,disputation ( ,doctor ,m>t9 ,lu!r    on
 ! ,p[] & ,efficacy ( ,indulg5ces    by 
,dr4 ,m>t9 ,lu!r1 #aeag      ,publi%$ 93
    ,works ( ,m>t9 ,lu!r    ,adolph     
,spae?1 ,l4,d4 ,re$1 ,h5ry ,ey/]        
,jacobs1 et ,al41 ,trans4  ,eds4        
7,philadelphia3 ,a4 ,j4 ,holman         
,company1 #aiae71 ,vol4 #a1 pp4 #bi-ch4 
,,disputation ,,( ,,doctor ,,m>t9 ,,lu!r
    ,,on ,,! ,,p[] ,,& ,,efficacy ,,(   
,,indulg5ces    ,,octob] #ca1 #aeag     
,out ( love = ! tru? & ! desire to br+ x
 to light1 !  foll[+ propositions w be  
discuss$ at ,witt5b]g1 "u !  presid5cy (
 ! ,rev]5d ,fa!r ,m>t9 ,lu!r1 ,ma/] (   
,arts & (  ,sacr$ ,!ology1 & ,lectur] 9 
,ord9>y on ! same at t place4  ,:]e=e he
 reque/s t ^? :o are unable to be pres5t
 &  debate orally ) u1 may d s by lett]4
    ,9 ! ,"n our ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/4 ,am54
    #a4 ,our ,"l & ,ma/] ,jesus ,*ri/1  
:5 ,he said ,po5it5tiam agite1  will$ t 
! :ole life ( believ]s %\ld be          
rep5tance4    #b4 ,?is ^w _c be und]/ood
 to mean sacram5tal p5ance1 i4e41       

confession & satisfaction1 :i* is       
adm9i/]$ by ! prie/s4    #c4 ,yet x     
means n inw>d rep5tance only2 nay1 !re  
is no inw>d  rep5tance :i* does n       
outw>dly "w div]s mortifications ( !    
fle%4    #d4 ,! p5alty ( s91 !re=e1     
cont9ues s long z hatr$ ( self          
cont9ues2 = ?is is ! true inw>d         
rep5tance1 & cont9ues until  our        
entrance into ! k+dom ( heav54    #e4 ,!
 pope does n int5d to remit1 & _c remit 
any p5alties  o!r ?an ^? :i* he has     
impos$ ei!r by 8 own au?ority or by  t (
 ! ,canons4    #f4 ,! pope _c remit any 
guilt1 except by decl>+ t x has  be5    
remitt$ by ,god & by ass5t+ to ,god's   
remission2 ?\gh1 to be  sure1 he may    
grant remission 9 cases res]v$ to 8     
judgm5t4 ,if 8  "r to grant remission 9 
su* cases 7 despis$1 ! guilt w\ld  rema9
 entirely un=giv54    #g4 ,god remits   
guilt to no "o :om ,he does n1 at ! same
 "t1  humble 9 all ?+s & br+ into       
subjection to ,8 vic>1 !  prie/4  #h4 ,!
 p5it5tial canons are impos$ only on !  

liv+1 &1  accord+ to !m1 no?+ %\ld be   
impos$ on ! dy+4    #i4 ,!re=e ! ,holy  
,_s 9 ! pope is k9d to u1 because 9 8   
decrees he always makes exception ( !   
article ( dea? & (  necessity4    #aj4  
,ignorant & wick$ are ! do+s ( ^? prie/s
 :o1 9 !  case ( ! dy+1 res]ve canonical
 p5ances = purgatory4    #aa4 ,?is *ang+
 ( ! canonical p5alty to ! p5alty (     
purgatory  is q evid5tly "o ( ! t>es t 7
 s[n :ile ! bi%ops  slept4    #ab4 ,9   
=m] times ! canonical p5alties 7 impos$ 
n aft]1 b  be=e absolution1 z te/s (    
true contrition4    #ac4 ,! dy+ are fre$
 by dea? f all p5alties2 !y are already 
dead to canonical rules1 & h a "r to be 
releas$ f !m4    #ad4 ,! imp]fect heal? 
( s\l1 t is to say1 ! imp]fect love1  ( 
! dy+ br+s ) x1 ( necessity1 great fe>2 
& ! small]  ! love1 ! great] is ! fe>4  
#ae4 ,?is fe> & horror is suffici5t (   
itself alone 7to say no?+  ( o!r ?+s7 to
 con/itute ! p5alty ( purgatory1 s9ce x 
is  v ne> to ! horror ( despair4    #af4
 ,hell1 purgatory1 & heav5 seem to diff]

