,libr>ies47 ,,! ,,pap] ,,moneys ,,( ,,europe ,,_! ,,moral ,,& ,,economic ,,significance ,by ,,francis ,w4 ,,hir/ ,,bo/on ,,& ,,new ,,york ,,h\ghton ,,miffl9 ,,company ,! ,riv]side ,press ,cambridge #aibb ,,copyright1 #aibb1 ,,by ,,! ,,reg5ts ,,( ,,! ,,univ]sity ,,( ,,cali=nia ,,all ,,rights ,,res]v$ ,! ,riv]side ,press ,,cambridge ,,massa*usetts ,,pr9t$ ,,9 ,,! ,u4,s4,a4 ,,b>b>a ,,we9/ock ,,lectures ,,on ,,! ,,morals ,,( ,,trade ,?is s]ies w conta9 essays by repres5tative s*ol>s & m5 ( affairs deal+ ) ! v>i\s phases ( ! moral law 9 its be>+ on bus9ess life "u ! new economic ord]1 fir/ deliv]$ at ! ,univ]sity ( ,cali=nia on ! ,we9/ock f\ndation4 ,,! ,,pap] ,,moneys ,,( ,,europe ,,_! ,,moral ,,& ,,economic ,,significance ,no m sev]e reflection c\ld be pass$ ^u ! moral & political capacity ( ! human species ?an ?is3 ,five ?\s& ye>s aft] ! inv5tion ( writ+1 ?ree ?\s& aft] ! inv5tion ( money1 & 7ne>ly7 five hundr$ s9ce ! inv5tion ( pr9t+1 gov]nm5ts all ov] ! _w are employ+ ! ?ird inv5tion = ! purpose ( debas+ ! second2 !reby robb+ millions ( innoc5t individuals ( _! prop]ty on a scale s ext5sive t previ\s public confiscations ( private prop]ty ?r\gh ! adult]ation ( money--9 anci5t ,rome1 9 ,irel& "u ,james ! ,second1 9 ,prussia dur+ ! ,sev5 ,ye>s' ,w>1 9 ! ,am]ican colonies & ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 9 ,portugal1 9 ,greece1 9 v>i\s republics ( ,c5tral & ,s\? ,am]ica1 ev5 ! assignats ( ! ,fr5* ,revolution--seem pigmy frauds 9 comp>ison ) ! pres5t va/ inundation ( c\nt]feit pap] money4 ,9 ^! times1 :5 s mu* att5tion is giv5 to :at ,i may call ! prehi/oric hi/ory ( mank9d1 x w\ld ill become me1 a m]e adv5tur] 9 an?ropology1 to discuss ! orig9 ( money or to attempt an explanation ( ! curi\s fact t ! art ( co9+ money 0 inv5t$ & p]fect$ a ?\s& ye>s be=e ! art ( pr9t+4 ,! co9s /ruck by ! be/ cities ( anci5t ,greece are a model & a reproa* to our mod]n m9ts2 & be+ = ! mo/ "p ( good silv]1 !y fulfill$ ! two ma9 functions ( curr5cy--z a measure ( value & a m$ium ( ex*ange4 ,silv] 0 well adapt$ = ! purposes ( curr5cy by its ductility1 durability1 divisibility1 portability1 & value4 ,its value dep5d$ on ?ree ?+s4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 x 0 sc>ce2 9 ! second1 x 0 mu* 9 dem& = ! arts & manufactures2 & 9 ! ?ird place1 its intr9sic value 0 increas$ & /abiliz$ by ! ne$s & dem&s ( ! m9ts4 ,gold _h simil> qualifications1 b x 0 too sc>ce & too preci\s until ! n9ete5? c5tury1 9 ! c\rse ( :i* 7= reasons :i* ,i ne$ n ent] ^u "h71 mo/ ( ! great comm]cial nations adopt$ a gold /&>d4 ,copp] possess$ 9 a less degree ! qualifications ( gold & silv]1 b x 0 ! fir/ metal to be co9$ into money 9 anci5t ,rome4 ,! ,roman z or pondo weigh$ a ,roman p\nd ( good copp]1 !re=e possess$ ! two pr9cipal attributes ( good money1 a def9ite weight & a def9ite f95ess4 ,x 0 divid$ l our troy p\nd into twelve ounces ( good copp]4 ,! ,engli% ,troyes or ,troy p\nd 0 fir/ us$ 9 ! ,engli% m9t 9 ! "t ( ,h5ry ! ,eigh?4 ,edw>d ! ,fir/'s p\nd /]l+ 0 a ,t[] p\nd ( silv] ( a def9ite f95ess4 ,*>lemagne's livre 0 a ,troyes#a p\nd ( silv] ( def9ite f95ess4 ,! old ,engli% ,scot* p5ce or p5nies conta9$ orig9ally a real p5nyweight ( silv]1 "o tw5tie? ( an ounce & "o two hundr$ & =tie? ( a p\nd4 ,! fam\s pre-w> ,engli% sov]eign1 n[ demonetiz$ & misrepres5t$ by ! depreciat$ pap] p\nd1 0 itself also a weight2 b ! tw5ty %ill+s & two hundr$ & =ty p5ce :i* ex*ang$ = x 7 tok5 co9s dep5d+ = _! value ^u ! gold sov]eign4 #a ,! ,fair ( ,troyes 9 ,*ampaign 0 at t "t frequ5t$ by all ! nations ( ,europe1 & ! weights & measures ( s fam\s a m>ket 7 g5]ally kn[n & e/eem$4 7,adam ,smi?1 ,weal? ( ,nations1 ,book ,i1 *ap1 ,,iv47 ,f ! "t ( ,*>lemagne among ! ,fr5*1 & f t ( ,william ! ,conqu]or among ! ,engli% wrote ,adam ,smi? 9 #aggf1 ! proportion betwe5 ! p\nd1 ! %ill+ & ! p5ny1 seems to h be5 uni=mly ! same z at pres5t1 ?