,series ,four ,men1 ,manners and ,critics ,no4 #b ,anonymous1 ,of ,genius1 in ,the ,occasional ,paper1 ,volume ,,iii1 ,number #aj 7#agai7 and ,aaron ,hill1 ,preface to ,the ,creation 7#agbj7 ,with an ,introduction by ,gretchen ,graf ,pahl ,the ,augustan ,reprint ,society ,march1 #aidi ,price3 ,one ,dollar ,,general ,,editors ,,richard ,c4 ,,boys1 ,university of ,michigan ,,edward ,,niles ,,hooker1 ,university of ,california1 ,los ,angeles ,h4,t4 ,,swedenberg1 ,,jr41 ,university of ,california1 ,los ,angeles ,,assistant ,,editor ,w4 ,,earl ,,britton1 ,university of ,michigan ,,advisory ,,editors ,,emmett ,l4 ,,avery1 ,state ,college of ,washington ,,benjamin ,,boyce1 ,university of ,nebraska ,,louis ,i4 ,,bredvold1 ,university of ,michigan ,,cleanth ,,brooks1 ,yale ,university ,,james ,l4 ,,clifford1 ,columbia ,university ,,arthur ,,friedman1 ,university of ,chicago ,,samuel ,h4 ,,monk1 ,university of ,minnesota ,,ernest ,,mossner1 ,university of ,texas ,,james ,,sutherland1 ,queen ,mary ,college1 ,london ,lithoprinted from copy supplied by author by ,edwards ,brothers1 ,inc4 ,ann ,arbor1 ,michigan1 ,u4,s4,a4 ,transcriber's ,note3 ,some of the latin footnotes and the errata were difficult or impossible to read4 ,these are annotated4 ,,introduction ,the anonymous essay ,of ,genius1 which appeared in the ,occasional ,paper of #agai1 still considers genius largely a matter of aptitude or talent1 and applies the term to the mechanick as well as the fine arts4 ,the work is1 in fact1 essentially a pamphlet on education4 ,the author's main concern is training1 and study1 and conscious endeavor4 ,naturally enough1 his highest praise--even where poetry is in question--is reserved for those solid ,augustan virtues of judgment and good sense4 ,and yet the pamphlet reveals some of the tangled roots from which the later concept of the original or primitive genius grew4 ,for here are two prerequisites of that later1 more extravagant concept4 ,one is the author's positive delight in the infinite differences of human temperaments and talents--a delight from which might spring the preference for original or unique works of art4 ,the other is his conviction that there is something necessary and foreordained about those differences3 a conviction essential to faith in the artist who is apparently at the mercy of a genius beyond his own control4 ,the importance of this latter belief was long ago indicated in ,paul ,kaufman's ,heralds of ,original ,genius4 ,while his tone is perhaps more exuberant than that of most of his immediate contemporaries1 there is nothing particularly new in our author's interest in those aspects of human nature which render a man different from his fellows4 ,it is true that the main stress of neoclassical thought had rested on the fundamental likeness of all men in all ages1 and had sought an ideal and universal norm in morals1 conduct1 and art4 ,but there had always been counter currents making for a recognition of the inescapable differences among various races and individuals4 ,such deviations were often merely tolerated1 but toward the close of the seventeenth century more and more voices had praised human diversity4 ,england1 in particular1 began to take notice of the number of originals abounding in the land4 ,at least as old as the delight in human differences was the belief in the foreordained nature of at least those differences resulting in specific vocational aptitudes4 ,this is the conviction that each man has at birth--innately and inevitably--a peculiar bent for some particular contribution to human society4 ,environment is not ignored by the man who wrote ,of ,genius1 for he insists that each man's bent may be greatly developed by favorable circumstances and proper education1 and1 conversely1 that it may be entirely frustrated by unpropitious circumstances or wilful neglect4 ,but in no way can a man's inborn talent for one thing be converted to a talent for anything else4 ,in the works of many ,augustan writers1 too1 it is easy to see how the enthusiasm for individualism1 later to become one of the hallmarks of romanticism1 actually sprang from an earlier faith in a ,god-directed universe of law and order4 ,there is a kind of universal law of supply and demand1 and the argument is simply that each link in the human chain1 like those in the animate and inanimate worlds above and below it1 is predestined to a specific function for the better ordering of the whole4 ,lewis ,maidwell1 for instance1 still employs the medieval and ,renaissance analogy of the correspondence between the human body and the social organism 7,an ,essay upon the ,necessity and ,excellency of ,education73 ,upon ,consideration we find this ,difference of ,tempers to arise from ,providence1 and the ,law of the ,creation1 and to be most ,evident in al ,irrational1 and ,inanimat ,beings 444 ,one ,man is no more design'd for ,al ,arts1 than ,al ,arts for ,one ,man4 ,we are born ,confaederats1 mutually to help ,one another1 therefor appropriated in the ,body ,politic1 to this1 or that ,busyness1 as our ,members are in the ,natural to perform their separat ,offices4 ,this same comparison between the body politic and the body human occurs in the essay of #agai1 and even the author's chief analogy drawn from musical harmony bears with it some of the flavor of an older system of universal correspondences4 ,his comparison of the force of genius to the pull of gravity1 however1 evokes a newer picture4 ,yet it is a picture no less orderly and one from which the preordained function of each individual could be just as logically derived4 ,and his rhapsodic praise of the infinite diversity of human temperaments is based on that favorite comparison with natural scenery and that familiar canon of neoclassical esthetics3 ordered variety within unity1 whether it be in nature or in art4 ,the author of the pamphlet of #agai introduces another refinement on the idea of an inborn bent or genius4 ,a man is born not only with a peculiar aptitude for the vocation of writing1 but with a peculiar aptitude for a particular style of writing4 ,some such aptitude had presumably resulted in that individuality of style1 that particular character1 which #agth-century ,biblical critics were busily searching out in each of the writers of ,scripture4 ,individuality or originality in the form or plan of a work of art1 however1 was quite another thing1 and praise of it far more rare4 ,yet there had always been protests against the imposition of a universal classical standard1 and our author's insistence that some few geniuses have the right to discard the ,rules of ,art and all such ,leading-strings follows a well-worn path of reasoning4 ,his scientific analogy1 drawn from those natural philosophers who had cast off the yoke of ,aristotle and all other ,mens ,light1 is one which had appeared at least as early as #affa in ,robert ,boyle's ,considerations ,touching the ,style of ,holy ,scripture4 ,it had been reiterated by ,dryden and several others who refused to recognize an ipse dixit in letters any more than in science4 ,it must be noted1 however1 that this rejection of authority for a few rare individuals in no way constitutes a rejection of reason or conscious art4 ,the genius has the right to cast off the fetters only after he has well studied them4 ,only in one instance does our author waver toward another conception4 ,this is when he pauses to echo ,rowe's preface to ,shakespeare and ,addison's famous ,spectator no4 #afj4 ,then indeed he boasts that ,england has had many ,originals who1 without the help of ,learning1 by the meer ,force of natural ,ability1 have produc'd ,works which were the ,delight of their own ,times1 and have been the ,wonder of ,posterity4 ,but when he doubts whether learning would have helped or spoiled them1 it is hard to escape the conclusion that he is still poised on the horns of the typical neoclassical antithesis3 that supposed enmity between reason1 which was generally thought to create the form of the poem1 and the emotions and imagination1 which were considered largely responsible for its style4 ,only when the admiration for such emotional and imaginative qualities should outweigh the desire for symmetrical form2 when primitive literature should be preferred to ,virgil and ,horace2 and when this preference should be joined with a belief in the diversity and fatality of literary bents--only then could the concept of original genius burst into full bloom4 ,in ,aaron ,hill's preface to the paraphrase of ,genesis1 published in #agbj1 we find no preoccupation with the fatality of temperament and style4 ,but we do find a rising discontent with the emptiness and restraint of much contemporary verse1 and a very real preference for a more meaningful and a more emotional and imaginative poetry4 ,we find1 in fact1 a genuine appreciation for the poetry of the ,old ,testament--a poetry which ,biblical scholars like ,le ,clerc were already viewing as the product of untrained primitives4 ,hill was not alone in his admiration for ,biblical style1 for the praise of the unclassical poetry of the ,bible1 which had begun in the ,renaissance1 had swelled rather than diminished during the neoclassical age4 ,by the second decade of the #ahth century such ,augustans as ,dennis1 ,gildon1 and ,pope were crying up its beauties4 ,not all agreed1 of course1 on just what those beauties were4 ,and still less did they agree on the extent to which contemporary poetry should imitate them4 ,one thing upon which almost all would have agreed1 however1 was the adoption of the historical point of view in the approach to ,hebrew poetry4 ,yet many of ,hill's predecessors had stopped short with the historical justification4 ,blackmore1 for instance1 had condemned as bigots and sectarians all those who denied that the ,hebrew way was as great as the classical4 ,he had pronounced it a mere accident of fate that modern poetry of ,western ,europe was modeled on that of ,greece and ,rome rather than on that of ancient ,israel4 ,but he had been perfectly willing to accept that fate--and to remodel the form and style of the book of ,job on what he considered the pattern of the classical epic4 ,hill is as far as most of his contemporaries from appreciating such a literal translation as the ,king ,james ,version4 ,on the other hand1 he is one of a small group of critics who were beginning to see that at least certain aspects of ,biblical style were of universal appeal2 that they might be as effective psychologically for the modern ,englishman as for the ancient ,jew4 ,and he sees in this collection of ancient ,oriental literature a corrective for some of the worst tendencies of a degenerate contemporary poetry4 ,hill's attack upon the current preoccupation with form and polish1 and his contempt for mere smoothness1 for the padded redundancy of ,addison and the elaborate rhetoric of ,trapp1 are all part of a campaign waged by a small group of critics to