 z d despair1  almo/-despair1 & !       
assurance ( safety4    #ag4 ,) s\ls 9   
purgatory x seems necess>y t horror %\ld
 gr[  less & love increase4    #ah4 ,x  
seems unprov$1 ei!r by reason or        
,scripture1 t !y are  outside ! /ate (  
m]it1 t is to say1 ( increas+ love4     
#ai4 ,aga91 x seems unprov$ t !y1 or at 
lea/ t all ( !m1  are c]ta9 or assur$ ( 
_! own bless$ness1 ?\gh we may be q     
c]ta9 ( x4    #bj4 ,!re=e by full       
remission ( all p5alties ! pope means n 
actually ( all1 b only ( ^? impos$ by   
himself4    #ba4 ,!re=e ^? prea*]s (    
indulg5ces are 9 error1 :o say t  by !  
pope's indulg5ces a man is fre$ f e     
p5alty1 & sav$2    #bb4 ,:]eas he remits
 to s\ls 9 purgatory no p5alty :i*1     
accord+  to ! canons1 !y w\ld h _h to   
pay 9 ?is life4  #bc4 ,if x is  at all  
possible to grant to any "o ! remission 
( all p5alties  :atsoev]1 x is c]ta9 t  
?is remission c be grant$ only to  ! mo/
 p]fect1 t is1 to ! v fewe/4    #bd4 ,x 
mu/ ne$s be1 !re=e1 t ! great] "p ( ! p 

are deceiv$ by t indiscrim9ate &        
highs\nd+ promise ( release  f p5alty4  
#be4 ,! p[] :i* ! pope has1 9 a g5]al   
way1 ov] purgatory1 is  j l ! p[] :i*   
any bi%op or curate has1 9 a special    
way1  )9 8 own diocese or p>i%4    #bf4 
,! pope does well :5 he grants remission
 to s\ls 9  purgatory1 n by ! p[] ( !   
keys 7:i* he does n possess71  b by way 
( int]cession4    #bg4 ,!y prea* man :o 
say t s soon z ! p5ny j+les into !      
money-box1 ! s\l flies out ( purgatory4 
#bh4 ,x is c]ta9 t :5 ! p5ny j+les into 
! money-box1 ga9  & av>ice c be         
increas$1 b ! result ( ! int]cession ( !
  ,*ur* is 9 ! p[] ( ,god alone4    #bi4
 ,:o kn[s :e!r all ! s\ls 9 purgatory   
wi% to be b\ght out  ( x1 z 9 ! leg5d ( 
,/s4 ,sev]9us & ,pas*al4    #cj4 ,no "o 
is sure t 8 own contrition is s9c]e2 mu*
 less t  he has atta9$ full remission4  
#ca4 ,r>e z is ! man t is truly p5it5t1 
s r>e is also ! man  :o truly buys      
indulg5ces1 i4e41 su* m5 are mo/ r>e4   
#cb4 ,!y w be condemn$ et]nally1 toge!r 

) _! tea*]s1 :o  believe !mselves sure (
 _! salvation because !y h lett]s (     
p>don4    #cc4 ,m5 mu/ be on _! gu>d    
aga9/ ^? :o say t ! pope's  p>dons are t
 ine/imable gift ( ,god by :i* man is   
reconcil$ to  ,him2    #cd4 ,= ^! graces
 ( p>don conc]n only ! p5alties (       
sacram5tal satisfaction1 & ^! are       
appo9t$ by man4    #ce4 ,!y prea* no    
,*ri/ian doctr9e :o tea* t contrition is
 n  necess>y 9 ^? :o int5d to buy s\ls  
out ( purgatory or to buy               
confessionalia4    #cf4 ,e truly        
rep5tant ,*ri/ian has a "r to full      
remission (  p5alty & guilt1 ev5 )\t    
lett]s ( p>don4    #cg4 ,e true         
,*ri/ian1 :e!r liv+ or dead1 has "p 9   
all !  bless+s ( ,*ri/ & ! ,*ur*2 & ?is 
is grant$ him by ,god1  ev5 )\t lett]s (
 p>don4    #ch4 ,nev]!less1 ! remission 
& p>ticipation 9 ! bless+s (  ! ,*ur*   
:i* are grant$ by ! pope are 9 no way to
 be despis$1  = !y are1 z ,i h said1 !  
decl>ation ( div9e remission4    #ci4 ,x
 is mo/ difficult1 ev5 = ! v ke5e/      

!ologians1 at "o  & ! same "t to comm5d 
to ! p ! abundance ( p>dons &  ! ne$ (  
true contrition4    #dj4 ,true          
contrition seeks & loves p5alties1 b    
lib]al p>dons only  relax p5alties &    
cause !m to be hat$1 or at lea/1 furni% 
an  occasion = hat+ !m4    #da4         
,apo/olic p>dons are to be prea*$ )     
caution1 le/ ! p  may falsely ?9k !m    
pref]able to o!r good works ( love4     
#db4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught t ! pope
 does n int5d !  buy+ ( p>dons to be    
comp>$ 9 any way to works ( m]cy4       
#dc4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught t he :o 
gives to ! poor or l5ds  to ! ne$y does 
a bett] "w ?an buy+ p>dons2    #dd4     
,because love gr[s by works ( love1 &   
man becomes bett]2 b by  p>dons man does
 n gr[ bett]1 only m free f p5alty4     
#de4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught t he :o 
sees a man 9 ne$1 &  passes him by1 &   
gives 8 money = p>dons1 pur*ases n !    
indulg5ces ( ! pope1 b ! indignation (  
,god4    #df4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught
 t unless !y h m ?an !y  ne$1 !y are    

