99 99 99 99 99 ---------------------------------------- --------------------- ,transcriber's ,note3 ,,np ligature in the table on page #hi is shown in this document as ,,np4 ,bold words are surrounded with 's4 ---------------------------------------- --------------------- 99 99 99 99 99 ,,the ,,religion ,,of ,,ancient ,,rome ,by ,,cyril ,,bailey1 ,m4,a4 ,,fellow ,,and ,,tutor ,,of ,,balliol ,,college1 ,,oxford ,,london ,,archibald ,,constable ,,co ,,ltd #aijg ,i wish to express my warm thanks to ,mr4 ,w4 ,warde ,fowler for his kindness in reading my proofs1 and for many valuable hints and suggestions4 ,c4,b4 ,,balliol ,,college1 ,jan #beth1 #aijg4 ,,contents ,,chap4 ,,page ,i4 ,,introduction--,,sources ,,and ,,scope #a ,,ii4 ,,the ',,antecedents' ,,of ,,roman ,,religion #d ,,iii4 ,,main ,,features ,,of ,,the ,,religion ,,of ,,numa #ab ,,iv4 ,,early ,,history ,,of ,,rome--,,the ,,agricultural ,,community #ca ,v4 ,,worship ,,of ,,the ,,household #cf ,,vi4 ,,worship ,,of ,,the ,,fields #eh ,,vii4 ,,worship ,,of ,,the ,,state #ge ,,viii4 ,,auguries ,,and ,,auspices #if ,,ix4 ,,religion ,,and ,,morality--,,conclusion #ajc ,,the ,,religion ,,of ,,ancient ,,rome ,,chapter ,i ,,introduction--,,sources ,,and ,,scope ,the conditions of our knowledge of the native religion of early ,rome may perhaps be best illustrated by a parallel from ,roman archaeology4 ,the visitor to the ,roman ,forum at the present day1 if he wishes to reconstruct in imagination the ,forum of the early ,republic1 must not merely 'think away' many strata of later buildings1 but1 we are told1 must picture to himself a totally different orientation of the whole3 the upper layer of remains1 which he sees before him1 is for his purpose in most cases not merely useless1 but positively misleading4 ,in the same way1 if we wish to form a picture of the genuine ,roman religion1 we cannot find it immediately in classical literature2 we must banish from our minds all that is due to the contact with the ,east and ,egypt1 and even with the other races of ,italy1 and we must imagine1 so to speak1 a totally different mental orientation before the great influx of ,greek literature and ,greek thought1 which gave an entirely new turn to ,roman ideas in general1 and in particular revolutionised religion by the introduction of anthropomorphic notions and sensuous representations4 ,but in this difficult search we are not left without indications to guide us4 ,in the writings of the savants of the late ,republic and of the ,empire1 and in the ,augustan poets1 biassed though they are in their interpretations by ,greek tendencies1 there is embodied a great wealth of ancient custom and ritual1 which becomes significant when we have once got the clue to its meaning4 ,more direct evidence is afforded by a large body of inscriptions and monuments1 and above all by the surviving ,calendars of the ,roman festival year1 which give us the true outline of the ceremonial observances of the early religion4 ,it is not within the scope of this sketch to enter1 except by way of occasional illustration1 into the process of interpretation by which the patient work of scholars has disentangled the form and spirit of the native religion from the mass of foreign accretions4 ,i intend rather to assume the process1 and deal1 as far as it is possible in so controversial a subject1 with results upon which authorities are generally agreed4 ,neither will any attempt be made to follow the development which the early religion underwent in later periods1 when foreign elements were added and foreign ideas altered and remoulded the old tradition4 ,we must confine ourselves to a single epoch1 in which the native ,roman spirit worked out unaided the ideas inherited from half-civilised ancestors1 and formed that body of belief and ritual1 which was always1 at least officially1 the kernel of ,roman religion1 and constituted what the ,romans themselves--staunch believers in their own traditional history--loved to describe as the ',religion of ,numa4' ,we must discover1 as far as we can1 how far its inherited notions ran parallel with those of other primitive religions1 but more especially we must try to note what is characteristically ,roman alike in custom and ritual and in the motives and spirit which prompted them4 ,,chapter ,,ii ,,the ',,antecedents' ,,of ,,roman ,,religion ,in every early religion there will of course be found1 apart from external influence1 traces of its own internal development1 of stages by which it must have advanced from a mass of vague and primitive belief and custom to the organised worship of a civilised community4 ,the religion of ,rome is no exception to this rule2 we can detect in its later practice evidences of primitive notions and habits which it had in common with other semi-barbarous peoples1 and we shall see that the leading idea in its theology is but a characteristically ,roman development of a marked feature in most early religions4 #a4 ,magic4--,anthropology has taught us that in many primitive societies religion--a sense of man's dependence on a power higher than himself--is preceded by a stage of magic--a belief in man's own power to influence by occult means the action of the world around him4 ,that the ancestors of the ,roman community passed through this stage seems clear1 and in surviving religious practice we may discover evidence of such magic in various forms4 ,there is1 for instance1 what anthropology describes as 'sympathetic magic'--the attempt to influence the powers of nature by an imitation of the process which it is desired that they should perform4 ,of this we have a characteristic example in the ceremony of the aquaelicium1 designed to produce rain after a long drought4 ,in classical times the ceremony consisted in a procession headed by the pontifices1 which bore the sacred rain-stone from its resting-place by the ,porta ,capena to the ,capitol1 where offerings were made to the sky-deity1 ,iuppiter1 but#a from the analogy of other primitive cults and the sacred title of the stone 7lapis manalis71 it is practically certain that the original ritual was the purely imitative process of pouring water over the stone4 ,a similar rain-charm may possibly be seen in the curious ritual of the argeorum sacra1 when puppets of straw were thrown into the ,tiber--a symbolic wetting of the crops to which many parallels may be found among other primitive peoples4 ,a sympathetic charm of a rather different character seems to survive in the ceremony of the augurium canarium1 at which a red dog was sacrificed for the prosperity of the crop--a symbolic killing of the red mildew 7robigo72 and again the slaughter of pregnant cows at the ,fordicidia in the middle of ,april1 before the sprouting of the corn1 has a clearly sympathetic connection with the fertility of the earth4 ,another prominent survival--equally characteristic of primitive peoples--is the sacredness which attaches to the person of the priest-king1 so that his every act or word may have a magic significance or effect4 ,this is reflected generally in the ,roman priesthood1 but especially in the ceremonial surrounding the flamen ,dialis1 the priest of ,iuppiter4 ,he must appear always in festival garb1 fire may never be taken from his hearth but for sacred purposes1 no other person may ever sleep in his bed1 the cuttings of his hair and nails must be preserved and buried beneath an arbor felix--no doubt a magic charm for fertility--he must not eat or even mention a goat or a bean1 or other objects of an unlucky character4 #b4 ,worship of ,natural ,objects4--,a very common feature in the early development of religious consciousness is the worship of natural objects--in the first place of the objects themselves and no more1 but later of a spirit indwelling in them4 ,the distinction is no doubt in individual cases a difficult one to make1 and we find that among the ,romans the earlier worship of the object tends to give way to the cult of the inhabiting spirit1 but examples may be found which seem to belong to the earlier stage4 ,we have1 for instance1 the sacred stone 7silex7 which was preserved in the temple of ,iuppiter on the ,capitol1 and was brought out to play a prominent part in the ceremony of treaty-making4 ,the fetial1 who on that occasion represented the ,roman people1 at the solemn moment of the oath-taking1 struck the sacrificial pig with the silex1 saying as he did so1 ',do thou1 ,diespiter1 strike the ,roman people as ,i strike this pig here to-day1 and strike them the more1 as thou art greater and stronger4' ,here no doubt the underlying notion is not merely symbolical1 but in origin the stone is itself the god1 an idea which later religion expressed in the cult-title specially used in this connection1 ,iuppiter ,lapis4 ,so again1 in all probability1 the termini or boundary-stones between properties are in origin the objects--though later only the site--of a yearly ritual at the festival of the ,terminalia on ,february the #bcrd1 and they are1 as it were1 summed up in 'the god ,terminus1' the great sacred boundary-stone1 which had its own shrine within the ,capitoline temple1 because1 according to the legend1 'the god' refused to budge even to make room for ,iuppiter4 ,the same notion is most likely at the root of the two great domestic cults of ,vesta1 'the hearth1' and ,ianus1 'the door1' though a more spiritual idea was soon associated with them2 we may notice too in this connection the worship of springs1 summed up in the subsequent deity ,fons1 and of rivers1 such as ,volturnus1 the cult-name of the ,tiber4 #c4 ,worship of ,trees4--,but most conspicuous among the cults of natural objects1 as in so many primitive religions1 is the worship of trees4 ,here1 though doubtless at first the tree was itself the object of veneration1 surviving instances seem rather to belong to the later period when it was regarded as the abode of the spirit4 ,we may recognise a case of this sort in the ficus ,ruminalis1 once the recipient of worship1 though later legend1 which preferred to find an historical or mythical explanation of cults1 looked upon it as sacred because it was the scene of the suckling of ,romulus and ,remus by the wolf4 ,another fig-tree with a similar history is the caprificus of the ,campus ,martius1 subsequently the site of the worship of ,iuno ,caprotina4 ,a more significant case is the sacred oak of ,iuppiter ,feretrius on the ,capitol1 on which the spolia opima were hung after the triumph--probably in early times a dedication of the booty to the spirit inhabiting the tree4 ,outside ,rome1 showing the same ideas at work among neighbouring peoples1 was the 'golden bough' in the grove of ,diana at ,aricia4 ,nor was it only special trees which were thus regarded as the home of a deity2 the tree in general is sacred1 and any one may chance to be inhabited by a spirit4 ,the feeling of the country population on this point comes out clearly in the prayer which ,cato recommends his farmer to use before making a clearing in a wood3 ',be thou god or goddess1 to whom this grove is sacred1 be it granted to us to make propitiatory sacrifice to thee with a pig for the clearing of this sacred spot'2 here we have a clear instance of the tree regarded as the dwelling of the sacred power1 and it is interesting to compare the many similar examples which#b ,dr4 ,frazer has collected from different parts of the world4 #d4 ,worship of ,animals4--,of the worship of animals we have comparatively little evidence in ,roman religion1 though we may perhaps detect it in a portion of the mysterious ritual of the ,lupercalia1 where the ,luperci dressed themselves in the skins of the sacrificed goats and smeared their faces with the blood1 thus symbolically trying to bring themselves into communion with the sacred animal4 ,we may recognise it too in the association of particular animals with divinities1 such as the sacred wolf and woodpecker of ,mars1 but on the whole we may doubt whether the worship of animals ever played so prominent a part in ,roman religion as the cult of other natural objects4 #e4 ,animism4--,such are some of the survivals of very early stages of religious custom which still kept their place in the developed religion of ,rome1 but by far the most important element in it1 which might indeed be described as its 'immediate antecedent1' is the state of religious feeling to which anthropologists have given the name of ',animism4' ,as far as we can follow the development of early religions1 this attitude of mind seems to be the direct outcome of the failure of magic4 ,primitive man begins to see that neither he nor his magicians really possess that occult control over the forces of nature which was the supposed basis of magic3 the charm fails1 the spell does not produce the rain and when he looks for the cause1 he can only argue that these things must be in the hands of some power higher than his own4 ,the world then and its various familiar objects become for him peopled with spirits1 like in character to men1 but more powerful1 and his success in life and its various operations depends on the degree in which he is able to propitiate these spirits and secure their co-operation4 ,if he desires rain1 he must win the favour of the spirit who controls it1 if he would fell a tree and suffer no harm1 he must by suitable offerings entice the indwelling spirit to leave it4 ,his 'theology' in this stage is the knowledge of the various spirits and their dwellings1 his ritual the due performance of sacrifice for purposes of propitiation and expiation4 ,it was in this state of religious feeling that the ancestors of ,rome must have lived before they founded their agricultural settlement on the ,palatine3 we must try now to see how far it had retained this character and what developments it had undergone when it had crystallised into the ',religion of ,numa4' ,,footnotes3 #a ,frazer1 ,golden ,bough1 vol4 i4 pp4 #ha ff4 #b ,golden ,bough1 vol4 i4 pp4 #aha-ahe4 ,,chapter ,,iii ,,main ,,features ,,of ,,the ,,religion ,,of ,,numa #a4 ,theology4--,the characteristic appellation of a divine spirit in the oldest stratum of the ,roman religion is not deus1 a god1 but rather numen1 a power3 he becomes deus when he obtains a name1 and so is on the way to acquiring a definite personality1 but in origin he is simply the 'spirit' of the 'animistic' period1 and retains something of the spirit's characteristics4 ,thus among the divinities of the household we shall see later that the ,genius and even the ,lar ,familiaris1 though they attained great dignity of conception1 and were the centre of the family life1 and to some extent of the family morality1 never quite rose to the position of full-grown gods2 while among the spirits of the field the wildness and impishness of character associated with ,faunus and his companion ,inuus--almost the cobolds or hobgoblins of the flocks--reflects clearly the old 'animistic' belief in the natural evilness of the spirits and their hostility to men4 ,the notion of the numen is always vague and indefinite3 even its sex may be uncertain4 ',be thou god or goddess' is the form of address in the farmer's prayer already quoted from ,cato3 'be it male or female' is the constant formula in liturgies and even dedicatory inscriptions of a much later period4 ,these spirits are1 as we have seen1 indwellers in the objects of nature and controllers of the phenomena of nature3 but to the ,roman they were more4 ,not merely did they inhabit places and things1 but they presided over each phase of natural development1 each state or action in the life of man4 ,varro1 for instance1 gives us a list of the deities concerned in the early life of the child1 which1 though it bears the marks of priestly elaboration1 may yet be taken as typical of the feeling of the normal ,roman family4 ,there is ,vaticanus1 who opens the child's mouth to cry1 ,cunina1 who guards his cradle1 ,edulia and ,potina1 who teach him to eat and drink1 ,statilinus1 who helps him to stand up1 ,adeona and ,abeona1 who watch over his first footstep1 and many others each with his special province of protection or assistance4 ,the farmer similarly is in the hands of a whole host of divinities who assist him at each stage of ploughing1 hoeing1 sowing1 reaping1 and so forth4 ,if the numen then lacks personal individuality1 he has a very distinct specialisation of function1 and if man's appeal to the divinity is to be successful1 he must be very careful to make it in the right quarter3 it was a stock joke in ,roman comedy to make a character 'ask for water from ,liber1 or wine from the nymphs4' ,hence we find in the prayer formulae in ,cato and elsewhere the most careful precautions to prevent the accidental omission of the deity concerned3 usually the worshipper will go through the whole list of the gods who may be thought to have power in the special circumstances2 sometimes he will conclude his prayer with the formula 'whosoever thou art1' or 'and any other name by which thou mayest desire to be called4' ,the numen is thus vague in his conception but specialised in his function1 and so later on1 when certain deities have acquired definite names and become prominent above the rest1 the worshipper in