make poetry once again a vehicle of the very highest truth4 ,he insists1 too1 that great thought cannot be contained within the untroubled cadences of the heroic couplet4 ,his own preference led to the freer1 though currently unfashionable1 ,pindaric1 the irregularity of which seemed justified by ,biblical example1 for despite a century and a half of study and speculation the secret of ,biblical verse had not been solved and to most critics even the ,psalms appeared devoid of any pattern4 ,indeed1 ,cowley had declared that in their freedom of structure and abruptness of transition the odes of ,pindar were like nothing so much as the poetry of ,israel4 ,in addition1 ,hill would have the modern poet profit by another quality of ,biblical style3 its magic combination of a magnificent ,plainness with the ,spirit of ,imagery4 ,this is the ,hebrew virtue of concrete suggestiveness1 so highly prized by #bjth-century critics and so alien to the generalized abstractions and the explicit clarity of much #ahth-century poetry4 ,in consonance with those who believed poetry best communicated truth because it appealed to man's senses and emotions as well as to his logical faculty1 ,hill praises those pictur'd ,meanings of ,poetry which enflame a ,reader's ,will1 and bind down his ,attention4 ,yet his analysis of ,trapp's metaphorical expansions of ,biblical imagery reveals that ,hill does not like detailed descriptions or long-drawn-out comparisons4 ,instead1 he admires the ,hebrew ability to spring the imagination with a few vividly concrete details4 ,prior to ,hill one can find1 in a few paraphrasers and critics like ,denham and ,lamy1 signs of an appreciation of the concrete suggestiveness of the ,bible1 but most of the hundreds of paraphrasers had felt it desirable to expand ,biblical images to beautify and clarify them4 ,hill was apparently the first to prove the esthetic loss in such a practice by an analysis of particular paraphrastic expansions4 ,despite his theory1 however1 ,hill's own paraphrase seems almost as artificial and un-,biblical as those he condemns4 ,he often forgets the principles he preaches4 ,but even in his preface there is evident a blind spot that is a mark of his age4 ,his false ideas of decorum1 admiration for ,milton1 and approval of ,dennis's interpretation of the sublime as the vast and the terrible1 all lead him to condemn the low or the familiar4 ,and his own efforts to raise both his language and his comparisons to suit the high ,biblical subject1 result in personifications1 compound epithets1 and a ,miltonic vocabulary1 by which the very simplicity he himself found in the ,bible is destroyed4 ,another decade was to pass before ,john ,husbands would demonstrate a clear appreciation for the true simplicity of the ,bible and praise its penmen in terms close to those employed to describe original genius4 ,gretchen ,graf ,pahl ,pomona ,college ,the essay ,of ,genius1 from the ,occasional ,paper 7#agai71 is reproduced from a copy in the ,new ,york ,public ,library4 ,the typescript of ,aaron ,hill's preface is based on a copy in the ,henry ,e4 ,huntington ,library4 ,both works are used with permission4 ,,the ,,occasional ,,paper4 ,,vol4 ,,iii4 ,,numb4 ,x4 ,,of ,,genius4 ,the ,cartesian ,categories are contain'd in these two ,verses1 ,mens1 mensura1 quies1 motus1 positura1 ,figura1 ,sunt1 cum materia1 cunctarum ,exordia rerum4 ,the ,spiritual ,nature1 ,mens1 is at the head of ,all4 ,it ought to be look'd on here1 as a ,transcendent ,nature1 qu vagatur per omnes ,categorias4 ,bayle's ,diction4 on the ,heathen ,doctrine of many ,genij4 ,see ,,cainites4 ,,london3 ,printed for ,,em4 ,,matthews at the ,bible in ,pater-,noster-,row2 ,j4 ,,roberts1 in ,warwick-,lane2 ,j4 ,,harrison1 under the ,royal ,exchange2 and ,a4 ,,dodd1 without ,temple-,bar4 ,,mdccxix4 ,,of ,,genius4 ,it is a ,matter of common ,observation1 that there is a vast ,variety in the ,bent of ,mens ,minds4 ,some have a ,taste of one ,way of ,living1 some of another2 some have a ,turn for one kind of ,employment1 others for what is quite different4 ,whether this be from the ,constitution of the ,mind itself1 as some ,soils are more apt to produce some ,plants and ,herbs than others2 or from the ,laws of ,union between the ,body and ,mind1 as some ,climates are more kindly to nurse particular ,vegetables than others2 or from the immediate ,impulse of that ,power which governs the ,world1 is not so easy to determine4 ,we ascribe this to a difference of ,genius amongst ,men4 ,genius was a ,deity worshipped by the ,ancient ,idolaters3 ,sometimes as the ,god of ,nature2 sometimes as the ,god of a particular ,city or ,country1 or ,fountain1 or ,wood1 or the like2 sometimes as the ,guardian and ,director of a single ,person4 ,exuitur1 ,geniumq2 meum prostratus adorat4 ,propert4 l4 #d4 ,el4 #i ,v4 #dc4 ,the ,heathens had a ,notion1 that every ,man upon his ,birth was given up to the,a ,conduct of some invisible ,being1 who was to form his ,mind1 and govern and direct his ,life4 ,this ,being the ,greeks called,b ,greek3 ,daimn or ,daimonion2 the ,latins1 ,genius4 ,some of them suppos'd a,d ,pair of ,genij were to attend every ,man from his ,birth2 one ,good1 always putting him on the ,practice of ,virtue2 the other ,bad1 prompting him to a vicious ,behaviour2 and according as their several ,suggestions were most attended to1 the ,man became either ,virtuous or ,vicious in his ,inclinations3 ,and from this ,influence1 which the ,genius was suppos'd to have towards forming the ,mind1 the ,word was by degrees made to stand for the ,inclination itself4 ,hence,e indulgere ,genio with the ,latins signifies1 to give ,scope to ,inclination1 and more commonly to what is none of the best4 ,on the other ,hand1 ,f,defraudare ,genium1 signifies to deny ,nature what it craves4 ,a ,ferunt ,theologi1 in lucem editis ,hominibus cunctis1 ,salva firmitate fatali1 bujusmodi quedam1 velut actus vectura1 numina ,sociari3 ,admodum tamen paucissimis visa1 quos multiplices auxere virtutes4 ,idque ,oracula ,autores docuerunt praclari4 ,ammian ,marcel ,lib4 #ba4 ,b ,greek3 ,hapanti ,daimn andri symparistatai ,euthys genomen mystaggos tou biou4 ,menan ,c ,scit ,genius ,natale comes1 qui temperat ,astrum1 ,nature ,deus ,humana4 ,horat4 ,transcriber's ,note3 ,this footnote is not seen in the text4 ,d ,volunt unicuique ,genium appositum ,damonem benum malum1 hoc est rationem qua ad meliora semper boriatur1 libidinem qua ad pejora1 hic est ,larva ,genius malus1 ille bonus ,genius ,lar4 ,serv4 in ,virgil1 ,lib4 #f4 v4 #gdc4 ,e ,indulge ,genio3 carpamus dulcia4 ,pers4 ,sat4 #e4 ,f ,suum defraudans ,genium4 ,terent4 ,phorm4 ,act #a4 ,but a ,genius in common ,acceptation amongst us1 doth not barely answer to this ,sense4 ,the ,pondus ,anim is to be taken into its ,meaning1 as well as the bare ,inclination2 as ,gravitation in a ,body 7to which this bears great ,resemblance7 doth not barely imply a determination of its ,motion towards a certain ,center1 but the ,vis or ,force with which it is carried forward2 and so the ,english ,word ,genius1 answers to the same ,latin ,word1 and ,ingenium together4 ,g,ingenium is the ,vis ingenita1 the natural ,force or ,power with which every ,being is indued2 and this1 together with the particular ,inclination of the ,mind1 towards any ,business1 or ,study1 or ,way of ,life1 is what we mean by a ,genius4 ,both are necessary to make a ,man shine in any ,station or ,employment4 ,nothing considerable can be done against the ,grain1 or as the ,latins express it1 invita ,minerva1 in spite of ,power and ,inclination1 ,forc'd ,studies1 says,h ,seneca1 will never answer3 ,the ,labour is in vain where ,nature recoils4 ,indeed1 where the ,inclination towards any ,thing is strong1 ,diligence and ,application will in a great ,measure supply the ,defect of natural ,abilities3 ,but then only is in a finish'd ,genius1 when with a strong ,inclination there is a due ,proportion of ,force and ,vigour in the ,mind to pursue it4 ,g ,ingenium quasi intus genitum4 ,h ,male respondent ingenia coacta2 reluctante natur irritus ,labor est4 ,there is a vast ,variety of these ,inclinations among ,mankind4 ,some there are who have no bent to ,business at all2 but1 if they could indulge ,inclination1 would doze out ,life in perpetual ,sloth and ,inactivity3 ,others can't be altogether ,idle1 but incline only to trifling and useless ,employments1 or such as are altogether out of ,character4 ,both these sorts of ,men are properly good for nothing3 ,they just live1 and help to,i consume the ,products of the ,earth1 but answer no valuable ,end of ,living1 out of ,inclination ,i mean2 ,providence and good ,government have sometimes made them serviceable against it4 ,i ,fruges consumere nati4 ,horat4 ,the better1 and in ,truth only valuable1 ,part of ,mankind1 have a ,turn for one sort of ,business or other1 but with great variety of ,taste4 ,some are addicted to deep ,thought and ,contemplation3 ,some to the abstracted ,speculations of ,metaphysicks2 some to the evident ,demonstrations of the ,mathematicks2 some to the ,history of ,nature1 built upon true ,narration1 or accurate ,observations and ,experiments3 ,some to the ,invention of ,hypotheses1 to solve the various ,phenomena4 ,some affect the study of ,languages1 ,criticism1 ,oratory1 ,poetry1 and such like ,studies4 ,some have a ,taste for ,musick1 some for ,history and those ,sciences which must help to ,accuracy in it3 ,some have ,heads turned for ,politicks1 and others for ,wars4 ,some few there are of such quick and strong ,faculties1 as to grasp at every thing1 and who have made a very eminent ,figure in several ,professions at once4 ,we have known in our ,days the same ,men learned in the ,laws1 acute ,philosophers1 and deep ,divines3 ,we have known others at once eloquent ,orators1 brave ,soldiers1 and finished ,statesmen4 ,but these ,instances are rare4 ,the more general ,inclination among ,men is to some ,mechanical ,business4 ,of this there is most general ,use for the ,purposes of ,human ,life1 and it needs most ,hands to carry it on4 ,the bulk of ,mankind seem turned for some or other of these ,employments1 and make them their ,choice2 and were not such a multiplicity of ,hands engaged in them1 great part of the ,conveniencies of ,human ,life would be wanting4 ,but even the ,multitude of these ,employments leaves room for great variety of ,inclinations1 and for different ,genij1 to display and exert themselves4 ,this is an admirable and wise ,provision to answer every ,end and ,occasion of ,mankind1 for a sure and harmonious ,concurrence of ,mens ,actions to all the necessary and useful ,affairs of the ,world4 ,when in very different ,ways1 but with equal ,pleasure and ,application1 they contribute to the ,order and ,service of the whole4 ,mr4 ,dryden has given an ,hint1 how we may form a beautiful and pleasing ,idea of this from the ,powers of ,musick1 that arise from the ,variety and artful ,composition of ,sounds4 ,from ,harmony1 from ,heavenly ,harmony1 ,this ,universal ,frame began4 ,from ,harmony to ,harmony1 ,thro' all the ,compass of the ,notes it ran1 ,the ,diapasm closing full in ,man4 ,there seems to be a wonderful ,likeness in the natural ,make of ,mens ,minds to the various ,tones and ,measures of ,sounds2 and in their ,inclinations and most pleasing ,tastes to the several ,styles and ,manners of ,musick4 ,something there is in the ,mind1 of alike ,composition1 that is easily touch'd by the kindred ,harmony of ,musick1 ,for ,man may justly tuneful ,strains admire1 ,his ,soul is ,musick1 and his ,breast a ,lyre4 ,we have all the ,materials of ,musick in the ,tones and ,measure4 ,for the infinite ,variety ,composition admits of1 can be nothing else1 but higher or lower ,tones1 stronger or softer ,sounds1 with a slower or swifter ,motion4 ,the ,artist1 by an harmonious ,mixture of these1 makes the ,musick either strong and martial1 brisk and airy1 grave and solemn1 or soft and moving4 ,there seems to be in ,man a ,composition of natural ,powers and ,capacities1 not unlike to these4 ,from hence ,i would take the first ,original of their distinguishing ,genij4 ,the ,words by which they are usually explain'd1 have a manifest ,allusion hereto4 ,thus we say of some ,men1 they have a brisk and airy ,genius2 of others1 they have a strong and active ,genius1 a quick and lively ,spirit1 a grave and solemn ,temper1 and the like4 ,the different readiness of ,apprehension1 strength of ,judgment1 vivacity of ,fancy and ,imagination1 with a more or less active ,disposition1 and the several ,mixtures of which these ,powers are capable1 are sufficient to explain this4 ,they may shew us how some have a particular ,genius for ,wit and ,humour1 others for ,thought and ,speculation4 ,whence it is1 some love a constant and persevering ,application to whatever they undertake2 and others are continually jumping from one ,thing to another1 without finishing any thing at all4 ,but we do not only consider in ,musick these ,materials1 as ,i may call them1 of which it is composed2 but also the ,style and ,manner4 ,this diversifies the ,genius of the ,composer1 and produces the most sensible and touching ,difference4 ,there is in all ,musick the natural difference of ,tone and ,measure4 ,they are to be found in the most vulgar ,compositions of a ,jig or an ,hornpipe4 ,but it is a full ,knowledge of the ,force and ,power of ,sounds1 and a judicial ,application of them to the several ,intentions of ,musick1 that forms the ,style of a ,purcel or ,corelli4 ,this is owing to successive ,improvements4 ,the ,ear is formed to an elegant ,judgment by ,degrees4 ,what is harsh and harmonious is discovered and corrected4 ,by many ,advantages1 some at last come to find out what1 in the whole ,compass of ,sounds1 is most soft and touching1 most brisk and enlivening1 most lofty and elevating4 ,so that whatever the ,artist intends1 whether to set an ,air1 or compose a ,te ,deum1 he does either1 with an equal ,genius1 that is1 with equal ,propriety and ,elegance4 ,thus long ago1 ,timotheus to his breathing flute1 and sounding ,lyre1 ,could swell the ,soul to ,rage1 or kindle soft ,desire4 ,and1 ,thus ,david's ,lyre did ,saul's wild ,rage controul1 ,and tune the harsh ,disorders of his ,soul4 ,this may direct us to another ,cause1 from whence a ,genius arises3 ,a ,genius that is formed and acquired4 ,for the ,turn that ,education1 ,company1 ,business1 the ,taste of the ,age1 and above all1 ,principles of vitious or virtuous ,manners1 give to a ,man's natural ,capacities1 is what chiefly forms his ,genius4 ,thus we say of some1 they have a rude unpolish'd ,genius2 of others1 they have a fine1 polite ,genius4 ,the manner of applying the natural ,powers of the ,mind1 is what alone may produce the most different and opposite ,genij4 ,libertine ,principles1 and ,virtuous ,morals1 may form the ,genius of a ,rake1 from the same natural ,capacity1 out of which ,virtuous ,principles might have form'd an ,hero4 ,there is certainly in our natural ,capacities themselves1 a ,fitness for some ,things1 and ,unfitness for others4 ,thus whatever great ,capacities a ,man may have1 if he is naturally timorous1 or a ,coward1 he never can have a ,warlike ,genius4 ,if a ,man has not a good ,judgment1 how great soever his ,wit may be1 or polite his ,manners1 he never will have the ,genius of a ,statesman4 ,just as strong ,sounds and brisk ,measures can never touch the softer ,passions4 ,yet as the ,art and ,skill of the ,composer1 is required to the ,genius of ,musick1 so is a ,knowledge of the ,force and ,power of the natural ,capacity1 and a judicious ,application of it to the best and most proper ,purposes1 what forms a ,genius for any ,thing4 ,this is the effect of ,care1 ,experience and a right ,improvement of every ,advantage that offers4 ,on this ,observation ,horace founded his ,rules for a ,poetical ,genius4 ,versate diu quid sere recusent ,quid valeant humeri4 ,and1 ,ego nec studium sine divite vena1 ,nec rude quid profit video ingenium4 ,to speak my ,thoughts1 ,i hardly know ,what witless ,art1 or artless ,wit can do4 ,the same ,observation in another kind is elegantly described by ,mr4 ,waller4 ,great ,julius on the ,mountains bred1 ,a ,flock perhaps1 or ,herd had led4 ,he that the ,world subdued1 had been ,but the best ,wrestler on the ,green4 ',tis ,art and ,knowledge that draw forth ,the hidden ,seeds of ,native ,worth4 ,they blow those ,sparks1 and make 'em rise ,into such ,flames as touch the ,skies4 ,the ,high and ,martial ,spirit of ,casar would have inclined and fitted him1 to gain the ,prize of ,wrestling above any ,country ,sport4 ,but it was the ,circumstance of his own ,birth and ,fortune1 the ,state and ,condition of the ,commonwealth1 and the ,concurrence of many other ,advantages1 which he improv'd with great ,care and ,application1 that made him a finish'd ,genius1 both in ,arms and ,policy4 ,there is yet another ,thing of ,consequence to a true ,genius in ,musick4 ,a ,knowledge of the ,compass and peculiar ,advantages of each several ,instrument4 ,for the same ,composition will very differently touch both the ,ear and the ,mind1 as perform'd by a ,flute1 or ,trumpet1 an ,organ1 or a ,violin4 ,a difference of which1 all discern by the ,ear1 but which requires a judicious ,observation in the ,composer4 ,mr4 ,hughes has thus express'd their different ,powers4 ,let the ,trumpet's shrill ,voice1 ,and the ,drum's thundering ,noise ,rouse every dull ,mortal from ,sorrow profound4 ,and1 ,proceed1 sweet ,charmer of the ,ear1 ,proceed1 and through the mellow ,flute1 ,the moving ,lyre1 ,and ,solitary ,lute1 ,melting ,airs1 soft ,joys inspire1 ,airs for drooping ,hope to hear4 ,and again1 ,now1 let the sprightly ,violin ,a louder ,strain begin3 ,and now1 ,let the deep mouth'd ,organ blow1 ,swell it high and ,sink it low4 ,hark6 how the ,treble and the ,base ,in wanton ,fuges each other chase1 ,and swift ,divisions run their ,airy ,race4 ,thro' all the travers'd ,scale they fly1 ,in winding ,labyrinths of ,harmony1 ,by turns ,they rise and fall1 by ,turns we live and die4 ,one might not unfitly compare to this difference of ,instruments1 the different ,make and ,constitution of ,mens ,bodies1 with the ,influence they have1 and the ,impression they make on their ,minds1 ,passions and ,actions4 ,from hence alone they may know much1 how to direct their own proper ,capacities1 and how they are to suit each ,person they are to use1 to the most proper ,employment4 ,as ,mr4 ,pope ,speaks of the ,instruments of ,musick4 ,in a sadly pleasing ,strain1 ,let the warbling ,lute complain4 ,let the loud ,trumpet sound1 ,till the ,roofs all around ,the shrill ,echo's rebound4 ,while in more lengthen'd ,notes and slow1 ,the deep1 majestick1 solemn ,organs blow4 ,harmony1 in its most restrain'd ,sense1 is the apt and agreeable mixture of various ,sounds4 ,such a ,composition of them as is fitted to please the ,ear4 ,but every thing in a more extended ,sense is harmonious1 where there is a variety of ,things dispos'd and mix'd in such apt and agreeable ,manner4 ,things may indeed be thrown together in a ,crowd1 without ,order or ,art4 ,and then every thing appears in ,confusion1 disagreeable and apt to disgust4 ,but absolute ,uniformity will give little more ,pleasure than meer ,confusion4 ,to be ever harping on one ,string1 though it be touch'd by the most ,masterly ,hand1 will give little more ,entertainment to the ,ear1 than the most confused and discordant variety of ,sounds mingled by the ,hand of a meer ,bungler4 ,to have the ,eye for ever fix'd on one beautiful ,object1 would be apt to abate the ,satisfaction1 at least in our present ,state4 ,variety relieves and refreshes4 ,it is so in the natural ,world4 ,hills and ,valleys1 ,woods and ,pasture1 ,seas and ,shores1 not only diversify the ,prospect1 but give much more ,entertainment to the ,eye1 that can successively go from one to the other1 than any of them could singly do4 ,and could we see into all the ,conveniencies of things1 how well they are fitted to each other1 and the common ,purposes of all1 we shou'd find that the ,diversity is as usefull as it is agreeable4 ,it is the same also with the ,world of ,mankind4 ,if all had a like ,turn or ,cast of ,mind1 and all were bent upon one ,business or way of ,living1 it would spoil much of the present ,harmony of the ,world1 and be a manifest ,inconvenience to the ,publick4 ,perhaps one ,part of ,learning1 or ,method of ,business1 would be throughly cultivated and improved2 but how many others must be neglected1 or remain defective8 ,and it would create ,jealousy and ,uneasiness among themselves4 ,as ,men are forc'd to justle in a ,crowd4 ,for there would not be sufficient ,scope for every one to exert and display himself1 nor so much ,room for many to excel1 when all must do it in one ,way4 ,variety of ,inclination and ,capacity is an admirable ,means of common ,benefit4 ,it opens a wide ,field for ,service to ,others1 and gives great ,advantage to ,mens own ,improvement4 ,and it is surprising to consider how great this ,diversity is4 ,it is almost as various as that of bodily ,features and ,complexion4 ,there is no ,instance of any kind of ,learning or ,business2 any ,thing relating to the ,necessity or ,delight of ,life2 not the meanest ,office or the hardest ,labour1 but some or other are found to answer the different ,purposes of each4 ,they are carried through all the ,difficulties in their several ,ways1 by the meer ,force of a ,genius3 ,and attempt and achieve that1 with an high relish of ,pleasure1 which would give the greatest ,disgust to others and utterly discourage them4 ,this stirs up an useful ,emulation1 and gives full ,scope for every one to show ,himself and appear to advantage4 ,and it is certainly for the ,beauty and ,advantage of the ,body4 ,as many ,hands employed in different ,ways about some noble ,building1 