4 #b4af 7#dc-iai74 ,relation ( good1 intellig5ce & s\l l light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,relation primitive betwe5 s\l & body1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,relation1 ,/oic1 category confuses ! new ) ! ant]ior1 vi4 #a4ca 7#db-hhh74 ,relations are simultane\s exi/5ces1 vi4 #a4g 7#db-hdh74 ,relations1 are !y subjective ( objective8 vi4 #a4g 7#db-hdg74 ,relay ( s5sation f organ to direct+ pr9ciple1 impossible1 iv4 #g4g 7#b-fg74 ,relay transmission1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bhj72 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-ebb74 ,relays 9 spread+ light1 v4 #c4i 7#di-aaje74 ,rememb] itself1 ! s\l does n ev51 iv4 #d4b 7#bh-ddc74 ,rememb]s1 s\l becomes t :i* %e does1 iv4 #d4c 7#bh-dde74 ,rem9isc5ces ( intelligible entities1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajg74 ,rep5tances ( gno/ics1 oppos$1 ii4 #i4f 7#cc-fjh74 ,repugnance natural to /udy ( unity1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-ae74 ,resemblance lack+1 makes contr>ies1 vi4 #c4bj 7#dd-igj74 ,resemblance ( intelligible to e>?ly bas$ on ! conv]se 7,platonic71 v4 #h4f 7#ca-efa74 ,resemblance to div9ity is s\l's welf>e1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,resemblance to div9ity1 result ( homely virtues1 i4 #b4a 7#ai-beg74 ,resemblance1 two k9ds1 effect & cause or simultane\s effects1 i4 #b4b 7#ai-beh74 ,resid5ce & sub/rate ( =ms to matt]1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aig74 ,resid5ce dem&$ by =ms1 aga9/ ,mod]atus ( ,gades1 ii4 #d4ab 7#ab-baa74 ,resid5ce1 "m1 nurse or o!r nature is matt]1 iii4 #f4ah 7#bf-chb74 ,resid5ce ( et]nal g5]ation is matt]1 iii4 #f4ac 7#bf-cgc74 ,resid5ce ( =m is matt] z image ( ext5sion1 ii4 #d4aa 7#ab-baj74 ,resid5ce ( univ]sal s\l is heav51 immortaliz+ x1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hag74 ,responsible = our ills1 ,gods are n1 iv4 #d4cg 7#bh-ejj74 ,responsible1 spontaneity n affect$ by involunt>9ess1 iii4 #b4aj 7#dg-ajfj74 ,responsibility dep5ds solely on involunt>9ess1 vi4 #h4a 7#ci-ggd74 ,responsibility n injur$ by guidance ( ,daemon1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bch74 ,responsibility n to be %ift$ f responsible reason1 iii4 #b4ae 7#dg-ajfe74 ,re/1 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agh72 v4 #c4g 7#di-aaja74 ,re/ & motion bel[ "o1 iii4 #i4g 7#ac-bbe74 ,re/ & movem5t di/9ction also inapplicable1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fjj74 ,re/1 z category1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihg72 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijc74 ,re/ consi/s ( *ange1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-aai74 ,re/1 intelligible1 ! =m by :i* all consi/s1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd74 ,re/ ( ,h]aclitus1 description ( ec/atic goal1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afe72 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,resultance ( causes is any?+1 ii4 #c4ad 7#eb-aaha74 ,results ( ec/asy1 rema9+ close to div9ity1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,retirem5t ( s\l is to sup]ior p[]1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aie74 ,retribution div9e1 all are l$ to x by secret road1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaa74 ,return ( prodigal1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,return ( s\l to intelligible by ?ree pa?s1 i4 #c4a 7#bj-bgj74 ,return ( s\l to its pr9ciple on de/ruction ( body1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aie74 ,reveal]s ( ! et]nal1 are s5se-objects1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-acj74 ,revelation ( div9e p[] expresses true k1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-fag74 ,rew>ds may be neglect$ by good1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajee74 ,rhea1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che72 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahe74 ,ri*es1 inequality ( no mom5t to an et]nal be+1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-faf74 ,ridicul\s to compla9 ( l[] nature ( animals1 iii4 #b4i 7#dg-ajei74 ,ridicul\s to expect p]fections1 b d5y x to nature1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjg74 ,"r ( leav+ _w res]v$ by wise m51 i4 #d4af 7#df-ajci74 ,rises to ! good1 does ! s\l1 by scorn+ all ?+s bel[1 vi4 #g4ca 7#ch-gej74 ,roads1 secret1 leads all to retribution1 iv4 #d4de 7#bg-eaa74 ,rocks h greate/ non5tity1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfa74 ,ru% ( s\l t[>ds ! "o1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aabj74 ,same pr9ciple1 h[ c x exi/ 9 all ?+s8 vi4 #d4f 7#bb-bie74 ,same pr9ciple1 h[ v>i\s ?+s c p>ticipate1 vi4 #d4ab 7#bb-cjc74 ,same ?+ n se5 9 ! ,supreme by diff]5t p]sons1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-ega74 ,sample is only ?+ we c exam9e1 v4 #h4c 7#cc-eee74 ,sample t mu/ be purifi$1 is image ( intellig5ce1 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eee74 ,sanative elem5t ( life1 is ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhd74 ,sanctu>y1 inn]1 p5etrations into1 result+ advantage ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,sanctu>y ( ec/asy1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb72 i4 #h4g 7#ea-aaeb72 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeg72 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,sanctu>y ( my/]ies1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,satiety does n produce scorn1 9 ! intelligible1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,satisfaction ( desire to live is n happ9ess1 i4 #e4b 7#cf-fhd74 ,saturn1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahe72 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc72 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhi74 ,saturn & ,m>s1 relations are q illogical1 ii #c4e 7#eb-aafi74 ,saturn held d[n by *a9s1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,saturnian realm1 vi4 #a4d 7#aj-agh74 ,s*eme1 "p 9 x s\l mu/ fit itself to1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajga74 ,sci5ce does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4ag 7#dc-ibj74 ,sci5ce is ei!r a movem5t or some?+ composite1 vi4 #b4ah 7#dc-ibc74 ,sci5ce is pres5t 9 ! :ole1 pot5tially at lea/1 v4 #i4h 7#e-aaa74 ,sci5ce is ! actualization ( ! notions t are pot5tial sci5ce1 vi4 #b4bj 7#dc-ibe74 ,sci5ce1 "p & :ole 9 x n applicable to s\l1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-cij74 ,sci5ce's1 greate/ is t\*$ ) ! good1 vi4 #g4c 7#ch-gfj74 ,scorn n produc$ by satiety 9 ! intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,scorn ( life implies good1 vi4 #g4bi 7#ch-gdh74 ,scorn ( ?is _w no gu>antee ( goodness1 ii4 #i4af 7#cc-fcj74 ,scorn+ all ?+s bel[1 s\l rises to ! good1 vi4 #g4ca 7#ch-gej74 ,sculptor1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,seal ( wax1 impressions on1 are s5sations1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-ff74 ,second mu/ be p]fect1 v4 #d4a 7#g-acf74 ,second necess>ily begott5 by fir/1 v4 #d4a 7#g-ace74 ,second rank ( univ]se1 s\ls ( m51 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,second>y evil is accid5tal =mlessness1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaed74 ,second>y evil is matt]1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadf74 ,second>y evil ( s\l1 i4 #h4e 7#ea-aadh74 ,secrecy ( my/]y-rites expla9s ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-aga74 ,secret p[]s 9 ev]y?+1 iv4 #d4cg 7#bh-ejj74 ,secret road1 leads all to div9e retribution1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaa74 ,see+ ,god )\t emotion1 sign ( lack ( unification1 vi4 #i4d 7#i-aee74 ,seek+ any?+ beyond life1 dep>ts f x1 vi4 #e4ab 7#bc-cca74 ,seem+ to be beautiful satisfies1 b only be+ good satisfies1 v4 #e4ab 7#cb-eid74 ,seems z if ! begott5 0 a univ]sal s\l1 vi4 #d4ad 7#bb-cjg74 ,se5 ! ,supreme1 no "o :o has calls him *ance1 vi4 #h4ai 7#ci-hjg74 ,self autocracy1 vi4 #h4ba 7#ci-hjg74 ,self-consci\sness c exi/ 9 a simple pr9ciple1 v4 #c4a 7#di-ajij74 ,self-consci\sness consi/s ( becom+ intellig5ce1 v4 #c4d 7#di-ajif74 ,self-consci\sness is n ne$$ by self-suffici5t good1 vi4 #g4ch 7#ch-gfc74 ,self-consci\sness is m p]fect 9 intellig5ce ?an 9 ! s\l1 v4 #c4f 7#di-ajih74 ,self-consci\sness result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,self-control is assimilation to div9ity1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfc74 ,self-control limit$ by s\l's purification1 v4 #b4e 7#ai-bfc74 ,self-developm5t1 "o object ( inc>nation1 v4 #h4e 7#ca-eei74 ,self-e/eem1 prop]1 v4 #a4a 7#aj-agc74 ,self-exi/5ce possess$ by ess5ce1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgh74 ,self-glorifi$1 image ( a trap on way to ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,self is ! s\l1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-eg74 ,self-lum9\s /atues 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,self-suffici5cy ( supreme1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aabj74 ,self-victory ov]1 ma/]y ( fate1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,sem9al reason1 ii4 #f4a 7#ag-bdf72 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,sem9al reason does n conta9 ord]1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,sem9al reason h>monizes ) its appe>+ actualization1 vi4 #c4af 7#dd-ifj74 ,sem9al reason produces man1 ii4 #c4ab 7#eb-aagh74 ,sem9al reasons1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eec72 v4 #g4a 7#ah-beb74 ,sem9al reasons1 z qualifi$ matt] w\ld be composite & second>y1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhf74 ,sem9al reasons1 cause ( diff]5ce ( ?+s1 v4 #g4a 7#ah-bea74 ,sem9al reasons cause ! s\l1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahd74 ,sem9al reasons may be contr>y to s\l's nature1 b n to s\l1 vi4 #g4g 7#ch-gaj74 ,s5sation1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd74 ,s5sation & memory1 iv4 #f 7#da-hbi74 ,s5sation & memory1 ,/oic doctr9es (1 hang toge!r1 iv4 #f4a 7#da-hbi74 ,s5sation z dream ( ! s\l1 f :i* we mu/ wake1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfc74 ,s5sation _c di/+ui% quality diff]5ces1 vi4 #c4ag 7#dd-ifc74 ,s5sation _c rea* tru?1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-egf74 ,s5sations cause ( emotion1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhb74 ,s5sation equival5t to good1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajba74 ,s5sation dep5ds on s5se-%ape1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,s5sation1 ext]nal & int]nal1 i4 #a-g 7#ec-aaii74 ,s5sation implies ! feel+ s\l1 i4 #a4f 7#ec-aaih74 ,s5sation1 int]m$i>y1 dem&s conceptive ?\ght1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgb74 ,s5sation is limit$ to ! common integral p>ts ( ! univ]se1 iv4 #e4h 7#bi-ebi74 ,s5sation mu/ fir/ be exam9$1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dgb74 ,s5sation n a s\l di/raction1 iv4 #d4be 7#bh-dgg74 ,s5sation n 9 head1 b 9 bra91 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbe74 ,s5sation1 psy*ology (1 iv4 #c4bf 7#bg-dcj74 ,s5sation relay$ f organ to direct+ pr9ciple impossible1 iv4 #g4g 7#b-fg74 ,s5sation tak5 z _! guide1 ,/oic's fault1 vi4 #a4bh 7#db-hhd74 ,s5sations are actualizations1 n only 9 sight1 b 9 all s5ses1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hce74 ,s5sations are n exp]i5ces b relative actualizations1 iv4 #f4b 7#da-hca74 ,s5sations z impressions on seal ( wax1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-ff74 ,s5sations di/ract f ?