\gh ! value ( ea* has be5 v diff]5t2 = 9 e c\ntry ( ! _w1 ,i believe1 ! av>ice & inju/ice ( pr9ces & sov]eign /ates1 abus+ ! confid5ce ( _! subjects1 h by degrees dim9i%$ ! real quantity ( metal :i* _h be5 orig9ally conta9$ 9 _! co9s4 ,! ,roman z1 9 ! latt] ages ( ! republic1 0 r$uc$ to ! tw5ty-f\r? "p ( its orig9al value1 &1 in/ead ( weigh+ a p\nd1 came to weigh only half an ounce4 ,! ,engli% p\nd & p5ny conta9 at pres5t ab\t a ?ird only2 ! ,scots p\nd & p5ny ab\t a ?irty-six?2 & ! ,fr5* p\nd & p5ny ab\t a sixty-six? "p ( _! orig9al value4 ,by means ( ^? op]ations1 ! pr9ces & sov]eign /ates :i* p]=m$ !m 7 enabl$1 9 appe>ance1 to pay _! debts & fulfil _! engagem5ts ) a small] quantity ( silv] ?an w\ld o!rwise h be5 requisite4 ,x 0 inde$ 9 appe>ance only2 = _! cr$itors 7 really defraud$ ( a "p ( :at 0 due to !m4 ,all o!r debtors 9 ! /ate 7 all[$ ! same privilege1 & might pay ) ! same nom9al sum ( ! new & debas$ co9 :atev] !y _h borr[$ 9 ! old4 ,su* op]ations1 !re=e1 h always prov$ fav\rable to ! debtor1 & ru9\s to ! cr$itor1 & h sometimes produc$ a great] & m univ]sal revolution 9 ! =tunes ( private p]sons1 ?an c\ld h be5 occasion$ by a v great public calamity4#b #b ,weal? ( ,nations1 ,book ,i1 *ap4 ,,iv4 ,john ,/u>t ,mill foll[s 8 ma/] 9 expos+ & d5\nc+ :at he calls ?is lea/ cov]t ( all =ms ( knav]y :i* consi/s 9 call+ a %ill+ a p\nd4 ,b ! op9ions ( ,mill1 ! sa9t ( rationalism1 des]ve & dem& citation z !y br+ u directly to our subject4 ,he writes3 ,:5 gold & silv] _h become virtually a m$ium ( ex*ange1 by becom+ ! ?+s = :i* p g5]ally sold1 & ) :i* !y g5]ally b\ght1 :atev] !y _h to sell or buy2 ! contrivance ( co9+ obvi\sly sugge/$ itself4 ,by ?is process ! metal 0 divid$ into conv5i5t portions1 ( any degree ( smallness1 & be>+ a recognis$ proportion to "o ano!r2 & ! tr\ble 0 sav$ ( weigh+ & assay+ at e *ange ( possessors1 an inconv5i5ce :i* on ! occasion ( small pur*ases w\ld soon h become insupportable4 ,gov]nm5ts f\nd x _! int]e/ to take ! op]ation into _! own h&s1 & to int]dict all co9+ by private p]sons2 inde$1 _! gu>antee 0 (t5 ! only "o :i* w\ld h be5 reli$ on1 a reliance h[ev] :i* v (t5 x ill des]v$2 pr(ligate gov]nm5ts hav+ until a v mod]n p]iod seldom scrupl$1 = ! sake ( robb+ _! cr$itors1 to conf] on all o!r debtors a lic5ce to rob !irs1 by ! %all[ & impud5t artifice ( l[]+ ! /&>d2 t lea/ cov]t ( all modes ( knav]y1 :i* consi/s 9 call+ a %ill+ a p\nd1 t a debt ( a hundr$ p\nds may be cancell$ by ! paym5t ( a hundr$ %ill+s4 ,x w\ld h be5 z simple a plan1 & w\ld h answ]$ j z well1 to h enact$ t a hundr$ %\ld always be int]pret$ to mean five1 :i* w\ld h effect$ ! same r$uction 9 all pecuni>y contracts1 & w\ld n h be5 at all m %ameless4 ,su* /rokes ( policy h n :olly ceas$ to be recomm5d$1 b !y h ceas$ to be practis$1 except occasionally ?r\gh ! m$ium ( pap] money1 9 :i* case ! "* ( ! transaction1 f ! great] obscurity ( ! subject is a little less b>efac$4#c #c ,mill1 ,political ,economy1 ,book ,,iii1 *ap4 ,,vii4 ,a few illu/rations f ! pa/ may help u to a critical contemplation ( ! pres5t monet>y conditions on ! cont95t ( ,europe1 :i* con/itute fraud & robb]y on ! mo/ :olesale scale ev] practis$ by gov]nm5ts 7) ! /yle & title ( democracies67 ^u ! mis]able victims1 call$ citiz5s1 & suppos$ to be end[$ ) ! bless+s ( self-det]m9ation4 ,^? :o believe t w>1 if n a div9e in/itution1 is at lea/ an inevitable feature ( human society may plead 9 ext5uation ( ?is species ( fraud t x is usually ! la/ desp]ate res\rce ( a gov]nm5t :i* has pl$g$ all its taxes & cr$it = w> or armam5ts4 ,i rememb] read+ 9 ! ,roman hi/orian ,sallu/ ( a f9ancial crisis :i* 0 end$ by debts contract$ 9 silv] be+ paid (f 9 copp]--arg5tum re solutum e/4 ,a few ye>s be=e ,adam ,smi? wrote 8 *apt] on money1 ,fr$]ick ! ,great1 dur+ ! ,sev5 ,ye>s' ,w>1 resort$ to ! ,jew1 ,ephraim1 :o co9$ t9 silv]3 ,outside noble1 inside slim1 ,outside ,fr$]ick1 inside ,ephraim4 ,b ,fr$]ick1 wis] & m hone/ ?an our ,european bellig]5ts1 made x 8 fir/ c>e aft] ! peace to re/ore an hone/ silv] co9age4 ,a lively example f ,engli%1 or r ,iri%1 hi/ory is suppli$ by ,macaulay & belongs to ! ye> #afhi4 ,x is "o ( ! incid5ts 9 ,james ! ,second's brief & luckless gov]nm5t ( ,irel&3 ,x is rem>kable t :ile ! ,k+ ,james ,,ii 0 los+ ! confid5ce & good w ( ! ,iri% ,commons by fa9tly def5d+ aga9/ !m1 9 "o qu>t]1 ! in/itution ( prop]ty1 he 0 himself1 9 ano!r qu>t]1 attack+ t in/itution ) a viol5ce1 if possible m reckless ?an !irs4 ,he soon f\nd t no money came into 8 ,ex*equ]4 ,! cause 0 suffici5tly obvi\s4 ,trade 0 at an end4 ,float+ capital _h be5 )drawn 9 great masses f ! isl&4 ,( ! fix$ capital mu* _h be5 de/roy$1 & ! re/ 0 ly+ idle4 ,?\s&s ( ^? ,prote/ants :o 7 ! mo/ indu/ri\s & intellig5t "p ( ! population _h emigrat$ to ,engl&4 ,?