by ! ,biblio?que nationale de ,france 7,bn,f_/,gallica7 at http3_/_/gallica4bnf4fr7 ,,! ,,po/hum\s ,,works ,,( ,,?omas ,,de ,,qu9cey4 ,,edit$ ,,f ,,! ,,orig9al ,,mss41 ,,) ,,introductions ,,& ,,notes4 ,,by ,,alex&] ,h4 ,,japp1 ,,lld41 ,f4,r4,s4,e4 ,,volume ,i4 ,,london3 ,,william ,,he9emann4 #ahia4 ,all rights res]v$4 ,,suspiria ,,de ,,pr(undis4 ,) ,o!r ,essays1 ,,critical1 ,,hi/orical1 ,,biographical1 ,,philosophical1 ,,imag9ative ,,& ,,humor\s1 ,,by ,,?omas ,,de ,,qu9cey4 ,illu/ration ,,london3 ,,william ,,he9emann4 #ahia4 ,all rights res]v$4 ,to ,mrs4 ,,baird ,,smi? & ,miss ,,de ,,qu9cey1 :o put into my h&s ! rema9s 9 manuscript ( _! fa!r1 t ,i might select & publi% f !m :at 0 deem$ to be available = su* a purpose1 ?is volume is d$icat$1 ) _m & grateful ?anks = _! confid5ce & aid1 by _! devot$ fri5d1 ,,alex&] ,h4 ,,japp4 ,,preface4 99 99 99 99 99 ,x only ne$s to be said1 by way ( ,preface1 t ! articles 9 ! pres5t volume h be5 select$ m ) a view to v>iety & contra/ ?an w be ! case ) ^? to foll[4 ,& x is "r t ,i %\ld ?ank ,mr4 ,j4 ,r4 ,mc,ilraith = fri5dly help 9 ! read+ ( ! pro(s4 ,a4 ,h4 ,j4 ,transcrib]'s ,note3 ,?is etext conta9s lett]s ) macrons1 & h be5 not$ z su*3 u repres5ts u ) a macron1 & 7o repres5ts o ) a breve4 ,,cont5ts4 ,,*apt] ,,page ,,g5]al ,,introduction xi ,i4 ,,suspiria ,,de ,,pr(undis3 ,introduction1 ) ,complete ,li/ ( ! ',suspiria' #a #a4 ,! ,d>k ,int]pret] #g #b4 ,! ,solitude ( ,*ildhood #ac #c4 ,:o is ?is ,woman t beckone? & w>ne? me f ! ,place :]e %e is1 & 9 ^: eyes is ,woeful ,remembrance8 ,i guess :o %e is #af #d4 ,! ,pr9cess :o ov]look$ "o ,se$ 9 a ,pomegranate #bb #e4 ,notes = ',suspiria' #bd ,,ii4 ,,! ,,lovelie/ ,,sight ,,= ,,woman',s ,,eyes #bi 99 99 99 99 99 ,,iii4 ,,:y ,,! ,,pagans ,,c\ld ,,n ,,inve/ ,,_! ,,gods ,,) ,,any ,,iota ,,( ,,gr&eur #cc ,,iv4 ,,on ,,pagan ,,sacrifices #ci ,v4 ,,on ,,! ,,my?us #dc 99 99 99 99 99 ,,vi4 ,,david',s ,,numb]+ ,,( ,,! ,,p--,,! ,,politics ,,( ,,! ,,situation #dg ,,vii4 ,,! ,,jews ,,z ,a ,,sep>ate ,,p #fb ,,viii4 ',,:at ,,is ,,tru?8' ,,! ,,je/+ ,,pilate ,,said--,a ,,false ,,gloss #fh ,,ix4 ,,:at ,,scalig] ,,says ,,ab\t ,,! ,,epi/le ,,to ,,jude #ga 99 99 99 99 99 ,x4 ,,murd] ,,z ,a ,,f9e ,,art #gg ,,xi4 ,,anecdotes--,,juv5al #he ,,xii4 ,,anna ,,l\isa #hi 99 99 99 99 99 ,,xiii4 ,,"s ,,?\ghts ,,on ,,biography #ajj ,,xiv4 ,,great ,,=g]s3 ,,*att]ton ,,& ,,walpole1 ,,& ',,junius' #abe ,,xv4 ,,daniel ,o',,connell #acb 99 99 99 99 99 ,,xvi4 ,,france ,,pa/ ,,& ,,france ,,pres5t #adc ,,xvii4 ,,rome',s ,,recruits ,,& ,,engl&',s ,,recruits #adg ,,xviii4 ,,national ,,mann]s ,,& ,,false ,,judgm5t ,,( ,,!m #afc ,,xix4 ,,increas$ ,,possibilities ,,( ,,sympa?y ,,9 ,,! ,,pres5t ,,age #afe 99 99 99 99 99 ,,xx4 ,,! ,,pr9ciple ,,( ,,evil #afh ,,xxi4 ,,on ,,miracles #agc ,,xxii4 ',,let ,,him ,,come ,,d[n ,,f ,,! ,,cross' #agg ,,xxiii4 ,,is ,,! ,,human ,,race ,,on ,,! ,,d[n ,,grade8 #ahj 99 99 99 99 99 ,,xxiv4 ,,brevia3 ,,%ort ,,essays 7,,9 ,,connection ,,) ,,ea* ,,o!r73 #a4 ,paganism & ,*ri/ianity--! ,ideas ( ,duty & ,hol9ess #ahe #b4 ,moral & ,practical #aid #c4 ,on ,words & ,/yle #bjg #d4 ,!ological & ,religi\s #bbf #e4 ,political1 etc4 #bfi #f4 ,p]sonal ,confessions1 etc4 #bga #g4 ,pagan ,lit]ature #bgi #h4 ,hi/orical1 etc4 #bhc #i4 ,lit]>y #bib ,,xxv4 ,,omitt$ ,,passages ,,& ,,v>iations3 #a4 ,! ,rhapsodoi #cjf #b4 ,mrs4 ,evans & ! ,gazette #caj #c4 ,a ,lawsuit ,legacy #cac #d4 ,! ,true ,ju/ifications ( ,w> #cae #e4 ,philosophy ,defeat$ #cag #f4 ,! ,highwayman's ,skeleton #cbj #g4 ,! ,ransom = ,wat]loo #cbc #h4 ,desid]ium #cbf ,,g5]al ,,introduction4 ,^! articles recov]$ f ! ,,mss4 ( ,de ,qu9cey w1 ! ,editor believes1 be f\nd ( sub/antive value4 ,9 "s cases !y ?r[ fre% light on 8 op9ions & ways ( ?9k+2 9 o!r cases !y deal ) topics :i* are n t\*$ at all 9 8 collect$ works3 & c]ta9ly1 :5 read alongside ! writ+s ) :i* ! public is already famili>1 w give altoge!r a new idea ( 8 range bo? ( int]e/s & activities4 ,! ',brevia1' especially1 w probably be reg>d$ z ?r[+ m light on 8 "* & individuality--exhibit+ m ( ! inn] life1 9 fact--?an any numb] ( lett]s or rem9isc5ces f ! p5s ( o!rs w\ld be f\nd to d4 ,x is z ?\gh ! ord9>y read] 7 ask$ to sit d[n at ease ) ! au?or1 :5 he is 9 8 mo/ social & communicative mood1 :5 he has donn$ 8 dress+-g[n & slipp]s1 & is incl9$ to unbosom himself1 & t freely1 on matt]s :i* usually1 & 9 g5]al society1 he w\ld h be5 incl9$ to %un1 or at all ev5ts to pass ov] lightly4 ,"h we h him at "o mom5t pres5t+ ! results ( speculations ! l(tie/ t c engage ! m9d ( man2 at ano!r mak+ note ( :imsical or surpris+ po9ts 9 ! man or woman he has met )1 or 9 ! books he has read2 at ano!r1 amus+ himself ) ! mo/ rec5t anecdote1 or bon-mot1 or reflect+ on ! late/ accid5t or murd]1 or good-natur$ly not+ odd lapses 9 /yle 9 magaz9e or newspap]4 ,x mu/ n be suppos$ t ! au?or himself 0 incl9$ to lay su* weight on ^! /ray notes1 z might be presum$ f ! =m 9 :i* !y are "h pres5t$4 ,t might give ! impression ( a mo/ me?odic work] & ?9k]1 :o _h be=e him a c>efully-index$ commonplace book1 into :i* he po/$ at ! prop] place 8 r\gh notes & sugge/ions4 ,t 0 n ,de ,qu9cey's way4 ,if he 0 n "o ( ! weal?y m5 :o c>e n h[ !y give1 he 0 "o :o made ! mo/ c>eless record ev5 ( :at 0 likely to be valuable--at all ev5ts to himself4 ,8 habit 0 to make notes j z !y occurr$ to him1 & on ! %eet t he *anc$ to h at ! mom5t be=e him4 ,x might be ! 'copy' = an article inde$1 & 9 a little squ>e pat* at ! corn]--sep>at$ f ! ma9 text by an insulat+ l9e ( ink drawn r\nd ! =eign matt]--?r\gh ?is1 n seldom1 :5 f9i%$ he w\ld lightly draw 8 p52 mean+ probably to return to x :5 8 ,,ms4 came back to him f ! pr9t]1 :i* acc\nts1 x may be1 9 "s measure = 8 reluctance to get rid (1 or to de/roy1 'copy' already pr9t$ f4 ,sometimes we h f\nd on a %eet a doz5 or s ( l9es ( a well-kn[n article2 & ! re/ fill$ up ) notes1 "s writt5 "o way ( ! pap]1 "s ano!r1 & n[ & !n entangl$ 9 ! mo/ surpris+ fa%ion4 ,9 ^! cases1 :]e ! notes1 ( c\rse1 7 meant = 8 own eye1 he wrote 9 a small spid]y h&writ+ ) _m contractions--a k9d ( %or?& ( 8 own1 & v diff]5t inde$ f 8 ord9>y clean1 cle>1 neat p5man%ip4 ,9 _m cases ^! notes dem&$ no little c>e & clos5ess 9 deciph]+--! m t ! ,,mss4 _h be5 tumbl$ ab\t1 & 7 (t5 deeply /a9$ by glasses o!r ?an ink/&s hav+ be5 plac$ ^u !m4 ',)9 t circle none d>$ walk b he1' said ,tom ,hood 9 8 g5ially humor\s way2 & _m ( ^! ?\ghts 7 ?us p>tially or :olly encircl$4 ,pages ( articles t _h already be5 pr9t$ 7 int]mix$ ) o!rs t _h n2 & ! fir/ piece ( "w t ,i ent]$ on 0 r\ghly to sep>ate ! pr9t$ f ! unpr9t$--fir/ hav+ c>efully copi$ out f ! =m] any ( ! spid]y-look+ notes int]ject$ !re1 to :i* ,i h already ref]r$4 ,! next process 0 to arrange ! _m sep>ate pages & seem+ fragm5ts into heaps1 by subjects2 & f9ally to exam9e ^! c>efully &1 ) a view to 'connections1' to place !m toge!r4 ,9 n a few cases :]e ! !me 0 attractive & ! prospect promis+1 utt] failure to complete ! article or sket* 0 ! result1 ! op5+ or end+ passages1 or a page 9 ! middle1 hav+ be5 un=tunately de/roy$ or lo/4 ,s num]\s 7 ^! notes1 s v>i$ _! subjects1 t "o got q a new idea ( ! extreme electrical quality ( 8 m9d1 z he himself call$ x2 & ,i %all h greatly fail$ 9 my endeav\r 9 ! case ( ^! volumes1 if ,i h n succe$$ 9 imp>t+ some?+ ( ! same impression to ! read]4 ,"h we h pro( t va/ s*emes1 su* z ! great hi/ory ( ,engl&1 ( :i* ,mr4 ,james ,hogg1 s5r41 humor\sly told u 9 8 ',recollections' 7',memoir1' *4 ed41 pp4 #ccj1 #cca71 7 n m]ely subjects ( conv]sation & je/1 b t he _h actually proce$$ to build up masses ( notes & figures ) a view to ^!2 & v>i\s slips & pages rema9 to %[ t he _h actually comm5c$ to write ! hi/ory ( ,engl&4 ,! %ort article1 includ$ 9 ! pres5t volume1 on ! ',p[] ( ! ,h\se ( ,commons z ,cu/odian ( ! ,purse1' is m>k$ = ',my ,hi/ory ( ,engl&4' ,o!r portions are m>k$ z int5d$ = ',my book on ! ,inf9ite1' & o!rs /ill ',= my book on ! ,relations ( ,*ri/ianity to ,man4' ,"o c inf]1 inde$1 t sev]al ( ! articles well-kn[n to u1 notably ',*ri/ianity z an ,organ ( ,political ,movem5t1' = "o1 7 orig9ally conceiv$ z portions ( a great "w on ',*ri/ianity 9 ,relation to ,human ,developm5t4' ,x is ?us necess>y to be v explicit 9 /at+ t1 ?\gh ^! notes are z fai?fully reproduc$ z has be5 possible to me1 ! classification & arrangem5t ( !m1 "u :i* !y assume ! aspect ( some?+ ( "o connect$ essay on ! ma9 subject1 ,i alone am responsible =2 ?\gh ,i d n believe1 s def9ite & cle> 7 8 ideas on c]ta9 subjects & 9 c]ta9 relations1 t he himself w\ld h reg>d$ !m z los+ any?+ by su* arrangem5t1 b r ga9+ v mu*1 if !y 7 to be giv5 at all to ! public4 ,sev]al ( ! articles 9 ?is volume sugge/ t he also contemplat$ a great "w on ',paganism & ,*ri/ianity1' 9 :i* he w\ld h demon/rat$ t ,paganism _h exhau/$ all ! g]ms ( progress t lay )9 x2 & t all beyond ! po9ts rea*$ by ,paganism is due to ,*ri/ianity1 & alone to ,*ri/ianity1 :i*1 9 op5+ up a cle> view ( ! inf9ite ?r\gh purely exp]im5tal m$iums 9 man's he>t1 t\*$ to new life1 sci5ce1 philosophy1 art1 inv5tion & e k9d ( culture4 ,respect+ ! recov]$ ',suspiria1' all t x is ne$ful to say w be f\nd 9 an introduction special to t head1 & x does n seem to me t ,i ne$ to add "h any?+ m4 ,9 e o!r respect ! articles mu/ speak = !mselves4 ,,de ,,qu9cey',s ,,po/hum\s ,,works4 ,i4 ,,suspiria ,,de ,,pr(undis4 ,,introduction1 ,,) ,,complete ,,li/ ,,( ,,! ',,suspiria4' ,! f9ale to ! fir/ "p ( ! ',suspiria1' z we f9d f a note ( ! au?or's own1 0 to include ',! ,d>k ,int]pret]1' ',! ,spectre ( ! ,brock51' & ',savannah-la-,m>4' ,! ref]5ces to ',! ,d>k ,int]pret]' 9 ! latt] w\ld ?us become intelligible1 z ! read] is n !re 9 any full s5se in=m$ :o ! ',d>k ,int]pret]' 02 & ! piece1 recov]$ f 8 ,,mss4 & n[ pr9t$1 may ?us be reg>d$ z hav+ a special value = ,de ,qu9cey /ud5ts1 &1 inde$1 = read]s g5]ally4 ,9 ,blackwood's ,magaz9e he did inde$ int]polate a s5t5ce or two1 & ^! 7 reproduc$ 9 ! ,am]ican edition ( ! works 7,fields's72 b !y are s slight & g5]al comp>$ ) ! complete ',suspiria' n[ pres5t$1 t !y d n 9 any way detract f its orig9ality & value4 ,! ma/]-idea ( ! ',suspiria' is ! p[] :i* lies 9 suff]+1 9 agony unutt]$ & unutt]able1 to develop ! intellect & ! _s ( man2 to op5 ^! to ! ineffable conceptions ( ! inf9ite1 & to "s disc]nm5t1 o!rwise impossible1 ( ! b5efic5t might t lies 9 pa9 & sorr[4 ,de ,qu9cey seeks 8 symbols sometimes 9 natural ph5om5a1 (t5] 9 ! creation ( mighty ab/ractions2 & ! moral ( all mu/ be set =? 9 ! burd5 ( ',! ,daught] ( ,lebanon1' t ',god may give by seem+ to refuse4' ,prose-poems1 z !y h be5 call$1 !y are deeply philosophical1 pres5t+ "u ! guise ( phantasy ! pr(\nde/ laws ( ! work+ ( ! human _s 9 its mo/ t]rible discipl9es1 & ass]t+ = ! d>ke/ ph5om5a ( human life "s comp5sat+ elem5ts z awak5]s ( hope & fe> & awe4 ,! s5se ( a great p>iah _w is ev] pres5t ) him--a _w ( outca/s & ( innoc5ts be>+ ! burd5 ( vic>i\s woes2 & ?us x is t 8 title is ju/ifi$--,suspiria de ,pr(undis3 ',sighs f ! ,dep?s4' ,we f9d ,de ,qu9cey writ+ 9 8 prefatory notice to ! enl>g$ edition ( ! ',confessions' 9 ,novemb]1 #ahef3 ',all along ,i _h reli$ ^u a cr[n+ grace1 :i* ,i _h res]v$ = ! f9al page ( ?is volume1 9 a succession ( "s tw5ty or tw5ty-five dreams & noon-day visions1 :i* _h aris5 "u ! latt] /age ( opium influ5ce4 ,^! h disappe>$2 "s "u circum/ances :i* all[ me a reasonable prospect ( recov]+ !m1 "s unacc\ntably1 & "s di%on\rably4 ,five or six ,i believe 7 burn$ 9 a sudd5 conflagration :i* arose f ! sp>k ( a c&le fall+ unobs]v$ among/ a v l>ge pile ( pap]s 9 a b$room1 :]e ,i 0 alone & read+4 ,fall+ n on1 b among/ & )9 ! pap]s1 ! fire w\ld soon h be5 ahead ( conflict1 &1 by communicat+ ) ! slight woodwork & drap]ies ( a b$1 x w\ld h imm$iately envelop$ ! la?s ( ! ceil+ ov]head1 & ?us ! h\se1 f> f fire-eng9es1 w\ld h be5 burn$ d[n 9 half-an-h\r4 ,my att5tion 0 fir/ drawn by a sudd5 light ^u my book2 & ! :ole diff]5ce betwe5 a total de/ruction ( ! premises & a trivial loss 7f books *>r$7 ( five gu9eas 0 due to a l>ge ,spani% cloak4 ,?is1 ?r[n ov] & !n drawn d[n tightly1 by ! aid ( "o sole p]son1 some:at agitat$1 b reta9+ h] pres5ce ( m9d1 effectually ext+ui%$ ! fire4 ,among/ ! pap]s burn$ p>tially1 b n s burn$ z to be absolutely irretrievable1 0 ,! ,daught] ( ,lebanon1 & ?is ,i h pr9t$ & h int5tionally plac$ x at ! end1 z appropriately clos+ a record 9 :i* ! case ( poor ,ann ! ,outca/ =m$ n only ! mo/ memorable & ! mo/ sugge/ively pa!tic incid5t1 b also t :i*1 m ?an any o!r1 col\r$--or 7m truly1 ,i %\ld say7 %ap$1 m\ld$ & rem\ld$1 compos$ & decompos$--! great body ( opium dreams4' ,aft] ?is loss ( ! great] portion ( ! ',suspiria' copy1 ,de ,qu9cey seems to h become indiff]5t 9 "s degree to _! cont9uity & relation to ea* o!r4 ,he drew ! ',affliction ( ,*ildhood' & ',dream ,e*oes1' :i* /ood e>ly 9 ! ord] ( ! ',suspiria1' into ! ',autobiographic ,sket*es1' & also ! ',spectre ( ! ,brock51' :i* 0 meant to come some:at lat] 9 ! s]ies z orig9ally plann$2 &1 z we h se51 he app5d$ ',! ,daught] ( ,lebanon' to ! ',opium ,confessions1' )\t any ref]5ce1 save 9 ! preface1 to its really hav+ =m$ "p ( a sep>ate collection ( dreams4 ,f a li/ f\nd among 8 ,,mss4 we are able to give ! arrangem5t ( ! :ole z x w\ld h appe>$ _h no accid5t occurr$1 & all ! pap]s be5 at h&4 ,^? foll[$ by a cross are ^? :i* are n[ recov]$1 & ^? ) a dagg] :at 7 repr9t$ ei!r z ',suspiria' or o!rwise 9 ,messrs4 ,black's editions4 ,,suspiria ,,de ,,pr(undis4 #a4 ,dream+1 cross #b4 ,! ,affliction ( ,*ildhood4 cross ,dream ,e*oes4 cross #c4 ,! ,engli% ,mail ,coa*4 cross 7#a7 ,! ,glory ( ,motion4 7#b7 ,vision ( ,sudd5 ,dea?4 7#c7 ,dream-fugue4 #d4 ,! ,palimpse/ ( ! ,human ,bra94 cross #e4 ,vision ( ,life4 cross #f4 ,memorial ,suspiria4 cross #g4 ,levana & our ,ladies ( ,sorr[4 #h4 ,solitude ( ,*ildhood4 big cross #i4 ,! ,d>k ,int]pret]4 big cross #aj4 ,! ,app>ition ( ! ,brock54 cross #aa4 ,savannah-la-,m>4 #ab4 ,! ,dreadful ,infant4 7,!re 0 ! glory ( innoc5ce made p]fect2 !re 0 ! dreadful beauty ( infancy t _h se5 ,god47 #ac4 ,f\nd]+ ,%ips4 #ad4 ,! ,ar*bi%op & ! ,controll] ( ,fire4 #ae4 ,god t did/ ,promise4 #af4 ,c\nt ! ,leaves 9 ,vallombrosa4 #ag4 ,b if ,i submitt$ ) ,resignation1 n ! less ,i se>*$ = ! ,unse>*able--sometimes 9 ,arab ,des]ts1 sometimes 9 ! ,sea4 #ah4 ,t ran be=e u 9 ,malice4 #ai4 ,morn+ ( ,execution4 #bj4 ,daught] ( ,lebanon4 cross #ba4 ,kyrie ,eleison4 #bb4 ,! ,pr9cess t lo/ a ,s+le ,se$ ( a ,pomegranate4 big cross #bc4 ,! ,nurs]y 9 ,arabian ,des]ts4 #bd4 ,! ,halcyon ,calm & ! ,c(f94 #be4 ,faces6 ,angels' ,faces6 #bf4 ,at t ,^w4 #bg4 ,oh1 ,apo?anate6 t hate/ ,dea?1 & cleanse/ f ! ,pollution ( ,sorr[4 #bh4 ,:o is ?is ,woman t = "s ,mon?s has foll[$ me up & d[n8 ,h] face ,i _c see1 = %e keeps = ev] beh9d me4 #bi4 ,:o is ?is ,woman t beckone? & w>ne? me f ! ,place :]e %e is1 & 9 ^: ,eyes is ,woeful remembrance8 ,i guess :o %e is4 big cross #cj4 ,cagot & ,cressida4 #ca4 ,le! & ,anapaula4 #cb4 ,oh1 sweep away1 ,angel1 ) ,angelic ,scorn1 ! ,dogs t come ) ,curi\s ,eyes to gaze4 ,?us ( ! ?irty-two ',suspiria' int5d$ by ! au?or1 we h only n9e t receiv$ 8 f9al corrections1 & ev5 ) ^? n[ recov]$1 we h only ab\t "o half ( ! :ole1 presum+ t ^? :i* are lo/ or rema9$ unwritt5 w\ld h av]ag$ ab\t ! same l5g? z ^? we h4 ,to ^? :o h /udi$ ! ',suspiria' z publi%$1 h[ sugge/ive _m ( ^! titles w be6 ',c\nt ! ,leaves 9 ,vallombrosa'--:at phantasies w\ld t h conjur$ up6 ,! lo/1 ! app>5tly wa/$ ( ! leaves f ! tree ( human life1 & ! possibilities ( use & r$emption6 ,de ,qu9cey w\ld !re d\btless h giv5 u "u a =m m or less fanciful or symbolical 8 read+ ( ! problem3 ',:y ,nature out ( fifty se$s ,s (t5 br+s b "o to be>4' ,! case ( ! ,cagots1 ! p>iahs ( ! ,pyr5ees1 z we "k f ref]5ces else:]e1 excit$ 8 curiosity1 z did all ( ! p>iah class1 & mu* engag$ 8 att5tion2 & 9 ! ',cagot & ,cressida' ',suspiria' we %\ld probably h _h "u symbols ( mighty ab/ractions ! vision ( ! p>iah _w1 & ! _w ( heal? & outw>d =tune :i* scorns & excludes ! o!r1 & p>tly1 at all ev5ts1 actively dooms x to a liv+ dea? 9 ,engl& ( to-day1 z 9 ,india ( ! pa/1 & 9 ,jewry ( old1 :]e ! lep] 0 ?ru/ outside ! wall to wail ',unclean6 unclean6' #a4--,,! ,,d>k ,,int]pret]4 ',oh1 et]nity ) out/ret*$ w+s1 t broode/ ov] ! secret tru?s 9 ^: roots lie ! my/]ies ( man--8 :5ce1 8 :i!r--h ,i se>*$ !e1 & /ruck a "r key on ?y dreadful organ6' ,suff]+ is a mighti] ag5cy 9 ! h&s ( nature1 z a ,demiurgus creat+ ! intellect1 ?an mo/ p are aw>e (4 ,! tru? ,i he>d (t5 9 sleep f ! lips ( ! ,d>k ,int]pret]4 ,:o is he8 ,he is a %ad[1 read]1 b a %ad[ ) :om y mu/ suff] me to make y acqua9t$4 ,y ne$ n be afraid ( him1 = :5 ,i expla9 8 nature & orig9 y w see t he is ess5tially in(f5sive2 or if sometimes he m5aces ) 8 c\nt5ance1 t is b seldom3 & !n1 z 8 features 9 ^? moods %ift z rapidly z cl\ds 9 a gale ( w9d1 y may always look = ! t]rific aspects to vani% z fa/ z !y h ga!r$4 ,z to 8 orig9--:at x is1 ,i "k exactly1 b _c )\t a little circuit ( prep>ation make y und]/&4 ,p]haps y are aw>e ( t p[] 9 ! eye ( _m *ildr5 by :i* 9 d>kness !y project a va/ !atre ( phantasmagorical figures mov+ =w>ds or backw>ds betwe5 _! b$-curta9s & ! *amb] walls4 ,9 "s *ildr5 ?is p[] is semi-volunt>y--!y c control or p]haps susp5d ! %[s2 b 9 o!rs x is altoge!r automatic4 ,i myself1 at ! date ( my la/ confessions1 _h se5 9 ?is way m processions--g5]ally solemn1 m\rnful1 belong+ to et]nity1 b also at times glad1 triumphal pomps1 t seem$ to ent] ! gates ( ,"t--?an all ! religions ( paganism1 fi]ce or gay1 ev] witness$4 ,n[1 !re is 9 ! d>k places ( ! human _s--9 grief1 9 fe>1 9 v9dictive wra?--a p[] ( self-projection n unlike to ?is4 ,?irty ye>s ago1 x may be1 a man call$ ,symons committ$ sev]al murd]s 9 a sudd5 epilepsy ( planet-/ruck fury4 ,accord+ to my recollection1 ?is case happ5$ at ,hoddesdon1 :i* is 9 ,middlesex4 ',rev5ge is sweet6' 0 8 helli% motto on t occasion1 & t motto itself records ! abysses :i* a human w c op54 ,rev5ge is n sweet1 unless by ! mighty *>m ( a *>ity t seeke? n h] own x has become b5ignant4#a ,& :at he _h to rev5ge 0 woman's scorn4 ,he _h be5 a pla9 f>m-s]vant2 &1 9 fact1 he 0 execut$1 z su* m5 (t5 are1 on a prop] po9t ( pr(essional respect to _! call+1 9 a smock-frock1 or bl\se1 to r5d] s ugly a cla% ( syllables4 ,8 "y mi/ress 0 e way & by mu* 8 sup]ior1 z well 9 prospects z 9 education4 ,b ! man1 by nature arrogant1 & little acqua9t$ ) ! _w1 presumptu\sly rais$ 8 eyes to "o ( 8 "y mi/resses4 ,great 0 ! scorn ) :i* %e repuls$ 8 audacity1 & h] si/]s p>ticipat$ 9 h] disda94 ,^u ?is affront he brood$ night & day2 &1 aft] ! t]m ( 8 s]vice 0 ov]1 & he1 9 effect1 =gott5 by ! family1 "o day he sudd5ly desc5d$ among/ ! wom5 ( ! family l an ,avat> ( v5geance4 ,"r & left he ?rew out 8 murd]\s knife )\t di/9ction ( p]son1 leav+ ! room & ! passage float+ 9 blood4 ,! f9al result ( ?is c>nage 0 n s t]rific z x ?reat5$ to be4 ,"s1 ,i ?9k1 recov]$2 b1 also1 "o1 :o did n recov]1 0 unhappily a /rang] to ! :ole cause ( 8 fury4 ,n[1 ?is murd]] always ma9ta9$1 9 conv]sation ) ! prison *apla91 t1 z he ru%$ on 9 8 helli% c>e]1 he p]ceiv$ di/9ctly a d>k figure on 8 "r h&1 keep+ pace ) himself4 ,^u t ! sup]/iti\s1 ( c\rse1 suppos$ t "s fi5d _h reveal$ himself1 & associat$ 8 sup]flu\s pres5ce ) ! d>k atrocity4 ,symons 0 n a philosoph]1 b my op9ion is1 t he 0 too mu* s to tol]ate t hypo!sis1 s9ce1 if !re 0 "o man 9 all ,europe t ne$$ no tempt] to evil on t ev5+1 x 0 precisely ,mr4 ,symons1 z nobody knew bett] ?an ,mr4 ,symons himself4 ,i _h n ! b5efit ( 8 acqua9tance1 or ,i w\ld h expla9$ x to him4 ,! fact is1 9 po9t ( awe a fi5d w\ld be a poor1 trivial bagatelle comp>$ to ! %ad[y projections1 umbras & p5umbras1 :i* ! unse>*able dep?s ( man's nature is capable1 "u adequate excitem5t1 ( ?r[+ (f1 & ev5 into /ation>y =ms4 ,i %all h occasion to notice ?is po9t aga94 ,!re are creative ag5cies 9 e "p ( human nature1 ( :i* ! ?\s&? "p c\ld nev] be reveal$ 9 "o life4 ,y h he>d1 read]1 9 vision :i* describes our ,ladies ( ,sorr[1 p>ticul>ly 9 ! d>k admonition ( ,madonna1 to h] wick$ si/] t hate? & tempte?1 :at root ( d>k uses may lie 9 moral convulsions3 n ! uses hypocritically vaunt$ by !atrical devotion :i* affronts ! maje/y ( ,god1 t ev] & 9 all ?+s loves ,tru?--pref]s s9c]ity t is err+ to piety t cants4 ,rebellion :i* is ! s9 ( wit*craft is m p>donable 9 ,8 sight ?an spee*ify+ resignation1 li/5+ ) complac5cy to its own self-conque/s4 ,%[ always z mu* neighb\rhood z ?\ can/ to grief t abases itself1 :i* w co/ !e b little ef=t if ?9e own grief ha? be5 great4 ,b ,god1 :o sees ?y ef=ts 9 secret1 w sl[ly /r5g!n ^? ef=ts1 & make t to be a real de$1 be>+ tranquillity = ?yself1 :i* at fir/ 0 b a feeble wi% brea?+ homage to ,him4 ,9 aft]-life1 f tw5ty to tw5ty-f\r1 on look+ back to ^? /ruggles ( my *ildhood1 ,i us$ to wond] exce$+ly t a *ild c\ld be expos$ to /ruggles on su* a scale4 ,b two views unfold$ ^u me z my exp]i5ce wid5$1 :i* took away t wond]4 ,! fir/ 0 ! va/ scale ^u :i* ! suff]+s ( *ildr5 are f\nd ev]y:]e exp&$ 9 ! realities ( life4 ,! g5]ation ( infants :i* y see is b "p ( ^? :o belong to x2 7 born 9 x2 & make1 ! _w ov]1 n "o half ( x4 ,! miss+ half1 m ?an an equal numb] to ^? ( any age t are n[ liv+1 h p]i%$ by e k9d ( torm5ts4 ,?ree ?\s& *ildr5 p] annum--t is1 ?ree hundr$ ?\s& p] c5tury2 t is 7omitt+ ,sundays71 ab\t t5 e day--pass to heav5 ?r\gh flames#b 9 ?is v isl& ( ,great ,brita94 ,& ( ^? :o survive to rea* maturity :at multitudes h f\ght ) fi]ce pangs ( hung]1 cold1 & nak$ness6 ,:5 ,i came to "k all ?is1 !n rev]t+ my eye to my /ruggle1 ,i said (t5times x 0 no?+6 ,secondly1 9 wat*+ ! infancy ( my own *ildr51 ,i made ano!r discov]y--x is well kn[n to mo!rs1 to nurses1 & also to philosoph]s--t ! te>s & lam5tations ( infants dur+ ! ye> or s :5 !y h no o!r language ( compla9t run ?r\gh a gamut t is z inexhau/ible z ! cremona ( ,pagan9i4 ,an e> b mod]ately le>n$ 9 t language _c be deceiv$ z to ! rate & modulus ( ! suff]+ :i* x indicates4 ,a fretful or peevi% cry _c by any ef=ts make itself impassion$4 ,! cry ( impati5ce1 ( hung]1 ( irritation1 ( reproa*1 ( al>m1 are all diff]5t--diff]5t z a *orus ( ,bee?ov5 f a *orus ( ,moz>t4 ,b if ev] y saw an infant suff]+ = an h\r1 z sometimes ! heal?ie/ does1 "u "s attack ( ! /oma*1 :i* has ! tig]-grasp ( ! ,ori5tal *ol]a1 !n y w he> moans t address to _! mo!rs an angui% ( supplication = aid su* z might /orm ! he>t ( ,molo*4 ,once he>+ x1 y w n =get x4 ,n[1 x 0 a con/ant rem>k ( m9e1 aft] any /orm ( t nature 7occurr+1 suppose1 once 9 two mon?s71 t always on ! foll[+ day1 :5 a long1 long sleep _h *as$ away ! d>kness & ! memory ( ! d>kness f ! little creature's bra91 a s5sible expansion _h tak5 place 9 ! intellectual faculties ( att5tion1 obs]vation1 & animation4 ,x r5ew$ ! case ( our great mod]n poet1 :o1 on li/5+ to ! rav+ ( ! midnight /orm1 & ! cra%+ :i* x 0 mak+ 9 ! mighty woods1 rem9d$ himself t all ?is hell ( tr\ble ',tells also ( bright calms t %all succe$4' ,pa9 driv5 to agony1 or grief driv5 to fr5zy1 is ess5tial to ! v5tilation ( pr(\nd natures4 ,a sea :i* is deep] ?an any t ,c\nt ,massigli#c measur$ _c be se>*$ & torn up f its sleep+ dep?s )\t a levant] or a monsoon4 ,a nature :i* is pr(\nd 9 excess1 b also introv]t$ & ab/ract$ 9 excess1 s z to be 9 p]il ( wa/+ itself 9 int]m9able rev]ie1 _c be awak5$ sometimes )\t afflictions t g to ! v f\ndations1 heav+1 /irr+1 yet f9ally h>moniz+2 & x is 9 su* cases t ! ,d>k ,int]pret] does 8 "w1 reveal+ ! worlds ( pa9 & agony & woe possible to man--possible ev5 to ! innoc5t _s ( a *ild4 #b4--,,! ,,solitude ,,( ,,*ildhood4 ,z no?+ :i* is impassion$ escapes ! eye ( poetry1 nei!r has ?is escap$ x--t !re is1 or may be1 ?r\gh solitude1 'sublime attractions ( ! grave4' ,b ev5 poetry has n p]ceiv$ t ^! attractions may arise = a *ild4 ,n1 inde$1 a passion = ! grave z ! grave--f t a *ild revolts2 b a passion = ! grave z ! portal ?r\gh :i* x may recov] "s heav5ly c\nt5ance1 "m or si/]1 t has vani%$4 ,?r\gh solitude ?is passion may be exalt$ into a fr5zy l a nympholepsy4 ,at fir/1 :5 9 *ildhood we f9d ourselves torn away f ! lips t we c\ld hang on = ev]1 we ?r[ out our arms 9 va9 /ruggles to snat* at !m1 & pull !m back aga94 ,b :5 we h felt = a "t h[ hopeless is t ef=t1 & t !y _c come to u1 we desi/ f t /ruggle1 & next we :isp] to our he>ts1 ,might n we g to !m8 ,su* 9 pr9ciple & orig9 0 ! fam\s ,dulce ,domum#d ( ! ,engli% s*oolboy4 ,su* is ! ,heimweh 7home-sickness7 ( ! ,g]man & ,swiss soldi] 9 =eign s]vice4 ,su* is ! passion ( ! ,cal5ture4 ,d\btless1 read]1 y h se5 x describ$4 ,! poor sailor is 9 tropical latitudes2 deep1 brea?less calms h prevail$ = weeks4 ,fev] & delirium are ^u him4 ,sudd5ly f 8 re/less hammock he />ts up2 he w fret no long] 9 d>kness2 he asc5ds ^u deck4 ,h[ motionless are ! deeps6 ,h[ va/--h[ sweet are ^! %9+ za>rahs ( wat]6 ,he gazes1 & sl[ly "u ! blaz+ sc5]y ( 8 bra9 ! sc5]y ( 8 eye unsettles4 ,! wat]s are swall[$ up2 ! seas h disappe>$4 ,gre5 fields appe>1 a sil5t dell1 & a pa/oral cottage4 ,two faces appe>--are at ! door--sweet female faces1 & behold !y beckon him4 ',come to u6' !y seem to say4 ,! picture rises to 8 we>i$ bra9 l a sanctus f ! *oir ( a ca!dral1 & 9 ! tw9kl+ ( an eye1 /ung to madness by ! crav+s ( 8 he>t1 ! man is ov]bo>d4 ,he is gone--he is lo/ = ?is _w2 b if he miss$ ! arms ( ! lovely wom5--wife & si/]--:om he s\ght1 assur$ly he has settl$ into arms t are mighti] & n less indulg5t4 ,i1 "y z ,i 01 _h "o feel+ n le>n$ f books1 & t c\ld n h be5 le>n$ f books1 ! deepe/ ( all t connect !mselves ) natural sc5]y4 ,x is ! feel+ :i* 9 ',! ,h>t-leap ,well' ( ,wordswor?1 9 8 ',dani% ,boy1' & o!r exquisite poems is br\ght out1 viz41 ! brea?less1 my/]i\s1 ,pan-l sil5ce t haunts ! noon-day4 ,if !re 7 w9ds abroad1 !n ,i 0 r\s$ myself into sympa!tic tumults4 ,b if ?is dead sil5ce haunt$ ! air1 !n ! peace :i* 0 9 nature e*o$ ano!r peace :i* lay 9 graves1 & ,i fell into a sick langui%+ = ?+s :i* a voice f heav5 seem$ to say '_c be grant$4' ,!re is a ,g]man sup]/ition1 :i* eight or t5 ye>s aft] ,i read1 ( ! ,erl-k+ & 8 daught]4 ,! daught] _h p[] to tempt infants away into ! invisible _w2 b x is1 z ! read] und]/&s1 by collusion ) "s infirmity ( sick desire = su* worlds 9 ! infant itself4 ',:o is t rides ?r\gh ! =e/ s fa/8' ,x is a knight :o c>ries 8 infant ^u 8 saddle-b[4 ,! ,erl-k+'s daught] rides by 8 side2 &1 9 words audible only :5 %e means !m to be he>d1 %e says3 ',if ?\ wilt1 de> baby1 ) me g away1 ,we w see a f9e %[1 we w play a f9e play4' ,t s\nds lovely to my e>s4 ,oh yes1 t collusion ) dim sleep+ infancy is lovely to me2 b ,i 0 too advanc$ 9 intellect to h be5 tempt$ by su* temptations4 ,/ill !re 0 a p]il\s attraction = me 9 worlds t slept & re/$2 & if ! ,erl-k+'s daught] _h reveal$ h]self to my p]ceptions1 !re 0 "o '%[' t %e might h promis$ :i* w\ld h wil$ me away ) h] into ! dimme/ dep?s ( ! mightie/ & remote/ =e/s4 #c4--,,:o ,,is ,,?is ,,woman ,,t ,,beckone? ,,& ,,w>ne? ,,me ,,f ,,! ,,place ,,:]e ,,%e ,,is1 ,,& ,,9 ,,^: ,,eyes ,,is ,,woeful ,,remembrance8 ,i ,,guess ,,:o ,,%e ,,is4 ,9 my dreams 7 (t5 prefigurem5ts ( my future1 z ,i c\ld n b read ! signs4 ,:at man has n "s "t 9 dewy morn1 or seque/]$ eve1 or 9 ! /ill night-wat*es1 :5 deep sleep falle? on o!r m5 b visite? n 8 we>y eyelids--:at man1 ,i say1 has n "s "t hu%$ 8 _s & que/ion$ ) himself :e!r "s ?+s se5 or obscurely felt1 7 n anticipat$ z by my/ic =eta/e 9 "s f> halcyon "t1 po/-natal or ante-natal he knew n2 only assur$ly he knew t = him pa/ & pres5t & future m]g$ 9 "o awful mom5t ( lightn+ revelation4 ,oh1 _s t dwelle? 9 man1 h[ subtle are ?y revelations2 h[ deep1 h[ deliri\s ! raptures ?\ can/ inspire2 h[ poignant ! /+s ) :i* ?\ can/ pi]ce ! he>t2 h[ sweet ! honey ) :i* ?\ assuage/ ! w\nd2 h[ d>k ! despairs & accus+s t lie beh9d ?y curta9s1 & leap ^u u l lightn+ f ! cl\d1 ) ! s5se z ( "s heav5ly blazon+1 & (t5times c>ry u beyond ourselves6 ,x is a sweet morn+ 9 ,june1 & ! fragrance ( ! roses is waft$ t[>ds me z ,i move--= ,i am walk+ 9 a lawny mead[1 /ill wet ) dew--& a wav]+ mi/ lies ov] ! di/ance4 ,sudd5ly x seems to lift1 & out ( ! dewy dimness em]ges a cottage1 emb[]$ ) roses & clu/]+ clematis2 & ! hills1 9 :i* x is set l a gem1 are tree-clad1 & rise bill[y beh9d x1 & to ! "r & to ! left are gli/5+ expanses ( wat]4 ,ov] ! cottage !re hangs a halo1 z if cl\ds _h b p>t$ !re4 ,f ! door ( t cottage em]ges a figure1 ! c\nt5ance full ( ! trepidation ( "s dread woe fe>$ or rememb]$4 ,) wav+ arm & te>ful uplift$ face ! figure fir/ beckons me onw>d1 & !n1 :5 ,i h advanc$ "s y>ds1 fr[n+1 w>ns me away4 ,z ,i /ill cont9ue to advance1 despite ! w>n+1 d>kness falls3 figure1 cottage1 hills1 trees1 & halo fade & disappe>2 & all t rema9s to me is ! look on ! face ( h] t beckon$ & w>n$ me away4 ,i read t glance z by ! inspiration ( a mom5t4 ,we _h be5 toge!r2 toge!r we _h ent]$ "s tr\bl$ gulf2 /ruggl$ toge!r1 suff]$ toge!r4 ,0 x z lov]s torn asund] by calamity8 0 x z combatants =c$ by bitt] necessity into bitt] feud1 :5 we only1 9 all ! _w1 ye>n$ = peace toge!r8 ,oh1 :at a se>*+ glance 0 t :i* %e ca/ on me6 z if %e1 be+ n[ 9 ! spiritual _w1 ab/ract$ f fle%1 rememb]$ ?+s t ,i c\ld n rememb]4 ,oh1 h[ ,i %udd]$ z ! sweet sunny eyes 9 ! sweet sunny morn+ ( ,june--! mon? t 0 my 'angelical'2 half spr+1 yet ) summ] dress1 t to me 0 v 'angelical'--seem$ reproa*fully to *all5ge 9 me recollections ( ?+s pass$ ?\s&s ( ye>s ago 7old inde$1 yet t 7 made new aga9 = u1 because n[ fir/ x 0 t we met aga974 ,oh1 heav5s6 x came ov] me z do? ! rav5 ov] ! infect$ h\se1 z f a b$ ( violets sweeps ! sa9tly od\r ( corruption4 ,:at a glimpse 0 ?us reveal$6 glory 9 despair1 z ( t gorge\s vegetation t hid ! /]ilities ( ! grave 9 ! tropics ( t summ] long ago2 ( t heav5ly beauty :i* slept side by side )9 my si/]'s c(f9 9 ! mon? ( ,june2 ( ^? sa9tly swells t rose f an inf9ite di/ance--,i "k n :e!r to or f my si/]4 ,c\ld ?is be a memorial ( t nature8 ,are ! ne>] & m di/ant /ages ( life ?us dimly connect$1 & ! connection hidd51 b sudd5ly reveal$ = a mom5t8 ,?is lady = ye>s appe>$ to me 9 dreams2 9 t1 consid]+ ! electric "* ( my dreams1 & t !y 7 f> less l a lake reflect+ ! heav5s ?an l ! p5cil ( "s mighty arti/--,da ,v9ci or ,mi*ael ,angelo--t _c copy 9 simplicity1 b comm5ts 9 fre$om1 :ile reflect+ 9 fidelity1 !re 0 no?+ to surprise4 ,b a *ange 9 ?is appe>ance 0 rem>kable4 ,(t5times1 aft] eight ye>s _h pass$1 %e appe>$ 9 summ] dawn at a w9d[4 ,x 0 a w9d[ t op5$ on a balcony4 ,?is feature only gave a di/9ction1 a ref9em5t1 to ! aspect ( ! cottage--else all 0 simplicity4 ,_s ( ,peace1 dove-l dawn t slept ^u ! cottage1 ye 7 n brok5 by any p>ticipation 9 my grief & despair6 ,= ev] ! vision ( t cottage 0 r5ew$4 ,did ,i roam 9 ! dep?s ( sweet pa/oral solitudes 9 ! ,we/1 ) ! t9kl+ ( %eep-bells 9 my e>s1 a r\nd$ hillock1 se5 vaguely1 w\ld %ape itself into a cottage2 & at ! door my monitory1 regretful ,hebe w\ld appe>4 ,did ,i w&] by ! sea%ore1 "o g5tly-swell+ wave 9 ! va/ heav+ pla9 ( wat]s w\ld sudd5ly trans=m itself into a cottage1 & ,i1 by "s involunt>y inw>d impulse1 w\ld 9 fancy advance t[>d x4 ,ah1 read]1 y w ?9k ?is :i* ,i am go+ to say too ne>1 too holy1 = recital4 ,b n s4 ,! deep] a woe t\*es me 9 he>t1 s mu* ! m am ,i urg$ to recite x4 ,! _w disappe>s3 ,i see only ! gr& reliques ( a _w--memorials ( a love t has dep>t$1 has be5--! record ( a sorr[ t is1 & has its greyness conv]t$ into v]dure--monum5ts ( a wra? t has be5 reconcil$1 ( a wrong t has be5 aton$ =--convulsions ( a /orm t has gone by4 ,:at ,i am go+ to say is ! mo/ l a sup]/iti\s ?+ t ,i ev] %all say4 ,& ,i h reason to ?9k t e man :o is n a villa9 once 9 8 life mu/ be sup]/iti\s4 ,x is a tribute :i* he pays to human frailty1 :i* tribute if he w n pay1 :i* frailty if he w n %>e1 !n also he %all n h any ( its /r5g?4 ,! face ( ?is monitory ,hebe haunt$ me = "s ye>s 9 a way t ,i mu/ fa9tly attempt to expla94 ,x is little to say t x 0 ! sweete/ face1 ) ! mo/ peculi> expression ( sweetness1 t ,i _h ev] se53 t 0 mu*1 b t 0 e>?ly4 ,!re 0 some?+ m t]rific1 believe me1 ?an ?is2 yet t 0 n ! ^w3 t]ror looks to ! future2 & ?is p]haps did1 b n prim>ily4 ,*iefly x look$ at "s unkn[n pa/1 & 0 = t reason awful2 yes1 awful--t 0 ! ^w4 ,?us1 on any ( ^? heav5ly sunny morn+s1 t n[ are buri$ 9 an endless grave1 did ,i1 transport$ by no human means1 ent] t cottage1 & desc5d to t breakfa/-room1 my e>lie/ salute 0 to h]1 t ev]1 z ! look ( pictures d1 ) h] eyes pursu$ me r\nd ! room1 & (t5times ) a subtle *eck+ ( grief1 z if great sorr[ _h be5 or w\ld be h]s4 ,& x 01 too1 9 ! sweet ,maytime4 ,oh yes2 %e 0 b z if %e _h be5--z if x 7 h] orig9al 444 *os5 to h be5 ! aurora ( a heav5ly clime2 & !n sudd5ly %e 0 z "o ( :om1 = "s ?\s& ye>s1 ,p>adise _h receiv$ no report2 !n1 aga91 z if %e ent]$ ! gates ( ,p>adise n less innoc5t2 &1 aga91 z if %e c\ld n ent]2 & "s blame--b ,i knew n :at blame--0 m9e2 & n[ %e look$ z ?\gh brok5 ) a woe t no man c\ld read1 z %e s\ght to travel back to h] e>ly joy--yet no long] a joy t is sublime 9 innoc5cy1 b a joy f :i* sprung abysses ( memories pollut$ into angui%1 till h] te>s seem$ to be suffus$ ) drops ( blood4 ,all ar\nd 0 peace & ! deep sil5ce ( untr\bl$ solitude2 only 9 ! lovely lady 0 a sign ( horror1 t _h slept1 "u deep ages ( fro/1 9 h] he>t1 & n[ rose1 z ) ! ru%+ ( w+s1 to h] face4 ,c\ld x be suppos$ t "o life--s pitiful a ?+--0 :at mov$ h] c>e8 ,oh no2 x 01 or x seem$1 z if ?is poor wreck ( a life happ5$ to be t "o :i* det]m9$ ! fate ( "s ?\s& o!rs4 ,no?+ less2 no?+ s abject z "o poor fifty ye>s--no?+ less ?an a c5tury ( c5turies c\ld h /irr$ ! horror t rose to h] lovely lips1 z once m %e wav$ me away f ! cottage4 ,oh1 read]1 five ye>s aft] ,i saw t sweet face 9 reality--saw x 9 ! fle%2 saw t pomp ( womanhood2 saw t cottage2 saw a ?\s& times t lovely domicile t he>d ! coo+ ( ! solit>y dove 9 ! solit>y morn+2 saw ! grace ( *ildhood & ! %ad[s ( graves t lay1 l creatures asleep1 9 ! sun%9e2 saw1 also1 ! horror1 someh[ realiz$ z a %ad[y reflection f myself1 :i* w>n$ me (f f t cottage1 & :i* /ill r+s ?r\gh ! dreams ( five-&-tw5ty ye>s4 ,! g5]al s5tim5t or s5se ( pre-exi/5ce1 ( :i* ?is ,suspiria may be reg>d$ z "o significant & affect+ illu/ration1 _h ?is record 9 ! outset ( ! ',rem9isc5ces ( ,wordswor?'3 ',oh1 s5se ( my/]i\s pre-exi/5ce1 by :i*1 ?r\gh ye>s1 9 :i* z yet a /rang] to ^? valleys ( ,we/morel&1 ,i view$ myself z a phantom self--a second id5tity project$ f my own consci\sness1 & already liv+ among/ !m--h[ 0 x1 & by :at prophetic in/9ct1 t already ,i said to myself (t5times1 :5 *as+ day-dreams along ! pictures ( ^! wild m\nta9\s labyr9?s1 :i* z yet ,i _h n trav]s$1 ,"h1 9 "s di/ant ye>1 ,i %all be %ak5 ) love1 & !re ) /ormie/ grief & regret8 ,:5ce 0 x t sudd5 revelations came ^u me1 l ! draw+s up ( a curta91 & clos+ aga9 z rapidly1 ( sc5es t made ! future heav5 ( my life8 ,& h[ 0 x t 9 ?\ght ,i 01 & yet 9 reality 0 n1 a d5iz51 already1 9 #ahjc1 #ahjd1 #ahje1 ( lakes & =e/ lawns1 :i* ,i nev] saw till #ahjg8 & t1 by a prophetic in/9ct ( he>t1 ,i rehe>s$ & liv$ ov]1 z x 71 9 vision ^? *apt]s ( my life :i* h c>ri$ ) !m ! weightie/ burd5 ( joy & sorr[1 & by ! m>g9 ( ^? v lakes & hills ) :i* ,i prefigur$ ?is connection8 &1 9 %ort1 t = me1 by a transc5d5t privilege1 dur+ ! novitiate ( my life1 mo/ truly ,i might say3 ',9 to-day already walk$ to-morr[4' #d4--,,! ,,pr9cess ,,:o ,,ov]look$ ,,"o ,,se$ ,,9 ,a ,,pomegranate4 ,!re is a /ory told 9 ! ',arabian ,nights' ( a pr9cess :o1 by ov]look+ "o se$ ( a pomegranate1 precipitat$ ! ev5t :i* %e _h lab\r$ to make impossible4 ,%e lies 9 wait = ! ev5t :i* %e =esees4 ,! pomegranate swells1 op5s1 splits2 ! se$s1 :i* %e kn[s to be roots ( evil1 rapidly %e swall[s2 b "o--only "o--be=e x c\ld be arre/$1 rolls away into a riv]4 ,x is lo/6 x is irrecov]able6 ,%e has triumph$1 b %e mu/ p]i%4 ,already %e feels ! flames m\nt+ up :i* are to consume h]1 & %e calls = wat] ha/ily--n to deliv] h]self 7= t is impossible71 b1 nobly =gett+ h] own mis]y1 t %e may prev5t t de/ruction ( h] bro!r mortal :i* _h be5 ! orig9al object = haz>d+ h] own4 ,yet :y g to ,arabian fictions8 ,ev5 9 our daily life is exhibit$1 9 proportions f> m gigantic1 t t5d5cy to swell & amplify itself into m\nta9s ( d>kness1 :i* exi/s (t5times 9 g]ms t are imp]ceptible4 ,an error 9 human *oice1 an infirmity 9 ! human w1 ?\gh x 7 at fir/ less ?an a mote1 ?\gh x %\ld sw]ve f ! "r l9e by an int]val less ?an any ?read ',t ev] spid] twi/$ f h] womb1' sometimes beg9s to swell1 to gr[1 to wid5 its di/ance rapidly1 travels (f into b\ndless spaces remote f ! true c5tre1 spaces incalculable & irretraceable1 until hope seems ext+ui%$ & return impossible4 ,su* 0 ! c\rse ( my own opium c>e]4 ,su* is ! hi/ory ( human errors e day4 ,su* 0 ! orig9al s9 ( ! ,greek !ories on ,deity1 :i* c\ld n h be5 heal$ b by putt+ (f _! own nature1 & k9dl+ into a new pr9ciple--absolutely undiscov]able1 z ,i cont5d1 = ! ,grecian intellect4 ,(t5times an e*o goes z x 7 to sleep3 ! s]ies ( rev]b]ations has di$ away4 ,sudd5ly a second s]ies awak5s3 ?is subsides1 !n a ?ird wak5s up4 ,s ( actions done 9 y\?4 ,aft] great tumults all is quiet$4 ,y dream t !y are ov]4 ,9 a mom5t1 9 ! tw9kl+ ( an eye1 on "s fatal morn+ 9 middle-life ! f>-(f consequ5ces come back ^u y4 ,& y say to y\rself1 ',oh1 ,heav51 if ,i _h fifty lives ?is crime w\ld reappe>1 z ,pelion ^u ,ossa6' ,s 0 x ) my affection4 ,left to natural peace1 ,i might h conqu]$ x3 ,v]s*m]zeon4 ,to *>m x d[n by ! m]e suff]+ ( grief1 to hu% x by endurance1 t 0 ! natural policy--t 0 ! natural process4 ,b behold6 ,a new =m ( sorr[ arises1 & ! two multiply toge!r4 ,& ! worm :i* 0 beg9n+ to fall asleep is r\s$ aga9 to pe/il5tial fi]c5ess4 #e4--,,notes ,,= ',,suspiria4' ,my/]y unfa?omable ( ,dea?6 ,my/]y unapproa*able ( ,god6 ,de/9$ x 01 f ! f\ndations ( ! _w1 t ea* my/]y %\ld make w> ^u ! o!r3 once t ! less] my/]y %\ld swall[ up = a mom5t a limbus ( ! great]2 & t woe is pa/3 once t ! great] my/]y %\ld swall[ up = ev] ! :ole vortex ( ! less]2 & t glory is yet to come4 ,aft] :i* man1 t is ! son ( ,god1 %all lift up 8 eyes = ev]1 say+1 ',behold6 ^! 7 two my/]ies2 & "o is n2 & !re is b "o my/]y t survives = ev]6' ,if an et]nity 7,dea? suppos$7 is z va/ z a />1 yet ! mo/ mis]able ( e>?ly blocks n f\r feet squ>e w eclipse1 masque1 hide x f c5tre to circumf]5ce4 ,& s x really is4 ,incr$ible z x might seem ap>t f exp]i5ce1 ! dreadful reality ( dea? is utt]ly )drawn f u because itself dw9dles to an app>5t mote1 & ! p]i%+ non-reality ?ick5s into a d>kness z massy z a rock4 ,great *anges summon to great m$itations4 ,daily we see ! mo/ joy\s ( ev5ts take a col\r+ ( solemnity f ! m]e relation 9 :i* !y /& to an unc]ta9 future3 ! bir? ( a *ild1 heir to ! greate/ expectations1 & welcom$ clamor\sly by ! sympa?y ( myriads1 speaks to ! m reflect+ 9 an und]tone ( monitory sadness1 7 x only z a tribute to ! frailty ( human expectations3 & a m>riage-day1 ( all human ev5ts ! mo/ lawfully fe/al1 yet ne$s some?+ ( ef=t to *ase away ! bod+ sadness :i* settles unavoidably ^u any new c>e]2 ! promise is vague1 b new hopes h creat$ new dang]s1 & responsibilities contract$ p]haps ) rapture are *>g$ ) m5ace4 ,= e "o ( u1 male or female1 !re is a ye> ( crisis--a ye> ( solemn & consci\s transition1 a ye> 9 :i* ! light-he>t$ s5se ( ! irresponsible ceases to gild ! heav5ly dawn4 ,a ye> !re is1 settl$ by no law or usage1 = me p]haps ! eighte5?1 = y ! sev5te5?1 = ano!r ! n9ete5?1 )9 ! gates ( :i*1 und]nea? ! gloomy ar*way ( :i*1 sits a phantom ( y\rself4 ,turn a screw1 tight5 a l9*-p9--:i* is n to disease1 b p]haps to exalt1 ! mighty ma*9]y ( ! bra9--& ! ,inf9ities appe>1 be=e :i* ! tranquillity ( man unsettles1 ! graci\s =ms ( life dep>t1 & ! gho/ly ent]s4 ,s pr(\ndly is ?is true1 t (t5times ,i h said ( my own trem5d\s exp]i5ce 9 ?is region--de/9$ too c]ta9ly1 ,i fe>1 f9ally to swall[ up intellect & ! life ( life 9 ! he>t1 unless ,god ( ,8 m]cy fet*es me away by "s sudd5 dea?--t dea?1 consid]$ z an entrance to ?is gho/ly _w1 is b a po/]n-gate by comp>ison ) ! heav5-aspir+ ve/ibule ?r\gh :i* ?is _w ( ! ,inf9ite introduces ! gho/ly _w4 ,"t1 if x does n dim9i% grief1 alt]s its "*4 ,at fir/ we /ret* out our h&s 9 v bl9dness ( he>t1 z if try+ to draw back aga9 ^? :om we h lo/4 ,b1 aft] a season1 :5 ! impot5ce ( su* ef=ts has become too s5sibly felt1 f9d+ t !y w n come back to u1 a /range fasc9ation arises :i* ye>ns aft] "s mode ( go+ to !m4 ,!re is a gulf fix$ :i* *ildhood r>ely c pass4 ,b we l9k our wi%es ) :atsoev] w\ld g5tly waft u ov]4 ,we /ret* out our h&s1 & say1 ',si/]1 l5d u ?y help1 & plead = u ) ,god1 t we may pass ov] )\t mu* agony4' ,! joy ( an infant1 or joy-g5]ation1 )\t significance to an unpr(\nd & common m9d--h[ /range to see ! excess ( pa?os 9 t2 yet m5 ( any 7or at lea/ ( mu*7 s5sibility see 9 ?is a transpicu\s masque = ano!r =m1 viz41 ! et]nal gr\nd ( sorr[ 9 all human he>ts4 ,?is1 by ! way1 9 an essay on ,william ,wordswor?1 %\ld be notic$ z ! *>m ( 8 poetry2 & ! note diff]5tial1 9 fact4 ,at lea/1 ,i "k n ( any =m] poet :o has s sy/ematically s\ght 8 sadness 9 ! v luxury ( joy4 ,?us1 9 ! ',two ,april ,morn+s1' ':at a mortal fre%ness ( dewy radiance6 :at an attraction ( e>ly summ]6 :at a vision ( roses 9 ,june6 ,yet x is all transmut$ to a purpose ( sadness4' ,ah1 read]1 scorn n t :i*--:e!r y refuse x or n z ! reality ( realities--is assur$ly ! reality ( dreams1 l9k+ u to a f> va/] cycle1 9 :i* ! love & ! langui%+1 ! ru9 & ! horror1 ( ?is _w are b mom5ts--b elem5ts 9 an et]nal circle4 ,! cycle /ret*es f an ,ea/ t is =gott5 to a ,we/ t is b conjectur$4 ,! m]e fact ( y\r own individual calamity is a life2 ! trag$y is a nature2 ! hope is b z a dim augury writt5 on a fl[]4#e ,if ! ?+s t h frett$ u _h n "s art = retir+ into secret oblivion1 :at a hell w\ld life become6 ,n[1 und]/& h[ 9 "s n]v\s d]angem5ts ?is horror really takes place4 ,"s ?+s t _h sunk into utt] =getfulness1 o!rs t _h fad$ into vision>y p[]1 all rise z gray phantoms f ! du/2 ! field ( our e>?ly combats t %\ld by rights h settl$ into peace1 is all alive ) ho/s ( resurrections--cavalries t sweep 9 gu/y *>ges--columns t ?und] f af>--arms gleam+ ?r\gh cl\ds ( sulphur4 ,god takes c>e = ! religion ( little *ildr5 :]esoev] ,8 ,*ri/ianity exi/s4 ,:]esoev] !re is a national ,*ur* e/abli%$1 to :i* a *ild sees all 8 protectors resort2 :]esoev] he beholds among/ e>?ly creatures :om mo/ he hon\rs pro/rate 9 devotion be=e ^! illimitable heav5s1 :i* fill to ov]fl[+ ! total capacities ( 8 "y ador+ he>t2 :]esoev] at int]vals he beholds ! sleep ( dea?1 fall+ ^u ! m5 or wom5 :om he has se5--a dep? /ret*+ z f> bel[ 8 p[] to fa?om z ^? p]sons asc5d beyond 8 p[]s to pursue--,god speaks to _! he>ts by dreams & _! tumultu\s gr&eurs4 ,ev5 by solitude does ,god speak to little *ildr51 :5 made vocal by ! s]vices ( ,*ri/ianity1 z also he does by d>kness :]esoev] x is peopl$ ) visions ( ,8 almighty p[]4 ,= a pagan *ild1 = a ,greek *ild1 solitude 0 no?+2 = a ,*ri/ian *ild x is made ! p[] ( ,god1 & ! hi]oglyphic ( ,8 mo/ di/ant tru?4 ,! solitude 9 life is deep = ! millions :o h none to love !m1 & deep = ^? :o suff] by secret & incommunicable woe & h none to pity !m4 ,?us1 be y assur$ t ?\gh infancy talks lea/ ( t :i* slumb]s deepe/1 x yet re/s 9 its own transc5d5t solitude4 ,b infancy1 y say1 talks surely mo/ ( t :i* is upp]mo/ 9 its he>t4 ,yes1 d\btless ( t :i* is upp]mo/1 b n at all ( t :i* slumb]s bel[ ! f\ndations ( its he>t4 ,& !n foll[s a sugge/ion to put 9 a note3 ,i except "o case1 ! case ( any *ild :o is m>k$ = dea? by organic disease1 & kn[s x4 ,9 su* cases ! creature is *ang$--t :i* w\ld h be5 un*ildlike ceases to (f5d1 = a new "* is =m+4 ,,footnotes3 #a ,see ! /ory ( ! "y soldi] :o told 8 (fic]1 on hav+ be5 /ruck by him1 t 'he w\ld make him rep5t x4' 7,close ( autobiographic sket*1 ',infant ,lit]ature4'7 #b ,?ree ?\s& *ildr5 are annually burnt to dea? 9 ! nations ( ,engl& & ,scotl&1 *iefly ?r\gh ! c>elessness ( p>5ts4 ,i %udd] to add ano!r & d>k] cause1 :i* is a deep disgrace to ! pres5t age4 #c ,c\nt ,massigli 7an ,au/rian (fic] 9 ! imp]ial s]vice7 ab\t sixty ye>s ago fa?om$ & attempt$ to fa?om _m p>ts ( ! ,m$it]ranean & ! ,atlantic4 ,if ,i rememb] rightly1 he f\nd ! bottom )9 less ?an an ,engli% mile4 #d ,! /ory & ! v]ses are1 or us$ to be1 well kn[n4 ,a s*oolboy1 =bidd5 to return home at ! holidays1 is suspect$ to h writt5 ! lyrical ,lat9 v]ses ^u ! rapture ( return+ home1 & to h brea!d out 8 life 9 ! angui% ( ?us reviv+ ! images :i* = him 7 nev] to be realiz$4444 ,! read] mu/ n fancy any flaw 9 ! ,lat9 title4 ,x is elliptic2 revis]e be+ und]/ood1 or "s simil> ^w4 #e ,i allude to ! signatures ( nature4 ,,ii4 ,,! ,,lovelie/ ,,sight ,,= ,,woman',s ,,eyes4 ,! lovelie/ sight t a woman's eye op5s ^u 9 ?is _w is h] fir/-born *ild2 & ! holie/ sight ^u :i* ! eyes ( ,god settle 9 ,almighty sanction & p]fect bless+ is ! love :i* soon k9dles betwe5 ! "m & h] infant3 mute & spee*less on ! "o side1 ) no language b te>s & kisses & looks4 ,beautiful is ! philosophy 444 :i* arises out ( t reflection or passion connect$ ) ! transition t has produc$ x4 ,fir/ comes ! :ole mighty drama ( love1 purifi$#f ev] m & m1 h[ (t5 f gross] feel+s1 yet ( necessity ?r\gh its v elem5ts1 oscillat+ betwe5 ! f9ite & ! inf9ite3 ! haught9ess ( womanly pride1 s dignifi$1 yet n always free f ! ne> contagion ( error2 ! romance s ennobl+1 yet n always entirely reasonable2 ! t5d] dawn ( op5+ s5tim5ts1 po9t+ to an idea 9 all ?is :i* x nei!r c rea* nor c\ld long su/a94 ,?9k ( ! great /orm ( agitation1 & fe> & hope1 ?r\gh :i*1 9 h] e>lie/ days ( womanhood1 e woman mu/ naturally pass1 fulfill+ a law ( h] ,creator1 yet a law :i* re/s ^u h] mix$ con/itution2 animal1 ?\gh indef9itely asc5d+ to :at is non-animal--z a daught] ( man1 frail 444 & imp]fect1 yet also z a daught] ( ,god1 /&+ erect1 ) eyes to ! heav5s4 ,next1 :5 ! great v]nal passov] ( sexual t5d]ness & romance has fulfill$ its purpose1 we see1 ris+ z a ,pho5ix f ?is great my/]y ( ennobl$ in/9cts1 ano!r my/]y1 mu* m pr(\nd1 m affect+1 m div9e--n s mu* a rapture z a blissful repose ( a ,sabba?1 :i* swall[s up ! m p]i%+ /ory ( ! fir/2 =c+ ! va/ he>t ( female nature ?r\gh /ages ( asc5t1 =c+ x to pursue ! transmigrations ( ! ,psy*e f ! aurelic condition1 s gl[+ 9 its col\r1 into ! w+$ creature :i* mixes ) ! my/]y ( ! dawn1 & asc5ds to ! alt> ( ! inf9ite heav5s1 ris+ by a ladd] ( light f t sympa?y :i* ,god surveys ) approbation2 & ev5 m s z ,he beholds x self-purify+ "u ,8 ,*ri/ianity to t sympa?y :i* ne$s no purification1 b is ! holie/ ( ?+s on ?is e>?1 & t 9 :i* ,god mo/ reveals ,himself ?r\gh ! nature ( humanity4 ,well is x = ! glorification ( human nature t ?r\gh ^! ! va/ majority ( wom5 mu/ = ev] pass2 well also t1 by plac+ its sublime g]ms ne> to female y\?1 ,god ?us turns away by anticipation ! div9e/ ( discipl9es f ! rapaci\s absorption ( ! grave4 ,"t is f\nd--h[ (t5--= ^? :o are e>ly summon$ into r5d]+ back _! glori\s privilege1 :o yet h ta/$ 9 its fir/-fruits ! p>adise ( mat]nal love4 ,& p]ta9+ also to ?is "p ( ! subject1 ,i w tell y a result ( my own obs]vations ( no light importance to wom54 ,x is ?is3 ,n9ete5 times out ( tw5ty ,i h rem>k$ t ! true p>adise ( a female life 9 all ranks1 n too elevat$ = con/ant int]c\rse ) ! *ildr51 is by no means ! ye>s ( c\rt%ip1 nor ! e>lie/ p]iod ( m>riage1 b t seque/]$ *amb] ( h] exp]i5ce1 9 :i* a "m is left alone ?r\gh ! day1 ) s]vants p]haps 9 a di/ant "p ( ! h\se1 & 7,god be ?ank$67 *iefly :]e !re are no s]vants at all1 %e is att5d$ by "o sole companion1 h] little fir/-born angel1 z yet cl++ to h] robe1 imp]fectly able to walk1 /ill m imp]fect 9 its prattl+ & innoc5t ?\ghts1 cl++ to h]1 haunt+ h] :]ev] %e goes z h] %ad[1 cat*+ f h] eye ! total inspiration ( its little palpitat+ he>t1 & s5d+ to h]s a ?rill ( secret pleasure s (t5 z its little f+]s fa/5 on h] own4 ,left alone f morn+ to night ) ?is "o companion1 or ev5 ) ?ree1 /ill we>+ ! graces ( infancy2 buds ( v>i\s /ages ^u ! self-same tree1 a woman1 if %e has ! great bless+ ( approa*+ su* a luxury ( p>adise1 is mov+--too (t5 n aw>e t %e is mov+--?r\gh ! div9e/ section ( h] life4 ,z ev5+ sets 91 ! husb&1 ?r\gh all walks ( life1 f ! highe/ pr(essional d[n to t ( common lab\r1 returns home to v>y h] modes ( conv]sation by su* ?\ghts & int]e/s z are m consonant ) 8 m ext5sive capacities ( intellect4 ,b by t "t h] *ild 7or h] *ildr57 w be repos+ on ! little c\*1 & 9 ! morn+1 duly z ! sun asc5ds 9 p[]1 %e sees be=e h] a long1 long day ( p]fect pleasure 9 ?is society :i* ev5+ w br+ to h]1 b :i* is int]wov5 ) e fibre ( h] s5sibilities4 ,?is condition ( noiseless1 quiet love is t1 above all1 :i* ,god blesses & smiles ^u4 ,,footnotes3 #f ,h[ purifi$8 ,& if x %\ld be answ]$1 ?r\gh & "u ,*ri/ianity1 ! fool 9 8 he>t w\ld sc(f & say3 ',:at woman ?9ks ( religion 9 h] y\?ful c\rt%ip8' ,no2 b x is n :at %e ?9ks (1 b :at ?9ks ( h]2 n :at %e contemplates 9 consci\sness1 b :at contemplates h]1 & rea*es h] by a necessity ( social 78 ideal7 action4 ,romance is ! product ( ,*ri/ianity1 b s is s5tim5t4 ,,iii4 ,,:y ,,! ,,pagans ,,c\ld ,,n ,,inve/ ,,_! ,,gods ,,) ,,any ,,iota ,,( ,,gr&eur4 ,x is n = s idle a purpose z t ( %[+ ! ,pagan backslid+--t is too evid5t--b = a f> subtl] purpose1 & "o :i* no man has t\*$1 viz41 ! incapacity ( creat+ gr&eur = ! ,pagans1 ev5 ) c>te blan*e 9 _! fav\r1 t ,i write ?is pap]4 ,no?+ is m incompreh5sible ?an ! foll[+ fact--no?+ ?an ?is :5 ma/]$ & und]/ood is m ?or\ghly in/ructive--! fact t hav+ a wide1 a limitless field op5 be=e !m1 free to give & to take away at _! own pleasure1 ! ,pagans c\ld n inve/ _! ,gods ) any iota ( gr&eur4 ,diana1 :5 y translate h] into ! ,moon1 !n inde$ p>takes 9 all ! natural gr&eur ( a planet associat$ ) a dreamy light1 ) =e/s1 =e/ lawns1 etc41 or ! wild accid5ts ( a huntress4 ,b ! ,moon & ! ,huntress are surely n ! creations ( ,pagans1 nor indebt$ to !m = any?+ b ! murd]\s deplum+ :i* ,pagan my?ology has op]at$ ^u all t is 9 e>? or 9 ! wat]s t are "u ! e>?4 ,n[1 :y c\ld n ! anci5ts raise "o little sc9tillat+ glory 9 behalf ( _! mon/r\s deities8 ,s f> are !y f ?us rais+ ,jupit]1 t he is sometimes made ! gr\nd ( nature 7n1 obs]ve1 = any positive reason t !y _h = any relation t ,jupit] _h to ,creation1 b simply = ! negative reason t !y _h nobody else7--nev] does ,jupit] seem m disgu/+ ?an :5 z j n[ 9 a translation ( ! ',batra*ia' ,i read t ,jupit] _h giv5 to frogs an amphibi\s nature1 mak+ ! awful1 anci5t1 fir/-born secrets ( ,*aos to be 81 & ?us =c+ into contra/ & remembrance 8 odi\s p]sonality4 ,:y1 :y1 :y c\ld n ! ,romans1 etc41 make a gr&eur = _! ,gods8 ,n be+ able to make !m gr&1 !y daub$ !m ) f9]y4 ,all t p imag9e 9 ! ,jupit] ,olympus ( ,phidias--!y !mselves conf]4 ,b an apo/le is beyond _! rea*4 ,:51 be x well obs]v$1 ! cruel & d>k religions are f> m successful ?an ^? ( ,greece & ,rome1 = ,osiris1 etc41 by ! might ( ! devil1 ( d>kness1 are truly t]rific4 ,cybele /&s z a middle t]m half-way betwe5 ^! d>k =ms & ! ,greek or ,roman4 ,pluto is ! v model ( a puny attempt at d>kness utt]ly fail+4 ,he looks big2 he pa9ts himself hi/rionically2 he soots 8 face2 he has a ma/]ful dog1 no?+ half s fe>ful z a wolf-dog or bloodh\nd2 & he raises 8 own manes1 poor1 /ridul\s ,/ruldbrugs4 ,va9ly did ! anci5t ,pagans fight aga9/ ?is fatal weakness4 ,!y may conf] ^u _! ,gods glitt]+ titles ( 'ambrosial1' 'immortal'2 b ! human m9d is c>eless ( positive ass]tion1 & ( clamor\s it]ation 9 h[ev] angry a tone1 :5 sil5tly x obs]ves /eal+ out ( facts already conc$$ "s fatal consequ5ce at w> ) all ^! empty pret5sions--mortal ev5 9 ! virtual conceptions ( ! ,pagans4 ,if ! ,pagan ,gods 7 really immortal1 if ess5tially !y repell$ ! t\* ( mortality1 & n ?r\gh ! adulatory homage ( _! wor%ip]s caus+ _! true aspects to unsettle or altoge!r to disappe> 9 cl\ds ( inc5se1 !n h[ came :ole dyna/ies ( ,gods to pass away1 & no man c\ld tell :i!r8 ,if really !y defi$ ! grave1 !n h[ 0 x t age & ! infirmities ( age pass$ ^u !m l ! %ad[ ( eclipse ^u ! gold5 faces ( ! planets8 ,if ,apollo 7 a be>dless "y man1 8 fa!r 0 n su*--he 0 9 ! vig\r ( maturity2 maturity is a flatt]+ t]m = express+ x1 b x means pa/ y\?--& 8 gr&fa!r 0 sup]annuat$4 ,b ev5 ?is gr&fa!r1 :o _h be5 once :at ,apollo 0 n[1 c\ld n pret5d to m ?an a transitory /ation 9 ! long succession ( ,gods4 ,o!r dyna/ies1 kn[n ev5 to man1 !re _h be5 be=e 82 & eld] dyna/ies be=e t1 ( :om only rum\rs & suspicions surviv$4 ,ev5 ?is ta9t1 h[ev]1 ?is direct access ( mortality1 0 less %ock+ to my m9d 9 aft]-ye>s ?an ! abom9able fact ( its reflex or indirect access 9 ! %ape ( grief = o!rs :o _h di$4 ,i ne$ n multiply in/ances2 !y are )\t end4 ,! read] has b to ?r[ 8 memory back ^u ! angui% ( ,jupit]1 9 ! ',iliad1' = ! approa*+ dea? ( 8 son ,s>p$on1 & 8 va9 /ruggles to deliv] himself f ?is gha/ly net2 or ^u ,!tis1 fight+ aga9/ ! vision ( h] mat*less ,pelides caught 9 ! same vortex2 or ^u ! ,muse 9 ,euripides1 hov]+ 9 ! air & wail+ ov] h] "y ,rhesus1 h] brave1 h] beautiful "o1 ( :om %e tru/$ t he _h be5 de/9$ to conf\nd ! ,grecian ho/4 ,:at6 a ,god1 & liable to ! pollution ( grief6 ,a ,goddess1 & /&+ e h\r )9 ! p]il ( t dismal %ad[6 ,"h 9 "o mom5t m>k ! recoil1 ! intol]able recoil1 ^u ! ,pagan m9d1 ( t /+ :i* va9ly !y pret5d$ to h conqu]$ on behalf ( _! ,pan!on4 ,did ! read] fancy t ,i 0 fatigu+ myself ) any task s sup]flu\s z t ( prov+ ! ,gods ( ! hea!n to be no ,gods8 ,9 t case he has n und]/ood me4 ,my object is to %[ t ! anci5ts1 t ev5 ! ,greeks1 c\ld n support ! idea ( immortality4 ,! idea crumbl$ to pieces "u _! t\*4 ,9 realiz+ t idea unconsci\sly1 !y suff]$ elem5ts to slip 9 :i* defeat$ its v ess5ce 9 ! result2 & n by accid5t3 o!r elem5ts !y c\ld n h f\nd4 ,d\btless an insol5t ,grecian philosoph] w\ld say1 ',surely1 ,i knew t immortality meant ! be+ lib]at$ f mortality4' ,yes1 b ?is is no m ?an ! negative idea1 & ! dem& is to give ! affirmative idea4 ,or p]haps ,i %all bett] expla9 my mean+ by sub/itut+ o!r t]ms ) my own illu/ration ( _! value4 ,i say1 !n1 t ! ,greek idea ( immortality involves only ! nom9al idea1 n ! real idea4 ,n[1 ! nom9al idea 7or1 :i* is ! same ?+1 ! nom9al def9ition7 is t :i* simply sket*es ! outl9e ( an object 9 ! %ape ( a problem2 :]eas ! real def9ition fills up t outl9e & solves t problem4 ,! nom9al def9ition /ates ! conditions "u :i* an object w\ld be realiz$ = ! m9d2 ! real def9ition executes ^? conditions4 ,! nom9al def9ition1 t ,i may express x mo/ briefly & po9t$ly1 puts a "q2 ! real def9ition answ]s t "q4 ,?us1 to give our illu/ration1 ! insoluble problem ( squ>+ ! circle pres5ts u ) a good nom9al idea4 ,!re is no vagu5ess at all 9 ! idea ( su* a squ>e2 x is t squ>e :i*1 :5 a giv5 circle is laid be=e y1 w\ld pres5t ! same sup]ficial cont5ts 9 su* exquisite tru? ( repetition t ! eye ( ,god c\ld detect no %ad[ ( m or ( less4 ,no?+ c be pla9] ?an ! dem&--?an ! "q4 ,b z to ! answ]1 z to ! real conditions "u :i* ?is dem& c be realiz$1 all ! wit ( man has n be5 able to d m ?an approa* x4 ,or1 aga91 ! idea ( a p]fect commonweal?1 cle> en\gh z a nom9al idea1 is 9 its infancy z a real idea4 ,or1 p]haps1 a /ill m lively illu/ration to "s read]s may be ! idea ( p]petual motion4 ,nom9ally--t is1 z an idea sket*$ problem-wise--:at is pla9]8 ,y are requir$ to assign "s pr9ciple ( motion su* t x %all revolve ?r\gh ! p>ts ( a me*anism self-su/a9$4 ,suppose ^? p>ts to be call$ by ! names ( our ,engli% alphabet1 & to /& 9 ! ord] ( our alphabet1 !n ,a is ?r\gh ,b ,c ,d1 etc41 to pass d[n ) its total p[] ^u ,z1 :i* reciprocally is to come r\nd undim9i%$ ^u ,a ,b ,c1 etc41 = ev]4 ,nev] 0 a nom9al def9ition ( :at y want m simple & lum9\s4 ,b com+ to ! real def9ition1 & f9d+ t e lett] 9 succession mu/ /ill give some?