\ght1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,s5se beauties1 less delightful ?an moral1 i4 #f4d 7#a-dd74 ,s5se beauty1 transition to intellectual1 i4 #f4c 7#a-de74 ,s5se be+1 common elem5t1 9 matt] =m & comb9ation1 vi4 #c4d 7#dd-idj74 ,s5se gr[? & emotions lead to divisibility1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,s5se objects are int]m$iate betwe5 =m & matt]1 iii4 #f4ag 7#bf-cha74 ,s5se objects1 h[ are n evil1 iii4 #b4h 7#dg-ajee74 ,s5se objects1 m51 v4 #i4a 7#i-adh74 ,s5se objects1 motion =1 vi4 #c4bc 7#dd-igf74 ,s5se objects reveal et]nal1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-acj74 ,s5se objects unreal1 made up ( appe>ance1 iii4 #f4ab 7#bf-cga74 ,s5se organs1 s5se bett] )\t m$ium h[ev] passible1 iv4 #e4a 7#bi-eae74 ,s5se p[] ( s\l deals only ) ext]nal ?+s1 v4 #c4b 7#di-ajia74 ,s5se qualities1 _m o!r conceptions belong among !m1 vi4 #c4af 7#dd-ifa74 ,s5se %ape1 l tools1 is int]m$iate1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,s5se _w creat$ n by reflection b self-necessity1 iii4 #b4b 7#dg-ajdd74 ,s5se _w has less unity ?an intelligible _w1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbb74 ,s5se _w1 ! g5]ation 9 x1 is :at be+ is 9 ! intelligible1 iv4 #c4c 7#bg-cib74 ,s5ses1 n giv5 only = utility1 iv4 #d4bd 7#bh-dge74 ,s5ses n giv5 to man1 f exp]i5ce ( mis=tune1 vi4 #g4a 7#ch-fig74 ,s5ses ( e>? may be diff]5t f ours1 iv4 #d4bf 7#bh-dgh74 ,s5tim5ts1 mo/ ke5ly felt1 con/itute p lov]s1 i4 #f4d 7#a-df74 ,sep>ation ( s\l f body1 enables s\l to use x1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaic74 ,sep>ation ( s\l f body is dea?1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,sep>ation ( s\l f body1 process involv$1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-cei74 ,sep>ation ref]s n only to body b accretions1 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjd74 ,sex alone w\ld n acc\nt = diff]5ces ( ?+s1 v4 #g4b 7#ah-beb74 ,%ad[s necess>y to ! p]fection ( a picture1 iii4 #b4aa 7#dg-ajfj74 ,%ape is n a quality1 b a specific appe>ance ( reason1 vi4 #a4aa 7#db-heg74 ,%ape is ! actualization1 ?\ght ! =m ( be+1 v4 #i4h 7#e-aaa74 ,%ape receiv$ f else:]e1 v4 #i4e 7#e-ajg74 ,%apeless impressions (1 diff] f m5tal blank1 ii4 #d4aj 7#ab-bjg74 ,%apeless %ap]1 ess5tial beauty & ! transc5d5t to ,supreme1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,sight1 ii4 #h 7#ce-fhj74 ,sight1 actualize z ?\ght1 v4 #a4e 7#aj-aha74 ,sight & ?\ght =m b "o1 v4 #a4e 7#aj-aha74 ,sight1 s5se (1 does n possess ! image se5 )9 x1 iv4 #f4a 7#da-hbi74 ,sight1 two me?ods (1 =m & light1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf74 ,significance ( puni%m5ts & mis=tunes1 iv4 #c4af 7#bg-dad74 ,sil5ce1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,simile f light+ fire f refraction1 iii4 #f4ad 7#bf-cgf74 ,simile ( ab/raction1 triangles1 circles1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,simile ( badly tun$ lyre _c produce h>mony1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,simile ( captive 9 gold5 *a9s--matt]1 i4 #h4ae 7#ea-aafc74 ,simile ( cave & grotto1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-abj74 ,simile ( c5t] & circul> intellig5ce1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjd74 ,simile ( *oral ballet1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afe74 ,simile ( circles1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc72 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfb74 ,simile ( cle> gold1 admitt+ its real nature1 iv4 #g4aj 7#b-ha74 ,simile ( cosmic *oric ballet1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afe74 ,simile ( ,cupid & ,psy*e1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-afg74 ,simile ( drama ( life1 all[s = good & bad1 iii4 #b4ah 7#dg-ajgb74 ,simile ( face 9 sev]al mirrors1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,simile ( =ekn[l$ge ( physician to expla9 ,provid5ce1 iii4 #c4e 7#dh-ajhe74 ,simile ( gue/ & ar*itect ( h\se1 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fce74 ,simile ( head ) ?ree faces all r\nd1 vi4 #e4g 7#bc-cbj74 ,simile ( light 9 air1 z s\l is pres5t 9 body1 iv4 #c4bb 7#bg-dbc74 ,simile ( light rema9+ on high1 :ile %9+ d[n1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abd74 ,simile ( light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,simile ( love t wat*es at door ( ! belov$1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbe74 ,simile ( man fall5 9 mud1 ne$+ wa%+1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dh74 ,simile ( man ) feet 9 ba? tub1 vi4 #i4h 7#i-afc74 ,simile ( mirror1 i4 #d4aj 7#df-ajcd74 ,simile ( mob 9 assembly1 vi4 #d4ae 7#bb-caj74 ,simile ( net 9 ! sea = univ]se 9 s\l1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-dje74 ,simile ( op9ion & imag9ation illu/rates relation betwe5 matt] & reason1 iii4 #f4ae 7#bf-cgg74 ,simile ( ov]weight$ birds1 s5sual man1 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,simile ( peak1 =m$ by unit+ ( s\ls1 vi4 #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,simile ( pilot gov]n+ ! %ip1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,simile ( platonic vision !ory to expla9 simultaneity ( unity & duality1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,simile ( pre>rang$ dance z />'s motion1 iv4 #d4cc 7#bh-dib74 ,simile ( radii ar\nd c5tre1 iv4 #b4a 7#ba-bgg74 ,simile ( radii c5t]+1 to expla9 unify+ s5sations1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-bgg74 ,simile ( radii meet+ 9 c5tre1 i4 #g4a 7#ed-abji74 ,simile ( ray f c5tre to circumf]5ce1 iv4 #a 7#d-ajj74 ,simile ( sci5ce expla9s :ole & "p1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbb72 iv4 #i4e 7#h-ade74 ,simile ( seal on wax1 iv4 #i4d 7#h-add74 ,simile ( se$ to expla9 unity ( ess5ce 9 _m s\ls1 iv4 #i4e 7#h-ade74 ,simile ( spr+ ( wat]1 iii4 #h4a 7#cj-edg74 ,simile ( /rik+ cord ( a lyre1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbf74 ,simile ( sun & light1 vi4 #e4e 7#bc-cai74 ,simile ( ! sun's rays1 vi4 #e4e 7#bc-cai74 ,simile ( ! tree ( ! univ]se1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,simile ( v9e & bran*es1 v4 #c4g 7#dh-ajhh74 ,simile1 ,platonic1 ( driv]s ( horses1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,simple & n comp\nd is ! ,supreme1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-eii74 ,simple bodies1 _! exi/5ce dem&s t ( _w-s\l1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eg74 ,simple is ! s\l2 composite ! body1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,simple no?+ is1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ajd74 ,simple1 )\t some?+ simple no?+ manifold c\ld exi/1 ii4 #d4c 7#ab-aii74 ,simple's exi/5ce necess>y to t ( "o1 v4 #f4c 7#bd-ccf74 ,simplification1 approa* ( s\l to good1 i4 #f4f 7#a-ej74 ,simplification z pa? to unity1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aeb74 ,simplification ( ec/asy1 sup] beauty & sup] virtue1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,simplicity ( pr9ciple1 insures its fre$om ( action1 vi4 #h4d 7#ci-ggi74 ,simplicity ! intellig5t1 does n d5y composit5ess1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbb74 ,simplicity ! intelligible1 implies height ( s\rce1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbb74 ,simultaneity ( end & pr9ciple 9 ,supreme1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,simultaneity ( ev]y?+ 9 ! intelligible _w1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,simultaneity ( ! intelligible p]mits no memory1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,simultane\s giv+ & receiv+ by _w-s\l1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acb74 ,simultane\s ( "o & _m1 intellig5ce conta9s ! inf9ite z vi4 #g4ad 7#ch-gbe74 ,simultane\s unity & duality ( ?\ght1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,simultane\s )9 & )\t is vi4 #d4g 7#bb-bie74 ,s9 & ju/ice1 n de/roy$ by sup]ficiality ( mis=tunes1 iii4 #b4af 7#dg-ajfg74 ,si/] b5efic5t1 is _w-s\l to our s\l1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcc74 ,situation1 z ,ari/otelian category1 vi4 #a4bd 7#db-hgg74 ,slav]y ( good1 accuses ,provid5ce1 iii4 #b4f 7#dg-ajfb74 ,socrates1 i4 #h4g2 iii4 #b4ae2 iv4 #c4e2 ii4 #e4b2 vi4 #b4a2 vi4 #c4f1 #ae4 ,socrates 7z repres5tative man71 v4 #a4d 7#aj-agi72 v4 #g4a 7#ah-bea74 ,solid ?+s1 ne>e/ non5tity1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfa74 ,solution ( puzzle is t be+ is ev]y:]e pres5t1 vi4 #e4c 7#bc-cag74 ,some:at1 a p>ticle to modify1 any /atem5t ab\t ! supreme1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gig74 ,son1 begott5 by supreme1 report ( ec/asy1 see pun on koros1 iii4 #h4aa 7#cj-eej72 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-ega74 ,s\l1 aft] rea*+ yond] does n /ay2 reasons :y1 vi4 #i4aj 7#i-afh74 ,s\l alone possesses memory1 iv4 #c4bf 7#g-dcb74 ,s\l & body consequ5ces ( mixture1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaid74 ,s\l & body =m fusion1 iv4 #d4ah 7#bh-dfe74 ,s\l & body mixture impossible1 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaie74 ,s\l & body1 primitive relation betwe51 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,s\l & body1 relation betwe51 vi4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,s\l & intellig5ce1 besides ideas1 conta9$ 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #i4ac 7#e-aaf74 ,s\l & judgm5t1 passibility (1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,s\l & relation ) ,god & individual1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,s\l & s\l ess5ce1 di/9ction betwe51 i4 #a4b 7#ec-aaib74 ,s\l & we1 ! relation betwe51 i4 #a4ac 7#ec-abjf74 ,s\l z divisible & indivisible1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bgi74 ,s\l z hypo/atic actualization ( intellig5ce1 v4 #a4c 7#aj-agg74 ,s\l z numb]1 v4 #a4e 7#aj-ahj74 ,s\l becomes :at %e rememb]s1 iv4 #d4c 7#bh-dde74 ,s\l begets h] comb9ation1 its nature1 vi4 #g4e 7#ch-gjh74 ,s\l begets _m because incorporeal1 iv4 #g4d 7#h-add74 ,s\l be+ impassable1 ev]y?+ contr>y is figurative1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,s\l bo? divisible & indivisible1 iv4 #a 7#d-ajj74 ,s\l c p5etrate body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gb74 ,s\l _c be corporeal1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gj74 ,s\l _c be entirely dragg$ d[n1 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjc74 ,s\l _c lose p>ts1 ii4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,s\l _c possess evil )9 h]self1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeh74 ,s\l capable ( ext5sion1 vi4 #d4a 7#bb-bhf74 ,s\l cele/ial ( _w1 iii4 #e4c 7#ej-aabh74 ,s\l1 circul> movem5t (1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfb74 ,s\l1 comb9ation z mixture or resultant product1 i1 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,s\l con=ms de/9y to h] "*1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bch74 ,s\l conta9s body1 iv4 #h4bj 7#bg-dba74 ,s\l-diff]5ce betwe5 individual univ]sal1 iv4 #c4g 7#bg-cii74 ,s\l direct$ by natural law1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagc74 ,s\l divisible1 mix$ & d\ble1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,s\l does n entirely ent] into body1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,s\l does n ev5 rememb] h]self1 iv4 #d4b 7#bh-ddc74 ,s\l d\ble1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha72 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dch74 ,s\l desc5d$ into _w ve/ige (1 is ,daemon1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,s\l di/raction1 s5sation is n1 iv4 #d4be 7#bh-dgg72 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bda74 ,s\l divisible1 h[ %e divides at dea?1 iv4 #a 7#d-ajj74 ,s\l entire1 fa%ion$ :ole & individuals1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cbb74 ,s\l ess5ce d]ives f h] be+1 vi4 #b4f 7#dc-ijj74 ,s\l ex]ts a v>i$ action1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fb74 ,s\l feel+ impli$ by s5sation1 i4 #a4f 7#ec-aaih74 ,s\l feels passions )\t exp]i5c+ !m1 iv4 #d4ai 7#bh-dff74 ,s\l gives life to psy*ologic elem5ts1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,s\l1 good & intellig5ce relat$ to light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,s\l gov]ns body z pilot ! %ip1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,s\l1 greatness (1 no?