\s&s _h tak5 refuge 9 ! places :i* /ill held out = ,william & ,m>y4 ,( ! ,roman ,ca?olic peasantry1 :o 7 9 ! vigor ( life1 ! majority _h enli/$ 9 ! army or _h jo9$ gangs ( plund]]s4 ,! pov]ty ( ! treasury 0 ! necess>y effect ( ! pov]ty ( ! c\ntry3 public prosp]ity c\ld be re/or$ only by ! re/oration ( private prosp]ity2 & private prosp]ity c\ld be re/or$ only by ye>s ( peace & security4 ,james 0 absurd en\gh to imag9e t !re 0 a m spe$y & efficaci\s rem$y4 ,he c\ld1 he conceiv$1 at once extricate himself f 8 f9ancial difficulties by ! simple process ( call+ a f>?+ a %ill+4 ,! "r ( co9+ 0 und\bt$ly a fl[] ( ! pr]ogative2 &1 9 8 view1 ! "r ( co9+ includ$ ! "r ( debas+ ! co94 ,pots1 pans1 knock]s ( doors1 pieces ( ordnance :i* _h long be5 pa/ use1 7 c>ri$ to ! m9t4 ,9 a %ort "t lumps ( base metal1 nom9ally wor? ne> a million /]l+1 intr9sically wor? ab\t a sixtie? "p ( t sum1 7 9 circulation4 ,a royal edict decl>$ ^! pieces to be legal t5d] 9 all cases :atsoev]4 ,a mortgage = a ?\s& p\nds 0 cle>$ (f by a bag ( c\nt]s made out ( old kettles4 ,! cr$itors :o compla9$ to ! ,c\rt ( ,*anc]y 7 told by ,fitton to take _! money & be gone4 ,b ( all classes1 ! tradesm5 ( ,dubl91 :o 7 g5]ally ,prote/ants1 7 ! greate/ los]s4 ,at fir/1 ( c\rse1 !y rais$ _! dem&s2 b ! magi/rates ( ! city took on !mselves to meet ?is h]etical incl9ation by putt+ =? a t>iff regulat+ prices4 ,any man :o belong$ to ! ca/e n[ dom9ant might walk into a %op1 lay on ! c\nt] a bit ( brass wor? ?reep5ce1 & c>ry (f goods to ! value ( half a gu9ea4 ,legal rem$ies 7 out ( ! "q4 ,inde$ ! suff]]s ?\ght !mselves happy if1 by ! sacrifice ( _! /ock 9 trade1 !y c\ld r$eem _! limbs & _! lives4 ,!re 0 n a bak]'s %op 9 ! city r\nd :i* tw5ty or ?irty soldi]s 7 n con/antly pr[l+4 ,"s p]sons :o refus$ ! base money 7 arre/$ by troop]s & c>ri$ be=e ! ,provo/ ,m>%al1 :o curs$ !m1 swore at !m1 lock$ !m up 9 d>k cells1 &1 by ?reat5+ to hang !m at _! own doors1 soon ov]came _! resi/ance4 ,( all ! plagues ( t "t none made a deep] or a m la/+ impression on ! m9ds ( ! ,prote/ants ( ,dubl9 ?an ! plague ( brass money4 ,to ! recollection ( ! confusion & mis]y :i* _h be5 produc$ by ,james' co9 mu/ be 9 "p ascrib$ ! /r5u\s opposition :i*1 ?irty-five ye>s lat]1 l>ge classes firmly atta*$ to ! ,h\se ( ,hanov]1 (f]$ to ! gov]nm5t ( ,george ! ,fir/ 9 ! affair ( ,woods' ,pat5t4#d #d ,macaulay1 ,hi/ory ( ,engl&1 ,i1 *ap4 ,,xii4 ,! ,affair ( ,woods' ,pat5t is celebrat$ 9 ,swift's ,drapi] lett]s4 ,b pap] money (f]s f> m ext5sive facilities to knav]y ?an a metallic curr5cy4 ,9 8 ,essays on ! ,monet>y ,hi/ory ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1#e ,mr4 ,*>les ,j4 ,bullock has describ$ 9 suffici5t detail ! c>nival ( fraud & corruption :i* att5d$ ! pap] money co9$ or r pr9t$ by mo/ ( ! ,am]ican colonies 9 ! c5tury prec$+ ! ,am]ican ,revolution4 ,?us1 ab\t ! middle ( ! eighte5? c5tury1 ! pap] money ( ,massa*usetts fell to an eigh? ( its orig9al value4 ,p 7 driv5 to b>t]1 & "o writ] obs]v$ t ! morals ( ! p depreciate ) ! curr5cy4 ,p>ties 7 divid$ into debtors & cr$itors1 & a ,new ,engl& writ] 9 #agdi not$3 ,! ,debtor side has _h ! asc5dant ev] s9ce anno #agda to ! almo/ utt] ru9 ( ! c\ntry4#f ,to ?is writ] belongs ! cr$it ( disc]n+1 at a "t :5 ev5 ,b5jam9 ,frankl9 0 9 error1 t ! repeat$ l>ge emissions ( ,pap] ,money 7 responsible = its depreciation4 #e ,macmillan1 #aijj4 #f ,d\glass4 ,n wor? a ,cont95tal is an expression :i* br+s u to ! next *apt] 9 ,am]ican exp]i5ce ( inconv]tible pap] curr5cies4 ,! s-call$ ,cont95tal money 0 ! means by :i* ! ,cont95tal ,congress & ! individual colonies--too timid to tax--endeavor$ to f9ance ! ,revolution>y ,w>4 ,by #agha1 a pap] doll> 0 wor? less ?an two c5ts 9 specie1 & soon aft]w>d x became practically wor?less4#g ,robb]y 0 legaliz$2 rogues fl\ri%$2 & _! frauds 7 enc\rag$ & protect$ by a gov]nm5t ^: policy enabl$ debtors to pay _! debts 9 valueless money4 ,we he> ( cr$itors runn+ away f _! debtors & be+ paid (f )\t m]cy4 ,/ories 7 told ( cr$itors 9 ,rhode ,isl& leap+ out ( back w9d[s to escape ! att5tions ( _! debtors4#h ,9 %ort1 ! law became an eng9e ( oppression & de/roy$ ! =tunes ( ?