b\nd to keep back :at is necess>y = _!  
own  families1 & by no means to squ&] x 
on p>dons4    #dg4 ,*ri/ians are to be  
taught t ! buy+ ( p>dons is a matt]  (  
free w1 & n ( comm&m5t4    #dh4         
,*ri/ians are to be taught t ! pope1 9  
grant+ p>dons1  ne$s1 & !re=e desires1  
_! dev\t pray] = him m ?an !  money !y  
br+4    #di4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught 
t ! pope's p>dons are useful1 if  !y d n
 put _! tru/ 9 !m2 b altoge!r h>mful1 if
 ?r\gh  !m !y lose _! fe> ( ,god4       
#ej4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught t if !  
pope knew ! exactions (  !              
p>don-prea*]s1 he w\ld r t ,/4  ,pet]'s 
*ur* %\ld  g to a%es1 ?an t x %\ld be   
built up ) ! sk91 fle% &  bones ( 8     
%eep4    #ea4 ,*ri/ians are to be taught
 t x w\ld be ! pope's wi%1 z x  is 8    
duty1 to give ( 8 own money to v _m ( ^?
 f :om  c]ta9 hawk]s ( p>dons cajole    
money1 ev5 ?\gh ! *ur* ( ,/4  ,pet]     
might h to be sold4    #eb4 ,! assurance
 ( salvation by lett]s ( p>don is va91  
ev5  ?\gh ! commiss>y1 nay1 ev5 ?\gh !  

pope himself1 7 to /ake  8 s\l ^u x4    
#ec4 ,!y are enemies ( ,*ri/ & ( ! pope1
 :o bid ! ,^w ( ,god  be altoge!r sil5t 
9 "s ,*ur*es1 9 ord] t p>dons may be    
prea*$ 9 o!rs4    #ed4 ,injury is done !
 ,^w ( ,god :51 9 ! same s]mon1 an equal
  or a long] "t is sp5t on p>dons ?an on
 ?is ,^w4    #ee4 ,x mu/ be ! int5tion (
 ! pope t if p>dons1 :i* are a  v small 
?+1 are celebrat$ ) "o bell1 ) s+le     
processions  & c]emonies1 !n ! ,gospel1 
:i* is ! v greate/ ?+1  %\ld be prea*$ )
 a hundr$ bells1 a hundr$ processions1 a
  hundr$ c]emonies4    #ef4 ,! treasures
 ( ! ,*ur*1 out ( :i* ! pope grants     
indulg5ces1 are n suffici5tly nam$ or   
kn[n among ! p (  ,*ri/4    #eg4 ,t !y  
are n temporal treasures is c]ta9ly     
evid5t1 = _m  ( ! v5dors d n p\r out su*
 treasures s easily1 b only  ga!r !m4   
#eh4 ,nor are !y ! m]its ( ,*ri/ & !    
,sa9ts1 = ev5 )\t  ! pope1 ^! always "w 
grace = ! inn] man1 & ! cross1  dea?1 & 
hell = ! outw>d man4    #ei4 ,/4        
,lawr5ce said t ! treasures ( ! ,*ur* 7 

!  ,*ur*'s poor1 b he spoke accord+ to !
 usage ( ! ^w 9 8  own "t4    #fj4 ,)\t 
ra%ness we say t ! keys ( ! ,*ur*1 giv5 
by  ,*ri/'s m]it1 are t treasure2       
#fa4 ,= x is cle> t = ! remission (     
p5alties & ( res]v$  cases1 ! p[] ( !   
pope is ( itself suffici5t4    #fb4 ,!  
true treasure ( ! ,*ur* is ! ,mo/ ,holy 
,gospel ( !  glory & ! grace ( ,god4    
#fc4 ,b ?is treasure is naturally mo/   
odi\s1 = x makes ! fir/  to be la/4     
#fd4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ! treasure (         
indulg5ces is naturally mo/  acceptable1
 = x makes ! la/ to be fir/4    #fe4    
,!re=e ! treasures ( ! ,gospel are nets 
) :i* !y  =m]ly 7 wont to fi% = m5 (    
ri*es4    #ff4 ,! treasures ( !         
indulg5ces are nets ) :i* !y n[ fi%  = !
 ri*es ( m54    #fg4 ,! indulg5ces :i* !
 prea*]s cry z ! greate/ graces  are    
kn[n to be truly su*1 9 s f> z !y       
promote ga94    #fh4 ,yet !y are 9 tru? 
! v smalle/ graces comp>$ ) !  grace (  
,god & ! piety ( ! ,cross4    #fi4      
,bi%ops & curates are b\nd to admit !   

