,,! ,,un?9k+ ,,de/roy] by ,,rog ,,phillips ,gordon & ,h>old bo? admitt$ ! possibility ( ?9k+ entities o!r ?an human4 ,b w\ld !y ev] recognize ! physical =m ( "s ( ^! be+s8 ,hey1 ,gordon6 ,gordon ,m>l[1 ,ph4,d41 /raight5$ up & turn$ 9 ! direction ( ! voice1 ! g>d5 tr[el dangl+ 9 8 dirt-/a9$ :ite canvas glove4 ,8 wide m\? broke into a smile t reveal$ ev5 :ite tee?4 ,x 0 ,h>old ,h>p]1 an und]graduate /ud5t1 :o _h call$4 ,hop ov] ! f5ce & come 91 ,gordon invit$4 ,he dropp$ ! tr[el &1 tak+ (f 8 "w gloves1 rea*$ into 8 pocket & extract$ an old pipe4 ,he fill$ x1 ! welcom+ smile rema9+ on 8 lips1 :ile ,h>old ,h>p] approa*$1 /epp+ c>efully betwe5 ! r[s ( c>rots1 cabbages1 & caulifl[]4 ,h>old held a newspap] 9 8 h&4 ,:5 he rea*$ ,gordon ,m>l[ he held x op5 & po9t$ to ! headl9e4 ,,robot ,,rocket ,,%ip ,,to ,,m>s4 ,gordon took ! pap] & read ! item1 puff+ sl[ly & cont5t$ly on 8 old pipe4 ,8 eyes took on an int]e/$ look :5 he came to ! report]'s speculations on ! possibility ( intellig5t life on ,m>s4 ,f9ally he h&$ ! newspap] back to ,h>old4 ,y "k1 ,h>old1 he said1 ,i wond] if !y w\ld recognize intellig5t life if !y saw x on o!r planets4 ,( c\rse !y w\ld1 ,h>old repli$4 ,reg>dless ( its =m !re w\ld be artifacts t only intellig5t life c\ld create4 ,w\ld !re8 ,gordon snort$4 ,i wond]4 ,he squatt$ d[n1 pick+ up ! tr[el & lazily pok+ x into ! ri* soil at 8 feet4 ,t's :y ,i wond]1 he cont9u$4 ,we are s prone to set up te/s on :at intellig5t life is t we are likely to miss x entirely if x doesn't con=m exactly to our preconceiv$ notions4 ,we assume t if a be+ is intellig5t x mu/ get ! urge to build artifacts ( "s k9d--pots & vases1 h\ses1 idols1 ma*9]y1 metal objects4 ,b ,,mu/ x8 ,9 ord] to d s x mu/ h h&s & p]haps legs4 ,suppose x doesn't h su* ?+s8 ,suppose t no matt] h[ intellig5t x might be1 x c\ld n d ^? ?+s6 ,!n x w\ldn't be intellig5t1 w\ld x8 ,h>old ask$1 puzzl$4 ,we are assum+ x is1 ,gordon said pati5tly4 ,!re are o!r outlets = intellig5ce ?an mak+ clay pots4 ,z a la/ resort = an intellig5t be+ !re is always--?9k+4 ,he *uckl$ at 8 joke4 ,illu/ration3 ,h>old held a newspap] 9 8 h&s4 ,i've (t5 wond]$ :at x w\ld be l to be a ?9k+1 reason+ be+ ) no p[]s ( movem5t :atsoev]4 ,) bodily en]gy provid$ automatically by environm5t1 say1 & all ! days ( life ) no?+ to d b ?9k4 ,:at a *ance = a philosoph]6 ,:at dep?s ( ?\ght he might explore4 ,:at heights ( intellectual p]ception he might atta94 ,& if !re 7 "s means ( contact ) o!rs ( 8 k9d1 s t all c\ld pool _! ?\ghts & guide ! y\ng] g5]ation1 :at progress su* a race might make6 99 99 99 99 99 ,& s we see1 ,ont telepa!d1 t !re mu/ be a ,:ole ( :i* ea* ( u is a "p only4 ,! old process :i* says ',i ?9k1 !re=e ,i am1' has its fallacy 9 ! /atem5t1 ',i ?9k4' ,x assumes t t ass]tion is axiomatic & basic1 :5 9 reality x is ! conclusion d]iv$ f a long process ( m5tal introspection4 ,x is a !ory r ?an an axiom4 ,b don't y ?9k1 ,ont1 ,upt repli$1 t y are confus+ ! n\m5on ) ! ph5om5on8 ,:at ,i mean is1 ! fact ( ?9k+ is !re f ! v />t or ! conclusion c\ldn't be rea*$2 & ! !oretical conclusion1 z y call x1 is m]ely ! f9al recognition ( some?