,transcrib]'s ,note3 ,! footnotes h be5 numb]$ & mov$ to ! end ( ! docum5t4 ,?is file 0 produc$ f images g5]\sly made available by ,! ,int]net ,ar*ive_/,am]ican ,libr>ies4 ,a ,,%ort ,,hi/ory ,,( ,,! ,,book ,,( ,,common ,,pray] ,,toge!r ,,) ,,c]ta9 ,,pap]s ,,illu/rative ,,( ,,liturgical ,,revision #ahgh-ahib ,,by ,,william ,,re$ ,,hunt+ton ,d4 ,d4 ,d4 ,c4 ,l4 ,rector ( ,grace ,*ur* ,new ,york ,,new ,,york ,,?omas ,,:ittak] #b & #c ,bible ,h\se ,copyright1 #ahic1 by ,,?omas ,,:ittak]1 ,,! ,,m]%on ,,company ,,press1 ,,rahway1 ,n4 ,j4 ,,cont5ts ,i4 ,a ,%ort ,hi/ory ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]3 ,i4 ,orig9s1 ,,ii4 ,vicissitudes1 ,,ii4 ,revision ( ! ,am]ican ,common ,pray]1 ,,iii4 ,! ,book ,annex$3 ,its ,critics & its ,prospects1 ,app5dix3 ,i4 ,p]man5t & ,v>iable ,*>act]i/ics ( ! ,pray] ,book--,a ,s]mon ,be=e ,revision1 #ahgh ,,ii4 ,! ,outcome ( ,revision1 #ahib ,,iii4 ,tabul> ,view ( ,additions ,made at ! ,successive ,revisions1 #aeeb-ahib ,,introductory ,,note4 ,! op5+ pap] ( ?is collection 0 orig9ally read z a lecture be=e a liturgical class1 & is n[ publi%$ = ! fir/ "t4 ,! o!rs h appe>$ 9 pr9t f "t to "t dur+ ! movem5t = revision4 ,if !y h any p]man5t value1 x is because ( _! %[+1 s f> z ! writ]'s "p 9 ! matt] is conc]n$1 :at ?+s 7 attempt$ & :at ?+s fail$ ( accompli%m5t4 ,%\ld !y s]ve z contributory to "s future n>rative ( ! revision1 ! object ( _! publication w h be5 accompli%$4 ,s mu* has be5 said z to ! pov]ty ( our ga9s on ! side ( enri*m5t1 z comp>$ ) :at has be5 secur$ 9 ! l9e ( flexibility1 t x has seem$ prop] to app5d to ! volume a ,comp>ative ,table detail+ ! additions ( liturgical matt] made to ! ,common ,pray] at ! successive revisions4 ,w4 ,r4 ,h4 ,new ,york1 ,*ri/mas1 #ahib4 ,a ,,%ort ,,hi/ory ,,( ,,! ,,book ,,( ,,common ,,pray]4 ,a ,,%ort ,,hi/ory ,,( ,,! ,,book ,,( ,,common ,,pray]4 ,i4 ,,orig9s4 ,liturgical wor%ip1 und]/ood 9 ! l>ge/ s5se ! phrase c be>1 means div9e s]vice r5d]$ 9 accordance ) an e/abli%$ =m4 ,( late ye>s !re has be5 an attempt made among puri/s to conf9e ! ^w liturgy to ! (fice entitl$ 9 ! ,pray] ,book1 ,! ,ord] = ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp] or ,holy ,communion4 ,?is re/rict$ & specializ$ int]pretation ( a famili> ^w may s]ve ! purposes ( te*nical s*ol>%ip1 = und\bt$ly !re is mu* to be said 9 favor ( ! n>r[$ signification z we %all see2 b unless ,engli% lit]ature c be rewritt51 pla9 p :o draw _! vocabul>y f /&>d au?ors w g on call+ s]vice-books liturgies reg>dless ( ! fact t !y conta9 _m ?+s o!r ?an t "o (fice :i* is entitl$ to be nam$ by em95ce ! ,liturgy4 ,?is ,conv5tion1 write ! fa!rs ( ! ,am]ican ,episcopal ,*ur* 9 ! ,ratification pr9t$ on ! f\r? page ( ! ,pray] ,book1 hav+ 9 _! pres5t session set =? a ,book ( ,common ,pray] & o!r rites & c]emonies ( ! ,*ur*1 d h]eby e/abli% ! said book2 & !y decl>e x to be ! ,liturgy ( ?is ,*ur*4 ,= ! orig9 ( liturgy ?us broadly def9$ we h to g a long way back2 beyond ! ,pray] ,book1 beyond ! ,mass-book1 beyond ! anci5t ,sacram5t>ies1 yes1 beyond ! synagogue wor%ip1 beyond ! temple wor%ip1 beyond ! tab]nacle wor%ip2 9 fact ,i am dispos$ to ?9k t1 logically1 we %\ld be unable to /op %ort until we _h rea*$ ! v he>t ( man itself1 t dimly disc]n$ gr\ndwork we call human nature1 & _h discov]$ !re ^? two in/9cts1 ! "o ( wor%ip & ! o!r ( greg>i\sness1 f :5ce all =ms ( common pray] h sprung4 ,:]e ?ree or two assemble = ! purposes ( supplication1 "s =m mu/ necess>ily be accept$ if !y are to pray 9 unison4 ,:5 ! disciples came to ,jesus begg+ him t he w\ld tea* !m h[ to pray1 he gave !m1 n twelve sev]al =ms1 ?\gh d\btless ,james's special ne$s diff]$ f ,john's & ,simon's f ,jude's--he gave !m1 n twelve1 b "o4 ,:5 ye pray1 0 8 answ]1 say ,our ,fa!r4 ,t 0 ! beg9n+ ( ,*ri/ian ,common ,pray]4 ,because we are m5 we wor%ip1 because we are fell[-m5 our wor%ip mu/ h =m4 ,b waiv+ ?is la/ analysis ( all :i* c>ries u across ! :ole field ( hi/ory at a leap1 x becomes necess>y to seek = liturgical beg9n+s by a m plodd+ process4 ,if we take t manual ( wor%ip ) :i* z ,engli%-speak+ ,*ri/ians we are ourselves ! mo/ famili>1 ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 & all[ x to fall naturally ap>t1 z a bun* ( fl[]s w\ld d if ! /r+ 7 cut1 we discov] t 9 po9t ( fact we h1 z 9 ! case ( ! ,bible1 _m books 9 "o4 ,we h sc>cely turn$ ! title-page1 = in/ance1 be=e we come ^u a ritual ( daily wor%ip1 an ord] = ,morn+ ,pray] & an ord] = ,ev5+ ,pray]1 consi/+ 9 ! ma9 ( ,psalms1 ,scripture ,lessons1 ,antiphonal ,v]sicles1 & ,collects4 ,app5d$ to ?is we f9d a ,litany or ,g5]al ,supplication & a collection ( special pray]s4 ,m>k an int]val "h1 & note t we h complet$ ! fir/ volume ( our liturgical libr>y4 ,next1 we h a sacram5tal ritual1 entitl$1 ,! ,ord] = ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp] or ,holy ,communion1 +5i\sly int]wov5 by a sy/em ( appropriate pray]s & ,new ,te/am5t read+s ) ! ,sundays & holydays ( ! ye>4 ,?is gives u our second volume4 ,!n foll[ num]\s (fices :i* we %all f9d x conv5i5t to classify "u two heads1 namely3 ^? :i* may be said by a bi%op or by a presbyt]1 & ^? t may be said by a bi%op only4 ,"u ! =m] head come ! baptismal (fices1 ! ,ord] = ! ,burial ( ! ,dead1 & ! l2 "u ! latt]1 ! s]vices ( ,ord9ation & ,confirmation & ! ,=m ( ,consecration ( a ,*ur* or ,*apel4 ,9 ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& z x exi/$ be=e ! ,re=mation1 ^! f\r volumes1 z ,i h call$ !m1 7 di/9ct & recogniz$ realities4 ,ea* _h its title & ea* its sep>ate use4 ,! "n ( ! book ( daily s]vices 0 ,! ,brevi>y4 ,! "n ( ! book us$ 9 ! celebration ( ! ,holy ,communion 0 ,! ,missal4 ,! "n ( ! book ( ,special ,(fices 0 ,! ,ritual4 ,! "n ( ! book ( su* (fices z c\ld be us$ by a bi%op only 0 ,! ,pontifical4 ,x 0 "o ( ! greate/ ( ! a*ievem5ts ( ! ,engli% re=m]s t !y succe$$ 9 cond5s+1 aft] a practical fa%ion1 ^! f\r books1 or1 to speak m accurately1 ! fir/ ?ree ( !m1 ,brevi>y1 ,missal1 & ,ritual1 into "o4 ,! ,pontifical1 or ,ord9al1 !y cont9u$ z a sep>ate book1 al?\gh x soon = ! sake ( conv5i5ce became cu/om>y 9 ,engl&1 z x has always be5 cu/om>y "h1 = ,pray] ,book & ,ord9al to be /it*$ toge!r by ! b9d]s into a s+le volume4 ,popul>ly speak+ ! ,pray] ,book is ! entire volume "o pur*ases "u t "n f ! booksell]1 b accurately speak+ ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] ends :]e ,! ,=m & ,mann] ( ,mak+1 ,orda9+1 & ,consecrat+ ,bi%ops1 ,prie/s1 & ,deacons beg9s4 ,f9is %\ld be writt5 aft] ! ,psalt]1 z inde$ f ! ,pray] ,book's ,table ( ,cont5ts pla9ly appe>s4 ,sett+ aside n[1 = ! pres5t1 t portion ( ! =mul>ies :i* corresponds to ! ,ritual & ,pontifical ( ! m$iaeval ,*ur*1 ,i proce$ to speak rapidly ( ! antec$5ts ( ,brevi>y & ,missal4 ,:5ce came !y8 ,& h[ are we to acc\nt = _! be+ sund]$ s di/9ctly z !y are8 ,!y came1 s "s ( ! mo/ ?\ghtful ( liturgical /ud5ts are agre$1 f a s\rce no less remote ?an ! ,temple ( ,solomon1 & !y are sev]$1 to speak figuratively1 by a valley n unlike t :i* 9 our ?\ghts divides ! ,m\nt ( ,beatitudes f ! ,hill ( ,calv>y4 ,9 t memorable build+ to :i* ref]5ce 0 j made1 influ5tial ov] ! de/9ies ( our race z no o!r h\se ( man's mak+ ev] 01 !re w5t on f day to day ^! two ?+s1 psalmody & sacrifice4 ,peace-(f]+1 burnt-(f]+1 s9-(f]+1 ! morn+ oblation1 & ! ev5+ oblation--^! ) o!r c]emonies ( a l "* w5t to make :at we "k z ! sacrificial ritual ( ! temple4 ,b ?is 0 n all4 ,x w\ld appe> t !re 7 o!r s]vices 9 ! temple ov] & above ^? t c\ld /rictly be call$ sacrificial4 ,! ,hebrew ,psalt]1 ! hymn-book ( t e>ly day1 conta9s mu* t 0 evid5tly int5d$ by ! writ]s = temple use1 & ev5 m t c\ld be easily adapt$ to su* use4 ,& al?\gh !re is no direct evid5ce t 9 ,solomon's "t =ms ( pray] o!r ?an ^? associat$ ) sacrificial rites 7 9 use1 yet :5 we f9d m5tion 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t ( p go+ up to ! temple ( ^? lat] days at ! h\r ( pray]1 x seems reasonable to inf] t ! cu/om 0 an anci5t "o1 & t f ! beg9n+ ( ! temple's hi/ory =ms ( wor%ip n /rictly speak+ sacrificial _h be5 a /at$ feature ( ! ritual4 ,b :e!r 9 ! temple or n1 c]ta9ly 9 ! synagogues1 :i* aft] ! return f ! captivity sprang up all ov] ! ,jewi% _w1 s]vices compos$ ( pray]s1 ( psalms1 & ( read+s f ! law & ! prophets 7 ( cont9ual occurr5ce4 ,!re=e we may safely say t ) ^! two =ms ( div9e s]vice1 ! sacrificial & ! simply devotional & didactic1 ! apo/les1 ! f\nd]s ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1 _h be5 famili> f _! *ildhood4 ,!y 7 at home 9 bo? synagogue & temple4 ,!y knew by sight ! ritual ( ! alt>1 & by e> ! ritual ( ! *oir4 ,!y 7 accu/om$ to ! spectacle ( ! prie/ (f]+ ! victim2 !y 7 us$ to he>+ ! s+]s *ant ! psalms4 ,we see ?us :y x is t ! public wor%ip ( ! ,*ur* %\ld h come d[n to u 9 two great l9es1 :y !re %\ld be a tradition ( eu*>i/ic wor%ip &1 p>allel to ?is1 a tradition ( daily pray]2 = z ! "o usage l9ks itself1 9 a s5se1 to ! sacrificial sy/em ( ,god's anci5t p & has 9 x a sugge/ion ( ! temple wor%ip1 s ! o!r seems to %[ a cont9uity ) :at w5t on 9 ^? less pret5ti\s sanctu>ies :i* _h place 9 all ! cities & villages ( ,judea1 & inde$ :]ev]1 ?r\gh\t ! ,roman _w1 ,jewi% coloni/s 7 to be f\nd4 ,! e>lie/ ,*ri/ian disciples hav+ be5 !mselves ,hebrews1 no?+ c\ld h be5 m natural ?an _! m\ld+ ! wor%ip ( ! new ,*ur* 9 g5]al accordance ) ! models t _h /ood be=e _! eyes f *ildhood 9 ! old4 ,! ,psalms 7 sung 9 ! synagogues accord+ to a settl$ pr9ciple4 ,we _c wond]1 !n1 t ! ,psalt] %\ld h cont9u$ to be :at 9 fact x _h always be51 ! hymn-book ( ! ,*ur*4 ,moreov]1 !y _h 9 ! synagogue besides _! psalmody a sy/em ( ,bible read+s1 conf9$1 ( c\rse1 to ! ,old ,te/am5t ,scriptures4 ,?is is not$ 9 ! obs]vation t fell f ,simon ,pet]1 at ! fir/ ,c\ncil ( ! ,*ur*1 ,moses ( old "t ha? 9 e city !m t prea* him1 be+ read 9 ! synagogue e ,sabba? day4 ,scripture lessons1 !re=e1 w\ld be no novelty4 ,we ga!r also f ! ,new ,te/am5t1 n to speak ( o!r au?orities1 t 9 ! apo/olic days p 7 famili> ) :at 7 kn[n z h\rs ( pray]4 ,!re 7 p>ticul> times 9 ! day1 t is to say1 :i* 7 held to be especially appropriate = wor%ip4 ,pet] & ,john w5t up toge!r into ! temple at ! h\r ( pray]1 be+ ! n9? h\r4 ,aga91 at ,joppa1 we f9d ! =m] ( ^! two apo/les go+ up ^u ! h\se-top to pray at ! six? h\r4 ,long be=e ?is ,david _h m5tion$ morn+ & ev5+ & noon z fitt+ h\rs ( pray]1 & "o psalmi/1 9 8 en?usiasm1 _h ev5 gone s f> z to decl>e sev5 times a day to be n too (t5 = giv+ ,god ?anks4 ,!re 0 also ! prec$5t ( ,daniel op5+ 8 w9d[s t[>d ,j]usalem ?ree times a day4 ,z ! love = ord] & sy/em grew ye> by ye> /rong] 9 ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1 ! laws t gov]n ritual w\ld be likely to become m /r+5t1 & s v probably x came to pass4 ,= aught we "k to ! contr>y1 ! obs]vance ( fix$ h\rs ( pray] 0 a matt] ( volunt>y action ) ! ,*ri/ians ( ! fir/ age4 ,!re 01 z we say1 no %all ab\t x4 ,b :5 ! f\nd]s ( ! mona/ic ord]s came ^u ! sc5e a fix$ rule took ! place ( simple cu/om1 & :at _h be5 optional became m&atory4 ,by ! "t we rea* ! m$iaeval p]iod evolution has _h its p]fect "w1 & we f9d 9 exi/5ce a s*eme ( daily s]vice curi\sly & pa9fully elaborate4 ,! m$iaeval !ologians 7 v fond ( classify+ ?+s by sev5s4 ,9 ! symbolism ( ,holy ,scripture sev5 appe>s z ! numb] ( p]fection1 x be+ ! aggregate ( ?ree1 ! numb] ( ,deity1 & f\r1 ! numb] ( ! e>?4 ,accord+ly we f9d 9 ! !ology ( ^? times sev5 sacram5ts1 sev5 deadly s9s1 sev5 contr>y virtues1 sev5 works ( m]cy1 & also sev5 h\rs ( pray]4 ,^! sev5 h\rs 7 kn[n z ,mat9s1 ,prime1 ,ti]ce1 ,sext1 ,nones1 ,vesp]s1 & ,compl5e4 ,! !ory ( ! h\rs ( pray] 0 t at ea* "o ( !m a special (fice ( devotion 0 to be said4 ,beg9n+ be=e sunrise ) mat9s !re 0 to be daily a r\nd ( s]vices at /at$ int]vals culm9at+ at b$time 9 t :i*1 z its "n indicat$1 fill$ out ! s]ies1 ,compl5e4 ,to :at ext5t ?is ideal s*eme ( devotion 0 ev] c>ri$ out 9 practice x is difficult positively to say4 ,probably 9 ! mona/ic & conv5tual life ( ! sev]] ord]s !re 0 an approximation to a punctual obs]vance ( ! h\rs z !y successively arriv$4 ,possibly ! mod]n m9d fails to d full ju/ice to ! conception ( wor%ip on :i* ?is sy/em 0 bas$4 ,^? pr9ciples ( devotion ( :i* ! ros>y is ! visible symbol d n easily comm5d !mselves to u4 ,!y h ab\t !m a sugge/ion ( me*anism4 ,!y rem9d u ( ! ,buddhi/ pray+ :eel1 & seem to put ! ,*ur* 9 ! attitude ( expect+ to be he>d = h] mu* speak+4 ,d\btless _m a pure1 c\rage\s _s f\ght ! good fight ( fai? successfully 9 spite ( all ?is weight ( outw>d obs]vances2 b 9 ! judgm5t ( ! wis] heads among ,engli% *ur*m51 ! "t _h come1 by ! middle ( ! sixte5? c5tury1 :5 ?is complicat$ armor mu/ ei!r be greatly light5$ or else run ! risk ( be+ ca/ aside altoge!r4 ,let ,cranm] tell 8 own /ory4 ,?is is :at he says 9 ! ,preface to ! ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 z to ! ritual grievances ( ! times4 ,! passage is wor? li/5+ to if only = ! qua9tness ( its /rong & :olesome ,engli%3 ,!re 0 nev] any?+ by ! wit ( man s well devis$ or s surely e/abli%$ :i*1 9 cont9uance ( "t1 ha? n be5 corrupt$1 z1 among o!r ?+s1 x may pla9ly appe> by ! common pray]1 9 ! ,*ur*1 commonly call$ div9e s]vice4 ,! fir/ orig9al & gr\nd :]e(1 if a man w\ld se>* out by ! anci5t fa!rs1 he %all f9d t ! same 0 n orda9$ b ( a good purpose1 & = a great advancem5t ( godl9ess1 = !y s ord]$ ! matt] t all ! :ole ,bible1 or ! greate/ "p !re(1 %\ld be read ov] once 9 ! ye> 4 4 4 ,b ^! _m ye>s pa/ ?is godly & dec5t ord] ( ! anci5t fa!rs ha? be5 s alt]$1 brok51 & neglect$ by plant+ 9 unc]ta9 /ories1 leg5ds1 responds1 v]ses1 va9 repetitions1 commemorations1 & synodals t commonly1 :5 any book ( ! ,bible 0 begun1 be=e ?ree or f\r *apt]s 7 read out all ! re/ 7 unread4 ,& 9 ?is sort ! ,book ( ,esaie 0 begun 9 ,adv5t1 & ! ,book ( ,g5esis 9 ,septuagesima1 b !y 7 only begun & nev] read ?r\gh 4 4 4 ,& moreov]1 :]eas ,/4 ,paul w\ld h su* language spok5 to ! p 9 ! ,*ur* z !y might und]/& & h pr(it by he>+ ! same1 ! s]vice 9 ?is ,*ur* ( ,engl& 7^! _m ye>s7 ha? be5 read 9 ,lat9 to ! p1 :i* !y und]/ood n1 s t !y h he>d ) _! e>s only1 & _! he>ts1 _s1 & m9d h n be5 edifi$ !reby 4 4 4 ,moreov]1 ! numb] & h>dness ( ! rules call$ ! ,pie1 & ! manifold *ang+s ( ! s]vice 0 ! cause t to turn ! ,book only 0 s h>d & intricate a matt] t _m times !re 0 m bus9ess to f9d out :at %\ld be read ?an x 0 to read x :5 x 0 f\nd out4 ,^! inconv5i5ces !re=e consid]$1 "h is set =? su* an ord] :]eby ! same %all be r$ress$4 ,z an illu/ration ( :at ,cranm] meant by 8 curi\s phrase1 plant+ 9 unc]ta9 /ories1 take ! foll[+ ,lessons quot$ by ,dr4 ,neale 9 8 ,essays on ,liturgiology3 ,besides ! commemoration ( sa9ts1 writes ?is di/+ui%$ antiqu>ian1 !re are 9 c]ta9 local cal5d]s notices ( national ev5ts connect$ ) ! well-be+ ( ! ,*ur*4 ,?us1 9 ! ,p>isian ,brevi>y1 we h on ! eighte5? ( ,augu/ a commemoration ( ! victory ( ,philip ! ,fair 9 ,fl&]s1 ,a4,d4 #acjd4 ,"h is ! f\r? ( ! appo9t$ lessons3 ,philip ! ,fair1 ,k+ ( ! ,fr5*1 9 ! ye> #acjd1 ab\t ! fea/ ( ,/4 ,m>y ,magdal5e1 hav+ set =? ) 8 bro!rs ,*>les & ,l\is & a l>ge army into ,fl&]s1 pit*$ 8 t5t ne> ,mons1 :]e 0 a camp ( ! rebel ,flem+s4 ,b :51 on ! eighte5? ( ,augu/1 :i* 0 ! ,tuesday aft] ! ,assumption ( ,/4 ,m>y1 ! ,fr5* _h f morn+ till ev5+ /ood on ! def5ce1 & 7 re/+ !mselves at nightfall1 ! enemy1 by a sudd5 attack1 ru%$ on ! camp ) su* fury t ! body-gu>d _h sc>ce "t to def5d him4 ,response4 ,come f ,lebanon1 my sp\se2 come1 & ?\ %alt be cr[n$1 ,! odor ( ?y sweet o9tm5ts is above all p]fumes4 ,v]sicle4 ,! righte\s judge %all give a cr[n ( righte\sness4 ,!n1 aft] ?is %ort int]lude ( snat*es f ,holy ,scripture1 !re foll[s ! ,fif? ,lesson3 ,at ! beg9n+ ( ! fight ! life ( ! k+ 0 9 great dang]1 b %ortly aft]1 8 troops cr[d+ toge!r f all qu>t]s to 8 t5t1 :]e ! battle 0 %>pe/1 obta9$ an illu/ri\s victory ov] ! enemy--& m ( ?is sort until all ( a sudd5 we come ^u ! ,song ( ,solomon aga94 ,v4 ,?\ art all fair1 my love2 come f ,lebanon4 ,r4 ,!y t h n defil$ _! g>m5ts1 !y %all walk ) me 9 :ite1 = !y are wor?y4 ,is n ,cranm]'s contemptu\s m5tion ( ^! unc]ta9 leg5ds & va9 repetitions amply ju/ifi$8 ,& c we be too ?ankful to ! /urdy *ampions ( ! ,re=mation1 :o 9 ! face ( no little opposition & by ef=ts sc>cely appreciat$ to-day1 cut u loose f all responsibility = su* solemn nons5se8 ,!re are "s :o feel aggriev$ t *apt]s f ! ,apocrypha %\ld h f\nd admission to our new lection>y1 & !re are ev5 ^? :o ?9k t ( ! canonical ,scriptures1 passages m edify+ ?an c]ta9 ( ^? appo9t$ to be read might h be5 *os51 b :at w\ld !y ?9k if !y 7 compell$ to he> ! m9i/] at ! lecturn say3 ,"h beg9ne? ! fir/ *apt] ( ! ,adv5tures ( ,philip ! ,fair8 ,b ! re=m]s1 happily1 7 n disc\rag$ by ! port5t\s front ( wood1 hay1 & /ubble :i* ! liturgical edifice ( _! day pres5t$ to ! eye4 ,!y felt conv9c$ t !re 7 also to be f\nd mix$ 9 ) ! build+ mat]ial gold1 silv]1 & preci\s /ones1 & = ^! !y det]m9$ to make dilig5t se>*1 resolv$ mo/ ( all t ! f\ndation laid %\ld be ,jesus ,*ri/4 ,?is sy/em ( canonical h\rs1 !y argu$1 ?is sev5-fold (fice ( daily pray] is all v beautiful 9 !ory1 b x nev] c be made :at 9 fact x nev] 9 ! pa/ has be51 a practicable ?+4 ,let u be cont5t if we c d s mu* z w9 p to _! devotions at morn+ & at night4 ,) ?is object 9 view ,cranm] & 8 associates subject$ ! s]vices ( ! h\rs to a process ( comb9ation & cond5sation4 ,! ,(fices = ! fir/ ?ree h\rs !y compress$ into ,an ,ord] = ,daily ,morn+ ,pray]1 or1 z x 0 call$ 9 ,edw>d's fir/ ,book1 ,an ,ord] = ,mat9s1 & ! ,(fices = ! la/ two h\rs1 namely1 ,vesp]s & ,compl5e1 !y made ov] into ,an ,ord] = ,daily ,ev5+ ,pray]1 or1 z x 0 nam$ 9 ,edw>d's fir/ ,book1 ,an ,ord] = ,ev5song4 ,^! two =mul>ies1 ! ,ord] = ,mat9s & ! ,ord] = ,ev5song1 make ! core & sub/ance ( our pres5t daily (fices4 ,b ! tradition ( daily pray] is only "o ( ! two great devotional h]itages ( ! ,*ur*4 ,) ! de/ruction ( ! temple by ! ,roman soldi]y1 ! sacrificial ritual ( ! ,jewi% ,*ur* came to a sudd5 end2 b x 0 n ,god's purpose t ! memory ( sacrifice %\ld fade out ( m5's m9ds or t ! ?\ght ( sacrifice %\ld be bani%$ f ! field ( wor%ip4 ,ye>s be=e ! day :5 ! legion>ies ( ,titus m>*$ amid flame & smoke1 into ! fall+ sanctu>y ( an out-worn fai?1 "o :o 0 pres5tly to die ^u a cross _h tak5 bread1 _h bless$ x & brok5 x1 & giv+ x to c]ta9 foll[]s ga!r$ ab\t him1 _h said1 ,take1 eat2 ?is is my body1 :i* is giv5 = y3 ?is d 9 remembrance ( me4 ,likewise also he _h tak5 ! cup aft] supp]1 say+1 ,?is cup is ! ,new ,te/am5t 9 my blood :i* is %$ = y4 ,c]ta9ly !re mu/ be a relation ( cause & effect betwe5 ?is sc5e & ! fact1 :i* is a fact1 t ! mo/ anci5t fragm5ts ( primitive ,*ri/ian wor%ip n[ discov]able are =ms = ! due commemoration ( ! sacrifice ( ! dea? ( ,*ri/4 ,^! v5]able monum5ts seem to exclaim z we deciph] !m3 ,ev5 s1 ,"l1 x is done z ?\ did/ say4 ,?y "n1 ,o ,"l1 endure? =ev] & s do? ?y memorial f g5]ation to g5]ation4 ,( ! ref]5ces to ,*ri/ian wor%ip discov]able 9 docum5ts lat] ?an ! ,new ,te/am5t ,scriptures !re are ?ree t /& out ) peculi> prom95ce1 namely1 ! lately discov]$ ,tea*+ ( ! ,twelve ,apo/les1 plac$ by "s au?orities z e>ly z ! fir/ half ( ! second c5tury2 ! fam\s lett] ( ,pl9y to ! ,emp]or ,trajan1 a writ+ ( ! same p]iod2 & ! ,apology or ,def5ce address$ by ,ju/9 ,m>tyr to ,anton9us ,pius ab\t ! ye> #adj aft] ,*ri/4 ,! notewor?y fact 9 connection ) ^! passages is t ( ! ?ree1 two c]ta9ly1 & probably ! ?ird also1 ref] directly to ! ,holy ,communion4 ,9 ! ,tea*+ we h a di/9ct sket* ( a eu*>i/ic s]vice ) ?ree ( ! prescrib$ pray]s app>5tly giv5 9 full4 ,9 ,ju/9 ,m>tyr's acc\nt1 ! evid5ce ( a def9itely e/abli%$ liturgical =m is p]haps less pla91 b no?+ t he says w\ld appe> to be irreconcilable ) ! exi/5ce ( a m or less ela/ic ritual ord]4 ,:e!r he does or does n int5d to describe extemporane\s pray] z =m+ "o feature ( ! eu*>i/ic wor%ip ( ! ,*ri/ians ( 8 "t dep5ds ^u ! translation we give to a s+le ^w 9 8 n>rative4 ,lat] on 9 ! life ( ! ,*ur*1 ?\gh by j h[ mu* lat] is a difficult po9t ( s*ol>%ip1 we are br\ght 9 contact ) a numb] ( =mul>ies1 all ( !m fram$ = ! uses ( eu*>i/ical wor%ip1 all ( !m1 t is to say1 design$ to p]petuate ! comm&m5t1 ,?is d 9 remembrance ( me1 & all ( !m pres]v+1 no matt] 9 :at "p ( ! _w !y may be f\nd1 a c]ta9 /ructural uni=mity4 ,^! are ! primitive liturgies1 z !y are call$1 ! /udy ( :i* has 9 late ye>s atta9$ almo/ to ! dignity ( a sci5ce4 ,z to ! exact measure ( antiquity t ought to be accord$ to ^! v5]able docum5ts ! au?orities diff] & probably w always diff]4 ,dr4 ,neale's en?usiasm c>ri$ him s f> t he 0 p]suad$ & s\ght to p]suade o!rs ( ! exi/5ce ( liturgical quotations 9 ! writ+s ( ,/4 ,paul4 ,?is hypo!sis is at ! pres5t "t g5]ally reject$ by sob]-m9d$ s*ol>s4 ,p]haps ! p]sonal equation ent]s equally into ! conclusions ( ^? :o assign a v late orig9 to ! liturgies1 pu%+ !m along z f> z ! six? or sev5? c5tury4 ,if "o happ5s to h a root$ dislike = prescrib$ =ms ( wor%ip1 & believes !m 9 8 he>t to be bo? unscriptural & unspiritual1 x w be ! mo/ natural ?+ 9 ! _w = him to disp>age :atev] evid5ce makes 9 favor ( ! e>ly orig9 ( liturgies4 ,hammond is s5sible :5 he says 9 ! ,preface to 8 valuable "w entitl$ ,liturgies ,ea/]n & ,we/]n1 ,i h assum$ an int]m$iate position betwe5 ! views ( ^? on ! "o h& :o hold t ! liturgies _h assum$ a recogniz$ & fix$ =m s e>ly z to be quot$ 9 ! ,epi/les to ! ,cor9?ians & ,hebrews 4 4 4 & ( ^?1 on ! o!r1 :o because !re are "s palpable int]polations & m>ks ( comp>atively late date 9 "s ( ! texts1 ass]t broadly t !y are all untru/wor?y & valueless z evid5ce4 ,?is view ,i v5ture to ?9k1 he adds1 equally uncritical & gr\ndless ) ! =m]4 ,to sum up1 ! argum5t 9 behalf ( an apo/olic orig9 = ! ,*ri/ian ,liturgy may be compactly /at$ ?us3 ,! v e>lie/ monum5ts ( ,*ri/ian wor%ip t we possess are rituals ( ?anksgiv+1 hav+ direct ref]5ce to ! sacrifice ( ! dea? ( ,*ri/4 ,go+ back f ^! to ! ,new ,te/am5t we f9d !re ! n>rative ( ! in/itution ( ! ,holy ,communion by ,*ri/ himself1 & 9 connection ) x ! comm&1 ,?is d 9 remembrance ( me4 ,x is1 ,i submit1 a reasonable inf]5ce t ! liturgies 9 ! ma9 fairly repres5t :at x 0 9 ! m9d ( ! apo/le to recognize & e/abli% z prop] ,*ri/ian wor%ip4 ,i d n call x demon/ration1 ,i call x reasonable inf]5ce4 ,!re is a /rik+ p>allelism betwe5 ! argum5t = liturgical wor%ip & ! argum5t = episcopacy4 ,9 bo? cases we take ! gr\nd t cont9uity exi/$ betwe5 ! life ( ! ,*ur* z we f9d x a hundr$ ye>s aft] ! la/ ( ! apo/les _h gone to 8 re/ & ! life ( ! ,*ur* z x is pictur$ 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t4 ,t !re 7 _m *anges dur+ ! int]val mu/ no d\bt be grant$1 b we say t if ^? *anges 7 s]i\s ones affect+ great pr9ciples ( belief or ord]1 ^? :o ma9ta9 t su* a hidd5 revolution took place are b\nd to br+ positive evid5ce to ! fact4 ,?is hi/ory ( ! ,*ur* dur+ ! second c5tury has be5 lik5$ ) m ( +5uity ?an ( poetical beauty to ! pass+ ( a tra9 ?r\gh a railway tunnel4 ,we see ! tra9 ent]1 we see x em]ge1 b its movem5t :ile inside ! tunnel is conceal$ f u4 ,simil>ly we may say t we see ) comp>ative di/9ctness ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* ( ! ,apo/olic ,age1 & we see ) comp>ative di/9ctness ! ,*ur* ( ! ,age ( ,cyprian & ,orig51 b ) respect to ! int]val sep>at+ ! two p]iods we are n inde$ :olly1 b1 we are1 x mu/ be confess$1 v l>gely ignorant4 ,& yet z 9 ! case ( ! tunnel we confid5tly affirm an id5tity betwe5 :at we saw g 9 & :at we see com+ out1 s ) ! doctr9e1 discipl9e1 & wor%ip ( ! ,*ur*1 ! usages ( ! ?ird c5tury1 we argue1 are probably 9 _! lead+ features :at ! usages ( ! fir/ c5tury 74 ,if reason to ! contr>y c be giv51 well & good2 b 9 ! abs5ce ( c\nt]vail+ te/imony we abide by our inf]5ce1 hold+ x to be s\nd4 ,i am f> f wi%+ to ma9ta9 t ^! consid]ations b9d liturgical wor%ip ^u ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* z a matt] ( obligation = all "t4 ,x might be argu$1 & ,i ?9k ) great =ce1 t liturgical wor%ip hav+ be5 univ]sal ?r\gh\t ! anci5t _w1 hea!n z well z ,jewi%1 ! apo/les & fa!rs ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* judg$ x unwise to make any dep>ture at ! outset f a cu/om s inv>iable1 tru/+ x to ! _s ( ! new religion to "w out fre] & less =mal me?ods ( approa*+ ,god ?r\gh ,*ri/ 9 ! times to come4 ,?is1 ,i confess1 /rikes me z a p]fectly legitimate l9e ( reason+ & "o :i* is /r5g!n$ r ?an weak5$ by :at we h se5 happ5 9 ,*ri/5dom s9ce ! sixte5? c5tury4 ,great bodies ( ,*ri/ians h = a p]iod ( "s ?ree hundr$ ye>s be5 wor%ipp+ ,almighty ,god 9 non-liturgical ways1 & h n be5 left )\t witness t _! s]vice 0 acceptable to ! ,div9e ,maje/y4 ,moreov]1 ! fact t absolute rigidity 9 liturgical use nev] 0 insi/$ ^u 9 any age ( ! ,*ur* until ! ,engli% pass$ _! ,act ( ,uni=mity1 makes 9 ! same direction4 ,& yet ev5 aft] ^! all[ances h be5 made1 !re rema9s a consid]able am\nt ( solid satisfaction = ^? :o d adh]e to ! liturgical me?od1 9 ! ?\ght t !y are 9 ! l9e :i* is app>5tly ! l9e ( cont9uity1 & t _! int]pretation ( ! apo/olic purpose ) respect to wor%ip is ! int]pretation t has be5 g5]ally receiv$ 9 ,*ri/5dom z f> back z we c g4 ,,ii4 ,,vicissitudes4 ,c]ta9 ( ! necromanc]s ( ! f> ,ea/ are said to h ! p[] ( caus+ a tree to spr+ up1 spread its bran*es1 blossom1 & be> fruit be=e ! eyes ( ! look]s-on )9 ! space ( a few mom5ts4 ,mod]n liturgies h sometimes be5 br\ght into be+ by a process z extemporane\s z ?is1 b n su* 0 ! g5esis ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,!re are at lea/ eight =ms "u :i* ! ,pray] ,book has be5 f "t to "t au?oritatively set =?--five ,engli%1 "o ,scotti%1 "o ,iri%1 & "o ,am]ican2 s t1 if we w\ld be accurate1 we are b\nd to specify1 :5 we speak ( ,! ,pray] ,book1 :i* ( sev]al ,pray] ,books we h 9 m9d4 ,! tru? is1 !re exi/s 9 connection ) ev]y?+ t gr[s1 :e!r x be plant1 animal1 or build+1 a c]ta9 my/]y l t :i* atta*es to :at1 9 ! case ( a man1 we call p]sonal id5tity4 ,:i* is ! true1 ! actual ,napoleon8 ,is x ! ,napoleon ( ! ,directory1 or ! ,napoleon ( ! ,consulate1 or ! ,napoleon ( ! ,empire8 ,at ea* epo* we disc]n a diff]5t phase ( ! man's "*1 & yet we are compell$ to ackn[l$ge1 9 ! face ( all ! v>iations1 t we h to d ) "o & ! same man4 ,b j z a %ip acquires1 z we may say1 h] p]sonal id5tity :5 %e is laun*$ & nam$1 ev5 ?\gh !re may be a great deal yet to be done 9 ! way ( f9i%+ & furni%+ be=e %e c be pron\nc$ seawor?y1 s x is ) a book t is de/9$ to und]go repeat$ revision & recon/ruction1 x does acquire1 on ! day :5 x is fir/ publi%$1 & fir/ giv5 a di/9ctive title1 a c]ta9 "* ! los+ ( :i* w\ld be ! loss ( p]sonal id5tity4 ,!re is _m an old ca!dral t might prop]ly en\gh be call$ a re-edit$ book 9 /one4 ,norman ar*itecture1 ,e>ly ,engli%1 ,decorat$1 & ,p]p5dicul>1 all are !re1 & yet "o dom9ant ?\ght p]vades ! build+4 ,not)/&+ ! _m times x has be5 ret\*$1 ! fabric /ill expresses to ! eye ! orig9al creative purpose ( ! design]2 !re is no possibility ( our mi/ak+ ,salisbury = ,york or ,pet]bor\gh = ,london4 ,! fir/ ,book ( ,common ,pray] 0 built up ( blocks t = ! mo/ "p _h be5 previ\sly us$ 9 o!r build+s1 b ! result+ /ructure exhibit$1 f ! v mom5t x receiv$ a "n1 su* di/9ct & unmi/akable *>act]i/ics z h gu>ante$ x p]sonal id5tity ?r\gh m ?an ?ree hundr$ ye>s4 ,h5ce1 :ile x is 9 "o s5se true t !re are no few] ?an eight ,books ( ,common ,pray]1 x is 9 ano!r s5se equally true t ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] is "o4 ,an id5tity ( purpose1 ( scope1 & ( _s %[s itself 9 all its v>i\s =ms "u :i* ! book exi/s1 s t :e!r we are speak+ ( ! ,fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ,k+ ,edw>d ! ,six?1 or ( ! book adopt$ by ! ,*ur* ( ,irel& aft] its dise/abli%m5t1 or ( ! ,am]ican ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 :at we h 9 m9d is1 9 a v real & deep s5se1 "o & ! same ?+4 ,let u proce$ n[ to a rapid survey ( ! facts connect$ ) ! fir/ issue ( ! ,common ,pray]4 ,= a p]iod long ant]ior to ! ,re=mation !re _h be5 9 use among ! ,engli% brief books ( devotion kn[n z prim]s1 writt5 9 ! language ( ! p4 ,! fact t ! public s]vices ( ! ,*ur* 7 inv>iably conduct$ 9 ! ,lat9 tongue made a resort to su* exp$i5ts z ?is necess>y1 unless religion 0 to be res]v$ z ! private prop]ty ( ecclesia/ics4 ,by a curi\s process ( evolution ! prim]1 f hav+ be5 9 m$iaeval times a book :olly religi\s & devotional1 has come to be 9 our day a book :olly secul> & educational4 ,we associate x ) ,noah ,web/] & ! ,h>p] ,bro!rs4 ,! ,new ,engl& ,prim] ( ! ,puritans1 ) its odd jumble ( piety & ! ?ree ,r's1 m>ks a po9t ( transition f ! anci5t to ! mod]n type4 ,b ?is by ! way4 ,! prim] we are n[ conc]n$ ) is ! devotional prim] ( ! times j previ\s to ! ,re=mation4 ,?is1 z a rule1 conta9$ pray]s1 ! ,belief1 ! ,ave ,m>ia1 a litany ( "s sort1 ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts1 & :atev] else !re might be t 9 ! m9d ( ! compil] came "u ! head ( ?+s :i* a ,*ri/ian ought to "k4 ,!re 7 ?ree ( ^! prim]s set =? dur+ ! reign ( ,h5ry ! ,eigh?1 "o 9 #aece1 "o 9 #aeci1 & "o 9 #aede4 ,dur+ ! space t int]v5$ betwe5 ! publication ( ! second & t ( ! ?ird ( ^! prim]s1 appe>$ ,! ,litany & ,suffrages1 a =mul>y compil$1 z is g5]ally believ$1 by ,cranm]1 ! !n ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury1 & 9 sub/ance id5tical ) ! ,litany we use to-day4 ,?is ,litany ( #aedd has be5 prop]ly describ$ z ! precursor & fir/ in/alm5t ( ! ,engli% ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,x 0 ! nucleus or c5tre ( cry/allization ab\t :i* ! o!r con/itu5t portions ( our manual ( wor%ip 7 de/9$ to be gr\p$4 ,a qua9t exhortation 0 prefix$ to ?is ,litany1 9 :i* x 0 said to h be5 set =? because ! n und]/&+ ! pray]s & suffrages =m]ly us$ caus$ t ! p came b slackly to ! processions4 ,besides ! prim]s & ! ,litany1 !re 7 pr9t$ 9 ,h5ry's reign v>i\s editions ( a book ( ,epi/les & ,gospels 9 ,engli%4 ,!re 0 also publi%$ a ,psalt] 9 ,lat9 & ,engli%4 ,all ?is look$ r to ! edification ( individual ,*ri/ians 9 _! private devotional life ?an to ! public wor%ip ( ! ,*ur*1 b we are n to suppose t mean:ile ! l>g] int]e/s ( ! :ole body 7 =gott54 ,s e>ly z 9 ! ye> #aedb1 ,convocation1 :i* accord+ to ! ,anglican !ory /&s t[>d ! ,*ur* 9 ! same attitude t ,p>liam5t holds to ! ,/ate1 appo9t$ a ,committee ( ,eight to review & correct ! exi/+ s]vice-books4 ,we "k v little z to ! proce$+s ( ?is committee1 b t some?+ 0 done1 & a real impulse giv5 to liturgical revision1 is evid5c$ by ! fact t at a meet+ ( ,convocation held soon aft] ,k+ ,h5ry's dea? a resolution prevail$ ,t ! books ( ! ,bi%ops & o!rs :o by ! comm& ( ! ,convocation h labor$ 9 exam9+1 re=m+1 & publi%+ ! div9e s]vice1 may be produc$ & laid be=e ! exam9ation ( ?is h\se4 ,! next important /ep 9 ! process we are /udy+ 0 ! publication by au?ority 9 ! e>ly spr+ ( #aedh1 ( an ,ord] ( ! ,communion1 z x 0 call$1 a =mul>y prep>$ by ,cranm] to enable ! prie/1 aft] hav+ consecrat$ ! elem5ts 9 ! usual mann]1 to di/ribute !m to ! p ) ! s5t5ces ( deliv]y spok5 9 ,engli%4 ,! prie/1 t is to say1 0 to proce$ ) ! s]vice ( ! ,mass z usual 9 ! ,lat9 tongue1 b aft] he _h himself receiv$ ! bread & ! w9e1 he 0 to proce$ to a s]vice ( ,communion = ! p 9 a spee* !y c\ld und]/&4 ,almo/ ev]y?+ 9 ?is t5tative docum5t1 z we may call x1 0 subsequ5tly incorporat$ 9 ! ,(fice ( ! ,holy ,communion z we are us+ x to-day4 ,we h1 !n1 z an abid+ result ( ! liturgical exp]im5ts made 9 anticipation ( ! actual sett+ =? ( an au?oritative ,pray] ,book1 ! ,litany & ?is ,ord] ( ! ,communion4 ,! "t 0 n[ ripe = some?+ bett] & m complete2 a new k+ 0 ^u ! ?rone1 & "o ^: c\nsellors 7 bett] dispos$ t[>d *ange ?an ev] ,h5ry _h be54 ,! great movem5t we "k "u ! "n ( ! ,re=mation t\*$ ! life ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* 9 e "o ( its ?ree great dep>tm5ts--doctr9e1 discipl9e1 & wor%ip4 ,9 ,h5ry's m9d1 h[ev]1 ! "q appe>s to h be5 almo/ exclusively "o ( discipl9e or polity4 ,8 qu>rel 0 n ) ! accept$ !ological errors ( 8 day1 = z ,def5d] ( ! ,fai? he cov]$ "s ( ! wor/ ( !m ) 8 %ield4 ,nei!r 0 he ill-dispos$ t[>d ! me?ods & usages ( public wor%ip s f> z we c judge4 ,8 qu>rel fir/1 la/1 & always 0 ) a c]ta9 rival claimant ( p[]1 ^: pret5d$ au?ority he 0 det]m9$ to drive out ( ! realm1 to wit1 ! ,pope4 ,b :ile x 0 ?us ) ,h5ry1 x 0 f> o!rwise ) _m ( ! m ?\ghtful & dev\t among 8 !ologians1 & :5 ! re/ra9t t _h be5 laid on !m 0 remov$ by ! k+'s dea?1 !y welcom$ ! opportunity to apply to doctr9e & wor%ip ! same re=m+ t\* t _h already rem\ld$ polity4 ,an enl>g$ ,committee ( ,convocation sat at ,w9dsor 9 ! summ] ( #aedh1 & z a result !re 0 f9ally set =?1 & ord]$ to be put into use on ,:itsunday1 #aedi1 :at has become kn[n 9 hi/ory z ! ,fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 ,to dwell on ^? features ( ! ,fir/ ,book t h rema9$ unalt]$ to ! pres5t day w\ld be sup]flu\s2 ,i %all !re=e1 9 speak+ ( x1 conf9e myself to ! di/9ctive & *>act]i/ic po9ts 9 :i* x diff]s f ! ,pray] ,books t h succe$$ x4 ,x is wor?y ( note t 9 ! title page ( ! ,fir/ ,book !re is a cle> di/9ction drawn betwe5 ! ,*ur* ,univ]sal1 or :at we call 9 ! ,te ,deum ! holy ,*ur* ?r\gh\t all ! _w1 & t p>ticul> ,*ur* to :i* ,k+ ,edw>d's subjects1 9 virtue ( _! be+ ,engli%m51 belong$4 ,! book is said to be ! ,book ( ! ,common ,pray] & adm9i/ration ( ! ,sacram5ts & o!r ,rites & ,c]emonies ( ,! ,*ur*1 aft] ! use ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,! ,*ur* is recogniz$ z be+ a l>g] &1 p]haps1 old] ?+ ?an ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 :ile at ! same "t x is intimat$ t only ?r\gh su* use ( ^! same pray]s & sacram5ts z ! ,engli% ,*ur* orda9s & au?orizes c ,engli% folk come into communion ) ! great family ( believ]s spread ov] ! :ole e>?4 ,! ,preface is a s+ul>ly racy piece ( ,engli%1 9 :i* ) ! utmo/ pla9ness ( spee* ! compil]s give _! reasons = hav+ dealt ) ! old s]vices z !y h done4 ,?is reappe>s 9 ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book ( ! pres5t day "u ! title ,conc]n+ ! ,s]vice ( ,! ,*ur*1 & s describ$ is plac$ aft] ! ,preface writt5 9 #affb by ! ,revis]s ( ! ,re/oration4 ,! ,ord] = ,daily ,morn+ ,pray]1 z we "n x1 is call$ 9 ,edw>d's ,fir/ ,book ,an ,ord] = ,mat9s daily ?r\gh ! ye>4 ,simil>ly1 :at we call ! ,ord] = ,daily ,ev5+ ,pray] 0 /yl$ ,an ,ord] = ,ev5song4 ,^! beautiful names1 ,mat9s & ,ev5song1 :i* x is a great pity to h lo/1 = surely !re is no?+ sup]/iti\s ab\t !m1 disappe>$ f ! book z subsequ5tly revis$1 & save 9 ! ,lection>y ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& h no pres5t recognition4 ,"o ( !m1 h[ev]1 ,ev5song1 seems to be com+ v g5]ally into colloquial use4 ,! ,ord] = ,mat9s began ) ! ,"l's ,pray]4 ,!n1 aft] ! famili> v]sicles /ill 9 use1 includ+ two t h no place 9 our ,am]ican book1 ,o ,god1 make spe$ to save me4 ,o ,"l1 make ha/e to help me1 !re foll[$ 9 full ! #ie? ,psalm1 a portion ( :i* is kn[n to u z ! ,v5ite4 ,f ?is po9t ! s]vice proce$$1 z 9 ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book ( to-day1 ?r\gh ! ,collect = ,grace1 :]e x came to an end4 ,! /ructure ( ,ev5song 0 simil>1 beg9n+ ) ! ,"l's ,pray] & end+1 z our %ort5$ ,ev5+ ,pray] n[ does1 ) ! ,collect = ,aid aga9/ ,p]ils4 ,!n foll[$ ! ,a?anasian ,cre$1 & imm$iately aft]w>d came ! ,introits1 ,collects1 ,epi/les1 & ,gospels4 ,^! ,introits1 s-call$1 7 psalms appo9t$ to be sung :5 ! prie/ 0 ab\t to beg9 ! ,holy ,communion4 ,!y _h be5 an anci5t feature ( div9e s]vice1 b 7 dropp$ f ! subsequ5t books z a requir$ feature ( ! ,*ur*'s wor%ip4 ,! title ( ! ,communion ,s]vice 9 ,edw>d's ,fir/ ,book is z foll[s3 ,! ,supp] ( ! ,"l & ! ,holy ,communion commonly call$ ! ,mass4 ,imm$iately aft] ! ,pray] = ,purity--i4 e41 9 ! place :]e we h ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts1 comes ! ,gloria 9 ,excelsis4 ,! s]vice !n proce$s v mu* z ) u1 except t ! ,pray] = ! ,*ur* ,militant & ! ,consecration ,pray] are weld$ into "o1 & ! ,pray] ( ,humble ,access giv5 a place imm$iately be=e ! reception ( ! elem5ts4 ,i note1 9 pass+1 c]ta9 phrases & s5t5ces t are peculi> to ! ,communion ,(fice ( ! ,fir/ ,book1 z1 = in/ance1 ?is f ! ,pray] = ! :ole /ate ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur*3 ,& "h we d give unto !e mo/ high praise & he>ty ?anks = ! wond]ful grace & virtue decl>$ 9 all ?y sa9ts f ! beg9n+ ( ! _w1 & *iefly 9 ! mo/ glori\s & bless$ ,virg9 ,m>y1 ,"m ( ?y ,son ,jesus ,*ri/ our ,"l & ,god1 & 9 ! holy patri>*s1 prophets1 apo/les1 & m>tyrs1 ^: examples1 ,o ,"l1 & /eadfa/ness 9 ?y fai? & keep+ ?y holy comm&m5ts grant u to foll[4 ,we comm5d unto ?y m]cy1 ,o ,"l1 all o!r ?y s]vants :i* are dep>t$ h5ce f u ) ! sign ( fai? & d n[ re/ 9 ! sleep ( peace4 ,grant unto !m1 we besee* !e1 ?y m]cy & ev]la/+ peace1 & t at ! day ( ! g5]al resurrection we & all !y :i* be ( ! my/ical body ( ?y ,son may altoge!r be set on 8 "r h&4 ,& ?is f ! clos+ portion ( ! ,consecration3 ,yet we besee* !e to accept ?is our b\nd5 duty & s]vice1 & comm& ^! our pray]s & supplications by ! m9i/ry ( ?y holy angels to be br\ght up into ?y holy tab]nacle be=e ! sight ( ?y div9e maje/y4 ,foll[+ close ^u ! ,communion ,s]vice came ! ,litany1 diff]+ v little f :at we h to-day1 save 9 ! memorable petition1 ,f ! tyranny ( ! ,bi%op ( ,rome & all 8 dete/able enormities1 good ,"l deliv] u4 ,! ,baptismal ,(fices ( ! ,fir/ ,book conta9 c]ta9 unique features4 ,! sign ( ! cross is ord]$ to be made on ! *ild's brea/ z well z on 8 =ehead4 ,!re is a =m ( exorcism said ov] ! infant 9 :i* ! unclean _s is comm&$ to come out & to dep>t4 ,!re is also ! giv+ ( ! ,crisome or :ite ve/ure z a symbol ( innoc5ce4 ,take ?is :ite ve/ure = a tok5 ( ! innoc5cy :i* by ,god's grace 9 ?is holy sacram5t ( ,baptism is giv5 unto !e1 & = a sign :]eby ?\ art admoni%$1 s long z ?\ live/1 to give ?yself to innoc5cy ( liv+1 t aft] ?is transitory life ?\ maye/ be p>tak] ( ! life ev]la/+4 ,! ,cate*ism 9 ,edw>d ,,vi4 ,fir/ ,book1 z 9 ! subsequ5t books d[n to #affb1 is made a "p ( ! ,confirmation ,(fice1 al?\gh x does n cle>ly appe> t ! *ildr5 7 expect$ to say x z a prelim9>y to ! s]vice4 ,! ,(fice = ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick conta9s provision = private confession & absolution1 & also directs t ! prie/ %all ano9t ! sick man ) oil if he be desir$ to d s4 ,! ,(fice = ! ,communion ( ! ,sick all[s ! practice ( :at is call$ ! res]vation ( ! elem5ts1 b conta9s also1 be x obs]v$1 t rubric :i* has held its place ?r\gh all ! *anges ! ,pray] ,book has und]gone1 :]e we are taught t if ! sick man by any j imp$im5t fail to receive ! sacram5t ( ,*ri/'s body & blood1 ! curate %all in/ruct him t if he d truly rep5t him ( 8 s9s & /eadfa/ly believe t ,jesus ,*ri/ ha? suff]$ dea? ^u ! cross = him 4 4 4 he do? eat & dr9k ! body & blood ( our ,savi\r ,*ri/1 pr(itably to 8 s\l's heal? al?\gh he d n receive ! sacram5t ) 8 m\?4 ,! ,burial ,(fice conta9s a recognition ( pray] = ! dead1 b except 9 ! matt] ( ! arrangem5t ( ! p>ts diff]s b little f ! s]vice /ill 9 use4 ,a special ,introit1 ,collect1 ,epi/le1 & ,gospel are appo9t$ = ! ,celebration ( ! ,holy ,communion :5 !re is a ,burial ( ! ,dead4 ,a ,comm9ation ,(fice = ,a%-,w$nesday1 sub/antially id5tical ) t /ill 9 use 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 concludes ! book4 ,! ,fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ,k+ ,edw>d ! ,six?1 memorable z x 0 de/9$ to become1 prov$1 s f> z actual use 0 conc]n$1 b %ort-liv$4 ,x became op]ative1 z we h se51 on ,:itsunday1 #aedi1 b x 0 soon evid5t t :ile ! new s]vices w5t too f> 9 ! direction ( re=m to please ! fri5ds ( ! anci5t ord] ( ?+s1 !y did n g f> en\gh to meet ! wi%es ( ! re=m+ p>ty4 ,be=e ! ye> 0 out no few] ?an ?ree translations ( ! ,liturgy into ,lat9 _h be5 und]tak5 ) a view to in=m+ ! ,prote/ant div9es ( ! ,cont95t z to :at _! ,engli% colleagues 7 do+4 ,!re 0 already )9 ! ,*ur* 7( ,engl&71 writes ,c>dwell1 9 8 comp>ison ( ,edw>d's two books1 a p>ty1 ?\gh probably n num]\s1 :i* esp\s$ ! peculi> s5tim5ts ( ,calv92 !re 7 o!rs1 & ,cranm]1 x appe>s1 _h rec5tly be5 "o ( !m1 adh]+ /rictly to ! op9ions ( ,lu!r2 !re 7 _m1 & ^? among ! mo/ active & ! mo/ le>n$1 :o adopt$ ! views ( ,bull+] & ! !ologians ( ,zuri*2 !re 0 a /ill l>g] body anxi\s to comb9e all classes ( ,prote/ants "u "o g5]al confession1 & all ^!1 ?\gh ) di/9ct objects & diff]5t degrees ( impati5ce1 look$ =w>d to a revision ( ! ,liturgy1 to br+ x m completely into accordance ) _! own s5tim5ts4 ,z a result ( ! agitation ?us vividly pictur$ by ,c>dwell1 !re came =? 9 #aeeb ! book kn[n z ! ,second ,pray] ,book ( ,k+ ,edw>d ,,vi41 a "w ( ! v greate/ int]e/1 = ! reason t x 0 de/9$ to become ! basis ( all future revisions4 ,:itsunday1 #aedi1 0 ! day :5 ! ,fir/ ,book began to be us$4 ,! ,fea/ ( ,all ,sa9ts1 #aeeb1 0 ! date (ficially appo9t$ = ! introduction ( ! ,second ,book4 ,pres5tly ,k+ ,edw>d di$1 & by an act ( ,m>y pass$ 9 ,octob]1 #aeec1 ! use ( 8 ,book became illegal on & aft] ,decemb] #bj? ( t ye>4 ,x ?us appe>s t ! ,fir/ ,book 0 9 use = two ye>s & ab\t f\r mon?s1 & ! ,second ,book "o ye> & ab\t two mon?s4 ,a memorable ?ree ye>s & a half = ! ,engli%-speak+ peoples ( all "t to come1 = x is n too mu* to say t :ile ! language ( ,tyndale & ( ,cranm] cont9ues to be he>d on e>?1 ! devotions !n put into =m w keep on m\ld+ ! religi\s ?