+ less ?an is receiv$--t ,o1 = in/ance1 _c give to ,p all :i* x receiv$ f ,n--!n no matt] = ! triviality ( ! loss 9 ea* sep>ate case1 always x is ga!r+ & accumulat+2 y\r h&s drop d[n 9 despair2 y feel t a pr9ciple ( dea? p]vades ! ma*9]y2 ret>d x y may1 b come x w at la/4 ,& a pro( rema9s beh9d1 z y\r only result1 t :il/ ! nom9al def9ition may sometimes run be=e ! real def9ition = ages1 & yet f9ally be ov]tak5 by x1 9 o!r cases ! "o flies hopelessly be=e ! pursuit ( ! o!r1 defies x1 & nev] w be ov]tak5 to ! end ( "t4 ,t fate1 t necessity1 besieg$ ! ,grecian idea ( immortality4 ,rise f =gott5 du/1 my ,plato2 ,/agyrite1 /& up f ! grave2 ,anaxagoras1 ) ?y bright1 cl\dless intellect t se>*$ ! skies1 ,h]aclitus1 ) ?y gloomy1 my/]i\s intellect t fa?om$ ! deeps1 come =w>d & execute = me ?is dem&4 ,h[ %all t immortality1 :i* y give1 :i* y mu/ give z a trophy ( hon\r to y\r ,pan!on1 su/a9 itself aga9/ ! blights f ^? humanities :i* also1 by an equal necessity1 />t+ f y\r basis1 give y mu/ to t ,pan!on8 ,h[ w y prev5t ! sad reflux ( t tide :i* f9ally engulfs all ?+s "u any attempt to execute ! nom9al idea ( a ,deity8 ,y _c d x4 ,weave y\r div9ities 9 t ,grecian loom ( y\rs1 & no skill 9 ! workman%ip1 nor c>e t wisdom c devise1 w ev] cure ! fatal flaws 9 ! texture3 = ! mortal ta9t lies n s mu* 9 y\r "w z 9 ! orig9al errors ( y\r loom4 ,,iv4 ,,on ,,pagan ,,sacrifices4 ,ask any well-in=m$ man at r&om :at he supposes to h be5 done ) ! sacrifices1 he w answ] t really he nev] ?\ght ab\t x1 b t naturally he supposes ! fle% 0 burnt ^u ! alt>s4 ,n at all1 read]2 a sacrifice to ! ,gods meant univ]sally a banquet to man4 ,he :o gave a spl5did public d9n] ann\nc$ 9 o!r words t he design$ to celebrate a sacrificial rite4 ,?is 0 ( c\rse4 ,he1 on ! o!r h&1 :o ann\nc$ a sacrificial pomp did 9 o!r words proclaim by s\nd ( trumpet t he gave a d9n]4 ,?is 0 ( necessity4 ,h5ce1 :5 ,agamemnon (f]s a hecatomb to ,jupit]1 8 bro!r ,m5elaus walks 9 to d9n]1 ,greek3 ha*lto/1 )\t invitation4 ,z a bro!r1 we are told by ,hom] t no invitation 0 requir$4 ,he _h ! privilege ( :at 9 ,g]man is beautifully call$ 'e9 ,k9d des ,hauses1' a *ild ( ! h\se4 ,?is disp5sation f ! necessity ( a =mal invitation ,hom] expla9s1 b z to explanation h[ he knew t !re 0 a d9n]1 t he passes ov] z sup]flu\s4 ,a va/ h]d ( ox5 c\ld n be sacrific$ )\t op5 & public display ( ! prep>ation1 & t a human banquet mu/ accompany a div9e sacrifice--?is 0 s mu* a self-evid5t tru? t ,hom] does n tr\ble himself to make s ne$less an explanation4 ,h5ce1 !re=e1 a case ( legislation 9 ,/4 ,paul's ,*ri/ian adm9i/ration1 :i* ,i w v5ture to say few read]s und]/&4 ,take ! ,fea/ ( ,ephesus4 ,"h1 z 9 all cities ( ,asia ,m9or & ,greece1 ! ,jews liv$ 9 great numb]s4 ,! univ]sal hospitality ov] all ^! regions 0 exhibit$ 9 d9n]s 7,greek3 dehipna74 ,n[1 x happ5$ n sometimes1 b always1 t he :o gave a d9n] _h on ! same day made a sacrifice at ! ,great ,temple2 nay1 ! d9n] 0 always "p ( ! sacrifice1 & ?us ! foll[+ dilemma arose4 ,scruples ( eat+ "p ( sacrifices 7 absolutely un9telligible1 except z insults to ,ephesus4 ,to d5y ! exi/5ce ( ,diana _h no mean+ 9 ! e>s ( an ,ephesian4 ,all t he did und]/& 01 t if y happ5$ to be a hat] ( ,ephesus1 y mu/ hate ! gu>dian deity ( ,ephesus4 ,& ! sole inf]5ce he c\ld collect f y\r refus+ to eat :at _h be5 hall[$ to ,diana 0--t y hat$ ,ephesus4 ,! dilemma1 !re=e1 0 ?is3 ei!r grant a tol]ation ( ?is practice1 or else f>ewell to all amicable int]c\rse = ! ,jews ) ! citiz5s4 ,9 fact1 x 0 to proclaim op5 w> if ?is concession 7 refus$4 ,a scruple ( consci5ce might h be5 all[$ =1 b a scruple ( ?is nature c\ld f9d no all[ance 9 any ,pagan city :atev]4 ,moreov]1 x _h really no f\ndation4 ,! tru? is f> o!rwise ?an t ,pagan deities 7 dreams4 ,f> f x4 ,!y 7 z real z any o!r be+s4 ,! accommodation1 !re=e1 :i* ,/4 ,paul mo/ wisely grant$ 0--to eat socially1 )\t reg>d to any c]emony ?r\gh :i* ! food might h pass$4 ,s long z ! ,judaiz+ ,*ri/ian 0 no p>ty to ! religi\s c]emonies1 he 0 free ( all p>ticipation 9 idolatry4 ,s9ce if ! m]e op5 op]ation ( a ,pagan process c\ld trans=m into ! "* ( an accomplice "o :o ) no ass5t+ he>t ate ( ! food1 9 t case ,*ri/ ,himself might by possibility h %>$ 9 an idolatr\s banquet1 & we ,*ri/ians at ?is day 9 ! ,ea/ ,indies might = mon?s toge!r become unconsci\s accomplices 9 ! f\l idolatries ( ! ,buddhi/ & ,brahm9ical sup]/itions4 ,b s ess5tially 7 ! convivial banquets ( ! ,pagans int]wov5 ) _! religi\s rites1 s ess5tially 0 a great d9n] a great (f]+ to ! ,gods1 & vice v]s--a great (f]+ to ! ,gods a great d9n]--t ! v m9i/]s & *ief ag5ts 9 religion 7 at fir/ ! same4 ,cocus1 or ,greek3 mageiro/1 0 ! v same p]son z ! ,pope1 or presid+ arbit] 9 succession to a ,pope4 ',sunt eadem1' says ,casaubon1 ',cocus et ,pope4' ,& ( ?is a mo/ /rik+ example is yet extant 9 ,a!nu4 ,f ! correspond5ce :i* = _m c5turies 0 extant betwe5 ,alex&] ! ,great1 :5 emb>k$ ^u 8 great exp$itions1 & 8 royal "m ,olympias1 :o rema9$ 9 ,mac$on1 0 "o f :i* we h an extract ev5 at ?is day1 :]e he1 z we le>n f ! lett] quot$1 _h be5 urg+ 8 "m to pur*ase = him a good cook4 ,& :at 0 made ! te/ supreme ( 8 skill8 ,:y1 ?is1 t he %\ld be ,greek3 ?ysihn hempeiro/1 an arti/ able to dress a sacrificial banquet4 ,:at he meant is ?is3 ,i d n want an ord9>y cook1 :o might be equal to ! prep>ation ( a pla9 7or1 :at is ! same ?+1 secul>7 d9n]1 b a p]son qualifi$ or compet5t to take *>ge ( a hecatomb d9n]4 ,8 "m's reply addresses itself to t "o po9t only3 ,greek3 ,peligua ton mageiron labe hapd ?/ mtro/1 :i* is 9 effect3 ',a cook is x t y want8 ,:y1 !n1 y _c d bett] ?an take m9e4 ,! man is a reliable table ( sacrifices2 he kn[s ! :ole ritual ( ^? great (ficial & sacr$ d9n]s giv5 by ! late k+1 y\r fa!r4 ,he is acqua9t$ ) ! :ole cuis9e ( ! m my/]i\s religions1 ! ,orgiacs' 7probably f ! neighb\r+ ,?race71 '& all ! great c]emonies & obs]vances practis$ at ,olympia1 & ev5 :at y may eat on ! great ,/4 ,leg] ,day4 ,s don't lose sight ( ! arrangem5t1 b take ! man z a pres5t1 f me1 y\r affectionate "m1 & be sure to s5d (f an express = him at y\r e>lie/ conv5i5ce4' 99 99 99 99 99 ,pr(essor ,rob]tson ,smi? 9 8 late/ "w has well po9t$ out t ev5 ) ! ,hebrews ! sacrifices 7 eat5 9 common till ! sev5? c5tury ,b4 ,c41 :5 ! s9-(f]+s1 9 a "t ( great national di/ress1 came to be sla9 be=e ,jehovah1 & 'none b ! prie/s ate ( ! fle%1' a phase ( sacrificial specialization :i* m>ks ! beg9n+ ( ! exclusive sac]dotalism ( ! ,jews4--,,ed4 ,v4 ,,on ,,! ,,my?us4 ,t :i* ! tradition ( ! p is to ! tru? ( facts--t is a my?us to ! reasonable orig9 ( ?+s4 ,transcrib]'s ,note3 ?ree dots 9 a v]tical l9e above a t9y circle ,^! objects to an eye at ,transcrib]'s ,note3 l[ t9y circle might all melt into "o ano!r1 z />s are conflu5t :i* mod]n a/ronomy has prismatically split4 ,says ,r5nell1 z a reason = a ,mahometan orig9 ( a canal ?r\gh ,cairo1 su* is ! tradition ( ! p4 ,b we see among/ ourselves h[ great works are ascrib$ to ! devil or to ! ,romans by antiqu>ians4 ,9 ,r5nell we see ! effects ( syn!sis4 ,he ?r[s back 8 obs]vations1 l a woman ?read+ a s]ies ( ne$les or a %uttle runn+ ?r\gh a s]ies ( r+s1 ?r\gh a succession ( ,egyptian canals 7p4 #dgh71 %[+ ! real action ( ! case1 t a t5d5cy exi/$ to ?is4 ,&1 by ! way1 "h comes ano!r /rong illu/ration ( ! popul> adult]ations4 ,!y 9 our c\ntry conf\nd ! ',romans1' a vulg> expression = ! ,roman ,ca?olics1 ) ! anci5t national p ( ,rome4 ,"h "o elem5t ( a my?us ,b has melt$ into ! my?us ,x1 & 9 f>-di/ant times might be v p]plex+ to antiqu>ians1 :5 ! popul> tradition 0 too old = !m to see ! po9t ( juncture :]e ! ali5 /ream _h fall5 94 ,!n1 aga91 n only ignorance1 b love1 comb9es to adult]ate ! tradition4 ,e man wi%es to give 8 own c\ntry an int]e/ 9 any?+ great4 ,:at an ef=t has be5 made to suck ,sir ,t4 ,r4 back into ,scotl&6 ,?us1 x is too difficult )\t a motive to hold ap>t va/ di/ances or int]vals t lie 9 a field :i* has all ga!r$ into a blue haze4 ,/>s1 divid$ by millions ( miles1 collapse into ea* o!r4 ,s my?i3 & !n comes ! p]plexity--! entanglem5t4 ,!n come also1 f lacun aris+ 9 ^! int]weld$ /ories1 temptations to falsehood4 ,by ! way1 ev5 ! rec5t tale ( ,a/yages seems to h be5 piec$3 ! difficulty 0 to f9d a motive = ,cyrus1 reput$ a good man1 to make w> on 8 gr&fa!r4 ,kill him he might by accid5t4 ,b ! dream requir$ t he %\ld de?rone 8 gr&fa!r4 ,accord+ly ! dreadful /ory is devis$2 b :y %\ld ,cyrus adopt ! injuries ( a nobleman :o1 if all 7 true1 _h only sav$ himself by accid5t8 ,impossible z x w\ld seem to transmute ,socrates into a my?us1 consid]+ ! broad daylight :i* !n re/$ ^u ,a!nian hi/ory1 & ! inextricable way 9 :i* ,socrates is entangl$ 9 t hi/ory 7al?\gh we h all se5 _m a ,scriptural p]sonage s transmut$ "u f> less col\rable pret5ses or advantages71 /ill x is evid5t t ! m$ival s*oolm5 did practically treat ,socrates z some?+ ( t sort--z a my?ical1 symbolic1 or repres5tative man4 ,socrates is ! et]nal bur!n ( _! quillets1 quodlibets1 problems1 syllogisms2 = !m he is ! ,ulysses ( ! ,odyssey1 t mu*-suff]+ man2 or1 to speak m adequately1 = !m he is ! ,john ,doe & ! ,ri*>d ,roe ( ,engli% law1 ^: feuds h torm5t$ ! e>? & inc5s$ ! heav5s ?r\gh a cycle ( unc\nt$ c5turies1 & mu/ h giv5 a bad "* ( our planet on its ,engli% side4 ,to su* an ext5t 0 ?is pu%$1 t _m ( ! s*ola/ic writ]s became we>i$ ( enunciat+ or writ+ 8 "n1 &1 anticipat+ ! occasional fa%ion ( ,my lud & ,y\r lud%ip at our ,engli% ,b>1 or ( ,hocus ,pocus z an abbreviation ( pure we>9ess = ,hoc e/ ,corpus1 !y call$ him n ,socrates1 b ,sortes4 ,n[1 :5ce1 let me ask1 0 ?is cu/om d]iv$8 ,z to ,doe & ,roe1 :o or :at fir/ set !m by ! e>s toge!r is n[ probably pa/ all discov]y4 ,b z to ,sortes1 t he 0 a m]e contraction = ,socrates is prov$ 9 ! same way t ,mob is %[n to h be5 a brief way ( writ+ ,mobile vulgus1 viz41 t by ,bi%op ,/ill+fleet 9 p>ticul> ! two =ms1 ,mob & ,mobile vulgus are us$ int]*angeably & indiff]5tly ?r\gh sev]al pages consecutively--j z ,cant] & ,cant]bury gallop1 ( :i* ! "o 0 at fir/ ! m]e %or?& expression ( ! o!r1 7 at "o p]iod int]*ang$1 & = ! same reason4 ,! abbreviat$ =m wore ! air ( plebeian slang at its fir/ introduction1 b its conv5i5ce fav\r$ x3 soon x became reconcil$ to ! e>1 !n x ceas$ to be slang1 & f9ally ! orig9al =m1 ceas+ to h any app>5t advantage ( propriety or elegance1 dropp$ into total disuse4 ,sortes1 x is a cle> case1 inh]it$ f ,socrates 8 di/ress+ po/ ( t>get-g5]al = ! arr[s ( disputati\s ,*ri/5dom4 ,b h[ came ,socrates by t di/9ction8 ,i _c h a d\bt t x 0 /r5g? ( tradition t imput$ su* a use ( ! ,socratic "n & "* to ,plato4 ,! read] mu/ rememb] t1 al?\gh ,socrates 0 no my?us1 & lea/ ( all c\ld be su*1 to 8 own lead+ disciple1 t 0 no reason :y he %\ld n be treat$ z a my?us4 ,9 ,wales1 "s n9e or t5 ye>s ago1 ,rebecca1 z ! my/]i\s & masqu$ r$ress] ( public wrongs1 0 rapidly pass+ into a my?ical expression = t univ]sal "* ( ,rhadaman?ian av5g] or v9dicator4 ,s ( ,capta9 ,rock1 9 ,irel&4 ,s ( ,elias among/ ! ,jews 7:5 ,elias %all come71 z ! sublime1 my/]i\s1 & 9 "s degree pa!tic expression = a great tea*] lurk+ among/ ! dreadful mi/s4 ,,vi4 ,,david',s ,,numb]+ ,,( ,,! ,,p--,,! ,,politics ,,( ,,! ,,situation4 ,y read 9 ! ,hebrew ,scriptures ( a man :o _h ?irty sons1 all ( :om 'rode on :ite asses'2 ! rid+ on :ite asses is a circum/ance t expresses _! high rank or di/9ction--t all 7 pr9ces4 ,9 ,syria1 z 9 ,greece & almo/ ev]y:]e1 :ite 0 ! regal symbolic col\r4#g ,& any mode ( equitation1 f ! f> inf]ior weal? ( anci5t times1 impli$ weal?4 ,mules or asses1 besides t !y 7 s f> sup]ior a race 9 ,syria no less ?an 9 ,p]sia1 to furni% a fav\rite designation = a w>like h]o1 c\ld mu* m conv5i5tly be us$ on ! wret*$ roads1 z yet f\nd ev]y:]e1 until ! ,romans began to treat road-mak+ z a regul> bus9ess ( milit>y pione]+4 ,9 ?is case1 !re=e1 !re 7 ?irty sons ( "o man1 & all provid$ ) pr9cely e/abli%m5ts4 ,consequ5tly1 to h ?irty sons at all 0 some:at surpris+1 & possible only 9 a l& ( polygamy2 b to keep none back 9 obscurity 7z 0 done 9 cases :]e ! funds ( ! family w\ld n all[ ( giv+ to ea* 8 sep>ate e/abli%m5t7 argu$ a condition ( unusual opul5ce4 ,t x 0 surpris+ is v true4 ,b z !re=e involv+ any argum5t aga9/ its tru?1 ! writ] w\ld ju/ly d5y by plead+--= t v reason1 because x 0 surpris+1 did ,i tell ! /ory4 ,9 a tra9 ( #a1ejj ye>s naturally !re mu/ happ5 _m wond]ful ?+s1 bo? z to ev5ts & p]sons4 ,7 ^! cr[d$ toge!r 9 "t or locally1 ^! inde$ we %\ld incr$ul\sly reject4 ,b :5 we und]/& ! va/ remot5ess f ea* o!r 9 "t or 9 place1 we freely admit ! t5d5cy lies ! o!r way2 ! wond] w\ld be if !re 7 n _m co9cid5ces t ea* = itself sep>ately might be look$ ^u z /range4 ,& z ! surgeon _h set himself to collect c]ta9 cases = ! v reason t !y 7 s unacc\ntably fatal1 ) a purpose !re=e ( includ+ all t did n t]m9ate fatally1 s we %\ld rememb] t g5]ally hi/orians 7al?\gh less s if a ,jewi% hi/orian1 because he _h a f> nobl] *a9 ( wond]s to record7 d n feel !mselves op5 to ! objection ( romanc+ if !y report some?+ out ( ! ord9>y track1 s9ce exactly t sort ( matt] is _! object1 & x _c b be f\nd 9 a consid]able proportion :5 _! c\rse travels ov] a va/ range ( successive g5]ations4 ,x w\ld be a m>vell\s ?+ inde$ if e "o ( five hundr$ m5 :om an au?or _h *os5 to record biographically %\ld h = 8 baptismal "n--,francis4 ,b if y f\nd t ?is 0 ! v reason = 8 admitt+ ! man into 8 s]ies1 t1 h[ev] /range a reason1 x _h 9 fact gov]n$ him 9 select+ 8 subjects1 y w\ld no long] see any?+ to />tle y\r belief4 ,b let me give an int]e/+ case p>tly illu/rat+ ?is pr9ciple4 ,once ,i 0 pres5t on an occasion :]e1 ( two "y m51 "o v "y & v clev] 0 sugge/+ infidel scruples1 & ! o!r1 s mu* old] z to be ent]+ on a pr(essional c>e] ) consid]able di/9ction1 0 on ! v po9t ( dr9k+-9 all t 8 companion urg$ z s mu* weighty objection t c\ld n be answ]$4 ,! y\ng] man 79 fact1 a boy7 _h j us$ a passage f ! ,bible1 9 :i* "o ( ! circum/ances 0--t ! ,jewi% army consi/$ ( #abj1jjj m54 ',n[1' said he1 'kn[+ z we all d ! enormity ( su* a =ce z a peace e/abli%m5t1 ev5 = mighty empires l ,engl&1 h[ p]fectly l a fairy-tale or an ,arabian ,nights' ent]ta9m5t does x s\nd to he> ( su* mon/r\s armam5ts 9 a little c\ntry l ,juda1 equal1 p]haps1 to ! twelve c\nties ( ,wales6' ,?is 0 address$ to myself1 & ,i c\ld see by ! :ole expression ( ! "y physician t 8 condition 0 exactly ?is--8 /udies _h be5 purely pr(essional2 he made himself a k+1 because 7hav+ happ5$ to hurt 8 leg7 he wore :ite fasci ab\t 8 ?igh4 ,he knew little or no?+ ( ,scriptural records2 he _h n read at all ^u ?is subject2 q z little _h he ?\ght1 &1 un=tunately1 8 conv]sation _h la9 among/ clev] *emi/s & naturali/s1 :o _h a prejudgm5t 9 ! case t all ! ability & free p[] ( m9d ran into ! *annel ( scepticism2 t only p situat$ z mo/ wom5 are %\ld acquiesce 9 ! fai? or politics ( _! fa!rs or pr$ecessors1 or c\ld believe mu* ( ! ,scriptures1 except ^? :o 7 sl[ to exam9e = !mselves2 b t multitudes pret5d$ to believe ^u "s int]e/$ motive4 ,?is 0 precisely ! situation ( ! "y physician himself--he li/5$ ) manife/ int]e/1 *eck$ himself :5 go+ to speak2 he knew ! dang] ( be+ reput$ an infidel1 & he _h no temp] = m>tyrdom1 z 8 :ole ge/ure & mann]1 by its t5d5cy1 %[$ :at 0 pass+ 9 8 m9d4 ',yes1 ,x is "r1 manife/ly "r1 & e rational view f our mod]n /&>d ( good s5se & reflective political economy t5ds to ! same conclusion4 ,by ! reflex light ( political economy we "k ev5 at ?is h\r mu* z to ! condition ( anci5t l&s l ,pale/9e1 ,a!ns1 etc41 q unreveal$ to ! wise/ m5 among/ !m4 ,b = me1 :o am ent]+ on a critical walk ( social life1 ,i %all ne$ e aid f advantage\s impression 9 fav\r ( my religi\s belief1 s ,i _c 9 prud5ce speak1 = ,i %all speak too w>mly1 & ,i =be>4' ,:at ,i repli$1 & 9 t in/ance usefully repli$--= x suffic$ to *eck "o :o 0 gravitat+ d[nw>ds to infidelity1 & likely to settle !re = ev] if he once rea*$ t po9t--0 9 sub/ance ?is3 ,fir/ly1 t ! plea1 ) reg>d to ! numb]s z mo/ extraord9>y1 0 s f> f affect+ ! cr$ibility ( ! /atem5t disadvantage\sly1 t on t gr\nd1 agreeably to ! logic ,i h s scantily exp\nd$1 ?is v feature 9 ! case 0 :at p>tly engag$ ! notice ( ! ,scriptural writ]4 ,x 0 a great army = s little a nation4 ,& !re=e1 w\ld ! writ] say1 !re=e 9 pr9t ,i record x4 ,secondly1 t we mu/ n1 h[ev]1 be misl$ by ! n>r[ limits1 ! ,wel% limits1 to suppose a ,wel% population4 ,= t :il/ ! twelve c\nties ( ,wales d n n[ yield above half-a-million ( p1 ,pale/9e _h pretty c]ta9ly a numb] fluctuat+ betwe5 f\r & six millions4 ,?irdly1 t ! great consid]ation ( ?is 0 ! /age 9 ! expansion ( society at :i* ! ,hebrew nation !n /ood1 & ! sublime int]e/--sublime en\gh to !m1 ?\gh f> f compreh5d+ ! solemn freight ( hopes confid$ to !mselves--:i* !y consci\sly def5d$4 ,x 0 an age 9 :i* no pay 0 giv5 to ! soldi]4 ,n[1 :5 ! soldi] con/itutes a sep>ate pr(ession1 ) ! regul> pay he und]takes ! regul> dang] & h>d%ips4 ,!re is no motive = giv+ ! pay & ! rations b precisely t he does s und]take4 ,b :5 no pay at all is all[$ out ( any common fund1 x w nev] be endur$ by ! ju/ice ( ! :ole society or by an individual memb] t he1 ! individual1 z "o insulat$ /ake-hold]1 hav+ no great] int]e/ emb>k$ ?an o!rs1 %\ld und]take ! dang] or ! lab\r ( w>f>e = ! :ole4 ,& two inf]5ces arise ^u hav+ armies s imm5se3 ,fir/1 t !y 7 a militia1 or m prop]ly n ev5 t1 b a ,l&wehr--t is1 a posse comitatus1 ! :ole m>tial /r5g? ( ! p 7"o 9 f\r71 drawn out & slightly tra9$ to meet a dang]1 :i* 9 ^? times 0 always a pass+ cl\d4 ,regul> & successive campaigns 7 unkn[n2 ! enemy1 :oev] he might be1 c\ld z little support a regul> army z ! p ( ,pale/9e4 ,consequ5tly1 all ^! enemies w\ld h to disp]se ha/ily to _! reap+ & m[+1 j z we may obs]ve ! ,jews d "u ,jo%ua4 ,x requir$1 !re=e1 no long abs5ce f home4 ,x 0 b a m>*1 b a wait+ = opportunity1 wat*+ = a fav\rable day--sun%9e or cl\d1 ! ris+ or subsid+ ( a riv]1 ! w9d 9 ! enemy's face1 or an ambu% skilfully po/$4 ,all 0 !n ready2 ! signal 0 giv51 a great battle ensu$1 & by sunset ( "o anxi\s day all 0 ov] 9 "o way or ano!r4 ,^u ?is position ( circum/ances !re 0 nei!r any fair disp5sation f p]sonal s]vice 7except :]e citiz5s' scruples int]f]$71 nor any motive = wi%+ x4 ,on ! contr>y1 by a v few days' s]vice1 a /igma1 n = ! individual only1 b = 8 h\se & k91 w\ld be evad$ = ages ( hav+ trea*]\sly =sak5 ! commonweal? 9 agony4 ,& ! pref]5ce = a fight+ /ation w\ld be too eag] in/ead ( too backw>d4 ,x w\ld become (t5 requisite to d :at x is evid5t ! ,jews 9 reality did--to make successive sift+ & w9n[+ f ! s]vice troops1 at e /age ?r[+ out ^u sev]] pr9ciples ( exam9ation ^? :o seem$ lea/ able to face a try+ crisis1 :il/ hon\rable po/s ( no great dep5d5cy w\ld be assign$ to ^? reject$1 z modes ( soo?+ _! (f5d$ pride4 ,?is 9 ! case ( a great dang]2 b 9 ! case ( an ord9>y dang] !re is no d\bt t _m vic>i\s arrangem5ts w\ld exi/ by way ( evad+ s injuri\s a movem5t z t ( ! :ole fight+ population4 ,ei!r ! ord9>y wat* & w>d1 9 t section :i* happ5$ to be locally ?reat5$--z1 = in/ance1 by invasion on "o side f ,edom or ,moab1 on ano!r side f ! ,canaanites or ,phili/9es--w\ld und]take ! case z "o :i* _h fall5 to !m by allotm5t ( ,provid5ce2 or t section ^: s]vice happ5$ to be due = ! mon?1 )\t local reg>ds1 w\ld face ! exig5cy4 ,b 9 any great national dang]1 "u t /age ( society :i* ! ,jews _h rea*$ betwe5 ,moses & ,david--t /age :5 fight+ is no sep>ate pr(essional duty1 t /age :5 su* ?+s are ann\nc$ by !re be+ no milit>y pay--n ! army :i* is s l>ge z #abj1jjj m51 b ! army :i* is s small1 requires to be expla9$4#h ,secondly1 ! o!r inf]5ce f ! ph5om5on ( no milit>y pay1 & !re=e no sep>ate fight+ pr(ession1 is ?is--t =eign w>1 w> ( aggression1 w> = booty1 w> = m>tial glory1 is q unkn[n4 ,n[1 all rules ( political economy1 appli$ to ! ma9t5ance ( armies1 mu/ ( c\rse contemplate a regul> trade ( w> pursu$ ) ^? objects1 & n a dome/ic w> = beat+ (f an attack ^u he>?s & alt>s4 ,su* a w> only1 be x obs]v$1 c\ld be lawfully ent]ta9$ by ! ,jewi% p4 ,mahomet1 :5 he /ole all 8 great ideas f ! ,mosaic & ,*ri/ian revelations1 f\nd x inevitable to add "o pr9ciple unkn[n to ei!r3 ?is 0 a religi\s motive = p]petual w> ( aggression1 & su* a pr9ciple he discov]$ 9 ! imag9>y duty ( summ>y proselytism4 ,no in/ruction 0 requir$4 ,x 0 suffici5t = ! conv]t t1 ) or )\t s9c]ity1 "u t]ror ( a sword at 8 ?roat1 he spoke ! words al\d :i* dis[n$ all o!r fai? ?an 9 ,allah & ,mahomet 8 prophet4 ,x 0 suffici5t = ! soldi] t he he>d ( a nation d5y+ or ignor+ ,mahomet1 to ju/ify any atrocity ( invasive w>f>e4 ,b ! ,jews _h no su* commission--a proselyte ne$$ m evid5ces ( ass5t ?an simply to bawl out a %ort =mula ( words1 & he :o refus$ to become a proselyte 0 no object ( p]secution4 ,"s nations h =c$ _! languages ^u o!rs z badges ( s]vitude4 ,b ! ,romans 7 s f> f treat+ _! language 9 ?is way1 t !y compell$ b>b>\s nations on _! fronti] to pay = a lic5se to use ! ,lat9 tongue4 ,& ) mu* m reason did ! ,jews1 in/ead ( wi%+ to obtrude _! sublime religion ^u =eign]s1 expect t all :o valu$ x %\ld manife/ _! value by com+ to ,j]usalem1 by seek+ in/ruction f ! doctors ( ! law1 & by wor%ipp+ 9 ! out] c\rt ( ! ,temple4 ,su* 0 ! prodigi\s /ate ( sep>ation f a ,mahometan pr9ciple ( fanatical proselytism 9 :i* ! ,jews 7 plac$ f ! v fir/4 ,"o small di/rict only 0 to be cle>$ ( its anci5t idolatr\s1 & probably desp]ately demoraliz$1 tribes4 ,ev5 ?is purification x 0 n int5d$ %\ld be in/ant2 & ^u ! foll[+ reason1 p>tly unveil$ by ,god & p>tly left to an integration1 viz41 t 9 ! case ( s sudd5 a desolation ! wild bea/s & noxi\s s]p5ts w\ld h encroa*$ too mu* on ! human population4 ,s mu* is express$1 & probably ! sequel =ese5 01 t ! ,jews w\ld h laps$ into a wild hunt+ race1 & h outworn t c]emonial prop5sity :i* fitt$ !m = a civil life1 :i* =m$ !m into a hive 9 :i* ! great "w ( ,god 9 ,%iloh1 ,8 probation>y ,temple or ,8 glori\s ,temple & s]vice at ,j]usalem1 op]at$ z ! my/]i\s in/9ct ( a que5 bee1 to compress & organize ! :ole society into a cohesion l ?is ( life4 ,"h1 p]haps1 lay ! reason = n all[+ ( any sudd5 summ>y extirpation1 ev5 = ! idolatr\s tribes2 :il/1 ^u a second pr9ciple1 x 0 nev] meant t ?is extirpation %\ld be complete4 ,sn>es & temptations 7 n to be too ?ickly s[n--9 t case ! re/less ,jew w\ld be too sev]ely tri$2 b nei!r 7 !y to be utt]ly )drawn--9 t case 8 fai? w\ld und]go no probation4 ,ev5 ^u ?is small dome/ic scale1 !re=e1 x appe>s t aggressive w>f>e 0 limit$ bo? = int]e/ & = "t4 ,fir/1 x 0 n to be too complete2 second1 ev5 = ?is incomplet5ess x 0 n to be conc5trat$ )9 a %ort "t4 ,x 0 bo? to be n>r[ & to be gradual4 ,by v necessity1 !re=e1 ( its orig9al appo9tm5t ?is "p ( ! national economy1 ?is small sy/em ( aggressive w>f>e1 c\ld n provide a reason = a milit>y pr(ession4 ,b all o!r w>s ( aggression1 w>s op]at+ ^u =eign objects1 _h no all[ance1 no motive1 no col\rable plea2 = ! attacks ^u ,edom1 ,midian1 ,moab1 7 m]e acts ( retaliation1 &1 /rictly speak+1 n aggressive at all1 b p>ts ( def5sive w>f>e4 ,consequ5tly !re rema9$ no p]man5t case ( w> "u ,div9e all[ance t c\ld ev] ju/ify ! e/abli%m5t ( a milit>y ca/e2 = ! civil w>s ( ! ,jews ei!r grew out ( "s "o intol]able crime tak5 up1 adopt$1 & wick$ly def5d$ by a :ole tribe 7z 9 ! case ( t horrible atrocity committ$ by a few ,b5jamites1 & !n adopt$ by ! :ole tribe71 9 :i* case a bloody ext]m9at+ w> "u ,god's sanction succe$$ & rapidly drew to a close1 or else grew out ( ! ru9\s s*ism betwe5 ! t5 tribes & ! two seat$ 9 or ab\t ,j]usalem4 ,& z ?is s*ism _h no c\nt5ance f ,god1 /ill less c\ld ! w>s :i* foll[$ x4 ,s t :at bellig]5t /ate rema9s t c\ld h be5 contemplat$ or provid$ = 9 ! orig9al ,mosaic !ory ( _! con/itution8 ,cle>ly none at all1 except ! "o sole case ( a =eign invasion4 ,b z ?is1 if 9 any national /r5g?1 /ruck at ! v exi/5ce ( ! p1 & at _! holy citadel 9 ,%iloh or 9 ,j]usalem1 x call$ out ! :ole milit>y /r5g? to ! la/ man ( ! ,hebrew p4 ,consequ5tly 9 any case1 :5 ! armies c\ld t5d at all to great num]ical am\nt1 !y mu/ t5d to an excessive am\nt4 ,&1 s f> f be+ a difficult problem to solve 9 ! #abj1jjj m51 ! true difficulty w\ld lie ! o!r way1 to acc\nt = its be+ s mu* r$uc$4 ,x seems to me highly probable t ! (f5ce ( ,david 9 numb]+ ! p1 :i* ultimately 0 ! occasion ( fix+ ! site = ! ,temple ( ,j]usalem1 po9t$ to ?is rem>kable milit>y position ( ! ,jewi% p--a position =bidd+ all fix$ milit>y in/itutions1 & :i* yet ,david 0 probably contemplat+ 9 t v c5sus4 ,simply to numb] ! p c\ld n h be5 a crime1 nor c\ld x be any desid]atum = ,david2 because we are too (t5 told ( ! mu/] rolls = ! :ole nation1 & = ea* p>ticul> tribe1 to feel any room = d\bt t ! reports on ?is po9t 7 con/antly correct$1 br\ght "u review ( ! gov]n+ eld]s1 c\ncils1 judges1 pr9ces1 or k+1 accord+ to ! hi/orical circum/ances1 s t ! ne$ & ! crim9ality ( su* a c5sus w\ld vani% at ! same mom5t4 ,b ?is 0 n ! c5sus ord]$ by ,david4 ,he want$ a m specific return1 probably ( ! p>ticul> weal? & nature ( ! employm5t pursu$ by ea* individual family1 s t ^u ?is return he might gr\nd a p]man5t milit>y organization = ! p2 & su* an organization w\ld h ?or\ghly revolutioniz$ ! "* ( ! population1 z well z drawn !m into =eign w>s & alliances4 ,x is pa9ful to ?9k t _m amiable & really c&id m9ds 9 se>* ( tru? are laid hold ( by "s plausible argum5t1 z 9 ?is case ! "y physician1 by a topic ( political economy1 :5 a local exam9ation ( ! argum5t w\ld altoge!r *ange its be>+4 ,?is argum5t1 popul>ly en=c$1 seem$ to imply ! impossibility ( support+ a l>ge =ce :5 !re 7 no public funds b su* z ran t[>ds ! support ( ! ,levites & ! maje/ic s]vice ( ! alt>4 ,b ! confusion arises f ! d\ble s5se ( ! ^w 'army1' z a ma*9e ord9>ily disposable = all =eign objects indiff]5tly1 & "o :i* 9 ,juda exclusively c\ld be appli$ only to su* a s]vice z mu/ 9 its own nature be sudd51 brief1 & always t5d+ to a decisive cata/rophe4 ,& t ?is 0 ! true =m ( ! crime1 n only circum/ances lead me to suspect1 b especially ! rem>kable demur ( ,joab1 :o 9 8 respectful remon/rance said 9 effect t1 :5 ! :ole /r5g? ( ! nation 0 kn[n 9 sum--mean+ f ! ord9>y /ate returns--:at ne$ 0 !re to se>* m inquisitively into ! special details8 ,:]e all 7 ready to fight *e]fully1 :y seek = sep>ate m9uti z to ea* p>ticul> class8 ,^? g5]al returns _h reg>d only to ! ord9>y causa belli--a ho/ile invasion4 ,&1 !n1 all nations alike1 rude or ref9$1 h gone ^u ! same g5]al outl9e ( computation--t1 subtract+ ! females f ! males1 ?is1 9 a gross g5]al way1 w\ld always bisect ! total return ( ! population4 ,&1 !n1 to make a second bisection ( ! male half w\ld subtract "o qu>t] f ! entire p z too "y or too old1 or o!rwise z too infirm = w>like lab\rs1 leav+ precisely "o qu>t] ( ! nation--e f\r? head--z available = w>4 ,?is process = ,david's case w\ld h yield$ p]haps ab\t #a1ajj1jjj fight+ m5 ?r\gh\t ,pale/9e4 ,b ?is unwieldy pospolite 0 f> f meet+ ,david's secret anxieties4 ,he _h rem>k$ ! fickle & insurrection>y /ate ( ! p4 ,ev5 aga9/ himself h[ easy _h x be5 f\nd to organize a sudd5 rebellion1 & to conceal x s prosp]\sly t he & 8 :ole c\rt sav$ !mselves f capture only by a few h\rs' />t ( ! enemy1 & ?r\gh ! enemy's want ( cavalry4 ,?is dang] meantime hav+ vani%$1 x might be possible t = ,david p]sonally no o!r great conspiracy %\ld di/urb 8 seat ^u ! ?rone4 ,none ( ,david's sons approa*$ to ,absalom 9 popul>ity2 & yet ! subsequ5t attempt ( ,adonijah %[$ t ! revolution>y temp] 0 /ill awake 9 t qu>t]4 ,b :at ,david fe>$1 9 a fur!r-look+ _s1 0 ! t5ure by :i* 8 imm$iate desc5dants w\ld ma9ta9 _! title4 ,! dang] 0 ?is3 ov] & above ! want ( any pr9ciple = regulat+ ! succession1 & ?is want op]at+ 9 a /ate ( ?+s f> less det]m9$ ?an among/ monogam\s nations--"o son plead+ 8 priority ( bir?2 ano!r1 p]haps1 8 "m's high] rank1 a ?ird plead+ 8 v juniority1 inasmu* z ?is br\ght him )9 ! description ( porphyrog5iture1 or royal bir?1 :i* is (t5 felt z transc5d5t z primog5iture--ev5 ! p1 ap>t f ! sev]al pret5d]s to ! ?rone1 w\ld create sep>ate int]e/s z gr\nds = insurrection or = inte/9e feuds4 ,!re seems good reason to ?9k t already ! t5 tribes1 ,israel z oppos$ to ,judah1 look$ ^u ! m fav\r$ & royal tribe ( ,judah1 ) _! supplem5t>y section ( ,b5jam91 z unduly fav\r$ 9 ! national economy4 ,secretly !re is little d\bt t !y murmur$ ev5 aga9/ ,god = rank+ ?is p[]ful tribe z ! pr]ogative tribe4 ,! jeal\sy _h evid5tly ris5 to a great height2 x 0 suppress$ by ! vigilant & /rong gov]nm5t ( ,solomon2 b at ! outset ( 8 son's reign x explod$ at once1 & ! ,scriptural acc\nt ( ! case %[s t x proce$$ ^u old grievances4 ,! boyi% ra%ness ( ,rehoboam might exasp]ate ! lead]s1 & precipitate ! issue2 b v cle>ly all _h be5 prep>$ = a revolt4 ,& ,i w\ld rem>k t by ! '"y m5' ( ,rehoboam are und\bt$ly meant ! soldi]s--! body-gu>ds :om ! ,jewi% k+s n[ reta9$ z an elem5t ( royal pomp4 ,?is is ! inv>iable use ( ! t]m 9 ! ,ea/4 ,ev5 9 ,josephus ! t]m = ! milit>y by pr(ession is g5]ally '! "y m5'2 :il/ '! eld]s' mean ! c\ncilors ( /ate4 ,david saw en\gh ( ! popul> _s to be satisfi$ t !re 0 no political reliance on ! p]man5ce ( ! dyna/y2 & ev5 at home !re 0 an int]nal s\rce ( weakness4 ,! tribe ( ,b5jam9 7 mortifi$ & inc5s$ at ! deposition ( ,saul's family & ! bloody proscription ( t family adopt$ by ,david4 ,"o only1 a gr&son ( ,saul1 he _h sp>$ out ( love to 8 fri5d ,jona?an4 ,?is 0 ,mephibo-%e?2 b he 0 incapacitat$ = ! ?rone by lam5ess4 ,& h[ deep ! res5tm5t 0 among/ ! ,b5jamites is evid5t f ! insult+ advantage tak5 ( 8 despond5cy 9 ! day ( di/ress by ,%imei4 ,= ,%imei _h no motive = ! act ( com+ to ! roadside & curs+ ! k+ beyond 8 atta*m5t to ! h\se ( ,saul4 ,humanly speak+1 ,david's prospect ( propagat+ 8 own dyna/y 0 b small4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ,god _h promis$ him ,8 support4 ,& h5ce x 0 t 8 crime arose1 viz41 ^u 8 infidelity1 9 seek+ to secure ! ?rone by a m]e human arrangem5t 9 ! fir/ place2 secondly1 by su* an arrangem5t z mu/ disorganize ! exi/+ !ocratic sy/em ( ! ,jewi% p4 ,^u ?is crime foll[$ 8 *a/isem5t 9 a sudd5 pe/il5ce4 ,& x is rem>kable 9 h[ significant a mann] ,god manife/$ ! nature ( ! trespass1 & ! p>ticul> c\rse ?r\gh :i* ,he _h meant orig9ally1 & did /ill mean1 to c\nt]act ! wor/ issue ( ,david's appreh5sions4 ,x happ5$ t ! angel ( ! pe/il5ce halt$ at ! ?re%+-floor ( ,araunah2 & precisely t spot did ,god by dreams to ,david indicate z ! site ( ! glori\s ,temple4 ,?us x seem$ z ?\gh 9 s _m words ,god _h decl>$3 ',n[ t all is ov]1 y\r crime & its puni%m5t1 und]/& t y\r fe>s 7 va94 ,i w cont9ue ! ?rone 9 y\r h\se long] ?an y\r anxieties c p]sonally pursue its desc5t4 ,& ) reg>d to ! t]rors f ,israel1 al?\gh ?is ev5t ( a great s*ism is inevitable & ess5tial to ,my c\ncils1 yet ,i w n all[ x to op]ate = ! ext9ction ( y\r h\se4 ,& t v ,temple1 9 t v place :]e ,my angel 0 commission$ to pause1 %all be "o great means & "o great pl$ge to y ( ,my decree 9 fav\r ( y\r po/]ity4 ,= ?is h\se1 z a common sanctu>y to all ,jewi% blood1 %all create a p]petual int]e/ 9 behalf ( ,judah among/ ! o!r tribes1 ev5 :5 mak+ w> ^u ,j]usalem4' ,witness if x 7 b t "o case :]e #bjj1jjj captives ( ,judah 7 re/or$ )\t ransom1 7 clo!d completely1 7 f$1 by ! v m5 :o _h j massacr$ _! fight+ relatives4 ,,footnotes3 #g ,ev5 9 ,rome1 :]e ! purple 7:atev] col\r t might h be57 is usually imag9$ to be ! symbol ( regal /ate--& aft]w>ds _! improv$ arts ( dye+1 & improv$ mat]ials1 became s spl5did t x 0 made s--:ite _h always be5 ! col\r ( a mon>*y4 ',a :ite l95 b& 0 ! simple badge ( ,ori5tal royalty' 7,m]ivale's ',hi/ory ( ,rome1' ii41 p4 #dfh74--;,,ed4 #h ,?is 0 ! case ev5 ) ! ,hom]ic ,greeks4 ,mr4 ,glad/one makes a po9t ( ?is 7see ',juv5tus ,mundi1' p4 #dbi73 ',! privates ( ! army are call$ by ! names ( laos1 ! p2 demos1 ! community2 & ple?us1 ! multitude4 ,b no notice is tak5 ?r\gh\t ! poem ( ! exploits ( any soldi] bel[ ! rank ( an (fic]4 ,/ill1 all att5d ! ,assemblies4 ,on ! :ole1 ! ,greek ho/ is n s mu* an army1 z a community 9 arms4' ,ev5 ! common p1 n only 9 cities b 9 camps1 assembl$ to he> ! delib]ations ( ! *iefs4--,,ed4 ,,vii4 ,,! ,,jews ,,z ,a ,,sep>ate ,,p4 ,! argum5t = ! sep>ation & di/9ct curr5t ( ! ,jews1 fl[+ z !y pret5d ( ! riv] ,rhone ?r\gh ! ,lake ( ,g5eva--nev] mix+ its wat]s ) ^? :i* surr\nd x--has be5 by "s infidel writ]s defeat$ & evad$ by "o ^w2 & "h1 z ev]y:]e else1 an unwise tea*] w seek to hide ! answ]4 ,yet h[ inf9itely bett] to /ate x fully1 & !n %[ t ! evasion has no =m at all2 b1 on ! contr>y1 p[]fully argues ! inconsi/5cy & incapacity ( ^? :o urge x4 ,= in/ance1 ,i rememb] ,b\lang]1 a ,fr5* infidel1 ^: "w 0 duly translat$ by a ,scot*man1 answ]s x ?us3 ,:at is !re miracul\s 9 all ?is8 he dem&s4 ,li/5 to me1 & ,i w %[ y 9 two m9utes t x re/s ^u m]e %[ & pure delusion4 ,h[ is x1 :y is x1 t ! ,jews h rema9$ a sep>ate p8 ,simply f _! usages1 9 ! fir/ place2 b1 secondly1 /ill m f ! fact t ^! usages1 :i* ) o!r peoples exi/ also 9 "s repres5tative %ape1 ) !m modify !mselves1 %ift1 alt]1 adapt !mselves to ! climate or to ! hum\r or accid5ts ( life among/ ^? amid/ :om *ance has ?r[n !m2 :]eas among/ ! ,jews e cu/om1 ! mo/ trivial1 is also "p ( _! legislation2 & _! legislation is also _! religion4 7,b\lang]1 by ! way1 is f> f express+ t objection s cle>ly z ,i h "h done2 b ?is is 8 drift & purpose1 s f> z he knew h[ to express x47 ,take any o!r p--,isaurians1 ,a!nians1 ,romans1 ,cor9?ians--d\btless all ^! & _m o!rs h transmitt$ _! blood d[n to our ages1 & are n[ liv+ among/ u by repres5tation4 ,b :y d we n p]ceive ?is8 ,:y d ! ,a!nians seem to h p]i%$ utt]ly8 ,simply = ?is reason3 !y 7 a pla/ic1 yield+1 unob/9ate race4 ,an ,a!nian liv$ 9 a port ( ,italy1 m>ri$ an ,italian woman2 !nce ?rew out l9es ( desc5t to ,milan1 !nce to ,p>is2 & because 8 ,attic usages 7 all local1 epi*orial1 & ti$ to a p>ticul> my?ology :i* has giv5 way1 or to a sup]/ition :i* is defunct1 or to a patriotic remembrance :i* has vani%$ ) ! l& & ! sympa?y t support$ x2 h5ce1 & ^u o!r simil> argum5ts1 ! ,a!nian has long s9ce melt$ into ! mass ) :i* he 0 int]mix$2 he 0 a unit atta*$ to a va/ ov]p[]+ numb] f ano!r s\rce1 & into t numb] he has long s9ce be5 absorb$2 he 0 a drop 9 a va/ ocean1 & long ago he has be5 conf\nd$ ) ! wat]s t did n diff]1 except num]ically1 f 8 own4 ,b ! ,jews are an ob/9ate1 bigot$ p2 & !y h ma9ta9$ _! sep>ation1 n by any ov]rul+ or co]c+ miracle1 b 9 a way p]fectly obvi\s & palpable to !mselves--obvi\s by its op]ation1 obvi\s 9 its rem$y4 ,!y w\ld n resign _! cu/oms4 ,^u ^! ord9ances1 positive & negative1 comm&+ & =bidd+ _m peculi> rites1 consecrat+ & desecrat+ _m common escul5t articles1 ^! ,jews h laid ! /ress & emphasis ( religion4 ,!y w\ld n resign !m2 !y did n expect o!rs to adopt !m--n 9 any case2 =tiori n f a degrad$ p4 ,& h5ce1 n by any my/]i\s op]ation ( ,provid5tial control1 arose _! sep>ation1 _! resolute refusal to bl5d ) o!r races4 ,?is is ! infidel's attempt to rebut1 to defeat1 utt]ly to conf\nd1 ! argum5tative =ce ( ?is mo/ a/oni%+ among/ all hi/orical pictures t ! planet pres5ts4 ,! foll[+ is ! answ]3 ,x is =gott5 t along ) ! ,jews !re is ano!r p conc]n$ z illu/rations ( ! same prophetic fatality--( t same inevitable eye1 t same p]spective ( vision1 :i* belong$ to ^? ^: eyes ,god _h op5$4 ,! ,arabs1 z *ildr5 ( a common ance/or1 ought n to be =gott5 9 ?is s5t5ce ^u _! bro!r nation4 ,!y ?r\gh ,i%mael1 ! ,jews ?r\gh ,isaac1 & m imm$iately ?r\gh ,israel ! son ( ,isaac1 7 two div]g+ bran*es ( "o orig9al /em2 & to bo? 0 pron\nc$ a correspond+ doom--a s5t5ce :i* argu$ 9 bo? a pr9ciple ( duration & self-propagation1 t is memorable 9 any race4 ,! *ildr5 ( ,i%mael are ! ,arabs ( ! des]t4 ,_! de/9y z a rov+ robb] nation1 & liable to all m5's h&s1 z !y indiff]5tly levi$ spoil on all1 0 e>ly pron\nc$4 ,& "h1 aga91 we see at once h[ x w be evad$3 x is ! des]t1 x is ! climate1 x is ! solemnity ( t un*ang+ basis1 :i* w secure ! un*ang+ life ( its *ildr54 ,b x is rem>kable en\gh t ,gibbon & o!r infidels1 kick+ viol5tly aga9/ ?is /&+ miracle 7because1 if n s 9 itself1 yet1 accord+ to ,bi%op ,butl]'s j explanation conc]n+ miracul\s p] de-rivationem z record+ a miracul\s p[] ( vision71 h by oscillation clung to ! fixture ( basis1 & reject$ x2 = n[ ,gibbon d5ies t ! ,arabs h held ?is con/ant t5or ( life2 !y h *ang$ x1 he ass]ts1 9 l>ge & notori\s cases4 ,well1 !n1 if !y h1 !n at once falls to ! gr\nd ?is alleg$ ov]rul+ co]cion a priori ( ! climate & ! des]t4 ,climate & des]t d n necess>ily co]ce !m1 if 9 l>ge & notori\s cases !y h fail$ to d s4 ,s feels ,gibbon2 &1 by an in/9ct ( timidity1 back he flies to ! previ\s evasion--to ! natural controll+ p[] ( climate & soil1 admitt+ ! ,scriptural fact1 b seek+ = x an unscriptural gr\nd1 z be=e he _h fl[n 9 ov]-precipitate anxiety to ! d5ial ( ! ,scriptural fact1 b 9 t d5ial involv+ a )drawal ( ! unscriptural gr\nd4 ,! sceptics 9 t in/ance %[ _! secret s5se ( a pref]5ce f ! di/ract$ eag]ness ) :i* !y fly backw>ds & =w>dwise betwe5 two reciprocally ho/ile evasions4 ,! answ] ,i res]ve1 & meantime ,i rem>k3 ,secondly1 t1 suppos+ ?is answ] to h any =ce1 /ill x meets only "o moiety ( ! ,scriptural fatality2 viz41 ! disp]sion ( ! ,jews--! fact t1 let !m be ga!r$ 9 :at numb]s !y might1 let !m ev5 be conc5trat$ by millions1 !re=e 9 ! lit]al s5se n disp]s$1 yet 9 ! political s5se univ]sally und]/ood1 !y w\ld be disp]s$1 because nev]1 9 no in/ance1 ris+ to be a p1 sui juris1 a nation1 a di/9ct community1 kn[n to ! public law ( ,europe z hav+ ! rights ( peace & w>1 b always a m]e accid5t & vagrant excess among/ nations1 n hav+ ! b>e rights ( citiz5%ip2 s f> f be+ a nation1 n be+ an ackn[l$g$ memb] ( any nation4 ,?is exquisite disp]sion--n e?nographic only1 b political--is t half ( ! ,scriptural mal$iction :i* ! ,b\lang] answ] attempts to meet2 b ! o!r half--t !y %\ld be 'a byword1 an a/oni%m5t1' etc4--is entirely bl9k$4 ,_h ! "w ev5 prosp]$1 x w\ld /ill h to recomm5ce4 ,! ,arm5ians are disp]s$ ?r\gh all ,ea/]n l&s1 s are ! ,arabs2 ev5 ! desc5dants ( ,ali are f\nd sev]$ f _! natal soil2 b !y are n !re=e disp]s$3 !y h endur$ no g5]al indignities4 ,?irdly1 x does n meet ! fact ( ! ,jewi% exi/5ce 9 any %ape1 :e!r z a di/9ct or an amalgamat$ p4 ,!re is no d\bt t _m races ( m51 z ( brute animals1 h be5 utt]ly ext+ui%$4 ,9 cases su* z ^? ( ! ,emim1 or ,re?9im1 a race di/+ui%$ by peculi> size1 s z to be mon/r\s 9 comp>ison ) o!r m51 ?is ext9ction c\ld m readily be realiz$2 or 9 ! case ( a nation m>k$1 z ,h]odotus records1 by a slight] texture ( scale1 ! ext9ction might be asc]ta9$ by ! physiologi/2 b no d\bt x has (t5 occurr$1 precisely z a family is ext+ui%$1 or z c]ta9 trees 7= example1 ! true gold5 pipp97 are obs]v$ to die (f1 n by local influ5ces only1 b by a decay attack+ ! v pr9ciple ( _! exi/5ce4 ,( _m anci5t races x is probable en\gh t no blood directly trac$ f !m c\ld at ?is day be se>*$ by ! eye ( ,god4 ,families arise among/ ! royal l9eage ( ,europe t sudd5ly1 l a lamp fitfully gl[+ up j ! mom5t be=e x expires1 ?r[ (f1 z by "s f9al ef=t1 a num]\s g5]ation ( pr9ces & pr9cesses2 !n sudd5ly all contract z rapidly into a s+le *ild1 :i* p]i%+1 ! family is absolutely ext9ct4 ,& s mu/ _m nations h p]i%$1 & s mu/ ! ,jews h be5 pre-em95tly expos$ to p]i%1 f ! peculi>1 fi]ce1 & almo/ immortal1 p]secutions :i* !y h und]gone1 & ! horrid fr5zies ( excit$ mobs 9 cruel cities ( :i* !y h /ood ! brunt4 ,,viii4 ',,:at ,,is ,,tru?8' ,,! ,,je/+ ,,pilate ,,said--,a ,,false ,,gloss4 ,x is true t ,pilate c\ld n be expect$ fully to compreh5d an idea :i* 0 yet new to man2 ,*ri/'s words 7 beyond 8 dep?4 ,b1 /ill1 8 natural light w\ld guide him ?us f>--t1 al?\gh he _h nev] he>d ( any tru? :i* rose to t di/9ction1 /ill1 if any "o class ( tru? %\ld 9 future come to eclipse all o!r classes ( tru? immeasurably1 z reg>d$ its practical results1 z reg>d$ "s d>k dep5d5cy ( human int]e/s1 9 t case x w\ld c]ta9ly m]it ! di/9ctive "n ( ',! ,tru?4' ,! case 9 :i* su* a di/9ction w\ld become reasonable & available 0 "o utt]ly unrealiz$ to 8 exp]i5ce1 n ev5 )9 ! light ( 8 conjectures z to its special conditions2 b1 /ill1 z a g5]al possibility x 0 conceivable to 8 und]/&+2 ?\gh n compreh5sible1 yet appreh5sible4 ,& 9 go+ on to ! next great "q1 to ! inevitable "q1 ',:at is ! tru?8' ,pilate _h no ?\ght ( je/+4 ,je/+ 0 ! la/ ?+ ( :i* 8 impassion$ mood 9 t great h\r 0 capable4 ,roman magi/rates ( supreme rank 7 little dispos$ to je/+ on ! judgm5t-seat among/ a refractory & dang]\s p2 & ( ,pilate 9 p>ticul>1 e ^w1 e ef=t1 e act1 demon/rate t he 0 agitat$ ) new in/9cts & misgiv+s ( "s %ad[y revelation op5+ ^u man1 t 8 he>t 0 convuls$ ) despond+ anxiety 9 ! fir/ place to save ! man :o appe>$ ! deposit>y ( ?is revelation1 b :o1 if1 aft] all1 only a sublime lunatic1 01 at ! v lea/1 innoc5t ( all (f5ce4 ,x mu/ h /ruck all close obs]v]s ( e>ly ,*ri/ianity h[ l>ge a proportion ( ! new conv]ts lay among/ ,roman (fic]s1 or 7to speak m adequately7 among/ ,romans ( high rank1 bo? m5 & wom54 ,& = t !re 0 high reason4 ,9 ! advance ( civilization1 & 9 ! correspond+ decay ( idolatr\s religions1 !re 0 fa/ aris+ a new gr[? ( crav+s among/ m54 ,my?ological & desp]ately immoral religions1 t spoke only to ! bl9d s5se ( p[]1 _h be5 giv+ way ?r\gh ! ?ree previ\s c5turies to a fe>ful ext5t4 ,!y _h rec$$ f ! high] natures ( bo? ,greece & ,rome z ! sea has locally rec$$ f _m %ores ( ! e>?4 ,su* natures 7 left 'mis]ably b>e'2 ! s5se ( dep5d5cy by any tie ^u ! invisible _w1 or at lea/ ^u ! sup]natural _w1 _h decay$1 & unless ?is pa9ful void 7 fill$ up by "s supplem5t>y bond 9 ! same direction1 a condition ( practical a!ism mu/ take place1 su* z c\ld n b />ve & impov]i% 9 human nature ^? ye>n+s aft] ! inf9ite :i* are ! pl$ges ( all int]nal gr&eur4 ,b ?is dep5d5cy c\ld n be replac$ by "o ( ! same vici\s nature4 ,into any new dep5d5cy a new elem5t mu/ be introduc$4 ,! s5se ( insuffici5cy w\ld be r5ew$ 9 triple /r5g? if m]ely ! old relations ( weakness to p[]1 ( art to great] art1 ( intellect to high] intellect1 ( less to m )9 ! same exact limits z to k9d ( excell5ce1 %\ld be rehe>s$ "u new names or improv$ !ogonies4 ,hi!rto1 no relation ( man to div9e or demoniac p[]s _h includ$ ! lea/ p>ticle or fraction or h9t ( any moral elem5t2 nor 0 su* an elem5t possible 9 t dep5d5cy1 = pr(\nd reasons4 ,,ix4 ,,:at ,,scalig] ,,says ,,ab\t ,,! ,,epi/le ,,to ,,jude4 ,be=e any canon 0 settl$1 _m works _h become curr5t 9 ,*ri/ian circles ^: orig9 0 dubi\s4 ,! traditions ab\t !m v>i$ locally4 ,"s1 x is alleg$1 t w\ld really h be5 entitl$ to a canonical place1 _h be5 lo/ by accid5t2 to "s1 :i* /ill surviv$1 ?is place _h be5 refus$ ^u gr\nds t might n h satisfi$ u ( ?is day1 if we _h ! books & ! gr\nds ( rejection be=e u2 &1 f9ally1 o!rs1 x is urg$1 h obta9$ ?is sacr$ di/9ction ) no "r to x4 ,9 p>ticul>1 ! ,second ,epi/le ( ,/4 ,pet]1 ! ,second ( ,/4 ,jude1 ! ,epi/le ( ,/4 ,james1 & ! ?ree ( ,/4 ,john1 are d5\nc$ z supposititi\s 9 ! ',scalig]ana4' ,b ! writ] be=e u is wrong 9 lay+ any /ress on ! op9ions !re express$4 ,!y be> ! m>ks ( conv]sational ha/e & ( ,scalig]an audacity4 ,:at is ! objection made1 = in/ance1 to '9 quibus sunt mira1 qu non vid5tur esse ,apo/olica'8 ,t is itself m /range z a criticism ?an any?+ 9 ! epi/les c be = its doctr9e4 ,! only ?+ t5d+ to a reason = ! summ>y treatm5t is t ! ,ea/]n ,*ur* does n ackn[l$ge !m = canonical4 ,b op9ions quot$ f ana are seldom ( any au?ority2 inde$1 ,i h myself too frequ5tly se5 ! unfai?fulness ( su* reports4 ,! report]1 z he _c dec5tly be tak+ notes at ! "t ( speak+1 endeav\rs aft]w>ds to recall ! mo/ int]e/+ passages by memory4 ,he =gets ! context2 :at introduc$--:at foll[$ to expla9 or modify ! op9ions4 ,he supplies a conjectural context ( 8 own1 & ! result is a romance4 ,b if ! report] 7 ev5 accurate1 s mu* all[ance mu/ be made = ! lic5se ( conv]sation--its ard\r1 its hurry1 & its frequ5t playfulness--t :5 all ^! d$uctions are made1 really n a fraction rema9s t "o c hone/ly c>ry to acc\nt4 ,besides1 ! eld] ,scalig] 0 drunk pretty (t51 & ,joe seems r 'fre%' at times4 ,^u consid]ation1 x may be z well to repeat :at x is t ,scalig] is report$ to h said3 ',! ,epi/le ( ,jude is n 81 z nei!r is t ( ,james1 nor ! second ( ,pet]1 9 all :i* are /range ?+s t seem 7seem--m>k t67 f> en\gh f be+ ,apo/olical4 ,! ?ree ,epi/les ( ,john are n f ,john ! ,apo/le4 ,! second ( ,pet] & ,jude belong to a lat] age4 ,! ,ea/]n ,*ur* does n own !m1 nei!r are !y ( evangelical au?ority4 ,!y are unle>n$1 & (f] no m>ks ( ,gospel maje/y4 ,z reg>ds _! int]nal value1 believe !m ,i may say t ,i d1 b x is because !y are 9 no ways ho/ile to u4' ,n[1 obs]ve1 ! gr\nds ( objection are purely /hetical1 except 9 ! s+le argum5t f ! au?ority ( ! ,ea/]n ,*ur*4 ,:at does he mean by 'unle>n$1' or want+ 'maje/y1' or conta9+ '/range ?+s'8 ,7 ev] su* vague pu]ilities collect$ into "o %ort p>agraph8 ,?is is pure imp]t95ce1 & ,phil4 des]ves to be privately reprim&$ = quot+ su* w9dy *aff )\t not+ & prote/+ x z colloquial4 ,b :at ,i wi% ! read] to m>k--! ,greek3 ?o hepimhy?ion--is1 t suppose ! two ,scalig]s among/ ! ,*ri/ian ,fa!rs engag$ 9 fix+ ! canon3 great] le>n+ y _c h2 nei!r 0 !re1 to a dead c]ta9ty1 "o t5? "p z mu* among/ ! canon-settl]s4 ,yet all ?is m>vell\s le>n+ fumes away 9 boyi% imp]t95ce4 ,x conf\nds itself4 ,& e ,*ri/ian says1 ,oh1 take away ?is sup]flu\s weight ( erudition1 t1 be+ s r>e a ?+1 _c be want$ 9 ! broad highways ( religion4 ,:at we d want is humility1 docility1 rev]5ce = ,god1 & love = man4 ,^! are s[n broadca/ among/ human he>ts4 ,n[1 ^! apply !mselves to ! s5se ( ,scripture1 n to its grammatical niceties4 ,b if s1 ev5 t case %[s indirectly h[ little c\ld dep5d ^u ! m]e v]bal attire ( ! ,bible1 :5 ! *ief ma/]s ( v]bal sci5ce 7 s ready to g a/ray--rid+ on ! bill[s s imp]fectly moor$4 ,9 ! ideas ( ,scripture lies its et]nal an*orage1 n 9 its p]i%able words1 :i* are %ift+ = ev] l quicks&s1 z ! ,bible passes by translation successively into e spok5 language ( ! e>?4 ,:at !n8--',:at !n8' retorts ! angry read] aft] all ?is1 ':y !n1 p]haps1 !re may be a screw loose 9 ! ,bible4' ,true1 !re may1 & :at is m1 "s v great s*ol>s take ^u !m to ass]t t !re is4 ,yet1 /ill1 :at !n8 ,! two possible errors op5 to ! ,fa!rs ( our canon1 to ! m5 ^u :om re/$ ! weighty task ( say+ to all mank9d :at %\ld be ,bible1 & :at %\ld be n ,bible1 ( mak+ & limit+ t mighty _w1 are--t !y may h done t :i* !y ought n to h done1 &1 secondly1 left undone t :i* !y ought to h done4 ,!y may h admitt$ writ]s :om !y ought to h exclud$2 & !y may h exclud$ writ]s :om !y ought to h admitt$4 ,?is is ! ext5t ( _! possible (f5ces1 & !y are suppos$ by "s critics to h committ$ bo?4 ,b suppose t !y h1 /ill ,i say--:at !n8 ,:at is ! nature ( ! wrong done to u by ! wor/ mi/ake ascrib$ to !m8 ,let u consid]4 ,x is suppos$ by "s s*ol>s t we h 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t z x n[ /&s a "w writt5 by ,apollos1 viz41 ! ,epi/le to ! ,romans4 ,yet1 if s1 ! error am\nts only to a misnom]4 ,on ! o!r h&1 !re are ,epi/les on :i* has be5 *>g$ ! same error 9 relation to ! "n ( ! au?or1 & ! m important error ( ?\ghts unbecom+ to a ,*ri/ian 9 au?ority3 = in/ance1 ! ,epi/le ( ,/4 ,james4 ,?is *>ge 0 *iefly urg$ by a v intemp]ate man1 & 9 a v intemp]ate /yle4 ,i notice x z be+ a case :i* ,phil4 has notic$4 ,b ,phil4 m]its a g5tle rap on 8 knuckles = ! inconsid]ation ) :i* he has cit$ a *>ge made & report$ ) s mu* levity4 ,he quotes x f ! ',scalig]ana4' ,n[1 :at "r ^u su* a subject has any man to quote su* an au?ority8 ,! reasons aga9/ li/5+ ) mu* att5tion to ! ',scalig]ana' are ^!3 ,fir/1 ! ,scalig]s1 bo? fa!r & son1 7 ! two mo/ impud5t m5 t ev] walk$ ! planet4 ,i %\ld be loa? to say s ill-natur$ a ?+ z t _! impud5ce 0 equal to _! le>n+1 because t =ces e man to say1 ',ah1 !n1 :at impud5t fell[s !y mu/ h be56' ,x is k9d] & ju/] to say t _! le>n+ 0 at lea/ equal to _! impud5ce1 = t w =ce e man to exclaim1 ',ah1 if s1 :at prodigies ( le>n+ !y mu/ h be56' ,yes1 !y 7--absolute mon/]s ( le>n+1 le>n$ mon/]s4 ,b z mu* le>n+ (t5 makes m5 mad1 /ill m frequ5tly x makes !m furi\s = assault & batt]y2 to use ! ,am]ican phrase1 !y gr[ 'wolfy ab\t ! %\ld]s1' f a p]iodical it*9ess = fight+4 ,o!r m5 be+ %y ( attack+ ! ,scalig]s1 x 0 no fault ( !irs1 y "k1 b a necessity1 to attack o!r m5--unless y expect$ !m to h no fight+ at all4 ,x 0 always a reason ) !m = try+ a fall ) a writ]1 if !y d\bt$ mu* :e!r !y _h any excuse = hang+ a qu>rel on4 ,secondly1 all ana :atev] are bad au?orities4 ,suppos+ ! ?+ really said1 we are to rememb] ! huge privilege ( conv]sation1 h[ immeasurable is t6 ,y y\rself1 read]1 ,i presume1 :5 talk+1 w say m 9 an h\r ?an y w /& to 9 a mon?4 ,i'm sure ,i d4 ,:5 ! re9s are put into my h&s ,i /ick at no?+--headlong ,i drive l a lunatic1 until ! v room 9 :i* we are talk+1 ) all t x inh]its1 seems to sp9 r\nd ) absolute v]tigo at ! extravagances ,i utt]4 ,?irdly1 b aga91 0 ! ?+ really said8 ,=1 z ano!r c5sure ^u ! :ole libr>y ( ana1 ,i c ass]t--t1 if ! lic5se ( conv]sation is enorm\s1 to t p :o inhale t gas ( colloquial f]m5tation seldom mean mu* above "o "p 9 sixty ( :at !y say1 on ! o!r h& ! lic5se ( report]s is f> great]4 ,to =get ! circum/ances "u :i* a ?+ 0 said is to alt] ! ?+1 to h lo/ ! context1 ! p>ticul> rem>k 9 :i* y\r own orig9at$1 ! mitigations ( a h>% s5tim5t f playfulness ( mann]2 9 %ort1 to drop ! sett+ ( ! ?\ghts is (t5times to falsify ! t5d5cy & value ( ^? ?\ghts4 ,,note ,,by ,,! ,,editor4--,! ,phil4 "h ref]r$ to is ! ,philoleu!ros ,anglicanus ( ! essay on ',prote/antism1' z %ort5$ by ,de ,qu9cey1 & ) :om ,de ,qu9cey1 9 t essay1 deals v effectively & wittily on occasion4 ,x4 ,,murd] ,,z ,a ,,f9e ,,art4 7,,"s ,,notes ,,= ,a ,,new ,,pap]47 ,a new pap] on ,murd] z a ,f9e ,art might op5 ?us3 t on ! model ( ^? ,g5tlem5 ,radicals :o _h vot$ a monum5t to ,palm]1 etc41 x 0 propos$ to erect /atues to su* murd]]s z %\ld by _! next-(-k91 or o!r p]son int]e/$ 9 _! glory1 make out a claim ei!r ( sup]ior atrocity1 or1 9 equal atrocity1 ( sup]ior neatness1 cont9uity ( execution1 p]fect prep>ation or felicit\s orig9ality1 smoo?ness or curiosa felicitas 7elaborate felicity74 ,! m5 :o murd]$ ! cat1 z we read 9 ! ,newgate ,cal5d>1 7 good1 b ,williams bett] :o murd]$ ! baby4 ,& p]haps 7b ! helli% felicity ( ! la/ act makes u demur7 ,field+ 0 sup]ior4 ,= y nev] he> ( a fire swall[+ up a fire1 or a ra9 /opp+ a deluge 7= ?is w\ld be a reign ( ,kilk5ny cats72 b :at fire1 deluge1 or ,kilk5ny cats c\ld n d1 ,field+ propos$1 viz41 to murd] ! murd]]s1 to become himself ! ,nemesis4 ,field+ 0 ! murd]] ( murd]]s 9 a d\ble s5se--rhetorical & lit]al4 ,b t 01 aft] all1 a small matt] comp>$ ) ! f9e art ( ! man call+ himself ,outis1 on :i* = a mom5t we mu/ dwell4 ,outis--s at all ev5ts he 0 call$1 b d\btless he indulg$ 9 _m aliases--at ,nott+ham jo9$ vehem5tly & s9c]ely1 z x seem$1 9 pursuit ( a wret* tax$ ) hav+ murd]$1 twelve ye>s previ\sly1 a wife & two *ildr5 at ,halifax1 :i* wret* 7:5 all ! depositions 7 be=e ! magi/rate7 turn$ out to be ! a=esaid ,mr4 ,outis4 ,t sugge/s a wide field ( speculation & ref]5ce4#i ,note ! p[] ( murd]]s z f9e-art pr(essors to make a new />t1 to turn ! corn]1 to retreat ^u ! road !y h come1 z ?\gh x 7 new to !m1 & to make div]sions t dis>m suspicion4 ,?is !y owe to =tunate obscurity1 :i* atte/s anew ! wond]ful comp5sations ( life2 = celebrity & p[] comb9e to produce drawbacks4 ,a =eign] :o l&s 9 ,calcutta at an h\r :i* nobody c "n1 & endeav\rs to effect a sneak+ entrance at ! po/]n-gate#aj ( ! gov]nor-g5]al's palace1 may be a dec5t man2 b ?is we "k1 t he has cut ! t[+-rope :i* b\nd 8 own boat to ! great ark ( 8 c\ntry4 ,x may be t1 9 leav+ ,p>is or ,naples1 he 0 simply cutt+ ! connection ) cr$itors :o %[$ signs ( atta*m5t n good = 8 heal?4 ,b x may also be t he ran away by ! blaze ( a burn+ inn1 :i* he _h fir$ 9 ord] to hide ?ree ?roats :i* he _h cut1 & n9e purses :i* he _h /ol54 ,!re is no gu>antee = su* a man's "*4 ,h we1 !n1 no su* vauri5s at home8 ,no1 n 9 ! classes /&+ fav\rably = promotion4 ,! privilege ( safe crim9ality1 n liable to exposure1 is limit$ to classes cr[d$ toge!r l leaves 9 ,vallombrosa2 = !m to run away into "s mighty city1 ,man*e/] or ,glasg[1 is to comm5ce life anew4 ,!y turn ov] a new leaf ) a v5geance4 ,_m are ! c>p5t]s1 bricklay]s1 bak]s' appr5tices1 etc41 :o are n[ liv+ dec5tly 9 ,bri/ol1 ,newca/le1 ,hull1 ,liv]pool1 aft] m>ry+ sixte5 wives1 & leav+ families to ! c>e ( twelve sep>ate p>i%es4 ,t scamp is at ?is mom5t circulat+ & gyrat+ 9 society1 l a respectable te-totum1 ?\gh we "k n 8 exact "n1 :o1 if he 7 pleas$ to reveal himself 9 sev5te5 p>ts ( ?is k+dom1 :]e 7to use ! police language7 he has be5 'want$' = "s ye>s1 w\ld be hang$ sev5te5 times runn+1 besides putt+ sev5te5 ,gov]nm5t rew>ds into ! pockets ( sev5te5 policem54 ,oh1 read]1 y little "k ! unutt]able romances p]petrat$ = ev] 9 our mo/ popul\s empire1 "u cl\d ( night & di/ance & utt] pov]ty1 ,m>k t--( utt] pov]ty4 ,weal? is p[]2 b x is a je/ 9 comp>ison ( pov]ty4 ,spl5d\r is p[]2 b x is a joke to obscurity4 ,to be poor1 to be obscure1 to be a bak]'s appr5tice or a tailor's j\rneyman1 ?r[s a p[] ab\t a man1 clo!s him ) attributes ( ubiquity1 really ) ^? privileges ( concealm5t :i* 9 ! r+ ( ,gyges 7 b fabul\s4 ,is x a k+1 is x a sultan1 t su* a man rivals8 ,oh1 fri5d1 he rivals a spiritual p[]4 ,two m5 are on record1 p]haps _m m might h be5 on t record1 :o wrote s _m books1 & p]petrat$ s _m pamphlets1 t at fifty !y _h =gott5 mu* ( _! own lit]>y villa9ies1 & at sixty !y comm5c$ ) murd]\s f]ocity a s]ies ( answ]s to argum5ts :i* x 0 prov$ ^u !m aft]w>ds t !y !mselves _h emitt$ at ?irty--?us com+ r\nd ) volleys ( small %ot on _! own heads1 z ! ,:isp]+ ,gall]y at ,/4 ,paul's beg9s to retaliate any secrets y h committ$ to its keep+ 9 e*o+ ?und]s aft] a "t1 or z ,sir ,john ,m&eville "u ,arctic skies he>d 9 ,may all ^? curses ?aw+1 & explod+ l m9ute-guns1 :i* _h be5 froz5 up 9 ,novemb]4 ,ev5 l ^? self-reply+ au?ors1 ev5 l ^? self-rev]b]ators 9 ,/4 ,paul's1 ev5 l ^? ,arctic practition]s 9 curs+1 :o drew bills & po/ obits 9 mal$iction1 :i* 7 to be hon\r$ aft] ! dea? ( w9t]1 _m m5 are liv+ at ?is mom5t 9 m]ry ,engl& :o h figur$ 9 s _m *>act]s1 illu/rat$ s _m villages1 run away f s _m t[ns1 & p]=m$ ! c5tral "p 9 s _m c>e]s1 t 7 ! "*1 ! village1 ! t[n1 ! c>e]1 br\ght back ) all its circum/ances to _! memories1 positively !y w\ld fail to recognise _! own pres5ce or inc>nation 9 _! own acts & bodies4 ,we h all read ! /ory told by ,addison ( a sultan1 :o 0 p]suad$ by a d]vi% to dip 8 head into a bas9 ( en*ant$ wat]1 & !reupon f\nd himself ^u "s o!r globe1 a son 9 a poor man's family1 m>ri$ aft] c]ta9 ye>s ! woman ( 8 he>t1 _h a family ( sev5 *ildr5 :om he pa9fully br\ght up1 w5t aft]w>ds ?r\gh _m p]secutions1 walk$ p5sively by ! sea%ore m$itat+ "s escape f 8 mis]ies1 ba!d 9 ! sea z a relief f ! noon-day heat1 & on lift+ up 8 head f ! waves f\nd himself lift+ up 8 head f ! bas9 into :i* t curs$ d]vi% _h p]suad$ him to dip4 ,& :5 he w\ld h cudgell$ ! holy man = t long life ( mis]y :i* _h1 ?r\gh 8 means1 be5 inflict$ ^u himself1 behold6 ! holy man prov$ by affidavit t1 9 ?is _w1 at any rate 7:]e only he c\ld be puni%able71 ! life _h la/$ b ?irty-?ree seconds4 ,ev5 s d ! d>k c>e]s ( _m among/ our obscure & migratory villa9s f ye>s %r9k up to mom5t>y specks1 or1 by _! v multitude1 altoge!r evanesce4 ,burke & ,h>e1 x is well kn[n1 _h lo/ all c\nt ( _! sev]al murd]s2 !y no m rememb]$1 or c\ld attempt to rememb]1 _! sep>ate victims1 ?an a respectable old bank] ( sev5ty-?ree c rememb] all ! bills ) _! indorsem5ts made payable = half-a-c5tury at 8 bank2 or ?an ,foote's turnpike-keep]1 :o _h kept all ! toll-b> tickets to ,k5s+ton = =ty-eight ye>s1 pret5d$ to recollect ! features ( all ! m5 :o _h deliv]$ !m at 8 gate4 ,= a "t1 p]haps1 ,burke 7:o 0 a man ( f9e s5sibility7 _h a repres5tative vision ( spasms1 & /ruggles1 & convulsions1 t]m9at+ 9 a t5-p\nd note indors$ by ,dr4 ----4 ,h>e1 on ! o!r h&1 0 a man ( pr9ciple1 a man t y c\ld dep5d ^u--ord] a corpse = ,friday1 & on ,friday y _h x--b he _h no feel+ :atev]4 ,yet see ! unity ( result = him & ,burke4 ,= bo? alike all tr\blesome recollections ga!r$ into "o blue haze ( heav5ly ab/ractions3 ord]s execut$ ) fidelity1 *eques on ! bank]s to be cross$ & pass$ & ca%$1 are no m rememb]$4 ,t is ! acme ( p]fection 9 our art4 99 99 99 99 99 ,"o great class ( crim9als ,i am aw>e ( 9 pa/ times z hav+ specially torm5t$ myself--! class :o h left secrets1 riddles1 beh9d !m4 ,:at bus9ess has any man to bequea? a conundrum to all po/]ity1 unless he leaves 9 "s sep>ate *annel ! solution8 ,?is mu/ h be5 done 9 malice1 & = ! purpose ( annoy+ u1 le/ we %\ld h too mu* prop] enjoym5t ( life :5 he %\ld h gone4 ,= nobody kn[s :e!r ! sc\ndrel c\ld h solv$ x himself--too l 9 t respect to "s *>ades :i*1 9 my boyi% days 7b !n ,i _h ! excuse ( y\?1 :i* !y _h n71 ,i n unfrequ5tly prop\nd$ to "y ladies4 ,take ?is z a specim53 ,my fir/ raises a little hope2 my second v little inde$2 & my :ole is a va/ ro> ( despair4 ,no "y lady c\ld ev] solve x2 nei!r c\ld ,i4 ,we all _h to give x up4 ,a *>ade t only ne$s an answ]1 :i*1 p]haps1 "s di/ant g5]ation may supply1 is b a half & half1 t5tative approa* to ?is4 ,v mu* ( ?is nature 0 ! g5ius or ,daimon 7don't say ,demon7 ( ,socrates4 ,h[ _m ?