+ to d ) size ( body1 vi4 #d4e 7#bb-bic74 ,s\l has d\ble aspect1 to body & to intellig5ce1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,s\l has no corporeal possibility1 h5ce incorporeal1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eg74 ,s\l has to exi/ 9 tw(old sph]e1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acj74 ,s\l has v>i\s motions1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fb74 ,s\l1 heal?y1 c "w1 iv4 #c4d 7#bg-cie74 ,s\l1 h]self1 body-us] & comb9ation ( bo?1 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,s\l1 h[ c %e rema9 impassible1 ?\gh giv5 up to emotion1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,s\l1 h[ %e comes to "k vice1 i4 #h4i 7#ea-aaee74 ,s\l human1 z indep5d5t pr9ciple1 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,s\l human1 :5 9 body1 has possibilities up or d[n1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,s\l1 if %e 7 corporeal body1 w\ld h no s5sation1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fd74 ,s\l1 immortal1 i4 #a4b 7#ec-aaib74 ,s\l1 impassibility (1 iii4 #f4a 7#bf-cej74 ,s\l imp]i%able1 iv4 #g4ab 7#b-hb74 ,s\l 9 body z =m is 9 matt]1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dba74 ,s\l 9 body z :ole 9 a "p1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dba74 ,s\l 9 ! body z light 9 ! air1 iv4 #c4bb 7#bg-dbc74 ,s\l1 individual1 born ( intellig5ce1 vi4 #b4bb 7#dc-ibi74 ,s\l intellig5ce1 good are l light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,s\l1 int]m$i>y elem5tal1 also inadmissible1 ii4 #i4e 7#cc-fjg74 ,s\l invisible1 cause ( ^! emotions1 i4 #f4e 7#a-df74 ,s\l is a def9ite ess5ce1 z p>ticul> be+1 vi4 #b4e 7#dc-ijj74 ,s\l is a numb]1 vi4 #e4i 7#bc-cbd72 v4 #a4e 7#aj-ahj74 ,s\l is a simple actualization1 ^: ess5ce is life1 iv4 #g4ab 7#b-hc74 ,s\l is a simple 7sub/ance7 ! man himself1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,s\l is a :ole ( di/9ct divisible & indivisible p>ts1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dai74 ,s\l is all ?+s1 iii4 #d4c 7#ae-bcf74 ,s\l is arti/ ( ! univ]se1 iv4 #g4ac 7#b-hd74 ,s\l is bo? be+ & life1 vi4 #b4f 7#dc-ija74 ,s\l is bo? puni%able & impassible1 i4 #a4ab 7#ec-abjd74 ,s\l is d\ble 7see ,h]cules71 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dch74 ,s\l is ev]y:]e entire1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,s\l is free by intellig5ce1 :i* is free by itself1 vi4 #h4g 7#ci-ghc74 ,s\l is =m$ gov]n+ ! body 7,ari/otle71 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaie74 ,s\l is =m$ insep>able f body 7,alex&] ( ,aphrodisia71 i4 #a4d 7#ec-aaie74 ,s\l is 9 body z pilot is 9 %ip1 iv4 #c4ba 7#bg-dbb72 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,s\l is individuality1 & is =m & workman ( body1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-eg74 ,s\l is inf9ite z compris+ _m s\ls1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bif74 ,s\l is locat$1 n 9 body1 b body 9 s\l1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbc74 ,s\l is matt] ( intellig5ce 7=m71 v4 #a4c 7#aj-agh74 ,s\l is nei!r h>mony nor entele*y1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gd74 ,s\l is p>tly m+l$ & sep>at$ f body1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaic74 ,s\l is prior to body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gd74 ,s\l is sub/antial f "o be+1 simple matt]1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fa74 ,s\l is ! pot5tiality ( produc+1 n ( becom+1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cdf74 ,s\l1 its be+1 iv4 #a 7#d-ajj74 ,s\l leav+ body1 leaves trace ( life1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhc74 ,s\l light =ms animal nature1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaih74 ,s\l1 l div9ity1 is always "o1 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djb74 ,s\l l face 9 sev]al mirrors1 i4 #a4h 7#ec-abjj74 ,s\l may be said to come & g1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbc74 ,s\l may h two faults1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,s\l mu/ be "o & manifold1 ev5 on ,/oic hypo!ses1 iv4 #b4b 7#ba-bha74 ,s\l mu/ be /ripp$ ( =m to %9e 9 prim>y nature1 vi4 #i4g 7#i-afa74 ,s\l mu/ fir/ be dissect$ f body to exam9e h]1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icd74 ,s\l mu/ fit h]self to h] "p 9 ! s*eme1 iii4 #b4a1 #g 7#dg-ajga74 ,s\l necess>y to unify manifold s5sations1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fe74 ,s\l ne$$ by body = life1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dah74 ,s\l n decomposable1 iv4 #g4a1 #d 7#b-hd74 ,s\l n evil by h]self b by deg5]ation1 i4 #h4d 7#ea74 ,s\l n 9 body z "p 9 a :ole1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dba74 ,s\l n 9 body z quality 9 a sub/rate1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbb74 ,s\l n 9 body1 b body 9 s\l1 iv4 #d4ae 7#bh-dfj74 ,s\l n 9 "t1 ?\gh h] actions & reactions are1 v4 #i4d 7#e-ajf74 ,s\l n ! limit ( "o asc5t1 :y8 v4 #i4d 7#e-ajf74 ,s\l obeys fate only :5 evil1 iii4 #a4aj 7#dg-ajfj74 ,s\l ( ! unity1 proves t ( ! ,supreme1 vi4 #e4i 7#bc-cbc74 ,s\l orig9ates movem5ts1 b is n alt]$1 iii4 #f4c 7#bf-cee74 ,s\l p[] ev]y:]e1 localiz$ 9 special organ1 iv4 #c4bc 7#bg-dbd74 ,s\l p[] reveal$ 9 simultaneity ( control ov] _w1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-agf74 ,s\l p[]s rema9 ! same ?r\gh\t all *anges ( body1 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djb74 ,s\l pri/9e1 preci\s1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-agf74 ,s\l1 psy*ological di/9ctions 91 i4 #a4a 7#ec-aaia74 ,s\l pure1 w\ld rema9 isolat$1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,s\l puzzle ( h] be+ "o1 yet 9 all1 iv4 #c4d 7#bg-cid74 ,s\l1 rational1 if sep>at$ :at w\ld %e rememb]8 iv4 #c4bg 7#bg-dcc74 ,s\l receives h] =m f intellig5ce1 iii4 #i4e 7#ae-bbd74 ,s\l relat$ to x might h be5 d>kness1 ii4 #i4ab 7#cc-fbe74 ,s\l rema9s incorporeal1 vi4 #g4ca 7#ch-gej74 ,s\l rises to ! good by scorn+ all ?+s bel[1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbb74 ,s\l said to be 9 body because body alone is visible1 vi4 #g4ce 7#ch-geg74 ,s\l scorns ev5 ?\ght1 %e is intellectualiz$ & ennobl$1 iv4 #c4d 7#bg-cie74 ,s\l1 sick1 devot$ to h] body1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,s\l1 spee* 9 ! intelligible _w1 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjc74 ,s\l split into ?ree1 intelligible1 int]m$i>y & s5se-_w4 ,s\l symbolizes d\ble ,h]cules1 i4 #a4ac 7#ec-abjf74 ,s\l1 ! two betwe5 !m1 p>tition ! fund ( memory1 iv4 #c4ca 7#bg-dci74 ,s\l1 ?ree pr9ciples1 reason1 imag9ation & s5sation1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aage74 ,s\l1 to :i* ( ours does individuality belong1 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjc74 ,s\l1 triune1 "o nature = ?ree p[]s1 iv4 #i4e 7#ea-aafc74 ,s\l unh>m$1 if h] flight f "h bel[ is prompt en\gh1 i4 #g4bf 7#a-ej74 ,s\l unity does n resemble reason unity1 z x includes plurality1 vi4 #b4f 7#dc-ija74 ,s\l1 univ]sal1 is ev]y:]e entire1 vi4 #d4i 7#bb-cjj74 ,s\l uses ! body z tool1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaic74 ,s\l unconsci\s ( h] high] "p1 if di/ract$ by s5se1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,s\l w n seem entirely )9 u1 if functions are n localiz$1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dai74 ,s\l's action divid$ by division ( "t1 iv4 #d4ae 7#bh-dfj74 ,s\l's activity is triple3 ?9k+1 self-pres]vation & creation1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abe74 ,s\l's affection comp>$ to lyre1 iii4 #f4d 7#bf-ceg74 ,s\ls all are "o 9 ! _w s\l1 b are diff]5t1 iv4 #i4a 7#h-aci74 ,s\ls all h _! demon :i* is _! love4 iii4 #e4d 7#ej-aabi74 ,s\ls are z immortal z ! "o f :om !y proce$1 vi4 #d4aj 7#bb-cja74 ,s\ls are plural unity ( sem9al reasons1 vi4 #b4e 7#dc-hii74 ,s\ls are unit$ by _! highe/1 vi4 #i4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,s\ls z amphibi\s1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abf74 ,s\l's asc5sion to eligible _w1 ii4 #i4b 7#ac-bbb74 ,s\l's bodies may be relat$ diff]5tly1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhe74 ,s\ls c reason intuitionally )\t ratioc9ation1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-dag74 ,s\ls _c lose p>ts1 iv4 #g4e 7#b-fc74 ,s\l's condition 9 high] regions1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdj74 ,s\l con=ms de/9y to h] "*1 iii4 #d4e 7#ae-bch74 ,s\l's con=mity to univ]sal1 proves !y are n p>ts ( h]1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-chi74 ,s\l's desc5t into body1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbb74 ,s\l's desire1 liv] seat (1 iv4 #d4bh 7#bh-dhj74 ,s\l's de/9y dep5ds on condition ( bir? ( univ]se1 ii4 #c4ad 7#eb-aaha74 ,s\ls develop manifoldness z intellig5ce does1 iv4 #c4e 7#bg-cif74 ,s\ls diff] z d ! s5sations1 vi4 #d4f 7#bb-bid74 ,s\ls1 diff]5ce betwe51 iv4 #c4h 7#bg-djj74 ,s\ls1 d all =m a s+le "o1 iv4 #i 7#h-aci74 ,s\l's dream is s5sation1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfc74 ,s\ls fir/ g 9 ,heav5 9 ! intelligible _w1 iv4 #c4ag 7#bg-dae74 ,s\ls =m a g5etic b n num]ic unity1 iv4 #i4a 7#h-adf74 ,s\ls t ent] into ?is _w g5]ate a love demon1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,s\l's highe/ "p always rema9s above body4 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,s\l's highe/ "p1 ev5 :ole1 sees vision ( intelligible wisdom1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,s\ls1 h[ !y come to desc5d1 iv4 #c4ac 7#bg-daj74 ,s\l's immortality1 iv4 #g 7#b-ef74 ,s\l's inc>nation is = p]fection ( univ]se1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,s\ls incorporeal dwell )9 intellig5ce1 iv4 #c4bd 7#bg-dbg74 ,s\ls1 individual1 are ! emanations ( ! univ]sal1 iv4 #c4a 7#bg-chh74 ,s\l's in/rum5t is ! body1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,s\l's l[] "p1 9 s5se _w1 fa%ions body1 v4 #a4aj 7#aj-aij74 ,s\ls may be unifi$ )\t be+ id5tical1 iv4 #i4b 7#h-adj74 ,s\l's m$iation betwe5 indivisible & divisible ess5ce1 iv4 #b 7#ba-bgi74 ,s\l's memory 9 intelligible _w1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,s\l's mixture ( reason & indet]m9ation1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacc74 ,s\l's multiplicity1 bas$ on _! unity1 iv4 #i4d 7#g-hdc74 ,s\l's nature is int]m$iate1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acj74 ,s\ls n isolat$ f intellig5ce