\ght & fir+ ! spiritual imag9ation ( ?is race4 ,! po9ts 9 :i* ! second ( ,k+ ,edw>d's two books diff]s f ! fir/ are ( su* s]i\s mom5t & ! g5]al complexion ( ! lat] "w has 9 x su* an access ( ,prote/ant color+1 t high ,anglican writ]s h be5 9 ! habit ( attribut+ ! ma9 features ( ! revision to ! int]f]5ce ( ! ,cont95tal ,re=m]s4 ,if x _h n be5 = ! imp]t95t m$dl+1 !y h be5 accu/om$ to say1 ( su* =eign]s z ,buc]1 ,pet] ,m>tyr1 & ,john a-,lasco1 we might h be5 enjoy+ at ! pres5t day ! admirable & truly ,ca?olic devotions set =? 9 ! fre% morn+ ( ! ,re=mation1 be=e ! e>?-born vapors ( !ological controv]sy & ecclesia/ical p>tisan%ip _h becl\d$ an o!rwise fair sky4 ,b x does n appe> t !re is any solid f\ndation 9 fact = ^! compla9ts4 ,! natural spread ( ! _s ( re=m among ! p ( ! realm1 tak5 9 connection ) ! *anges ( op9ion :i* ! swift movem5t ( ! times necess>ily eng5d]$ 9 ! m9ds ( ! lead+ div9es1 are ( !mselves q suffici5t to acc\nt = :at took place4 ,c]ta9ly1 if ! ,engli% ( t day 7 at all l _! desc5dants 9 our "t1 x is 9 ! highe/ degree unlikely t !y w\ld h all[$ a h&ful ( le>n$ refugees to =ce ^u !m *anges :i* _! own sob] judgm5t did n approve4 ,! tru? is1 v little is c]ta9ly kn[n z to ! details ( :at 0 done 9 ! mak+ ( ,edw>d's ,second ,book4 ,ev5 ! names ( ! memb]s ( ! committee intru/$ ) ! revision are matt] ( conjecture1 & ( ! proce$+s ( t body no au!ntic record survives4 ,:at we d possess & are 9 a position to criticise is ! book itself1 & to a brief review ( ! po9ts 9 :i* x diff]s f its pr$ecessor we w n[ pass4 ,^u tak+ up ! ,second ,book aft] lay+ d[n ! ,fir/1 "o is /ruck imm$iately ) ! *ang$ look ( ,morn+ ,pray]4 ,?is is no long] call$ ,mat9s1 & no long] beg9s z be=e ) ! ,"l's ,pray]4 ,an ,introduction has be5 prefix$ to ! (fice consi/+ ( a collection ( s5t5ces f ,holy ,scripture1 all ( !m ( a p5it5tial "*1 & besides ^! ( an ,exhortation1 a ,confession1 & an ,absolution4 ,!re c be little d\bt t ?is opportunity = mak+ public ackn[l$gm5t ( s9 & he>+ ! decl>ation ( ,god's will+ness to =give1 0 meant to c\nt]balance ! removal f ! book ( all ref]5ce1 save 9 "o in/ance1 to private confession & absolution4 ,! ,*ur* ( ,engl& has always reta9$ 9 h] ,visitation ,(fice a p]mission to ! prie/ to pron\nce absolution privately to ! sick man4 ,?is 0 a feature ( ! ,fir/ ,book t 0 n di/urb$ 9 ! ,second4 ,b :]ev] else !y f\nd any?+ t seem$ to look t[>d ! cont9uance ( ! sy/em famili>ly kn[n to u "u ! "n ( ! ,confessional1 !y expung$ x4 ,betwe5 ! ,exhortation & ! ,confession !re is1 9 po9t ( lit]>y m]it1 a noticeable contra/1 & x is sc>cely to be believ$ t bo? =mul>ies c h proce$$ f "o & ! same p54 ,ano!r /ep 9 ! ,prote/ant direction 0 ! prohibition ( c]ta9 ve/m5ts t 9 ! ,fir/ ,book _h be5 all[$1 z ! alb & cope4 ,! ,introit ,psalms 7 tak5 away4 ,! ^w table 0 ev]y:]e sub/itut$ = ! ^w alt>4 ,! *anges 9 ! ,(fice ( ! ,holy ,communion 7 num]\s & significant4 ,! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts1 = in/ance1 7 ins]t$ 9 ! place :]e we n[ h !m4 ,! ,gloria 9 ,excelsis 0 transf]r$ f ! beg9n+ ( ! s]vice to ! end4 ,! ,exhortations 7 re-writt54 ,! supplication = ! dead 0 tak5 out ( ! ,pray] = ! :ole /ate ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur*1 & ! words militant "h on e>? 7 add$ to ! title ) a view to conf9+ ! scope ( ! int]cession to ! circle ( p /ill alive4 ,! ,confession1 ,absolution1 ,com=table ,words1 & ,pray] ( ,humble ,access 7 plac$ be=e ! ,consecration in/ead ( aft] x4 ,mo/ important ( all 0 ! *ange ( ! words appo9t$ to be said 9 deliv]+ ! elem5ts to ! communicants4 ,9 ! ,fir/ ,book ^! _h be51 ,! body ( our ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/ :i* 0 giv5 = !e1 pres]ve ?y body & s\l unto ev]la/+ life1 & 9 ! case ( ! cup1 ,! blood ( our ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/1 :i* 0 %$ = !e1 pres]ve ?y body & s\l unto ev]la/+ life4 ,= ^! 7 n[ sub/itut$ 9 ! "o in/ance ! words1 ,take & eat ?is 9 remembrance t ,*ri/ di$ = !e1 & fe$ on him 9 ?y he>t by fai?1 ) ?anksgiv+1 & 9 ! o!r1 ,dr9k ?is 9 remembrance t ,*ri/'s blood 0 %$ = !e1 & be ?ankful4 ,f ! ,(fice = ! ,communion ( ! ,sick ! direction to res]ve ! elem5ts 0 omitt$1 z 0 also ! p]mission to ano9t ! sick man ) oil4 ,! ,s]vice ( ,baptism 0 no long] suff]$ to reta9 ! exorcism ( ! evil _s1 or ! :ite ve/ure1 or ! unction2 & !re 7 o!r items ( less important *ange4 ,^? m5tion$ reveal pla9ly en\gh :at 0 ! animus ( ! revis]s4 ,mo/ evid5tly ! int5tion 0 to produce a liturgy m ?or\ghly re=m$1 m 9 h>mony ) ! new tone & temp] :i* ! religi\s ?\ght ( ! times 0 tak+ on4 ,we come to ! ,?ird ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,bloody ,m>y 0 dead1 & ,elizabe? _h succe$$ to ! ?rone4 ,dur+ ! ,roman reaction proclamation _h be5 made t all ! ,re=m$ s]vice-books %\ld be giv5 up to ! ecclesia/ical au?orities )9 fifte5 days to be burn$4 ,?is is d\btless ! reason :y copies ( ! liturgical books ( ,edw>d's reign are n[ s exce$+ly r>e4 ,repr9ts ( !m ab\nd1 b ! orig9als exi/ only z co/ly curiosities4 ,soon aft] ,elizabe?'s accession a committee ( div9es assembl$ "u h] au?ority = ! purpose ( aga9 revis+ ! =mul>ies4 ,! que5 0 p]sonally a ,high-,*ur*woman1 & h] own judgm5t is said to h be5 favorable to tak+ ! fir/ ( ,edw>d's two books z ! basis ( ! revision1 b a contr>y pref]5ce sway$ ! committee1 & ! l9es foll[$ 7 ^? ( #aeeb & n ^? ( #aedi4 ,! new features di/9ctive ( ! ,pray] ,book ( ,elizabe?1 o!rwise kn[n z ! ,pray] ,book ( #aeei1 are n num]\s4 ,a table ( ,prop] ,lessons = ,sundays 0 introduc$4 ,! old ve/m5ts recogniz$ 9 ! e>li] "p ( ,k+ ,edw>d's reign 7 aga9 legaliz$4 ,! petition = deliv]ance f ! tyranny ( ! ,pope 0 /ruck out ( ! ,litany1 & by a compromise peculi>ly ,engli% 9 its "*1 &1 z exp]i5ce has %[n1 exce$+ly well judg$1 ! two =ms ( words t _h be5 us$ 9 ! deliv]y ( ! elem5ts 9 ! ,holy ,communion 7 weld$ toge!r into ! %ape 9 :i* we h !m /ill4 ,que5 ,elizabe?'s ,pray] ,book cont9u$ 9 use = five-&-=ty ye>s4 ,no?+ 0 m natural ?an t :5 %e di$ !re %\ld come ) ! accession ( a new dyna/y a dem& = fre% revision4 ,k+ ,james1 :o 0 n afflict$ ) any want ( confid5ce 9 8 own judgm5t1 invit$ c]ta9 repres5tatives ( ! disaffect$ p>ty to meet1 "u 8 presid5cy1 ! ,*ur*m5 9 c\ncil ) a view to ! settlem5t ( diff]5ces4 ,! ,puritans _h be5 ga9+ 9 /r5g? dur+ ,elizabe?'s reign1 & !y felt t !y 7 n[ 9 position to dem& a l>g] measure ( liturgical re=m ?an t mon>* & h] advis]s _h be5 will+ to conc$e to !m4 ,k+ ,james conv5$ 8 conf]5ce at ,hampton ,c\rt1 ne> ,london1 & he himself 0 good en\gh to preside4 ,v little came ( ! debate4 ,! ,puritans _h dem&$ ! discont9uance ( ! sign ( ! cross 9 ,baptism1 ( b[+ at ! "n ( ,jesus1 ( ! r+ 9 m>riage1 & ( ! rite ( confirmation4 ,! words prie/ & absolution !y s\ght to h expung$ f ! ,pray] ,book1 & !y desir$ t ! we>+ ( ! surplice %\ld be made optional4 ,almo/ no?+ 0 conc$$ to !m4 ,! words or ,remission ( ,s9s 7 add$ to ! title ( ! ,absolution1 c]ta9 ,pray]s & ,?anksgiv+s 7 introduc$1 & t portion ( ! ,cate*ism :i* deals ) ! ,sacram5ts 0 = ! fir/ "t set =?4 ,& ?us ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book />t$ out ^u its f\r? lease ( life de/9$ 9 ?is =m to endure un*ang$1 ?\gh by no means unassail$1 = m ?an half a c5tury4 ,a /irr+ half c5tury x 04 ,! ,puritan defeat at ,hampton ,c\rt 0 r$ress$ at ,naseby4 ,) ! com+ 9 ( ! ,long ,p>liam5t ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] w5t out1 & to all appe>ances ! triumph ( ! ,commonweal? meant ! f9al ext9ction ( ! usage ( liturgical wor%ip on ,engli% soil4 ,! book1 "u its v>i\s =ms1 _h la/$ j a hundr$ ye>s :5 he :o ,no?+ common did or mean ,^u t memorable sc5e suff]$ at ,:itehall4 ,!y buri$ him 9 ,/4 ,george's ,*apel1 ,w9dsor1 & no s+le ^w ( ! ,pray] ,book he _h lov$ & = :i* he _h f\ght 0 said ov] 8 grave4 ,on ,janu>y #c1 #afde1 ,p>liam5t repeal$ ! /atutes ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 & ( ,elizabe? t _h enjo9$ ! use ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 & took ord] t !reaft] only su* div9e s]vice %\ld be lawful z accord$ ) :at 0 call$ ! ,directory1 a manual ( sugge/ions ) respect to public wor%ip adopt$ by ! ,presbyt]ian p>ty z a sub/itute = ! anci5t liturgy4 ,) ! re/oration ( ! ,/u>ts 9 #affj came naturally ! re/oration ( ! ,pray] ,book1 & ) equal naturalness a revision ( x4 ,b ( :at sort %\ld ! revision be1 & "u ^: auspices conduct$8 ,?is 0 an anxi\s "q = ! advis]s1 civil & ecclesia/ical1 ( ! re/or$ k+4 ,%\ld ! second ,*>les take up ! book j z x _h fall5 f ! h&s ( ! fir/ ,*>les1 un*ang$ 9 l9e or lett]1 or %\ld he seek by judici\s alt]ations & timely concessions to w9 back = ! national ,*ur* ! good-w & loyalty ( ^? :o1 eighte5 ye>s be=e1 _h brok5 d[n h] h$ge8 ,! situation may be describ$ z triangul>4 ,! k+'s secret & p]sonal sympa?ies 7 probably all along ) ! ,roman ,*ur*2 8 (ficial allegiance 0 pla9ly due to ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&2 & yet1 at ! same "t1 he ow$ mu* to ! =be>ance ( ! m5 :o _h be5 dom9ant "u ! ,commonweal?4 ,! m9d ( ! nation _h1 inde$1 react$ t[>d mon>*y1 b n ) su* an absolute & h>dy r5unciation ( ! doctr9es ( popul> sov]eignty z to make x safe = ! return+ k+ to d precisely z he *ose4 ,! glori\s ,revolution t 0 de/9$ s soon to foll[ ^u ! heels ( ! graci\s ,re/oration gave evid5ce1 :5 x came1 t !re 7 "s ?+s ! p ( ,engl& priz$ ev5 m highly ?an an h]$it>y ?rone4 ,misgiv+s z to ! am\nt !re might /ill be ( ?is sort ( electricity 9 ! atmosph]e sugge/$ to ! k+ & 8 c\nsellors ! exp$i5cy ( hold+ a conf]5ce1 at :i* ! lead]s on ei!r side might br+ =w>d _! /rong reasons 9 favor ( ?is or t me?od ( deal+ ) ! ecclesia/ical "q 9 g5]al1 & m especially ) ! vex$ problem ( wor%ip4 ,accord+ly1 e>ly 9 ! spr+ ( #affa ! ,k+ issu$ a royal w>rant summon+ to meet at ! ,savoy ,palace 9 ! ,/r& an equal numb] ( repres5tatives ( bo? p>ties--namely1 "o-&-tw5ty ,*ur*m5 & "o-&-tw5ty ,presbyt]ians4 ,! ,episcopal deputation consi/$ ( twelve bi%ops & n9e o!r div9es call$ coadjutors4 ,! ,presbyt]ians _h also _! twelve pr9cipal m5 & _! n9e coadjutors4 ,conspicu\s among ! ,episcopalians = weight ( le>n+ 7 ,bi%ops ,s&]son1 ,cos91 & ,walton1 & ,doctors ,pe>son1 ,sp>r[1 & ,heyl94 ,baxt]1 ,reynolds1 ,calamy1 & ,lightfoot 7 ! mo/ notable ( ! ,presbyt]ians4 ,! conf]5ce1 :i* has ev] s9ce be5 kn[n f its place ( meet+ 7an old palace ( ! ,pi$montese ,ambassadors7 z ! ,savoy ,conf]5ce1 conv5$ on ,april #ae1 #affa4 ,= v>i\s reasons1 x 0 evid5t f ! outset t ! ,*ur*m5 7 9 a position ( great advantage4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 signs & tok5s ( a r5ew$ confid5ce 9 mon>*y & ( a reviv$ atta*m5t to ! reign+ ,h\se 7 becom+ daily m num]\s4 ,be=e he _h _h a *ance to te/ ! /r5g? ( ! exi/+ political p>ties & to "k h[ ?+s really /ood1 ,*>les _h borne himself v discreetly t[>d ! ,presbyt]ians1 & _h held out hopes to !m :i*1 z ! ev5t prov$1 7 de/9$ nev] to be realiz$4 ,9 a decl>ation put =? 9 ! autumn ( #affj1 aft] he _h be5 = "s mon?s on ,engli% soil1 he _h ev5 gone s f> z to say3 ,:5 we 7 9 ,holl& we 7 att5d$ by _m grave & le>n$ m9i/]s f h5ce1 :o 7 look$ ^u z ! mo/ able & pr9cipal ass]t]s ( ! ,presbyt]ian op9ions2 ) :om we _h z mu* conf]5ce z ! multitude ( affairs :i* 7 !n ^u u w\ld p]mit u to h1 & to our great satisfaction & com=t f\nd !m p]sons full ( affection to u1 ( zeal = ! peace ( ! ,*ur* & ,/ate1 & nei!r enemies1 z !y h be5 giv5 out to be1 to episcopacy or liturgy1 b mode/ly to desire su* alt]ations 9 ei!r1 z )\t %ak+ f\ndations might be/ allay ! pres5t di/emp]s4 ,by ! "t ! conf]5ce met x _h become evid5t1 f votes tak5 9 ,p>liam5t & o!rwise1 t ! ,*ur*m5 c\ld su/a9 t[>d _! oppon5ts a some:at /iff] attitude ?an ?is )\t imp]ill+ _! cause4 ,ano!r great advantage enjoy$ by ! ,episcopalians grew out ( ! fact t !y 7 ! p>ty 9 possession4 ,!y _h only to pr(ess !mselves satisfi$ ) ! ,pray] ,book z x /ood1 9 ord] to ?r[ ! ,presbyt]ians into ! position ( assailants1 & def5se is always easi] ?an attack4 ,%eldon1 ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 0 n sl[ to p]ceive ?is4 ,at ! v fir/ meet+ ( ! conf]5ce1 he is report$ to h said t z ! ,non-con=mi/s1 & n ! bi%ops1 _h s\ght = ! conf]5ce1 no?+ c\ld be done till ! =m] _h deliv]$ _! exceptions 9 writ+1 toge!r ) ! additional =ms & alt]ations :i* !y desir$4 ,^u :i* ,bi%op ,burnet 9 8 ,hi/ory ( 8 own ,times rem>ks3 ,%eldon saw well :at ! effect w\ld be ( putt+ !m to make all _! dem&s at once4 ,! numb] ( !m rais$ a mighty outcry aga9/ !m1 z p t c\ld nev] be satisfi$4 ,! ,presbyt]ians1 h[ev]1 took up ! *all5ge1 set to "w at =mulat+ _! objections1 & appo9t$ ,ri*>d ,baxt]1 ! mo/ fam\s ( _! numb]1 to %[ :at c\ld be done 9 ! way ( mak+ a bett] manual ( wor%ip ?an ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,baxt]1 a truly great man & wise 9 a way1 ?\gh sc>cely 9 ! liturgical way1 0 guilty ( ! incr$ible folly ( und]tak+ to con/ruct a ,pray] ,book )9 a =tnight4 ,( ?is liturgy x is probably safe to say t no d5om9ation ( ,*ri/ians1 h[ev] anti-prelatical or ecc5tric1 w\ld = a mom5t dream ( adopt+ x1 if1 inde$1 !re be a s+le local congregation any:]e t c\ld be p]suad$ to employ x4 ,! *>act]i/ic ( ! devotions is l5g?9ess4 ,! op5+ s5t5ce ( ! pray] ) :i* ! book beg9s conta9s by actual c\nt eighty-?ree words4 ,x is probable t ,baxt] by 8 ra% act did m to injure ! cause ( intellig5t & rev]5tial liturgical revision ?an any t5 m5 h done be=e or s9ce4 ,9 e discussion ( ! subject he is almo/ sure to be br\ght =w>d z ! awful example4 ,a docum5t mu* m to ! po9t ?an ,baxt]'s ,liturgy 0 ! =mal catalogue ( faults & blemi%es alleg$ aga9/ ! ,pray] ,book1 :i* ! ,puritan memb]s ( ! conf]5ce 9 due "t br\ght 94 ,?is indictm5t1 = x may fairly be call$ su*1 s9ce x 0 drawn up 9 sep>ate c\nts1 is v int]e/+ read+4 ,( ! exceptions aga9/ ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 z ! ,puritans nam$ _! li/ ( liturgical grievances1 "s mu/ /rike almo/ any read] ( ! pres5t day z trivial & unwor?y4 ,o!rs aga9 !re are t draw a sympa!tic ,am5 f _m qu>t]s to-day4 ,to an ,am]ican ,episcopalian ! catalogue is *iefly int]e/+ z %[+ h[ ready & ev5 eag] 7 our colonial ance/ors ( a hundr$ ye>s ago to remove out ( ! way su* kn[n rocks ( (f5ce z !y c\ld4 ,an att5tive /ud5t ( ! ,am]ican ,pray] ,book _c fail to be /ruck ) ! numb] ( in/ances 9 :i* ! text gives evid5ce ( ! influ5ce ex]t$ ov] ! m9ds ( our revis]s by :at _h be5 urg$1 m ?an a hundr$ ye>s be=e1 by ! ,puritan memb]s ( ! ,savoy ,conf]5ce4 ,! defeat ( #affa 01 9 a measure at lea/1 av5g$ 9 #aghi4 ,x is enc\rag+ to ^? :o ca/ _! bread ^u liturgical wat]s to notice aft] h[ _m days ! return may come4 ,b ! conf]5ce1 to all outw>d seem+1 0 a failure4 ,baxt]'s unhappy ,pray] ,book 0 its own suffici5t refutation1 & z = ! li/ ( special grievances x 0 met by ! bi%ops ) an ,answ] t 0 full ( h>d raps & conc$$ almo/ no?+4 ,a few deta*$ p>agraphs may s]ve to illu/rate ! g5]al tone ( ?is reply4 ,"h1 = in/ance1 is ! comm5t ( ! bi%ops ^u ! reque/ ( ! ,puritans to be all[$ occasionally to sub/itute extemporane\s = liturgical devotions4 ,! gift or r _s ( pray] consi/s 9 ! inw>d graces ( ! _s1 n 9 extempore expressions :i* any man ( natural p>ts hav+ a voluble tongue & audacity may atta9 to )\t any special gift4 ,no?+ v conciliatory 9 t4 ,to ! compla9t t ! ,collects are too %ort1 ! bi%ops reply t !y _c = t reason be acc\nt$ faulty1 be+ l ^? %ort b preval5t pray]s 9 ,scripture1 ,"l1 be m]ciful to me a s9n]4 ,"l1 increase our fai?4 ,! ,puritans _h object$ to ! antiphonal elem5t 9 ! ,pray]-,book s]vices1 & desir$ to h no?+ ( a responsive "* all[$ beyond ! s+le ^w ,am54 ,b1 rejo9 ! bi%ops1 !y directly practise ! contr>y 9 "o ( _! pr9cipal p>ts ( wor%ip1 s++ ( psalms1 :]e ! p be> z great a "p z ! m9i/]4 ,if ?is way be done 9 ,hopk9's :y n 9 ,david's ,psalms2 if 9 metre1 :y n 9 prose2 if 9 a psalm1 :y n 9 a litany8 ,%>p1 b n w9n+4 ,! ,puritans _h object$ to ! p's kneel+ :ile ! ,comm&m5ts 7 read on ! score t ignorant wor%ipp]s might mi/ake ! ,decalogue = a =m ( pray]4 ,) "s asp]ity ! bi%ops reply t :y ,*ri/ian p %\ld n ^u _! knees ask _! p>don = _! life =feit$ = ! brea* ( e comm&m5t & pray = grace to keep !m = ! "t to come !y mu/ be m ?an 'ignorant' t c scruple4 ,! "t dur+ :i* ! conf]5ce at ! ,savoy %\ld cont9ue its sessions _h be5 limit$ to f\r mon?s4 ,?is p]iod expir$ on ,july #bd1 #affa1 & ! app>5tly fruitless disputation 0 at an end4 ,mean:ile1 h[ev]1 ,convocation1 ! recogniz$ legislature ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 _h begun to sit1 & ! bi%ops _h und]tak5 a revision ( ! ,pray] ,book aft] _! own m9d1 & ) slight reg>d to :at !y _h be5 he>+ f _! critics at ! ,savoy4 ,! bulk ( _! "w1 :i* includ$1 x is said1 m ?an six hundr$ alt]ations1 mo/ ( !m ( a v]bal "* & ( no great importance1 0 accompli%$ )9 ! compass ( a s+le mon?4 ,x is consol+ to ^? :o )9 our own memory h be5 *>g$ ) indec5t ha/e = seek+ to effect a revision ( ! ,am]ican ,book ( ,common ,pray] )9 a p]iod ( n9e ye>s1 to f9d ?is prec$5t 9 ecclesia/ical hi/ory = _! s great ra%ness4 ,s9ce ,*>les ! ,second's day !re has be5 no =mal revision ( ! ,pray] ,book ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& by ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,"s slight relaxations ( liturgical use on ,sundays h be5 made legal by ,act ( ,p>liam5t1 b 9 all important respects ! ,pray] ,book ( ,victoria is id5tical ) ! book set =? by ,convocation & sanction$ by ,p>liam5t %ortly aft] ! collapse ( ! ,savoy ,conf]5ce4 ,"u no previ\s lease ( life did ! book enjoy any?+ l s long a p]iod ( cont9u$ exi/5ce4 ,elizabe?'s book 0 ! longe/ liv$ ( all t prec$$ ! ,re/oration1 b t only cont9u$ 9 use five-&-=ty ye>s4 ,b ! ,pray] ,book ( #affa has n[ held its own 9 ,engl& = two c5turies & a qu>t]4 ,:51 !re=e1 we are ask$ to accept ! fir/ ,edw>dian ,book z ! only j expon5t ( ! religi\s m9d ( ,engl&1 x is op5 to u to reply1 ,:y %\ld we1 see+ t ! ,c>ol9e ,book has s]v$ z ! vehicle ( ,engli% devotion = a p]iod sev5ty-five times z long8 ,! mo/ volum9\s ( ! additions made to ! ,pray] ,book1 9 #affa1 7 ! ,(fice = ! ,baptism ( ,adults & ! ,=ms ( ,pray] to be us$ at ,sea4 ,! wide diffusion1 "u ! ,commonweal?1 ( :at 7 !n call$ ,anabapti/ op9ions1 _h br\ght x to pass t ?r\gh\t ! k+dom !re 7 ?\s&s ( m5 & wom5 :o _h gr[n up unbaptiz$4 ,at ! "t ( ! ,re=mation su* a ?+ z an un*ri/5$ ,*ri/5dom seems n to h be5 ?\ght possible4 ,at any rate no provision 0 made = ! cont+5cy4 ,b ^u ! spread ( lib]ty ( religi\s ?\ght !re foll[$1 logically en\gh1 ! spread ( lib]ty ( religi\s action1 & x 0 n /range t aft] a :ole g5]ation _h sp5t its life 9 controv]sy ( ! w>me/ sort ov] ?is v po9t ( ,baptism1 !re 7 f\nd to be 9 ,engl& multitudes ( ! unbaptiz$4 ,ano!r reason assign$ 9 ! ,preface ( ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book = ! addition ( ?is (fice 0 t x might be us$ = ! baptiz+ ( natives 9 ! plantations & o!r conv]ts4 ,?is is ! fir/ h9t ( any awak5+ ( ! consci5ce ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* to a s5se ( duty t[>d ^? /rang]s & =eign]s :o 9 ! ,great] ,brita9 ( ^! lat] days fill s l>ge a place4 ,! composition ( ! (fice1 :i* diff]s v little1 p]haps sc>cely en\gh1 f t appo9t$ = ! ,baptism ( ,infants1 is attribut$ to ,griffi?1 ! ,bi%op ( ,/4 ,asaph4 ,! compil] ( ! ,=ms ( ,pray] to be us$ at ,sea 0 ,bi%op ,s&]son1 fam\s among ,engli% !ologians z an au?ority on casui/ry4 ,he mu/ h f\nd x r a nice case ( consci5ce to decide :e!r a ,/u>t div9e 9 prep>+ =ms ( pray] = a navy t _h be5 ! creation ( ,oliv] ,cromwell ought :olly to omit an ackn[l$gm5t ( ! nation's obligation to t /\t-he>t$1 if non-,episcopal ,*ri/ian4 ,o!r additions ( importance made at ?is revision 7 ! ,g5]al ,?anksgiv+1 9 all probability ! "w ( ,reynolds1 a con=m+ ,presbyt]ian div9e1 ! ,collect1 ,epi/le1 & ,gospel = ! ,six? ,sunday aft] ! ,epiphany1 ! ,pray] = ,p>liam5t1 ^u ! l9es ( :i* our own ,pray] = ,congress 0 aft]w>d modell$1 & ! ,pray] = ,all ,sorts & ,conditions ( ,m54 ,9 ! ,litany ! words rebellion & s*ism 7 introduc$ into "o ( ! suffrages1 becom+ tide-m>ks ( ! havoc wr\ght 9 ,*ur* & ,/ate by :at ! revis]s1 d\btless1 look$ back ^u z ! flood ( ! ungodly4 ,! words ,bi%ops1 ,prie/s1 & ,deacons 7 sub/itut$ = ,bi%ops1 ,pa/ors1 & ,m9i/]s ( ! ,*ur*4 ,new ,collects 7 appo9t$ = ! ,?ird ,sunday 9 ,adv5t & = ,/4 ,/eph5's ,day4 ,bo? ( ^! are di/9ct ga9s1 albeit _h ! op9ion !n prevail$ t to introduce into ! ,pray] ,book any?+ f ! p5 ( a liv+ writ] is an impiety1 we %\ld h ga9$ nei!r ( !m4 ,ano!r important *ange made 9 #affb 0 ! adoption = ! ,s5t5ces1 ,epi/les & ,gospels ( ! language ( ,k+ ,james's ,bible 9 place ( t ( e>li] v]sions4 ,?is pr9ciple 0 n appli$ to ! ,psalt]1 to ! ,decalogue1 or1 9 fact1 to any ( ! portions ( ,scripture conta9$ 9 ! ,communion ,s]vice4 ,x is also int]e/+ to note t ! ,confession 9 ! ,holy ,communion1 :i* ! e>li] rubric _h direct$ %\ld be said by "o ( ! congregation1 or else by "o ( ! m9i/]s1 or by ! prie/ himself1 0 n[ made g5]al & enjo9$ ^u all ! wor%ipp]s4 ,mo/ sugge/ive ( all1 h[ev]1 0 ! re9s]tion at ! end ( ! ,communion ,s]vice ( a c]ta9 ,decl>ation ab\t ! significance ( ! act ( kneel+ at ! reception ( ! elem5ts1 :i* _h1 z "s say1 irregul>ly & )\t prop] au?ority1 f\nd its way into ! ,second ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi41 b _h be5 omitt$ f all subsequ5t books till n[4 ,?is ,decl>ation1 :i* f its n be+ pr9t$ 9 r$ ink is kn[n to ^? :o dislike x "u ! "n ( ! black rubric1 0 und\bt$ly int5d$ to ease ! consci5ces ( ^? :o scrupl$ to kneel at ! alt>-rail = fe> ( seem+ to c\nt5ance t sup]/iti\s adoration ( ! elem5ts kn[n to & /igmatiz$ by ! ,re=m]s z ho/-wor%ip4 ,! language ( ! black rubric z x /ood 9 ,edw>d's ,second ,book 0 z foll[s3 ,al?\gh no ord] c be s p]fectly devis$ b x may be ( "s1 ei!r = _! ignorance & infirmity1 or else ( malice & ob/9acy1 miscon/ru$1 deprav$1 & int]pret$ 9 a wrong "p2 & yet because bro!rly *>ity wille? t s mu* z conv5i5tly may be (f5ces %\ld be tak5 away2 !re=e we will+ to d ! same3 :]eas1 x is orda9$ 9 ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 9 ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp]1 t ! communicants kneel+ %\ld receive ! ,holy ,communion1 :i* ?+ be+ well meant = a signification ( ! humble & grateful ackn[l$g+ ( ! b5efits ( ,*ri/ giv5 unto ! wor?y receiv]1 & to avoid ! pr(anation & disord]1 :i* ab\t ! ,holy ,communion might else ensue1 le/ yet ! same kneel+ might be ?\ght or tak5 o!rwise2 we d decl>e t x is n meant !reby1 t any adoration is done or ought to be done1 ei!r unto ! sacram5tal bread or w9e !re bodily receiv$ or unto any real & ess5tial pres5ce !re be+ ( ,*ri/'s natural fle% & blood4 ,= z conc]n+ ! sacram5tal bread & w9e !y rema9 /ill 9 _! v natural sub/ances1 & !re=e may n be ador$1 = t 7 idolatry to be abhorr$ ( all fai?ful ,*ri/ians3 & z conc]n+ ! natural body & blood ( our ,savi\r ,*ri/1 !y are 9 heav5 & n "h1 = x is aga9/ ! tru? ( ,*ri/'s true natural body to be 9 m places ?an 9 "o at "o "t4 ,9 re/or+ ?is significant ,decl>ation1 ! revis]s ( #affb sub/itut$ ! words corporal pres5ce = ! words real & sub/antial pres5ce1 b probably ) no int5tion o!r ?an t ( mak+ ! orig9al mean+ m pla94 ,! fact t 9 ! tee? & eyes ( ! black rubric ! practice kn[n z ,eu*>i/ical adoration has become widely preval5t 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 only %[s h[ little dep5d5ce c be plac$ on =ms ( words to keep ev5 excell5t & religi\s p f do+ ! ?+s !y h a m9d to d4 ,9 tak+ leave ( ! ,c>ol9e revision1 x may be p]mitt$ to dwell = a mom5t ^u ! s]i\s "* ( ! conclusion rea*$ by ! ecclesia/ical lead]s ( t day4 ,an opportunity 0 giv5 !m to conciliate diss5t4 ,)\t go+ all l5g?s1 )\t 9 any measure imp]ill+ ! great f\ndation pr9ciples ( ,anglican religion1 !y might1 x w\ld seem1 h won back to ! national *ur* ?\s&s ( ^? :om _! /]nness n only repell$ b p]man5tly embitt]$4 ,b x 0 ! h\r ( victory ) ! ,*ur*m51 & ,woe to ! conqu]$ seems to h be5 _! cry4 ,!y set _! faces z a fl9t aga9/ concession2 !y pass$ _! iron-clad act ( uni=mity1 & n[ = m ?an two hundr$ ye>s religion 9 ,great ,brita9 has be5 a h\sehold divid$ aga9/ itself4 ,p]haps no?+ t ! m5 ( ! ,re/oration c\ld h done w\ld h made x o!rwise4 ,p]haps ! famili> "q ( ! cynical ,dean ( ,/4 ,patrick's1 ,:at imports x h[ l>ge a gate y op51 if !re be always left a numb] :o place a pride & a m]it 9 refus+ to ent]8 0 a fair "q1 & fatal to any dream ( unity4 ,& yet "o may be p>don$ = believ+ t _h a little ( ! oil ( bro!rly k9dness be5 p\r$ ^u ^? tr\bl$ wat]s we :om ! waves /ill buffet might to-day be sail+ a smoo!r sea4 ,z /at$ above1 ! ,convocation ( #affb gave to ! ,pray] ,book ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& ! =m x has ev] s9ce reta9$4 ,b x mu/ n be suppos$ t no ef=ts h be5 made mean:ile to br+ *anges to pass4 ,! books writt5 ^u ! subject =m a lit]ature by !mselves4 ,! "o really s]i\s attempt to recon/ruct ! ,liturgy 9 po/-,c>ol9e times 0 t :i* grew naturally en\gh out ( ! ,revolution ( #afhh4 ,9 e previ\s crisis ( political *ange1 ! ,pray] ,book _h felt ! tremor along ) ! /atute-book4 ,*ur* & ,/ate1 l he>t & bra91 are sympa!tically responsive to "o ano!r2 revisions ( rubrics g naturally along ) revisions ( codes4 ,x 0 only :at might h be5 anticipat$1 !re=e1 t :5 ,william & ,m>y came to ! ?rone a ,commission %\ld issue = a new review4 ,if ,elizabe? _h f\nd x necess>y to revise ! book1 if ,james _h f\nd x necess>y1 if ,*>les _h f\nd x necess>y1 :y %\ld n ! /rong h& ( ,william ( ,orange be laid ^u ! pages8 ,b ?is "t ! rule 0 de/9$ to f9d its exception4 ,! "w ( review 01 inde$1 und]tak5 by a ,royal ,commission1 includ+ among its memb]s ! great names ( ,/ill+fleet1 ,tillotson1 & ,bev]idge1 b no?+ came ( _! "w4 ,convocation aga9 %[$ itself unfri5dly to any?+ l concessive measures1 & s complete 0 ! obscurity into :i* ! do+s ( ! ,commission fell1 t ev5 z late z #ahdi1 ,c>dwell1 9 ! ?ird edition ( 8 ,hi/ory ( ,conf]5ces1 speaks z if he knew no?+ ( ! :]eab\ts ( ! record4 ,9 #ahed ! manuscript m9utes ( ! ,commission's proce$+s 7 discov]$ 9 ! ,libr>y ( ,lambe? ,palace1 & by ord] ( ,p>liam5t pr9t$ z a ,blue-book4 ,! same docum5t has also be5 publi%$ 9 a m readable =m by ,bag/]4 ,"o rises f ! p]usal ( ?is ,broad ,*ur* ,pray] ,book--= su*1 p]haps1 ,tillotson's attempt may n unfairly be call$--pr(\ndly ?ankful t ! promot]s ( x 7 n suff]$ to succe$4 ,! ,preface to our ,am]ican ,book ( ,common ,pray] ref]s to ?is attempt$ review ( #afhi z a great & good "w4 ,b ! greatness & ! goodness mu/ h la9 9 ! motive1 = "o fails to disc]n !m ei!r 9 ! matt] or 9 ! mann] ( :at 0 recomm5d$4 ,ev5 ,macaulay1 ,:ig t he is1 fails n to put on record 8 condemnation ( ! lit]>y viol5ce :i* ! ,pray] ,book s n>r[ly escap$ at ! h&s ( ! ,royal ,commission ( #afhi4 ,t]s5ess 0 n ! special excell5cy ( ,macaulay's own /yle1 yet ev5 he res5t$ ,bi%op ,patrick's notion t ! ,collects c\ld be improv$ by amplification4 ,"o ( ! few really good sugge/ions made by ! ,commission]s 0 t ( us+ ! ,beatitudes 9 ! ,(fice ( ! ,holy ,communion z an alt]nate = ! ,decalogue4 ,!re are c]ta9 fe/ivals ( ! ,*ri/ian ye> :5 su* a sub/itution w\ld be mo/ timely & refre%+4 ,we make a leap n[ ( j a hundr$ ye>s4 ,f #afhi we pass to #aghi1 & f9d ourselves 9 ! city ( ,philadelphia1 at a conv5tion assembl$ = ! purpose ( fram+ a con/itution & sett+ =? a liturgy = a body ( ,*ri/ians de/9$ to be kn[n z ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur* 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica4 ,dur+ ! int]val betwe5 ! issue ( ! ,decl>ation ( ,indep5d5ce & ! ,ratification ( ! ,con/itution ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 ! p 9 ?is c\ntry :o _h be5 br\ght up 9 ! communion ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& f\nd !mselves ecclesia/ically 9 a v delicate position inde$4 ,z coloni/s !y _h be5 canonically "u ! spiritual jurisdiction ( ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 a some:at remote diocesan4 ,b ) ?is ,episcopal bond brok5 & no new "o =m$1 !y seem$ to be 9 a peculi> s5se adrift4 ,x does n fall to me to n>rate ! /eps t l$ to ! f9al e/abli%m5t ( ! episcopacy ^u a sure f\ndation1 nor yet to trace ! process ?r\gh :i* ! ,*ur*'s legislative sy/em came gradually to its completion4 ,our int]e/ is a liturgical "o1 & our subject matt] ! evolution ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,i say no?+1 !re=e1 ( o!r matt]s t 7 debat$ 9 ! ,conv5tion ( #aghi1 b %all propose in/ead t we conf9e ourselves to :at 0 said & done ab\t ! ,pray] ,book4 ,9 ord]1 h[ev]1 fully to appreciate ! situation we mu/ g back a little4 ,9 a half-=mal & half-in=mal fa%ion !re _h come into exi/5ce1 f\r ye>s be=e ?is ,conv5tion ( #aghi assembl$1 an ,am]ican ,liturgy n[ kn[n by ! "n ( ,! ,propos$ ,book4 ,x _h be5 compil$ on ! basis ( ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book by a ,committee ( ?ree em95t cl]gym51 ,dr4 ,:ite ( ,p5nsylvania1 ,dr4 ,william ,smi? ( ,m>yl&1 & ,dr4 ,:>ton ( ,delaw>e4 ,precisely :at measure ( acceptance ?is book enjoy$1 or to :at ext5t x came actually into use1 are difficult1 p]haps hopeless que/ions4 ,:at we "k = c]ta9 is t ! public op9ion ( ! great] numb] ( ,*ur*m5 reject$ x z inadequate & unsatisfactory4 ,9 ! ,conv5tion ( #aghi ,! ,propos$ ,book does n seem to h be5 s]i\sly consid]$ 9 op5 debate at all1 ?\gh d\btless !re 0 mu* talk ab\t x1 mu* controv]sy ov] its m]its & dem]its at ,philadelphia d9n]-tables & else:]e :ile ! session 0 9 progress4 ,! tru? is1 ! *anges set =? 9 ,! ,propos$ ,book 7 too sweep+ to comm5d !mselves to ! sob] second-?\ght ( m5 ^: blood /ill %[$ ! t9cture ( ,engli% cons]vatism4 ,possibly also "s old flames ( ,tory res5tm5t 7 rek9dl$1 "h & !re1 by ! prom95ce giv5 9 ! book to a =m ( public ?anksgiv+ = ! ,f\r? ( ,july4 ,!re 7 ,*ur*m5 d\btless at t day :o fail$ duly to appreciate :at 7 call$ 9 ! title ( ! (fice1 ! ine/imable bless+s ( ,religi\s & ,civil ,lib]ty4 ,o!rs aga9 may h be5 (f5d$ by ! treatm5t measur$ out to ! ,psalt]1 :i* 0 portion$ into ?irty selections ( two p>ts ea*1 ) ! ,b5$icite add$ at ! end1 to be us$1 if desir$1 on ! ?irty-fir/ day ( any mon?4 ,ano!r some:at crude & unliturgical device 0 ! runn+ toge!r )\t break ( ! ,morn+ ,pray] & ! ,litany4 ,i speak ( blemi%es1 b ,! ,propos$ ,book _h its excell5ces also4 ,j at pres5t x is ! fa%ion 9 ,anglican circles to heap ridicule & contempt on ,! ,propos$ ,book out ( all proportion to its real dem]its4 ,someh[ x is ?\ght to compromise u ) ! ,engli% by %[+ up our ecclesia/ical ance/ors 9 an unfavorable light z unle>n$ & ignorant m54 ,x is treat$ z p w sometimes treat an old family portrait ( a =ebe>1 :o 9 8 day 0 "u a cl\d1 mismanag$ tru/ funds1 or made money 9 ! slave trade4 ,?us a grave hi/oriograph] by way ( speak+ com=tably on ?is score1 assures u t ! volume spe$ily sunk into obscurity1 becom+ "o ( ! r>e/ ( ! books illu/rative ( our ecclesia/ical annals4 ,& yet1 curi\sly en\gh1 ,! ,propos$ ,book 0 9 "s po9ts m *ur*ly1 us+ ! ^w 9 a s5se expressive ( liturgical accuracy1 ?an ! book f9ally adopt$4 ,9 ! ,morn+ ,pray] x has ! ,v5ite 9 full & n abridg$4 ,! ,b5$ictus x also gives entire4 ,a s+le =m ( ,absolution is suppli$4 ,! v]sicles foll[+ ^u ! ,cre$ are m num]\s ?an ours4 ,9 ! ,ev5+ ,pray] ! great ,gospel ,hymns1 ! ,magnificat & ! ,nunc dimittis1 /& 9 ! places to :i* we ) t>dy ju/ice h only j re/or$ !m4 ,aga91 if we consid] ^? features ( ,! ,propos$ ,book t 7 reta9$ & made "p ( ! ,liturgy 9 #aghi1 we %all h fur!r reason to refra9 f :olesale condemnation ( ?is t5tative "w4 ,= example1 we owe ! two op5+ s5t5ces ( ,morn+ ,pray]1 ,! ,"l is 9 8 holy temple & ,f ! ris+ ( ! sun1 to ,! ,propos$ ,book1 & also ! special =m = ,?anksgiv+ ,day4 ,& yet1 on ! :ole1 ! ,conv5tion ( #aghi act$ mo/ wisely 9 det]m9+ t x w\ld make ! ,pray] ,book ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 r ?an ,! ,propos$ ,book1 ! real basis ( revision4 ,x did s1 & z a result we h :at has s]v$ u s well dur+ ! fir/ c5tury ( our national life--! ,book ( ,common ,pray] & ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,sacram5ts & o!r rites & c]emonies ( ! ,*ur* accord+ to ! use ( ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur* 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica4 ,! po9ts :]e9 ! ,am]ican ,pray] ,book diff]s f ! ,pray] ,book ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& are too num]\s to be catalogu$ 9 full4 ,!y w appe>1 says ! ,preface 7a composition borr[$1 by ! way1 almo/ :olly f ,! ,propos$ ,book71 &1 x is to be hop$1 ! reasons ( !m also1 ^u a comp>ison ( ?is ) ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,! mo/ important diff]5ces are ! foll[+3 ,! p]missive use ( ,selections ( ,psalms 9 place ( ! ,psalms appo9t$ = ! day ( ! mon?4 ,?is 0 d\btless sugge/$ by ! :olesale trans=mation ( ! ,psalt] 9 ,! ,propos$ ,book into a s]ies ( selections4 ,! p]mitt$ %ort5+ ( ! ,litany is an ,am]ican feature4 ,a numb] ( ! special pray]s1 z1 = example1 ! pray] = a sick p]son1 t = p]sons go+ to sea1 ! ?anksgiv+s = a recov]y & = a safe return1 all ^! are peculi> to ! ,am]ican use4 ,ext5sive alt]ations 7 made 9 ! ,m>riage ,s]vice & c]ta9 greatly ne$$ ones 9 ! ,burial ,(fice4 ,! two mo/ notewor?y diff]5ces1 h[ev]1 are ! omission f our ,pray] ,book ( ! s-call$ ,a?anasian ,cre$1 & ! ins]tion 9 x ( t "p ( ! ,consecration ,pray] 9 ! ,communion ,(fice kn[n z ! ,invocation4 ,! engraft+ ( ?is latt] feature we owe to ! influ5ce ( ,bi%op ,seabury1 :o by ?is addition n only assimilat$ ! language ( our liturgy m closely to t ( ! anci5t =mul>ies ( ! ,ori5tal ,*ur*1 b also insur$ our be+ kept rem9d$ ( ! truly spiritual "* ( ,holy ,communion4 ,x is ! _s t quick5e?1 ?is ,invocation seems to say2 ! fle% pr(ite? no?+4 ,q 9 l9e ) ?is 0 ! alt]ation made at ! same "t 9 ! language ( ! ,cate*ism4 ,! ,body & ,blood ( ,*ri/1 says ! ,engli% ,book1 :i* are v]ily & inde$ tak5 & receiv$ by ! fai?ful 9 ! ,"l's ,supp]4 ,! ,body & ,blood ( ,*ri/1 says ! ,am]ican ,book1 :i* are spiritually tak5 & receiv$ by ! fai?ful 9 ! ,"l's ,supp]4 ,_m v]bal *anges are to be f\nd scatt]$ "h & !re ?r\gh ! book1 "s ( !m = ! bett]1 "s1 p]haps1 = ! worse4 ,! prevail+ purpose seems to h be5 to expunge all obsolete words & phrases :ile deal+ t5d]ly ) obsolesc5t ones4 ,9 ?is c\rse1 h[ev]1 ! revis]s 7 by no means always & ev]y:]e consi/5t4 ,prev5t1 9 ! s5se ( anticipate1 is alt]$ 9 "s places b left un*ang$ 9 o!rs4 ,9 ! ,visitation ( ,prison]s1 an (fice borr[$ f ! ,iri% ,pray] ,book1 ! ?or\ghly obsolete expression1 ,z y t5d]1 9 ! s5se ( z y value1 ! salvation ( y\r s\l1 is reta9$4 ,f ! ,psalt] has disappe>$ 9 ! ,am]ican ,book ,?\ telle/ my ,sitt+s1 al?\gh :y ?is p>ticul> ar*aism %\ld h be5 select$ = bani%m5t & a hundr$ o!rs sp>$1 x is n easy to und]/&4 ,p]haps "s sudd5 impati5ce seiz$ ! revis]1 l t :i* mov$ ,bi%op ,wr51 :ile annotat+ 8 ,pray] ,book1 to write on ! m>g9 ( ! cal5d> = ,augu/1 ,out ) 'dog days' f among ! sa9ts4 ,consid]+ :at a bond ( unity ! ,"l's ,pray] appe>s to be becom+ among all ,engli%-speak+ wor%ipp]s1 x is1 p]haps1 to be regrett$ t our revis]s *ang$ ! word+ ( x 9 two or ?ree places4 ,! excision ( ,light5 our d>kness mu/ probably be attribut$ to ! prosaic matt]-(-fact temp] :i* _h possession ( ev]ybody & ev]y?+ dur+ ! la/ qu>t] ( ! eighte5? c5tury4 ,! ,ord9al1 ! ,articles1 ! ,consecration ( ,*ur*es1 & ! ,in/itution ( ,m9i/]s made no "p ( ! ,pray] ,book z x 0 set =? 9 #aghi2 nor d !y1 ev5 n[1 /rictly speak+1 make a "p ( x1 al?\gh 9 ! matt] ( b9d+ =ce & legal au?ority !y are on ! same foot+4 ,! ,ord9al & ,articles are sub/antially id5tical ) ! ,engli% ,ord9al & ,articles1 save 9 ! matt] ( a ref]5ce to ! ,a?anasian ,cre$ & sev]al ref]5ces to ! connection ( ,*ur* & ,/ate4 ,! ,consecration ( ,*ur*es & ! ,in/itution ( ,m9i/]s are (fices di/9ctively ,am]ican4 ,if ,i add t ! ,am]ican ,book drops out ( ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick a =m ( private absolution1 & greatly modifies ! s]vice = ,a%-,w$nesday1 we %all h made our survey ( diff]5ces tol]ably1 ?\gh by no means exhau/ively complete4 ,& n[ :at is ! lesson taught u by ! hi/ory ( ! ,pray] ,book8 ,homiletical z ! "q s\nds1 x is wor? ask+4 ,we h review$ rapidly1 b n c>elessly1 ! vicissitudes ( ! book's wond]ful c>e]1 & we ought to be 9 a position to draw "s sort ( in/ructive inf]5ce f x all4 ,well1 "o ?+ taught u is ?is1 ! s+ul> p[] ( survival t lives 9 graci\s words4 ,!y wond]$ at ! graci\s words :i* proce$$ out ( ,8 m\?1 & because !y wond]$ at !m !y treasur$ !m up4 ,k9d words1 says ! *ild's hymn1 c nev] die2 nei!r c k9dly words1 & k9dly 9 ! deepe/ s5se are _m1 _m ( ! words ( ! ,common ,pray]2 !y t\* t :i* is mo/ ca?olic 9 u1 t :i* /rongly l9ks u to our k9d4 ,!re is t 9 "s ( ! ,collects :i* z x has la/$ s9ce ! days :5 ,roman emp]ors 7 sitt+ on _! ?rones1 s w x la/ :ile man cont9ues :at he is1 a pray+ creature4 ,ano!r ?+ taught u by ! ,pray] ,book's hi/ory is ! duty ( be+ =ev] on our gu>d 9 ! religi\s life aga9/ ! falsehood ( extremes4 ,! emancipat$ ?9k]s :o acc\nt all /&>ds ( belief to be no bett] ?an dungeon walls1 sc(f at ?is feature ( ! ,anglican "* ) mu* bitt]ness4 ,y\r ,*ur* is a ,*ur* ( compromises1 !y say1 & y\r boa/$ ,via m$ia only a c[>d's pa?1 ! poor refuge ( ! man :o d>es n walk 9 ! op54 ,b :5 we see ?is ,pray] ,book condemn$ = be+ :at x is by ,bloody ,m>y1 & !n aga9 condemn$ = be+ :at x is by ! ,long ,p>liam5t1 ! ?\ght occurs to u t possibly !re is en%r9$ 9 ?is mu*-p]secut$ volume a tru? l>g] ?an ! ,romani/ is will+ to tol]ate1 or ! ,puritan g5]\s en\gh to appreh5d4 ,a ?ird important lesson is t we are n to conf\nd revision ) ru91 or to suppose t because a book is m>vell\sly good x _c conceivably be bett]$4 ,ea* accompli%$ revision ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] has be5 a di/9ct /ep 9 advance4 ,if ,god 9 8 wise provid5ce suff]$ an excell5t gr[? ( devotion to spr+ up out ( ! soil ( ,engl& 9 ! days ( ,edw>d ! ,six?1 &1 aft] _m ye>s1 det]m9$ t l a v9e out ( ,egypt x %\ld be br\ght across ! sea & giv5 root on ^! %ores1 we ne$ n fe> t we are ab\t to lose utt]ly our pleasant plant if we notice t ! twigs & leaves are adapt+ !mselves to ! climate & ! atmosph]e ( ! new dwell+-place4 ,! life )9 ! v9e rema9s :at x always 04 ,! gr[? means heal?4 ,! p[] ( adaptation is ! gu>antee ( a p]petual y\?4 ,,revision ,,( ,,! ,,am]ican ,,common ,,pray]4 ,,ii4 ,,revision ,,( ,,! ,,am]ican ,,common ,,pray]4#a ,! revision ( long e/abli%$ =mul>ies ( public wor%ip is1 z x ought to be1 a matt] compass$ ab\t ) ob/acles _m & great4 ,a wise d\btfulness prompts cons]vative m9ds to ?r[ e mov] = *ange ^u ! def5sive1 :5 liturgical int]e/s are at /ake4 ,s _m m5 are born into ! _w ) a native disposition to tamp] ) & t9k] all settl$ ?+s1 & s _m m become p]suad$1 z "t goes on1 ( a p]sonal mission to pull d[n & remake :atev] has be5 once built up1 e/eem+ life a failure unless !y h contriv$ to build ea* 8 own monum5t ^u a cle>+1 t lov]s ( ! old ways are sometimes compell$ 9 %e] self-def5ce to put on ! appe>ance ( be+ m ob/9ately set aga9/ *ange ?an !y really are4 ,x ought n to be absolutely impossible to alt] a national h&-book ( wor%ip 7:i* is :at any manual call+ itself a ,common ,pray] mu/ aspire to become71 b x is well t x %\ld be all b impossible to d s4 ,logically x might seem z if ! possession ( a p[] to make involv$ a cont9uance ( p[] to remake2 & s x does1 to a c]ta9 ext5t1 b only to a c]ta9 ext5t4 ,liv+ organisms _c be remodell$ ) ! same fre$om z dead matt]4 ,a solemnity hangs ab\t ! mom5t ( bir? t atta*es to no o!r crisis 9 a man's life until dea? comes4 ,simil>ly !re are c]ta9 features :i* ! f\nd]s ( in/itutions1 ! fir/ mak]s ( organic law1 impr9t la/+ly ^u _! "w4 ,we may de/roy ! liv+ ?+ s br\ght to bir?2 to kill is always possible2 b only by v gradual & pla/ic me?ods c we hope 9 any measure to recon/ruct ! actual embodim5t ( life once a*iev$4 ,! m5 ( #aghi _h u 9 _! p[]1 ev5 z ! m5 ( #aedi _h _h bo? !m & u4 ,9 e creative epo* _m ?+s are settl$ by :i* unborn g5]ations w be b\nd4#b ,x may be urg$ t ?is is an argum5t aga9/ adopt+ liturgies 9 ! fir/ in/ance z vehicles ( wor%ip2 & su* und\bt$ly x is 9 s f> =? z immobility ought 9 su* matt]s to be reckon$ a disadvantage4 ,b we are b\nd to take into acc\nt ! ga9 :i* comes ) immobility z well z ! drawbacks4 ,we mu/ consid] h[ l>ge a proportion ( ! rev]5ce :i* ! great in/itutes ( human life exact f u is due to ! fixity ( ! ?+s !mselves4 ,mont ,blanc loses no?+ ( its hold ^u our admiration because we always f9d x 9 ! same place4 ,m5 l to feel t !re is some?+ 9 ! _w /rong] ?an ! individual w1 /rong] simply because x expresses ! settl$ common-s5se ( _m z to :at is fitt+ & "r 9 contra/ ) ! :im ( "o4 ,lawy]s1 z a class1 are almo/ z cons]vative z ecclesia/ics1 & = ! v reason t !y also are *>g$ ) ! cu/ody ( e/abli%$ =ms :i* x is important t m5 %\ld rev]5ce4 ,laws affect+ ! t5ure ( prop]ty1 ! b9d+ =ce ( contracts1 ! /ability ( ! m>riage relation1 n only _c be lightly alt]$1 ! v phraseology 9 :i* !y are c\*$ mu/ be c>efully h&l$1 = fe> le/ ) ! pass+ away ( ! =m some?