commiss>ies (  apo/olic p>dons1 ) all   
rev]5ce4    #gj4 ,b /ill m are !y b\nd  
to /ra9 all _! eyes & att5d  ) all _!   
e>s1 le/ ^! m5 prea* _! own dreams      
in/ead (  ! commission ( ! pope4    #ga4
 ,he :o speaks aga9/ ! tru? ( apo/olic  
p>dons1 let him be  ana!ma & accurs$6   
#gb4 ,b he :o gu>ds aga9/ ! lu/ & lic5se
 ( !  p>don-prea*]s1 let him be bless$6 
#gc4 ,! pope ju/ly ?und]s aga9/ ^? :o1  
by any art1 contrive  ! injury ( !      
traffic 9 p>dons4    #gd4 ,b mu* m does 
he int5d to ?und] aga9/ ^? :o use !     
pretext ( p>dons to contrive ! injury ( 
holy love & tru?4    #ge4 ,to ?9k !     
papal p>dons s great t !y c\ld absolve a
 man  ev5 if he _h committ$ an          
impossible s9 & violat$ ! ,"m (         
,god--?is is madness4    #gf4 ,we say1  
on ! contr>y1 t ! papal p>dons are n    
able to  remove ! v lea/ ( v5ial s9s1 s 
f> z its guilt is conc]n$4    #gg4 ,x is
 said t ev5 ,/4 ,pet]1 if he 7 n[ ,pope1
 c\ld n  be/[ great] graces2 ?is is     
blasphemy aga9/ ,/4 ,pet] & aga9/  !    

pope4    #gh4 ,we say1 on ! contr>y1 t  
ev5 ! pres5t pope1 & any pope  at all1  
has great] graces at 8 disposal2 to wit1
 ! ,gospel1 p[]s1  gifts ( heal+1 etc41 
z x is writt5 9 ,i4 ,cor9?ians xii4     
#gi4 ,to say t ! cross1 emblazon$ ) !   
papal arms1 :i* is set  up by ! prea*]s 
( indulg5ces1 is ( equal wor? ) ! ,cross
  ( ,*ri/1 is blasphemy4    #hj4 ,!     
bi%ops1 curates & !ologians :o all[ su* 
talk to be  spread among ! p1 w h an    
acc\nt to r5d]4  #ha4 ,?is  unbridl$    
prea*+ ( p>dons makes x no easy matt]1  
ev5 =  le>n$ m51 to rescue ! rev]5ce due
 to ! pope f sl&]1 or  ev5 f ! %rewd    
que/ion+s ( ! laity4    #hb4 ,to        
wit3--,:y does n ! pope empty purgatory1
 = ! sake (  holy love & ( ! dire ne$ ( 
! s\ls t are !re1 if he  r$eems an      
inf9ite numb] ( s\ls = ! sake ( mis]able
 money  ) :i* to build a ,*ur*8 ,! =m]  
reasons w\ld be mo/ j2  ! latt] is mo/  
trivial4    #hc4 ,aga93--,:y are mortu>y
 & anniv]s>y masses = ! dead  cont9u$1 &
 :y does he n return or p]mit ! )drawal 

( !  end[m5ts f\nd$ on _! behalf1 s9ce x
 is wrong to pray = !  r$eem$8    #hd4  
,aga93--,:at is ?is new piety ( ,god & !
 pope1 t = money  !y all[ a man :o is   
impi\s & _! enemy to buy out ( purgatory
  ! pi\s s\l ( a fri5d ( ,god1 & d n r1 
because ( t  pi\s & belov$ s\l's own    
ne$1 free x = pure love's sake8    #he4 
,aga93--,:y are ! p5it5tial canons long 
s9ce 9 actual fact  & ?r\gh disuse      
abrogat$ & dead1 n[ satisfi$ by ! grant+
 (  indulg5ces1 z ?\gh !y 7 /ill alive &
 9 =ce8    #hf4 ,aga93--,:y does n !    
pope1 ^: weal? is to-day great] ?an  !  
ri*es ( ! ri*e/1 build j ?is "o *ur* (  
,/4 ,pet] )  8 own money1 r ?an ) !     
money ( poor believ]s8    #hg4          
,aga93--,:at is x t ! pope remits1 & :at
 p>ticipation  does he grant to ^? :o1  
by p]fect contrition1 h a "r to full    
remission & p>ticipation8    #hh4       
,aga93--,:at great] bless+ c\ld come to 
! ,*ur* ?an if !  pope 7 to d a hundr$  
times a day :at he n[ does once1 & be/[ 
on e believ] ^! remissions &            

p>ticipations8    #hi4 ,s9ce ! pope1 by 
8 p>dons1 seeks ! salvation ( s\ls  r   
?an money1 :y does he susp5d !          
indulg5ces & p>dons  grant$ h]et(ore1   
s9ce ^! h equal efficacy8    #ij4 ,to   
repress ^! argum5ts & scruples ( ! laity
 by =ce  alone1 & n to resolve !m by    
giv+ reasons1 is to expose !  ,*ur* & ! 
pope to ! ridicule ( _! enemies1 & to   
make  ,*ri/ians unhappy4    #ia4 ,if1   
!re=e1 p>dons 7 prea*$ accord+ to ! _s &
  m9d ( ! pope1 all ^! d\bts w\ld be    
readily resolv$2 nay1 !y  w\ld n exi/4  
#ib4 ,away1 !n1 ) all ^? prophets :o say
 to ! p (  ,*ri/1 ,peace1 peace1 & !re  
is no peace6    #ic4 ,bless$ be all ^?  
prophets :o say to ! p ( ,*ri/1  ,cross1
 cross1 & !re is no cross6    #id4      
,*ri/ians are to be exhort$ t !y be     
dilig5t 9 foll[+  ,*ri/1 _! ,head1 ?r\gh
 p5alties1 dea?s1 & hell2    #ie4 ,& ?us
 be confid5t ( ent]+ into heav5 r ?r\gh 
_m  tribulations1 ?an ?r\gh ! assurance 
( peace4              ,?is text 0       
conv]t$ to ,,ascii =mat = ,project      

