,transcribed from the #aijf ,archibald ,constable ,co4 ,ltd4 edition by ,david ,price1 ccx#jgd;coventry4ac4uk ,,celtic ,,religion ,,in ,,pre-,,christian ,,times ,by ,,edward ,,anwyl1 ,m4,a4 ,,late ,,classical ,,scholar ,,of ,,oriel ,,college1 ,,oxford ,,professor ,,of ,,welsh ,,and ,,comparative ,,philology ,,at ,,the ,,university ,,college ,,of ,,wales1 ,,aberystwyth ,,acting-,,chairman ,,of ,,the ,,central ,,welsh ,,board ,,for ,,intermediate ,,education ,,london ,,archibald ,,constable ,,co ,,ltd #af ,,james ,,street ,,haymarket #aijf ,edinburgh3 ,t4 and ,a4 ,,constable1 ,printers to ,his ,majesty ,,foreword ,it is only as prehistoric archaeology has come to throw more and more light on the early civilisations of ,celtic lands that it has become possible to interpret ,celtic religion from a thoroughly modern viewpoint4 ,the author cordially acknowledges his indebtedness to numerous writers on this subject1 but his researches into some portions of the field especially have suggested to him the possibility of giving a new presentation to certain facts and groups of facts1 which the existing evidence disclosed4 ,it is to be hoped that a new interest in the religion of the ,celts may thereby be aroused4 ,e4 ,,anwyl4 ,,aberystwyth1 ,february #ae1 #aijf4 ,,chapter ,i--,,introductory3 ,,the ,,celts ,in dealing with the subject of ',celtic ,religion' the first duty of the writer is to explain the sense in which the term ',celtic' will be used in this work4 ,it will be used in reference to those countries and districts which1 in historic times1 have been at one time or other mainly of ,celtic speech4 ,it does not follow that all the races which spoke a form of the ,celtic tongue1 a tongue of the ,indo-,european family1 were all of the same stock4 ,indeed1 ethnological and archaeological evidence tends to establish clearly that1 in ,gaul and ,britain1 for example1 man had lived for ages before the introduction of any variety of ,aryan or ,indo-,european speech1 and this was probably the case throughout the whole of ,western and ,southern ,europe4 ,further1 in the light of comparative philology1 it has now become abundantly clear that the forms of ,indo-,european speech which we call ,celtic are most closely related to those of the ,italic family1 of which family ,latin is the best known representative4 ,from this it follows that we are to look for the centre of dissemination of ,aryan ,celtic speech in some district of ,europe that could have been the natural centre of dissemination also for the ,italic languages4 ,from this common centre1 through conquest and the commercial intercourse which followed it1 the tribes which spoke the various forms of ,celtic and ,italic speech spread into the districts occupied by them in historic times4 ,the common centre of radiation for ,celtic and ,italic speech was probably in the districts of ,noricum and ,pannonia1 the modern ,carniola1 ,carinthia1 etc41 and the neighbouring parts of the ,danube valley4 ,the conquering ,aryan-speaking ,celts and ,italians formed a military aristocracy1 and their success in extending the range of their languages was largely due to their skill in arms1 combined1 in all probability1 with a talent for administration4 ,this military aristocracy was of kindred type to that which carried ,aryan speech into ,india and ,persia1 ,armenia and ,greece1 not to speak of the original speakers of the ,teutonic and ,slavonic tongues4 ,in view of the necessity of discovering a centre1 whence the ,indo-,european or ,aryan languages in general could have radiated ,eastwards1 as well as ,westwards1 the tendency to-day is to regard these tongues as having been spoken originally in some district between the ,carpathians and the ,steppes1 in the form of kindred dialects of a common speech4 ,some branches of the tribes which spoke these dialects penetrated into ,central ,europe1 doubtless along the ,danube1 and1 from the ,danube valley1 extended their conquests together with their various forms of ,aryan speech into ,southern and ,western ,europe4 ,the proportion of conquerors to conquered was not uniform in all the countries where they held sway1 so that the amount of ,aryan blood in their resultant population varied greatly4 ,in most cases1 the families of the original conquerors1 by their skill in the art of war and a certain instinct of government1 succeeded in making their own tongues the dominant media of communication in the lands where they ruled1 with the result that most of the languages of ,europe to-day are of the ,aryan or ,indo-,european type4 ,it does not1 however1 follow necessarily from this that the early religious ideas or the artistic civilisation of countries now ,aryan in speech1 came necessarily from the conquerors rather than the conquered4 ,in the last century it was long held that in countries of ,aryan speech the essential features of their civilisation1 their religious ideas1 their social institutions1 nay1 more1 their inhabitants themselves1 were of ,aryan origin4 ,a more critical investigation has1 however1 enabled us to distinguish clearly between the development of various factors of human life which in their evolution can follow and often have followed more or less independent lines4 ,the physical history of race1 for instance1 forms a problem by itself and must be studied by anthropological and ethnological methods4 ,language1 again1 has often spread along lines other than those of race1 and its investigation appertains to the sphere of the philologist4 ,material civilisation1 too1 has not of necessity followed the lines either of racial or of linguistic development1 and the search for its ancient trade-routes may be safely left to the archaeologist4 ,similarly the spread of ideas in religion and thought is one which has advanced on lines of its own1 and its investigation must be conducted by the methods and along the lines of the comparative study of religions4 ,in the wide sense1 then1 in which the word ',celtic religion' will be used in this work1 it will cover the modes of religious thought prevalent in the countries and districts1 which1 in course of time1 were mainly characterised by their ,celtic speech4 ,to the sum-total of these religious ideas contributions have been made from many sources4 ,it would be rash to affirm that the various streams of ,aryan ,celtic conquest made no contributions to the conceptions of life and of the world which the countries of their conquest came to hold 7and the evidence of language points1 indeed1 to some such contributions71 but their quota appears to be small compared with that of their predecessors2 nor is this surprising1 in view of the immense period during which the lands of their conquest had been previously occupied4 ,nothing is clearer than the marvellous persistence of traditional and immemorial modes of thought1 even in the face of conquest and subjugation1 and1 whatever ideas on religion the ,aryan conquerors of ,celtic lands may have brought with them1 they whose conquests were often only partial could not eradicate the inveterate beliefs of their predecessors1 and the result in the end was doubtless some compromise1 or else the victory of the earlier faith4 ,but the ,aryan conquerors of ,gaul and ,italy themselves were not men who had advanced up the ,danube in one generation4 ,those men of ,aryan speech who poured into the ,italian peninsula and into ,gaul were doubtless in blood not unmixed with the older inhabitants of ,central ,europe1 and had entered into the body of ideas which formed the religious beliefs of the men of the ,danube valley4 ,the common modifications of the ,aryan tongue1 by ,italians and ,celts alike1 as compared with ,greek1 suggests contact with men of different speech4 ,among the names of ,celtic gods1 too1 like those of other countries1 we find roots that are apparently irreducible to any found in ,indo-,european speech1 and we know not what pre-,aryan tongues may have contributed them4 ,scholars1 to-day1 are far more alive than they ever were before to the complexity of the contributory elements that have entered into the tissue of the ancient religions of mankind1 and the more the relics of ,celtic religion are investigated1 the more complex do its contributory factors become4 ,in the long ages before history there were unrecorded conquests and migrations innumerable1 and ideas do not fail to spread because there is no historian to record them4 ,the more the scanty remnants of ,celtic religion are examined1 the clearer it becomes that many of its characteristic features had been evolved during the vast period of the ages of stone4 ,during these millennia1 men had evolved1 concomitantly with their material civilisation1 a kind of working philosophy of life1 traces of which are found in every land where this form of civilisation has prevailed4 ,man's religion can never be dissociated from his social experience1 and the painful stages through which man reached the agricultural life1 for example1 have left their indelible impress on the mind of man in ,western ,europe1 as they have in every land4 ,we are thus compelled1 from the indications which we have of ,celtic religion1 in the names of its deities1 its rites1 and its survivals in folk-lore and legend1 to come to the conclusion1 that its fundamental groundwork is a body of ideas1 similar to those of other lands1 which were the natural correlatives of the phases of experience through which man passed in his emergence into civilised life4 ,to demonstrate and to illustrate these relations will be the aim of the following chapters4 ,,chapter ,,ii--,,the ,,chief ,,phases ,,of ,,celtic ,,civilisation ,in the chief countries of ,celtic civilisation1 ,gaul1 ,cisalpine and ,transalpine1 ,britain and ,ireland1 abundant materials have been found for elucidating the stages of culture through which man passed in prehistoric times4 ,in ,britain1 for example1 palaeolithic man has left numerous specimens of his implements1 but the forms even of these rude implements suggest that they1 too1 have been evolved from still more primitive types4 ,some antiquarians have thought to detect such earlier types in the stones that have been named 'eoliths' found in ,kent1 but1 though these 'eoliths' may possibly show human use1 the question of their history is far from being settled4 ,it is certain1 however1 that man succeeded in maintaining himself for ages in the company of the mammoth1 the cave-bear1 and other animals now extinct4 ,whether palaeolithic man survived the ,ice ,age in ,britain has not so far been satisfactorily decided4 ,in ,gaul1 however1 there is fair evidence of continuity between the ,palaeolithic and ,neolithic periods1 and this continuity must obviously have existed