appealing to them will add a cult-title1 to indicate the special character in which he wishes the deity to hear3 the woman in childbirth will appeal to ,iuno ,lucina1 the general praying for victory to ,iuppiter ,victor1 the man who is taking an oath to ,iuppiter as the deus ,fidius4 ,as a still later development the cult-title will1 as it were1 break off and set up for itself1 usually in the form of an abstract personification3 ,iuppiter1 in the two special capacities just noted1 gives birth to ,victoria and ,fides4 ,the conception of the numen being so formless and indefinite1 it is not surprising that in the genuine ,roman religion there should have been no anthropomorphic representations of the divinity at all4 ',for #agj years1' ,varro tells us1 taking his date from the traditional foundation of the city in #ged ,b4,c41 'the ,romans worshipped their gods without images1' and he adds the characteristic comment1 'those who introduced representations among the nations1 took away fear and brought in falsehood4' ,symbols of a few deities were no doubt recognised3 we have noticed already the silex of ,iuppiter and the boundary-stone of ,terminus1 which were probably at an earlier period themselves objects of worship1 and to these we may add the sacred spears of ,mars1 and the sigilla of the ,state-,penates4 ,but for the most part the numina were without even such symbolic representation1 nor till about the end of the regal period was any form of temple built for them to dwell in4 ,the sacred fire of ,vesta near the ,forum was1 it is true1 from the earliest times enclosed in a building2 this1 however1 was no temple1 but merely an erection with the essentially practical purpose of preventing the extinction of the fire by rain4 ,the first temple in the full sense of the word was according to tradition built by ,servius ,tullius to ,diana on the ,aventine3 the tradition is significant1 for ,diana was not one of the di indigetes1 the old deities of the ',religion of ,numa1' but was introduced from the neighbouring town of ,aricia1 and the attribution to ,servius ,tullius nearly always denotes an ,etruscan#c or at any rate a non-,roman origin4 ,there were1 however1 altars in special places to particular deities1 built sometimes of stone1 sometimes in a more homely manner of earth or sods4 ,we hear for instance of the altar of ,mars in the ,campus ,martius1 of ,quirinus on the ,quirinal1 of ,saturnus at the foot of the ,capitol1 and notably of the curious underground altar of ,consus on what was later the site of the ,circus ,maximus4 ,but more characteristic than the erection of altars is the connection of deities with special localities4 ,naturally enough in the worship of the household ,vesta had her seat at the hearth1 ,ianus at the door1 and the 'gods of the storehouse' 7,penates7 at the cupboard by the hearth1 but the same idea appears too in the state-cult4 ,hilltops1 groves1 and especially clearings in groves 7luci7 are the most usual sacred localities4 ,thus ,quirinus has his own sacred hill1 ,iuppiter is worshipped on the ,capitol1 ,vesta and ,iuno ,lucina have their sacred groves within the boundaries of the city1 and ,dea ,dia1 ,robigus1 and ,furrina similar groves at the limits of ,roman territory4 ,the record of almost every ,roman cult reveals the importance of locality in connection with the di indigetes1 and the localities are usually such as would be naturally chosen by a pastoral and agricultural people4 ,such were roughly the main outlines of the genuine ,roman 'theology4' ,it has no gods of human form with human relations to one another1 interested in the life of men and capable of the deepest passions of hatred and affection towards them1 such as we meet1 for instance1 in the mythology of ,greece1 but only these impersonal individualities1 if we may so call them1 capable of no relation to one another1 but able to bring good or ill to men1 localised usually in their habitations1 but requiring no artificial dwelling or elaborate adornment of their abode2 becoming gradually more and more specialised in function1 yet gaining thereby no more real protective care for their worshippers--a cold and heartless hierarchy1 ready to exact their due1 but incapable of inspiring devotion or enthusiasm4 ,let us ask next how the ,romans conceived of their own relations towards them4 #b4 ,the ,relation of ,gods and ,men4--,the character of the ,roman was essentially practical and his natural mental attitude that of the lawyer4 ,and so in his relation towards the divine beings whom he worshipped there was little of sentiment or affection3 all must be regulated by clearly understood principles and carried out with formal exactness4 ,hence the ius sacrum1 the body of rights and duties in the matter of religion1 is regarded as a department of the ius publicum1 the fundamental constitution of the state1 and it is significant1 as ,marquardt has observed1 that it was ,numa1 a king and lawgiver1 and not a prophet or a poet1 who was looked upon as the founder of the ,roman religion4 ,starting from the simple general feeling of a dependence on a higher power 7religio71 which is common to all religions1 the ,roman gives it his own characteristic colour when he conceives of that dependence as analogous to a civil contract between man and god4 ,both sides are under obligation to fulfil their part3 if a god answers a man's prayer1 he must be repaid by a thank-offering3 if the man has fulfilled 'his bounden duty and service1' the god must make his return3 if he does not1 either the cause lies in an unconscious failure on the human side to carry out the exact letter of the law1 or else1 if the god has really broken his contract1 he has1 as it were1 put himself out of court and the man may seek aid elsewhere4 ,in this notion we have the secret of ,rome's readiness under stress of circumstances1 when all appeals to the old gods have failed1 to adopt foreign deities and cults in the hope of a greater measure of success4 ,the contract-notion may perhaps appear more clearly if we consider one or two of the normal religious acts of the ,roman individual or state4 ,take first of all the performance of the regular sacrifices or acts of worship ordained by the state-calendar or the celebration of the household sacra4 ,the pietas of man consists in their due fulfilment1 but he may through negligence omit them or make a mistake in the ritual to be employed4 ,in that case the gods1 as it were1 have the upper hand in the contract and are not obliged to fulfil their share1 but the man can set himself right again by the offering of a piaculum1 which may take the form either of an additional sacrifice or a repetition of the original rite4 ,so1 for instance1 when ,cato is giving his farmer directions for the lustration of his fields1 he supplies him at the end with two significant formulae3 'if1' he says1 'you have failed in any respect with regard to all your offerings1 use this formula3 ,father ,mars1 if thou hast not found satisfaction in my former offering of pig1 sheep1 and ox 7the most solemn combination in rustic sacrifices71 then let this offering of pig and sheep and ox appease thee3 but if you have made a mistake in one or two only of your offerings1 then say1 ,father ,mars1 because thou hast not found satisfaction in that pig 7or whatever it may be71 let this pig appease thee4' ,on the other hand1 for intentional neglect1 there was no remedy3 the man was impius and it rested with the gods to punish him as they liked 7deorum iniuriae dis curae74 ,but apart from the regularly constituted ceremonies of religion1 there might be special occasions on which new relations would be entered into between god and man4 ,sometimes the initiative would come from man3 desiring to obtain from the gods some blessings on which he had set his heart1 he would enter into a votum1 a special contract by which he undertook to perform certain acts or make certain sacrifices1 in case of the fulfilment of his desire4 ,the whole proceeding is strictly legal3 from the moment when he makes his vow the man is voti reus1 in the same position1 that is1 as the defendant in a case whose decision is still pending2 as soon as the gods have accomplished their side of the contract he is voti damnatus1 condemned1 as it were1 to damages1 having lost his suit2 nor does he recover his independence until he has paid what he undertook3 votum reddidi lubens merito 7',i have paid my vow gladly as it was due'7 is the characteristic wording of votive inscriptions4 ,if the gods did not accomplish the wish1 the man was of course free1 and sometimes the contract would be carried so far that a time-limit for their action would be fixed by the maker of the vow3 legal exactness can hardly go further4 ,or again1 the initiative might come from the gods4 ,some marked misfortune1 an earthquake1 lightning1 a great famine1 a portentous birth1 or some such occurrence would be recognised as a prodigium1 or sign of the god's displeasure4 ,somehow or other the contract must have been broken on the human side and it was the duty of the state to see to the restoration of the pax deum1 the equilibrium of the normal relation of god and man4 ,the right proceeding in such a case was a lustratio1 a solemn cleansing of the people--or the portion of the people involved in the god's displeasure--with the double object of removing the original reason of misfortune and averting future causes of the divine anger4 ,the commercial notion is not perhaps quite so distinct here1 but the underlying legal relationship is sufficiently marked4 ,if then the question be asked whether the relation between the ,roman and his gods was friendly or unfriendly1 the correct answer would probably be that it was neither4 ,it was rather what ,aristotle in speaking of human relations describes as 'a friendship for profit'3 it is entered into because both sides hope for some advantage--it is maintained as long as both sides fulfil their obligations4 #c4 ,ceremonial4--,it has been said sometimes that the old ,roman religion was one of cult and ritual without dogma or belief4 ,as we have seen this is not in origin strictly true1 and it would be fairer to say that belief was latent rather than non-existent3 this we may see1 for instance1 from ,cicero's dialogues on the subject of religion1 where in discussion the fundamental sense of the dependence of man on the help of the gods comes clearly into view3 in the domestic worship of the family too cult was always to some extent 'tinged with emotion1' and sanctified by a belief which made it a more living and in the end a more permanent reality than the religion of the state4 ,but it is no doubt true that as the community advanced1 belief tended to sink into the background3 development took place in cult and not in theology1 so that by the end of the ,republic1 to take an example1 though the festival of the ,furrinalia was duly observed every year on the #beth of ,july1 the nature or function of the goddess ,furrina was1 as we learn from ,cicero1 a pure matter of conjecture1 and ,varro tells us that her name was known only to a few persons4 ,nor was it mere lapse of time which tended to obscure theology and exalt ceremonial3 their relative position was the immediate and natural outcome of the underlying idea of the relation of god and man4 ,devotion1 piety--in our sense of the term--and a feeling of the divine presence could not be enjoined or even encouraged by the strictly legal conception on which religion was based3 the 'contract-notion' required not a 'right spirit' but right performance4 ,and so it comes about that in all the records we have left of the old religion the salient feature which catches and retains our attention is exactness of ritual4 ,all must be performed not merely 'decently and in order1' but with the most scrupulous care alike for every detail of the ceremonial itself1 and for the surrounding circumstances4 ,the omission or misplacement of a single word in the formulae1 the slightest sign of resistance on the part of the victim1 any disorder among the bystanders1 even the accidental squeak of a mouse1 are sufficient to vitiate the whole ritual and necessitate its repetition from the very beginning4 ,one of the main functions of the ,roman priesthood was to preserve intact the tradition of formulae and ritual1 and1 when the magistrate offered sacrifice for the state1 the pontifex stood at his side and dictated 7praeire7 the formulae which he must use4 ,almost the oldest specimen of ,latin which we now possess is the song of the ,salii1 the priests of ,mars1 handed on from generation to generation and repeated with scrupulous care1 even though the priests themselves1 as ,quintilian assures us1 had not the least notion what it meant4 ,nor was it merely the words of ceremonial which were of vital importance3 other details must be attended to with equal exactness4 ,place1 as we have seen1 was an essential feature even in the conception of deity1 and it must have required all the personal influence of ,augustus and his entourage to reconcile the people of ,rome1 with the ancient home of the goddess still before their eyes1 to the second shrine of ,vesta within the limits of his palace on the ,palatine4 ,the choice of the appropriate offering again was a matter of the greatest moment and was dictated by a large number of considerations4 ,the sex of the victim must correspond to the sex of the deity to whom it is offered1 white beasts must be given to the gods of the upper world1 black victims to the deities below4 ,mars at his ,october festival must have his horse1 ,iuno ,caprotina her goat1 and ,robigus his dog1 while in the more rustic festivals such as the ,parilia1 the offering would be the simpler gift of millet-cakes and bowls of milk3 in the case of the ,bona ,dea we have the curious provision that if wine were used in the ceremonial1 it must1 as she was in origin a pastoral deity1 always be spoken of as 'milk4' ,the persons who might be present in the various festivals were also rigidly determined3 men were excluded from the ,matronalia on ,march #a1 from the ,vestalia on the #ith of ,june1 and from the night festival of the ,bona ,dea3 the notorious escapade of ,clodius in #fb ,b4,c4 shows the scandal raised by a breach of this rule even at the period when religious enthusiasm was at its lowest ebb4 ,slaves were specifically admitted to a share in certain festivals such as the ,saturnalia and the ,compitalia 7the festival of the ,lares71 whereas at the ,matralia 7the festival of the matrons7 a female slave was brought in with the express purpose of being significantly driven away4 ,the general notion of the exactness of ritual will perhaps become clearer when we come to examine some of the festivals in detail1 but it is of extreme importance for the understanding of the ,roman religious attitude1 to think of it from the first as an essential part in the expression of the relation of man to god4 #d4 ,directness of ,relation--,functions of ,priests4--,in contrast to all this precision of ritual1 which tends almost to alienate humanity from deity1 we may turn to another hardly less prominent feature of the ,roman religion--the immediateness of relation between the god and his worshippers4 ,not only may the individual at any time approach the altar of the god with his prayer or thank-offering1 but in every community of persons its religious representative is its natural head4 ,in the family the head of the household 7pater familias7 is also the priest and he is responsible for conducting the religious worship of the whole house1 free and slave alike3 to his wife and daughters he leaves the ceremonial connected with the hearth 7,vesta7 and the deities of the store-cupboard 7,penates71 and to his bailiff the sacrifice to the powers who protect his fields 7,lares71 but the other acts of worship at home and in the fields he conducts himself1 and his sons act as his acolytes4 ,once a year he meets with his neighbours at the boundaries of their properties and celebrates the common worship over the boundary-stones4 ,so in#d the larger outgrowth of the family1 the gens1 which consisted of all persons with the same surname 7nomen1 not cognomen71 the gentile sacra are in the hands of the more wealthy members who are regarded as its heads2 we have the curious instance of ,clodius even after his adoption into another family1 providing for the worship of the gens ,clodia in his own house1 and we may remember ,virgil's picture of the founders of the gentes of the ,potitii and the ,pinarii performing the sacrifice to ,hercules at the ara maxima1 which was the traditional privilege of their houses4 ,when societies 7sodalitates7 are formed for religious purposes they elect their own magistri to be their religious representatives1 as we see in the case of the ,salii and the ,luperci4 ,finally1 in the great community of the state the king is priest1 and with that exactness of parallelism of which the ,roman was so fond1 he--like the pater familias--leaves the worship of ,vesta in the hands of his 'daughters1' the ,vestal virgins4 ,and so1 when the ,republic is instituted1 a special official1 the rex sacrorum1 inherits the king's ritual