,transcrib]'s note3 ,a few typographical errors h be5 correct$3 !y are li/$ at ! end ( ! text4 ,9 ma!matical =mulae ! c>at 77 & und]score 77 introduce sup]scripts or subscripts respectively1 ( "o "* or a gr\p enclos$ 9 curly braces 7xyz74 ,else:]e und]scores delimit italics 9 ! text1 & braces enclose ! orig9al page numb]s ?us #abc4 ,,by ,,augu/us ,,de ,,morgan ,a ,,budget ,,( ,,p>adoxes ,,repr9t$ ,,) ,,! ,,au?or',s ,,additions ,,f ,,! ,,a!naeum ,,second ,,edition ,,edit$ ,,by ,,david ,,eug5e ,,smi? ,,) ,a ,,new ,,introduction ,,by ,,erne/ ,,nagel ,,pr(essor ,,( ,,philosophy1 ,,columbia ,,univ]sity ,,unabridg$ ,,edition--,,two ,,volumes ,,b\nd ,,z ,,"o ,volume ,,ii ,,dov] ,,publications1 ,,inc41 ,,new ,,york 99 99 99 99 99 ,?is new ,dov] ,edition1 publi%$ 9 #aied1 is an unabridg$ republication ( ! ,second ,edition ( #aiae1 ) a new introduction by ,pr(essor ,erne/ ,nagel4 ,copyright #aied by ,dov] ,publications1 ,inc4 ,manufactur$ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates ( ,am]ica 99 99 99 99 99 #a ,a ,,budget ,,( ,,p>adoxes4 ,,volume ,,ii4 ,,on ,,"s ,,philosophical ,,a!i/s4 ,) ! g5]al run ( ! philosophical a!i/s ( ! la/ c5tury ! notion ( a ,god 0 an hypo!sis4 ,!re 0 left an admitt$ possibility t ! vague some:at :i* w5t by m names ?an "o1 might be p]sonal1 intellig5t1 & sup]9t5d5t4 ,9 ! works ( ,laplace1#a :o is sometimes call$ an a!i/ f 8 writ+s1 !re is no?+ f :i* su* an inf]5ce c be drawn3 unless inde$ a ,rev]5d ,fell[ ( ! ,royal ,society may be held to be ! fool :o said 9 8 he>t1 etc41 etc41 if 8 contributions to ! ,philosophical ,transactions g no high] ?an nature4 ,! foll[+ anecdote is well kn[n 9 ,p>is1 b has nev] be5 pr9t$ entire4 ,laplace once w5t 9 =m to pres5t "s edition ( 8 ,sy/eme du ,monde to ! ,fir/ ,consul1 or ,emp]or4 ,napoleon1 :om "s wags _h told t ?is book conta9$ no m5tion ( ! "n ( ,god1 & :o 0 fond ( putt+ emb>rass+ que/ions1 receiv$ x )--,m4 ,laplace1 !y tell me y h writt5 ?is l>ge book on ! sy/em ( ! univ]se1 & h nev] ev5 m5tion$ its ,creator4 ,laplace1 :o1 ?\gh ! mo/ supple ( politicians1 0 z /iff z a m>tyr on e po9t ( 8 philosophy or religion 7e4 g41 ev5 "u ,*>les ,x he nev] conceal$ 8 dislike ( ! prie/s71 drew himself up & answ]$ #b bluntly1 ,je n'avais pas beso9 de cette hypo!se-la4#b ,napoleon1 greatly amus$1 told ?is reply to ,lagrange1 :o exclaim$1 ,ah6 c'e/ une belle hypo!se2 ca explique beauc\p de *oses4#c ,x is commonly said t ! la/ words ( ,laplace 71 ,ce que n\s connaissons e/ peu de *ose2 ce que n\s ignorons e/ imm5se4#d ,?is looks l a p>ody on ,newton's pebbles3#e ! foll[+ is ! true acc\nt2 x comes to me ?r\gh "o remove f ,poisson4#f ,aft] ! publication 79 #ahbe7 ( ! fif? volume ( ! ,mecanique ,cele/e1 ,laplace became gradually weak]1 & ) x mus+ & ab/ract$4 ,he ?\ght mu* on ! great problems ( exi/5ce1 & (t5 mutt]$ to himself1 ,qu'e/ ce que c'e/ que t\t cela6#g ,aft] _m alt]nations1 he appe>$ at la/ s p]man5tly pro/rat$ t 8 family appli$ to 8 favorite pupil1 ,m4 ,poisson1 to try to get a ^w f him4 ,poisson paid a visit1 & aft] a few words ( salutation1 said1 ,j'ai une bonne n\velle a v\s annonc]3 on a recu au ,bureau des ,longitudes une lettre d',allemagne annoncant que ,m4 ,bessel a v]ifie p> l'obs]vation vos dec\v]tes !oriques sur les satellites de ,jupit]4#h ,laplace op5$ 8 eyes & answ]$ ) deep #c gravity1 ,l'homme ne p\rsuit que des *im]es4#i ,he nev] spoke aga94 ,8 dea? took place ,m>* #e1 #ahbg4 ,! language us$ by ! two great geomet]s illu/rates :at ,i h said3 a supreme & guid+ intellig5ce--ap>t f a bl9d rule call$ nature ( ?+s--0 an hypo!sis4 ,! absolute d5ial ( su* a rul+ p[] 0 n 9 ! plan ( ! high] philosoph]s3 x 0 left = ! small] fry4 ,a r\nd ass]tion ( ! non-exi/5ce ( any?+ :i* /&s 9 ! way is ! refuge ( a c]ta9 class ( m9ds3 b x succe$s only ) ?+s subjective2 ! objective (f]s resi/ance4 ,a philosoph] ( ! appropriative class tri$ x ^u ! con/able :o appropriat$ him3 ,i d5y y\r exi/5ce1 said he2 ,come along all ! same1 said ! unpsy*ological policeman4 ,eul]#aj 0 a believ] 9 ,god1 d[nright & /raight=w>d4 ,! foll[+ /ory is told by ,?iebault1#aa 9 8 ,s\v5irs de v+t ans de sej\r a ,b]l91#ab publi%$ 9 8 old age1 ab\t #ahjd4 ,?is volume 0 fully receiv$ z tru/wor?y2 & ,m>%all ,moll5dorff#ac told ! ,duc de ,bassano#ad 9 #ahjg t x 0 ! mo/ v]aci\s ( books writt5 by ! mo/ hone/ ( m54 ,?iebault says t he has no p]sonal k ( ! tru? ( ! /ory1 b #d t x 0 believ$ ?r\gh\t ! :ole ( ! nor? ( ,europe4 ,did]ot#ae paid a visit to ! ,russian ,c\rt at ! invitation ( ! ,empress4 ,he conv]s$ v freely1 & gave ! y\ng] memb]s ( ! ,c\rt circle a good deal ( lively a!ism4 ,! ,empress 0 mu* amus$1 b "s ( h] c\ncillors sugge/$ t x might be desirable to *eck ^! expositions ( doctr9e4 ,! ,empress did n l to put a direct muzzle on h] gue/'s tongue1 s ! foll[+ plot 0 contriv$4 ,did]ot 0 in=m$ t a le>n$ ma!matician 0 9 possession ( an algebraical demon/ration ( ! exi/5ce ( ,god1 & w\ld give x him be=e all ! ,c\rt1 if he desir$ to he> x4 ,did]ot gladly cons5t$3 ?\gh ! "n ( ! ma!matician is n giv51 x 0 ,eul]4 ,he advanc$ t[>ds ,did]ot1 & said gravely1 & 9 a tone ( p]fect conviction3 ,monsieur1 7a bn7 _/ n x1 donc ,dieu exi/e2 repondez6#af ,did]ot1 to :om algebra 0 ,hebrew1 0 emb>rass$ & disconc]t$2 :ile peals ( laught] rose on all sides4 ,he ask$ p]mission to return to ,france at once1 :i* 0 grant$4 ,,rotation ,,( ,,! ,,moon4 ,an exam9ation ( ! ,a/ronomical doctr9e ( ! ,moon's rotation4 ,by ,j4 ,l4#ag ,ed9burgh1 #ahdg1 #hvo4 ,a sy/ematic attack ( ! "* aft]w>ds made ) less skill & m notice by ,mr4 ,jell+] ,symons4 ,july #ahff1 ,j4 ,l4 appe>s z ,mr4 ,james ,laurie1 ) a new pamphlet ,! ,a/ronomical doctr9es ( ! ,moon's rotation 444 ,ed9burgh4 ,( all ! works ,i h se5 on ! "q1 ?is is ! mo/ confid5t1 & ! sore/4 #e ,a writ] on a/ronomy said ( ,mr4 ,jell+] ,symons1#ah ,( c\rse he conv9c$ no "o :o knew any?+ ( ! subject4 ,?is ung5]\s slur on ! speculator's memory appe>s to h be5 ke5ly felt2 b its tru? is admitt$4 ,^? :o knew any?+ ( ! subject are ! s-call$ m5 ( sci5ce1 ^: ?ree ,p's 7 assail$2 pre/ige1 pride1 & prejudice3 ?is ! au?or tries to effect = himself ) ?ree ,q's2 quibble1 quirk1 & quiddity4 ,he expla9s t ! ,scribes & ,ph>isees w\ld n he> ,jesus1 & t ! lordly bi%op ( ,rome w n ca/ 8 ti>a & keys at ! feet ( ! humble presbyt] :o n[ plays ! "p ( pope 9 ,scotl&4 ,i d n "k :om he means3 b p]haps ! fri5ds ( ! presbyt]-pope may consid] ?is an ung5]\s slur4 ,! be/ pro( ( ! a/ronom] is j su* z might h be5 expect$ f ! m]e/ ( blockheads2 b z ! giv] is ( c\rse n a blockhead1 ?is circum/ance %[s h[ deeply bl9d$ by prejudice he mu/ be4 ,( c\rse ! p>adox]s d n p]suade any p]sons :o "k _! subjects3 & s ^! ,scribes & ,ph>isees reject ! ,messiah4 ,we mu/ suppose t ! mak]s ( ?is comp>ison are ,*ri/ians3 = if !y ?\ght ! ,messiah an en?usia/ or an impo/or1 !y w\ld be absurd 9 comp>+ ^? :o reject :at !y take = tru? ) o!rs :o once reject$ :at !y take = falsehood4 ,& if ,*ri/ians1 !y are bo? irrev]5t & bl9d to all analogy4 ,! ,messiah1 ) ,8 ,div9e mission prov$ by miracles :i* all might see :o *ose to look1 is degrad$ into a prototype ( ,james ,laurie1 +5i\sly a/ronomiz+ ^u ignorant geometry & false logic1 & comp>+ to blockheads ^? :o expose 8 nons5se4 ,_! comp>ison is z fooli% z--suppos+ #f !m ,*ri/ians--x is pr(ane3 b1 l errors 9 g5]al1 its o!r end po9ts to tru?4 ,!re 7 ,pseudo*ri/s & ,anti*ri/s2 & a ,concordance w\ld f9d ! real =]unn]s ( all ! p>adox]s4 ,b !y are n s clev] z ! old false prophets3 !re are none ( :om we %\ld be incl9$ to say t1 if x 7 possible1 !y w\ld deceive ! v educat$4 ,n an ,egyptian among !m all c make upro> en\gh to collect f\r ?\s& m5 t are murd]]s--( common s5se--to lead out into ! wild]ness4 ,no?+1 says ! motto ( ?is "w1 is s difficult to de/roy z ! errors & false facts propagat$ by illu/ri\s m5 ^: words h au?ority4 ,i d5y x altoge!r4 ,!re are ?+s mu* m difficult to de/roy3 x is mu* m difficult to de/roy ! tru?s & real facts support$ by su* m54 ,& aga91 x is mu* m difficult to prev5t m5 ( no au?ority f sett+ up false pret5sions2 & x is mu* m difficult to de/roy ass]tions ( fancy speculation4 ,_m an error ( ?\ght & le>n+ has fall5 be=e a gradual gr[? ( ?\ghtful & le>n$ opposition4 ,b su* ?+s z ! quadrature ( ! circle1 etc41 are nev] put d[n4 ,& :y8 ,because ?\ght c influ5ce ?\ght1 b ?\ght _c influ5ce self-conceit3 le>n+ c annihilate le>n+3 b le>n+ _c annihilate ignorance4 ,a sword may cut ?r\gh an iron b>2 & ! sev]$ ends w n reunite3 let x g ?r\gh ! air1 & ! yield+ sub/ance is :ole aga9 9 a mom5t4 ,miracles v]sus ,nature3 be+ an application ( c]ta9 propositions 9 ! !ory ( *ances to ! ,*ri/ian miracles4 ,by ,protimale!s4#ai ,cambridge1 #ahdg1 #hvo4 ,! !ory1 z may be suppos$1 is c>ri$ fur!r ?an mo/ /ud5ts ( ! subject w\ld hold def5sible4 #g ,an a/ronomical ,lecture4 ,by ! ,rev4 ,r4 ,wilson4#bj ,gre5ock1 #ahdg1 #abmo4 ,aga9/ ! moon's rotation on h] axis4 ,h&$ ab\t 9 ! /reets 9 #ahdg3 ,i quote ! :ole3 ,important discov]y 9 a/ronomy1 communicat$ to ! ,a/ronom] ,royal1 ,decemb] #ba/1 #ahdf4 ,t ! ,sun revolve r\nd ! ,planets 9 #begdh-b_/e ye>s1 9 consequ5ce ( ! comb9$ attraction ( ! planets & _! satellites1 & t ! ,e>? revolve r\nd ! ,moon 9 #ah ye>s & #bbh days4 ,d4 ,t4 ,,glazi] alt]$ ) a p5 into ,,glazion4 ,price "o p5ny4 #ahdg4 ,9 ! ,unit$ ,s]vice ,magaz9e = ,septemb]1 #ahdg1 ,mrs4 ,borron1#ba ( ,%rewsbury1 publi%$ "s rem>ks t5d+ to impea* ! fact t ,neptune1 ! planet f\nd by ,galle1#bb really 0 ! planet :i* ,le ,v]ri] & ,adams#bc _h a "r to claim4 ,?is 0 foll[$ 7,septemb] #ad7 by two pages1 sep>ately circulat$1 ( ,fur!r ,obs]vations ^u ! ,planets ,neptune & ,uranus1 ) a ,!ory ( ,p]turbations2 & 7,octob] #ai1 #ahdh7 by ?ree pages ( ,a ,review ( ,m4 ,lev]ri]'s ,exposition4 ,sev]al p]sons1 :5 ! rem>kable discov]y 0 made1 cont5d$ t ! planet actually discov]$ 0 an intrud]2 & ! future hi/ories ( ! discov]y mu/ conta9 "s acc\nt ( ?is little aft]piece4 ,tim ,l9k9wat]'s !ory t !re is no place l ,london = co9cid5ces1 w\ld h be5 utt]ly ov]?r[n 9 favor ( :at !y us$ to call ! cele/ial spaces1 if !re _h be5 a planet :i* by *ance 0 put #h ne> ! place assign$ to ,neptune at ! "t :5 ! discov]y 0 made4 ,,e>ly ,,ideas ,,( ,,aviation4 ,a]ial ,navigation2 conta9+ a description ( a propos$ fly+ ma*9e1 on a new pr9ciple4 ,by ,da$alus ,britannicus4 ,london1 #ahdg1 #hvo4 ,9 #ahdb-dc a ,mr4 ,h5son#bd _h propos$ :at he call$ an a]onaut /eam-eng9e1 & a ,bill 0 br\ght 9 to incorporate an ,a]ial ,transit ,company4 ,! pres5t plan is altoge!r diff]5t1 ! mov+ p[] be+ ! explosion ( mix$ hydrog5 & air4 ,no?+ came ( x--n ev5 a ,bill4 ,:at ! f9al de/9y ( ! balloon may be no "o kn[s3 x may reasonably be suspect$ t difficulties w at la/ be ov]come4 ,d>w91#be 9 8 ,botanic ,g>d5 7#agha71 has ! foll[+ prophecy3 ,soon %all ?y arm1 unconqu]$ ,/eam6 af> ,drag ! sl[ b>ge1 or drive ! rapid c>2 ,or1 on wide-wav+ w+s exp&$1 be> ,! fly+ *>iot ?r\gh ! fields ( air4 ,d>w9's contempor>ies1 no d\bt1 smil$ pity on ! poor man4 ,x is wor? note t ! two true prophecies h be5 fulfill$ 9 a s5se diff]5t f t ( ! pr$ictions4 ,d>w9 0 ?9k+ ( ! sugge/ion ( ,jona?an ,hulls1#bf :5 he spoke ( dragg+ ! sl[ b>ge3 x is only v rec5tly t ! /eam-tug has be5 employ$ on ! canals4 ,! c> 0 to be driv51 n drawn1 & on ! common roads4 ,p]haps1 ! fly+ *>iot w #i be some?+ ( a "* :i* we _c imag9e1 ev5 ) ! two prophecies & _! fulfilm5ts to help u4#bg ,,! ,,secret ,,( ,,! ,,univ]se ,,divulg$4 ,a book = ! public4 ,new ,discov]y4 ,! causes ( ! circulation ( ! blood2 & ! true nature ( ! planet>y sy/em4 ,london1 #ahdh1 #hvo4 ,light is ! su/a9] ( motion bo? 9 ! e>? & 9 ! blood4 ,! natural /&>d1 ! pulse ( a p]son 9 heal?1 f\r beats to "o respiration1 gives ! natural second1 :i* is ! measure ( ! e>?'s progress 9 its daily revolution4 ,! ,greek fable ( ! ,titans is an elaborate exposition ( ! atomic !ory3 b any attempt to conv9ce le>n$ classics w\ld only meet _! d]ision2 s mu* does long-fo/]$ prejudice /& 9 ! way ( tru?4 ,! au?or compla9s bitt]ly t m5 ( sci5ce w n att5d to him & o!rs l him3 he obs]ves1 t 9 ! "t occupi$ 9 decl9+1 a man ( sci5ce might te/ ! m]its4 ,?is is1 alas6 too true2 s well d applicants ( ?is k9d "k h[ to /ick on4 ,b e rule has its exception3 ,i h he>d ( "o4 ,! late ,"l ,sp5c]#bh--! ,"l ,al?orp ( ! ,h\se ( ,commons--told me t a speculator once got access to him at ! ,home ,(fice1 & 0 proce$+ to unfold 8 way ( s]v+ ! public4 ,i d n und]/& ^! ?+s1 said ,"l ,al?orp1 b ,i happ5 to h ---- 7nam+ an em95t eng9e]7 up/airs2 suppose y talk to him on ! subject4 ,! discov]] w5t up1 & 9 half-an-h\r return$1 & said1 ,i am v mu* oblig$ to y\r ,lord%ip = introduc+ me to ,mr4 ----2 he has conv9c$ me #aj t ,i am q wrong4 ,i suppos$1 :5 ,i he>d ! /ory--b x w\ld n h be5 seemly to say x--t ,"l ,a4 exhal$ c&or & s5se1 :i* infect$ ^? :o came )9 rea*3 he w\ld h done s1 if anybody4 ,,! ,,trisection ,,& ,,quadrature ,,aga94 ,a me?od to trisect a s]ies ( angles hav+ relation to ea* o!r2 also ano!r to trisect any giv5 angle4 ,by ,james ,sabb54 #ahdh 7two qu>to pages74 ,! consequ5ce ( ye>s ( int5se ?\ght3 v likely1 & v sad4 #ahdh4 ,! foll[+ 0 s5t to me 9 manuscript4 ,i give ! :ole ( x3 ,quadrature ( ! ,circle4--,a quadrant is a curvil9e> angle trav]s+ r\nd & at an equal di/ance f a giv5 po9t1 call$ a c5t]1 no two po9ts 9 ! curve be+ at ! same angle1 b irreptiti\sly graduat+ f #ij to #fj4 ,x is !re=e a mean angle ( #ij & #fj1 :i* is #ge1 because x is m ?an #fj1 & less ?an #ij1 approximately f #fj to #ij1 & f #ij to #fj1 ) equal g5]ation 9 ea* irreptiti\s approximation1 !re=e meet+ 9 #ge1 & :i* is ! mean angle ( ! quadrant4 ,or suppose a l9e drawn f a giv5 po9t at #ij1 & f ! same po9t at #fj4 ,let ea* ( ^! l9es revolve on ?is po9t t[>d ea* o!r at an equal ratio4 ,!y w become "o l9e at #ge1 & bisect ! curve1 :i* is "o-six? ( ! entire circle4 ,! result1 tak+ #af z a diamet]1 gives an area ( #bja4jgbdjj1 & a circumf]5ce ( #ej4bfha4 ,! orig9al conception1 its natural h>mony1 & ! result1 to my own m9d is a demon/rative tru?1 :i* ,i presume x "r to make kn[n1 ?\gh p]haps at ! haz>d ( unpleasant if n unc\rte\s rem>ks4 ,i h add$ punctuation3 ! h&writ+ & spell+ #aa are ^? ( an educat$ p]son2 ! ^w irreptiti\s is indubitable4 ,! :ole is a natural curiosity4 ,! quadrature & exact area ( ! circle demon/rat$4 ,by ,wm4 ,pet]s4 #hvo4 n4 d4 7circa #ahdh74bi ,sugge/ions z to ! necessity = a revolution 9 philosophy2 & prospectus = ! e/abli%m5t ( a new qu>t]ly1 to be call$ ! ,physical ,philosoph] & ,het]odox ,review4 ,by ,q4 ,e4 ,d4 #hvo4 #ahdh4 ,^! works are by "o au?or1 :o also publi%$1 z appe>s by adv]tisem5t1 ,newton rescu$ f ! precipitancy ( 8 foll[]s ?r\gh a c5tury & a half1#cj & ,dang]s along a coa/ by correct+ 7z x is call$7 a %ip's reckon+ by be>+s ( ! l& at night fall1 or 9 a fog1 ne>ly out ( pr9t4 ,subscriptions are reque/$ = a new edition4 ,! area ( a circle is made f\r-fif?s ( ! circumscrib$ squ>e3 prov$ on an assumption :i* x is purpos$ to expla9 9 a long] essay4#ca ,! au?or1 z ,q4 ,e4 ,d41 0 9 controv]sy ) ! ,a!naeum j\rnal1 & criticis$ a correspond5t1 ,d41 :o wrote aga9/ a c]ta9 class ( discov]]s4 ,he believ$ ! common !ories ( hydro/atics to be wrong1 & "o ( 8 que/ions 03 ,h y ev] tak5 into acc\nt an5t gravity & gravitation ! fact t a five gra9 cube ( cork w ( itself half s9k 9 ! wat]1 :il/ x w take #bj gra9s ( brass1 :i* w s9k ( itself1 to pull "u ! o!r half8 ,fit ?is if y c1 fri5d ,d41 to y\r notions ( gravity & specific gravity1 z appli$ to ! con/ruction ( a univ]sal law ( gravitation4 ,?is ! ,a!naeum publi%$--b )\t "s ,italics1 = :i* ! editor 0 %>ply reprov$1 z a suffici5t #ab specim5 ( ! quod erat ,d4 mon/r&um3 on :i* ! au?or rem>ks--,d1--,:]e=e ! e c>et8 is x ,d apo/rophe8 ,d'1 ,d',m1 ,d',mo1 ,d',mon/r&um2 we _c f9d ! wit ( x4 ,?is ,i conjecture to conta9 an illusion to ! "n ( ! suppos$ au?or2 b :e!r ,de ,mocritus1 ,de ,mo/h5es1 or ,de ,moivre 0 int5d$1 ,i am n will+ to decide4 ,! ,scriptural ,cal5d> & ,*ronological ,re=m]1 = ! /atute ye> #ahdi4 ,includ+ a review ( rec5t publications on ! ,sabba? "q4 ,london1 #ahdi1 #abmo4#cb ,?is is ! almanac ( a sect ( ,*ri/ians :o keep ! ,jewi% ,sabba?1 hav+ a *apel at ,mill ,y>d1 ,goodman's ,fields4 ,!y wrote controv]sial works1 & p]haps d s /ill2 b ,i nev] *anc$ to see "o4 ,geometry v]sus ,algebra2 or ! trisection ( an angle geometrically solv$4 ,by ,w4 ,upton1 ,b4,a4#cc ,ba? 7circa #ahdi74 #hvo4 ,! au?or publi%$ two tracts "u ?is title1 conta9+ diff]5t alleg$ pro(s3 b nei!r gives any notice ( ! *ange4 ,bo? conta9 ! same preface1 compla9+ ( ! ,briti% ,association = refus+ to exam9e ! production4 ,i suppose t ! au?or1 f9d+ 8 fir/ pro( wrong1 inv5t$ ! second1 ( :i* ! ,association nev] _h ! (f]2 &1 feel+ sure t !y w\ld h equally refus$ to exam9e ! second1 ?\ght x ju/ifiable to #ac pres5t t second z ! "o :i* !y _h refus$4 ,mr4 ,upton has discov]$ t ! common way ( f9d+ ! circumf]5ce is wrong1 w\ld set x "r if he _h leisure1 &1 9 ! mean "t1 has solv$ ! problem ( ! duplication ( ! cube4 ,! trisector ( an angle1 if he dem& att5tion f any ma!matician1 is b\nd to produce1 f 8 con/ruction1 an expression = ! s9e or cos9e ( ! ?ird "p ( any angle1 9 t]ms ( ! s9e or cos9e ( ! angle itself1 obta9$ by help ( no high] ?an ! squ>e root4 ,! ma!matician kn[s t su* a ?+ _c be2 b ! trisector virtually says x c be1 & is b\nd to produce x1 to save "t4 ,?is is ! mis=tune ( mo/ ( ! solv]s ( ! celebrat$ problems1 t !y h n k en\gh to pres5t ^? consequ5ces ( _! results by :i* !y c be easily judg$4 ,sometimes !y h ! k & quibble out ( ! use ( x4 ,9 _m cases a p]son makes an hone/ beg9n+ & pres5ts :at he is sure is a solution4 ,by conf]5ce ) o!rs he at la/ feels uneasy1 fe>s ! light1 & puts self-love 9 ! way ( x4 ,di%one/y sometimes foll[s4 ,! speculators are1 z a class1 v apt to imag9e t ! ma!maticians are 9 fraudul5t conf$]acy aga9/ !m3 ,i ought r to say t ea* "o ( !m cons5ts to ! mode 9 :i* ! re/ are treat$1 & fancies conspiracy aga9/ himself4 ,! mania ( conspiracy is a v curi\s subject4 ,i d n mean ^! rem>ks to apply to ! au?or be=e me4 ,"o ( ,mr4 ,upton's trisections1 if true1 w\ld prove ! tru? ( ! foll[+ equation3 #c cos 7!ta _/ #c7 #a root7#d - s9#b!ta7 :i* is c]ta9ly false4#cd #ad ,9 #aheb ,i exam9$ a t]rific con/ruction1 at ! reque/ ( ! late ,dr4 ,walli*1#ce :o 0 anxi\s to p]suade a poor c\ntryman ( 81 t trisection ( ! angle 0 wa/e ( "t4 ,"o ( ! pr9ciples 01 t magnitude & direction det]m9e ea* o!r4 ,! con/ruction 0 equival5t to ! ass]tion t1 !ta be+ any angle1 ! cos9e ( its ?ird "p is s9 #c!ta 4 cos7#e!ta_/#b7 s9#b !ta s9 7#e!ta_/#b7 divid$ by ! squ>e root ( s9#b #c!ta 4 cos#b 7#e!ta_/#b7 s9#d !ta s9 #c!ta 4 s9 #e!ta 4 s9#b !ta4 ,?is is f my r\gh notes1 & ,i believe x is correct4#cf ,x is s ne>ly true1 unless ! angle be v obtuse1 t common draw+1 appli$ to ! con/ruction1 w n detect ! error4 ,!re are _m =mulae ( ?is k9d3 & ,i h sev]al times f\nd a speculator :o has discov]$ ! correspond+ con/ruction1 has se5 ! approximate success ( 8 draw+--(t5 z great z absolute tru? c\ld give 9 graphical practice1--& has !n set ab\t 8 demon/ration1 9 :i* he always succe$s to 8 own cont5t4 ,!re is a trisection ( :i* ,i h lo/ bo? cutt+ & ref]5ce3 ,i ?9k x is 9 ! ,unit$ ,s]vice ,j\rnal4 ,i c\ld n detect any error 9 x1 ?\gh c]ta9 !re mu/ #ae be "o4 ,at lea/ ,i discov]$ t two p>ts ( ! diagram 7 incompatible unless a c]ta9 po9t lay 9 l9e ) two o!rs1 by :i* ! angle to be trisect$--& :i* 0 trisect$--0 b\nd to be ei!r #j deg4 or #ahj deg44 ,aug4 #bb1 #ahff4 ,mr4 ,upton /icks to 8 subject4 ,he has j publi%$ ,! ,uptonian ,trisection4 ,respectfully d$icat$ to ! s*oolma/]s ( ! ,unit$ ,k+dom4 ,x seems to be a new attempt4 ,he takes no notice ( ! s5t5ce ,i h put 9 italics3 nor does he m5tion my notice ( him1 unless he means to include me among ^? by :om he has be5 ridicul$ & sne]$ at or br&$ z a bra9less h]etic4 ,i did nei!r "o nor ! o!r3 ,i ?\ght ,mr4 ,upton a p>adox] to :om x 0 likely to be wor? :ile to prop\nd ! def9ite ass]tion n[ 9 italics2 & ,mr4 ,upton does n f9d x conv5i5t to take issue on ! po9t4 ,he pref]s g5]al ass]tions ab\t algebra4 ,s long z he _c meet algebra on ! above "q1 he may issue z _m respectful *all5ges to ! ma!maticians z he c f9d pap] to write3 he w meet ) no att5tion4 ,!re is "o trisection :i* is ( m importance ?an t ( ! angle4 ,x is easy to get half ! pap] on :i* y write = m>g92 or a qu>t]2 b v tr\blesome to get a ?ird4 ,%[ u h[1 easily & c]ta9ly1 to fold ! pap] into ?ree1 & y w be a real b5efactor to society4 ,e>ly 9 ! c5tury !re 0 a ,turki% trisector ( ! angle1 ,husse9 ,eff5di1 :o publi%$ two me?ods4 ,he 0 ! fa!r ( ,ame5 ,bey1 :o 0 well kn[n 9 ,engl& ?irty ye>s ago z a mo/ amiable & cultivat$ g5tleman & an excell5t ma!matician4 ,he 0 !n a /ud5t at ,cambridge2 & he di$1 ye>s ago1 9 comm& ( ! army 9 ,syria4 ,husse9 ,eff5di 0 in/ruct$ 9 ma!matics by ,+liz ,selim ,eff5di1 :o translat$ a "w #af ( ,bonnyca/le#cg into ,turki%4#ch ,?is ,engli%man 0 ,ri*>d ,baily1 bro!r ( ,francis ,baily#ci ! a/ronom]1 :o emigrat$ to ,turkey 9 8 y\?1 & adopt$ ! mann]s ( ! ,turks1 b :e!r _! religion also ,i nev] he>d1 ?\gh ,i %\ld suppose he did4 ,i n[ give ! lett]s f ! agricultural labor] & 8 fri5d1 describ$ on page #ab1 ,vol4 ,i4 ,!y are curiosities2 & ! hi/ory ( ! quadrature c nev] be well writt5 )\t "s specim5s ( ?is k9d3 ,doctor ,morgan1 ,sir4 ,p]mit me to address y ,brute ,creation may p]haps enjoy ! faculty ( behold+ visible ?+s ) a m p5itrat+ eye ?an ourselves4 ,b ,spiritual objects are z f> out ( _! rea* z ?\gh !y _h no be+ ,ne>e/ !re=e to ! brute ,creation are ^? m5 :o ,suppose !mselves to be s f> gov]n$ by ext]nal objects z to believe no?+ b :at !y ,see & feel ,& ,c accom$ate to _! ,%all[ und]/&+ & ,imag9ations ,my ,de> ,sir ,let u all ,consult ourselves by ! wise prov]b4 ,i believe t evry mans m]it ability aught to be appreciat$ & valu$ ,9 proportion to its wor? utility ,9 :atev] ,/ate or ,circum/ances !y may =tunately or un=tunately be plac$ ,& happy x is = evry man to "k 8 wor? & place ,:5 a ,g5tleman ( y\r ,/&+ 9 ,society ,clad ) ^? honors ,c n und]/& or ,solve a problem ,t is explicitly expla9$ by words & ,lett]s & #ag ma!matically op]at$ by figu]s ,he _h be/ consult ! wise prov]d ,d t :i* ?\ ,can/ und]/& & ,compreh5d = ?y good4 ,i w\ld recomm5d t ,su* ,g5tleman ,*ange 8 bus9ess ,& appropriate 8 "t & att5tion to a ,sunday ,s*ool to ,le>n :at he ,c\ld & keep ! ,litle ,*ildr5 =m durt+ _! ,close ,) ,s9c]e feel+s ( ,gratitude = y\r weakness & ,inability ,i am ,sir y\r ,sup]ior 9 ,ma!matics ---- #ahdi ,june ?#bi4 ,dor ,morg9 ,sir ,i wrote & ,s5t my "w to ,pr(essor ---- ( ---- ,/ate ( ---- ,unit$ ,/ates ,i am n[ 9 ! possession ( ! facts t he highly approves ( my "w4 ,& ,says he w ,insure me ,rew>d 9 ! ,/ates ,i write ?is t y may und]/& t ,i h k ( ! unfair way t ,i am treat$ ,9 my own nati ,c\nty ,i am told & h reasons to believe t x is ! ,cl]gy t treat me s unju/4 ,i am n ,desir\s ( heap+ ,disonors ^u my own nation4 ,b if ,i h to ,leave ?is k+dom )\t my ,j dues4 ,! _w ,%all "k h[ ,i am & h be5 treat$4 ,i am ,sir ,desir\s ( my ,j dues ---- #ahdi ,july #c4 ,july #g?1 #ahdi4 ,sir1 ,i h be5 giv5 to und]/& t a fri5d ( m9e "o :om ,i %all nev] be a%am$ to ackn[l$ge z #ah su* ?o' l[ly 8 orig9e2 nay n only n a%am$ b pr\d ( do+ s = ,i am "o ( ^? :o e/eem & respect a man accord+ to 8 ability & probity1 deem+ ) ,dr4 ,watts 't ! m9d is ! /&>d ( ! man1'#dj has laid be=e y & ask$ y\r op9ion ( 8 extraord9>y p]=mance1 viz4 ! quadrature ( ! circle1 he did ?is ) ! firme/ belief t y w\ld n only treat ! matt] 9 a /raight=w>d mann] b ) ! conviction t f y\r kn[n or suppos$ k ( ma!maticks w\ld h giv5 an upright & honorable decision ^u ! subject2 b ! "q is h y done s8 ,c\ld ,i say yes ,i w\ld ) ! greate/ ( pleasure & h congratulat$ y ^u y\r decision :atev] x might h be5 b ,i am sorry to say t ,i _c y\r lett] is a paltry evasion1 y say 't x is a great pity t y 7,mr4 ----7 %\ld h attempt$ ?is 7! quadrature ( ! circle7 = y\r ma!matical k is n suffici5t to make y "k 9 :at ! problem consi/s1' y don't say 9 :at x does consi/ accord+ to y\r ideas1 oh6 no no?+ ( ! sort1 y ent] into no disquisition ^u ! subject 9 ord] to %[ :]e y ?9k ,mr4 ---- is wrong & :y y h n is simply--because y _c--y "k t he has done x & :at is if ,i am n wrongly in=m$ y h be5 he>d to say s4 ,he has done :at y nor any o!r ma!matician z ^? :o call !mselves su* h done4 ,& :at is ! reason t y w n c&idly ackn[l$ge to him z y h to o!rs t he has squ>$ ! circle %all ,i tell y8 x is because he has p]=m$ ! feat to obta9 ! glory ( :i* ma!maticians h battl$ f "t immemorial t !y might encircle _! br[s ) a wrea? ( laurels f> m glori\s ?an ev] conqu]or won x is simply ?is t x is a poor man a #ai humble artisan :o has ga9$ t victory t y don't l to ackn[l$ge x y don't l to be beat5 & worse to ackn[l$ge t y h miscalculat$1 y h 9 %ort too small a s\l to ackn[l$ge t he is "r4 ,i 0 ask$ my op9ion & ,i gave x unhesitat+ly 9 ! affirmative & ,i am back$ 9 my op9ion n only by ,mr4 ---- a ma!matician & wat*mak] resid+ 9 ! boro ( ,s\?w>k b by no less an au?ority ?an ! ,pr(essor ( ma!matics ( ---- ,college ---- ---- ,unit$ ,/ates ,mr4 ---- & ,i presume t he at lea/ is y\r equal z an au?ority & ,mr4 ---- says t ! gov]nm5t ( ! ,u4,s4 w recomp5se ,m4 ,d4 = ! discov]y he has made if s :at a reflection ^u ,old engl& ! boa/$ l& ( fre$om ! nurs]y ( arts & sci5ces t h] sons are oblig$ to g to a =eign c\ntry to obta9 t recomp5se to :i* !y are ju/ly entitl$ ,9 conclusion ,i _h to contradict an ass]tion y made to ! effect t '!re is n nor ev] 0 any rew>d (f]$ by ! gov]nm5t ( ?is c\ntry = ! discov]y ( ! quadrature ( ! circle4' ,i beg to in=m y t !re 0 b t x hav+ be5 deem$ an impossibility ! gov]nm5t has )drawn x4 ,i d ?is ^u no less an au?ority ?an ! ,m>quis ( ,nor?ampton4#da ,i am1 sir1 y\rs ---- ,dr4 ,morgan4 ,,! ,,moon',s ,,rotation4 ,notes on ! ,k9ematic ,effects ( ,revolution & ,rotation1 ) ref]5ce to ! ,motions ( ! ,moon & ( ! e>?4 ,by ,h5ry ,p]igal1 ,jun4 ,esq4 ,london1 #ahdf-ahdi1 #hvo4 ,on ! misuse ( te*nical t]ms4 ,ambiguity ( ! t]ms ,rotation & ,revolution1 ow+ to ! d\ble mean+ improp]ly #bj attribut$ to ea* ( ! words4 7,no date nor place1 b by ,mr4 ,p]igal1#db ,i h no d\bt1 & conta9+ lett]s ( #ahdi & #ahej47 ,! moon controv]sy4 ,facts v4 ,def9itions4 ,by ,h4 ,p41 ,jun4 ,london1 #ahef1 #hvo4 7pp4 #d47 ,mr4 ,h5ry ,p]igal help$ me tw5ty ye>s ago ) ! diagrams1 direct f ! la! to ! wood1 = ! article ,tro*oidal ,curves1 9 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia3 ^! cuts add v greatly to ! value ( ! article1 :i*1 inde$1 c\ld n h be5 made intelligible )\t !m4 ,he has _h _m ye>s' exp]i5ce1 z an amateur turn]1 9 comb9ation ( d\ble & triple circul> motions1 & has publi%$ valuable diagrams 9 pr(usion4 ,a p]son to :om ! d\ble circul> motion is famili> 9 ! la! naturally looks ^u "o circle mov+ ^u ano!r z 9 simple motion1 if ! second circle be fix$ to ! revolv+ radius1 s t "o & ! same po9t ( ! mov+ circle travels ^u ! fix$ circle4 ,mr4 ,p]igal comm5c$ 8 attack ^u ! moon = mov+ ab\t h] axis1 9 ! fir/ ( ! tracts above1 t5 ye>s be=e ,mr4 ,jell+] ,symons2#dc b he did n ?9k x necess>y to make x a subject = ! ,times newspap]4 ,8 famili>ity ) comb9$ motions enabl$ him to h&le 8 argum5ts mu* bett] ?an ,mr4 ,j4 ,symons c\ld d3 9 fact1 he is ! cle>e/ assailant ( ! lot :i* turn$ out ) ,mr4 ,j4 ,symons4 ,b he is z wrong z ! re/4 ,! assault is n[1 ,i suppose1 ab&on$1 until x becomes epidemic aga94 ,?is x w d3 x is "o ( ^? fallacies :i* are v tempt+4 ,!re 0 a dispute on ! subject 9 #agdh1 betwe5 ,james ,f]guson#dd & an anonym\s oppon5t2 & ,i ?9k !re h be5 o!rs4 #ba ,a poet appe>s 9 ! field 7,july #ai1 #ahfc7 :o calls himself ,cyclops1 & writes f\r octavo pages4 ,he makes a di/9ction betwe5 rotation & revolution2 & 8 doctr9es & phrases are s l ^? ( ,mr4 ,p]igal t he is a foll[] at lea/4 ,"o ( 8 argum5ts has s (t5 be5 us$ t x is wor? :ile to cite x3 ,w\ld ,ma!maticals--=soo?-- ,if true1 h fail$ to prove its tru?8 ,w\ld n !y--if !y c\ld--submit ,"s ov]:elm+ pro(s ( x8 ,b /ill x tott]s pro(less6 ,h5ce ,!re's /rong presumptive evid5ce ,none d--or c--su* pro( pr(\nd ,because ! dogma is uns\nd4 ,=1 7 !re means ( do+ s1 ,!y w\ld h prov$ x long ago4 ,?is is only "o ( ! alt]natives4 ,pro( requires a p]son :o c give & a p]son :o c receive4 ,i feel inspir$ to add ! foll[+3 ,a bl9d man said1 ,z to ! ,sun1 ,i'll take my ,bible oa? !re's none2 ,= if !re _h be5 "o to %[ ,!y w\ld h %[n x long ago4 ,h[ came he su* a goose to be8 ,did he n "k he c\ldn't see8 ,n he6 ,! absurdity ( ! v]ses is 9 ! argum5t4 ,! writ] 0 n s ignorant or s di%one/ z to affirm t no?+ _h be5 (f]$ by ! o!r side z pro(2 accord+ly1 8 syllogism am\nts to ?is3 ,if y\r proposition 7 true1 y c\ld h giv5 pro( satisfactory to me2 b ?is y h n done1 !re=e1 y\r proposition is n true4 ,! e*oes ( ! moon-controv]sy rea*$ ,b5>es 9 #aheg1 9 :i* ye> 0 !re publi%$ a pamphlet ,does ! ,moon ,rotate8 9 ,sanskrit & ,engli%4 ,! #bb argum5ts are mu* ! same z ^? ( ! discussion at home4 ,,on ,,! ,,names ,,( ,,religi\s ,,bodies4 ,we see t !re are p>adox]s 9 argum5t z well z 9 ass]tion ( fact3 my plan does n br+ me mu* into contact ) ^!2 b ano!r in/ance may be useful4 ,sects1 :e!r religi\s or political1 give !mselves names :i*1 9 mean+1 are claim$ also by _! oppon5ts2 loyal1 lib]al1 cons]vative 7( good71 etc4 h be5 sev]ally appropriat$ by p>ties4 ,:ig & ,tory are unobjectionable names3 ! fir/--:i* occurs 9 ,engli% ballad z well z 9 ,scotl&--is s\r milk2#de ! second is a robb]4 ,9 !ology1 ! ,greek ,*ur* is ,or?odox1 ! ,roman is ,ca?olic1 ! mod]n ,puritan is ,evangelical1 etc4 ,! ^w ,*ri/ian 7,vol4 ,i1 p4 #bdhdf7 is an in/ance4 ,:5 words beg91 !y c>ry _! mean+s4 ,! ,jews1 :o _h _! ,messiah to come1 & ! foll[]s ( ,jesus ( ,naz>e?1 :o took ,him = _! ,messiah1 7 bo? ,*ri/ians 7:i* means ,messianites73 ! ,jews w\ld nev] h inv5t$ ! t]m to signify ,jesuans1 nor w\ld ! disciples h inv5t$ su* an ambigu\s t]m = !mselves2 _h !y done s1 ! ,jews w\ld h disput$ x1 z !y w\ld h done 9 lat] times if !y _h _h fair play4 ,! ,jews ( our day1 ,i see by _! newspap]s1 speak ( ,jesus ,*ri/ z ! ,rabbi ,jo%ua4 ,b ! #bc hea!ns1 :o knew little or no?+ ab\t ! ,jewi% hope1 w\ld naturally apply ! t]m ,*ri/ians to ! only foll[]s ( a ,messiah ( :om !y _h he>d4 ,= ! ,jesuans invad$ !m 9 a mission>y way2 :ile ! ,jews did n attempt1 at lea/ op5ly1 to make proselytes4 ,all su* words z ,ca?olic1 etc41 are well en\gh z m]e nom5clature2 & ! _w falls = ! mo/ "p1 into any names :i* p>ties *oose to give !mselves4 ,silly p f\nd inf]5ces on ?is concession2 &1 z usually happ5s1 !y c cite "s ( _! bett]s4 ,/4 ,augu/9e1#dg a freaki% argu]1 or1 to put x 9 ! way ( an old writ]1 lectorem ne multiloquii ta$io fa/idiat1 ,punicis quibusdam argutiis recre>e solet1#dh asks1 ) triumph1 to :at *apel a /rang] w\ld be direct$1 if he inquir$ ! way to ! ,ca?olic assembly4 ,b ! be/ exhibition ( ?is k9d 9 our own c5tury is t made by ! excell5t ,dr4 ,john ,miln]1#di 9 a "w 7fir/ publi%$ 9 #ahja or #ahjb7 :i* ,i suppose /ill circulates1 ,! ,end ( ,religi\s ,controv]sy3 a />tl+ title :i*1 s f> z its tru? is conc]n$1 might z well h be5 ,! floor ( ! bottomless pit4 ,?is writ]1 :om e "o ( 8 read]s w swe> to h be5 a wor?y s\l1 ?\gh _m1 ev5 ( 8 own sect1 w n admire "s ( 8 logic1 speaks z foll[s3 ,lett] xxv4 ,on ! true ,*ur* be+ ,ca?olic4 ,9 treat+ ( ?is ?ird m>k ( ! true ,*ur*1 z express$ 9 our common cre$1 ,i feel my spirits s9k )9 me1 & ,i am almo/ tempt$ to ?r[ away my p5 9 despair4 ,= :at *ance is !re ( op5+ ! eyes ( c&id ,prote/ants to ! o!r m>ks ( ! ,*ur*1 if !y are capable ( keep+ !m %ut to ?is8 ,e "t !y address ! #bd ,god ( ,tru?1 ei!r 9 solemn wor%ip or 9 private devotion /ret* ( rhetoric1 !y are =c$1 ea* ( !m1 to repeat3 ,i believe 9 ,,! ,,ca?olic ,*ur*1 & yet if ,i ask any ( !m ! "q3 ,are y a ,,ca?olic8 he is sure to answ] me1 ,no1 ,i am a ,,prote/ant6 ,0 !re ev] a m gl>+ in/ance ( inconsi/5cy & self-condemnation among rational be+s6 ,john ,miln]1 hone/ & true1 ,did :at hone/ p /ill may d1 ,if !y write = ! _m & n = ! few1 ,b :at by & bye !y mu/ es*ew4 ,he %ort5$ 8 clause2 & = a reason4 ,if he _h us$ ! :ole epi!t :i* he knew s well1 any "o might h giv5 8 argum5t a half-turn4 ,_h he writt51 z he ought1 ! ,holy ,ca?olic ,*ur* & !n argu$ z above1 "s sly ,prote/ant w\ld h p>odi$ him ) & yet if ,i ask any ( !m ! "q3 ,are y ,,holy8 he is sure to answ] me ,no1 ,i am a ,,s9n]4 ,to take ! adjective f ! ,*ur*1 & apply x to ! individual p>tisan1 is recogniz$ slipslop1 b n gr\nd ( argum5t4 ,if ,dr4 ,m4 _h ask$ 8 ,prote/ant :e!r he belong$ to ! ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 ! answ] w\ld h be5 ,yes1 b n to ! ,roman bran*4 ,:5 he put 8 "q z he did1 he 0 rightly answ]$ & 9 8 own division4 ,?is leav+ out words is a common practice1 especially :5 ! omitt] is 9 au?ority1 & _c be expos$4 ,a ye> or two ago a bi%op wrote a snubb+ lett] to a poor p>son1 :o _h compla9$ t he 0 oblig$1 9 burial1 to s5d ! wor/ ( s9n]s to ev]la/+ happ9ess4 ,! bi%op /]nly said1 hope#ej is n assurance4 #be ,c\ld ! cl]gyman h d>$ to answ]1 he w\ld h said1 ,no1 my ,"l6 b 'sure & c]ta9 hope' is z l assurance z a m9ik9 man is l a dw>f4 ,sad to say1 a !ologian mu/ be illogical3 ,i feel sure t if y took ! cle>e/ head$ writ] on logic t ev] liv$1 & made a bi%op ( him1 he w\ld be %am$ by 8 own books 9 a twelvemon?4 ,miln]'s sophism is gl>+3 b :y %\ld ,dr4 ,miln] be wis] ?an ,/4 ,augu/9e1 "o ( 8 tea*]s8 ,i am tempt$ to let out ! true d]ivation ( ! ^w ,ca?olic1 z exclusively appli$ to ! ,*ur* ( ,rome4 ,all c f9d x :o h access to ! ,rituale ( ,bonav5tura ,piscator#ea 7lib4 i4 c4 #ab1 de nom9e ,sacrae ,ecclesiae1 p4 #hg ( ! ,v5ice #bf folio ( #aecg74 ,i am told t !re is a ,rituale 9 ! ,index ,expurgatorius1 b ,i h n ?\ght x wor? :ile to exam9e :e!r ?is be ! "o3 ,i am r incl9$ to ?9k1 z ,i h he>d else:]e1 t ! book 0 held too dang]\s = ! fai?ful to "k ( x1 ev5 by a prohibition3 x w\ld n surprise me at all if ,roman ,*ri/ians %\ld d5y its exi/5ce4#eb ,x amuses me to give1 at a great di/ance ( "t1 a small ,r[l& = a small ,oliv]1#ec :i* ,i receiv$1 de p> l',eglise1#ed s f> z lay 9 ! ,oliv]-c>ri] m ?an tw5ty ye>s ago4 ,! foll[+ contribution ( m9e to ,notes & ,qu]ies 7#c;d ,s]4 vi4 p4 #age1 ,aug4 #bg1 #ahfd7 w expla9 :at ,i say4 ,!re _h be5 a compla9t t a contributor _h us$ ! t]m ,papi/1 :i* a v excell5t dignit>y ( ! ,papal sy/em pron\nc$ an (f5sive t]m3 ,,papi/4 ,! t]m papi/ %\ld be /ripp$ ( all except its etymological mean+1 & appli$ to ^? :o give ! high] & f9al au?ority to ! decl>ation ex ca!dra#ee ( ! ,pope4 ,see ,dr4 ,wiseman's#ef article1 ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 9 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia4 ,:at is "o to d ab\t ^! names8 ,fir/1 x is cle> t (f5ce %\ld1 :5 possible1 be avoid$3 secondly1 no "o mu/ be requir$ to give a "n :i* favors any assumption made by ^? to :om x is giv51 & n #bg grant$ by ^? :o give x4 ,?us ! subdivision :i* calls itself di/9ctly ,evangelical has no "r to expect o!rs to conc$e ! title4 ,n[ ! ^w ,ca?olic1 ( c\rse1 falls "u ?is rule2 & ev5 ,roman ,ca?olic may be refus$ to ^? :o w\ld re/rict ! ^w ,ca?olic to !mselves4 ,roman ,*ri/ian is unobjectionable1 s9ce ! ,roman ,*ur* does n d5y ! "n ( ,*ri/ian to ^? :om %e calls h]etics4 ,no "o is b\nd 9 ?is matt] by ,acts ( ,p>liam5t4 ,9 _m cases1 no d\bt1 names :i* h (f5sive association are us$ m]ely by habit1 sometimes by h]$it>y transmission4 ,boswell records ( ,johnson t he always us$ ! words diss5t+ tea*]1 refus+ m9i/] & cl]gyman to all b ! recipi5ts ( episcopal ord9ation4 ,?is di/9ctive phrase has be5 widely adopt$3 x occurs 9 ! ,index ( #c;d ,s4 iv4 ,notes & ,qu]ies4 ,"h we f9d ,platts 7,rev4 ,john71 ,unit>ian tea*]1 #dab2 ! article index$ has ,unit>ian m9i/]4 ,?is1 ( c\rse is habit3 an int5tional refusal ( ! ^w m9i/] w\ld nev] occur 9 an index4 ,i rememb] t1 :5 ,i fir/ read ab\t ,sam ,johnson's little bit ( exclusiv5ess1 ,i said to myself3 ,tea*]8 ,tea*]8 surely ,i rememb] ,"o :o is (t5 call$ tea*]1 b nev] m9i/] or cl]gyman3 h n ! diss5t]s got ! be/ ( x8 ,:5 ,i said t ! ,roman ,*ur* conc$es ! epi!t ,*ri/ians to ,prote/ants1 ,i did n mean t all its adh]5ts d ! same4 ,!re is1 or 01 a ,roman newspap]1 ! ,tablet1 :i*1 sev5 or eight ye>s ago1 0 "o ( ! mo/ virul5t ( ! p>ty j\rnals4 ,9 x ,i read1 ref]r+ to "s compla9t ( grievance ab\t mix$ m>riages1 t if ,*ri/ians w\ld m>ry ,prote/ants !y mu/ take ! consequ5ces4 ,my memory notes ?is well2 because ,i recollect$1 :5 ,i saw x1 t !re 0 9 ! /able a horse fit to run 9 ! curricle ) ?is "o4 ,ab\t sev5te5 ye>s ago an ,ox=d ,m4 ,a41 :o hat$ #bh ma!matics l a g5u9e ,oxonian ( ! la/ c5tury1 0 writ+ on education1 & 0 compell$ to give "s c\nt5ance to ! na/y subject4 ,he got out clev]ly2 = he gave z 8 reason = ! p]mission1 t man is an ari?metical1 geometrical1 & me*anical animal1 z well z a rational s\l4 ,! ,tablet 0 f\nd$ by an old pupil ( m9e1 ,mr4 ,fr$]ic ,lucas1#eg :o avail$ himself ( 8 k ( me to write "s sev]e articles--ev5 abusive1 ,i 0 told1 b ,i nev] saw !m--aga9/ me1 = contribut+ to ! ,dubl9 ,review1 & pok+ my h]etic nose into or?odox places4 ,dr4 ,wiseman1 ! editor1 came 9 = 8 %>e1 & ought to h got all4 ,:o ev] blam$ ! pig = intrud+ himself into ! cab9 :5 ! door 0 left op58 ,:5 ,mr4 ,lucas 0 my pupil1 he 0 ( ! ,society ( ,fri5ds--9 any article b ?is ,i %\ld say ,quak]--& 0 quiet & g5tlemanly1 z memb]s ( t ,*ur*--9 any article b ?is ,i %\ld1 f m]e habit1 say sect--usually are4 ,?is is due to 8 memory2 =1 by all ,i he>d1 :5 he *ang$ 8 religion he ceas$ to be ,lucas c\*ant1 & became ,lucas rampant1 fang$ & langu$ gules4 7,i look$ into ,guillim#eh to see if my t]ms 7 "r3 ,i c\ld n f9d !m2 b to prove ,i h be5 !re1 ,i notice t he calls a viol9 a viol5t4 ,h[ comes ! ^w to take ?is =m87 ,i met ) sev]al ,roman ,*ri/ians1 born & br$1 :o 7 v mu* annoy$ at ,mr4 ,lucas & 8 do+s2 & said "s sev]e ?+s ab\t new conv]ts ne$+ kick+-/raps4 #bi ,! m5tion ( ,dr4 ,wiseman rem9ds me ( ano!r ^w1 appropriat$ by ,*ri/ians to !mselves3 fides2#ei ! ,roman fai? is fides1 & no?+ else2 & ! adh]5ts are fideles4#fj ,h]eby hangs a retort4 ,:5 ,dr4 ,wiseman 0 fir/ 9 ,engl&1 he gave a c\rse ( lectures 9 def5ce ( 8 cre$1 :i* 7 ?\ght v conv9c+ by ^? :o 7 already conv9c$4 ,!y det]m9$ to give him a m$al1 & !re 0 a v s]i\s discussion ab\t ! leg5d4 ,dr4 ,wiseman told me himself t he _h answ]$ to 8 subscrib]s t he w\ld n h ! m$al at all unless--7nam+ "s ,italian au?ority1 :om ,i =get7 approv$ ( ! leg5d4 ,at la/ pro fide v9dicata#fa 0 *os53 ?is may be read ei!r 9 a ,popi% or h]etical s5se4 ,! fem99e sub/antive fides means confid5ce1 tru/1 7x is made to mean belief71 b fidis1 ) ! same ablative1 fide1 & also fem99e1 is a fiddle-/r+4#fb ,if a ,lat9 writ] _h _h to make a leg5d signify+ ,= ! def5ce ( ! fiddle-/r+1 he c\ld n h done x o!rwise1 9 ! t]s5ess ( a leg5d1 ?an by writ+ pro fide v9dicata4 ,accord+ly1 :5 a ,roman ,*ri/ian talks to y ( ! fai?1 z a ?+ :i* is 8 & n y\rs1 y may say fiddle4 ,i h se>*$ ,bonav5tura ,piscator 9 va9 = notice ( ?is ambiguity4 ,b ! ,greeks said fiddle2 accord+ to ,suidas1#fc ,greek3 sk9dapsos#fd--;a ^w mean+ a f\r /r+$ in/rum5t play$ ) a quill--0 an exclamation ( contemptu\s diss5t4 ,h[ ! wits ( diff]5t races jump6 #cj ,i am rem9d$ ( a case ( fides v9dicata1 :i*1 be+ 9 a public lett]1 respond+ to a public invitation1 0 n meant to be confid5tial4 ,"s ( ! pupils ( ,univ]sity ,college1 9 :i* all subdivisions ( religion are 7#ahff2 71 #ahfg7 on a level1 h ( c\rse *ang$ _! views 9 aft] life1 & become adh]5ts ( v>i\s high *ur*es4 ,on ! occasion ( a d9n] ( old /ud5ts ( ! ,college1 conv5$ by circul>1 "o ( ^! /ud5ts1 :e!r !n ,roman or ,tract>ian ,*ri/ian ,i d n rememb]1 n cont5t ) simply giv+ negative answ]1 or none at all1 concoct$ a jorum ( !ological rebuke1 & s5t x to ! ,d9n] ,committee4 ,heyday6 said "o ( !m1 ?is man got out ( b$ backw>ds6 ,h[ is t8 said ! re/4 ,:y1 read 8 "n backw>ds1 & y w see4 ,z ?us read x 0--,no grub6#fe ,,! ,,^w ,,*ur*4 ,to return to ,notes & ,qu]ies4 ,! sub/itution 9 ! 7editorial7 index ( ,unit>ian tea*]1 = ! contributor's ,unit>ian m9i/]1 /ruck me v mu*4 ,i h seldom f\nd su* ?+s unmean+4 ,b z ! j\rnal _h always be5 free f editorial sect>ianisms1--& v apt to *eck ! contributorial1--,i c\ld n be sure 9 ?is case4 ,true x 01 t ! editor & publi%] _h be5 *ang$ m ?an a ye> be=e2 b ?is 0 n ( mu* =ce4 ,?\gh "o swall[ does n make a summ]1 ,i h g5]ally f\nd x %[ t summ] is com+4 ,h[ev]1 ?\ght ,i to myself1 if ?is be ,little ,%ibbole?1 we %all h ,big ,%ibbole? by-&-bye4 ,at la/ x came4 ,ab\t a twelvemon? aft]w>ds1 7#c;d ,s4 vii4 p4 #cf7 ! foll[+ 0 ! editorial answ] to ! "q :5 ! e/abli%m5t 0 fir/ call$ ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& & ,irel&3 #ca ,t unmean+ clause1 ',! ,unit$ ,*ur* ( ,engl& & ,irel&1' :i* occurs on ! title-page ( ,! ,book ( ,common ,pray]1 0 fir/ us$ at ! comm5cem5t ( ! pres5t c5tury4 ,! au?ority = ?is phrase is ! fif? article ( ! ,union ( #ahjj3 ',t ! ,*ur*es ( ,engl& & ,irel& be unit$ into "o ,prote/ant 767 episcopal ,*ur*1 to be call$ ,! ,unit$ ,*ur* ( ,engl& & ,irel&4' ,( c\rse1 *ur*m5 are n responsible = ! !ology ( ,acts ( ,p>liam5t1 especially ^? pass$ dur+ ! d>k ages ( ! ,georgian era4 ,t is to say1 ! j\rnal gives its adhesion to ! p>ty :i*--"u ! assum$ title ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&--claims = ! end[$ corporation = ! support ( religion rights :i* ,p>liam5t _c control1 & makes x1 9 fact1 a p[] above ! ,/ate4 ,! ,/ate has giv5 an in*3 x calls ?is corporation by ! "n ( ! ,unit$ ,*ur* ( ,engl& & ,irel&1 z if nei!r ,engl& nor ,irel& _h any o!r ,*ur*4 ,! corporation1 accord+ly aspires to an ell4 ,b ?is ! nation w only give ) ! aspiration prefix$4 ,to illu/rate my allusion 9 a delicate way to polite e>s1 ,i w relate :at happ5$ 9 a ,johnian lecture-room at ,cambridge1 "s fifty ye>s ago1 my in=mant be+ pres5t4 ,a y\? ( undue aspirations 0 giv+ a proposition1 & at la/ said1 ,let ,e ,f be produc$ to ',l'3 ,n q s f>1 ,mr4 ----1 said ! lectur]1 quietly1 to ! great amusem5t ( ! class1 & ! utt] a/oni%m5t ( ! aspirant1 :o knew no m ?an a ,tract>ian ! t5d5cy ( 8 con/ruction4 ,?is ^w ,*ur* is made to h a v my/ical mean+4 ,! foll[+ dialogue betwe5 ,ecclesia/es & ,ha]eticus1 :i* ,i _c v\* =1 has (t5 tak5 place 9 _s1 if n 9 lett]3 ,e4 ,! ^w ,*ur* 7,greek3 ekklesia7#ff is nev] us$ 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t except g5]ally or locally = t holy & my/ical body to :i* ! sacram5ts & ! ord9ances ( ,*ri/ianity are entru/$4 #cb ,h4 ,inde$6 ,e4 ,x is beyond a d\bt 7"h he quot$ half a doz5 texts 9 support74 ,h4 ,d y mean t any doctr9e or ord9ance :i* 0 solemnly practis$ by ! ,greek3 ekklesia is b9d+ ^u y & me8 ,e4 ,c]ta9ly1 unless we %\ld be cut (f f ! congregation ( ! fai?ful4 ,h4 ,h y a c\ple ( h\rs to sp>e8 ,e4 ,:at =8 ,h4 ,if y h1 ,i propose we sp5d !m 9 cry+1 ,great is ,diana ( ! ,ephesians6 ,e4 ,:at d y mean8 ,h4 ,y ought to "k ! solemn s]vice ( ! ,greek3 ekklesia 7,acts xix4 #cb1 #da71 at ,ephesus2 :i* any "o might take to be true ,*ur*1 by ! m "p n kn[+ :]e=e !y 7 come toge!r1 & :i* 0 dismiss$1 aft] "o ( ! mo/ s5sible s]mons ev] prea*$1 by ! ,record]4 ,e4 ,i see y\r mean+3 x is true1 !re is t "o exception6 ,h4 ,:y1 ! ,record]'s s]mon itself conta9s ano!r1 ! ,greek3 ennomos ekklesia1#fg legislative assembly4 ,e4 ,ah6 ! ,new ,te/am5t c only be int]pret$ by ! ,*ur*6 ,h4 ,i see6 ! ,*ur* int]prets itself into exi/5ce out ( ! ,new ,te/am5t1 & !n int]prets ! ,new ,te/am5t out ( exi/5ce into itself6 ,i look ^u all ! ,*ur*es z fair game :i* decl>e ( me t absque dubio 9 aet]num p]ibo2#fh n = _! presumption t[>ds ,god1 b = _! p]sonal insol5ce t[>ds myself4 ,i f9d t _! sect>ies />e :5 ,i say ?is4 ,:y6 !y d n speak ( y 9 p>ticul>6 ,^! poor reason]s seem to ?9k t !re c\ld be no mean+1 z aga9/ me1 unless x %\ld be prop\nd$ t )\t d\bt he %all p]i% ev]la/+ly1 especially ,a4 ,de ,morgan4 ,b ,i hold1 ) ! s*oolm51 t ,omnis homo e/ animal 9 conjunction ) ,sortes e/ homo am\nts to ,sortes e/ animal4#fi ,b !y d n mean x p]sonally6 ,e univ]sal proposition is #cc p]sonal to e in/ance ( ! subject4 ,if ?is be n conc$$1 !n ,i retort1 9 _! own s5se & mann]1 ,:osoev] w\ld s]ve ,god1 be=e all ?+s he mu/ n pron\nce ,god's decision ^u 8 neighbor4 ,:i* decision1 except e "o leave to ,god himself1 )\t d\bt he is a bigot$ noodle4 ,! reason+ habit ( ! educat$ community1 9 f\r cases out ( five1 p]mits univ]sal propositions to be /at$ at "o "t1 & d5i$1 pro re nata1#gj at ano!r4 ,be=e we proce$ to consid] any "q involv+ physical pr9ciples1 we %\ld set out ) cle> ideas ( ! naturally possible & impossible4 ,! em95t man :o said ?is1 :5 want+ x = 8 views ( m5tal education 767 nev] meant x = m ?an :at 0 9 h&1 nev] assum$ x 9 ! rese>*es :i* w give him to po/]ity6 ,i h he>d half-a-doz5 def5ces ( 8 hav+ said ?is1 n "o ( :i* affirm$ ! tru? ( :at 0 said4 ,a wor?y cl]gyman wrote t if ,a4 ,b4 _h said a c]ta9 ?+ ! po9t 9 "q w\ld h be5 e/abli%$4 ,x 0 %[n to him t ,a4 ,b4 _h said x1 to :i* ! reply 0 a refusal to admit ! po9t because ,a4 ,b4 said x 9 a second pamphlet & 9 answ] to objections4 ,& ,i might give fifty su* in/ances ) v little se>*4 ,always assume m ?an y want2 because y _c tell h[ mu* y may want3 put :at is ov] into ! didn't-mean-t basket1 or ! extreme case :at-n4 ,,prote/ant ,,& ,,papal ,,*ri/5dom4 ,some?+ ne> =ty ye>s ( exam9ation ( ! !ologies on & (f--m ye>s v mu* on ?an q (f--h giv5 me a good title--to myself1 ,i ask no "o else = leave--to make ! foll[+ rem>ks3 ,a conclusion has premises1 facts or doctr9es f pro( or au?ority1 & mode ( inf]5ce4 ,!re may be inv5tion or #cd falsehood ( premise1 ) good logic2 & !re may be t5able premise1 foll[$ by bad logic2 & !re may be bo? false premise & bad logic4 ,! ,roman sy/em has su* a p[]ful manufactory ( premises1 t bad logic is little want$2 !re is comp>atively little ( x4 ,! doctr9e-=ge ( ! ,roman ,*ur* is "o glori\s comp\nd ( ev]y?+ t c\ld make ,h]aclitus#ga sob & ,democritus#gb snigg]4 ,b n ! only "o4 ,! ,prote/ants1 9 te>+ away f ! ,*ur* ( ,rome1 took ) !m a fair quantity ( ! results ( ! ,roman =ge1 :i* !y c\ld n br+ !mselves to give up4 ,!y _h m 9 !m ( ,m>t9 ?an ( ,jack4 ,b !y w\ld h no premises1 except f ! ,new ,te/am5t2 ?\gh "s ek$ out ) a few g5]al ,c\ncils4 ,! consequ5ce is t !y h be5 oblig$ to f9d su* a logic z w\ld br+ ! conclusions !y require out ( ! canonical books4 ,& a que] logic x is2 no?+ b ! ,roman =ge c be comp>$ ) ! ,prote/ant loom4 ,! pick+1 ! pat*+1 ! piec+1 :i* goes to ! ,prote/ant t]m9i ad quem1#gc w\ld be z rem>kable to ! g5]al eye1 z ! ,roman manufacture ( t]m9i a quo1#gd if x 7 n t ! _w at l>ge seizes ! "* ( an ass]t$ fact bett] ?an t ( a mode ( inf]5ce4 ,a gr& /ep t[>ds ! deification ( a lady1 made by alleg$ revelation #ahjj ye>s aft] h] dea?1 is ( gl>+ evid5ce3 two or ?ree additional %iffle-%uffles t[>ds def5ce ( say+ ! ,a?anasian curse 9 *ur* & unsay+ x out ( *ur*1 are h>dly notic$4 ,swift has bungl$ 8 satire :]e he makes ,pet] a p>ty to f9d+ out :at he wants1 totidem syllabis & totidem lit]is1 #ce :5 he _c f9d x totidem v]bis#ge ,?is is ,prote/ant me?od3 ! ,roman plan is viam faciam2 ! ,prote/ant plan is viam inv5iam4#gf ,! public at l>ge beg9s to be conv]sant ) ! ways ( wriggl+ out1 z %[n 9 ! int]pretations ( ! damnatory p>ts ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$1 ! phrases ( ! ,burial ,s]vice1 etc4 ,! "t w come :5 ! same public w beg9 to see ! ways ( wriggl+ 94 ,b "o ?+ at a "t3 nei!r ,papal ,rome nor ,prote/ant ,rome 0 built--nor w be pull$ d[n--9 a day4 ,! di/9ction above drawn betwe5 ! two great anti!ses ( ,*ri/5dom may be illu/rat$ z foll[s4 ,two sets ( little g5]al deal]s liv$ opposite to "o ano!r3 all sold milk4 ,ea* vaunt$ its own produce3 "o set said t ! /uff on ! o!r side ! way 0 only *alk & wat]2 ! o!r said t ! opposites sold all sorts ( fil?1 ( :i* calves' bra9 0 ! lea/ na/y4 ,n[ ! fact 0 t bo? sets sold milk1 & f ! same dairy3 b adult]at$ ) diff]5t sorts ( dirty wat]3 & bo? hone/ly believ$ t ! mixture 0 :at !y 7 meant to sell & ought to sell4 ,! great diff]5ce betwe5 !m1 ab\t :i* ! appr5tices f\ght ea* o!r l ,trojans1 0 t ! calves' bra9 m5 p\r$ milk into ! wat]1 & ! *alk m5 p\r$ wat] into ! milk4 ,! ,greek & ,roman sects on "o side1 ! ,prote/ant sects on ! o!r1 mu/ all h *ur*es3 ! ,greek & ,roman sects p\r ! ,new ,te/am5t into _! *ur*es2 ! ,prote/ant sects p\r _! *ur*es into ! ,new ,te/am5t4 ,! ,greek & ,roman insi/ ^u ! ,new ,te/am5t be+ no m ?an "p & p>cel ( _! *ur*es3 ! ,prote/ant insi/ ^u _! *ur*es be+ z mu* "p & p>cel ( ! ,new ,te/am5t4 ,all dwell vehem5tly ^u ! doctr9e t !re mu/ be milk #cf some:]e2 & ea* says--,i h x4 ,! doctr9e is true3 & c be v]ifi$ by any "o :o c & w g to ! dairy = himself4 ,him w ! sev]al trad]s decl>e to h no milk at all4 ,!y w br+ _! own w>es1 & *all5ge a trial3 !y want no?+ b to "n ! judges4 ,to v>y ! metaphor1 ^? :o h look$ at ,*ri/ianity 9 op5 day1 "k t all :o see x ?r\gh pa9t$ w9d[s %ut out mu* ( ! light ( heav5 & color ! re/2 x matt]s no?+ t ! /a9s are %ap$ into :at are meant = sa9ts & angels4 ,b !re is ano!r side to ! "q4 ,to decompose any sub/ance1 x mu/ be plac$ betwe5 ! poles ( ! batt]y4 ,n[ !ology is b "o pole2 philosophy is ! o!r4 ,no "o c make out ! comb9ations ( our day unless he read ! writ+s bo? ( ! prie/ & ! philosoph]3 & if any "o %\ld hold ! fir/ ^w (f5sive1 ,i tell him t ,i mean bo? words to be significant4 ,9 read+ ^! writ+s1 he w ne$ to br+ bo? wires toge!r to f9d out :at x is all ab\t4 ,"t 0 :5 mo/ prie/s 7 v explicit ab\t ! fate ( philosoph]s1 & mo/ philosoph]s 7 v c&id ab\t _! op9ion ( prie/s4 ,b ?\gh "s extremes ( ! old sorts /ill rema91 !re is n[1 9 ! middle1 su* a fusion ( ! two pursuits t a pla9 man is w(ully puzzl$4 ,! !ologian writes a philosophy :i* seems to tell u t ! ,new ,te/am5t is a sy/em ( psy*ology2 & ! philosoph] writes a ,*ri/ianity :i* is utt]ly un9telligible z to ! "q :e!r ! ,resurrection be a fact or a transc5d5tal allegory4 ,:at betwe5 ! !ologian :o ass5ts to ! ,a?anasian d5unciation 9 :at seems ! s5se ( no d5unciation1 & ! philosoph] :o p>ades a ,*ri/ianity :i* looks l no revelation1 !re is a maze :i* ?reat5s to h ! only possible clue 9 ! !ory t ev]y?+ is some?+ else1 & no?+ is any?+ at all4 ,b ?is is a p>adox f> beyond my h&l+3 x is a ,budget ( itself4 #cg ,,religion ,,& ,,philosophy4 ,religion & ,philosophy1 ! two be/ gifts ( ,heav51 set up 9 opposition to ea* o!r at ! revival ( lett]s2 & nev] did compet+ tradesm5 m grossly misbehave4 ,bad wi%es & bad names flew ab\t l sw>ms ( wasps4 ,! ,a?anasian curses 7 int5d$ aga9/ philosoph]s2 :o1 _h !y be5 a corporation1 ) /ate p[]s to protect !m1 w\ld h =muliz$ a p] contra4 ,b ! tradesm5 are beg9n+ to comb9e3 !y are civil to ea* o!r2 too civil by half4 ,i speak especially ( ,great ,brita94 ,old !ology has run (f to ritualism1 mu* lam5t+1 ) no com=t except ! discov]y t ! cloak ,paul left at ,troas 0 a *asuble4 ,philosophy1 :i* always _h a little s5se sew$ up 9 its g>m5ts--to pay = its fun]al8--has exp5d$ a trifle 9 accommodat+ itself to ! new sy/em4 ,b ! two are poles ( a batt]y2 & a "q arises4 ,if ,pet] ,pip] pick$ a peck ( pepp]1 ,:]e is ! peck ( pepp] ,pet] ,pip] pick$8 ,if ,religion & ,philosophy be ! two poles ( a batt]y1 ^: is ! batt]y ,religion & ,philosophy h be5 made ! poles (8 ,is ! *ange 9 ! relation ( ! wires any presumption ( a removal ( ! manag]s8 ,we "k pretty well :o h&l$ ! in/rum5t3 has he resign$ or be5#gg turn$ out8 ,has he be5 put "u #ch re/riction8 ,a fool may ask m que/ions ?an tw5ty sages c answ]3 b !re is hope2 = tw5ty sages _c ask m que/ions ?an "o review] c answ]4 ,i %\ld l to see ! opposite sides employ$ ^u ! "q1 ,:at are ! commoda1 & :at ! p]icula1#gh ( ! curr5t approximation ( ,religion & ,philosophy8 ,all ?is is v pr(ane & irrev]5t6 ,x has always be5 s held by ^? ^: position dem&s su* hold+4 ,to describe ! ,*ur* z x is passes = assail+ ! ,*ur* z x ought to be ) all :o _c d )\t x4 ,9 ,b$lam#gi a poor creature :o fanci$ he 0 ,/4 ,paul1 0 told by ano!r pati5t t he 0 an impo/or2 ! fir/ maniac lodg$ a compla9t aga9/ ! second = call+ ,/4 ,paul an impo/or1 :i*1 he argu$1 ) mu* appe>ance ( sanity1 ought n to be p]mitt$ 9 a well regulat$ madh\se4 ,no?+ c\ld p]suade him t he _h miss$ ! "q1 :i* 0 :e!r he 0 ,/4 ,paul4 ,! same ?+ takes place 9 ! _w at l>ge4 ,& especially mu/ be not$ ! refusal to p]mit to ! pr(ane ! million? "p ( ! lic5ce assum$ by ! sacr$4 ,i give a s\nd *ur*man ! epitaph ( ,/4 ,john ,long2 ! usual pronunciation ( ^: "n mu/ be not$-- ,behold6 ye quacks1 ! v5geance /rong ,on de$s l y\rs imp++3 ,= "h bel[ lies ,/4 ,john ,long#hj ,:o n[ mu/ be long s+e+4 ,h[ %ameful to pron\nce ?is ( ! poor man6 ,:at1 ,mr4 ,or?odox6 may ,i n d 9 joke to "o pret5d] :at #ci y d 9 e>ne/--unless y quibble--to all ! millions ( ! ,greek ,*ur*1 & a great _m o!rs4 ,en\gh ( y & y\r reason+6 ,g & squ>e ! circle6 ,! few ye>s :i* end ) #ahfg h %[n1 n m]ely ! int]m$iate fusion ( ,!ology & ,philosophy ( :i* ,i h spok51 b mu* conc5tration ( ! two extremes1 :i* looks l a ga!r+ ( =ces = "s v h>d f\ght ,armag$don4 ,extreme !ology has be5 aim+ at a high ,*ur* 9 ,engl&1 :i* is to %[ a new front to all h]esy3 & extreme philosophy is contriv+ a physical organization :i* is to ?9k1 & to %[ t m9d is a consequ5ce ( matt]1 or ?\ght a recreation ( bra94 ,! physical speculators beg9 ) a possible hypo!sis1 9 :i* !y aim at explanation3 & s ! bold aspirations ( ! au?or ( ! ,ve/iges f9d /&+-gr\nd 9 ! v>iation ( species by natural selection4 ,"s relics--s suppos$--( extremely anci5t m5 are br\ght to help ! g5]al cause4 ,only di/ant h9ts are giv5 t by possibility x may end 9 ! =mation ( all liv+ organisms f a v few1 if n f "o4 ,! bett] heads above m5tion$ "k t _! !ory1 if true1 does n be> ^u morals4 ,! =mation ( sol> sy/ems f a nebul> hypo!sis1 foll[$ by organizations gradually em]g+ f "s curi\s play ( p>ticles1 nay1 ! v evolution ( m9d & ?\ght f su* an app>atus1 are all z consi/5t ) a ,p]sonal creative p[] to :om homage & ob$i5ce are due1 & :o has decl>$ himself1 z ) a bl9d ,nature ( ,?+s4 ,a pure mat]iali/1 z to all ?+s visible1 may be ev5 a bigott$ ,*ri/ian3 ?is is n frequ5t1 b x is possible4 ,!re is a prov]b :i* says1 ,a pig may fly1 b x isn't a likely bird4 ,b :5 ! psy*ological speculator comes 91 he (t5 und]takes to draw inf]5ces f ! physical conclusions1 by jo9+ on 8 trem5d\s app>atus ( a priori k4 ,he d$uces t he c d )\t a ,god3 he c d$uce all ?+s #dj )\t any su* necessity4 ,) ,occam#ha & ,newton he w h no m causes ?an are necess>y to expla9 ph5om5a to him3 & if by pure head-"w comb9$ ) results ( physical obs]vation he c con/ruct 8 univ]se1 he mu/ be a v unphilosophical man :o w\ld encumb] himself ) a useless ,creator6 ,!re is some?+ tangible ab\t my me?od1 says he2 y\rs is vague4 ,he requires x to be grant$ t 8 sy/em is positive & t y\rs is impositive4 ,s reason$ ! /age coa*man :5 ! railroads began to depose him--,if y're upset 9 a /age-coa*1 :y1 !re y are6 b if y're upset on ! railroad1 :]e are y8 ,! answ] lies 9 ano!r "q1 ,:i* is mo/ positive k1 ,god d$uc$ f man & 8 hi/ory1 or ! po/ulates ( ! few :o ?9k !y c reason a priori on ! tacit assumption ( unlimit$ comm& ( data8 ,we are n yet come to ! exi/5ce ( a s*ool ( philosoph]s :o explicitly d5y a ,creator3 b we are on ! way1 ?\gh common s5se may int]pose4 ,!re are always /raws :i* %[ ! direction ( ! w9d4 ,i h be=e me ! pr9t$ lett] ( a m$ical man--to ^: pr(essional ability ,i h good te/imony--:o f9ds ! vital pr9ciple 9 highly r>efi$ oxyg54 ,) ! usual logic ( su* ?9k]s1 he dismisses ! et]nal p]sonal id5tity because ,if s\l1 _s1 m9d1 :i* are m]ely modes ( s5sation1 be ! attribute or function ( n]ve-tissue1 x _c possibly h any exi/5ce ap>t f its mat]ial organism6 ,h[ does he "k ?is impossibility8 ,if all ! m9d we "k be f n]ve-tissue1 h[ does x appe> t m9d 9 o!r planets may n be ano!r ?+8 ,nay1 :5 we come to possibilities1 does n 8 own sy/em give a que] "o8 ,if highly r>efi$ oxyg5 be vital p[]1 m highly r>efi$ oxyg5 #da may be m vital & m p[]ful4 ,:]e is ?is to /op8 ,is x impossible t a f9ite quantity1 r>efi$ ad inf9itum1 may be an ,omnipot5t8 ,p]haps ! true ,g5esis1 :5 writt51 w op5 ) ,9 ! beg9n+ 0 an imp]ial qu>t ( oxyg5 at #fj deg4 ( ,fahr5heit1 & ! pressure ( ! atmosph]e2 & ?is oxyg5 0 inf9itely r>efi$2 & ?is oxyg5 became ,god4 ,= myself1 my aspirations z to ?is sy/em are ,mani*aean4 ,! qu>t ( oxyg5 is ! ,ormuzd1 or good pr9ciple3 ano!r qu>t1 ( hydrog51 is ! ,ahriman1 or evil pr9ciple6 ,my au?or says t 8 sy/em expla9s ,freewill & ,immortality s obvi\sly t x is difficult to read previ\s speculations ) becom+ gravity4 ,my d$uction expla9s ! conflict ( good & evil ) su* cle>ness t no "o c h5ce=w>d read ! ,new ,te/am5t ) becom+ rev]5ce4 ,! surgeon :om ,i h describ$ is an e>ly bud :i* w probably be nipp$ by ! fro/ & )] on ! gr\nd3 b !re is a good crop com+4 ,mat]ial pneuma is de/9$ to high functions2 & man is to read by gas-light4 ,,! ,,sun ,,an ,,electric ,,space4 ,! sol> sy/em truly solv$2 demon/rat+ by ! p]fect h>mony ( ! planets1 f\nd$ on ! f\r univ]sal laws1 ! ,sun to be an electric space2 & a s\rce ( e natural production display$ ?r\gh\t ! sol> sy/em4 ,by ,james ,hopk9s4#hb ,london1 #ahdi1 #hvo4 ,! au?or says3 ,i am satisfi$ t ,i h giv5 ! true laws con/itut+ ! ,sun to be space2 & ,i call ^u ^? dispos$ to ma9ta9 ! contr>y1 to give true laws %[+ him to be a body3 until su* c be satisfactorily e/abli%$1 ,i h an und\bt$ claim to ! cr$it ( my !ory1--,t ! ,sun is an ,electric ,space1 f$ & gov]n$ by ! #db planets1 :i* h ! prop]ty ( attract+ heat f x2 & ! means ( supply+ ! necess>y pabulum by _! deg5]at$ air driv5 (f t[>ds ! c5tral space--! wond]ful alembic 9 :i* x becomes transmut$ to ! revivify+ necessities ( cont9u\s action2 & ! c5tral space or ,sun be+ p]fectly electric1 has ! c\nt] prop]ty ( repuls+ ! bodies t attract x4 ,h[ wond]ful a conception6 ,h[ beautiful1 h[ magnific5t an arrangem5t6 ,o ,c5tre6 ,o ,space6 ,o ,electric ,space6 ,,joseph ,,ady4 #ahdi4 ,joseph ,ady#hc is entitl$ to a place 9 ?is li/ ( discov]]s3 8 great fault1 l t ( "s o!rs1 lay 9 pu%+ 8 me?od too f>4 ,he began by detect+ unclaim$ divid5ds1 & disclos+ !m to _! "r own]s1 exact+ 8 fee be=e he made 8 communication4 ,he !n g5]aliz$ into try+ to get fees f all ( ! "n belong+ to a divid5d2 & he gave my/]i\s h9ts ( dang] imp5d+4 ,= in/ance1 he w\ld write to a cl]gyman t a legal p5alty 0 hang+ ov] him2 & :5 ! al>m$ div9e =w>d$ ! sum requir$ = disclosure1 he 0 favor$ ) an extract f "s old /atute or canon1 nev] repeal$1 =bidd+ a cl]gyman to be a memb] ( a corporation1 & 0 rem9d$ t he _h insur$ 8 life 9 ! ---- ,(fice1 :i* _h a royal *>t]4 ,he 0 faceti\s1 0 ,joseph3 he describ$ himself 9 8 circul>s z p]sonally kn[n to ,sir ,pet] ,laurie#hd & all o!r ald]m52 :i* 0 ne>ly true1 #dc z he _h be5 be=e mo/ ( !m on *>ges ( false pret5ce2 b ,i believe he 0 ne>ly always )9 ! law4 ,sir ,james ,duke1 :5 ,"l ,mayor1 hav+ p>ticul>ly displeas$ him by a decision1 8 circul>s ( #ahdi conta9 ! foll[+3 ,%\ld y h cause to compla9 ( any p>ty1 ,sir ,j4 ,duke has contriv$ a new law ( evid5ce1 viz41 write to him1 he w consid] y\r lett] suffici5t pro(1 & make ! p>ties compla9$ ( pay )\t judge or jury1 & w frank y f e exp5se4 ,i /rongly suspect t ,joseph ,ady believ$ 9 himself4 ,he sometimes issu$ a second w>n+1 ( a ,sibyll9e "*3 ,%\ld y f9d cause to compla9 ( anybody1 my volunt>y ref]ee1 ! ,rt4 ,hon4 ,sir ,pet] ,laurie1 ,kt41 p]petual ,deputy ,"l ,mayor1 w see ju/ice done y )\t any *>ge :atev]3 he & 8 toady1 -- ---- ----4 ,! accurs$ ( ,moses c hang any man3 ?us1 by cat*+ him alone & swe>+ ,nabo? spake evil aga9/ ,god & ! ,k+4 ,!re=e 767 ,i admit no /rang]s to a p]sonal conf]5ce )\t a prepaym5t ( #bjs4 ea*4 ,_h y att5d$ to my =m] notice y w\ld h receiv$ twice z mu*3 neglect ?is & y w lose all4 ,,on ,,mod]n ,,a/rology4 ,zadkiel's ,almanac = #ahdi4 ,n9ete5? numb]4 ,raphael's ,prophetic ,almanac = #ahdi4 ,tw5ty-n9? numb]4 ,reasons = belief 9 judicial a/rology1 & rem>ks on ! dang]\s "* ( popi% prie/craft4 ,london1 #ahdi1 #abmo4 ,a/ronomy 9 a nut%ell3 or ! lead+ problems ( ! sol> sy/em solv$ by simple proportion only1 on ! !ory ( magnetic attraction4 ,by ,lieut4 ,morrison1#he ,n4 ,n4 ,london 7s4 a47 #abmo4 #dd ,lieut4 ,morrison is ,zadkiel ,tao ,sze1 & decl>es himself 9 real e>ne/ an a/rolog]4 ,!re are a great _m books on a/rology1 b ,i h n felt int]e/ en\gh to pres]ve _m ( !m :i* h come 9 my way4 ,if any?+ ev] _h a fair trial1 x 0 a/rology4 ,! idea itself is natural en\gh4 ,a human be+1 set d[n on ?is e>?1 )\t any tradition1 w\ld probably suspect t ! heav5ly bodies _h some?+ to d ) ! guidance ( affairs4 ,i ?9k t any "o :o tries w asc]ta9 t ! planets d n prophesy3 b if he %\ld f9d to ! contr>y1 he w ( c\rse g on ask+4 ,a great _m p]sons class toge!r belief 9 a/rology & belief 9 app>itions3 ! two ?+s diff] 9 precisely ! way 9 :i* a sci5ce ( obs]vation diff]s f a sci5ce ( exp]im5t4 ,_m make ! mi/ake :i* ,m4 le ,m>quis made :5 he came too late1 & hop$ ,m4 ,cass9i#hf w\ld d ! eclipse ov] aga9 = 8 ladies4 ,! app>ition *ooses its own "t1 & comes z seldom or z (t5 z x pleases1 be x dep>t$ _s1 n]v\s d]angem5t1 or imposition4 ,consequ5tly x c only be obs]v$1 & n exp]im5t$ ^u4 ,b ! heav5s1 if a/rology be true1 are prophesy+ away day & night all ! ye> r\nd1 & ab\t e body4 ,exp]im5ts c be made1 !n1 except only on r>e ph5om5a1 su* z eclipses3 anybody may *oose 8 "t & 8 "q4 ,?is is ! great diff]5ce3 & exp]im5ts 7 made1 c5tury aft] c5tury4 ,if a/rology _h be5 true1 x mu/ h la/$ 9 an ev]-improv+ /ate4 ,if x be true1 x is a tru?1 & a useful tru?1 :i* _h exp]i5ce & prejudice bo? 9 its favor1 & yet lo/ gr\nd z soon z a/ronomy1 its work+ tool1 began to improve4 #ahej4 ,a lett] 9 ! h&writ+ ( an educat$ man1 dat$ f a /reet 9 :i* x mu/ be tak5 t educat$ p]sons live1 is address$ to ! ,secret>y ( ! #de ,a/ronomical ,society ab\t a matt] on :i* ! writ] says 8 pr(essional pursuit w enable him to give a satisfactory reply4 ,9 a "q be=e a c\rt ( law x is sworn on "o side t ! moon 0 %9+ at a c]ta9 h\r ( a c]ta9 night on a c]ta9 spot 9 ,london2 on ! o!r side x is affirm$ t %e 0 cl\d$4 ,! ,secret>y is reque/$ to decide4 ,?is is curi\s1 z ! "q is n a/rological4 ,p]sons /ill s5d to ,gre5wi*1 n[ & !n1 to h _! =tunes told4 ,9 "o case1 n v _m ye>s ago1 a "y g5tleman begg$ to "k :o 8 wife 0 to be1 & :at fee he 0 to remit4 ,sometimes ! a/ronom] turns conjur] = fun1 & 8 prophesies are fulfill$4 ,x is relat$ ( ,flam/e$#hg t an old woman came to "k ! :]eab\ts ( a bundle ( l95 :i* _h /ray$4 ,flam/e$ drew a circle1 put a squ>e into x1 & gravely po9t$ out a dit*1 ne> h] cottage1 9 :i* he said x w\ld be f\nd4 ,he meant to h giv5 ! woman a little good advice :5 %e came back3 b %e came back 9 great delight1 ) ! bundle 9 h] h&1 f\nd 9 ! v place4 ,! late ,b>on ,za*#hh receiv$ a lett] f ,pons1#hi a successful f9d] ( comets1 compla9+ t = a c]ta9 p]iod he _h f\nd no comets1 ?\gh he _h se>*$ dilig5tly4 ,za*1 a man ( mu* sly humor1 told him t no spots _h be5 se5 on ! sun = ab\t ! same "t--:i* 0 true1--& assur$ him t :5 ! spots came back1 ! comets w\ld come ) !m4 ,"s "t aft] he got a lett] #df f ,pons1 :o in=m$ him ) great satisfaction t he 0 q "r1 t v l>ge spots _h appe>$ on ! sun1 & t he _h f\nd a f9e comet %ortly aft]4 ,i d n v\* = ! fir/ /ory1 b ,i h ! second 9 ,za*'s h&writ+4 ,x w\ld m5d ! joke exce$+ly if "s day a real relation %\ld be e/abli%$ betwe5 comets & sol> spots3 ( late ye>s good reason has be5 %[n = advanc+ a connection betwe5 ^! spots & ! e>?'s magnetism4#ij ,if ! two ?+s _h be5 put to ,za*1 he w\ld probably h *os5 ! comets4 ,"h is a h9t = a p>adox3 ! sol> spots are ! dead comets1 :i* h p>t$ ) _! light & heat to fe$ ! sun1 z 0 once sugge/$4 ,i %\ld n wond] if ,i 7 too late1 & ! ?+ _h be5 actually ma9ta9$4 ,my li/ does n conta9 ! tw5tie? "p ( ! possible :ole4 ,! m5tion ( co9cid5ces sugge/s an ev]la/+ s\rce ( explanations1 applicable to all t is extraord9>y4 ,! great p>adox ( co9cid5ce is t ( ,leibnitz1 kn[n z ! pre-e/abli%$ h>mony1 or law ( co9cid5ces1 by :i*1 sep>ately & indep5d5tly1 ! body receives impressions1 & ! m9d proce$s z if x _h p]ceiv$ !m f )\t4 ,e s5sation1 & ! consequ5t /ate ( ! s\l1 are indep5d5t ?+s co9cid5t 9 "t by ! pre-e/abli%$ law4 ,! philosoph] c\ld n o!rwise acc\nt = ! connection ( m9d & matt]2 & he nev] goes by s vulg> a rule z ,:atev] is1 is2 to him t :i* is n cle> z to h[1 is n at all4 ,philosoph]s 9 g5]al1 :o tol]ate ea* o!r's !ories mu* bett] ?an ,*ri/ians d ea* o!r's fail+s1 seldom revive ,leibnitz's fantasy3 !y seem to act ^u ! maxim quot$ by ,fa!r ,eu/ace#ia f ! #dg ,decretals1 ,fac9ora o/5di dum puniuntur1 flagitia autem abscondi deb5t4#ib ,! great gho/-p>adox1 & its !ory ( co9cid5ces1 w rise to ! surface 9 ! m9d ( e "o4 ,b ! use ( ! ^w co9cid5ce is "h at v>iance ) its common mean+4 ,:5 ,a is con/antly happ5+1 & also ,b1 ! occurr5ce ( ,a & ,b at ! same mom5t is ! m]e co9cid5ce :i* may be casualty4 ,b ! case be=e u is t ,a is con/antly happ5+1 :ile ,b1 :5 x does happ51 almo/ always happ5s ) ,a1 & v r>ely )\t x4 ,t is to say1 su* is ! ph5om5on ass]t$3 & all :o rationally ref] x to casualty1 affirm t ,b is happ5+ v (t5 z well z ,a1 b t x is n ?\ght wor?y ( be+ record$ except :5 ,a is simultane\s4 ,( c\rse ,a is "h a dea?1 & ,b ! spectral appe>ance ( ! p]son :o dies4 ,9 talk+ ( ?is subject x is necess>y to put out ( ! "q all :o play fa/ & loose ) _! secret convictions3 ^! _h bett] give u a reason1 :5 !y feel int]nal pressure = explanation1 t !re is no wea!rcock at ,kilve2 ?is w\ld d = all cases4 ,b p]sons ( real inquiry w see t fir/1 exp]i5ce does n be> out ! ass]t$ frequ5cy ( ! spectre1 )\t ! alleg$ co9cid5ce ( dea?3 & secondly1 t if ! cr[d ( purely casual spectres 7 s great t x is no wond] t1 n[ & !n ! p]son %\ld h di$ at or ne> ! mom5t1 we ought to expect a mu* l>g] proportion ( cases 9 :i* ! spectre %\ld come at ! mom5t ( ! dea? ( "o or ano!r ( all ! clu/] :o are closely connect$ ) ! orig9al ( ! spectre4 ,b ?is1 we "k1 is almo/ )\t example4 ,x rema9s !n1 = all1 :o speculate at all1 to look ^u ! ass]t$ ph5om5on1 ?9k :at !y may ( x1 ! ?+ :i* is to be expla9$1 z a connection 9 "t ( ! dea?1 & ! #dh simultane\s appe>ance ( ! dead4 ,any p]son ! lea/ us$ to ! !ory ( probabilities w see t purely casual co9cid5ce1 ! wrong spectre be+ comp>atively s r>e t x may be said nev] to occur1 is n )9 ! rational field ( possibility4 ,! purely casual co9cid5ce1 f :i* !re is no escape except ! actual doctr9e ( special provid5ces1 c>ri$ d[n to a v l[ po9t ( special int5tion1 requires a junction ( ! ?+s ! l ( ea* ( :i* is always happ5+4 ,i w give ?ree in/ances :i* h occurr$ to myself )9 ! la/ few ye>s3 ,i solemnly v\* = ! lit]al tru? ( e "p ( all ?ree3 ,9 ,augu/ #ahfa1 ,m4 ,s5>mont1#ic ( ! ,fr5* ,in/itute1 wrote to me to ! effect t ,fresnel#id _h s5t to ,engl&1 9 or %ortly aft] #ahbd1 a pap] = translation & ins]tion 9 ! ,european ,review1 :i* %ortly aft]w>ds expir$4 ,! "q 0 :at _h become ( t pap]4 ,i exam9$ ! ,review at ! ,museum1 f\nd no trace ( ! pap]1 & wrote back to t effect at ! ,museum1 add+ t ev]y?+ n[ dep5d$ on asc]ta9+ ! "n ( ! editor1 & trac+ 8 pap]s3 ( ?is ,i ?\ght !re 0 no *ance4 ,i po/$ ?is lett] on my way home1 at a ,po/ ,(fice 9 ! ,hamp/ead ,road at ! junction ) ,edw>d ,/reet1 on ! opposite side ( :i* is a book/all4 ,l\ng+ = a mom5t ov] ! expos$ books1 sicut meus e/ mos1#ie ,i saw1 )9 a few m9utes ( ! po/+ ( ! lett]1 a little cat*-p5ny book ( anecdotes ( ,macaulay1 :i* ,i b\ght1 & ran ov] = a m9ute4 ,my eye 0 soon caught by ?is s5t5ce3 ,"o ( ! "y fell[s imm$iately wrote to ! editor 7,mr4 ,walk]7 #di ( ! ,european ,review4 ,i ?us got ! clue by :i* ,i asc]ta9$ t !re 0 no *ance ( recov]+ ,fresnel's pap]4 ,( ! m5tion ( curr5t reviews1 n "o 9 a ?\s& names ! editor4 ,9 ! summ] ( #ahfe ,i made my fir/ acqua9tance ) ! tales ( ,na?aniel ,haw?orne1 & ! fir/ ,i read 0 ab\t ! siege ( ,bo/on 9 ! ,w> ( ,indep5d5ce4 ,i c\ld n make x out3 ev]ybody seem$ to h got into somebody else's place4 ,i 0 beg9n+ ! second tale1 :5 a p>cel arriv$3 x 0 a lot ( old pamphlets & o!r rubbi%1 z he call$ x1 s5t by a fri5d :o _h lately sold 8 books1 _h n ?\ght x wor? :ile to s5d ^! ?+s = sale1 b ?\ght ,i might l to look at !m & possibly keep "s4 ,! fir/ ?+ ,i look$ at 0 a %eet :i*1 be+ op5$1 display$ ,a plan ( ,bo/on & its environs1 %ew+ ! true situation ( 8 ,maje/y's army & also t ( ! rebels1 drawn by an eng9e]1 at ,bo/on ,oct4 #agge4 ,su* detail$ plans ( curr5t sieges be+ !n uncommon1 x is expla9$ t ,! pr9cipal "p ( ?is plan 0 survey$ by ,ri*>d ,williams1 ,lieut5ant at ,bo/on2 & s5t ov] by ! son ( a nobleman to 8 fa!r 9 t[n1 by ^: p]mission x 0 publi%$4 ,i imm$iately saw t my confusion arose f my suppos+ t ! k+'s troops 7 besieg+ ! rebels1 :5 x 0 j ! o!r way4 ,april #a1 #ahec1 :ile engag$ 9 mak+ "s notes on a logical po9t1 an idea occurr$ :i* 0 p]fectly new to me1 on ! mode ( conciliat+ ! notions omnipres5ce & indivisibility into p>ts4 ,:at x 0 is no matt] "h3 suffice x t1 s9ce x 0 publi%$ else:]e 79 a pap] on ,inf9ity1 ,camb4 ,phil4 ,trans4 vol4 xi4 p4 #a7 ,i h n _h x produc$ to me4 ,i _h j f9i%$ a p>agraph on ! subject1 :5 a p>cel came 9 f a booksell] conta9+ ,heywood's#if ,analysis ( ,kant's ,critick1 #ahdd4 #ej ,on turn+ ov] ! leaves ,i f\nd 7p4 #aji7 ! id5tical ?\ght :i* up to ?is day1 ,i only "k z 9 my own pap]1 or 9 ,kant4 ,i feel sure ,i _h n se5 x be=e1 = x is 9 ,kant's fir/ edition1 :i* 0 nev] translat$ to my k2 & x does n appe> 9 ! lat] editions4 ,mr4 ,heywood gives "s acc\nt ( ! fir/ edition4 ,9 ! broad%eet :i* gave acc\nt ( ! dy+ sc5e ( ,*>les ,,ii1 x is said t ! ,roman ,ca?olic prie/ 0 introduc$ by ,p4 ,m4 ,a4 ,c4 ,f4 ,! *a9 0 ?is3 ! ,du*ess ( ,portsm\?#ig appli$ to ! ,duke ( ,york1 :o may h consult$ 8 ,cordeli] confessor1 ,mansuete1 ab\t procur+ a prie/1 & ! prie/ 0 smuggl$ into ! k+'s room by ! ,du*ess & ,*iff9*4#ih ,n[ ! lett]s are a v]bal acro/ic ( ,p]e ,mansuete a ,cordeli] ,fri>1 & a syllabic acro/ic ( ,ports,mouth & ,chif,finch4 ,?is is a s+ul> co9cid5ce4 ,macaulay adopt$ ! fir/ int]pretation1 pref]r+ x to ! second1 :i* ,i br\ght be=e him z ! conjecture ( a ne> relative ( my own4 ,b ,mansuete is n m5tion$ 9 8 n>rative3 x may well be d\bt$ :e!r ! writ] ( a broadside = ,engli% read]s w\ld use ,p]e in/ead ( ,fa!r4 ,& ! p]son :o really rem9d$ ! ,duke ( ! duty he ow$ to 8 bro!r1 0 ! ,du*ess & n ,mansuete4 ,b my affair is only ) ! co9cid5ce4 ,b !re are co9cid5ces :i* are really connect$ )\t ! connection be+ kn[n to ^? :o f9d 9 !m matt] ( a/oni%m5t4 ,pres5tim5ts furni% m>k$ cases3 sometimes !re is no my/]y to ^? :o h ! clue4 ,9 ! ,g5tleman's ,magaz9e 7vol4 #hj1 "p #b1 p4 #cc7 we read1 ! subject be+ pres5tim5t ( dea?1 z foll[s3 ,9 #aggh1 to come ne>] ! recollection ( #ea survivors1 at ! tak+ ( ,pondi*]ry1 ,capta9 ,john ,flet*]1 ,capta9 ,de ,morgan1 & ,lieut5ant ,bosanquet1 ea* di/9ctly =etold 8 own dea? on ! morn+ ( 8 fate4 ,i h no d\bt ( all ?ree2 & ,i knew x ( my gr&fa!r long be=e ,i read ! above passage4 ,he saw t ! batt]y he comm&$ 0 unduly expos$3 ,i ?9k by ! sap runn+ ?r\gh ! =t :5 produc$4 ,he repres5t$ ?is to ! eng9e] (fic]s1 & to ! comm&]-9-*ief2 ! eng9e]s d5i$ ! tru? ( ! /atem5t1 ! comm&] believ$ !m1 my gr&fa!r quietly obs]v$ t he mu/ make 8 w1 & ! ,fr5* fulfill$ 8 pr$iction4 ,8 w bore date ! day ( 8 dea?2 & ,i always ?\ght x m rem>kable ?an ! fulfilm5t ( ! prophecy t a soldi] %\ld n consid] any dang] %ort ( "o l ! above1 suffici5t reason to make 8 w4 ,i suppose ! o!r (fic]s 7 simil>ly po/$4 ,i am told t milit>y m5 v (t5 def] mak+ _! wills until j be=e an action3 b to face ! ord9>y risks inte/ate1 & to wait until spe$y dea? mu/ be ! all b c]ta9 consequ5ce ( a /upid mi/ake1 is c>ry+ ! pr9ciple v f>4 ,9 ! matt] ( co9cid5ces !re are1 z 9 o!r cases1 two wond]ful extremes ) e int]m$iate degree4 ,at "o end we h ! confid5t p :o c attribute any?+ to casual co9cid5ce2 :o all[ ,zadok ,impo/ure & ,na?an ,co9cid5ce to ano9t ,solomon ,selfconceit k+4 ,at ! o!r end we h ^? :o see some?+ v curi\s 9 any co9cid5ce y please1 & ^: m9ds ye>n = a deep reason4 ,a speculator ( ?is class happ5$ to f9d t ,mat!w viii4 #bh-cc & ,luke viii4 #bf-cc conta9 ! same acc\nt1 t ( ! demons ent]+ into ! sw9e4 ,v odd6 *apt]s tally+1 & v]ses s ne>ly3 is ! v]sification rightly manag$8 ,exam9ation is sure to %[ t !re are mon/r\s inconsi/5cies 9 ! mode ( division1 :i* be+ correct$1 ! v]ses tally z well z ! *apt]s4 ,& !n h[ comes x8 ,i _c g on1 #eb = ,i h no gift at tortur+ a co9cid5ce1 b ,i w\ld lay twop5ce1 if ,i c\ld make a bet--:i* ,i nev] did 9 all my life--t "s "o or m ( my read]s w try x4 ,"s p say t ! /udy ( *ances t5ds to awak5 a _s ( gambl+3 ,i suspect ! contr>y4 ,at any rate1 ,i myself1 ! writ] ( a ma!matical book & a comp>atively popul> book1 h nev] laid a bet nor play$ = a /ake1 h[ev] small3 n "o s+le "t4 ,x is useful to record su* in/ances z ,i h giv51 ) precision & on ! solemn ^w ( ! record]4 ,:5 su* a /ory z t ( ,flam/e$ is told1 a priori assures u t x c\ld n h be53 ! /ory may h be5 a b5 trovato1#ii b n ! bundle4 ,x is also useful to e/abli% "s ( ! good jokes :i* all take = inv5tions4 ,my fri5d ,mr4 ,j4 ,bell+ham ,+lis1#ajj be=e #ahjj1 saw ! tobacconi/'s c>riage ) a sample ( tobacco 9 a %ield1 & ! motto ,quid rides#aja 7,n4 ,q41 #c;d ,s4 i4 #bde74 ,8 fa!r 0 able to tell him all ab\t x4 ,! tobacconi/ 0 ,jacob ,br&on1 well kn[n to ! eld] ,mr4 ,+lis1 & ! p]son :o />t$ ! motto1 ! in/ant he 0 ask$ = su* a ?+1 0 ,h>ry ,cal5d] ( ,lloyd's1 a s*ol> & a wit4 ,my fri5d ,mr4 ,h4 ,crabb ,rob9son#ajb rememb]s ! ,k+'s ,c\nsel 7,samuel ,m>ryat7 :o took ! motto ,causes produce effects1 :5 8 success enabl$ him to />t a c>riage4 ,! co9cid5ces ( errata are sometimes v rem>kable3 x may be t ! mispr9t has a /+4 ,! dea? ( ,sir ,w4 ,hamilton#ajc ( ,ed9burgh 0 kn[n 9 ,london on a ,?ursday1 & ! editor ( ! ,a!naeum wrote to #ec me 9 ! aft]noon = a %ort obitu>y notice to appe> on ,saturday4 ,i da%$ (f ! few l9es :i* appe>$ )\t a mom5t to ?9k3 & ^? ( my read]s :o might p]haps ?9k me capable ( contriv+ errata ) mean+ w1 ,i am sure1 all[ ! hurry1 ! occasion1 & my own peculi> relation to ! dep>t$1 z suffici5t reasons = believ+ 9 my entire innoc5ce4 ,( c\rse ,i c\ld n see a pro(3 & two errata occurr$4 ,! words addition to ,/ew>t#ajd require = addition to read edition (4 ,?is repres5ts :at _h be5 insi/$ on by ! ,ed9burgh publi%]1 :o1 fright5$ by ! edition ( ,reid1#aje _h /ipulat$ = a simple repr9t )\t notes4 ,aga9 pr9ciples ( logic & ma!matics requir$ = ma!matics read metaphysics4 ,no f\r words c\ld be put toge!r :i* w\ld h s good a title to be ,hamilton's motto4 ,april #ahej1 f\nd 9 ! lett]-box1 ?ree loose leaves1 well pr9t$ & ov] punctuat$1 be+ ,*apt] ,,vi4 ,bre?r51 lo ,i come1 hold+ =? ! ^w ( life1 = s ,i am comm&$4444 ,*apt] ,,vii4 ,he> my pray]1 ,o g5]ations6 & walk by ! way1 to dr9k ! wat]s ( ! riv]4444 ,*apt] ,,viii4 ,he>k5 o e>?1 e>?1 e>?1 & ! k+s ( ! e>?1 & _! armies4444 ,a v l>ge collection might be made ( su* apo/olic writ+s4 ,!y g on well en\gh 9 a mi/y--meant = my/ical--imitation ( ,/4 ,paul or ! prophets1 until at la/ "s prodigi\s want ( keep+ %[s ! education ( ! writ]4 ,= example1 aft] half a page :i* might #ed pass = ,irv+'s#ajf prea*+--?\gh a p]son to :om x 0 pres5t$ z su* w\ld say t mo/ likely ! head & tail w\ld make some?+ m l head & tail ( x--we are a/\nd$ by a decl>ation f ! ,holy ,_s1 speak+ ( himself1 t he is n a%am$ ( ! ,gospel ( ,*ri/4 ,x w\ld be long be=e we %\ld f9d 9 educat$ rhapsody--( :i* !re are specim5s en\gh--su* a ?+ z a p]son ( ! ,tr9ity tak+ m]it = moral c\rage en\gh to /& :]e ,/4 ,pet] fell4 ,! foll[+ decl>ation comes next--,i w judge betwe5 cattle & cattle1 t use _! tongues4 ,,! ,,figure ,,( ,,! ,,e>?4 ,! figure ( ! e>?4 ,by ,j4 ,l4 ,murphy1#ajg ( ,birm+ham4 7,london & ,birm+ham1 #d pages1 #abmo47 7#ahej87 ,mr4 ,murphy invites att5tion & objection to "s ass]tions1 z t ! e>? is prolate1 n oblate4 ,if ! philosoph]'s conclusion be "r1 !n ! pole is ! c5t] ( a valley 767 ?irte5 miles deep4 ,h5ce x w\ld be v w>m4 ,x is answ] en\gh to ask--,:o kn[s t x is n8 999999 ,a p>agraph 9 ! ,,ms4 appe>s to h be5 ins]t$ 9 ?is place by mi/ake4 ,x w be f\nd 9 ! ,app5dix at ! end ( ?is volume4--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 ,,p]petual ,,motion4 #ahea4 ,! foll[+ lett] 0 writt5 by "o ( a class ( p]sons :om1 aft] mu* exp]i5ce ( !m1 ,i #ee d n pron\nce insane4 ,b 9 ?is case ! second s5t5ce gives a suspicion ( actual delusion ( ! s5ses2 ! ?ird looks l t eye = ! ma9 *ance :i* passes = sanity on ! ,/ock ,ex*ange & else:]e3 #ae? ,sept4 #ahea4 ,g5tlem51--,i pray y take /eps to make kn[n t ye/]day ,i complet$ my inv5tion :i* w give motion to e c\ntry on ! ,e>?2--to move ,ma*9]y6--! long s\ght 9 va9 ',p]petual ,motion'66--,i 0 support$ at ! "t by ! ,que5 & ,h4,r4,h4 ,pr9ce ,alb]t4 ,if1 ,g5tlem51 y c advise me h[ to proce$ to claim ! rew>d1 if any is (f]$ by ! ,gov]nm5t1 or h[ to secure ! ,,pat5t = ! ma*9e1 or 9 any way assi/ me by advice 9 ?is great "w1 ,i %all mo/ graci\sly ackn[l$ge y\r consid]ation4 ,^! are my convictions t my ,,sev]al discov]ies w be realiz$3 & ?is great "o c be at once act$ ^u3 al?\gh at ?is mom5t x only exi/s 9 my m9d1 f my k ( c]ta9 fix$ pr9ciples 9 nature3--! ,ma*9e ,i h n made1 z ,i only complet$ ! discov]y ,,ye/]day1 ,sunday6 ,i h1 etc4 ---- ---- ,to ! ,directors ( ! ,london ,univ]sity1 ,g[] ,/reet4 ,,on ,,spiritualism4 ,! ,div9e ,drama ( ,hi/ory & ,civilisation4 ,by ! ,rev4 ,james ,smi?1 ,m4,a4#ajh ,london1 #ahed1 #hvo4 ,i h sev]al books on t great p>adox ( our day1 ,spiritualism1 b ,i %all exclude all b ?ree4 ,! bibliography ( ?is subject is n[ v l>ge4 ,! "q is "o bo? ( evid5ce & speculation2--,are ! facts #ef true8 ,are !y caus$ by spirits8 ,^! ,i %all n ent] ^u3 ,i %all m]ely recomm5d ?is "w z t ( a spirituali/ :o does n ent] on ! subject1 :i* he takes = grant$1 b applies 8 d]iv$ views to ! hi/ory ( mank9d ) le>n+ & ?\ght4 ,mr4 ,smi? 0 a man ( a v peculi> turn ( ?9k+4 ,he 01 :5 alive1 ! editor1 or an editor1 ( ! ,family ,h]ald3 ,i say :5 alive1 to speak accord+ to k2 =1 if 8 own views be true1 he may h a h& 9 x /ill4 ,! answ]s to correspond5ts1 9 8 "t1 7 piquant & orig9al above any ,i ev] saw4 ,i ?9k a v readable book might be made out ( !m1 resembl+ ,guesses at ,tru?3 ! turn giv5 to an inquiry ab\t morals1 religion1 or socials1 is (t5 ( ! highe/ degree ( unexpect$ness2 ! poor qu]i/ w\ld f9d himself "r 9 a mo/ unpalatable way4 ,answ]s to correspond5ts1 9 newspap]s1 are v (t5 ! fag ends ( lit]ature4 ,i %all nev] =get ! foll[+4 ,a p]son 0 invit$ to "n a rule )\t exception1 if he c\ld3 he answ]$ ,a man mu/ be pres5t :5 he is %av$4 ,a lady--:at "r h ladies to decide que/ions ab\t %av+8--said ?is 0 n prop]ly a rule2 & ! oracle 0 consult$4 ,! editor agre$ ) ! lady2 he said t a man mu/ be pres5t :5 he is %av$ is n a rule1 b a fact4 ,among my anonym\s communicants is "o :o /ates t ,i h done inju/ice to ! ,rev4 ,james ,smi? 9 ref]r+ to him z a spirituali/1 & plac+ 8 ,div9e ,drama among p>adoxes3 x is no p>adox1 nor d spirituali/ic views m> or weak5 ! execution ( ! design4 ,q true3 = ! design is to produce & en=ce spirituali/ic views2 & lea!r does n m> nor weak5 a %oemak]'s plan4 ,i knew ,mr4 ,smi? well1 & h (t5 talk$ to him on ! subject3 b m te/imony f me is unnecess>y2 8 book w speak = itself4 #eg ,8 peculi> /yle w ju/ify a little m quotation ?an is j necess>y to prove ! po9t4 ,look+ at ! battle ( op9ion n[ 9 progress1 we see t ,mr4 ,smi? 0 a presci5t3 7,p4 #ehh47 ,f ! g5]al review ( p>ties 9 ,engl&1 x is evid5t t no c\ntry 9 ! _w is bett] prep>$ = ! great ,battle ( ,op9ion4 ,:]e else c ! battle be f\ght b :]e ! armies are array$8 ,& "h !y all are1 ,greek1 ,roman1 ,anglican1 ,scot*1 ,lu!ran1 ,calv9i/1 ,e/abli%$ & ,t]ritorial1 ) ,b>onial ,bi%ops1 & ,none/abli%$ ( e grade--*ur*es ) liv+ prophets & apo/les1 & *ur*es ) dead prophets & apo/les1 & apo/olical *ur*es )\t apo/les1 & philosophies )\t ei!r prophets or apo/les1 & only want+ "o m1 '! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1' l ,a>on's rod1 to swall[ up & dige/ !m all1 & !n bud & fl\ri%4 ,z if to prep>e our m9ds = ?is desirable & inevitable consummation1 diff]5t p>ties h be5 favor$ ) a revival ( t v _s ( revelation by :i* ! ,*ur* itself 0 orig9ally f\nd$4 ,!re is a complete s]ies ( spiritual revelations 9 ,engl& & ! ,unit$ ,/ates1 besides mesm]ic ph5om5a t be> a resemblance to revelation1 & ?us gradually op5 ! m9d ( ! philosophical & infidel classes1 z well z ! pr(ess$ believ]s ( t old revelation :i* !y nev] witness$ 9 liv+ action1 to a bett] und]/&+ ( t ,law ( ,nature 7= x is a ,law ( ,nature7 9 :i* all revelation orig9ates & by :i* its spiritual communications are regulat$4 ,mr4 ,smi? proce$s to say t !re are only ?irty-five incorporat$ *ur*es 9 ,engl&1 all =m$ f ! ,new ,te/am5t except five1 to ea* ( :i* five he conc$es a revelation ( its own4 ,! five are ! ,quak]s1 ! ,sw$5borgians1 ! ,s\?cottians1 ! ,irv+ites1 & ! ,mormonites4 ,( ,joanna ,s\?cott he speaks z foll[s3 #eh 7,p4 #eib47 ,joanna ,s\?cott#aji is n v gallantly treat$ by ! g5tlem5 ( ! ,press1 :o1 we believe1 )\t kn[+ any?+ ab\t h]1 m]ely pick up _! idea ( h] "* f ! rabble4 ,we once ent]ta9$ ! same rabble idea ( h]2 b hav+ read h] works--= we really h read !m--we n[ reg>d h] ) great respect4 ,h[ev]1 !re is a great abundance ( *aff & /raw to h] gra92 b ! gra9 is good1 & z we d n eat ei!r ! *aff or /raw if we c avoid x1 nor ev5 ! raw gra91 b ?ra% x & w9n[ x1 & gr9d x & bake x1 we f9d x1 aft] und]go+ ?is process1 n only v palatable1 b a special da9ty ( its k9d4 ,b ! husk is an insurm\ntable ob/acle to ^? le>n$ & educat$ g5tlem5 :o judge ( books entirely by ! /yle & ! gramm>1 or ^? :o eat gra9 z x gr[s1 l ! cattle4 ,su* m5 w\ld reject all prological revelation2 = !re nev] 0 & probably nev] w be a revelation by voice & vision communicat$ 9 classical mann]4 ,x w\ld be an invasion ( ! rights & pr]ogatives ( ,humanity1 & z contr>y to ! ,div9e & ,e/abli%$ ord] ( mundane gov]nm5t1 z a field ( qu>t]n loaves or hot ,fr5* rolls4 ,mr4 ,smi?'s book is spiritualism f beg9n+ to end2 & my anonym\s ga9say]1 hone/ ( c\rse1 is ei!r ignorant ( ! "w he ?9ks he has read1 or has a mo/ rem>kable developm5t ( ! organ ( imp]ception4 ,a ,,cond5s$ ,,hi/ory ,,( ,,ma!matics4 ,i cut ! foll[+ f a ,sunday pap] 9 #ahdi3 ,x4 ,y4--,! ,*aldeans began ! ma!matics1 9 :i* ! ,egyptians excell$4 ,!n cross+ ! sea1 by means #ei ( ,?ales1#aaj ! ,milesian1 !y came into ,greece1 :]e !y 7 improv$ v mu* by ,py?agoras1#aaa ,anaxagoras1#aab & ,anopides#aac ( ,*ios4 ,^! 7 foll[$ by ,briso1#aad ,antipho1 two circle-squ>]s2 :]e is ,euclid8 & ,hippocrates1#aae b ! excell5ce ( ! algebraic art 0 begun by ,geb]1#aaf an ,arabian a/ronom]1 & 0 c>ri$ on by ,c>danus1#aag ,t>taglia1#aah ,clavius1#aai1 ,/ev9us1#abj ,ghetaldus1#aba ,h]igenius1#abb ,fran4 ,van ,s*oot5 mean+ ,francis ,van ,s*oot5#abc1 ,florida de ,beaume1#abd etc4 ,bryso 0 a mi/ak5 man4 ,antipho _h ! disadvantage ( be+ 9 advance ( 8 age4 ,he _h ! notion ( :i* ! mod]n geometry has made s mu*1 t ( #fj a circle be+ ! polygon ( an inf9itely great numb] ( sides4 ,he c\ld make no use ( x1 b ! notion itself made him a sophi/ 9 ! eyes ( ,ari/otle1 ,eutocius1#abe etc4 ,geb]1 an ,arab a/ronom]1 & a reput$ conjur] 9 ,europe1 seems to h giv5 8 "n to un9telligible language 9 ! ^w gibb]i%4 ,at "o "t algebra 0 trac$ to him2 b v absurdly1 ?\gh ,i h he>d x sugge/$ t algebra & gibb]i% mu/ h _h "o inv5tor4 ,any p]son :o m$dles ) ! circle may f9d himself ! crane :o 0 nett$ among ! geese3 z ,antipho = "o1 & ,olivi] de ,s]res#abf = ano!r4 ,?is la/ g5tleman asc]ta9$1 by weigh+1 t ! area ( ! circle is v ne>ly t ( ! squ>e on ! side ( ! inscrib$ equilat]al triangle3 :i* x is1 z ne> z #c4afb 444 to #c4ada4444 ,he did n pret5d to m ?an approximation2 b ,montucla & o!rs misund]/ood him1 &1 /ill worse1 misund]/ood _! own misund]/&+1 & made him say ! circle 0 exactly d\ble ( ! equilat]al triangle4 ,he 0 let out ( limbo by ,lacroix1 9 a note to 8 edition ( ,montucla's ,hi/ory ( ,quadrature4 ,,/4 ,,vitus1 ,,patron ,,( ,,cyclomet]s4 ,quadratura del c]*io1 trisezione dell' angulo1 et duplicazione del cubo1 problemi geometricam5te risolute e dimo/rate dal ,rev]5do ,arciprete di ,san ,vito ,d4 ,dom5ico ,angh]a1#abg ,malta1 #ahed1 #hvo4 #fa ,equazioni geometri*e1 e/ratte dalla lett]a del ,rev4 ,arciprete 444 al ,pr(essore ,pullic9o#abh sulla quadratura del c]*io4 ,milan1 #ahee or #ahef1 #hvo4 ,il ,m$it]raneo gazetta di ,malta1 #bf ,decembre #ahee1 ,no4 #iji3 also #iaa1 #iab1 #iac1 #iad1 #icf1 #ici4 ,! ,malta ,times1 ,tuesday1 #i? ,june #aheg4 ,misura esatta del c]*io1 dal ,rev4 ,d4 ,angh]a4 ,malta1 #aheg1 #abmo4 ,quadrature ( ! circle 444 by ! ,rev4 ,d4 ,angh]a1 ,ar*prie/ ( ,/4 ,vito4 ,malta1 #aheh1 #abmo4 ,i h look$ = ,/4 ,vitus 9 catalogues ( sa9ts1 b nev] f\nd 8 leg5d1 ?\gh he figures z a day-m>k 9 ! olde/ almanacs4 ,he mu/ be prop]ly accr$it$1 s9ce he 0 an ar*prie/4 ,& ,i pron\nce & orda91 by "r accru+ f ! tr\ble ,i h tak5 9 ?is subject1 t he1 ,/4 ,vitus1 :o leads 8 vot>ies a nev]-end+ & unmean+ dance1 %all h5ce=? be held & tak5 to be ! patron sa9t ( ! circle-squ>]4 ,8 day is ! #ae? ( ,june1 :i* is also t ( ,/4 ,mode/us1#abi ) :om ! said circle-squ>] (t5 has no?+ to d4 ,& he mu/ n put himself "u ! fir/ sa9t ) a slant5dicul> ref]5ce to ! o!r1 z is mu* to be fe>$ 0 done by ! ,c>d9al :o came to gov]n ,engl& ) a title conta9+ ,/4 ,pud5tiana1#acj :o %>es a day ) ,/4 ,dun/an4 ,! ,ar*prie/ ( ,/4 ,vitus w h x t ! squ>e inscrib$ 9 a semicircle is half ( ! semicircle1 or ! circumf]5ce #c-a_/e diamet]s4 ,he is active & able1 ) #fb no?