somewhere4 ,still in spite of the indications of continuity1 the civilisation of primitive man in ,gaul presents one aspect that is without any analogues in the life of the palaeolithic men of the ,river ,drift period1 or in that of man of the ,new ,stone ,age4 ,the feature in question is the remarkable artistic skill shown by the cave men of the ,dordogne district4 ,some of the drawings and carvings of these men reveal a sense of form which would have done credit to men of a far later age4 ,a feature such as this1 whatever may have been its object1 whether it arose from an effort by means of 'sympathetic magic' to catch animals1 as ,m4 ,salomon ,reinach suggests1 or to the mere artistic impulse1 is a standing reminder to us of the scantiness of our data for estimating the lines of man's religious and other development in the vast epochs of prehistoric time4 ,we know that from the life of hunting man passed into the pastoral stage1 having learned to tame animals4 ,how he came to do so1 and by what motives he was actuated1 is still a mystery4 ,it may be1 as ,m4 ,salomon ,reinach has also suggested1 that it was some curious and indefinable sense of kinship with them that led him to do so1 or more probably1 as the present writer thinks1 some sense of a need of the alliance of animals against hostile spirits4 ,in all probability it was no motive which we can now fathom4 ,the mind of early man was like the unfathomable mind of a boy4 ,from the pastoral life again man passed after long ages into the life of agriculture1 and the remains of neolithic man in ,gaul and in ,britain give us glimpses of his life as a farmer4 ,the ox1 the sheep1 the pig1 the goat1 and the dog were his domestic animals2 he could grow wheat and flax1 and could supplement the produce of his farm by means of hunting and fishing4 ,neolithic man could spin and weave2 he could obtain the necessary flint for his implements1 which he made by chipping and polishing1 and he could also make pottery of a rude variety4 ,in its essentials we have here the beginnings of the agricultural civilisation of man all the world over4 ,in life1 neolithic man dwelt sometimes in pit-dwellings and sometimes in hut-circles1 covered with a roof of branches supported by a central pole4 ,in death1 he was buried with his kin in long mounds of earth called barrows1 in chambered cairns and cromlechs or dolmens4 ,the latter usually consist of three standing stones covered by a cap-stone2 forming the stony skeleton of a grave that has been exposed to view after the mound of earth that covered it has been washed away4 ,in their graves the dead were buried in a crouching attitude1 and fresh burials were made as occasion required4 ,sometimes the cromlech is double1 and occasionally there is a hole in one of the stones1 the significance of which is unknown1 unless it may have been for the ingress and egress of souls4 ,graves of the dolmen or cromlech type are found in all the countries of ,western ,europe1 ,north ,africa1 and elsewhere1 wherever stone suitable for the purpose abounds1 and in this we have a striking illustration of the way in which lines of development in man's material civilisation are sooner or later correlated to his geographical1 geological1 and other surroundings4 ,the religious ideas of man in neolithic times also came into correlation with the conditions of his development1 and the uninterpreted stone circles and pillars of the world are a standing witness to the religious zeal of a mind that was haunted by stone4 ,before proceeding to exemplify this thesis the subsequent trend of ,celtic civilisation may be briefly sketched4 ,through the pacific intercourse of commerce1 bronze weapons and implements began to find their way1 about #bjjj ,b4,c4 or earlier1 from ,central and ,southern ,europe into ,gaul1 and thence into ,britain4 ,in ,britain the ,bronze ,age begins at about #aejj or #adjj ,b4,c41 and it is thought by some archaeologists that bronze was worked at this period by the aid of native tin in ,britain itself4 ,there are indications1 however1 that the introduction of bronze into ,britain was not by way of commerce alone4 ,about the beginning of the ,bronze period are found evidences in this island of a race of different type from that of neolithic man1 being characterised by a round skull and a powerful build1 and by general indications of a martial bearing4 ,the remains of this race are usually found in round barrows4 ,this race1 which certainly used bronze weapons1 is generally believed to have been the first wave that reached ,britain of ,aryan conquerors of ,celtic speech from the nearest part of the continent1 where it must have arrived some time previously1 probably along the ,rhine valley4 ,as the type of ,celtic speech that has penetrated farthest to the west is that known as the ,goidelic or ,irish1 it has not unreasonably been thought that this must have been the type that arrived in ,britain first4 ,there are indications1 too1 that it was this type that penetrated furthest into the west of ,gaul4 ,its most marked characteristic is its preservation of the pronunciation of ,u as 'oo' and of ,,qu1 while the ',brythonic' or ,welsh variety changed ,u to a sound pronounced like the ,french 'u' or the ,german 'u' and also ,,qu to ,p4 ,there is a similar line of cleavage in the ,italic languages1 where ,latin corresponds to ,goidelic1 and ,oscan and ,umbrian to ,brythonic4 ,transalpine ,gaul was probably invaded by ,aryan-speaking ,celts from more than one direction1 and the infiltration and invasion of new- comers1 when it had once begun1 was doubtless continuous through these various channels4 ,there are cogent reasons for thinking that ultimately the dominant type of ,celtic speech over the greater part of ,gaul came to be that of the ,p rather than the ,,qu type1 owing to the influx from the ,east and ,northeast of an overflow from the ,rhine valley of tribes speaking that dialect2 a dialect which1 by force of conquest and culture1 tended to spread farther and farther ,west4 ,into ,britain1 too1 as time went on1 the ,p type of ,celtic was carried1 and has survived in ,welsh and ,cornish1 the remnants of the tongue of ancient ,britain4 ,we know1 too1 from the name ,eporedia 7,yvrea71 that this dialect of ,celtic must have spread into ,cisalpine ,gaul4 ,the latter district may have received its first ,celtic invaders direct from the ,danube valley1 as ,m4 ,alexandre ,bertrand held1 but it would be rash to assume that all its invaders came from that direction4 ,in connection1 however1 with the history of ,celtic religion it is not the spread of the varying types of ,celtic dialect that is important1 but the changes in the civilisation of ,gaul and ,britain1 which reacted on religious ideas or which introduced new factors into the religious development of these lands4 ,the predatory expeditions and wars of conquest of military ,celtic tribes in search for new homes for their superfluous populations brought into prominence the deities of war1 as was the case also with the ancient ,romans1 themselves an agricultural and at the same time a predatory race4 ,the prominence of war in ,celtic tribal life at one stage has left us the names of a large number of deities that were identified with ,mars and ,bellona1 though all the war-gods were not originally such4 ,in the ,roman calendar there is abundant evidence that ,mars was at one time an agricultural god as well as a god of war4 ,the same1 as will be shown later1 was the probable history of some of the ,celtic deities1 who were identified in ,roman times with ,mars and ,bellona4 ,caesar tells us that ,mars had at one time been the chief god of the ,gauls1 and that in ,germany that was still the case4 ,in ,britain1 also1 we find that there were several deities identified with ,mars1 notably ,belatucadrus and ,cocidius1 and this1 too1 points in the direction of a development of religion under military influence4 ,the ,gauls appear to have made great strides in military matters and in material civilisation during the ,iron ,age4 ,the culture of the ,early ,iron ,age of ,hallstatt had been developed in ,gaul on characteristic lines of its own1 resulting in the form now known as the ,la ,tene or ,marnian type4 ,this type derives it name from the striking specimens of it that were discovered at ,la ,tene on the shore of ,lake ,neuchatel1 and in the extensive cemeteries of the ,marne valley1 the burials of which cover a period of from #cej-bjj ,b4,c4 ,it was during the third century ,b4,c4 that this characteristic culture of ,gaul reached its zenith1 and gave definite shape to the beautiful curved designs known as those of ,late-,celtic ,art4 ,iron appears to have been introduced into ,britain about #cjj ,b4,c41 and the designs of ,late-,celtic ,art are here represented best of all4 ,excellent specimens of ,late-,celtic culture have been found in ,yorkshire and elsewhere1 and important links with continental developments have been discovered at ,aylesford1 ,aesica1 ,limavady1 and other places4 ,into the development of this typical ,gaulish culture elements are believed to have entered by way of the important commercial avenue of the ,rhone valley from ,massilia 7,marseilles71 from ,greece 7via ,venetia71 and possibly from ,etruria4 ,prehistoric archaeology affords abundant proofs that1 in countries of ,celtic speech1 metal-working in bronze1 iron1 and gold reached a remarkably high pitch of perfection1 and this is a clear indication that ,celtic countries and districts which were on the line of trade routes1 like the ,rhone valley1 had attained to a material civilisation of no mean character before the ,roman conquest4 ,in ,britain1 too1 the districts that were in touch with continental commerce had1 as ,caesar tells us1 also developed in the same direction4 ,the religious counterpart of this development in civilisation is the growth in many parts of ,gaul1 as attested by ,caesar and by many inscriptions and place-names1 of the worship of gods identified with ,mercury and ,minerva1 the deities of civilisation and commerce4 ,it is no accident that one of the districts most conspicuous for this worship was the territory of the ,allobrogic confederation1 where the commerce of the ,rhone valley found its most remarkable development4 ,from this sketch of ,celtic civilisation it will readily be seen how here as elsewhere the religious development of the ,celts stood closely related to the development of their civilisation generally4 ,it must be borne in mind1 however1 that all parts of the ,celtic world were not equally affected by the material development in question4 ,part of the complexity of the history of ,celtic religion arises from the fact that we cannot be always