dur+ desc5t1 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-dji74 ,s\ls ( />s & inc>nate humans gov]n worlds untr\bl$ly1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abc74 ,s\ls ( ! second univ]sal rank are m51 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,s\l's p[]s diff] & !nce d n act ev]y:]e1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adc74 ,s\l's prim>y & second>y evil1 iii4 #h4e 7#cj-ech74 ,s\ls progno/icate b d n cause ev5t1 ii4 #c4f 7#eb-aaga74 ,s\l's purification & sep>ation1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-cei74 ,s\l's relation to body is t ( /atue & metal1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-agf74 ,s\l's relation to intellig5ce is t ( matt] to =m1 v4 #a4c 7#aj-agh74 ,s\ls resemble v>i\s =ms ( gov]nm5ts1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfd74 ,s\ls reta9 unity & diff]5ces1 on diff]5t levels1 iv4 #c4e 7#bg-cif74 ,s\l's sep>ation f body enables h] to use ! body z tool1 i4 #a4c 7#ec-aaic74 ,s\ls %[ k9%ip to _w by fidelity to _! own nature1 iii4 #c4a 7#dh-ajgg74 ,s\l's sup]ior & inf]ior bodies relat$ 9 ?ree ways1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhe74 ,s\ls t *ange _! condition alone h memory1 iv4 #d4f 7#bh-ddh74 ,s\ls unit$1 intellig5ce %9$ d[n f ! peak =m$ by !m1 vi4 #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,s\ls unit$ to _w-s\ls by functions1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-cib74 ,s\ls weak5$ by individual contemplation1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abe74 ,s\l's welf>e is resemblance to div9ity1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,s\ls1 :y !y take diff]5t k9ds ( bodies1 iv4 #c4ab 7#bg-daj74 ,s\rce1 common1 by x all ?+s are unit$1 vi4 #g4ab 7#ch-gba74 ,s\rce1 height (1 impli$ by simplicity ( ! intelligible1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbb74 ,s[+ ( s\l 9 />s & matt]1 iv4 #h4de 7#f-abg74 ,space1 #e4a1 #aj4 ,space1 corporeal1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbj74 ,space has no?+ to d ) intelligible light1 :i* is non-spatial1 v4 #e4g 7#bi-ebf74 ,space1 result ( procession ( ! univ]sal s\l1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjf74 ,space said to measure movem5t because ( its det]m9ation1 iii4 #g4aa 7#de-ajaa74 ,species de/roy$ by fundam5tal unity1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hid74 ,spectacle ,div9e 9 ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,spectator ( vision becomes p>ticipator1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efi74 ,spee* is a quantity1 vi4 #c4ab 7#dd-ied74 ,spee* is a quantity1 classification (1 vi4 #c4ab 7#dd-ied74 ,spee* ( s\l 9 ! intelligible _w1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-dda74 ,sph]ical figure1 intelligible is ! primitive "o1 vi4 #f4ag 7#cd-fge74 ,sp9dle ( fate 7significance71 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagd72 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bdb74 ,_s & its apportionm5t1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,spirits inanimate1 i4 #d4g 7#b-ef74 ,spiritual becomes love1 begun physically1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-gee74 ,spiritual body1 ii4 #b4b 7#ad-bca74 ,spiritual gno/ic di/9ction ( m51 ii4 #i4ah 7#cc-fcg74 ,spiritual m51 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,spl5dor1 la/ view ( revelation1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,splitt+ ( intelligible pr9ciple1 ii4 #d4e 7#ab-bjb74 ,splitt+ ( unity typifi$ by mutilation ( ,saturn1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,splitt+ up ( s\l at dea?1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bda74 ,spontaneity n affect$ by irresponsible1 iii4 #b4aj 7#dg-ajfj74 ,/ability & ess5ce1 di/9ction betwe51 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijc74 ,/ability & movem5t exi/ because ?\ght by intellig5ce1 vi4 #b4h 7#dc-ijd74 ,/ability ano!r k9d ( movem5t1 vi4 #b4g 7#dc-ijc74 ,/ability1 di/9ction f1 vi4 #c4bg 7#dd-ihj74 ,/ability does n imply /illness 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #c4bg 7#dd-ihb74 ,/ability ( ess5ce only accid5tal1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aec74 ,/&>d human _c measure _w s\l1 ii4 #i4g 7#cc-fab74 ,/> action m+l$ only affects already natural process1 ii4 #c4ab 7#eb-aaff74 ,/>-s\l & _w-s\l intellectual diff]5ces1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfc74 ,/>s affect physical1 n ess5tial be+1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-ie74 ,/>s & _w-s\l are impassable1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-ejf74 ,/>s answ] pray]s unconsci\sly1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-eje74 ,/>s are inexhau/ible & ne$ no refre%m5t1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbg74 ,/>s are !y animate8 ,/>s are !y inanimate8 ,/>s1 z well z sun1 may be pray$ to1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,/>s1 body or w d n sway e>?ly ev5ts1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-die74 ,/>s by _! body produce only passions ( univ]se1 ii4 #c4aj 7#eb-aagg74 ,/>s conta9 n only fire b e>?1 ii4 #a4f 7#dj-hba74 ,/>s d n ne$ memories to answ] pray]s1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-eje74 ,/>s foll[ ! univ]sal k9d1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,/>s h no memory1 because uni=mly blissful1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-eje74 ,/>s influ5ce is f contemplation ( intelligible _w1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-dif74 ,/>s motion comp>$ to a pre>rang$ dance1 iv4 #d4cc 7#bh-dib74 ,/>s natural radiation ( good1 expla9s _! influ5ce1 iv4 #d4ce 7#bh-dig74 ,/>s pr$ict because ( s\l's accid5ts1 ii4 #c4aj 7#eb-aagg74 ,/>s s]ve z lett]s 9 :i* to read nature1 iii4 #a4f 7#c-ie74 ,/>s1 s\ls gov]n worlds untr\bl$ by1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abc74 ,/>s sway g5]al b n detail$ fate1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhg74 ,/>s1 :at is & :at is n produc$ by !m1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagh74 ,/atue1 art makes out ( r\gh m>ble1 v4 #h4a 7#ca-eea74 ,/atue1 composite ( =m & matt]1 v4 #i4c 7#e-ejd74 ,/atue1 ess5tial be+s z /atues1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,/atue1 heat+ ( /atue by metal only indirect1 vi4 #a4ba 7#db-hgd74 ,/atue1 ju/ice z self born intellectual /atue1 vi4 #f 7#cd-fec74 ,/atue1 metal is n pot5tiality ( /atue1 ii4 #e4a 7#be-cdb74 ,/atue1 purifi$ cleans )9 h]self div9e /atues1 v4 #g4aj 7#b-ha74 ,/atue1 %9+ 9 front rank is unity1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb74 ,/atue1 s\l is to body z metal is to /atue1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gf74 ,/atues at entrance ( temples left beh9d1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-agj74 ,/atues ( palace ( div9ity1 vi4 #g4ce 7#ch-geh74 ,/]ility ( nature indicat$ by ca/ration1 iii4 #f4ai 7#bf-che74 ,/ill1 :y ! heav5s d n rema91 ii4 #i4a 7#dj-had74 ,/illness1 n impli$ by /ability 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #c4bg 7#dd-ihj74 ,/oic explanation ( beauty1 symmetry1 oppos$1 i4 #f4a 7#a-da74 ,/oic f\r categories evaporate1 leav+ matt] z basis1 vi4 #a4bi 7#db-hhf74 ,/oic ,god is only modifi$ matt]1 vi4 #a4bg 7#de-hha74 ,/oic relation category confuses new ) ant]ior1 vi4 #a4ca 7#db-hhh74 ,/oics1 v4 #i4d 7#e-ajf74 ,/oics' fault is to h tak5 s5sation z _! guide1 vi4 #a4bh 7#db-hhd74 ,/ones gr[+ :ile 9 e>?1 iv4 #d4bg 7#bh-dgi72 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gah74 ,/raight l9e repres5ts s5sation1 :ile ! s\l is l a circle1 v4 #a4g 7#aj-ahd74 ,/raight movem5t1 vi4 #d4b 7#bb-bhh72 ii4 #b4ab 7#ad-bca74 ,/udi$ _w mu/ be j z "o w\ld analyze ! voice1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icc74 ,/udy ( "t makes u desc5d f ! intelligible1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iie74 ,sub-consci\s nature h9d]s dom9ance ( bett]-self1 iii4 #c4d 7#dh-ajha74 ,subdivision inf9ite ( bodies1 leads to de/ruction1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,subject1 "o's notion does n come f subject itself1 vi4 #f4ac 7#cd-ffc74 ,sublun> sph]e1 immortality does n ext5d to x1 ii4 #a4e 7#dj-hbj74 ,sublun>y div9ities1 crimes %\ld n be attribut$ to1 iv4 #d4ca 7#bh-dhi74 ,sub/ance z ,/oic category w\ld be split up1 vi4 #a4be 7#db-hgh74 ,sub/antial act or habitation is hypo/asis1 vi4 #a4f 7#db-hde74 ,sub/rate1 iii4 #c4f 7#dh-ajhg74 ,sub/rate & resid5ce ( =ms1 is matt]1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aig74 ,sub/rate dem&$ by process ( elem5ts1 ii4 #d4f 7#ab-bjc74 ,sub/rate ne$$ by composition ( ! body1 ii4 #d4aa 7#ab-bji74 ,sub/rate n common to all elem5ts1 be+ indet]m9ate1 ii4 #d4ac 7#ab-bac74 ,subsum$ "u be+ 9 ess5ce n ev]y?+ c1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hic74 ,successive enum]ation inevitable 9 describ+ ! et]nal1 iv4 #h4f 7#f-abi74 ,succumb to ! law ( ! univ]se1 :y _m s\ls d1 iv4 #c4ae 7#bg-dac74 ,su*ness1 ii4 #g4b 7#cg-gja74 7,:atness47 ,su*ness lat] ?an be+ & quiddity1 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh74 ,suff]+ & action _c be sep>ate categories1 vi4 #a4ag 7#db-hff74 ,suff]+ ( mo/ m5 physical1 virtu\s man suff]s lea/ because mo/ suff]+ is physical1 i4 #d4ac 7#df-ajcf74 ,suff]+ "p ( virtu\s man is ! high]1 i4 #d4ac 7#df-ajcf74 ,sugge/ive is influ5ce ( reason1 i4 #b4e 7#ai-bfd74 ,suicide1 i4 #i 7#af-bdc74 ,suicide breaks up ! appo9t$ "t ( life1 i4 #i 7#af-bdd74 ,suicide unavailable ev5 to avoid insanity1 i4 #i 7#af-bdd74 ,suitability & opportunity1 cause (1 puts !m beyond *ance1 vi4 #h4ah 7#ci-hjf74 ,sun & ray1 simile (1 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehg72 v4 #c4i 7#di-aaje74 ,sun z well z />s1 may be pray$ to1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,sunlight exi/s ev]y:]e1 vi4 #d4g 7#bb-bif74 ,sunrise only image = div9e approa*1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehh74 ,sup]abundance1 mann] 9 :i* all ?+s issue f "o1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aid74 ,sup]-beauty & sup]-virtue1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,sup]-beauty ( ! ,supreme1 v4 #h4h 7#ca-efd74 ,sup]-be+ a*iev$ 9 ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,sup]-ess5tial pr9ciple does n ?9k1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,sup]-ess5tiality & sup]-exi/5ce ( ,supreme1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aaai74 ,sup]-exi/5ce & sup]-ess5tiality ( ,supreme1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aaai72 v4 #d4b 7#g-acg74 ,sup]-exi/5ce ( fir/ pr9ciple1 vi4 #g4ch 7#ch-gfc74 ,sup]-=m is uni=m unity1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aeb74 ,sup]-goodness is ,supreme1 vi4 #i4f 7#i-afj74 ,sup]ior pr9ciple n always utiliz$1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjc74 ,sup]ior w\ld be ne$$ if ! good ?\ght1 vi4 #g4dj 7#ch-gfg74 ,sup]-lib]ty may be attribut$ to intellig5ce1 vi4 #h4f 7#ci-ghb74 ,sup]-ma/] ( himself is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4aj 7#ci-gij74 ,sup]-re/1 sup]-motion1 sup]-?