\s&s ( le>n$ writ]s & pr9t]s h gone to sleep ov] too pr(\nd attempts to solve t1 :i* ,socrates ought to h be5 able to solve at sight4 ,i am myself ( op9ion t x 0 a dram-bottle1 :i* someone rais$ a gho/ to expla94 ,!n ! ,entele*eia ( ,ari/otle2 did y ev] read ab\t t1 excell5t read]8 ,mo/ p fancy x to h meant "s unutt]able crot*et 9 metaphysics1 "s horrible idea 7le/ ! police %\ld be aft] x7 )\t a "n2 t is1 until ! ,/agyrite repair$ ! inju/ice ( 8 conduct by giv+ x a pretty long "o4 ,my op9ion n[1 z y are anxi\s to "k x1 is1 t x 0 a lady1 a swee!>t ( ,ari/otle's2 = :at 0 to h9d] ,ari/otle hav+ a swee!>t8 ,i d>e say ,?omas ,aqu9as1 dry & arid z he 01 rais$ 8 unpr9cipl$ eyes to "s ,neapolitan beauty1 began a sonnet to "s lady's eyebr[1 ?\gh he might =get to f9i% x4 ,& my belief is t ?is lady1 ambiti\s z ,semele1 wi%$ to be introduc$ z an et]nal jewel into ! great vault ( h] lov]'s immortal ,philosophy1 :i* 0 to travel mu* f>!r & agitate f> long] ?an 8 royal pupil's conque/s4 ,^u t ,ari/otle1 keep+ h] h&1 said3 ',my love1 ,i'll ?9k ( x4' ,& !n x occurr$ to him1 t 9 ! v heav5s _m lovely ladies1 ,&rom$a1 ,cassiopeia1 ,ariadne1 etc41 _h be5 plac$ z con/ellations 9 t map :i* _m *ronologi/s suppose to h be5 prep>$ = ! use ( ! %ip ,argo1 a :ole g5]ation be=e ! ,trojan w>4 ,b]5ice1 ?\gh he c\ld n be aw>e ( t1 _h int]e/ ev5 to procure a place 9 t map = h] r+lets2 & ( c\rse = h]self %e might h4 ,consid]+ :i*1 ,ari/otle said3 ',hang me6 if ,i don't put h] among ! t5 ,categories6' ,on aft] ?\ghts he put h] high]1 = an ,entele*eia is z mu* above a ,category z our ,padi%ah ,victoria is above a ,turki% sultan4 ',b n[1 ,/ag1' said ! lady 7privileg$ z a swee!>t %e call$ him ,/ag1 ?\gh ev]ybody else 0 oblig$ to call him ,/agyrite71 'h[ w !y "k x's meant = me1 ,/ag8' ,^u :i* ,i am sorry to say ! philosoph] fell to curs+ & swe>+1 be/[+ bless+s on 8 own optics & on po/]ity's1 mean+ y\rs & m9e1 say+3 ',let !m f9d x out4' ,well1 n[1 y see ,i h f\nd x out4 ,b t is m ?an ,i hope = my crypto-crim9als1 & !re=e ,i take ?is my only way ( giv+ !m celebration & mal$iction 9 "o brea?4 ,,footnotes3 #i ,not)/&+ :at he _h writt5 9 ! essay on ! ',ess5es1' no d\bt ,de ,qu9cey1 if he _h complet$ ?is pap]1 c\ld n h escap$ *>act]i/ic1 & p]haps grimly humor\s1 ref]5ces ( 8 own to ! ,sic>ii1 ( :om ,josephus has a good deal to tell 9 8 ',jewi% ,w>'2 = x seems to u 8 ?\ghts 7 be>+ directly t way4 ,josephus says ( ! ,sic>ii3 ',9 ^! days !re arose ano!r sort ( robb]s 9 ,j]usalem1 :o 7 nam$ ,sic>ii1 :o slew m5 9 ! day-"t & 9 ! middle ( ! city1 m especially at ! fe/ivals4 ,!re !y mix$ ) ! multitude1 & hav+ conceal$ little dagg]s "u _! g>m5ts1 ) ^! !y /abb$ ^? t 7 _! enemies2 & :5 any fell d[n dead1 ! murd]]s jo9$ ! by/&]s 9 express+ _! indignation2 s t f _! plausibilities !y c\ld by no means be discov]$4 ,! fir/ man t 0 sla9 by !m 0 ,jona?an ! high-prie/1 aft] :i* _m 7 sla9 e day4'--,,ed4 #aj ',po/]n-gate4' ,see ! leg5d ( ,sir ,eu/ace ! ,crusad]1 & ! good ,sir ,hub]t1 :o 's\nd$ ! horn :i* he alone c\ld s\nd1' z told by ,wordswor?4 ,,xi4 ,,anecdotes--,,juv5al4 ,all anecdotes1 z ,i h (t5 rem>k$ 9 pr9t1 are lies4 ,x is pa9ful to use h>% words1 &1 kn[+ by my own feel+s h[ mu* ! read] is %ock$ by ?is rude ^w lies1 ,i %\ld really be mu* gratifi$ if x 7 possible to supplant x by "s g5tl] or m c\rte\s ^w1 su* z falsehoods1 or ev5 fibs1 :i* dilutes ! atrocity ( untru? into some?+ ( an amiable weakness1 wrong1 b /ill v5ial1 & natural 7& s f>1 !re=e1 reasonable74 ,any?+ = peace3 b really 9 ?is in/ance ,i _c indulge ! read]4 ,! in/9cts ( morality w n all[ ( x1 & /ill less ! passion :i* made ,juv5al a poet1#aa viz41 ! passion ( enorm\s & bloody indignation4 ,f ! beg9n+ ( ?is c5tury1 ) wra? cont9ually gr[+1 ,i h laid x d[n z a rule1 & if ! la/ ye> ( x1 viz41 ,a4 ,d4 #aijj1 %\ld ov]he> my voice among/ ! babbl+s t w !n be tr\bl+ ! atmosph]e--9 t case x w he> me /ill reaffirm+1 ) an indignation /ill ga!r+ /r5g?1 & !re=e approa*+ ev] ne>] & ne>] to a ,juv5alian p[] ( v]sification1 s t p]haps ,i %all !n speak 9 rhym$ c\plets--t all anecdotes pret5d+ to be sm>t1 b to a dead c]ta9ty if !y pret5d to be epigrammatic1 are & mu/ be lies4 ,!re is1 9 fact1 no security = ! tru? ( an anecdote1 no gu>antee :atev]1 except its int5se /upidity4 ,if a man is se>*$ at a police-(fice1 on ! gr\nd t he 0 caught try+ ! w9d[-%utt]s ( silv]smi?s2 !n1 if x %\ld happ5 t 9 8 pockets is f\nd absolutely no?+ at all except "o solit>y pav+-/one1 9 t case ,*>ity1 :i* believe? all ?+s 79 fact1 is cr$ul\s to an anile degree71 w be dispos$ to lock up ! pav+-/one1 & re/ore x to ! man on 8 lib]ation z if x 7 really 8 own1 ?\gh philosophy mutt]s indignantly1 be+ all b c]ta9 t ! fell[ /ole x4 ,& really ,i h be5 too c&id a great deal 9 admitt+ t a man may appropriate an anecdote1 & e/abli% 8 claim to x by plead+ its awful /upidity4 ,t might be ! case1 & ,i believe x 01 :5 anecdotes 7 _m & writ]s 7 few4 ,b ?+s are *ang$ n[4 ,fifty ye>s ago1 if a man 7 se5 runn+ away ) ! pace ( a lunatic1 & y %\ld s+ out1 ',/op t fell[2 he is runn+ (f ) ! %9-bone ( my great-gr&mo!r6' all ! p 9 ! /reet w\ld h cri$ out 9 reply1 ',oh1 nons5se6 ,:at %\ld he want ) y\r great-gr&mo!r's %9-bone8' & t w\ld h seem$ reasonable4 ,b n[1 to see h[ ?+s are alt]$1 any man ( s5se w\ld reply1 ',:at %\ld he want ) my great-gr&mo!r's %9-bone8 ,:y1 he'll gr9d x1 & !n he'll mix x ) guano4' ,?is is :at he & ! l ( him h actually done by %iploads ( p f> m entitl$ to consid]ation ?an any "o ( my f\r great-gr&mo!rs 7= ,i _h f\r1 ) eight %9-bones among/ !m74 ,x is well kn[n t ! field ( ,wat]loo 0 made to r5d] up all its bones1 ,briti% or ,fr5*1 to c]ta9 bone-mills 9 agricultural di/ricts4 ,borod9o & ,leipzig1 ! two bloodie/ ( mod]n battlefields1 are suppos$ betwe5 !m--:at by ! h>ve/ ( battle1 :at by ! h>ve/ ( neighb\r+ hospitals--to be seiz$ or possess$ ( f\r hundr$ ?\s& %9-bones1 & o!r int]e/+ specim5s to mat*4 ,negotiations h be5 proce$+ at v>i\s times betwe5 ! lead+ bone-mills 9 ,engl& & ! ,jews 9 ,dresd5 or 9 ,mosc[4 ,hi!rto ^! negotiations h brok5 d[n1 because ! ,jews /ood out = #cg p] %5t41 calculat$ ^u ! co/s ( exhumation4 ,b ( late !y %[ a disposition to d bus9ess at #cc p] %5t43 ! contract w !re=e move =w>ds aga92 x w g ahead2 & ! du/ ( ! fai?ful armies1 toge!r ) ! du/ ( _! enemies1 w v soon be f\nd1 n 9 ! /opp] ( a bunghole 7z ,pr9ce ,hamlet conceiv$ too prematurely71 b 9 an unprec$5t$ crop ( ,sw$i% turnips4 ,bones *ange _! value1 x seems ?us cle>ly2 & anecdotes *ange _! value2 & 9 t proportion hone/y1 z reg>ds "o or ! o!r1 *anges ! value ( its *ances4 ,b :at has all ?is to d ) ',old ,nick'8 ,/op3 let me consid]4 ,t title 0 plac$ at ! head ( ?is article1 & ,i admit t x 0 plac$ !re by myself4 ,else1 :il/ ,i 0 w&]+ f my text1 & va9ly endeav\r+ to recollect :at x 0 t ,i _h meant by ?is text1 a r&om ?\ght came ov] me 7immoral1 b natural71 t ,i w\ld *>ge ! head+ ( ,old ,nick ^u ! compositor1 ass]t+ t he _h plac$ x !re 9 ob/9ate defiance ( all ! ord]s to ! contr>y1 & supplications to ! contr>y1 t ,i _h address$ to him = a mon?2 by :i* means ,i %\ld ?r[ ^u him ! responsibility ( acc\nt+ = s port5t\s an ensign4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,editor',s ,,note4--,x is evid5t t ,de ,qu9cey m$itat$ a mu* long] essay on anecdotes z false1 9 :i* ,niccolo ,ma*iavelli w\ld h come 9 = notice--h5ce ! playful ref]5ces 9 ! close4 ,,footnotes3 #aa ',! passion :i* made ,juv5al a poet4' ,! s*ol> ne$s no explanation2 b ! read] ^: s*ol>%ip is yet among/ 8 futurities 7:i* ,i conceive to be ! civile/ way ( describ+ an ignoramus7 mu/ und]/& t ,juv5al1 ! ,roman satiri/1 :o 0 9 fact a pr$e/9$ poet 9 virtue ( 8 ebulli5t he>t1 t boil$ ov] once or twice a day 9 ang] t c\ld n be express$ ^u witness+ ! enormities ( dome/ic life 9 ,rome1 0 will+ to =ego all pret5sions to natural p[] & inspiration = ! sake ( obta9+ su* influ5ce z w\ld enable him to reprove ,roman vices ) effect4 ,,xii4 ,,anna ,,l\isa4 ,,specim5 ,,translation ,,f ,,voss ,,9 ,,hexamet]s1 ,,) ,,lett] ,,to ,,pr(essor ,w4 7',,*ri/oph] ,,nor?'74 ,,dr4 ,,nor?1 ,doctor1 ,i say1 = ,i he> t ! six ,univ]sities ( ,engl& & ,scotl& h s5t y a doctor's degree1 or1 if !y h n1 all ! _w kn[s !y ought to h done2 & ! m %ame = !m if !y keep no ',remembranc]' to put !m 9 m9d ( :at !y mu/ all[ to be among/ _! mo/ sacr$ duties4 ,b t's all "o4 ,i once read 9 my *ildhood a pretty book1 call$ ',wilson's ,acc\nt ( ! ,pelew ,isl&s1' at :i* isl&s1 y "k1 ,h4,m4,s4 ,antelope 0 wreck$--j ab\t ! "t1 ,i fancy1 :5 y1 ,doctor1 & myself 7 9 long petticoats & mak+ "s noise 9 ! _w2 ! book 0 n writt5 by ,capta9 ,wilson1 b by ,keates1 ! s5tim5tali/4 ,at ! v end1 h[ev]1 is an epitaph1 & t 0 writt5 by ! capta9 & %ip's company3 ',/op1 read]1 /op1 let nature claim a te>2 ,a pr9ce ( m9e1 ,lee ,boo1 lies buri$ "h4' ,?is epitaph us$ (t5 to make me cry1 & 9 commemoration ( t effect1 :i* 7l t ( all ca?>tics t ,i "k (1 no matt] h[ dra/ic at fir/7 has long be5 gr[+ weak] & weak]1 ,i propose 7^u y\r all[+ me an opportunity7 to sup]scribe y 9 any *ur*y>d y w appo9t3 ',/op1 read]1 /op1 let g5ius claim a te>2 ,a doct'r ( m9e1 ,lee ,kit1 lies buri$ "h4' ',doct'r (' y are to read into a dissyllable1 & pretty mu* l ,boney's old fri5d on ! road f ,mosc[1 ,g5]al ,doct'r(f1 :o 'doctor'd !m (f1' z ! ,laureate obs]ves1 & prescrib$ = ! :ole ,fr5* army gratis4 ,b n[ to bus9ess4 ,= y\r in=mation1 ,doctor1 x _c be necess>y1 b on acc\nt ( v _m read]s x w be s1 to say t ,voss's ',luise' has long tak5 its place 9 ! lit]ature ( ,g]many z a classical "w--9 fact1 z a gem or cab9et *ef d'oeuvre2 nay1 almo/ z _! unique specim5 9 any national s5se ( ! light] & less pret5d+ muse2 less pret5d+1 ,i mean1 z to ! pomp or gravity ( ! subject1 b on t v acc\nt m pret5d+ z respects ! m9ut] graces ( its execution4 ,9 ! comp>ative e/imate ( ,g]mans1 ! ',luise' holds a /ation correspond+ to t ( our ',rape ( ! ,lock1' or ( ,gresset's ',v]t-v]t'--correspond+1 t is1 9 its degree ( relative value4 ,z to its k9d ( value1 "s notion may be =m$ ( x ev5 9 t respect also f ! ',rape ( ! ,lock1' b ) ?is diff]5ce1 t ! sc5es & situations & descriptions are !re d]iv$ f ! daily life & habits ( a fa%ionable belle & ! f9e g5tlem5 :o surr\nd h]1 :]eas 9 ! ',luise' !y are d]iv$ exclusively f ! homeli] & m patri>*al economy ( a rural cl]gyman's h\sehold2 & 9 ?is respect ! ',luise' comes ne>e/ by mu*1 9 comp>ison ( any o!r "w t ,i "k (1 to our own ',vic> ( ,wakefield4' ,l t delightful portrait ( rural life 9 a p>ticul> aspect1 or idyll z x might be call$1 ! ',luise' aims at ?r[+ op5 = our amusem5t ! int]ior ( a village p>sonage 7,scotice1 'manse'72 l t 9 its e>li] half 7= ! latt] half ( ! ',vic>' is a sad collapse f ! tru? & nature ( ! orig9al conception into ! m>vell\s ( a commonplace novel71 ! ',luise' exhibits ! sev]al memb]s ( a ru/ic cl]gyman's family accord+ to _! diff]5ces ( sex1 age1 & /&+1 9 _! natural1 undisguis$ features1 all unconsci\sly m>k$ by *>act]i/ic foibles1 all engag$ 9 ! ex]cise ( _! daily habits1 nei!r f9] nor co>s] ?an circum/ances naturally all[1 & all indulg+ 9 su* natural hopes or fictions ( romance z gr[ out ( _! situation 9 life4 ,! ',luise1' 9 %ort1 & ! ',vic> ( ,wakefield' are bo? alike a succession ( circum/antial del9eations select$ f m]e ru/ic life1 b ru/ic life 9 its mo/ pure & intellectual =m2 = z to ! noble c\ntess 9 ! ',luise1' or ! squire & 8 uncle1 ,sir ,william1 9 ! ',vic> ( ,wakefield1' !y d n int]f]e suffici5tly to di/urb ! ess5tial level ( ! movem5t z reg>ds ! incid5ts1 or to col\r ! mann]s & ! sc5]y4 ,agree+1 h[ev]1 9 ?is g5]al purpose1 ! two works diff] 9 two consid]able features2 "o1 t ! ',vic> ( ,wakefield' describes ! rural cl]gyman ( ,engl&1 ',luise' ! rural cl]gyman ( ,nor? ,g]many2 ! o!r1 t ! ,engli% idyll is writt5 9 prose1 ! ,g]man 9 v]se--bo? ( :i* diff]5ces1 & ! sep>ate peculi>ities gr[+ out ( !m1 w1 x may p]haps be ?\ght1 require a few words ( critical discussion4 ,!re has always exi/$ a "q z to ! true pr9ciples ( translation :5 appli$1 n to ! m]e lit]ature ( k 7because !re x is impossible t two op9ions c arise1 by h[ mu* clos] ! v]sion by s mu* ! bett]71 b to ! lit]ature ( p[]1 & to su* works--above all1 to poems--z might fairly be consid]$ works ( art 9 ! highe/ s5se4 ,to :at ext5t ! pr9ciple ( comp5sation might reasonably be c>ri$1 ! lic5se1 t is1 ( dep>t+ f ! /rict lit]al =ms ( ! orig9al writ]1 :e!r z to expressions1 images1 or ev5 z to ! second>y ?\ghts1 = ! sake ( reproduc+ !m 9 "s %ape less repell5t to a mod]n e>1 & !re=e virtually su/a9+ ! h>mony ( ! composition by prev5t+ ! att5tion f settl+ 9 a disproportionate degree ^u :at might h a />tl+ effect to a ta/e tra9$ "u mod]n discipl9e--?is "q has always be5 p5d+ z a "q op5 to revision be=e ! mod]n c\rts ( criticism2 z surely to y1 ,dr4 ,nor?1 "o ( ! *ief 'swells' on t b5*1 ,i ne$ n say4 ,b1 = ! sake ( accurate ?9k+1 x is wor? :ile obs]v+ t =m]ly ?is "q 0 mov$ almo/ exclusively ) a view to ! ,lat9 & ,greek classics2 & t circum/ance gave a great & a v j bias to ! :ole dispute4 ,= ! diff]5ce ) reg>d to any capital au?or ( anci5t days1 z comp>$ ) mod]n au?ors1 is ?is1 t "h we h a tw(old int]e/--an int]e/ ) "w1 & a sep>ate int]e/ 9 ! writ]4 ,take ! ',prome!us ,desmotes' ( s*ylus1 & suppose t a translator %\ld (f] u an ,engli% ',prome!us1' :i* he ackn[l$g$ to be v free1 b at ! same "t cont5d$ t 8 v>iations f ! ,greek 7 s _m d[nright improvem5ts1 s t1 if he _h n giv5 u ! g5u9e ',prome!us1' he _h giv5 u some?+ bett]4 ,9 su* a case we %\ld all reply1 b we d n want some?+ bett]4 ,our object is n ! be/ possible drama t c\ld be produc$ on ! fable ( ',prome!us'2 :at we want is ! v ',prome!us' t 0 writt5 by s*ylus1 ! v drama t 0 repres5t$ at ,a!ns4 ,! ,a!nian audi5ce itself1 & :at pleas$ its ta/e1 is already "o subject ( int]e/4 s*ylus on 8 own acc\nt is ano!r4 ,^! are collat]al & ali5 subjects ( int]e/ q indep5d5t ( our int]e/ 9 ! drama1 & = ! sake ( ^! we wi% to see ! real orig9al ',prome!us'--n accord+ to any man's notion ( improvem5t1 b su* z came f a sublime ,grecian poet1 su* z satisfi$ a ,grecian audi5ce1 m ?an two ?\s& ye>s ago4 ,we wi%1 9 fact1 = ! real s*ylus1 'unh\sel'd1 unaneal'd1' ) all 8 imp]fections on 8 head4 ,su* 0 ! way1 & ! j way1 ( argu+ ! po9t :5 ! application 0 limit$ to a great au!ntic classic ( ! ,antique2 nor 0 ! case at all diff]5t :]e ,ario/o or any o!r illu/ri\s ,italian classic 0 conc]n$4 ,b a new sort ( casui/ry 9 ?is "q has aris5 9 our own times1 & by accid5t *iefly 9 connection ) ,g]man lit]ature2 b x may well be1 ,dr4 ,nor?1 t y w be m div]t$ by a c>eful scrut9y ( my metres aft] ,voss 9 illu/ration1 ?an by any fur!r diss]tation on my "p on a subject t y "k s well4 ,believe me1 ,always y\rs admir+ly1 ,x4 ,y4 ,z4 ,! ,p>son's ,d9n]4 ,9 ! mon? ( leafy ,june1 b5ea? cele/ial azure ,( skies all cl\dless1 sate ! ag$ ,rector ( ,e/hwaite ,d9+ amid/ 8 h\sehold2 b n ! m]idian ard\r ,( sunbeams fi]ce he felt2 him ! %ady v]&a ,) v9e-clad trellis def5ds3 beyond a p5dul\s awn+ ,( b\ghs self-wrea?'d f limes 7^: mighty limbs ov]>*+ ,spann$ ! l[ ro( ( ! h\se7 spreads f> effectual umbrage ,= "y & old alike2 noontide awfully brea?less ,settl$ 9 deepe/ sil5ce on ! woods & valley ( ,e/hwaite4 ,yet n ! less !re w\ld rise1 aft] /ille/ int]val (t51 #aj ,l[ :isp]+ gales t /ole1 l sobb+ murmur ( infant ,dream+ 9 arms mat]nal1 into ! he>t o' ! y\nge/3 ,gales t at mo/ c\ld raise a s+le r+let ( auburn ,z x p5cill'd ! noble br[ ( ! y\?ful ,anna ,l\isa-- ,sole *ild t surviv$ to !e1 oh1 ag$ pa/or ( ,e/hwaite4 ,clad 9 8 morn+ g[n1 ! rev]5d prie/ at a table ,( sculptur'd /one 0 seat$2 & 8 seat 0 a massy b easy ,settle ( oak1 :i* 9 y\? 8 anci5t s]vitor1 ,isaac1 ,footman1 sexton1 & /ew>d1 butl] & g>d5] also1 ,c>v$ by ! w9t] fire 9 nights ( gloomy ,novemb]1 ,& ?r\gh _m a long1 long night ( _m a d>k ,decemb]4 #ba ,! good man's he>t 0 glad1 & 8 eyes 7 suffus'd ) a rapture ,( p]fect love z !y settl$ on h]--t pulse ( 8 he>t's blood1 ,! "o sole prop ( 8 h\se1 ! beautiful ,anna ,l\isa4 ,by ! side ( himself sate 8 wife1 t anci5t tam] ( h\semaids1#ab ,yet k9d ( he>t z a dove1 & ) matron graces adorn+ ,h] place z %e sate disp5s+ hospitality b\ndless ,to ! /rang]s )9 h] gates2 =1 lo6 two /rang]s on "o side ,sate ( ! long /one table2 yet /rang]s by mann] or action ,"o w\ld n suppose !m2 nor 7 !y1 b gue/s ev] hon\r'd1 #cj ,& de> to ea* he>t 9 ! h\se ( ?' anci5t ,rector ( ,e/hwaite4 ,! eld] ( !m 0 call$ ,augu/us ,h>ry ,delancey1 ,& he rode z a cornet ( horse 9 ! mighty imp]ial army4 ,him _h ! p>5ts approv$ 7& ^? 7 melodi\s acc5ts1 ,! sweete/ he ev] _h he>d7 z suitor ( ,anna ,l\isa4 ,b f lips m ruby f>--f> m melodi\s acc5ts ,_h rea*'d 8 e>s s9ce !n2 = %e1 ! daught]1 h] own self1 ,_h condesc5d$ at la/ to utt] sweet ratification ,( all 8 hopes2 l[ :isp'r+ ! 'yes'--cele/ial answ] ,t rais$ him to p>adise gates on p9ion#ac ( expectation4 #dj ,ov] aga9/ 8 belov$ he sate--! suitor enam\r'd3 ,& ,god ,he kn[s t inde$ %\ld x prove an idolatr\s error ,to look 9 ! eyes ( a lady till y feel a dreamy devotion1 ,i fe> = ! heal? ( y\r s\l t day1 oh1 ,h>ry ,delancey6 ,next to ,delancey !re sate 8 pupil1 ,magnus ,adolphus1 ,a fair-hair$ boy ( t51 half an orphan1 a c\nt ( ! empire-- ,magnus ,adolphus ( ,arn/e91 t great ,bav>ian e>ldom4 ,him _h 8 wid[$ "m1 ! noble ,c\ntess ( ,arn/e91 ,plac$ ) ,delancey betimes1 z "o 9 knightly requirem5ts ,skilful & all-accompli%$1 t he ! 'y\?ful idea'#ad #ej ,might 'tea* h[ to %oot' 7) a pi/ol1 videlicet71--horses ,to m\nt & to manage ) boldness1 h\nds to foll[ 9 hunt+ ,! fox1 ! tusky bo>1 ! /ag ) 8 beautiful antl]s3 ,arts1 :e!r graceful or useful1 9 arms or eque/rian usage1 ,did ,augu/us imp>t to 8 pupil1 ! y\?ful e>l ( ! empire4 ,to ride ) /irrups or none1 to m\nt f ! ne>-side or (f-side 7,:i* /ill is requir$ 9 ! troop] :o rides 9 ! ,au/rian army71 ,to ride ) bridle or none1 on a saddle ,turki% or ,engli%1 ,to =ce y\r horse to curvet1 pir\ette1 dance on 8 haun*es1 ,& :il/ danc+ to la% ) 8 feet1 & sugge/ an effectual h9t+ #fj ,to ! enemy's musquete]s to cle> ! road = ! h9t]3 ,or aga91 if y want a guide by night1 9 a dang]\s highway ,beset ) ! enemies' m>ksm5 & sw>m+ ) murd]\s ambu%1 ,to tra9 y\r horse 9 ! art ( delicate ins9uation1 ,g5tly rais+ a ho( to tap at ! door o' ! woodsman4 ,b1 if he p]si/s 9 snor+1 or pret5d+ to snore1 or is angry ,at y\r summons to leave 8 lair 9 ! arms ( 8 wife or 8 infants1 ,to practise y\r horse 9 ! duty ( /ormy recalcitration1 ,:eel+ r\nd to pres5t 8 heels1 & 9 mid c>acol+ ,to s5d ! emp]or's greet+ smack ?r\gh ! panel ( oakwood#ae #gj ,t makes ! poor man s h>d ( he>+ imp]ial ord]s4 ,arts su* z ^! & o!rs1 ! use ( ! sabre on horseback1 ,all modes ( skill gymna/ic1 modes :e!r =ceful or artful1 ,( dea?-grapple if by *ance a cannon-%ot %\ld un-horse y1 ,all modes ( us+ ! limbs ) address1 ) spe$1 or enorm\s ,ef=t ( brutal /r5g?1 all ?is did ,h>ry ,delancey ,tea* to 8 docile pupil3 & arts m nobly delightful1 ,arts ( ! head or ! he>t1 arts intellectual2 empire ,ov] dead m5's books1 ov] regions ( high m$itation1 ,comp>ative tactics1 w>f>e z !n conduct$ 9 ages ,:5 p[d] 0 none1 nor cannon1 b brute catapult1 #ha ,bl9d rams1 bra9less wild asses1 ! /ony sl+] ( huge /ones4#af ,iron 0 "l ( ! _w2 iron reign$1 man 0 8 eng9e2 ,b n[ ! rule is rev]s$1 man b9ds & insults ov] iron4 ,toge!r did !y1 "y tutor1 "y pupil1 ,augu/us1 ,adolphus1 ,range ov] hi/ory m>tial1 or read /rategical au?ors1 ,x5ophon1 ,arrian1 old ,polybius1 old ,polynus 7,?9k n ^! ,polys1 my boy1 7 bloom+ ,pollies ( our days671 ,& above all o!rs1 !y read ! laurel'd h]o ( h]oes1 ,?rice k+ly ,roman ,julius1 sun-bright lead] ( armies1 ,:o plant$ 8 god-l foot on ! necks ( a :ole g5]ation4 #ia ,su* /udies1 su* arts 7 ^? by :i* "y ,h>ry ,delancey ,s\ght to dis*>ge ! tru/ :i* to him ! ,lady ( ,arn/e9 ,confid$ ) hopes mat]nal2 ?us tra9$1 he hop$ t ,adolphus ,w\ld %9e 9 8 native l&1 = high 0 8 place 9 ! empire4 ,,editor',s ,,note4--,?is 01 ( c\rse1 writt5 = ,blackwood's ,magaz9e2 b x nev] appe>$ !re4 ,,footnotes3 #ab ',t tam] ( h\semaids'3 ,greek3 ,hektoros ippodamoio--( ,hector1 ! tam] ( horses 7',iliad'74 #ac ',on p9ion ( expectation4' ,"h ,i w\ld reque/ ! read] to notice t x w\ld h be5 easy = me to pres]ve ! regul> dactylic close by writ+ 'p9ion ( anticipation2' z also 9 ! =m] in/ance ( '_m a d>k ,decemb]' to h writt5 '_m a ra9y ,decemb]4' ,b 9 bo? cases ,i pref]r$ to lock up by ! massy spondaic v>iety2 yet nev] =gett+ to premise a danc+ dactyle--'_m a'--& 'p9ion (4' ,n m]ely = v>iety1 b = a sep>ate effect ( peculi> maje/y4 #ad ,allud+ to a ridicul\s passage 9 ,?omson's ',seasons'3 ',delightful task6 to tea* ! "y idea h[ to %oot4' #ae ,all ^! arts1 viz41 tea*+ ! horse to fight ) 8 =elegs or la% out ) 8 h9d-legs at v>i\s angles 9 a g5]al mele ( horse & foot1 b especially tea*+ him ! secret ( 'invit+' an ob/9ate ,g]man boor to come out & take ! air /rapp$ 9 front ( a troop]1 & d 8 duty z guide to ! imp]ial cavalry1 7 import$ into ! ,au/rian s]vice by an ,engli% rid+-ma/] ab\t ! ye> #agge-hj4 ,& no d\bt x mu/ h be5 horses tra9$ on ?is le>n$ sy/em ( education f :i* ! ,highl&]s ( ,scotl& d]iv$ _! t]ror ( cavalry4 #af ',bl9d rams1 bra9less wild asses1' etc4 ,! 'arietes1' or batt]+-rams ) iron-b\nd =eheads1 ! 'onagri1' or wild asses1 etc41 7 among/ ! poliorcetic eng9es ( ! anci5ts1 :i* d n appe> to h receiv$ any ess5tial improvem5t aft] ! "t ( ! brilliant ,pr9ce ,demetrius1 ! son ( ,alex&]'s great capta91 ,antigonus4 ,,xiii4 ,,"s ,,?\ghts ,,on ,,biography4 ,we h he>d f a man :o witness$ ! failure ( ,miss ,baillie's ',de ,mont=d1' not)/&+ ! sc5ic advantages ( a va/ ,london !atre1 f9e dresses1 f9e music at int]vals1 &1 above all1 ! sup]b act+ ( ,john ,kemble1 support$ on t occasion by 8 incomp>able si/]1 t ?is unexpect$ disappo9tm5t began ) ! gall]y1 :o c\ld n compreh5d or ent] into a hatr$ s fi5di% gr[+ out ( causes s slight z any by possibility supposable 9 ! trivial ,rez5velt4 ,to feel teas$ by su* a man1 to dislike him1 occasionally to pres5t him ) y\r complim5ts 9 ! %ape ( a duodecimo kick--well & good1 no?+ b "r4 ,& ! plot manife/ly t5d$ to a comic issue4 ,b murd]6--a ,macbe? murd]6--n ! injury s mu* z ! man himself 0 incomm5surate1 0 too slight by a ?\s& degrees = s appall+ a cata/rophe4 ,x reacts ^u ,de ,mont=d1 mak+ him ignoble t c\ld be mov$ s pr(\ndly by an ag5cy s contemptible4 ,some?+ ( ! same disproportion !re is1 ?\gh 9 a diff]5t way1 betwe5 any qu>rel t may h divid$ u f a man 9 8 life-"t & ! savage rev5ge ( pursu+ ! qu>rel aft] 8 dea? ?r\gh a malici\s biography4 ,yet1 if y hat$ him ?r\gh no qu>rel1 b simply 7z we all hate _m m5 t di$ a ?\s& ye>s ago7 = some?+ vici\s1 or :i* y ?9k vici\s1 9 8 modes ( ?9k+1 :y mu/ y1 ( all m51 be ! "o to und]take an edition ( 8 works1 ') a life ( ! au?or'8 ,leave t to "s neutral writ]1 :o nei!r loves nor hates4 ,& :il/ cr[ds ( m5 ne$ bett] biographical records :om x is easy to love & n difficult to hon\r1 d n y degrade y\r own he>t or disgu/ y\r read]s by select+ = y\r exemplification n a model to be imitat$1 b a wild bea/ to be bait$ or a crim9al to be tortur$8 ,we privately hate ,mr4 ,?omas ,hobbes1 ( ,malmsbury2 we "k mu* evil ( him1 & we c\ld expose _m ( 8 tricks effectually4 ,we also hate ,dean ,swift1 & ^u :at we ?9k sub/antial argum5ts4 ,"s ( our own contempor>ies we hate p>ticul>ly2 ,cobbett1 = in/ance1 & o!r bad fell[s 9 fu/ian & corduroys4 ,b = t v reason we w n write _! lives4 ,or1 if we %\ld d s1 only because !y might happ5 to /& z individuals 9 a s]ies1 & aft] w>n+ ! read] ( our own bias4 ,= x is too odi\s a spectacle to imprison a fell[-creature 9 a book1 l a /ag 9 a c>t1 & turn him out to be hunt$ ?r\gh all 8 d\bles = a day's amusem5t4 ,x too mu* resembles t case ( und\bt$ occurr5ce bo? 9 ,france & ,g]many1 :]e 'respectable' individuals1 simply z amateurs1 & n at all ) any view to ! sal>y or fees ( op]at+1 h come =w>d z c&idates = ! po/ ( public execution]4 ,:at is e man's duty is no man's duty by pref]5ce4 ,& unless :]e a writ] is ?ru/ ^u su* a duty by an (ficial necessity 7z1 if he contracts = a ',biographia ,britannica1' 9 t case he is b\nd by 8 contract to g ?r\gh ) ! :ole s]ies--rogues & all71 x is too pa9ful to see a human be+ c\rt+ & woo+ ! task ( do+ execution ^u 8 bro!r 9 8 grave4 ,nay1 ev5 9 ! case :]e ?is execution]'s task arises spontane\sly out ( "s duty previ\sly und]tak5 )\t a ?\ght ( its sev]] functions1 we are /ill %ock$ by any ext]m9at+ v5geance too rancor\sly pursu$4 ,e read] mu/ h be5 disgu/$ by ! unrel5t+ p]secution ) :i* ,gif=d1 a de=m$ man1 ) ! spiteful nature sometimes too develop$ 9 ! de=m$1 _h und]tak5 '= our fa!rs 9 ! ,r[' an edition ( ,mass+]4 ,probably he _h n ?\ght at ! "t ( ! crim9als :o w\ld come be=e him = judgm5t4 ,b aft]w>ds x did n embitt] ! job t ^! p]quisites ( (fice accru$1 lucro ponatur1 t su* (f5d]s z ,coxet]1 ,mr4 ,monck ,mason1 & o!rs 7 to be 'ju/ifi$' by c\rse ( law4 ,c\ld he n h /at$ _! errors1 & displac$ _! rubbi%1 )\t fur!r p]sonalities8 ,h[ev]1 he does n1 b makes ! air res\nd ) 8 kn\t1 until ! read] wi%es ,coxet] 9 8 ?roat1 & ,monck ,mason1 l '! curs$ old fell[' 9 ,s9bad1 m\nt$ ) pat5t spurs ^u 8 back4 ,we %all be int]rupt$1 h[ev]1 & t we c]ta9ly =esee1 by ! objection--t we are fight+ ) %ad[s1 t nei!r ! loge 9 "o extreme1 nor ! libel 9 ! o!r extreme1 f9ds a place 9 our lit]ature4 ,does x n8 ,yes1 read]1 ea* ( ^! biographical =ms exi/s 9 fav\r among u1 & ( "o x is v d\btful inde$ :e!r x ought n to exi/4 ,! loge is f\nd abundantly diffus$ ?r\gh our monum5tal epitaphs 9 ! fir/ place1 & !re e man w c\nt]sign ,wordswor?'s judgm5t 7see ',! ,excursion' & also ,wordswor?'s prose ,essay on ,epitaphs71 t x is a bless+ = human nature to f9d "o place 9 ?is _w sacr$ to *>itable ?\ghts1 "o place at lea/ (f]+ a sanctu>y f evil speak+4 ,s f> !re is no d\bt4 ,b ! ma9 lit]>y =m1 9 :i* ! ,engli% loge pres5ts itself1 is ! ,fun]al ,s]mon4 ,& 9 ?is also1 n less ?an 9 ! *ur*y>d epitaph1 k9d feel+ ought to preside2 & = ! same reasons1 ! sanctity ( ! place :]e x is deliv]$ or orig9ally publi%$1 & ! solemnity ( ! occasion :i* has prompt$ x2 s9ce1 if y _c f9d matt] 9 ! dep>t$ p]son's "* f]tile 9 praise ev5 :il/ /&+ by ! new-made grave1 :at folly has tempt$ y into writ+ an epitaph or a fun]al s]mon8 ,! good ought c]ta9ly to pr$om9ate 9 bo?1 & 9 ! epitaph no?+ b ! good1 because 7 x only = a reason sugge/$ by ,wordswor?1 viz41 ! elaborate & ev]la/+ "* ( a record *isell$ out pa9fully 9 ea* sep>ate lett]1 x w\ld be sc&al\s to conf] s durable an exi/5ce 9 /one or m>ble ^u trivial human infirmities1 su* z d n ent] into ! la/ solemn reckon+ ) ! _w beyond ! grave2 :il/1 on ! o!r h&1 all grav] (f5ces are hu%$ into 'dread repose1' &1 :]e !y happ5 to be too atroci\s or too memorable1 are at once a suffici5t argum5t = nev] hav+ und]tak5 any su* memorial4 ,^! consid]ations privilege ! epitaph z sacr$ to *>ity1 & taboo$ aga9/ ! revelations ( c&\r4 ,! epitaph _c op5 its scanty records to any brea?+ or ins9uation ( infirmity4 ,b ! ,fun]al ,s]mon1 ?\gh %>+ 9 ! same g5]al temp] ( indulg5ce t[>ds ! errors ( ! deceas$ p]son1 might advantage\sly be laid op5 to a f> m lib]al discussion ( ^? p]sonal or intellectual weaknesses :i* may h ?w>t$ ! influ5ce ( "* o!rwise em95tly ,*ri/ian4 ,! ,oraison ,funbre ( ! ,fr5* proposes to itself by its orig9al model1 :i* mu/ be s\ght 9 ! ,epideictic or panegyrical oratory ( ! ,greeks1 a purpose purely & exclusively eulogi/ic3 ! problem suppos$ is to ab/ract f ev]y?+ n m]itori\s1 to exp& & develop ! total spl5d\r ( ! individual out ( t "o c5tre1 t ma9 b5eficial relation to 8 own age1 f :i* ?is spl5d\r radiat$4 ,! incid5ts ( ! life1 ! successions ( ! biographical detail1 are b slightly trac$1 no f>!r1 9 fact1 ?an is requisite to ! intelligibility ( ! praises4 ,:]eas1 9 ! ,engli% ,fun]al ,s]mon1 !re is no pr9ciple ( absolute exclusion op]at+ aga9/ ! m9ute/ circum/antiations ( fact :i* c t5d to any useful purpose ( illu/rat+ ! "*4 ,& :at is too mu* = ! scale ( a s]mon lit]ally prea*$ be=e a congregation1 or modell$ to c\nt]feit su* a mode ( address1 may easily f9d its place 9 ! explanatory notes4 ,?is is no romance1 or ideal sket* ( :at might be4 ,x is1 & x has be54 ,!re are p]sons ( memorable int]e/ 9 pa/ times1 ( :om all t we "k is embodi$ 9 a fun]al s]mon4 ,= in/ance1 ,j]emy ,taylor 9 t way1 or by 8 ,epi/les ,d$icatory1 has br\ght out ! *>act]i/ic features 9 "s ( 8 own patrons1 :om else we %\ld h kn[n only z nom9is umbras4 ,b a m impressive illu/ration is f\nd 9 ! case ( ,john ,h5d]son1 t man ( :om expectations s great 7 =m$1 & ( :om ,dr4 ,johnson & ,burke1 aft] meet+ & conv]s+ ) him1 pron\nc$ 79 ! ,scriptural words ( ! ,e?iopian que5 appli$ to ! ,jewi% k+1 ,solomon7 't ! half _h n be5 told !m4' ,= ?is man's memory almo/ ! sole orig9al record exi/s 9 ,agutt>'s fun]al s]mon2 = ?\gh o!r records exi/1 & "o f ! p5 ( a p]sonal fri5d1 ,mr4 ,joseph ,cottle1 ( ,bri/ol1 yet ! ma9 sub/ance ( ! biography is d]iv$ f ! fundus ( ?is "o s]mon4#ag ,& x is ( "s importance to cases ( fugitive or unobtrusive m]it t ?is m quiet & seque/]$ curr5t ( biography %\ld be kept op54 ,= ! local motives to an honor>y biographical notice1 9 ! %ape ( a ,fun]al ,s]mon1 w (t5 exi/1 :5 nei!r ! mat]ials are suffici5t1 nor a writ] happ5s to be disposable1 = a lab\r s s]i\s z a regul> biography4 ,"h !n1 on ! "o side1 are our ,engli% loges4 ,& we may add t among/ ! ,me?odi/s1 ! ,bapti/s1 & o!r religi\s sect>ies1 b especially among ! mission>ies ( all nations & *ur*es1 ?is class ( loges is cont9ually increas+4 ,n unfrequ5tly m5 ( f]v5t natures & ( sublime aspirations are ?us rescu$ f oblivion1 :il/ ! great p[] ( su* bodies z ! ,me?odi/s1 _! gr[+ weal?1 & consequ5t responsibility to public op9ion1 are pl$ges t !y w soon comm& all ! advantages ( colleges & academic ref9em5t2 s t if1 9 ! mann] ( ^! fun]al loges1 !re has sometimes be5 miss$ t elegance :i* %\ld h correspond$ to ! weight ( ! matt]1 h5ce=w>ds we may look to see ?is disadvantage giv+ way be=e in/itutions m ?or\ghly matur$4 ,b if ^! are our loges1 on ! o!r h&1 :]e are our libels8 ,?is is likely to be a topic ( (f5ce1 = _m read]s w />t at he>+ ! upright ,samuel ,johnson & ! good-hum\r$1 g>rul\s ,plut>* d5\nc$ z traffick]s 9 libel4 ,b a tru? is a tru?4 ,& ! temp] is s ess5tially diff]5t 9 :i* m5 l5d !mselves to ! propagation ( defamatory anecdotes1 ! impulses are s v>i\s to an (f5ce :i* is n always consci\sly p]ceiv$ by ^? :o are p>ties to x1 t we _c be too cauti\s ( suff]+ our hatr$ ( libel to involve e casual libell]1 or ( suff]+ our g5]al respect = ! p]son ( ! libell] to exon]ate him f ! *>ge ( libell+4 ,_m libels are writt5 9 ?is little _w ( ours unconsci\sly1 & "u _m motives4 ,p]haps we said t be=e1 b no matt]4 ,sometimes a gloomy fell[1 ) a murd]\s ca/ ( c\nt5ance1 sits d[n dogg$ly to ! task ( black5+ "o :om he hates worse '?an toad or asp4' ,= in/ance1 ,procopius p]=ms t 'lab\r ( hate' = ! ,emp]or ,ju/9ian1 p\r+ oil into 8 w\nds1 b1 !n 7z ,col]idge expresses x 9 a 'neat' s>casm71 oil ( vitriol4 ,nature mu/ h meant ! man = a ,spani% ,inquisitor1 s5t into ! _w be=e ,/4 ,dom9ic _h provid$ a trade = him1 or any v5t = 8 malice--s rancor\s 9 8 malignity1 s horrid & unrel5t+ ! torture to :i* he subjects 8 sov]eign & ! beautiful ,!odora4 ,9 ?is case1 f ! )]+ sc[l :i* accompanies ! libels1 we may be assur$ t !y are su* 9 ! mo/ aggravat$ =m--n malici\s only1 b false4 ,x is commonly said1 inde$1 9 our c\rts1 t tru? x is :i* aggravates ! libel4 ,& s x is z reg>ds ! feel+s or ! int]e/s ( ! man libell$4 ,= is x n insuff]able t1 if a poor man "u common human infirmity %all h committ$ "s crime & h paid its p5alty1 b aft]w>ds re=m+ or out-gr[+ 8 own follies1 seeks to ga9 an hone/ livelihood = 8 *ildr5 9 a place :i* ! k ( 8 pa/ transgression has n rea*$1 !n all at once he is to be ru9$ by "s creature purely malignant :o discov]s & publi%es ! secret tale8 ,9 su* a case mo/ und\bt$ly x is ! tru? ( ! libel :i* con/itutes its /+1 s9ce1 if x 7 n true or c\ld be made que/ionable1 x w\ld d ! poor man no mis*ief4 ,b1 on ! o!r h&1 x is ! falsehood ( ! libel :i* =ms its aggravation z reg>ds ! publi%]4 ,& c]ta9 we are1 _h we no o!r v\*] ?an ! in/9ct ( our hatr$ to ,procopius1 t 8 disloyal tales ab\t 8 great "l & lady are odi\sly ov]*>g$1 if n uni=mly false4 ,gibbon1 h[ev]1 *ooses to gratify 8 ta/e = ! luxury ( sc&al by believ+ at once 9 ! p]fect malice ( ! sl&]]1 & ! p]fect tru? ( 8 sl&]s4 ,"h !n1 9 ?is ,procopius1 is an in/ance ( ! gloomy libell]1 ^: v gloom makes affidavit ( 8 f\l _s f ! fir/4 ,!re is also ano!r =m1 less odi\s1 ( ! ho/ile libell]3 x occurs frequ5tly 9 cases :]e ! writ] is n *>geable ) secret malice1 b is 9 a mon/r\s passion4 ,a %[]-ba? might be ( s]vice 9 t case1 :]eas 9 ! ,procopius case no?+ b a copi\s or a ,procopius application ( ! kn\t c answ]4 ,we1 = in/ance1 h 7or _h1 = p]haps x has be5 /ol57 a biography ( t same ,p>k]1 aft]w>ds ,bi%op ( ,ox=d1 ) :om ,&rew ,m>vell '& o!rs :o call$ ,milton fri5d' _h su* r\gh-&-tumble feuds ab\t #afff1 & at ^: exp5se x 0 t ,m>vell made ! :ole nation m]ry 9 8 ',rehe>sal ,transpros$4' ,?is ,p>k] _h a 'knack' at mak+ himself odi\s2 he _h a curiosa felicitas 9 attract+ hatr$s1 & :]ev] he lodg$ = a =tnight he trail$ aft] him a va/ p>abolic or hyp]bolic tail ( enmity & curses1 all smoke & fire & t>ni%1 :i* bore ! same ratio to 8 small body ( m]it t a comet's tail1 measur+ billions ( miles1 does to ! little comet>y mass4 ,! rage aga9/ him 0 embitt]$ by politics1 & inde$ sometimes by knavi% tricks2 ! fir/ n be+ always 'conf\nd$1' nor ! la/ 'fru/rat$4' ,s t ,p>k]1 on ! :ole1 0 a man :om x might be held a duty to hate1 & !re=e1 ( c\rse1 to kn\t z (t5 z y c\ld p]suade him to expose a fair ext5t ( surface = ! action ( ! la%4 ,_m m5 pur*as$ a kn\t = 8 sake1 & took _! *ance = gett+ a '%y' at him1 z ,p>k] might happ5 to fav\r _! int5tions4 ,b "o furi\s g5tleman1 :o is resolv$ to 'take 8 full *ange' out ( ,p>k]1 & !re=e to lose no "t1 comm5ces op]ations 9 ! v fir/ words ( 8 biography3 ',p>k]1' says he1 '! au?or ( ----1 0 ! spawn ( ,samuel ,p>k]4' ,8 rage w n wait = an opportunity2 he ?r[s (f a torr5t ( fi]y sp>ks 9 advance1 & gives full notice to ,p>k] t he w run 8 tra9 "r into him1 if he c come up ) 8 re>4 ,?is man is n malici\s1 b trucul5t2 l ! eld] ,scalig]1 ( :om x 0 obs]v$ t1 hav+ be5 an (fic] ( cavalry up to 8 =tie? ye> 7:5 he took to le>n+ ,greek71 he always fanci$ himself on horseback1 *>g+1 & cutt+ ?roats 9 ! way ( pr(essional duty1 z (t5 z he f\nd himself summon$ to pursue & 'cut up' "s lit]>y del9qu5t4 ,fire & fury1 'bubble & squeak1' is ! prevail+ "* ( 8 critical composition4 ',come1 & let me give !e to ! f[ls ( ! air1' is ! cry ) :i* ! m>tial critic salutes ! affright$ au?or4 ,yet1 meantime1 x is impossible t he c ent]ta9 any p]sonal malice1 = he does n "k ! features ( ! individual enemy :om he is pursu+4 ,b ?us f> he agrees ) ! ,procopian ord] ( biograph]s--t bo? are gov]n$1 9 :atev] evil !y may utt]1 by a _s ( animosity3 "o by a bellig]5t _s :i* w\ld humble its enemy z an enemy 9 a fair pit*$ battle1 ! o!r by a subtle _s ( malice1 :i* w\ld ext]m9ate its enemy n 9 t "* m]ely1 b z an individual by poison or by /rangl+4 ,libels1 h[ev]1 may be accr$it$ & publi%$ :]e !re is no p>ticle ( enmity or ( sudd5 irritation4 ,su* 7 ! libels ( ,plut>* & ,dr4 ,johnson4 ,!y are libels prompt$ by no ho/ile feel+s at all1 b adopt$ by m]e bl9d _s ( cr$ulity4 ,9 ?is _w ( ours1 s f> z we are acqua9t$ ) its do+s1 !re are precisely f\r s]ies--f\r aggregate bodies--( ,lives1 & no m1 :i* y c call celebrat$2 :i* h _h1 & are likely to h1 an ext5sive influ5ce--ea* aft] its own k9d4 ,:i* be !y8 ,to arrange !m 9 po9t ( "t1 fir/ /& ,plut>*'s lives ( em95t ,greeks & ,romans2 next1 ! long succession ( ! ,fr5* ,memoirs1 beg9n+ ) ,philippe de ,comm9es1 9 ! "t ( ,l\is ,,xi4 or our ,edw>d ,,iv41 & end+1 let u say1 ) ! slight record ( himself 7b n )\t int]e/7 ( ,l\is ,,xviii42 ?irdly1 ! ,acta ,sanctorum ( ! ,boll&i/s2 f\r?ly1 ,dr4 ,johnson's ',lives ( ! ,poets4' ,! ?ird is a biographical record ( ! ,romi% sa9ts1 foll[+ ! ord] ( ! m>tyrology z x is dige/$ ?r\gh ! ,roman cal5d> ( ! ye>2 &1 z our own ',biographia ,britannica' has only mov$ =w>ds 9 sev5ty ye>s to ! lett] ',h1' or !reab\ts 7:i* may be ow+ to ! diss5t+ blight ( ,dr4 ,kippis71 p>i passu1 ! ,acta ,sanctorum w be f\nd n mu* f>!r advanc$ ?an ! mon? ( ,may--a pleasant mon? c]ta9ly1 b 7z ! ,spectator (t5 ins9uates7 p]il\s to sa9t%ip4 ,lay+ ?is "w out ( consid]ation1 z be+ *iefly employ$ 9 eulogy su* z c\ld n be extravagant :5 appli$ to ! glori\s army ( m>tyrs 7al?\gh "h also1 we d\bt n1 are _m libels aga9/ m5 conc]n+ :om x matt]s little :e!r !y 7 libell$ or n71 all ! re/ ( ! great biographical works are absolutely saturat$ ) libels4 ,plut>* may be ?\ght to balance 8 extravagant sl&]s by 8 impossible eulogies4 ,he sees no?+ wond]ful 9 actions t 7 f> beyond ! level ( any motives exi/+ "u pagan moralities2 &1 on ! o!r h&1 he traduces great m5 l ,cs>1 ^: natures 7 beyond 8 scale ( measurem5t1 by trac+ _! policy to petty purposes entirely ,plut>*ian4 ,b he 0 a ,greekl+ 9 a deg5]ate age ( ,grecians4 ,z to ! ,fr5* ,memoirs1 :i* are (t5 s exce$+ly amus+1 !y pur*ase _! livel9ess by "o et]nal sacrifice ( pla9 tru?4 ,_! rep>tees1 felicit\s propos1 & po9t$ anecdotes are b "o roll+ fire ( falsehoods4 ,&1 g5]ally1 x may be laid d[n z a rule1 t all collectors ( happy retorts & /rik+ anecdotes are c>eless ( tru?4 ,l\is ,,xiv4 does seem to h _h a natural gift ( mak+ brilliant complim5ts & happy impromptus2 & yet ! v be/ ( 8 reput$ mots 7 spuri\s4 ,"s may be trac$ to ,cic]o1 ,hi]ocles1 ,diog5es2 & "s to 8 mod]n pr$ecessors4 ,t witty rem>k ascrib$ to him ab\t ! disposition ( ,=tune1 z be+ a lady1 to )draw h] fav\rs f old m5 l himself & ! ,m>*al ,b\ffl]s1 0 really utt]$ ne>ly two c5turies be=e by ! ,emp]or ,*>les ,v41 :o probably /ole x f "s ,spani% collection ( je/s4 ,& s ( fifty 9 e hundr$ beside4 ,& ! ,fr5* are n only apt beyond o!r nations to abuse ! lic5se ( /eal+ f our pr$ecessor quod licuit semp]que licebit1 b also1 9 a degree peculi> to !mselves1 !y h a false de-naturaliz$ ta/e 9 ! humor\s1 & z to ! limits ( ! extravagant4 ,we h =m]ly illu/rat$ ?is po9t1 & especially we notic$ x z a case impossible to any nation b ! ,fr5* to h tol]at$ ! pret5d$ 'abs5ces' ( ,la ,fonta9e--z1 = in/ance1 8 affect+ to conv]se ) 8 own son z an entire /rang]1 & ask+ ! lady :o _h pres5t$ him :at might be ! "n ( t amiable "y man4 ,! incr$ulus odi faces "o 9 e page ( a ,fr5* memoir2 v]acity is an unkn[n virtue1 &1 :]ev] t is ! ta/e1 look = libels by :olesale4 ,too (t5 ev5 ! unnatural & ! mon/r\s is c\rt$1 r ?an miss ! object ( arre/+ & />tl+4 ,n[1 ,dr4 ,johnson's calumnies or romances 7 n ( t ord]4 ,he _h a heal?y _s ( rev]5ce = tru?2 b he 0 cr$ul\s to excess1 & he 0 plagu$ by an infirmity n uncommon among/ lit]>y m5 :o h no families ( "y p gr[+ up ar\nd _! he>?--! hank]+ aft] gossip4 ,he 0 curi\s ab\t ! dome/ic habits ( 8 celebrat$ c\ntrym52 inquisitive 9 a morbid degree ab\t _! pecuni>y affairs3 ',:at h y got 9 t pocket :i* bulges out s prom95tly8' ',:at did y\r fa!r d ) t hundr$ gu9eas :i* he receiv$ on ,monday f ,jacob ,jonson8' ,&1 z 8 'swall[' 0 enorm\s--z ! ,doctor w\ld believe m fables 9 an h\r ?an an able-bodi$ li> w\ld inv5t 9 a week--naturally !re 0 no limit to ! sl&]s ) :i* 8 ',lives ( ! ,poets' are ov]run4 ,( ! f\r great biographical works :i* we h m5tion$1 we hold ,dr4 ,johnson's to be by f> ! be/ 9 po9t ( composition4 ,ev5 ,plut>*1 ?\gh p>donably ov]rat$ 9 consequ5ce ( ! great subjects :i* he treats 7:i* aga9 are 'great' by b5efit ( di/ance & ! va/ ab/ract+ process execut$ by "t ^u ! petty & ! famili>71 is loose & rambl+ 9 ! pr9ciples ( 8 nexus2 & !re lies ! great ef=t = a biograph]1 !re is ! /ra91 & t is ! task--viz41 to weld ! disconnect$ facts into "o sub/ance1 & by int]fus+ natural reflections to create = ! motions ( 8 n>rative a high] impulse ?an "o m]ely *ronologic4 ,9 ?is respect1 ! be/ ( ,dr4 ,johnson's ',lives' are und\bt$ly ! v be/ :i* exi/4 ,!y are ! mo/ highly f9i%$ among/ all ma/]pieces ( ! biographic art1 &1 z respects ! ,doctor p]sonally1 !y are1 beyond comp>ison1 8 be/ "w4 ,x is a great ?+ 9 any "o art or function1 ev5 ?\gh x 7 n a great "o1 to h excell$ all ! lit]ature ( all languages4 ,& if ! read] fancies t !re lurks any:]e a collection ( lives1 or ev5 "o life 7?\gh x 7 ! ',agricola' ( ,tacitus71 :i* z a "w ( ref9$ art & execution c be ?\ght equal to ! be/ ( ,dr4 ,johnson's1 we %\ld be grateful to him if he w\ld assign x 9 a lett] to ,mr4 ,blackwood3 ',& ?\gh ! night be raw1 ,we'll see x too1 ! fir/ we ev] saw4' ,we say no?+ ( ! ,calmuck ,t>t>s2 !y hold 7see ,b]gmann's ',/reif]ei5'7 t _! ',ds*ang>iade' is ! f9e/ ( all epic poems1 pa/ or com+2 &1 !re=e1 ! ,calmuck ,lives ( ! ,poets w naturally be inimitable4 ,b conf9+ our view to ! unhappy lit]atures ( ,europe1 anci5t or mod]n1 ?is is :at we ?9k ( ,dr4 ,johnson's ef=ts z a biograph]4 ,consequ5tly1 we _c be tax$ ) any ins5sibility to 8 m]it4 ,& z to ! critical "p ( 8 ,lives1 if no ?\ghtful read] c be expect$ to abide by 8 haughty decisions1 yet1 on ! o!r h&1 e man reads 8 op9ions ) pleasure1 f ! intellectual activity & ! sep>ate ju/ice ( ! ?\ghts :i* !y display4 ,b z to 8 libell\s prop5sity1 t re/s ^u indep5d5t pr9ciples2 = all 8 ability & all 8 logic c\ld n elevate 8 m9d above ! region ( gossip4 ,take 8 ',life ( ,savage4' ,?is 0 ! orig9al ne/-egg1 ^u :i*1 z a basis1 & p]haps z ! occasional sugge/ion ( su* an ent]prise1 all ! re/--all[ u a pomp\s ^w--sup]v5$4 ,x 0 admirably writt51 because writt5 con amore1 & also because writt5 con odio2 & "u ei!r impulse is x possible to imag9e gross] delusions8 ,johnson p]suad$ himself t ,savage 0 a f9e g5tleman 7a rle n difficult to support 9 t age1 :5 c]emony & a gorge\s co/ume 7 among/ ! auxili>y di/9ctions ( a g5tleman71 & also t he 0 a man ( g5ius4 ,! fir/ claim 0 necess>ily tak5 ^u tru/ by ! ,doctor's read]s2 ! o!r might h be5 exam9$2 b aft] a few pa9ful ef=ts to read ',! ,w&]]' & o!r insipid trifles1 succe$+ g5]ations h resolv$ to take t ^u tru/ also2 = 9 v tru? ,savage's writ+s are ( t ord] :i* 'd n let !mselves be read4' ,:y1 !n1 _h publi%]s b\ght !m8 ,publi%]s 9 ^? days 7 m]e tradesm51 )\t access to lib]al society4 ,ev5 ,ri*>dson1 ?\gh a man ( great g5ius1 9 8 publi%]'s "* 0 an obsequi\s1 nay1 s]vile1 admir] ( ! f9e g5tleman :o wore a sword1 embroid]$ clo!s1 & ,me*l9 ruffles ab\t 8 wri/s2 above all ?+s1 he glorifi$ & ador$ a ,lovelace1 ) a f9e p]son1 :o sang gaily to %[ 8 c>elessness ( l[ p1 nev] came abroad except 9 a s$an-*air1 & lib]ally di/ribut$ 8 curses to ! "r & ! left 9 all respectable m5's %ops4 ,?is temp]1 ) h] usual sagacity1 ,lady ,m4 ,wortley ,montagu c\ld detect 9 ,ri*>dson1 & = ?is %e despis$ him4 ,b ?is x 01 & "s little vision ( possible patronage f ,"l ,tyrconnel1 :i* _h obta9$ any prices at all = ,savage f su* kn[+ publi%]s z 7 !n aris+2 b g5]ally ,savage _h reli$ ^u subscriptions1 :i* 7 /ill common1 &1 9 8 case1 z a man suppos$ un=tunate1 7 giv5 purely z *>ity4 ,) :at a/oni%m5t does a lit]>y =eign] ( any judgm5t f9d a ,savage plac$ among/ ! classics ( ,engl&6 & f ! scale ( 8 life reasonably he mu/ inf] t he is rank$ among/ ! lead]s1 :il/ ! ext5t 9 :i* 8 works are multipli$ w\ld ?r[ him back ^u ! tru?--t he is utt]ly unkn[n to 8 c\ntrym54 ,^!1 h[ev]1 7 ! delusions ( good nature4 ,b :at are we to ?9k ( ,dr4 ,johnson's abett+ t mon/r\s libel aga9/ ,lady ,macclesfield8 ,%e1 unhappily1 z a woman bani%$ )\t hope f all good society by h] e>ly misconduct z a wife 7b1 let x n be =gott51 a neglect$ wife71 _h nobody to speak a ^w on h] behalf3 all evil 0 believ$ ( "o :o _h violat$ h] m>riage v[s4 ,b _h ! affair occurr$ 9 our days1 ! public j\rnals w\ld h right$ h]4 ,!y w\ld h %[n ! folly ( believ+ a va91 conceit$ man l ,savage & 8 nurse1 ) no v\*]s :atev]1 ^u a po9t :]e !y _h ! deepe/ int]e/ at /ake2 :il/ on ! opposite side1 suppos+ _! /ory true1 spoke = !m ! /ronge/ ( all natural in/9cts--! plead+ ( ! mat]nal he>t1 combat$ by no self-int]e/ :atev]4 ,surely if ,lady ,macclesfield _h n be5 support$ by indignation aga9/ an impo/ure1 m]ely = h] own ease & com=t1 %e w\ld h p5sion$ ,savage1 or h procur$ him "s place "u ,gov]nm5t--n difficult 9 ^? days = a p]son ) h] connections 7h[ev] sunk z respect$ female society7 to h obta9$ = an only son4 ,9 ! /]nness ( h] resi/ance to all attempts ^u h] purse we read h] s5se ( ! fraud4 ,&1 on ! o!r h&1 0 ! conduct ( ,savage t ( a son8 ,he _h no legal claims ^u h]1 consequ5tly no pret5ce = mole/+ h] 9 h] dwell+-h\se4 ,& w\ld a real son--a great lubb]ly fell[1 well able to "w z a port] or a footman--h[ev] w\nd$ at h] ob/9ate rejection1 h be5 likely1 9 pursuit ( no legal rights1 to h al>m$ h] by ?reat5+ lett]s & intrusions1 = no purpose b "o confess$ly ( pecuni>y extortion8 ,f ! v mode ( pursu+ 8 claim x is pla9 t ,savage felt x to be a false "o4 ,x seems1 also1 to be =gott5 by mo/ read]s1 t at ?is day real sons--n d5i$ to be su*--are cont9ually bani%$1 nay1 eject$ =cibly by policem51 f ! pat]nal ro( 9 requital ( j su* pr(ligate conduct z ,savage display$2 s t1 grant 8 improbable /ory1 /ill he 0 a disord]ly reprobate1 :o 9 ^! days w\ld h be5 consign$ to ! treadmill4 ,b ! :ole 0 a hoax4 ,savage1 h[ev]1 is b a s+le case1 9 relation to :i* ,dr4 ,johnson /ood 9 a special position1 t diseas$ 8 judgm5t4 ,b look at ,pope's life1 at ,swift's1 at ,"y's--at all ! lives ( m5 contempor>y ) himself3 !y are ov]run ) defamatory /ories1 or traits ( t ord] :i* w\ld mo/ h /ung !m1 _h !y return$ to life4 ,b x 0 an accid5t mo/ b5eficial to ,dr4 ,johnson t ne>ly all ^! m5 left no ne> relatives beh9d to call him to acc\nt4 ,! public 7 amus$1 z !y always are by exhibitions ( infirmity or folly 9 "o :om o!rwise !y 7 compell$ to admire2 t 0 a sort ( rev5ge = !m to set (f aga9/ a pa9ful p]petuity ( homage4 ,?us f> ! libels s]v$ only z je/s1 &1 =tunately = ,dr4 ,johnson1 !re arose no aft]-reckon+4 ,"o p]iod1 9 fact1 ( ?irty ye>s _h int]v5$ betwe5 ! la/ ( ^! m5 & ! publication ( ! ,lives2 x 0 among/ ! late/ works ( ,dr4 ,johnson3 ?us1 & because mo/ ( !m left no desc5dants1 he escap$4 ,_h ! ord9>y proportion ( ^! m5 be5 m>ri$1 ! result w\ld h be5 diff]5t2 & :atev] might h be5 ?\ght ( any individual case among/ ! compla9ts1 mo/ und\bt$ly1 f ! great numb] to :i* ! ,doctor _h expos$ himself1 among/ :i* _m 7 n ( a nature to be evad$ by any v\*]s :atsoev]1 a fatal effect w\ld h settl$ on ! ,doctor's moral reputation4 ,he w\ld h be5 pass$ d[n to po/]ity z a deal] 9 :olesale sc&al1 :o c>$ no?+ = ! w\nd$ feel+s ( relatives4 ,x is a trifle aft] t to add t he w\ld frequ5tly h be5 cudgell$4 ,?is public judgm5t ^u ,dr4 ,johnson & ^! cudgell+s w\ld h be5 too sev]e a *a/isem5t = ! (f5ces1 :i*1 aft] all1 argu$ no heavi] del9qu5cy ?an a levity 9 exam9+ 8 *ance au?orities1 & a con/itutional cr$ulity4 ,dr4 ,johnson's eas9ess ( fai? = ! sup]natural1 ! grossness ( 8 sup]/ition 9 relation to su* mis]able impo/ures z ! ,cock ,lane gho/1 & its scrat*+s on ! wall1 fl[$ f ! same s\rce2 & 8 conv]sation furni%es _m pro(s t he _h no pr9ciple ( resi/ance 9 8 m9d1 no reasonable scepticism1 :5 any disp>ag+ anecdote 0 told ab\t 8 ne>e/ fri5ds4 ,:o b he w\ld h believ$ ! mon/r\s tale3 t ,g>rick1 s us$ to address+ l>ge audi5ces extempore1 s quick & lively 9 8 appreh5sions1 _h absolutely be5 dismiss$ f a c\rt ( ju/ice z an idiot--z a man incapable ( giv+ ! c\rt in=mation ev5 ^u a "q ( 8 own pr(ession8 ,z to 8 cr$ulity ) respect to ! some:at h>mless =g]ies ( ,psalmanaz]1 & ) respect to ! villa9\s impo/ure ( ,l&]1 we imag9e t o!r causes co-op]at$ to ^? errors beyond m]e facility ( ass5t+4 ,9 ! latt] case we fe> t jeal\sy ( ,milton z a s*ol>1 a feel+ f :i* he nev] cleans$ himself1 _h be5 ! *ief cause ( 8 s readily deliv]+ himself a dupe to allegations n speci\s1 back$ by =g]ies t 7 any?+ b +5i\s4 ,dr4 ,johnson _h a n>r[ escape on t occasion4 ,_h ,dr4 ,d\glas fa/5$ ^u him z ! collusive abettor ( ,l&]1 z ! man ^: sanction _h ev] won ev5 a mom5t>y cr$it = ! obscure libell]1 & z ! "o beyond all o!rs ( ! age ^: critical occupation ought mo/ to h secur$ him aga9/ su* a delusion1 ! "* ( ,johnson w\ld h suff]$ s]i\sly4 ,luckily1 ,dr4 ,d\glas sp>$ him2 & ,johnson1 see+ ! infamy ( ! hoax1 & ! precipice ne> :i* he /ood1 ha/5$ to sep>ate himself f ,l&]1 & to (f] su* rep>ation z he c\ld1 by dictat+ t unhappy lett] ( recantation4 ,l&] mu/ h cons5t$ to ?is /ep f hopes ( patronage2 & p]haps ! obscure place ( slave-driv] 9 ! ,we/ ,indies1 9 :i* he di$ 7aft] recant+ 8 recantation71 might be ! unsatisfactory bait ( 8 ne$y ambition4 ,b assur$ly ,l&] c\ld h made out a bett] case = himself ?an t :i*1 "u 8 "n1 ! ,doctor address$ to ! ,bi%op2 x 0 a d>k spot 9 ,dr4 ,johnson's life4 ,a ,scotsman1 said he1 mu/ be a /range "o :o w\ld n tell a falsehood 9 a case :]e ,scotl& 0 conc]n$2 & we fe> t any fable ( defamation mu/ h be5 gross inde$ :i* ,dr4 ,johnson w\ld n h c\nt5anc$ aga9/ ,milton4 ,8 ',life ( ,milton1' z x n[ /&s1 conta9s "s ( ! grosse/ calumnies aga9/ t mighty poet :i* h ev] be5 haz>d$2 & "s ( ! deepe/ misrepres5tations are col\r$1 to ! unsuspect+ read]1 by an affectation ( m]rim5t4 ,b 9 8 'he>t ( he>ts' ,dr4 ,johnson dete/$ ,milton4 ,gray1 ev5 ?\gh1 z be+ little ( a m$dl] ) politics1 he furni%$ no h&le to ! ,doctor = wra? s unrel5t+1 0 a subject ( deep jeal\sy f 8 reput$ s*ol>%ip4 ,nev] did ! spite ( ! ,doctor m emblazon itself ?an 9 8 review ( ,gray's lyrical compositions2 ! v affectation ( prefac+ 8 review by call+ ! two *ief odes '! wond]ful wond] ( wond]s' betrays a female spite2 & nev] did ! arrogance ( ,dr4 ,johnson's nature flame out s conspicu\sly z 9 "s ( ! phrases us$ on ?is occasion4 ,p]haps x is an in/ance ( self-inflation absolutely unique :]e he says1 ',my k9dness = a man ( lett]s'2 ?is1 x seems1 caus$ him to feel pa9 at see+ ,gray desc5d+ to :at he1 ! ,doctor 7z a "o-sid$ op9ion ( 8 own71 held to be a fanta/ic fopp]y4 ,! "q we po9t at is n ?is suppos$ fopp]y--0 x su* or n8 ,milton's hav+ *]i%$ t 'fopp]y' 0 a suffici5t argum5t = dete/+ x4 ,:at we fix ! read]'s eye ^u is1 ! unp>allel$ arrogance ( apply+ to ,gray ?is extreme language ( condesc5d+ patronage4 ,he really _h 'a k9dness' = ! little man1 & 0 n a%am$1 z "s p w\ld be1 to own x2 s t x %ock$ him m ?an else x w\ld h done1 to see ! man disgrac+ himself 9 ?is way4 ,h[ev]1 x is probable t all ! mis/atem5ts ( ,dr4 ,johnson1 ! invidi\s impressions1 & ! ludicr\s or injuri\s anecdotes fa/5$ ad libitum ^u m5 previ\sly op5 to p>ticul> attacks1 nev] w be expos$2 & = ?is1 among/ o!r reasons1 t sometimes ! facts ( ! case are irrecov]able1 ?\gh falsehood may be app>5t2 & /ill m because few m5 w be dispos$ to degrade !mselves by assum+ a second>y & m9i/]ial (fice 9 hang+ ^u ! errors ( any man4 ,pope 0 a great fav\rite ) ,dr4 ,johnson1 bo? z an unreflect+ ,tory1 :o travell$ ! :ole road to ,jacobitism--?us f> resembl+ ! ,doctor himself2 secondly1 z "o :o complim5t$ himself :il/ yet a "y man1 & ev5 :il/ we>+ a masque--complim5t$ him "u circum/ances :i* make complim5ts d\bly useful1 & make !m trebly s9c]e4 ,if any man1 !re=e1 he w\ld h treat$ indulg5tly ,pope3 yet 8 life x is :i* has ma9ly fix$ ^u ,pope t false impression :i* pr$om9ates at ?is day--t d\btless intellectually he 0 a v brilliant little man2 b morally a spiteful1 peevi%1 waspi%1 n>r[-he>t$ cynic4 ,:]eas no imputation c be m unf\nd$4 ,pope1 unless 9 cases :5 he _h be5 madd5$ by lampoons1 0 a mo/ b5ignant creature2 &1 ) ! slighte/ ackn[l$gm5t ( 8 own m]it1 !re nev] liv$ a lit]>y man :o 0 s g5]\sly eag] to associate o!rs 9 8 own hon\rs--^? ev5 :o _h no adequate pret5sions4 ,if y1 read]1 %\ld1 l ourselves1 h _h occasion to inve/igate ,pope's life1 "u an int5tion ( record+ x m accurately or m compreh5sively ?an has yet be5 done1 y w feel ! tru? ( :at we are say+4 ,& especially we w\ld recomm5d to e man1 :o wi%es to ?9k ju/ly ( ,pope 9 ?is respect1 t he %\ld comp>e 8 conduct t[>ds lit]>y competitors ) t ( ,addison4 ,dr4 ,johnson1 hav+ p>tially exam9$ ! lives ( bo?1 mu/ h be5 s f> qualifi$ to d ju/ice betwe5 !m4 ,b ju/ice he has n done2 & to him *iefly we repeat t at ?is day are ow+ ! false impressions ( ,pope's selfi%1 ung5ial1 or misan?ropic nature2 & ! humiliat+ associations connect$ ) ,pope's petty manoeuvr+ 9 trivial dome/ic affairs1 *iefly ?r\gh ,dr4 ,johnson's means1 w nev] be oblit]at$4 ,let u turn1 h[ev]1 f ,dr4 ,johnson1 :om1 ) our g5]al respect = 8 upright nature1 x is pa9ful to foll[ ?r\gh circum/ances :]e ei!r jeal\sy 7z sometimes7 or cr$ulity & ! love ( gossip 7z v (t57 has misl$ him into gratify+ ! ta/e ( ! envi\s at a great sacrifice ( dignity to ! ma9 uphold]s ( our lit]ature4 ,^! m5 ought n to h be5 '%[n up' = a comic or malici\s effect4 ,a nation :o value _! lit]ature z we h reason to value ours ought to %[ _! s5se ( ?is value by =gett+ ! degrad+ infirmities 7n ! v5ial & human infirmities7 ( ^? to ^: admirable end[m5ts !y owe its excell5ce4 ,turn+ away1 !re=e1 f ^? modes ( biography :i* h hi!rto pursu$ any vici\s extreme1 let u n[ briefly expla9 our own ideal ( a happi]1 s\nd]1 & m ennobl+ biographical art1 hav+ ! same g5]al objects z h]et(ore1 b ) a m express view to ! b5efit ( ! read]4 ,look+ ev5 at ^? memoirs :i*1 l ,hayley's ( ,c[p]1 h be5 *eck$ by pa!tic circum/ances f fix+ any slur or irrev]5tial sc&al ^u _! subject1 we /ill see a great fault 9 ! mass ( biographic records2 & :at is x8 ,x is--t1 ev5 :]e no disposition is manife/$ to copy ei!r ! loge or ! libell\s pasqu9ade1 too g5]ally ! au?or appe>s ex (ficio z ! con/ant 'patronus' or legal advocate = ! p]son record$4 ,& s he ought1 if we und]/& t sort ( advocacy :i* 9 ,engli% c\rts ! judge 0 =m]ly presum$ to ex]cise on behalf ( ! def5dant 9 crim9al trials4 ,be=e t rem>kable *ange by :i* a prison] 0 inve/$ ) ! privilege ( employ+ sep>ate c\nsel1 ! judge 0 8 c\nsel4 ,! judge took c>e t no wrong 0 done to him2 t no false impression 0 left ) ! jury2 t ! witnesses aga9/ him %\ld n be suff]$ to run on )\t a suffici5t rig\r ( cross-exam9ation4 ,b c]ta9ly ! judge ?