,illustration3 ,cover art ,transcriber's note3 the various sections of this book had varying page headers4 ,those headers have been collected at the start of each section as introductory paragraphs4 ,,the ,,wisdom ,,of ,,the ,,east ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ptah-,,hotep ,,and ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ke',,gemni3 ,,the ,,oldest ,,books ,,in ,,the ,,world4 ,,translated ,,from ,,the ,,egyptian ,,with ,,an ,,introduction ,,and ,,appendix ,,by ,,battiscombe ,g4 ,,gunn ,,london ,,john ,,murray1 ,,albemarle ,,street #aijf ,,to ,,my ,,mother ,,vii4,,nov4,,mcmiv ,,contents ,page ,,introduction 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #aa ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ptah-,,hotep 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #da ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ke',,gemni 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #fb ,,appendix ,,note ,,to ,,appendix 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #fe ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,amenemh',,et 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #fg ,,explanation ,,of ,,names 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #gb ,,bibliography 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 #gc #aj ,,editorial ,,note ,the object of the editors of this series is a very definite one4 ,they desire above all things that1 in their humble way1 these books shall be the ambassadors of good-will and understanding between ,east and ,west1 the old world of ,thought1 and the new of ,action4 ,in this endeavour1 and in their own sphere1 they are but followers of the highest example in the land4 ,they are confident that a deeper knowledge of the great ideals and lofty philosophy of ,oriental thought may help to a revival of that true spirit of ,charity which neither despises nor fears the nations of another creed and colour4 ,finally1 in thanking press and public for the very cordial reception given to the ,wisdom of the ,east series1 they wish to state that no pains have been spared to secure the best specialists for the treatment of the various subjects at hand4 ,l4 ,,cranmer-,,byng4 ,s4 ,a4 ,,kapadia4 #d1 ,,harcourt ,,buildings1 ,,inner ,,temple1 ,,london4 #aa ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ptah-,,hotep ,,introduction ,memorials of the ,past--,the ,land of ,darkness--,the ,time of ,ptah-,hotep--,concerning the ,book--,the ,treatise of ,ke',gemni--,date of the ,manuscript--,an ,egyptian ,chesterfield--,who was ,ptah-,hotep8--,his ,teaching--,views on ,women--,the ,gods of ,egypt--,previous ,translations--,the ,oldest ,book ,known ,is there anything whereof it may be said1 ,see1 this is new6 ,it hath been already of old time1 ,which was before us4 ,there is no remembrance of former things2 ,neither shall there be any remembrance ,of things that are to come ,with those that shall come after4 ,in these days1 when all things and memories of the past are at length become not only subservient to1 but submerged by1 the matters and needs of the immediate present1 those paths of knowledge that lead into regions seemingly remote from such needs are somewhat discredited2 and the aims of those that follow them whither they lead are regarded as quite out of touch with the real interests of life4 ,very greatly is this so with archaeology1 and the study of ancient and curious tongues1 and searchings into old thoughts on high and ever-insistent questions2 a public which has hardly time to #ab read more than its daily newspaper and its weekly novel has denounced--almost dismissed--them1 with many other noble and wonderful things1 as 'unpractical1' whatever that vague and hollow word may mean4 ,as to those matters which lie very far back1 concerning the lands of several thousand years ago1 it is very generally held that they are the proper and peculiar province of specialists1 dry-as-dusts1 and persons with an irreducible minimum of human nature4 ,it is thought that knowledge concerning them1 not the blank ignorance regarding them that almost everywhere obtains1 is a thing of which to be rather ashamed1 a detrimental possession2 in a word1 that the subject is not only unprofitable 7a grave offence71 but also uninteresting1 and therefore contemptible4 ,this is a true estimate of general opinion1 although there are those who will1 for their own sakes1 gainsay it4 ,when1 therefore1 ,i state that one of the writings herein translated has an age of nearly six thousand years1 and that another is but five hundred years younger1 it is likely that many will find this sufficient reason against further perusal1 deeming it impossible that such things can possess attraction for one not an enthusiast for them4 ,yet so few are the voices across so great a span of years that those among them having anything to tell us should be welcome exceedingly2 whereas1 for the most part1 they have cried in the #ac wilderness of neglect hitherto1 or fallen on ears filled with the clamour of more instant things4 ,i could show1 if this were a fitting place1 that ,archaeology is not at all divorced from life1 nor even devoid of emotion as subtle and strange1 as swift and moving1 as that experienced by those who love and follow ,art4 ,she1 ,archaeology1 is1 for those who know her1 full of such emotion2 garbed in an imperishable glamour1 she is raised far above the turmoil of the present on the wings of ,imagination4 ,her eyes are sombre with the memory of the wisdom driven from her scattered sanctuaries2 and at her lips wonderful things strive for utterance4 ,in her are gathered together the longings and the laughter1 the fears and failures1 the sins and splendours and achievements of innumerable generations of men2 and by her we are shown all the elemental and terrible passions of the unchanging soul of man1 to which all cultures and philosophies are but garments to hide its nakedness2 and thus in her1 as in ,art1 some of us may realise ourselves4 ,withal she is heavy-hearted1 making continual lamentation for a glory that has withered and old hopes without fulfilment2 and all her habitations are laid waste4 ,as for the true lover of all old and forgotten things1 it may justly be said of him1 as of the poet1 ,nascitur1 non fit4 ,for the dreams and the wonder are with him from the beginning2 and in early childhood1 knowing as yet hardly #ad the names of ancient peoples1 he is conscious of1 and yearns instinctively toward1 an immense and ever-receding past4 ,with the one1 as with the other1 the unaccountable passion is so knitted into his soul that it will never1 among a thousand distractions and adverse influences1 entirely forsake him2 nor can such an one by willing cause it to come or to depart4 ,he will live much in imagination1 therein treading fair places now enwrapped in their inevitable shroud of wind-blown sand2 building anew temples whose stones hardly remain one upon the other1 consecrate to gods dead as their multitudes of worshippers2 holding converse with the sages who1 with all their lore1 could not escape the ultimate oblivion3 a spectator of splendid pageants1 a ministrant at strange rites1 a witness to vast tragedies1 he also has admittance to the magical kingdom1 to which is added the freedom of the city of ,remembrance4 ,his care will be to construct1 patiently and with much labour1 a picture 7which is often less than an outline7 of the conditions of the humanity that has been2 and he neither rejects nor despises any relic1 however trivial or unlovely1 that will help him1 in its degree1 to understand better that humanity or to bridge the wide chasms of his ignorance4 ,moreover1 great age hallows all things1 even the most mean1 investing them with a certain sanctity2 and the little sandal of a nameless #ae child1 or the rude amulet placed long ago with weeping on the still bosom of a friend1 will move his heart as strongly by its appeal as the proud and enduring monument of a great conqueror insatiable of praise4 ,at times1 moving among the tokens of a period that the ravenous years dare not wholly efface in passing1 he hears1 calling faintly as from afar1 innumerable voices--the voices of those who1 stretching forth in ,sheol eager hands toward ,life1 greatly desire that some memorial of them1 be it but a name1 may survive in the world of men4444 ,ancient ,egypt fares perhaps better than other countries of antiquity at the hands of the 'general reader1' and sometimes obtains a hearing when they do not1 by reason of its intimate contact at certain periods with the nation that has brought us the ,old ,testament4 ,because of this the report of it has been with us constantly1 and it has nearly become a symbol in religion4 ,the stories of ,moses and the magicians1 and of the dealings of ,abraham and ,joseph with ,pharaoh1 together with the rude woodcuts of ,egyptian taskmasters and cupbearers in family ,bibles1 have invested the venerable land with a dreamy mystery2 while every one has heard of ',rameses1 the ,pharaoh of the ,oppression1' and ',meneptah1 the ,pharaoh of the ,exodus4' ,and it is possible that for the sake of such #af association1 if not for his own sake1 ,ptah-hotep will be considered worthy of notice4 ,but in spite of the fact that the ,ancient ,egyptians enjoy rather more popularity than their contemporaries1 it is evident that the books which they wrote are closed books to those who have not the glamour of vanished peoples1 and the fascination of mighty cities now made desolate1 strong upon them4 ,yet in the heterogeneous and pitiful flotsam that reluctant seas have washed to us piecemeal from a remote past1 there are1 as will be shown later1 many things which1 although proceeding from a culture and modes of thought as far removed from our own as they may well be1#a are worth the reading1 which do not require any special knowledge for their understanding2 and of these are the translations in this book4 ,the following pages1 which1 although addressed to the 'general reader1' may yet be of some assistance to those especially interested in ,egypt1 give1 among other matters1 the place of the ,instructions of ,ptah-hotep and ,ke'gemni in the 'literature' of ,egypt2 their place--their #ag unique place--in the literature of the world2 their value historically2 a description of the document in which they were found2 what is known of their authors2 a discussion of their contents4 ,the land of which the ,father of ,history declared that no other country held so many wonders1 has bequeathed us1 by various channels1 the rumour and remnant of a strange knowledge4 ,she has devised us enigmas insoluble1 and rendered up to us signs and messages whose meaning is dark for all time4 ,and she has left a religion1 'veiled in allegory and illustrated by symbol1' as fascinating as impenetrable for those who approach it4 ,for