+ wrong ab\t him except 8 p>adoxes4 ,9 ! second tract nam$ he has giv5 ! te/imonials ( cr[n$ heads & m9i/]s1 etc4 z foll[s4 ,l\is-,napoleon gives ?anks4 ,! m9i/] at ,tur9 ref]s x to ! ,academy ( ,sci5ces1 & hopes s mu* labor w be judg$ degna di pregio4#aca ,! ,vice-,*ancellor ( ,ox=d--a blunt ,engli%man--begs to say t ! ,univ]sity has nev] propos$ ! problem1 z "s affirm4 ,! ,pr9ce ,reg5t ( ,bad5 has receiv$ ! "w ) lively int]e/4 ,! ,academy ( ,vi5na is n 9 a position to ent] into ! "q4 ,! ,academy ( ,tur9 (f]s ! mo/ di/9ct ?anks4 ,! ,academy della ,crusca att5ds only to lit]ature1 b gives ?anks4 ,! ,que5 ( ,spa9 has receiv$ ! "w ) ! highe/ appreciation4 ,! ,univ]sity ( ,salamanca gives inf9ite ?anks1 & feels true satisfaction 9 hav+ ! book4 ,"l ,palm]/on gives ?anks1 by ! h& ( ,william ,san4 ,! ,vic]oy ( ,egypt1 n be+ yet up 9 ,italian1 w sp5d 8 fir/ mom5ts ( leisure 9 /udy+ ! book1 :5 x %all h be5 translat$ into ,fr5*3 9 ! mean "t he congratulates ! au?or ^u 8 victory ov] a problem s long held insoluble4 ,all ?is is s]i\sly publi%$ z a rate 9 aid ( demon/ration4 ,if ^! royal complim5ts _c make ! circumf]5ce ( a circle ab\t #b p] c5t4 l>g] ?an geometry w h x --:i* is all t is want$--no wond] t ?rones are %aky4 ,i am in=m$ t ! leg5d ( ,/4 ,vitus is giv5 by ,ribad5eira#acb 9 8 lives ( ,sa9ts1 & t ,b>onius1#acc 9 #fc 8 ,m>tyrologium ,romanum1 ref]s to sev]al au?ors :o h writt5 conc]n+ him4 ,!re is an acc\nt 9 ,mrs4 ,jameson's#acd ,hi/ory ( ,sacr$ & ,leg5d>y ,art 7ed4 ( #ahfc1 p4 #edd74 ,b x seems t ,/4 ,vitus is ! patron sa9t ( all dances2 s t ,i 0 n s f> wrong 9 mak+ him ! protector ( ! cyclomet]s4 ,:y he is repres5t$ ) a cock is a disput$ po9t1 :i* is n[ made cle>3 next aft] gallus gall9aceus#ace himself1 !re is no cr[] l ! circle-squ>]4 ,,celebrat$ ,,approximations ,,( pi4 ,! foll[+ is an extract f ! ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia1 ,art4 ,,tables3 #ahec4 ,william ,%anks1#acf ,contributions to ,ma!matics1 compris+ *iefly ! ,rectification ( ! ,circle to #fjg ,places ( ,tables1 ,london1 #ahec4 7,,quadrature ,,( ,,! ,,circle47 ,"h is a table1 because x tabulates ! results ( ! subord9ate /eps ( ?is enorm\s calculation z f> z #ebg decimals3 ! rema9d] be+ add$ z results only dur+ ! pr9t+4 ,= in/ance1 "o /ep is ! calculation ( ! reciprocal ( #fja4efja2 & ! result is giv54 ,! numb] ( pages requir$ to describe ^! results is #hg4 ,mr4 ,%anks has also ?r[n (f1 z *ips or spl9t]s1 ! values ( ! base ( ,napi]'s log>i?ms1 & ( its log>i?ms ( #b1 #c1 #e1 #aj1 to #acg decimals2 & ! value ( ! modulus 4#dcdb 444 to #acf decimals3 ) ! #ac?1 #be?1 #cg? 444 up to ! #gba/ p[]s ( #b4 ,^! trem5d\s /ret*es ( calculation--at lea/ we s call !m 9 our day--are useful 9 sev]al respects2 !y prove m ?an #fd ! capacity ( ?is or t comput] = labor & accuracy2 !y %[ t !re is 9 ! community an increase ( skill & c\rage4 ,we say 9 ! community3 we fully believe t ! unequall$ turnip :i* e n[ & !n appe>s 9 ! newspap]s is a suffici5t presumption t ! av]age turnip is gr[+ bigg]1 & ! :ole crop heavi]4 ,all :o "k ! hi/ory ( ! quadrature are aw>e t ! sev]al increases ( numb]s ( decimals to :i* pi has be5 c>ri$ h be5 indications ( a g5]al increase 9 ! p[] to calculate1 & 9 c\rage to face ! labor4 ,"h is a comp>ison ( two diff]5t times4 ,9 ! day ( ,cock]1#acg ! pupil 0 direct$ to p]=m a common subtraction ) a voice-accompanim5t ( ?is k9d3 '#g f #d ,i _c1 b add #aj1 #g f #ad rema9s #g1 set d[n #g & c>ry #a2 #h & #a :i* ,i c>ry is #i1 #i f #b ,i _c1 etc4' ,we h be=e u ! ann\ncem5t ( ! foll[+ table1 undat$1 z op5 to inspection at ! ,cry/al ,palace1 ,syd5ham1 9 two diagrams ( #g ft4 #b 91 by #f ft4 #f 943 ',! figure #i involv$ into ! #iab? p[]1 & antec$5t p[]s or involutions1 conta9+ upw>ds ( #gc1jjj figures4 ,also1 ! pro(s ( ! above1 conta9+ upw>ds ( #adf1jjj figures4 ,by ,samuel ,fanc\rt1 ( ,m9c+ ,lane1 ,london1 & complet$ by him 9 ! ye> #ahcg1 at ! age ( sixte54 ,n4,b4 ,! :ole op]ation p]=m$ by simple ari?metic4' ,! "y op]ator calculat$ by successive squ>+ ! #b;d1 #d?1 #h?1 etc41 p[]s up to ! #eab?1 ) pro( by division4 ,b #eaa multiplications by #i1 9 ! %ort 7or #aj-a7 way1 w\ld h be5 mu* easi]4 ,! #b;d1 #cb;d1 #fd?1 #abh?1 #bef?1 & #eab? p[]s are giv5 at ! back ( ! ann\ncem5t4 ,! p[]s ( #b h be5 calculat$ = _m purposes4 ,9 ,vol4 ,,ii ( 8 ,magia ,univ]salis ,naturae et ,artis1 ,h]bipoli1 #afeh1 #dto1 ! ,jesuit ,gasp> ,s*ott#ach hav+ discov]$1 on "s gr\nds ( !ological #fe magic1 t ! degrees ( grace ( ! ,virg9 ,m>y 7 9 numb] ! #bef? p[] ( #b1 calculat$ t numb]4 ,:e!r or no 8 numb] correctly repres5t$ ! result he ann\nc$1 he c]ta9ly calculat$ x rightly1 z we f9d by comp>ison ) ,mr4 ,%anks4 ,!re is a po9t ab\t ,mr4 ,%anks's #fjh figures ( ! value ( pi :i* attracts att5tion1 p]haps )\t des]v+ x4 ,x might be expect$ t1 9 s _m figures1 ! n9e digits & ! ciph] w\ld occur ea* ab\t ! same numb] ( times2 t is1 ea* ab\t #fa times4 ,b ! fact /&s ?us3 #c occurs #fh times2 #i & #b occur #fg times ea*2 #d occurs #fd times2 #a & #f occur #fb times ea*2 #j occurs #fj times2 #h occurs #eh times2 #e occurs #ef times2 & #g occurs only #dd times4 ,n[1 if all ! digits 7 equally likely1 & #fjh draw+s 7 made1 x is #de to #a aga9/ ! numb] ( sev5s be+ z di/ant f ! probable av]age 7say #fa7 z #dd on "o side or #gh on ! o!r4 ,!re mu/ be "s reason :y ! numb] #g is ?us depriv$ ( its fair %>e 9 ! /ructure4 ,"h is a field ( speculation 9 :i* two bran*es ( inquir]s might unite4 ,!re is b "o numb] :i* is treat$ ) an unfairness :i* is incr$ible z an accid5t2 & t numb] is ! my/ic numb] sev56 ,if ! cyclomet]s & ! apocalyptics w\ld lay _! heads toge!r until !y come to a unanim\s v]dict on ?is ph5om5on1 & w\ld publi% no?+ until !y are ( "o m9d1 !y w\ld e>n ! gratitude ( _! race4--,i 0 wrong3 x is ! ,pyramid-speculator :o %\ld h be5 appeal$ to4 ,a correspond5t ( my fri5d ,pr(4 ,piazzi ,smy?#aci notices t #c is ! numb] ( mo/ frequ5cy1 & t #c-a_/g is ! ne>e/ approximation to x 9 simple digits4 ,pr(essor ,smy? himself1 ^: ^w on ,egypt is p>adox ( a v high ord]1 back$ by a great quantity ( useful labor1 ! results :i* w be made available by ^? :o d n receive #ff ! p>adoxes1 is incl9$ to see confirmation = "s ( 8 !ory 9 ^! ph5om5a4 ,,curi\s ,,calculations4 ,^! p>adoxes ( calculation sometimes appe> z illu/rations ( ! value ( a new me?od4 ,9 #ahfc1 ,mr4 ,g4 ,suffield1#adj ,m4,a41 & ,mr4 ,j4 ,r4 ,lunn1#ada ,m4,a41 ( ,cl>e ,college & ( ,/4 ,john's ,college1 ,cambridge1 publi%$ ! :ole quoti5t ( #ajjjj 444 divid$ by #gfii1 ?r\gh\t ! :ole ( "o ( ! recurr+ p]iods1 hav+ #gfih digits4 ,?is 0 done 9 illu/ration ( ,mr4 ,suffield's me?od ( ,syn!tic division4 ,ano!r in/ance ( computation c>ri$ to p>adoxical l5g?1 9 ord] to illu/rate a me?od1 is ! solution ( x#c - #bx #e1 ! example giv5 ( ,newton's me?od1 on :i* all improvem5ts h be5 te/$4 ,9 #ahca1 ,f\ri]'s#adb po/hum\s "w on equations %[$ #cc figures ( solution1 got ) enorm\s labor4 ,?9k+ ?is a good opportunity to illu/rate ! sup]iority ( ! me?od ( ,w4 ,g4 ,horn]1#adc n yet kn[n 9 ,france1 & n mu* kn[n 9 #fg ,engl&1 ,i propos$ to "o ( my classes1 9 #ahda1 to beat ,f\ri] on ?is po9t1 z a ,*ri/mas ex]cise4 ,i receiv$ sev]al answ]s1 agree+ ) ea* o!r1 to #ej places ( decimals4 ,9 #ahdh1 ,i repeat$ ! proposal1 reque/+ t #ej places might be exce$$3 ,i obta9$ answ]s ( #ge1 #fe1 #fc1 #eh1 #eg1 & #eb places4 ,b "o answ]1 by ,mr4 ,w4 ,h>ris ,john/on1#add ( ,dundalk1 & ( ! ,excise ,(fice1 w5t to #aja decimal places4 ,to te/ ! accuracy ( ?is1 ,i reque/$ ,mr4 ,john/on to und]take ano!r equation1 connect$ ) ! =m] "o 9 a way :i* ,i did n expla94 ,8 solution v]ifi$ ! =m] "o1 b he 0 unable to see ! connection1 ev5 :5 8 result 0 obta9$4 ,my read] may be z mu* at a loss3 ! two solutions are3 #b4jideeadhaedbcbfe444 #i4jeddheahdegfgcdj444 ,! results are publi%$ 9 ! ,ma!matician1 ,vol4 ,,iii1 p4 #bij4 ,9 #ahea1 ano!r pupil ( m9e1 ,mr4 ,j4 ,p[] ,hicks1#ade c>ri$ ! result to #aeb decimal places1 )\t kn[+ :at ,mr4 ,john/on _h done4 ,! result is 9 ! ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia1 article ,,involution ,,& ,,evolution4 ,i rem>k t :5 ,i write ! initial ( a ,*ri/ian "n1 ! mo/ usual "n ( t initial is und]/ood4 ,i nev] saw ! "n ( ,w4 ,g4 ,horn] writt5 at l5g?1 until ,i appli$ to a relative ( 81 :o told me t he 01 z ,i suppos$1 ,wm4 ,george1 b t he 0 nam$ aft] a relative ( t surname4 ,! squ>e root ( #b1 to #aaj decimal places1 0 giv5 #fh me 9 #aheb by my pupil1 ,mr4 ,william ,h5ry ,colvill1 n[ 7#ahfg7 ,civil ,surgeon at ,baghdad4 ,x 0 #a4dadbacefbcgcjiejdhhjafhhgbdbjifihjghe fif #gahgecgfidhjgcagffgigcgiijgcbdghdfbajgj c #hhejchgecdcbgfdaegbgcejachdfbc ,mr4 ,james ,/eel#adf ( ,birk5head v]ifi$ ?is by actual multiplication1 & produc$ #b - #behjdac _/ #ajaag z ! squ>e4 ,calcolo decidozz9ale del ,b>one ,silvio ,f]r>i4 ,tur91 #ahed1 #dto4 ,?is is a s]i\s proposal to alt] our num]al sy/em & to c\nt by twelves4 ,?us #aj w\ld be twelve1 #aa ?irte51 etc41 two new symbols be+ inv5t$ = t5 & elev54 ,! names ( numb]s mu/ ( c\rse be *ang$4 ,!re are p]sons :o ?9k su* *anges practicable4 ,i ?\ght ?is proposal absurd :5 ,i fir/ saw x1 & ,i ?9k s /ill3#adg b ! "o ,i %all pres5tly describe beats x s completely 9 t po9t1 t ,i h n a smile left = ?is "o4 ,,on ,,comets4 ,! successful & !re=e probably true !ory ( ,comets4 ,london1 #ahed4 7#dpp4 duodecimo47 ,! au?or is ! late ,mr4 ,pet] ,legh1#adh ( ,norbury ,boo?s ,hall1 ,knuts=d1 :o publi%$ = eight or t5 #fi ye>s ! ,ombrological ,almanac1 a "w ( ass]t$ discov]y 9 meteorology4 ,! !ory ( comets is t ! jo9t attraction ( ! new moon & sev]al planets 9 ! direction ( ! sun1 draws (f ! gases f ! e>?1 & =ms ^! cometic meteors4 ,b h[ ^! meteors come to describe orbits r\nd ! sun1 & to become capable ( hav+ _! returns pr$ict$1 is n expla9$4 ,a ,,new ,,phase ,,( ,,mormonism4 ,! ,mormon1 ,new ,york1 ,saturday1 ,oct4 #bg1 #ahee4 ,a newspap] head$ by a gr& picture ( />r$ & /rip$ bann]s1 beehive1 & eagle surm\nt+ x4 ,a scroll on ea* side3 on ! left1 ,mormon cre$4 ,m9d y\r own bus9ess4 ,brigham ,"y2#adi on ! "r1 ,giv5 by inspiration ( ,god4 ,joseph ,smi?4#aej ,a lead+ article on ! discov]ies ( ,pr(4 ,orson ,pratt#aea says1 ,mormonism has long tak5 ! lead 9 religion3 x w soon be 9 ! van bo? 9 sci5ce & politics4 ,at ! beg9n+ ( ! pap] is ,pr(essor ,pratt's ,law ( ,planet>y ,rotation4 ,! cube roots ( ! d5sities ( ! planets are z ! squ>e roots ( _! p]iods ( rotation4 ,! squ>es ( ! cube roots ( ! masses divid$ by ! squ>es ( ! diamet]s are z ! p]iods ( rotation4 ,ari?metical v]ification attempt$1 & ! :ole v mode/ly /at$ #gj & comm5t$ on4 ,dat$ ,g4 ,s4 ,l4 ,city1 ,utah ,t]41 ,aug4 #a1 #ahee4 ,if ! cre$1 z above1 be correctly giv51 no wond] ! ,mormonites are 9 su* bad odor4 ,,ma!matical ,,illu/rations ,,( ,,doctr9e4 ,! two e/ates2 or bo? worlds ma!matically consid]$4 ,london1 #ahee1 small 7pp4 #af74 ,! au?or has publi%$ ma!matical works ) 8 "n4 ,! pres5t tract is int5d$ to illu/rate ma!matically a po9t :i* may be guess$ f ! title4 ,b ! symbols d v little 9 ! way ( illu/ration3 ?us1 x be+ ! pres5t value ( ! future e/ate 7et]nal happ9ess71 & a ( all t ?is _w c give1 ! au?or impresses x on ! ma!matician t1 x be+ inf9itely great] ?an a1 x a x1 s t a ne$ n be consid]$4 ,?is w n act mu* m p[]fully on a ma!matician by virtue ( ! symbols ?an if ^? same symbols _h be5 disp5s$ )3 ev5 ?\gh1 z ! au?or adds1 ,x 0 ?is me?od ( neglect+ inf9itely small quantities t ,sir ,isaac ,newton 0 indebt$ to = 8 greate/ discov]ies4 ,!re has be5 a mod]ate quantity ( well-meant attempt to en=ce1 sometimes motive1 sometimes doctr9e1 by argum5ts drawn f ma!matics1 ! propon5ts be+ p]sons unskill$ 9 t sci5ce = ! mo/ "p4 ,! gr\nd is v dang]\s3 = ! illu/ration (t5 turns ! o!r way ) great] p[]1 9 a mann] :i* requires only a little m k to see4 ,i h1 9 my life1 he>d f ! pulpit or read1 at lea/ a doz5 times1 t all s9 is inf9itely great1 prov$ z foll[s4 ,! great] ! be+1 ! great] ! s9 ( any (f5ce aga9/ him3 !re=e ! (f5ce committ$ aga9/ an inf9ite be+ is inf9itely great4 ,n[ ! ma!matician1 ( :i* ! propos]s ( ?is argum5t are n aw>e1 is p]fectly famili> ) quantities :i* increase toge!r1 & nev] cease increas+1 b s t "o ( !m rema9s f9ite :5 #ga ! o!r becomes inf9ite4 ,9 fact1 ! argum5t is a p]fect non sequitur4#aeb ,^? :o propose x h 9 _! m9ds1 ?\gh 9 a cl\dy & indef9ite =m1 ! idea ( ! increase ( guilt be+ proportionate to ! increase ( greatness 9 ! be+ (f5d$4 ,b ?is x w\ld nev] d to /ate3 = by su* /atem5t n only w\ld ! argum5t lose all t x has ( ! picturesque1 b ! ass]t$ premise w\ld h no /rong air ( exact tru?4 ,h[ c\ld any "o und]take to appeal to consci5ce to decl>e t an (f5ce aga9/ a be+ #d-g_/aj times z great z ano!r is exactly1 no m & no less1 #d-g_/aj times z great an (f5ce aga9/ ! o!r8 ,! inf9ite "* ( ! (f5ce aga9/ an inf9ite be+ is laid d[n 9 ,dryd5's ,religio ,laici1#aec & is1 no d\bt1 an old argum5t3 ,=1 grant+ we h s9n$1 & t ?' (f5ce ,( man is made aga9/ ,omnipot5ce1 ,"s price t be>s proportion mu/ be paid1 ,& inf9ite ) inf9ite be weigh$4 ,see !n ! ,dei/ lo/2 remorse = vice ,n paid2 or1 paid1 inadequate 9 price4 ,dryd51 9 ! words be>s proportion is 9 v]se m accurate ?an mo/ ( ! rec5t repeat]s 9 prose4 ,& ?is is n ! only case ( ! k9d 9 8 argum5tative poetry4 ,my old fri5d1 ! late ,dr4 ,ol9?us ,gregory1#aed :o 0 a s\nd & le>n$ ma!matician1 adopt$ ?is dang]\s k9d ( illu/ration 9 8 ,lett]s on ! ,*ri/ian ,religion4 #gb ,he argu$1 by p>allel1 f :at he suppos$ to be ! necess>ily my/]i\s nature ( ! impossible quantity ( algebra to ! necess>ily my/]i\s nature ( c]ta9 doctr9es ( 8 sy/em ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,b all ! difficulty & my/]y ( ! impossible quantity is n[ cle>$ away by ! advance ( algebraical ?\ght3 & yet ,dr4 ,gregory's book cont9ues to be sold1 & no d\bt ! illu/ration is /ill accept$ z appropriate4 ,! mode ( argum5t us$ by ! au?or ( ! tract above nam$ has a /rik+ defect4 ,he talks ( r$uc+ ?is _w & ! next to pres5t value1 z an actu>y does ) successive lives or next pres5tations4 ,does value make int]e/8 & if n1 :y8 ,& if x d1 !n ! pres5t value ( an et]nity is n inf9itely great4 ,:o is ignorant t a p]petual annuity at five p] c5t is wor? only tw5ty ye>s' pur*ase8 ,?is po9t ought to be discuss$ by a p]son :o treats heav5 z a def]r$ p]petual annuity4 ,i d n ask him to d s1 & w\ld r he did n2 b if he w d x1 he mu/ ei!r deal ) ! "q ( disc\nt1 or be ask$ ! reason :y4 ,:5 a v "y man1 ,i 0 frequ5tly exhort$ to "o or ano!r view ( religion by pa/ors & o!rs :o ?\ght t a ma!matical argum5t w\ld be irresi/ible4 ,& ,i he>d ! foll[+ m ?an once1 & h s9ce se5 x 9 pr9t1 ,i =get :]e4 ,s9ce et]nal happ9ess belong$ to ! p>ticul> views 9 "q1 a b5efit inf9itely great1 !n1 ev5 if ! probability ( _! argum5ts 7 small1 or ev5 inf9itely small1 yet ! product ( ! *ance & b5efit1 accord+ to ! usual rule1 might give a result :i* no "o ought 9 prud5ce to pass ov]4 ,!y did n see t ?is appli$ to all sy/ems z well z _! own4 ,i take ?is argum5t to be ! mo/ p]v]se ( all ! p]v]sions ,i h he>d or read on ! subject3 !re is "s high au?ority = x1 :om ,i =get4 ,! moral ( all ?is is1 t su* ?+s z ! prec$+ %\ld be kept out ( ! way ( ^? :o are n #gc ma!maticians1 because !y d n und]/& ! argum5t2 & ( ^? :o are1 because !y d4 ,! high au?ority ref]r$ to above is ,pascal1 an e>ly cultivator ( ma!matical probability1 & obvi\sly too mu* enam\r$ ( 8 new pursuit4 ,b he conceives himself b\nd to wag] on "o side or ! o!r4 ,to ! argum5t 7,p5sees1 *4 #g7aee t le ju/e e/ de ne po9t p>i]1 he answ]s1 ,oui3 mais il faut p>i]3 v\s etes emb>que2 et ne p>i] po9t que ,dieu e/1 c'e/ p>i] qu'il n'e/ pas4#aef ,leav+ ,pascal's argum5t to make its way ) a p]son :o1 be+ a sceptic1 is yet positive t ! issue is salvation or p]dition1 if a ,god !re be1--= ! case z put by ,pascal requires ?is1--,i %all m]ely obs]ve t a p]son :o elects to believe 9 ,god1 z ! be/ *ance ( ga91 is n "o :o1 accord+ to ,pascal's cre$1 or any o!r wor? nam+1 w really secure t ga94 ,i wond] :e!r ,pascal's curi\s imag9ation ev] pres5t$ to him 9 sleep 8 conv]t1 9 ! future /ate1 %ak5 out ( a r$-hot dice-box ^u a r$-hot haz>d-table1 z p]haps he might h be51 if ,dante _h be5 ! lat] ( ! two4 ,! orig9al idea is due to ! eld] ,arnobius1#aeg :o1 z cit$ by ,bayle1#aeh speaks ?us3 ,s$ et ipse ,*ri/us quae pollicetur1 non probat4 ,ita e/4 ,nulla enim1 ut dixi1 futurorum pote/ exi/]e comprobatio4 ,cum ergo haec sit conditio futurorum1 ut t5]i et compreh5di nullius poss9t anticipationis attactu2 nonne #gd purior ratio e/1 ex duobus inc]tis1 et 9 ambigua expectatione p5d5tibus1 id potius cr$]e1 quod aliquas spes f]at1 quam omn9o quod nullas8 ,9 illo enim p]iculi nihil e/1 si quod dicitur imm9]e1 cassum fiat et vacuum3 9 hoc damnum e/ maximum1 id e/ salutis amissio1 si cum tempus adv5]it ap]iatur non fuisse m5dacium4#aei ,really ,arnobius seems to h got z mu* out ( ! notion1 9 ! ?ird c5tury1 z if he _h be5 f\rte5 c5turies lat]1 ) ! ari?metic ( *ances to help him4 ,,novum ,,organum ,,moralium4 ,! ,s5t9el1 vol4 ix4 no4 #bg4 ,london1 ,saturday1 ,may #bf1 #ahee4 ,?is is ! fir/ ,london numb] ( an ,iri% pap]1 ,prote/ant 9 politics4 ,x op5s ) ,sugge/ions on ! subject ( a ,novum ,organum ,moralium1 :i* is ! application ( algebra & ! diff]5tial calculus to morals1 socials1 & politics4 ,!re is also a lead+ article on ! subject1 & "s applications 9 notes to o!r articles4 ,a sep>ate publication 0 aft]w>ds made1 ) ! addition ( a long ,preface2 ! au?or be+ a cl]gyman :o ,i presume mu/ h be5 ! editor ( ! ,s5t9el4 ,sugge/ions z to ! employm5t ( a ,novum ,organum ,moralium4 ,or1 ?\ghts on ! nature ( ! ,diff]5tial ,calculus1 & on ! application ( its pr9ciples to metaphysics1 ) a view to ! atta9m5t ( demon/ration & c]ta9ty 9 moral1 #ge political & ecclesia/ical affairs4 ,by ,tre%am ,dames ,gregg1#afj ,*apla9 ( ,/4 ,m>y's1 )9 ! *ur* ( ,/4 ,ni*olas intra muros1 ,dubl94 ,london1 #ahei1 #hvo4 7pp4 xl #cb74 ,i h a p]sonal int]e/ 9 ?is sy/em1 z w appe> f ! foll[+ extract f ! newspap]3 ,we 7 subsequ5tly ref]r$ to ,de ,morgan's ,=mal ,logic & ,boole's ,laws ( ,?\ght#afa bo? v elaborate works1 & greatly 9 ! direction tak5 by ourselves4 ,t ! writ]s amaz+ly surpass u 9 le>n+ we mo/ will+ly admit1 b we v5ture to pron\nce ( bo? _! le>n$ treatises1 t !y deal ) ! subject 9 a mode t is s*ola/ic to an excess4444 ,t _! works h be5 = a consid]able space ( "t be=e ! _w & effect$ no?+1 w\ld argue t !y h ov]look$ ! vital nature ( ! !me4444 ,on ! :ole1 ! writ+s ( ,de ,morgan & ,boole g to ! full ju/ification ( our pr9ciple )\t 9 any wise s tr5*+ ^u our gr\nd z to r5d] u op5 to reproa* 9 claim+ our ,calculus z a great discov]y4444 ,b we r5\nce any paltry jeal\sy z to a matt] s va/4 ,if ,de ,morgan & ,boole h _h a priority 9 ! case1 to !m we *e]fully %all resign ! glory & honor4 ,if su* be ! tru?1 !y h nei!r done ju/ice to ! discov]y1 nor to !mselves q true4 ,!y h1 "u ! circum/ances1 act$ l '! fooli% man1 :o roa/e? n t :i* he take? #gf 9 hunt+4444 ,x w be suffici5t = u1 h[ev]1 to be ! ,columbus ( ^! great ,am]ici1 & popul>ize :at !y f\nd1 if !y f\nd x4 ,we1 z f ! m\nta9 top1 w !n become _! trumpet]s1 & cry glory to ,de ,morgan & glory to ,boole1 "u ,him :o is ! s\rce ( all glory1 ! only good & wise1 to ,:om be glory = ev]6 ,if !y be our pr$ecessors 9 ?is matt]1 !y h1 "u ,him1 tak5 moral que/ions out ( ! category ( probabilities1 & r5d]$ !m p]fectly c]ta94 ,9 t case1 let _! books be read by ^? :o may d\bt ! pr9ciples ?is day laid be=e ! _w z a great discov]y1 by our newspap]4 ,our cry %all be ,greek3 eurekasi6#afb ,let u hope t !y w jo9 u1 & h5ce=? keep _! light sic f "u _! bu%el4 ,= myself1 & = my old fri5d ,mr4 ,boole1 :o ,i am sure w\ld jo9 me1 ,i disclaim bo? priority1 simultaneity1 & po/]iority1 & reque/ t no?+ may be trumpet$ f ! m\nta9 top except our abjuration ( all community ( ?\ght or op]ation ) ?is ,novum ,organum4 ,to su* community we c make no m claim ?an ,am]icus c\ld make to be+ ! =]unn] ( ,columbus :o popul>iz$ 8 discov]ies4 ,we d n wi% = any ,greek3 eurekasi & n ev5 = ,greek3 heurekasi4 ,= self & ,boole1 ,i po9t out :at w\ld h conv9c$ ei!r ( u t ?is h\se is divid$ aga9/ itself4 ,alpha be+ an apo/olic elem5t1 delta ! doctr9al elem5t1 & ,*i ! body ( ! fai?ful1 ! *ur* is ,alpha delta ,*i1 we are told4 ,also1 t if ,alpha become negative1 or ! ,apo/olicity become ,diabolicity my words2 or if delta become negative1 & doctr9e become h]esy2 or if ,*i become negative1 t is1 if ! fai?ful become unfai?ful2 ! *ur* becomes negative1 ! v opposite to :at x ought to be4 ,= self & ,boole1 ,i admit ?is4 ,b--:i* is n notic$--if ,alpha & delta %\ld bo? become negative1 diabolical orig9 #gg & h]etical doctr9e1 !n ! *ur*1 ,alpha delta ,*i1 is /ill positive1 :at x ought to be1 unless ,*i be also negative1 or ! p unfai?ful to x1 9 :i* case x is a bad *ur*4 ,n[1 self & ,boole--?\gh ,i admit ,i h n ask$ my p>tn]--are ( op9ion t a diabolical *ur* ) false doctr9e does h>m :5 ! p are fai?ful1 & c d good only :5 ! p are unfai?ful4 ,we may be wrong1 b ?is is :at we d ?9k4 ,accord+ly1 we h caught no?+1 & c !re=e roa/ no?+ ( our own3 ,i cont5t myself ) roa/+ a jo9t ( ,mr4 ,gregg's l>d]4 ,^! ma!matical vag>ies h uses :i* w ju/ify a l>ge am\nt ( quotation3 & 9 a score ( ye>s ?is may p]haps be ! only atta9able record4 ,i !re=e proce$4 ,aft] obs]v+ t by ?is calculus juries 7heav5 help !m6 say ,i7 c calculate damages almo/ to a nicety1 & fur!r t x is made abundantly evid5t t c e x is ! g5]al expression = an individual1 x is not$ t ! numb] ( ! ,bea/ is n giv5 9 ! ,revelation 9 words at l5g?1 b z ,greek3 *xw'4#afc ,on ?is ! foll[+ rem>k is made3 ,c x be possible t we h 9 ?is case a specim5 giv5 to u ( ! ari?metic ( heav51 & an expression reveal$1 :i* indicates by its function ( addibility1 ! "n ( ! *ur* 9 "q1 & ( ea* memb] ( x2 & by its function ( multiplicability ! doctr9e1 ! mission1 & ! memb]s ( ! great ,synagogue ( ,apo/acy8 ,we m]ely prop\nd ^! que/ions2--we d n pret5d to solve !m4 ,aft] a translation 9 blank v]se--a v pretty "o--( ! #ah? ,psalm1 ! au?or proce$s z foll[s1 to r5d] x into diff]5tial calculus3 #gh ,& ! :ole tells u j ?is1 t ,david did :at he c\ld4 ,he augm5t$ ^? elem5ts ( 8 con/itution :i* 7 7exceptis excipi5dis7#afd subject to himself1 & ! ,almighty !n augm5t$ 8 p]sonal qualities1 & 8 vocational /atus4 ,o!rwise1 to ?r[ ! matt] into ! expression ( our notation1 ! v>iable e 0 augm5t$1 & c x rose proportionally4 ,! law ( ! v>iation1 accord+ to our !ory1 w\ld be ?us express$4 ,! resultant 0 ,david ! k+ c e x c r8 7:o _h be5 ,david ! %eph]d boy71 & f ! conditions ( ! !orem we h du_/de ce7dx_/de7 ex7dc_/de7x cx :i*1 9 ! t]ms ( ord9>y language1 j means1 ! increase ( ,david's educational excell5ce or qualities--8 piety1 8 pray]fulness1 8 humility1 ob$i5ce1 etc4--0 s great1 t :5 multipli$ by 8 orig9al tal5t & position1 x produc$ a product s great z to be equal 9 its am\nt to royalty1 honor1 weal?1 & p[]1 etc43 9 %ort1 to all ! attributes ( maje/y4#afe ,! solution ( ! family problem is ( high int]e/4 ,x is to det]m9e ! effect on ! family 9 g5]al f a *ange ( conduct 9 "o ( !m4 ,! p]son *os5 is "o ( ! maid-s]vants4 ,let c e x be ! fa!r2 c#a;e#ax#a ! "m1 etc4 ,! family !n consi/s ( ! maid's ma/]1 h] mi/ress1 h] "y ma/]1 h] "y mi/ress1 & fell[ s]vant4 ,n[ ! ma/]'s call+ 7or c7 is to ex]cise 8 %>e ( control ov] ?is s]vant1 & m9d ! re/ ( 8 bus9ess3 call ?is rema9d] a1 & let 8 call+ g5]ally1 or all 8 affairs1 be to 8 maid-s]vant z m 3 y1 i4e41 y 7mz_/c72 444 #gi & ?is expression w repres5t 8 relation to ! s]vant4 ,consequ5tly1 c e x 7a mz_/c7e x2 o!rwise 7a mz_/c7e x is ! expression = ! fa!r :5 view$ z ! girl's ma/]4 ,i h no objection to repeat s f>2 b ,i w n give ! =mula = ! maid's relation to h] "y ma/]2 = ,i am n q sure t all "y ma/]s are to be tru/$ ) x4 ,suffice x t ! son w be affect$ directly z 8 influ5ce ov] h]1 & inv]sely z 8 vocational p[]3 if !n he %\ld h "s influ5ce & no vocational p[]1 ! effect on him w\ld be inf9ite4 ,?is is dismal to ?9k (4 ,fur!r1 ! =mula br+s out t if "o s]vant improve1 ! o!r mu/ det]iorate1 & vice v]sa4 ,?is is n ! exp]i5ce ( mo/ families3 & ! au?or rem>ks z foll[s3 ,t is1 we %\ld v5ture to say1 a v beautiful result1 & we may say x yield$ u no little a/oni%m5t4 ,:at our calculation might lead to we nev] dreamt (2 t x %\ld educe a conclusion s recondite t our unassi/$ p[] nev] c\ld h atta9$ to1 & :i*1 if we c\ld h conjectur$ x1 w\ld h be5 at be/ ! mo/ di/ant probability1 t conclusion be+ itself1 z x w\ld appe>1 ! qu9tess5ce ( tru?1 af=d$ u a measure ( satisfaction t 0 n slight4 ,t ! writ+s ( ,mr4 ,boole & myself g to ! full ju/ification ( ?is pr9ciple1 is only true 9 ! s5se 9 :i* ! ,scot* use1 or did use1 ! ^w ju/ification4 ,a ,,tribute ,,to ,,boole4 ,! la/ numb] ( ?is ,budget _h /ood 9 type = mon?s1 wait+ until !re %\ld be a little cessation ( correspond5ce m connect$ ) ! ?+s ( ! day4 #hj ,i _h q =gott5 :at x 0 to conta92 & little ?\ght1 :5 ,i read ! pro(1 t my allusions to my fri5d ,mr4 ,boole1 !n 9 life & heal?1 w\ld n be pr9t$ till _m weeks aft] 8 dea?4 ,_h ,i rememb]$ :at my la/ numb] conta9$1 ,i %\ld h add$ my expression ( regret & admiration to ! num]\s obitu>y te/imonials1 :i* ?is great loss to sci5ce has call$ =?4 ,! sy/em ( logic allud$ to 9 ! la/ numb] ( ?is s]ies is b "o ( _m pro(s ( g5ius & pati5ce comb9$4 ,i might legitimately h ent]$ x among my p>adoxes1 or ?+s c\nt] to g5]al op9ion3 b x is a p>adox :i*1 l t ( ,cop]nicus1 excit$ admiration f its fir/ appe>ance4 ,t ! symbolic processes ( algebra1 inv5t$ z tools ( num]ical calculation1 %\ld be compet5t to express e act ( ?\ght1 & to furni% ! gramm> & diction>y ( an all-conta9+ sy/em ( logic1 w\ld n h be5 believ$ until x 0 prov$4 ,:5 ,hobbes1#aff 9 ! "t ( ! ,commonweal?1 publi%$ 8 ,computation or ,logique1 he _h a remote glimpse ( "s ( ! po9ts :i* are plac$ 9 ! light ( day by ,mr4 ,boole4 ,! unity ( ! =ms ( ?\ght 9 all ! applications ( reason1 h[ev] remotely sep>at$1 w "o day be matt] ( notoriety & common wond]3 & ,boole's "n w be rememb]$ 9 connection ) "o ( ! mo/ important /eps t[>ds ! atta9m5t ( ?is k4 ,,decimals ,,run ,,riot4 ,! ,decimal ,sy/em z a :ole4 ,by ,dov] ,/att]4#afg ,london & ,liv]pool1 #ahef1 #hvo4 #ha ,! proposition is to make ev]y?+ decimal4 ,! day1 n[ #bd h\rs1 is to be made #aj h\rs4 ,! ye> is to h t5 mon?s1 ,unusb]1 ,duob]1 etc4 ,=tunately !re are t5 comm&m5ts1 s !re w be nei!r addition to1 nor d$uction f1 ! moral law4 ,b ! twelve apo/les6 ,ev5 reject+ ,judas1 !re is a :ole apo/le ( difficulty4 ,^! po9ts ! au?or does n t\*4 ,,on ,,phonetic ,,spell+4 ,! fir/ book ( ,phonetic ,read+4 ,london1 ,fr$4 ,pitman1#afh ,phonetic ,depot1 #bj1 ,pat]no/] ,r[1 #ahef1 #abmo4 ,! ,phonetic ,j\rnal4 ,devot$ to ! propagation ( phonetic read+1 phonetic longh&1 phonetic %or?&1 & phonetic pr9t+4 ,no4 #df4 ,saturday1 #ae ,novemb] #ahef4 ,vol4 #ae4 ,i write ! titles ( a c\ple out ( sev]al tracts :i* ,i h by me4 ,b ! numb] ( publications issu$ by ! promot]s ( ?is spirit$ attempt is v l>ge inde$4#afi ,! attempt itself has _h no success ) ! mass ( ! public4 ,?is ,i d n regret4 ,_h ! _w f\nd t ! *ange 0 useful1 ,i %\ld h gone cont5t$ly ) ! /ream2 b n )\t regrett+ our old language4 ,i admit ! difficulties :i* our unpron\nceable spell+ puts 9 ! way ( le>n+ to read3 & ,i h no d\bt t1 z affirm$1 x is easi] to tea* *ildr5 phonetically1 & aft]w>ds to introduce !m to our common sy/em1 ?an to proce$ 9 ! usual way4 ,b by ! usual way ,i mean proce$+ by lett]s f ! v beg9n+4 ,if1 :i* ,i am sure is a bett] plan1 *ildr5 be taught at ! comm5cem5t v mu* by complete words1 z if !y 7 le>n+ ,*9ese1 & be gradually accu/om$ to #hb resolve ! kn[n words into lett]s1 a fraction1 p]haps a consid]able "o1 ( ! advantage ( ! phonetic sy/em is de/roy$4 ,x mu/ be rememb]$ t a phonetic sy/em c only be an approximation4 ,! diff]5ces ( pronunciation exi/+ among educat$ p]sons are s great1 t1 on ! phonetic sy/em1 diff]5t p]sons ought to spell diff]5tly4 ,b ! phonetic p>ty h produc$ some?+ :i* w immortalize _! plan3 ,i mean _! %or?&1 :i* has _h a fraction ( ! success x des]ves4 ,all :o "k any?+ ( %or?& mu/ see t no?+ b a phonetic sy/em c be wor?y ( ! "n3 & ! sy/em promulgat$ is skilfully done4 ,7 ,i a "y man ,i %\ld apply myself to x sy/ematically4 ,i believe ?is is ! only sy/em 9 :i* books 7 ev] publi%$4 ,i wi% "s "o w\ld contribute to a public j\rnal a brief acc\nt ( ! dates & circum/ances ( ! phonetic movem5t1 n =gett+ a li/ ( ! books publi%$ 9 %or?&4 ,a *ild beg9n+ to read by himself may owe t]rible dreams & wak+ images ( horror to our spell+1 z ,i did :5 six ye>s old4 ,9 "o ( ! common poetry-books !re is an admonition aga9/ conf9+ little birds 9 cages1 & ! *ild is ask$ :at if a great giant1 amaz+ly /rong1 7 to take y away1 %ut y up1 ,& fe$ y ) vic-tu-als y ne-v] c\ld be>4 ,! book 0 hyph5$ = ! beg9n]'s use2 & ,i _h n ! lea/ idea t vic-tu-als 7 vittles3 by ! s\nd ( ! ^w ,i judg$ !y mu/ be ( iron2 & x ent]$ into my s\l4 ,! wor/ ( ! phonetic %or?& book is t !y n[h]e1 s f> z ,i h se51 give all ! symbols1 9 e /age ( advancem5t1 toge!r1 9 "o or foll[+ pages4 ,x is symbols & talk1 m symbols & m talk1 etc4 ,a univ]sal view ( ! signs ought to beg9 ! works4 #hc ,a ,,h&ful ,,( ,,little ,,p>adox]s4 ,ombrological ,almanac4 ,sev5te5? ye>4 ,an essay on ,anemology & ,ombrology4 ,by ,pet] ,legh1#agj ,esq4 ,london1 #ahef1 #abmo4 ,mr4 ,legh1 already m5tion$1 0 an intellig5t c\ntry g5tleman1 & a legitimate speculator4 ,b ! clue 0 n res]v$ = him4 ,! pro( t ! ?ree angles ( a triangle are equal to two "r angles look$ = 9 ! inflation ( ! circle4 ,by ,g54 ,p]ronet ,?ompson4 ,london1 #ahef1 #hvo4 7pp4 #d47 ,ano!r attempt1 ! ?ird1 at ?is old difficulty1 :i* _c be put into few words ( explanation4#aga ,comets consid]$ z volcanoes1 & ! cause ( _! velocity & o!r ph5om5a !reby expla9$4 ,london 7circa #ahef71 #hvo4 ,! title expla9s ! book bett] ?an ! book expla9s ! title4 #ahef4 ,a /rang] appli$ to me to "k :at ! ideas ( a fri5d ( 8 7 wor? ^u ! magnitude ( ! e>?4 ,! matt] be+ "o involv+ po9ts ( antiquity1 ,i m5tion$ v>i\s p]sons ^: speculations he seem$ to h ignor$2 among o!rs1 ,?ales4 ,! reply 01 ,i am in/ruct$ by ! au?or to in=m y t he is p]fectly acqua9t$ ) ! works ( ,?ales1 ,euclid1 ,ar*im$es1 444 ,i _h "s ?\ght ( ask+ :e!r he _h us$ ! ,elzevir edition ( ,?ales1#agb :i* is kn[n to be v incomplete1 or t ( ,pr(essor ,niem& ) ! lections1 ,nirg5d1 #ahbd1 #b vols4 folio2 j to see :e!r ! #hd la/ w\ld n h be5 ! v edition he _h read4 ,b ,i refra9$1 9 m]cy4 ,! moon is ! image ( ! ,e>?1 & is n a solid body4 ,by ,the ,longitude4#agc 7,private ,circulation47 ,9 five p>ts4 ,london1 #ahef1 #aheg1 #aheg2 ,calcutta1 #aheh1 #aheh1 #hvo4 ,! e>? is br\ght to a focus2 x describes a loop$ orbit r\nd ! sun4 ,! eclipse ( ! sun is ?us expla9$3 ,at ! "t ( eclipses1 ! image is m or less s directly be=e or beh9d ! e>? t1 9 ! case ( new moon1 bright rays ( ! sun fall & be> ^u ! spot :]e ! figure ( ! e>? is br\ght to a focus1 t is1 be> ^u ! image ( ! e>?1 :5 a d>kness beyond is produc$ rea*+ to ! e>?1 & ! sun becomes m or less eclips$4 ,h[ ! e>? is br\ght to a focus we d n f9d /at$4 ,writ]s ( ?is k9d always h ! argum5t t "s ?+s :i* h be5 ridicul$ at fir/ h be5 f9ally e/abli%$4 ,^? :o put into ! lott]y _h ! same k9d ( argum5t2 b 7 always answ]$ by be+ rem9d$ h[ _m blanks !re 7 to "o prize4 ,i am loa? to pron\nce aga9/ any?+3 b x does =ce itself ^u me t ! au?or ( ^! tracts has drawn a blank4 ,,lun> ,,motion ,,aga94 ,times1 ,april #f or #g1 #ahef4 ,! moon has no rot>y motion4 ,a lett] f ,mr4 ,jell+] ,symons1#agd inspector ( s*ools1 :i* comm5c$ a controv]sy ( _m lett]s & pamphlets4 ,?is dispute comes on at int]vals1 & w cont9ue to d s4 ,x sometimes arises f inability to und]/& ! "* ( simple rotation1 geometrically2 sometimes f n und]/&+ ! me*anical doctr9e ( rotation4 #he ,lun> ,motion4 ,! :ole argum5t /at$1 & illu/rat$ by diagrams2 ) lett]s f ! ,a/ronom] ,royal4 ,by ,jell+] ,c4 ,symons4 ,london1 #ahef1 #hvo4 ,! ,a/ronom] ,royal endeavor$ to dis5tangle ,mr4 ,j4 ,c4 ,symons1 b fail$4 ,mr4 ,airy#age c correct ! error ( a %ip's compasses1 because he c put h] head :i* way he pleases3 b ?is he _c d ) a speculator4 ,mr4 ,symons1 9 ?is tract1 ins9uat$ t ! rotation ( ! moon is "o ( ! silv] %r9es ( ! craftsm54 ,to see a ?+ s cle>ly z to be satisfi$ t all :o say !y d n see x are tell+ wilful falsehood1 is ! nature ( man4 ,_m ( all sects f9d mu* com=t 9 x1 :5 !y ?9k ( ! o!rs2 _m unbeliev]s solace !mselves ) x aga9/ believ]s2 prie/s ( old "t f\nd$ ! "r ( p]secution ^u x1 & ( our "t1 9 "s cases1 ! "r ( sl&]3 _m ( ! p>adox]s make x an argum5t aga9/ /ud5ts ( sci5ce4 ,b ,i mu/ say = m5 ( sci5ce1 = ! :ole body1 t !y are fully p]suad$ ( ! hone/y ( ! p>adox]s4 ,! simple tru? is1 t all ^? ,i h m5tion$1 believ]s1 unbeliev]s1 prie/s1 p>adox]s1 are n s sure !y are "r 9 _! po9ts ( diff]5ce t !y c safely all[ !mselves to be p]suad$ ( ! hone/y ( oppon5ts4 ,^? :o "k demon/ration are diff]5tly situat$4 ,i suspect a tra9 might be laid = ! =mation ( a bett] habit 9 ?is way4 ,we "k t ,suv>(f#agf taught 8 ,russians at ,ismail n to fe> ! ,turks by accu/om+ !m to *>ge bundles ( faggots dress$ 9 turbans1 etc4 ,at :i* y\r wise m5 sne]$ 9 phrases witty1 ,he made no answ]--b he took ! city6 ,w\ld x n be a good ?+ to ex]cise boys1 9 pairs1 9 ! foll[+ dialogue3--,sir1 y are q wrong6--,sir1 #hf ,i am sure y hone/ly ?9k s6 ,?is 0 sugge/$ by :at us$ to take place at ,cambridge 9 my day4 ,by /atute1 e ,b4,a4 0 oblig$ to p]=m a c]ta9 numb] ( disputations1 & ! fa!r ( ! college _h to affirm t x _h be5 done4 ,"s 7 p]=m$ 9 e>ne/3 ! re/ 7 huddl$ ov] z foll[s4 ,two c&idates occupi$ ! places ( ! respond5t & ! oppon5t3 ,recte /atuit ,newtonus1 said ! respond5t3 ,recte non /atuit ,newtonus1#agg said ! oppon5t4 ,?is 0 repeat$ ! requisite numb] ( times1 & c\nt$ = z _m acts & oppon5cies4 ,! p>ties !n *ang$ places1 & ea* unsaid :at he _h said on ! o!r side ( ! h\se3 ,i rememb] ?9k+ t x 0 capital drill = ! ,h\se ( ,commons1 if any ( u %\ld ev] get !re4 ,! process 0 repeat$ ) e pair ( c&idates4 ,! real disputations 7 v sev]e ex]cises4 ,i 0 badg]$ = two h\rs ) argum5ts giv5 & answ]$ 9 ,lat91--or :at we call$ ,lat9--aga9/ ,newton's fir/ section1 ,lagrange's#agh d]iv$ functions1 & ,locke#agi on innate pr9ciples4 ,& ?\gh ,i took (f ev]y?+1 & 0 pron\nc$ by ! mod]ator to h disput$ magno honore1#ahj ,i nev] _h su* a /ra9 ( ?\ght 9 my life4 ,= ! inf]ior oppon5ts 7 made z %>p z _! bett]s by _! tutors1 :o kept li/s ( que] objections1 drawn f all qu>t]s4 ,! oppon5ts us$ to meet ! day be=e to comp>e _! argum5ts1 t ! same might n come twice ov]4 ,b1 aft] ,i left ,cambridge1 x became ! fa%ion to invite ! respond5t to be pres5t1 :o !re=e le>nt all t 0 to be br\ght aga9/ him4 ,?is made ! :ole ?+ a f>ce3 & ! disputations 7 aboli%$4 #hg ,! ,doctr9e ( ! ,moon's ,rotation1 consid]$ 9 a lett] to ! ,a/ronomical ,c5sor ( ! ,a!naeum4 ,by ,jones ,l4 ,mac,elshender4#aha ,ed9burgh1 #ahef1 #hvo4 ,?is is an appeal to ^? cultivat$ p]sons :o w read x to ov]rule ! dicta ( judges :o w\ld sacrifice tru? & ju/ice to pr(essional rule1 or p]sonal pique1 pride1 or prejudice2 mean+1 ! great mass ( ^? :o h /udi$ ! subject4 ,b h[8 ,suppose ! cultivat$ p]sons 7 to side ) ! au?or1 w\ld ^? :o h conclusions to draw & applications to make cons5t to be wrong because ! g5]al body ( intellig5t m51 :o make no special /udy ( ! subject1 are aga9/ !m8 ,!y w\ld d no su* ?+3 !y w\ld reque/ ! g5]al body ( intellig5t m5 to f9d _! own a/ronomy1 & welcome4 ,b ! tru? is1 t ?is intellig5t body kn[s bett]3 & no p]sons "k bett] t !y "k bett] ?an ! speculators !mselves4 ,b suppose ! g5]al body 7 to comb9e1 9 opposition to ^? :o h /udi$4 ,( c\rse all my li/ mu/ be admitt$ to _! trial2 & !n arises ! "q :e!r bo? sides are to be he>d4 ,if s1 ! g5]al body ( ! intellig5t mu/ he> all ! e/abli%$ side h to say3 t is1 !y mu/ become j z mu* ( /ud5ts z ! inculpat$ or?odox !mselves4 ,& w !y n !n get into pr(essional rule1 pique1 pride1 & prejudice1 z ! o!rs did8 ,b if1 :i* ,i suspect1 !y are int5d$ to judge z !y are1 !y w be 9 a r>e difficulty4 ,all ! p>adox]s are ( l pret5sions3 !y _c1 z a class1 be "r1 = ea* "o contradicts a great _m ( ! re/4 ,!re w be ! puzzle :i* sil5c$ ! crew ( ! cutt] 9 ,m>ryat's novel ( ! ,dog ,fi5d4#ahb ,a tog is a tog1 said ,jans54--,yes1 repli$ ano!r1 we all "k a dog is a dog2 b ! "q is--,is ?is dog #hh a dog8 ,& ?is "q w\ld arise ^u e dog ( !m all4 ,,zetetic ,,a/ronomy4 ,zetetic ,a/ronomy3 ,e>? n a globe4 #aheg 7,broad%eet74 ,?\gh only a travel+ lectur]'s adv]tisem5t1 !re are s _m argum5ts & quotations t x is a little pamphlet4 ,! lectur] ga9$ great praise f prov9cial newspap]s = 8 +5uity 9 prov+ t ! e>? is a flat1 surr\nd$ by ice4 ,"s ( ! j\rnals r incl9e to ! view3 b ! ,leice/] ,adv]tis] ?9ks t ! /atem5ts w\ld seem v s]i\sly to invalidate "s ( ! mo/ important conclusions ( mod]n a/ronomy1 :ile ! ,norfolk ,h]ald is cle> t !re mu/ be a great error on "o side or ! o!r4 ,?is broad%eet is pr9t$ at ,aylesbury 9 #aheg1 & ! lectur] calls himself ,p>allax3 b at ,tr[bridge1 9 #ahdi1 he 0 ,s4 ,g\ld54#ahc ,9 ?is la/ adv]tisem5t is ! foll[+ ann\ncem5t3 ,a pap] on ! above subjects 0 read be=e ! ,c\ncil & ,memb]s ( ! ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society1 ,som]set ,h\se1 ,/r&1 ,london 7,sir ,john ,f4 ,w4 ,h]s*el1#ahd ,presid5t71 ,friday1 ,dec4 #h1 #ahdh4 ,no acc\nt ( su* a pap] appe>s 9 ! ,notice = t mon?3 ,i suspect t ! above is ,mr4 ,s4 ,g\ld5's way ( repres5t+ ! foll[+ occurr5ce3 ,dec4 #h1 #ahdh1 ! ,secret>y ( ! ,a/ronomical ,society 7,de ,morgan by "n7 said1 at ! close ( ! proce$+s1--,n[1 g5tlem51 if y w promise n to tell ! ,c\ncil1 ,i w read some?+ = y\r amusem5t3 & he !n read a few ( ! argum5ts :i* _h be5 transmitt$ by ! lectur]4 ,! fact is wor? not+ t f #ahdi to #aheg1 argum5ts on ! r\ndness or flatness ( ! e>? did it9]ate4 ,i h #hi no d\bt !y did mu* good3 = v few p]sons h any di/9ct idea ( ! evid5ce = ! rotundity ( ! e>?4 ,! ,blackburn ,/&>d & ,pre/on ,gu>dian 7,dec4 #ab & #af1 #ahdi7 unite 9 /at+ t ! lectur] ran away f 8 second lecture at ,burnley1 hav+ be5 r too h>d press$ at ! end ( 8 fir/ lecture to expla9 :y ! l>ge hull ( a %ip disappe>$ be=e ! sails4 ,! p]sons pres5t & wait+ = ! second lecture assuag$ _! disappo9tm5t by conclud+ t ! lectur] _h slipp$ (f ! icy edge ( 8 flat disk1 & t he w\ld n be se5 aga9 till he peep$ up on ! opposite side4 ,b1 /range z x may appe>1 ! oppos] ( ! e>?'s r\ndness has m ( a case--or less ( a want ( case--?an ! ari?metical squ>] ( ! circle4 ,! evid5ce t ! e>? is r\nd is b cumulative & circum/antial3 scores ( ph5om5a ask1 sep>ately & indep5d5tly1 :at o!r explanation c be imag9$ except ! sph]icity ( ! e>?4 ,! evid5ce = ! e>?'s figure is trem5d\sly p[]ful ( its k9d2 b ! pro( t ! circumf]5ce is #c4adaeibfe444 times ! diamet] is ( a high] k9d1 be+ absolute ma!matical demon/ration4 ,! ,zetetic sy/em /ill lives 9 lectures & books2 z x ought to d1 = !re is no way ( tea*+ a tru? comp>able to opposition4 ,! la/ ,i he>d ( x 0 9 lectures at ,plym\?1 9 ,octob]1 #ahfd4 ,s9ce ?is "t a prospectus has be5 issu$ ( a "w entitl$ ,! ,e>? n a ,globe2 b :e!r x has be5 publi%$ ,i d n "k4 ,! cont5ts are z foll[s3 ,! ,e>? a ,plane--,h[ circumnavigat$4--,h[ "t is lo/ or ga9$4--,:y a %ip's hull disappe>s 7:5 outw>d b\nd7 be=e ! ma/ head4--,:y ! ,pol> ,/> sets :5 we proce$ ,s\?w>d1 etc4--,:y a p5dulum vibrates ) less velocity at ! ,equator ?an #ij at ! ,pole4--,! all[ance = rotundity suppos$ to be made by surveyors1 n made 9 practice4--,measurem5t ( ,arcs ( ! ,m]idian unsatisfactory4--,degrees ( ,longitude ,nor? & ,s\? ( ! ,equator consid]$4--,eclipses & ,e>?'s =m consid]$4--,! ,e>? no motion on axis or 9 orbit4--,h[ ! ,sun moves above ! ,e>?'s surface conc5tric ) ! ,nor? ,pole4--,cause ( ,day & ,night1 ,w9t] & ,summ]2 ! long alt]nation ( light & d>kness at ! ,pole4--,cause ( ! ,sun ris+ & sett+4--,di/ance ( ! ,sun f ,london1 #d1jbh miles--,h[ measur$4--,*all5ge to ,ma!maticians4--,cause ( ,tides4--,moon self-lum9\s1 ,,n a reflector4--,cause ( ,sol> & ,lun> eclipses4--,/>s n worlds2 _! di/ance4--,e>?1 ! only mat]ial _w2 its true position 9 ! univ]se2 its condition & ultimate de/ruction by fire 7#b ,pet] iii471 etc4 ,i wi% !re 7 geoplatylogical lectures 9 e t[n2 9 ,engl& 7platylogical1 9 composition1 ne$ n mean babbl+74 ,! late ,mr4 ,h5ry ,ar*]#ahe w\ld1 if alive1 be v mu* oblig$ to me = record+ 8 vehem5t d5ial ( ! r\ndness ( ! e>?3 he 0 excit$ if he he>d any "o call x a globe4 ,i _c produce 8 pro( f ! ,pyramids1 & f "s caves 9 ,arabia4 ,he _h o!r curi\s notions1 ( c\rse3 ,i %\ld no m believe t a flat e>? 0 a man's only p>adox1 ?an ,i %\ld t ,dut5s1#ahf ! editor ( ,leibnitz1 0 ecc5tric only 9 supply+ a too? :i* he _h lo/ by "o :i* he f\nd 9 an ,italian tomb1 & fully believ$ t x _h once belong$ to ,scipio ,africanus1 ^: family vault 0 discov]$1 x is suppos$1 9 #aghj4 ,mr4 ,ar*] is ( note z #ia ! sugge/] ( ! p]=at$ bord] ( ! po/age-/amps1 &1 ,i ?9k1 ( ! way ( do+ x2 = ?is he got #djjjl4 rew>d4 ,he 0 a civil eng9e]4 7,augu/ #bh1 #ahfe47 ,! ,zetetic ,a/ronomy has come into my h&s4 ,:51 9 #ahea1 ,i w5t to see ! ,great ,exhibition1 ,i he>d an organ play$ by a p]=m] :o seem$ v desir\s to exhibit "o p>ticul> /op4 ,:at d y ?9k ( t /op8 ,i 0 ask$4--,t dep5ds on ! "n ( x1 said ,i4--,oh6 :at c ! "n h to d ) ! s\nd8 't :i* we call a rose1' etc4--,! "n has ev]y?+ to d ) x3 if x be a flute-/op1 ,i ?9k x v h>%2 b if x be a railway-:i/le-/op1 ,i ?9k x v sweet4 ,s z to ?is book3 if x be *ildi%1 x is clev]2 if x be manni%1 x is unusually fooli%4 ,! flat e>?1 float+ tremul\sly on ! sea2 ! sun mov+ always ov] ! flat1 giv+ day :5 ne> en\gh1 & night :5 too f> (f2 ! self-lum9\s moon1 ) a semi-transp>5t invisible moon1 creat$ to give h] an eclipse n[ & !n2 ! new law ( p]spective1 by :i* ! vani%+ ( ! hull be=e ! ma/s1 usually ?\ght to prove ! e>? globul>1 really proves x flat2--all ^! & o!r ?+s are well fitt$ to =m ex]cises = a p]son :o is le>n+ ! elem5ts ( a/ronomy4 ,! mann] 9 :i* ! sun dips into ! sea1 especially 9 tropical climates1 upsets ! :ole4 ,mungo ,p>k1#ahg ,i ?9k1 gives an ,african hypo!sis :i* expla9s ph5om5a bett] ?an ?is4 ,! sun dips into ! we/]n ocean1 & ! p !re cut him 9 pieces1 fry him 9 a pan1 & !n jo9 him toge!r aga91 take him r\nd ! und]way1 & set him up 9 ! ea/4 ,i hope ?is book w be read1 & t _m w be puzzl$ by x3 = !re are _m ^: notions ( a/ronomy des]ve no bett] fate4 ,!re is no subject on :i* !re is s little #ib accurate conception z t ( ! motions ( ! heav5ly bodies4 ,! au?or1 ?\gh confid5t 9 ! extreme1 nei!r impea*es ! hone/y ( ^? ^: op9ions he assails1 nor allots !m any future inconv5i5ce3 9 ^! po9ts he is wor?y to live on a globe1 & to revolve 9 tw5ty-f\r h\rs4 7,octob]1 #ahff47 ,a foll[] appe>s1 9 a "w d$icat$ to ! prec$+ au?or3 x is ,!oretical ,a/ronomy exam9$ & expos$ by ,common ,s5se4 ,! au?or has #abh well-/uff$ octavo pages4 ,i hope he w n be ! la/4 ,he pr9ts ! newspap] acc\nts ( 8 "w3 ! ,*ur* ,times says--n see+ h[ ! satire might be retort$--,we nev] began to despair ( ,scripture until we discov]$ t ',common ,s5se' _h tak5 up ! cudgels 9 its def5ce4 ,?is pap] consid]s our au?or z ! type ( a ,prote/ant4 ,! au?or himself1 :o gives a summ>y ( 8 argum5ts 9 v]se1 has "o c\plet :i* is wor? quot+3 ,h[ is't t sailors1 b\nd to sea1 ) a 'globe' w\ld nev] />t1 ,b 9 its place w always take ,m]cator's#ahh ,,level *>t6 ,to :i* ,i answ]3 ,:y1 really ,mr4 ,common ,s5se1 y've nev] got s f> ,z to ?9k ,m]cator's planisph]e %[s c\ntries z !y are2 ,x won't d to measure di/ances2 x po9ts out h[ to /e]1 ,b ?is di/ortion's n = y2 ano!r is1 ,i fe>4 ,! e>? mu/ be a cyl9d]1 if seaman's *>ts be true1 ,or else ! b\nd>ies1 "r & left1 are "o z well z two2 ,!y contradict ! notion t we dwell ^u a pla91 ,= /raight away1 )\t a turn1 w br+ y home aga94 ,!re are v>i\s plane projections2 & ea* "o has its use3 ,i wi% a mild] ^w w\ld rhyme--b really y're a goose6 ,! great wi% ( p]sons :o expose !mselves z above1 is to be argu$ )1 & to be treat$ z reputable #ic & refutable oppon5ts4 ,common ,s5se rem9ds u t no am\nt ( blatant ridicule w turn "r into wrong4 ,he is p]fectly correct3 b !n no am\nt ( bad argum5t w turn wrong into "r4 ,^! two ?+s balance2 & we are j :]e we 73 b y %\ld answ] our argum5ts1 = :om1 ,i ask8 ,w\ld reason conv9ce ?is k9d ( reason]8 ,! issue is a %ort & a cle> "o4 ,if ^! p>ties be :at ,i cont5d !y are1 !n ridicule is made = !m3 if n1 = :at or = :om8 ,if !y be "r1 !y are only pass+ ?r\gh ! appo9t$ trial ( all good ?+s4 ,appeal is made to ! future3 & my ,budget is int5d$ to %[ samples ( ! long l9e ( h]oes :o h fall5 )\t victory1 ea* ( :om _h 8 day ( confid5ce & 8 prophecy ( success4 ,let ! future decide3 !y say r\ndly t ! e>? is flat2 ,i say flatly t x is r\nd4 ,! p>adox]s all want reason1 & n ridicule3 !y are all accessible1 & w\ld yield to conviction4 ,well !n1 let !m reason ) "o ano!r6 ,!y divide into squads1 ea* ) a subject1 & z _m diff]5t op9ions z p]sons 9 ea* squad4 ,if !y be really :at !y say !y are1 ! true man ( ea* set c put d[n all ! re/1 & c come cr[n$ ) glory & girdl$ ) scalps1 to ! attack on ! or?odox misbeliev]s4 ,b !y "k1 to a man1 t ! re/ are n fit to be reason$ )3 !y pay ! regul>s ! complim5t ( believ+ t ! only *ance lies ) !m4 ,!y ?9k 9 _! he>ts1 ea* "o = himself1 t ridicule is ( fit appliance to ! re/4 ,mir&a4 ,a book divid$ into ?ree p>ts1 entitl$ ,s\ls1 ,numb]s1 ,/>s1 on ! ,neo-,*ri/ian ,religion 444 ,vol4 i4 ,london1 #aheh1 #ahei1 #ahfj4 #hvo4 ,! "n ( ! au?or is ,filopanti4#ahi ,he ann\nces himself z ! #di? & la/ ,emanuel3 8 imm$iate #id pr$ecessors 7 ,emanuel ,wa%+ton1 ,emanuel ,newton1 & ,emanuel ,galileo4 ,he is to collect nations into "o family4 ,he kn[s ! transmigrations ( ! :ole human race4 ,?us ,desc>tes became ,william ,,iii ( ,engl&3 ,rog] ,bacon became ,boccaccio4 ,b ,*>les ,,ix1#aij 9 retribution = ! massacre ( ,/4 ,b>?olomew1 0 hang$ 9 ,london "u ! "n ( ,b>!lemy = ! murd] ( ,coll>d3 & _m ( ! ,prote/ants :om he kill$ z ,k+ ( ,france 7 %\t+ at 8 dea? be=e ! ,old ,bailey4 ,,! ,,sabba?--,,! ,,great ,,pyramid ,a ,lett] to ! memb]s ( ! ,anglo-,biblical ,in/itute1 dat$ ,sept4 #g1 #aheh1 & sign$ ',h]man ,he9fett]4'#aia 7,broad%eet47 ,?is g5tleman is well kn[n to ! read]s ( ! ,a!naeum1 9 :i*1 = ne>ly tw5ty ye>s1 he has ins]t$1 z adv]tisem5ts1 long argum5ts 9 favor ( ,*ri/ians keep+ ! ,jewi% ,sabba?1 beg9n+ on ,friday ,ev5+4 ,! pres5t lett] ma9ta9s t1 by ! =ce ( ! def9ite article1 ! days ( creation may n be consecutive1 b may h any "t--millions ( ye>s--betwe5 !m4 ,?is +5i\s way ( reconcil+ ! au?or ( ,g5esis & ! indications ( geology is wor?y to be add$ to ! li/1 already pretty num]\s4 ,mr4 ,he9fett] has tak5 su* pa9s to make himself a public agitator1 t #ie ,i d n feel x to be any invasion ( private life if ,i /ate t ,i h he>d he is a l>ge corn-deal]4 ,no d\bt he is a memb] ( ! congregation ^: almanac has already be5 describ$4 ,! great ,pyramid4 ,:y 0 x built8 ,& :o built x8 ,by ,john ,taylor1 #ahei1aib #abmo4 ,?is "w is v le>n$1 & may be ref]r$ to = ! hi/ory ( previ\s speculations4 ,x pr(esses to connect ! dim5sions ( ! ,pyramid ) a sy/em ( metrology :i* is suppos$ to h left /rong traces 9 ! sy/ems ( mod]n times2 %[+ ! ,egyptians to h _h good approximate k ( ! dim5sions ( ! e>?1 & ( ! quadrature ( ! circle4 ,^! are po9ts on :i* co9cid5ce is h>d to di/+ui% f int5tion4 ,sir ,john ,h]s*el#aic notic$ ?is "w1 & gave sev]al co9cid5ces1 9 ! ,a!naeum1 ,nos4 #afif & #afig1 ,april #bh & ,may #e1 #ahfj3 & !re are "s rem>ks by ,mr4 ,taylor 9 ,no4 #agja1 ,june #b1 #ahfj4 ,mr4 ,taylor's mo/ rec5t publication is-- ,! battle ( ! ,/&>ds3 ! anci5t1 ( f\r ?\s& ye>s1 aga9/ ! mod]n1 ( ! la/ fifty ye>s--! less p]fect ( ! two4 ,london1 #ahfd1 #abmo4 ,?is is int5d$ z an app5dix to ! "w on ! ,pyramid4 ,mr4 ,taylor di/9ctly attributes ! orig9al sy/em to revelation1 ( :i* he says ! ,great ,pyramid is ! record4 ,we are advanc+1 he rem>ks1 t[>ds ! end ( ! ,*ri/ian disp5sation1 & he adds t x is satisfactory to see t we reta9 ! /&>ds :i* 7 giv5 by unwritt5 revelation #gjj ye>s be=e ,moses4 ,?is is light+ ! c&le at bo? ends2 = myself1 ,i %all n und]take to d5y or affirm ei!r :at is said ab\t ! d>k pa/ or :at is h9t$ ab\t ! d>k future4 #if ,my old fri5d ,mr4 ,taylor is well kn[n z ! au?or ( ! argum5t :i* has conv9c$ _m1 ev5 mo/1 t ,sir ,philip ,francis#aid 0 ,junius3 pamphlet1 #ahac2 supplem5t1 #ahag2 second edition ,! ,id5tity ( ,junius ) a di/+ui%$ liv+ "* e/abli%$1 ,london1 #ahah1 #hvo4 ,he told me t ,sir ,philip ,francis1 9 a %ort conv]sation ) him1 made only ?is rem>k1 ,y may dep5d ^u x y are q mi/ak53 ! phrase appe>s to me rem>kable2 x has an air ( criticism on ! book1 free f all p]sonal d5ial4 ,he also m5tion$ t a he>] told him t ,sir ,philip said1 speak+ ( writ]s on ! "q1--,^? fell[s1 = half-a-cr[n1 w\ld prove t ,jesus ,*ri/ 0 ,junius4 ,mr4 ,taylor implies1 ,i ?9k1 t he is ! fir/ :o />t$ ! sugge/ion t ,sir ,philip ,francis 0 ,junius1 :i* ,i h no means ei!r ( confirm+ or refut+4 ,if x be s & ,i n[ "k t ,mr4 ,taylor himself nev] he>d ( any pr$ecessor1 ! circum/ance is v rem>kable3 x is seldom inde$ t ! fir/ propos] ( any solution ( a great & vex$ "q is ! p]son :o s ne>ly e/abli%es 8 po9t 9 g5]al op9ion z ,mr4 ,taylor has done4 ,z to ! ,junius "q 9 g5]al1 !re is a little bit ( ! philosophy ( horse-rac+ :i* may be usefully appli$4 ,a man :o is s confid5t ( 8 horse t he places him f> above any o!r1 may nev]!less1 & does1 refuse to give odds aga9/ all 9 ! field3 = _m small adv]se *ances unit$ make a big *ance = "o or o!r ( ! oppon5ts4 ,i suspect ,mr4 ,taylor has made x at lea/ #bj to #a = ,francis aga9/ any "o competitor :o has be5 nam$3 b :at ! odds may be aga9/ ! #ig :ole field is m difficult to settle4 ,:at if ! real ,junius %\ld be "s p]son n yet nam$8 ,mr4 ,jopl+1 ,leisure ,h\r1 ,may #bc1 #ahfc1 relies on ! porphyry c(f] ( ! ,great ,pyramid1 9 :i* he f9ds ! mo/ anci5t & accurate /&>d ( measure 9 exi/5ce4 ,i am %ock$ at be+ oblig$ to place a ?\ghtful & le>n$ writ]1 & an old fri5d1 be=e su* a successor z he "h meets )4 ,b *ronological arrangem5t defies all o!r arrangem5t4 7,i _h hop$ t ! prec$+ acc\nt w\ld h met ,mr4 ,taylor's eye 9 pr9t3 b he di$ dur+ ! la/ summ]4 ,= a man ( a v ?\ghtful & quiet temp]am5t1 he _h a curi\s turn = vex$ que/ions4 ,b he reflect$ v long & v pati5tly be=e he publi%$3 & all 8 works are valuable = _! accurate le>n+1 :i*ev] side ! read] may take47 ,,mrs4 ,,elizabe? ,,cottle4 #ahei4 ,! ,cottle ,*ur*4--,= m ?an tw5ty ye>s pr9t$ pap]s h be5 s5t ab\t 9 ! "n ( ,elizabe? ,cottle4#aie ,x is n s rem>kable t su* pap]s %\ld be concoct$ z t !y %\ld circulate = su* a l5g? ( "t )\t attract+ public att5tion4 ,eighty ye>s ago ,mrs4 ,cottle might h rivall$ ,lieut4 ,bro!rs or ,joanna ,s\?cott4#aif ,long h5ce1 :5 ! n[ curr5t volumes ( our j\rnals are well-ransack$ works ( ref]5ce1 ^? :o look into !m w be glad to see ?is #ih feature ( our "t3 ,i !re=e make a few extracts1 fai?fully copi$ z to type4 ,! ,italic is f ! ,new ,te/am5t2 ! ,roman is ! requisite int]pretation3 ,rob]t ,cottle '0 numb]$ 7#eaif7 ) ! transgressors' at ! back ( ! ,*ur* 9 ,norwood ,cemet]y1 ,may #ab1 #aheh--;,isa4 liii4 #ab4 ,! ,rev4 ,j4 ,g4 ,coll9son1 ,m9i/] ( ,/4 ,james's ,*ur*1 ,*apham1 ! !n di/rict *ur*1 be=e ,all ,sa9ts 0 built1 read ! fun]al s]vice ov] ! ,sepul*re :]e9 nev] be=e man 0 laid4 ,hewn on ! /one1 'at ! m\? ( ! ,sepul*re1' is 8 "n1--,rob]t ,cottle1 born at ,bri/ol1 ,june #b1 #aggd2 di$ at ,kirk/all ,lodge1 ,clapham ,p>k1 ,may #f1 #aheh4 ,& t day 7,may #ab1 #aheh7 0 ! prep>ation 7day & ye> = '! ,,prep>$ place = y'--,cottleites---by ! wid[$ "m ( ! ,fa!r's h\se1 at ,kirk/all ,lodge--,john xiv4 #b1 #c74 ,& ! ,sabba? 7,*ri/mas ,day1 ,dec4 #be1 #ahei7 drew on 7= ! resurrection ( ! ,*ri/ian body on '! ?ird ,prote/ant ,sun-day'--#a ,cor4 xv4 #ce74 ,:y seek ye ! liv+ 7,god ( ! ,new ,j]usalem--,heb4 xii4 #bb2 ,rev4 iii4 #ab7 among ! dead 7m573 he 7! ,god ( ,jesus7 is n "h 79 ! grave71 b is ris5 79 ! p]son ( ! ,holy ,gho/1 f ! supp] ( '! dead 9 ! second dea?' ( ,paganism74 ,rememb] h[ he spake unto y 79 ! *ur* ( ! ,rev4 ,george ,clayton1#aig ,april #ad1 #ahci74 ,i w n dr9k h5ce=? 7at ?is la/ ,cottle supp]7 ( ! fruit ( ?is 7,tr9ity7 v9e1 until t day 7,*ri/mas ,day1 #ahei71 :5 ,i 7,elizabe? ,cottle7 dr9k x new ) y 7,cottleites7 9 my ,fa!r's k+dom--,john xv4 ,if ?is 7,tr9it>ian7 cup may n pass away f me 7,elizabe? ,cottle1 ,april #ad1 #ahci71 except ,i dr9k x 7'new ) y ,cottleites1 9 my ,fa!r's ,k+dom'71 ?y w be done--,matt4 xxvi4 #bi1 #db1 #fd4 ',our ,fa!r :i* art 7,god7 9 ,heav51' hall[$ be ?y "n1 ?y 7,cottle7 k+dom #ii come1 ?y w be done 9 e>?1 z x is 7done7 9 7! new7 ,heav5 7& new e>? ( ! new "n ( ,cottle--,rev4 xxi4 #a2 iii4 #ab74 444 ,que5 ,elizabe?1 f ,a4,d4 #aeeh to #aeff4 ,& ?is ,,^w yet once m 7by a second ,elizabe?--! ,,^w ( 8 oa?7 signifie? 7at ,john ,scott's baptism ( ! ,holy ,gho/7 ! remov+ ( ^? ?+s 7^? ,gods & ^? doctr9es7 t are made 7accord+ to ! ,cre$s & ,comm&m5ts ( m57 t ^? ?+s 79 ! moral law ( ,god7 :i* _c be %ak5 7z a rule ( fai? & practice7 may rema91 :]e=e we receiv+ 7f ,elizabe?7 a k+dom 7( ,god17 :i* _c be mov$ 7by ,satan7 let u h grace 79 8 ,grace ( ,cant]bury7 :]eby we may s]ve ,god acceptably 7) ! acceptable sacrifice ( ,elizabe?'s body & blood ( ! communion ( ! ,holy ,gho/7 ) rev]5ce 7= tru?7 & godly fe> 7( ! unp>donable s9 ( blasphemy aga9/ ! ,holy ,gho/7 = our ,god 7! ,holy ,gho/7 is a consum+ fire 7to ! nation t w n s]ve him 9 ! ,cottle ,*ur*74 ,we _c def5d ourselves aga9/ ! ,almighty1 & if ,he is our def5ce1 no nation c invade u4 ,9 v]se #d ! ,*ur* ( ,/4 ,pet] is 9 prison betwe5 f\r quat]nions ( soldi]s--! ,holy ,alliance ( #ahae4 ,rev4 vii4 i4 ,elizabe?1 ! ,angel ( ! ,"l ,jesus appe>s to ! ,jewi% & ,*ri/ian body ) ! vision ( prophecy to ! ,rev4 ,geo4 ,clayton & 8 cl]ical bre?r51 ,april #h?1 #ahci4 ,rhoda 0 ! "n ( h] maid at ,putney ,t]race :o us$ to op5 ! door to h] ,pet]1 ! ,rev4 ,rob]t ,a%ton1#aih ! ,pa/or ( '! little flock' '( #abj names toge!r1 assembl$ 9 an upp] 7s*ool7 room' at ,putney ,*apel1 to :i* little flock %e gave ! revelation 7,acts4 i4 #ac1 #ae7 ( ,jesus ! same ,k+ ( ! ,jews ye/]day at ! pray] meet+1 ,dec4 #ca1 #ahda1 & to-day1 #ajj ,jan4 #a1 #ahdb1 & = ev]4 ,see book ( ,life1 page #bd4 ,matt4 xviii4 #ai1 xxi4 #ac-af4 ,9 v]se #f ! ,italian body ( ,/4 ,pet] is sleep+ '9 ! second dea?' betwe5 ! two ,imp]ial soldi]s ( ,france & ,au/ria4 ,! ,emp]or ( ,france f ,jan4 #a1 to ,july #aa1 #ahei1 causes ! ,italian *a9s ( ,/4 ,pet] to fall (f f 8 ,imp]ial h&s4 ,i say unto !e1 ,rob]t ,a%ton1 ?\ art ,pet]1 a /one1 & ^u ?is rock1 ( tru?1 w ,i ,elizabe?1 ! angel ( ,jesus1 build my ,cottle ,*ur*1 & ! gates ( hell1 ! doors ( ,/4 ,pet]1 at ,rome1 %all n prevail aga9/ x--,matt4 xvi4 #ah4 ,rev4 iii4 #g-ab4 ,?is w be en\gh = ! purpose4 ,:5 any "o :o pleases c circulate new revelations ( ?is k9d1 un9t]rupt$ & unatt5d$ to1 new revelations w cease to be a good inve/m5t ( exc5tricity4 ,i take x = grant$ t ! g5tlem5 ^: names are m5tion$ h no?+ to d ) ! circul>s or _! doctr9es4 ,any lady :o may happ5 to be intru/$ ) a revelation may nom9ate h] own pa/or1 or any o!r cl]gyman1 "o ( h] apo/les2 & x is difficult to say to :at c\rt ! nom9ees c appeal to get ! commission abrogat$4 ,m>* #af1 #ahfe4 ,dur+ ! la/ two ye>s ! circul>s h cont9u$4 ,x is h9t$ t funds are l[3 & two g5tlem5 :o are repres5t$ z gone to ,be?lehem asylum 9 despair say t ,mrs4 ,cottle w sp5d all t %e ha?1 :ile ,h] ,maje/y's ,m9i/]s are fl\ri%+ on ! wages ( s94 ,! foll[+ is p]haps "o ( ! mo/ rem>kable passages 9 ! :ole3 ,extol & magnify ,him 7,jehovah1 ! ,ev]la/+ ,god1 see ! ,magnificat & ,luke i4 #de1 #df--fh--gc--gi71 t ride? 7by rail & /eam ov] l& & sea1 f 8 holy habitation at ,kirk/all ,lodge1 ,psa4 lxxvii4 #ai1 #bj71 ^u ! 7,cottle7 heav5s1 z x 7 7,sept4 #i1 #ahfd1 see pages #ba1 #agj71 ^u an 7ex]cis+1 ,psa4 cxxxi4 #a71 horse-7*air1 b\ght ( ,mr4 ,john ,w>d1 ,leice/]-squ>e74 #aja ,i h pretty good evid5ce t !re is a cl]gyman :o ?9ks ,mrs4 ,cottle a v s5sible woman4 ,! ,cottle ,*ur*4 ,_h ,i *anc$ to light ^u x at ! "t ( writ+1 ,i %\ld c]ta9ly h giv5 ! foll[+4 ,a pr9t$ lett] to ! ,we/]n ,times1 by ,mr4 ,rob]t ,cottle1 0 accompani$ by a manuscript lett] f ,mrs4 ,cottle1 app>5tly a circul>4 ,! date 0 ,novr4 #ahec1 & ! subject 0 ! proc$ure aga9/ ,mr4 ,maurice#aii at ,k+'s ,college = d\bt+ t ,god w\ld puni% human s9s by an exi/5ce ( torture la/+ ?r\gh ye>s numb]$ by millions ( millions ( millions ( millions 7repeat ! ^w millions )\t end17 etc4 ,! memory ( ,mr4 ,cottle has1 ,i ?9k1 a "r to ! quotation3 he seems to h be5 no p>ticipator 9 ! notions ( 8 wife3 ,! cl]gy ( ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*1 tak5 at ! r\nd numb] ( #bj1jjj1 may1 9 _! fir/ e/ate1 be lik5$ to #bj1jjj gold blanks1 de/9$ to become sov]eigns1 9 succession1--!y are plac$ betwe5 ! matrix ( ! ,m9t1 :51 by ! pressure ( ! screw1 !y receive ! impress t fits !m to become "p ( ! curr5t co9 ( ! realm4 ,9 a way some:at analog\s ?is great body ( ! cl]gy h ea* pass$ ?r\gh ! crucibles ( ,ox=d & ,cambridge1--h be5 assay$ by ! ,bi%op's *apla91 t\*+ ! heal? ( _! s\ls1 & ! validity ( _! call by ! ,div9e ,_s1 & !n ! g5tle pressure ( a prelate's h& ^u _! heads2 & ! words--',receive ! ,holy ,gho/1' h1 9 a brief space ( "t1 wr\ght a #ajb *ange 9 !m1 mu* ak9 to ! miracle ( transub/antiation--! prie/s are complet$1 & !y become ! curr5t ecclesia/ical co9 ( our c\ntry4 ,! :ole body ( cl]gy1 "h spok5 (1 h und]gone ! prelim9>y induction ( baptism & confirmation2 & all h be5 duly orda9$1 pr(ess+ to hold "o fai?1 & to believe 9 ! selfsame doctr9es6 ,9 %ort1 to be z id5tical z ! #bj1jjj sov]eigns1 if comp>$ "o ) ! o!r4 ,b m9d is n malleable & ductile1 l gold2 & all ! prep>ations ( te/s1 cre$s1 & cate*isms w n insure uni=mity ( belief4 ,no /amp ( or?odoxy w produce ! same impress on ! m9ds ( diff]5t m54 ,v>iety is manife/1 & pat5t1 ^u ev]y?+ m5tal & mat]ial4 ,! ,almighty has n creat$1 nor man fa%ion$1 two ?+s alike6 ,h[ futile1 !n1 is ! attempt to %ape & m\ld man's appreh5sion ( div9e tru? by "o fallible /&>d ( man's inv5tion6 ,if pro( ( ?is be requir$1 an appeal might be made to hi/ory & ! exp]i5ce ( eighte5 hundr$ ye>s4 ,?is is an argum5t ( =ce aga9/ ! reasonabl5ess ( expect+ t5s ( ?\s&s ( educat$ read]s ( ! ,new ,te/am5t to f9d ! doctr9e above describ$ 9 x4 ,! lady's argum5t aga9/ ! doctr9e itself is v /rik+4 ,speak+ ( an outcry on ?is matt] among ! ,diss5t]s aga9/ "o ( _! body1 :o 0 ! son ( ! ,:ite ,/one 7,rev4 ii4 #ag71 or ! ,roman cem5t-mak]1 %e says-- ,if ! doctr9e = :i* !y s wick$ly fight 7 true1 :at w\ld become ( ! black g5tlem5 = ^: r$emption ,i h be5 sacrific$ f ,april #h #ahci4 ,!re are c]ta9ly v curi\s po9ts ab\t ?is revelation4 ,!re h be5 _m surmises ab\t ! f9al re/oration ( ! inf]nal spirits1 f ! e>lie/ ages ( ,*ri/ianity until our own day3 a collection ( !m w\ld be wor? mak+4 ,on read+ ?is 9 pro(1 ,i see a possibility t by black g5tlem5 may be meant ! cl]gy3 #ajc ,i suppose my fir/ int]pretation mu/ h be5 sugge/$ by context3 ,i leave ! po9t to ! read]'s sagacity4 ,,james ,,smi?1 ,,ar*-,,p>adox]4 ,! ,problem ( squ>+ ! circle solv$2 or1 ! circumf]5ce & area ( ! circle discov]$4 ,by ,james ,smi?4#bjj ,london1 #ahei1 #hvo4 ,on ! relations ( a squ>e inscrib$ 9 a circle4 ,read at ! ,briti% ,association1 ,sept4 #ahei1 publi%$ 9 ! ,liv]pool ,c\ri]1 ,oct4 #h1 #ahei1 & repr9t$ 9 broad%eet4 ,! "q3 ,are !re any comm5surable relations betwe5 a circle & o!r ,geometrical figures8 ,answ]$ by a memb] ( ! ,briti% ,association 444 ,london1 #ahfj1 #hvo4--,?is has be5 translat$ into ,fr5* by ,m4 ,arm& ,grange1 ,bordeaux1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,! ,quadrature ( ! ,circle4 ,correspond5ce betwe5 an em95t ma!matician & ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 7,memb] ( ! ,m]sey ,docks & ,h>b\r ,bo>d71 ,london1 #ahfa1 #hvo4 7pp4 #bjj74 ,lett] to ! 444 ,briti% ,association 444 by ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 ,liv]pool1 #ahfa1 #hvo4 ,lett] to ! 444 ,briti% ,association 444 by ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 ,liv]pool1 #ahfb1 #hvo4--,^! lett]s ! au?or promis$ to cont9ue4 ,a ,nut to crack = ! read]s ( ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan's ',budget ( ,p>adoxes4' ,by ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 ,liv]pool1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,pap] read at ! ,liv]pool ,lit]>y & ,philosophical ,society1 report$ 9 ! ,liv]pool ,daily ,c\ri]1 ,jan4 #bf1 #ahfd4 ,repr9t$ z a pamphlet4 ,! ,quadrature ( ! circle1 or ! true ratio betwe5 ! diamet] & circumf]5ce geometrically & ma!matically demon/rat$4 ,by ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 ,liv]pool1 #ahfe1 #hvo4 #ajd ,on ! relations betwe5 ! dim5sions & di/ances ( ! ,sun1 ,moon1 & ,e>?2 a pap] read be=e ! ,lit]>y & ,philosophical ,society ( ,liv]pool1 ,jan4 #be1 #ahfd4 ,by ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 ,! ,briti% ,association 9 ,jeop>dy1 & ,dr4 ,:ewell1 ! ,ma/] ( ,tr9ity1 9 ! /ocks )\t hope ( escape4 ,pr9t$ = ! au?ors 7,j4 ,s4 confess$1 & also hidd5 "u ,nauticus74 7,no date1 #ahfe74 ,! ,briti% ,association 9 ,jeop>dy1 & ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan 9 ! ,pillory )\t hope ( escape4 ,london1 #ahff1 #hvo4 ,:5 my "w appe>$ 9 numb]s1 ,i _h n any?+ l an adequate idea ( ,mr4 ,james ,smi?'s sup]iority to ! re/ ( ! _w 9 ! po9ts 9 :i* he is sup]ior4 ,he is beyond a d\bt ! able/ head at unreason+1 & ! greate/ h& at writ+ x1 ( all :o h tri$ 9 our day to atta* _! names to an error4 ,common cyclomet]s s9k into puny or?odoxy by 8 side4 ,! behavior ( ?is s+ul> "* induces me to pay him ! complim5t :i* ,a*illes paid ,hector1 to drag him r\nd ! walls aga9 & aga94 ,he 0 treat$ ) unusual notice & 9 ! mo/ g5tle mann]4 ,! unnam$ ma!matician1 ,e4 ,m4 be/[$ a volume ( mild correspond5ce ^u him2 ,r[an ,hamilton#bja quietly prov$ him wrong 9 a way accessible to an ord9>y s*oolboy2 ,:ewell1#bjb z we %all see1 gave him ! means ( see+ himself wrong1 ev5 m easily ?an by ,hamilton's me?od4 ,no?+ w\ld d2 x 0 small kick & silly fl+ at all2 & he expos$ 8 conceit by alleg+ t he1 ,james ,smi?1 _h plac$ ,:ewell 9 ! /ocks4 ,he w !re=e be univ]sally pron\nc$ a prop] object ( ! sev]e/ lit]>y puni%m5t3 b ! op9ion ( all :o c put two propositions toge!r w be t ( ! _m /rokes ,i h giv51 ! h>de/ & mo/ tell+ are my republications ( 8 own attempts to reason4 ,he w come out ( my h&s 9 ! position he ought #aje to hold1 ! ,supreme ,pontiff ( cyclomet]s1 ! viceg]5t ( ,/4 ,vitus ^u e>?1 ! ,mamam\*i ( burlesque on inf]5ce4 ,i beg9 ) a review ( him :i* appe>$ 9 ! ,a!naeum ( ,may #aa1 #ahfa4 ,mr4 ,smi? says ,i wrote x3 ?is ,i nei!r affirm nor d5y2 to d ei!r w\ld be a s9 aga9/ ! editorial sy/em else:]e describ$4 ,_m p]sons tell me !y "k me by my /yle2 let !m =m a guess3 ,i c only say t _m h decl>$ z above :ile fa/5+ on me some?+ :i* ,i _h nev] se5 nor he>d (4 ,! ,quadrature ( ! ,circle3 ,correspond5ce betwe5 an ,em95t ,ma!matician & ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 7,ed9burgh1 ,oliv] ,boyd2 ,london1 ,simpk91 ,m>%all ,co47 ,a few weeks ago we 7 9 p]petual motion4 ,we did n !n suppose t any?+ w\ld tempt u on a circle-squ>+ exp$ition3 b ! circum/ances ( ! book above nam$ h a peculi>ity :i* induces u to give x a few words4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 a g5tleman resid+ ne> ,liv]pool1 0 "s ye>s ago seiz$ ) ! morbus cyclometricus4#bjc ,! symptoms soon took a def9$ =m3 8 circumf]5ce %rank into exactly #c-a_/h times 8 diamet]1 in/ead ( close to #c-af_/aac1 :i* ! ma!matician kn[s to be s ne> to tru? t ! error is h>dly at ! rate ( a foot 9 #b1jjj miles4 ,?is %r9k+ ( ! circumf]5ce rema9$ until x became absolutely necess>y t x %\ld be exam9$ by ! ,briti% ,association4 ,?is body1 :i* z ,mr4 ,james ,smi? f\nd to 8 sorr[1 has "s int]e/ 9 'jeal\sly gu>d+ ! my/]ies ( _! pr(ession1' refus$ at fir/ to ent]ta9 ! "q4 ,on ?is ,mr4 ,smi? *ang$ 8 'tactics' & ! "n ( 8 pap]1 & smuggl$ 9 ! subject "u ! =m ( ',! ,relations ( a ,circle inscrib$ 9 a ,squ>e'6 ,! pap] 0 ?us =c$ ^u ! ,association1 = ,mr4 ,smi? in=ms u t he #ajf 'gave ! ,section to und]/& t he 0 n ! man t w\ld p]mit ev5 ! ,briti% ,association to trifle ) him4' ,9 o!r words1 ! ,association bore ) & 7 bor$ ) ! pap]1 z ! %orte/ way out ( ! matt]4 ,mr4 ,smi? also circulat$ a pamphlet4 ,"s k9d-he>t$ man1 :o did n "k ! disord] z well z we d1 & :o appe>s 9 ,mr4 ,smi?'s h&some octavo z ,e4 ,m4--! initials ( 'em95t ma!matician'--wrote to him & (f]$ to %[ him 9 a page t he 0 all wrong4 ,mr4 ,smi? !reupon op5$ a correspond5ce1 :i* is ! bulk ( ! volume4 ,:5 ! correspond5ce 0 f> advanc$1 ,mr4 ,smi? ann\nc$ 8 int5tion to publi%4 ,8 b5evol5t in/ructor--we mean 9 int5tion--prote/$ aga9/ ! publication1 say+ ',i d n wi% to be gibbet$ to ! _w z hav+ be5 fooli% en\gh to ent] ^u :at ,i feel n[ to h be5 a ridicul\s ent]prise4' ,= ?is ,mr4 ,smi? c>$ no?+3 he p]si/$ 9 ! publication1 & ! book is be=e u4 ,mr4 ,smi? has _h s mu* grace z to conceal 8 k9d advis]'s "n "u ,e4 ,m41 t is to say1 he has divid$ ! wrong among all :o may be suspect$ ( hav+ attempt$ s hopeless a task z t ( putt+ a little s5se into 8 head4 ,he has violat$ ! dec5cies ( private life4 ,aga9/ ! w ( ! k9d-he>t$ man :o und]took 8 case1 he has publi%$ lett]s :i* 7 int5d$ = no o!r purpose ?an to cle> 8 poor head ( a hopeless delusion4 ,he des]ves ! sev]e/ ca/igation2 & he w get x3 8 abuse ( confid5ce w /ick by him all 8 days4 ,n t he has done 8 b5efactor--9 int5tion1 aga9--any h>m4 ,! pati5ce ) :i* ,e4 ,m4 put ! blund]s into intelligible =m1 & ! p]sev]ance ) :i* he tri$ to f9d a cranny-hole = common reason+ to get 9 at1 are m ?an respectable3 !y are admirable4 ,x is1 we c assure ,e4 ,m41 a good ?+ t ! nature ( ! circle-squ>] %\ld be s completely expos$ z 9 ?is volume4 ,! b5efit :i* he int5d$ ,mr4 ,james ,smi? may be #ajg conf]r$ ^u o!rs4 ,& we %\ld v mu* l to "k 8 "n1 & if agreeable to him1 to publi% x4 ,z to ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 we c only say ?is3 he is n mad4 ,madm5 reason rightly ^u wrong premises3 ,mr4 ,smi? reasons wrongly ^u no premises at all4 ,e4 ,m4 v soon f\nd out t1 to all appe>ance1 ,mr4 ,smi? got a circle ( #c-a_/h times ! diamet] by mak+ x ! supposition to set out ) t !re 0 su* a circle2 & !n f9d+ c]ta9 consequ5ces :i*1 s x happ5$1 7 n inconsi/5t ) ! supposition on :i* !y 7 made4 ,error is sometimes self-consi/5t4 ,h[ev]1 ,e4 ,m41 to be q sure ( 8 gr\nd1 wrote a %ort lett]1 /at+ :at he took to be ,mr4 ,smi?'s hypo!sis1 conta9+ ! foll[+3 ',on ,,ac z diamet]1 describe ! circle ,d1 :i* by hypo!sis %all be equal to ?ree & "o-eigh? times ! l5g? ( ,,ac4444 ,i beg1 be=e proce$+ fur!r1 to ask :e!r ,i h rightly /at$ y\r argum5t4' ,to :i* ,mr4 ,smi? repli$3 ',y h /at$ my argum5t ) p]fect accuracy4' ,/ill ,e4 ,m4 w5t on1 & we c\ld n help1 aft] ! above1 tak+ ^! lett]s z ! initials ( ,ev]la/+ ,m]cy4 ,at la/1 h[ev]1 :5 ,mr4 ,smi? flatly d5i$ t ! area ( ! circle lies betwe5 ^? ( ! inscrib$ & circumscrib$ polygons1 ,e4 ,m4 0 fairly beat51 & gave up ! task4 ,mr4 ,smi? 0 left to write 8 preface1 to talk ab\t ! c]ta9 victory ( tru?--:i*1 oddly en\gh1 is ! consolation ( all hopelessly mi/ak5 m52 to comp>e himself ) ,galileo2 & to expose to ! _w ! p]v]se behavior ( ! ,a/ronom] ,royal1 on :om he want$ to fa/5 a conv]sation1 & :o repli$1 ',x w\ld be a wa/e ( "t1 ,sir1 to li/5 to any?+ y c\ld h to say on su* a subject4' ,hav+ ?us dispos$ ( ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 we proce$ to a few rem>ks on ! subject3 x is "o :i* a j\rnal w\ld nev] orig9ate1 b :i* is r5d]$ necess>y f "t to "t by ! attempts ( ! autopseu/ic to become #ajh het]opseu/ic4 ,to ! ma!matician we h no?+ to say3 ! "q is1 :at k9d ( assurance c be giv5 to ! _w at l>ge t ! wick$ ma!maticians are n act+ 9 conc]t to keep d[n _! sup]ior1 ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 ! curr5t ,galileo ( ! quadrature ( ! circle4 ,let u fir/ obs]ve t ?is "q does n /& alone3 indep5d5tly ( ! millions ( simil> problems :i* exi/ 9 high] ma!matics1 ! f9d+ ( ! diagonal ( a squ>e has j ! same difficulty1 namely1 ! entrance ( a pair ( l9es ( :i* "o _c be def9itely express$ by means ( ! o!r4 ,we w %[ ! read] :o is up to ! multiplication-table h[ he may g on1 on1 on1 ev] ne>]1 nev] !re1 9 f9d+ ! diagonal ( a squ>e f ! side4 ,write d[n ! foll[+ r[s ( figures1 & m1 if y l1 9 ! way describ$3 #a #b #e #ab #bi #gj #afi #djh #ihe #a #c #g #ag #da #ii #bci #egg #acic ,aft] ! second1 ea* numb] is made up ( d\ble ! la/ increas$ by ! la/ b "o3 ?us1 #e is #a m ?an twice #b1 #ab is #b m ?an twice #e1 #bci is #da m ?an twice #ii4 ,n[1 take out two adjac5t numb]s f ! upp] l9e1 & ! "o bel[ ! fir/ f ! l[]3 z #gj #afi #ii4 ,multiply toge!r #ii & #afi1 giv+ #af1gca4 ,if1 !n1 y w say t #gj diagonals are exactly equal to #ii sides1 y are 9 error ab\t ! diagonal1 b an error ! am\nt ( :i* is n s great z ! #af1gca/ "p ( ! diagonal4 ,simil>ly1 to say t five diagonals make exactly sev5 sides does n involve an error ( ! #hd? "p ( ! diagonal4 ,n[1 :y has n ! "q ( cross+ ! squ>e be5 z celebrat$ z t ( squ>+ ! circle8 ,m]ely because ,euclid demon/rat$ ! impossibility ( ! fir/ #aji "q1 :ile t ( ! second 0 n demon/rat$1 completely1 until ! la/ c5tury4 ,! ma!maticians h _m me?ods1 totally diff]5t f ea* o!r1 ( arriv+ at "o & ! same result1 _! celebrat$ approximation to ! circumf]5ce ( ! circle4 ,an intrepid calculator has1 9 our own "t1 c>ri$ 8 approximation to :at !y call #fjg decimal places3 ?is has be5 done by ,mr4 ,%anks1#bjd ( ,h\ghton-le-,spr+1 & ,dr4 ,ru!r=d#bje has v]ifi$ #dda ( ^! places4 ,b ?\gh #fjg looks l>ge1 ! g5]al public w =m b a hazy notion ( ! ext5t ( accuracy acquir$4 ,we h se51 9 ,*>les ,knight's#bjf ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia1 an acc\nt ( ! matt] :i* may illu/rate ! unimag9able1 ?\gh rationally conceivable1 ext5t ( accuracy obta9$4 ,say t ! blood-globule ( "o ( our animalcules is a million? ( an in* 9 diamet]4 ,fa%ion 9 ?\ght a globe l our own1 b s mu* l>g] t our globe is b a blood-globule 9 "o ( its animalcules3 nev] m9d ! microscope :i* %[s ! creature be+ r a bulky in/rum5t4 ,call ?is ! fir/ globe above u4 ,let ! fir/ globe above u be b a blood-globule1 z to size1 9 ! animalcule ( a /ill l>g] globe1 :i* call ! second globe above u4 ,g on 9 ?is way to ! tw5tie? globe above u4 ,n[ g d[n j z f> on ! o!r side4 ,let ! blood-globule ) :i* we />t$ be a globe peopl$ ) animals l ours1 b r small]3 #aaj & call ?is ! fir/ globe bel[ u4 ,take a blood-globule out ( ?is globe1 p x1 & call x ! second globe bel[ u3 & s on to ! tw5tie? globe bel[ u4 ,?is is a f9e /ret* ( progression bo? ways4 ,n[ give ! giant ( ! tw5tie? globe above u ! #fjg decimal places1 &1 :5 he has measur$ ! diamet] ( 8 globe ) accuracy wor?y ( 8 size1 let him calculate ! circumf]5ce ( 8 equator f ! #fjg places4 ,br+ ! little philosoph] f ! tw5tie? globe bel[ u ) 8 v be/ microscope1 & set him to see ! small error :i* ! giant mu/ make4 ,he w n succe$1 unless 8 microscopes be mu* bett] = 8 size ?an ours are = ours4 ,n[ x mu/ be rememb]$ by any "o :o w\ld laugh at ! clos5ess ( ! approximation1 t ! ma!matician g5]ally goes ne>]2 9 fact 8 !orems h usually no error at all4 ,! v p]son :o is bewild]$ by ! prec$+ description may easily =get t if !re 7 no error at all1 ! ,lilliputian ( ! million? globe bel[ u c\ld n f9d a flaw 9 ! ,brobd+nagian ( ! million? globe above4 ,! ?ree angles ( a triangle1 ( p]fect accuracy ( =m1 are absolutely equal to two "r angles2 no /ret* ( progression w detect any error4 ,n[ ?9k ( ,mr4 ,lacomme's ma!matical advis] 7ante1 ,vol4 ,i1 p4 #df7 mak+ a difficulty ( advis+ a /onemason ab\t ! quantity ( pavem5t 9 a circul> floor6 ,we w n[1 = our non-calculat+ read]1 put ! matt] 9 ano!r way4 ,we see t a circle-squ>] c advance1 ) ! utmo/ confid5ce1 ! ass]tion t :5 ! diamet] is #a1jjj1 ! circumf]5ce is accurately #c1abe3 ! ma!matician decl>+ t x is a trifle m ?an #c1ada-a_/b4 ,if ! squ>] be "r1 ! ma!matician has err$ by ab\t a #bjj? "p ( ! :ole3 or has n kept 8 acc\nts "r by ab\t #ajs4 9 e #ajjl4 ,( c\rse1 if he set out ) su* an error he w accumulate blund] ^u blund]4 ,n[1 if !re be a process 9 :i* #aaa close k ( ! circle is requisite1 x is 9 ! pr$iction ( ! moon's place--say1 z to ! "t ( pass+ ! m]idian at ,gre5wi*--on a giv5 day4 ,we _c give ! lea/ idea ( ! complication ( details3 b common s5se w tell u t if a ma!matician _c f9d 8 way r\nd ! circle )\t a relative error f\r times z big z a /ockbrok]'s commission1 he mu/ ne$s be dreadfully out 9 8 attempt to pr$ict ! "t ( passage ( ! moon4 ,n[1 :at is ! fact8 ,8 error is less ?an a second ( "t1 & ! moon takes #bg days odd to revolve4 ,t is to say1 sett+ out ) #ajs4 9 #ajjl4 ( error 9 8 circumf]5ce1 he gets )9 ! fif? "p ( a f>?+ 9 #ajjl4 9 pr$ict+ ! moon's transit4 ,n[ we _c ?9k t ! respect 9 :i* ma!matical sci5ce is held is great en\gh--?\gh we f9d x n small--to make ?is g d[n4 ,t respect is f\nd$ ^u a notion t "r ends are got by "r means3 x w h>dly be cr$it$ t ! tru? c be got to f>?+s out ( data :i* are wrong by %ill+s4 ,ev5 ! celebrat$ ,hamilton#bjg ( ,ed9burgh1 :o held t 9 ma!matics !re 0 no way ( go+ wrong1 0 fully impress$ ) ! belief t ?is 0 because error 0 avoid$ f ! beg9n+4 ,he nev] w5t s f> z to say t a ma!matician :o beg9s wrong mu/ end "r someh[4 ,!re is always a difficulty ab\t ! mode 9 :i* ! ?9k+ man ( common life is to deal ) subjects he has n /udi$ to a pr(essional ext5t4 ,he mu/ =m op9ions on matt]s !ological1 political1 legal1 m$ical1 & social4 ,if he c make up 8 m9d to *oose a guide1 !re is1 ( c\rse1 no p]plexity3 b on all ! subjects m5tion$ ! direction-po/s po9t diff]5t ways4 ,n[ :y %\ld he n =m 8 op9ion ^u an ab/ract ma!matical "q8 ,:y n conclude t1 z to ! circle1 x is possible ,mr4 ,james ,smi? may be ! man1 j #aab z ,adam ,smi?#bjh 0 ! man ( ?+s !n to come1 or ,lu!r1 or ,galileo8 ,x is true t !re is an unanimity among ma!maticians :i* prevails 9 no o!r class3 b ?is makes ! *ance ( _! all be+ wrong only diff]5t 9 degree4 ,& m ?an ?is1 is x n g5]ally ?\ght among u t prie/s & physicians 7 nev] s mu* wrong z :5 !re 0 mo/ appe>ance ( unanimity among !m8 ,to ! prec$+ que/ions we see no answ] except ?is1 t ! individual inquir] may z rationally decide a ma!matical "q = himself z a !ological or a m$ical "q1 s soon z he c put himself into a position 9 ma!matics1 level ) t 9 :i* he /&s 9 !ology or m$ic9e4 ,! e-day ?\ght & read+ ( common life h a c]ta9 resemblance to ! ?\ght & read+ dem&$ by ! le>n$ faculties4 ,! rese>*1 ! balance ( evid5ce1 ! e/imation ( probabilities1 :i* are us$ 9 a "q ( m$ic9e1 are closely ak9 9 "*1 h[ev] diff]5t ! matt] ( application1 to ^? :i* s]ve a m]*ant to draw 8 conclusions ab\t ! m>kets4 ,b ! ma!maticians h me?ods ( _! own1 to :i* no?+ 9 common life be>s close analogy1 z to ! nature ( ! results or ! "* ( ! conclusions4 ,! logic ( ma!matics is c]ta9ly t ( common life3 b ! data are ( a diff]5t species2 !y d n admit ( d\bt4 ,an exp]t ari?metician1 su* z is ,mr4 ,j4 ,smi?1 may fancy t calculation1 m]ely z su*1 is ma!matics3 b ! value ( 8 book1 & 9 ?is po9t ( view x is n small1 is ! full mann] 9 :i* x %[s t a practis$ ari?metician1 v5tur+ into ! field ( ma!matical demon/ration1 may %[ himself utt]ly de/itute ( all t di/+ui%es ! reason+ geometrical inve/igator f ! calculator4 #aac ,& fur!r1 x %\ld be rememb]$ t 9 ma!matics ! p[] ( v]ify+ results f> exce$s t :i* is f\nd 9 any?+ else3 & also ! v>iety ( di/9ct me?ods by :i* !y c be atta9$4 ,x foll[s f all ?is t a p]son :o desires to be z ne> ! tru? z he c w n judge ! results ( ma!matical demon/ration to be op5 to 8 criticism1 9 ! same degree z results ( o!r k9ds4 ,%\ld he feel compell$ to decide1 !re is no h>m done3 8 circle may be #c-a_/h times its diamet]1 if x please him4 ,b we mu/ w>n him t1 9 ord] to get ?is circle1 he mu/1 z ,mr4 ,james ,smi? has done1 make x at home3 ! laws ( space & ?\ght beg leave respectfully to decl9e ! ord]4 ,i w ins]t n[ at l5g?1 f ! ,a!naeum ( ,june #h1 #ahfa1 ! easy refutation giv5 by my deceas$ fri5d1 ) ! rem>ks :i* prec$e4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 ( ^: p]=mance 9 ! way ( squ>+ ! circle we spoke "s weeks ago 9 t]ms %ort ( entire acquiesc5ce1 has adv]tis$ himself 9 our columns1 z our read]s w h se54 ,he has also =w>d$ 8 lett] to ! ,liv]pool ,albion1 ) an additional /atem5t1 :i* he did n make 9 our j\rnal4 ,he d5ies t he has violat$ ! dec5cies ( private life1 s9ce 8 correspond5t revis$ ! pro(s ( 8 own lett]s1 & 8 'prote/ _h respect only to mak+ 8 "n public4' ,?is /atem5t ,mr4 ,james ,smi? prec$es by say+ t we h treat$ z true :at we well knew to be false3 & he foll[s by say+ t we h n read 8 "w1 or we %\ld h kn[n ! above facts to be true4 ,mr4 ,smi?'s pretext is z foll[s4 ,8 correspond5t ,e4 ,m4 says1 ',my lett]s 7 n int5d$ = publication1 & ,i prote/ aga9/ _! be+ publi%$1' & he subjo9s ',!re=e ,i mu/ desire t my "n may n be us$4' ,! obvi\s mean+ is t ,e4 ,m4 prote/$ aga9/ ! publication altoge!r1 b1 judg+ t ,mr4 ,smi? 0 #aad det]m9$ to publi%1 desir$ t 8 "n %\ld n be us$4 ,t he aft]w>ds correct$ ! pro(s m]ely means t he ?\ght x wis] to let !m pass "u 8 own eyes ?an to leave !m entirely to ,mr4 ,smi?4 ,we h receiv$ f ,sir ,w4 ,r[an ,hamilton#bji a pro( t ! circumf]5ce is m ?an #c-a_/h diamet]s1 requir+ no?+ b a k ( f\r books ( ,euclid4 ,we give x 9 brief z an ex]cise = our juv5ile read]s to fill up4 ,x rem9ds u ( ! old days :5 real geomet]s us$ to ?9k x wor? :ile s]i\sly to demoli% pret5d]s4 ,mr4 ,smi?'s fame is n[ assur$3 ,sir ,w4 ,r4 ,hamilton's brief & easy exposure w procure him notice 9 connection ) ?is celebrat$ problem4 ,x is to be %[n t ! p]imet] ( a regul> polygon ( #bj sides is great] ?an #c-a_/h diamet]s ( ! circle1 & /ill m1 ( c\rse1 is ! circumf]5ce ( ! circle great] ?an #c-a_/h diamet]s4 #a4 ,x foll[s f ! #d? ,book ( ,euclid1 t ! rectangle "u ! side ( a regul> decagon inscrib$ 9 a circle1 & t side increas$ by ! radius1 is equal to ! squ>e ( ! radius4 ,b ! product #gia 7#gia #abhj7 is less ?an #abhj x #abhj2 if !n ! radius be #abhj ! side ( ! decagon is great] ?an #gia4 #b4 ,:5 a diamet] bisects a *ord1 ! squ>e ( ! *ord is equal to ! rectangle "u ! d\bles ( ! segm5ts ( ! diamet]4 ,b ! product #abe 7#d x #abhj - #abe7 is less ?an #gia x #gia4 ,if !n ! bisect$ *ord be a side ( ! decagon1 & if ! radius be /ill #abhj1 ! d\ble ( ! less] segm5t exce$s #abe4 #c4 ,! rectangle "u ?is d\bl$ segm5t & ! radius is equal to ! squ>e ( ! side ( an inscrib$ regul> polygon ( #bj sides4 ,b ! product #abe x #abhj is equal to #djj x #djj2 !re=e1 ! side ( ! la/-m5tion$ polygon is great] ?an #djj1 if ! radius be /ill #abhj4 ,9 o!r words1 if ! radius be repres5t$ by ! new #aae memb] #af1 & !re=e ! diamet] by #cb1 ?is side is great] ?an #e1 & ! p]imet] exce$s #ajj4 ,s t1 f9ally1 if ! diamet] be #h1 ! p]imet] ( ! inscrib$ regul> polygon ( #bj sides1 & /ill m ! circumf]5ce ( ! circle1 is great] ?an #be3 t is1 ! circumf]5ce is m ?an #c-a_/h diamet]s4 ,! la/ "w 9 ! li/ 0 ?us notic$ 9 ! ,a!naeum1 ,may #bg1 #ahfe4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? appe>s to be tir$ ( wait+ = 8 place 9 ! ,budget ( ,p>adoxes1 & accord+ly publi%es a long lett] to ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan1 ) v>i\s prefaces & po/scripts4 ,! lett] op5s by a h9t t ! ,budget appe>s at v long int]vals1 & 'app>5tly )\t any suffici5t reason = x4' ,z ,mr4 ,smi? h9ts t he %\ld l to see ,mr4 ,de ,morgan1 :om he calls an 'elephant ( ma!matics1' 'pump+ 8 bra9s' 'beh9d ! sc5es'--an odd ?+ = an elephant to d1 & an odd place to d x 9--to get an answ]1 we ?9k he may mean to h9t t ! ,budget is delay$ until ! pump has work$ successfully4 ,mr4 ,smi? is in=m$ t we h _h ! :ole manuscript ( ! ,budget1 except+ only a f9al summ+-up1 9 our h&s s9ce ,octob]1 #ahfc4 ,?is does n ref] to ! ,supplem5t4 ,!re has be5 no delay3 we knew f ! beg9n+ t a s]ies ( hi/orical articles w\ld be frequ5tly int]rupt$ by ! ?+s ( ! day4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? lets out t he has nev] be5 able to get a private l9e f ,mr4 ,de ,morgan 9 answ] to 8 communications3 we %\ld h guess$ x4 ,he says1 ',! ,pr(essor is an old bird & n to be easily caught1 & by no ef=ts ( m9e h ,i be5 able1 up to ! pres5t mom5t1 ei!r to induce or twit him into a discussion4444' ,mr4 ,smi? curtails ! prov]b3 old birds are n to be caught ) *aff1 nor ) twit1 :i* seems to be ,mr4 ,smi?'s ^w = 8 own *aff1 &1 s long z ! fir/ lett] is s\nd$1 a v prop] ^w4 ,:y does he n try a little gra9 ( s5se8 ,mr4 ,smi? evid5tly #aaf ?9ks t1 9 8 "* z an elephant1 ! ,pr(essor has n pump$ up bra9 en\gh to furni% =? a bird4 ,9 s]i\s e>ne/1 ,mr4 ,smi? ne$s no answ]4 ,9 "o ?+ he excites our curiosity3 :at is meant by demon/rat+ 'geometrically & ma!matically8' ,i n[ proce$ to my orig9al treatm5t ( ! case4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? w1 ,i h no d\bt1 be ! mo/ uneclips$ circle-squ>] ( our day4 ,he w n owe ?is di/9ction to 8 be+ an influ5tial & respect$ memb] ( ! comm]cial _w ( ,liv]pool1 ev5 ?\gh ! p[] ( publi%+ :i* 8 means give him %\ld induce him to issue a :ole libr>y ^u "o p>adox4 ,nei!r w he owe x to ! pa9s tak5 ) him by a ma!matician :o correspond$ ) him until ! jo9t lett]s fill$ an octavo volume4 ,nei!r w he owe x to ! notice tak5 ( him by ,sir ,william ,hamilton1 ( ,dubl91 :o refut$ him 9 a mann] intelligible to an ord9>y /ud5t ( ,euclid1 :i* refutation he calls a rem>kable p>adox easily expla9able1 b )\t expla9+ x4 ,:at he w owe x to ,i proce$ to %[4 ,until ! publication ( ! ,nut to ,crack ,mr4 ,james ,smi? /ood among circle-squ>]s 9 g5]al4 ,i might h treat$ him ) ridicule1 z ,i h done o!rs3 & he says t he does n d\bt he %all come 9 = 8 %>e at ! tail end ( my ,budget4 ,b ,i c make a bett] job ( him ?an s1 z ,locke w\ld h phras$ x3 he is su* a v /rik+ example ( some?+ ,i h said on ! use ( logic t ,i pref] to make an example ( 8 writ+s4 ,on "o po9t inde$ he well des]ves ! scutica1#baj if n ! horribile flagellum4#baa ,he tells me t he w br+ 8 solution to me 9 su* a =m z %all compel me to admit x z un fait accompli une faute accomplie8#bab #aag or leave myself op5 to ! humiliat+ *>ge ( ma!matical ignorance & folly4 ,he has also honor$ me ) "s private lett]s4 ,9 ! fir/ ( ^! he gives me a piece ( in=mation1 aft] :i* he _c imag9e t ,i1 z an hone/ ma!matician1 c possibly h ! slighte/ hesitation 9 admitt+ 8 solution4 ,!re is a tol]able res]voir ( mode/ assurance 9 a man :o writes to a p]fect /rang] ) :at he takes = an argum5t1 & gives an oblique ?reat ( imputation ( di%one/y 9 case ! argum5t be n admitt$ )\t hesitation2 n to speak ( ! m9or *>ges ( ignorance & folly4 ,all ?is is bl9d self-confid5ce1 )\t mixture ( malici\s mean+2 & ,i r l x3 x makes me und]/& h[ ,sam ,johnson came to say ( 8 old fri5d ,mrs4 ,cobb1#bac--;,i love ,moll ,cobb = h] impud5ce4 ,i h n[ done ) my fri5d's suavit] 9 modo1#bad & proce$ to 8 =tit] 9 re#bae3 ,i %all %[ t he has convict$ himself ( ignorance & folly1 ) an hone/y & c&or wor?y ( a bett] value ( pi4 ,mr4 ,smi?'s me?od ( prov+ t e circle is #c-a_/h diamet]s is to assume t x is s1--if y dislike ! t]m datum1 !n1 by hypo!sis1 let #h circumf]5ces be exactly equal to #be diamet]s1--& !n to %[ t e o!r supposition is !reby made absurd4 ,! "r to ?is assumption is en=c$ 9 ! ,nut by ! foll[+ analogy3 ,i ?9k y 767 w n d>e 767 to dispute my "r to ?is hypo!sis1 :5 ,i c prove by means ( x t e o!r value ( pi w lead to ! grosse/ absurdities2 unless inde$1 y are prep>$ to dispute ! "r ( ,euclid to adopt a false l9e hypo!tically = ! purpose #aah ( a 'r$uctio ad absurdum'#baf demon/ration1 9 pure geometry4 ,euclid assumes :at he wants to disprove1 & %[s t 8 assumption leads to absurdity1 & s upsets itself4 ,mr4 ,smi? assumes :at he wants to prove1 & %[s t 8 assumption makes o!r propositions lead to absurdity4 ,?is is en\gh = all :o c reason4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? _c be argu$ )2 he has ! :ip-h& ( all ! ?9k]s 9 ! _w4 ,montucla w\ld h said ( ,mr4 ,smi? :at he said ( ! g5tleman :o squ>$ 8 circle by giv+ #ej & #di ! same squ>e root1 ,il a p]du le droit d'etre frappe de l'evid5ce4#bag ,x is ,mr4 ,smi?'s habit1 :5 he f9ds a conclusion agree+ ) its own assumption1 to reg>d t agreem5t z pro( ( ! assumption4 ,! foll[+ is ! piece ( in=mation :i* w settle me1 if ,i be hone/4 ,assum+ pi to be #c-a_/h1 he f9ds out by work+ in/ance aft] in/ance t ! mean proportional betwe5 "o-fif? ( ! area & "o-fif? ( eight is ! radius4 ,t is1 if pi #be_/h1 sqrt77pir#b7_/e 4 #h_/e7 r4 ,?is rem>kable g5]al pr9ciple may fail to e/abli% ,mr4 ,smi?'s quadrature1 ev5 9 an hone/ m9d1 if t m9d %\ld happ5 to "k t1 a & b be+ any two numb]s :atev]1 we ne$ only assume-- pi a#b_/;b1 to get at sqrt77pir#b7_/;a 4 b_/a7 r4 ,we naturally ask :at sort ( glimm] c ,mr4 ,smi? h ( ! subject :i* he pr(esses to treat8 ,on ?is po9t he has giv5 satisfactory in=mation4 ,i _h m5tion$ ! old problem ( f9d+ two mean proportionals1 #aai z a prelim9>y to ! duplication ( ! cube4 ,on ?is m5tion ,mr4 ,smi? writes z foll[s4 ,i put a few words 9 capitals2 & ,i write rq#bah = ! sign ( ! squ>e root1 :i* emb>rasses small type3 ,?is e/abli%es ! foll[+ infallible rule1 = f9d+ two mean proportionals ,,( ,,equal ,,value1 & is m ?an a prelim9>y1 to ! fam\s old problem ( ',squ>+ ! circle4' ,let any f9ite numb]1 say #bj1 & its f\r? "p 7#a_/d77bj7 #e1 be giv5 numb]s4 ,!n rq7#bj x #e7 rq #ajj #aj1 is _! mean proportional4 ,let ?is be a giv5 mean proportional ,,to ,,f9d ,,ano!r ,,mean ,,proportional ,,( ,,equal ,,value4 ,!n #bj x pi_/#d #bj x #c4abe_/d #bj x 4#ghabe #ae4fbe w be ! fir/ numb]2 z #be 3 #af 33 rq #bj 3 rq #h4aib3 & 7rq #h4aib7b x pi_/#d #h4aib x 4#ghabe #f4d w be ! second numb]2 !re=e rq7#ae4fbe x #f4d7 rq #ajj #aj1 is ! requir$ mean proportional4444 ,n[1 my good ,sir1 h[ev] compet5t y may be to prove e man a fool n e man1 ,mr4 ,smi?6 only "s2 pray le>n logical quantification :o n[ ?9ks1 or 9 times gone by has ?\ght1 ! ',squ>+ ( ! ,circle' a possibility2 ,i d\bt1 &1 on ! evid5ce af=d$ by y\r ,budget1 ,i _c help d\bt+1 :e!r y 7 ev] be=e compet5t to f9d two mean proportionals by my unique me?od4--7,nut1 pp4 #dg1 #dh47 ,t ,i nev] 01 ,i solemnly decl>e6 ,all read]s c be made to see ! foll[+ exposure4 ,:5 #e & #bj are giv51 x is a mean proportional :5 9 #e1 x1 #bj1 #e is to x z x to #bj4 ,& x mu/ be #aj4 ,b x & y are two mean proportionals :5 9 #e1 x1 y1 #bj1 x #abj is a mean proportional betwe5 #e & y1 & y is a mean proportional betwe5 x & #bj4 ,& ^! means are x #e cub]oot#d1 y #e cub]oot#af4 ,b ,mr4 ,smi? f9ds "o mean1 f9ds x aga9 9 a r\ndab\t way1 & produces #aj & #aj z ! two 7equal67 means1 9 solution ( ! fam\s old problem4 ,?is is en\gh3 if m 7 want$1 !re is m :]e ?is came f4 ,let x n be =gott5 t ,mr4 ,smi? has f\nd a translator abroad1 two1 p]haps ?ree1 foll[]s at home1 &--mo/ surpris+ ( all--a real ma!matician to try to set him "r4 ,& ?is ma!matician did n discov] ! "* ( ! subsoil ( ! l& he 0 try+ to cultivate until a goodly octavo volume ( lett]s _h pass$ & repass$4 ,i h notic$1 9 m qu>t]s ?an "o1 an app>5t want ( p]ception ( ! full am\nt ( ,mr4 ,smi?'s ignorance3 p]sons :o h n be5 9 contact ) ! non-geometrical circle-squ>]s h a k9d ( d\bt z to :e!r anybody c c>ry ?