duties1 while the superintendence of the ,vestals passes to his representative in the matter of religious law1 the pontifex maximus1 whose official residence is always the regia1 ,numa's palace4 ,the state is but the enlarged household and the head of the state is its religious representative4 ,if then the approach to the gods is so direct1 where1 it may be asked1 in the organisation of ,roman religion is there room for the priest8 ,two points about the ,roman priesthood are of paramount importance4 ,in the first place1 they are not a caste apart3 though there were restrictions as to the holding of secular magistracies in combination with the priesthood--always observed strictly in the case of the rex sacrorum and with few exceptions in the case of the greater flamines--yet the pontifices might always take their part in public life1 and no kind of barrier existed between them and the rest of the community3 ,iulius ,caesar himself was pontifex maximus4 ,in the second place they are not regarded as representatives of the gods or as mediators between god and man1 but simply as administrative officials appointed for the performance of the acts of state-worship1 just as the magistrates were for its civil and military government4 ,in origin they were chosen to assist the king in the multifarious duties of the state-cult--the flamines were to act as special priests of particular deities1 the most prominent among them being the three great priests of ,iuppiter 7flamen ,dialis71 ,mars1 and ,quirinus2 the pontifices were sometimes delegates of the king on special occasions1 but more particularly formed his religious consilium1 a consulting body1 to give him advice as to ritual and act as the repositories of tradition4 ,in later times the flamines still retain their original character1 the pontifices and especially the pontifex maximus are responsible for the whole organisation of the state-religion and are the guardians and interpreters of religious lore4 ,in the state-cult then the priests play a very important part1 but their relation to the worship of the individual was very small indeed4 ,they had a general superintendence over private worship and their leave would be required for the introduction of any new domestic cult2 in cases too where the private person was in doubt as to ritual or the legitimacy of any religious practice1 he could appeal to the pontifices for decision4 ,otherwise the priest could never intervene in the worship of the family1 except in the case of the most solemn form of marriage 7confarreatio71 which1 as it conferred on the children the right to hold certain of the priesthoods1 was regarded itself as a ceremony of the state-religion4 ,in his private worship then the individual had immediate access to the deity1 and it was no doubt this absence of priestly mediation and the consequent sense of personal responsibility1 no less than its emotional significance1 which caused the greater reality and permanence of the domestic worship as compared with the organised and official cults of the state4 ,,footnotes3 #c ,etruscan builders were according to tradition employed on the earliest ,roman temples4 #d ,this is all open to doubt1 but see ,de ,marchi1 ,il ,culto ,privato1 vol4 ii4 ,,chapter ,,iv ,,early ,,history ,,of ,,rome--,,the ,,agricultural ,,community ,after this sketch of the main features which we must expect to find in ,roman religion1 we may attempt to look a little more in detail at its various departments1 but before doing so it is necessary to form some notion of the situation and character of the ,roman community3 religion is not a little determined by men's natural surroundings and occupations4 ,the subject is naturally one of considerable controversy1 but certain facts of great significance for our purpose may fairly be taken as established4 ,the earliest settlement which can be called ',rome' was the community of the ,palatine hill1 which rises out of the valleys more abruptly than any of the other hills and was the natural place to be selected for fortification3 the outline of the walls and sacred enclosure running outside them 7pomoerium7 may still be traced1 marking the limits of 'square ,rome' 7,roma quadrata71 as the historians called it4 ,the ,palatine community no doubt pursued their agricultural labours over the neighbouring valleys and hills1 and gradually began to extend their settlement till it included the ,esquiline and ,caelian and other lesser heights which made up the ,septimontium--the next stage of ,rome's development4 ,meanwhile a kindred settlement had been established on the opposite hills of the ,quirinal and ,viminal1 and ultimately the two communities united1 enclosing within their boundaries the ,capitol and their meeting-place in the valley which separated them--the ,forum4 ,in this way was formed the ,rome of the ,four ,regions1 which represents the utmost extent of its development during the period which gave rise to the genuine ,roman religion4 ,all these stages have left their mark on the customs of religion4 ,roma quadrata comes to the fore in the ,lupercalia3 not merely is the site of the ceremony a grotto on the ,palatine 7,lupercal71 but when the ,luperci run their purificatory course around the boundaries1 it is the circuit of the ,palatine hill which marks its limits4 ,annually on the #aath of ,december the festival of the ,septimontium was celebrated1 not by the whole people1 but by the montani1 presumably the inhabitants of those parts of ,rome which were included in the second settlement4 ,finally1 the addition of the ,quirinal settlement is marked by the inclusion among the great state-gods of ,quirinus1 who must have been previously the local deity of the ,quirinal community4 ,but more important for us than the history of the early settlement is its character4 ,we have spoken of early ,rome as an agricultural community3 it would be more exact and more helpful to describe it as a community of agricultural households4 ,the institutions of ,rome1 legal as well as religious1 all point to the household 7familia7 as the original unit of organisation3 the individual1 as such1 counted for nothing1 the community was but the aggregate of families4 ,domestic worship then was not merely independent of the religion of the community3 it was prior to it1 and is both its historical and logical origin4 ,yet the life of the early ,roman agriculturalist could not be confined to the household3 in the tilling of the fields and the care of his cattle he meets his neighbour1 and common interests suggest common prayer and thanksgiving4 ,thus there sprung up the great series of agricultural festivals which form the basis of the state-calendar1 but were in origin--as some of them still continued to be--the independent acts of worship of groups of agricultural households4 ,gradually1 as the community grew on the lines we have just seen1 there grew with it a sense of an organised state1 as something more than the casual aggregation of households or clans 7gentes74 ,as the feeling of union became stronger1 so did the necessity for common worship of the gods1 and the state-cult came into being primarily as the repetition on behalf of the community as a whole of the worship which its members performed separately in their households or as joint-worshippers in the fields4 ,but the conception of a state must carry with it at least two ideas over and beyond the common needs of its members3 there must be internal organisation to secure domestic tranquillity1 and--since there will be collision with other states--external organisation for purposes of offence and defence4 ,religion follows the new ideas1 and in two of the older deities of the fields develops the notions of justice and war4 ,organisation ensues1 and the general conceptions of state-deities and state-ritual are made more definite and precise4 ,it will be at once natural and convenient that we should consider these three departments of religion in the order that has just been suggested--the worship of the household1 the worship of the fields1 the worship of the state4 ,but it must not be forgotten that both the departments themselves and the evidence for them frequently overlap4 ,the domestic worship is not wholly distinguishable from that of the fields1 the state-cult is1 as we have seen1 very largely a replica of the other two4 ,the evidence for the domestic and agricultural cults is in itself very scanty1 and we shall frequently have to draw inferences from their counterparts in the state4 ,above all1 it is not to be supposed that any hard and fast line between the three existed in the ,roman's mind2 but for the purposes of analysis the distinction is valuable and represents a historical reality4 ,,chapter ,v ,,worship ,,of ,,the ,,household #a4 ,the ,deities4--,the worship of the household seems to have originated1 as has been suggested1 in the sense of the sacredness of certain objects closely bound up with the family life--the door1 the protection against the external world1 by which the household went out to work in the morning and returned at evening1 the hearth1 the giver of warmth and nourishment1 and the store-cupboard1 where was preserved the food for future use4 ,at first1 in all probability1 the worship was actually of the objects themselves1 but by the time that ,rome can be said to have existed at all1 'animism' had undoubtedly transformed it into a veneration of the indwelling spirits1 ,ianus1 ,vesta1 and the ,penates4 ,of the domestic worship of ,ianus no information has come down to us1 but we may well suppose that as the defence of the door and its main use lay with the men of the household1 so they1 under the control of the pater familias1 were responsible for the cult of its spirit4 ,vesta was1 of course1 worshipped at the hearth by the women1 who most often used it in the preparation of the domestic meals4 ,in the original round hut1 such as the primitive ,roman dwelt in--witness the models which he buried with his dead and which recent excavations in the ,forum have brought to light--the 'blazing hearth' 7such seems to be the meaning of ,vesta7 would be the most conspicuously sacred thing2 it is therefore not surprising to find that her simple cult was the most persistent of all throughout the history of ,rome1 and did not vary from its original notion4 ,even ,ovid can tell the inquirer 'think not ,vesta to be ought else than living flame1' and again1 ',vesta and fire require no effigy'--notions in which he has come curiously near to the conceptions of the earliest religion4 ,the ,penates in the same way were at first 'the spirits'--whoever they might be--who preserved and increased the store in the cupboard4 ,then as the conception of individual deities became clearer1 they were identified with some one or other of the gods of the country or the state1 among whom the individual householder would select those who should be the particular ,penates of his family3 ,ceres1 ,iuno1 ,iuppiter1 ,pales would be some of those chosen in the earlier period4 ,nor are we to suppose that selection was merely arbitrary3 the tradition of family and clan1 even possibly of locality1 would determine the choice1 much as the patron-saints of a church are now determined in a ,roman ,catholic country4 ,two other deities are very prominent in the worship of the early household1 and each is a characteristic product of ,roman religious feeling1 the ,lar ,familiaris and the ,genius4 ,the ,lares#e seem to have been in origin the spirits of the family fields3 they were worshipped1 as ,cicero tells us1 'on the farm in sight of the house1' and they had their annual festival in the ,compitalia1 celebrated at the compita--places where two or more properties marched4 ,but one of these spirits1 the ,lar ,familiaris1 had special charge of the house and household1 and as such was worshipped with the other domestic gods at the hearth4 ,as his protection extended over all the household1 including the slaves1 his cult is placed specially in the charge of the bailiff's wife 7vilica74 ,he is regularly worshipped at the great divisions of the month on ,calends1 ,nones1 and ,ides1 but he has also an intimate and beautiful connection with the domestic history of the family4 ,an offering is made to the ,lar on the occasion of a birth1 a wedding1 a departure1 or a return1 and even--a characteristically ,roman addition--on the occasion of the first utterance of a word by a son of the house3 finally1 a particularly solemn sacrifice is made to him after a death in the family4 ,the ,genius is perhaps the most difficult conception in the ,roman religion for the modern mind to grasp4 ,it has been spoken of as the 'patron-saint' or 'guardian-angel1' both of them conceptions akin to that of the ,genius1 but both far too definite and anthropomorphic3 we shall understand it best by keeping the 'numen' notion clearly in mind and looking to the root-meaning of the word 7genius connected with the root of gignere1 to beget74 ,it was after all only a natural development of the notions of 'animism' to imagine that man too1 like other objects1 had his indwelling spirit--not his 'soul' either in our sense of moral and intellectual powers1 or in the ancient sense of the vital principle--but rather as the derivation suggests1 in origin simply the spirit which gave him the power of generation4 ,hence in the house1 the sphere of the ,genius is no longer the hearth but the marriage-bed 7lectus genialis74 ,this notion growing somewhat wider1 the ,genius comes to denote all the full powers1 almost the personality1 of developed manhood1 and especially those powers which make for pleasure and happiness3 this is the origin of such common phrases as genium curare1 genio indulgere1 meaning practically to 'look after oneself1' 'to indulge oneself4' ,every man1 then1 has this 'spirit of his manhood' in his ,genius1 and correspondingly every woman her ,iuno1 or spirit of womanhood1 which are worshipped on the birthdays of their owners4 ,no doubt later the ,genius was accredited with powers over the fortune and misfortune of his possessor1 but he never really developed anything like the independence of a god1 and remained always rather a numen4 ,the individual revered his own ,genius1 but the household cult was concerned1 as one would expect1 with the ,genius of the master of the house1 the pre-eminent ,genius of the family4 ,its special locality was1 for the reason just noticed1 the marriage-bed and its symbol1 the house-snake1 kept as a revered inmate and cherished in the feeling that evil happening to it meant misfortune to the master4 ,the festival of the ,genius was naturally the master's birthday1 and on that day slaves and freedmen kept holiday with the family and brought offerings to the ,genius domus4 ,it is a significant fact1 and may serve to bring out the underlying notion1 that in later paintings1 when anthropomorphism and sensuous representation held sway over all ,roman religion1 though the other gods of the household were depicted after the manner of ,greek deities1 the ,genius is either represented by his symbolic snake or appears with the human features and characteristics of the head of the house1 his owner4 ,the spirit-gods then of the door and the hearth1 the specially chosen deities of the store-cupboard1 the particular field-power presiding over the household1 and the spirit of the master's personality were the gods of the early home1 and round their worship centred the domestic religion4 ,we must attempt to see what was its relation to family life4 #b4 ,religion and the ,family ,life4--,we have already noticed the main occasions of regular sacrifice to the deities of the household1 the offerings to the ,lar on ,calends1 ,nones1 and ,ides1 to the ,genius on the master's birthday1 and so on1 and we are enabled to form a fair picture of the rites from paintings which1 although of later date1 undoubtedly represent the continuous tradition of domestic custom4 ,in a wall-painting at ,herculaneum1 for instance1 we have a picture of the pater familias1 represented with veiled head 7according to regular ,roman custom7 and the cornucopia of the ,genius1 making sacrifice at a round altar or hearth4 ,opposite him stands the flute-player 7tibicen7 playing to drown any unpropitious sound1 while on either side are two smaller figures1 presumably the sons1 acting as attendants 7camilli71 and both clad 7succincti7 in the short sacrificial tunic 7limus72 one carries in his left hand the sacred dish 7patera71 and in his right garlands or1 more probably1 ribbons for the decoration of the victim3 the other is acting as victimarius and bringing the pig for sacrifice1 but the animal is hurrying with almost excessive eagerness towards the altar1 no doubt to show that there is none of the reluctance which would have been sufficient to vitiate the sacrifice4 ,but from our point of view such formal acts of worship are of less importance than the part played by religion in the daily life of the household4 ,there is evidence both for earlier and later periods that the really 'pious' would begin their day with prayer and sacrifice to the household gods1 and like ,virgil's ,aeneas1 typically pius in all the meanings of the word1 