certain of the degree of progress in civilisation which any given district had made1 of the ideas which pervaded it1 or of the absorbing interests of its life4 ,another difficulty1 too1 is that the accounts of ,celtic religion given by ancient authorities do not always harmonise with the indisputable evidence of inscriptions4 ,the probability is that the religious practices of the ,celtic world were no more homogeneous than its general civilisation1 and that the ancient authorities are substantially true in their statements about certain districts1 certain periods1 or certain sections of society1 while the inscriptions1 springing as they do from the influence of the ,gallo-,roman civilisation1 especially of ,eastern ,gaul and military ,britain1 give us most valuable supplementary evidence for districts and environments of a different kind4 ,the inscriptions1 especially by the names of deities which they reveal1 have afforded most valuable clues to the history of ,celtic religion1 even in stages of civilisation earlier than those to which they themselves belong4 ,in the next chapter the correlation of ,celtic religious ideas to the stages of ,celtic civilisation will be further developed4 ,,chapter ,,iii--,,the ,,correlation ,,of ,,celtic ,,religion ,,with ,,the ,,growth ,,of ,,celtic ,,civilisation ,in dealing with the long vista of prehistoric time1 it is very difficult for us1 in our effort after perspective1 not to shorten unduly in our thoughts the vast epochs of its duration4 ,we tend1 too1 to forget1 that in these unnumbered millennia there was ample time for it to be possible over certain areas of ,europe to evolve what were practically new races1 through the prepotency of particular stocks and the annihilation of others4 ,during these epochs1 again1 after speech had arisen1 there was time enough to recast completely many a language1 for before the dawn of history language was no more free from change than it is now1 and in these immense epochs whatever ideas as to the world of their surroundings were vaguely felt by prehistoric men and formulated for them by their kinsmen of genius1 had abundant time in which to die or to win supremacy4 ,there must have been aeons before the dawn even of conscious animism1 and the experiment of trying sympathetic magic was1 when first attempted1 probably regarded as a master-stroke of genius4 ,the ,stone ,age itself was a long era of great if slow progress in civilisation1 and the evolution of the practices and ideas which emerge as the concomitants of its agricultural stage1 when closely regarded1 bear testimony to the mind's capacity for religious progress in the light of experience and intelligent experiment1 and at the same time to the errors into which it fell4 ,the ,stone ,age has left its sediment in all the folk-lore of the world4 ,to the casual observer many of the ideas embedded in it may seem a mass of error1 and so they are when judged unhistorically1 but when viewed critically1 and at the same time historically1 they afford many glimpses of prehistoric genius in a world where life was of necessity a great experiment4 ,the folk-lore of the world reveals for the same stages of civilisation a wonderful uniformity and homogeneity1 as ,dr4 ,j4 ,g4 ,frazer has abundantly shown in his ,golden ,bough4 ,this uniformity is not1 however1 due to necessary uniformity of origin1 but to a great extent to the fact that it represents the state of equilibrium arrived at between minds at a certain level and their environment1 along lines of thought directed by the momentum given by the traditions of millennia1 and the survival in history of the men who carefully regarded them4 ,the apparently unreasoned prohibitions often known as 'taboos1' many of which still persist even in modern civilised life1 have their roots in ideas and experiences which no speculation of ours can now completely fathom1 however much we may guess at their origin4 ,many of these ancient prohibitions have vanished under new conditions1 others have often survived from a real or supposed harmony with new experiences1 that have arisen in the course of man's history4 ,after passing through a stage when he was too preoccupied with his material cares and wants to consider whether he was haunted or not1 early man in the ,celtic world as elsewhere1 after long epochs of vague unrest1 came to realise that he was somehow haunted in the daytime as well as at night1 and it was this sense of being haunted that impelled his intellect and his imagination to seek some explanation of his feelings4 ,primitive man came to seek a solution not of the ,universe as a whole 7for of this he had no conception71 but of the local ,universe1 in which he played a part4 ,in dealing with ,celtic folk-lore1 it is very remarkable how it mirrors the characteristic local colouring and scenery of the districts in which it has originated4 ,in a country like ,wales1 for example1 it is the folk-lore of springs1 caves1 mountains1 lakes1 islands1 and the forms of its imagination1 here as elsewhere1 reflect unmistakably the land of its origin4 ,where it depicts an 'other world1' that 'other world' is either on an island or it is a land beneath the sea1 a lake1 or a river1 or it is approachable only through some cave or opening in the earth4 ,in the hunting-grounds of the ,celtic world the primitive hunter knew every cranny of the greater part of his environment with the accuracy born of long familiarity1 but there were some peaks which he could not scale1 some caves which he could not penetrate1 some jungles into which he could not enter1 and in these he knew not what monsters might lurk or unknown beings might live4 ,in ,celtic folk-lore the belief in fabulous monsters has not yet ceased4 ,man was surrounded by dangers visible and invisible1 and the time came when some prehistoric man of genius propounded the view that all the objects around him were no less living than himself4 ,this animistic view of the world1 once adopted1 made great headway from the various centres where it originated1 and man derived from it a new sense of kinship with his world1 but also new terrors from it4 ,knowing from the experience of dreams that he himself seemed able to wander away from himself1 he thought in course of time that other living things were somehow double1 and the world around him came to be occupied1 not merely with things that were alive1 but with other selves of these things1 that could remain in them or leave them at will4 ,here1 again1 this new prehistoric philosophy gave an added interest to life1 but it was none the less a source of fresh terrors4 ,the world swarmed with invisible spirits1 some friendly1 some hostile1 and1 in view of these beings1 life had to be regulated by strict rules of actions and prohibitions4 ,even in the neolithic stage the inhabitants of ,celtic countries had attained to the religious ideas in question1 as is seen not only by their folk-lore and by the names of groups of goddesses such as the ,matres 7or mothers71 but by the fact that in historic times they had advanced well beyond this stage to that of named and individualised gods4 ,as in all countries where the gods were individualised1 the men of ,celtic lands1 whether aborigines or invaders1 had toiled along the steep ascent from the primitive vague sense of being haunted to a belief in gods who1 like ,esus1 ,teutates1 ,grannos1 ,bormanus1 ,litavis1 had names of a definite character4 ,among the prohibitions which had established themselves among the races of ,celtic lands1 as elsewhere1 was that directed against the shedding of the blood of one's own kin4 ,there are indications1 too1 that some at any rate of the tribes inhabiting these countries reckoned kinship through the mother1 as in fact continued to be the case among the ,picts of ,scotland into historic times4 ,it does not follow1 as we know from other countries1 that the pre-,aryan tribes of ,gaul and ,britain1 or indeed the ,aryan tribes themselves in their earliest stage1 regarded their original ancestors as human4 ,certain names of deities such as ,tarvos 7the bull71 ,moccos 7the pig71 ,epona 7the goddess of horses71 ,damona 7the goddess of cattle71 ,mullo 7the ass71 as well as the fact that the ancient ,britons1 according to ,caesar1 preserved the hen1 the goose1 and the hare1 but did not kill and eat them1 all point to the fact that in these countries as elsewhere certain animals were held in supreme respect and were carefully guarded from harm4 ,judging from the analogy of kindred phenomena in other countries1 the practice of respecting certain animals was often associated with the belief that all the members of certain clans were descended from one or other of them1 but how far this system was elaborated in the ,celtic world it is hard to say4 ,this phenomenon1 which is widely known as totemism1 appears to be suggested by the prominence given to the wild boar on ,celtic coins and ensigns1 and by the place assigned on some inscriptions and bas-reliefs to the figure of a horned snake as well as by the effigies of other animals that have been discovered4 ,it is not easy to explain the beginnings of totemism in ,gaul or elsewhere1 but it should always be borne in mind that early man could not regard it as an axiomatic truth that he was the superior of every other animal4 ,to reach that proud consciousness is a very high step in the development of the human perspective1 and it is to the credit of the ,celts that1 when we know them in historic times1 they appear to have attained to this height1 inasmuch as the human form is given to their deities4 ,it is not always remembered how great a step in religious evolution is implied when the gods are clothed with human attributes4 ,m4 ,salomon ,reinach1 in his account of the vestiges of totemism among the ,celts1 suggests that totemism was merely the hypertrophy of early man's social sense1 which extended from man to the animals around him4 ,this may possibly be the case1 but it is not improbable that man also thought to discover in certain animals much-needed allies against some of the visible and invisible enemies that beset him4 ,in his conflict with the malign powers around him1 he might well have regarded certain animals as being in some respects stronger combatants against those powers than himself2 and where they were not physically stronger1 some of them1 like the snake1 had a cunning and a subtlety that seemed far to surpass his own4 ,in course of time certain bodies of men came to regard themselves as being in special alliance with some one animal1 and as being descended from that animal as their common ancestor4 ,the existence side by side of various tribes1 each with its definite totem1 has not yet been fully