+ basic & axiomatic t 0 !re all ! "t6 ,true1 ,ont repli$4 ,b /ill1 to ! ?9k+ m9d1 x is a !ory & n an axiom4 ,all n\m5a are !re be=e we arrive at an und]/&+ ( !m4 ,?\ght1 if x exi/s z su*1 is also !re4 ,b ! !oretical conclusion ,i ?9k has no m degree ( c]ta9ty ?an any o!r ?+ ! m9d c deal )4 ,to say ',i ?9k' is to ass]t ! tru? ( an hypo!sis :i* ,,may be true1 b n necess>ily s4 ,& !n to conclude1 ',!re=e ,i am1' is to advance "o ( ! mo/ %aky conclusions ( all "t4 ,und]nea? t s-call$ logical conclusion lies a metaphysics ( be+1 a !ory ( ,:oles1 a recognition by diff]5tiation ( p>ts1 ) a d5ial ( all b ! "o "p set ap>t by t diff]5tiation1 &1 9 %ort1 ! mo/ irrational hodgepodge ( contradictory conclusions ! ?9k+ m9d c conceive4 ,?is pre-cognition t enables "o to arrive at ! t5u\s /atem5t1 ',i ?9k1 !re=e ,i am1' is nicely ?r[n out by tagg+ x ) ano!r metaphysical intangible call$ illusion--z if ! m9d c sep>ate illusion f reality by "s absolute /&>d4 ,i believe y're "r1 ,ont1 ,upt repli$ sl[ly1 8 telepa!d ?\ghts subdu$ ) respect4 ,x is possible t ! concept1 ',i ?9k1' is ! illusion1 :ile ! s-call$ illusions are ! reality4 99 99 99 99 99 ,ev5 )\t ! b5efit ( pa/ ?\ghts1 ,gordon 0 say+1 :ack+ (f a we$ a y>d away & ne>ly upsett+ himself1 a m9d ) no?+ to d b ?9k c\ld accompli% miracles4 ,suppose x 0 n aw>e ( any o!r ?9k+ entity1 ?\gh x might be surr\nd$ by su* simil> entities4 ,x w\ld be born or come into exi/5ce "s way1 arrive at self-aw>5ess & c]ta9 o!r aw>5esses to base its ?9k+ on1 dep5d+ on its /ructure1 &-- he look$ up at ,h>old />tl$ at 8 own conclusion--x might ev5 arrive at ! ultimate solution to all reality & compreh5d ! f\ndations ( ! ,univ]se6 ,& ev5tually be de/roy$ )\t any o!r entity hav+ ! b5efit ( x all1 ,h>old comm5t$ dryly4 ,:at a pity t w\ld be1 ,gordon murmur$4 ,= ! human race to /ruggle = hundr$s ( ye>s1 & h "s unguessable entity on ,m>s d all t 9 "o lifetime--& x all g to wa/e :ile "s blund]+ ass l&s on ,m>s & passes x by1 look+ = artifacts4 99 99 99 99 99 ,b t is only ! />t 9 ! blund]s conta9$ 9 t mo/ pr(\nd philosophical revelation ( old1 ,ont /at$4 ,aft] arriv+ at a prec>i\s conclusion ab\t exi/5ce ! anci5ts 7 n satisfi$4 ,!y _h to say1 ',if ,i am ,i mu/ h be5 creat$6' ,!n !y g on & say1 ',if ,i 0 creat$ !re mu/ be a ,creator6' ,& ?us !y so> f _! prec>i\s p]* 9 exi/5ce1 so> on nonexi/5t w+s1 & p]* on ! ess5ce ( evanesc5ce6 ,!y d n recognize ! alt]native--t to exi/ does n necess>ily imply a beg9n+4 ,!y d n recognize x because !y h d]iv$ all _! tools f reality ar\nd !m & !n d5i$ ! reality :ile accept+ ! validity ( ! tools ( ?