,,love--,,marriage-- ,,birth ,,control ,being a ,speech delivered at the ,church ,congress at ,birmingham1 ,october1 #aiba3 ,,with ,a ,,foreword ,,by ,,lord ,,dawson ,,of ,,penn ,illustration3 logo ,london ,,nisbet ,,co4 ,,ltd4 #bb ,,berners ,,street1 ,w4#a ,first ,published ,january1 #aibb ,reprinted ,january1 #aibb ,reprinted ,february1 #aibb ,reprinted ,april1 #aibb ,all rights reserved ,,foreword ,at the ,church ,congress held this autumn at ,birmingham ,i was honoured by an invitation to speak on ,sexual ,relationships4 ,the subject-matter of that speech has aroused widespread interest and some controversy4 ,it is being published in response to numerous requests and because most of the reports1 being of necessity condensed1 inadequately and even in some instances incorrectly set forth the views ,i endeavoured to champion2 for any speech on a subject so difficult to handle needs to be read in its entirety if misapprehensions are to be avoided4 ,and first1 may ,i thank numerous correspondents2 and those in disagreement equally with those in agreement with me4 ,one and all they bear testimony1 if indeed such were needed1 to how widespread and responsible is the interest on this question1 and therefore to the wisdom of its full consideration4 ,amongst the letters are intimate human documents which pathetically disclose1 as does professional experience1 how frequently happiness is marred by ignorance of either the principles or the methods which should condition the true conception of sexual relationships4 ,i elected to deal with these relationships in their healthy rather than their morbid aspects1 because the study of health is a sure way to lessen disease4 ,mere denunciations of evil serve but small purpose4 ,the aim of statesmanship is rather to seek out causes and ponder over remedies1 and prominent among remedies is surely the study of the significance and purport of sex love in a well-ordered and ,christian community and provision for its healthy outlet4 ,to this the first part of my speech was devoted4 ,the view there upheld has brought forth a large measure of agreement and no reasoned disagreement4 ,the second part of my speech dealing with birth control 7or what in strict accuracy should be called conception control7 has aroused more controversy1 but ,i venture to think that some1 at least1 of the criticism directed against my argument will disappear with a perusal of this full text of my speech4 ,therein will be found condemnation of infertile marriages and a strong plea that children are essential to the health and happiness of man and woman1 are necessary to each other and of vital importance to the nation4 ,the difference between my critics and myself is not as to the vital necessity of the family following marriage1 but rather this--they would like to see the large families prevalent fifty years ago restored 7and where means and circumstances are favourable1 such large families may be the source of much happiness72 whereas under present-day conditions ,i should regard them as seldom attainable and desirable1 and would favour smaller families of children born at predetermined intervals4 ,a married couple who have produced four children in twenty years cannot be said to have ignored the precept be fruitful and multiply and replenish the earth because they have so selected the times for the conceptions of their children as to enable them to give those children a better upbringing rather than have selfishly left the sequence of their offspring to blind chance4 ,the argument that the nation should foster large families in order more quickly to people the untenanted portions of the ,empire1 and so add to the strength and wealth of the ,british ,dominions1 requires serious attention1 not in isolation1 but in conjunction with other considerations1 and calls forth varying opinions from economists4 ,on the other hand1 emigration into foreign lands would seem to be a source of weakness to a nation4 ,the feeding1 clothing and educating of a young ,briton cost the nation a definite sum of money1 say1 ,l#djj2 if at the age of twenty1 when he is ready to produce1 that young ,briton emigrates to a foreign state1 he is a definite loss to the country of his birth and the country of his adoption is the gainer4 ,from another standpoint the criticism is made that ,i have not urged the paramount necessity of diminishing the population of these islands4 ,with the economic soundness of this view others are better fitted to deal1 but no economic considerations would outweigh the importance of child life inspiring the homes of the land1 and if the number and sequence of children can be regulated by the parents' circumstances1 these homes will increase in number1 will start when parents are younger and confer greater benefits alike on the family and the ,state4 ,if need be1 the ,state could grant a progressive