\ght x no "p ( 8 duty to make '! worse appe> ! bett] reason'2 to ?r[ du/ into ! eyes ( ! jury2 or to lab\r any po9t ( equivocation = ! sake ( giv+ ! prison] an extra *ance ( escap+4 ,&1 if x is really "r t ! prison]1 :5 obvi\sly guilty1 %\ld be aid$ 9 evad+ 8 probable conviction1 !n c]ta9ly 9 pa/ times he _h less ?an ju/ice4 ,= mo/ und\bt$ly no judge w\ld h attempt$ :at we all saw an advocate attempt+ ab\t a ye> ago1 t1 :5 e p]son 9 c\rt 0 satisfi$ ( ! prison]'s guilt1 f ! pro( sudd5ly br\ght to light ( 8 hav+ cl&e/9ely left ! plate ( 8 murd]$ victim 9 a p>ticul> p>ty's safe keep+1 at t mom5t ! advocate 7?\gh secretly pro/rat$ by ?is ov]:elm+ discov]y7 /ruggl$ va9ly to fix ^u ! hon\rable witness a f\l /igma ( self-contradiction & p]jury = ! s+le purpose ( turn+ loose a savage murd]] ^u society4 ,if ?is 7 n m ?an ju/ice1 !n assur$ly 9 all times pa/ ! prison] _h f> less4 ,n[1 precisely ! diff]5ce betwe5 ! advocacy ( ! judge1 & ! advocacy ( a special c\nsel reta9$ by ! prison]1 expresses ! diff]5ce :i* we contemplate betwe5 ! biograph] z he has hi!rto protect$ 8 h]o & t biograph] :om we w\ld sub/itute4 ,is he n to %[ a p>tiality = 8 subject8 ,d\btless2 b hi!rto1 9 ^? lives :i* h be5 f>!/ f loges1 ! au?or has ?\ght x 8 duty to uphold ! g5]al sy/em1 polity1 or pr9ciples ^u :i* 8 subject has act$4 ,?us ,middleton & all o!r biograph]s ( ,cic]o1 :il/ nev] m$itat+ any panegyrical acc\nt ( t /atesman1 & (t5times regrett+ 8 vanity1 = in/ance1 h q z little ?\ght x all[able to condemn ! ma9 political views1 !ories1 & consequ5tly actions1 ( ,cic]o4 ,b :y n8 ,:y %\ld a biograph] be fett]$ 9 8 *oice ( subjects by any imag9>y duty ( adopt+ ! views held by him ^: life he records8 ,to make w> ^u ! man1 to qu>rel ) him 9 e page1 t is q z little 9 accordance ) our notions2 & we h already expla9$ above our s5se ( its hatefulness4 ,= !n ! "q recurs = ev]3 ,:at necessity =c$ y ^u a subject ^: conduct y ?or\ghly disapprove8 ,b let him %[ ! t5d]ness :i* is due to a great man ev5 :5 he errs4 ,let him expose ! total ab]rations ( ! man1 & make ?is exposure salut>y to ! pa!tic wisdom ( 8 read]s1 n alim5t>y to _! self-conceit1 by keep+ con/antly be=e _! eyes ! excell5ce & spl5d\r ( ! man's p[]s 9 contra/ ) 8 cont9u$ failures4 ,let him %[ su* patronage to ! h]o ( 8 memoir z ! ,engli% judge %[$ to ! poor prison] at 8 b>1 tak+ c>e t he %\ld suff] no %ad[ ( inju/ice f ! witnesses2 t ! prison]'s own self-def5ce %\ld 9 no "p be defeat$ ( its effect by want ( prop] words or want ( prop] skill 9 press+ ! =cible po9ts on ! att5tion ( ! jury2 b o!rwise leav+ him to 8 own real m]its 9 ! facts ( 8 case1 & all[+ him no relief f ! pressure ( ! ho/ile evid5ce b su* z he c\ld f9d ei!r 9 c\nt]-evid5ce or 9 ! intr9sic weight ( 8 own g5]al "*4 ,on ! s*eme ( biography !re w\ld be few p]sons 9 any dep>tm5t ( life :o w\ld be accompani$ to ! close by a b[+ & obsequi\s report]2 !re w\ld be f> less ( uni=m approbation presumable 9 memoirs2 b1 on ! o!r h&1 !re w\ld be exhibit$ pretty g5]ally a t5d] _s ( deal+ ) human infirmities2 a l>ge application ( human errors to ! b5efit ( succe$+ g5]ations2 &1 la/ly1 !re w\ld be an op5+ made = ! free exam9ation ( _m lives :i* are n[ 9 a mann] clos$ aga9/ criticism2 :il/ to ea* sep>ate life !re w\ld be an access & an invitation laid b>e = m9ds hi!rto feel+ !mselves exclud$ f approa*+ ! subject by imp]fect sympa?y ) ! pr9ciples & doctr9es :i* ^? lives 7 suppos$ to illu/rate4 ,b our re=m$ view ( biography w\ld be bett] expla9$ by a sket* appli$ to ,cic]o's life or to ,milton's4 ,9 ei!r case we might easily %[1 consi/5tly ) ! exposure ( enorm\s errors1 t ea* 0 ! wise/ man ( 8 own day4 ,& ) reg>d to ,cic]o 9 p>ticul>1 out ( 8 own lett]s to ,atticus1 we might %[ t e capital op9ion :i* he held on ! politics ( ,rome 9 8 own day 0 false1 gr\ndless1 contradictory4 ,yet = all t1 we w\ld engage to leave ! read] 9 a /ate ( f> deep] admiration = ! man ?an ! holl[ & hypocritical ,middleton ev] felt himself1 or c\ld !re=e h communicat$ to 8 read]s4 ,,editor',s ,,note4--,! ref]5ce on p4 #abb is to ! fam\s case ( ,c\rvoisi]1 9 #ahdj1 & ?is fixes #ahda z ! date ( ! essay4 ,c\rvoisi] 0 a valet :o murd]$ & robb$ 8 ma/]1 putt+ ! plate into ! c>e ( an old woman1 & mak+ x appe> a burgl>y4 ,he 0 def5d$ by a b>ri/] nam$ ,philips1 :o receiv$ f ! prison] a confession ( 8 guilt1 & aft]w>ds1 9 c\rt1 took ,heav5 to witness t he believ$ him innoc5t1 ?\gh ! woman1 by accid5t almo/1 _h be5 f\nd1 & giv5 evid5ce4 ,philips 0 disb>r$4 ,,footnotes3 #ag ,9 ,mrs4 ,hannah ,m's draw+-room at ,b>ley ,wood1 among/ ! few pictures :i* adorn$ x1 hung a kit-kat portrait ( ,john ,h5d]son4 ,?is1 & our private k t ,mrs4 ,h4 ,m4 _h p]sonally kn[n & admir$ ,h5d]son1 l$ u to conv]se ) t lady ab\t him4 ,:at we glean$ f h] 9 addition to ! notices ( ,agutt> & ( "s among/ ,johnson's biograph]s may yet see ! light4 ,,xiv4 ,,great ,,=g]s3 ,,*att]ton ,,& ,,walpole1 ,,& ',,junius4' ,i h ev] be5 dispos$ to reg>d z ! mo/ v5ial ( deceptions su* impositions z ,*att]ton _h practis$ on ! public cr$ulity4 ,:om did he deceive8 ,nobody b ^? :o well des]v$ to be deceiv$1 viz41 %all[ antiqu>ies1 :o pret5d$ to a sort ( k :i* !y _h n s mu* z ta/$4 ,& x always /ruck me z a judicial infatuation 9 ,horace ,walpole1 t he1 :o _h s brutally pron\nc$ ! dea? ( ?is m>vell\s boy to be a matt] ( little consequ5ce1 s9ce o!rwise he w\ld h come to be hang$ = =g]y1 %\ld himself1 n z a boy "u eighte5 7& ,i ?9k "u sev5te5 at ! fir/ issu+ ( ! ,r[ley fraud71 slav+ = a few gu9eas t he might procure ! simple/ food = himself1 & !n buy pres5ts = ! de> "m & si/] :om he _h left 9 ,bri/ol1 b z an eld]ly man1 ) a cle> six ?\s& p] annum1#ah commit a f> m delib]ate & audaci\s =g]y ?an t imput$ 7if ev5 accurately imput$7 to ,*att]ton4 ,i "k ( no publi%$ docum5t1 or none publi%$ "u ,*att]ton's sanction1 9 :i* he =mally decl>$ ! ,r[ley poems to h be5 ! compositions ( a prie/ liv+ 9 ! days ( ,h5ry ,,iv41 viz41 9 or ab\t ! ye> #adjj4 ,und\bt$ly he suff]$ p to und]/& t he _h f\nd ,,mss4 ( t p]iod 9 ! t[] ( ,/4 ,m>y ,r$cliff at ,bri/ol1 :i* he really _h done2 & :e!r he simply tol]at$ !m 9 runn+ (f ) ! idea t ^! p>ticul> poems1 writt5 on discol\r$ p>*m5ts by way ( col\r+ ! hoax1 7 among/ ! ,/4 ,m>y treasures1 or positively said s1 9 ei!r view1 consid]+ ! circum/ances ( ! case1 no man ( k9d feel+s w mu* condemn him4 ,b ,horace ,walpole r\ndly & audaci\sly affirm$ 9 ! fir/ s5t5ce ( 8 preface to ! poor romance ( ',otranto1' t x _h be5 translat$ f ! ,italian ( ,onuphrio ,muralto1 & t ! ,,ms4 0 /ill pres]v$ 9 ! libr>y ( an ,engli% ,ca?olic family2 circum/antiat+ 8 ne$less falsehood by o!r mo/ sup]flu\s details4 ,ne$less1 ,i say1 because a book ) ! ,walpole "n on ! title-page 0 z sure ( sell+ z "o ) ,*att]ton's obscure "n 0 at t "t sure ( n sell+4 ,possibly ,horace ,walpole did n c>e ab\t sell+1 b wi%$ to measure 8 own intr9sic p[] z a noveli/1 = :i* purpose x 0 a bett] c\rse to pres]ve 8 incognito4 ,b ?is he might h pres]v$ )\t tell+ a circum/antial falsehood4 ,:]eas ,*att]ton knew t 8 only *ance ( em]g+ f ! obscure /ation ( a grave-digg]'s son1 & c>ry+ into com=t ! de> female relatives t _h half-/>v$ !mselves = him 7,i speak ( ?+s :i* h s9ce come to my k ?irty-five ye>s aft] ,*att]ton & 8 woes _h be5 buri$ 9 a paup]'s c(f971 lay 9 brib+ public att5tion by "s extr9sic attraction4 ,macph]son _h rec5tly engag$ ! public gaze by 8 ',ossian'--an abortion fa!r$ ^u ! f\r? c5tury aft] ,*ri/4 ,:at s natural z to attempt o!r abortions--ideas & ref9em5ts ( ! eighte5? c5tury--ref]r+ !mselves to ! fifte5?8 ,_h ?is h>mless hoax succe$$1 he w\ld h deliv]$ ^? f pov]ty :o deliv]$ him f ignorance2 he w\ld h rais$ ^? f ! du/ :o rais$ him to an a]ial height--yes1 to a height f :i* 7b x 0 aft] 8 dea?71 l ,ate or ,eris1 come to cause ano!r ,trojan w>1 he ?rew d[n an apple ( discord among/ ! lead+ s*ol>s ( ,engl&1 & seem$ to say3 ',!re1 ,dean ( ,exet]6 !re1 ,laureate6 !re1 ,tyr:itt1 my man6 ,me y h murd]$ among/ y4 ,n[ fight to dea? = ! boy t liv+ y w\ld n h hir$ z a %oeblack4 ,my blood be ^u y6' ,rise up1 m>tyr$ blood6 rise to heav5 = a te/imony aga9/ ^! m5 & ?is g5]ation1 or else burr[ 9 ! e>?1 & f t spr+ up l ! /ones ?r[n by ,deucalion & ,pyrrha into h>ve/s ( feud1 into armies ( self-ext]m9at+ foes4 ,poor *ild6 immortal *ild6 ,slight 7 ?y trespasses on ?is e>?1 heavy 0 ?y puni%m5t1 & x is to be hop$1 nay1 x is c]ta91 t ?is disproportion did n escape ! eye :i*1 9 ! algebra ( human actions1 e/imates bo? sides ( ! equation4 ,"l ,byron 0 ( op9ion t p abus$ ,horace ,walpole = sev]al s9i/] reasons1 ( :i* ! fir/ is repres5t$ to be t he 0 a g5tleman4 ,n[1 ,i1 on ! contr>y1 am ( op9ion t he 0 n always a g5tleman1 z p>ticul>ly se5 9 8 correspond5ce ) ,*att]ton4 ,on ! o!r h&1 x is b j to recollect t 9 reta9+ ,*att]ton's ,,mss4 7o!rwise an unfeel+ act1 yet *iefly imputable to indol5ce71 ! wor/ aggravation ( ! case "u ! poor boy's con/ruction1 viz41 t if ,walpole _h n kn[n 8 l[ rank 'he w\ld n h d>$ to treat him 9 t way1' ?\gh a v natural feel+1 0 really an unf\nd$ "o4 ,horace ,walpole 7,i call him s1 because he 0 n !n ,"l ,or=d7 c]ta9ly _h n be5 aw>e t ,*att]ton 0 o!r ?an a g5tleman by bir? & /ation4 ,! natural dignity ( ! boy1 :i* _h n condesc5d$ to any degrad+ applications1 misl$ ?is practis$ man ( ! _w4 ,b recurr+ to ,"l ,byron's ins9uations z to a sy/ematic design ( runn+ ,"l ,or=d d[n1 ,i beg to say t ,i am no p>ty to any su* design4 ,x is n likely t a furi\s ,cons]vative l myself1 :o h ! mis=tune also to be ! mo/ bigot$ ( ,tories1 w\ld be s4 ,i disclaim all p>ticipation 9 any clam\r aga9/ ,"l ,or=d :i* may h aris5 on democratic feel+4 ,feel+ ! pr(\nde/ pity = ! 'm>vell\s boy' ( ,bri/ol1 & ev5 love1 if x be possible to feel love = "o :o 0 9 8 unhon\r$ grave be=e ,i 0 born1 ,i res5t ! conduct ( ,"l ,or=d1 9 ?is "o in/ance1 z univ]sally ! ,engli% public has res5t$ x4 ,b g5]ally1 z a writ]1 ,i admire ,"l ,or=d 9 a v high degree4 ,z a lett]-writ]1 & z a brilliant sket*] ( social aspects & situations1 he is f> sup]ior to any ,fr5* au?or :o c\ld possibly be nam$ z a competitor4 ,& z a writ] ( p]sonal or anecdotic hi/ory1 let ! read] turn to ,voltaire's ',sicle de ,l\is ,quatorze1' 9 ord] to appreciate 8 extraord9>y m]it4 99 99 99 99 99 ,next w occur to ! read] ! =g]y ( ',junius4' ,:o did t8 ,oh1 villa9s t h ev] d\bt$ s9ce ',junius ,id5tifi$'6 ,oh1 scamps--oh1 pitiful scamps6 ,y1 read]1 p]haps belong to ?is wret*$ corps4 ,b1 if s1 und]/& t y belong to x "u false in=mation4 ,i h he>d myriads talk ^u ?is subject4 ,"o man said to me1 ',my de> fri5d1 ,i sympa?ize ) y\r fury4 ,y are "r4 ,right] a man _c be4 ,righte/ ( all m5 y are4' ,i 0 "r--right]--righte/6 ,t _h happ5$ to few m54 ,b aga9 ?is flatt]+ man w5t on1 ',yes1 my excell5t fri5d1 "r y are1 & evid5tly ,sir ,philip ,francis 0 ! man4 ,8 back] prov$ x4 ,! day aft] 8 book appe>$1 if any man _h (f]$ me exactly two ?\s& to "o 9 gu9eas1 t ,sir ,philip 0 n ! man1 by ,jupit]6 ,i w\ld h decl9$ ! bet4 ,s div9e1 s exquisite1 s ,grecian 9 its p]fection1 0 ! demon/ration1 ! apodeixis 7or :at d y call x 9 ,greek871 t ?is brilliant ,sir ,philip--:o1 by ! way1 wore 8 ord] ( ! ,ba? z univ]sally z ev] he tax$ ,sir ,william ,drap] ) do+--_h be5 ! au?or ( ,junius4 ,b "h lay ! p]plexity ( ! matt]4 ,at ! lea/ five-&-tw5ty excell5t m5 prov$ by po/hum\s fri5ds t !y1 e "m's son ( !m1 _h also p]petrat$ ,junius4' ',!n !y 7 li>s1' ,i answ]$4 ',oh no1 my "r fri5d1' he int]rupt$1 'n li>s at all2 amiable m51 "s ( :om confess$ on _! dea?-b$s 7?ree to my c]ta9 k7 t1 alas6 !y _h err$ aga9/ ! law ( *>ity4 ,b h[8 said ! cl]gyman4 ,:y1 by t inf]nal magaz9e ( sne]s & all un*>itabl5ess1 ! ',lett]s ( ,junius4' ,let me und]/& y1 said ! cl]gyman3 y wrote ',junius'8 ,alas6 ,i did1 repli$ ,a4 ,two ye>s aft] ano!r cl]gyman said to ano!r p5it5t1 ,& s y wrote ',junius'8 ,too true1 my de> sir4 ,alas6 ,i did1 repli$ ,b4 ,"o ye> lat] a ?ird p5it5t 0 go+ (f1 & ^u ! cl]gyman say+1 ,bless me1 is x possible8 ,did y write ',junius'8 he repli$1 ,ah1 wor%ipful sir1 y t\* a pa9ful *ord 9 my remembrances--,i n[ wi% ,i _h n4 ,alas6 rev]5d sir1 ,i did4 ,n[1 y see1' w5t on my fri5d1 's _m m5 at ! ,new ,drop1 z y may say1 hav+ ) te>s & groans tax$ !mselves ) ,junius z ! climax ( _! (f5ces1 "o beg9s to ?9k t p]haps all m5 wrote ,junius4' ,well1 s f> !re 0 reason4 ,b :5 my fri5d cont5d$ also t ! pro(s array$ 9 pamphlets prov$ ! :ole alphabet to h writt5 ',junius1' ,i c\ld n /& 8 absurdities4 ,dea?-b$ confessions1 ,i admitt$1 7 /rong4 ,b z to ^! wret*$ pamphlets1 "s "t or o!r ,i w mu/] !m all = a field-day2 ,i w brigade !m1 z if ! g5]al ( ! di/rict 7 com+ to review !m2 & !n1 if ,i d n m[ !m d[n to ! la/ man by op5+ a trea*]\s batt]y ( grape-%ot1 may all my h\sehold die "u a fi]c] ,junius6 ,! true reasons :y any man fancies t ',junius' is an op5 "q mu/ be ^! ?ree3 ,fir/1 t !y h nev] read ! pro(s array$ aga9/ ,sir ,philip ,francis2 ?is is ! g5]al case4 ,secondly1 t1 accord+ to ,san*o's prov]b1 !y want bett] bread ?an is made ( :eat4 ,!y are n cont5t ) pro(s or absolute demon/rations4 ,!y require y1 l ! wit* ( ,endor1 to raise ,sir ,philip f ! grave1 t !y may cross-exam9e him4 ,?irdly 7& ?is is ! fault ( ! able writ] :o unmask$ ,sir ,philip71 !re happ5$ to be ! /ronge/ argum5t t ev] pick$ a ,bramah-lock aga9/ ! unkn[n writ] ( ',junius'2 apply ?is1 & if x fits ! w>ds1 oh1 ,gem9i6 my de> fri5d1 b y are "r--right]--righte/2 y h caught ',junius' 9 a rabbit-sn>e4 ,,footnotes3 #ah ',six ?\s& p] annum1' viz41 on ! au?ority ( 8 own confession to ,p9k]ton4 ,,editor',s ,,note4--,de ,qu9cey is guilty ( a slight lapse ( memory 9 ref]5ce to ',! ,ca/le ( ,otranto' & ,onuphrio ,muralto4 ,x 0 n 9 ! fir/ s5t5ce ( ! preface1 b on ! title-page1 t ,walpole s pla9ly attribut$ ! "w to ano!r4 ,! orig9al title-page1 :i*1 ( c\rse1 0 dropp$ out :5 x became kn[n to all ! _w t ,walpole 0 ! au?or1 read ?us3 ',! ,ca/le ( ,otranto3 a ,/ory4 ,translat$ by ,william ,m>%all1 ,g5t4 ,f ! orig9al ,italian ( ,onuphrio ,muralto1 ,canon ( ! ,*ur* ( ,/4 ,ni*olas1 at ,otranto4 ,london3 pr9t$ = ,?omas ,l[nds1 9 ,fleet ,/reet4 #agfe4' ,,xv4 ,,daniel ,o',,connell4 ,) a s+le view to ! intellectual pret5sions ( ,mr4 ,o',connell1 let u turn to 8 late/ ,g5]al ,epi/le1 dat$ f ',conciliation ,hall1' on ! la/ day ( ,octob]4 ,?is is no r&om1 or 7to use a p$antic t]m7 p]functory docum5t2 n a docum5t is ?is to :i* indulg5ce is due4 ,by its subject1 n less ?an by its address1 x /&s =? audaci\sly z a delib]ate1 z a solemn1 z a national /ate pap]2 = its subject is ! future political condition ( ,irel& "u ! assumption ( ,repeal2 = its address is1 ',to ! ,p ( ,irel&4' ,s plac+ himself1 a writ] has x n )9 8 *oice to play ! fool2 x is n )9 8 compet5ce to tumble or 'come al(t' or play antics z a m\ntebank2 8 !me b9ds him to dec5cy1 8 audi5ce to gravity4 ,speak+1 ?\gh x be b by ! w9die/ ( fictions1 to a nation1 is n a man pl$g$ to respectful language8 speak+1 ?\gh x is b by a *im]a z wild z ,repeal to a "q ( national welf>e1 a man is pl$g$ to s9c]ity4 ,_h he sev5 devils ( mock]y & bant] )9 him1 = t h\r he mu/ sil5ce !m all4 ,! f\l fi5d mu/ be rebuk$1 ?\gh x 7 ,mahu & ,bohu :o %\ld prompt him to buffoon]y1 :5 /&+ at ! b> ( nations4 ,?is is ! law1 ?is ! condition1 "u :i* ,mr4 ,o',connell 0 speak+ :5 he issu$ t rec5t address4 ,giv5 su* a case1 simil> circum/ances presuppos$1 he c\ld n evade ! obligations :i* !y impose4 ,f su* obligations !re is no disp5sation to be b\ght--no1 n at ,rome2 f ! obligations obs]ve1 & ^? obligations1 we repeat1 are--s9c]ity 9 ! fir/ place1 & respectful or def]5tial language 9 ! second4 ,su* 7 ! duties2 n[ let u look to ! p]=mance4 ,& t we may judge ( t ) m advantage = se>*+ & apprais+ ! qualities ( ?is docum5t1 p]mit u to sugge/ ?ree sep>ate que/ions1 ! fir/ be+ ?is3 ,:at 0 ! occasion ( ! ,address8 ,secondly1 :at 0 its o/5sible object8 ,?irdly1 :at are ! argum5ts by :i*1 z its means1 ! pap] travels t[>ds t object8 ,fir/1 z to ! occasion ( ! ,address4 ,we h said t ! date1 viz41 ! #ca/ ( ,octob]1 is falsifi$4 ,x 0 n dat$ on ! #ca/ ( ,octob]1 b on or ab\t ! sev5? day ( ,novemb]4 ,ev5 t falsehood1 ?\gh at fir/ sight trivial1 is en\gh = suspicion4 ,if ,x1 a kn[n li>1 utt]s a lie at />t+1 x is n = him to plead 9 mitigation ! app>5t uselessness ( ! lie1 x is = u to presume out ( ! fact a use1 :]e ! fact exi/s4 ,a lead] 9 ! ,fr5* ,revolution prote/$ (t5 aga9/ blood%$ & o!r atrocities--n z be+ too bad1 b1 on ! contr>y1 z be+ too good1 too preci\s to be wa/$ ^u ord9>y occasions4 ,&1 on ! same pr9ciple1 we may be sure t any habitual li>1 :o has long f\nd ! b5efit ( falsehoods at 8 utmo/ ne$1 w h =m$ too pr(\nd a rev]5ce = ?is p[]ful res\rce 9 a mom5t ( p]plexity ev] to ?r[ away a falsehood1 or to squ&] ^u a caprice ( ! mom5t t lie :i*1 be+ seasonably employ$1 might h sav$ him f confusion4 ,! arti/ 9 ly+ is n ! man to lie gratuit\sly4 ,f ! fir/1 !re=e1 satisfi$ ourselves t !re 0 a lurk+ motive--! key to ?is falsification ( date--we paus$ to se>* x out4 ,9 t we f\nd little difficulty4 ,= :at 0 ! pr(ess$ object ( ?is ,address8 ,x 0 to meet & to ov]?r[ two notions "h repres5t$ z great popul> errors4 ,b :y at ?is "t8 ,:]e=e all ?is heat at ! pres5t mom5t8 ,grant t ! propositions d5\nc$ z errone\s 7 s 9 v de$1 :y %\ld crim9als /&+ "u ! %ad[ ( public v5geance ready to desc5d1 s *ildi%ly misuse ! int]val1 m]cifully all[$ = _! own def5ce1 9 read+ lectures ^u ab/ract political speculations1 confess$ly be>+ no relation to any militant int]e/ n[ 9 "q8 ,q z imp]t95t x w\ld be1 :5 call$ ^u = ! answ] ^u ',guilty or n ,guilty8' to read a section f ! ,c\ncil ( ,tr5t1 or a rescript f ,c>d9al ,bell>m9e4 ,yet ! m extravagant 0 ! logic ( ?is proce$+1 ! m urg5t became ! presumption ( a cov]t motive1 & t motive we soon saw to be ?is4 ,let ! read] weigh x1 & ! good s5se ( ! man :o at su* a mom5t c\ld suff] su* a motive to prevail4 ,?us x is3 :5 ,clont>f 0 int]cept$1 & implicitly1 ?\gh n =mally1 all simil> meet+s 7 by t "o act = ev] prohibit$1 ! fir/ days ( t]ror 7 naturally occupi$ ) ! panic ( ! conspirators1 & 9 provid+ = _! p]sonal t]rors4 ,b :5 ! du/ ( ?is great upro> began to settle1 & objects aga9 became di/+ui%able 9 natural daylight1 ! fir/ consequ5ce :i* /ruck ! affright$ m5 ( ! conspiracy 0 ! *ill+ effect ( ! ,gov]nm5t policy ^u ! ,o',connell r5t2 n ! weekly r5t1 appli$ nobody kn[s h[1 b ! annual r5t appli$ to ,mr4 ,o',connell's private b5efit4 ,?is 0 9 jeop>dy1 & on ! foll[+ argum5t3 ,orig9ally ?is r5t _h be5 levi$ z a comp5sation to ,mr4 ,o',connell 9 8 "* ( ,iri% b>ri/]--n = s]vices r5d]$ or to be r5d]$1 b = curr5t s]vices cont9ually be+ r5d]$ 9 ,p>liam5t f session to session1 = exp5ses incid5t to t k9d ( duty1 & also z an indemnification = ! consequ5t loss ( fees at ! ,iri% ,b>4 ,yet n[1 9 #ahdc1 hav+ ceas$ to att5d 8 duty 9 ,p>liam5t1 ,mr4 ,o',connell c\ld no long] claim 9 t s5atorial "*4 ,su* a pret5sion w\ld be too gross = ! und]/&+ ev5 ( a ,connaught peasant4 ,& 9 t !re 0 a great loss4 ,= ! allegation ( a ,p>liam5t>y w>f>e1 "u ! vague idea ( pu%+ =w>d good bills = ,irel&1 or ret>d+ bad ones1 _h be5 a pleasant & easy lab\r to ! p>i% prie/s4 ,x 0 n necess>y to horse:ip#ai _! flocks too sev]ely4 ,if all 0 n cle> to 'my *ildr5's' und]/&+1 at lea/ my *ildr5 _h no mut9\s demur 9 a positive %ape ready = s]vice4 ,recusants !re 71 & /urdy ones1 b !y c\ld put no face on _! guilt1 & _! s9 0 n contagi\s4 ,unhappily1 f ?is indef9ite condition ( m]it ,mr4 ,o',connell himself _h translat$ 8 claim to a v di/9ct "o f\nd$ ^u a cle>1 kn[n1 absolute attempt to co]ce ! ,gov]nm5t into passive collusion ) prospective treason4 ,?is attempt1 said ! peasantry1 w ! ,gov]nm5t /&1 or w x n8 ',:y1 !n1' repli$ ! ,gov]nm5t1 on ! #ag? ( ,octob]1 'we w n4' ,! ari/ocracy ( ,irel& may n h done _! duty z reg>ds ! ,repeal2 x is too c]ta9 t !y h n1 because !y h done no?+ at all4 ,b x is also c]ta9 t _! v utt]mo/ w\ld h be5 unavail+ = "o pr9cipal object conc]n$4 ,o!r great objects1 h[ev]1 might h be5 atta9$4 ,=eign nations might h be5 disabus$ ( _! silly delusions on ! ,iri% relations to ,engl&1 al?\gh ! ,iri% peasantry c\ld n4 ,! mon/r\s impression also ^u _m ,engli% & ,scot* p>ties1 t a g5]al unity ( s5tim5t prevail$ 9 ,irel& z to ! desirabl5ess ( an indep5d5t ,p>liam5t--?is1 ?is1 we say l\dly1 w\ld h be5 dissipat$1 _h e ,iri% c\nty met by its g5try disav[+ & abom9at+ all s5tim5ts t5d+ t[>ds a purpose s guilty z political disunion4 ,yet1 9 palliation ( ?is mo/ griev\s failure1 we1 9 ! _s ( p]fect c&\r1 w rem9d our read]s ( ! depress+ effect too (t5 att5d+ "o flagrant w\nd 9 any sy/em ( p[] or means4 ,let a man lose by a sudd5 bl[--by fire1 by %ipwreck1 or by comm]cial failure--a sum ( tw5ty ?\s& p\nds1 t be+ f\r-fif?s ( 8 entire prop]ty1 h[ (t5 x is f\nd t m]e dejection ( m9d w incapacitate him f look+ *e]fully aft] ! rema9+ fif?6 ,& ?is ?\gh x is n[ become f> m ess5tial to 8 welf>e2 &1 secondly1 ^u a motion t5d+ upw>ds & n d[nw>ds1 he w\ld h reg>d$ five ?\s& p\nds z a preci\s treasure wor?y ( 8 ef=ts1 :e!r = protection or = improvem5t4 ,some?+ analog\s to ?is weighs d[n ! he>ty ex]tions ( ! ,iri% g5try4 ,met at ! v ?re%old1 affront$ at />t+1 by ?is insuff]able tyranny ( prie/ly int]f]5ce--humiliat$ & /ung to ! he>t by ! consci\sness t ^? natural influ5ces :i* ev]y:]e else settle indefeasibly ^u prop]ty1 are 9 ,irel& int]cept$1 fil*$1 viol5tly robb$ & pocket$ by a body ( pr(essional nuisances sprung almo/ univ]sally f paup]s--?us dis9h]it$ ( _! prim>y rights1 ?us pillag$1 ?us %orn l ,samson ( ^? natural ornam5ts 9 :i* resid$ _! natural /r5g?1 feel+ !mselves 7l t same ,samson 9 ! language ( ,milton7 turn$ out to ! scorn ( _! c\ntrym5 z 'tame we!rs' ridicul\sly fleec$ & mutilat$--!y droop1 !y langui% z to all public _s2 & :il/ by temp]am5t1 by natural end[m5t1 by cont9ual int]c\rse ) ! noble ari/ocracy ( ,brita9 7f :om also !y are *iefly desc5d$71 !y %\ld be among/ ! lead+ *ivalries ( ,europe1 9 v fact !y are1 = political or social purposes1 ! mo/ p[]less g5try 9 exi/5ce4 ,act+ 9 a corporate capacity1 !y c d no?+4 ,! malignant planet ( ?is l[-born prie/hood comes betwe5 !m & ! peasantry1 eclips+ (t5times ! sun%9e ( _! compreh5sive b5efic5ce1 & always de/roy+ _! p[] to disc\nt5ance#bj evil-do]s4 ,"h is ! sad excuse4 ,b1 = all t1 we mu/ affirm t1 if ! ,iri% l&$ g5try d n yet come =w>d to retrieve ! gr\nd :i* !y h =feit$ by in]tia1 hi/ory w record !m z passive collud]s ) ! ,dubl9 repeal]s4 ,! evil is s op]atively deep1 look+ backw>d or =w>d1 t we h purposely br\ght x =w>d 9 a second aspect1 viz41 z contra/$ ) ! ,london press4 ,= ! "o1 z we h be5 %[+1 !re is a /rong plea 9 palliation2 = ! o!r !re is none4 ,let u be frank4 ,?is is :at we affirm1 t x 01 x is1 x w be h]eaft]1 )9 ! p[]s ( ! ,london press to h ext+ui%$ ! ,repeal or any simil> agitation2 !y c\ld h done ?is1 & ?is !y h n done4 ,b let u also n be misund]/ood4 ,d we say ?is 9 a _s ( disrespect8 ,are we among/ ! p>ties :o 7:5 *>act]iz+ ! ,am]ican press7 infam\sly say1 ',let u1 h[ev]1 look homew>ds to our own press1 & be sil5t = v %ame'8 ,are we ! p to jo9 ! vici\s correspond5t ( an ev5+ pap] :om b a week ago we saw d5\nc+ ! editor ( ! ,exam9] newspap] z a public nuisance1 & recomm5d+ him z a fit subject ( "s degrad+ puni%m5t1 = no bett] reason ?an t he _h ex]cis$ 8 und\bt$ "r ( expos+ del9qu5cies or follies 9 a g>rul\s "l8 ,f> be su* vil5esses f u4 ,we hon\r ! press ( ?is c\ntry4 ,we "k its con/itution1 & we "k ! m]e impossibility 77 x only f ! great capital requir$7 t any b m5 ( hon\r & s5sibilities & conspicu\s tal5t1 & m5 brilliantly accompli%$ 9 po9t ( education1 %\ld become writ]s or editors ( a lead+ j\rnal1 or inde$ ( any daily j\rnal4 ,"h & !re may float 9 gurgite va/o "s atroci\s pap] l5d+ itself ^u sy/em to ! villa9ies ( private sl&]4 ,b su* a pap] is sure to be an inconsid]able "o 9 ! m]e s5se ( prop]ty1 & !re=e1 by a logical consequ5ce 9 our frame ( society1 e way inconsid]able--ris+ )\t ef=t1 s9k+ )\t notice4 ,9 fact1 ! :ole /aff & e/abli%m5t ( newspap]s h ris5 9 social consid]ation )9 our own g5]ation2 & at ?is mom5t n m]ely proprietors & editors1 b report]s & o!r m9i/]ial ag5ts to ^! va/ eng9es ( civility1 h all asc5d$ 9 _! sup]ior ord]s to ! highe/ levels ( au!ntic responsibility4 ,we make ^! ackn[l$gm5ts 9 ! m]e _s ( equity1 & because we disda9 to be conf\nd$ ) ^? ra% p]sons :o talk glibly ( a 'lic5ti\s press' ?r\gh _! own lic5ti\s ignorance4 ,?an ignorance no?+ is s lic5ti\s = ra% say+ or = ob/9ate d5y+4 ,! ,briti% press is n lic5ti\s2 nei!r 9 ,london nor 9 ,ed9burgh is x ev] lic5ti\s2 & !re is mu* ne$ t x %\ld be o!rwise1 hav+ at ?is "t s unlimit$ a p[] ov] ! public m9d4 ,b ! v uprightness ( ! lead+ j\rnali/s1 & all ! o!r elem5ts ( _! p[]1 d b con/itute ! evil1 d b aggravate ! mis*ief1 :]e !y happ5 to g a/ray2 yes1 9 e case :]e ^! j\rnali/s miss ! n>r[ pa? ( ?\ghtful prud5ce4 ,!y d miss x occasionally2 !y mu/ miss x2 & we cont5d t !y h miss$ x at pres5t4 ,:at !y h done t !y ought n to h done4 ,curr5cy1 buoyancy1 !y ought n to h impress$ ^u s$ition1 ^u conspiracy1 ^u treason4 ,curr5cy1 buoyancy1 !y h impress$ ^u s$ition1 ^u conspiracy1 ^u treason4 ,z to ,mr4 ,o',connell himself1 x is useless1 & x argues "s ?ick d>kness ( m9d1 to remon/rate or g5]ally to address any argum5ts f :atsoev] qu>t]1 :i* ei!r appeal to a s5se ( tru?1 :i*1 secondly1 manife/ inconsi/5cies1 or1 ?irdly1 :i* argue !re9 a t5d5cy ru9\s to himself4 ,let u ?9k4 ,burke ass]t$ ( himself1 & to our belief truly1 t hav+ at diff]5t p]iods set 8 face 9 diff]5t directions--n[ to ! ea/1 n[ to ! we/1 n[ po9t+ to purposes ( relaxation or lib]ality1 n[ aga9 to purposes ( co]cive & popul> re/ra9t--he _h not)/&+ be5 uni=m1 if measur$ ^u a high] scale4 ,transc5d+ objects1 co9cid+ nei!r in/antly ) ! fir/1 nor except by accid5t ) ! la/1 b indiff]5tly aid$ by ari/ocratic =ces or by democratic1 %ift+ weights :i* sometimes call$ = accessories ( gravity1 sometimes = subtraction1 mighty fluctuat+ :eels :i* sometimes ne$$ fly:eels to mod]ate or h>monize1 sometimes ne$$ concurr5t :eels to urge or aggravate _! impetus--^! 7 ! p[]s :i* he _h f\nd himself summon$ to calculate1 to *eck1 to support1 ! va/ algebraic equation ( gov]nm5t2 = ?is he _h /r5g!n$ sub/antially by app>5t contr>ieties ( policy2 & 9 a sy/em ( wat*-"w s exquisite z to v>y its f9e balances et]nally1 et]nally he _h consult$ by r$ress+ ! errors em]g5t1 by v>y+ ! poise 9 ord] t he might n v>y ! equipoise1 by correct+ inequalities1 or by =e/all+ extremes4 ,t 0 a man ( h]oic build1 & ( him x might be said at 8 dea?1 ',truly ?is man 0 a son ( ,anak4' ,n[1 ( ,mr4 ,o',connell a man might affirm some?+ simil>2 t z ) reg>d to ,edmund ,burke x is altoge!r useless to detect contradictions 9 =m1 see+ t he kn[s ( ?is1 t he ju/ifies ?is1 glories 9 ?is1 vehem5tly dem&s praise = ?is contradiction1 z all discord is h>mony n und]/ood1 plann$ 9 ! lett] & ov]rul$ 9 ! _s2 s may ,o',connell say1 ',g5tlem51 grubs1 reptiles1 v]m91 tr\ble n y\rselves to f9d out contradictions or discords 9 my conduct2 vex n y\r sl5d] faculties by array+ ho/s ( promises t defeat promises1 or pr9ciples t de/roy pr9ciples--y %all n ne$ to lab\r2 ,i w make y a pres5t ( ?ree huge cani/]s lad5 & runn+ ov] ) ! flatte/ d5ials 9 "o brea? ( t :i* ,i affirm$ 9 ano!r4 ,b1 l ,edmund ,burke1 ,i regi/] my conduct by ano!r table & by its f9al result4 ,on ! dial :i* y see1 ! h&s po9t ?us & ?us2 b ^u a high] & transc5d5t dial ^! f+]s d b precipitate or ret>d "o gigantic h&1 po9t+ always & monoton\sly to ! unity ( a p]fect selfi%ness4 ,! ev]la/+ tack+ 9 my c\rse gives me (t5 ! air ( retrograd+ & los+2 b1 9 fact1 ^! retrogressions are mom5t>y1 ^! los+s ( my object are no m ?an seem+1 are /ill b ! same /eal?y creep+ up "u cov] ( frequ5t compliances ) ! breeze t happ5s to ?w>t me1 t[>ds ! "o et]nal pole ( my own self-int]e/2 t is ! pole-/> :i* only nev] sets1 & ,i flatt] myself t amid/ va/ app>5t w&]+s or multipli$ div]g5ces !re w be detect$ by ! eye ( ! philosoph] a consi/5cy 9 family objects :i* is absolute1 a div9e unity ( selfi%ness4' ,?is we d n "q4 ,b to w is n to d2 & ,mr4 ,o',connell1 ) a true loyalty to 8 "o object ( private aims1 has n ma9ta9$ ! consi/5cy ( 8 policy4 ,all m5 "k t he has adv5tur$ )9 ! limits ( conspiracy2 t c\ld n be = 8 b5efit4 ,he has t\*$ ev5 ! d>k p5umbra ( treason2 t c\ld n b risk ! sum ( 8 o!r /riv+s4 ,b he :o has fail$ = himself 9 a /rife s absolute1 = t only mu/ be di/ru/$ by 8 c\ntrym54 ,,footnotes3 #ai ',to horse:ip1' etc4 ,let x n be said t ?is is any sl&] ( ours2 w\ld t we c\ld pron\nce x a sl&]6 ,b ^? :o 7l ourselves7 h visit$ ,irel& ext5sively "k t ! p>i% prie/ uses a horse:ip1 9 _m circum/ances1 z 8 pr(essional insigne4 #bj ,look at ,"l ,wat]=d's case1 9 ! v mon? ( ,novemb]1 #ahdc4 ,is !re a c\nty 9 all ,engl& t w\ld h tamely witness$ 8 expulsion f among/ !m by fire1 & by sword & by poison8 ,,note ,,by ,,! ,,editor4--,?is article on ,o',connell1 writt5 9 ! end ( #ahdc1 is pr9t$1 n on acc\nt ( any political ref]5ce x might be presum$ to h1 b only because ( its hi/orical & lit]>y int]e/4 ,ap>t f ! light x may ?r[ on ,de ,qu9cey's lean+s1 z1 9 c]ta9 respects1 di/9ctly 9 ! direction ( patriotic ,toryism ( ! mo/ rampant type1 x may be ( value z sugge/+ h[ ess5tially1 9 n a few po9ts1 ! ,iri% "q to-day rema9s precisely z x 0 9 ! "t ( ,o',connell2 & h[ ! ,tories ( to-day are apt to view x f precisely ! same plane z ^? ( #ahdc4 ,x might also be cit$ z ano!r pro( n only ( ,de ,qu9cey's v ke5 int]e/ 9 all ! lead+ que/ions ( ! "t1 b z an illu/ration ( ! ,john ,bull w>m? & heat :i* he1 ! dream]1 ! recluse1 ! lov] ( ab/ract problems1 c\ld br+ into su* discussions4 ,"h1 at all ev5ts1 8 views 7 def9ite en\gh1 & /at$ ) a bold precision ( ,engli% pla9ness t w\ld h pleas$ ! mo/ pron\nc$ly ,tory or ,unioni/ newspap] editors ( t day4 ,,xvi4 ,,france ,,pa/ ,,& ,,france ,,pres5t4 ,to speak 9 ! simplicity ( tru?1 c>+ n = p>ty or p>tisan1 is n ! ,france ( ?is day1 ! ,france :i* has issu$ f t great furnace ( ! ,revolution1 a bett]1 happi]1 m hopeful ,france ?an ! ,france ( #aghh8 ,all[+ = any evil1 pres5t or rev]sion>y1 9 ! political aspects ( ,france1 t may yet give cause = anxiety1 c a wise man d5y t f ! ,france ( #ahdj1 "u ,l\is ,philippe ( ,orleans1 asc5ds to heav5 a report ( f> happi] days f ! sons & daught]s ( pov]ty ?an f ! ,france ( ,l\is ,,xvi48 ,p]sonally t sixte5? ,l\is 0 a good k+1 sorr[+ = ! abuses 9 ! l&1 & will+ 7at lea/1 aft] affliction _h %>p5$ 8 reflect+ consci5ce71 _h t *oice be5 all[$ him1 to h r$eem$ !m by any p]sonal sacrifice4 ,b t 0 n possible4 ,c5turies ( misrule are n ransom$ by an individual ru92 & _h x be5 possible t ! d>k g5ius ( 8 family1 ! same :o once toll$ fun]al knells 9 ! e>s ( ! fir/ ,b\rbon1 & call$ him out z a m>tyr hurry+ to meet 8 own sacrifice--c\ld we suppose ?is gloomy repres5tative ( 8 family de/9ies to h met him 9 "s solit>y ap>tm5t ( ! ,tuil]ies or ,v]sailles1 "s twilight gall]y ( ance/ral portraits1 he c\ld h met him ) ! purpose ( rais+ ! curta9 f be=e ! long s]ies ( 8 h\sehold woes--f him ! k+ w\ld h le>n$ t no p]sonal ransom c\ld be accept$ = misgov]nm5t s anci5t4 ,levia?an is n s tam$4 ,arre>s s va/ imply a correspond+ acc\ntability1 correspond+ by its am\nt1 correspond+ by its p]sonal subjects4 ,cr[n & p--all _h err$2 all mu/ suff]4 ,blood mu/ fl[1 te>s mu/ be %$ ?r\gh a g5]ation2 riv]s ( lu/ration mu/ be ?r[n ?r\gh t ,augean accumulation ( guilt4 ,& exactly !re1 x is suppos$1 lay ! error ( ,burke2 ! compass ( ! p5alty1 ! ar* :i* x trav]s$1 mu/ be> "s proportion to t ( ! evil :i* _h produc$ x4 ,:5 ,i ref]r$ to ! d>k g5ius ( ! family :o once toll$ fun]al knells 9 ! e>s ( ! fir/ ,b\rbon1 ,i meant1 ( c\rse1 ! fir/ :o sat ^u ! ?rone ( ,france1 viz41 ,h5ri ,quatre4 ,! allusion is to ! la/ h\rs ( ,h5ry's life1 to ! rem>kable prophecies :i* =]an 8 dea?1 to _! rem>kable fulfilm5t1 & 7:at is m rem>kable ?an all beside7 to 8 self-surr5d]1 9 ! _s ( an unresi/+ victim1 to a bloody fate :i* he reg>d$ z inexorably doom$4 ,?is k+ 0 n ! good pr9ce :om ! ,fr5* hold out to u2 n ev5 ! accompli%$1 ! *ivalr\s1 ! elevat$ pr9ce to :om hi/ory po9ts = "o ( h] models4 ,fr5* & ultra-,fr5* mu/ h be5 ! ideal ( ! good or ! noble to :i* he c\ld h approximat$ 9 ! e/imate ( ! mo/ ?\ghtless4 ,he _h t sort ( milit>y c\rage :i* 01 & is1 m common ?an we$s4 ,9 all else he 0 a l[-m9d$ man1 vulg> 9 8 ?\ghts1 mo/ unpr9cely 9 8 habits4 ,he 0 ev5 worse ?an t3 wick$1 brutal1 s5sually cruel4 ,& 8 wick$ m9i/]1 ,sully1 ?an :om a m s]vile m9d nev] exi/$1 illu/rates 9 "o passage 8 own "* & 8 ma/]'s by ! apology :i* he (f]s = ,h5ry's hav+ notori\sly left _m illegitimate *ildr5 to p]i% ( hung]1 toge!r ) _! too-confid+ mo!rs4 ,:at8 ,t 9 ! pressure ( bus9ess he really =got !m4 ,fam9e mock$ at la/ ! deadlie/ (f5ce4 ,8 own innoc5t *ildr51 up & d[n ,france1 because !y 7 illegitimate1 _! too-confid+ mo!rs1 because !y 7 weak & fri5dless by hav+ = 8 sake =feit$ ! fav\r ( ,god & man1 ?is amiable k+ _h left to p]i% ( hung]4 ,!y did p]i%2 "m & infant4 ,a cry asc5d$ aga9/ ! k+4 ,ev5 9 s5sual ,france su* atrocities c\ld n utt]ly s9k to ! gr\nd4 ,b :at says ! apologetic m9i/]8 ,a/oni%$ t anybody c\ld ?9k ( abridg+ a k+'s lic5se 9 su* p>ticul>s1 he bru%es away ! :ole *>ge z s mu* ung5tlemanly imp]t95ce1 disda9+ any fur!r plea ?an ! pressure ( bus9ess1 :i* s naturally acc\nt$ = ! royal inatt5tion or =getfulness 9 ^! little affairs4 ,obs]ve t ?is pressure ( bus9ess nev] 0 su* t ! k+ c\ld n f9d "t = pursu+ ^! intrigues & multiply+ ^! rev]sions ( woe4 ,:at enormities6 ,a k+ 7at all times ( ,nav>re1 & = half 8 life ( ,france7 suff]s 8 *ildr5 to die ( hung]1 consigns _! mo!rs to ! same fate1 b aggravat$ by remorse & by ! spectacle ( _! p]i%+ infants6 ,^! clam\rs c\ld n p5etrate to ! ,l\vre1 b !y p5etrat$ to a high] c\rt1 & 7 writt5 9 books f :i* !re is no erasure all[$4 ,s mu* = ! vaunt$ 'g5]osity' ( ,h5ry ,,iv4 ,z to ano!r feature ( ! *ivalr\s "*1 elegance ( mann]s1 let ! read] consult ! report ( an ,engli% ambassador1 a man ( hon\r & a g5tleman1 ,sir ,george ,c>ew4 ,x 0 publi%$ ab\t ! middle ( ! la/ c5tury by ! indefatigable ,bir*1 to :om our hi/oric lit]ature is s mu* indebt$1 & x proves suffici5tly t ?is idol ( ,fr5*m5 all[$ himself 9 habits s co>se z to disgu/ ! mo/ creep+ ( 8 own c\rti]s2 su* t ev5 ! blackgu>ds ( a manly nation w\ld revolt f !m z f\l & self-di%on\r+4 ,deep & p]man5t is ! mis*ief wr\ght 9 a nation by false models2 & correspond+ is ! impression1 immortal ! b5efit1 f good ones4 ,! ,engli% p h be5 ! bett] = _! ,alfr$1 t pa!tic ideal ( a good k+1 ?r\gh a space ( n[ ne>ly a ?\s& ye>s4 ,! ,fr5* are ! worse to ?is h\r 9 consequ5ce ( ,francis ,i4 & ,h5ry ,,iv4 ,& note ?is1 t ev5 ! spuri\s m]it ( ! two ,fr5* models c be su/a9$ only by disguises1 by suppressions1 by elaborate v>ni%+s2 :]eas ! ,engli% pr9ce is (f]$ to our admiration ) a ,scriptural simplicity & a ,scriptural fidelity1 n z "s gay leg5d ( romance1 "s ,telema*us ( ,fnelon1 b z "o :o _h err$1 suff]$1 & _h be5 purifi$2 z a %eph]d t _h gone a/ray1 & saw t ?r\gh 8 transgressions ! flock also _h be5 scatt]$4 ,,xvii4 ,,rome',s ,,recruits ,,& ,,engl&',s ,,recruits4 ,two facts on :i* a s\nd e/imate ( ! ,roman corn-trade dep5ds are ^!3 fir/1 ! v important "o1 t x 0 n ,rome 9 ! s5se ( ! ,italian p59sula :i* reli$ ^u =eign corn1 b 9 ! n>r[e/ s5se ,rome ! city2 z respect$ :at we n[ call ,lomb>dy1 ,flor5ce1 ,g5oa1 etc41 ,rome did n di/urb ! anci5t agriculture4 ,! o!r fact (f]s1 p]haps1 a /ill m important consid]ation4 ,rome 0 latt]ly a mo/ popul\s city--we are dispos$ to agree ) ,lipsius1 t x 0 f\r times z popul\s z mo/ mod]ns e/eem--mo/ c]ta9ly x bore a high] ratio to ! total ,italy ?an any o!r capital 7ev5 ,london7 has s9ce borne to ! t]ritory ov] :i* x presid$4 ,consequ5tly x w be argu$ t 9 su* a ratio mu/ ! =eign importations ( ,rome1 ev5 9 ! limit$ s5se ( ,rome ! city1 h op]at$ m de/ructively ^u ! dome/ic agriculture4 ,grant t n ,italy1 b ,rome1 0 ! ma9 import] ( =eign gra91 /ill1 if ,rome to all ,italy 7 z "o to f\r 9 population1 :i* !re is good reason to believe x 01 !n ev5 ^u t di/9ction x w be insi/$ t ! ,roman importation cru%$ "o-f\r? ( ! native agriculture4 ,n[1 ?is we d5y4 ,"s "p ( ! ,african & ,egyptian gra9 0 b a sub/itution = ! ,s>d9ian1 & s f> made no diff]5ce to ,italy 9 pl\ghs1 b only 9 d5>ii4 ,b ! ma9 consid]ation ( all is1 t ! ,italian gra9 0 n )drawn f ! va/ population ( ,rome--?is is n ! logic ( ! case--no2 on ! contr>y1 ! va/ population ( ,rome arose & sup]v5$ z a consequ5ce ^u ! op5+ ( ! =eign ,alex&rian corn trade4 ,x 0 n ,rome t quirt$ ! home agriculture4 ,rome1 9 ! full s5se1 nev] w\ld h exi/$ )\t =eign supplies4 ,if1 !re=e1 ,rome1 by means ( =eign gra91 rose f f\r hundr$ ?\s& heads to f\r millions1 !n x foll[s t 7except z to ! orig9al dem& = ! f\r hundr$ ?\s&7 n "o pl\gh 0 disus$ 9 ,italy t ev] _h be5 us$4 ,:il/1 ev5 ) reg>d to ! orig9al dem& ( ! f\r hundr$ ?\s&1 by s mu* ( ! ,egyptian gra9 z _h be5 a m]e sub/itution = ,s>d9ian no effect :atev] c\ld h foll[$ to ,italian agriculture4 ,"h1 !re=e1 we see ! _m limitations :i* arise to ! mod]n doctr9e ^u ! de/ructive agricultural consequ5ces ( ! ,roman corn trade4 ,rome may h prev5t$ ! ,italian agriculture f exp&+1 b %e c\ld n h caus$ x to decl9e4#ba ,n[1 let u see h[ f> ?is ,roman corn trade affect$ ! ,roman recruit+ s]vice4 ,x is alleg$ t agriculture decl9$ "u ! =eign corn trade1 & t = ?is reason pl\ghm5 decl9$4 ,b if we h %[n cause = d\bt+ :e!r agriculture decl9$1 or only did n increase1 !n we are at lib]ty to inf] t pl\ghm5 did n decl9e1 b only did n increase4 ,ev5 ( ! real & n imag9>y pl\ghm5 at any "t possess$ by ,italy1 too _m 9 ! s\? 7 slaves1 & !re=e ineligible = ! legion>y s]vice1 except 9 desp]ate inte/9e /ruggles l ! ,social w> or ! ,s]vile4 ,rome c\ld n lose = h] recruit+ s]vice any pl\ghm5 b ^? :om %e _h really possess$2 nor out ( ^? :om really %e possess$ any t 7 slaves2 nor out ( ^? :om 7n be+ slaves7 %e might h us$ = soldi]s c\ld x be said t %e 0 liable to any absolute loss except z to ^? :om ord9>ily %e did use z soldi]s1 & pref]r$ to use 9 circum/ances ( free *oice4 ,^! po9ts premis$1 we g on to say t no craze curr5t among/ le>n$ m5 has m deeply di/urb$ ! tru? ( hi/ory ?an ! notion t ',m>si' & ',peligni1' or o!r big-bon$ ,italian ru/ics1 ev] by *oice con/itut$ ! g5]al or ev5 ! fav\rite recruit+ fund ( ! ,roman republic4 ,9 ?\s&s ( books we h se5 x ass]t$ or assum$ t ! ,romans triumph$ s ext5sively *iefly because _! armies 7 compos$ ( ,roman or k9dr$ blood4 ,?is is false4 ,n ! mat]ial1 b ! milit>y sy/em1 ( ! ,romans 0 ! true key to _! a/oni%+ successes4 ,9 ! "t ( ,hannibal a ,roman consul reli$ *iefly1 x is true1 ^u ,italian recruits1 because he c\ld seldom look = m5 ( o!r blood4 ,& x is possible en\gh t ! same man1 ,fabius or ,m>cellus1 if he _h be5 s5t abroad z a proconsul1 might f9d 8 *oice ev5 !n 9 :at =m]ly _h be5 8 necessity4 ,9 "s respects x is probable t ! ,italian ru/ic ( true ,italian blood 0 at t p]iod ! be/ raw mat]ial#bb easily procur$ = ! legion>y soldi]4 ,b circum/ances alt]$2 z ! range ( w> exp&$ to ! ,ea/ x became f> too co/ly to recruit 9 ,italy2 nor1 if x _h be5 less co/ly1 c\ld ,italy h suppli$ ! wa/e4 ,above all1 ) ! advantages ( ! ,roman milit>y sy/em1 no p>ticul> physical mat]ial 0 requir$ = mak+ good soldi]s4 ,= ^! reasons x 0 t1 aft] ! ,levant 0 p]man5tly occupi$ by ! ,romans1 :]e any legion _h be5 orig9ally /ation$ !re x cont9u$ to be /ation$1 & !re x 0 recruit$1 &1 unless 9 "s r>e em]g5cy ( a critical w> aris+ at a di/ance1 !re x 0 s cont9ually recruit$1 t 9 ! lapse ( a g5]ation x conta9$ h>dly any ,roman or ,italian blood 9 its composition1 l ! ,attic %ip :i* _h be5 repair$ ) c$> until x reta9$ no fragm5t ( its orig9al oak4 ,?us1 ! legion /ation$ at ,antio* became entirely ,syrian2 t /ation$ at ,alex&ria1 ,grecian1 ,jewi%1 &1 9 a sep>ate s5se1 ,alex&r9e4 ,cs>1 x is notori\s1 rais$ "o entire legion ( ,gauls 7di/+ui%$ by ! cognizance ^u ! helmet ( ! l>k1 :5ce commonly call$ ! legion ( ! ,alauda74 ,b he recruit$ all 8 legions 9 ,gaul4 ,9 ,spa9 ! armies ( ,assanius & ,petreius1 :o surr5d]$ to ,cs> "u a conv5tion1 consi/$ *iefly ( ,spani>ds 7n ,hispani5ses1 or ,romans born 9 ,spa91 b ,hispani1 ,spani>ds by blood72 at ,ph>salia a l>ge "p ( ,cs>'s army 7 ,gauls1 & ( ,pompey's x is well kn[n t _m ev5 among/ ! legions conta9$ no ,europeans at all1 b 7z ,cs> seasonably rem9d$ 8 army7 consi/$ ( vagabonds f e "p ( ! ,ea/4 ,f all ?is we argue t ,s4,p4,q4,r4 did n dep5d latt]ly ^u native recruit+4 ,&1 9 fact1 !y did n ne$ to d s2 _! sy/em & discipl9e w\ld h made good soldi]s out ( mop-h&les1 if 7l ,lucian's magical mop-h&les7 !y c\ld only h le>n$ to m>* & to fill buckets ) wat] at ! ^w ( comm&4 ,we see1 too1 ! secret p[] & also ! secret political wisdom ( ,*ri/ianity 9 ano!r in/ance4 ,^? public l>gesses ( gra91 :i*1 9 old ,rome1 comm5c$ ^u pr9ciples ( ambition & ( facti\s enc\ragem5t to p>tisans1 9 ! new ,rome ( ,con/ant9ople 7 propagat$ = ages "u ! novel motive ( ,*ri/ian *>ity to paup]s4 ,?is practice has be5 condemn$ by ! :ole *orus ( hi/orians :o fancy t f ?is cause ! dome/ic agriculture langui%$1 & t a b\nty 0 giv5 ^u paup]ism4 ,b ^! are rev]ies ( lit]>y m54 ,t p>ticul> section ( rural indu/ry :i* langui%$ 9 ,italy1 did s by a reaction f r5t 9 ! sev]e mod]n s5se4 ,! gra9 import$ f ,s>d9ia1 f ,africa ! prov9ce1 & f ,egypt1 0 gr[n ^u soils less co/ly1 because ) equal co/ m productive4 ,! effect ^u ,italy f br++ back any consid]able portion ( ?is prov9cial corn-gr[?#bc to h] dome/ic di/ricts w\ld h be5 sudd5ly to develop r5t ^u a l>ge s]ies ( evils1 & to load ! prov9cial gra9 z well z ! home-gr[n--! *eap prov9cial z well z ! de> home-gr[n--) ! :ole diff]5ce ( ^! new co/s4 ,nei!r is ! policy ( ! case at all analog\s to our own at ! mom5t4 ,9 ?ree circum/ances x diff]s ess5tially3 ,fir/1 prov9ces are n =eign]s2 colonies are n enemies4 ,an exotic corn-trade c\ld n = ,rome d ! two great injuries :i* assur$ly x w\ld d = ,engl&2 x c\ld n transf] ! ma*9]y ( opul5ce to a ho/ile & rival /ate2 x c\ld n inve/ a jeal\s competitor ) p[] sudd5ly to cut (f supplies t _h gr[n into a necessity1 & ?us to create 9 "o mon? a fam9e or an insurrection4 ,egypt _h nei!r ! p[] nor any prospect ( ! p[] to act z an indep5d5t /ate t[>ds ,rome2 ! transf] to ,egypt ( ! ,roman agriculture1 suppos+ x to h be5 great] ?an x really 01 c\ld h op]at$ b l a transf] f ,norfolk to ,york%ire4 ,secondly1 z respect$ ,italy1 ! =eign gra9 did n ent] ! same m>kets z ! native4 ,ei!r "o or ! o!r w\ld h lo/ its advantage1 & ! natural b\nty :i* x enjoy$ f circum/ances1 by do+ s4 ,consequ5tly ! evils ( an artificial scale1 :]e gra9 rais$ "u "o set ( circum/ances fixes or modifies ! price = gra9 rais$ "u a diff]5t set ( circum/ances1 7 unkn[n 9 ! ,italian m>kets4 ,b ^! evils by a special ma*9]y1 viz41 ! ma*9]y ( good & bad seasons1 are aggravat$ = a mod]n /ate int5sely1 :5ev] %e dep5ds too mu* ^u ali5 /ores2 & specifically !y are aggravat$ by ! fact t bo? gra9s ent] ! same m>ket1 s t ! "o by too high a price is enc\rag$ unreasonably1 ! o!r by ! same price 7too l[ = opposite circum/ances7 is depress$ ru9\sly z reg>ds com+ ye>s2 :5ce 9 ! end two sets ( di/urbances--"o set frequ5tly f ! pres5t seasons1 & a second set f ! way 9 :i* ^! are made to act ^u ! future m>kets4 ,?irdly1 ! ,roman corn-trade did n ( necessity affect h] milit>y s]vice injuri\sly1 & = ?is reason1 t rural economy did n ( necessity langui% because agriculture langui%$ locally2 "s o!r culture1 z ( v9ey>ds1 oliveta1 or*>ds1 pa/ures1 replac$ ! decl9+ culture ( gra92 if pl\ghm5 7 few]1 o!r lab\r]s 7 m4 ,x is =gott51 besides1 t ! decl9e ( ,italian agriculture1 nev] m ?an local1 0 exce$+ly gradual2 = two hundr$ & fifty ye>s be=e ! ,*ri/ian era ,italy nev] _h dep5d$ exclusively ^u h]self4 ,s>d9ia & ,sicily1 at h] own doors1 7 h] gran>ies2 consequ5tly ! *ange nev] _h be5 t abrupt *ange :i* mod]n writ]s imag9e4 ,b let u indulge 9 ! luxury ( confirm+ :at we h said by ! light ( contra/4 ,suppose ! circum/ances *ang$1 suppose !m rev]s$1 & !n all ^? evil consequ5ce s\ght to take effect :i* 9 ! case ( ,rome we h d5i$4 ,n[1 x happ5$ t !y 7 rev]s$2 n1 inde$1 = ,rome1 :o _h be5 h]self ru9$ z metropolis ( ! ,we/ be=e ! effects ( a =eign corn-dep5d5ce c\ld unfold !mselves1 b = h] daught] & rival 9 ! ,ea/4 ,e>ly 9 ! sev5? c5tury1 ne> to ! v crisis ( ! ,hegira 7:i* dates f ! ,*ri/ian ye> #fbb71 ,con/ant9ople1 ,ea/]n ,rome1 sudd5ly became acqua9t$ ) ! panic ( fam9e4 ,9 "o h\r p]haps ?is *ange fell ^u ! imp]ial city1 &1 b = ! imp]ial gran>ies1 n ! panic ( fam9e1 b fam9e itself1 w\ld h surpris$ ! imp]ial city2 = ! sudd5ness ( ! calamity w\ld h all[$ no means ( se>*+ out or rais+ up a relief to x4 ,at t "t ! greate/ man :o ev] occupi$ ! *air ( ! ,ea/]n ,cs>s1 viz41 ,h]aclius1#bd 0 at ! head ( affairs4 ,b ! p]plexity 0 su* t no man c\ld face x4 ,on ! "o h& ,con/ant9e1 ! f\nd] ( ?is junior ,rome1 _h settl$ ^u ! h\ses ( ! city a claim = a weekly dim5sum ( gra94 ,^u ?is !y reli$2 s t d\bly ! ,gov]nm5t /ood pl$g$--fir/1 = ! importation ( corn t %\ld be suffici5t2 secondly1 = its di/ribution ^u t]ms z ne> to ^? ( ,con/ant9e z possible4 ,b1 on ! o!r h&1 ,p]sia 7! "o great /ation>y enemy ( ! empire7 _h 9 ! ye> #fah sudd5ly ov]run ,egypt2 gra9 became defici5t on ! banks ( ! ,nile--_h x ev5 be5 pl5tiful1 to s dete/$ an enemy x w\ld h be5 d5i$--& ?us1 )\t a mon?'s w>n+1 ! supply1 :i* _h n fail$ s9ce ! inauguration ( ! city 9 #ccj1 ceas$ 9 "o week4 ,! p ( ?is mighty city 7 press$ by ! heavie/ ( afflictions4 ,! emp]or1 "u false expectations1 0 tempt$ into mak+ engagem5ts :i* he c\ld n keep2 ! ,gov]nm5t1 at a p]iod :i* o!rwise & = _m ye>s to come 0 "o ( awful crisis1 became p>tially insolv5t2 ! %eph]d 0 di%on\r$1 ! flocks 7 ru9$2 & _h t ,p]sian armam5t :i* ab\t t5 ye>s lat] laid siege to ,con/ant9ople !n /ood at h] gates1 ! ,cross w\ld h be5 trampl$ on by ! fire-wor%ipp+ idolat]1 & ! b>b>\s ,av> w\ld h desolat$ ! walls ( ! glorifi$ ,cs> :o fir/ saw ,*ri/ m>*+ 9 ! van ( ,roman armies4 ,su* an iliad ( woes w\ld h exp&$ itself s]iatim1 & by a long procession1 f ! "o orig9al mis*ief ( dep5d+ = daily bread ^u ^? :o might sudd5ly become enemies or tools ( enemies4 ,engl&6 read 9 ! di/ress ( t great ,cs>1#be :o may ) propriety be call$ ! e>lie/ 7z he 0 ! mo/ prosp]\s7 ( ,crusad]s1 read 9 ! int]nal /ruggle ( 8 he>t--too consci\s t di%on\r _h settl$ ^u 8 purple--read 9 ! degradations :i* he trav]s$ z "s fi]y furnace 7yet n uns+$71 ! inevitable curses :i* await nations :o sacrifice1 = a mom5t>y conv5i5ce ( bread1 sacrifice = a loaf1 ! *>t] ( _! supremacy6 ,?is is lit]ally to fulfil ! ,scriptural case ( sell+ a bir?right = a mess ( pottage4 ,= ,engl& we may say ( ?is case--,transeat 9 exemplum6 ,great ,brita91 on ! contr>y1 is limit$ 9 h] recruit+-gr\nds by mod]n political relations z respects ,europe3 %e has =m$ an excell5t =eign corps long ago 9 ! ,m$it]ranean2 a ,hessian corps 9 ,am]ica2 an admirable ,hanov]ian legion dur+ ! late w>4 ,b circum/ances too (t5 prev5t h] rely+ 7z ! ,romans did7 on ! p]fection ( h] milit>y sy/em s f> z to disp5se ) native mat]ials2 except1 inde$1 9 ! ,ea/1 :]e ! ,roman pr9ciple is c>ri$ out to ! wide/ ext5t1 ne$+ only "o-t5? ( ,briti% by way ( model & inspiration "u circum/ances ( peculi> trial6 ,9 ,african /ations also1 9 ! ,we/ ,indies & on ! ,am]ican cont95t 7z 9 ,honduras71 ,engl& proce$s 7?\gh insuffici5tly7 ^u ?is f9e ,roman pr9ciple1 mak+ h] !ory1 h] discipl9e1 & ! network ( h] rules d ! "w ( h] own too co/ly h&s4 ,%e1 l ,rome1 f9ds ! b5efit ( h] f9e sy/em *iefly 9 ! disp5sation :i* x facilitates f work+ ) any exhau/ible fund ( means4 ,excell5t mu/ be t workman%ip :i* c af=d to be c>eless ab\t its mat]ials2 yet /ill--:]e naturally & ess5tially x mu/ be said t mat]iem sup]abat opus1 because "o section ( our m>tial s]vice moves by nautical soldi]s1 & ) respect to ! o!r half because x is necess>y to meet ,european troops by m5 ( ,briti% blood--we _c1 = ,european purposes1 look to any o!r di/ricts ?an our own native (fic9 ( population4 ,! ,life ,gu>ds 7#a/ regim5t7 & ! ,blues 7#bnd7 recruit *iefly1 or did s ?irty ye>s ago1 9 ,york%ire4 ,?is is a manufactur+ c\nty1 ?\gh 9 a mode ( manufactur+ :i* escapes _m evils ( ! factory sy/em4 ,& g5]ally we are little dispos$ p$antically to disp>age t[ns z funds ( a good soldi]y4 ,m5 ( mighty bone & !ws1 sons ( ,anak1 to our own c]ta9 k1 arise 9 ,k5dal1 ,wakefield1 ,brad=d & ,le$s2 huge m51 by ?\s&s1 among/ ! sp9n]s & weav]s ( ,glasg[1 ,paisley1 etc41 well able to fight _! way ?r\gh battalions ( clod-hopp]s ^: talk is ( ox54 ,b1 unless 9 times subject to special di/ress1 x is n s easy to tempt away ! weav] f 8 loom z ! delv] f 8 spade4 ,we believe ! reason to be1 t ! monotony ( a ru/ic life is m oppressive to ^? :o h limit$ res\rces ?an ! correspond+ monotony ( a t[n life4 ,= ?is reason1 & = _m o!rs1 x is c]ta9--& p]haps 7unless we get to fight+ ) /eam-m57 x w cont9ue to be c]ta9 ?r\gh c5turies--t1 = ! ma9 /aple ( h] armies & h] navies1 ,engl& mu/ dep5d ^u ! quality ( h] bold peasantry & noble yeomanry2 = we mu/ rememb] t1 ( ^? huge-limb$ m5 :o are f\nd 9 ! six nor!rn c\nties ( ,engl& & 9 ! ,scotti% ,l[l&s1 ( ^? elegantly-=m$ m5 :o are f\nd 9 ,devon%ire1 ,cornwall1 etc41 ( ^? h>dy m5 7a feature 9 human physics /ill m important7 :o are f\nd 9 e di/rict--if _m are n[ resid5t 9 t[ns1 mo/ ( !m orig9at$ 9 ru/ic life2 & f ru/ic life x is t ! res]voir ( t[ns is p]man5tly f$4 ,rome 01 ,engl& nev] w be1 indep5d5t ( h] rural population4 ,rome nev] _h a yeomanry1 ,rome nev] _h a race ( c\ntry g5tlem52 ,engl& has bo? ^u a scale s truly noble t x w be ! simple/ expression ( t nobility to say1 po9t+ to our villages1 ',behold ! cradle ( our army6' z inv]sely to say1 po9t+ to t army3 ',behold ! manhood ( our villages6' ,z reg>ds ,rome1 f ! bisection ( ! ,roman t]ritory into two sev]al corn di/ricts dep5d+ ^u a sep>ate agriculture1 x results t h] weal? c\ld n be defeat$ & transf]r$2 secondly1 x results f ! total subjection ( ,egypt1 t no emb>go c\ld be laid on ! h>ve/s ( ! ,nile1 & no fam9e c\ld be organiz$ aga9/ ,rome2 ?irdly1 x results t ! ,roman milit>y sy/em 0 ?us n liable to be affect$ by any dep5d5cy ^u =eign gra94 ,on ! argum5t t ?is dep5d5cy _h always be5 proce$+ gradually 9 ,italy1 s z virtually to reimburse itself by vic>i\s culture1 :]eas 9 ,engl& ! transition f indep5d5cy to dep5d5cy1 be+ accompli%$ 7if at all7 9 "o day by ,act ( ,p>liam5t1 w\ld be ru9\sly abrupt2 & also on ! argum5t ,b1 t ,rome1 if sl[ly los+ any recruit+ di/ricts at home1 f\nd comp5satory di/ricts all r\nd ! ,m$it]ranean1 :il/ ,engl& c\ld f9d no su* comp5satory di/ricts--we d5y t ! circum/ances ( ! ,roman corn trade h ev] be5 /at$ truly2 & we expect ! ?anks ( our read]s = draw+ _! att5tion to ?is outl9e ( ! po9ts :i* ess5tially diff]5c$ x f ! mod]n corn trade ( ,engl&4 ,engl& mu/1 b ,rome c\ld n1 reap f a =eign corn dep5d5cy3 fir/ly1 ru9\s di/urbance to ! natural expansions ( h] weal?2 secondly1 fam9e by int]vals = h] va/ population2 ?irdly1 impov]i%m5t to h] recruit+ s]vice4 ,^! are ! dreadful evils 7"s uni=m1 "s cont+5t7 :i* ,engl& w\ld inh]it ( h] native agriculture1 b :i* ,rome escap$ "u t p>tial transf]1 nev] really accompli%$4 ,meantime1 let ! read] rememb] t x is ,rome1 & n ,engl&--,rome hi/orically1 n ,engl& politically--:i* =ms ! object ( our exposure4 ,engl& is b ! means ( ! illu/ration4 ,9 our own days w>s 9 _! ebbs & fl[s are b ano!r "n = ! res\rces ( ! national ex*equ]1 or expressions ( its artificial facilities = turn+ ^? res\rces to acc\nt4 ,! great artifice ( anticipation appli$ to national income--an artifice sure to foll[ :]e civilization has exp&$1 & :i* w\ld h aris5 to ,rome _h h] civilization be5 ei!r 7,a7 completely develop$1 or 7,b7 exp&$ orig9ally f a true radix--has introduc$ a new era into national hi/ory4 ,! man :o1 hav+ _h prop]ty1 inve/s 9 ! ,funds1 & divides betwe5 8 gr&*ildr5 & ! five subsequ5t g5]ations :at w yield !m subsi/5ce1 is ! au?or ( an expansive improvem5t :i* has be5 enjoy$ by all 9 turn1 & ) m fix$ assurance 9 ! la/ case ?an 9 ! fir/4 ,he is a public b5efactor 9 m ways ?an appe>s on ! surface3 he takes ! mo/ effici5t gu>antees aga9/ ne$less w>s4 ,capta9 ,j5k9s's e>s#bf might h be5 r$eem$ at a less price2 b /ill ! w> taught a lesson1 :i*1 if avoidable at t in/ant1 0 c]ta9ly blamable2 b x _h its use 9 en=c+ on o!r nations ! conviction t ,engl& wa%$ out insult ) retribution1 & = e drop ( blood wantonly spilt dem&$ an ocean 9 return4 ,p]haps y w say ?is 0 no great improvem5t on ! old4 ,no2 n 9 appe>ance1 x may be2 b t 0 because w> _h to op5 a field :i* m]e diplomacy1 unsupport$ by ! sword1 c\ld n op51 & secur$ :at we may well call a moral result 9 ! eye ( ! :ole _w1 :i* diplomacy c\ld n secure 9 our guilty ,europe4 ,b 0 t1 y ask1 a condition to be contemplat$ ) complete satisfaction8 ,no2 nor is x "r t x %\ld4 ,b ! dawn ( a new era is approa*+1 = :i* t may h done its in/allm5t ( prep>ation4 ,n t w> w cease = _m g5]ations1 b t x w cont9ually move m 9 great] subjection to national laws & ,*ri/ian op9ion4 ,nev]more w x be excit$ by m]e c\rt intrigue1 or ev5 by m9i/]ial necessities4 ,no m w a qu>rel betwe5 two ladies ab\t a pair ( gloves1 or a fit ( ill-temp] 9 a pr9ce t[>d 8 m9i/]1 call =? ! dread sc\rge by way ( lett+ (f p]sonal irritation or r$ress+ ! balance ( p>ties4 ,fund+1 !re=e1 0 a great /ep 9 advance2 & ev5 already we h only to look into ! ,ex*equ] 9 ord] to read ! possibilities1 ! ebbs & fl[s ( w> be=eh&4 ,?is consid]ation ( money1 x is true--ev5 z ! s9ews ( w>--0 n s great 9 anci5t hi/ory4 ,& ! reason is evid5t4 ,k+s did n !n g to w> by money1 b = money4 ,!y did n look into ! ,ex*equ] = ! means ( a campaign1 b !y look$ into a campaign = ! means ( an ,ex*equ]4 ,yet ev5 9 ^! nations1 m ( _! hi/ory1 ( _! do+s & suff]+s1 lay 9 _! economy ?an any:]e else4 ,! great ,ori5tal phantoms1 su* z ! ,ph>aohs & ! ,s>gons1 did1 x is true1 br+ nations to w> )\t mu* m c>e = ! commiss>iat dep>tm5t ?an is giv5 9 ! battles ( ! ,kites & ,daws4 ,yet ev5 !re ! political economy made itself felt1 obscurely & indirectly x may be1 b really & effectively1 act+ by laws t v>i$ _! =ce r to ! eye ?an to ! und]/&+1 & pres5t$ inde$ a f9al re/ra9+ =ce to ^! k+s also4 ,= exam9e ^! w>s1 fabul\s z !y are2 look into ! :51 ! :5ce1 ! h[2 into ! duration ( ! campaigns1 into _! objects1 & into ! quality ( ! troops1 into ! circum/ances "u :i* !y 7 tra9$ & f\ght1 & ?is w abundantly appe>4 ,c]ta9ly1 ! commiss>iat :i* we d by =esight1 !y did by brute ef=ts ( p[]2 b ! lead+ economical laws :i* are n[ cle> to u1 & :i*1 ) full p]ception ( _! inevitable op]ation1 we take into acc\nt1 made !mselves felt 9 ! la/ result if only !n bl9dly realiz$2 & 9 ! fact t ^! laws are n[ cle>ly appreh5d$ lies ! prevail+ reason t mod]n w>s mu/1 on ! side alike ( ! commiss>iat & ( social effects 9 v>i\s directions1 be widely diff]5t f w> 9 anci5t times4 ,,footnotes3 #ba ,"o pret5d$ pro( ( a decl9e is f\nd 9 ! suppos$ sub/itution ( slave lab\r = free ,italian lab\r4 ,?is began1 x is urg$1 on ! op5+ ( ! ,nile corn trade4 ,un=tunately1 t is a m]e romance4 ,ovid1 describ+ rural appe>ances 9 ,italy :5 z yet ! trade 0 h>dly 9 its infancy1 speaks ( ! ru/ic lab\r] z work+ 9 fett]s4 ,juv5al1 9 an age :5 ! trade _h be5 va/ly exp&$1 notices ! same ph5om5on almo/ 9 ! same t]ms4 #bb ',! be/ raw mat]ial4' ,"s p hold t ! ,romans & ,italians 7 a c[>dly nation4 ,we d\bt ?is on ! :ole4 ,physically1 h[ev]1 !y 7 inf]ior to _! neighb\rs4 ,x is c]ta9 t ! ,transalp9e ,gauls 7 a conspicu\sly tall] race4 ,cs> says3 ',gallis1 pr magnitud9e corporum quorum1 brevitas no/ra contemptui e/' 7',bell4 ,gall4' #b1 #cj f9472 & ! ,g]mans1 9 a /ill high] degree1 7 bo? l>g] m5 & e way m p[]ful4 ,! kites1 says ,juv5al1 _h nev] fea/$ on c>cases s huge z ^? ( ! ,cimbri & ,teutones4 ,b ?is physical sup]iority1 ?