yet all help either to secure its ,strength1 or furnish out all the ,convenience1 or give a ,state and ,grandeur to it4 ,the ,wisdom and ,beauty of ,providence appear at once in this ,variety and ,distinction of ,powers and ,inclinations among ,mankind4 ,it is a very wise and a necessary ,provision for the common ,good1 and the ,advantage and ,pleasure of particular ,men4 ,it answers to all the ,ends and ,occasions of ,mankind4 ,they are in this ,way made helpful to one another1 and capable of serving ,themselves1 and that without much trouble or fatigue4 ,business by this ,means becomes a ,pleasure4 ,the greatest ,labours and ,cares are easy and entertaining to ,him who pursues his ,genius4 ,inclination still urges the ,man on3 ,obstacles and ,oppositions only sharpen his ,appetite1 and put ,him upon summoning all his ,powers1 that ,he may exert ,himself to the uttermost1 and get over his ,difficulties4 ,all the several ,arts and ,sciences1 and all the ,improvements made in them from ,time to ,time2 all the different ,offices and ,employments of humane ,life1 are owing to this variety of ,powers and ,inclinations among ,men4 ,and is it not obvious to every ,eye how much of the ,conveniences and ,comforts of humane ,life spring from these ,originals8 ,it is a glorious ,display and most convincing ,proof of the ,interest of ,providence in humane ,affairs1 and the ,wisdom of its ,conduct1 to fit ,things in this ,manner to their proper ,uses and ,ends4 ,and so to sort ,mankind1 and suit their ,talents and ,inclinations1 that all may contribute somewhat to the ,publick ,good1 and hardly one ,member of the whole ,body be lost in the ,reckoning1 useless to it self1 or unserviceable to the ,body4 ,were it otherwise1 what large ,tracts of humane ,affairs would lie perfectly waste and uncultivated8 ,whereas now all the ,parts of humane ,learning and ,life lie open to ,improvement1 and some or other is fitted by ,nature1 and dispos'd by ,inclination1 to help towards it4 ,and as ,providence gives the ,hint1 ,men should take it1 and follow the ,conduct of ,genius in the ,course of their ,studies1 and ,way of ,employment in the ,world2 and in the ,education and ,disposal of their ,children4 ,men too often in this ,case consult their own ,humour and ,convenience1 not the ,capacity and ,inclination of the ,child3 ,and are governed by some or other external ,circumstance1 or lower ,consideration2 as1 what they shall give with them1 or to whom to commit the ,care of them1 c4 ,thus they after contrive unsuitable ,marriages1 on the single ,view of worldly ,advantage4 ,from this ,cause proceed fatal ,effects1 and many young ,men of great ,hopes1 and good ,capacities1 miscarry in the after ,conduct of ,life1 and prove useless or mischievous to the ,world4 ,they turn off from a disagreeable ,employment1 and run into ,idleness and ,extravagance4 ,if ,people better consider'd the peculiar ,genius or proper ,talents of their ,children1 and took their ,measures of ,treatment and ,disposal thence1 we should certainly find answerable ,improvements and lasting good ,effects4 ,the several ,kinds of ,learning and ,business would come to be more advanced1 and the ,lives of ,men become more useful and significant to the ,world4 ,i have known a large ,family of ,children1 with so remarkable a ,diversity of ,genius1 as to be a little ,epitome of ,mankind4 ,some studious and thoughtful1 and naturally inclin'd to ,books and ,learning2 ,others diligent and ambitious1 and disposed to ,business and rising in the ,world4 ,some bold and enterprizing1 and loved nothing so well as the ,camp and the ,field2 or so daring and unconfined1 that nothing would satisfy but going to ,sea and visiting ,foreign ,parts4 ,some have been gay and airy1 ,others solid and retired4 ,some curious and ,observers of other ,men2 ,others open and careless4 ,in short1 their ,capacities have been as various as their ,natural ,tempers or ,moral ,dispositions4 ,now what a ,blunder would be committed in the ,education of such a ,family1 if1 with this different ,turn of ,mind in the ,children1 there should be no difference made in the ,management of them1 or their ,disposal in the ,world4 ,if all should be put into one ,way of ,life1 or brought up to one ,business4 ,or if in the ,choice of ,employment for ,them1 their several ,biass and ,capacity be not consulted1 but the roving ,genius mew'd up in a ,closet1 and confounded among ,books3 ,and the studious and thoughtful ,genius sent to wander about the ,world1 and be perfectly scattered and dissipated1 for want of proper ,application and closer ,confinement4 ,whereas1 one such a ,family wisely educated1 and dispos'd in the ,world1 would prove an extensive ,blessing to ,mankind1 and appear with a distinguished ,glory2 was the proper ,genius of every ,child first cultivated1 and he then put into a ,way of ,life that would suit his ,taste4 ,genius is a part of natural ,constitution1 not acquir'd1 but born with us4 ,yet it is capable of ,cultivation and ,improvement4 ,it has been a common ,question1 whether a ,man be born a ,poet or made one8 but both must concur4 ,nature and ,art must contribute their ,shares to compleat the ,character4 ,limbs alone will not make a ,dancer1 or a ,wrestler4 ,nor will ,genius alone make a good ,poet2 nor the meer ,strength of natural ,abilities make a considerable ,artist of any kind4 ,good ,rules1 and these reduc'd to ,practice1 are necessary to this ,end4 ,and ,use and ,exercise in this1 as well as in all other ,cases1 are a second ,nature4 ,and1 oftentimes1 the second ,nature makes a prodigious ,improvement of the ,force and ,vigour of the first4 ,it has been long ago determined by the great ,masters of ,letters1 that good ,sense is the chief ,qualification of a good ,writer4 ,scribendi certe sapere est ,principium ,fons4 ,horat4 ,yet the best natural ,parts in the ,world are capable of much ,improvement by a due ,cultivation4 ,doctrina sed vim promovet insitam1 ,rectique cultus ,pectora roborant4 ,horat4 ,the ,spectator's golden ,scales1 let down from ,heaven to discover the true ,weight and ,value of ,things1 expresses this ,matter in a ,way which at once shews1 a ,genius1 and its ,cultivation4 ,there is a ,saying among the ,scots1 that an ,ounce of ,mother-,wit1 is worth a ,pound of ,clergy4 ,i was sensible of the ,truth of this ,saying1 when ,i saw the difference between the ,weight of natural ,parts and that of ,learning4 ,i observ'd that it was an hundred ,times heavier than before1 when ,i put ,learning into the same ,scale with it4 ,it has been observ'd1 of an ,english ,author1 that he would be all ,genius4 ,he would reap the ,fruits of ,art1 but without the ,study and ,pains of it4 ,the ,lim ,labor is what he cannot easily digest4 ,we have as many ,instances of ,originals1 this way1 as any ,nation can produce4 ,men1 who without the help of ,learning1 by the meer ,force of natural ,ability1 have produced ,works which were the ,delight of their own ,times1 and have been the ,wonder of ,posterity4 ,it has been a ,question1 whether ,learning would have improved or spoiled them4 ,there appears somewhat so nobly ,wild and ,extravagant in these great ,genij1 as charms infinitely more1 than all the ,turn and ,polishing which enters into the ,french ,bel ,esprit1 or the ,genius improved by ,reading and ,conversation4 ,but tho' this will hold in some very rare ,instances1 it must be much for its ,advantage in ordinary ,cases1 that a ,genius should be diligently and carefully cultivated4 ,in order to this1 it should be early watched and observ'd4 ,and this is a matter that requires deep ,insight into ,humane ,nature4 ,it is not so easy as many imagine1 to pronounce what the proper ,genius of a ,youth is4 ,every one who will be fiddling1 has not presently a ,genius for ,musick4 ,the ,idle ,boy draws ,birds and ,men1 when he should be getting his ,lesson or writing his ,copy2 ,this ,boy1 says the ,father1 must be a ,painter2 when alas6 this is no more the ,boy's ,genius than the ,parhelion is the true ,sun4 ,but those who have the ,care of ,children1 should take some ,pains to know what their true ,genius is4 ,for here the ,foundation must be laid for improving it4 ,if a ,mistake be made here1 the ,man sets out wrong1 and every ,step he takes carries him so much farther from ,home4 ,the true ,genius being discovered1 it must be supplied with ,matter to work upon1 and employ it self4 ,this is ,fuel for the ,fire4 ,and the fitting a ,genius with proper ,materials1 is putting one into the ,way of going through the ,world with ,wind and ,tide4 ,the whole ,force of the ,mind is applied to its proper ,use4 ,and the ,man exerts all his ,strength1 because he follows ,inclination1 and gives himself up to the proper ,conduct of his ,genius4 ,this is the right way to excel4 ,the ,man will naturally rise to his utmost ,height1 when he is directed to an ,employment that at once fits his ,abilities1 and agrees with his ,taste4 ,care must also be taken1 that a ,genius be not overstrain'd4 ,our ,powers are limited4 ,none can carry beyond their certain ,weight4 ,whilst we follow ,inclination1 and keep within the ,bounds of our ,power1 we act with ,ease and ,pleasure4 ,if we strain beyond our ,power1 we crack the ,sinews1 and after two or three vain ,efforts1 our ,strength fails1 and our ,spirits are jaded4 ,it wou'd be of mighty ,advantage towards improving a ,genius1 to make its ,employment1 as much as possible1 a ,delight and ,diversion1 especially to young ,minds4 ,a ,man toils at a ,task1 and finds his ,spirits flag1 and his ,force abate1 e'er he has gone half thro'2 whereas he can put forth twice the ,strength1 and complain of no ,fatigue1 in following his ,pleasures4 ,of so much ,advantage is it to make ,business a ,pleasure1 if possible1 and engage the ,mind in it out of ,choice4 ,it naturally reluctates against ,constraint1 and is most unwilling to go on when it knows it must4 ,but if it be left to its own ,choice1 to follow ,inclination and pursue its ,pleasure1 it goes on without any ,rubs1 and rids twice the ,ground1 without being half so much tired4 ,exercise is also very necessary to improve a ,genius4 ,it not only shines the more1 by exerting it self1 but1 like the ,limbs of an ,humane ,body1 gathers ,strength by frequent and vigorous ,use1 and becomes more pliable and ready for ,action4 ,there must indeed sometimes be a ,relaxation4 ,our ,minds will not at present bear to be continually bent1 and in perpetual ,exercise4 ,but our ,faculties manifestly grow by using them4 ,the more we exert our selves1 if we do not overstrain our ,powers1 the greater ,readiness and ,ability we acquire for future ,action4 ,a ,genius1 in order to be much improv'd1 should be well workt1 and kept in close ,application to its proper ,pursuit4 ,all the ,foreign ,help must be procured1 that can be had1 towards this ,improvement4 ,the ,instruction and ,example of such as excell in that particular way1 to which