+s s f>4 ,b ,i am an old bird z ,mr4 ,smi? himself calls me2 a ,simorg1 an all-kn[+ ,bird ( ,ages 9 matt]s ( cyclometry4 ,! curi\s ph5om5a ( ?\ght "h exhibit$ illu/rate1 z above said1 a rem>k ,i h long ago made on ! effect ( prop] /udy ( logic4 ,mo/ p]sons reason well en\gh on matt] to :i* !y are accu/om$1 & 9 t]ms ) :i* !y are famili>4 ,b 9 unaccu/om$ matt]1 & ) use ( /range t]ms1 few except ^? :o are practis$ 9 ! ab/ractions ( pure logic c be tol]ably sure to keep _! feet4 ,& "o ( ! reasons is easily /at$3 t]ms :i* are n q famili> p>take ( ! vagu5ess ( ! ,x & ,y on :i* ! /ud5t ( logic le>ns to see ! =mal =ce ( a proposition indep5d5tly ( its mat]ial elem5ts4 ,i make ! foll[+ quotation f my f\r? pap] on logic 9 ! ,cambridge ,transactions3 ,! uncultivat$ reason proce$s by a process almo/ entirely mat]ial4 ,?\gh ! necess>y law ( ?\ght #aba mu/ det]m9e ! conclusion ( ! pl\ghboy z mu* z t ( ,ari/otle himself1 ! pl\ghboy's conclusion w only be tol]ably sure :5 ! matt] ( x is su* z comes )9 8 usual cognizance4 ,he kn[s t geese be+ all birds does n make all birds geese1 b ma9ly because !re are ducks1 *ick5s1 p>tridges1 etc4 ,a beg9n] 9 geometry1 :5 ask$ :at foll[s f ',e ,a is ,b1' answ]s ',e ,b is ,a4' ,t is1 ! necess>y laws ( ?\ght1 except 9 m9ds :i* h exam9$ _! tools1 are n v sure to "w correct conclusions except ^u famili> matt]4444 ,z ! cultivation ( ! individual increases1 ! laws ( ?\ght :i* are ( mo/ usual application are appli$ to famili> matt] ) tol]able safety4 ,b difficulty & risk ( error make a new appe>ance ) a new subject2 & ?is1 9 mo/ cases1 until new subjects are famili> ?+s1 unusual matt] common1 untri$ nom5clature habitual2 t is1 until x is a habit to be occupi$ ^u a novelty4 ,x is obs]v$ t _m p]sons reason well 9 "s ?+s & badly 9 o!rs2 & ?is is attribut$ to ! consequ5ce ( employ+ ! m9d too mu* ^u "o or ano!r subject4 ,b ^? :o "k ! tru? ( ! prec$+ rem>ks w n h f> to seek = :at is (t51 p]haps mo/ (t51 ! true reason4444 ,i ma9ta9 t logic t5ds to make ! p[] ( reason ov] ! unusual & unfamili> m ne>ly equal to ! p[] ov] ! usual & famili> ?an x w\ld o!rwise be4 ,! second is increas$2 b ! fir/ is almo/ creat$4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 by br++ ignorance1 folly1 di%one/y into contact ) my "n1 9 ! way ( conditional ins9uation1 has done me a good turn3 he has giv5 me "r to a fre$om ( p]sonal rem>k :i* ,i might h decl9$ to take 9 ! case ( a p]son :o is useful & respect$ 9 matt]s :i* he und]/&s4 ,tit = tat is logic all ! _w ov]4 ,by ! way1 :at has become ( ! re/ ( ! maxim3 we nev] he> x #abb n[4 ,:5 ,i 0 a boy1 9 "s p>ts ( ! c\ntry at lea/1 x ran ?us3 ,tit = tat2 ,butt] = fat3 ,if y kill my dog1 ,i'll kill y\r cat4 ,he is a gl>+ in/ance ( ! tru? ( ! obs]vations quot$ above4 ,i w answ] = x t1 at ! ,m]sey ,dock ,bo>d1 he nev] dreams ( prov+ t ! balance at ! bank]'s is l>g] ?an t 9 ! book by assum+ t ! l>g] sum is !re1 & !n prov+ t ! o!r supposition--! small] balance--is ^u t assumption1 an absurdity4 ,he nev] says to ano!r director1 ,h[ c y d>e to refuse me a "r to assume ! l>g] balance1 :5 y y\rself1 ! o!r day1 said1--,suppose1 = argum5t's sake1 we _h #hj1jjjl4 at ! bank]'s1 ?\gh y knew ! book only %[$ #cj1jjjl48 ,?is is ! way 9 :i* he has support$ 8 geometrical p>adox by ,euclid's example3 & ?is is n ! way he reasons at ! bo>d2 ,i "k x by ! "* ( him z a man ( bus9ess :i* has rea*$ my e>s f sev]al qu>t]s4 ,b 9 geometry & rational ari?metic he is a smatt]]1 ?\gh exp]t at computation2 at ! bo>d he is a tra9$ man ( bus9ess4 ,! language ( geometry is s new to him t he does n "k :at is meant by two mean proportionals3 b all ! phrases ( comm]ce are root$ 9 8 m9d4 ,he is mo/ un]asably book$ 9 ! hi/ory ( ! squ>+ ( ! circle1 z ! speculator :o took a "r to assume a proposition = ! de/ruction ( o!r propositions1 on ! express gr\nd t ,euclid assumes a proposition to %[ t x de/roys itself3 :i* is z if ! curate %\ld dem& p]mission to ?rottle ! squire because ,/4 ,patrick drove ! v]m9 to suicide to save !mselves f slaught]4 ,he is conspicu\s z a speculator :o1 m visibly ?an almo/ any o!r kn[n to hi/ory1 reason$ 9 a circle by way ( reason+ on a circle4 ,b #abc :at ,i h *iefly to d ) is ! =ce ( in/ance :i* he has l5t to my ass]tion t m5 :o h n _h real tra9+ 9 pure logic are unsafe reason]s 9 matt] :i* is n famili>4 ,x is h>d to get fir/-rate examples ( ?is1 because !re are few :o f9d ! way to ! pr9t] until practice & reflection h giv5 security aga9/ ! grosse/ slips4 ,i _c b ?9k t 8 case w lead _m to take :at ,i h said into consid]ation1 among ^? :o are compet5t to ?9k ( ! great m5tal discipl9es4 ,to ?is end ,i %\ld desire him to cont9ue 8 ef=ts1 to amplify & develop 8 great pr9ciple1 t ( prov+ a proposition by assum+ x & tak+ z confirmation e consequ5ce t does n contradict ! assumption4 ,s9ce my ,budget comm5c$1 ,mr4 ,smi? has writt5 me notes3 ! portion :i* ,i h pres]v$--,i suppose sev]al h be5 mislaid--makes a hundr$ & sev5 pages ( note-pap]1 closely writt54 ,to all ?is ,i h n answ]$ "o ^w3 b ,i ?9k ,i _c h read few] ?an =ty pages4 ,9 ! la/ lett] ! writ] in=ms me t he w n write at great] l5g? until ,i h giv5 him an answ]1 accord+ to ! rules ( good society4 ,did ,i n "k t = e in* ,i wrote back he w\ld return an ell8 ,surely 9 va9 ! net is spread 9 ! eyes ( any?+ t ha? a w+4 ,!re 7 sev]al good excuses = n writ+ to ,mr4 ,j4 ,smi?3 ,i w m5tion five4 ,fir/1 ,i di/9ctly ann\nc$ at ! beg9n+ ( ?is ,budget t ,i w\ld n communicate ) squ>]s ( ! circle4 ,secondly1 any answ] ,i might *oose to give might ) p]fect propriety be res]v$ = ?is article2 _h ! imputation ( incivility be5 made aft] ! fir/ note1 ,i %\ld imm$iately h repli$ to ?is effect3 b ,i presum$ x 0 q und]/ood4 ,?irdly1 ,mr4 ,smi?1 by 8 publication ( ,e4 ,m4's lett]s aga9/ ! wi% ( ! writ]1 _h put himself out ( ! pale ( correspond5ce4 ,f\r?ly1 he _h also gone beyond ! rules ( good society 9 s5d+ #abd lett] aft] lett] to a p]son :o _h %[n by 8 sil5ce an int5tion to avoid correspond5ce4 ,fif?ly1 ^! same rules ( good society are contriv$ to be flexible or frangible 9 extreme cases3 o!rwise !re w\ld be no liv+ "u !m2 & good society w\ld be bad4 ,fa!r ,aldrov& has laid d[n ! necess>y di/9ction--,i tell !e1 ?\ fooli% ,flem+1 ! text speake? b ( promises made unto ,*ri/ians1 & !re is 9 ! rubric a special exemption ( su* z are made to ,wel*m54 ,!re is also a rubric to ! rules ( good society2 & squ>]s ( ! circle are among ^? :om !re is special p]mission n to answ]3 !y are ! wild ,wel*m5 ( geometry1 :o are always assail+1 b nev] tak+1 ! ,g>de ,d\l\reuse#bai ( ! circle4 ,at ?is comm5t>y1 proce$s ! /ory1 ! ,flem+ gr9n$ s broadly z to %[ 8 :ole case ( broad /rong :ite tee?4 ,i "k n :e!r ! ,wel*man w\ld h done ! l1 b ,i hope ,mr4 ,james ,smi? w3 & ,i hope he has z good a case to %[ z ,wilk9 ,flammock4 ,= ,i wi% him long life & long heal?1 & %\ld be v glad to see s mu* en]gy employ$ 9 a productive way4 ,i hope he wi%es me ! same3 if n1 ,i w give him :at all 8 judici\s fri5ds w ?9k a good reason = do+ s4 ,8 pamphlets & lett]s are all ti$ up toge!r1 & w =m a curi\s lot :5 dea? or cessation ( p[] to =age among book-%elves %all br+ my little libr>y to ! hamm]4 ,& ?is "t may n be f> (f3 = ,i 0 ,x ye>s old 9 ,a4,d4 ,x#b2 n #d 9 ,a4,d4 #af1 nor #e 9 ,a4,d4 #be1 b /ill 9 "o case "u t law4 ,& n[ ,i h made my own age a problem ( quadrature1 & ,mr4 ,j4 ,smi? may solve x4 ,b ,i prote/ aga9/ 8 me?od ( assum+ a result1 & mak+ itself prove itself3 he might 9 ?is way1 z sure z eggs is eggs 7a corruption ( ,x is ,x71 make me #a1hfd ye>s old1 :i* is a great deal too mu*4 #abe ,april #e1 #ahfd4--,mr4 ,smi? cont9ues to write me long lett]s1 to :i* he h9ts t ,i am to answ]4 ,9 8 la/1 ( #ca closely writt5 sides ( note-pap]1 he in=ms me1 ) ref]5ce to my ob/9ate sil5ce1 t ?\gh ,i ?9k myself & am ?\ght by o!rs to be a ma!matical ,golia?1 ,i h resolv$ to play ! ma!matical snail1 & keep )9 my %ell4 ,a ma!matical snail6 ,?is _c be ! ?+ s call$ :i* regulates ! /rik+ ( a clock2 = x w\ld mean t ,i am to make ,mr4 ,smi? s\nd ! true "t ( day1 :i* ,i w\ld by no means und]take ^u a clock t ga9s #ai seconds odd 9 e h\r by false quadrature4 ,b he v5tures to tell me t pebbles f ! sl+ ( simple tru? & common s5se w ultimately crack my %ell1 & put me hors de combat4#bbj ,! confusion ( images is amus+3 ,golia? turn+ himself into a snail to avoid pi #c-a_/h1 & ,james ,smi?1 ,esq41 ( ! ,m]sey ,dock ,bo>d3 & put hors de combat--:i* %\ld h be5 ca*e#bba--;by pebbles f a sl+4 ,if ,golia? _h crept into a snail-%ell1 ,david w\ld h crack$ ! ,phili/9e ) 8 foot4 ,!re is some?+ l mode/y 9 ! implication t ! crack-%ell pebble has n yet tak5 effect2 x might h be5 ?\ght t ! sl+] w\ld by ?is "t h be5 s++-- ,& ?rice & "o-eigh? ,i r\t$ all my foes1 ,& ?rice & "o-eigh? ,i slew ! sla94 ,b he promises to give ! public 8 nut-crack] if ,i d n1 be=e ! ,budget is conclud$1 unravel ! p>adox1 :i* is ! ma!matico-geometrical nut he has giv5 me to crack4 ,mr4 ,smi? is a crack man3 he w crack 8 own nut2 he w crack my %ell2 9 ! mean "t he cracks himself up4 ,heav5 s5d he d n crack himself into lat]al contiguity ) himself4 ,on ,june #bg ,i receiv$ a lett]1 9 ! h&writ+ ( ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 sign$ ,nauticus4 ,i h asc]ta9$ #abf t "o ( ! lett]s to ! ,a!naeum sign$ ,nauticus is 9 ! same h&writ+4 ,i make a few extracts3 444 ,! important "q at issue has be5 treat$ by a brace ( ma!matical birds ) too mu* levity4 ,x may be said1 h[ev]1 t s>casm & ridicule sometimes succe$1 :]e reason fails4444 ,su* a c\rse is n well suit$ to a discussion4444 ,= ?is reason ,i %all = ! future ?is implies !re has be5 a pa/1 s t ,nauticus is n be=e me = ! fir/ "t endeavor to conf9e myself to dry reason+ f incontrov]tible premises4 444 ,x appe>s to me t s f> z 8 !ory is conc]n$ he comes (f unsca!d4 ,y might h f\nd a hole 9 ,smi?'s circle 7h y se5 a pamphlet be>+ ?is title8 ,i nev] he>d ( x until n[71 b aft] all x is q possible ! hole may h be5 left by design1 = ! purpose ( entrapp+ ! unw>y4 ,on ! publication ( ! above1 ! au?or ( ! pamphlet oblig+ly =w>d$ a copy to me ( ,a ,hole 9 ,smi?'s ,circle--by a ,cantab3 ,longman & ,co41 #ahei1 7pp4 #ae74 ,x is pity to lose any fun we c get out ( ! affair1 says my almamat]nal bro!r3 to :i* ,i add t 9 su* a case w>n+ )\t joke is worse ?an none at all1 z giv+ a false idea ( ! nature ( ! dang]4 ,! ,cantab takes "s absurdities on :i* ,i h n dwelt3 b !re are en\gh to af=d a ,cantab f e college 8 own sep>ate hunt+ gr\nd4 ,does ?is h9t t 8 mode ( pro(1 namely1 assum+ ! ?+ to be prov$1 0 a design to entrap ! unw>y8 if s1 x bangs ,banagh]4 ,0 8 conf\nd+ two mean proportionals ) "o mean proportional f\nd twice ov] a trick ( ! same int5t8 if s1 x beats cockfight+4 ,t ,nauticus is ,mr4 ,smi? appe>s f o!r int]nal evid5ce4 ,9 #ahai1 ,mr4 ,j4 ,c4 ,hobh\se#bbb 0 s5t to ,newgate = a #abg libel on ! ,h\se ( ,commons :i* 0 only int5d$ = a libel on ,"l ,ersk9e4#bbc ,! ex-,*ancellor _h tak5 ,mr4 ,hobh\se to be ?9k+ ( him 9 a c]ta9 s5t5ce2 ?is ,mr4 ,hobh\se d5i$1 add+1 ,!re is b "o man 9 ! c\ntry :o is always ?9k+ ( ,"l ,ersk9e4 ,i say t !re is b "o man ( our day :o w\ld c\ple me & ,mr4 ,james ,smi? z a brace ( ma!matical birds4 ,mr4 ,smi?'s !ory is unsca!d by me4 ,n a d\bt ab\t x3 b h[ does he himself come (f8 ,i %\ld nev] ?9k ( refut+ a !ory prov$ by assumption ( itself4 ,i left ,mr4 ,smi?'s pi unt\*$3 or1 if ,i put 9 my ?umb & pull$ out a plum1 x 0 to give a notion ( ! cook1 n ( ! di%4 ,! important "q at issue 0 n ! circle3 x 01 :olly & solely1 :e!r ! abbreviation ( ,james might be spell$ ,jimm4#bbd ,?is is p]sonal to ! v]ge ( scurrility3 b 9 lit]>y controv]sy ! *all5g] names ! weapons1 & ,mr4 ,smi? beg9s ) *>ge ( ignorance1 folly1 & di%one/y1 by conditional implication4 ,s t ! "q is1 n ! p]sonality ( a ^w1 b its applicability to ! p]son designat$3 x is en\gh if1 z ! ,lat9 gramm> has x1 ,v]bum p]sonale concordat cum nom9ativo4#bbe ,i may plead prec$5t = tak+ a lib]ty ) ! or?ography ( ,jem4 ,an in/ructor ( y\? 0 sc&aliz$ at ! abrupt & irregul>--b v effective--op5+ ( ,wordswor?'s little piece3 #abh ,a simple *ild ,t lightly draws its brea?1 ,& feels its life 9 e limb1 ,:at %\ld x "k ( dea?8 ,s he m5d$ ! matt] by in/ruct+ 8 pupils to read ! fir/ l9e ?us3 ,a simple *ild1 de> bro!r ----4 ,! bro!r1 we inf] f s\nd1 0 to be ,james1 & ! blank mu/ !re=e be fill$ up ) ,jimb4 ,i w notice "o po9t ( ! lett]1 to make a little m di/9ction betwe5 ! two birds4 ,nauticus lays d[n--q correctly--t ! s9e ( an angle is less ?an its circul> measure4 ,he !n takes #c4adaf = #ahj deg41 & f9ds t #cf' is 4#jajdgb4 ,b ?is is exactly :at he f9ds = ! s9e ( #cf' 9 tables3 he concludes t ei!r #c4adaf or ! tables mu/ be wrong4 ,he does n "k t s9es1 z well z pi1 are int]m9able decimals1 ( :i* ! tables1 to save pr9t+1 only take 9 a f9ite numb]4 ,he is a six-figure man3 let u g ?rice aga9 to make up n9e1 & we h z foll[s3 ,circul> measure ( #cf' 4#jajdgaige444 ,s9e ( #cf' 4#jajdgaghd444 ,excess ( measure ov] s9e 4#jjjjjjaia444 ,mr4 ,smi? invites me to say :i* is wrong1 ! quadrature1 or ! tables3 ,i leave him to guess4 ,he says 8 ass]tions arise naturally & necess>ily out ( ! argum5ts ( a circle-squ>]3 he might j z well lay d[n t all ! pigs w5t to m>ket because x is record$ t ,?is pig w5t to m>ket4 ,i mu/ say = circle-squ>]s t v few br+ _! pigs to s poor a m>ket4 ,i answ] ! above argum5t because x is1 ( all :i* ,mr4 ,james ,smi? has produc$1 ! only "o :i* rises to ! level ( a s*oolboy3 to meet him halfway ,i desc5d to t level4 ,mr4 ,smi? asks me to solve a problem 9 ! ,a!naeum3 #abi & ,i w d x1 because ! "q w illu/rate :at is bel[ s*oolboy level4 ,let x repres5t ! circul> measure ( an angle ( #ae deg41 & y half ! s9e ( an angle ( #cj deg4 area ( ! squ>e on ! radius ( a circle ( diamet] unity 4#be4 ,if x - y xy1 fir/ly1 :at is ! ari?metical value ( xy8 secondly1 :at is ! angle ( :i* xy repres5ts ! circul> measure8 ,if x repres5t #ae deg4 & y be #a_/d1 xy repres5ts #c deg4 #de'1 :e!r x - y be xy or no4 ,b1 y be+ #a_/d1 x - y is n xy unless x be #a_/c1 t is1 unless #abx or pi be #d1 :i* ,mr4 ,smi? w\ld n admit4 ,h[ c\ld a p]son :o _h j receiv$ su* a lesson z ,i _h giv5 imm$iately pray = fur!r exposure1 furni%+ ! /uff s lib]ally z ?is8 ,is x possible t ,mr4 ,smi?1 because he signs himself ,nauticus1 means to d5y 8 own v regul>1 legible1 & peculi> h&8 ,x is en\gh to make ! o!r memb]s ( ! ,liv]pool ,dock ,bo>d cry1 ,m]sey on ! man6 ,mr4 ,smi? says t = ! future he w give up :at he calls s>casm1 & conf9e himself1 z f> z possible1 to :at he calls dry reason+ f incontrov]tible premises4 ,if ,i h fairly taught him t 8 s>casm w n succe$1 ,i hope he w f9d t 8 wit's end is 8 logic's beg9n+4 ,i n[ reply to a "q ,i h be5 ask$ aga9 & aga9 s9ce my la/ ,budget appe>$3 ,:y d y take s mu* tr\ble to expose su* a reason] z ,mr4 ,smi?8 ,i answ] z a deceas$ fri5d ( m9e us$ to answ] on l occasions--,a man's capacity is no measure ( 8 p[] to d mis*ief4 ,mr4 ,smi? has untir+ en]gy1 :i* does some?+2 self-evid5t hone/y ( conviction1 :i* does m2 & a long purse1 :i* does mo/ ( all4 ,he has made at lea/ t5 publications1 full ( figures :i* few read]s c criticize4 ,a great _m p are /agg]$ to ?is ext5t1 t !y imag9e !re mu/ be #acj ! indef9ite some?+ 9 ! my/]i\s all ?is4 ,!y are br\ght to ! po9t ( suspicion t ! ma!maticians ought n to treat all ?is ) su* undisguis$ contempt1 at lea/4 ,n[ ,i h no fe> = pi3 b ,i d ?9k x possible t g5]al op9ion might 9 "t dem& t ! cr[d ( circle-squ>]s1 etc4 %\ld be admitt$ to ! honors ( opposition2 & ?is w\ld be a "t-tax ( five p] c5t41 "o man ) ano!r1 ^u ^? :o are bett] employ$4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? may be made useful1 9 h&s :i* und]/& h[ to d x1 t[>ds prev5t+ su* op9ion f gr[+4 ,a speculator :o expressly assumes :at he wants to prove1 & argues t all :i* contradicts x is absurd1 because x _c /& side by side ) 8 assumption1 is a case :i* c be expos$ to all4 ,& ! be/ p]son to expose x is "o :o has liv$ 9 ! pa/ z well z ! pres5t1 :o takes mi/h9k+ f po9ts ( view :i* none b a /ud5t ( hi/ory c occupy1 & :o has some?+ ( a turn = ! bus9ess4 ,:e!r ,i h any motive b public good mu/ be ref]r$ to ^? :o c decide :e!r a mission>y *ooses 8 pursuit solely to conv]t ! hea!n4 ,i %all c]ta9ly be ?\ght to h a little ( ! _s ( ,col4 ,quagg1 :o delight$ 9 /rapp+ ! ,grace-walk+ ,bre?r54 ,i mu/ quote ?is myself3 if ,i d n1 "s "o else w1 & !n :]e am ,i8 ,! ,colonel's pr9ciple is describ$ z foll[s3 ,i licks ye because ,i k91 & because ,i l1 & because ye'se critt]s t licks is good =4 ,sk9s ye h on1 & sk9s ,i'll h (f2 h>d or s(t1 wet or dry1 spr+ or fall4 ,walk 9 grace if ye l till pumpk9s is pea*es2 b lick$ ye mu/ be till y\r toe-nails drop (f & y\r noses ble$ blue ink4 ,&--lick$--!y--7--accord+ly4 ,i am rem9d$ ( ?is by ! excessive confid5ce ) :i* ,mr4 ,james ,smi? pr$ict$ t he w\ld treat me z ,zephaniah ,/ockdollog] 7,sam ,slick calls x slockdollag]7 treat$ ,goliah ,quagg4 ,he has ann\nc$ 8 #aca int5tion ( br++ me1 ) a contrite he>t1 & clean %av$1--#daeibfe444 razor$ d[n to #be1--to a camp-meet+ ( circle-squ>]s4 ,b !re is ?is diff]5ce3 ,zephaniah only want$ to pass ! ,colonel's smi?y 9 peace2 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? s\ght a fight ) me4 ,z soon z ?is ,budget began to appe>1 he oil$ 8 own /rap1 & attempt$ to treat me z ! t]rible ,colonel w\ld h treat$ ! in(f5sive bro!r4 ,he is at lib]ty to try aga94 ,,! ,,moon ,,hoax4 ,! ,moon-hoax2 or ! discov]y t ! moon has a va/ population ( human be+s4 ,by ,ri*>d ,adams ,locke4#bbf ,new ,york1 #ahei1 #hvo4 ,?is is a repr9t ( ! hoax already m5tion$4 ,i suppose ,r4 ,a4 ,locke is ! "n assum$ by ,m4 ,nicollet4#bbg ,! publi%] in=ms u t :5 ! hoax fir/ appe>$ day by day 9 a morn+ pap]1 ! circulation increas$ fivefold1 & ! pap] obta9$ a p]man5t foot+4 ,besides ?is1 an edition ( #fj1jjj 0 sold (f 9 less ?an "o mon?4 ,! discov]y 0 also publi%$ "u ! "n ( ,a4 ,r4 ,grant4#bbh ,sohncke's#bbi ,biblio!ca ,ma!matica conf\nds ?is ,grant ) ,pr(4 ,r4 ,grant#bcj ( ,glasg[1 ! au?or ( ! ,hi/ory ( ,physical ,a/ronomy1 :o is accord+ly made to gu>antee ! discov]ies 9 ! moon4 ,i hope ,adams ,locke w n m]ge 9 ,j4 ,c4 ,adams1#bca ! co-discov]] ( ,neptune4 ,sohncke gives ! titles ( #acb ?ree ,fr5* translations ( ! ,moon hoax at ,p>is1 ( "o at ,bordeaux1 & ( ,italian translations at ,p>ma1 ,pal]mo1 & ,milan4 ,a ,correspond5t1 :o is evid5tly fully ma/] ( details1 :i* he has giv5 at l5g?1 in=ms me t ! ,moon hoax appe>$ fir/ 9 ! ,new ,york ,sun1 ( :i* ,r4 ,a4 ,locke 0 editor4 ,x s mu* resembl$ a /ory !n rec5tly publi%$ by ,edg> ,a4 ,poe1 9 a ,s\!rn pap]1 ,adv5tures ( ,hans ,pfaal1 t "s ,new ,york j\rnals publi%$ ! two side by side4 ,mr4 ,locke1 :5 he left ! ,new ,york ,sun1 />t$ ano!r pap]1 & discov]$ ! manuscript ( ,mungo ,p>k2#bcb b ?is did n deceive4 ,! ,sun1 h[ev]1 cont9u$ its c>e]1 & _h a great success 9 an acc\nt ( a balloon voyage f ,engl& to ,am]ica1 9 sev5ty-five h\rs1 by ,mr4 ,monck ,mason1#bcc ,mr4 ,h>rison ,a9swor?1#bcd & o!rs4 ,i h no d\bt t ,m4 ,nicollet 0 ! au?or ( ! ,moon hoax1#bce writt5 9 a way :i* m>ks ! practis$ obs]vatory a/ronom] beyond all d\bt1 & by evid5ce se5 9 ! mo/ m9ute details4 ,nicollet _h an eye to ,europe4 ,i suspect t he took ,poe's /ory1 & made x a basis = 8 own4 ,mr4 ,locke1 x w\ld seem1 :5 he attempt$ a fabrication = himself1 did n succe$4 ,! ,e>? we inhabit1 its pa/1 pres5t1 & future4 ,by ,capt4 ,drayson4#bcf ,london1 #ahei1 #hvo4 ,! e>? is gr[+2 absolutely gr[+ l>g]3 its diamet] increases ?ree-qu>t]s ( an in* p] mile e ye>4 ,! f\ndations ( our build+s w give way 9 #acc "t3 ! telegraph cables break1 & no cause ev] assign$ except %ips' an*ors1 & su* ?+s4 ,! book is = ^? ^: common s5se is unw>p$1 :o c judge evid5ce z well z ! able/ philosoph]4 ,! prospect is n a bad "o1 = population increases s fa/ t a l>g] e>? w be want$ 9 "t1 unless emigration to ! ,moon c be manag$1 a proposal ( :i* x mu* surprises me t ,bi%op ,wilk9s has a monopoly4 ,,impalem5t ,,by ,,reque/4 ,a!naeum1 ,augu/1 #ai1 #ahfe4 ,notice to ,correspond5ts4 ,r4 ,w4--,if y w consult ! op5+ *apt] ( ! ,budget ( ,p>adoxes1 y w see t ! au?or pres5ts only works 9 8 own libr>y at a giv5 date2 & ?is = a purpose expla9$4 ,= ourselves we h c>efully avoid$ all[+ any writ]s to pres5t !mselves 9 our columns on ! gr\nd t ! ,budget has pass$ !m ov]4 ,we ga!r t ,mr4 ,de ,morgan contemplates additions at a future "t1 p]haps 9 a sep>ate & augm5t$ "w2 if s1 ^? :o compla9 t o!rs ( no great] claims ?an !mselves h be5 ridicul$ may f9d !mselves :]e !y wi% to be4 ,we h done :at we c = y by =w>d+ y\r lett] to ,mr4 ,de ,morgan4 ,! au?or ( ,an ,essay on ! ,con/itution ( ! ,e>?1 publi%$ 9 #ahdd1 dem&$ ( ! ,a!naeum1 z an act ( fairness1 t a lett] f him %\ld be publi%$1 prov+ t he _h z mu* "r to be impal$ z ,capt4 ,drayson4 ,he holds1 on speculative gr\nds1 :at ! o!r claims to h prov$ by measurem5t1 namely1 t ! e>? is gr[+2 & he believes t 9 "t--a good long "t1 n our "t--! e>? & o!r planets may gr[ into suns1 ) sy/ems ( _! own4 ,?is g5tleman s5t me a copy ( 8 "w1 aft] ! comm5cem5t ( my ,budget2 b ,i h no recollection ( hav+ receiv$ x1 & ,i _c f9d x on ! 7nurs]y8 #acd qu>ant9e87 %elves on :i* ,i keep my une/abli%$ discov]ies4 ,_h ,i kn[n ( ?is "w 9 "t1 7see ! ,introduction7 ,i %\ld ( c\rse1 h impal$ x 7h]aldically7 ) ! o!r "w2 b ! two are v diff]5t4 ,capt4 ,drayson pr(esses to prove 8 po9t by results ( obs]vation2 & ,i ?9k he does n succe$4 ,! au?or be=e me only speculates2 & a speculator c get any conclusion into 8 premises1 if he w only build or hire !m ( %ape & size to suit4 ,x rem9ds me ( a /atem5t ,i he>d ye>s ago1 t a score ( p]sons1 or ne> x1 7 to d9e inside ! skull ( "o ( ! aborig9al animals1 de> little creatures6 ,:]eat ,i wond]$ va/ly1 no?+ d\bt+2 facts be+ /ubborn & n easy drove1 z ,mrs4 ,gamp said4 ,b ,i soon le>n$ t ! skull 0 n a real "o1 b artificially con/ruct$ by ! me?ods--me?ods :i* h _h /rik+ v]ifications1 too--:i* enable zoologi/s to g ! :ole hog by help ( a toe or a bit ( tail4 ,?is took (f ! edge ( ! wond]3 a hundr$ p c d9e inside an inf]5ce1 if y draw x l>ge en\gh4 ,! me?od might happ5 to fail = once3 = in/ance1 ! toe-bone might h be5 abnormaliz$ by !rian or saurian malady2 & ! possibility ( su* failure1 ev5 :5 ( small probability1 is ( great alleviation4 ,! au?or be=e me is1 app>5tly1 ! sole fabricator ( 8 own premises4 ,) vital =ce 9 ! e>? & cont9ual creation on ! "p ( ! orig9al ,creator1 he exp&s our bit ( a resid5ce z desir$4 ,b1 z ! ,newtoness ( ,cook]y obs]v$1 ,fir/ cat* y\r h>e4 ,:5 ?is is done1 :5 y h a gr[+ e>?1 y %all dress x ) all mann] ( proximate causes1 & s]ve x up ) a gr[+ ,moon = sauce1 a gr[+ ,sun1 if x please y1 at ! o!r end1 & gr[+ planets = side-di%es4 ,hop+ ?is am\nt ( impalem5t w be satisfactory1 ,i g on to some?+ else4 #ace ,,! ,,hailesean ,,sy/em ,,( ,,a/ronomy4 ,! ,hailesean ,sy/em ( ,a/ronomy4 ,by ,john ,davey ,hailes#bcg 7two pages duodecimo1 #ahfj74 ,he (f]s to take #ajj1jjjl4 to #a1jjjl4 t he %[s ! sun to be less ?an sev5 millions ( miles f ! e>?4 ,! e>? 9 ! c5t]1 revolv+ ea/w>d1 ! sun revolv+ we/w>d1 s t !y meet at half ! circle di/ance 9 ! #bd h\rs4 ,! diamet] ( ! circle be+ #ihcidehcjc1 ! circumf]5ce is #cjiaaefiibj4 ,! foll[+ writt5 *all5ge 0 =w>d$ to ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,a/ronomical ,society3 x w %[ ! g5]al read]--& help him t[>ds e>n+ 8 "n--:at sort ( ?+s come e n[ & !n to our sci5tific bodies4 ,i h add$ punctuation3 ,*all5ge4 #a1jjj to #cj1jjj4 ,lev]ri]'s#bch "n /& plac$ fir/4 ,d ! wor?y ,fr5*man ju/ice4 ,by aw>d+ him ! m$al 9 a trice4 ,give ,adams#bci an extra--( :i* neck & neck ! race4 ,n[ ,i *all5ge to meet !m & ! ,f4,r4,s4's all1 ,= good w & "o ?\s& p\nds to _! ?irty ?\s& )all1 ,t ,i produce a sy/em1 :i* %all measure ! "t1 ,:5 ! ,sun 0 v]tical to ,gibeon1 aft]w>d to ,sy5e4 ,to meet any "t 9 ,london--"n y\r own p]iod1 ,to be decid$ by a majority ( twelve p]sons--a ,presid5t1 odd4 ,t mean1 if ! twelve equally divide1 ! ,presid5t decide1 ,i %\ld pref] ! ,bi%op ( ,london1 ov] ! meet+ to preside4 ,,john ,,davy ,,hailes4 ,feb4 #ag1 #ahdg4 ,mr4 ,hailes /ill issues 8 fly+ %eets4 ,! la/ ,i h met ) 7,octob] #g1 #ahfc7 in=ms u t ! latitude ( #acf ,engl& is sl[ly increas+1 :i* is ! true cause ( ! alt]ation 9 ! v>iation ( ! magnet4 ,mr4 ,hailes cont9ues 8 rese>*es4 ,witness 8 new ,hailesean sy/em ( ,a/ronomy1 display+ ,jo%ua's miracle-"t1 orig9 ( "t f sci5ce1 ) ,bible & ,egyptian hi/ory4 ,rew>ds (f]$ = a/ronomical problems4 ,) magnetism1 etc4 etc4 ,a/ronomical *all5ge to all ! _w4 ,publi%$ at ,cambridge1 9 #ahfe4 ,! au?or agrees ) ,newton 9 "o m>k$ po9t4 ,errores quam m9imi non sunt contemn5di1#bdj says ,isaac3 mean+ 9 figures1 n 9 or?ography4 ,mr4 ,hailes ent]s into ! _s1 bo? positive & negative1 ( ?is dictum1 by giv+ ! di/ance ( ,sidius f ! c5t] ( ! e>? at #afc1afb1jjh miles #aj feet #h in*es #ag-bh?s ( an in*4 ,( c\rse1 he is aw>e t ! c5t] ( figure ( ! e>? is #ag4aiih in*es f ! c5t] ( gravity4 ,:i* ( ! two is he speak+ (8 ,! ,div9e ,my/]y ( ,life4 ,london #ahfa1 #ahmo4 7pp4#cb74 ,! au?or has add$ "o class to zoology1 :i* is pr9t$ 9 capitals1 z d]iv$ f zoe1 life1 n f zoon1 animal4 ,t class is ( ,incorporealia1 ord] ,i41 ,inf9itum1 ( "o g5us )\t plurality1 ,deus3 ord] ,,ii41 ,f9ita1 angels good & evil4 ,! re/ is all ab\t a triune sy/em1 ) a diagram4 ,! au?or is n aw>e t ,greek3 zoon is n animal1 b liv+ be+4 ,ari/otle _h class$ gods "u ,greek3 zoa1 & has be5 call$ to acc\nt = x by mod]ns :o h tak5 ! ^w to mean animal4 ,a ,,*ance ,,= ,,inv5tors4 ,explication du ,zodiaque de ,d5d]ah1 des ,pyramides1 et de ,g5ese4 ,p> le ,capita9e au longc\rs ,ju/9 ,robl94#bda ,ca51 #ahfa4 #hvo4 #acg ,capt4 ,robl91 hav+ discov]$ ! sites ( gold & diamond m9es by help ( ! zodiac ( ,d5d]ah1 (f]$ half to ! %>ehold]s ( a company :i* he propos$ to =m4 ,"o ( our j\rnals1 by help ( ! zodiac ( ,esne1 (f]$1 at five francs a head1 to tell ! %>ehold]s ! exact am\nt ( gold & diamonds :i* ea* w\ld get1 & to make up ! am\nt pr$ict$ to ^? :o got less4 ,!re are moods ( ! m>ket 9 ,engl& 9 :i* ?is company c\ld h be5 =m$3 s we mu/ n laugh at our neighbors4 ,,johannes ,,von ,,gumpa*4 ,a million's wor? ( prop]ty1 & five hundr$ lives annually lo/ at sea by ! ,!ory ( ,gravitation4 ,a lett] on ! true figure ( ! e>?1 address$ to ! ,a/ronom] ,royal1 by ,johannes von ,gumpa*4#bdb ,london1 #ahfa1 #hvo4 7pp4 #ed74 ,! true figure & dim5sions ( ! e>?1 9 a lett] address$ to ! ,a/ronom] ,royal4 ,by ,joh4 von ,gumpa*4 #bnd ed4 entirely reca/4 ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 7pp4 #bff74 ,two issues ( a lett] publi%$ ) two diff]5t title-pages1 "o address$ to ! ,secret>y ( ! ,royal ,society1 ! o!r to ! ,secret>y ( ! ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society4 ,x w\ld seem t ! same lett] is also issu$ ) two o!r titles1 address$ to ! ,briti% ,association & ! ,royal ,geographical ,society4 ,by ,joh4 von ,gumpa*4 ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,baby-,worlds4 ,an essay on ! nasc5t memb]s ( our sol> h\sehold4 ,by ,joh4 von ,gumpa*4 ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,! e>?1 x appe>s1 in/ead ( be+ flatt5$1 is elongat$ at ! poles3 by ignorance ( :i* ! loss above m5tion$ occurs ye>ly4 ,!re is1 or is to be1 a sub/itute = attraction & an application hi!rto neglect$1 ( a #ach recogniz$ law ( optics to ! a/ronomical !ory1 %[+ ! true orbits ( ! heav5ly bodies to be p]fectly circul>1 & _! orbital motions to be p]fectly uni=m4 all irregul>ities be+1 ,i suppose1 optical delusions4 ,mr4 ,von ,gumpa* is a le>n$ man2 :at else1 "t mu/ %[4 ,,sl&] ,,p>adoxes4 ,p]petuum ,mobile3 or ,se>* = self-motive ,p[]4 ,by ,h5ry ,dircks4#bdc ,london1 #ahfa1 #hvo4 ,a useful collection on ! hi/ory ( ! attempts at p]petual motion1 t is1 at obta9+ ! consequ5ces ( p[] )\t any p[] to produce !m4 ,septemb] #g1 #ahfc1 a correspond5t ( ! ,times gave an anecdote ( ,george ,/eph5son1#bdd :i* he obta9$ f ,rob]t ,/eph5son4#bde ,a p]petual motioni/ want$ to expla9 8 me?od2 to :i* ,george repli$--,sir6 ,i %all believe x :5 ,i see y take y\rself up by ! wai/b&1 & c>ry y\rself ab\t ! room4 ,nev] 0 ! problem bett] /at$4 ,!re is a p>adox ( :i* ,i ought to give a specim51 ,i mean ! sl&]-p>adox2 ! case ( a p]son :o takes x into 8 head1 ^u evid5ce furni%$ entirely by ! work+s ( 8 own ?\ghts1 t "s o!r p]son has committ$ a f\l act ( :i* ! _w at l>ge w\ld no m suppose him guilty ?an !y w\ld suppose t ! e>? is a flat bord]$ by ice4 ,if ,i 7 to det]m9e on giv+ cases 9 :i* ! self-delud$ p]son imag9es #aci a conspiracy aga9/ himself1 !re w\ld be no end ( *oices4 ,_m ( ! gross] cases are f\nd at la/ to be accompani$ by m5tal disord]1 & x is difficult to avoid ref]r+ ! :ole class to some?+ diff]5t f simple misuse ( ! reason+ p[]4 ,! fir/ in/ance is "o :i* puts 9 a /rong light ! /ate ( ?+s 9 :i* we live1 br\ght ab\t by our glori\s fre$om ( ?\ght1 spee*1 & writ+4 ,! ,gov]nm5t treat$ x ) neglect1 ! press ) sil5t contempt1 & ,i w answ] = x _m ( my read]s n[ he> ( x = ! fir/ "t1 :5 x comes to be enroll$ among circle-squ>]s & e>?-/opp]s1 :]e1 z ! old philosoph] said1 x w n gravitate1 be+ 9 proprio loco4#bdf #ahfb4 ,on new ye>'s day1 #ahfb1 :5 ! nation 0 9 ! full tide ( sympa?y ) ! ,que51 & regret = its own loss1 a pap] call$ ! ,free ,press publi%$ a numb] devot$ to ! consid]ation ( ! causes ( ! dea? ( ! ,pr9ce ,consort4 ,x is s rambl+ & inconsecutive t x takes m ?an "o read+ to und]/& x4 ,x is aga9/ ! ,times newspap]4 ,fir/1 ! foll[+ ins9uation3 ,to ! legal m9d1 ! "p ( ! "p tak5 by ! ,times w pres5t a prima facie case ( ! grave/ nature1 9 ! evid5t =e-k ( ! ev5t1 & ! prep>ation to turn x to acc\nt :5 x %\ld h occurr$4 ,! article pr9t$ on ,saturday mu/ h be5 writt5 on ,friday4 ,t article c\ld n h appe>$ _h ! ,pr9ce be5 int5d$ to live4 ,next1 x is affirm$ t ! ,times int5d$ to convey ! idea t ! ,pr9ce _h be5 poison$4 ,up to ?is po9t we are m]ely deal+ ) words :i* ! ,times publi%es1 & ^! c leave n a %ad[ ( d\bt t !re is an int5tion to promulgate ! idea t ,pr9ce ,alb]t _h be5 poison$4 ,! article !n goes on ) a /range olio ( #adj ins9uations to ! effect t ! ,pr9ce 0 ! ob/acle to ,russian intrigue1 & t if he %\ld h be5 poison$1--:i* ! writ] /rongly h9ts may h be5 ! case1--"s ,m9i/] "u ! influ5ce ( ,russia mu/ h done x4 ,en\gh = ?is record4 ,un sot tr\ve t\j\rs un plus sot qui l'admire3#bdg :o c he be 9 ?is case8 ,,! ,,neptune ,,controv]sy4 #ahdf4 ,at ! end ( ?is ye> arose ! celebrat$ controv]sy relative to ! discov]y ( ,neptune4 ,^? :o "k x are well aw>e t ,mr4 ,adams's#bdh n[ und\bt$ "r to rank ) ,le ,v]ri]#bdi 0 made sure at ! v outset by ! mann] 9 :i* ,mr4 ,airy1#bej ! ,a/ronom] ,royal1 came =w>d to /ate :at _h tak5 place betwe5 himself & ,mr4 ,adams4 ,^? :o "k all ! /ory ab\t ,mr4 ,airy be+ arre/$ 9 8 progress by ! neglect ( ,mr4 ,adams to answ] a lett]1 ) all ! imputations :i* might h be5 ?r[n ^u himself = laxity 9 ! matt]1 "k also t ,mr4 ,airy's conduct exhibit$ moral c\rage1 hone/ feel+1 & will+ness to sacrifice himself1 if ne$ 71 to ! atta9m5t ( ! ends ( private ju/ice1 & ! e/abli%m5t ( a national claim4 ,a writ] 9 a magaz9e1 9 a long & elaborate article1 argu$ ! supposition--put 9 e way except d[nright ass]tion1 aft] ! fa%ion ( su* ?+s--t ,mr4 ,airy _h communicat$ ,mr4 ,adams's results to ,m4 ,le ,v]ri]1 ) int5tion t !y %\ld be us$4 ,8 presumption z to motive is t1 _h ,mr4 ,adams be5 recogniz$1 !n ! discov]y mu/ h be5 indisputably an ,engli%man's1 & t ,engli%man n ! ,a/ronom] ,royal4 ,mr4 ,adams's conclusions 7 ret\*$ 9 ,france1 & s5t #ada ov] ! ye> aft]4 ,! pro( giv5 is t x _c be imag9$ o!rwise4 ,c x !n be imag9$ t ! ,a/ronom] ,royal receiv$ su* results f ,mr4 ,adams1 support$ z !y 7 by ,pr(essor ,*allis's#bea valuable te/imony z to _! probable accuracy1 & did n br+ ! ,fr5* a/ronom] acqua9t$ ) !m1 especially z he 0 aw>e t 8 fri5d 0 engag$ 9 matt]s be>+ directly ^u ^! results8 ,! :ole argum5t ! au?or /yles evid5ce :i* ,i consid] x difficult to refute4 ,he ends by call+ ^u c]ta9 p]sons1 ( :om ,i am "o1 to see ample ju/ice done4 ,?is is ! duty ( e "o1 accord+ to 8 opportunities4 ,s :5 ! reput$ au?or--! article be+ anonym\s--01 9 #ahdi1 propos$ z a ,fell[ ( ! ,a/ronomical ,society1 ,i jo9$--if ,i rememb] "r1 ,i orig9at$--an opposition to 8 election1 until ei!r ! au?or%ip %\ld be d5i$1 or a prop] retraction made4 ,! fri5ds ( ! au?or nei!r d5i$ ! fir/1 nor produc$ ! second3 & !y judg$ x prud5t to )draw ! proposal4 ,_h ,i he>d ( any subsequ5t rep5tance1 ,i w\ld h tak5 "s o!r in/ance1 in/ead ( ?is3 %\ld ,i yet he> ( su* a ?+1 ,i w take c>e to notice x 9 ! cont9uation ( ?is li/1 :i* ,i confid5tly expect1 life & heal? p]mitt+1 to be able to make 9 a few ye>s4 ,?is mu* may be said1 t ! au?or1 9 a lecture on ! subject1 giv5 9 #ahdi1 & publi%$ ) 8 "n1 did n repeat ! *>ge4 ,! libel 0 publi%$ 9 ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e1#beb 7vol4 = #ahdf1 pp4 #fjd-fae73 & ! editor support$ x z foll[s1 7vol4 = #ahdg1 p4 #dgf74 ,9 answ] to ,mr4 ,%eep%anks's *>itable hope t he _h be5 hoax$1 #adb he says3 ,mr4 ,%eep%anks _c c]ta9ly h read ! article ref]r$ to4444 ,sev]e & inculpatory x is--unju/ "s may deem x 7?\gh we ourselves are out ( ! numb]47444 ,a 'hoax' =soo?6 ,may we be (t5 ! dupes ( su* hoaxes6 ,he !n goes on to describe ! article z direct$ aga9/ ! ,a/ronom] ,royal's alleg$ neglect to give ,mr4 ,adams t enc\ragem5t & protection :i* 0 8 due1 & does n h9t "o ^w ab\t ! article conta9+ ! *>ge ( hav+ secretly & fraudul5tly transmitt$ news ( ,mr4 ,adams's rese>*es to ,france1 t an ,engli%man might n h ! honor ( ! discov]y4 ,mr4 ,%eep%anks hav+ call$ ?is a delib]ate calumny1 )\t a p>ticle ( pro( or probability to support x1 ! editor says :at ! rev]5d g5tleman means by ?is1 we are at a loss to und]/&4 ,he !n proce$s n to rememb]4 ,i repeat "h1 :at ,i h said else:]e1 t ! managem5t ( ! j\rnal has *ang$ h&s2 b f #ahdf to #ahef1 x _h ! coll> ( ,s4,s4 7sci5tific sl&]74 ,! pray] = m su* ?+s 0 answ]$ 7,see p4 #cdi74 ,,james ,,ivory4#bec ,i h said t ^? :o are possess$ ) ! idea ( conspiracy aga9/ !mselves are apt to imag9e bo? conspirators & _! bad motives & actions4 ,a p]son :o %\ld take up ! idea ( comb9ation aga9/ himself )\t feel+ ill-w & orig9at+ accusations w\ld be inde$ a p>adox4 ,b su* a p>adox has exi/$4 ,x is v well kn[n1 bo? 9 & beyond ! sci5tific _w1 t ! late ,james ,ivory 0 subject to ! #adc impression ( :i* ,i am speak+2 & ! di>ies & o!r s\rces ( anecdote ( our day w c]ta9ly1 soon] or lat]1 make x a "p ( 8 biography4 ,! consequ5ce w be t to 8 memory w be atta*$ ! unfavorable impression :i* ! usual conduct ( su* p]sons creates2 unless x %\ld happ5 t "s "o :o kn[s ! real /ate ( ! case puts ! two sides ( x prop]ly toge!r4 ,ivory 0 ( t note 9 ! sci5tific _w :i* may be guess$ f ,laplace's description ( him z ! fir/ geomet] 9 ,brita9 & "o ( ! fir/ 9 ,europe4 ,be+ 9 possession ( accurate k ( 8 peculi>ity 9 m cases ?an "o2 & 9 "o case "u 8 own h&3 & hav+ be5 able to make full inquiry ab\t him1 especially f my fri5d ! late ,?omas ,gall[ay#bed--:o came aft] him at ,s&hur/--"o ( ! few p]sons ) :om he 0 intimate3--,i h decid$1 aft] full delib]ation1 to =e/all ! future biographies4 ,t ,ivory 0 haunt$ by ! fe> ( :i* ,i h spok51 to ! fulle/ ext5t1 came to my own public & (ficial k1 z ,secret>y ( ! ,a/ronomical ,society4 ,x 0 ! duty ( ,mr4 ,epps1#bee ! ,assi/ant ,secret>y1 at ! "t :5 ,francis ,baily#bef fir/ ann\nc$ 8 discov]y ( ! ,flam/e$ ,pap]s1 to report to me t ,mr4 ,ivory _h call$ at ! ,society's ap>tm5ts to inquire into ! cont5ts ( ^? pap]s1 & to express 8 hope t ,mr4 ,baily 0 n attack+ liv+ p]sons "u ! names ( ,newton & ,flam/e$4#beg ,mr4 ,gall[ay1 to :om ,i communicat$ ?is1 imm$iately w5t to ,mr4 ,ivory1 & succe$$1 aft] "s explanation1 9 sett+ him "r4 ,?is is b "o ( _m in/ances 9 :i* a man ( ?or\ghly s\nd judgm5t 9 e o!r respect seem$ to be "u a complete *a9 ( delusions ab\t ! conduct ( #add o!rs to himself4 ,b ! p>adox is ?is3--,i nev] c\ld le>n t ,ivory1 pass+ 8 life "u ! impression t secret & unprovok$ enemies 7 at "w ^u 8 "*1 ev] orig9at$ a *>ge1 imput$ a bad motive1 or all[$ himself an unc\rte\s expression4 ,"s lett]s ( 81 n[ 9 my possession1 ref]r+ to a private matt]1 are1 except 9 ! ma9 impression on :i* !y proce$1 unobjectionable 9 e po9t3 !y might h be5 writt5 by a cauti\s fri5d1 ^: object 01 if possible1 to prev5t a diff]5ce f becom+ a duel )\t compromis+ 8 pr9cipal's rights or "*4 ,kn[+ t 9 "s qu>t]s ! k ( ,ivory's peculi>ity is m or less connect$ ) a notion t ! usual consequ5ces foll[$1 ,i ?9k ! prec$+ /atem5t due to 8 memory4 ,,?ree ,,classes ,,( ,,j\rnals4 ,9 su* a record z ! pres5t1 :i* mixes up ! grosse/ speculative absurdities ) e degree ( :at is bett]1 an in/ance ( ano!r k9d may f9d an appropriate place4 ,! faults ( j\rnalism1 :5 m]ely expos$ by o!r j\rnalism pass by & are no m reg>d$4 ,a di/9ct acc\nt ( an und5iable meanness1 record$ 9 a "w ( amusem5t & ref]5ce bo?1 may h its use3 su* a ?+ may act z a w>n+4 ,an editor :o is go+ to indulge 8 private grudge may be prev5t$ f c\nt+ ^u oblivion z a matt] ( c]ta9ty4 ,!re are ?ree k9ds ( j\rnals1 ) ref]5ce to ! mode ( entrance ( contributors4 ,fir/1 z a ?+ :i* has be51 b :i* n[ h>dly exi/s1 !re is ! j\rnal 9 :i* ! editor receives a fix$ sum to f9d ! matt]4 ,9 su* a j\rnal1 e article :i* ! editor c get a fri5d to give him is s mu* 9 8 own pocket1 :i* has a great t5d5cy to l[] ! "* ( ! articles2 b ,i am n conc]n$ ) ?is po9t4 ,secondly1 !re is ! j\rnal :i* is support$ by volunt>y contributions ( #ade matt]1 ! editor select+4 ,?irdly1 !re is ! j\rnal 9 :i* ! contributor is paid by ! proprietors 9 a mann] ) :i* ! lit]>y editor has no?+ to d4 ,! ?ird class is ! safe class1 z its editors "k3 &1 z a usual rule1 !y refuse unpaid contributions ( ! editorial ca/4 ,x is said t :5 ,cann+#beh decl9$ a *eque =w>d$ = an article 9 ! ,qu>t]ly1 ,john ,murray#bei s5t x back ) a blunt ?reat t if he did n take 8 money he c\ld nev] be admitt$ aga94 ,! great publi%] told him t if m5 l himself 9 position work$ = no?+1 all ! m5 l himself 9 tal5t :o c\ld n af=d x w\ld n "w = ! ,qu>t]ly4 ,if ! above did n happ5 betwe5 ,cann+ & ,murray1 x mu/ h happ5$ betwe5 "s o!r two4 ,n[ j\rnals ( ! second class--& ( ! fir/1 if su* !re be--h a fault to :i* !y alone are v liable1 to say no?+ ( ! editorial function 7see ! pap] at ! beg9n+1 p4 #aa et seq471 be+ v mu* cramp$1 a sort ( gratitude t[>ds effective contributors leads ! j\rnal to help _! p]sonal likes & dislikes1 & to sympa?ize ) !m4 ,moreov]1 ?is sort ( j\rnal is m accessible ?an o!rs to articles convey+ p]sonal imputation3 & :5 ^! provoke discussion1 ! j\rnal is apt to take ! "p ( ! assailant to :om x l5t itself 9 ! fir/ in/ance4 ,,! ,,me*anics' ,,magaz9e4 ,among ! j\rnals :i* w5t all l5g?s ) contributors :om !y valu$1 0 ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e#bfj 9 ! p]iod #ahdf-ef4 ,i _c say t matt]s h n m5d$ 9 ! la/ t5 ye>s3 & ,i draw "s #adf presumption t !y h m5d$ f my n hav+ he>d1 s9ce #ahef1 ( any?+ resembl+ =m] proce$+s4 ,& on actual inquiry1 made s9ce ! la/ s5t5ce 0 writt51 ,i f9d t ! prop]ty has *ang$ h&s1 ! editor is no long] ! same1 & ! managem5t is ( a diff]5t /amp4 ,?is j\rnal is *iefly support$ by volunt>y articles3 & x is ! j\rnal 9 :i*1 z above not$1 ! ridicul\s *>ge aga9/ ! ,a/ronom] ,royal 0 made 9 #ahdi4 ,! foll[+ in/ance ( attempt at rev5ge is s amus+ t ,i select x z ! in/ance ( ! defect :i* ,i int5d to illu/rate2 = its pu]ility br+s out 9 bett] relief ! po9ts :i* are n s easily se5 9 m adult attempts4 ,! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e1 :i* by its connection ) eng9e]+1 etc41 _h always tak5 some:at ( a ma!matical "*1 began1 a little be=e #ahdf1 to h m to d ) ab/ract sci5ce4 ,obs]v+ ?is1 ,i began to s5d %ort communications1 :i* 7 always ?ankfully receiv$1 ins]t$1 & well spok5 (4 ,any "o :o looks = my "n 9 t j\rnal 9 #ahdf-di1 w see no?+ b ! mo/ respectful & ev5 laudatory m5tion4 ,9 ,may #ahdi occurr$ ! affair at ! ,a/ronomical ,society1 & my %>e 9 =c+ ! )drawal ( ! "n ( ! alleg$ contributor to ! j\rnal4 ,9 ,febru>y #ahej occurr$ ! opportunity ( paym5t4 ,! ,companion to ! ,almanac#bfa _h to be notic$1 9 :i*1 z !n usual1 0 an article sign$ ) my "n4 ,i %all give ! review ( ?is article entire1 z a sample ( a c]ta9 /yle1 z well z an illu/ration ( my po9t4 ,! read] w obs]ve t my "n is n m5tion$4 ,?is w\ld n h done2 ! read]s ( ! ,magaz9e w\ld h />$ to see a "n ( n infrequ5t occurr5ce 9 previ\s ye>s all ( a sudd5 fall5 f ! heav5 ( respect into ! pit ( contempt1 l ,lucif]1 son ( ! morn+4 ,b be=e #adg giv+ ! review1 ,i %all obs]ve t ,mr4 ,adams1 9 ^: favor ! attack on ! ,a/ronom] ,royal 0 made1 did n appreciate ! favor2 & ( c\rse did n come =w>d to %ield 8 *ampion4 ,?is gave deadly (f5ce1 z appe> f ! foll[+ passage1 7,febru>y #af1 #ahej73 ,x 0 our int5tion to ent] into a comp>ison ( ! cont5ts ( our ,nautical ,almanack ) ^? ( its rival1 ! ,connaissance des ,temps2 b we %all def] x = ! pres5t4 ,! ,nautical ,almanack = #ahea w conta9 ,mr4 ,adams's pap] ',on ! ,p]turbation ( ,uranus'2 & :5 x comes1 9 due c\rse1 be=e ! public1 we are q sure t t g5tleman w expect t we %all aga9 ent] ^u ! subject ) peculi> delight4 ,:il/ we h a ?or\gh loa?+ = mean1 c[>dly1 crawl]s--we h an especial pleasure 9 ma9ta9+ ! claims ( m5 :o are truly grateful z well z highly tal5t$3 ,mr4 ,adams1 !re=e1 w f9d t he _c be disappo9t$--& ! occasion w af=d u an opportunity = mak+ ! comp>ison to :i* we h adv]t$4 ,?is passage illu/rates :at ,i h said on ! editorial function 7,vol4 ,i1 p4 #ae74 ,:at prec$es & foll[s has "s criticism on ! ,gov]nm5t1 ! ,a/ronom] ,royal1 etc41 b res]v$ 9 allusion1 oblique 9 s>casm1 & n fi]cely unc\rte\s4 ,! co>s5ess ( ! passage ,i h quot$ %[s editorial ins]tion1 :i* is also %[n by its blund]4 ,! ins]t] is wait+ = ! ,almanac ( #ahea t he may review ,mr4 ,adams's pap]1 :i* is to be conta9$ 9 x4 ,8 own contributor1 only two s5t5ces be=e ! ins]tion1 _h said1 ,! ,nautical ,almanac1 we believe1 is publi%$ ?ree or f\r ye>s 9 advance4 ,9 fact1 ! ,almanac = #ahea--) ,mr4 ,adams's pap] at ! end--0 publi%$ at ! end ( #ahdg or v beg9n+ ( #ahdh2 x _h !re=e be5 m ?an two ye>s be=e ! public :5 ! passage quot$ 0 writt54 ,& probably e p]son 9 ! c\ntry :o 0 fit to review ,mr4 ,adams's #adh pap]--& mo/ ( ^? :o 7 fit to read x--knew t x _h be5 widely circulat$1 9 revise1 at ! end ( #ahdf3 my copy has writt5 on x1 #b;d revise1 ,decemb] #bg1 #ahdf1 at noon1 9 ! h&writ+ ( ! ,sup]9t5d5t ( ! ,almanac2 & ,i "k t !re 0 an ext5sive issue ( ^! revises1 br\ght out by ! ,le-,v]ri]-&-,adams discussion4 ,i n[ give ! review ( myself1 7,febru>y #bc1 #ahej73 ,! ,briti% ,almanack & ,companion4 ,! ,companion to ?is ,almanack1 = "s ye>s aft] its fir/ publication1 annually conta9$ sci5tific articles by ,sir ,j4 ,lubbock#bfb & o!rs ( a high ord] & great int]e/2 we h n[1 h[ev]1 clos$ ! publication z a sci5tific "o 9 remembrance ( :at x 01 & n 9 consequ5ce ( :at x is4 ,its li/ ( contributors on sci5ce1 has gr[n 'small by degrees & beautifully less1' until x has dw9dl$ d[n to "o--'a la/ rose ( summ] left )]+ alone4' ,! "o contributor has contribut$ "o pap] ',on ,anci5t & ,mod]n ,usage 9 ,reckon+4' ,! le>n$ critic's *ef d'oeuvre1 is consid]$1 by compet5t judges1 to be an ,essay on ,old ,almanacks pr9t$ a few ye>s ago 9 ?is annual1 & suppos$ to be writt5 ) ! view ( surpass+ a pr(\nd memoir on ! same subject by ,james ,o4 ,halliwell1#bfc ,esq41 ,f4,r4 & ,a4,s4,s41 b ! trem5d\s ef=t :i* ! le>n$ writ] !n made to excel _m titl$ competitors = honors 9 ! antique l9e appe>s to h _h a sad effect ^u 8 m5tal p[]s--at any rate1 8 ef=ts h s9ce ye>ly become dull] & dull]2 happily1 at la/1 we %\ld suppose1 '! anci5t #adi & mod]n usage 9 reckon+' indicates ! l[e/ po9t to :i* ! vis in]tia ( ! le>n$ writ]'s peculi> g5ius c =ce him4 ,we w give a few extracts f ! article4 ,! le>n$ au?or says1 ',^? :o are accu/om$ to settle ! mean+ ( anci5t phrases by self-exam9ation w f9d "s /range conclusions arriv$ at by u4' ,! writ] nev] wrote a m correct s5t5ce--x admits ( no k9d ( dispute4 ',language & c\nt+1' says ! le>n$ au?or1 'bo? came be=e ! logical discussion ( ei!r4 ,x is n all[able to argue t some?+ is or 01 because x ought to be or ought to h be54 ,t two negatives make an affirmative1 ought to be2 if no man h done no?+1 ! man :o has done no?+ does n exi/1 & e man has done some?+4 ,b 9 ,greek1 & 9 un$ucat$ ,engli%1 x is unque/ionable t 'no man has done no?+' is only an emphatic way ( say+ t no man has done any?+2 & x w\ld be absurd to reason t x c\ld n h be5 s1 because x %\ld n4'--p4 #e4 ',b !re is ano!r diff]5ce betwe5 old & new times1 yet m rem>kable1 = we h no?+ ( x n[3 :]eas 9 ?+s indivisible we c\nt ) our fa!rs1 & %\ld say 9 buy+ an acre ( l&1 t ! result has no p>ts1 & t ! pur*as]1 till he owns all ! gr\nd1 owns none1 ! *ange ( possession be+ in/antane\s4 ,?is second diff]5ce lies 9 ! habit ( consid]+ no?+1 n\ght1 z]o1 ciph]1 or :atev] x may be call$1 to be at ! beg9n+ ( ! scale ( numb]s4 ,c\nt f\r days f ,monday3 we %\ld n[ say ,tuesday1 ,w$nesday1 ,?ursday1 ,friday2 =m]ly1 x w\ld h be5 ,monday1 ,tuesday1 ,w$nesday1 ,?ursday4 ,_h we ask$1 :at at t rate is ! fir/ day f ,monday1 all w\ld h />$ at a phrase !y _h nev] he>d4 ,^? :o 7 capable ( ext5d+ language w\ld h said1 ,:y x mu/ be ,monday itself3 ! re/ w\ld h said1 !re c #aej be no fir/ day f ,monday1 = ! day aft] is ,tuesday1 :i* mu/ be ! second day3 ,monday1 "o2 ,tuesday1 two1'--p4 #aj4 ,we assure our read]s t ! :ole article is equally lucid1 & its logic alike =mal4 ,!re are "s exce$+ly valuable footnotes2 we give "o ( ! mo/ int]e/+1 tak5 f ! le>n$ ,mr4 ,halliwell's pr(\nd book on ,nurs]y ,rhymes#bfd--;a celebrat$ production1 = :i* x is suppos$ ! au?or 0 made ,f4,r4,s4 ',"o's n9e1 ,two's "s1 ,?ree's a _m1 ,f\r's a p5ny1 ,five's a little hundr$4' ',! la/ l9e ref]s to five score1 ! s-call$ hundr$ be+ m usually six score4 ,! fir/ l9e1 look$ at etymologically1 is "o is n "o1 & ! *ange ( ?\ght by :i* n9e1 ! decimal ( "o1 aims to be associat$ ) ! decimal ( plurality is curi\s3'--,v4 ,?is valuable & pr(\nd essay w v probably be transf]r$ to ! next edition ( ! le>n$ ,mr4 ,halliwell's r>e "w1 ( k9dr$ wor?1 entitl$ ',,r>a ,,ma!matica1' x w !n be des]v$ly h&$ d[n to po/]ity z a cov]+ = *eap trunks--a mo/ appropriate ar*ive = su* a treasure4 ,9 ,decemb]1 #ahdf1 ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e publi%$ a libel on ,airy 9 ! matt] ( ! discov]y ( ,neptune4 ,9 ,may1 #ahdi1 "o 99 99 99 0 to h be5 br\ght =w>d = election at ! ,a/ronomical ,society1 & 0 oppos$ by me & o!rs1 on ! gr\nd t he 0 ! probable au?or ( ?is libel1 & t he w\ld n1 p]haps c\ld #aea n1 d5y x4 ,n4,b4 ,i no m d\bt t he 0 ! au?or !n ,i d\bt t ,i am ! au?or ( ?is s5t5ce4#bfe ,accord+ly1 99 99 99 0 )drawn1 & a discussion took place1 = :i* see ! ,a!naeum1 ,no4 #aabf1 ,may #bf1 #ahdi1 p4 #edd4 ,! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e 0 v sore1 b up to ?is day has nev] v5tur$ beyond an attack on ,airy1 private :isp]+s aga9/ ,adams--7see ante1 p4 #adg71--;& ! above aga9/ myself4 ,9 due "t1 ,i d\bt n my "n w appe> z "o ( ! ames damnees#bff ( ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e4#bfg ,t4 ,s4 ,,davies ,,on ,,euclid4 ,fir/1 z to ,mr4 ,halliwell4 ,! late ,?omas ,/eph5s ,davies1#bfh excell5t 9 geometry1 & mo/ le>n$ 9 its hi/ory1 0 also a good h& at enmity1 ?\gh n implacable4 ,he & ,mr4 ,halliwell1 :o _h long be=e be5 v mu* "o1 71 at ?is date1 v mu* two4 ,i d n ?9k ,t4 ,s4 ,davies wrote ?is article2 & ,i ?9k t by giv+ my reasons ,i %all d s]vice to 8 memory4 ,x mu/ h be5 writt5 at ! beg9n+ ( ,febru>y2 & )9 ?ree days ( t "t ,t4 ,s4 ,davies 0 mak+ ov] to me1 by 8 own free act1 to be kept until claim$ by ! relatives1 :at all :o knew ev5 8 writ+s knew t he consid]$ z ! mo/ preci\s deposit he _h ev] _h 9 8 keep+--,horn]'s#bfi pap]s4 ,8 lett] ann\nc+ ! transmission is dat$ ,febru>y #b1 #ahej4 ,?is is a /rong po9t2 b !re is ano!r q z /rong4 ,euclid & #aeb 8 writ+s 7 matt]s on :i* ,t4 ,s4 ,davies knew nei!r fe> nor favor3 he c\ld n h writt5 lightly ab\t a man :o /ood high ) him z a judge ( ,euclid4 ,n[ 9 ?is v lett] ( ,feb4 #b1 !re is a s5t5ce :i* ,i highly value1 because1 z a=esaid1 x is on a po9t on :i* he w\ld nev] h yield$ any?+1 to :i* he _h paid life-long att5tion1 & on :i* he _h ! bias ( hav+ long /ood alone4 ,9 fact1 kn[+--& :at ,i %all quote confirms me1--t 9 ! matt] ( ,euclid 8 h& 0 aga9/ e man1 ,i expect$1 :5 ,i s5t him a copy ( my #bb-;column article1 ,eucleides 9 ,smi?'s ,diction>y1#bgj to h receiv$ back a criticism1 t w\ld h bl[n me out ( ! wat]3 & ,i ?\ght x n unlikely t a man s well up 9 ! subject might h made me feel demoli%$ on "s po9ts4 ,in/ead ( ?is1 ,i got ! foll[+3 ,al?\gh on "o or two m9or po9ts ,i d n q accord ) y\r views1 yet z a :ole & )\t reg>d to any m9or po9ts1 ,i ?9k y are ! fir/ :o has succe$$ 9 a del9eation ( ,euclid z a geomet]4 ,all ?is duly consid]$1 x is utt]ly incr$ible t ,t4 ,s4 ,davies %\ld h writt5 ! review 9 "q4 ,& yet ,mr4 ,halliwell is treat$ j z ,t4 ,s4 ,davies w\ld h treat$ him1 z to tone & _s4 ,! inf]5ce 9 my m9d is t we h "h a m>k$ in/ance ( ! jo9+ ( hatr$s :i* takes place 9 j\rnals support$ by volunt>y contributions ( matt]4 ,%\ld any?+ ev] h reviv$ ?is article--& no "o ev] kn[s :at might h be5 fi%$ up f ! =gott5 mass ( j\rnals--! treatm5t ( ,mr4 ,halliwell w\ld c]ta9ly h ?r[n a suspicion on ,t4 ,s4 ,davies1 a l>ge & regul> contributor to ! ,magaz9e4 ,x is good s]vice to 8 memory to po9t out :at makes x incr$ible t he %\ld h writt5 s unwor?y an article4 ,! fault is ?is4 ,!re are f\r extracts3 ! fir/ #aec ?ree are p]fectly well pr9t$4 ,! pr9t+ ( ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e 0 v good4 ,i 0 always exce$+ly satisfi$ ) ! mann] 9 :i* my articles appe>$1 )\t my see+ pro(4 ,mo/ likely ^! extracts 7 pr9t$ f my pr9t$ pap]2 if n ! extractor 0 a good copi]4 ,i "k ?is by a te/ :i* has (t5 s]v$ me4 ,i use ! subjunctive--if no man h done no?+1 an ord9>y transcrib]1 n>rat+ a quotation almo/ always lets 8 own habit write has4 ,! f\r? extract has ?ree alt]ations1 all t5d+ to make me ridicul\s4 ,none is alt]$1 9 two places1 into n9e1 d5ial into decimal1 & comes into aims2 s t none1 ! d5ial ( "o1 comes to be associat$ ) ! d5ial ( plurality1 reads z n9e1 ! decimal ( "o1 aims to be associat$ ) ! decimal ( plurality4 ,?is is int5tional2 _h x be5 a compositor's read+ ( bad h&writ+1 ^! w\ld n h be5 ! only mi/akes2 to say no?+ ( ! corrector ( ! press4 ,& bo? ! compositor & read] w\ld h guess$1 f ! fir/ l9e be+ translat$ into "o is n "o1 t x mu/ h be5 "o's none1 n "o's n9e4 ,b x 0 n int5d$ t ! gem %\ld be recov]$ f ! unfa?om$ cave1 & set 9 a ,budget ( ,p>adoxes4 ,we h _h pl5ty ( sl&]-p>adox4 ,i n[ give a halfp5nywor? ( bread to all ?is sack1 an in/ance ( ! p>adox ( b5evol5ce1 9 :i* an individual runs c\nt] to all ! ideas ( 8 "t1 & sees 8 way into ! next c5tury4 ,at ,ami5s1 at ! end ( ! la/ c5tury1 an in/itution 0 end[$ by a ,m4 de ,morgan1 to :om ,i hope ,i am ( k91 b ,i _c trace x2 ! "n is common at ,ami5s4 ,x 0 ! fir/ ( ! k9d ,i ev] he>d (4 ,x is a ,salle d',asyle = *ildr51 :o are taught & wa%$ & tak5 c>e ( dur+ ! h\rs 9 :i* _! p>5ts mu/ be at "w4 ,! f\nd] 0 a l>ge :olesale groc] & colonial import]1 :o 0 made a ,b>on by ,napoleon ,i = 8 comm]cial success & 8 *>ities4 #aed ,,jas4 ,,smi? ,,aga94 #ahfb4 ,mr4 ,smi? replies to me1 /ill sign+ himself ,nauticus3 ,i give an extract3 ,by hypo!sis :at1 aga96 let #ad deg4 #bd' be ! *ord ( an arc ( #ae deg4 b ,i wont1 says #ad deg4 #bd'1 & consequ5tly equal to a side ( a regul> polygon ( #bd sides inscrib$ 9 ! circle4 ,!n #d times #ad deg4 #bd' #eg deg4 #cf' ! radius ( ! circle 444 ,t is1 f\r times ! *ord ( an arc is ! *ord ( f\r times ! arc3 & ! sum ( f\r sides ( a c]ta9 p5tagon is equal to ! fif?4 ,?is is ! capital ( ! column1 ! cr[n ( ! ar*1 ! apex ( ! pyramid1 ! wat]%$ ( ! elevation4 ,oh6 ,j4 ,s46 ,j4 ,s46 groans ,geometry--,summum ,j4 ,s4 summa injuria6#bga ,! o!r ,j4 ,s41 ,joseph ,scalig]1#bgb z already m5tion$1 _h 8 own way ( d5y+ t a /raight l9e is always ! %orte/ di/ance betwe5 two po9ts4 ,a p>allel might be in/itut$1 b n 9 half a column4 ,& ,j4 ,s4 ! second has be5 s tightly h&l$ t he may n[ be dismiss$1 ) an inscription = 8 circul> %ield1 obta9$ by *ang+ ,lexica contexat into ,circus quadr&us 9 an epigram ( ,j4 ,s4 ! fir/3 ,si quem dura manet s5t5tia judicis1 olim ,damnatum a]umnis suppliciisque caput1 ,hunc neque fabrili lass5t erga/ula massa1 ,nec rigidas vex5t fossa metalla manus4 ,circus quadr&us3 nam--caet]a quid moror8--omnes ,po5>um facies hic labor unus habet4#bgc #aee ,i _h writt5 z f> z damnatum :5 9 came ! lett] ( ,nauticus z a pr9t$ slip1 ) a reque/ t ,i w\ld consid] ! slip z a 'revis$ copy4' ,n a ^w ( alt]ation 9 ! "p ,i h quot$6 ,& 9 ! ev5+ came a lett] desir+ t ,i w\ld alt] a gross error2 b n ! "o above3 ?is is revis+ )\t revision6 ,if !re 7 cyclomet]s en\gh ( ?is /amp1 !y w\ld1 z cultivation progresses--& really1 ) ,john ,/u>t ,mill 9 = ,we/m9/]1 x seems on ! move1 ev5 ?\gh1 z ,i le>n :ile correct+ ! pro(1 ,glad/one be out f ,ox=d2 = ,ox=d is no worse ?an 9 #ahbi1 :ile ,we/m9/] is f> above :at %e ev] has be53 election "t excuses ev5 su* a p>5!sis z ?is--be engag$ to amuse ^? :o c af=d x ) p>alogism at _! meals1 aft] ! mann] ( ! o!r jok]s :o wore ! caps & bells4 ,! ri* w\ld !n ord] _! d9n]s ) panem et ,circ5ses1--up ) ! victuals & ! circle-games--z ! poor did 9 ! days ( old4 ,mr4 ,smi? is det]m9$ t half a column %all n d4 ,n a day )\t some?+ f him3 lett]1 pr9t$ pro(1 pamphlet4 ,9 :at is ! la/ at ?is mom5t ( writ+ he tells me t "p ( ! title ( a "w ( 8 w be ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan 9 ! pillory )\t hope ( escape4 ,& :]e w he be himself8 ,?is ,i detect$ by an ef=t ( reason+ :i* ,i nev] c\ld h made except by foll[+ 9 8 /eps4 ,9 all matt]s connect$ ) pi ! lett]s l & g are closely relat$3 ?is appe>s 9 ! well-kn[n =mula = ! "t ( oscillation pi sqrt7l 3 g74 ,h5ce g may be writt5 = l1 b only once3 d x twice1 & y require ! "t to be pi sqrt7l#b 3 g#b74 ,?is may be re9=c$ by obs]v+ t if z a datum1 or if y dislike t ^w1 by hypo!sis1 ! fir/ l be a g1 x is absurd t x %\ld be an l4 ,write g = ! fir/ l1 & we h un fait accompli4 ,i %all be 9 pillory2 & ov]head1 9 a cl\d1 w sit ,mr4 ,james ,smi? on "o /ick laid across two o!rs1 "u a nimbus ( #c-a_/h diamet]s to #aef ! circumf]5ce--9 pi-glory4 ,oh = a draw+ ( ?is sc5e6 ,mr4 ,de ,morgan pres5ts 8 complim5ts to ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 & reque/s ! honor ( an ex*ange ( photographs4 ,july #bf4--;,ano!r pr9t$ lett]4--,mr4 ,james ,smi? begs = a di/9ct answ] to ! foll[+ pla9 "q3 ,h ,i n 9 ?is communication br\ght "u y\r notice tru?s t 7 nev] be=e dream$ ( 9 y\r geometrical & ma!matical philosophy8 ,to :i*1 he hav+ tak5 ! precaution to pr9t ! ^w tru?s 9 italics1 ,i c consci5ti\sly answ]1 ,yes1 y h4 ,& n[ ,i %all take no m notice ( ^! tru?s1 until ,i receive some?+ :i* surpasses all t has yet be5 done4 ,a ,,few ,,small ,,p>adox]s4 ,! ,circle sec]n$ f ! ,squ>e2 & its area gaug$ 9 t]ms ( a triangle common to bo?4 ,by ,wm4 ,h\l/on1#bgd ,esq4 ,london & ,j]sey1 #ahfb1 #dto4 ,mr4 ,h\l/on squ>es at ab\t f\r poetical quotations 9 a page1 & br+s out pi #c4adbac4444 ,8 frontispiece is a v>iegat$ diagram1 hav+ p>ts designat$ ,inigo & ,outigo4 ,all :i* relieves ! subject1 b does n remove ! error4 ,consid]ations respect+ ! figure ( ! ,e>?4444 ,by ,c4 ,f4 ,bakewell4#bge ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,newton & o!rs ?9k t 9 a revolv+ sph]e ! #aeg loose surface matt] w t5d to ! equator3 ,mr4 ,bakewell ?9ks x w t5d to ! poles4 ,on ecc5tric & c5tric =ce3 a new !ory ( projection4 ,by ,h4 ,f4 ,a4 ,pratt1 ,m4,d4#bgf ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,dr4 ,pratt n only upsets ,newton1 b cuts away ! v gr\nd he /&s on3 = he de/roys ! fir/ law ( motion1 & w n h ! natural t5d5cy ( matt] 9 motion to be rectil9e>4 ,?is1 z we h se51 0 ,john ,wal%'s#bgg notion4 ,9 a m rec5t "w ,on ,orbital ,motion1 ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo41 ,dr4 ,pratt insi/s on ano!r ( ,wal%'s notions1 namely1 t ! precession ( ! equ9oxes is caus$ by ! motion ( ! sol> sy/em r\nd a di/ant c5tral sun4 ,9 ?is la/ "w ! au?or ref]s to a few notes1 :i* completely de/roy ! !ory ( gravitation 9 t]ms p]fectly intelligible z well to ! unle>n$ z to ! le>n$3 to me !y are q un9telligible1 :i* r t5ds to confirm a notion ,i h long _h1 t ,i am nei!r "o ?+ nor ! o!r4 ,!re is an ambiguity ( phrase :i* delights a writ] on logic1 always on ! look-out = specim5s ( homonymia or aequivocatio4 ,! au?or1 z a physician1 is accu/om$ to appeal f m]e =mulae3 accord+ly1 he sets at n\ght ! :ole ( ! ma!matics1 :i* he does n und]/&4 ,?is equivocation betwe5 ! =mula ( ! physician & t ( ! ma!matician is z good1 ?\gh n s p]ceptible to ! _w at l>ge1 z t made by ,mr4 ,briggs's fri5d 9 ,pun*'s picture1 :i* ,i cut out to pa/e into my ,logic4 ,mr4 ,briggs wrote = a c\ple ( bruis]s1 mean+ to prep>e oats = 8 horses3 8 fri5d s5t him ! ,:ite*apel ,*ick5 & ! ,bayswat] ,sla%]1 ) ! gloves1 all ready4 #aeh ,on matt] & e!r1 & ! secret laws ( physical *ange4 ,by ,t4 ,r4 ,birks1 ,m4,a4#bgh ,cambridge1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,bold ef=ts are made at molecul> !ories1 & ! "o be=e me is ably aim$4 ,:5 ! ,newton ( ?is subject %all be seat$ 9 8 place1 books l ! pres5t w be %>ply look$ into1 to see :at am\nt ( anticipation !y h made4 ,,dr4 ,,?orn ,,& ,,mr4 ,,bid54 ,! hi/ory ( ! '?orn tree & bu%' f ! e>lie/ to ! pres5t "t3 9 :i* is cle>ly & pla9ly %[n ! desc5t ( h] mo/ graci\s ,maje/y & h] ,anglo-,saxon p f ! half tribe ( ,ephraim1 & possibly f ! half tribe ( ,manasseh2 & consequ5tly h] "r & title to possess1 at ! pres5t mom5t1 = h]self & = !m1 a %>e or %>es ( ! desolate cities & places 9 ! l& ( _! =efa!rs6 ,by ,!ta1 ,m4,d4#bgi 7,private circulation47 ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,?is is mu* ab\t ,?orn1 & its connect$ words1 ,?or1 ,?o?1 ,!ta1 etc4 ,x is a v my/]i\s vag>y4 ,! au?or ( x is ! p]son :om ,i h describ$ else:]e z hav+ = 8 device ! r\nd man 9 ! ?ree-corn]$ hole1 ! writ] ( ! little heap ( satirical anonym\s lett]s ab\t ! ,bea/ & #fff4 ,by accid5t ,i discov]$ ! writ]3 s t if !re be any m ?orns to crackle "u ! pot1 !y ne$ n be anonym\s4 ,nor w !y be anonym\s4 ,s9ce ,i wrote ! above1 ,i h receiv$ onym\s lett]s1 z om9\s z ! re/4 ,! writ]1 ,william ,?orn1 ,m4,d41 is oblig$ to reveal #aei himself1 s9ce x is 8 object to prove t he himself is "o #fff4 ,by us+ ,w = d\ble ,vau 7or #ab7 he cooks ! numb] out ( 8 own "n4 ,b he says x is ! numb] n ( a bea/ b ( a man1 & adds1 ,!reby hangs a tale6 :i* s\nds l contradiction4 ,he in=ms me t he w talk ! matt] ov] ) me3 b ,i %all c]ta9ly h no?+ to say to a g5tleman ( 8 numb]2 x is be/ to keep on ! safe side4 ,9 "o lett] ,i am in=m$ t n a l9e %\ld ,i h _h1 b = my sne] at #fff1 :i*1 !re=e1 ,i am well pleas$ to h giv54 ,i am also told t my "n means ! 'g>d5 ( dea?1' t place 9 :i* ! tree ( k 0 pluck$1 & s y are l y\r "n 'dead' to ! fact t y are an ,israelite1 l ^? 9 ,ezekiel #cg *4 ,"s h9ts are giv5 t ,i %all n f>e well 9 ! next _w1 :i* any "o :o reads ! *apt] 9 ,ezekiel w see is q aga9/ 8 comp>ison4 ,! read] mu/ n imag9e t my progno/icator means ,morgan to be a corruption ( ,mortj>d92 he proves 8 po9t by ,hebrew3 b any philologi/ w\ld tell him ! true d]ivation ( ! "n1 & h[ ,glamorgan came to get x4 ,x w be ( mu* com=t to ^? "y m5 :o h n got ?r\gh to "k t ! tree ( k itself 0 once 9 ! same case4 ,& s good bye to #fff = ! pres5t1 & ! assumption t ! enigma is to be solv$ by ! unit$ num]al =ces ( ! lett]s ( a ^w4 ,x is wor?y ( note t1 z soon z my ,budget comm5c$1 two gu>dian spirits />t$ up1 fell[ m5 z to ! fle%1 bo? totally unkn[n to me3 !y h /uck to me f fir/ to la/4 ,james ,smi?1 ,esq41 f9ally ,nauticus1 wat*es ov] my "* 9 ?is _w1 & w\ld fa9 pres]ve me f ignorance1 folly1 & di%one/y1 by inclos+ me 9 a magic circle ( #c-a_/h diamet]s 9 circumf]5ce4 ,! r\nd man 9 ! ?ree-corn]$ hole1 f9ally ,william ,?orn1 ,m4,d41 takes *>ge ( my future de/9y1 #afj & tries to br+ me to ! tru? by unfold+ a score ( mean+s--all "r--( #fff4 ,he h9ts t ,i1 & my wife1 are s]vants ( ,satan3 at lea/ he desires u bo? to rememb] t we _c s]ve ,god & ,satan2 & he c h>dly mean t we are s]v+ ! fir/1 & t he w\ld h u s]ve ! second4 ,z becomes an int]pret] ( ! ,apocalypse1 he uses sev5 diff]5t seals2 b n m ?an "o to "o lett]4 ,if 8 seals be all signet-r+s1 he mu/ be :at ,ari/ophanes calls a sphragidony*>gocometical fell[4 ,b--& _m ?anks to him = ! same--?\gh an ,m4,d41 he has n s5t me a s+le vial4 ,& s mu* = my tree ( secul> k & my tree ( spiritual life3 ,i dismiss !m ) ?anks f myself & ?anks f my read]4 ,! dual ( ! ,py?agorean sy/em 0 ,isis & ,diana2 ( ! ,jewi% law1 ,moses & ,a>on2 & ( ! ,city ( ,london1 ,gog & ,magog2 ( ! ,p>adoxiad1 ,james ,smi?1 ,esq41 & ,william ,?orn1 ,m4,d4 ,septemb]1 #ahff4 ,mr4 ,james ,bid5#bhj has favor$ me ) "s ( 8 publications4 ,he is a rival ( ,dr4 ,?orn2 a prophet by "n-"r & cre/-"r4 ,he is ( royal desc5t ?r\gh ! ,de ,biduns4 ,he is ! wat*man ( ,ezekiel3 ,god has told him s4 ,he is ! au?or ( ,! ,true ,*ur*1 a phrase :i* seems to h a book-mean+ & a mission-mean+4 ,he %all speak = himself3 ,a cre/ ( ! ,bid5s has significance4 ,x is a lion rampant betwe5 w+s--w+s 9 ,scripture d5ote ! flight ( "t4 ,?us ! bea/s or liv+ creatures ( ! ,revelations h ea* six w+s1 intimat+ a condition ( mank9d up to & t[>ds ! close ( six ?\s& ye>s ( ,bible tea*+4 ,! two w+s ( ! cre/ w\ld ?us intimate p[] t[>ds ! expiration ( #bjjj ye>s1 z "t is m>k$ 9 ! hi/ory ( ,great ,brita94 #afa ,9 a rec5t publication1 ,! ,pe/il5ce1 ,:y ,inflict$1 are giv5 _m reasons :y ! writ] ?9ks himself to be ! appo9t$ wat*man =etold by ,ezekiel1 *apt]s iii4 & xxxiii4 ,among ! reasons are _m prophecies fulfill$ 9 him4 ,( ^! x is n[ ne$ful to note two z be>+ especially on ! subject ( ! reign ( ,d>ius4 #a4--;,9 ,daniel x is said1 ',d>ius ! ,m$ian took ! k+dom1 be+ ab\t ?reescore & two ye>s old4'--,daniel v4 #ca4 ,:5 ',bel%azz>' ! k+ ( ! ,*aldeans is f\nd want+1 ,d>ius takes ! k+dom4 ,x is n giv5 him by ! popul> voice2 he ass]ts 8 "r1 & ?is is n d5i$4 ,he takes x :5 ab\t sixty-two ye>s ( age4 ,! language ( ,daniel is prophetic1 & ,d>ius has 9 ano!r an antitype4 ,! writ] 0 born ,july #ah?1 #ahjc2 & ! claim 0 ass]t$ at ! close ( #ahfe1 :5 he 0 ab\t sixty-two ye>s ( age4 ,! claims :i* h be5 ass]t$ dem& a settl$ fai?1 & :i* c\ld only be rea*$ ?r\gh a long c\rse ( div9e tea*+4 ,:5 ,i 0 a little boy at s*ool1 "o ( my s*ool-fell[s took x into 8 head to set up a lott]y ( m>bles3 ! ?+ took1 & he made a /ony pr(it4 ,soon1 "o aft] ano!r1 e boy _h 8 lott]y1 & x 01 ,i won't put into y\rs unless y put into m9e4 ,?is knock$ up ! s*eme4 ,x w be ! same ) ! prophets4 ,dr4 ,?orn1 ,mr4 ,bid51 ,mrs4 ,cottle1#bha etc4 w gr[ imitators1 until we are all po9t$ out 9 ! ,bible3 b ,a w n admit ,b's claim unless ,b admits 84 ,= myself1 z else:]e %[n1 ,i am ! fir/ ,bea/ 9 ! ,revelations4 ,e contrab& prophet gets a few foll[]s3 x is a great po9t to make ^! sequaci\s p into ,buridan's asses1 :i* !y w become :5 prophets are s num]\s t !re is no *oos+4 #afb ,,sir ,g4 ,c4 ,,lewis4 ,an hi/orical survey ( ! ,a/ronomy ( ! ,anci5ts4 ,by ! ,rt4 ,hon4 ,sir ,g4 ,c4 ,lewis4#bhb #hvo4 #ahfb4 ,!re are few m5 ( our day :om ,i admire m ?an ! late ,sir ,g4 ,lewis3 he 0 hone/1 e>ne/1 sagaci\s1 le>n$1 & indu/ri\s4 ,he probably sacrific$ 8 life to 8 conjunction ( lit]ature & politics3 & he /ood high z a m9i/] ( /ate 9 addition to 8 "* z a man ( lett]s4 ,! "w above nam$ is ( great value1 & w be read = its intr9sic m]it1 consult$ = its cr[d ( valuable ref]5ces1 quot$ = its aid to "o side ( _m a discussion1 & oppos$ = its =ce aga9/ ! o!r4 ,its au?or 0 also a wit & a satiri/4 ,i "k ( ?ree classical satires ( our day :i* are inimitable imitations3 ,mr4 ,mald5's#bhc ,pragmatiz$ ,leg5ds1 ,mr4 ,mansel's#bhd ,phronti/]ion1 & ,sir ,g4 ,cornewall ,lewis's ,inscriptio ,antiqua4 ,9 ?is la/1 ,,heydiddl$iddle!cat&!fiddle etc4 is treat$ z an ,oscan inscription1 & r5d]$ into ,lat9 by approv$ me?ods4 ,z few read]s h se5 x1 ,i give ! result3 ,hejus d$it lib5t]1 d$it lib5t]4 ,deus propitius e/1 deus donatori lib5t] favet4 ,deus 9 vi>um #afc junctura ovorum dape colitur1 deus mundi4 ,deus 9 litatione voluit1 b5igno animo1 ha$um1 taurum intra f9es loci sacri port&os4 ,deus1 bis lu/ratus1 beat fossam sacrae libationis4#bhe ,h[ !n comes ! hi/ory ( a/ronomy among ! p>adoxes8 ,simply because ! au?or1 s admirably :5 writ+ ab\t :at he knew1 did n "k :at he did n "k1 & blund]$ l a circle-squ>]4 ,& :y %\ld ! faults ( s good a writ] be record$ 9 su* a li/ z ! pres5t8 ,= ?ree reasons3 ,fir/1 & =emo/1 because if ! exposure be n made by "s "o1 ! errors w gradually ooze out1 & ! "w w get ! "* ( inaccurate4 ,no?+ hurts a book ( :i* few c fa?om ! dep?s s mu* z a pla9 blund] or two on ! surface4 ,secondly1 because ! reviews ei!r pass$ ov] ^! errors or treat$ !m too g5tly1 r imply+ _! exi/5ce ?an expos+ !m4 ,?irdly1 because !y /rongly illu/rate ! melan*oly tru?1 t no "o kn[s en\gh to write ab\t :at he does n "k4 ,! di/9ctness ( ! errors is a m]it2 x proce$s f ! cle>-head$ness ( ! au?or4 ,! suppression 9 ! j\rnals may be due p>tly to admiration ( ! tal5t & en]gy :i* liv$ two difficult lives at once1 p>tly to respect = high position 9 public affairs1 p>tly to "s ( ! critics be+ !mselves m5 ( le>n+ only1 unable to detect ! errors4 ,b we "k t action & reaction are equal & contr>y4 ,if our g5]ation take no notice ( defects1 & all[ !m to g d[n undetect$ among m]its1 ! next g5]ation w discov] !m1 w p]haps believe u incapable ( detect+ !m1 at lea/ w pron\nce our judgm5t good = no?+1 & w =m an #afd op9ion 9 :i* ! m]its w be und]rat$3 s x has be51 is1 & w be4 ,! be/ ?+ t c be done = ! memory ( ! au?or is to remove ! uns\nd "p t ! rema9d] may ?rive4 ,! errors d n affect ! "w2 !y occur 9 passages :i* might v well h be5 omitt$3 & ,i consid] t1 9 mak+ !m conspicu\s1 ,i am b cutt+ away a delet]i\s fungus f a noble tree4 7,p4 #aed74 ,! p]iodic times ( ! five planets 7 /at$ by ,eudoxus1#bhf z we le>n f ,simplicius2#bhg ! foll[+ is 8 /atem5t1 to :i* ! true times are subjo9$1 = ! sake ( comp>ison3 ,,/atem5t ,,( ,,eudoxus ,,true ,,"t ,m]cury #a ye> -- #hg;d4 #bc;h4 ,v5us #a -- #bbd;d4 #af;h4 ,m>s #b #ay4 #cba;d4 #bc;h4 ,jupit] #ab #aay4 #cae;d4 #ad;h4 ,saturn #cj #biy4 #agd;d4 #a;h4 ,^u ?is det]m9ation two rem>ks may be made4 ,fir/1 ! error ) respect to ,m]cury & ,v5us is consid]able2 ) respect to ,m]cury1 x is1 9 r\nd numb]s1 #cfe in/ead ( #hh days1 m ?an f\r times too mu*4 ,ari/otle rem>ks t ,eudoxus di/+ui%es ,m]cury & ,v5us f ! o!r ?ree planets by giv+ !m "o sph]e ea*1 ) ! poles 9 common4 ,! proximity ( ,m]cury to ! sun w\ld r5d] its c\rse difficult to obs]ve & to measure1 b ! cause ( ! l>ge error ) respect to ,v5us 7#acj days7 is n app>5t4 #afe ,sir ,g4 ,lewis takes ,eudoxus z mak+ ! planets move r\nd ! sun2 he has accord+ly comp>$ ! geoc5tric p]iods ( ,eudoxus ) our helioc5tric p]iods4 ,:at great] blund] c be made by a writ] on anci5t a/ronomy ?an giv+ ,eudoxus ! ,cop]nican sy/em8 ,if ,m]cury 7 a black spot 9 ! middle ( ! sun x w\ld ( c\rse move r\nd ! e>? 9 a ye>1 or appe> to d s3 let x sw+ a little on "o side & ! o!r ( ! sun1 & ! av]age p]iod is /ill a ye>1 ) slight dep>tures bo? ways4 ,! same = ,v5us1 ) l>g] dep>tures4 ,say t a p]son n mu* accu/om$ to ! di/9ction might = once write d[n ! mi/ake2 h[ are we to expla9 its rema9+ 9 ! m9d 9 a p]man5t =m1 & be+ made a gr\nd = su* speculation z t ( ! difficulty ( obs]v+ ,m]cury lead+ to a p]iod f\r times :at x ought to be1 correct$ 9 pro( & publi%$ by an indu/ri\s & ?\ghtful p]son8 ,only 9 "o way3 ! writ] 0 q out ( 8 dep?4 ,?is "o case is conclusive2 be x said ) all respect = ! real /aple ( ! "w & ( ! au?or4 ,he knew well ! diff]5ce ( ! sy/ems1 b n ! effect ( ! diff]5ce3 he is ano!r in/ance ( :at ,i h _h to illu/rate by help ( a v diff]5t p]son1 t x is difficult to reason well ^u matt] :i* is n famili>4 7,p4 #bed74 ,cop]nicus1 9 fact1 suppos$ ! axis ( ! e>? to be always turn$ t[>ds ! ,sun47#afi7 7#afi74 ,see ,delambre1 ,hi/4 ,a/r4 ,mod41 ,vol4 ,i1 p4 #if4 ,x 0 res]v$ to ,kepl] to prop\nd ! hypo!sis ( ! con/ant p>allelism ( ! e>?'s axis to itself4 ,if !re be "o ?+ m prom95t ?an ano!r 9 ! "w ( ,cop]nicus himself1 9 ! popul> explanations ( x1 & 9 ! page ( ,delambre#bhh cit$1 x is t ! p>allelism ( ! e>?'s axis is a gl>+ "p ( ! #aff !ory ( ,cop]nicus4 ,:at ,kepl]#bhi did 0 to ?r[ away1 z unnecess>y1 ! me?od by :i* ,cop]nicus1 p] fas et nefas1#bij secur$ x4 ,cop]nicus1 ?9k+ ( ! e>?'s orbital revolution z ^? w\ld ?9k :o 7 accu/om$ to ! solid orbs--& mu* z ! /opp]s ( ! moon's rotation d n[3 :y d !y n /r5g!n !mselves ) ,cop]nicus8--?\ght t ! e>?'s axis w\ld always incl9e ! same end t[>ds ! sun1 unless measures 7 tak5 to prev5t x4 ,he did take measures3 he inv5t$ a comp5sat+ conical motion ( ! axis to pres]ve ! p>allelism2 &1 :i* is "o ( ! mo/ rem>kable po9ts ( 8 sy/em1 he obta9$ ! precession ( ! equ9oxes by giv+ ! necess>y trifle m ?an comp5sation4 ,:at />es u 9 ! face at ! beg9n+ ( ! p>agraph to :i* ! au?or ref]s8 ,c'e/ donc p\r arriv] a ce p>allelisme1 ou p\r le cons]v]1 que ,cop]nic a cru devoir rec\rir a ce m\vem5t egal et oppose qui detruit l'effet qu'il attribue si gratuitem5t au premi]1 de d]ang] le p>allelisme4#bia ,p>allelism at any price1 is ! motto ( ,cop]nicus3 y ne$ n pay s de>1 is ! rem>k ( ,kepl]4 ,! op9ions giv5 by ,sir ,g4 ,lewis ab\t ! effects ( mod]n a/ronomy1 :i* he does n und]/& & s+ul>ly und]values1 w n[ be se5 to be ( no au?ority4 ,he fancies t--to give an in/ance--= ! det]m9ation ( a %ip's place1 ! inv5tion ( *ronomet]s has be5 f> m important ?an any improvem5t 9 a/ronomical !ory 7p4 #bed74 ,n to speak ( latitude1--?\gh ! omission is n )\t importance1--he ought to h kn[n t longitude is f\nd by ! diff]5ce betwe5 :at o'clock x is at ,gre5wi* & at ! %ip's place1 at #afg "o absolute mom5t ( "t4 ,n[ if a *ronomet] 7 q p]fect--:i* no *ronomet] is1 be x said--& w\ld truly tell ,gre5wi* mean "t all ov] ! _w1 x ought to h be5 cle> t j z good a wat* is want$ = ! "t at ! place ( obs]vation1 be=e ! longitude ( t place ) respect to ,gre5wi* c be f\nd4 ,!re is no su* wat*1 except ! />ry heav5 itself3 & t wat* c only be read by a/ronomical obs]vation1 aid$ by ! be/ k ( ! heav5ly motions4 ,i ?9k ,i h done ,sir ,g4 ,lewis's v excell5t book m good ?an all ! review]s put toge!r4 ,i w give an old in/ance 9 :i* lit]ature got into confusion ab\t a/ronomy4 ,!ophra/us1#bib :o is ei!r ! culprit or 8 hi/orian1 attributes to ,meton1#bic ! contriv] ( ! lun> cal5d> ( n9ete5 ye>s1 :i* la/s to ?is day1 t 8 sol/ices 7 det]m9$ = him by a c]ta9 ,phae9us ( ,elis on ,m\nt ,lycabettus4 ,nobody else m5tions ?is a/ronom]3 ?\gh x is pretty c]ta9 t ,meton himself made m ?an "o appo9tm5t ) him = ! purpose ( obs]v+ sol/ices2 & we may be sure t if ei!r 7 beh9d 8 "t1 x 0 ,meton4 ,= ,phae9us ,helius is ! %9+ sun himself2 & 9 ! a/ronomical poet ,aratus#bid we read ab\t ! n9ete5 ye>s ( ! %9+ sun3 ,greek3 ,enneakaideka kukla phae9\ eelioio4#bie ,"s man ( lett]s mu/ h turn$ ,apollo into ,phae9us ( ,elis2 & !re he is 9 ! hi/ories ( a/ronomy to #afh ?is day4 ,salmasius#bif w h ,aratus to h meant him1 & proposes to read ,greek3 eleioio3 he did n obs]ve t ,phae9us is a v common adjective ( ,aratus1 & t1 if 8 conjecture 7 "r1 ?is ,phae9us w\ld be ! only non-my?ical man 9 ! poems ( ,aratus4 ,:5 ,i read ,sir ,george ,lewis's book1 ! po9ts :i* ,i h criticiz$ /ruck me z n to be wond]$ at1 b ,i did n rememb] :y at ! "t4 ,a ,*ancellor ( ! ,ex*equ] & a writ] on anci5t a/ronomy are birds ( su* diff]5t trees t ! second did n recall ! fir/4 ,9 #ahee ,i 0 "o ( a deputation ( ab\t tw5ty p]sons :o wait$ on ,sir ,g4 ,lewis1 z ,*ancellor ( ! ,ex*equ]1 on ! subject ( a decimal co9age4 ,! deputation 0 "o ( mu* =ce3 ,mr4 ,airy1 ) myself & o!rs1 repres5t$ ma!matics2 ,william ,br[n1#big ^: deal+s ) ! ,unit$ ,/ates 7 reckon$ by ye>ly millions1 c\nt$ duodecimally 9 ,engl& & decimally 9 ,am]ica1 0 ! be/1 b n ! only1 repres5tative ( comm]ce4 ,!re 7 bullioni/s1 acc\ntants1 retail]s1 etc4 ,sir ,g4 ,l4 walk$ into ! room1 took 8 seat1 & )\t wait+ "o mom5t1 began to read ! deputation a sm>t lecture on ! evils ( a decimal co9age2 x w\ld require alt]ation ( all ! tables1 x w\ld imp$e calculation1 etc4 etc4 ,( ^? argum5ts aga9/ x :i* weigh$ ) _m ( bett] k ?an 81 he obvi\sly knew no?+4 ,! memb]s ( ! deputation began to make _! /atem5ts1 & met ) curi\s d5ials4 ,he int]rupt$ me ) ,surely !re is no d\bt t ! calculations ( our books ( ari?metic are easi] #afi ?an ^? 9 ! ,fr5* books4 ,he 0 n aw>e t ! univ]sally admitt$ sup]iority ( decimal calculation made _m ( ^? :o pref] our sy/em = ! m>ket & ! c\nt] ca/ a long+ & l+]+ look t[>ds decimals4 ,my answ] & ! smiles :i* he saw ar\nd1 made him give a que] puzzl$ look1 :i* seem$ to say1 ,i may be out ( my dep? "h6 ,8 mann] *ang$1 & he li/5$4 ,i saw bo? ! slap-da% mode 9 :i* he dealt ) subjects on :i* he _h n ?\ght1 & ! temp]am5t :i* admitt$ suspicion :5 ! means ( k came 9 8 way4 ,hav+ se5 8 two phases1 ,i wond] nei!r at 8 m ?an usual exhibition ( %all[ness :5 %all[1 nor at ! int5sity ( ! contra/ :5 he _h great] dep?4 ,,decimal ,,co9age4 ,among ! p>adox]s are ! political p>adox]s :o c>e n h[ f> !y g 9 debate1 _! only object be+ to c>ry ! ,h\se ) !m = ! curr5t ev5+4 ,:at ,i h said ( editors ,i repeat ( !m4 ,! pres]vation ( a v m>k$ in/ance1 ! association ( political recklessness ) cyclometrical & ,apocalyptic absurdity1 may h a t5d5cy to w>n1 n inde$ any h>d5$ public-man & s9n]1 b "s "y m9ds :i* h ye>n+s t[>ds politics1 & are 9 =mation ( habits4 ,9 ! debate on decimal co9age ( ,july #ab1 #ahee1 ,mr4 ,l[e1#bih !n memb] = ,kidd]m9/]1 an effective speak] & a sm>t man1 exhibit$ himself 9 a spee* on :i* ,i wrote a comm5t = ! ,decimal ,association4 ,i h seldom se5 a m wret*$ attempt to di/ort ! po9ts ( a public "q ?an ! :ole ( ?is spee*4 ,look+ at ! intellig5ce %[n by ! speak] on o!r occasions1 #agj x is cle> t if *>ity1 in/ead ( believ+ all ?+s1 believ$ only all ?+s b "o1 he might tremble = 8 political "*2 = ! hone/y ( 8 int5tion on ?is occasion might be ! incr$ible exception4 ,i give a few p>agraphs ) comm5ts3 ,9 comm5t+ on ! humor\s1 b /ill argum5tative spee* ( ,mr4 ,l[e1 ! memb] = ,kidd]m9/]1 we may obs]ve1 9 g5]al1 t x consi/s ( po9ts :i* h be5 sev]al times set =?1 & sev]al times answ]$4 ,mr4 ,l[e has se5 ^! answ]s1 b does n allude to !m1 f> less attempt to meet !m4 ,!re are1 no d\bt1 individuals1 :o %[ 9 _! public speak+ ! outw>d & visible signs ( a great] degree ( acut5ess ?an !y c summon to guide _! private ?9k+4 ,if ,mr4 ,l[e be n "o ( ^!1 if ! p[] ( 8 m9d 9 ! closet be at all comp>able to ! p[] ( 8 tongue 9 ! ,h\se1 x may be suspect$ t 8 res]ve ) respect to :at has be5 put =w>d by ! v p>ties aga9/ :om he 0 cont5d+1 arises f "o or bo? ( two ?+s--a high op9ion ( ! argum5ts :i* he ignor$--a l[ op9ion ( ! g5]ality ( ! p]sons :om he address$4 ,bo?1 ,i d\bt n4 ,did !y calculate 9 flor9s ,9 ! "n ( common s5se1 8 h[ c x be object$ to a sy/em t p d n use x be=e x is introduc$8 ,let ! decimal sy/em be complet$1 & calculation %all be made 9 flor9s2 t is1 flor9s %all take _! prop] place4 ,if flor9s 7 introduc$ n[1 !re mu/ be a column = ! odd %ill+4 ,he 0 glad t "s hon4 ,if ! hon4 g5tleman make g5tleman _h d]iv$ b5efit ?is ass]tion ( himself1 x f ! issue ( flor9s4 ,8 is n = u to ga9say x4 only exp]i5ce ( _! ,x only proves t he is "o conv5i5ce 01 t :5 he ( t class ( #aga m5 :o ought to h receiv$ are describ$ 9 ! old song1 half-a-cr[n1 he _h g5]ally ( :i* "o c\plet runs receiv$ a flor91 & :5 he ?us3 ought to h paid a flor91 he _h g5]ally paid ,i sold my c[ to buy me a half-a-cr[n4 7,he>1 he>1 calf2 & laught]47 ,i nev] make a b>ga9 b ,i lose half1 ,) a etc4 etc4 etc4 ,b he _c mean t ,engli%m5 9 g5]al are s easily manag$4 ,& z to ,jona?an1 :o is b ,john l5g!n$ out a little1 he w\ld see creation :ittl$ into *ips be=e he w\ld ev5 split :at may h5ce=? be call$ ! ,kidd]m9/] diff]5ce4 ,! ,h\se1 n unmov$--= x laugh$--) sly humor decid$ t ! introduction ( ! flor9 _h be5 em95tly successful & satisfactory4 ,! tru? is t ,mr4 ,l[e "h attacks no?+ except ! coexi/5ce ( ! flor9 & half-cr[n4 ,we are endeavor+ to aboli% ! half-cr[n4 ,let ,mr4 ,l[e jo9 u2 & he w1 if we succe$1 be reliev$ f ! pressure on 8 pocket :i* mu/ arise f hav+ ! turn ( ! m>ket always aga9/ him4 ,f a flor9 !y get to #b ,note ! sophism ( express+ #b-e?s ( a p5ny1 b :o our co9 9 t]ms ( ! ev] b\ght any?+1 :o ev] p5ny1 :i* we ab&on1 reckon$ or wi%$ to reckon in/ead ( ! flor91 :i* 9 su* a co9 z t8 we reta94 ,rememb] t ?is 7,he>1 he>47 #b #b-e?s is ! hundr$? "p ( ! p\nd1 :i* is call$1 z yet1 a c5t4 ,nobody buys any?+ at a c5t1 because ! c5t is n yet introduc$4 ,nobody reckons 9 c5ts = ! same reason4 ,ev]ybody wi%es to reckon 9 c5ts1 :o wi%es to comb9e ! advantage ( decimal reckon+ ) ! pres]vation ( ! p\nd z #agb ! highe/ unit ( acc\nt2 among/ o!rs1 a majority ( ! ,h\se ( ,commons1 ! ,bank ( ,engl&1 ! majority ( ,london bank]s1 ! ,*amb]s ( ,comm]ce 9 v>i\s places1 etc4 etc4 etc4 ,su* a co9 c\ld nev] come ,does #b-a_/b;d4 nev] pass f into g5]al circulation h& to h&8 ,& is #b-a_/b;d4 because x repres5ts no?+ s precisely ! modulus ( :i* corresponds ) any ( popul> wants1 t an ! wants ( ! p4 alt]ation ( #d p] c5t4 w\ld make x useless8 ,( all ! values :i* #b-a_/b;d4 measures1 f ?ree p\nds ( potatoes d[n to c]ta9 argum5ts us$ 9 ! ,h\se ( ,commons1 !re is n "o = :i* a c5t w\ld n d j z well4 ,mr4 ,l[e has fall5 into ! misconception ( ! p]son :o admir$ ! disp5sation ( ,provid5ce by :i* l>ge riv]s are made to run ?r\gh cities s great & t[ns s _m4 ,if ! c5t 7 to be introduc$ to-morr[1 /raightway ! buns & cakes1 ! soda-wat] bottles1 ! %ort omnibus f>es1 ! bun*es ( radi%es1 etc4 etc4 etc41 w\ld adapt !mselves to ! co94 ,if ! propos$ sy/em 7 ,! confusion ( ideas "h adopt$1 !y w\ld all be exhibit$ is mo/ in/ructive4 compell$ to live 9 decimals ,! speak] is "u ! = ev]2 if a man d9$ at a impression t we are public h\se he w\ld h to introduc+ fractions3 ! pay = 8 d9n] 9 decimal tru? is1 t we only want to fractions4 7,he>1 he>47 ,he ab&on ! m difficult object$ to t1 = he fractions :i* we h got1 ?\ght t a man ought to be & to introduce easi] able to pay = 8 d9n] 9 fractions4 ,does he d5y ?is8 integ]s4 7,he>1 he>1 & a ,let u trace 8 d5ial to its laugh47 legitimate consequ5ces4 ,a man ought to pay = 8 d9n] 9 integ]s4 #agc ,n[1 if ,mr4 ,l[e insi/s on x t our integ] is ! p\nd1 he is b\nd to admit t ! pres5t integ] is ! p\nd1 ( :i* a %ill+1 etc41 are fractions4 ,! next "t he has a *op & a p9t ( /\t 9 ! city1 ! wait] %\ld say--,a p\nd1 sir1 to y1 & %\ld add1 ,please to rememb] ! wait] 9 integ]s4 ,mr4 ,l[e fancies t :5 he pays "o & sixp5ce1 he pays 9 integ]s1 & s he does1 if 8 integ] be a p5ny or a sixp5ce4 ,let him br+ 8 m9d to contemplate a mil z ! integ]1 ! l[e/ integ]1 & ! sev5 c5ts five mils :i* he w\ld pay "u ! new sy/em w\ld be paym5t 9 integ]s also4 ,b1 z x happ5s ) "s o!rs1 he looks up ! pres5t sy/em1 ) ,cock]1#bii & ,walk+ame1#cjj & always looks d[n ! propos$ sy/em4 ,! ^w decimal is ob/9ately associat$ ) fractions1 = :i* !re is no ne$4 ,h5ce x becomes s mu* ( a bugbe>1 t1 to p>ody ! l9es ( ,pope1 :i* probably sugge/$ "o ( ,mr4 ,l[e's phrases-- ,d9n] he f9ds too pa9ful an endeavor1 ,condemn$ to pay 9 decimals = ev]4 ,! pres5t sy/em1 h[ev]1 ,a pleasant sum ev5 = an _h n yet be5 *ang$ into accompli%$ ma!matician4 decimal sy/em4 ,t *ange ,:at does divid$ by ! might appe> v easy to decimal ( a p\nd mean8 accompli%$ ma!maticians ,p]haps x means r$uc$ to & m5 ( sci5ce1 b x 0 ! decimal ( a p\nd6 ,mr4 "o :i* x w\ld be v ,l[e supposes1 z _m o!rs difficult to c>ry out4 7,he>1 d1 t1 aft] ! *ange1 he>74 ,:at w\ld h to be all calculations w be done8 ,e sum w\ld h to propos$ 9 old money1 & be r$uc$ into a vulg> !n conv]t$ into new4 ,he fraction ( a p\nd1 & !n _c hit ! #agd idea t divid$ by ! decimal ( a ! new co9s w take ! p\nd--a pleasant sum = an place ( ! old4 ,?is lack ( old applewoman to "w out6 appreh5sion w pres5tly 7,he>1 he>1 & laught]47 appe> fur!r4 ,x w\ld n be an agreeable ,let ! memb]s be assur$ task1 ev5 = "s memb]s ( t n9e half-p5ce w be1 t ,h\se1 to r$uce #d-a_/b;d41 = e practical purpose1 or n9e half-p5ce1 to mils4 #ah mils4 ,b n[ to ! fact 7,he>1 he>47 ass]t$4 ,davies ,gilb]t#cja us$ to ma9ta9 t dur+ ! long p]iod he sat 9 ! ,h\se1 he nev] knew m ?an ?ree m5 9 x1 at "o "t1 :o _h a tol]able notion ( fractions4 ,i he>d him give ! names ( ?ree at ! "t :5 he spoke3 !y 7 ,w>burton1#cjb ,pollock1#cjc & ,hume4#cjd ,he himself 0 !n out ( ,p>liam5t4 ,joseph ,hume affirm$ t he _h nev] met ) m ?an t5 memb]s :o 7 ari?meticians4 ,b bo? ^! g5tlem5 _h a high /&>d4 ,mr4 ,l[e has giv5 a mu* m damag+ op9ion4 ,he evid5tly means t ! g5]al run ( memb]s c\ld n d 8 "q4 ,x is done z foll[s3 ,s9ce f>?+s ga9 on mils1 at ! rate ( a :ole mil 9 #bd f>?+s 7#bd f>?+s be+ #be mils71 x is cle> t #ah f>?+s be+ ?ree-qu>t]s ( #bd f>?+s1 w ga9 ?ree-qu>t]s ( a mil2 t is1 #ah f>?+s are eighte5 #age mils & ?ree-qu>t]s ( a mil4 ,any numb] ( f>?+s is z _m mils & z _m tw5ty-f\r?s ( a mil4 ,to a c]ta9 ext5t1 we feel able to prote/ aga9/ ! mann] 9 :i* ,kidd]m9/] has treat$ ! o!r con/itu5cies4 ,we d n hold x impossible to give ! ,memb]s ( ! ,h\se 9 g5]al a suffici5t k ( ! mean+ & consequ5ces ( ! decimal succession ( units1 t5s1 hundr$s1 ?\s&s1 etc42 & we believe t !re are 9 ! ,h\se itself compet5t m51 9 numb] en\gh to tea* all ! re/4 ,all t is want$ is ! p[] ( />t+ f ! kn[n to arrive at ! unkn[n4 ,n[ !re is "o k9d ( decimals ) :i* e memb] is acqua9t$--! ,*ilt]n ,hundr$s4 ,if public op9ion w\ld enable ! compet5t m9ority to />t f ?is 9 _! tea*+1 n z a basis1 b z an alt]native1 9 ?ree weeks ! fundam5tals w\ld be acquir$1 & memb]s 9 g5]al w\ld be z fit to turn #d-a_/b;d4 into mils1 z any boys on ! l[] =ms ( a comm]cial s*ool4 ,= a long p]iod ( ye>s1 allusion to ! g5]al ignorance ( ari?metic1 has be5 a /&+ mode ( argum5t1 & has always be5 well receiv$3 :5ev] "o memb] describes o!rs z kn[no?+s1 ^? o!rs cry ,he> to ! c\ntry 9 a transport ( delight4 ,9 ! mean:ile ! c\ntry is gradually arriv+ at ! conclusion t a true joke is no joke4 ,! ma9 objection 01 if ,f9e words1 wrongly us$4 ,! !y w5t bel[ #f;d41 t ! new co9s are comm5surable new scale ( co9s w\ld n )1 & 9 a f9ite ratio be comm5surate 9 any f9ite to1 ! old ones4 ,! f>?+ ratio ) any?+ 9 ?is is to ! mil z #be to #bd4 ,! new curr5cy ( mils4 speak] has some?+ "h 9 ! bud1 :i* we %all pres5tly meet ) 9 ! fl[]2 & fallacies are m easily nipp$ 9 fl[] ?an 9 bud4 #agf ,no less ?an five ( our ,?is dreadful *ange ( value pres5t co9s mu/ be call$ consi/s 9 sixp5ce f>?+ 91 or else--:i* w\ld be go+ to ! half-%ill+ worse--new values mu/ be in/ead ( sixp5ce4 ,:e!r giv5 to !m4 ! new f>?+s be call$ mils or n is ( no consequ5ce4 ,if a poor man put a p5ny 9 ,mr4 ,l[e1 :o _c pass a 8 pocket1 x w\ld come out half-cr[n = m ?an a a co9 ( diff]5t value1 flor91 or get 9 a flor9 at :i* he w\ld n und]/&4 less ?an half-a-cr[n1 has ,suppose he ow$ ano!r man a su* a high fai? 9 ! p5ny1 h[ 0 he to pay him 8 /]n] /uff ( 8 fell[ ,0 he to pay him 9 mils8 c\ntrym51 t he believes ,f\r mils w\ld be too little1 any two ( !m w\ld g to & five mils w\ld be too fi/y cuffs = ! #be? "p mu*4 ,! hon4 g5tlem5 said ( a f>?+4 ,he reasons !re w\ld be only a mil ?us3 ,he has (t5 he>d 9 betwe5 !m4 ,t 0 exactly ! /reets1 ,i'd fight y x4 ,he believ$ !re w\ld be = ! fiftie? "p ( a a 'mill' betwe5 !m4 7,mu* f>d53 & hav+ 7t is1 laught]47 = a ,memb]7 a notion bo? ( fractions & logic1 he inf]s t ^? :o w\ld fight = ! #ej? ( a f>?+ w\ld1 a =tiori1 fight = a #be?4 ,8 mi/ake arises f 8 n kn[+ t :5 a p]son (f]s to fight ano!r = #a_/bjj;d41 he really means to fight = love2 & t ! /ake is m]ely a matt] ( =m1 a feign$ issue1 a pro =ma report ( progress4 ,d ! ,memb]s ( ! ,h\se ?9k !y h all ! =ms to !mselves8 ,:at w\ld be ! pres5t ,we %\ld h>dly believe all expression = f\r-p5ce8 ?is to be utt]$ 9 e>ne/1 ,:y1 #j4aff 7a laugh72 = if we _h n kn[n #agg t ?reep5ce8 4#jabe2 = a sev]al p]sons :o h n p5ny8 4#jjdaff1 & s on ad ,mr4 ,l[e's humor1 nev]!less inf9itum 7a laugh72 = a h 8 impressions on ?is half-p5ny8 4#jjbjhc ad po9t4 ,x mu/ !re=e be inf9itum4 7,a laugh74 ,:at answ]$2 b h[ is ?is to w\ld be ! pres5t be done s]i\sly8 expression = a f>?+8 ,:y1 4#jjajdaf ad inf9itum4 ,dialogue betwe5 a memb] ( 7,a laugh74 ,& ?is 0 ! ,p>liam5t & an orange-boy1 sy/em :i* 0 to cause su* ?ree days aft] ! a sav+ 9 figures1 & ^! introduction ( ! complete 7 ! quantities into :i* decimal sy/em4 ,! memb]1 ! poor w\ld h to r$uce go+ d[n to ! ,h\se1 wants ! curr5t co9 ( ! realm4 oranges to su/a9 8 voice 7,*e]s74 ,) e respect 9 a two h\rs' spee* on = decimal fractions1 ( mov+ t #ajjjjjl4 be plac$ :i* he boa/$ no pr(\nd at ! disposal ( ,h] k1 he d\bt$ :e!r ,maje/y1 to supply ! poor ! poor 7 equal to m5tal ) ready-reckon]s4 ari?metic ( ?is k9d1 7he>1 he>7 & he hop$ ! ,boy4 ,f9e oranges6 two a adoption ( ! sy/em w\ld p5ny6 two a p5ny6 #agh be def]r$ until !re 7 "s pro( t !y w\ld be ,memb]4 ,"h boy1 two6 ,n[1 able to und]/& x2 =1 h[ am ,i to pay y8 aft] all1 ?is 0 ! "q ( ! poor1 & ! ,boy4 ,give y *ange1 y\r :ole weight ( ! *ange honor4 w\ld fall ^u !m4 ,let ! ri* by all means h ,memb]4 ,ah6 b h[8 ,:]e's p]mission to p]plex y\r ready-reckon]8 !mselves by any division ( a p\nd !y pleas$2 b d ,boy4 ,i sells a bett] sort n let !m1 by any nor !m4 ,m9e's real ,*eyny4 exp]im5t l ?is1 impose difficulties ^u ! poor & ,memb]4 ,b y see a compel m5 to c>ry f>?