+ ( ! sub/ance g also4 ,moreov]1 ! affections ( m5 fa/5 !mselves v t5aci\sly to su* a trellis z a liturgy af=ds4 ,! love = ! old words & ! old tunes aga9/ :i* all innovators 9 hymnody1 h[ev] des]v+1 h to d battle1 ass]ts itself "u ! =m ( love = ! old pray]s ) t5-fold vehem5ce4 ,an imm5se fund ( lat5t heat sm\ld]s b5ea? ! maxim1 ,let ! anci5t cu/oms prevail2 & few ( ! victories a*iev$ by ! papacy are s />tl+ z ^? t h result$ 9 ! displacem5t ( ! liturgical uses ( local ,*ur*es1 t ( ,p>is1 = example1 by ! ,roman rite4 ,b true pr9ciples1 z we are (t5 rem9d$1 become falsehoods :5 %ov$ across ! l9e ( prop] measure4 ,! v cycles ( ! a/ronom]s h an end1 & ! clock-"w ( ! mo/ anci5t heav5s1 or at lea/ our read+ ( x1 calls1 f "t to "t1 = readju/m5t4 ,s long z man cont9ues fallible 8 be/ int5d$ workman%ip w occasionally dem& su* alt]ation = ! bett] z1 )9 ! limits already po9t$ out1 may be possible4 ,_m signs ( ! times sugge/ t ! h\r = a fre% review ( ! ,anglican =mul>ies ( wor%ip is nigh at h&4 ,"s ( ^! tok5s are writt5 on a sky broad en\gh to cov] ! :ole ,engli%-speak+ race1 o!rs ( !m are visible *iefly )9 our own national horizon4 ,) respect to ! ,engli% book1 ,c>dwell #c writ+ 9 #ahdj & ,freeman#d 9 #ahee1 consid]$ revision1 h[ev] desirable 9 ! ab/ract1 to be a ?+ utt]ly out ( rea*1 n )9 ! circle1 z ! p>liam5t>y phrase n[ runs1 ( practical politics4 ,b x may be fairly que/ion$ :e!r ^! high au?orities1 7 !y liv+ to-day1 w\ld n concur 9 ! judgm5t ( a m rec5t writ] :5 he says--9 language :i*1 mutatis mut&is1 applies to our own case3 ,! mo/ weighty plea 9 favor ( timely inquiry into ! subject is t ! process ( revision is actually go+ on piecemeal1 & ) no v intellig5t survey ( ! be>+s z a prelim9>y to any "o in/alm5t4 ,! ,new ,lection>y ( #ahga1 ! ,%ort5$ ,s]vices ,act1 ! debates 9 ! ,convocation ( ,cant]bury on rubrical am5dm5ts1 none ( !m m>k$ by any suffici5t c>e or k1 & all fraught ) at lea/ ! possibility ( s]i\s consequ5ce1 are examples ( =mal & recogniz$ inroads on ! ,act ( ,uni=mity2 :ile su* practical ?\gh unau?oriz$ additions to ! scanty gr\p ( ,anglican =mul>ies z ! ,?ree ,h\rs' ,devotion1 ,h>ve/ ,?anksgiv+s1 ,public ,in/itution ( ,incumb5ts1 ,ord9ation ( ,read]s & ,deaconesses1 & ,*ildr5's ,s]vices prove inconte/ably t ! n>r[ limits ( ! ,common ,pray] ,book are no long] adequate = ! spiritual ne$s ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 4 4 4 ,x is evid5t1 !n1 t cont5t$ acquiesc5ce ) ! old /ate ( ?+s already belongs to ! pa/1 & t a return to x is impossible4 ,we mu/ p]=ce advance1 = good or ill1 9 ! pa? ( revision1 & _c ev5 mat]ially slack5 ! pace nor def] ! crisis4 ,"o *oice1 h[ev]1 is left 9 our p[]1 & t is ! mo/ important ( all1 namely1 ! direction :i* revision %all take--t ( cons]vative & recup]ative addition1 or t ( fur!r evisc]ation1 c]emonial or devotional4 #e ,a measure look+ 9 ! direction t[>ds :i* ?is review] po9ts 0 actually pass$ by ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( our own ,*ur* at its late session 9 ,octob]1 #ahhj4 ,! word+ ( ! ,resolution ref]r$ to 0 z foll[s3 ,resolv$3 ,t a ,jo9t ,committee1 to consi/ ( sev5 bi%ops1 sev5 presbyt]s1 & sev5 laym5 be appo9t$ to consid] & report to ! next ,g5]al ,conv5tion :e!r1 9 view ( ! fact t ?is ,*ur* is soon to ent] ^u ! second c5tury ( its organiz$ exi/5ce 9 ?is c\ntry1 ! *ang$ conditions ( ! national life d n dem& c]ta9 alt]ations 9 ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] 9 ! direction ( liturgical enri*m5t & increas$ flexibility ( use4#f ,9 ! pres5t article ! writ] proposes to inquire1 9 connection ) ?is measure3 7#a7 ,:at motives may fairly be suppos$ to h actuat$ ! ,conv5tion 9 all[+ s important an initiatory /ep to be tak58 7#b7 ,:at measure ( au?ority 0 conf]r$ on & :at scope giv5 to ! ,jo9t ,committee !n con/itut$8 7#c7 ,:at reasons exi/ = consid]+ ! pres5t a happy mom5t to attempt liturgical revision1 )9 c]ta9 limits1 %\ld su* a ?+ be det]m9$ ^u8 7#d7 ,:at s]i\s difficulties & ob/acles are likely to be enc\nt]$ 9 ,committee1 9 ,conv5tion1 & 9 ! ,*ur* at l>ge8 7#e7 ,:at p>ticul> improvem5ts & adju/m5ts ( our exi/+ sy/em w\ld be1 9 po9t ( fact1 be/ wor? ! ef=t necess>y to secure !m8 ,i4 ,! int]pretation ( motives1 difficult en\gh 9 ! case ( individuals1 becomes m]e guess-"w :5 ! action "u analysis is t ( a l>ge body ( m54 ,:i* "o ( _m consid]ations urg$ ^u ! ,conv5tion c>ri$ ) x ! supreme weight ( p]suasion 9 ?is p>ticul> in/ance x is impossible to say4 ,two or ?ree argum5ts1 h[ev]1 f _! frequ5t reappe>ance 9 ! debate may fairly be judg$ to h ex]cis$ a controll+ influ5ce4 ,"o ( ^! 0 h9t$ at 9 ! language ( ! resolution itself1 namely1 ! call = revision t has gr[n out ( ! *ang$ conditions ( ! national life4 ,%rewd & f>-see+ z 7 ,william ,:ite & 8 coadjutors 9 _! =eca/ ( n9ete5? c5tury ne$s made f ! /&po9t ( ! ,peace ( ,v]sailles1 !y w\ld h be5 m ?an human _h !y succe$$ 9 anticipat+ all ! civil & ecclesia/ical consequ5ces de/9$ to fl[ f t memorable ev5t4 ,c]ta9ly x ought n to be held /range t ?is new ,am]ica ( ours1 ) its enorm\sly multipli$ t]ritory1 its conglom]ate ( races1 its novel =ms ( association1 its multiplicity ( indu/ries n dream$ ( a g5]ation ago1 %\ld h dem&s to make 9 respect to a bett] adaptation ( anci5t =mul>ies to pres5t wants1 su* z ?\ghtful p c\nt bo? reasonable & cog5t4 ,t a ,pray] ,book revis$ prim>ily = ! use ( a half-proscrib$ ,*ur* plant$ "h & !re along a sp>sely inhabit$ sea-coa/1 %\ld s]ve z amply z x does ! purposes ( a population n[ swoll5 f f\r millions to fifty1 & cov]+ ! :ole bread? ( ! cont95t1 is m>vel en\gh2 to ass]t = ! book entire adequacy to meet ^! alt]$ circum/ances is a mi/ake4 ,new "t1 new favors1 & new joys1 s a famili> hymn affirms1 d a new song require4 ,we h conc$$ ! pr9ciple s f> z psalmody is conc]n$1 :y n apply x to ! s]vice ( pray] z well z to t ( praise1 & 9 addition to our new hymns secure also su* new int]cessions & new ?anksgiv+s z ! ne$s ( to-day sugge/8 ,! ref]5ce 9 ! resolution to ! approa*+ completion ( ! c5tury has s9ce be5 playfully *>act]iz$ z a bit ( s5tim5talism4#g ,! criticism w\ld be entirely j if ! m]e recurr5ce ( ! c5t5nial anniv]s>y 7 ! po9t *iefly emphasiz$4 ,b :5 a c5tury closes z ?is "o ( ours has done ) a great social revolution :]eby all e/ates ( m5 h be5 m or less affect$1 ! proposal to signalize entrance ^u a fre% /ret* ( national life by mak+ devotional prep>ation = x is some?+ bett] ?an a pretty conceit2 !re is a s]i\s reasonabl5ess 9 x4#h ,e revision ( ! ,common ,pray] ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 & !re h be5 f\r ( !m s9ce ,edw>d's ,fir/ ,book 0 put 9 pr9t1 has tak5 place at "s important era ( transition 9 ! national life3 & conv]sely x may be said t e civil crisis1 ) a s+le exception1 has left its m>k ^u ! =mul>ies4 ,to "o :o argues t because we 9 ?is c\ntry are evid5tly ent]+ ^u a new phase ( ! national life we ought simil>ly to re-en=ce & readju/ our s]vice-book1 x is no suffici5t reply to urge ! sev]ance effect$ "h betwe5 ,*ur* & ,/ate4 ,! fact t ours is a non-e/abli%$ ,*ur* does n make h] :olly unresponsive to ! %ocks ( *ange t t\* ! civil fabric4 ,9 s f> z a political r5ewal alt]s ! social grad+ ( society1 br++ 9 education1 = in/ance1 :]e be=e x 0 n1 or sudd5ly develop+ new =ms ( indu/rial activity1 ! ,*ur*1 :e!r e/abli%$ or n1 is 9 duty b\nd to take cognizance ( ! fre% field ( duty ?us sudd5ly ?ru/ ^u h]1 & to prep>e h]self accord+ly4 ,9 ! ,preface add$ to ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book at ! ,re/oration1 & commonly attribut$ to ,s&]son1 t /aid & well weigh$ man1 z ,hammond call$ him1 !re occurs a s5t5ce :i*1 bo? on acc\nt ( its embody+ 9 a few words ! :ole philosophy ( liturgical revision & because ( a c]ta9 practical be>+ pres5tly to be po9t$ out1 x is wor? :ile1 9 spite ( its famili>ity1 to quote3 ,! p>ticul> =ms ( ,div9e wor%ip1 & ! rites & c]emonies appo9t$ to be us$ !re91 be+ ?+s 9 _! own nature indiff]5t & alt]able & s ackn[l$g$1 x is b reasonable1 t ^u weighty & important consid]ations1 accord+ to ! v>i\s exig5cy ( times & occasions1 su* *anges & alt]ations %\ld be made !re91 z to ^? t are 9 place ( au?ority %\ld f "t to "t seem ei!r necess>y or exp$i5t4 ,contemporane\sly ) ?is utt]ance !re came into ! ,pray] ,book1 z a direct consequ5ce ( ! enorm\s enl>gem5t ( ! naval & comm]cial m>9e t _h tak5 place "u ! ,commonweal?1 ! ,=ms ( ,pray] to be us$ at ,sea4 ,"h 0 a wise & "r-m9d$ recognition ( a new want t _h sprung up ) a new "t1 a want :i* jeal\sy ( ! ,puritans :o _h built up ! naval supremacy did n prev5t ! ,c>ol9e bi%ops f meet+4 ,b ! *ange t pass$ on ,engl& dur+ five ye>s ( ,cromwell 0 z no?+ comp>$ ) ! trans=mation ( ,am]ica "u n9ety-five ye>s ( ! f$]al con/itution4 ,take a s+le illu/ration4 ,! ye> #aghi1 ! date ( ! ,ratification ( ! ,am]ican ,pray] ,book1 saw sea-isl& cotton fir/ plant$ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 & x 0 ab\t t "t t upl& cotton also began to be cultivat$ = home & =eign use4 ,z ! effect ( ?is sc>cely notic$ exp]im5t !re /raightway sprang up an indu/ry1 ,nor? & ,s\?1 :i* has be5 to our c\ntry almo/ :at h] %ipp+ int]e/ is to ,great ,brita94 ,bi%op ,:ite & 8 associates 7 n to blame = failure to provide bread t all ?is unanticipat$ multitude ( toil]s %\ld eat4 ,& yet a failure !re has be54 ,no "o :o has n labor$ at ! task ( try+ to comm5d ! ,*ur* ( ! ,pray] ,book to ! work+ class1 z x is repres5t$ 9 our l>ge manufactur+ t[ns1 c "k h[ lam5table t failure is4 ,we ga!r 9 ! ri* & ! poor1 b ! great middle class t makes ! /aple & ! /r5g? ( ,am]ican society /&s alo(4 ,n[h]e 9 ?is c\ntry1 = in/ance1 has ! ,*ur* _h a bett] opportunity to %[ :at x c\ld d = ,am]ican p ?an 9 ! city ( ,l[ell1 :]e cotton sp9n+ _h its fir/ l>ge developm5t4 ,x 0 a virg9 soil3 ! ,episcopal ,*ur*1 z r>ely happ5s1 0 e>lie/ on ! gr\nd3 & n only s1 b x enjoy$ = "s ye>s ! fri5dly protection ( ! proprietors ( ! new settlem5t1 almo/ a religi\s monopoly--01 9 fact1 an ecclesia/ical pres]ve4 ,moreov]1 ?is beg9n+ ant$at$ ! ,iri% occupation by _m ye>s1 at lea/ s f> z skill$ labor 0 conc]n$1 = dur+ a consid]able p]iod ! op]atives 9 ! mills 7 ( native ,new ,engl& /ock1 ! be/ possible mat]ial to be made ov] into *ur*m5 & *ur*wom54 ,& yet not)/&+ all ?is1 & not)/&+ ! pati5t & un9t]mitt$ toil ?r\gh m ?an fifty ye>s ( p]haps ! mo/ labori\s p>i% prie/ on ! ,am]ican cl]gy li/1 ! ,episcopal ,*ur* has to-day b a comp>atively sl5d] hold ^u ! affections & loyalty ( ! p ( ?is l>ge/ ( ! manufactur+ cities ( ,new ,engl&4 ,a simil> failure to rea* ! masses betrays itself 9 ,worce/] & ,fall ,riv]1 ! two cities ( l "* t come next 9 ord] ( population1 = 9 ! =m] ( ^! la/ nam$ places only ab\t two p] c5t1 ( ! inhabitants h affiliations ( any sort ) ! ,episcopal ,*ur*4 ,x 0 consid]ations ( ?is sort1 back$ p]haps by memories ( ! r++ appeal s\nd$ ?ree ye>s be=e at ,bo/on by ! ,bi%op ( ,connecticut1 t mov$ ! ,conv5tion to int]pret z some?+ bett] ?an a bit ( s5tim5talism ! invitation to look ! times 9 ! face1 & give ! new c5tury its infant baptism4 ,b besides all ?is !re press$ ^u ! m9d ( bi%ops & deputies a cumulative argum5t ( a :olly diff]5t sort4 ,! dem& = revision seem$ to be clos+ 9 ^u ! ,*ur* on conv]g+ l9es4 ,x 0 pla9 t1 be=e long1 h&s ( *ange mu/ necess>ily be laid ^u c]ta9 semi-deta*$ portions ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,!re 0 ! ,new ,lection>y1 = example1 t w\ld pres5tly be knock+ = hospitable reception )9 ! cov]s1 & ! old ,ea/] ,tables1 z !y n[ /&1 c\ld n1 x 0 obs]v$1 la/ v mu* long]4 ,a new book1 9 ! publi%]'s s5se ( t t]m1 w\ld soon h to be made4 ,! sanctity ( /]eotype plates mu/ be di/urb$4 ,moreov]1 "h 0 an admirable opportunity to settle ! wrangle1 n[ ( n9e ye>s' /&+1 ov] ! be/ way ( br++ to pass %ort5$ s]vices = week-day use4 ,add to ?is ! fact t ! intr9sic weakness ( ! driblet me?od ( revision#i _h be5 made s abundantly pla9 t ev5 its =m] fri5ds wisely refra9$ f all attempt to urge x1 & our summ+ up ( probable motives becomes approximately complete4 ,,ii4 ,z to ! measure ( au?ority conf]r$ on1 & scope all[$ to ! ,committee ( ,tw5ty-"o1 x is possible to speak ) m def9it5ess4 ,a precisian might ( c\rse1 7 he s dispos$1 take up ! gr\nd t ! report ( ! ,committee :5 made ought to be monosyllabic1 ,yes or ,no4 ,! word+ ( ! resolution admits ( su* a con/ruction beyond a d\bt2 ! ,jo9t ,committee 0 reque/$ to consid] & report :e!r1 etc41 etc4 ,b no "o :o li/5$ to ! debate on ! resolution c\ld h be5 left 9 unc]ta9ty z to ! real animus ( ! measure4 ,! ?+ int5d$ to be au?oriz$ 0 an exp]im5tal review1 ) impli$ ref]5ce to a limit$ revision at "s "t future1 9 case ! fruits ( ! review %\ld comm5d !mselves to ! m9d ( ! ,*ur*4 ,a di/9ction mu/ be drawn betwe5 revision & review4 ,revision implies review z an antec$5t /ep1 b review is by no means necess>ily foll[$ by revision4 ,! ,engli% book 0 review$ & revis$ 9 #affb2 x 0 review$ b n revis$ 9 #afhi4 ,review is t5tative & advisory2 revision is au?oritative & f9al4 ,9 ! pres5t in/ance n an atom ( p[] to effect b9d+ *ange has be5 convey$4 ,no au?ority has be5 giv5 to anybody to t\* a l9e or a lett] ( ! ,pray] ,book save 9 ! way ( sugge/ion & recomm5dation4 ,responsible action has be5 held :olly 9 res]ve4 ,moreov]1 ev5 ! pa?way ( review 0 mo/ scrupul\sly h$g$4 ,apply+ to ! resolution ! legal maxim1 expressio unius e/ exclusio alt]ius1 "o sees at a glance t doctr9al *ange is a matt] left :olly on "o side4 ,! two po9ts to :i* ! ,committee is in/ruct$ to b5d all its /udies are liturgical enri*m5t & increas$ flexibility ( use4 ,:atsoev] is m ?an ^! is irrelevant4 ,accurate di/+ui%m5t betwe5 su* enri*m5ts z h & su* z h n a doctr9al be>+ is1 no d\bt1 a delicate po9t1 & mu/ be set d[n among ! difficulties to be enc\nt]$4 ,z su* x w be consid]$ fur!r on4 ,= ! pres5t ! fact to be not$ is t ! au?oriz$ review]s are bo? 9 honor & 9 duty b\nd to keep !mselves absolutely cle> ( controv]sial bias4 ,! movem5t is n a movem5t to alt] 9 any slighte/ respect ! dogmatic tea*+ ( ! ,*ur*1 n a movem5t to unsettle f\ndations1 n a movem5t t[>d dis[n+ or repudiat+ our pa/1 b simply & only an endeavor to make ! ,common ,pray]1 if possible 7& we are f> f be+ sure1 z yet1 t x is possible71 a bett] ?+ ( its k9d1 m compreh5sive1 m ela/ic1 m readily responsive to ! dem&s ( all occasions & ! ne$s ( all sorts & conditions ( m54 ,"s :o are deeply p]suad$ t only by doctr9al revision 9 "o direction or ano!r c ! ,pray] ,book be made ?or\ghly to comm5d itself to ! he>t & m9d ( ! ,am]ican p w e/eem ! measure ( *ange above indicat$ n wor? ! ef=t indisp5sable to ! atta9m5t ( x4 ,be x s2 o!r "s !re are :o d ?9k ! attempt well advis$ & :o are will+ to waive _! own pet notions z to possible doctr9al improvem5ts ( ! book = ! sake ( secur+ a cons5sus ^u c]ta9 great practical improvem5ts :i* come )9 ! range ( ?+s atta9able4 ,c]ta9 x is t any attempt ( a body ( review]s l ?is to di/urb1 ev5 by %ad[$ h9t1 ! exi/+ doctr9al settlem5t "u :i* we are liv+ toge!r1 w\ld be res5t$ by ! :ole ,*ur*4 ,!re are div9es among u :o 9 ! int]e/ ( a m %>ply def9$ or?odoxy are consci5ti\sly b5t ^u secur+ ! re9troduction among our =mul>ies ( ! s-call$ ,a?anasian ,cre$4 ,!re are o!rs :o consid] t a m damag+ bl[ at ! ca?olicity ( our dogmatic position z a ,*ur* c\ld sc>cely be dealt4 ,aga91 !re are !ologians :o acc\nt ! ,pray] ,book to be s ?or\ghly saturat$ 9 all its p>ts ) ! sacram5tal idea1 t !y w\ld acc\nt x n only a piece ( f>-see+ /atesman%ip1 b also a p]fectly safe proc$ure to all[ ^? :o *ose to d s to ?ank ,god aft] a *ild's baptism = ! simple fact t he _h !reby be5 graft$ into ! body ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur*4 ,b ov] aga9/ ^! /& a mu* l>g] numb] :o ?9k no?+ ( ! sort1 & :o w\ld put up ) ! liturgical %ortcom+s ( ! ,pray] ,book1 g )\t enri*m5ts = a ?\s& ye>s1 r ?an see ! s+le ^w reg5]ate dropp$ out ( ! po/-baptismal (fice4 ,s5sible m5 n a few are to be f\nd :o hold t ! incom+ tide ( ho/-wor%ip ) :i*1 z !y conceive1 our re=m$ ,*ur* is ?reat5$ c nev] be /ay$ unless "s c>efully contriv$ def9ition ins]t$ 9 ! ,pray] ,book %all make impossible ?is subtile & ref9$ species ( idolatry4 ,b m5 no :it less s5sible laugh !m 9 ! face1 po9t+ to ! black rubric & its hi/ory z evid5ce t betwe5 ! admitt$ doctr9e ( ! real pres5ce & ! disall[$ t5et ( transub/antiation no imp]vi\s b>ri] ( words c possibly be run4 ,^! illu/rations ( probable div]g5ce 9 op9ion1 9 case ! field ( doctr9e 7 once ent]$1 might be multipli$4 ,! retranslation ( ! ,nic5e ,cre$ & ! m accurate punctuation ( its s5t5ces2 ! r5d]+ ( ! ^w ,sabba? 9 ! ,f\r? ,comm&m5t into its ,engli% equival5t ( ,re/2 ! abolition ( ! curi\s misnom] "u :i* we g on call+ ,,xxxviii ,articles ,,xxxix2 ! removal f ! ,cate*ism1 or else ! conv]sion into "m ,engli% ( t sad crux infantum1 ! answ] to ! "q1 ,:at desire/ ?\ ( ,god 9 ?is pray]8 are a few examples ( less importance ?an ^? previ\sly cit$2 & yet1 9 ! case ( ! lea/ ( !m1 x is mo/ unlikely t ! advocates ( *ange w\ld h ! %[ ( h&s 9 _! favor1 s s5sitive is ! m9d ( ! ,*ur* to any?+ t looks 9 ! lea/ degree l tamp]+ ) ! /&>ds ( weight & measure1 ! %ekels ( ! sanctu>y4 ,on ! o!r h&1 !re are c]ta9 manife/ & palpable in/ances ( inaccuracy &1 m r>ely1 infelicity ( diction :i* ! review]s might v prop]ly take occasion to am5d ev5 ?\gh su* alt]ations c\ld n be classifi$ by a /rict con/ructioni/ "u ei!r ( ! two heads enri*m5t & flexibility4 ,9 ! ma/]ly ,report ( ! ,rev4 ,dr4 ,t4 ,w4 ,coit to ! ,jo9t ,committee appo9t$ by ! ,conv5tion ( #ahda to prep>e a ,/&>d ,pray] ,book1#aj a docum5t ( classical rank1 !re is m ?an "o intimation ( ! hope t future review]s w\ld be giv5 a l>g] lib]ty 9 ?is direction ?an he _h himself enjoy$4 ,he *af$1 & naturally en\gh1 "u ! necessity ( repr9t+ 9 a /&>d book1 evid5t & ackn[l$g$ solecisms & blund]s4 ,we want$1 he says1 to correct "o ungrammatical clause 9 ! ,consecration ,pray] ( ! ,communion ,s]vice4 ,x is 9 ! la/ s5t5ce b "o1 at its close4 ,x %\ld be1 n t he may dwell 9 !m & !y 9 him2 b1 t he may dwell 9 u & we 9 him4 ,! pray] is made up out ( two or ?ree o!rs2 & anyone :o w exam9e ! p>ts put toge!r w easily see h[ ! ?+ 0 ov]look$4 ,a mu* great] error 0 ov]look$ else:]e1 %[+ t our ,am]ican compil]s 7 n suffici5tly aw>e ( ! necessity :i* requires t ! ,pray] ,book %\ld always be consi/5t ) itself4 ,i allude to some?+ 9 ! (fice = ! ,private ,baptism ( ,*ildr54 ,suppose a cl]gyman to avail himself ( ! lic5se giv5 9 ! ,rubric aft] ! c]tification4 ,he w !n be made to talk ?us3 ',z ! ,holy ,gospel do? witness to our com=t1 on ?is wise--,do/ ?\ 9 ! "n ( ?is *ild1' etc4#aa ,o!r cases ( evid5t inaccuracy1 besides ^? ref]r$ to by ?is em95t critic1 might be cit$1 ev5 f ! late/ ,/&>d ,pray] ,book1 t ( #ahga4 ,x is h>d1 = in/ance1 to imag9e ev5 ! v]ie/ m>t9et 9 su* matt]s object+ to ! r$ress ( a great wrong done on page #cf ( ! volume m5tion$1 :]e ! pray] to be us$ at ! meet+s ( ,conv5tion is ent]$ "u ! g5]al head+1 ,= malefactors aft] condemnation4 ,our ecclesia/ical legislators h d\btless1 l ! re/ ( u1 err$ & /ray$ m ?an once1 b to deal out to !m su* h>% measure z ?is is cruel4 ,a /range unc]ta9ty w\ld seem f ! ,rubric to exi/ ) ref]5ce to ! limits ( ! ,litany4 ,on page #eed ( ! ,/&>d ,pray] ,book1 ! words1 ,"h ende? ! ,litany1 occur imm$iately aft] ! pray]1 ,we humbly besee* !e1 ,o ,fa!r1 :ile on page #ca ! same /atem5t is plac$ imm$iately aft] ! m9or b5$iction4 ,^! are n faults = :i* x c\ld ev] be wor? :ile to revise a ,pray] ,book1 b !y are blemi%es ( :i* ! revis]s ( a ,pray] ,book ought to take note4 ,x is a grav] matt] to speak ( infelicities ( diction 9 a book s ju/ly fam\s z ! ,pray] ,book = its pure & :olesome ,engli%4 ,wordswor?'s curse on ,"o :o w\ld peep & botanize ,^u 8 "m's grave seems1 9 ! judgm5t ( _m1 fairly e>n$ by ! critic1 :oev] he may be1 :o v5tures to sugge/ t 9 any slighte/ in/ance ! language ( ! =mul>ies might h be5 m happily phras$4 ,b !re are spots on ! sun4 ,9 ! pray] already ref]r$ to1 t = use at ! meet+s ( ,conv5tion1 ! petition1 ,we besee* !e to be pres5t ) ! c\ncil ( ?y ,*ur* "h assembl$ 9 ?y "n & pres5ce does seem op5 to ! *>ge ( tautology if no?+ worse4 ,x w\ld be well if :]ev] ! ^w occurs 9 ! ,pray] ,book 9 connection ) ,deity ! an?ropomorphic plural e>s c\ld be replac$ by ! symbolic s+ul> e>4 ,consid]+ also ! great evil ( hav+ 9 a =mul>y ( wor%ip too _m ?+s t h to be labori\sly expla9$1 x might be well if 9 ! ,litany ! adjective sudd51 :i* ev] s9ce ,hook]'s day has giv5 p]petual occasion = cavil1 7 to yield to untimely1 or "s l ^w m sugge/ive ?an sudd5 ( ! ?\ght clumsily express$ 9 ! ,*apel ,liturgy by ! awkw>d phrase1 dea? unprep>$ =4#ab ,x mu/ be aga9 rem>k$ t ^! are n po9ts = ! sake ( :i* ^w-fanci]s w\ld be ju/ifi$ 9 di/urb+ an exi/+ ord] ( ?+s2 !y are simply in/ances ( less] improvem5ts t might v prop]ly accompany l>g] ones1 %\ld l>g] ones ev] be s]i\sly und]tak54 ,) s _m pegs ^u :i* controv]sies might be hung />+ u 9 ! face1 c we ?9k ( x z at all likely t any consid]able numb] ( ,*ur*m5 assembl$ 9 committee 7to say no?+ ( ,conv5tion7 w be able to agree ^u a common l9e ( action ) ref]5ce to an am5dm5t ( ! =mul>ies8 ,t is ! v po9t at issue1 & h[ x is to be decid$ only ! ev5t c %[4 ,c]ta9ly 9 ! roll ( ! victories ( *>ity1 a favorable result1 7 x a*iev$1 w\ld /& exce$+ high4 ,?is reflection naturally leads up to ! inquiry :e!r !re is any special reason to consid] ! pres5t a happy mom5t to attempt )9 ! limits already def9$ a revision ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,,iii4 ,! argum5t = timel9ess has be51 9 "p1 already /at$4 ,a revision w be timely1 if ! times imp]atively dem& x2 & ! ma9 reasons = ?9k+ t !y d are be=e ! read]4 ,some?+1 h[ev]1 is /ill left to be said 9 evid5ce t ! movem5t n[ begun is opportune--n rudely ?ru/ ^u ! ,*ur*4 ,to ev]y?+1 sai? ! prea*]1 !re is a season1 & a "t to e purpose "u heav51 & among ! categories t foll[ ?is /atem5t we f9d reckon$ :at answ]s to liturgical enri*m5t1 = !re is1 he obs]ves1 a "t to build up4 ,fifty ye>s ago a p]suasive argum5t aga9/ attempt+ to am5d ! ,pray] ,book1 ei!r 9 text or rubrics1 might h be5 bas$ ^u ! lack ( h&s compet5t to und]take s delicate a task4 ,raw mat]ial1 well adapt$ to edification1 0 ly+ ab\t 9 blocks1 b skill$ workm5 7 sc>ce4 ,?is c h>dly be said to-day4 ,simultane\sly ) ! beg9n+ ( ! ,ox=d movem5t1 !re naturally sprang up a fre% int]e/ 9 liturgical /udies1 an int]e/ :i* has gone on deep5+ & wid5+ until 9 volume & mom5tum ! /ream has n[ probably rea*$ its out] limit4 ,! conv9c+ citation1 ,!re 7 giants 9 ^? days1 ) :i* a late bi%op ( "o ( ! ,new ,engl& dioceses us$ to en=ce 8 major premise t wisdom di$ ) ,cranm] & 8 colleagues1 no long] satisfies4 ,probably no p]iod ( correspond+ l5g? 9 ! :ole range ( ,engli% ,*ur* hi/ory has %[n itself s ri* 9 ! fruits ( liturgical /udy z ! fifty ye>s t h elaps$ s9ce ! introduction into ! ,engli% ,p>liam5t ( ! fir/ ,re=m ,bill4#ac ,?is p>ticul> hi/orical l&m>k is m5tion$ on acc\nt ( ! close connection ( cause & effect betwe5 x & ! rem>kable movem5t set on foot by ,newman1 ,pusey1 ,keble1 & ,fr\de4 ,to be sure1 "o ( ! e>lie/ utt]ances 9 ! ,tracts ran 9 ^! words3 ,attempts are mak+ to get ! ,liturgy alt]$4 ,my de> bre?r51 ,i besee* y consid] ) me :e!r y ought n resi/ ! alt]ation ( ev5 "o jot or tittle ( x4#ad ,& yet1 not)/&+ ?is disclaim]1 "o ( ! ma9 impulses t lay beh9d ! :ole movem5t repres5t$ by ! ,tracts 0 an e>ne/ desire to quick5 ! life ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 9 ! region ( wor%ip4 ,9 ! ,table ( ! ,tracts1 %[+ _! arrangem5t accord+ to ,subjects1 ! ,liturgical section comes fir/4 ,! pres5t writ] ackn[l$ges b a v limit$ sympa?y ) ! doctr9al motives & aims ( ei!r ! e>li] or ! lat] ,tract>ians4 ,b let u1 above all ?+s1 be fair4 ,) :atev] prepossessions "o looks back ^u x1 ! gr\nd trav]s$ by ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& dur+ ! pa/ fifty ye>s _c be o!rwise reg>d$ ?an z a field s[n ) m+l$ t>es & :eat4 ,individuals w diff] 9 judgm5t z to ! proportion 9 :i* ^! two products ( a common soil h coexi/$1 b ev5 ^? :o h mo/ /\tly oppos$ !mselves to ! ,ox=d movem5t1 z a :ole1 are fa9 to cr$it x )1 at lea/1 ?is "o good result1 ! rescue ( ! usages ( wor%ip f slov5l9ess & torpor1 & ! e/abli%m5t ( a bett] /&>d ( :at is seemly1 rev]5t1 & beautiful 9 ! public s]vice ( ,almighty ,god4 ,n t !re h n be51 ev5 9 ?is respect1 grave errors 9 ! direction ( excess2 ! /atem5t v5tur$ is simply ?is1 t1 up to a c]ta9 po9t1 all ,*ur*m5 agree 9 admitt+ a g5u9e & :olesome improvem5t 9 ! popul> e/imate ( :at public wor%ip1 z su*1 ought to be4 ,an imm5se am\nt ( dev\t /udy has be5 giv51 dur+ ! p]iod m5tion$1 by _m able m5 to liturgical subjects1 & x w\ld be /range inde$ if fifty ye>s ( se>*+ criticism _h n result$ 9 ! detection ( "s few po9ts 9 :i* =mul>ies orig9ally compil$ to meet ! ne$s ( ! sixte5? c5tury might be bett] adapt$ to ! requirem5ts ( ! tw5tie?4 ,or1 to put ! same po9t 9 ano!r way1 has n all ?is se>*+ into ! m9es ( buri$ treasure1 all ?is gett+ toge!r ( qu>ri$ /one 7) possibly a c]ta9 surplusage ( /ubble7 be5 s mu* labor lo/1 if !re is nev] to come ! recognition ( a ripe mom5t = ! ,*ur* to avail itself ( ! results a*iev$8 ,are ! /udi\s toils ( a ,palm]1 a ,maskell1 a ,neale1 a ,scudamore1 & a ,bright to g = no?+ except 9 s f> z !y h be5 contributory to our fund ( ecclesiological lore8 ,if s1 ! contempt (t5 express$ = ritual & liturgical /udies by /ud5ts busy ) o!r l9es ( rese>* w\ld seem to be n :olly undes]v$4 ,a good opportunity is n[ be=e ! ,*ur* to give answ] z to :e!r ?is =m ( inve/igation is or is n any?+ bett] ?an a species ( sacr$ antiqu>ianism4 ,liturgiology z an aspirant = recognition among ! useful sci5ces may be said at ! pres5t mom5t to be wait+ = ! v]dict4 ,to be sure1 x c be ass]t$ = liturgiology t to ^? :o love x x is a /udy t proves itself1 l poetry1 its own exce$+ great rew>d4 ,x is n wor? :ile to dispute ?is po9t4 ,liturgiology pursu$ = its own sake may n be ! l(tie/ ( /udies1 b ?is1 at lea/1 c be said = x1 t x is a n less respectable object ( pursuit ?an _m ano!r specialty ! devotees ( :i* look d[n ^u ! liturgiologi/ ) self-complac5t scorn z a m]e *iffoni]4 ,! =ms :i* ,*ri/ian wor%ip has tak5 on 9 successive g5]ations & among peoples ( v>i\s blood are c]ta9ly z well wor?y ( analysis & classification z are ! flora & fauna ( ,patagonia or ,new ,zeal&4 ,b :ile ! ,patagonian naturali/ secures recognition & is decorat$1 e jaunty man ( lett]s feels at lib]ty to sc(f at ! liturgiologi/ z a labori\s trifl]4 ,moreov]1 rememb]+ t 9 favorite /udies1 z 9 crops1 !re rules a pr9ciple ( rotation1 fa%ion affect+ ev5 /aid div9es ) its subtle influ5ce1 we may look to see pres5tly a decl9e ( int]e/ 9 ?is p>ticul> dep>tm5t ( inquiry4 ,especially may s]i\s m5 be expect$ to turn _! att5tion 9 o!r directions1 %\ld x be f\nd t a ,non possumus awaits e ef=t to make ! fruits ( _! labor available = ! n\ri%m5t ( ! ,*ur*'s daily life4 ,s !n1 in/ead ( def]r+ action until liturgical k %all h become m widely spread1 & available liturgical mat]ial m abundant1 we %all1 if we are wise1 p]ceive t only by mov+ promptly w x be possible 9 ?is case to take ! tide at ! full4 ,nev] aga9 w opportunity be m ripe4 ,ano!r evid5ce ( timel9ess is suppli$ by ! pres5t pacific condition ( ! ,*ur*4 ,previ\s movem5ts t[>d liturgical revision h be5 ( a m or less p>tisan & acrimoni\s temp]4 ,n[ = ! fir/ "t we seem to be tak+ up ?is subject )\t ! expression ( a fe> f any qu>t] t if *anges are made ?is or t p>ty w get ! advantage ( "s o!r4 ,! peculi> conditions t ensure ?is unwont$ truce ( ,god are n likely to la/ =ev]1 nor is x p]haps :olly desirable t !y %\ld d s2 :at is desirable1 & v desirable1 is t we %\ld avail ourselves ( ! lull to accompli% c]ta9 *anges = ! bett]1 :i* 9 ord9>y times ! preval5t heat ( friction makes impossible4 ,! ,jo9t ,committee ( ,tw5ty-"o is confid5tly believ$ to conta9 )9 itself e %ade ( color kn[n to belong to ! ,anglican spectrum2 if :ite light %\ld be f\nd to em]ge1 ?ree ye>s h5ce1 z a result ( ! ,committee's labors1 x w be said1 & truly1 t nev] be=e 9 our hi/ory c\ld su* a bl5d+ ( ! rays possibly h tak5 place4 ,/ill ano!r consid]ation prop]ly includ$ "u ! g5]al head ( timel9ess is said to h be5 urg$ ) mu* =ce 9 ! ,h\se ( ,bi%ops :5 ! enri*m5t resolution 0 "u discussion4 ,up to ! pres5t "t ! ,episcopal ,*ur* ( ?is c\ntry has /ood easily at ! head 9 ! matt] ( provid+ = ! p a dignifi$ & beautiful ord] ( div9e s]vice4 ,9 fact1 !re has be51 until lately1 no "o to compete4 ,b all ?is is *ang+4 ,ours are no long] ! only congregations 9 :i* common pray] is to be f\nd4 ,x is true t ?us f> ! attempts at imitation h be5 r grotesque ?an =midable1 b su*1 until rec5tly1 h also be51 9 ! judgm5t ( =eign critics1 all ( our ,am]ican endeavors aft] art4 ,we are to consid] :at apt le>n]s our quick-witt$ c\ntrym5 h %[n !mselves to be1 9 s mu* t ev5 ,*ri/mas ,day1 once ! bete noire ( ,puritan legislators1 has come to be acc\nt$ almo/ a national fe/ival1 & we %all be conv9c$ t our primacy 9 ! field ( liturgies is n an absolutely assur$ position4 ,?is argum5t is op5 to ! criticism t x seems to l[] & *eap5 ! :ole subject by repres5t+ ,anglican religion 9 a m5dicant attitude bidd+ = ! favor ( ! great ,am]ican public1 & vex$ t o!rs1 fell[-suppliants1 h /ol5 a good =mula ( appeal4 ,nev]!less !re is a c]ta9 am\nt ( reasonabl5ess 9 ?is way ( putt+ ! ?+4 ,c]ta9ly ) ^? :o reckon ! liturgical mode ( wor%ip among ! notes ( ! ,*ur*1 ! argum5t is "o t ought to h m>k$ influ5ce2 :ile ) ^? :o1 n s p]suad$1 nev]!less view ) pleas$ int]e/ ! g5]al spread ( a liturgical ta/e among ! p ( ?is c\ntry1 see+ 9 x a tok5 ( bett] ?+s to come1 a h>b+] ( l>g] agreem5ts ?an we h yet atta9$ to1 & ( an approa*+ consolation ( ,israel once n ?\ght possible--ev5 ) su* ! argum5t ought n to be :olly p[]less4#ae ,! fact t ! ,convocations ( ,cant]bury & ,york h tak5 9 h& & c>ri$ ?r\gh a revision ( ! rubrics ( ! ,pray] ,book w seem to ^? :o hold t our ,*ur* ought to advance p>i passu ) ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 & no fa/]1 ano!r evid5ce ( ! timel9ess ( ! ,am]ican movem5t4 ,"u ! title ( ,! ,convocation ,pray] ,book !re has lately appe>$ 9 ,engl& an edition ( ! ,pray] ,book s pr9t$ z to %[ h[ ! book w\ld read 7 ! recomm5dations ( ,york & ,cant]bury to g into effect4 ,x is true t ! cons5t ( ,p>liam5t mu/ be secur$ be=e ! alt]$ rubrics c h ! =ce ( law2 b :atev] may come ( ! rubrics recomm5d$1 ! exi/5ce ( ! book conta9+ !m is evid5ce en\gh ( a wide-spread conviction among ! ,engli% cl]gy t *ange is ne$$4 ,inde$ nev] has ?is po9t be5 m p[]fully put 9 ! fewe/ possible words ?an by ! brilliant1 & no less logical ?an brilliant ,bi%op ( ,pet]bor\gh 9 a rec5t spee* 9 ! ,upp] ,h\se ( ,convocation4#af ,if ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& wants absolute peace1 %e %\ld h def9ite rubrics4 ,x is true he goes on to say t 9 8 judgm5t ! dang]s ( c>ry+ ! "q ( rubrical revision into ,p>liam5t are great] ?an ! evil ( lett+ x alone1 b x is to be rememb]$ t we 9 ?is c\ntry are hamp]$ ) no ,p>liam5t>y entanglem5ts & are free to d ( our own motion1 & 9 a quiet1 ord]ly way1 t :i* ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& c only d at ! risk ( some?+ v l revolution4 ,b ?is matt] ( ! rubrics & _! susceptibility ( improvem5t w come up lat] on4 ,x seem$ prop] to ref] to x1 if no m1 "u ! head ( timel9ess4 ,if no?+ else 9 ! way ( *ange be opportune at ! pres5t mom5t1 x is an easy task to %[ t ! rubrics1 z !y /&1 cry al\d = a revision4 ,,iv4 ,! ob/acles to be enc\nt]$ by any ,committee und]tak+ s to c>ry =w>d a review ( ! ,pray] ,book t revision may ev5tually result1 are ( two sorts2 !re are ! inh]5t difficulties ( ! "w itself1 su*1 = in/ance1 z t ( mat*+ ! lit]>y /yle ( ! sixte5? c5tury writ]s1 & !re is ! :olesome dread ( a *ange = ! worse :i* is sure to ass]t itself 9 _m qu>t]s ! mom5t def9ite propositions %all h rea*$ a po9t at :i* ! yeas & nays are likely to be call$4 ,beg9n+1 !n1 ) ! inh]5t difficulties1 & tak+ !m 9 ! inv]se ord] ( ardu\sness1 we see at once h[ h>d x mu/ be to secure unity & self-consi/5cy 9 ! revision ( a book s complicat$ z ! ,common ,pray]4 ,x is l remodell+ an old h\se4 ,we ?9k x a v easy matt]1 some?+ t c be done 9 "o's head1 b ! mi/ake is discov]$ :5 ! new door design$ to give symmetry to ?is room is f\nd to h spoil$ ! looks ( t1 :5 ! enl>gem5t ( ! libr>y turns out to h ov]tax$ ! heat+ en]gy ( ! fireplace1 & ! +5i\s /aircase1 in/ead ( end+ :]e x 0 expect$ to end1 br+s up aga9/ an intractable brick wall4 ,j su* p]ils z ^! w beset anybody :o v5tures to di/urb ! adju/m5ts ( ! ,pray] ,book z x is & to introduce desirable additions4 ,b dome/ic ar*itecture is n giv5 up on acc\nt ( ! pati5t c>efulness ! practice ( x dem&s1 nei!r ne$ ,liturgical ,revision be despair$ ( because x requires ( ! m5 :o und]take x a l wisdom 9 look+ be=e & aft]4 ,! really =midable b>ri] to revision1 s f> z :at h be5 call$ ! inh]5t difficulties are conc]n$1 is rea*$ :5 we t\* /yle4 ,h[ to h&le )\t h>m+ ! s5t5ces 9 :i* ,engli% religion phras$ itself :5 ,engli% language 0 fre%] & m flu5t ?an x c ev] be aga9 is a s]i\s "q4 ,! h&s t seek to enri* may well be caution$ to take he$ le/ !y despoil4 ,x is to be rememb]$1 h[ev]1 9 ! way ( reassurance t ! alt]ations mo/ likely to f9d favor ) ! review]s are su* z w enri* by re/or+ lo/ excell5cies1 r ?an by introduc+ =ms fa%ion$ on a mod]n anvil4 ,! mo/ s5sitive critic c\ld n1 on ! score ( ta/e1 f9d fault ) ! replacem5t 9 ! ,ev5+ ,pray] ( ! ,magnificat & ! ,nunc dimittis1 nor ( br++ back a few ( ! ,v]sicles t 9 ! ,engli% book foll[ ! ,"l's ,pray]1 nor yet ( our be+ all[$ to say1 ,light5 our d>kness1 we besee* !e1 ,"l1 r ?an ,o ,"l1 our ,heav5ly ,fa!r1 by ^: ,almighty p[] we h be5 pres]v$ ?is day4 ,objections to ^! alt]ations may be readily imag9$1 b x w\ld be necess>y to base !m on o!r gr\nds ?an ^? ( lit]>y fa/idi\sness4 ,9 ! case ( enri*m5ts l ^! no "o c\ld raise ! cry t ! faultless ,engli% ( ! ,pray] ,book _h be5 m>r$4 ,b :at %all be said ( ! composition ( entirely new s]vices & (fices1 if x %\ld be judg$ exp$i5t to give admission to any su*8 ,h[ c we be sure t su* mod]n additions to ! edifice w\ld be suffici5tly 9 keep+ ) ! g5]al tone ( ! eld] ar*itecture8 ,x might be held to be an adequate answ] to ^! que/ions to reply t if ! liv+ ,*ur* _c n[ tru/ h]self to speak out ?r\gh h] =mul>ies 9 h] natural voice z %e did v5ture to d 9 ! sev5te5? c5tury & ! eighte5?1 x mu/ be t %e has fall5 into t /age ( decrepitude :]e ! natural voice is unc]ta94 ,b1 really1 :at ought to be said is ?is--t if ! same canons ( /yle t rul$ ! sixte5? c5tury writ]s are /udi$ & obey$1 !re is no reason 9 ! _w :y a result equally satisfactory ) ! "o !n atta9$ %\ld n be rea*$ n[4 ,!re is no?+ sup]natural ab\t ! ,engli% ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,cranm] & 8 associates 7 n inspir$4 ,! prose /yle ( ! n9ete5? c5tury may n be z good z t ( ! sixte5?1 b1 at its be/1 x is va/ly sup]ior to eighte5? c5tury /yle1 & ( ?is la/ !re are already no inconsid]able specim5s 9 ! ,am]ican ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,! ,(fice = ! ,visitation ( ,prison]s1 = example1 is s r$ol5t ( ! times ( ! ,georges1 :5 x 0 compos$1 t x might be appropriately en\gh int]leav$ ) pr9ts out ( ,hog>?4 ,a bit ( ,palladian ar*itecture 9 a ,go?ic *ur* is n m easily recogniz$4 ,_m worse ?+s might happ5 to ! ,pray] ,book ?an t ! n9ete5? c5tury %\ld leave its impress ^u ! pages4 ,9 fact1 x is j z possible1 if m5 w only ?9k s1 to use our language ) effect = any good purpose to-day z x 0 ?ree hundr$ ye>s ago4 ,all t is necess>y is a will+ness to submit to ! same re/rictions1 & ^? mo/ly moral1 t controll$ ! old writ]s2 & our "w1 ?\gh n id5tical ) !irs1 w h ! prop] simil>ity4 ,true1 a mod]n au?or may n be able to reproduce1 )\t a palpable betrayal ( affectation & mann]ism1 ! precise *>act]i/ics ( a bygone /yle4 ,*att]tons are n num]\s4 ,x is easi] to secure = ! brass &irons & mahogany d9+ *airs ( our own manufacture ! look ( ^? t belong$ to our gr&fa!rs ?an x is to cat* ! tones ( voices long dead2 & j z good judgm5t dictates ! wisdom ( repeat+ ! hone/ & ?or\gh workman%ip ( ! old cab9et-mak]s 9 place ( slavi%ly imitat+ _! patt]ns1 s x w be well if ! compil]s ( devotional =ms = mod]n use seek to say :at !y h to say ) sixte5? c5tury simplicity r ?an 9 sixte5? c5tury spee*4 ,9 lett]s1 z 9 conduct1 ! supreme *>m ( /yle is ! abs5ce ( self-consci\sness4 ,say 9 pla9 words ! ?+ y mean1 & say x z if y meant x1 is good advice to any seek] aft] rhetorical excell5ce1 be he "y or old4 ,! ,re=m]s1 t is to say1 ! m5 :o ,engli%$ ! ,pray] ,book1 9 seek+ to meet ! devotional ne$s ( ! p ( _! own "t d n seem to h be5 at pa9s to tie !mselves to ! diction ( a previ\s g5]ation4 ,!y d>$ to call a spade a spade :5ev] & :]ev] ! tool came into use1 & !y h _! rew>d 9 ! p]man5ce ( _! "w4 ,sweetnesses & prett9esses !y bani%$ altoge!r4 ,inde$1 9 ^? days x seems n to h occurr$ to p t su* ?+s _h any?+ to d ) religion4 ,x 0 n t !y did n "k h[ to talk 9 ! sweet way--nev] has s5tim5talism be5 m rife 9 g5]al lit]ature ?an !n1 b !y w\ld n talk 9 t way2 ! /]n traditions ( ,holy ,*ur* ?r\gh\t all ! _w =bade4 ,religion 0 a mo/ s]i\s ?+ to _! m9ds1 & !y w\ld speak ( x mo/ s]i\sly or n at all4 ,nev] s9ce language began to be us$ h sev]ity & t5d]ness be5 m m>vell\sly bl5d$ ?an 9 ! old] portions ( ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book4 ,?is effect is l>gely due to an almo/ entire ab/5tion on ! "p ( ! writ]s f figurative language1 or at lea/ f all imag]y t is n readily recogniz$ z ,scriptural4 ,bread & beef are :at m5 dem& = a /eady diet4 ,sweetmeats are well en\gh1 n[ & !n1 b only n[ & !n4 ,x is ! failure to obs]ve ?is pla9 canon ( /yle t has made %ipwreck ( _m an attempt to con/ruct liturgies de novo4 ,ambiti\s fram]s ( =ms ( wor%ip seem almo/ inv>iably to =get t !re may be su* a ?+ z a too exquisite pray]1 an altoge!r too eloqu5t address to ! ?rone ( grace4 ,! longe/ & fulle/ supplicatory portion ( ! ,pray] ,book1 ! ,litany1 does n conta91 f ! fir/ s5t5ce to ! la/1#ag "o s+le figurative expression1 x is lit]ally pla9 ,engli% f beg9n+ to end2 b c\ld language be fram$ m int5se1 m satisfy+1 m likely to endure8 ,scriptural metaphor1 :e!r because x comes to u ) ! /amp ( au?ority or on acc\nt ( "s subtle intr9sic excell5ce1 x may be difficult to say1 does n pall ^u ! ta/e4 ,& yet ev5 ?is is us$ sp>+ly 9 ! ,pray] ,book1 "s ( ! mo/ /rik+ exceptions to ! g5]al rule be+ af=d$ by ! collects = ! fir/ & ?ird ,sundays 9 ,adv5t1 ! collects = ! ,epiphany & ,ea/] ,ev51 & ! op5+ pray] 9 ! ,baptismal ,(fice4 ,all ^! are in/ances ( /rictly ,scriptural metaphor1 & moreov] x is to be kept 9 m9d t !y are design$ = occasional1 n con/ant use4 ,9 ! ord]s = daily ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]1 ! lo/ %eep ( ! ,g5]al ,confession & ! dew ( ,god's bless+ 9 ! ,collect = ,cl]gy & ,p are almo/ ! sole1 if n ! sole cases ( evid5t metaphor1 & ^! aga9 are ,scriptural4 ,:5 9 ,j]emy ,taylor's pray]1 introduc$ by ! ,am]ican revis]s into ! ,ord] = ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick1 we come ^u ! comp>ison ( human life to a vale ( mis]y we feel t someh[ we h /ruck a new curr5t 9 ! atmosph]e2 = ! mom5t x is ! rhetorician :o speaks1 & no long] ! e>ne/ seek] aft] ,god4 ,besides ?is fre$om f figures ( spee*1 we notice 9 ! /yle ( ,pray] ,book ,engli% a c>eful avoidance ( :atev] looks l a metaphysical ab/raction4 ,! aim is ev] to pres5t ,god & div9e ?+s z realities r ?an z m]e concepts or notions ( ! m9d4 ,s f> z ! writ] rememb]s1 n a s+le pray] 9 ! :ole book beg9s ) t =mula s de> to ! mak]s ( extempor>y =ms ( devotion1 ,o ,?\4 ,on ! contr>y1 ! approa* to ! ,div9e ,maje/y is almo/ always made ) a ref]5ce to "s attribute or *>act]i/ic t l9ks ,deity to man & man's affairs2 x is ,o ,god1 ! ,protector ( all t tru/ 9 !e1 or ,almighty & ev]la/+ ,god :o ( ?y t5d] love t[>d mank9d1 or ,"l ( all p[] & might :o art ! au?or & giv] ( all good ?+s4 ,c>d9al ,newman 9 "o ( 8 !ological works writt5 be=e 8 dep>ture f ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 has a p[]ful passage be>+ ^u ?is po9t4 ,he is criticis+ ! evangelicals = _! "o-sid$ way ( sett+ =? :at x mu/ mean to prea* ! ,gospel4 ,no less a p]son ?an ,legh ,ri*mond is ! object ( 8 /rictures4 ,a rem>kable contra/ betwe5 our ,*ur*'s & ?is false view ( religion1 he says1 is af=d$ 9 ! respective modes ( treat+ a dea?-b$ 9 ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick1 & a popul> mod]n "w1 ! ,dairyman's ,daught]4 ,! latt] runs ?us3 ,my de> fri5d1 d y n ,,feel t y are support$8 ,! ,"l deals v g5tly ) me1 %e repli$4 ,are n 8 promises v preci\s to y8 ,!y are all yea & am5 9 ,*ri/ ,jesus44 4 ,d y exp]i5ce any d\bts or temptations on ! subject ( y\r et]nal safety8 ,no1 sir2 ! ,"l deals v g5tly ) me & gives me peace4 ,:at are y\r views ( ! d>k valley ( dea? n[ t y are pass+ ?r\gh x8 ,x is n d>k4 ,n[1 if x be said t su* que/ions & answ]s are n only 9 _! place innoc5t b natural & beautiful1 ,i answ] t ?is is n ! po9t1 b ?is1 viz41 !y are evid5tly int5d$1 :atev] _! m]its1 z a patt]n ( :at dea?