proved for the ,gaulish system1 and may well have been a developed social arrangement that was not an essential part of such a mode of thought in its primary forms4 ,the place of animal-worship in the ,celtic religion will be more fully considered in a later chapter4 ,here it is only indicated as a necessary stage in relation to man's civilisation in the hunting and the pastoral stages1 which had to be passed through before the historic deities of ,gaul and ,britain in ,roman times could have come into being4 ,certain of the divine names of the historic period1 like ,artio 7the bear-goddess71 ,moccus 7the pig71 ,epona 7the mare71 and ,damona 7the sheep71 bear the unmistakable impress of having been at one time those of animals4 ,as for the stage of civilisation at which totemism originated1 there is much difference of opinion4 ,the stage of mind which it implies would suggest that it reflects a time when man's mind was preoccupied with wild beasts1 and when the alliances and friendships1 which he would value in life1 might be found in that sphere4 ,there is much plausibility in the view put forward by ,m4 ,salomon ,reinach1 that the domestication of animals itself implies a totemistic habit of thought1 and the consequent protection of these animals by means of taboos from harm and death4 ,it may well be that1 after all1 the usefulness of domestic animals from a material point of view was only a secondary consideration for man1 and a happy discovery after unsuccessful totemistic attentions to other animals4 ,we know not how many creatures early man tried to associate with himself but failed4 ,in all stages of man's history the alternation of the seasons must have brought some rudiments of order and system into his thoughts1 though for a long time he was too preoccupied to reflect upon the regularly recurring vicissitudes of his life4 ,in the pastoral stage1 the sense of order came to be more marked than in that of hunting1 and quickened the mind to fresh thought4 ,the earth came to be regarded as the ,mother from whom all things came1 and there are abundant indications that the earth as the ,mother1 the ,queen1 the ,long-lived one1 etc41 found her natural place as a goddess among the ,celts4 ,her names and titles were probably not in all places or in all tribes the same4 ,but it is in the agricultural stage that she entered in ,celtic lands1 as she did in other countries1 into her completest religious heritage1 and this aspect of ,celtic religion will be dealt with more fully in connection with the spirits of vegetation4 ,this phase of religion in ,celtic countries is one which appears to underlie some of its most characteristic forms1 and the one which has survived longest in ,celtic folk-lore4 ,the ,earth-mother with her progeny of spirits1 of springs1 rivers1 mountains1 forests1 trees1 and corn1 appears to have supplied most of the grouped and individualised gods of the ,celtic pantheon4 ,the ,dis1 of whom ,caesar speaks as the ancient god of the ,gauls1 was probably regarded as her son1 to whom the dead returned in death4 ,whether he is the ,gaulish god depicted with a hammer1 or as a huge dog swallowing the dead1 has not yet been established with any degree of certainty4 ,,chapter ,,iv--,,celtic ,,religion ,,and ,,the ,,development ,,of ,,individualised ,,deities ,like other religions1 those of the ,celtic lands of ,europe supplemented the earlier animism by a belief in spirits1 who belonged to trees1 animals1 rocks1 mountains1 springs1 rivers1 and other natural phenomena1 and in folk-lore there still survives abundant evidence that the ,celt regarded spirits as taking upon themselves a variety of forms1 animal and human4 ,it was this idea of spirits in animal form that helped to preserve the memory of the older totemism into historic times4 ,it is thus that we have names of the type of ,brannogenos 7son of the raven71 ,artogenos 7son of the bear71 and the like1 not to speak of simpler names like ,bran 7raven71 ,march 7horse71 surviving into historic times4 ,bronze images1 too1 have been found at ,neuvy-en-,sullias1 of a horse and a stag 7now in the ,orleans museum71 provided with rings1 which were1 as ,m4 ,salomon ,reinach suggests1 probably used for the purpose of carrying these images in procession4 ,the wild boar1 too1 was a favourite emblem of ,gaul1 and there is extant a bronze figure of a ,celtic ,diana riding on a boar's back4 ,at ,bolar1 near ,nuits1 there was discovered a bronze mule4 ,in the museum at ,mayence is a bas-relief of the goddess of horses1 ,epona 7from the ,gaulish ,epos,lat4 equus1 horse71 riding on horseback4 ,one of the most important monuments of this kind is a figure of ,artio1 the bear-goddess 7from ,celtic ,artos1 a bear71 found at ,muri near ,berne4 ,in front of her stood a figure of a bear1 which was also found with her4 ,the bull of the ,tarvos ,trigaranos bas-relief of ,notre ,dame was also in all likelihood originally a totem1 and similarly the horned serpents of other bas-reliefs1 as well as the boar found on ,gaulish ensigns and coins1 especially in ,belgic territory4 ,there is a representation1 too1 of a raven on a bas-relief at ,compiegne4 ,the name ',moccus1' which is identified with ,mercury1 on inscriptions1 and which is found inscribed at ,langres1 ,trobaso1 the valley of the ,ossola and the ,borgo san ,dalmazzo1 is undoubtedly the philological equivalent of the ,welsh moch 7swine74 ,in ,britain1 too1 the boar is frequently found on the coins of the ,iceni and other tribes4 ,in ,italy1 according to ,mr4 ,warde ,fowler1 the pig was an appropriate offering to deities of the earth1 so that in the widespread use of the pig as a symbol in the ,celtic world1 there may be some ancient echo of a connection between it and the earth-spirit4 ,its diet of acorns1 too1 may have marked it out1 in the early days of life in forest- clearings1 as the animal embodiment of the oak-spirit4 ,in the legends of the ,celtic races1 even in historic times1 the pig1 and especially the boar1 finds an honoured place4 ,in addition to the animals aforementioned1 the ass1 too1 was probably at one time venerated in one of the districts of ,gaul1 and it is not improbable that ,mullo1 the name of a god identified with ,mars and regarded as the patron of muleteers1 mentioned on inscriptions 7at ,nantes1 ,craon1 and ,les ,provencheres near ,craon71 meant originally 'an ass4' ,the goddess ,epona1 also1 whose worship was widely spread1 was probably at one time an animal goddess in the form of a mare1 and the name of another goddess1 ,damona1 either from the root dam,ir4 dam1 7ox72 or ,welsh daf-ad 7sheep71 may similarly be that of an ancient totem sheep or cow4 ,nor was it in the animal world alone that the ,celts saw indications of the divine4 ,while the chase and the pastoral life concentrated the mind's attention on the life of animals1 the growth of agriculture fixed man's thoughts on the life of the earth1 and all that grew upon it1 while at the same time he was led to think more and more of the mysterious world beneath the earth1 from which all things came and to which all things returned4 ,nor could he forget the trees of the forest1 especially those which1 like the oak1 had provided him with their fruit as food in time of need4 ,the name ,druid1 as well as that of the centre of worship of the ,gauls of ,asia ,minor1 ,drunemeton 7the oak-grove71 the statement of ,maximus of ,tyre that the representation of ,zeus to the ,celts was a high oak1 ,pliny's account of ,druidism 7,nat4 ,hist41 xvi4 #ie71 the numerous inscriptions to ,silvanus and ,silvana1 the mention of ,dervones or ,dervonnae on an inscription at ,cavalzesio near ,brescia1 and the abundant evidence of survivals in folk- lore as collected by ,dr4 ,j4 ,g4 ,frazer and others1 all point to the fact that tree-worship1 and especially that of the oak1 had contributed its full share to the development of ,celtic religion1 at any rate in some districts and in some epochs4 ,the development of martial and commercial civilisation in later times tended to restrict its typical and more primitive developments to the more conservative parts of the ,celtic world4 ,the fact that in ,caesar's time its main centre in ,gaul was in the territory of the ,carnutes1 the tribe which has given its name to ,chartres1 suggests that its chief votaries were mainly in that part of the country4 ,this1 too1 was the district of the god ,esus 7the eponymous god of the ,essuvii71 and in some degree of ,teutates1 the cruelty of whose rites is mentioned by ,lucan4 ,it had occurred to the present writer1 before finding the same view expressed by ,m4 ,salomon ,reinach1 that the worship of ,esus in ,gaul was almost entirely local in character4 ,with regard to the rites of the ,druids1 ,caesar tells us that it was customary to make huge images of wickerwork1 into which human beings1 usually criminals1 were placed and burnt4 ,the use of wickerwork1 and the suggestion that the rite was for purifying the land1 indicates a combination of the ideas of tree-worship with those of early agricultural life4 ,when the ,emperor ,claudius is said by ,suetonius to have suppressed ,druidism1 what is meant is1 in all probability1 that the more inhuman rites were suppressed1 leading1 as the ,scholiasts on ,lucan seem to suggest1 to a substitution of animal victims for men4 ,on the side of civil administration and education1 the functions of the ,druids1 as the successors of the primitive medicine men and magicians1 doubtless varied greatly in different parts of ,gaul and ,britain according to the progress that had been made in the differentiation of functions in social life4 ,the more we investigate the state of the ,celtic world in ancient times1 the clearer it becomes1 that in civilisation it was very far from being homogeneous1 and this heterogeneity of civilisation must have had its influence on religion as well as on other social phenomena4 ,the natural conservatism of agricultural life1 too1 perpetuated many practices even into comparatively late times1 and of these we catch a glimpse in ,gregory of ,tours1 when he tells us that at ,autun the goddess ,berecyntia was worshipped1 her image being carried on a wagon for the protection of the fields and the vines4 ,it is not impossible that by ,berecyntia ,gregory means the goddess ,brigindu1 whose name occurs on an inscription at ,volnay in the same district of ,gaul4 ,the belief in corn-spirits1 and other ideas connected with the central thought of the farmer's life1 show1 by their persistence in ,celtic as well as other folklore1 how deeply they had entered into the inner tissue of the agricultural mind1 so as to be linked to its keenest emotions4 ,here the rites of religion1 whether persuasive as