a ,man's ,mind is turned1 is of vast ,use4 ,a good ,master in the ,mechanical ,arts1 and careful ,observation of the nicest and most dextrous ,workmen1 will help a ,genius of this sort4 ,a good ,tutor in the ,sciences1 and free ,conversation with such as have made great ,proficiency in them1 must vastly improve the more liberal ,genius4 ,reading1 and careful ,reflection on what a ,man reads1 will still add to its ,force1 and carry the ,improvement higher4 ,reading furnishes ,matter1 ,reflexion digests it1 and makes it our own2 as the ,flesh and ,blood which are made out of the ,food we eat4 ,and ,prudence and the ,knowledge of the ,world1 must direct us how to employ our ,genius1 and on all occasions make the best ,use of it4 ,what will the most exalted ,genius signify1 if the ,world reaps no ,advantage from it8 ,he who is possess'd of it1 may make it turn to ,account to himself1 and have much ,pleasure and ,satisfaction from it2 but it is a very poor ,business1 if it serves no other ,purpose1 than to supply ,matter for such private and narrow ,satisfaction4 ,it is certainly the ,intention of ,providence1 that a good ,genius should be a publick ,benefit2 and to wrap up such a ,talent in a ,napkin1 and bury it in the ,earth1 is at once to be unfaithful to ,god1 and defraud ,mankind4 ,those who have such a ,trust put into their ,hands1 should be very careful that they do not abuse it1 nor squander it away4 ,the best ,genius may be spoiled4 ,it suffers by nothing more1 than by neglecting it1 and by an ,habit of ,sloth and ,inactivity4 ,by ,disuse1 it contracts ,j,rust1 or a ,stiffness which is not easily to be worn off4 ,even the sprightly and penetrating1 have1 thro' this neglect1 sunk down to the ,rank of the dull and stupid4 ,some ,men have given very promising ,specimens in their early ,days1 that they could think well themselves2 but1 whether from a pusillanimous ,modesty1 or a lazy ,temper at first1 ,i know not2 they have by ,degrees contracted such an ,habit of ,filching and ,plagiary1 as to lose their ,capacity at length for one ,original ,thought4 ,some ,writers indeed1 as well as ,practitioners in other ,arts1 seem only born to copy2 but it is ,pity those1 who have a ,stock of their own1 should so entirely lose it by ,disuse1 as to be reduc'd to a ,necessity1 when they must appear in ,publick1 to borrow from others4 ,j ,otium ingera rubig4 ,transcriber's ,note3 rubig not readable1 may be the word for rust or stiffness4 ,men should guard against this ,mischief with great ,care4 ,a ,genius once squandered away by neglect1 is not easily to be recovered4 ,tacitus assigns a very proper ,reason for this4 ,k,such is the ,nature1 saith he1 of ,humane ,infirmity1 that ,remedies cannot be applied1 as quick as ,mischiefs may be suffered2 and as the ,body must grow up by slow ,degrees1 but is presently destroyed2 so you may stifle a ,genius much more easily than you can recover it4 ,for you'll soon relish ,ease and ,inactivity1 and be in ,love with ,sloth1 which was once your ,aversion4 ,this can hardly fail of raining the best ,capacity1 especially1 if from a neglect of severer ,business1 ,men run into a ,dissolution of ,manners1 which is the too common ,consequence4 ,the greatest ,minds have thus been often wholly enervated1 and the best ,parts buried in utter ,obscurity4 ,k ,natura infirmitatis humanae1 tadiora sunt remedia quam mala2 ut corpora lente augescunt1 cito extinguuntur1 sic ingenia studiaque oppresseris1 facilius quam revocaveris2 subit quippe ipsius inertiae dulcedo1 et invisa primo desidia postremo amatur4 ,tacit4 ,vit4 ,agricol4 c4 #c4 ,though the ,rules of ,art may be of great ,service to improve a ,genius1 it is very prejudicial1 in many ,cases1 to fetter it self with these ,rules1 or confine itself within those ,limits which others have fixed4 ,how little would ,science have been improv'd1 if every new ,genius1 that applies himself to any ,branch of it1 had made other ,mens ,light1 his ne plus ultra1 and resolved to go no farther into it1 than the ,road had been beaten before him4 ,no doubt there were ,men of as good natural ,abilities in the ,ages before the ,revival of ,learning1 as there have been since4 ,but they were cramped with the ,jargon of a wordy and unintelligible ,philosophy1 and durst not give themselves the ,liberty to think in ,religion1 without the ,boundaries fixed by the ,church1 for fear of ,anathemas1 and an ,inquisition4 ,till those ,fetters were broken1 little ,advance was made1 for many ,ages together1 in any useful or solid ,knowledge4 ,in truth1 every ,man who makes a new ,discovery1 goes at first by himself2 and as long as the greatest ,minds are ,content to go in ,leading-strings1 they will be but upon a ,level with their ,neighbours4 ,on the other ,hand1 ,capacities of a lower size must be obliged to more of ,imitation4 ,all their ,usefulness will be spoiled by forming too high ,models for themselves4 ,if they will be of ,service1 they must be content to keep the beaten ,road4 ,should they attempt to soar too high1 they will only meet with ,icarus's ,fate4 ,a common ,genius will serve many common ,purposes exceeding well1 and render a ,man conspicuous enough1 tho' there may be no distinguishing ,splendor about him to dazzle the ,beholders ,eyes4 ,but if he attempts any ,thing beyond his ,strength1 he is sure to lose the ,lustre which he had1 if he does not also weaken his ,capacity1 and impair his ,genius into the ,bargain4 ,so just in all ,cases is the ,poet's ,advice to ,writers4 ,sumite ,materiam vestris qui scribitis aquam ,veribus4 ,horat4 ,weigh well your ,strength1 and never undertake ,what is above your ,power4 ,and this brings to ,mind another very common ,occasion of ruining many a good ,genius2 ,i mean1 wrong ,application4 ,nothing will satisfie ,parents1 but their ,children must apply their ,minds to one of the learned ,professions1 when1 instead of consulting the ,reputation or ,interest of their ,children1 by such a preposterous ,choice1 they turn them out to live in an ,element no way suited to their ,nature1 and expose them to ,contempt and ,beggary all their ,days2 while at the same ,time they spoil an ,head1 admirably turn'd for ,traffick or ,mechanicks4 ,and he is left to bring up the ,rear in the learned ,profession1 or it may be lost in the ,crowd1 who would have shined in ,trade1 and made a prime ,figure upon the ,exchange4 ,many have by this ,means run their ,heads against a ,pulpit1 7as a ,satyrical ,genius once expressed it7 who would have made admirable ,ploughmen4 ,there is a different ,taste in ,men1 as to the learned ,professions themselves1 which qualities and disposes them for the one1 but would never make them appear with any ,lustre in another4 ,this has been often made evident in the different ,figures1 which some1 who lived in ,obscurity before1 have made upon a lucky ,incident that led them out of the mistaken ,track into which they were first put4 ,where ,providence does not relieve a ,genius from this ,error in setting out1 the ,man must be kept under the ,hatches all his ,days4 ,there are very different ,manners of ,writing1 and each of them just and agreeable in their ,kind1 when ,nature is followed1 and a ,man endeavours ,perfection in that ,style and ,manner which suits his own ,humour and ,abilities4 ,some please1 and indeed excel in a ,mediocrity1 ,lwho quite lose themselves if they attempt the ,sublime4 ,some succeed to a wonder in the ,account of all ,readers whilst they confine themselves to close ,reasoning2 who1 if they are so ill advise'd1 as to meddle with ,wit2 only make themselves the ,jest4 ,m,that is easy and agreeable which is natural2 what is forc'd1 will appear distorted and give ,disgust4 ,l ,dum vitat humum1 nubes et inania captet4 ,horat4 ,m ,ingenio1 sicut in ,agro1 quanquam alia diu ,serantur atque elaborentur1 gratiora tamen quae su sponte nascuntur4 ,tacit4 de ,orator1 c4 #f4 ,it is of fatal ,consequence to a good ,genius to grasp at too much4 ,a certain ,magistrate 7says ,bruyere7 arriving1 by his ,merit1 to the first ,dignities of the ,gown1 thought himself qualified for every ,thing4 ,he printed a ,treatise of ,morality1 and published himself a ,coxcomb4 ,universal ,genij and universal ,scholars are generally excellent at nothing4 ,he is certainly the wisest ,man1 who endeavours to be perfectly furnished for some ,business1 and regards other ,matters as no more than his ,amusement4 ,a ,genius being thus observed1 humoured and cultivated1 is to be kept in ,heart1 and upon proper ,occasions to be exerted4 ,without this1 it may sink and be lost4 ,all ,habits are weakened by ,disuse4 ,and ,men who are furnished with a ,genius1 for publick ,usefulness1 should put themselves forward2 ,i mean1 with due ,modesty and ,prudence1 and not suffer their ,talents to be hid1 when a fair ,opportunity offers to do ,service with them4 ,indeed it is too common an ,unhappiness for ,men to be so placed1 as to have no ,opportunity and ,advantage for shewing their ,genius4 ,as ,matters are generally managed in the ,world1 ,men are for the most part staked down to such ,business1 in such ,alliances1 or in such ,circumstances1 that they have no proper ,occasions of exerting themselves2 but instead of that1 are continually tugging and striving with things that are cross and ungrateful to them4 ,and that must be a strong ,mind indeed1 that shall break through the ,censures and ,opposition of the ,world1 and dare to quit a ,station1 for which a ,man has been brought up1 and in which he has acted for some ,time1 that he may get into another ,sphere1 where he sees he can act according to the ,impulses of his ,genius4 ,tho' such as have had the ,courage and ,skill to follow those ,impulses1 till they have gain'd the ,stations which suited their ,taste and ,inclination1 have seldom fail'd of appearing considerable4 ,but ,multitudes1 by this ,situation of ,affairs1 have been forc'd1 in a manner1 to stifle a ,genius1 because they could have no fair ,opportunity of exerting it4 ,a crazy ,constitution1 and a ,body liable to continual ,disorders1 call off the ,attention of many a great ,mind1 from what might otherwise procure very great ,reputation and ,regard4 ,their ,genius no sooner begins a little to exert itself1 but the ,spirits flag1 and one unhappy ,ail or other1 enfeebles and discourages the ,mind4 ,lust and ,wine mightily obstruct all ,attempts that require ,application2 and will neither allow a ,man duly to furnish his ,mind1 nor rightly to use that ,furniture he has4 ,an ,intrigue or a ,bottle may sometimes give an ,opportunity for a ,man to shew his ,genius1 but will utterly spoil all regular and reputable ,exertings of it4 ,he who would put forth his ,genius to the ,advantage of ,himself or the ,world1 should give into no ,pleasures that will enervate or dissolve his ,mind4 ,he must keep it bent for ,business1 or he will bring all ,business to nothing4 ,conceit and ,affectation on one hand1 and ,peevishness and ,perverseness of ,temper on the other1 will lay the best ,genius under great ,disadvantages1 and raise such ,dislike and ,opposition1 as will bear it down in spite of all its ,force and ,furniture4 ,a graceful ,mixture of ,boldness and ,modesty1 with a ,smoothness and ,benignity of ,temper1 will much better make a ,man's ,way into the ,world1 and procure him the ,opportunity of exerting his ,genius4 ,but there is nothing lies as an heavier ,weight upon a ,man1 or hinders ,him more from shewing ,himself to ,advantage1 and employing his great ,abilities for the ,service of ,others2 than the ,quarrels and ,contentions of ,parties4 ,many have their ,talents imprison'd1 by being of the hated and sinking ,side4 ,their ,light is wholly smother'd and suppress'd1 that it may not shine out with a ,lustre on the ,party to which they belong1 whether it be in ,politicks or ,religion4 ,and all ,struggles of a ,genius are vain1 when a ,man is born down at once by ,clamour and ,power4 ,this is very discouraging to a ,man who has taken much ,pains in cultivating his ,genius2 and many have1 without doubt1 been tempted wholly to neglect themselves1 from the ,dread of these ,discouragements4 ,i own this ,neglect is not to be excused altogether1 though it grieves one that there should be any ,occasion given for it4 ,there is still ,room for ,men to follow and improve a ,genius1 and hope by it to benefit ,mankind1 and procure ,regard to ,themselves4 ,and it is hard to say1 what ,way of exerting it will turn most to ,account4 ,peculiar ,honours are due to those who appear to ,advantage in the ,pulpit4 ,numerous ,applauses and ,preferments attend those who acquit themselves well at the ,bar4 ,there is a great deal of ,renown to those who are eminent in the ,senate4 ,there are high ,advantages to such as excel in ,counsel and on ,embassies4 ,immortal ,lawrels will crown such as are brave1 expert and victorious in ,arms4 ,there are the ,blessings of ,wealth and ,plenty to those who manage well their ,trades and ,merchandize4 ,the ,names of the skilful ,architect1 the cunning ,artificer1 the fine1 exact and well devising ,painter1 are sometimes enrolled in the ,lists of ,fame4 ,the learned1 experienced and successful ,physician1 may become as considerable for ,repute and ,estate1 as one of any other ,profession4 ,musick also may have its ,masters1 who shall be had in lasting ,esteem4 ,the ,poets ,performances may be ,nmore durable than ,brass1 and long lived as ,time it ,self4 ,every ,science may have ,professors that shall shine in the learned ,world4 ,with all the ,discouragements that may damp a ,genius1 there is yet a wide ,field for it to exert it self1 and ,room to hope it will not be in vain4 ,n ,exegi monumentum aere perennius ,regalique situ pyramidum altius1 ,quod non imber edax1 non ,aquilo impotens ,possit diruere aut innumerabilis ,annorum series et fuga temporum3 ,horat ,i was going to add something of exerting one's ,genius as an ,author4 ,but ,i found1 it would fill up too much ,room in my ,paper1 should ,i enlarge on the several ,ways of ,mens appearing considerable4 ,and ,i was so apprehensive of the ,reputation1 which the ,divine1 the ,historian1 the ,critick1 the ,philosopher1 and almost all the other ,authors1 have above us ,essay-,writers1 that ,i thought ,i should but lessen the ,regards to my own ,genius1 should ,i have set to ,view the ,advantages of ,others4 ,it will sufficiently gratify my ,ambition as an ,author1 if the ,world will be so good natured as to think ,i have handsomely excus'd my self2 that ,i am tolerably fitted1 in the ,way in ,i am1 to give ,entertainment to my ,readers1 and do them some ,service4 99 99 99 99 99 ,,finis 99 99 99 99 99 ,,errata ,transcriber's ,note3 ,not readable 99 99 99 99 99 ,,the ,,creation4 ,a ,pindaric ,illustration ,,of ,a ,,poem1 ,originally written by ,,moses1 ,on ,that ,,subject4 ,,with ,a ,,preface to ,mr4 ,,pope1 ,,concerning ,the ,sublimity of the ,ancient ,,hebrew ,,poetry1 and a material and obvious ,defect in the ,,english4 ,,london3 ,printed for ,t4 ,,bickerton1 at the ,crown in ,pater-noster-,row4 ,m4 ,,dcc4 ,,xx4 ,price ,one ,shilling4 ,,preface to ,,mr4 ,,pope ,sir1 ,about two ,years ago1 upon a slight ,misapprehension of some ,expressions of yours1 which my ,resentment1 or perhaps my ,pride1 interpreted to the ,disadvantage of a ,poetical ,trifle1 ,i had then newly publish'd1 ,i suffer'd myself to be unreasonably transported1 so far1 as to inscribe you an angry1 and inconsiderate ,preface2 without previous ,examination into the ,justness of my ,proceeding4 ,i have lately had the ,mortification to learn from your own ,hand that you were entirely guiltless of the fact charg'd upon you2 so that1 in attempting to retaliate a suppos'd ,injury1 ,i have done a real ,injustice4 ,the only ,thing which an honest ,man ought to be more asham'd of than his faults1 is a ,reluctance against confessing them4 ,i have already acknowledg'd mine to yourself3 ,but no publick ,guilt is well aton'd1 by a private ,satisfaction2 ,i therefore send you a ,duplicate of my ,letter1 by way of the ,world1 that all1 who remember my ,offence1 may also witness my ,repentance4 ,sir1 ,i am under the greatest ,confusion ,i ever felt in my ,life1 to find by your ,letter1 that ,i have been guilty of a ,crime1 which ,i can never forgive ,myself1 were it for no other ,reason1 than that ,you have forgiven it4 ,i might have learnt from your ,writings the ,extent of your ,soul1 and shou'd have concluded it impossible for the ,author of those elevated ,sentiments1 to sink beneath them in his ,practice4 ,you are generously moderate1 when you mitigate my ,guilt1 and miscall it a ,credulity2 'twas a passionate1 and most unjustifiable ,levity1 and must still have remain'd unpardonable1 whatever ,truth might have been found in its mistaken ,occasion4 ,what stings me most1 in my ,reflection on this ,folly1 is1 that ,i know not how to atone it2 ,i will endeavour it1 however2 being always asham'd1 when ,i have attempted to revenge an ,injury1 but never more proud1 than when ,i have begg'd pardon for an ,error4 ,if you needed an ,inducement to the strengthening your ,forgiveness1 you might gather it from these two ,considerations2 ,first1 ,the ,crime was almost a ,sin against ,conviction2 for though not happy enough to know you personally1 your ,mind had been my intimate ,acquaintance1 and regarded with a kind of partial ,tenderness1 that made it little less than ,miracle1 that ,i attempted to offend you4 ,a sudden ,warmth1 to which1 by ,nature1 ,i am much too liable1 transported me to a ,condition1 ,i shall best describe in ,shakespear's ,sense1 somewhere or other4 ,blind in th' obscuring ,mist of heedless ,rage1 ,i've rashly shot my ,arrows o'er a ,house1 ,and hurt my ,brother4444 ,a ,second ,consideration is1 the ,occasion you have gather'd to punish my ,injustice1 with more than double ,sharpness1 by your ,manner of receiving it4 ,the ,armour of your ,mind is temper'd so divinely1 that my mere ,human ,weapons have not only fail'd to pierce1 but broke to pieces in rebounding4 ,you meet ,assaults1 like some expert ,arabian1 who1 declining any ,use of his own ,javelin1 arrests those which come against him1 in the ,fierceness of their ,motion1 and overcomes his ,enemies1 by detaining their own ,weapons4 ',tis a noble ,triumph you now exercise1 by the ,superiority of your ,nature2 and while ,i see you looking down upon the ,distance of my ,frailty1 ,i am forc'd to own a ,glory1 which ,i envy you2 and am quite asham'd of the poor ,figure ,i am making1 in the bottom of the ,prospect4 ,i feel1 ,i am sure1 ,remorse1 enough to satisfy you for the ,wrong1 but to express it1 wou'd1 ,i think1 exceed even your own ,power4 ,yours1 whose sweet ,songs can rival ,orpheu's ,strain1 ,and force the wondring ,woods to dance again1 ,make moving ,mountains hear your pow'rful ,call1 ,and headlong ,streams hang list'ning in their ,fall4 ,no ,words can be worthy to come after these2 ,i will therefore hasten to tell you1 that ,i am1 and will ever be1 with the greatest ,truth and ,respect1 ,,sir1 ,your ,most ,humble1 and ,most ,obedient ,servant1 ,a4 ,hill4 ,i have now attempted1 as far as ,i am able1 to throw off a ,weight1 which my ,mind has been uneasy under4 ,i cannot say1 in the ,city ,phrase1 that ,i have balanc'd the ,account1 but you must admit of ,composition1 where full ,payment is impossible4 ,i shall be so far from regretting you the old ,benefit of ,lex talionis1 that ,i forgive you heartily1 beforehand1 for any thing you may hereafter think fit to say1 or do1 to my ,disadvantage2 nay1 the ,pleasure ,i enjoy by reflecting on your good ,nature1 will degenerate to a ,pain1 if one ,accident or other1 in the ,course of your ,life1 does not favour me with some ,occasion of advancing your ,interest4 ,having said thus much to you1 in your ,quality of a ,good ,man1 ,i will proceed to address you1 in your other ,quality1 of a ,great ,poet2 in which ,light ,i look up to you with extraordinary ,comfort1 as to a new ,constellation breaking out upon our ,world1 with equal ,heat1 and ,brightness1 and cross-spangling1 as it were1 the whole ,heaven of ,wit with your milky way of ,genius4 ,you cou'd never have been born at a ,time1 which more wanted the ,influence of your ,example3 ,all the ,fire you bring with you1 and the ,judgment you are acquiring1 in the ,course of your ,journey1 will be put to their full stress1 to support and rebuild the sinking ,honours of ,poetry4 ,it was a ,custom1 which prevail'd generally among the ,ancients1 to impute ,celestial ,descent to their ,heroes2 ,the ,vanity1 methinks1 might have been pardonable1 and rational1 if apply'd to an ,art2 since ,arts1 when they are at once delightful and profitable1 as you will certainly leave ,poetry1 have one real ,mark of ,divinity1 they become1 in some measure1 immortal4 ,and as the oldest1 and1 ,i think1 the sublimest ,poem in the ,world1 is of ,hebrew ,original1 and was made immediately after passing the ,red-,sea1 at a ,time1 when the ,author had neither ,leisure1 nor ,possibility1 to invent a new ,art3 ,it must therefore be undeniable1 either that the ,hebrews brought ,poetry out of ,egypt1 or that ,moses receiv'd it from ,god1 by immediate ,inspiration4 ,this last1 being what a ,poet should be fondest of believing1 ,i wou'd fain suppose it probable1 that ,god1 who was pleas'd to instruct ,moses with what ,ceremony he wou'd be worship'd1 taught him also a ,mode of ,thinking1 and expressing ,thought1 unprophan'd by vulgar ,use1 and peculiar to that ,worship4 ,god then taught ,poetry first to the ,hebrews1 and the ,hebrews to ,mankind in general4 ,but1 however this may have been1 there is1 apparently1 a divine ,spirit1 glowing forcibly in the ,hebrew ,poetry1 a kind of terrible ,simplicity2 a magnificent ,plainness6 which is commonly lost1 in ,paraphrase1 by our mistaken ,endeavours after heightening the ,sentiments1 by a figurative ,expression2 ,this is very ill ,judg'd3 ,the little ,ornaments of ,rhetorick might serve1 fortunately enough1 to swell out the ,leanness of some modern ,compositions2 but to shadow over the ,lustre of a divine ,hebrew ,thought1 by an ,affectation of enliv'ning it1 is to paint upon a ,diamond1 and call it an ,ornament4 ,it is a surprizing ,reflection1 that these noble ,hebrew ,poets shou'd have written with such admirable ,vigour three ,thousand ,years ago2 and that1 instead of improving1 we should affect to despise them2 as if1 to write smoothly1 and without the ,spirit of ,imagery1 were the true ,art of ,poetry1 because the only ,art we practise4 ,it puts me in ,mind of the famous ,roman ,lady1 who suppos'd1 that ,men had1 naturally1 stinking ,breaths1 because she had been us'd to it1 in her ,husband4 ,the most obvious ,defect in our ,poetry1 and ,i think the greatest it is liable to1 is1 that we study ,form1 and neglect ,matter4 ,we are often very flowing1 and under a full ,sail of ,words1 while we leave our ,sense fast aground1 as too weighty to float on ,frothiness2 ,we run on1 upon false ,scents1 like a ,spaniel1 that starts away at ,random after a ,stone1 which is kept back in the ,hand1 though ,it seem'd to fly before him4 ,to speak with ,freedom on this ,subject1 is a ,task of more ,danger than ,honour2 for few ,minds have real ,greatness enough to consider a ,detection of their ,errors1 as a ,warning to their ,conduct1 and an ,advantage to their ,fame2 ,but no discerning ,judgment will consider it as ill ,nature1 in one ,writer1 to mark the ,faults of another4 ,a general ,practice of that ,kind wou'd be the highest ,service to poetry4 ,no ,disease can be cur'd1 till its ,nature is examin'd2 and the first likely ,step towards correcting our ,errors1 is resolving to learn impartially1 that we have ,errors to be corrected4 ,i will1 therefore1 with much ,freedom1 but no manner of ,malice1 remark an ,instance or two1 from no mean ,writers1 to prove1 that our ,poetry has been degenerating apace into mere ,sound1 or ,harmony2 nor ought ,this to be consider'd as an invidious ,attempt1 since whatever ,pains we take1 about polishing our ,numbers1 where we raise not our ,meaning1 are as impertinently bestowed1 as the ,labour wou'd be1 of setting a broken ,leg after the ,soul has left the ,body4 ,the ,gunners have a ,custom1 when a ,ball is too little for the ,bore of their ,canon1 to wrap ,towe about it1 till it fills the ,mouth of the ,piece2 after which1 it is discharg'd1 with a ,thunder1 proportionable to the ,size of the ,gun2 ,but its ,execution at the ,mark1 will immediately discover1 that the ,noise of the ,discharge was a great deal too big for the ,diameter of the ,bullet4 ,it is just the same thing with an unsinewy ,imagination1 sent abroad in sounding ,numbers2 ,the ,loftiness of the ,expression will astonish shallow ,readers into a temporary ,admiration1 and support it1 for a while2 but the ,bounce1 however loud1 goes no farther than the ,ear2 ,the ,heart remains unreach'd by the ,languor of the ,sentiment4 ,poetry1 the most elevated ,exertion of human ,wit1 is no more than a weak and contemptible ,amusement1 wanting ,energy of ,thought1 or ,propriety of ,expression4 ,yet we may run into ,error1 by an injudicious ,affectation of attaining ,perfection1 as ,men1 who are gazing upward1 when they shou'd be looking to their ,footsteps1 stumble frequently against ,posts1 while they have the ,sun in ,contemplation4 ,in attempting1 for ,example1 to modernize so lofty an ,ode as the #ajdth ,psalm1 the ,choice of ,metaphors shou'd1 methinks1 have been considered1 as one of the most remarkable ,difficulties4 ,there seems to have been a ,necessity1 that they shou'd be noble1 as well as natural2 and yet1 if too much rais'd1 they wou'd endanger an ,extinction of the ,charms1 which they were design'd to illustrate4 ,that powerful ,imagination of 'the ,sea1 climbing over the ,mountains ,tops1 and rushing back1 upon the ,plains1 at the ,voice of ,god's ,thunder1' ought certainly to have been express'd with as much ,plainness as possible3 ,and1 to demonstrate how ill the contrary ,measure has succeeded1 one need only observe how it looks in ,mr4 ,trapp's ,metaphorical ,refinement4 ,the ,ebbing ,deluge did its ,troops recal1 ,drew off its ,forces1 and disclos'd the ,ball1 ,they1 at th' ,eternal's ,signal march'd away4 ,who does not discern1 in this ,place1 what an ,injury is done to the original ,image1 by the military ,metaphor8 ,recalling the ',troops' of a ,deluge1 ',drawing off its ,forces'2 and its ',marching away1 at a ,signal1' carry not only a visible ,impropriety of ,thought1 but are infinitely below the ,majesty of ,that ,god1 who is so dreadfully represented thundering his ,commands to the ,ocean2 ,they are directly the ,reverse of that terrible ,confusion1 and overwhelming ,uproar of ,motion1 which the ,sea1 in the ,original1 is suppos'd to fall into4 ,the ,march of an ,army is pleasing1 orderly1 slow2 ,the ,inundation of a ,sea1 from the ,tops of the ,mountains1 frightful1 wild and tumultuous2 ,every ,justness and ,grace of the original ,conception is destroyed by the ,metaphor4 ,in the same ,psalm1 the ,hebrew ,poet describing ,god1 says1 '4444,he maketh the ,clouds his ,chariots1 and walketh on the ,wings of the ,wind4' ,making the ',clouds his ,chariots1' is a strong and lively ,thought2 ,but ,that of 'walking on the ,wings of the ,wind1' is a ,sublimity1 that frightens1 astonishes1 and ravishes the ,mind of a ,reader1 who conceives it1 as he shou'd do4 ,the ,judgement of the ,poet in this ,place1 is discernable in three different ,particulars2 ,the ,thought is in itself highly noble1 and elevated2 ,to move at all upon the ,wind1 carries with it an ,image of much ,majesty and ,terror2 ,but this natural ,grandeur he first encreas'd by the ,word ',wings1' which represents the ,motion1 as not only on the ,winds1 but on the ,winds in their utmost ,violence1 and ,rapidity of ,agitation4 ,but then at last1 comes that finishing ,sublimity1 which attends the ,word 'walks'6 ,the ,poet is not satisfied to represent ,god1 as riding on the ,winds2 nor even as riding on them in a ,tempest2 ,he therefore tells us1 that ,he walks on their ,wings2 that so our ,idea might be heighten'd to the utmost1 by reflecting on this calm1 and easy ,motion of the ,deity1 upon a ,violence1 so rapid1 so furious1 and ungovernable1 to our human ,conception4 ,yet as nothing can be more sublime1 so nothing can be more simple1 and plain1 than this noble ,imagination4 ,but ,mr4 ,trapp1 not contented to express1 attempts unhappily to adorn this inimitable ,beauty1 in the following ,manner4 ,who1 borne in ,triumph o'er the ,heavenly ,plains1 ,rides on the ,clouds1 and holds a ,storm in ,reins1 ,flies on the ,wings of the sonorous ,wind1 c4 ,here his imperfect1 and diminishing ,metaphor1 of the ',rains1' has quite ruin'd the ,image2 ,what rational1 much less noble ,idea1 can any ,man conceive of a ,wind in a ,bridle8 ,the unlucky ,word ',plains' too1 is a downright ,contradiction to the ,meaning of the ,passage4 ,what wider ,difference in ,nature1 than between driving a ,chariot over a ,plain1 and moving enthron'd1 amidst ,that rolling1 and terrible ,perplexity of ,motions1 which we figure to our ,imagination1 from a ',chariot of ,clouds'8 ,but the mistaken ,embellishment of the ,word 'flies1' in the last ,verse1 is an ,error almost unpardonable2 ,instead of improving the ,conception1 it has made it trifling1 and contemptible1 and utterly destroy'd the very ,soul of its ,energy6 'flies' on the ,wind6 ,what an ,image is ,that1 to express the ,majesty of ,god8 ,to 'walk' on the ,wind is astonishing1 and horrible2 ,but to 'fly' on the ,wind1 is the ,employment of a ,bat1 of an ,owl1 of a ,feather6 ,mr4 ,trapp is1 ,i believe1 a ,gentleman of so much ,candour1 and so true a ,friend to the ,interest of the ,art he professes1 that there will be no ,occasion to ask his pardon1 for dragging a ,criminal ,metaphor1 or two1 out of the ,immunity of his ,protection4 ,mr4 ,philips has lately been told in ,print1 by one of our best ,criticks1 that he has excell'd all the ,ancients1 in his ,pastoral ,writings2 ,he will1 therefore1 be apt to wonder1 that ,i take the ,liberty to say1 in downright ,respect to ,truth1 and the ,justice due to ,poetry1 that ,i have not only seen modern pastorals1 much better than ,his1 but that his appear1 to me1 neither natural1 nor equal4 ,one might extend this ,remark to the very ,names of his ,shepherds2 ,lobbin1 ,hobbinol1 and ,cuddy are nothing of a ,piece1 with ,lanquet1 ,mico1 and ,argol2 nor do his ,personages agree better with themselves1 than their ,names with one another4 ,mico1 for ,example1 at the first ,sight we have of him1 is a very polite ,speaker1 and as metaphorical as ,mr4 ,trapp4 ,this ,place may seem for ,shepherds ,leisure made1 ,so lovingly these ,elms unite their ,shade6 ,th'ambitious ,woodbine6 how it climbs1 to breathe ,its balmy ,sweets around1 on all beneath6 ,but1 alas6 this ,fit of ,eloquence1 like most other ,blessings1 is of very short ,continuance2 ,it holds him but ,just one ,speech3 ,in the beginning of the next1 he is as very a ,rustick1 as ,colin ,clout1 and has forgot all his ,breeding4 ,no ,skill of ,musick can ,i1 simple ,swain1 ,no fine ,device1 thine ,ear to entertain2 ,albeit some deal ,i pipe1 rude though it be1 ,sufficient to divert my1 ,sheep1 and ,me4 ,there is no ,transformation ,in ,ovid more sudden1 or surprizing2 ,he has ,reason indeed to say1 that1 when he pipes some deal1 his ',sheep' are 'diverted' with him4 ,his ,readers1 ,i am afraid too1 are as merry as his ,sheep2 ,if he was but as skilful in ,change of ,time1 as he is in ,change of ,dialect1 commend me to him for a ,musician6 ,the pied ,piper1 who drew all the ,rats of a ,city out1 after his ,melody1 came not near him for ,variety4 ,if the late excellent ,mr4 ,addison1 whose ,verses abound in ,graces1 which can never be too much admir'd1 shall be1 often1 found liable to an ,overflow of his ,meaning1 by this ,dropsical ,wordiness1 which we so generally give into1 it will serve at the same time1 as a ,comfort1 and a ,warning2 and incline us to a severe ,examination of our ,writings1 when we venture out upon a ,world1 that will1 one time or other1 be sure to censure us impartially2 ,in ,that ,gentleman's ,works1 whoever looks close1 will discover ,thorns on every ,branch of his ,roses2 ,for ,example1 we all hear1 with ,delight1 in his celebrated ,letter from ,italy1 that1 there1 444 ,the ,muse so oft her ,harp has strung1 ,that not a ,mountain rears its ,head unsung4 ,but1 he adds1 in the very next ,line1 that every shady ,thicket too1 grows renown'd in ,verse2 now one can never help remembering1 that ,thickets are ,births1 as it were of ,yesterday2 the mere ,infancy of ,woods6 and that the oldest ,woods in ,italy may be growing on ,foundations of ruin'd ,cities1 which flourish'd in the ,times he there