,witt5b]g by    ,all5 ,mulvey & is 9 !  
public doma94  ,y may freely            
di/ribute1 copy or pr9t ?is text4       
,please direct any comm5ts    or        
sugge/ions to3 ,rev4 ,rob]t ,e4 ,smi? ( 
! ,wal!r ,libr>y at    ,concordia       
,!ological ,sem9>y4      ,e-mail3       
,c,f,w,library,,crf4,,cuis4,,edu        
,surface ,mail3 #ffjj ,n4 ,cl9ton ,/41  
,ft4 ,wayne1 ,,9 #dfhbe ,,usa    ,phone3
 7#bai7 #dha-babc    ,fax3 7#bai7       
#dha-babf              ,disputatio pro  
,decl>atione ,virtutis ,indulg5ti>um4   
by ,dr4 ,m>t9 ,lu!r1 #adhc-aedf    ,d4  
,,m>t9 ,,lu!rs ,,w]ke3 ,,kritis*e       
,,gesammtausgabe4    #a4 ,b& 7,weim>3   
,h]mann ,boehlau1 #ahhc74 pp4 #bcc-bch4 
,,pw #jja-jja,la          ,?is text 0   
conv]t$ to ,,ascii =mat = ,project      
,witt5b]g by    ,rev4 ,rob]t ,e4 ,smi? &
 is 9 ! public doma94  ,y may freely    
di/ribute1 copy or pr9t ?is text4       
,please direct any comm5ts    or        
sugge/ions to3 ,rev4 ,rob]t ,e4 ,smi? ( 
! ,wal!r ,libr>y at    ,concordia       

,!ological ,sem9>y4      ,e-mail3       
,c,f,w,library,,crf4,,cuis4,,edu        
,surface ,mail3 #ffjj ,n4 ,cl9ton ,/41  
,ft4  ,wayne1 ,,9 #dfhbe ,,usa          
,phone3 7#bai7 #dha-babc    ,fax3 7#bai7
 #dha-babf        ,amore et /udio       
elucid&e v]itatis hec subscripta        
disputabuntur  ,witt5b]ge1 ,presid5te   
,r4 ,p4 ,m>t9o ,lut!r1 ,artium et ,s4   
,!ologie  ,magi/ro eiusdemque ibidem    
lectore ,ord9>io4 ,qu>e petit1 ut qui   
non  possunt v]bis pres5tes nobiscum    
discept>e agant id lit]is abs5tes4  ,9  
nom9e dom9i no/ri ,hiesu ,*ri/i4  ,am54 
#a4 ,dom9us et magi/] no/] ,iesus       
,*ri/us dic5do ',p5it5tiam agite  c4'   
omnem vitam fidelium p5it5tiam esse     
voluit4  #b4 ,quod v]bum de  p5it5tia   
sacram5tali 7id e/ confessionis et      
satisfactionis1 que  sac]dotum m9i/]io  
celebratur7 non pote/ intelligi4    #c4 
,non tam5 solam int5dit int]iorem1 immo 
int]ior nulla e/1 nisi  =is op]etur     
v>ias c>nis mortificationes4    #d4     
,manet itaque p5a1 donec manet odium sui

 7id e/ p5it5tia v]a  intus71 scilicet  
usque ad introitum regni celorum4    #e4
 ,papa non vult nec pote/ ullas p5as    
remitt]e pret] eas1 quas  arbitrio vel  
suo vel canonum imposuit4    #f4 ,papa  
non pote/ remitt]e ullam culpam nisi    
decl>&o1 et  approb&o remissam a deo    
,aut c]te remitt5do casus res]vatos     
sibi1  quibus contemptis culpa prorsus  
reman]et4    #g4 ,nulli prorus remittit 
deus culpam1 qu9 simul eum subiiciat    
humiliatum 9 omnibus sac]doti suo       
vic>io4    #h4 ,canones p5it5tiales     
solum viv5tibus sunt impositi nihilque  
morituris secundum eosdem debet imponi4 
#i4 ,inde b5e nobis facit               
spiritussanctus 9 papa excipi5do 9 suis 
decretis semp] articulum mortis et      
necessitatis4    #aj4 ,indocte et male  
faciunt sac]dotes ii1 qui morituris     
p5it5tias  canonicas 9 purgatorium      
res]vant4    #aa4 ,zizania illa de mut&a
 p5a ,canonica 9 p5am purgatorii vid5tur
  c]te dormi5tibus episcopis sem9ata4   
#ab4 ,olim p5e canonice non po/1 s$ ante