rebate of taxation1 and educational facilities for each of three children born after the second and where the father is twenty-five years of age or upwards4 ,it is held by some that artificial birth control is contrary to ,christian morals4 ,this is the view firmly held by the ,roman ,catholic ,church1 and since the governance of the ,roman communion is based on authority1 its decisions are binding on its members and command our respect4 ,but pronouncements of ,protestant communions do not owe their force to authority1 but to the conviction they carry in the minds and consciences of their people1 and no clear scriptural sanction for the condemnation of birth control has been given1 nor does the report of the ,lambeth ,conference vouchsafe any reasons why it is physically and morally harmful4 ,a distinguished prelate of our ,church has characterised the views herein set forth as very unguarded4#a ,if by that expression he means careless1 he cannot have done me the honour of reading my speech1 which1 whatever its demerits1 bears ample evidence of carefully considered thought and expression4 ,if by unguarded he means outspoken1 ,i will plead justification4 ,for is it not time that a question which deeply concerns not only the thought1 but the practice of the thinking portions of communities should be fully considered and its strength and its weakness disclosed by full discussion8 ,the world looks to its leaders for reasoned guidance1 not for assertion which may be but the husk of a thought that has gone4 ,what is wanted is reasoned consideration1 not unreasoned condemnation4 ,for churchmen and statesmen alike1 opportunism helps in situations which are small1 but never in those which are large2 there clarity of principle alone stands forth as a beacon to light the path4 ,footnote #a3 ,diocesan ,conference at ,york4 ,the fear that discussion of this vital problem will endanger morality surely loses sight of the fact of knowledge being so fundamental to our well-being1 that incidental dangers encountered along its path must not deter us from its continued pursuit4 ,moreover1 it will be noticed that ,i have discriminated between the principle of birth control and the methods of its application1 the latter being preferably determined by the advice of the family doctor rather than by the perusal of books in general circulation4 ,the attitude of mind of the ,church towards the problems of sexual relationships is part of a larger question1 viz41 the ever-widening gap between the formal teaching of the ,church and the actual belief of the present generation1 including many who by baptism and early training belong to her fold4 ,this gap between authority and actuality of belief imposes a strain on intellectual integrity and weakens the foundations of a real allegiance4 ,for those of us who are of mature years the gap is bridged by the tender associations of our childhood and the memory of parents1 for whom no such gap existed1 and whose faith and character have left indelible impressions on our lives4 ,but for the youth of to-day no such bridge exists4 ,the ,war has caused a hiatus and thought has broken with tradition4 ,thus1 youth is no longer willing to accept forms and formulae only on account of their age4 ,so it has set out on a voyage of inquiry1 and finding some things which are doubtful and others which are insufficient1 is searching for forms of expression more in harmony with the realities of life and knowledge4 ,although becoming estranged in thought from the ,church1 it is possessed of deep religious feeling and1 firm on the rock foundation of faith1 is trying to build a superstructure more in accord with the progress of revelation1 not only in religion1 but in science1 and the needs of the world in which it moves and has its being4 ,far be it1 that ,i should write thee sin or blame1 ,or think thee unbefitting holiest place1 ,perpetual fountain of domestic sweets1 ,whose bed is undefiled and chaste pronounced1 ,present1 or past1 as saints and patriarchs used4 ,here ,love his golden shafts employs1 here lights ,his constant lamp1 and waves his purple wings1 ,reigns here and revels2 not in the bought smile ,of harlots1 loveless1 joyless1 unendeared1 ,casual fruition2 nor in court-amours1 ,mixed dance1 or wanton mask1 or midnight ball1 ,or serenate1 which the starved lover sings ,to his proud fair1 best quitted with disdain4 ,these1 lulled by nightingales1 embracing slept1 ,and on their naked limbs the flowery roof ,showered roses1 which the morn repaired4 ,paradise ,lost1 ,book ,,iv4 ,,love--,,marriage--,,birth ,,control ,may ,i make certain preliminary observations8 ,painters and poets depict ,love to us in golden hues and arouse in us happy and sympathetic1 and1 ,i trust1 reminiscent response1 helping us to realise that life without the love of man and woman would be like the world without