+ is n[ 4#jjadafffff ready-reckon]s 9 _! ad inf9itum1 & if we pocket to give !m all ^! multiply ?is by #d---- fractional quantities4 7,he>1 he>47 ,boy4 ,hold h>d1 ,guv'n]2 ,i sees :at y're art]4 ,n[ :at'll y /& if ,i puts y up to x8 :i* ,bill ,smi? he put me up 9 two m9utes1 cause he goes to ! ,ragg$ ,s*ool4 ,memb]4 ,y don't mean t y d )\t a book6 ,boy4 ,book be bl[$4 ,come n[1 old un1 "h's summut = bo? on u4 ,i got a flor91 y gives me a half-a-cr[n = x1 & ,i l>ns y ! new money1 gives y y\r oranges1 & calls y a brick into ! b>ga94 ,memb] 7to himself74 ,nev] _h su* a *ance ( gett+ (f half-a-cr[n = value s9ce t ---- fell[ ,b[r+ c>ri$ 8 cro*et4 7,al\d47 ,well1 boy1 x's a b>ga94 ,n[6 ,boy4 ,:y1 look 'e "h1 my trump1 its a f>d5 m to ! tizzy--t's :at x is4 ,memb]4 ,:at's t8 ,boy4 ,:y1 y kn[s a sixp5ce :5 y sees x4 7,aside74 ,ble/ if ,i ?9k he does6 ,well1 its six br[ns & a f>d5 n[4 ,a lady buys two oranges1 & =ks #agi out a sixp5ce2 well 9 coorse1 ,i h&s ov] fipp5ce f>d5 a/ead ( fipp5ce4 ,i always gives a f>d5 m *ange1 & takes accord+4 ,memb] 79 utt] surprise1 lets 8 oranges tumble into ! gutt]74 ,nev] m9d6 ,!y won't be want$ n[4 7,walks (f "o way4 ,boy makes a pass ( naso-digital mesm]ism1 & walks (f ! o!r way74 ,to ! poor1 :o keep no books1 ! :ole secret is ,sixp5ce f>?+ to ! half %ill+1 twelve p5ce halfp5ny to ! %ill+4 ,! new twop5ce halfp5ny1 or c5t1 w be at once five to ! %ill+4 ,9 conclusion1 we rem>k t ?ree v common misconceptions run ?r\gh ! hon4 ,memb]'s argum5t2 &1 comb9$ 9 diff]5t proportions1 give v>iety to 8 patt]ns4 ,fir/1 he w h x t we design to br+ ! un$ucat$ into contact ) decimal fractions4 ,if x be s1 x w only be z ,m4 ,j\rda9 0 br\ght into contact ) prose4 ,9 fact1 ,quoi6 qu& je dis1 ,nicole1 apportez-moi mes pant\fles1 c'e/ de la prose8#cje may be r5d]$3 ,:at6 d y mean t t5 to ! flor9 is a c5t a piece mu/ be call$ decimal reckon+8 ,if we _h to com=t a poor man1 horror-/ruck by ! ?reat ( decimals1 we %\ld tell him :at mann] ( fractions _h be5 inflict$ ^u him hi!rto2 no?+ less awful ?an qu>to-duodecimo-vicesimals1 we %\ld assure him4 ,secondly1 he assumes t ! p5ny1 su* z x n[ is1 w rema91 z a co9 ( e/imation1 aft] x has ceas$ to be a co9 ( ex*ange2 & t ! mass ( ! p w cont9ue to ?9k ( prices 9 old p5ce1 & to calculate !m 9 new ones1 or else 9 new mils4 ,no answ] is requir$ to ?is1 beyond ! m]e /atem5t ( ! nature ( ! assumption & d5ial4 #ahj ,?irdly1 he attributes to ! un$ucat$ community a want ( p]ception & ( op]ative p[] :i* really does n belong to !m4 ,! evid5ce (f]$ to ! ,committee ( ! ,h\se %[s t no fe> is ent]ta9$ on ?is po9t by ^? :o come mo/ 9 contact ) f>?+ pur*as]s4 ,& ?is w\ld seem to be a rule1--t is1 fe> ( ! intellig5ce ( ! l[] ord]s 9 ! m9ds ( ^? :o are n 9 daily communication ) !m1 no fe> at all 9 ! m9ds ( ^? :o are4 ,a rem>kable in/ance ( ?is di/9ction happ5$ five-&-tw5ty ye>s ago4 ,! ,admiralty reque/$ ! ,a/ronomical ,society to report on ! alt]ations :i* %\ld be made 9 ! ,nautical ,almanac1 ! seaman's guide-book ov] ! ocean4 ,! greate/ alt]ation propos$ 0 ! description ( cele/ial ph5om5a 9 mean 7or clock "t71 in/ead ( app>5t 7or sundial7 "t1 till !n always employ$4 ,?is *ange w\ld require t 9 a great _m op]ations ! seaman %\ld let alone :at he =m]ly alt]$ by addition or subtraction1 & alt] by addition or subtraction :at he =m]ly let alone2 provid$ always t :at he =m]ly alt]$ by addition he %\ld1 :5 he alt]$ at all1 alt] by subtraction1 & vice v]sa4 ,?is 0 a tol]ably difficult *ange = un$ucat$ skipp]s1 work+ by rules !y _h only le>n$ by rote4 ,! ,a/ronomical ,society appo9t$ a ,committee ( =ty1 ( :om n9e 7 naval (fic]s or m]*ant seam5 ,i 0 on ?is ,committee4 ,"s m5 ( sci5ce 7 mu* afraid ( ! *ange4 ,!y c\ld n tru/ an ignorant skipp] or mate to make ^? alt]ations 9 _! r\t9e1 on ! correctness ( :i* ! %ip might dep5d4 ,_h ! ,committee consi/$ ( m5 ( sci5ce only1 ! *ange might nev] h be5 v5tur$ on4 ,b ! naval m5 laugh$1 & said !re 0 no?+ to fe>2 & on _! au?ority ! alt]ation 0 made4 ,! up%ot 01 t1 aft] ! new almanacs appe>$1 n a ^w ( compla9t 0 ev] he>d on ! matt]4 ,_h ! ,h\se ( ,commons _h to #aha decide ?is "q1 ) ,mr4 ,l[e to quote ! description giv5 by ,basil ,hall#cjf 7:o1 by ! way1 0 "o ( ! ,committee7 ( an obs]vation on :i* ! safety ( ! %ip dep5d$1 work$ out by ! light ( a lant]n 9 a gale ( w9d (f a lee %ore1 ?is simple & useful *ange might at ?is mom5t h be5 9 ! h&s ( its t5? ,gov]nm5t ,commission4 ,aug4 #ad1 #ahff4 ,! ,committee 0 appo9t$ 9 ! spr+ ( #ahcj3 x consi/$ ( =ty memb]s4 ,dea?1 ( c\rse1 has be5 busy2 !re are n[ left ,"l ,%aftesbury1#cjg ,mr4 ,babbage1#cjh ,sir ,john ,h]s*el1#cji ,sir ,?omas ,macle>#caj 7,a/ronom] ,royal at ! ,cape ( ,good ,hope71 ,dr4 ,rob9son#caa 7( ,armagh71 ,sir ,james ,s\?1#cab ,"l ,wrottesley1#cac & myself4 #ahb ,,! ,,tonal ,,sy/em4 ,project ( a new sy/em ( ari?metic1 weight1 measure1 & co9s1 propos$ to be call$ ! tonal sy/em1 ) sixte5 to ! base4 ,by ,j4 ,w4 ,my/rom4#cad ,philadelphia1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,t is to say1 sixte5 is to take ! place ( t51 & to be writt5 #aj4 ,! :ole language is to be *ang$2 e man ( u is to be sixte5-/r+$ ,jack & e woman sixte5-/r+$ ,jill4 ,our old "o1 two1 ?ree1 up to sixte51 are to be 7,noll go+ = no?+1 :i* w please ^? :o dislike ! memory ( ,old ,noll7 replac$ by ,an1 ,de1 ,ti1 ,g1 ,su1 ,by1 ,ra1 ,me1 ,ni1 ,ko1 ,hu1 ,vy1 ,la1 ,po1 ,fy1 ,ton2 & !n ,ton-an1 ,ton-de1 etc4 = #ag1 #ah1 etc4 ,! numb] :i* 9 ! sy/em has ! symbol #bh7ac7e7aa7g7ad7j7ae7 7us+ our pres5t comp\nds in/ead ( new types7 is to be pron\nc$ ,detam-memill-lasan-suton-hubong-ramill- posanfy4 ,! ye> is to h sixte5 mon?s1 & "h !y are3 ,anu>y1 ,debrian1 ,tim&]1 ,go/us1 ,suv5>y1 ,bylian1 ,ratamb]1 ,mesudius1 ,nicto>y1 ,kolumbian1 ,husamb]1 ,vyctorius1 ,lambo>y1 ,polian1 ,fyl&]1 ,tonborius4 ,surely ,an-mon?1 ,de-mon?1 etc4 w\ld d z well4 ,probably ! wants ( poetry 7 consid]$4 ,b :at are we to d ) our old poets8 ,= example-- ,x 0 a night ( lovely ,june1 ,high rose 9 cl\dless blue ! moon4 ,let u translate-- ,x 0 a night ( lovely ,nicto>y1 ,high rose 9 cl\dless blue ! 7:at1 9 ! "n ( all t is absurd874 ,& aga91 ,fyl&] ?r[n into our ,decemb]6 ,:at is #ahc to become ( ^? l9es ( ,pra$1 :i* ,i rememb] com+ out :5 ,i 0 at ,cambridge1-- ,oh6 n['s ! "t ( all ! ye> = fl[]s & fun1 ! ,maydays2 ,to trim y\r :isk]s1 curl y\r hair1 & s9ivate ! ladies4 ,if ,i 7 ask$ :i* ,i pref]r$1 ?is sy/em or t ( ,b>on ,f]r>i#cae already m5tion$1 proce$+ by twelves1 ,i %\ld reply1 ) ,c&ide1 :5 he _h ! option giv5 ( runn+ ! gauntlet or be+ %ot3 ,les volontes sont libres1 et je ne veux ni l'un ni l'autre4#caf ,we c imag9e a speculator provid+ su* a sy/em = ,utopia z x w\ld be 9 ! m9d ( a ,laputan3 b to expla9 h[ an eng9e] :o has survey$ mank9d f ,philadelphia to ,ro/( on ! ,don %\ld = a mom5t ent]ta9 ! idea ( su* a sy/em be+ actually adopt$1 w\ld beat a jury ( sol>-sy/em-mak]s1 ?\gh !y 7 %ut up f ! beg9n+ ( ,anu>y to ! end ( ,tonborius4 ,:5 ,i see su* a s*eme z ?is imag9$ to be practicable1 ,i admire ! wisdom ( ,provid5ce 9 provid+ ! quadrature ( ! circle1 etc41 to op5 a h>mless sph]e ( action to ! possessors ( ! k9d ( +5uity :i* x displays4 ,^? :o cultivate ma!matics h a "r to speak /rongly on su* ef=ts ( ari?metic z ?is3 =1 to my k1 p]sons :o h no k are frequ5tly dispos$ to imag9e t _! mak]s are true bro!rs ( ! craft1 a little m intelligible ?an ! re/4 ,,"s ,,small ,,p>adox]s4 ,vis in]tiae victa1#cag or ,fallacies affect+ sci5ce4 ,by ,james ,r$die4#cah ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 #ahd ,an attack on ! ,newtonian me*anics2 revolution by gravitation demon/rably impossible2 mu* to be said = ! e>? be+ ! immovable c5t]4 ,a good analysis ( cont5ts at ! beg9n+1 a ?+ seldom f\nd4 ,! au?or has foll[$ up 8 attack 9 a pap] submitt$ to ! ,briti% ,association1 b :i* x appe>s ! ,association decl9$ to consid]4 ,x is entitl$-- ,victoria ,toto ,coelo2 or1 ,mod]n ,a/ronomy reca/4 ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,at ! end is a criticism ( ,sir ,g4 ,lewis's ,hi/ory ( ,anci5t ,a/ronomy4 ,on ! def9ition & nature ( ! ,sci5ce ( ,political ,economy4 ,by ,h4 ,dunn+ ,macleod1#cai ,esq4 ,cambridge1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,a pap] read--b1 accord+ to ! report1 n und]/ood--at ! ,briti% ,association4 ,!re is a notion t political economy is entirely ma!matical2 & its negative quantity is /rongly recomm5d$ = /udy3 x conta9s ! :ole ( ! ,funds1 ,cr$it1 #cb p>ts out ( #cc ( ! value ( ,l&4444 ,! ma!matics are describ$ z consi/+ (--fir/1 numb]1 or ,ari?metic2 secondly1 ! !ory ( dep5d5t quantities1 subdivid$ into dep5d5ce by cause & effect1 & dep5d5ce by simultane\s v>iations2 ?irdly1 indep5d5t quantities or unconnect$ ev5ts1 :i* is ! !ory ( probabilities4 ,i am n a%am$1 hav+ ! ,briti% ,association z a co-non-intellig5t1 to say ,i d n und]/& ?is3 !re is a p>adox 9 x1 & ! au?or %\ld give fur!r explanation1 especially ( 8 negative quantity4 ,mr4 ,macleod has ga9$ #ahe praise f great names = 8 political economy2 b ?is1 ,i suspect1 mu/ h be5 = o!r p>ts ( 8 sy/em4 ,on ! pr9ciples & practice ( j ,intonation1 ) a view to ! abolition ( temp]am5t4444 ,by ,g5]al ,p]ronet ,?ompson4#cbj ,six? ,edition4 ,london1 #ahfb1 #hvo4 ,"h is ,g5]al ,?ompson aga91 ) ano!r p>adox3 b always ma/] ( ! subject1 always well up 9 :at 8 pr$ecessors h done1 & always aim+ at a useful end4 ,he desires to aboli% temp]am5t by additional keys1 & has con/ruct$ an enh>monic organ ) =ty s\nds 9 ! octave4 ,if ?is c be introduc$1 ,i1 = "o1 %all delight to he> x3 b !re are v great difficulties 9 ! way1 great] ?an /ood ev5 9 ! way ( ! repeal ( ! bread-tax4 ,9 a pap] on ! beats ( organ-pipes & on temp]am5t publi%$ "s ye>s ago1 ,i said t equal temp]am5t appe>$ to me insipid1 & n s agreeable z ! effect ( ! in/rum5t :5 9 progress t[>ds be+ :at is call$ out ( tune1 be=e x becomes (f5sively wrong4 ,!re is ?r\gh\t t p]iod unequal temp]am5t1 det]m9$ by accid5t4 ,g5]al ,?ompson1 tak+ me "o way1 says ,i h laun*$ a decl>ation :i* is likely to make an epo* 9 musical practice2 a public musical critic1 tak+ me ano!r way1 quizzes me = pref]r+ music out ( tune4 ,i d n ?9k ,i des]ve ei!r "o rem>k or ! o!r4 ,my oppon5t critic1 ,i suspect1 takes equally temp]$ & 9 tune to be phrases ( "o mean+4 ,b by equal temp]am5t is meant equal di/ribution among all ! keys ( ! error :i* an in/rum5t mu/ h1 :i*1 ) twelve s\nds only 9 ! octave1 pr(esses to be fit = all ! keys4 ,i am rem9d$ ( ! equal temp]am5t :i* 0 once appli$ to ! po/m5's jackets4 ,! coats 7 all made = ! av]age man3 ! #ahf consequ5ce 0 t all ! tall m5 _h _! tails too %ort2 all ! %ort m5 _h !m too long4 ,"s "o innoc5tly ask$ :y ! tall m5 did n *ange coats ) ! %ort ones4 ,a diagram illu/rat+ a discov]y 9 ! relation ( circles to "r-l9$ geometrical figures4 ,london1 #ahfc1 #abmo4 ,! circle is divid$ into equal sectors1 :i* are jo9$ head & tail3 b a prop]ty is suppos$ :i* is n true4 ,an attempt to assign ! squ>e roots ( negative p[]s2 or :at is sqrt -#a8 ,by ,f4,h4 ,la+4#cba ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,if ,i und]/& ! au?or1 -a & a are ! squ>e roots ( -a#b1 z prov$ by multiply+ !m toge!r4 ,! au?or seems q unaw>e ( :at has be5 done 9 ! la/ fifty ye>s4 ,,byrne',s ,,dual ,,ari?metic4 ,dual ,ari?metic4 ,a new art4 ,by ,oliv] ,byrne4#cbb ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,! plan is to ?r[ numb]s into ! =m a7#a4a7;b 7#a4ja7;c 7#a4jja7;d444 & to op]ate ) ?is =m4 ,?is is an +5i\s & elaborate speculation2 & ,i h no d\bt ! au?or has practis$ 8 me?od until he c\ld surprise any "o else by 8 use ( x4 ,b ,i d\bt if he w p]suade o!rs to use x4 ,z ask$ ( ,wilk9s's univ]sal language1 ,:]e is ! second man to come f8 ,an effective pr$ecessor 9 ! same l9e ( inv5tion #ahg 0 ! late ,mr4 ,?omas ,w$dle1#cbc 9 8 ,new1 simple1 & g5]al me?od ( solv+ num]ic equations ( all ord]s1 #dto1 #ahdb4 ,! ,royal ,society1 to :i* ?is pap] 0 (f]$1 decl9$ to pr9t x3 !y ought to h pr9t$ an organiz$ me?od1 :i*1 )\t subsidi>y tables1 %[$ !m1 9 six qu>to pages1 ! solution 7x#h4cfgigedca7 ( ! equation #acgi4ffd x#fbb #bfhfjcd x #ajdcb x#aeb - #agbijbbd x #ajeah x#fj #bebdaef x #ajegd #j4 ,! me?od proce$s by successive factors ( ! =m1 a be+ ! fir/ approximation1 a x #a4;b x #a4j;c x #a4jj;d4444 ,9 my copy ,i f9d a few corrections made by me at ! "t 9 ,mr4 ,w$dle's ann\ncem5t4 ,x 0 read be=e t le>n$ body ! ,r4 ,s4 & !y 7 pleas$ b to transmit _! ?anks to ! au?or4 ,! endisc\ragem5t :i* he receiv$ induces obliges him to lay ! result ( 8 enquiries 9 ?is important bran* ( ma!matics be=e ! public 1 at 8 own exp5se2 he be+ an u%] 9 a s*ool at ,newca/le4 ,:i* is mo/ satirical1 ,mr4 ,w$dle or myself8 ,! ,society1 9 ! acc\nt :i* x gave ( ?is pap]1 describ$ x z a new & rem>kably simple me?od possess+ sev]al important advantages4 ,mr4 ,ru!r=d's#cbd ext5d$ value ( pi 0 read at ! v next meet+1 & 0 pr9t$ 9 ! ,transactions2 & v prop]ly3 ,mr4 ,w$dle's pap] 0 exclud$1 & v v improp]ly4 ,,horn]',s ,,me?od4 ,i ?9k x may be admit$ t ! indisposition to look at & enc\rage improvem5ts ( calculation :i* once #ahh m>k$ ! ,royal ,society is no long] 9 exi/5ce4 ,b n )\t sev]e lessons4 ,!y _h ! luck to accept ,horn]'s#cbe n[ celebrat$ pap]1 conta9+ ! me?od :i* is f> on ! way to become univ]sal3 b !y refus$ ! pap] 9 :i* ,horn] develop$ 8 views ( ?is & o!r subjects3 x 0 pr9t$ by ,t4 ,s4 ,davies#cbf aft] ,horn]'s dea?4 ,i make myself responsible = ! /atem5t t ! ,society c\ld n reject ?is pap]1 yet felt unwill+ to pr9t x1 & sugge/$ t x %\ld be )drawn2 :i* 0 done4 ,b ! sev]e/ lesson 0 ! loss ( ,b>rett's ,me?od1#cbg n[ ! univ]sal in/rum5t ( ! actu>y 9 8 highe/ calculations4 ,x 0 pres5t$ to ! ,royal ,society1 & refus$ admission into ! ,transactions3 ,francis ,baily#cbh pr9t$ x4 ,! ,society is n[ bett] in=m$3 live & le>n1 mean+ mu/ live1 s bett] le>n1 ought to be ! especial motto ( a corporation1 & is g5]ally act$ on1 m or less4 ,horn]'s me?od beg9s to be introduc$ at ,cambridge3 x 0 publi%$ 9 #ahbj4 ,i rememb] t :5 ,i fir/ w5t to ,cambridge 79 #ahbc7 ,i he>d my tutor say1 9 conv]sation1 !re is no d\bt t ! true me?od ( solv+ equations is ! "o :i* 0 publi%$ a few ye>s ago 9 ! ,philosophical ,transactions4 ,i wond]$ x 0 n taught1 b presum$ t x belong$ to ! high] ma!matics4 ,?is ,horn] himself _h 9 8 head3 & 9 a s5se x is true2 = all l[] bran*es belong to ! high]3 b he w\ld h />$ to h be5 told t he1 ,horn]1 #ahi 0 )\t a ,european pr$ecessor1 & 9 ! di/9ctive "p ( 8 discov]y 0 heir-at-law to ! nameless ,brahm9--,t>t>--,ant5oa*ian--:at y please--:o concoct$ ! extraction ( ! squ>e root4 ,x 0 some:at m ?an tw5ty ye>s aft] ,i _h ?us he>d a ,cambridge tutor %[ s5se ( ! true place ( ,horn]'s me?od1 t a pupil ( m9e :o _h pass$ on to ,cambridge 0 desir$ by 8 college tutor to solve a c]ta9 cubic equation--"o ( an integ] root ( two figures4 ,9 a m9ute ! "w & answ] 7 pres5t$1 by ,horn]'s me?od4 ,h[6 said ! tutor1 ?is c't be1 y "k4 ,!re is ! answ]1 ,sir6 said my pupil1 greatly amus$1 = my pupils le>nt1 n only ,horn]'s me?od1 b ! e/imation x held at ,cambridge4 ,yes6 said ! tutor1 !re is ! answ] c]ta9ly2 b x /&s to reason t a cubic equation _c be solv$ 9 ?is space4 ,he !n sat d[n1 w5t ?r\gh a process ab\t t5 times z long1 & !n said ) triumph3 ,!re6 t is ! way to solve a cubic equation6 ,i ?9k ! tutor 9 ?is case 0 nev] mat*$1 except by ! c\ntry organi/4 ,a ma/] ( ! in/rum5t w5t into ! organ-l(t dur+ s]vice1 & ask$ ! organi/ to let him play ! congregation out2 cons5t 0 giv54 ,! /rang]1 :5 ! "t came1 began a volunt>y :i* made ! p op5 _! e>s1 & wond] :o _h got into ! l(t3 !y kept _! places to enjoy ! treat4 ,:5 ! organi/ saw ?is1 he pu%$ ! int]lop] (f ! /ool1 ) ,y'll nev] play 'em out ?is side ,*ri/mas4 ,he !n began 8 own drone1 & ! congregation began to move quietly away4 ,!re1 said he1 t's ! way to play 'em out6 ,i h n scrupl$ to be> h>d on my own univ]sity1 on ! ,royal ,society1 & on o!r respectable exi/5ces3 be+ v mu* ! fri5d ( all4 ,i w n[ cle> ! ,royal ,society f a v small & obscure sl&]1 simply because ,i "k h[4 ,?is diss]tation began ) #aij ! "w ( ,mr4 ,oliv] ,byrne1 ! dual ari?metician1 etc4 ,?is writ] publi%$1 9 #ahdi1 a me?od ( calculat+ log>i?ms4#cbi ,fir/1 a long li/ ( in/ances 9 :i*1 z he alleges1 =eign discov]]s h be5 pillag$ by ,engli%m51 or turn$ into ,engli%m53 = example1 ,o',neill1#ccj s call$ by ,mr4 ,byrne1 ! rectifi] ( ! semi-cubical p>abola claim$ by ! ,saxons "u ! "n ( ,neal3 ! gr&fa!r ( ?is ma!matician 0 conspicu\s en\gh z ,neal2 he 0 ar*bi%op ( ,york4 ,?is li/1 says ! writ]1 might be cont9u$ )\t end2 b he has m]cy1 & f9i%es ) 8 own case1 z foll[s3--,ab\t tw5ty ye>s ago1 ,i discov]$ ?is me?od ( directly calculat+ log>i?ms4 ,i c\ld g5]ally f9d ! log>i?m ( any numb] 9 a m9ute or two )\t ! use ( books or tables4 ,! importance ( ! discov]y subject$ me to all sorts ( pry+4 ,"s ass]t$ t ,i committ$ a table ( log>i?ms to memory2 o!rs attribut$ x to a peculi> m5tal prop]ty2 & :5 ,societies & individuals fail$ to extract my secret1 !y nev] fail$ to traduce ! inv5tor & ! inv5tion4 ,among ! le>n$ ,societies1 ! ,royal ,society ( ,london play$ a v base "p4 ,:5 ,i h m space & "t at my disposal1 ,i w rev]t to ?is subject aga94 ,su* a trump]y /ory z ?is rema9s unnotic$ at ! "t2 b :5 all are gone1 a /ray copy f a /all falls into h&s :i*1 n kn[+ :at to make ( x1 make hi/ory ( x4 ,x is a v curi\s di/ortion4 ,! read] may take x on my au?ority1 t ! ,royal ,society play$ no "p1 good or bad1 nor _h ! option ( play+ a "p4 #aia ,b ,i myself p>s magna fui3#cca & :5 ! au?or has space & "t at 8 disposal1 he mu/ n take all ( !m2 ,i %all want a little ( bo?4 ,,are ,,atoms ,,worlds8 ,! my/]y ( be+2 or are ultimate atoms inhabit$ worlds8 ,by ,ni*olas ,odg]s4#ccb ,r$ru? & ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,?is book1 z a p>adox1 beats quadrature1 duplication1 trisection1 philosoph]'s /one1 p]petual motion1 magic1 a/rology1 mesm]ism1 clairvoyance1 spiritualism1 homoeopa?y1 hydropa?y1 k9esipa?y1 ,essays & ,reviews1 & ,bi%op ,col5so1#ccc all put toge!r4 ,( all ! suppositions ,i h giv5 z actually argu$1 ?is is ! "o :i* is h>de/ to d5y1 & h>de/ to admit4 ,res]v+ ! "q--z beyond human discussion--:e!r our p>ticles ( c>bon1 etc4 are clu/]s ( worlds1 ! au?or produces 8 reasons = ?9k+ t !y are at lea/ s+le worlds4 ,( c\rse--?\gh n m5tion$--! possibility is to be add$ ( ! same ?+ be+ true ( ! p>ticles :i* make up our p>ticles1 & s d[n1 = ev]3 &1 on ! o!r h&1 ( our planets & />s z be+ p>ticles 9 "s l>g] univ]se1 & s up1 = ev]4 ,great fleas h little fleas ^u _! backs to bite 'em1 ,& little fleas h less] fleas1 & s ad inf9itum4 ,& ! great fleas !mselves1 9 turn1 h great] fleas to g on2 ,:ile ^! aga9 h great] /ill1 & great] /ill1 & s on4#ccd ,i h (t5 _h ! notion t all ! nebulae we see1 includ+ our own1 :i* we call ! ,milky ,way1 may be p>ticles ( snuff 9 ! box ( a giant ( a proportionately #aib l>g] univ]se4 ,( c\rse ! m9im ( "t--a million ( ye>s or :atev] ! geologi/s make x#cce--:i* our little affair has la/$1 is b a v small fraction ( a second to ! great creature 9 ^: nose we %all all be 9 a few t5s ( ?\s&s ( millions ( millions ( millions ( ye>s4 ,all ?is is q possible1 & ! probabilities = & aga9/ are q out ( rea*4 ,p]haps also all ! worlds1 bo? above & bel[ u1 are fac-similes ( our own4 ,if s1 away goes free w = good & all2 unless1 inde$1 we und]p9 our sy/em ) ! hypo!sis t all ! fac-simile bodies ( diff]5t sizes are actuat$ by a common s\l4 ,^! acute supplem5t>y notions ( m9e g f> to get rid ( ! difficulty :i* "s h f\nd 9 ! common !ory t ! s\l inhabits ! body3 x has be5 /at$ t !re is1 some:]e or ano!r1 a _w ( s\ls :i* communicate ) _! bodies by wondr\s filam5ts ( a nature nei!r m5tal nor mat]ial1 b ( a t]tium quid fit to be a g-betwe52 z x 7 a corporispiritual copp] encas$ 9 a spiritucorporeal gutta-p]*a4 ,my !ory is t e s\l is ev]y:]e 9 posse1 z ! s*oolm5 said1 b n any:]e 9 actu1 except :]e x f9ds "o ( its bodies4 ,^! a priori difficulties be+ ?us remov$1 ! sy/em ( p>ticle-worlds is r$uc$ to a dry "q ( fact1 & remitt$ to ! decision ( ! microscope4 ,& a gr& field may ?us be op5$1 z optical sci5ce progresses6 ,= ! worlds are n fac-similes ( ours 9 "t3 !re is n a mom5t ( our pa/1 & n a mom5t ( our future1 b is ! pres5t ( "o or m ( ! p>ticles4 ,a w write ! dea? ( ,caes>1 & ,b ! build+ ( ! ,pyramids1 by actual obs]vation ( ! processes ) a p[] ( a ?\s& millions2 ,c w discov] ! comm5cem5t ( ! ,mill5nium1 & ,d ! #aic t]m9ation ( ,ers* & ,grub]'s ,lexicon1#ccf z m]e physical ph5om5a4 ,aga9/ ?is glori\s future !re is a sad om53 ! initials ( ! =]unn] ( ?is discov]y are--,,no6 ,,! ,,sup]natural4 ,! ,hi/ory ( ! ,sup]natural 9 all ages & nations1 & 9 all ,*ur*es1 ,*ri/ian & ,pagan3 demon/rat+ a univ]sal fai?4 ,by ,wm4 ,h[itt4#ccg ,london1 #b vols4 #hvo4 #ahfc4 ,mr4 ,h[itt is a prea*] ( spiritualism4 ,he cem5ts an enorm\s collection ( alleg$ facts ) a vivid outp\r+ ( exhortation1 & an unsp>+ fl[ ( s>casm aga9/ ! scorn]s ( all classes4 ,he & ! ,rev4 ,j4 ,smi?#cch 7ante1 #ahed7 are ! mo/ ?or\ghgo+ univ]sali/s ( all ! writ]s ,i "k on spiritualism4 ,if ei!r c ins]t ! small end ( ! w$ge1 he w n let y (f "o fraction ( ! conclusion t all c\ntries1 9 all ages1 h be5 ! !at]s ( "o va/ spiritual display4 ,& ,i suspect t ?is consequ5ce _c be avoid$1 if any "p ( ! sy/em be ( truly spiritual orig94 ,mr4 ,h[itt treats ! philosoph]s ei!r z ignorant babies1 or z consci\s _s-fe>]s3 & seems mu* incl9$ to accuse ! _w at l>ge ( dread+1 le/ by ! actual pres5ce ( ! o!r _w _! ,*ri/ianity %\ld imbibe a spiritual elem5t :i* w\ld unfit x = ! purposes ( _! lives4 #aid ,,f ,,matt] ,,to ,,_s4 ,f ,matt] to ,_s4 ,by ,c4 ,d4 ,) a preface by ,a4 ,b4#cci ,london1 #ahfc1 #hvo4 ,?is is a "w on ,spiritual ,manife/ations4 ,! au?or upholds ! facts = spiritual ph5om5a3 ! prefator susp5ds 8 op9ion z to ! cause1 ?\gh he upholds ! facts4 ,! "w beg9s sy/ematically ) ! l[] class ( ph5om5a1 proce$s to ! high] class1 & (f]s a !ory1 sugge/$ by ! facts1 ( ! connection ( ! pres5t & future life4 ,i agree 9 ! ma9 ) ,a4 ,b42 b c1 ( c\rse1 make none b horresc5t ref]5ce to 8 treatm5t ( ! small] philosoph]s4 ,?is is always ! way ) y\r p>adox]s3 !y behave t[>ds or?odoxy z ! ?re%] fi% behaves t[>ds ! :ale4 ,b if true1 z is said1 t ! drubb+ cle>s ! great fi% ( p>asites :i* he c\ld n o!rwise get rid (1 he ought to be> no malice4 ,?is preface retorts a little ( t contempt :i* ! philosophical _w has be/[$ ) heap$ measure ^u ^? :o h believ$ _! s5ses1 & h drawn natural1 ev5 if ha/y1 inf]5ces4 ,!re is philosoph]craft z well z prie/craft1 bo? f "o s\rce1 bo? ( "o _s4 ,9 ,engli% cities & t[ns1 ! m9i/] ( religion has be5 tam$3 s _m weapons are b>$ aga9/ him :5 he obtrudes 8 (fice 9 a dictatory mann]1 t1 z a rule1 !re is no m quiet & mode/ memb] ( society ?an ! urban cl]gyman4 ,dom9ation ov] religi\s belief is res]v$ = ! exclusive use ( ^? :o admit ! "r3 ! r>e exception to ?is mode ( behavior is laugh$ at z a bigot1 or %unn$ z a nuisance4 ,b ! ov]be>+ m9i/] ( nature1 :o snaps y ) unphilosophical z ! cl]gyman once fright5$ y ) infidel1 is /ill a recogniz$ memb] ( society1 wants tam+1 & w get x4 ,he we>s ! prie/'s ca/-(f #aie clo!s1 dy$ to escape detection3 ! bett] sort ( philosoph]s w\ld gladly set him to squ>e ! circle4 ,! book j nam$ appe>$ ab\t ! same "t z ?is ,budget began 9 ! ,a!naeum4 ,x 0 commonly attribut$1 ! book to my wife1 ! preface to myself4 ,"s "t aft]1 our names 7 actually ann\nc$ by ! publi%]1 :o ought to "k4 ,x w be held to confirm ?is /atem5t t ,i ann\nce our hav+ 9 our possession "s tw5ty reviews ( diff]5t l5g?s1 & ( all *>act]s3 :o ev] collects a numb] ( reviews ( a book1 except ! au?or8 ,a great _m ( ^! reviews settle ! matt] a priori4 ,if !re _h be5 spirits 9 ! matt]1 !y w\ld h done ?is1 & !y w\ld n h done t4 ,jean ,mesli]#cdj said !re c\ld be no ,god ov] all1 =1 if !re _h be5 "o1 ,he w\ld h e/abli%$ a univ]sal religion4 ,if ,j4 ,m4 knew t1 ,j4 ,m4 0 "r3 b if ,j4 ,m4 did n "k t1 !n ,j4 ,m4 0 on ! high priori road1 & may be left to 8 c\rse4 ,! same to all :o "k :at spirits w\ld d & w\ld n d4 ,a4 ,b4 v di/9ctly said t he knew "s ( ! ass]t$ facts1 believ$ o!rs on te/imony1 b did n pret5d to "k :e!r !y 7 caus$ by spirits1 or _h "s unkn[n & unimag9$ orig94 ,?is he said z cle>ly z ,i c\ld h said x myself4 ,b a great _m p]sons _c und]/& su* a frame ( m9d3 _! own app>atus is a k9d ( _s-level1 & _! conclusion on any subject is ! little bubble1 :i* is always at "o end or ! o!r4 ,_m ( ! review]s decl>e t ,a4 ,b4 is a secret believ] 9 ! _s-hypo!sis3 & "o ( !m wi%es t he _h endors$ 8 op9ion m boldly4 ,accord+ to ?is review]1 any "o :o writes ,i boldly #aif say ,i am unable to *oose1 contradicts himself4 ,9 tru?1 a p]son :o does say x has a good deal ( c\rage1 = ea* side believes t he secretly favors ! o!r2 & bo? look ^u him z a c[>d4 ,9 spite ( all ?is1 ,a4 ,b4 boldly repeats t he feels assur$ ( _m ( ! facts ( spiritualism1 & t he _c pret5d to affirm or d5y any?+ ab\t _! cause4 ,! great bulk ( ! illogical "p ( ! educat$ community--:e!r majority or m9ority ,i "k n2 p]haps six ( "o & half-a-doz5 ( ! o!r--h n p[] to make a di/9ction1 _c be made to take a di/9ction1 & ( c\rse1 nev] attempt to %ake a di/9ction4 ,) !m all su* ?+s are evasions1 subt]fuges1 come-(fs1 loopholes1 etc4 ,!y w\ld hang a man = horse-/eal+ "u a /atute aga9/ %eep-/eal+2 & w\ld laugh at y if y quibbl$ ab\t ! di/9ction betwe5 a horse & a %eep4 ,i divide ! illogical--,i mean p :o h n t am\nt ( natural use ( s\nd inf]5ce :i* is really n uncommon--into ?ree classes3--,fir/ class1 ?ree v>ieties3 ! ,niddy1 ! ,noddy1 & ! ,noodle4 ,second class1 ?ree v>ieties3 ! ,niddy-,noddy1 ! ,niddy-,noodle1 & ! ,noddy-,noodle4 ,?ird class1 undivid$3 ! ,niddy-,noddy-,noodle4 ,no p]son has a "r to be angry ) me = m ?an "o ( ^! subdivisions4 ,! want ( di/9ction 0 illu/rat$ to me1 :5 a boy1 ab\t #ahbj1 by ! report ( a trial :i* ,i %all nev] =get3 boys read newspap]s m ke5ly ?an m54 ,e n[ & !n a b5* ( c\ntry magi/rates r a/oni%es ! t[n populations1 accu/om$ to rub _! bra9s#cda aga9/ "o ano!r4 ,su* a /ory z ! foll[+ w\ld1 #aig 9 our day1 br+ d[n grave rem>ks f above3 b ,i write ( ! old5 7or ,eldon#cdb7 "t1 :5 no?+ b conviction 9 a c\rt ( record w\ld displace a magi/rate4 ,9 t day ! ?ird-class amalgamator ( di/9ct ?+s 0 (t5 on ! b5* ( qu>t]-sessions4 ,an attorney 0 *>g$ ) hav+ be5 out at night poa*+4 ,a cle> alibi 0 e/abli%$2 & p]jury _h c]ta9ly be5 committ$4 ,! :ole gave reason to suspect t "s ill-will]s ?\ght ! b5* dislik$ ! attorney s mu* t any conviction 0 c]ta9 on any evid5ce4 ,! b5* did dislike ! attorney3 b n to ! ext5t ( ?9k+ he c\ld sn>e any p>tridges 9 ! fields :ile he 0 asleep 9 b$1 except ! dream-p>tridges :i* are n always protect$ by ! dream-laws4 ,s ! *airman said1 ,mr4 ----1 y are dis*>g$2 b y %\ld consid] ?is "o ( ! mo/ =tunate days ( y\r life4 ,! attorney indignantly remon/rat$1 b ! magi/rate 0 "r2 = he said1 ,mr4 ----1 y h frequ5tly be5 employ$ to def5d poa*]s3 h y be5 c>eful to impress ^u !m ! enormity ( _! practices8 ,x appe>$ 9 a wrangl+ conv]sation t ! magi/rates saw little moral diff]5ce betwe5 poa*+ & be+ a poa*]'s pr(essional def5d] )\t lectur+ him on 8 wick$ness3 b !y admitt$ ) reluctance1 t !re 0 a legal di/9ction2 & ! bra9 ( ,n#c c\ld no fur!r g4 ,?is is ne>ly fifty ye>s ago2 & ,we/]nism 0 n q ext9ct4 ,if ! pres5t lords ( ! hills & ! valleys want to %9e1 let !m publi% a true hi/ory ( _! own ord]4 ,i am j old en\gh to rememb] "s ( ! la/ ( ! squires & p>sons :o prote/$ aga9/ tea*+ ! poor to read & write4 ,!y n[ write books = ! work+ classes1 give !m lectures1 & ! l4 ,!re is n[ no class1 z a class1 m highly educat$1 broadly educat$1 & deeply educat$1 #aih ?an ^? :o 71 9 old times1 be/ describ$ z p>tridge-popp+ squire5s4 ,i h myself1 :5 a boy1 he>d ,old ,booby speak+ ) pride ( ,"y ,booby z hav+ too high a _s to be conf9$ to books3 & ,i suspect$ t 8 dislike to tea*+ ! poor arose 9 fact f a feel+ t !y w\ld1 if taught a little1 pass 8 heir4 ,a4 ,b4 recomm5d$ ! _s-!ory z an hypo!sis on :i* to gr\nd inquiry2 t is1 z ! means ( sugge/ion = ! direction ( inquiry4 ,e p]son :o kn[s any?+ ( ! progress ( physics und]/&s :at is meant2 b n ! review]s ,i speak (4 ,_m ( !m consid] ,a4 ,b4 z adopt+ ! _s-hypo!sis4 ,! :ole book 0 writt51 z bo? ! au?ors po9t out1 to sugge/ inquiry to ^? :o are curi\s2 ,c4 ,d4 firmly believ+1 ,a4 ,b4 z above4 ,nei!r ,c4 ,d4 nor ,a4 ,b4 make any o!r pret5ce4 ,bo? dwell ^u ! abs5ce ( au!ntications & ! suppression ( names z utt]ly prev5tive ( any?+ l pro(4 ,& ,a4 ,b4 says t 8 read] w give him cr$it1 if n himself a goose1 = see+ t ! t5d] ( an anonym\s *eque w\ld be ( equal effect1 :e!r drawn on ! ,bank ( ,engl& or on ,aldgate ,pump4 ,by ?is te/ a numb] ( ! review]s are f\nd to be geese3 = !y take ! au?ors z (f]+ pro(1 & insi/1 aga9/ ! au?ors1 on ! v po9t on :i* ! au?ors _h !mselves insi/$ be=eh&4 ,leav+ aside imp]ceptions ( ?is k9d1 ,i proce$ to notice a cl]ical & m$ical review4 ,i h liv$ mu* 9 ! middle ages1 especially s9ce ! inv5tion ( pr9t+2 & f !nce ,i h br\ght away a high respect = & grateful recollection (--! prie/ 9 ev]y?+ b !ology1 & ! physician 9 ev]y?+ b m$ic9e4 ,! pr(essional h>ness 0 unfavorable to all progress1 except on a beat5 road2 ! pr(essional bl9k]s prev5t$ all b ! beat5 road f be+ se53 ! pr(essional re9s 7 pull$ at ! slighte/ attempt to quick5 pace1 ev5 on ! p]mitt$ pa?2 & ! #aii pr(essional :ip 0 heavily laid on at ! slighte/ attempt to div]ge4 ,b :5 ! intellig5t man ( ei!r class turn$ 8 att5tion out ( 8 ord9>y "w1 he _h1 9 mo/ cases1 ! fre%ness & vigor ( a boy at play1 & l ! boy1 he felt 8 fre$om all ! m f ! contra/ ( s*ool-re/ra9t4 ,9 ! case ( m$ic9e1 & physics g5]ally1 ! le>n$ 71 9 "s ess5tial po9ts1 m rational ?an _m ( _! pres5t impugn]s4 ,!y pass = hav+ put a priori ob/acles 9 ! way ( progress3 !y might r be reprov$ = too mu* belief 9 progress obta9$ by a priori means4 ,!y w\ld h %\t$ ) laught] at a dunce :o--9 a review ,i read1 b )\t mak+ a note--decl>$ t he w\ld n believe 8 s5ses except :5 :at !y %[$ him 0 capable ( explanation ^u "s kn[n pr9ciple4 ,i h se5 su* /uff z ?is attribut$ to ! s*oolm52 b only by ^? :o knew no?+ ab\t !m4 ,! foll[+1 :i* ,i wrote "s ye>s ago1 w give a notion ( a di/9ction wor? rememb]+4 ,x is address$ to ! au?orities ( ! ,college ( ,physicians4 ,! ignom9y ( ! ^w empiric dates f ! ages 9 :i* s*ola/ic philosophy d$uc$ physical consequ5ces a priori2--! ages 9 :i*1 because a lion is /rong1 rubb+ ) lion's fat w\ld h be5 held an infallible tonic4 ,9 ^? happy days1 if a physician _h giv5 decoction ( a c]ta9 b>k1 only because 9 numb]less in/ances t decoction _h be5 f\nd to /r5g!n ! pati5t1 he w\ld h be5 a mis]able empiric4 ,n t ! colleges w\ld h pass$ ov] 8 returns because !y 7 empirical3 !y knew bett]4 ,!y 7 z skilful 9 f9d+ causes = facts1 z facts = causes4 ,! presid5t & ! elects ( t day w\ld h walk$ out into ! =e/ ) a rope1 & w\ld h pull$ he>tily at ! tree :i* yield$ ! b>k3 nor w\ld !y ev] h left x until !y _h pull$ out a legitimate #bjj reason4 ,if ! tree _h resi/$ all _! ef=ts1 !y w\ld h said1 ',ah6 no wond] n[2 ! b>k ( a /rong tree makes a /rong man4' ,b if !y _h manag$ to s]ve ! tree z y w\ld l to s]ve homoeopa?y1 !n x w\ld h be5 ',we might h guess$ x2 all ! virtus roborativa has settl$ 9 ! b>k4' ,!y admitt$1 z we "k f ,moli]e1 ! virtus dormitiva#cdc ( opium1 = no o!r reason ?an t opium facit dormire4#cdd ,_h ! m$ic9e n be5 previ\sly kn[n1 !y w\ld1 /range z x may seem to mod]n ph>macopoei/s1 h accord$ a virtus dormitiva to ! new facit dormire4 ,on ?is po9t !y h be5 misappreh5d$4 ,!y 7 prone to inf] facit f a virtus imag9$ a priori2 & !y 7 ready 9 supply+ facit 9 favor ( an or?odox virtus4 ,!y might h gone s f>1 = example1 "u pre-notional impressions1 z ! allit]ative allopa?1 :o1 :5 ma9t5ance ( tru? 0 busy oppos+ ! progress ( sci5ce call$ vacc9ation1 decl>$ t "s ( its pati5ts c\gh$ l c[s1 & bell[$ l bulls2 b !y nev] refus$ to f9d virtus :5 facit came ^u !m1 no matt] :5ce4 ,!y w\ld r h accept$ ,t5t]d5 /eeple ?an h reject$ ! ,goodw9 ,s&s4 ,!y w\ld h laugh$ _! mod]n imitators to scorn3 b z !y are n "h1 we d x = !m4 ,! man ( our day--! a priori philosoph]--tries ! "q :e!r opium c cause sleep by f9d+ out 9 ! recesses ( 8 own noddle :e!r ! drug c h a dormitive p[]3 ,well6 b did n ! s*oolman d ! same8 ,he did2 b m>k ! di/9ction4 ,! s*oolman _h rec\rse to fir/ pr9ciples1 :5 !re 0 no opium to try x by3 our man settles ! po9t 9 ! same way ) a lump ( opium be=e him4 ,! s*oolman %ift$ 8 pr9ciples ) 8 facts3 ! man ( our draw+-rooms w fight facts ) 8 pr9ciples1 j z an old #bja physician w\ld h done 9 actual practice1 ) ! rod ( 8 ,*ur* at 8 back4 ,! /ory ab\t ,galileo--:i* seems to h be5 ei!r a joke made aga9/ him1 or by him--illu/rates ?is4 ,nature abhors a vacuum 0 ! explanation ( ! wat] ris+ 9 a pump3 b !y f\nd t ! wat] w\ld n rise m ?an #cb feet4 ,!y ask$ = explanation3 :at does ! satiri/ make ! s*oolm5 say8 ,t ! /oppage is n a fact1 because nature abhors a vacuum8 ,no6 b t ! pr9ciple %\ld be t nature abhors a vacuum z f> z #cb feet4 ,& ?is is :at w\ld h be5 done4 ,!re are /ill among u bo? prie/s & physicians :o w\ld h belong$1 _h !y liv$ ?ree or f\r c5turies ago1 to ! glori\s b& ( :om ,i h spok51 ! majority ( ! intellig5t1 work+ well = mank9d out ( ! pr(essional pursuit4 ,b we h a great _m :o h help$ to abase _! classes4 ,g :]e we may1 we f9d specim5s ( ! l[] ord]s ( ! m9i/ry ( religion & ! m9i/ry ( heal? %[+ !mselves small] ?an ! small ( o!r pursuits4 ,& h[ is ?is8 ,fir/1 because ea* pr(ession is ent]$ ^u a m]e work+ smack ( its k1 )\t any dep? ( education1 g5]al or pr(essional4 ,n t ?is is ! :ole explanation1 nor 9 itself objectionable3 ! great mass ( ! _w mu/ be t5d$1 s\l & body1 by ^? :o are nei!r ,hook]s#cde nor ,h>veys#cdf3 let su* p]sons n v5ture ultra crepidam1 & !y are useful & respectable4 ,b1 secondly1 !re is a va/ upheav+ ( ?\ght f ! dep?s ( commonplace le>n+4 ,i am a cl]gyman6 ,sir6 ,i am a m$ical man6 ,sir6 & =?) ! nature ( ?+s is pick$ to pieces1 & !re is a race1 ) ! la/ ! w9n]1 betwe5 ,philosophy m\nt$ on ,folly's donkey1 & ,folly m\nt$ on ,philosophy's donkey4 ,h[ =tunate #bjb x is = ,law t h] battles are f\ght by politicians 9 ! ,h\ses ( ,p>liam5t4 ,n t x is bett] done3 b !n politics be>s ! blame4 ,i n[ come to ! m$ical review4 ,aft] a quantity ( rem>k :i* has be5 already dispos$ (1 ! writ] %[s ,greek le>n+1 a field 9 :i* ! old physician w\ld h _h a little k4 ,a4 ,b41 = ! joke's sake1 _h left untranslat$1 z be+ too deep1 a rem>kably easy s5t5ce ( ,ari/otle1 to ! effect t :at has happ5$ 0 possible1 = if impossible x w\ld n h happ5$4 ,! review]1 9 simple a/oni%m5t1--x 0 simple--at ! pret5d$ incapacity--,i 0 told by ,a4 ,b4 t ! joke 0 int5d$ to draw out a review]--translates3--,he says t ?is s5t5ce is ,a4 ,b4's summ+ up ( ! evid5ce ( ,spiritualism4 ,n[1 be+ a sort ( alt] ego#cdg ( ,a4 ,b41 ,i d decl>e t he is n su* a fool z to re/ ! evid5ce ( ,spiritualism--! _s explanation--^u ! occurr5ce ( c]ta9 facts prov+ ! possibility ( ^? v facts4 ,9 tru?1 ,a4 ,b4 refuses to receive spiritualism1 :ile he receives ! facts3 ?is is ! gi/ ( 8 :ole preface1 :i* simply admits spiritualism among ! qualifi$ c&idates1 & does n "k :at o!rs !re may be4 ,! review] speaks ( ,ari/otle z t cle> ?9k] & concise writ]4 ,i /rongly suspect t 8 k ( ,ari/otle 0 limit$ to ! s+le s5t5ce :i* he _h translat$ or got translat$4 ,ari/otle is concise 9 phrase1 n 9 book1 & is p[]ful & pr(\nd 9 ?\ght3 b no "o :o kn[s t 8 writ+1 all we h ( him1 is ! v opposite ( cle>1 w pret5d to decide t he ?\ght cle>ly4 ,z 8 writ+1 s probably 0 8 ?\ght2 & 8 books are1 if n any?+ b cle>1 at lea/ any?+ good b cle>4 ,nobody ?9ks !m cle> except a p]son :o always cle>s difficulties3 :i* ,i h no d\bt 0 ! review]'s habit2 t is1 if he ev] took ! field #bjc at all4 ,! g5tleman :o read ,euclid1 all except ! ,z & ,bs & ! pictures ( scrat*es & scrawls1 is ! type ( a num]\s class4 ,! review] f9ds t ! ^w amosgepotically1 us$ by ,a4 ,b41 is utt]ly my/]i\s & incompreh5sible4 ,he hopes 8 translation ( ! bit ( ,greek w %ield him f imputation ( ignorance3 & ?9ks ! ^w may be ref]r$ to ! obscure dialect out ( :i* sprung an]oid1 kalos geusis sauce1 & ,anaxyridian tr\s]s4 ,to lump ! fir/ two phrases ) ! ?ird smacks ( ignorance 9 a ,greek critic2 = ,greek3 anaxuridia1 bree*es1 w\ld h turn$ up 9 ! lexicon2 & kalos geusis1 ?\gh absurd1 is n obscure4 ,& ,greek3 amosgepos1 someh[ or o!r1 is z easily f\nd z ,greek3 anaxuridia4 ,! ^w an]oid1 ,i admit1 has puzzl$ bett] s*ol>s ?an ! critic3 b nev] "o :o kn[s ! uns*ol>like way 9 :i* words end+ 9 ,greek3 eides h be5 r5d]$4 ,! an]oid b>omet] does n use a column ( air 9 ! same way z ! old in/rum5t4 ,n[ ,greek3 a]oeides--prop]ly l ! atmosph]e--is by sci5tific non-s*ol>%ip r5d]$ hav+ to d ) ! atmosph]e2 & ,greek3 ana]oeides--say ana]oid--d5ies hav+ to d ) ! atmosph]e2 a nice ?+ to say ( an in/rum5t :i* is to measure ! weight ( ! atmosph]e4 ,"o m absurdity1 & we h an]oid1 & !re y are4 ,! critic ends ) a decl>ation t no?+ 9 ! book %akes 8 fai? 9 a ,qu>t]ly review] :o said t susp5sion ( op9ion1 until fur!r evid5ce arrives1 is ju/ifiable3 a /range summ+ up = an article :i* insi/s ^u utt] rejection be+ unavoidable4#cdh ,! express$ aim ( bo? ,a4 ,b4 & ,c4 ,d4 0 to excite inquiry1 & get fur!r evid5ce3 until ?is is done1 nei!r asks = a v]dict4 ,oh :]e6 & oh :]e6 is old ,m$ic9e's le>n+ gone6 ,!re 0 "s 9 ! days ( yore1 :5 ,pop]y #bjd 0 on6 ,& x's oh6 = "s ,greek1 j to f9d a ^w ^u6 ,! review] :o1 lexicon 9 h&1 c nei!r make out anaxyridical1 amosgepotical1 kalos geusis1 nor di/+ui% !m f an]oid1 _c be tru/$ :5 he says he has translat$ a s5t5ce ( ,ari/otle4 ,he may h done x2 b1 z he says ( spiritualism1 we mu/ susp5d our op9ion until fur!r evid5ce %all arrive4 ,we n[ come to ! !ological review4 ,i h be=e allud$ to ! faults ( logic :i* are ,prote/ant necessities3 b ,i nev] said t ,prote/ant argum5t _h no?+ b p>alogism4 ,! writ] be=e me atta9s ?is complet5ess3 f beg9n+ to end he is ( t confusion & p]v]sion :i*1 z appli$ to int]pretation ( ! ,new ,te/am5t1 is s common z to pass unnotic$ by s]mon-he>]s2 b :i*1 :5 appli$ out ( *ur*1 is expos$ ) laught] 9 all subjects except !ology4 ,i %all take "o in/ance1 putt+ "s words 9 italics4 ,a4 ,b4 ,!ological ,critic4 ,my /ate ( m9d1 :i* ref]s 444 he proce$s to argue t ! :ole ei!r to unse5 he himself is outside its intellig5ce1 or some?+ sacr$ pale because he ref]s :i* man has nev] _h any all ^! /range ph5om5a to conception (1 proves me to unse5 spiritual be out ( ! pale ( ! intellig5ce4 ,royal ,society4 ,! possibility ( a yet unimag9$ cause is insi/$ on 9 sev]al places4 ,on ?is gr\nd x is argu$ by ,a4 ,b4 t spirituali/s are incauti\s = giv+ 9 at once to ! _s doctr9e4 ,b1 x is said1 !y may be ju/ifi$ by ! philosoph]s1 :o make ! fl9t axes1 z !y call !m1 to be ! works ( m51 because no "o c see :at else !y c be4 ,?is k9d ( adoption1 condemn$ z a conclusion1 is approv$ z a provisional !ory1 sugge/ive ( direction ( inquiry3 exp]i5ce hav+ %[n t #bje inquiry direct$ by a wrong !ory has l$ to m good ?an inquiry )\t any !ory at all4 ,all ?is ,a4 ,b4 has fully set =?1 9 sev]al pages4 ,on x ! review] rem>ks t ) inf9ite satisfaction he tries to ju/ify 8 view ( ! case by urg+ t !re is no o!r way ( acc\nt+ = x2 aft] ! fa%ion ( ! philosoph]s ( our own day1 :o conclude t c]ta9 fl9ts f\nd 9 ! drift are ! "w ( m51 because ! geologi/ does n see :at else !y c be4 ,aft] ?is twi/ ( mean+1 ! review] proce$s to say1 & ,a4 ,b4 w\ld c]ta9ly jo9 him1 ,!re is no ne$ to combat any su* mode ( reason+ z ?is1 because x w\ld apply ) equal =ce & ju/ice to any !ory :atev]1 h[ev] fanta/ic1 pr(ane1 or silly4 ,& s1 hav+ %[n h[ ! review] has hung himself1 ,i leave him funip5dul\s4 ,"o in/ance m1 & ,i h done4 ,a review]1 n !ological1 speak+ ( ! common argum5t t ?+s :i* are d]id$ are n !re=e to be reject$1 writes z foll[s3--,x might z well be said t !y :o laugh$ at ,j5n]#cdi & vacc9ation 71 9 a c]ta9 b v unsatisfactory way1 witnesses to ! possible excell5ce ( ! sy/em ( ,/4 ,john ,long4#cej ,( c\rse x might3 & ( c\rse x is said by all p ( common s5se4 ,9 introduc+ ! ^w possible1 ! review] has hit ! po9t3 ,i suspect t ?is ^w 0 introduc$ dur+ revision1 to put ! s5t5ce into fight+ ord]2 hurry prev5t+ x be+ se5 t ! s5t5ce 0 ?us made to fight on ! wrong side4 ,j5n]1 :o 0 laugh$ at1 0 "r2 !re=e1 x is n impossible--t is1 x is possible--t a d]id$ sy/em may be "r4 ,m>k ! ?ree gradations3 9 m$io tutissimus ibis4#cea #bjf ,review]4--,if a sy/em be d]id$1 x is no gr\nd ( susp5se t d]id$ sy/ems h turn$ out true3 if x 71 y w\ld susp5d y\r op9ion ab\t ,/4 ,john ,long on acc\nt ( ,j5n]4--,ans4 ,y ought to d s1 z to possibility2 & be=e exam9ation2 n ) ! notion t ,j4 proves ,/4 ,j4 probable2 only possible4 ,common ,s5se4--,! pa/ em]g5ce ( tru?s out ( d]id$ sy/ems proves t !re is a practical c]ta9ty ( l occurr5ce to come4 ,b1 inasmu* z a hundr$ speculative fool]ies are />t$ = "o tru?1 ! m9d is p]mitt$ to approa* ! exam9ation ( any "o giv5 novelty ) a bias aga9/ x ( a hundr$ to "o3 & ?is p]mission is giv5 because s x w be1 leave or no leave4 ,e "o has lic5ce n to jump ov] ! moon4 ,p>adox]4--,great m5 h be5 d]id$1 & ,i am d]id$3 :i* proves t my sy/em ought to be adopt$4 ,?is is a summ>y ( all ! degrees 9 :i* p>adox]s cont5d = ! =m] d]ision ( tru?s n[ e/abli%$1 giv+ _! sy/ems probability4 ,i annex a p>agraph :i* ,d e c4 ins]t$ 9 ! ,a!naeum ( ,octob] #bc1 #ahdg4 ,discov]]s & ,discov]ies4 ,ari/otle once s5t 8 s]vant to ! cell> to fet* w9e3--& ! fell[ br\ght him back small be]4 ,! ,/agirite 7:o knew ! diff]5ce7 call$ him a blockhead4 ',sir1' said ! man1 'all ,i c say is1 t ,i f\nd x 9 ! cell>4' ,! philosoph] mutt]$ to himself t an affirmative conclusion c\ld n be prov$ 9 ! second figure1--& ,mrs4 ,ari/otle1 :o 0 by1 0 n less effective 9 h] rem>k1 t small be] 0 n w9e because x 0 9 ! same cell>4 ,bo? 7 "r en\gh3 & our philosoph]s might take a lesson f ei!r--= !y ins9uate an affirmative conclusion 9 ! second figure4 ,great discov]]s h be5 little valu$ by e/abli%$ #bjg s*ools1--& !y are little valu$4 ,! results ( true sci5ce are /range at fir/1--& s are _!'s4 ,_m great m5 h oppos$ exi/+ notions1--& s d !y4 ,all great m5 7 obscure at fir/1--& !y are obscure4 ,?9k+ m5 d\bt1--& !y d\bt4 ,_! small be]1 ,i grant1 has come out ( ! same cell> z ! w9e2 b ?is is n en\gh4 ,if !y _h let x /& a:ile 9 ! old w9e-casks1 x might h imbib$ a little ( ! flavor4 ,!re are bett] reviews ?an ,i h notic$2 :i*1 ?\gh entirely diss5t+1 are unassailable on _! own pr9ciples4 ,:at ,i h giv5 repres5ts five-six?s ( ! :ole4 ,b x mu/ be confess$ t ! fraction ( fairness & mod]ation & susp5d$ op9ion :i* ! doctr9e ( ,_s ,manife/ations has met )--ev5 9 ! l[] reviews--is /rik+ly l>ge comp>$ to :at w\ld h be5 ! case fifty ye>s ago4 ,x is to be hop$ t our popul> & p]iodical lit]atures are giv+ u "o ?9k] creat$ = tw5ty geese d\ble-fea!r$3 if ?is hope be realiz$1 we %all d6 ,see+ all t ,i see1 ,i am n prep>$ to g ! l5g? ( a fri5d ( m9e :o1 aft] read+ a good specim5 ( ! l[] review+1 exclaim$--,oh6 if all ! fools 9 ! _w c\ld be roll$ up into "o fool1 :at a review] he w\ld make6 ,cal5dri] ,univ]sel et ,p]petuel2 p> le ,comm&eur ,p4 ,j4 ,arson4#ceb ,publie p> ses ,enfans 7,oeuvre po/hume74 ,nice1 #ahfc1 #dto4 ,i %all n give any acc\nt ( ?is curi\s cal5d>1 ) all its *anges & symbols4 ,b !re is "o proposal1 :i*1 c\ld we alt] ! g5]al notions ( "t--a ?+ ( v dubi\s possibility--w\ld be conv5i5t4 ,! week is made to wax & wane1 culm9at+ on ! ,sunday1 #bjh :i* comes 9 ! middle4 ,?ursday1 ,friday1 ,saturday1 are asc5d+ or wax+ days2 ,monday1 ,tuesday1 ,w$nesday1 are desc5d+ or wan+ days4 ,our six days1 lump$ toge!r aft] ! great di/+ui%+ day1 ,sunday1 are too _m to be di/9ctly ?\ght ( toge!r3 a division ( ?ree prec$+ & ?ree foll[+ ! day ( mo/ note w\ld be mu* m easily us$4 ,b all ?is comes too late4 ,x may be1 nev]!less1 t "s individuals may be able to adju/ _! affairs ) advantage by ref]r+ ,?ursday1 ,friday1 ,saturday1 to ! foll[+ ,sunday1 & ,monday1 ,tuesday1 ,w$nesday1 to ! prec$+ ,sunday4 ,b ,m4 ,arson's proposal to alt] ! names ( ! days is no m necess>y ?an x is practicable4 ,,cyclometry4 ,i am n to ent] any?+ ,i d n possess4 ,! read] !re=e w n le>n f me ! feats ( _m a man-at-arms 9 ^! subjects4 ,he mu/ be cont5t1 unless he w be/ir himself = himself1 n to "k h[ ,mr4 ,patrick ,cody trisects ! angle at ,mull9avat1 or ,pr(essor ,recalcati squ>es ! circle at ,milan4 ,b ?is la/ is to be done by subscription1 at five francs a head3 a bank] is nam$ :o gu>antees re/itution if ! solution be n p]fectly rigor\s2 ! bank] himself1 ,i suppose1 is ! judge4 ,i h he>d ( a man ( bus9ess :o settl$ ! circle 9 ?is way3 if x c be r$uc$ to a debtor & cr$itor acc\nt1 x c c]ta9ly be done2 if n1 x is n wor? do+4 ,montucla w give ! acc\nts ( ! lawsuits :i* wag]s on ! problem h produc$ 9 ,france4 ,nei!r w ,i ent] at l5g? ^u ! success ( ! new squ>] :o adv]tises 7,nov4 #ahfc7 9 a c\ntry pap] t1 hav+ read t ! circul> ratio 0 undet]m9$1 ,i ?\ght x v /range t s _m great s*ol>s 9 all ages %\ld h fail$ 9 f9d+ ! true ratio1 & h be5 det]m9$ to try myself4444 ,i am ab\t to secure ! #bji b5efit ( ! discov]y1 s until !n ! public _c "k my new & true ratio4 ,i h be5 in=m$ t ?is trial makes ! diamet] to ! circumf]5ce z #fd to #bja1 giv+ pi #c4adjfbe exactly4 ,! result 0 obta9$ by ! discov]] 9 ?ree weeks aft] he fir/ he>d ( ! exi/5ce ( ! difficulty4 ,?is quadrator has s9ce publi%$ a little slip1 & ent]$ x at ,/ation]s' ,hall4 ,he says he has done x by actual measurem5t2 & ,i he> f a private s\rce t he uses a disk ( #ab in*es diamet]1 :i* he rolls ^u a /raight rail4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? did ! same at "o "t2 z did also 8 p>tisan at ,bordeaux4 ,we h1 !n1 bo? #c4abe & #c4adjfbe1 by actual measurem5t4 ,! second result is m ?an ! fir/ by ab\t "o "p 9 #bjj4 ,! second roll+ is a v cr$itable "o2 x is ab\t z mu* bel[ ! m>k z ,ar*im$es 0 above x4 ,its p]=m] is a jo9]1 :o evid5tly kn[s well :at he is ab\t :5 he measures2 he is n wrong by #a 9 #c1jjj4 ,! read] w smile at ! quiet self-suffici5cy ) :i* ,i h be5 det]m9$ to try myself foll[s ! in=mation t s _m great s*ol>s 9 all ages h fail$4 ,x is an admirable _s1 :5 accompani$ by common s5se & uncommon self-k4 ,:5 ,i 0 an und]graduate !re 0 a little att5dant 9 ! libr>y :o gave me ! foll[+1--,z to clean+ ?is libr>y1 ,sir1 if ,i h spok5 to ! ,ma/] once ab\t x1 ,i h spok5 fifty times3 b x is ( no use2 he w n employ litt]y m52 & s ,i am oblig$ to look aft] x myself4 ,i d n ?9k ,i h m5tion$ ! bright =m ( quadrature 9 :i* a squ>e is made equal to a circle by mak+ ea* side equal to a qu>t] ( ! circumf]5ce4 ,! la/ squ>] ( ?is k9d :om ,i h se5 figures 9 ! la/ numb] ( ! ,a!naeum = #ahee3 he says ! ?+ is no long] a problem1 b an axiom4 ,he does n "k t ! area ( ! circle is great] ?an t ( any o!r figure ( ! same circuit4 ,?is any "o might see )\t #baj ma!matics4 ,h[ is x possible t ! figure ( greate/ area %\ld h any "o l5g? 9 its circuit unlike 9 =m to any o!r "p ( ! same l5g?8 ,! feel+ :i* tempts p]sons to ?is problem is t :i*1 9 romance1 made x impossible = a knight to pass a ca/le :i* belong$ to a giant or an en*ant]4 ,i once gave a lecture on ! subject3 a g5tleman :o 0 introduc$ to x by :at ,i said rem>k$1 l\d en\gh to be he>d by all ar\nd1 ,only prove to me t x is impossible1 & ,i w set ab\t x ?is v ev5+4 ,?is r9d]pe/ ( geometry _c be cur$1 :5 once x has seat$ itself 9 ! sy/em3 all t c be done is to apply :at ! le>n$ call prophylactics to ^? :o are yet s\nd4 ,:5 once ! virus gets into ! bra91 ! victim goes r\nd ! flame l a mo?2 fir/ "o way & !n ! o!r1 beg9n+ :]e he end$1 & end+ :]e he begun3 ?us v]ify+ ! old l9e ,9 girum imus nocte1 ecce6 et consumimur igni4#cec ,e ma!matician kn[s t scores ( me?ods1 diff]+ altoge!r f ea* o!r 9 process1 all end 9 ?is my/]i\s #c4adaei4441 :i* insi/s on call+ itself ! circumf]5ce to a unit ( diamet]4 ,a read] :o is compet5t to foll[ processes ( ari?metic may be easily satisfi$ t su* me?ods d actually exi/4 ,i w give a sket*1 c>ri$ out to a few figures1 ( ?ree3 ! fir/ two ,i nev] met ) 9 my read+2 ! ?ird is ! old me?od ( ,vieta4#ced ,i f9d t bo? ! fir/ & second me?ods are conta9$ 9 a !orem ( ,eul]4 ,:at ,mr4 ,james ,smi? says ( ^! me?ods is wor? not+4 ,he says ,i h giv5 ?ree fancy pro(s ( ! value ( pi3 he evid5tly takes me to be (f]+ demon/ration4 ,he proce$s ?us3-- ,8 fir/ pro( is traceable to ! diamet] ( a circle #baa ( radius #a4 ,8 second1 to ! side ( any inscrib$ equilat]al triangle to a circle ( radius #a4 ,8 ?ird1 to a radius ( a circle ( diamet] #a4 ,n[1 x may be frankly admitt$ t we c arrive at ! same result by _m o!r modes ( ari?metical calculation1 all ( :i* may be %[n to h "s sort ( relation to a circle2 b1 aft] all1 ^! results are m]e exhibitions ( ! prop]ties ( numb]s1 & h no m to d ) ! ratio ( diamet] to circumf]5ce 9 a circle ?an ! price ( sug> ) ! mean height ( spr+ tides4 7,corr4 ,oct4 #ba1 #ahfe74 ,i quote ?is because x is "o ( ! few cases--o!r ?an absolute assumption ( ! conclusion--9 :i* ,mr4 ,smi?'s conclusions w\ld be true if 8 premise 7 true4 ,_h ,i giv5 :at foll[s z pro(1 x w\ld h be5 prop]ly rem>k$1 t ,i _h only exhibit$ prop]ties ( numb]s4 ,b ,i took c>e to tell my read] t ,i 0 only go+ to %[ him me?ods :i* end 9 #c4adaei4444 ,! pro(s t ^! me?ods e/abli% ! value ( pi are = ^? :o w read & c und]/&4 #bjjjjjjjj #cadae #cgii #fffffffg #bhag #bffffffg #acfc #aadbhega #ffa #ejgicfe #cba #bcjhhjb #aef #ajfefja #gf #digbha #cg #bcdjad #ah #aajhdi #i #ebghe #e #bebde #b #abaah #a #ehcd -------- -------- ------- #cadaecgii #cadae #ibfe #bab #a4 ,take any diamet]1 d\ble x1 take #a-c;d ( t d\ble1 #b-e?s ( ! la/1 #c-g?s ( ! la/1 #d-i?s ( ! la/1 #e-aa?s ( ! la/1 & s on4 ,! sum ( all is ! circumf]5ce ( t diamet]4 ,! prec$+ is ! process :5 ! diamet] is a hundr$ millions3 ! errors aris+ f rejection ( fractions be+ less5$ by proce$+ on a ?\s& millions1 & /rik+ (f "o figure4 ,"h #bjj etc4 is d\ble ( ! diamet]2 #fff etc4 is #a-crd ( #bjj etc42 #bff etc4 is #b-e?s ( #fff etc42 #aad etc4 is #c-g?s ( #bff etc42 #ejg etc4 is #d-i?s ( #aad etc42 & s on4 #b4 ,to ! squ>e root ( #c add its half4 ,take half ! ?ird "p ( ?is2 half #b-e?s ( ! la/2 half #c-g?s ( ! la/2 & s on4 ,! sum is ! circumf]5ce to a unit ( diamet]4 ,squ>e root ( #c4444 #a4gcbjejha 4#hffjbedj ------------ #b4eihjgfba 4#dccjabgj 4#jhffjbed #aheegfh #dabcic #icgbf #bafbi #ejdg #aahh #bha #fg #af #d #a ------------ #c4adaeibfe #c4 ,take ! squ>e root ( #a_/b2 ! squ>e root ( half ( "o m ?an ?is2 ! squ>e root ( half ( "o m #bac ?an ! la/2 & s on1 until we come z ne> to unity z ! numb] ( figures *os5 w p]mit4 ,multiply all ! results toge!r1 & divide #b by ! product3 ! quoti5t is an approximation to ! circumf]5ce :5 ! diamet] is unity4 ,tak+ aim at f\r figures1 t is1 work+ to five figures to secure accuracy 9 ! f\r?1 we h 4#gjgab = ! squ>e root ( #a_/b2 4#ibcij = ! squ>e root ( half "o m ?an 4#gjgab2 & s on1 ?r\gh 4#ihjhj1 4#iiebj1 4#iihhj1 4#iiigj1 4#iiiib1 4#iiiih4 ,! product ( ! eight results is 4#fcffg2 divide #b by ?is1 & ! quoti5t is #c4adac4441 ( :i* f\r figures are correct4 ,_h ! product be5 4#fcfcfc444 in/ead ( 4#fcffg4441 ! fam\s result ( ,ar*im$es1 #bb-g?s1 w\ld h be5 accurately true4 ,x is s+ul> t no cyclomet] ma9ta9s t ,ar*im$es hit x exactly4 ,a lit]>y j\rnal c\ld h>dly admit z mu* z ! prec$+1 if x /ood alone4 ,b 9 my pres5t und]tak+ x passes z ! halfp5nywor? ( bread to _m gallons ( sack4 ,_m m me?ods might be giv51 all end+ 9 ! same result1 let t result mean :at x may4 ,n[ s9ce doz5s ( me?ods1 to :i* doz5s m might be add$ at pleasure1 concur 9 giv+ "o & ! same result2 & s9ce ^! me?ods are decl>$ by all :o h %[n k ( ma!matics to be demon/rat$3 x is n ask+ too mu* ( a p]son :o has j a little k ( ! fir/ elem5ts t he %\ld le>n m1 & put 8 h& ^u ! error1 be=e he intrudes 8 ass]tion ( ! exi/5ce ( error ^u ^? :o h giv5 m "t & att5tion to x ?an himself1 & :o are 9 possession1 ov] & above _m demon/rations1 ( _m consequ5ces v]ify+ ea* o!r1 ( :i* he c "k no?+4 ,?is is all t is requir$4 ,let any "o squ>e ! circle1 & p]suade 8 fri5ds1 if he & !y please3 let him pr9t1 & let all read :o *oose4 ,b let him ab/a9 f intrud+ himself ^u ^? :o h be5 satisfi$ by exi/+ demon/ration1 until he is prep>$ #bad to lay 8 f+] on ! po9t 9 :i* exi/+ demon/ration is wrong4 ,let him also say :at ?is my/]i\s #c4adaei444 really is1 :i* comes 9 at e door & w9d[1 & d[n e *imney1 call+ itself ! circumf]5ce to a unit ( diamet]4 ,?is mo/ impud5t & successful impo/or holds false title-de$s 9 8 h&s1 & invites exam9ation3 surely ^? :o c f9d out ! rightful own] are equally able to detect ! =g]y4 ,all ! quadrators are agre$ t1 be ! "r :at x may1 #c4adaei444 is wrong4 ,x w\ld be well if !y w\ld put _! heads toge!r1 & say :at ?is wrong result really means4 ,! ma!maticians ( all ages h tri$ all mann] ( processes1 ) "o object 9 view1 & by me?ods :i* are admitt$ to yield demon/ration 9 c\ntless cases4 ,!y h all arriv$ at "o result4 ,a l>ge numb] ( oppon5ts unite 9 decl>+ ?is result wrong1 & all agree 9 two po9ts3 fir/1 9 diff]+ among !mselves2 secondly1 9 decl9+ to po9t out :at t curi\s result really is :i* ! ma!matical me?ods all agree 9 giv+4 ,mo/ ( ! quadrators are n aw>e t x has be5 fully demon/rat$ t no two numb]s :atsoev] c repres5t ! ratio ( ! diamet] to ! circumf]5ce ) p]fect accuracy4 ,:5 !re=e we are told t ei!r #h to #be or #fd to #bja is ! true ratio1 we "k t x is no su* ?+1 )\t ! necessity ( exam9ation4 ,! po9t t is left op51 z n fully demon/rat$ to be impossible1 is ! geometrical quadrature1 ! det]m9ation ( ! circumf]5ce by ! /raight l9e & circle1 us$ z 9 ,euclid4 ,! g5]al run ( circle-squ>]s1 he>+ t ! quadrature is n pron\nc$ to be demon/ratively impossible1 imag9e t ! ari?metical quadrature is op5 to _! +5uity4 ,be=e attempt+ ! ari?metical problem1 !y ought to acquire k en\gh to read ,lamb]t's#cee demon/ration 7la/ giv5 9 ,brew/]'s#cef translation #bae ( ,leg5dre's#ceg ,geometry7 &1 if !y c1 to refute x4 ,x w be giv5 9 an ,app5dix4 ,probably "s h begun ?is way1 & h caught a ,t>t> :o has refus$ to let !m g3 ,i h nev] he>d ( any "o :o1 9 produc+ 8 own demon/ration1 has laid 8 f+] on ! faulty "p ( ,lamb]t's inve/igation4 ,?is is ! answ] to ^? :o ?9k t ! ma!maticians treat ! ari?metical squ>]s too lightly1 & t z "s p]son may succe$ at la/1 all attempts %\ld be exam9$4 ,^? :o h s ?\ght1 n kn[+ t !re is demon/ration on ! po9t1 w probably admit t a p]son :o contradicts a !orem ( :i* ! demon/ration has be5 ackn[l$g$ = a c5tury by all :o h allud$ to x z read by !mselves1 may reasonably be requir$ to po9t out ! error be=e he dem&s att5tion to 8 own result4 ,apopempsis ( ! ,tutel>ies4--,aga9 & aga9 ,i am told t ,i sp5d too mu* "t & tr\ble ^u my two tutel>ies3 b :5 ,i come to my summ+-up ,i %all make x appe> t ,i h a purpose4 ,"s say ,i am too h>d ^u !m3 b ?is is q a mi/ake4 ,bo? ( !m beat little ,oliv] himself 9 ! art & sci5ce ( ask+ = m2 b )\t ,oliv]'s excuse1 = ,i _h giv5 good all[ance4 ,bo? began ) me1 n ,i ) !m3 & bo? knew :at !y _h to expect :5 !y appli$ = a second help+4 ,on ,july #ca1 ! ,monday aft] ! publication ( my rem>ks on my #fff correspond5t1 ,i f\nd ?ree notes 9 sep>ate envelopes1 address$ to me at #g;,a1 ,univ]sity ,college4 ,:5 ,i saw ! ?ree new digits ,i 0 tak5 rhy?mopoetic1 z foll[s-- ,"h's ! ,doctor aga9 ) 8 figs1 & by ,heav5s6 ,he 0 always at sixes1 & n[ he's at sev5s4 ,to und]/& ?is fully ! read] mu/ "k t ! great] "p ( ,apocalyptic int]pretation has long be5 cond5s$1 9 my m9d1 into ! ,turki% /reet-cry--,9 ! #baf "n ( ! ,prophet6 figs6 ,i make a few extracts4 ,! read] w obs]ve t ,dr4 ,?orn grumbles at 8 private lett]s be+ publicly ridicul$4 ,a man 0 summon$ = a glutolactic assault2 he compla9$ ( ! publication ( 8 proce$+3 ,i kick$ etc4 9 confid5ce1 he said4 ,aft] read+ y\r la/1 :i* tries 9 e way to hold me up to public ridicule = d>+ to write y privately 't y w\ld be d----d1' omitt$ by accid5t "o w\ld say1 ,:y h any?+ to d ) su* a te/y p]son8 ,wrong ^w2 no te/y p]son c manage cool & consecutive ridicule4 ,qua]e1 :at is ?is ^w8 ,is x any?+ b a corruption ( ! obsolete ^w tet*y ( ! same mean+8 ,"s ?9k t\*y is our mod]n =m ( tet*y1 :i* ,i greatly d\bt4 ,my answ] is1 ! poor man is lam5tably ignorant2 he is n only s1 b 'out ( ! way' q true2 my read]s "k me by ?is "t = an out-(-!-way p]son4 ,:at o!r c\ld tackle my squad ( p>adox]s8 ,:at o!r w\ld und]take ! job8 ,c he be br\ght back & =m "o ( ^? :o 9 ,ezekiel #cg *4 h ! ,_s brea!d into !m & live4444 ,h ,i any o!r feel+ t[>ds y except t ( peace & goodwill8 ,n to y\r di/9ct k2 b 9 all ^? :o s5d p to '! o!r place' = contempt ( _! int]pretations1 !re is a lurk+ wi% :i* is fa!r to ! ?\ght2 'y w be d----d' & 'y be d--d' are ,siamese tw9s4 ,( c\rse y\r sne] at #fff br\ght pla9 words2 b :5 m5 m$dle ) :at !y d n und]/& 7n hav+ ! d\ble ,vahu7 !y mu/ be dealt ) fai?fully by ^? :o d4444 ,!y mu/2 :i* ju/ifies ! ,budget ( ,p>adoxes3 b no occasion to s5d !m any:]e2 no prea*ee & floggee too1 z ! negro said4 ,_m w f9d ! text ,prov4 i4 #bf fully realiz$4 ,all ?is conta9s di/9ct assumption ( a "r '( c\rse' to decl>e accurs$ ^? :o d n respect ! writ]'s vag>y4444 ,if ,i c\ld b get ! ,hebrew3 ,a1 ! ,ox-head1 :i* 9 ,old ,hebrew 0 j ! ,lat9 ,digamma1 ,f1 out #bag ( y\r "n1 & c\ld !n ,?au y ) ! ,?au ( ,ezekiel ix1 #d1 ! *i1 !n y w\ld be> ! numb] ( a man6 ,b ?is is too h>d = me1 al?\gh n s = ! ,"l6 ,j]4 xxxii4 #ag4444 ,& n[ a ^w3 is ridicule ! "r ?+ 9 s solemn a matt] z ! discussion ( ,holy ,writ8 ,is food = ridicule ! "r ?+8 ,did ,i discuss ,holy ,writ8 ,i did n3 ,i concuss$ pr(ane scribble4 ,ev5 ! ,doctor did n discuss2 he only enunciat$ & d5unciat$ out ( ! mass ( inf]5ces :i* a my/ical head has f\nd premises = 9 ! ,bible4 ,m #dj ,o #gj ,r #ajj ,g #f ,n #ej ---- #bff ,hebrew3 t*i #djj ,t ill op9ions are ne> relations ( ill wi%es1 w be detect$ by ^? :o are on ! look out4 ,! foll[+ 0 tak5 d[n 9 a ,scot* ,*ur* by ,mr4 ,cobd51#ceh :o h&$ x to a ,roman fri5d ( m9e1 = 8 delectation 79 #ahee73 ,"l1 we ?ank !e t ?\ ha/ br\ght ! ,pope into tr\ble2 & we pray t ?\ w\ld/ be m]cifully pleas$ to increase ! same4 ,"h is a m>tyr :o qu>rels ) 8 cr[n2 a mission>y :o reviles 8 p]secutor3 s5d him to ,new ,zeal&1 & he w\ld disagree ) ! ,maoris :o ate him4 ,man ( unilat]al reciprocity6 h y1 :o write to a /rang] ) h9ts t t /rang] & 8 wife are *ildr5 ( p]dition1 ! bad ta/e to compla9 ( a fac] 9 return8 ,z ,james ,smi?#cei--! ,attorney-wit1 n ! ,dock-cyclomet]--said1 or ne>ly said1 ,a pretty ?+1 =soo?6 ,is he to burn1 all scald+ hot1 ,me & my wife1 & am ,i n ,to job him out a too?8 #bah ,^? :o ?9k p>ody vulg> w be pleas$ to sub/itute = ! above a quotation f ,butl]#cfj3-- ,!re's no?+ s absurd or va9 ,or b>b>\s or inhumane1 ,b if x lay ! lea/ pret5ce ,to piety & godl9ess1 ,or t5d]-he>t$ consci5ce1 ,& zeal = gospel tru?s pr(ess1-- ,does sacr$ in/antly comm5ce1 ,& all t d>e b "q x are /raight ,pron\nc$ ?' uncircumcis$ & reprobate1 ,z malefactors t escape & fly ,into a sanctu>y = def5ce1 ,mu/ n be br\ght to ju/ice !nce1 ,al?\gh _! crimes be ne'er s great & high4 ,& he t d>es presume to d't ,is s5t5c$ & deliv]$ up ,to ,satan t engag$ him to't4 ,,! ,,numb] ,,( ,,! ,,bea/4 ,( all ! droll]ies ( controv]sy none is m amus+ ?an ! mann] 9 :i* ^? :o provoke a combat expect to lay d[n ! laws ( retaliation4 ,y mu/ n /rike ?is way6 y mu/ n p>ry t way6 ,if y don't take c>e1 we %all nev] m$dle ) y aga96 ,we 7 n prep>$ = su* z ?is6 ,:y did we h any?+ to d ) su* a te/y p]son8 ,m4 ,j\rda9 mu/ ne$s %[ ,nicole1 8 s]vant-maid1 h[ good a ?+ x 0 to be sure ( fight+ )\t be+ kill$1 by c>e & ti]ce4#cfa ,et cela n'e/ il pas beau d'etre assure de son fait qu& on se bat contre quelqu'un8 ,la1 p\sse moi un peu1 p\r voir4 ,,nicole4 ,eh bi56 quoi8 ,m4 ,,j\rda94 ,t\t beau4 ,hola6 #bai ,ho6 d\cem5t4 ,diantre soit la coqu9e6 ,,nicole4 ,v\s me dites de p\ss]4 ,m4 ,,j\rda94 ,oui2 mais tu me p\sses en ti]ce1 avant que de p\ss] en qu>te1 et tu n'z pas la pati5ce que je p>e4 ,8 colleague1 my secul> tutel>y1 :o also made an ana*roni/ic onset1 ) 8 rep>tees & 8 retorts1 be=e !re 0 any?+ to fire at1 takes :at ,i give by way ( subsequ5t provocation ) a good humor :i* w\ld make a conv]t ( me if he c\ld af=d 4#jafeibfe 444 ( a gra9 ( logic4 ,he in/antly s5t me 8 photograph = ! ask+1 & ano!r lett] 9 pro(4 ,! ,?or-hamm]] does no?+ b grumble1 except :5 he tells a good /ory1 :i* he says he _h f ,dr4 ,ab]ne?y4#cfb ,a ,mr4 ,james ,dunlop 0 popp+ at ! ,papi/s ) a #fff-rifl$ gun1 :5 ,dr4 ,*alm]s#cfc quietly said1 ,:y1 ,dunlop1 y be> x y\rself1 & h&$ him a pap] on :i* ! num]als 9 ,i ,a ,c ,o ,b ,v ,s ,d ,v ,n ,l ,o ,p ,v ,s #a #ajj #e #ejj #e #ej #e 7 add$ up4 ,?is is almo/ z good z ! ,filii ,dei ,vic>ius1 ! num]ical lett]s ( :i* also make #fff4 ,no m ( ^! crazy--,i fir/ wrote pu]ile1 b :y %\ld "y cricket]s be libell$8--attempts to extract religi\s use f num]ical vag>ies1 & to make ,god ov] all a propos] ( salvation conundrums3 & no m ( ! trump]y h9ts ab\t future de/9y :i* is too great a complim5t to call blasphem\s4 ,if ! ,doctor w ciph] ^u ! lett] 9 ,greek3 en hoi metroi metreite metre!setai hum9#cfd ) d\ble ,vahu cubic measure1 he w p]haps le>n to leave (f try+ to fright5 me into ga!r+ grapes f ?orns4 ,my/ical h]m5eutics may be put to good use by out-(-!-way p4 ,!y may be made to call ! att5tion #bbj ( ! _m to a di/9ction well kn[n among ! le>n$4 ,! books ( ! ,new ,te/am5t h be5 = #a1ejj ye>s divid$ into two classes3 ! ackn[l$g$ 7,greek3 homolog\m5a71 :i* x has always be5 p>adox n to receive2 & ! controv]t$ 7,greek3 antilegom5a71 ab\t :i* !re has always be5 t diff]5ce ( op9ion :i* no s*ol> ov]looks1 h[ev] he may decide = himself aft] balance ( evid5ce4 ,eusebius1#cfe :o fir/ 7l4 #c1 c4 #be7 record$ ! di/9ction--:i* 0 mu* insi/$ on by ! e>ly ,prote/ants--/ates ! books :i* are que/ion$ z d\btful1 b :i* yet are approv$ & ackn[l$g$ by _m--or ! _m1 x is n easy to say :i* he means--to be ! ,epi/les ( ,james & ,jude1 ! second ( ,pet] & ! second & ?ird ( ,john4 ,9 o!r places he speaks d\bt+ly ( ! ,epi/le to ! ,hebrews4 ,! ,apocalypse he does n ev5 admit into ?is class1 = he proce$s z foll[s--,i use ! second edition ( ! ,engli% folio translation 7#agji71 to av]t suspicion ( bias f myself3-- ,among ! spuri\s ,greek3 no?oi let !re be rank$ bo? ! "w entitl$ ! ,acts ( ,paul1 & ! book call$ ,pa/or1 & ! ,revelation ( ,pet]3 & moreov]1 t :i* is call$ ! ,epi/le ( ,b>nabas1 & t nam$ ! ,doctr9es ( ! ,apo/les3 & moreov]1 z ,i said1 ! ,revelation ( ,john 7if y ?9k good71 :i* "s1 z ,i h said1 d reject1 b o!rs all[ (1 & admit among ^? books :i* are receiv$ z unque/ionable & und\bt$4 ,eusebius1 ?\gh he w n admit ! ,apocalypse ev5 into ! controv]t$ li/1 b gives p]mission to call x spuri\s1 yet qualifies 8 p]mission 9 a mann] :i* almo/ annihilates ! di/9ctive =ce ( ,greek3 no?os1 & gives ! book a claim to rank 7if y ?9k good1 aga97 9 ! controv]t$ li/4 ,& ?is is ! impression receiv$ by #bba ! m9d ( ,l>dn]1 :o gives ,eusebius fully & fairly1 b :5 he sums up1 consid]s 8 au?or z admitt+ ! ,apocalypse into ! second li/4 ,a /ick may easily be f\nd to beat ! fa!r ( ecclesia/ical hi/ory4 ,!re are :ole faggots 9 writ]s z opposite z ,b>onius & ,gibbon1 :o are p]haps 8 two mo/ celebrat$ sons4 ,b we c h>dly imag9e him totally misrepres5t+ ! /ate ( op9ion ( ^? = :om & among :om he wrote4 ,! usual plan1 t ( mak+ an au?or take ! views ( 8 read]s1 is m easy 9 8 case ?an 9 t ( any o!r writ]3 =1 z ! riddle says1 he is ,y-see-by-u2 & to ?is read+ ( 8 "n he has (t5 be5 subject$4 ,dr4 ,na?aniel ,l>dn]1#cff :o1 ?\gh het]odox 9 doctr9e1 tries h>d to be or?odox z to ! ,canon1 is sometimes apt to ?9k t ! li/ %\ld be collect$ & divid$ z 9 ,eusebius4 ,he w\ld h no "o ( ! controv]t$ books to be all[$1 by itself1 to e/abli% any doctr9e4 ,ev5 )\t go+ s f>1 a due use ( e>ly op9ion & long cont9u$ discussion w\ld p]haps prev5t rational p f be+ induc$ by ^? :o h ! d\ble ,vahu to place ! ,apocalypse above ! ,gospels1 :i* all ! ,bivahuites d 9 effect1 & "s are said to h done 9 express words4 ,b my especial purpose is to po9t out t an easy way ( gett+ rid ( #ffe out ( #fff ( ! my/ics is to require !m to e/abli% ! ,apocalypse be=e !y beg94 ,see if !y ev5 "k s mu* z t !re is a cr[d ( te/imonies = & aga9/1 runn+ ?r\gh ! fir/ f\r c5turies1 :i* makes ?is book ! mo/ difficult ( ! :ole ,canon4 ,try ?is me?od1 & y w escape beautiful1 z ! ,fr5* say4 ,dean ,al=d1#cfg 9 ,vol4 ,,iv1 p4 #h1 ( 8 ,new ,te/am5t1 gives an elaborate h&l+ ( ?is "q4 ,he concludes by say+ t he _c #bbb v5ture to refuse 8 cons5t to ! tradition t ! ,apo/le is ! au?or4 ,?is modifi$ adh]5ce1 or non-nonadh]5ce1 pretty well repres5ts ! feel+ ( or?odox ,prote/ants1 :5 le>n+ & common s5se come toge!r4 ,i h (t51 9 =m] days1 _h ! attempt made to place ! ,apocalypse on my neck z conta9+ prophecies yet unfulfill$4 ,! prec$+ me?od prev5ts success2 & s does ! foll[+4 ,x may almo/ be tak5 = grant$ t !ological sy/em-fight]s d n read ! ,new ,te/am5t3 !y hunt x = deta*$ texts2 !y li/5 to x 9 *ur* 9 t /ate ( quiesc5t non5tity :i* is call$ rev]5t att5tion3 b !y nev] read x4 ,:5 x is br\ght =w>d1 y mu/ pret5d to f9d x necess>y to turn to ! book itself3 y mu/ read ,! revelation 444 to %[ unto 8 s]vants ?+s :i* mu/ %ortly come to pass4444 ,bless$ is he t reade? 444 = ! "t is at h&4 ,y mu/ !n ask y\r my/ic :e!r ?+s def]r$ = #ahjj ye>s 7 %ortly to come to pass1 etc48 ,y mu/ tell him t ! ,greek ,greek3 en ta*ei1 r5d]$ %ortly1 is z /rong a phrase z ! language has to signify soon4 ,! int]pret] w probably look z if he _h nev] read ?is op5+3 ! *ances are t he takes up ! book to see :e!r y h be5 committ+ a fraud4 ,he w !n give y "s exquisite evasion3 ,i h he>d x plead$ t ! above 0 a m]e preamble4 ,?is ^w m]e is all-suffici5t3 x turns any?+ into no?+4 ,p]haps he w say t ! argum5t is t ( ! ,papi/s3 if s1 tell him t !re is no ,*ri/ian sect b be>s true witness aga9/ "s "o or m absurdities 9 o!r sects4 ,an anonyme sugge/s t ,greek3 en ta*ei may n be soon1 x may be quickly1 )\t ref]5ce to "t :53 he cont9ues ?us1 ,may n "t be 'at h&' :5 x is ready to come1 no matt] h[ long delay$8 ,i n[ und]/& :at 999999 & 999999 meant :5 !y borr[$ my books & promis$ to return !m quickly1 x 0 )\t #bbc ref]5ce to "t :54 ,z to "t at h&--provid$ y make a long arm--,i admire ! quirk1 b _c receive x3 ! ^w is ,greek3 engus1 :i* is a ^w ( clos5ess 9 "t1 9 place1 9 reckon+1 9 k9dr$1 etc4 ,ano!r g5tleman is n surpris$ t ,apocalyptic read+ leads to a d\bt ( ! canonicity ( ! book3 x ought n to re/ on *ur* te/imony1 b on visible miracle4 ,he (f]s me1 or any read] ( ! ,a!naeum1 ! sight ( a miracle to t effect1 & )9 =ty-eight h\rs' j\rney 7f>e paid74 ,i seldom travel1 & my fir/ ?\ght 0 :e!r my c>pet-bag w\ld be f\nd )\t a regul> hunt3 b1 on read+ fur!r1 ,i f\nd t x 0 only a concordance t w\ld be want$4 ,=ty h\rs' collection & num]ical calculation ( ,greek n\ns w\ld make x--%\ld ,i happ5 to agree ) ! writ]--_m hundr$ millions to "o t ,revelation xiii is sup]human4 ,!re is b "o v]se 7! fif?7 :i* ! writ] does n see v]ifi$4 ,i look$ at ?is v]se1 & 0 mu* />tl$4 ,! ,budget began 9 ,octob] #ahfc3 %\ld x la/ until ,m>* #ahfg--;x is n[ ,augu/ #ahff--;x is cle> t ,i am ! fir/ ,bea/1 & my p>adox]s are ! sa9ts :om ,i p]secute4 ,! ,budget did t]m9ate 9 ,m>* #ahfg3 ,i hope ! g5tleman w be satisfi$ ) ! result+ int]pretation4 ,! same oppon5t is surpris$ t ,i %\ld suppose a ?+ :i* comes to pass mu/ be complet$1 & _c conta9 :at is to happ5 #ahjj ye>s aft]4 ,all :o h any k ( ,engli% idiom "k t a ?+ comes to pass :5 x happ5s1 & came to pass aft]w>ds4 ,b z ! orig9al is ,greek1 we mu/ look at ! ,greek3 x is ,greek3 dei g5e/hai = mu/ come to pass1 & we "k t ,greek3 eg5eto is :at is usually translat$ came to pass4 ,no ^w ( m f9i%$ completion exi/s 9 ,greek4 ,& n[ = a la/ r\nd ( bit]-bit ) ! ,?or-hamm]]1 ( :om1 z 9 ! o!r case1 ,i %all take no #bbd m notice until he c contrive to surpass himself1 :i* ,i d\bt 8 be+ able to d4 ,he in=ms me t by *ang+ ,a into ,hebrew3 t 9 my "n he c make a #fff ( me2 add+1 ,?is is too h>d = me1 al?\gh n s = ! ,"l6 ,%e] nons5se6 ,he c\ld j z easily h direct$ to ,pr(4 ,de ,morg,hebrew3 tn z h assign$ me ap>tm5t #g;,a 9 ,univ]sity ,college4 ,x w\ld h be5 se5 = :om x 0 int5d$3 & if n1 x w\ld /ill h rea*$ me1 = my colleagues h = _m a ye> h&$ all out-(-!-way ?+s ov] to me4 ,!re is no #g;,a3 b #g is ! ,museum ( ,mat]ia ,m$ica4 ,i took ! only h9t :i* ! address gave3 ,i inquir$ = hellebore1 b !y told me x 0 n n[ recogniz$1 t ! old notion ( its value 0 q obsolete1 & t !y _h no?+ :i* 0 consid]$ a specific 9 s5>y or sept5>y cases4 ,! great platitude is ! ref]5ce ( su* a difficulty z writ+ ,hebrew3 t = ,a to ! ,almighty6 ,n *ildi%1 b fatu\s3 real *ildi%ness is delightful4 ,i knew an infant to :om1 be=e he c\ld speak pla91 8 p>5ts _h attempt$ to give notions ( ! ,div9e attributes3 a wise plan1 _m ?9k4 ,8 fa!r _h d&l$ him up-side-d[n1 end+ )1 ,!re n[6 ,papa c\ld n dance on 8 head6 ,! mannik9 made a solemn face1 & said1 ,b ,dod tood6 ,i ?9k ! ,doctor has r mi/ak5 ! way ( becom+ z a little *ild1 int5d$ 9 ,matt4 xviii4 #c3 let u hope ! w may be tak5 = ! de$4 ,two poets h giv5 images ( transition f infancy to manhood3 ,dryd51--= ! ,h9d is ,dryd5 himself on all f\rs6 & ,wordswor?1 9 8 own "* ( broad-nail$1 fea!rless bip$3 ,! prie/ cont9ues :at ! nurse began1 ,& ?us ! *ild imposes on ! man4 ,! *ild's ! fa!r ( ! man1 ,& ,i c\ld wi% my days to be ,b\nd ea* to ea* by natural piety4 #bbe ,9 ,wordswor?'s aspiration x is meant t s5se & piety %\ld gr[ toge!r3 9 ,dryd5's description a comb9ation ( ,my/icism ,& ,bigotry 7c ?is be ! d\ble ,vahu871 p]sonifi$ z ! prie/1--:o always cat*es x on ?is score1 ?\gh ! same _s is f\nd 9 all associations1--succe$s ! boguey-tea*+ ( ! nurse4 ,nev] 0 ! contra/ ( smile & sc[l1 ( light & d>kness1 bett] se5 ?an 9 ! two pictures4 ,b an acro/ic di/9ction may be drawn4 ,:5 my/icism pr$om9ates ov] bigotry1 we h ! grotesque picturesque1 & ! natural ord] ( words gives u ,mab1 an appropriate sugge/ion4 ,b :5 bigotry has ! upp] h&1 we see ,bam1 :i* is j z appropriate2 = bigotry ne>ly always deals ) facts & logic s z to require ! application ( at lea/ "o ( ! m9or words by :i* di%one/y is signifi$4 ,i ?9k t ,m is ! ,doctor's initial1 & t ,que5 ,mab tickles him 9 8 sleep ) ! %>p end ( a #f4 7,monday1 ,augu/ #ba47 ,?ree weeks hav+ elaps$ )\t notice f me ( ! ,doctor1 ,i receive a rem9d] ( 8 exi/5ce1 9 :i* ,i f9d t z ,i am ! ,daniel :o judges ! ,magi ( ,babylon1 x is to be po9t$ out t ,daniel bore a c]ta9 numb]1 t ( a man 7belov$71 ,daniel1 *4 #aj4 v4 #aa1 & :i* y c]ta9ly d n4 ,!n1 by ,greek p[]1 ,belte%azz> is made #fff4 ,"h is ano!r awkw>d imitation ( ! way ( a baby *ild4 ,:5 y h sport$ ) ! t9y creature until x runs away (f5d$1 by ! "t y h got into conv]sation aga9 y w f9d ! game is to be r5ew$3 a little head peeps out f a hid+-place ) ,i don't love y4 ,! prop] rejo9d] is1 ,v well6 !n ,i'll h pussy4 ,b 9 ! case be=e me !re is a rule ( ?ree sums to d2 z baby 3 ,pussy ,dr4 33 #fff 3 ! answ] requir$4 ,i w "w x out1 if ,i c4 ,! squ>+ ( ! circle & ! discov]y ( ! ,bea/ are ! two goals--& goals also--( _m unbalanc$ intellects1 & ( a few in/ances ( ! bett] k9d4 #bbf ,i might h said m ( #fff1 b ,i am n deep 9 its bibliography4 ,a "w has come into my h&s :i* conta9s a l>ge numb] ( not$ cases3 to "s ( my read]s x w be a treat to see ! collection2 & ! sight w p]haps be ( "s use to ^? :o h read controv]sy on ! few celebrat$ cases :i* are ( g5]al notoriety4 ,x is writt5 by a le>n$ deciph]]1 a man :o really knew ! hi/ory ( ! subject1 ! ,rev4 ,david ,?om1#cfh ( ,bold ,/reet ,*apel1 ,liv]pool1 :o di$1 ,i am told1 a few ye>s ago4 ,anybody :o reads 8 book w be incl9$ to p>ody a criticism :i* 0 once made on ,paley's#cfi ,evid5ces--,well6 if !re be any?+ 9 ,*ri/ianity1 ?is man is no fool4 ,&1 if he %\ld *ance to rememb] x1 he w be /rongly rem9d$ ( a s5t5ce 9 my op5+ *apt]1--,! mann] 9 :i* a p>adox] w %[ himself1 z to s5se or nons5se1 w n dep5d ^u :at he ma9ta9s1 b ^u :e!r he has or has n made a suffici5t k ( :at has be5 done by o!rs1 especially z to ! mode ( do+ x1 a prelim9>y to inv5t+ k = himself4 ,& ?is is re9=c$ by ! fact t ,mr4 ,?om1 ?\gh a s*ol>1 0 n conspicu\s = le>n+1 except 9 ?is 8 great pursuit4 ,he 0 a p>adox] on o!r po9ts4 ,he reconcil$ ,calv9ism & et]nal reprobation ) ,univ]salism & f9al salvation2 %[+ ^! two doctr9es to be all "o4 ,?is g5tleman mu/ n be conf\nd$ ) ! ,rev4 ,john ,hamilton ,?om#cgj 7no relation71 at or ne> ! same #bbg "t & until rec5tly1 ( ,r5%aw ,/reet ,*apel1 ,liv]pool :o 0 "o ( ! m9ority 9 ! ,liv]pool controv]sy :51 ne>ly ?irty ye>s ago1 ?ree h]etical ,unit>ian s*oon]s ex*ang$ %ott$ s]mons ) ?irte5 ,or?odox %ips ( ! l9e1 & put up _! *all5g]s' d&]--an ,am]ican corruption ( d--d ang]--to su* an ext5t1 by quiet & respectful argum5t1 t ^? oppon5ts actually address$ a pr9t$ int]cession to ! ,almighty = ! ,unit>ian triad1 z = ,jews1 ,turks1 ,infidels1 & ,h]etics4 ,s mu* = ! di/9ction1 :i* bo? g5tlem5 w\ld ?ank me = mak+ v cle>3 ,i take x q = grant$ t a guess] at #fff w\ld feel horrifi$ at be+ tak5 = a ,unit>ian1 & t a ,unit>ian w\ld feel que]ifi$ at be+ tak5 = a guess] at #fff4 ,mr4 ,david ,?om's book is ,! ,numb] & ,names ( ! ,apocalyptic ,bea/s1 ,"p ,i1 #ahdh1 #hvo43 ,i ?9k ! second "p 0 nev] publi%$4 ,i give ! ,greek & ,lat9 solutions1 omitt+ ! ,hebrew3 z usual1 all ! ,greek lett]s are num]al1 b only ,m ,d ,c ,l ,x ,v ,i ( ! ,lat94 ,i d n give ei!r ! deciph]]s or _! reasons3 ,i h n room = ?is2 nor w\ld ,i1 if ,i c\ld1 bias my read] = "o r ?an ano!r4 ,d4 ,f4 ,julianus ,caes> ,a!us 7or ,aug4#cga72 ,diocles ,augu/us2 ,ludovicus2 ,silve/] ,secundus2 ,l9us ,secundus2 #bbh ,vic>ius ,filii ,dei2 ,doctor et ,rex ,lat9us2 ,paulo ,v4 ,vice-,deo2 ,vic>ius ,g5]alis ,dei 9 ,t]ris2 ,ipse ,ca?olicae ,ecclesiae ,visibile ,caput2 ,dux ,cl]i2 ,una1 ,v]a1 ,ca?olica1 ,infallibilis ,ecclesia2 ,auctoritas politica ecclesia/icaque ,papalis 7,lat9a w also d72 ,lu!rus ,ductor ,gregis2 ,calv9us tri/is fidei int]pres2 ,dic ,lux 2 ,ludvvic2 ,w4 ,laud2 ,greek3 ,late9os2#cgb ,greek3 he lat9e basileia2 ,greek3 ekklesia italika2 ,greek3 euan?as2 ,greek3 teitan2 ,greek3 arn\me2 ,greek3 lampetis2 ,greek3 ho niketes2 ,greek3 kakos hodegos2 ,greek3 ale!s blab]os2 ,greek3 palai baskanos2 ,greek3 amnos adikos2 ,greek3 antemos2 ,greek3 g5s]ikos2 ,greek3 eu9as2 ,greek3 ,b5$iktos2 ,greek3 ,bonibazios g4 papa x4 e4 e4 e4 a41 mean+ ,boniface ,,iii4 ,pope #fh?1 bi%op ( bi%ops ! fir/6 ,greek3 oulpios2 ,greek3 dios eimi he h]as2 ,greek3 he missa he papike2 ,greek3 l\!rana2 ,greek3 saxoneios2 ,greek3 ,bezza anti!os 7,beza72 ,greek3 he alazoneia bi\2 ,greek3 ,maometis2 ,greek3 ,maometes b42 ,greek3 !os eimi epi gaies2 ,greek3 iapetos2 ,greek3 papeiskos2 ,greek3 dioklasianos2 ,greek3 *e9a2 ,greek3 braski2 ,greek3 ,ion ,paune2 ,greek3 k\poks2 7c[pox1 ,greek3 s be+ ! vau2 c]ta9ly ! #bbi vacc9at$ h ! m>k ( ! ,bea/72 ,greek3 ,bonnep>te2 ,greek3 ,n4 ,bonep>te2 ,greek3 euporia2 ,greek3 p>adosis2 ,greek3 to mega!rion4 ,all sects fa/5 ?is numb] on _! oppon5ts4 ,x is f\nd 9 ,m>t9 ,laut]1 affirm$ to be ! true way ( writ+ ! "n1 by c>ry+ numb]s ?r\gh ! ,roman ,alphabet4 ,"s ,jews1 accord+ to ,mr4 ,?orn1 f\nd x 9 ,hebrew3 ,,j%w ,,ntsrj ,jesus ( ,naz>e?4 ,i f9d on inquiry t ?is satire 0 actually put =? by "s m$ieval rabbis1 b t x is n idiomatic3 x repres5ts q fairly ,jesus ,naz>5e1 b ! ,hebrew wants an article q z mu* z ! ,engli% wants !4 ,mr4 ,david ,?om's own solution hits h>d at all sides3 he f9ds a #fff = bo? bea/s2 ,greek3 he phr5 7! m9d7 = ! fir/1 & ,greek3 ekklesiai s>kikai 7fle%ly *ur*es7 = ! second4 ,a solution :i* embodies all m5tal philosophy 9 "o bea/ & all dogmatic !ology 9 ! o!r1 is v tempt+3 = 9 ^! are ! two great supports ( ,anti*ri/4 ,x w n1 h[ev]1 mislead me1 :o h kn[n ! true explanation a long "t4 ,! ?ree sixes indicate t any two ( ! ?ree subdivisions1 ,roman1 ,greek1 & ,prote/ant1 are1 9 corruption ( ,*ri/ianity1 six ( "o & half a doz5 ( ! o!r3 ! di/9ctions ( units1 t5s1 hundr$s1 are no?+ b ! old way 7#a ,samuel xviii4 #g1 & ,concordance at t51 hundr$1 ?\s&7 ( symboliz+ diff]5ces ( numb] 9 ! subdivisions4 ,x may be good to "k t1 ev5 9 speculations on #fff1 !re are diff]5t degrees ( unreason4 ,all ! div9]s1 :5 !y get a colleague or an oppon5t1 at once proce$ to reckon him up3 b "s d x 9 play & "s 9 e>ne/4 ,mr4 ,david ,?om f\nd a "y g5tleman ( ! "n ,/4 ,claire busy at ! ,bea/ numb]3 he =?) add$ ! lett]s 9 ,greek3 / klaire & f\nd #fff3 ?is 0 good fun4 ,b my spiritual tutel>y1 :5 he f\nd t he c\ld n make a bea/ ( me1 except by *ang+ ,hebrew3 ,a into ,hebrew3 ,t1 solemnly ref]r$ ! difficulty to ! ,almighty3 ?is 0 poor e>ne/4 #bcj ,i am glad ,i did n notice1 9 "t to ins]t x 9 ! ,a!naeum1 a v rem>kable p>adox] br\ght =w>d by ,mr4 ,?om1 8 fri5d ,mr4 ,wap%>e#cgc3 x is a little too /rong = ! g5]al public4 ,9 ! ,a!naeum !y w\ld h se5 & read x3 b ?is book w be avoid$ by ! weak] bre?r54 ,x is z foll[s3 ,god1 ! ,elohim1 0 six days 9 creat+ all ?+s1 & hav+ made ,,man he ent]$ into 8 re/4 ,he is no m se5 z a ,creator1 z ,elohim1 b z ,jehovah1 ! ,"l ( ! ,sabba?1 & ! ,_s ( life 9 ,,man1 :i* ,_s worke? s9 9 ! fle%2 = ! ,_s ( ,love1 9 all fle%1 is ,lu/1 or ! _s ( a bea/1 ,s ,rom4 vii4 ,& :i* ,_s is crucifi$ 9 ! fle%4 ,he !n1 z ,jehovah--z ! p[] ( ! ,law1 9 & ov] all fle%1 ,john viii4 #dd--;increases t :i* he has made z ! ,elohim1 & 8 p[] %all la/ = #f days1 or #f p]iods ( "t1 comput$ at a mill5nium ( ye>s2 & at ! end ( :i* six days1 he :o is ! ,_s ( all fle% %all manife/ himself z ! ,holy ,_s ( ,almighty ,love1 & ( all tru?2 & s %all ! ,*ur* h h] ,sabba? ( ,re/--all cont5tion be+ at an end4 ,?is is1 z well z ,i may n[ express x1 my solution ( ! my/]y 9 ,hebrew1 & 9 ,greek1 & also 9 ,lat91 ,,ihs4 ,= he t 0 lift$ up is ,k+ ( ! ,jews1 & is ! ,"l ( all ,life1 work+ 9 u1 bo? to w & to d2 z is manife/ 9 ! ,jews--!y slay+ him t 8 blood might be good = ! heal+ ( ! nations1 ( all p & tongues4 ,z ! ,fa!r ( all natural fle%1 he is ! ,_s ( ,lu/1 z 9 all bea/s2 z ! ,fa!r1 or ,k+ ( ! ,jews1 he is ! ,devil1 z he himself witnesse? 9 ,john viii41 already ref]r$ to4 ,z lift$ up1 he is trans=m$ into ! ,_s ( ,love1 a light to ! ,g5tiles1 & ! glory ( 8 p ,israel4444 ,= !re is b ,,"o ,god1 ,,"o ,"l1 ,,"o ,_s1 ,,"o body1 etc4 & he :o 0 ,satan1 ! ,_s ( life 9 t body1 is1 9 #bca ,*ri/ crucifi$1 se5 9 ! ,_s t is 9 all1 & ?r\gh all & ov] all1 ,god bless$ = ev]4 ,all ?is seems well meant1 & ,mr4 ,?om pr9ts x z conv9c$ ( its piety1 & pron\nces no op9ion4 ,my/ics ( all sorts6 see :at y may come to1 or :at may come to y6 ,i h ins]t$ ! above = y\r good4 ,!re is no?+ 9 ?is _w s /eady z "s ( ! p>adox]s4 ,!y are l ! spid]s :o g on sp9n+ aft] !y h web en\gh to cat* all ! flies 9 ! neighborhood1 if ! flies w\ld b come4 ,!y are l ! wild bees :o g on mak+ honey :i* !y nev] c eat1 prov+ sic vos non vobis to be a physical necessity ( _! own contriv+4 ,b nobody robs _! hives3 no1 unlike ! bees1 !y g ab\t (f]+ _! w>e to any :o w take x z a gift4 ,i _h j writt5 ! la/ s5t5ce 7,oct4 #cj1 #ahff1 #h4de ,a4,m47 :5 9 comes ! second note receiv$ ?is morn+ f ,dr4 ,?orn3 at #a4cj ,p4,m4 came 9 a ?ird4 ,^! arise out ( ! above acc\nt ( ! ,rev4 ,d4 ,?om1 publi%$ ,oct4 #bg3 ?ree notes _h arriv$ be=e4 ,= curiosity ,i give "o day's all[ance1 suppos+ ^! to be all3 m may arrive be=e night4 #bi? ,oct4 #ahff4 ,de> ,sir1-- ,9 re swa/ika4#cgd ,s t ',zaphna? ,paaneah' may be aft] all ! reveal] ( ! ',nor!rn ,tau' ,greek3 ,phan]oo--,to make manife/1 %ew1 or expla92 & ?is may satisfy ! ,h\se ( ,joseph 9 ,amos #e;c4 ,:ile ,belte%azz> #fff may be also satisfactory to ! ,h\se ( ,david1 & s we may h ,ze*4 #aj;c4 #fv4 9 op]ation :5 ,ezekiel #cg;c4 #afv4 has be5 realis$2--b !re1 :at is ! use ( writ+1 x is all ,coptic #bcb to a man :o has n swa/ika1 ,! ,?au ( ! ,nor?1 ! d\ble ,vahu ,hebrew3 ,wqamats,w4 ,look at ,j]emiah #c;c4 #hv4 & !n to ,psalm #hc = 'hidd5 ones' ,hebrew3 ,,ts%eva,,pwdage%,nsegol,y ,y%eva,,hwqamats,h--,! ,zephoni ,jehovah1 & say :e!r !y h any connection ) ! ,zephon ,?au4 ,! ,hamm] ( ,?or ( ,j]emiah #bc;c4 #biv4 z ,i gave y 9 ,no4 #c ( my pres5t edition4 ,y\rs truly ,,le ,,*evali] ,,au ,,c94 ,by ,greek ,p[]4 ,c #bj ,h #h ,e #e ,v #f ,a #a ,l #cj ,i #aj ,e #e ,r #ajj ,a #a ,u #djj ,c #bj ,i #aj ,n #ej ---- #fff ,!re w be ?\s&s ( ,morgans :o w be among ! wise & prud5t ( ,hosea #ad;c4 #iv4 :5 ! ,sev5? ,angel s\nds1 let me numb] t ,"o by ,greek1 ,rev4 #ag;c4 #av3 #bcc ,s #bjj ,e #e x ,v #f ,e #e ,n #ej ,t #cjj ,h #h ,a #a ,n #ej x ,g #f ,e #e ,l #cj ---- #fff ,v & ,g #ab ought to be equal to "o ,gammadion or #cswa/ika#c x #d #ab1 :at say y8 ,london1 ,octob] #bi1 #ahff4 ,de> ,sir1-- ,9 re swa/ika v]sus maltese cross4 ,h[ev] pret5ti\s ! ,x or maltese cross may be1 & x is peculi>ly s j n[ 9 ?is l&2 aft] all x is only made ( two ,roman ,v's--& s is only "o inv]t$7#aj7--;& !re=e is n ! p]fect numb] #ab ( ,reveln1 b is ! m>k ( ! goddess ,decima6 ,y\rs truly ,,wm4 ,,?orn4 ,_h ! "o :o s5t =? a pa/oral 7,romi%7 ! o!r day1 rema9$ among/ ! fai?ful expectants1 see h[ he w\ld h numb]$1 :]eas he sold himself = ! privilege ( sign+ maltese cross ,,h5ry ,e4 ,,mann+4#cge #bcd ,by ,engli% ,key4 ,h #h ,e #e ,n #dj ,r #hj ,y #adj ,e #e ,d #d ,w #abj ,a #a ,r #hj ,d #d ,m #cj ,a #a ,n #dj ,n #dj ,i #i ,n #dj ,g #g swa/ika #ab ---- #fff ,c y n[ und]/& ! diff]5ce betwe5 swa/ika & maltese cross or ,x8 ,look to my *all5ge4 ,cutt+ f newspap]3-- ,,italy4 ,rome 7via ,m>seilles71 ,octob] ,mr4 ,glad/one has paid a visit to ! ,pope4 ,by ,greek ,p[]4 ,g #f ,l #cj ,a #a ,d #d ,s #bjj ,t #cjj ,o #gj ,n #ej ,e #e ---- #fff ,& :at !n swa/ika8 #bce ,9 o!r lett]s ,john ,/u>t ,mill is #fff if ! a be left out2 ,*asuble is p]fect4 ,john ,brighte#cgf is a fait accompli2 & ,i am ask$ :e!r intellect c acc\nt = ! f9al e4 ,v easily3 ?is ,bea/ is n ! ,m4 ,p41 b ano!r p]son :o spells 8 "n diff]5tly4 ,b if ,john ,/urt ,mill & ,john ,brighte *oose s to write !mselves1 !y may4 ,a curi\s collection2 a my/ical phantasmagoria6 ,!re are ^? :o w try to f9d mean+3 !re are ^? :o w try to f9d purpose4 ,& "s !y said--,:at are y at8 ,& "s--,:at are y art]8 ,my acc\nt ( ,mr4 ,?om & 8 #fff appe>$ on ,octob] #bg3 & on ! #bi? ,i receiv$ f ! editor a copy ( ,mr4 ,?om's s]mons publi%$ 9 #ahfc 7he di$ ,feb4 #bg1 #ahfb7 ) be/ wi%es = my heal? & happ9ess4 ,! editor does n "n himself 9 ! book2 b he sign$ 8 "n 9 my copy3 & may my circumf]5ce nev] be m ?an #c-a_/h ( my diamet] if ! signature1 "n & writ+ bo?1 7 n t ( my circle squ>e + fri5d ,mr4 ,james ,smi?6 ,& s ,i h come 9 contact ) him on #fff z well z on pi6 ,i %\ld h no?+ left to live =1 _h ,i n happ5$ to he> t he has a p]petual motion on h&4 ,i return$ ?anks & k9d reg>ds3 & ,miss ,miggs's words--,"h's =giv5esses ( injuries6 "h's amicabl5esses6--rang 9 my e>s4 ,b ,i 0 made slightly uncom=table3 h[ c\ld ! w> g on aft] ?is armi/ice8 ,c\ld ,i ev] make x und]/ood t ! truce only ext5d$ to ! d\ble ,vahu & ?+s !reunto relat+8 ,x 0 once held by seaf>+ m5 t !re 0 no peace ) ,spani>ds beyond ! l9e3 ,i 0 det]m9$ t !re mu/ be no concord ) ,j4 ,s4 inside ! circle2 t ?is mu/ be a special exception1 l ,fa!r ,huddle/on #bcf & old ,gr\se 9 ! gun-room4 ,i 0 n long 9 anxiety2 tw5ty-f\r h\rs aft] ! book ( s]mons !re came a copy ( ! ?reat5$ exposure--,! ,briti% ,association 9 ,jeop>dy1 & ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan 9 ! ,pillory )\t hope ( escape4 ,by ,james ,smi?1 ,esq4 ,london & ,liv]pool1 #hvo41 #ahff 7pp4 #id74 ,?is exposure consi/s ( repr9ts f ! ,a!naeum & ,correspond5t3 ( ?+s new !re is b "o4 ,9 a %ort preface ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 p>ticul>ly recomm5ds to read to ! end4 ,at ! end is an app5dix ( two pages1 9 type z l>ge z ! "w2 a v prom95t p]oration4 ,x is an article f ! ,a!naeum1 left out ( its place4 ,9 ! la/ s5t5ce ,mr4 ,j4 ,smi?1 :o _h ask$ :e!r 8 "* z an hone/ ,geomet] & ,ma!matician 0 n at /ake1 is w>n$ aga9/ ! fallacia plurium int]rogationum4#cgg ,he is told t !re is n a m hone/ :at's-8-"n 9 ! _w3 b t z to ! c\nt] :i* he calls 8 "* z a ma!matician1 he is assur$ t x has be5 /ak$ ye>s ago1 & lo/4 ,& ?us tru? has ! la/ ^w4 ,!re is no occasion to say mu* ab\t repr9ts4 ,"o ( !m is a lett] t giv5 above ( ,augu/ #be1 #ahfe1 writt5 by ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 to ! ,correspond5t4 ,x is "o ( 8 quadratures2 & ! joke is t ,i am made to be ! writ]3 x appe>s z :at ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 hopes ,i %all h ! s5se to write 9 ! ,a!naeum & =e/all him4 ,:5 ,i saw myself ?us quot$--yes6 quot$6 d\ble commas1 fir/ p]son--,i felt z ,i suppose did ,wm4 ,wilb]=ce#cgh :5 he set eyes on ! affectionate b5$iction ( ! potato :i* waggi% comrades _h impos$ on a raw ,iri% report] z "p ( 8 spee*4 ,i felt z ,m>t9#cgi ( #bcg ,galway--k9d fri5d ( ! poor dumb creatures6--:5 he 0 told t ! newspap]s _h put him 9 ,italics4 ,i appeal to y1 ,mr4 ,speak]6 ,i appeal to ! ,h\se6 ,did ,i speak 9 ,italics8 ,d ,i ev] speak 9 ,italics8 ,i appeal to editor & read]s1 :e!r ,i ev] squ>$ ! circle until a week or two ago1 :5 ,i gave my *>itable mode ( reconcil+ ! discrepant cyclomet]s4 ,! absurdity ( ! imitation ( symbolic reason+ is s lusci\sly ri*1 t ,i %all ins]t x :5 ,i make up my f9al book4 ,somebody ma/]$ ,spani% m]ely to read ,don ,quixote3 x w\ld be wor? :ile to le>n a little algebra m]ely to enjoy ?is a b-i/ical attack on ! w9dmills4 ,! pr9ciple is1 ,prove some?+ 9 z r\ndab\t a way z possible1 m5tion ! circle once or twice irrelevantly 9 ! c\rse ( y\r pro(1 & !n make an act ( ,q4 ,e4 ,d4 9 words at l5g?4 ,! foll[+ is h>dly c>icature3-- ,to prove t #b & #b make #e4 ,let a #b1 b #e3 let c #feh1 ! numb] ( ! ,h\se3 let d #fff1 ! numb] ( ! ,bea/4 ,!n ( necessity d a b c #a2 s t #a is a h>moni\s & logical quantification ( ! numb] ( :i* we are to take c>e4 ,n[1 b1 ! middle ( our digital sy/em1 is1 by ma!matical & geometrical comb9ation1 a mean betwe5 #e #a & #b #b4 ,let #a be remov$ to be tak5 c>e (1 a ?