into our hands the keys of these things have not been delivered2 wherefore much study of them is a weariness to the flesh1 and of the hazarding of interpretations there is no end4 ,but apart from the mazes of mythology1 the broken ways of history and the empty letter of a dead faith1 there are1 as is known to some1 and as this little book professes to show1 many documents which are antique1 but not antiquated1 possessing interest above the purely archaeological--the interest called human4 ,of these are the tales which recall1 in incident as in style1 those of the immortal collection1 full of the whole glamour of the ,east1 the ,thousand ,nights and a ,night4 #ah ,such are the love-songs1 full of the burning utterance of desire2 the pathetic and even bitter dirges1 whose singers have seen all the works that are done under the sun1 and found all to be vanity and vexation of spirit4 ,and such also are the didactic poems for the instruction of youth1 which--in poetic phrase and in great detail--inculcate1 among other things1 the practice of right conduct as the price of happiness2 a courtesy hardly less considerate than our own2 and a charity which1 when certain inevitable shortcomings are allowed for1 bears comparison with almost any later system4 ,out of these there are many that may properly claim a place in a series bearing the seal of the ,wisdom of the ,east1 though they belong only to the more objective and 'practical' side of that ,wisdom4 ,but1 as touching the books here translated--the ,instructions of ,ptah-hotep and of ,ke'gemni--they possess1 apart from the curious nature of their contents1 a feature of the greatest interest1 and an adequate claim on the notice of all persons interested in literature and its history4 ,for if the datings and ascriptions in them be accepted as trustworthy 7there is no reason why they should not be so accepted71 they were composed about four thousand years before ,christ1 and three thousand five hundred and fifty years before ,christ1 respectively4 ,and the significance of those remote dates is1 that they are the oldest #ai books in the world1 the earliest extant specimens of the literary art4 ,they stand on the extreme horizon of all that ocean of paper and ink that has become to us as an atmosphere1 a fifth element1 an essential of life4 ,books of many kinds had of course been written for centuries before ,ptah-hotep of ,memphis summarised1 for the benefit of future generations1 the leading principles of morality current in his day2 even before the ,vizier1 five hundred years earlier1 gave to his children the scroll which they prized above all things on earth2#b but those have perished and these remain4 ,there are lists of titles which have a large sound1 and prayers to the ,gods for all good things1 on the tombs and monuments of kings and magnates long before the time of ,ke'gemni2 but those are not books in any sense of that word4 ,even the long1 strange chants and spells engraven in the ,royal ,pyramids over against ,memphis are later than the time of ,ptah-hotep1 and cannot be called books in their present form1 although some of them apparently originated before the ,first ,dynasty4#c ,nor do the oldest books of any other country approach these two in antiquity4 ,to draw #bj comparisons between them let us1 in imagination1 place ourselves at the period at which ,ptah-hotep lived1 that is1 about ,b4,c4 #ceej1 'under ,king ,issi1 living for ever1' and take a glance at futurity4 ,the ,babylonians are doubtless exercising their literary talents2 but they will leave nothing worthy the name of book to the far posterity of fifty-four centuries hence4 ,thirteen centuries shall pass before ,hammurabi1 ,king of ,babylon1 drafts the code of laws that will be found at that time4 ,only after two thousand years shall ,moses write on the origin of things1 and the ,vedas be arranged in their present form4 ,it will be two-and-a-half thousand years before the ,great ,king of ,jerusalem will set in order many proverbs and write books so much resembling1 in form and style1 that of ,ptah-hotep2#d before the source and summit of ,european literature will write his world epics4 ,for the space of years between ,solomon and ourselves1 great though it seem1 is not so great as that between ,solomon and ,ptah-hotep4 ,the number of extant texts of the class to which the subjoined immediately belong is not large in proportion to the rest of ,egyptian ,,mss41 #ba but they seem to be representative of the class1 being diverse in date and subject1 but similar in form4 ,there is great uniformity in the arrangement of most of them1 in the following respects4 ,they have as title the word ',instruction' 7seb'yet71 and are written by a father for the advantage of his son2 they are very poetic in their arrangement of words and phrases1 and are usually divided into short sections or paragraphs by the use of red ink for the first sentence of each4 ,such is the ,instruction of ,ptah-hotep on morality 7the finest of its class72 the ,instruction of ,king ,amenemh'et on the hollowness of friendship and other matters2 the ,instruction of ,deu'of1 the son of ,kherti1 on the excellence of the literary life2 and others4 ,in many respects and in many details they greatly resemble the didactic works of the ,old ,testament and ,apocrypha4 ,these ',instructions' were held in high esteem as text-books and writing exercises in schools--a circumstance to which we owe the preservation of many of them4 ,for a considerable number of important and interesting poems1 letters1 and narratives are only known to us from school exercise-books4 ,the pupil at the ',chamber of ,instruction' wrote out about three pages of these each day1 as a means of improving his writing1 as a model of style in composition1 and for purposes of edification4 ,these exercises #bb abound in errors of spelling and grammar1 having sometimes the master's corrections elegantly written above in red4 ,as may be imagined1 a schoolboy's scrawl over three thousand years old is no easy thing to translate2 but faute de mieux the ,egyptologist welcomes any version1 even the most barbarous4 ,fortunately1 the ,,ms4 from which these translations come is not of this kind2 a detailed description of it may interest some of my readers4 ,the ,prisse ,papyrus1 which is well known by name and a few extracts to all persons conversant with ,egyptian matters1 was acquired in ,egypt by ,m4 ,prisse d',avennes1 a ,french archaeologist of distinction1 and published by him in #ahdg4e ,the exact place of its discovery is unknown4 ,m4 ,prisse is said to have bought it of one of the fellahn whom he employed to make excavations at the burial-ground of ,thebes4 ,this man pretended that he had no knowledge of its finding1 as he was trying to sell it for a friend4 ,it is believed that it was actually taken by the ,arab from the tomb of one of the ,kings ',entef2#f but this is not certain4 ,if it were1 it would perhaps enable us to fix a terminus ad que1 for the writing of this copy1 although tombs often contain objects of later date4 ,the papyrus was presented in about #ahdg1 by ,m4 ,prisse1 to the #bc ,bibliotheque ,nationale 7in those days the ,bibliotheque ,royale7 at ,paris1 where it still is1 divided and glazed in the usual manner4 ,spread out flat1 it measures about #bc ft4 #g in41 with an average height of #e #g_/h in41 which is about the usual height of papyri of the ,eleventh and ,twelfth ,dynasties4 ,it contains at present eighteen pages of heavy and bold black and red writing1 in the so-called hieratic character4 ,at first sight it appears to be in perfect preservation1 being entirely free from the cracks and decay which mar many fine manuscripts of far later date2 but an examination of the contents shows that an unknown quantity has been torn off from the commencement4 ,originally the roll contained at least two books1 of which we have the latter part of one and the whole of the other4 ,between these there is a blank space of some #ec in4 ,the characters are clearly and carefully made1 but are not always correct1 as though the copyist had a badly written or very cursive copy before him1 and was not always sure of his spelling4 ,the first of these books1 of which only the last two pages remain to us1 is a treatise on deportment1 and is here called the ,instruction of ,ke'gemni4 ,it has always been attributed to this person since its discovery1 but examination of as much of the book as exists will show that it is not said to have been written by him4 ,because #bd his is the only name mentioned1 ,egyptologists have concluded that he is the author4 ,the unnamed ,vizier1 who called his children to him1 can hardly be ,ke'gemni1 who was not raised to the rank of ,vizier and ,governor of a city until afterwards4 ,ke'gemni may well have been a son of the author4 ,this is not of material importance1 however1 as the date of writing is given as the end of the reign of ,heuni1 the last ,king of the ,third ,dynasty1 who died about #ciih ,b4,c4 ,this book1 then1 which argues a society of some refinement1 is1 so far as it goes1 the oldest in the world4 ,after a long stretch of blank papyrus1 from which a third book has perhaps been erased1 we come upon the ,instruction of ,ptah-hotep in its entirety1 divided into sections by red writing1 as aforesaid4#g ,in this1 also1 we get a definite date1 for we learn in the opening lines that its author 7or compiler7 lived in the reign of ,king ,issi4 ,now ,issi was the last ruler but one of the ,fifth ,dynasty1 and ruled forty-four years1 from about #cehj to #cecf ,b4,c4 ,thus we may take about #ceej as the period of ,ptah-hotep4 ,of these two kings there is hardly anything to say4 ,heuni is only known to us by mention of his name2 we have no record of any act of his4 #be ,of ,issi the only exploit that remains is this3 that he sent his ,treasurer1 ,be'wrded1 to ,somaliland#h to obtain for him a certain kind of dwarf2 this the ,treasurer brought back1 and received much reward therefor4 ,that is all that is left of the reigns of two kings1 who ruled long1 who perhaps ruled greatly and wisely1 having just cause to hope that their fame and the report of their good deeds might never pass away4 ,such is the fate of kings4 ,the copy of these ,instructions that we have1 the only complete copy1#i is far later than the later of these dates4 ,an examination of the writing shows that it is not earlier than the ,eleventh ,dynasty1 and is probably of the ,twelfth4#aj ,more than this cannot be said2 where it was written1 by whom1 and when1 are not stated1 as they are in many cases4 ,the writing lacks the fine regularity of that of the professional scribes of the ,twelfth ,dynasty1 and has many points of divergence therefrom2 but the papyrus is assigned by the best judges to this period4 ,this gives it an antiquity of about four thousand five hundred years2 