\ght is ! "o sup]-consci\sness & sup]-life1 iii4 #i4g1 #i 7#ac-bbf74 ,sup]-virtue1 s\l meets absolute beauty1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,supra active1 ! good is1 z supra-cogitative1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cch74 ,supra cogitative1 ! good z1 is also supra-active1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cch74 ,supra-?9k+ pr9ciple does n ?9k1 necess>y to work+ ( intellig5ce1 v4 #f4b 7#bd-ccd74 ,supremacy is ! cause ( ! good1 vi4 #g4bc 7#ch-gci74 ,supremacy ( good implies its supremacy ov] all its possessions1 v4 #e4ac 7#cb-eie74 ,supreme admits ( no reason+1 demon/ration1 fai? or cause1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efc74 ,supreme1 all language ab\t x is metaphorical1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gie74 ,supreme z a spr+ ( wat]1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,supreme z be+ z be+ & ess5ce1 v4 #c4ag 7#di-aaai72 v4 #i4b 7#g-adi72 v4 #d4b 7#g-ach72 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehd72 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehe74 ,supreme1 assi/$ by intellig5ce w\ld h no room = *ance1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjd74 ,supreme bani%es all *ance1 vi4 #h4aj 7#ci-ghi74 ,supreme be+ n produc$ by *ance1 vi4 #h4aa 7#ci-gic74 ,supreme beyond *ance because ( suitability1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjf74 ,supreme c be approa*$ suffici5tly to be spok5 (1 v4 #c4ad 7#di-aaad74 ,supreme c be attribut$ cont+5ce only "u new def9ition1 vi4 #h4i 7#ci-ghg74 ,supreme c be attribut$ physical qualities only by analogy1 vi4 #h4h 7#ci-ghe74 ,supreme _c aspire high]1 be+ sup]-goodness1 vi4 #i4f 7#i-aei74 ,supreme comm&s himself1 vi4 #h4bj 7#ci-hji74 ,supreme consi/s ) himself1 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hjj74 ,supreme c\ld n be call$ *ance by any "o :o _h se5 him1 vi4 #h4ai 7#ci-hjg74 ,supreme1 e t]m %\ld be limit$ by "s :at or high]1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gig74 ,supreme =mlessness %[n by approa*+ s\l's rejection ( =m1 vi4 #g4cd 7#ch-gef74 ,supreme inevitable = intellig5ce t is intelligible1 iii4 #h4i 7#cj-edd74 ,supreme intellig5ce is k+ ( k+s1 v4 #ae4c 7#cb-ehj74 ,supreme intellig5ce1 nature (1 i4 #h4b4 7#ea-aadd74 ,supreme is bo? be+ & :yness1 ii4 #g4b 7#cg-gjg74 ,supreme is entirely "o1 does n expla9 orig9 ( manifold1 v4 #i4ad 7#e-aaf74 ,supreme is ess5tial beauty1 ! %apeless %ap] & ! transc5d5t1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,supreme is ev]y:]e & n[h]e1 is incl9ation & imm95ce1 vi4 #h4af 7#ci-hja74 ,supreme is ineffable1 v4 #c4ac 7#di-aaac74 ,supreme is limitless1 v4 #g4cb 7#ch-gec74 ,supreme is pot5tiality ( all ?+s1 above all actualization1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edf74 ,supreme is sup]-be+1 because n dep5d5t on x1 vi4 #h4ai 7#ci-hjg74 ,supreme is ! good1 because ( its supremacy1 vi4 #g4bc 7#ch-gci74 ,supreme is ! p[]1 really ma/] ( himself1 vi4 #h4i 7#ci-ghh72 vi4 #h4aj 7#ci-gij74 ,supreme is w be+ & actualization1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gie74 ,supreme mu/ be free1 z *ance is escap$ by int]ior isolation1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gie72 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hjj74 ,supreme mu/ be simple & n comp\nd1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-eii74 ,supreme nam$ ,apollo1 v4 #e4f 7#cb-ehd74 ,supreme n intellig5ce t aspires to =m ( good1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edh74 ,supreme ( ?ree ranks ( exi/5ce is ! beautiful1 vi4 #g4db 7#ch-ggj74 ,supreme "o only figuratively1 vi4 #i4e 7#i-aeg74 ,supreme pr9ciples mu/ !n be unity1 intellig5ce & s\l1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fjj74 ,supreme1 prov5 by ! unity ( ! s\l1 vi4 #e4i 7#bc-cbc74 ,supreme sup]-ma/] ( himself1 vi4 #h4ab 7#ci-gic74 ,supreme unity adju/s all l[] gr\p unities1 vi4 #f4aa 7#cd-ffj74 ,supreme w\ld wi% to be :at he is1 is su* z he w\ld wi% to be1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gif72 vi4 #h4ae 7#ci-hjj74 ,sw9e1 simile ( ! impure1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,sympa?y betwe5 individual & univ]sal s\l due to common orig91 iv4 #c4h 7#dh-ajhh72 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-ega74 ,syllables a quantity1 vi4 #c4ab 7#dd-ied74 ,symmetry1 e>?ly1 contemplates univ]sal symmetry1 v4 #i4aa 7#e-aad74 ,symmetry1 ,/oic def9ition ( beauty1 oppos$1 i4 #f4a 7#a-da74 ,sympa!tic h>mony1 e>? feels & directs by x1 iv4 #d4bf 7#bh-dgg74 ,sympa?y1 cosmic1 ii4 #a4g 7#dj-hbd74 ,sympa?y1 does n =ce id5tity ( s5sation1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-adb74 ,sympa?y implies unity ( all be+s 9 l[] magic en*antm5t1 iv4 #i4c 7#h-aeb74 ,sympa?y1 love work+ z1 effects magic1 iv4 #d4dj 7#bh-ejc74 ,sympa?y ( s\l & body1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,sympa?y ( s\l's highe/ self1 basis ( memory1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hcb74 ,sympa?y or community ( affection1 ,/oic1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-ei74 ,sy/em1 co-exi/5ce ( unity & multiplicity1 dem&s organization 91 vi4 #g4aj 7#ch-gaf74 ,tam+ ( body1 i4 #d4ad 7#df-ajcg74 ,!ology reveal$ by a/rology1 ii4 #c4g 7#eb-aagb74 ,telescop+1 ( intelligible entities1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,temp]am5t ( corporeal pr9ciples1 is heal?1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-ga74 ,temp]am5t1 s\l z mixture1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eh74 ,temp]ance1 gate ( ec/asy1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,temp]ance int]pret$ z purification1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,temp]ance is n real category1 vi4 #b4ah 7#dc-ibc74 ,temp]ate man is good's indep5d5ce f pleasure1 vi4 #g4bi 7#ch-gdg74 ,temples ( div9ity1 expla9$ by psy*ology1 iv4 #c4a 7#bg-chg74 ,temporal conceptions impli$ by priority ( ord]1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfa74 ,t5d+ t[>ds ! good1 all ?+s t5d t[>ds ! "o1 vi4 #b4ab 7#dc-iad74 ,t5sion1 ,/oic1 iv4 #g4ac 7#b-hc72 iv4 #e4d 7#bi-ebb74 ,t]re/rial ?+s d n la/ s long z cele/ial ones1 ii4 #a4e 7#dj-hai74 ,te/imony1 to its creator by _w1 iii4 #b4c 7#dg-ajdg74 ,! liv+ animal1 i4 #a4e 7#ec-aabf74 ,!odore1 f ,p#a;ato's ,!atetus1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aaej74 ,!odore ( ,as9e1 8 infra cele/ial vault 7invisible place71 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg72 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aih74 ,!ory ( happ9ess consi/+ 9 reasonable life1 i4 #d4b 7#df-ajbb74 ,?+ 9 itself1 diff]s f non5tity1 ii4 #d4aj 7#ab-bjg74 ,?+ 9 itself1 qualityless1 f\nd by ab/raction1 ii4 #d4aj 7#ab-bjg74 ,?+s good is _! =m1 vi4 #g4bg 7#ch-gdd74 ,?9k1 body _c1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,?9k+ 9 con=mity ) intellig5ce1 two ways1 v4 #c4d 7#di-ajid74 ,?9k+ is p]ception )\t help ( ! body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,?9k+ ourselves1 is ?9k+ an intellectual nature1 iii4 #i4f 7#ac-bbd74 ,?9k+ pr9ciple1 ! fir/1 is ! g5]al second1 v4 #f4b 7#bd-cce74 ,?9k+ pr9ciples--:i* is ! fir/1 & :i* is ! second8 v4 #f4a 7#bd-cce74 ,?ird pr9ciple is s\l1 iii4 #i4a 7#ac-bba74 ,?ird rank ( exi/5ce %\ld n be occupi$ by modality1 vi4 #a4cj 7#db-hhg74 ,?\ght & life1 diff]5t grades (1 iii4 #h4g 7#cj-edj74 ,?\ght actualization ( light1 v4 #a4e 7#aj-aha74 ,?\ght z fir/ actualization ( a hypo/asis is n 9 fir/ pr9ciple1 vi #g4dj 7#ch-gff74 ,?\ght z t\* ( ! good leads to ec/asy1 vi4 #g4cf 7#ch-gfj74 ,?\ght bel[ "o & ,supreme1 iii4 #i4g1 #i 7#ac-bbf74 ,?\ght b5ea? ! sup] ess5tial pr9ciple1 v4 #f 7#bd-cci74 ,?\ght di/ract$ f by s5sation1 iv4 #h4h 7#f-acb74 ,?\ght implies simultane\s unity & duality1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,?\ght 9 fir/ pr9ciple w\ld imply attributes1 & t manifoldness1 v4 #f4b 7#bd-ccf74 ,?\ght is actualiz$ intellig5ce1 v4 #c4e 7#di-ajig74 ,?\ght is b5ea? ! fir/ s intellig5ce implies ! latt]1 v4 #f4e 7#bd-cch72 v4 #f4b1 #f 7#bd-cci74 ,?\ght is inspiration = good1 v4 #f4e 7#bd-cch74 ,?\ght is integral "p ( intellig5ce1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egi74 ,?\ght is see+ ! intelligible1 v4 #d4b 7#g-ach74 ,?\ght is ! =m2 %ape ! actualization ( be+1 v4 #i4h 7#e-aaa74 ,?\ght1 life & exi/5ce1 conta9$ 9 prim>y exi/5ce1 v4 #f4f 7#bd-cci74 ,?\ght made impossible only by ! fir/ pr9ciple be+ "o exclusively1 v4 #f4c 7#bd-cce74 ,?\ght1 "o ) sight1 v4 #a4e 7#aj-aha74 ,?\ght1 self direction (1 is n *angeabl5ess1 iv4 #d4b 7#bh-ddd74 ,?\ght1 ! means by :i* intellig5ce passes f unity to duality1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,?\ghts1 conceptive1 dem& int]m$i>y s5sation1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgb74 ,?\ghts1 contr>y to rights1 possess real exi/5ce1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacf74 ,?\ghts1 highe/1 h incorporeal objects1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fh74 ,?ree k9ds ( m51 v4 #i4a 7#e-ajb74 ,?ree m5 9 ea* ( u1 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh74 ,?ree pr9ciples1 v4 #f4b 7#bd-ccd to #ccg72 v4 #a4aj 7#aj-ahi74 ,?ree ranks ( exi/5ce1 vi4 #d4aa 7#bb-cjb72 v4 #a4aj 7#aj-ahi72 v4 #f4b 7#bd-cce72 iii4 #c4c 7#dh-ajgg72 iii4 #e4i 7#ej-aach72 vi4 #a4cj 7#dc-hhg72 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh74 ,?ree sph]es1 v4 #a4h 7#aj-ahf74 ,?reefold activity ( s\l1 ?\ght1 self-pres]vation & creation1 iv4 #h4c 7#f-abe74 ,"t & et]nity1 iii4 #g 7#de-ihe74 ,"t arose z measurem5t ( ! activity ( ! univ]sal s\l1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,"t z motion1 errors 91 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihg74 ,"t becomes1 iii4 #g1 int4 7#de-ihe74 ,"t c be increas$1 :y n happ9ess1 i4 #e4g 7#cf-fhg74 ,"t _c be divid$ )\t imply+ s\l's action1 iv4 #d4ae 7#bh-dfj74 ,"t1 consid]$ z motion1 z moveable or z some?+ ( motion1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iif74 ,"t1 if x is a quantity1 :y a sep>ate category8 vi4 #a4ac 7#db-hfa74 ,"t includ$ action & reaction ( s\l1 n s\l itself1 iv4 #d4ae 7#bh-dfj74 ,"t is also )9 u1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajad74 ,"t is z int]ior to ! s\l z et]nity is to exi/5ce1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjh74 ,"t is measur$ by movem5t & is measure ( movem5t1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajaa74 ,"t is no int]val ( movem5t 7,/oic ,z5o71 iii4 #g4g 7#de-iii74 ,"t is n a numb]$ numb] 7,ari/otle71 iii4 #g4h 7#de-ajjj74 ,"t is n a quantity1 vi4 #a4e 7#db-hdd74 ,"t is n an accid5t or consequ5ce ( movem5t1 iii4 #g4i 7#de-ajjd74 ,"t is n begott5 by movem5t b only indicat$ !reby1 iii4 #g4aa 7#de-ajji74 ,"t is n motion & re/ 7,/rato71 iii4 #g4g 7#de-ajjj74 ,"t is n movem5t1 iii4 #g4g 7#de-iig74 ,"t is n ! numb] & measure ( movem5t 7,ari/otle71 iii4 #g4h 7#de-ajjj74 ,"t is pres5t ev]y:]e1 z aga9/ ,antiphanes & ,critolaus1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajac74 ,"t is ! l5g? ( ! life ( ! univ]sal s\l1 iii4 #g4aa 7#de-ajjh74 ,"t is ! life ( ! s\l1 consid]$ 9 ! movem5t by :i* %e passes f "o actualization to ano!r1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,"t is ! model ( its image et]nity1 iii4 #g int4 7#de-ihe74 ,"t is ! univ]se1 iii4 #g4a 7#de-ihf74 ,"t is to ! _w-s\l1 :at et]nity is to intellig5ce1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjg74 ,"t jo9$ to actions to make !m p]fect1 vi4 #a4ai 7#db-hfh74 ,"t mu/ be /udi$ comp>atively among ! philosoph]s1 iii4 #g4f 7#de-iif74 ,"t none1 only a s+le day = _w-s\ls1 iv4 #d4g 7#bh-dej74 ,"t or place d n figure among ! categories1 vi4 #b4af 7#dc-iai74 ,"t1 ,plato unc]ta9 ab\t x1 iii4 #g4ab 7#de-ajab74 ,"t replac$ by et]nity 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #i4aj 7#e-aac74 ,"t's