+ no real ma!matician c refuse )\t s]i\s injury to 8 ma!matical & geometrical reputation4 ,x foll[s ( necessity t #b #b #e1 quod erat demon/rumhorr5dum4 ,if ,simpk9 ,m>%all h n1 aft] my notice1 to acc\nt = a gross ( copies m ?an w\ld h gone (f )\t me1 ! _w is n wor?y ( its ,james ,smi?6 ,! only fault ( ! above is1 t !re is m #bch connection ?an 9 ! process ( ,fab] ,cyclometricus3 s mu*1 9 fact1 t ! blund]s are visible4 ,! utt] irrelevance ( premises to conclusion _c be exhibit$ ) ! requisite obscurity by any "o :o is able to foll[ reason+3 x is high art display$ 9 a c]ta9 ton+ d[n ( ! aegri somnia1 :i* br+s !m to a c]ta9 look ( reproa* to reason+ :i* ,i c only burlesque4 ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 produces some?+ :i* resembles argum5t mu* z a *impanzee 9 dolor1 because balk$ ( 8 d9n]1 resembles a ?9k+ man at 8 /udies4 ,my humble attempt at imitation ( him is m l a monkey hang+ by 8 tail f a tree & try+ to crack a cocoa-nut by 8 *att]4 ,i c\ld =give ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 any?+1 prop]ly head$4 ,i w\ld all[ him to prove--= himself--t ! ,quadrature ( ! ,circle is ! *ild ( a private m>riage betwe5 ! ,bull ,unig5itus & ! ,pragmatic ,sanction1 claim+ ti! ( onions = repeal ( ! ,mortma9 ,act1 be=e ! ,bi%ops 9 ,committee "u ! kit*5 table3 8 mode ( imitat+ reason w\ld d ?is ) ease4 ,b :5 he puts 8 imitation into my m\?1 to make me :at he calls a real ma!matician1 my s\l rises 9 epigram aga9/ him4 ,i say ) ! doll's dressmak]--su* a job makes me feel l a puppet's tailor myself--,he ought to h a little pepp]8 j a few gra9s8 ,i ?9k ! "y man's tricks & mann]s make a claim ^u 8 fri5ds = a little pepp]8 ,de ,faure#chj & ,joseph ,scalig]#cha come into my head3 my read] may look back = !m4 ,?ree circlesqu>]s to ! mann] born1 ,switz]l&1 ,france1 & ,engl& did adorn1 ,de ,faure 9 equations did surpass1 ,joseph at contradictions 0 an ass4 ,groan$ ,folly1 ,i'm us$ up6 ,:at %all ,i d ,to make ,james ,smi?8 ,gr9n$ ,momus1 ,jo9 ! two6 #bci ,z to my locus po5it5tiae1#chb ! read] :o is fit to enjoy ! lett] ,i h already allud$ to w see t ,i h a s(t & easy position2 t ! ?+ is really a pill[ry2 & t ,i am1 l ,p]rette's pot ( milk1 ,bi5 pose sur un c\ss9et4#chc ,joanna ,s\?cott#chd nev] _h a foll[] :o believ$ 9 h] ) m humble piety ?an ,mr4 ,james ,smi? believes 9 himself4 ,aft] all t has happ5$ to him1 he asks me ) high confid5ce to favor ! writ] ) a pro( t ,i /ill cont9ue ( op9ion t ! be/ ( ! argum5t is 9 my jokes1 & ! be/ ( ! joke is 9 8 argum5ts4 ,i w n s favor him4 ,at ! v outset ,i told him 9 pla9 ,engli% t he has ! :iph& ( all ! reason]s 9 ! _w1 & 9 pla9 ,fr5* t il a p]du le droit d'etre frappe de l'evid5ce#che2 ,i might h said p5du4#chf ,to :i* ,i n[ add1 9 pla9 ,lat91 ,sapi5ti pauca1 indocto nihil4#chg ,! law ( ,*anc]y says t he :o w h equity mu/ d equity3 ! law ( reason+ says t he :o w h pro( mu/ see pro(4 ,! introduction ( ?+s q irrelevant1 by way ( reproa*1 is an argum5t 9 univ]sal reque/3 & x (t5 happ5s t ! argum5t s produc$ really tells aga9/ ! produc]4 ,s common is x t we =get h[ boyi% x is2 b we are /rik+ly rem9d$ :5 x actually comes f a boy4 ,9 a c]ta9 police c\rt1 c]ta9 small boys 7 arraign$ = conspir+ to hoot an obnoxi\s individual on 8 way f "o ( _! s*ool exhibitions4 ,?is proce$+ 0 necess>y1 because !re seem$ to be a p]man5t conspiracy to annoy ! g5tleman2 & ! #bdj ma/]s did n feel able to int]f]e 9 :at took place outside ! s*ool4 ,s ! boys 7 arraign$2 & _! fri5ds1 z silly 9 _! way z !mselves1 all[$ "o ( !m to make ! def5ce1 in/ead ( employ+ c\nsel2 & did n ev5 give !m any useful h9ts4 ,! def5ce 0 z foll[s2 & any "o :o does n see h[ ri*ly x sets (f ! def5ces ( bigg] boys 9 bigg] matt]s has mu* to le>n4 ,! innoc5t conviction t !re 0 answ] 9 ! latt] "p is delightful4 ,( c\rse f9e & recognizance foll[$4 ,a---- said ! boys _h receiv$ great provocation f ,b----4 ,he 0 con/antly ?reat5+ !m ) a horse:ip :i* he c>ri$ 9 8 h& ! boy did n say :at _h pass$ to induce him to take su* a weapon1 & he _h repeat$ly insult$ ! ma/]1 :i* ! boys c\ld n /&4 ,b---- _h 9 8 own draw+-room told him 7,a----7 t he _h drawn 8 sword aga9/ ! ma/] & ?r[n away ! scabb>d4 ,b---- knew well t if he came to ! college he w\ld cat* x1 & !n he w5t (f ?r\gh a side door--:i* 0 no sign ( pluck2 & !n he br\ght ,mrs4 ,b---- ) him1 ?9k+ t h] pres5ce w\ld protect him4 ,my read]s may expect a ^w on ,mr4 ,?om's s]mons1 aft] my acc\nt ( 8 que] do+s ab\t #fff4 ,he is evid5tly an hone/ & dev\t man1 mu* want+ 9 discrim9ation4 ,he has a s]mon ab\t private judgm5t1 9 :i* he halts betwe5 ! logical & legal mean+s ( ! ^w4 ,he loa!s ^? :o apply _! private judgm5t to ! ^w ( ,god3 "h he means ^? :o decide :at x ought to be4 ,he seems 9 o!r places aw>e t ! !ological phrase means tak+ "r to det]m9e :at x is4 ,he uses 8 own private judgm5t v freely1 & is /rong 9 ! conclusion t o!rs ought n to use !irs except z he tells !m h[2 he leaves all ! re/ ( mank9d free to ?9k ) him4 ,9 ?is he is n orig9al3 8 fame mu/ re/ on 8 s5>y tripod4 #bda ,,james ,,smi? ,,once ,,m4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi?'s proc$ures are n c>icature ( reason+2 !y are c>icature ( blund]+4 ,! old way ( prov+ t #b #a is solemn e>ne/ comp>$ ) 8 demon/rations4 ,z foll[s3#chh ,let x #a ,!n x#b x ,& x#b - #a x - #a ,divide bo? sides by x - #a2 !n x #a #a2 b x #a1 :5ce #b #a4 ,:5 a man is regul>ly snubb$1 bulli$1 bl[n up1 walk$ into1 & put d[n1 !re is usually "s reaction 9 8 favor1 a k9d ( deo/racism1 :i* _c be> to he> him always call$ ! blund]]4 ,i hope x w be s 9 ?is case4 ,!re is no?+ ,i m desire ?an to see sects ( p>adox]s4 ,!re are fully five ?\s& adults 9 ,engl& :o ought to be ! foll[]s ( "s "o false quadrature4 ,& ,i h mo/ hope ( #c-a_/h1 because ,i ?9k ,mr4 ,james ,smi? bett] fitt$ to be ! lead] ( an organiz$ infatuation ?an any "o ,i "k (4 ,he wants no pity1 & w get none4 ,he has en]gy1 means1 good humor1 /rong conviction1 "*1 & popul>ity 9 8 own circle4 ,&1 mo/ indisp5sable po9t ( all1 he /icks at no?+2 ,9 coelum juss]is1 ibit4#chi ,:5 my in/ructor f\nd ,i did n pr9t an acceptance ( :at ,i h quot$1 he address$ me z foll[s 7,corr41 ,sept #bc73-- ,9 ?is life1 h[ev]1 we mu/ d our duty1 &1 :5 #bdb necess>y1 use ! rod1 n 9 a _s ( rev5ge1 b = ! b5efit ( ! culprit & ! good ( society4 ,n[1 ,sir1 ! opportunity has be5 ?r[n 9 y\r way ( slipp+ out ( ! pillory )\t risk ( s]i\s injury2 b1 l an ob/9ate ur*91 y h *os5 to qu>rel ) y\r opportunity & rema9 !re1 & ?us y compel me to deal ) y z s*oolma/]s us$ to d ) /upid boys 9 bygone days--t is to say1 y =ce me to ! use ( ! critic's rod1 compel me to put y :]e little ,jack ,horn] sat1 &1 z a w>n+ to o!r naughty boys1 to ornam5t y ) a dunce's cap4 ,! task ,i set y 0 a v simple "o1 z ,i %all make manife/ at ! prop] "t4 ,9 "o or m places1 z well z ?is1 ,mr4 ,smi? %[s t he does n "k ! leg5d ( little ,jack ,horn]1 :om he imag9es to be put 9 ! corn] z a bad boy4 ,?is is curi\s2 = !re _h be5 _m allusions to ! /ory 9 ! j\rnal he 0 writ+ 91 & ! ,*ri/mas pie _h become alt]$ into ! ,sea=? pi4 ,mr4 ,smi? is satisfi$ at la/ t--:at betwe5 argum5t & puni%m5t he has conv9c$ me4 ,he says 7,corr41 ,jan4 #bg1 #ahff73 ,i tell him )\t hesitation t he kn[s ! true ratio ( diamet] to circumf]5ce z well z ,i d1 & if he be wise he w admit x4 ,i %\ld hope ,i d1 & bett]2 b !re is no occasion to admit :at ev]ybody kn[s4 ,i h (t5 wi%$ t we c\ld h a slight glimpse ( ! reception :i* 0 giv5 to "s ( ! old cyclomet]s3 b we h no?+1 except ! grave disapprobation ( hi/orians4 ,i am resolv$ to give ! ,new ,zeal&] a *ance ( kn[+ a little m ?an ?is ab\t "o ( !m at lea/2 &1 by ! =tunate entrance into life ( ! ,correspond5t1 ,i am able to d x4 ,i omit sob] ma!matical answ]s1 ( :i* !re 7 sev]al4 ,! foll[+ lett] is grave e>ne/3 ,sir1--,i h wat*$ ,mr4 ,james ,smi?'s writ+s on ?is subject f ! fir/1 & ,i did hope t1 z ! m #bdc he dep>ts f tru? ! m easy x mu/ be to refute him1 ?is by no means always true "s ( y\r correspond5ts w\ld by ?is "t h done s4 ,i own t ,i am unable to detect ! fallacy ( 8 argum5t2 & ,i am q c]ta9 t ',pi' is wrong1 9 ,no4 #bc1 :]e he decl>es t ,mr4 ,smi? is 'ignorant ( ! v elem5ts ( ma!matical tru?4' ,i h obs]v$ an imm5se am\nt ( geometrical reason+ on 8 "p1 & ,i _c see t x is ei!r fair or hone/ to d5y ?is1 :i* may be reg>d$ z ! 'elem5ts' ( ma!matical tru?4 ,w\ld x n be bett] = ',pi' to answ] ,mr4 ,smi?1 to refute 8 argum5ts1 to po9t out _! fallacies1 & to save le>n]s f error1 ?an to plunge into gross insult & unmanly abuse8 ,w\ld x n be well1 also1 t ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan %\ld fav\r u ) a little reason+8 ,i h hi!rto se5 no attempt to ov]?r[ ,mr4 ,smi?'s argum5ts2 ,i tru/ t ?is w n cont9ue1 s9ce ! subject is "o ( imm5se importance to sci5ce 9 g5]al1 especially to nautical sci5ce1 & all t !reto belongs4 ,y\rs1 etc41 ,a ,,capta91 ,r4,n4 ,on look+ at ?is homoeopa?ic treatm5t ( ! #c-a_/h quadrature--rememb]1 homoeopa?ic1 similia similibus1#cij n inf9itesimal--& at ! imputation ?r[n ^u x1 ,i ask$ myself1 :at is vulg>ity8 ,no two agree1 except 9 ?is1 t e "o sees vulg>ity 9 :at is direct$ aga9/ himself4 ,m>k ! _w1 & see if any?+ be s common z ! description ( ! o!r side's rem>ks z vulg> attempt at wit4 ,i suppose y ?9k t v witty3 ! answ] is ,no my fri5d6 y\r rem>k %[s t y feel x z wit1 s t ! purpose is answ]$2 ,i keep my razor = some?+ else ?an cutt+ blocks2 ,i am incl9$ to ?9k t out ( place is a necess>y attribute ( true vulg>ity4 ,& fur!r1 x is to be notic$ t no?+ is #bdd unproducible--salvo pudore#cia--:i* has classical au?ority1 mod]n or anci5t1 9 its favor4 ,he is a vulg> fell[2 ,i ask$ him :at he 0 ^u1 & :at d y ?9k he answ]$1 ,my legs6--,well1 & has he n ju/ification8 :at d y f9d 9 ,t]5ce8 ,quid agitur8 ,/atur4#cib ,i d n ev5 bl5* f my pr9ciple :]e ,i f9d t x br+s :at is call$ tak+ a sight )9 p]missible =ms ( expression3 ,rabelais n only e/abli%es its antiquity1 b makes x ,engli%4 ,our old translation#cic has x ?us 7book #b4 *4 #ai73 ,!n made ! ,engli%man ?is sign4 ,8 left h&1 all op51 he lift$ up into ! air1 !n in/antly %ut into 8 fi/ ! f\r f+]s !re(2 & 8 ?umb ext5d$ at l5g? he plac$ ^u ! tip ( 8 nose4 ,pres5tly aft] he lift$ up 8 "r h& all op5 & abas$ & b5t x d[nw>ds1 putt+ ! ?umb !re( 9 ! v place :]e ! little f+] ( ! left h& did close 9 ! fi/1 & ! f\r "r h& f+]s he s(tly mov$ 9 ! air4 ,!n contr>ily he did ) ! "r h& :at he _h done ) ! left1 & ) ! left :at he _h done ) ! "r4 ,an impressive sight6 ,! mak+ ( a fi/ ( ! left h& is a great addition ( p[]1 & %\ld be foll[$ 9 mod]n practice4 ,! g5tle sullation ( ! front f+]s1 ) ! cl5*$ fi/ beh9d !m1 says z pla9ly z possible1 ,put suavit] 9 modo 9 ! van1 b don't =get to h =tit] 9 re#cid 9 ! re>4 #bde ,my ,budget 0 ann\nc$ 7,m>* #bc1 #ahfg7 = completion on ! #cj?4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? wrote five lett]s1 "o be=e ! completion1 f\r aft] x2 ! five conta9$ #fh pages ( qu>to lett] pap]4 ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 _h pick$ up a cl]ical correspond5t1 ) :om he 0 9 ! heat ( battle4 ,m>* #bg4--;,de> ,sir4 ,v truly y\rs4 ,duty2 = my own sake2 j "t left to retrieve my errors2 s5ds copy ( lett] to cl]gyman2 new pro( nev] be=e ?\ght (2 m]e/ tyro w\ld laugh if ,i 7 to /ifle x1 :e!r by rhodomontade or sil5t contempt2 keep y\r temp]4 ,i %all be conv9c$2 & if _w be "r 9 suppos+ me incapable ( a f\l act1 ,i %all proclaim glori\s discov]y 9 ! ,a!naeum4 ,april #ae4--,sir1444 ,my de> ,sir1 ,y\r s9c]e tutel>y4 ,copy ( ano!r lett] to cl]gyman2 discov]y te/$ by log>i?ms2 reasons su* z none b a knave or a s9n] c resi/4 ,let me advise y to take c\nsel be=e x is too late6 ,keep y\r temp]4 ,let n y\r pride get ! bett] ( y\r discretion6 ,screw up y\r c\rage1 my good fri5d1 & resolve to %[ ! _w t y are an hone/ man4444 ,april #bj4--,sir 444 ,y\r v s9c]e & favorite tutel>y4 ,i h long play$ ! cur1 snapp+ & sn>l+4442 sudd5ly lo/ my p[]1 & became half-/>v$ dog )\t _s to b>k2 try if air _c re/ore me2 calls himself ! ?i/le 9 allusion to my o!r tutel>y1 ! ?orn2 ,w\ld ,i pref] 8 next "w to be1 ',a :ip = ! ,ma!matical ,cur1 ,pr(4 ,de ,m4' ,9 "s previ\s lett] :i* ,i h mislaid1 he told me 8 next w\ld be 'a muzzle = ! ,ma!matical ,bull dog1 ,pr(4 ,de ,m4' ,april #bc4--,sir4 ,v s9c]ely y\rs4 ,m lett]s to cl]gyman2 y may z well knock y\r head aga9/ a /one wall to improve y\r intellect z attempt to controv]t my pro(s4 ,i ?\ght s too2 & tri$ nei!r4 #bdf ,may #f4--,my de> ,sir4 ,v s9c]ely y\rs4 ,all to myself1 & no?+ to note4 ,july #b4--,no m 9 ?is int]val4 ,all t prec$es is a desp]ate attempt to induce me to cont9ue my descriptions3 notoriety at any price4 ,i d>e say ! matt] is f9i%$3 ! record ( s m>k$ an in/ance ( self-delusion w be useful4 ,i app5d to ! =ego+ a lett] f ,dr4 ,:ewell#cie to ,mr4 ,james ,smi?4 ,! ,ma/] ( ,tr9ity 0 conspicu\s z a r\gh cu/om]1 an intellectual bully1 an ov]be>+ disputant3 ! "* 0 z well e/abli%$ z t ( ,sam ,johnson4 ,b !re 0 a m>k$ diff]5ce4 ,x 0 said ( ,johnson t if 8 pi/ol miss$ fire1 he w\ld knock y d[n ) ! butt end ( x3 b ,:ewell1 9 l case1 always ackn[l$g$ ! miss1 & load$ aga9 or n1 z ! case might be4 ,he rem9d$ me ( ,d5nis ,brulgrudd]y1 :o says to ,dan1 ,pacify me ) a good reason1 & y'll f9d me a dutiful ma/]4 ,i knew him f ! "t :5 he 0 my tea*] at ,cambridge1 m ?an =ty ye>s4 ,z a tea*]1 he 0 any?+ b dictatorial1 & he 0 p]fectly accessible to proposal ( objections4 ,he came 9 contact ) me 9 8 sla%+ way twice 9 our aft] jo9t lives1 & on bo? occasions he ackn[l$g$ himself ov]come1 by t *ange ( mann]1 & apologetic mode ( cont9uance1 :i* ,i _h se5 him employ t[>ds o!rs "u l circum/ances4 ,i _h express$ my wi% to h a !rmomet] ( probability1 ) impossibility at "o end1 z #b & #b make #e1 & necessity at ! o!r1 z #b & #b make #d1 & a graduat$ rise ( examples betwe5 !m4 ,d[n came a bl[3 ,:at6 put necess>y & cont+5t propositions toge!r6 ,x's absurd6 ,i po9t$ out t ! two k9ds ( necessity are b su* extremes ( probability z #j & inf9ity are ( numb]1 & illu/rat$ by an urn ) #a :ite & n black #bdg balls1 n increas+ )\t limit4 ,x 0 frankly se51 & ! po9t yield$2 a l>ge company 0 pres5t4 ,aga91 9 a l>ge p>ty1 aft] d9n]1 & politics be+ ! subject1 ,i 0 proce$+1 9 discussion ) ,mr4 ,:ewell1 ) ,i ?9k444--,ugh6 y ?9k6 0 ! answ]4 ,i repeat$ my phrase1 & gave z a reason ! words :i* ,"l ,grey#cif _h us$ 9 ! ,h\se ( ,lords ! night be=e 7! celebrat$ advice to ! ,bi%ops to set _! h\ses 9 ord]74 ,he _h n he>d ( ?is1 & 8 mann] *ang$ 9 an in/ant3 he 0 ! rational discuti5t all ! re/ ( ! ev5+1 hav+ previ\sly be5 no?+ b a disputant ) all ! di/9ctions /rongly m>k$4 ,i h said t ,:ewell 0 g5tle ) 8 pupils2 x 0 ! same ) all :o want$ tea*+3 x 0 only on an arm$ enemy t he drew 8 weapon4 ,! lett] :i* he wrote to ,mr4 ,j4 ,smi? is an in/ance3 & z x applies ) p]fect fidelity to ! ef=ts ( unreason+ above describ$1 ,i give x "h4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? is skilfully expos$1 & felt x2 z is prov$ by putt+ ! writ] 9 ! /ocks4 ,! ,lodge1 ,cambridge1 ,septemb] #ad?1 #ahfb4 ,sir1--,i h receiv$ y\r explanation ( y\r proposition t ! circumf]5ce ( ! circle is to its diamet] z #be to #h4 ,i am afraid ,i %all disappo9t y by say+ t ,i see no =ce 9 y\r pro(3 & ,i %\ld hope t y w see t !re is no =ce 9 x if y consid] ?is3 ,9 ! :ole c\rse ( ! pro(1 ?\gh ! ^w cycle occurs1 !re is no prop]ty ( ! circle employ$4 ,y may d ?is3 y may put ! ^w hexagon or dodecagon1 or any o!r ^w describ+ a polygon 9 ! place ( ,circle 9 y\r pro(1 & ! pro( w\ld be j z good z be=e4 ,does n ?is satisfy y t y _c h prov$ a prop]ty ( t special figure--a circle8 #bdh ,or y may d ?is3 calculate ! side ( a polygon ( #bd sides inscrib$ 9 a circle4 ,i ?9k y are a ,ma!matician en\gh to d ?is4 ,y w f9d t if ! radius ( ! circle be "o1 ! side ( ?is polygon is 4#bfd etc4 ,n[1 ! arc :i* ?is side subt5ds is accord+ to y\r proposition #c4abe_/ab 4#bfjd1 & !re=e ! *ord is great] ?an its arc1 :i* y w all[ is impossible4 ,i %all be glad if ^! argum5ts satisfy y1 & ,i am1 ,sir1 y\r ob$i5t ,s]vant1 ,w4 ,,:ewell4 ,,an ,m4,p4',s ,,ari?metic4 ,9 ! debate ( ,may1 #ahff1 on ,electoral ,qualifications1 a "q arose ab\t ari?metical capability4 ,mr4 ,glad/one ask$ h[ _m memb]s ( ! ,h\se c\ld divide #accjl4 #gs4 #f;d4 by #bl4 #acs4 #h;d4 ,six hundr$ & fifty-eight1 answ]$ "o memb]2 ! ?+ _c be done1 answ]$ ano!r4 ,!re is an old p>adox to :i* ?is relates3 x arises out ( ! ignorance ( ! di/9ction betwe5 ab/ract & concrete ari?metic4 ,magnitude may be divid$ by magnitude2 & ! answ] is numb]3 h[ (t5 does #ab;d4 conta9 #d;d42 answ] ?ree times4 ,magnitude may be divid$ by numb]1 & ! answ] is magnitude3 #ab;d4 is divid$ 9 f\r equal p>ts1 :at is ea* "p8 ,answ] ?ree p5ce4 ,! honorable objector1 ^: "n ,i suppress1 tru/+ t he has m5d$ 8 ways1 gave ! foll[+ utt]ance3 ,) reg>d to ! division sum1 x 0 q possible to divide by a sum1 b n by money4 ,h[ c\ld any "o divide money by #bl4 #afs4 #h;d48 7,laught]47 ,! "q might be ask$1 ',h[ _m times #bs4 w g into #al48' b t 0 n divid+ by money2 x 0 simply divid+ #bj by #b4 ,he might be ask$1 ',h[ _m times w #fs4 #h;d4 g into a p\nd8' b x 0 only requir$ to divide #bdj by #hj4 ,if ! "r hon4 g5tleman 7 to ask ! hon4 #bdi memb] = ,brighton 7,pr(essor ,fawcett71#cig or any o!r au?ority1 he w\ld receive ! same answ]--viz41 t x 0 possible to divide by a sum1 b n by money4 7,he>47 ,i %all leave all comm5t = ! second edition1 if ,i publi% "o4#cih ,i %all be sure to h some?+ to laugh at4 ,any?+ said f a respectable qu>t]1 or suppos$ to be said1 is sure to f9d def5d]s4 ,sam ,johnson1 a s\nd ari?metician1 comp>+ himself1 & :at he alone _h done 9 ?ree ye>s1 ) =ty ,fr5* ,academicians & _! =ty ye>s1 said x prov$ t an ,engli%man is to a ,fr5*man z #dj x #dj to #c1 or z #afjj to #c4 ,boswell1 :o 0 no great h& at ari?metic1 made him say t an ,engli%man is to a ,fr5*man z #c to #afjj4 ,:5 ,i po9t$ ?is out1 ! suppos$ ,johnson 0 def5d$ ?r\gh ?ick & ?9 9 ,notes & ,qu]ies4 ,i am n[ curi\s to see :e!r ! foll[+ w f9d a palliator4 ,x is f ,tri/ram ,%&y1 book ,v4 *apt] #c4 ,!re are two curi\s idioms1 = = & half 9 half2 b ^! h no?+ to d ) my po9t3 ,a bless+ :i* ti$ up my fa!r's tongue1 & a mis=tune :i* set x loose ) a good grace1 7 pretty equal3 sometimes1 inde$1 ! mis=tune 0 ! bett] ( ! two2 =1 = in/ance1 :]e ! pleasure ( h>angue 0 z t51 & ! pa9 ( ! mis=tune b z five1 my fa!r ga9$ half 9 half2 & consequ5tly 0 z well aga9 (f z if x _h nev] befall5 him4 ,?is is a jolly confusion ( ideas2 & wants no?+ b a def5d] to make x p]fect4 ,a p]son :o inve/s five #bej ) a return ( t51 & "o :o loses five ) "o h& & ga9s t5 ) ! o!r1 bo? leave (f five ri*] ?an !y began1 no d\bt4 ,! fir/ ga9s half 9 half1 m prop]ly half on half1 t is1 ( ! return1 #aj1 ! second #e is ga9 ^u ! fir/ #e inve/$4 ,half 9 half is a que] way ( say+ c5t4 p] c5t4 ,if ! #el4 inve/$ be all ! man _h 9 ! _w1 he comes out1 aft] ! ga91 twice z well (f z he began1 ) ref]5ce to 8 :ole =tune4 ,b x is v odd to say t balance ( #el4 ga9 is twice z good z if no?+ _h befall51 ei!r loss or ga94 ,a ma!matician ?9ks #e an inf9ite numb] ( times z great z #j4 ,! :ole confusion is n s app>5t :5 money is 9 "q3 = money is money :e!r ga9$ or lo/4 ,b ?\gh pleasure & pa9 /& to "o ano!r 9 ! same algebraical relation z money ga9$ & lo/1 yet !re is m ?an algebra c take acc\nt ( 9 ! diff]5ce4 ,next1 ,ri4 ,milw>d#cii 7,ri*>d1 no d\bt1 b x _c be prov$7 :o publi%$ ,seld5's#djj ,table ,talk1 :i* he _h collect$ :ile s]v+ z amanu5sis1 makes ,seld5 say1 ,a subsidy 0 c\nt$ ! fif? "p ( a man's e/ate2 & s fifty subsidies is five & =ty times m ?an a man is wor?4 ,= times read subsidies1 :i* seems "p ( ! confusion1 & !re rema9s ! mak+ all ! subsidies equal to ! fir/1 ?\gh ! :ole ( :i* !y are to be ! fif?s is p]petually dim9i%$4 ,?irdly1 !re is ! confusion ( ! great misoma? #bea ( our own day1 :o discov]$ two quantities :i* he av]s to be id5tically ! same1 b ! great] ! "o ! less ! o!r4 ,he _h a tru? 9 8 m9d1 :i* 8 notions ( quantity 7 inadequate to clo! 9 language4 ,?is errone\s phraseology has n f\nd a def5d]2 & ,i am almo/ incl9$ to say1 ) ,fal/aff1 ,! poor abuses ( ! "t want c\nt5ance4 ,,errone\s ,,ari?metical ,,notions4 ,%all[ num]i/s1 z ,cock]#dja is made to call !m1 h long be5 at "w ^u ! "q h[ to multiply money by money4 ,x is1 ,i h obs]v$1 a v common way ( amus+ ! t$ium ( a sea voyage3 ,i h _h m ?an "o bet ref]r$ to me4 ,because an oblong ( five in*es by f\r in*es conta9s #e x #d or #bj squ>e in*es1 p say t five in*es multipli$ by f\r in*es is tw5ty squ>e in*es3 &1 ?9k+ t !y h multipli$ l5g? by l5g?1 !y />e :5 !y are told t money _c be multipli$ by money4 ,"o ( my bett]s made x an argum5t = ! ?+ be+ impossible1 t !re is no squ>e money3 :at c\ld ,i d b sugge/ t po/age-/amps %\ld be made legal t5d]4 ,multiplication mu/ be repetition3 ! repeat+ process mu/ be indicat$ by numb] ( times4 ,i once _h difficulty 9 p]suad+ ano!r ( my bett]s t if y repeat five %ill+s z (t5 z !re are hairs 9 a horse's tail1 y d n multiply five %ill+s by a horsetail4#djb ,i am v sorry to say t ^! wrong notions h f\nd support--,i ?9k !y d s no long]--9 ! ,univ]sity ( ,cambridge4 ,9 #ahef or #aheg1 an exam9] 0 displac$ by a vote ( ! ,s5ate4 ,! pretext 0 t he 0 too sev]e an exam9]3 b x 0 well kn[n t #beb great dissatisfaction _h be5 express$1 f> & wide ?r\gh ! ,colleges1 at an absurd "q :i* he _h giv54 ,he actually propos$ su* a fraction z #fs4 #c;d4 --------4 #ags4 #d;d4 ,z common s5se ga9$ a he>+ v soon1 !re is no occasion to say m4 ,9 #aheh1 x 0 propos$ at a college exam9ation1 to divide #bbeeg days1 #bj h\rs1 #bj m9utes1 #dh seconds1 by #eg m9utes1 #ab seconds1 & also to expla9 ! fraction #cbl4 #ahs4 #h;d4 -------------4 #fbl4 #abs4 #i;d4 ,all p>adoxy1 9 matt]s ( demon/ration1 arises out ( muddle ab\t fir/ pr9ciples4 ,:o c say h[ mu* ( x is to be laid at ! door ( ! ,univ]sity ( ,cambridge1 = n tak+ c>e ( ! elem5ts ( ari?metical ?\ght8 ,,on ,,lit]>y ,,b>ga9s4 ,! ph5om5a ( ! two ends ( society1 :5 br\ght toge!r1 give int]e/+ comp>isons3 ,i mean ! e>ly beg9n+s ( ?\ght & lit]ature1 & our own high & f9i%$ /ate1 z we ?9k x4 ,!re is "o v rem>kable po9t4 ,9 ! e>ly day1 ! lett] 0 matt] ( ! close/ adh]5ce1 & impli$ mean+s 7 n admitt$4 ,! bless+ ( ,isaac meant = ,esau1 w5t to false ,jacob1 9 spite ( ! imposition2 & ! writ] ( ,g5esis seems to int5d to give ! notion t ,isaac _h no p[] to pron\nce x null & void4 ,& ,jacob's policy1 :]eby he became ri*--z ! *apt]-head+ puts x--9 speckl$ & spott$ /ock1 is n consid]$ z a violation ( ! agreem5t1 :i* contemplat$ natural proportions4 ,9 #bec ! /ory ( ,lycurgus ! lawgiv] is held to h behav$ fairly :5 he b\nd ! ,sp>tans to obey 8 laws until he return$--intimat+ a %ort abs5ce--he int5d+ nev] to return4 ,& ,vi%noo1 :5 he ask$ ! usurp] = ?ree /eps ( t]ritory z a dw>f1 & !n enl>g$ himself until he c\ld br+ heav5 & e>? "u ! b>ga91 0 ?\ght clev]1 c]ta9ly1 b q fair4 ,!re is no?+ ( ?is k9d recogniz$ 9 our day3 s f> good4 ,b !re is a bad contr>y3 ! age is apt1 9 int]pretation1 to upset ! lett] 9 favor ( ! view--v (t5 ! aft] ?\ght--( "o side only4 ,! case ( ,john ,palm]1#djc ! improv] ( ! mail coa* sy/em1 is smo!r$4 ,he 0 to h an (fice & a sal>y1 & #b-a_/b p] c5t = life on ! increas$ rev5ue ( ! ,po/-,(fice4 ,8 rights turn$ out s l>ge1 t ,gov]nm5t w\ld n pay !m4 ,= misconduct1 real or pret5d$1 !y turn$ him out ( 8 (fice3 b 8 b>ga9 z to ! p]c5tage _h no?+ to d ) 8 future conduct2 x 0 paym5t = 8 plan4 ,i "k no?+1 except f ! debates ( #ahjh 9 ! two ,h\ses3 if any "o c r$eem ! cr$it ( ! nation1 ! field is op54 ,:5 ,i 0 "y1 ! old /ag]s spoke ( ?is transaction sp>+ly1 & dismiss$ x spe$ily4 ,! gov]nm5t did n *oose to rememb] :at private p]sons mu/ rememb]1 & are made to rememb]1 if ne$ful4 ,:5 ,dr4 ,l>dn]#djd made 8 b>ga9 ) ! #bed publi%]s = ! ,cab9et ,cyclopa$ia he propos$ t he1 z editor1 %\ld h a c]ta9 sum = e hundr$ sold above a c]ta9 numb]3 ! publi%]s1 :o did n ?9k !re 0 any *ance ( rea*+ ! turn+ sale ( ?is /ipulation1 readily cons5t$4 ,b x turn$ out t ,dr4 ,l>dn] saw fur!r ?an !y3 ! returns "u ?is /ipulation gave him a v h&some addition to 8 o!r receipts4 ,! publi%]s />$2 b !y paid4 ,!y _h no idea ( /&+ out t ! am\nt 0 too mu* = an editor2 !y knew t1 ?\gh ! editor _h a p]c5tage1 !y _h all ! re/2 & !y w\ld n h felt aggriev$ if he _h receiv$ t5 times z mu*4 ,b gov]nm5ts1 :i* _c be br\ght to book be=e a sworn jury1 are rul$ only by public op9ion4 ,john ,palm]'s day 0 also ! day ( ,?omas ,fy%e ,palm]1#dje & ! gov]nm5ts1 9 _! prosecutions = s$ition1 knew t ^! w\ld h a reflex action ^u ! m9ds ( all :o wrote ab\t public affairs4 ,,decl>ation ,,( ,,belief #ahfd-fe4--;,x (t5 happ5s t p]sons comb9e to ma9ta9 & en=ce an op9ion2 b x is1 9 our /ate ( society1 a p>adox to unite = ! sole purpose ( blam+ ! opposite side4 ,to invite educat$ m5 to d ?is1 & above all1 m5 ( le>n+ or sci5ce1 is ! next p>adoxical ?+ ( all4 ,b ?is 0 done by a small comb9ation 9 #ahfd4 ,!y got toge!r & drew up a decl>ation1 to be sign$ by /ud5ts ( ! natural sci5ces1 :o 7 to express _! s9c]e regret t rese>*es into #bee sci5tific tru? are p]v]t$ by "s 9 our own times into occasion = ca/+ d\bt ^u ! tru? & au!nticity ( ! ,holy ,scriptures4 ,9 words ( ambigu\s sophi/ry1 !y proce$$ to reque/1 9 effect1 t p w\ld be pleas$ to adopt ! views ( *ur*es z to ! complete inspiration ( all ! canonical books4 ,! great "q :e!r ! ,^w ( ,god is 9 ! ,bible1 or :e!r ! ,^w ( ,god is all ! ,bible1 0 quietly tak5 = grant$ 9 favor ( ! second view2 to ! end t m5 ( sci5ce might be induc$ to blame ^? :o took ! fir/ view4 ,! fir/ public att5tion 0 drawn to ! subject by ,sir ,john ,h]s*el1#djf :o 9 refus+ to sign ! writ s5t to him1 adm9i/]$ a rebuke 9 ! ,a!naeum1 :i* w\ld h op5$ mo/ eyes to see t ! case 0 hopeless4 ,! words ( a man ^: suavit] 9 modo makes 8 =tit] 9 re#djg cut blocks ) a razor are wor? pres]v+3 ,i consid] ! act ( call+ ^u me publicly to av[ or disav[1 to approve or disapprove1 9 writ+1 any religi\s doctr9e or /atem5t1 h[ev] c>efully or cauti\sly drawn up 79 o!r words1 to app5d my "n to a religi\s manife/o7 to be an infr+em5t ( t social =be>ance :i* gu>ds ! fre$om ( religi\s op9ion 9 ?is c\ntry ) especial sanctity4444 ,i consid] ?is movem5t simply mis*iev\s1 hav+ a direct t5d5cy 7by putt+ =w>d a new ,%ibbole?1 a new v]bal te/ ( religi\s p>tisan%ip7 to add a fre% elem5t ( discord to ! already too discordant relations ( ! ,*ri/ian _w4444 ,b no nicety ( word+1 no artifice ( human language1 w suffice to discrim9ate ! hundr$? "p ( ! %ades ( mean+ 9 :i* ! mo/ _w-wide diff]5ces ( ?\ght on su* subjects may be involv$2 or prev5t ! mo/ g5tle word$ & app>5tly ju/ifiable expression ( regret1 s embodi$1 f grat+ on ! #bef feel+s ( ?\s&s ( e/imable & well-int5tion$ m5 ) all ! h>%ness ( controv]sial ho/ility4 ,o!r doses 7 adm9i/]$ by ,sir ,j4 ,b[r+1#djh ,sir ,w4 ,r[an ,hamilton1#dji & myself4 ,! sign$ decl>ation 0 promis$ = ,*ri/mas1 #ahfd3 b no?+ pres5table 0 !n ready2 & x 0 ne> ,midsumm]1 #ahfe1 be=e x 0 publi%$4 ,p]sons (t5 incauti\sly put _! names )\t see+ ! "* ( a docum5t1 because !y co9cide 9 its op9ions4 ,9 ?is way1 probably1 fifte5 respectable names 7 procur$ be=e pr9t+2 & ^!1 :5 committ$1 7 hawk$ z "p ( an application to solicit ! favor ( o!r signatures4 ,x is likely en\gh no "o ( ! fifte5 saw t ! decl>ation 01 n ma9t5ance ( _! own op9ion1 b regret 7a civil ^w = blame7 t o!rs %\ld ?9k diff]5tly4 ,:5 ! li/ appe>$1 !re 7 no few] ?an #gaf names6 ,b analysis %[$ t ?is roll 0 n a specim5 ( ! mature sci5ce ( ! c\ntry4 ,! collection 0 v miscellane\s3 #ch 7 designat$ z /ud5ts ( ! ,college ( ,*emi/ry1 mean+ "y m5 :o att5d$ lectures 9 t college4 ,b z all ! ,royal ,society _h be5 appli$ to1 a te/ results z foll[s4 ,( ,fell[s ( ! ,royal ,society1 #fjj 9 numb]1 #fb gave _! signatures2 ( writ]s 9 ! ,philosophical ,transactions1 #aff 9 numb]1 #ai gave _! signatures4 ,r\ghly speak+1 !n1 only "o out ( t5 c\ld be got to express disapprobation ( ! free comp>ison ( ! results ( sci5ce ) ! /atem5ts ( ! canonical books4 ,& ,i am satisfi$ t _m ( ^! ?\ght !y 7 sign+ only a decl>ation ( diff]5ce ( op9ion1 n ( blame = t diff]5ce4 ,! numb] ( p]sons is n small :o1 :5 x comes to sign+ pr9t$ docum5ts1 w\ld put _! names to a decl>ation t ! c(fee-pot ought to be tak5 d[n-/airs1 mean+ t ! teapot ought to be br\ght #beg up-/airs4 ,& _m ( !m w\ld def5d x4 ,"s w\ld say t ! two ?+s are n contradictory2 :i*1 ) a snort or two ( contempt1 w\ld be v effective4 ,o!rs w\ld1 9 ! c&id & quiet tone1 po9t out t x is all "o1 because c(fee is usually tak5 be=e tea1 & x keeps ! table cle> to s5d away ! c(fee-pot be=e ! teapot is br\ght up4 ,! orig9al signatures 7 dec5tly int]r$ 9 ! ,bodleian ,libr>y3 & ! advocates ( scatt]+ indef9ite blame = indef9ite s9s ( op9ion among indef9ite p]sons are1 ,i und]/&1 divid$ 9 op9ion ab\t ! "t at :i* ! next attempt %all be made ^u m5 ( sci5tific /udies3 "s are = ! ,greek ,cal5ds1 & o!rs = ! ,roman ,olympiads4 ,b1 ) _! usual love ( indef9it5ess1 !y h det]m9$ t ! *oice %all be argu$ ^u ! basis t :i* comes fir/ _c be settl$1 & is ( no consequ5ce4 ,i give ! decl>ation entire1 z a curiosity3 & p>allel ) x ,i give a sub/itute :i* 0 propos$ 9 ! ,a!naeum1 z wor?y to be sign$ bo? by /ud5ts ( !ology1 & by /ud5ts ( sci5ce1 especially 9 pa/ "t4 ,:5 a new attempt is made1 x w be wor? :ile to look at bo?3 ,decl>ation4 ,propos$ ,sub/itute4 ,we1 ! und]sign$ ,/ud5ts ,we1 ! und]sign$ ,/ud5ts ( ! ,natural ,sci5ces1 ( ,!ology & ( ,nature1 desire to express our s9c]e desire to express our s9c]e regret1 t rese>*es into regret1 t common notions ( sci5tific tru? are p]v]t$ religi\s tru? are p]v]t$ by "s 9 our own times into by "s 9 our own times into occasion = ca/+ d\bt occasion = ca/+ reproa* ^u ! ,tru? & ^u ! advocates ( ,au!nticity ( ! ,holy demon/rat$ or highly ,scriptures4 probable sci5tific !ories4 #beh ,we conceive t x is ,we conceive t x is impossible = ! ,^w ( impossible = ! ,^w ( ,god1 z writt5 9 ! book ( ,god1 z correctly read 9 ! nature1 & ,god's ,^w writt5 ,book ( ,nature1 & ! ,^w 9 ,holy ,scripture1 to ( ,god1 z truly int]pret$ contradict "o ano!r1 out ( ! ,holy ,scripture1 to h[ev] mu* !y may appe> contradict "o ano!r1 to diff]4 h[ev] mu* !y may appe> to diff]4 ,we are n =getful t ,we are n =getful t ,physical ,sci5ce is n nei!r !ological complete1 b is only 9 a int]pretation nor physical condition ( progress1 & k is yet complete1 b t at pres5t our f9ite t bo? are 9 a condition reason enables u only to see ( progress2 & t at z ?r\gh a glass d>kly1 pres5t our f9ite reason enables u only to see bo? "o & ! o!r z ?r\gh a glass d>kly ! writ]s ( ! orig9al decl>ation h di/9ctively appli$ to physical sci5ce ! phrase by :i* ,/4 ,paul d5otes ! imp]fections ( !ological vision1 :i* !y tacitly assume to be q p]fect1 & we confid5tly believe1 & we confid5tly believe1 t a "t w come :5 ! t a "t w come :5 ! two records w be se5 to two records w be se5 to agree 9 e p>ticul>4 ,we agree 9 e p>ticul>4 ,we _c b deplore t _c b deplore t ,natural ,sci5ce %\ld be ,religion %\ld be look$ ^u look$ ^u ) suspicion by ) suspicion by "s & _m :o d n make a /udy ,sci5ce by o!rs1 ( ! ( x1 m]ely on acc\nt ( /ud5ts ( ei!r :o d n ! unadvis$ mann] 9 :i* make a /udy ( ! #bei "s are plac+ x 9 o!r1 m]ely on acc\nt ( opposition to ,holy ,writ4 ! unadvis$ mann] 9 :i* "s are plac+ ,religion 9 opposition to ,sci5ce1 & "s are plac+ ,sci5ce 9 opposition to ,religion4 ,we believe t x is ! duty ,we believe t x is ! duty ( e ,sci5tific ,/ud5t to ( e !ological /ud5t inve/igate nature simply = to inve/igate ! ,scripture1 ! purpose ( elucidat+ & ( e sci5tific tru?1 /ud5t to inve/igate ,nature1 simply = ! purpose ( elucidat+ tru?4 & t if he f9ds t "s ,& if ei!r %\ld f9d t ( 8 results appe> to be 9 "s ( 8 results appe> to contradiction to ! ,writt5 be 9 contradiction1 :e!r ,^w1 or r to 8 own to ,scripture or to ,nature1 or int]pretations ( x1 :i* r to 8 own may be errone\s1 he %\ld int]pretation ( "o or ! n presumptu\sly affirm t o!r1 :i* may be errone\s1 8 own conclusions mu/ be he %\ld n affirm z ) "r1 & ! /atem5ts ( c]ta9ty t 8 own ,scripture wrong2 conclusion mu/ be "r1 & ! o!r int]pretation wrong3 r1 leave ! two side by b %\ld leave ! two side side till x %all please ,god by side = fur!r inquiry to all[ u to see ! mann] into bo?1 until x %all 9 :i* !y may be please ,god to all[ u to reconcil$2 arrive at ! mann] 9 :i* !y may be reconcil$4 &1 in/ead ( insi/+ ^u ,9 ! mean :ile1 in/ead ( ! seem+ diff]5ces insi/+1 & lea/ ( all betwe5 ,sci5ce & ! ) acrimony or injuri\s ,scriptures1 x w\ld be z #bfj /atem5ts ab\t o!rs1 well to re/ 9 fai? ^u ! ^u ! seem+ diff]5ces po9ts 9 :i* !y agree4 betwe5 ,sci5ce & ! ,scriptures1 x w\ld be a ?\s& times bett] to re/ 9 fai? z to our future /ate1 9 hope z to our com+ k1 & 9 *>ity z to our pres5t diff]5ces4 ,! di/9ctness ( ! fallacies is cr$itable to ! compos]s1 & %[s t sci5tific habits t5d to cle>ness1 ev5 to sophi/ry4 ,n[h]e does x s pla9ly /& out t ! ,writt5 ,^w means ! s5se 9 :i* ! accus] takes x1 :ile ! s5se ( ! o!r side is _! int]pretation4 ,! infallible *ur* on "o side1 array$ aga9/ h]etical pravity on ! o!r1 is se5 9 all subjects 9 :i* m5 diff]4 ,at s*ool !re 7 v>i\s games 9 :i* "o or ano!r advantage 0 ! "r ( ^? :o fir/ call$ = x4 ,9 adult argum5t ! same ?+ is (t5 attempt$3 we (t5 he>--,i cri$ ,*ur* fir/6 ,i end ) ! answ] :i* ,i myself gave to ! application3 its revival may possibly save me f a repetition ( ! l4 ,if !re be any?+ ,i hate m ?an ano!r x is ! proposal to place any p]sons1 especially ^? :o all[ fre$om to me1 "u any abridgm5t ( _! lib]ty to ?9k1 to inf]1 & to publi%4 ,if !y break ! law1 take ! law2 b d n make ! law3 ,greek3 agoraioi agontai enkaleitosan allelois4#daj ,i w\ld r be ask$ to take %>es 9 an argyro/]etic company 7) limit$ liability7 = break+ into h\ses by night on =k & spoon err&s4 ,i %\ld put aside ?is proposal ) no?+ b laught]4 ,x 0 a joke aga9/ ,sam ,rog]s#daa t 8 appe>ance 0 v l t ( a corpse4 ,! ,john ,bull #bfa newspap]--suppose we n[ say ,!odore ,hook#dab--;av]r$ t :5 he hail$ a coa* "o night 9 ,/4 ,paul's ,*ur*y>d1 ! j>vey said1 ,ho6 ho6 my man2 ,i'm n go+ to be tak5 9 t way3 g back to y\r grave6 ,?is is ! answ] ,i %all make = ! future to any relics ( a =m] "t :o %all want to call me (f ! /& = _! own purposes4 ,:at obligation h ,i to admit t !y belong to our _w8 ,,scripture ,,& ,,sci5ce4 ,! ,writ ,de ,ha]etico ,commis]&o4#dac ,nov4 #ad1 #ahfd4 ,?is docum5t 0 s5t to me f\r days ago4 ,x 'solicits ! favor'--,i ?\ght at fir/ x 0 a groc]'s supplication = tea & sug> patronage--( my signature to expression ( 's9c]e regret' t "s p]sons unnam$--g5]al w>rants are illegal--diff] f :at ,i am suppos$--by p]sons :om x does n conc]n--to hold ab\t ,scripture & ,sci5ce 9 _! real or alleg$ discrepancies4 ,no su* favor f me3 = ?ree reasons4 ,fir/1 ,i agree ) ,sir4 ,j4 ,h]s*el t ! solicitation is an intrusion to be publicly repell$4 ,secondly1 ,i d n regret t o!rs %\ld diff] f me1 ?9k :at ,i may3 ^? o!rs are z good z ,i1 & z well able to ?9k1 & z mu* entitl$ to _! conclusions4 ,?irdly1 ev5 if ,i did regret1 ,i %\ld be a%am$ to put my "n to bad *emi/ry made to d duty = good reason+4 ,! decl>ation is an awkw>d attempt to saturate sophism ) truism2 b ! sophism is left l>gely 9 excess4 #bfb ,i owe ! inquisitors a grudge = tak+ d[n my conceit ( myself4 ,= two mon?s ,i h cr[$ 9 my own m9d ov] my fri5d ,sir ,j4 ,h]s*el1 fancy+ t ! promot]s in/9ctively knew bett] ?an to br+ _! fallacies be=e a writ] on logic4 ,ah6 my de> ,sir ,john6 ?\ght ,i1 if y _h %[n y\rself to be well up 9 ,b>b>a ,cel>5t1#dad & _h ev] & anon a/oni%$ ! natives ) ! di/9ction betwe5 simplicit] & secundum quid1 no autograph-hunt]s w\ld h bait$ a trap ) non sequitur#dae to cat* y\r signature4 ,:at c ,i say n[8 ,i hide my dim9i%$ head1 dim9i%$ by ! horns :i* ,i h be5 compell$ to draw 94 ,^? :o make p]sonal solicitation = support to an op9ion ab\t religion are b\nd to "k _! m54 ,! k+ _h a "r to ,bro!r ,neale's money1 because ,bro!r ,neale (f]$ x4 ,_h he put 8 h& into purse aft] purse by way ( f9d+ out all :o 7 ( ,bro!r ,neale's m9d1 he w\ld h be5 ju/ly met by a rap on ! knuckles :5ev] he miss$ 8 m>k4 ,! k9d ( te/ be=e me is ! utmo/ our "t w all[ ( t inquisition into op9ion :i* has be5 ! curse ( ,*ri/ianity ev] s9ce ! ,/ate took ,provid5ce "u its protection4 ,! writ de ha]etico commis]&o is little m ?an ! smell ( ! empty cask3 & ^? :o issue x may repres5t ! old woman ) h] ,o suavis anima1 quale 9 te dicam bonum ,antehac fuisse2 tales cum s9t reliquiae4#daf ,x is no excuse t ! illegitimate bantl+ is a v little "o4 ,its p>5ts may ?9k !mselves h>dly treat$ :5 !y are call$ l9eal successors ( ,tony ,fire-!-faggot3 #bfc b1 deg5]ate ?\gh !y be1 su* is _! ance/ry4 ,let e all[ance be made = !m3 b _! unholy fire mu/ be trodd5 out2 s long z a sp>k is left1 no?+ b fuel is want$ to make a blaze4 ,if ?is _c be done1 let ! flame be conf9$ to !ology1 ?\gh ev5 !re x burns ) dim9i%$ vigor3 & let *>ity1 c&or1 s5se1 & ridicule1 be ready to play ^u x :5ev] !re is any *ance ( its ext5d+ to lit]ature & sci5ce4 ,:at w\ld be ! consequ5ce if ?is te/-sign+ absurdity 7 to gr[8 ,deep w\ld call unto deep2 c\nt]-decl>ation w\ld answ] decl>ation1 ea* /rong] ?an ! "o be=e4 ,! moves w\ld g on l ! dispute ( two ,g]man /ud5ts1 ( :om ea* is b\nd to a %>p] retort on a graduat$ scale1 until at la/ comes dumm] ,junge6#dag--;& !n !y mu/ fight4 ,!re is a g5tleman 9 ! upp] fifte5 ( ! sign]s ( ! writ--! hawk+ ( ^: names appe>s to me v bad ta/e--:om ,i met 9 cordial coop]ation = _m a ye> at a sci5tific bo>d4 ,all ,i knew ab\t 8 religion 0 t he1 z a cl]gyman1 mu/ 9 "s s5se or o!r receive ! #ci ,articles3--all t he c\ld "k ab\t m9e 0 t ,i 0 "s k9d ( h]etic1 or s reput$4 ,if we _h come to sign+ opposite manife/oes1 turn-ab\t1 we might h f\nd ourselves 9 ! l[e/ dep?s ( p>ty discussion at our v c\ncil-table4 ,i tru/ ! li/ ( subscrib]s to ! decl>ation1 :5 x comes to be publi%$1 w %[ t ! bulk ( ^? :o h really add$ to our k h se5 ! ?+ 9 its true light4 ,! promot]s--,i say no?+ ab\t ! subscrib]s--( ! movem5t w1 ,i tru/1 n feel aggriev$ at ! c\rse ,i h tak5 or ! rem>ks ,i h made4 ,walt] ,scott says t be=e we judge ,napoleon by ! temptation to :i* he yield$1 we ought to rememb] h[ mu* he may h resi/$3 ,i invite !m to apply ?is rule to myself2 !y c h no idea ( ! feel+ ) :i* ,i #bfd contemplate all attempts to repress fre$om ( inquiry1 nor ( ! loa?+ ) :i* ,i recoil f ! proposal to be art & "p4 ,!y h ask$ me to give a public op9ion ^u a c]ta9 po9t4 ,x is true t !y h _h ! k9dness to t5d] bo? ! op9ion !y wi% me to =m1 & ! %ape 9 :i* !y w\ld h x appe>3 ,i w let !m draw me out1 b ,i w n let !m take me 94 ,if !y w put an a/]isk to my "n1 & ?is lett] to ! a/]isk1 !y are welcome to my signature4 ,z ,i d n expect !m to reli% ?is proposal1 ,i w n solicit ! favor ( its adoption4 ,b !y h giv5 a "r to ?9k1 = !y h ask$ me to ?9k2 to publi%1 = !y h ask$ me to all[ !m to publi%2 to blame !m1 = !y h ask$ me to blame _! bett]s4 ,%\ld !y v5ture to f9d fault because my direction ( disapproval1 publicly giv51 is half a revolution diff]5t f !irs1 !y w be kn[n z hav+ pres5t$ a load$ docum5t at ! head ( a travel] 9 ! highway ( discussion1 )--,y\r signature or y\r sil5ce6 ,,! ,,fly-,,leaf ,,p>adox4 ,! p>adox be+ ! proposition ( some?+ :i* runs c\nt] to :at w\ld g5]ally be ?\ght likely1 may pres5t itself 9 _m ways4 ,!re is a fly-leaf p>adox1 :i* puzzl$ me = _m ye>s1 until ,i f\nd a probable solution4 ,i frequ5tly saw1 9 ! blank leaves ( old books1 le>n$ books1 ,bibles ( a "t :5 a ,bible 0 v co/ly1 etc41 ! "n ( an own] :o1 by ! h&writ+ & spell+1 mu/ h be5 an illit]ate p]son or a *ild1 foll[$ by ! date ( ! book itself4 ,accord+ly1 ?is un$ucat$ p]son or "y *ild seem$ to be ! fir/ own]1 :i* 9 _m cases 0 n cr$ible4 ,look+ "o day at a ,b>k]'s#dah ,bible ( #aeii1 ,i saw an #bfe inscription 9 a *ild's writ+1 :i* c]ta9ly belong$ to a mu* lat] date4 ,x 0 ,m>?a ,taylor1 h] book1 giu5 me by ,granny ,scott to keep = h] sake4 ,) ?is ! usual v]ses1 foll[$ by #aeii1 ! date ( ! book4 ,b x s *anc$ t ! blank page opposite ! title1 on :i* ! above 0 writt51 0 a v]so ( ! la/ leaf ( a pray] book1 :i* _h be5 b\nd be=e ! ,bible2 & on ! recto ( ?is leaf 0 a colophon1 ) ! date #afcb4 ,x /ruck me imm$iately t un$ucat$ p]sons & *ildr51 hav+ se5 dates writt5 "u names1 & n be+ q up 9 *ronology1 did frequ5tly f9i% (f ) ! date ( ! book1 :i* />$ !m 9 ! face4 ,always write 9 y\r books4 ,y may be a silly p]son--= ?\gh y\r read+ my book is r a contr>y presumption1 yet x is n conclusive--& y\r obs]vations may be silly or irrelevant1 b y _c tell :at use !y may be ( long aft] y are gone :]e ,budgete]s cease f tr\bl+4 ,i pick$ up ! foll[+ book1 pr9t$ by ,j4 ,frankl9#dai at ,bo/on1 dur+ ! p]iod 9 :i* 8 y\ng] bro!r ,b5jam9 0 8 appr5tice4 ,& z ,b5jam9 0 appr5tic$ v e>ly1 & is record$ z hav+ le>n$ ! me*anical art v rapidly1 !re is "s presumption t "p ( x may be 8 "w1 ?\gh he 0 b ?irte5 at ! "t4 ,z ?is set ( editions ( ,hodd]#dbj 7by #bff ,mose#dba7 is n m5tion$1 to my k1 ,i give ! title 9 full3 ,hodd]'s ,ari?metick3 or t necess>y art made mo/ easy3 ,be+ expla9$ 9 a way famili> to ! capacity ( any t desire to le>n x 9 a little "t4 ,by ,james ,hodd]1 ,writ+-ma/]4 ,! ,five & tw5tie? edition1 revis$1 augm5t$1 & above a ?\s& faults am5d$1 by ,h5ry ,mose1 late s]vant & successor to ! au?or4 ,bo/on3 pr9t$ by ,j4 ,frankl91 = ,s4 ,phillips1 ,n4 ,buttolph1 ,b4 ,elliot1 ,d4 ,h5*man1 ,g4 ,phillips1 ,j4 ,elliot1 & ,e4 ,negus1 booksell]s 9 ,bo/on1 & sold at _! %ops4 #agai4 ,! book is a v small octavo1 ! type & execution are cr$itable1 ! woodcut at ! beg9n+ is clumsy4 ,x is a p]fect copy1 page = page1 ( ! ,engli% editions ( ,mose's ,hodd]1 ( :i* ! "o call$ sev5te5? is ( ,london1 #afij4 ,!re is n a syllable to %[ t ! edition above describ$ might n be ( ,bo/on 9 ,engl&4 ,presumptions1 b n v /rong ones1 might be d]iv$ f ! "n ( ,frankl91 & f ! l>ge numb] ( booksell]s :o comb9$ 9 ! und]tak+4 ,x *anc$1 h[ev]1 t a =m] own] _h made ! foll[+ note 9 my copy3 ,w$nessday1 ,july ye #ad1 #agif1 att t5 9 ye =5oon we saild f ,bo/on1 came too twice1 once 9 ,k+ ,rode1 & once 9 ye ,n>r[s4 ,saild by ye ligh?\se 9 ye ev5g4 #bfg ,no ord9>y map w\ld decide ^! po9ts3 s ,i _h to apply to my fri5d ,sir ,francis ,beau=t1#dbb & ! *>ts at ! ,admiralty decid$ imm$iately = ,massa*usetts4 ,,p>adoxes ,,( ,,or?ography ,,& ,,computation4 ,! ,fr5* are able p>adox]s 9 _! spell+ ( =eign names4 ,! ,abbe ,sabati] de ,ca/res1#dbc 9 #aggb1 gives an acc\nt ( an imag9>y dialogue betwe5 ,swif1 ,adisson1 ,otwai1 & ,bol+brocke4 ,i _h hop$ t ?is 0 a ?+ ( =m] days1 l ! lit]al roa/+ ( h]etics2 b ! *>ity :i* hope? all ?+s mu/ hope = disappo9tm5ts4 ,look+ at a rec5t "w on ! hi/ory ( ! popes1 ,i f\nd ref]r$ to1 9 ! matt] ( ,urban ,,viii#dbd & ,galileo1 ref]5ces to ! works ( two ,engli%m51 ! ,rev4 ,w9 ,worewel & ! ,rev4 ,rad5 ,p[54 ,wm4 ,:ewell & ,bad5 ,p[ell4#dbe ,i mu/ n =get ! mod]ate computation p>adox4 ,?is is ! way by :i* l>ge figures are usually obta9$4 ,any?+ surpris+ly great is got by ! l[e/ computation1 any?+ z surpris+ly small by ! utmo/ computation2 & ^! are ! two great subdivisions ( mod]ate computation4 ,9 ?is way we le>n t #gj1jjj p]sons 7 execut$ 9 "o reign1 & #aej1jjj p]sons #bfh burn$ = wit*craft 9 "o c5tury4 ,sometimes ?is computation is v close4 ,by a c>d be=e me x appe>s t all ! ,*ri/ians1 includ+ ^? disp]s$ 9 hea!n c\ntries1 ^? ( ,great ,brita9 & ,irel& except$1 are #aih1gbh1jjj p1 & pay _! cl]gy #h1heb1jjjl4 ,b #f1djj1jjj p pay ! cl]gy ( ! ,anglo-,iri% ,e/abli%m5t #h1hif1jjjl42 & #ad1fjj1jjj ( o!r d5om9ations pay #a1jbd1jjjl4 ,:5 ,i read mod]ate computations1 ,i always ?9k ( ,voltaire & ! memoires du fameux eveque de ,*iapa1 p> lesquels il p>ait qu'il avait egorge1 ou brule1 ou noye dix millions d'infideles en ,am]ique p\r les conv]tir4 ,je crus que cet eveque exagg]ait2 mais qu& on r$uisait ces sacrifices a c9q millions de victimes1 cela s]ait encore admirable4#dbf ,,c5trifugal ,,=ce4 ,my ,budget has be5 arrang$ by au?ors4 ,?is is ! only plan1 = mu* ( ! rem>k is p]sonal3 ! peculi>ities ( ! p>adox] are a l>ge "p ( ! int]e/ ( ! p>adox4 ,z to subject-matt]1 !re are po9ts :i* /& /rongly out2 ! quadrature ( ! circle1 = in/ance4 ,b !re are o!rs :i* _c be drawn out s z to be conspicu\s 9 a review ( writ]s3 z "o in/ance1 ,i may take ! c5trifugal =ce4 ,:5 ,i 0 ab\t n9e ye>s old ,i 0 tak5 to he> a c\rse ( lectures1 giv5 by an it9]ant lectur] 9 a c\ntry t[n1 to get z mu* z ,i c\ld ( ! second half ( a good1 s\nd1 philosophical omnisci5ce4 ,! fir/ half 7& sometimes m7 comes by nature4 ,to ?is end ,i smelt *emicals1 le>n$ t !y 7 diff]5t k9ds ( g91 saw "y wags try to kiss ! girls "u ! excuse ( :at 0 call$ laugh+ gas--:i* ,i 0 sure #bfi 0 n to blame = m ?an five p] c5t ( ! requisite assurance--& s =?4 ,?is 0 all well s f> z x w5t2 b !re 0 also ! excessive notion ( creative p[] exhibit$ 9 ! millions ( miles ( ! sol> sy/em1 ( :i* p[] ,i wond]$ !y did n give a /ill gr&] idea by express+ ! di/ances 9 in*es4 ,b ev5 ?is 0 no?+ to ! +5i\s contrivance ( ! c5trifugal =ce4 ,y h he>d :at ,i h said ( ! wond]ful c5tripetal =ce1 by :i* ,div9e ,wisdom has reta9$ ! planets 9 _! orbits r\nd ! ,sun4 ,b1 ladies & g5tlem51 x mu/ be cle> to y t if !re 7 no o!r =ce 9 action1 ?is c5tripetal =ce w\ld draw our e>? & ! o!r planets into ! ,sun1 & univ]sal ru9 w\ld ensue4 ,to prev5t su* a cata/rophe1 ! same wisdom has implant$ a c5trifugal =ce ( ! same am\nt1 & directly opposite1 etc4 ,i _h nev] he>d ( ,alfonso ,x ( ,ca/ile1#dbg b ,i v5tur$ to ?9k t if ,div9e ,wisdom _h j let ! planets alone x w\ld come to ! same ?+1 ) equal & opposite tr\bles sav$4 ,! p>adox]s deal l>gely 9 speculation conduct$ ^u ! above explanation4 ,!y provide ext]nal ag5ts = :at !y call ! c5trifugal =ce4 ,"s make ! sun's rays keep ! planets (f1 )\t a ?\ght ab\t :at w\ld become ( our poor eyes if ! pu% ( ! light :i* falls on ! e>? 7 a c\nt]poise to all its gravitation4 ,! true explanation _c be giv5 "h1 = want ( room4 ,,cambridge ,,poets4 ,sometimes a p]son :o has a po9t to c>ry w ass]t a s+ul> fact or pr$iction = ! sake ( 8 po9t2 & #bgj ?is p>adox has almo/ obta9$ ! sole use ( ! "n4 ,p]sons :o h reputation to c>e = %\ld bew>e h[ !y adopt ?is plan1 :i* n[ & !n ev5tuates a spank]1 z ! ,am]ican editor said4 ,"l ,byron1 9 ,engli% ,b>ds1 etc4 7#ahji71 ridicul+ ,cambridge poetry1 wrote z foll[s3 ,b :]e fair ,isis rolls h] pur] wave1 ,! p>tial muse delight$ loves to lave2 ,on h] gre5 banks a gre5] wrea? %e wove1 ,to cr[n ! b>ds t haunt h] classic grove2 ,:]e ,ri*>ds#dbh wakes a g5u9e poet's fires1 ,& mod]n ,britons glory 9 _! sires4#dbi ,!re is "s acc\nt ( ! ,rev4 ,geo4 ,ri*>ds1 ,fell[ ( ,oriel & ,vic> ( ,bampton1 7,m4,a4 9 #agia7 9 ! ,liv+ ,au?ors by ,watk9s#dcj & ,%ob]l#dca 7#ahaf74 ,9 ,riv]s's ,liv+ ,au?ors1 ( #agih1 :i* is be/ fitt$ = citation1 z be+ publi%$ be=e ,"l ,byron wrote1 he is spok5 ( 9 high t]ms4 ,! ,aborig9al ,britons 0 an ,ox=d 7special7 prize poem1 ( #agia4 ,*>les ,lamb m5tions ,ri*>ds z 8 s*ool-fell[ at ,*ri/'s ,hospital1 au?or ( ! ,aborig9al ,britons1 ! mo/ spirit$ ( ! ,ox=d ,prize ,poems3 a pale1 /udi\s ,grecian4 ,z ,i nev] he>d ( ,ri*>ds z a poet1#dcb ,i conclude t 8 fame is defunct1 except 9 :at may prove to be a v ambigu\s k9d ( immortality1 conf]r$ by ,"l ,byron4 ,! awkw>dness ( a case :i* "t has brok5 d[n #bga is increas$ by ! eulogi/ himself add+ s p[]ful a "n to ! li/ ( ,cambridge poets1 t 8 college has plac$ 8 /atue 9 ! libr>y1 m conspicu\sly ?an t ( ,newton 9 ! *apel2 & ?is al?\gh ! greatness ( poetic fame _h "s s]i\s drawbacks 9 ! moral "* ( "s ( 8 writ+s4 ,& x w be f\nd on inquiry t ,byron1 to get 8 in/ance aga9/ ,cambridge1 _h to g back eighte5 ye>s1 pass+ ov] sev5 int]m$iate productions1 ( :i* he _h ei!r nev] he>d1 or :i* he w\ld n cite z wak+ a g5u9e poet's fires4 ,! conclusion seems to be t ! ,aborig9al ,britons is a rem>kable y\?ful production1 n equall$ by subsequ5t ef=ts4 ,to enhance ! position 9 :i* ! satiri/ plac$ himself1 two ?+s %\ld be rememb]$4 ,fir/1 ! gl[+ & ju/ifiable t]ms 9 :i* ,byron _h spok51--a hundr$ & odd l9es be=e he f\nd x conv5i5t to say no ,cambridge poet c\ld comp>e ) ,ri*>ds1--( a ,cambridge poet :o di$ only ?ree ye>s be=e ,byron wrote1 & produc$ greatly admir$ works :ile actually /udy+ 9 ! ,univ]sity4 ,! fame ( ,kirke ,:ite#dcc /ill lives2 & future lit]>y critics may p]haps comp>e 8 writ+s & ^? ( ,ri*>ds1 simply by reason ( ! curi\s relation 9 :i* !y are "h plac$ alongside ( ea* o!r4 ,& x is mu* to ,byron's cr$it t1 9 speak+ ( ! deceas$ ,cambridge poet1 he =got 8 own argum5t & its exig5cies1 & prov$ himself only a p>adox] pro re nata4 ,secondly1 ,byron 0 v un=tunate 9 ano!r passage ( ! same poem3 #bgb ,:at v>i$ wond]s tempt u z !y pass6 ,! c[-pox1 tractors1 galvanism1 & gas4 ,9 turns appe>1 to make ! vulg> />e1 ,till ! swoln bubble bur/s--& all is air6 ,?ree ( ! bubbles h bur/ to mighty ends4 ,! metallic tractors are disus$2 b ! =ce :i*1 if any?+1 !y put 9 action1 is at ?is day1 "u ! "n ( mesm]ism1 us$1 prohibit$1 respect$1 scorn$1 assail$1 def5d$1 ass]t$1 d5i$1 decl>$ utt]ly obscure1 & univ]sally kn[n4 ,x 0 h>d l9es to select = c&idates = oblivion n "o ( :om got 94 ,i %all myself1 ,i am assur$1 be "s day cit$ = laugh+ at ! great discov]y ( ----3 ! blank is left = my read] to fill up 9 8 own way2 b ,i ?9k ,i %all n be s unlucky 9 f\r diff]5t ways4 ,,falsifi$ ,,pr$iction4 ,! n>ration be=e ! fact1 z prophecy has be5 call$1 sometimes q z true z ! n>ration aft] ! fact1 is v ridicul\s :5 x is wrong4 ,:y1 ! pre-n>rator c\ld n "k2 ! po/-n>rator might h kn[n4 ,a good collection ( unlucky pr$ictions might be made3 ,i h>dly "k "o s fit to g ) ,byron's z t ( ! ,rev4 ,daniel ,riv]s1 already quot$1 ab\t ,johnson's biograph]s4 ,pet] ,p9d>#dcd may be excus$1 z p]sonal satire 0 8 object1 = address+ ,boswell & ,mrs4 ,piozzi#dce z foll[s3 ,in/ead ( add+ spl5dor to 8 "n1 ,y\r books are d[nright gibbets to 8 fame2 ,y nev] ) po/]ity c ?rive1 ',tis by ! ,rambl]'s dea? alone y live4 ,b ,riv]s1 9 prose n>rative1 0 n s excusable4 ,he says3 #bgc ,z admir]s ( ! le>n+ & moral excell5ce ( _! h]o1 we gl[ at almo/ e page ) indignation t 8 weaknesses & 8 fail+s %\ld be disclos$ to public view4444 ,johnson1 aft] ! lu/] he _h reflect$ on ! "n ( ,?rale 444 0 to h 8 memory tortur$ & abus$ by h] dete/$ it* = scribbl+4 ,m injury1 we w v5ture to affirm1 has be5 done to ! fame ( ,johnson by ?is ,lady & h] late biographical helpmate1 ?an 8 mo/ av[$ enemies h be5 able to effect3 & if 8 "* becomes unpopul> ) "s ( 8 successors1 x is to ^? gossip+ fri5ds he is indebt$ = ! favor4 ,poor de> old ,sam6 ! be/ kn[n dead man alive6 clev]1 good-he>t$1 logical1 ugly be>6 ,:]e w\ld he h be5 if x _h n be5 = ,boswell & ,?rale1 & _! imitators8 ,:at w\ld biography h be5 if ,boswell _h n %[n h[ to write a life8 ,riv]s is to be comm5d$ = n ?r[+ a s+le ,/one at ,mrs4 ,?rale's second m>riage4 ,?is poor lady beg9s to receive a little ju/ice4 ,! lit]>y _w seems to h f\nd out t a blue-/ock+ dame :o keeps op5 h\se = a set among !m has a "r1 if x s please h]1 to m>ry aga9 )\t tak+ measures to c>ry on ! cake-%op4 ,i 0 be=e my age 9 ?is respect3 z a boy-read] ( ,boswell1 & a few o!r ?+s t fell 9 my way1 ,i came to a cle>ness t ! conduct ( society t[>ds ,mrs4 ,piozzi 0 blackgu>d4 ,%e want$ no?+ b :at 0 9 t day a woman's only effici5t protection1 a male relation ) a brace ( pi/ols1 & a compet5t notion ( us+ !m4 ,,byron ,,& ,,wordswor?4 ,byron's mi/ake ab\t ,hallam 9 ! ,p9d> /ory may be wor? plac+ among absurdities4 ,= elucidation1 suppose t "s poet 7 n[ to speak-- #bgd ,( man's fir/ disob$i5ce1 & ! fruit ,eve gave to ,adam 9 8 bir?day suit-- & "s critic 7 to call x nons5se1 w\ld t critic be laugh+ at ,milton8 ,payne ,knight1#dcf 9 8 ,ta/e1 translat$ "p ( ,gray's ,b>d into ,greek4 ,"s ( 8 l9es are ,greek3 !rma d' ho t5gon dakrua /ona*ais ,greek3 oulon melos phob]ai ,greek3 eeide phonai4 ,lit]ally ?us3 ,wett+ w>m te>s ) groans1 ,cont9u\s *ant ) fe>ful ,voice he sang4 ,on :i* ,hallam rem>ks3 ,! twelf? l9e our fir/ is nons5se4 ,& s x is1 a poet c no m wet 8 te>s ) 8 groans ?an wet 8 ale ) 8 :i/le4 ,n[ ?is fir/ l9e is f ,p9d>1 b is only "p ( ! s5se2 9 full x is3 ,greek3 !rma de t5gon dakrua /ona*ais ,greek3 hor?ion phonase4 ,p9d>'s ,greek3 t5gon mu/ be ,engli%$ by %$d+1 & he /&s alone 9 ?is use4 ,he says1 %$d+ w>m te>s1 he cri$ out l\d1 ) groans4 ,byron speaks ( ,classic ,hallam1 mu* r5[n$ = ,greek3 & repres5ts him z criticis+ ! ,greek ( all ,payne's l9es1 & n discov]+ t ! l9es 7 ,p9d>'s #bge until aft] publication4 ,byron 0 too mu* ( a s*ol> to make ?is blund] himself3 he ei!r accept$ ! facts f report1 or else took satirical lic5ce4 ,& :y n8 ,if y want to laugh at a p]son1 & he w n give occasion1 ^: fault is x t y are oblig$ to make x8 ,hallam did criticise "s ( ,payne ,knight's ,greek2 b ) ! caution ( 8 "*1 he rem>k$ t possibly "s ( ^! que] phrases might be critic-traps ju/ifi$ by "s "o use ( "s "o au?or4 ,i rememb] well hav+ a ,lat9 essay to write at ,cambridge1 9 :i* ,i took c>e to ins]t a few mon/r\s & unusual idioms f ,cic]o3 a p]son ) a ,nizolius1#dcg & )\t scruples may get scores ( !m4 ,s :5 my tutor rais$ 8 voice aga9/ ^! oddities1 ,i 0 up to him1 = ,i came d[n ^u him ) ,cic]o1 *apt] & v]se1 & got r\nd him4 ,& s my own solecisms1 _m ( !m1 pass$ un*all5g$4 ,byron _h m good 9 8 nature ?an he 0 fond ( lett+ out3 :e!r he 0 a s\r$ misan?rope1 or :e!r 8 ve9 lay t way 9 poetry1 & he felt x necess>y to fit 8 demeanor to x1 are matt]s f> beyond me4 ,mr4 ,crabb ,rob9son#dch told me ! foll[+ /ory m ?an once4 ,he 0 at ,*>les ,lamb's *amb]s 9 ! ,temple :5 ,wordswor? came 91 ) ! new ,ed9burgh ,review 9 8 h&1 & fume on 8 c\nt5ance4 ,^! review]s1 said he1 put me out ( pati5ce6 ,"h is a "y man--!y say he is a "l--:o has writt5 a volume ( poetry2 & ^! fell[s1 j because he is a "l1 set ^u him1 laugh at him1 & sne] at 8 writ+4 ,! "y man w d some?+1 if he goes on z he has begun4 ,b ^! review]s seem to ?9k #bgf t nobody may write poetry1 unless he lives 9 a g>ret4 ,crabb ,rob9son told ?is long aft] to ,lady ,byron1 :o said1 ,ah6 if ,byron _h kn[n t1 he w\ld nev] h attack$ ,wordswor?4 ,he w5t "o day to meet ,wordswor? at d9n]2 :5 he came home ,i said1 ',well1 h[ did ! "y poet get on ) ! old "o8' ',:y1 to tell y ! tru?1' said he1 ',i _h b "o feel+ f ! beg9n+ ( ! visit to ! end1 & t 0--rev]5ce6' ,lady ,byron told my wife t h] husb& _h a v great respect = ,wordswor?4 ,i suppose he w\ld h said--z ! ,ar*angel said to 8 ,satan--,our diff]5ce is poli etical4 ,i suspect t ,field+ w\ld1 if all 7 kn[n1 be rank$ among ! unlucky rail]s at suppos$ p>adox4 ,9 8 ,miscellanies 7#agdb1 #hvo7 he wrote a satire on ! ,*rysippus or ,gu9ea1 an animal :i* multiplies itself by division1 l ! polypus4 ,?is he supposes to h be5 drawn up by ,petrus ,gualt]us1 mean+ ! fam\s usur]1 ,pet] ,walt]4 ,he calls x a pap] prop] to be read be=e ! ,r----l ,society3 & next ye>1 #agdc1 a qu>to repr9t 0 made to resemble a pap] 9 ! ,philosophical ,transactions4 ,s f> z ,i c make out1 "o object is ridicule ( :at ! zoologi/s said ab\t ! polypus3 a repr9t 9 ! =m ( ! ,transactions 0 c]ta9ly satire on ! ,society1 n on ,pet] ,walt] & 8 knack ( multiply+ gu9eas4 ,old poets h recogniz$ ! quadrature ( ! circle z a well-kn[n difficulty4 ,dante comp>es himself1 :5 bewild]$1 to a geomet] :o _c f9d ! pr9ciple on :i* ! circle is to be measur$3 ,quale e 'l geometra *e tutto s' affige ,p] misur> lo c]*io1 e non ritruova1 ,p5s&o qual pr9cipio ond' egli indige4#dci #bgg ,& ,qu>les#ddj speaks z foll[s ( ! summum bonum3 ,or is't a t>t idea1 to procure ,an edge1 & keep ! practic s\l 9 ure1 ,l t de> *ymic du/1 or puzzl+ quadrature8 ,! poetic notion ( ! quadrature mu/ n be =gott54 ,ari/ophanes1 9 ! ,birds1 introduces a geomet] :o ann\nces 8 int5tion to make a squ>e circle4 ,pope1 9 ! ,dunciad1 deliv]s himself z foll[s1 ) a ,greek pronunciation r /range 9 a translator ( ,hom]4 ,probably ,pope recogniz$1 z a g5]al rule1 ! v common practice ( ?r[+ back ! acc5t 9 defiance ( quantity1 se5 9 o'rator1 au'ditor1 se'nator1 ca't5>y1 etc4 ,mad ,ma!sis alone 0 unconf9$1 ,too mad = m]e mat]ial *a9s to b9d1-- ,n[ to pure space lifts h] ec/atic />e1 ,n[1 runn+ r\nd ! circle1 f9ds x squ>e4 ,! au?or's note expla9s t ?is reg>ds ! wild & fruitless attempts ( squ>+ ! circle4 ,! poetic idea seems to be t ! geomet]s try to make a squ>e circle4 ,disraeli quotes x z f9ds its squ>e1 b ! orig9als d n support ?is read+4 ,,de ,,bec\rt4 ,i h come 9 ! way ( a "w1 entitl$ ,! ,grave ( ,human ,philosophies 7#ahbg71 translat$ f ! ,fr5* ( ,r4 de ,bec\rt#dda by ,a4 ,dalmas4 ,x supports1 b ,i suspect n v accurately1 ! views ( ! old ,h9du books4 #bgh ,t ! sun is only #dej miles f u1 & only #dj miles 9 diamet]1 may be pass$ ov]2 my affair is ) ! /ate ( m9d into :i* p]sons ( ,m4 ,bec\rt's temp]am5t are br\ght by a fancy4 ,he fully grants1 z c]ta91 f\r millions ( ye>s z ! duration ( ! ,h9du race1 & #aief z t ( ! univ]se4 ,x mu/ be admitt$ he is n :olly wrong 9 say+ t our errors ab\t ! univ]se proce$ f our ignorance ( its orig91 antiquity1 organization1 laws1 & f9al de/9ation4 ,liv+ 9 an age ( light1 he avails himself ( t opportunity to remove ?is veil ( d>kness1 etc4 ,! sy/em ( ! ,brahm9s is ! only true "o3 he adds t x has nev] be=e be5 attempt$1 z x c\ld n be obta9$ except by him4 ,! au?or reque/s u fir/1 to lay aside prejudice2 next1 to read all he says 9 ! ord] 9 :i* he says x3 we may !n pron\nce judgm5t ^u a "w :i* beg9s by tak+ ! ,brahm9s = grant$4 ,all ! p>adox]s make ! same reque/s4 ,!y d n see t compliance w\ld br+ ?\s&s ( sy/ems be=e ! _w e ye>3 we h scores z x is4 ,h[ is a poor c&id inquir] to *oose4 ,=tunately1 ! m9d has its gr& jury z well z its little "o3 & x w n put a book ^u its trial )\t a prima facie case 9 its favor4 ,& ) mo/ ( ^? :o really se>* = !mselves1 t case is nev] made out )\t evid5ce ( k1 /&+ out cle> & /rong1 9 ! book to be exam9$4 ,,beque/ ,,( ,a ,,quadrature4 ,!re is mu* private hi/ory :i* w nev] come to light1 c>et quia vate sacro1#ddb because no ,budgete] comes across x4 ,_m ye>s ago a man ( bus9ess1 ^: life 0 pass$ 9 bank+1 amus$ 8 leisure ) quadrature1 0 successful ( c\rse1 & bequea!d ! result 9 a seal$ book1 :i* ! legatee 0 enjo9$ n to sell #bgi "u a ?\s& p\nds4 ,! true ratio 0 #c4adaf3 ,i h ! anecdote f ! legatee's executor1 :o op5$ ! book4 ,t a bank] %\ld squ>e ! circle is v cr$ible3 b h[ c\ld a ,city man come by ! notion t a ?\s& p\nds c\ld be got = x8 ,a fri5d ( m9e1 "o ( ! tw9s ( my zodiac1 w sp5d a ?\s& p\nds1 if he h n done x already1 9 black & :ite cyclometry3 b ,i w answ] = x t he1 a man ( s\nd bus9ess notions1 nev] ent]ta9$ ! idea ( pi rec\p+ him1 z !y n[ say4 ,i speak ( individual success3 ( c\rse if a company 7 =m$1 especially if x 7 ( unlimit$ lie-ability1 ! %>es w\ld be tak54 ,no (f5ce2 !re is no?+ b :at a pun w ei!r sanctify1 ju/ify1 or nullify3 ,x comes o'er ! s\l l ! sweet ,s\? ,t brea!s ^u a bank ( vile hits4 ,! %>es w\ld be at a premium ( #c-a_/h on ! day aft] issue4 ,if !y pres5t$ me ) ! numb] ( %>es ,i des]ve1 = sugge/ion & adv]tisem5t1 ,i %\ld /& up = ! ,ar*prie/ ( ,/4 ,vitus#ddc & #c-a_/e1 ) a view to a little m gold on ! bridge4 ,i n[ ins]t a c\ple ( reviews1 "o ab\t ,cyclopa$ias1 "o ab\t epi/ol>y collections4 ,%\ld any read] wi% = explanation ( ?is ins]tion1 ,i ask him to reflect a mom5t1 & imag9e me set to ju/ify all ! additions n[ be=e him6 ,9 tru? ^! reviews are ! repositories ( _m odds & ends3 !y 7 n made to ! books2 ! mat]ials 7 9 my notes1 & ! books came z to a ready-made clo!s %op1 & f\nd :at w\ld fit !m4 ,_m rememb] ,curll's#ddd beque/ ( "s v good titles #bhj :i* only want$ treatises writt5 to !m4 ,well6 "h 7 "s tol]able reviews--z times g--:i* only want$ books fitt$ to !m4 ,accord+ly1 "s tags 7 made to jo9 on ! books2 & !n z ! read] sees4 ,i %\ld f9d x h>d to expla9 :y ! ins]tion is made 9 ?is place r ?an ano!r4 ,b aga91 suppose ,i 7 put to make su* an explanation ?r\gh\t ! volume4 ,! improv] :o laid out gr\nds & always /udi$ :at he call$ unexpect$ness1 0 ask$ :at "n he gave x = ^? :o walk$ ov] 8 gr\nds a second "t4 ,he 0 sil5c$2 b ,i h an answ]3 ,x is t :i* is giv5 by ! v proc$ure ( tak+ up my book a second "t4 ,,review ,,( ,,cyclopa$ias4 ,octob] #ai1 #ahfa4 ,! ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia4 ,conduct$ by ,*>les ,knight4#dde #bb vols43 viz41 ,geography1 #d vols42 ,biography1 #f vols42 ,natural ,hi/ory1 #d vols42 ,arts & ,sci5ces1 #h vols4 7,bradbury ,evans47 ,! ,encyclopa$ia ,britannica3 a ,diction>y ( ,arts1 ,sci5ces1 & ,g5]al ,lit]ature4 ,eigh? ,edition4 #ba vols4 & ,index4 7,black47 ,! two editions above describ$ are complet$ at ! same "t3 & !y /& at ! head ( ! two great bran*es into :i* pantological und]tak+s are divid$1 z at once ! l>ge/ & ! be/ ( _! classes4 ,:5 ! works are br\ght toge!r1 ! fir/ ?+ t /rikes ! eye is ! syllable ( diff]5ce 9 ! names4 ,! ^w ,cyclopa$ia is a bit ( mod]n purism4 ,?\gh ,greek3 enkuklopaideia#ddf is n absolutely ,greek ( ,greece1 we le>n f bo? ,pl9y#ddg & ,qu9tilian#ddh t ! circle #bha ( ! sci5ces 0 s call$ by ! ,greeks1 & ,vitruvius#ddi has !nce naturaliz$ encyclium 9 ,lat94 ,nev]!less we admit t ! initial en w\ld h euphoniz$ b badly ) ! ^w ,p5ny3 & ! ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia is ! augm5t$1 revis$1 & di/ribut$ edition ( ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia4 ,x has inde$ be5 said t ,cyclopa$ia %\ld mean ! education ( a circle1 j z ,cyropa$ia is ! education ( ,cyrus4 ,b ?is is easily upset by ,ari/otle's ^w ,greek3 kuklophoria1#dej motion 9 a circle1 & by _m o!r cases1 = :i* see ! lexicon4 ,! e>lie/ pr9t$ ,encyclopa$ia ( ?is k9d 0 p]haps ! fam\s myrr\r ( ! worlde1 :i* ,caxton#dea translat$ f ! ,fr5* & pr9t$ 9 #adhj4 ,! orig9al ,lat9 is ( ! ?irte5? c5tury1 or e>li]4 ,?is is a collection ( v %ort treatises4 ,9 or %ortly aft] #adif appe>$ ! ,m>g>ita ,philosophica ( ,gregory ,reis*1#deb ! same we mu/ suppose1 :o 0 confessor to ! ,emp]or ,maximilian4#dec ,?is is aga9 a collection ( treatises1 ( mu* m pret5sion3 & ! e/imation =m$ ( x is prov$ by ! numb] ( editions x w5t ?r\gh4 ,9 #aeca appe>$ ! little collection ( works ( ,r+elb]g1#ded :i* is truly call$ an ,encyclopa$ia by #bhb ,morh(1 ?\gh ! ?umbs & f+]s ( ! two h&s w meet ov] ! l5g? ( its "o volume4 ,!re are m small collections2 b we pass on to ! fir/ "w to :i* ! "n ( ,encyclopa$ia is giv54 ,?is is a pond]\s ,sci5ti>um ,omnium ,encyclopa$ia ( ,al/$1#dee 9 f\r folio volumes1 commonly b\nd 9 two3 publi%$ 9 #afbi & aga9 9 #afdi2 ! true p>5t ( all ! ,encyclopa$ias1 or collections ( treatises1 or works 9 :i* t "* pr$om9ates4 ,! fir/ great diction>y may p]haps be tak5 to be ,h(man's ,lexicon ,univ]sale#def 7#afgg72 b ,*amb]s's#deg 7s call$7 ,diction>y 7#agbh7 has a bett] claim4 ,& we support our propos$ nom5clature by obs]v+ t ,al/$ accid5tally call$ 8 "w ,encyclopa$ia1 & ,*amb]s simply ,cyclopa$ia4 ,we %all make "o little extract f ! myrr\r1 & "o f ,r+elb]g4 ,caxton's au?or makes a s+ul> rem>k = 8 "t2 & "o well wor?y ( att5tion4 ,! gramm> rules ( a language1 he says1 mu/ h be5 inv5t$ by =eign]s3 ,& :an any su*e tonge 0 p]fytely _h & usyd amonge any p1 ?an o!r p n us$ to ! same tonge caus$ rulys to be made :]by !y myght l]ne ! same tonge 444 & su*e rulys be call$ ! gram] ( t tonge4 ,r+elb]g says t if ! "r no/ril ble$1 ! little f+] ( ! "r h& %\ld be crook$1 & squeez$ ) great =ce2 & ! same = ! left4 #bhc ,we pass on to ! ,encyclop$ie1#deh comm5c$ 9 #agea2 ! "w :i* has1 9 _m m9ds1 connect$ ! ^w encyclopa$i/ ) t ( infidel4 ,read]s ( our day are surpris$ :5 !y look into ?is "w1 & wond] :at has become ( all ! irreligion4 ,! tru? is1 t ! "w--?\gh d5\nc$ ab ovo#dei on acc\nt ( ! "* ( its support]s--0 nei!r adapt$1 nor int5d$1 to excite any p>ticul> rem>k on ! subject3 no "w ( :i* ,d',alemb]t#dfj 0 co-editor w\ld h be5 />t$ on any su* plan4 ,=1 fir/1 he 0 a real sceptic3 t is1 d\btful1 ) a m9d n made up4 ,next1 he valu$ 8 quiet m ?an any?+2 & w\ld z soon h gone to sleep ov] an hornet's ne/ z h contemplat$ a sy/ematic attack ^u ei!r religion or gov]nm5t4 ,z to ,did]ot#dfa--( ^: v>i$ c>e] ( ?\ght x is difficult to fix ! "* ( any "o mom5t1 b :o is v frequ5tly tak5 among u = a pure a!i/--we w quote "o s5t5ce f ! article ,encyclop$ie1 :i* he wrote himself3--,dans le moral1 il n'y a que ,dieu qui doit s]vir de modele a #a';homme2 dans les art1 que la nature4#dfb ,a great _m read]s 9 our c\ntry h b a v hazy idea ( ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! political ,encyclopa$ia1 z we may call x1 & ! ,encyclop$ie ,me?odique1#dfc :i* we always take to be meant--:e!r rightly or n we _c tell--:5 we he> ( ! great ,fr5* ,encyclopa$ia4 ,?is "w1 :i* takes mu* f its #bhd pr$ecessor1 pr(ess+ to correct x1 0 begun 9 #agib1 & f9i%$ 9 #ahcb4 ,!re are #aff volumes ( text1 & #fdci plates1 :i* are sometimes incorporat$ ) ! text1 sometimes make ab\t #dj m volumes4 ,?is is /ill ! mon/] production ( ! k9d2 ?\gh probably ! ,g]man ,cyclopa$ia ( ,ers* & ,grub]1#dfd :i* 0 begun 9 #ahah1 & is /ill 9 progress1 w beat x 9 size4 ,! great ,fr5* "w is a collection ( diction>ies2 x consi/s ( ,cyclopa$ias ( all ! sep>ate bran*es ( k4 ,x is n a "w1 b a collection ( works1 "o or ano!r dep>tm5t is to be b\ght f "t to "t2 b we nev] he>d ( a complete set = sale 9 "o lot4 ,z %ips gr[ long] & long]1 ! "q arises :at limit !re is to ! l5g?4 ,"o answ] is1 t x w nev] d to try su* a l5g? t ! /]n w be rott5 be=e ! pr[ is f9i%$4 ,?is :olesome rule has n be5 att5d$ to 9 ! matt] be=e u2 ! e>li] p>ts ( ! great ,fr5* "w 7 antiquat$ be=e ! :ole 7 complet$3 some?+ ( ! k9d w happ5 to t ( ,ers* & ,grub]4 ,! production ( a great diction>y ( ei!r ( ! k9ds is f> f an easy task4 ,!re is "o way ( manag+ ! ,encyclopa$ia :i* has be5 l>gely resort$ to2 inde$1 we may say t no su* "w has be5 free f x4 ,?is plan is to ?r[ all ! att5tion ^u ! great treatises1 & to resort to pa/e & scissors1 or "s process ( equally easy "*1 = ! small] articles4 ,h[ev] x may be done1 x has be5 ! rule t ! ,encyclopa$ia ( treatises %\ld h its supplem5tal ,diction>y ( a v incomplete "*4 ,x is true t ! treatises are int5d$ to d a good deal2 & t ! ,index1 if x be good1 knits ! treatises & ! diction>y into "o :ole ( ref]5ce4 ,/ill !re are two /ools1 & betwe5 !m a great deal w fall to ! gr\nd4 ,! diction>y portion ( ! ,britannica is n to be comp>$ ) its #bhe treatises2 ! "p call$ ,miscellane\s & ,lexicographical 9 ! ,metropolitana#dfe is a great failure4 ,! defect is incomplet5ess4 ,! biographical portion1 = example1 ( ! ,britannica is v defective3 ( _m names ( note 9 lit]ature & sci5ce1 :i* become kn[n to ! read] f ! treatises1 !re is no acc\nt :atev] 9 ! diction>y4 ,s t ! read] :o has le>nt ! results ( a life 9 a/ronomy1 = example1 mu/ g to "s o!r "w to "k :5 t life began & end$4 ,?is defect has run ?r\gh all ! editions2 x is 9 ! ca/+ ( ! "w4 ,! read] mu/ le>n to take ! results at _! true value1 :i* is n small4 ,he mu/ accu/om himself to reg>d ! ,britannica z a spl5did body ( treatises on all t c be call$ heads ( k1 bo? great] & small]2 ) help f ! accompany+ diction>y1 b n ( ! mo/ complete "*4 ,practically1 we believe1 ?is defect _c be avoid$3 two plans ( ess5tially diff]5t /ructure _c be associat$ on ! condition ( ea* or ei!r be+ all[$ to abbreviate ! o!r4 ,! defect ( all o!rs :i* x is mo/ difficult to avoid is inequality ( p]=mance4 ,take any diction>y y please1 ( any k9d :i* requires ! association ( a numb] ( contributors1 & ?is defect mu/ result4 ,we d n m]ely mean t "s w d _! "w bett] ?an o!rs2 ?is ( c\rse3 we mean t !re w be /ructural diff]5ces ( execution1 affect+ ! relative ext5t ( ! diff]5t p>ts ( ! :ole1 z well z e o!r po9t by :i* a "w c be judg$4 ,a wise editor w n attempt any /rong measures ( correction3 he w rememb] t if "s portions be bel[ ! re/1 :i* is a disadvantage1 x foll[s t "s portions mu/ be above ! re/1 :i* is an advantage4 ,! only practical level1 if #bhf level !re mu/ be1 is t ( m$iocrity1 if n ( absolute wor?lessness3 any attempt to secure equality ( /r5g? w result 9 equality ( weakness4 ,effici5t developm5t may be cut d[n into meag] brevity1 & 9 ?is way only c app>5t equality ( plan be secur$ ?r\gh\t4 ,x is f> pref]able to c\nt ^u diff]5ces ( execution1 & to proce$ ^u ! ackn[l$g$ expectation t ! prom95t m]its ( ! "w w be settl$ by ! accid5tal "* ( ! contributors2 x be+ held impossible t any editorial ef=ts c secure a uni=m /&>d ( goodness4 ,:]ev] ! greate/ p[] is f\nd1 x %\ld be suff]$ to produce its natural effect4 ,!re are1 inde$1 critics :o ?9k t ! m]it ( a book1 l ! /r5g? ( a *a91 is t ( its weake/ "p3 b !re are o!rs :o "k t ! p>allel does n hold1 & :o w rememb] t ! union ( _m writ]s mu/ %[ exagg]ation ( ! inequalities :i* almo/ always exi/ 9 ! production ( "o p]son4 ,! true plan is to fo/] all ! good t c be got1 & to give developm5t 9 ! directions 9 :i* mo/ res\rces are f\nd3 a ,cyclopa$ia1 l a plant1 %\ld gr[ t[>ds ! light4 ,! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia _h its %>e ( ?is k9d ( defect or excell5ce1 accord+ to ! way 9 :i* ! measure is tak54 ,! circum/ance is n s mu* notic$ z might be expect$1 & ?is because _m a p]son is 9 ! habit ( us+ su* a diction>y *iefly ) relation to "o subject1 8 own2 & m /ill want x = ! pure diction>y purpose1 :i* does n g mu* beyond ! mean+ ( ! ^w4 ,b ! p]son ( full & v>i$ ref]5ce feels ! diff]5ces2 & criticism makes capital ( !m4 ,! ,useful ,k ,society 0 always odi\s to ! organs ( religi\s bigotry2 & "o ( !m1 adv]t+ to ! fact t geography 0 treat$ ) great ability1 & mo/ unusual fullness1 9 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia1 ann\nc$ x by mak+ x ! sole m]it ( #bhg ! "w t1 ) suffici5t addition1 x w\ld make a tol]ably good gazette]4 ,"s ( our read]s may /ill h hang+ ab\t !m ! feel+s d]iv$ f ?is old repugnance ( a class to all t did n associate direct doctr9al tea*+ ( religion ) e attempt to communicate k4 ,i w take "o m in/ance1 by way ( po9t+ out ! ext5t to :i* /upidity c g4 ,if !re be an a/ronomical fact ( ! telescopic "* :i*1 next aft] ,saturn's r+ & ,jupit]'s satellites1 0 kn[n to all ! _w1 x 0 ! exi/5ce ( multitudes ( d\ble />s1 treble />s1 etc4 ,a respectable qu>t]ly ( ! !ological ca/1 :i* 9 m]cy we refra9 f nam+1 0 ignorant ( ?is common k1--imag9$ t ! m5tion ( su* sy/ems 0 a blund] ( "o ( ! writ]s 9 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia1 & la%$ ! presum$ ignorance ( ! /atem5t 9 ! foll[+ words1 deliv]$ 9 ,april1 #ahcg3 ,we h =gott5 ! "n ( t ,sidrophel :o lately discov]$ t ! fix$ />s 7 n s+le />s1 b appe> 9 ! heav5s l soles at ,bill+sgate1 9 pairs2 :ile a second a/ronom]1 "u ! influ5ce ( t competition 9 trade :i* ! political economi/s tell u is s advantage\s to ! public1 pr(esses to %[ u1 ?r\gh 8 sup]ior telescope1 t ! app>5tly s+le />s are really ?ree4 ,be=e su* wondr\s m&>9s ( sci5ce1 h[ cont9ually mu/ homunculi l ourselves keep 9 ! backgr\nd1 le/ we come betwe5 ! w9d & _! nobility4 ,c]ta9ly ^! little m5 ought to h kept 9 ! backgr\nd2 b !y did n3 & ! gr[+ reputation ( ! "w :i* !y assail$ has *ronicl$ !m 9 lit]>y hi/ory2 grubs 9 amb]4 ,?is important matt] ( inequality1 :i* has l$ u s f>1 is "o to :i* ! ,encyclopa$ia is z subject z ! ,cyclopa$ia2 b x is n s easily recogniz$ z a fault4 #bhh ,we receive ! fir/ book z ma9ly a collection ( treatises3 we "k _! au?ors1 & we treat !m z individuals4 ,we see1 = in/ance1 ! names ( two lead+ writ]s on ,optics1 ,brew/]#dff & ,h]s*el4#dfg ,x w\ld n at all surprise u if ei!r ( ^! writ]s %\ld be f\nd criticis+ ! o!r by "n1 ev5 ?\gh ! v view oppos$ %\ld be conta9$ 9 ! same ,encyclopa$ia ) ! criticism4 ,& 9 l mann]1 we %\ld hold x no wond] if we f\nd "s ?ird writ] n comp>able to ei!r ( ^? we h nam$4 ,x is n s 9 ! ,cyclopa$ia3 "h we d n "k ! au?or1 except by inf]5ce f a li/ ( :i* we nev] ?9k :ile consult+ ! "w4 ,we d n diss5t f ?is or t au?or3 we blame ! book4 ,! ,encyclopa$ia ,britannica is an old fri5d4 ,?\gh x holds a pr\d place 9 our pres5t lit]ature1 yet ! "t 0 :5 x /ood by itself1 m complete & m cle> ?an any?+ :i* 0 to be f\nd else:]e4 ,!re mu/ be /udi\s m5 alive 9 pl5ty :o rememb] :5 !y 7 /udi\s boys1 :at a lit]>y luxury x 0 to pass a few days 9 ! h\se ( a fri5d :o _h a copy ( ?is "w4 ,! pres5t edition is a wor?y successor ( ^? :i* w5t be=e4 ,! la/ ?ree editions1 t]m9at+ 9 #ahbd1 #ahdb1 & #ahfa1 seem to %[ t a lun> cycle _c pass )\t an am5d$ & augm5t$ edition4 ,detail$ criticism is out ( ! "q2 b we may notice ! effective cont9uance ( ! plan ( giv+ g5]al hi/orical diss]tations on ! progress ( k4 ,( "s ( ^! diss]tations we h _h to take sep>ate notice2 & all w be ref]r$ to 9 our ord9>y treatm5t ( curr5t lit]ature4#dfh ,! lit]>y excell5ce ( ^! two ext5sive und]tak+s is ( ! same high "*4 ,to _m ?is w #bhi ne$ ju/ification3 !y w n easily conc$e to ! *eap & rec5t "w a "r to /& on ! same %elf ) ! old & tri$ magaz9e1 newly repl5i%$ ) ! be/ ( ev]y?+4 ,^? :o are cognizant by use ( ! k9d ( mat]ial :i* fills ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia w ne$ no fur!r evid5ce3 to o!rs we %all quote a v rem>kable & c]ta9ly v complete te/imony4 ,! ,cyclopa$ia ( ! ,physical ,sci5ces1 publi%$ by ,dr4 ,ni*ol#dfi 9 #aheg 7notic$ by u1 ,april #d71 is "o ( ! mo/ orig9al ( our special diction>ies4 ,! foll[+ is an extract f ! editor's preface3 ,:5 ,i ass5t$ to ,mr4 ,griff9's proposal t ,i %\ld edit su* a ,cyclopa$ia1 ,i _h x 9 my m9d t ,i might make ! scissors em95tly effective4 ,alas6 on n>r[ly exam9+ our be/ ,cyclopa$ias1 ,i f\nd t ! scissors _h become blunt$ ?r\gh too frequ5t & vigor\s use4 ,"o great exception exi/s3 viz41 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia ( ,*>les ,knight4#dgj ,! *eape/ & ! lea/ pret5d+1 x is really ! mo/ philosophical ( our sci5tific diction>ies4 ,x is n made up ( a s]ies ( treatises1 "s good & _m indiff]5t1 b is a ?or\gh ,diction>y1 well proportion$ & g5]ally writt5 by ! be/ m5 ( ! "t4 ,! m closely x is exam9$1 ! m deeply w our obligation be felt to ! intellig5ce & consci5ti\sness ( its projector & editor4 ,aft] ,dr4 ,ni*ol's c&id & amus+ ann\ncem5t ( 8 scissorial purpose1 x is b fair to /ate t no?+ ( ! k9d 0 ultimately c>ri$ into effect1 ev5 ^u ! "w 9 :i* he f\nd s mu* to praise4 ,i quote ?is te/imony because x is ( a peculi> k9d4 #bij ,! success ( ! ,p5ny ,magaz9e l$ ,mr4 ,*>les ,knight 9 #ahcb to propose to ! ,useful ,k ,society a ,cyclopa$ia 9 weekly p5ny numb]s4 ,^! two works /amp ! "n ( ! projector on ! lit]ature ( our day 9 v legible *>act]s4 ,eight volumes ( #dhj pages ea* 7 contemplat$2 & ,mr4 ,long#dga & ,mr4 ,knight 7 to take ! jo9t managem5t4 ,! plan embrac$ a popul> acc\nt ( ,art & ,sci5ce1 ) v brief biographical & geographical in=mation4 ,! e>ly numb]s ( ! "w _h "s ( ! ,p5ny ,magaz9e "*3 no "o c look at ! pictures ( ! ,abbot & ,abbess 9 _! robes )\t see+ ?is4 ,by ! "t ! second volume 0 complet$1 x 0 cle>ly se5 t ! plan 0 work+ out its own ext5sion3 a great developm5t ( design 0 submitt$ to1 & ,mr4 ,long became sole editor4 ,contributors c\ld n be f\nd to make articles ( ! requisite p[] 9 ! assign$ space4 ,"o ( !m told u t :5 he he>d ( ! eight volumes1 happ5+ to want a %elf to be ne> at h& = conta9+ ! "w z x w5t on1 he ord]$ x to be made to hold tw5ty-five volumes easily4 ,b ! inexorable logic ( facts beat him aft] all3 = ! complete "w conta9$ tw5ty-six volumes & two ?ick volumes ( ,supplem5t4 ,! p5ny issue 0 br\ght to an end by ! /ate ( ! law1 :i* requir$1 9 #ahcc1 t ! fir/ & la/ page ( ev]y?+ sold sep>ately %\ld conta9 ! "n & address ( ! pr9t]4 ,! p5ny numb]s conta9$ ?is impr9t on ! fold ( ! out] leaf3 & qui tam#dgb in=mations 7 laid aga9/ ! ag5ts 9 v>i\s t[ns4 #bia ,x became necess>y to call 9 ! /ock2 & ! p5ny issue 0 ab&on$4 ,mon?ly p>ts 7 sub/itut$1 :i* v>i$ 9 bulk1 z ! dem&s ( ! plan became m urg5t1 & 9 price f "o sixp5ce to ?ree4 ,! second volume ( ,supplem5t appe>$ 9 #ahdf1 & dur+ ! f\rte5 ye>s ( issue no "o mon?ly "p 0 ev] beh9d its "t4 ,?is result is ma9ly due to ! peculi> qualities ( ,mr4 ,long1 :o unites ! tal5ts ( ! s*ol> & ! editor 9 a degree :i* is altoge!r unusual4 ,if any "o %\ld imag9e t a mix$ mass ( contributors is a punctual piece ( ma*9]y1 let him take to edit+ ^u t hypo!sis1 & he %all see :at he %all see & le>n :at he %all le>n4 ,! ,engli% conta9s ab\t t5 p] c5t m matt] ?an ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia & its supplem5ts2 includ+ ! ?ird supplem5t>y volume ( #ahdh1 :i* we n[ m5tion = ! fir/ "t4 ,! lit]>y "w ( ! two editions co/ )9 #ejjl4 & #ej1jjjl43 t ( ! two editions ( ! ,britannica co/ #da1jjjl4 ,b !n x is to be rememb]$ t ! ,britannica _h matt] to beg9 ^u1 :i* _h be5 paid = 9 ! =m] editions4 ,r\ghly speak+1 x is probable t ! au?or%ip ( a page ( ! same size w\ld h co/ ne>ly ! same 9 "o z 9 ! o!r4 ,! longe/ articles 9 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia 7 ,rome 9 #ih columns & ,york%ire 9 #hf columns4 ,! only article :i* c be call$ a treatise is ! ,a/ronom] ,royal's ,gravitation1 f\nd$ on ! me?od ( ,newton 9 ! elev5? section1 b c>ri$ to a mu* great] ext5t4 ,9 ! ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia1 ! longe/ article ( geography is ,asia1 9 #de columns4 ,9 natural hi/ory ! antelopes dem& #cf columns4 ,9 biography1 ,well+ton uses up #db columns1 & 8 great milit>y oppon5t #da columns4 ,9 ! division ( ,arts & ,sci5ces1 :i* includes mu* ( a social & comm]cial "*1 ! l5g? ( articles (t5 dep5ds ^u ! /ate ( ! #bib times ) reg>d to ! subject4 ,our read]s w\ld n hit ! longe/ article ( ?is dep>tm5t 9 tw5ty guesses3 x is ,deaf & ,dumb 9 #fj columns4 ,z o!r specim5s1 we may cite ,a/ronomy1 #ai2 ,bank+1 #cf2 ,bl9d1 #bd2 ,briti% ,museum1 #ce2 ,cotton1 #bg2 ,drama1 #bf2 ,gravitation1 #ej2 ,libr>ies1 #ej2 ,pa9t+1 #cd2 ,railways1 #ah2 ,sculpture1 #cf2 ,/eam1 etc41 #cg2 ,table1 #dj2 ,telegraph1 #cj2 ,wel% language & lit]ature1 #ci2 ,wool1 #ba4 ,^! are ! long articles ( special subdivisions3 ! words "u :i* ! ,encyclopa$ia gives treatises are n s prom95t4 ,z 9 ,algebra1 #aj2 ,*emi/ry1 #ab2 ,geometry1 #h2 ,logic1 #ad2 ,ma!matics1 #e2 ,music1 #i4 ,b ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! collection ( treatises & ! diction>y may be illu/rat$ ?us3 ?\gh ,ma!matics h only five columns1 ,ma!matics1 rec5t t]m9ology (1 has eight3 & ?is article we believe to be by ,mr4 ,cayley1#dgc :o c]ta9ly ought to "k 8 subject1 be+ himself a l>ge manufactur] ( ! new t]ms :i* he expla9s4 ,aga91 ?\gh ,music 9 g5]e1 z ! s*oolm5 said1 has only n9e columns1 ,temp]am5t & ,tun+1 has eight1 & ,*ord alone has two4 ,& s on4 ,9 a diction>y ( ?is k9d x is difficult to make a total cle>ance ( p]sonality3 by :i* we mean t exhibition ( peculi> op9ion :i* is (f5sive to ta/e :5 x is %ift$ f ! individual on ! corporate book4 ,! treatise ( ! kn[n au?or may1 z we h said1 c>ry t au?or's controv]sies on its own %\ld]s3 & ev5 8 crot*ets1 if we may use su* a ^w4 ,b #bic ! diction>y %\ld n put itself into antagonism ) g5]al feel+1 nor ev5 ) ! feel+s ( classes4 ,we ref] p>ticul>ly to ! ord9>y & editorial tea*+ ( ! article4 ,if1 inde$1 ! writ]1 be+ at issue ) mank9d1 %\ld confess ! diff]5ce1 & give ab/ract ( 8 full gr\nds1 ! case is alt]$3 ! editor !n1 z x 71 admits a correspond5t to a /atem5t ( 8 own individual views4 ,! diction>y portion ( ! ,britannica is q cle> ( any lapses on ?is po9t1 s f> z we "k3 ! treatises & diss]tations re/ ^u _! au?ors4 ,! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia 0 all b cle>3 & great ne$ 0 !re t x %\ld h be5 s4 ,! ,useful ,k ,society1 />t+ on ! pr9ciple ( p]fect neutrality 9 politics & religion1 0 oblig$ to keep /rict wat* aga9/ ! entrance ( all attempt ev5 to look ov] ! h$ge4 ,!re 7 two--we believe only two--in/ances ( :at we h call$ p]sonality4 ,! fir/ 0 9 ! article ,bunyan4 ,x is wor? :ile to extract all t is said--9 an article ( ?irty l9es--ab\t a writ] :o is all b univ]sally held to be ! greate/ ma/] ( allegory t ev] wrote3 ,8 works 7 collect$ 9 two volumes1 folio1 #agcf-g3 among !m ',! ,pilgrim's ,progress' has atta9$ ! greate/ notoriety4 ,if a judgm5t is to be =m$ ( ! m]its ( a book by ! numb] ( times x has be5 repr9t$1 & ! _m languages into :i* x has be5 translat$1 no production 9 ,engli% lit]ature is sup]ior to ?is co>se allegory4 ,on a composition :i* has be5 extoll$ by ,dr4 ,johnson1 & :i* 9 our own times has receiv$ a v high critical op9ion 9 its favor probably ,s\!y1 x is haz>d\s to v5ture a disapproval1 & we1 p]haps1 speak ! op9ion ( a small m9ority :5 we confess t to u x appe>s to be mean1 jejune & we>isome4 --,if ! un=tunate critic :o ?us individualiz$ himself _h be5 a s$ul\s read] ( ,bunyan1 8 p[] ov] #bid ,engli% w\ld n h be5 s jejune z to h ne$$ t fe>ful ^w4 ,?is little bit ( criticism excit$ mu* amusem5t at ! "t ( its publication3 b x 0 s ?or\ghly exceptional & individual t x 0 seldom or nev] *>g$ on ! book4 ,! second in/ance occurr$ 9 ! article ,soc9ians4 ,x _h be5 arrang$ t ! head-words ( ,*ri/ian sects %\ld be intru/$ to memb]s ( ! sects !mselves1 on ! und]/&+ t ! articles %\ld simply set =? ! acc\nts :i* ! sects !mselves give ( _! own doctr9es4 ,?us ! article on ! ,roman ,*ur* 0 writt5 by ,dr4 ,wiseman4#dgd ,b ! ,unit>ians 7 n all[$ to come )9 ! rule3 z 9 o!r qu>t]s1 !y 7 treat$ z ! gypsies ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,"u ! head ,soc9ians--a "n repudiat$ by !mselves--an oppon5t 0 all[$ n m]ely to /ate _! alleg$ doctr9es 9 8 own way1 b to apply /rong t]ms1 su* z audaci\s unfairness1 to "s ( _! do+s4 ,! prote/s :i* 7 made aga9/ ?is invasion ( ! und]/&+ produc$1 9 due "t1 ! article ,unit>ians1 writt5 by "o ( t p]suasion4 ,we ne$ n say t ^! errors h be5 am5d$ 9 ! ,engli% ,cyclopa$ia3 & our *ief purpose 9 m5tion+ !m is to rem>k1 t ?is is all we c f9d on ! po9ts 9 "q aga9/ tw5ty-eight l>ge volumes produc$ by an editor ^: task 0 mon?ly1 & ^: issue 0 nev] delay$ a s+le h\r4 ,h[ mu* 0 arre/$ be=e publication none b himself c say4 ,we h n allud$ to "o or two remon/rances on que/ions ( absolute fact1 :i* are beside ! pres5t purpose4 ,bo? k9ds ( encyclopa$ic works h be5 fa%ion$ ^u pr$ecessors1 f ! v e>lie/ :i* _h a pr$ecessor to be f\nd$ ^u2 & ! und]tak+s be=e u w be !mselves ! ance/ors ( a l9e ( successors4 ,^? :o write 9 su* collections %\ld be #bie c>eful :at !y say1 = no "o c tell h[ long a mis-/atem5t may live4 ,on ?is po9t we w give ! hi/ory ( a pair ( epi!ts4 ,:5 ! hi/orian ,de ,?\#dge di$1 & left ! spl5did libr>y :i* 0 catalogu$ by ,b\illaud#dgf & ! bro!rs ,dupuis#dgg 7,bullialdus & ,puteanus71 !re 0 a manuscript ( ,de ,?\'s fri5d ,vieta1#dgh ! ,h>monicon ,coele/e1 ( :i* x is on record1 "u ,b\illaud's h&1 t he himself l5t x to ,cosmo de' ,m$ici1#dgi to :i* mu/ be add$ t ,m4 ,libri#dhj f\nd x 9 ! ,magliabec*i ,libr>y at ,flor5ce 9 our own day4 ,b\illaud1 x seems1 entirely =got :at he _h done4 ,some?+1 probably1 t ,pet] ,dupuis said to ,b\illaud1 :ile !y 7 at "w on ! catalogue1 rema9$ on 8 memory1 & 0 publi%$ by him 9 #afde1 long aft]2 to ! effect t ,dupuis l5t ! manuscript to ,m]s5ne1#dha f :om x 0 procur$ by "s int5d+ plagi>i/1 :o w\ld n give x back4 ,?is 0 repeat$ by ,%]burne1#dhb 9 #afge1 :o speaks ( ! "w1 :i* be+ communicat$ to ,m]s5nus 01 by "s p]fidi\s acqua9tance ( t hone/-m9d$ p]son1 surreptiti\sly tak5 f him1 & irrecov]ably lo/ or suppress$1 to ! unspeakable detrim5t ( ! lett]$ _w4 ,n[ let ! #bif read] look ?r\gh ! diction>ies ( ! la/ c5tury & ! pres5t1 sci5tific or g5]al1 at ! article1 ,vieta1 & he w be amus$ ) ! con/ant recurr5ce ( hone/-m9d$ ,m]s5ne1 & 8 surreptiti\s acqua9tance4 ,we _c h se5 less ?an ?irty copies ( ^! epi!ts4 ,,review ,,( ,,macclesfield ,,lett]s4 ,octob] #ah1 #ahfb4 ,correspond5ce ( ,sci5tific ,m5 ( ! ,sev5te5? ,c5tury1 9 ! ,collection ( ! ,e>l ( ,macclesfield4#dhc #b vols4 7,ox=d1 ,univ]sity ,press47 ,?\gh ! title-page ( ?is collection be>s ! date #ahda1 x is only j complet$ by ! publication ( its ,table ( ,cont5ts & ,index4 ,)\t ^!1 a "w ( ! k9d is useless = consultation1 & _c make its way4 ,! reason ( ! delay w appe>3 its effect is well kn[n to u4 ,we h f\nd inquir]s into ! hi/ory ( sci5ce s+ul>ly ignorant ( ?+s :i* ?is collection might h taught !m4 ,9 ! same ye>1 #ahda1 ! ,hi/orical ,society ( ,sci5ce1 :i* _h b a brief exi/5ce1 publi%$ a collection ( lett]s1 eighty-?ree 9 numb]1 edit$ by ,mr4 ,halliwell1#dhd ( ,engli% m5 ( sci5ce1 :i* dovetails ) ! "o be=e u1 & is = ! mo/ "p ( a prior date4 ,! two %\ld be b\nd up toge!r4 ,! small] collection runs f #aefb to #afhb2 ! l>g]1 f #afjf to pa/ #agjj4 ,we %all speak ( ! two z ! ,museum collection & ! ,macclesfield collection4 ,& ne> !m %\ld be plac$1 9 e sci5tific libr>y1 ! valuable collection publi%$1 by ,mr4 ,edle/on1#dhe = ,tr9ity ,college1 9 #ahej4 #big ,! hi/ory ( ^! lett]s runs back to fam\s ,john ,coll9s1 ! attorney-g5]al ( ! ma!matics1 z he has be5 call$1 :o wrote to ev]ybody1 he>d f ev]ybody1 & s5t copies ( ev]ybody's lett] to ev]ybody else4 ,he 0 9 ,engl& :at ,m]s5ne#dhf 0 9 ,france3 z e>ly z #afga1 ,e4 ,b]n>d#dhg addresses him z ! v ,m]s5nus & intellig5ce ( ?is age4 ,john ,coll9s#dhh 0 nev] m ?an acc\ntant to ! ,excise ,(fice1 to :i* he 0 promot$ f tea*+ writ+ & ciph]+1 at ! ,re/oration3 he di$ 9 #afhb4 ,we h _h a man ( ! same (fice 9 our own day1 ! late ,pr(4 ,s*uma*]1#dhi :o made ! little ,dani% ,obs]vatory ( ,altona ! junction ( all ! l9es by :i* a/ronomical in=mation 0 convey$ f "o c\ntry to ano!r4 ,:5 ! collision took place betwe5 ,d5m>k & ! ,du*ies1 ! ,engli% ,gov]nm5t1 mov$ by ! ,a/ronomical ,society1 in/ruct$ its diplomatic ag5ts to repres5t /rongly to ! ,dani% ,gov]nm5t1 :5 occasion %\ld arise1 ! great importance ( ! ,obs]vatory ( ,altona to ! a/ronomical communications ( ! :ole _w4 ,b ,s*uma*] _h 8 own celebrat$ j\rnal1 ! ,a/ronomis*e ,na*ri*t51 by :i* to "w out "p ( 8 plan2 private correspond5ce 0 8 supplem5t>y assi/ant4 ,coll9s _h only correspond5ce to rely on4 ,no?+ is bett] kn[n ?an t x 0 ,coll9s's collection :i* furni%$ ! mat]ials put =w>d by ! ,committee ( ! ,royal ,society 9 #agab1 z a def5ce ( ,newton aga9/ ! p>tisans ( ,leibnitz4 ,! not$ ,comm]cium ,epi/olicum is b ! abbreviation ( a title :i* runs on ) ,d4 ,johannis ,coll9s et aliorum 444 ,! :ole ( ?is collection pass$ into ! h&s ( #bih ,william ,jones1#dij ! fa!r ( ! ,indian ,judge ( ! same "n1 :o di$ 9 #agdi4 ,jones 0 orig9ally a tea*]1 b 0 pres5t$ ) a valuable s9ecure by ! int]e/ ( ,george1 second ,e>l ( ,macclesfield1 ! mov] ( ! bill = ! *ange ( /yle 9 ,brita91 :o di$ ,presid5t ( ! ,royal ,society4 ,?is *ange ( /yle may p]haps be trac$ to ! union ( en]gies :i* 7 br\ght into conc]t by ! accid5t ( a common tea*]3 ,"l ,macclesfield & ,"l ,*e/]field1#dia ! mov] & ! second]1 & ,daval1#dib :o drew ! bill1 7 pupils ( ,de ,moivre4#dic ,jones1 :o 0 a respectable ma!matician ?