\s&s :o _h put _! confid5ce 9 x4 ,9 ! words ( ,breck1 a fri5dly critic1 444 ! old debts 7 paid :5 ! pap] money 0 m ?an sev5ty to "o 444 wid[s1 orphans & o!rs 7 paid = money l5t 9 specie ) depreciat$ pap]4 #g ,bullock1 ,monet>y ,hi/ory ( ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 *ap4 ,v4 #h ,ibid41 *ap4 ,v4 ,9 #aghj ,congress actually adopt$ a plan to r$eem its pap] issues at "o =tie? ( _! pret5d$ or nom9al value4 ,! a/oni%+ ?+ is t all ?is knav]y 0 devis$1 or w9k$ at1 n only by l[ class politicians b by /atesm5 ( r5[n4 ,! maxim salus populi suprema lex 0 reli$ ^u n = ! fir/ or la/ "t z a suffici5t excuse = a crime f> m p]nici\s ?an t ( a private =g]4 ,b we h n yet realiz$1 9 our m9ds or 9 our p5al codes1 t public vices ought to be puni%$ at lea/ z vigor\sly z private crimes4 ,t1 ev5 z a desp]ate la/ resort = f9anc+ w>1 a flood ( pap] money defeats its own object 0 conclusively prov$ a few ye>s lat] dur+ ! ,fr5* ,revolution4 ,! ,fr5* assignats h tak5 _! place 9 hi/ory z ! classical example ( pap] money made wor?less by ov]-issue4 ,aft] _! f9al collapse 9 #agif1 ,fr5* f9ance rev]t$ p]=ce to a metallic basis4 ,s ,mr4 ,hawtrey1 a ,briti% ,treasury (ficial1 :o has giv5 u rec5tly a lucid & suffici5tly detail$ acc\nt ( ?is extraord9>y incid5t--extraord9>y b no long] s+ul>1 = ! same c\rse ) ! same results has be5 pursu$ dur+ & s9ce ! w> ( #aiad-aiah by ,russia & ,pol&1 & 9 a great] or less degree by mo/ ( ! ,european bellig]5ts4 ,! issue ( ,fr5* assignats began 9 #aghi because ! assembly w\ld n vote adequate taxation1 & ,neck]1 ! m9i/] ( f9ance1 0 unable to borr[ en\gh to cov] ! deficit4 ,9 ! two ye>s f #aghi to #agia1 ! public rev5ue 0 #dgj millions1 & ! public exp5ditures1 #agai millions1 ( livres4 ,! deficit 0 cov]$ by assignats1 or pap] livres1 be>+ int]e/1 9 d5om9ations v>y+ f #ajjj to #e livres4 ,?us ! assignats may be reg>d$ z a float+ debt curr5cy4 ,9 ,novemb]1 #agia1 ! assignats 7 wor? #eb p] c5t ( _! face value4 ,9 ,june1 #agib1 aft] ! decl>ation ( w> on ,au/ria1 !y rose to #eg4 ,aft] ! victory ( ,valmy1 9 ,septemb]1 !y rose to #gb & rema9$ !re till ,decemb]4 ,9 ,janu>y1 #agic1 ! k+ 0 guillot9$1 & w> 0 decl>$ on ,engl&4 ,by ,augu/1 aft] viol5t fluctuations1 ! assignat _h fall5 to #ae p] c5t ( its face value4 ,!reaft] ! laws en=c+ ! acceptance ( assignats 7 /r5g!n$4 ,x became an (f5ce to sell co91 or to diff]5tiate betwe5 co9 & assignats 9 any transaction1 or to refuse paym5t 9 assignats1 or to negotiate assignats at a disc\nt4 ,by a decree ( ! #e? ( ,septemb] ! dea? p5alty itself 0 impos$4 ,"h 0 a =c$ curr5cy inde$4#i #i ,r4 ,g4 ,hawtrey1 ,curr5cy & ,cr$it4 ,longmans ,gre5 ,co41 ,london1 #aiai4 ,= a few mon?s an artificial improvem5t 0 effect$ 9 ! value ( ! assignat by ^! f]oci\s measures2 b 9 #agie1 aft] ! ,t]ror1 ! sy/em & ! pap] money collaps$4 ,! gold & silv] money1 :i* _h be5 ho>d$1 return$ to circulation4 ,9 ,june1 #agie1 ! quotation ( ! assignat oscillat$ viol5tly4 ,on "o day a l\is ( #bd livres w\ld buy #dej pap] livres1 on ano!r1 #ajjj4aj ,pap] notes :i* fluctuat$ s viol5tly 7 useless z money4 ,!y c\ld n s]ve ei!r z a m$ium ( ex*ange or z a measure ( value4 ,c\ntry p express$ _! contempt = ! assignats by call+ !m l'arg5t de ,p>is4 ,a new curr5cy ( m&ats 0 tri$1 into :i* assignats 7 made conv]tible4 ,x 0 a complete failure4 ,! assignats 7 w\nd up 9 #agif1 & 9 ,febru>y1 #agig1 !re 0 a g5]al demonetisation ( pap] money4#aa ,! hold]s got practically no?+4 ,france return$ to h>d ca%1 z ,mexico has done rec5tly4 ,9 #aiah1 :5 ,mr4 ,hawtrey wrote1 he 0 able to describe ! decl9e & full ( ! assignats z an 'almo/ unique' in/ance ( ! curr5cy ( a great nation fad+ away into no?+4 ,! ,russian pap] r\ble has p]=m$ ! same feat s9ce #aiah4 ,s has ! ,poli% m>k4 ,& n[ 7,decemb]1 #aiba7 ! ,g]man pap] m>k is also fad+ into no?+ness4#ab ,9 ,au/ria & 9 mo/ ( ! new /ates ( ,europe1 ! inconv]tible pap] legal t5d] curr5cy has lo/ almo/ ! :ole ( its value1 9 comp>ison ) ! pre-w> co9 :i* x pret5ds to repres5t4 #aj ,hawtrey1 op4 cit41 *ap4 ,,xv4 #aa ,a turn :i* ev5 a ,poli% ,*ancellor ( ! ,ex*equ] might envy4 #ab ,9 ! second week ( ,novemb] ! m>k fell to #acjj to ! pap] p\nd1 recov]+ a day or two lat] 7,w$nesday1 ,novemb] #i7 to #ihj4 ,! real diff]5ce betwe5 ! pres5t monet>y conditions & ! ,am]ican cont95tals1 or ! ,fr5* assignats1 is a diff]5ce n ( k9d1 b ( degree & ext5t4 ,! causes & ! consequ5ces1 ! motives ( ^? :o "w ! m9t1 ! ru9 & demoralization ( ! victims1 ! effects ^u public & private debts & cr$it are ! same4 ,b a :ole cont95t populat$ by f\r hundr$ millions ( p is conc]n$4 ,! comm]cial & moral fabric ( ,european civilization is tott]+4 ,?ree ye>s h pass$ s9ce ! w> end$2 b ! curr5cies & ex*anges ( ,europe are 9 a mu* worse condition ?an :5 peace 0 be+ negotiat$4 ,at ! end ( ,june1 #aiba1 ,i walk$ f my (fice 9 ! ,/r& d[n to ,messrs4 ,h&s ,co41 :o deal 9 =eign money at ,*>+ ,cross4 ,on ! way ,i pass$ ! %op ( a tailor1 :o _h plac>d$ on 8 %op w9d[ ! ann\ncem5t t he w\ld give a hundr$ ?