-b$ exam9ations %\ld be4 ,su* is ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick 9 ! n9ete5? c5tury4 ,n[ let u li/5 to ! n]v\s & /]n tone ( ! sixte5?4 ,9 ! ,pray] ,book ! m9i/] is in/ruct$ to say to ! p]son visit$3 ,=asmu* z aft] ?is life !re is an acc\nt to be giv5 to ! ,righte\s ,judge 4 4 4 ,i require y to exam9e y\rself & y\r e/ate bo? t[>d ,god & man4 ,!re=e ,i %all rehe>se to y ! ,articles ( our ,fai?1 t y may "k :e!r y d believe z a ,*ri/ian man %\ld or no 4 4 4 ',!n %all ! m9i/] exam9e :e!r he rep5t him truly ( 8 s9s1 & be 9 *>ity ) all ! _w3 exhort+ him to =give f ! bottom ( 8 he>t all p]sons :o h (f5d$ him1 & if he ha? (f5d$ any o!r to ask _! =giv5ess1 & :]e he ha? done injury or wrong to any man t he make am5ds to ! utmo/ ( 8 p[]4' 4 4 4 ,su* is ! contra/ betwe5 ! dreamy talk ( mod]n ,prote/antism1 & 'holy fe>'s /]n gl[' 9 ! ,*ur* ,ca?olic4#ah ,9 ?is /rik+1 ?\gh p]haps some:at unnecess>ily h>% way1 ,newman br+s out a po9t :i* is unque/ionably true1 namely1 t ! language ( ! ,pray] ,book is ( ! sort :i* x is j n[ ! fa%ion to call reali/ic1 t is1 a language conv]sant ) great facts r ?an ) phases ( feel+ & moods ( m9d2 :i* aft] all is only ano!r way ( say+ t x is a ,book ( ,common ,pray] & n a manual = ! fur!rance ( spiritual introspection4 ,^!1 !n1 are ! *>act]i/ics ( ! ,pray] ,book /yle3 x is simple1 /raight=w>d1 unmetaphorical1 reali/ic4 ,s]i\sly x looks almo/ l a /udi$ insult alike to ! s*ol>%ip & to ! religion ( our day1 to say t ^! are excell5cies atta9able no long]4 ,t revis]s v5tur+ ^u additions to ! ,pray] ,book w\ld be b\nd to set ! face z a fl9t aga9/ any slighte/ approa* to s5tim5tality is true4 ,b :y assume t ! m5 d n exi/ :o are capable ( su* a measure ( self-control8 ,grant t !re are :ole volumes ( devotional matt]1 orig9al & compil$1 :i* "o may ransack )\t f9d+ a s+le =m t is n ei!r prolix1 wi%y-wa%y1 or sup]/iti\s--x does n foll[ t if ! ,pray] ,book is to be enri*$1 ! enri*m5ts mu/ necess>ily come f su* s\rces4 ,moreov] x is to be rememb]$ t !re is ano!r vice ( /yle to be %unn$ 9 liturgical composition q z c>efully z s5tim5tality1 namely1 jejun5ess4 ,we _c escape be+ s5tim5tal simply by be+ dull4 ,feel+ mu/ n be d5i$ its place 9 pray] = fe> t x may n prove itself a duly *a/5$ feel+4 ,!re ought to be a he>t ( fire und]nea? ! calm surface ( e =mul>y ( wor%ip4 ,flame & smoke are out ( place2 b a liturgy %\ld gl[ ?r\gh\t4 ,coldness1 pure & simple1 has no place 9 devotion4 ,ov] & above ! intr9sic difficulties 9 ! way ( revision gr[+ out ( ! delicate nature ( ! "w itself1 ob/acles ( a diff]5t sort are c]ta9 to be enc\nt]$4 ,9 s l>ge a body ( m5 z ! ,jo9t ,committee ( ! two ,h\ses1 entire & cordial agreem5t is almo/ too mu* to be expect$2 & !n ev5 suppos+ a unanim\s report submitt$1 :at is likely to foll[8 ,:y ?is--if ! *anges propos$ are few1 ! cry w be rais$1 ,x surely is n wor? :ile to alt] ! ,pray] ,book = ! sake ( s insignificant a ga92 :]eas if ! *anges propos$ are consid]able1 ! c\nt] cry w be s\nd$1 ,?is is revolution4 ,!n !re is ! anxi\s "q1 ,h[ w x look to ! ,engli%8 ,:at w be ! effect on ! ,concordat if we t\* ! ,pray] ,book8 ,to be sure1 ! ,concordat does n seem to weigh v heavily on ! %\ld]s ( ! o!r p>ty1 z inde$ !re is no reason :y x %\ld4 ,convocation does n mu* di/urb itself z to ! view ,g5]al ,conv5tion is likely to take ( its say+s & do+s1 & ev5 dise/abli%m5t might proce$ )\t our be+ call$ into consultation4 ,& yet ! ,concordat difficulty w h to be reckon$ )2 & ! dire spectre ( a possible dis[n+ ( u by our "m ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& w h to be laid1 be=e any alt]ations 9 ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] w be acc\nt$ by "s among u p]fectly safe4 ,b x is sc>cely wor? :ile to g on gratuit\sly sugge/+ opposition argum5ts4 ,!y w be sure to pres5t !mselves unsolicit$ 9 due "t4 ,= ! pres5t x is en\gh to add t if ! movem5t = liturgical revision has n 9 x en\gh t\ghness ( fibre to enable x to survive vigor\s attack1 x does n des]ve success4 ,v4 ,"u ! head ( liturgical enri*m5t ought to be class$ :atev] alt]ation w\ld really s]ve to enhance ! beauty1 maje/y1 or fitness1 ( accept$ =mul>ies ( wor%ip4 ,excision may1 "u conceivable circum/ances1 be enri*m5t4 ,james ,wyatt und\bt$ly imag9$ t he 0 improv+ ! ,engli% ca!drals :5 he :itewa%$ _! int]iors1 add$ composition p9nacles to ! we/ t[]s ( ,durham1 & re>rang$ ! anci5t monum5ts ( ,salisbury2 b an important "p ( ! enri*m5t accompli%$ by our n9ete5? c5tury re/or]s has la9 simply 9 ! undo+ ( :at ,wyatt did4 ,aga91 sub/itution may be enri*m5t1 z 9 ! case :]e a wood5 spire built ^u a /one t[] is tak5 d[n to be replac$ by hone/ "w4 ,x w\ld be an enri*m5t if 9 ,/4 ,george's ,*apel1 ! c5tral %r9e ( ,briti% royalty1 ! %am insignia n[ ov]hang+ ! /alls ( ! knights ( ! g>t] 7 to give room to g5u9e armor4 ,n m]ely !n by addition1 b possibly1 9 "s in/ances1 by bo? subtraction & sub/itution1 we may f9d ! ,pray]-book z x is op5 to improvem5t4 ,be=e1 h[ev]1 ent]+ ^u any criticism ( ! =mul>ies 9 detail1 x is important to draw a di/9ction betwe5 two v diff]5t ?+s1 namely1 ! /ructure ( a liturgical (fice & ! cont5ts ( x4 ,by /ructure %\ld be und]/ood ! skeleton or frame t makes ! gr\ndwork ( any giv5 (fice1 by cont5ts ! actual liturgical mat]ial employ$ 9 fill+ out ! (fice to its prop] cont\r4 ,! (fices ( ! ,roman ,brevi>y1 = example1 cont9ue1 = ! mo/ "p1 id5tical 9 /ructure f day to day1 ! ye> ?r\gh2 b !y v>y 9 cont5ts4 ,= an illu/ration ne>] home take our own ,ord] = ,daily ,morn+ ,pray]4 ,! /ructure ( x is z foll[s3 #a4 ,s5t5ces1 #b4 ,exhortation1 #c4 ,confession1 #d4 ,absolution1 #e4 ,"l's ,pray]1 #f4 ,v]sicles1 #g4 ,invitatory ,psalm1 #h4 ,! ,psalms = ! day1 #i4 ,lection1 #aj4 ,an!m or ,canticle1 #aa4 ,lection1 #ab4 ,an!m or ,canticle1 #ac4 ,cre$1 #ad4 ,v]sicles1 #ae4 ,collect = ! day1 #af4 ,/at$ ,collects & ,pray]s1 #ag4 ,b5$iction4 ,n[ x is evid5t t )\t dep>t+ by a hair's bread? f ! l9es ( ?is framework1 an indef9ite numb] ( s]vices might by a process ( sub/itution be put toge!r1 ea* "o ( :i* w\ld 9 outw>d appe>ance diff] widely f e o!r "o4 ,! id5tical skeleton1 t is to say1 might be s v>i\sly clo!d ^u t no two ( its embodim5ts w\ld be alike4 ,b is x desirable to run v mu* aft] v>iety ( su* a sort 9 a book ( pray] design$ = common use8 ,mo/ assur$ly1 ,no4 ,to jeop>d ! supreme desid]atum 9 a p's manual ( wor%ip1 simplicity3 to make x any h>d] ?an x n[ is = ! av]age /rang] 9 ! ,*ur* to f9d ! places1 w\ld be on ! "p ( revisioni/s an unp>donable blund]4 ,!re are1 h[ev]1 a few po9ts at :i* ! ,morn+ ,pray] might advantage\sly be enri*$1 & no risk run4 ,x w\ld surely add no?+ to ! difficulty ( f9d+ ! places if = "o-half ( ! pres5t op5+ s5t5ces !re 7 to be sub/itut$ s5t5ces appropriate to special days & seasons ( ! ecclesia/ical ye>4 ,we %\ld 9 ?is way be enabl$ to give ! key-note ( ! morn+'s wor%ip at ! v outset4 ,hav+ once dep>t$1 z 9 ! case ( our fir/ two s5t5ces1 f ! ,engli% prec$5t ( putt+ only p5it5tial v]ses ( ,scripture to ?is use1 !re is no reason :y we %\ld n c>ry out /ill m fully 9 our selection ! pr9ciple ( appropriat5ess4 ,! s5t5ces displac$ ne$ n be lo/1 = !y might /ill /&1 z n[1 at ! op5+ ( ! ,ev5+ ,pray]4 ,pass+ on to ! decl>ations ( absolution !re is an opportunity to simplify ! arrangem5t by omitt+ ! alt]nate =m borr[$ f ! ,ord] = ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp]1 :]e only x prop]ly belongs4 ,?is1 h[ev]1 is a *ange likely to be resi/$ on doctr9al gr\nds1 & ne$ n be urg$4 ,com+ to ! ,v5ite1 we f9d ano!r opportunity to acc5tuate ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>4 ,x may be said t ! rubric1 z x is already writt51 all[s = ! sub/itution ( special an!ms on ! great] fe/ivals & fa/s4 ,?is is true2 b by giv+ ! an!m = ,ea/] a place ( honor1 :ile relegat+ an!ms = ! o!r great days to an unnotic$ spot betwe5 ! ,selections & ! ,psalt]1 ! ,am]ican compil]s did practically discrim9ate 9 favor ( ,ea/] & aga9/ ! re/4 ,! real ne$s ( ! case w\ld be m wisely met if ! p]mission to omit ,v5ite n[ atta*$ to ! n9ete5? day ( ! mon? 7 to be ext5d$ to ,a%-,w$nesday & ,good ,friday1 & special ,new ,te/am5t an!ms analag\s to ! ,ea/] "o 7 to be ins]t$ along ) ! respective ,collects1 ,epi/les1 & ,gospels1 = ,*ri/mas-day & ,:itsunday4 ,by ?is *ange we %\ld put ea* ( ! ?ree great fe/ivals ( ! ye> into possession ( an invitatory an!m ( its own2 & we %\ld obviate on ! fa/+ days1 by ! simple exp$i5t ( omission1 ! futile ef=ts ( *oir-ma/] & organi/ to trans=m ,v5ite f a cry ( joy into a moan ( grief4 ,?is br+s u to ! ,psalt]4 ,"h we h an opportunity to correct ! palpable blund] by :i* x has come ab\t t ! greate/ ( ! p5it5tial psalms1 ! fifty-fir/1 has no place assign$ x among ! prop] psalms ei!r = ,a%-,w$nesday or = ,good ,friday4#ai ,x w\ld also be well to make optional1 if n obligatory1 ! use ( prop] psalms on days o!r ?an ^? already provid$ ) !m2 e4 g41 ,adv5t ,sunday1 ! ,epiphany1 ,ea/] ,ev51 ,tr9ity ,sunday1 & ,all ,sa9ts' ,day4#bj ,!re w\ld be a /ill l>g] ga9 9 ! direction ( flexibility ( use1 z well z a great economy ( valuable space1 if in/ead ( repr9t+ "s ?irty ( ! ,psalms ( ,david "u ! "n ( ,selections1 we 7 to provide = all[+ select psalms to be ann\nc$ by numb] 9 ! same mann] t prop] psalms are n[ ann\nc$4 ,in/ead ( only ! t5 selections we n[ h1 !re might !n be made available tw5ty or ?irty gr\ps ( psalms at absolutely no sacrifice ( room4 ,x has be5 object$ to ?is proposal t ! same difficulty :i* n[ atta*es to ! f9d+ ( ! prop] psalms on great days w\ld emb>rass congregations :5ev] select psalms 7 giv5 out2 b ?is is fairly met by ! c\nt] consid]ation t if our p 7 to be educat$ by ! use ( select psalms into a m facile h&l+ ( ! ,psalt] x w\ld be j s mu* ga9$ = days :5 ! prop] psalms mu/ ( necessity be f\nd & read4 ,! s]vices1 t is to say1 w\ld run all ! m smoo?ly on ! great days1 aft] congregations _h become habituat$1 on ord9>y days1 to pick+ out ! psalms by numb]4 ,ano!r /ep 9 ! l9e ( simplification1 & "o :i* x is 9 ord] to m5tion "h1 w\ld be ! removal f ! ,morn+ ,pray] ( ,gloria 9 ,excelsis1 see+ t x is nev]1 or almo/ nev]1 sung at ! end ( ! psalms unless at ,ev5+ ,pray]4 ,z to ! exp$i5cy ( re/or+ :at has be5 lo/ ( ,b5$ictus aft] ! second lesson1 ! pres5t writ] (f]s no op9ion4 ,!re are "s :o w>mly advocate ! replacem5t1 & !re is1 unque/ionably1 mu* to be said 9 favor ( x4 ,x is unlikely t any doctr9al motive dictat$ ! abbreviation4 ,paus+ a mom5t at ! ,cre$s = ! ins]tion ( a bett] title ?an ,or ?is be=e ! confession ( ,nicaea1 we pass to ! v]sicles t foll[4 ,"h aga9 x w\ld be enri*m5t to re/ore ! words ( ! ,engli% book1 al?\gh ! task ( f9d+ an equally melodi\s equival5t = ,o ,"l1 save ! ,que5 might n be easy4 ,happily ! o!r v]sicles are su* z no civil revolution c make obsolete4 ,x w nev] be amiss to pray1 ,endue ?y m9i/]s ) righte\sness4 ,answ]4 ,& make ?y *os5 p joyful4 ,^! are all ! alt]ations = :i* ! pres5t ,morn+ ,pray] consid]$ z a =m ( ,div9e ,s]vice = ,sundays w\ld seem to call4 ,x w be obs]v$ t !y are f> f be+ ( a radical "*1 t !y affect ! /ructure ( ! (fice n at all1 & t\* ! cont5ts ( x b slightly4 ,! case is alt]$ :5 we come to ! ,ord] = ,ev5+ ,pray]4 ,"h !re is a dem&1 n inde$ = any /ructural *ange1 b = v decid$ enri*m5t by sub/itution4 ,! word+ ( ! (fice is altoge!r too exact an e*o ( :at has be5 said only a few h\rs be=e 9 ,morn+ ,pray]4 ,x betok5s a pov]ty ( res\rces t does n really exi/1 :5 we all[ ourselves ?us to exhort1 confess1 absolve1 int]c$e1 & give ?anks 9 ! v same phrases at ?ree 9 ! aft]noon t 7 on our lips at elev5 9 ! morn+4 ,d\btless liturgical wor%ip owes a good measure ( its *>m to ! subtle p[] ( repetition2 b ! pr9ciple is "o t mu/ be h&l$ & appli$ ) ! mo/ delicate tact1 or virtue goes out ( x4 ,we mu/ di/+ui% betwe5 simil>ity & sam5ess4 ,! ord]$ recurr5ce ( acc5ts is :at makes ! rhy?m ( v]se2 b = all t1 !re is a diff]5ce betwe5 poetry & s+-song1 j z !re is a diff]5ce betwe5 melody & monotony4 ,moreov]1 ! ta/e ( mank9d und]goes *ange z to ! sorts ( repetition :i* x is dispos$ to tol]ate4 ,no mod]n poet ( /&+ w\ld v5ture1 = in/ance1 to employ id5tical epi!ts to ! ext5t t ,hom] does1 mak+ ,aurora rosy-f+]$ e "t %e appe>s ^u ! sc5e1 & ,juno z inv>iably ox-ey$4 ,p 7 pleas$ ) x !n1 !y w\ld n be pleas$ ) x n[4 ,x is possible 9 liturgies s to employ ! pr9ciple ( repetition t no we>y+ s5se ( sam5ess w be convey$1 & aga9 x is possible s to mismanage x z to trans=m wor%ip into some?+ little bett] ?an a sl[ me*anic ex]cise4 ,m]e it]ation1 z su*1 is b>r5 ( spiritual p[]2 witness ! endless say+s ov] ( ,kyrie ,eleison 9 ! ,ori5tal s]vice-books1 a species ( va9 repetition :i* a liturgical writ] ( high intellig5ce rightly *>act]izes z unmean+1 if n pr(ane4#ba ,n[ ! common popul> criticism ^u ! ,ev5+ ,pray] ( ! ,*ur* is t x repeats too slavi%ly ! word+ ( ! ,morn+ ,pray]4 ,if ?is is an unju/ criticism we ought n to let ourselves be tr\bl$ by x4 ,on ! o!r h&1 if x is a j criticism x w be mu* wis] ( u to he$ ?an to /ifle ! voice t tells u ! tru?4 ,x might seem to be /ra9+ a po9t 7 "o to v5ture to expla9 ! pres5t v noticeable dis9cl9ation ( ,*ur*m5 to att5d a second s]vice on ,sunday1 by connect+ x ) ! p>ticul> infelicity 9 "q2 b t ! excuse1 ,we h said all ?is once to-day2 :y say x aga98 may possibly h some?+1 ev5 if n mu*1 to d ) ! /ay+ at home is c]ta9ly a fair conjecture4 ,)\t alt]+ at all ! /ructure ( ! ,ev5+ ,pray]1 x w\ld be p]fectly possible s to refill or reclo! t =mul>y z to give x ! "o ?+ ne$ful :i* n[ x lacks--fre%ness4 ,9 su* a process ! ,magnificat & ! ,nunc dimittis w\ld play an important "p2 z w\ld also c]ta9 anci5t collects ( :i* we h he>d mu* ( late4 ,fail+ ?is1 ! next be/ ?+ 7& ! ?+1 x may be add$1 mu* m likely to be done1 consid]+ :at a t\gh resi/ant is old usage7 w\ld be ! provision ( an alt]nate & optional =m ( ,ev5+ ,pray]1 to be us$ ei!r 9 lieu (1 or z supplem5t>y to ! exi/+ (fice4 ,9 ! fram+ ( su* a ,lat] ,ev5song a l>g] fre$om w\ld be possible ?an 9 ! refill+ ( a =m ! ma9 l9es ( :i* 7 already fix$4 ,/ill1 ! fir/ plan w\ld be bett]1 if only x c\ld be br\ght )9 ! range ( ?+s possible4 ,next to ,ev5+ ,pray] 9 ! ord] ( ! ,table ( ,cont5ts comes ! ,litany4 ,"h !re is no call = enri*m5t1#bb ?\gh increas$ flexibility ( use might be secur$ = ?is v5]able =m ( int]cessory pray] by prefix+ to x ! foll[+ rubric abridg$ f a simil> "o propos$ 9 ,! ,convocation ,pray] ,book3 ,a ,g5]al ,supplication1 to be sung or said on ,sundays1 ,w$nesdays1 & ,fridays1 & on ! ,rogation ,days1 aft] ! ?ird collect at ,morn+ or ,ev5+ ,pray]1 or be=e ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,holy ,communion2 or z a sep>ate ,s]vice4 ,,note4--,! ,litany may be omitt$ altoge!r on ,*ri/mas ,day1 ,ea/] ,day1 & ,:itsunday ,9 connection ) ! ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,s]vice !re is ano!r important "q t imp]atively dem&s discussion1 namely1 a week-day wor%ip4 ,! movem5t = %ort5$ s]vices1 s-call$1 has %>$ ! usual fate ( all ef=ts at bett]+ ! life ( ! ,*ur*1 9 be+ at ! outset ( its c\rse widely & s]i\sly misund]/ood4 ,! impression has gone abroad1 & to-day holds possession ( _m o!rwise well-in=m$ p1 t a l>ge & gr[+ p>ty 9 ! ,episcopal ,*ur* has op5ly decl>$ itself we>i$ out ) ov]mu* pray] & praise4 ,7 su* inde$ ! fact1 ! sc&al w\ld be grave2 b ! real tru? ab\t ! matt] is t ! promot]s ( %ort5$ s]vices1 in/ead ( seek+ to dim9i%1 are really eag] to see multipli$ ! am\nt ( wor%ip r5d]$ 9 our *ur*es4 ,%ort5$ s]vices is a phrase ( ,engli%1 n ,am]ican orig91 & has won its way "h by d9t ( euphony r ?an ( fitness4 ,readju/$ s]vices1 ?\gh a m clumsy1 w\ld be a less misdirect+ t]m4 ,9 ! matt] ( ,sunday wor%ip1 ! lib]ty n[ g5]ally conc$$ ( us+ sep>ately ! ,morn+ ,pray]1 ! ,litany1 & ! ,holy ,communion is all t ne$ be ask$4 ,:e!r ^! s]vices1 or at lea/ two ( !m1 d n 9 !mselves admit ( a c]ta9 measure ( improvem5t is a po9t t has already be5 consid]$1 b !re c]ta9ly is no ne$ ( %ort5+ !m1 :atev] else x may be ?\ght well to d4 ,:5 :at a ,bo/on wor?y once t]m$ a holy alacrity is obs]v$1 on ! "p ( bo? m9i/] & s+]s1 ev5 ! aggregat$ s]vices ( ,morn+ ,pray]1 ,litany1 & ,ante-,communion1 toge!r ) a s]mon five-&-tw5ty m9utes long1 c easily be br\ght )9 ! compass ( an h\r & a half--a measure ( "t n unreasonably l>ge to be giv5 to ! pr9cipal occasion ( wor%ip on ! ,"l's ,day4 ,z = ! ,ev5+ ,pray]--!re c]ta9ty ought to be no call = ! %ort5+ ( t on ,sundays2 = x w\ld be sc>cely dec5t or prop] to devote to su* a s]vice any?+ less ?an ! half h\r ! exi/+ (fice dem&s4 ,:at ! advocates ( %ort5$ s]vices really desire to see fur!r$ is an increase 9 ! frequ5cy ( opportunities = wor%ip dur+ ! week1 _! conviction be+ t if ! ,*ur* 7 to au?orize brief s]vices = morn+ & ev5+ use1 su* z w\ld n occupy mu* m "t ?an family pray]s ord9>ily d1 ! att5dance might be secur$ ( _m :o1 at pres5t1 put aside ! :ole "q ( go+ to *ur* on week-days z impracticable4 ,suppos+ x c\ld be prov$ t su* a provision w\ld "w to ! disc\ragem5t ( family pray]1 x w\ld pla9ly be wrong to advocate x2 no prie/hood is m sacr$ ?an t :i* comes ) fa!rhood4 ,b we mu/ face ! fact t 9 our mod]n ,am]ican life family pray]1 l sundry o!r :olesome habits1 has fall5 l>gely into disuse4 ,if ! ,*ur* c1 9 any measure1 supplem5t ! defici5cies ( ! h\sehold1 & help to supply to individuals a bless+ !y w\ld gladly enjoy at _! own homes1 if !y might1 x is h] pla9 duty to d s4 ,moreov]1 _m a m9i/] :o s+le-h&$ _c n[ prud5tly und]take a daily s]vice1 z t is commonly und]/ood1 w\ld ackn[l$ge himself equal to ! less ext5d$ requirem5t4 ,n a few c>eful & fri5dly obs]v]s ( ! practical work+ ( ,anglican religion h be5 reluctantly l$ to consid] ! daily s]vice1 z an in/itution1 only meagrely successful4 ,look+ at ! matt] hi/orically we f9d no reason to wond] at su* a conclusion4 ,our exi/+ usage 7or m correctly1 p]haps1 non-us]7 dates f ! ,re=mation p]iod4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur* & nation ( t day _h gr[n up famili> ) ! spectacle ( a v l>ge body ( cl]ics1 secul> & regul>1 ^: daily occupation may be said to h be5 ! pursuit ( religion4#bc ,! religion pursu$ consi/$ *iefly 9 ! say+ ( pray]s1 & v ?or\ghly1 s f> at lea/ z ! consumption ( "t 0 conc]n$1 7 ! pray]s said4 ,:at m natural ?an t1 "u su* circum/ances1 & ) su* associations1 ! compil]s ( a common ,pray] ,book = ! p %\ld h fail$ to see any good reason = discrim9at+ betwe5 ! am\nt ( s]vice prop] to ! ,"l's ,day & ! am\nt t might be reasonably expect$ on o!r days8 ,!oretically !y 7 "r1 all "t belongs to ,god & he is z appropriately wor%ipp$ on ,tuesdays & ,?ursdays z on ,sundays4 ,& yet z a result ( _! mak+ no su* discrim9ation1 we h ! daily s]vice on our h&s--a comp>ative1 ev5 if n an utt] failure4 ,we may lam5t ! fact1 b a fact x is1 t ,9 spite ( all its improv$ appliances = secur+ leisure1 ! _w is busi] ?an ev] x 02 & !re w always be ^? :o w insi/ t ! comm& to labor on six days is z imp]ative z ! injunction to re/ ^u ! sev5?4 ,z a consequ5ce ( all ?is accel]at$ bus9ess1 & ( ! dim9ution 9 ! numb] ( p]sons (ficially set ap>t = pray]1 ! unabridg$ s]vice ( ! ,*ur* fails to comm& a week-day att5dance4 ,we h no cl]ks n[adays to fill ! *oir4 ,! only cl]ks kn[n to mod]n times are busy at _! desks4 ,x may be urg$ 9 reply to ?is t ! practical work+ ( ! daily s]vice ought to be kept a second>y consid]ation1 & t its ma9 purpose is symbolical1 or repres5tative2 ! prie/ kneel+ 9 8 place1 day by day1 z a witness t ! p1 ?\gh unable p]sonally to be pres5t1 d1 9 he>t & m9d1 approve ( a daily morn+ & ev5+ sacrifice ( pray]4 ,?is conception ( ! daily s]vice z a vic>i\s ?+ has a c]ta9 my/ical beauty ab\t x1 b if x is to be adopt$ z ! ,*ur*'s own let u1 at lea/1 cle> ourselves ( inconsi/5cy by /rik+ out ! ^w common f be=e ! ^w pray] 9 *>act]iz+ our book4 ,:at is really ne$$ = daily use 9 our p>i%es is a %ort =m ( wor%ip specially fram$ = ! purpose4 ,if !y c\ld be employ$ )\t (f5ce to ! ,prote/ant e> 7& !y are good ,engli% ,re=mation words7 ,week-,day ,mat9s & ,week-,day ,ev5song w\ld n be ill *os5 names = su* s]vices4 ,! framework ( ^! ,less] ,ord]s = ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]1 z !y might also be call$1 7 ! o!r titles f\nd obnoxi\s1 ought to be modell$ ^u ! l9es ( ! exi/+ daily (fices1 ?\gh ) a c>eful avoidance ( id5tity 9 cont5ts4 ,!re %\ld be1 = in/ance1 z unv>y+ elem5ts1 ! read+ ( ! lessons = ! day1 ! use ( ! collect = ! day1 & ! say+ or s++ ( ! psalms = ! day4 ,ano!r con/ant w\ld be ! ,"l's ,pray]2 b aside f ^! ! ,less] ,ord] ne$ h no?+ 9 common ) ! ,ord] z we h x n[4 ,!re might be1 = example1 aft] ! mann] ( ! old s]vice-books1 an invitatory op5+ ) v]sicles & responses1 or if ! pres5t mode ( op5+ by s5t5ces 7 pref]r$1 specially *os5 s5t5ces1 diff]5t f ^? ) :i* ! ,sunday wor%ip has made u famili>1 c\ld be employ$4 ,moreov]1 ! an!ms or canticles & ! pray]s1 ) ! exception ( ! two j m5tion$1 ought also to be di/9ctive1 &1 9 ! te*nical s5se ( ! ^w1 prop] to ! week-day use4 ,aga91 x w\ld s]ve v p[]fully & appropriately to emphasize ! pivot po9ts 9 ! ritual ye> if ?is same pr9ciple 7 to be appli$ to sa9ts' days1 & we 7 to h special ,holyday ,mat9s & ,holy-day ,ev5song1 !re /ill be+ requir$1 on ! great] fe/ivals & fa/s1 ! normal ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray] prop] to ! ,"l's ,day4#bd ,! argum5t 9 favor ( ?us specializ+ ! s]vices = week-days & holydays1 9 pref]5ce to foll[+ ! only me?od h]et(ore ?\ght possible1 namely1 t ( %ort5+ ! ,"l's ,day ,ord]1 re/s on two gr\nds4 ,9 ! fir/ place p]missions to skip & omit are ( !mselves objectionable 9 a book ( devotions4 ,!y h an uncomely look4 ,our ,am]ican ,common ,pray] boa/s too _m disfigurem5ts ( ?is sort already4 ,su* a rubric z ,! m9i/] may1 at 8 discretion1 omit all t foll[s to1 etc4 1 puts "o 9 m9d ( ! f+]-po/ po9t+ out a %ort cut to we>y travell]s4 ,x is inopportune ?us to h9t at exhau/ion z ! probable concomitant ( wor%ip4 ,t ea* =m %\ld h an integrity ( its own1 %\ld z a sep>ate :ole be ei!r said complete or left unsaid1 is bett] liturgical philosophy ?an any %ort5$ s]vices act c %[4 ,9 ! second place1 a c]ta9 am\nt ( v>iety w\ld be secur$ by ! propos$ me?od :i* "u ! exi/+ sy/em we miss4 ,!re is1 ( c\rse1 su* a dang] z t ( provid+ too mu* liturgical v>iety4 ,amateur mak]s ( ,pray] ,books almo/ inv>iably fall into ?is sl\gh4 ,hymn-books1 z is well kn[n1 (t5 de/roy _! own usefulness by includ+ too _m hymns2 & ,pray] ,books may d ! same by hav+ too _m pray]s4#be ,to transgress 9 ! compil+ ( =mul>ies ! l9e ( av]age memory1 to provide m mat]ial ?an ! m9d ( an habitual wor%ipp] is likely to assimilate1 is to misread human nature4 ,b "h1 z else:]e1 !re is a j mean4 ,cranm] & 8 colleagues 9 ! "w ( revision jump$ at "o b\nd f a s*eme :i* provid$ a di/9ctive set ( s]vices = e day 9 ! ye> to a s*eme t assign$ "o /]eotyp$ =m to all days4 ,n[ no?+ c\ld be m unwise ?an any attempt to re/ore ! me?ods ( ! ,brevi>y1 ) its complicat$ & artificial =ms ( devotion2 b s f> to imitate ! ,brevi>y z to provide )9 limits = a recognition ( man's innate love ( *ange w\ld be wisdom4 ,by hav+ a di/9ctive s]vice = week-days1 & a di/9ctive s]vice = holydays1 ,ave might add j t little increm5t to ! ,*ur*'s p[] ( traction t 9 _m in/ances w\ld avail to *ange ,i _c g to *ur* ?is morn+ into ,i _c /ay away4 ,x w be urg$ z a c\nt]-argum5t to ^! consid]ations t ! ?+ is impossible1 t su* a measure ( enri*m5t is entirely 9 excess ( any?+ ! ,*ur* has express$ a wi% to h1 & t = review]s to propose a plan s sweep+ w\ld be suicide4 ,d\btless ?is might be a suffici5t answ] to anybody :o imag9$ t by a b>e majority vote ( two successive ,g5]al ,conv5tions new =mul>ies ( daily wor%ip c\ld be =c$ ^u ! ,*ur*4 ,b suppose su* =mul>ies 7 to be made optional2 suppose !re 7 to be giv5 to p>i%es ! *oice betwe5 ^! ?ree ?+s1 viz43 7a7 ! normal ,morn+ ,pray]2 7b7 a %ort5$ =m ( ! normal ,morn+ ,pray]2 & 7c7 su* a special ord] z has be5 sket*$--:at !n8 ,w\ld ! ,*ur*'s lib]ty be impair$6 ,on ! contr>y1 w\ld n ! bord]s ( t lib]ty h be5 mo/ wisely & safely wid5$ by ! /eady h& ( law8 ,?is is p]haps ! "r po9t at :i* to call att5tion to ! pres5t /ate ( ! %ort5$ s]vices controv]sy1 = we>isome z ! /ory has become by frequ5t repetition1 ! nexus betwe5 x & ! subject 9 h& is too important to be left out ( sight4 ,9 ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( #ahgg1 :]e ! topic "u its ,am]ican aspects 0 = ! fir/ "t ?or\ghly discuss$1 ! two ,h\ses came to a deadlock4 ,! deputies on ! "o h&1 almo/ to a man1 vot$ 9 favor ( giv+ ! desir$ relief by rubric1 ?us po/pon+ = ?ree ye>s' "t ! fruition ( _! wi%2 :ile ! bi%ops ) a unanimity und]/ood to h be5 equally /rik+ insi/$ t a simple canon1 su* z c\ld be pass$ at once1 w\ld suffice4 ,& s ! subject dropp$4 ,at ! late ,conv5tion ( #ahhj an eir5icon 0 discov]$4 ,! quick eye ( "o ( ! legal memb]s ( ! ,h\se ( ,deputies detect$ on ! f\r? page ( ! ,pray] ,book1 j opposite ! ,preface1 a loophole ( escape1 to wit1 ,! ,ratification ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,"h 0 ! v t]tium quid :]eby ! common wi% ( bo? p>ties to ! dispute might be effect$ )\t injury to ! s5sibilities ( ei!r4 ,! ,ratification c]ta9ly did n look l a canon2 nei!r c\ld anybody ) 8 eyes op5 call x a rubric--:y n am5d t1 & say no m ab\t x8 ,! sugge/ion prevail$1 & by a vote ( bo? ,h\ses1 ! foll[+ extraord9>y docum5t is h]eaft] to /& 7! next ,g5]al ,conv5tion cons5t+7 9 ! v =e-front ( ! ,pray] ,book3 ,,! ,,ratification ,,( ,,! ,,book ,,( ,,common ,,pray]4 ,by ! ,bi%ops1 ! ,cl]gy1 & ! ,laity ( ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur* 9 ,g5]al ,conv5tion assembl$4 ,! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( ! ,*ur* hav+ h]et(ore1 to wit3 on ! sixte5? day ( ,octob] 9 ! ye> ,a4 ,d4 #aghi1 set =? a ,book ( ,common ,pray] & ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,sacram5ts & o!r ,rites & ,c]emonies ( ! ,*ur*1 & !reby e/abli%$ ! said book1 & decl>$ x to be ! ,liturgy ( said ,*ur*1 & requir$ t x be receiv$ z su* by all ! memb]s ( ! same & be 9 use f & aft] ! fir/ day ( ,octob] 9 ! ye> ( our ,"l #agij2 ! same book is h]eby ratifi$ & confirm$1 & ord]$ to be ! use ( ?is ,*ur* f ?is "t =?4 ,b note1 h[ev]1 t on days o!r ?an ,sundays1 ,*ri/mas-day1 ! ,epiphany1 ,a%-,w$nesday1 ,good ,friday1 & ,asc5sion ,day1 x %all suffice if ! ,m9i/] beg9s ,morn+ or ,ev5+ ,pray] at ! ,g5]al ,confession or ! ,"l's ,pray] prec$$ by "o or m ( ! ,s5t5ces appo9t$ at ! beg9n+ ( ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]1 & end aft] ! ,collect = ,grace or ! ,collect = ,aid aga9/ ,p]ils1 ) #b ,cor4 xiii4 #ad1 us+ s mu* ( ! ,lessons appo9t$ = ! day & s mu* ( ! ,psalt] z he %all judge to be = edification4 ,& note also t on any day :5 ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray] %all h be5 duly said or are to be said1 & on days o!r ?an ^? fir/ a=em5tion$1 x %all suffice1 :5 ne$ may require1 if a s]mon or lecture be prec$$ by at lea/ ! ,"l's ,pray] & "o or m ,collects f\nd 9 ?is book1 provid$ t no pray]s n set =? 9 said book1 or o!rwise au?oriz$ by ?is ,*ur*1 %all be us$ be=e or aft] su* s]mon or lecture4#bf ,& note fur!r also t on any day ! ,morn+ ,pray]1 ! ,litany1 or ! ,ord] = ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp] may be us$ z a sep>ate & indep5d5t s]vice1 provid$ t no "o ( ^! s]vices %all be disus$ habitually4 ,x may seem h>% to *>act]ize ?is act z ! mutilation ( a monum5t2 b really x does seem to be little else4 ,! old ,ratification ( #aghi is an hi/oric l&m>k2 x is ! sign-manual ( ! ,*ur* ( ,:ite's & ,seabury's day1 & ought nev] to be di/urb$ or tamp]$ ) :ile ! ,pray] ,book /&s4 ,! ye> #ahhi might v prop]ly see a supplem5tal ,ratification writt5 "u x2 & te/ify+ to ! fact ( ,revision2 b to write into t v5]able text special directions z to :at may be done on days o!r ?an ,a%-,w$nesday1 & :at mu/ n be done )\t #b ,cor4 xiii4 #ad1 is v mu* z if ! ,city ,gov]nm5t ( ,cambridge %\ld cause to be cut ^u ! /one "u ! ,wa%+ton elm :i* n[ records ! fact t !re ! comm&] ( ! ,am]ican armies fir/ drew 8 sword1 div]s & sundry additional items ( in=mation1 su* z ! di/ance to ,wat]t[n1 ! %orte/ pa? across ! common1 etc41 etc4 ,:y ! ,conv5tion aft] hav+ entru/$ to a ,jo9t ,committee1 by a decisive vote1 ! task ( devis+ means = secur+ = ! ,pray] ,book increas$ flexibility ( use1 %\ld h ?\ght x necess>y subsequ5tly to take up ) ?is compromise ( a compromise 7= su* ! proposal to am5d ! ,ratification really is7 x is difficult to say4 ,p]haps x 0 ) ! det]m9ation to h1 at any rate1 some?+ to fall back ^u 9 case ! l>g] & m compreh5sive measure %\ld come to naught4 ,! rubric is confess$ly ! prop] place = directions z to h[ to use ! s]vices1 & b = ! v natural & def5sible objection on ! "p ( "s to t\*+ ! ,pray] ,book at all1 !re nev] w\ld h be5 any "q ab\t x4#bg ,?is objection hav+ be5 at la/ waiv$1 a /raight pa? is n[ op5 to ! end desir$1 & x ought to be foll[$ ev5 at ! co/ ( ?ree ye>s m ( delay4 ,return+ to ! g5]al subject1 & /ill foll[+ ! ord] ( ! ,table ( ,cont5ts1 we come to ,pray]s & ,?anksgiv+s ^u sev]al ,occasions4 ,"h x w\ld be well to note m intelligibly ?an is done by ! pres5t rubric ! prop] places = ! introduction ( ! ,pray]s & ! ,?anksgiv+s1 provid+ = ! use ( ! =m] be=e1 & ( ! latt] aft] ! ,g5]al ,?anksgiv+4 ,z to ! defici5cies 9 ?is dep>tm5t let ! late ,dr4 ,muhl5b]g speak4 ,! ,pray] ,book1 he says1 is n und]valu$ z to its treasures 9 ass]t+ its wants4 ,! latt] _c be d5i$4 ,witness ! meagre am\nt ( ,new ,te/am5t pray] & praise = ! r\nd ( fe/ivals & fa/s2 ! abs5ce ( any =ms suit$ to ! peculi> circum/ances ( our own ,*ur* & c\ntry & to ! times we live 92 or = our b5evol5t & educational in/itutions4 ,!re are no pray]s = ! increase ( ,m9i/]s1 = ,missions1 or ,mission>ies1 = ! ,*ri/ian tea*+ ( ! "y2 = sponsors on occasions ( ,baptism2 = p]sons sett+ out on long j\rneys by l&1 q z p]il\s z voyages by sea2 = ! sick desir+ ! pray]s ( ! ,*ur* :5 !re is no prospect ( or desire = recov]y2 = ! b]eav$ at fun]als1 & _m o!r occasions = :i* !re might z well be provision z = ^? few = :i* we already h ! occasional pray]s4#bh ,aft] ! ,pray]s & ,?anksgiv+s come ,! ,collects1 ,epi/les1 & ,gospels 4 ,"h aga9 !re is "s room = enri*m5t4 ,di/9ctive collects = ! fir/ f\r days ( ,holy ,week1 = ,monday & ,tuesday 9 ,ea/] ,week1 & = ,monday & ,tuesday 9 ,:itsun ,week1 w\ld add v mat]ially to our liturgical weal?1 :ile !re w\ld seem to be no reason :atev] :y !y %\ld n be _h4 ,x w\ld also s]ve to enhance ! symmetry ( ! ,*ri/ian ,ye> if ! old fea/ ( ! ,transfiguration#bi 7,augu/ #f7 7 to be re/or$ to its place among ! recogniz$ holy days ( ! ,*ur* & giv5 its prop] collect1 epi/le1 & gospel4 ,!re are "s liturgi/s :o desire ! re/oration ( ! introits ( ! ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 ,! introit 7s call$ f be+ ! psalm sung :5 ! prie/ goes )9 ! alt>-rails7 has be5 9 mod]n usage replac$ by a metrical hymn4 ,a suffici5t reason = n pr9t+ ! introit = ea* day 9 full1 j be=e ! collect1 z 0 ! mode 9 ,edw>d's ,book1 is t to d s w\ld involve a co/ly sacrifice ( room4 ,a compromise c\rse w\ld be to ins]t betwe5 ! title ( ea* ,sunday or holyday & ! collect prop] to x1 a simple num]ical ref]5ce /at+ :]eab\ts 9 ! ,psalt] ! introit = ! day is to be f\nd1 & add+ p]haps ! ,lat9 cat*words4 ,any attempt to make ! use ( ! introit obligatory 9 our times w\ld meet ) des]v$ failure2 ! metrical hymn has ga9$ too firm a hold ^u ! affections ( ! ,*ur* at l>ge ev] to be will+ly surr5d]$4 ,com+1 next1 to ! ord]s = ! adm9i/ration ( ! two sacram5ts1 we f9d ourselves on delicate gr\nd1 :]e s]i\s *ange ( any sort is out ( ! "q4 ,p]mission1 "u c]ta9 circum/ances1 /ill fur!r to abbreviate ! ,(fice ( ! ,communion ( ! ,sick might1 h[ev]1 be s\ght )\t giv+ reasonable cause ( al>m to any1 & g5]al cons5t might p]haps also be _h = a provision ) respect to ! ,exhortation1 ,de>ly belov$ 9 ! ,"l1 t 9 ,*ur*es :]e !re is frequ5t ,communion x %all suffice to read ! ,exhortation above writt5 once 9 a mon? on ! ,"l's ,day4#cj ,!re are ?ree liturgical features ( ! ,scotti% ,communion ,(fice :i* "s h ?\ght might be advantage\sly transf]r$ to our own s]vice4 ,!y are 7a7 ! ins]t+ aft] ,*ri/'s summ>y ( ! ,law a response1 ,"l1 h m]cy ^u u & write ^! ?y laws 9 our he>ts1 we besee* !e2 7b7 ! repeat+ by ! p1 aft] ! read+ ( ! ,gospel1 ( a =mula ( ?anks correspond+ to ! ,glory be to !e1 ,o ,"l1 t prec$es x2 & 7c7 ! say+ or s++ ( an ,(f]tory s5t5ce at ! pres5tation ( ! alms4 ,^u ^! sugge/$ enri*m5ts ! pres5t writ] (f]s no op9ion4 ,9 ! ,ord] ( ,confirmation a sub/itution = ! pres5t preface#ca ( a responsive op5+1 9 :i* ! bi%op %\ld *>ge ! m9i/] to pres5t none b su* z he has f\nd by p]sonal inquiry apt & meet = ! reception ( ! rite w\ld be a m>k$ improvem5t4 ,! rema9+ ,occasional ,(fices w\ld seem to dem& no *ange ei!r 9 /ructure or cont5ts1 al?\gh 9 "s1 p]haps 9 all ( !m1 additional rubrics w\ld be helpful to wor%ipp]s4 ,"s addition to ! numb] ( ,occasional ,(fices w\ld be a real ga94 ,we ne$1 = in/ance1 a %ort ,(fice = ! ,burial ( ,infants & ,"y ,*ildr52 a ,daybreak ,(fice = ,great ,fe/ivals2 an ,(fice = ,midday ,pray]2 an ,(fice ( ,pray] 9 behalf ( ,missions & ,mission>ies2 an ,(fice = ! ,sett+ ap>t ( a ,layman z a ,read]1 or z a ,mission>y2 a ,=m ( ,pray] at ! ,lay+ ( a ,corn]-/one2 & possibly "s o!rs4 ,x is evid5t t ^! new =mul>ies might give opportunity = ! introduction ( hi!rto unus$ collects1 an!ms1 & b5$ictions ( a sort t w\ld greatly enhance ! g5]al usefulness ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,?is completes ! survey ( ! field ( liturgical enri*m5t4 ,a full discussion ( ! alli$ topic1 flexibility ( use1 w\ld involve ! exam9ation 9 detail ( all ! rubrics ( ! ,pray] ,book1 & = ?is !re is no room4 ,x is en\gh to say t unless ! rubrics1 ! h+es & jo9ts ( a s]vice-book1 are kept well oil$1 mu* creak+ is a necess>y result4 ,!re are turn+-po9ts 9 our public wor%ip :]e congregations almo/ inv>iably betray an awkw>d emb>rassm5t1 simply because !re is no?+ to tell !m :e!r !y are expect$ to /& or to sit or to kneel4 ,x is easy to sne] at su* po9ts z trifles & to make sport ( ^? :o call att5tion to !m2 b if x is wor? our :ile to h ritual wor%ip at all x is also wor? our :ile to make ! directions z to h[ p are to behave adequate1 explicit1 pla94 ,a l(ty contempt = detail is n ! tok5 ( good adm9i/ration ei!r 9 ,*ur* or ,/ate4 ,to ! li/ ( defective rubrics add ^? t are confess$ly obsolete & su* z are palpably contradictory & we h a bill ( p>ticul>s t w\ld amply ju/ify a rubrical revision ( ! ,pray] ,book ev5 if no?+ m 7 to be attempt$4 ,!re is ano!r reason4 ,f> m rapidly ?an _m p imag9e1 we are drift+ away f ! position ( a ,*ur* t wor%ips by liturgy to t ( a ,*ur* wor%ipp+ by directory4 ,! multiplicity ( uses t vex$ ! ,anglican ,re=m]s is 9 our day multipli$ f\r-fold4 ,to ^? :o hone/ly consid] a directory a bett] ?+ ?an a liturgy ?is process ( relaxation is mo/ welcome1 b = o!rs :o hold t1 until ! b9d+ clauses ( a ,book ( ,common ,pray] h be5 =mally resc9d$1 !y ought to be obs]v$1 ! spectacle is ! rev]se ( edify+4 ,!y w\ld mu* pref] see+ ! *annels ( lib]ty op5$ at ! t\* ( law1 & ?is is "o ( _! *ief reasons = advocat+ revision4 ,two que/ions rema9 unt\*$1 bo? ( !m ( great practical importance4 ,c\ld ! ,pray] ,book be enri*$ to ! ext5t sugge/$ 9 ?is pap] )\t a s]i\s & mo/ undesirable increase 9 its bulk z a volume8 ,ev5 suppos+ ?is 7 possible1 is x at all likely t ! ,*ur* c\ld be p]suad$ to accept ! am5d$ book8 ,unless ! fir/ ( ^! two em95tly prop] que/ions c be met1 !re is1 or ought to be1 an end to all talk ab\t revision4 ,! advantage to a ,*ur* ( be+ able to keep all its au?oritative =mul>ies ( wor%ip )9 ! compass ( a s+le volume is ine/imable4 ,ev5 ! pres5t en=c$ sev]ance ( ! ,hymnal f ! ,pray] ,book is a mis=tune4#cb ,^? 7 good days :5 ,bible & ,pray] ,book 0 ! ,*ur*man's all suffici5t =mula s f> z volumes 7 conc]n$4 ,rome boa/s a mu* l>g] ritual v>iety ?an ours1 b %e secures x by multiply+ books4 ,! ,missal is 9 "o volume1 ! ,brevi>y 9 f\r1 ! ,pontifical1 ! ,ritual1 & ! ,c]emonial 9 "o ea*1 mak+ eight 9 all4#cc ,?is is an evil1 & "o f :i* we ,anglicans h _h a happy escape4 ,x 0 evid5tly ) a great groan ( relief t ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& %ook h]self free f ! :ole ho/ ( s]vice-books1 & e/abli%$ h] "o only volume4 ,x behooves u to be wat*ful h[ we take a s+le /ep t[>ds becom+ entangl$ 9 ! old me%es4#cd ,b ne$ ! enri*m5t ( ! ,pray] ,book--su* enri*m5t z has be5 describ$1 necess>ily involve an unwield9ess 9 ! volume1 or1 :at w\ld be /ill worse1 an ov]fl[ into a supplem5t8 ,c]ta9ly n2 = by judici\s managem5t e *ange advocat$ 9 ?is pap]1 & m besides1 might be accompli%$ )\t transgress+ by s mu* z a page or a p>agraph ! limits ( ! pres5t /&>d book4 ,all ! space ne$$ c\ld be secur$ by ! simple exp$i5t ( omitt+ matt] t has be5 f\nd by actual exp]i5ce to be sup]flu\s4 ,r$undancy & unnecess>y repetition are to ! discr$it ( a book t enjoys su* an unrivall$ reputation z ! ,common ,pray]4 ,!y are blemi%es ^u ! face ( its lit]>y p]fectness4 ,:o has n m>vell$ at ! /range duplication ( ! ,litany & ! ,(fice ( ! ,holy ,communion 9 ! ,ord9al1 :5 ! special petitions prop] to ^? s]vices :5 us$ 9 t connection might easily h be5 pr9t$ by !mselves ) a direction t !y be ins]t$ 9 ! appo9t$ place8 ,s*ol>s1 ( c\rse1 "k p]fectly well h[ ?is came ab\t4 ,! ,ord9al does n belong to ! ,pray] ,book prop]1 b has a sep>ate id5tity ( its own4 ,:5 pr9t$ z a book by itself x is all v well t x %\ld include ! ,litany & ! ,holy ,communion 9 full1 b :y all[ ^! sup]flu\s pages to cr[d out o!rs t are really ne$$8#ce ,x has already be5 expla9$ h[ ! room n[ occupi$ by ! ,selections might be economiz$1 & by ! same simple device ! space engross$ by div]s psalms "h & !re 9 ! ,occasional ,(fices1 e4 g41 ,psalm li 9 ! ,visitation ( ,prison]s1 & ,psalm cxxx 9 ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick c\ld be made available = o!r use4 ,aga91 :y cont9ue to devote a qu>t] ( a page ( preci\s space to ! ,pray] = imprison$ debtors1 see+ t n[1 = a long "t pa/1 !re has be5 no su* ?+ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates z imprisonm5t = debt8 ,by avail+ ourselves ( only a portion ( ^! possible me?ods ( g>n]+ space1 all t is desir$ might be accompli%$1 )\t mak+ ! ,pray] ,book bulki] by a s+le leaf ?an x is to-day4 ,b w\ld a ,pray] ,book ?us enri*$ be accept$ by ! ,*ur* at l>ge8 ,is !re any reason to ?9k t ! in]tia :i* inh]es 9 all l>ge bodies1 & to a s+ul>ly m>k$ degree 9 our own ,communion1 c\ld be ov]come8 ,! ,g5]al ,conv5tion c give an approximate answ] to ^! que/ions2 x _c settle !m decisively1 = x is a body :i* mirrors only to a c]ta9 ext5t ! real m9d & temp] ( ! con/itu5cies repres5t$ 9 x4 ,"o ?+ is c]ta91 t only by all[+ fulle/ possible play to ! pr9ciple ( local option c\ld any :olly new piece ( "w on ! "p ( revisioni/s1 h[ev] excell5t x might be 9 itself consid]$1 f9d acceptance4 ,to all[ features introduc$ into ! body ( an exi/+ s]vice to be acc\nt$ optional1 w\ld inde$ be impossible1 )\t g5d]+ ! v wilde/ confusion4 ,^u su* po9ts ! ,*ur* w\ld h to decide outright1 = or aga9/1 & /& by h] decisions4 ,b z respects e additional & novel ,(fice propos$1 ! greate/ c>e ought to be tak5 to h ! indef9ite ,an r ?an ! def9ite ,! prefix$ to x4 ,be=e su* new uses are made b9d+ on all1 !y mu/ h met & endur$ ! te/ ( ?or\gh trial by "s4 ,?is is only fair4 ,b !re is a limit1 x mu/ be rememb]$1 9 ! ,*ur*'s case to ! b9d+ p[] ( prec$5t & prescription4 ,! social ord] *anges1 & ( ^! tides t ebb & fl[ x is our b\nd5 duty to take note4 ,_h m]e av]sion to *ange1 dogg$ unwill+ness to v5ture an exp]im5t always c>ri$ ! day1 in/ead ( hav+ ! ,pray] ,book z x is1 we %\ld /ill be dre>ily debat+ ! rival m]its ( ,h]e=d & ,s>um4 ,! great "q to be settl$ is1 ,does an em]g5cy exi/ s]i\s en\gh to w>rant an attempt on our "p to make bett] :at we "k already to be good8 ,is ! ,republic expect+ ( u1 & reasonably expect+ ( u1 great] ?+s ?an ) our pres5t equipm5t we are q able to accompli%8 ,!re are eyes t ?9k !y see a great future be=e ?is ,*ur*--are !y "r1 or is x only mirage8 ,at any rate ours is no return trip--we are outw>d b\nd4 ,! %ip is cutt+ new & untri$ wat]s ) h] keel at e mom5t4 ,!re is no occasion to "q ! suffici5cy ( ei!r compass or helm1 b 9 c]ta9 matt]s ( a practical sort !re is a dem& ^u u to use judgm5t1 we are b\nd to give a place 9 our seaman%ip to pres5t common-s5se z well z to respect = anci5t usage1 & along ) x all to feel "s confid5ce t if ! %ip is :at we ?9k h] to be1 ! w9ds ( ,god may be tru/$ to br+ h] safely into port4 ,,! ,,book ,,annex$3 ,,its ,,critics ,,& ,,its ,,prospects4 ,,! ,,book ,,annex$3 ,,its ,,critics ,,& ,,its ,,prospects4#cf ,fir/1 la/1 & always ?is is to be said ) respect to ! revision ( ! ,am]ican ,common ,pray]1 t unless we c accompli% x ) he>ty good feel+ ! attempt at improvem5t ought to be ab&on$ altoge!r4 ,! day has gone by :5 new =mul>ies ( wor%ip c\ld be impos$ on an unwill+ ,*ur* by edict1 & al?