and it looks good to last as long again1 if only it be not examined over-much nor brought out into the light too often4 #bf ,it is as fresh and readable as in the year after it was written4 ,will the books of our time last one-tenth so long8 ,it is not without a feeling of awe1 even of sadness1 that one with any sense of the wonder of things gazes for the first time on the old book1 and thinks of all it has survived4 ,so many empires have arisen and gone down since those words were penned1 so many great and terrible things have been4 ,and we are fortunate indeed in having such a book as this of ,ptah-hotep for the most ancient complete literary work extant4 ,for not by any magical texts1 or hymns and prayers1 should we be so well shown the conditions of that early time2 but our moralist1 by advancing counsels of perfection for every contingency1 has left us a faithful record of his age4 ,the veil of five-and-a-half thousand years is rent1 and we are met with a vivid and a fascinating picture of the domestic and social life of the ',old ,kingdom4' ,we read of the wife1 who must be treated kindly at all costs2 the genial generosity of the rich man1 and the scowling boor1 a thorn in the side of his friends and relations1 the laughing-stock of all men2 the unquenchable talkers of every station in life1 who argue high1 who argue low1 who also argue round about them1 as common as now in the ,east1 and the trusted councillor1 weighing every word2 the obstinate ignoramus who sees #bg everything inverted1 listening open-mouthed to the disjointed gossip of those near him1 and the scholar1 conversing freely with learned and unlearned alike1 recognising that1 measured against the infinite possibilities of knowledge and skill1 we are all much of the same stature2 the master of the estate or province1 treated with infinite respect by his subordinates in rank and wealth1 and the paid servants that are never satisfied1 who leave after presents have been made them2 the hard-working clerk who casts accounts all day1 and the tradesmen who will perhaps give you credit when money is dear1 if you have previously made friends of them2 the well-bred diner-out1 lightly passing on his favourite dish1 contenting himself with plain fare1 and the gourmand who visits his friends at meal-times1 departing only when the larder is entirely exhausted4 ,not only do we find such characters as these in ,ptah-hotep's hand-book1 but interesting scenes are brought near to us by the writing-reed of that primaeval ,chesterfield4 ,we find ourselves taking supper at the table of a great man4 ,his subordinates sit round1 scarcely daring to raise their eyes from their food1 not speaking to their host until spoken to4 ,he serves the food that is before him according to his liking for each guest2 and the less favoured find solace in the reflection that even the distribution of food is #bh according to ,providence4 ,we pass on4 ,now we are in the hall of council with the other overseers and officials of the province1 and our overlord presiding4 ,we notice with astonishment the extreme solemnity and strict observance of custom and precedence in this archaic period4 ,many of those who have met report on the matters under their charge1 and others debate on them4 ,the one now speaking is discussing a trade about which he knows nothing1 and an expert rises and makes very short work of his opponent's arguments4 ,now we are among some people dividing up property4 ,one of them has tried1 of course1 to bully his friends into giving him more than his due share1 and1 having failed1 leaves the house in a rage4 ,he will regret it later4 ,and so on4 ,nothing definite is known concerning these two nobles beyond what is said of them in their works4 ,a fine tomb of a certain ,ke'gemni exists at ,memphis2 his titles1 so far as can be ascertained1#aa are3 ,judge of the ,high ,court3 ,governor of the ,land unto its ,limit1 ,south and ,north3 ,director of every ,command4 ,he has sometimes been supposed to be identical with our ,ke'gemni2 #bi but ,i am assured by those most competent to judge that this tomb cannot be earlier than the ,fifth ,dynasty 7a good three hundred years from the date assigned to the moralist71 so that the theory that they are one person may be dismissed as highly improbable4 ,no other person of the name is known4 ,the position is much the same with ,ptah-hotep4 ,there are near ,memphis the tombs of several nobles of this name1 of whom two lived in the reign of ,issi2 and in this case1 again1 it has been assumed that one#ab of these two must be the writer of the ,instruction4 ,but in neither instance do the titles coincide with or include those assigned to him4 ,the highest title which he bears1 ,eldest ,son of the ,king1 does not anywhere appear in these tombs4 ,it is true that one of these contemporaries was ,hereditary ,chief2 but we know that ,ptah-hotep was a common name at this time1 and in the absence of more certain proof it will be well to abstain from the identification of like names upon insufficient grounds4 ,thus it is only by the chance discovery of this #cj scroll that these two princes of old time1 whose bodies are blown about the desert dust these many centuries1 are secured from utter oblivion2 men 'such as did bear rule in their kingdoms1 men renowned for their power1 giving counsel by their understanding1 and declaring prophecies3 ,leaders of the people by their counsels1 and by their knowledge of learning meet for the people1 wise and eloquent in their instructions4' ,and against such as these1 that from remote years 'have left a name behind them1 that their praises might be reported1' how many are there 'which have no memorial2 who are perished1 as though they had never been2 and are become as though they had never been born2 and their children after them4'#ac ,i had intended to make a detailed analysis of the moral sense of ,ptah-hotep and ,ke'gemni1 but it appears unnecessary2 since they give their advice so clearly and simply1 they may safely be left to speak for themselves4 ,but as especially noteworthy ,i would point to the gracious tolerance of ignorance enjoined in #a 7,ptah-hotep71 and the fine reason given for that injunction1 in contrast with the scorn expressed for the obstinate fool 7,ph4 #dj72 the care due to a wife 7,ph4 #ba71 which is in signal contrast to the custom of other ,eastern nations in this #ca respect2#ad the great stress laid on filial duties 7,ph4 #ch1 #ci1 #da1 #db1 #dc72 the enthusiasm for obedience1 expressed in a jargon of puns 7,ph4 #ch71 which1 once the high-watermark of style among ,egyptian literati1 has long since lost its savour2 the interesting matter on manners at table 7,kg4 #b1 #c1 ,ph4 #g1 #i71 in society 7,kg4 #d1 ,ph4 #ad1 #ah1 #bj1 #cd71 and in official positions 7,ph4 #e1 #h1 #ac1 #ae1 #af1 #ag1 #bd1 #bh74 ,a rough classification including many sections is here given3 ,duties toward superiors 7,ph4 #b1 #g1 #h1 #aj1 #af1 #bg1 #ca74 ,duties toward equals 7#c1 #f1 #ad1 #ah1 #bj1 #bf1 #bi1 #cc1 #ce1 #cg74 ,duties toward inferiors 7#a1 #d1 #e1 #af1 #ag1 #bb74 ,the whole teaching resolves into the maxim1 ,be good1 and you will be happy2 not at all in the sense that virtue is its own reward--,i do not think that that would have seemed an adequate return to ,ptah-hotep--but in the sense of material welfare rewarding1 as a matter of course1 an honourable life4 ,following his reasoning1 if a man be obedient as a son1 punctilious as a servant1 generous and gentle as a master1 and courteous as a friend1 then all good things shall fall to him1 he shall reach a green old age honoured by the ,king1 and his memory shall be long in the land4 ,this theory1 which is not #cb found satisfactory in our day1 is insisted on by most of the ancient moralists1 who appear to regard it1 not as a substitute for conscience1 but rather as a raison d'tre or justification thereof4 ,yet1 centuries before a ,king of ,israel had seen all things that are1 and found them vanity1 a ,king of ,egypt had left it on record that he had done all good things for his subjects1 and that 'there was no satisfaction therein4' ,it has been said with some truth of codes of morals and laws that what is omitted is almost as important as what is included4 ,but we must not carry this too far2 we should be foolish indeed did we assert that those things omitted from such a code as ,ptah-hotep's were not practised or not held to be important in his day4 ,for example1 he 'knows nothing'--as a ,higher ,critic would say--of kindness to animals2 but we know from many things that the ,egyptians treated animals kindly and made much of them as pets4 ,in the very tomb of that ,ptah-hotep mentioned above1#ae who may be our author1 is depicted the bringing of three dogs and a tame monkey to him while he is dressing2 possibly so that he may feed them himself4 ,and this kindly feeling obtained throughout ,egyptian history4 ,they treated animals more as 'dumb friends' in those days than might have been #cc a priori expected1 and more1 perhaps1 than any other nation of antiquity4 ,again1 he 'knows nothing' of duties to the mother1 although he is so insistent on duties to the father2 but the high position of women and their matriarchal privileges oppose any deduction that ,egyptian manners were somewhat to seek in this direction4 ,ke'gemni says of the unsociable man that he is a grief to his mother1 and another moralist of uncertain date 7perhaps ,twelfth ,dynasty1 about ,b4,c4 #bgjj71 named ',eney1 is explicit on this matter4 ,he says to his son1 ',i gave thee thy mother1 she that bore thee with much suffering4444 ,she placed thee at the ,chamber of ,instruction for the sake of thine instruction in books2 she was constant to thee daily1 having loaves and beer in her house4 ,when thou art grown1 and hast taken to thee a wife1 being master in thy house1 cast thine eyes on the one that gave thee birth and provided thee with all good things1 as did thy mother4 ,let her not reproach thee1 lest she lift up her hands to the ,god1 and ,he hear her prayer4' ,and1 most remarkable of all omissions1 there is nothing said as to duties to the ,gods4 ,in ,egypt1 whose ,gods are beyond counting1 where almost everybody was a priest1 ,ptah-hotep--himself a ',holy ,father' and ',beloved of the ,god'--has no word to say on religious obligations1 devoting his work entirely to the principles of charity and duty to one's neighbour4 ,it is #cd seemingly sufficient to him that one do the right in this world1 without thinking overmuch about the other4 ,this is the more curious in that other writers of the same class have many injunctions regarding worship and sacrifice2 and so complete is his reserve touching this matter1 so important in the eyes of other ,egyptians1 that it is easy to believe that it was intentional4 ,we may even discern in him a protagonist of the modern ',ethical ,school1' whose adherents may be interested to find their views implicitly held so long ago4 ,notwithstanding this singularity1 he is by no means unmindful of ,deity4 ,we notice that he has occasion to speak several times of 'the ,god'#af in ,his relation to humanity and human affairs4 ,if we collect these references to the ,god1 we shall find that the following qualities are attributed to ,him4 ,he rewards diligence 7#i1 #aj7 and punishes sin 7#f1 #aj2 also ,kg4 #e72 ,he is the giver of good things 7,ph4 #bb1 #cj1 #dc71 dispenses fate and preordains events 7#f1 #g1 #i1 #bf71 loves ,his creation 7#bf71 observes men's actions 7#aj71 desires them to be fruitful and multiply 7#ab74 ,all this is in complete accord with the belief of other religions--including ,christianity--regarding the ,godhead4 ,and here we touch another pleasing characteristic of this most ancient of books--its catholic spirit and disregard of those #ce mythological and esoteric riddles that most ,egyptian works propound to us continually4 ,it will be noticed that 'the ,god' is not anywhere mentioned by name4 ,osiris 7#e7 and ,horus 7#da7 are alluded to1 but only historically1 in respect of their rule upon earth1 not as present powers4 ,the reason is this1 that at that time the ,gods1 even the great ,gods1 were only local1 that is to say1 their worship was confined to certain towns or districts 7'nomes'71 and beyond the boundaries of these their names lost that power and influence which they exerted in their peculiar provinces4 ,a book1 therefore1 which spoke of one ,god only--by name--would have been found much limited as to popularity and use4 ,hence the old moralists and didactic writers1 whatever ,god they might themselves worship1 forebore to mention ,him1 since by many readers ,he would not be recognised as paramount2 they wrote instead1 ',the ,god1' that is1 'the ,god of your allegiance1 whoever ,he may be4' ,thus1 were the reader a native of ,heliopolis1 his ,god would be ,atmu1 the ,setting ,sun2 of ,memphis1 ,ptah1 the ,revealer2 of ,hermopolis1 ,thoth1 ,master of ,divine ,words and ,chief of the ,eight4 ,it was for this reason that the unknown author of what is called the ',negative ,confession'#ag makes the deceased say1 ',i have not scorned the #cf ,god of my town4' ,and1 indeed1 so simply and purely does ,ptah-hotep speak of the ,god that the modern reader can1 without the least degradation of his ideals1 consider the author as referring to the ,deity of monotheism1 and if he be of ,christendom1 read ,god2 if of ,islam1 read ,allah2 if of ,jewry1 ,jehovah4#ah ,no doubt the gulf fixed between teaching and practice was as great then as now4 ,we have the teaching1 we know that the teaching was current all over ,egypt in various forms1 but of the practice we know very little4 ,human nature being much the same at all times and places1 we must beware of measuring the one by the other1 the unknown by the known1 and must be content to take such counsels as showing the ,egyptian-- ,not what he was1 but what he should have been4 ,it is established that they were a kindly1 peace-loving people1 genial and courtly2 but whether law-abiding is another matter4 ,we know nothing about their laws1 but we know #cg that the law-courts were busy1 and that legal officials were numerous2 and we know1 further1 that their duplicity and lack of straightforwardness were proverbial among the ,greeks and ,romans1 and persists to this day4 ,i have noted above the resemblance of the ,egyptian ,instructions to the ,jewish didactic books 7,proverbs and ,ecclesiastes in the ,old ,testament1 ,wisdom of ,solomon and ,ecclesiasticus in the ,apocrypha72 this will be obvious to all readers4 ,compare1 e4g41 the opening of ,ptah-hotep 7,b7 with the opening of ,proverbs4 ,it is not necessary to point out all the parallels in detail4 ,i come1 lastly1 to speak of other translations4#ai ,the first into any language was that of the ,rev4 ,d4 ,i4 ,heath1 ,vicar of ,brading1 ,isle of ,wight4 ,this version1 which first appeared in #ahef1 was ruined by the translator's theory that the ,prisse ,papyrus contained references to the ,exodus1 and was written by the ',shepherd-,king1' ,aphobis4 ,how he obtained that name from ,ptah-hotep1 how he read the ,exodus into his book1 or how he got three-fourths of his translation1 it is not possible to say4 ,written in a style which is in itself a matter for decipherment1 it is full of absurdities and gratuitous mistakes1 and #ch is entirely worthless4 ,it is one more instance of the lamentable results that arise when a person with a preconceived ,biblical theory comes into contact with ,egyptian records4 ,in the following year ,m4 ,chabas did part of the papyrus into ,french1 and1 as might be expected of an ,egyptologist of such attainments1 his version was infinitely more accurate than the foregoing4 ,in #ahfi ,herr ,lauth made a translation--also partial--into ,latin1 and in #ahhd2 ,m4 ,philippe ,virey published a careful study and complete translation of both books4 ,his rendering#bj was subsequently translated into ,english and published 7with some alterations7 in ,records of the ,past1 #ahij1 and has remained the only complete translation in ,english4 ,it has been taken bodily 7even the footnotes7 into ,myer's ,oldest ,books in the ,world1 and has been put into charming verse by ,canon ,rawnsley in his ,notes for the ,nile4 ,thus it appears to be1 in a sense1 the standard version4 ,nevertheless1 it leaves very much to be desired in point of accuracy1 although the general sense of each section is usually caught4 ,of later years ,mr4 ,griffith has done important work on this text1 and ,i am indebted to his translations for several readings4 ,as regards the version here offered1 ,i will only say that it has been done with considerable care1 #ci without prejudice1 and1 it is thought1 in accordance with scientific methods of translation2 and that it has been compared with all previous renderings1 and will be found to be1 on the whole1 the most accurate that has yet appeared4 ,and now ,i will leave ,ptah-hotep to speak for himself4 ,it may be thought that he has been introduced at too great length2 but ,i would point out that his book has been strangely overlooked by the educated public hitherto1 although it would be difficult to over-estimate its importance1 to literature as the oldest complete book known1 to ethics and theology as the earliest expression of the mystery we name ,conscience1 and to lovers of antiquity as one of the most instructive and touching relics of a people and a power that once were great and are now brought to nothing4 ,by a happy chance the words of our sage have been justified1 in that he said1 ',no word that hath here been set down shall cease out of the land for ever4' ,would indeed that we had more of such books as this1 whereby we may a little lighten the darkness that lies behind the risings of a million suns2 and learn how little the human heart1 and the elements of human intercourse1 alter throughout the ages4 ,and what of the other writers of that time1 whose works and whose very names are entirely swept away8 ,to this there is no better answer made than in the lamentation made by the harper close upon five #dj thousand years ago1 which was written up in the tomb of ,king ',entef3 ,those that built them tombs1 he sang1 have now no resting-place4 ,lo6 what of their deeds8 ,i have heard the words of ,yemhotep and of ,hardedef1 whose sayings men repeat continually4 ,behold6 where are their abodes8 ,their walls are over-thrown1 and their places are not1 even as though they had not been4' ,the burden of ,egypt4 ,,battiscombe ,g4 ,,gunn4 #c1 ,,park ,,hill ,,road1 ,,croydon4 #a ,much ingenuity has been expended to show that ,egyptian manners and customs1 books1 and other things1 were much the same as our own1 as though the supposed similarity reflected any credit either on them or on us4 ,except in customs which are common to all times and places1 as drinking beer1 writing love-letters1 making wills1 going to school1 and other things antecedently probable1 the ,egyptian life can show very few parallels to the life of to-day4 #b ,the monuments leave no doubt of this4 ,pen and ink were used in the ,first ,dynasty1 and speech had been reduced to visible signs before that4 #c ,about ,b4,c4 #aggj4 ,in all ,egyptian dates given in this book ,i follow ,professor ,petrie's chronology4 #d ,these are round figures1 of course1 and in the case of ,solomon and ,moses traditional dates4 ,modern criticism places ,genesis and ,proverbs much later than #aejj and #ajjj ,b4,c4 #e ,see ,appendix for the literature of this papyrus4 #f ,these were kings of the ,eleventh ,dynasty1 about #bihf ,b4,c4 #g ,in the translation these divisions are indicated1 for purposes of reference1 by numbers and letters1 which are not1 of course1 in the original4 ,so also in the ,instruction of ,amenemh'et 7,appendix74 #h ,pwenet3 the identification is not certain4 #i ,fragments of another are in the ,british ,museum4 #aj ,it has been thought to be as late as the ,seventeenth 7about #afjj ,b4,c471 but the balance of opinion favours the above-mentioned period4 #aa ,the inscriptions and sculptures from this tomb have not yet been published1 but a work dealing with it will shortly appear4 ,the above titles1 excepting the first1 are from ,lepsius1 ,denkmler aus gypten und thiopien1 ,abth4 ,,ii4 #dh1 ,berlin1 #ahdi-fh4 #ab ,called ,ptah-hotep ,i4 by ,egyptologists4 ,for a description of his tomb1 see ,mariette1 ,a41 ,les ,mastabas de l',ancien ,empire1 ,paris1 #ahhi1 ,d4 #fb4 ,for the other ,ptah-hotep under ,issi1 see ,quibell1 ,j4 ,e41 and ,griffith1 ,f4 ,l41 ,egyptian ,research ,account2 ,the ,ramesseum and the ,tomb of ,ptah-,hotep1 ,london1 #ahih4 ,also ,davies1 ,n4 de ,g41 and ,griffith1 ,f4 ,l41 ,egypt ,exploration ,fund2 ,the ,mastaba of ,ptahhetep and ,akhethetep at ,saqqara1 #b vols41 ,london1 #aijj1 #aija4 ,the little figure on the cover of this book is from this tomb4 #ac ,the ,wisdom of the ,son of ,sirach1 chap4 xliv4 #ad ,the ,egyptians were monogamists at this time1 and the wife enjoyed social equality with her husband4 #ae ,page #bi1 footnote4 #af ,nter4 #ag ,this is an arbitrary name not existing in the original4 ,it would be better named ',the ,declaration of ,innocence4' #ah ,it has been thought by many ,egyptologists that 'the ,god' mentioned in this and other texts is a nameless monotheistic abstraction transcending all named gods4 ,although this theory has the support of many great names1 ,i venture to say that the evidence for such an important doctrine is in the highest degree unsatisfactory4 #ai ,the books mentioned here are set forth in detail in the ,bibliography4 #bj ,only of ,ptah-hotep4 #da ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ptah-,,hotep ,the ,ethics of ,argument--,manners for ,guests--,from ,father