\ght d]iv$ f x4 ,& 9 ?is way !y arrive at an absolute exi/5ce ( ,some?+ !y h nev] s5s$ or felt 9 any way1 :ile d5y+ all t !y h felt & s5s$1 & give x attributes :i* _! s5se ( idealism dictates x mu/ h1 & call x ,god4 ,!n1 ,upt said ?\ghtfully1 ,i take x y are an a!i/8 ,c]ta9ly ,,n1 ,ont gr[l$ telepa?ically4 ,b y impli$ t 9 y\r comm5ts on ! conclusions ( ! anci5ts1 ,upt insi/$4 99 99 99 99 99 ,b if !re are no artifacts1 ,h>old said4 ,& no signs ( intellig5ce :atev]1 h[ c\ld we ev] "k t !re ,,0 intellig5ce "s place8 ,!re mu/ be "s way1 ,gordon said4 ,i've taught logic at ! ,u = fifte5 ye>s n[1 & ,i've done a lot ( ?9k+ on ! subject4 ,if we ev] rea* ,m>s ,i ?9k we %\ld be v c>eful :at we t\*4 ,we w\ld be clumsy bulls 9 a *9a %op1 n kn[+ ! true wor? ( :at we f\nd1 de/roy+ :at might be f\nd to be priceless by lat] & m c>eful explor]s4 ,m>s is old] ?an ! ,e>?1 & ,i c't help be+ conv9c$ t !re is ,,"s =m ( intellig5ce !re4 99 99 99 99 99 ,i impli$ no su* ?+ z a!ism1 ,ont insi/$4 ,i m]ely said t ! reason+ us$ by ! anci5ts to arrive at ! ,creator 0 ! mo/ slip%od & illogical possible4 ,!re 0 ano!r l9e us$ long ago t 0 m solid1 b /ill v weak4 ,x />t$ out ) ! /atem5t1 ',i c be aw>e ( no?+ b ?\ghts4' ,ext]nal /imuli1 if su* !re are1 mu/ be trans=m$ into ?\ght be=e ,i c be aw>e ( !m4 ,s9ce ,i c nev] be aw>e ( any?+ o!r ?an ?\ght1 :y assume any?+ except ?\ght exi/s8 ,y1 & all o!r ?+s1 exi/ z ?\ghts 9 my m9d4 ,!re is no?+ except :at exi/s 9 my m9d4 ,!re=e1 by t tok51 ,i am ,god6 ,b1 ,upt *uckl$1 by ! same tok5 ,i c insi/ t ,i am ,god & y are j a product ( my own creation4 ,yes1 ,ont agre$4 ,s x pres5ts a dilemma4 ,to resolve x1 x is necess>y to po/ulate a ,supreme ,m9d1 & to say t all ?+s are j ?\ghts 9 ,god's ,m9d4 ,t makes u bo? ! same !n & !re is no argum5t ab\t :o is ,god6 99 99 99 99 99 ,h>old kick$ a lump ( moi/ e>? abs5tly4 ,x seems to me1 ,gordon1 he said cauti\sly1 t y are bit+ ! air ) y\r tee?4 ,if !re are intellig5t be+s on ,m>s !y w be aw>e ( u1 & make !mselves kn[n4 ,if = no o!r reason !y w d t to keep u f de/roy+ !m4 ,gordon /ood up & ar*$ 8 back4 ,he plac$ ! g>d5 tr[el & gloves 9 ! hip pocket ( 8 cov]alls & tapp$ 8 pipe on ! heel ( 8 %oe4 ,y are assum+1 he said1 t su* be+s c f9d a way to communicate ) u4 ,b h y ?\ght ( ! possibility t if _! abilities to reason are undetectable to u1 by ! same tok5 !y might n be aw>e we are intellig5t8 ,a mad bull 9 a pa/ure c ?9k aft] a fa%ion1 b w\ld y try to reason ) him8 ,y w\ld run if he *>g$ y1 & if he caught up ) y & maul$ y x w\ld nev] occur to y to say1 ',look "h1 old boy4 ,let's talk ?is ?+ ov] fir/4' ,bo? m5 laugh$4 ,gordon />t$ walk+ along ! r[ he 0 /&+ 91 t[>d ! h\se4 ,h>old kept pace4 ,i see y\r po9t1 he agre$4 ,!re are s _m ?