\gh great = special purposes1 0 n su* absolutely4 ,= ! m g5]al uses ( ! legion>y soldi]1 = m>*+1 = ca/rametation1 & ! daily lab\rs ( ! spade or mattock1 a light] build 0 bett]4 ,z to s+le combats1 x 0 "o effect f ! ,roman 7z f e good7 discipl9e--t x dim9i%$ ! op5+s = su* %[y b p]il\s modes ( conte/4 #bc ',any consid]able portion ( ?is prov9cial corn gr[?1' i4e41 ( ! prov9cial culture :i* 0 pursu$ on acc\nt ( ,rome1 mean+ n ! gov]nm5t ( ,rome1 b1 9 a rigor\s s5se1 on acc\nt ( ,rome ! city4 ,= "h lies a great ov]sight ( hi/orians & economi/s4 ,because ,rome1 ) a view to h] own privileg$ population1 i4e41 ! urban population ( ,rome1 ! metropolis1 9 ord] t %e might support h] public di/ributions ( gra91 almo/ ( necessity dep5d$ on =eign supplies1 we are n to suppose t ! great mass ( ,italian t[ns & municipia did s4 ,m>itime t[ns1 hav+ ! b5efit ( ports or ( conv5i5t access1 und\bt$ly 7 p>ticipators 9 ! ,roman advantage4 ,b inl& t[ns w\ld 9 ^? days h =feit$ ! :ole diff]5ce betwe5 =eign & dome/ic gra9 by ! enorm\s co/ ( inl& c>riage4 ,( canals !re 0 b "o2 ! riv]s 7 n g5]ally navigable1 & ports z well z riv] %ipp+ 7 want+4 #bd ',h]aclius4' ,! same prosodial fault affects ?is "n z t ( ,alex&ria4 ,9 ea* "n ! ,lat9 i repres5ts a ,greek ei1 & 9 t situation 7viz41 z a p5ultimate syllable7 %\ld receive ! emphasis 9 pronunciation z well z ! s\nd ( a long i 7t s\nd :i* is he>d 9 ,longinus74 ,s aga9 ,academia1 n ,academia4 ,! ,greek acc5tuation may be d\bt$1 b n ! ,roman4 #be ,we h already said t ,h]aclius1 :o & ^: family fill$ ! ?rone ( ,ea/]n ,cs> = exactly "o hundr$ ye>s 7#faa-gaa71 consequ5tly int]e/+ 9 ?is way 7if 9 no o!r71 t he1 z ! read] w see by consid]+ ! limits 9 po9t ( "t1 mu/ h met & exhau/$ ! fir/ rage ( ! ,mahometan avalan*e1 m]its accord+ to our e/imate ! title ( fir/ & noble/ among/ ! ,ori5tal ,cs>s4 ,!re are records or traditions ( 8 e>lie/ acts t we c\ld wi% o!rwise4 ,:i* ( u w\ld n (f5d ev5 at ?is day1 if call$ ^u to act "u "o scale ( sympa?ies1 & to be judg$ "u ano!r8 ,9 8 own day1 too pa9fully we say x1 ,h]aclius c\ld n h foll[$ :at we v5ture to believe ! sugge/ions ( 8 he>t1 9 relation to 8 pr$ecessor1 because a policy _h be5 e/abli%$ :i* made x dang]\s to be m]ciful1 & a /ate ( public feel+ :i* made x effem9ate to p>don4 ,fir/ make x safe to p]mit a man's life1 be=e y pron\nce x ignoble to au?orize 8 dea?4 ,/rip m]cy ( ru9 to its au?or1 be=e y affirm ^u a judicial puni%m5t ( dea? 7z !n x 07 cruelty 9 ! advis] or ignobility 9 ! approv]4 ,escap+ f ^! pa9ful sc5es at ! ?re%old ( 8 public life1 we f9d ,h]aclius prep>+ = a w>1 ! mo/ difficult t 9 any age any h]o has confront$4 ,we call him ! e>lie/ ( ,crusad]s1 because he fir/ & lit]ally f\ght = ! recov]y ( ! ,cross4 ,we call him ! mo/ prosp]\s ( ,crusad]s1 because he fir/--he la/--succe$$ 9 all t he s\ght1 br++ back to ,syria 7ultimately to ,con/ant9ople7 t sublime symbol ( victori\s ,*ri/ianity :i* _h be5 disgracefully lo/ at ,j]usalem4 ,yet :y1 :5 comp>+ him n ) ,crusad]s1 b ) ,cs>s1 d we pron\nce him ! noble/8 ,read]1 :i* is x t is felt by a ?\ghtful man--suppos+ him call$ ^u to select "o act by pref]5ce be=e all o!rs--to be ! gr&e/ act ( our own ,wellesley8 ,is x n ! sagaci\s prep>ation ( ! l9es at ,torres ,v$ras1 ! self-ma/]y :i* lur$ ! ,fr5* on to _! ru91 ! long-suff]+ policy :i* re9$ up 8 troops till t ru9 0 accompli%$8 ',i bide my "t1' 0 ! dreadful wat*word ( ,well+ton ?r\gh t great drama2 9 :i*1 let u tell ! ,fr5* critics on ,trag$y1 !y w f9d ! mo/ absolute unity ( plot2 = ! =m+ ( ! l9es z ! fatal noose1 ! wil+ back ! enemy1 ! pursuit :5 ! "w ( disorganization 0 p]fect1 all 7 p>ts ( "o & ! same drama4 ,if he 7z ano!r ,scipio7 saw ano!r ,zama1 9 ?is in/ance he 0 n our ,scipio or ,m>cellus1 b our ,fabius ,maximus3 ',unus homo nobis cunct&o re/ituit rem4'--',ann4' #h1 #bg4 ,n[1 su* 0 ! ,emp]or ,h]aclius4 ,he also _h 8 av5g+ ,zama4 ,b1 dur+ a memorable int]val ( elev5 ye>s1 he held back2 fi]cely re9$ up 8 wra?2 brood$2 smil$ (t5 balefully2 wat*$ 9 8 lair2 & !n1 :5 ! h\r _h /ruck1 let slip 8 armies & 8 ?und]bolts z no ,cs> _h ev] done1 except t "o :o f\nd$ ! "n ( ,cs>4 #bf ,a brutal outrage on a ,capta9 ,j5k9s--i4e41 cutt+ (f 8 e>s--0 ! cause ( a w> ) ,spa9 9 ! reign ( ,george ,,ii4--,,ed4 ,,xviii4 ,,national ,,mann]s ,,& ,,false ,,judgm5t ,,( ,,!m4 ,anecdotes illu/rative ( mann]s1 above all ( national mann]s1 w be f\nd on exam9ation1 9 a f> l>g] proportion ?an might be suppos$1 rank falsehoods4 ,malice is ! secret f\ndation ( all anecdotes 9 t class4 ,! ord9>y c\rse ( su* falsehoods is1 t fir/ ( all "s /rang] & ali5 to ^? feel+s :i* h prompt$ a p>ticul> usage--incapable1 !re=e1 ( ent]+ fully into its _s or mean+--tries to exhibit its absurdity m =cibly by pu%+ x into an extreme or try+ case4 ,com+ himself f "s gross =m ( ,kle9/dtigkeit1 :]e no re/ra9ts ( decorum exi/1 & :]e ev]ybody speaks to ev]ybody1 he has be5 utt]ly conf\nd$ by ! ,engli% c]emony ( 'introduction1' :5 en=c$ z ! s9e qu non condition ( p]sonal int]c\rse4 ,if ,engl& is "r1 !n h[ cl[ni%ly wrong mu/ h be5 8 own previ\s circles6 ,if ,engl& is n ridicul\sly fa/idi\s1 !n h[ be/ially grovell+ mu/ be ! _s ( social int]c\rse 9 8 own l&6 ,b no man reconciles himself to ?is view ( ?+s 9 a mom5t4 ,he kicks ev5 aga9/ 8 own secret convictions4 ,he blu%es ) %ame & ang] at ! ?\ght ( 8 own family p]haps br\ght sudd5ly into collision ) poli%$ ,engli%m52 he ?rills ) wra? at ! recollection ( hav+ himself trespass$ ^u ?is code ( re/riction at a "t :5 he 0 yet unw>n$ ( its exi/5ce4 ,9 ?is temp] he is little qualifi$ to review su* a regulation ) reason & good s5se4 ,he seeks to make x appe> ridicul\s4 ,he presses x into viol5t cases = :i* x 0 nev] int5d$4 ,he supposes a case :]e "s fell[-creature is dr[n+4 ,h[ w\ld an ,engli%man act1 h[ c\ld he act1 ev5 "u su* circum/ances z ^!8 ,we "k1 we :o are bl9d$ by no spite1 t z a b> to p]sonal communication or to any int]*ange ( good (fices "u appeals s =cible z ^!1 ?is law ( =mal pres5tation betwe5 ! p>ties nev] did & nev] w op]ate4 ,! :ole motive to su* a law gives way at once4 ,,xix4 ,,increas$ ,,possibilities ,,( ,,sympa?y ,,9 ,,! ,,pres5t ,,age4 ,"s ye>s ago ,i _h occasion to rem>k t a new era 0 com+ on by ha/y /rides = national politics1 a new organ 0 matur+ itself = public effects4 ,sympa?y--h[ great a p[] is t6 ,consci\s sympa?y--h[ immeasurable6 ,n[1 = ! total developm5t ( ?is p[]1 "t is ! mo/ critical ( elem5ts4 ,?irty ye>s ago1 :5 ! ,ed9burgh mail took n9ety-six h\rs 9 its transit f ,london1 h[ sl[ 0 ! reaction ( ! ,scotti% capital ^u ! ,engli%6 ,eight days = ! diaulos#bg ( ! j\rney1 & two1 suppose1 = gett+ up a public meet+1 compos$ a cycle ( t5 be=e an act receiv$ its comm5t>y1 be=e a spee* receiv$ its refutation1 or an appeal its damnatory answ]4 ,:at 0 ! consequ5ce8 ,! s\nd 0 disconnect$ f its e*o1 ! kick 0 sev]$ f ! recalcitration1 ! ',take y ?is6' 0 unl9k$ f ! ',& take y t6' ,v5geance 0 defeat$1 & sympa?y dissolv$ into ! air4 ,b n[ m>k ! diff]5ce4 ,a meet+ on ,monday 9 ,liv]pool is by possibility report$ 9 ! ,london ,/&>d ( ,monday ev5+4 ,on ,tuesday1 ! spl5did m]*ant1 suppose 8 "n 7 ,?omas ,s&s1 :o _h j s5t a vibration ?r\gh all ! pulses ( ,liv]pool1 ( ,man*e/]1 ( ,w>r+ton1 sees ?is great roll+ fire 7:i* h>dly yet has rea*$ 8 own outly+ neighb\rhoods7 tak5 up af> (f1 r$\bl$1 multipli$1 peal aft] peal1 ?r\gh ! va/ artill]ies ( ,london4 ,back comes roll+ ^u him ! smoke & ! ?und]--! defiance to ! sl&]] & ! w>n+ to ! (f5d]--groans t h be5 extort$ f w\nd$ hon\r1 aspirations ris+ f ! f]v5t he>t--tru? t _h be5 hidd51 wisdom t *all5g$ co-op]ation4 ,& ?us x is t all ! nation1 ?us 'all t mighty he>t1' ?r\gh n9e hundr$ miles ( space1 f ,su!rl&%ire by ,london to ! myrtle climate ( ,cornwall1 has become & is ev] m becom+ "o inf9ite h>p1 swept by ! same breeze ( s5tim5t1 rev]b]at+ ! same sympa?ies ',"h1 !re1 & 9 all places at "o "t4'#bh ,"t1 !re=e1 t anci5t enemy ( man & 8 frail purposes1 h[ pot5t an ally has x become 9 comb9ation ) great me*anic *anges6 ,_m an imp]fect hemisph]e ( ?\ght1 action1 desire1 t c\ld n h]et(ore unite ) its correspond+ hemisph]e1 because sep>at$ by t5 or f\rte5 days ( susp5se1 n[ moves electrically to its integration1 hurries to its complem5t1 realizes its orbicul> p]fection1 sph]ical completion1 ?r\gh t simple s]ies ( improvem5ts :i* to man h giv5 ! w+s & tal>ia ( ,gods1 = ! h]alds h dimly sugge/$ a future rival%ip ) ! velocities ( light1 & ev5 n[ h inaugurat$ a race betwe5 ! *ild ( mortality & ! ,nor? ,w9d4 ,,footnotes3 #bg ',! diaulos ( ! j\rney4' ,we recomm5d to ! amateur 9 words ?is ,greek phrase1 :i* expresses by "o ^w an egress l9k$ ) its correspond+ regress1 :i* indicates at once ! voyage outw>ds & ! voyage inw>ds1 z ! briefe/ ( expressions = :at is te*nically call$ 'c\rse ( po/1' i4e41 ! reciprocation ( po/1 its sy/ole & dia/ole4 #bh ,wordswor?4 ,,xx4 ,,! ,,pr9ciple ,,( ,,evil4 ,we are n to suppose ! rebel1 or1 m prop]ly1 corrupt$ angels--! rebellion be+ 9 ! result1 n 9 ! int5tion 7:i* is z little conceivable 9 an exalt$ _s z t man %\ld prep>e to make w> on gravitation7--7 ess5tially evil4 ,:e!r a pr9ciple ( evil--ess5tial evil--any:]e exi/s c only be guess$4 ,s gloomy an idea is %ut up f man4 ,yet1 if s1 possibly ! angels & man 7 ne>+ x cont9ually4 ,possibly aft] a c]ta9 approa* to t ,mael/rom recall might be hopeless4 ,possibly _m an*ors _h be5 ?r[n out to pick up1 _h all dragg$1 & la/ ( all came to ! ,jewi% trial4 7,( c\rse1 "u ! ,pagan abs5ce ( s91 a fall 0 impossible4 ,a return 0 impossible1 9 ! s5se t y _c return to a place :i* y h nev] left4 ,h ,i ev] notic$ ?is87 ,we are n to suppose t ! angels 7 really 9 a /ate ( rebellion4 ,s f> f t1 x 0 evid5tly among/ ! purposes ( ,god t :at are call$ false ,gods1 & are s 9 ! ultimate s5se ( re/+ on ta9t$ pr9ciples & t5d+ to ru9--p]haps irretrievable 7?\gh x w\ld be ! same ?+ practically if no re/oration 7 possible b ?r\gh va/ ons ( unhappy inc>nations7--b o!rwise 7 z real z any?+ c be into ^: nature a g]m ( evil has ent]$1 %\ld effect a second>y m9i/ration ( ! la/ importance to man's welf>e4 ,d\bt !re c be little t )\t any religion1 any s5se ( dep5d5cy1 or gratitude1 or rev]5ce z to sup]ior natures1 man w\ld rapidly h det]iorat$2 & t w\ld h t5d$ to su* de/ruction ( all nobl] pr9ciples--patriotism 7/rong 9 ! old _w z ) u71 humanity1 ties ( p>5tage or neighb\rhood--z w\ld soon h ?9n$ ! _w2 s t ! ,jewi% process ?us go+ on mu/ h fail$ = want ( correspond5cies to ! s*eme--possibly endless oscillations :i*1 h[ev] co9cid5t ) plagues1 w\ld extirpate ! human race4 ,we may see 9 manufactur+ neighb\rhoods1 s long z no dep5d5cy exi/s on ma/]s1 :]e wages %[ t n "w1 b workm51 are sc>ce1 h[ unamiable1 insol5t1 fi]ce1 are ! p2 ! poor cottag]s on a great e/ate may sometimes (f5d y by too obsequi\s a _s t[>ds all g5try4 ,t 0 a transition /ate 9 ,engl& dur+ ! fir/ half ( ! eighte5? c5tury1 :5 few manufactur]s & m]*ants _h ris5 to su* a g5]\s model4 ,b ?is leaves room = _m dome/ic virtues t w\ld suff] greatly 9 ! o!r /ate4 ,yet ?is is b a fa9t image ( ! total indep5d5cy4 ,oa?s 7 sacr$ only ?r\gh ! temporal judgm5ts suppos$ to ov]take ^? :o insult$ ! ,gods by summon+ !m to witness a false contract4 ,b ?is w\ld h be5 only "p ( ! evil4 ,s long z m5 ackn[l$g$ high] natures1 !y 7 d\btful ab\t futurity4 ,?is d\bt _h little /r5g? on ! side ( hope1 b mu* on ! side ( fe>4 ,! bless+s ( any future /ate 7 *e]less & insipid mock]ies2 s ,a*illes--h[ he bemoans 8 /ate6 ,b ! torm5ts 7 real4 ,by f> m1 h[ev]1 !y1 ?r\gh ?is co>se ag5cy ( syllogi/ic dread1 w\ld act to %[ man ! degradation ( 8 nature :5 all light ( a high] exi/5ce _h disappe>$4 ,t :i* did n exi/ = natures suppos$ capable orig9ally ( immortality1 h[ %\ld x exi/ = him8 ,& t man mu/ h obs]v$ ) little att5tion :at takes place 9 ?is _w if he ne$s to be told t no?+ t5ds to make 8 own species *eap & hateful 9 8 eyes s c]ta9ly z moral degradation driv5 to a po9t ( no hope4 ,s 9 squalid dungeons1 9 captivities ( slaves1 nay1 9 absolute paup]ism1 all hate ea* o!r fi]cely4 ,ev5 ) u1 h[ sad is ! ?\ght--t1 j z a man ne$s pity1 z he is /ript ( all ?+s1 :5 mo/ ! sympa?y ( m5 %\ld settle on him1 !n mo/ is he contemplat$ ) a h>d-he>t$ contempt6 ,! ,jews :5 injur$ by our own oppressive pr9ces 7 despis$ & hat$4 ,_h !y rais$ an empire1 lick$ _! oppressors well1 !y w\ld h be5 compassionately lov$4 ,s lunatics h]et(ore2 s galley-slaves--,t\lon1 ,m>seilles1 etc4 ,?is brutal pr9ciple ( degradation soon develop$ 9 man4 ,! ,gods1 !re=e1 p]=m$ a great ag5cy = man4 ,& x is cle> t ,god did n disc\rage common rites or rights = ,8 alt> or !irs4 ,nay1 he s5t ,israel to ,egypt--z "o reason--to le>n c]emonies among/ a p :o seque/]$ !m4 ,9 evil ! ,jews always clove to _! religion4 ,next ! difficulty ( p1 miracles1 ?\gh less = false ,gods1 & lea/ ( all = ! meane/1 0 alike = bo?4 ,a/>te does n kill ,say? on ! spot1 b by a judgm5t4 ,gods1 no m _! ,god1 spake an in/ant law4 ,ev5 ! prophets are prop]ly no prophets1 b only ! mode ( spee* by ,god1--z cle> z ,he c speak4 ,m5 mi/ake ,god's hate by _! own4 ,s nei!r c\ld ,he reveal ,himself4 ,a va/ age w\ld be requir$ = see+ ,god4 ,b = ! ?\ght ( man z evil 7or ( any o!r =m ( evil71 z reconcilable ) _! idea ( a p]fect ,god1 a happy idea may1 l ! categories1 proce$ ^u a necessity = a p]fect inv]sion ( ! me?odus conspici5di4 ,let u retrace1 b 9 su* a =m z to be appreh5sible by all read]s4 ,analytic & syn!tic propositions at once ?r[ light ^u ! notion ( a category4 ,once x _h be5 a m]e ab/raction2 ( no possible use except z a conv5i5t cell = ref]r+ 7z 9 a ne/ ( boxes71 :i* may p]haps z mu* degrade ! idea z a relative ( my own degrad$ ! image ( ! cresc5t moon by say+1 9 8 abhorr5ce ( s5tim5tality1 t x rem9d$ him ( ! segm5t f 8 own ?umb-nail :5 clean cut by an in/rum5t call$ a nail-cutt]4 ,?is 0 ! ,ari/otelian notion4 ,b ,kant c\ld n cont5t himself ) ?is idea4 ,8 own !ory 7#a7 z to "t & space1 7#b7 ! refutation ( ,hume's notion ( cause1 & 7#c7 8 own great discov]y ( syn!tic & analytic propositions1 all prep>$ ! way = a totally new view4 ,b1 n[1 :at is ! orig9 ( ?is necessity appli$ to ! category z f\nd$ 9 ! syn!sis8 ,h[ does a syn!sis make itself or any?+ else necess>y8 ,expla9 me t4 ,?is 0 writt5 p]haps a =tnight ago4 ,n[1 ,monday1 ,may #bc 7day fix$ = ,dan ,good's execution71 ,i d expla9 x by :at ?is mom5t ,i seem to h discov]$--! necessity ( cause1 ( sub/ance1 etc41 lies 9 ! int]v5+ syn!sis4 ,?is y mu/ pass ?r\gh 9 ! c\rse t5d+ to & f9ally rea*+ ! idea2 = ! analytical presupposes ?is syn!sis4 ,n only mu/ ! en]gies ( de/ruction be equal to ^? ( creation1 b1 9 fact1 p]haps by ! trespass+ a little ( ! fir/ ^u ! la/1 is ! true advance su/a9$2 = x mu/ be an advance z well z a balance4 ,b y say ?is w b 9 o!r words mean t =ces devot$ 7& prop]ly s7 to production or creation are absorb$ by de/ruction4 ,true2 b ! oppos+ ph5om5a w be go+ on 9 a l>ge ratio1 & ea* mu/ react on ! o!r4 ,! productive mu/ meet & correspond to ! de/ructive4 ,! de/ructive mu/ revise & /imulate ! cont9u$ production4 ,,xxi4 ,,on ,,miracles4 ,:at else is ! lay+ ( su* a /ress on miracles b ! case ( 'a wick$ & adult]\s g5]ation ask+ a sign'8 ,b :at are ^! miracles =8 ,to prove a legislation f ,god4 ,b1 fir/1 ?is c\ld n be prov$1 ev5 if miracle-work+ 7 ! te/ ( ,div9e mission1 by do+ miracles until we knew :e!r ! p[] 7 g5u9e2 i4e41 n1 l ! magicians ( ,ph>aoh or ! wit* ( ,endor1 f bel[4 ,secondly1 y are a poor1 pitiful creature1 t ?9k ! p[] to d miracles1 or p[] ( any k9d t c exhibit itself 9 an act1 ! note ( a god-l commission4 ,bett] is "o ray ( tru? 7n se5 previ\sly by man71 ( moral tru?1 e4g41 =giv5ess ( enemies1 ?an all ! p[]s :i* c\ld create ! _w4 ',oh yes6' says ! objector2 'b ,*ri/ 0 holy z a man4' ,?is we "k fir/2 !n we judge by ,8 p[] t ,he mu/ h be5 f ,god4 ,b if x 7 d\btful :e!r ,8 p[] 7 f ,god1 !n1 until ?is d\bt is o!rwise1 is indep5d5tly remov$1 y _c decide if ,he 0 holy by a te/ ( hol9ess absolutely irrelevant4 ,) o!r hol9ess--app>5t hol9ess--a simulation might be comb9$4 ,y c nev] tell t a man is holy2 & = ! pla9 reason t ,god only c read ! he>t4 ',let ,him come d[n f ! cross1 & we1' etc4 ,yes2 !y fanci$ s4 ,b see :at w\ld really h foll[$4 ,!y w\ld h be5 /unn$ & conf\nd$ = ! mom5t1 b n at all conv]t$ 9 he>t4 ,_! hatr$ to ,*ri/ 0 n built on _! unbelief1 b _! unbelief 9 ,*ri/ 0 built on _! hatr$2 & ?is hatr$ w\ld n h be5 mitigat$ by ano!r 7h[ev] a/\nd+7 miracle4 ,?is ,i wrote 7,monday morn+1 ,june #g1 #ahdg7 9 ref]5ce to my say+ on ! g5]al "q ( miracles3 ,:y ^! dubi\s miracles8--su* z cur+ bl9dness t may h be5 cur$ by a process8--s9ce ! unity giv5 to ! act ( heal+ is probably 7m probably ?an o!rwise7 b ! figurative unity ( ! t5d5cy to my?us2 or else x is t unity misappreh5d$ & mi/ranslat$ by ! report]s4 ,su*1 aga91 z ! miracles ( ! loaves--s liable to be utt]ly gossip1 s incapable ( be+ wat*$ or exam9$ among/ a cr[d ( #g1jjj p4 ,besides1 7 ^! p mad8 ,! v fact :i* is said to h drawn ,*ri/'s pity1 viz41 _! situation 9 ! des]t1 surely c\ld n h escap$ _! own att5tion on go+ ?i!r4 ,?9k ( #g1jjj p ru%+ to a sort ( de/ruction2 = if less ?an t ! m]e inconv5i5ce 0 n wor?y ( ,div9e att5tion4 ,n[1 said ,i1 :y n give u 7if miracles are requir$7 "o t nobody c\ld d\bt--remov+ a m\nta91 e4g48 ,yes2 b "h ! o!r p>ty beg9 to see ! evil ( miracles4 ,oh1 ?is w\ld h co]c$ p into believ+6 ,re/ y safe z to t4 ,x w\ld h be5 no believ+ 9 any prop] s5se3 x w\ld1 at ! utmo/--& suppos+ no vital demur to popul> miracle--h l$ p into t belief :i* ,*ri/ ,himself describes 7& regrets7 z call+ ,him ,"l6 ,"l6 ,! pret5d$ belief w\ld h left !m j :]e !y 7 z to any real belief 9 ,*ri/4 ,previ\sly1 h[ev]1 or ov] & above all ?is1 !re w\ld be ! demur 7let ! miracle h be5 :at x might7 (1 ,by :at p[]1 by ^: ag5cy or help8 ,= if ,*ri/ does a miracle1 probably ,he may d x by alliance ) "s ,z /&+ beh9d1 out ( sight4 ,or if by ,8 own skill1 h[ or :5ce d]iv$1 or ( :at nature8 ,?is ob/9ately recurr5t "q rema9s4 ,!re is n ! meane/ c\rt 9 ,*ri/5dom or ,islam t w\ld n say1 if call$ on to adjudicate ! rights ( an e/ate on su* evid5ce z ! m]e facts ( ! ,gospel3 ',o good ,god1 h[ c we d ?is8 ,:i* ( u kn[s :o ?is ,mat!w 0--:e!r he ev] liv$1 or1 if s1 :e!r he ev] wrote a l9e ( all ?is8 or1 if he did1 h[ situat$ z to motives1 z to means ( in=mation1 z to judgm5t & discrim9ation8 ,:o kn[s any?+ ( ! contrivances or ! v>i\s p]sonal int]e/s 9 :i* ! :ole n>rative orig9at$1 or :58 ,all is d>k & du/y4' ,no?+ 9 su* a case c be prov$ b :at %9es by its own light4 ,nay1 ,god ,himself c\ld n atte/ a miracle1 b 7li/5 to ?is67--b by ! int]nal revelation or visit+ ( ! ,_s--to evade :i*1 to disp5se ) :i*1 a miracle is ev] resort$ to4 ,besides ! objection to miracles t !y are n capable ( atte/ation1 ,hume's objection is n t !y are false1 b t !y are incommunicable4 ,two diff]5t duties arise = ! man :o witnesses a miracle & = him :o receives traditionally4 ,! duty ( ! fir/ is to confide 9 8 own exp]i5ce1 :i* may1 besides1 h be5 repeat$2 ( ! second1 to confide 9 8 und]/&+1 :i* says3 ',less m>vel t ! report] %\ld h err$ ?an t nature %\ld h be5 violat$4' ,h[ de>ly d ^! p betray _! own hypocrisy ab\t ! div9ity ( ,*ri/ianity1 & at ! same "t ! meanness ( _! own natures1 :o ?9k ! ,messiah1 or ,god's ,mess5g]1 mu/ fir/ prove ,8 own commission by an act ( p[]2 :]eas 7#a7 a new revelation ( moral =ces c\ld n be inv5t$ by all g5]ations1 & 7#b7 an act ( p[] mu* m probably argues an alliance ) ! devil4 ,i %\ld gloomily suspect a man :o came =w>d z a magician4 ,suppose ! ,gospels writt5 ?irty ye>s aft] ! ev5ts1 & by ignorant1 sup]/iti\s m5 :o h adopt$ ! fables t old wom5 _h surr\nd$ ,*ri/ )--h[ does ?is supposition vitiate ! report ( ,*ri/'s p>ables8 ,b1 on ! o!r h&1 !y c\ld no m h inv5t$ ! p>ables ?an a man alleg+ a diamond-m9e c\ld inv5t a diamond z atte/ation4 ,! p>ables prove !mselves4 ,,xxii4 ',,let ,,him ,,come ,,d[n ,,f ,,! ,,cross4' ,n[1 ?is is exce$+ly well wor? consid]ation4 ,i "k n at all :e!r :at ,i am go+ to say has be5 said already--life w\ld n suffice 9 e field or section ( a field to se>* e nook & section ( a nook = ! possibilities ( *ance utt]ance giv5 to any /ray op9ion4 ,b ?is ,i "k )\t any d\bt at all1 t x _c h be5 said effectually1 _c h be5 s said z to publi% & disp]se itself2 else x is impossible t ! crazy logic curr5t ^u ^! topics %\ld h liv$1 or t _m sep>ate argum5ts %\ld ev] = v %ame h be5 utt]$4 ,said or n said1 let u presume x unsaid1 & let me /ate ! true answ] z if de novo1 ev5 if by accid5t some:]e ! d>kness %elt]s ?is same answ] z utt]$ long ago4 ,n[1 !re=e1 ,i w suppose t ,he _h come d[n f ! ,cross4 ,no case c s p[]fully illu/rate ! fil?y falsehood & pollution ( t idea :i* m5 g5]ally ent]ta91 :i* ! sole cr$itable books univ]sally build ^u4 ,:at w\ld h foll[$8 ,?is w\ld h foll[$3 t1 inv]t+ ! ord] ( e true emanation f ,god1 in/ead ( gr[+ & exp&+ = ev] l a symbol3 1 x w\ld h atta9$ its maximum at ! fir/4 ,! effect = ! half-h\r w\ld h be5 prodigi\s1 & f t mom5t :5 x began to flag x w\ld degrade rapidly1 until1 9 ?ree days1 a f> fi]c] hatr$ aga9/ ,*ri/ w\ld h be5 m\ld$4 ,= obs]ve3 into :at /ate ( m9d w\ld ?is m>vel h be5 receiv$8 ,into any good-w t[>ds ,*ri/1 :i* previ\sly _h be5 defeat$ by ! belief t ,he 0 an impo/or 9 ! s5se t ,he pret5d$ to a p[] ( miracles :i* 9 fact ,he _h n8 ,by no means4 ,! s5se 9 :i* ,*ri/ _h be5 an impo/or = !m 0 9 assum+ a commission1 a spiritual embassy ) appropriate functions1 promises1 prospects1 to :i* ,he _h no title4 ,h[ _h t notion--n1 viz41 ( miracul\s impo/or%ip1 b ( spiritual impo/or%ip--be5 able to ma9ta9 itself8 ,:y1 :at %\ld h reasonably de/roy$ ! notion8 ,?is1 viz41 ! sublimity ( ,8 moral sy/em4 ,b does ! read] imag9e t ?is sublimity is ( a nature to be se5 intellectually--t is1 insulat$ & 9 vacuo = ! intellect8 ,no m ?an by geometry or by a sorites any man con/itutionally imp]fect c\ld come to und]/& ! nature ( ! sexual appetite2 or a man born deaf c\ld make repres5table to himself ! liv+ tru? ( music1 a man born bl9d c\ld make repres5table ! liv+ tru? ( col\rs4 ,all m5 are n equally deaf 9 he>t--f> f x--! diff]5ces are inf9ite1 & "s m5 nev] c\ld compreh5d ! beauty ( spiritual tru?4 ,b no man c\ld compreh5d x )\t prep>ation4 ,t prep>ation 0 f\nd 9 8 tra9+ ( ,judaism2 :i* to ^? ^: he>ts 7 he>ts ( fle%1 n /ony & *>m$ aga9/ he>+1 _h already anticipat$ ! fir/ outl9es ( ,*ri/ian ideas4 ,s91 purity1 hol9ess unimag9able1 ^! _h already be5 inoculat$ into ! ,jewi% m9d4 ,& among/ ! race inoculat$ ,*ri/ f\nd en\gh = a c5tral nucleus to ,8 future ,*ur*4 ,b ! natural t5d5cy "u ! fev]-mi/ ( /rife & passion1 evok$ by ! pres5t position 9 ! _w op]at+ ^u robu/1 full-blood$ life1 un%ak5 by grief or t5d]ness ( nature1 or con/itutional sadness1 is to fail altoge!r ( see+ ! features :i* s p[]fully m>k ,*ri/ianity4 ,^? features1 in/ead ( com+ out into /rong relief1 resemble :at we see 9 m\nta9\s regions :]e ! mi/ cov]s ! l(tie/ peaks4 ,we h he>d ( a man say+3 ',give me su* titles ( hon\r1 s _m myriads ( p\nds1 & !n ,i w consid] y\r proposal t ,i %\ld turn ,*ri/ian4' ,n[1 survey--pause = "o mom5t to survey--! immeasurable effront]y ( ?is spee*4 ,fir/1 x replies to a proposal hav+ :at object--our happ9ess or 88 ,:y1 ( c\rse1 83 h[ are we int]e/$1 except on a sublime pr9ciple ( b5evol5ce1 9 8 fai? be+ "r8 ,secondly1 x is a reply presum+ money1 ! mo/ fle%ly ( objects1 to modify or any way control religion1 i4e41 a spiritual conc]n4 ,?is 9 itself is already mon/r\s1 & pretty mu* ! same z x w\ld be to ord] a *>ge ( bayonets aga9/ gravitation1 or aga9/ an avalan*e1 or aga9/ an e>?quake1 or aga9/ a deluge4 ,b1 suppose x 7 n s1 :at incompreh5sible reason+ ju/ifies ! notion t n we are to be paid1 b t he is to be paid = a *ange n conc]n+ or affect+ our happ9ess1 b 88 ,,xxiii4 ,,is ,,! ,,human ,,race ,,on ,,! ,,d[n ,,grade8 ,z to individual nations1 x is matt] ( notoriety t !y are (t5 improgressive4 ,z a :ole1 x may be true t ! human race is "u a necessity ( sl[ly advanc+2 & x may be a necessity1 also1 t ! curr5t ( ! mov+ wat]s %\ld f9ally absorb into its motion t "p ( ! wat]s :i*1 left to itself1 w\ld /agnate4 ,all ?is may be true--& yet x w n foll[ t ! human race mu/ be mov+ con/antly ^u an asc5d+ l9e1 z ?us3 ,b _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ ,a nor ev5 ^u su* a l9e1 ) cont9ual pauses or re/s int]pos$1 z ?us3 ,illu/ration :]e !re is no go+ back1 ?\gh a con/ant int]ruption to ! go+ =w>d2 b a ?ird hypo!sis is possible3 !re may be cont9ual loss ( gr\nd1 yet s t cont9ually ! loss is m ?an comp5sat$1 & ! total result1 = any consid]able p]iod ( obs]vation1 may be t progress is ma9ta9$3 ,illu/ration ,at ,o1 by comp>ison ) ! previ\s elevation at ,a1 !re is a repeat$ fall+ back2 b /ill ^u ! :ole1 & pursu+ ! inquiry ?r\gh a suffici5tly l>ge segm5t ( "t1 ! con/ant report is--asc5t4 ,^u ?is explanation x is p]fectly consi/5t ) a g5]al belief 9 ! go+ =w>d ( man--t ?is p>ticul> age 9 :i* we live might be /ation>y1 or might ev5 h gone back4 ,x _c1 !re=e1 be ^u any priori pr9ciple t ,i ma9ta9 ! sup]iority ( ?is age4 ,x is1 & mu/ be ^u special exam9ation1 appli$ to ! ph5om5a ( ?is special age4 ,! la/ c5tury1 9 its fir/ ?irty ye>s1 (f]$ ! spectacle ( a dea?-l collapse 9 ! national en]gies4 ,all great int]e/s suff]$ toge!r4 ,! intellectual p[] ( ! c\ntry1 spite ( ! brilliant display 9 a l[] elem5t1 made by "o or two m5 ( g5ius1 langui%$ z a :ole4 ,! religi\s feel+ 0 torpid1 & 9 a degree :i* insur$ ! /rong reaction ( "s irritat+ galvanism1 or quick5+ impulse su* z t :i* 0 9 fact suppli$ by ,me?odism4 ,x is n ) t age t ,i wi% to comp>e ! pres5t4 ,i comp>e x ) ! age :i* t]m9at$ ?irty ye>s ago--r\s$1 invigorat$1 se>*$ z t age 0 ?r\gh all its s5sibilities by ! electric %ock ( ! ,fr5* ,revolution4 ,x is by comp>ison ) an age s ke5ly alive1 p5etrat$ by ideas /irr+ & uproot+1 t ,i w\ld comp>e x2 & ev5 !n ! balance ( ga9 9 well-calculat$ res\rce1 fix$ yet /imulat+ ideals1 ,i hold to be 9 our fav\r--& ?is 9 opposition to mu* argum5t 9 an adv]se _s f _m & influ5tial qu>t]s4 ,inde$1 x is a rem>k :i* m ?an once ,i h be5 l$ to make 9 pr9t3 t if a =eign] 7 to inquire = ! moral philosophy1 ! e?ics1 & ev5 = ! metaphysics1 ( our ,engli% lit]ature1 ! answ] w\ld be1 ',look = !m 9 ! great body ( our ,div9ity4' ,n m]ely ! m s*ola/ic works on !ology1 b ! occasional s]mons ( our ,engli% div9es conta9 a body ( ri*] philosophical speculation ?an is else:]e to be f\nd2 &1 to say ! tru?1 f> m in/ructive ?an any?+ 9 our ,lockes1 ,b]keleys1 or o!r express & pr(essional philosoph]s4 ,hav+ said ?is by way ( %[+ t ,i d n ov]look _! j pret5sions1 let me h leave to notice a foible 9 ^! writ]s :i* is n m]ely some:at ludicr\s1 b ev5 s]i\sly injuri\s to tru?4 ,"o & all1 ?r\gh a long s]ies ( two hundr$ & fifty ye>s1 ?9k !mselves call$ ^u to tax _! c\ntrym5--ea* sev]ally 9 8 own age--) a sep>ate1 peculi>1 & unexampl$ guilt ( infidelity & irreligion4 ,ea* wor?y man1 9 8 turn1 sees 9 8 own age ov]t signs ( ^! (f5ces n to be mat*$ 9 any o!r4 ,five-&-tw5ty p]iods ( t5 ye>s ea* may be tak51 conc]n+ ea* ( :i* "s excell5t writ] may be cit$ to prove t x _h rea*$ a maximum ( atrocity1 su* z %\ld n easily h be5 susceptible ( aggravation1 b :i* inv>iably ! relays ?r\gh all ! subsequ5t p]iods affirm _! own contempor>ies to h atta9$4 ,e dec5nium is regul>ly worse ?an t :i* prec$es x1 until ! m9d is p]fectly conf\nd$ by ! ,pelion ^u ,ossa :i* mu/ ov]:elm ! la/ t]m ( ! tw5ty-five4 ,x is ! m]e necessity ( a logical sorites1 t su* a horrible race ( villa9s z ! m5 ( ! tw5ty-fif? dec5nium ought n to be suff]$ to brea!4 ,n[1 ! :ole error arises out ( an imbecile self-surr5d] to ! fir/ impressions f ! process ( ab/raction z appli$ to remote objects4 ,survey a t[n "u ! b5efit ( a t5 miles' di/ance1 comb9$ ) a dreamy sun%9e1 & x w appe> a city ( cele/ial palaces4 ,ent] x1 & y w f9d ! same fil?1 ! same ru9s1 ! same disproportions z any:]e else4 ,s ( pa/ ages1 se5 ?r\gh ! haze ( an ab/raction :i* removes all circum/antial features ( de=mity4 ,call up any "o ( ^? ages1 if x 7 possible1 into ! realities ( life1 & ^! wor?y prais]s ( ! pa/ w\ld be surpris$ to f9d e feature repeat$ :i* !y _h fanci$ peculi> to _! own times4 ,mean:ile ?is errone\s doctr9e ( s]mons has a d\ble ill consequ5ce3 fir/1 ! :ole *a9 ( tw5ty-five writ]s1 :5 br\ght toge!r1 consecutively reflect a col\r+ ( absurdity ^u ea* o!r2 sep>ately !y might be endurable1 b all at once1 pr$icat+ 7ea* ( 8 own p]iod exclusively7 :at runs ) a roll+ fire ?r\gh tw5ty-five su* p]iods 9 succession1 _c b recall to ! read] t s5seless doctr9e ( a physical decay 9 man1 z if man 7 once /rong]1 broad]1 tall]1 etc4--^u :i* hypo!sis ( a gradual desc5t :y %\ld x h /opp$ at any special po9t8 ,h[ c\ld ! human race h fail$ long ago to rea* ! po9t ( z]o8 ,b1 secondly1 su* a doctr9e is mo/ injuri\s & insult+ to ,*ri/ianity4 ,if1 aft] eighte5 hundr$ ye>s ( developm5t1 x c\ld be s]i\sly true ( ,*ri/ianity t x _h left any age or g5]ation ( m5 worse 9 conduct1 or 9 feel+1 or 9 belief1 ?an all _! pr$ecessors1 :at reasonable expectation c\ld we h t 9 eighte5 hundr$ ye>s m ! case w\ld be bett]8 ,su* ?\ghtless op9ions make ,*ri/ianity to be a failure4 ,,xxiv4 ,,brevia3 ,,%ort ,,essays 7,,9 ,,connection ,,) ,,ea* ,,o!r47 #a4--,,paganism ,,& ,,*ri/ianity--,,! ,,ideas ,,( ,,duty ,,& ,,hol9ess4 ,! ,pagan ,god c\ld h p]fect peace ) 8 vot>y1 & yet c\ld h no t5d5cy to draw t vot>y to himself4 ,n s ) ! ,god ( ,*ri/ianity1 :o _c give ,8 peace )\t draw+ l a vortex to ,himself1 :o _c draw into ,8 own vortex )\t f9d+ ,8 peace fulfill$4 ',an age :5 lu/re too int5se4'--,i am mu* mi/ak5 if ,mr4 ,wordswor? is n deeply wrong "h4 ,wrong he is beyond a d\bt z to ! fact2 = !re c\ld h be5 no virtual int5sity ( lu/re 7unless m]ely z a t9sel toy7 :5 x 0 contradict$ by ev]y?+ 9 ! mann]s1 habits1 & situations ( ! ,pagan ,gods--!y :o 7 cont5t to play 9 ! co>se/ mann] ! "p ( gay "y bloods1 s[+ _! wild oats1 & ) a recklessness ( consequ5ces to _! female p>tn]s nev] by possibility rivall$ by m54 ,i believe & affirm t lu/re ! mo/ dazzl+ & bl9d+ w\ld n h any ennobl+ effect except z receiv$ into a matrix ( previ\s une>?ly & holy type4 ,z to ,bac*us be+ et]nally "y1 ! anci5ts _h no idea or p[] to frame ! idea ( et]nity4 ,_! et]nity 0 a limit>y ?+4 ,& ?is ,i say n empirically1 b priori1 on ! gr\nd t )\t ! idea ( hol9ess & unfle%l9ess1 et]nity _c rise buoyant f ! gr\nd1 _c su/a9 itself4 ,b waive ?is1 & :at becomes ( ! o!r ?+s8 ,if he 7 *>act]i/ically di/+ui%$ z "y1 !n1 by a m]e reb\nd ( ! logic1 ! o!rs 7 n s hon\r$1 else :]e is ! special privilege ( ,bac*us8 ',& %e %all s+ !re z 9 ! days ( h] y\?' 7,hosea ii4 #ae74--,! case ( pa?os1 a p]son com+ back to places1 recall+ ! days ( y\? aft] a long woe1 is q unkn[n to ! anci5ts--nay1 ! mat]nal affection itself1 ?\gh us$ inevitably1 is nev] consci\sly review$ z an object ( beauty4 ,duties arise ev]y:]e1 b--d n mi/ake--n "u _! sublime =m z duties4 ,i claim ! hon\r to h fir/ expos$ a fallacy too common3 duties nev] did1 nev] w1 arise save "u ,*ri/ianity1 s9ce )\t x ! s5se ( a morality light5$ by religi\s motive1 aspir+ to hol9ess1 n only ( act1 b ( motive1 _h n be=e x ev5 aris54 ,x is ! pressure ( society1 its m]e ne$s & palpable claims1 :i* fir/ calls =? duties1 b n z duties2 r z ! ca/+ ( p>ts 9 a sc5ical arrangem5t4 ,a duty1 "u ! l[ conception to :i* at fir/ x con=ms1 is a rle1 no m2 x is /rictly :at we mean :5 we talk ( a "p4 ,! s5se ( consci5ce /rictly is n t\*$ "u any prec$+ sy/em ( religion4 ,x is ! daught] ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,h[ little did ,wordswor? seize ! fact 9 8 ,ode3 ',/]n ,daught] ( ! ,voice ( ,god' is n en\gh2 ! voice ( ,god is ! consci5ce2 & nei!r has be5 develop$ except by ,*ri/ianity4 ,! consci5ce ( a pagan 0 a consci5ce po9t+ to detection3 x po9t$ only to ! ne$s ( society1 & caus$ fe>1 %ame1 anxiety1 only on ! pr9ciples ( sympa?y2 t is1 f ! impossibility ( releas+ himself f a dep5d5ce on ! reciprocal feel+s--! reb\nd1 ! dep5d5ce on ! res5tm5ts ( o!rs4 ,morals4--,ev5 ord9>y morals c\ld h little practical weight ) ! anci5ts3 witness ! ,roman juries & ,roman trials4 ,_h !re be5 any s5se ( ju/ice pr$om9ant1 c\ld ,cic]o h hop$ to prevail by su* def5ces z t ( ,milo & fifty-six o!rs1 :]e ! argum5t is m]ely fanciful--su* a ,he9-gesp9/ z might be applaud$ ) 'v good6' 'bravo6' 9 any mock trial l t silly "o devis$ by ,dean ,swift4 ,! sl[ness & obtus5ess ( ! ,romans to pa?os appe>s priori 9 _! amphi!atre1 & its t5d5cy to put out ! !atre2 secondly1 po/]iori1 9 ! fact t _! !atre 0 put out2 & also1 po/]iori1 9 ! co>s5ess ( _! s5sibilities to real di/resses unless co/um$ & made s5sible z well z intelligible4 ,! grossness ( ?is dem&1 :i* proce$$ ev5 s f> z p9*+ to elicit a cry1 is beyond easy cr$it to m5 ( _! "t4 ,! n>r[ range ( ! ,greek intellect1 always revolv+ ?r\gh sev5 or eight c5turies ab\t a few memorable examples--f ! ,life ( ,!mi/ocles to ,z5o or ,demo/h5es4 ,! ,grecian glories ( e k9d seem sociable & affable1 c\rt+ sympa?y4 ,! ,jewi% seem malignantly ,greek3 aut>keis4 ,b j z ,paganism respect$ only rights ( action1 possession1 etc41 ,*ri/ianity respects a f> high] scale ( claims1 viz41 z to ! w\nds to feel+s1 to deep injury1 ?\gh n gr\nd$ 9 any?+ measurable or exp\ndable by ext]nal results4 ,man6 y h said t :i* y 7 too pr\d & ob/9ate to unsay1 :i* has lac]at$ "s he>t = ?irty ye>s t _h p]haps secretly & fai?fully s]v$ y & y\rs4 ,*ri/ianity lays hold on t z a po9t ( consci5ce1 if n ( hon\r1 to make am5ds1 if 9 no o!r way1 by remorse4 ,z to ! te>s ( ,o$ipus 9 ! crises4 ,i am compell$ to believe t ,sophocles err$ z reg>d$ nature2 = 9 cases s transc5d5t z ?is ,greek nature & ,engli% nature c\ld n diff]4 ,9 ! great agony on ,m\nt ,oeta1 ,h]cules po9ts ! pity ( 8 son ,hyllus to ! extremity ( torm5t besieg+ him on ! humiliat+ evid5ce ( ! te>s :i* !y extort$ f him4 ',pity me1' says he1 't weep ) sobs l a girl3 a ?+ t no "o c\ld h *>g$ ^u ! man' 7po9t+ to himself72 'b ev] )\t a groan ,i foll[$ out to ! end my calamities4' ,n[1 on ! contr>y1 on ! words ( ! oracle1 t beckon$ away ) impati5t s\nds ,o$ipus f 8 de> sublime ,antigone1 ,o$ipus is made to weep4 ,b ?is is impossible4 ,always ! te>s arose1 & w arise1 on ! relaxation ( ! torm5t & 9 ! re> ( sil5t angui% on its sudd5 susp5se1 amid/ a cont9u$ headlong movem5t2 & also1 9 look+ back1 te>s1 unless *eck$1 might easily arise4 ,b nev] dur+ ! torm5t3 on ! rack !re are no te>s %$1 & ^? :o suff]$ on ! scaffold nev] yet %$ te>s1 unless x may h be5 at "s oblique glance at ?+s collat]al to _! suff]+1 z suppose a sudd5 glimpse ( a *ild's face :i* !y _h lov$ 9 life4 ,is n e ,greek3 ain ( civilization an inh]itance f a previ\s /ate n s high8 ,?us1 e4g41 ! ,romans1 ) s little ( ,*ri/ian re/ra9t1 w\ld h p]i%$ by reaction ( _! own vices1 b = c]ta9 prejudices & follies ab\t trade1 manufacture1 etc41 & b = oil on _! p]sons to prev5t contagion4 ,n[1 ?is oil _h be51 ,i ?9k1 a secret bequea!d f "s old] & high] civilization long s9ce pass$ away4 ,we h x n1 b nei!r h we s mu* ne$$ x4 ,soon1 h[ev]1 we %all re/ore ! secret by sci5ce m p]fect4 ,0 ,*ri/ianity meant to n>r[ or to wid5 ! road to future happ9ess8 ,if ,i 7 translat$ to "s o!r planet1 ,i %\ld say3 #a4 ,no2 = x rais$ a f> high] /&>d--ergo1 made ! realization ( ?is f> m difficult4 #b4 ,yes2 = x introduc$ a new ma*9]y = realiz+ ?is /&>d3 7fir/7 ,*ri/'s atonem5t1 7second7 grace4 ,b1 accord+ to "s bigots 7z ,j]emy ,taylor & ,sir ,?omas ,br[ne71 z cit$ by ,col]idge1 ,*ri/ianity fir/ op5$ any road at all4 ,yet1 surely !y =get t1 if simply to come too e>ly 0 ! fatal b> to _! claims 9 ! case1 ,abraham1 ! fa!r ( ! fai?ful1 c\ld n b5efit4 ,ye/]day1 ,?ursday1 ,octob] #ba 7#ahdc71 ,i ?9k1 or ! day be=e1 ,i fir/ p]ceiv$ t ! fir/ great pro( ( ,*ri/ianity is ! pro( ( ,judaism1 & ! pro( ( t lies 9 ! ,jehovah4 ,:at m]ely natural man capable ( devis+ a ,god = himself su* z ! ,jewi%8 ,( all eradications ( ?is doctr9e 7( human progress71 ! mo/ difficult is t connect$ ) ! outw>d %[s--9 air1 9 col\r+1 9 =m1 9 gr\p+ ( ! great elem5ts compos+ ! furniture ( ! heav5s & ! e>?4 ,x is mo/ difficult1 ev5 :5 conf9+ "o's att5tion to ! mod]n case1 & neglect+ ! comp>ison ) ! anci5t1 at all to assign ! analysis ( ^? /eps by :i* to u ,*ri/ians 7b nev] be=e7 ! sea & ! sky & ! cl\ds & ! _m int]-modifications ( ^!1 ,a1 ,b1 ,c1 ,d1 & aga9 ! _m int]actions ( ! :ole1 ! sun 7,s471 ! moon 7,m471 ! noon 7,n4 ,s47--! brea?less1 sil5t noon--! gay aft]noon--! solemn glory ( sunset--! dove-l glimpse ( ,p>adise 9 ! t5d] light ( e>ly dawn--by :i* ^! obta9 a p[] utt]ly unkn[n1 undream$ (1 un9telligible to a ,pagan4 ,if we _h spok5 to ,plato--to ,cic]o--( ! deep pa?os 9 a sunset1 w\ld he--w\ld ei!r--h gone along ) u8 ,! fooli% read] ?9ks1 ,:y1 p]haps n1 n altoge!r z to ! quantity--! degree ( emotion4 ,d\btless1 x is und5iable t we mod]ns h f> m s5sibility to ! ph5om5a & visual glories ( ?is _w :i* we inhabit4 ,& x is possible t1 reflect+ on ! s+ul>ity ( ?is *>act]i/ic badge worn by mod]n civilization1 he may g s f> z to suspect t ,*ri/ianity has _h some?+ to d ) x4 ,b1 on seek+ to complete ! *a9 :i* connects !m1 he f9ds himself q unable to recov] ! pr9cipal l9k4 ,n[1 x w prove1 aft] all1 ev5 = myself :o h expos$ & reveal$ ^! new ligatures by :i* ,*ri/ianity connects man ) awful int]e/s 9 ! _w1 a mo/ insurm\ntable task to assign ! total nidus 9 :i* ?is new p[] resides1 or ! total ph5om5ology ?r\gh :i* t passes to & fro4 ,g5]ally x seems to /& ?us3 ,god reveals ,himself to u m or less dimly 9 va/ numb]s ( processes2 = example1 9 ^? ( vegetation1 animal gr[?1 cry/allization1 etc4 ,^! impress u n prim>ily1 b second>ily on reflection1 aft] consid]+ ! enormity ( *anges work$ annually1 & work+ ev5 at ! mom5t we speak4 ,!n1 aga91 o!r arrangem5ts ?r[ u m p[]fully ^u ! moral qualities ( ,god2 e4g41 we see ! f5ce1 ! %ell1 ! cov]+1 v>i$ 9 t5 million ways1 by :i* 9 buds & blossoms ,he insures ! ultimate protection ( ! fruit4 ,:at protection1 analog\s to ?is1 has ,he e/abli%$ = animals2 or1 tak+ up ! "q 9 ! ideal case1 = man1 ! supreme ( ,8 creatures8 ,we p]ceive t ,he has reli$ ^u love1 ^u love /r5g!n$ to ! adamant9e =ce ( insanity or delirium1 by ! m]e aspect ( utt]1 utt] helplessness 9 ! human infant4 ,x is n by p[]1 by means visibly develop$1 t ?is result is secur$1 b by means spiritual & 'transc5d5tal' 9 ! highe/ degree4 ,! bas5ess & incorrigible ignobility ( ! ,ori5tal m9d is se5 9 ! radical inability to appreciate ju/ice :5 br\ght into collision ) ! royal privileges ( rul]s t repres5t ! nation4 ,n only1 = example1 d ,turks1 etc41 ?9k x an ess5tial function ( royalty to cut (f heads1 b !y ?9k x ess5tial to ! consummation ( ?is function t ! sacrifice %\ld re/ ^u caprice kn[n & av[$4 ,to suppose x wick$ z a m]e process ( execut+ ! laws w\ld rob x ( all its gr&eur4 ,x w\ld /& = no?+4 ,nay1 ev5 if ! p[] 7 conc$$1 & ! sov]eign %\ld ab/a9 f us+ x ( 8 own free w & *oice1 ?is w\ld n satisfy ! wret*$ ,turk4 ,blood1 lawless blood--a horrid ,molo*1 surm\nt+ a grim company ( tortur]s & execution]s1 & on ! o!r side revell+ 9 a ?\s& uncons5t+ wom5--?is hide\s image ( brutal p[] & unv>ni%$ lu/ is cle>ly indisp5sable to ! ,turk z inc>nat+ ! repres5tative gr&eur ( 8 nation4 ,) ?is ideal ev] pres5t to ! ,asiatic & ,mohamm$an m9d1 no wond] t ev5 _! religion ne$s ! aid ( ! sword & blood%$ to secure conv]sion4 ,9 ! ,spectator is m5tion$1 z an ,ea/]n apologue1 t a vizi] :o 7l ,*auc]'s ,canace7 _h le>n$ ! language ( birds us$ x ) political effect to 8 sov]eign4 ,! sultan _h dem&$ to "k :at a c]ta9 rev]5d owl 0 spee*ify+ ab\t to ano!r owl di/antly relat$ to him4 ,! vizi] li/5$1 & report$ t ! lib]al old owl 0 mak+ a settlem5t ^u 8 daught]1 9 case 8 fri5d's son %\ld m>ry h]1 ( a doz5 ru9$ villages4 ,loyally long life to our noble sultan6 ,i %all1 my de> fri5d1 always h a ru9$ village at y\r s]vice aga9/ a ra9y day1 s long z our pres5t rul] reigns & desolates4 ,obliviscor jam injurias tuas1 ,clodia4--,?is is ab\t ! mo/ b>efac$ use ( ! rhetorical trick--viz41 to affect n to d1 to pass ov] :il/ actually do+ all ! :ile--t any:]e ,i h met )4--',pro ,clio1' p4 #bcd p4 #ce1 ,volgraff's edition4 ,evas]9t & compreh5d]9t4--,suppose !y _h ru%$ out1 & suppose !y _h seiz$ ,lic9us4 ,s ,i read--n iss5t4--,ibid41 p4 #bcf ,ibid41 p4 #dd4 ,velim vel potius quid nolim dic]e4--,ari/otle's case ( ?r[+ ov]bo>d y\r own prop]ty4 ,he vult dic]e1 else he c\ld n mean1 yet nonvult1 = he is %ock$ at say+ su* ?+s ( ,clodia4--,ibid41 p4 #bdb ,ibid41 p4 #di4 #b4--,,moral ,,& ,,practical4 ,morality4--,t ,paley's pr9ciple does n apply to ! high] morality ( ,*ri/ianity is evid5t f ?is3 :5 ,i seek to br+ be=e myself "s ord9>y =m ( wick$ness t all m5 (f5d by1 ,i ?9k1 p]haps1 ( _! +ratitude4 ,! man born to #djj a ye> ?9ks no?+ ( x1 comp>es himself only ) ^? above 8 own /&>d1 & sees r a gr\nd ( discont5t 9 8 #djj z n be+ #d1jjj ?an any gr\nd ( deep ?ankfulness4 ,n[1 ?is be+ s odi\s a =m ( immorality1 %\ld--by ,paley--t]m9ate 9 excessive evil4 ,on ! contr>y1 x is ! pr9ciple1 ! v dissatisfaction :i* ,god uses = keep+ ! _w mov+ 7h[ villa9\s ! =m--^! '+s'674 ,all fai? 9 ! great majority is1 & ought to be1 implicit4 ,t is1 y\r fai? is n unroll$--n sep>ately appli$ to ea* individual doctr9e--b is appli$ to "s individual man1 & on him y rely4 ,:at he says1 y say2 :at he believes1 y believe4 ,n[1 he believes all ^! doctr9es1 & y implicitly ?r\gh him4 ,b :at ,i *iefly say z ! object ( ?is note is1 t ! bulk ( m5 mu/ believe by an implicit fai?4 ,ergo1 decry x n4 ,y delude y\rself1 ,*ri/ian !ori/1 ) ! idea ( (f5ces t else w\ld unfit y = heav5 be+ wa%$ out by rep5tance4 ,b he>k5 a mom5t4 ,figure ! case ( ^? innum]able p t1 hav+ no temptation1 small or great1 to commit murd]1 w\ld h committ$ x *e]fully = half-a-cr[n2 t1 hav+ no op5+ or possibility = committ+ adult]y1 w\ld h committ$ x 9 case !y _h4 ,n[1 ( ^! p1 hav+ no possibility ( rep5tance 7= h[ rep5t ( :at !y h n done871 & yet ripe to excess = ! guilt1 :at w y say8 ,%all !y p]i% because !y might h be5 guilty8 ,%all !y n p]i% because ! pot5tial guilt 0 n1 by pure accid5t1 accompli%$ 9 esse8 ,"h is a mi/ake to be gu>d$ aga9/4 ,if y ask :y su* a man1 ?\gh by nature gross or ev5 ,swift-l 9 8 love ( dirty ideas1 yet1 because a g5tleman & mov+ 9 correspond+ society1 does n indulge 9 su* brutalities1 ! answ] is t he ab/a9s ?r\gh ! modifications ( ! sympa?ies4 ,a l[ man 9 l[ society w\ld n be d\btful ( its reception2 b he1 by ! anticipations ( sympa?y 7a =m t %\ld be introduc$ z te*nically z ,kant's anticipations ( p]ception71 feels x w\ld be ill or gloomily receiv$4 ,well n[1 ,i1 :5 say+ t a man is alt]$ by sympa?y s z to ?9k t1 ?r\gh means ( ?is p[]1 :i* o!rwise he w\ld n ?9k1 %all be int]pret$ ( su* a case z t above4 ,b wait2 !re is a di/9ction3 ! man does n ?9k diff]5tly1 he only acts z if he ?\ght diff]5tly4 ,! case ,i contemplate is f> o!rwise2 x is :]e a man feels a lively contempt or admiration 9 consequ5ce ( see+ or he>+ su* feel+s p[]fully express$ by a multitude1 or1 at lea/1 by o!rs :i* else he w\ld n h felt4 ,vulg> p w\ld sit = h\rs 9 ! pres5ce ( p ! mo/ ref9$1 totally unaw>e ( _! sup]iority1 = ! same reason t mo/ p 7if ass5t+ to ! praise ( ! ,"l's ,pray]7 w\ld d s hyp]-critically1 because its real & *ief beauties are negative4 ,n only is x false t my und]/&+ is no measure or rule = ano!r man1 b ( necessity x is s1 & e /ep ,i take t[>ds tru? = myself is a /ep made on behalf ( e o!r man4 ,we d\bt if ! _w 9 ! s5se ( a syn!sis ( action--! procession & c>ry+ out ( ends & purposes--c\ld consi/ ) ! ,greek3 anti-_w 79 a religi\s s5se74 ,m5 :o divide all into pi\s p & next to devils see 9 su* a /ate ( evil ! natural t5d5cy 7z 9 all o!r mon/r\s evils--:i* ?is mu/ be if an evil at all7 to correction & r$ress4 ,b n[ assume a man1 sob]1 hon\rable1 *e]ful1 heal?y1 active1 occupi$ all day long 9 toilsome duties 7or :at he believes duties7 = ends n selfi%2 ?is man has nev] _h a ?\ght ( dea?1 hell1 etc41 & look+ abroad on ^? :o dwell 9 su* contemplations1 he reg>ds !m s9c]ely1 n unk9dly or ) contempt2 p>tially he respects !m1 b he looks on !m z "u a mon/r\s delusion1 9 a fev]1 9 a panic1 z 9 a case ( brok5 equilibrium4 ,n[ he is "r4 ,&1 moreov]1 secondly1 two o!r feel+s or suspicions come on1 7#a7 ( hypocrisy1 7#b7 ( ! violation ( inn] %ame 9 publi%+ ! mo/ awful private feel+s4 ,! ,t5d5cy ( a ,good ,=tune inh]it$4--,i "k n t any man has reason to wi% a suffici5t patrimonial e/ate = 8 son4 ,mu* to h some?+ s z to />t ) an advantage4 ,b ! natural consequ5ce ( hav+ a full =tune is to become idle & vapid4 ,=1 on ask+ :at a "y man has t he c employ himself ^u1 ! answ] w\ld be1 ',oh6 :y1 ^? pursuits :i* presuppose solitude4' ,at once y feel ?is to be holl[ nons5se4 ,n "o man 9 t5 ?\s& has p[]s to turn solitude into a bless+4 ,!y c>e n1 e4g41 = geometry2 & ! cause is *iefly t !y h be5 ill taught 9 geometry2 & ! effect is t geometry mu/ & w langui%1 if treat$ z a m]e amateur pursuit4 ,s ( any o!r4 ,secondly1 yet ( ,engli%m5 ,i mu/ say t beyond all nations a man s situat$ does n1 9 fact1 become idle4 ,he x is1 & 8 class1 t dis*>ge ! public bus9ess ( ea* c\nty or di/rict4 ,?irdly3 ,& 9 ! view1 7 !re no o!r1 "o sees at once ! use ( fox-hunt+1 let x be z boi/]\s z y please4 ,is x n bett] to be boi/]\s ?an gossip-ridd51 eaves-dropp+1 seek+ alim5t = ! spirits 9 ! petty sc&al ( ! neighb\rhood8 ',he' 7,! ,times7 'decl>es t ! poore/ artisan has a great] /ake ?an !y' 7'! ,l&$ ,int]e/'7 '9 ! prosp]ity ( ! c\ntry1 & is1 consequ5tly1 m likely to give s\nd advice4 ,8 exposition ( ! intimate connection exi/+ betwe5 ! welf>e ( ! poor workman & ! welf>e ( ! c\ntry is bo? j & admirable4 ,b he manife/ly und]rates ! correspond+ relations ( ! l&[n]s1 & :olly omits to %[1 ev5 if ! artisan's /ate 7 ! greate/1 h[ 8 op9ions are likely to be mo/ valuable4 ,to suppose t a man is necess>ily ! be/ judge 9 :atev] conc]ns him mo/ is a sad non-sequitur2 = if self-int]e/ ensur$ wisdom1 no "o w\ld ev] g wrong 9 any?+4 ,e man w\ld be 8 own m9i/]1 & e invalid w\ld be 8 own be/ physician4 ,! w\nd$ limbs ( ! community are ! be/ judges ( ! pa9 !y suff]2 b x is ! wise heads ( ! community t be/ c apply a rem$y t be/ c cure ! w\nd )\t caus+ x to break out 9 ano!r qu>t]4 ,pov]ty is bl9d2 b ! upp] classes education has enlight5$1 & habit made =esee+4' ,we live 9 times great f ! ev5ts & little f ! "* ( ! actors4 ,e mon? summons u to ! spectacle ( "s new p]fidy 9 ! lead]s ( p>ties & ! mo/ conspicu\s public s]vants2 & ! pr(ligacy :i* we *>ge ^u ! /atesm5 ( ! sev5te5? c5tury has revolv$ 9 full measure ^u our own days4 ,ju/ifications ( ,novels4--,! two foll[+ ju/ifications ( novels occur to me4 ,fir/ly1 t if "s dreadful crisis await$ a %ip ( pass5g]s at ! l9e--:]e equally ! dang] 0 my/]i\s & multi=m1 ! safety my/]i\s & multi=m--h[ mon/r\s if a man %\ld say to a lady1 ',:at are y read+8' ',oh1 ,i'm read+ ab\t our dreadful crisis1 n[ s ne>'2 & he %\ld answ]1 ',oh1 nons5se6 read some?+ to improve y\r m9d2 read ab\t ,alex&] ! ,great1 ab\t ,spurius ,ahala1 ab\t ,caius ,grac*us1 or1 if y please1 ,tib]ius4' ,b j su* nons5se x is1 :5 p ridicule read+ romances 9 :i* ! great ev5t ( ! fiction is ! real great ev5t ( a female life4 ,!re are o!rs1 y say--%e loses a *ild4 ,yes1 t's a great ev5t4 ,b t arises out ( ?is va/ equ9octial ev5t4 ,secondly1 z all ?+s are pr$ispos$ to ! natures :i* mu/ be surr\nd$ by !m1 s we may see t ! elem5t ( social evolution ( "*1 mann]s1 caprices1 etc41 has be5 adapt$ to ! va/ mass ( human m9ds4 ,x is a mean elem5t1 y say4 ,! revelations ( ,alb]t ,smi?1 ,dick5s1 etc41 are ess5tially mean1 vulg>1 plebeian1 n only 9 an ari/ocratic s5se1 b also 9 a philosophical s5se4 ,true1 b ! m9ds t are to live & move 9 x are also mean1 ess5tially mean4 ,no?+ gr& 9 !m8 ,yes1 d\btless 9 ! v]ie/ grub z to capacity1 b ! capacity is undevelop$4 ,ergo1 z to ! intrigue or fable1 & z to ! conduct or evolution ( ?is fable--novels mu/ be ! *ief natural res\rce ( woman4 ,moral ,c]ta9ty4--,z t a *ild ( two ye>s 7or "u7 is n p>ty to a plot4 ,n[1 ?is w\ld all[ a %ade ( d\bt--a *ild s old might cry out or give notice4 ,?is mon/r\s repres5tation t ! great w> ) ,france 7#ahjc-ae7 _h = its object to prev5t ,napoleon f sitt+ on ! ?rone ( ,france--:i* rec5tly1 9 contempt ( all tru? & common-s5se1 ,i h s repeat$ly se5 advanc$--?r[s a man pr(\ndly on ! "q ( :at 0 ! object ( t w>4 ,surely1 9 s f> z we are conc]n$1 ! matt] 0 settl$ at ,ami5s 9 ! v fir/ ye> ( ! c5tury4 ,decemb]1 #agii1 ,napoleon _h be5 suff]$ by ! un/eady public op9ion ( ,france--abhorr+ a ma/]1 & yet s5sible t = ! *ief consci\s necessity ( ,france1 viz41 a develop] ( h] lat5t m>tial p[]s1 %e mu/ look = a ma/] or else h h] p[]s squ&]$--to m\nt ! consul> ?rone4 ,he liv$1 he c\ld live1 only by victori\s w>4 ,mo/ p]il\s 0 ! prospect = ,engl&4 ,9 ! pa? :i* n ,napoleon1 b ,france1 0 n[ prep>+ to tread1 & :i* 0 ! pa? ( ,napoleon no o!rwise ?an t he 0 ! tool ( ,france1 0 t s]vitor :o mu/ gratify h] gr& infirmity or else be rapidly ext+ui%$ himself1 unhappily = h]self1 ,engl& 0 ! ma9 c\nt]-*ampion4 ,! c\rse ( hon\r left to ,engl& 0 too fatally ! c\rse ( resi/ance4 ,resi/ance to :at8 ,to ,napoleon p]sonally8 ,n at all2 b to ,napoleon z pl$g$ by 8 de/9y to ! prosecution ( a ,fr5* conqu]+ policy4 ,t p]sonally ,engl& _h no ho/ility to ,napoleon is settl$ by ! fact t %e _h at ,ami5s *e]fully conc$$ ! sup]ior p[]4 ,"u :at title8 w\ld h be5 ! mo/ *ildi% ( demurs4 ,t by act %e nev] conc$$ ! title ( emp]or 0 ! m]e natural diplomatic result ( nev] hav+ once be5 at peace ) ,napoleon "u t title4 ,else x 0 a po9t ( entire indiff]5ce4 ,grant+ ! consul%ip1 %e _h grant$ all t c\ld be ask$4 ,& :at %e oppos$ 0 ! det]m9$ w> c\rse ( ,napoleon & ! s*emes ( ultra-,poli% p>tition to :i* ,napoleon _h privately tempt$ h] "u circum/ances ( no su* s5se z exi/$ & /ill exi/ = ,russia4 ,?is policy1 z soon z expos$1 & n be=e bitt] insults to h]self1 ,engl& resi/$4 ,& !re=e x is t at ?is day we live4 ,b z to ,napoleon1 z ap>t f ! policy ( ,napoleon1 no *ildi%ness c be wild]4 ,at "s unlucky mom5t :5 ! ,cr[n comm&$ unusual res\rces1 ! ,de ,qu9ceys met ) ! fate ascrib$1 p]haps fabul\sly1 to "s small heav5ly bodies 7a/]oids or :at1 ,i d n precisely "k73 on "s d>k day1 by mi/ake p]haps1 !y explod$1 & scatt]$ _! ru9s all ov] ! c5tral prov9ces ( ,engl&1 :]e *iefly _h la9 _! t]ritorial influ5ce4 ,especially 9 ! c\nties ( ,leice/]1 ,l9coln & ,rutl& 7 f\nd fragm5ts ( ! va/ l&$ e/ates held by ^! pot5tates :5 ,e>ls ( ,w9*e/]4 ,! hatr$ ( tru? at fir/ dawn+--t in/9ct :i* makes y revolt f ! pure beams :i* se>* ! f\l dep?s & abysses ( error--is well illu/rat$ by ! action ( ! atmosph]ic curr5ts1 :5 bl[+ ?r\gh an op5 w9d[ ^u smoke4 ,:at d y see8 ,sometimes ! impression is /rong ^u y\r ocul> belief t ! w9d[ is driv+ ! smoke 94 ,y c h>dly be conv9c$ ( ! contr>y--sc>cely :5 five or sev5 m9utes has absolutely r>efi$ ! smoke s mu* t a book-lett]+ previ\sly invisible has become ev5 legible4 ,& at la/1 :5 ! fact1 ! result1 ! exp]i5ce1 has correct$ ! contradictory !ory ( ! eye1 y beg9 to suspect1 )\t any aid f sci5ce1 t !re 7 two curr5ts1 "o ( :i* comes r\nd 9 a curve ,illu/ration3 7 & effects ! exit = ! o!r :i* ! w9d[ _h driv5 92 j z 9 ! ,/raits ( ,gibralt> !re is manife/ly an upp] curr5t sett+ "o way1 :i* y !re=e conjecture to argue a l[] curr5t sett+ ! o!r1 & ?us r$ress+ ! equilibrium4 ,"h ! smoke corresponds to bits ( *ip or any loose susp5d$ body 9 ! ,gibralt> curr5t4 ,:at answ]s to ! curr5t ( wat] is ! air1 & if ! equilibrium is kept up1 ! re-entrant curr5t balances y\r retir+ curr5t1 & ! latt] c>ries out ! smoke entangl$ 9 itself4 ,by ! objection1 say1 ( a *ild1 !re ought to be a re-entrant column ( smoke1 :i* !re is n4 ,= ! air drives ! smoke ( ! fire up ! *imney1 & ( its own contribution ! air has no smoke to give4 ,or ! ,augean /able may image x4 ,d\btless :5 ! fir/ di/urbance took place 9 ! abom9able mess1 ^? act+ w\ld be apt to "q = a mom5t :e!r x _h n be5 m advisable to leave x alone4 ,morali/s say1 ',nobody w attack y1 or hate y1 or blame y = y\r virtues4' ,:at falsehood6 ,n z virtues1 x may be 9 _! eyes1 b virtues1 nev]!less4 ,connect ) ,kant ! error ( suppos+ tas p>5tum1 etc41 to be ! doctr9e ( s94 ,n = :at y h done1 b = :at y are--n because 9 life y did =sake a wife & *ildr5--did endure to eat & dr9k & lie s(tly y\rself :il/ ^? :o %\ld h be5 z y\r he>t-drops 7 />v+3 n because y did t s mu* is =giv5 y1 b because y 7 capable ( t1 !re=e y are incapable ( heav54 ,immode/y4--,! greate/ mi/ake occurs to me n[ 7,w$nesday1 ,april #ag?1 '#dd74 ,a girl :o %\ld h be5 unhappily consci\s ( voluptu\s h\rs1 h] y w\ld call mode/ 9 case ( h] pass+ ) d[nca/ looks4 ,b :y1 !n1 is %e n s8 ,t girl is immode/ :o reconciles to h]self su* ?+s1 & yet assumes ! look ( innoc5ce4 ,ab\t ,wom54--,a man br+s 8 own idle preconceptions1 & fancies t he has le>n$ !m f 8 exp]i5ce4 ,f> m to be fe>$ ?an any dep? ( s]i\s love1 h[ev] absorb+ & app>5tly fooli%1 is t vici\s condition 9 :i* trifl+ takes ! place ( all s]i\s love1 :5 wom5 are view$ only z dolls1 & address$ ) an odi\s le] ( affect$ kn[+ness z 'my de>1' w9k1 etc4 ,n[ to ?is t5ds ! false condition ( wom5 :5 call$ '! ladies4' ,on ! o!r h&1 :at an awful elevation arises :5 ea* views 9 ! o!r a creature capable ( ! same noble duties--%e no less ?an he a creature ( l(ty aspirations2 %e by ! same "r a daught] ( ,god z he a son ( ,god2 %e be>+ h] eyes erect to ! heav5s no less ?an he6 ,l[ ,degree4--,we see (t5 t ?is takes place v /rongly & decid$ly ) reg>d to m51 notori\sly pleasant m5 & rem>kably good-natur$1 :i* %[s at once 9 :at road ! ?