would 'rouse the slumbering flame upon the altar and gladly approach again the ,lar and little ,penates whom he worshipped yesterday4' ,but this was perhaps exceptional devotion1 and the daily worship in the normal household centred rather round the family meal4 ,in the old and simple house the table would be placed at the side of the hearth1 and1 as the household sat round it1 master and man together1 a part of the meal1 set aside on a special sacred dish 7patella71 would be thrown into the flames as the gods' portion4 ,sometimes incense might be added1 and later a libation of wine3 when images had become common1 the little statuettes of ,lares and ,penates would be fetched from the shrine 7lararium7 and placed upon the table in token of their presence at the meal4 ,even in the luxurious1 many-roomed house of the imperial epoch1 when the dining-table was far from the kitchen-hearth1 a pause was made in the meal and an offering sent out to the household-gods1 nor would the banquet proceed until the slave had returned and announced that the gods were favourable 7deos propitios73 so persistent was this tradition of domestic piety4 ,prayer might be made at this point on special occasions to special deities1 as1 for instance1 before the beginning of the sowing of the crops1 appeal was made to ,iuppiter1 and a special portion of the meal 7daps7 was set aside for him4 ,the sanctification of the one occasion when the whole household met in the day cannot fail to have had its effect on the domestic life1 and1 even if it was no direct incentive to morality1 it yet bound the family together in a sense of dependence on a higher power for the supply of their daily needs4 ,we observed incidentally how the small events of domestic life were given their religious significance1 particularly in connection with the worship of ,lar and ,genius1 but to complete the sketch of domestic religion1 we must examine a little more closely its relation to the process of life1 and especially to the two important occasions of birth and marriage4 ,in no department of life is the specialisation of function among the numina more conspicuous than in connection with birth and childhood4 ,apart from the general protection of ,iuno ,lucina1 the prominent divinity of childbirth1 we can count in the records that have come down to us some twenty subordinate spirits1 who from the moment of conception to the moment of birth watched1 each in its own particular sphere1 over the mother and the unborn child4 ,as soon as the birth had taken place began a series of ceremonies1 which are of particular interest1 as they seem to belong to a very early stage of religious thought1 and have a markedly rustic character4 ,immediately a sacred meal was offered to the two field-deities1 ,picumnus and ,pilumnus1 and then the ,roman turned his attention to the practical danger of fever for the mother and child4 ,at night three men gathered round the threshold1 one armed with an axe1 another with a stake1 and a third with a broom3 the two first struck the threshold with their implements1 the third swept out the floor4 ,over this ceremony were said to preside three numina1 ,intercidona 7connected with the axe71 ,pilumnus 7connected with the stake1 pilum71 and ,deverra 7connected with the act of sweeping74 ,its object was1 as ,varro explains it1 to avert the entrance of the half-wild ,silvanus by giving three unmistakeable signs of human civilisation2 we shall probably not be wrong in seeing in it rather an actual hacking1 beating1 and sweeping away of evil spirits4 ,on the ninth day after birth1 in the case of a boy1 on the eighth in the case of a girl1 occurred the festival of the naming 7solemnitas nominalium74 ,the ceremony was one of purification 7dies lustricus is its alternative title71 and a piacular offering was made to preserve the child from evil influences in the future4 ,friends brought presents1 especially neck-bands in the form of a half-moon 7lunulae71 and the golden balls 7bullae7 which were worn as a charm round the neck until the attainment of manhood4 ,of the numerous petty divinities which watched over the child's early years we have already given some account4 ,in their protection he remained until he arrived at puberty1 about the age of seventeen1 when with due religious ceremony he entered on his manhood4 ,at home1 on the morning of the festival1 he solemnly laid aside the bulla and the purple-striped garb of childhood 7toga praetexta7 before the shrine of the household gods1 and made them a thank-offering for their protection in the past4 ,afterwards1 accompanied by his father and friends and clad now in the toga virilis1 he went solemnly to the ,capitol1 and1 after placing a contribution in the coffers of ,iuventas--or probably in earlier times of ,iuppiter ,iuventus--made an offering to the supreme deity ,iuppiter ,capitolinus4 ,the sacred character of the early years of a young ,roman's life could hardly be more closely marked4 ,though confarreatio was the only essentially religious form of marriage1 and was sanctified by the presence of the pontifex maximus and the flamen ,dialis1 yet marriage even in the less religious ceremony of coemptio was always a sacrum4 ,it must not take place on the days of state-festivals 7feriae71 nor on certain other dies religiosi1 such as those of the ,vestalia or the feast of the dead 7,parentalia74 ,both the marriage itself and the preliminary betrothal 7sponsalia7 had to receive the divine sanction by means of auspices1 and in the ceremonies of both rites the religious element1 though bound up with superstition and folk-customs1 emerges clearly enough4 ,the central ceremony of the confarreatio was an act partly of sacrifice1 partly1 one might almost say1 of communion4 ,the bride and bridegroom sat on two chairs united to one another and covered with a lambskin1 they offered to ,iuppiter bloodless offerings of a rustic character 7fruges et molam salsam71 they employed in the sacrifice the fundamental household necessaries1 water1 fire1 and salt1 and themselves ate of the sacred spelt-cake 7libus farreus71 from which the ceremony derived its name4 ,the crucial point in the more civil ceremony of coemptio was the purely human and legal act of the joining of hands 7dextrarum iunctio71 but it was immediately followed by the sacrifice of a victim1 which gave the ceremony a markedly religious significance4 ,the customs connected with the bringing of the bride to the bridegroom's house--so beautifully depicted in ,catullus' ,epithalamium--her forcible abduction from her parents1 the ribaldry of the bridegroom's companions1 the throwing of nuts as a symbol of fecundity1 the carrying of the bride over the threshold1 a relic probably of primitive marriage by capture1 the untying of the bridal knot on the bridal couch--are perhaps more akin to superstition than religion1 but we may notice two points in the proceedings4 ,firstly1 the three coins 7asses7 which the bride brought with her1 one to give to her husband as a token of dowry1 one to be offered at the hearth to her new ,lar ,familiaris1 one to be offered subsequently at the nearest compitum 7a clear sign of connection between the household ,lar and those of the fields72 and secondly1 an echo of the feature so marked all through domestic life1 the crowd of little numina1 who took their part in assisting the ceremony4 ,there was ,domiduca1 who brought the bride to the bridegroom's house1 ,iterduca1 who looked after her on the transit1 ,unxia1 who anointed her1 ,cinxia1 who bound and unbound her girdle1 and many others4 ,this sketch of the household worship of the ,romans will1 ,i hope1 have justified my contention that there was in it an element more truly 'religious' than anything we should gather from the ceremonies of the state4 ,the ideas are simpler1 the numina seem less cold and more protective1 the worshippers more sensible of divine aid4 ,when we have looked at the companion picture of the farmer in the fields1 we shall go on to see how the worship of the agricultural household is the prototype and basis of the state-cult1 but first we must consider briefly the very difficult question of the relation of the living to the dead4 #c4 ,relation of the ,living and the ,dead4--,the worship of the spirits of dead ancestors is so common a feature in most primitive religions that it may seem strange even to doubt whether it existed among the ,romans1 but1 although the question is one of extreme difficulty1 and the evidence very insufficient1 ,i am inclined to believe that1 though the living were always conscious of their continued relation to the dead1 and sensitive of the influence of the powers of the underworld1 yet there was not1 strictly speaking1 any cult of the dead4 ,let us attempt briefly to collect the salient features in ritual1 and see to what conclusion they point as to the underlying belief4 ,one of the most remarkable facts in domestic worship is that1 whereas the moment of birth and the other great occasions of life are surrounded with religious ceremony and belief1 the moment of death passes without any trace of religious accompaniment3 it is as though the dying man went out into another world where the ceremonials of this life can no more avail him1 nor its gods protect him4 ,as to his state after death1 opinion varied at different times under different influences1 but the simple early notion1 connected especially with the practice of burial as opposed to cremation1#f was that his spirit just sank into the earth1 where it rested and returned from time to time to the upper world through certain openings in the ground 7mundi71 whose solemn uncovering was one of the regular observances of the festal calendar3 later1 no doubt1 a more spiritual notion prevailed1 though it never reached definiteness or universality4 ,one idea1 however1 seems always to be prominent1 that the happiness of the dead could be much affected by the due performance of the funeral rites2 hence it was the most solemn duty of the heir to perform the iusta for the dead1 and if he failed in any respect to carry them out1 he could only atone for his omission by the annual sacrifice of a sow 7porca praecidanea7 to ,ceres and ,tellus--to the divinities of the earth1 be it noticed1 and not to the dead themselves4 ,the actual funeral was not a religious ceremony2 a procession was formed 7originally at night7 of the family and friends1 in which the body of the dead was carried--accompanied by the busts 7imagines7 of his ancestors--to a tomb outside the town1 and was there laid in the grave4 ,the family on their return proceeded at once to rites of purification from the contamination which had overtaken them owing to the presence of a dead body4 ,two ceremonies were performed1 one for the purification of the house by the sacrifice of a sow 7porca praesentanea7 to ,ceres accompanied by a solemn sweeping out of refuse 7exverrae71 the other the lustration of their own persons by fire and water4 ,this done1 they sat down with their friends to a funeral feast 7silicernium71 which1 ,cicero tells us1 was regarded as an honour rather to the surviving members of the family than to the dead1 so that mourning was not worn4 ,two other ceremonies within the following week1 the feriae denicales and the novendiale sacrum1 brought the religious mourning to a close4 ,not that the dead were forgotten after the funeral3 year by year1 on the anniversaries of death and burial1 and on certain fixed occasions known by such suggestive titles as 'the day of roses' and 'the day of violets1' the family would revisit the tomb and make simple offerings of salt cake 7mola salsa71 of bread soaked in wine1 or garlands of flowers3 there is some trace1 on such occasions1 of prayer1 but it would seem to be rather the repetition of general religious formulae than a petition to the dead for definite blessings4 ,such are the principal features of the family ritual in relation to their dead2 but if we are to form any just notion of belief1 we must supplement them by reference to the ceremonies of the state1 which here1 as elsewhere1 are very clearly the household-cult 'writ large4' ,in the ,calendars we find two obvious celebrations in connection with the dead1 taking place at different seasons of the year1 and consisting of ceremonies markedly different in character4 ,in the gloomy month of ,february--associated with solemn lustrations--occurs the festival known popularly 7though not in the ,calendars7 as the ,parentalia or dies ,parentales1 that is1 the days of sacrifice in connection with the dead members of the family 7parentes1 parentare74 ,it begins with the note on ,february #ac1 ,virgo ,vestalis parentat1 and continues till the climax1 ,feralia1 on ,february #ba4 ,during these days the magistrates laid aside the insignia of their offices1 the temples were shut1 marriages were forbidden1 and every family carried out at the tombs of its relatives ceremonies resembling those of the sacra privata4 ,the whole season closed on ,february #bb with the festival of the ,caristia or cara cognatio1 a family reunion of the survivors in a kind of 'love-feast1' which centred in the worship of the ,lar ,familiaris4 ,here we seem to have simply1 as in the family rites1 a peaceful and solemn acknowledgment by the community as a whole of the still subsisting relation of the living and the dead4 ,on the #ith1 #aath1 and #acth of ,may occurs the ,lemuria1 a ceremony of a strikingly different order4 ,once again temples are shut and marriages forbidden1 but the ritual is of a very different nature4 ,the ,lemures or ,larvae--for there seems to be little distinction between the two names--are regarded no longer as members of the family to be welcomed back to their place1 but as hostile spirits to be exorcised4#g ,the head of the house rises from bed at midnight1 washes1 and walks barefoot through the house1 making signs for the aversion of evil spirits4 ,in his mouth he carries black beans--always a chthonic symbol--which he spits out nine times without looking round1 saying1 as he does so1 ',with these ,i redeem me and mine'3 he washes again1 and clanks brass vessels together2 nine times he repeats the formula1 'depart1 ,manes of our fathers' 7no doubt using the dignified title ,manes euphemistically71 and then finally turns round4 ,here we have in a quite unmistakeable manner the feeling of the hostility of the spirits of the dead3 they must be given their appropriate food and got out of the place as quickly as possible4 ,some scholars have attempted to explain the difference between these two festivals on the assumption that the ,parentalia represents the commemoration of the duly buried dead1 the ,lemuria the apotropaic right for the aversion of the unburied1 and therefore hostile spirits2 but ,ovid has given a far more significant hint1 when he tells us that the ,lemuria was the more ancient festival of the two4 ,so far we have had no indication of anything approaching divinity in connection with the dead or the underworld as distinct from the earth-goddesses1 but the evidence for it1 though vague and shadowy1 is not wanting4 ,certain mysterious female deities1 ,tarpeia1 ,acca ,larentia1 ,carna1 and ,laverna1 of whom late aetiological myth had its own explanation1 have1 in all probability1 been rightly interpreted by ,mommsen as divinities of the lower world3 the commemorative 'sacrifice at the tomb1' which we hear of in connection with the first two1 was in reality1 we may suppose1 an offering to a chthonic deity at a mundus4 ,a rather more tangible personality is ,vediovis1 who three times a year has his celebration 7,agonia not feriae7 in the ,calendar3 he1 as his name denotes1 must be the 'opposite of ,iove1' that is1 probably1 his chthonic counterpart1 a notion sufficiently borne out by his subsequent identification with the ,greek ,pluto4 ,finally1 of course1 there is that vague body1 the ,di ,manes1 'the good gods1' the principal deities of the world of the dead2 to them invocations are addressed1 and they have their place in the formulae of the parentalia and the opening of the mundi4#h ,in connection with them1 acting as a link with the female deities1 we have the strange goddess ,genita ,mana1 the 'spirit of birth and death4' ,controversy is acute as to the interpretation of these facts1 especially in regard to the question whether or no the spirits of the dead were actually worshipped4 ,i would hazard the following reconstruction of history as consistent with what we otherwise know of ,roman religion1 and with the evidence before us4 ,from the earliest times the ,roman looked upon his dead relations as in some sense living1 lying beneath the earth1 but capable alike of returning to the world above and of influencing in some vague way the fortunes of the living1 especially in relation to the crops which sprung from the ground in which they lay4 ,at first1 when his religion was one of fear1 he regarded the dead as normally hostile1 and their presence as something to be averted2 this is the stage which gave birth to the ,lemuria4 ,as civilisation increased1 and the sense of the unity of household and community developed1 fear1 proving ungrounded1 gave place to a kindlier feeling of the