nature w be reveal$ by its bir?1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,tol]ation by s\l1 )\t guilt1 iii4 #a4h 7#c-ig74 ,tomb ( s\l is body1 iv4 #h4a1 #d 7#f-abf74 ,tool1 body uses ! s\l z1 i4 #a4b 7#ee-aaid72 iv4 #g4a 7#b-eg74 ,tools are int]m$iate1 l s5se %ape1 iv4 #d4bc 7#bh-dgc74 ,torm5ts ( hell are re=matory1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-ddh74 ,total reason ( univ]se1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,t\*1 ! good is a simple p]ception ( itself1 vi4 #g4ci 7#ch-gfd74 ,t\*$ ) ! good is ! greate/ ( sci5ces1 vi4 #g4cf 7#ch-gfj74 ,trace ( life1 left by s\l :5 leav+ body1 iv4 #d4bi 7#bh-dhc74 ,trace ( ! ,"o1 is ! be+ ( s\ls1 v4 v4 #e 7#cb-ehc74 ,traditions ( div9ity conta9$ by ! _w1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-faf74 ,tra9+ & education1 memory ne$s1 iv4 #f4c 7#da-hce74 ,tra9+ "h bel[ help s\ls to rememb] :5 beyond1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddh74 ,tra9+ ( int]ior vision1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,trance ( ec/asy1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-afi74 ,transc5d5ce ( good ov] intellig5ce & life1 v4 #c4af 7#di-aaag74 ,transc5d5t1 v4 #c 7#di-ajij74 ,transc5d5t %apeless %ap] & ess5tial beauty is supreme1 vi4 #g4cc 7#ch-ged74 ,transc5d+ unity dem&$ by contemplation ( intellig5ce1 v4 #c4aj 7#di-aajf74 ,transition ( s5se-beauty to intellectual1 i4 #f4c 7#a-de74 ,transmigration1 animals into animals1 plants1 birds1 eagles & so>+ birds & bee1 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bce74 ,transmigration1 two k9ds1 into human or animal bodies1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-djc74 ,transmission1 reception1 relation und]lies action & exp]i5ce1 vi4 #a4bb 7#db-hgd74 ,transp>5cy ( ev]y?+ 9 intelligible _w1 v4 #h4d 7#ca-eeh74 ,trap on way to ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-efi74 ,trav]se heav51 )\t leav+ re/ 7cele/ial div9ities71 v4 #h4c 7#ca-eef74 ,tree ( ! univ]se1 simile (1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,triad is limit ( diff]5tiation1 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjb74 ,triangles equal to two1 iii4 #e4g 7#ej-aacf74 ,triangles1 mat]ial & immat]ial1 expla9 tr9e relations1 vi4 #e4aa 7#bc-ccj74 ,tr9ity1 comp>$ to light1 sun & moon1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd72 vi4 #g4f 7#ch-gjh72 vi4 #g4g 7#ch-gaa72 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abe72 vi4 #g4db 7#ch-ggj72 vi4 #b4h 7#dc-ije72 iv4 #g4ac 7#b-hd72 iii4 #d4b 7#ae-bcd74 ,triune1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,triune1 s\l1 "o nature 9 ?ree p[]s1 ii4 #c4d 7#eb72 v4 #a 7#aj-agc72 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjb74 ,triune play implies also id5tity & diff]5ce1 vi4 #b4h 7#dc-ije74 ,true good1 implies c\nt]feit1 vi4 #g4bf 7#ch-gdc74 ,tru? ext]nal to intellig5ce1 a !ory t de/roys intellig5ce1 v4 #e4a 7#cb-egf74 ,tru?1 field (1 intellig5ce evolves1 vi4 #g4ac 7#ch-gbc74 ,tru? self-probative2 no?+ tru]1 v4 #e4b 7#cb-egi74 ,two-fold s\l ex]ts two-fold provid5ce1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abb74 ,two-fold sph]e 9 :i* s\l has to exi/1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-acj74 ,two1 n addition to "o1 b a *ange1 vi4 #f4ad 7#cd-fff74 ,ugl9ess1 av]sion =1 expla9s love = beauty1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dg74 ,ugl9ess consi/s ( =mlessness1 i4 #f4b 7#a-dc74 ,ugl9ess is a =eign accretion1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dh74 ,ugl9ess is =m's failure to dom9ate matt]1 i4 #h4i 7#ea-aaef74 ,ugl9ess is pr$om9ance ( matt]1 v4 #g4b 7#ah-bec74 ,ugl9ess ( m5 due to l[]+ !mselves to l[] natures1 & ignor+ !mselves1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egd74 ,ulysses1 i4 #f4h 7#a-eb74 ,unalloy$ is no evil = ! liv+ p1 i4 #g4c 7#ed-abaj74 ,unatta*$1 condition o wise man1 i4 #d4a1 #g 7#df-ajbi74 ,unavoidable & univ]sal evils are1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aadi74 ,unc]ta9ty 9 location ( good & beauty1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,un*angeabl5ess ( =m & matt]1 iii4 #f4aj 7#bf-cfh74 ,unconsci\sly d />s answ] pray]s1 iv4 #d4d 7#bh-eje72 iv4 #d4b 7#bh-eje74 ,unconsci\sness does n h9d] virtue1 h&som5ess or heal?1 i4 #d4i 7#df-ajcc74 ,unconsci\sness ( oneself 9 ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,unconsci\sness ( s\l intellig5ce & "o does n detract f _! exi/5ce1 v4 #a4ab 7#aj-aia74 ,undef9ability ( unity 7ref]r$ to by feel+s71 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aea74 ,und]/& & fit y\rself to ! _w in/ead ( compla9+ ( x1 ii4 #i4ac 7#cc-fbe74 ,undi/urb$ is ! _w-s\l by ! ?+s ( s5se1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,unhapp9ess increas$ by duration1 :y n happ9ess8 i4 #e4f 7#cf-fhf74 ,unh>m$ is ! s\l by inc>nation1 if prompt 9 flight1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abh74 ,unification does n reveal true k1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-fag74 ,unification process1 v4 #a4e 7#aj-ahj72 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,unification ) div9ity result ( ec/asy1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,uni=m action1 ex]t$ by body1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fb74 ,uni=m 9 itself is unity & sup]-=m1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aeb74 ,un9c>nate s\ls gov]n _w untr\bl$ly1 iv4 #h4b 7#f-abc74 ,unique 7,monad71 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha72 v4 #e4ac 7#cb-eie74 ,unissu$ bro!rs ( ,jupit]1 vi4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,unit>y are intelligibles1 b n absolute unity1 vi4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,unit>y is consci\sness1 ?\gh conta9+ ?9k]1 ii4 #i4a 7#cc-fja74 ,unit>y numb]1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fef74 ,unit$ are all ?+s by a common s\rce1 vi4 #g4ab 7#ch-gba74 ,unit$ are s\ls1 by _! highe/1 vi4 #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,unit$ s\ls1 intellig5ce %9es d[n f ! peak =m$ by !m1 vi4 #g4ae 7#ch-gbf74 ,unities1 diff]5t k9ds (1 v4 #e4d 7#cb-ehb74 ,unit+ ( highe/ p>ts ( m5 9 intelligible1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbg74 ,unit+ ( intellig5ce1 z x rises to ! intelligible1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,unit+ s\l & body =ms individual aggregate1 i4 #a4f 7#ec-aaig74 ,unity1 v4 #a4f 7#aj-ahb72 v4 #e4d 7#cb-eha74 ,unity above all2 intellig5ce & ess5ce4 vi4 #i4b 7#i-adi74 ,unity absolute1 is fir/1 :ile intellig5ce is n1 vi4 #i4b 7#i-aej74 ,unity1 ab/ruse1 because s\l has repugnances to su* rese>*es1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aea74 ,unity an accid5t among/ s5se ?+s1 some?+ m 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #f4ad 7#cd-fff74 ,unity & ess5ce1 g5u9e relations betwe51 vi4 #b4aa 7#dc-iaa74 ,unity & numb] prec$e ! "o & _m be+s1 vi4 #f4aj 7#cd-fei74 ,unity z indivisible & inf9ite1 vi4 #i4f 7#i-aeh74 ,unity is ! self-uni=m & =mless sup] =m1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aeb74 ,unity1 by x all ?+s dep5d on ! good1 i4 #g4b 7#ed-abji74 ,unity1 by ?9k+ intellig5ce passes to duality1 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccc74 ,unity1 co-exi/5ce (1 dem&s organization 9 sy/em1 vi4 #g4aj 7#ch-gaf74 ,unity1 conta9$ 9 s5se objects1 is n unity itself1 vi4 #f4af 7#cd-fga74 ,unity1 contemplation 9 nature1 iii4 #h 7#cj-eca74 ,unity does n ev5 ne$ itself1 vi4 #i4f 7#i-aei74 ,unity1 ev]y?+ t5ds t[>d x z x t5ds t[>d ! good1 vi4 #b4ab 7#dc-iad74 ,unity1 fundam5tal ( g5]a1 w\ld de/roy species1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hid74 ,unity1 great] 9 intelligible ?an 9 physical _w1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbg74 ,unity1 if pass$ into ! manifold1 w\ld de/roy univ]se1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,unity1 imp>t$ by s\l is n pure1 vi4 #i4a 7#i-adg74 ,unity1 incompreh5sible1 vi4 #i4d 7#i-aed74 ,unity 9 manifoldness1 vi4 #e4f 7#bc-cbj74 ,unity into plurality split by numb]s1 vi4 #f4i 7#cd-fef74 ,unity is 9 ! manifold by a mann] ( exi/5ce1 vi4 #d4h 7#bb-bif74 ,unity is intelligible1 ?\gh p>ticipat$ 9 by s5se-objects1 vi4 #f4ac 7#cd-ffd74 ,unity is n intellig5ce1 its manifold produc$ by a unity1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddc74 ,unity1 lack (1 causes corporeity to be non5tity1 iii4 #f4f 7#bf-cfb74 ,unity1 multiple1 radiation (1 v4 #c4ae 7#di-aaae74 ,unity mu/ be s\ght = 9 ess5ce1 vi4 #e4a 7#bc-cdb74 ,unity mu/ exi/ 9 ! intelligible be=e be+ appli$ to mutable be+s1 vi4 #f4aa 7#cd-fei74 ,unity necess>y to exi/5ce ( all be+s1 especially collective n\ns1 vi4 #i4a 7#i-adg74 ,unity n category1 are argum5ts aga9/1 vi4 #b4aj 7#dc-iaj74 ,unity n m]e numb]+1 b exi/5ce1 vi4 #i4b 7#i-adi74 ,unity n synonym\s ) ess5ce1 vi4 #b4i 7#dc-ijh74 ,unity ( app]ception1 iv4 #d4a 7#bh-ddb74 ,unity ( be+ does n exclude unity ( o!r be+s1 vi4 #d4d 7#bb-bij74 ,unity ( reason con/itut$ by conta9$ contr>ies1 iii4 #b4af 7#dg-ajfi74 ,unity ( s\l1 does n resemble reason unity because x includes plurality1 vi4 #b4f 7#dc-ija74 ,unity ( s\l n effect$ by plurality ( p[]s1 iv4 #i4d 7#h-adc74 ,unity ( s\l reta9$ on diff]5t levels1 iv4 #c4e 7#bg-cif74 ,unity ( s\ls bas$ on _! multiplicity1 iv4 #i4d 7#h-adc74 ,unity ( ,supreme entail$ by its be+ a pr9ciple1 v4 #d4a 7#g-acd74 ,unity ( ,supreme only figurative1 vi4 #i4e 7#i-aeg74 ,unity ( ! s\l proves t ( ! ,supreme1 vi4 #e4i 7#bc-cbc74 ,unity ( w1 be+ an actualization1 is ! ,supreme1 vi4 #h4ac 7#ci-gie74 ,unity only = its exam9ation are its p>ts ap>t1 vi4 #b4c 7#dc-hig74 ,unity pass+ into manifold w\ld de/roy univ]se1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,unity reigns /ill m 9 ! good1 vi4 #b4aa 7#dc-iab74 ,unity self-suffici5t1 ne$+ no e/abli%m5t1 vi1 #i4f 7#i-aei74 ,unity indef9able1 ref]r$ to by feel+1 vi4 #i4c 7#i-aed74 ,unity1 :y _w proce$$ f x1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,unity's =m is pr9ciple ( numb]s1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehc74 ,univ]sal & unavoidable evils are1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aadi74 ,univ]sal be+1 description (1 vi4 #d4b 7#bb-bhf74 ,univ]sal be+ is indivisible1 vi4 #d4c 7#bb-bhh74 ,univ]sal be+1 />s foll[]s (1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagi74 ,univ]sal1 second rank1 s\ls ( m51 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aahj74 ,univ]sal s\l1 fir/ actualization ( ess5ce & intellig5ce1 v4 #b4b 7#aa-aid74 ,univ]sal s\l is ev]y:]e entire1 vi4 #d4i 7#bb-cjj74 ,univ]sal s\l may n be judg$ by human /&>ds1 ii4 #i4g 7#cc-faa74 ,univ]sal s\l's motion1 immortaliz$ heav51 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hag74 ,univ]sality ( creator ov]came all ob/acles1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efb74 ,univ]se1 ii4 #a 7#dj-hac74 ,univ]se & deity if include sep>able s\l1 ii4 #c4i 7#eb-aagf74 ,univ]se animat$ by _w-s\l1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-djd74 ,univ]se z a s+le h>mony1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aagj74 ,univ]se1 bir? (1 de/9y ( s\ls dep5d on1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,univ]se dep5ds on s+le pr9ciple1 ii4 #c4g 7#eb-aaag74 ,univ]se1 diagram (1 iv4 #d4af 7#bh-dfb74 ,univ]se1 hi]>*ical con/itution1 vi4 #b4b 7#dc-hib74 ,univ]se is h>mony 9 spite ( ! faults 9 ! details1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahe74 ,univ]se l light1 sun & moon1 v4 #f4d 7#bd-ccg74 ,univ]se moves 9 circle1 & /&s /ill simultane\sly1 ii4 #b4c 7#ad-bcj74 ,univ]se1 no?