+ travels4 ,& if su* a nature %\ld be comb9$ ) :at ,butl] ?9ks virtue1 x might be d\btful to :i* ( ! two ! tribute ( k9d att5tions 7 paid2 b n[ see+ ! true case1 we "k h[ to int]pret ?is hypo!tical case ( ,butl]'s accord+ly4 ',visit ! s9s ( ! fa!rs1' etc4 ,?is p pret5d to ?9k mon/r\s4 ,yet :at else 9 effect happ5s & mu/ happ5 to ,jews inh]it+ by filial ob$i5ce & natural sympa?y all t anti-,*ri/ian ho/ility :i* prevail$ 9 ! age succe$+ to t ( ,*ri/8 ,:at evil--( suff]+1 ( p5alties n[ or 9 res]ve may be atta*$ to ?is _s ( ho/ility--foll[s ! *ildr5 ?r\gh all g5]ations6 ,case ( ,timoleon1 ^: kill+ ( 8 bro!r might aft]w>ds be read into ,x ,y ,z or into ,x a b accord+ to 8 conduct 7ei!r into murd] or patriotism71 is a good illu/ration ( syn!sis4 ,to illu/rate ,cic]o's argum5t 9 ',pro ,clio' z to ! frequ5cy ( m5 wild & dissipat$ 9 y\? becom+ em95t citiz5s1 "o might adduce ?is case f ! ^w ,!mi/ocles 9 ! ,index to ! ,grci ,rhetorici4 ,b ,i see or ,i fancy cause to notice ?is passage = ! foll[+ cause3 x conta9s only n9e words1 f\r 9 ! fir/ comma1 five 9 ! la/1 & ( ^! n9e f\r are tak5 up 9 not+ ! "t ,greek3 to prton to tel52 ergo1 five words record ! rem>kable revolution f "o /ate to ano!r1 & ! "* ( ea* /ate4 ,two cases ( "y m5's dissipation--#a4 ,horace's record ( 8 fa!r's advice3 ',concessa1' etc42 #b4 ,cic]o's ',pro ,clio4' ,:at ,crot*ets 9 e ,direction6--#a4 ,! ,g]mans1 or1 let me speak m correctly1 "s ( ! ,g]mans 7& d\btless full ( ,ho* be] or /rong dr9k71 f\nd out "s ?irty ye>s ago t !re 7 only ?ree m5 ( g5ius 9 ! records ( our planet4 ,& :o 7 !y8 7#a7 ,hom]2 7#b7 ,%akespe>e2 7#c7 ,goe!4 ,s t absolutely ,milton 0 %ut out f ! con/ellation4 ,ev5 he want$ a ticket1 ?\gh ,ma/] ,sorr[s-(-,w]!r _h "o4 ,! port]1 x seems1 fanci$ he _h no m>riage g>m5t1 a mi/ake :i* a mob might correct1 say+1 ',no m>riage g>m5t6 !n1 damme1 he %all h ?is fell['s' 7viz41 ,goe!'s74 ,! tr9ity1 accord+ to ^! vagabonds1 0 complete )\t ,milton1 z ! ,roman pomp 0 full to ! eye ( ! sycophant )\t ! bu/ ( ,brutus4 #b4 ,macaulay fanci$ !re 7 only two m5 ( g5ius 9 ! reign ( ,*>les ,,ii41 viz41 ,milton & ! t9k] ,bunyan4 #c4 ,col]idge 7p4 #bcg1 ',table-,talk'7 fanci$ !re 7 only two m5 ( g5ius 9 8 own g5]ation3 ,w4 ,w4 & ,sir ,humphrey ,davy4 ,j]emy ,taylor hav+ m5tion$ two religi\s m51 ,/4 ,paul ! ,h]mit & ,sulpitius1 z hav+ aton$ = "s suppos$ fooli% g>rulities1 ! "o by a ?ree ye>s' sil5ce1 ! o!r by a lifelong sil5ce1 goes on to express 8 dissatisfaction ) a mode ( rabiosa sil5tia s memorable z ?is4 ,yet x is c]ta9 9 sil5ce !re is wisdom1 & !re may be deep religion4 ,& inde$ x is c]ta91 great k1 if x be )\t vanity1 is ! mo/ sev]e bridle ( ! tongue4 ,= s ,i h he>d t all ! noises & prat+ ( ! pool1 ! croak+ ( frogs & toads1 is hu%$ & appeas$ ^u ! in/ant ( br++ ^u !m ! light ( a c&le or tor*4 ,e beam ( reason & ray ( k *ecks ! dissolut5ess ( ! tongue4 ',ut quisque contemplissimus e/1 ita solutissim l+u e/1' said ,s5eca4 ,! sil5ce mu/ be ,greek3 kairios1 n sull5 & ill-natur$2 'nam sic etiam tacuisse nocet'8--( all ?+s 9 ! _w a prat+ religion & mu* talk 9 holy ?+s does mo/ pr(ane ! my/]i\sness ( x1 & dismantles its reg>d1 & makes *eap its rev]5ce & takes (f fe> & awfulness1 & makes x loose & g>i%1 & l ! laught]s ( drunk5ness4 ,public ,morality4--,x ought n to be left to a man's int]e/ m]ely to protect ! animals 9 8 p[]4 ,dogs are no long] work$ 9 ! way !y 71 al?\gh ! *ange mu/ h arbitr>ily robb$ _m poor m5 ( half bread4 ,b 9 a case z valuable z t ( ! horse1 x has be5 kn[n t a man has incurr$ ! total ru9 ( a s]ies ( horses aga9/ ev5 8 own ga9 or self-int]e/4 ,!re ought to be a cu/os vet]anorum1 a keep] & protector ( ! poor brutes :o are br\ght )9 ! pale ( social use & s]vice4 ,! difficulty1 y say6 ,legislation has met & dealt effectively ) f> m complicat$ & m9ute matt]s ?an t4 ,=1 aft] all1 consid] h[ few ( ! brute creation on any wide & p]man5t scale are br\ght into ! s*eme ( human life4 ,"s birds z food1 "s fi%es z ditto2 beeves z food & sometimes z appli]s ( /r5g?2 horses 9 bo? *>act]s4 ,^! ) elephants & camels1 mules1 asses1 goats1 dogs1 & %eep1 cats & rabbits1 gold-fi%es & s++-birds1 really compose ! :ole ( our animal equipage h>ness$ to ! c> ( human life4 #c4--,on ,words ,& ,/yle4 ,!re are a numb] ( words :i*1 unlock$ f _! absurd imprisonm5t1 w\ld become ext5sively useful4 ,we %\ld say1 = in/ance1 'condign hon\rs1' 'condign treatm5t' 7treatm5t appropriate to ! m]its71 ?us at once realiz+ two rational purposes1 viz41 giv+ a useful function to a ^w1 :i* at pres5t has none1 & also provid+ an intelligible expression = an idea :i* o!rwise is left )\t means ( utt]+ itself except ?r\gh a pond]\s circumlocution4 ,precisely 9 ! same circum/ances ( idle & absurd seque/ration /&s ! t]m polemic4 ,at pres5t1 accord+ to ! popul> usage1 ?is ^w has "s fanta/ic inali5able connection ) controv]sial !ology4 ,!re _c be a m *ildi% *im]a4 ,no d\bt !re is a polemic side or aspect ( !ology2 b s !re is ( all k2 s !re is ( e sci5ce4 ,! radical & *>act]i/ic idea conc]n$ 9 ?is t]m polemic is f\nd 9 our own ,p>liam5t>y di/9ction ( ! good speak]1 z contra/$ ) ! good debat]4 ,! good speak] is he :o unfolds ! :ole ( a "q 9 its affirmative aspects1 :o pres5ts ^! aspects 9 _! j proportions1 & accord+ to _! ord]ly & symmetrical d$uctions f ea* o!r4 ,b ! good debat] is he :o faces ! negative aspects ( ! "q1 :o meets sudd5 objections1 has an answ] = any mom5t>y summons ( d\bt or difficulty1 dissipates seem+ inconsi/5cies1 & reconciles ! geometrical smoo?ness ( priori ab/ractions ) ! co>se angul>ities ( practical exp]i5ce4 ,! great "w ( ,ric>do is ( necessity1 & almo/ 9 e page1 polemic2 :il/ v (t5 ! p>ticul> objections or difficulties1 to :i* x replies1 are n indicat$ at all1 be+ spread ?r\gh entire sy/ems1 & assum$ z precognita t are famili> to ! le>n$ /ud5t4 ,writ+ to s*ola/ic p]sons1 ,i %\ld be a%am$ to expla91 b hop+ t ,i write to _m also ( ! non-s*ola/ic1 & ev5 ( ! unle>n$1 ,i rejoice to expla9 ! prop] s5se ( ! ^w implicit4 ,z ! ^w condign1 s capable ( an ext5d$ s5se1 is yet con/antly re/rict$ to "o mis]able association1 viz41 t ) ! ^w puni%m5t 7= we nev] say1 z we might say1 'condign rew>ds'71 s also ! ^w implicit is 9 ,engli% always associat$ ) ! ^w fai?4 ,p say t ,papi/s h an implicit fai? 9 _! prie/s4 ,:at !y mean is ?is3 ,if a piece ( arras1 or a c>pet1 is fold$ up1 !n x is implicit accord+ to ! orig9al ,lat9 ^w2 if x is unfold$ & display$1 !n x is explicit4 ,!re=e1 :5 a poor illit]ate man 7suppose a bog-trott] ( ,mayo or ,galway7 says to 8 prie/ 7z 9 effect always he does say71 ',sir1 ,i _c compreh5d all ?is doctr9e2 bless y1 ,i h n ! ?\s&? "p ( ! le>n+ = x1 s x is impossible t ,i %\ld directly believe x4 ,b y\r rev]5ce believes x1 ! ?+ is wrapt up 7implicit7 9 y1 & ,i believe x on t acc\nt4' ,"h ! prie/ believes explicitly3 he believes implicitly4 ,mod]n4--,is x n %ameful t to ?is h\r ev5 lit]>y m5 ( cr$it & repute _c = ! life ( !m int]pret ?is l9e f ',z ,y ,l ,x'-- ',full ( wise saws & mod]n in/ances'8 ,a man z well read z ,mr4 ,!odore ,hook1 & _m a hundr$ beside1 h s]i\sly und]/ood x to mean ',full ( old prov]bs1 ! tradition>y wisdom ( nations1 & ( illu/rative examples drawn f mod]n exp]i5ce4' ,nons5se6 ,! mean+ is1 ',full ( old maxims & prov]bs1 & ( trivial attempts at argum5t4' ,t is1 t$i\sly r$undant 9 rules d]iv$ f ! treasury ( popul> prov]bs1' & 9 feeble attempts at connect+ ^! g5]al rules ) ! special case be=e him4 ,! sup]annuat$ old magi/rate sets out ) a prov]b1 z = in/ance ?is1 t ! "m ( mis*ief is no bigg] ?an a midge's w+4 ,t prov]b =ms 8 major proposition4 ,9 8 m9or proposition he goes on to argue t ! trespass *>g$ ^u ! p>ticul> prison] be=e him 0 v little bigg] ?an a midge's w+4 ,& !n 9 8 conclusion triumphantly he inf]s1 ,ergo1 ! prison] at ! b> is ! "m ( mis*ief4 ,b says ! con/able1 ',please1 y\r wor%ip1 ! prison] is a man1 a hulk+ clodhopp]1 "s six or sev5 feet high1 ) a /rong black be>d4' ',well1 t makes no odds1' rejo9s 8 wor%ip2 '!n he's ! fa!r ( mis*ief4 ,cl]k1 make out 8 mittimus4' ,! ^w 'in/ance' 7f ! s*ola/ic in/antia7 nev] meant example 9 ,%akespe>e's age4 ,! ^w 'mod]n' nev] once 9 ,%akespe>e means :at x means to u 9 ^! days4 ,ev5 ! monki% ,lat9 ^w 'mod]nus' fluctuat$ 9 mean+1 & did n always imply rec5s1 neot]icus2 b 9 ,%akespe>e nev]4 ,:at does x mean 9 ,%akespe>e8 ,once & = ev] x means trivial1 inconsid]able4 ,dr4 ,johnson _h too mu* feel+ n to p]ceive t ! ^w 'mod]n' _h ?is value 9 ,%akespe>e's acceptation2 practically1 he felt t x avail$ = t s5se1 b !oretically he c\ld n make out ! :y4 ,x means t1 said ! ,doctor2 b feebly & qu]ul\sly1 l "o sick ( ! pip1 he add$1 ',yet ,i don't "k :y4' ,don't y8 ,n[1 we d4 ,! fact is1 ,dr4 ,johnson 0 9 a fit ( ! dismals at t "t2 he _h rec5tly committ$ a debau* ( tea1 hav+ exce$$ 8 usual all[ance by sev5ty-five cups1 s t naturally he _h a 'curmurr+' 9 ! /oma*4 ,else he c\ld n h fail$ to see :at we are n[ go+ to expla9 ) a wet f+]4 ,ev]ybody is aw>e t to be mat]ial is ! v opposite ( be+ trivial4 ,:at is 'mat]ial' 9 a *a9 ( evid5ce1 or 9 an argum5t1 c nev] be trifl+4 ,n[1 !re=e1 if y c f9d a ^w t w flatly contradict ?is ^w mat]ial1 !n y h a capital t]m = express+ :at is trivial4 ,well1 y f9d 9 ! ^w immat]ial all t y are seek+4 ',x is q immat]ial' w suit ,mr4 ,t\ts's purpose j z well z ',x is really ( no consequ5ce1 ( no consequ5ce 9 ! _w4' ,to say 9 a law c\rt t ! objection is immat]ial is o!rwise to say t x is trivial4 ,"h1 !n1 is ! fir/ /ep3 to contradict ! idea ( mat]ial is effectually to express ! idea ( trivial4 ,let u n[ see if we c f9d any o!r contradiction to ! idea ( mat]ial1 = "o anti!sis to t idea w express z well z any o!r anti!sis ! c\nt]pole ( ! trivial4 ,n[1 cle>ly ! sub/ance ( a ?+1 ! mat]ial out ( :i* x is made1 is (t5times ( great importance by comp>ison ) its %ape1 fa%ion1 or mode4 ,x is ( value 9 y\r eyes to "k :e!r y\r family plate is 9 sub/ance ( gold or ( silv]2 b :e!r su* a vessel is r\nd or squ>e1 ornam5t$ ) a wrea? ( acan?us or ivy1 support$ by tig]s or by fawns1 may be a trivial consid]ation1 or ev5 worse2 = ! fa%ion ( y\r plate1 aft] x has once become obsolete1 may c\nt aga9/ y = s mu* loss z some?+ t w co/ a good deal ( money to alt]4 ,"h1 !n1 is ano!r contradiction to ! mat]ial1 & !re=e ano!r expression = ! trivial3 matt]1 z aga9/ vacancy or ! privation ( matt]1 yields ! anti!sis ( mat]ial or immat]ial1 sub/antial & unsub/antial2 matt]1 z aga9/ =m1 yields ! anti!sis ( sub/ance & %ape1 or o!rwise ( mat]ial & modal--:at is matt] & :at is ! m]e modification ( matt]1 its v>iation by means ( ornam5t or %ape4 ,! ^w 'mod]n' is !re=e 9 ,%akespe>e uni=mly to be pron\nc$ ) ! long o1 z 9 ! words modal1 modi%1 & nev] ) ! %ort o ( m7od]ate1 m7ode/1 or our pres5t ^w m7od]n4 ,& ! law "u :i* ,%akespe>e uses ! ^w is ?is3 :atsoev] is s trivial z to fall into ! relation ( a m]e %ape or fleet+ mode to a p]man5t sub/ance1 t ) ,%akespe>e is modi%1 or 7accord+ to 8 =m7 mod]n4#bi ,?us1 a weak1 trivial argum5t 7or in/antia1 ! s*ola/ic t]m = an argum5t n lat5t m]ely1 or m]ely hav+ ! (fice ( su/a9+ a tru?1 b urg$ z an objection1 hav+ ! polemic (fice ( contradict+ an oppon5t7 is 9 ,%akespe>e's idiom1 :5 view$ z aga9/ a sub/antial argum5t1 a mod]n argum5t4 ,aga91 :5 ,cleopatra1 def5d+ h]self aga9/ ! p]fidy ( h] /ew>d1 wi%es to impress ^u ,octavius t any articles :i* %e may h kept back f ! inv5tory ( h] p]sonal *attels are b trifles1 %e expresses ?is by say+ t !y are b ',su* z we greet mod]n fri5ds )al2' i4e41 su* z we be/[1 at welcom+ or at p>t+1 ^u ! slighte/ acqua9tances4 ,! :ole /ress ( ! logic lies ^u ! epi!t mod]n--= simply z fri5ds1 _h !y be5 sub/antial fri5ds1 !y might h levi$ any am\nt f ! royal lady's b\nty2 k+doms w\ld h be5 slight gifts 9 h] eyes1 & t w\ld soon h be5 object$ to by h] conqu]or4 ,b h] argum5t is1 t ! p to :om su* gifts w\ld be comm5surate are m]e modi% fri5ds1 p]sons kn[n to u on t]ms ( b>e civility1 p ) :om we ex*ange salutations 9 ! /reet1 or occasional calls1 :at n[ we call acqua9tances1 = :om 9 ,%akespe>e's "t !re 0 no di/+ui%+ expression4 ,ano!r case we rememb] at ?is mom5t 9 ',all's ,well t ,ends ,well4' ,x occurs 9 ,act ,,ii41 at ! v op5+ ( sc5e iii42 ! p>ticul> edition1 ! only "o we c comm& at ! mom5t1 is an obscure "o publi%$ by ,scott1 ,web/] & ,ge>y1 ,*>t]h\se ,squ>e1 #ahdj1 & we m5tion x ?us circum/antially because ! passage is falsely punctuat$2 & we h little d\bt t 9 all o!r editions1 :e!r ) or )\t ! false punctuation1 ! syntax is g5]ally misappreh5d$4 ,9 reality1 ! false punctuation has itself gr[n out ( ! false appreh5sion ( ! syntax1 & n vice v]s4 ,?us ! words /& lit]atim et punctuatim3 ',!y say1 miracles are pa/3 & we h our philosophical p]sons to make mod]n & famili> ?+s1 sup]natural & causeless4' ,! comma ought to h be5 plac$ aft] 'famili>1' ! s5se be+ ?is--& we h among/ u sceptical & irreligi\s p to repres5t z trivial & ( daily occurr5ce ?+s :i* 9 reality are sup]natural & causeless 7t is1 n ly+ among/ ! succession ( physical causes & effects1 b s5t z miracles by ! imm$iate ag5cy ( ,god74 ,accord+ to ! true s5se1 ?+s sup]natural & causeless mu/ be und]/ood z ! subject1 ( :i* mod]n & famili> is ! pr$icate4 ,mr4 ,gr9don fancies t frog is d]iv$ f ! syllable ,greek3 tra* 7k7 ( ,greek3 batra*os4 ,?is w cause "s p to smile1 & recall ,m5age's pleasantry ab\t ,alfana1 ! man ( ,orl&o2 ,x is true t frog at fir/ sight seems to h no lett] 9 common except ! sn>l+ lett] 7lit]a can9a74 ,b ?is is n s2 ! a & ! o1 ! s & ! k1 are p]haps ess5tially ! same4 ,& ev5 9 ! case :]e1 positively & lit]ally1 n a s+le lett] is id5tical1 x is odd1 b und5iable1 t ! two words may be ne>ly alli$ z "m & *ild4 ,"o in/ance is notori\s1 b x is wor? cit+ = a purpose ( in/ructive inf]5ce4 ',j\rnal1' z a ,fr5* ^w1 or1 if y please1 z an ,engli% ^w--:5ce came t8 ,unque/ionably & demon/rably f ! ,lat9 ^w dies1 9 :i*1 h[ev]1 visibly !re is n "o lett] ! same z any "o ( ! sev5 t are 9 j\rnal4 ,yet m>k ! rapidity ( ! transition4 ,dies 7a day7 has = its d]ivative adjective daily ! ^w diurnus4 ,n[1 ! old ,roman pronunciation ( diu 0 exactly ! same z gio1 bo? be+ pron\nc$ z our ,engli% jorn4 ,"h1 9 a mom5t1 we see ! :ole--giorno1 a day1 0 n d]iv$ directly f dies1 b second>ily ?r\gh diurnus4 ,!n foll[$ giornal1 = a di>y1 or regi/] ( a day1 & f t to ,fr5*1 z also1 ( c\rse1 ! ,engli% j\rnal4 ,b ! moral is1 t :5 to ! eye no lett] is ! same1 may x n be s to ! e>8 ,already ! di ( dies anticipates & enfolds ! giorno4 ,mr4 ,gr9don ju/ly rem>ks ^u ! t5d5cy1 9 _m in/ances1 ( ! ,g]man ss to reappe> 9 ,engli% =ms z t4 ,?us heiss 7hot71 fuss 7foot71 etc4 ,^! are ,mr4 ,gr9don's own examples1 & a /rik+ confirmation occurs 9 ! old ,engli% hight1 us$ = he 0 call$1 & aga9 = ! p>ticiple call$1 & aga91 9 ! ',met4 ,romanus1' = ,i 0 call$3 ',lorde1 he saide1 ,i high? ,segram\r4' ,n[1 ! ,g]man is heiss5 7to be call$74 ,& ?is is a t5d5cy hidd5 9 _m long ages3 z1 = in/ance1 9 ,greek1 e p]son mu/ rememb] ! transition ( ,greek3 tt & ,greek3 ss z 9 ,greek3 ?att1 ,greek3 ?ass4 ,on ,pronunciation & ,spell+4--,if we are to surr5d] ! old v]nacul> s\nd ( ! e 9 c]ta9 situations to a ridicul\s criticism ( ! eye1 & 9 defiance ( ! prote/s ris+ up clamor\sly f e qu>t] ( old ,engli% s*ol>%ip1 let u at lea/ "k to :at we surr5d]4 ,:at lett] is to usurp ! vacant seat8 ,:at lett]8 retorts ! puri/--:y1 an e1 to be sure4 ,an e8 ,& d y call t an e8 ,d y pron\nce 't5' z if x 7 writt5 'tun'1 or 'm5' z if writt5 'mun'8 ,! ',d]' 9 ,d]by1 suppos+ x tol]able at all to alt] its pres5t legitimate s\nd1 ought1 !n1 to be pron\nc$ z ! ',d]' 9 ! ,iri% "n ,d]ry1 n z ',dur'2 & ! ',b]' 9 ,b]keley n z ',bur1' b z ! ',b]' 9 ,b]yl4 ,b ! :ole conceit has its orig9 9 pure ignorance ( ,engli% ar*ology1 & 9 ! w9die/ ( all vanities1 viz41 ! attempt to h>monize ! spell+ & ! pronunciation ( languages4 ,naturally1 x fills "o ) contempt = ^! ',d]by' puri/s to f9d t _! own object1 ! v purpose !y are bl9dly & unconsci\sly aim+ at1 has be5 s little /udi$ or /eadily contemplat$ by !m 9 any?+ approa*+ to its :ole ext5t4 ,:y1 ^u ! pr9ciple :i* !y sil5tly & virtually set up1 ?\gh c>ry+ x out s contradictorily 7driv+ out an a on ! plea t x is n an e1 only to end by sub/itut+1 & )\t be+ aw>e1 ! /ill remot] lett] u71 ! consequ5ce mu/ be t ! :ole language w\ld g to wreck4 ,n9e names out ( e t5 w\ld ne$ t9k]+4 ',london1' = in/ance1 no m receives ! normal s\nd ( ! o 9 ei!r ( its syllables ?an does ! e 9 ',d]by4' ,! normal s\nd ( ! o is t he>d 9 'song1' 'romp1' 'homage1' 'drop4' ,nev]!less1 ! s\nd giv5 to ! o 9 ',london1' ',cromwell1' etc41 :i* /rictly is ! %ort s\nd ( u 9 'lubb]1' 'butt]1' etc41 is a second>y s\nd ( o 9 p>ticul> comb9ations1 ?\gh n emphatically its prop] s\nd4 ,! v same def5ce applies to ! e 9 ',b]keley1' etc4 ,x is ! legitimate s\nd ( ! ,engli% e 9 t p>ticul> comb9ation1 viz41 :5 prec$+ an r1 ?\gh n its normal s\nd4 ,b ?9k ( ! wild havoc t w\ld be made ( o!r m complex anomalies1 if ^! puri/s look$ an in* 9 advance4 ,gloce/] or ,gl\ce/]1 ,worce/]1 ,cir5ce/]1 ,pontefract1 etc4 ,:at elaborate & mon/r\s pronunciations w\ld !y affix to ^! names8 ,! :ole l& w\ld cease to recognise itself4 ,& t ! puri/s %\ld nev] h contemplat$ ^! v]itable results1 ?is x is :i* seals & rivets "o's contempt = !m4 ,n[1 if su* h>mony 7 at all desirable 7:]eas1 on ! contr>y1 we %\ld ?us be c>ry+ ru9 into ! traditions & oblit]ation into ! e?nological l9ks ( languages1 indu/ri\sly1 9 fact1 ?r[+ up insup]able ob/acles 9 ! pa? ( hi/orical rese>*es71 x w\ld be f> bett]1 in/ead ( adju/+ ! pronunciation to ! imag9>y value ( ! spell+1 inv]sely to adju/ ! spell+ to ! kn[n & e/abli%$ pronunciation1 z a c]ta9 class ( lunatics among/ ourselves1 viz41 ! phonetic gang1 h = "s "t be5 do+ sy/ematically4 ,"h1 !re=e1 ,i hope is "o fix$ po9t4 ,"h !re is an*orage4 ,! usage is ! rule1 at any rate2 & ! law ( analogy takes effect only :]e t _c be decisively asc]ta9$4 ,! ,lat9 ,^w ',felix4'--,! ,romans appe> to me to h _h no t]m = happy1 :i* argues t !y _h n ! idea4 ,felix is ta9t$ ) ! idea ( success1 & is ?us palpably ref]r$ to life z a competition1 :i* = ,romans e di/+ui%$ life 04 ,9 fact1 ap>t f 8 city ! ,roman 0 no?+4 ,too poor to h a villa or any mode ( retirem5t1 x is cle> t ! v idea ( ,roman life supposes = ! va/ majority a necessity ( ?ick cr[d$ int]c\rse1 )\t ! possibility ( solitude4 ,i1 = my peculi> con/itution ( m9d1 to :om solitude has 9 all p]iods ( life be5 m ( a necessity almo/ ?an air1 view ) special horror ! life ( a ,roman or ,a!nian4 ,all ! morn+ he _h to att5d a facti\s hu/+s or a c\rt--assemblies delib]ative or judicial4 ,"h only he 0 somebody1 & yet1 h[ev]1 somebody ?r\gh o!rs4 ,comb9+ ) "o lead] & _m und]l+s l himself1 he also became a p[]2 b 9 himself & = himself1 aft] all1 he 0 consci\sly no?+4 ,:5 ,cic]o speaks ( 8 nunquam m9us ,solus quam cum solus1 he is ann\nc+ :at he feels to be1 & kn[s w be1 accept$ z a v extraord9>y fact4 ,= ev5 9 rure x is evid5t t fri5ds made x a duty ( fri5d%ip to seek out & relieve _! ru/icat+ fri5ds4 ,on ! ,di/9ction betwe5 ',rhetorica ut5s' & ',rhetorica doc5s'4--,x 0 a p]plexity1 famili> to ! exp]i5ce ( ! ,s*oolm51 t (t5times "o does n "k :e!r to und]/& by ! t]m logic ! act & process ( reason+ involv$ & lat5t 9 any s]ies ( connect$ propositions1 or ?is same act & process =mally ab/ract+ itself z an art & sy/em ( reason+4 ,= in/ance1 if y %\ld happ5 to say1 ',dr4 ,isaac ,watts1 ! ,engli% ,noncon=mi/1 0 a good man1 & a clev] man2 b alas6 = 8 logic1 :at c 8 be/ fri5d say = x8 ,! mo/ *>itable op9ion mu/ pron\nce x at ! be/ s1 s'--9 su* a case1 :at is x t y w\ld be und]/ood to speak (8 ,w\ld x be ! g5]al quality ( ! ,doctor's reason+1 ! /yle & "* ( 8 philosophical me?od1 or w\ld x be ! p>ticul> little book kn[n z ',! ,doctor3 8 ,logic1' price #es41 b\nd 9 calf1 & :i* y might be v %y ( t\*+ ) a pair ( tongs1 = fe> ( dimm+ _! /eel poli%1 s long z y\r wife's eye 0 ^u y\r motions8 ,! same ambiguity affects _m o!r cases4 ,= in/ance1 if y he>d a man say1 ',! rhetoric ( ,cic]o is n fitt$ to *all5ge mu* int]e/1' y might naturally und]/& x ( ! p>ticul> /yle & rhetorical col\r+--:i* 0 tax$ ) be+ florid2 nay1 ,rhodian2 nay1 ev5 ,asiatic--t *>act]izes t great orator's compositions2 or1 aga91 ! context might s re/ra9 ! ^w z to =ce x into mean+ ! p>ticul> sy/em or !ory ( rhetoric address$ to ,h]5nius1 a sy/em :i* 7be+ traditionally ascrib$ to ,cic]o7 is usually pr9t$ among/ 8 works4 ,"h1 & 9 scores ( simil> cases1 lies (t5 a trap = ! und]/&+2 b ! ,s*oolm5 evad$ ?is trap by di/+ui%+ betwe5 ',rhetorica ut5s1' & ',rhetorica doc5s1' betwe5 ! rhetoric t laid d[n or deliv]$ didactically ! elem5ts ( oratorical p]suasion z an art to be le>n$1 & rhetoric1 on ! o!r h&1 z a creative en]gy t wield$ ^! elem5ts by ! m\? ( ,p]icles 9 ! ye> #ddj ,b4 ,c41 or by ! m\? ( ,demo/h5es1 #cdj ,b4 ,c42 betwe5 rhetoric ! s*ola/ic art & rhetoric ! heav5-born p[]2 betwe5 ! rhetoric ( ,ari/otle t illum9at$ ! solit>y /ud5t1 & ! rhetoric ( ,demo/h5es t ran along 9 roll+ ?und]s to ! foot/ool ( ,artax]xes' ?rone4 ,oh1 ^! de> sp9dle-%ank$ ,s*oolm56 !y 7 p1 respect$ read]1 n to be sneez$ at4 ,:at signifies hav+ sp9dle-%anks8 ,synonyms4--,a repres5tative & a delegate1 accord+ to ,burke1 are id5tical2 b !re is ! same diff]5ce z betwe5 a p]son :o on 8 own results ( judgm5t manages ! int]e/s ( ,x1 & a p]son m]ely report+ ! voice ( ,x4 ,probably !re nev] 0 a case :i* s %>ply illu/rat$ ! liability ( goodi% practical und]/&+ to miss1 to fail 9 see+1 an object ly+ "r be=e ! eyes2 & t is m wond]ful 9 cases :]e ! object is n "o ( multitude1 b exi/s almo/ 9 a /ate ( insulation4 ,at ! coron]'s inque/ on a "y woman :o di$ f tight-lac+1 act+1 x 0 said1 9 comb9ation ) a v full meal ( animal food1 to ?r[ ! he>t out ( position1 ,mr4 ,wakely pron\nc$ ,engli% or ,briti% p all di/ort$ 9 ! sp9e1 :]eas ,cont95tal p 7 all "r4 ,cont95tal6 ,h[ unlimit$ an idea6 ,:y1 x meant no?+2 x def9es no?+1 limits no?+1 excludes no?+4 ,:o or :at is ,cont95tal8 ,app>5tly x means anyone out ( #bdj millions n be+ "o ( ! #bg millions 9 ! ,britannides4 ,e man escapes an insane folly :o happ5s to brea! an air ,e4 7,n4 ,e41 ,s4 ,e41 ,n4 ,n4 ,e41 ,s4 ,s4 ,e41 etc47 ( ! ,britannides4 ,vanity1 ! inevitable wi% to improve1 or r to avail1 "o's self ( a natural means (f]$ = deep5+ & m>k+ out ! natural outl9e ( ! %ape1 i4e41 ( ! sexual *>act]i/ics1 has no effect1 dies out1 ! in/ant t a family is "o ( ^? :o h ! privilege ( bask+ any:]e #b1jjj miles ,e4 or #b1jjj miles ,n4 & ,s46 ,a :i/l+ to a horse3 ,poppysme 7vide ,:i/l+1 ,lat4 ,dict472 b poppysme is a patt+1 a clapp+1 on ! back1 neck1 or1 d\btless1 :]ev] ! animal is s5sible ( praise4 ',take/ away4' ,?is beautiful expression1 ?\gh exquisitely treat$ by position-- ',t all evil ?\ghts & aims ,take/ away1' is yet orig9ally borr[$ by ,mr4 ,w4 f ! ,litany3 ',o ,lamb ( ,god1 t take/ away ! s9s ( ! _w4' ,9 /yle to expla9 ! true "* ( note-writ+--h[ compress$ & unrambl+ & direct x ought to be1 & illu/rate by ! villa9\s twaddle ( _m ,%akespe>ian notes4 ,syllogism4--,9 ! ,ed94 ,adv]tis] = ,friday1 ,janu>y #be1 #ahef1 a passage occurs tak5 f ,le ,nord 7or ,j\rnal du ,nord71 or "s pap] ^: accurate title ,i d n "k1 und]/ood to be ,russian 9 its lean+s1 :i* makes a mo/ absurd & ignorant use ( ?is ^w4 ,! ,allies are repres5t$ z address+ an argum5t to ,russia1 am\nt+1 ,i ?9k1 to ?is1 viz43 t1 9 ord] to te/ h] s9c]ity1 w\ld x n be well = ,russia at once to c$e su* insulat$ po9ts ( t]ritory z 7 valuable to ,russia or suspici\s to ! ,allies simply z furni%+ means = invasion ( ,turkey8 ,& ?is argum5t is call$ a syllogism4 ',laid 9 wait = him4'--,?is false phrase occurs 9 "s article 7a ,crimea article1 ,i suppose7 9 ! same ,adv]tis] ( ,janu>y #be4 ,& ,i mu* d\bt :e!r any ord9>y e> w\ld reconcile itself to lay 9 wait 7z a pa/ t5se7 ev5 :5 in/ruct$ 9 its propriety4 ,^? ,scotticisms are wor/ :i* are nons5sical1 z e4g43 ',:5ev] he di$ ,fully m4' ,time\s & dubiety are bad1 simply z n au?oriz$ by any b local usage4 ,a ^w us$ only 9 ,prov5ce or among/ ! ,pyr5ees c\ld n be employ$ by a classical ,fr5* writ]1 except "u a caveat & = a special purpose4 ,pl5ty1 us$ "u ! absurd mislead+ ( its t]m9al 'y' z an adjective4 ,along/1 rememb] (2 able =1 ! worse ( liquor1 to call =1 to g ! l5g? (1 z appli$ to a di/ance2 ',i don't ?9k x1' in/ead ( ',i don't ?9k s4' ,9 ! ,lady's ,newspap] = ,saturday1 ,may #h1 #aheb 7,no4 #bhj71 occurs ! v wor/ case ( exagg]at$ & incr$ible mix$ sill9ess & vulg>ity connect$ ) ! use ( assi/ = help at ! d9n]-table t ,i h met )4 ,x occurs 9 ! review ( a book entitl$ ',! ,illu/rat$ ,london ,cook]y ,book1' by ,fr$]ick ,bi%op4 ,mr4 ,bi%op1 x seems1 _h 'enjoy$ ! (fice ( cuis9i] at ! ,palace1 & among "s ( our fir/ nobility4' ,he has1 by ! way1 an introductory ',philosophy ( ,cook]y4' ,two cases occur ( ?is mat*less absurdity3 #a4 ,an ideal c>v] is describ$3 he1 aft] c>v+1 'is z cool & collect$ z ev]1 & assi/s ! portions he has c>v$ ) z mu* grace z he display$ 9 c>v+ ! f[l4' #b4 ,fur!r on1 :5 contra/+1 n ! c>v]s1 b ! ?+s to be c>v$1 com+ to ',neck ( ,veal1' he says ( ! c>v]3 ',%\ld ! v]tebr h n be5 jo9t$ by ! but*]1 y w\ld f9d y\rself 9 ! position ( ! ungraceful c>v]1 be+ compell$ to ex]cise a degree ( /r5g? :i* %\ld nev] be suff]$ to appe>1 v possibly1 too1 assi/+ gravy 9 a mann] n contemplat$ by ! p]son un=tunate en\gh to receive x4' ,g5teel is ! vulg>e/ & mo/ plebeian ( all kn[n words4 ,accord+ly 7& /range x is t ! educat$ us]s ( ?is ^w %\ld n p]ceive t fact71 ari/ocratic p--p 9 ! mo/ und\bt$ lite ( society z to rank or connections--utt]ly ignore ! ^w4 ,!y are aw>e ( its exi/5ce 9 ,engli% diction>ies2 !y "k t x slumb]s 9 ^? va/ repositories2 !y ev5 appreh5d y\r mean+ 9 a vague way :5 y employ x z an epi!t = assign+ ! pret5sions ( an individual or a family4 ,g5]ally x is und]/ood to imply t ! p>ty s describ$ is 9 a position to make morn+ calls1 to leave c>ds1 to be pres5table = any?+ to ! contr>y app>5t 9 mann]s1 /yle ( conv]sation1 etc4 ,b ^! & o!r sugge/ions /ill leave a va/ area unmapp$ ( blank *>ts 9 :i* ! s\nd+s are /ill d\btful4 ,! ^w 'g5teel' is s em95tly vulg> app>5tly = ?is reason1 t x pres5ts a non-vulg> di/9ction "u a gross & vulg> conception ( t di/9ction4 ,! true & c5tral notion1 on :i* ! ^w revolves1 is elevat+2 b1 by a false ab/raction ( its elem5ts1 x is degrad$4 ,& yet 9 p>ts ( ?is isl& :]e ! progress ( ref9em5t is torpid1 & ! field ( vision is bo? n>r[ & un*ang+ 9 all t reg>ds ! nuances ( mann]s1 ,i h rem>k$ t ! ^w 'g5teel' ma9ta9s its old advantage\s acceptation2 & z a pro( ( ?is1 em95t & ev5 revolution>y ?9k]s born & br$ 9 su* prov9cial twilight1 use ! ^w z if unta9t$ & h>dly aw>e t x is flybl[n4 ,among ourselves x is c]ta9 t a peculi> /yle ( gossip1 ( babble1 & ( m9iature intrigu+1 inve/s ! atmosph]e ( little 't[ni%ness1' su* z (t5 entangles ! m ?\ghtful & dignifi$ ( ! resid5ts 9 tr\blesome ef=ts at passive resi/ance or active c\nt]-action4 ,9 deal+ ) ?is matt]1 ,mr4 ,wordswor? in/anc$ ,nor?ampton & ,nott+ham2 b a broad] diff]5ce c\ld h>dly be ?an betwe5 ^! t[ns4 ,& j z 'g5teel' rema9s ! vulg>e/ ( all words1 s ! words 'simple' & 'simplicity1' among/ all kn[n words1 (f] ! mo/ complex & lea/ simple ( ideas4 ,hav+ made ?is deprecation on behalf ( my own crim9ality 9 us+ su* a ^w z 'g5teel1' ,i g on to say t :il/ ,nor?ampton 0 7& is1 ,i believe7 ( all t[ns ! mo/ g5teel1 ,nott+ham = m ?an two c5turies has be5 ! mo/ insurrection>y & 9 a sc>let excess democratic4 ,nott+ham1 9 fact1 has always resembl$ ! ,alex&ria ( anci5t days2 :il/ ,nor?ampton c\ld n be o!r ?an ari/ocratic z ! c5tre ( a c\nty m ?ickly gemm$ by ! ance/ral seats ( our nobility ?an any beside 9 ! isl&4 ,norwi*1 aga91 ?\gh a seat ( manufactur+ indu/ry1 has always be5 modifi$ consid]ably by a lit]>y body ( resid5ts4 ',me9 alt] ,h]r' 7von ,/e97 'pflegte dann wohl s*]z5d zu sag53 ,i* msse von irg5d e9e ,hexe me95 ,altem als e9 ,we*selbalg 9's ,ne/ gelegt seyn2 i* gehre (f5b> e9em ,/amm am]ikanis*] wild5 an1 und habe no* die ,hhn]hundnase zum ,auswitt]n des v]s*i$55 ,blutes4' ,arndt1 speak+ ( 8 p[] to detect at sight 7:5 se5 at a di/ance7 ,russians1 ,engli%1 etc41 says t ,von ,/e9 repli$ ?us 9 8 surprise4 ,b ,i h cit$ ! passage z "o :i* amply illu/rates ! susp5sive =m ( s5t5ce 9 ! ,g]man always indicat$ by a colon 7371 ?us3 'zu sag53 ,i* msse'--to say t ,i mu/ h be5 7p4 #afd74 ,! active s5se ( fe>ful1 viz41 t :i* causes & communicates t]ror--n t :i* receives t]ror--0 und\bt$ly 9 ,%akespe>e's age1 b especially among/ poets1 ! prepond]ant s5se4 ,accord+ly ,i am ( op9ion t ev5 9 neutral cases1 su* z are op5 indiff]5tly to ei!r s5se1 viz41 t :i* affrights1 or t :i* is itself affright$1 ! bias 9 ,%akespe>e's int]pretation ( ! feel+ lay t[>ds ! =m] movem5t4 ,= in/ance1 9 "o ( 8 sonnets3 ',oh1 fe>ful m$itation6 :]e1 alas6' ! true con/ruction ,i believe to be--n ?is3 ,oh1 ?\gh d]iv+ t]ror f ! circum/ances surr\nd+ !e1 suff]+ t]ror f ! ent\rage ( consid]ations pursu+ !e2 b ?is3 ,oh1 ?\ght impress+ & creat+ t]ror1 etc4 ,a 'fe>ful' ag5t 9 ,%akespe>e's use is n "o t %r9ks 9 al>m f ! act1 b an ag5t t causes o!rs to %r9k2 n panic-/ruck1 b panic-/rik+4 ,miss ,edgewor?1 let me rem>k1 commits trespasses on language t are really pa/ excus+4 ,9 "o place %e says t a man '_h a contemptible op9ion' ( "s o!r man's und]/&+4 ,su* a blund] is n ( t class :i* usage sanctions1 & an accuracy n mu* %ort ( p$antry w\ld be argu$ 9 notic+3 x is at once illit]ate & vulg> 9 ! v la/ degree4 ,i mean t x is common among/ vulg> p1 & !m only4 ,x ranks1 = in/ance1 ) ! common =mula ( ',i am agreeable1 if y pref] x4' ,/yle is ! dis5tangl+ ( ?\ghts or ideas reciprocally involv$ 9 ea* o!r4 #d4--,,!ological ,,& ,,religi\s4 ,religion "u any ( its aspects1 reveal+ or consol+--religion 9 connection ) any ( its aff9ities1 e?ics or metaphysics1 :5 self-evok$ by a p]son ( e>ne/ nature1 n impos$ f )\t by ! necessities ( mona/ic life1 n caught z a contagion f ! example ( fri5ds t surr\nd y1 argues "s 'va/ volcanic ag5cy' mov+ at subt]rane\s dep?s bel[ ! ord9>y work+ m9d ( daily life1 & entitl$ by its own intr9sic gr&eur to ennoble ! curiosity 7else a petty passion7 :i* may put que/ions z to its orig94 ,9 any case ( religion aris+1 z a spontane\s bir?1 9 ! mid/ ( ali5 =ces1 x is inevitable to ask = its :y & its :5ce4 ,religion consid]$ z a s5tim5t ( devotion1 z a ye>n+ aft] "s d$ication to an immeasurable pr9ciple ( t noble/ temple among all temples--'! upright he>t & pure1' or religion1 aga91 z ! appreh5sion ( "s mighty syn!sis among/ tru?s dimly p]ceiv$ h]et(ore amid/ sep>at+ cl\ds1 b n[ br\ght into /rict indissoluble connection1 proclaims a revolution s great t x is o!rwise n to be acc\nt$ = ?an z ! break+ out ( a g]m ( ! sup]natural 9 man z a se$ f a hi!rto b>r5 soil4 ,s9 is t secret ^w1 t d>k aporrton ( ! human race1 undiscov]able except by express revelation1 :i* hav+ once be5 laid 9 ! great ?+s ( ,god z a g]m9al pr9ciple1 has s9ce blossom$ into a va/ gr[? ( sublime ideas kn[n only to ^? nations :o h liv$ "u ! m\ld+ ( ,scriptural tru?--& compreh5d+ all functions ( ! ,inf9ite op]atively famili> to man4 ,yes1 ,i affirm t !re is no =m ?r\gh :i* ! ,inf9ite reveals itself 9 a s5se compreh5sible by man & adequate to man2 t !re is no sublime ag5cy :i* compresses ! human m9d f infancy s z to m+le ) ! mom5ts ( its gr[?1 positively none b has be5 9 its :ole orig9--9 e "p--& exclusively develop$ out ( t trem5d\s my/]y :i* lurks "u ! "n ( s94 ,yes1 ,i affirm t ev5 9 its dreams e ,*ri/ian *ild is inve/$ by an atmosph]e ( sublimity unkn[n to ! greate/ ( ,pagan philosoph]s3 t gold5 rays rea* x by two functions ( ! ,inf9ite2 & t ^!1 9 common ) ^? emanations ( ! ,inf9ite t d n settle ^u ! m9d until mature ye>s1 are all projections--d]ivations or c\nt]positions--f ! obscure idea ( s92 c\ld n h exi/$ "u any previ\s condition2 & = a ,pagan m9d w\ld n h be5 intelligible4 ,s94--,x is n only t ! ,inf9ite arises z "p ( ! entire sy/em re/+ on s91 b specifically f s9 ap>t f its c\nt]=ces or reactions1 viz41 f s9 z a ?+1 & ! only ?+ orig9ally %ad[y & 9 a t]rific s5se my/]i\s4 ,/5*4--,i believe t "u ,burke's comm5t>y1 ?is idea w\ld become a high te/ ( ! doctr9e ( ! ,inf9ite4 ,he pron\nces x sublime1 or sublime 9 cases ( int5sity4 ,n[1 fir/ ( all1 ! int5se /ate ( ev]y?+ or any?+ is b a mode ( p[]1 t idea or elem5t or mom5t ( greatness "u a v>i$ =m4 ,"h1 !n1 is no?+ prop] or sep>ately peculi> to /5*3 x is n /5* z /5*1 b /5* z a mode or =m ( s5sation1 capable !re=e ( int5sification4 ,x is b a case "u :at we may suppose a g5]al ,kantian rule--t e s5sation runs ?r\gh all gradations1 f ! l[e/ or mo/ obscure & nasc5t to ! highe/4 ,secondly1 h[ev]1 pass ov] to ! contemplation ( /5* z /5*3 !n ,i affirm--t z simply exp\nd+ ! decay1 & alt]+ or spoil+ t5d5cy or /ate ( all ?+s--simply z a regi/] ( imp]fection1 & ( "o :i* does n 7z ru9s to ! eye7 ev] put on a pleas+ transitional aspect1 x is m]ely disagreeable1 b also at ! same "t mean4 ,= ! imp]fection is m]ely transitional & fleet+1 n absolute4 ,fir/1 mid/ & la/1 x is or c be gr& :5 x rev]ts or comes r\nd ^u its m$iat+ po9t1 or po9t ( reaction4 ,! arrangem5t ( my ,inf9ite mu/ be ?us3 ,aft] hav+ exp\nd$ ! idea ( hol9ess :i* ,i mu/ %[ to be n[ pot5t1 proce$ to %[ t ! ,pagan ,gods did n realize & did n meet ?is idea2 t !n came ! exposure ( ! ,pagan ,gods & ! consci\s pres5ce ( a new =ce among mank9d1 :i* op5$ up ! idea ( ! ,inf9ite1 ?r\gh ! awak5+ p]ception ( hol9ess4 ,i believe t 9 e mode ( exi/5ce1 :i* probably is always by an inc>nation1 ! sy/em ( fle% is made to yield ! organs t express ! alliance ( man ) ! ,inf9ite4 ,?us ! idea ( my/]y1 ,greek3 aporrta1 f9ds its organ ( expression 9 ! s5sualities ( ! human race4 ,aga91 ! crime1 :atev] x 71 & ! et]nal pollution is express$ 9 ^! same organs4 ,also1 ! prolongation ( ! race s z to f9d ano!r sy/em is secur$ by ! same organs4 ,g5]ally1 t is1 = a million aga9/ a unit1 ! awful my/]y by :i* ! fe>ful p[]s ( dea?1 & sorr[1 & pa91 & s9 are lock$ into p>ts ( a :ole2 s z1 9 fact1 to be repetitions1 reaffirmations ( ea* o!r "u a diff]5t phase--?is is no?+1 does n exi/4 ,dea? s9ks to a m]e collective t]m--a category--a ^w ( conv5i5ce = purposes ( arrangem5t4 ,y depress y\r h&s1 &1 behold6 ! sy/em disappe>s2 y raise !m1 x reappe>s4 ,?is is no?+--a ciph]1 a %ad[4 ,clap y\r h&s l an ,arabian girl1 & all comes back4 ,un/op y\r e>s1 & a ro> z ( ,/4 ,lawr5ce ent]s3 /op y\r e>s1 & x is muffl$4 ,to & fro2 x is & x is n--is n & is4 ,ah1 mighty heav51 t su* a mock]y %\ld cov] ! :ole vision ( life6 ,x is & x is n2 & on to ! day ( y\r dea? y w /ill h to le>n :at is ! tru?4 ,! et]nal n[ ?r\gh ! dreadful loom is ! ov]fl[+ future p\r$ back into ! capaci\s res]voir ( ! pa/4 ,all ! active elem5t lies 9 t inf9itesimal n[4 ,! future is n except by relation2 ! pa/ is n at all1 & ! pres5t b a sign ( a nexus betwe5 ! two4 ,god's words require p]iods1 s ,8 c\nsels4 ,he _c precipitate !m any m ?an a man 9 a /ate ( happ9ess c commit suicide4 ,d\btless x is und5iable t a man may arm 8 h& ) a sword3 & t 8 fle% w be f\nd p5etrable to ! sword1 happy or n4 ,b ?is app>5t physical p[] has no exi/5ce1 no value = a creature hav+ a d\ble nature3 ! moral nature n only indisposes him to use 8 p[]1 b really creates a f> great] antagoni/ p[]4 ,?is ,god--too great to be contemplat$ /eadily by ! l(tie/ ( human eyes2 too approa*able & condesc5d+ to be %unn$ by ! meane/ 9 affliction3 realiz+ ?us 9 ano!r =m t reconcilem5t ( extremes1 :i* ,/4 ,paul obs]v$3 f> f all creat$ be+s1 yet also v ne>4 ',a conviction t !y ne$$ a ,savi\r 0 gr[+ among/ m54' ,h[8 ,9 :at s5se8 ,savi\r f :at8 ,y c't be sav$ f no?+4 ,!re mu/ be a dang]1 an evil ?reat5+1 be=e ev5 9 fancy y c ?9k ( a deliv]]4 ,n[1 :at evil 0 !re exi/+ to a ,pagan8 ,s98 ,mon/r\s6 ,no su* idea ev] dawn$ ^u ! ,pagan intellect4 ,dea?8 ,yes2 b t 0 inali5able f 8 nature4 ,pa9 & disease8 ,yes2 b ^! 7 p]haps inali5able also4 ,mitigat$ !y might be1 b x mu/ be by human sci5ce1 & ! progress ( k4 ,grief8 ,yes2 b ?is 0 inali5able f life4 ,mitigat$ x might be1 b by sup]ior philosophy4 ,f :at1 !n1 0 a ,savi\r to save8 ,if no?+ to save f1 h[ any ,savi\r8 ,b "h arises z ! awful ( awfuls to me1 ! deep1 deep exposure ( ! insuffici5t k & s5se ( :at is peculi> to ,*ri/ianity4 ,to imag9e "s s5se ( impurity1 etc41 lead+ to a wi% = a ,savi\r 9 a ,pagan1 is to defraud ,*ri/ianity ( all its gr&eur4 ,if ,paganism c\ld develop ! want1 x is n at all cle> t ,paganism did n develop ! rem$y4 ,heav5s6 h[ deplorable a bl9dness6 ,b did n a ,pagan lady feel ! insuffici5cy ( e>?ly ?+s = happ9ess8 ,no2 because any feel+ t5d+ 9 t direction w\ld be to h]1 z to all ar\nd h]1 simply a diseas$ feel+1 :e!r f dyspepsia or hypo*ondria1 & "o1 :e!r diseas$ or n1 wor?less = practical purposes4 ,x w\ld h to be a ,*ri/ian lady1 if some?+ f> beyond1 some?+ inf9ite1 7 n connect$ ) x1 dep5d+ on x4 ,b if ?is 7 by y ascrib$ to ! ,pagan lady1 !n t is 9 o!r words to make h] a ,*ri/ian lady already4 ,exhibition ( a ,roman ,dialogue on ,s94--,:at6 says ! ignorant & unreflect+ mod]n ,*ri/ian4 ,d y mean to tell me t a ,roman1 h[ev] buri$ 9 worldly objects1 w\ld n be />tl$ at he>+ ( a ,savi\r8 ,n[1 he>k54 ,,roman4 ,savi\r6 ,:at d y mean8 ,savi\r = :at8 ,9 good fai?1 my fri5d1 y lab\r "u "s misconception4 ,i am us$ to rely on myself = all ! sav+ t ,i ne$4 ,&1 g5]ally speak+1 if y except ! sea1 & ^? curs$ nor?-ea/ w9ds1 ,i "k ( no p>ticul> dang]4 ,,*ri/ian4 ,oh1 my fri5d1 y totally mi/ake ! matt]4 ,i mean sav+ f s94 ,,roman4 ,sav+ f a fault1 t is--well1 :at sort ( a fault8 ,or1 h[ %\ld a man1 t y say is no long] on e>?1 save me f any fault8 ,is x a book to w>n me ( faults t ,he has left8 ,,*ri/ian4 ,:y1 yes4 ,n t ,he wrote ,himself2 b ,he talk$1 & ,8 foll[]s h record$ ,8 views4 ,b /ill y are q 9 ! d>k4 ,n faults1 b ! f\nta9 ( all faults1 t is :at ,he w save y f4 ,,roman4 ,b h[8 ,i c und]/& t by illum9at+ my judgm5t 9 g5]al ,he might succe$ 9 mak+ me m prud5t4 ,,*ri/ian4 ',judgm5t1' 'prud5t'--^! words %[ h[ wide by a :ole hemisph]e y are ( ! tru?4 ,x is y\r w t ,he applies ,8 correction to4 ,,roman4 ',w6' :y ,i've none b peaceable & lawful designs1 ,i assure y4 ,oh6 ,i beg9 to see4 ,y ?9k me a p>tn] ) ^? pirates t we j spoke to4 ,,*ri/ian4 ,n at all1 my fri5d4 ,i speak n ( designs or int5tions4 ,:at ,i mean is1 ! s\rce ( all desires--:at ,i w\ld call y\r wills1 y\r :ole moral nature4 ,,roman 7bridl+74 ,ahem6 ,i hope ,roman nature is q z little 9 ne$ ( improvem5t z any o!r4 ,!re are ! ,cretans2 !y held up _! heads4 ,accord+ly !y _h _! fire in/itutions1 & t true in/itution aga9/ brib]y & luxury1 & all su* /uff4 ,!y fanci$ !mselves impregnable4 ,:y1 bless y6 ev5 ,m>cus ,tullius1 t 0 a pros+ k9d ( man & r peevi% ab\t su* ?+s1 c\ld n keep 9 ! tru?4 ',:y1 ,cato1 my boy1' says he1 'y talk4' ,& to he> y1 brib]y & luxury w\ld n leave "o a /ick to fight =4 ,:y1 n[1 ^! same ,cretans--"l6 we took ! conceit out ( !m 9 tw5ty-five m9utes4 ,no m "t1 ,i assure y1 did x co/ ?ree ( our cohorts to settle ! :ole lot ( !m4 ,,*ri/ian4 ,my fri5d1 y are m & m 9 ! d>k4 ,:at ,i mean is n pres5t 9 y\r s5ses1 b a disease4 ,,roman4 ,oh1 a disease6 t's ano!r ?+4 ,b :]e8 ,,*ri/ian4 ,:y1 x affects ! bra9 & ! he>t4 ,,roman4 ,well1 n[1 "o at a "t4 ,take ! bra9--we h a disease1 & we treat x ) :ite hellebore4 ,!re may be a bett] way4 ,b answ] me ?is4 ,if y are g5]ally affect$1 :at "r h y to br+1 z y are suppos+1 a diseas$ bra9 to a s\nd "o8 ,we ,romans are all s\nd--s\nd z a bell4 ,!n ,*ri/ian goes on to ! hi/ory ( ! fall4 ,b ! :ole w\ld be self-baffl$ & con/ru$ away f want ( s9 z ! anti!sis ( hol9ess4 ,:y ,/4 ,paul & ! ,a!nians did n come to an ,und]/&+4--,s1 aga91 if y ?9k t ,/4 ,paul _h a *ance ) ! ,a!nians4 ,if he _h1 x w\ld tax 8 div9e b5evol5ce to see t he =bore to pursue x4 ,?is attempt %[s t he 0 "u a misconception4 ,he fanci$ a possibility ( prea*+ a pure religion4 ,:at foll[$8 ,he 01 he mu/ h be5 defeat$4 ,t is1 practically1 else :y did he n p]si/8 ,b 8 confutation 0 ! factual confutation ( exp]i5ce4 ,x 0 no g4 ,t he f\nd too surely4 ,b :y8 ,i am sure t he nev] f\nd out4 ,en\gh t he felt--t "u a /rong in/9ct he misgave--a deep1 deep gulf betwe5 him & !m1 s t nei!r c\ld he make a way to _! s5se1 nor !y1 except conjecturally1 to 84 ,=1 j review ! case4 ,:at 0 ! ,greek3 euangelion1 ! good tid+s1 :i* he ann\nc$ to man8 ,:at bur!n ( hope8 ,:at revelation ( a my/]y ( hope aris+ out ( a deep] my/]y ( despair8 ,he ann\nc$ a deliv]]4 ,deliv]]6 f :at8 ,answ] t--f :at8 ,:y1 f evil1 y say4 ,evil6 ( :at k9d8 ,:y1 y retort1 did n ! ,pagans admit t man 0 ly+ "u evil8 ,n at all2 no?+ ( ! k9d4 ,b y are sure y h he>d ( su* ?+s8 ,v likely4 ,& n[ y are =c$ back ^u y\r argum5ts y rememb] specially t evil z to its orig9 0 a fav\rite speculation ( !irs4 ,evil1 9 its mo/ compreh5sive designation1 :5ce is x8 ,h[ came x8 ,n[1 m>k1 ev5 to t ext5t1 viz41 ! ext5t indicat$ by ?is problem1 ! anci5ts _h no conception ( evil correspond+ to1 no1 nor dimly approa*+ to1 a correspond5ce ) ours4 ,!y _h no ineffable /&>d ( purity2 h[1 !n1 any function ( impurity8 ,!y _h no ineffable doctr9e ( pa9 or suff]+ answ]+ to a f> m realiz$ /ate ( p]ception1 &1 !re=e1 unimag9ably m exquisite2 h[1 !n1 c\ld !y raise a "q on ! nature or f\nta9s ( su* pa9s8 ,!y execut$ no syn!sis1 & c\ld execute none ^u ! calamities ( life2 !y nev] said 9 ord9>y talk t ?is 0 a _w ( sorr[1 ei!r apo/rophiz+ a newborn *ild1 or a _w ( disappo9tm5t1 bemoan+ a mature victim2 nei!r z 9 ! angui% ( m$itative reflection1 nor 9 ! prud5ce ( ext5uat+ apology4 ,! gr& sanctus :i* arises f human s5sibility1 ,p]i% empires & ! cr[ns ( k+s1 etc41 fir/ arose 9 connection ) ,*ri/ianity4#cj ,life 0 a good life2 man 0 a prosp]\s be+4 ,hope = m5 0 8 natural air2 despond5cy ! elem5t ( 8 own self-creat$ folly4 ,nei!r c\ld x be o!rwise4 ,=1 besides t1 x w\ld be too immeasurable a draught ( woe to say 9 "o brea? t ?is only 0 ! crux or affirmation ( man's fate1 & yet t ?is also 0 wret*$ p] se2 n accid5tally made wret*$ by imprud5ce1 b ess5tially & irrevocably s by necessity ( its nature4 ,besides all ?is1 :i* has a lurk+ dep5d5cy ^u man's calculations ( :at is safe1 he sees t ?is mode ( ?9k+ w\ld leave him no?+2 yet ev5 t extreme consequ5ce w\ld n *eck "s hone/ or s9c]e or desp]ate m9ds f utt]+ _! convictions t life really 0 ?is desp]ate game--mu* to lose & no?+ 9 ! be/ case to w94 ,s f> !re w\ld h be5 a dang]\s gravitation at all times to ! sad conclusion ( ,paganism4 ,b1 mean:ile1 ?is dang]\s gravitation 0 too dang]\s1 & ,provid5ce has deeply c\nt]act$ x by pr9ciples laid d[n 9 human nature4 ,i affirm t :]e ! ideas ( man1 :]e ! possible inf9ities are n develop$1 !n also ! exorbitant on ! o!r field is /rongly pull$ up4 ,no ideals ( evil c take place except "u ideals ( happ9ess t passe? all und]/&+4 ,no syn!sis c ev] be execut$1 t is1 no annum]ation ( ,a1 ,b1 ,c into a common total1 view$ z elem5ts t5d+ to a common unity1 unless previ\sly ?is unity has be5 preconceiv$1 because ! elem5ts are n elem5ts1 viz41 orig9al con/itu5ts ( a repres5tative :ole 7a s]ies t5d+ to a summation71 unless t :i* is con/itut$--t :ole--is previ\sly giv5 9 idea4 ,s9ce ,a & ,b & ,c c\ld n be view$ z t5d+ to a unity1 hav+ no exi/5ce except ?r\gh !m1 unless previ\sly t unity _h exi/$ = ! regulation & eduction ( its compon5t elem5ts4 ,& ?is unity 9 ! case ( mis]y nev] c\ld h be5 giv5 unless f> high] functions ?an any :i* c\ld endure ,paganism1 or :i* ,paganism c\ld endure4 ,until ! sad elem5t ( a diseas$ w is introduc$1 until ! affect+ notion is develop$ ( a f\nta9 9 man himself well+ up ! mis]y = ev]1 no idea ( mis]y c\ld arise4 ,suff]+ is limit$ & transitory4 ,:at pa9 is p]man5t 9 man8 ,ev5 ! deepe/ lac]ation ( ! human he>t1 t :i* is inflict$ by ! loss ( ^? :o 7 ! pulses ( our he>ts1 is soo!d 7if nev] :olly heal$7 by "t4 ,"o ag5cy ( "t w\ld avail = ?is effect 7 !re no o!r4 ,! features ( ! individual :om we m\rn gr[ dimm] & dimm] z "t advances2 &1 p>i passu1 ! features ( places & collat]al objects & associat$ p]sons f :om rev]b]at$ ^! afflict+ rem9isc5ces ( ! lo/ object4 ,i return3 ,deliv]] f :at8 ,f suff]+ or mis]y4 ,b t 0 n ackn[l$g$1 nor c\ld h be51 we c\ld see no mis]y z a hypo!sis except 9 ^! two modes3 ,fir/1 z a radication 9 man by means ( some?+ else1 "s ?ird ?+4 ,secondly1 z a syn!sis--z a ga!r+ "u a pr9ciple :i* mu/ act prior to ! ga!r+ 9 ord] to provoke x4 7,! syn!sis mu/ be r5d]$ possible & *all5g$ by ! priori unity :i* o!rwise con/itutes t unity47 ,z a metaphysical possibility evil 0 recognis$ ?r\gh its unfa?omable nature4 ,b ?is 0 because su* a nature already presuppos$ a ,god's nature1 realiz+ 8 own ends1 /epp$ 9 ) effect4 ,= ! highe/ =m--! normal or transc5d5t =m--( virtue to a ,pagan1 0 9 ! "* ( citiz54 ,inde$1 ! "o sole or affirmative =m ( virtue lay 9 ?is sole function1 viz41 ( public1 ( patriotic virtue4 ,s9ce "h only x 0 possible to introduce an additional good to ! _w4 ,all o!r virtue1 z ( ju/ice betwe5 individual & individual1 did b r$ress a previ\s error1 sometimes ( ! man himself1 sometimes ( social arrangem5t1 sometimes ( accid5t4 ,x 0 a plus :i* balanc$ & comp5sat$ a pre-exi/+ m9us--an action 9 regressu1 :i* came back ) prevail+ p[] ^u an action 9 progressu4 ,b to be a patriot 0 to fulfil a call ( ! sup]]ogatory he>t--a great nisus ( sympa?y ) ! "o sole inf9ite1 ! sole practical inf9ite t man pre-,*ri/ian ev] c\ld g5]ate = 8 contemplation4 ,n[1 !re=e1 x foll[$ t ! idea ( virtue "h only f\nd its realization4 ,virtue1 9 fact1 0 n d]ivatively or consequ5tially connect$ ) patriotism1 x 0 imman5t2 n transitively associat$ by any l9ks :atev]1 b imman5tly int]twi/$1 indwell+ 9 ! idea4 ,!re=e x happ5$ t a man1 h[ev] he>tsick ( ?is tumid1 bladd]y delusion1 al?\gh to him x 0 a balloon1 by sci5ce punctur$1 lac]at$1 collaps+1 trail$ ?r\gh dit* & mud "u ! r\gh h&l+ & ! fe>ful realities ( life1 yet he dur/ n av[ 8 private feel+s4 ,t w\ld h be5 ev5 worse ?an ) u3 x w\ld h be5 to proclaim virtue & vice m]e bubbles & *im]as4 ,he :o really ?9ks s ev5 we reasonably suspect ( practical indiff]5ce unless :5 we believe him to speak z a misan?rope4 ,! "q suppose to comm5ce z to ! div9e mission ( ,*ri/4 ,& ! feeble und]/&+ is sure to ?9k ?is w be prov$ be/ by prov+ ! subject ( ?is d\bt to h be5 a miracle-work+ p[]4 ,& ( all miracles1 to h ma/]$ 7n m]ely escap$ or evad$7 dea? w be 9 8 op9ion ! greate/4 ,s t if ,*ri/ c\ld be prov$ to h absolutely conqu]$ dea?1 i4e41 to h submitt$ to dea?1 b only to recoil f 8 p[] & ov]?r[ x1 to h di$ & subsequ5tly to h ris5 aga91 w1 =tiori1 prove ,him to h be5 s5t ( ,god4 ,n s4 ,all & e basis ( cr$ibility mu/ be laid 9 ! moral nature1 :]e ! ?+ to be believ$ is important1 i4e41 moral4 ,& ,i !re=e op5 ) ?is rem>k absolutely z]malm5de to ! common intellect3 ,t f a holy fai? y may inf] a p[] ( resurrection1 b n f a p[] ( resurrection fifty times repeat$ c we inf] a holy fai?4 ,:at 9 ! la/ result is ! ?+ to be prov$8 ,:y1 a holy revelation1 n ( k1 b ( ?+s practical2 ( ag5da1 n sci5da4 ,x is ess5tial t ?is holy %\ld also be new1 orig9al1 revelatum4 ,because1 else1 ! div9e/ ?+s :i* are connata & h be5 common to all m51 po9t to no c]ta9 au?or4 ,!y belong to ! d>k f\ndations ( our be+1 & _c *all5ge a tru/1 fai?1 or expectation z susp5d$ ^u any p>ticul> individual man :atev]4 ,"h1 !n1 arises ! ,greek3 prtontok9on4 ,?ick d>kness sits on e man's m9d z to ,*ri/'s revelation4 ,he fancies t x am\nts to ?is3 ',d :at is good4 ,d y\r duty4 ,be good4' ,& ) ?is vague notion ( ! doctr9e1 natural is x t he %\ld ?9k x z old z ! hills4 ,! fir/ /ep to a san] view is1 to und]/&--if a man has s5se en\gh to rea* s high--t ! subtle/ discov]ies ev] made by man1 all put toge!r1 d n make "o wave ( t ,atlantic z to novelty & orig9ality :i* lies 9 ! moral s*eme ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,i d n mean 9 ! total s*eme ( ,*ri/ianity1 r$emption1 etc4 ,no1 b 9 ! e?ics4 ,all e?ics t ev] ,greece ref9$ or ,rome illu/rat$1 01 & c\ld be1 only ! same univ]sal sy/em ( social e?ics--e?ics prop] & exclusive to man & man int] se1 ) no glimpse ( any upw>d relation%ip4 ,n[ ,*ri/ianity looks upw>d = ! fir/ "t4 ,?is 9 ! fir/ place4 ,secondly1 out ( t upw>d look ,*ri/ianity looks second>ily d[n aga91 & reacts ev5 ^u ! social e?ics 9 ! mo/ trem5d\s way4 ,= my ,book on ! ,relations ( ,*ri/ianity to ,man4--,s4 ,t4 ,c4 cites ,j]emy ,taylor1 etc41 = horrible passages on ! gloomy /ate ( ! *ances = virtu\s ,pagans4 ,s4 ,t4 ,c4 9 a m lib]al g5]ation is %ock$2 & ( c\rse 9 8 read]s z 9 himself secretly1 he pr(esses m lib]al ideas4 ,aye1 b h[ is he entitl$ to ^! ideas8 ,=1 on fur!r consid]ation1 x is n ,cic]o only1 or ,epictetus only1 t w\ld suff] "u ?is law ( ,*ri/ianity view$ 9 its reag5cy1 b also ,abraham1 ,david1 ,isaiah1 ,ezekiel1 ,hezekiah4 ,because1 h[ c\ld !y b5efit by a ,r$eem] n yet reveal$--nay1 by a ,r$eem] n ev5 exi/+8 ,= x is n ! second p]son 9 ! ,tr9ity--n ,he sep>ately & ab/ract$ly--t is ! ,r$eem]1 b t second p]son inc>nat$4 ,/4 ,paul app>5tly wi%$ to smuggle ?is trem5d\s "q into a fraudul5t solution1 by mix+ up ,abraham 7) o!rs pre-,*ri/ian & ,*ri/ian7 into ! long array ( ^? ^: ,fai? _h sav$ !m4 ,b fai? 9 :om8 ,g5]al fai? 9 ,god is n ! ?+1 x is fai? 9 ,jesus ,*ri/2 & we are solemnly told 9 _m %apes t no o!r "n 0 giv5 on e>? ?r\gh :i* m5 c\ld be deliv]$4 ,inde$1 if n1 h[ is ! ,messiah ( su* exclusive & p>am\nt importance to man8 ,! ,messiah 0 z yet 7viz41 9 ,abraham's "t7 a prophecy--a dim1 prophetic outl9e ( "o :o %\ld be reveal$4 ,b if ,abraham & _m o!rs c\ld d )\t ,him1 if ?is 0 a disp5sable idea1 h[ 0 x 9 any case1 fir/ or la/1 indisp5sable8 ,besides1 recur to ! !ory ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,mo/ und5iably x 0 ?is1 t nei!r ( ! two elem5ts int]e/$ 9 man c\ld save him2 n ,god2 ,he might h p[]1 b ,8 purity revolt$4 ,p[] 7or d\btfully s71 b no w4 ,n man--= he1 hav+ ! w1 _h no p[]4 ,god 0 too holy2 manhood too unholy4 ,man's gifts1 applicable1 b insuffici5t4 ,god's suffici5t1 b inapplicable4 ,!n came ! compromise4 ,h[ if man c\ld be engraft$ ^u ,god8 ,?us only1 & by su* a syn!sis1 c\ld ! ineffable qualities ( ,god be s co-ord9at$ ) ^? ( man4 ,suppose ev5 t a v]bal inspiration c\ld h be5 secur$--secur$1 obs]ve1 aga9/ gradual *anges 9 language & aga9/ ! reaction>y corruption ( concurr5t v]sions1 :i* x w\ld be impossible to gu>antee z also enjoy+ su* an inspiration 7s9ce1 9 t case1 :at b>ri] w\ld divide m9e or anybody's wilfully false translations f t pret5d+ to au?ority8 ,i repeat :at8 ,none is conceivable1 s9ce :at c\ld y h beyond ! assurance ( ! translator1 ev5 :i* c\ld only gu>antee 8 int5tions7--"h is a cause ( mis9t]pretation am\nt+ to ru91 viz41 aft] be+ read = c5turies z if practically meant = our guidance1 su* & su* a *apt] 7e4g41 ,jael & ,sis]a71 long proscrib$ by ! noble z a record ( abom9able p]fidy1 has at l5g? be5 ju/ifi$ on ! gr\nd t x 0 nev] meant = any?+ else4 ,?us we might get rid ( ,david1 etc41 7 x n t = 8 flexible ob$i5ce to ! cl]us he has be5 pron\nc$ ! man aft] ,god's own he>t4 ,is x n dreadful t at ! v ve/ibule ( any attempt to execute ! pret5d$ law ( ,god & its s5t5ces to hell we are int]rupt$ by "o case 9 e ?ree z exceptional8 ,( ! dea?s1 "o 9 ?ree are ( *ildr5 "u five4 ,add to ^! surely v _m up to twelve or ?irte51 & _m up to eighte5 or tw5ty1 !n y h a law :i* susp5ds itself = "o case 9 e two4 ,note 9 ! argum5t drawn f p]i%abl5ess ( language4 ,n only 7:i* ,i h not$7 is any language1 ergo ! orig9al1 ,*aldan1 ,greek1 etc41 p]i%able ev5 = ^? :o use x1 b also ! va/ op5+s to error :i* all languages op5 to translators =m a sep>ate s\rce ( error 9 translators1 viz43 #a4 ,! old "o on my li/ t = !m ! guidance ( inspiration has ceas$1 else1 if n1 y mu/ set up an inspiration sep>ately to translators1 s9ce1 if y say--,no1 n at all1 :y1 :i* !n8 #b4 ,! unc]ta9ty ( a =eign language ev5 9 a day contempor>y ) ! orig9al writ]1 & !re=e ov] & above :at arises f lapse ( "t & gradual alt]ations4 ,on ,human ,progress4--,(t5times x /rikes u all t ?is is s ins5sible z to elude obs]vation ! v nice/4 ,five ye>s add no?+1 we fancy4 ,n[ inv]t y\r glass4 ,9 #afdb ,engli%m5 are fight+ = great ab/ract pr9ciples4 ,9 #adfj-hc 7i4e41 #ajj #ag #db ye>s be=e1 or #aei ye>s7 !y are fight+ = p]sons1 = rival c&idates4 ,9 #adfj !y c\ld n h conceiv$ m ?an an ,esquimaux c ent]ta9 a "q ab\t ! con/itution ( lyric poetry1 or ! diff]5tial pr9ciples ( ,engli% & ,greek trag$y1 ! b>e/ approximation to que/ions t 9 #afdb are gr\nds ( furi\s qu>rel1 ( bloody qu>rel1 ( ext]m9ation4 ,n[ !n1 look+ =w>d1 y w\ld see f ye> to ye> little if any gr[?2 b inv]t+ y\r glass1 look+ back f ! /ation ( #afdb to #adfj1 y see a progress t if subdivid$ among/ all ! #aei ye>s w\ld give to ea* x_/#j z its quota1 i4e4 inf9ity4 ,9 fact1 x is l ! progression f no?+ to some?+4 ,x is--creation4 ,all ! body ( ! ,*ri/ian _w w\ld fly out 9 a rage if y %\ld say t ,*ri/ianity requir$ ( y _m ?+s t 7 easy1 b "o ?+ t 0 n4 ,yet ?is is und\bt$ly true2 x requires y to believe1 & ev5 9 ! case :]e y "k :at x is to believe1 & s f> are free f p]plexity1 y h x n 9 y\r own p[] to ensure 7?\gh y c influ5ce greatly7 y\r own p[] to believe4 ,b also great d\bt = _m 7& = all t are n some:at metaphysical7 att5ds ! k ( :at is believ+4 ,z to my "m's fancy t ,sir ,w4 ,jones _h f\nd 9 ! ,ea/ pro(s ( ,*ri/ianity1 hav+ gone out an infidel4 ,to d h] ju/ice1 nev] once aft] %e _h adopt$ a !ory ( ,*ri/ianity did %e inquire or feel anxi\s ab\t its pro(4 ,b to review ! folly ( ?is idea4 #a4 ,t ,*ri/ianity !re :]e x reign$ & 0 meant to reign %\ld be insuffici5t 9 its pro(s2 b t 9 a f> di/ant l&1 lurk+ 9 "s hole or corn]1 !re %\ld be pro(s ( its tru?1 j precisely :]e ^! pro(s 7 n want$4 ,& aga91 t ^! %\ld be res]v$ = "o s*ol> rambl+ into a solit>y pa?1 :]e 9 a moral s5se nobody c\ld foll[ him 7= x is nobody--?is or t ori5tal s*ol>74 ,& we are sure t 8 pro( 0 n ( t ord] to %9e by its own light1 else x w\ld h res\nd$ ?r\gh ,engl&4 #b4 ,t = _m hundr$s ( ye>s ,*ri/ianity %\ld h be5 receiv$1 g5]ation aft] g5]ation %\ld h liv$ "u its vital action1 ^u no suffici5t argum5t1 & sudd5ly su* an argum5t %\ld turn up z a rew>d to a man 9 a c\ntry n ,*ri/ian = be+ m incr$ul\s ?an 8 neighb\rs2 h[ impossible6 ,t fraudul5t argum5t :i* affects to view ! h>d%ips ( an adv5tur\s life & its p]ils z capable ( "o sole impression--t ( repulsion--& secondly z ! sole circum/ances ab\t su* adv5tures1 injures f ! mom5t :5 x is p]ceiv$3 n #a4 ,! writ] only2 no matt] = him1 wor?less li>1 h[ mu* he s9ks 9 ! op9ion ( 8 read]s3 b #b4 ,! ,apo/les4 ,n[ see ! injury ( falsehood4 ,sudd5ly x snaps1 & ) a great reaction causes a j> to ! :ole sy/em1 :i* 9 ord9>y m9ds x is nev] likely to recov]4 ,! reason x is n (t5] p]ceiv$ is t p read su* books 9 a somnol5t1 inactive /ate ( m9d1 "o-t5? com+ to a subject on :i* !y h already made up _! m9ds1 & op5 to no fre% impressions1 ! o!r n9e-t5?s c>+ n "o /raw ab\t ! matt]1 z read+ x 9 an age ( irreflectiv5ess & purely ?r\gh an act ( ob$i5ce to _! sup]iors1 else n only does ?is hypocritical attempt to v>ni% give way all at once1 & sudd5ly 7) an occasion ev] aft] ( d\bt1 & caus+ a reflection to any self-suffici5t man1 sudd5ly com+ to p]ceive t he has be5 *eat$1 & ) "s ju/ification = jeal\sy !nce=w>ds to ! mak] up ( a case71 b also x robs ! ,apo/les ( ! human grace !y really possess$4 ,= if we suppose !m arm$ aga9/ all temptations1 sn>es1 s$uctions1 by a sup]natural sy/em ( end[m5ts1 ?is is b ! case ( an angel--nay1 n ( an angel1 = x is probable t :5 an angel inc>nat$ himself1 or "o ( ! ,pagan deities1 :o 0 oblig$ fir/ to inc>nate himself be=e he c\ld act among/ m51 or s mu* z be se5 by m51 he 0 b\nd by all ! defects ( man1 i4e41 he c\ld *oose only an ideal1 s f> ideal z to elude ! wor/ effects f vice1 intemp]ance1 etc4 ,! angel :o wre/l$ ) ,jacob probably did 8 be/2 he 0 a /\t fell[1 b s 0 ! patri>*4 ,! v condition ( inc>nation1 & ?is because ! m]e ext]nal =m already includes limitations 7z ( a fi%1 n to fly2 ( a man1 n to fly1 etc47 probably includes z a necessity1 n z a *oice1 ! adoption ( all evils connect$ ) ! nature assum$4 ,ev5 ! ,son ( ,god1 once inc>nat$1 0 n exempt$ f any evil ( fle%2 ,he grew1 pass$ ?r\gh ! peculi> infirmities ( e /age up to mature life2 w\ld h gr[n old1 infirm1 weak1 _h ,he liv$ long]2 0 liable to dea?1 ! wor/ ( all human evils1 & 0 n1 we may be sure1 exempt$ f any "o fle%ly desire ) reg>d to sex1 or enemies1 or companions1 b because t div9e pr9ciple1 :i* also is 9 man1 yes1 9 e man ! f\le/ & base/--?is light :i* ! d>kness compreh5d$ n1 & :i* 9 "s is e>ly ext+ui%$1 b 9 all fights fitfully ) ! w9ds & /orms ( ?is human atmosph]e1 9 ,him 0 rais$ to a lu/re unspeakable by ,8 pure & holy w4 ,if ! ,apo/les 7 m cele/ially arm$ 9 any o!r s5se ?an z we are all arm$ f above by call+ =? our bett] natures1 if 9 any o!r s5se ?an z sorr[ arms u by purify+ our natures1 z sorr[ful reflection1 z m$itation & e>ne/ endeav\rs to resi/ our angry in/9cts 7:i*1 on ! contr>y1 h[ (t5 d m5 obey "u ! vile pret5ce ( be+ put by consci5ce on a pa9ful duty71 !n1 ,i say1 :at 7 ! ,apo/les to u8 ,:y %\ld we admire !m8 ,h[ c we make !m models ( imitation8 ,x is l t case ( ,an>*>sis ! ,scy?ian4 ,x does c]ta9ly inc5se a ,*ri/ian to ?9k t /upid ,mahomm$ans %\ld impute to u su* *ildi% idolatries z t ( ,god hav+ a son & heir--j z ?