 absolutionem imponebantur  tanquam     
t5tam5ta v]e contritionis4    #ac4      
,morituri p] mortem omnia solvunt et    
legibus canonum mortui iam  sunt1       
hab5tes iure e>um relaxationem4    #ad4 
,imp]fecta sanitas seu *>itas morituri  
necess>io secum f]t  magnum timorem1    
tantoque maiorem1 quanto m9or fu]it     
ipsa4    #ae4 ,hic timor et horror satis
 e/ se solo 7ut alia taceam7 fac]e p5am 
purgatorii1 cum sit proximus            
desp]ationis horrori4    #af4 ,vid5tur  
inf]nus1 purgaturium1 celum diff]re1    
sicut desp]atio1  prope desp]atio1      
securitas diff]unt4    #ag4 ,necess>ium 
videtur animabus 9 purgatorio sicut m9ni
 horrorem ita  aug]i *>itatem4    #ah4  
,nec probatum videtur ullis aut         
rationibus aut scripturis1 quod s9t     
extra /atum m]iti seu aug5de *>itatis4  
#ai4 ,nec hoc probatum esse videtur1    
quod s9t de sua beatitud9e c]te  et     
secure1 saltem omnes1 licet nos         
c]tissimi simus4  #bj4 ,igitur papa  p] 
remissionem pl5>iam omnium p5>um non    

simplicit] omnium  intelligit1 s$ a     
seipso tantummodo imposit>um4    #ba4   
,errant itaque indulg5ti>um pr$icatores 
ii1 qui dicunt p] pape  indulg5tias     
hom9em ab omni p5a solvi et salv>i4     
#bb4 ,qu9 nullam remittit animabus 9    
purgatorio1 quam 9 hac vita  debuiss5t  
secundum ,canones solv]e4    #bc4 ,si   
remissio ulla omnium omn9o p5>um pote/  
alicui d>i1 c]tum  e/ eam non nisi      
p]fectissimis1 i4e4 paucissimis1 d>i4   
#bd4 ,falli ob id necesse e/ maiorem    
p>tem populi p] indiff]5tem  illam et   
magnificam p5e solute promissionem4     
#be4 ,qualem pote/atem habet papa 9     
purgatorium g5]alit]1 talem  habet      
quilibet ,episcopus et ,curatus 9 sua   
diocesi et p>o*ia  specialit]4    #a4   
#bf ,optime facit papa1 quod non        
pote/ate clavis 7quam nullam  habet7 s$ 
p] modum suffragii dat animabus         
remissionem4    #b4 #bg ,hom9em         
pr$icant1 qui /atim ut iactus nummus 9  
ci/am  t9ni]it evol>e dicunt animam4    
#c4 #bh ,c]tum e/1 nummo 9 ci/am t9ni5te

 aug]i que/um et  av>iciam posse3       
suffragium autem ecclesie e/ 9 arbitrio 
dei solius4    #d4 #bi ,quis scit1 si   
omnes anime 9 purgatorio vel9t r$imi1   
sicut de  s4 ,sev]9o et ,pas*ali factum 
n>ratur4    #e4 #cj ,nullus securus e/  
de v]itate sue contritionis1 multom9us  
de  consecutione pl5>ie remissionis4    
#f4 #ca ,quam r>us e/ v]e p5it5s1 tam   
r>us e/ v]e indulg5tias  r$im5s1 i4 e4  
r>issimus4    #g4 #cb ,damnabuntur      
inet]num cum suis magi/ris1 qui p]      
lit]as  v5i>um securos sese cr$unt de   
sua salute4    #h4 #cc ,cav5di sunt     
nimis1 qui dicunt v5ias illas ,pape     
donum esse  illud dei ine/imabile1 quo  
reconciliatur homo deo4    #i4 #cd      
,gratie enim ille v5iales tantum        
respiciunt p5as  satisfactionis         
sacram5talis ab hom9e con/itutas4       
#aj4 #ce ,non *ri/iana pr$icant1 qui    
doc5t1 quod r$empturis animas  vel      
confessionalia non sit necess>ia        
contritio4    #aa4 #cf ,quilibet        
*ri/ianus v]e compunctus habet          

remissionem  pl5>iam a p5a et culpa     
etiam s9e lit]is v5i>um sibi debitam4   
#ab4 #cg ,quilibet v]sus *ri/ianus1 sive
 vivus sive mortuus1 habet              
p>ticipationem omnium bonorum ,*ri/i et 
,ecclesie etiam s9e lit]is  v5i>um a deo
 sibi datam4    #ac4 #ch ,remissio tam5 
et p>ticipatio ,pape nullo modo e/      
contemn5da1 quia 7ut dixi7 e/ decl>atio 
remissionis div9e4    #ad4 #ci          
,difficillimum e/ etiam doctissimis     
,!ologis simul extoll]e  v5i>um         
l>gitatem et contritionis v]itatem coram
 populo4    #ae4 #dj ,contritionis      
v]itas p5as qu]it et amat1 ,v5i>um autem
  l>gitas relaxat et odisse facit1      
saltem occasione4    #af4 #da ,caute    
sunt v5ie apo/olice pr$ic&e1 ne populus 
false  intelligat eas pref]ri cet]is    
bonis op]ibus *>itatis4    #ag4 #db     
,doc5di sunt *ri/iani1 quod ,pape m5s   
non e/1 r$emptionem  v5i>um ulla ex p>te
 comp>&am esse op]ibus mis]icordie4     
#ah4 #dc ,doc5di sunt *ri/iani1 quod    
dans paup]i aut mutuans eg5ti  melius   