sunshine4 ,though1 therefore1 the social student in his approach to the subject is not helped by the beauties of colour and song1 it behoves him to avoid undue solemnity1 and still more an air of portentous foreboding4 ,in each age customs have been deplored as heralds of evil1 but the evils have seldom materialised4 ,one of the difficulties of this subject is that those who are called upon to give counsel are apt to forget the strength of the forces to be dealt with1 for it is during youth especially that sex attractions are so powerful1 and1 may ,i add1 so delightful4 ,middle-aged people may be divided into three classes4 ,those who are still young4 ,those who have forgotten they were young4 ,those who were never young4 ,and it is with the first class before my eyes that ,i am privileged to address this audience4 ,i will confine my attention to the sexual relationships between unrelated adult people in youth and prime4 ,it is common ground that sex love between such people should be the physical expression of a lasting affection1 and be so intimately blended with the feelings of helpfulness1 sympathy1 and intimate friendship as to form a union of body1 mind and spirit4 ,it further should be associated with the love of and desire for children4 ,this complex is best secured by the institution of marriage4 ,all its constituent features1 except two1 are vividly realised in intimate friendship1 and above all1 in that unique bond between mother and son which with some of us is the most wonderful thing in our lives4 ,its two exclusively distinctive features are3 sex love and child love4 ,these are the real problems before us to-day1 particularly the former1 and if in these remarks ,i seem to concentrate on the problems of sex love1 be it understood ,i do so from a desire to save the time of the meeting and not because ,i think sex love should reign alone in unbalanced supremacy4 ,and by sex love ,i mean that love which involves intercourse or the desire for such4 ,it is necessary to my argument to emphasise that sex love is one of the clamant dominating forces of the world4 ,not only does history show the destinies of nations and dynasties determined by its sway--but here in our every-day life we see its influence1 direct or indirect1 forceful and ubiquitous beyond aught else4 ,,an ,,imperious ,,instinct4 ,any statesmanlike review1 therefore1 will recognise that here we have an instinct--so fundamental1 so imperious--that its influence is a fact which has to be accepted3 suppress it you cannot4 ,you may guide it into healthy channels--but an outlet it will have1 and if that outlet is inadequate or unduly obstructed1 irregular channels will be forced4 ,we uphold the control of sex love outside marriage by the individual--and that we are right in so doing is incontestable4 ,but let us realise that in practice self-control has a breaking point1 and that if in any community marriage is difficult or late of attainment1 an increase of irregular unions will inevitably result4 ,that the ,church recognises this is shown by the statement that marriage was instituted to prevent sin4 ,in considering the problem of illicit intercourse and its attendant evils the social conditions that make for a wholesome life are of more efficiency than ,acts of ,parliament to suppress vice4 ,my desire1 however1 on this occasion is rather to consider sex love in relation to marriage4 ,the first point ,i wish to make is that people need more knowledge of the scientific bearings of sex relations and more clearly defined guidance of their rightful purport and practice4 ,they are imperfectly provided with both4 ,we talk about instructing the young when we are neither clear nor agreed amongst ourselves1 and the young are endangered as much by crudity as by absence of instruction4 ,all are agreed that union of body should be in association with union of mind and soul2 all are agreed that the rearing of children is a pre-eminent purpose4 ,but what purport is there beyond these8 ,here there is a lack of precision4 ,,the ,,church ,,and ,,marriage4 ,what does the ,church service say8 ,it says ,marriage was ordained for a remedy against sin1 and to avoid fornication2 that such persons as have not the gift of continency might marry and keep themselves undefiled members of ,christ's body4 ,now this is a very negative blessing4 ,it implies that where unfortunately people cannot be continent that marriage gives the best way out--enables them to get relief within the pale of virtue4 ,this attitude affords to sex love no positive purport or merit of its own1 and is in striking conflict with the facts of life through the ages--facts which carry social approval4 ,the recent pronouncement of the ,church as set forth in ,resolution #fh of the ,lambeth ,conference seems to imply condemnation of sex love as such1 and to imply sanction of sex love only