+ 9 x inanimate1 iv4 #d4cf 7#bh-dii74 ,univ]se passions produc$ by body ( />s1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagh74 ,univ]se1 p]fection (1 evils are necess>y1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahg74 ,univ]se picture1 t pictures itself1 ii4 #c4ah 7#eb-aahh74 ,univ]se1 plan (1 is f et]nity1 ,provid5ce1 vi4 #h4ag 7#ci-hjc74 ,univ]se specializ$1 organ (1 e be+ is1 iv4 #d4de 7#bh-eaj74 ,univ]se w\ld be de/roy$ if unity pass$ into ! manifold1 iii4 #h4aj 7#cj-edg74 ,univ]se's influ5ce %\ld be p>tial only1 iv4 #d4cd 7#bh-did74 ,univ]se's total reason1 ii4 #c4ac 7#eb-aagh74 ,unju/ acts una/rological !ory blame div9e reason1 iii4 #b4aj 7#dg-ajei74 ,unmeasur$1 is intelligible numb] inf9ite1 vi4 #f4ah 7#cd-fgf74 ,unnotic$ are _m new ?+s1 iv4 #d4h 7#bh-dej74 ,unreflective id5tification n z high z memory1 iv4 #d4d 7#bh-dde74 ,unse5 is beauty 9 supreme fusion1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,uranus1 see ,kronos1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabg74 ,uranus 7,coleus71 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,utility n ! only decid+ factor ) ! s5ses1 iv4 #d4bd 7#bh-dge74 ,utiliz$1 sup]ior pr9ciple n always1 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjc74 ,v>i$ action1 ex]t$ by s\l1 iv4 #g4d 7#b-fb74 ,v>iety may dep5d on lat5cy ( "p ( sem9al reason1 v4 #g4a 7#ah-bec74 ,v>iety ( _w-s\l's life makes v>iety ( "t1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,vase = =m1 see resid5ce1 see j>1 iv4 #c4bj 7#bg-dbj74 ,vase is ! body1 iv4 #c4g 7#bg-cii74 ,vase ( creation ( ,timaeus1 iv4 #c4g 7#bg-cii74 ,vault1 ,!odore ( ,as9e's infra cele/ial1 ii4 #d4a 7#ab-aih72 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,vegetables n irrational & root$ 9 ! intelligible1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gag74 ,v5us1 iv4 #c4ad 7#bg-dab72 iii4 #e4ah 7#ej-aacf72 ii4 #c4e1 #f 7#eb-aagj74 ,v5us z subord9ate nature ( _w-s\l1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 ,v5us beauty1 :5ce x came1 v4 #h4b 7#ca-eec74 ,v5us is _w-s\l1 iii4 #e4e 7#ej-aaca74 ,v5us1 ,jupit] & ,m]cury also consid]$ a/rologically1 ii4 #c4e 7#eb-aagj74 ,v5us1 "m ( ,eros1 iii4 #e4b 7#ej-aabe74 ,v5us1 or ! s\l is ! individual ( ,jupit]1 iii4 #e4h 7#ej-aacg74 ,v5us ,urania1 vi4 #i4i 7#i-afg74 ,ve/a1 pun on1 repres5ts intellig5ce1 v4 #e4e 7#cb-ehc74 ,ve/a repres5ts e>?1 iv4 #d4bg 7#bh-dhj74 ,ve/ige ( s\l desc5d$ into _w is demon1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,vice z di%>mony1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ceb74 ,vice caus$ by ext]nal circum/ances1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaed72 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagd72 iii4 #a 7#c-hf72 vi4 #h 7#ci-ggc74 ,vice1 h[ s\l comes to "k x1 i4 #h4i 7#ea-aaee74 ,vice is deprivation 9 s\l1 i4 #h4aa 7#ea-aaeg74 ,vice n absolute b d]iv$ evil1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaee74 ,vices1 intemp]ance & c[>dl9ess comes f matt]1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,victory ov] self is ma/]y ( fate1 ii4 #c4ae 7#eb-aahb74 ,v9dication1 ,god's ju/ice by philosophy1 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhg74 ,v9e & bran*es1 simile (1 iii4 #c4g 7#dh-ajhh74 ,viol5ce1 pro( (1 unnaturalness1 z ( sickness1 v4 #h4aa 7#ca-egj74 ,virtue affects ! s\l diff]5tly f o!r passions1 iii4 #f4c 7#bf-cef74 ,virtue an intellectualiz+ habit t lib]ates ! s\l1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-ghj74 ,virtue z a h>mony1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ceb74 ,virtue z h>mony expla9s evil 9 s\l1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ceb74 ,virtue belongs to s\l1 n to intellig5ce ( sup]-intellig5ce1 i4 #b4b 7#ai-bei74 ,virtue c conqu] any mis=tune1 i4 #d4h 7#df-ajca74 ,virtue *anges life f evil to good1 i4 #g4c 7#ed-abaj74 ,virtue consid]$ a good1 because p>ticipation 9 good1 i4 #h4ab 7#ea-aaeh74 ,virtue consi/s n 9 conv]sion b 9 its result1 i4 #b4d 7#ai-bfa74 ,virtue consi/s ( do+ good :5 n "u trials1 iii4 #a4aj 7#c-ih74 ,virtue d]iv$ f primitive nature ( s\l1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagd74 ,virtue does n figure among true categories1 vi4 #b4ag 7#dc-ibj74 ,virtue indep5d5t ( action1 vi4 #h4e 7#ci-ggi74 ,virtue is good1 n absolute1 b p>ticipat+1 i4 #h4h 7#ea-aaee74 ,virtue is s\l's t5d5cy to unity ( faculties1 vi4 #i4a 7#i-aadg74 ,virtue n corporeal1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,virtue n possess$ by body1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-fi74 ,virtue ( appetite expla9$1 iii4 #f4b 7#bf-ced74 ,virtue ! road to escape evils1 i4 #b4a 7#ai-bef74 ,virtue1 )\t :i*1 ,god is a m]e ^w ignor$ by gno/ics1 ii4 #i4ae 7#cc-fbi74 ,virtues1 i4 #b4 ,virtue's a*ievem5t makes ?is ! be/ ( all possible worlds1 ii4 #i4h 7#cc-fae74 ,virtues are only purifications1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,virtues are symmetrical 9 developm5t1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,virtues1 ,ari/otelian1 rational1 i4 #c4f 7#bj-bgd74 ,virtues1 by %ap+ man1 increase div9e elem5t 9 him1 i4 #b4b 7#ai-bei74 ,virtues _c be ascrib$ to div9ity1 i4 #b4a 7#ai-bef74 ,virtue1 *oir (1 ,/oic1 vi4 #i4aa 7#i-agj74 ,virtues1 discussion (1 is *>act]i/ic ( g5u9e philosophy1 ii4 #i4ae 7#cc-fba74 ,virtues exi/ ?r\gh incorporeality ( s\l1 iv4 #g4h 7#b-gj74 ,virtues1 high]1 are cont9uations upw>d ( ! homely1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,virtues1 high]1 imply l[] b n conv]sely1 i4 #c4g 7#ai-bff74 ,virtues1 high]1 m]ge into wisdom1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,virtues1 homely1 assimilate u to div9ity only p>tially1 i4 #b4c 7#ai-bfj74 ,virtues1 homely 7civil1 prud5ce1 c\rage1 temp]ance1 ju/ice71 i4 #b4a 7#ai-beg74 ,virtues1 homely1 produce 9 man a measure & proportion1 i4 #b4b 7#ai-bei74 ,virtues1 homely1 to be supplem5t$ by div9e discont5t1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,virtues1 homely1 yield resemblance to div9ity1 i4 #b4a 7#ai-bef74 ,virtues1 h[ !y purify1 i4 #b4d 7#ai-bfa74 ,virtues1 l[]1 are mutually relat$1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bff74 ,virtues mu/ be supplem5t$ by div9e discont5t1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,virtues1 natural1 yield only to p]fect views1 ne$ correction ( philosophy1 i4 #c4f 7#bj-bge74 ,virtues1 ,platonic1 homely & high]1 di/+ui%$1 i4 #b4c 7#ai-bfj74 ,virtu\s actions d]iv$ f self1 are free1 iii4 #a4aj 7#c-ii74 ,virtu\s man c suff] only 9 ! l[] "p1 i4 #d4ac 7#df-ajbc74 ,virtu\s man is fully happy1 i4 #d4d 7#df-ajbf74 ,virtu\s man is he ^: highe/ pr9ciple is active1 iii4 #d4f 7#ae-bci74 ,virtu\s m5 d "r at all times1 ev5 "u trials1 iii4 #a4aj 7#c-ii74 ,virtu\s w only object conv]sion ( s\l t[>ds h]self1 i4 #d4aa 7#df-ajce74 ,vision & he>+1 process (1 iv4 #e 7#bi-ebc74 ,vision does n ne$ int]m$i>y body1 iv4 #e4a 7#bi-ead74 ,vision fur!r1 recall intelligible entities n memory1 iv4 #d4e 7#bh-ddg74 ,vision int]ior1 h[ tra9$1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ec74 ,vision n dep5d5t on m$ium's vision1 iv4 #e4c 7#bi-ebj74 ,vision ( ,god1 ec/atic supreme purpose ( life1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,vision ( intelligible wisdom1 la/ /age ( s\l progress1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,vision1 !ory (1 ii4 #h 7#ce-fhj72 iv4 #g4f 7#b-fe72 v4 #e4g 7#cb-ehf72 v4 #f4a 7#bd-ccd72 vi4 #a4bj 7#db-hgb74 ,visual angle !ory ( ,ari/otle refut$1 ii4 #h4b 7#ce-fhb74 ,voice z "o w\ld analyze x1 s mu/ ! _w be /udi$1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icc74 ,voice us$ by demons & o!r inhabitants ( air1 iv4 #c4ah 7#bg-dag74 ,volunt>9ess n exclud$ by necessity1 iv4 #h4e 7#f-abg74 ,volunt>9ess1 ! basis ( responsibility1 vi4 #h4a 7#ci-ggd74 ,volunt>y movem5ts1 vi4 #c4bf 7#dd-ihj74 ,volunt>y s\l deta*m5t =bidd51 i4 #i 7#af-bde74 ,vulcan1 iii4 #b4ad 7#dg-ajfd74 ,wak5+ to true reality cont5t ( approa* to ,him1 v4 #e4aa 7#cb-eib74 ,w>f>e1 int]nec9e1 necess>y1 iii4 #b4a1 #e 7#dg-ajfd74 ,wa%+ ( man fall5 9 mud1 simile ( purification1 i4 #f4e 7#a-dh74 ,wa/age1 none 9 heav51 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hah74 ,wa/age ( physical body1 & matt]1 ii4 #a4d 7#dj-hai74 ,wa/age1 see leakage1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbg74 ,wa/age1 see leakage1 none 9 cele/ial light1 ii4 #a4h 7#dj-hbf74 ,wat]1 conta9$ 9 ! intelligible _w1 vi4 #g4aa 7#ch-gbj74 ,way to conceive ( fir/ pr9ciple1 v4 #e4aj1 #aa 7#cb-eib74 ,wax seal1 impressions are s5sations1 ,/oic1 iv4 #g4f 7#b-ff72 iii4 #f4i 7#bf-cff72 iv4 #f4a 7#da-hbi74 ,we & ours1 psy*ological names ( s\l1 v4 #c4c 7#di-ajid74 ,we & ours1 psy*ological t]ms1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,we & ! real man1 di/9ctions betwe51 i4 #a4aj 7#ec-abjb74 ,we & ! s\l1 relation betwe51 ii4 #a4c 7#ec-aaid74 ,we1 n ours1 is intelligible1 i4 #a4g 7#ec-aaii74 ,weak5+ ( inc>nate s\ls due to individual contemplation1 iv4 #h4d 7#f-abe74 ,weakness & affection ( man1 subject him to magic1 iv4 #d4dd 7#bh-eji74 ,weakness ( s\l consi/s ( fall+ into matt]1 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafj74 ,weakness ( s\l is evil1 i4 #h4d 7#ea-aadg74 ,weal? caus$ by ext]nal circum/ances1 ii4 #c4h 7#eb-aagd74 ,wean+ ( ! s\l f ! body1 iii4 #f4e 7#bf-cei74 ,welf>e ( s\l is resemblance to div9ity1 i4 #f4f 7#a-di74 ,:atness1 vi4 #g4ai 7#ch-gce74 ,:atness & affections 7quiddity7 ( be+ di/+ui%es betwe51 ii4 #f4b 7#ag-bdh74 ,:]e or place is ,ari/otelian category1 vi4 #a4a1 #d 7#db-hfb74 ,:ole & individuals fa%ion$ by entire s\l1 vi4 #e4h 7#bc-cbb74 ,:ole is good1 ?\gh cont9u$ m+l$ p>ts1 iii4 #b4ag 7#dg-ajgj74 ,:ole ( divisible & indivisible p>ts1 human s\l is1 iv4 #c4ai 7#bg-dai74 ,:ole1 reason is a1 vi4 #e4aj 7#bc-cbf74 ,:yness is =m1 vi4 #g4ai 7#ch-gce72 vi4 #g4b 7#ch-gcb74 ,:yness ( its =ms conta9$ by its intellig5ce1 ii4 #g4b 7#ch-gcb74 ,w be1 n are 9 "o1 all ?+s1 v4 #b4a 7#aa-aic74 ,w1 fre$om (1 on :at is x bas$1 vi4 #h4b 7#ci-gge74 ,w ( ! "o1 vi4 #h 7#ci-ggc74 ,w+s ( s\ls lo/1 iv4 #c4g 7#bg-cii74 ,w+s1 s\ls lose !m :5 fall+1 iv4 #h4a 7#f-abj72 i4 #h4ad 7#ea-aafa74 ,wisdom & prud5ce1 fir/ are types2 become virtues by contemplation ( s\l1 i4 #b4g 7#ai-bfg74 ,wisdom d]iv$ f intellig5ce1 & ultimately f good1 v4 #i4b 7#e-ajd74 ,wisdom does n imply reason+ & memory1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-def74 ,wisdom1 e/abli%$ by spiritual prepond]ance1 i4 #d4ad 7#df-ajcg74 ,wisdom1 highe/1 nature l[e/ 9 _w-s\l's wisdom1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-deh74 ,wisdom1 intelligible1 la/ /age ( s\l-progress1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efg74 ,wisdom is v be+1 v4 #h4e 7#ca-eei74 ,wisdom none ! less happy = be+ unconsci\s1 i4 #d4i 7#df-ajcb74 ,wisdom ( creator makes compla9ts grotesque1 iii4 #b4ad 7#dg-ajfc74 ,wisdom ( s\l alone has virtue1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,wisdom se5 9 div9e1 v4 #h4aj 7#ca-efh74 ,wisdom1 two k9ds1 ( s\l & ( intellig5ce1 i4 #b4f 7#ai-bfe74 ,wisdom univ]sal1 p]man5t because timeless1 iv4 #d4aa 7#bh-def74 ,wise man1 description ( 8 me?ods1 i4 #d4ad 7#df-aacg74 ,wise man1 h[ he escapes all en*antm5ts1 iv4 #d4dc 7#bh-ejg74 ,wise man rema9s unatta*$1 i4 #d4af 7#df-ajci74 ,wise man uses in/rum5ts only z tempor>y means ( developm5t1 i4 #d4af 7#df-ajdj74 ,wise m51 two w be equally happy ?