to ,son--,a ,just ,judge--,the ,treatment of ,servants--,duties of the ,great--,the ,test of ,friendship--,the ,beauty of ,obedience--,one ,generation to ,another--,whom the ,king ,honoureth ,the ,instruction of the ,governor of his ,city1 the ,vizier1 ,ptah-hotep1 in the ,reign of the ,king of ,upper and ,lower ,egypt1 ,issi1 living for ever1 to the end of ,time4 ,a4 ,the ,governor of his ,city1 the ,vizier1 ,ptah-hotep1 he said3 ',o ,prince1 my ,lord1 the end of life is at hand2 old age descendeth upon me2 feebleness cometh1 and childishness is renewed4 ,he that is old lieth down in misery every day4 ,the eyes are small2 the ears are deaf4 ,energy is diminished1 the heart hath no rest4 ,the mouth is silent1 and he speaketh no word2 the heart stoppeth1 and he remembereth not yesterday4 ,the bones are painful throughout the body2 good turneth unto evil4 ,all taste departeth4 ,these things doeth old age for mankind1 being evil in all things4 ,the nose is stopped1 and he breatheth not for weakness 7871 whether standing or sitting4 ',command me1 thy servant1 therefore1 to make over my princely authority to my son4 ,let me speak unto him the words of them that hearken to the counsel of the men of old time2 those that #db hearkened unto the gods4 ,i pray thee1 let this thing be done1 that sin may be banished from among persons of understanding1 that thou may enlighten the lands4' ,said the ,majesty of this ,god3#a ',instruct him1 then1 in the words of old time2 may he be a wonder unto the children of princes1 that they may enter and hearken with him4 ,make straight all their hearts2 and discourse with him1 without causing weariness4' ,b4 ,here begin the proverbs of fair speech1 spoken by the ,hereditary ,chief1 the ,holy ,father1#b ,beloved of the ,god1 the ,eldest ,son of the ,king1 of his body1 the ,governor of his ,city1 the ,vezier1 ,ptah-hotep1 when instructing the ignorant in the knowledge of exactness in fair-speaking2 the glory of him that obeyeth1 the shame of him that transgresseth them4 ,he said unto his son3 #a4 ,be not proud because thou art learned2 but discourse with the ignorant man1 as with the sage4 ,for no limit can be set to skill1 neither is there any craftsman that possesseth full advantages4 ,fair speech is more rare than the emerald that is found by slave-maidens on the pebbles4 #b4 ,if thou find an arguer talking1 one that is well disposed and wiser than thou1 let thine arms #dc fall1 bend thy back1#c be not angry with him if he agree 787 not with thee4 ,refrain from speaking evilly2 oppose him not at any time when he speaketh4 ,if he address thee as one ignorant of the matter1 thine humbleness shall bear away his contentions4 #c4 ,if thou find an arguer talking1 thy fellow1 one that is within thy reach1 keep not silence when he saith aught that is evil2 so shalt thou be wiser than he4 ,great will be the applause on the part of the listeners1 and thy name shall be good in the knowledge of princes4 #d4 ,if thou find an arguer talking1 a poor man1 that is to say not thine equal1 be not scornful toward him because he is lowly4 ,let him alone2 then shall he confound himself4 ,question him not to please thine heart1 neither pour out thy wrath upon him that is before thee2 it is shameful to confuse a mean mind4 ,if thou be about to do that which is in thine heart1 overcome it as a thing rejected of princes4 #e4 ,if thou be a leader1 as one directing the conduct of the multitude1 endeavour always to be gracious1 that thine own conduct be without defect4 ,great is ,truth1 appointing a straight path2 never hath it been overthrown since the #dd reign of ,osiris4#d ,one that oversteppeth the laws shall be punished4 ,overstepping is by the covetous man2 but degradations 787 bear off his riches1 for the season of his evil-doing ceaseth not4 ,for he saith1 ',i will obtain by myself for myself1' and saith not1 ',i will obtain because ,i am allowed4' ,but the limits of justice are steadfast2 it is that which a man repeateth from his father4 #f4 ,cause not fear among men2 for this the ,god punisheth likewise4 ,for there is a man that saith1 ',therein is life'2 and he is bereft of the bread of his mouth4 ,there is a man that saith1 ',power is therein'2 and he saith1 ',i seize for myself that which ,i perceive4' ,thus a man speaketh1 and he is smitten down4 ,it is another that attaineth by giving unto him that hath not2 not he that causeth men dread4 ,for it happeneth that what the ,god hath commanded1 even that thing cometh to pass4 ,live1 therefore1 in the house of kindliness1 and men shall come and give gifts of themselves4 #g4 ,if thou be among the guests of a man that is greater than thou1 accept that which he giveth thee1 putting it to thy lips4 ,if thou look at him that is before thee 7thine host71 pierce him not #de with many glances4 ,it is abhorred of the soul#e to stare at him4 ,speak not till he address thee2 one knoweth not what may be evil in his opinion4 ,speak when he questioneth thee2 so shall thy speech be good in his opinion4 ,the noble who sitteth before food divideth it as his soul moveth him2 he giveth unto him that he would favour--it is the custom of the evening meal4 ,it is his soul that guideth his hand4 ,it is the noble that bestoweth1 not the underling that attaineth4 ,thus the eating of bread is under the providence of the ,god2 he is an ignorant man that disputeth it4 #h4 ,if thou be an emissary sent from one noble to another1 be exact after the manner of him that sent thee1 give his message even as he hath said it4 ,beware of making enmity by thy words1 setting one noble against the other by perverting truth4 ,overstep it not1 neither repeat that which any man1 be he prince or peasant1 saith in opening the heart2 it is abhorrent to the soul4 #i4 ,if thou have ploughed1 gather thine harvest in the field1 and the ,god shall make it great under thine hand4 ,fill not thy mouth at thy neighbours' table4444#f ,if a crafty man be the #df possessor of wealth1 he stealeth like a crocodile from the priests4 ,let not a man be envious that hath no children2 let him be neither downcast nor quarrelsome on account of it4 ,for a father1 though great1 may be grieved2 as to the mother of children1 she hath less peace than another4 ,verily1 each man is created to his destiny by the ,god1 ,who is the chief of a tribe1 trustful in following him4 #aj4 ,if thou be lowly1 serve a wise man1 that all thine actions may be good before the ,god4 ,if thou have known a man of none account that hath been advanced in rank1 be not haughty toward him on account of that which thou knowest concerning him2 but honour him that hath been advanced1 according to that which he hath become4 ,behold1 riches come not of themselves2 it is their rule for him that desireth them4 ,if he bestir him and collect them himself1 the ,god shall make him prosperous2 but ,he shall punish him1 if he be slothful4 #aa4 ,follow thine heart during thy lifetime2 do not more than is commanded thee4 ,diminish not the time of following the heart2 it is abhorred of the soul1 that its time of ease be taken away4 ,shorten not the daytime more than is needful to #dg maintain thine house4 ,when riches are gained1 follow the heart2 for riches are of no avail if one be weary4 #ab4 ,if thou wouldest be a wise man1 beget a son for the pleasing of the ,god4 ,if he make straight his course after thine example1 if he arrange thine affairs in due order1 do unto him all that is good1 for thy son is he1 begotten of thine own soul4 ,sunder not thine heart from him1 or thine own begotten shall curse thee4 ,if he be heedless and trespass thy rules of conduct1 and is violent2 if every speech that cometh from his mouth be a vile word2 then beat thou him1 that his talk may be fitting4 ,keep him from those that make light of that which is commanded1 for it is they that make him rebellious4#g ,and they that are guided go not astray1 but they that lose their bearings cannot find a straight course4 #ac4 ,if thou be in the chamber of council1 act always according to the steps enjoined on thee at the beginning of the day4 ,be not absent1 or thou shall be expelled2 but be ready in entering and making report4 ,wide#h is the seat of one that hath made address4 ,the council-chamber acteth by strict rule2 and all its plans are in accordance with method4 ,it is the ,god that #dh advanceth one to a seat therein2 the like is not done for elbowers4 #ad4 ,if thou be among people1 make for thyself love1 the beginning and end of the heart4 ,one that knoweth not his course shall say in himself 7seeing thee71 ',he that ordereth himself duly becometh the owner of wealth2 ,i shall copy his conduct4' ,thy name shall be good1 though thou speak not2 thy body shall be fed2 thy face shall be seen among thy neighbours2 thou shalt be provided with what thou lackest4 ,as to the man whose heart obeyeth his belly1 he causeth disgust in place of love4 ,his heart is wretched 7871 his body is gross 7871 he is insolent toward those endowed of the ,god4 ,he that obeyeth his belly hath an enemy4#i #ae4 ,report thine actions without concealment2 discover thy conduct when in council with thine overlord4 ,it is not evil for the envoy that his report be not answered1 ',yea1 ,i know it1' by the prince2 for that which he knoweth includeth not this4 ,if he 7the prince7 think that he will oppose him on account of it1 he thinketh ',he will be silent because ,i have spoken4'#aj #af4 ,if thou be a leader1 cause that the rules #di that thou hast enjoined be carried out2 and do all things as one that remembereth the days coming after1 when speech availeth not4 ,be not lavish of favours2 it leadeth to servility 7871 producing slackness4 #ag4 ,if thou be a leader1 be gracious when thou hearkenest unto the speech of a suppliant4 ,let him not hesitate to deliver himself of that which he hath thought to tell thee2 but be desirous of removing his injury4 ,let him speak freely1 that the thing for which he hath come to thee may be done4 ,if he hesitate to open his heart1 it is said1 ',is it because he 7the judge7 doeth the wrong that no entreaties are made to him concerning it by those to whom it happeneth8' ,but a well-taught heart hearkeneth readily4 #ah4 ,if thou desire to continue friendship in any abode wherein thou enterest1 be it as master1 as brother1 or as friend2 wheresoever thou goest1 beware of consorting with women4 ,no place prospereth wherein that is done4 ,nor is it prudent to take part in it2 a thousand men have been ruined for the pleasure of a little time short as a dream4 ,even death is reached thereby2 it is a wretched thing4 ,as for the evil liver1 one leaveth him for what he doeth1 he is avoided4 ,if his desires be not gratified1 he regardeth 787 no laws4 #ej #ai4 ,if thou desire that thine actions may be good1 save thyself from all malice1 and beware of the quality of covetousness1 which