\gh n an inv5tor1 collect$ ! l>ge/ ma!matical libr>y ( 8 day1 & became possessor ( ! pap]s ( ,coll9s1 :i* conta9$ ^? ( ,oughtr$#did & o!rs4 ,"s ( ^! pap]s pass$ into ! cu/ody ( ! ,royal ,society3 b ! bulk 0 ei!r bequea!d to1 or pur*as$ by1 ,"l ,macclesfield2 & ?us !y f\nd _! way to ,%irburn ,ca/le1 :]e !y /ill rema94 ,a little be=e #ahcf1 ?is collection attract$ ! att5tion ( a se>*+ inquir] into po9ts ( ma!matical hi/ory1 ! late ,pr(essor ,rigaud1#die :o di$ 9 #ahci4 ,he exam9$ ! :ole collection ( lett]s1 obta9$ ,"l ,macclesfield's cons5t to _! publication1 & induc$ ! ,ox=d ,press to be> ! exp5se4 ,x mu/ be p>ticul>ly rememb]$ t !re /ill rema9s at ,%irburn ,ca/le a #bii valuable mass ( non-epi/ol>y manuscripts4 ,s f> z we c see1 ! be/ *ance ( a fur!r exam9ation & publication lies 9 public enc\ragem5t ( ! collection n[ be=e u3 ! ,ox=d ,press might be induc$ to ext5d its op]ations if x 7 f\nd t ! results 7 really ( int]e/ to ! lit]>y & sci5tific _w4 ,rigaud di$ be=e ! "w 0 complet$1 & ! publication 0 actually made by "o ( 8 sons1 ,s4 ,jordan ,rigaud1#dif :o di$ ,bi%op ( ,antigua4 ,b ?is publication 0 little notic$1 = ! reasons giv54 ,! completion n[ publi%$ consi/s ( a suffici5t table ( cont5ts1 ( ! briefe/ k9d1 by ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan1 & an excell5t index by ! ,rev4 ,john ,rigaud4#dig ,! "w is n[ fairly />t$ on its c>e]4 ,if we 7 *>g$ to write a volume ) ! title ,small ?+s 9 _! connection ) great1 we c\ld n d bett] ?an *oose ! small "p ( ?is collection ( lett]s z our basis4 ,! names1 z well z ! cont5ts1 are bo? great & small3 ! great names1 ^? :i* are kn[n to e ma!matician :o has any infusion ( ! hi/ory ( 8 pursuit1 are ,briggs1#dih ,oughtr$1 ,*>les ,cav5di%1#dii ,gascoigne1#ejj ,se? ,w>d1#eja ,wallis1#ejb #cjj ,huyg5s1#ejc ,coll9s1#ejd ,william ,petty1#eje ,hooke1#ejf ,boyle1#ejg ,pell1#ejh ,old5burg1#eji ,branck]1#eaj ,slusius1#eaa ,b]tit1#eab ,b]n>d1#eac ,borelli1#ead ,m\ton1#eae ,p>dies1#eaf ,f]mat1#eag ,t[neley1#eah ,auz\t1#eai #cja ,d4 ,gregory1#ebj ,halley1#eba ,ma*91#ebb ,montmort1#ebc ,cotes1#ebd ,jones1#ebe ,saund]son1#ebf ,reyneau1#ebg ,brook ,taylor1#ebh ,maup]tuis1#ebi ,b\gu]1#ecj ,la ,condam9e1#eca ,folkes1#ecb ,macclesfield1#ecc #cjb ,bak]1#ecd ,b>r[1#ece ,flam/e$1#ecf ,"l ,br\nk]1#ecg ,j4 ,gregory1#ech ,newton#eci & ,keill4#edj ,to ^! ! ,museum collection adds ! names ( ,?omas ,digges1#eda ,dee1#edb ,ty*o ,brahe1#edc ,h>riot1#edd ,lydyat1#ede ,briggs1#edf ,w>n]1#edg ,t>porley1 ,pell1#edh ,lilly1#edi ,old5burg1#eej ,coll9s1#eea ,morl&4#eeb #cjc ,! fir/ :o appe>s on ! sc5e is ! celebrat$ ,oughtr$1 :o is relat$ to h di$ ( joy at ! ,re/oration3 b x %\ld be add$1 by way ( excuse1 t he 0 eighty-six ye>s old4 ,he is an animal ( ext9ct race1 an ,eton ma!matician4 ,few ,eton m51 ev5 ( ! m9ority :i* kn[s :at a slid+ rule is1 are aw>e t ! inv5tor 0 ( _! own s*ool & college3 b !y may be excus$1 = ,dr4 ,hutton1#eec s f> z 8 ,diction>y be>s witness1 seems n to h kn[n x any m ?an !y4 ,a glance at "o ( 8 lett]s rem9ds u ( a lett] f ! ,a/ronom] ,royal on ! discov]y ( ,neptune1 :i* we pr9t$ ,m>* #bj1 #ahdg4 ,mr4 ,airy#eed !re cont5ds1 & proves x bo? by ,lev]ri]#eee & by ,adams1#eef t ! limit$ publication ( a private lett] is m effici5t ?an ! m g5]al publication ( a pr9t$ memoir4 ,! same may be true ( a dead lett]1 z oppos$ to a dead book4 ,our eye 0 caught by a lett] ( ,oughtr$ 7#afbi71 conta9+ sy/ematic use ( contractions = ! words s9e1 cos9e1 etc41 prefix$ to ! symbol ( ! angle4 ,?is is s v important a /ep1 simple z x is1 t ,eul]#eeg is ju/ly held to h greatly advanc$ trigonometry by its introduction4 ,nobody t we "k ( has notic$ t ,oughtr$ 0 ma/] ( ! improvem5t1 & will+ to h taught x1 if p w\ld h le>nt4 ,aft] look+ at 8 dead lett]1 we naturally turn$ to 8 dead book on trigonometry1 & !re we f\nd ! abbreviations s1 sco1 t1 tco1 se1 seco1 regul>ly e/abli%$ z "p ( ! sy/em ( ! "w4 ,b n "o ( ^? :o h inve/igat$ ! cont5d+ claims ( ,eul] & ,?omas #cjd ,simpson#eeh has *anc$ to "k ( ,oughtr$'s ,trigonometrie3 & ! pres5t revival is due to 8 lett]1 n to 8 book4 ,a casual read]1 turn+ ov] ! pages1 w\ld imag9e t almo/ all ! lett]s _h be5 pr9t$1 ei!r 9 ! ,g5]al ,diction>y1 or 9 ,bir*1#eei etc43 s (t5 does ! supplem5t>y rem>k beg9 ) ?is lett] has be5 pr9t$ 9 ----4 ,= ourselves we ?\ght1 until we c\nt$1 t a l>ge majority ( ! lett]s _h be5 giv51 ei!r 9 :ole or 9 "p4 ,b ! positive /rikes ! m9d m =cibly ?an ! negative3 we f9d t all ( :i* any portion has be5 9 type makes up v little m ?an a qu>t]2 ! cases 9 :i* ! :ole lett] is giv5 be+ a m9ority ( ?is qu>t]4 ,! p]son :o has be5 be/ ransack$ is ,flam/e$3 ( #cf lett]s f him1 #cd _h be5 previ\sly giv5 9 :ole or 9 "p4 ,( #ei lett]s to & f ,newton1 only #ag h be5 cull$4 ,! lett]s h be5 mod]niz$ 9 spell+1 &1 to "s ext5t1 9 algebraical notation2 x also seems t conjectural me?ods ( introduc+ int]polations into ! text h be5 necess>y4 ,= all ?is we are sorry3 ! sci5tific value ( ! collection is little alt]$1 b its lit]>y value is some:at l[]$4 ,b x c\ld n be help$3 ! pr9t]s c\ld n "w f ! orig9als1 & ,pr(essor ,rigaud _h to copy ev]y?+ himself4 ,a fac-simile mu/ h be5 ! "w ( m "t ?an he _h to give3 _h he attempt$ x1 8 dea? w\ld h cut %ort ! :ole und]tak+1 in/ead ( all[+ him to prep>e ev]y?+ b a preface1 & to sup]9t5d ! pr9t+ ( "o ( ! volumes4 ,we may also add1 t we believe we h notices ( all ! lett]s 9 ! ,macclesfield collection4 ,we judge ?is because sev]al :i* are too trivial to pr9t are numb]$ & describ$2 & ^? w\ld c]ta9ly n h be5 notic$ if any omissions _h #cje be5 made4 ,& we "k t e lett] 0 remov$ f ,%irburn ,ca/le to ,ox=d4 ,two p]sons em]ge f oblivion 9 ?is s]ies ( lett]s4 ,! fir/ is ,mi*ael ,d>y1#efj an obscure ma!matician1 :o 0 9 correspond5ce ) ,newton & o!r />s4 ,he 0 a gaug] at ,bri/ol1 by ! int]e/ ( ,coll9s2 aft]w>ds a c&idate = ! ma!matical s*ool at ,*ri/'s ,hospital1 ) a c]tificate f ,newton3 he 0 !n a gunn] 9 ! ,t[]1 & is la/ly describ$ by ,wallis z ,mr4 ,d>y1 ! tobacco-cutt]1 a kn[+ man 9 algebra4 ,9 #afgd1 ,d>y writes to ,newton at ,cambridge1 z foll[s3--,al?\gh ,i s5t y ?ree pap]s ye/]day1 ,i _c refra9 f s5d+ y ?is4 ,i h _h fre% ?\ghts ?is morn+4 ,two mon?s aft]w>ds poor ,newton writes to ,coll9s1 ,mr4 ,d>y is v solicit\s ab\t ma!matics3 b 9 spite ( ! p]secution1 he subscribes himself to ,d>y y\r lov+ fri5d4 ,d>y's problem is t ( f9d+ ! rate ( int]e/ ( an annuity ( :i* ! value & t]m are giv54 ,d>y's !orem1 :i* he seems to h inv5t$ specially = ! solution ( 8 problem1 ?\gh x is ( wide range1 c be exhibit$ to ma!matical read]s ev5 9 our columns4 ,9 mod]n language1 x is t ! limit ( phinx1 :5 n increases )\t limit1 is a solution ( phix x4 ,we h m5tion$ ! ,i4 ,newton to :om ,d>y look$ up2 we add a ^w ab\t ! "o on :om he look$ d[n4 ,dr4 ,john ,newton1#efa a s$ul\s publi%] ( log>i?ms1 tables ( int]e/1 etc41 :o began 8 c>e] be=e ,isaac ,newton1 sometimes puzzles ^? :o d n "k him1 :5 describ$ z ,i4 ,newton4 ,! sci5tific _w 0 ( op9ion t all t 0 valuable 9 "o ( 8 works 0 tak5 f ,d>y's private communications4 #cjf ,! second "* above allud$ to is "o :o c>ri$ ma!matical rese>*es a f> great] l5g? ?an ,newton himself3 ! assi/ance :i* he r5d]$ 9 ?is respect1 ev5 to ,newton1 has nev] be5 ackn[l$g$ 9 mod]n times3 ?\gh ! "w be=e u %[s t 8 contempor>ies 7 fully aw>e ( x1 & nev] ?\ght ( conceal+ x4 ,9 8 !ory ( gravitation1 9 :i*1 s f> z he w5t1 we h e reason to believe he 0 prior to ,newton1 he did n ext5d 8 calculations to ! di/ance ( ! moon2 8 views 9 ?is matt] 7 purely t]re/rial1 & l$ him to *>ge accord+ to weight4 ,he 0 ,john ,/iles1 ! ,london & ,cambridge c>ri]3 8 "n is a h\sehold ^w 9 ! ,macclesfield ,lett]s1 & is ev5 en%r9$ 9 ! dep?s ( ,bir*'s qu>tos4 ,d>y in=ms ,newton--let u d 8 memory ?is ju/ice--t he _h paid ,john ,/iles = ! c>riage4 ,at ! "t :5 ! railroad to ,cambridge 0 op5$1 a correspond5t recomm5d$ ! directors1 9 our columns1 to call an eng9e by ! "n ( ,john ,/iles1 & nev] to let t "n g (f ! road4 ,we d n "k :e!r ! advice 0 foll[$3 if n1 we repeat x4 ,little po9ts ( life & mann]s come out occasionally4 ,bak]1 ! au?or ( a "w on algebra mu* e/eem$ at ! "t1 wrote to ,coll9s t _! circum/ances are alike1 hav+ a j & equal numb] ( *>geable olive-bran*es1 & be+ 9 ! same pr$icam5t & bless$ condemnation ) y1 n m prea*+ ?an unpaid1 & prea*+ ! art ( cont5tm5t to o!rs1 am =c$ to practise x4 ,b ! la/ s5t5ce ( 8 lett] runs z foll[s3 ,i h s5t by ! be>] 444 tw5ty %ill+s1 z a tok5 to y2 desir+ y to accept ( x1 z a small ta/e f ,y\rs1 ,?os4 ,bak]4 ,9 our day1 m5 ( a /ation to pay p>i% taxes d n (f] _! fri5ds h>d money to buy liquor4 ,b ,flam/e$#efb writes to ,coll9s z foll[s3 ,la/ week he s5t u d[n ! c\nt]p>t1 :i* #cjg my fa!r has scal$1 & ,i return up to y by ! c>ri]1 ) #el4 to be paid to ,mr4 ,l5eve = ! writ+1 ,i h add$ #bs4 #f;d4 ov]1 :i* w pay ! exp5ses & s]ve to dr9k1 ) him4 ,?is w\ld seem z odd to u z x w\ld h seem$ ?irty ye>s ago t half-a-cr[n %\ld pay c>riage = a de$ f ,d]by to ,london1 & leave m>g9 = a bottle ( w9e3 9 our day1 ! ,po/-(fice & ! ,fr5* treaty w\ld j manage x betwe5 !m4 ,b ,flam/e$ does n limit 8 fri5d to "o bottle2 he adds1 ,if y exp5d m ?an ! half-cr[n1 ,i w make x good aft] ,:itsuntide4 ,coll9s does n rememb] exactly :]e he _h met ,james ,gregory1 & m5tions two equally likely places ?us3 ,sir1 x 0 once my good hap to meet ) y 9 an aleh\se or 9 ,sion ,college4 ,!re is a little pro( h[ univ]sally ! d9n]-h\r 0 twelve o'clock4 ,a/ronom]s well "k ! me?od ( f9d+ "t by equal altitudes ( ! sun be=e & aft] noon3 ,huygh5s calls x le moy5 de deux egales hauteurs du soleil devant et apres d9]4#efc ,!re is "o m5tion ( ,mr4 ,cock]1#efd our fam\s ,engli% grav] & writ]1 n[ a s*oolma/] at ,nor?ampton4 ,?is is ! true ,cock]3 8 g5u9e works are specim5s ( writ+1 su* z engrav$ copy-books1 includ+ "s on ari?metic1 ) copp]-plate que/ions & space = ! work+2 also a book ( =ms = law-/ation]s1 ) specim5s ( legal h&writ+4 ,x is record$ some:]e t ,cock] & ano!r1 ^: "n we =get1 compet$ ) ! ,italians 9 ! beauty ( _! fl\ri%es4 ,?is 0 8 real fame3 & 9 ^! matt]s he 0 great4 ,! eigh? edition ( 8 book ( law =ms 7#afge71 publi%$ %ortly aft] ,cock]'s dea?1 has a preface sign$ ,j4 ,h4 ,?is 0 ,john ,hawk9s1 :o became possess$ ( ,cock]'s pap]s--at lea/ he said s--& #cjh subsequ5tly =g$ ! fam\s ,ari?metic1#efe a second "w on ,decimal ,ari?metic1 & an ,engli% diction>y1 all attribut$ to ,cock]4 ,! pro(s ( ?is are set out 9 ,de ,morgan's ,ari?metical ,books4 ,among _m o!r corroborative circum/ances1 ! clumsy =g]1 aft] decl>+ t ,cock] to 8 dy+ day resi/$ /rong solicitation to publi% 8 ,ari?metic1 makes him write 9 ! preface ,ille ego qui quondam#eff ( ?is k9d3 ,i h be5 in/rum5tal to ! b5efit ( _m1 by virtue ( ^? useful arts1 writ+ & engrav+2 & d n[1 ) ! same wont$ alacrity1 ca/ ?is my ari?metical mite into ! public treasury4 ,! book itself is n comp>able 9 m]it to at lea/ half-a-doz5 o!rs4 ,h[ !n comes ,cock] to be ! imp]sonation ( ,ari?metic8 ,unless "s "o c %[ pro(1 :i* we h nev] f\nd1 t he 0 s be=e #agef1 ! matt] is to be acc\nt$ = ?us4 ,ar?ur ,murphy1#efg ! dramati/1 0 by ta/e a man ( lett]s1 & end$ by be+ ! translator ( ,tacitus2 ?\gh _m d n "k t ! two are "o4 ,8 fri5ds _h tri$ to make him a man ( bus9ess2 & no d\bt he _h be5 well pli$ ) comm]cial ari?metic4 ,8 fir/ dramatic p]=mance1 ! f>ce ( ,! ,appr5tice1 produc$ 9 #agef1 is ab\t an idle "y man :o mu/ ne$s turn actor4 ,two ( ! be/ kn[n books ( ! day 9 ari?metic 7 ^? ( ,cock] & ,w+ate4#efh ,murphy *ooses ,w+ate to be ! "n ( an old m]*ant :o #cji delights 9 vulg> fractions1 & ,cock] to be 8 ari?metical cat*word--,y read ,%akespe>e6 get ,cock]'s ,ari?metic6 y may buy x = a %ill+ on any /all2 be/ book t ev] 0 wrote6 & s on4 ,! f>ce became v popul>1 &1 z we believe1 0 ! means ( elevat+ ,cock] to 8 pres5t p$e/al1 :]e ,w+ate w\ld h be51 if 8 "n _h _h ! droll] s\nd ( ! two to ,engli% e>s4 ,a notoriety ( an old] day turns up1 ,major-,g5]al ,lamb]t4#efi ,! common /ory is t he 0 bani%$ to ,gu]nsey1 :]e he pass$ ?irty ye>s 9 conf9em5t1 re>+ & pa9t+ fl[]s4 ,b ,bak]1 9 #afgh1 repres5ts him z a prison] at ,plym\?1 s5d+ equations = solution z a *all5ge3 probably 8 place ( conf9em5t 0 v>i$1 & 8 occupation also4 ,g5]al ,lamb]t 0 remov$ to ,plym\?1 probably ab\t #affh4 ,8 daught] captur$ ! son ( ! ,gov]nor ( ,gu]nsey1 :o !re=e probably 0 reckon$ an unsafe cu/odi] !nce=w>d2 ?\gh he assur$ ! k+ t he _h turn$ ! "y c\ple out ( doors1 & _h nev] giv5 !m a p5ny4 ,great importance 0 atta*$ to ,lamb]t's safe det5tion3 probably ! rema9+ republicans look$ ^u him z to be _! next ,cromwell1 if su* a ?+ 7 to be4 ,!re 7 /&+ ord]s to %oot him at once on ! fir/ appe>ance ( any enemy be=e ! isl&4 ,see ,notes & ,qu]ies1 #c;d ,s4 iv4 #hi4 ,coll9s in=ms ,james ,gregory t "s ( ! ,royal ,academy wrote ov] to ,mr4 ,old5burg1 :o 0 desir$ to imp>t ! same to ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,royal ,society1 t ! ,fr5* ,k+ 0 will+ to all[ p5sions to "o or two le>n$ ,engli%m51 b !y nev] made any answ] #caj to su* a proposal4 ,?is 0 writt5 9 #afga1 & ! ?+ probably happ5$ sev]al ye>s be=e4 ,mr4 ,de ,morgan communicat$ ! acc\nt ( ! proposal to ,"l ,macaulay1 :o repli$ t he did n ?9k t any ,engli%man receiv$ a lit]>y p5sion f ,l\is2 b t !re is a curi\s lett]1 ab\t #affd1 f ! ,fr5* ,ambassador1 9 :i* he says t he has1 by 8 ma/]'s ord]s1 be5 mak+ inquiries z to ! /ate ( le>n+ 9 ,engl&1 & t he is sorry to f9d t ! be/ writ] is ! infam\s ,miltonus4 ,on two su* indep5d5t te/imonies x may be held prov$ t ! ,fr5* ,k+ _h attempt$ to buy a little adh]5ce f ,engli% lit]ature & sci5ce2 & ! sil5t contempt ( ! ,royal ,society is an honorable fact 9 _! hi/ory4 ,ano!r little bit ( politics is z foll[s4 ,oughtr$ is in=m$ t ,mr4 ,fo/]1#egj our ,lectur] on ,a/ronomy at ,gre%am ,college1 is put out because he w n kneel d[n at ! communion-table4 ,a ,scotsman ,mungo ,murray1 "o t is v]bi bis m9i/]1#ega is n[ lectur] 9 ,mr4 ,fo/]'s place4 ,w>d 9 8 "w on ! ,gre%am ,pr(essors1#egb suppresses ! reason1 & ! suppression l[]s ! "* ( 8 book4 ,fo/] 0 expell$ 9 #afcf1 & re-elect$ on a vacancy 9 #afda1 :5 ,puritanism _h ga9$ /r5g?4 ,! correspond5ce ( ,newton w\ld require deep] sift+ ?an c\ld be giv5 9 su* an article z ! pres5t4 ,! fir/ ( ! lett]s 7#affi7 is curi\s1 z pres5t+ ! #caa appe>ance ( =ms belong+ to ! great calculus :i*1 9 ?is p>agraph1 we ought to call t ( fluxions4 ,we f9d1 ( ! date ,febru>y #ah1 #affi-gj1 :at we believe is ! e>lie/ manife/ation ( t morbid "p ( ,newton's temp]am5t :i* has be5 s v>i\sly repres5t$4 ,he _h solv$ a problem--be+ t :i* we h call$ ,d>y's--on :i* he writes z foll[s3 ,! solution ( ! annuity problem1 if x w be ( any use1 y h my leave to ins]t into ! ,philosophical ,transactions1 s x be )\t my "n to x4 ,= ,i see n :at !re is desirable 9 public e/eem1 7 ,i able to acquire & ma9ta9 x4 ,x w\ld p]haps increase my acqua9tance1 ! ?+ :i* ,i *iefly /udy to decl9e4 ,?ree lett]s t\* ^u ! exp]im5t ( glass rubb$ to cause v>i\s motions 9 bits ( pap] und]nea?3 !y are supplem5ts to ! acc\nt giv5 by ,newton to ! ,royal ,society1 & pr9t$ by ,bir*4 ,x 0 ,newton1 s f> z appe>s1 :o add$ glass to ! sub/ances kn[n to be electric4 ,soon aft]w>ds we come to a little bit ( ! hi/ory ( ! appo9tm5t to ! ,m9t4 ,x has appe>$ f ! rese>*es ( late ye>s t ,newton 0 long an aspirant = public employm5t3 ! only coolness :i* is kn[n to h tak5 place betwe5 him & ,*>les ,montague#egc ,halifax arose out ( 8 imag9+ t 8 fri5d 0 n 9 e>ne/ ab\t gett+ him into ! public s]vice4 ,m>* #ad1 #afif1 ,newton writes ?us to ,halley3 ,& if ! rum\r ( pref]m5t = me 9 ! ,m9t %\ld h]eaft]1 ^u ! dea? ( ,mr4 ,ho> ! comptroll]1 or any o!r occasion1 be reviv$1 ,i pray t y w\ld #cab endeav\r to obviate x by acqua9t+ y\r fri5ds t ,i nei!r put 9 = any place 9 ! ,m9t1 nor w\ld m$dle ) ,mr4 ,ho>'s place1 7 x (f]$ to me4 ,?is means t ,mr4 ,ho>'s place _h be5 sugge/$1 :i* ,newton seems to h decl9$4 ,five days aft]w>ds1 ,montague writes to ,newton t he is to h ! ,w>d5%ip4 ,x is fair to ,newton to say t 9 all probability ?is 0 n--or only 9 a small] degree--a "q ( p]sonal dignity1 or ( sal>y4 ,x mu/ by ?is "t h be5 cle> to him t ! m9i/]1 ?\gh long b\nd to make him an object ( patronage1 0 actually seek+ him = ! ,m9t1 because he want$ bo? ,newton's "n & 8 tal5ts = bus9ess--:i* he knew to be great--9 ! weighty & dang]\s op]ation ( re/or+ ! co9age4 ,x may h be51 & probably 01 ! case t ,newton _h a tol]ably accurate notion ( :at he w\ld h to d1 & ( :at degree ( p[] w\ld be necess>y to enable him to d x 9 8 own way4 ,we h said t ! non-epi/ol>y manuscripts are /ill unexam9$4 ,!re is a *ance t "o ( !m may answ] a "q ( two c5turies' /&+1 :i* is wor? answ]+1 because x has be5 s (t5 ask$4 ,ab\t #afdj1 ,w>n]1#egd aft]w>ds assi/$ by ,pell1#ege comm5c$ a table ( antilog>i?ms1 ( ! k9d :i* ,dodson#egf aft]w>ds con/ruct$ anew & publi%$4 ,9 ! ,museum collection !re is inquiry aft] inquiry f ,*>les ,cav5di%1#egg fir/1 z to :5 ! ,analogics1 z he call$ !m1 w\ld be f9i%$2 next1 :5 !y w\ld be pr9t$4 ,pell answ]s1 9 #afdd1 t ,w>n] left 8 pap]s to a k9sman1 :o _h become bankrupt1 & proce$s ?us3 ,i am n a little afraid t all ,mr4 ,w>n]'s pap]s1 #cac & no small %>e ( my lab\rs !re91 are seaz$ ^u1 & mo/ unma!matically divid$ betwe5 ! seque/rators & cr$itors1 :o 7n be+ able to ballance ! acc\nt :]e !re appe>e s _m numb]s1 & mu* tr\bl$ at ! sight ( s _m crosses & circles 9 ! sup]/iti\s ,algebra & t black art ( ,geometry7 w1 no d\bt1 det]m9e once 9 _! lives to become figure-ca/]s1 & s vote !m all to be ?r[5 into ! fire1 if "s good body doe n reprieve !m = pye-bottoms1 = :i* purposes y "k analogicall numb]s are incomp>ably apt1 if !y be accurately calculat$4 ,pell aft]w>ds told ,wallis#egh t ! pap]s _h fall5 into ! h&s ( ,dr4 ,busby1#egi & ,coll9s#ehj writes t !y 7 left 9 ! h&s ( ,dr4 ,?orndike1#eha a preb5d>y ( ,we/m9/]2 :5ce ,rigaud#ehb seems to say t ,?orndike _h left !m to ,dr4 ,busby4 ,bir*#ehc says t he procur$ = ! ,royal ,society f\r boxes f ,busby's tru/ees1 conta9+ pap]s ( ,w>n] & ,pell3 b !re is no o!r tradition ( su* ?+s 9 ! ,society4 ,b 9 ! ,bir* manuscripts at ! ,briti% ,museum1 !re turns up1 z pr9t$ 9 :at we call ! ,museum collection1 a li/ ( ,w>n]'s pap]s1 ) ,coll9s's receipt to ,dr4 ,?orndike at ! bottom1 & engagem5t to re/ore !m on dem&4 ,! date is ,decemb] #ad1 #affg2 ,wallis's /atem5t be+ 9 #afic4 ,x is possible t ,busby may be a mi/ake altoge!r3 he 0 v unlikely to h _h *>ge ( any ma!matical pap]s3 !re may h be5 a confusion betwe5 ! ,preb5d>y ( ,we/m9/] & ! ,head ,ma/] ( ,we/m9/] ,s*ool4 ,if s1 9 all probability ,?orndike h&$ #cad ! cumbr\s lot ov] to ! notori\s collector ( ma!matical pap]s1 bless+ himself t he got rid ( !m 9 a mann] :i* w\ld insure _! return if he 7 call$ ^u by ! own]s to re/ore !m4 ,x is mu* aga9/ ?is hypo!sis t ,dodson1 :o c]ta9ly recalculat$1 c say no?+ m ab\t ,w>n] ?an a repetition ( ,wallis's /ory3 ?\gh1 _h ,coll9s kept ! pap]s1 !y w\ld probably h be5 9 ,jones's possession at ! v "t :5 ,dodson1 :o 0 a fri5d ( ,jones & a us] ( 8 libr>y1 0 engag$ on 8 own computations4 ,b ev5 books1 & /ill m manuscripts1 are (t5 s+ul>ly ov]look$2 & x rema9s n v improbable t ,w>n]'s table is n[ at ,%irburn ,ca/le1 among ! unexam9$ manuscripts4 ,,cyclometry ,,& ,,/eel ,,p5s4 ,r$it labor actus 9 orbem4#ehd ,among ! matt]s :i* h come to me s9ce ! ,budget op5$1 !re is a pamphlet ( quadrature ( two pages & a half f ,pr(essor ,recalcati1#ehe already m5tion$4 ,x ends ) ,quelque objection qu'on fasse t\*ant les raisonnem5ts ci-dessus on tomb]a t\j\rs dans l'absurde4#ehf ,a civil eng9e]--s he says--has made ! quadrature no long] a problem1 b an axiom4 ,z foll[s3 ,take ! quadrant ( a circle ^: circumf]5ce is giv51 squ>e ! quadrant :i* gives ! true squ>e ( ! circle4 ,because #cj _/ #d #g4e x #g4e #ef4be ! positive squ>e ( a circle ^: circumf]5ce is #cj4 ,brevity1 ! s\l ( wit1 is ! w+s ( mighty-w9ds to quadrature1 & s5ds x fly+ all abroad4 ,a surbodhic>y--some?+ l ,m4,a4 or ,,ll4,d41 ,i und]/&--at ,calcutta1 publi%$ 9 #ahfc ! division ( an #cae angle into any odd numb] ( p>ts1 demon/ration & all 9--:5 ! diagram is omitt$--"o page1 good-siz$1 well-lead$ type1 small duodecimo4 ,b 9 ! ,preface he ackn[l$ges %e] inability to execute 8 task4 ,mr4 ,william ,dean1 ( ,todmord51 9 #ahfc1 ann\nc$ #c-i_/fd z prov$ bo? practically & geometrically3 he has be5 already m5tion$ anonym\sly4 ,next ,i h ! tract ( ,don ,juan ,l>riva1 publi%$ at ,leiria 9 #ahef1 & d$icat$ to ,que5 ,victoria4 ,mr4 ,w4 ,pet]s1#ehg already m5tion$1 :o has = "s mon?s be5 circulat+ diagrams on a c>d1 publi%es 7,augu/1 #ahfe7 ,! ,circle ,squ>$4 ,he agrees ) ! ,ar*prie/ ( ,/4 ,vitus4 ,he h9ts t a l>g] publication w dep5d p>tly on ! support he receives1 & p>tly on ! ca/igation1 = :i* la/1 ( c\rse1 he looks to me4 ,cyclomet]s h _! sev]al /yles ( wit2 s h anticyclomet]s too1 = t matt]4 ,mr4 ,pet]s w n all[ me any extra-j\rnal be+3 ,i am ess5tially a quotation f ! ,a!naeum2 ,a4 ,de ,morgan et praet]ea nihil4#ehh ,if he _h to pay = keep+ me set up1 he w\ld f9d out 8 mi/ake1 & w\ld be glad to comp\nd h&somely = a /]eotype4 ,next comes a magnific5t %eet ( pa/ebo>d1 pr9t$ on bo? sides4 ,hav+ glanc$ at x & detect$ quadrature1 ,i began me?odically at ! beg9n+--,by ,royal ,comm&1 ) ! lion & unicorn1 & all t comes betwe54 ,m]cy on u6 ?\ght ,i to myself3 has ,h] ,maje/y ref]r$ ! "q to ! ,judicial ,committee ( ! ,privy ,c\ncil1 :]e all ! great difficulties g n[-a-days1 & is ?is proclamation ! result8 ,on read+ fur!r ,i 0 reliev$ by f9d+ t ! fir/ side is entirely an adv]tisem5t ( ,joseph ,gillott's#ehi /eel p5s1 ) engrav+ ( 8 #caf premises1 & notice ( novel application ( 8 unrivall$ ma*9]y4 ,! second side beg9s ) ! circle rectifi$ by ,w4 ,e4 ,walk]1#eij :o f9ds pi #c4adaeidghifbdaee4444 ,?is is an (f-%oot f an accurate geometrical rectification1 on :i* is to be presum$ ,mr4 ,gillott's new ma*9]y is f\nd$4 ,i h no d\bt t ,mr4 ,walk]'s error1 :i* is only 9 ! six? place ( decimals1 w n hurt ! p5s1 unless x be by ! slighte/ possible increase ( ! t5d5cy to op5 at ! po9ts4 ,?is arises f ,mr4 ,walk] hav+ rectifi$ above pro( by 4#jjjjjbacfjcdcfb4444 ,la/ly1 ,i1 ev5 ,i myself1 :o h long felt t ,i 0 a quadrature bel[ p>1 h solv$ ! problem by means :i*1 9 ! pres5t /ate ( ! law ( libel1 ,i d>e n divulge4 ,b ! result is p]mitt$2 & x goes f> to expla9 all ! discordances4 ,! ratio ( ! circumf]5ce to ! diamet] is n always ! same6 ,n t x v>ies ) ! radius2 ! geomet]s are "r en\gh on t po9t3 b x v>ies ) ! "t1 9 a mann] dep5d+ ^u ! diff]5ce ( ! true longitudes ( ! ,sun & ,moon4 ,a fri5d ( m9e--at lea/ until he misbehav$--insi/$ on ! mean "r asc5sions3 b ,i s]v$ him z ,abraham s]v$ 8 gue/ 9 ,frankl9's p>able4 ,! true =mula is1 ,a & a be+ ! ,sun's & ,moon's longitudes1 pi #c-ac_/hj #c_/hj cos7,a - a74 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? obta9$ 8 quadrature at full moon2 ! ,ar*prie/ ( ,/4 ,vitus & "s o!rs at new moon4 ,until ,i c v5ture to publi% ! demon/ration1 ,i recomm5d ! read] to d z ,i d1 :i* is to adopt #c4adaei4441 & to ?9k ( ! matt] only at ! two po9ts ( ! lun> mon? at :i* x is correct4 ,! ,nautical ,almanac w no d\bt give ^! po9ts 9 a %ort "t3 ,i am 9 correspond5ce ) ! ,admiralty1 ) no?+ #cag to get ov] except :at ,i mu/ call a p]v]se notion on ! "p ( ! ,sup]9t5d5t ( ! ,almanac1 :o suspects "o correction dep5d+ on ! ,moon's latitude2 & ! ,a/ronom] ,royal leans t[>ds ano!r dep5d+ on ! date ( ! ,que5's accession4 ,i h no pati5ce ) ^! m53 :at c ! ,moon's node ( ! ,que5's reign possibly h to d ) ! ratio 9 "q8 ,b ?is is ! way ) all ! regul> m5 ( sci5ce2 ,newton is to !m etc4 etc4 etc4 etc4 ,! foll[+ me?od ( f9d+ ! circumf]5ce ( a circle 7tak5 f a pap] by ,mr4 ,s4 ,dra*#eia 9 ! ,phil4 ,mag41 ,jan4 #ahfc1 ,suppl47 is z accurate z ! use ( #c4adaeibfe4 ,f ?ree diamet]s d$uct #h-?\s&?s & #g-million?s ( a diamet]2 to ! result add five p] c5t4 ,we h !n n q en\gh2 b ! %ortcom+ is at ! rate ( ab\t an in* & a sixtie? ( an in* 9 #ad1jjj miles4 ,,jacob ,,behm54 ,?\gh ,i h met ) no?+ b a little tract f ! s*ool ( ,jacob ,behm5#eib 7or ,boehme2 ,i keep to ! old ,engli% v]sion ( 8 "n71 yet !re has be5 m1 & ( a m rec5t date4 ,i am told ( an ,introduction to ,!osophy ,!o private1 ,i suppose1 z 9 !ological2 or1 ! ,sci5ce ( ! ,my/]y ( ,*ri/1 publi%$ 9 #ahed1 mo/ly f ! writ+s ( ,william ,law#eic3 & also ( a volume ( #fhh pages1 ( ! same ye>1 pr9t$ = private circulation1 conta9+ notes = a biography ( ,william ,law4 ,! editor ( ! fir/ "w wi%es to gr[ a #cah g5]ation ( p]fect ,*ri/ians by f\nd+ a ,!osophic ,college1 = :i* he reque/s ! public to raise a hundr$ ?\s& p\nds4 ,!re is a good acc\nt ( ,jacob ,behm5 9 ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia4 ,! au?or m5tions inaccurate acc\nts1 "o ( :i* he quotes1 z foll[s3 ,he d]iv$ all 8 my/ical & raptur\s doctr9e f ,wood's#eid ,a!nae ,oxoni5ses1 ,vol4 ,i1 p4 #faj1 & ,hi/4 et ,antiq4 ,acad4 ,oxon41 ,vol4 ,,ii1 p4 #cjh4 ,on :i* ! au?or rem>ks t ,wood 0 born aft] ,behm5's dea?4 ,!re mu/ h be5 a few words :i* slipp$ out3 :at is meant is t ,behm5 d]iv$ 8 doctr9e f ,rob]t ,fludd1#eie = :om see ,wood's etc4 etc4 ,ev5 ?is is absurd en\gh3 = ,behm5 began to publi% 9 #afaj1 & ,fludd 9 #afaf4 ,fludd 0 a ,rosicrucian1 & a my/ic ( a diff]5t type f ,behm54 ,i h "s ( 8 works1 & c\ld produce out ( !m p>adoxes en\gh1 accord+ to our ways ( ?9k+1 to fit out a ho/4 ,b ! ,rosicrucian sy/em 0 a recogniz$ s*ool ( its day1 & ,fludd1 a man ( great le>n+1 _h abettors en\gh 9 all :i* he advanc$1 & pr$ecessors 9 mo/ ( x4 ,a ,correspond5t has rec5tly s5t a %ort summ>y ( ! claims ( ,jacob ,behm5 to rank high] ?an ,i h plac$ him4 ,i %all gladly ins]t ?is summ>y 9 ! book ,i contemplate1 z a /atem5t ( :at is said ( ,behm5 f> less liable to suspicion ( exagg]ation ?an any?+ ,i c\ld write4 ,i %all add a few extracts f ,behm5 himself1 9 support ( 8 "r to be 9 my li/4 ,jacob ,behm54--,t ,pr(4 ,de ,morgan classes ,jacob ,behm5 among p>adox]s c only be attribut$ to ! fact ( 8 be+ av[$ly unacqua9t$ ) ! writ+s #cai ( t au?or4 ,p]haps y may ?9k a few words f "o :o kn[s !m well ( suffici5t int]e/ to ! le>n$ ,pr(essor1 & y\r read]s 9 g5]al1 to be wor?y ( space 9 y\r columns4 ,! metaphysical sy/em ( ,behm5--! mo/ p]fect & only true "o--/ill awaits a qualifi$ comm5tator4 ,behm5's c\ntryman1 ,dionysius ,&reas ,freh]1#eif :o sp5t ! great] "p ( 8 life 9 ?is c\ntry1 & ^: exposition ( ,behm5 exi/s only 9 ,,ms41 fill+ _m volumes1 writt5 9 ,engli%1 ) ! exception ( two1 writt5 9 ,g]man1 ) num]\s beautiful1 highly +5i\s1 & elaborate illu/rations1--copies ( "s ( :i* are 9 ! ,briti% ,museum1 b all ! orig9als ( :i* are 9 ! possession ( ! g5tleman :o is ! editor ( ! two works allud$ to by ,pr(essor ,de ,morgan1--?is ,freh] 0 ! fir/ to philosophically exp\nd ,behm5's sy/em1 :i* 0 aft]w>ds1 ) ! help ( ^! ,,mss41 z x 71 popul>iz$ by ,william ,law2 b bo? ,freh] & ,law conf9$ !mselves *iefly to its !ological aspect4 ,9 ,behm51 h[ev]1 is to be f\nd1 n only ! true gr\nd ( all !ology1 b also t ( all physical sci5ce4 ,he demon/rat$ ) a fullness1 accuracy1 complet5ess & c]ta9ty t leave no?+ to be desir$1 ! inn]mo/ gr\nd ( ,deity & ,nature2 &1 conf9+ myself to ! latt]1 ,i c f my own k ass]t1 t 9 ,behm5's writ+s is to be f\nd ! true & cle> demon/ration ( e physical fact t has be5 discov]$ s9ce 8 day4 ,?us1 ! sci5ce ( electricity1 :i* 0 n yet 9 exi/5ce :5 he wrote1 is !re anticipat$2 & n only does ,behm5 describe all ! n[ kn[n ph5om5a ( t =ce1 b he ev5 gives u ! orig91 g5]ation & bir? ( electricity itself4 ,aga91 positive evid5ce c be adduc$ t ,newton d]iv$ all 8 k ( gravitation & its #cbj laws f ,behm51 ) :om gravitation or attraction is1 & v prop]ly s1 z he %[s u1 ! fir/ ( ! sev5 prop]ties ( ,nature4 ,! !ory def5d$ by ,mr4 ,grove1#eig at ! ,nott+ham meet+ ( la/ ye>1 t all ! app>5tly di/9ct causes ( moral & physical ph5om5a are b s _m manife/ations ( "o c5tral =ce1 & t ,cont9uity is ! law ( nature1 is cle>ly laid d[n1 & its tru? demon/rat$1 by ,behm51 z well z ! di/9ction betwe5 _s & matt]1 & t ! moral & mat]ial _w is p]vad$ by a sublime unity4 ,& ?\gh all ?is 0 n admitt$ 9 ,behm5's days1 because sci5ce 0 n !n suffici5tly advanc$ to und]/& ! deep s5se ( our au?or1 _m ( 8 passages1 !n un9telligible1 or app>5tly absurd1 read by ! light ( ! pres5t age1 are f\nd to conta9 ! positive enunciation ( pr9ciples at ^: discov]y & e/abli%m5t sci5ce has only j arriv$ by we>isome & pa9ful inve/igations4 ,e new sci5tific discov]y goes to prove 8 pr(\nd & intuitive insight into ! mo/ secret work+s ( nature2 & if sci5tific m51 in/ead ( %>+ ! prejudice aris+ f ignorance ( ,behm5's sy/em1 w\ld place !mselves on ! vantage gr\nd x af=ds1 !y w\ld at once f9d !mselves on an em95ce :5ce !y c\ld behold all ! arcana ( nature4 ,behm5's sy/em1 9 fact1 %[s u ! inside ( ?+s1 :ile mod]n physical sci5ce is cont5t ) look+ at ! outside4 ,behm5 traces back e outw>d manife/ation or developm5t to its "o c5tral root1--to t "o c5tral en]gy :i*1 z yet1 is only suspect$2 e l9k 9 ! *a9 ( 8 demon/ration is p]fect1 & !re is n "o l9k want+4 ,he c>ries u f ! out-bir?s ( ! circumf]5ce1 along ! radius to ! c5t]1 #cba or po9t1 & beyond t ev5 to ! z]o1 demon/rat+ ! con/itution ( ! z]o1 or no?+1 ) ma!matical precision4 ,c4 ,w4 ,h4 ,& s ,behm5 is no subject = ! ,budget6 ,i wait$ until ,i %\ld *ance to light on "o ( 8 volumes1 kn[+ t any volume w\ld d1 & almo/ any page4 ,my fir/ hap 0 on ! second volume ( ! edition ( #affd 7#dto1 publi%$ by ,m4 ,ri*>dson7 & op5+ ne> ! beg9n+1 a turn or two br\ght me to page #ac1 :]e ,i saw ab\t sulphur & m]curius z foll[s3 ,?us ,,sul is ! s\l1 9 an h]b x is ! oil1 & 9 man also1 accord+ to ! _s ( ?is _w 9 ! ?ird pr9ciple1 :i* is cont9ually g5]at$ out ( ! angui% ( ! w 9 ! m9d1 & ! ,brim/one-worm is ! ,_s1 :i* ha? ! fire & burne?3 ,,phur is ! s\r :eel 9 itself :i* cause? t4 ,m]curius compreh5de? all ! f\r =ms1 ev5 z ! life spr+e? up1 & yet ha? n its d>k beg9n+ 9 ! ,c5t] z ! ,,phur ha?1 b aft] ! fla% ( fire1 :5 ! s\r d>k =m is t]rifi$1 :]e ! h>dness is turn$ into pliant %>pness1 & :]e ! second w 7viz4 ! w ( nature1 :i* is call$ ! ,angui%7 arise?1 !re ,m]curius ha? its orig9al4 ,= ,,m] is ! %iv]+ :eel1 v horrible1 %>p1 v5om\s1 & ho/ile2 :i* assimulate? x ?us 9 ! s\rness 9 ! fla% ( fire1 :]e ! s\r wra?ful life arise?4 ,! syllable ,,cu is ! press+ out1 ( ! ,anxi\s w ( ! m9d1 f ,nature3 :i* is climb+ up1 & wille? to be out al(t4 ,,ri is ! compreh5sion ( ! fla% ( fire1 :i* 9 ,,m] give? a cle> s\nd & tune4 ,= ! fla% make? ! tune1 & x is ! ,salt-,_s :i* s\nde?1 & its =m 7or quality7 is gritty l s&1 & h]e9 arise noises1 s\nds & voices1 & ?us ,,cu compreh5de? ! fla%1 & s ! pressure is z a w9d :i* ?ru/e?1 & give? a _s to ! fla%1 s t x live? & burne?4 ,?us ! #cbb syllable ,,u is call$ ! burn+ fire1 :i* ) ! _s cont9ually drive? itself =?3 & ! syllable ,,cu presse? cont9ually ^u ! fla%4 ,%ades ( ,taul]#eih & ,p>acelsus1#eii h[ /rangely y d mix6 ,well may ,hallam call ,g]many ! native soil ( ,my/icism4 ,_h ,behm5 be5 ! lea/ ( a s*ol>1 he w\ld n h divid$ sulph-ur & m]c-ur-i-u z he has done3 & ! inflexion u1 t boy ( all "w1 w\ld h be5 reject$4 ,i ?9k x w be held t a writ] f :om hundr$s ( pages l ! above c\ld be br\ght toge!r1 is fit = ! ,budget4 ,if ,sampson ,arnold ,mackay#fjj _h ti$ 8 etymologies to a my/ical ,*ri/ology1 in/ead ( a my/ical infidelity1 he might h _h a s*ool ( foll[]s4 ,! nons5se ab\t ,newton borr[+ gravitation f ,behm5 passes only ) ^? :o "k nei!r :at ,newton did1 nor :at 0 done be=e him4 ,! above rem9ds me ( a class ( p>adox]s :om ,i wond] t ,i =got2 !y are )\t exception ! greate/ bores ( all1 because !y c put ! small end ( _! p>adox into any lit]>y conv]sation :atev]4 ,i mean ! p :o h he>d ! local pronunciation ( celebrat$ names1 & attempt n only to imitate x1 b to impose on o!rs _! brok5 ,g]man or ,arabic1 or :at n4 ,!y also le>n ! v]nacul> names ( ^? :o are g5]ally spok5 ( 9 _! ,lat9 =ms2 at lea/1 !y le>n a few cases1 & hawk !m z evid5ces ( erudition4 ,!y are mis]ably mi/ak53 s*ol>%ip1 z a rule1 #cbc always accepts ! v]nacul> =m ( a "n :i* has v]nacul> celebrity4 ,hallam writes ,behm53 8 index-mak]1 r sup]flu\sly1 gives ,behm5 or ,boehm4 ,& he reta9s ,melan*?on1#fja ! "n giv5 by ,reu*l9#fjb to 8 little k9sman ,s*w>tz]d1 because ! _w has adopt$ x3 b he w none ( ,capnio1 ! "n :i* ,reu*l9 fitt$ on to himself1 because ! _w has n adopt$ x4 ,he calls ! old =ms p$antry3 b he sees t ! rejection ( well-e/abli%$ results ( p$antry w\ld be great] p$antry /ill4 ,! p>adox]s assume ! "q t x is m correct to s\nd a man by lame imitation ( 8 own c\ntrym5 ?an z usual 9 ! c\ntry 9 :i* ! s\nd is to be made4 ,aga9/ !m are1 fir/1 ! _w at l>ge2 next1 an ov]p[]+ majority ( ^? :o "k some?+ ab\t surnames & _! hi/ory4 ,"s ?irty ye>s ago--a fact--!re appe>$ at ! police-(fice a compla9ant :o f\nd 8 own law4 ,9 ! c\rse ( 8 argum5t1 he ask$1 ,:at does ,kitty say8--,:o's ,kitty8 said ! magi/rate1 y\r wife1 or y\r nurse8--,sir6 ,i mean ,kitty1 ! celebrat$ lawy]4--,oh6 said ! magi/rate1 ,i suspect y mean ,mr4 ,*itty1#fjc ! au?or ( ! great "w on plead+4--,i d sir6 ,b ,*itty is an ,italian "n1 & ought to be pron\nc$ ,kitty4 ,?is man 0 a full-bl[n fl[]3 b !re is _m a mode/ bud2 & all ought ei!r to blu% :5 se5 or to wa/e _! pronunciation on ! des]t air4 #cbd ,a ,,plea ,,= ,,k+ ,,cu/om4 ,i /& up = ,k+ ,cu/om1 or ,usus1 z ,horace call$ him1 ) :om is arbitrium ! decision1 & jus ! "r1 & norma ! way ( decid+1 simply because he has pote/as ! p[]4 ,he may admit "o & ano!r pr9ciple to advise3 b ,cu/om is n a con/itutional k+2 he may li/5 to 8 cab9et1 b he decides = himself3 & if ! m9i/ry %\ld resign1 he blesses 8 />s & does )\t !m4 ,we h a glori\s lib]ty 9 ,engl& ( own+ nei!r diction>y1 gramm>1 nor spell+-book3 z _m z *oose write by ei!r ( ! ?ree1 & decide all disput$ po9ts _! own way1 ^? foll[+ !m :o please4 ,?r\gh\t ?is book ,i h call$ p by ! names :i* d5ote !m 9 _! books1 or by our v]nacul> names4 ,?is is ! intelligible way ( proce$+4 ,i might1 = in/ance 7,vol4 ,i1 p4 #dd71 h spok5 ( ,*>les de ,bovelles1#fjd ( ,lefevre d',etaples1#fje ( ,pel]91#fjf & ( ,eti5ne4#fjg ,b ,i pref] ! old plan4 ,^? :o l ano!r plan bett]1 are welcome to sub/itute ) a p51 :5 !y "k :at to write2 :5 !y d n1 x is cle> t !y w\ld n h und]/ood me if ,i _h giv5 mod]n names4 ,! pr9cipal advis]s ( ,k+ ,cu/om are z foll[s4 ,fir/1 !re is ,etymology1 ! *iffonni]1 or g5]al rag-m]*ant1 :o has made su* a =tune ( late ye>s 9 8 own bus9ess t he beg9s to be consid]$ highly respectable4 ,he gives advice :i* is m ?\ght ( ?an foll[$1 p>tly on acc\nt ( ! fe>ful extremes into :i* he runs4 ,he lately ask$ "s boys ( sixte51 at a matriculation exam9ation 9 ,engli%1 to :at bran* ( #cbe ! ,indo-,g]manic family !y felt incl9$ to ref] ! ,pu%to language1 & :at *anges 9 ! =ce ( ! lett]s took place 9 pass+ f ,greek into ,moeso-,go?ic4 ,because all syllables 7 once words1 he is a little incl9$ to insi/ t !y %all be s /ill4 ,he w\ld gladly rule ,engli% ) a ,saxon rod1 :i* might be p]mitt$ ) a c]ta9 discretion :i* he has nev] atta9$3 & :5 oppos$1 he def5ds himself ) analogies ( ! ,aryan family until ^? :o he> him long = ! discov]y ( an ,a?anasyus4 ,he w transport a ^w beyond seas--he is record] ( ,rhematopolis--on circum/antial evid5ce :i* looks l my/]y gone mad2 b1 /range to say1 some?+ v (t5 comes to light aft] s5t5ce is pass$ :i* proves ! s\ndness ( ! conviction4 ,! next advis] is ,logic1 a swe>+ old ju/ice ( peace1 quorum1 & rotulorum1 ^: excesses br\ght on su* a fit ( ! g\t t = _m ye>s he 0 unable to move4 ,he is n[ m5d+1 & 8 fri5ds say he has s[n 8 wild oats4 ,he has "s influ5ce ) ! educat$ subjects ( ,cu/om1 & w h m1 if he c le>n ! l9e at :i* int]f]5ce ought to /op3 ) !m he has succe$$ 9 mak+ an affirmative ( two negatives2 b ! vulg> won't nev] h no?+ to say to him4 ,he has always rail$ at ,milton = writ+ t ,eve 0 ! faire/ ( h] daught]s2 b has nev] satisfactorily %[n :at ,milton ought to h said in/ead4 ,! ?ird advis] has m influ5ce ) ! mass ( ! subjects ( ,k+ ,cu/om ?an ! o!r two put toge!r2 8 "n is ,fiddlefaddle1 ! toy-%op keep]2 & ! o!r two put him =w>d to d _! wor/ "w4 ,9 return1 he (t5 uses _! names )\t au?ority4 ,he took ,etymology to witness t means to an end mu/ be plural3 & he w\ld h any "o me?od to be a mean4 ,b ,etymology prov$ him wrong1 ,k+ ,cu/om ref]r$ him to 8 ,cate*ism1 9 :i* is a means :]eby we receive ! same1 & ,analogy--a subord9ate ( #cbf ,etymology--ask$ :e!r he ?\ght x a great new to he> t he 0 wrong4 ,x 0 ei!r ?is ,fiddlefaddle1 or ,l9dley ,murray#fjh 8 travel]1 :o p]suad$ ! ,miss ,slipslops1 ( ! ,ladies ,sem9>y1 to put ,! ,misses ,slipslop ov] ! gate4 ,sixty ye>s ago1 ?is bagman call$ at all ! girls' s*ools1 & got _m ( ! tea*]s to insi/ on ! pupils say+ ,is x n & ,c ,i n = ,isn't x & ,c't ,i3 ( :i* x came t ! poor girls 7 dreadfully laugh$ at by _! irrev]5t bro!rs :5 !y w5t home = ! holidays4 ,_h ?is bad advis] n be5 sev]ely *eck$1 he might by ?is "t h propos$ our say+ ,! ,que5's ( ,engl& son1 decl>+1 9 ! "n ( ,logic1 t ! pr9ce 0 ! ,que5's son1 n ,engl&'s4 ,la/ly1 !re is ,typography ! metallurgi/1 an executive (fic] :o is always at "w 9 secret1 & ^: lawless mode ( advis+ is (t5 done by c>ry+ 8 notions into effect )\t leave giv54 ,he x is :o nev] ceases sugge/+ t ! same ^w is n to occur 9 a second place )9 sight ( ! fir/4 ,:5 ! ,au?oriz$ ,v]sion 0 fir/ pr9t$1 he began ?is trick at ! passage1 ,let !re be light1 & !re 0 light2 he drew a l9e on ! pro( "u ! second light1 & wrote lum9osity8 opposite4 ,he is /ronge/ 9 ! punctuations & o!r signs2 he has a pepp]-box full ( commas always by 8 side4 ,he puts ev]y?+ "u m>ks ( quotation :i* he has ev] he>d be=e4 ,an e>ne/ prea*]1 9 a v mov+ s]mon1 us$ ! phrase ,alas6 & alack a day6 ,typography /uck up ! inv]t$ commas because he _h read ! old ,anglo-,indian toa/1 ,a lass & a lac a day6 ,if any "o %\ld h ! s5se to leave out ( 8 ,greek #cbg ! unmean+ scrat*es :i* !y call acc5ts1 he goes to a lexicon & puts !m 94 ,he is p[]ful 9 r\t9e2 b :5 two r\t9es int]lace or ov]lap1 he frequ5tly takes ! wrong "o4 ,subject to bad advice1 & sometimes misl$ = a season1 ,k+ ,cu/om goes on 8 quiet way & is sure to be "r at la/4 ,treason does nev] prosp]3 :at's ! reason8 ,:y1 :5 x prosp]s1 none d>e call x treason4 ,language is 9 con/ant f]m5tation1 & all t is ?r[n 91 s f> z x is n fit to assimilate1 is ?r[n (f2 & ?is )\t any obvi\s /ruggle4 ,9 ! mean:ile e "o :o has read good au?ors1 f ,%akspe>e d[nw>d1 kn[s :at is & :at is n ,engli%2 & kn[s1 also1 t our language is n "o & indivisible4 ,two v diff]5t turns ( phrase may bo? be equally good1 & z good z c be3 we may be reliev$ ( ! consequ5ces ( contempt ( "o c\rt by habeas corpus issu+ out ( ano!r4 ,,te/ ,,( ,,language4 ,hallam rem>ks t ! ,au?oriz$ ,v]sion ( ! ,bible is n 9 ! language ( ! "t ( ,james ! ,fir/3 t x is n ! ,engli% ( ,raleigh or ( ,bacon4 ,"h arises ! "q :e!r ,raleigh & ,bacon are ! true expositors ( ! language ( _! "t2 & :e!r !y 7 n r ! incipi5t promot]s ( a *ange :i* 0 successfully resi/$ by--among o!r ?+s--! ,au?oriz$ ,v]sion ( ! ,te/am5ts4 ,i am n prep>$ to conc$e t ,i %\ld h giv5 to ! ,engli% :i* w\ld h be5 fa%ion$ ^u t ( ,bacon by imitators1 su* z !y usually are1 ! admiration :i* is =c$ f me by ,bacon's ,engli% f ,bacon's p54 ,on ?is po9t we h a notable p>allel4 ,samuel ,johnson #cbh comm&s our admiration1 at lea/ 9 8 matur$ /yle3 b we nauseate 8 foll[]s4 ,x is an op9ion ( m9e t ! works ( ! lead+ writ]s ( an age are seldom ! prop] specim5s ( ! language ( _! day1 :5 t language is 9 its /ate ( progression4 ,i judge ( a language by ! colloquial idiom ( educat$ m53 t is1 ,i take ?is to be ! be/ m$ium betwe5 ! extreme cases ( "o :o is ignorant ( gramm> & "o :o is p]*$ ^u a /yle4 ,dialogue is :at ,i want to judge by1 & pla9 dialogue3 s ,i *oose ,rob]t ,recorde#fji & 8 pupil 9 ! ,ca/le ( ,k1 writt5 be=e #aeef4 ,:5 ,dr4 ,rob]t gets into 8 altitudes ( in/ruction1 he diff]s f 8 own common phraseology z mu* z probably did ,bacon :5 he wrote morals & philosophy4 ,b e n[ & !n ,i come to a little pla9 talk ab\t a common ?+1 ( :i* ,i propose to %[ a specim54 ,any?+ c be made to look old by su* *anges z makes into make?1 ) a little old spell+4 ,i %all inv]t ^! *anges1 us+ ! new] =m ( inflexion1 & ! mod]n spell+3 ) no o!r v>iation :atev]4 ,s*ol>4 ,yet ! reason ( t is easy en\gh to be conceiv$1 = :5 ! day is at ! longe/ ! ,sun mu/ ne$s %9e ! m "t1 & s mu/ x ne$s %9e ! less "t :5 ! day is at ! %orte/3 ?is reason ,i h he>d _m m5 decl>e4 ,ma/]4 ,t may be call$ a crabb$ reason1 = x #cbi goes backw>d l a crab4 ,! day makes n ! ,sun to %9e1 b ! ,sun %9+ makes ! day4 ,& s ! l5g? ( ! day makes n ! ,sun to %9e long1 nei!r ! %ortness ( ! day causes n sic ! ,sun to %9e ! less] "t1 b contr>iwise ! long %9+ ( ! ,sun makes ! long day1 & ! %ort %9+ ( ! ,sun makes ! less] day3 else answ] me :at makes ! days long or %ort8 ,s*ol>4 ,i h he>d wise m5 say t ,summ] makes ! long days1 & ,w9t] makes ! long nights4 ,ma/]4 ,!y might h said m wisely1 t long days make summ] & %ort days make w9t]4 ,s*ol>4 ,:y1 all t seems "o ?+ to me4 ,ma/]4 ,is x all "o to say1 ,god made ! e>?1 & ! e>? made ,god8 ,covet\sness ov]comes all m51 & all m5 ov]come covet\sness8 ,s*ol>4 ,no1 n s2 = "h ! effect is turn$ to be ! cause1 & ! ag5t is made ! pati5t4 ,ma/]4 ,s is x to say ,summ] makes long days1 :5 y %\ld say3 ,long days make summ]4 ,s*ol>4 ,i p]ceive x n[3 b ,i 0 s bl9d$ ) ! vulg> error1 t if y _h dem&$ ( me fur!r :at did make ! summ]1 ,i _h be5 l to h answ]$ t gre5 leaves d make summ]2 & ! soon] by remembrance ( an old say+ t a ye> %\ld come 9 :i* ! summ] %\ld n be kn[n b by ! gre5 leaves4 ,ma/]4 ,yet ?is say+ does n import t gre5 leaves d make summ]1 b t !y betok5 summ]2 s are !y ! sign & n ! cause ( summ]4 ,i h tak5 a :ole page ( our au?or1 )\t omission1 t ! read] may see t ,i d n pick out s5t5ces conv5i5t = my purpose4 ,i h done no?+ b alt] ! ?ird p]son ( ! v]b & ! spell+3 b great is ! effect !re(4 ,we say ! ,sun %9+ makes ! day2 ,recorde1 ! ,sonne %ynynge make? ! daye4 #ccj ,^! po9ts ap>t1 we see a resemblance betwe5 our ,engli% & t ( ?ree hundr$ ye>s ago1 9 ! common talk ( educat$ p]sons1 :i* w all[ u to affirm t ! language ( ! au?oriz$ ,bible mu/ h be5 v close to t ( its "t4 ,= ,i _c admit t mu* *ange c h tak5 place 9 fifty ye>s3 & ! language ( ! v]sion repres5ts bo? our common ,engli% & t ( ,recorde ) v close approximation4 ,take s5t5ces f ,bacon & ,raleigh1 & x w be app>5t t ^! writ]s w be held to diff] f all ?ree1 ,recorde1 ! v]sion1 & ourselves1 by diff]5ces ( ! same "*4 ,b we speak ( ,recorde's conv]sation1 & ( our own4 ,we conclude t x is ! pla9 & almo/ colloquial "* ( ! ,au?oriz$ ,v]sion :i* di/+ui%es x f ! ,engli% ( ,bacon & ,raleigh1 by approximat+ x to ! common idiom ( ! "t4 ,if any "o w ca/ an eye ^u ! lett]s ( in/ruction writt5 by ,cecil#faj & ! ,bi%op ( ,london to ! translators !mselves1 or to ! g5]al directions s5t to !m 9 ! ,k+'s "n1 he w f9d t ^! pla9 bus9ess compositions diff] f ! ,engli% ( ,bacon & ,raleigh by ! same sort ( diff]5ces :i* di/+ui% ! v]sion itself4 ,,pronunciation4 ,! =eign ^w1 or ! ^w ( a di/rict1 or class ( p1 passes into ! g5]al v]nacul>2 b x is long be=e ! specially le>n$ w ackn[l$ge ! "r ( ^? ) :om !y come 9 contact to foll[ g5]al usage4 ,! rule is simple3 s long z a ^w is te*nical or local1 ^? :o "k its te*nical or local pronunciation may reasonably employ x4 ,b :5 ! ^w has become g5]al1 ! speciali/ is n v wise if he refuse to foll[ #cca ! mass1 & p]fectly fooli% if he insi/ on o!rs foll[+ him4 ,!re h be5 a few :o dem&$ t ,eul] %\ld be pron\nc$ 9 ! ,g]man fa%ion3#faa ,eul] has long be5 ! prop]ty ( ! _w at l>ge2 :at does x matt] h[ 8 own c\ntrym5 pron\nce ! lett]s8 ,%all we insi/ on ! ,fr5* pron\nc+ ,newton )\t t f9al tong :i* !y nev] fail to give him8 ,!y w\ld be wise en\gh to laugh at u if we did4 ,we rememb] t a p$ant :o 0 insi/+ on all ! pronunciations be+ reta9$1 0 met by a maxim 9 contradiction1 inv5t$ at ! mom5t1 & fa!r$ ^u ,ka5-foo-tzee1#fab an au?ority :i* he 0 *all5g$ to dispute4 ,:om did y speak (8 said ! bewild]$ man ( accuracy4 ,le>n y\r own sy/em1 0 ! answ]1 be=e y impose x on o!rs2 ,confucius says t too4#fac ,! old ,engli% has fote1 fode1 loke1 coke1 roke1 etc41 = foot1 etc4 ,& above rhymes 9 ,*auc] to remove4 ,suspect+ t ! broad] s\nds are ! old]1 we may surmise t remove & food h reta9$ _! old s\nds1 & t cook1 once coke1 w\ld h rhym$ to our ,luke1 ! v[el be+ br\ght a little ne>]1 p]haps1 to ! o 9 our pres5t coke1 ! fuel1 probably s call$ z us$ by cooks4 ,if ?is be s1 ! ,*ief ,ju/ice ,cook#fad ( our lawy]s1 & ! ,coke 7pron\nc$ l ! fuel7 ( ! great] "p ( ! _w1 are equally wrong4 ,! lawy] has no "r :atev] to fa/5 8 pronunciation ^u u3 ev5 leav+ aside ! g5]al cu/om1 he _c prove himself "r1 & is probably wrong4 ,^? :o #ccb "k ! village ( ,rokeby 7pron\nc$ ,rookby7 despise ! _w = n kn[+ h[ to "n ,walt] ,scott's poem3 t same _w nev] ask$ a "q ab\t ! matt]1 & ! reception ( ! p>ody ( ,jokeby1 :i* soon appe>$1 0 a suffici5t indication ( _! notion4 ,^? :o w\ld fa/5 ! hodi]nal s\nd ^u u may be rem9d$ t ! "q is1 n :at !y call x n[1 b :at x 0 call$ 9 ,cromwell's "t4 ,?r[ away g5]al usage z a lawgiv]1 & ?is is ! po9t :i* em]ges4 ,probably ,ruke-by w\ld be "r1 ) a little turn+ ( ! ,italian u t[>ds o ( mod]n ,engli%4 ,"s ( ! above is f an old review4 ,i d n always notice su* ins]tions3 ,i take no?+ b my own writ+s4 ,a fri5d once said to me1 ,ah6 y got t out ( ! ,a!naeum6 ,excuse me1 said ,i4 ! ,a!naeum got t out ( me6 ,,apologies ,,to ,,cluvi]4 ,x is "p ( my function to d ju/ice to any cyclomet]s ^: me?ods h be5 wrongly describ$ by any or?odox sne]]s 7myself includ$74 ,9 ?is "* ,i mu/ notice ,de?levus ,cluv]ius1#fae z ! ,leipzig ,acts call him 7probably ,de?leu ,cluvi]71 gr&son ( ! celebrat$ geograph]1 ,philip ,cluvi]4 ,! gr&son 0 a ,fell[ ( ! ,royal ,society1 elect$ on ! same day z ,halley1#faf ,novemb] #cj1 #afgh3 ,i suppose he liv$ 9 ,engl&4 ,?is #ccc man is quizz$ 9 ! ,leipzig ,acts = #afhf2 &1 if ,montucla ins9uate rightly1 by ,leibnitz1 :o is fur!r suspect$ ( want+ to embroil ,cluvi] ) 8 own oppon5t ,nieuw5tiit1#fag on ! matt] ( inf9itesimals4 ,s f> good3 ,i h no?+ aga9/ ,leibnitz1 :o ?\gh he 0 ironical1 told u :at he laugh$ at4 ,b ,montucla has behav$ v unfairly3 he repres5ts ,cluvi] z plac+ ! ess5ce ( 8 me?od 9 ! solution ( ! problem con/ru]e mundum div9ae m5ti analogum1 to con/ruct a _w correspond+ to ! div9e m9d4 ,no?+ to beg9 )3 no way ( proce$+4 ,n[1 x ought to h be5 ex data l9ea con/ru]e1#fah etc43 !re is a giv5 l9e1 :i* is some?+ to g on4 ,fur!r1 !re is a way ( proce$+3 x is to f9d ! product ( #a1 #b1 #c1 #d1 etc4 = ev]4 ,moreov]1 ,montucla *>ges ,cluvi] ) unsqu>+ ! p>abola1 :i* ,ar*im$es _h squ>$ z tight z a glove4 ,b he nev] m5tions h[ v ne>ly ,cluvi] agrees ) ! ,greek3 !y only diff] by #a divid$ by #cn#b1 :]e n is ! inf9ite numb] ( p>ts ( :i* a p>abola is compos$4 ,?is mu/ h be5 ! conceit t tickl$ ,leibnitz1 & made him wi% t ,cluvi] & ,nieuw5tiit %\ld fight x out4 ,cluvi]1 0 admitt$1 on t]ms ( irony1 into ! ,leipzig ,acts3 he appe>$ on a m s]i\s foot+ 9 ,london4 ,x is v r>e = "o cyclomet] to refute ano!r3 les corsaires ne se batt5t pas4#fai ,! only in/ance ,i recall is t ( ,m4 ,cluvi]1 :o 7,phil4 ,trans41 #afhf1 ,no4 #ahe7 refut$ ,m4 ,mallemont de ,messange1#fbj :o #ccd publi%$ at ,p>is 9 #afhf4 ,he does x 9 a v s]i\s /yle1 & %[s himself a ma!matician4 ,& yet 9 ! ye> 9 :i*1 9 ! ,phil4 ,trans41 he 0 a geomet]1 & "o :o rebukes 8 squ>] = quot+ ,mat!w xi4 #be1 9 t v ye> he 0 ! vision>y :o1 9 ! ,leipzig ,acts1 pr(ess$ to build a _w resembl+ ! div9e m9d by multiply+ toge!r #a1 #b1 #c1 #d1 etc4 up to inf9ity4 ,,! ,,ra9b[ ,,p>adox4 ,!re is a v pretty op5+ = a p>adox :i* has nev] f\nd its p>adox] 9 pr9t4 ,! philosoph]s tea* t ! ra9b[ is n mat]ial3 x comes f ra9-drops1 b ^? ra9-drops d n take color4 ,!y only give x1 z l5ses & mirrors2 & ea* "o drop gives all ! colors1 b ?r[s !m 9 diff]5t directions4 ,accord+ly1 ! same drop :i* furni%es r$ light to "o spectator w furni% violet to ano!r1 prop]ly plac$4 ,ent] ! p>adox] :om ,i h to inv5t4 ,! philosoph] has gull$ y nicely4 ,look into ! wat]1 & y w see ! reflect$ ra9b[3 take a look+-glass held sideways1 & y see ano!r reflection4 ,h[ c\ld ?is be1 if !re 7 no?+ color$ to reflect8 ,! p>adox]'s facts are true3 & :at are call$ ! reflect$ ra9b[s are o!r ra9b[s1 caus$ by ^? o!r drops :i* are plac$ s z to give ! colors to ! eye aft] reflection1 at ! wat] or ! look+-glass4 ,a few ye>s ago an arti/ exhibit$ a picture ) a ra9b[ & its app>5t reflection3 he simply copi$ :at he _h se54 ,:5 8 picture 0 exam9$1 "s />t$ ! idea t !re c\ld be no reflection ( a ra9b[2 !y 7 "r3 !y inf]r$ t ! arti/ _h made a mi/ake2 !y 7 wrong4 ,:5 x 0 expla9$1 "s agre$ & "s diss5t$4 ,want$1 #cce imm$iately1 an able p>adox]3 te/imonials to be =w>d$ to ei!r end ( ! ra9b[1 ,no4 #a4 ,no circle-squ>] ne$ apply1 ,8 ,v>iegat$ness hav+ be5 pleas$ to adopt #c4adaei444 f ,noah d[nw>ds4 ,,ty*o ,,brahe ,,reviv$4 ,! sy/em ( ,ty*o ,brahe1#fba ) "s alt]ation & addition1 has be5 reviv$ & cont5d$ = 9 our own day by a ,dane1 ,w4 ,zytph51#fbb :o has publi%$ ,! ,motion ( ! ,sun 9 ! ,univ]se1 7second edition7 ,cop5hag51 #ahfe1 #hvo1 & ,le ,m\vem5t ,sid]al1 #ahfe1 #hvo4 ,i make an extract4 ,h[ c "o expla9 ,cop]nically t ! velocity ( ! ,moon mu/ be add$ to ! velocity ( ! ,e>? on ! "o place 9 ! ,e>?'s orbit1 to le>n h[ f> ! ,moon has advanc$ f "o fix$ /> to ano!r2 b 9 ano!r place 9 ! orbit ^! velocities mu/ be subtract$ 7! movem5ts tak+ place 9 opposite directions7 to atta9 ! same result8 ,9 ! ,cop]nican & o!r sy/ems1 x is well kn[n t ! ,moon1 ab/ract+ f ! insignificant exc5tricity ( ! orbit1 always 9 tw5ty-f\r h\rs p]=ms an equally long di/ance4 ,:y has ,cop]nicus nev] be5 d5om9at$ ,fundam5tus or ,fundator8 ,because he has nev] conv9c$ anybody s ?or\ghly t ?is o!rwise s natural epi!t has occurr$ to ! m9d4 ,really ! second "q is m effective aga9/ ,newton ?an aga9/ ,cop]nicus2 = x upsets gravity3 ! fir/ is ( great dep?4 #ccf ,,james ,,smi? ,,w ,,n ,,d[n4 ,! ,correspond5t j\rnal makes a little episode 9 ! hi/ory ( my ,budget 7born ,may1 #ahfe1 di$ ,april1 #ahff74 ,x consi/$ entirely ( lett]s writt5 by correspond5ts4 ,9 ,augu/1 a correspond5t :o sign$ ,fair ,play--& :o ,i 0 aft]w>ds told 0 a lady--?\ght x w\ld be a good joke to br+ 9 ! ,cyclomet]s4 ,accord+ly a lett] 0 writt51 compla9+ t ?\gh ,mr4 ,sylve/]'s#fbc demon/ration ( ,newton's !orem--!n attract+ public att5tion--0 duly laud$1 ! possibly great] discov]y ( ! quadrature seem$ to be blu%+ unse51 & wa/+ etc4 ,x w5t on z foll[s3 ,pr(4 ,de ,morgan1 :o1 f 8 position 9 ! sci5tific _w1 might fairly af=d to look fav\rably on less practis$ ef=ts ?an 8 own1 seems to delight 9 ridicul+ ! discov]]4 ,sci5ce is1 ( c\rse1 a v respectable p]son :5 he comes out & makes himself useful 9 ! _w x mu/ h be5 a lady2 ea* sex gives sci5ce to ! o!r3 b :51 l a monk ( ! ,middle ,ages1 he %uts himself up x mu/ h be5 a lady2 !y always snub ! ba*elors 9 8 cloi/]$ cell1 repeat+ 8 mumpsimus f day to day1 & despis+ ! lab\r]s on ! outside1 we beg9 to ?9k ( ,galileo1#fbd ,j5n]1#fbe ,h>vey1#fbf & o!r glori\s trios1 :o h be5 contemn$ 444 ,! writ] !n call$ ^u ,mr4 ,james ,smi?#fbg to come #ccg =w>d4 ,! irony 0 n se52 & t day =tnight appe>$ ! fir/ ( m ?an ?irty lett]s f 8 p54 ,mr4 ,smi? 0 foll[$ by ,mr4 ,r$die1#fbh ,zadkiel1#fbi & o!rs1 on _! sev]al subjects4 ,to "s ( ! lett]s ,i h ref]r$2 to o!rs ,i %all come4 ,! ,correspond5t 0 to become a fir/-class sci5tific j\rnal2 ! "t _h arriv$ at :i* tru? _h an organ3 & ,i receiv$ =mal notice t ,i c\ld n /ifle x by sil5ce1 nor conv]t x into falsehood by ridicule4 ,:5 my read] sees my extracts1 he w readily believe my decl>ation t ,i %\ld h be5 ! la/ to /ifle a publication :i* 0 e week :at ,james ,mill#fcj w\ld call a dose ( capital = my ,budget4 ,a few anti-p>adox]s br\ght 9 common s5se3 b to ! mass ( ! read]s ( ! j\rnal x all seem$ to be ! diff]5ce betwe5 ,twe$l$um & ,twe$l$ee4 ,"s said t ! influx ( sci5tific p>adoxes kill$ ! j\rnal3 b my belief is t !y made x la/ long] ?an x o!rwise w\ld h done4 ,tw5ty ye>s ago ,i recomm5d$ ! p>adox]s to comb9e & publi% _! views 9 a common j\rnal3 ) a ca?olic editor1 :o _h no pet !ory1 b a /]n det]m9ation n to exclude any?+ m]ely = absurdity4 ,i suspect x w\ld answ] v well4 ,a /rong title1 or motto1 w\ld be want$3 n s co>se z 0 ro>$ out 9 a ,cambridge mob :5 ,i 0 an und]graduate--,no ,k+6 ,no ,*ur*6 ,no ,h\se ( ,lords6 ,no no?+1 bla/ me6--b some?+ on t pr9ciple4 ,at ! end ( #ahfg ,i address$ ! foll[+ lett] to ! ,a!naeum3 ,,pseudoma?1 ,,philoma?1 ,,& ,,graphoma?4 ,decemb] #ca1 #ahfg ,_m ?anks = ! pres5t ( ,mr4 ,james ,smi?'s lett]s #cch ( ,sept4 #bh & ( ,oct4 #aj & #ab4 ,he asks :]e y w be if y read & dige/ 8 lett]s3 y probably w be some:]e fir/4 ,he aft]w>ds asks :at ! ,,we ( ! ,a!naeum w be if1 f9d+ x impossible to controv]t1 x %\ld refuse to pr9t4 ,i answ] = y1 t ,we-,we ( ! ,a!naeum1 n be+ ,wa-,wa ! wild goose1 s conspicu\s 9 ,hiawa?a1 w leave :at controv]ts itself to pr9t itself1 if x please4 ,philoma? is a good old ^w1 easi] to write & speak ?an ma!matician4 ,x wants ! words betwe5 :i* ,i h plac$ x4 ,!y are n well =m$3 pseudoma!te & graphoma!te w\ld be bett]3 b !y w d4 ,i give an in/ance ( ea*4 ,! pseudoma? is a p]son :o h&les ma!matics z ! monkey h&l$ ! razor4 ,! creature tri$ to %ave himself z he _h se5 8 ma/] d2 b1 n hav+ any notion ( ! angle at :i* ! razor 0 to be held1 he cut 8 own ?roat4 ,he nev] tri$ a second "t1 poor animal6 b ! pseudoma? keeps on at 8 "w1 proclaims himself clean-%av$1 & all ! re/ ( ! _w hairy4 ,s great is ! diff]5ce betwe5 moral & physical ph5om5a6 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? is1 beyond d\bt1 ! great pseudoma? ( our "t4 ,8 #c-a_/h is ! lea/ ( a wond]ful *a9 ( discov]ies4 ,8 books1 l ,:itbread's b>rels1 w "o day rea* f ,simpk9 ,m>%all's to ,kew1 plac$ upright1 or to ,w9dsor laid l5g?-ways4 ,! ,que5 w run away on _! ne> approa*1 z ,bi%op ,hatto did f ! rats3 b ,mr4 ,james ,smi? w foll[ h] 7 x to ,john o' ,groats4 ,! philoma?1 = my pres5t purpose1 mu/ be exhibit$ z giv+ a lesson to presumption4 ,! foll[+ anecdote is f\nd 9 ,?iebault's#fca ,s\v5irs de v+t ans de sej\rs a ,b]l91 publi%$ 9 #ahjd4 ,! book itself got a high "* = tru?4 ,9 #ahjg ,m>%al ,moll5dorff#fcb #cci answ]$ an inquiry ( ! ,duc de ,bassano1#fcc by say+ t x 0 ! mo/ v]aci\s ( books1 writt5 by ! mo/ hone/ ( m54 ,?iebault does n claim p]sonal k ( ! anecdote1 b he v\*es = its be+ receiv$ z true all ov] ! nor? ( ,europe4#fcd ,did]ot#fce paid a visit to ,russia at ! invitation ( ,ca!r9e ! ,second4 ,at t "t he 0 an a!i/1 or at lea/ talk$ a!ism3 x w\ld be easy to prove him ei!r "o ?+ or ! o!r f 8 writ+s4 ,8 lively sallies on ?is subject mu* amus$ ! ,empress1 & all ! y\ng] "p ( h] ,c\rt4 ,b "s ( ! old] c\rti]s sugge/$ t x 0 h>dly prud5t to all[ su* unres]v$ exhibitions4 ,! ,empress ?\ght s too1 b did n l to muzzle h] gue/ by an express prohibition3 s a plot 0 contriv$4 ,! scorn] 0 in=m$ t an em95t ma!matician _h an algebraical pro( ( ! exi/5ce ( ,god1 :i* he w\ld communicate be=e ! :ole ,c\rt1 if agreeable4 ,did]ot gladly cons5t$4 ,! ma!matician1 :o is n nam$1 0 ,eul]4#fcf ,he came to ,did]ot ) ! grave/ air1 & 9 a tone ( p]fect conviction said1 ,monsieur6 7a bn7_/n x donc ,dieu exi/e2 repondez6#fcg ,did]ot1 to :om algebra 0 ,hebrew1 ?\gh ?is is express$ 9 a v r\ndab\t way by ,?iebault--& :om we may suppose to h expect$ "s v]bal argum5t ( alleg$ algebraical clos5ess1 0 disconc]t$2 :ile peals ( laught] s\nd$ on all sides4 ,next day he ask$ p]mission to return to ,france1 :i* 0 grant$4 ,an algebrai/ w\ld h #cdj turn$ ! tables completely1 by say+1 ,monsieur6 v\s savez bi5 que votre raisonnem5t dem&e le developpem5t de x suivant les puissances enti]es de n4#fch ,goldsmi? c\ld n h se5 ! anecdote1 or he might h be5 suppos$ to h drawn f x a h9t z to ! way 9 :i* ! ,squire demoli%$ poor ,moses4 ,! graphoma? is a p]son :o1 hav+ no ma!matics1 attempts to describe a ma!matician4 ,noveli/s p]=m 9 ?is way3 ev5 ,walt] ,scott n[ & !n burns 8 f+]s4 ,8 dream+ calculator1 ,davy ,ramsay1 swe>s by ! bones ( ! immortal ,napi]4 ,scott ?\ght t ! ! philoma?s wor%ip$ relics3 s !y d1 9 "o s5se4 ,look into ,hutton's#fci ,diction>y = ,napi]'s ,bones1 & y %all le>n all ab\t ! little knick-knacks by :i* he did multiplication & division4 ,b nev] a bone ( 8 own did he contribute2 he pref]r$ elephants' tusks4 ,! au?or ( ,headlong ,hall#fdj makes a gr& error1 :i* is q high sci5ce3 he says t ,laplace prov$ ! precession ( ! equ9oxes to be a p]iodical inequality4 ,he %\ld h said ! v>iation ( ! obliquity4 ,b ! f9e/ in/ance is ! foll[+3 ,mr4 ,w>r51#fda 9 8 well-wr\ght tale ( ! m>tyr-philosoph]1 0 incauti\s en\gh to inv5t ! symbols by :i* 8 savant satisfi$ himself ,laplace#fdb 0 "r on a d\btful po9t4 ,& ?is is :at he put toge!r-- sqrt-#c;a#b1 rectangley#b _/ z#b #i - n #i1 n x log e4 ,n[1 to ,did]ot & ! mass ( mank9d ?is might be ,laplace all ov]3 &1 9 a =g$ note ( ,pascal1 w\ld #cda prove him q up to gravitation4 ,b ,i "k ( no?+ l x1 except 9 ! lately receiv$ /ory ( ! ,am]ican orator1 :o 0 call$ on = "s ,lat91 & p]orat$ ?us3 ,committ+ ! de/9y ( ! c\ntry to y\r h&s1 ,g5tlem51 ,i may )\t fe> decl>e1 9 ! language ( ! noble ,roman poet1 ,e pluribus unum1 ,multum 9 p>vo1 ,ultima ,?ule1 ,s9e qua non4#fdc ,b ! ,am]ican got ne>] to ,horace ?an ! m>tyr-philosoph] to ,laplace4 ,= all ! words are 9 ,horace1 except ,?ule1 :i* might h be5 !re4 ,b rectangle is n a symbol want$ by ,laplace2 nor c we see h[ x c\ld h be52 9 fact1 x is n recogniz$ 9 algebra4 ,z to ! junctions1 etc41 ,laplace & ,horace are ab\t equally well imitat$4 ,fur!r ?anks = ,mr4 ,smi?'s lett]s to y ( ,oct4 #ae1 #ah1 #ai1 #bh1 & ,nov4 #d1 #ae4 ,! la/ ( ^! lett]s has two curi\s discov]ies4 ,fir/1 ,mr4 ,smi? decl>es t he has se5 ! editor ( ! ,a!naeum3 9 sev]al previ\s lett]s he m5tions a "n4 ,if he knew a little ( j\rnalism he w\ld be aw>e t editors are a peculi> race1 obta9$ by natural selection4 ,!y are nev] se51 ev5 by _! (ficials2 only he>d d[n a pipe4 ,secondly1 an ellipse or oval is compos$ ( f\r arcs ( circles4 ,mr4 ,smi? has got hold ( ! con/ruction ,i 0 taught1 :5 a boy1 = a pretty f\r-arc oval4 ,b my tea*]s knew bett] ?an to call x an ellipse3 ,mr4 ,smi? does n2 b he produces f x su* confirmation ( #c-a_/h z w\ld conv9ce any hone/ editor4 ,surely ! cyclomet] is a ,d>w9ite developm5t ( a spid]1 :o is always at circles1 & always beg9s aga9 :5 8 web is bru%$ away4 ,he in=ms y t he #cdb has be5 privileg$ to discov] tru?s unkn[n to ! sci5tific _w4 ,?is we "k2 b he proce$s to %[ t he is equally =tunate 9 art4 ,he goes on to say t he w make use ( y to br+ ^? tru?s to light1 j z an arti/ makes use ( a dummy = ! purpose ( arrang+ 8 drap]y4 ,! pa9t]'s lay-figure is = fl[+ robes2 ! hairdress]'s dummy is = curly locks4 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? %\ld read ,sam ,well]'s pa!tic /ory ( ! f\r wax dummies4 ,z to 8 use ( a dummy1 x is q correct4 ,:5 ,i 0 at ,univ]sity ,college1 ,i walk$ "o day into a room 9 :i* my ,lat9 colleague 0 exam9+4 ,"o ( ! que/ions 01 ,give ! lives & fates ( ,sp4 ,maelius1#fdd & ,sp4 ,cassius4#fde ,umph6 said ,i1 surely all "k t ,spurius ,maelius 0 :ipp$ = adult]at+ fl\r1 & t ,spurius ,cassius 0 hang$ = pass+ bad money4 ,n[1 a robe arrang$ on a dummy w\ld look j l ! toga ( ,cassius on ! gall[s4 ,accord+ly1 ,mr4 ,smi? is "r 9 ! drap]y-hang] :i* he has *os53 he has be5 detect$ 9 ! attempt to pass bad circles4 ,he compla9s bitt]ly t 8 geometry1 in/ead ( be+ read & und]/ood by y1 is h&$ ov] to me to be treat$ aft] my scurril\s fa%ion4 ,x is cle> en\gh t he w\ld r be h&l$ 9 ?is way ?an n h&l$ at all1 or :y does he g on writ+8 ,he mu/ "k by ?is "t t x is a "p ( ! in/itution t 8 untru?ful & absurd tra% %all be di/ill$ into m9e at ! rate ( ab\t #c-a_/h pages ( ! fir/ to "o column ( ! second4 ,y\r read]s w nev] "k h[ mu* !y ga9 by ! process1 until ,mr4 ,james ,smi? publi%es x all 9 a big book1 or until !y get hold ( :at he has already publi%$4 ,i h six p\nds avoirdupois ( pamphlets & lett]s2 & !re is m ?an half a p\nd ( lett]s #cdc writt5 to y 9 ! la/ two mon?s4 ,y\r compositor mu/ feel aggriev$ by ! rejection ( ^! cle>ly writt5 docum5ts1 )\t erasures1 & on "o side only4 ,y\r correspond5t has all ! mak+s ( a good contributor1 except ! k ( 8 subject & ! s5se to get x4 ,he is1 9 fact1 only a mask3 ( :om ! fox ,o quanta species1 inquit1 c]ebrum non habet4#fdf ,i d n despair ( ,mr4 ,smi? on any "q :i* does n involve t un=tunate two-/ick wicket at :i* he p]si/s 9 b[l+4 ,he has publi%$ _m pap]s2 he has =w>d$ !m to ma!maticians3 & he _c get answ]s2 p]haps n ev5 read]s4 ,does he ?9k t he w\ld get m notice if y 7 to pr9t him 9 y\r j\rnal8 ,:o w\ld /udy 8 columns8 ,n ! ma!matician1 we "k2 & he kn[s4 ,w\ld o!rs8 ,8 balls are aim$ too wide to be block$ by any "o :o is ne> ! wicket4 ,he has long ceas$ to be wor? ! answ] :i* a new invad] may get4 ,r[an ,hamilton1#fdg ye>s ago1 completely knock$ him ov]2 & he has nev] attempt$ to po9t out any error 9 ! %ort & easy me?od by :i* t p[]ful inve/igator condesc5d$ to %[ t1 be "r :o may1 he mu/ be wrong4 ,!re are "s p]sons :o feel incl9$ to ?9k t ,mr4 ,smi? %\ld be argu$ )3 let ^? p]sons und]/& t he has be5 argu$ )1 refut$1 & has nev] attempt$ to /ick a p5 into ! refutation4 ,he /at$ t x 0 a rem>kable p>adox1 easily explicable2 & t is all4 ,aft] ?is evasion1 ,mr4 ,james ,smi? is bel[ ! necessity ( be+ told t he is unwor?y ( answ]4 ,8 fri5ds compla9 t ,i d no?+ b *aff him4 ,absurd6 ,i w9n[ him2 & if no?+ b *aff results1 ^: fault is t8 ,i am usefully employ$3 = he is ! type ( a class :i* ought to be kn[n1 & :i* ,i h done mu* to make kn[n4 #cdd ,no?+ came ( ?is until ,july #ahfi1 :5 ,i receiv$ a repr9t ( ! above lett]1 ) a comm5t1 describ$ z ,app5dix ,d ( a "w 9 c\rse ( publication on ! geometry ( ! circle4 ,! ,a!naeum j\rnal receiv$ ! same3 b ! ,editor1 9 8 private capacity1 receiv$ ! :ole "w1 be+ ,! ,geometry ( ! ,circle & ,ma!matics z appli$ to ,geometry by ,ma!maticians1 %[n to be a mock]y1 delusion1 & a sn>e1 ,liv]pool1 #hvo1 #ahfi4 ,mr4 ,j4 ,s4 "h appe>s 9 deep fight ) ,pr(essor ,:itwor?1#fdh & ,mr4 ,wilson1#fdi ! au?or ( ! alleg$ am5dm5t ( ,euclid4 ,h[ ^! accompli%$ ma!maticians c\ld be inveigl$ into cont9u$ discussion is inexplicable4 ,mr4 ,:itwor? began by compla9+ ( ,mr4 ,smi?'s attacks ^u ma!maticians1 cont9u$ to correspond aft] he 0 conv9c$ t ,j4 ,s4 prov$ an arc & its *ord to be equal1 & only retreat$ :5 ,j4 ,s4 *>g$ him ) believ+ 9 #c-a_/h1 & refus+ ackn[l$gm5t4 ,mr4 ,wilson 0 introduc$ to ,j4 ,s4 by a volunte] def5se ( 8 geometry f ! assaults ( ! ,a!naeum4 ,?is ! editor w\ld n publi%2 s ,j4 ,s4 s5t a copy to ,mr4 ,wilson himself4 ,"s correspond5ce ensu$1 b ,mr4 ,wilson soon f\nd out 8 man1 & )drew4 ,!re is a little d]ision ( ! ,a!naeum & a m]it$ puni%m5t = t unscrupul\s critic & contemptible ma!matical twaddl]1 ,de ,morgan4 ,,mr4 ,,r$die',s ,,a/ronomy4 ,at p4 #ahc ,i m5tion$ ,mr4 ,r$die1#fej ! au?or ( ,vis ,in]tiae ,victa & ( ,victoria toto coelo1#fea :i* la/ is n #cde an address to ! :ole heav51 ei!r f a ,roman ,goddess or a ,briti% ,que51 :atev] a s*ol> may suppose4 ,betwe5 ^! ,mr4 ,r$die has publi%$ ,! ,me*anics ( ! ,heav5s1 #hvo1 #ahfb3 ?is ,i nev] saw until he s5t x to me1 ) an invitation to notice x1 he v well kn[+ t x w\ld cat*4 ,8 speculations d battle ) common notions ( ma!matics & ( me*anics1 :i*1 to use a fem99e idiom1 he blasphemes s y c't ?9k6 & ,i suspect t if y d n blaspheme !m too1 y c't ?9k4 ,he appeals to ! truly sci5tific1 & w\ld be glad to h read]s :o h read :at he controv]ts1 i4e41 ,newton's ,pr9cipia3 ,i wi% he may get !m2 ,i mean ,i hope he may obta9 !m4 ,to none b ^! w\ld an acc\nt ( 8 speculations be intelligible3 ,i accord+ly dispos$ ( him 9 a v %ort p>agraph ( description4 ,n[ _m p>adox]s desire notice1 ev5 ?\gh x be disp>ag+4 ,i h lett]s f m ?an "o--besides :at h be5 s5t to ! ,editor ( ! ,a!naeum--compla9+ t !y are n laugh$ at2 al?\gh !y des]ve x1 !y tell me1 z mu* z "s :om ,i h ins]t$4 ,mr4 ,r$die in=ms me t ,i h n said a s+le ^w aga9/ 8 books1 ?\gh ,i h giv5 ne>ly a column to sixte5-/r+ ari?metic1 & z mu* to animalcule univ]ses4 ,:at ne$ to say any?+ to read]s ( ,newton aga9/ a book f :i* ,i quot$ t revolution by gravitation is demon/rably impossible8 ,x w\ld be z useless z evid5ce aga9/ a man :o has plead$ guilty4 ,mr4 ,r$die d]isively ?anks me = small m]cies2 he wrote me private lett]s2 he publi%$ !m1 & m1 9 ! ,correspond5t4 ,he gave me1 pro viribus suis1#feb su* a dress+ y c't ?9k1 bo? = my ,budget non-notice1 & = reviews :i* he assum$ me to h writt54 ,he outlaw$ himself by decl>+ 7,correspond5t1 ,nov4 #aa1 #ahef7 t ,i--9 a review--_h made a quotation :i* 0 g>bl$1 evid5tly on purpose #cdf to make x appe> t he 0 advocat+ solely a geoc5tric hypo!sis1 :i* is n true4 ,9 fact1 he did 8 be/ to get l>g] m]cy4 ,& he %all h x2 & at a l5g? :i* %all cont5t him1 unless 8 mecomet] be an insatiable app>atus4 ,b ,i fe> t 9 o!r respects ,i %all no m satisfy him ?an ! ,iri% drumm] satisfi$ ! poor culprit :51 aft] sev]al times *ang+ ! direction ( ! /roke at e>ne/ entreaty1 he 0 at la/ provok$ to call out1 ,bad cess to ye1 ye spalpe56 /rike :]e "o w1 !re's no plas+ ye6 ,mr4 ,r$die atta*es mu* =ce to ,b]keley's#fec old argum5ts aga9/ ! doctr9e ( fluxions1 & advances objections to ,newton's second section1 :i* he takes to be new4 ,to me !y appe> su* z h be5 (t5 made1 to copy a description giv5 9 a review3 ?\gh ,i h no d\bt ,mr4 ,r$die got !m out ( himself4 ,b ! :ole matt] comes to ?is3 ,mr4 ,r$die *all5g$ answ]1 especially f ! ,briti% ,association1 & got none4 ,he presumes t ?is is because he is "r1 & _c be answ]$3 ! ,association is will+ to risk itself ^u ! c\nt]-notion t he is wrong1 & ne$ n be answ]$2 because s wrong t none :o c\ld und]/& an answ] w\ld be likely to want "o4 ,mr4 ,r$die dem&s my att5tion to a po9t :i* _h already p>ticul>ly /ruck me1 z giv+ ! means ( %[+ to all read]s ! k9d ( confusion into :i* p>adox]s are apt to fall1 9 spite ( ! cle>e/ in/ruction4 ,x is a v hone/ blund]1 & requires notice3 x may o!rwise mislead "s1 :o may suppose t no "o able to read c\ld be mi/ak5 ab\t s simple a matt]1 #cdg let him be ev] s wrong ab\t ,newton4 ,accord+ to 8 own mis-/atem5t1 9 less ?an five mon?s he made ! ,a/ronom] ,royal ab&on ! !ory ( ! sol> motion 9 space4 ,! ann\ncem5t is made 9 ,augu/1 #ahfe1 z foll[s3 ! italics are n m9e3 ,! ?ird 7,victoria 44471 al?\gh only publi%$ 9 ,septemb]1 #ahfc1 has already _h its triumph4 ,x is ! book t =c$ ! ,a/ronom] ,royal ( ,engl&1 aft] publicly tea*+ ! contr>y = ye>s1 to come to ! conclusion1 /range z x may appe>1 t ! :ole "q ( sol> motion 9 space is at ! pres5t "t 9 d\bt & abeyance4 ,?is admission is made 9 ! ,annual ,report ( ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society1 publi%$ 9 ! ,society's ,mon?ly ,notices = ,febru>y1 #ahfd4 ,x is add$ t sol> motion is full ( self-contradiction1 :i* ! a/ronom]s simply ov]look$1 b :i* !y d>e n n[ d5y aft] be+ once po9t$ out4 ,! foll[+ is ano!r ( 8 acc\nts ( ! matt]1 giv5 9 ! ,correspond5t1 ,no4 #ah1 #ahfe3 444 ,y ought1 :5 y came to put me 9 ! ',budget1' to h be5 aw>e ( ! ,report ( ! ,c\ncil ( ! ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society1 :]e x appe>s t ,pr(essor ,airy1#fed ) a bett] appreciation ( my demon/rations1 _h admitt$--'/range1' say ! ,c\ncil1 'z x may appe>1'--t '! :ole "q ( sol> motion 9 space & "h ,mr4 ,r$die omits "s words is n[ 9 d\bt & abeyance4' ,y 7 culpable z a public tea*] ( no little pret5sions1 if y 7 'unaw>e' ( ?is4 ,if aw>e ( x1 y ought n to h suppress$ su* an important te/imony to my really hav+ be5 'v successful' 9 draw+ ! tee? ( ! pegtops1 ?\gh y ?\ght !m s firmly fix$4 ,& if y /ill suppress #cdh x1 9 y\r ,app5dix1 or :5 y repr9t y\r ',budget1' y w !n be guilty ( a suppressio v]i1 also ( fur!r injury to me1 :o h nev] injur$ y4444 ,mr4 ,r$die mu/ h be5 v well satisfi$ 9 8 own m9d be=e he v5tur$ su* a *all5ge1 ) an answ] f me loom+ 9 ! di/ance4 ,! foll[+ is ! passage ( ! ,report ( ! ,c\ncil1 etc41 f :i* he quotes3 ,& yet1 /range to say1 not)/&+ ! ne> co9cid5ce ( all ! results ( ! be=e-m5tion$ indep5d5t me?ods ( inve/igation1 ! inevitable logical inf]5ce d$uc$ by ,mr4 ,airy is1 t ! :ole "q ( sol> motion 9 space1 s f> at lea/ z acc\nt+ = ! prop] motion ( ! />s is conc]n$1 ,i h put 9 italics ! words omitt$ by ,mr4 ,r$die appe>s to rema9 at ?is mom5t 9 d\bt & abeyance4 ,mr4 ,r$die has =k$ me1 z he ?9ks1 on a dilemma3 if unaw>e1 culpable ignorance2 if aw>e1 suppressive int5tion4 ,b ! ?+ is a trilemma1 & ! ?ird horn1 on :i* ,i elect to be plac$1 is surm\nt$ by a d\bly-/uff$ seat4 ,fir/1 ,mr4 ,airy has n *ang$ 8 op9ion ab\t ! fact ( sol> motion 9 space1 b only susp5ds x z to ! suffici5cy ( pres5t means to give ! am\nt & direction ( ! motion4 ,secondly1 all t is allud$ to 9 ! ,a/ronomical ,report 0 said & pr9t$ be=e ! ,victoria proclamation appe>$4 ,s t ! au?or1 in/ead ( draw+ ! too? ( ! ,a/ronom] ,royal's pegtop1 has burnt 8 own doll's nose4 ,william ,h]s*el1#fee & aft] him ab\t six o!r a/ronom]s1 _h aim$ at det]m9+1 by ! prop] motions ( ! />s1 ! po9t ( ! heav5s t[>ds :i* ! sol> sy/em is mov+3 _! results 7 tol]ably accordant4 ,mr4 ,airy1 9 #ahei1 propos$ an improv$ me?od1 &1 apply+ x to />s ( l>ge prop] motion1 produc$ #cdi mu* ! same result z ,h]s*el4 ,mr4 ,e4 ,dunk91#fef "o ( ,mr4 ,airy's /aff at ,gre5wi*1 appli$ ,mr4 ,airy's me?od to a v l>ge numb] ( />s1 & produc$1 aga91 ne>ly ! same result z be=e4 ,?is pap] 0 read to ! ,a/ronomical ,society 9 ,m>*1 #ahfc1 0 pr9t$ 9 ab/ract 9 ! ,notice ( t mon?1 0 pr9t$ 9 full 9 ! volume !n curr5t1 & 0 ref]r$ to 9 ! ,annual ,report ( ! ,c\ncil 9 ,febru>y1 #ahfd1 "u ! "n ( ! ,a/ronom] ,royal's elaborate inve/igation1 z exhibit$ by ,mr4 ,dunk94 ,bo? ,mr4 ,airy & ,mr4 ,dunk9 express grave d\bts z to ! suffici5cy ( ! data3 &1 reg>d+ ! co9cid5ce ( all ! results z highly curi\s1 feel x necess>y to wait = calculations made on bett] data4 ,! report ( ! ,c\ncil /ates ^! d\bts4 ,mr4 ,r$die1 :o only publi%$ 9 ,septemb]1 #ahfc1 happ5$ to see ! ,report ( ,febru>y1 #ahfd1 assumes t ! d\bts 7 !n fir/ express$1 & decl>es t 8 book ( ,septemb] _h ! triumph ( =c+ ! ,a/ronom] ,royal to ab&on ! fact ( motion ( ! sol> sy/em by ! ,febru>y foll[+4 ,_h ,mr4 ,r$die1 :5 he saw t ! ,c\ncil 7 av[$ly describ+ a memoir pres5t$ "s "t be=e1 tak5 ! precaution to f9d out :5 t memoir 0 pres5t$1 he w\ld p]haps h se5 t d\bts ( ! results obta9$1 express$ by "o a/ronom] 9 ,m>*1 #ahfc1 & by ano!r 9 #ahei1 c\ld n h be5 due to 8 publication ( ,septemb]1 #ahfc4 ,& any "o else w\ld h le>nt t nei!r a/ronom] d\bts ! sol> motion1 ?\gh bo? d\bt ! suffici5cy ( pres5t means to det]m9e its am\nt & direction4 ,?is is impli$ 9 ! omitt$ words1 :i* ,mr4 ,r$die--^: omission w\ld h be5 di%one/ if he _h se5 _! mean+--no d\bt took = pleonasm1 sup]fluity1 ov]mu*ness4 ,! ra%ness :i* pu%$ him headlong #cej into ! quillet t 8 ?und]bolt _h /opp$ ! *>iot ( ! ,sun & knock$ ! ,gre5wi* ,phaeton (f ! box1 is ! same :i* betray$ him into yet gr&] error--:i* des]ves ! full ^w1 quidlibet--ab\t ! ,pr9cipia ( ,newton4 ,!re has be5 no *ange ( op9ion at all4 ,:5 a p]son und]takes a long inve/igation1 8 op9ion is t1 at a c]ta9 date1 !re is prima facie gr\nd = ?9k+ a s\nd result may be obta9$4 ,%\ld x happ5 t ! inve/igation ends 9 d\bt ^u ! suffici5cy ( ! gr\nds1 ! inve/igator is n put 9 ! wrong4 ,he knew be=eh& t !re 0 an alt]native3 & he takes ! horn ( ! alt]native indicat$ by 8 calculations4 ,! two sides ( ?is case pres5t an in/ructive contra/4 ,eight a/ronom]s produce ne>ly ! same result1 & yet ! la/ two d\bt ! suffici5cy ( _! means3 comp>e !m ) ! :at's-8-"n :o ru%es 9 :]e ?+-em-bobs fe> to tread4 ,i 0 n aw>e1 until ,i _h writt5 :at prec$es1 t ,mr4 ,airy _h giv5 a suffici5t answ] on ! po9t4 ,mr4 ,r$die says 7,correspond5t1 ,jan4 #bj1 #ahff73 ,i claim to h =c$ ,pr(essor ,airy to give up ! notion ( 'sol> motion 9 space' altoge!r1 = he admits x to be 'at pres5t 9 d\bt & abeyance4' ,i fir/ made t claim 9 a lett] address$ to ! ,a/ronom] ,royal himself 9 ,june1 #ahfd1 & 9 reply+1 v c\rte\sly1 to o!r portions ( my lett]1 he did n ga9say t "p ( x4 ,mr4 ,r$die is n ready at read+ satire1 or he nev] w\ld h s miss$ ! mean+ ( ! c\rte\s reply on "o po9t1 & ! total sil5ce ^u ano!r4 ,mr4 ,airy mu/ be "o ( ^? peculi> p]sons :o1 :5 !y d n ?9k an ass]tion wor? notice1 let x alone1 )\t notic+ x by a notification ( non-notice4 ,he w\ld nev] commit ! bull ( ,sir6 ,i w n say a ^w on t subject4 ,he w\ld put x ?us1 ,sir6 ,i w only say t5 words on t subject1--&1 hav+ ?us said !m1 w\ld #cea proce$ to some?+ else4 ,he assum$1 z a matt] ( =m1 t ,mr4 ,r$die w\ld draw ! prop] inf]5ce f 8 sil5ce3 & ?is because he did n c>e :e!r or no ! assumption 0 correct4 ,! ,me*anics ( ! ,heav5s1 :i* ,mr4 ,r$die s5ds to be notic$1 %all be notic$1 s f> z an extract goes3 ,my connection ) ?is subject is1 inde$1 v simply expla9$4 ,9 endeavor+ to und]/& ! laws ( physical a/ronomy z g5]ally taught1 ,i happ5$ to ent]ta9 "s d\bt :e!r gravitat+ bodies c\ld revolve1 & hav+ aft]w>ds imbib$ "s vague idea t ! laws ( ! univ]se 7 *emical & physical r ?an me*anical1 & someh[ connect$ ) electricity & magnetism z oppos+ correlative =ces--mo/ probably sugge/$ to my m9d1 z to _m o!rs1 by ! transc5d5t discov]ies made 9 electro-magnetism by ,pr(essor ,f>aday#feg--my =m] d\bts ab\t gravitation 7 reviv$1 & ,i 0 l$ v naturally to try & discov] :e!r a gravitat+ body really c\ld revolve2 & ,i became conv9c$ x c\ld n1 be=e ,i _h ev] presum$ to look into ! demon/rations ( ! ,pr9cipia4 ,?is is en\gh aga9/ ! book1 )\t a ^w f me3 ,i ins]t x only to %[ ^? :o "k ! subject :at mann] ( writ] ,mr4 ,r$die is4 ,x is cle> t presum$ is a slip ( ! p52 x %\ld h be5 condesc5d$4 ,mr4 ,r$die repres5ts me z dream+ ov] paltry p>adoxes4 ,he is "r2 _m ( my p>adoxes are paltry3 he is wrong2 ,i am wide awake to !m4 ,a s+le mo?1 beetle1 or butt]fly1 may be a paltry ?+2 b :5 a cab9et is arrang$ by g5us & species1 we !n beg9 to admire ! #ceb inf9ite v>iety ( a sy/em con/ruct$ on a wond]ful sam5ess ( lead+ *>act]i/ics4 ,& :y %\ld p>adoxes be d5i$ t collective importance1 paltry z _m ( !m may individually be1 :i* is accord$ to mo?s1 beetles1 or butt]flies8 ,mr4 ,r$die himself sees t !re is a me?od 9 my mode ( deal+ ) p>adoxes4 ,i hope ,i h aton$ = ! scant9ess ( my =m] article1 & put ! demon/rat$ impossibility ( gravitation on t level ) ,hubongramillposanfy ari?metic & inhabit$ atoms :i* ! demon/rator--n q )\t reason--claims = x4 ,9 ! ,introduction to a collect$ edition ( ! ?ree works1 ,mr4 ,r$die describes 8 ,me*anism ( ! ,heav5s1 f :i* ,i h j quot$1 z-- a public *all5ge (f]$ to ! ,briti% ,association & ! ma!maticians at ,cambridge1 9 ,augu/1 #ahfb1 call+ ^u !m to po9t to a s+le demon/ration 9 ! ,pr9cipia or else:]e1 :i* ev5 attempts to prove t ,univ]sal ,gravitation is possible1 or to %[ t a gravitat+ body c\ld possibly revolve ab\t a c5t] ( attraction4 ,! *all5ge 0 n accept$1 & nev] w be4 ,no su* demon/ration exi/s4 ,& ! public mu/ judge = !mselves z to ! "* ( a s-call$ c]ta9 sci5ce1 :i* ?us %r9ks f rigid exam9ation1 & d>es n def5d itself :5 publicly attack$3 also ( ! "* ( its tea*]s1 :o c be cont5t to rema9 dumb "u su* circum/ances4 ,,on ,,p>adox]s ,,9 ,,g5]al4 ,! above is ! commonplace talk ( ! class1 ( :i* ,i proce$ to speak )\t m application to ?is p>adox] ?an to t4 ,x rem9ds "o ( ! funny "y rascals :o us$1 9 times n yet q =gott51 to abuse ! pass5g]s1 z long z !y c\ld keep up ) ! #cec /age coa*2 dropp+ (f at la/ ) ,:y don't y get d[n & ?ra% u8 ,y're afraid1 y're afraid6 ,!y w all[ ! public to judge = !mselves1 b ) some:at ( ! feel+ ( ! wor?y uncle 9 ,tom ,jones1 :o1 ?\gh he w\ld let "y p *oose = !mselves1 w\ld h !m *oose wisely4 ,!y try to be s awfully moral & s gha/ly satirical t !y mu/ be answ]$3 & !y are be/ answ]$ 9 _! own division4 ,we h all he>d ( ! way 9 :i* sailors cat's-paw$ ! monkeys3 !y taunt$ ! dwell]s 9 ! trees ) /ones1 & ! monkeys taunt$ !m ) cocoa-nuts 9 return4 ,b ^! 7 silly d5drobats3 _h !y belong$ to ! ,briti% ,association !y w\ld h said--,no6 ,no6 de> fri5ds2 x is n 9 ! it9]>y3 if y want nuts1 y mu/ climb1 z we d4 ,! public has ref]r$ ! "q to ,"t3 ! proc$ure ( ?is great k+ ,i v5ture to describe1 f prec$5ts1 by an adaptation ( "s sm>t anapae/ic tetramet]s--y\r anapae/ is ! foot = satire to halt on1 bo? 9 ,greek & ,engli%--:i* ,i read ab\t tw5ty ye>s ago1 & ) ! po9t ( :i* ,i 0 mu* tickl$4 ,poeta/]s 7 laugh$ at2 b ,mr4 ,slum1 :om ,i employ$--,mr4 ,*>les ,dick5s oblig$ me ) 8 address--conv]t$ ! idea into t ( a hit at ma!matica/]s1 z easily z he turn$ ! ,w>r5 acro/ic into ,j>ley4 ,z he obs]v$1 :5 ,i settl$ 8 little acc\nt1 x is *eap] ?an any prose1 ?\gh ! broom 0 n /ol5 q ready made3 ,=ty /ripes save "o = ! small] ,p>adox]s4 ,h>k to ! wisdom ! sages prea* ,:o nev] h le>nt :at !y try to tea*4 ,we are ! lights ( ! age1 !y say6 ,we are ! m51 & ! ?9k]s we6 ,s we build up guess-"w ! livelong day1 ,9 a topsy-turvy sort ( way1 ,"s ) & "s want+ a plus b4 ,let ! ,briti% ,association fuss2 ,:at are !irs to ! feats to be wr\ght by u8 #ced ,%all ! e>? /& /ill8 ,w ! r\nd come squ>e8 ,mu/ ,isaac's book be ! ne/ ( a m>e8 ,ought ! moon to be taught by ! laws ( space ,to turn half r\nd )\t "r-ab\t-face8 ,our :imsey crot*ets w manage x all2 ,deep6 ,deep6 po/]ity w !m call6 ,?\gh ! _w1 = ! pres5t1 lets !m fall ,d[n6 ,d[n6 to ! twop5ny box ( ! /all6 ,?us !y--,b ! m>plot ,"t /&s by1 ,) a kn[+ w9k 9 8 funny old eye4 ,he grasps by ! top an imm5se fool's cap1 ,:i* he calls a philosopha/]-trap3 ,& rightly en\gh1 = :ile ^! little m5 ,croak l\d z a conc]t ( frogs 9 a f51 ,he fir/ s+les out "o1 & !n ano!r1 ,d[n goes ! cap--lo6 a mom5t's po!r1 ,a _s l t :i* a ru%light utt]s ,z j at ! la/ x kicks & gutt]s3 ,:5 ! cruel smo!r] is rais$ aga9 ,only snuff1 & b little ( t1 w rema94 ,b ?\gh uno avulso ?us comes e day ,non deficit alt] is also 9 play3 ,= ! vacant p>ts are1 "o & all1 ,soon tak5 by puppets j z small2 ,:o *irp1 *irp1 *irp1 ) a gras%opp]'s glee1 ,we're ! lamps ( ! ,univ]se1 ,we6 ,we6 ,we6 ,b ,"t1 ^: spee* is nev] long1-- ,he hasn't "t = x--/ops ! song ,& says--,lilliput lamps6 leave ! twop5ny boxes1 ,& %9e 9 ! ,budget ( ,p>adoxes6 ,:5 a p>adox] p>ades capital lett]s & diagrams :i* are z good z ,newton's to all :o "k no?+ ab\t x1 "s p]sons wond] :y sci5ce does n rise & triturate ! :ole ?+4 ,?is is :y3 all :o are fit to read ! refutation are satisfi$ already1 & c1 if !y please1 detect ! p>adox] = !mselves4 ,^? :o are n fit to d ?is w\ld n "k ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! true answ] & ! new capitals & diagrams on :i* ! delight$ p>adox] w\ld decl>e #cee t he _h crumbl$ ! philosoph]s1 & n !y him4 ,tru/ him = hav+ ! la/ ^w3 & :at matt]s x :e!r he cr[ ! unansw]able soon] or lat]8 ,!re are b two c\rses to take4 ,"o is to wait until he has committ$ himself 9 some?+ :i* all c und]/&1 z ,mr4 ,r$die has done 9 8 fancy ab\t ! ,a/ronom] ,royal's *ange ( op9ion3 he c !n be put 9 8 true place4 ,! o!r is to con/ruct a ,budget ( ,p>adoxes1 t ! _w may see h[ ! ?+ is always go+ on1 & t ! picture ,i h concoct$ by cribb+ & spoil+ a bit ( poetry is drawn f life4 ,he :o wond]s at !re be+ no answ] has se5 "o or two3 he does n "k t !re are always fifty ) equal claims1 ea* ( :om reg>ds 8 be+ rank$ ) ! re/ z =ty-n9e di/9ct & sev]al sl&]s ^u himself1 ! great ,mully ,ully ,gue4 ,& ! fifty w\ld soon be five hundr$ if any notice 7 tak5 ( !m4 ,!y call mank9d to witness t sci5ce w n def5d itself1 ?\gh publicly attack$ 9 t]ms :i* might /+ a pickpocket into /&+ up = 8 "*3 sci5ce1 9 return1 all[s mank9d to witness or n1 at pleasure1 t x does n def5d itself1 & yet receives no injury f c5turies ( assault4 ,demon/rative reason nev] raises ! cry ( ,*ur* 9 ,dang]6 & x _c h any ,diction>y ( ,h]esies except a ,budget ( ,p>adoxes4 ,mi/ak5 claimants are left to ,"t & 8 ext+ui%]1 ) ! approbation ( all ?9k+ non-claimants3 !re is no ne$ ( a succession ( exposures4 ,"t gets ?r\gh ! job 9 8 own workmanlike mann] z already describ$4 ,on look+ back m ?an tw5ty ye>s1 ,i f9d among my cutt+s ! foll[+ passage1 relat+ to a p]son :o _h signaliz$ himself by an ef=t to tea* comets to ! conductor ( ! ,nautical ,almanac3 ,our bre?r5 ( ! lit]>y class h n ! lea/ idea ( ! small am\nt ( appe>ance ( k #cef :i* sets up ! sci5tific *>latan4 ,_! _w is l>ge1 & !re are _m :o h t mod]ate k1 & p]ception ( :at is k1 be=e :i* extreme ignorance is detect$ 9 its fir/ prank4 ,!re is a public ( mod]ate cultivation1 = ! mo/ "p s\nd 9 its judgm5t1 always ready 9 its decisions4 ,accord+ly1 all _! successful pret5d]s h "s pret5sion4 ,x is n s 9 sci5ce4 ,^? :o h a "r to judge are few] & f>!r betwe54 ,! consequ5ce is1 t _m sci5tific pret5d]s h no?+ b pret5sion4 ,?is is ne>ly z applicable n[ z !n4 ,x is impossible to make ^? :o h n /udi$ = !mselves fully aw>e ( ! tru? ( :at ,i h quot$4 ,! be/ *ance is collection ( cases2 9 fact1 a ,budget ( ,p>adoxes4 ,^? :o h no k ( ! subject c ?us argue f ! se5 to ! unse54 ,all c feel ! impracticability ( ! ,hubongramillposanfy num]ation1 & ! absurdity ( ! equality ( cont\r ( a regul> p5tagon & hexagon 9 "o & ! same circle4 ,_m may accord+ly be satisfi$1 on ! assurance ( ^? :o h /udi$1 t !re is z mu* ( impracticability1 or z mu* ( absurdity1 9 ?+s :i* are hidd5 "u ,s9es1 tang5ts1 secants1 radius1 cos9es ,subtang5ts1 segm5ts & all ^? signs2 ,en\gh to prove t he :o read 'em ,0 j z mad z he :o made 'em4 ,n t ,i mean to be disrespectful to ma!matical t]ms3 !y are %ort & easily expla9$1 & compete favorably ) ^? ( mo/ o!r subjects3 = in/ance1 ) ,horse-pleas1 trav]ses1 demurr]s1 ,je(ails1 imp>lances1 & errors1 ,av]m5ts1 b>s1 & prote/&os1 ,& puis d'arreign cont9u&os4 #ceg ,f :i* x appe>s t1 tak+ ! selections made by satiri/s = our samples1 !re are1 "o ) ano!r1 f\r lett]s m 9 a law t]m ?an 9 "o ( ma!matics4 ,b plead+ has be5 simplifi$ ( late ye>s4 ,all p>adox]s c publi%2 & any "o :o likes may read4 ,b ?is is n en\gh2 !y f9d t !y _c publi%1 or ^? :o c f9d !y are n read1 & !y lay _! plans a?w>t ! noses ( ^? :o1 !y ?9k1 ought to read4 ,to recomm5d !m to be cont5t ) publication1 l o!r au?ors1 is an affront3 ( ?is ,i w give ! read] an amus+ in/ance4 ,my good nature1 ( :i* ,i keep a /ock1 ?\gh ,i d n use x all up 9 ?is ,budget1 prompts me to conceal ! "n4 ,i receiv$ ! foll[+ lett]1 accompani$ by a prospectus ( a "w on metaphysics1 physics1 a/ronomy1 etc4 ,! au?or is evid5tly "o :om ,i %\ld delight to honor3 ,sir1--,a fri5d ( m9e has m5tion$ y\r "n 9 t]ms ( panig]ic sic1 z be+ ( high /&+ 9 ma!matics1 & ( greatly orig9al ?\ght4 ,i s5d y ! enclos$ )\t comm5t2 &1 assum+ t ! b5t ( y\r m9d is 9 free inquiry1 %all feel a pleasure 9 %[+ y my portfolio1 :i*1 z a ma!matician1 y w ackn[l$ge to be deeply int]e/+1 ev5 9 an educational po9t ( view4 ,! "w is complete1 & ! sy/em s f> p]fect$ z to place x above criticism2 &1 s f> z reg>ds a/ronomy1 z w ,ptolemy beyond rivalry sic3 no d\bt "s words omitt$4 ,believe me to be1 ,sir1 ) ! pr(\nde/ respect1 etc4 ,! "w is ! result ( ?irty-five ye>s' travel & obs]vation1 labor1 exp5se1 & self-abnegation4 ,i repli$ to ! effect t my "t 0 fully occupi$1 & t ,i 0 oblig$ to decl9e discussion ) _m p]sons :o h views ( _! own2 t ! prop] way is to publi%1 s t ^? :o *oose may read :5 !y c f9d leisure4 ,i add$ t ,i %\ld advise a precursor 9 ! %ape ( a small pamphlet1 z two octavo volumes #ceh w\ld be too mu* = mo/ p]sons4 ,?is 0 s\nd advice2 b x is n ! fir/1 second1 or ?ird "t t x has prov$ v unpalatable4 ,i receiv$ ! foll[+ answ]1 to :i* ,i take ! lib]ty ( prefix+ a bit ( leon9e wisdom3 ,si doceas /ultum1 laetum non dat tibi vultum2 ,odit te multum2 vellet te scire sepultum4#feh ,sir1--,i pray y p>don ! error ,i un9t5tionally h fall5 into2 deceiv$ by ! ,f4,r4,s4 ,i am n ,f4,r4,s4 ,i took y to be a man ( sci5ce omnis homo e/ animal1 ,sortes e/ homo1 ergo ,sortes e/ animal#fei in/ead ( ! m]e ma!matician1 or human calculat+-ma*9e4 ,believe me1 ,sir1 y also h mi/ak5 y\r mission1 z ,i h m9e4 ,i wrote to y z ,i w\ld to any o!r man well up 9 ma!matics1 ) ! int5t to call y\r att5tion to a s+ul> fact ( omission by ,euclid1 & o!r great ma!maticians3 &1 9 select+ y1 ,i did y an honor :i*1 f :at ,i h j n[ he>d1 0 entirely out ( place4 ,i ?9k1 consid]+ ! nature ( ! "w set =? 9 ! prospectus1 y are guilty ( bo? folly & presumption1 9 assum+ ! "* ( a patron2 = y\r own s5se ought to h assur$ y t 0 su* my object ,i %\ld n h s\ght him 9 a ,de ,morgan1 :o exi/s only by patronage ( o!rs4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ,i deem x to be an unp>donable piece ( presumption 9 (f]+ y\r advice ^u a subject ! magnitude1 importance1 & real utility ( :i* y "k no?+ ab\t3 by do+ s y h (f]$ me a direct insult4 ,! sy/em is a manual ( ,philosophy1 a "o insep>able :ole ( metaphysics & physic2 embrac+ po9ts ! mo/ int]e/+1 laws ! mo/ important1 #cei doctr9es ! mo/ ess5tial to advance man 9 accordance ) ! _s ( ! times4 ,i may n live to see x 9 pr9t2 =1 at ----1 life at be/ is unc]ta93 b1 live or die1 be assur$ ,sir1 x is n my int5tion to debase ! "w by seek+ patronage1 or p&]+ to ! public ta/e4 ,y\r advice 0 ! less ne$$1 see+ ,i am an old-e/abli%$ ----4 ,i rema91 etc4--,p4,s4 ,y w oblige me by return+ ! prospectus ( my "w4 ,my read] w1 ,i am sure1 n take ?is transition f ! pr(\nde/ respect to ! l(tie/ insol5ce = an apocraphical correspond5ce1 to use a ^w ,i f9d 9 ! ,prospectus3 on my honor x is g5u9e4 ,he w be bett] employ$ 9 discov]+ :e!r ,i exi/ by patroniz+ o!rs1 or by be+ patroniz$ by !m4 ,i make any "o :o c f9d x out a fair (f]3 ,i w give him my patronage if ,i turn out to be ,bufo1 on condition he gives me 81 if ,i turn out to be ,bavius4#ffj ,i ne$ h>dly say t ,i consid]$ ! la/ lett] to be "o ( ^? to :i* no answ] is s good z no answ]4 ,^! lett]s rem9d me 9 "o respect ( ! correspond5ts ( ! newspap]s4 ,my o!r p>ty wrote because a fri5d _h po9t$ me out3 b he w\ld n h writt5 if he _h kn[n :at ano!r fri5d told him j 9 "t = ! second lett]4 ,! man :o s5ds 8 compla9t to ! newspap] v (t5 says1 9 effect1 ,don't imag9e1 ,sir1 t ,i read y\r columns2 b a fri5d :o sometimes does has told me 444 ,x is word$ ?us3 ,my att5tion #cfj has be5 direct$ to an article 9 y\r pap] ( 444 ,_m ?anks to my fri5d's fri5ds = n m5tion+ ! ,budget3 _h my fri5d's att5tion be5 direct$ to x ,i might h lo/ a /rik+ example ( ! p>adox] 9 se>* ( a patron4 ,t my ,fri5d 0 on ?is sc5t 9 ! fir/ lett] is reveal$ 9 ! second4 ,language 0 giv5 to man to conceal 8 ?