as a means to an end--namely1 procreation1 though it must be admitted it lacks that clearness of direction which in so vital a matter one would have expected4 ,it almost reminds me of one of those diplomatic formulae which is not intended to be too clear4 ,allow me to quote from it3-- ,in opposition to the teaching which under the name of science and religion encourages married people in the deliberate cultivation of sexual union as an end in itself1 we steadfastly uphold what must always be regarded as the governing consideration of ,christian marriage4 ,one is the primary purpose for which marriage exists--namely1 the continuation of the race through the gift and heritage of children2 the other is the paramount importance in married life of deliberate and thoughtful self-control4 ,,the ,,facts ,,of ,,life4 ,now the plain meaning of this statement is that sexual union should take place for the sole purpose of procreation1 that sexual union as an end in itself--not1 mind you1 the only end--7there we should all agree71 but sexual union as an end in itself is to be condemned4 ,that means that sexual intercourse should rightly take place only for the purpose of procreation4 ,now the large majority of conceptions take place immediately after and before the monthly period4 ,quite a large family could easily result from quite a few sexual unions4 ,for the rest the couple should be celibate4 ,any intercourse not having procreation as its intention is sexual union as an end in itself1 and therefore by inference condemned by the ,lambeth ,conference4 ,think of the facts of life4 ,let us recall our own love--our marriage1 our honeymoon4 ,has not sexual union over and over again been the physical expression of our love without thought or intention of procreation8 ,have we all been wrong8 ,or is it that the ,church lacks that vital contact with the realities of life which accounts for the gulf between her and the people8 ,the love envisaged by the ,lambeth ,conference is an invertebrate joyless thing--not worth the having4 ,fortunately it is in contrast to the real thing as practised by clergy and laity4 ,fancy an ardent lover 7and what respect have you for a lover who is not ardent7--the type you would like your daughter to marry--virile1 ambitious1 chivalrous--a man who means to work hard and love hard4 ,fancy putting before these lovers--eager and expectant of the joys before them--the ,lambeth picture of marriage4 ,do you expect to gain their confidence8 ,they ask for bread2 you give them a stone4 ,,allegiance ,,of ,,the ,,young4 ,authority1 and ,i include under authority the ,churches1 will never gain the allegiance of the young unless their attitude is more frank1 more courageous1 and more in accordance with realities4 ,and to tell you the truth1 ,i am not sure that too much prudent self-restraint suits love and its purport4 ,romance and deliberate self-control do not1 to my mind1 rhyme very well together4 ,a touch of madness to begin with does no harm4 ,heaven knows life sobers it soon enough4 ,if you don't start life with a head of steam you won't get far4 ,sex love has1 apart from parenthood1 a purport of its own4 ,it is something to prize and to cherish for its own sake4 ,it is an essential part of health and happiness in marriage4 ,and now1 if you will allow me1 ,i will carry this argument a step further4 ,if sexual union is a gift of ,god it is worth learning how to use it4 ,within its own sphere it should be cultivated so as to bring physical satisfaction to both1 not merely to one4 ,the attainment of mutual and reciprocal joy in their relations constitutes a firm bond between two people and makes for durability of their marriage tie4 ,reciprocity in sex love is the physical counterpart of sympathy4 ,more marriages fail from inadequate and clumsy sex love than from too much sex love4 ,,passion ,a ,,worthy ,,possession4 ,the lack of proper understanding is in no small measure responsible for the unfulfilment of 7connubial7 happiness1 and every degree of discontent and unhappiness may from this cause occur1 leading to rupture of the marriage bond itself4 ,how often do medical men have to deal with these difficulties1 and how fortunate if such difficulties are disclosed early enough in married life to be rectified4 ,otherwise how tragic may be their consequences1 and many a case in the ,divorce ,court has thus had its origin4 ,to the foregoing contentions it might be objected you are encouraging passion4 ,my reply would be1 passion is a worthy possession2 most men1 who are any good1 are capable of passion4 ,you all enjoy ardent and passionate love in art and literature4 ,why not give it a place in real life8 ,why some people look askance at passion is because they are confusing it with sensuality4 ,sex love without passion is a poor1 lifeless thing4 ,sensuality1 on the other hand1 is on a level