is a grievous inner 787 malady4 ,let it not chance that thou fall thereinto4 ,it setteth at variance fathers-in-law and the kinsmen of the daughter-in-law2 it sundereth the wife and the husband4 ,it gathereth unto itself all evils2 it is the girdle of all wickedness4#aa ,but the man that is just flourisheth2 truth goeth in his footsteps1 and he maketh habitations therein1 not in the dwelling of covetousness4 #bj4 ,be not covetous as touching shares1 in seizing that which is not thine own property4 ,be not covetous toward thy neighbours2 for with a gentle man praise availeth more than might4 ,he that is covetous cometh empty from among his neighbours1 being void of the persuasion of speech4 ,one hath remorse for even a little covetousness when his belly cooleth4 #ba4 ,if thou wouldest be wise1 provide for thine house1 and love thy wife that is in thine arms4 ,fill her stomach1 clothe her back2 oil is the remedy of her limbs4 ,gladden her heart during thy lifetime1 for she is an estate profitable unto its lord4 ,be not harsh1 for gentleness mastereth her more than strength4 ,give 787 to her that for which she sigheth and that toward which her #ea eye looketh2 so shalt thou keep her in thine house4444 #bb4 ,satisfy thine hired servants out of such things as thou hast2 it is the duty of one that hath been favoured of the ,god4 ,in sooth1 it is hard to satisfy hired servants4 ,for one#ab saith1 ',he is a lavish person2 one knoweth not that which may come from him4' ,but on the morrow he thinketh1 ',he is a person of exactitude 7parsimony71 content therein4' ,and when favours have been shown unto servants1 they say1 ',we go4' ,peace dwelleth not in that town wherein dwell servants that are wretched4 #bc4 ,repeat not extravagant speech1 neither listen thereto2 for it is the utterance of a body heated by wrath4 ,when such speech is repeated to thee1 hearken not thereto1 look to the ground4 ,speak not regarding it1 that he that is before thee may know wisdom4 ,if thou be commanded to do a theft1 bring it to pass that the command be taken off thee1 for it is a thing hateful according to law4 ,that which destroyeth a vision is the veil over it4 #bd4 ,if thou wouldest be a wise man1 and one sitting in council with his overlord1 apply thine heart unto perfection4 ,silence is more profitable unto thee than abundance of speech4 ,consider #eb how thou may be opposed by an expert that speaketh in council4 ,it is a foolish thing to speak on every kind of work1 for he that disputeth thy words shall put them unto proof4 #be4 ,if thou be powerful1 make thyself to be honoured for knowledge and for gentleness4 ,speak with authority1 that is1 not as if following injunctions1 for he that is humble 7when highly placed7 falleth into errors4 ,exalt not thine heart1 that it be not brought low4#ac ,be not silent1 but beware of interruption and of answering words with heat4 ,put it far from thee2 control thyself4 ,the wrathful heart speaketh fiery words2 it darteth out at the man of peace that approacheth1 stopping his path4 ,one that reckoneth accounts all the day passeth not an happy moment4 ,one that gladdeneth his heart all the day provideth not for his house4 ,the bowman hitteth the mark1 as the steersman reacheth land1 by diversity of aim4 ,he that obeyeth his heart shall command4#ad #bf4 ,let not a prince be hindered when he is occupied2 neither oppress the heart of him that is already laden4 ,for he shall be hostile toward one that delayeth him1 but shall bare his soul #ec unto one that loveth him4 ,the disposal of souls is with the ,god1 and that which ,he loveth is ,his creation4 ,set out1 therefore1 after a violent quarrel2 be at peace with him that is hostile unto thee his opponent4 ,it is such souls that make love to grow4 #bg4 ,instruct a noble in such things as be profitable unto him2 cause that he be received among men4 ,let his satisfaction fall on his master1 for thy provision dependeth upon his will4 ,by reason of it thy belly shall be satisfied2 thy back will be clothed thereby4 ,let him receive thine heart1 that thine house may flourish and thine honour--if thou wish it to flourish--thereby4 ,he shall extend thee a kindly hand4 ,further1 he shall implant the love of thee in the bodies of thy friends4 ,forsooth1 it is a soul loving to hearken4#ae #bh4 ,if thou be the son of a man of the priesthood1 and an envoy to conciliate the multitude14444#af speak thou without favouring one side4 ,let it not be said1 ',his conduct is that of the nobles1 favouring one side in his speech4' ,turn thine aim toward exact judgments4 #ed #bi4 ,if thou have been gracious at a former time1 having forgiven a man to guide him aright1 shun him1 remind him not after the first day that he hath been silent to thee concerning it4 #cj4 ,if thou be great1 after being of none account1 and hast gotten riches after squalor1 being foremost in these in the city1 and hast knowledge concerning useful matters1 so that promotion is come unto thee2 then swathe not thine heart in thine hoard1 for thou art become the steward of the endowments of the ,god4 ,thou art not the last2 another shall be thine equal1 and to him shall come the like fortune and station4 #ca4 ,bend thy back unto thy chief1 thine overseer in the ,king's palace1 for thine house dependeth upon his wealth1 and thy wages in their season4 ,how foolish is one that quarrelleth with his chief1 for one liveth only while he is gracious4444 ,plunder not the houses of tenants2 neither steal the things of a friend1 lest he accuse thee in thine hearing1 which thrusteth back the heart4#ag ,if he know of it1 he will do thee an injury4 ,quarrelling in place of friendship is a foolish thing4 #ee #cb4 ,concerning continence4 #cc4 ,if thou wouldest seek out the nature of a friend1 ask it not of any companion of his2 but pass a time with him alone1 that thou injure not his affairs4 ,debate with him after a season2 test his heart in an occasion of speech4 ,when he hath told thee his past life1 he hath made an opportunity that thou may either be ashamed for him or be familiar with him4 ,be not reserved with him when he openeth speech1 neither answer him after a scornful manner4 ,withdraw not thyself from him1 neither interrupt 787 him whose matter is not yet ended1 whom it is possible to benefit4 #cd4 ,let thy face be bright what time thou livest4 ,that which goeth into the storehouse must come out therefrom2 and bread is to be shared4 ,he that is grasping in entertainment shall himself have an empty belly2 he that causeth strife cometh himself to sorrow4 ,take not such an one for thy companion4 ,it is a man's kindly acts that are remembered of him in the years after his life4#ah #ce4 ,know well thy merchants2 for when thine affairs are in evil case1 thy good repute among thy friends is a channel 787 which is filled4 ,it is more important than the dignities of a man2 and #ef the wealth of one passeth to another4 ,the good repute of a man's son is a glory unto him2 and a good character is for remembrance4 #cf4 ,correct chiefly2 instruct conformably therewith4 ,vice must be drawn out1 that virtue may remain4 ,nor is this a matter of misfortune1 for one that is a gainsayer becometh a strife-maker4 #cg4 ,if thou make a woman to be ashamed1 wanton of heart1 one known by her townsfolk to be falsely placed1 be kind unto her for a space1 send her not away1 give her to eat4 ,the wantonness of her heart shall esteem thy guidance4 ,c4 ,if thou obey these things that ,i have said unto thee1 all thy demeanour shall be of the best2 for1 verily1 the quality of truth is among their excellences4 ,set the memory of them in the mouths of the people2 for their proverbs are good4 ,nor shall any word that hath here been set down cease out of this land for ever1 but shall be made a pattern whereby princes shall speak well4 ,they 7my words7 shall instruct a man2 how he shall speak1 after he hath heard them2 yea1 he shall become as one skilful in obeying1 excellent in speaking1 after he hath heard them4 ,good fortune shall befall him1 for he shall be of the highest rank4 ,he shall be gracious to the end of his life2 he shall be #eg contented always4 ,his knowledge shall be his guide 787 into a place of security1 wherein he shall prosper while on earth4 ,the scholar#ai shall be content in his knowledge4 ,as to the prince1 in his turn1 forsooth1 his heart shall be happy1 his tongue made straight4 ,and in these proverbs his lips shall speak1 his eyes shall see1 and his ears shall hear1 that which is profitable for his son1 so that he deal justly1 void of deceit4 #ch4 ,a splendid thing is the obedience of an obedient son2 he cometh in and listeneth obediently4 ,excellent in hearing1 excellent in speaking1 is every man that obeyeth what is noble2 and the obedience of an obeyer is a noble thing4 ,obedience is better than all things that are2 it maketh good-will4 ,how good it is that a son should take that from his father by which he hath reached old age 7,obedience74 ,that which is desired by the ,god is obedience2 disobedience is abhorred of the ,god4 ,verily1 it is the heart that maketh its master to obey or to disobey2 for the safe and sound life of a man are his heart4 ,it is the obedient man that obeyeth what is said2 he that loveth to obey1 the same shall carry out commands4 #eh ,he that obeyeth becometh one obeyed4 ,it is good indeed when a son obeyeth his father2 and he 7his father7 that hath spoken hath great joy of it4 ,such a son shall be mild as a master1 and he that heareth him shall obey him that hath spoken4 ,he shall be comely in body and honoured by his father4 ,his memory shall be in the mouths of the living1 those upon earth1 as long as they exist4#bj #ci4 ,let a son receive the word of his father1 not being heedless of any rule of his4 ,instruct thy son thus2 for the obedient man is one that is perfect in the opinion of princes4 ,if he direct his mouth by what hath been enjoined him1 watchful and obedient1 thy son shall be wise1 and his goings seemly4 ,heedlessness leadeth unto disobedience on the morrow2 but understanding shall stablish him4 ,as for the fool1 he shall be crushed4 #dj4 ,as for the fool1 devoid of obedience1 he doeth nothing4 ,knowledge he regardeth as ignorance1 profitable things as hurtful things4 ,he doeth all kind of errors1 so that he is rebuked therefor every day4 ,he liveth in death #ei therewith2 it is his food4 ,at chattering speech he marvelleth1 as at the wisdom of princes1 living in death every day4 ,he is shunned because of his misfortunes1 by reason of the multitude of afflictions that cometh upon him every day4 #da4 ,a son that hearkeneth is as a ,follower of ,horus4#ba ,he is good after he hearkeneth2 he groweth old1 he reacheth honour and reverence4 ,he repeateth in like manner to his sons and daughters1 so renewing the instruction of his father4 ,each man instructeth as did his