\ghts2 b x is n e "o :o c d x4 ,among ! mo/ valuable in=mation :i* my read]s w get f me is comp>ison ( ! reactions ( p>adox]s1 :5 n admitt$ to argum5t1 or :5 laugh$ at4 ,( c\rse1 !y are misrepres5t$2 & at ?is !y are angry1 or :i* is ! same ?+1 take great pa9s to assure ! read] t !y are n4 ,s f> natural1 & s f> good2 any?+ %ort ( concession ( a case :i* mu/ be s]i\sly met by c\nt]-reasons is sure to be misrepres5tation4 ,my fri5d ,mr4 ,james ,smi? & my fri5d ,mr4 ,r$die are bo? t]ribly misrepres5t$3 !y res5t x by "s ins9uations 9 :i* x is n easy to detect :e!r ,i am a consci\s smo!r] ( tru?1 or only muddle-head$ & ignorant4 ,?is 0 writt5 be=e ,i receiv$ my la/ communication f ,mr4 ,james ,smi?4 ,he tells me t ,i am wrong 9 say+ t 8 "w 9 :i* ,i /& 9 ! pillory is all repr9t3 ,i h no d\bt ,i conf\nd$ "s ( x ) "s ( ! manuscript or slips :i* ,i _h receiv$ f my mu* n-agre$-) correspond5t4 ,he adds t my mi/ake 0 int5tional1 & t my reason is obvi\s to ! read]4 ,?is is in=mation1 z ! sea-s]p5t said :5 he read 9 ! newspap] t he _h a mane & tusks4 ,,! ,,d\ble ,,vahu ,,process4 ,my fri5d ,dr4 ,?orn#ffa sees deep] into my my/]y4 ,by ! way1 he /ill s5ds an occasional t\* at ! old #cfa subject2 & he wants me p>ticul>ly to tell my read]s t ! ,lat9 num]al lett]s1 if ,m be left out1 give #fff4 ,& s !y d3 witness ,,dclxvi4 ,a p]son :o ?9ks ( ! orig9 ( symbols w soon see t #fff is our numb] because we h five f+]s on ea* h&3 _h we _h b f\r1 our my/ic numb] w\ld h be5 express$ by #eee1 & w\ld h /ood = our pres5t #cfe4 ,_h n be5 ! numb] on ea* h&1 ! great numb] w\ld h be5 7n #a7 7#dn#b #bn #a7 ,) no f+] on ea* h&1 ! numb] w\ld h be5 #a3 ) "o f+] less ?an none at all on ea* h&1 x w\ld h be5 #j4 ,b :at does ?is mean8 ,"h is a "q = an algebraical p>adox]6 ,s soon z we h f\nd out h[ _m f+]s ! inhabitants ( any "o planet h on ea* h&1 we h ! means ( kn[+ _! numb] ( ! ,bea/1 & !nce all ab\t !m4 ,v mu* /ruck ) ?is h9t ( discov]y1 ,i turn$ my att5tion to ! means ( develop+ x4 ,! fir/ po9t 0 to cle> my vision ( all ! old cat>acts4 ,i propose ! foll[+ exp]im5t1 subject ( c\rse to ! cons5t ( p>ties4 ,let ,dr4 ,?orn ,d\ble-,vahu ,mr4 ,james ,smi?1 & ,?au ,mr4 ,r$die3 if ei!r be dep>adox$ by ! treatm5t1 ,i w cons5t to und]go x myself4 ,provid$ always t ! temp]ature requir$ be n s high z ! ,doctor h9ts at3 if ! ,turki% ,ba?s w d = ?is _w1 ,i am cont5t4 ,! ?ree p>adox]s la/ nam$ & myself h a p5tasyllable conv5tion1 "u :i*1 ?\gh we g f> beyond civility1 we keep )9 civilization4 ,?\gh ,mr4 ,james ,smi? pron\nc$ t ,i mu/ be di%one/ if ,i did n see 8 argum5t1 :i* he knew ,i %\ld n d to say no?+ ( rec5t accusation2 ?\gh ,dr4 ,?orn decl>$ me a competitor = fire & brim/one--& my wife1 too1 :i* d\bles ! joke3 ?\gh ,mr4 ,r$die #cfb 0 c]ta9 ,i _h g>bl$ him1 evid5tly on purpose to make falsehood appe> tru?2 yet all ?ree pr(ess respect = me z to ev]y?+ b p[] to see tru?1 or c&or to admit x4 ,& on ! o!r h&1 ?\gh ^! 7 ! modes ( op5+ communication ) me1 & ?\gh ,i h no d\bt t all ?ree are prop] p]sons ( :om to inquire :e!r ,i %\ld g up-/airs or d[n-/airs1 etc41 yet ,i am satisfi$ !y are ?or\ghly respectable m51 z to ev]y?+ b reason+4 ,& ,i d>e say our sev]al pr(essions are f> m true 9 ext5t ?an 9 _m :i* are made "u m p>liam5t>y =m4 ,we f9d excuses = ea* o!r3 !y make all[ances = my be+ hoodw9k$ by ,ari/otle1 by ,newton1 by ! ,devil2 & ,i p]mit !m to feel1 = ,i "k !y _c get on )\t x1 t _! reasons are su* z none b a knave or a s9n] c resi/4 ,b !y are cont5t ) cutt+ a slice ea* out ( my "*3 nei!r ( !m is m ?an an uncle1 a ,bone-a-"p2 ,i n[ come to a dreadful nephew1 ,bone-!-:ole4 ,i w n give ! "n ( ! poor fell[ :o has fall5 s f> bel[ bo? ! hone/um & ! utile1 to say no?+ ( ! decorum or ! dulce4#ffb ,he is ! f\r? :o has tak5 elaborate notice ( me2 & my advice to him w\ld be1 ,nec qu>ta loqui p]sona laboret4#ffc ,accord+ to him1 ,i scorn humanity1 sc&alize le>n+1 & disgrace ! press2 x admits ( no mann] ( d\bt t my object is to mislead ! public & sil5ce tru?1 at ! exp5se ( ! int]e/s ( sci5ce1 ! weal? ( ! nation1 & ! lives ( my fell[ m54 ,! only ?+ left to be settl$ is1 :e!r ?is is due to ignorance1 natural di/a/e = tru?1 p]sonal malice1 a wi% to curry favor ) ! ,a/ronom] ,royal1 or m]e toadyism4 ,! only accusation :i* has tru? 9 x is1 t ,i h made myself a public scav5g] ( sci5ce3 ! ass]tion1 :i* is ! #cfc mo/ false ( all is1 t ! results ( my broom & spade are %ot "r 9 betwe5 ! columns ( ! ,a!naeum4 ,i decl>e ,i nev] 9 my life ins]t$ a ^w betwe5 ! columns ( ! ,a!naeum3 ,i feel huff$ & miff$ at ! v supposition4 ,i h made myself a public scav5g]2 & :y n8 ,is ! mud nev] to be collect$ into a heap8 ,i look d[n ^u ! o!r scav5g]s1 ( :om !re h be5 a few--m]e hi/orical drudges2 ,montucla1 ,hutton1 etc4--z n fit to compete ) me4 ,i say ( !m :at "o cross+-sweep] said ( ! re/3 ,!y are well en\gh = ! common ?+2 b put !m to a bit ( fancy-"w1 su* z sweep+ r\nd a po/1 & see :at a mess !y make ( x6 ,:o c t\* me at sweep+ r\nd a p>adox]8 ,if ,i complete my design ( publi%+ a sep>ate "w1 an old copy w be fi%$ up f a /all two hundr$ ye>s h5ce by ! com+ man1 & w be describ$ 9 an article :i* w end by 8 comp>+ our c5tury ) 8 own1 & sigh+ out 9 ! be/ ,new ,zeal& pronunciation-- ,dans ces tems-la ,c'etait deja comme ca6#ffd ,,or?odox ,,p>adox]s4 ,& pray1 ,sir6 ,i h be5 ask$ by m ?an "o--d y\r or?odox nev] fall into mi/ake1 nor rise into absurdity8 ,!y n only d bo?1 b !y admit x ( ea* o!r v freely2 individually1 !y are conv9c$ ( s91 b n ( any p>ticul> s94 ,!re is n a syndox] among !m all b draws 8 l9e 9 su* a way z to include among p>adox]s a great _m :om ,i %\ld exclude altoge!r f ?is "w4 ,my wor/ specim5s are b exagg]ations ( :at may be f\nd1 occasionally1 9 ! ?\ghts ( sagaci\s inve/igators4 ,at ! end ( ! #cfd glori\s dream1 we le>n t !re is a way to ,hell f ! gates ( ,heav51 z well z f ! ,city ( ,de/ruction3 & t ?is is true ( o!r ?+s besides ,*ri/ian pilgrimage is affirm$ at ! end ( ! ,budget ( ,p>adoxes4 ,if ,d',alemb]t#ffe _h produc$ en\gh ( a quality to mat* 8 celebrat$ mi/ake on ! *ance ( ?r[+ head 9 two ?r[s1 he w\ld h be5 9 my li/4 ,if ,newton _h produc$ en\gh to mat* 8 reception ( ! /ory t ,nausicaa1 ,hom]'s ,phaeacian pr9cess1 inv5t$ ! cele/ial sph]e1 foll[$ by 8 s]i\s surmise t %e got x f ! ,argonauts1--!n ,newton himself w\ld h _h an appe>ance ent]$ = him1 9 spite ( ! ,pr9cipia4 ,9 illu/ration1 ,i may cite a few words f ,tri/ram ,%&y3 ',a soldi]1' cri$ my uncle ,toby1 int]rupt+ ! ,corporal1 'is no m exempt f say+ a fooli% ?+1 ,trim1 ?an a man ( lett]s4'--',b n s (t51 an' please y\r honor1' repli$ ! ,corporal4 ,my uncle ,toby gave a nod4 ,i n[ proce$ to die out4 ,"s prefatory rem>ks w foll[ 9 "t4#fff ,i %all h occasion to insi/ t all is n b>r53 ,i ?9k ,i %all f9d1 on ca/+ up1 t two out ( five ( my p>adox]s are n to be utt]ly condemn$4 ,among ! bett] lot w be f\nd all gradations ( m]it2 at ! same "t1 z 0 rem>k$ on q a diff]5t subject1 !re may be little to *oose betwe5 ! la/ ( ! sav$ & ! fir/ ( ! lo/4 ,! high] & bett] class is wor?y ( blame2 ! l[] & worse class is wor?y ( praise4 ,! high] m5 are to be reprov$ = n tak+ up ?+s 9 :i* !y c\ld d "s good3 ! l[] m5 are to be comm5d$ = tak+ up ?+s 9 :i* !y c d no great h>m4 ,! circle problem is l ,pet] ,peebles's lawsuit3 #cfe ',b1 ,sir1 ,i %\ld really spoil any cause ?ru/ on me s ha/ily4'--',ye _c spoil x1 ,alan1' said my fa!r1 't is ! v cream ( ! bus9ess1 man1--444 ! case is come to t pass t ,/air or ,arni/on c\ld n m5d x1 & ,i don't ?9k ev5 y1 ,alan1 c d x mu* h>m4' ,i am /rongly rem9d$ ( ! monks 9 ! d>k] "p ( ! ,middle ,ages4 ,to a c]ta9 proportion ( !m1 p]haps two out ( five1 we are indebt$ = ! pres]vation ( lit]ature1 & _! contempor>ies = good tea*+ & mitigation ( socials evils4 ,b ! rema9+ ?ree 7 ! fleas & flies & ?i/les & bri>s ) :om ! satiri/ lumps !m1 ab\t a c5tury be=e ! ,re=mation3 ,fl51 flyys1 & fr]is1 populum dom9i male ca$unt2 ,?y/lis & br]is cresc5tia gram9a la$unt4 ,*ri/e nol5s gu]ras qui cuncta pace tu]is1 ,de/rue p] t]ras br]is1 fl51 flyys1 & fr]is4 ,fl51 flyys1 & fr]is1 f\l falle hem ?ys fyft5 y]is1 ,= non t h] is lovit fl51 flyys ne fr]is4#ffg ,i %\ld n be q s savage ) my second class4 ,tak5 toge!r1 !y may be made to give useful w>n+ to ^? :o are engag$ 9 le>n+ "u bett] auspices3 aye1 ev5 useful h9ts2 = bad ?+s are v (t5 only good ?+s spoil$ or misus$4 ,my plan is t ( a pr$ecessor 9 ! "t ( ,edw>d ! ,second3 ,meum e/ propositum g5ti imp]itae ,artes frugi r$d]e melioris vitae4#ffh ,to ?is end ,i h spok5 ) fre$om ( books z books1 ( op9ions z op9ions1 ( ignorance z ignorance1 ( #cff presumption z presumption2 & ( writ]s z ,i judge may be fairly inf]r$ f :at !y h writt54 ,"s--to :om ,i am !re=e "u great obligation--h p]mitt$ me to enl>ge my plan by assaults to :i* ,i h allud$2 assaults :i* all[ a privilege ( retort1 ( :i* ,i h (t5 avail$ myself2 assaults :i* give my read]s a "r ( p>tn]%ip 9 ! amusem5t :i* ,i myself h receiv$4 ,= ! pres5t ,i cut & run3 a ,catil9e1 pursu$ by a *orus ( ,cic]os1 ) ,qu\sque t&em8 ,quamdiu nos8 ,nihil ne te8#ffi end+ )1 ,9 te conf]ri pe/em i/am jam pridem oportebat1 quam tu 9 nos omnes jamdiu ma*9>is6 ,i c>ry ) me ! reflection t ,i h furni%$ to ^? :o ne$ x su* a magaz9e ( w>n+s z !y w n f9d else:]e2 a signatis cavetote3#fgj & ,i ?r[ back at my pursu]s--,valete1 doctores s9e doctr9a2 facite ut proxima congressu vos salvos corporibus et sanos m5tibus videamus4#fga ,"h ends ! ,budget ( ,p>adoxes4 #cfg 99 99 99 99 99 ,,app5dix4 ,i ?9k x "r to give ! pro( t ! ratio ( ! circumf]5ce to ! diamet] is incomm5surable4 ,?is me?od ( pro( 0 giv5 by ,lamb]t1#fgb 9 ! ,b]l9 ,memoirs = #agfa1 & has be5 also giv5 9 ! notes to ,leg5dre's#fgc ,geometry1 & to ! ,engli% translation ( ! same4 ,?\gh n elem5t>y algebra1 x is )9 ! rea* ( a /ud5t ( ord9>y books4#fgd ,let a cont9u$ fraction1 su* z a ----- b c ----- d e - f etc41 be abbreviat$ into a_/b c_/d e_/f etc43 ea* fraction be+ und]/ood z fall+ d[n to ! side ( ! prec$+ sign 4 ,9 e su* fraction we may suppose b1 d1 f1 etc4 #cfh positive2 a1 c1 e1 c4 be+ z requir$3 & all are suppos$ integ]s4 ,if ?is succession be cont9u$ ad inf9itum1 & if a_/b1 c_/d1 e_/f1 etc4 all lie betwe5 -#a & #a1 exclusive1 ! limit ( ! fraction mu/ be incomm5surable ) unity2 t is1 _c be ,a_/,b1 :]e ,a & ,b are integ]s4 ,fir/1 :atev] ?is limit may be1 x lies betwe5 -#a & #a4 ,?is is obvi\sly ! case ) any fraction p_/7q omega71 :]e omega is betwe5 -#a3 =1 p_/q1 be+ #a1 & p & q integ]1 _c be br\ght up to #a1 by ! value ( omega4 ,h5ce1 if we take any ( ! fractions a_/b1 a_/b c_/d1 a_/b c_/d e_/f1 etc4 say a_/b c_/d e_/f g_/h we h1 g_/h be+ betwe5 -#a1 s is e_/f g_/h1 s !re=e is c_/d e_/f g_/h2 & s !re=e is a_/b c_/d e_/f g_/h4 ,n[1 if possible1 let a_/b c_/d etc4 be ,a_/,b at ! limit2 ,a & ,b be+ integ]s4 ,let ,p ,a c_/d e_/f etc41 ,q ,p e_/f g_/h etc41 ,r ,q g_/h i_/k etc4 ,p1 ,q1 ,r1 etc4 be+ integ] or fractional1 z may be4 ,x is easily %[n t all mu/ be integ]3 = #cfi ,a_/,b a_/b ,p_/,a1 or1 ,p a,b - b,a ,p_/,a c_/d ,q_/,p1 or1 ,q c,a - d,p ,q_/,p e_/f ,r_/,q1 or1 ,r e,p - f,q etc41 etc4 ,n[1 s9ce a1 ,b1 b1 ,a1 are integ]s1 s also is ,p2 & !nce ,q2 & !nce ,r1 etc4 ,b s9ce ,a_/,b1 ,p_/,a1 ,q_/,p1 ,r_/,q1 etc4 are all betwe5 -#a & #a1 x foll[s t ! unlimit$ succession ( integ]s ,p1 ,q1 ,r1 are ea* less 9 num]ical value ?an ! prec$+4 ,n[ !re c be no su* unlimit$ succession ( desc5d+ integ]s3 consequ5tly1 x is impossible t a_/b c_/d1 etc4 c h a comm5surable limit4 ,x easily foll[s t ! cont9u$ fraction is incomm5surable if a_/b1 c_/d1 etc41 be+ at fir/ great] ?an unity1 become & cont9ue less ?an unity aft] "s "o po9t4 ,say t i_/k1 l_/m1444 are all less ?an unity4 ,!n ! fraction i_/k l_/m 444 is incomm5surable1 z prov$3 let x be kappa4 ,!n g_/7h kappa7 is incomm5surable1 say lambda2 e_/7f lambda7 is ! same1 say mu2 also c_/7d mu71 say nu1 & a_/7b nu71 say rho4 ,b rho is ! fraction a_/b c_/d 444 itself2 :i* is !re=e incomm5surable4 ,let phiz repres5t a a#b a#c #a - ------- -------------- 4444 z #bz7z#a7 #b4c4z7z#a77z#b7 #cgj ,let z be positive3 ?is s]ies is conv]g5t = all values ( a1 & approa*es )\t limit to unity z z increases )\t limit4 ,*ange z into z #a1 & =m phiz - phi7z#a73 ! foll[+ equation w result-- a phiz-phi7z#a7 ------7phi7z#b77 z7z#a7 a phi7z#a7 a phi7z#a7 a phi7z#b7 or a - ---------- 4 z - ---------- 4 --- ---------- z phiz z phiz z#a phi7z#a7 a psiz7zpsi7z#a77 psiz be+ 7a_/z77phi7z#a7_/phiz72 ( :i* obs]ve t x dim9i%es )\t limit z z increases )\t limit4 ,accord+ly1 we h psiz a_/z psi7z#a7 a_/z a_/7z#a7 psi7z#b7 a_/z a_/7z#a7 a_/7z#b7 psi7z#c71 etc4 ,&1 psi7z n7 dim9i%+ )\t limit1 we h a_/z 4 phi7z#a7_/phiz 7a_/z7 7a_/7z#a77 7a_/7z#b77 7a_/77z#c7 44477 ,let z #a_/b2 & let #d;a -x#b4 ,!n 7a_/z7phi7z#a7 is -7x#b_/b7 7 #a - x#b_/7b4c7 x#d_/7b4c4d4e44477 or -7x_/#b7 s9 x4 ,aga9 phiz is #a - x#b_/b x#d_/7b4c4d7 or cos x3 & ! cont9u$ fraction is 7#a_/d7x#b_/7a_/b7 7#a_/d7x#b_/7c_/b7 7#a_/d7x#b_/7e_/b7 444 or -x_/#b x_/#a -x#b_/c -x#b_/e 444 #cga :5ce tan x x_/#a -x#b_/c -x#b_/e -x#b_/g 444 ,or1 z writt5 9 ! usual way1 tan x x ------- #a - x#b ------- #c - x#b ------- #e - x#b ------- #g - 444 ,?is result may be prov$ 9 v>i\s ways3 x may also be v]ifi$ by calculation4 ,to d ?is1 rememb] t if a#a_/;b#a a#b_/;b#b a#c_/;b#c 444 an_/bn ,pn_/,qn2 !n ,p#a;a#a1 ,p#b;b#b ,p#a1 ,p#c;b#c ,p#b;a#c ,p#a1 ,p#d;b#d ,p#c;a#d ,p#b1 etc4 ,q#a;b#a1 ,q#b;b#b ,q#a;a#b1 ,q#c;b#c ,q#b;a#c ,q#a1 ,q#d;b#d ,q#c;a#d ,q#b1 etc4 9 ! case be=e u we h a#ax1 a#b-x#b1 a#c-x#b1 a#d-x#b1 a#e-x#b1 etc4 b#aa1 b#bc1 b#ce1 b#dg1 b#ei1 etc4 ,p#ax ,q#aa ,p#bcx ,q#bc-x#b ,p#caex-x#c ,q#cae-fx#b ,p#dajex-#ajx#c ,q#daje-dex#bx#d ,p#eidex-#ajex#cx#e ,q#eide-dbjx#baex#d ,p#fajciex-#abfjx#cbax#e ,q#fajcie-dgbex#bbajx#d-x#f ,we c use ?is algebraically1 or ari?metically4 ,if we divide ,pn by ,qn1 we %all f9d a s]ies agree+ ) ! kn[n s]ies = tan x1 z f> z n t]ms4 ,t s]ies is x x#c_/c #bx#e_/ae #agx#g_/cae #fbx#i_/bhce 444 #cgb ,take ,p#e1 & divide x by ,q#e 9 ! common way1 & ! fir/ five t]ms w be z "h writt54 ,n[ take x 4#a1 :i* means t ! angle is to be "o t5? ( ! actual unit1 or1 9 degrees #e deg44#gbiegh4 ,we f9d t :5 x 4#a1 ,p#f #ajch4bdjba1 ,q#f #ajcdg4ggjiii2 :5ce ,p#f divid$ by ,q#f gives 4#ajjccdfgaa4 ,n[ #e deg44#gbiegh is #e deg4#dc'df-a_/b2 & f ! old tables ( ,rheticus#fge--no mod]n tables c>ry ! tang5ts s f>--! tang5t ( ?is angle is 4#ajjccdgfgj4 ,n[ let x 7#a_/d7pi2 9 :i* case tan x #a4 ,if 7#a_/d7pi be comm5surable ) ! unit1 let x be 7m_/n71 m & n be+ integ]s3 we "k t 7#a_/d7pi #a4 ,we h !n #a7m_/n7_/#a- 7m#b_/n#b7_/c- 7m#b_/n#b7_/e- 444 m_/n- m#b_/cn- m#b_/en- m#b_/gn- 444 ,n[ x is cle> t m#b_/cn1 m#b_/en1 m#b_/gn1 etc4 mu/ at la/ become & cont9ue sev]ally less ?an unity4 ,! cont9u$ fraction is !re=e incomm5surable1 & _c be unity4 ,consequ5tly pi#b _c be comm5surable3 t is1 pi is an incomm5surable quantity1 & s also is pi#b4 ,i ?\ght ,i %\ld end ) a grave bit ( app5dix1 deeply ma!matical3 b p>adox foll[s me :]ev] ,i g4 ,! =ego+ is--9 my own language--f ,dr4 7n[ ,sir ,david7 ,brew/]'s#fgf ,engli% edition ( ,leg5dre's ,geometry1 7,ed9burgh1 #ahbd1 #hvo47 translat$ by "s "o :o is n nam$4 ,i pick$ up a notion1 :i* o!rs _h at ,cambridge 9 #ahbe1 t ! translator 0 ! late ,mr4 ,galbrai?1#fgg !n kn[n at ,ed9burgh z a writ] & tea*]4 #cgc ,b x turns out t x 0 by a v diff]5t p]son1 & "o de/9$ to %9e 9 q ano!r walk2 x 0 a "y man nam$ ,?omas ,c>lyle4#fgh ,he prefix$1 f 8 own p51 a ?\ghtful & +5i\s essay on ,proportion1 z good a sub/itute = ! fif? ,book ( ,euclid z c\ld h be5 giv5 9 ! space2 & q en\gh to %[ t he w\ld h be5 a di/+ui%$ tea*] & ?9k] on fir/ pr9ciples4 ,b he left ! field imm$iately4 99 99 99 99 99 7,! foll[+ is ! passage ref]r$ to at ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ed47 ,mi*ael ,/ifelius#fgi edit$1 9 #aeed1 a second edition ( ! ,algebra 7,die ,coss471 ( ,*ri/oph] ,rudolff4#fhj ,?is is "o ( ! e>lie/ works 9 :i* & - are us$4 ,/ifelius 0 a que] man4 ,he has introduc$ into ?is v "w ( ,rudolff 8 own int]pretation ( ! numb] ( ! ,bea/4 ,he det]m9$ to fix ! "* ( ,pope ,leo3 s he pick$ ! num]al lett]s f ,,leodecimvs1 & by tak+ 9 ,x f ,,leo ,x4 & /rik+ out ,m z /&+ = my/]ium1 he hit ! numb] exactly4 ,?is discov]y complet$ 8 conv]sion to ,lu!r1 & 8 det]m9ation to ?r[ (f 8 mona/ic v[s4 ,lu!r dealt ) him z /raight-=w>dly z ) ,melan*?on ab\t 8 a/rology3 he accept$ ! conclusions1 b told him to cle> 8 m9d ( all ! premises ab\t ! ,bea/4 ,/ifelius #cgd did n take ! advice1 & proce$$ to settle ! end ( ! _w out ( ! prophet ,daniel3 he fix$ on ,octob]1 #aecc4 ,! p>i%ion]s ( "s cure :i* he held1 hav+ full fai?1 began to sp5d _! sav+s 9 all k9ds ( good eat+ & dr9k+2 we may *>itably hope ?is 0 n ! way ( prep>+ = ! ev5t :i* _! pa/or po9t$ out4 ,!y succe$$ 9 mak+ !mselves z fit = ,heav5 z ,laz>us1 s f> z begg>y w5t3 b :5 ! "t came1 & ! _w la/$ on1 !y want$ to kill _! deceiv]1 & w\ld h done s b = ! int]f]5ce ( ,lu!r4 #cge 99 99 99 99 99 ,,index4 ,pages d5ot$ by num]als ( ?is k9d 7#bhg7 ref] to biographical notes1 *iefly by ! editor4 ,num]als l #dbf ref] to books discuss$ by ,de ,morgan1 or to lead+ topics 9 ! text4 ,num]als l #abf indicate m9or ref]5ces4 ,abbott1 ,ju/ice1 ,i1 #aha4 ,ab]ne?y1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bai4 ,aborig9al ,britons1 a poem1 ,,ii1 #bgj4 ,academy ( ,sci5ces1 ,fr5*1 ,i1 #afc4 ,adair1 ,j41 ,i1 #bbc4 ,adam1 ,m41 ,i1 #fe4 ,adams1 ,j4 ,c41 ,i1 #dc1 #hb1 #che1 #chh2 ,,ii1 #aca1 #ace1 #adj1 #cjc4 ,ady1 ,joseph1 ,,ii1 #db1 #db4 ,agnew1 ,h4 ,c41 ,i1 #cbh4 ,agricola1 ,j41 ,i1 #cid4 ,agricultural ,labor]'s lett]1 ,,ii1 #af4 ,agrippa1 ,h4 ,c41 ,i1 #dh1 #dh4 ,a9swor?1 ,w4 ,h41 ,,ii1 #acb4 ,airy1 ,i1 #he1 #hh1 #aeb1 #bdb2 ,,ii1 #he1 #adj1 #aej1 #cjc1 #cdg4 ,al*emy1 ,i1 #abe4 ,alfonso ,x 7,el ,sabio71 ,,ii1 #bfi4 ,al=d1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #bba4 ,alfr$1 ,k+1 ,ballad (1 ,,ii1 #bb4 ,algebra1 ,i1 #aba4 ,algebraic symbols1 ,i1 #aba4 ,almanac1 ,i1 #cjj2 ,,ii1 #adg1 #adh1 #bjg4 7,see ,ea/]47 ,aloysius ,lilius1 ,i1 #cfb4 ,al/$1 ,j4 ,h41 ,,ii1 #bhb4 ,ame5 ,bey1 ,,ii1 #ae4 ,amicable ,society1 ,i1 #cdg4 ,amp]e1 ,i1 #hf4 ,amphisba5a s]p5t1 ,i1 #ca4 ,anagrams1 ,de ,morgan1 ,i1 #ach4 ,anaxagoras1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,angh]a1 ,,ii1 #fj1 #fj1 #fa1 #bgi4 ,annuities1 ,fallacies (1 ,i1 #aeg4 ,anti*ri/1 ,i1 #acj4 ,antimony1 ,i1 #abe4 ,ant9ewtonism1 ,i1 #afb4 ,ant9omians1 ,i1 #cid4 ,antiphon1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,antonie1 ,f41 ,i1 #abf1 #abf4 ,apollonius1 ,i1 #da1 #ajg4 ,app>itions1 ,,ii1 #dg4 ,arago1 ,i1 #bdc1 #cij4 ,aratus1 ,,ii1 #afg4 ,arbu?not1 ,i1 #acc1 #acd4 ,ar*]1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #ij4 ,ar*im$es1 ,i1 #e1 #aa1 #db1 #hc1 #ajg4 ,ar*ytas1 ,i1 #ec4 ,argoli1 ,i1 #ajd4 ,ari/ocrat1 z a sci5ti/1 ,i1 #aca4 ,ari/otle1 ,i1 #e1 #cca4 ,arnobius1 ,,ii1 #gc4 ,arson1 ,p4 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bjg4 ,a%ton1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #ii4 ,a/rology1 ,i1 #aah1 #abg1 #abh1 #cej2 ,,ii1 #dc4 ,a/ronom]'s ,dr9k+ ,song1 ,i1 #chj4 ,a/ronomical ,aphorisms1 ,i1 #cih4 ,p>adox1 ,i1 #cid4 ,police ,report1 ,i1 #cij4 ,society4 7,see ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society47 ,a/ronomy1 ,bailly's exagg]at$ view (1 ,i1 #aff4 ,a/unica1 ,didacas1 ,i1 #ij4 ,a?anasian ,cre$1 ,i1 #cga4 ,a!i/s1 ,philosophical1 ,i1 #a4 ,atoms1 ,,ii1 #aia4 #cgf ,attraction1 ,i1 #acf1 #aea1 #aee4 ,augu/9e1 ,/41 ,,ii1 #bc4 ,aurora borealis1 ,i1 #acd4 ,au/51 ,jane1 ,i1 #aia4 ,auz\t1 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,aviation1 ,e>ly ideas (1 ,,ii1 #h4 ,babbage1 ,c41 ,i1 #bjg1 #bij1 #bia2 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,ba*et1 de ,meziriac1 ,i1 #afa4 ,bacon1 ,f41 ,i1 #e1 #ge1 #ge1 #gf1 #gi1 #hi1 #ade1 #cca4 ,bacon1 ,r41 ,i1 #e1 #abf1 #abf1 #cfj2 ,,ii1 #id4 ,baconian controv]sy1 ,i1 #ada4 ,bad5 ,p[ell1 ,,ii1 #bfg4 ,bailly1 ,j4 ,s41 ,i1 #aff1 #aff1 #cjh4 ,baily1 ,f41 ,i1 #cjh1 #cji2 ,,ii1 #af1 #adc1 #ahh4 ,baily1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #af4 ,bak]1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,bakewell1 ,f4 ,c41 ,,ii1 #aef1 #aef4 ,banks1 ,j41 ,i1 #bh4 ,b>b]9i1 ,m41 ,,ii1 #bfg4 ,b>k]1 ,c41 ,,ii1 #bfb4 ,b>onius1 ,i1 #cc1 #ce2 ,,ii1 #fb4 ,b>reme1 ,i1 #db4 ,b>rett1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #ahh4 ,b>r[1 ,i41 ,i1 #afj2 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,b>uel1 de1 ,i1 #afe4 ,bassano1 ,duc de1 ,,ii1 #c1 #cci4 ,baxt]1 ,t41 ,i1 #adf4 ,bayle1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #gc4 ,beau=t1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #bfg4 ,beaugr&1 ,i1 #aai1 #aba4 ,beaulieu1 ,i1 #aai1 #aai1 #aba4 ,beaune1 de1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,bec\rt1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #bgg4 ,b$=d1 ,duke (1 7#f?71 ,i1 #ahb4 ,behm51 ,i1 #afh1 #bed2 ,,ii1 #cag4 ,bell5d51 ,w41 ,i1 #age4 ,b5tley1 ,i1 #aaj4 ,b]keley1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #cdf4 ,b]n>d1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #big1 #cjj4 ,b]n>dus ,trevisanus1 ,i1 #abf1 #abf4 ,b]n\llis1 ,i1 #acj1 #aej1 #cce1 #ccf4 ,b]tius1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,bese1 ,i1 #ff4 ,bessel1 ,i1 #chd2 ,,ii1 #b4 ,be?une1 ,i1 #ii1 #bgi1 #bia4 ,betteswor?1 ,i1 #ai4 ,beza4 7,see ,bese47 ,bick]/e?1 ,e4 ,h41 ,i1 #bch4 ,bidd]1 ,i1 #hf4 ,bid51 ,j41 ,,ii1 #aeh1 #afj4 ,bidle1 7,biddle71 ,i1 #bci4 ,biot1 ,i1 #he4 ,bir*1 ,t41 ,i1 #ajh2 ,,ii1 #cjd1 #cac4 ,birks1 ,t4 ,r41 ,,ii1 #aeh1 #aeh4 ,bi%op1 ,g41 ,i1 #chf4 ,bi%ops z ,p>adox]s1 ,i1 #bbf4 ,boccaccio1 ,i1 #ch4 ,boe?ius1 ,i1 #db1 #de4 ,boehme4 7,see ,behm547 ,boncompagni1 ,i1 #bih4 ,boniface1 ,/41 ,i1 #cb4 ,bonnyca/le1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #af4 ,book]1 ,i1 #aae4 ,boole1 ,g41 ,i1 #bfa1 #ccb2 ,,ii1 #ge1 #gi4 --,a tribute to1 ,,ii1 #gi4 ,borelli1 ,g4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,borello1 ,i1 #fi4 ,boreman1 ,i1 #aac4 ,borron1 ,mrs41 ,,ii1 #g4 ,boscovi*1 ,i1 #aef1 #afd4 ,b\gu]1 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,b\illaud1 ,i1 #hg2 ,,ii1 #bie4 ,b\v>d1 ,a41 ,i1 #cbg4 ,bovillus1 ,i1 #dd2 ,,ii1 #cbd4 --,epitome (1 ,i1 #dd4 ,b[dl]1 ,h4 ,m41 ,i1 #aid4 ,b[r+1 ,j41 ,i1 #ceb2 ,,ii1 #bef4 ,boyle1 ,r41 ,i1 #bd1 #abe2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,bradley1 ,i1 #bd4 ,bradw>d9e1 ,i1 #bbg1 #bbh1 #bbi4 ,brahe4 7,see ,ty*o ,b47 ,branck]1 ,i1 #ajg2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,br5an1 ,j41 ,i1 #ccj1 #ccj4 ,brew/]1 ,d41 ,i1 #ci1 #acg1 #adj2 ,,ii1 #bad1 #bhh1 #cgb4 ,briggs1 ,i1 #fi2 ,,ii1 #bii1 #cjb4 ,bright1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bce4 ,br9kley1 ,j41 ,i1 #caa4 ,britannicus1 ,d41 ,,ii1 #h4 ,briti% ,museum libr>y1 ,i1 #aea4 ,bro!rs1 ,r41 ,i1 #cae2 ,,ii1 #ig4 ,br\gham1 ,h5ry1 ,"l1 ,i1 #aia4 ,br\nck] 7,br\nk]71 ,i1 #acb2 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,br[n1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #afh4 ,br[ne1 ,t41 ,i1 #ca4 ,bruck]1 ,i1 #fa4 ,brunet1 ,i1 #djb4 ,bru5n[1 ,i1 #chf4 ,bruno1 ,i1 #ei1 #ei4 ,bryson1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,bu]gi1 ,i1 #eb4 ,buffon1 ,i1 #bhb4 ,bul/rode1 ,,ii1 #hd4 ,bungus1 ,i1 #ee1 #ee1 #eg4 ,buoncompagno1 ,u41 ,i1 #cfb4 #cgg ,burgon1 ,j4 ,w41 ,,ii1 #cj4 ,buridan1 ,i1 #cg4 --,que/iones morales1 ,i1 #cg4 ,buridan's ,ass1 ,i1 #cg4 ,burke1 ,e41 ,i1 #agc4 ,burlesque1 ,fr5d's1 ,i1 #bjh4 ,burnet1 ,g41 ,i1 #ajg4 ,burney1 ,frances1 ,i1 #aij4 ,burton1 ,frances ,b41 ,i1 #cgd4 ,busby1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #cac4 ,buteo1 ,i1 #ea4 ,butl]1 ,g41 ,i1 #aii4 ,butl]1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #bah4 ,buxton1 ,j41 ,i1 #hf4 ,byrgius4 7,see ,bu]gi47 ,byrne1 ,o41 ,i1 #cbi2 ,,ii1 #ahf1 #aij4 ,byron1 ,i1 #ahf2 ,,ii1 #bgj1 #bgc4 ,cabbala1 ,i1 #bgb4 ,calculat+ ,boys1 ,i1 #hf4 ,calculus1 ,i1 #abi4 ,cal5d>4 7,see ,ea/]47 ,cambridge ,poets1 ,,ii1 #bfi4 ,campanus1 ,i1 #db1 #dc4 ,cann+1 ,geo41 ,,ii1 #ade4 ,c>cavi1 ,i1 #ajf4 ,c>danus1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,c>lile1 ,r41 ,i1 #bga4 ,c>lyle1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #cgc4 ,c>not1 ,i1 #ajg4 ,c>ol9e tables1 ,i1 #abd4 ,casaubon1 ,i1 #aaa4 ,case1 ,j41 ,i1 #abh1 #abh4 ,cass9i1 ,j41 ,i1 #agb4 ,ca/el1 ,i1 #adh1 #adh4 ,ca/iglioni1 ,i1 #aci4 ,ca/l]eagh1 ,i1 #ahe1 #ahf4 ,cataldi1 ,i1 #fi1 #fi4 ,catcott1 ,a41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,causans1 de1 ,i1 #bih4 ,cavali]i1 ,i1 #ajf4 ,cav5di%1 ,c41 ,i1 #ajf2 ,,ii1 #bii1 #cab4 ,cav5di%1 ,w41 ,i1 #bij4 ,caxton1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #bha4 ,cayley1 ,a41 ,,ii1 #bib4 ,cecil1 ,r4 7#a/ ,e>l ( ,salisbury71 ,,ii1 #ccj4 ,c5trifugal =ce1 ,,ii1 #bfh4 ,ceul54 7,see ,van ,ceul547 ,*allis1 ,j41 ,i1 #cij2 ,,ii1 #ada4 ,*alm]s1 ,i1 #ajb2 ,,ii1 #bai4 ,*amb]s1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #bhb4 ,*amb]s1 ,r41 ,i1 #cdd1 #cdd4 ,*>les ,,ix1 ,,ii1 #id4 ,*>les ,x1 ,,ii1 #a4 ,*asles1 ,i1 #ci1 #bbi4 ,*e/]field1 ,e>l ( 7#d?71 ,,ii1 #bih4 ,*iff9*1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #ej4 ,*'9 ,*iu-%ang1 ,,ii1 #ff4 ,*itty1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cbc4 ,*iu-*ang1 ,suan-%u1 ,,ii1 #fg4 ,*ri/ian ,evid5ce ,society1 ,i1 #bgj4 ,*ri/ie1 ,i1 #bg4 ,*ri/mann1 ,i1 #bgb1 #bgb4 ,*ur* "q1 ,i1 #fb4 ,*ur*1 ,! ^w1 ,,ii1 #cj4 ,circle squ>]s4 7,see ,squ>+ ! ,circle47 ,circulat+ m$ia ( ma!matics1 ,i1 #ajg4 ,ciruelo4 7,see ,san*ez47 ,clairaut1 ,i1 #bai1 #chb4 ,cl>5ce1 ,duke (1 ,i1 #agi4 ,cl>ke1 ,r41 ,i1 #bee4 ,clavius1 ,i1 #aa1 #fi1 #aaa1 #aab1 #cce1 #cfb1 #cfc1 #cgb2 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,clayton41 ,geo41 ,,ii1 #ih4 ,cluvi]1 ,d41 ,,ii1 #ccb1 #ccb4 ,cobb1 ,m>y1 ,,ii1 #aag4 ,cobbett1 ,w41 ,i1 #agg1 #bjj1 #cii4 ,cobd51 ,r41 ,,ii1 #bag4 ,cock]1 ,i1 #db2 ,,ii1 #fd1 #agc1 #bea1 #cjg4 ,cody1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #bjh4 ,coke1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #cca4 ,colburn1 ,z41 ,i1 #hf4 ,col5so1 ,i1 #fc1 #bdg2 ,,ii1 #aia4 ,coll9s1 ,j41 ,i1 #ajg2 ,,ii1 #big1 #cjj1 #cjb1 #cac4 ,colvill1 ,w4 ,h41 ,,ii1 #fh4 ,cometic a/rology1 ,i1 #abh4 ,comets1 ,i1 #abh2 ,,ii1 #fh1 #hc4 ,com9ale1 ,c41 ,i1 #afb1 #afb4 ,compton1 ,s4 ,j4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #ai4 ,computation1 ,p>adoxes (1 ,,ii1 #bea1 #bfg4 ,condam9e1 ,c4 ,m4 de la1 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,conduitt1 ,john1 ,i1 #cig4 ,conduitt1 ,mrs41 ,i1 #acf4 ,congregation ( ! ,index1 ,i1 #ij4 ,conv]se propositions1 ,i1 #bie4 ,convocation at ,ox=d1 ,i1 #if4 ,cooke1 ,m>g>et1 ,i1 #caj4 ,coop]1 ,a4 ,a4 7,%aftsbury71 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,cop]nicus1 ,i1 #e1 #f1 #gf1 #ij1 #aba1 #agb1 #chj2 ,,ii1 #afe1 #cce4 ,copley1 ,j4 ,s41 ,i1 #aih4 ,corm\ls1 ,i1 #bbe4 ,cosmology1 ,i1 #agb4 #cgh ,cotes1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,cottle1 ,mrs41 ,,ii1 #ig1 #ig1 #afa4 ,craig1 ,j41 ,i1 #abi1 #abi4 ,cre$1 ,ma!matics ( a1 ,i1 #cbi4 ,cribb1 ,t41 ,i1 #cad4 ,crotus1 ,j41 ,i1 #cah4 ,cruick%ank1 ,g41 ,i1 #ahf4 ,cube1 ,duplication (1 ,i1 #cdi4 ,cumyns1 ,eliza1 ,i1 #bii4 ,cunn+ham1 ,i1 #agb1 #agb4 ,curabelle1 ,i1 #bba4 ,curi\s ,calculations1 ,,ii1 #ff4 ,curll1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #bgi4 ,cusa1 ,i1 #dd1 #dg1 #cfj4 ,cu/om1 ,,ii1 #cbd4 ,cyclometry1 ,,ii1 #bjh4 7,see ,squ>+ ( ! ,circle47 ,cyclopa$ias1 ,review (1 ,,ii1 #bhj4 ,d',alemb]t1 ,i1 #chb2 ,,ii1 #bhc1 #cfd4 ,dalg>no1 ,i1 #aaf1 #aag4 ,dalton1 ,j41 ,i1 #bee4 ,d',arblay1 ,mme41 ,i1 #aij4 ,d>w91 ,e41 ,,ii1 #h4 ,d>w9ism1 ,primitive1 ,i1 #cdd4 ,d>y1 ,m41 ,,ii1 #cje4 ,daval1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #bih4 ,davies1 ,t4 ,s41 ,,ii1 #aea1 #aea1 #ahh4 ,day1 ,a41 ,i1 #bie1 #bie4 ,de ,b>uel1 ,i1 #afe4 ,de ,beaune4 7,see ,beaune47 ,de ,bec\rt1 ,,ii1 #bgg1 #bgg4 ,deb5ham1 ,j41 ,i1 #cic4 ,de ,causans4 7,see ,causans47 ,de*ales4 7,see de ,*alles47 ,de ,*alles1 ,i1 #de4 ,decimal co9age1 ,,ii1 #hj1 #afh1 #afi4 ,decimals run riot1 ,,ii1 #hj4 ,dee1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,de ,faure1 ,i1 #adi4 ,de la ,leu1 ,i1 #big4 ,delambre1 ,i1 #afj1 #afg1 #ced2 ,,ii1 #afe4 ,democritus1 ,,ii1 #cd4 ,de ,moivre1 ,i1 #bd1 #cgf2 ,,ii1 #bih4 ,de ,moli]es1 ,i1 #bbj4 ,de ,mol9a1 ,i1 #big4 ,demonville1 ,i1 #bia1 #bic4 ,de ,morgan1 ,a41 ,i1 #aia1 #chc2 ,,ii1 #aid4 --,refusal ( ,,ll4 ,d41 ,i1 #aia4 ,de ,morgan1 ,g4 ,c41 ,i1 #chc4 ,de ,morgan1 ,mrs41 ,i1 #aif2 ,,ii1 #aid4 ,d5ison1 ,j41 ,i1 #cdh1 #cec4 ,desaguli]s1 ,i1 #aec1 #aef1 #aeg4 ,des>gues1 ,i1 #aai1 #bba4 ,desc>tes1 ,i1 #e1 #ei1 #aje1 #acb1 #afe1 #bjd1 #bbj2 ,,ii1 #id4 ,de ,s]res1 ,,ii1 #fj4 ,de ,sluse4 7,see ,sluse47 ,de ,?\1 ,i1 #ea1 #aaa1 #aac2 ,,ii1 #bie4 ,de ,vaus5ville1 ,i1 #ab4 ,devon%ire1 ,duke ( 7#g?71 ,i1 #bij4 ,diam&i1 ,i1 #hf4 ,didacus ,a/unica1 ,i1 #ij4 ,did]ot1 ,,ii1 #d1 #bhc1 #cci4 ,digby1 ,k41 ,i1 #ajh4 ,digges1 ,t41 & ,l41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,dionysius ,exiguus1 ,i1 #cfj4 ,dircks1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #ach1 #ach4 ,discov]]s & discov]ies1 ,,ii1 #bjf4 ,discov]y1 ,basis (1 ,i1 #he4 ,d',israeli1 ,i41 ,i1 #aae1 #aah1 #acf1 #ahh1 #bbg4 ,ditton1 ,i1 #acc1 #acc4 ,division1 ,nature (1 ,,ii1 #bdh4 ,dobson1 ,j41 ,i1 #bcd1 #bcd4 ,dodson1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cab4 ,dodt1 ,i1 #eb4 ,dogg]el v]se1 ,i1 #cda4 ,doll&1 ,i1 #cgg4 ,d\ble ,vahu ,process1 ,,ii1 #cfj4 ,d\glas1 ,g41 ,i1 #bcb4 ,dra*1 ,s4 ,m41 ,,ii1 #cag4 ,drayson1 ,g4 ,a4 ,w41 ,,ii1 #acb1 #acb4 ,dryd51 ,,ii1 #ga4 ,dual ari?metic1 ,,ii1 #ahf4 ,du*esne1 ,i1 #eb4 ,dumorti]1 ,i1 #cac4 ,duncan1 ,a41 ,i1 #agi4 ,dunk91 ,e41 ,,ii1 #cdi4 ,duodecimal scale1 ,,ii1 #fh4 ,duplication ,problem1 ,i1 #cdi4 ,dupuy1 ,j4 & ,p41 ,,ii1 #bie4 ,dut5s1 ,l41 ,,ii1 #ij4 ,dy]1 ,g41 ,i1 #agh4 ,e>?1 ,figure (1 ,,ii1 #ed4 ,ea/]1 ,i1 #cei4 ,ea/] ,day ,p>adoxes1 ,i1 #cec4 ,ebr+ton1 ,?os41 ,i1 #bdg4 ,edgewor?1 ,m>ia1 ,i1 #aia4 ,editorial ,sy/em1 ,i1 #ae4 ,edle/on1 ,i1 #adj2 ,,ii1 #bif4 ,edw>ds1 ,j41 ,i1 #add4 ,edw>ds1 ,t41 ,i1 #aab4 ,eir5aeus ,philale!s1 ,i1 #abe1 #abe1 #abf4 ,eldon1 ,"l 7#a/71 ,,ii1 #aig4 ,elephant /ory1 ,i1 #eh4 ,elizabe?1 ,que51 ,i1 #abh4 ,ell5bor\gh1 ,b>on1 ,i1 #aha4 #cgi ,ellicot1 ,i1 #bd4 ,ellis1 ,i1 #gf1 #hb4 ,engel1 ,i1 #bcj4 ,engli% language1 ,orig9 (1 ,i1 #bae4 ,enriques1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #cfg4 ,epps1 ,j41 ,i1 #aec2 ,,ii1 #adc4 ,equation ( fif? degree1 ,i1 #bej1 #cgc4 ,erasmus1 ,i1 #aaj4 ,era/us1 ,i1 #fe4 ,eri*s51 ,i1 #afc4 ,ers*1 ,,ii1 #aic1 #bhb4 ,ersk9e1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #abg4 ,esp]anto1 ,=]unn] (1 ,i1 #aaf4 ,euclid1 ,i1 #e1 #dc2 ,,ii1 #aah1 #aea4 --,)\t ,axioms1 ,i1 #bhg4 ,eudoxus1 ,,ii1 #afd4 ,eul]1 ,i1 #bba1 #chb2 ,,ii1 #c1 #d1 #cjc1 #cca1 #cci4 ,eusebius1 ,,ii1 #bbj4 ,eu/ace1 ,j4 ,c41 ,,ii1 #df4 ,eutocius1 ,i1 #da2 ,,ii1 #fj4 ,evelyn1 ,j41 ,i1 #ajh4 ,ev]ett1 ,j41 ,i1 #cdf4 ,evid5ce1 ,i1 #eg1 #eh4 ,fab]4 7,see ,/apul5sis47 ,fairfax1 ,m>y1 ,i1 #bdb4 ,falco1 ,i1 #ec4 ,f>aday1 ,m41 ,,ii1 #cea4 ,faure1 de1 ,i1 #adi2 ,,ii1 #bch4 ,fawcett1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #bdi4 ,f]guson1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bj4 ,f]mat1 ,i1 #abb1 #bba2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,f]r>i1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #fh4 ,fiction1 ,new era 91 ,i1 #ahi4 ,fi5us1 ,i1 #gd1 #gd4 ,filopanti1 ,q4 ,b41 ,,ii1 #ic4 ,f9aeus1 ,i1 #ej1 #ej1 #aac4 ,f9leyson1 ,j41 ,i1 #cad1 #cad4 ,flam/e$1 ,i1 #hg1 #cji2 ,,ii1 #de1 #adc1 #cjb1 #cjf4 ,flet*]1 ,i1 #cgh4 ,fludd1 ,,ii1 #cah4 ,fly-leaf ,p>adox1 ,,ii1 #bfd4 ,folkes1 ,m41 ,i1 #acf2 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,font5elle1 ,i1 #ajc4 ,=bes1 ,d41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,=man1 ,w41 ,i1 #bif1 #bif1 #cjf4 ,=/]1 ,t4 ,i4 ,m41 ,i1 #cbj1 #cbj4 ,fosc>9i1 ,i1 #ij4 ,fo/]1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #caj4 ,f\ri]1 ,,ii1 #ff4 ,fox1 ,g41 ,i1 #cig4 ,francis1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #if4 ,francoeur1 ,i1 #cfe4 ,frankl&1 ,w4 ,b41 ,i1 #bcj1 #bhg4 ,frankl91 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bfe4 ,fre$om ( op9ion1 ,gr[? (1 ,i1 #bfe4 ,freh]1 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cai4 ,fr5* academy on circle squ>+1 ,i1 #afc4 ,fr5d1 ,w41 ,i1 #aif1 #aif1 #bjf1 #bjh1 #beb4 ,fresnel1 ,,ii1 #dh4 ,fromondus1 ,i1 #gd1 #gd1 #ii4 ,fro/1 ,i4 & ,j41 ,i1 #cid4 ,fry1 ,elizabe?1 ,i1 #bbd4 ,full]1 ,t41 ,i1 #hf4 ,fulton1 ,r41 ,i1 #adh4 ,gadbury1 ,j41 ,i1 #aae1 #aae4 ,galbrai?1 ,j4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cgb4 ,galileo1 ,i1 #e1 #f1 #cb1 #gf1 #hb1 #hc1 #if1 #abb1 #cha4 ,galle1 ,j4 ,g41 ,i1 #chf2 ,,ii1 #g4 ,gall[ay1 ,i1 #ef1 #eg2 ,,ii1 #adc4 ,gambl]s1 ,i1 #bhj4 ,g>rick1 ,i1 #ba4 ,gascoigne1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #bii4 ,gass5di1 ,i1 #ajg4 ,gauss1 ,i1 #hf1 #ajg1 #caj4 ,gemi/us1 ,g41 ,i1 #ahh4 ,g5tleman's ,mon?ly1 ,miscellany1 ,i1 #bjh4 ,gephry&]4 7,see ,salicetus47 ,g]gonne1 ,i1 #ccf4 ,ghetaldi1 ,i1 #hc2 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,gho/ p>adox1 ,,ii1 #dg4 ,giddy 7,gilb]t71 ,,ii1 #agd4 ,gilb]t1 ,davies1 ,,ii1 #ff1 #agd4 ,gilb]t1 ,william1 ,i1 #f1 #fh1 #fh1 #gf4 ,gillot1 ,,ii1 #cae4 ,glazi] 7,glazion71 ,,ii1 #g4 ,godw91 ,f41 ,i1 #ajc4 ,godw91 ,w41 ,i1 #agd4 ,golius1 ,i1 #ajf4 ,gomp]tz1 ,b41 ,i1 #cgh4 ,g\lburn1 ,i1 #bhh4 ,g\ld51 ,s41 ,,ii1 #hh4 ,graham1 ,i1 #bd4 ,gr&amicus1 ,i1 #ajd1 #ajd4 ,grang]1 ,j41 ,i1 #aef4 ,grant1 ,a4 ,r41 ,,ii1 #aca4 ,grant1 ,r41 ,i1 #cib2 ,,ii1 #aca4 ,grassi1 ,o41 ,i1 #bfb4 ,grass9i1 ,i1 #bca4 ,graunt1 ,j41 ,i1 #aac1 #aad1 #aed4 ,gravity1 ,i1 #aea1 #bdd1 #cdh1 #cec4 #chj --,newton's apple1 ,i1 #acf4 ,greek num]als1 ,,ii1 #gg4 ,gre5e1 ,r41 ,i1 #ace1 #ace4 ,gre5hill1 ,sir ,g41 ,i1 #acf4 ,gre5wi* obs]vatory1 ,i1 #hg4 ,gregg1 ,t4 ,d41 ,,ii1 #ge1 #ge4 ,gregorian ,cal5d>1 ,i1 #cfc4 ,gregory1 ,d41 ,i1 #ff2 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,gregory1 ,j41 ,i1 #aah1 #aah1 #bjg2 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,gregory ,o41 ,,ii1 #ga4 ,gregory1 ,pope1 ,i1 #cfb4 ,grevil1 ,i1 #bjb4 ,grey1 ,c41 7#b;d ,e>l71 ,i1 #cae2 ,,ii1 #bdg4 ,gros>t1 ,i1 #ada1 #ada1 #ade4 ,grove1 ,w4 ,r41 ,,ii1 #cbj4 ,grub]1 ,,ii1 #aic1 #bhb4 ,gru5b]g]1 ,i1 #gj4 ,grynaeus1 ,i1 #ff4 ,gu>icus1 ,i1 #dc4 ,guillim1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bh4 ,guld91 ,i1 #hc4 ,gumpa*1 ,von1 ,,ii1 #acg1 #acg4 ,gunn+1 ,h41 ,i1 #aih4 ,gurney4 7,see ,fry1 ,e47 ,gu?rie1 ,w41 ,i1 #cie4 ,hailes1 ,j4 ,d41 ,,ii1 #ace1 #ace4 ,hailesean sy/em ( a/ronomy1 ,,ii1 #ace4 ,hale1 ,m41 ,i1 #abc1 #abc4 ,hales1 ,s41 ,i1 #abc4 ,hall1 ,b41 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,hallam1 ,i1 #aei4 ,halley1 ,i1 #bd1 #abd1 #caa2 ,,ii1 #cja1 #ccb4 ,halliwell-,phillips1 ,,ii1 #adh1 #bif4 ,hamilton1 ,w41 ,i1 #aab1 #aag1 #cca1 #cce1 #cci1 #cda1 #cdb2 ,,ii1 #eb1 #ec1 #aaa4 ,hamilton1 ,w4 ,r[an1 ,i1 #ccb2 ,,ii1 #ajd1 #bef1 #cdc4 ,hanov]1 ,k+ (1 ,i1 #bja4 ,h>dy1 ,c41 ,i1 #bih4 ,h>dy1 ,t41 ,i1 #agh4 ,h>riot1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,h>vey1 ,i1 #gf1 #gh2 ,,ii1 #bja4 ,hauff1 ,i1 #bcj4 ,haughton1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #cgb4 ,hauksbee1 ,f41 ,i1 #aef4 ,hayes1 ,c41 ,i1 #acb1 #acb4 ,hea?1 ,d4 ,d41 ,i1 #gf4 ,he9fett]1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #id1 #id4 ,helmont1 ,j4 ,b4 van1 ,i1 #abe4 ,h5son1 ,,ii1 #h4 ,h]aclitus1 ,,ii1 #cd4 ,h]b>t1 ,j4 ,f41 ,i1 #bec1 #bec2 ,,ii1 #gh4 ,h]igone1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,h]s*el1 ,j41 ,i1 #hj1 #bii1 #cbf1 #chc1 #chf2 ,,ii1 #hh1 #ie1 #aha1 #bee1 #bfa1 #bfb4 ,h]s*el1 ,w41 ,i1 #ha1 #aea1 #aib1 #bbe1 #bcc1 #bii2 ,,ii1 #bhh1 #cdh4 ,heywood1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #di4 ,hicks1 ,j4 ,p41 ,,ii1 #fg4 ,higg9s1 ,g41 ,i1 #beg1 #bgd4 ,hil>ius1 ,pope1 ,i1 #cei4 ,hill1 ,j41 ,i1 #ba1 #bb1 #bc1 #bd4 ,hill1 ,rev4 ,r41 ,i1 #aib4 ,hill1 ,sir ,r41 ,i1 #afe1 #bcb4 ,h9d1 ,j4 ,r41 ,i1 #chd4 ,hippocrates1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,hoax1 ,an int]e/+1 ,i1 #afc4 --,lun> ,cau/ic1 ,i1 #bhh4 --,moon 7,h]s*el71 ,i1 #cbf2 ,,ii1 #aca4 ,hobbes1 ,i1 #aje1 #aji1 #adc1 #add2 ,,ii1 #hj4 ,hobh\se1 ,j4 ,c41 ,,ii1 #abf4 ,hodd]1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bfe4 ,hodge1 ,c4 ,b41 ,i1 #aad4 ,hodges1 ,w41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,h(fmann1 ,j4 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bhb4 ,h(fmann1 ,j4 ,j4 ,i4 von1 ,i1 #bcj4 ,holl[ay1 ,b41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,holmes1 ,o4 ,w41 ,i1 #aji4 ,holyoake1 ,g4 ,j41 ,i1 #cii1 #cii4 ,hone1 ,w41 ,i1 #abd1 #ahj1 #ahd1 #ahe4 ,hook1 ,t4 ,e41 ,,ii1 #bfa4 ,hooke1 ,i1 #gg2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,hook]1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #bja4 ,hopk9s1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #da4 ,horace1 ,i1 #dj4 ,horne1 ,g41 ,i1 #aeb1 #aeb1 #aed1 #aee1 #bcf4 ,horne1 ,j41 ,i1 #agh4 ,horn]1 ,l41 ,i1 #agf4 ,horn]1 ,w4 ,g41 ,,ii1 #ff1 #aea1 #ahg4 ,h\l/on1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #aef1 #aef4 ,h[>d1 ,e41 ,i1 #aca4 ,h[ison1 ,w41 ,i1 #bef1 #bef4 ,h[itt1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #aic1 #aic4 ,h[ley1 ,i1 #fc4 ,hulls1 ,i1 #adg1 #adg2 ,,ii1 #h4 ,hume1 ,j41 ,i1 #ceb2 ,,ii1 #agd4 ,husa9 ,rifki1 ,,ii1 #af4 ,husse9 ,eff5di1 ,,ii1 #ae4 ,hut*9son1 ,j41 ,i1 #aed1 #aed4 ,hutton1 ,c41 ,i1 #aec1 #afa2 ,,ii1 #cjc1 #cdj4 ,huygh5s1 ,i1 #ajj1 #acc2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,imag9>y numb]s1 ,,ii1 #ahf4 ,impalem5t by reque/1 ,,ii1 #acc4 ,inaudi1 ,i1 #hf4 ,index ,expurgatorius1 ,i1 #ij4 #cha ,infant prodigies1 ,i1 #hf4 ,+lis1 ,j4 ,b41 ,,ii1 #eb4 ,+lis1 ,r4 ,h41 ,i1 #ceb4 ,+liz ,selim ,eff5di1 ,,ii1 #ae4 ,innoc5t ,i41 ,i1 #cei4 ,irv+1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #ed4 ,ivory1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #adb1 #adb4 ,jabir b5 ,aflah1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,jack1 ,r41 ,i1 #adi4 ,jacotot1 ,j41 ,i1 #bgh1 #bgh4 ,jameson1 ,mrs41 ,,ii1 #fc4 ,jeffreys1 ,g41 ,i1 #ahc4 ,j5n]1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #bje4 ,jesuit contributions1 ,i1 #afd4 ,johnson1 ,h4 ,c41 ,i1 #cej4 ,johnson1 ,s41 ,i1 #bj1 #aij1 #bei2 ,,ii1 #aag4 ,john/on1 ,w4 ,h41 ,,ii1 #fg4 ,jomb]t1 ,i1 #afa4 ,jon*]e1 ,i1 #adf1 #adf4 ,jones1 ,w41 ,i1 #ace2 ,,ii1 #bih1 #cja4 ,jones1 ,rev4 ,w41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,jonson1 ,b41 ,i1 #ac4 ,j\rnals1 ,?ree classes (1 ,,ii1 #add4 ,kantesian ,jewel]1 ,i1 #beh4 ,k>/51 ,i1 #bcj4 ,kae/n]1 ,i1 #dc1 #aaj1 #aab4 ,kat]1 ,i1 #aa4 ,keck]mann1 ,i1 #c4 ,keill1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,kepl]1 ,i1 #eb1 #gf1 #hb1 #cha2 ,,ii1 #aff4 ,k]igan1 ,t41 ,i1 #cjh1 #cec4 ,k]\alle1 ,de1 ,,ii1 #ej4 ,k]sey1 ,i1 #ajg4 ,k+1 ,wm41 ,i1 #bdf4 ,kir*]1 ,adolphe1 ,i1 #bbi4 ,kir*]1 ,a?anasius1 ,i1 #ajc4 ,kirkr+ius1 ,t41 ,i1 #abe1 #abe4 ,kittle1 ,i1 #bcf4 ,kle91 ,f41 ,,ii1 #cfg4 ,knight1 ,c41 ,,ii1 #aji1 #bhj1 #bhi4 ,knight1 ,g41 ,i1 #aea1 #aea4 ,knight1 ,r4 ,p41 ,,ii1 #bgd4 ,knight1 ,wm41 ,i1 #ig4 ,ko5ig1 ,s41 ,i1 #aej4 ,lacomme1 ,i1 #df4 ,la ,condam9e1 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,lacroix1 ,i1 #da1 #aei1 #bjg4 ,lactantius1 ,i1 #cc1 #if4 ,lagrange1 ,i1 #bba1 #bhh1 #cac1 #chb2 ,,ii1 #hf4 ,la+1 ,f4 ,h41 ,,ii1 #ahf1 #ahf4 ,lal&e1 ,i1 #aei4 ,lamb1 ,c41 ,i1 #agh2 ,,ii1 #bgj4 ,lamb]t1 ,j4 ,h41 ,i1 #ccf2 ,,ii1 #bad1 #cfg4 ,lamb]t1 ,john1 ,,ii1 #cji4 ,language1 ,te/ (1 ,,ii1 #cbg4 ,lansb]gius1 ,i1 #gj1 #gj4 ,laplace1 ,i1 #bd1 #bee1 #chb2 ,,ii1 #a1 #cdj4 ,l>dn]1 ,d41 ,,ii1 #bec4 ,l>dn]1 ,n41 ,i1 #ad2 ,,ii1 #bba4 ,laud1 ,i1 #ade4 ,laud]1 ,w41 ,i1 #big4 ,laur5t1 ,p41 ,i1 #cji1 #cji4 ,laurie1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #d4 ,laurie1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #db4 ,laurus1 ,i1 #cha4 ,law1 ,edmund1 ,i1 #aha4 ,law1 ,edw>d1 ,i1 #aha4 ,law1 ,w41 ,i1 #afh1 #bed2 ,,ii1 #cag4 ,le ,coq1 ,i1 #hf4 ,lee1 ,r41 ,i1 #ff4 ,lee1 ,s41 ,i1 #aca4 ,lee1 ,w41 ,i1 #aeg4 ,legate1 ,i1 #ei4 ,leg5dre1 ,i1 #bbi2 ,,ii1 #bae1 #cfg4 ,legh1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #fh1 #hc4 ,leibnitz1 ,i1 #e1 #g2 ,,ii1 #df4 ,leo1 ,/41 ,i1 #cei4 ,lev]ri]1 ,i1 #dc1 #hb1 #chc1 #chf1 #chh1 #cij2 ,,ii1 #g1 #ace1 #adj1 #cjc4 ,lewis1 ,g4 ,c41 ,,ii1 #afb1 #afb4 ,libri1 ,i1 #dj1 #fb2 ,,ii1 #bie4 ,lilius1 ,aloysius1 ,i1 #cfb4 ,lilly1 ,i1 #aae2 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,lip51 ,m41 ,i1 #bih4 ,little1 ,j41 ,i1 #bjf4 ,liv+/on1 ,r41 ,i1 #adh4 ,locke1 ,j41 ,i1 #adb1 #adb1 #add2 --& ,soc9ianism1 ,i1 #adb4 ,locke1 ,r41 ,i1 #adf4 ,locke1 ,r4 ,a41 ,i1 #cbf2 ,,ii1 #hf1 #aca4 ,logan1 ,w4 ,e41 ,i1 #ccg4 ,logic1 ,=mal1 ,i1 #aeh2 ,,ii1 #ge4 --,has no p>adoxes1 ,i1 #ccj4 ,london ,ma!matical ,society1 ,i1 #chc4 ,london1 ,univ]sity (1 ,i1 #bei2 ,,ii1 #ga4 ,long1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #bij4 ,long1 ,j4 ,/4 ,j41 ,,ii4 #ch1 #bje4 ,longitude problems1 ,i1 #acb1 #adf1 #bdi4 ,longley1 ,c4 ,t41 ,i1 #cbe4 ,longomontanus1 ,i1 #aje1 #aje4 ,lott]y1 ,i4 #bha4 ,lovett1 ,r41 ,i1 #afe1 #aff4 ,l[e1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #afi4 ,l[ndes1 ,w4 ,t41 ,i4 #djb4 ,lubbock1 ,j41 ,i1 #bgi2 ,,ii1 #adh4 #chb ,lucas1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #bh4 ,lucian1 ,i1 #ajb4 ,lun> ,cau/ic ,joke1 ,i1 #bhh4 ,lunn1 ,j4 ,r41 ,,ii1 #ff4 ,lydiat1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,lyndhur/1 ,i1 #aih4 ,macclesfield1 ,e>ls (1 ,i1 #g2 ,,ii1 #bif1 #cja4 ,macclesfield1 ,lett]s1 ,,ii1 #bif4 ,mac,elshender1 ,,ii1 #hg4 ,ma*91 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,mackey1 ,john1 ,i1 #cdi4 ,mackey1 ,s4 ,a41 ,i1 #bef4 ,macle>1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,macleod1 ,h4 ,d41 ,,ii1 #ahd1 #ahd4 ,magic1 ,i1 #aah4 ,magna ,*>ta1 ,i1 #be4 ,magnus1 ,i1 #db4 ,maitl&1 ,s41 ,i1 #fc1 #afc4 ,malac>ne1 ,i1 #aai4 ,mald51 ,h41 ,,ii1 #afb4 ,malius1 ,,ii1 #cdb4 ,mallem5s1 ,,ii1 #ccc4 ,mank9d gullible1 ,i1 #aae4 ,mann+1 ,h4 ,e41 7,c>d471 ,,ii1 #bcc4 ,mansel1 ,h4 ,l41 ,,ii1 #afb4 ,m>celis1 ,j41 ,i1 #abi1 #abi4 ,m>et1 ,,ii1 #c4 ,m>g>ita ,philosophica4 7,see ,reis*47 ,m>ryat1 ,capt41 ,,ii1 #hg4 ,m>%1 ,h41 ,i1 #aii1 #bga4 ,m>t91 ,b41 ,i1 #aeb1 #aec4 ,m>t91 ,r41 ,,ii1 #bcf4 ,mas]es1 ,f41 ,i1 #aig1 #bjc4 ,mason1 ,m41 ,,ii1 #acb4 ,ma!matical ,illu/rations ( ,doctr9e1 ,,ii1 #gj2 --,psy*ology1 ,i1 #bec2 --,society1 ,i1 #cgd1 #cgf1 #chb2 --,!ology1 ,i1 #adi4 ,ma!matics1 ,cond5s$ hi/ory (1 ,,ii1 #eh4 ,matt] to ,_s1 ,,ii1 #aid4 ,maty1 ,i1 #bc4 ,maup]tuis1 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,maurice1 ,f4 ,d41 ,,ii1 #aja4 ,maurolycus1 ,i1 #aba4 ,maxwell1 ,a41 ,i1 #ajb4 ,meadley1 ,g4 ,w41 ,i1 #bbc4 ,me*anics ,magaz9e1 ,,ii1 #ada1 #ade4 ,m$ici1 ,cosmo de1 ,,ii1 #bie4 ,m$ic9e1 ,/atus (1 ,i1 #bff4 ,melan*?on1 ,,ii1 #cbc4 ,m5e/ri]1 ,i1 #abg1 #abg4 ,m]cator1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #ib4 ,m]cator's projection1 ,i1 #hd4 ,m]s5ne1 ,i1 #ajf1 #ajg2 ,,ii1 #bie1 #big4 ,mesli]1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #aie4 ,meteorologi/1 ,an e>ly1 ,i1 #cbj4 ,meteorology1 ,i1 #cbg4 ,metius1 ,a4 & ,p41 ,i1 #eb1 #ii1 #ii4 ,meton1 ,,ii1 #afg4 ,metric ,sy/em1 ,=]unn] (1 ,i1 #aga4 ,meziriac1 ,i1 #afa4 ,milbanke1 ,a4 ,i41 ,i1 #bbe4 ,mill1 ,jas41 ,i1 #bfj4 ,mill]1 ,joe1 ,i1 #ahb4 ,mill]1 ,s41 ,i1 #afg4 ,mills1 ,elizabe?1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #g4 ,milne1 ,j41 ,i1 #bhf4 ,miln]1 ,i41 ,i1 #bea1 #bea4 ,miln]1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bc4 ,miln]'s lamp1 ,i1 #beb4 ,milw>d1 ,,ii1 #bej4 ,miracles vs4 ,nature1 ,,ii1 #f4 ,mit*ell1 ,j41 ,i1 #bdb4 ,moli]e1 ,i1 #bcb4 ,mol9a1 ,a4 ,c4 de1 ,i1 #big4 ,moll5dorff1 von1 ,,ii1 #c1 #cch4 ,mondeux1 ,i1 #hf4 ,montague1 ,c41 ,,ii1 #caa4 ,montmort1 ,p4 ,r4 de1 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,montucla1 ,i1 #dj1 #de1 #ed1 #fe1 #aag1 #abj1 #aei1 #afc2 ,,ii1 #fj4 ,moon ,hoax1 ,i1 #cbf2 ,,ii1 #aca4 ,moon1 ,nature (1 ,,ii1 #hd2 --,rotation (1 ,,ii1 #d1 #ai1 #hd1 #hg4 ,m1 ,hannah1 ,i1 #ahi1 #aib4 ,m1 ,h5ry1 ,i1 #abc4 ,moore1 ,dr4 ,john1 ,i1 #aij4 ,moore1 ,sir ,john1 ,i1 #aij4 ,morgan1 ,s41 ,i1 #f4 ,morgan1 ,t41 ,i1 #aia4 ,morgan1 ,w41 ,i1 #bbc1 #bbd4 ,morh(1 ,i1 #fa4 ,mor91 ,i1 #ii1 #ii4 ,mor9us1 ,j4 ,b41 ,i1 #adi4 ,morl&1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #cjb4 ,mormonism1 ,,ii1 #fi4 ,morrison1 ,r4 ,j41 ,i1 #cba2 ,,ii1 #dc4 ,mose1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #bff4 ,mottelay1 ,i1 #fh4 ,motti1 ,,ii1 #fj4 ,m\ton1 ,i1 #agb2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,muggleton1 ,i1 #cid1 #cie4 ,multiplication1 ,nature (1 ,,ii1 #bea4 ,mur*ison1 ,r4 ,i41 ,i1 #chd4 ,murh>d1 ,i1 #dc1 #bih4 #chc ,murphy1 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cjh4 ,murphy1 ,j4 ,l41 ,,ii1 #ed1 #ed4 ,murphy1 ,p41 ,i1 #cbg1 #cih4 ,murphy1 ,r41 ,i1 #cdi1 #cdi4 ,murray1 ,j41 ,i1 #ahf2 ,,ii1 #ade4 ,murray1 ,l41 ,,ii1 #cbf4 ,murray1 ,mungo1 ,,ii1 #caj4 ,musgrave1 ,t41 ,i1 #cbd4 ,mydorge1 ,i1 #bih4 ,my/rom1 ,j4 ,w41 ,,ii1 #ahb4 ,my?ological p>adoxes1 ,i1 #bef4 ,names ( ,religi\s ,bodies1 ,,ii1 #bb4 ,napi]1 ,j41 ,i1 #e1 #ff1 #fg1 #hb4 ,napoleon1 ,d\bts z to1 ,i1 #bdf4 ,nautical ,almanac1 ,i1 #cjj2 ,,ii1 #adg4 ,neal1 ,i1 #ih4 ,negative numb]s1 ,i1 #aif1 #bjc4 ,neile1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #aij4 ,neptune1 ,discov]y (1 ,i1 #chg2 ,,ii1 #adj4 7,see ,adams1 ,lev]ri]47 ,nesse1 ,c1 ,i1 #abh1 #abh4 ,newcomb1 ,s41 ,i1 #afb4 ,newcom51 ,t41 ,i1 #adg4 ,newton1 ,sir ,isaac1 ,i1 #e1 #f1 #h1 #bd1 #ci1 #hd1 #hh1 #acj1 #acf1 #aci1 #add1 #ade1 #adh1 #aeb1 #aed1 #aee1 #afb1 #afe1 #afg1 #aig1 #bbe1 #bcg1 #bdb1 #beg1 #bhb1 #bif1 #big1 #cji1 #caa1 #chb1 #cid1 #cie1 #cif1 #cig2 ,,ii1 #b1 #gj1 #ahd1 #big1 #cjb1 #cje4 ,newton1 ,john1 ,,ii1 #cje4 ,nic5e ,cre$1 ,i1 #cga4 ,ni*ol1 ,j4 ,p41 ,,ii1 #bhi4 ,ni*olas4 7,see ,cusa47 ,ni*ols1 ,j41 ,i1 #age4 ,nicolas1 ,n4 ,h41 ,i1 #ced4 ,nicollet1 ,i1 #cbf2 ,,ii1 #aca4 ,nicolson1 ,w41 ,i1 #bja4 ,nieuw5tijt1 ,,ii1 #ccc4 ,nizzoli1 ,m41 ,,ii1 #bge4 ,non-,euclidean geometry1 ,,ii1 #hc4 ,nor?ampton1 ,m>quis ( 7#b;d71 ,,ii1 #ai4 ,novum ,organum ,moralium1 ,,ii1 #gd4 ,numb]1 ,my/]y (1 ,i1 #ee1 #ef1 #afi4 ,numb] ( ! ,bea/ 7#fff71 ,i1 #ee1 #acj1 #bgb1 #bih1 #ceb2 ,,ii1 #gg1 #aei1 #bag1 #bah1 #cfa1 #cgc4 ,num]al sy/em1 ,,ii1 #fh4 ,nurs]y rhymes1 ,,ii1 #aej4 ,occam1 ,wm4 (1 ,,ii1 #dj4 ,odg]s1 ,n41 ,,ii1 #aia1 #aia4 ,o9opides ( ,*ios1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,old5burgh1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #cjj1 #cjb4 ,or?odox ,p>adoxes1 ,,ii1 #cfc4 ,or?ography1 ,p>adoxes (1 ,,ii1 #bfg4 ,ortw9us1 ,i1 #cai4 ,oughtr$1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #bih1 #cjc4 ,ow5son1 ,i1 #aia4 ,ozanam1 ,i1 #afa1 #cab4 ,pagi1 ,i1 #cb4 ,pa9e1 ,t41 ,i1 #agc1 #agc1 #bga4 ,paley1 ,w41 ,i1 #bbb2 ,,ii1 #bbf4 ,palm]1 ,c41 ,i1 #bbe4 ,palm]1 ,h41 ,i1 #ada1 #ada1 #ade4 ,palm]1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bec4 ,palm]1 ,t4 ,f41 ,,ii1 #bed4 ,palm]1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #cg4 ,palm]/on1 ,visc\nt 7#c;d71 ,i1 #bij1 #ceb4 ,palmezeaux1 ,i1 #afg4 ,panizzi1 ,a41 ,i1 #aea4 ,papi/1 ,,ii1 #bf4 ,p>acelsus1 ,,ii1 #cbb4 ,p>adox def9$1 ,i1 #b1 #ca4 ,p>adox1 religi\s1 ,i1 #bcf4 ,p>adox]s 9 g5]al1 ,,ii1 #ceb4 ,p>allels1 ,!ory (1 ,i1 #bbi1 #cdd4 ,p>dies1 ,i4 ,g41 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,p>k1 ,mungo1 ,,ii1 #ia1 #acb4 ,p>k]1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #id4 ,p>k]1 ,g4 7,e>l ( ,macclesfield71 ,,ii1 #bif4 ,p>r1 ,s41 ,i1 #agc1 #agc1 #age1 #agf1 #ahd4 ,p>sey1 ,i1 #bic1 #bic4 ,p>tridge1 ,j41 ,i1 #cje4 ,pasb]gius1 ,i1 #cha4 ,pascal1 ,i1 #ci1 #aai1 #abb1 #bbj1 #bba2 ,,ii1 #gc4 ,pascal's ,hexagram1 ,i1 #bba4 ,passot1 ,i1 #bgi1 #bgi4 ,passov]1 ,i1 #ceh1 #cgb4 ,patriotic p>adox1 ,i1 #bca4 ,paucton1 ,i1 #agb4 ,paulian1 ,i1 #afe1 #afe4 ,peacock1 ,geo41 ,i1 #aif1 #cej4 ,peacock1 ,t4 ,l41 ,i1 #aij1 #cdj4 ,pe>ce1 ,a4 ,j41 ,,ii1 #dc4 ,pe>ne1 ,t41 ,i1 #bci4 ,peel1 ,sir ,r41 ,i1 #bij1 #ceb4 ,peel1 ,w4 ,y41 ,i1 #bij4 ,pel]91 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cbd4 ,pell1 ,j41 ,i1 #aje1 #aje1 #ajg2 ,,ii1 #cjj1 #cjb1 #cab4 ,pepys1 ,i1 #aac1 #aad4 ,p]igal1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #ai1 #bj4 #chd ,p]petual motion1 ,i1 #aah1 #cdh2 ,,ii1 #ee1 #ach4 ,p]spective1 ,new !ory (1 ,i1 #bic4 ,pet]s1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #aa1 #cae4 ,petition+ ,comet1 ,i1 #abg4 ,petrie1 ,w4 ,m4 ,f41 ,i1 #cbh4 ,petty1 ,i1 #aad2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,philale!s1 ,eir5aeus1 ,i1 #abe1 #abe1 #abf4 ,philale!s1 ,eug5ius1 ,i1 #bee4 ,phillips1 ,r41 ,i1 #bdb1 #bdb1 #bde4 ,philo ( ,gad>a1 ,i1 #dj1 #dj4 ,philosoph]'s /one1 ,i1 #aah1 #abe4 ,philosophical a!i/s1 ,,ii1 #a4 ,philosophy & ,religion1 ,,ii1 #cg4 ,phonetic spell+1 ,,ii1 #ha4 pi1 values (1 ,i1 #aa1 #dc1 #de1 #df1 #eb1 #fi1 #ajj1 #aaj1 #abi1 #ace1 #adf1 #bde1 #bhc1 #bhd1 #bid1 #cdg1 #cdh1 #cdi1 #cej2 ,,ii1 #fj1 #fc1 #aje1 #aaj1 #aah1 #ace1 #aef1 #bji1 #bgi1 #cae1 #caf4 ,pighius1 ,i1 #cgb4 ,pike1 ,s41 ,i1 #bcf1 #bcf4 ,p9d>1 ,p41 ,,ii1 #bgb4 ,piozzi1 ,mrs41 ,i1 #bce2 ,,ii1 #bgb4 ,piscator1 ,b41 ,,ii1 #be4 ,pitman1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #ha1 #ha4 ,place1 ,f41 ,i1 #aii4 ,planets inhabitable1 ,i1 #ajj1 #ajb4 ,plato1 ,i1 #e4 ,platt1 ,h41 ,i1 #abf1 #abf4 ,playfair1 ,j41 ,i1 #bcc4 ,ple?o1 ,g41 ,i1 #ahh4 ,pl9y1 ,,ii1 #bhj4 ,pl\cquet1 ,i1 #ccf1 #ccg4 ,poe1 ,e4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #acb4 ,po9c>e1 ,i1 #acf4 ,poisson1 ,i1 #bib2 ,,ii1 #b4 ,pollock1 ,j4 ,f41 ,,ii1 #agd4 ,pons1 ,,ii1 #de4 ,pope1 ,wm41 ,i1 #bgg1 #bgg4 ,porta1 ,i1 #fh1 #fh1 #hc4 ,porteus1 ,b41 ,i1 #aic1 #bjc4 ,porteus1 ,h4 ,f4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #aeg1 #aeg4 ,porus1 ,i1 #dd4 ,p[ell1 ,bad51 ,,ii1 #bfg4 ,p[ell1 ,w4 ,s41 ,i1 #bbb4 ,pratt1 ,h4 ,f4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #aeg1 #aeg4 ,pratt1 ,o41 ,,ii1 #fi4 ,pr$aval1 ,c\nt de1 ,i1 #cdh4 ,prescot1 ,b41 ,i1 #bgj1 #bgj1 #bgh4 ,pre/] ,john1 ,i1 #gj1 #ga1 #aeb4 ,price1 ,r41 ,i1 #bbc4 ,probability1 ,disc\rse on1 ,i1 #bgi4 ,proclus1 ,i1 #ahh1 #ahh4 ,prodigies1 ,y\?ful1 ,i1 #bai1 #ccb4 ,pronunciation1 ,,ii1 #ccj4 ,prote/ant & ,papal ,*ri/5dom1 ,,ii1 #cc4 ,protimale!s1 ,,ii1 #f4 ,ptolemy1 ,i1 #e1 #cc1 #chj4 ,pullic9o1 ,,ii1 #fa1 #fa4 ,pusey1 ,i1 #fd4 ,pyramids1 ,!1 ,i1 #cbh2 ,,ii1 #ie1 #acf4 ,py?agoras1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,quadrature problem4 7,see ,squ>+ ! circle47 ,qu>les1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #bgg4 ,qu9tilian1 ,,ii1 #bhj4 ,quotem1 ,c41 ,i1 #cii4 ,rabelais1 ,i1 #ajb4 ,ra9b[ ,p>adox1 ,,ii1 #ccd4 ,rama*&ra1 ,y41 ,i1 #cgd4 ,ram*undra1 ,i1 #cgd4 ,ramus1 ,i1 #e4 ,recalcati1 ,,ii1 #bjh1 #cad4 ,recorde1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #cbh4 ,r$die1 ,jas41 ,,ii1 #ahc1 #ahc1 #cdd1 #cfj4 ,reeve1 ,j41 ,i1 #cie4 ,regiomontanus1 ,i1 #dh1 #cfj4 ,reis*1 ,i1 #de2 ,,ii1 #bha4 ,religion & ,philosophy1 ,,ii1 #cg4 ,religi\s bodies1 ,names (1 ,,ii1 #bb2 --cu/oms1 ,attacks on1 ,i1 #agg2 --,insurance1 ,i1 #cde2 --,p>adox1 ,i1 #bcf2 --,tract society1 ,i1 #aib4 ,remigius1 ,i1 #ej4 ,reu*l91 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cbc4 ,revelations1 ,napi] on1 ,i1 #ff4 ,revilo1 7,o4 ,byrne71 ,i1 #bda1 #cbi1 #cbi4 ,reyneau1 ,c4 ,r41 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,rheticus1 ,i1 #fi2 ,,ii1 #cgb4 ,rhonius1 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,ribad5eira1 ,p4 de1 ,,ii1 #fb4 ,riccioli1 ,i1 #if4 ,ri*>ds1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #bgj4 ,rigaud1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bii4 ,rigaud1 ,s4 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bii4 ,rigaud1 ,s4 ,p41 ,i1 #adj2 ,,ii1 #bih1 #cac4 ,r+elb]gh1 ,j4 ,s41 ,,ii1 #bha4 ,ripley1 ,g41 ,i1 #abf1 #abf4 ,rit*ie1 ,w41 ,i1 #bie1 #bie4 ,ritt]husius1 ,i1 #fj4 ,rive1 ,j4-,j41 ,i1 #afj4 ,rob]tson1 ,jas41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,rob]val1 ,i1 #aje1 #abb4 #che ,rob9son1 ,b41 ,i1 #adh1 #adh4 ,rob9son1 ,h4 ,c41 ,i1 #cad2 ,,ii1 #eb1 #bge4 ,rob9son1 ,r41 ,i1 #agg4 ,rob9son1 ,t4 ,r41 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,robl91 ,j41 ,,ii1 #acf4 ,rog]s1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #bfj4 ,roget1 ,p4 ,m41 ,i1 #cih4 ,room51 ,a4 van1 ,i1 #aaj4 ,ross1 ,j4 ,c41 ,i1 #cjc4 ,rosse1 ,i1 #bf4 ,rossi1 ,g41 ,i1 #bca1 #bca4 ,rotation ( ! ,moon1 ,,ii1 #d1 #ai4 ,r\gh1 ,w41 ,i1 #aih4 ,r[n+1 ,j41 ,i1 #aee4 ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society1 ,i1 #bg2 --,=]unn] (1 ,i1 #cgd4 ,royal ,society1 ,i1 #ba1 #bb1 #bd-cj1 #ef1 #eg1 #acf1 #aec1 #afc1 #afd1 #afe4 ,rudio1 ,i1 #aei2 ,,ii1 #cfg4 ,rudolff1 ,c41 ,,ii1 #cgc4 ,russell1 ,e>l 7#a/71 ,i1 #bif4 ,ru!r=d1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #aji4 ,sabati]1 ,a41 ,,ii1 #bfg4 ,sabellius1 ,i1 #bda4 ,sacrobosco1 ,i1 #cfj4 ,sadl]1 ,t41 ,i1 #bch1 #bda4 ,sa9t-,m>t91 ,i1 #afg1 #afh1 #bjf4 ,/4-,mesm91 ,m4 de41 ,i1 #bhj4 ,/4 ,v9c5t1 ,g4 de41 ,i1 #aaj1 #aag4 ,/4 ,vitus1 ,patron ( ,cyclomet]s1 ,,ii1 #fj4 ,sales1 de1 ,i1 #afg4 ,salicetus1 ,i1 #fd4 ,salisbury1 ,e>l ( 7#a/71 ,,ii1 #ccj4 ,salmasius1 ,claudius1 ,,ii1 #afh4 ,salusbury1 ,he/]1 ,i1 #bce4 ,san*ez1 ,petro1 ,i1 #bbi1 #bbi4 ,s&]s1 ,w41 ,i1 #bjg4 ,s&]son1 ,r41 ,i1 #ace4 ,s>a1 ,r41 ,i1 #big4 ,saund]son1 ,n41 ,i1 #cgg2 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,scalig]1 ,i1 #dd1 #aaj1 #aaa1 #aab1 #aac2 ,,ii1 #bch4 ,scevole de ,/4 ,m>!1 ,i1 #aac4 ,s*oot51 ,van1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,s*opp1 ,i1 #fj4 ,s*ott1 ,i1 #fd2 ,,ii1 #fd4 ,s*uma*]1 ,h4 ,c41 ,i1 #ajg2 ,,ii1 #big4 ,s*wab1 ,i1 #bcj4 ,sci5tific p>adoxes1 ,i1 #bcb4 ,scott1 ,mi*ael1 ,i1 #ch4 ,scott's ,devils1 ,i1 #ch4 ,scott1 ,w41 ,i1 #bj1 #bg1 #ch1 #ci1 #aee1 #aia4 ,scripture & ,sci5ce1 ,,ii1 #bfa4 ,se>*1 ,john1 ,i1 #bdg4 ,seld51 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bej4 ,s5>mont1 ,,ii1 #dh4 ,s]res1 ,de1 ,,ii1 #fj4 ,%aftesbury1 ,e>l (1 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,%akespe>e1 ,i1 #ac4 ,%anks1 ,,ii1 #fc1 #fe1 #aji4 ,%aw1 ,p41 ,i1 #adb4 ,%eep%anks1 ,j41 ,i1 #adg4 ,%eep%anks1 ,r41 ,i1 #bij4 ,%elley1 ,i1 #agd4 ,%eph]d1 ,s41 ,i1 #abd4 ,%]burne1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #bie4 ,%]idan1 ,r4 ,b41 ,i1 #age4 ,%]idan1 ,t41 ,i1 #age4 ,%ob]l1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #bgj4 ,%rewsbury1 ,i1 #ajh4 ,siddons1 ,mrs41 ,i1 #ahi4 ,simms1 ,w41 ,i1 #aeb4 ,simplicius1 ,,ii1 #afd4 ,simpson1 ,t41 ,i1 #cgg2 ,,ii1 #cjd4 ,simson1 ,r41 ,i1 #aig1 #bjb1 #bcc4 ,s9clair1 ,g41 ,i1 #bjg4 ,sl&] ,p>adoxes1 ,,ii1 #ach4 ,sloane1 ,i1 #bd4 ,sluse1 ,r4 de1 ,i1 #aah1 #aah2 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,smi?1 ,adam1 ,,ii1 #aab4 ,smi?1 ,jas41 ,i1 #df2 ,,ii1 #ajc1 #ajc1 #aed1 #bcf1 #bcg1 #bch1 #bda1 #ccf1 #cfj4 ,smi?1 ,jas41 ,,ii1 #bag4 ,smi?1 ,jas4 7,%eph]d71 ,,ii1 #ee1 #aic4 ,smi?1 ,joseph1 ,,ii1 #fi4 ,smi?1 ,ri*>da1 ,i1 #bdb4 ,smi?1 ,?omas1 ,i1 #cdf1 #cdf4 ,smi?1 ,wm41 ,,ii1 #aeb4 ,smy?1 ,c4 ,p41 ,i1 #cbh2 ,,ii1 #fe4 ,snell1 ,i1 #ge1 #ge4 ,soc9ianism1 ,i1 #adb1 #adc4 ,soc9us1 ,i1 #c1 #adc4 ,socrates ,s*ola/icus1 ,i1 #ceh4 ,sohncke1 ,l4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #aca4 ,som]ville1 ,mrs41 ,i1 #bdb4 ,s\?1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,s\?cott1 ,joanna1 ,,ii1 #eh1 #ig1 #bci4 ,spe>man1 ,r41 ,i1 #bcg4 ,speculative ?\ght 9 ,engl&1 ,i1 #cgd4 ,sp$d+1 ,i1 #gf1 #hb1 #adb4 ,spe$1 ,j41 ,i1 #bja4 ,speke1 ,i1 #gj4 ,spell+1 phonetic1 ,,ii1 #ha4 ,sp5ce1 ,w41 ,i1 #bca1 #bca4 ,sp5c]1 ,e>l 7#c;d71 ,,ii1 #i4 #chf ,sp9oza1 ,i1 #c1 #cg4 ,spiritualism1 ,,ii1 #dg1 #ee1 #bjg4 ,spurius ,cassius ,viscell9us1 ,,ii1 #cdb4 ,spurius ,maelius1 ,,ii1 #cdb4 ,squ>+ ! circle1 ,i1 #h1 #db1 #dd1 #df1 #dg1 #ej1 #eb1 #ec1 #fi1 #gj1 #ge1 #aji1 #aag1 #aai1 #abi1 #ace1 #adf1 #adi1 #aei1 #afc1 #afd1 #cdg1 #cdh1 #cgd2 ,,ii1 #aj1 #aa1 #fj1 #aje1 #aed1 #aef1 #bjh1 #bgh1 #cad4 ,/aeckel1 ,i1 #bcj4 ,/anhope1 ,p4 ,d41 7,e>l ( ,*e/]field71 ,,ii1 #bih4 ,/apul5sis1 ,i1 #dd2 ,,ii1 #cbd4 ,/> polygons1 ,i1 #bbi4 ,/>kie1 ,g41 ,i1 #abf1 #abf4 ,/att]1 ,d41 ,,ii1 #hj4 ,/eam%ip sugge/$1 ,i1 #adg4 ,/eel1 ,jas41 ,,ii1 #fh4 ,/5ography1 ,,ii1 #ha4 ,/eph5s1 ,i1 #dd2 ,,ii1 #cbd4 ,/eph5son1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #ach4 ,/eph5son1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #ach4 ,/ev91 ,i1 #hc1 #cac2 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,/ew>t1 ,d41 ,,ii1 #ec4 ,/ew>t1 ,r41 ,i1 #ahf4 ,/ifel1 ,m41 ,,ii1 #cgc4 ,/raf=d1 ,e>l (1 ,i1 #bdj4 ,/rat=d1 ,w4 ,s41 ,i1 #cjj4 ,/reet1 ,t41 ,i1 #abd4 ,/ukely1 ,w41 ,i1 #bcf4 ,suffield1 ,g41 ,,ii1 #ff4 ,suidas1 ,,ii1 #bi4 ,sumn]1 ,c4 ,r41 ,i1 #cbd4 ,sumn]1 ,j4 ,b41 ,i1 #cbd4 ,sun z an electric space1 ,,ii1 #da4 ,sup]natural1 ,!1 ,,ii1 #aic4 ,suv>(f1 ,,ii1 #he4 ,swa/ika1 ,,ii1 #bca4 ,sw$5borg1 ,e41 ,i1 #bee4 ,swift1 ,i1 #ai1 #acc4 ,sylve/]1 ,j4 ,j41 ,,ii1 #ccf4 ,sym+ton1 ,w41 ,i1 #adh4 ,symons1 ,,ii1 #d1 #e1 #bj1 #hd1 #he4 ,sympa!tic p[d]1 ,i1 #ajh4 ,synesius1 ,i1 #abe4 ,talbot1 ,g41 ,i1 #bb1 #ajh4 ,talbot's p[d]1 ,i1 #ajh4 ,t>taglia1 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,tasse1 ,i1 #ajf4 ,tate1 ,j41 ,i1 #aii4 ,taul]1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #cbb4 ,taylor1 ,brook1 ,,ii1 #cja4 ,taylor1 ,john1 ,i1 #ceb2 ,,ii1 #ie4 ,taylor1 ,robt41 ,i1 #bgj4 ,taylor1 ,t41 ,i1 #ahh1 #ahh4 ,teissi]1 ,i1 #aac4 ,temple1 ,h4 ,j41 ,i1 #bij4 ,t5t]d51 ,*ief ,ju/ice1 ,i1 #aha4 ,?ales1 ,,ii1 #ei1 #hc4 ,!ism indep5d5t ( ,revelation1 ,i1 #cii4 ,!lwall1 ,j41 ,i1 #agh4 ,!odoretus1 ,i1 #ceh4 ,!ological ,p>adoxes1 ,i1 #caf4 ,!ology1 ,ma!matical1 ,i1 #abi1 #adi4 ,!ophra/us1 ,,ii1 #afg4 ,?iebault1 ,,ii1 #c1 #cch4 ,?om1 ,d41 ,,ii1 #bbf1 #bdj4 ,?om1 ,j4 ,h41 ,,ii1 #bbf4 ,?ompson1 ,p41 ,i1 #g4 ,?ompson1 ,t4 ,p41 ,i1 #beb1 #bhg1 #cdd2 ,,ii1 #hc1 #ahe4 ,?omson1 ,dr41 ,i1 #ba4 ,?omson1 ,w41 ,i1 #cbe4 ,?orn1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #aeh1 #aeh1 #cfj4 ,?orndike1 ,h41 ,,ii1 #cac4 ,?rale1 ,mrs41 ,i1 #bce4 ,?url[1 ,b>on1 ,i1 #bbb4 ,?yraeus1 ,i1 #ej4 ,tides1 ,new !ory (1 ,i1 #cic4 ,tomb/ones ( ma!maticians1 ,i1 #ajf4 ,tonal ,sy/em1 ,,ii1 #ahb4 ,tooke1 ,h41 ,i1 #agh4 ,torriano1 ,e41 ,i1 #bej4 ,t[neley1 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,t[nley1 ,c41 ,,ii1 #cjj4 ,trisection problem1 ,i1 #aah2 ,,ii1 #aj1 #ab1 #ac1 #ae4 ,tr\ghton1 ,i1 #aeb4 ,turnor1 ,e41 ,i1 #acg4 ,ty*o ,brahe1 ,i1 #e1 #gf1 #cha2 ,,ii1 #cjb1 #cce4 ,upton1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #ab1 #ab1 #ae4 ,ursus1 ,i1 #eb4 ,val5t9e1 ,b41 ,i1 #abe1 #abe4 ,van ,ceul51 ,i1 #eb1 #gj1 #ajj4 ,van de ,wey]1 ,i1 #cac4 ,van ,ett51 ,i1 #afa4 ,van ,helmont1 ,i1 #abe1 #abe4 ,van ,room51 ,i1 #aaj4 ,van ,s*oot51 ,,ii1 #ei4 ,vaughan1 ,t41 ,i1 #bee4 ,victor9us1 ,i1 #cei4 ,viete1 ,i1 #ea2 ,,ii1 #baj1 #bie4 ,virgil1 ,/41 ,i1 #cb1 #cc1 #cd1 #ii4 #chg ,virg9ia1 ,univ]sity (1 ,i1 #bcc4 ,viscell9us1 ,,ii1 #cdb4 ,vitruvius1 ,,ii1 #bha4 ,vivian1 ,t41 ,i1 #agb1 #agb4 ,vogel1 ,a4 ,f41 ,i1 #cgc4 ,voltaire1 ,i1 #ajc1 #afe1 #aff1 #afg1 #afh1 #bdh2 ,,ii1 #bfh4 ,von ,gumpa*1 ,,ii1 #acg1 #acg4 ,von ,hutt51 ,i1 #cah4 ,von ,wolzog54 7,see ,wolzog547 ,vyse1 ,r4 ,w4 ,h41 ,i1 #cbh4 ,walk]1 ,w4 ,e41 ,,ii1 #caf4 ,walk+ame1 ,f41 ,,ii1 #agc4 ,walli*1 ,n41 ,,ii1 #ad4 ,wallis1 ,j41 ,i1 #ajg1 #aji1 #aaj2 ,,ii1 #bii1 #cac4 ,walpole1 ,i1 #bc1 #aca4 ,wal%1 ,john1 ,i1 #bfj1 #bfj2 ,,ii1 #aeg4 ,wap%>e1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bcj4 ,w>burton1 ,h41 ,i1 #cdi4 ,w>burton1 ,wm41 ,i1 #ee1 #aab2 ,,ii1 #agd4 ,w>d1 ,s41 ,,ii1 #bii4 ,w>+1 ,e41 ,i1 #bjc1 #bbb4 ,w>n]1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #cjb1 #cab4 ,w>r51 ,s41 ,,ii1 #cdj4 ,watk9s1 ,j41 ,,ii1 #bgj4 ,watson1 ,bp41 ,i1 #bbc4 ,watt1 ,r41 ,i1 #ajb1 #djb4 ,watts1 ,i41 ,,ii1 #ah4 ,w$dle1 ,t41 ,,ii1 #ahg4 ,w5twor?1 ,?os41 ,i1 #bdj4 ,:>ton1 ,i1 #aae4 ,:ately1 ,r41 ,i1 #bdf1 #bdf1 #cbd4 ,:ately's ,p>adox1 ,i1 #bdf4 ,:ewell1 ,i1 #aja1 #aja1 #bgc1 #cad1 #chj2 ,,ii1 #ajd1 #bdf1 #bdg4 ,:igs1 ,,ii1 #bb4 ,:i/on1 ,j41 ,i1 #adg4 ,:i/on1 ,w41 ,i1 #acc1 #acc1 #adf1 #aef1 #caa4 ,:ite1 ,h4 ,k41 ,,ii1 #bga4 ,:ite1 ,j4 ,b41 ,i1 #bdh4 ,:ite1 ,r41 ,i1 #aa4 ,:it=d1 ,i1 #aje4 ,:itwor?1 ,w4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cdd4 ,:izgig1 ,on !1 ,i1 #bed4 ,wightman1 ,i1 #ei4 ,wilb]=ce1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #bcf4 ,wilk9s1 ,j41 ,i1 #if1 #ajj1 #aaf1 #bbf4 ,williams1 ,j4 ,b41 ,i1 #cgh4 ,williams1 ,t41 ,i1 #aga1 #aga4 ,wilson1 ,sir ,j41 ,i1 #bba4 ,wilson1 ,j4 ,m41 ,,ii1 #cdd4 ,wilson1 ,r41 ,,ii1 #g1 #g4 ,wilson's ,!orem1 ,i1 #bbb4 ,w+ate1 ,e41 ,,ii1 #cjh4 ,w9t]1 ,i1 #df4 ,wirgman1 ,t41 ,i1 #beh1 #beh4 ,wiseman1 ,n4 ,p4 ,s41 ,,ii1 #bf1 #fa1 #bid4 ,wolcot1 ,j4 7,pet] ,p9d>71 ,,ii1 #bgb4 ,woll/onecraft1 ,i1 #agc1 #agc4 ,wolzog51 ,i1 #ajf4 ,wood1 ,a41 ,i1 #ih4 ,wood1 ,john1 ,i1 #bcc4 ,wood1 ,wm41 ,i1 #bdf1 #bdf4 ,woodley1 ,w41 ,i1 #cjg1 #cjg4 ,wordswor?1 ,,ii1 #bgc4 ,wright1 ,e41 ,i1 #hd4 ,wright1 ,t41 ,i1 #aea1 #aea1 #aeb1 #aec4 ,wright1 ,w41 ,,ii1 #i4 ,wronski1 ,i1 #bdi1 #bej4 ,wrottesley1 ,j4 7,b>on71 ,,ii1 #aha4 ,"y1 ,b41 ,,ii1 #fi4 ,"y1 ,j4 ,w4 ,a41 ,,ii1 #cfg4 ,"y1 ,t41 ,i1 #bd1 #cj1 #bej4 ,y\?ful ,prodigies1 ,i1 #bai4 ,yvon1 ,i1 #big4 ,za*1 von1 ,,ii1 #de1 #aif4 ,za*>y1 ,pope1 ,i1 #cb1 #cd4 ,zadkiel1 ,i1 #cba2 ,,ii1 #dc4 ,zetetic ,a/ronomy1 ,,ii1 #hh4 ,zodiac1 ,,ii1 #acf4 ,zytph51 ,,ii1 #cce4 99 99 99 99 99 ,notes ,transcrib]'s note3 ,ref]5ces to ,notes 9 ,volume ,i are %[n z 9 ! pr9t$ book1 ) ! resequ5c$ footnote numb]s 9 ! ,project ,gut5b]g ,edition 7,e,text-,no4 #bcajj7 add$ ?us #abc4 #a ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bee1 note #f #ehd4 #b ,i h no ne$ = ?is hypo!sis4 #c ,ah1 x is a beautiful hypo!sis2 x expla9s _m ?+s4 #d ,:at we "k is v slight2 :at we don't "k is imm5se4 #e ,brew/] relates 7,life ( ,sir ,isaac ,newton1 ,vol4 ,,ii1 p4 #djg7 t1 a %ort "t be=e 8 dea?1 ,newton rem>k$3 ,i d n "k :at ,i may appe> to ! _w1 b to myself ,i seem to h be5 only l a boy play+ on ! sea%ore1 & div]t+ myself 9 n[ & !n f9d+ a smoo!r pebble or a pretti] %ell ?an ord9>y1 :il/ ! great ocean ( tru? lay all undiscov]$ be=e me4 #f ,see ,vol4 ,i1 p4 #bib1 note #a #fcb4 #g ,:at is all t6 #h ,i h "s good news to tell y3 at ! ,bureau ( ,longitudes !y h j receiv$ a lett] f ,g]many ann\nc+ t ,m4 ,bessel has v]ifi$ by obs]vation y\r !oretical discov]ies on ! satellites ( ,jupit]4 #i ,man foll[s only phantoms4 #aj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #chb1 note #ac #ghf4 #aa ,dieudonne ,?iebault 7#agcc-ahjg7 0 a ,jesuit 9 8 e>ly life1 b he left ! ord] & took up ! /udy ( law4 ,9 #agfe he w5t to ,prussia & became a favorite ( ,fr$]ick ! ,great4 ,he return$ to ,france 9 #aghe & became head ( ! ,lycee at ,v]sailles4 #ab ,memories ( ,tw5ty ,ye>s ( ,resid5ce 9 ,b]l94 ,!re 0 a second ,fr5* & an ,engli% edition 9 #ahje4 #ac ,ri*>d ,joa*im ,he9ri* von ,moll5dorff 7#agbd-ahaf7 began 8 c>e] z a page ( ,fr$]ick ! ,great 7#agdj7 & became field m>%al 7#agic7 & comm&] ( ! ,prussian army on ! ,rh9e 7#agid74 #ad ,hugues ,b]n>d ,m>et 7#agfc-ahci7 0 n ,duc de ,bassano 9 #ahjg1 ?is title n be+ conf]r$ ^u him until #ahji4 ,he 0 ambassador to ,engl& 9 #agib & to ,naples 9 #agic4 ,napoleon made him head ( ! cab9et & 8 special confidant4 ,! ,b\rbons exil$ him 9 #ahaf4 #ae ,d5is ,did]ot 7#agac-aghd71 ^: ,lettre sur les aveugles 7#agdi7 introduc$ him to ! _w z a philosoph]1 & ^: "w on ! ,encyclop$ie is s well kn[n4 #af ,sir1 7a bn7 _/ n x1 :5ce ,god exi/s2 answ]6 #ag ,?is 0 "o ,james ,laurie ( ,musselburgh4 #ah ,jel+] ,cookson ,symons 7#ahji-ahfj7 0 an (fice-hold] ) a decid$ lean+ t[>ds ! improvem5t ( education & social conditions4 ,he wrote ,a ,plea = ,s*ools 7#ahdg71 ,! ,indu/rial ,capacities ( ,s\? ,wales 7#ahee71 & ,lun> ,motion 7#ahef71 to :i* la/ "w ! critic probably ref]s4 #ai ,protimale!s foll[$ ?is by ano!r "w along ! same l9e ! foll[+ ye>1 ,! ,indep5d5ce ( ! ,te/imony ( ,/4 ,mat!w & ,/4 ,john te/$ & v9dicat$ by ! !ory ( *ances4 #bj ,wilson _h already tak5 up ! lance aga9/ sci5ce 9 8 ,/rictures on ,geology & ,a/ronomy1 9 ref]5ce to a suppos$ want ( h>mony betwe5 ^! sci5ces & "s p>ts ( ,div9e ,revelation1 ,glasg[1 #ahdc4 ,he _h also v5tur$ ^u poetry 9 8 ,pleasures ( ,piety1 ,glasg[1 #ahcg4 #ba ,mrs4 ,borron 0 ,elizabe? ,willes=d ,mills be=e h] m>riage4 ,%e made an attempt at lit]ature 9 h] ,sibyl's ,leaves1 ,london 7pr9t$ at ,devonport71 #ahbf4 #bb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #chf1 note #aj #hja4 #bc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 notes #g #cb & #h #cc4 #bd ,8 fly+ ma*9e1 design$ 9 #ahdc1 0 "o ( ! e>lie/ attempts at aviation on any ext5sive scale4 #be ,erasmus ,d>w9 7#agca-ahjb7 0 ! gr&fa!r ( ,*>les ,d>w94 ,! "w "h m5tion$ _h great influ5ce1 be+ translat$ into ,fr5*1 ,portuguese1 & ,italian4 ,cann+ p>odi$ x 9 8 ,loves ( ! ,triangles4 #bf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #adg1 note #a #cab4 #bg ,! notes on ?is page 7 writt5 on ! day ( ! fun]al ( ,wilbur ,wright1 ,june #a1 #aiab1 ! man :o realiz$ all ( ^! prophecies1 & !n di$ a victim ( municipal crime1--( typhoid fev]4 #bh ,john ,*>les1 ?ird ,e>l ,sp5c] 7#aghb-ahde71 to ^: ef=ts ! ,re=m ,bill 0 greatly indebt$ = its f9al success4 #bi ,?is 0 publi%$ 9 ,london 9 #ahea in/ead ( #ahdh4 #cj ,?is appe>$ 9 #ahdf4 #ca ,?is 0 done 9 ,! ,circle ,squ>$1 publi%$ at ,brighton 9 #ahfe4 #cb ,x fir/ appe>$ 9 #ahdg1 "u ! title1 ,! ,scriptural ,cal5d> & ,*ronological ,re=m]1 #ahdh4 ,includ+ a review ( tracts by ,dr4 ,w>dlaw & o!rs on ! ,sabba? "q4 ,by ,w4 ,h4 ,black4 ,! "o above m5tion$1 = #ahdi1 0 pr9t$ 9 #ahdh1 & 0 also by ,black 7#ahjh-ahgb74 ,he 0 pa/or ( ! ,sev5? ,day ,bapti/s & 0 int]e/$ 9 ar*eology & 9 books4 ,he catalogu$ ! manuscripts ( ! ,a%molean ,museum at ,ox=d4 #cc ,william ,upton1 a ,tr9ity ,college man1 ,dubl94 ,he also wrote ,upton's ,physioglyphics1 ,london1 #ahdd2 ,p>s prima4 ,geometria v9dicata2 antiquorumque ,problematum1 ad hoc tempus desp]atorum1 ,trisectionis ,anguli1 ,circulique ,quadraturae1 ,solutio1 p] ,euclid5 effecta1 ,london 7pr9t$ at ,s\?ampton71 #ahdg2 ,! ,uptonian ,trisection1 ,london1 #ahff2 & ,! ,circle ,squ>$1 ,london1 #ahgb4 #cd ,= example1 if !ta #ij deg4 we %\ld h #c cos #cj deg4 #a root7#d - s9#b #ij deg471 or #c4 #a_/b root#c #a root#c1 or #a_/b root#c #a4 #ce ,na?aniel ,walli* 7#aghf-ahed7 0 surgeon at ! ,dani% settlem5t at ,s]ampore :5 ! ,ea/ ,india ,company took ov] ! control 9 #ahjg4 ,he ent]$ ! ,briti% m$ical s]vice & 0 invalid$ to ,engl& 9 #ahbh4 ,8 ,plantae ,asiaticae ,r>iores 7#c vols41 ,london1 #ahcj-ahcb7 0 recogniz$ z a /&>d4 ,he became vice-presid5t ( ! ,l9nean ,society1 ,f4 ,r4 ,s41 & fell[ ( ! ,royal ,asiatic ,society4 #cf ,b if !ta #ij deg4 ?is ass]ts t cos #cj deg4 7s9 #bgj deg4 4 cos #bbe deg4 s9#b #ij deg4 4 s9 #bbe deg47 _/ root7s9#b #bgj deg4 4 cos#b #bbe deg4 s9#d #ij deg4 s9 #bgj deg4 4 s9 #dej deg4 4 s9#b #ij deg471 or t #a_/b root#c 7-#a 4 7-#a _/root#b7 #a 4 7-#a_/root#b7 _/ root#a 4 #a_/b #a - #a 4 #a 4 #a7 #j _/ root7#a_/b71 s t ,de ,morgan mu/ h made "s error 9 copy+4 #cg ,john ,bonnyca/le 7di$ 9 #ahba7 0 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,woolwi*4 ,8 edition ( ,bossut's ,hi/ory ( ,ma!matics 7#ahjc71 & 8 works on elem5t>y ma!matics 7 well kn[n4 #ch ,! bibliographies give ,husa9 ,rifki z ! translator1 a practical geometry z ! "w1 & #ahjb z ! date4 #ci ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cji1 note #b #fgj4 #dj ,probably 9 ,! ,improvem5t ( ! ,m9d :i* ,isaac ,watts 7#afgd-agdh7 publi%$ 9 #agda4 ,8 ,horae ,lyricae appe>$ 9 #agjf1 & ! ,hymns1 by :i* he is /ill well kn[n1 9 #agjg4 #da ,sp5c] ,jo%ua ,alwyne ,compton1 second ,m>quis ( ,nor?ampton 7#agij-ahea71 0 a poet1 a sci5ti/1 & a /atesman4 ,he 0 presid5t ( ! ,royal ,society f #ahch to #ahdi4 #db ,besides ! writ+s "h m5tion$ ,p]igal publi%$ a "w on ,geometric ,maps 7,london1 #ahec71 & ,graphic ,demon/rations ( ,geometric ,problems 7#ahia74 #dc ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #e1 note #ah4 #dd ,james ,f]guson 7#agaj-aggf7 0 a portrait pa9t]1 an a/ronom]1 & a popul> writ] & lectur] on v>i\s subjects4 #de ,9 ! old ballad ( ,k+ ,alfr$ & ! ,%eph]d1 :5 ! latt] is tempt+ ! disguis$ k+ into 8 s]vice1 he says3 ,( :ig & :ey we h good /ore1 ,& keep good pease-/raw fire4 ,:ig is !n a prep>ation ( milk4 ,b ano!r commonly cit$ d]ivation may be suspect$ f ! ^w :iggamor be+ us$ be=e :ig1 z appli$ to ! political p>ty2 :ig may be a contraction4 ,p]haps bo? d]ivations conspir$3 ! ^w :iggamor1 said to be a ^w ( comm& to ! horses1 might contract into :ig1 & ! contraction might be welcom$ = its own native mean+4--,a4 ,de ,m4 #df ,?is 0 p4 #adg 9 ! fir/ edition4 #dg ,/4 ,augu/9e 7#ced-dcj7 0 bi%op ( ,hippo4 ,8 ,confessiones1 9 #ac books1 0 writt5 9 #cig1 & 8 ,de ,civitate ,dei 9 #dbf4 #dh ,he 0 wont to indulge 9 c]ta9 ,punic subtleties le/ he %\ld we>y ! read] by mu* speak+4 #di ,john ,miln] 7#agea-ahbf71 bi%op ( ,ca/abala1 a well-kn[n antiqu>ian4 #ej ,x w be said t :5 ! f9al happ9ess is spok5 ( 9 sure & c]ta9 hope1 x is ! ,resurrection1 g5]ally2 b :5 aft]w>ds application is made to ! individual1 simple hope is all t is pr$icat$ :i* m]ely means wi%8 ,i "k x3 b j be=e ! g5]al decl>ation1 x is decl>$ t x has pleas$ ,god ( 8 great m]cy to take unto ,himself1 ! s\l ( our de> bro!r3 & betwe5 ! hopes he>ty ?anks are giv5 t x has pleas$ ,god to deliv] our de> bro!r out ( ! mis]ies ( ?is wick$ _w1 ) an additional pray] t ! numb] ( ! elect may %ortly be accompli%$4 ,all :i* means1 t our de> bro!r is decl>$ to be tak5 to ,god1 to be 9 a place n s mis]able z ?is _w--a description :i* excludes ! wick$ place--& to be ( ! elect4 ,yes1 b x w be said aga96 d y n "k t :5 ?is ,liturgy 0 fram$1 all :o 7 n 9 ! road to ,heav5 7 excommunicat$ burial s]vice read ov] !m4 ,suppos+ ! fact to h be5 true 9 old "t1 :i* is a v spicy supposition1 h[ does t excuse ! pres5t practice8 ,h y a "r always to say :at y believe _c always be true1 because y ?9k x 0 once always true8 ,yes1 b1 *oose :om y please1 y _c be c]ta9 ,he is n gone to ,heav54 ,true1 & *oose :i* ,bi%op y please1 y _c be demon/ratively c]ta91 he is n a conceal$ unbeliev]3 may ,i !re=e say ( ! :ole b5*1 s+ulatim et s]iatim1 t !y are unbeliev]s8 ,no6 ,no6 ,! voice ( common s5se1 ( :i* common logic is a "p1 is sl[ly op5+ ! eyes ( ! multitude to ! unpr9cipl$ reason+ ( !ologians4 ,rememb] #ahai4 ,:at *ance _h ,p>liam5t>y ,re=m :5 ! ,h\se ( ,commons ?ank$ ! ,man*e/] sabre-m58 ,if y d n re=m y\r ,liturgy1 x w be re=m$ = y1 & soon] ?an y ?9k6 ,! di%one/ int]pretations1 by def5ce ( :i* ev5 ! m9ds ( *ildr5 are corrupt$1 & :i* ?r[ _! %oots into lit]ature & comm]ce1 w be s5t to ! place :5ce !y came3 & ov] ! door ( ! e/abli%$ organization = tea*+ religion w be po/$ ! foll[+ notice3 ,%ift & ,subt]fuge1 ,%uffle & ,dodge1 ,no long] "h all[$ to lodge6 ,all ?is ought to be writt5 by "s "o :o belongs to ! ,e/abli%m5t3 9 him1 x w\ld be q prud5t & prop]2 9 me1 x is k9d & *>itable4--,a4 ,de ,m4 #ea ,b few d h access to x1 = ! "w is n at all common1 & ?is ,piscator is r>ely m5tion$4 #eb ,?is d]ivation has be5 omitt$4--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 #ec ,a bl[ = a bl[4 ,rol& & ,oliv] 7 two ( ! palad9s ( ,*>lemagne ^: exploits 7 s alike t ea* 0 con/antly receiv+ cr$it = :at ! o!r did4 ,f9ally !y met & f\ght = five days on an isl& 9 ! ,rh9e1 b ev5 at ! end ( t p]iod x 0 m]ely a drawn battle4 #ed ,9 ! "n ( ! *ur*4 #ee ,f ! *air1 (ficially4 #ef ,ni*olas ,patrick ,/eph5 ,wiseman 7#ahjb-ahfe71 ^: elevation to ! ar*bi%opric ( ,we/m9/] & ! c>d9alate 7#ahej7 l$ to ! act prohibit+ ,roman ,ca?olics f assum+ episcopal titles 9 ,engl&1 a law t 0 nev] en=c$4 #eg ,he 0 born 9 #ahab & 0 conv]t$ to ,ca?olicism 9 #ahci4 ,he f\nd$ ! ,tablet 9 ,london 9 #ahdj1 remov+ its (fice to ,dubl9 9 #ahdi4 ,he became ,m4 ,p4 9 #aheb1 & at ! "t ( 8 dea? 7#ahee7 he 0 prep>+ a memorial to ! ,pope ask+ him to annul ! proclamation ( an ,iri% bi%op prohibit+ 8 prie/s f tak+ "p 9 politics4 #eh ,john ,guillim 7#aefe-afba7 0 ! fir/ to sy/ematize & illu/rate ! :ole sci5ce ( h]aldry4 ,he publi%$ ,a display ( ,h]aldrie3 manife/+ a m easie accesse to ! k !re( 9 #afaj4 #ei ,fai?4 #fj ,fai?ful4 #fa ,= ! fai? v9dicat$4 #fb ,! words are ( ! same root1 & h5ce our ^w fiddle4 ,"s suppose ?is root means a rope1 :i*1 z t to :i* y tru/1 becomes1 9 "o div]g5ce1 confid5ce itself--j z a rock1 & o!r words1 come to mean reliance--& 9 ano!r1 a little /r+4--,a4 ,de ,m4 #fc ,! ,greek lexicograph]1 a ,*ri/ian1 liv+ aft] #ajjj ,a4 ,d4 ,8 lexicon 0 fir/ pr9t$ at ,milan 9 #adii4 #fd ,sk9dapsos4 #fe ,?is 0 ,john ,william ,burgon 7#ahac-ahhh71 ,gre%am pr(essor ( !ology 7#ahfg7 & dean ( ,*i*e/]4 ,he 0 an ultra-cons]vative1 oppos+ ! revis$ v]sion ( ! ,new ,te/am5t1 & say+ ( ! admission ( wom5 to ! univ]sity exam9ations t x 0 a ?+ inexp$i5t & immode/4 #ff ,ekklesia1 or ecclesia4 #fg ,ennomos ekklesia4 #fh ,)\t d\bt ,i %all p]i% =ev]4 #fi ,e man is an animal4 ,sortes is a man4 ,sortes is an animal4 #gj ,= a special purpose4 #ga ,h]aclitus ( ,ephesus1 ! weep+ philosoph]1 #f? c5tury ,b4 ,c4 #gb ,democritus1 ! laugh+ philosoph]1 f\nd] ( ! atomi/ic !ory1 #e? c5tury ,b4 ,c4 #gc ,ends to :i*4 #gd ,ends f :i*4 #ge ,9 j z _m syllables1 ,) j z _m lett]s1 ,9 j z _m words4 #gf ,i %all make a way1 ,i %all f9d a way4 #gg ,! notion t ! ,evil ,_s is a function>y liable to be dismiss$ = n att5d+ to 8 duty1 is1 s f> z my read+ goes1 utt]ly unkn[n 9 !ology4 ,my fir/ wr9kle on ! subject 0 ! rem>k ( ! ,som]set%ire f>m] ^u ,palm] ! poison]-- ,well6 if ! ,devil don't take he1 he didn't ought to be all[$ to be devil no long]4--,a4 ,de ,m4 ,william ,palm] 7#ahbd-ahef7 0 a memb] ( ! ,royal ,college ( ,surgeons & practis$ m$ic9e at ,london4 ,he 0 hang$ 9 #ahef = hav+ poison$ a fri5d & 0 also suspect$ ( hav+ poison$ 8 wife & bro!r = _! insurance money1 besides be+ guilty ( num]\s o!r murd]s4 ,8 trial 0 v mu* 9 ! public att5tion at ! "t4 #gh ,advantages & dang]s4 #gi ,! old priory ( ,/4 ,m>y ( ,be?lehem 9 ,london1 0 us$ z an asylum = ! insane4 ,! "n 0 corrupt$ to ,b$lam4 #hj ,ref]r+ to ! common ,engli% pronunciation ( ,/4 ,john1 almo/ ,s9j94 ,john ,/4 ,john ,long 7#agih-ahcd71 an ,iri%man by bir?1 practis$ m$ic9e 9 ,london4 ,he claim$ to h f\nd a specific = rheumatism & tub]culosis1 b ^u ! dea? ( "o ( 8 pati5ts 9 #ahcj he 0 tri$ = manslaught]4 ,he di$ ( tub]culosis f\r ye>s lat]1 refus+ to take 8 own treatm5t4 #ha ,william ( ,occam 7d4 #acdi71 s call$ f 8 bir?place1 ,ockham1 9 ,surrey4 ,he 0 a ,franciscan1 & lectur$ on philosophy 9 ! ,sorbonne4 #hb ,he signs himself ,james ,hopk9s1 s*oolma/]1 & ?is seems to h be5 8 only publi%$ ef=t4 #hc ,joseph ,ady 7#aggj-aheb7 0 a fam\s sw9dl]4 ,"o ( 8 be/-kn[n s*emes 0 to s5d out lett]s in=m+ ! recipi5ts t !y w\ld le>n some?+ to _! advantage on paym5t ( a c]ta9 sum4 ,he sp5t "s "t 9 prison4 #hd ,sir ,pet] ,laurie 7c4 #aggi-ahfa7 0 wor? ref]r+ to1 = he 0 prom95t z a magi/rate & 0 honor$ because ( 8 int]e/ 9 all social re=ms4 ,he made a =tune z a contractor1 became %]iff ( ,london 9 #ahbc1 & 0 knight$ 9 ! foll[+ ye>4 ,he became ,"l ,mayor ( ,london 9 #ahcb4 #he ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cba1 note #b #fia4 ,! ,a/ronomy 9 a nut%ell appe>$ 9 #ahfj4 ,! ,h]ald ( ,a/rology 0 fir/ publi%$ 9 ,london 9 #ahca1 by ,zadkiel ! ,se]4 ,x 0 cont9u$ z ,! ,a/rological ,almanac 7,london1 #ahcd71 z ,zadkiel's ,almanac & ,h]ald ( ,a/rology 7ibid41 #ahce1 edit$ by ,r4 ,j4 ,morrison1 & subsequ5tly by ,a4 ,j4 ,pe>ce71 & z ,raphael's ,prophetic ,almanac 7#ahdj-ahee74 #hf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #agb1 note #c #chb4 #hg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hg1 note #d #acc4 #hh ,franz ,xav]1 ,freih]r von ,za* 7#aged-ahcb7 0 director ( ! obs]vatory at ,seeb]ge ne> ,go?a4 ,he wrote ! ,tabulae speciales ab]rationis et mutationis 7#ahjf-g71 ,novae et correctae tabulae solis 7#agib71 & ,l'attraction des montagnes et ses effets sur le fil a plomb 7#ahad74 #hi ,jean ,l\is ,pons 7#agfa-ahca7 0 connect$ ) ! obs]vatory at ,m>seilles = ?irty ye>s 7#aghi-ahai74 ,he lat] became director ( ! obs]vatory at ,m>lia1 ne> ,lucca1 & subsequ5tly fill$ ! same (fice at ,flor5ce4 ,he 0 an indefatigable se>*] = comets1 discov]+ #cg betwe5 #ahja & #ahbg1 among !m be+ ! "o t be>s ,encke's "n4 #ij ,?is hypo!sis has n[ become an e/abli%$ fact4 #ia ,john ,*etwode ,eu/ace 7c4 #agfb-ahae7 0 born 9 ,irel&4 ,al?\gh a ,roman ,ca?olic prie/ he liv$ = a "t at ,cambridge :]e he did "s tutor+4 ,8 ,classical ,t\r appe>$ 9 #ahac & w5t ?r\gh sev]al editions4 #ib ,crimes %\ld be expos$ :5 !y are puni%$1 b disgraceful acts %\ld be hidd54 #ic ,h5ri ,hureau de ,s5>mont 7#ahjh-ahfb7 0 pr(essor ( m9]alogy at ! ,ecole des m9es & exam9] at ! ,ecole polyte*nique at ,p>is4 #id ,augu/9 ,jean ,fresnel 7#aghh-ahbg71 ,+5ieur des ponts et *aussees1 gave ! fir/ exp]im5tal pro(s ( ! wave !ory ( light4 ,he /udi$ ! que/ions ( int]f]5ce & pol>ization1 & det]m9$ ! approximate velocity ( light4 #ie ,z is my cu/om4 #if ,francis ,heywood 7#agif-aheh7 made ! fir/ ,engli% translation ( ,kant's ,critick ( ,pure ,reason 7#ahch1 repr9t$ 9 #ahdh74 ,! ,analysis came out1 z "h /at$1 9 #ahdd4 #ig ,l\ise ,r5ee de ,k]\alle1 ,du*ess ( ,portsm\? & ,aubigny 7#afdi-agcd71 0 a favorite ( ,*>les ,,ii4 ,%e us$ h] influ5ce to keep him "u ! control ( ,l\is ,,xiv4 #ih ,william ,*iff9* 7c4 #afjb-afhh7 0 page ( ! k+'s b$-*amb] & keep] ( ! private closet to ,*>les ,,ii4 ,he 0 "o ( ! k+'s intimates & 0 an unscrupul\s h5*man4 #ii ,well devis$4 #ajj ,john ,bell+ham ,+lis4 ,8 ,philobiblion translat$ f ! fir/ edition 7( ,ric>dus d',aung]vile1 ,bi%op ( ,durham71 #adgc1 appe>$ at ,london 9 #ahcb4 ,x 0 republi%$ 9 ,am]ica 7,albany1 ,n4 ,y47 9 #ahfd4 #aja ,:at are y laugh+ at8 #ajb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cad1 note #d #fha4 #ajc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aab1 note #g #baa4 #ajd ,ref]r+ to ,hamilton's edition ( ! ,collect$ ,works ( ,dugald ,/ew>t1 #aj volumes1 ,ed9burgh1 #ahed-eh4 ,x is n commonly rememb]$ t ,/ew>t 7#agec-ahbh7 taught ma!matics at ! ,univ]sity ( ,ed9burgh be=e he took up philosophy4 #aje ,?is 0 ,hamilton's edition ( ! ,works ( ,?omas ,reid 7#b vols41 ,ed9burgh1 #ahdf-ahfc74 ,reid 7#agaj-agif7 includ$ ma!matics 9 8 "w 9 philosophy at ,ab]de54 ,9 #agfd he succe$$ ,adam ,smi? at ,glasg[4 #ajf ,edw>d ,irv+ 7#agib-ahcd71 ! fam\s prea*]4 ,at fir/ he assi/$ ,dr4 ,*alm]s at ,glasg[1 b 9 #ahbb he w5t to ,london :]e he met ) great success4 ,a few ye>s lat] he became m5tally unbalanc$ & 0 f9ally expell$ f 8 *ur* 7#ahcb7 = h]esy4 ,he 0 a great fri5d ( ,c>lyle4 #ajg ,he also wrote a numb] ( o!r p>adoxes1 includ+ ,an ,essay t[>ds a ,sci5ce ( ,consci\sness 7#ahch71 ,in/9ctive ,natural ,religion 7#aheh71 ,popul> ,treatise on ! /ructure1 diseases1 & treatm5t ( ! human tee? 7#ahcg71 & ,on ,heada*e 7#ahei74 #ajh ,james ,smi? 7#ahja-aheg71 kn[n z ,%eph]d ,smi?1 0 a sociali/ & a my/ic1 ) a philosophy t 0 wittily describ$ z ,ori5tal pan!ism translat$ into ,scot*4 ,he 0 editor ( sev]al j\rnals4 #aji ,joanna ,s\?cott 7#agej-ahad7 0 kn[n = h] rhym+ prophecies 9 :i* %e ann\nc$ h]self z ! woman spok5 ( 9 ,revelations xii4 ,%e _h at "o "t z _m z #ajj1jjj disciples1 & %e e/abli%$ a sect t long surviv$ h]4 #aaj ,?ales1 c4 #fdj-edh ,b4 ,c4 #aaa ,py?agoras1 #ehj-eja ,b4 ,c4 #aab ,anaxagoras1 #dii-dbh ,b4 ,c41 ! la/ ( ! ,ionian s*ool1 tea*] ( ,euripides & ,p]icles4 ,plut>* speaks ( him z hav+ squ>$ ! circle4 #aac ,o9opides ( ,*ios1 contempor>y ( ,anaxagoras4 ,proclus tells u t ,o9opides 0 ! fir/ to %[ h[ to let fall a p]p5dicul> to a l9e f an ext]nal po9t4 #aad ,bryson & ,antiphon1 contempor>ies ( ,socrates1 inv5t$ ! s-call$ me?od ( exhau/ions1 "o ( ! =]unn]s ( ! calculus4 #aae ,he wrote1 c4 #ddj ,b4 ,c41 ! fir/ elem5t>y textbook on ma!matics 9 ! ,greek language4 ,! lunes ( ,hippocrates are well kn[n 9 geometry4 #aaf ,jabir b5 ,aflah4 ,he liv$ c4 #ajhe1 at ,seville1 & wrote on a/ronomy & sph]ical trigonometry4 ,! ,gebri filii ,affla ,hispal5sis de a/ronomia libri ,,ix 0 publi%$ at ,nuremb]g 9 #aecc4 #aag ,hi]onymus ,c>danus1 or ,girolamo ,c>dano 7#aeja-aegf71 ! great algebrai/4 ,8 ,artis magnae sive de regulis ,algebrae 0 publi%$ at ,nuremb]g 9 #aede4 #aah ,nicolo ,t>taglia 7c4 #aejj-aeeg71 ! great rival ( ,c>dan4 #aai ,see note #e #ih1 ,vol4 ,i1 page #fi4 #abj ,see note #aj #abd1 ,vol4 ,i41 page #hc4 #aba ,see note #i #abc1 ,vol4 ,i1 page #hc4 #abb ,pi]re ,h]igone liv$ 9 ,p>is ! fir/ half ( ! #ag? c5tury4 ,8 ,c\rs ma!matique 7#f vols41 #afcd-afdd7 _h "s /&+ b 0 n at all orig9al4 #abc ,franciscus van ,s*oot5 7di$ 9 #affa7 0 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,leyd54 ,he edit$ ,desc>tes's ,la ,geometrie4 #abd ,florimond de ,beaune 7#afja-afeb7 0 ! fir/ ,fr5*man to write a comm5t>y on ,desc>tes's ,la ,geometrie4 ,he did "s notewor?y "w 9 ! !ory ( curves4 #abe ,see note #c #bc1 ,vol4 ,i1 page #da4 #abf ,olivi] de ,s]res 7b4 9 #aeci7 0 a writ] on agriculture4 ,montucla speaks ( him 9 8 ,quadrature du c]cle 7page #bbg7 z hav+ ass]t$ t ! circle is twice ! inscrib$ equilat]al triangle1 al?\gh1 z ,de ,morgan po9ts out1 ?is did n fairly int]pret 8 position4 #abg ,angh]a wrote n only ! ?ree works "h m5tion$1 b also ! ,problemi del piu alto int]esse sci5tifico1 geometricam5te risoluti e dimo/rati1 ,naples1 #ahfa4 ,8 quadrature 0 def5d$ by ,giovanni ,motti 9 a "w entitl$ ,matematica ,v]a4 ,falsita del si/ema ciclometrico d',ar*im$e1 quadratura del c]*io d',angh]a1 ric]ca algebraica dei lati di qualunque poligono regol>e inscritto 9 un circolo1 ,vogh]a1 #ahgg4 ,! ,problemi ( #ahfa conta9s ,angh]a's portrait1 & /ates t he liv$ at ,malta f #ahdi to #ahfa4 ,x fur!r /ates t ! ,malta publications are 9 "p reproduc$ 9 ?is "w4 #abh ,?is 0 8 fri5d ,paolo ,pullic9o ^: ,elogio 0 pron\nc$ by ,l4 ,f>rugia at ,malta 9 #ahij4 ,he wrote a "w ,la ,santa ,effegie della ,blata ,v]g9e ,m>ia1 publi%$ at ,valetta 9 #ahfh4 #abi ,/4 ,vitus1 ,/4 ,mode/us1 & ,/4 ,cresc5tia 7 all m>tyr$ ! same day1 be+ torn limb f limb aft] lions & molt5 lead _h prov$ ( no avail4 ,at lea/ s ! /ory runs4 #acj ,! ref]5ce is to ,c>d9al ,wiseman4 ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bf1 note #ef4 #aca ,wor?y ( e/eem4 #acb ,p$ro de ,ribad5eira 7,ribad5eyra1 ,rivad5eira71 0 born at ,tol$o 9 #aebf & di$ 9 #afaa4 ,he held high position 9 ! ,jesuit ord]4 ,! "w ref]r$ to is ! ,flos ,sanctorum o libro de las vidas de los santos1 ( :i* !re 0 an edition at ,b>celona 9 #afdc4 ,8 life ( ,loyola 7#aegb7 & ,hi/oria ecclesia/ica del ,cisma del re9o de ,+lat]ra 7 well kn[n4 #acc ,caes> ,b>onius 7#aech-afjg7 0 made a c>d9al 9 #aeie & became libr>ian at ! ,vatican 9 #aeig4 ,! "w ref]r$ to appe>$ at ,rome 9 #aehi4 #acd ,mrs4 ,jameson's 7#agid-ahfj7 works 7 v popul> half a c5tury ago1 & /ill h "s circulation among art lov]s4 ,! fir/ edition ( ! "w m5tion$ appe>$ 9 #ahdh4 #ace ,! b>ny>d cock4 #acf ,%anks did no?+ b comput+4 ,! title %\ld1 ( c\rse1 read to #fjg ,places ( ,decimals4 ,he lat] c>ri$ ! computation to #gjg decimal places4 7,proc4 ,roy4 ,society1 ,,xxi1 p4 #cai47 ,he also prep>$ a table ( prime numb]s up to #fj1jjj4 7,proc4 ,roy4 ,society1 ,,xxii1 p4 #bjj47 #acg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #db1 note #d #bd4 #ach ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #fd1 note #a #gh4 #aci ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cbh1 note #a #gjd4 #adj ,george ,suffield publi%$ ,syn!tic ,division 9 ,ari?metic1 to :i* ref]5ce is made1 9 #ahfc4 #ada ,john ,rob]t ,lunn wrote *iefly on ,*ur* matt]s1 al?\gh he publi%$ a "w on motion 9 #ahei4 #adb ,jean ,bapti/e ,joseph1 ,b>on ,f\ri] 7#agfh-ahcj71 sometime pr(essor 9 ! ,milit>y ,s*ool at ,p>is1 & lat] at ! ,ecole polyte*nique4 ,he is be/ kn[n by 8 ,!orie analytique de la *aleur 7,p>is1 #ahbb71 9 :i* ! ,f\ri] s]ies is us$4 ,! "w "h ref]r$ to is ! ,analyse des equations det]m9ees 7,p>is1 #ahca74 #adc ,william ,george ,horn] 7#aghf-ahcg7 acquir$ a "n = himself 9 ma!matics 9 a curi\s mann]4 ,he 0 n a univ]sity man nor 0 he a ma!matician ( any /&+4 ,he taught s*ool ne> ,bri/ol & at ,ba?1 & seems to h /umbl$ ^u 8 +5i\s me?od = f9d+ ! approximate roots ( num]ical high] equations1 includ+ z a special case ! extract+ ( ! v>i\s roots ( numb]s4 ,davies ,gilb]t pres5t$ ! me?od to ! ,royal ,society 9 #ahai1 & x 0 repr9t$ 9 ! ,ladies' ,di>y = #ahch1 & 9 ! ,ma!matician 9 #ahdc4 ,! me?od 0 orig9al z f> z ,horn] 0 conc]n$1 b x is practically id5tical ) ! "o us$ by ! ,*9ese algebrai/ ,*'9 ,*iu-%ang1 9 8 ,su-%u ,*iu-*ang ( #abdg4 ,b ev5 ,*'9 ,*iu-%ang c h>dly be call$ ! discov]] ( ! me?od s9ce x is m]ely ! ext5sion ( a process = root extract+ t appe>$ 9 ! ,*iu-*ang ,suan-%u ( ! second c5tury ,b4 ,c4 #add ,he aft]w>ds edit$ ,l(tus's ,inl& ,rev5ue ,(fic]s' ,manual 7,london1 #ahfe74 ,! two equations m5tion$ 7 x#c - #bx #e & y#c - #ijy#b #bejjy - #af1jjj #j1 9 :i* y #cj - #ajx4 ,h5ce ea* place ( y is ! complem5t ( ! foll[+ place ( x ) respect to #i4 #ade ,probably ! ,john ,p[] ,hicks :o wrote a memoir on ,t4 ,h4 ,key1 ,london1 #ahic4 #adf ,possibly ! "o :o wrote on ! quadrature ( ! circle 9 #ahha4 #adg ,z x is4 ,b :at a pity t we h n #ab f+]s1 ) duodecimal fractions in/ead ( decimals6 ,we %\ld !n h #j4f = #a_/b1 #j4d = #a_/c1 #j4h = #b_/c1 #j4c = #a_/d1 #j4i = #c_/d1 & #j4af = #a_/h1 in/ead ( #j4e1 #j4ccc1 #j4fff1 #j4be1 #j4ge1 & #j4abe z we n[ h ) our decimal sy/em4 ,9 o!r words1 ! mo/ frequ5tly us$ fractions 9 bus9ess w\ld be mu* m easily repres5t$ on ! duodecimal scale ?an on ! decimal scale t we n[ use4 #adh ,he wrote ,h9ts = an ,essay on ,anemology & ,ombrology 7,london1 #ahci-dj7 & ,! ,music ( ! ,eye 7,london1 #ahca74 #adi ,brigham ,"y 7#ahja-ahgg7 0 born at ,:it+ham1 ,v]mont1 & ent]$ ! ,mormon *ur* 9 #ahcb4 ,9 #ahdj he 0 s5t z a mission>y to ,engl&4 ,aft] ! dea? ( ,joseph ,smi? he became presid5t ( ! ,mormons 7#ahdg71 lead+ ! *ur* to ,salt ,lake ,city 7#ahdh74 #aej ,joseph ,smi? 7#ahje-ahdd7 0 also born 9 ,v]mont1 & 0 f\r ye>s ! junior ( ,brigham ,"y4 ,! ,book ( ,mormon appe>$ 9 #ahbg1 & ! *ur* 0 f\nd$ 9 #ahcj4 ,he 0 murd]$ 9 #ahdd4 #aea ,orson ,pratt 7#ahaa-ahha7 0 "o ( ! twelve apo/les ( ! ,mormon ,*ur* 7#ahce71 & made sev]al mission>y j\rneys to ,engl&4 ,he 0 pr(essor ( ma!matics 9 ! ,univ]sity ( ,des]et 7! ,mormon "n = ,utah74 ,besides ! pap] m5tion$ ,pratt wrote ! ,div9e ,au!nticity ( ! ,book ( ,mormon 7#ahdi71 ,cubic & ,biquadratic ,equations 7#ahff71 & a ,key to ! ,univ]se 7#ahff74 #aeb ,x does n foll[4 #aec ,dryd5 7#afca-agjj7 publi%$ 8 ,religio ,laici 9 #afhb4 ,! use ( ! ^w proportion 9 ! s5se ( ratio 0 common be=e 8 "t1 b he uses x 9 ! s5se ( hav+ f\r t]ms2 t is1 t price is to price z (f5ce is to (f5ce4 #aed ,ol9?us ,gilb]t ,gregory 7#aggd-ahda7 succe$$ ,hutton z pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,woolwi*4 ,he 01 ) ,de ,morgan1 mu* int]e/$ 9 f\nd+ ! ,univ]sity ( ,london4 ,he wrote on a/ronomy 7#agic71 me*anics 7#ahjf71 practical ma!matics 7#ahbe71 & ,*ri/ian evid5ces 7#ahaa74 #aee ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bbj1 note #f #dhb4 ,! ,p5sees appe>$ po/hum\sly 9 #afgj4 #aef ,! "r ?