with gluttony--a physical excess--detached from sentiment1 chivalry1 or tenderness4 ,it is just as important to give sex love its place as to avoid its over emphasis4 ,its real and effective restraints are those imposed by a loving and sympathetic companionship1 by the privileges of parenthood1 the exacting claims of career and that civic sense which prompts men to do social service4 ,now that the revision of the ,prayer ,book is receiving consideration1 ,i should like to suggest1 with great respect1 that an addition be made to the objects of marriage in the ,marriage ,service1 in these terms3 ,the complete realisation of the love of this man and this woman1 the one for the other4 ,,birth ,,control4 ,and now1 if you will permit me1 ,i will pass on to consider the all-important question of ,birth ,control4 ,first1 ,i will put forward with confidence the view that birth control is here to stay4 ,it is an established fact1 and for good or evil has to be accepted4 ,although the extent of its application can be and is being modified1 no denunciations will abolish it4 ,despite the influence and condemnations of the ,church1 it has been practised in ,france for well over half a century1 and in ,belgium and other ,catholic countries is extending4 ,and if the ,roman ,catholic ,church1 with its compact organisation1 its power of authority1 and its discipline1 cannot check this procedure1 is it likely that ,protestant ,churches will be able to do so8--for ,protestant religions depend for their strength on the conviction and esteem they establish in the heads and hearts of their people4 ,the reasons which lead parents to limit their offspring are sometimes selfish1 but more often honourable and cogent4 ,the desire to marry and to rear children well equipped for life's struggle1 limited incomes1 the cost of living1 burdensome taxation1 are forcible motives2 and1 further1 amongst the educated classes there is the desire of women to take a part in life and their husband's careers1 which is incompatible with oft-recurring pregnancies4 ,absence of birth control means late marriages1 and these carry with them irregular unions and all the baneful consequences4 ,it is idle to decry illicit intercourse and interpose obstacles to marriage at one and the same time4 ,but1 say many whose opinions are entitled to our respect3 ,yes--birth control may be necessary1 but the only birth control which is justifiable is voluntary abstention from connubial relations4 ,such abstention would be either ineffective or1 if effective1 impracticable and harmful to health and happiness4 ,to limit the size of a family to1 say1 four children during a child-bearing period of #bj-be years1 would be to impose on a married couple an amount of abstention which for long periods would almost be equivalent to celibacy1 and when one remembers that owing to economic reasons the abstention would have to be most strict during the earlier years of married life when desires are strongest1 ,i maintain a demand is being made which for the mass of people it is impossible to meet2 that the endeavours to meet it would impose a strain hostile to health and happiness and carry with them grave dangers to morals4 ,imagine a young married couple in love with each other--the parents1 say1 of one child1 who feel they cannot afford another child for1 say1 three years--being expected to occupy the same room and to abstain for two years4 ,the thing is preposterous4 ,you might as well put water by the side of a man suffering from thirst and tell him not to drink it4 ,and further than that1 if the efforts to abstain are seriously made the strain involved is harmful to the health and temper--if the efforts do not succeed the minds of husband and wife are troubled by doubts and anxieties which are damaging to their intimate relationships4 ,and1 moreover1 if this harmful restraint succeeds in preventing conception there eventuates the inevitable prevalence of sex excitement followed by abortive and half-realised satisfaction1 and the enhanced risk of the man or woman yielding to outside sex temptations4 ,no--birth control by abstention is either ineffective1 or1 if effective1 is pernicious4 ,,the ,,home',s ,,true ,,interests4 ,i will next consider ,artificial ,control4 ,the forces in modern life which make for birth control are so strong that only convincing reasons will make people desist from it4 ,it is said to be unnatural and intrinsically immoral4 ,this word unnatural perplexes me4 ,civilisation involves the chaining of natural forces and their conversion to man's will and uses4 ,much of medicine and surgery consists of means to overcome nature4 ,when anaesthetics were first used at childbirth there was an outcry on the part of many worthy and religious people that their use under such circumstances was unnatural and wicked1 because ,god meant woman to suffer the