+s we assume unconsci\sly :5 we speculate on ! possibilities ( intellig5t life on ,m>s1 ,gordon w5t on1 /oop+ ov] to pull a we$ he _h miss$ 9 8 e>li] we$+4 ,rate ( ?9k+ is mo/ probably a function ( ! mat]ial organism4 ,"s o!r ?9k+ creature might ?9k fa/] or sl[]--p]haps s mu* s t we c\ldn't foll[ !m ev5 if we c\ld tune 9 on _! ?\ghts directly4 ,imag9e a m9d s pond]\s t x takes a ye> = x to ?9k z mu* z we d 9 a m9ute6 ,spe$ w\ldn't necess>ily h to be a function ( size1 ei!r4 ,some?+ incr$ibly small might take ages to ?9k a simple ?\ght4 ,h y ev] he>d ! ,g]man tale call$ ,! ,?ree ,sleep]s1 ,h>old8 ,no1 ,i hav5't1 ,h>old repli$4 99 99 99 99 99 ,well1 9 a small t[n 9 ,g]many !re 7 ?ree m5 s fat t !y c\ld b>ely walk4 ,!y sp5t ne>ly all _! "t sleep+4 ,! only tr\ble 0 t e day or s someone w\ld di/urb !m by s++ or walk+ by1 or "s o!r trivial ?+ t is always happ5+ 9 a small t[n1 no matt] h[ dead x is4 ,"o "t :5 !y 7 di/urb$ ?ree days runn+ !y got mad & decid$ to g to ! hills4 ,!y look$ 9 ! hills until !y f\nd a nice dry cave4 ,!re !y relax$ ) deep sighs ( cont5tm5t & w5t to sleep4 ,day aft] day1 week aft] week1 !y slept undi/urb$4 ,!n "o day a dog w&]$ into ! cave1 saw ! ?ree brea?+ m\nta9s ( fle% & he>d ! d9 ( _! deep snor+2 &1 sc>$ half to dea?1 let out a %rill yip & sk$addl$4 ,a week lat] "o ( ! ?ree sleep]s /irr$1 op5$ 8 eyes briefly1 & mutt]$1 ',:at 0 t noise8' ,!n he promptly w5t back to sleep4 ,t5 days lat] ! second sleep] /irr$1 mutt]$1 ',damf9o1' & w5t back to sleep4 ,ne>ly a mon? lat] ! ?ird sleep] op5$ 8 eyes sudd5ly1 />$ at ! ro( ( ! cave = a mom5t1 & said1 ',i ?9k x 0 a dog4' ,!n he w5t back to sleep4 ,! way ! /ory goes no?+ ev] came ne> ! cave aga91 s !y are /ill !re1 fa/ asleep--/ill fat1 too1 ,i suppose4 ,i see :at y're driv+ at1 ,h>old said1 *uckl+ ov] ! /ory4 ,we assume t any intellig5t be+ :atev]1 if x exi/s1 ?9ks at ! same ,,rate we d2 b x might n4 ,t's "r1 ,gordon admitt$4 ,& !re are ev5 m subtle assumptions we make unconsci\sly4 ,= "o1 we assume t a ?9k+ creature mu/ ?9k 9 ! same way we d4 ,we might n ev5 be able to recognize ?9k+ :5 we meet x1 on ano!r planet4 ,no-- he held up 8 h& to sil5ce ! "q on ,h>old's lips1 --,i don't "k exactly :at ,i mean4 ,i'll put x ?is way4 ,we h /eam eng9es & gasol9e eng9es4 ,we also h electric motors4 ,suppose we h /eam-eng9e ?\ght4 ,h[ w\ld we recognize electric-motor ?9k+8 ,or p]haps a little clos] to :at ,i'm try+ to express1 we h ari?metic & algebra4 ,suppose ) our ari?metic m9ds ) no slighte/ inkl+ ( ! exi/5ce ( a v>iable1 we run into an algebra m9d8 ,we might mi/ake x = some?+ f> remov$ f ?9k+ or intellig5ce4 ,we g on ! assumption t any?+ t doesn't /omp up1 give a salute1 & solemnly ann\nce ',h['1 is un9tellig5t4 ,x might j be m int]e/$ 9 its own ?