facit quam si v5ias r$im]eet4    #ai4   
#dd ,quia p] opus *>itatis crescit      
*>itas et fit homo melior1  s$ p] v5ias 
non fit melior s$ tantummodo a p5a      
lib]ior4    #bj4 #de ,doc5di sunt       
*ri/iani1 quod1 qui videt eg5um et      
neglecto eo  dat pro v5iis1 non         
idulg5tias ,pape s$ indignationem dei   
sibi  v5dicat4    #ba4 #df ,doc5di sunt 
*ri/iani1 quod nisi sup]fluis abund5t   
necess>ia t55tur domui sue ret9]e et    
nequaquam propt] v5ias  effund]e4       
#bb4 #dg ,doc5di sunt *ri/iani1 quod    
r$emptio v5i>um e/ lib]a1  non precepta4
    #bc4 #dh ,doc5di sunt *ri/iani1 quod
 ,papa sicut magis eget ita magis  optat
 9 v5iis d&is pro se devotam orationem  
quam promptam pecuniam4    #bd4 #di     
,doc5di sunt *ri/iani1 quod v5ie ,pape  
sunt utiles1 si non  9 cas confidant1   
,s$ noc5tissime1 si timorem dei p] eas  
amittant4    #be4 #ej ,doc5di sunt      
*ri/iani1 quod si ,papa nosset          
exactiones  v5ialium pr$icatorum1 mallet
 ,basilicam s4 ,petri 9 c9]es ire quam  

edific>i cute1 c>ne et ossibus ovium    
su>um4    #a4 #ea ,doc5di sunt *ri/iani1
 quod ,papa sicut debet ita vellet1     
etiam v5dita 7si opus sit7 ,basilicam s4
 ,petri1 de suis pecuniis d>e  illis1 a 
quorum plurimis quidam concionatores    
v5i>um pecuniam  eliciunt4    #b4 #eb   
,vana e/ fiducia salutis p] lit]as      
v5i>um1 etiam si  ,commiss>ius1 immo    
,papa ipse suam animam pro illis        
impign]>et4  #c4  #ec ,ho/es ,*ri/i et  
,pape sunt ii1 qui propt] v5ias pr$ic&as
  v]bum dei 9 aliis ecclesiis p5itus    
sil]e iub5t4    #d4 #ed ,iniuria fit    
v]bo dei1 dum 9 eodem s]mone equale vel 
longius  tempus imp5ditur v5iis quam    
illi4    #e4 #ee ,m5s ,pape necess>io   
e/1 quod1 si v5ie 7quod m9imum e/7 una  
campana1 unis pompis et c]emoniis       
celebrantur1 ,euangelium 7quod  maximum 
e/7 c5tum campanis1 c5tum pompis1 c5tum 
c]emoniis  pr$icetur4    #f4 #ef ,!sauri
 ecclesie1 unde ,pape dat indulg5tias1  
neque satis  nom9ati sunt neque cogniti 
apud populum ,*ri/i4    #g4 #eg         

,temporales c]te non esse patet1 quod   
non tam facile eos  pr(undunt1 s$       
tantummodo colligunt multi              
concionatorum4    #h4 #eh ,nec sunt     
m]ita ,*ri/i et sanctorum1 quia hec     
semp] s9e ,papa  op]antur gratiam hom9is
 int]ioris et crucem1 mortem inf]numque 
ext]ioris4    #i4 #ei ,!sauros ecclesie 
s4 ,laur5tius dixit esse paup]es        
ecclesie1  s$ locutus e/ usu vocabuli   
suo tempore4    #aj4 #fj ,s9e tem]itate 
dicimus claves ecclesie 7m]ito ,*ri/i   
donatas7 esse !saurum i/um4    #aa4 #fa 
,cl>um e/ enim1 quod ad remissionem     
p5>um et casuum sola  sufficit pote/as  
,pape4    #ab4 #fb ,v]us !saurus        
ecclesie e/ sacrosanctum euangelium     
glorie et  gratie dei4    #ac4 #fc ,hic 
autem e/ m]ito odiosissimus1 quia ex    
primis facit  novissimos4    #ad4 #fd   
,!saurus autem indulg5ti>um m]ito e/    
gratissimus1 quia ex  novissimis facit  
primos4    #ae4 #fe ,igitur !sauri      
,euangelici rhetia sunt1 quibus olim    
piscabantur viros diviti>um4    #af4 #ff

 ,!sauri indulg5ti>um rhetia sunt1      
quibus nunc piscantur  divitias virorum4
    #ag4 #fg ,indulg5tie1 quas          
concionatores vocif]antur maximas       
gratias1  intelliguntur v]e tales quoad 
que/um promov5dum4    #ah4 #fh ,sunt    
tam5 re v]a m9ime ad gratiam dei et     
crucis pietatem  comp>ate4    #ai4 #fi  
,t55tur ,episcopi et ,curati v5i>um     
apo/olic>um  ,commiss>ios cum omni      
rev]5tia admitt]e4  #bj4 #gj ,s$ magis  
t55tur omnibus oculis int5d]e1 omnibus  
auribus adv]t]e1 ne pro  commissione    
,pape sua illi somnia pr$ic5t4  #ba4 #ga
 ,contra v5i>um  apo/olic>um v]itatem   
qui loquitur1 sit ille ana!ma et        
mal$ictus4    #bb4 #gb ,qui v]o1 contra 
libid9em ac lic5tiam v]borum            
,concionatoris  v5i>um curam agit1 sit  
ille b5$ictus4    #bc4 #gc ,sicut ,papa 
iu/e fulm9at eos1 qui 9 fraudem negocii 
v5i>um  quacunque arte ma*9antur1       
#bd4 #gd ,multomagnis fulm9>e int5dit   
eos1 qui p] v5i>um pretextum  9 fraudem 
sancte *>itatis et v]itatis ma*9antur1  