in prayer1 or compulsory as in sympathetic magic1 whether associated with communal or propitiatory sacrifice1 whether directed to the earth or to the heaven1 all had an intensely practical and terribly real character1 due to man's constant preoccupation with the growth and storage of food for man and beast4 ,in the hunting1 the pastoral1 and above all in the agricultural life1 religion was not a matter merely of imagination or sentiment1 but one most intimately associated with the daily practice of life1 and this practical interest included in its purview rivers1 springs1 forests1 mountains1 and all the setting of man's existence4 ,and what is true of agriculture is true also1 in a greater or less degree1 of the life of the ,celtic metal-worker or the ,celtic sailor4 ,even in late ,welsh legend ,amaethon 7old ,celtic ,ambactonos71 the patron god of farming 7,welsh ,amaeth71 and ,gofannon1 the patron god of the metal-worker 7,welsh gof1 ,irish gobha71 were not quite forgotten1 and the prominence of the worship of the counterparts of ,mercury and ,minerva in ,gaul in historic times was due to the sense of respect and gratitude1 which each trade and each locality felt for the deity who had rid the land of monsters1 and who had brought man into the comparative calm of civilised life4 ,,chapter ,v--,,the ,,humanised ,,gods ,,of ,,celtic ,,religion ,one of the most striking facts connected with the ,celtic religion is the large number of names of deities which it includes4 ,these names are known to us almost entirely from inscriptions1 for the most part votive tablets1 in acknowledgment of some benefit1 usually that of health1 conferred by the god on man4 ,in ,britain these votive tablets are chiefly found in the neighbourhood of the ,roman walls and camps1 but we cannot be always certain that the deities mentioned are indigenous4 ,in ,gaul1 however1 we are on surer ground in associating certain deities with certain districts1 inasmuch as the evidence of place-names is often a guide4 ,these inscriptions are very unevenly distributed over ,gaulish territory1 the ,western and the ,north-,western districts being very sparsely represented4 ,in the present brief sketch it is impossible to enter into a full discussion of the relations of the names found on inscriptions to particular localities1 and the light thus thrown on ,celtic religion2 but it may be here stated that investigation tends to confirm the local character of most of the deities which the inscriptions name4 ,out of these deities1 some1 it is true1 in the process of evolution1 gained a wider field of worshippers1 while others1 like ,lugus1 may even have been at one time more widely worshipped than they came to be in later times4 ,occasionally a name like ,lugus 7,irish ,lug71 ,segomo 7,irish1 in the genitive1 ,segamonas71 ,camulos1 whence ,camulodunum 7,colchester71 ,belenos 7,welsh ,belyn71 ,maponos 7,welsh ,mabon71 ,litavis 7,welsh ,llydaw71 by its existence in ,britain as well as in ,gaul1 suggests that it was either one of the ancient deities of the ,aryan ,celts1 or one whose worship came to extend over a larger area than its fellows4 ,apart from a few exceptional considerations of this kind1 however1 the local character of the deities is most marked4 ,a very considerable number are the deities of springs and rivers4 ,in ,noricum1 for example1 we have ,adsalluta1 a goddess associated with ,savus 7the river ,save74 ,in ,britain 'the goddess' ,deva 7the ,dee71 and ,belisama 7either the ,ribble or the ,mersey71 a name meaning 'the most warlike goddess1' are of this type4 ,we have again ,axona the goddess of the river ,aisne1 ,sequana1 the goddess of the ,seine1 ,ritona of the river ,rieu1 numerous nymphs and many other deities of fountains4 ,doubtless many other names of local deities are of this kind4 ,aerial phenomena appear to have left very few clear traces on the names of ,celtic deities4 ,vintios1 a god identified with ,mars1 was probably a god of the wind1 ,taranucus1 a god of thunder1 ,leucetios1 a god of lightning1 ,sulis 7of ,bath7 a sun-goddess1 but beyond these there are few1 if any1 reflections of the phenomena of the heavens4 ,of the gods named on inscriptions nearly all are identified with ,mercury1 ,mars1 or ,apollo4 ,the gods who came to be regarded as culture-deities appear from their names to be of various origins3 some are humanised totems1 others are in origin deities of vegetation or local natural phenomena4 ,as already indicated1 it is clear that the growth of commercial and civilised life in certain districts had brought into prominence deities identified with ,mercury and ,minerva as the patrons of civilisation4 ,military men1 especially in ,britain1 appear to have favoured deities like ,belatucadros 7the brilliant in war71 identified with ,mars4 ,about fourteen inscriptions mentioning him have been found in the ,north of ,england and the ,south of ,scotland4 ,the goddess ,brigantia 7the patron- deity of the ,brigantes71 too1 is mentioned on four inscriptions3 ,cocidius1 identified with ,mars1 is mentioned on thirteen3 while another popular god appears to have been ,silvanus4 ,among the most noticeable names of the ,celtic gods identified with ,mercury are ,adsmerius or ,atesmerius1 ,dumiatis 7the god of the ,puy de ,dome71 ,iovantucarus 7the lover of youth71 ,teutates 7the god of the people71 ,caletos 7the hard71 and ,moccus 7the boar74 ,several deities are identified with ,mars1 and of these some of the most noticeable names are ,albiorix 7world-king71 ,caturix 7battle-king71 ,dunatis 7the god of the fort71 ,belatucadrus 7the brilliant in war71 ,leucetius 7the god of lightning71 ,mullo 7the mule71 ,ollovidius 7the all-knowing7 ,vintius 7the wind-god71 and ,vitucadrus 7the brilliant in energy74 ,the large number of names identified with ,mars reflects the prominent place at one time given to war in the ideas that affected the growth of the religion of the ,celtic tribes4 ,of the gods identified with ,hercules1 the most interesting name is ,ogmios 7the god of the furrow7 given by ,lucian1 but not found on any inscription4 ,the following gods too1 among others1 are identified with ,jupiter3 ,aramo 7the gentle71 ,ambisagrus 7the persistent71 ,bussumarus 7the large-lipped71 ,taranucus 7the thunderer71 ,uxellimus 7the highest74 ,it would seem from this that in historic times at any rate ,jupiter did not play a large part in ,celtic religious ideas4 ,there remains another striking feature of ,celtic religion which has not yet been mentioned1 namely the identification of several deities with ,apollo4 ,these deities are essentially the presiding deities of certain healing-springs and health-resorts1 and the growth of their worship into popularity is a further striking index to the development of religion side by side with certain aspects of civilisation4 ,one of the names of a ,celtic ,apollo is ,borvo 7whence ,bourbon71 the deity of certain hot springs4 ,this name is ,indo-,european1 and was given to the local fountain- god by the ,celtic-speaking invaders of ,gaul3 it simply means 'the ,boiler4' ,other forms of the name are also found1 as ,bormo and ,bormanus4 ,at ,aquae ,granni 7,aix-la-,chapelle7 and elsewhere the name identified with ,apollo is ,grannos4 ,we find also ,mogons1 and ,mogounus1 the patron deity of ,moguntiacum 7,mainz71 and1 once or twice1 ,maponos 7the great youth74 ,the essential feature of the ,apollo worship was its association in ,gallo- ,roman civilisation with the idea of healing1 an idea which1 through the revival of the worship of ,a,esculapius1 affected religious views very strongly in other quarters of the empire4 ,it was in this conception of the gods as the guides of civilisation and the restorers of health1 that ,celtic religion1 in some districts at any rate1 shows itself emerging into a measure of light after a long and toilsome progress from the darkness of prehistoric ideas4 ,what ,caesar says of the practice of the ,gauls of beginning the year with the night rather than with the day1 and their ancient belief that they were sprung from ,dis1 the god of the lower world1 is thus typified in their religious history4 ,in dealing with the deities of the ,celtic world we must not1 however1 forget the goddesses1 though their history presents several problems of great difficulty4 ,of these goddesses some are known to us by groups--,proximae 7the kinswomen71 ,dervonnae 7the oak-spirits71 ,niskai 7the water-sprites71 ,mairae1 ,matronae1 ,matres or ,matrae 7the mothers71 ,quadriviae 7the goddesses of cross roads74 ,the ,matres1 ,matrae1 and ,matronae are often qualified by some local name4 ,deities of this type appear to have been popular in ,britain1 in the neighbourhood of ,cologne and in ,provence4 ,in some cases it is uncertain whether some of these grouped goddesses are ,celtic or ,teutonic4 ,it is an interesting parallel to the existence of these grouped goddesses1 when we find that in some parts of ,wales ',y ,mamau' 7the mothers7 is the name for the fairies4 ,these grouped goddesses take us back to one of the most interesting stages in the early ,celtic religion1 when the earth-spirits or the corn-spirits had not yet been completely individualised4 ,of the individualised goddesses many are strictly local1 being the names of springs or rivers4 ,others1 again1 appear to have emerged into greater individual prominence1 and of these we find several associated on inscriptions1 sometimes with a god of ,celtic name1 but sometimes with his ,latin counterpart4 ,it is by no means certain that the names so linked together were thus associated in early times1 and the fashion may have been a later one1 which1 like other fashions1 spread after it had once begun4 ,the relationship in some cases may have been regarded as that of mother and son1 in others that of brother and sister1 in others that of husband and wife1 the data are not adequate for the final decision of the question4 ,of these associated pairs the following may be noted1 ,mercurius and ,rosmerta1 ,mercurius and ,dirona1 ,grannus 7,apollo7 and ,sirona1 ,sucellus and ,nantosvelta1 ,borvo and ,damona1 ,cicolluis 7,mars7 and ,litavis1 ,bormanus and ,bormana1 ,savus and ,adsalluta1 ,mars and ,nemetona4 ,one of these names1 ,sirona1 probably meant the long-lived one1 and was applied to the earth-mother4 ,in ,welsh one or two names have survived which1 by their structure1 appear to have been ancient names of goddesses2 these are ,rhiannon 7,rigantona1 the great queen71 and ,modron 7,matrona1 the great mother74 ,the other ,british deities will be more fully treated by another writer in this series in a work on the ancient mythology of the ,british ,isles4 ,it is enough to say that research tends more and more to confirm the