\s& r\bles to e cu/om] :o b\ght a suit ( clo!s f him4 ,he add$ t at ! pre-w> rate ( ex*ange ! "o hundr$ ?\s& r\bles w\ld be wor? t5 ?\s& p\nds4 ,he did n add t !y 7 at t "t wor? only two %ill+s4#ac ,on arriv+ at my de/9ation1 ,i ask$ to see specim5s ( ! mo/ debas$ curr5cies & ev5tually laid out t5 %ill+s1#ad or1 to be exact1 #is_/#aj;d4 ,"h is ! bill3 ,t5 ,g]man m>ks co/ me "o %ill+ ,a hundr$ ,au/rian cr[ns co/ me "o & sixp5ce ,a hundr$ ,poli% m>ks co/ me sixp5ce ,tw5ty-five ,russian 7,cz>7#ae r\bles 7#aiji7 co/ me sixp5ce ,two ,italian lire co/ me eightp5ce ,two ,greek dra*mas co/ me eightp5ce ,two ,r\manian lei co/ me sixp5ce ,five ,yugoslav d9>s#af co/ me "o %ill+ ,t5 ,cze*oslovakian cr[ns co/ me "o %ill+ ,five ,bulg>ian levas co/ me sixp5ce ,five ,f9ni% m>ks co/ me "o %ill+ ,five ,e/honian m>ks co/ me "o %ill+ ,five ,latvian r\bles co/ me sixp5ce #ac ,a mon? or two lat] !y 7 n wor? a %ill+4 ,! ,russian ,soviet ,gov]nm5t 0 (f]+ two hundr$ ?\s& r\bles = "o pre-w> silv] r\ble6 #ad ,two doll>s4 #ae ,tw5ty-five ,soviet r\bles w\ld h be5 de> at a f>?+4 #af ,on ?is note is /amp$ #bj ,kruna to indicate t five d9>s ex*ang$ = tw5ty ,au/rian cr[ns4 ,to %[ t my fri5d1 ! ex*ange deal]1 made a dec5t pr(it out ( ?is retail transaction1 ,i quote "s ( 8 sell+ rates = ! day on :i* he bas$ 8 *>ges3 ,rates ( ,ex*ange ,june #bi1 #aiba ,au/rian pap] cr[ns #bdjj-bfjj = #a ,f9ni% m>ks #bbj-bdj = #a ,g]man m>ks #bfe-bge = #a ,poli% m>ks #fjjj 7sell+ rate7 = #a ,greek dra*mas #fb-fe = #a ,italian lire #gf-gg = #a ,r\manian lei #bcj-bej = #a ,! la/ ,i he>d f ,vi5na 0 t !y _h be5 v>y+ f t5 ?\s& to fifte5 ?\s& to ! pap] p\nd6 ,! diff]5ce 9 ! rates dep5d$1 ( c\rse1 ^u :e!r ! cu/om] 0 buy+ or sell+ ! =eign money4 ,if he 0 buy+ ,au/rian notes1 he w\ld get tw5ty-f\r hundr$ pap] cr[ns = a p\nd4 ,if he 0 sell+ !m1 he w\ld receive a p\nd 9 ex*ange = tw5ty-six hundr$ pap] cr[ns4 ,all ^! pap] notes are call$ aft]1 & pr(ess to repres5t1 silv] co9s1 :i* 7 !mselves be=e ! w>1 tok5s1 & pass$ curr5t at m ?an _! intr9sic value because ( _! relation to gold4 ,?us ! pre-w> p>ity ( m>ks 0 ab\t tw5ty to ! gold p\nd2 ( ,au/rian cr[ns1 ab\t tw5ty-f\r2 ( francs1 lire1 etc41 ab\t tw5ty-five4 ,on ! day ( my pur*ase1 !re=e1 ! ex*ange value ( ! ,g]man m>k 0 less ?an "o ?irte5?1 ( ! ,au/rian cr[n less ?an "o "o hundr$?1 & ( ! ,poli% m>k1 "o two hundr$?1 ( its pre-w> /atus4 ,b ?is und]e/imates ! depreciation2 = ! ,briti% p\nd is no long] a gold sov]eign1 & ev5 gold has be5 depreciat$4#ag ,! pap] p\nd 9 ,june1 #aiba1 01 ,i ?9k1 ab\t ! equival5t ( twelve pre-w> %ill+s 9 pur*as+ p[]4 ,! gold doll>1 :i* w\ld only buy a little m ?an f\r %ill+s be=e ! w>1 w\ld buy five at ! beg9n+ ( ,decemb]1 #aiba4 #ag ,to-day1 ,novemb] #cj1 #aiba1 ! pap] p\nd is wor? ab\t f\r fif?s ( a gold p\nd4 ,! pur*as+ p[] ( gold--say1 ! gold doll>--is p]haps ab\t two ?irds ( :at x 0 be=e ! w>4 ,al?\gh an inconv]tible pap] curr5cy has no intr9sic value1 x c 79 accordance ) ! quantity !ory ( money7 be ma9ta9$ at a fairly /able ratio to gold or commodities by an hone/ gov]nm5t if ! total issue is fix$1 or kept betwe5 reasonable maximum & m9imum limits4 ,! rise ( prices s9ce ! w>1 9 ea* c\ntry :]e reliable /ati/ics are available1 has be5 9 proportion to ! expansion ( ! pap] curr5cy1 all[ance be+ made = ! sc>city ( commodities4 ,( c\rse a decl9e 9 pur*as+ p[] foll[s an expansion ( circulation4 ,! /ability ( ! ,briti% pap] p\nd s9ce a limit 0 impos$ illu/rates ! correctness ( ! quantity !ory ( money4 ,its increase 9 pur*as+ p[] 7l t ( ! gold doll>7 dur+ ! fir/ half ( #aiba is1 ( c\rse1 due to ! fact t ! supply ( utilities _h ov]tak5 ! dem&4 ,at fir/ sight x seems difficult to und]/& h[ any gov]nm5t1 h[ev] bad1 c delib]ately issue flood ^u flood ( inconv]tible pap] money1 see+ t its pr9t+ op]ations are ru9\s to bo? public & private cr$it4 ,to obta9 ! same am\nt ( rev5ue1 ea* new issue1 ea* new dose1 has to be mu* l>g] ?an ! prec$+4 ,9 ! c\rse ( twelve mon?s1 = example1 ! ex*ange value ( ! ,poli% m>k 0 divid$ by t51 t is1 at ! end ( ! p]iod1 t5 times z mu* pap] money _h to be pr9t$ z at ! beg9n+1 to get ! same rev5ue4 ,yet ! ,poli% ,gov]nm5t cont9u$ ^u its c\rse ) ! approval & support ( ! ,poli% ,diet4 ,! foll[+ quotation is f ! ,w>saw correspond5t ( ! ,london ,economi/1 :o wrote on ,july #bh1 #aiba3 ,! effects ( ! la/ collapse ( ! ex*anges are beg9n+ to make !mselves felt1 & ! ,diet is already prep>+ fre% gr\nd = new curr5cy inflation4 ,by its la/ vote ! limit on ! note circulation has be5 increas$ to #aah milli>ds1 & on ! advances ( ! ,poli% ,national ,bank to ! ,gov]nm5t to #aej milli>ds4 ,! depreciation ( ! ,poli% m>k 9 ,june 0 foll[$ by a rise ( prices1 & ?is l$ imm$iately to a /rike movem5t 9 almo/ all indu/ries4 ,9 ! ,lodz di/rict #dj1jjj workm5 h gone on /rike1 dem&+ a wage increase ( #abj p] c5t6 ,! manufactur]s decl>e t !y _c raise wages by m ?an #bj p] c5t2 t ev5 "u pres5t conditions ! ,poli% textile indu/ry is 9 a mo/ difficult position on ! =eign m>kets1 especially 9 ,r\mania1 ! ,baltic ,/ates1 etc4 ,posnania 0 m5ac$ by an agr>ian /rike1 b a settlem5t has be5 rea*$4 ,! /rike ( ! municipal work]s 9 ,w>saw 0 %ort-liv$4 ,ev]y:]e1 h[ev]1 wages h be5 increas$ by m ?an #ej p] c5t4 ,?is naturally w entail a new wave ( ris+ prices1 ! ,gov]nm5t w be oblig$ to d\ble ! sal>ies ( its (ficials1 & ! pr9t+ press w "w aga9 "u a high] pressure4 ,?is is ! vici\s circle r\nd :i* ! c\ntry has be5 travell+ = ?ree ye>s4 ,ex uno disce omnes4 ,! monet>y policy ( ! ,poli% ,gov]nm5t is m]ely a flagrant example ( ! rec5t monet>y hi/ory ( all ! /ates ( ,europe nor!a/1 s\!a/1 ea/1 ( ! ,rh9e & ( ! ,alps4 ,!re is only "o real rem$y1 ! re/abli%m5t ( complete peace1 dis>mam5t1 ! abolition ( conscription1 ! dra/ic r$uction ( bloat$ bureaucracies1 & a :olesale l[]+ ( t>iffs1 :i* w all[ ! mis]able & half-/>v$ populations to r5ew ! arts ( peace & ! ex*ange ( _! agricultural products & manufactures4 ,,app5dix ,,! ,,brussels ,,conf]5ce#ah ,if all c\ntries 7 includ$1 a g5]al & proportionate r$uction ( ! milit>y & naval e/abli%m5ts to "o half ( _! pres5t co/ w\ld set free a fund ( probably at lea/ #c1jjj1jjj1jjj to #d1jjj1jjj1jjj annually = ! pur*ase ( food & useful commodities1 = ! /abilization & p>tial re/oration ( debas$ pap] curr5cies1 = ! paym5t ( debt1 ! removal ( public deficits1 ! revival ( cr$it1 & ! r$uction ( taxes4 ,?us ! road to recov]y lies pla9 be=e u4 ,w x be tak5 by ! /atesm5 to ^: h&s ! peoples h intru/$ _! lives & =tunes8 #ah ,tak5 by p]mission f an article by ! au?or 9 ! ,saturday ,ev5+ ,po/ ( ,novemb] #ab1 #aiba4 ,,deficits ,,! ,,rule ,9 ord] to %[ t ?is view is 9 con=mity ) ! conclusions ( exp]ts1 & ev5 ( (ficials delegat$ = ! purpose ( exam9+ _w f9ance by ! gov]nm5ts !mselves1 ,i turn to ! conclusions unanim\sly arriv$ at by ! ,brussels conf]5ce a ye> ago1 aft] eighty-six f9ancial exp]ts f ?irty-n9e c\ntries _h pres5t$ ! acc\nts & balance %eets ( _! respective gov]nm5ts4 ,9 a g5]al review ( ! situation !y po9t out t ! total ext]nal debt ( ! ,european bellig]5ts1 conv]t$ into doll>s at p>1 am\nts to ab\t #aee milli>d doll>s1 comp>$ ) ab\t #ag milli>d doll>s 9 #aiac4 ,!y say t ! gov]nm5t exp5ditures ( ! ,european bellig]5ts am\nt to betwe5 #bj & #dj p] c5t ( ! total incomes ( ! peoples4 ,!y say emphatically t ! re/oration ( real peace1 ) dis>mam5t1 is ! fir/ condition = ! _w's recov]y4 ,f\r commissions 7 appo9t$4 ,! fir/ dealt ) public f9ance1 & its resolutions 7 adopt$ unanim\sly by ! conf]5ce4 ,! foll[+ extract f its resolutions des]ves att5tion3 ,?irty-n9e nations h 9 turn plac$ be=e ! ,int]national ,f9ancial ,conf]5ce a /atem5t ( _! f9ancial position4 ,! exam9ation ( ^! /atem5ts br+s out ! extreme gravity ( ! g5]al situation ( public f9ance ?r\gh\t ! _w1 & p>ticul>ly 9 ,europe4 ,_! import may be summ$ up 9 ! /atem5t t ?ree out ( e f\r ( ! c\ntries repres5t$ at ?is conf]5ce & elev5 out ( twelve ( ! ,european c\ntries anticipate a budget deficit 9 ! pres5t ye>4 ,public op9ion is l>gely responsible = ?is situation4 ,! close connection betwe5 ^! budget deficits & ! co/ ( liv+1 :i* is caus+ su* suff]+ & unre/ ?r\gh\t ! _w1 is f> f be+ grasp$4 ,ne>ly e gov]nm5t is be+ press$ to incur fre% exp5diture2 l>gely on palliatives :i* aggravate ! v evils aga9/ :i* !y are direct$4 ,! fir/ /ep is to br+ public op9ion 9 e c\ntry to realize ! ess5tial facts ( ! situation & p>ticul>ly ! ne$ = re/abli%+ public f9ances on a s\nd basis z a prelim9>y to ! execution ( ^? social re=ms :i* ! _w dem&s4 ,public att5tion %\ld be especially drawn to ! fact t ! r$uction ( prices & ! re/oration ( prosp]ity is dep5d5t on ! increase ( production1 & t ! cont9ual excess ( gov]nm5t exp5diture ov] rev5ue repres5t$ by budget deficits is "o ( ! mo/ s]i\s ob/acles to su* increase ( production1 z x mu/ soon] or lat] involve ! foll[+ consequ5ces3 7a7 ,a fur!r inflation ( cr$it & curr5cy4 7b7 ,a fur!r depreciation 9 ! pur*as+ p[] ( ! dome/ic curr5cy1 & a /ill great] in/ability ( ! =eign ex*anges4 7c7 ,a fur!r rise 9 prices & 9 ! co/ ( liv+4 ,! c\ntry :i* accepts ! policy ( budget deficits is tread+ ! slipp]y pa? :i* leads to g5]al ru92 to escape f t pa? no sacrifice is too great4 ,x is !re=e imp]ative t e gov]nm5t %\ld1 z ! fir/ social & f9ancial re=m1 on :i* all o!rs dep5d3 7a7 ,re/rict its ord9>y recurr5t exp5diture1 includ+ ! s]vice ( ! debt1 to su* an am\nt z c be cov]$ by its ord9>y rev5ue4 7b7 ,rigidly r$uce all exp5diture on armam5ts 9 s f> z su* r$uction is compatible ) ! pres]vation ( national security4 7c7 ,ab&on all unproductive extraord9>y exp5diture4 7d7 ,re/rict ev5 productive extraord9>y exp5diture to ! l[e/ possible am\nt4 ,! ,supreme ,c\ncil ( ! ,alli$ ,p[]s 9 its pron\ncem5t on ! eigh? ( ,m>* decl>$ t armies %\ld ev]y:]e be r$uc$ to a peace foot+2 t armam5ts %\ld be limit$ to ! l[e/ possible figure compatible ) national security & t ! ,league ( ,nations %\ld be invit$ to consid]1 z soon z possible1 proposals to ?is end4 ,! /atem5ts pres5t$ to ! conf]5ce %[ t1 on an av]age1 "s #bj p] c5t ( ! national exp5diture is /ill be+ devot$ to ! ma9t5ance ( armam5ts & ! prep>ations = w>4 ,! conf]5ce desires to affirm ) ! utmo/ emphasis t ! _w _c af=d ?is exp5diture4 ,only by a frank policy ( mutual cop]ation c ! nations hope to rega9 _! old prosp]ity1 & 9 ord] to secure t result1 ! :ole res\rces ( ea* c\ntry mu/ be devot$ to /rictly productive purposes4 ,! conf]5ce accord+ly recomm5ds mo/ e>ne/ly to ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,league ( ,nations ! desirability ( conf]r+ at once ) ! sev]al gov]nm5ts conc]n$1 ) a view to secur+ a g5]al & agre$ r$uction ( ! cru%+ burd5s :i* on _! exi/+ scale armam5ts /ill impose on ! impov]i%$ peoples ( ! _w1 sapp+ _! res\rce & imp]il+ _! recov]y f ! ravages ( w>4 ,! conf]5ce hopes t ! ,assembly ( ! ,league1 :i* is ab\t to meet1 w take en]getic action to ?is end4 ,! above recomm5dations 7 ignor$ by ! ,league ( ,nations & by practically all ! gov]nm5ts conc]n$4 ,consequ5tly ! debts & deficits ( mo/ ,european c\ntries are l>g] at ! pres5t "t ?an !y 7 a ye> ago1 & mo/ ( ! pap] curr5cies h depreciat$--"s v heavily--dur+ ! la/ twelve mon?s4 ,,! ,,dang]s ,,( ,,inflation ,i turn next to ! resolutions propos$ by ! second commission :i* _h to exam9e problems ( curr5cy & =eign ex*ange4 ,f its resolutions1 :i* also 7 adopt$ unanim\sly by ! conf]5ce1 ,i extract ! foll[+3 ,! curr5cies ( all bellig]5t & ( _m o!r c\ntries1 ?\gh 9 greatly v>y+ degrees1 h s9ce ! beg9n+ ( ! w> be5 exp&$ artificially1 reg>dless ( ! usual re/ra9ts ^u su* expansion--to :i* we ref] lat]--& )\t any correspond+ increase 9 ! real weal? ^u :i* _! pur*as+ p[] 0 bas$2 inde$ 9 mo/ cases 9 spite ( a s]i\s r$uction 9 su* weal?4 ,x %\ld be cle>ly und]/ood t ?is artificial & unre/ra9$ expansion1 or inflation1 z x is call$1 ( ! curr5cy or ( ! titles to imm$iate pur*as+ p[] does n & _c add to ! total real pur*as+ p[] 9 exi/5ce1 s t its effect mu/ be to r$uce ! pur*as+ p[] ( ea* unit ( ! curr5cy4 ,x is 9 fact a =m ( debas+ ! curr5cy4 ,! effect ( x has be5 to int5sify1 9 t]ms ( ! inflat$ curr5cies1 ! g5]al rise 9 prices1 s t a great] am\nt ( su* curr5cy is ne$$ to procure ! accu/om$ supply ( goods & s]vices4 ,:]e ?is additional curr5cy 0 procur$ by fur!r inflation--t is1 by pr9t+ m pap] money or creat+ fre% cr$it--!re arose :at has be5 call$ a vici\s spiral ( con/antly ris+ prices & wages & con/antly increas+ inflation1 ) ! result+ disorganization ( all bus9ess1 dislocation ( ! ex*anges1 a progressive increase 9 ! co/ ( liv+1 & consequ5t labor unre/4 ,x is ( ! utmo/ importance t ! gr[? ( inflation %\ld be /opp$2 & ?is1 al?