\gh "u our c>efully gu>d$ sy/em ( ecclesia/ical legislation !re is little dang] ( ei!r ha/e or unfairness1 we mu/ be> x well 9 m9d t some?+ m ?an a con/itutional majority ( bo? h\ses is ne$ful if we w\ld see liturgical revision cr[n$ ) real success4 ,( c\rse1 absolute unanimity is n to be expect$4 ,e improvem5t t ! _w has se5 0 greet$ at its bir? by a *orus ( select voices s\nd+ ! famili> an!m1 ,! old is bett]2 & ! g5]ation ( ^?1 :o1 9 ! /urdy phrase ( ,k+ ,james's revis]s1 give lik+ unto no?+ b :at is fram$ by !mselves1 & hamm]$ on _! anvil1 w be always ) u4 ,b sub/antial unanimity may exi/1 ev5 :5 absolute unanimity is impossible1 & if any?+ l z g5]al a cons5t c be secur$ = revision 9 #ahhf z 0 giv5 to x 9 #ahhc1 ! fri5ds ( ! movem5t w h good reason to be satisfi$4 ,t !re has be51 s9ce ! publication ( ,! ,book ,annex$ z ,modifi$1 a c]ta9 measure ( reaction aga9/ ! _s ( *ange mu/ be evid5t to all :o wat* c>efully ! pulse ( public op9ion 9 ! ,*ur*4 ,:e!r ?is reaction be z s]i\s z "s imag9e1 :e!r x h good reasons to allege1 & :e!r x be n already giv+ tok5s ( sp5t =ce1 are po9ts :i* 9 ! pres5t pap] w be t\*$ only incid5tally1 = ! writ]'s purpose is r ir5ic ?an polemical1 & he is m conc]n$ to remove misappreh5sions & allay fe>s ?an to seek ! fad+ leaf ( a controv]sial victory4 ,,limitations4 ,no e/imate ( ! m]its & dem]its ( ,! ,book ,annex$ c be a j "o t leaves out ( acc\nt ! limitations "u :i* ! fram]s ( x did _! "w4 ,^! limitations 7 n unreasonable ones4 ,x 0 "r & prop] t !y %\ld be impos$4 ,!re is no good gr\nd = a belief t ! "t w ev] come :5 a blank *eque1 to borr[ ,mr4 ,gos*5's m]cantile figure1 w be giv5 to any company ( liturgical revis]s to fill out z !y may see fit4 ,b ! m\ld]s ( =ms1 9 :atev] dep>tm5t ( pla/ic art _! specialty lies1 :5 *all5g$ to %[ cause :y _! "w is defici5t 9 symmetry or complet5ess1 h an und\bt$ "r to plead 9 reply ! "* ( ! conditions "u :i* !y labor$4 ,! pres5t in/ance (f]s no exception to ! g5]al rule4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 a di/9ct pl$ge 0 giv5 9 ! ,h\se ( ,deputies1 9 #ahhj1 be=e cons5t to ! appo9tm5t ( ! ,jo9t ,committee 0 secur$1 t 9 case su* p]mission to laun* a movem5t 9 favor ( revision z 0 ask$ = 7 to be grant$1 no attempt w\ld be made s]i\sly to *ange ! ,liturgy prop]1 namely1 ! ,(fice ( ! ,holy ,communion4 ,! "q 0 di/9ctly ask$ by a cl]ical deputy f ! diocese ( ,m>yl&1#cg ,d y desire to modify ! ,(fice ( ! ,holy ,communion8 & x 0 z di/9ctly answ]$ by ! mov] ( ! resolution "u :i* ! ,jo9t ,committee 0 f9ally appo9t$1 ,no1 we d n4 ,x is true t su* a pl$ge1 made by a s+le memb] ( "o ,h\se1 c\ld only measurably control ! action ( a ,jo9t ,committee 9 :i* bo? ,h\ses 7 to be repres5t$2 b x is equally pla9 t ! mak] ( ! pl$ge 0 9 honor b\nd to d all 9 8 p[] to secure ! obs]vance ( its t]ms4 ,let ?is hi/orical fact be not$ by ^? :o are dispos$ to compla9 t ! ,jo9t ,committee did n pull to pieces & entirely re>range ! ,anglo-,scoto-,am]ican ,(fice1 :i* n[ = a long "t1 & until q rec5tly1 we h be5 taught to e/eem ! ne>e/ possible approa* to liturgical p]fection4 ,"u ?is same head ( limitations mu/ be set d[n ! foll[+ resolutions pass$ by ! ,jo9t ,committee itself1 at its fir/ regul> meet+3 ,resolv$1 ,t ?is ,committee ass]ts1 at ! outset1 its conviction t no alt]ation %\ld be made t\*+ ei!r /atem5ts or /&>ds ( doctr9e 9 ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,resolv$1 ,t ?is ,committee1 9 all its sugge/ions & acts1 be guid$ by ^? pr9ciples ( liturgical con/ruction & ritual use :i* h guid$ ! compilation & am5dm5ts ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 & h made x :at x is4 ,x 0 manife/ly impossible1 "u resolutions l ^!1 to dep>t v widely f e/abli%$ prec$5t1 or 9 any s]i\s measure to di/urb ! f\ndations ( ?+s4 ,! fir/ ( !m %ut out :olly ! consid]ation ( su* que/ions z ! re9/atem5t ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$ or ! proposal to make optional ! use ( ! ^w reg5]ate 9 ! ,baptismal ,(fices2 :ile ! o!r =bade ! introduction ( su* s5tim5tal & grotesque conceits z ,an ,(fice = ! ,bless+ ( ,c&les1 ,an ,(fice = ! ,b5$iction ( a ,lifeboat1 & ,an ,(fice = ! ,reconciliation ( a ,laps$ ,cl]ic4#ch ,/ill ano!r v s]i\s limitation1 & "o especially unfri5dly to t p]fectness ( cont\r :i* we naturally look to see 9 a liturgical =mul>y1 grew out ( ! t5d] solicitude ( ! ,committee = :at may be call$ ! ve/$ rights ( congregations4 ,!re 0 a /rong reluctance to ! cutt+ away ev5 ( :at might seem to be dead wood1 le/ !re %\ld ensue1 or be ?\ght to ensue1 ! loss ( some?+ really valuable4 ,x 0 only z ! result ( mu* pa9/ak+ ef=t1 & only at "s sacrifice ( lit]>y fa/idi\sness1 t ! ,committee 0 enabl$ to report a book ( :i* x c\ld be said t1 :ile x add$ mu* ( possible enri*m5t1 x took away almo/ no?+ t _h be5 9 actual possession4#ci ,!re c\ld be no bett] illu/ration ( ?is po9t ?an is af=d$ by c]ta9 ( ! alt]ations propos$ to be made 9 ! ,ord] = ,ev5+ ,pray]4 ,! ,committee felt assur$ t ^u no po9t 0 ! judgm5t ( ! ,*ur* likely to be m unanim\s ?an 9 approv+ ! re/oration to _! "t-honor$ home 9 ! ,ev5+ ,(fice ( ,magnificat & ,nunc dimittis1 & yet s unwill+ 7 !y to displace ,bonum e/ confit]i & ,b5$ic anima mea f positions !y h only occupi$ s9ce #aghi t !y au?oriz$ ! unque/ionably clumsy exp$i5t ( pr9t+ ?ree responds to ea* ,lesson4 ,probably a l>ge majority ( ! ,committee w\ld h pref]r$ to drop ,bonum e/ confit]i & ,b5$ic anima mea altoge!r1 reta9+ ,cantate ,dom9o & ,deus mis] eatur z ! sole alt]nates to ! two ,gospel canticles1 z 9 ! ,engli% ,book1 b r ?an h a ?\s& voices cry out1 z x 0 believ$ !y w\ld cry out1 ,y h robb$ u1 ! device ( a second alt]nate 0 adopt$1 to ! sad defacem5t ( ! pr9t$ page4 ,9 may be *>g$ t1 9 ?us *oos+1 ! ,committee betray$ timidity1 & t a wise boldness w\ld h be5 ! bett] c\rse2 b if acc\nt be tak5 ( ! attitude consi/5tly ma9ta9$ by ,g5]al ,conv5tion t[>ds any proposition = ! *ange ( s mu* z a comma 9 ! ,pray] ,book1 dur+ a p]iod ( fifty ye>s prior to ! introduction ( ,! ,book ,annex$1 x w p]haps be conclud$ t = ! *>act]ization ( ! ,committee's policy timidity is sc>cely s prop] a ^w z caution4 ,,special ,,criticisms4 7a7 ,=eign4 ,z !re is reason to believe t op9ion at home has be5 v consid]ably affect$ by =eign criticism ( ,! ,book ,annex$1 x w be well at ?is po9t to give "s att5tion to :at has be5 said 9 ,engli% j\rnals 9 review ( ! "w ?us f> accompli%$4 ,! m notewor?y ( ! =eign criticisms are ^? conta9$ 9 ,! ,*ur* ,qu>t]ly ,review1 ,! ,*ur* ,times1 & ,! ,gu>dian4#dj ,! ,*ur* ,qu>t]ly review] op5s ) an expression ( deep regret at ! failure to take advantage ( ! opportunity = re9/at+ ! ,a?anasian ,cre$4 ,z already obs]v$1 no su* opportunity exi/$4 ,by =mal vote ! ,jo9t ,committee deb>r$ itself f any proce$+ ( ?is sort1 & ! ,conv5tion1 :i* sat 9 judgm5t on its "w1 0 manife/ly ( op9ion t 9 s act+ ! ,committee _h rightly int]pret$ its *>t]4 ,! review]1 :o is 9 full sympa?y ) ! movem5t = enri*m5t z su*1 goes on to recomm5d1 z a m excell5t way ?an t foll[$ 9 ,! ,book ,annex$1 ! compilation ( ,an ,app5dix to ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] to conta9 ! mu* ne$$ ,additional ,s]vices = bo? ,sunday & o!r use 9 *ur*es1 9 mission *apels1 & 9 religi\s communities1 z well z a full supply ( ,occasional ,pray]s & ,?anksgiv+s = objects & purposes1 mission>y & o!rwise1 :i* are z yet entirely unrepres5t$ 9 our ,(fices4 ,!re are obvi\s reasons :y ?is device %\ld comm5d itself to an ,engli% ,*ur*man1 = x is unlikely t any?+ bett] ?an ?is1 or1 inde$1 any?+ "o half s satisfactory1 c\ld be secur$ by ,act ( ,p>liam5t4 ,= some?+ v mu* bett] ?an ?is1 h[ev]1 a self-gov]n$ ,*ur*1 l our own1 has a "r to look1 &1 9 all probability1 w cont9ue to look until ! ?+ is f\nd4 ,an ,app5dix to a manual ( wor%ip1 :e!r ! manual be ,pray] ,book or ,hymnal1#da is & _c b be1 f ! v nature ( ?+s1 a blemi% to ! eye1 an emb>rassm5t to ! h&1 & a vexation to ! _s4 ,su* add5da c>ry on _! face ! sugge/ion t !y are make%ifts1 po/scripts1 aft]-?\ghts2 & 9 _! lack ( dignity1 z well z ( conv5i5ce1 pron\nce _! own condemnation4 ,moreov]1 9 our p>ticul> case1 no ,app5dix1 ,prym]1 or ,au?oriz$ ,vade-mecum c\ld accompli% ! ends t are mo/ ( all desir$4 ,fancy putt+ ! ,magnificat1 ! ,nunc dimittis1 ! ,v]sicles t foll[ ! ,cre$1 & ! ,light5 our d>kness into an ,app5dix4 ,x w\ld be ! defeat ( our ma9 object4 ,!n1 too1 ?is is to be rememb]$1 t 9 ord] to secure a fully au?oriz$ ,app5dix1 we1 9 ?is c\ntry1 %\ld be oblig$ to foll[ precisely ! same legal process we foll[ 9 alt]+ ! ,pray] ,book4 ,if an ,occasional ,(fice _c pass ! ordeal ( ! criticism ( two successive ,conv5tions1 x ought n to be set =? at all2 if x c & does /& t te/1 !n x ought to be ins]t$ 9 ! ,pray] ,book 9 ! p>ticul> place :]e x mo/ appropriately belongs & may mo/ readily be f\nd4 ,moreov]1 x %\ld be rememb]$ t "o1 & by no means ! lea/ effici5t1 ( ! causes t br\ght ! ,common ,pray] into exi/5ce 9 ! sixte5? c5tury 0 disgu/ at ! multiplication ( s]vice-books4 ,we ,am]ican ,*ur*m5 h two already2 let u bew>e ( add+ a ?ird4 ,! critic ( ,! ,qu>t]ly 0 probably unacqua9t$ ) ! fact t 9 ! ,am]ican ,episcopal ,*ur* ! exp]im5tal sett+ =? ( ,(fices = optional & discretional use is n possible "u ! t]ms ( ! ,con/itution4 ,we ei!r mu/ adopt outright & = p]man5t use1 or else p]emptorily reject :atev] is urg$ ^u u 9 ! "n ( liturgical improvem5t4 ,ent]+ next ^u a detail$ criticism ( ! cont5ts ( ,! ,book ,annex$ ! writ] proce$s to (f] a numb] ( sugge/ions1 "s ( !m ( great value4 ,he pleads e>ne/ly & ) real =ce = ! re/oration ( ! ,"l's ,pray] to its place ( honor betwe5 ! ,cre$ & ! ,preces1 %[+1 9 a passage ( s+ul> beauty1 h[ ! :ole daily (fice may be said to h gr[n out (1 or radiat$ f1 or be5 cry/alliz$ r\nd ! c5tral ,pat] no/] ev5 z f ! ,words ( ,in/itution has gr[n ! ,*ri/ian ,liturgy4 ,! critic has only praise = ! am5dm5ts 9 ! ,(fice = ,?anksgiv+ ,day2 approves ! selection ( ,prop] ,s5t5ces = ! op5+ ( ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]2 av]s1 c]ta9ly ) tru?1 t ! ,(fice ( ! ,beatitudes might be improv$2 welcomes ! v full rep]tory ( special pray]s2 ?9ks t ! ,%ort ,(fice ( ,pray] = ,sundry ,occasions c]ta9ly supplies a want2 rejoices 9 ! recognition ( ! ,fea/ ( ! ,transfiguration2 & closes :at is by f> ! mo/ consid]able1 &1 bo? z respects praise & blame1 ! mo/ valuable ( all ! reviews t h be5 made ( ,! ,book ,annex$ :e!r at home or abroad1 ) ^! words3 ,on ! :ole1 we v he>tily congratulate our ,transatlantic bro!rs on ! labors ( _! ,jo9t ,committee4 ,we hope _! recomm5dations may be adopt$1 & m 9 ! same direction2 & t ! two or ?ree s]i\s blemi%es :i* we h felt con/ra9$ to po9t out & to lam5t may be remov$ f ! book 9 ! =m f9ally adopt$4 ,& fur!r1 we v e>ne/ly tru/ t ?is "w1 :i* has be5 v evid5tly s c>efully & consci5ti\sly done1 may spe$ily1 by way ( example & prec$5t1 be> fruit 9 a l process ( enri*m5t among ourselves4 ,comm5d+ ^! la/ words to ! consid]ation ( ^? :o take al>m at ! sugge/ion ( t\*+ ! ,pray] ,book le/ we may hurt ! susceptibilities ( our k9 beyond sea1 & unduly anticipate t jo9t action ( bo? ,*ur*es1 :i*1 at lea/ until dise/abli%m5t comes1 mu/ always rema9 a %e] impossibility1 we pass to a consid]ation ( ! six articles contribut$ to ! ,*ur* ,times 9 ,july & ,augu/ la/1 "u ! title1 ,! ,revis$ ,am]ican ,pray] ,book4 ,"h we come ^u a writ] :o1 if n always edify+1 has ! und\bt$ m]it ( be+ nev] dull4 ,9 fact1 s delici\sly are logical inconsequ5ce & accid5tal humor m+l$ ?r\gh\t 8 fifte5 columns ( discursive criticism t a suspicion arises z to ! writ]'s nationality4 ,x is d\btful :e!r anyone born on ! ,engli% side ( ! ,iri% ,sea c\ld possibly h sugge/$ ! e/abli%m5t ( a ,sa9t's ,day 9 honor ( ! late respect$ ,w>d5 ( ,rac9e ,college1 or s]i\sly h propos$ t ,messrs4 ,oliv] ,w5dell ,holmes1 ,russell ,l[ell1 ,h5ry ,james1 & ,w4 ,d4 ,h[ells be appo9t$ a jury ( lit]>y arbitram5t to sit 9 judgm5t on ! liturgical language ( ,! ,book ,annex$2 & ?is out ( respect to our prop] national pride4 ,d\btless x w\ld add p]ceptibly to ! amus$ s5se ( ! unfitness ( ?+s ) :i* ^! em95t lib]als mu/ h se5 !mselves ?us nam$1 if p]mission c\ld be giv5 to ! jury1 :5 empanell$1 to co-opt into its numb] ,mr4 ,samuel ,clem5s & ,mr4 ,dudley ,w>n]4#db ,! g5]al t5or ( ! writ] 9 ,! ,*ur* ,times may fairly be inf]r$ f ! foll[+ extract f ! fir/ article ( ! s]ies3 ,! judgm5t t mu/ be pron\nc$ on ! "w z a :ole is precisely t :i* has be5 pass$ on ! ,revis$ ,new ,te/am5t1 t !re are d\btless "s few *anges = ! bett]1 s obvi\s & s dem&$ be=eh& by all educat$ op9ion t to h neglect$ !m w\ld at once h /amp$ ! revis]s z blockheads & dunces2 b t ! set-(f 9 ! way ( petty & m$dlesome *anges = ! worse1 neglect ( really desirable improvem5ts1 bad ,engli%1 failure 9 ! v matt] ( pure s*ol>%ip j :]e x 0 lea/ to be expect$1 & g5]al dep>ture f ! t]ms ( ! ,commission assign$ to !m 7notably by _! introduction ( confusion in/ead ( flexibility into ! s]vices1 s t ! congregation c seldom "k :at is go+ to happ57 has s entirely outweigh$ ! m]its ( ! "w t x _c possibly be adopt$ by ! ,*ur*1 & mu/ be dismiss$ z a dismal fiasco1 to be dealt ) anew 9 "s m adequate fa%ion4 ,?is p>agraph is n reproduc$ = ! purpose ( discr$it+ ! writ] ( x z a judge ( ,engli% prose1 = !re are v>i\s passages 9 ! c\rse ( ! six articles t w\ld m readily l5d !mselves to su* a use4 ,! object 9 quot+ x is simply to put ! read] into possession1 9 a compact =m1 ( ! mo/ angry1 ev5 if n ! mo/ =midable1 ( ! v>i\s indictm5ts yet br\ght aga9/ ,! ,book ,annex$4 ,moreov]1 ! la/ words ( ! extract supply a good text = c]ta9 didactic rem>ks t ought to be made1 ) respect to :at is possible & :at is n possible 9 ! l9e ( liturgical revision 9 ,am]ica4 ,wor?less z ! result ( ! ,jo9t ,committee's labors has turn$ out to be1 _! motive1 we are assur$1 0 a good "o4 ,! critic's cont5tion is n t ! "w !y und]took is a "w t ought n to be done1 b r t :5 done x %\ld be bett] done4 ,! revision z pres5t$ mu/ be dismiss$ z a dismal fiasco1 b only dismiss$ 9 ord] to be dealt ) anew 9 "s m adequate fa%ion4 ,b on :at gr\nd c we re/ ?is sangu9e expectation ( bett] ?+s to come8 ,:5ce is to orig9ate & h[ is to be appo9t$ ! commission ( exp]ts :i* is to give u at la/ ! ,ideal ,liturgy8 ,c>d9al ,newman 9 "o ( 8 less] controv]sial tracts rem>ks3 ,if ! ,engli% p lodge p[] 9 ! _m1 n 9 ! few1 :at wond] t its op]ation is r\ndab\t1 clumsy1 sl[1 int]mitt5t1 & disappo9t+8 ,y _c eat y\r cake & h x2 y _c be at once a self-gov]n+ nation & h a /rong gov]nm5t4#dc ,simil>ly x may be said t1 h[ev] great ! difficulties t beset liturgical revision by legislative process at ! h&s ( "s five hundr$ m51 nev]!less ! fact rema9s t ! body kn[n 9 law z ,! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur* 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica has provid$ 9 its ,con/itution t *ange 9 its =mul>ies %all be s effect$ & n o!rwise4 ,x may turn out t we mu/ give up 9 despair ! :ole movem5t = a bett] adaptation ( our manual ( wor%ip to ! ne$s ( our l& & ( our "t2 x may be f\nd t ! ob/acles 9 ! way are absolutely insup]able2 b let u dream no dreams ( see+ ?is ?+ h&$ ov]1 ) p[]1 to a commission ( exp]ts1 = t is some?+ :i* w nev] come to pass4 ,:e!r exp]ts 9 liturgies are any m likely to furni% u ) good pray]s ?an exp]ts 9 prosody are likely to give u ! be/ poetry is a tempt+ "q1 b "o t mu/ be left1 = ! pres5t1 on "o side4 ,p]haps1 if ! inquiry 7 to be pu%$1 we might f9d ourselves %ut up to ! curi\s conclusion t ! fram]s ( ! v e>lie/ liturgies1 ! au?ors ( ! old sacram5t>ies1 7 ei!r v]bally inspir$ or else 7 lack+ 9 ! qualifications :i* alone c\ld fit !m to d wor?ily ! "w !y wor?ily did1 = cle>ly exp]ts !y 7 n4 ,b ! "q t imm$iately conc]ns u is "o ( simple fact4 ,assum+ ! pres5t labori\s ef=t at bett]m5t to h be5 prov$ a fiasco1 h[ is ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion to set 9 motion any m promis+ eng9]y ( revision8 ,summon 91 say our ,engli% advis]s1 compet5t s*ol>s1 & give !m c>te blan*e to d :at !y w4 ,b ! ,conv5tion1 :i* is by law ! f9al arbit]1 has no p[] to invite to a %>e 9 its c\ncils m5 :o h no con/itutional "r to a seat ^u its floor4 ,h[ ?ankfully %\ld we welcome z p>ticipants 9 our debates & z allies 9 our legislation ! em95t liturgical s*ol>s :o give lu/re to ! cl]gy li/ ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&2 b we are z p[]less to make !m memb]s ( ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion z we %\ld be to =ce !m into ! ,h\se ( ,commons4 ,! same holds true at home4 ,if ! sev]al dioceses fail to discov] _! own +lori\s ,miltons1 & w n s5d !m up to ,g5]al ,conv5tion1 ,g5]al ,conv5tion may1 & d\btless does1 lam5t ! bl9dness ( ! con/itu5cies1 b x _c correct _! blund]4 ,! dioceses 9 :i* ! exp]ts canonically reside _h _h full w>n+ t important liturgical int]e/s 7 to be discuss$ & act$ ^u 9 ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( #ahhc2 :y 7 ! exp]ts left at home8 ,& if !y 7 n return$ 9 #ahhc1 is !re suffici5t reason to believe t !y w ev] be return$ 9 any com+ ye> ( grace8 ,x mu/ be ei!r t ! ,am]ican ,*ur* is b]eft ( exp]ts1 or else t ! con/itu5cies1 influ5c$ possibly by ! h>d s5se ( ! laity1 h le>n$ hopelessly to conf\nd ! exp]t ) ! doctr9aire4 ,( exp]t te/imony1 9 ! %ape ( ! liturgical mat]ial ga!r$1 ma9ly by ,engli% writ]s1 dur+ ! la/ fifty ye>s1 ! ,jo9t ,committee _h no lack4 ,t ?is mat]ial 0 c>efully sift$ & consci5ti\sly us$1 ,! ,book ,annex$ w itself "o day be ackn[l$g$ to be ! suffici5t evid5ce4 ,!re is /ill ano!r po9t t mu/ be tak5 into acc\nt 9 ?is connection1 to wit1 ! attitude :i* ! ,episcopate has a "r to take ) respect to any propos$ "w ( liturgical revision4 ,bi%ops h probably become inur$ to ! h>d measure habitually dealt out to !m 9 ! columns ( ! ,*ur* ,times1 & are unlikely to all[ *>ges ( ignorance & incompet5cy s f> to di/urb _! composure z to make !m afraid to prosecute a "w :i*1 f "t immemorial1 has be5 held to lie peculi>ly )9 _! prov9ce4 ,x may be affirm$1 ) "s confid5ce1 t no revision ( ! ,am]ican ,(fices w ev] be ratifi$1 9 ! conduct ( :i* ! ,bi%ops ( ! ,*ur* h n be5 all[$ ! lead]%ip :i* belongs to !m ( "r4 ,!n x is = ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion c>efully to consid] :e!r any ,h\se ( ,bi%ops de/9$ to be conv5$ 9 our "t is likely to h on its roll ! names ( any prelates m compet5t1 :e!r on ! score ( le>n+ or ( practical exp]i5ce1 to deal ) a "w ( liturgical revision ?an 7 ! sev5 prelates elect$ by ! free voice ( _! bre?r5 to repres5t ! ,episcopal ,ord] on ! ,jo9t ,committee ( ,tw5ty-"o4 ,com+ to details ! review] ( ! ,*ur* ,times regrets1 fir/ ( all1 ! failure ( ! ,conv5tion to *ange ! "n ( ! ,*ur*4 ,he goes on to express a disapproval1 m or less qualifi$1 ( ! discretion>y p[] giv5 to bi%ops to set =? =ms ( pray] = special occasions1 & ( ! cont9u$ p]mission to use ,selections ( ,psalms in/ead ( ! psalms = ! day4 ,x is n q cle> :e!r he approves ! expansion ( ! ,table ( ,prop] ,psalms or n1 ?\gh he ?9ks x ab/ract$ly desirable t provision be made 9 ?is connection = ,corpus ,*ri/i & ,all ,s\ls4 ,he condemns ! latitude all[$ 9 ! *oice ( lessons "u ! rules ( ! new lection>y1 fe>+ t a cl]gyman :o happ5s to dislike any giv5 *apt] because ( its cont5ts may be tempt$ habitually to suppress x by sub/itut+ ano!r1 b 9 ! v next p>agraph he gravely que/ions ! exp$i5cy ( limit+ congregations to su* hymns z h be5 duly set =? & all[$ by au?ority4 ,yet mo/ obs]v]s1 at lea/ on ?is side ( ! wat]1 are ( op9ion t lib]ty ( *oice )9 ! limits ( ! ,bible is a f> saf] fre$om1 s f> z ! bre$+ ( h]esy goes1 ?an lib]ty ( *oice beyond ! limits ( ! ,hymnal has prov$ itself to be4 ,! review] is pleas$ ) ! addition ( ! ,fea/ ( ! ,transfiguration to ! ,cal5d>1 b desid]ates m1 & w\ld gladly welcome ! introduction into ! ,pray] ,book ( commemorations ( em95t sa9ts1 f ,ignatius d[n1#dd b ( ?is1 m5tion has already be5 made1 & x is unnecess>y to rev]t to x4 ,!re foll[s next a prote/ aga9/ ! selection ( prop] ,s5t5ces prefix$ to ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]4 ,! revis]s seem to h a glimm]+ ( :at 0 ! "r ?+ to d 4 4 4 b !y %\ld h swept away ! undevotional & unliturgical plan ( beg9n+ ) c]ta9 deta*$ texts1 :i* has no fitness :atev]1 & has nev] ev5 seem$ to answ] any useful end4 ,?is is /rong] language ?an mo/ ( u are likely to approve4 ,a ,*ur* t directly takes issue ) ,rome1 z ours does1 ) respect to ! true s\rce ( au?ority 9 religion has an excell5t reason = lett+ ! voice ( ,holy ,scripture s\nd ! key-note ( h] daily wor%ip1 :e!r !re be anci5t prec$5t = su* a use or n4 ,at ! same "t1 ! review]'s av]m5t t ! only prop] op5+ is ! ,invocation ( ! ,holy ,tr9ity is entitl$ to att5tion2 & x is wor? consid]+ :e!r ! latt] portion ( ! n9ete5? v]se ( ! tw5ty-eigh? *apt] ( ,/4 ,mat!w's ,gospel might n be advantage\sly add$ to ! li/ ( op5+ ,s5t5ces1 = optional use4 ,9 speak+ ( ! new alt]nate to ! ,decl>ation ( ,absolution1 ! review] sugge/s mo/ happily t x w\ld be well to revive ! =m ( mutual confession ( prie/ & p f\nd 9 ! old s]vice-books4#de ,?is proposal w\ld probably n be ent]ta9$ 9 connection ) ! regul> ,ord]s = ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]1 b room = su* a feature might p]haps be f\nd 9 "s optional (fice4 ,aft] a grudg+ comm5dation ( ! /eps tak5 9 ,! ,book ,annex$ to re/ore ! ,gospel ,canticles1 ! review] next puts 9 a /rong plea = a l>g] all[ance ( v]sicles & responses aft] ! ,cre$1 cont5d+ t ?is is j "o ( ! places :]e enri*m5t1 mu* beyond t ( replac+ ! ,engli% v]sicles & responses n[ miss+1 is feasible & easy1 to :i* ! answ] is t we1 :o love ^! miss+ v]sicles1 %all ?9k ourselves =tunate if we succe$ 9 rega9+ only s mu* z we h lo/4 ,ev5 ?is w be accompli%$ ) difficulty4 ,x is mo/ int]e/+1 h[ev]1 to notice t ?is /\t def5d] ( all t is ,engli% ackn[l$ges ! c\pl+ toge!r ( ! v]sicle1 ,give peace 9 our "t1 ,o ,"l1 & ! response1 ,because !re is none o!r t fighte? = u1 b only ?\1 ,o ,god1 to be a v infelicit\s non-sequitur4 ,= correct+ ?is palpable incongruity1 ! au?ors ( ,! ,book ,annex$ h be5 %>ply criticis$ "h at home4 ,:at 7 !y t !y %\ld h presum$ to di/urb anci5t ,anglican prec$5t 9 su* a po9t8 ,if we c\ld n und]/& :y ! ,god ( battles1 z ! ,god ( battles1 %\ld be implor$ to give peace 9 our "t1 s mu* ! worse = our intellig5ce4 ,b "h comes ! mo/ acrid ( all our critics1 & %[s h[ ! collocation ( s5t5ces 9 ! ,engli% ,book has1 f ! beg9n+1 be5 due to a palpable blund] 9 cond5s+ an (fice ( ! ,s>um ,brevi>y4 ,( ! ,am]ican sub/itute = ?is unhappy response ! be/ he c say1 h[ev]1 is t x is well int5tion$4 ,( ! ,(fice ( ! ,beatitudes ! review] decl>es t x ne$s ?or\gh reca/+ be=e x c /&1 & 9 ?is we agree ) him1 z w h]eaft] appe>1 ?\gh :olly unable to concur 9 8 sweep+ condemnation1 9 ?is connection1 ( "o ( ! mo/ beautiful ( ,canon ,bright's liturgical compositions1 ! ,collect beg9n+1 ,o ,god1 by :om ! meek are guid$ 9 judgm5t & light rise? up 9 d>kness = ! godly4 ,( ?is exquisite piece ( idiomatic ,engli%1 ! review] all[s himself to speak z be+ a v poor composition1 defective 9 rhy?m4 ,! criticism ( ! eu*>i/ic portions ( ,! ,book ,annex$ is ma9ly 9 ! l9e ( compla9t t m has n be5 add$ 9 ! way ( new collects & prop] prefaces1 b ^u ?is po9t x is unnecess>y to dwell1 ! reasons hav+ be5 already giv5 :y ! ,jo9t ,committee & ! ,conv5tion left ! liturgy prop] almo/ unt\*$4 ,nei!r is !re any?+ t specially calls = notice or s]i\s reply 9 :at is said ab\t ! ,occasional ,(fices4 ,! ,(fice = ! ,burial ( ,*ildr5 is ackn[l$g$ to be a ne$$ addition1 b z x /&s is pit*$ 9 an entirely wrong key4 ,! cognate (fices 9 ! ,rituale ,romanun & ! ,prie/'s ,pray] ,book ought to h %[n ! ,committee1 7 x n = _! peculi> untea*abl5ess1 a bett] way4 ,to "o :o c read betwe5 ! l9es1 ?is arraignm5t ( ! ,am]icans = _! lack ( docility to ! tea*+s ( ! ,prie/'s ,pray] ,book is n devoid ( droll]y4 ,x w happily illu/rate ! peculi> difficulties t beset liturgical revision to close ?is resume ( ! c5sures ( ,! ,*ur* ,times by pr9t+1 side by side1 ! review]'s e/imate ( ! *anges propos$ 9 ! ,confirmation ,(fice & ! indep5d5t judgm5t ( a le>n$ evangelical div9e ( our own ,*ur* ^u ! same po9t4 ,! ,confirmation ,s]vice1 z "o ( ! v poore/ 9 ! ,anglican rites1 /ood p>ticul>ly 9 ne$ ( am5dm5t & enri*m5t1 especially by ! removal ( ! ambigu\s ^w confirm appli$ to ! acts ( ! c&idates1 :]eby ! errone\s op9ion t !y came m]ely to confirm & ratify _! baptismal promises1 & n to be confirm$ & /r5g!n$ 9 virtue ( some?+ be/[$ ^u !m1 has ga9$ curr5cy4 ,?us f> ! ,engli% ,rituali/4 ,"h foll[s ! ,am]ican ,evangelical3 ,i /ill hope y w see y\r way cle> to modify ! pres5t draft ( ! propos$ ,confirmation ,(fice1 z x gives a mu* high] ,sacram5t>ian idea ( x ?an ! pres5t1 a concession :i* w greatly please ! ,sac]dotali/s1 to :i* !y are by no means entitl$4 ,! critic ( ,! ,gu>dian is a writ] ( diff]5t make1 & entitl$ e way to ! mo/ respectful att5tion4 ,8 fault-f9d+1 :i* is inv>iably c\rte\s1 is ma9ly conf9$ to ! defici5cies ( ,! ,book ,annex$4 ,he w\ld h _h m done r ?an less2 b at ! same "t cle>ly po9ts out t "u ! re/rictions :i* controll$ ! ,committee m c\ld n fairly h be5 expect$4 ,he regrets t 9 re/or+ ! lo/ portions ( ,v5ite & ,b5$ictus ! ,conv5tion did n make ! use ( ! complete =m 9 e case obligatory2 & ( ! eight conclud+ v]ses ( ! latt] canticle1 :i* "u ! rubric ( ,! ,book ,annex$ are only obligatory dur+ ,adv5t1 he says1 ,imag9e _! omission on ,*ri/mas ,day6 ,to ?is criticism !re are sev]al answ]s1 any "o ( :i* may be held to be suffici5t4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 x %\ld be rememb]$ t into ! ,committee's plan ( enri*m5t !re ent]$ ! elem5t ( diff]5tiation4 ,! clos+ portion ( ! ,v5ite has a special appropriat5ess to ,l5t2 ! clos+ portion ( ! ,b5$ictus a special appropriat5ess to ,adv5t4 ,moreov]1 if any congregations desire ! :ole ( ^! two canticles ?r\gh\t ! ye>1 !re is no?+ 9 ! rubrics ( ,! ,book ,annex$ to =bid su* an enjoym5t ( !m4 ,!y may be sung 9 full always2 b only 9 ,l5t 9 ! "o case1 & 9 ,adv5t 9 ! o!r1 ma/ !y be s sung4 ,! revision ,committee 0 in=m$1 on :at 0 consid]$ ! highe/ au?ority1 t 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& ! ,b5$ictus1 on acc\nt ( its l5g?1 _h be5 v g5]ally disus$4 ,b1 h[ev] ?is may be1 !re c be little d\bt t ! ef=t aft] re/oration w\ld h fail$ completely 9 ! late ,conv5tion _h ! use ( ^! two canticles 9 full be5 insi/$ ^u by ! promot]s ( revision4 ,!re is less ( v]bal criticism 9 ,! ,gu>dian's review ?an c\ld h be5 wi%$1 = any sugge/ions ) respect to inaccuracies ( /yle or rhy?mical %ortcom+s w\ld h be5 mo/ welcome f ! p5 ( s compet5t a c5sor4 ,att5tion is call$ to ! unmusical fl[ ( language 9 ! alt]nate ,confession provid$ = ! ,ev5+ ,(fice2 ! figurative features ( ! propos$ ,collect = ,maundy-,?ursday are *>act]iz$ z infelicit\s2 & ! ,collect provid$ = ! ,fea/ ( ! ,transfiguration is decl>$ to be inf]ior to ! correspond+ "o 9 ! ,s>um ,brevi>y4 ,( ?is sort ( criticism1 at ! h&s ( m5 :o "k _! craft1 ,! ,book ,annex$ _c h too mu*4 ,9 fact1 ( su* immeasurable importance is good ,engli% 9 ?is connection1 t x w\ld be no h>d%ip 7 e sep>ate clause ( :atev] =mul>y x may be propos$ to engraft ^u ! ,pray] ,book to be subject$ to ! mo/ se>*+ te/s4 ,let an epo* be agre$ ^u1 if necess>y1 t %all s]ve z ! crit]ion ( admissibility = words & phrases4 ,let x be decid$1 = in/ance1 t no ^w t _c prove an ,elizabe?an p>5tage1 or1 if ?is be too sev]e a /&>d1 !n no ^w ( po/-,c>ol9e orig91 %all be admitt$ )9 ! sacr$ prec9cts4 ,probably !re are words 9 ,! ,book ,annex$ :i* su* a canon w\ld eject2 b let u h !m po9t$ out1 & _! m]its & dem]its discuss$4 ,su* criticism w\ld be ( inf9itely m value to ! real int]e/s ( revision ?an ^? vague & g5]al *>ges ( crud5ess & want ( f9i% :i* x is always s easy to make & sometimes s difficult to illu/rate4 ,! writ] 9 ,! ,gu>dian closes an only too brief comm5t>y ^u :at ! ,conv5tion has laid be=e ! ,*ur* ) ! foll[+ words3 ,_m ( ! proposals n[ 9 "q are excell5t2 b o!rs w be improv$ by reconsid]ation 9 ! light ( full] ritual /udy1 su* z w be se5 to produce a m exact & cultur$ ritual ae/hesis1 p]haps we may1 )\t (f5ce1 add1 a m delicate appreciation ( rhy?m4 ,:at ,! ,book ,annex$ pres5ts to u 9 ! way ( em5dation is1 on ! :ole1 good2 b1 if subject$ to a delib]ate rec5sion1 x w\ld1 we pr$ict1 become /ill bett]4 ,if ?us improv$ by ! ,conv5tion ( #ahhf1 x might be f9ally adopt$ by ! ,conv5tion ( #ahhi4 ,?is conspectus ( ,engli% critical op9ion w\ld be incomplete 7 no acc\nt to be made ( ! utt]ances ( ! v>i\s writ]s & speak]s :o dealt ) ! g5]al subject ( liturgical revision at ! rec5t ,*ur* ,congress at ,portsm\?4 ,! ,book ,annex$ c\ld sc>cely ask a m complete ju/ification ?an is suppli$ by ^! te/imonies ( m5 :o at lea/ may be suppos$ to be acqua9t$ ) ! ne$s ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,! foll[+ cat5a1 made up f ?ree ( ! f\r ,pap]s#df read ^u ! ,pray] ,book1 gives a fair notion ( ! g5]al tone ( ! discussion4 ,x w be wor? anyone's :ile to collate x ) ! ?irty ,resolutions t make up ! ,notification to ! ,dioceses4 ,c x be s]i\sly d\bt$ t !re are requirem5ts ( ?is age :i* are n satisfi$ by ! provision = public wor%ip made 9 ! sixte5? c5tury8 ,c any really suppose t ! compil]s ( t brief manual1 ! ,pray] ,book1 h[ev] pr\d we may rightly be ( _! "w1 7 s gift$ ) inspir$ =esight z to save ! ,*ur* ( future ages ! responsibilities ( consid]+ & supply+ ! devotional wants ( successive g5]ations8 ,:o has n felt ! scant9ess ( holy association 9 our ,sunday & week-day wor%ip8 4 4 4 ,mu*1 ,i "k1 has be5 suppli$ by our hymnology1 :i* has progress$ nobly 9 proportion z ! meagr5ess ( our liturgical provision has be5 realiz$4 ,b beyond hymns we ne$ actual =ms ( s]vice1 :i* %all /rike ! e> & t\* ! he>t by fre% & vivid adaptations ( ,god's ,^w to ! great my/]ies ( ! ,gospel fai? 4 4 4 ,aft]-s]vices on ,sunday ev5+s h ( late gr[n common2 = !m we ne$ also ! aid ( regul> & ela/ic =ms4 ,mo/ deplorably h we felt ! ne$ ( int]cessory s]vices = ,home & ,=eign ,missions2 &1 ?\gh !re are beautiful metrical litanies :i* be> directly on ^! & o!r objects1 yet ^! are n suffici5t1 & ( c\rse are limit$ to times :5 a good & /rong *oir c be secur$2 4 4 4 & fur!r we want v simple =ms ( pray] to accompany addresses giv5 9 homes & mission rooms4#dg ,i decl>e x z my conviction1 aft] _m ye>s ( 7,i hope7 a n indol5t m9i/ry1 & ( _m opportunities ( obs]vation & exp]im5t1 t ! ,*ur* /&s 9 press+ & imm$iate ne$ ( a few re>rangem5ts & adaptations ( "s ( h] ,(fices2 also ( an enorm\s numb] ( supplem5t>y ,(fices or s]vices--"s = frequ5t use1 o!rs = occasional purposes )9 ! consecrat$ build+s2 & t besides ^! !re is ne$ ( a supply ( special ,(fices = ! use ( a recogniz$ lay ag5cy outside ( ! *ur* edifices4 ,:y limit our introductory s5t5ces to sev5 deprecatory texts8 4 4 4 ,:y c we n introduce ! an!m us$ on ,ea/]-day1 in/ead ( ! ,v5ite1 ?r\gh\t ! ,octave2 or at lea/ on ,ea/] ,monday & ,tuesday8 ,w\ld n spiritual life be deep5$ & int5sifi$1 &1 be/ ( all1 be /r5g!n$1 by ! use 9 ! same mann] ( a suitable an!m in/ead ( ! ,v5ite on ,adv5t ,sundays1 on ,*ri/mas-day1 at ,epiphany1 on ,a%-,w$nesday1 on ,good ,friday1 dur+ ,rogation days1 at ,asc5sion-tide1 & on h>ve/ fe/ivals & ! special annual ,*ur* fe/ival ( ! ye>8 ,i submit t an enri*m5t ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] is also requir$4 ,= al?\gh1 z already sugge/$1 ?is may be provid$ to "s ext5t by a ,collect = occasional use be=e ! f9al pray] ( ,morn+ ,pray] or ,ev5song1 ! ne$s ( ! ,*ur* w n be fully suppli$ )\t "s complete additional (fices4 ,c]ta9ly an additional s]vice = ,sunday aft]noon & ev5+ 4 4 4 ,! times are v solemn1 & we mu/ wait no long] 4 4 4 ,we h talk$ = ne>ly tw5ty-five ye>s--n va9ly1 ,i believe--b let u g & d n a little 9 ! next five ye>s 4 4 4 ,prove y\rself to be ( ! ,*ur* ( ,god by do+ all ! "w ( ! ,*ur*1 & 9 ! prop] way4 ,proclaim be=e our ,god by y\r actions & y\r activities1 & by provid+ all t is ne$$1 n only = ,*ur*m51 b = e>ne/ ,*ri/ians :o are n ,*ur*m51 & = ! poor1 we>y s9n]s :o are liv+ z if !re 7 nei!r ,*ur* nor ,savi\r1 su* s]vices = ! "o1 & su* means = draw+ ! o!rs to ,*ri/1 t !y all may become "o 9 him4 ,& = all ?is y mu/ h 7z ,i ?9k73 #a4 ,possibly a small re>rangem5t ( exi/+ s]vices4 #b4 ,v>iety & additions 9 "s ( ^! s]vices4 #c4 ,enri*m5t by _m s]vices supplem5t>y4 #d4 ,s]vices = use by laym54 ,i wi% to al>m none1 b ,i wi% we 7 all a/ir1 = !re is no "t to wait4#dh ,i %\ld l to sugge/1 if x seems desirable1 z x does to me1 to make any fur!r v>iation f ! orig9al arrangem5t ( ,morn+ ,pray]1 t on su* days z ,ea/]-day1 ,:itsunday1 & ,asc5sion-day we %\ld beg9 9 a little diff]5t fa%ion ?an we d n[4 ,is x always ne$ful to beg9 on su* great days ( rejoic+ = ,*ri/ians ) ! same s5t5ces & ! same ,exhortation & ,confession1 & h to wait1 s to speak1 to give v5t to our feel+s till we rea* ! special psalms = ! day8 ,might we n on su* days accept ! glori\s facts1 & beg9 ) "s special & appropriate psalm or an!m8 4 4 4 ,?us we %\ld at once get ! great doctr9e ( ! day1 & be let to rejoice 9 x at ! v outset1 & !n g on to ! ,"l's ,pray] & ! re/ z we h x n[4 ,confession ( s9 & absolution are n left out 9 ! s]vices ( ! day1 z1 ( c\rse1 !y occur 9 ! ,holy ,communion2 b leav+ !m out 9 ! ord9>y s]vices1 & beg9n+ 9 ! way sugge/$1 w\ld at "o & ! same "t m>k ! day m cle>ly1 & give opportunity = ,*ri/ian gladness to %[ itself 4 4 4 ,only "o o!r alt]ation w\ld1 ,i ?9k1 be ne$$1 namely1 t a good selection ( psalms be made1 & us$1 z 9 ! ,am]ican ,*ur*1 at ! discretion ( ! m9i/]4 ,i ?9k all mu/ feel t = "o reason or ano!r all ! psalms are n adapt$ = ! ord9>y wor%ip ( a mix$ congregation2 & ?is plan w\ld ease ! m9ds ( _m cl]gy & laity4 ,also copy+ ! ,am]ican ,*ur*1 x w\ld be well to omit ! ,litany on ,*ri/mas-day1 ,ea/]-day1 & ,:itsunday4#di ,9 ! light ( ?is summ>y ( ,anglican desid]ata1 compil$ by :olly fri5dly h&s1 x is pla9 t :atev] we may d 9 ?is c\ntry 9 ! l9e ( liturgical revision1 always suppos+ x to be gravely & c>efully done1 in/ead ( h>m+1 ought m>vell\sly to help ! real int]e/s ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,c]ta9 pr9ciples ( polity adopt$ 9 our own ,*ur* a c5tury ago1 & notably among !m ^? affect+ ! legislative rights ( ! laity 9 matt]s ecclesia/ical1 are beg9n+ to f9d t>dy recognition 9 ! ,engl& ( ! pres5t4 ,possibly a hundr$ ye>s h5ce1 or soon]1 a l *ange ( m9d may br+ ,engli% ,*ur*m5 to ! approval ( liturgical me?ods :i*1 ev5 if n :olly consonant to ! temp] ( ! ,act ( ,uni=mity1 h nev]!less be5 f\nd useful & effective 9 ! "w ( br++ ! tru? & ! p[] ( ,god to be> ^u ! common life ( a great nation4 ,! ,*ur* ( ,engl& is to-day mov+ on t[>d *anges & *ances ( :i* %e sees en\gh already to al>m & n yet en\gh to reassure h]4 ,! dimness ( unc]ta9ty cov]s :at may yet turn out to be ! ,m\nt ( h] ,transfiguration1 & %e fe>s z %e ent]s into ! cl\d4 ,h[ %all we be/ & mo/ wisely %[ our sympa?y8 ,by pass+ resolutions ( condol5ce8 ,by *ildi% commis]ation1 ! utt]ance ( feign$ lips1 ^u ! approa*+ sorr[s ( dise/abli%m5t8 ,n ?us at all1 b r by a c\rage\s & well-consid]$ pione]+ "w1 :i* %all h x = its purpose to feel ! gr\nd & blaze ! pa? :i* pres5tly %e & we may f9d ourselves tread+ 9 company4 ,ti$ z %e is1 = h] an und]tak+ ( ?is sort is impossible4 ,we c %[ h] no great] k9dness ?an by ent]+ ^u x ( our own motion & alone4 7b7 ,am]ican4 ,criticism at home has be5 abundant2 mu* ( x intellig5t & helpful1 & by no means s mu* ( x z might h be5 expect$ capti\s4 ,( :at may be call$ (ficial reviews !re h be5 ?ree1 "o f ! ,diocese ( ,c5tral ,new ,york1 "o f ! ,diocese ( ,wiscons91 & "o f ! ,diocese ( ,ea/on4 ,! subject has also be5 dealt ) 9 c>efully prep>$ essays publi%$ f "t to "t 9 ,! ,*ur* ,review & ,! ,*ur* ,eclectic1 :ile 9 ! case ( ! weekly j\rnals ! treatm5t ( ! topic has be5 s frequ5t & s full t a m]e catalogue ( ! editorial articles & contribut$ communications 9 ,:i*1 dur+ ! two ye>s la/ pa/1 liturgical revision has be5 discuss$ w\ld ov]tax ! limits ( ! pres5t pap]4 ,! only practicable means ( deal+ ) ?is mass ( criticism is to adopt ! inductive me?od1 & to seek to draw out f ! utt]ances ( ^! _m voices ! f\r or five di/9ct concepts t sev]ally lie beh9d !m4 ,9 lim9e h[ev]1 let ?is be said1 t ! broade/ g5]alization ( all is "o to :i* ! v discordance ( ! critics be>s ! be/ possible witness4 ,( a s*eme ( re vision aga9/ :i* is press$1 9 ,virg9ia1#ej ! *>ge ( ,m>iolatry2 9 ,ohio1#ea ! *>ge ( ,latitud9>ianism2 & 9 ,wiscons9#eb ! *>ge ( ,puritanic pravity1 ?is mu* may at lea/ be said1 t x possesses ! note ( fairness4 ,f h5ce=? sugge/ions ( p>tisan bias are cle>ly out ( ord]4 ,! ,anglo-,ca?olic c5sures ( ,! ,book ,annex$ are sub/antially summ$ up 9 ! ass]tion t due reg>d is n _h1 9 ! *anges propos$1 to ! /ructural pr9ciples ( liturgical sci5ce4 ,9 ! exce$+ly well writt51 if some:at "o-sid$ docum5t1 already ref]r$ to z ! ,wiscons9 ,report1 ?is is1 ?r\gh\t1 ! burd5 ( ! compla9t4 ,! accompli%$ au?or ( ! ,report1 ?an :om no "o ( ! critics at home or abroad has %[n a ke5] or a bett] cultivat$ liturgical in/9ct1 is afraid t a free use ( all ! lib]ties p]mitt$ by ! new rubrics ( ! daily (fices w\ld s revolutionize ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray] z practically to oblit]ate ! l9e ( _! desc5t f ! old mona/ic =ms4 ,if !re 7 valid gr\nd = su* an expectation ! al>m might be ju/ifiable2 b is !re8 ,! practical effect ( ! rubrics t make = abbreviation w be to give u back1 on weekdays almo/ exactly1 & ) measurable precision on ,sundays also1 ! ,mat9s & ,ev5song ( ! ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 ,surely ?is is n ! de/ruction ( cont9uity ) ! pre-,re=mation ,*ur*4 ,9 8 dislike ( ! provision = graft+ ! ,beatitudes ^u ! ,ev5+ ,pray]1 ! au?or ( ! ,wiscons9 ,report w h _m sympa?iz]s1 ! pres5t writ] among !m2 b 9 8 fe> t 9 ! introduction ( ! ,proem to ! ,song ( ! ,?ree ,*ildr51 z a possible respond to ! ,fir/ ,lesson1#ec !re lurks a cov]t design to de?rone ! ,te ,deum1 he is likely to f9d few to agree ) him4 ,b aft] all1 may n ?is scrupul\s reg>d = ! prec$5ts set u 9 ! old s]vice-books be c>ri$ too f>8 ,x is :olesome1 b !re is a limit to ! :olesom5ess ( x4 ,we rememb] :o x 0 t made w> = ! sake ( a sci5tific fronti]4 ,"s ( ! sci5tific fronti]s 9 ! region ( liturgies are z illusory z 8 04 ,= example1 ,! ,book ,annex$ may be unsci5tific 9 draw+ z l>gely z x does on ! language ( ! ,apocalypse = v]sicles & responses4 ,!re has c]ta9ly be5 a dep>ture f ,anglican prec$5t 9 ?is reg>d4 ,& yet x w\ld sc>cely seem t we c\ld g f> a/ray 9 borr[+ f ! liturgy ( heav51 :e!r !re be e>?ly prec$5t or n4 ,cranm] & 8 associates made a f> bold] break ) ! old (fice-books ?an ,! ,book ,annex$ makes ) ! ,/&>d ,common ,pray]4 ,! /atem5t ( ! ,wiscons9 ,report1 t ,! ,re=m]s ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* did n v5ture to write new ,(fices ( ,pray]1 mu/ be tak5 ) qualifications4 ,!y did n make (fices absolutely de novo1 b !y did cond5se & comb9e old (fices 9 a mann] t practically made a new ?+ ( !m4 ,!y took ! mona/ic s]vices & c\rage\sly rem\ld$ !m into a =m suitable = ! new era 9 :i* mona/]ies 7 to exi/ no long]4 ,happily !y 7 s ?or\gh 9 _! "w t comp>atively little *ange is call$ = 9 adapt+ :at !y fitt$ to ! ne$s ( ! sixte5? c5tury to ! m v>i$ requirem5ts ( ! n9ete5?4 ,/ill1 :5 !y are quot$ z cons]vatives1 & we are ref]r$ = evid5ce ( _! dislike ( *ange to t p>ticul> p>agraph ( ! ,preface to ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book entitl$1 ,conc]n+ ! ,s]vice ( ! ,*ur*#ed x is wor? our :ile to foll[ up ! ref]5ce & see :at is actually !re said4 ,! ,wiscons9 ,committee use v s(t words 9 speak+ ( ! m$iaeval p]v]sions & corruptions ( ,div9e ,s]vice4 ,x 0 9 ! mona/]ies *iefly1 !y tell u1 t ^! s]vices receiv$ ! embelli%m5ts & wond]ful v>iety :i* we f9d 9 ! lat] c5turies4 ,b ! foll[+ is ! cruel mann] 9 :i*1 9 ! ,engli% ,preface cit$ z au?ority1 ! embelli%m5ts & wond]ful v>iety are *>act]iz$3 ,b ^! _m ye>s pa/1 ?is godly & anci5t ord] ( ! anci5t fa!rs ha? be5 s alt]$1 brok51 & neglect$1 by plant+ 9 unc]ta9 /ories & leg5ds1 ) multitudes ( responds1 v]ses1 va9 repetitions1 commemorations1 & synodals1 t commonly :5 any book ( ! ,bible 0 begun1 aft] ?ree or f\r *apt]s 7 read out1 all ! re/ 7 unread4 4 4 4 ,& fur!rmore1 not)/&+ t ! anci5t fa!rs h divid$ ! ,psalms into sev5 portions1 :]e( e "o 0 call$ a ,nocturn1 n[ ( late "t a few ( !m h be5 daily said & ! re/ utt]ly omitt$ 4 4 4 ,s t "h y h an ,ord] = ,pray] & = ! ,read+ ( ! ,holy ,scripture mu* agreeable to ! m9d & purposes ( ! old fa!rs1 & a great deal m pr(itable & commodi\s ?an t :i* ( late 0 us$4 ,?is is cons]vatism 9 ! v be/ s5se1 = ! object aim$ at is pla9ly ! cons]vation ( purity1 simplicity1 & tru?1 b surely x is n ! cons]vatism ( m5 ) :om inaction is ! only wisdom & immobility ! sole beatitude4 ,we *ange our sky completely 9 pass+ f ,anglo-,ca?olic to ,broad ,*ur* criticism ( ,! ,book ,annex$4 ,?is la/ has1 9 ! ma91 address$ itself to ! rubrical features ( ! propos$ revision4 ,y promis$ u 'flexibility1' ! accusation runs1 b :at y are really giv+ u is simply rigidity "u a new =m4 ,let ?