continued existence of the dead as members of household and state1 and even in some sense as an additional bond between the living3 this is the period which produced the sacra privata and the ,parentalia4 ,when the numen-feeling began to pass into that of deus1 in the first place a connection was felt between the spirits of the dead and the deities of the earth associated with the growth of the crops1 in the second the notion that the underworld must have its gods as well as the world above1 produced the shadowy female deities and ,vediovis4 ,lastly1 the same kind of feeling which added ,parentalia to ,lemuria developed the vague general notion of the ,di ,manes1 not the deified spirits of the dead1 but peaceful and on the whole kindly divinities holding sway in the world of dead spirits1 yet accessible to the prayers of the living4 ,the dead1 then1 were not themselves worshipped1 but they needed commemoration and kindly gifts1 and they had in their lower world deities to whom prayer might be made and worship given4 ,,footnotes3 #e ,it is right to state that there is a totally different theory1 according to which the ,lares were the spirits of the dead ancestors and the ,lar ,familiaris an embodiment1 as it were1 of all the family dead4 #f ,it is significant that even when the dead were cremated1 one bone was carefully preserved in order to be symbolically buried4 #g ,we may note that1 though it is a state festival1 our information is solely of rites in individual households4 #h ,their mention in sepulchral inscriptions dates from the time of the ,empire1 when a new conception of their nature had sprung up4 ,,chapter ,,vi ,,worship ,,of ,,the ,,fields ,the life of the early ,roman in the fields1 his activities1 his hopes and fears1 are reflected in the long list of agricultural festivals which constitute the greater part of the celebrations in the ,calendar1 and follow closely the seasons and occupations of the agricultural year4 ,we are1 of course1 in the ,calendar dealing1 to speak strictly1 with the worship of the state1 and not with the semi-private festivals of groups of farmers1 but in many instances1 such as the ,robigalia1 the state seems only to have taken over the cult of the farmers1 preserving carefully the site on which the celebration took place2 in others1 such as the ,terminalia and the ,parilia1 it seems to have established1 as it were1 a state-counterpart of a rite performed independently at many rustic centres3 in both cases we are justified in inferring the practice of the early ,roman agriculturalist4 ,we shall see that in most cases these festivals are associated--though often loosely enough--with the worship of a particular divinity4 ,sometimes1 however1--as in the case of the ,lupercalia--it is very difficult to discover who this divinity was2 in other festivals1 such as the ,robigalia1 it looks as if the eponymous deity was a comparatively late development4 ,we may1 therefore1 suppose1 on the analogy of what we have already seen to be the general lines of development in ,roman religion1 that the festivals in origin centred round a purpose rather than a personality1 and were addressed 'to all spirits whom it might concern'2 and that later1 when the deus notion was on the increase1 they either attached themselves to some god whose personality was already distinct1 as the ,vinalia were attached to ,iuppiter1 or 'developed' a deity of their own4 ,among these deities1 strictly functional as a rule and existing only in connection with their special festival1 we shall notice the frequent recurrence of a divinity pair1 not1 of course1 mythologically related as husband and wife1 but representing1 perhaps1 the male and female aspects of the same process of development4 ,the festivals divide themselves naturally into three groups3 those of ,spring1 expressive of the hopes and fears for the growing crops and herds2 those of ,summer1 the festivals of fulfilment1 including the celebration of harvest2 and those of ,winter1 the festivals of sowing1 of social rejoicing1 and in the later months of purificatory anticipation of the coming year4 #a4 ,festivals of ,spring4--,the old ,roman year--as may be seen clearly enough from the names of the months still known by numbers1 ,september1 ,october1 etc4--began in ,march3 according to tradition ,romulus reckoned a year of ten months altogether1 and ,numa added ,january and ,february4 ,the ,spring months properly speaking may be reckoned as ,march1 ,april1 and ,may4 ,in ,march there were in the developed ,calendar no festivals of an immediately recognisable agricultural character1 but the whole month was practically consecrated to its eponymous deity1 ,mars4 ,now1 to the ,roman of the ,republic1 ,mars was undoubtedly the deity associated with war1 and his special festivals in this month are of a warlike character3 on the #ith the priests 7,salii7 began the ancient custom of carrying his sacred shields 7ancilia7 round the town from one ordained resting-place to another3 on the #aith1 ,quinquatrus1 the shields were solemnly purified1 and on the #bcrd the same ceremony was performed with the war-trumpets3 the ,equirria 7horse-races7 of ,march #ad may have had an agricultural origin--we shall meet with races later on as a feature of rustic festivals--but they were certainly celebrated in a military manner4 ,yet there is good reason for believing that ,mars was in origin associated not with war1 but with the growth of vegetation3 he was1 as we shall see1 the chief deity addressed in the solemn lustration of the fields 7,ambarvalia71 and if our general notion of the development of religion with the growing needs of the agricultural community crystallising into a state be correct1 it may well be that a deity originally concerned with the interests of the farmer took on himself the protection of the soldier1 when the fully developed state came into collision with its neighbours4 ,if so1 we may well have in these recurring festivals of ,mars the sense1 as ,mr4 ,warde ,fowler has put it1 of 'some great numen at work1 quickening vegetation1 and calling into life the powers of reproduction in man and the animals4' ,possibly another agricultural note is struck in the ,liberalia of the #agth3 though the cult of ,liber was almost entirely overlaid by his subsequent identification with ,dionysus1 it seems right to recognise in him and his female counterpart1 ,libera1 a general spirit of creativeness4 ,the character of ,april is much more clearly marked3 the month is filled with a series of festivals--all of a clearly agricultural nature--prayers for the crops now in the earth1 and the purification of the men and animals on the farm4 ,the series opens with the ,fordicidia on the #aeth1 when pregnant cows were sacrificed3 their unborn calves were torn from them and burnt1 the ashes being kept by the ,vestal ,virgin in ,vesta's storehouse 7penus ,vestae7 for use at the ,parilia4 ,the general symbolism of fertility is very clear2 the goddess associated with the festival is ,tellus1 the earth herself1 and the local origin of these festivals is shown in the fact that not only was the sacrifice made for the whole people on the ,capitol1 but separately in each one of the curiae4 ,the ,fordicidia is closely followed by the ,cerealia on the #aith--the festival of another earth-goddess 7,ceres1 creare7--more especially connected with the growth of corn4 ,a very curious feature of the ritual was the fastening of fire-brands to the tails of foxes1 which were then let loose in what was afterwards the ,circus ,maximus3 a symbol possibly1 as ,wissowa thinks1 of sunlight1 possibly of the vegetation-spirit4 ,but the most important of the ,april ceremonies is undoubtedly the ,parilia of the #bast1 the festival of the very ancient rustic numen1 ,pales4 ,ovid's#i description of the celebration is so interesting and so full of the characteristic colour of the ,roman rustic festivals that ,i may perhaps be pardoned for reproducing it at greater length4 ',shepherd1' he says1 addressing the rustic worshipper1 'at the first streak of dawn purify thy well-fed flocks3 let water first besprinkle them1 and a branch sweep clean the ground4 ,let the folds be adorned with leaves and branches fastened to them1 while a trailing wreath covers the gay-decked gates4 ,let blue flames rise from the living sulphur and the sheep bleat loud as she feels the touch of the smoking sulphur4 ,burn the male olive-branch and the pine twig and juniper1 and let the blazing laurel crackle amid the hearth4 ,a basket full of millet must go with the millet cakes3 this is the food wherein the country goddess finds pleasure most of all4 ,give her too her own share of the feast and her pail of milk1 and when her share has been set aside1 then with milk warm from the cow make prayer to ,pales1 guardian of the woods4' ,the poet then recites a long prayer1 in which the farmer first begs forgiveness for any unwitting sins he may have committed against the rustic deities1 such as trespassing on their groves or sheltering his flocks beneath their altar1 and then prays for the aversion of disease and the prosperity of crops1 flocks1 and herds4 ',thus must the goddess be won1 this prayer say four times turning to the sunrise1 and wash thy hands in the running stream4 ,then set the rustic bowl upon the table in place of the wine-bowl1 and drink the snowy milk and dark must1 and soon through the heaps of crackling straw leap in swift course with eager limbs4' ,all the worshippers then set to leaping through the blazing fires1 even the flocks and herds were driven through1 and general hilarity reigned4 ,many points of detail might be noticed1 such as that in the urban counterpart of the festival1 which ,ovid carefully distinguishes from the country celebrations1 the fire was sprinkled with the ashes from the calves of the ,fordicidia and the blood of ,mars' ,october horse--another link between ,mars and agriculture4 ,but it is most interesting to note the double character of the ceremony--as a purification of man and beast on the one hand1 and on the other a prayer for the prosperity of the season to come4 ,three special festivals remain in ,april4 ,at the ,vinalia 7priora7 of the #bcrd1 the wine-skins of the previous year were opened and the wine tasted1 and1 we may suppose1 supplication was made for the vintage to come1 the festival being dedicated to the sky-god1 ,iuppiter4 ,at the ,robigalia of the #beth the offering of a dog was made for the aversion of mildew 7robigo71 to ,robigus 7who looks like a developed eponymous deity7 at the fifth milestone on the ,via ,claudia--the ancient boundary of ,roman territory4 ,the ,floralia of the #bhth does not occur in the old ,calendars1 probably because it was a moveable feast 7feriae conceptivae71 but it is an unmistakeable petition to the numen ,flora for the blossoming of the season's flowers4 ,may was a month of more critical importance for the welfare of the crops1 and therefore its festivals were mostly of a more sombre character4 ,the #ith1 #aath1 and #acth were the days set apart for the ,lemuria1 the aversion of the hostile spirits of the dead1 of which we have already spoken1 and a similarly gloomy character probably attached to the ,agonia of ,vediovis on the #bast4 ,but of far the greatest interest is the moveable feast of the ,ambarvalia1 the great lustration of the fields1 which took place towards the end of the month3 the date of its occurrence was no doubt fixed according to the state of the crops in any given year4 ,as the individual farmer purified his own fields for the aversion of evil1 so a solemn lustration of the boundaries of the state was performed by special priests1 known as the ,arval brethren 7fratres ,arvales74 ,with ceremonial dancing 7tripudium7 they moved along the boundary-marks and made the farmer's most complete offering of the pig1 sheep1 and ox 7suovetaurilia73 the fruits of the last year and the new harvest 7aridae et virides7 played a large part in the ceremonial1 and a solemn litany was recited for the aversion of every kind of pest from the crops4 ,in ,virgil's account the prayer is made to ,ceres1 and we know that in imperial times1 when the ,ambarvalia became very closely connected with the worship of the imperial house1 the centre of the cult was the earth-goddess1 ,dea ,dia2 but in the earliest account of the rustic ceremony which we possess in ,cato1 ,mars is addressed in the unmistakeable character of an agricultural deity4 ',father ,mars1 ,i pray and beseech thee that thou mayest be gracious and favourable to me1 to my home1 and my household1 for which cause ,i have ordained that the offering of pig1 sheep1 and ox be carried round my fields1 my land1 and my farm3 that thou mayest avert1 ward off1 and keep afar all disease1 visible and invisible1 all barrenness1 waste1 misfortune1 and ill weather3 that thou mayest suffer our crops1 our corn1 our vines and bushes to grow and come to prosperity3 that thou mayest preserve the shepherds and the flocks in safety1 and grant health and strength to me1 to my home1 and my household4' ,we have perhaps here another rustic ceremony addressed in origin to all numina1 whom it might concern1 and1 as it were1 specialising itself from time to time in an appeal to one definite deity or another1 but it is also clear evidence of an early agricultural association of ,mars4 ,the ,ambarvalia is one of the most picturesque of the field ceremonies1 and a peculiarly beautiful and imaginative description of it may be found in the first chapter of ,pater's ,marius the ,epicurean4 ,in ,june and ,july the farmer was waiting for the completion of the harvest1 and the great state-festivals of the period are not agricultural4 #b4 ,festivals of the ,harvest4--,in ,august the farmer's hopes are at last realised1 and the harvest is brought in4 ,the season is marked by two closely connected festivals on the #bast and #beth in honour of the old divinity-pair1 ,consus 7condere71 the god of the storehouse and ,ops1 the deity of the wealth of harvest4 ,at the ,consualia1 an offering is made by the flamen ,quirinalis1 assisted by the ,vestal virgins1 at an underground altar in the ,circus ,maximus1 specially uncovered for the occasion3 here we have probably not so much the notion of a chthonic deity1 as a relic of the simple practices of an early agricultural age1 when the crops were stored underground4 ,the beasts who had taken part in the harvest were released from their labours during the day1 and were decorated with flowers3 the festival included a race of mules1 the regular ,italian beasts of burden4 ,four days after this general festivity occurred the second harvest-ceremony of the ,opiconsivia1 held in the shrine 7sacrarium7 of the ,regia1 and attended only by the pontifex maximus and the ,vestal virgins4 ,this is clearly the state-harvest of the regal period1 the symbolic storing of the state-crops in the sacred storehouse of the palace by the king and his daughters4 ,both festivals are significant1 and we shall meet with ,consus and ,ops again in close connection in ,december4 ,the ,portunalia of the #agth may have been another harvest-home1 if we can believe the old authorities1 who tell us that ,portunus was a 'god of doors' 7portae74 ,the ,vinalia ,rustica of ,august #ai we cannot sufficiently interpret through lack of information3 it cannot1 of course1 have been the festival of the vintage1 for it is too early3 it may have been a propitiatory ceremony for the ripening grapes1 in which case it was probably connected with the auspicatio vindemiae1 in which the flamen ,dialis 7note again the association of ,iuppiter and the vine7 solemnly plucked the first grapes2 or it may be a festival of wine1 not vines1 in which case its main feature would most likely be the opening of the last year's vintage4 ,september contains no great festival1 and the harvest-season closes on ,october #aa with the ,meditrinalia--the nearest approach to a thanksgiving for the vintage4 ,on that day the first must of the new vintage and the wine of the old were solemnly tasted1 apparently as a spell against disease1 the worshipper using the strange formula1 ',i drink the new and the old wine1 with new wine and old ,i heal 7medeor7 disease4' ,this ceremony gave its name to the festival and was the cause of the subsequent evolution of an eponymous deity1 ,meditrina1 but there is little doubt that in origin here1 as in the other wine-festivals1 the deity concerned was at first ,iuppiter4 ,among the other rustic ceremonies of the month we may notice the festival of springs 7,fontinalia7 on ,october #ac3 wells were decorated with garlands and flowers flung into the waters4 #c4 ,festivals of the ,winter4--,the winter-festivals cannot be summed up under one general notion so easily as those of spring or summer1 but they fall fairly naturally into two groups--the festivals immediately connected with agricultural life and those associated with the dead and the underworld or with solemn purification4 ,the main action of the farmer's life during the winter is1 of course1 the sowing of the next year's crop1 which was commemorated in the ancient festival of the ,saturnalia on ,december #ag4 ,though the ,saturnalia is perhaps