begetter1 repeating it unto his children4 ,let them in turn speak with their sons and daughters1 that they may be famous in their deeds4 ,let that which thou speakest implant true things and just in the life of thy children4 ,then the highest authority shall arrive1 and sins depart from them4 ,and such men as see these things shall say1 ',surely that man hath spoken to good purpose1' and they shall do likewise2 or1 ',but surely that man was experienced4' ,and all people shall declare1 ',it is they that shall direct the multitude2 dignities are not complete without them4' ,take not any word away1 neither add one2 #fj set not one in the place of another4 ,beware of opening444#bb in thyself4 ,be wary of speech when a learned man hearkeneth unto thee2 desire to be stablished for good in the mouth of those that hear thee speaking4 ,if thou have entered as an expert1 speak with exact 787 lips1 that thy conduct may be seemly4 #db4 ,be thine heart overflowing2 but refrain thy mouth4 ,let thy conduct be exact while amongst nobles1 and seemly before thy lord1 doing that which he hath commanded4 ,such a son shall speak unto them that hearken to him2 moreover1 his begetter shall be favoured4 ,apply thine heart1 what time thou speakest1 to saying things such that the nobles who listen declare1 ',how excellent is that which cometh out of his mouth6' #dc4 ,carry out the behest of thy lord to thee4 ,how good is the teaching of a man's father1 for he hath come from him1 who hath spoken of his son while he was yet unborn2 and that which is done for him 7the son7 is more than that which is commanded him4 ,forsooth1 a good son is of the gift of the ,god2 he doeth more than is #fa enjoined on him1 he doeth right1 and putteth his heart into all his goings4 ,d4 ,if now thou attain my position1 thy body shall flourish1 the ,king shall be content in all that thou doest1 and thou shalt gather years of life not fewer than ,i have passed upon earth4 ,i have gathered even fivescore and ten years of life1 for the ,king hath bestowed upon me favours more than upon my forefathers2 this because ,i wrought truth and justice for the ,king unto mine old age4 ,,it ,,is ,,finished ,,from ,,its ,,beginning ,,to ,,its ,,end ,,even ,,as ,,found ,,in ,,writing4 #a ,the ,king4 #b ,title of an order of the priesthood4 #c ,the customary attitude of a submissive inferior at that time4 #d ,the ,god ,osiris was believed to have reigned on earth many thousand years before ,mns1 the first historical king4 #e ,soul ka'1 and throughout this work4 ,ka' is translated person in #bb1 will in #bg4 #f ,an obscure or corrupt phrase here follows1 which does not admit of satisfactory translation4 #g ,translation doubtful4 #h i4e4 comfortable4 #i ,his belly1 presumably4 #aj ,the above translation is not satisfactory2 the text may be corrupt4 ,no intelligible translation of it has yet been made4 #aa i4e4 all wickedness is contained therein4 #ab ,a servant4 #ac ,compare ,prov4 xvii4 #ah4 #ad ,so also in life1 by diversity of aim1 alternating work and play1 happiness is secured4 ,tacking is evidently meant in the case of the steersman4 #ae ,this section refers to the relations between the son of a nobleman and his tutor1 dwelling on the benefits from former pupils in high places1 if their schooldays have been pleasant4 ,the last sentence of this section1 as of sections #bc and #be1 is somewhat propos des bottes4 #af ,an obscure phrase is here4 #ag ,literally1 ,it is that which preventeth the heart from advancing 787 ,a curious phrase4 #ah ,literally1 after his stick or sceptre4 #ai ,who knows them4 #bj ,the greater part of this section is a play upon the root 'sdem1 which in its meaning includes our hear 7listen7 and obey4 ,this tiresome torture of words is frequent in ,egyptian1 especially in old religious texts4 #ba ,the ,followers of ,horus are a legendary dynasty of demigods1 believed by the ,egyptians to have ruled for about #ac1djj years after the reign of ,horus1 and before that of ,mns4 ,there is also an order of spirits of this name4 #bb ,a word of unknown meaning2 apparently some kind of plant4 ,such a word seems out of place here1 and may be idiomatic1 like our flowery language4 ,but the preceding line obviously refers to this book4 #fb ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,ke',,gemni ,on ,avoiding ,offence #a4a ,the cautious man flourisheth1 the exact one is praised2 the innermost chamber openeth unto the man of silence4 ,wide#b is the seat of the man gentle of speech2 but knives are prepared against one that forceth a path1 that he advance not1 save in due season4 #b4 ,if thou sit with a company of people1 desire not the bread that thou likest3 short is the time of restraining the heart1 and gluttony is an abomination2 therein is the quality of a beast4 ,a cup of water quencheth the thirst1 and a mouthful of melon supporteth the heart4 ,a good thing standeth for goodness1 but some small thing standeth for plenty4#c ,a base man is he that is governed by his belly2 he departeth only when he is no longer able to fill full his belly in men's houses4 #fc #c4 ,if thou sit with a glutton1 eat with him1 then depart 7874 ,if thou drink with a drunkard1 accept drink1 and his heart shall be satisfied4 ,refuse not meat when with a greedy man4 ,take that which he giveth thee2 set it not on one side1 thinking that it will be a courteous thing4 #d4 ,if a man be lacking in good fellowship1 no speech hath any influence over him4 ,he is sour of face toward the glad-hearted that are kindly to him2 he is a grief unto his mother and his friends2 and all men cry1 ',let thy name be known2 thou art silent in thy mouth when thou art addressed6' #e4 ,be not haughty because of thy might in the midst of thy young soldiers4 ,beware of making strife1 for one knoweth not the things that the ,god will do when ,he punisheth4 ,the ,vizier caused his sons and daughters to be summoned1 when he had finished the rules of the conduct of men4 ,and they marvelled when they came to him4 ,then he said unto them1 ',hearken unto everything that is in writing in this book1 even as ,i have said it in adding unto profitable sayings4' ,and they cast themselves on their bellies1 and they read it1 even as it was in writing4 ,and it was better in their opinion than any thing in this land unto its limits4 ,now they were living when ,his ,majesty1 the ,king of ,upper and ,lower ,egypt1 ,,heuni1 #fd departed1 and ,his ,majesty1 the ,king of ,upper and ,lower ,egypt1 ,,senf,,ru1 was enthroned as a gracious king over the whole of this land4 ,then was ,ke'gemni made ,governor of his ,city and ,vizier4 ,,it ,,is ,,finished4 #a ,the original is not divided into sections4 #b i4e4 comfortable #c ,this is a rather dark saying1 but apparently the author means that although the duly instructed guest will only partake moderately of the abundance before him1 what he eats is as good as the rest4 ,his portion will be equal to the whole as regards quality1 though inferior as regards quantity4 #fe ,,appendix ,the ,instruction of ,amenemh'et ,i4 is here given as a contrast to the foregoing4 ,it is a ,testament1 however1 rather than an ,instruction1 and contains more historical matter than didactic4 ,it is written in a terse and pointed style1 combined with the parallelism and antithesis which was the prevailing vehicle of poetic thought in ,egyptian4 ,the rank of its author and the exceeding bitterness of his mood make it a document of great interest4 ,there is no reason to doubt its authenticity4 ,this ,king was the founder of the glorious ,twelfth ,dynasty1 a period which has been called the ,golden ,age of ,egypt4 ,he ruled from about #bggh-bgdh ,b4,c41 and1 although he describes himself as over-lenient1 was really one of the most vigorous and powerful of all the ,sons of the ,sun who for five thousand years wore the double crown of the ,two ,egypts4 ,the circumstances in which the new dynasty arose are not known2 nor have we any other record of the attempt on his life1 here recounted4 #ff ,in the twentieth year of his reign he associated his son1 ,senwesert ,i41 with him in a co-regency which lasted ten years4 ,from #h we gather that the attempted assassination took place just before the dual rule2 while the ,instruction was evidently penned shortly before the writer's death4 ,the 'house' referred to is presumably his pyramid-tomb1 called ,ke'-nfer-amenemh'et4 ,amenemh'et is exalted and good4 ,the site of this building is not known4 ,this ,instruction was popular as a school exercise in the ',new ,kingdom1' and we possess several copies or parts of copies4 ,there is no good text for the latter part 7 #ab ff71 which is corrupt in such ,,mss4 as contain it4 ,i have used the critical text of ,mr4 ,griffith1 published in the ,zeitschrift fr gyptische ,sprache1 #ahif4 ,it is hoped that the ,bibliography will be useful to students of the books of ,ptah-hotep and ,ke'gemni4 ,b4 ,g4 ,g4 #fg ,,the ,,instruction ,,of ,,amenemhe',,et ,a ,palace ,conspiracy--,hail and ,farewell ,beginneth here the ,instruction made by the ,majesty of the ,king of ,upper and ,lower ,egypt ,,sehotep-',,eb-,r'1 ,son of the ,sun ,,amenemh',,et1 the ,justified4#a ,he speaketh thus in discovering words of truth unto his ,son1 the ,lord of the ,world3 #a4 ,shine forth1 he saith1 even as the ,god4 ,hearken to that which ,i say unto thee3 that thou may reign over the land1 that thou may govern the world1 that thou may excel in goodness4 #b4 ,let one withdraw himself from his subordinates entirely4 ,it befalleth that mankind give their hearts unto one that causeth them fear4 ,mix not among them alone2 fill not thine heart with a brother2 know not a trusted friend2 make for thyself no familiar dependents2 in these things is no satisfaction4 #c4 ,when thou liest down have care for thy very life1#b since friends exist not for a man in the #fh day of misfortunes4 ,i gave to the beggar1 and caused the orphan to live2 ,i made him that had not to attain1 even as he that had4 #d4 ,but it was the eater of my food that made insurrection against me2 to whom ,i gave mine hands1 he created disturbance thereby2 they that arrayed them in my fine linen regarded me a shadow2 and it was they that anointed themselves with my spices that entered my harem4 #e4 ,my images are among the living2 and my achievements are among men4 ,but ,i have made an heroic story that hath not been heard2 a great feat of arms that hath not been seen4 ,surely one fighteth for a lassoed ox that forgetteth yesterday2#c and good fortune is of no avail unto one that cannot perceive it4 #f4 ,it was after the evening meal1 and night was come4 ,i took for myself an hour of ease4 ,i lay down upon my bed1 for ,i was weary4 ,my heart began to wander 7874 ,i slept4 ,and lo6 weapons were brandished1 and there was conference concerning me4 ,i acted as the serpent of the desert4#d #g4 ,i awoke