+s /ay z !y are1 & we w und]take to f9d all ! 'flexibility' we c>e to h1 )\t help f legislation4 ,?is criticism has at lea/ ! m]it ( intelligibility1 = x directly antagonizes :at 01 )\t d\bt1 "o ma9 purpose ) ! revis]s1 namely1 t ( reviv+ respect = ! rubrics by mak+ compliance ) _! t]ms a m practicable ?+4 ,evid5tly :at ,broad ,*ur*m51 or at lea/ a section ( !m1 w\ld pref] is ! preval5ce ( a g5]al cons5t "u :i* x %all be tak5 = grant$ t rubrics are n lit]ally b9d+ on ! m9i/]1 b are to be /ret*$ & adapt$1 at ! discretion ( ! (ficiant1 z ! exig5cies ( times & seasons may sugge/4 ,x is urg$ t su* a common und]/&+ already 9 great measure exi/s2 & t to enact new rubrics n[1 or to remodel old ones1 w\ld look l an attempt to revivify a pr9ciple ( compliance :i* we h tacitly agre$ to consid] dead4 ,! answ] to ?is argum5t is n f> to seek4 ,if ! ,*ur* means to all[ ! ,common ,pray]1 :i* hi!rto has be5 reg>d$ z a liturgy1 to lapse into ! /atus ( a directory2 if1 9 o!r words1 %e is cont5t to see h] manual ( wor%ip alt]$ f a book ( in/ructions z to h[ ,div9e ,s]vice %all be p]=m$ into a book ( sugge/ions z to h[ x may be r5d]$1 ! *ange ought to be (ficially & def9itely ann\nc$1 & n left to individual inf]5ce or unc]ta9 conjecture4 ,we are rapidly slipp+ into a position sc>cely consi/5t ) ei!r ! dignity or ! honor ( a great ,*ur*--t ( seem+ to be :at we are n4 ,to give x out to ! public t we are a law-respect+ communion1 & !n to :isp] x ab\t among ourselves t our laws b9d only ^? :o *oose to be b\nd by !m1 may s]ve z a conv5i5t device = tid+ ov] a pres5t difficulty1 b is1 oh ! :ole1 a c\rse ( proc$ure m likely to h>d5 ?an to relieve t5d] consci5ces4 ,take1 by way ( illu/ration1 ! case ( a city cl]gyman :o w\ld gladly introduce into 8 p>i% ! usage ( daily s]vice1 b :o is conv9c$1 :e!r rightly or wrongly1 t to secure ev5 a fair att5dance ( wor%ipp]s he ought to h ! lib]ty ( s f> cond5s+ ! ,morn+ or ! ,ev5+ ,(fice z to br+ x )9 ! limits ( a qu>t] ( an h\r4 ,he seeks relief ?r\gh ! lawful *annel ( rubrical revision1 & is only laugh$ at = 8 pa9s4 ,9 ?is busy n9ete5? c5tury x is nons5se1 he is assur$1 to sp5d a doz5 ye>s 9 besieg+ s obdurate a =tress z ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion4 ,! way to secure %ort5$ s]vices is to %ort5 s]vices4 ,?is is easy logic1 & applicable 9 m directions ?an "o4 ,only see h[ smoo?ly x runs3 ,if y want hymns t are n 9 ! ,hymnal1 pr9t !m4 ,if y want a confessional-box1 set x up4 ,if y want a res]v$ sacram5t1 ord] ! c>p5t] to make a tab]nacle & ! locksmi? to provide a bolt4#ee ,?is is a f> less tr\blesome me?od ( secur+ ! ends desir$ ?an ! t$i\s & r\ndab\t process ( propos+ a *ange at "o meet+ ( ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion1 hav+ y\r proposal knock$ ab\t among "s =ty or fifty dioceses1 & br\ght up = f9al action ?ree ye>s lat]4 ,& yet1 sup]ior z ! =m] me?od may be to ! latt] 9 po9t ( cel]ity & directness1 ! latt] has c]ta9 advantages ov] ! =m] t ought to be evid5t to m5 :o are n fright5$ by hav+ _! scrupul\sness call$ scrupulosity4 ,moreov]1 :y %\ld ?is :ole matt] be discuss$1 z s commonly x is discuss$1 :olly f ! cl]ical side8 ,h ! laity no rights 9 ! liturgy :i* ! cl]gy are b\nd to respect8 ,:5 & :]e did ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur* conf] on its m9i/]s a g5]al disp5s+ p[] ov] ! ord9ances ( wor%ip :i* x )held f ! body ( ! fai?ful8 ,h]et(ore x has be5 held t :5 a layman w5t to *ur* he _h a "r to expect c]ta9 ?+s gu>ante$ him by ! ,*ur*'s law4 ,if all ?is has be5 *ang$1 !n =mal notice ought to be s]v$ ^u u by ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion t su* is ! fact4 ,,! ,,motive ,,( ,,! ,,ef=t ,,aft] ,,revision4 ,x is ask$1 & ) no little %[ ( plausibility1 ,:y--9 ! face ( su* manifold ho/ility & su* p]si/5t opposition1 :y press ! movem5t = revision any fur!r8 ,is x wor? :ile to divide public s5tim5t 9 ! ,*ur* ^u a "q t looks to _m to be sc>cely m ?an a lit]>y "o8 ,:y n drop ! :ole ?+1 & let x fall into ! limbo1 :]e lie already ! ,propos$ ,book & ! ,memorial ,pap]s8 ,= ?is reason1 & x is suffici5t3 ,!re has aris5 9 ,am]ica a movem5t t[>d ,*ri/ian unity1 ! l ( :i* has n be5 se5 s9ce ! c\ntry 0 settl$4 ,x is ! confid5t belief ( _m t ! key to ! situation lies ) t ,*ur* :i* m truly ?an any o!r may be said to repres5t ! hi/orical ,*ri/ianity ( ! peoples ( ,engli% /ock4 ,"o ( ! elem5ts 9 ?is l>g] movem5t is ! "q ( ! =m ( wor%ip4 ,! *ief significance ( ,! ,book ,annex$ lies 9 ! claim made = x by its fri5ds1 t m adequately ?an ! pres5t ,/&>d x supplies :at may fairly be dem&$ z _! manual ( wor%ip by a p circum/anc$ l ours4 ,:ile1 9 "o s5se1 m ,engli% ?an ! pres5t book 9 t x re/ores liturgical treasures lo/ at ! ,revolution1 x is also m ?or\ghly ,am]ican1 9 t x recognizes & all[s = _m ne$s :i* ! newly enfran*is$ coloni/s ( #aghi c\ld n h be5 expect$ to =esee4 ,! "q is1 ,%all we turn a cold %\ld] on ! movem5t *ur*w>d ( our non-,anglican bre?r5 ( ! re=m$ fai?1 do+ our be/ to *ill _! approa*es ) a h>d ,non possumus1 or %all we g out to meet !m ) words ( welcome on our lips8 ,union "u ! ,lat9 ob$i5ce is impossible4 ,= u1 9 ! face ( ! decrees ( #ahgj1 !re c be no peace ) ,rome4 ,! ,greeks are a good way (f4 ,our true solid>ity1 if solid>ity is to be a*iev$ at all1 is n ) ,celts1 b ) our own ki? & k91 ! *ildr5 ( ! ,re=mation4 ,is x wise ( u to say to ^! fell[ ,*ri/ians ( ours1 adh]5ts ( ! ,ca?olic ,fai? z well z we1 ,nay1 b ! ne>] y draw to u ! f>!r we mean to draw away f y2 ! m closely y approximate to ,anglican religion1 ! m closely %all we1 = ! sake ( diff]5c+ ourselves f y1 approximate to ,vatican religion8 ,9 bett] h>mony ) ! apo/olic temp]1 9 tru] cont9uity ) ! e>ly *ur*man%ip1 %\ld we be f\nd1 7 we to jo9 voices ?us3 ,v4 ,come ye1 & let u walk 9 ! light ( ! ,"l4 ,r4 ,& he w tea* u ( 8 ways1 & we w walk 9 8 pa?s4 ,,ii4 ,! ,book ,annex$ may be said to hold to ! possible /&>d ,common ,pray] ( #ahij a relation n unlike t ( a clay model to ! /atue :i* is to be4 ,! mat]ial is /ill 9 condition to be m\ld$2 ! end is n yet4 ,x 0 9 anticipation ( ?is /ate ( ?+s t ! fri5ds ( revision 9 #ahhc 7 anxi\s to c>ry ?r\gh ! prelim9>y /age ( acceptance z _m ( _! propositions z possible4 ,to rev]t to our p>able1 ! modell]1 9 treat+ ! face ( 8 provisional image1 mu/ be c>eful to lay on clay en\gh1 or he may f9d himself b>r$ at ! la/ mom5t f giv+ ! features j t f9i%+ t\* :i* is to make !m ready = ! m>ble4 ,all ! skill 9 ! _w w n enable him to secure = ! face precisely ! expression he w\ld h x we>1 if ! mat]ia be insuffici5t4 ,look$ at 9 ?is light1 ! sugge/ion made by ! ,jo9t ,committee 9 ! ,h\se ( ,deputies at an e>ly /age ( ! session ( #ahhc1 t ! entire ,book ,annex$1 9 precisely ! =m 9 :i* x _h be5 submitt$1 %\ld be pass$1 & s5t d[n to ! dioceses = consid]ation1 in/ead ( be+ ! arbitr>y & unreasonable dem& x 0 reckon$ by ^? :o lift$ _! eyebr[s at ! v m5tion ( su* a ?+1 0 really a s5sible proposition :i* ! ,conv5tion w\ld h done well to he$4 ,few1 if any1 critics ( ,! ,book ,annex$ z ,modifi$ h pron\nc$ x an improvem5t to ,! ,book ,annex$ z pres5t$4 ,! ,book came out ( ! ,conv5tion less admirable ?an x w5t 94 ,z a s*ool ( ,liturgies1 ! long debate at ,philadelphia 0 d\btless salut>y & helpful1 b :e!r ! imm$iate results1 z %[n 9 ! em5dation ( ! ,jo9t ,committee's "w1 7 equally des]v+ ( praise is ano!r "q4 ,nev]!less1 z 0 argu$ 9 ! pap] ( :i* ?is "o is ! cont9uation1 we mu/ take ?+s z we f9d !m1 n z we wi% !y 72 & s9ce !re is no o!r me?od ( liturgical revision kn[n to our laws ?an revision by popul> debate1 to revision by popul> debate we mu/ reconcile ourselves z be/ we may4 ,regrets are idle4 ,let u be ?ankful t ! amicable /ruggle at ,philadelphia _h = its outcome s l>ge r ?an s small a mass ( workable mat]ial1 & in/ead ( acc\nt+ ,! ,book ,annex$ to be :at "o ( ! sign]s ( ! ,jo9t ,committee's ,report has lately call$ x1 a melan*oly production1 recognize 9 x ! g]m ( some?+ exce$+ly to be desir$4 ,f ! fir/1 !re has nev] be5 any disposition on ! "p ( sob]-m9d$ fri5ds ( ,revision to c>ry ?r\gh _! s*eme ) a ru%2 ! delay t is likely to bett] ?+s !y w welcome2 ! only delay !y deprecate is ! delay t kills4 ,! *anges enum]at$ 9 ! ,notification to ! ,dioceses1 & illu/rat$ to ! eye 9 ,! ,book ,annex$ z ,modifi$1 may be broadly classifi$ "u ! foll[+ heads3 7a7 ,cle>ly desirable alt]ations1 ) respect to :i* !re is practically unanim\s cons5t1 & = :i* !re is imm$iate dem&1 e4 g41 %ort5$ (fices ( week-day pray]4 7b7 ,alt]ations desirable 9 ! ma91 b likely to be m cordially acquiesc$ 91 c\ld /ill fur!r improvem5t be secur$1 e4 g41 ! new v]sicles introduc$ into ,ev5+ ,pray] aft] ! ,cre$4 7c7 ,alt]ations g5]ally acc\nt$ undesirable on any t]ms1 e4 g41 ! p]missive rubrics ) respect to ! read+ ( c]ta9 psalms dur+ ,l5t1 in/ead ( ! regul> responds to ! ,fir/ & ,second ,lessons ( ! ,ev5+ ,pray]4 ,! "q arises1 ,is any c\rse ( action possible t w give u )\t delay ! *anges :i* = "s fifte5 ye>s ! :ole ,*ur* has be5 labor+ to secure2 t w give u1 ) a reasonable delay ( ?ree ye>s long]1 ! confess$ improvem5ts a little m improv$2 :ile at ! same "t we are kept f becom+ involv$ 9 ! wret*$ confusion sure to result f putt+ into circulation1 )9 a brief p]iod1 two au?oriz$ b div]se books ( ,common ,pray]8 ,?is ?reefold "q x is propos$ to meet ) a ?reefold affirmative4 ,,! ,,/&>d ,,pray] ,,book ,,( #ahij4 ,! end we ought to h 9 view is ! publication1 9 ! ye> #ahij1 ( a /&>d ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 su* z %all embody ! ripe results ( :at w !n h be5 a p]iod ( t5 ye>s ( cont9u\s labor 9 ! "w ( liturgical revision4 ,to ?is reckon+ ( t5 ye>s %\ld prop]ly be add$ ! sev5te5 ye>s t int]v5$ betwe5 ! pres5tation ( ,! ,memorial 9 #ahec & ! pass+ ( ! ,enri*m5t ,resolutions 9 #ahhj3 s t really our ,revision w\ld look back = its hi/orical beg9n+s1 n across a decade m]ely1 b ov] almo/ ! lifetime ( a g5]ation4 ,no s+le "o ( ! v>i\s revisions ( ! ,engli% ,book has obs]v$ any?+ l s leisurely a movem5t4 ,b by :at me?ods ( legislative proc$ure c\ld su* a result z ! "o indicat$ be rea*$8 ,! prec$5t ( ! la/ c5tury does n help u v mu*4 ,! ,am]ican ,book ( ,common ,pray] 0 set =? on ! sixte5? day ( ,octob] 9 ! ye> ( our ,"l #aghi2 b ) an express /atutory provision t ! use ( ! book1 z s set =?1 %\ld n become obligatory till ! fir/ day ( ,octob]1 #agij4 ,we _c copy ?is l9e ( proc$ure1 = ! simple reason t no su* und]tak+ z t ( #aghi is 9 h&4 ,x is n n[ propos$ to legislate into exi/5ce a new ,liturgy4 ,! task be=e u is ! f> humbl] "o ( pass+ judgm5t ^u c]ta9 propositions ( *ange1 almo/ e "o ( :i* admits ( segregation1 has an indep5d5t id5tity ( its own1 & may be accept$ or reject$ :olly )\t ref]5ce to :at is likely to happ5 to ! o!r propositions t accompany x4 ,! ,book ,annex$ z ,modifi$ is 9 no prop] s5se a ,propos$ ,book1 nor c x )\t misrepres5tation be call$ su*2 x is simply a sample publication#ef illu/rative ( :at ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] w\ld be1 7 all ! ,resolutions ( ,revision t pass$ _! fir/ /age ( approval 9 #ahhc c>ri$ into f9al effect2 a result mo/ unlikely to occur4 ,,! ,,means ,,to ,,! ,,end4 ,! mo/ exp$iti\s & e way satisfactory means to ! end t has n[ be5 def9$ w\ld be ! appo9tm5t1 at an e>ly /age ( ! session 9 ,octob]1 ( a ,jo9t ,committee ( ,conf]5ce4 ,to ?is committee %\ld be ref]r$3 7a7 ,! "q3 ,h[ _m ( ! ,resolutions ( #ahhc1 or ( ! sev]al recomm5dations !re9 conta9$1 is x ei!r practicable or desirable to approve at once8 7b7 ,! "q3 ,h[ may su* ( ! ,resolutions ( #ahhc z are too good to be lo/1 b n 9 _! pres5t =m good en\gh to satisfy ! ,*ur*1 be s rem\ld$ z to make _! adoption probable 9 #ahhi8 7c7 ,all new propositions ( improvem5t t may f "t to "t dur+ ! session be br\ght to ! notice ( ! ,conv5tion1 ei!r by individual memb]s or by memorials f ,diocesan ,conv5tions4 ,su* a ,committee ( ,conf]5ce1 hold+ daily sessions ( ?ree or f\r h\rs ea*1 w\ld be able 9 due "t to report a c>efully dige/$ s*eme :i* c\ld !n be intellig5tly discuss$4 ,by ?is me?od a flood ( frivol\s & aimless talk w\ld be cut (f )\t 9 ! slighte/ degree infr++ or limit+ ! real lib]ty ( debate4 ,b ev5 if ! ,conv5tion 7 to %[ itself reluctant to give to a select committee s l>ge a p[] z ?is ( prep>+ an ag5da pap]1 x /ill w\ld be possible to ref] to su* a committee ! subject-matt] ( s _m ( ! resolutions z might *ance1 :5 put ^u _! passage1 to fail by a n>r[ vote4 ,x is to be rememb]$ t ! v>i\s recomm5dations conta9$ 9 ! resolutions ( #ahhc are to be vot$ ^u 9 ipsissimis v]bis4 ,!re w be no opportunity = ! famili> cry3 ,mr4 ,presid5t1 ,i rise to propose an am5dm5t4 ,! resolution1 or ! section ( a resolution1 z ! case may be1 w ei!r be approv$ j z x /&s or condemn$ j z x /&s4 ,9 ?is respect !re w be an imm5se sav+ ( "t4 ,mo/ ( ! t$i\sness ( debate gr[s out ( ! natural disposition ( legislators to try ea* 8 own h& at bett]+ ! ?+ propos$2 h5ce am5dm5ts1 am5dm5ts to am5dm5ts1 & sub/itutes = ! am5dm5t to ! am5dm5t4 ,ev5 ! mak]s ( p>liam5t>y law 7mu* endur+ creatures7 lose _! pati5ce at ?is po9t1 & p]emptorily lay x d[n t confusion %all no fur!r g4 ,b to return to ! suppos$ case ( a proposition lo/ because ( "s slight defect1 :i*1 if only our ,m$o-,p]sian law _h p]mitt$ an am5dm5t1 c\ld easily h be5 rem$i$4 ,surely ! s5sible c\rse 9 su* a case z t w\ld be to ref] ! subject-matt] ( ! lo/ resolution to ! ,committee ( ,conf]5ce1 ) in/ructions to report a new resolution to be f9ally act$ ^u ?ree ye>s h5ce4 ,s !n1 :e!r !re be giv5 to ! ,committee ( ,conf]5ce ei!r ! l>ge p[] to recomm5d a c>efully ?\ght out way ( deal+ ) all ! mat]ial en bloc1 or ! less] function ( sitt+ 9 judgm5t on new propositions1 & ( rem\ld+ reject$ ones1 9 ei!r case !re c\ld sc>cely fail to result f ! appo9tm5t ( su* a committee l>ge & sub/antial ga9s4 ,,improvem5ts4 ,x foll[s1 f :at has be5 said1 t if !re are features t admit ( improvem5t 9 ! proposals :i* ! ,conv5tion has laid be=e ! ,*ur* = scrut9y1 n[ is emphatically ! "t = sugge/+ ! bett] ?+ t might be done4 ,ev5 ! bitt]e/ oppon5ts ( ,! ,book ,annex$ c sc>cely be s sangu9e z to imag9e t no?+ at all is com+ f ?is labor$ movem5t = revision4 ,a measure :i* 0 s f> =? acceptable to ! accr$it$ repres5tatives ( ! ,*ur*1 9 c\ncil assembl$1 z to pass its fir/ /age ?ree ye>s ago almo/ by acclamation1 is n de/9$ to exp]i5ce total collapse4 ,! law ( probabilities =bids ! supposition4 ,! p]sonal make-up ( ! next ,g5]al ,conv5tion w be to a great ext5t id5tical ) t ( ! la/1 & ( ! "o be=e ! la/4 ,sob]-m9d$ m5 famili> ) ! "w ( legislation are n accu/om$ to rev]se _! own well consid]$ decisions )\t weighty cause4 ,! /rong probability is t some?+ 9 ! l9e ( em5dation1 precisely h[ mu* or h[ little no "o c say1 w1 z a matt] ( fact1 be done4 ,9 view ( ?is likelihood1 w\ld n ^? :o are dissatisfi$ ) ,! ,book ,annex$ z x /&s be tak+ ! wis] c\rse 7 !y to sub/itute co-op]ative = vitup]ative criticism8 ,s f> z ! pres5t writ] is 9 any s5se au?oriz$ to speak = ! fri5ds ( revision1 he c assure ! dissid5ts t su* co-op]ation w\ld be mo/ welcome4 ,a4 ,b41 a s*ol> ?or\ghly famili>1 we w suppose1 ) ! s\rces ( liturgical mat]ial1 is dissatisfi$ ) ! collects propos$ = ! successive days ( ,holy ,week4 ,v well1 he has a p]fect "r to 8 dissatisfaction & to ! expression ( x 9 ! /ronge/ t]ms at 8 comm&4 ,he does only 8 pla9 duty 9 seek+ to exclude f ! ,pray] ,book any?+ t seems to him unwor?y ( a place 9 x4 ,b see+ t he mu/ ne$s1 z a liturgical exp]t1 ackn[l$ge t ! defici5cy :i* ! ,jo9t ,committee s\ght to make good is a real & n a m]ely fanci$ defici5cy1 w\ld n ,a4 ,b4 approve himself a m judici\s c\nsellor if1 in/ead ( b5d+ all 8 en]gy to ! disp>agem5t ( ! collects propos$1 he %\ld devote a portion ( x to ! discov]y & sugge/ion ( pray]s m happily word$8 ,& ?is rem>k holds good ) ref]5ce to :atev] new feature is to be f\nd betwe5 ! cov]s ( ,! ,book ,annex$4 ,if bett]m5t be possible1 ^! six mon?s n[ ly+ be=e u af=d ! "t ( all times 9 :i* to %[ h[1 ) ! lea/ ( loss & mo/ ( ga91 x may be br\ght ab\t4 ,! ,diocese ( ,m>yl& is fir/ 9 ! field ) an adequate contribution ( ?is sort4 ,a ?or\ghly compet5t committee1 appo9t$ 9 ,octob]1 #ahhd1 has rec5tly pr9t$ its ,report1 & :e!r ! ,diocesan ,conv5tion adopt1 am5d1 or reject :at is pres5t$ to x1 !re c be little d\bt t ! m9d ( ! ,*ur* at l>ge w be p]ceptibly affect$ by :at ^! repres5tative m5 ( ,m>yl& h said4#eg ,ap>t f a c]ta9 aroma ( omnisci5ce p]vad+ x 7) :i*1 by ! way1 sundry infelicities ( language 9 ! text ( ! ,report1 only indiff]5tly consort71 ! docum5t1 is a =cible "o1 & ( great practical value4 ,! ,committee h gone ov] ! entire field cov]$ by ! ,notification to ! ,dioceses1 tak+ up ! ,resolutions "o by "o1 & n only not+ 9 connection ) ea* :atev] is 9 itself objectionable1 b also 7a f> m difficult task7 sugge/+ 9 :at respect ?is or t proposition might be bett] put4 ,! app>atus criticus ?us provid$1 :ile n infallible1 is em95tly helpful1 sets a :olesome patt]n1 & if supplem5t$ by o!rs ( l t5or & scope1 w g f> to light5 ! labor ( :atev] committee may h ! f9al rec5sion ( ! :ole "w put into its h&s4#eh ,x w\ld be a poor self-conceit 9 ! fram]s ( ,! ,book ,annex$1 t %\ld prompt !m to res5t z intrusive any criticism :atsoev]4 ,:at we all h at he>t is ! br++ ( our manual ( wor%ip z ne>ly z possible to su* a pit* ( p]fectness z ! nature ( ?+s human w all[4 ,! ?+ we seek is a ,liturgy :i* %all draw to itself ev]y?+ t is be/ & mo/ dev\t )9 our national bord]s1 a ,common ,pray] suit$ to ! common wants ( all ,am]icans4 ,:atev] truly makes = ?is end1 x w be our wisdom to welcome1 :e!r ^? :o br+ x =w>d are popul>ly labell$ z belong+ to ?is1 t1 or ! o!r s*ool ( ,*ur*man%ip4 ,to all[ p>ty jeal\sies to m> ! symmetry & fulness ( a "w 9 :i* all ,*ur*m5 ought to h an equal inh]itance w\ld be ! wor/ ( blund]s4 ,by all means let ! raim5t ( ne$lework & ! clo?+ ( wr\ght gold be :at !y %\ld be = su* sacr$ uses z h]s :o is ! daught] ( ! great ,k+1 b let u n fall to wrangl+ ab\t ! vats 9 :i* ! ?read 0 dy$ or ! riv] b$ f :i* ! gold 0 ga!r$4 ,9 a lat] pap] ! pres5t writ] int5ds to v5ture ^u a task simil> to t und]tak5 by ! ,m>yl& ,committee4 ,he w d ?is l>gely 9 ! hope ( enc\rag+ by example o!r & m compet5t critics to busy !mselves 9 ! same way4 ,mean:ile a few obs]vations may n be amiss ) respect to ! s\rces ( liturgical mat]ial1 & ! me?ods by :i* !y c be drawn ^u to ! be/ advantage4 ,!re has be51 fir/ & la/1 a deal ( ill consid]$ talk ab\t ! b\ndlessness ( ! liturgical treasures ly+ unus$ 9 ! pre-,re=mation =mul>ies ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 z well z 9 ! old sacram5t>ies & (fice-books ( ! ,ea/ & ! ,we/4 ,wond] is express$ t ) su* limitless weal? at its comm&1 an ,enri*m5t ,committee %\ld h br\ght 9 s pov]ty-/rick5 a ,report4 ,h we n ,muratori & ,mabillon8 x is ask$3 ,daniel & ,assemani1 ,r5audot & ,go>8 ,are !re n ,missals ,roman1 ,ambrosian1 & ,moz>abic8 ,brevi>ies ,anglican1 ,gallican1 & ,quignonian8 ,has ,maskell delv$ & ,neale translat$ & ,littl$ale compil$ 9 va98 ,to all ( :i* !re are two replies1 namely3 fir/1 ,x is inexp$i5t to ov]load a ,pray] ,book1 ev5 if ! mat]ial be ( ! be/2 & secondly1 ,?is be/ mat]ial is by no means s abundant z ! volume ( our res\rces w\ld seem to sugge/4 ,x 0 = ! v purpose ( escap+ r$undancy & gett+ rid ( surplusage t ! ,anglican ,re=m]s cond5s$ ,missal1 ,brevi>y1 & ,rituale into ! "o small & h&y volume kn[n z ! ,fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 ,x 0 a bold /roke1 d\btless d5\nc$ z p]il\sly radical at ! "t2 b exp]i5ce has ju/ifi$ ,cranm] & 8 fri5ds4 ,9 ! :ole hi/ory ( liturgies !re is no record ( a wis] /ep4 ,x is sc>cely possible s griev\sly to s9 aga9/ a p's ,pray] ,book z by mak+ x m complicat$ 9 arrangem5t & m bulky 9 volume ?an ne$ actually requires4 ,x 0 gr\nd ( ju/ifiable pride ) ! ,enri*m5t ,committee t ! ,book :i* !y br\ght 91 despite ! _m additions x conta9$1 0 no ?ick] by a s+le page ?an ! ,pray] ,book z x is4 ,to be sure1 ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion spoil$ all ?is by insi/+ on reta9+ c]ta9 duplicat$ =mul>ies :i* ! ,committee _h v prop]ly dropp$ 9 ord] to f9d room = fre% mat]ial4 ,b ( ! ,book z fir/ pres5t$1 x 0 possible to say t 9 no degree 0 x m cumbr\s ?an t to :i* ! p 7 already accu/om$4 ,d\btless x w\ld h be5 /ill m to ! ,committee's cr$it c\ld !y h br\ght 9 an enri*$ ,book small] by a ?ird ?an ! ,book 9 use2 b ?is _! cons]vatism =bade4 ,( ev5 great] mom5t is ! o!r po9t1 :i* conc]ns ! quality ( ! available mat]ial4 ,x is ! greate/ mi/ake 9 ! _w to suppose t simply because a giv5 pray] exi/s1 say 9 an ,ori5tal liturgy1 & has be5 translat$ into ,engli% by an em95t s*ol>1 x is !re=e prop] mat]ial to be work$ into our s]vices4 ,z a matt] ( fact1 a great deal ( devotional language ( :i* ! ,ori5tal liturgies is made up is prolix & t$i\s to a degree simply insuff]able4 ,moreov] 9 ! case ( pray]s 9 !mselves admirable 9 ! orig9al tongue 9 :i* !y 7 compos$1 all is (t5 lo/ ?r\gh lack ( a v]bal felicity 9 ! translation4 ,if anyone que/ions ?is judgm5t1 let him toil ?r\gh ,neale's & ,littl$ale's ,translations ( ! ,primitive ,liturgies & see :e!r he c f9d six1 nay1 ?ree1 consecutive l9es :i* he w\ld be will+ to see introduc$ into our own ,communion ,(fice4 ,or1 z respects translations f ! ,lat9 (fice-books ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 let him scrupul\sly se>* ! pages ( ! ,s>um ,h\rs1 z done into ! v]nacul> by ! ,record] ( ,salisbury1 & see h[ _m ( ! ,collects /rike him z good en\gh to be transplant$ into ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,! result ( ?is latt] voyage ( discov]y w be an increas$ wond] at ! afflu5ce ( ! m$iaeval devotions1 comb9$ ) amazem5t at ! pov]ty & unsatisfactor9ess ( ! exi/+ translations4 ,x is ) a ,lat9 collect z ) a ,greek ode or an ,italian sonnet3 no matt] h[ wond]ful ! diction1 ! *>m ( x is z a lock$ secret until ! ?+ has be5 ,engli%$ by g5ius ak9 to 8 :o fir/ made x out ( 8 own he>t4 ,( o!rs besides ! _m brave m5 :o liv$ be=e ,agamemnon might x be writt53 s$ omnes illacrumabiles ,urg5tur1 ignotique l>ga ,nocte1 c>5t quia vate sacro4 ,x 0 ! peculi> felicity ( ,s*ill] t he _h ,col]idge = a translator1 & ! %ades ( ,gregory & ,leo owe x to a liv+ ,anglican div9e t we ,engli%-speak+ ,*ri/ians c ?9k _! ?\ghts aft] !m1 & pray _! pray]s4 ,su* be+ ! facts 9 ! case1 x is evid5t t ! range ( *oice op5 to ,am]ican revis]s is f> n>r[] ?an half-in=m$ p]sons imag9e x to be4 ,! v be/ s\rces ( liturgical mat]ial are ! foll[+3 7a7 ,k+ ,james's ,bible1 includ+ ! ,apocrypha1 & supplem5t$ by ! ,pray] ,book v]sion ( ! ,psalms2 7b7 ,! old ,sacram5t>ies1 ,leon9e1 ,gregorian1 & ,gelasian1 *iefly z illu/rat$ by ! g5ius ( ,dr4 ,bright2 7c7 ,! ,brevi>y 9 its v>i\s =ms2 7d7 ,! ,prim]s & o!r l fragm5ta ( ! era ( ! ,engli% ,re=mation2#ei 7e7 ,! devotional writ+s ( ! great ,anglican div9es ( ! s*ool ( ,&rews1 ,k51 & ,taylor2#fj & la/ & lea/1 7f7 ,! v>i\s manuals ( pray]1 ( :i* ! pa/ tw5ty ye>s h %[n !mselves s prolific4#fa ,( ! ,anglican writ]s1 ,j]emy ,taylor w\ld be by f> ! mo/ helpful1 7 x n = ! effloresc5ce ( 8 /yle4 ,z x is1 ! be/ use t c be made ( 8 exub]ant devotions is to cull f !m "h & !re a tell+ phrase or a musical cad5ce4 ,! ,g5]al ,int]cession1 = example1 on page #ej ( ,! ,book ,annex$1 is a c5to to :i* ,taylor is ! *ief contributor4 ,t ! ,enri*m5t ,committee made ! be/ possible use ( ! v>i\s qu>ries to :i* !y _h access is unlikely4 ,ev5 if !y cr$it$ !mselves ) hav+ done s1 x w\ld be immode/ ( !m to say x4 ,bett] mat]ial ?an any t _! rese>*es br\ght to light may /ill be ly+ ne> ! surface1 some:]e close at h&1 wait+ to be une>!d4 ,c]ta9ly ?is pap] w n h be5 writt5 9 va9 if x s]ves ! purpose ( provok+ to ! good "w ( discov]y "s ( ^? :o on ! score bo? ( quality & ( quantity acc\nt :at has be5 ?us f> done 9 ! l9e ( revision inadequate & meagre4 ,,iii4 ,x is next propos$ to take up ! ,philadelphia ,resolutions ( ,revision 7#ahhc7 "o by "o1 & to consid] 9 :at measure1 if 9 any1 ! subject-matt] ( ea* ( !m lies op5 to improvem5t4 ,%\ld ! me?od ( proc$ure recomm5d$ 9 ! previ\s pap]1 or any me?od resembl+ x1 f9d favor at ! approa*+ ,conv5tion1 & a ,conf]5ce ,committee ( ! two ,h\ses be appo9t$ to rem\ld ! "w ) ref]5ce to f9al action ?ree ye>s h5ce1 criticism ( ?is sort1 ev5 ?\gh inadequate1 c sc>cely fail ( be+ 9 "s measure helpful4 ,,resolution ,i4 ,! ,title-page 4 ,! proposals "u ?is head are two 9 numb]3 7a 7 t ! words1 toge!r ) ! ,psalt] or ,psalms ( ,david1 be dropp$ f ! title-page z sup]flu\s1 & 7b 7 t a g5]al title1 ,,! ,,book ,,( ,,common ,,pray]1 be pr9t$ on ! fir/ page ( ! leaf prec$+ ! title-page4 ,nei!r ( ^! sugge/ions is ( any great importance1 & ! int]e/ atta*+ to !m is ma9ly bibliographical4 ,:5ev] any addition has be5 made to ! ,pray] ,book ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 ! rule has be5 to note x inv>iably 9 ! ,table ( ,cont5ts1 & sometimes also on ! title-page4 ,until #affb ! ,psalt] =m$ no "p ( ! ,pray] ,book2 x 0 a volume by itself1 & 0 cit$ z su*4 ,9 fact1 x 0 a sort ( ,hymnal ,companion to ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,9 ! revision ( #affb ! ,psalt] 0 incorporat$1 & imm$iately !re appe>$ ^u ! title-page ( ! ,common ,pray]1 9 addition to :at _h be5 !re be=e1 ! words1 toge!r ) ! ,psalt] or ,psalms ( ,david pr9t$ z !y are to be sung or read 9 ! *ur*es4 ,! pres5t title-page ( ! ,engli% ,book has a s+ul>ly cr[d$ & awkw>d look1 contra/+ mo/ unfavorably 9 ?is reg>d ) ^? ( #aeei1 #aeeb1 & #aedi4fb ,b if ! ne$less m5tion ( ! ,psalt] on our pres5t title-page gives pleasure to any consid]able numb] ( p1 x w\ld be fooli% to press ! sugge/ion ( a *ange4 ,let x pass4 ,( a m s]i\s "* w\ld be ! omission1 :i* "s urge1 ( ! words ,prote/ant ,episcopal f ! title-page4 ,%\ld any?+ ( ?is sort be done1 :i* is mo/ unlikely1 ,dr4 ,eg>'s sugge/ion to drop ! words1 ( ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur*1 leav+ x to read1 accord+ to ! use 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica1 w\ld c>ry ! bett] note ( ca?olicity4 ,b1 aft] all1 ! remon/rants h only to turn ! page to f9d ! obnoxi\s ,prote/ant ,episcopal s fa/ rivet$ into ! ,ratification t no?+ %ort ( an act ( viol5ce done to hi/ory c\ld accompli% ! excision ( x4#fc ,,resolution ,,ii4 ,! ,introductory ,portion4 7a7 ,table ( ,cont5ts4--,! sugge/ion#fd t all entries aft] ,! ,psalt] %\ld be pr9t$ 9 italics1 is a good "o4 7b7 ,conc]n+ ! ,s]vice ( ! ,*ur*4--,?is sub/itute = ! pres5t ,ord] h[ ! ,psalt] is appo9t$ to be read & ,ord] h[ ! re/ ( ! ,holy ,scripture is appo9t$ to be read is l>gely bas$ on ! provisions ( ! s-call$ ,%ort5$ ,s]vices ,act ( #ahgb4 ,! second p>agraph relat+ to ! use ( ! ,litany appe>s to be sup]flu\s4 ,! enl>g$ ,table ( ,prop] ,psalms & ! ,table ( ,selections ( ,psalms1 :i* come "u ?is same g5]al head+1 w\ld be a v great ga94 ,:y ! ,m>yl& ,committee %\ld h pron\nc$ ! latt] ,table practically useless1 s9ce ! psalms are n to be pr9t$1 x is h>d1 9 ! face ( ! exi/+ usage ) respect to ,prop] ,psalms1 to und]/&2 nor is !re any special felicity 9 ! proposal emanat+ f ! same s\rce t ! numb] ( ! ,selections be cut d[n to ?ree1 "o = fea/s & "o = fa/s & "o = an extra s]vice on ,sunday nights4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ! ,m>yl& ,committee does well 9 recomm5d+ t p]mission be giv5 to ! m9i/] to %ort5 ! ,lessons at 8 discretion1 ?\gh ! h>d & fa/ condition1 provid$ he read n less ?an fifte5 consecutive v]ses1 ap>t f ! que/ionable ,engli% 9 :i* x is phras$1 smacks m ( ! drill-room ?an ( ! sanctu>y4 ,f> bett] w\ld x be 7if ! sugge/ion may be v5tur$7 to all[ no lib]ty ( abridgm5t :atev] 9 ! case ( ,prop] ,lessons1 :ile giv+ entire fre$om ( *oice on all occasions = :i* no prop] lessons h be5 appo9t$4 ,s f> z f]ial days are conc]n$1 x w\ld be mu* wis] to let ! ,table ( ,lessons be reg>d$ z sugge/ive & n m&atory4 ,! half-way recognition ( ?is pr9ciple 9 ! new ,lection>y1 9 :i* su* a fre$om is all[$1 provid$ ! ,lesson tak5 be "o ( ^? appo9t$ = "s day 9 ! same week1 seems op5 to a suspicion ( *ildi%ness4 ,! rubrical direction entitl$ ,hymns & ,an!ms requires v]bal correction1 b embodies a :olesome pr9ciple4 ,"u ?is same g5]al head ( ,! ,introductory ,portion come ! new ,lection>y & ! new ,tables = f9d+ ,ea/]4 ,( ^!1 ! =m] is law already1 except s f> z respects ! ,lessons appo9t$ = ! propos$ ,fea/ ( ! ,transfiguration4 ,! ,ea/] ,tables are a monum5t to ! erudition & accuracy ( ! late ,dr4 ,francis ,h>ison4 ,! ,tables 9 our pres5t ,/&>d run to ! ye> #ahii4 ,p]haps a :olesome cons]vatism ought to discov] a t9cture ( impiety 9 any proposal to di/urb !m be=e ! c5tury has expir$4 ,,resolution ,,iii4 ,! ,morn+ ,pray]4 7a7 ,! ,fir/ ,rubric4--,! ,m>yl& ,committee is q "r 9 rem>k+ t ! language ( ?is important rubric1 z set =? by ! ,conv5tion ( #ahhc1 is inelegant & inaccurate1 b ano!r diocese has call$ att5tion to ! fact t ! sub/itute :i* ,m>yl& (f]s w\ld1 if adopt$1 enable any rector :o might be s m9d$ to )hold entirely f ! non-communicat+ portion ( 8 flock all opportunity = public confession & absolution f ye>'s end to ye>'s end4 ,x is n = a mom5t to be suppos$ t !re 0 any cov]t int5tion "h1 b ! incid5t illu/rates ! value to rubric-mak]s ( ! ,horatian w>n+--,brevis esse labor o1 obscurus fio4 ,pass+ by ! ,prop] ,s5t5ces = special ,days & ,seasons1 aga9/ :i* no s]i\s compla9t has be5 ent]$1#fe we come to ! propos$ %ort alt]native = ! ,decl>ation ( ,absolution4 ,z x /ood 9 ! ,s>um ,use ?is ,absolution ran z foll[s3 ,! ,almighty & ,m]ciful ,"l grant y ,absolution & ,remission ( all y\r s9s1 space = true p5it5ce1 am5dm5t ( life1 & ! grace & consolation ( ! ,holy ,_s4 ,am54#ff ,) ! s+le *ange ( ! ^w p5it5ce to rep5tance ?is is ! =m 9 :i* ! ,absolution /ood 9 ! orig9al ,book ,annex$4 ,! ,conv5tion ?\ght t x detect$ a ,romaniz+ g]m 9 ! place assign$ to p5it5ce1 & an ar*aism 9 ! temporal s5se assign$ to space1 & accord+ly re>rang$ ! :ole s5t5ce4 ,b 9 _! ef=t to m5d ! language1 our legislators assur$ly m>r$ ! music4#fg 7e7 ,! ,b5$ictus es1 ,dom9e4--,! ins]tion ( ?is ,canticle z an alt]nate to ! ,te ,deum 0 9 ! int]e/ ( %ort5$ s]vices = week-day use1 z has be5 already expla9$4 ,! same purpose c\ld be s]v$ equally well1 & ! always objectionable exp$i5t ( a second alt]nate avoid$1 by spac+ (f ! la/ six v]ses ( ! ,b5$icite1 :i* h an integrity ( _! own1 & prefix+ a rubric simil> to ^? t /& be=e ! ,v5ite & ! ,b5$ictus 9 ,! ,book ,annex$2 e4 g43 ,on week-days1 x %all suffice if only ! latt] portion ( ?is ,canticle be said or sung4 7n7 ,! ,b5$ictus4--,) ref]5ce to ! re/oration ( ! la/ portion ( ?is ,hymn1 x has be5 v prop]ly rem>k$ by "o ( ! critics ( ,! ,book ,annex$1 t ! l9e ( division betwe5 ! requir$ & ! optional portions w\ld m prop]ly come aft] ! eigh? ?an aft] ! f\r? v]se4 ,?is w\ld make ! portion res]v$ = ,adv5t beg9 ) ! ref]5ce to ,john ! ,bapti/1 z und\bt$ly x ought to d3 ,& ?\1 *ild1 %alt be call$ ! ,prophet ( ! ,highe/4 7o7 ,de ,pr(undis4--,!re w probably be g5]al cons5t to ! omission ( ?is alt]nate1 z be+ :at ! ,m>yl& ,committee naively call x1 too m\rnful a psalm = ?is purpose4#fh ,,resolution ,,iv4 ,daily ,ev5+ ,pray]4 7c7 ,! propos$ words1 ,let u humbly confess our s9s unto ,almighty ,god1 are ju/ly ?\ght by _m to be inf]ior bo? 9 rhy?m & 9 dignity to ,let u make humble confession to ,almighty ,god4 7i7-7l7 ,!re seems to be absolute unanimity 9 ! judgm5t t ,magnificat & ,nunc ,dimittis ought1 z ,gospel ,hymns1 to h ! prior places aft] ! ,lessons :i* !y foll[4 ,9 ! int]e/ ( simplicity ( arrangem5t a l g5]al cons5t to omit altoge!r ,bonum e/ confit]i & ,b5$ic anima mea w\ld be mo/ =tunate1 b ?is po9t has be5 already enl>g$ ^u 9 a previ\s pap]4#fi ,! ,notes1 p]mitt+ ! use ( ,psalms xlii4 & xliii4 aft] ! ,lessons dur+ ,l5t1 seem to h f\nd no favor 9 any qu>t]1 & ought und\bt$ly to be dropp$4 7n7 ,if ! lo/ v]sicles are to be re/or$ aft] ! ,cre$1 z all :o h le>n$ to love !m 9 ! s]vice ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& mu/ e>ne/ly desire1 "s bett] sub/itute = ,god save ! que51 ?an ,o ,"l1 save our rul]s1 ought surely to be f\nd4#gj ,moreov]1 ! ord] ( ! v]sicles1 z ,pr(4 ,gold has cle>ly po9t$ out1#ga is op5 to improvem5t4 ,,resolution ,v4 ,! ,beatitudes ( ! ,gospel4 ,?is is ! "o feature ( ,! ,book ,annex$ aga9/ :i* ! fire ( ho/ile criticism has be5 ! mo/ p]si/5tly direct$4 ,:e!r ! /rictures pass$ ^u ! ,(fice h be5 9 all cases z intellig5t z !y h be5 sev]e1 may be op5 to "q1 b !re c be no d\bt :atev] t1 9 its pres5t =m1 ,resolution ,v4 w\ld1 if put to ! vote1 be reject$4 ,pass+ by ! m viol5t utt]ances ( ^? ^: language almo/ sugge/s t !y f9d some?+ objectionable 9 ! v ,,beatitudes !mselves1#gb x w suffice to consid] & weigh :at has be5 said 9 v>i\s qu>t]s1 fir/1 ab\t ! unprec$5t$ "* ( ! ,(fice1 & secondly1 conc]n+ ! infelicity ( ! appo9t$ response1 ,"l1 h m]cy ^u u1 & be x unto ?y s]vants accord+ to ?y ^w4 ,s f> z conc]ns prec$5t1 x ought to be en\gh to say t ! words are our ,"l's words1 & t !y 7 ?r[n by him into a =m :i* readily l5ds itself to antiphonal use4 ,! v same *>act]i/ics ( p>allelism & anti!sis1 t make ! ,psalms s am5able to ! purposes ( wor%ip1 are conspicu\s 9 ! ,,beatitudes4 ,if ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 = ?ree hundr$ ye>s1 has be5 will+ to give place 9 h] devotions to ! ,curses ( ! ,old ,te/am5t1#gc we ( ,am]ica ne$ n to be afraid1 prec$5t or no prec$5t1 to make room among our =mul>ies = ! ,bless+s ( ! ,new4 ,^? :o all[ !mselves to *>act]ize ! liturgical use ( ^! memorable say+s ( ! ,son ( ,man z fancy ritual & s5tim5talism may well pause to ask !mselves :at mann] ( _s !y are (4 ,! ,,beatitudes are ! *>t] ( ! k+dom ( heav54 ,if !y are s5tim5tal1 ! k+dom is s5tim5tal2 b if1 on ! o!r h&1 !y con/itute ! organic law ( ! ,p ( ,god1 !y h at lea/ z fair a "r z ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts to be publi%$ f ! alt>1 & answ]$ by ! great congregation4 ,b is ! compla9t ( no prec$5t a valid "o1 ev5 suppos+ consid]ations ( intr9sic fitness to h be5 rul$ out8 ,! ,liturgy ( ,/4 ,*ryso/om provides t ! ,beatitudes %all be sung on ,sundays 9 room ( ! ?ird antiphon4#gd ,! le>n$ ,bi%op ( ,haiti1 9 a pap] w>mly comm5d+ ! liturgical use ( ! ,,beatitudes1#ge calls att5tion to ! fur!r fact t ! ,eight ,say+s h a place 9 "s ( ! s]vice-books ( ! ,ea/]n ,*ur* 9 ! ,(fice = ! ,six? & ,n9? ,h\rs1 & notes ! sugge/ive & t\*+ circum/ances t1 z !re us$1 !y h = a response ! words ( ! p5it5t ?ief ^u ! cross4 ,we might all ( u well pray to be rememb]$ 9 t k+dom to :i* ^! ,bless+s give ! law4 ,9 ,! ,prim] set =? by ! ,k+'s ,maje/y & 8 ,cl]gy 9 #aede1 a sort ( /epp+-/one to ! lat] ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 we f9d ! ,,beatitudes v +5i\sly work$ into ! ,(fice ( ,! ,h\rs1 z an!ms2 beg9n+ ) ,prime & end+ ) ,ev5song4 ,appropriate ,collects are int]wov51 "s ( !m s beautiful z to be well wor? pres]v+4#gf ,b ! mo/ int]e/+ prec$5t ( all rema9s /ill to be /udi$4 ,9 ! fir/ ye> ( ! reign ( ,william & ,m>y1 a ,royal ,commission 0 appo9t$ to revise ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,! mo/ em95t ,anglican div9es ( ! day1 includ+ ,tillotson1 ,/ill+fleet1 ,patrick1 & ,bev]idge1 7 among ! memb]s4 ,to all outw>d appe>ance ! movem5t came to naught2 = ! propos$ revision 0 n ev5 put into pr9t1 until 9 #ahed1 ! ,h\se ( ,commons1 9 response to a motion ( ,mr4 ,heywood1 ord]$ x to be publi%$ z a ,blue-book4 ,& yet 9 "s way our ,am]ican revis]s ( #aghi mu/ h f\nd access to ! orig9al volume z x lay hidd5 9 ! ar*bi%op's libr>y at ,lambe?2 = n only does _! "w %[ probable evid5ce ( su* consultation1 b 9 _! ,preface !y di/9ctly ref] to ! ef=t ( ,k+ ,william's ,commission z a great & good "w1#gg a ?+ !y w\ld sc>cely h done _h !y possess$ no real k ( ! facts4 ,macaulay's sne]+ ref]5ce to ! "w ( ! ,commission is well kn[n1 b1 /rangely en\gh1 ! ju/ice :i* a ,:ig review] )holds1 a high ,anglican div9e conc$es1 = no less exact+ a critic ?an ,dr4 ,neale1 :ile manife/+1 z 0 to be expect$1 a g5]al dislike ( ! ,commission]s ( #afhi1 & ( _! "w1 does yet f9d some?+ to praise 9 :at !y recomm5d$4#gh ,among ! real improvem5ts sugge/$ by ! ,commission 0 ! liturgical use ( ! ,,beatitudes1 & ?is 9 two places1 once 9 ,! ,ord] = ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp]1 z an alt]nate to ! ,t5 ,comm&m5ts2 & aga9 9 ! ,comm9ation ,(fice z a prop] balance to ! ,ana!mas ( ! ,law4 ,b ! ,commission1 l ! late ,jo9t ,committee on ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 0 un=tunate 9 its *oice ( a response2 & no wond]1 = ! task ( f9d+ ! prop] "o is difficult4#gi ,a ,beatitude diff]s f a ,comm&m5t 9 t :ile ! latt] enjo9s ! =m] only decl>es4 ,! "o !re=e simply calls = ass5t1 or1 at mo/1 ass5t c\pl$ ) petition1 :ile ! o!r p]emptorily dem&s a cry = m]cy4 ,! immemorial =m ( ! cry = m]cy 9 ! devotions ( ,*ri/5dom is ! ,kyrie eleison1 ,"l1 h m]cy ^u u2 ! immemorial =m ( ass5t ! ^w ,am54 ,c we d bett]1 !re=e1 9 adapt+ ! ,,beatitudes to liturgical use ?an to treat !m precisely z ! ,curses are treat$ 9 ! ,comm9ation ,(fice ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 namely1 by ins]t+ aft] ea* "o ( !m a pla9 ,am54 ,?is recomm5dation has ! great m]it ( simplicity4 ,two or ?ree /rik+ly +5i\s s*emes = supply+ ea* ( ! ,eight ,say+s ) a prop] response ( its own h be5 sugge/$2#hj b ! objection to !m is t1 beautiful ?\gh !y are1 _! complexity w\ld emb>rass & di/ress ! kneel+ wor%ipp]4 ,9 ^! matt]s1 practical drawbacks h to be tak5 into acc\nt z well z ab/ract excell5cies1 & no matt] h[ felicit\s ! antiphonal responses1 !y w\ld be worse ?an useless 7 a puzzl$ congregation to refuse to jo9 9 !m4 ,!re w be f\nd app5d$ to ?is ,pap] a plan = reca/+ ! ,(fice ( ! ,,beatitudes 9 su* a way z to make x co9cide /ructurally1 z f> z x goes1 ) ! introductory portion ( ! ,holy ,communion4#ha ,7 ! ,(fice to be ?us set =?1 x w\ld be possible on week-days1 & ) s+ul> appropriat5ess on ,sa9ts' ,days1 to sub/itute ! ,,beatitudes = ! ,comm&m5ts1 )\t encumb]+ ! ,communion ,(fice ) an alt]nate4 ,%\ld ?is sugge/ion f9d acceptance1 ! two ,collects 9 ! pres5t ,(fice ( ,,beatitudes1 :i* are f> too good to be lo/1 "o ( !m be+ ! modifi$ =m ( a ,leon9e orig9al1 & ! o!r "o ( ! v be/ ( ,canon ,bright's own compositions1 might be transf]r$ to a place among ! ,occasional ,pray]s4 ,,resolution ,,vi4 ,! ,litany4 ,! rubrics prefix$ to ! ,litany are a ga91 b except by ! addition ( ! two new suffrages1 ! "o = ! ,presid5t & ! o!r = ! increase ( ! m9i/ry1 x w probably be be/ to leave ! text ( ?is =mul>y unt\*$4 ,ev5 9 ! case ( ! new petitions x w\ld be well if !y c\ld be graft$ ^u suffrages already exi/+1 a ?+ t might easily be done4#hb ,x w\ld be a liturgical improvem5t if ! ,litany1 9 its %ort5$ =m1 7 to end at ! ,*ri/e1 audi1 & ! m9i/] direct$ to return1 at ?is po9t1 to ! ,g5]al ,?anksgiv+ 9 ! ,morn+ ,pray]4 ,?is w\ld divide ! ,litany symmetrically1 in/ead ( arbitr>ily1 z is n[ done1 & w\ld remove ! ,g5]al ,?anksgiv+ f a place to :i* x has little claim ei!r by hi/orical prec$5t or natural congruity4 ,! greate/ improvem5t ( all w\ld be ! re/oration ( ! augu/ & massive words ( invocation :i* ( old /ood at ! beg9n+ ( ! ,litany4 ,! mod]n invocations h a dignity ( _! own1 b !y are n to be comp>$ = devotional p[] & simple maje/y ) ! m anci5t ones4 ,b = an enri*m5t s good z ?is1 x is too mu* to hope4 ,,resolution ,,vii4 ,pray]s & ,?anksgiv+s4 ,! ,m>yl& ,committee#hc h mu* to say 9 criticism ( ?is section1 & (f] _m valuable sugge/ions1 ! be/ ( !m be+ a recomm5dation to pr9t ! ,pray] entitl$1 ,= ,grace to speak ! ,tru? 9 ,love1 9 ,canon ,bright's own words4 ,"s ( _! comm5ts1 on ! o!r h&1 sugge/ canons ( criticism :i*1 if appli$ to ,! ,pray] ,book z x is1 w\ld make havoc ( its *oice/ treasures4#hd ,! ,committee ( ,c5tral ,new ,york#he g mu* fur!r 9 ! l9e ( de/ructive criticism ?an _! bre?r5 ( ,m>yl&1 & aft] except+ f\r ( ! propos$ pray]s1 condemn all ! re/ to dismissal4 ,possibly ?is is j judgm5t1 b ^? :o h se>*$ dilig5tly ! /oreh\ses ( devotional ,engli%1 w ?9k twice be=e !y cons5t to x4 ,no d\bt ! phraseology ( "s ( ! propos$ pray]s might be improv$4 ,9 view ( ! se>*+ criticism to :i* = ?ree ye>s x has be5 expos$1 x w\ld be /range inde$ if su* 7 n f\nd to be ! case4 ,b ! collection z a :ole1 in/ead ( suff]+ loss1 ought to receive increm5t4 ,at lea/ ?ree or f\r m pray]s = ! "w ( missions 9 its v>i\s aspects ought to be add$1 also a ,pray] = ! fur!rance ( ,*ri/ian ,education 9 ,s*ools & ,colleges4 ,z ,br4 ,d[d5 %rewdly asks1 9 speak+ ( spiritual ne$s :i* we po/pone express+ = lack ( language suffici5tly arti/ic 9 =m1 ,:at is ! measure ( our fai? 9 ! efficacy ( unit$ pray]1 :5 we are cont5t to g on1 ye> aft] ye>1 & nev] come toge!r to ask ,god to supply ^? ne$s8#hf ,!re is "o consid]ation connect$ ) ?is supply ( special pray]s too frequ5tly lo/ out ( sight4 ,:ile x is p]fectly true t ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] 0 nev] design$ to be a ,treasury ( ,devotion = individuals1 x is equally true t = ?