the most familiar to us of all the ,roman festivals1 partly from the allusions in the classics1 especially in ,horace1 partly because it is no doubt the source of many of our own ,christmas festivities1 it is yet almost impossible now to recover anything of its original ,roman character4 ,greek influence set to work on it very early1 identifying ,saturnus with ,cronos and establishing him in a ,greek temple with all the accompaniments of ,greek ritual4 ,all the familiar features of the festival--the freedom and license of the slaves1 the giving of presents1 even the wax-candles1 which are the prototype of those on our own ,christmas-tree--are almost certainly due to ,greek origin4 ,we are left with nothing but the name ,saturnus 7connected with the root of semen1 serere7 and the date to assure us that we have here in reality a genuine ,roman festival of the sowing of the crops4 ,of a similar nature--marking1 as ,ovid tells us1 the completion of the sowing--was the feriae sementivae or ,paganalia1 associated with the earth-goddesses1 ,ceres and ,tellus4 ,meal-cakes and a pregnant sow were the offerings1 the beasts who had helped in the ploughing were garlanded1 and prayer was made for the seed resting in the ground4 ,a curious feature of the winter worship is the repetition of festivals to the harvest deities1 ,consus and ,ops1 separated by the same interval of three days1 on ,december #ae and #ai3 it may be that we have here an indication of the final completion of the harvest1 or1 as ,mr4 ,warde ,fowler has suggested1 a ceremonial opening of the storehouses1 to see that the harvest is not rotting4 ,among the other country festivals of the period we may notice that of ,carmenta1 on the #aath and #aeth of ,january3 she seems to have been in origin a water-numen1 but was early associated with childbirth3 hence the rigid exclusion of men from her ceremonies and possibly the taboo on leathern thongs1 on the ground that nothing involving death must be used in the worship of a deity of birth4 ,the repetition of her festival may possibly point to separate celebrations of the communities of ,palatine and ,quirinal4 ,at this time1 too1 occurred the rustic ceremonies at the boundaries 7,terminalia7 and the offering to the ,lares at the 'marches' 7,compitalia71 of which we have spoken in treating of the worship of the house4 ,the other group of winter-festivals is of a much more gloomy and less definitely rustic type1 though they clearly date from the period of the agricultural community4 ,of the ,feralia of ,february #ba1 the culmination of the festival of the kindred dead 7,parentalia71 we have already spoken4 ,the ,larentalia is a very mysterious occasion1 and was supposed by the ,romans themselves to be an offering 'at the tomb' of a legendary ,acca ,larentia1 mistress of ,hercules4 ,but we have seen reason to think that ,larentia was in reality a deity of the dead1 and the 'tomb' a mundus3 if so1 we have another link between the winter season and the worship of the underworld4 ,there remains the weird festival of the ,lupercalia on ,february #ae1 to which we have had occasion to refer several times1 and which has become more familiar to most of us than other ,roman festivals owing to its political use by ,mark ,antony in #dd ,b4,c4 ,as we have argued already1 it seems to belong to the very oldest stratum of the ,palatine settlement1 and we may therefore appropriately close this account of the early festivals with a somewhat fuller description of it4 ,the worshippers assembled at the ,lupercal1 a cave on the ,palatine hill3 there goats and a dog were sacrificed1 and two youths belonging to the two colleges of ,fabian and ,quintian 7or ,quintilian7 ,luperci had their foreheads smeared with the knife used for the sacrifice and wiped with wool dipped in milk--at which point it was ordained that they should laugh4 ,then they girt on the skins of the slain goats and1 after feasting1 ran their course round the boundaries of the ,palatine hill1 followed each by his own company of youths1 and striking women on their way with strips1 known as februae or ,iunonis amicula1 cut from the goats' hides4 ,here we have a summary of many of the important points which we have noticed in the rustic festivals3 from the pre-,roman stratum comes the idea of communion with the sacrificed animal in the smearing of the blood and the wearing of the skin1 and also the magic charm involved in the striking of the women to procure fertility3 it is typical of the true feeling of ,roman religion that we cannot with any certainty tell what deity was associated with the rite1 though probably it was ,faunus3 the rustic character of the ceremony is indicated by the bowl of milk in which the wool was dipped and the sacrifice of goats3 the idea of lustration is clearly marked in the course round the boundaries3 the original ,palatine settlement stands out in the limits of that course and the site of the ,lupercal1 and the later synoecismus is seen in the1 presumably subsequent1 addition of the second college of ,luperci4 ,a careful study of the ,lupercalia as an epitome of the character and development of the ,roman agricultural festivals1 though it would not show the brighter aspect of some of the spring and summer celebrations1 would yet give a true notion of the history and spirit of the whole4 ,,footnotes3 #i ,ov41 ,fast41 iv4 #gce4 ,,chapter ,,vii ,,worship ,,of ,,the ,,state ,since1 in the matter of religion1 the ,roman state is in the main but the agricultural household magnified1 we shall not1 in considering its worship1 be entering on a new stratum of ideas1 but rather looking at the development of notions and sentiments already familiar4 ,to deal1 however1 with the state-worship in full would not only far exceed the limits of this sketch1 but would lead us away from religious ideas into the region of what we might now call 'ecclesiastical management4' ,i propose therefore to confine myself to two points1 firstly1 the broadening of the old conceptions of the household and the fields and their adaptation to the life of the state1 and secondly--to be treated very shortly and as an indication of the ,roman character--the organisation of religion4 #a4 ,development of the ,worship of ,house and ,fields4--,here we shall find two main characteristics4 ,the state in the first place1 as we have several times hinted in anticipation1 establishes its own counterpart of the household and rustic cults and adapts to its own use the ideas which they involve3 in the second1 and particularly in connection with some of the field-deities1 it evolves new and very frequently abstract notions1 foreign to the life of the independent country households1 but necessary and vital to the life of an organised community4 ,let us look first at the fate of the household deities4 ,ianus4--,we left ,ianus as the numen of the house-door3 he passes into the state exactly in the same capacity3 the state too has its 'door1' the gate at the north-east corner of the ,forum1 and this becomes the seat of his state-cult--the door which1 according to ,augustan legend1 is opened in the time of war and only shut when ,rome is at peace with all the world4 ,but reflection soon gets to work on ,ianus3 a door has two sides1 it can both open and shut2 therefore1 as early as the song of the ,salii1 he has developed the cult-epithets ',opener1' ',shutter' 7,patulci1 ,cloesi71 and as soon as he is thought of as anything approaching a personality he is 'two-headed' 7bifrons71 as he appears in later representations4 ,the door again is the first thing you come to in entering a house3 the 'door-spirit' then1 with that tendency to abstraction which we shall see shortly in other cases1 becomes the god of beginnings4 ,he watches over the very first beginning of human life in his character of ,consevius2 to him is sacred the first hour of the day 7pater matutinus71 the ,calends of every month1 and the first month of the year 7,ianuarius72 to him too is offered by the rex sacrorum the first sacrifice of the year1 the ,agonium on the #ith of ,january4 ,in this capacity1 moreover1 his name comes first in all the formulae of prayer1 and he is looked upon--not indeed as the father of the gods--for that is a much too anthropomorphic notion--but as what we might now term their 'logical antecedent'3 divum deus1 as the song of the ,salii quaintly puts it1 principium deorum1 as later interpretation explained it4 ,yet through all he remains the most typical ,roman deity3 he does not acquire a temple till #bag ,b4,c41 nor a bust until quite late1 nor is he ever identified with a ,greek counterpart4 ,in his capacity as pater matutinus he has a native female counterpart in ,matuta1 a dawn-deity1 who becomes a protectress in childbirth1 and as such is the centre of the matrons' festival1 the ,matralia of ,june #aa4 ,vesta4--,the history of ,vesta is perhaps less romantic1 but it affords a more exact parallel between household and state4 ,in the primitive community the king's hearth is not merely of symbolical importance1 but of great practical utility1 in that it is kept continually burning as the source of fire on which the individual householder may draw3 hence it is the duty of the king's daughters to care for it and keep the flame perpetually alight4 ,in ,rome the temple of ,vesta is the king's hearth1 situated1 as one would expect1 in close proximity to the regia4 ,the fire is kept continually blazing except on the #ast of ,march of every year1 when it is allowed to go out and is ceremonially renewed4 ,the ,vestal virgins1 sworn to perpetual virginity and charged with the preservation of the sacred flame1 are 'the king's daughters1' living in a kind of convent 7atrium ,vestae7 and under the charge of the king's representative1 the pontifex maximus4 ,it is their duty too1 as the natural cooks of the sacred royal household1 to make the salt cake 7mola salsa7 to be used at the year's festivals and to preserve it and other sacred objects1 such as the ashes of the ,fordicidia1 in the storehouse of ,vesta 7penus ,vestae74 ,in the month of ,june from the #gth to the #aeth1 with a climax on the #ith1 the day of the ,vestalia1 the matrons who all the year round have tended their own hearths1 come in solemn procession bare-footed to make their homely offerings at the state-hearth1 and the virgins meanwhile offer the cakes that they have made4 ,for eight days the ceremony continues1 during which time the bakers and millers keep holiday2 the days are religiosi 7marriages are unlucky and other taboos are observed7 and also nefasti 7no public business may be performed72 until the ceremony closes on the #aeth1 with the solemn cleansing of the temple and the casting of the refuse into the ,tiber1 and then the normal life of the state may be renewed--,q4 ,st4 ,d4 ,f4 7,quando ,stercus ,delatum ,fas7 is the unique entry in the ,calendars4 ,this is all less imaginative than the development of ,ianus1 but the underlying feeling is intensely ,roman and there could be no clearer idea of the natural adaptation of the household-cult to the religion of the state4 ,penates1 ,lares1 and ,genius4--,the other household deities too have their counterpart1 though not so prominently marked1 in the worship of the state4 ,the magistrates1 on entering office1 took oath by ,iuppiter and the ,di ,penates populi ,romani ,quiritium1 and that the conception was as wide in the state as in the household is shown by the fact that on less formal occasions the formula appears as ,iuppiter et ceteri di omnes immortales4 ,the ,penates of the state then would include all the state-deities2 but that their original character is not lost sight of we can see from the statement of ,varro that in the penus ,vestae 7the 'state storehouse'7 were preserved their sigilla--not apparently sensuous representations1 but symbolic objects1 such as we have seen before in cases like that of the silex of ,iuppiter4 ,the ,lares again find their counterpart in the ,lares ,praestites of the state1 and their rustic festival1 the ,compitalia1 has its urban reproduction1 which1 as it involved considerable license on the part of populace and slaves1 was often in the later period of the ,republic a cause of serious political disturbance4 ,even the ,genius1 though rather vaguely1 passes over to the state and we hear of the ,genius populi ,romani or the ,genius urbis ,romae1 with regard to which ,servius quotes from an inscription on a shield the characteristic addition1 sive mas sive femina3 in much later times we find the exact counterpart of the domestic worship of the ,genius of the pater familias in the cult of the ,genius of the ,emperor--the foundation of the whole of the imperial worship4 ,we have observed already how the cults of the fields were taken over by the state and their counterparts established in the great festivals of the ,calendar4 ,naturally enough most of the deities concerned1 existing only for the part they played in these festivals1 retained their original character without further development4 ,but with a few it was different3 it was their fate to acquire new characteristics and new functions1 and1 developing with the needs of the community1 to become the great gods of the state3 of these we must give some brief account4 ,iuppiter4--,we have known ,iuppiter hitherto either in connection with certain very primitive survivals1 or in the genuine ,roman period as a sky-numen1 concerned with the grape-harvest in the two ,vinalia and the ,meditrinalia1 and the recipient at the family meal of a daps as a general propitiation before the beginning of the sowing4 ,as sky-god he passes to the state3 ,lucetius 7lux7 is his title in the song of the ,salii and to him are sacred the ,ides of every month--the time of the full moon1 when there is most light in the heavens by night as well as day4 ,in his agricultural connection he has his wine-festivals in the state as in the country1 and the household daps becomes the more elaborate epulum ,iovis1 in which the whole community1 as it were1 entertained him at a banquet4 ,as a sky-deity1 too1 he is particularly concerned with the thunderbolt and the lightning-flash 7,iuppiter ,fulmen1 ,fulgur71 and to him are sacred the always ominous spots which had been struck by lightning 7bidentalia73 with the more alarming occurrence of lightning by night he has a special connection under the cult-title ,iuppiter ,summanus4 ,but as the little community grew1 and especially perhaps after the union of the two settlements1 the worship of ,iuppiter ,feretrius1 associated with the sacred oak upon the ,capitol--the hill between ,palatine and ,quirinal--comes more and more into prominence as a bond of union and the central point of the state's religious life3 it tends indeed to take the place of priority1 which had previously been occupied by ,ianus4 ,the community goes to war with its neighbours1 and after a signal victory the spolia opima must be dedicated on the sacred oak3 indeed ,iuppiter is in a special sense with them in the battle and must now be worshipped as the 'stayer of rout' 7,stator7 and the 'giver of victory' 7,victor74 ,war is a new province of the state's activity1 but1 characteristically enough1 it does not evolve its own numen1 but enlarges the sphere of the somewhat elastic spirits already existing4 ,so too in the internal organisation of the state there is felt the need of a religious sanction for public morality1 and ,iuppiter--though vaguely at first--takes on him the character of a deity of justice4 ,in this connection he is primarily the god of oaths3 we have seen how his sacred silex was used in the oath of treaty3 it is also the most solemn witness to the oath of the citizen4 ,iuppiter ,lapis becomes specially the ,dius ,fidius1 a cult-title which subsequently sets up for itself and produces a further offshoot in the abstract ,fides4 ,finally1 towards the end of our period the ,iuppiter of the ,capitol emerges triumphant1 as it were1 from his struggle with his rivals and1 with the new title of ,iuppiter ,optimus ,maximus1--the 'best and greatest1' that is1 of all the ,iuppiters--takes his place as the supreme deity of the ,roman state and the personification of the greatness and majesty of ,rome itself4 ,to his temple hereafter the ,roman youth will come to make his offering when he takes the dress of manhood2 here the magistrates will do sacrifice before entering on their year of office3 here the victorious general will pass in procession with the spoils of his victory3 on the walls shall be suspended treaties with foreign nations and offerings sent by subject princes and states from all quarters of the world3 all that ,rome is to be1 will be1 as it were1 embodied in the sky-spirit of the sacred oak1 the god of justice and of victory in war4 ,iuno4--,iuppiter carries with him into the state-worship his female counterpart1 ,iuno1 with his own characteristics1 in a certain degree1 and his own privileges4 ,she is ,lucina and ,fulgura as he is ,lucetius and ,fulgur3 white cows are her offerings as white steers are his3 as the ,ides are sacred to ,iuppiter1 so--though they are not a festival--are the ,calends to ,iuno4 ,but from the first she shows a certain independence and