+ to d is n to wag] at all4 ,yes1 b y ought to wag]2 y h />t$ out2 & n to wag] at all t ,god exi/s is to wag] t he does n exi/4 #aeg ,he liv$ ab\t #cjj ,a4,d41 9 ,africa1 & wrote ,libri septem adv]sus ,g5tes4 ,?is 0 pr9t$ at ,rome 9 #aedb-c4 #aeh ,pi]re ,bayle 7#afdg-agjf7 0 pr(essor ( philosophy at ! ,pro/e/ant ,univ]sity at ,s$an f #afge until its dissolution 9 #afha4 ,he !n became pr(essor at ,rott]dam 7#afha-afic74 ,9 #afhd he began ! publication ( 8 j\rnal ( lit]>y criticism ,n\velles de la ,republique des ,lettres4 ,he is be/ kn[n = 8 erudite ,dictionnaire hi/orique et critique 7#afig74 #aei ,b ,*ri/ himself does n prove :at he promises4 ,x is true4 ,=1 z ,i h said1 !re _c be any absolute pro( ( future ev5ts4 ,!re=e s9ce x is a condition ( future ev5ts t !y _c be grasp$ or compreh5d$ by any ef=ts ( anticipation1 is x n m reasonable1 out ( two alt]natives t are unc]ta9 & t are hang+ 9 d\btful expectation1 to give cr$5ce to ! "o t gives "s hope r ?an to ! "o t (f]s none at all8 ,= 9 ! =m] case !re is no dang] if1 z is said to ?reat51 x becomes empty & void2 :ile 9 ! latt] case ! dang] is greate/1 t is1 ! loss ( salvation1 if :5 ! "t comes x is f\nd t x 0 n a falsehood4 #afj ,gregg wrote sev]al o!r p>adoxes1 includ+ ! foll[+3 ,! ,au!ntic ,report ( ! extraord9>y case ( ,tre%am ,dames ,gregg 444 8 committal to ,bridewell = refus+ to give 8 recognizance 7,dubl91 #ahda71 ,an ,appeal to ,public ,op9ion ^u a ,case ( ,injury & ,wrong 444 9 ! case ( a "q ( pr]ogative t arose betwe5 ,r4 ,:ately 444 ,ar*bi%op ( ,dubl9 & ! au?or 7,london1 #ahfa71 ,! ,cosmology ( ,sir ,isaac ,newton prov$ to be 9 accordance ) ! ,bible 7,london1 #ahga71 ,! ,/eam ,locomotive z reveal$ 9 ! ,bible 7,london #ahfc7 & ,on ! ,sacr$ ,law ( #ahff1 conf]r+ p]petual life ) immunity f decay & disease4 ,a c5to ( decisive scriptural oracles /rangely discov]$ 7,london & ,dubl91 #ahge74 ,^! titles w help ! read] to und]/& ! man :om ,de ,morgan s pleasantly satirizes4 #afa ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bfa1 note #b #eib4 #afb ,!y h f\nd x4 #afc ,! late ,greeks us$ ! lett]s ( _! alphabet z num]als1 add+ ?ree e>ly alphabetic *>act]s4 ,! lett] *i repres5t$ #fjj1 xi repres5t$ #fj1 & digamma /ood = #f4 ,?is gives #fff1 ! numb] ( ! ,bea/ giv5 9 ! ,revelation4 #afd ,all[+ = necess>y exceptions4 #afe ,mr4 ,gregg is n alone 9 8 ef=ts to use ! calculus 9 orig9al l9es1 z any "o :o has read ,h]b>t's application ( ! subject to psy*ology w recall4 #aff ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aje1 note #d #ahh2 page #aji1 note #a #aig4 #afg ,! full title %[s ! plan1--,! ,decimal ,sy/em z a :ole1 9 its relation to "t1 measure1 weight1 capacity1 & money1 9 unison ) ea* o!r4 ,b :y is ?is s mu* worse ?an ! ,fr5* plan ( :i* we h only ! metric sy/em & ! decimal division ( ! angle left8 #afh ,"o ( ! bro!rs ( ,sir ,isaac ,pitman 7#ahac-ahig71 ! inv5tor ( mod]n /5ography4 ,( ^! bro!rs1 ,b5jam9 taught ! art 9 ,am]ica1 ,jacob 9 ,au/ralia1 & ,joseph1 ,h5ry1 & ,fr$]ick 9 ,engl&4 #afi ,= example1 ,! ,phonographic ,lectur] 7,london1 #ahga etc471 ,! ,phonographic ,/ud5t 7#ahfg1 etc471 & ,! ,%or?& ,magaz9e 7#ahff1 etc474 #agj ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #fh1 note #adh4 #aga ,x involves ! !ory ( non-,euclidean geometry1 ,euclid's po/ulate ( p>allels be+ us$ 9 prov+ ?is !orem4 #agb ,ref]r+ to ! fact t none ( ! works ( ,?ales is extant4 #agc ,! au?or 0 "o ,b4 ,bul/rode4 ,p>ts #d & #e 7 pr9t$ at ,calcutta4 #agd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #e1 note #ah4 #age ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #he1 note #b #abi4 #agf ,alex&] ,vasilievi* ,suv>(f 7#agbi-ahjj71 a ,russian g5]al :o f\ght aga9/ ! ,turks1 9 ! ,poli% w>s1 & 9 ! e>ly ,napoleonic campaigns4 ,:5 he took ,ismail 9 #agij he s5t ?is c\plet to ,empress ,ca!r9e4 #agg ,newton ha? det]m9$ rightly1 ,newton ha? n det]m9$ rightly4 #agh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bhh1 note #c #fba4 #agi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cbf1 note #a #gjj4 #ahj ,) great honor4 #aha ,app>5tly unkn[n to biograph]s4 ,he seems to h writt5 no?+ else4 #ahb ,capta9 ,m>ryat 7#agib-ahdh7 publi%$ ,sn>ley-y[1 or ! ,dog ,fi5d 9 #ahcg4 #ahc ,he is n kn[n to biograph]s1 & publi%$ no?+ else "u ?is "n4 #ahd ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hj1 note #e #aai4 #ahe ,he publi%$ a ,family & ,comm]cial ,illu/rat$ ,almanack & ,ye> ,book 444 = #ahfa 7,ba?1 #ahfj74 #ahf ,l\is ,dut5s 7#agcj-ahab7 0 born at ,t\rs1 b w5t to ,engl& z a "y man4 ,he made ! fir/ collection ( ! works ( ,leibnitz1 aga9/ ! advice ( ,voltaire1 :o wrote to him3 ,les ecrits de ,leibnitz sont ep>s comme les feuilles de la ,sybille1 et aussi obscurs que les ecrits de cette vieille4 ,! "w appe>$ at ,g5eva1 9 six volumes1 9 #agfi4 #ahg ,mungo ,p>k 7#agga-ahjf71 ! fir/ ,european to explore ! ,nig] 7#agie-f74 ,8 ,travels 9 ! ,int]ior ( ,africa appe>$ 9 #agii4 ,he di$ 9 ,africa4 #ahh ,g]h>d ,m]cator 7#aeab-aeid7 ! well-kn[n map mak] ( ,l\va94 ,! ,m]cator's ,projection 0 probably made z e>ly z #aeej1 b ! pr9ciple ( its con/ruction 0 fir/ set =? by ,edw>d ,wright 7,london1 #aeii74 #ahi ,quirico ,b>illi ,filopanti wrote a numb] ( works & monographs4 ,he succe$$ 9 gett+ 8 ,ces>e al ,rubicone & ,degli usi idraulici della ,tela 9 ! ,memoria letta 444 all' ,accademia delle ,sci5ze 9 ,bologna 7#ahdg1 #ahff74 ,he also wrote ,dio esi/e 7#ahha71 ,dio ,lib]ale 7#ahhj71 & ,sunto della memoria sulle geuranie ossia di alcune s+ol>i relazioni cosmi*e della t]ra e del cielo 7#ahfb74 #aij ,! p]iods ( disembodim5t may be int]e/+4 ,!y w be se5 f ! foll[+ dates3 ,desc>tes 7#aeif-afej71 ,william ,,iii 7#afej-agjb72 ,rog] ,bacon 7#abad to c4 #abid71 ,boccaccio 7#acac-acge74 ,*>les ,,ix 0 born 9 #aeej & di$ 9 #aegd4 #aia ,8 real "n 0 ,fr$]ick ,p>k]1 & he wrote sev]al works on ! ,greek language & on religion4 ,among ^! 7 a translation ( ! ,new ,te/am5t f ! ,vatican ,,ms4 7#ahfd71 ,! ,reveal$ ,hi/ory ( ,man 7#ahed71 ,an ,enquiry respect+ ! ,punctuation ( ,anci5t ,greek 7#ahda71 & ,rules = ,asc]ta9+ ! s5se convey$ 9 ,anci5t ,greek ,manuscripts 7#ahdh1 ! sev5? edition appe>+ 9 #ahfb74 #aib ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ceb1 second note #a #gcf4 ,! lit]ature on ! subject ( ! ,great ,pyramid1 consid]$ f ! /&po9t ( metrology1 is ext5sive4 #aic ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hj1 note #e #aai4 #aid ,sir ,philip ,francis 7#agdj-ahah7 0 a ,:ig politician4 ,! evid5ce t he 0 ! au?or ( ! ,lett]s ( ,junius 7#agfi-aggb7 is purely circum/antial4 ,he 0 cl]k 9 ! w> (fice at ! "t ( _! publication4 ,9 #aggd he 0 made a memb] ( ! ,supreme ,c\ncil ( ,b5gal1 & 0 a vigor\s oppon5t ( ,w>r5 ,ha/+s1 ! two fight+ a duel 9 #aghj4 ,he ent]$ p>liam5t 9 #aghd & 0 among ! lead]s 9 ! agitation = p>liam5t>y re=m4 #aie ,mrs4 ,cottle publi%$ a numb] ( lett]s t attract$ att5tion at ! "t4 ,among ^! 7 lett]s to ! emp]or ( ,france & k+ ( ,s>d9ia 7#ahei7 relat+ to ! prophecies ( ! w> betwe5 ,france & ,au/ria2 to ,g4 ,c4 ,lavis & ,h] ,maje/y's ,m9i/]s 7#ahei7 relat+ to h] claims z a prophetess2 & to ! ,cr[n$ ,heads at ,/4 ,james1 ! ,k+ ( ,prussia1 & o!rs 7#ahfj71 relat+ to c]ta9 passages ( ,scripture4 ,%e also wrote ,! ,lamb's ,book ( ,life = ! ,new ,j]usalem ,*ur* & ,k+dom1 int]pret$ = all nations 7#ahfa74 #aif ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cae1 note #b #fhe1 & ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #eh1 note #aji4 #aig ,a ,congregational m9i/]1 :o publi%$ a numb] ( s]mons1 *iefly obitu>ies1 betwe5 #ahjd & #ahea4 ,8 ,frailty ( ,human ,life1 two s]mons deliv]$ on ! occasion ( ! dea? ( ,pr9cess ,*>lotte1 w5t ?r\gh at lea/ ?ree editions4 #aih ,he 0 secret>y ( ! ,congregational ,bo>d & editor ( ! ,congregational ,ye> ,book 7f #ahdf7 & ! ,congregational ,manual4 #aii ,fr$]ick ,d5ison ,maurice 7#ahje-ahgb7 began 8 prea*+ z a ,unit>ian b ent]$ ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur* 9 #ahca1 be+ orda9$ 9 #ahcd4 ,he 0 pr(essor ( ,engli% & ,hi/ory at ,k+'s ,college1 ,london1 f #ahdj to #ahec4 ,he 0 "o ( ! f\nd]s ( ,que5's ,college = wom51 & 0 ! fir/ pr9cipal ( ! ,work+ ,m5's ,college1 ,london4 ,! subject ref]r$ to by ,de ,morgan is 8 expression ( op9ion 9 8 ,!ological ,essays 7#ahec7 t future puni%m5t is n et]nal4 ,z a result ( ?is expression he lo/ 8 pr(essor%ip at ,k+'s ,college4 ,9 #ahff he 0 made ,knightbridge ,pr(essor ( ,casui/ry1 ,moral ,!ology1 & ,moral ,philosophy at ,cambridge4 #bjj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #df1 note #a #db4 ,besides ! books m5tion$ 9 ?is li/ he wrote ,! ,ratio betwe5 ,diamet] & ,circumf]5ce demon/rat$ by angles1 & ,euclid's ,!orem1 ,proposition #cb1 ,book ,i1 prov$ to be fallaci\s 7,liv]pool1 #ahgj74 ,?is is ! !orem :i* ass]ts t ! ext]ior angle ( a triangle is equal to ! sum ( ! two opposite int]ior angles1 & t ! sum ( ! int]ior angles equals two "r angles4 ,he also publi%$ 8 ,curiosities ( ,ma!matics 9 #ahgj1 a "w conta9+ an ext5sive correspond5ce ) e "o :o w\ld pay any att5tion to him4 ,de ,morgan 0 !n too feeble to %[ any int]e/ 9 ! f9al ef=t ( ! subject ( "s ( 8 ke5e/ satire4 #bja ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ccb1 note #d #gji4 #bjb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aja1 note #d #agd4 #bjc ,! circle-squ>+ disease2 lit]ally1 ! circle-measur+ disease4 #bjd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #fc1 note #acf4 #bje ,william ,ru!r=d 7c4 #agih-ahga71 tea*] ( ma!matics at ,woolwi*1 secret>y ( ! ,royal ,a/ronomical ,society1 editor ( ,! ,ma!matician1 & au?or ( v>i\s textbooks4 ,! ,ext5sion ( pi to #ddj places1 appe>$ 9 ! ,proce$+s ( ! ,royal ,society 9 #ahec 7p4 #bgd74 #bjf ,*>les ,knight 7#agia-ahgc7 0 associat$ ) ,de ,morgan = _m ye>s4 ,aft] #ahbh he sup]9t5d$ ! publications ( ! ,society = ! ,diffusion ( ,useful ,k1 to :i* ,de ,morgan contribut$1 & he edit$ ! ,p5ny ,cyclop$ia 7#ahcc-ahdd7 = :i* ,de ,morgan wrote ! articles on ma!matics4 #bjg ,sir ,william ,hamilton4 ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aab1 note #g #baa4 #bjh ,adam ,smi? 7#agbc-agij7 0 n only kn[n = 8 ,weal? ( ,nations 7#aggf71 b = 8 ,!ory ( ,moral ,s5tim5ts 7#agei71 publi%$ :ile he 0 pr(essor ( moral philosophy at ,glasg[ 7#ageb-agfd74 ,he 0 ,"l ,rector ( ! univ]sity 9 #aghg4 #bji ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ccb1 note #d #gji4 #baj ,:ip4 #baa ,t]rible la%4 #bab ,an accompli%$ fact an accompli%$ fault4 #bac ,see ,extracts f ! ,di>y & ,lett]s ( ,mrs4 ,m>y ,cobb1 ,london1 #ahje4 #bad ,g5tle 9 mann]4 #bae ,brave 9 action4 ,! motto ( ,e>l ,newbor\gh 0 ,suavit] 9 modo1 =tit] 9 re4 #baf ,r$uction to an absurdity1 a me?od ( pro( occasionally us$ 9 geometry & 9 logic4 #bag ,he has lo/ ! "r ( be+ mov$ 7/ruck7 by evid5ce4 #bah ,= radix quadratus4 ,! usual root sign is suppos$ to be d]iv$ f r 7= radix71 & at "o "t q 0 commonly us$ = squ>e1 z 9 ,viete's /yle ( writ+ ,aq = ,a#b4 #bai ,! ,g>de ,d\l\reuse 0 a ca/le 9 ! m>*es ( ,wales & receiv$ its "n because ( its exposure to attacks by ! ,wel%4 #bbj ,out ( ! fight4 #bba ,hidd54 #bbb ,john ,cam ,hobh\se 7#aghf-ahfi71 ,b>on ,br\ghton1 0 committ$ to ,newgate = two mon?s 9 #ahai = 8 anonym\s pamphlet1 ,a ,trifl+ ,mi/ake4 ,?is 0 a great adv]tisem5t = him1 & ^u 8 release he 0 at once elect$ to p>liam5t = ,we/m9/]4 ,he 0 a /rong support] ( all re=m measures1 & 0 ,secret>y = ,w> 9 #ahcb4 ,he 0 creat$ ,b>on ,br\ghton de ,gyf=d 9 #ahea4 #bbc ,?omas ,ersk9e 7#agej-ahbc71 ! fam\s orator4 ,he became ,"l ,*ancellor 9 #ahjf1 b sat 9 ! ,h\se ( ,commons mo/ ( 8 life4 #bbd ,! above is expla9$ 9 ! ,,ms4 by a p>agraph ref]r+ to "s anagrams1 9 "o ( :i*1 by help ( ! or?ography sugge/$1 a designation = ?is cyclomet] 0 obta9$ f ! lett]s ( 8 "n4--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 #bbe ,a p]sonal v]b agrees ) its subject4 #bbf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cbf1 note #a #gjj4 #bbg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cbf1 note #b #gja4 #bbh ,app>5tly unkn[n to biograph]s4 #bbi ,! ,biblio!ca ,ma!matica ( ,ludwig ,adolph ,sohncke 7#ahjg-ahec71 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,ko5igsb]g & ,halle1 cov]$ ! p]iod f #ahcj to #ahed1 be+ complet$ by ,w4 ,engelmann4 ,x appe>$ 9 #ahed4 #bcj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cib1 note #b #hje4 #bca ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #g #cb4 #bcb ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ia1 note #ahg4 #bcc ,mason made a notable balloon trip f ,london to ,weilburg1 9 ! ,du*y ( ,nassau1 9 ,novemb]1 #ahcf1 cov]+ #ejj miles 9 #ah h\rs4 ,he publi%$ an acc\nt ( ?is trip 9 #ahcg1 & a "w entitl$ ,a]onautica 9 #ahch4 #bcd ,william ,h>rison ,a9swor? 7#ahje-ahhe7 ! noveli/4 #bce ,on ?is "q see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cbf1 note #b #gja4 #bcf ,major ,g5]al ,alfr$ ,wilks ,drayson1 au?or ( v>i\s works on geology1 a/ronomy1 milit>y survey+1 & adv5ture4 #bcg ,hailes also wrote sev]al o!r p>adoxes on a/ronomy & circle squ>+ dur+ ! p]iod #ahdc-ahgb4 #bch ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #h #cc4 #bci ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #g #cb4 #bdj ,v small errors are n to be condemn$4 #bda ,he seems to h writt5 no?+ else4 #bdb ,besides ! p>adoxes "h m5tion$ by ,de ,morgan he wrote sev]al o!r works1 includ+ ! foll[+3 ,abriss d] ,babylonis*-,assyris*5 ,ges*i*te 7,mannheim1 #ahed71 ,a ,popul> ,inquiry into ! ,moon's rotation on h] axis 7,london1 #ahef71 ,practical ,tables = ! r$uction ( ! ,mahometan dates to ! ,*ri/ian kal5d> 7,london1 #ahef71 ,grundzuege e9] neu5 ,weltlehre 7,muni*1 #ahfj71 & ,on ! hi/orical ,antiquity ( ! ,p ( ,egypt 7,london1 #ahfc74 #bdc ,dircks 7#ahjf-ahgc7 0 a civil eng9e] ( prom95ce1 & a memb] ( ! ,briti% ,association & ! ,royal ,society ( ,ed9burgh4 ,he wrote 7#ahfc7 on ,pepp]'s ,gho/1 an +5i\s optical illusion inv5t$ by him4 ,!re 0 a second edition ( ! ,p]petuum ,mobile 9 #ahgj4 #bdd ,george ,/eph5son 7#agha-ahdh71 ! inv5tor ( ! fir/ successful /eam locomotive4 ,8 fir/ eng9e 0 tri$ 9 #ahad4 #bde ,rob]t ,/eph5son 7#ahjc-ahei71 ! only son ( ,george4 ,mo/ ( ! e>ly improvem5ts 9 locomotive manufacture 7 due to him4 ,he 0 also well kn[n = 8 con/ruction ( great bridges4 #bdf ,9 its prop] place4 #bdg ,a fool always f9ds a bigg] fool to admire him4 #bdh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #g #cb4 #bdi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #h #cc4 #bej ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #he1 note #b #abi4 #bea ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cij1 note #a #cij4 #beb ,f #ahbc to #aheb x 0 edit$ by ,i4 ,c4 ,rob]tson2 f #aheb to #aheg by ,r4 ,a4 ,brooman2 & f #aheg to #ahfc by ,brooman & ,e4 ,j4 ,re$4 #bec ,sir ,james ,ivory 7#agfe-ahdb7 01 z a "y man1 manag] ( a flax mill 9 ,scotl&4 ,9 #ahjd he 0 made pr(essor ( ma!matics at ! ,royal ,milit>y ,college1 !n at ,m>l[ & lat] at ,s&hur/4 ,he 0 deeply int]e/$ 9 ma!matical physics1 & !re is a !orem on ! attraction ( ellipsoids t be>s 8 "n4 ,he 0 aw>d$ ?ree m$als ( ! ,royal ,society1 & 0 knight$ toge!r ) ,h]s*el & ,brew/]1 9 #ahca4 #bed ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ef1 note #a #fd4 #bee ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aec1 note #e #cch4 #bef ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cji1 note #b #fgj4 #beg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hg1 note #d #acc4 #beh ,george ,cann+ 7#aggj-aheg71 ! ,tory /atesman & fri5d ( ,scott1 0 mu* int]e/$ 9 f\nd+ ! ,qu>t]ly ,review 7#ahjh7 & 0 a contributor to its pages4 #bei ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ahf1 note #ad #dah4 #bfj ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ada1 note #beb4 #bfa ,de ,morgan _h a numb] ( excell5t articles 9 ?is publication4 #bfb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bgi1 note #a #faa4 #bfc ,james ,or*>d ,halliwell 7#ahbj-ahhi71 aft]w>ds ,halliwell-,phillips1 came into prom95ce z a writ] at an e>ly age4 ,:5 he 0 sev5te5 he wrote a s]ies ( lives ( ma!maticians = ! ,p>!non4 ,8 ,r>a ,ma!matica appe>$ :5 he 0 b n9ete54 ,he 0 a great bibliophile & an en?usia/ic /ud5t ( ,%akespe>e4 #bfd ,?is 0 writt5 at ! age ( tw5ty-two4 #bfe ,! subject ( ?is criticism is ( long pa/ date1 & z x has only be5 introduc$ by ! au?or z an in/ance ( faulty editor%ip1 ,i h omitt$ ! "n ( ! writ] ( ! libel1 & a few l9es ( fur!r detail4--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 #bff ,condemn$ s\ls4 #bfg ,! editor ( ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e di$ soon aft] ! above 0 writt54--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 #bfh ,?omas ,/eph5s ,davies 7#agie-ahea7 0 ma!matical ma/] at ,woolwi* & ,f4 ,r4 ,s4 ,he contribut$ a s]ies ( ,geometrical ,notes to ! ,me*anics' ,magaz9e & edit$ ! ,ma!matician4 ,he also publi%$ a numb] ( text-books4 #bfi ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ff1 note #adc4 #bgj ,! ,diction>y ( ,greek & ,roman ,biography 7#ahdi71 edit$ by ,sir ,william ,smi? 7#ahac-ahic71 ^: o!r diction>ies on classical & biblical matt]s are well kn[n4 #bga ,o ,j4 ,s46 ,?is is ! wor/6 ! greate/ possible injury6 #bgb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dd1 note #i #cd & page #aaj1 note #e #bja4 #bgc ,if !re's a man :om ! judge's pitiless s5t5ce awaite?1 ,8 head condemn$ to p5alties & tribulations1 ,let nei!r p5it5ti>ies tire him ) labor]'s burd5s ,nor let 8 /iff5$ h&s be h>rass$ by "w 9 ! m9es4 ,he mu/ squ>e ! circle6 ,= :at else d ,i c>e8--all ,kn[n puni%m5ts ?is "o task ha? surely includ$4 #bgd ,h\l/on 0 9 ! cu/oms s]vice4 ,he also publi%$ ,inkl+s ( ,areal ,autometry1 ,london1 #ahgd4 #bge ,?is is ,fr$]ick ,c4 ,bakewell4 ,he _h already publi%$ ,natural ,evid5ce ( a ,future ,life 7,london1 #ahce71 ,philosophical ,conv]sations 7,london1 #ahcc1 ) o!r editions71 & ,electric ,sci5ce 7,london1 #ahec1 ) o!r editions74 #bgf ,h5ry ,f4 ,a4 ,pratt _h already publi%$ ,a ,diss]tation on ! p[] ( ! int]cept$ pressure ( ! ,atmosph]e 7,london1 #ahdd7 & ,! ,g5ealogy ( ,creation 7#ahfa74 ,lat] he publi%$ a "w ,on ,orbital ,motion 7#ahfc71 & ,a/ronomical ,inve/igations 7#ahfe74 #bgg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bfj1 note #a #eia4 #bgh ,?omas ,rawson ,birks 7#ahaj-ahhc71 a !ologian & controv]siali/1 fell[ ( ,tr9ity ,college1 ,cambridge1 & 7#ahgb7 pr(essor ( moral philosophy 9 t univ]sity4 ,he wrote ,mod]n ,rationalism 7#ahec71 ,! ,bible & ,mod]n ,?\ght 7#ahfa71 ,! ,fir/ ,pr9ciples ( ,moral ,sci5ce 7#ahgc71 & ,mod]n ,physical ,fatalism & ! ,doctr9e ( ,evolution 7#ahgf71 ! la/ be+ an attack on ,h]b]t ,sp5c]'s ,fir/ ,pr9ciples4 #bgi ,pseudonym = ,william ,?orn4 ,9 ! foll[+ ye> 7#ahfc7 he publi%$ a second "w1 ,! ,?orn-,tree3 be+ a ,hi/ory ( ,?orn ,wor%ip1 a reply to ,bi%op ,col5so's "w entitl$ ,! ,p5tateu* & ! ,book ( ,jo%ua critically exam9$4 #bhj ,besides ,! ,pe/il5ce 7#ahff7 he publi%$ ,! ,true ,*ur* 7#ahea71 ,! ,*ur* & h] de/9ies 7#ahee71 ,religi\s re=mation imp]atively dem&$ 7#ahfd71 & ,! ,bible plan unfold$ 7second edition1 #ahgb74 #bha ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ig1 note #aie4 #bhb ,sir ,george ,cornewall ,lewis 7#ahjf-ahfc7 also wrote an ,essay on ! ,orig9 & ,=mation ( ! ,romance ,languages 7#ahce71 an ,essay on ! ,gov]nm5t ( ,dep5d5cies 7#ahda71 & an ,essay on ,=eign ,jurisdiction & ! ,extradition ( ,crim9als 7#ahei74 ,he 0 ,*ancellor ( ! ,ex*equ] 9 #ahee & ,home ,secret>y 9 #ahei4 #bhc ,h5ry ,mald5 7#ahjj-ahgf71 a classical s*ol>1 fell[ ( ,tr9ity ,college1 ,cambridge1 & pr(essor ( ,greek at ,univ]sity ,college 7#ahca-ahgf71 !n 7#ahca7 ! ,univ]sity ( ,london4 ,he wrote a ,hi/ory ( ,rome to #cij ,b4 ,c4 7#ahcj71 & ,on ! ,orig9 ( ,univ]sities & ,academical ,degrees 7#ahce74 #bhd ,h5ry ,longueville ,mansel 7#ahbj-ahga71 !ologian & metaphysician1 read] 9 !ology at ,magdal5 ,college1 ,ox=d 7#ahee71 & pr(essor ( ecclesia/ical hi/ory & ,dean ( ,/4 ,paul's 7#ahff74 ,he wrote on metaphysics1 & 8 ,bampton ,lectures 7#aheh7 7 repr9t$ sev]al times4 #bhe ,hejus gave freely1 gave freely4 ,god is propiti\s1 ,god is favorable to him :o gives freely4 ,god is honor$ ) a banquet ( eggs at ! cross roads1 ! god ( ! _w4 ,god1 ) b5ignant _s1 desir$ 9 sacrifice a goat1 a bull to be c>ri$ )9 ! prec9cts ( ! holy place4 ,god1 twice propitiat$1 blesses ! pit ( ! sacr$ libation4 #bhf ,eudoxus ( ,cnidus 7#djh-cee ,b4 ,c47 _h mu* to d ) ! e>ly sci5tific a/ronomy ( ! ,greeks4 ,! fif? book ( ,euclid is g5]ally attribut$ to him4 ,8 a/ronomical works are kn[n *iefly ?r\gh ! poetical v]sion ( ,aratus m5tion$ 9 note #ac1 page #afg4 #bhg ,simplicius1 a native ( ,cilicia1 liv$ 9 ! #f? c5tury ( our era4 ,he 0 driv5 f ,a!ns by ,ju/9ian & w5t to ,p]sia 7#eca71 b he return$ lat] & _h "s fame z a tea*]4 #bhh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #afj1 note #c #cdh4 #bhi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gf1 note #c #aab4 #bij ,?r\gh "r & wrong4 #bia ,x is !re=e to arrive at ?is p>allelism1 or to pres]ve x1 t ,cop]nicus fe>$ to be oblig$ to h rec\rse to ?is equal & opposite movem5t :i* de/roys ! effect :i* he attribut$ s freely to ! fir/1 ( d]ang+ ! p>allelism4 #bib ,a contempor>y ( ,plato & a disciple ( ,ari/otle4 #bic ,meton's sol/ice1 ! beg9n+ ( ! ,metonic cycles1 has be5 plac$ at #dcb ,b4 ,c4 ,ptolemy /ates t he made ! l5g? ( ! ye> #cfe-a_/d #a_/gb days4 #bid ,aratus liv$ ab\t #bgj ,b4 ,c41 at ! c\rt ( ,antigonus ( ,mac$onia1 & probably practic$ m$ic9e !re4 ,he 0 ! au?or ( two a/ronomical poems1 ! ,greek3 ,pha9om5a1 app>5tly bas$ on ! lo/ "w ( ,eudoxus1 & ! ,greek3 ,dioseeia bas$ on ,ari/otle's ,meteorologica & ,de ,signis ,v5torum ( ,!ophra/us4 #bie ,! n9ete5 7-ye>7 cycle ( ! %9+ sun4 #bif ,claudius ,salmasius 7#aehh-afec71 or ,claude ,saumaise1 0 a di/+ui%$ classici/1 & pr(essor at ! ,univ]sity ( ,leyd54 ,! ^w ,greek3 eleioio means ,elian1 ?us mak+ ! phrase ref] to ! brilliant "o ( ,elis4 #big ,sir ,william ,br[n 7#aghd-ahfd74 ,9 #ahjj ! family mov$ to ,baltimore1 & !re ! fa!r1 ,alex&] ,br[n1 became prom95t 9 ! l95 trade4 ,william w5t to ,liv]pool :]e he acquir$ great weal? z a m]*ant & bank]4 ,he 0 made a b>onet 9 #ahfc4 #bih ,rob]t ,l[e 7#ahaa-ahib71 visc\nt ,%]brooke1 0 a fell[ ( ,magdal5 ,college1 ,ox=d 7#ahce74 ,he w5t to ,au/ralia 9 #ahdb & 0 v successful at ! b>4 ,he return$ to ,engl& 9 #ahej & became lead] writ] on ! ,times4 ,he 0 _m ye>s 9 p>liam5t1 & 9 #ahhj 0 rais$ to ! pe]age4 #bii ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #db1 note #d #bd4 #cjj ,francis ,walk+ame 7fl4 ab\t #agea-aghe71 ^: ,tutor's ,assi/ant w5t ?r\gh _m editions f #agea-ahed4 #cja ,davies ,gilb]t 7#agfg-ahci74 ,8 family "n 0 ,giddy1 b he assum$ 8 wife's "n4 ,he sat 9 p>liam5t f #ahjf to #ahcb4 ,9 #ahai he secur$ ! e/abli%m5t ( ! ,cape ( ,good ,hope obs]vatory4 ,he 0 ,treasur] 7#ahbj-ahbg7 & ,presid5t 7#ahbg-ahcj7 ( ! ,royal ,society4 #cjb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ee1 note #b #fc4 #cjc ,sir ,jona?an ,fr$]ick ,pollock 7#aghc-ahgj7 ent]$ p>liam5t 9 #ahca & 0 knight$ 9 #ahcd4 #cjd ,joseph ,hume 7#aggg-ahee7 ent]$ p>liam5t 9 #ahab & = ?irty ye>s 0 lead] ( ! ,radical p>ty4 #cje ,:at6 :5 ,i say1 ',nicole1 br+ me my slipp]s1' is t prose8 #cjf ,capta9 ,basil ,hall 7#aghh-ahdd71 a naval (fic]1 c>ri$ on a s]ies ( p5dulum obs]vations 9 #ahbj-ahbb1 :ile on a cruise ( ! we/ coa/ ( ,nor? ,am]ica4 ,! results 7 publi%$ 9 #ahbc 9 ! ,philosophical ,transactions4 ,he also wrote two popul> works on travel t w5t ?r\gh num]\s editions4 #cjg ,an?ony ,a%ley ,coop] 7#ahja-ahhe71 ,e>l ( ,%aftesbury4 ,8 "n is connect$ ) philan?ropic "w & factory legislation4 #cjh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bjg1 note #ab #dfi4 #cji ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hj1 note #e #aai4 #caj ,sir ,?omas ,macle> 7#agid-ahgi71 an ,iri%man by bir?1 became ,a/ronom] ,royal at ! ,cape ( ,good ,hope 9 #ahcc4 ,he 0 an indefatigable obs]v]4 ,he 0 knight$ 9 #ahfj4 #caa ,?omas ,romney ,rob9son 7#agib-ahhb71 ano!r ,iri% a/ronom] ( prom95ce4 ,he 0 a deputy pr(essor at ,tr9ity ,college1 ,dubl91 b took *>ge ( ! ,armagh obs]vatory 9 #ahbc & rema9$ !re until 8 dea?4 #cab ,sir ,james ,s\? 7#aghe-ahfg7 0 9 e>ly life a surgeon1 b gave up 8 practice 9 #ahaf & fitt$ up a private obs]vatory4 ,he contribut$ to ! sci5ce ( a/ronomy1 p>ticul>ly ) respect to ! /udy ( d\ble />s4 #cac ,sir ,john ,wrottesley 7#agih-ahfg71 second ,b>on ,wrottesley4 ,l ,sir ,james ,s\?1 he took up ! /udy ( a/ronomy aft] a pr(essional c>e]1--9 8 case 9 law4 ,he built a private obs]vatory 9 #ahbi & made a long s]ies ( obs]vations1 publi%+ ?ree /> catalogues4 ,he 0 presid5t ( ! ,a/ronomical ,society f #ahda to #ahdc1 & ( ! ,royal ,society f #ahed to #aheg4 #cad ,he seems to h writt5 no?+ else4 #cae ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #fh1 note #adg4 #caf ,! wills are free1 & ,i wi% nei!r ! "o nor ! o!r4 #cag ,! =ce ( in]tia conqu]$4 #cah ,r$die also wrote ,! ,me*anics ( ! ,heav5s1 ref]r$ to lat] 9 ?is "w4 ,he mu/ n be confus$ ) ,judge ,james ,r$die 7#aggc-aheb71 ( ,glasg[1 :o wrote on int]national law1 al?\gh ?is is done 9 ! pr9t$ edition ( ! ,briti% ,museum catalogue1 = he is m5tion$ by ,de ,morgan some:at lat] z alive 9 #ahfb4 #cai ,h5ry ,dunn+ ,macleod 7#ahba-aijb71 a lawy] & writ] on political economy1 0 a ,scot*man by bir?4 ,he wrote on economical que/ions1 & lectur$ on bank+ at ,cambridge 7#ahgg7 & at ,k+'s ,college1 ,london 7#ahgh74 ,he 0 a free lance 9 8 field1 & 0 n consid]$ or?odox by ! majority ( economi/s ( 8 "t4 ,he 0 an unsuccessful c&idate = ! *airs ( political economy at ,cambridge 7#ahfc71 ,ed9burgh 7#ahga71 & ,ox=d 7#ahhh74 #cbj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #beb1 note #b #egf4 #cba ,francis ,h5ry ,la+ 7#ahaf-ahhi7 0 a graduate ( ,que5's ,college1 ,cambridge1 & a cl]gyman 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& until #ahdf1 :5 he ent]$ ! ,*ur* ( ,rome4 ,he taught 9 v>i\s ,jesuit colleges until #ahfb1 :5 8 ecc5tricity 0 too m>k$ to w>rant ! ,*ur* 9 all[+ him to cont9ue4 ,he publi%$ v>i\s controv]sial writ+s dur+ 8 lat] ye>s4 ,( c\rse if he _h kn[n ! works ( ,wessel1 ,gaus1 ,buee1 ,arg&1 & o!rs1 he w\ld n h made su* a sorry exhibition ( 8 ignorance ( ma!matics4 #cbb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cbi1 note #a #gje4 ,! book w5t into a second edition 9 #ahfd4 #cbc ,?omas ,w$dle 7#ahag-ahec7 01 at ! "t ( publi%+ ?is pap]1 a tea*] 9 a private s*ool4 ,9 #ahea he became pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,s&hur/4 ,he contribut$ sev]al pap]s to ! ,cambridge & ,dubl9 ,ma!matical ,j\rnal1 *iefly on geometry4 #cbd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #aji1 note #bje4 #cbe ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ff1 note #adc4 #cbf ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #aea1 note #bfh4 #cbg ,george ,b>rett 7#ageb-ahba7 work$ f #aghf to #ahaa on a set ( life insurance & annuity tables4 ,he inv5t$ a plan kn[n z ! column> me?od = ! con/ruction ( su* tables1 & z ,de ,morgan /ates1 ?is 0 publi%$ by ,francis ,baily1 appe>+ 9 ! app5dix to 8 "w on annuities1 9 ! edition ( #ahac4 ,"s ( 8 tables 7 us$ 9 ,babbage's ,comp>ative ,view ( ! v>i\s ,in/itutions = ! ,assurance ( ,lives 7#ahbf74 #cbh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cji1 note #b #fgj4 #cbi ,?is 0 8 ,practical %ort & direct ,me?od ( ,calculat+ ! ,log>i?m ( any giv5 ,numb]1 & ! ,numb] correspond+ to any giv5 ,log>i?m 7#ahdi74 #ccj ,?is is ,william ,neile 7#afcg-afgj71 gr&son ( ,ri*>d ,neile 7n ,neal71 ,ar*bi%op ( ,york4 ,at ! age ( #ai1 9 #afeg1 he gave ! fir/ rectification ( ! semicubical p>abola4 ,al?\gh he communicat$ x to ,br\nck]1 ,wr51 & o!rs1 x 0 n publi%$ until #afci1 :5 x appe>$ 9 ,john ,wallis's ,de ,cycloide4 #cca ,i myself 0 a consid]able "p4 #ccb ,he also wrote ,a ,glance at ! ,univ]se 7#b;d ?\s& 9 #ahfb71 & ,! ,resurrection ,body 7#ahfi74 #ccc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #fc1 note #a #gd4 #ccd ,z ,swift gave x 9 8 ,poetry4 ,a ,rhapsody1 x is z foll[s3 ,s1 naturali/s obs]ve1 a flea ,has small] fleas t on him prey2 ,& ^! h small] /ill to bite 'em4 ,& s proce$ ad inf9itum4 #cce ,p]haps #a1fjj1jjj1jjj ye>s1 if ,boltwood's rec5t computations bas$ on radium dis9tegration /& ! te/4 ,?is w\ld mean1 accord+ to ,mac,curdy's e/imate1 #fj1jjj1jjj ye>s s9ce life fir/ appe>$ on ! e>?4 #ccf ,de ,morgan wrote bett] ?an he knew1 = ?is "w1 ! ,allgeme9e ,encyclopa$ie d] ,wiss5s*aft5 und ,ku5/e1 begun at ,leipsic 9 #ahah1 is /ill 7#aiac7 unf9i%$4 ,section ,i1 ,a-,g1 consi/s ( #ii p>ts 9 #ef volumes2 ,section ,,ii1 ,h-,n1 consi/s ( #dc volumes & is n yet complet$2 & ,section ,,iii1 ,o-,z1 consi/s ( #be volumes ?us f>1 ) mo/ ( ! "w /ill to be done4 ,johann ,samuel ,ers* 7#agff-ahbh71 ! f\nd]1 0 head libr>ian at ,halle4 ,johann ,gottfri$ ,grub] 7#aggd-ahea71 8 associate1 0 pr(essor ( philosophy at ! same univ]sity4 #ccg ,william ,h[itt 7#agib-ahgi7 0 a poet1 a spirituali/1 & a miscellane\s writ]4 ,he & 8 wife became spirituali/s ab\t #ahej4 ,he wrote num]\s popul> works on travel1 nature & hi/ory4 #cch ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ee1 note #ajh4 #cci ,z w be inf]r$ f ! text1 ,c4 ,d4 0 ,mrs4 ,de ,morgan1 & ,a4 ,b4 0 ,de ,morgan4 #cdj ,jean ,mesli] 7#afgh-agcc71 cure ( ,e/repigny1 9 ,*ampagne1 0 a skeptic1 b prea*$ only /rict or?odoxy to 8 p4 ,x 0 only 9 8 manuscript1 ,mon ,te/am5t1 t 0 publi%$ aft] 8 dea?1 & t caus$ a great s5sation 9 ,france1 t 8 antagonism to ,*ri/ianity became kn[n4 #cda ,b>on ,za* relates t a fri5d ( 81 9 a writ+ int5d$ = publication1 said ,un esprit doit se frott] contre un autre4 ,! c5sors /ruck x out4 ,! ,au/rian police h a ke5 eye = consequ5ces4--,a4 ,de ,m4 ,"o m9d mu/ rub aga9/ ano!r4 ,on ,b>on ,za*1 see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #de1 note #d4 #cdb ,ref]r+ to ! fir/ ,"l ,eldon 7#agea-ahch71 :o 0 ,"l ,*ancellor f #agii to #ahbg1 ) ! exception ( "o ye>4 #cdc ,sleep+ p[]4 #cdd ,causes sleep4 #cde ,ri*>d ,hook] 7c4 #aeed-afjj71 a !ologian1 ! able/ liv+ advocate ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& z by law e/abli%$4 #cdf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gf1 note #c #aab4 #cdg ,o!r ,i1--o!r self4 #cdh ,?is utt] rejection has be5 repeat$ 7#ahgb7 by ! same writ]4--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 #cdi ,edw>d ,j5n] 7#agdi-ahbc7 0 a physician & biologi/4 ,8 fir/ exp]im5ts 9 vacc9ation 7 made 9 #agif1 & 8 discov]y 0 publi%$ 9 #agih4 #cej ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ch1 note #hj4 #cea ,y w g mo/ safely 9 ! middle 7way74 #ceb ,pi]re ,joseph ,arson 0 kn[n e>ly 9 ! #ai? c5tury = 8 controv]sy ) ,ho5e ,wronski ! ma!matician1 :om he attack$ 9 8 ,docum5t p\r l'hi/oire des gr&s f\rbes qui ont figure sur la t]re 7#ahag-ahah74 #cec ,we ent] ! c\rse by night & are consum$ by fire4 #ced ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ea1 note #c #ea4 #cee ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ccf1 note #h #gac4 #cef ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #acg1 note #h #bhf4 #ceg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bbi1 note #b #eae4 #ceh ,ri*>d ,cobd5 7#ahjd-ahfe71 ! cotton manufactur] & /atesman :o 0 prom95t 9 8 advocacy ( ! repeal ( ! ,corn ,laws4 #cei ,james ,smi? 7#agge-ahci71 solicitor to ! ,bo>d ( ,ordnance4 ,) 8 bro!r ,horatio he wrote num]\s satires4 ,8 ,horace 9 ,london 7#ahac7 imitat$ ! ,roman poet4 ,8 works 7 collect$ & publi%$ 9 #ahdj4 #cfj ,samuel ,butl] 7#afab-afhj71 ! poet & satiri/1 au?or ( ,hudibras 7#affc-afgh74 #cfa ,is x n f9e to be sure ( "o's action :5 ent]+ 9 a combat ) ano!r8 ,!re1 pu% me a little 9 ord] to see4 ,,nicole4 ,well6 :at's ! matt]8 ,m4 ,,j\rda94 ,sl[ly4 ,ho !re6 ,ho6 g5tly4 ,deuce take ! rascal6 ,,nicole4 ,y told me to pu%4 ,m4 ,,j\rda94 ,yes1 b y pu%$ me en ti]ce1 be=e y pu%$ en qu>te1 & y did n give me "t to p>ry4 #cfb ,john ,ab]ne?y 7#agfd-ahca71 ! fam\s physician & surgeon4 #cfc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajb1 note #e #age4 #cfd ,) :at measure ye mete1 x %all be measur$ to y aga94 #cfe ,eusebius ( ,caes>ea 7c4 #bfj-cdj71 lead] ( ! mod]ate p>ty at ! ,c\ncil ( ,nicaea1 & au?or ( a ,hi/ory ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* 9 t5 books 7c4 #cbd ,a4 ,d474 #cff ,na?aniel ,l>dn] 7#afhd-agfh71 a non-con=mi/ m9i/] & "o ( ! fir/ to advocate ! sci5tific /udy ( e>ly ,*ri/ian lit]ature4 #cfg ,h5ry ,al=d 7#ahaj-ahga7 ,dean ( ,cant]bury 7#aheg-ahga7 & editor ( ! ,greek ,te/am5t 7#ahdi-ahfa74 #cfh ,! "w 0 ,! ,numb] & ,names ( ! ,apocalyptic ,bea/s3 ) an explanation & application4 ,"p ,i4 ,london1 #ahdh1 z m5tion$ bel[4 ,?om also wrote ,! ,assurance ( ,fai?1 or ,calv9ism id5tifi$ ) ,univ]salism 7,london1 #ahcc71 & v>i\s o!r religi\s works4 #cfi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bbb1 note #ad #dij4 #cgj ,john ,hamilton ,?om 7#ahjh-ahid7 0 conv]t$ to ,unit>ianism & 0 long a m9i/] 9 t *ur*1 prea*+ 9 ! ,r5%aw ,/reet ,*apel f #ahca to #ahff4 ,de ,morgan ref]s to ! ,liv]pool ,unit>ian controv]sy conduct$ by ,james ,m>t9eau & ,h5ry ,giles 9 response to a *all5ge by ?irte5 ,anglican ,cl]gy4 ,9 #ahci ,?om contribut$ f\r lectures & a lett] to ?is controv]sy4 ,among 8 religi\s works 7 a ,life ( ,blanco ,:ite 7#ahde7 & ,hymns1 ,*ants1 & ,an!ms 7#ahed74 #cga ,! spell+ ( ^! names is occasionally *ang$ to meet ! condition t ! num]ical value ( ! lett]s %all be #fff1 ! numb] ( ! bea/ ( ,revelations4 ,! names include ,julius ,caes>2 ,val]ius ,jovius ,diocletianus 7#bdi-cac71 emp]or f #bhg to #cje1 p]secutor ( ! ,*ri/ians2 ,l\is1 presumably ,l\is ,,xiv2 ,g]b]t 7#idj-ajjc71 :o reign$ z ,pope ,sylve/] ,,ii f #iii to #ajjc1 kn[n to ma!maticians = 8 abacus & 8 int]e/ 9 geometry1 & accus$ by 8 oppon5ts z be+ 9 league ) ! devil2 ,l9us1 ! second ,bi%op ( ,rome1 ! successor ( ,pet]2 ,camillo ,borghese 7#aeeb-afba71 :o reign$ z ,pope ,paul ,v f #afje to #afba1 & :o excommunicat$ all ,v5ice 9 #afjf = its claim to try ecclesia/ics be=e lay tribunals1 ?us tak+ a position :i* he 0 =c$ to ab&on2 ,lu!r1 ,calv92 ,laud 7see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ade1 note #g #cjg72 ,g5s]ic 7c4 #djf-dgg71 k+ ( ! ,v&als1 :o sack$ ,rome 9 #dee & p]secut$ ! or?odox ,*ri/ians 9 ,africa2 ,boniface ,,iii1 :o 0 pope = n9e mon?s 9 #fjf2 ,beza 7see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ff1 note #f #hc72 ,mohamm$2 ,greek3 braski1 :o 0 ,giovanni ,angelo ,bras*i 7#agag-agii71 & :o reign$ z ,pope ,pius ,,vi f #agge to #agii1 dy+ 9 captivity because he decl9$ to resign 8 temporal p[] to ,napoleon2 ,bonap>te2 &1 "u ,greek3 ,ion ,paune1 possibly ,pope ,john ,,xiv1 :o reign$ 9 #ihc & #ihd dur+ ! abs5ce ( ,boniface ,,vii 9 ,con/ant9ople4 #cgb ,! ,greek words & names are also occasionally misspell$ s z to fit !m to ! numb] #fff4 ,!y are ,greek3 ,late9os 7,lat971 ,greek3 he lat9e basileia 7! ,lat9 k+dom71 ,greek3 ekklesia italika 7! ,italian ,*ur*71 ,greek3 euan?as 7bloom+71 ,greek3 teitan 7,titan71 ,greek3 arn\me 7r5\nce71 ,greek3 lampetis 7! lu/r\s71 ,greek3 ho niketes 7conqu]or71 ,greek3 kakos hodegos 7bad guide71 ,greek3 ale!s blab]os 7tru?ful h>mful "o71 ,greek3 palai baskanos 7a sl&]] ( old71 ,greek3 amnos adikos 7unmanageable lamb71 ,greek3 antemos 7,antemos71 ,greek3 g5s]ikos 7,g5s]ic71 ,greek3 eu9as 7) /\t fib]s71 ,greek3 ,b5$iktos 7,b5$ict71 ,greek3 ,bonibazios g4 papa x4 e4 e4 e4 a4 7,boniface ,,iii1 pope #fh1 bi%op ( bi%ops ,i71 ,greek3 oulpios 7baneful71 ,greek3 dios eimi he h]as 7,i1 a god1 am !71 ,greek3 he missa he papike 7! papal brief71 ,greek3 l\!rana 7,lu!ran71 ,greek3 saxoneios 7,saxon71 ,greek3 ,bezza anti!os 7,beza antigod71 ,greek3 he alazoneia bi\ 7! illusion ( life71 ,greek3 ,maometis 7,mahomet72 ,greek3 ,maometes b4 7,mahomet ,,ii71 ,greek3 !os eimi epi gaies 7,i am "l ov] ! e>?71 ,greek3 iapetos 7,iapetos1 fa!r ( ,atlas71 ,greek3 papeiskos 7,papeiskos71 ,greek3 dioklasianos 7,diocletian71 ,greek3 *e9a 7,*e9a ,ca98 ,*9a871 ,greek3 braski 7,bras*i1 z expla9$ 9 note #aj71 ,greek3 ,ion ,paune 7,paunian violet1 b see note #aj71 ,greek3 k\poks 7c[pox71 ,greek3 ,bonnep>te 7,bonnep>te71 ,greek3 ,n4 ,bonep>te 7,n4 ,bonep>te71 ,greek3 euporia 7facility71 ,greek3 p>adosis 7surr5d]71 ,greek3 to mega!rion 7! mega!reum1 ! bea/74 #cgc ,james ,wap%>e1 ^: ,h>mony ( ! ,^w ( ,god 9 ,_s & 9 ,tru? appe>$ 9 #ahdi4 #cgd ,! lit]ature relat+ to ! ,swa/ika is too ext5d$ to p]mit ( any adequate summ>y 9 ^! notes4 #cge ,h5ry ,edw>d ,mann+ 7#ahjh-ahib71 at fir/ an ,anglican cl]gyman1 he became a ,roman ,ca?olic prie/ 9 #ahea1 & became ,c>d9al 9 #ahge4 ,he succe$$ ,c>d9al ,wiseman z ,ar*bi%op ( ,we/m9/] 9 #ahfe4 ,he wrote a numb] ( religi\s works4 #cgf ,john ,bright 7#ahaa-ahhi71 ,quak]1 cotton manufactur]1 & /atesman4 ,he work$ ) ,cobd5 = free trade1 peace1 & re=m ( ! electorate4 #cgg ,! fallacy ( _m que/ions4 #cgh ,william ,wilb]=ce 7#agei-ahcc71 be/ kn[n = 8 long fight = ! abolition ( ! slave trade4 #cgi ,ri*>d ,m>t9 7#aged-ahcd71 high %]iff ( ,c\nty ,galway & own] ( a l>ge e/ate 9 ,connem>a4 ,curi\sly en\gh1 he 0 kn[n bo? = 8 read9ess 9 duell+ & = 8 love = animals4 ,he 0 kn[n z ,humanity ,m>t91 & 9 #ahbb secur$ ! passage ( an act to prev5t ! cruel & improp] treatm5t ( cattle4 ,he 0 "o ( ! f\nd]s 7#ahbd7 ( ! ,royal ,society = ! ,prev5tion ( ,cruelty to ,animals4 ,he is usually consid]$ ! orig9al ( ,godfrey ,o',malley 9 ,lev]'s novel1 ,*>les ,o',malley4 #chj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #adi1 note #a #cbc1 also text on same page4 #cha ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dd1 note #i #cd1 also text1 ,vol4 ,i1 page #aaj4 #chb ,p5it5tial seat4 #chc ,well plac$ ^u ! cu%ion4 #chd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #eh1 note #aji4 #che ,he has lo/ ! "r ( be+ influ5c$ by evid5ce4 #chf ,hung up4 #chg ,a few ?+s to ! wise1 no?+ to ! unlett]$4 #chh ,! fallacy results f divid+ bo? memb]s ( an equation by #j1 x - #a be+ ! same z #a - #a1 & call+ ! quoti5ts f9ite4 #chi ,if y ord] him to ! sky he w g4 #cij ,similia similibus curant]1 ,l cures l1 ! homeopa?ic motto4 #cia ,)\t h>m to ! proprieties4 #cib ,:at are y do+8 ,i am /&+ "h4 #cic ,lors fei/ l',anglois tel signe4 ,la ma9 gaus*e t\te ouv]te il leva hault en l'a]1 puis f]ma au po+ les quatres doigtz d'icelle et le p\lce e/5du assit sus la p9ne du nez4 ,s\bda9 apres leva la dextre t\te ouv]te1 et t\te ouv]te la baissa1 joignant la p\lce au lieu que f]mait le petit doigt de la gaus*e1 et les quatre doigtz d'icelle m\voit l5tem5t en l'a]4 ,puis au reb\rs feit de la dextre ce qu'il avoit faict de la gaus*e1 et de la gaus*e ce que avoit faict de la dextre4--,a4 ,de ,m4 #cid ,suavit] 9 modo1 =tit] 9 re1 ,g5tle 9 mann]s1 firm 9 action4 #cie ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aja1 note #d #agd4 #cif ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cae1 note #c #fhf4 #cig ,h5ry ,fawcett 7#ahcc-ahhd7 became totally bl9d 9 #aheh1 b 9 spite ( ?is h&icap he became pr(essor ( political economy at ,cambridge & sat 9 p>liam5t = a numb] ( ye>s4 ,he *ampion$ ! cause ( re=m & 9 p>ticul> he 0 prom95t 9 ! protection ( ! native int]e/s ( ,india4 ,! e/abli%+ ( ! p>cels po/ 7#ahhb7 took place :ile he 0 po/ma/] g5]al 7#ahhj-ahhd74 #cih ,( c\rse ! :ole ?+ dep5ds ^u :at def9ition ( division is tak54 ,we c multiply #b ft4 by #c ft4 if we def9e multiplication s z to all[ x1 or #b ft4 by #c lb1 gett+ foot-p\nds1 z is done 9 physics4 #cii ,ri*>d ,milw>d 7#afji-afhj71 = s ! "n is usually giv51 0 rector ( ,great ,braxt$ 7,essex7 & canon ( ,w9dsor4 ,he 0 long ! amanu5sis ( ,john ,seld51 & ! ,table ,talk 0 publi%$ n9e ye>s aft] ,milw>d's dea?1 f notes t he left4 ,"s d\bt has be5 ca/ ^u ! au!nticity ( ! "w ow+ to _m ( ! op9ions t x ascribes to ,seld54 #djj ,john ,seld5 7#aehd-afed7 0 a juri/1 legal antiqu>y1 & ,ori5tal s*ol>4 ,he sat 9 ! ,long ,p>liam5t1 & :ile an advocate ( re=m he 0 n an extremi/4 ,he 0 s5t to ! ,t[] = 8 support ( ! resolution aga9/ tonnage & p\ndage1 9 #afbi4 ,8 ,hi/ory ( ,ty!s 7#afah7 0 suppress$ at ! dem& ( ! bi%ops4 ,8 ,de ,diis ,syriis 7#afag7 is /ill e/eem$ a classic on ,semitic my?ology4 #dja ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #db1 note #d #bd4 #djb ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bdi1 note #cih4 #djc ,john ,palm] 7#agdb-ahah7 0 a !atrical manag]4 ,9 #aghb he set =? a plan = =w>d+ ! mails by /age coa*es in/ead ( by po/m54 ,pitt adopt$ ! plan 9 #aghd4 ,palm] 0 made comptroll]-g5]al ( ! po/ (fice 9 #aghf & 0 dismiss$ six ye>s lat] = arbitr>ily susp5d+ a deputy4 ,he _h be5 v]bally promis$ #b-a_/b on ! increas$ rev5ue1 b ,pitt gave him only a p5sion ( ,l#cjjj4 ,9 #ahac he 0 aw>d$ ,l#ej1jjj 9 addition to 8 p5sion4 #djd ,dionysius ,l>dn] 7#agic-ahei71 pr(essor ( natural philosophy 9 ,london ,univ]sity 7n[ ,univ]sity ,college74 ,8 ,cab9et ,cyclopa$ia 7#ahbi-ahdi7 conta9$ #acc volumes4 ,de ,morgan wrote on probabilities1 & ,l>dn] on v>i\s bran*es ( ma!matics1 & !re 7 _m o!r well-kn[n contributors4 ,l>dn] is said to h made #bjj1jjj on a lecture t\r 9 ,am]ica4 #dje ,?omas ,fys*e ,palm] 7#agdg-ahjb7 jo9$ ! ,unit>ians 9 #aghc1 & 9 #aghe took a *>ge 9 ,dundee4 ,he 0 arre/$ = s$ition because ( an address t x 0 falsely alleg$ t he gave be=e a society kn[n z ! ,fri5ds ( ,lib]ty4 ,z a matt] ( fact ! address 0 giv5 by an un$ucat$ weav]1 & ,palm] 0 m]ely ask$ to revise x1 decl9+ to d ev5 ?is4 ,nev]!less he 0 s5t5c$ to ,botany ,bay 7#agid7 = sev5 ye>s4 ,! trial ar\s$ great indignation4 #djf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hj1 note #e #aai4 #djg ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bdd1 note #cid4 #djh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ceb1 note #a #gca4 #dji ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ccb1 note #d #gji4 #daj ,! lawy]s are br\ght into c\rt2 let !m accuse ea* o!r4 #daa ,samuel ,rog]s 7#agfc-ahee71 ! poet & art connoisseur4 ,he decl9$ ! laureate%ip on ! dea? ( ,wordswor? 7#ahej74 ,byron1 8 pret5d$ fri5d1 wrote a lampoon 7#ahah7 ridicul+ 8 cadav]\s appe>ance4 #dab ,!odore ,edw>d ,hook 7#aghh-ahda71 ! well-kn[n wit4 ,he is satiriz$ z ,mr4 ,wagg 9 ,vanity ,fair4 ,! ,john ,bull 0 f\nd$ 9 #ahbj & ,hook 0 made editor4 #dac ,on pity+ ! h]etic4 #dad ,a t]m ( m$ieval logic4 ,b>b>a3 ,all ,m is ,p1 all ,s is ,m1 h5ce all ,s is ,p4 ,cel>5t3 ,no ,m is ,p1 all ,s is ,m1 h5ce no ,s is ,p4 #dae ,simply1 ,accord+ to :i*1 ,x does n foll[4 #daf ,o sweet s\l1 :at good %all ,i decl>e ,t h]et(ore 0 ?9e1 s9ce su* are ?y rema9s6 #dag ,/upid fell[6 #dah ,*ri/oph] ,b>k] 7c4 #aebi-aeii71 also call$ ,b>k>1 0 ! ,que5's pr9t]4 ,he began to publi% books 9 #aefi1 b did no actual pr9t+ until #aegf4 ,9 #aege ! ,g5eva ,bible 0 fir/ pr9t$ 9 ,engl&1 ! "w be+ done = ,b>k]4 ,he publi%$ #ch p>tial or complete editions ( ! ,bible f #aege to #aehh1 & #cd 7 publi%$ by 8 deputies 7#aehh-aeii74 #dai ,james ,frankl9 7#afig-agce7 0 born 9 ,bo/on1 ,mass41 & 0 s5t to ,london to le>n ! pr9t]'s trade4 ,he return$ 9 #agag & />t$ a pr9t+ h\se4 ,b5jam91 8 bro!r1 0 appr5tic$ to him b ran away 7#agbc74 ,james publi%$ ! ,new ,engl& ,c\rant 7#agba-agbg71 & ,b5jam9 is said to h begun 8 lit]>y c>e] by writ+ = x4 #dbj ,james ,hodd] 0 a writ+ ma/] 9 ,tok5h\se ,y>d1 ,lo?bury1 9 #affa1 & lat] kept a bo>d+ s*ool 9 ,bromley-by-,b[4 ,8 fam\s ari?metic appe>$ at ,london 9 #affa & w5t ?r\gh _m editions4 ,x 0 ! basis ( ,cock]'s "w4 7,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #db1 note #d #bd47 ,x 0 long ?\ght to h be5 ! fir/ ari?metic publi%$ 9 ,am]ica1 & x 0 ! fir/ ,engli% "o4 ,!re 01 h[ev]1 an ari?metic publi%$ mu* e>li] ?an ?is1 9 ,mexico1 ! ,sum>io comp5dioso 444 con algunas reglas tocantes al ,aritmetica1 by ,juan ,diaz ,freyle1 9 #aeef4 #dba ,h5ry ,mose1 ,hodd]'s successor1 kept a s*ool 9 ,%]borne ,lane1 ,london4 #dbb ,re> ,admiral ,sir ,francis ,beau=t 7#aggd-aheg71 ,f4,r4,s41 0 hydrograph] to ! ,navy f #ahbi to #ahee4 ,he prep>$ an atlas t 0 pr9t$ by ! ,society = ! ,diffusion ( ,useful ,k4 #dbc ,anto9e ,sabati] 7#agdb-ahag71 born at ,ca/res1 0 kn[n z ! ,abbe b 0 really no?+ m ?an a cl]c tonsure4 ,he liv$ at ,c\rt & 0 p5sion$ to write aga9/ ! philosoph]s ( ! ,voltaire gr\p4 ,he pos$ z ! def5d] ( morality1 a commodity ( :i* he seems to h possess$ n ! slighte/ trace4 #dbd ,maffeo ,b>b]9i 0 pope1 z ,urban ,,viii1 f #afbc to #afdd4 ,x 0 dur+ 8 ambiti\s reign t ,galileo 0 summon$ to ,rome to make 8 recantation 7#afcc71 ! exact nature ( :i* is /ill a matt] ( dispute4 #dbe ,?is ,bad5 ,p[ell 7#agif-ahfj7 0 ! ,savilian pr(essor ( geometry 7#ahbg-ahfj7 at ,ox=d4 #dbf ,memoirs ( ! fam\s bi%op ( ,*iapa1 by :i* x appe>s t he _h but*]$ or burn$ or dr[n$ t5 million infidels 9 ,am]ica 9 ord] to conv]t !m4 ,i believe t ?is bi%op exagg]at$2 b if we %\ld r$uce ^! sacrifices to five million victims1 ?is w\ld /ill be admirable4 #dbg ,alfonso ,x 7#abba-abhd71 kn[n z ,el ,sabio 7! ,wise71 0 int]e/$ 9 a/ronomy & caus$ ! ,alphons9e ,tables to be prep>$4 ,^! table 7 us$ by a/ronom]s = a long "t4 ,x is said t :5 ! ,ptolemaic sy/em ( ! univ]se 0 expla9$ to him he rem>k$ t if he _h be5 pres5t at ! ,creation he c\ld h %[n h[ to arrange ?+s 9 a mu* simpl] fa%ion4 #dbh ,george ,ri*>ds 7c4 #agfg-ahcg71 fell[ ( ,oriel 7#agij-agif71 ,bampton lectur] 7#ahjj71 ,vic> ( ,/4 ,m>t9's-9-!-,fields1 ,we/m9/] 7#ahbd71 & a poet ( no mean ability4 #dbi ,! ,aborig9al ,britons1 an excell5t poem1 by ,ri*>ds4 7,note by ,byron47--,a4 ,de ,m4 #dcj ,john ,watk9s 7d4 aft] #ahca71 a tea*] & miscellane\s writ]4 #dca ,fr$]ic ,%ob]l 7#agge-ahec71 a miscellane\s writ]4 #dcb ,he wrote1 besides ! ,aborig9al ,britons1 ,songs ( ! ,aborig9al ,b>ds 7#agib71 ,mod]n ,france3 a ,poem 7#agic71 ,od91 a drama 7#ahjd71 ,emma1 a drama on ! model ( ! ,greek !atre 7#ahjd71 ,poems 7#b volumes1 #ahjd71 & a ,monody on ! ,dea? ( ,"l ,nelson 7#ahjf74 #dcc ,h5ry ,kirke ,:ite 7#aghe-ahjf71 publi%$ 8 fir/ volume ( poems at ! age ( #ah4 ,s\!y & ,william ,wilb]=ce became int]e/$ 9 him & procur$ = him a siz>%ip at ,/4 ,john's ,college1 ,cambridge4 ,he at once %[$ great brilliancy1 b he di$ ( tub]culosis at ! age ( #ba4 #dcd ,john ,wolcot1 kn[n z ,pet] ,p9d> 7#agch-ahai71 0 a ,london physician4 ,he wrote num]\s satirical poems4 ,8 ,bozzy & ,piozzi1 or ! ,briti% ,biograph]s1 appe>$ 9 #aghf1 & rea*$ ! #i? edition 9 #aghh4 #dce ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bce1 note #h #ecb4 #dcf ,ri*>d ,payne ,knight 7#agej-ahbd7 0 a collector ( bronzes1 gems1 & co9s1 _m ( 8 pieces be+ n[ 9 ! ,briti% ,museum4 ,he sat 9 p>liam5t = tw5ty-six ye>s 7#aghj-ahjf71 b took no active "p 9 legislation4 ,he oppos$ ! acquisition ( ! ,elg9 ,m>bles1 hold+ !m to be ( little importance4 ,8 ,analytical ,inquiry into ! ,pr9ciples ( ,ta/e appe>$ 9 #ahjh4 #dcg ,m>io ,nizzoli 7#adih-aeff71 a well-kn[n /ud5t ( ,cic]o1 0 = a "t pr(essor at ! ,univ]sity ( ,p>ma4 ,8 ,obs]vationes 9 ,m4 ,tullium ,cic]onem appe>$ at ,pratalbo9o 9 #aece4 ,x 0 revis$ by 8 nephew "u ! title ,!saurus ,cic]onianus 7,v5ice1 #aegj74 #dch ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cad1 note #d #fha4 #dci ,l ! geomet]1 :o b5ds all 8 p[]s ,to measure ! circle1 & does n succe$1 ,?9k+ :at pr9ciple he ne$s4 #ddj ,francis ,qu>les 7#aeib-afdd71 a religi\s poet4 ,he wrote p>aphrases ( ! ,bible & num]\s elegies4 ,9 ! e>ly days ( ! revolution>y /ruggle he sid$ ) ! ,royali/s4 ,"o ( 8 mo/ popul> works 0 ! ,emblems 7#afce71 ) illu/rations by ,william ,m>%all4 #dda ,regnault de ,bec\rt wrote ,la ,creation du monde1 ou ,sy/eme d'organisation primitive suivi de l'int]pretation des pr9cipaux ph5om5es et accid5ts que se sont op]es dans la nature depuis l'orig9e de univ]s jusqu'a nos j\rs 7#ahaf74 ,?is may be ! "w translat$ by ,dalmas4 #ddb ,because x lacks a holy prophet4 #ddc ,angh]a4 ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #fj1 note #abg4 #ddd ,edmund ,curll 7#afge-agdg71 a well-kn[n booksell]1 publi%]1 & pamphlete]4 ,he 0 = a "t at ,! ,peacock )\t ,temple ,b>1 & lat] at ,! ,dial & ,bible aga9/ ,/4 ,dun/an's ,*ur*4 ,he 0 f9$ repeat$ly = publi%+ immoral works1 & once /ood 9 ! pillory = x4 ,he is ridicul$ 9 ! ,dunciad = hav+ be5 toss$ 9 a blanket by ! boys ( ,we/m9/] ,s*ool because ( an oration t displeas$ !m4 #dde ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #aji1 note #bjf4 #ddf ,encyclopa$ia4 #ddg ,au?or ( ! ,hi/oria ,naturalis 7#gg ,a4,d47 #ddh ,au?or ( ! ,de ,in/itutione ,oratorio ,libri ,,xii 7c4 #ia ,a4,d47 #ddi ,8 ,de ,ar*itectures ,libri ,x 0 n m]ely a "w on ar*itecture & build+1 b on ! education ( ! ar*itect4 #dej ,cyclophoria4 #dea ,william ,caxton 7c4 #adbb-;c4#adib71 sometime ,gov]nor ( ! ,company ( ,m]*ant ,adv5tur]s 9 ,bruges 7betwe5 #addi & #adgj74 ,he le>n$ ! art ( pr9t+ ei!r at ,bruges or ,cologne1 & betwe5 #adga & #adgg set up a press at ,we/m9/]4 ,tradition says t ! fir/ book pr9t$ 9 ,engl& 0 8 ,game & ,playe ( ,*esse 7#adgd74 ,! ,myrr\r ( ! ,worlde & ?'ymage ( ! same appe>$ 9 #adhj4 ,x conta9s a brief /atem5t on ari?metic1 ! fir/ ma!matics to appe> 9 pr9t 9 ,engl&4 #deb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #de1 note #f #dj4 ,de ,morgan is wrong z to ! date ( ! ,m>g>ita ,philosophica4 ,! fir/ edition appe>$ at ,freiburg 9 #aejc4 #dec ,reis* 0 confessor to ,maximilian ,i 7#adei-aeai71 ,k+ ( ! ,romans 7#adhf7 & ,emp]or 7#adic-aeai74 #ded ,joa*im ,/]ck ,r+elb]gh 7c4 #adii-;c4 #aecf71 tea*] ( philosophy & ma!matics 9 v>i\s cities ( ,france & ,g]many4 ,8 ,in/itutionum a/ronomic>um libri ,,iii appe>$ at ,basel 9 #aebh1 8 ,cosmographia at ,p>is 9 #aebi1 & 8 ,op]a at ,leyd5 9 #aeca4 #dee ,johannes ,he9ri* ,al/$ 7#aehh-afch7 0 pr(essor ( philosophy & !ology at 8 bir?place1 ,h]born1 9 ,nassau1 & lat] at ,weiss5b]g4 ,he publi%$ sev]al works1 includ+ ! ,elem5tale ma!maticum 7#afaa71 ,sy/ema physicae h>monicae 7#afab71 ,me?odus admir&orum ma!maticorum 7#afac71 ,encyclopa$ia septem tomis di/9cta 7#afcj71 & ! "w m5tion$ above4 #def ,johann ,jakob ,h(fmann 7#afce-agjf71 pr(essor ( ,greek & hi/ory at 8 bir?place1 ,basel4 ,he also wrote ! ,epitome metrica hi/oriae univ]salis civilis et sacrae ab orbe condito 7#afhf74 #deg ,ephraim ,*amb]s 7c4 #afhj-agdj71 a crot*ety1 p5uri\s1 b k9d-he>t$ free?9k]4 ,8 ,cyclopa$ia1 or an ,univ]sal ,diction>y 0 translat$ into ,fr5* & is said to h sugge/$ ! great ,encyclop$ie4 #deh ,encyclop$ie1 ou ,dictionnaire raisonne des sci5ces1 des arts et des meti]s1 p> un societe de g5s de lettres4 ,mis en ordre et publie p> ,m4 ,did]ot1 et quant a la p>tie ma!matique1 p> ,m4 d',alemb]t4 ,p>is1 #agea-aghj1 #ce volumes4 #dei ,f ! egg 7/ate74 #dfj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #chb1 note #ab #ghe4 #dfa ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #d1 note #ae4 #dfb ,9 morals no?+ %\ld s]ve man z a model b ,god2 9 ! arts1 no?+ b nature4 #dfc ,encyclop$ie ,me?odique1 ou p> ordre de mati]es4 ,p>is1 #aghb-ahcb1 #aff-a_/b volumes4 #dfd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #aic1 note #ccf4 #dfe ,encyclopa$ia ,metropolitana2 or1 ,univ]sal ,diction>y ( ,k4 ,london1 #ahde1 #bi volumes4 ,a second edition came out 9 #ahdh-aheh 9 #dj volumes4 #dff ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #acg1 note #h #bhf4 #dfg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hj1 note #e #aai4 #dfh ,de ,morgan %\ld be alive to satirize "s ( ! /atem5ts on ! hi/ory ( ma!matics 9 ! elev5? edition4 #dfi ,john ,pr+le ,ni*ol 7#ahjd-ahei71 ,regius pr(essor ( a/ronomy at ,glasg[ & a popul> lectur] on ! subject4 ,he lectur$ 9 ! ,unit$ ,/ates 9 #ahdh-ahdi4 ,8 ,views ( ! ,ar*itecture ( ! ,heav5s 7#ahch7 0 a v popul> "w1 & 8 ,planet>y ,sy/em 7#ahdh1 #ahej7 conta9s ! fir/ sugge/ion = ! /udy ( sun spots by ! aid ( photography4 #dgj ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #aji1 note #bjf4 #dga ,george ,long 7#ahjj-ahgi71 a native ( ,p\lton1 9 ,lanca%ire1 0 call$ to ! ,univ]sity ( ,virg9ia :5 he 0 only tw5ty-f\r ye>s old z pr(essor ( anci5t languages4 ,he return$ to ,engl& 9 #ahbh to become pr(essor ( ,greek at ,london ,univ]sity4 ,f #ahcc to #ahdi he edit$ ! tw5ty-n9e volumes ( ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia4 ,he 0 an au?ority on ,roman law4 #dgb ,a legal phrase1 ,qui tam pro dom9a reg9a1 quam pro se ipso sequitur1--,:o sues z mu* on ! ,que5's acc\nt z on 8 own4 #dgc ,ar?ur ,cayley 7#ahba-ahie7 0 a fell[ ( ,tr9ity ,college1 ,cambridge 7#ahdb-ahdf7 & 0 aft]w>ds a lawy] 7#ahdi-ahfc74 ,dur+ 8 f\rte5 ye>s at ! b> he publi%$ "s two hundr$ ma!matical pap]s4 ,9 #ahfc he became pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,cambridge1 & s rema9$ until 8 dea?4 ,8 collect$ pap]s1 n9e hundr$ 9 numb]1 7 publi%$ by ! ,cambridge ,press 9 #ac volumes 7#ahhi-ahih74 ,he contribut$ ext5sively to ! !ory ( inv>iants & cov>iants4 ,de ,morgan's ref]5ce to 8 co9+ ( new names is ju/ifi$1 al?\gh 8 contempor>y1 ,pr(essor ,sylve/]1 s f> surpass$ him 9 ?is respect z to h be5 dubb$ ! ma!matical ,adam4 #dgd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bf1 note #ef4 #dge ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aaa1 note #c #bjg4 #dgf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hg1 note #f #ace4 #dgg ,pi]re ,dupuy 7#aehb-afea7 0 a fri5d & relative ( ,de ,?\4 ,) ! collaboration ( 8 bro!r & ,nicolas ,rigault he publi%$ ! #afbj & #afbf editions ( ,de ,?\'s ,hi/ory4 ,he also wrote on law & hi/ory4 ,8 y\ng] bro!r1 ,jacques 7di$ 9 #afef71 edit$ 8 works4 ,! two _h a valuable collection ( books & manuscripts :i* !y bequea!d to ! ,royal ,libr>y at ,p>is4 #dgh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ea1 note #c #ea4 #dgi ,x 0 ,cosmo de' ,m$ici 7#aeij-afba7 :o 0 ! patron ( ,galileo4 #dhj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dj1 note #d #bj4 #dha ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajf1 note #d #ahh4 #dhb ,sir ,edw>d ,%]burne 7#afah-agjb71 a s*ol> ( consid]able reputation4 ,! ref]5ce by ,de ,morgan is to ,! ,sph]e ( ,m>cus ,manilius1 9 ! app5dix to :i* is a ,catalogue ( ,a/ronom]s1 anci5t & mod]n4 #dhc ,george ,p>k]1 second ,e>l ( ,macclesfield 7#afig-agfd74 ,he erect$ an obs]vatory at ,%irburn ,ca/le1 ,ox=d%ire1 9 #agci1 & fitt$ x out ) ! be/ equipm5t !n available4 ,he 0 ,presid5t ( ! ,royal ,society 9 #ageb4 #dhd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #adh1 note #bfc4 #dhe ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #adj1 note #g #bif4 #dhf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajf1 note #d #ahh4 #dhg ,edw>d ,b]n>d 7#afch-afif71 al?\gh ,savilian pr(essor ( a/ronomy at ,ox=d1 0 *iefly int]e/$ 9 ar*eology4 #dhh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajg1 note #a #aij4 #dhi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajg1 note #a #aij4 #dij ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ace1 note #c #bha4 #dia ,philip ,dorm] ,/anhope1 f\r? ,e>l ( ,*e/]field 7#afid-aggc71 well kn[n = ! lett]s writt5 to 8 son :i* 7 publi%$ po/hum\sly 7#aggd74 #dib ,pet] ,daval 7di$ 9 #agfc71 ,vice-,presid5t ( ! ,royal ,society1 & an a/ronom] ( "s ability4 #dic ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cgf1 note #a #gff4 #did ,william ,oughtr$ 7c4 #aegc-affj71 a fell[ ( ,k+'s ,college1 ,cambridge1 & aft]w>ds vic> ( ,aldbury1 ,surrey1 wrote ! be/-kn[n ari?metic & trigonometry ( 8 "t4 ,8 ,ari?meticae 9 ,num]o ,speciebus ,in/itutio 444 quasi ,clavis ,ma!maticae e/ 7#afca7 w5t ?r\gh _m editions & appe>$ 9 ,engli% z ,! ,key to ! ,ma!maticks new =g$ & fil$ 9 #afdg4 #die ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #adj1 note #e #bid4 #dif ,/eph5 ,jordan ,rigaud 7#ahaf-ahei7 0 s5ior assi/ant ma/] ( ,we/m9/] ,s*ool 7#ahdf7 & head ma/] ( ,que5 ,elizabe?'s ,s*ool at ,ipswi* 7#ahej74 ,he 0 made ,bi%op ( ,antigua 9 #aheh & di$ ( yell[ fev] ! foll[+ ye>4 #dig ,he also wrote a memoir ( 8 fa!r1 privately pr9t$ at ,ox=d 9 #ahhc4 #dih ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #fi1 note #c #if4 #dii ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajf1 note #d #ahh4 #ejj ,william ,gascoigne 0 born at ,middleton be=e #afab & 0 kill$ 9 ! battle ( ,m>/on ,moor 9 #afdd4 ,he 0 an a/ronom] & inv5t$ ! micromet] ) movable ?reads 7be=e #afci74 #eja ,se? ,w>d 7#afag-afhi7 0 depriv$ ( 8 fell[%ip at ,cambridge = refus+ to sign ! cov5ant4 ,he became pr(essor ( a/ronomy at ,ox=d 7#afdi71 ,bi%op ( ,exet] 7#affb71 ,bi%op ( ,salisbury 7#affg71 & ,*ancellor ( ! ,g>t] 7#afga74 ,he is be/ kn[n = 8 solution ( ,kepl]'s problem to approximate a planet's orbit1 :i* appe>$ 9 8 ,a/ronomia geometrica 9 #afef4 #ejb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aaj1 note #b #aih4 #ejc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajj1 note #b #agb4 #ejd ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajg1 note #a #aij4 #eje ,see ,vol4 ,i page #aad1 note #f #bbj4 #ejf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gg1 note #d #aah4 #ejg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #abe1 note #c #bec4 #ejh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aje1 note #b #ahf4 #eji ,he9ri* ,old5burgh 7#afbf-afgh7 0 consul 9 ,engl& = ! ,city ( ,brem51 8 bir?place1 & aft]w>ds became a private tea*] 9 ,london4 ,he became secret>y ( ! ,royal ,society & contribut$ on physics & a/ronomy to ! ,philosophical ,transactions4 #eaj ,?omas ,branck]1 or ,brank] 7#afcf-afgf7 wrote ! ,doctr9ae spha]icae adumbratio et usus globorum artificialium 7#affb7 & translat$ ! algebra ( ,rhonius ) ! help ( ,pell4 ,! latt] "w appe>$ "u ! title ( ,an ,introduction to ,algebra 7#affh71 & is notewor?y z hav+ br\ght be=e ,engli% ma!maticians ! symbol _/ = division4 ,! symbol nev] _h any /&+ on ! ,cont95t = ?is purpose1 b !reaft] became s popul> 9 ,engl& t x is /ill us$ 9 all ! ,engli%-speak+ _w4 #eaa ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aah1 note #a #bcj4 #eab ,pi]re ,b]tius 7#aefe-afbi7 0 a native ( ,fl&]s & 0 educat$ at ,london & ,leyd54 ,he became a pr(essor at ,leyd51 & lat] held ! *air ( ma!matics at ! ,college de ,france4 ,he wrote *iefly on geography4 #eac ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #big1 note #dhg4 #ead ,giovanni ,alphonso ,borelli 7#afjh-afgi7 0 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,mess9a 7#afdf-afef7 & at ,pisa 7#afef-afeg71 aft] :i* he taught 9 ,rome at ! ,conv5t ( ,/4 ,panteleon4 ,he wrote sev]al works on geometry1 a/ronomy1 & physics4 #eae ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #agb1 note #b #cha4 #eaf ,ignace ,ga/on ,p>dies 7c4 #afcf-afgc71 a ,jesuit1 pr(essor ( anci5t languages & lat] ( ma!matics & physics at ! ,college ( ,pau1 & aft]w>ds pr(essor ( rhetoric at ! ,college ,l\is-le-,gr& at ,p>is4 ,he wrote on geometry1 a/ronomy & physics4 #eag ,pi]re ,f]mat 0 born 9 #afjh 7or possibly 9 #aeie7 ne> ,t\l\se1 & di$ 9 #affe4 ,al?\gh connect$ ) ! p>liam5t ( ,t\l\se1 8 significant "w 0 9 ma!matics4 ,he 0 "o ( ! _w's g5iuses 9 ! !ory ( numb]s1 & 0 "o ( ! f\nd]s ( ! !ory ( probabilities & ( analytic geometry4 ,aft] 8 dea? 8 son publi%$ 8 edition ( ,diophantus 7#afgj7 & 8 ,v>ia op]a ma!matica 7#afgi74 #eah ,?is may be ,*ri/oph] ,t[nley 7#afjc-afgd7 ! antiqu>y1 or 8 nephew1 ,ri*>d1 :o improv$ ! micromet] already inv5t$ by ,gascoigne4 #eai ,adri5 ,auz\t a native ( ,r\51 :o di$ at ,rome 9 #afia4 ,he inv5t$ a screw micromet] ) movable ?reads 7#afff7 & made _m improvem5ts 9 a/ronomical in/rum5ts4 #ebj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ff1 note #i #hf4 #eba ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #abd1 note #g #bdh4 #ebb ,john ,ma*9 7d4 #agea7 0 pr(essor ( a/ronomy at ,gre%am ,college 7#agac-agea7 & secret>y ( ! ,royal ,society4 ,he translat$ ,newton's ,pr9cipia into ,engli%4 ,8 computation ( pi to #ajj places is giv5 9 ,william ,jones's ,synopsis palm>iorum ma!seos 7#agjf74 #ebc ,pi]re ,remond de ,montmort 7#afgh-agai7 0 canon ( ,notre ,dame until 8 m>riage4 ,he 0 a g5tleman ( leisure & devot$ himself to ! /udy ( ma!matics1 especially ( probabilities4 #ebd ,rog] ,cotes 7#afhb-agaf71 fir/ ,plumian pr(essor ( a/ronomy & physics at ,cambridge1 & editor ( ! second edition ( ,newton's ,pr9cipia4 ,8 po/hum\s ,h>monia ,m5sur>um 7#agbb7 conta9s ,cotes's ,!orem on ! b9omial equation4 ,newton said ( him1 ,if ,mr4 ,cotes _h liv$ we _h kn[n some?+4 #ebe ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ace1 note #c #bha4 #ebf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cgg1 note #d #gfi4 #ebg ,*>les ,r5e ,reyneau 7#afef-agbh7 0 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,ang]s4 ,8 ,analyse demontree1 ou ,mani]e de res\dre les problemes de ma!matiques 7#agjh7 0 a successful attempt to popul>ize ! !ories ( m5 l ,desc>tes1 ,newton1 ,leibnitz1 & ! ,b]n\llis4 #ebh ,brook ,taylor 7#afhe-agca71 secret>y ( ! ,royal ,society1 & /ud5t ( ma!matics & physics4 ,8 ,me?odus increm5torum directa et inv]sa 7#agae7 0 ! fir/ treatise on ! calculus ( f9ite diff]5ces4 ,x conta9$ ! well-kn[n !orem t be>s 8 "n4 #ebi ,pi]re ,l\is ,moreau de ,maup]tuis 7#afih-agei7 0 s5t ) ,clairaut 7#agce7 to measure an arc ( a m]idian 9 ,lapl&4 ,he 0 head ( ! physics dep>tm5t 9 ! ,b]l9 ,academy f #agde until #agec4 ,he wrote ,sur la figure de la t]re 7#agch7 & on geography & a/ronomy4 #ecj ,pi]re ,b\gu] 7#afih-ageh7 0 pr(essor ( hydrography at ,p>is1 & 0 "o ( ^? s5t by ! ,academy ( ,sci5ces to measure an arc ( a m]idian 9 ,p]u 7#agce74 ,! object ( ?is & ! "w ( ,maup]tuis 0 to det]m9e ! %ape ( ! e>? & see if ,newton's !ory 0 support$4 #eca ,*>les ,m>ie de la ,condam9e 7#agja-aggd7 0 a memb] ( ! ,p>is ,academy ( ,sci5ces & 0 s5t ) ,b\gu] to ,p]u1 = ! purpose m5tion$ 9 ! prec$+ note4 ,he wrote on ! figure ( ! e>?1 b 0 n a sci5ti/ ( high rank4 #ecb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #acf1 note #e #bhc4 #ecc ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bif1 note #dhc4 #ecd ,?omas ,bak] 7c4 #afbe-afhi7 gave a geometric solution ( ! biquadratic 9 8 ,geometrical ,key1 or ,gate ( ,equations unlock$ 7#afhd74 #ece ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #afj1 note #e #cej4 #ecf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hg1 note #d #acc4 #ecg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #acb1 note #b #bgb4 #ech ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aah1 second note #a #bca4 #eci ,! "n ( ,newton is s well kn[n t no note seems necess>y4 ,he 0 born at ,wool/horpe1 ,l9coln%ire1 9 #afdb1 & di$ at ,k5s+ton 9 #agbg4 #edj ,john ,keill 7#afga-agba71 pr(essor ( a/ronomy at ,ox=d f #agaj1 is said to h be5 ! fir/ to tea* ! ,newtonian physics by direct exp]im5t1 ! app>atus be+ inv5t$ by him = ! purpose4 ,he wrote on a/ronomy & physics4 ,8 ,epi/ola de legibus virium c5tripet>um1 9 ! ,philosophical ,transactions = #agjh1 accus$ ,leibnitz ( hav+ obta9$ 8 ideas ( ! calculus f ,newton1 ?us />t+ ! priority controv]sy4 #eda ,?omas ,digges 7d4 9 #aeie7 wrote ,an ,ari?meticall ,milit>e ,treatise1 nam$ ,/ratioticos 7#aegi71 & complet$ ,a geometrical practise1 nam$ ,pantometria 7#aega7 t _h be5 begun by 8 fa!r1 ,leon>d ,digges4 #edb ,john ,dee 7#aebg-afjh71 ! mo/ fam\s a/rolog] ( 8 day1 & some?+ ( a ma!matician1 wrote a preface to ,bill+sley's translation ( ,euclid into ,engli% 7#aegj74 #edc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gf1 note #c #aab4 #edd ,?omas ,h>riot 7#aefj-afba7 0 tutor 9 ma!matics to ,sir ,walt] ,raleigh1 :o s5t him to survey ,virg9ia 7#aehe74 ,he 0 "o ( ! be/ ,engli% algebrai/s ( 8 "t1 b 8 ,artis ,analyticae ,praxis ad ,aequationes ,algebraicas resolv5das 7#afca7 did n appe> until t5 ye>s aft] 8 dea?4 #ede ,?omas ,lydiat 7#aegb-afbf71 rector ( ,alk]ton1 devot$ 8 life *iefly to ! /udy ( *ronology1 writ+ ^u ! subject & tak+ issue ) ,scalig] 7#afja74 #edf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #fi1 note #c #if4 #edg ,walt] ,w>n] edit$ ,h>riot's ,artis ,analyticae ,praxis 7#afca74 ,t>porley is n kn[n 9 ma!matics4 #edh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aje1 note #b #ahf4 #edi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aae1 note #c #bbd4 #eej ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #cjj1 note #eji4 #eea ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajg1 note #a #aij4 #eeb ,sir ,samuel ,morl& 7#afbe-afie7 0 a diplomat & inv5tor4 ,= "s ye>s he 0 assi/ant to ,john ,pell1 !n ambassador to ,switz]l&4 ,he wrote on ari?metical in/rum5ts inv5t$ by him 7#afgc71 on hydro/atics 7#afig7 & on *ur* hi/ory 7#afeh74 #eec ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aec1 note #d #ccg4 #eed ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #he1 note #b #abi4 #eee ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #h #cc4 #eef ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dc1 note #g #cb4 #eeg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #chb1 note #ac #ghf4 ,! hi/ory ( ! subject may be foll[$ 9 ,braunmuehl's ,ges*i*te d] ,trigonometrie4 #eeh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cgg1 note #c #gfh4 #eei ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajh1 note #b #aib4 #efj ,mi*ael ,d>y wrote ,d>y's ,miscellanies 7#affi71 ,gaug+ epitomis$ 7#affi71 & ,! g5]al ,doctr9e ( ,equation 7#affd74 #efa ,john ,newton 7#afbb-afgh71 canon ( ,h]e=d 7#afgc71 educational re=m]1 & writ] on elem5t>y ma!matics & a/ronomy4 #efb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #hg1 note #d #acc4 #efc ,! av]age ( ! two equal altitudes ( ! sun be=e & aft] d9n]4 #efd ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #db1 note #d #bd4 #efe ,london1 #afgh4 ,x w5t ?\gh _m editions4 #eff ,?is ,i :o once 444 #efg ,ar?ur ,murphy 7#agbg-ahje7 work$ 9 a bank+ h\se until #aged4 ,he !n w5t on ! /age & met ) "s success at ,cov5t ,g>d54 ,8 fir/ com$y1 ,! ,appr5tice 7#agef7 0 s successful t he left ! /age & took to play writ+4 ,8 translation ( ,tacitus appe>$ 9 #agic1 9 f\r volumes4 #efh ,edmund ,w+ate 7#aeif-afef7 w5t to ,p>is 9 #afbd z tutor to ,pr9cess ,h5rietta ,m>ia & rema9$ !re sev]al ye>s4 ,he wrote ,l'usage de la regle de proportion 7,p>is1 #afbd1 ) an ,engli% translation 9 #afbf71 ,ari?metique ,log>i?metique 7,p>is1 #afbf1 ) an ,engli% translation 9 #afce71 & ,( ,natural & ,artificial ,ari?metick 7,london1 #afcj1 revis$ 9 #afej-afeb71 "p ,i ( :i* 0 "o ( ! mo/ popul> textbooks ev] produc$ 9 ,engl&4 #efi ,john ,lamb]t 7#afai-afid7 0 ,major-,g5]al dur+ ! ,revolution & help$ to draw up ! reque/ = ,cromwell to assume ! protectorate4 ,he 0 imprison$ 9 ! ,t[] by ! ,rump ,p>liam5t4 ,he 0 conf9$ 9 ,gu]nsey until ! cl&e/9e m>riage ( 8 daught] ,m>y to ,*>les ,hatton1 son ( ! gov]nor1 aft] :i* he 0 remov$ 7#affg7 to ,/4 ,ni*olas 9 ,plym\? ,s\nd4 #egj ,samuel ,fo/] 7d4 9 #afeb7 0 made pr(essor ( a/ronomy at ,gre%am ,college 9 ,m>*1 #afcf1 b resign$ 9 ,novemb] ( t ye>1 be+ succe$$ by ,mungo ,murray4 ,murray vacat$ 8 *air by m>riage 9 #afda & ,fo/] succe$$ him4 ,he wrote on diall+ & made a numb] ( improvem5ts 9 geometric in/rum5ts4 #ega ,twice ( ! ^w a m9i/]1 t is1 twice a m9i/] ( ! ,gospel4 #egb ,?is is ,! ,lives ( ! ,pr(essors ( ,gre%am ,college to :i* is prefix$ ! ,life ( ! ,f\nd]1 ,sir ,?omas ,gre%am1 ,london1 #agdj4 ,x 0 writt5 by ,john ,w>d 7c4 #afgi-ageh71 pr(essor ( rhetoric 7#agbj7 at ,gre%am ,college & vice-presid5t 7#ageb7 ( ! ,royal ,society4 #egc ,*>les ,montagu 7#affa-agae71 fir/ ,e>l ( ,halifax1 0 ,"l ( ! ,treasury 9 #afib1 & 0 creat$ ,b>on ,halifax 9 #agjj & ,visc\nt ,sunbury & ,e>l ( ,halifax 9 #agad4 ,he introduc$ ! bill e/abli%+ ! ,bank ( ,engl&1 ! bill becom+ a law 9 #afid4 ,he _h tr\bles ( 8 own1 )\t consid]+ ,newton1 = he 0 impea*$ 9 #agja1 & 0 ! subject ( a damag+ resolution ( c5sure z auditor ( ! ex*equ] 9 #agjc4 ,al?\gh no?+ came ( ei!r ( ^! attacks1 he 0 out ( (fice dur+ mu* ( ,que5 ,anne's reign4 #egd ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #cjb1 note #edg4 #ege ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aje1 note #b #ahf4 #egf ,james ,dodson 7d4 #ageg7 0 ma/] ( ! ,royal ,ma!matical ,s*ool1 ,*ri/'s ,hospital4 ,he 0 ,de ,morgan's great-gr&fa!r4 ,! ,anti-,log>i?mic ,canon 0 publi%$ 9 #agdb4 #egg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajf1 note #d #ahh4 #egh ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aaj1 note #b #aih4 #egi ,ri*>d ,busby1 7#afjf-afie71 ma/] ( ,we/m9/] ,s*ool 7#afdj7 _h among 8 pupils ,dryd5 & ,locke4 #ehj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajg1 note #a #aij4 #eha ,h]b]t ,?orndike 7#aeih-afgb71 fell[ ( ,tr9ity ,college1 ,cambridge 7#afbj-afdf71 & ,preb5d ( ,we/m9/] 7#affa71 0 a well-kn[n !ological writ] ( ! "t4 #ehb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #adj1 note #e #bid4 #ehc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ajh1 note #b #aib4 #ehd ,labor p]=m$ returns 9 a circle4 #ehe ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bjh4 #ehf ,:atev] objections "o may make to ! above argum5ts1 "o always falls into an absurdity4 #ehg ,see ,vol4 ,,ii4 page #aa1 note #bi4 ,! ,circle ,squ>$2 & ! solution ( ! problem adapt$ to expla9 ! diff]5ce betwe5 squ>e & sup]ficial measurem5t appe>$ at ,brighton 9 #ahfe4 #ehh ,& beyond t no?+4 #ehi ,gillott 7#agei-ahgc7 0 ! pione] mak] ( /eel p5s by ma*9]y1 r$uc+ ! price f #as4 ea* to #d;d4 a gross4 ,he 0 a great collector ( pa9t+s & old viol9s4 #eij ,william ,edw>d ,walk] wrote five works on circle squ>+ 7#ahec1 #ahed1 #aheg1 #ahfb1 #ahfd71 mo/ly & p]haps all publi%$ at ,birm+ham4 #eia ,solomon ,m4 ,dra* wrote ,an easy ,rule = =muliz+ all ,epicyclical ,curves 7,london1 #ahdi71 ,on ! ,circle area & ,heptagon-*ord 7,london1 #ahfd71 ,an easy g5]al ,rule = fill+ up all ,magic ,squ>es 7,london1 #ahgc71 & ,hebrew ,almanack-,signs 7,london1 #ahgg71 besides num]\s articles 9 j\rnals4 #eib ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #afh1 note #c #cga4 #eic ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bed1 note #b #ehj4 #eid ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ih1 note #f #afc4 #eie ,rob]t ,fludd or ,flud 7#aegd-afcg7 0 a physician ) a l>ge ,london practice4 ,he d5i$ ! diurnal rotation ( ! e>?1 & 0 attack$ by ,kepl] & ,m]s5ne1 & accus$ ( magic by ,gass5di4 ,8 ,apologia ,comp5diania1 ,frat]nitatem de ,rosea ,cruce suspicionis 444 maculis asp]sam1 v]itatis quasi ,fluctibus ablu5s 7,leyd51 #afaf7 is "o ( a l>ge numb] ( works ( ! my/ic type4 #eif ,consult ,to ! ,*ri/ianity ( ! ,age4 ,notes 444 compris+ an elucidation ( ! scope & cont5ts ( ! writ+s 444 ( ,dionysius ,&reas ,freh] 7#ahed74 #eig ,sir ,william ,rob]t ,grove 7#ahaa-ahif71 al?\gh call$ to ! b> 7#ahce7 & to ! b5* 7#ahec71 is be/ kn[n = 8 "w z a physici/4 ,he 0 pr(essor ( exp]im5tal philosophy 7#ahdj-ahdg7 at ! ,london ,in/itution1 & inv5t$ a batt]y 7#ahci7 kn[n by 8 "n4 ,8 ,correlation ( ,physical ,=ces 7#ahdf7 w5t ?r\gh six editions & 0 translat$ into ,fr5*4 #eih ,johann ,taul] 7c4 #acjj-acfa71 a ,dom9ican monk ( ,/rassburg1 a my/ic1 closely 9 t\* ) ! ,gottesfreunde ( ,basel4 ,8 ,s]mons fir/ appe>$ 9 pr9t at ,leipsic 9 #adih4 #eii ,p>acelsus 7c4 #adij-aeda74 ,8 real "n 0 ,!ophra/es ,bomba/ von ,hoh5heim1 & he took ! "n by :i* he is g5]ally kn[n because he held himself sup]ior to ,celsus4 ,he 0 a fam\s physician & ph>maci/1 b 0 also a my/ic & neo-,platoni/4 ,he lectur$ 9 ,g]man on m$ic9e at ,basel1 b lo/ 8 position ?r\gh ! opposition ( ! or?odox physicians & apo!c>ies4 #fjj ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bef1 note #b #ehh4 #fja ,philip ,s*w>z]d 7#adig-aefj7 0 pr(essor ( ,greek at ,witt5b]g4 ,he help$ ,lu!r ) 8 translation ( ! ,bible4 #fjb ,johann ,reu*l9 7#adee-aebb71 ! fir/ great ,g]man humani/1 0 v influ5tial 9 e/abli%+ ! /udy ( ,greek & ,hebrew 9 ,g]many4 ,8 lectures 7 mo/ly deliv]$ privately 9 ,heidelb]g & ,/uttg>t4 ,unlike ,melan*?on1 he rema9$ 9 ! ,ca?olic ,*ur*4 #fjc ,joseph ,*itty 7#aggf-ahda7 publi%$ 8 ,prec$5ts ( ,plead+ 9 #ahjh & 8 ,reports ( ,cases on ,practice & ,plead+ 9 #ahbj-bc 7#b volumes74 #fjd ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dd1 note #a #ce4 #fje ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dd1 note #d #ch4 #fjf ,jean ,pel]91 also kn[n z ,viator1 :o wrote on p]spective4 ,8 "w appe>$ 9 #aeje1 ) editions 9 #aeji & #aeba4 #fjg ,h5ry ,/eph5s4 ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #dd1 note #c #cg4 #fjh ,! well-kn[n gramm>ian 7#agde-ahbf74 ,he 0 born at ,swat>a1 9 ,p5nsylvania1 & practis$ law 9 ,new ,york until #aghd1 aft] :i* he resid$ 9 ,engl&4 ,8 gramm> 7#agie7 w5t ?r\gh #ej editions1 & ! abridgm5t 7#ahah7 ?r\gh #abj editions4 ,murray's fri5d ,dalton1 ! *emi/1 said t ( all ! contrivances inv5t$ by human +5uity = puzzl+ ! bra9s ( ! "y1 ,l9dley ,murray's gramm> 0 ! wor/4 #fji ,rob]t ,recorde 7c4 #aeaj-aeeh7 read & probably taught ma!matics & m$ic9e at ,cambridge up to #aede4 ,aft] t he taught ma!matics at ,ox=d & practis$ m$ic9e 9 ,london4 ,8 ,gr\nde ( ,artes1 publi%$ ab\t #aedj1 0 ! fir/ ari?metic publi%$ 9 ,engli% t _h any influ5ce4 ,x w5t ?r\gh _m editions4 ,! ,ca/le ( ,k appe>$ 9 #aeea4 ,x 0 a textbook on a/ronomy & ! fir/ to set =? ! ,cop]nican !ory 9 ,engl&4 ,l ,recorde's o!r works x 0 writt5 on ! cate*ism plan4 ,8 ,:et/one ( ,witte 444 conta9y+ !xtraction ( ,rootes3 ,! ,cosike practise1 ) ! rule ( ,equation3 & ! woorkes ( ,surde ,nombres appe>$ 9 #aeeg1 & x is 9 ?is "w t ! mod]n sign ( equality fir/ appe>s 9 pr9t4 ,! ^w ,cosike is an adjective t 0 us$ = a long "t 9 ,g]many z equival5t to algebraic1 be+ d]iv$ f ! ,italian cosa1 :i* /ood = ! unkn[n quantity4 #faj ,rob]t ,cecil 7c4 #aefc-afab71 fir/ ,e>l ( ,salisbury1 ,secret>y ( ,/ate "u ,elizabe? 7#aeif-afjc7 & "u ,james ,i 7#afjc-afab74 #faa ,9 ,am]ica ! ,g]man pronunciation is at pres5t univ]sal among ma!maticians1 z 9 ! case ( mo/ o!r ,g]man names4 ,?is is due1 no d\bt1 to ! great influ5ce t ,g]many has _h on ,am]ican education 9 ! la/ fifty ye>s4 #fab ,! late/ translit]ation is sub/antially ,k'ung-fu-tzvu4 #fac ,! t5d5cy seems to be1 h[ev]1 to adopt ! =ms us$ ( individuals or places z rapidly z ! mass ( p comes to be prep>$ = x4 ,?us ! spell+ ,leipzig1 in/ead ( ,leipsic1 is com+ to be v common 9 ,am]ica4 #fad ,sir ,edw>d ,coke 7#aeeb-afcd71 ! celebrat$ juri/4 #fae ,de?lef ,cluvi] or ,cluev] 7d4 #agjh at ,hamburg7 0 a nephew1 n a gr&son1 ( ,philippe ,cluvi]1 or ,philipp ,cluev] 7#aehj-;c4 #afbc74 ,de?lef travel$ 9 ,france & ,italy & !n taught ma!matics 9 ,london4 ,he wrote on a/ronomy & philosophy & also publi%$ 9 ! ,acta ,eruditorum 7#afhf7 8 ,s*$iasma geometricum de nova inf9itorum sci5tia4 ,quadratura circuli inf9itis modis demon/rata1 & 8 ,monitum ad geometras 7#afhg74 ,philippe 0 geograph] ( ! ,academy ( ,leyd54 ,8 ,introductionis 9 univ]sam geographiam tam vet]em quam novam libri sex appe>$ at ,leyd5 9 #afbd1 ab\t ! "t ( 8 dea?4 #faf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #abd1 note #g #bdh4 #fag ,b]n>d ,nieuw5tijt 7#afed-agah71 a physician & burgoma/] at ,purm]5d4 ,8 ,consid]ationes circa ,analyseos ad quantitates inf9ite p>vas applicatae ,pr9cipia et ,calculi ,diff]5tialis usum 7,am/]dam1 #afid7 0 attack$ by ,leibnitz4 ,he repli$ 9 8 ,consid]ationes secundae 7#afid71 & also wrote ! ,analysis ,inf9itorum1 seu ,curvil9eorum ,proprietates ex ,polygonorum ,natura d$uctae 7#afie74 ,8 mo/ fam\s "w 0 on ! exi/5ce ( ,god1 ,het ,regt ,gebruik d] ,w]elt ,bes*\w+5 7#agah74 #fah ,f a giv5 l9e to con/ruct etc4 #fai ,pirates d n fight "o ano!r4 #fbj ,claude ,mallem5s 7,mallem5t7 de ,messanges 7#afec-agbc7 0 pr(essor ( philosophy at ! ,college du ,plessis1 9 ,p>is1 = #cd ye>s4 ,! "w to :i* ,de ,morgan ref]s is probably ! ,fameux ,probleme de la quadrature du c]cle1 resolu geometriquem5t p> le c]cle et a ligne droite t appe>$ 9 #afhc4 #fba ,on ,ty*o ,brahe see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gf1 note #c #aab4 #fbb ,wilhelm ,fr$]ik von ,zytph5 also publi%$ ! ,tid5s ,/roem1 a *ronological table1 9 #ahdj4 ,! "w to :i* ,de ,morgan ref]s1 ! ,sol5s ,bevaegelse i ,v]d5srummet1 appe>$ fir/ 9 #ahfa4 ,de ,morgan seems to h miss$ 8 ,nogl ,ord om ,cirkel5s ,quadratur :i* appe>$ 9 #ahfe1 at ,cop5hag54 #fbc ,james ,joseph ,sylve/] 7#ahad-ahig71 pr(essor ( natural philosophy at ,univ]sity ,college1 ,london 7#ahcg-ahda71 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ! ,univ]sity ( ,virg9ia 7#ahda-ahde71 actu>y 9 ,london 7#ahde-ahee71 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,woolwi* 7#ahgg-ahhd7 & at ,johns ,hopk9s ,univ]sity1 ,baltimore 7#ahgg-ahhd71 & ,savilian pr(essor ( geometry at ,ox=d 7#ahhd-ahid74 #fbd ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gf1 note #c #aab4 #fbe ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #bje1 note #cdi4 #fbf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #gf1 note #c #aab4 #fbg ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #df1 note #a #db4 #fbh ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ahc1 note #cah4 #fbi ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #cba1 note #b #fia4 #fcj ,james ,mill1 born #aggc1 di$ #ahcf4 #fca ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #c1 note #aa4 #fcb ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #c1 note #ac4 #fcc ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #c1 note #ad4 #fcd ,?is anecdote is pr9t$ at page #d 7,vol4 ,,ii72 b z x is us$ 9 illu/ration "h1 & is giv5 m 9 detail1 ,i h n omitt$ x4--,s4,e4 ,de ,m4 #fce ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #d1 note #ae4 #fcf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #chb1 note #ac #ghf4 #fcg ,monsieur1 7a bn7_/n x1 :5ce ,god exi/s2 answ] t6 #fch ,monsieur1 y "k v well t y\r argum5t requires ! developm5t ( x accord+ to integral p[]s ( n4 #fci ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #aec1 note #d #ccg4 #fdj ,?omas ,love ,peacock 7#aghe-ahff7 an ,engli% noveli/ & poet4 #fda ,p]haps ,dr4 ,samuel ,w>r5 7#ahjg-ahgg71 ! au?or ( ,t5 ,?\s& a ,ye> 7s]ially 9 ,blackwood's 9 #ahci2 ,london1 #ahda74 #fdb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bee1 note #f #ehd4 #fdc ,f _m1 "o2 mu* 9 little2 ,ultima ,?ule 7! mo/ remote region72 )\t :i* n4 #fdd ,spurius ,maelius 7fl4 #ddj ,b4 ,c471 :o di/ribut$ corn freely among ! poor 9 ! fam9e ( #ddj ,b4 ,c4 & 0 assass9at$ by ! patricians4 #fde ,spurius ,cassius ,viscell9us1 ,roman consul 9 #ejb1 #dic1 & #dhf ,b4 ,c4 ,put to dea? 9 #dhe4 #fdf ,o :at a f9e be>+1 he said1 t has no bra94 #fdg ,sir ,william ,r[an ,hamilton4 ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ccb1 note #d #gji4 #fdh ,william ,all5 ,:itwor?1 ! au?or ( ! well-kn[n ,*oice & ,*ance 7,cambridge1 #ahfg71 & o!r works4 #fdi ,james ,maurice ,wilson1 ^: ,elem5t>y ,geometry appe>$ 9 #ahfh & w5t ?r\gh sev]al editions4 #fej ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #ahc1 note #cae4 #fea ,=ce ( in]tia conqu]$1 & ,victory 9 ! :ole heav5s4 #feb ,) all 8 might4 #fec ,george ,b]keley 7#afhe-agec71 ,bi%op ( ,cloyne1 ! ideali/ic philosoph] & au?or ( ! ,pr9ciples ( ,human ,k 7#agaj71 ,! ,analy/1 or a ,disc\rse address$ to an ,infidel ,ma!matician 7#agcd71 & ,a ,def5se ( ,free?9k+ 9 ,ma!matics 7#agce74 ,he ass]t$ t space involves ! idea ( movem5t )\t ! s5sation ( resi/ance4 ,space s5sation less ?an ! m9ima s5sibilia is1 !re=e1 impossible4 ,f ?is he argues t inf9itesimals are impossible concepts4 #fed ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #he1 note #b #abi4 #fee ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ha1 note #f #abj4 #fef ,edw9 ,dunk9 revis$ ,l>dn]'s ,h&book ( ,a/ronomy 7#ahfi7 & ,miln]'s ,! ,heav5s & ! ,e>? 7#ahgc7 & wrote ,! ,midnight ,sky 7#ahfi74 #feg ,mi*ael ,f>aday 7#agia-ahfg7 ! celebrat$ physici/ & *emi/4 ,he 0 an assi/ant to ,sir ,humphrey ,davy 7#ahac7 & became pr(essor ( *emi/ry at ! ,royal ,in/itution1 ,london1 9 #ahbg4 #feh ,if y tea* a fool he %[s no joy\s c\nt5ance2 he cordially hates y2 he wi%es y buri$4 #fei ,e man is an animal1 ,sortes is a man1 !re=e ,sortes is an animal4 #ffj ,may "s *oice patron bless ea* grey goose quill2 ,may e ,bavius h 8 ,bufo /ill4--,,pope1 ,prologue to ! ,satires4 ,bavius has become prov]bial z a bad poet f ! l9es 9 ,v]gil's ,eclogues 7,,iii1 #ij73 ,qui ,bavium non odit1 amet tua c>m9a1 ,maevi1 ,atque idem jungat vulpes1 et mulgeat hircos4 ,he :o does n hate ,bavius %all love ?y v]ses1 ,o ,maevius2 & ! same %all yoke foxes & %all milk he-goats4 ,bavius & ,maevius 7 ! wor/ ( ,lat9 poets1 condemn$ by ,horace z well z ,v]gil4 #ffa ,see ,vol4 ,,ii1 page #aeh1 note #bgi4 #ffb ,hone/1 useful1 h&some1 sweet4 #ffc ,let n ! f\r? man attempt to speak4 #ffd ,9 ^? old times1--ah ',twas j l ?is1 ah6 #ffe ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #chb1 note #ab #ghe4 #fff ,^! rem>ks 7 nev] writt54--,s4 ,e4 ,de ,m4 #ffg ,fleas1 flies1 & fri>s1 are ma/]s :o sadly ! p abuse1 ,& ?i/les & bri>s are sure gr[+ gra9s to abuse4 ,o ,*ri/1 :o hate/ /rife & slay/ all ?+s 9 peace1 ,de/roy :]e'er are rife1 bri>s1 fri>s1 flies & fleas4 ,fleas1 flies1 & fri>s f\l fall !m ^! fifte5 ye>s ,= none t !re is love? fleas1 flies1 nor fr]es4 #ffh ,x is my plan to re/ore to an unskill$ race ! wor?y arts ( a bett] life4 #ffi ,! fir/ s5t5ces ( ! fir/ oration ( ,cic]o aga9/ ,catil9e3 ,quo usque t&em abut]e1 ,catil9a1 pati5tia no/ra8 7,h[ long1 ,o ,catil9e1 w y abuse our pati5ce87 ,quamdiu etiam furor i/e tuus nos eludet8 7,h[ long w ?is y\r madness baffle u87 ,nihilne te nocturnum praesidium ,palati1 444 nihil horum ora voltusque mov]unt8 7,does ! night wat* ( ! ,palatium1 444 d ! faces & expressions ( all ^! m5 fail to move y87 ,9 te conf]ri 444 7,?is plague %\ld h be5 inflict$ ^u y long ago1 :i* y h plott$ aga9/ u s long47 #fgj ,bew>e ( ! ?+s t are m>k$4 #fga ,f>ewell1 ye tea*]s )\t le>n+6 ,see to x t at our next meet+ we may f9d y /rong 9 body & s\nd 9 m9d4 #fgb ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #ccf1 note #h #gac4 #fgc ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #bbi1 note #b #eae4 #fgd ,?is pro(1 al?\gh capable ( improvem5t1 is left z 9 ! orig9al4 ,^? :o may be int]e/$ 9 ! ma!matics ( ! "q1 may consult ,f4 ,enriques1 ,frag5 d] ,elem5t>geometrie 7,g]man by ,fleis*]71 ,leipsic1 #aijg1 ,"p ,,ii1 p4 #bfg2 ,f4 ,rudio1 ,ar*im$es1 ,huyg5s1 ,lamb]t1 ,leg5dre4 ,vi] ,abh&lung5 ueb] die ,kreismessung1 ,leipsic1 #ahib2 ,f4 ,kle91 ,fam\s ,problems ( ,elem5t>y ,geometry 7,engli% by ,beman & ,smi?71 ,bo/on1 #ahie2 ,j4 ,w4 ,a4 ,"y1 ,monographs on ,mod]n ,ma!matics1 ,new ,york1 #aiaa1 ,*ap4 ,,ix 7by ! editor ( ! pres5t edition ( ,de ,morgan47 #fge ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #fi1 note #b #ie4 #fgf ,see ,vol4 ,i1 page #acg1 note #h #bhf4 #fgg ,joseph ,all5 ,galbrai? :o1 ) ,samuel ,haughton1 wrote ! ,galbrai? & ,haughton's ,sci5tific ,manuals4 7,euclid1 #ahef2 ,algebra1 #ahfj2 ,trigonometry1 #ahed2 ,optics1 #ahed1 & o!rs47 #fgh ,?is note on ,c>lyle 7#agie-ahha7 is int]e/+4 ,! translation ( ,leg5dre appe>$ 9 ! same ye> 7#ahbd7 z 8 translation ( ,goe!'s ,wilhelm ,mei/]4 #fgi ,mi*ael ,/ifel 7#adhg-aefg71 also kn[n z ,/iefel1 ,/yfel1 & ,/ifelius1 0 an ,augu/9e monk b became a conv]t to ,lu!ranism4 ,he 0 pr(essor ( ma!matics at ,j5a 7#aeei-aefg74 ,8 edition ( ! ,coss appe>$ at ,ko5igsb]g 9 #aeec1 ! fir/ edition hav+ be5 publi%$ 9 #aebe4 ,! & - signs fir/ appe>$ 9 pr9t 9 ,widman's ari?metic ( #adhi1 b = purposes ( algebra ?is book 0 "o ( ! fir/ to make !m kn[n4 #fhj ,*ri/(f ,rudolff 0 born ab\t #aejj & di$ betwe5 #aedj & #aeeb4 ,die ,coss appe>$ 9 #aebe & 8 ari?metic 9 #aebf4 99 99 99 99 99 ,corrections made to pr9t$ orig9al4 ,page #i1 long-fo/]$ prejudice3 'p]judice' 9 orig9al4 ,page #gc1 ,p5sees1 *4 #g3 ',pansees' 9 orig9al4 ,page #abg1 & pull$ out a plum3 'und' 9 orig9al4 ,page #adg1 did n come =w>d3 '=word' 9 orig9al4 ,page #agb1 come into g5]al circulation3 'circulalation' 9 orig9al4 ,ibid41 ! m difficult fractions :i* we h got3 'he h got' 9 orig9al4 ,page #aib1 x has be5 /at$3 '/>t$' 9 orig9al4 ,page #baf1 ! obsolete ^w tet* ( ! same mean+3 'mea+' 9 orig9al4 ,page #bbh1 ,greek3 dioklasianos3 'dioklalasianos' 9 orig9al4 ,page #bcc4 ,aft] ,h5ry ,e4 ,mann+' 7 pr9t$ two p>agraphs ,%ill+ v]sus ,franc4' & ,teutonic ,long ,hundr$ #abj v]sus #ajj or ! ,decimal "q4' ,^! appe> to h be5 set 9 error1 !re is no applicable context4 ,page #caf1 9 a mann] dep5d+ ^u ! diff]5ce3 'man]' 9 orig9al4 ,page #cbb1 nei!r :at ,newton did1 nor :at 0 done be=e him43 'n' 7= 'nor'7 9 orig9al4 ,page #cdd1 ,victoria toto coelo3 'tolo' 9 orig9al4 ,page #cfh1 _c be br\ght up to #a3 'up to -' 9 orig9al4 ,page #cga1 ,q#b;b#b ,q#a;a#b3 ',q#b;b#b ,q#a-;a#b' 9 orig9al4 ,note #ej1 all :o 7 n 9 ! road to ,heav5 7 excommunicat$3 'excomunicat$' 9 orig9al4 ,note #cgb1 ,greek3 he alazoneia bi\3 'alaxoneia' 9 orig9al4 ,ibid41 ,iapetos3 ',ispetos' 9 orig9al4 ,ibid41 ,papeiskos3 ',paspeisoks' 9 orig9al4 ,ibid41 ,greek3 dioklasianos3 'dioklalasianos' 9 orig9al4