\ghts ?an 9 ! visitors f ,e>?1 ,h>old sugge/$4 ,x might1 ,gordon said4 ,or x might be int5sely curi\s & /udy+ ! ,e>?m5 v closely ) s5ses o!r ?an sight & he>+4 99 99 99 99 99 ,b1 ,ont add$ ?\ghtfully1 al?\gh ! conclusion t we are all ?\ghts 9 ! m9d ( ! ,creator is logically un%akeable1 x isn't v satisfy+1 f a logical po9t1 because x makes ,god no?+ m ?an ! compromis+ ( a cute dilemma4 ,x places ! ,creator 9 ! same light z ! f9al decision to locate ! ,capitol ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates at ,wa%+ton4 ,:]e's t8 ,upt ask$ quickly4 ,i don't "k1 ,ont said te/ily4 ,t's j some?+ ,i pick$ up out ( ! blue1 s to speak4 ,inspirational ?\ght4 ,= all ,i "k x's j a figm5t ( my imag9ation4 ,i've _h inspirational ?\ghts too1 ,upt said excit$ly4 ,i hav5't spok5 ( !m to y because ,i 0 afraid y might ?9k ,i 0 becom+ disorganiz$ 9 my ?\ghts4 ,i've done a lot ( ?9k+ ab\t ! inspirational /uff ,i get n[ & !n1 ,ont said matt]-(-factly4 ,if x came all ! "t ,i w\ld be incl9$ to ?9k x 0 ! ,voice ( ! ,supreme ,be+ ,itself6 ,b x doesn't come t way4 ,nei!r does m9e1 ,upt said4 ,i (t5 ?9k !re mu/ be angels t hov] ov] u at times & bless u ) _! wise ?\ghts1 p]haps look+ into u to see if we are 'ready' yet4 ,:5 ,i seem to s5se ^! p[]ful ?\ghts ab\t me ,i try to feel humble & wor%ipful4 ,i hope 9 t way "o ( !m w see fit to reveal himself to me som$ay4 ,!y might1 ,ont said hopefully4 ,i w\ldn't m9d actually talk+ to "o ( !m myself4 ,b speak+ ( t1 we don't "k = sure t ^! inspirational ?\ghts ar5't actually our own4 ,!y ,,seem diff]5t1 b t may be because !y arise 9 "s "p ( our deep subconsci\s ?\ght processes4 ,i've be5 try+ to ext5d my s5se ( aw>5ess 9 ord] to rea* into my subconsci\s m9d & actually plumb x to its dep?s4 ,"o ?+ ,i've f\nd is t mo/ ( my ,,real ?9k+ goes on !re1 & only rises to ! surface ( consci\sness :5 x is complet$6 ,t l5ds probability to ! !ory t ,,all su* voices ( inspiration are m]ely my own subconsci\s m9d giv+ me ! end products ( c>efully ?\ght out tra9s ( reason+ x _h dream$ up4 ,i ?9k ,i'll try t l9e ( developm5t myself1 ,upt said4 ,i'd nev] ?\ght ( x4 ,maybe inspiration is only subconsci\s ?\ght ris+ to ! surface ( consci\sness4 ,maybe x is4 ,b if s1 ,i'll be v disappo9t$4 ,i'd hop$ sometime to be able to commune ) "s intellig5ce inf9itely sup]ior to m9e & really le>n ! true nature ( ?+s4 99 99 99 99 99 ,i s9c]ely hope ,i'm wrong ab\t x1 ,ont said4 ,i too w\ld l to believe t !re is m 9 reality ?an j u4 ,i wond] if o!r k9ds ( entities are possible8 ,i mean ?9k+ be+s ) diff]5t =ms1 diff]5t s5ses1 p]haps diff]5t types ( ?9k+4 ,x may be !y exi/ & we ar5't equipp$ to detect !m4 ,!y may be ar\nd u all ! "t1 aw>e ( u & our pu]ile ?\ghts1 b s sup]ior to u 9 e way t !y don't ?9k x wor? :ile ev5 to consid] our feeble cogitations4 ,i w\ldn't call ,,y\r cogitations feeble1 ,ont1 ,upt exclaim$ admir+ly4 ,t is a po9t ( relativity1 ,ont said1 some:at flatt]$4 ,x does seem 9 va91 ?