develops on lines of her own4 ,in the curious ceremony of the fixing of the ,nones 7the first quarter of the month71 held on the ,calends in the curia ,calabra1 she seems to appear as a moon-goddess3 the rex sacrorum1 after a report from a pontifex as to the appearance of the new moon1 announces the result in the formula3 ',i summon thee for five 7or seven7 days1 hollow ,iuno' 7dies te quinque septem kalo1 ,iuno ,covella3 hence the name ,kalendae74 ,but far more prominently--either as a female divinity herself1 or1 as some think1 owing to the supposed influence of the moon on female life--does ,iuno figure as the deity of women1 and especially in association with childbirth and marriage4 ,as ,lucina she is1 as we have seen1 the presiding deity of childbirth1 and her festival on the #ast of ,march1 though not in the ,calendars 7because confined to women and not therefore a festival of the whole people71 attained immense popularity under the title of the ,matronalia4 ,she has too a general superintendence of the rites of marriage1 and the various little numina1 who play so prominent a part in the ceremonies1 tend to attach themselves to her as cult-titles4 ,the festival of the servant-maids in honour of ,iuno ,caprotina on the #gth of ,july shows the same notion of ,iuno as the women's goddess1 which appears again in common parlance when women speak of their ,iuno1 just as men do of their ,genius4 ,later on ,iuno acquires the characteristics of majesty 7,regina7 and protection in war 7,curitis1 ,sospita71 partly no doubt as ,iuppiter's counterpart1 but more directly through the introduction of cults from neighbouring ,italian towns4 ,mars4--,we have seen reason to believe that in the earlier stages of ,roman religion ,mars was a numen of vegetation1 but though the ,ambarvalia was duly taken over into the state-cult and attained a very high degree of importance1 yet there can be no doubt that in the state-religion ,mars was pre-eminently associated with war4 ,iuppiter might help at need in averting defeat and awarding victory1 but it was with ,mars that the general conduct of war rested4 ,his sacred animal is the warlike wolf1 his symbols the spears and the sacred shields 7ancilia71 which during his own month 7,martius7--the #ast of which is his special festival--his priests 7,salii7 wearing the full war-dress 7trabea and tunica picta7 carry with sacred dance and song round the city4 ,his altar is in the ,campus ,martius1 outside the city-walls and therefore within the sphere of the imperium militiae1 and the other festivals associated with him are of a warlike character3 the races of the war-horse 7,equirria7 on ,march #ad and ,february #bg1 and the great race on the ,ides of ,october1 when the winner was solemnly slain3 the lustration of the arms at the ,quinquatrus on ,march #ai and the ,armilustrium of ,october #ai--;at the beginning and end of the campaigning season3 and the lustration of the war-trumpets on the #bcrd of ,march and the #bcrd of ,may4 ,but above all in honour of ,mars is held the great quinquennial lustrum associated with the census1 when the people are drawn up in military array around his altar in the ,campus ,martius and the solemn offering of the suovetaurilia 7is this a faint relic of his agricultural character87 after being carried three times round the gathered host1 is offered on his altar in prayer for the military future of the state4 ,hardly any god in the state-cult has his character so clearly marked1 and we may regard ,mars as a deity who1 taking on new functions to suit the needs of the times1 almost entirely lost the traces of his original nature4 ,quirinus4--,iuppiter and ,mars then became the great state-deities of the developed community and to them is added1 as the contribution of the ,colline settlement1 their own particular deity1 ,quirinus4 ,he1 like them1 has his own flamen2 like ,mars he has his ,salii1 and his festival finds its place in the ,calendars on ,february the #agth4 ,but of his ritual and character we know practically nothing3 the ritual was obscured because his festival coincided with the much more popular festival of the curiae1 the stultorum feriae3 of his character1 we can only conjecture that he was to the ,colline settlement what ,mars was to the ,palatine1 whereas later after the complete amalgamation he seems to have been distinguished from ,mars as representing 'armed peace' rather than war--an idea which is borne out by the associations of the closely allied word ,quirites4 ,be that as it may1 we have in ,iuppiter1 ,mars1 and ,quirinus the great state-triad of the synoecismus1 who held their own until at the beginning of the next epoch they were supplanted by the new ,etruscan triad of the ,capitol1 ,iuppiter1 ,iuno and ,minerva4 #b4 ,organisation4--,it might perhaps be thought that the organisation of religion is a matter remote from its spirit1 and is not therefore a suitable subject for discussion1 where the object is rather to bring out underlying motives and ideas3 but in dealing with the ,roman religion1 where ceremonial and legal precision were so prominent1 it would be even misleading to omit some reference to the very characteristic manner in which the state1 taking over the rather chaotic elements of the agricultural worship1 organised them into something like a consistent whole4 ,its most complete achievement in this direction was without doubt the regulation of the religious year4 ,we have spoken many times of the ,calendars 7,fasti73 it is necessary now to obtain some clearer notion of what they were4 ,in ,rome itself and various ,italian towns have been found some thirty inscriptions1 one almost complete 7,maffeiani71 the others more or less fragmentary1 giving the tables of the months and marking precisely the character and occurrences of every day in the year4 ,we may take as a specimen the latter half of the month of ,august from the ,fasti ,maffeiani4 ,a4 ,,eid4 ,,np4 ,c4 ,,volc4 ,,np4 ,b4 ,f4 ,d4 ,c4 ,c4 ,c4 ,e4 ,,opic4 ,,np4 ,d4 ,c4 ,f4 ,c4 ,e4 ,,port4 ,,np4 ,g4 ,,volt4 ,,np4 ,f4 ,c4 ,h4 ,,np4 ,g4 ,,vin4 ,f4,p4 ,a4 ,f4 ,h4 ,c4 ,b4 ,f4 ,a4 ,,cons4 ,,np4 ,c4 ,c4 ,b4 ,,en4 ,in the first column are given the nundinal letters of the days1 showing their position in the eight days' 'week' from one market day 7nundinae7 to the next4 ,in the second column are noted first the great divisions of the month1 ,calends1 ,nones1 and ,ides1 and then the religious character of each individual day is indicated by certain signs1 whose explanations throw a good deal of light on ,roman religions notions4 ,it will be seen that the letters of most frequent occurrence are ,f1 ,c1 and ,n 7or in our extract ,,np73 these correspond to the broad distinction between days profane and sacred4 ,f 7fastus7 denotes a day on which the business of the state may be performed1 on which the praetor may say 7fari7 the three words1 do1 dico1 addico1 which summed up the decisions of the ,roman law3 ,c 7comitialis7 marks a day on which the legislative assemblies 7comitia7 may be held3 it is by implication ,f as well4 ,n 7nefastus71 on the other hand1 denotes the sacred day1 consecrated to the worship of the gods1 on which therefore state-business may not be transacted3 similarly the very mysterious and much disputed sign ,,np1 whether it differs in precise signification from ,n or not1 certainly marks a day of sacred character4 ,,en1 which occurs once in this extract 7from endotercisus1 the old ,latin form of intercisus7 signifies a 'split' day 7dies fissus71 the beginning and end of which were sacred1 while the middle period was free for business4 ,in the second column also 7in large letters in some of the other ,calendars7 are named the feriae publicae1 the great annual state-festivals1 fixed for one particular day 7feriae stativae73 such1 in this case1 are the ,portunalia1 ,vinalia1 and ,consualia4 ,these fasti were exhibited in the ,forum and on the walls of temples1 and the conscientious ,roman could have no possible difficulty in finding out when he might lawfully transact his business and what festivals the state was observing3 of the #cee days of the old ,calendar #aa were fissi1 #bce were fasti 7#aib comitiales71 and #aji nefasti4 ,we may remark as curious features in the ,calendar1 denoting rigid adherence to principle1 that with one exception1 the ,poplifugia of ,july #e1 no festival ever occurs before the ,nones1 that with two exceptions1 the ,regifugium of ,february #bd and the ,equirria of the #adth of ,march1 no festival falls on an even day of the month1 and that there is a marked avoidance of successive feast-days3 even the three days of the ,lemuria allow an interval of a day between each4 ,in the matter of ritual and observance1 state-organisation--and its absence--are alike significant4 ,of the general exactness of ritual and its specific variations on different occasions a fair notion has perhaps already been gathered2 it may help to fill out that notion if we can put together a sketch of the normal process of a sacrifice to the gods4 ,before the sacrifice began the animal to be offered was selected and tested3 if it had any blemish or showed any reluctance1 it was rejected4 ,if it were whole and willing1 it was bound with fillets 7infulae7 around its forehead1 and long ribbons 7vittae7 depending from them4 ,it was then brought to the altar 7ara7 by the side of which stood a portable brazier 7foculus74 ,the celebrant--magistrate or priest--next approached dressed in the toga1 girt about him in a peculiar manner 7cinctus ,gabinus71 and carried up at the back so as to form a hood 7velato capite73 the herald proclaimed silence1 and the flute-player began to play his instrument4 ,the first part of the offering was then made by the pouring of wine and scattering of incense on the brazier3 it was followed by the ceremonial slaughter 7immolatio7 of the animal4 ,the celebrant sprinkled the victim with wine and salted cake1 and made a symbolic gesture with the knife4 ,the victim was then taken aside by the attendants 7victimarii71 and actually slaughtered by them3 from it they extracted the sacred parts 7exta71 liver1 heart1 gall1 lungs1 and midriff1 and after inspecting them to see that they had no abnormality--but not in the earlier period for purposes of augury--wrapped them in pieces of flesh 7augmenta71 cooked them1 and brought them back to the celebrant1 who laid them as an offering upon the altar1 where they were burnt4 ,the rest of the flesh 7viscera7 was divided as a sacred meal between the celebrant and his friends--or in a state-offering among the priests1 and probably the magistrate4 ,we cannot refrain from remarking here the extreme precision of ritual1 the scrupulous care with which the human side of the contract was fulfilled and the--almost legal--division of the victim between gods and men4 ,but though the ritual was so exact1 one must not be led away by modern analogies to suppose that there was ever anything like a rigid constraint on the private citizen for the observance of festivals4 ,the state-festivals were in the strictest sense offerings made to the gods by the representative magistrates or priests1 and if they were present1 all was done that was required3 the whole people had been1 by a legal fiction1 present in their persons4 ,no doubt the private citizen would often attend in large numbers at the celebrations1 especially at the more popular festivals1 but from some1 such as the ,vestalia1 he was actually excluded4 ,on the other hand1 though it did not demand presence1 the state did--at least theoretically--demand the observance of the feast-day by private individuals4 ,the root-notion of feriae was a day set apart for the worship of the gods1 and on it therefore the citizen ought to do 'no manner of work4' ,the state observed this condition fully in the closing of law-courts and the absence of legislative assemblies1 and in theory too the private citizen must refrain from any act which was not concerned with the worship of the gods1 or rendered absolutely necessary1 as1 for instance1 if 'his ox or his ass should fall into a pit4' ,but it is characteristic of ,rome that the state did not seek for offence1 but only punished it if accidentally seen3 on a feast-day the rex sacrorum and the flamines might not see work being done2 they therefore sent on a herald in advance to announce their presence1 and an actual conviction involved a money-fine4 ,perhaps more scrupulously than the feriae were observed the dies religiosi1 days of 'abstinence1' on which certain acts1 such as marriage1 the beginning of any new piece of work1 or the offering of sacrifice to the gods1 were forbidden3 such1 in the oldest period1 were the days on which the mundus was open1 or the temple of ,vesta received the matrons1 the days when the ,salii carried the ancilia in procession1 and the periods of the two festivals of the dead in ,february and ,may2 but for eluding their observance too devices were not unknown4 ,in the state-organisation of religion1 then1 we seem to see just the same features from which we started3 as a basis the legal conception of the relation of god to man1 as a result the extreme care and precision in times and ceremonials1 as a corollary in the state the idea of legal representation and the consequent looseness of hold on the action of the individual4 ,,chapter ,,viii ,,auguries ,,and ,,auspices ,so far we have been considering the regular relations of man and god1 seen in recurring or special offerings1 in vows and in acts of purification and lustration--all based on the contract-notion1 all endeavours on man's part to fulfil his bounden duty1 that the gods may be constrained in turn to theirs4 ,but so strong was the feeling of divine presence and influence in the ,roman's mind1 that he was not content with doing his best by these regular means to secure the favour of the gods1 but wished before undertaking any business of importance to be able to assure himself of their approval4 ,his practical common-sense evolved1 as it were1 a complete 'code'--in the flight and song of birds1 in the direction of the lightning-flash1 in the conduct of men and animals--by which he believed that the gods communicated to him their intentions3 sometimes these indications 7auspicia7 might be vouchsafed by the gods unasked 7oblativa71 sometimes they would be given in answer to request 7impetrativa73 but as to their meaning1 there could be no doubt1 provided they were interpreted by one skilled in the lore and tradition of augury4 ,we may observe here1 though our evidence is much slighter1 the same three stages which we have noticed in the sacrificial worship1 the homely domestic auspices1 the auguries of the agricultural life1 and the organised system in the state4 ,in the household the use of auspices was in origin at any rate very general indeed3 ',nothing1' ,cicero tells us1 'of importance used to be undertaken unless with the sanction of the auspices' 7auspicato74 ,the right of interrogating the will of the gods1 rested1 as one might expect1 with the master of the house1 assisted no doubt by the private augur as the repository of lore and the interpreter of what the master saw4 ,but of the details of domestic augury we know but little4 ,cato in one passage insists on the extreme importance of silence for the purpose1 and ,festus suggests that this was secured by the master of the house rising in the depths of the night to inspect the heavens4 ,we have seen already that the taking of the auspices played an important part in the ceremonies of betrothal and marriage1 and that the indications of the divine will might be very varied we may gather from a story in ,cicero4 ,an aunt wishing to take the auspices for her niece's betrothal1 conducted her into an open consecrated space 7sacellum7 and sat down on the stool of augury 7sella7 with her niece standing at her side4 ,after a while the girl tired and asked her aunt to give her a little of the stool3 the aunt replied1 ',my child1 ,i give up my seat to you'3 nothing further happened and this answer turned out in fact to be the auspicious sign3 the aunt died1 the niece married the widower and so became mistress of the house4 ,of augury in agricultural life we have some indication in the annual observance of the 'spring augury' 7augurium verniserum7 and the midsummer ceremony of the augurium canarium1 which seems to have been a combination of the offering of a red dog 7possibly to avert mildew7 and an augury for the success of the crops4 ,to the rustic stratum possibly belongs also the augurium salutis populi1 though later it was a yearly act celebrated whenever the ,roman army was not at war and so became connected with the shutting of the temple of ,ianus4 ,the state greatly developed and organised the whole system of auguries and auspices4 ,the college of augurs ranked second only in importance to the pontifical college1 and their duties with regard to both augury and auspice are sufficiently clear4 ,like the pontifices in relation to cult1 they are the storehouse of all tradition1 and to them appeal may be made in all cases of doubt both public and private3 they were jealous of their secrets and in later times their mutual consciousness of deception became