\gh we 7 b>b>\s en\gh to believe t ,god 0 liable to old age--t ! "t 0 com+1 h[ev] di/ant1 :5 somebody w\ld say to him1 ',come1 ,sir1' or ',come1 my ,"l1 really y are n :at y 74 ,x's "t y gave y\rself "s ease 7,greek3 euphmi1 "t1 inde$1 t y resign$ ! p[]s to :i* y are unequal71 & let a y\ng] man take ! re9s4' ,none b a fil?y b>b>ian c\ld c>ry =w>d 8 ?\ghts s little z n to see t ?is son 9 due "t w\ld f9d himself 9 ! same pr$icam5t4 ,n[ m>k h[ ,*ri/ian l&s w\ld en=ce ?is doctr9e ( unity by horrid co]cions4 ,!y hang1 dr[n1 burn1 crucify ^? :o d5y x4 ,s t1 be assur$ y are plant+ y\r corn]-/one on ! mo/ w9dy ( delusions4 ,y y\rselves d n ascribe any m]it to ,mahomm$ sep>ate f t ( reveal+ ! unity ( ,god4 ,consequ5tly1 if t is a %ak5 craze aris+ f m]e inability on 8 "p1 a little1 a v little in=mation w\ld h cut up by ! v roots ! :ole peculi>ity ( ,islam4 ,= if a wise man c\ld h assembl$ ^! conceit$ ,arabians & told !m3 ,great ?ieves1 y fancy y\rselves to h %ot f> ahead ( ! ,*ri/ians z to ! po9t ( unity1 & if y _h ,i w\ld grant t y _h made a prodigi\s advance4 ,b y are deceiv+ qu>rell]s4 ,x is all a ^w--m]e smoke1 t bl9ds y4 ,! ,*ri/ian seems to affirm ?ree ,gods1 & ev5 to aggravate ?is wick$ness by call+ "o ( !m 'a ,son1' ?us seem+ to accept t mon/r\s notion t ,god is liable to old age & decrepitude1 s z to provide wisely aga9/ ,8 own dotage4 ,b all ?is is an error3 ^! ?ree app>5t ,gods are b "o1 & 9 ! mo/ absolute s5se "o4 ,! mo/ %ock+ly se>*+1 influ5tial1 & p]man5t blund] t ev] has affect$ ! m9d ( man has be5 ! fancy t a religion includes a cre$ z to its ,greek3 aporrhta1 & a morality2 9 %ort1 t x 0 doctr9al by necessity1 enactory1 & 7:i* has be5 ! practical "p ( ! blund]7 !re=e exclusive1 because3 #a4 ,) our notion ( a religion z ess5tially doctr9al1 ! v fir/ axiom ab\t x is1 t be+ true itself x makes all o!rs false4 ,:]eas1 ! capital di/9ction ( ! ,pagan 0--t giv51 suppos+ to be assum$1 #aj1jjj religions--all mu/ be true simultane\sly1 all equally4 ,:5 a religion includes any di/9ct propositions (f]$ to ! und]/&+ 7t is1 ,i ?9k1 re/+ ^u a pr9ciple or t5d5cy to a consequ5ce by way ( diff]5c+ f facts :i* also are = ! und]/&+1 b !n b>ely to contemplate n ) a p[] ( react+ on ! und]/&+1 = e pr9ciple introduces into ! m9d t :i* may become a modification1 a re/ra9t2 :]eas1 a fact re/ra9s no?+ 9 ! way ( ?\ght unless x includes a pr9ciple71 x w\ld rise cont9ually 9 its exclusive p[] accord+ to ! numb] ( ^? propositions4 ,at fir/ x might exclude all b t51 eight1 sev51 & s on2 f9ally1 z integrat$ x w\ld exclude all4 #b4 ,if y ask on :at pr9ciple a ,pagan believ$ 8 religion1 ! "q to him 0 almo/ amus+ & laughable4 ,i w illu/rate ! case4 ,a man meets y :o inquires 9 a hurri$1 suppose ev5 9 an agitat$ way1 :e!r y met a tall man1 bl9d ( "o eye1 dress$ 9 su* a col\r$ dress1 etc4 ,n[1 does x ev] occur to y t ! inquir] is ly+8 ,ly+6 ,:]e=e %\ld he lie8 ,or aga91 if y say t y\r h\se /&s "u a hill1 t ?ree out ( f\r *imneys smoke1 & t y mu/ inde$ try "s ( ! inv5tions = rem$y+ ?is annoyance1 w\ld any man 9 8 s5ses ?9k ( speculat+ on ! possibility t all ?is %\ld be a romance8 ,or1 to come ne>] 9 ! k9d ( fact1 if a man repres5t$ 8 family =tune z hav+ be5 bequea!d by a maid5 aunt 9 ! la/ g5]ation1 w\ld any man say o!rwise ?an t d\btless ! man knew 8 own b5efactors & relatives be/8 ,on ?is same pr9ciple1 :5 ,*ri/ 0 m5tion$ z ! div9ity ador$ by a c]ta9 "p ( ! ,jews :o 7 by way ( di/9ction call$ ,*ri/ians1 :y %\ld a ,roman object8 ,:at motive c\ld he h = d5y+ ! exi/5ce or ! div9e exi/5ce ( ,*ri/8 ,ev5 ! idea ( diss5t or s*ism1 "s ,jews wor%ipp+1 "s prote/+1 w\ld n mu* puzzle him4 ,some?+ l x _h occurr$ 9 ,pagan l&s4 ,neptune & ,a!ne _h cont5d$ = ,attica4 ,& "u ! slight inquiry :i* he w\ld ev] make1 or li/5 to :5 made by o!rs1 he might wond] at ! ranc\r display$ by ! prote/+ p>ty1 b he w\ld take x = grant$ t a div9ity ( "s local section _h be5 unduly pu%$ into pre-em95ce ov] a m /rictly epi*orial div9ity4 ,he w\ld g (f ) ?is notion1 t :]eas1 ! eld] ,jews insi/$ on pay+ v[s1 etc41 to a ,god call$ ,jehovah1 a section s\ght to transf] t allegiance to a div9ity call$ ,*ri/4 ,if he 7 fur!r press$ on ! subject1 he w\ld fancy t v possibly1 z _h be5 ?\ght1 f\nd or imag9$ 9 ! case ( ,syrian deities or ,egyptian1 etc41 t p]haps ,*ri/ might correspond to ,apollo1 z ,a/>te to ,diana1 ,neptune ( ,latium to ! ,poseidn ( ,greece4 ,b if n1 t w\ld cause no scruple at all4 ,?us f> x 0 by possibility a m]e affair ( v]bal diff]5ce4 ,b suppose x asc]ta9$ t 9 no po9t ( ! symbols surr\nd+ ! wor%ip ( ,*ri/1 or ! conception ( ,8 p]son1 ,he c\ld be id5tifi$ ) any previ\sly-kn[n ,pagan ,god--t w\ld only introduce ,him into ! matricula ( ,gods z a positive novelty4 ,nor w\ld x h />tl$ a ,roman to he> t 9 ,india or any c\ntry l>ge en\gh !re %\ld be a sep>ate ,pan!on ( _m ?\s& deities1 plus "s o!r ,pan!on ( div9ities correspond+ to _! own4 ,= ,syria--b /ill m 9 "o section ( ,syrian ,pale/9e--?is w\ld surprise him quoad ! degree1 n quoad ! pr9ciple4 ,! ,jew _h a sep>ate or peculi> ,god1 :y n8 ,no nation c\ld exi/ )\t ,gods3 ! v sep>ate exi/5ce ( a p1 trivial z x might be 9 p[] & weal?1 argu$ a tutel>y ,god1 b1 ( c\rse1 proportion$ to ! de/9ies at lea/ 7& 9 "p to ! pres5t size7 ( ! c\ntry4 ,?us f> no difficulties at all4 ,b ! morality6 ,aye1 b t w\ld nev] be acc\nt$ a "p ( religion4 ,z well conf\nd a sci5ce ) religion4 ,aye1 b ! ,greek3 aporrhta4 ,^! w\ld be view$ z ! rites ( ,adonis1 or ( ,c]es2 y c\ld n w>n him f 8 preconception t ^! conc]n$ only ,jews4 ,:]e1 !re=e1 lodg$ ! (f5ce8 ,:y "h1 z p]sonalities--= su* m]ely 7 all religions--! ,god mu/ be measur$ by 8 nation4 ,s "s ,romans propos$ to introduce ,*ri/ into ! ,roman ,pan!on4 ,b :at fir/ explod$ z a civil (f5ce 0 ! dem& ( supremacy & ! inconceivable pr9ciple set up ( incompatibility4 ,?is 0 m]e folly4 ,a mu* m solemn1 significant & prophetic mean+ ?an ! common "o may be secur$ to ! fam\s passage 9 ,/4 ,mat!w--',& ?\ %alt call ,8 "n ,jesus4' ,?is injunction we>s ! mo/ impressive "* belong+ to heav5ly adjuration1 :5 x is ?us confid$ to ! c>e & cu/ody ( a special angel1 & 9 ! v h\r ( inauguration1 & among/ ! v bir?-?roes ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,= 9 two sep>ate modes ! att5tion is secretly po9t$ & solicit$ to ! gr& s]p5t9e artifice1 :i* met & confront$ ! almo/ insurm\ntable difficulty besett+ ,*ri/ianity on its v ?re%old3 ,fir/1 by ! record ( ! e>ly !rapeutic miracles1 s9ce 9 t way only1 viz41 by a sci5ce ( heal+1 :i* ! philosoph] equally ) ! populace recognis$ z re/+ ^u inspiration f ,god1 c\ld ! magi/rate & civil au?ority h be5 /eadily propitiat$2 secondly1 by ! v v]bal sugge/ion c\*$ 9 ! "n ,jesus1 or ,heal]4 ,at ! mo/ critical ( mom5ts an angel reveals himself1 = ! purpose ( say+ ',?\ %alt call ,8 "n ,jesus'--& :y ,jesus8 ,because1 says ! angel1 ',he %all heal or cleanse ,8 p f s9 z f a bodily disease4' ,?us1 9 "o & ! same mom5t is sugge/$ prospectively to ! e>ly ,*ri/ian1 :o is look+ =w>d 9 se>* ( "s adequate protection aga9/ ! civil magi/rate1 & !oretically & retrospectively is sugge/$ to ! ,*ri/ian ( our own philosophiz+ days1 t admirable res\rce ( :at by a %or?& expression ,i w call ,hakimism4 ,! ,hakim1 ! ,jesus1 ! ,heal]1 comes f ,god4 ,mobs mu/ n be tol]at$4 ,b nei!r mu/ ! deep !rapeutic inspirations ( ,god be made ( none effect1 or n>r[$ 9 _! applications4 ,& ?us 9 "o mom5t 0 ! panic f disease arm$ aga9/ ! panic f insurg5t mobs2 ! privileg$ ,hakim 0 m>%all$ aga9/ ! privileg$ magi/rate2 & ! deep sup]/ition1 :i* saw1 & n unreasonably1 a demon rag+ 9 a lawless mob1 saw also a demon n less bl9d or cruel 9 ! pe/il5ce t walk$ 9 d>kness4 ,&1 z "o magnet creates o!r magnets1 s also ! ,hakim1 once privileg$1 c\ld secretly privilege o!rs4 ,& ! physical ,hakim c\ld by no te/ or %ibbole? be prev5t$ f sil5tly introduc+ ! spiritual ,hakim4 ,& ?us1 :il/ ?rones & c\ncils 7 tumultuat+ 9 panic1 behold6 sudd5ly ! ,*ri/ian soldi] 0 reveal$ among/ !m z an arm$ man4 'crasez l'infme1' ,i also say3 & :o is he8 ,x w\ld be m]e insanity to suppose t x c\ld be any tea*] ( moral tru?s4 ,ev5 ,i1 :o s mu* despise ,socrates1 c\ld n reasonably call him l'infme4 ,b :o1 !n1 is l'infme8 ,x is he :o1 f9d+ 9 ^? great ideas :i* ,i h notic$ z revelations f ,god1 & :i* ?r[ op5 to ! />tl$ he>t ! heav5 ( heav5s1 9 ! purity1 ! hol9ess1 ! peace :i* passe? all und]/&+1 f9d+ no argum5t ( div9ity1 !n aft]w>ds does f9d x 9 ! little tricks ( leg]dema91 9 conjur+1 9 pr/igia4 ,b "h1 ?\gh p]haps r\s$ a little to see ! bas5ess ( rely+ on ^! miracles1 & also 9 ! re> a f> worse argum5t aga9/ !m1 he /ill feels uncom=table at su* words appli$ to ?+s :i* ,*ri/ did4 ,*ri/ c\ld n make1 nor wi%$ to make1 t great :i* 0 inh]5tly mean2 t relevant1 :i* 0 orig9ally irrelevant4 ,if ,he did ?+s 9 !mselves mean1 x 0 because ,he suit$ ,himself to mean m9ds1 incapable ( high] views2 wret*es su* z exi/ among/ u ( mod]n days by millions1 on :om all ,8 ,div9e words 7 ?r[n away1 wret*es deaf & bl9d & besott$1 to :om x 0 said 9 va93 ',he t looke? ^u a woman1' & :at foll[s1 creat+ by a rod ( div9ity 9 man's he>t a f> sup]ior ideal ( ! moral2 :o he>d ) indiff]5ce ,8 ',bless ^? :o p]secute y2' yes1 li/5$ unmov$ to ,8 ',suff] little *ildr5 to come unto ,me2' :o he>d ) ang] ,8 ',9 heav5 !re is nei!r m>ry+ nor giv+ 9 m>riage2' :o abhorr$ ,8 great doctr9e t ! c\nsels ( ,god 7 n read 9 ! ev5ts ( ?+s#ca2 :o slight$ z trivial t pray] :i* a wise man might /udy ) pr(it = a ?\s& ye>s2 bea/s1 wret*es1 t turn$ away deaf & bl9d1 ev5 z _! sons turn away1 f ^! argum5ts ( a tru? f> transc5d+ all t yet _h come among/ m52 b :il/ trampl+ ) _! brutal ho(s ^u su* fl[]s ( ,p>adise1 turn$ 9 /upid wond]m5t to "s m]e leg]dema9 or juggl]y4 ,! ,tru?4--,b :at tongue c express1 :at scale c measure1 ! awful *ange 9 man's relations to ! unse5 _w8 ,:]e !re _h be5 a blank n fill$ by any?+1 n by any smoke or dusky t>ni% ( suspicion1 n fill$ by s mu* z any %ad[y outl9e or vague phantom ( possibility1 !re 0 n[ se5 ris+1 'l ,t5]iffe or ,atlas'--say r1 by symboliz+ ! greate/ ( human int]e/s by ! greate/ ( human visual objects1 l ! sn[y peaks ( ! ,himalaya1 peaks t by m5's feel+s are ref]r$ to ! heav5s r ?an to ! e>?2 to ! be+s '^: dwell+ is no ?ick fle%1' r ?an to m5 :o h 9 no age succe$$ 9 scal+ !m2 & :o 9 _! /eps to ^? mighty ?rones h he>d no?+ b dread cra%es ( s\nd--aga9 to fade or vani%1 ! colossal =m1 nev] ! mighty idea ( ',! ,tru?4'#cb ,:]e !re _h be5 no?+1 a blank1 a *asm1 !re /ood 9 solemn proportions a new object = man1 call$ ,! ,tru?4 ,:y 0 x call$ ,! ,tru?8 ,h[ c\ld su* an idea arise8 ,_m p]sons w be weak en\gh to fancy t1 z ,greek3 hopots 0 sometimes an artifice ( rhetoric = express+ ! exclusive supremacy ( ,hom]1 & z by a pure affectation & movem5t ( dissimulation a man 0 call$ by ! title ( ,! ,orator1 8 own fav\rite ,greek or ,roman ?us affect+ = ! mom5t to "k ( no o!r 7= all su* emphatic & exclusive uses ( ! imply a mom5t>y annihilation ( ! competitors1 z ?\gh 9 comp>ison ( ! ideal exemplification ^! m9or & approximat+ =ms _h no exi/5ce--or at lea/1 n quoad hunc locum--z '! m\nta9 9 ,sicily' w\ld rightly indicate ,etna71 on ! same artificial pr9ciple !y may imag9e rhetoricians to h d5om9at$ 7or if n1 to h _h x 9 _! p[] to d5om9ate7 "s "o dep>tm5t ( tru? :i* !y wi%$ to fav\r z ! tru?4 ,b ?is conv5tional d5om9ation w\ld n avail1 & = two reasons3 ,fir/1 t rival modes ( tru? 7physics aga9/ ma!matics1 rhetoric aga9/ music7 w\ld conte/ ! title1 & no su* d5om9ation w\ld h a basis ( any b a sort ( c\rtesy or vic>i\s h>moni\s reality f ! v fir/4 ,secondly1 t1 /&+ 9 no relation :atev] to ,god1 e mode1 =m1 division or subdivision ( tru? m]ely intellectual w\ld ga9 no?+ at all by su* o/5tati\s arts4 ,algebra has be5 di/+ui%$ by glori\s names2 s has ! fanci$ k ( transmutation appli$ to ! metals2 s1 d\btless1 has _m a vision>y speculation ( magic2 s1 aga91 has ! ridicul\s s*w]m]ey ( ! ,rabbis 9 p>ticul> ages4 ,b ^? are z transi5t & ev5 = ! mom5t z p>tial titles z ! titles ( ,inv9cible or ,s]aphic appli$ to s*ola/ic div9es4 ,out ( ?is idea ! tru? grew1 next 7suppose x7 ano!r ,m>tyrdom4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 all human doctr9es & ?is is z betwe5 a m>ble /atue & a quick ?+4 ,! /atue may be bett]1 & x may be ( bett] mat]ial2 x may be ( ivory1 ( m>ble1 & among/ m>bles kn[n to ! anci5t sculptors ( sev]al diff]5t k9ds ! mo/ priz$2 ( silv] gilt1 ( holl[ gold1 ( massy gold1 & 9 all degrees ( skill2 b /ill "o condition applies to all--:atev] ! mat]ial1 :oev] ! arti/1 ! /atue is inanimate1 ! brea? ( life is n )9 its no/rils4 ,motion1 spontaneity1 action & antagoni/ action1 ! subtle wat*-"w ( ! bra91 ! mighty laboratory ( ! he>t1 vision1 s5sibility1 self-propagat$ w>m?1 pleasure1 hope1 memory1 ?\ght1 lib]ty--n "o ( ^! div9e gifts does x possess4 ,x is cold1 icy1 s5seless1 dull1 in]t matt]4 ,let ,phidias h =m$ ! /atue1 x is no bett]4 ,let ! pure/ gold be its mat]ial1 x is no wor?i] ?an ! meane/ model 9 clay to ! valuation ( ! philosoph]4 ,& "h1 z 9 s _m cases1 ! great philosoph] meets ) ! lab\r+ man2 bo? meet ) ! little innoc5t *ild4 ,all h ! same und]valuation ( ! /atue4 ,& if any man values x prepo/]\sly1 x w be nei!r a great philosoph]1 nor a lab\r+ man ) horny fi/s1 nor a little innoc5t & natural *ild4 ,x w be "s crazy simpleton1 :o dignifies himself z a man ( ta/e1 z elegans =m>um spectator1 z "o hav+ a judici\s eye = ! di/9ctions ( =m4 ,b n[1 sudd5ly1 let "o ( ! meane/ ( ^! /atues beg9 to /ir & %iv] ) ! my/]y ( life1 let x be ann\nc$ t some?+ 'quick' is 9 ! =m1 let ! creep+ ( life1 ! suffusion ( s5sibility1 ! awful s5se ( responsibility & acc\ntability rip5 !mselves1 :at a %ock--:at a panic6 ,:at an int]e/--h[ pr(\nd--w\ld diffuse itself 9 e *annel4 ,su* is ! e?ics ( ,god z contra/$ ) ! e?ics ( ,greek philosoph]s4 ,! only great ?+ ev] done by ,greece or by ,greek philosoph]s 0 ! e?ics4 ,yet1 aft] all1 ^! 7 b integrations ( ! natural e?ics implant$ 9 ea* man's he>t4 ,integrations !y 71 b re>rangem5ts--r$evelopm5ts f "s common s\rce4 ,x is rem>kable t ! ,scriptures1 valu+ cle>ness & f5c+ aga9/ misund]/&+s above all ?+s1 nev] susp5d--!re is no ,greek3 epo* 9 ! scriptural /yle ( ! e>ly books4 ,&1 !re=e1 :5 ,i fir/ came to a text1 ',if :51' ,i 0 ?und]/ruck1 & ,i f\nd t ?is belongs to ! m cultivat$ age ( ,hebrew lit]ature4 ',& ! sw9e because x divide? ! ho(1 yet *ewe? n ! cud1 x is unclean unto y' 7,deut4 xiv4 #h74 ,n[ ! obvi\s mean+ is1 prim facie1 t ! gr\nd ( its uncleanness 0 its divid+ ! ho(4 ,:]eas1 s f> f ?is1 to divide ! ho( is a gr\nd ( cleanness4 ,x is a fact1 a s9e qu non--t is1 a negative condition ( cleanness2 b n1 !re=e1 tak5 s+ly ! affirmative or effici5t cause ( cleanness4 ,x mu/ 9 addition to ?is *ew ! cud--x mu/ rum9ate4 ,:i*1 aga91 0 b a s9e qu non--t is1 a negative condition1 indisp5sable1 inde$2 ^: abs5ce c\ld n be tol]at$ 9 any case1 b ^: pres5ce did n !re=e1 & z a matt] ( c\rse1 avail any?+4 ,= ! rev]se case occurr$ 9 ! camel1 h>e1 & rabbit4 ,!y d *ew ! cud1 ! abs5ce ( :i* habit caus$ ! sw9e to be reject$1 b !n !y 'divide n ! ho(4' ,accord+ly !y 7 equally reject$ z food ) ! sw9e4 ,we see ! great ,jewi% lawgiv] look+ =w>d to cases :i* actually occurr$ ne>ly five hundr$ ye>s aft]1 z dem&+ a k+1 & aga9 look+ /ill f>!r to cases eight hundr$ & a ?\s& ye>s aft]--_! disob$i5ce & rebellion to ,god4 ,n[1 _m w ?9k t x mu/ h be5 an easy ?+ = any p1 :5 sw]v+ f _! law1 & especially 9 t "o great fundam5tal article ( idolatry z ! ,jews s cont9ually did1 & s naturally :5 ! case is exam9$1 to always h an easy retreat3 ! plagues & curses d5\nc$ w\ld beg9 to unfold !mselves1 & !n :at m easy ?an to rel9qui% ! idolatr\s rites or cu/oms1 resum+ ) _! old rituals to ,god _! old privileges8 ,b ?is 0 d\bly impossible4 ,fir/1 because m5 utt]ly misconceive ! matt] :5 !y suppose t ) direct consecutive succession ! judgm5t w\ld succe$ ! trespass4 ,l>ge tracts ( "t w\ld int]v5e4 ,else su* direct clockwork z s9 & puni%m5t1 rep5tance & relief1 w\ld di%on\r ,god n less ?an !y w\ld trivialize ! p4 ,god !y w\ld (f5d by defeat+ all ,8 purposes2 ! p !y w\ld r5d] vile by rip5+ into me*anic dissimulation4 ,! wra? ( ,god slept (t5 = a long season2 ,he saw z "o :o saw n4 ,& by ! "t t ,8 l>ge c\ncils _h ov]tak5 !m1 & ,8 judgm5ts 7 fa/ com+ up ) ! (f5d]s1 !y _h s h>d5$ !mselves 9 error t a :ole gr[? ( false desires _h sprung up1 & ( false beliefs1 bl9d maxims1 bad habits1 bad connections1 & prov]bs1 :i* f\nd out a reconciliation ( t irreconcilable tru? ) ! f\le/ pollutions4 ,! victims ( temptation _h become sl[ ev5 to suspect _! own condition4 ,&1 if "s m enlight5$ did s1 ! road ( exi/5ce 0 no long] easy4 ,error _h wov5 *a9s ab\t !m4 ,!y 7 enme%$4 ,& x is b a fa9t emblem ( _! situation to say1 t z well may a man comm5ce a habit ( intoxication = ! purpose ( hav+ five ye>s' pleasure1 & !n halt+ 9 8 c>e]1 z ! ,jews may contam9ate !mselves t5tatively ) idolatr\s connections "u ! delusion t x w\ld always be "t en\gh = untread+ _! /eps :5 ^! connections _h begun to produce evil4 ,= !y c\ld n recov] ! /ation f :i* !y sw]v$4 ,!y t _h n[ realiz$ ! casus fo$]is1 ! case 9 :i* !y _h cov5ant$ !mselves to desi/ f idolatry1 7 no long] ! m5 :o _h made t cov5ant4 ,!y _h *ang$ pr(\ndly & imp]ceptibly4 ,s t ! v vision ( tru? 0 ov]ca/ ) c>nal d\bts2 ! tru? itself _h retir$ to a va/ di/ance & %one b feebly = !m1 & ! v w 0 palsi$ 9 its motions ( recov]y4 ,9 su* a /ate1 suppose x confirm$ & n[ ?reat5+ t[>ds a total ali5ation f ! tru? once deliv]$1 :at c\ld avail to save !m8 ,no?+ b affliction 9 ! heavie/ =m4 ,va9 x 0 n[ to hope = a *eap] re/oration1 s9ce ! v fir/ light5+ ( _! judicial puni%m5t w\ld seem to !m a reason = relaps+1 by seem+ to argue t !re _h be5 two pr9ciples4 ,x 0 b a false al>m1 !y w\ld say1 aft] all4 ,affliction1 !re=e1 0 pa/ all sub/itution or rem$y4 ,yet ev5 ?is case1 ?is pro/ration to ! gr\nd1 _h be5 met = a ?\s& ye>s by ,god's s]vants4 ,if ,i h %[n t quick5+ _s :i*1 diffus+ itself ?r\gh all ?\ghts1 s*emata1 possible pr9ciples1 motives ( s5sibility1 & =ms ( ta/e1 has diff]5c$ ! pre-,*ri/ian man f ! po/-,*ri/ian2 if ,i h detect$ t secret ^w :i* ,god subtly introduc$ into ?is _w1 kept 9 a /ate ( incubation = two mill5nia1 !n ) ! flames & visible ag5cy ( a volcanic explosion =c$ into inf9ite disruption1 caus$ to k9dle into a g5]al fire--t ^w by :i* sadness is spread ov] ! face ( ?+s1 b also inf9ite gr&eur--!n may ,i rightly lay ?is z "o *apt] ( my ,em5dation ( ,human ,k4 ,! same ?+ precisely takes place 9 lit]ature z 9 spiritual ?+s4 ,:5 a man is entangl$ & suffocat$ 9 bus9ess1 all relat+ to t :i* %r9ks up to a po9t--& obs]ve1 ,i d n mean t be+ conceiv$ z a t5t above 8 head x contracts1 b t1 view$ z a body at a di/ance1 x %r9ks up to a po9t1 & really vani%es z a real ?+--:5 ?is happ5s1 hav+ no subjective exi/5ce at all1 b purely & int5sely objective1 he misconceives x j 9 ! same way z a poor ignorant man misconceives le>n+ or k2 fancy+1 e4g41 l ,heylius s5ior1 t he ought to "k ! road out ( ! wood 9 :i* !y 7 !n entangl$4 ,x is probable t ,adam meant only ! unity ( man z to 8 nature1 :i* also is meant by mak+ all m5 ( "o blood4 ,simil>ly ,boeckh--,greek3 en g5ei--:i* does n mean t ,gods & m5 are ! same1 b t ( ea* ! sep>ate race has unity 9 itself4 ,s ! fir/ man1 ,adam1 w mean ! e>lie/ race ( m51 p]haps spread ?r\gh ?\s&s ( ye>s4 ,x is a viol5t case ( prejudice1 ?is ord9>y appeal ( ,bossuet1 ',qu'ont gagn les philosophes avec leurs disc\rs pompeux8' 7p4 #bij74 ,n[ h[ %\ld t case h be5 tri$ ?or\ghly be=e ! pr9t+ ( books8 ,yet x may be said ! ,gospel 0 s tri$4 ,true1 b )\t hav+ ! p[] ( fully gratify+ itself ?r\gh ! :ole range ( its capability4 ,t 0 = a lat] "t1 h5ce a new pro( ( its reality4 ,an ,analogy4--#a4 ,i h some:]e read t a wick$ set ( ,jews1 probably1 :5 rebuk$ = wick$ness1 repli$1 ',:at6 are we n ! peculi> p ( ,god8 ,/range1 !n1 if we may n h a privilege m ?an o!rs to d wrong6' ,! wret*es fanci$ t to be ! p ( ,god--! *os5 p--impli$ a lic5se to d wrong1 & _h a man told !m1 ,no1 x 0 j ! o!r way2 !y 7 to be bett] ?an o!rs1 absolutely1 !y w\ld h trembl$ ) wra?4 #b4 ,precisely ! same idea1 ,i am sure1 lurks 9 _m m9ds z to rep5tance4 ,x is odi\s to ?9k (1 ?is mak+ ,god ! abettor & enc\rag] ( evil2 b ,i am sure x is s1 viz41 t1 because ,god has said ,he w h m]cy on ! p5it5t1 !y fancy t1 z ! *ief consequ5ce f t doctr9e1 !y may commit s9s )\t anxiety2 ?\gh o!rs1 n "u ! ,*ri/ian privilege1 w\ld be call$ to acc\nt = ! same s91 p5it5t or n p5it5t4 ,b !y--su* is _! ?\ght--are enc\rag$ to s9 by ! assurance t rep5tance w always be op5 to !m1 & ?is !y may pursue at leisure4 ,n[1 if a man %\ld say3 ',b1 my fri5ds1 ?is means real p5it5ce2' !y w\ld reply1 ',oh1 b we mean real p5it5ce4' ',well1 if y d1 y mu/ "k t t is n always possible4' ',n possible6' ,!n make !m und]/& t2 !y w ro> ) wra?1 & prote/ aga9/ x z no privilege at all4 ,! lit]al int]pretation ( ! ,mosaic ,cosmogony is ! v expression ( a b>b>ian m9d & p1 rely+ s f> on magic z to make all natural process ( g5]ation or production impossible1 rely+ s f> on natural processes z to make ! fiat ( supreme p[] evid5tly inapplicable4 ,x is exactly ! ,m9]va ( ! ,pagans draggl$ 9 h] skirts4 ,idolatry4--,x is n only a m]e bl9d crot*et ( ,isaiah's 7,j]emiah's87 to ridicule idols--utt]ly wide ( any real imp]fection1 b also x misses all t really might be bad4 ,! true evil is n to k9dle ! idea ( ,apollo by an image or lik5ess1 b to wor%ip ,apollo1 i4e41 a god to be 9 "s s5se false--belong+ to a sy/em connect$ ) evil4 ,t may be bad2 b !re c be no sep>ate evil 9 reanimat+ ! idea ( ?is ,apollo by a picture4 ,i h obs]v$ _m times1 b nev] c\ld und]/& 9 any rational s5se1 ! habit ( f9d+ a confirmation ( ! ,bible 9 m]e ar*ologic facts occasionally br\ght to light & tally+ ) ! ,biblical records4 ,z 9 ! ,ph>aonic & ,egyptian usages1 & lately 9 ! case ( ,nimrod1 a great collat]al confirmation ( ,ezekiel has be5 fanci$4 ,b h[8 ,suppos+ ,ezekiel to h recit$ accurately ! dim5sions ( ,n9eveh1 h[ %\ld t make him a true prophet8 ,or suppos+ him a false "o1 :at motive %\ld t furni% = mismeasur+ ,n9eveh8 ,! ,gospels appe> to h be5 writt5 long aft] ! ev5ts1 & :5 controv]sies or v>iations _h aris5 ab\t !m1 !y h app>5tly be5 modifi$ & %ap$ to meet ^? disputes4 ,! sun /&s /ill4 ,i am p]suad$ t ?is means no su* incr$ible miracle z is ord9>ily imag9$4 ,! int]pretation arises f misconceiv+ an ,ori5tal expression1 & a =cible z well z natural "o4 ,( all p ! ,jews c\ld lea/ mi/ake ! nature ( ! sun & moon1 z ?\gh by possibility !y c\ld /& 9 a relation to a p>ticul> valley3 t ! sun c\ld h /ood /ill 9 ,gibeon1 & ! moon 9 ,ajalon4 ,s9ce !y view$ sun & moon z two great lights1 adequat$ & correspond+ to day & night1 t alone %[s t !y did n mean any objective sol/ice ( ! h\r1 = else :y 9 ,ajalon8 ,naturally x w\ld be a ph5om5on *iefly made kn[n to ! c5tral sanctity ( t ,god ^: miracul\s int]position _h caus$ s unkn[n an arre/ ( ord9>y nature2 ,j]usalem 0 n !n kn[n1 x 0 ,jebus1 a city ( ,jebusites2 & ! fact :i* subsequ5tly creat$ its sanctity did n occur till m ?an f\r c5turies aft]w>ds 7viz41 on ! ?re%+-floor ( ,araunah74 ,b ,%iloh exi/$1 & ,horeb1 & ,s9ai1 & ! graves ( ! ,patri>*s4 ,& all ^? places w\ld h exp\nd$ ! ref]5ce ( ! miracle1 w\ld h trac$ x to ! v s\rce ( its orig92 s z to %[ n !n only1 n to ! contempor>ies only1 b 7:i* w\ld be mu* m important7 to aft] g5]ations1 :o might suspect "s mi/ake 9 _! ance/ors z expla9+ _! mean+1 or 9 !mselves z und]/&+ x4 ,:at x really means1 ,i am p]suad$1 is m]ely to express t ! day 01 ( all hi/orical days1 ! mo/ important4 ,:at6 d p nev] reflect on ! ,greek3 to positive ( _! read+8 ,if !y did1 !y w\ld rememb] t ! v idea ( a great c>d9al ev5t1 z ( ! f\ndation ( ! ,olympiads1 0 z an arre/1 a paus+1 ( "t2 caus+ y to hang & l+] on t "t4 ,& ! gr&eur ( ?is ,jewi% ,wat]loo 9 :i* ,god e/abli%$ possessions = ,8 p & execut$ an e>?ly day ( judgm5t on ! anci5t pollut]s 7?r\gh p]haps a ?\s& ye>s7 ( ! sacr$ l& 7already sacr$ z ! abode & bury+-place ( ,8 fir/ s]vants "u a cov5ant7 0 express$ by say+ t ! day l+]$1 arre/$ itself by a bur!n ( glori\s revolution s mighty z ?is great day ( ov]?r[4 ,= rememb] ?is3 ,w\ld n ,god h *ang$ ,ph>aoh's he>t1 s intractable1 by su* a miracle1 _h x be5 at all op5 to ,8 et]nal laws8 ,:]eas1 if y say1 ,aye1 b on t acc\nt :y grant ev5 s mu* di/9ction to ! day z y\r ance/or does8 answ]1 x 0 ! f9al-cause day4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur* pret5ds to give away ! ,bible )\t note or comm5t1 or--:i*1 9 fact1 is ! mean+--any impulse or bias to ! read]'s m9d4 ,! mon/r\s conceit ( ! ,prote/ant ,*ur*es1 viz41 ! "r ( private judgm5t 7:i* is1 9 effect1 l ! "r to talk nons5se1 or ! "r to criticise ,sir ,john ,h]s*el's books )\t ma!matics71 is ?us slavi%ly hon\r$4 ,yet all is deception4 ,already 9 ! translation at _m hundr$ po9ts %e has laid a re/ra9+ bias on ! read]1 already by ! division ( v]ses1 already by ! runn+ ab/racts ov] ! ,prophets1 %e has done ?is4 ,c ! p[] adequat$ to a g5]ation ( m9ds1 or to a succession ( _m g5]ations1 f9d its compreh5sion 9 an individual8 ,c ! might :i* ov]fl[s ! heav5 ( heav5s be conf9$ )9 a local resid5ce l t :i* twice re>$ itself by its f\ndations1 & ?ree times by its battlem5ts1 above ! ?re%+-floor ( ,araunah8#cc ,( t my/]y1 ( t local circumscription--9 :at s5se x 0 effect$1 9 :at s5se n effect$1 we "k no?+4 ,b ?is by m]e human m$itation1 ?is pr(\nd difficulty we may humanly und]/& & measure1 viz41 ! all b impossibility ( rea*+ ! man :o /&s remov$ to an ext5t ( fifte5 c5turies4 ,b "h comes 9 ! unspiritual m9d :i* ?9ks only ( facts--yet m>k me s f>1 ,rome by an augury ( wick$ gods /ret*$ to a p]iod ( #a1bjj ye>s4 ,yet h[ op5 to d\bt 9 "o s5se6 ,n1 ,i am sure1 9 any s5se und]/ood by man1 b ,i d\bt n 9 ! om9\s s5se int5d$4 ,*ang$ 9 all ?+s ess5tial1 %e 0 yet a mighty scept]$ pot5tate = ! _w until h] dep5d5cy on ,attila's good-w & =be>ance4 #ddd aft] ,*ri/ add$ to #geb ,b4 ,c4 complete ! p]iod4 ,b p]iod = :at8 ,= :om8 ,= a great idea t c\ld n be lo/4 ,! conception c\ld n p]i% if ! execution p]i%$4 ,b1 next ?9k ( ! temptation to my?us4 ,&1 f9ally1 ( ,god's plan unrealiz$1 ,8 conceptions unansw]$4 ,we %\ld rememb] t by ! confusion introduc$ into ! economy ( int]nal ,div9e op]ations !re is a tw(old difficulty plac$ betwe5 ! pray] & ! atta9m5t ( ! pray]4 #a/1 ! deflection1 slight ?\gh x may seem to ! man1 f ! /ate ( p]fect simplicity & ( natural desire2 #bndly1 ! deflection ( ! object desir$ f ! p>allelism ) ! purposes n[ became necess>y to ,god 9 ord] to rem$y abnorm\s %ift+ ( ! c5tre by man4 ,& aga91 9 ! "q ( ! language ( ,scripture1 ,i see ! same illu/ration4 ,sir ,william ,jones1 9 a fit ( luxuri\s pleasure-giv+1 l ,gibbons' fooli% fit#cd z to ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,c>?ag5a1 praises ! language ( ,scripture z unatta9able4 ,i say1 ,no4 ,?is is hypocrisy4 ,x is no di%on\r if we say ( ,god t1 9 ! s5se meant by ,sir ,william ,jones1 x is n possible = ,him to speak bett] ?an p[]ful writ]s c speak4 ,!y h ! same language z _! in/rum5t1 & z impossible w\ld x be = ,apollonius or ,sir ,william ,jones to p]=m a simple process ( addition bett] ?an an ord9>y keep] ( a %op4 ,9 ! s*emata1 because 9 ! orig9al ideas1 ,god says inde$ :at man _c1 = ^! are peculi> to ,god2 b :o be=e myself has %[n :at !y 78 ,z to m]e language1 h[ev]1 & its managem5t1 we h ! same id5tically4 ,& :5 a language lab\rs "u an infirmity1 z all d1 n ,god ,himself c\ld surm\nt x6 ,he is compromis$1 co]c$1 by ! elem5ts ( language2 b :at ( t8 ,x is an elem5t ( man's creat+4 ,& j z 9 desc5d+ on man by ,8 answ]s ,god is defeat$ or di/ort$ _m times by ! f\l atmosph]e 9 :i* man has ?r[n himself1 s 9 desc5d+ ^u ! m9d 7unless by dreams1 or "s language t he may h kept pure71 ,god is ?w>t$ & controll$ by ! imp]fections ( human language4 ,&1 ap>t f ! ideas1 ,i myself c\ld imitate ! ,scriptural language--,i "k its secret1 its pr9ciple ( movem5t :i* lies *iefly 9 high ab/ractions--f> bett] ?an is done 9 mo/ p>ts ( ! ,apocrypha4 ,! p[] lies 9 ! _s--! animat+ pr9ciple2 & v]ily su* a p[] seems to exi/4 ,& ! fact d]iv$ f ! hol9ess1 ! re/ra9ts ev5 ^u ! ,almighty's p[] ?r\gh ,8 own hol9ess1 goodness1 & wisdom1 are s va/ t1 in/ead ( ! unlimit$ p[] :i* hypocritical glorifi]s ascribe to ,him by way ( lip-hon\r1 9 rea*+ man ex-abundantibus 9 s transc5d5t a way t m]e excess ( means w\ld h p]plex$ a human *oice1 on ! contr>y1 ,i am p]suad$ t besides ! gulf ( #a1ejj ye>s s z to hold on1 s z to hold h>d1 & to effect ! translation ( ,8 w unalt]$1 uncorrupt$1 ?r\gh ! viol5t assaults ( idolatries all r\nd1 & ! p]v]se1 head/rong weakness ( a naturally unbeliev+ p1#ce d[n to ! "t ( ,*ri/ f ! "t ( ,moses--!re 0 ! lab\r h>dly to be effect$2 & :y8 ,i h always be5 a/oni%$ at m5 treat+ su* a case z a simple orig9al problem z to ,god4 ,b f> o!rwise4 ,x 0 a problem second>y to a *ange effect$ by man4 ,8 rays1 ,8 sun1 /ill desc5d$ z ev]2 b :5 !y came ne> to ! f\l atmosph]e ( man1 no ray c\ld pi]ce un/a9$1 unrefract$1 or ev5 untwi/$4 ,x 0 di/ort$ s z to make x h>dly )9 ! limits ( human capacity 7obs]ve1 ! difficulty 0 9 ! human p[] to receive1 to su/a91 to compreh5d--n 9 ! ,div9e p[] to radiate1 to receive :at 0 direct$ to x74 ,(t5 ,i h reflect$ on ! trem5d\s gulf ( sep>ation plac$ betwe5 man1 by 8 own act1 & all ! ,div9e bless+s :i* c\ld visit him4 7,?is is illu/rat$ by pray]2 =1 :ile we ?9k x odd t s _m pray]s ( good m5 = legitimate objects ( pray] %\ld seem to be unansw]$1 we nev]!less act z to our pray]s 9 a k9d ( unconsci\s hypocrisy1 z ?\gh to our s5se !y _h be5 answ]$ 9 "s ineffable way1 & all ! :ile our conduct1 to speak /rictly1 lies outside all ?is1 & rema9s :olly un9flu5c$ by x74 ,^! ideas ( ,god h life only by _! own inh]5t p[]3 yet :at risk t ,jews %\ld lapse into suppos+ !mselves sep>ately a fav\r$ p8 ,by ?is v error !y committ$ ! rebellion aga9/ :i* !y _h be5 w>n$--9 believ+ t !y only 7 conc]n$ 9 receiv+ a sup]natural aid ( r$emption3 ?us sil5tly sub/itut+ _! own m]its = ! ,div9e purposes4 ,all :i* did 9 fact happ54 ,b _! errors 7 ov]rul$1 else h[ c\ld ! human race be conc]n$ 9 _! (f5ces1 errors1 or m9i/ries8 ,! ,jews =got :at we mod]ns =get1 t !y 7 no sep>ate objects ( fav\r ) ,god1 b only a means ( fav\r4 ,:at occasion to 'argal-b>gal' ab\t :y ,god did n soon] accompli% ! s*eme ( ,*ri/ianity8 ,= besides t1 #a/1 possibly ! s*eme 9 its expansion ^u e>? requir$ a correspond+ expansion else:]e2 #bndly1 x is evid5t ev5 to our human s5se t none b ! mo/ *ildi% eudamoni/1 ^: notion ( happ9ess is t ( lazy luxury1 w\ld ?9k ( cramm+ m51 bidd+ !m op5 _! m\?s1 & at once drugg+ !m ) a s5sual opium 7z all bless+ mu/ be )\t previ\s & comm5surate elevation to ! level ( t bless+72 #crdly1 ! physical nature ( ! evil to be undone 0 su* z w\ld n h be5 7objectively w\ld n h be51 b /ill less c\ld x subjectively h be57 = ! conception ( man t dreadful my/]y :i* x really is1 _h ! awful introv]sion be5 measur$ back by few] /eps2 #d?ly1 & f9ally1 x seems at fir/ sight %ock+ to say ( ,god t ,he _c d ?is & ?is1 b x is n s4 ,)\t adv]t+ to ! d>k necessities t compass our *aotic s5se :5 we asc5d by cont9ual ab/raction to ! absolute1 )\t entangl+ ourselves va9ly 9 ^? wild]nesses t no creat$ intellect c range or measure--ev5 "o sole attribute ( ,god1 ,8 hol9ess1 makes x z impossible = ,him to proce$ except by c]ta9 /eps z x w\ld be impossible = a man1 ?\gh a free ag5t1 & app>5tly ma/]1 z he feels & ?9ks1 ( 8 own life1 to cut 8 ?roat :ile 9 a /ate ( pleasurable heal? bo? ( m9d & body4 #e4--,political1 etc4 ,sir ,rob]t ,walpole1 z to patriots1 0 l a man :o has orig9ally1 f 8 nurs]y up1 be5 ?or\ghly imbu$ ) ! t]ror ( gho/s1 :i* by education & example aft]w>ds he has be5 enc\rag$ to d5y4 ,half he does disbelieve1 &1 "u enc\rag+ circum/ances1 he does disbelieve x /\tly4 ,b at e fre% plausible al>m 8 e>ly fai? intrudes ) bitt] hatr$ aga9/ a class ( appe>ances t1 aft] all1 he is ^u sy/em pl$g$ to hold false4 ,no?+ c be m ludicr\s ?an 8 outcry1 & 8 la%+ ( 8 own tail to excite 8 c\rage & 8 wra? & 8 d5ial--?an 8 *all5ge ( ! lurk+ patriots 9 :at he conceives ! matt] ( frauds on ! rev5ue4 ,he assaults !m z if he saw !m /&+ 9 a r[ beh9d ! door1 & yet he pummels !m = be+ m]e m5 ( ! %ades--horrible mock]ies4 ,_h !re be5 any tru? 9 _! exi/5ce1 surely1 s /rongly z !y mu/] by _! own report1 "s "o or o!r ( ?is fact %\ld h giv5 me w>n+--%\ld h expos$ ! frauds4 ,b no1 all are sil5t z ! grave4 ,b "h ,sir ,rob]t ,walpole is z mu* wrong z if1 d\bt+ ! value or p[] ( ,me?odi/ prea*]s1 he %\ld make x ! te/ ( _! useful exi/5ce t1 z (t5 z a highwayman1 a footpad1 />t$ out ( ! wayside1 f ! o!r side %\ld />t a ,me?odi/ prea*] to reason ) him & to conv]t him4 ,are ! ,:igs less ari/ocratic ?an ! ,tories8 ,n at all4 ,9 t5d5cy by pr9ciple !y are ! same4 ,! real diff]5ce is n 9 ! cre$1 9 ! gr\ndwork1 b 9 c]ta9 po9ts ( practice & me?od4 ',he took 8 /& ^u ! tru?'--said by me ( ,sir ,rob]t ,peel--might seem to argue a l[] use ( '! tru?1' b 9 fact x is z happ5s to ! article ! itself3 y say ! gu>d1 speak+ ( a coa*2 ! key1 speak+ ( a trunk or wat*1 i4e41 ! z by usage appropriat$ to e coa*1 wat*1 trunk4 ,s "h ! tru?1 namely1 ( ! p>ticul> p]plexity4 ,! ,sepoy mut9y w be be/ und]/ood if y suppose ! ,roman emp]ors1 f ,romulus to ,augu/us1 f ! ,alban ,fa!rs d[n to ! ,o/rogo?s--! :ole l9e ( a ?\s& ye>s cr[d$ into two4 ,trunkmak]s may be great m53 !y cle>ly h ! upp] h& ( au?ors :om all ! _w admits to be great m54 ,= ! trunkmak] is ! pr9cipal 9 ! conc]n--he makes ! trunk1 :]eas ! au?or1 q a second>y arti/1 furni%es only ! l9+s4 99 99 99 99 99 ,case ( ,casui/ry4--,wraxall ju/ly notices t errors l ,pr9ce ,rup]t's f excess ( c\rage1 h[ev] ru9\s1 are nev] res5t$ by a c\ntry4 ,ergo ! inf]5ce t prud5ce w\ld be1 always if 9 ,byng's or ,"l ,/4 ,g]man's cases1 9 a matt] ( d\bt held to be bold fight+2 & yet 9 morals is t an all[able position8 #f4--,p]sonal ,confessions1 etc4 ,avaunt1 ye hypocrites6 :o make a :9+ pret5ce1 accord+ to a fix$ rule1 ( v]bally utt]+ ?anks to ,god = e *a/isem5t1 & :o say ?is is good = y4 ,s d n ,i1 be+ upright1 & ,god see+ my he>t1 :o also sees t ,i murmur n2 b if x 7 n good 9 ! end1 yet ,i submit4 ,he is n (f5d$ t ) upright s9c]ity ,i give no ?anks = x4 ,& ,i say t1 unless a man p]ceives ! p>ticul> way 9 :i* x has be5 good = him1 he _c s9c]ely1 truly1 or s z n to mock ,god ) 8 lips1 give ?anks simply on an priori pr9ciple1 ?\gh1 ( c\rse1 he may submit 9 humbl5ess4 ,i d n believe t ! fai? ( any man 9 ! app>5t fact t he w nev] aga9 see su* a p]son 7i4e41 by be+ remov$ by dea?7 is real4 ,i believe t ! degree ( fai? 9 ?is respect is regulat$ by an orig9al sett+ or fix+ ( our nature q unconsci\s to ourselves4 ,s1 aga91 ,i believe t hope is nev] utt]ly )drawn1 despair is nev] absolute4 ,& aga91 ,i believe t1 at ! l[e/ nadir1 ! res\rce ( dy+ z a means ( escape & translation to new *ances & op5+s is lodg$ 9 e man f> d[n bel[ ! sunlights ( consci\sness4 ,he feels t 8 dea? is n f9al2 7 x o!rwise he c\ld n ru% at ! escape s lightly4 ,inde$1 7 8 fate fix$ immutably1 ,i feel t x w\ld n h be5 left possible = him to commit suicide4 ,ju/ice4--,y say 9 ! usual _s ( vanity1 ,y or ,x has ! same degree ( ! _s ( ju/ice z ,v4 ,?is is easily said1 b ! te/ is1 :at w he d = x8 ,suppose a man to propose rew>ds exclusively to ^? :o assi/$ at a fire1 !n ,x & ,y1 suppose1 h equally se5 t _m did n assi/1 ev5 refus$ to d s4 ,b ,x p]haps w %r9k f expos+ !m2 ,v w enc\nt] any hatr$ = tru? & ju/ice by expos+ ! undes]v+4 ,x is a fooli% ?+ to say ',h>d words break no bones4' ,h[ impossible to call up f ! dep?s ( =gott5 times all ! unju/ or %ock+ ins9uations1 all ! scornful refusals to und]/& "o aright1 etc4 ,b surely an injury is no?+ to !m2 = t may be measur$1 made s5sible1 & _c be =gott51 :]eas ! o!r case is l ! dispute1 ',is he wrong z a poet8' comp>$ ) ?is1 ',is he wrong z a geometrician8' ,!re ne$ be no ang] ) ! latt] dispute2 x is capable ( decision4 ,!n1 aga91 a he>t s lac]at$ is requir$ by ,*ri/ianity to =give ! lac]ator4 ,h>d x is to d1 & imp]fectly x is ev] done1 except ?r\gh ! unbuckl+ ( human nature "u high] inspirations work+ toge!r ) "t4 ,in/ead ( be+ any complim5t x is ! mo/ pr(\nd insult1 ! idea "o c write some?+ rapidly4 ,x is no homage to ! writ]2 x is villa9\s ins5sibility to ! writt54 ,two subjects ( /ories occur to me4 #a4 ,= my ,arabian tales1 f\nd$ on ! /ory ( ! ,m9yas ,treasure-,h\se at ,or*om5us4 #b4 ,ano!r ( an abbess1 :o 0 su* by disp5sation1 b _h be5 m>ri$2 h] accompli%$ son succe$s 9 c>ry+ (f a nun4 ,%e lab\rs = ! discov]y & puni%m5t ( ! unkn[n crim9al1 till %e le>ns :o he is2 !n p>t+ f him = ev] 9 ! e>ly dawn1 %e1 sacrific+ to a love t = h] 0 to produce only hatr$ & ! total de/ruction ( ! total hopes ( h] age+ life4 ,spl5dide ,m5dax6 & ! m angel %e4 ,i f9d ! d\ble effect z ! reason ( my n[ read+ aga9 ) pr(it e book1 h[ev] (t5 read 9 e>li] times1 t by & ?r\gh my great] k & ! m num]\s que/ions gr[+ out ( t k1 ,i h deep] int]e/1 & by & ?r\gh ?is deep] int]e/ ,i h a value put ^u ^? que/ions1 & ,i h o!r que/ions sup]v5+ ?r\gh ! int]e/ alone4 ,! int]e/ is inc>nat$ 9 ! wid] k2 ! k is inc>nat$ 9 ! int]e/1 or at lea/ ! curiosity & que/ions4 ,^u try+ to impr9t ^u my memory t at su* a p]iod ! ,argives ceas$ to be call$ ,pelasgi1 & 7 h5ce=w>d call$ ,danai1 ,i felt h[ impracticable 7& d\btless 9 _! degree injuri\s1 = ?\gh an inf9itesimal injury only z reg>ds any s+le act d\btless1 yet1 p] se1 by t5d5cy d\btless all blank ef=ts ( ! memory unsupport$ by ! und]/&+ are bad71 mu/ be any viol5t ef=ts ( ! memory n fall+ 9 ) a previ\s prep>$ness4 ,music4--,i am satisfi$ t music involves a f> great] my/]y ?an we are aw>e (4 ,x is t univ]sal language :i* b9ds toge!r all creatures1 & b9ds !m by a pr(\nd] "p ( _! nature ?an any?+ m]ely intellectual ev] c\ld4 ,x is rem>kable 7z prov+ to me ! delibility ( ca/e7 t ! ,sudras ( ,c5tral ,india1 dur+ its va/ confusions "u ! ,mahrattas h endeav\r$ to pass !mselves = desc5dants ( ! ,k%atriyas 7or w>rior ca/e7 by assum+ ! sacr$ ?read1 also assum$ by ! ,rajpoots1 & also by "s ( ! ,sikhs4 ,i nev] see a va/ cr[d ( faces--at !atres1 races1 reviews--b "o ?+ makes !m sublime to me3 ! fact t all ^! p h to die4 ,/range x is t ?is multitude ( p1 s _m ( !m intellectually1 b also 7:i* is worse7 morally1 bl9d1 are )\t =e?\ght or s5se ( ! realities ( life4 ,?\gh ,i love fun1 et]nal je/+1 buffoon]y1 punn+ absolutely kills me4 ,su* ?+s d]ive all _! value f be+ made to int]v5e well ) o!r ?+s4 ,?is is curi\s3 ,%ame1 pa91 & pov]ty %all ,i endure1 ,:5 ropes or opium c my ease procure8 ,?is (f5ds nobody1 n till y say1 ',i'll buy a rope4' ,b n[3 ,:5 money's gone1 & ,i no debts c pay1 ,self-murd] is an hon\rable way-- ?\gh ! same ess5tially1 ?is %ocks all m54 ,i h 9 ! c\rse ( my mis=tunes fa/$ = ?irty ye>s3 a dreadful fate1 if x _h be5 to come4 ,b1 be+ pa/1 x is lawful to reg>d x ) satisfaction1 z hav+1 l all fa/+ & mortification1 %>p5$ to an excruciat+ degree my intellectual faculties4 ,h5ce my love & ev5 furor n[ = ma!matics1 f :i* 9 my y\? ,i fl$4 ,! ,arr[ ,ket*1 six guns1 is record$ 9 ! ,ed9burgh ,adv]tis] = ,june #ad?1 #ahdd1 z hav+ return$ home 7to ,portsm\?7 on ,?ursday1 ,june #g?1 'aft] six ye>s & upw>ds 9 commission1' mo/ ( x survey+ ! ,falkl& ,isl&s2 'has lo/ only two m5 dur+ ?is long s]vice1 & ^? f natural causes2' 'nev] lo/ a sp>1 & has pl\gh$ ! ocean = upw>ds ( #ajj1jjj miles4' ,anecdotes f ,ed9burgh ,adv]tis]1 = ,june & ,may4 ,! dog ( a boy t di$ p>alytic f grief4 ,little *ild run ov] by railway waggon & horse1 clapp+ its h&s :5 ! %ad[ pass$ away1 leav+ x unhurt4 ,little girl ( six committ+ suicide f fe> ( a /epmo!r's wra?4 ,to note ! dire reactions 787 ( evils3 "y ?ieves gr[+ to old ones1 no sew]s1 damp1 fam9e-eng5d]+1 desolat+ & wa/+ plagues or typhus fev]1 want ( gran>ies or m5daci\s viol5ce de/roy+ food1 civil feuds com+ r\nd 9 int]nec9e w>s1 & g5]al desolations1 &1 z 9 ,p]sia1 eight millions occupy+ ! home/eads ( ?ree hundr$ millions4 ,"h1 if any:]e1 is se5 ! almighty reactions ?r\gh :i* ! cycle ( human life1 oscillat+1 moves4 ,9 ! spee* ( ! ,"l ,provo/ ( ,ed9burgh 7report$ on ,june #ad?1 #ahdd71 x is recit$ t boys 'left to /roll ab\t ! /reets & closes1' acquire habits s fix$1 if n ( vice1 at lea/ ( idl5ess1 t 9 consequ5ce ( _! n be+ tra9$ to "s k9d ( discipl9e 9 _! e>ly ye>s1 ! habit ( vagabondiz+ acquires su* p[] t x is uncontrollable4 ,& h[ apt & =cible 0 t quotation 9 ! place assign$ x3 ',if ?\ =be> to deliv] !m t are drawn unto dea?1 & ^? t are ready to be sla92 if ?\ saye/1 ,behold1 we knew x n1 do? n ,he t pond]e? ! he>t1 consid] x8'--consid] x1 reg>d x1 make acc\nt ( x4 ,mann]s4--,! mak+ game ( a s]vant be=e company--a ?+ impossible to well-br$ p4 ,n[ obs]ve h[ ?is is illu/rative ( ,h---- ,/reet4 ,i confess myself :olly at a loss to compreh5d ! objections ( ! ,we/m9/] review] & ev5 ( my fri5d ,dr4 ,ni*ol1 to my comm5t>y on ! /range appe>ance 9 ,orion4 ,! review] says t ?is appe>ance 7on :i* he seems to f9d my language incompreh5sible7 _h be5 disp]s$ by ,"l ,rosse's telescope4 ,true1 or at lea/ s ,i he>4 ,b = all ?is1 x 0 orig9ally creat$ by t telescope4 ,x 0 9 ! int]val betwe5 ! fir/ report & ! subsequ5t reports f ,"l ,rosse's telescope t ,i made my comm5t>y4 ,b 9 ! case ( contradiction betwe5 two reports1 m accurate report ,i h n4 ,z reg>ds ! review]1 !re _h be5 no "t = ?is1 because ! book1 :i* he reviews1 is a simple repr9t 9 ,am]ica1 :i* he kn[s ,i _h _h no opportunity ( revis+4 ,b ,dr4 ,ni*ol p]plexes me4 ,t a new /age ( progress _h alt]$ ! appe>ances1 z d\btless fur!r /ages w alt] !m1 conc]ns me no?+1 ?\gh ref]r+ to a com+ republication2 = bo? alike app>5tly misund]/ood ! case z ?\gh x requir$ a real ph5om5on = its basis4 ,to und]/& ! matt] z x really is1 ,i beg to /ate ?is case4 ,wordswor? 9 at lea/ f\r diff]5t places 7"o be+ 9 ! f\r? book ( ',! ,excursion1' ?ree o!rs 9 ,sonnets7 describes mo/ impressive appe>ances among/ ! cl\ds3 a mon/]1 = in/ance1 ) a bell-hang+ air1 a dragon agape to swall[ a gold5 spe>1 & v>i\s o!rs ( affect+ beauty4 ,w\ld x h be5 any j rebuke to ,wordswor? if "s fri5d _h writt5 to him3 ',i regret mo/ s9c]ely to say t ! dragon & ! gold5 spe> _h all vani%$ be=e n9e o'clock'8 ,s1 aga91 ( ,haw?orne's face on a rock4 ,! v beauty ( su* appe>ances is 9 "p _! evanesc5ce4 ,to be or n to be4 ',n to be1 by ,g----' said ,g>rick4 ,?is is to be cit$ 9 relation to ,pope's-- ',man nev] is1 b always to be bless$4' ,political ,economy4--,:i* ( ^! two c\rses %all ,i take8 #a4 ,%all ,i revise1 ext5d1 cond5se my logic ( ,political ,economy1 embody+ e doctr9e 7& numb]+ !m7 :i* ,i h am5d$ or re-position$1 & introduce !m ?us 9 a lett] to ! ,politico-,economical ,society3 ',g5tlem51 c]ta9 ideas fundam5tal to ,political ,economy ,i pres5t$ 9 a book 9 ! endeav\r to effect a c]ta9 purpose4 ,^! 7 too mu* int]m+l$ ) less elem5t>y ideas 9 consequ5ce ( my defective self-comm& f a dreadful n]v\s idea1 & ?us by int]weav+ !y 7 ov]lapp$ & lo/4 ,b ,i am n dispos$ to submit to t wrong4 ,i affirm /eadily t ! f\ndations ( ,political ,economy are rott5 & crazy4 ,i defy1 & tak+ up my /& z a s*ol> ( ,ari/otle1 ,i defy all m5 to ga9say ! foll[+ exposures ( folly1 "o or any ( !m4 ,& :5 ,i %[ ! d>kness all r\nd ! v base ( ! hill1 all read]s may judge h[ great is t d>kness4' ,or1 #b4 ,%all ,i introduce !m z a *apt] 9 my ,logic8 #g4--,,pagan ,,lit]ature4 ,we mu/ nev] =get1 t x is n imp> m]ely1 b also disp>4 ,& su* is its value 9 ?is light1 t ,i prote/ five hundr$ k+s' ransoms1 nay1 any sum conceivable z a common contribution f all nations w\ld n be too mu* = ! inf9ite treasure ( ! ,greek tragic drama alone4 ,is x sup]ior to our own8 ,no1 nor 7s f> z capable ( collation7 n by _m degrees approa*+ to x4 ,& 7 ! case1 !re=e1 "o m]ely ( degrees1 !re w\ld be no room = ! pleasure ,i express4 ,b x %[s u ! ultimatum ( ! human m9d mutilat$ & ca/rat$ ( its inf9ities1 & 7:at is worse7 ( its moral inf9ities4 ,y mu/ imag9e n only ev]y?+ :i* !re is dreadful 9 fact1 b ev]y?+ :i* !re is my/]i\s to ! imag9ation 9 ! p>iah condition1 be=e y c approa* ! ,h]acleid4 ,yet1 ev5 ) ?is p>iah1 h[ poorly d mo/ m5 conceive x z no?+ m ?an a civil1 a police1 an economic affair6 ,valck5a]1 an admirable ,greek s*ol>1 0 n a man ( f9e und]/&+2 nor1 to say ! tru?1 0 ,porson4 ,inde$1 x is rem>kable h[ mean1 vulg>1 & uncapaci\s has be5 ! range ( intellect 9 _m fir/-rate ,grecians2 ?\gh1 on ! o!r h&1 ! read] w\ld deeply deceive himself if he %\ld imag9e t ,greek is an atta9m5t o!r ?an difficult1 labori\s1 & requir+ exempl>y tal5ts4 ,greek tak5 s+ly is1 to use an indisp5sable ,lat9 ^w1 in/>1 ! k ( all o!r languages4 ,b m5 ( ! highe/ tal5ts h (t5 begg>ly und]/&+s4 ,h5ce1 9 ! case ( ,valck5a]1 we mu/ d]ive ! contradictions 9 8 diatribe4 ,he practises ?is intol]able artifice2 he calls himself ,greek3 phil5ripideios2 bespeaks an unfair confid5ce f ! read]2 he takes cr$it = be+ once dispos$ to fav\r & indulge ,euripides4 ,9 ?is way he accr$its to ! c>eless read] all ! false *>ges or baseless concessions :i* he makes on any "q betwe5 ,euripides & 8 rivals4 ,su* m5 z ,valck5a] x is :o are bias$ & inflect$ be=eh&1 )\t p]ceiv+ x1 by all ! commonplaces ( criticism4 ,^!1 x is true1 d n arise out ( m]e %ad[s4 ,usually !y h a f\ndation 9 "s fact or modification4 ,:at !y fail 9 is1 9 ! j int]pretation ( ^! tru?s1 & 9 ! read+ ( _! high] relations4 ',! ,correggiosity ( ,correggio' 0 precisely meant = ,valck5a]4 ,! ,sophocleity ( ,sophocles he is ke5 to recognise1 & ! sup]iority ( ,sophocles z an arti/ is und5iable2 nor is x an advantage difficult to detect4 ,on ! o!r h&1 to be m ,hom]ic ?an ,hom] is no praise = a tragic poet4 ,x is f> m j1 p]t95t praise1 x is a gr\nd ( f> m int]e/+ praise1 t ,euripides is grant$ by 8 und]values to be ! mo/ tragic 7,greek3 tragi*otatos7 ( tragic poets4 ,aft] t he c af=d to let ,sophocles be ',greek3 ,hom]i*tos1 :o1 aft] all1 is n ',greek3 ,hom]i*tutos1 s long z s*ylus survives4 ,b ev5 s f> we are valu+ ,euripides z a poet4 ,9 ano!r "*1 z a philosoph]1 z a l>ge capaci\s ?9k]1 z a ma/] ( p5sive & sorr[-ta9t$ wisdom1 z a l>ge review] ( human life1 he is z mu* beyond all rival%ip f 8 sc5ic bre?r5 z he is bel[ "o ( !m z a sc5ic arti/4 ,is ! ,nile anci5t8 ,s is ,hom]4 ,is ! ,nile remote & hid+ its head 9 fable8 ,s is ,hom]4 ,is ! ,nile ! diffusive b5efactor ( ! _w8 ,s is ,hom]4#cf ,! neid4--,x is n any suppos$ excell5ce t has embalm$ ?is poem2 b ! en%r9+ ( ! diff]5tial ,roman pr9ciple 7! gr& aspir+ "* ( resolution71 all ref]r$ to ! c5tral pr9ciple ( ! aggr&izem5t ( ,rome4 ,! sublime ( wra? is n[h]e exhibit$ s well z 9 ,juv5al4 ,yet 9 ,juv5al pretty glimpses ( rural re/-- '444 infans cum collusore catello4'#cg ,t is pretty6 ,!re is ano!r :i* comes to my m9d & sugge/s 8 ris+ up & lay+ aside1 etc41 & %[s x to be an occasional act1 &1 ergo1 8 g>d5 is b a relaxation1 amusem5t4 ,glances :i* ! haughty eyes ( ,rome ?rew sometimes g5tly & rel5t+ly aside on man or woman1 *ildr5 or ! fl[]s4 ,h]odotus is z sceptical z ,plut>* is cr$ul\s4 ,h[ (t5 is n[ & at ?is "t appli$ to ! fictiti\s pres5t ( ! au?or1 :il/ a man argu+ g5]ally be=eh& w\ld say t surely a man c\ld always di/+ui% betwe5 n[ & !n4 #h4--;,,hi/orical1 ,,etc4 ,gr[? ( ! ,h\se ( ,commons4--,! ,h\se ( ,commons 0 ! p[] ( ! purse1 & :at gave its emphasis to t p[]8 ,simply ! gr[+ necessity ( /&+ =ces1 & ! gr[+ increase ( w>1 s t n[ out ( tw5ty millions1 fifte5 are appli$ to army & navy4 ,"o great evil1 z 9 practice x _h begun to %[ itself1 press$ ) equal inju/ice on ! p>ty :o suff]$ f x 7viz41 ! nation71 & ! p>ty :o seem$ to reap its b5efit4 ,?is 0 ! fact t z yet no sep>ation _h tak5 place betwe5 ! royal peculi> rev5ue1 & t ( ! nation4 ,! advance ( ! nation 0 n[ 7#afjc1 #a/ ( ,james ,i47 approa*+ to ! po9t :i* made ! evil oppression1 & yet _h n absolutely rea*$ ! po9t at :i* x c\ld be und5iably p]ceiv$4 ,mu* conte/ & debate divid$ ! /age ( incipi5t evil f ! /age ( confess$ grievance4 ,9 sp5d+ #ajj1jjj ^u a s+le fte1 ,james ,i4 might reasonably allege t he misappli$1 at any rate1 8 own funds4 ,wise or n1 ! act conc]n$ 8 own private h\sehold4 ,yet1 on ! o!r h&1 9 ! case ( money really public1 ! confusion ( ! two exp5ditures invit$ & veil$ ! transf] ( mu* f national objects t c\ld wait1 & 71 at any rate1 hidd5 f effectual scrut9y to ! private objects :i* tempt$ ! k+'s pr(usion4 ,:5 ,mr4 ,macaulay speaks s (t5 ( ,engl& s9k+ "u ?is or t ,/u>t to a ?ird-rate p[]1 he is ana*roniz+4 ,!re 0 no scale ( p[]s4 ,want ( roads & int]communication =bade x4 ,& h5ce until ! ,?irty ,ye>s' ,w> !re 0 no g5]al w>4 ,au/ria1 z by fiction ! ,roman ,empire1 & always /&+ awfully ne> to ,nor? ,italy1 _h a natural relation & gravitation t[>ds ,rome4 ,france1 by va+lory & ! old lit]>y pret5sions ( ,anj\1 _h also a balanc+ claim ^u ,italy4 ,milanese =m$ inde$ 7z ,fl&]s aft]w>ds7 ! r5dezv\s = ! two p[]s4 ,o!rwise1 only ,au/ria & ,spa9 7& ,spa9 n till jo9$ to ,au/ria7 & ,france--z great p[]s t t\*$ ea* o!r 9 _m po9ts--_h ev] =m$ a w>like trio4 ,no quadrille _h exi/$ until ! great civil w> = life & dea? betwe5 ,pop]y & ,prote/antism4 ,x 0 ano!r great evil t ! functions t[>ds :i*1 by inevitable in/9cts & t5d5cy ( progress1 ! ,h\se ( ,commons 0 cont9ually travell+1--n1 ,i repeat1 ?r\gh any encroa*+ _s z ! ,c\rt & t ,h\se ( ,commons itself p>tially fanci$1--7 n yet develop$3 false laws ( m51 i4e41 laws fram$ "u !ories misund]/ood ( rights & con/itutional p[]s1 hav+ z mu* di/ort$ ! true natural play ( ! organic manife/ation & t5d5cy t[>ds a :ole1 z ev] a dress too tight1 or a fl[]-pot too n>r[1 imp$$ ! developm5t ( *ild or plant4 ,que5 ,elizabe?1 !re=e1 always view$ ! ,h\se ( ,commons z a di/urb] ( ! public peace1 z a mut9e] & insurrectioni/1 :5 any special accid5t ?rew x ^u its natural function2 %e spoke ( ,/ate affairs1 & especially ( =eign affairs1 z beyond _! 'capacity1' :i* expression1 h[ev]1 mu/ 9 *>ity be int]pret$ philosophically z mean+ ! range ( compreh5sion consi/5t ) _! total means ( in/ruction & prep>ation1 includ+1 !re=e1 secret in=mation1 k ( disposable home res\rces z kn[n to ! (ficial deposit>ies ( ,/ate secrets1 etc41 & n1 z ! mod]n read] w und]/& x1 simply & exclusively ! intellectual p[] ( appreciation4 ,s9ce1 ) all h] disposition to exalt ! qualities ( pr9cely p]sons1 %e c\ld n be s absurdly haughty z to claim = pr9ces & ! c\nsellors :om int]e/ or bir? _h sugge/$ to !m a prec$5cy 9 pure natural end[m5ts4 ,*>les 0 a s9c]e believ] b n an e>ne/ believ] ( ! ,roman ,ca?olic fai?4 ,james 0 bo? s9c]e & pret]naturally e>ne/4 ,! ,re=mation4--,?is seems to %[ two ?+s3 #a/1 t a deep se>*+ & 'sagaci\s-f-af>' _s ( morality c m\ld itself "u ! prompt+ ( ,*ri/ianity1 su* z c\ld n h gr[n up "u ,paganism4 ,= x 0 ! abom9ations 9 po9t ( morality 7en fait de moralit87--indulg5ces1 ! confessional1 absolution1 ! preval5ce ( a m]e ritual--! usurpation ( =ms--^! x 0 :i* ,rome treat$ viol5tly2 & if %e draw 9 h] horns = ! pres5t1 /ill ^u any occasion (f]+1 ^u ! cl\d ( p]il pass+ away1 cle>ly %e w\ld r5ew h] conduct4 ,x 0 a t5d5cy viol5tly & inevitably belong+ to ! ,roman polity comb9$ ) ! ,roman int]e/1 unless1 p]haps1 z p]man5tly controll$ by a c\nt]-=ce4 #bndly1 ! syn!sis ( ?is curative =ce is by apposition ( p>ts sep>ately h>dly consci\s ( ! dang] or ev5 ( _! own act4 ,= we _c suppose ! va/ body ( opposition put =w>d 0 s "u direct consci\s appreciation ( ! evil & by an adequate c\nt]-action--d\btless x 0 by sympa?y ) o!rs hav+ bett] in=mation4 ,^! la/ burn$ m vividly z ! evil 0 fi]c]4 ,t m vivid sympa?y drew increase ( support]s4 ,memor&um4--,9 my hi/orical sket*es n to =get ! p]iod ( woe1 ant]ior to ! ,siege ( ,j]usalem1 :i* ,josephus describes z occurr+ 9 all ! ,grecian cities1 b :i* is s unacc\ntably ov]look$ by hi/orians4 ,! rule is to speak l ! fooli%1 & ?9k l ! wise1 & !re=e ,i agree to call our wor?y old "m 'little'--our 'little isl&'--z t seems to be ! prevail+ notion2 o!rwise ,i myself consid] ,great ,brita9 r a tall isl&4 ,a man is n call$ %ort because "s few ( 8 c\ntrym5 happ5 to be a trifle tall]2 & really ,i "k b ( two isl&s1 among t5s ( ?\s&s c\nt$ up by gazette]s on our planet1 t are tall]2 & ,i fancy1 ) su* figures z !irs1 !y are nei!r ( !m likely to ?9k ( any rival%ip ) our de> old "m4 ,:at isl&1 = in/ance1 w\ld *oose to be su* a great fat bea/ z ,borneo1 z broad z %e is long1 ) no apology = a wai/8 ,talk ( lac+ too tight1 inde$6 ,i'm sure ,borneo does n injure h]self 9 t way4 ,n[ our "m1 ?