to fight2 ,i was alone4 ,i found one struck down1 it was the captain of the guard4 ,had ,i received quickly the arms from his hand1 #fi ,i had driven back the dastards by smiting around4 ,but he was not a brave man on that night1 nor could ,i fight alone2 an occasion of prowess cometh not to one surprised4 ,thus was ,i4 #h4 ,behold1 then1 vile things came to pass1 for ,i was without thee2 the courtiers knew not that ,i had passed on to thee my power1 ,i sat not with thee on the throne4#e ,let me1 then1 make thy plans4 ,because ,i awed them not ,i was not unmindful of them2 but mine heart bringeth not to remembrance the slackness of servants4 #i4 ,is it the custom of women to gather together assailants8 are assassins reared within my palace8 was the opening done by cutting through the ground8 ,the underlings were deceived as to what they did4#f ,but misfortunes have not come in my train since my birth2 nor hath there existed the equal of me as a doer of valiance4 #aj4 ,i forced my way up to ,elephantin1 ,i went down unto the coast-lakes2#g ,i have stood upon the boundaries of the land1 and ,i have seen its centre4 ,i have set the limits of might by my might in my deeds4 #aa4 ,i raised corn1 ,i loved ,npi#h2 the ,nile begged of me every valley4 ,in my reign none #gj hungered2 none thirsted therein4 ,they were contented in that which ,i did1 saying concerning me1 ',every commandment is meet4' #ab4 ,i overcame lions2 ,i carried off crocodiles4 ,i cast the ,nubians under my feet2 ,i carried off the ,southern ,nubians2 ,i caused the ,asiatics to flee1 even as hounds4 #ac4 ,i have made me an house1 adorned with gold1 its ceiling with lapis lazuli1 its walls having deep foundations4 ,its doors are of copper1 their bolts are of bronze4 ,it is made for ever-lasting2 eternity is in awe of it4 ,i know every dimension thereof1 ,o ,lord of the ,world6 #ad4 ,there are divers devices in buildings4 ,i know the pronouncements of men when inquiring into its beauties2 but they know not that it was without thee1 ,o my son1 ,senwesert2 life1 safe and sound1 be to thee--by thy feet do ,i walk2 thou art after mine own heart2 by thine eyes do ,i see2 born in an hour of delight1 with spirits#i that rendered thee praise4 #ae4 ,behold1 that which ,i have done at the beginning1 let me set it in order for thee at the end2 let me be the landing-place of that which is in thine heart4 ,all men together set the ,white ,crown on the ,offspring of the ,god1 fixing it unto its due place4 ,i shall begin thy praises when in the ,boat of ,ra4 ,thy kingdom hath been from primeval time2 not by my doing1 #ga who have done valiant things4 ,raise up monuments1 make beautiful thy tomb4 ,i have fought against him whom thou knowest2 for ,i desire not that he should be beside thy ,majesty4 ,life1 safe and sound1 be to thee4 ,,it ,,is ,,finished4 #a ,a ceremonial title applied to deceased persons1 analogous to our the late4 ,justified is not an exact rendering1 but it is usual1 and will serve4 #b ,literally1 heart4 #c ,an allusion to the people of ,egypt1 whom he had freed from the foreign oppressors4 #d i4e4 he remained quiet but watchful4 #e ,referring to the co-regency with his son4 #f ,referring to the attempted assassination4 #g ,the limits1 south and north1 of his kingdom4 #h ,the god of corn4 #i ,or1 unborn souls 7hmmw74 #gb ,,an ,,explanation ,,of ,,names ,,occurring ,,in ,,this ,,book4 ,,amenemh',,et 4 4 4 4 ,the ,god ,amn is to the fore4 ,,heuni 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ,i have smitten4 ,issi 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ,of unknown meaning4 ,,ke',,gemni 4 4 4 4 4 4 ,i have found a soul2 or1 ,a soul is found for me4 ,,ptah-,,hotep 4 4 4 4 4 ,the ,god ,ptah is satisfied1 alluding either to the belief that to beget a child was pleasing to the ,god1 or to the dedication of the child to the ,god4 ,,seh,,tep-',,eb-,r' 4 4 ,contenting the heart of the ,god ,ra4 ,,senf,,ru 4 4 4 4 4 4 ,the beautifier4 ,,senwesert 4 4 4 4 4 ,of doubtful meaning2 connected with ,the ,goddess ,wesert4 ,other spellings of these names are3 ,amenemhat2 ,huna2 ,assa1 ',esse'2 ,ptahhetep2 ,sehetepabra1 ,rasehetepab2 ,seneferu2 ,usertesen4 #gc ,,bibliography ,brugsch1 ,h4 ,hieroglyphisches-demotisches ,wrterbuch 444 vols4 v4-vii4 ,leipzig1 #ahhj ff4 ,contains explanations of many difficult passages4 ,budge1 ,e4 ,a4 ,w4 ,an ,egyptian ,reading ,book4 ,london1 #ahhh4 ,second edition1 with transliteration into italics and vocabulary1 ,london1 #ahif4 ,contains the most convenient transcript of the ,p4,p4 ,follows throughout that of ,virey 7see below74 ,for some amendments see ,griffith in ,proc4 ,s4,b4,a4 7below74 ,the first edition is more accurate 7for this text7 than the second4 ,the vocabulary needs revision4 ,chabas1 ,f4 ,le plus ancien livre du monde2 tude sur le papyrus ,prisse4 ,revue archologique1 premire srie1 xv4 anno4 ,paris1 #aheg4 ,contains a discussion of the text1 etc41 and partial translation4 ,chabas1 ,f4 ,le papyrus ,prisse4 ,zeitschrift fr gyptische ,sprache4 ,berlin1 #ahgj4 ,discusses the meaning of various words4 ,chabas1 ,f4 ,le plus ancien livre du monde2 tude sur le papyrus ,prisse4 ,bibliothque orientale1 vol4 ii4 ,paris1 #ahgb4 ,the work of #aheg recast4 ,dumichen1 ,j4 ,les sentences de ,kakemni4 ,les ,bibles et les initiateurs religieux de l'humanit1 vol4 ii4 part i4 ,paris1 #ahhd4 ,contains a translation of ,kg4 ,griffith1 ,f4 ,l4 ,notes on ,egyptian ,texts of the ,middle ,kingdom1 iii4 ,proceedings of the ,society of ,biblical ,archaeology1 vol4 xiii4 ,london1 #ahij4 ,discusses the text1 correcting some previous errors in transcription4 ,translation of ,kg4 and ,a1 ,b of ,ph4 ,griffith1 ,f4 ,l4 ,egyptian ,literature4 ,a ,library of the #gd ,world's ,best ,literature4 ,new ,york1 #ahih-i4 ,contains translation of many sections4 ,heath1 ,d4 ,i4 ,on a ,,ms4 of the ,phoenician ,king ,assa1 ruling in ,egypt before ,abraham3 ,a ,record of the ,patriarchal ,age2 or ,the ,proverbs of ,aphobis1 ,b4,c4 #aijj2 now first fully translated4 ,monthly ,review4 ,london1 ,july1 #ahff4 ,the first 'translation' of ,kg4 and ,ph4 ,afterwards issued as a pamphlet1 ,london1 #aheh4 ,lauth1 ,f4 ,j4 ,der ,autor ,kadjimna vor #edjj ,jahren4 ,sitzungsberichte der kgl4 bayer4 ,akademie der ,wissenschaften4 ,munchen1 #ahfi1 ii4 ,contains an analysis of ,kg4 ,lauth1 ,f4 ,j4 ,der ,prim ,ptah-hotep ber das ,alter3 ,ptah-hoteps ,ethik4 ,sitzungsberichte der kgl4 bayer4 ,akademie der ,wissenschaften4 ,mnchen1 #ahgj1 ii1 ,heft i1 ,beilage4 ,contains analysis and translation into ,latin and ,german of the greater part of ,ph4 ,mahaffy1 ,j4 ,p4 ,prolegomena to ,ancient ,history1 part ii4 ,london1 #ahga4 ,contains translations from ,lauth's rendering4 ,myer1 ,t4 ,the ,oldest ,books in the ,world4 ,new ,york1 #aijj4 ,contains ,virey's translation and notes4 ,petrie1 ,w4 ,m4 ,f4 ,religion and ,conscience in ,ancient ,egypt4 ,london1 #ahih4 ,contains translations of many sections by ,f4 ,l4 ,griffith4 ,prisse d',avennes1 ,e4 ,facsimile d'un papyrus gyptien1 trouv ,thebes1 donn la ,bibliothque ,royale de ,paris1 et publi par ,e4 ,p4 d',a4 ,paris1 #ahdg4 ,rawnsley1 ,h4 ,d4 ,notes for the ,nile1 together with a ,metrical ,rendering of the ,hymns of ,ancient ,egypt1 and of the ,precepts of ,ptah-hotep 7the ,oldest ,book in the ,world74 ,london1 #ahib4 ,revillout1 ,e4 ,les deux prfaces du papyrus ,prisse4 ,revue gyptologique1 tome vii4 ,paris1 #ahif4 ,contains translation of ,kg4 and ,a of ,ph4 ,revillout1 ,e4 ,les ,maximes de ,ptah-hotep4 ,revue gyptologique1 tome x4 ,paris1 #aijb4 ,contains translation and text of ,ph4 ,virey1 ,p4 tudes sur le papyrus ,prisse1 le livre de ,kagimna et les leons de ,ptah-hotep4 ,bibliothque de #ge l'cole des ,hautes-tudes1 fasc4 #gj4 ,paris1 #ahhg4 ,contains complete translation and elaborate discussion of the text2 also glossary4 ,virey1 ,p4 ,the ,precepts of ,ptah-hotep 7the ,oldest ,book in the ,world74 ,records of the ,past1 new series1 vol4 iii4 ,london1 #ahij4 ,contains a translation of ,ph4 ,printed by ,hazell1 ,watson ,viney1 ,ld41 ,london and ,aylesbury4 ,,the ,,wisdom ,,of ,,the ,,east ,,series ,edited by ,l4 ,,cranmer-,,byng and ,dr4 ,s4 ,a4 ,,kapadia ,the object of the ,editors of this ,series is a very definite one4 ,they desire above all things that1 in their humble way1 these books shall be the ambassadors of good-will and understanding between ,east and ,west1 the old world of ,thought and the new of ,action4 ,in this endeavour1 and in their own sphere1 they are but followers of the highest example in the land4 ,they are confident that a deeper knowledge of the great ideals and lofty philosophy of ,oriental thought may help to a revival of that true spirit of ,charity which neither despises nor fears the nations of another creed and colour4 ,finally1 in thanking press and public for the very cordial reception given to the ,wisdom of the ,east ,series1 they wish to state that no pains have been spared to secure the best specialists for the treatment of the various subjects at hand4 ,,london ,,john ,,murray1 ,,albemarle ,,street1 ,w4 ,,wisdom ,,of ,,the ,,east ,,series ,in ,pott l#fmo1 price #a_/- each net in cloth limp 7excepting the first two volumes7 ,the ,teachings of ,zoroaster ,,and ,the ,philosophy of the ,parsi ,religion ,translated with ,introduction by ,,dr4 ,s4 ,a4 ,,kapadia1 ,lecturer ,university ,college1 ,london1 #b_/- net4 ,the ,awakening of the ,soul ,from the ,arabic of ,,ibn ,,tufail4 ,translated with ,introduction by ,,paul ,,bronnle1 ,ph4,d4 #a_/f net4 ,the ,duties of the ,heart ,by ,,rabbi ,,bachye4 ,translated from the ,hebrew with ,introduction by ,,edwin ,,collins1 ,hollier ,hebrew ,scholar1 ,u4,c4,l4 ,the ,classics of ,confucius ,i4 ,the ,book of ,history 7,shu-,king7 ,by ,w4 ,,gorn ,,old ,,ii4 ,the ,book of ,odes 7,shi-,king7 ,by ,l4 ,,cranmer-,,byng4 ,,iii4 ,the ,book of ,changes 7,i-,king7 ,in preparation4 ,the ,sayings of ,lao ,tzu ,from the ,chinese4 ,translated with ,introduction by ,,lionel ,,giles1 of the ,british ,museum4 ,the ,religion of the ,koran ,with ,introduction by ,,arthur ,n4 ,,wollaston1 ,c4,i4,e4 ,women and ,wisdom of ,japan ,with ,introduction by ,s4 ,,takaishi4 ,the ,rose ,garden of ,sa'di ,selected and ,rendered from the ,persian with ,introduction by ,l4 ,,cranmer-,,byng4 ,the ,wisdom of ,israel3 ,being ,extracts from the ,babylonian ,talmud and ,midrash ,rabboth ,translated from the ,aramaic with an ,introduction by ,,edwin ,,collins4 ,the ,instructions of ,ptah-,hotep ,from the ,egyptian4 ,translated with ,introduction by ,,battiscombe ,g4 ,,gunn4 ,others in preparation1 and will be duly announced ,all literary communications to be addressed to the ,editors at #d1 ,,harcourt ,,buildings1 ,,inner ,,temple1 ,,london ,n4,b4--,the ,editors will be pleased to receive suggestions and communications from all persons interested in ,oriental literature4