#be4 #ge ,op9>i v5ias papales tantas    
esse1 ut solv]e poss9t  hom9em1 etiam si
 quis p] impossibile dei g5itricem      
violasset1 ,e/  insanire4    #a4 #gf    
,dicimus contra1 quod v5ie papales nec  
m9imum v5ialium  peccatorum toll]e      
poss9t quo ad culpam4    #b4 #gg ,quod  
dicitur1 nec si s4 ,petrus modo ,papa   
esset maiores gratias  don>e posset1 e/ 
blasphemia 9 sanctum ,petrum et ,papam4 
#c4 #gh ,dicimus contra1 quod etiam i/e 
et quilibet papa maiores habet1         
scilicet ,euangelium1 virtutes1 gratias1
 curationum c4 ut #a4 ,co4 ,,xii4    #d4
 #gi ,dic]e1 ,crucem armis papalibus    
insignit] erectam cruci ,*ri/i          
equival]e1 blasphemia e/4    #e4 #hj    
,rationem r$d5t ,episcopi1 ,curati et   
,!ologi1 ,qui tales  s]mones 9 populum  
lic]e s9unt4    #f4 #ha ,facit hec      
lic5tiosa v5i>um pr$icatio1 ut nec      
rev]5tiam  ,pape facile sit etiam doctis
 viris r$im]e a calumniis aut c]te      
argutis que/ionibus laicorm4    #g4 #hb 
,scilicet4 ,cur ,papa non evacuat       

purgatorium propt] sanctissimam         
*>itatem et summam anim>um necessitatem 
ut causam omnium  iu/issimam1 ,si       
inf9itas animas r$imit propt] pecuniam  
fune/issimam  ad /ructuram ,basilice ut 
causam levissimam8    #h4 #hc ,item4    
,cur p]man5t exequie et anniv]s>ia      
defunctorum et non  r$dit aut recipi    
p]mittit b5eficia pro illis in/ituta1   
cum iam sit  iniuria pro r$emptis or>e8 
#i4 #hd ,item4 ,que illa nova pietas    
,dei et ,pape1 quod impio et inimico    
propt] pecuniam conc$unt animam piam et 
amicam dei r$im]e1 ,et tam5  propt]     
necessitatem ipsius met pie et dilecte  
anime non r$imunt eam  gratuita *>itate8
    #aj4 #he ,item4 ,cur ,canones       
p5it5tiales re ipsa et non usu iam diu 9
  semet abrogati et mortui adhuc tam5   
pecuniis r$imuntur p]  concessionem     
indulg5ti>um tanquam vivacissimi8       
#aa4 #hf ,item4 ,cur ,papa1 cuius opes  
hodie sunt opul5tissimis ,crassis       
crassiores1 non de suis pecuniis magis  
quam paup]um fidelium /ruit  unam       

tantummodo ,basilicam sancti ,petri8    
#ab4 #hg ,item4 ,quid remittit aut      
p>ticipat ,papa iis1 qui p]             
contritionem p]fectam ius hab5t pl5>ie  
remissionis et  p>ticipationis8    #ac4 
#hh ,item4 ,quid add]etur ecclesie boni 
maioris1 ,si ,papa1 sicut  semel facit1 
ita c5ties 9 die cuilibet fidelium has  
remissiones et  p>ticipationes tribu]et8
    #ad4 #hi ,ex quo ,papa salutem qu]it
 anim>um p] v5ias magis quam  pecunias1 
,cur susp5dit lit]as et v5ias iam olim  
concessas1 cum s9t  eque efficaces8     
#ae4 #ij ,hec scrupulosissima laicorum  
argum5ta sola pote/ate  compesc]e nec   
r$dita ratione dilu]e1 ,e/ ecclesiam et 
,papam ho/ibus  rid5dos expon]e et      
infelices *ri/ianos fac]e4    #af4 #ia  
,si ergo v5ie secundum spiritum et m5tem
 ,pape pr$ic>5tur1  facile illa omnia   
solv]5tur1 immo non ess5t4    #ag4 #ib  
,valeant itaque omnes illi prophete1 qui
 dicunt populo ,*ri/i  ',pax pax1' et   
non e/ pax4    #ah4 #ic ,b5e agant omnes
 illi prophete1 qui dicunt populo ,*ri/i

  ',crux crux1' et non e/ crux4    #ai4 
#id ,exhort&i sunt ,*ri/iani1 ut caput  
suum ,*ri/um p] p5as1  mortes inf]nosque
 sequi /udeant1    #bj4 #ie ,ac sic     
magis p] multas tribulationes intr>e    
celum quam p]  securitatem pacis        
confidant4    ,m4,d4,xvii4