\gh 9 diff]5t =tunes1 i4 #d4ae 7#df-ajch74 ,)drawal )9 y\rself1 i4 #f4i 7#a-ed74 ,wond]ful is relation ( "o 7qv47 to u1 v4 #e4h 7#cb-ehh74 ,^w prophoric & innate1 v4 #a4c 7#aj-agg74 ,^w1 s\l z & actualization ( intellig5ce1 v4 #a4c 7#aj-agg74 ,workman ( ! body1 in/rum5t is ! s\l1 iv4 #g4a 7#b-ef74 ,_w & creator are n evil1 ii4 #i 7#cc-eii74 ,_w z et]nally begott51 ii4 #i4b 7#cc-fjc74 ,_w body1 :y ! _w-s\l is ev]y:]e pres5t 9 x1 vi4 #d4a 7#bb-bhe74 ,_w conta9s traditions ( div9ity1 ii4 #i4i 7#cc-faf74 ,_w imp]i%able1 s long z ar*etype subsi/s1 v4 #h4ab 7#ca-egb74 ,_w intelligible1 ev]y?+ is actual1 ii4 #e4c 7#be-cdf74 ,_w is deity ( ?ird rank1 iii4 #e4f 7#ej-aacb74 ,_w mu/ be /udi$1 j z "o w\ld analyze ! voice1 vi4 #c4a 7#dd-icc74 ,_w n evil because ( our suff]+s1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fjf74 ,_w n to be blam$ = imp]fections1 iii4 #b4c 7#dg-ajdf74 ,_w1 no?+ m beautiful c\ld be imag9$1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fjf74 ,_w1 objective1 subsi/s1 ev5 :5 we are di/ract$1 v4 #a4ab 7#aj-aia74 ,_w1 outside our _w w\ld n be visible1 iv4 #e4h 7#bi-ebi74 ,_w p5etrat+ by intellig5ce t rema9s unmov$1 vi4 #e4aa 7#bc-cbh74 ,_w plann$ by ,god1 refut$1 v4 #h4g 7#ca-efa74 ,_w s5se & intelligible1 are !y sep>ate or classifiable toge!r1 vi4 #a4ab 7#db-hfj74 ,_w-s\l activity1 :5 measur$ is "t1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajje74 ,_w-s\l & human s\l1 diff]5ces betwe51 ii4 #i4g 7#cc-fab74 ,_w-s\l & individual s\ls born f intellig5ce1 vi4 #b4bb 7#dc-ibi74 ,_w-s\l & /> s\l1 intellectual diff]5ces1 iv4 #d4ag 7#bh-dfc74 ,_w-s\l & />s are impassible1 iv4 #d4db 7#bh-ejf74 ,_w-s\l animat$ by univ]se1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-djd74 ,_w-s\l basis ( exi/5ce ( bodies1 iv4 #g4c 7#b-fj74 ,_w-s\l begott5 f intellig5ce by unity & univ]sality1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,_w-s\l creates1 because ne>e/ ! intelligible1 iv4 #c4f 7#bg-cig74 ,_w-s\l creative1 n pres]vative1 ii4 #c4af 7#eb-aahc74 ,_w-s\l conta9s univ]se z sea ! net1 iv4 #c4i 7#bg-dje74 ,_w-s\l c\ld n h gone ?r\gh creation drama1 ii4 #i4d 7#cc-fje74 ,_w-s\l does n rememb] ,god1 cont9u+ to see him1 iv4 #d4g 7#bh-ddi74 ,_w-s\l1 e>? c feel z well z />s1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dga74 ,_w-s\l ex]ts influ5ce ap>t f a/rology & deviltry1 iv4 #d4cb 7#bh-dij74 ,_w-s\l glorifies man z life transfigures matt]1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-agf74 ,_w-s\l has no ratioc9ation1 iv4 #d4aa 7#bh-dee74 ,_w-s\l1 h[ idea ( x is rea*$1 ii4 #i4ag 7#cc-fcc74 ,_w-s\l1 9 x1 wisdom is ! l[e/ & nature ! highe/1 iv4 #d4ab 7#bh-deh74 ,_w-s\l inf]ior1 ii4 #b4c 7#ad-bcc74 ,_w-s\l in=ms all ?+s progressively1 iv4 #c4aj 7#bg-djf74 ,_w-s\l is to "t :at intellig5ce is to et]nity1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjg74 ,_w-s\l1 l5g? ( its life is "t1 iii4 #g4aa 7#de-ajjh74 ,_w-s\l m$iation1 ?r\gh x are b5efits grant$ to m51 iv4 #d4cj 7#bh-dhf74 ,_w-s\l1 nature (1 i4 #h4b 7#ea-aadd74 ,_w-s\l p>ticipates to create _w only by contemplation1 & is undi/urb$ !reby1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,_w-s\l1 ,plato is 9 d\bt ab\t its be+ l ! />s1 iv4 #d4bb 7#bh-dgj74 ,_w-s\l procession1 iii4 #h4e 7#cj-ecg74 ,_w-s\l procession results 9 space1 iii4 #g4aj 7#de-ajjf74 ,_w-s\l rema9s 9 ! intelligible1 iii4 #i4c 7#ac-bbc74 ,_w-s\l simultane\sly gives & receives z untr\bl$ m$ium1 iv4 #h4g 7#f-aca74 ,_w-s\l unconsci\s ( our *anges1 iv4 #d4g 7#bh-dej74 ,_w-s\l unconsci\s ( :at goes on 9 x1 iii4 #d4d 7#ae-bcg74 ,_w-s\l1 :y x is ev]y:]e entirely 9 ! _w body1 vi4 #d 7#bb-bhe74 ,_w-s\ls & individual s\ls insep>able1 because ( functions1 iv4 #c4b 7#bg-cib74 ,_w-s\l's creation ( _w is cause ( div9ity ( s\ls1 v4 #a4b 7#aj-age74 ,_w-s\l's exi/5ce1 basis ( t ( simple bodies1 iv4 #g4b 7#b-eg74 ,_w1 ?is is ! be/ ( all possible1 because we c a*ieve virtue1 ii4 #i4h 7#cc-fae74 ,_w1 to be 9 x b n ( x1 i4 #h4f 7#ea-aaej74 ,_w's te/imony to its creator1 iii4 #b4c 7#dg-ajdg74 ,zodiac1 ii4 #c4c 7#eb-aafe74 ,plot9os1 8 ,life1 ,times & ,philosophy ,by ,k5ne? ,sylvan ,gu?rie1 ,a4 ,m41 ,h>v>d1 ,ph4 ,d41 ,tulane4 ,?is is a lucid1 s*ol>ly sy/ematization ( ! views ( ,plot9os1 giv+ translation ( important & useful passages4 ,x is prec$$ by a c>eful indication & exposition ( 8 =mative influ5ces1 & a full biography deal+ ) 8 suppos$ obligations to ,*ri/ianity4 ,accurate ref]5ces are giv5 = e /atem5t & quotation4 ,! exposition (1 & ref]5ces on ,h]metic philosophy are by !mselves wor? ! price ( ! book4 ,dr ,h>ris1 ,u4,s4 ,commission] ( ,education has writt5 ab\t x 9 ! highe/ t]ms4 ,dr4 ,paul ,c>us1 ,editor ( ! ,op5 ,c\rt1 devot$ half a page ( ! ,july #ahig issue to an appreciative & comm5datory ,review ( x4 ,among ! _m o!r /rong comm5dations ( ! "w are ! foll[+3 ,f ,g4 ,r4 ,s4 ,mead1 ,editor ,! ,!osophical ,review1 ,london3 ,x may be /at$1 on ! basis ( a fairly wide k ( ! subject1 t ! summ>y ( our anonym\s au?or is ! ,,cle>e/ & ,,mo/ ,,intellig5t :i* has z yet appe>$4 ,! writ] bases himself ^u ! orig9al text1 & 8 happy phras+ ( ,platonic t]ms & 8 deep sympa?y ) ,platonic ?\ght proclaim ! pres5ce ( a capable translator ( ,plot9os among/ u4444 ,to make s lucid & capable a comp5dium ( ! works ( s great a giant ( philosophy z ,plot9os1 ! au?or mu/ h sp5t mu* "t 9 analys+ ! text & satisfy+ himself z to ! mean+ ( _m obscure passages2 to te/ 8 absolute accuracy w\ld require ! v]ification ( e ref]5ce among ! hundr$s giv5 9 ! tables at ! end ( ! pamphlet1 & we h only _h "t to v]ify "o or two ( ! m /rik+4 ,^! are z accurate z any?+ 9 a dige/ c rightly be expect$ to be4 ,9 addition to ! detail$ *apt]s on ! sev5 realms ( ! ,plot9ic philosophy1 on re9c>nation1 e?ics1 & /hetics1 we h introductory *apt]s on ,platonism1 ,ari/otelianism1 ,/oicism1 & ,emanationism1 & on ! relation%ip ( ,plot9os to ,*ri/ianity & ,paganism4 ,^? :o desire to ent] into ! ,plot9ian prec9cts ( ! temple ( ,greek philosophy by ! mo/ exp$iti\s pa? ,,_c d ,,bett] ?an take ?is little pamphlet = _! guide2 x is ( c\rse n p]fect1 b x is und5iably ,,! ,,be/ :i* has yet appe>$4 ,we h recomm5d$ ! ,t4,p4,s4 to procure a supply ( ?is pamphlet1 = to our ,platonic fri5ds & colleagues we say n only ,,y ,,%\ld1 b ,,y ,,mu/ read x4 ,,human ,,bro!rhood1 ,,nov4 #ahig1 9 a v ext5d$ & mo/ comm5datory review1 says3 ,,too ,,great ,,praise ,,c\ld ,,h>dly ,,be ,,be/[$ ^u ?is s*ol>ly contribution to ,platonic lit]ature4 ,net price1 clo? b\nd1 po/-paid1 #a4ca4 ,transcrib]'s ,notes3 ,punctuation & spell+ 7 made consi/5t :5 a pr$om9ant pref]5ce 0 f\nd 9 ?is f\r-volume set2 o!rwise !y 7 n *ang$4 ,simple typographical errors 7 correct$4 ,inconsi/5t capitalization has n be5 *ang$4 ,ambigu\s hyph5s at ! ends ( l9es 7 reta9$4 ,infrequ5t spell+ ( ,plot9us *ang$ to ! pr$om9ant ,plot9os4 ,sev]al op5+ or clos+ p>5!ses & quotation m>ks are unmat*$2 ,transcrib] has n attempt$ to det]m9e :]e !y belong4 ,page #ajcj3 ,! op5+ p>5!sis 9 7,nor w\ld he be tr\bl$ if ! memb]s ei!r has no mat* or %>es "o ) a subord9ate phrase4 ,su* %>+ occurs else:]e 9 ?is f\r-volume set4 ,page #ajei3 7! =m] = _! f]ocity1 has no mat*+ clos+ p>5!sis4 ,page #aahh1 footnote #bfh 7orig9ally #ga73 ,! op5+ p>5!sis 9 7! pr9cipal p[] ( ! s\l1 has no mat*1 or %>es "o ) a subord9ate phrase4 ,page #abah3 ,! op5+ quotation m>k j be=e ',he :o possesses ! virtues' has no mat*+ clos+ quotation m>k4 ,page #abfb3 ,! op5+ quotation m>k j be=e ',! intelligible is ( a nature' has no mat*+ clos+ quotation m>k4 ,page #abfe3 ,! op5+ quotation m>k j be=e 'be 9 relation ) a place1' has no mat*+ clos+ quotation m>k4 ,page #acah3 ,! op5+ quotation m>k j be=e ',be+ & ,ess5ce2' has no mat*+ clos+ quotation m>k4 ,page #acbg3 ,! fir/ few l9es 7 mispr9t$1 ) ! sub-head+ ,,importance ,,9 ,,! ,,pa/4 9 ! middle ( ! fir/ p>agraph & "p ( a ^w miss+ f t p>agraph4 ,?is e,book attempts to correct t4 ,concordance ,issues3 ,entries 9 ! ,concordance h n be5 sy/ematically *eck$ = accuracy2 "s errors h be5 correct$1 b o!rs probably rema94 ,detect$ errors are not$ bel[4 ,page ii3 ,alone ) ! alone444 #a-eej correct$ to #a-ej4 ,page v3 ,beauty consi/s 9 k9%ip to ! s\l444 #a4db4 correct$ to #a-db4 ,page vi3 ,be+ & actualization444 #cj-ghd correct$ to #ci-ghd4 ,page viii3 ,ca/ration1 second ref]5ce1 v4 #h4ac 7#ca-egc74 does n belong "h4 ,page xvii3 ,effusion1 la/ ^w reation c\ld be reaction or reason4 ,page xxix3 ,incorporeality ( s\l prov$ by its444 #b4gb4 correct$ to #b-gb4 ,page xxxii3 ,intellig5ce's exi/5ce prov$444 #ej-ajd4 correct$ to #e-ajd4 ,page xxxiv3 ,judgm5t ( "o "p by ano!r444 #eb-dgb4 correct$ to #eb-aagb4 ,page lviii3 ,some:at1 a p>ticle to modify444 #ca-gig correct$ to #ci-gig4 ,page lviii3 ,s\l & relation ) ,god1 ref]5ce to i4 0 mispr9t$ z ii4 ,page lviii3 ,s\l con=ms de/9y to h] "*444 #ec-bch4 correct$ to #ae-bch4 ,page lx3 ,s\l split into ?ree has no ref]5ce4 ,page lxii3 ,spectator ( vision becomes p>ticipator444 #cd-efi correct$ to #ca-efi4 ,page lxii3 ,/>s are !y animate8 has no ref]5ce4 ,page lxii3 ,/>s are !y inanimate8 has no ref]5ce4 ,page lxiv3 ,supreme intellig5ce1 nature (444 #ea-add4 correct$ to #ea-aadd4 ,page lxviii3 ,unity1 conta9$ 9 s5se objects444 #bd-fga correct$ to #cd-fga4 ,page lxxii3 ,we & ours1 psy*ological names ( s\l 0 miss+ "p ( ref]5ce2 recon/ruct$ by ,transcrib] bas$ on page ref]5ce4 ,footnote ,issues3 ,9 ^! notes1 an*or means ! ref]5ce to a footnote1 & footnote means ! in=mation to :i* ! an*or ref]s4 ,an*ors occur )9 ! ma9 text1 :ile footnotes are gr\p$ 9 sequ5ce at ! end ( ?is e,book4 ,! /ructure ( ! orig9al book requir$ "s exceptions to ?is1 z expla9$ bel[4 ,! orig9al text us$ *apt] endnotes4 ,9 ?is e,book1 !y h be5 comb9$ into a s+le1 asc5d+ sequ5ce bas$ on ! sequ5ce 9 :i* ! footnotes 7n ! an*ors7 occurr$ 9 ! orig9al book1 & plac$ at ! end ( ! ma9 text1 j be=e ! ,concordance4 ,f\r k9ds ( irregul>ities occurr$ 9 ! footnotes3 #a4 ,"s footnotes are ref]5c$ by m ?an "o an*or1 s two or m an*ors may ref] to ! same footnote4 #b4 ,"s an*ors 7 out ( sequ5ce1 app>5tly because !y 7 add$ aft]w>ds or because !y are %>e a footnote ) ano!r an*or4 ,!y h be5 r5umb]$ to mat* ! numb]s ( ! footnotes to :i* !y ref]4 #c4 ,"s footnotes h no an*ors4 ,^! are not$ bel[4 #d4 ,"o footnote 0 mispr9t$ beyond repair1 & ! next ?ree footnotes 7 miss+4 ,^! are not$ bel[4 ,page #ajgf3 ,footnote #fa 7orig9ally #db7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be 9 page range #ajfb-ajfd4 ,page #aaba3 ,footnote #ajj 7orig9ally #d7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be 9 page range #ajia-ajic4 ,page #aaba3 ,footnote #ajc 7orig9ally #g7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be 9 page range #ajid-ajig4 ,an*or #ii 7orig9ally #c7 on page #ajid c\ld be ! miss+ an*or1 z t numb] also is us$ on page #ajia4 ,page #aahh3 ,footnote #baj 7orig9ally #ac7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be on page #aaga or #aagb4 ,page #aahi3 ,footnote #bbf 7orig9ally #bi7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be on page #aagd or #aage4 ,page #abec3 ,footnote #cbi 7orig9ally #i7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be 9 page range #abai-abbf4 ,page #abhg3 ,footnote #dfi 7orig9ally #ih7 has no an*or2 ! miss+ an*or w\ld be on page #abhg4 ,page #acac3 ,*apt] numb] is ,,vii4 b !re is no e>li] ,,vi4 ,page #accc3 ,footnote #geh 7orig9ally #ba7 appe>s to be mispr9t$1 & ! next ?ree footnotes #gei-gfa 7orig9ally #bb-bd7 are miss+4