\gh no d\bt v difficult to d imm$iately 9 "s c\ntries1 c\ld quickly be accompli%$ by ab/a9+ f increas+ ! curr5cy--9 its broade/ s5se1 z def9$ above--& by increas+ ! real weal? ^u :i* su* curr5cy is bas$4 ,! cessation ( increase 9 ! curr5cy %\ld n be a*iev$ m]ely by re/rict+ ! issue ( legal t5d]4 ,su* a /ep1 if unaccompani$ by o!r measures1 w\ld be apt to aggravate ! situation by caus+ a monet>y crisis4 ,x is necess>y to attack ! causes :i* lead to ! necessity = ! additional curr5cy4 ,! *ief cause 9 mo/ c\ntries is t ! gov]nm5ts1 f9d+ !mselves unable to meet _! exp5ditures out ( rev5ue1 h be5 tempt$ to resort to ! artificial creation ( fre% pur*as+ p[]1 ei!r by ! direct issue ( additional legal-t5d] money or m frequ5tly by obta9+--especially f ! banks ( issue1 :i* 9 "s cases are unable & 9 o!rs unwill+ to refuse !m--cr$its :i* mu/ !mselves be satisfi$ 9 legal-t5d] money4 ,we say1 !re=e1 t gov]nm5ts mu/ limit _! exp5diture to _! rev5ue4 ,"h aga9 we h excell5t doctr9es & good practical advice f ^! f9ancial exp]ts to ! gov]nm5ts :i* appo9t$ !m4 ,b ! doctr9es h rema9$ unappli$1 & ! advice has be5 honor$ 9 ! brea* in/ead ( 9 ! obs]vance4 ,,wise ,,c\nsel ,,ignor$ ,i pass next to ! resolutions propos$ by ! commission on int]national trade & adopt$ unanim\sly by ! conf]5ce1 f :i* ! fir/ two p>agraphs w be quot$3 ,! ,int]national ,f9ancial ,conf]5ce affirms t ! fir/ condition = ! resumption ( int]national trade is ! re/oration ( real peace1 ! conclusion ( ! w>s :i* are /ill be+ wag$ & ! assur$ ma9t5ance ( peace = ! future4 ,! cont9uance ( ! atmosph]e ( w> & ( prep>ations = w> is fatal to ! developm5t ( t mutual tru/ :i* is ess5tial to ! resumption ( normal trad+ relations4 ,! security ( int]nal conditions is sc>cely less important1 z =eign trade _c prosp] 9 a c\ntry ^: int]nal conditions d n inspire confid5ce4 ,! conf]5ce tru/s t ! ,league ( ,nations w lose no opportunity to secure ! full re/oration & cont9u$ ma9t5ance ( peace4 ,! ,int]national ,f9ancial ,conf]5ce affirms t ! improvem5t ( ! f9ancial position l>gely dep5ds on ! g5]al re/oration z soon z possible ( good w betwe5 ! v>i\s nations2 & 9 p>ticul> x indorses ! decl>ation ( ! ,supreme ,c\ncil ( ! eigh? ,m>* la/ t ! ,/ates :i* h be5 creat$ or enl>g$ z a result ( ! w> %\ld at once re/abli% full & fri5dly cop]ation & arrange = ! unre/rict$ int]*ange ( commodities 9 ord] t ! ess5tial unity ( ,european economic life may n be impair$ by ! erection ( artificial economic b>ri]s4 ,"h aga9 !re is a full recognition ( ! fact t peace is necess>y to ! r5ewal ( prosp]ity1 & t ! atmosph]e ( w> prep>ations is fatal to ! gr[? ( trade4 ,b nei!r ! ,league ( ,nations nor ! ,supreme ,c\ncil1 s f> z ,i am aw>e1 has made any effective response to ^! appeals4 ,f\r?ly & la/ly1 ,i come to ! commission on int]national cr$its4 ,?is commission pass$ a numb] ( resolutions1 all ( :i* 7 adopt$ unanim\sly by ! conf]5ce2 b x w suffice to cite ! fir/ two3 ,! conf]5ce recognizes 9 ! fir/ place t ! difficulties :i* at pres5t lie 9 ! way ( int]national cr$it op]ations arise almo/ exclusively out ( ! di/urbance caus$ by ! w>1 & t ! normal work+ ( f9ancial m>kets _c be completely re/abli%$ unless peaceful relations are re/or$ betwe5 all peoples & ! out/&+ f9ancial que/ions result+ f ! w> are made ! subject ( a def9ite settlem5t :i* is put into execution4 ,! conf]5ce is1 moreov]1 ( op9ion t ! revival ( cr$it requires z prim>y conditions ! re/oration ( ord] 9 public f9ance1 ! cessation ( inflation1 ! purg+ ( curr5cies1 & ! fre$om ( comm]cial transactions4 ,! resolutions ( ! commission on int]national cr$its are !re=e bas$ on ! resolutions ( ! o!r commissions4 ,my argum5t !n is fully endors$ by ! exp]ts at ,brussels4 ,all ! facts & figures set =? 9 ! volum9\s records ( t rem>kable conf]5ce indicate ! urg5cy ( peace & dis>mam5t4 ,a ye> has pass$4 ,! ,brussels recomm5dations h be5 ignor$1 & conditions 9 ,europe z reg>ds its curr5cies1 debts1 trade & cr$it h det]iorat$4 ,! ,naval limitations propos$ by ,mr4 ,hughes at ,wa%+ton1 ev5 if !y are ratifi$1 w give practically no relief to ,europe4