view that the key to the history of the ,celtic deities is the realisation of the local character of the vast majority of them4 ,,chapter ,,vi--,,the ,,celtic ,,priesthood ,no name in connection with ,celtic religion is more familiar to the average reader than that of the ,druids1 yet there is no section of the history of ,celtic religion that has given rise to greater discussion than that relating to this order4 ,even the association of the name with the ,indo-,european root dru-1 which we find in the ,greek word drus1 an oak1 has been questioned by such a competent ,celtic scholar as ,m4 d',arbois de ,jubainville1 but on this point it cannot be said that his criticism is conclusive4 ,the writers of the ancient world who refer to the ,druids1 do not always make it sufficiently clear in what districts the rites1 ceremonies1 and functions which they were describing prevailed4 ,nor was it so much the priestly character of the ,druids that produced the deepest impression on the ancients4 ,to some philosophical and theological writers of antiquity their doctrines and their apparent affinities with ,pythagoreanism were of much greater interest than their ceremonial or other functions4 ,one thing at any rate is clear1 that the ,druids and their doctrines1 or supposed doctrines1 had made a deep impression on the writers of the ancient world4 ,there is a reference to them in a fragment of ,aristotle 7which may not1 however1 be genuine7 that is of interest as assigning them a place in express terms both among the ,celts and the ,galatae4 ,the prominent feature of their teaching which had attracted the attention of other writers1 such as the historian ,diodorus ,siculus and the ,christian theologian ,clement of ,alexandria1 was the resemblance of their doctrine concerning the immortality and transmigration of the soul to the views of ,pythagoras4 ,ancient writers1 however1 did not always remember that a religious or philosophical doctrine must not be treated as a thing apart1 but must be interpreted in its whole context in relation to its development in history and in the social life of the community in which it has flourished4 ,to some of the ancients the superficial resemblance between the ,druidic doctrine of the soul's future and the teaching attributed to ,pythagoras was the essential point1 and this was enough to give the ,druids a reputation for philosophy1 so that a writer like ,clement of ,alexandria goes so far as to regard the ,druids of the ',galatae' along with the prophets of the ,egyptians1 the ',chaldaeans' of the ,assyrians1 the 'philosophers of the ,celts1' and the ,magi of the ,persians as the pioneers of philosophy among the barbarians before it spread to the ,greeks4 ,the reason for the distinction drawn in this passage between the ',druids of the ,galatae' and 'the philosophers of the ,celts' is not clear4 ,diodorus ,siculus calls attention to the ,druidic doctrine that the souls of men were immortal1 and that after the lapse of an appointed number of years they came to life again1 the soul then entering into another body4 ,he says that there were certain 'philosophers and theologians' that were called ,druids who were held in exceptional honour4 ,in addition to these1 the ,celts1 he says1 had also seers1 who foretold the future from the flight of birds and by means of the offering of sacrifices4 ,according to him it was these priestly seers who had the masses in subjection to them4 ,in great affairs they had1 he says1 the practice of divination by the slaughter of a human victim1 and the observation of the attitude in which he fell1 the contortions of the limbs1 the spurting of the blood1 and the like4 ,this1 he states1 was an ancient and established practice4 ,moreover1 it was the custom1 according to ,diodorus1 to make no sacrifice without the presence of a philosopher 7apparently a ,druid in addition to the sacrificing seer71 the theory being that those who were authorities on the divine nature were to the gods intelligible mediators for the offering of gifts and the presentation of petitions4 ,these philosophers were in great request1 together with their poets1 in war as well as in peace1 and were consulted not merely by the men of their own side1 but also by those of the enemy4 ,even when two armies were on the point of joining battle1 these philosophers had been able1 ,diodorus says1 to step into the space between them and to stop them from fighting1 exactly as if they had charmed wild beasts4 ,the moral which ,diodorus draws from this is1 that even among the wildest of barbarians the spirited principle of the soul yields to wisdom1 and that ,ares 7the god of war7 even there respects the ,muses4 ,it is clear from this account that ,diodorus had in mind the three classes of non-military professional men among the ,celts1 to whom other ancient writers also refer1 namely1 the ,bards1 the ,seers1 and the ,druids4 ,his narrative is apparently an expansion1 in the light of his reading and philosophical meditation1 of information supplied by previous writers1 notably ,posidonius4 ,the latter1 too1 appears to have been ,julius ,caesar's chief authority1 in addition to his own observation1 but ,caesar does not appear expressly to indicate the triple division here in question4 ,the account which he gives is important1 and would be even more valuable than it is had he told us how far what he describes was written from his own personal information1 and the degree of variation 7if any7 of religious practice in different districts4 ,however1 ,caesar's statements deserve the closest consideration4 ,after calling attention to the division of the ,gaulish aristocracy into two main sections1 the ,druids and the ,knights1 he proceeds to speak of the ,druids4 ,these were occupied1 he says1 with religious matters1 they attended to public and private sacrifices1 and interpreted omens4 ,moreover1 they were the teachers of the country4 ,to them the young men congregated for knowledge1 and the pupils held their teachers in great respect4 ,they1 too1 were the judges in public and private disputes3 it was they who awarded damages and penalties4 ,any contumacy in reference to their judgments was punished by exclusion from the sacrifices4 ,this sentence of excommunication was the severest punishment among the ,gauls4 ,the men so punished were treated as outlaws1 and cut off from all human society1 with its rights and privileges4 ,over these ,druids there was one head1 who wielded the highest influence among them4 ,on his death the nearest of the others in dignity succeeded him1 or1 if several were equal1 the election of a successor was made by the vote of the ,druids4 ,sometimes the primacy was not decided without the arbitrament of arms4 ,the ,druids met at a fixed time of the year in a consecrated spot in the territory of the ,carnutes1 the district which was regarded as being in the centre of the whole of ,gaul4 ,this assembly of ,druids formed a court for the decision of cases brought to them from everywhere around4 ,it was thought1 ,caesar says1 that the doctrine of the ,druids was discovered in ,britain and thence carried over into ,gaul4 ,at that time1 too1 those who wanted to make a profounder study of it resorted thither for their training4 ,the ,druids had immunity from military service and from the payment of tribute4 ,these privileges drew many into training for the profession1 some of their own accord1 others at the instance of parents and relatives4 ,while in training they were said to learn by heart a large number of verses1 and some went so far as to spend twenty years in their course of preparation4 ,the ,druids held it wrong to put their religious teaching in writing1 though1 in almost everything else1 whether public or private affairs1 they made use of ,greek letters4 ,caesar thought that they discouraged writing on the one hand1 lest their teaching should become public property2 on the other1 lest reliance upon writing should lessen the cultivation of the memory4 ,to this risk ,caesar could testify from his own knowledge4 ,their cardinal doctrine was that souls did not perish1 but that after death they passed from one person to another2 and this they regarded as a supreme incentive to valour1 since1 with the prospect of immortality1 the fear of death counted for nothing4 ,they carried on1 moreover1 many discussions about the stars and their motion1 the greatness of the universe and the lands1 the nature of things1 the strength and power of the immortal gods1 and communicated their knowledge to their pupils4 ,in another passage ,caesar says that the ,gauls as a people were extremely devoted to religious ideas and practices4 ,men who were seriously ill1 who were engaged in war1 or who stood in any peril1 offered1 or promised to offer1 human sacrifices1 and made use of the ,druids as their agents for such sacrifices4 ,their theory was1 that the immortal gods could not be appeased unless a human life were given for a human life4 ,in addition to these private sacrifices1 they had also similar human sacrifices of a public character4 ,caesar further contrasts the ,germans with the ,gauls1 saying that the former had no ,druids to preside over matters of religion1 and that they paid no attention to sacrifices4 ,in his work on divination1 ,cicero1 too1 refers to the profession which the ,druids made of natural science1 and of the power of foretelling the future1 and instances the case of the ,a,eduan ,diviciacus1 his brother's guest and friend4 ,nothing is here said by ,cicero of the three classes implied in ,diodorus1 but ,timagenes 7quoted in ,ammianus7 refers to the three classes under the names 'bardi1' 'euhages' 7a mistake for 'vates'71 and 'drasidae' 7a mistake for 'druidae'74 ,the study of nature and of the heavens is here attributed to the second class of seers 7vates74 ,the highest class1 that of the ,druids1 were1 he says1 in accordance with the rule of ,pythagoras1 closely linked together in confraternities1 and by acquiring a certain loftiness of mind from their investigations into things that were hidden and exalted1 they despised human affairs and declared the soul immortal4 ,we see here the view expressed that socially as well as intellectually the ,druids lived according to the ,pythagorean philosophy4 ,origen also refers to the view that was prevalent in his time1 that ,zamolxis1 the servant of ,pythagoras1 had taught the ,druids the philosophy of ,pythagoras4 ,he further states that the ,druids practised sorcery4 ,the triple division of the non-military aristocracy is perhaps best given by ,strabo1 the ,greek geographer1 who here follows ,posidonius4 ,the three classes are the ,bards1 the ,seers 7ouateisvates71 and ,druids4 ,the ,bards were hymn-writers