\gh4 ,we sp5d our exi/5ce 9 solv+ ! problems ( reality1 & :5 we h solv$ !m we h no ne$ ( ! solution4 ,x gives u a feel+ ( satisfaction to ga9 ! !oretical basis ( reality f our po9t ( view4 ,b ,i = "o w\ld feel mu* bett] if we c\ld be ( s]vice to "s entity :o is unable to accompli% t himself1 b might be able to compreh5d x if we taught him4 ,all v noble1 ,upt said skeptically4 ,b ,i c't ev5 imag9e a ?9k+ creature diff]5t f u 9 any way4 ,t's :y x's s difficult1 ,ont said4 ,9 our own m9ds we t5d to become absolute r ?an relative 9 our conceptions4 ,"s o!r entity might1 = example1 ?9k mu* m sl[ly ?an we1 or ) incr$ible rapidity1 s t our ?\ghts w\ld be sluggi% to him1 or s swift t he w\ld nev] be able to grasp !m until long aft] we 7 gone4 ,also1 we t5d to ?9k t ?\ght z we exp]i5ce x1 is ! only possible type ( ?\ght4 ,9 reality !re may be o!rs4 ,diff]5t m5tal pr9ciples4 ,diff]5t mat]ial /ructure4 ,p]haps concepts outside our ability to grasp1 :ile ours might be outside ! ability ( su* creatures to grasp also4 ,i don't believe ,i grasp :at y're try+ to say1 ,upt hesitat$4 ,well1 put x ?is way1 ,ont said pati5tly4 ,all ?+s are relative4 ,:y n ?\ght8 ,x might be possible to h two ?9k+ m9ds :i* are relatively non-?9k+4 ,ea*1 f ,,e /&>d ( ! o!r1 be+ totally ?\ghtless & )\t intellig5ce or m9d4 ,n[ y're go+ too f>1 ,upt said4 ,?\ght is ?\ght1 ,i ?9k1 &--x's real4 ,if any o!r entity ?9ks1 its ?9k+ mu/ be real too4 ,( c\rse1 ,ont murmur$4 ,y miss ! po9t entirely4 ,if f e possible angle1 "s entity1 to ,,y1 c't ?9k & doesn't1 x is non-?9k+ & un9tellig5t4 ,"r8 99 99 99 99 99 ,gordon & ,h>old paus$ at ! edge ( ! g>d54 ,nice crop ( vegetables y h !re1 ,gordon1 ,h>old said appreciatively4 ,?anks1 ,gordon said4 ,say1 w\ldn't y\r wife l "s fre% vegetables8 ,)\t wait+ = an answ] he /epp$ back into ! g>d51 tak+ a knife f 8 pocket4 ,^! are nice n[1 he said1 b5d+ ov] & cutt+4 ,won't be mu* long] ?\gh4 ,br[n spots develop+ already4 ,i'll scrape (f ! br[n /uff = y1 b tell y\r wife to cook !m "r away4 ,9 a c\ple ( days !y'll spoil4 99 99 99 99 99 ,upt6 ,ont exclaim$1 exasp]at$4 ,:y don't y answ] me1 ,upt8 ,upt6 ,:]e are y1 ,upt8 ,:y don't y answ]8 99 99 99 99 99 ,!re y are1 ,gordon said1 smil+1 z he h&$ ,h>old ! head ( caulifl[]4 ,?anks1 ,h>old said1 accept+ ! :ite1 fre% head1 & balanc+ x 9 8 palm4 ,! two m5 cont9u$ up ! walk to ! h\se4 ,z ,i 0 say+1 ,gordon took up _! conv]sation1 :5 m5 get to ,m>s1 if !y ar5't c>eful !y may de/roy a civilization1 or ev5 ?\s&s ( intellig5t be+s1 )\t kn[+ x4444 ,,! ,,end ,transcrib]'s ,note3 ,?is etext 0 produc$ f ,amaz+ ,/ories ,decemb] #aidh4 ,ext5sive rese>* did n uncov] any evid5ce t ! ,u4,s4 copyright on ?is publication 0 r5ew$4 ,m9or spell+ & typographical errors h be5 correct$ )\t note4