\s&s & hundr$s ( ?\s&s ( our fell[-c\ntrym5 :o live remote f ,*ur* book-/ores1 or lack ! means ( patroniz+ !m1 ! ,pray] ,book is1 z a matt] ( fact1 _! only devotional help4 ,9 c\ntless h\seholds1 moreov]1 _m ( !m beyond ,prote/ant ,episcopal bord]s altoge!r1 ! ,pray] ,book is do+ a "w only less b5efic5t ?an x might d1 7 we to conc$e a v little m to t outw>dly illogical b spiritually self-consi/5t policy :i*1 break+ away1 a c5tury ago1 f ! *a9 ( prec$5t1 ins]t$ 9 ! ,am]ican ,book ,! ,=ms ( ,pray] to be us$ 9 ,families4 ,,resolution ,,viii4 ,p5it5tial ,(fice = ,a%-,w$nesday4 ,?is is ! ,engli% ,comm9ation ,(fice1 ) ! introductory portion omitt$4 ,x w\ld add to ! m]it ( ! =mul>y1 especially :5 us$ z a sep>ate (fice1 7 x to be prefac$ by ! v]sicle & response1 simil>ly employ$ 9 ! ,h]e=d ,brevi>y3 ,v4 ,let u confess unto ! ,"l1 = he is graci\s4 ,r4 ,& 8 m]cy endure? =ev]4 ,9 view ( ! great l5g? ( ! ,morn+ ,s]vice on ,a%-,w$nesday1 & ! close simil>ity betwe5 ! clos+ portion ( ! ,litany & ! int]m$iate portion ( ?is ,(fice1 ! foll[+ em5dation ( ! fir/ ,rubric is sugge/$1 a *ange :i* w\ld c>ry ) x ! omission ( ! ,rubric aft] psalm li4 a little fur!r on4 ,on ! ,fir/ ,day ( ,l5t1 at ,morn+ ,pray]1 ! ,(fice ensu+ %all be read imm$iately aft] ! words1 ,h m]cy ^u u1 9 ! ,litany1 & 9 place ( :at !re foll[e?4 ,9 ! ?ird ,rubric x might be well to add to %all be said ! words1 or sung4 ,! bless+ at ! end ( ! (fice %\ld /&1 z 9 ! ,engli% ,book1 9 ! precatory =m2 o!rwise we might h ! anomaly ( a b5$iction pron\nc$ be=e ! end ( ! s]vice4 ,,resolution ,,ix4 ,?anksgiv+-day or ,h>ve/-home4 ,! only alt]ation ne$$ 9 ?is (fice is ! re/oration ( ! beautiful pray] = unity to its own prop] word+ z giv5 9 ! s-call$ ,accession ,s]vice app5d$ to ! ,engli% ,pray] ,book4 ,z x /&s 9 ,! ,book ,annex$ ! language ( ! pray] is possibly ungrammatical & c]ta9ly r$undant4 ,a critic1 already m ?an once quot$1#hg prote/s aga9/ ! prom95ce giv5 to ?is (fice 9 ,! ,book ,annex$1 ascrib+ x to influ5ces born ( ! associations ( ,new ,engl&4 ,b al?\gh ! motive ( ! revis]s might h _h a worse orig9 ?an t ( :i* ! review] compla9s1 ! actual fact is t ! =mul>y 0 plac$ :]e x is purely 9 consid]ation ( ! liturgical fitness ( ?+s2 x hav+ be5 held t ! prop] position = an ,(fice ( ,?anksgiv+ mu/ be 9 imm$iate sequ5ce to an ,(fice ( ,p5it5ce4 ,x is ) s9c]e diffid5ce t ! pres5t writ] diff]s ) ,! ,sem9>ian1 on a po9t ( hi/orical prec$5t1 b he v5tures to sugge/ t to f9d ! prototype ( ,h>ve/-home we mu/ g back f> beyond ,new ,engl&1 & = t matt] f> beyond ,old ,engl&1 nay1 beyond ! ,*ri/ian era itself1 ev5 to ! day :5 x 0 said1 ,?\ %alt obs]ve ! ,fea/ ( ,tab]nacles1 sev5 days1 aft] t ?\ ha/ ga!r$ 9 ?y corn & ?y w9e4 ,d\btless !re is a joy great] ?an ! joy ( h>ve/1 & to ?is we give expression 9 ! ,eu*>i/2 b d\btless also ! joy ( h>ve/ is 9 itself a prop] joy & "o :i* f9ds fitt+ utt]ance 9 su* =ms ( pray] & praise z ?is4 ,,resolution ,,xi4 ,collects1 ,epi/les1 & ,gospels4 ,no dep>tm5t ( liturgical revision calls = a nic] t\* ?an t :i* includes ! ,collects4 ,t new collects = c]ta9 unsuppli$ fea/s & fa/s w\ld be a g5u9e enri*m5t ( ,! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 has long be5 g5]ally ackn[l$g$ among ,anglican s*ol>s4 ,! mo/ weighty fault to be f\nd ) ! collects add$ by ! revis]s is t 9 too l>ge proportion !y are address$ to ! second & ?ird ,p]sons ( ! ,holy ,tr9ity4 ,! ,eu*>i/ itself1 z a :ole1 is prop]ly conceiv$ ( z address$ to ! ,et]nal ,fa!r4 ,! ,collects1 z =m+ "p ( ! ,eu*>i/ic ,(fice1 ought1 /rictly speak+1 to be also s address$4 ,x is true t !re are exceptions to ?is rule1 & !y are f\nd1 "s ( !m1 9 ! ,pray] ,book z x is4 ,b ! revis]s ought n to h alt]$ ! proportion s m>k$ly z !y h done1 = :]eas 9 our pres5t ,book ! collects address$ to ! ,fa!r are z eighty-?ree to ?ree comp>$ ) ^? n s address$1 ! ratio 9 ,! ,book ,annex$ is t ( elev5 to ?ree4 ,moreov]1 !re w\ld seem to be no good reason = rev]t+ to ! usage ( ! ,fir/ ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi41 :i* provides a second ,collect1 ,epi/le1 & ,gospel = ! two great fea/s ( ,*ri/mas & ,ea/]4 ,a bett] way w\ld be to take ^! additional collects1 :i* are among ! mo/ beautiful 9 ! language1 & assign !m respectively to ! ,sunday aft] ,*ri/mas1 & ! ,monday 9 ,ea/]-week4 ,,resolution ,,xii4 ,! ,holy ,communion4 ,to ! few *anges propos$ 9 ?is ,(fice1 comp>atively slight exception has be5 tak5 9 any qu>t]4 ,x w probably be wise to leave ! language ( ! ,pray] ( ,consecration :olly unt\*$1 not)/&+ ! alleg$ grammatical error ne> ! end ( x4 ,! ,rubric :i* x has be5 propos$ to app5d to ! ,(fice1 t\*+ ! numb] ( communicants )\t :i* x %all n be lawful to adm9i/] ! ,sacram5t1 be+ ( a discipl9>y r ?an ( a liturgical "*1 ought n to be urg$4 ,! proposal to transf] ! ,pray] ( ,humble ,access to a place imm$iately be=e ! ,communion appe>s to be v g5]ally acceptable4 ,x w\ld relieve _m wor%ipp]s :o scruple z ,*ri/ians at respond+ to ! ,f\r? ,comm&m5t on ! score ( its ,judaic "*1 if ! language ( ! rubric prefix$ to ! ,decalogue c\ld conta91 z did ! correspond+ rubric 9 ,laud's ,book = ,scotl&1 a clause indicative ( ! my/ical & spiritual s5se 9 :i* ! ,law %\ld be int]pret$ by ^? :o live "u ! ,gospel4 ,b su* a proposal w\ld probably be acc\nt$ ( doctr9e1 & s be self-condemn$4 ,( ! desirability ( all[+ a week-day use ( ! ,,beatitudes 9 ! room ( ! ,,comm&m5ts en\gh has be5 already said4 ,,resolution ,,xvi4 ,confirmation4 ,! p]mission to use a =m ( pres5tation in/ead (1 or 9 addition to1 ! ,preface is likely to be widely welcom$4 ,! o!r add5da to ?is (fice1 be+ app>5tly di/a/eful 7= unlike reasons7 to all ! s*ools ( ?\ghts 9 ! ,*ur*1 are likely to fail ( acceptance2 & on ! :ole may easily be sp>$4 ,,resolution ,,xviii4 ,visitation ( ! ,sick4 ,! propos$ ,comm5datory ,pray]1 ?\gh 9 "s ( its features /rik+ly felicit\s1 is op5 to =mal improvem5t4 ,! addition ( a %ort ,litany ( ! ,dy+ w\ld be appreciat$ by ^? ^: m9i/ry is l>gely ex]cis$ among ! sick4 ,,resolution ,,xx4 ,burial ( ! ,dead4 ,by f> ! mo/ important section ( ?is ,resolution is ! "o provid+ = ! ins]tion ( special features :5 ! (fice is us$ at ! burial ( *ildr54 ,! provision1 or at lea/ ! sugge/ion1 ( a m appropriate ,lesson w\ld be wise1 b = ! re/1 ! (fice is almo/ all t c\ld be wi%$4 ,a rec5t critic#hh raises ! "q1 ,:y s+le out infants alone = a special s]vice8 ,:y n =ms = ri* m5 & poor m5--old m5 & maid5s--wid[s & orphans8 ,& yet our ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/ did s+le out little *ildr5 9 a v /rik+ & wond]ful mann]1 & drew a di/9ction betwe5 !m & u :i* may well ju/ify our treat+ _! obsequies ) a peculi> t5d]ness4 ,ev5 ,rome1 ,mat] dura infantum z %e has be5 sometimes ?\ght1 is /udi\s to consult 9 ?is po9t ! natural affections ( ! b]eav$1 & appo9ts a fun]al mass di/9ct f t appo9t$ = ! dead 9 g5]al4 ,bi%op ,seabury felt ! ne$ ( a rite ( ?is sort & prep>$ "o1 b :e!r x 0 ev] 9 actual use among ! cl]gy ( ,connecticut ! writ] is n in=m$4 ,_m1 v _m1 s9ce ,seabury's day1 h felt ! same ne$1 & x is safe to say t no "o feature ( ,! ,book ,annex$ has enjoy$ s univ]sal a welcome z ?is rightful concession to ! dem&s ( ! p>5tal he>t4 ,,conclusion4 ,! survey ( corrig5da is n[ complete4 ,! li/ looks l a long "o1 b really ! po9ts not$ are few comp>$ ) ^? :i* h pass$ un*all5g$4 ,"h & !re 9 ! ,resolutions t h n be5 consid]$ are words or phrases t admit ( improvem5t1 & :i* 9 an actual & au?oriz$ re-review by a ,committee ( ,conf]5ce w\ld und\bt$ly be improv$4 ,! bulk ( ! "w has1 = a p]iod ( ?ree ye>s1 /ood ! incessant fire ( a n always fri5dly criticism f> bett] ?an c\ld h be5 anticipat$ by ^? :o 9 ! fir/ in/ance gave x %ape4 ,! difficulties ( ! task h be5 imm5se4 ,t !y h n all ( !m be5 successfully ov]come is cle> en\gh1 b t !y 7 fac$ ) an hone/ purpose to be j & fair1 & t ?is purpose 0 clung to p]si/5tly ?r\gh\t1 is a cr$it :i* ,*ur*m5 ( ! next g5]ation w n )hold f ^? :o s\ght to be ( s]vice to !m4 ,x rema9s to be se5 :e!r ! repres5tatives ( ! ,*ur* w take up ?is "w & p]fect x2 or p] contra 9 response to ! dem& = a ,commission ( ,exp]ts1 or ! speci\s b utt]ly impracticable#hi proposal ( conc]t$ action ) ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 w decide to po/pone ! :ole affair to ! ,greek ,kal5ds4 ,"o ?+ is c]ta91 to wit1 t ! dea? ( ?is movem5t w mean inaction = at lea/ a qu>t] ( a c5tury4 ,! m5 d n live :o w h ! c\rage to emb>k on a fre% ent]prise ( ! l purport :ile ! %ipwreck ( ?is "o is be=e _! eyes4 ,!re are _m :o1 out ( a consci5ti\s fe> ( di/urb+ :at !y l to ?9k ( z p]man5tly settl$1 w\ld view su* a conclusion ( ! :ole matt] ) pr(\nd gratitude to ,god4 ,b !re are _m m to :om su* a confession ( ! ,*ur*'s inability to appreciate & unwill+ness to meet ! spiritual ne$s ( a civilization wond]fully unlike any?+ t has prec$$ x w\ld be mo/ di%e>t5+4 ,lea/ ( all is !re valid gr\nd = hope 9 ! case ( ^? :o fancy t if !y c only annihilate ?is project1 ! day w spe$ily come :5 !y c revise ! ,pray] ,book 9 a mann] p]fectly con=mable to _! own conception ( ! ,ideal ,liturgy1 & aft] a fa%ion :i* ! mo/ ard5t ,anglo-,ca?olic mu/ fa9 approve4 ,! ,am]ican ,book ( ,common ,pray] be>s ! impress to-day ( two controll+ m9ds1 ! m9d ( ,seabury & ! m9d ( ,:ite4 ,d\btless x /ood writt5 9 ! c\ncils ( ! ,div9e ,provid5ce t s x %\ld be4 ,! two m5 repres5t$ respectively ! two modes ( appreh5d+ spiritual tru? :i* h always be5 all[$ c\nt]play & int]action 9 ! hi/ory ( ,engli% religion1 & :i* always w be all[$ su* c\nt]play & int]action :ile ,engli% religion rema9s ! compreh5sive ?+ x is4 ,no s*eme ( liturgical revision1 no matt] h[ sci5tifically con/ruct$1 w ev] f9d acceptance ) ! p ( ?is ,*ur* :i* does n d ev5-h&$ ju/ice to bo? ( ! great hi/oric gr[?s :i* f9d _! common root 9 ,anglican soil4 ,:5 ! _s ( ,seabury %all h completely exorcis$ ! _s ( ,:ite1 or ! _s ( ,:ite %all h completely exorcis$ ! _s ( ,seabury f ! ,*ur* & f ! ,pray] ,book1 logic w h triumph$1 z sixte5 ye>s ago x triumph$ "u ! dome ( ,/4 ,pet]'s--logical consi/5cy w h triumph$1 b ca?olicity w h fl$4 ,,note4 ,,! ,,beatitudes ,,( ,,! ,,gospel4 ,on ,*ri/mas-day1 ,ea/]-day1 & ,:itsunday1 & on any week-day save ,a%-,w$nesday & ,good ,friday1 ?is ,(fice may be us$ 9 lieu ( s mu* ( ,! ,ord] = ! ,adm9i/ration ( ! ,"l's ,supp] z prec$e? ! ,epi/le = ! ,day4 ,?is ,(fice may also be us$ sep>ately on occasions = :i* no prop] ,ord] ha? be5 provid$4 ,! ,m9i/] /&+ up %all say ! ,"l's ,pray] & ! ,collect foll[+1 ! ,p kneel+1 b ! ,"l's ,pray] may be omitt$ if x ha? be5 said imm$iately be=e4 ,our ,fa!r1 :o art 9 heav51 ,hall[$ be ?y ,"n4 ,?y k+dom come4 ,?y w be done on e>?1 ,z x is 9 heav54 ,give u ?is day our daily bread4 ,& =give u our trespasses1 ,z we =give ^? :o trespass aga9/ u4 ,& lead u n into temptation2 ,b deliv] u f evil4 ,am54 ,! ,collect4 ,almighty ,god1 unto :om all he>ts are op51 all desires kn[n1 & f :om no secrets are hid2 ,cleanse ! ?\ghts ( our he>ts by ! inspiration ( ?y ,holy ,_s1 t we may p]fectly love !e1 & wor?ily magnify ?y holy ,"n2 ?r\gh ,*ri/ our ,"l4 ,am54 ,!n %all ! ,m9i/]1 turn+ to ! ,p1 rehe>se ! ,eight ,say+s ( our ,"l commonly call$ ,,! ,,beatitudes2 & ! ,p1 /ill kneel+1 %all aft] e "o ( !m rev]5tly say ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,jesus w5t up into a m\nta92 & 8 disciples came unto him4 ,& he op5$ 8 m\? & taught !m1 say+3 ,bless$ are ! poor 9 _s2 = !irs is ! k+dom ( heav54 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,bless$ are !y t m\rn2 = !y %all be com=t$4 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,bless$ are ! meek2 = !y %all inh]it ! e>?4 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,bless$ are !y :i* d hung] & ?ir/ aft] righte\sness2 = !y %all be fill$4 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,bless$ are ! pure 9 he>t2 = !y %all see ,god4 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,bless$ are ! peace-mak]s2 = !y %all be call$ ! *ildr5 ( ,god4 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,bless$ are !y :i* are p]secut$ = righte\sness' sake2 = !irs is ! k+dom ( heav54 ,answ]4 ,am54 ,m9i/]4 ,he> also :at ! voice f heav5 sai?4 ,bless$ are ! dead :o die 9 ! ,"l4 ,answ]4 ,ev5 s1 sai? ! ,_s1 = !y re/ f _! labors4 ,m9i/]4 ,let u pray4 ,almighty & ,et]nal ,god1 to :om is nev] any pray] made )\t hope ( m]cy2 ,b[ ?9e e>1 we besee* !e1 to our supplications1 & 9 ! c\ntry ( peace & re/ cause u to be made p>tn]s ) ?y holy s]vants2 ?r\gh ,jesus ,*ri/ our ,"l4 ,am54#ij ,!n %all be said ! ,collect = ! ,day &1 unless ! ,holy ,communion is imm$iately to foll[1 su* o!r pray] or pray]s1 tak5 out ( ?is ,book1 z ! ,m9i/] %all ?9k prop]4 ,,app5dix3 ,,s]mons ,,be=e ,,& ,,aft]4 ,,app5dix4 ,,p]man5t ,,& ,,v>iable ,,*>act]i/ics ,,op ,,! ,,pray] ,,book4 ,a ,,s]mon ,,prea*$ ,,9 ,,/4 ,,/eph5',s ,,*ur*1 ,,philadelphia1 ,,on ,,! ,,anniv]s>y ,,( ,,! ,,bi%op ,,:ite ,,pray] ,,book ,,society1 ,,sunday1 ,,novemb] #bd1 #ahgh4 ,"o g5]ation passe? away2 & ano!r g5]ation come?4--,eccles4 i4#d4 ,aga9/ ! backgr\nd ( ?is sombre fact ( *ange1 :atev] !re is 9 life t is /able /&s out ) a %>pness t compels notice4 ,j because ! _w is s full ( v>iabl5ess1 our he>ts' affections fa/5 ) ! tight] grip ^u any?+ t seems to h ! gu>antees ( p]man5ce4 ,! ,book ( ,common ,pray] appeals to u on ?is score1 precisely z ! ,bible1 9 its l>g] measure1 does3 x is ! book ( _m g5]ations1 n ( "o1 & !re is ! hid+ ( its p[]4 ,we h receiv$ ! ,pray] ,book f ! g5]ations t are gone2 we purpose h&+ x on :5 ano!r g5]ation come?2 we hold x = ! use & bless+ ( ! g5]ation :i* n[ is4 ,our ?\ghts ab\t ! book1 !re=e1 if we w\ld h ! ?9k+ rightly done1 mu/ take hold ^u ! pa/1 ! pres5t1 & ! future1 a bread? ( topic cov]$ well en\gh p]haps by ?is phrase1 ,! ,p]man5t & ! ,v>iable ,*>act]i/ics ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,i make no apology = ask+ y to take up ! subject 9 s grave a temp]4 ,n[1 = m ?an ?ree hundr$ ye>s1 ! ,common ,pray] has be5 ! manual ( wor%ip 9 use ) ! great] numb] ( ! p ( t race :i*1 mean:ile1 9 ! provid5ce ( ,god1 has be5 gr[+ up to be ! lead+ p[] on e>?4 ,ev]y:]e ! ,engli% language seems to be go+ =? conqu]+ & to conqu]1 & :i!rsoev] x p5etrates x c>ries ) x ! lett]s & ! social traditions ( a p ^: "* has be5 l>gely m\ld$ by ! influ5ces ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,africans1 ,indians1 ,h9doos are to-day1 ev5 9 _! hea!nism1 feel+ ! effects ( waves ( movem5t :i* ?rob f ?is c5tre4 ,m5 9 au?ority1 ! _w ov]1 are liv+ out1 ) m or less ( consi/5cy & ?or\ghness1 ^? convictions ab\t our duty t[>d ,god1 & our duty t[>d our neighbor1 :i* 7 e>ly inwr\ght into _! consci5ces ?r\gh ! in/rum5tality ( ^! v5]able =ms4 ,surely no "o c af=d to ?9k or speak o!rwise ?an mo/ s]i\sly & c>efully ) reg>d to a book :i* has beh9d x a hi/ory s wor?y1 s ri*1 s pregnant ) promise = ! future4 ,look fir/1 !n1 at ! p[] :i* ! ,pray] ,book draws f its affiliations ) ! pa/4 ,x is a common rem>k1 s common z to be commonplace1 t our liturgy owes its excell5ce to ! fact ( its n hav+ be5 ! composition or compilation ( any "o man4 ,s mu* is evid5t en\gh ^u ! face ( x3 = a =m ( wor%ip devis$ (f-h& by an individual1 or ev5 put toge!r by a committee sitt+ ar\nd a table1 c\ld sc>cely be :olly satisfactory to any save ! mak] or ! mak]s ( x4 ,b x is m to ! purpose to obs]ve t n only is ! ,pray] ,book n ! result ( any "o man's or any "o committee's labors2 x is n ! "w ev5 ( any "o g5]ation1 or ( any "o age4 ,! m5 :o gradually put ! ,pray] ,book into :at is sub/antially its pres5t %ape1 9 ! days ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 & ( ,elizabe?1 7 no m ! mak]s ( ! ,pray] ,book ?an 7 ! m5 :o1 9 a lat] reign1 set =? :at we call ! au?oriz$ v]sion ( ! ,holy ,scriptures1 ! fir/ translators ( ! ,bible4 ,9 bo? cases ! "w done 0 a "w ( review & revision4 ,a mu* m sev]e review1 a va/ly m sweep+ revision 9 ! case ( ! ,pray] ,book ?an 9 ! case ( ! ,bible1 ,i grant2 b /ill1 ma9ly a "w ( review & revision aft] all4 ,cont9uity1 t *>act]i/ic s preci\s 9 ! eye ( mod]n sci5ce1 cont9uity m>k$ ! :ole process4 ,! fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ! ,re=m$ ,*ur* ( ,engl& 0 a cond5s$1 simplifi$1 & purifi$ comb9ation ( =mul>ies ( wor%ip already 9 use 9 ! ,national ,*ur*4 ,a c]ta9 am\nt ( new mat]ial1 "s ( x home-made1 "s ( x drawn f =eign s\rces1 0 add$2 b ! great bulk ( ! new s]vice-book _h be5 conta9$ 9 "o or o!r ( ! old] manuals4 ,! ,re=m]s did b clip & prune1 ) t exquisite ta/e & judgm5t :i* belong by tradition to ,engli% g>d5]s1 ! ov]gr[? & rank luxuriance ( a too long neglect$1 c>eless-ord]$ g>d54 ,b :5ce came ! e>li] =mul>ies !mselves1 f :i* ,cranm] & ! re/ qu>ri$ ! /one = ! new build+8--to *ange ! metaphor z ,paul1 y rememb]1 does s sudd5ly f husb&ry to ar*itecture4#ia ,:5ce came ,missal1 & ,brevi>y1 & ,book ( ,(fices--! be/ portions ( :i* 7 m]g$ 9 ! ,engli% ,common ,pray]8 ,f ! f> pa/2 ! ,missal f ^? primitive liturgies or communion s]vices1 "s ( :i* we trace back ) c]ta9ty to ! lat] portion ( ! ante-,nic5eage1 & by n unreasonable conjecture to ! edge ( apo/olic days2 ! ,brevi>y or daily pray]s f ! times :5 ,*ri/ians fir/ took up community life2 ! ,(fices f p]iods ( unc]ta9 date all along ! track ( previ\s ,*ur* hi/ory4 ,b :at advantage1 asks someone full ( ! mod]n _s1 :at advantage has ! ,common ,pray] 9 t x c trace a g5ealogy runn+ up ?r\gh ages ( su* unc]ta9 reputation8 ,h we n be5 accu/om$ to reg>d ^? times z hopelessly corrupt1 imp5etrably d>k1 univ]sally sup]/iti\s8 ,ought we n to be mortifi$1 r ?an gratifi$1 to le>n t f ! pit ( s m\ldy a pa/ our book ( pray] 0 digg$8 ,w\ld n a br&-new liturgy1 mod]niz$ expressly to meet ! ne$s ( n9ete5? c5tury culture1 ) all ! old ,engli% idioms displac$1 e r\gh corn] smoo!d & e crook$ place made /raight--w\ld n t be some?+ f> wor?i] our respect1 bett] entitl$ to our allegiance1 ?an ?is book full ( f>-away e*oes1 & fa9t bell-notes f a half-=gott5 pa/8 ,yes1 if mod]n man 7 only mod]n man & no?+ m1 su* reason+ w\ld be extremely cog5t4 ,b :at if mod]n man be really1 n ! m]e creature ( ! c5tury 9 :i* he lives1 b ! ga!r$ sum & product ( all t has prec$$ him 9 hi/ory8 ,:at if y & ,i1 f ! v fact t we are liv+ n[1 h 9 ! dim gr\ndwork ( our nature some?+ t w\ld n h be5 !re _h we liv$ "o1 ?ree1 twelve hundr$ ye>s ago8 ,:at if !re be su* a ?+ z cumulative acquirem5t = ! race ( m51 s t a new g5]ation />ts ) an available capital ( associations & ideas ( :i* ! g5]ation la/ prec$+ x own$ b a "p8 ,take su* words z feudalism1 ! ,crusades1 ! ,r5aissance1 ! pr9t+ press1 consid] h[ mu* !y mean to u1 & !n rememb] t to a man ( ! ?ird c5tury !y w\ld h be5 empty s\nds convey+ absolutely no mean+4 ,:at all ?is goes to %[ is t human nature is a map :i* is cont9ually unroll+4 ,to say t ! entirety ( x lies betwe5 ! two m]idians t b\nd ! p>ticul> tract 9 :i* our own little life happ5s to be ca/ is /upid4 ,! :ole great pa/ belongs to u--riv] & isl&1 ocean1 =e/1 cont95t1 all are ours4 ,y & ! man 9 armor1 y & ! ,v5etian m]*ant1 y & ! c[l$ monk h some?+1 be x ev] s little1 some?+ 9 common4 ,t :i* 0 9 ! =egr\nd ( _! life is n[ 9 ! backgr\nd or 9 ! middle di/ance ( y\rs4 ,x has become a "p ( y4#ib ,s1 !n1 if we w\ld h a liturgy t %all speak to our :ole nature1 & n to a m]e fraction ( x1 x mu/ be a liturgy full ( voices s\nd+ out ( ! pa/4 ,!re mu/ be rem9d]s & sugge/ions 9 x ( all ! great epo*s ( ! ,*ur*'s /ory4 ,yes1 e*oes ev5 f ^? v ages :i* we call d>k 7p]haps z mu* because we are 9 ! d>k ab\t !m z on acc\nt ( any special blackness atta*+ to ! times !mselves71 "s e*oes ev5 f !m may h a rightful place 9 ! wor%ip :i* is to call out responsively all t is 9 ! he>t ( ! mo/ mod]n ( mod]n m54 ,z !re 7 h]oes be=e ,agamemnon1 s 7 !re holy & humble m5 ( he>t be=e ,cranm] & ,lu!r1 yes1 & be=e ,j]ome & ,augu/9e4 ,if any cry t ev] w5t up f any "o ( !m out ( ! dep?s ( t nature :i* !y %>e ) u & we ) !m1 if any brea? ( supplication1 any moan ( p5it5ce1 any %\t ( victory t issu$ f _! lips has made out to survive ! noise & tumult ( int]v5+ times1 x has e>n$ by its v p]si/5cy ( tone a prima facie title to be put into ! ,pray] ,book ( to-day4#ic ,& ?is is :y a pray] book may survive ! wreck ( _m sy/ems ( !ology4 ,a pray] book holds ! utt]ance ( our ne$s2 a !ological sy/em is ! embodim5t ( our ?\ghts4 ,n[ our ?\ghts ab\t ?+s div9e are pa9fully fallible & liable to *ange ) *ange ( times2 b a want :i* is g5u9ely & entirely human is a p]man5t fact2 ! great ne$s ( ! s\l nev] gr[ obsolete1 & ?\gh ! language 9 :i* ! lips %all clo! ! he>t's desire may alt]1 z ta/es alt]1 yet ! sub/ance ( ! pray] abides1 & 9 "s happy in/ances ! =m also abides4 ,to an eye t looks wisely & lov+ly on su* sights1 !re is ! same ke5 s5se ( enjoym5t 9 f9d+ "h & !re 9 ! ,pray] ,book sugge/ions ( =gott5 cu/oms1 rem9d]s ( fam\s p]sons & ev5ts1 t !re is 9 detect+ 9 ! masonry ( an old ca/le or m9/] tell-tale /ones :i* betray ! diff]5t ages1 ! sundry times & div]s mann]s :i* ! fabric repres5ts4 ,:o1 = in/ance1 t has trac$ ! hi/ory ( t apo/olic ord9ance1 ! kiss ( peace1 d[n ?r\gh ! liturgical *anges & revolutions ( eighte5 hundr$ ye>s1 c fail to be int]e/$ 9 f9d+ 9 a s+le clause ( "o ( ! exhortations ( our communion s]vice t :i* corresponds to ! lit]al kiss ( primitive times1 z well z to ! petrifi$ symbol ( ! orig9al reality1 ! silv]1 ivory1 or wood5 osculatory ( ! m$iaeval ,*ur*8#id ,s ) ,a%-,w$nesday1 a s+le syllable op5s a :ole *apt] ( ,*ur* hi/ory4 ,aga91 ! ,lat9 head+s to ! psalms ( ! ,psalt]2 ) :at an impati5t ge/ure c we imag9e a spruce revis] bru%+ ^! away z s mu* tra%6 ,!y are n tra%1 !y are way m>ks t tell ( times :5 dev\t m5 lov$ ^? cat*words1 z we love ! fir/ l9es ( our favorite hymns4 ,a few ( ! head+s1 su* z ,de ,pr(undis & ,mis]]e1 /ill possess su* associations = ourselves4 ,!re 0 a "t :5 v _m m ( !m meant to m5 n[ dead & gone z mu* z ,rock ( ,ages1 or ,sun ( my ,s\l1 or ,lead1 k9dly ,light1 c mean to y or me4#ie ,!n1 too1 ! monum5ts ( specially rev]$ h]oes ( ! fai? t dot ! pa?s ( ! ,common ,pray]1 h[ preci\s !y are6 ,we l to ?9k ( ,ambrose z speak+ to u 9 ! l(ty s5t5ces ( ! ,te ,deum4 ,x is pleasant to associate ,*ryso/om ) ! pray] t be>s 8 "n1 & to "k t he :o sway$ ! city's multitude /ill priz$ ! ,ma/]'s promise to ! two or ?ree ga!r$ toge!r 9 8 "n4 ,s also1 9 our ,am]ican ,book1 ,j]emy ,taylor1 ! mod]n ,*ryso/om1 meets u 9 ! ,(fice = ! ,visitation ( ! ,sick1 9 t solemn pray] address$ to ,him ^: days are )\t end1 & ^: m]cies _c be numb]$4 ,all ^! ?+s help to make ! ,pray] ,book ! l>ge-he>t$1 wide-m9d$ book we all ( u feel x to be1 s l a fri5d :om we rev]e because he is k9dly 9 8 tone1 g5]\s 9 8 judgm5ts1 quick to und]/& u at e po9t4 ,s mu* = ! pa/ ( ! ,pray] ,book4 ,we h t\*$ x 9 no image-break+ mood1 b ) rev]5ce4 ,"o g5]ation passe? away1 ano!r g5]ation come?1 & x has be5 ! peculi> felicity ( ?is book to /& ,a l9k among ! days1 to knit ,! g5]ations ea* to ea*4 ,we pass on to consid] ! pres5t usefulness ( ! ,pray] ,book & ! possibility ( ext5d+ t usefulness 9 ! future4 ,& n[ ,i %all speak :olly z an ,am]ican to ,am]icans1 n because ! de/9ies ( ! ,pray] ,book 9 ! ,new ,_w are ! m important1 ?\gh su* may 9 ! end turn out to be ! fact1 b simply because we are at home "h & "k our own wants & wi%es1 our own liabilities & opportunities1 f> bett] ?an we c possibly "k ^? ( o!r p4 ,z a ,*ur* we h always ti$ ourselves too slavi%ly to ,engli% prec$5t4 ,our v9e is greatly 9 dang] ( cont9u+ m]ely a pott$ ivy1 an indoor exotic4 ,! pa/ ( ! ,common ,pray] we _c disconnect f ,engl&1 b its pres5t & its future belong 9 "p at lea/ to u1 & x is 9 ?is light t we are b\nd z ,am]ican ,*ur*m5 to /udy !m4 ,let u agree1 !n1 t ! usefulness ( ! book "h & n[ lies l>gely 9 ! m\ld+ & =mative influ5ce :i* x is quietly ex]t+1 n only on ! religion ( ^? :o use x1 b also l>gely on ! religion ( ! f> great] numb] :o publicly use x n4 ,x has int]e/$ me1 z x w\ld int]e/ almo/ anyone1 to le>n h[ _m pray] books our booksell]s supply to ,*ri/ian p :o are n ,*ur*m54 ,evid5tly ! book is 9 use z a private manual ) ?\s&s1 :o own no op5 allegiance to ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal ,*ur*4 ,!y keep x on ! devotional %elf midway betwe5 ,?omas a ,kempis & ! ,pilgrim's ,progress1 f9d+ x a sort ( int]pret] ( ! "o to ! o!r1 & possess$ ( a c]ta9 flavor diff]5c+ x f bo?4 ,?is is a happy augury = ! future4 ,mu* lat5t heat is g5]at+ :i* %all yet w>m up ! dullness ( ! l&4 ,! se$-gra9 ( ! ,common ,pray] w n lie unproductive 9 ^? =gott5 furr[s4 ,! fitness ( su* a sy/em ( wor%ip z ?is to c\nt]act "s ( ! flagrant evils ( our popul> religion c sc>cely fail to comm5d x to ! m9ds ( ^? :o ?us unobs]v$ &1 z x 7 9 secret1 read & pond]4 ,mu* ( our ,am]ican piety1 f]vid z x is1 %[s confess$ly a fev]i%1 int]mitt5t "* :i* ne$s j su* a tonic z ! ,pray] ,book provides 9 :at ,keble happily call$ its sob] /&>d ( feel+ 9 matt]s ( practical religion4 ,!n1 too1 !re is ! con/antly increas+ int]e/ :i* x is su* a pleasure to obs]ve among ,*ri/ians ( all names 9 ! ord] ( ! ritual ye>1 9 ,*ri/mas & ,ea/]1 ,l5t & ,good-,friday--:o c tell h[ mu* ( ?is may n be due to ! leav5+ influ5ce ( ! ,pray] ,book1 ov] & above :at is effect$ by ! public s]vices ( ! ,*ur*8 ,i wond]1 said a fam\s revivali/ to a fri5d1 a cl]gyman ( our ,*ur*1 ,i wond] if y ,episcopalians "k :at a good ?+ y h 9 t ye> ( y\rs4 ,:y don't y use x m8 ,& true en\gh1 :y d we n8 ,t we might le>n to d s 0 a wi% v ne> to ! he>t ( t holy & true man :o1 if anyone1 des]ves ! title ( ! sa9t among our prie/s1 ! late ,dr4 ,muhl5b]g1 ! man :o tw5ty-five ye>s ago head$ ! n :olly abortive movem5t kn[n z ! ,memorial4#if ,"o fruit ( t movem5t is p]haps to be se5 9 ! e>ne/ desire n[ preval5t ?r\gh\t ! ,*ur* to see ! scope ( ! ,pray] ,book's influ5ce enl>g$4 ,9 ,g5]al ,conv5tions & ,*ur* ,congresses n[adays no topic excites great] int]e/ ?an ! "q h[ bett] to adapt ! s]vices ( ! ,*ur* to ! pres5t ne$s & special conditions ( all classes ( ! population4 ,to be sure1 ! app>5t impot5ce ( ! gov]n+ body to f9d or furni% any lawful way ( relief is a little disc\rag+1 b x is some?+ to see an almo/ univ]sal ass5t giv5 9 t]ms1 to ! proposition t relief ought to be _h4 ,:at we h to fe> is t dur+ ! long delay :i* puts (f ! only prop] & regul> me?od ( giv+ m ela/icity to ! s]vices1 !re may spr+ up a g5]ation ( ,*ur*m5 f ^: m9ds ! idea ( obligation to law 9 matt]s ( ritual obs]vance w h fad$ out altoge!r4 ,!re is a cons]vatism s cons]vative t x w /& by & see a build+ tumble d[n r ?an lay a sacrilegi\s h& on a s+le /one1 w see dam & mill & village all swept away soon] ?an lift ! fla%-bo>ds t keep ! sup]abundant wat] f com+ safely d[n4 ,x is among ! ?+s possible1 t = lack ( readju/m5t & timely adaptation ( ! laws regulat+ wor%ip1 j su* a fate may befall our :ole liturgical fabric4 ,! plausible !ory ( ! rubric ( common s5se1 ab\t :i* we h he>d s mu*1 a !ory good )9 limitations1 is ?reat5+1 by ! :olesale application x receives1 pres5tly to annul all o!r rubrics :atsoev]4 ,:51 by ?is process1 uni=mity & ev5 simil>ity %all h be5 utt]ly aboli%$1 :5 x %all h become impossible = "o to "k be=eh& ( a ,sunday :e!r he is go+ to mass1 or to meet+1 or to *ur*1 ! inquiry w be 9 ord]1 ,:at has cons]vatism ( ?is sort really cons]v$8 ,! p]sonal lib]ty ( ! (ficiat+ cl]gyman1 ,i fe> w be ! only answ]2 c]ta9ly n1 ,! lib]ty ( ! wor%ipp+ congregation4 ,! /raight & only hone/ way out ( our emb>rassm5t w1 "s day or o!r1 be f\nd1 ,i d>e n believe v soon1 9 a c>eful1 lov+1 fair-m9d$ revision ( ! =mul>ies2 a revision und]tak51 n = ! purpose ( giv+ victory to "o !ological p>ty r ?an to ano!r1 or ( *ang+ 9 any degree ! doctr9al tea*+ ( ! ,*ur*1 b solely & :olly ) a view to enri*+1 amplify+1 & mak+ m available ! liturgical treasures ( ! book4 ,"o g5]ation passe? away1 ano!r g5]ation come?4 ,z we h se5 9 ^! words an argum5t 9 favor ( n break+ ) ! pa/1 s let !m also speak to u ( our pla9 duty to ! pres5t4 ,true1 ! great ne$s are1 z ,i h said1 common alike to all ! g5]ations1 to ^? t pass & ^? t come2 b ! less] ne$s are v>iable1 & unless we are prep>$ to take ! gr\nd t because less] !y maybe disreg>d$ altoge!r1 we are b\nd1 ) ! *ang$ times1 to provide = ! new wants new satisfactions4 ,take1 simply by way ( illu/ration1 ! ne$ we /& 9 ( an appropriate =m ( ?ird s]vice = use on ,sundays 9 city *ur*es1 :5 ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray] h be5 already said accord+ to ! prescrib$ ord]4 ,:y h we no su* s]vice8 ,simply because no su* ne$ exi/$ 9 our ,am]ican cities :5 ! ,pray] ,book1 z we h x n[1 0 tak+ %ape1 at ! close ( ! la/ c5tury4 ,j z no =m = ! adm9i/ration ( ,adult ,baptism 0 put into ,que5 ,elizabe?'s ,pray] ,book1 simply because ! usage ( ,infant ,baptism 0 univ]sal 9 t day1 & !re 7 no unbaptiz$ adults2 b su* s]vice 0 ins]t$ at ! ,re/oration to meet ! ne$ t _h sprung up "u ! ,puritan regime2 s 0 x unnecess>y 9 ,bi%op ,:ite's day to provide = a =m ( s]vice :i* has only become practicable & desirable s9ce mod]n discov]y has enabl$ u to make ! public /reets almo/ z safe at night z 9 ! daytime1 & *ur*-go+ z easy by gaslight z by sunlight4 ,n[ x is p]fectly possible1 ( c\rse1 "u ! pres5t ord] ( ?+s1 & ) no *ange 9 rubric or canon law1 = any cl]gyman to provide an additional s]vice1 to provide x 9 ! =m ( a mosaic made up ( bits ( ! liturgy wr5*$ out ( _! prop] places1 & s irregul>ly put toge!r t no /rang] among ! wor%ipp]s c possibly1 ) ! book 9 h&1 ?read 8 way among its intricacies4 ,b :5 we consid] h[ _m exquisite gems ( devotional spee* !re are /ill left outside ! cov]s ( ! ,pray] ,book2 :5 we consid] h[ delightful x w\ld be to h back aga9 ! ,magnificat 1 & ! ,nunc ,dimittis 1 & "s ( ! sweet v]sicles ( ! ,ev5song ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&2 :5 we consid] ! lam5table mi/ake already made 9 our exi/+ =mul>ies ( introduc+ into ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray] id5tically ! same op5+ s5t5ces1 ! same ,g5]al ,exhortation1 ! same ,g5]al ,confession1 ! same ,decl>ation ( ,absolution1 ! same ,pray] = ! ,presid5t1 & ! same ,g5]al ,?anksgiv+--is x n evid5t t an additional1 or1 if y please1 an alt]native s]vice1 compos$ ( mat]ial n else:]e employ$1 w\ld be = ! wor%ipp]s a v great ga98 ,! repetition :i* we>ies is only ! repetition :i* we feel ne$ n h be54 ,we nev] tire ( ! ,collect = ,peace any m ?an we tire ( ! sunset4 ,x is 9 its place1 & we always welcome x4 ,9 a p]fect liturgy no =m ( words1 except ! ,cre$1 ! ,doxology1 & ! ,"l's ,pray]1 w\ld at any "t reappe>1 b z 9 arabesque "w e squ>e in* ( space diff]s f e o!r squ>e1 s ea* clause & s5t5ce ( ! manual ( wor%ip w\ld h a di/9ctive beauty ( its own1 to be look$ = precisely !re & n[h]e else4 ,?is is b "o illu/ration ( :at may be call$ a possible enri*m5t ( our ,book ( ,common ,pray]4 ,impov]i%m5t "u ! "n ( revision may v ju/ly be deprecat$1 b :o %all f9d any j fault ) an enri*m5t t is really su*8 ,we mu/ rememb] t ! m5 :o gave u :at we n[ h 71 9 _! day & g5]ation1 ! innovators1 advocates ( :at ! m timid spirits acc\nt$ dang]\s *ange4 ,we _c1 ,i ?9k1 suffici5tly admire ! c\rage\s =esight ( ^? ,re=m]s :o1 at a "t :5 public wor%ip 0 ma9ly associat$ 9 m5's m9ds ) :at w5t on among a numb] ( ecclesia/ics ga!r$ toge!r at "o end ( a *ur*1 d>$ to plant !mselves firmly on ! pr9ciple ( common pray]1 & to say1 ,h5ce=? ! wor%ip ( ! ,national ,*ur* %all be ! wor%ip n ( prie/s alone1 b ( prie/s & p too4 ,:at a bold act x 06 ,! pr9t+-press1 rememb]1 al?\gh x _h giv5 ! impulse to ! ,re=mation1 0 f> f be+ at t "t ! omnipres5t ?+ x is n[2 books 7 sc>ce2 popul> education1 z we und]/& x1 0 unkn[n2 !re 7 no means ( supply+ s]vice-books to ! poor] classes 7no ,pray] ,book ,societies1 l ?is ( y\rs71 nor c\ld ! books h be5 us$ _h !y be5 furni%$4 ,& yet 9 ! face ( ^! seem+ly insup]able ob/acles1 ! lead]s ( religi\s ?\ght 9 ! ,engl& ( t day _h ! sagacity to plan a sy/em ( wor%ip :i* %\ld involve p>ticipation by ! p 9 all ! acts ( div9e s]vice1 includ+ ! adm9i/ration ( ! sacram5ts4 ,"h 0 g5u9e /atesman%ip appli$ to ! adm9i/ration ( religion4 ,^? m5 disc]n$ wisely ! signs ( _! own times4 ,!y saw :at ! "r pr9ciple 01 !y =esaw :at ! art ( pr9t+ 0 de/9$ 9 "t to accompli%1 & !y did a piece ( "w :i* has bravely /ood ! we> & te> ( full ?ree hundr$ ye>s4 ,no ,*ur*man que/ions ! wisdom ( _! innovations n[4 ,is x hopeless to expect a l quickness ( disc]nm5t 9 ! lead]s ( to-day8 ,surely !y h eyes to see t a new _w has be5 born1 & t a ?\s& unexampl$ dem&s are press+ u on e side4 ,if ! ,pray] ,book is n enri*$ ) a view to meet+ ^? dem&s1 x is n = lack ( mat]ials4 ,a ,saturday review] has tri$ to fa/5 on ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& ! /igma ( be+ ! ,*ur* :i* = ! space ( two c5turies has n be5 able to evolve a fre% pray]4 ,if ! reproa* 7 j x w\ld be /++ inde$2 b x is mo/ cruelly unju/4 ,9 ! devotional lit]ature ( ! ,anglicanism ( ! la/ fifty ye>s1 to g no fur!r back1 !re may be f\nd pray]s fully equal 9 compass ( ?\ght & dep? ( feel+ to any ( ^? t are already 9 public use4 ,n to s+le out too _m in/ances1 x may suffice to m5tion ! pray]s app5d$ to ! book ( ,anci5t ,collects edit$ a few ye>s s9ce by a di/+ui%$ ,ox=d s*ol>4 ,! cl]gy are acqua9t$ ) !m1 & "k h[ beautiful !y are4 ,:y %\ld n ! :ole ,*ur* enjoy ! happ9ess ( us+ !m8#ig ,:y is !re n ! same propriety 9 our g>n]+ ! devotional h>ve/ ( ! ?ree hundr$ ye>s la/ pa/ t !re 0 9 ! ,re=m]s g>n]+ ! h>ve/ ( five times ?ree hundr$ ye>s8 ,"o g5]ation passe? away1 ano!r g5]ation come?4 ,i h spok5 ( ! pres5t & ! pa/1 :at n[ ( ! future8 ,we "k t all ?+s come to an end4 ,:at de/9y awaits ! book to :i* our ev5+ ?\ghts h be5 giv58 ,t is a pa? n op5 to our tread4 ,! cl\dy curta9 scre5s ! ?re%old ( x4 ,/ill we may li/5 & imag9e t we he> s\nds4 ,:at if su* a voice z ?is 7 to come to u f ! di/ance ( a hundr$ ye>s h5ce--a voice t+$ ) sadness1 & c>ry+ j ! lea/ sugge/ion ( reproa*8 ,our fa!rs1 ! voice says1 9 ! la/ qu>t] ( ! la/ c5tury1 =feit$ a gold5 opportunity4 ,x 0 a "t ( recon/ruction 9 ! ,/ate1 social life 0 tak+ on ! =m x 0 de/9$ long to reta91 a great w> _h come to an end & its results 7 be+ regi/]$1 all ?+s 7 flu5t4 ,moreov]1 !re happ5$1 j !n1 to be an almo/ unp>allel$ lull 9 ! /rife ( religi\s p>ties2 m5 7 m dispos$ ?an usual to agree2 ! int]e/ 9 liturgical rese>* 0 at its greate/1 & s*ol>s knew & c>$ m ?an !y h ev] done s9ce ab\t ! hi/ory & ! /ructure ( =ms ( pray]4 ,nev]!less1 timid c\ncils prevail$2 no?+ 0 done ) a view to bett] adapt+ ! sy/em to ! ne$s ( society1 & ! hope t ! ,*ur* might cease to we> ! dim5sions ( a sect1 & might become ! *os5 home ( a great p1 di$ unrealiz$4 ,we /ruggle on1 a half-he>t$ company1 & try to live ^u ! high traditions1 ! sweet memories ( our pa/4 ,god =bid1 my fri5ds1 t ! dismal prophecy come true6 ,we w n believe x4 ,b :at1 y ask1 is ! pa?way to any su* bett]m5t z ,i h v5tur$ r\ghly to sket* to-night8 ,i w n attempt to map x1 b ,i feel v confid5t :i* way x does n run4 ,i am sure x does n run ?r\gh ! region ( disaffection1 compla9t1 ?reat5+1 re/lessness1 petulance1 or secession4 ,m]e fretfulness nev] c>ries its po9ts4 ,no1 ! true way to bett] ?+s is always to beg9 by hold+ on manfully to t :i* we already are conv9c$ is good4 ,! be/ re/or]s ( old fabrics are ^? :o "w ) affectionate loyalty z ne>ly z possible on ! l9es ( ! fir/ build]s1 av]se to any *ange :i* is made m]ely = *ange's sake1 n s anxi\s to mod]nize z to re/ore1 & yet always awake to ! fact t :at !y h be5 set to d is to make ! build+ once m :at x 0 fir/ meant to be1 a practicable %elt]4 ,,! ,,outcome ,,( ,,revision--,a ,,s]mon#ih 4 4 4 ,we are ! s]vants ( ! ,god ( heav5 & e>?1 & build ! h\se t 0 build$ ^! _m ye>s ago4--,ezra v4#aa4 ,?is 0 ! reply ( ! rebuild]s ( ,j]usalem to c]ta9 critical look]s-on :o w\ld fa9 be in=m$ by :at au?ority a picturesque ru9 0 di/urb$4 ,x is a s]viceable answ] /ill4 ,!re are always ^? to :om ! activity ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* is a /&+ puzzle4 ,religion1 or at any rate reveal$ religion1 hav+1 z !y ?9k1 receiv$ its dea?-bl[1 ! unmi/akable signs ( life :i*1 f "t to "t1 x manife/s take on almo/ ! "* ( a p]sonal affront4 ,!y res5t !m4 ,:at "r h ^! ,*ri/ians to be %[+ su* a lively int]e/ 9 _! vanqui%$ fai?8 !y ask4 ,:at bus9ess h !y to be hold+ c\ncils1 & lay+ plans1 & act+ z if !y _h "s high & spl5did ef=t 9 h&8 ,are !y su* fools z to imag9e t !y c recon/ruct :at has s evid5tly tumbl$ into ru98 ,b ! wond]ful ?+ ab\t ?is great build+ ent]prise kn[n z ! k+dom ( ,god is t1 f ! day :5 ! corn]-/one 0 laid to ?is day1 ! workm5 on ! walls h nev] seem$ to "k :at x meant to be disc\rag$4 ,9 ! face ( taunt & rebuff & disappo9tm5t1 !y h kept on say+ to _! critics3 ,we are ! s]vants ( ! ,god ( heav5 & e>?1 & build ! h\se t 0 build$ ^! _m ye>s ago4 ,?is is j :at ! ,*ur* ,c\ncil :i* has be5 hold+ its sessions 9 ,baltimore dur+ ! la/ ?ree weeks has to say = itself4 ,its task has be5 an ar*itectural task4 ,accord+ to its lights1 x has be5 at "w ^u ! walls ( ! city ( ,god4 ,let me give y1 z my habit has be5 "u simil> circum/ances 9 ! pa/1 "s acc\nt ( its do+s4 ,! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( #ahib w be memorable 9 our ecclesia/ical annals = hav+ clos$ "o "q ( grave mom5t only to op5 a k9dr$ "o ( /ill l>g] rea*4 ,! "q clos$ 0 ! "q ( liturgical revision2 ! "q op5$ is ! "q ( con/itutional revision4 ,i %\ld l to speak to y ?is morn+ retrospectively ( ! "o1 & prospectively ( ! o!r4 ,x is n[ ab\t tw5ty ye>s s9ce ! "q ( modify+1 to "s ext5t1 ! me?ods ( our public wor%ip began to be moot$4 ,:ile x 0 ackn[l$g$ t ! ne$ 0 great] 9 ! "m c\ntry ?an "h1 _m ( ! repetitions & sup]fluities ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* s]vice hav+ be5 set aside by ,bi%op ,:ite & 8 compe]s 9 ! ,am]ican ,revision ( #aghi1 x 0 felt t fur!r improvem5ts 7 /ill possible1 & t ! "t _h fully come = mak+ !m4 ,s9ce ! beg9n+ ( ! s-call$ tract>ian movem5t 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& a great deal ( valuable liturgical mat]ial _h be5 accumulat+1 & x 0 disc]n$ t if ev] ! fruits ( ! s*ol>%ip ( su* m5 z ,palm] & ,neale & ,maskell & ,bright 7 to be g>n]$ ! h>ve/-day _h arriv$4 ,to ! "q (t5 ask$ :y x w\ld n h be5 wis] to wait until ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& _h l$ ! way & set ! patt]n1 ! answ] is t ! h&s ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 7 ti$1 z !y h be5 ti$ ^! _m ye>s pa/1 & z !y may cont9ue to be ti$1 = aught we "k to ! contr>y1 = _m ye>s to come4 ,! ,*ur* ( ,engl& _c t\* h] own ,pray] ,book1 :e!r to m5d or to m> x1 except ) ! cons5t ( t v mix$ body1 ! ,h\se ( ,commons--a cons5t %e is naturally & prop]ly mo/ lo? to ask4 ,imm]s$ 9 a v]itable ocean ( accumulat$ liturgical mat]ial1 %e is z helpless z ,tantalus to moi/5 h] lips ) s mu* z a s+le drop4 ,x 0 se5 t ?is fact laid ^u u ,am]ican ,*ur*m5 a responsibility z urg5t z x 0 unique1 viz41 ! responsibility ( do+ :at we c\ld to meet ! devotional ne$s ( pres5t-day ,*ri/5dom1 n only = our own advantage1 b ) a view to be+ ultimately ( s]vice to our ,anglican bre?r5 across ! sea4 ,an exp]im5t ( ! greate/ int]e/1 :i* = !m 0 a %e] impossibility1 x lay op5 to u to try4 ,aft] v>i\s abortive attempts _h come to n\ght1 a beg9n+ 0 at l5g? made 9 ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( #ahhj1 a jo9t committee ( bi%ops & deputies be+ !n appo9t$ to consid] :e!r1 9 view ( ! fact t ?is ,*ur* 0 soon to ent] ^u ! second c5tury ( its organiz$ exi/5ce 9 ,am]ica1 ! *ang$ condition ( ! national life did n dem& c]ta9 alt]ations 9 ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] 9 ! direction ( liturgical enri*m5t & increas$ flexibility ( use4 ,few 7 ( ! op9ion at ! "t t any?+ def9ite w\ld come ( ! delib]ations ( ?is committee1 & ! fact1 nev] be=e publicly /at$ till ?is mom5t1 t ( ! deputies appo9t$ to s]ve ^u x ! great] numb] 7 m5 :o _h n vot$ 9 favor ( ! measure1 makes x all ! m int]e/+ to rememb] t ! report1 :5 br\ght 9 at ,philadelphia ?ree ye>s lat]1 0 sign$ by e memb] ( ! committee !n liv+4 ,?is ,philadelphia report recomm5d$ v num]\s *anges 9 ! direction bo? ( flexibility & enri*m5t1 & by f> ! great] numb] ( ! recomm5dations met ) ! approval ( ! conv5tion4 ,!re is1 h[ev]1 a v wise provision ( our ,*ur* con/itution1 a provision /rik+ly *>act]i/ic ( ! ,anglo-,saxon m9d1 :i*1 by way ( mak+ all[ance = second ?\ght1 requires t liturgical *anges1 be=e be+ f9ally adopt$1 %all run ! gauntlet ( two successive conv5tions4 ,mu* 0 accept$ at ,philadelphia2 x rema9$ to be se5 h[ mu* w\ld pass ! ordeal ( its second read+ at ,*icago ?ree ye>s lat]4 ,into ! w> ( words wag$ ov] ! subject dur+ t int]val p]iod1 ,i h nei!r ! "t nor ! disposition to c>ry y4 ,! ?ree ye>s1 :ile !y gave opportunity = reaction1 also all[$ space = c\nt]-reaction2 s t :51 at la/1 ! "q came once m be=e ! ,*ur* 9 c\ncil assembl$ :e!r ! "w done at ,philadelphia %\ld be approv$ or disall[$1 m5's m9ds _h suffici5tly recov]$ balance to p]mit ( _! ex]cis+ discrim9ation4 ,accord+ly 9 #ahhf "s ?