and poets1 the ,seers sacrificers and men of science1 while the ,druids1 in addition to natural science1 practised also moral philosophy4 ,they were regarded as the justest of men1 and on this account were intrusted with the settlement of private and public disputes4 ,they had been the means of preventing armies from fighting when on the very verge of battle1 and were especially intrusted with the judgment of cases involving human life4 ,according to ,strabo1 they and their fellow-countrymen held that souls and the universe were immortal1 but that fire and water would sometime prevail4 ,sacrifices were never made1 ,strabo says1 without the intervention of the ,druids4 ,pomponius ,mela says that in his time 7c4 #dd ,a4,d471 though the ancient savagery was no more1 and the ,gauls abstained from human sacrifices1 some traces of their former practices still remained1 notably in their habit of cutting a portion of the flesh of those condemned to death after bringing them to the altars4 ,the ,gauls1 he says1 in spite of their traces of barbarism1 had an eloquence of their own1 and had the ,druids as their teachers in philosophy4 ,these professed to know the size and form of the earth and of the universe1 the motions of the sky and stars1 and the will of the gods4 ,he refers1 as ,caesar does1 to their work in education1 and says that it was carried on in caves or in secluded groves4 ,mela speaks of their doctrine of immortality1 but says nothing as to the entry of souls into other bodies4 ,as a proof of this belief he speaks of the practice of burning and burying with the dead things appropriate to the needs of the living4 ,lucan1 the ,latin poet1 in his ,pharsalia1 refers to the seclusion of the ,druids' groves and to their doctrine of immortality4 ,the ,scholiasts' notes on this passage are after the manner of their kind1 and add very little to our knowledge4 ,in ,pliny's ,natural ,history 7xvi1 #bdi71 however1 we seem to be face to face with another1 though perhaps a distorted1 tradition4 ,pliny was an indefatigable compiler1 and appears partly by reading1 partly by personal observation1 to have noticed phases of ,celtic religious practices which other writers had overlooked4 ,in the first place he calls attention to the veneration in which the ,gauls held the mistletoe and the tree on which it grew1 provided that that tree was the oak4 ,hence their predilection for oak groves and their requirement of oak leaves for all religious rites4 ,pliny here remarks on the consonance of this practice with the etymology of the name ,druid as interpreted even through ,greek 7the ,greek for an oak being drus74 ,were not this respect for the oak and for the mistletoe paralleled by numerous examples of tree and plant-worship given by ,dr4 ,frazer and others1 it might well have been suspected that ,pliny was here quoting some writer who had tried to argue from the etymology of the name ,druid4 ,another suspicious circumstance in ,pliny's account is his reference to the serpent's egg composed of snakes rolled together into a ball4 ,he states that he himself had seen such an 'egg1' of about the size of an apple4 ,pliny1 too1 states that ,tiberius ,caesar abolished by a decree of the ,senate the ,druids and the kind of seers and physicians the ,gauls then had4 ,this statement1 when read in its context1 probably refers to the prohibition of human sacrifices4 ,the historian ,suetonius1 in his account of the ,emperor ,claudius1 also states that ,augustus had prohibited 'the religion of the ,druids' 7which1 he says1 'was one of fearful savagery'7 to ,roman citizens1 but that ,claudius had entirely abolished it4 ,what is here also meant1 in view of the description given of ,druidism1 is doubtless the abolishing of its human sacrifices4 ,in later ,latin writers there are several references to ,druidesses1 but these were probably only sorceresses4 ,in ,irish the name drui 7genitive druad7 meant a magician1 and the word derwydd in mediaeval ,welsh was especially used in reference to the vaticinations which were then popular in ,wales4 ,when we analyse the testimony of ancient writers concerning the ,druids1 we see in the first place that to different minds the name connoted different things4 ,to ,caesar it is the general name for the non-military professional class1 whether priests1 seers1 teachers1 lawyers1 or judges4 ,to others the ,druids are pre-eminently the philosophers and teachers of the ,gauls1 and are distinguished from the seers designated vates4 ,to others again1 such as ,pliny1 they were the priests of the oak-ritual1 whence their name was derived4 ,in view of the variety of grades of civilisation then co-existing in ,gaul and ,britain1 it is not improbable that the development of the non-military professional class varied very considerably in different districts1 and that all the aspects of ,druidism which the ancient writers specify found their appropriate places in the social system of the ,celts4 ,in ,gaul and ,britain1 as elsewhere1 the office of the primitive tribal medicine-man was capable of indefinite development1 and all the forms of its evolution could not have proceeded pari passu where the sociological conditions found such scope for variation4 ,it may well be that the oak and mistletoe ceremonies1 for example1 lingered in remote agricultural districts long after they had ceased to interest men along the main routes of ,celtic civilisation4 ,the bucolic mind does not readily abandon the practices of millennia4 ,in addition to the term ,druid1 we find in ,aulus ,hirtius' continuation of ,caesar's ,gallic ,war 7,bk4 viii41 c4 xxxviii41 #b71 as well as on two inscriptions1 one at ,le-,puy-en-,velay 7,dep4 ,haute-,loire71 and the other at ,macon 7,dep4 ,saone-et-,loire71 another priestly title1 'gutuater4' ,at ,macon the office is that of a 'gutuater ,martis1' but of its special features nothing is known4 ,,chapter ,,vii--,,the ,,celtic ,,other-,,world ,in the preceding chapter we have seen that the belief was widely prevalent among ,greek and ,roman writers that the ,druids taught the immortality of the soul4 ,some of these writers1 too1 point out the undoubted fact1 attested by ,archaeology1 that objects which would be serviceable to the living were buried with the dead1 and this was regarded as a confirmation of the view that the immortality of souls was to the ,celts an object of belief4 ,the study of ,archaeology on the one hand1 and of ,comparative ,religion on the other1 certainly leads to the conclusion that in the ,bronze and the ,early ,iron ,age1 and in all probability in the ,stone ,age1 the idea prevailed that death was not the end of man4 ,the holed cromlechs of the later ,stone ,age were probably designed for the egress and ingress of souls4 ,the food and the weapons that were buried with the dead were thought to be objects of genuine need4 ,roman religion1 too1 in some of its rites provided means for the periodical expulsion of hungry and hostile spirits of the dead1 and for their pacification by the offer of food4 ,a tomb and its adjuncts were meant not merely for the honour of the dead1 but also for the protection of the living4 ,a clear line of distinction was drawn between satisfied and beneficent ghosts like the ,manes1 and the unsatisfied and hostile ghosts like the ,lemures and ,larvae4 ,to the ,celtic mind1 when its analytical powers had come to birth1 and man was sufficiently self-conscious to reflect upon himself1 the problem of his own nature pressed for some solution4 ,in these solutions the breath1 the blood1 the name1 the head1 and even the hair generally played a part1 but these would not in themselves explain the mysterious phenomena of sleep1 of dreams1 of epilepsy1 of madness1 of disease1 of man's shadow and his reflection1 and of man's death4 ,by long familiarity with the scientific or quasi-scientific explanations of these things1 we find it difficult to realise fully their constant fascination for early man1 who had his thinkers and philosophies like ourselves4 ,one very widely accepted solution of early man in the ,celtic world was1 that within him there was another self which could live a life of its own apart from the body1 and which survived even death1 burial1 and burning4 ,sometimes this inner self was associated with the breath1 whence1 for example1 the ,latin 'anima' and the ,welsh 'enaid1' both meaning the soul1 from the root an-1 to breathe4 ,at other times the term employed for the second self had reference to man's shadow3 the ,greek 'skia1' the ,latin 'umbra1' the ,welsh 'ysgawd1' the ,english 'shade4' ,there are abundant evidences1 too1 that the life-principle was frequently regarded as being especially associated with the blood4 ,another tendency1 of which ,principal ,rhys has given numerous examples in his ,welsh folk-lore1 was to regard the soul as capable of taking a visible form1 not necessarily human1 preferably that of some winged creature4 ,in ancient writers there is no information as to the views prevalent among the ,celts regarding the forms or the abodes of the spirits of the dead1 beyond the statement that the ,druids taught the doctrine of their re-birth4 ,we are thus compelled to look to the evidence afforded by myth1 legend1 and folk-lore4 ,these give fair indications as to the types of earlier popular belief in these matters1 but it would be a mistake to assume that the ideas embodied in them had remained entirely unchanged from remote times4 ,the mind of man at certain levels is quite capable of evolving new myths and fresh folk-lore along the lines of its own psychology and its own logic4 ,the forms which the soul could take doubtless varied greatly in men's opinions in different districts and in different mental perspectives1 but folk-lore tends to confirm the view that early man1 in the ,celtic world as elsewhere1 tended to emphasise his conception of the subtlety and mobility of the soul as contrasted with the body4 ,sooner or later the primitive philosopher was bound to consider whither the soul went in dreams or in death4 ,he may not at first have thought of any other sphere than that of his own normal life1 but other questions1 such as the home of the spirits of vegetation in or under the earth1 would suggest1 even if this thought had not occurred to him before1 that the spirits of men1 too1 had entrance to the world below4 ,whether this world was further pictured in imagination depended largely on the poetic genius of any given people4 ,the folk-lore of the ,celtic races bears abundant testimony to their belief that beneath this world there was another4 ,the 'annwfn' of the ,welsh was distinctly conceived in the folk-lore embodied in mediaeval poetry as being 'is elfydd' 7beneath the world74 ,in