\gh %e's old1 & has gone ?r\gh a _w ( tr\ble 9 h] "t1 is z jimp ab\t ! wai/ z a "y lass ( sev5te54 ,look at h] on any map ( ,europe1 & %e's q a picture4 ,x's an old rem>k t ! g5]al outl9e ( ! de> creature exactly resembles a lady sitt+4 ,%e turns h] back ^u ! ,cont95t1 no d\bt1 & t's :at makes ^? =eigne]+ rascals talk s mu* ( h] pride4 ,b %e mu/ turn h] back ^u somebody1 & :o is x t %\ld h ! b5efit ( h] c\nt5ance1 if n ^? p 9 ! f> ,we/ t are come ( h] own blood8 ,!y say %e's 'tetyy' also4 ,well1 !n1 if %e is1 y let h] alone1 good p ( ! ,cont95t4 ,%e'll n m$dle ) y if y don't m$dle ) h]4 ,%e's k9d en\gh1 &1 z to h] p]son1 ,i d ma9ta9 t %e's q tall en\gh1 r ?91 x's true1 b1 on ! :ole1 a bonny1 elegant1 de> old fight+ mamma4 ,mora ,alex&r9a4--,note on ,middleton's affect$ sne]4 ,a villa ( ,cic]o's1 :]e probably ! usual s\nd he>d w\ld be ! groans ( torm5t$ slaves1 _h be5 *ang$ = ! cells ( ,*ri/ian monks4 ,n[ m>k3 :at ! h\nd ,middleton means is1 h[ %ock+ to lit]>y s5sibilities t :]e an elegant ma/] ( ,lat9ity _h liv$1 !re %\ld succe$ dull1 lazy monks1 writ+ 7if !y wrote at all7 9 a b>b>\s /yle1 & dream+ away _! lives 9 torpor4 ,n[ p]mit me to pause a little4 ,?is is "o ( ^? sne]s :i* ,paley#ch & ,bi%op ,butl]#ci ?9k s unansw]able1 t we mu/ necess>ily lie d[n & let ! sne] ride r\gh-%od ov] u all4 ,let u see1 & = ?is reason1 read]1 d n grudge a little delay1 especially z y may 'skip' x4 ,dr4 ,cony]s ought to h rememb]$1 9 ! fir/ place1 t ! villa c\ld n long rema9 9 ! h&s ( ,cic]o4 ,ano!r own] w\ld succe$1 & !n ! *ances w\ld be t ! s\nds (t5e/ asc5d+ 9 ! h\r ( sunset or 9 ! cool ( ! dawn w\ld be ! %rieks ( slaves "u torture4 ,by _! own poor mis]able f>e contra/$ ) ! spl5d\r reek+ ar\nd !m1 ^! slaves _h a motive1 su* z our t5d]ly-treat$ 7(t5 pamp]$7 s]vants c nev] "k ! /r5g? (1 = break+ ! seal ( any w9e cask4 ,f ! anecdote told ( 8 own "m by ! wret*$ ,qu9tus ,cic]o1 ! f\l bro!r ( ,m>cus1 x appe>s t g5]ally !re 0 "s enc\ragem5t to d ?is1 on ! *ance ( 'work+ d[n' on ! ma/] t ! violat$ seal _h be5 among/ ! casks legitimately op5$4 ,= x seems t old ,mrs4 ,cic]o's h\sewifely plan 0 to seal up all alike1 empty & n empty4 ,consequ5tly ) h] no su* excuse c\ld avail4 ,:i* proves t (t5 x did avail1 s9ce h] /ratagem is m5tion$ z a v notable artifice4 ,:at foll[s8 ,:y1 t ! slave 0 d\bly tempt$3 #a/1 by ! luxury he witness$2 #bndly1 by ! impunity on :i* he might calculate4 ,(t5 he escap$ by %e] weight ( metal 9 ly+4 ,l ,*auc]'s mill]1 he swore1 :5 *>g$ ) /eal+ fl\r1 t x 0 n s4 ,b ?is v prospect & likelihood ( escape 0 (t5 ! v sn>e = tempt+ to excesses too flagrant or :]e secret m>ks _h be5 fix$4 ,besides1 _m o!r op5+s !re 71 accord+ to ! individual circum/ances1 b ?is 0 a /&+ "o1 = tempt+ ! poor unpr9cipl$ slave into trespass t irritat$ ei!r ! ma/] or ! mi/ress4 ,& !n came ^? p]iodical lac]ations & asc5d+ groans :i* ,s5eca m5tions z ! be/ means ( tell+ :at o'clock x 0 9 v>i\s h\seholds1 s9ce ! puni%m5ts 7 go+ on j at t h\r4 ,aft]1 :5 ! graci\s revolution ( ,*ri/ianity _h taught u1 & by a mem5to s solemn & imp]i%able1 no long] to pursue our human wra?1 t h\r ( vesp] sanctity _h come1 :i*1 by ! t5d5cy ( ! ,*ri/ian law & accord+ to ! degree 9 :i* x is obs]v$1 is = u a type & a symbol & a hi]oglyphic ( wra? ext+ui%$1 ( self-conque/1 ( *>ity 9 heav5 & on e>?4 ,n[1 ! monks1 x is supposable1 might be commonplace drones4 ,(t51 h[ev]1 !y w\ld be f> o!r1 transmitt]s by _! copy+ toils ( ^? v ,cic]onian works :i*1 b = !m1 w\ld h p]i%$4 ,& paus+ duly "h1 :at s5se1 :at propriety w\ld !re be 9 call+ on ! read] to notice ) a %ock ! pr(anation ( classical gr\nd 9 su* an example z ?is3 ',m>k ! /range revolutions ( ages2 !re1 :]e once ! div9e ,plato's ,academus /ood1 n[ rises a huge pr9t+-h\se *iefly occupi$ = ! la/ two ye>s 9 repr9t+ ,plato's works4' ,:y1 really ,plato himself w\ld look graci\sly on t revolution1 ,ma/] ,cony]s4 ,b next1 ! dulle/ ( ^! monks w\ld he> ! ,gloria 9 ,excelsis4 ,oh1 h[ pitiful x is to he> ,b---- alleg+ aga9/ ,mahomet t he _h done no public miracles4 ,:at8 ,w\ld x1 !n1 alt] y\r op9ion ( ,mahomet if he _h done miracles8 ,:at a pro(1 h[ full1 h[ p]fect6 ,t ,*ri/ianity1 9 _s1 9 p[]1 9 simplicity1 & 9 tru?1 _h no m hold ov] ,b---- ?an x _h ov] any ,pagan ,pontiff 9 ,rome1 is cle> to me f t4 ,s1 !n1 ! argum5t aga9/ ,mahomet is n t he wants utt]ly ! meekness--wants8 wants8 ,no1 t he utt]ly hates ! humility1 ! love t is /rong] ?an ! grave1 ! purity t _c be imag9$1 ! hol9ess z an ideal = man t _c be approa*$1 ! peace t passe? all und]/&+1 t p[] :i* out ( a little cl\d no bigg] ?an a man's h& gr[s = ev] & ev] until x w absorb ! _w & all t x inh]it1 t fir/ ( all creat$ ! t]ror ( dea? & ! wormy grave2 b t fir/ & la/ %e might triumph ov] "t--n ^!1 x seems by ,b----1 are ! argum5ts aga9/ ,mahomet1 b t he did n play leg]dema9 tricks1 t he did n turn a c[ into a horse6 ,9 :i* position ,b---- is precisely on a level ) ^? ,arab ,%eikhs1 or p]haps ,mamelukes1 :om ,napoleon s fooli%ly endeav\r$ to surprise by ,*9ese tricks3 ',aye1 all ?is is v well1 b c y make "o to be 9 ,cairo & 9 ,damascus at ! same mom5t8' dem&$ ! poor brutaliz$ wret*es4 ,& s also = ,b---- x is no?+4 ,oh1 bl9d ( he>t n to p]ceive t ! defect 0 entirely ow+ to ! age4 ,mahomet came to a mo/ sceptical region4 ,!re 0 no semblance or %ad[ among ! ,arabs ( t *ildi% cr$ulity :i* =ms ! atmosph]e = miracle4 ,on ! contr>y1 !y 7 a h>d1 fi]ce p1 & 9 t s5se b>b>\s2 b o!rwise !y 7 sceptical1 z is mo/ evid5t f all t !y accompli%$1 :i* foll[$ ! f\ndation ( ,islamism4 ,"h lies ! delusion ^u t po9t4 ,! ,arabs 7 evid5tly l all ! surr\nd+ nations4 ,!y 7 also mu* di/+ui%$ among all ,ori5tal peoples = c\rage4 ,?is fact has be5 put on record 9 7#a7 ! ,ea/ ,indies1 :]e all ! ,arab troops h prov$ !mselves by f> m =midable ?an twelve times ! numb] ( effem9ate ,b5galese & ,mahrattas1 etc4 7#b7 ,at ,ad51 :]e z rude fight]s )\t ! sci5ce ( w> !y h be5 mo/ ugly cu/om]s4 7#c7 ,9 ,alg]ia1 :]e ! ,fr5*1 ) all advantage ( discipl9e1 sci5ce1 artill]y1 h f\nd x a mo/ try+ & exhau/+ w>4 ,well1 z !y are n[1 s !y 7 be=e ,mahomet1 & j !n !y 7 ripe = conque/4 ,b !y want$ a comb9+ motive & a ju/ify+ motive4 ,mahomet suppli$ bo? ^!4 ,says he1 ',all nations are idolat]s2 g & ?ru/ !m into ! mill t !y may be trans=m$ to our lik5ess4' ,consequ5tly1 ! great idea ( ! tru?1 ( a tru? transc5d+ all available rights on ! o!r side1 0 =eign to ,mahometanism1 & any glimm]+ ( ?is t may seem to be f\nd 9 x 0 borr[$1 0 fil*$ f ,*ri/ianity4 #i4--,,lit]>y4 ,! ?ree greate/ p[]s :i* we "k ( 9 m\ld+ human feel+s are1 fir/1 ,*ri/ianity2 secondly1 ! actions ( m5 emblazon$ by hi/ory2 &1 9 ! ?ird place1 poetry4 ,if ! fir/ 7 repres5t$ to ! imag9ation by ! atmosph]ic air inve/+ our planet1 :i* we take to be ! mo/ awful laboratory ( p[]s--my/]i\s1 unse51 & absolutely inf9ite--! second might be repres5t$ by ! w9ds1 & ! ?ird by lightn+4 ,napoleon & ,"l ,byron h done m mis*ief to ! moral feel+s1 to ! tru? ( all moral e/imates1 to ! gr&eur & magnanimity ( man1 9 ?is pres5t g5]ation1 ?an all o!r causes act+ toge!r4 ,b h[8 ,simply by ?r[+ human feel+s into false comb9ations4 ,bo? ( !m l9k$ ! mean to ! gr&1 ! base to ! noble1 9 a way :i* (t5 proves fatally inextricable to ! poor infirm m9d ( ! ord9>y spectator4 ,"h is ,napoleon1 simply because he wields a va/ national ma*9]y1 ?r[+ a magic ( cel]ity & p[] into a p>ticul> action :i* absolutely ov]p[]s ! g5us attonitorum1 s t !y are reconcil$ by ! dazzle ( a spl5d\r n at all 9 ,napoleon1 to a bas5ess :i* really is 9 ,napoleon4 ,! man t nev] prais$ an enemy is %[n to ?is vile mob by ! light ?r[n (f f ! radiant p[] ( ,france z ! greate/ ( m52 he is conf\nd$ ) 8 support+ elem5t1 ev5 z ! ,jupit] ,olympus ( ,phidias1 t nev] sp>$ a woman 9 8 lu/1 seem$ ! holie/ ( deities :5 8 rott5ness 0 conceal$ by ivory & gold1 & 8 libid9\s head 0 light$ up by sunbeams f above4 ,"h is ,"l ,byron connect+1 9 ! portrait ( "s poor melodramatic h]o possibly1 "s noble quality ( c\rage or p]sev]ance ) scorn ! mo/ pu]ile & s5seless4 ,prone en\gh is poor degrad$ human nature to f9d some?+ gr& 9 scorn2 b1 aft] ?is arbitr>y comb9ation ( ,"l ,byron's1 nev] aga9 does ! poor man ?9k ( scorn b x sugge/s to him moral greatness1 nor ?9k ( greatness b x sugge/s scorn z its indisp5sable condition4 ,wordswor? is always record+ ph5om5a z !y are enjoy$2 ,col]idge z !y reconcile !mselves ) oppos+ or conflict+ ph5om5a4 ,w4 ,w4's social philosophy is surely %all[4 ,x is true ! man :o has a %all[ philosophy "u ! guidance ( ,*ri/ianity has a pr(\nd philosophy4 ,b ?is ap>t1 su* tru?s z ',he :o made ! creature w all[ = 8 frailties1' etc41 are commonplace4 99 99 99 99 99 ,inv5tion z a ,*>act]i/ic ( ,poets4--,i happ5$ ?is ev5+ 7,saturday1 ,augu/ #crd1 '#dd7 to be say+ ( ,w4 ,w4 to myself3 ',no poet is s free f all cases l ?is1 viz41 :]e all ! feel+s & spontane\s ?\ghts :i* !y h accumulat$ com+ to an end1 & yet ! case seem+ to require m to f9i% x1 or br+ x r\nd1 l a peal ( *ur* bells1 !y are =c$ to inv5t1 & =m descants on raptures nev] really felt4 ,sudd5ly ?is sugge/$ t inv5tion1 !re=e1 s f> f be+ a diff]5tial quality ( poetry1 01 9 fact1 ! pol> opposite1 spontane\sness be+ ! true quality4 ,trag$y4--,i believe x is a v useful ?+ to let "y p]sons cultivate _! k9d feel+s by repeat$ indulg5ces4 ,?us my *ildr5 (t5 ask$ :5 any?+ 0 to be paid or giv5 to any p]son1 t !y might h ! satisfaction ( giv+ x4 ,s ,i see cle>ly t "y boys or girls all[$ to c>ry abroad _! infant bro!rs & si/]s1 :5 ! little creature feels & manife/s a real dep5d5ce ^u !m 9 e act & movem5t1 :i* matre prs5te !y w\ld n h done1 :i* aga9 se5 & felt calls out e lat5t goodness ( ! eld] *ild's he>t4 ,s aga9 7"h ,i h clipp$ out ! case74 ,h[ev]1 fe$+ rabbits1 b above all ! action ^u wom5's he>ts 9 ! enorm\s expansion giv5 by ! relation to _! own *ildr51 develops a feel+ ( t5d]ness t aft]w>ds sets ! model = ! _w1 & w\ld die away1 or freeze1 or deg5]ate1 if x 7 g5]ally balk$4 ,n[ j su* an action has trag$y1 & if ! sympa?y ) calamities caus$ to noble natures by ignobl]1 or by d>k fates1 7 nev] op5$ or mov$ or call$ out1 x w\ld slumb] in]tly1 x w\ld ru/1 & become f> less ready to respond ^u any call be+ made4 ,su* s5sibilities are n consci\sly kn[n to ! possessor until develop$4 ,punctuation4--,suppose an ord9>y case :]e ! involution ( clauses w5t ?ree deep1 & t ea* 0 equally m>k$ (f by commas1 n[ ,i say t s f> f aid+ ! logic x w\ld require an imm5se ef=t to di/ribute ! relations ( logic4 ,b ! v purpose & use ( po9ts is to aid ! logic4 ,if inde$ y c\ld see ! po9ts at all 9 ?is relation /rophe anti/rophe #a #b #c #c #b #a ----1 ----1 ----1 apodosis ----1 ----1 ----1 !n inde$ all w\ld be cle>1 b ! six commas w & mu/ be view$ by e read] unv]s$ 9 ! logical me*anism ( s5t5ces z m]ely a succession ( ictuses1 s _m m9ute-guns hav+ no int]nal sy/em ( correspond5ce1 b m]ely repeat+ & reit]at+ ea* o!r1 exactly z 9 m51 guns1 horses1 timbrels1 baggage-waggons1 /&>ds4 ,%]idan's ,disputati\sness4--,i nev] he>d ( any case 9 ! :ole c\rse ( my life :]e disputati\sness 0 ! au?or ( any b5efit to man or bea/1 except+ always "o1 9 :i* x became a /orm an*or = poor ,%]idan1 sav+ him f sudd5 %ipwreck4 ,?is may be f\nd 9 ,mr4 ,moore's life1 some:]e ab\t ! date ( #agij1 & 9 *apt] xiii4 ,! book is ?irty-sev5 miles (f1 :i* is too f> to s5d = wat]1 or = sc&al1 or ev5 = 'extract1' ?\gh ,i'm 'fond ( extract4' ,!re=e1 9 default ( ,mr4 ,moore's v]sion1 ,i give my own4 ,! situation 0 ?is3 ,%]idan _h be5 cruis+ f breakfa/ to d9n] among/ ,jews1 ,*ri/ians1 & play]s 7m51 wom51 & ,h]veys71#dj & con/antly 9 ! same hackney coa*1 s t ! freight at la/ settl$ l ! s&-heap ( an h\r-glass into a frightful record ( co/ly mom5ts4 ,p]eunt et imputantur1 say "s imp]t95t "t-pieces1 9 speak+ ( ! h\rs4 ,!y p]i% & are debit$ to our acc\nt4 ,yes1 & :at made x worse1 ! cr$itor 0 an inexorable old ,j>vie1 :o1 ?\gh himself a cr$itor1 _h nev] he>d ! idea ( cr$it4 ,a gu9ea might be ow+1 & ,%]idan1 seldom rememb]+ 8 purse1 _h b a %ill+1 :i* ev5 9 a c\rt ( ,iri% law seem$ too small a compromise to (f]4 ,black look$ ! horizon1 /ormy ! (f+1 & night 0 com+ on1 :il/ ! port ( consignm5t 0 n[ )9 ?irty m9utes' sail4 ,sudd5ly a sight ( joy 0 describ$4 ,driv+ be=e ! w9d1 on b>e poles1 0 a well-kn[n fri5d ( ,%]idan's1 ,ri*>dson1 fam$ = v>i\s tal5t1 b also = an inv9cible headlong necessity ( disput+4 ,to pull ! *eck-/r+1 to take 8 fri5d on bo>d1 & to ru% into fi]ce polemic conv]sation 0 ! "w ( a mom5t = ,%]idan4 ,he well und]/ood ) ?is famili> fri5d h[ to br+ on a hot dispute4 ,9 ?ree m9utes x rag$1 y>d-arm to y>d-arm4 ,bo? grew w>m4 ,%]idan grew purple ) rage4 ,viol5tly int]rupt+ ,ri*>dson1 he said3 ',& ^! are y\r real s5tim5ts8' ,ri*>dson ) solemnity & artificial re/ra9t repli$3 ',mo/ solemnly !y are4' ',& y /& to !m1 & w ma9ta9 !m8' ',i w1' said ,ri*>dson1 ) m5ac+ solemnity & ev5 m\rnfulness4 ',i w to my dy+ day4' ',!n1' said ,%]idan furi\sly1 ',i'm hang$ if ,i'll /ay ano!r m9ute ) a man capable ( su* abom9able op9ions6' ,bang w5t ! door1 out he b\nc$1 & ,ri*>dson1 keep+ 8 seat1 pursu$ him ) triumphant explosions4 ',ah1 wret*6 :at8 y c't be> ! tru?4 ,y're oblig$ to hate ! tru?4 ,t is :y y cut & run be=e x4 ,huzza6 ,mr4 ,%]idan1 ,m4 ,p4 = ,/af=d1 runs l a h>e = fe> t he %\ld he> ! tru?4' ,precisely s1 ! tru? x 0 t he ran f4 ,! tru? at ?is p>ticul> mom5t 0 too pa9ful to 8 he>t4 ,%]idan _h fl$2 ! awful tru? am\nt$ to eighte5 %ill+s4 ,yes1 virtu\s ,ri*>dson1 y 7 "r2 tru? x 0 t he fl$ f2 tru? _h j !n become too pa9ful to 8 infirm m9d1 al?\gh x 0 useless to tell him s1 z by ?is "t he 0 out ( he>+4 ',yes1' said ,ri*>dson m$itatively to himself1 '! tru? has at la/ become insupportable to ?is unhappy man4' ,"r1 x _h s4 ,& 9 "o m9ute m x became insupportable ev5 to ! virtu\s ,ri*>dson1 :5 ! coa*man reveal$ ! odi\s ext5t ( ! tru?1 viz41 t ! f>e n[ am\nt$ to two-&-tw5ty %ill+s4 ,z ,i hate ev]y?+ t ! p love1 & above all ! odi\s levity ) :i* !y adopt e gr\ndless anecdote1 especially :]e x happ5s to be calumni\s1 ,i beg n to be suppos$ a believ] 9 ! common /ories curr5t ab\t ,%]idan's c>elessness ( pecuni>y obligations4 ,s f> f 'nev] pay+1' :i* is :at public sl&] has n ceas$ to report ( him1 he 0 79 ,mr4 ,moore's language7 'always pay+2' & = once t he paid too little1 a ?\s& times he paid a great deal too mu*4 ,_h1 inde$1 all 8 excesses ( paym5t be5 ga!r$ into "o fund1 t fund w\ld h cov]$ 8 deficits t5 times ov]4 ,x is1 h[ev]1 true t1 :il/ he 0 cont9ually pay+ ! hundr$-p\nd dem&s aga9/ him1 ) all _! ,jewi% accumulations ( int]e/1 he 0 cont9ually unfurni%$ ) money = 8 'm5us plaisirs' & trifl+ p]sonal exp5ses4 ,by /rong natural t5d5cy ( disposition1 ,%]idan 0 a man ( peculi>ly s5sitive hon\r1 & ! irregul>ities into :i* he fell1 m conspicu\sly aft] ! de/ruction ( ,drury ,lane by fire1 pa9$ nobody s mu* z himself4 ,x is ! s5se ( ?is fact1 & ! belief t ,%]idan 0 nev] a default] ?r\gh habits ( self-indulg5ce1 :i* call out 9 my m9d a reaction ( indignation at ! /ories curr5t aga9/ him4 ,bookb9d+ & ,book-,lett]+4--,lit]ature is a mean ?+ en\gh 9 ! ord9>y way ( pursu+ x z :at ! ,g]mans call a ,brod/udium2 b 9 its high] relations x is s noble t x is able to ennoble o!r ?+s1 suppos+ !m 9 any degree m9i/]ial to itself4 ,! pap]-mak]1 ergo ! rag-mak]1 ergo ! l95 clo?-mak]1 is ! true & orig9al creator ( ! mod]n press1 z ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,dubl9 long ago demon/rat$4 ,= ! art ( pr9t+ _h nev] halt$ = want ( ! typographic secret2 t 0 always kn[n1 kn[n & practis$ hundr$s ( ye>s be=e ! ,*ri/ian era4 ,x halt$ = want ( a mat]ial *eap en\gh & pl5tiful en\gh to make types o!r ?an a mo/ co/ly sub/itute = h&-copy+4 ,d y he> t1 g5tlem5 blockheads1 t seldom he> any?+ b y\rselves8 ,next aft] ! pap]-mak]1 :o furni%$ ! s9e qu non1 takes rank1 n ! engrav] or illu/rator 7our mod]n noveli/ _c swim )\t ?is c>icatur+ villa9 z "o ( 8 bladd]s2 all high] =ms ( lit]ature laugh at him71 b ! b9d]2 = he1 by rais+ books into ornam5tal furniture1 has giv5 ev5 to non-intellectual p by myriads a motive = enc\rag+ lit]ature & an int]e/ 9 its ext5sion4 ,any specim5 ( ,mr4 ,f]r>'s b9d+ ,i nev] saw1 b by ^? :o h1 x is said to h be5 magnific5t4 ,he & 8 family 7 once1 if n twice1 visit$ by ,*>les ,i41 & !y pres5t$ to t pr9ce a mo/ sumptu\s ,bible ( _! own b9d+2 :i* ,bible1 a lady once told me1 0 9 t collection gradually =m$ by ,george ,,iii4 at ,buck+ham ,h\se1 & f9ally pres5t$ to ! nation by 8 son4 ,i %\ld fe> x mu/ be 9 ru9s z a specim5 ( ! ,little ,gidd+ workman%ip4 ,! man :o goes to b$ 9 8 c(f9 dress$ 9 a jewell$ robe & a diamond-hilt$ sword1 is v liable to a visit f ! resurrection-man1 :o usually dis>ms & undresses him4 ,! ,bible t has its b9d+ inlaid ) gold1 s[$ ) ,ori5tal pe>l1 & made horr5t ) rubies1 sugge/s to _m a mo/ unscriptural mode ( se>*+ into its treasures1 & too l ! ,miltonic ,mammon's mode ( p]us+ ! gorge\s floors ( heav54 ,besides t1 if ! ,bible escap$ ! ,p>liam5t>y ,w>1 ! true art ( ! ,f]r> family w\ld be bett] display$ 9 a case ( less co/ & luxury4 ,c]ta9ly1 9 no "o art 0 ! /upidity ( ,europe m atroci\sly record$ ?an 9 ?is p>ticul> art practis$ by ! ,f]r>s4 ,b\ndless 0 ! field = improvem5t4 ,& 9 p>ticul>1 ,i _h myself drawn f ?is art1 z practis$ ( old1 "o /rik+ memorial ( t rem>kable g5ius = /upidity1 :i* 9 all ages alike seems to haunt man z by an inspiration1 unless he is r\s$ out ( x by panic4 ,x is ?is4 ,look at ! lett]+--t is1 ! labels lett]$ ) ! titles ( books--9 all libr>ies t are n ( rec5t date4 ,no man w\ld believe t ! v e>lie/ attempt to impress a m>k ( own]%ip ^u "s bucket ( ! ,argonauts1 or ! rude/ scrawl ( ,polyphemus 9 =g+ a t>ry br& ^u "s %eep :i* he _h /ol51 c\ld be s bad1 s /agg]+ & illegible1 z are ^! lit]>y inscriptions4 ,h[ mu* bett] to h _h a ?9 tablet or v5e]+ ( m>ble or iron adju/$ to ! back ( ! book4 ,a /one-cutt] 9 a rural *ur*y>d once told me t he *>g$ a p5ny p] lett]4 ,t may be *eap = a grave/one1 b x seems r high = a book4 ,plato w\ld co/ y fivep5ce1 ,ari/otle w\ld be %ock+2 & 9 dec5cy y mu/ put him into ,lat91 :i* w\ld add twop5ce m to e volume4 ,on a libr>y l t ( ,dresd5 or ! ,vatican1 x w\ld raise a national debt to lett] ! books4 ,cause ( ! ,novel's ,decl9e4--,no man1 x may be safely laid d[n z a g5]al rule1 c obta9 a /rong hold ov] ! popul> m9d )\t m or less ( real p[]4 ,a reality !re mu/ be4 ,! artifice1 ! trick]y1 _c arise 9 ?is fir/ /age1 z by any sub/itution ( a %ad[ = a reality4 ,if ! mass ( read]s feel a p[]1 & ackn[l$ge a p[]1 9 t case p[] !re mu/ be4 ,x 0 ! j rem>k ( ,dr4 ,johnson t m5 d n deceive !mselves 9 _! amusem5ts4 ,& amusem5t x is t ! great public seek 9 lit]ature4 ,! mean] & ! m s5sual ! dem&s ( a man are1 s mu* ! less possible x becomes to *eat him4 ,seek+ = w>m?1 he _c be wrong :5 he says t he has f\nd x4 ,ask+ = alcohol1 he w nev] be *eat$ ) wat]4 ,8 feel+s 9 su* a case1 8 impressions1 in/antane\sly ju/ify !mselves2 t is1 !y be> witness pa/ all d\bt+ to ! c]ta9ty ( :at !y report4 ,s f> !re is no op5+ to mi/ake4 ,! error1 ! op5+ to ! spuri\s on ! l>ge/ scale1 arises fir/ ^u ! quality ( ! p[]4 ,/r5g? v>ies ^u an endless scale1 n m]ely by its own gradations1 b by ! modes & ! degrees 9 :i* x comb9es ) o!r qualities4 ,& !re are _m comb9ations1 cases ( con/ant recurr5ce1 9 :i* "s natural vig\r1 b ( no rem>kable ord]1 ent]s into alliance ) animal prop5sities2 :]e a port5t\s success w indicate no correspond+ p[] 9 ! arti/1 b only an unusual ins5sibility to dec5cy & ! op9ion ( ?\ghtful p]sons4 ,novels are ! "o sole class ( books t ev] int]e/ ! public1 t rea* its he>t1 or ev5 cat* its eye4 ,& ! reason :y novels are becom+ mu* m lic5ti\s1 & mu* gross] 9 ! arts by :i* !y c\rt public fav\r1 lies und\bt$ly 9 ! quality ( t new read+ public :i* ! ext5sion ( education has add$ to ! old "o4 ,an education mis]ably %all[1 :il/ unavail+ = any purpose ( real elevation1 lets 9 ^u ! !atre ( :at is call$ by c\rtesy lit]ature a va/ additional audi5ce t once w\ld h be5 exclud$ altoge!r4 ,?is audi5ce1 *ang$ 9 no respect f its =m] condition ( intellect & mann]s & ta/e1 br++ only ! s+le qualification ( ability to read1 is n[ /rong en\gh 9 numb]s to impress a new "* ^u lit]ature 9 s f> z lit]ature has a motive = apply+ itself to _! wants4 ,! consequ5ces are %[+ !mselves1 & w %[ !mselves m broadly4 ,x is difficult ) prop] delicacy to seek illu/rations among/ our own liv+ writ]s4 ,illu/rations 7 all too easily f\nd did we c>e to ent] on ! task4 ,x is true t1 dur+ ! curr5cy ( any ye>1 :il/ ! quantity is liable to indet]m9ate augm5tation1 ballads w be r look+ d[n 9 ! m>ket4 ,b t is a %ad[ :i* settles ^u e e>?ly good ?+4 ,no ,greek book1 = in/ance1 among/ ! _m t h p]i%$1 w\ld s mu* rejoice _m ( u by its resurrection z ! com$ies ( ,m5&]4 ,yet1 if a correspond5t %\ld write ^w f ,pompeii t tw5ty-five ?\s& sep>ate dramas ( ,m5&] _h be5 f\nd 9 good pres]vation1 add+ 9 a po/script t =ty ?\s& m _h be5 imp\nd$ )9 ! la/ two h\rs1 & t !re 0 e prospect ( bagg+ two hundr$ ?\s& m be=e morn+1 we %\ld probably petition ,gov]nm5t to receive ! import+ vessels ) *a9-%ot4 ,n ev5 ,milton or ,%akespe>e c\ld make head aga9/ su* a ,lopez de ,vega pr9ciple ( ru9\s sup]fluity4 ,all[+ = ?is "o case ( pret]natural excess1 assum+ only t degree ( limitation :i* any absolute pa/ mu/ almo/ always create up to t po9t1 we say t !re is no conceivable composition1 or class ( compositions1 :i* w n be welcom$ into lit]ature provid$1 z to matt]1 t x %all embody "s natural /ra9 ( feel+1 & provid$1 z to mann]1 t x illu/rate ! *>act]i/ic /yle ( a kn[n g5]ation4 ,x might suffice = our pres5t purpose to h once firmly di/+ui%$ betwe5 ! two modes ( lit]ature4 ,b x may be z well to po9t out a few coroll>ies f ?is di/9ction1 :i* w s]ve at ! same "t to expla9 & to confirm x4 ,= in/ance1 fir/ ( all1 x has be5 abundantly insi/$ on 9 our mod]n times1 t ! value ( e lit]ature lies 9 its *>act]i/ic "p2 a tru? c]ta9ly1 b a tru? ^u :i* ! ,g]man *anticle] w\ld n h cr[$ & flapp$ 8 w+s s exult+ly1 _h he p]ceiv$ ! orig9al & indisp5sable s*ism betwe5 ! lit]ature ( k & ! lit]ature ( p[]1 because 9 ?is latt] only c any?+ *>act]i/ic ( a man or ( a nation be embodi$4 ,! sci5ce ( no man c be *>act]i/ic1 no man c geometrize or *emically analyze aft] a mann] peculi> to himself4 ,he may be ! fir/ to op5 a new road1 & 9 t mean+ x may be call$ 8 road2 b 8 x _c be by any su* peculi>ities z w f\nd an incommunicable excell5ce4 ,9 lit]ature prop]1 viz41 ! lit]ature ( p[]1 ?is is o!rwise4 ,!re may d\btless h be5 _m imitative poets1 we>+ little or no?+ ( a natural individuality2 b ( no poet1 t ev] l$ 8 own class1 c x h be5 possible t he %\ld h be5 o!rwise ?an /rongly diff]5c$ by inimitable features & by traits n transf]able4 ,consequ5tly ! ,greek3 to *>act]i/ic1 ( :i* 9 ,g]man cl\dl& s noisy a proclamation is made z ( "s transc5d5tal discov]y1 is a m]e inf]5ce f ! v idea ( a lit]ature4 ,= we repeat t 9 blank k a sep>ate peculi>ity m>k+ ! individual is n conceivable1 :]eas 9 a true lit]ature reflect+ human nature1 n z x repres5ts1 b z x wills1 n z a passive m9or1 b z a self-mov+ p[]1 x is n possible to avoid ! *>act]i/ic except only 9 ! degree by :i* ! inspir+ nature happ5s to be feeble4 ,! exorbitations t diff]5tiate !m may be ( n>r[ compass1 b only :]e ! motive p[] 0 orig9ally weak4 ,& agreeably to ?is rem>k x may be ass]t$ t 9 all lit]ature prop]ly s-call$ g5ius1 is always manife/$1 & tal5t g5]ally2 b 9 ! lit]ature ( k x may be d\bt$ v s]i\sly :e!r !re is any op5+ = m ?an tal5t4 ,g5ius may be def9$ 9 ! sev]e/ mann] z t :i* is g5]ally *>act]i/ic2 b a ?\s& times we repeat t "o man's mode ( kn[+ an object _c diff] f ano!r man's4 ,x _c be *>act]i/ic1 & its g5iality _c be ext]nally manife/$4 ,to h said1 !re=e1 ( ! poetry surviv+ f anci5t ,latium1 f ,ca/ile1 f ,engl&1 t ?is is nationally *>act]i/ic1 & kn[able ap>t by inali5able diff]5ces1 is say+ no m ?an foll[s out ( ! v def9ition by :i* any & e lit]ature prop] is limit$ & gu>d$ z a mode ( p[]4 ,secondly1 ev5 9 ! exceptions & hesitations ^u apply+ ! rig\r ( ?is di/9ction1 we may read ! natural recognition 7h[ev] lat5t or unconsci\s7 ( ! rule itself4 ,no man w\ld ?9k1 = example1 ( plac+ a treatise on survey+1 on m5suration1 on geological /ratifications1 9 any collection ( 8 national lit]ature4 ,he w\ld be lunatic to d s4 ,a ,birm+ham or ,glasg[ ,directory has an equal title to take its /ation 9 ! national lit]ature4 ,b he w hesitate on ! same "q aris+ ) reg>d to a hi/ory4 ,:]e ^u exam9ation ! hi/ory turns out to be a m]e *ronicle1 or regi/] ( ev5ts *ronologically arrang$1 ) no pr9ciple ( comb9ation p]vad+ x1 nor col\r+ f peculi> views ( policy1 nor sympa?y ) ! noble & impassion$ 9 human action1 ! decision w be univ]sal & p]emptory to ca%i] x f ! lit]ature4 ,yet ?is case1 be+ "o ( degree1 ranges ?r\gh a l>ge & d\btful gamut4 ,a hi/ory l t ( ,froiss>t1 or ( ,h]odotus1 :]e ! subjective f ! writ] bl5ds s p[]fully ) ! gross objective1 :]e ! moral picturesque is s pr$om9ant1 toge!r ) fre%ness ( s5sation :i* belongs to 'blissful infancy' 9 human life1 or to a /age ( society 9 correspond5ce to x1 _c suff] a demur ( jeal\sy z to its privilege ( ent]+ ! select fold ( lit]ature4 ,b su* advantages are ( limit$ di/ribution4 ,&1 to say ! tru?1 9 its own nature nei!r hi/ory nor biography1 unless treat$ ) peculi> grace1 & ar*itecturally m\ld$1 has any high pret5sion to rank z an organic limb ( lit]ature4 ,! v noble/ hi/ory1 9 mu* ( its sub/ance1 is b by a special indulg5ce )9 ! privilege ( t classification4 ,biography /&s on ! same foot+4 ,( ! _m memorials d$icat$ to ! life ( ,milton1 h[ few are entitl$ to take _! /ation 9 ! lit]ature6 ,& :y8 ,n m]ely t !y are disqualifi$ by _! defective execution1 b (t5 t !y necess>ily record :at has become common prop]ty4 ,,footnotes3 #bi ,betwe5 ! =ms modal1 modi%1 & mod]n1 ! diff]5ce is ( t slight ord] :i* is con/antly occurr+ betwe5 ! ,elizabe?an age & our own4 ,i%1 ous1 ful1 "s1 are cont9ually int]*ang+2 ?us1 pitiful = pite\s1 qu>rel\s = qu>relsome4 #cj ,i d5y t !re is or c\ld h be5 "o truant flutt]+ murmur ( ! he>t aga9/ ! reality ( glory4 ,& p>tly = ^! reasons3 #a/1 ,t1 hoc ab/racto1 defraud+ man ( ?is1 y leave him mis]ably b>e--b>e ( ev]y?+4 ,s t really & s9c]ely ! v wise/ m5 may be se5 cl++ convulsively1 & clut*+ ) _! dy+ h&s ! belief t glory1 t po/hum\s fame 7:i* = pr(\nd ends ( provid5ce has be5 end[$ ) a subtle p[] ( fraud su* z no man c ?or\ghly look ?r\gh2 = ^? :o1 l myself1 despise x mo/ completely1 _c by any art br+ =w>d a rationale1 a !ory ( its holl[ness t w give pl5>y satisfaction except to ^? :o are already satisfi$74 ,?us ,cic]o1 feel+ t if ?is 7 no?+1 !n _h all 8 life be5 a skirmi%1 "o cont9u$ skirmi% = %ad[s & non5tities2 a feel+ ( blank desolation1 too />tl+--too humiliat+ to be fac$4 ,b 7#bndly71 ! unse>*able hypocrisy ( man1 t hypocrisy :i* ev5 to himself is b dimly descri$1 t lat5t hypocrisy :i* always does1 & mo/ pr(itably1 possess e av5ue ( e man's ?\ghts1 h5ce a man :o %\ld op5ly h av[$ a doctr9e t glory 0 a bubble1 besides t1 in/ead ( be+ prompt$ to ?is on a pr9ciple :i* s f> rais$ him above o!r m51 mu/ h be5 prompt$ by a pr9ciple t sank him to ! level ( ! brutes1 viz41 acquiesc+ 9 total v5tr9e improvid5ce1 impresci5ce1 & selfi% ease 7if ease1 a ,pagan mu/ h x cum dignitate71 b above all he mu/ h made proclamation t 9 8 op9ion all dis9t]e/$ virtue 0 a *im]a1 s9ce all ! quadrif>i\s virtue ( ! s*ola/ic e?ics 0 f\nd$ ei!r on p]sonal self-suffici5cy1 on ju/ice1 mod]ation1 etc41 etc41 or on direct p]sonal & exclusive self-int]e/ z reg>d$ heal? & ! elem5ts ( pleasure4 #ca ,! t[] ( ,siloam4 #cb ,e def9ition is a syllogism4 ,n[1 because ! m9or proposition is con/antly false1 ?is does n affect ! case2 ea* man is "r to fill up ! m9or ) 8 own view1 & ess5tially !y d n disagree ) ea* o!r4 ,a 7! subject ( def47is x4 ,! ,tru? is ! sum ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,b ,c is x4 ,b my ,bapti/ view is ! sum ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,ergo ,c is ,a4 ,ergo my ,bapti/ view is ! ,tru?4 #cc ,x seems t ,h]od made *anges s va/--c]ta9ly 9 ! surm\nt+ works1 & also probably 9 "o place z to ! f\ndations1 t x c\ld n be call$ ! same ,temple ) t ( ! ,captivity1 except "u an abuse ( ideas z to matt] & =m1 ( :i* all nations h furni%$ illu/rations1 f ! %ip ,argo to t ( old ,drake1 f ,sir ,john ,cutl]'s /ock+s to ! ,highl&]'s 7or ,iri%man's7 musket4 #cd ,j z if a man sp5d+ 8 life to %[ ! folly ( ,me?odism %\ld bur/ into maudl9 te>s at sight ( ,john ,wesley1 & say1 ',oh1 if all m51 my de> bro!rs1 7 b ,me?odi/s6' #ce ,h[ s8 ,if ! ,jews 7 naturally infidels1 :y did ,god select !m8 ,b1 fir/1 !y might h1 & !y c]ta9ly _h1 o!r balanc+ qualities2 secondly1 9 ! s5se "h meant1 all m5 are infidels2 & we ourselves1 by ! v nature ( "o object :i* ,i w indicate1 are pretty g5]ally infidels 9 ! same s5se z !y4 ,look at our evid5ces2 look at ! sort ( means by :i* we (t5 attempt to ga9 proselytes among ! hea!n & at home4 ,f\l] infidelities !re are n4 ,special plead+1 work+ = a v]dict1 etc41 etc4 #cf ,?is idea is exp&$ & foll[$ out 9 detail 9 ! op5+ ( ',hom] & ! ,hom]id2' b ?is is evid5tly ! note f :i* t grew1 & is "h giv5 alike on acc\nt ( its compactness & felicity4--,,ed4 #cg ,satire ix41 l9es #fj1 #fa4 #ch ,:o c answ] a sne]8 #ci ,butl]--'unansw]able ridicule4' #dj ,said ( memb]s ( ! ,bri/ol family4 ,,xxv4 ,,omitt$ ,,passages ,,& ,,v>iations4 #a4--,,! ,,rhapsodoi4 ,! foll[+ on ! ',rhapsodoi' is a v>iation on t :i* appe>$ 9 ',hom] & ! ,hom]id1' ) "s q additional & new ?\ghts on ! subject4 ,ab\t ^! p1 :o !y 71 :at relation !y bore to ,hom]1 & :y !y 7 call$ ',rhapsodoi1' we h se5 debat$ 9 ,g]many ?r\gh ! la/ half c5tury ) z mu* rabid f]ocity z 0 ev] appli$ to ! books ( a fraudul5t bankrupt4 ,su* is ! natural imp]t95ce ( man4 ,if he suspects any secret1 or any base attempt to hide & conceal ?+s f himself1 he is mis]able until he f9ds out ! my/]y1 & especially :]e all ! p>ties to x h be5 defunct = #b1ejj ye>s4 ,great indignation seems reasonably to h be5 felt by all ,g]man s*ol>s t any man %\ld presume to h call$ himself a rhapsodos at any p]iod ( ,grecian hi/ory )\t s5d+ d[n a seal$ lett] to po/]ity /at+ all ! reasons :i* induc$ him to take s unacc\ntable a /ep4 ,no possible solution1 giv5 to any conceivable "q be>+ ^u ! ',rhapsodoi1' seems by any t5d5cy to affect any "q out/&+ ab\t ,hom]4 ,& we d n !re=e und]/& ! propriety ( int]m+l+ ?is dispute ) ! g5]al ,hom]ic litigation4 ,h[ev]1 to comply ) ! practice ( ,g]many1 we %all ?r[ away a few s5t5ces ^u ?is1 z a pure ad libitum digression4 ,! c\rte\s read]1 :om we beg also to suppose ! mo/ ignorant ( read]s1 by way ( ?us f\nd+ a necessity & a case ( philosophic reasonabl5ess = ! circum/antiality ( our own explanations1 w be pleas$ to und]/& t by anci5t tradition>y usage ! ^w rhapsodia is ! designation te*nically appli$ to ! sev]al books or cantos ( ! ',iliad' & ',odyssey4' ,s ! ^w fytte has ga9$ a te*nical appropriation to our n>rative poetry :5 x takes ! ballad =m4 ,n[1 ! ,greek ^w rhapsody is d]iv$ f a t5se ( ! v]b rhapto1 to sew z ) a ne$le1 to connect1 & ode1 a song1 *ant1 or c\rse ( s++4 ,if1 !re=e1 y conceive ( a rhapsodia1 n z ! op]a1 b z ! opus ( a s+]1 n z ! =m1 b z ! result ( 8 (ficial m9i/ration1 viz41 z t section ( a n>rative poem :i* =ms an intelligible :ole 9 itself1 :il/ 9 a subord9ate relation x is "o "p ( a l>g] :ole--?is idea repres5ts accurately en\gh ! use ( ! ^w rhapsodia 9 ! latt] p]iods ( ,greek lit]ature4 ,suppose ! ^w canto to be tak5 9 its lit]al etymological s5se1 x w\ld indicate a metrical composition meant to be sung or *ant$4 ,b :at con/itutes ! complexity ( ! idea 9 ! ^w rhapsodia is t bo? its sep>ate elem5ts1 ! poetry & ! musical deliv]y1 are equally ess5tial2 nei!r is a casual1 nei!r a subord9ate1 elem5t4 ,n[1 ! ',rhapsodoi1' z may be suppos$1 are ! p]sonal correlates ( ! rhapsodia4 ,?is be+ ! poem adapt$ to *ant+1 ^? 7 ! *ant]s4 ,& ! only important "q :i* we c imag9e to arise is1 ,h[ f> 9 any giv5 age we may presume ! functions ( ! poetical compos] & ! musical deliv]] to h be5 unit$4 ,we _c p]ceive t any possible relation betwe5 a rhapsody consid]$ z a section ( a poem & ! :ole ( t poem1 or any possible relation :i* ?is same rhapsody consid]$ z a ?+ to be sung or accompani$ in/rum5tally c\ld be> to ! nak$-speak+ rehe>sal ( ! same poem or to ! orig9al text ( t poem1 ev] c affect ! ma9 "q ( ,hom]'s integrity4 ,! ',rhapsodoi' come to be m5tion$ at all simply z be+ "o l9k 9 ! transmission ( ! ,hom]ic poems4 ,!y are f\nd exi/+ be=e ,pisi/ratus1 !y are f\nd exi/+ aft] ,pisi/ratus4 ,& !y decl9$ exactly z ! art ( read+ became g5]al4 ,we c approximate pretty closely to ! "t :5 ! ',rhapsodoi' ceas$2 b at :at "t !y began we defy any man to say4 ,plato 7,rep4 x47 repres5ts !m z go+ back into ! days ( ,hom]2 nay1 accord+ to ,plato1 ,hom] himself 0 a rhapsodos1 & it9]at$ 9 t "*4 ,s 0 ,hesiod4 ,& two rem>kable l9es1 ascrib$ to ,hesiod by "o ( ! ,s*olia/s ^u ,p9d>1 if we c\ld be sure t !y 7 g5u9e1 settle t "q3 ,greek3 ,en ,delo tote prton ego xai ,hom]os aoidoi ,melpom51 en ne>ois mnois rapsantes aoid4 ',!n1 fir/ ( all1' says ,hesiod1 'did ,i & ,hom] *ant z b>ds 9 ,delos1 lay+ ! nexus ( our poetic composition 9 promial hymns4' ,we und]/& him to mean ?is3 ,!re 7 _m s+]s & h>p]s :o sang or accompani$ ! words ( o!rs2 p]haps anci5t words--at all ev5ts1 n _! own4 ,naturally he 0 anxi\s to h x und]/ood t he & ,hom] _h high] pret5sions4 ,!y kill$ _! own mutton4 ,!y compos$ ! words z well z sang !m4 ,:]e bo? functions 7 s (t5 unit$ 9 "o man's p]son1 x became difficult to di/+ui% !m4 ,our own ^w b>d or m9/rel /ood 9 ! same ambiguity4 ,y c\ld n tell 9 _m cases :e!r ! ^w po9t$ to ! man's poetic or musical faculty4 ,anticipat+ t d\bt1 ,hesiod says t !y sang z orig9al poets4 ,= x is a rem>k ( ,suidas1 :i* he d$uces labori\sly1 t poetry1 be+ uni=mly sung 9 ! eld] ,greece1 acquir$ ! "n ( ,greek3 aoid4 ,?is t]m became te*nically appropriat$ to ! poetry1 or sub/ance ( :atev] 0 sung1 9 contradi/9ction to ! musical accompanim5t4 ,& ! poet 0 call$ ,greek3 aoidos ,s f> ,hesiod twice ov] secures ! dignity ( _! (fice f mis9t]pretation4 ,& !re1 by ! ^w ,greek3 raphantes he indicates ! sort ( poetry :i* !y cultivat$1 viz41 t :i* 0 exp&$ into long h]oic n>ratives1 & naturally connect$ itself bo? int]nally among/ its own p>ts1 & ext]nally ) o!r poems ( ! same class4 ,?us1 hav+ sep>at$ ,hom] & himself f ! m]e musicians1 next he sep>ates !m ev5 z poets f ^? :o simply compos$ hymns to ! ,gods4 ,^! h]oic leg5ds 7 kn[n to require mu* m elaborate /udy & art4 ,yet1 because a critical review] might take occasion to tax 8 piety 9 ?us compos+ human leg5ds 9 neglect ( ! ,gods1 ,hesiod1 =e/all+ him1 replies3 ',y're out !re1 my fri5d2 we 7 bo? pi\s1 & we put our piety into hymns address$ to ! ,gods1 :i*1 ) cab9etmak]s' skill1 we us$ also z int]ludes ( transition f "o leg5d to ano!r4' ,= x is notic$ frequ5tly & especially by a ,s*olia/ on ,ari/ophanes 7,pac4 #hbf71 t g5]ally speak+ ! promia to ! diff]5t p>ts ( n>rative-poems 7 entirely deta*$1 ,greek3 kai oud5 pros to pragma dlon1 & expla9 no?+ at all t conc]ns ! bus9ess4 #b4--,mrs4 ,evans & ! ',gazette4' ,9 8 autobiographic sket*1 ',introduction to ! ,_w ( ,/rife1' he tells ( 8 bro!r's ent]prise 9 e/abli%+ ! ,gazette1 :i* 0 to record _! do+s1 & also ( ,mrs4 ,evans's place on ! ,gazette4 ,! foll[+ is evid5tly a passage :i* 0 prep>$ = t "p ( ! article1 b 0 f "s cause or o!r omitt$3 ,i suppose no creature ev] l$ su* a life z ,i l$ on ! ,gazette2 sometimes runn+ up1 l ,wall5/e91 to ! giddie/ p9nacles ( hon\r1 !n d[n aga9 )\t notice or w>n+ to ! du/2 ca%i]$--r5d]$ incapable ( ev] s]v+ ,h4 ,m4 aga92 nay1 actually drumm$ out ( ! army1 my uni=m /ripp$ (f1 & ! 'rogue's m>*' play$ aft] me4 ,& all = :at8 ,i prote/1 to ?is h\r1 ,i h no guess4 ,if any p]son kn[s1 t p]son is n myself2 & ! read] is q z well able to furni% guesses to me z ,i to him--to enlight5 me ^u ! subject z ,i him4 ,mrs4 ,evans 0 a v important p]son 9 ! play2 ,i don't suppose t ?+s c\ld h gone on )\t h]4 ,=1 z !re 0 no writ] 9 ! ,gazette b my bro!r1 s !re 0 no read] ( x except ,mrs4 ,evans4 ,& "h came 9 a %ock+ annoyance to me t1 z (t5 z any necessity occurr$ 7:i* 0 e ?ird day7 = re/or+ me to my rank1 s9ce my bro!r w\ld n h x suppos$ t he c\ld be weak en\gh to initiate su* an indulg5ce1 ! ,gazette ?rew ! onus ( ?is amiable weakness1 & consequ5tly ( my gratitude1 ^u ,mrs4 ,evans1 affirm+ t ! major-g5]al _h receiv$ a p>don & an amne/y = all 8 pa/ atrocities at ! reque/ ( 'a di/+ui%$ lady1' :o 0 obscurely indicat$ 9 a p>5!sis z '! truly hon\rable ,mrs4 ,evans4' ,to li/5 to ! ,gazette "o w\ld h suppos$ t ?is woman1 :o s cordially dete/$ me1 sp5t h] :ole "t 9 go+ d[n on h] knees & mak+ e>ne/ supplications to ! ?rone on my behalf4 ,b :at signifi$ ! repres5tations ( ! ,gazette if ,i knew !m to be false8 ,aye1 b ,i did n "k t !y 7 false4 ,x is true t my obligations to h] 7 q a]ial1 & might1 z ! read] w ?9k1 h be5 support$ )\t any pret]natural ef=t4 ,b exactly ^! a]ial burd5s1 :e!r ( gratitude or ( hon\r1 mo/ oppress$ me z be+ lea/ tangible & incapable ( pecuni>y or o!r satisfaction4 ,no s9k+ fund c\ld meet !m4 ,& ev5 ! dull unimag9ative woman h]self1 et]nally held up to admiration z my resolute b5efactress1 got ! habit 7,i am sure7 ( look+ ^u me z "u nameless obligations to h]4 ,?is rais$ my wra?4 ,x 0 n t to my feel+s ! obligations 7 really a m]e figm5t ( pret5ce4 ,on ! contr>y1 accord+ to my pa9s endur$1 !y t[]$ up to ! cl\ds4 ,b ,i felt t nobody _h any "r to load me ) fav\rs t ,i _h nev] ask$ =1 & )\t leave ev5 ask$ f me2 & ! m real 7 ! fav\rs1 ! deep] ! wrong done to me4 ,i s\ght1 !re=e1 = "s means ( retaliation4 ,& x is odd t x 0 n till ?irty ye>s aft] t ,i p]ceiv$ "o4 ,x !n /ruck me t ! et]nal int]cession might h be5 equally odi\s to h]4 ,to f9d h]self pro/rate = ev]1 weep+ l ,niobe1 &1 if ! ,gazette 0 to be believ$1 refus+ to raise h]self f ! mud or ! fl9ty pavem5t till ,i _h be5 =giv51 & re9/at$ 9 my rank--ah1 h[ loa?some t mu/ h be5 to h]6 ,ah1 h[ loa?some ! :ole cycle ( fav\rs 7 to me1 consid]+ f :om !y came6 ,!n we _h effectually plagu$ ea* o!r4 ,& x 0 n )\t l\d laught]1 z ( malice unexpect$ly triumphant1 t ,i f\nd "o night ?irty ye>s aft]1 on regrett+ my p[]lessness ( v5geance1 t1 9 fact1 ,i _h amply triumph$ ?irty ye>s be=e4 ,s1 undaunt$ ,mrs4 ,evans1 if y live any:]e )9 call1 li/5 to ! assurance t all acc\nts are squ>$ betwe5 u1 & t we balanc$ our mutual debts by mutual disgu/2 & t1 if y plagu$ me p]v]sely1 ,i plagu$ y unconsci\sly4 ,& ?\gh %ot & bullets 7 =bidd5 fruit1 yet some?+ might be done ) h>d wadd+4 ,a good deal ( classical lit]ature disappe>$ 9 ?is way1 :i* by "o :o valu$ no classics v highly might be call$ ! way ( all fle%4 ,! be/ ( au?ors1 he cont5d$1 _h bett] p]i% by ?is w>like consummation ?an by ! +lori\s enmity ( bookworms & mo?s--honeycomb$1 z mo/ ( ! books _h be5 :i* _h gone out to ,india ) our two uncles4 ,ev5 wadd+1 h[ev]1 0 decl>$ to be inadmissible z too dang]\s1 aft] w\nds _h be5 inflict$ m ?an once4 #c4--;,a ,,lawsuit ,,legacy4 ,de ,qu9cey1 9 8 autobiographic sket* head$ ',laxton1' tells ( ! =tune ( ,miss ,watson1 :o aft]w>ds became ,lady ,c>b]y1 & also ( ! legacy left to h] 9 ! =m ( a lawsuit by h] fa!r aga9/ ! ,ea/ ,india ,company2 & among 8 pap]s we f9d ! foll[+ passage ei!r ov]look$ or omitt$1 = "s undiscov]able reason1 f t pap]1 ?\gh x has a value 9 its own way z express+ "s ( ,de ,qu9cey's views on law & equity2 & x is suffici5tly *>act]i/ic to be includ$ "h3 ,9 consequ5ce ( h] long m9ority1 ,miss ,watson mu/ h succe$$ at once to six ?\s& a ye> on complet+ h] tw5ty-fir/ ye>2 & %e also inh]it$ a ,*anc]y-suit1 :i* sort ( prop]ty is n[ 7#ahec7 r at a disc\nt 9 public e/imation2 b let ! read] assure himself t ev5 ! ,c\rt ( ,*anc]y is n q s black z x is pa9t$2 t ! true gr\nd = ! delays & ru9\s exp5ses 9 n9ety-n9e out ( "o hundr$ in/ances is n legal *ican]y1 /ill less ! wilful circuit\sness & word9ess ( law processes1 b ! great et]nal fact t1 :at ?r\gh lapse ( "t1 decays ( memory1 & loss ( docum5ts1 & :at ?r\gh int]e/$ suppressions ( tru?1 & ! disp]sions ( witnesses1 & causes by ! score beside1 ! ultimate tru? & equity ( human disputes is a matt] ( prodigi\s p]plexity2 nei!r is !re any possibility t ! mass ( litigations z to prop]ty ev] c be made *eap except 9 proportion z x is made dismally imp]fect4 ,no p[] t ev] yet 0 lodg$ 9 s5ates or 9 c\ncils c\ld avail1 ev] has avail$1 ev] w avail1 to int]cept ! immeasurable expansion ( t law :i* gr[s out ( social expansion4 ,fa/ z ! relations ( man multiply1 & ! modifications ( prop]ty ext5d1 mu/ ! correspond+ adaptations ( ! law run alongside4 ,! pret5d$ arre/s appli$ to ?is heav+ volcanic sy/em ( =ces by codifications1 l ^? ( ,ju/9ian or ,napoleon1 _h n la/$ = a ye> be=e all _h broke loose f its moor+s1 & 0 aga9 go+ ahead ) r$\bl+ impetus4 ,equally delusive are ! prospects held out t ! new sy/em ( *eap prov9cial ju/ice w be a *ange unconditionally = ! bett]4 ,already ! compla9ts aga9/ x are su* 9 bitt]ness & ext5t z to %[ t 9 v _m cases x mu/ be reg>d$ z a failure2 &1 :]e x is n1 t x mu/ be reg>d$ z a compromise3 once y _h #h degrees ( ! advantage ,x1 #d ( ,y2 n[ y h #g ( ,x1 #e ( ,y4 #d4--,,! ,,true ,,ju/ifications ,,( ,,w>4 ,! foll[+ 0 evid5tly int5d$ to appe> 9 ! article on ,w>3 ',mo/ ( :at has be5 writt5 on ?is subject 7! cruelty ( w>71 9 connection ) ! app>5tly fi]ce e?ics ( ! ,old ,te/am5t1 is 7) submission to s5tim5tali/s7 false & pr(\ndly unphilosophic4 ,x is ( ! same feeble "* z ! fla%y mod]n moralizations ^u ,w>4 ,! true ju/ifications ( w> lie f> bel[ ! dep?s ( any s\nd+s tak5 ^u ! *>ts ( effem9ate e>?-born e?ics4 ,& e?ics ( ,god1 ! ,scriptural e?ics1 se>* into dep?s t are old] & less measurable1 contemplate int]e/s t are m my/]i\s & entangl$ ) p]ils m awful ?an m]ely human philosophy has res\rces = appreciat+4 ,x is n at all impossible t a crisis has sometimes aris5 = ! human race1 9 :i* its capital int]e/ may be said to h ridd5 at s+le an*or4 ,^u ! issue ( a s+le /ruggle betwe5 ! p[]s ( light & d>kness--^u a motion1 a bias1 an impulse giv5 ?is way or t--all may h be5 /ak$4 ,out ( ,judaism came ,*ri/ianity1 & ! m]e possibility ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,f eld] /ages ( ! ,hebrew race1 hidd5 9 ?ick d>kness to u1 desc5d$ ! only pure glimpse all[$ to man ( ,god's nature4 ,traditionally1 b ?r\gh _m g5]ations1 & fight+ at e /age ) /orms or ) p]ils m ?an ev] 7 reveal$ to u1 ?is idea ( ,god1 ?is holy se$ ( tru?1 l "s secret jewel pass+ onw>ds ?r\gh armies ( robb]s1 made its way d[nw>d to an age 9 :i* x became ! matrix ( ,*ri/ianity4 ,! solit>y acorn _h rea*$ 9 safety ! p>ticul> soil 9 :i* x 0 fir/ capable ( exp&+ into a =e/4 ,! n>r[1 b at ! same "t au/]e1 tru? ( ,judaism1 furni%$ ! basis :i* by magic1 z x 71 bur/ sudd5ly & exp&$ into a va/ sup]/ructure1 no long] fitt$ = ! appreh5sion ( "o s+le unamiable race1 b (f]+ %elt] & repose to ! :ole family ( man4 ,^! ?+s are mo/ rem>kable ab\t ?is memorable trans-migration ( "o fai? into ano!r1 ( an imp]fect into a p]fect religion1 viz41 t ! e>ly /age _h b a slight resemblance to ! latt]1 nor c\ld h prefigur$ x to a human sagacity m ?an a l>va c\ld prefigure a *rysalis2 &1 secondly1 t :]eas ! product1 viz41 ,*ri/ianity1 nev] has be5 nor w be 9 any dang] ( ru91 ! g]m1 viz41 ! ,judaic idea ( ,god1 ! great radiation ?r\gh :i* ! ,deity kept op5 ,8 communication ) man1 app>5tly mu/ m ?an once h approa*$ an awful /ruggle = life4 ,?is solit>y tap] ( tru?1 /ruggl+ across a h[l+ wild]ness ( d>kness1 _h x be5 ev] totally ext+ui%$1 c\ld probably nev] h be5 reillum9$4 ,x may seem an easy ?+ = a m]e human philosophy to recov]1 & /eadily to ma9ta9 a pure ,hebrew conception ( ,god2 b s f> is ?is f be+ true1 t we believe x possible to expose 9 ! close/ ,pagan approximation to ?is ,hebrew type "s adult]\s elem5ts su* z w\ld h ensur$ its relapse into idolatr\s impurity4' #e4--,,philosophy ,,defeat$4 ,we h come ^u a passage :i* is omitt$ f ! ',confessions1' & z x is1 9 e way1 *>act]i/ic1 we %all give x3 ,my /udies h n[ be5 long int]rupt$4 ,i _c read to myself ) any pleasure1 h>dly ) a mom5t's endurance4 ,yet ,i read al\d sometimes = ! pleasure ( o!rs--because read+ is an accompli%m5t ( m9e1 &1 9 ! slang use ( ! ^w 'accompli%m5t' z a sup]ficial & ornam5tal atta9m5t1 almo/ ! only "o ,i possess--&1 =m]ly1 if ,i _h any vanity at all connect$ ) any end[m5t or atta9m5t ( m9e1 x 0 ) ?is2 = ,i _h obs]v$ t no accompli%m5t 0 s r>e4 ,play]s are ! wor/ read]s ( all2 ---- reads vilely1 & ,mrs4 ----1 :o is s celebrat$1 c read no?+ well b dramatic compositions--,milton %e _c read suff]ably4 ,p 9 g5]al read poetry )\t any passion at all1 or else ov]/ep ! mode/y ( nature & read n l s*ol>s4 ,( late1 if ,i h felt mov$ by any?+ 9 books1 x has be5 by ! gr& lam5tations ( ',samson ,agoni/es1' or ! great h>monies ( ! ,satanic speak] 9 ',p>adise ,rega9$1' :5 read al\d by myself4 ,a "y lady sometimes comes & dr9ks tea ) u4 ,at h] reque/ & ,m----'s ,i n[ & !n read ,w----'s poems to !m4 7,w----1 by-!-bye1 is ! only poet ,i ev] met :o c\ld read 8 own v]ses4 ,blank v]se he reads admirably47 ,?is1 !n1 has be5 ! ext5t ( my read+ = upw>ds ( sixte5 mon?s4 ,x frets me to ent] ^? rooms ( my cottage 9 :i* ! books /&4 ,9 "o ( !m1 to :i* my little boy has access1 he has f\nd out a use = "s ( !m4 ,somebody has giv5 him a b[ & arr[s--,god kn[s :o1 c]ta9ly n ,i1 = ,i h n en]gy or +5uity to inv5t a walk+-/ick--?us equipp$ = action1 he re>s up ! l>ge/ ( ! folios t he c lift1 places !m on a tott]+ base1 & !n %oots until he br+s d[n ! enemy4 ,he (t5 presses me to jo9 him2 & sometimes ,i cons5t1 & we are bo? engag$ toge!r 9 ^! intellectual lab\rs4 ,we build up a pile1 hav+ = its base "s sl5d] mod]n metaphysician1 ill able 7poor man67 to su/a9 su* a weight ( philosophy4 ,^u ?is we place ! ,dut* qu>tos ( ,desc>tes & ,sp9oza2 !n a ?ird /ory ( ,s*oolm5 9 folio--! ,ma/] ( ,s5t5ces1 ,su>ez1 ,picus ,mir&ula1 & ! ,telemonian bulk ( ,?omas ,aqu9as2 & :5 ! :ole ar*itecture seems firm & compact1 we f9i% our sy/em ( metaphysics by ro(+ ! :ole ) ,duval's enorm\s ,ari/otle4 ,s f> !re is "s pleasure--build+ up is some?+1 b :at is t to de/roy+8 ,?us ?9ks1 at lea/1 my little companion1 :o n[1 ) ! wra? ( ! ,py?ian ,apollo1 assumes 8 b[ & arr[s2 plants himself 9 ! remote/ corn] ( ! room1 & prep>es 8 fatal %afts4 ,! b[-/r+ twangs1 flights ( arr[s are 9 ! air1 b ! ,dut* impregnability ( ! ,b]g5-op-,zooms at ! base receives ! few :i* rea* ! m>k1 & !y recoil )\t mis*ief done4 ,aga9 ! baffl$ ar*] collects 8 arr[s1 & aga9 he takes 8 /ation4 ,an arr[ issues =?1 & takes effect on a weak side ( ,?omas4 ,symptoms ( dissolution appe>--! cohesion ( ! sy/em is loos5$--! ,s*oolm5 beg9 to tott]2 ! ,/agyrite trembles2 ,philosophy rocks to its c5tre2 &1 be=e x c be se5 :e!r "t w d any?+ to heal _! w\nds1 ano!r arr[ is plant$ 9 ! s*ism ( _! ontology2 ! mighty /ructure heaves--reels--seems 9 susp5se = "o mom5t1 & !n1 ) "o *oral cra%--to ! frantic joy ( ! "y ,sagitt>y--lies subv]t$ on ! floor6 ,kant & ,ari/otle1 ,nom9ali/s & ,reali/s1 ,doctors ,s]aphic or ,irrefragable1 :at c>es he8 ,all are at 8 feet--! ,irrefragable has be5 confut$ by 8 arr[s1 ! ,s]aphic has be5 f\nd mortal1 & ! greate/ philosoph] & ! lea/ diff] b accord+ to ! brief noise !y h made4 ,= ne>ly two ye>s ,i believe t ,i read no book b "o1 & ,i owe x to ! au?or1 ,mr4 ,ric>do1 to make grateful record ( x4 ,& !n he proce$s3 ,sudd5ly1 9 #ahah1 a fri5d 9 ,ed9burgh s5t me d[n ,mr4 ,ric>do's book1 etc4 #f4--,,! ,,highwayman',s ,,skeleton4 ,9 ! acc\nt :i* ,de ,qu9cey gives ( ! highwayman's skeleton1 :i* figur$ 9 ! museum ( ! di/+ui%$ surgeon1 ,mr4 ,:ite1 9 8 *apt] 9 ! ',autobiographic ,sket*es' head$ ',! ,man*e/] ,gramm> ,s*ool1' he 0 evid5tly re/ra9$ f ins]t+ "o passage1 :i* we h f\nd among 8 pap]s1 f consid]ations ( delicacy t[>ds p]sons :o might !n /ill be liv+4 ,b z he has !re pla9ly giv5 ! names ( ! lead+ p]sons conc]n$--! fam\s ,surgeon ,cruik%ank1#da !re c at ?is "t ( day be little risk ( (f5d+ or hurt+ anyone by pres5t+ ! passage1 :i* ! curi\s /ud5t ( ! ,autobiography c ins]t at ! prop] po9t1 & may feel t its pres5ce adds to ! complet5ess ( ! impression1 half-humor\s1 half-e]ie1 :i* ,de ,qu9cey 0 fa9 to produce by t some:at grim episode4 ,"h is ! passage3 ,x 0 a regul> & respectable bran* ( public indu/ry :i* 0 c>ri$ on by ! highwaym5 ( ,engl&1 & all ! p>ties to x mov$ ^u dec5t motives & by consid]ate me?ods4 ,9 p>ticul>1 ! robb]s !mselves1 z ! lead+ p>ties1 c\ld n be o!r ?an fir/-rate m51 z reg>d$ c\rage1 animal vig\r1 & p]fect horseman%ip4 ,/>t+ f any l[] /&>d ?an ?is1 n only _h !y no *ance ( cont9u$ success--_! failure 0 c]ta9 z reg>d$ ! conte/ ) ! travell]1 b also _! failure 0 equally c]ta9 z reg>d$ ! competition )9 _! own body4 ,! c&idates = a lucrative section ( ! road 7 sure to become tr\blesome 9 proportion z all adm9i/ration ( ! bus9ess ^u t "p ( ! l9e 0 feebly or indiscreetly work$4 ,h5ce x arose t individually ! *ief highwaym5 7 sure to comm& a deep pr(essional int]e/ among/ ! surgeons ( ! l&4 ,sometimes x happ5$ t a fir/-rate robb] 0 arre/$ & br\ght to trial1 b f defective evid5ce escap$4 ,mean:ile 8 f9e p]son _h be5 locally adv]tis$ & br\ght "u ! notice ( ! m$ical body4 ,?is _h occurr$ 9 a m em95t degree ?an 0 usual to ! robb] :o _h own$ :5 liv+ ! mat*less skeleton possess$ by ,mr4 ,:ite4 ,he _h be5 mo/ ext5sively survey$ ) anatomical eyes by ! :ole body ( ! m$ical pr(ession 9 ,london3 _! delib]ate judgm5t ^u him 0 t a m absolutely magnific5t figure ( a man did n exi/ 9 ,engl& ?an ?is highwayman1 & naturally !re=e v high sums 7 (f]$ to him z soon z 8 condemnation 0 c]ta94 ,! robb]1 ^: "n ,i entirely =get1 f9ally clos$ ) ! (f] ( ,cruik%ank1 :o 0 at t "t ! mo/ em95t surgeon 9 ,london4 ,^? days1 z is well kn[n1 7 days ( great irregul>ity 9 all t conc]n$ ! managem5t ( prisons & ! adm9i/ration ( crim9al ju/ice4 ,consequ5tly !re is no reason = surprise or = d\bt 9 ! /atem5t made by ,mr4 ,:ite1 t ,cruik%ank1 ^: pupil ,mr4 ,:ite !n 01 receiv$ "s special indulg5ces f "o ( ! "u-%]iffs beyond :at ! law w\ld /rictly h w>rant$4 ,! robb] 0 cut d[n consid]ably )9 ! appo9t$ "t1 0 in/antly plac$ 9 a *aise-&-f\r1 & 0 ?us br\ght s prematurely into ! private rooms ( ,cruik%ank1 t life 0 n z yet entirely ext9ct4 ,?is ,i he>d ,mr4 ,:ite repeat$ly ass]t4 ,he 0 himself at t "t among/ ! pupils ( ,cruik%ank1 & ?ree or f\r ( ! mo/ fav\r$ among/ ^! 7 pres5t1 & to "o ( !m ,cruik%ank obs]v$ quietly3 ',i ?9k ! subject is n q dead2 pray put y\r knife 9 7,mr4 ,x4 ,y47 at ?is po9t4' ,t 0 done2 a solemn f9is 0 plac$ to ! lab\rs ( ! robb]1 & p]haps a solemn inauguration to ! lab\rs ( ! /ud5t4 ,a ca/ 0 tak5 f ! sup]b figure ( ! highwayman2 he 0 !n dissect$1 8 skeleton became ! prop]ty ( ,cruik%ank1 & subsequ5tly ( ,mr4 ,:ite4 ,we 7 all call$ ^u to admire ! f9e proportions ( ! man1 & ( c\rse 9 t holl[ & unmean+ way :i* su* unle>n$ expressors ( judgm5t usually assume1 we all obsequi\sly met ! dem& levi$ ^u our admiration4 ,b1 = my "p1 ?\gh readily confid+ 9 ! pr(essional judgm5t ( anatomi/s1 ,i c\ld n b feel t ?r\gh my own unassi/$ judgm5t ,i nev] c\ld h arriv$ at su* a conclusion4 ,! unle>n$ eye has ga!r$ no rudim5tal po9ts to beg9 )4 ,n hav+ :at are ! normal outl9es to :i* ! f9e/ proportions t5d1 an eye s untutor$ _c ( c\rse judge 9 :at degree ! giv5 subject approa*es to ^!4 #g4--,,! ,,ransom ,,= ,,wat]loo4 ,! foll[+ gives a v>iation on a fam\s passage 9 ! ',dream ,fugue1' & x may be int]e/+ to ! read] to comp>e x ) t :i* ! au?or pr9t$4 ,f ^! v>iations x w be se5 t ,de ,qu9cey (t5 wrote & re-wrote 8 f9e/ passages1 & sometimes1 no d\bt1 f\nd x h>d to *oose betwe5 ! read+s3 ,?us z we ran l torr5ts2 ?us z ) bridal rapture our fly+ equipage swept ov] ! campo santo ( ! graves2 ?us z our burn+ :eels c>ri$ w>rior in/9cts1 k9dl$ e>?ly passions among/ ! trembl+ du/ bel[ u1 sudd5ly we became aw>e ( a va/ necropolis to :i* f af> we 7 hurry+4 ,9 a mom5t our madd5+ :eels 7 ne>+ x4 ',( purple granite 9 massive piles 0 ?is city ( ! dead1 & yet = "o mom5t x lay l a vision>y purple /a9 on ! horizon1 s mighty 0 ! di/ance4 ,9 ! second mom5t ?is purple city trembl$ ?r\gh _m *anges1 & grew z by fi]y pulsations1 s mighty 0 ! pace4 ,9 ! ?ird mom5t already ) our dreadful gallop we 7 ent]+ its suburbs4 ,sy/ems ( s>cophagi rose ) cre/s a]ial ( t]races & turrets into ! upp] glooms1 /rode =w>d ) haughty encroa*m5t ^u ! c5tral aisle1 ran back ) mighty %ad[s into answ]+ recesses4 ,:5 ! s>cophagi :eel$1 !n did our horses :eel4 ,l riv]s 9 horn$ floods :eel+ 9 pomp ( unfa?omable wat]s r\nd headl&s2 l hurricanes t ride into ! secrets ( =e/s1 fa/] ?an ev] light travels ?r\gh ! wild]ness ( d>kness1 we %ot ! angles1 we fl$ r\nd ! curves ( ! labyr9?9e city4 ,) ! /orm ( our horses' feet1 & ( our burn+ :eels1 did we c>ry e>?ly passions1 k9dle w>rior in/9cts among/ ! sil5t du/ ar\nd u1 du/ ( our noble fa!rs t _h slept 9 ,god s9ce ,creci4 ,e s>cophagus %[$ _m bas-reliefs1 bas-reliefs ( battles1 bas-reliefs ( battlefields1 battles f =gott5 ages1 battles f ye/]day2 battlefields t long s9ce ,nature _h heal$ & reconcil$ to h]self ) ! sweet oblivion ( fl[]s2 battlefields t 7 yet angry & crimson ) c>nage4 ,& n[ _h we rea*$ ! la/ s>cophagus1 already we 7 abrea/ ( ! la/ bas-relief2 already we 7 recov]+ ! arr[-l flight ( ! c5tral aisle1 :5 com+ up x 9 c\nt]view to ourselves we beheld ! fraile/ ( c>s1 built z might seem f floral wrea?s1 & f ! %ells ( ,indian seas4 ,half conceal$ 7 ! fawns t drew x by ! float+ mi/s t w5t be=e x 9 pomp4 ,b ! mi/s hid n ! lovely c\nt5ance ( ! infant girl t sate wi/ful ^u ! e>1 & hid n ! birds ( tropic plumage ) :i* %e play$4 ,face to face %e rode =w>d to meet u1 & baby laught] 9 h] eyes salut$ ! ru9 t approa*$4 ',oh1 baby1' ,i said 9 angui%1 'mu/ we t c>ry tid+s ( great joy to e p be ,god's mess5g]s ( ru9 to !e8' ,9 horror ,i rose at ! ?\ght4 ,b !n also1 9 horror at ! ?\ght1 rose "o t 0 sculptur$ 9 ! bas-relief--a dy+ trumpet]4 ,solemnly f ! field ( ,wat]loo he rose to 8 feet1 &1 unsl++ 8 /ony trumpet1 c>ri$ x 9 8 dy+ angui% to 8 /ony lips1 s\nd+ once1 & yet once aga91 proclamation t to ?y e>s1 oh baby1 mu/ h spok5 f ! battlem5ts ( dea?4 ,imm$iately deep %ad[s fell betwe5 u1 & %udd]+ sil5ce4 ,! *oir _h ceas$ to s+2 ! upro> ( our laurell$ equipage al>m$ ! graves no m4 ,by horror ! bas-relief _h be5 unlock$ into life4 ,by horror we t 7 s full ( life--we m51 & our horses ) _! fi]y =elegs ris+ 9 mid-air to _! ev]la/+ gallop--7 petrifi$ to a bas-relief4 ,oh1 glacial pageantry ( dea?1 t f end to end ( ! gorge\s ca!dral = a mom5t froze e eye by contagion ( panic4 ,!n = ! ?ird "t ! trumpet s\nd$4 ,back ) ! %att]+ bur/ came ! inf9ite ru%+ ( life4 ,! seals ( fro/ 7 rais$ f our /ifl+ he>ts4 #h4--;,,desid]ium4 ,"h is ano!r v>iation on a fam\s passage 9 ! ',autobiographic ,sket*es1' :i* w give ! read] "s fur!r opportunity = comp>ison3 ,at six ye>s ( age1 or !reab\ts 7,i write )\t any memorial notes71 ! glory ( ?is e>? = me 0 ext+ui%$4 ,x is f9i%$--n ^? words b t s5tim5t--0 ! misgiv+ ( my prophetic he>t2 ?\ght x 0 t gnaw$ l a worm1 t did n & t c\ld n die4 ',h[1 *ild1' a cynic w\ld h said1 if he _h deciph]$ ! secret read+ ( my sighs--'at six ye>s ( age1 w y pret5d t life has already exhau/$ its promises8 ,h y communicat$ ) ! gr&eurs ( e>?8 ,h y read ,milton8 ,h y se5 ,rome8 ,h y he>d ,moz>t8' ,no1 ,i _h n1 nor c\ld 9 ^? ye>s h appreciat$ any "o ( !m if ,i _h2 &1 !re=e1 und\bt$ly ! cr[n jewels ( our little planet 7 /ill wait+ = me 9 ! re>4 ,milton & ,rome & ',don ,giovanni' 7 yet to come4 ,b x matt]$ n :at rema9$ :5 set ov] aga9/ :at _h be5 tak5 away4 ,t x 0 :i* ,i s\ght = ev] 9 my bl9dness4 ,! love :i* _h exi/$ betwe5 myself & my dep>t$ si/]1 t1 z ev5 a *ild c\ld feel1 0 n a light t c\ld be rek9dl$4 ,no voice on e>? c\ld say1 ',come aga96' to a fl[] ( ,p>adise l t4 ,love1 su* z t is giv5 b once to any4 ,exquisite are ! p]ceptions ( *ildhood1 n less s ?an ^? ( mature/ wisdom1 9 :at t\*es ! capital int]e/s ( ! he>t4 ,& no argum5ts1 nor any consolations1 c\ld h soo!d me into a mom5t's belief1 t a w\nd s gha/ly z m9e admitt$ ( heal+ or palliation4 ,consequ5tly1 z ,i /ood m alone 9 ! v mid/ ( a dome/ic circle ?an ev] ,*ri/ian travell] 9 an ,african ,bilidulg]id amid/ ! t5ts ( infidels1 or ! h[ls ( lions1 day & night--9 ! d>kness & at noon-day--,i sate1 ,i /ood1 ,i lay1 mop+ l an idiot1 crav+ = :at 0 impossible1 & seek+1 grop+1 snat*+1 at t :i* 0 irretrievable = ev]4 ,,footnotes3 #da ,born #agdf1 di$ #ahjj4--;,,ed4 ,,! ,,end4