+s 7 reject$1 "s adopt$1 & "s rem&$ = fur!r revision4 ,b :y %\ld ,i confuse y\r m9ds by an attempt to tell 9 detail ! :ole /ory ( ! movem5t8 ,no matt] h[ cle> ,i might make ! n>rative x w\ld be difficult to foll[ x1 = 9 ! progress ( ! "w !re h be5 surprises _m1 successes & rev]ses n a few2 en\gh t1 at la/1 ! long labor is end$ & 9 ?is ,columbian ye> ! %ip comes into port4 ,z to results1 _! numb] & _! quality1 op9ions w ( c\rse diff]4 ,9 connection ) ?is1 z ) all simil> und]tak+s1 !re are _m to cry3 ,:o w %[ u any good8 ,c]ta9ly no?+ t c\ld be call$ a radical *ange has be5 br\ght to pass2 b !n1 is !re any reason to suppose t radical *anges 7 ei!r s\ght or desir$ by ^? :o h be5 active 9 ! movem5t8 ,c]ta9 di/9ct & indisputable ga9s may be c\nt$ up4 ,! recov]y ( ! great ,gospel hymns come "u ?is head4 ,!re are "s ( u :o ?9k t only to h succe$$ 9 replac+ ! ,magnificat & ! ,nunc ,dimittis 9 ! ,ev5+ ,pray] is ( itself a suffici5t rew>d = ye>s ( ef=t1 b ?is is only a small "p ( our h>ve/4 ,! new op5+ s5t5ces = ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]1 :i* h s adorn$ & beautifi$ our obs]vance ( great fe/ivals1 ! remodell+ ( ! ,a%-,w$nesday s]vice1 ! recov]$ ,fea/ ( ! ,transfiguration1 ! v>i\s provisions = adapt+ ! ,*ur*'s wor%ip to ! exig5cies ( times & seasons1 ! increas$ fre$om 9 ! use ( ! ,psalt]1 all ^! g to make up an aggregate ( bett]m5t ! measure ( :i* w be m fully und]/ood z "t goes on4 ,p>turiunt montes is an easy v]dict to pron\nce2 x rema9s to be prov$ :e!r 9 ?is case x is a j "o to r5d]4 ,if !re are "s 7z d\btless "s !re are7 :o hold t ! sample book pres5t$ at ,philadelphia 9 #ahhc1 faulty z x confess$ly 01 is /ill1 all ?+s consid]$1 a bett] book = ,am]ican ne$s ?an ! /&>d f9ally adopt$ at ,baltimore1 week be=e la/1 if !re are "s :o deeply regret ! failure to include among our special (fices "o = ! burial ( little *ildr51 & among our pray]s int]cessions = ! c\ntry1 = ! families ( ! l&1 = s*ools ( good le>n+1 = employ]s & ^? :om !y employ1 toge!r ) _m o!r =ms ( supplication ga!r$ f ! wide field ( ,engli% liturgiology--if1 ,i say1 !re arc "s :o are ( ?is m9d !y mu/ com=t !mselves ) ! reflection t1 aft] all1 !y are a m9ority1 t ! great] numb] ( ^? ^u :om re/$ ! responsibility ( decision did n wi% = ^! additions1 & t ! ?+s :i* f9ally f\nd acceptance 7 ! ?+s unanim\sly desir$4 ,=1 :5 we ?9k ( x1 ?is is p]haps ! v be/ feature ( ! :ole ?+1 look$ at 9 its l5g? & bread?1 t !re is no defeat$ p>ty1 no body ( p :o feel t !y h a "r to fret & sulk because unpalatable *anges h be5 =c$ ^u !m by n>r[ majorities4 ,x is a rem>kable fact1 t ( ! _m scores ( alt]ations effect$1 x c be truly said t1 ) r>e1 v r>e exceptions1 !y f\nd1 :5 x came to ! decisive vote1 :at 0 practically a unanim\s cons5t4 ,!y 7 ?+s t ev]ybody want$4 ,z to ! annoyance & vexation exp]i5c$ by wor%ipp]s dur+ ! ye>s ! revision has be5 9 progress1 p]haps ! v be/ ?+ t c be done1 n[ t ! end is s ne> at h&1 w be to =get all ab\t x4 ,9 a few mon?s1 at ! fur!/1 ! ,pray] ,book1 9 its complete =m1 w be available = pur*ase & use1 & ! hybrid copies :i* h be5 s long 9 circulation1 to ! sc&al ( p ( fa/idi\s ta/e1 w quickly vani% away4 ,mean:ile1 x is int]e/+ to "k t all ?r\gh ?is /ret* ( ye>s :ile ! ,pray] ,book has be5 9 solution1 z "s h be5 fond ( phras+ x1 ! ,episcopal ,*ur* has exhibit$ a rate ( gr[? q unp>allel$ 9 its hi/ory4 ,( c\rse nobody c say ) c]ta9ty :at has caus$ ! increase4 ,b x is at lea/ conceivable t among ! accel]at+ =ces has be5 ?is v "w ( liturgical revision4 ,p at l>ge h be5 made aw>e t ?is ,*ur* 0 hone/ly endeavor+ to adapt its sy/em ( wor%ip to ! ne$s ( our "t & c\ntry2 & ! m]e fact ( _! see+ ?is to be ! case has s]v$ to allay prejudice & to fo/] a _s ( inquiry4 ,f9d+ u dispos$ to relax some?+ ( our rigidity1 !y1 on _! "p1 h be5 fir/ attract$1 !n conciliat$1 & f9ally completely won4 ,i _c leave ?is subject )\t pay+ a p]sonal tribute to a prelate b = ^: aid 9 ! ,h\se ( :i* he is a di/+ui%$ ornam5t1 liturgical revision w\ld1 humanly speak+1 h long ago come to n\ght4 ,to ! fe>lessness1 ! pati5ce1 ! k9dly temp]1 & ! resolute purpose ( ,william ,croswell ,doane1 ,bi%op ( ,albany1 ?is ,*ur* = ^! results /&s deeply & la/+ly indebt$4 ,:5 o!rs' c\rage fail$ !m1 he /ood firm2 :5 fri5ds & colleagues 7 c\nsell+ retreat1 & "u _! brea? 7 :isp]+ ,fiasco6 & ,collapse6 8 _s nev] falt]$4 ,he has be5 true to a great purpose1 at ! co/ ( obloquy sometimes1 & to ! detrim5t ev5 ( old fri5d%ips4 ,sep>at$ f him by a doz5 %ades ( !ological op9ion & by z _m degrees ( ecclesia/ical bias1 ,i r5d] him "h & n[ t homage ( grateful appreciation :i* e ,*ur*man owes him4 ,s mu* = ! %ip t has dropp$ an*or4 ,i h left my self b a few mom5ts 9 :i* to say ,god-spe$ to ! o!r craft :i* is ev5 n[ slid+ d[n ! ways1 ready = ! great deep4 ,put p]haps x is j z well4 ,hi/ory is always a saf] l9e to ent] ^u ?an prophecy2 & 7 ,i to say all t is 9 my m9d & he>t z to ! possibilities ( ?is new v5ture ( fai? on ! ,*ur*'s "p1 con/itutional revision1 ,i might be betray$ into expressions ( hopefulness :i* w\ld /rike mo/ ( y z ov]wr\ght4 ,suffice x to say1 t nev] s9ce ! ,re=mation ( ,religion 9 ! sixte5? c5tury has a fair] prospect be5 op5$ to ! ,*ur* ( our affections ?an is op5$ to h] to-day4 ,no int]pretation ( ! div9e purpose ) respect to ?is broad l& we "n ,am]ica has "o-half s mu* ( likelihood z t :i* makes our c\ntry ! pr$e/9$ build+ plot = ! ,*ur* ( ! ,reconciliation4 ,all signs po9t t way4 ,to u1 if we h b ! eyes to see x1 !re falls1 n ?r\gh any m]it ( our own1 b by ! accid5t1 if x be "r to use t ^w1 by ! accid5t ( hi/orical association1 ! opportunity ( lead]%ip4 ,x is possible = u1 at ?is crisis ( our de/9y1 s to m\ld our organic law t we %all be br\ght into sympa!tic contact ) hundr$s ( ?\s&s ( our fell[-c\ntrym5 :o wor%ip ! same ,god1 hold ! same fai?1 love ! same ,*ri/4 ,on ! o!r h&1 x is possible = u s to f5ce ourselves (f f ?is huge family ( our fell[-believ]s z to secure = our la/+ h]itage only ! cold privileges ( a pr\d & selfi% isolation4 ,!re c\ld be no real ca?olicity 9 su* a *oice z t4 ,we h ! opportunity ( gr[+ into a great & compreh5sive ,*ur*4 ,we h ! opportunity ( dw9dl+ into a self-consci\s1 self-conceit$1 & unsympa!tic sect4 ,:i* %all x be8 ,) ^? to :om1 "u ,god1 ! rem\ld+ ( our organic law has be5 intru/$ x l>gely re/s to say4 ,,comp>ative ,,table ,,( ,,additions ,,made ,,to ,,! ,,book ,,( ,,common ,,pray] ,,at ,,! ,,sev]al ,,revisions ,,s9ce #aedi4 #aeeb #aeei #afjd #affb #aghi #ahib ,scripture ,s5t5ces #aa #h #ca ,collects #c #a #c ,epi/les #b #a #c ,gospels #a #a #c ,(fices #ac #h #a #a ,pray]s #ae #b #g #ah #ac #i ,prop] ,psalms 7days7 #b #aj ,selections ( ,psalms #aj #aj ,canticles #h #b ,v]sicles #d #c #aa ,litany ,suffrages #a #a ,cate*etical ,que/ions #ab ,exhortations #c #b ,,notes ,notes = a ,%ort ,hi/ory ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] #a ,fir/ pr9t$ 9 ! ,am]ican ,*ur* ,review1 ,april1 #ahha4 #b ,mu* confusion ( ?\ght & spee* 9 connection ) our ecclesia/ical legislation gr[s out ( n keep+ 9 m9d ! fact t "h 9 ,am]ica ! organic g5etic law ( ! ,*ur*1 z well z ( ! ,/ate1 is 9 writ+1 & compact$ into def9ite propositions4 ,we draw1 t is to say1 a f> %>p] di/9ction ?an x is possible to d 9 ,engl& betwe5 :at is con/itutional & :at is simply /atutory4 ,!re is no function ( our ,g5]al ,conv5tion t answ]s to ! omnipot5ce ( ,p>liam5t4 ,?is creative faculty 0 vacat$ once = all at ! adoption ( ! ,con/itution4 #c ,conf]5ces1 p4 #dfa4 #d ,pr9ciples ( ,div9e ,s]vice1 vol4 i4 p4 #cij4 #e ,*ur* ,qu>t]ly ,review1 ,london1 ,octob]1 #ahgf4 #f ,! votes ( ! ,h\se ( ,bi%ops are n report$ num]ically4 ,9 ! ,h\se ( ,cl]ical & ,lay ,deputies ! vote /ood z foll[s3 ,( ! ,cl]gy !re 7 #dc ,dioceses repres5t$--,ayes1 #cc2 nays1 #i2 divid$1 #a4 ,( ! ,laity !re 7 #ce ,dioceses repres5t$--,ayes1 #bj2 nays1 #aa2 divid$1 #d4--;,j\rnal ( ,conv5tion ( #ahhj1 p4 #aeb4 #g ,*ur* ,eclectic = ,novemb]1 #ahhj4 #h ,rememb]+ ! deluge ( c5t5nial rhetoric let loose ^u ! c\ntry five ye>s ago1 ano!r critic may well feel ju/ifi$ 9 f9d+ 9 ! language ( ! resolution :at he consid]s an unnecess>y raison d'etre4 ,b x is j possible t c5t5nial *anges re/ on a basis ( g5u9e cause & effect q indep5d5t ( ! decimal sy/em4 ,a c5tury cov]s ! range ( ?ree g5]ations1 & ! g5]ation is a natural1 n an arbitr>y division ( "t4 ,:at ! gr&fa!r practises ! son criticises & ! gr&son am5ds4 ,?is at lea/ ought to comm5d itself to ! consid]ation ( ! lov]s ( my/ical numb]s & p]iodic laws4 #i ,! real argum5t aga9/ ! driblet me?od 7by :i* is meant ! concession ( improvem5t only z x is actually conqu]$ in* by in*7 lies 9 :at has be5 already said ab\t ! undesirability ( frequ5t *anges 9 widely us$ =mul>ies ( wor%ip4 ,x may be true1 z "s allege1 t a revision ( ! ,pray] ,book w\ld %ake ! ,*ur*1 b x is m likely t half a doz5 pat*+s at tri5nial int]vals w\ld %att] x4 ,aft] tw5ty ye>s ( ?is sort ( piecemeal revision1 a v>iorum edition ( ! ,pray] ,book w\ld be a requisite ( e well furni%$ pew4 ,! late ,conv5tion has be5 twitt$ ) inconsi/5cy on ! score ( hav+ negativ$ outright ! proposal = a ,commission to ov]haul ! ,con/itution ( ! ,*ur* :ile cons5t+ to s5d ! ,pray] ,book to a committee = review4 ,disc]nm5t w\ld be a bett] ^w ?an inconsi/5cy1 = al?\gh on gr\nds ( pure !ory ! ,con/itution & ! ,pray] ,book seem to /& 9 correspond+ attitudes z respects me?ods ( am5dm5t1 9 practice ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! two is v wide4 ,tri5nial *anges 9 ! lett] ( ! ,con/itution 7& ^! h (t5 be5 made7 involve no inconv5i5ce to anybody1 = ! simple reason t t docum5t mu/ ( necessity be repr9t$ ) e fre% issue ( ! ,j\rnal4 ,old copies d n cont9ue 9 use1 except z books ( ref]5ce1 b old ,pray] ,books d hold _! place 9 p>i% *ur*es1 & ! spectacle ( congregations try+ to wor%ip 9 unison ) books "s ( :i* conta9$ ! read+ ( #ahhj1 o!rs t ( #ahhc1 & /ill o!rs t ( #ahhf w\ld sc>cely edify4 ,!oretically1 let x be freely grant$1 ! driblet me?od ( am5dm5t is ! prop] "o = bo? ,pray] ,book & ,con/itution1 b ! fact t ! ,conv5tion _h eyes to see t ?is 0 a case to :i* ! maxims ( pure ma!matics did n apply %\ld be set d[n to its cr$it1 r ?an its discr$it4 #aj ,repr9t$ toge!r ) a supplem5t>y ,lett] 9 ! ,j\rnal ( ! ,conv5tion ( #ahfh4 #aa ,dr4 ,coit's ,lett] ( #ahfh1 also repr9t$ 9 ,j\rnal ( t ye>4 #ab ,see ,book ( ,common ,pray] accord+ to ! use ( ,k+'s ,*apel1 ,bo/on4 ,among ! rhetorical crudities ( ?is emasculat$ ,pray] ,book 7f ! title-page ( :i*1 by ! way1 ! def9ite article has be5 ) praisewor?y tru?fulness omitt$7 few ?+s are worse ?an ! foll[+ f ! =m = ! ,burial ( ,*ildr51 a piece ( writ+ :i* 9 po9t ( /yle w\ld seem to savor m ( ! ,lodge ?an ( ! ,*ur*3 ,my bre?r51 :at is our life8 ,x is z ! e>ly dew ( morn+ t glitt]e? = a %ort "t1 & !n is exhal$ to heav54 ,:]e is ! beauty ( *ildhood8 ,:]e is sic ! light ( ^? eyes & ! bloom ( t c\nt5ance8 4 4 4 ,:o is "y & :o is old8 ,:i!r are we go+ & :at %all we become8 ,& yet ! au?or ( ?is mawki% v]biage probably fanci$ t he 0 improv+ ^u ! /ately ,engli% ( ! ,common ,pray]4 ,x is a w>n+ to all w\ld-be enri*]s4 #ac ,a li/ ( ! m noticeable ,anglican works on ,liturgies publi%$ dur+ ! p]iod nam$1 arrang$ 9 ! ord] ( _! appe>ance1 w s]ve to illu/rate ! accuracy ( ! /atem5t made above1 & may also be ( value to ! g5]al read] = purposes ( ref]5ce4 #ahcb4 ,orig9es ,liturgicae1 ,william ,palm]4 #ahcc-da4 ,tracts = ! ,times4 #ahdj4 ,conf]5ces on ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 ,edw>d ,c>dwell4 #ahdc4 ,! ,*oral ,s]vice ( ! ,*ur*es ( ,engl& & ,irel&1 ,john ,jebb4 #ahdd4 ,! ,anci5t ,liturgy ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 ,william ,maskell4 #ahde4 ,pick]+'s ,repr9ts ( ! ,pray] ,books ( #aedi1 #aeeb1 #aeei1 #afjc1 & #affb4 #ahdf4 ,monum5ta ,ritualia1 ,william ,maskell4 #ahdg4 ,reliquiae ,liturgicae1 ,pet] ,hall4 #ahdh4 ,fragm5ta ,liturgica1 ,pet] ,hall4 #ahdi4 ,book ( ,common ,pray] ) ,notes legal & hi/orical1 ,a4 ,j4 ,/eph5s4 ,manuscript ,book ( ,common ,pray] = ,irel&1 ,a4 ,j4 ,/eph5s4 ,tetralogia ,liturgica1 ,john ,mason ,neale4 #ahec4 ,two ,liturgies ( ,edw>d ,,vi41 ,edw>d ,c>dwell4 #ahee4 ,pr9ciples ( ,div9e ,s]vice1 ,philip ,freeman4 ,hi/ory ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 ,f4 ,proctor4 #aheh4 ,hi/ory ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 ,t4 ,la?bury4 #ahei4 ,directorium ,anglicanum1 ,j4 ,pur*as4 #ahfa4 ,anci5t ,collects1 ,william ,bright4 #ahfe4 ,lib] ,precum ,public>um1 ,bright & ,m$d4 #ahfe4 ,! ,prie/'s ,pray] ,book4 #ahfe4 ,hi/ory ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 ,r4 ,p4 ,blak5ey4 #ahff4 ,! ,pray] ,book ,int]leav$1 ,campion & ,beaumont4 #ahff4 ,! ,annotat$ ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 ,j4 ,h4 ,blunt4 #ahgj4 ,! ,liturgy ( ! ,*ur* ( ,s>um1 ,translat$1 ,*>les ,walk]4 #ahgj4 ,! ,fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi4 ) ! ,ord9al1 ,walton & ,m$d4 #ahgb4 ,psalms & ,litanies1 ,r[l& ,williams4 #ahgb4 ,notitia ,eu*>i/ica1 ,w4 ,e4 ,scudamore4 #ahge-hj4 ,diction>y ( ,*ri/ian ,antiquities1 ,smi? & ,*ee?am4 #ahgf4 ,fir/ ,pray] ,book ( ,edw>d ,,vi41 comp>$ ) ! successive ,revisions1 ,james ,p>k]4 #ahgg4 ,introduction to ! ,hi/ory ( ! successive ,revisions ( ! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 ,james ,p>k]4 #ahgh4 ,liturgies--,ea/]n & ,we/]n1 ,c4 ,e4 ,hammond4 #ahhj4 ,! ,convocation ,pray] ,book4 #ad ,tract ,no4 #c4 ,?\ghts respectfully address$ to ! ,cl]gy on alt]ations 9 ! ,liturgy4 #ae ,"o ( ! mo/ curi\s illu/rations ( ! spread ( ,anglican ideas ab\t wor%ip n[ 9 progress is to be f\nd 9 ! upspr++ 9 ! v bosom ( ,scotti% ,presbyt]ianism ( a ,,*ur* ,,s]vice ,,society4 ,two ( ! publications ( ?is ,society h lately fall5 9 ! pres5t writ]'s way4 ,!y be> ! impr9t ( ,wm4 ,blackwood ,sons1 ,ed9burgh1 & are entitl$ respectively1 ,a ,book ( ,common ,ord]1 & ,home ,pray]4 ,) que/ionable good ta/e ! compil]s h giv5 to ! =m] "w a ,greek & to ! latt] a ,lat9 sub-title 7,evxolioyiov & ,suspiria ,dome/ica74 ,bo? books h _m admirable po9ts1 al?\gh1 9 view ( ! facts ( hi/ory1 !re is a ludicr\s side to ?is attempt to comm5d ,engli% vi&s to ,nor!rn palates "u a ?9 g>niture ( ,scotti% h]bs :i* probably has n :olly escap$ ! notice ( ! compil]s !mselves4 #af ,see ,! ,gu>dian 7,london71 ,febru>y #i1 #ahha4 #ag ,unless f9ally to beat d[n ,satan "u our feet1 be reckon$ an exception4 #ah ,lectures on ,ju/ification1 p #chj4 #ai ,! rationale ( ?is curi\s lapse is simple4 ,! ,am]ican revis]s1 in/ead ( transf]r+ ! ,comm9ation ,(fice 9 toto to ! new book1 wisely decid$ to engraft c]ta9 features ( x ^u ! ,morn+ ,pray] = ,a%-,w$nesday4 ,9 ! process1 ! fifty-fir/ ,psalm1 :i* has a recogniz$ place 9 ! ,comm9ation1 dropp$ out1 in/ead ( be+ transf]r$1 z x %\ld h be51 to ! prop] psalms4 #bj ,see ! ,convocation ,pray] ,book4 #ba ,pray] ,book ,int]leav$1 p4 #fe4 #bb ,a curi\s illu/ration ( ! s5sitiv5ess ( ! ,prote/ant ,episcopal m9d to any?+ t c be suppos$ ev5 remotely to endang] our doctr9al settlem5t 0 af=d$ at ! late ,g5]al ,conv5tion1 :5 ! ,h\se ( ,deputies 0 ?r[n into some?+ v l a panic by a mo/ h>mless sugge/ion ) ref]5ce to ! op5+ s5t5ces ( ! ,litany4 ,a v5]able & ?or\ghly cons]vative deputy f ,s\? ,c>ol9a _h v5tur$ to say t x w\ld be doctr9ally an improvem5t if ! t5et ( ! d\ble procession ( ! ,holy ,gho/ 7 to be remov$ f ! ?ird ( ! invocations1 & a devotional improvem5t if ! language ( ! f\r? 7 to be phras$ 9 words m lit]ally ,scriptural & less m>k$ly !ological ?an ^? at pres5t 9 use4 ,eag] def5d]s ( ! fai? in/antly leap$ to _! feet 9 v>i\s p>ts ( ! ,h\se1 p]suad$ t a deadly ?ru/ _h be5 aim$ at ! doctr9e ( ! ,tr9ity4 ,nev] 0 !re a m gratuit\s misconception4 ,! real intr5*m5t ( ! doctr9e ( ! ,tr9ity1 s f> z ! ,litany is conc]n$1 lies 9 ! f\r op5+ words ( ! second & ! five op5+ words ( ! ?ird ( ! invocations1 & ^! x _h n be5 propos$ to t\*4 ,9 confirmation ( ?is view ( ! matt]1 x is p]t95t to in/ance ! ,book ( ,family ,pray]s lately put =? by a ,committee ( ! ,upp] ,h\se ( ! ,convocation ( ,cant]bury4 ,?is manual provides no few] ?an six diff]5t ,litanies1 all ( !m op5+ ) addresses to ! ?ree ,p]sons ( ! adorable ,tr9ity1 & yet 9 no "o in/ance is ! pr9ciple advocat$ by ! deputy f ,s\? ,c>ol9a unrecogniz$4 ,e "o ( ! six ,litanies beg9s ) language simil> to t :i* he recomm5d$4 ,see also 9 witness ( ! m$iaeval use1 :i* p>tially be>s out ,mr4 ,mc,crady's ?\ght1 ! anci5t ,litany repr9t$ by ,maskell f ,! ,prym] 9 ,engli%4 ,mon4 ,hit4 ii4 p4 #ie4 ,if ! ,upp] ,h\se ( ! ,convocation ( ,cant]bury1 fondly suppos$ by u ,anglicans to be ! v citadel ( s\nd doctr9e1 be ?us ta9t$ ) h]esy1 ^u :at c we dep5d8 ,polemical consid]ations aside1 probably ev5 ! mo/ or?odox w\ld all[ t ! invocations ( ! ,litany might ga9 9 devotional p[]1 :ile los+ no?+ 9 augu/ maje/y1 7 ! ?ird to run--,o ,god ! ,holy ,gho/1 ,sanctifi] ( ! fai?ful1 h m]cy ^u u mis]able s9n]s4 ,& ! f\r? z 9 ,bi%op ,heb]'s glori\s hymn1 ,holy1 ,holy1 ,holy1 ,"l ,god ,almighty1 h m]cy ^u u mis]able s9n]s4 ,b all ?is is doctr9al & pla9ly ultra vires4 #bc ,a v natural explanation1 by ! way1 ( ! fact1 (t5 notic$1 t !re is no petition 9 ! ,litany = an increase ( ! m9i/ry4 #bd ,"h1 i4 e41 9 connection ) ,sa9ts' ,day s]vices1 w\ld be an admirable opportunity = ! introduction into liturgical use ( ! ,beatitudes4 ,:at c\ld possibly be m appropriate8 ,& yet ^! mu* lov$ words ( ,*ri/ h seldom be5 giv5 ! place 9 wor%ip !y des]ve4 ,!y d f9d recognition z an antiphon 9 ! ,liturgy ( ,/4 ,*ryso/om4 ,to reass]t a usage associat$ 9 ! hi/ory ( liturgies ) ! "n ( ?is ,fa!r ( ! ,*ur* & ) 8 "n only1 w\ld be to pay him bett] honor ?an we n[ %[ by ?ree times ins]t+ 9 our ,pray] ,book ! collect conjecturally 8--a ?+ ! ,gold5-m\!d himself1 :5 9 ! fle%1 w\ld n h dream$ ( do+4 ,once1 he w\ld h said1 is en\gh4 #be ,! ,prie/'s ,pray] ,book has #fhh 7667 mo/ly juiceless4 #bf ,9 connection ) ?is clause !re sprang up an animat$ & int]e/+ debate 9 ! ,h\se ( ,deputies z to ! wisdom ( ?us seem+ to cut (f e opportunity = extempor>y pray] 9 our public s]vices4 ,up to ?is "t1 x 0 alleg$1 a lib]ty _h exi/$ ( us+ aft] s]mon1 if ! prea*] 7 dispos$ to d s1 ! free pray] :i* be=e s]mon x 0 confess$ly n p]mitt$ him to h--:y ?us cut (f p]emptorily an anci5t privilege8 :y ?us %>ply annul a traditional if n a *>t]$ "r8 ,at fir/ sight ?is di/9ction betwe5 be=e & aft] s]mon looks bo? arbitr>y & artificial1 b :5 exam9$ !re is f\nd to be a reason 9 x4 ,! s]mon1 especially 9 ! case ( emotional prea*]s1 is a sort ( bridge ( transition f :at we may call ! liturgical to ! spontane\s mood ( m9d1 & if ! speak] has c>ri$ 8 li/5]s ) him !y are across ! bridge at ! same mom5t ) himself4 ,! ?+ t w\ld h be5 incongru\s be=e1 becomes natural aft] ! m9i/] has be5 = "s "t speak+ less 9 8 prie/ly ?an 9 8 p]sonal "*4 ,! notion t ! po9ts at issue betwe5 ! advocates ( liturgical & ! advocates ( extemporane\s wor%ip c be settl$ by a promiscu\s jumbl+ toge!r ( ! two modes1 is a fond conceit1 z ! ,re=m$ ,episcopalians w d\btless confess :5 !y %all h _h "t en\gh to make full trial ( ! foll[+ rubrics 9 _! ,pray]-book3 ,!n %all ! ,m9i/] say ! ,collects & ,pray]s foll[+ 9 :ole or 9 "p1 or o!rs at 8 discretion4 ,"h may be us$ any ( ! occasional ,pray]s1 or extemporane\s ,pray]4 ,?is is bad philosophy4 ,x ne$ n be said t su* directions are undevotional--= d\btless !y 7 pi\sly meant2 b x mu/ be said t !y are in>ti/ic 7if ! ^w may be all[$71 at v>iance ) ! fitness ( ?+s & c\nt] to ! in/9ct ( purity4 ,=mality & in=mality are two ?+s t _c be m+l$ to advantage4 ,!re is place & "t = ea*4 ,! secret ( ! p[] ( liturgical wor%ip is wrapp$ up ) ! pr9ciple ( ord]4 ,a c]ta9 maje/y lies 9 ! movem5t :i* is )\t break4 ,on ! o!r h& ! *>m ( extemporane\s devotion1 & x is sometimes a v real *>m1 is traceable to our natural int]e/ 9 :atev] is irregul>1 fre%1 & spontane\s4 ,to suppose t we c secure at any giv5 "t ! good effects ( bo? me?ods by "s trick ( comb9ation is an error--z well attempt to arrange on ! same plot ( gr\nd a ,fr5* & an ,engli% g>d54 ,if inde$ ,*ri/ian p c\ld br+ !mselves to ackn[l$ge frankly ! legitimacy ( bo? me?ods & provide amicably = _! sep>ate use1 a great /ep =w>d 9 ! direction ( ,*ur* unity w\ld h be5 a*iev$2 b = a ca?olicity s ca?olic z ?is1 public op9ion is n yet ripe1 & p]haps may n be ripe = c5turies to come4 ,^? :o believe 9 ! excell5cy ( liturgies1 :ile n believ+ 9 !m z jure div9o1 w\ld be well cont5t 9 su* a case to wait ! work+ ( ! pr9ciple ( ! survival ( ! fitte/4 #bg ,! able & fair-m9d$ juri/ :o fir/ hit ^u ?is +5i\s s*eme = pat*+ ! ,ratification has lately1 ) *>act]i/ic frankness1 said sub/antially ?is "u 8 own signature4 ,! prop] place = ! am5dm5t1 he writes1 is at ! end ( ! fir/ rubric prec$+ ! s5t5ces ( ,scripture = bo? ,morn+ & ,ev5+ ,pray]1 aft] ! ^w ,scripture1 z ev]yone c see by look+4 ,he adds3 ,?is1 h[ev]1 is only a "q ( =m1 & ought n to int]f]e ) ! adoption ( ! am5dm5t at ! next ,conv5tion4 ,x is to be hop$ t ! resolution = enri*m5t1 s call$1 w pres5t a v>iety ( additions out ( :i* an acceptable selection c be made2 & :5 !y are f9ally c>ri$ t ! ,book ( ,common ,pray] w be n only ! /&>d book1 b a seal$ book1 s to speak1 = z _m g5]ations z h pass$ s9ce ! pres5t book 0 adopt$4--,lett] ( ! ,hon4 ,j4 ,b4 ,h[e ( ,indiana 9 ,! ,*ur*man = ,janu>y #bi1 #ahha4 #bh ,see page #egh ( ,evangelical ,ca?olic ,pap]s4 ,a collection ( ,essays1 ,lett]s1 & ,tractates f ,writ+s ( ,rev4 ,wm4 ,augu/us ,muhl5b]g1 ,d4 ,d4 dur+ ! la/ =ty ye>s4 ,! failure ( ?is dev\t & v5]at$ man to secure sundry mu* desir$ liturgical improvem5ts 7al?\gh x yet rema9s to be se5 :e!r ! failure has be5 total7 0 p]haps due to a c]ta9 vagu5ess inh]5t 9 8 plans ( re=m4 ,a cle> vision ( ! v ?+ desir$ seems to h be5 lack+1 or at lea/ ! gift ( imp>t+ x to o!rs4 ,b ev5 z no man has des]v$ bett] ( ! ,am]ican ,episcopal ,*ur* ?an he1 s x is no m ?an "r t 8 deeply *]i%$ wi%es %\ld be _h 9 c>eful remembrance4 #bi ,n[ a black-lett] day 9 ! ,engli% ,cal5d>4 #cj ,! ,convocation ,pray] ,book1 9 loc4 #ca ,orig9ally only an explanatory rubric4 ,see ,proct]1 p4 #cig4 #cb ,let u hope t be=e long !re may be devis$ "s bett] way ( provid+ relief = our ,wid[s & ,orphans ?an t ( ! indirect taxation ( ! s+]s ( hymns4 #cc ,! ,greek ,(fice ,books1 x is said1 fill eighte5 qu>tos4 #cd ,9 t naive & racy bit ( ,engli% 7omitt$ 9 our ,am]ican book7 entitl$ ,conc]n+ ! ,s]vice ( ! ,*ur*1 "o ( ! v *oice/ morsels is ! foll[+3 ,moreov]1 ! numb] & h>dness ( ! ,rules call$ ! ,pie1 & ! manifold *ang+s ( ! ,s]vice1 0 ! cause1 t to turn ! ,book only 0 s h>d & intricate a matt]1 t _m times !re 0 m bus9ess to f9d out :at %\ld be read ?an to read x :5 x 0 f\nd out4 #ce ,x may be wise to buttress ! position tak5 ) a quotation out ( ,dr4 ,coit4 ,we really1 h[ev]1 d n see any necessity = ei!r ( ^! ,s]vices 9 ,am]ican ,books1 z ) u ! ,ord9al always1 n[1 makes a "p ( ! ,pray] ,book 9 all editions4 ,x w\ld be a sav+ to expunge !m & no *ange w\ld be necess>y1 except ! introduction ( su* a litanical petition & suffrage ) ! ,s]vices = ,deacons & ,prie/s1 z already exi/s 9 ! ,s]vice = ,bi%ops4 ,! ,*ur* ( ,engl& reta9s ! ,litany 9 h] ,ord9al1 = t1 until latt]ly1 0 pr9t$ 9 a sep>ate book1 & 0 n to be _h unless ord]$ expressly4 ,& yet ) ev5 su* a practice %e has b "o ,communion ,s]vice4 ,we /udy *eapness & exp$ition 9 our day4 ,!y c bo? be consult$ "h1 salvafide et salva ecclesia4--,report ( #ahdd4 #cf ,fir/ pr9t$ 9 ,! ,*ur* ,review1 #ahhf4 #cg ,! ,rev4 ,dr4 ,orl&o ,hutton4 #ch ,prie/'s ,pray] ,book1 ,fif? edition1 pp4 #bch1 #bdc1 #bha4 #ci ,! ,pray] = ,imprison$ ,debtors is believ$ to be ! only =mul>y actually dropp$4 #dj ,! ,*ur* ,qu>t]ly ,review = ,april1 #ahhd1 & ,july1 #ahhd4 ,! ,*ur* ,times = ,augu/ #bi1 #ahhd2 also ,july #ca1 ,augu/ #g1 #ad1 #ba1 #bh1 ,septemb] #d1 #ahhe4 ,! ,gu>dian = ,july #bj1 #ahhe4 #da ,recall ! ,additional ,hymns ( #ahfh4 #db ,?is proposal ( arbitration has occasion$ s mu* innoc5t mir? t1 9 ju/ice to ! mak] ( x1 att5tion %\ld be call$ to ! ambiguity ( ! language 9 :i* x is c\*$4 ,! word+ ( ! passage is vague4 ,x is j possible t by ! "q :i* he w\ld be cont5t to submit to ! judgm5t ( ! f\r specifi$ m5 ( lett]s1 he means1 n1 z he has be5 und]/ood to mean1 ! :ole subject-matt] ( ,! ,book ,annex$1 b only ! ab/ract "q :e!r v]bal v>iations f ! ,engli% orig9al ( ! ,common ,pray] be or be n1 on gr\nds ( purity ( /yle1 desirable4 ,ev5 if ?is be all t he means !re is p]haps /ill room = a smile1 b1 at all ev5ts1 he ought to h ! b5efit ( ! d\bt4 #dc ,discussions & ,argum5ts1 p4 #cda4 #dd ,! li/ might be br\ght d[n z late z ! au?orities pleas$ to br+ x1 ev5 to include1 if !y *ose1 su* names z ,john ,keble1 ,james ,de ,kov51 & ,f]d9& ,ew]4--,! ,*ur* ,times = ,augu/ #ad1 #ahhe4 #de ,?is =m ( absolution sugge/$ z an alt]nate 9 ,! ,book ,annex$ is tak5 f ! s\rce m5tion$4 #df ,! pap] read by ! ,dean ( ,worce/] dealt exclusively ) ! legal aspects ( ! "q z x conc]ns ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 #dg ,! ,rev4 ,edg> ,morris ,dumbleton 7,rector ( ,/4 ,james's1 ,exet]74 #dh ,! ,rev4 ,george ,v5ables 7,hon4 ,canon ( ,norwi* & ,vic> ( ,great ,y>m\?74 #di ,! ,rev4 ,ar?ur ,james ,rob9son 7,rector ( ,:ite*apel74 #ej ,see lett] ( ,j4 ,l4 ,w4 9 ,! ,s\!rn ,*ur*man = ,augu/ #f1 #ahhe4 #ea ,see lett] ( ,rituali/ 9 ,! ,/&>d ( ! ,cross = ,july #b1 #ahhe4 #eb ,see ! ,report ( ! ,committee ( ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,diocese ( ,wiscons91 passim4 #ec ,! evid5t int5tion ( ! ,jo9t ,committee 9 ! introduction ( ?is ,canticle 0 to make x possible to %ort5 ! ,morn+ ,pray] on week-days1 )\t spoil+ ! /ructure ( ! (fice1 z is n[ (t5 done1 by leav+ out "o ( ! ,lessons4 ,x is c]ta9ly op5 to "q :e!r a bett] alt]nate might n h be5 provid$1 b x is surpris+ to f9d s well furni%$ a s*ol> z ! ,wiscons9 critic speak+ ( ! ,b5$ictus es ,dom9e z a liturgical novelty1 d]iv$ nei!r f ! ,anglican or ! m anci5t s]vice-hooks4 ,z a matt] ( fact ! ,b5$ictus es ,dom9e 0 sung daily 9 ! ,ambrosian ,rite at ,mat9s1 & is f\nd also 9 ! ,moz>abic ,brevi>y4 #ed ,see ,wiscons9 ,report1 p4 #e4 #ee ,see ! precautions recomm5d$ 9 ,! ,liv+ ,*ur* ,annual = #ahhf1 p4 #acb1 art4 ,tab]nacle4 #ef ,9 ?is respect ,! ,book ,annex$ may be comp>$ to ,! ,convocation ,pray] ,book publi%$ by ,murray 9 #ahhj1 = ! purpose ( %[+ :at ! ,engli% ,book w\ld be l if am5d$ 9 con=mity ) ! recomm5dations ( ! ,convocations ( ,cant]bury & ,york1 conta9$ 9 reports pres5t$ to h] ,maje/y ! ,que5 9 ! ye> #ahgi4 #eg ,! ,report 0 adopt$4 #eh ,9 addition to ! ,m>yl& ,report we h n[ a /ill m admirable "o f ,c5tral ,new ,york4 #ei ,/rangely en\gh ! ,elizabe?an p]iod1 s ri* 9 g5ius ( e o!r type1 seems to h be5 almo/ :olly b>r5 ( liturgical p[]4 ,m5 _h n ceas$ to write pray]s1 z a /\t volume 9 ! ,p>k] ,society's ,libr>y abundantly evid5ces2 b !y _h ceas$ to write !m ) ! t]s5ess & melody t give to ! /yle ( ! great ,*ur*m5 ( ! e>li] reigns s s+ul> a *>m4 #fj ,! liturgical manuscripts ( ,s&]son & ,wr51 made public only rec5tly by ! late ,bi%op ( ,*e/]1 ought to be includ$ "u ?is head4 #fa ,_m ( ^! ,treasuries1 ,gold5 ,gates1 & ! l1 h "h & !re some?+ good1 b = ! mo/ "p !y are disfigur$ by s9s aga9/ t sob] /&>d ( feel+1 ?an :i*1 z a high au?ority assures u1 no?+ except a s\nd rule ( fai? is m important 9 matt]s ( practical religion4 ,( all ( !m1 ,scudamore's unpret5ti\s little ,manual is1 p]haps1 ! be/4 #fb ,= a conspectus ( ! v>i\s title-pages1 see ,keel+'s ,litugiae ,britannicae1 ,london1 #ahdb4 #fc ,! "q ( a *ange 9 ! "n ( ! ,*ur* is a con/itutional1 & 9 no s5se a liturgical "q4 ,let x be consid]$ at ! prop] "t1 & 9 a prop] way1 b :y ?ru/ x precipitately into a discussion to :i* x is ?or\ghly =eign8 #fd ,by ! ,m>yl& ,committee4 #fe ,?is p>agraph 0 writt5 be=e ! au?or _h be5 privileg$ to read ,pr(4 ,gold's int]e/+ pap] 9 ,! ,sem9>ian4 ,x is only prop] to say t ?is accompli%$ writ] & v compet5t critic does object emphatically to ! !ory t ! op5+ ,s5t5ces are design$ to give ! key-note ( ! ,s]vice4 ,b "h he diff]s ) ,blunt1 z else:]e 9 ! same pap] he diss5ts f ,freeman & f ,littl$ale1 admirably illu/rat+ by 8 prop] ass]tion ( an indep5d5t judgm5t1 ! difficulty ( apply+ ! ,vic5tian rule 9 liturgical criticism4 ,su* v>iations ( op9ion d1 inde$1 make aga9/ sci5ce1 b !y favor good s5se4 #ff ,*amb]s's ,translation4 #fg ,?is is n to be und]/ood z an ackn[l$gm5t t ! doctr9al & philological objections to ! =mul>y z x orig9ally /ood 7 s\nd & suffici5t4 ,on ! lips ( a ,*ur* :i* decl>es rep5tance to be an act :]eby we =sake s91 a pray] = "t does n seem :olly inappropriate1 :ile z = ?is use ( ! ^w space ( :i* compla9t 0 made1 x %\ld be notic$ t ,k+ ,james's ,bible gives u n9ete5 prec$5ts = x2 & ! ,pray] ,book itself "o4 #fh ,9 ,! ,book ,annex$1 z orig9ally pres5t$1 !re /ood 9 ?is place ! beautiful & appropriate psalm1 ,levavi oculos4 ,b ! exp]ts decl>$ t ?is w\ld nev] d1 s9ce f "t immemorial ,levavi oculos _h be5 a ,vesp] ,psalm1 & x w\ld be little less ?an sacrilege to ins]t x 9 a morn+ s]vice1 h[ev] congru\s to su* a use ! word+ ( x might1 to an unsci5tific m9d1 appe>4 ,accord+ly ! excision 0 made2 b ^u inquiry x turn$ out t ! monks _h possess$ a l>g] measure ( good s5se1 z well z a bett] exegesis1 ?an ! ,conv5tion _h attribut$ to !m1 = ,levavi oculos1 x appe>s1 besides be+ a ,vesp] psalm1 /ood assign$1 9 ! ,s>um ,brevi>y1 to ,prime z well2 ! fact be+ t ! psalm is alike adapt$ to morn+ & to ev5+ use1 & s+ul>ly appropriate bo? to ! go+ out & ! com+ 9 ( ! daily life ( man4 #fi ,see p4 #f4 #gj ,o ,"l1 b[ ?9e e>1 has be5 sugge/$ z a sub/itute4 ,x is 9 ! words ( ,holy ,scripture1 x is ! precise metrical equival5t ( ,o ,"l1 save ! que51 & x is directly antiphonal to ! v]sicle :i* foll[s4 ,!re be+ no ,e/abli%$ ,*ur* 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 x is d\btful :e!r any pray]s = rul]s are desirable1 ov] & above ^? we already h4 ,& if ?is po9t be conc$$1 ! o!r consid]ations m5tion$ may be all[$ to h weight 9 favor ( ,o ,"l1 b[ ?9e e>4 #ga ,! ,sem9>ian1 #ahhf1 pp4 #bi1 #cj4 #gb ,x may be well to ?r[1 into a foot-note a s+le illu/ration ( :at might o!rwise be ?\ght an extravagant /atem5t4 ,! ,rev4 ,w4 ,c4 ,bi%op1 writ+ 9 ,! ,*ur* ,eclectic = ,febru>y1 #ahhd1 says3 ,! s]vice ( ! ,beatitudes propos$ by ! ,committee is j "o ( 'fancy-liturgy mak+1' :i* ought to be summ>ily reject$4 ,we h m ?an en\gh ( ?is sort ( ?+ already2 ! comm&m5ts1 com=table words1 et hoc g5us omne1 are any?+ b 'unique glories' ( our ,liturgy4 ,any?+ ( :i* we h exclusive possession is ne>ly c]ta9 to be a 'unique blund]1' in/ead ( any?+ bett]1 because ! *ances are a ?\s& to "o t any?+ really beautiful or edify+ w\ld h be5 discov]$ by1 & h comm5d$ itself to1 "s o!r ,*ri/ians 9 ! la/ two ?\s& ye>s4 ,if su* is to be ! nom5clature ( our new sci5ce1 ,devotion may well /& agha/ 9 ! face ( ,liturgies4 #gc ,see ! ,comm9ation ,(fice 9 ! ,pray] ,book ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 #gd ,daniel's ,codex ,liturgicus1 vol4 iv4 p4 #cdc4 ,quot$ 9 ,diction>y ( ,*ri/ian ,antiquities4 ,! translation ( makapismoi has be5 d\bt$2 b ,dr4 ,neale & ,pr(4 ,*ee?am agree t ! ref]5ce is to ! ,,beatitudes ( ! ,gospel4 #ge ,*ur* ,eclectic = ,april1 #ahhd4 #gf ,! foll[+ w s]ve z an illu/ration3 ,! ,an!m2 ,bless$ are ! m]ciful1 = !y %all get m]cy2 bless$ are ! clean 9 ! he>t1 = !y %all see ,god4 ,! ,v]sicle3 ,"l he> my pray]4 ,! ,answ]3 ,& let my cry come to !e4 ,let u pray4 ,"l ,jesu ,*ri/1 ^: prop]ty is to be m]ciful1 :i* art alway pure & clean )\t spot ( s92 ,grant u ! grace to foll[ !e 9 m]cifulness t[>d our neighbors1 & always to be> a pure he>t & a clean consci5ce t[>d !e1 t we may aft] ?is life see !e 9 ?y ev]la/+ glory1 :i* live/ & reigne/ ,god1 _w )\t end4 ,am54 #gg ,x is int]e/+ & sugge/ive to obs]ve ) h[ mu* less frequ5cy our att5tion is call$ to ?is p>agraph ( ! ,preface ?an to ! lat] "o :i* ass]ts hi/orical cont9uity ) ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 #gh ,essays on ,liturgiology1 p4 #bbf4 #gi ,! response propos$ by ! ,commission]s ran1 ,"l h m]cy ^u u1 & make u p>tak]s ( ?is bless+1 a pray] unobjectionable = sub/ance1 b pa9fully p$e/rian 9 /yle4 #hj ,notably "o 9 :i* ! responses are all tak5 f ,psalm li4 #ha ,see ,note at ! end ( ?is ,pap]4 #hb ,e4 g43 ,t x may please !e to s5d =? labor]s into ?y h>ve/1 & to h m]cy ^u all m54 #hc ,see ,report1 pp4 #f-i4 #hd ,/rike x out1 said ! lit]ali/ ( a c]ta9 committee on hymnody1 _m ye>s ago1 z he & 8 colleagues 7 sitt+ 9 judgm5t on ,watts's noble hymn1 ,!re is a l& ( pure delight4 ,ei!r /rike out ! :ole hymn or alt] t ^w1 'liv+4' ',bright fields1 beyond ! swell+ flood1 ,/& dress$ 9 liv+ gre54' ,:at s5se is !re 9 'liv+' gre58 ,x is ! grass t lives1 n ! gre54 ,happily ! sugge/ion fail$ to f9d a second]4 ,b revis]s1 ^: "w is to be pass$ ^u by ballot1 may well be %y ( idiomatic ,engli%4 ,take su* a phrase z1 ,n[ = ! com=tless tr\ble's sake ( ! ne$y2 ,l9dley ,murray1 7 he consult$1 w\ld h no m]cy on x3 & yet a m beautiful & t\*+ comb9ation ( words is n to be f\nd any:]e 9 ! ,psalt]4 ,x is ! utt] lack ( ?is idiomatic *>act]i/ic t makes ,lambe? pray]s prov]bially s insipid4 #he ,see ,report1 p4 #ab4 #hf ,quot$ 9 ,! ,*ur* ,eclectic = ,augu/1 #ahhf4 #hg ,pr(4 ,gold 9 ,! ,sem9>ian1 p4 #cd4 #hh ,! ,rev4 ,dr4 ,rob]t 9 ,! ,*ur*man = ,july #ag1 #ahhf1 #hi ,speci\s1 because our cont9uity ) ! ,*ur* life ( ,engl& is ine/imably preci\s2 impracticable1 because !re is no repres5tative body ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* au?oriz$ to treat ) u4 #ij ,?is ,pray] has be5 ga!r$ f ! ,dirige 9 ,! ,prim] set =? by ! ,k+'s ,maje/y & 8 ,cl]gy1 #aede2 ! same s\rce 7x is int]e/+ to note7 to :i* we trace ! ,engli% =m ( ! ,collect = ,purity at ! beg9n+ ( ! (fice4 #ia #a ,cor4 iii4 #i4 #ib ,born into life6--man gr[s ,=? f 8 p>5ts' /em1 ,& bl5ds _! bloods1 z ^? ,( !irs are bl5t 9 !m2 ,s ea* new man /rikes root into a f> =etime4 ,born into life6--we br+ ,a bias ) u "h1 ,&1 :5 "h1 ea* new ?+ ,affects u we come ne>2 ,to tunes we did n call our be+ mu/ keep *ime4 ,emp$ocles on ,etna4 #ic ,p>liam5ts1 prelates1 convocations1 synods may ord] =ms ( pray]4 ,!y may get spee*es to be spok5 upw>d by p on _! knees4 ,!y may obta9 a juxtaposition 9 space ( curi\sly tessellat$ pieces ( ,bible & ,pray] ,book4 ,b :5 ,i speak ( ! r>5ess & preci\sness ( pray]s1 ,i mean su* pray]s z conta9 ?ree conditions--p]man5ce1 capability jot be+ really pray$1 & univ]sality4 ,su* pray]s primates & s5ates c no m comm& ?an !y c ord] a new ,cologne ,ca!dral or ano!r epic poem4--,! ,bi%op ( ,b]ry's ,hampton ,lectures1 lect iv4 #id ,! foll[+ cat5a is curi\s3 ,salute "o ano!r ) an holy kiss4--,rom4 xvi4 #aj4 ,greet ye "o ano!r ) a kiss ( *>ity4--#a ,pet4 v4 #ad4 ,& let ! bi%op salute ! *ur*1 & say3 ,let ! peace ( ,god be ) y all4 ,& let ! p answ]1 ,& ) ?y _s4 ,& let ! deacon say to all1 ,salute "o ano!r ) a holy kiss4 ,& let ! cl]gy kiss ! bi%op2 & ( ! laity1 ! m5 ! m51 & ! wom5 ! wom51 & let ! *ildr5 /& by ! ,bema4 --,! ,div9e ,liturgy ( ,/4 ,clem5t 7,bretts's ,translation1 correct$ by ,neale74 ,at ,solemn ,high ,mass1 ! deacon kisses ! alt> at ! same "t ) ! celebrat+ prie/1 by :om he is salut$ ) ! kiss ( peace1 accompani$ by ^! words1 ,,pax ,,tecum4--,rubric ( ! ,roman ,missal4 ,,pax ,,or ,,paxbr$e4 ,a small plate ( gold1 or silv]1 or copp]-gilt1 enamell$1 or piece ( c>v$ ivory or wood ov]laid ) metal1 c>ri$ r\nd1 hav+ be5 kiss$ by ! prie/1 aft] ! ,agnus ,dei 9 ! ,mass1 to communicate ! kiss ( peace4--,pug9's ,gloss>y4 ,/4 ,george's ,*apel1 ,w9dsor4 ,item1 a f9e ,,pax1 silv] & gilt enamell$1 ) an image ( ! crucifixion1 ,m>y & ,john1 & hav+ on ! top ?ree crosses1 ) two %ields hang+ on ei!r side4 ,item1 a f]ial ,,pax1 ( plate ( silv] gilt1 ) ! image ( ! ,bless$ ,virg94--,dugdale's ,mona/icon quot$ 9 above ,gloss>y4 ,ye :o d truly & e>ne/ly rep5t y ( y\r s9s1 & are 9 love & *>ity ) y\r neighbors1 & int5d to lead a new life 4 4 4 ,draw ne> ) fai?1 & take ?is holy sacram5t to y\r com=t4--,%ort] ,exhortation 9 ! ,communion ,(fice ( ! ,pray] ,book4 #ie ,a fri5d :o he>d ! s]mon prea*$ has k9dly s5t me ! foll[+ apt illu/rations4 ,!y d n1 inde$1 come f hi/ory te*nically s-call$1 b !y report ! m9d ( "o to ^: eye ! :ole life ( ! ,middle ,ages 0 z an op5 book4 ,!re 0 n[ a pause1 ( :i* ! abbot avail$ himself by comm&+ ! bro!rhood to raise ! solemn *ant1 ,de pr(undis clamavi--,! ,mona/]y1 *ap1 xxxvii4 ',to be a gue/ 9 ! h\se :]e ,i %\ld comm&8' said ! ,templ>2 ',nev]6 ,*apla9s1 raise ! psalm1 ,qu>e fremu]unt ,g5tes8 ,knights1 squires1 & foll[]s ( ! ,holy ,temple1 prep>e to foll[ ! bann] ( ,beau-seant6'--,ivanhoe1 *ap4 xliv4 #if ,s _m good ?+s are wa%$ oat ( m5's memory by ! lapse ( ev5 a qu>t] ( a c5tury t possibly "s ev5 ( ^? :o knew all ab\t ! ,memorial 9 #aheb may be will+ to be rem9d$ :at its scope & purpose 74 ,! petition 0 address$ to ! bi%ops 9 c\ncil1 & pray$ = ! appo9tm5t ( a commission to report ^u ! practicability ( mak+ ?is ,*ur* a c5tral bond ( union among ! ,*ri/ian p ( ,am]ica1 by provid+ = z mu* fre$om 9 op9ion1 discipl9e1 & wor%ip z might be held to be compatible ) ! ess5tial fai? & ord] ( ! ,gospel4 ,! desir$ commission 0 appo9t$1 ,bi%ops ,otey1 ,doane1 ,a4 ,pott]1 ,burgess1 & ,williams be+ ! memb]s ( x4 ,_! ,report1 subsequ5tly edit$ 9 book =m by ,bi%op ,pott]1 is "o ( ! mo/ valuable docum5ts ( ,am]ican ,*ur* hi/ory4 ,! foll[+ extract f ,bi%op ,burgess' portion ( ! ,report w be read ) int]e/ by all :o ev] le>n$ to rev]e t !ologian = ! l>g5ess ( 8 le>n+1 ! calmness ( 8 judgm5t1 & ! goodness ( 8 he>t4 ,he has be5 speak+ ( liturgical *anges z contemplat$ & all[$ = by ! fram]s ( our ecclesia/ical sy/em4 ,!n he says3 ,!re w\ld seem to be five cont+5cies 9 :i* ! *anges1 ?us made possible & ?us p]mitt$1 become also wise & salut>y4 ,! fir/ is simply :5 x is evid5t t 9 any respect ! liturgy or its application may be r5d]$ m p]fect4 ,to haz>d = ?is result ! safety or unity ( ! ,*ur* may be inexcusable1 & ! utmo/ c]ta9ty may be dem&$ be=e a *ange ( ?is k9d %all be practically v5tur$4 ,b %\ld x be once e/abli%$1 beyond ! smalle/ d\bt1 t any addition or alt]ation w\ld increase ! excell5ce or ! excell5t influ5ce ( ! liturgy 9 any degree suffici5t to comp5sate or m ?an comp5sate = ! inconv5i5ces incid5t to all *ange1 x seems z difficult to say t x %\ld n be adopt$ by ! ,*ur*1 z to excuse any ,*ri/ian f add+ to 8 virtues or 8 usefulness4 ,! o!r 'cont+5cies' recogniz$ are briefly ^!3 7#b7 ,:5 9 process ( "t words or regulations h become obsolete or unsuitable4 7#c7 ,:5 civil or social *anges require ecclesia/ical *anges4 7#d7 ,:5 ! e>ne/ desire ( any respectable numb] ( ! memb]s ( ! ,*ur*1 or ( p]sons :o are )\t its communion1 is urg$ 9 behalf ( "s n :olly unreasonable proposal ( alt]ation4 7#e7 ,:5 error or sup]/ition has be5 introduc$2 :5 t :i* 0 at fir/ good & heal?ful has be5 p]v]t$ to ! n\ri%m5t ( falsehood or wick$ness2 or :5 t :i* 0 always evil has f\nd utt]ance1 & is n[ reveal$ 9 its true "*4 ,! ,memorial fail$ = ! reason t ! promot]s ( x _h n a cle>ly def9$ notion 9 _! own m9ds ( :at !y want$--! secret ( _m failures4 ,out ( its a%es !re may yet rise1 h[ev]1 "s bett] ?+ t ,god has kept 9 /ore4 #ig ,anci5t ,collects & ,o!r ,pray]s select$ = ,devotional ,use f ,v>i\s ,rituals4 ,by ,william ,bright1 ,m4 ,a4 ,j4 ,h4 ,jas4 ,p>k]1 ,ox=d & ,london4 ,f ! ,app5dix ,i take ! foll[+ illu/rations ( ! /atem5t v5tur$ above3 ,= ,guidance--,o ,god1 by :om ! meek are guid$ 9 judgm5t1 & light rise? up 9 d>kness = ! godly2 grant u 9 all our d\bts & unc]ta9ties ! grace to ask :at ?\ w\lde/ h u to d2 t ! ,_s ( wisdom may save u f all false *oices1 & t 9 ?y light we may see light1 & 9 ?y /raight pa? may n /umble3 ?r\gh ,jesus ,*ri/ our ,"l4 ,= ^? :o live 9 s94--,h m]cy1 ,o compassionate ,fa!r1 on all :o are h>d5$ ?r\gh ! deceitfulness ( s92 v\*safe !m grace to come to !mselves1 ! w & p[] to return to !e1 & ! lov+ welcome ( ?y =giv5ess ?r\gh ,jesus ,*ri/ our ,"l4 ,= all :o d ! "w ( ! ,*ur*4--,o ,"l1 )\t :om our labor is b lo/1 & ) :om ?y little ones g =? z ! mighty1 be pres5t to all works 9 ?y ,*ur* :i* are und]tak5 accord+ to ?y w1 & grant to ?y labor]s a pure int5tion1 pati5t fai?1 suffici5t success ^u e>?1 & ! bliss ( s]v+ !e 9 heav51 ?r\gh ,jesus ,*ri/ our ,"l4 ,= grace to speak ! ,tru? 9 love4--,o ,"l & ,savi\r ,jesus ,*ri/1 :o e>ne/ n to /rive nor cry1 b to let ?y words fall z ! drops t wat] ! e>?3 grant all :o cont5d = ! fai? once deliv]$1 nev] to injure x by clamor & impati5ce1 b speak+ ?y preci\s tru? 9 love1 s to pres5t x t x may be lov$1 & t m5 may see 9 x ?y goodness & ?y beauty3 :o live/ & reigne/ ) ! ,fa!r & ! ,holy ,gho/1 "o ,god1 _w )\t end4 ,bo? z reg>ds devotional flavor & lit]>y beauty ^! pray]s w1 ,i feel sure1 be judg$ wor?y1 by su* z w read !m m ?an once1 to /& by ! side c]ta9ly ( _m ( ! collects already 9 ! ,pray] ,book4 #ih ,prea*$ 9 ,grace ,*ur*1 ,n4 ,y41 on ! ,tw5tie? ,sunday aft] ,tr9ity1 t be+ ! ,sunday next foll[+ ! adj\rnm5t ( ! ,g5]al ,conv5tion ( #ahib4