struggles and pains of childbirth4 ,now we all admit it is right to control the process of childbirth1 and to save the mother as much pain as possible4 ,it is no more unnatural to control conception by artificial means than to control childbirth by artificial means4 ,surely the whole question turns on whether these artificial means are for the good or harm of the individual and the community6 ,do all contraceptive measures damage the individual8 ,the answer to that depends on the purpose for which they are used4 ,if they are used to render unions childless or inadequately fruitful they are harmful4 ,there are grounds for thinking that unrealisation of maternity favours sterility4 ,generally speaking1 birth control before the first child is inadvisable4 ,on the other hand1 the justifiable use of birth control is to limit the number of children1 and to spread out their arrival in such a way as to serve their true interests and those of their home4 ,that such applications of birth control produce no harm receives support from the study of the numbers and distribution of the children of the professional classes4 ,the advantage and disadvantage of this or that contraceptive is a technical matter for the doctors to determine4 ,again1 it has been stated that artificial control is harmful because it leads to excessive indulgence4 ,experience and evidence are against this being a fact4 ,contraceptives by the time and circumstance of their application involve prudence and control4 ,the proper and efficient restraints on undue sexual indulgence are to be found in mutual consideration1 sympathy1 and tenderness and the pressing claims of life's duties4 ,the sensualist who is not deterred from excess by these considerations will be completely careless whether his indulgence results in children or not--he is moved by his selfish impulses alone4 ,,careful ,,distinction4 ,once more1 careful distinction needs to be made between the use and the bad effects of the abuse of birth control4 ,that its abuse produces harm ,i fully agree--harm to parents1 to families1 and to the nation4 ,but abuse is not a just condemnation of legitimate use4 ,over-eating1 over-drinking1 over-smoking1 over-sleeping1 over-work do not carry condemnation of eating1 drinking1 smoking1 sleeping1 work4 ,but the evils of excessive birth control are very real4 ,there is first the individual--every woman is better in body and mind for child bearing--the periodic completion of the maternal cycle brings out the best1 preserves youth and maintains vital contact with life4 ,maternity gives to woman her most beautiful attributes4 ,fancy being mad enough to suppress it6 ,if one watches the woman with one child and all maternity finished before thirty1 and compare her at forty with the woman of the same age who has had1 say1 four children at proper intervals1 who usually has the advantage in preservation of youth and beauty8 ,not the former4 ,on the other hand1 it must be admitted that baby after baby every year or eighteen months wears and often exhausts a woman's strength4 ,the inference is that the use of birth control is good1 its abuse bad4 ,next1 the children4 ,is it even necessary to refer to the failure of the single-child household8 ,poor little thing6 ,surrounded by over-anxious parents1 spoilt1 no children to play with1 bored stiff by adults4 ,and then1 perhaps1 illness1 and it may be death--and when it is too late to produce another4 ,of the many tragedies ,i met in the war none exceeded that attaching to the loss of only children4 ,it often means the end of all things2 nothing to live for--just blank despair4 ,,the ,,way ,,of ,,happiness4 ,the parents and the home both need children of varying ages4 ,that is the way of happiness and enduring youth4 ,and lastly1 the national aspect may be stated very briefly4 ,if ,england is not to lose her place in the world her population must be maintained4 ,unless fathers and mothers produce an average of over three children that population will not be maintained4 ,if you say to a young husband and wife with their one or two children1 ,do you like to contemplate that when you both leave life your country will1 through your action1 be worse off than when you entered life8 that is an appeal to patriotism1 and likely to be a successful appeal4 ,there are signs of a public opinion forming which will condemn the selfishness of marriages without their proper heritage of children1 but such public opinion will not be strengthened by an indiscriminate condemnation of birth control4 ,may ,i end my speech with an appeal that the ,church approaches this question1 in common with certain others1 in the light of modern knowledge and the needs of a new world1 and unhampered by traditions which have outworn their usefulness8 ,,printed ,,in ,,great ,,britain ,,by ,,the ,,whitefriars ,,press1 ,,ltd41 ,,london ,,and ,,tonbridge4