proverbial4 ,the right of augury--in origin simply the inspection of the heavens--was theirs alone1 and it was exercised particularly on the annual occasions mentioned and at the installation of priests1 of which we get a typical instance in ,livy's account of the consecration of ,numa4 ,the auspices on the other hand--in origin 'signs from birds' 7avis1 spicere7--were the province of the magistrate about to undertake some definite action on behalf of the state whether at home or on the field of battle4 ,here the augur's functions were merely preparatory and advisory4 ,it was his duty to prepare the templum1 the spot from which the auspices are to be taken--always a square space1 with boundaries unbroken except at the entrance1 not surrounded by wall or necessarily by line1 but clearly indicated 7effatus7 by the augur1 and marked off 7liberatus7 from the surroundings3 in the comitia and other places in ,rome there were permanent templa1 but elsewhere they must be specially made4 ,the magistrate then enters the templum and observes the signs 7spectio73 if there is any doubt as to interpretation--and seeing the immense complication of the traditions 7disciplina71 this must often have been the case--the augur is referred to as interpreter4 ,the signs demanded 7impetrativa7 were originally always connected with the appearance1 song or flight of birds--higher or lower1 from left to right or right to left1 etc4 ,later others were included1 and with the army in the field it became the regular practice to take the auspices from the feeding of the sacred chickens 7pulli73 the best sign being obtained if1 in their eagerness to feed1 they let fall some of the grain from their beaks 7tripudium solistimum7--a result not difficult to secure by previous treatment and a careful selection of the kind of grain supplied to them4 ,but besides this deliberate 'asking for signs1' public business might at any moment be interrupted if the gods voluntarily sent an indication of disapproval 7oblativa73 the augurs then had always to be at hand to advise the magistrates whether notice should be taken of such signs1 and1 if so1 what was their signification1 and they even seem to have had certain rights of reporting themselves 7nuntiatio7 the occurrence of adverse ones4 ,the sign of most usual occurrence would be lightning--sometimes such an unexpected event as the seizure of a member of the assembly with epilepsy 7morbus comitialis7--and we know to what lengths political obstructionists went in later times in the observation of fictitious signs1 or even the prevention of business by the mere announcement of their intention to see an unfavourable omen 7servare de caelo74 ,the complications and ramifications of the augur's art are infinite1 but the main idea should by now be plain1 and it must be remembered that the kindred art of the soothsayer 7haruspex71 oracles1 and the interpretation of fate by the drawing of lots 7sortes7 are all later foreign introductions3 auspice and augury are the only genuine ,roman methods for interpreting the will of the gods4 ,here then in household1 fields1 and state1 we have a second type of relation to the gods1 running parallel to the ordinary practice of sacrifice and prayer1 distinct yet not fundamentally different4 ,as it is man's function to propitiate the higher spirits and prevent1 if possible1 the wrecking of his plans by their opposition1 so it is his business1 if he can1 to find out their intentions before he engages on any serious undertaking4 ,as in the ius sacrum his legal mind leads him to assume that the deities accept the responsibility of the contract1 when his own part is fulfilled1 so here1 like a practical man of business1 he assumes their construction of a code of communication1 which he has learned to interpret4 ,in its origin it is a notion common to many primitive religions1 but in its elaboration it is peculiarly and distinctively ,italian1 and1 as we know it1 ,roman4 ,,chapter ,,ix ,,religion ,,and ,,morality--,,conclusion ,it might be said that a religion--the expression of man's relation to the unseen--has not necessarily any connection with morality--man's action in himself and towards his neighbours3 that an individual--or even a nation--might perfectly fulfil the duties imposed by the 'powers above1' without being influenced in conduct and character4 ,such a view might seem to find an apt illustration in the religion of ,rome3 the ceremonial pietas towards the gods appears to have little to do with the making of man or nation4 ,but in the history of the world the test of religions must be their effect on the character of those who believed in them3 religion is no doubt itself an outcome of character1 but it reacts upon it1 and must either strengthen or weaken4 ,we are not therefore justified in dismissing the ',religion of ,numa' without inquiry as to its relation to morality1 for on our answer to that question must largely depend our judgment as to its value4 ,we are of course in a peculiarly difficult position to grapple with this problem through lack of contemporary evidence4 ,the ,rome we know1 in the epochs when we can fairly judge of character and morality1 was not the ,rome in which the ',religion of ,numa' had grown up and remained unquestioned3 it had been overlaid with foreign cults and foreign ideas1 had been used by priests and magistrates as a political instrument1 and discounted among the educated through the influence of philosophy4 ,but we may remember in the first place that even then1 especially in the household and in the country1 the old religion had probably a much firmer hold than one might imagine from literary evidence1 in the second that national character is not the growth of a day1 so that we may safely refer permanent characteristics to the period when the old religion held its own4 ,it may be admitted at once that the direct influence on morality was very small indeed4 ,there was no table of commandments backed by the religious sanction3 the sense of 'sin1' except through breach of ritual1 was practically unknown4 ,it is true that in the very early leges regiae some notion of this kind is seen--a significant glimpse of what the original relation may have been3 it is there ordained that the patron who betrayed his client1 or the client who deceived his patron1 shall be condemned to ,iuppiter2 the parricide to the spirits of his dead ancestors1 the husband who sells his wife to the gods of the underworld1 the man who removes his neighbour's landmark to ,terminus1 the stealer of corn to ,ceres4 ,all these persons shall be sacri3 they have offended against the gods and the gods will see to their punishment4 ,but these are old-world notions which soon passed into the background and the state took over the punishment of such offenders in the ordinary course of law4 ,nor again in the prayers of men to gods is there a trace of a petition for moral blessings3 the magistrate prays for the success and prosperity of the state1 the farmer for the fertility of his crops and herds1 even the private individual1 who suspends his votive-tablet in the temple1 pays his due for health or commercial success vouchsafed to himself or his relations4 ',men call ,iuppiter greatest and best1' says ,cicero1 'because he makes us not just or temperate or wise1 but sound and healthy and rich and wealthy4' ,still less1 until we come to the moralists of the ,empire1 is there any sense of that immediate and personal relation of the individual to a higher being1 which is really in religion1 far more than commandments and ordinances1 the mainspring and safeguard of morality3 even the conception of the ,genius1 the 'nearest' perhaps of all unseen powers1 had nothing of this feeling in it1 and it may be significant that1 just because of his nearness to man1 the ,genius never quite attained to god-head4 ,as far as direct relation is concerned1 religion and morality were to the ,roman two independent spheres with a very small point of contact4 ,nor even in its indirect influence does the formal observance of the ,roman worship seem likely at first sight to have done much for personal or national morality4 ,based upon fear1 stereotyped in the form of a legal relationship1 religio--'the bounden obligation'--made1 no doubt1 for a kind of conscientiousness in its adherents1 but a cold conscientiousness1 devoid of emotion and incapable of expanding itself to include other spheres or prompt to a similar scrupulousness in other relations4 ,the rigid and constant distinction of sacred and profane would incline the ,roman to fulfil the routine of his religious duty and then turn1 almost with a sigh of relief1 to the occupations of normal life1 carrying with him nothing more than the sense of a burden laid aside and a pledge of external prosperity4 ,even the religious act itself might be without moral significance3 as we have seen1 the worshipper might be wholly ignorant of the character1 even the name of the deity he worshipped1 and in any case the motive of his action was naught1 the act itself everything4 ,nor again had the ,roman religion any trace of that powerful incentive to morality1 a doctrine of rewards and punishments in a future life3 the ideas as to the fate of the dead were fluctuating and vague1 and the ,roman was in any case much more interested in their influence on himself than in their possible experiences after death4 ,the divorce then between religion and morality seems almost complete and it is not strange that most modern writers speak of the ,roman religion as a tiresome ritual formalism1 almost wholly lacking in ethical value4 ,and yet it did not present itself in this light to the ,romans themselves4 ,cicero1 sceptic as he was1 could speak of it as the cause of ,rome's greatness2 ,augustus1 the practical politician1 could believe that its revival was an essential condition for the renaissance of the ,roman character4 ,have we1 in our brief examination of its characteristics1 seen any features which may suggest the solution of this apparent antagonism8 ,was there in this formalism a life which escapes us1 as we handle the dry bones of antiquarianism8 ,in the first place there may be a danger that we underrate the value of formalism itself4 ,it spells routine1 but routine is not without value in the strengthening of character4 ,the private citizen1 who conscientiously day by day had carried out the worship of his household gods and month by month observed the sacred abstinence from work on the days of festival1 was certainly not less fitted to take his place as a member of a strenuous and well-organised community1 or to serve obediently and quietly in the army on campaign4 ,even the magistrate in the execution of his religious duties must have acquired an exactness and method1 which would not be valueless in the conduct of public business4 ,and when we pass to the origin of this formalism--the legal relation--the connection with the ,roman character becomes at once more obvious4 ,the 'lawgivers of the world1' who developed constitution and code to a systematised whole such as antiquity had not dreamed of before1 imported1 we may say if we like1 their legal notions into the sphere of religion3 but we must not forget the other side of the question4 ,the permanence and success of this greater contract with higher powers--the feeling that the gods did regard and reward exact fulfilment of duty--cannot have been without re-action on the relations of the life of the community3 it was1 as it were1 a higher sanction to the legal point of view3 a pledge that the relations of citizen and state too were rightly conceived4 ',there is1' says ,cicero1 speaking of the death of ,clodius in the language of a later age1 'there is a divine power which inspired that criminal to his own ruin3 it was not by chance that he expired before the shrine of the ,bona ,dea1 whose rites he had violated'3 the divine justice is the sanction of the human law4 ,even in the fear1 from which all ultimately sprang1 there was a training in self-repression and self-subordination1 which in a more civilised age must result in a valuable respect and obedience4 ,the descendants of those who had made religion out of an attempt to appease the hostile numina1 feeling themselves not indeed on more familiar terms with their 'unknown gods1' but only perhaps a little more confident of their own strength1 were not likely to be wanting in a disciplined sense of dependence and an appreciation of the value of respect for authority1 which alone can give stability to a constitution4 ,if fear with the ,romans was not the beginning of theological wisdom1 it was yet an important contribution to the character of a disciplined state4 ,but1 as ,i have hinted in the course of this sketch more than once1 the answer to this problem1 as well as the key to the general understanding of the ,roman religion1 is to be found in the worship of the household4 ,if we knew more of it1 we should see more clearly where religion and morality joined hands1 but we know enough to give us a clue4 ,there not only are the principal events of life1 birth1 adolescence1 marriage1 attended by their religious sanction1 but in the ordinary course of the daily round the divine presence and the dependence of man are continually emphasised4 ,the gods are given their portion of the family meal1 the sanctified dead are recalled to take their share of the family blessings4 ,the result was not merely an approach--collectively1 not individually--to that sense of the nearness of the unseen1 which has so great an effect on the actions of the living1 but a very strong bond of family union which lay at the root of the life of the state4 ,it would be difficult to find a clearer expression of the notion than in the fact that the same word pietas1 which expresses the due fulfilment of man's duty to god1 is also the ideal of the relations of the members of a household3 filial piety was1 in fact1 but another aspect of that rightness of relation1 which reveals itself in the worship of the gods4 ,no doubt that1 in the city-life of later periods1 this ideal broke down on both sides3 household worship was neglected and family life became less dutiful4 ,but it was still1 especially in the country1 the true backbone of ,roman society1 and no one can read the opening odes of ,horace's third book without feeling the strength of ,augustus' appeal to it4 ,and if we translate this1 as we have learned to do1 into terms of the state1 we can get some idea of what the ,romans meant by their debt to their religion4 ,as the household was bound together by the tie of common worship1 as in the intermediate stage the clan1 severed politically and socially1 yet felt itself reunited in the gentile rites1 so too the state was welded into a whole by the regularly recurring annual festivals and the assurance of the divine sanction on its undertakings4 ,it might be that in the course of time these rites lost their meaning and the community no longer by personal presence expressed its service to the gods1 but the cult stood there still1 as the type of ,rome's union to the higher powers and a guarantee of their assistance against all foes3 the religion of ,rome was1 as it has been said1 the sanctification of patriotism--the ,roman citizen's highest moral ideal4 ,it has been remarked1 perhaps with partial truth1 that the religion of the ,a,eneid--in many ways a summary of ,roman thought and feeling--is the belief in the fata ,romae and their fulfilment4 ,the very impersonality of this conception makes it a good picture of what religion was in the ,roman state4 ,it was not1 as with the ,jews1 a strong conviction of the rightness of their own belief and a certainty that their divine protectors must triumph over those of other nations1 but a feeling of the constant presence of some spirits1 who1 'if haply they might find them1' would1 on the payment of their due1 bear their part in the great progress of right and justice and empire on which ,rome must march to her victory4 ,it was the duty of the citizen1 with this conception of his city before his eyes1 to see to it that the state's part in the contract was fulfilled4 ,from his ancestors had been inherited the tradition1 which told him the when1 where1 and how1 and in the preservation of that tradition and its due performance consisted at once ,rome's duty and her glory4 ',if we wish1' says ,cicero1 'to compare ourselves with other nations1 we may be found in other respects equal or even inferior2 in religion1 that is in the worship of the gods1 we are far superior4' ,the religion of ,rome may not have advanced the theology or the ethics of the world1 but it made and held together a nation4 ,,works ,,bearing ,,on ,,the ,,early ,,religion ,,of ,,rome ,the ,golden ,bough1 7#bnd ,ed474 ,j4,g4 ,,frazer4 ,history of ,rome1 ,,book ,i4 ,,chap ,,xii4 ,,th4 ,,mommsen4 ,die ,religion der ,roemer4 ,e4 ,,aust4 ,religion und ,kultus der ,roemer4 ,g4 ,,wissowa4 ,il ,culto ,privato di ,roma ,antica1 ,,part ,i4 ,a4 ,,de-,,marchi4 ,the ,roman ,festivals4 ,w4 ,,warde ,,fowler4 ,the ,religion of ,numa4 ,j4,b4 ,,carter4 ,printed by ,t4 and ,a4 ,,constable1 ,printers to ,his ,majesty at the ,edinburgh ,university ,press 99 99 99 99 99