mediaeval ,welsh legend1 again1 this lower world is regarded as divided into kingdoms1 like this world1 and its kings1 like ,arawn and ,hafgan in the ,mabinogi of ,pwyll1 are represented as being sometimes engaged in conflict4 ,from this lower world had come to man some of the blessings of civilisation1 and among them the much prized gift of swine4 ,the lower world could be even plundered by enterprising heroes4 ,marriages like that of ,pwyll and ,rhiannon were possible between the dwellers of the one world and the other4 ,the other-world of the ,celts does not seem1 however1 to have been always pictured as beneath the earth4 ,irish and ,welsh legend combine in viewing it at times as situated on distant islands1 and ,welsh folk-lore contains several suggestions of another world situated beneath the waters of a lake1 a river1 or a sea4 ,in one or two passages also of ,welsh mediaeval poetry the shades are represented as wandering in the woods of ,caledonia 7,coed ,celyddon74 ,this was no doubt a traditional idea in those families that migrated to ,wales in post- ,roman times from ,strathclyde4 ,to those who puzzled over the fate of the souls of the dead the idea of their re-birth was a very natural solution1 and ,mr4 ,alfred ,nutt1 in his ,voyage of ,bran1 has called attention to the occurrence of this idea in ,irish legend4 ,it does not follow1 however1 that the souls of all men would enjoy the privilege of this re-birth4 ,as ,mr4 ,alfred ,nutt points out1 ,irish legend seems to regard this re-birth only as the privilege of the truly great4 ,it is of interest to note the curious persistence of similar ideas as to death and the other-world in literature written even in ,christian times and by monastic scribes4 ,in ,welsh1 in addition to ,annwfn1 a term which seems to mean the ',not-world1' we have other names for the world below1 such as 'anghar1' the loveless place2 'difant1' the unrimmed place 7whence the modern ,welsh word 'difancoll1' lost for ever72 'affwys1' the abyss2 'affan1' the land invisible4 ,the upper-world is sometimes called 'elfydd1' sometimes 'adfant1' the latter term meaning the place whose rim is turned back4 ,apparently it implies a picture of the earth as a disc1 whose rim or lip is curved back so as to prevent men from falling over into the 'difant1' or the rimless place4 ,in modern ,celtic folk-lore the various local other- worlds are the abodes of fairies1 and in these traditions there may possibly be1 as ,principal ,rhys has suggested1 some intermixture of reminiscences of the earlier inhabitants of the various districts4 ,modern folk-lore1 like mediaeval legend1 has its stories of the inter-marriages of natives of this world with those of the other-world1 often located underneath a lake4 ,the curious reader will find several examples of such stories in ,principal ,rhys's collection of ,welsh and ,manx folk-lore4 ,in ,irish legend one of the most classical of these stories is that of the betrothal of ,etain1 a story which has several points of contact with the narrative of the meeting of ,pwyll and ,rhiannon in the ,welsh ,mabinogi4 ,the name of ,arthur's wife1 ,gwenhwyfar1 which means 'the ,white ,spectre1' also suggests that originally she too played a part in a story of the same kind4 ,in all these and similar narratives1 it is important to note the way in which the ,celtic conceptions of the other-world1 in ,britain and in ,ireland1 have been coloured by the geographical aspects of these two countries1 by their seas1 their islands1 their caves1 their mounds1 their lakes1 and their mountains4 ,the local other-worlds of these lands bear1 as we might have expected1 the clear impress of their origin4 ,on the whole the conceptions of the other-world which we meet in ,celtic legend are joyous2 it is a land of youth and beauty4 ,cuchulainn1 the ,irish hero1 for example1 is brought in a boat to an exceedingly fair island round which there is a silver wall and a bronze palisade4 ,in one ,welsh legend the cauldron of the ,head of ,annwfn has around it a rim of pearls4 ,one ,irish story has a naive description of the glories of the ,celtic ,elysium in the words--',admirable was that land3 there are three trees there always bearing fruit1 one pig always alive1 and another ready cooked4' ,occasionally1 however1 we find a different picture4 ,in the ,welsh poem called ',y ,gododin' the poet ,aneirin is represented as expressing his gratitude at being rescued by the son of ,llywarch ,hen from 'the cruel prison of the earth1 from the abode of death1 from the loveless land4' ,the salient features1 therefore1 of the ,celtic conceptions of the other-world are their consonance with the suggestions made by ,celtic scenery to the ,celtic imagination1 the vagueness and variability of these conceptions in different minds and in different moods1 the absence of any ethical considerations beyond the incentive given to bravery by the thought of immortality1 and the remarkable development of a sense of possible inter-relations between the two worlds1 whether pacific or hostile4 ,such conceptions1 as we see from ,celtic legend1 proved an admirable stimulus and provided excellent material for the development of ,celtic narrative1 and the weird and romantic effect was further heightened by the general belief in the possibilities of magic and metamorphosis4 ,moreover1 the association with innumerable place-names of legends of this type gave the beautiful scenery of ,celtic lands an added charm1 which has attached their inhabitants to them with a subtle and unconquerable attachment scarcely intelligible to the more prosaic inhabitants of prosaic lands4 ,to the poetic ,celt the love of country tends to become almost a religion4 ,the ,celtic mind cannot remain indifferent to lands and seas whose very beauty compels the eyes of man to gaze upon them to their very horizon1 and the lines of observation thus drawn to the horizon are for the ,celt continual temptations to the thought of an infinity beyond4 ,the preoccupation of the ,celtic mind with the deities of his scenery1 his springs1 his rivers1 his seas1 his forests1 his mountains1 his lakes1 was in thorough keeping with the tenour of his mind1 when tuned to its natural surroundings4 ,in dealing with ,celtic religion1 mythology1 and legend1 it is not so much the varying local and temporal forms that demand our attention1 as the all-pervading and animating spirit1 which shows its essential character even through the scanty remains of the ancient ,celtic world4 ,celtic religion bears the impress of nature on earth far more than nature in the heavens4 ,the sense of the heaven above has perhaps survived in some of the general ,indo-,european ,celtic terms for the divine principle1 and there are some traces of a religious interest in the sun and the god of thunder and lightning1 but every student of ,celtic religion must feel that the main and characteristic elements are associated with the earth in all the variety of its local phenomena4 ,the great earth-mother and her varied offspring ever come to view in ,celtic religion under many names1 and the features even of the other-world could not be dissociated for the ,celt from those of his mother-earth4 ,the festivals of his year1 too1 were associated with the decay and the renewal of her annual life4 ,the bonfires of ,november1 ,may1 ,midsummer1 and ,august were doubtless meant to be associated with the vicissitudes of her life and the spirits that were her children4 ,for the ,celt the year began in ,november1 so that its second half-year commenced with the first of ,may4 ,the idea to which ,caesar refers1 that the ,gauls believed themselves descended from ,dis1 the god of the lower world1 and began the year with the night1 counting their time not by days but by nights1 points in the same direction1 namely that the darkness of the earth had a greater hold on the mind than the brightness of the sky4 ,the ,welsh terms for a week and a fortnight1 wythnos 7eight nights7 and pythefnos 7fifteen nights7 respectively confirm ,caesar's statement4 ,to us now it may seem more natural to associate religion with the contemplation of the heavens1 but for the ,celtic lands at any rate the main trend of the evidence is to show that the religious mind was mainly drawn to a contemplation of the earth and her varied life1 and that the ,celt looked for his other-world either beneath the earth1 with her rivers1 lakes1 and seas1 or in the islands on the distant horizon1 where earth and sky met4 ,this predominance of the earth in religion was in thorough keeping with the intensity of religion as a factor in his daily pursuits4 ,it was this intensity that gave the ,druids at some time or other in the history of the ,western ,celts the power which ,caesar and others assign to them4 ,the whole people of the ,gauls1 even with their military aristocracy1 were extremely devoted to religious ideas1 though these led to the inhumanity of human sacrifices4 ,at one time their sense of the reality of the other-world was so great1 that they believed that loans contracted in this world would be repaid there1 and practical belief could not go much further than that4 ,all these considerations tend to show how important it is1 in the comparative study of religions1 to investigate each religion in its whole sociological and geographical environment as well as in the etymological meaning of its terms4 ,in conclusion1 the writer hopes that this brief sketch1 which is based on an independent study of the main evidence for the religious ideas and practices of the ,celtic peoples1 will help to interest students of religion in the dominant modes of thought which from time immemorial held sway in these lands of the ,west of ,europe1 and which in folk-lore and custom occasionally show themselves even in the midst of our highly developed and complex civilisation of to-day4 ,the thought of early man on the problems of his being--for after all his superstitions reveal thought--deserve respect1 for in his efforts to think he was trying to grope towards the light4 ,,short ,,bibliography ,,rhys1 ,hibbert ,lectures on ,celtic ,heathendom4 ,,rhys1 ,celtic ,folk-lore1 ,welsh and ,manx4 ,,reinach1 ,s41 ,cultes1 ,mythes et ,religion4 ,,nutt1 ,,alfred1 ,the ,voyage of ,bran4 ,,squire1 ,mythology of the ,british ,islands4 ,,gaidoz1 ,esqiusse de ,mythologie gauloise4 ,,bertrand1 ,la ,religion des ,gaulois1 les ,druides et le ,druidisme4 ,,frazer1 ,the ,golden ,bough4 ,,joyce1 ,the ,social ,history of ,ireland4 ,d',,arbois ,,de ,,jubainville1 ,les ,druides et les dieux celtiques a forme d'animaux4 ,,windisch1 ,irische ,texte mit ,worterbuch4 ,,cynddelw1 ,cymru ,fu4 ,,foulkes1 ,enwogion ,cymru4 ,,campbell1 ,popular ,tales of the ,west ,highlands4