speaks of2 whence it must naturally be inferr'd1 that to say1 the ,italian ,thickets grow renown'd in ,roman ,verse1 though the ,mountains really do so1 is to make ,use of ,words1 without ,regard to their ,meaning2 ,a ,lapse of dangerous ,consequence1 because1 when the ,understanding is once shock'd1 this most rapturous ,elevation of the ,mind 7as when cold ,water is thrown suddenly upon boiling7 sinks at once to chilling ,flatness1 and is considered as mere ,gingle and childish ,amusement4 ,no ,man1 ,i believe1 has read without ,pleasure1 his fine and lively ,descriptions of the ,nar1 ,clitumnus1 ,mincio1 and ,albula1 but the worst of it is1 he winds us so long1 in and out1 between these ,rivers1 that he loses himself in their ,maeanders1 and brings us1 at last1 to a strange ,stream indeed1 which is 'immortaliz'd in ,song1' and yet 'lost ,in ,oblivion4' ,i look for ,streams1 immortaliz'd1 in ,song1 ,which lost1 and buried in ,oblivion lie4 ,the ,thought1 in this ,place1 is very lively and just1 but quite obscur'd by the ,redundancy and ,wantonness of the ,expression4 ,had he only said 'lost1' and 'buried1' ,it might have been urg'd1 that the ,rivers were dry'd up1 and no longer to be found1 in their old ,channels4 ,but1 let them be lost1 as to ,existence1 as certainly as he will1 they can never be lost in ',oblivion1' if they are 'immortaliz'd' in ,poetry4 ',immortal' is a favourite ,word in this ,gentleman's ,writings1 and leads him1 as most ,favourites are apt to do1 into very frequent ,errors4 ,it is naturally unpleasant1 to be detain'd too long in the ,maziness of one tedious ,thought1 express'd many ,ways successively4 ,when we read that the ',tiber is destitute of ,strength1' what else can we conclude1 but that its ,stream is a weak one8 ,but we are oblig'd to hear1 also1 that it 'derives its ,source from an unthrifty ,urn'3 ,well1 now1 may we go on8 ,no2 its ',urn' is not only 'unthrifty1' but its ',source' is unfruitful4 ,by this time1 one can scarce help1 enquiring1 what new ,meaning is convey'd to the ,apprehension1 by the ,multiplication of the ,phrases8 ,and not finding any1 we have no ,reflection to satisfy ourselves with1 but1 that the strongest ,flow of ,fancy1 is most subject to ,whirlpools4 ,it is from the same unweigh'd ,redundancy1 and ,misapplication of ,words1 that we so often find this excellent ,writer falling into the ,anticlimax4 ,as where1 for ,example1 he informs us of ,liberty1 that she is a ,goddess1 ,profuse of ,bliss1 and pregnant with ,delight1 ,eternal ,pleasures1 in her ,presence reign4 ,after ',profusion of ,bliss1' that is to say1 the heap'd ,enjoyment of all ,blessings to be wish'd for2 how does it cool the ,imagination1 to read of being 'pregnant with ,delight'8 ,had she been brought to ,bed of ',delight1' it had been but a poor ,delivery3 ,for what imports ',delight1' in ,comparison with ',bliss'8 ,and how much less too is pregnant with ,delight1' than ',delight' in ,possession6 ,but then again1 after both these1 what cou'd the ,author hope to teach us1 by adding1 that ',pleasure reigns in her ,presence4' ,can there be ',bliss' without ',delight'8 ,was there ever ',delight' without ',pleasure'8 ,it shou'd gradually have ascended thus1 ,pleasure1 ,delight1 ,bliss2 ,but to turn it the direct contrary ,way1 ,bliss1 ,delight1 ,pleasure1 is setting a poor ,meaning upon its ,head1 and the same thing as to say1 ,mr4 ,addison writ incomparably1 finely1 nay1 and tolerably4 ,a ,praise1 which1 ,i dare say1 he wou'd have given no ,body ,thanks for4 ,one wou'd think there were a kind of ,fatality in ,liberty1 since scarce any ,body can meddle either with the ,word or the ,thing1 but they turn all topsey turvey4 ,but ,i am sliding insensibly into a ,theme1 that requires rather a ,volume1 than a ,page or two2 ,i hasten therefore to present you a ,paraphrase on the ,six ,days ,work of the ,creator1 as described to us by ,moses1 in the ,first ,chapter of ,genesis1 which1 you know1 was written1 originally1 in ,verse4 ,it wou'd be difficult1 ,i am sure1 to match the ,greatness of that inspired ,author's ,images1 out of all the noble ,writings1 which have honour'd ,antiquity2 and whose most remarkable ,excellencies have been found1 in those ,parts of their ,works1 which they elevated1 and made more solemn1 by a ,mixture of their ,religion4 ,our ,poetry1 in so able a ,hand as ,yours1 might receive heavenly ,advantages1 from a ,practice of like ,nature4 ,but ,i am of ,opinion1 that no ,english ,verse1 except that1 which we1 ,i think a little improperly1 call ,pindaric1 can allow the necessary ,scope1 to so masterless a ,subject1 as the ,creation1 of all others the most copious1 and illustrious2 and which ought to be touch'd with most ,discretion1 and ,choice of ,circumstances4 ,mr4 ,milton1 ,mr4 ,cowley1 ,sir ,richard ,blackmore1 and now1 lately1 a young ,gentleman1 of a very lively ,genius1 have severally tried their ,strength in this celestial ,bow2 ,sir ,richard may be said indeed to have shot farthest1 but too often beside the ,mark2 ,he will permit me the ,liberty of owning my ,opinion1 that he is too minute1 and particular1 and rather labours to oppress us with every ,image he cou'd raise1 than to refresh and enliven us1 with the noblest1 and most differing4 ,he is also too unmindful of the ,dignity of his ,subject1 and diminishes it by mean1 and contemptible ,metaphors4 ,speaking of the ,skies1 he says they were ,spun thin1 and wove1 on ,nature's finest ,loom4 ,longinus is very angry with ,timaeus for saying of ,alexander1 that he conquer'd all ,asia1 in less ,time than ,isocrates took to write his ,panegyric1 ,because1 says the ,critick1 it is a pitiful ,comparison of ,alexander the ,great with a ,schoolmaster4 ,what then wou'd he have said of ,sir ,richard's ,metaphorical ,comparison of the ,,creator ,himself1 to a ,spinster1 and a ,weaver8 ,the very ,beasts of ,mr4 ,milton1 who kept ,moses in his ,eye1 carry ,infinitely more ,majesty1 than the ,skies of ,sir ,richard4 ,the ,grassy ,clods now calv'd2 and half appear'd ,the tawny ,lyon1 pawing to get free ,his hinder ,parts2 then springs1 as broke from ,bonds1 ,and1 rampant1 shakes aloft1 his brinded ,main6 ,the heaving ,leopard1 rising1 like the ,mole1 ,in ,heaps the crumbling ,earth about him threw6 ,these animated ,images1 or pictured ,meanings of ,poetry1 are the forcible ,inspirers1 which enflame a ,reader's ,will1 and bind down his ,attention4 ,they arise from living ,words1 as ,aristotle calls them2 that is1 from ,words so finely chosen1 and so ,justly ranged1 that they call up before a ,reader the ,spirit of their ,sense1 in that very ,form1 and ,action1 it impressed upon the ,writer4 ,but when the ,idea1 which a ,poet strives to raise1 is in itself magnificent and striking1 the ,dawb of ,metaphor1 or any spumy ,colourings of ,rhetoric can but deaden1 and efface it4 ,if ,sir ,richard had said1 concerning the ,skies1 on any other ,subject but ,this1 of the ,creation1 that they were 'spun thin1 and wove1 on ,nature's finest ,loom1' the ,thought had been so far from ,impropriety1 as to have been pleasing1 and praise-worthy2 ,but when the ,image he wou'd set before us1 is the ,maker of ,heaven and ,earth1 in all the dreadful ,majesty of his ,omnipotence1 producing at a ,word1 the noblest ,part of the ,creation1 and 'spreading out the ,heavens as a ,curtain'2 ,in this tremendous ,exercise of his ,divinity1 to compare him to a ,weaver1 and his ,expansion of the ,skies1 to the low ,mechanism of a ',loom1' is injudiciously to diminish an ,idea1 he pretends to heighten and illustrate4 ,i will end with a ,word or two concerning the different ,measure of the ,verse1 in which the following ,poem is written2 and which is apt to disgust ,readers1 not well grounded in ,poetry1 because it requires a fuller ,degree of ,attention than the ,couplet1 and1 as ,mr4 ,cowley has said of it1 444 ,will no unskilful ,touch endure1 ,but flings ,writer and ,reader too1 that sits not sure4 ,i have1 in another ,place1 endeavoured by ,arguments to demonstrate the ,preference of this ,kind of ,verse to any other2 ,i will here observe only1 from my ,experience of other ,writers1 that it wins1 insinuates1 and grows insensibly upon the ,relish of a ,reader1 till the little seeming ,harshness1 which is supposed to be in it1 softens gradually away1 and leaves a vigorous ,impression behind it1 of mixed ,majesty and ,sweetness4 ,a ,man1 who is just beginning to try his ,ear in ,pindaric1 may be compared to a new ,scater2 ,he totters strangely at first1 and staggers backward and forward2 ,every ,stick1 or frozen ,stone in his ,way1 is a ,rub that he falls at4 ,but when many repeated ,trials have embolden'd him to strike out1 and taught the true ,poize of ,motion1 he throws forward his ,body with a dextrous ,velocity1 and becoming ravish'd with the masterly ,sweep of his ,windings1 knows no ,pleasure greater1 than to feel himself fly through that well-measured ,maziness1 which he first attempted with ,perplexity4 ,but ,i will detain you no longer1 and hasten now to the ,poem1 which has given me this pleasing ,opportunity of telling you how much ,i am1 ,sir1 ,your ,most ,humble and ,obedient ,servant1 ,a4 ,,hill ,,the ,,augustan ,,reprint ,,society ,,announces ,,its ,publications for the ,third ,year7#aidh-aidi7 ,at least two items will be printed from each of the three following groups3 ,series ,,iv3 ,men1 ,manners1 and ,critics ,sir ,john ,falstaff 7pseud471 ,the ,theatre 7#agbj74 ,aaron ,hill1 ,preface to ,the ,creation2 and ,thomas ,brereton1 ,preface to ,esther4 ,ned ,ward1 ,selected ,tracts4 ,series ,v3 ,drama ,edward ,moore1 ,the ,gamester 7#agec74 ,nevil ,payne1 ,fatal ,jealousy 7#afgc74 ,mrs4 ,centlivre1 ,the ,busie ,body 7#agji74 ,charles ,macklin1 ,man of the ,world 7#agha74 ,series ,,vi3 ,poetry and ,language ,john ,oldmixon1 ,reflections on ,dr4 ,swift's ,letter to ,harley 7#agab72 and ,arthur ,mainwaring1 ,the ,british ,academy 7#agab74 ,pierre ,nicole1 ,de ,epigrammate4 ,andre ,dacier1 ,essay on ,lyric ,poetry4 ,issues will appear1 as usual1 in ,may1 ,july1 ,september1 ,november1 ,january1 and ,march4 ,in spite of rising costs1 membership fees will be kept at the present annual rate of #b4ej in the ,united ,states and ,canada2 #b4ge in ,great ,britain and the continent4 ,british and continental subscriptions should be sent to ,b4,h4 ,blackwell1 ,broad ,street1 ,oxford1 ,england4 ,american and ,canadian subscriptions may be sent to any one of the ,general ,editors4 ,,to ,,the1 ,,augustan ,,reprint ,,society3 ,i enclose the membership fee for the third year the second and third year the first1 second1 and third year ,,name4444 ,,address4444 ,,note3 ,all income received by the ,society is devoted to defraying cost of printing and mailing4 ,,the ,,augustan ,,reprint ,,society ,,makes ,,available ,inexpensive ,reprints of ,rare ,materials ,,from ,,english ,,literature ,,of ,,the ,,seventeenth ,,and ,,eighteenth ,,centuries ,students1 scholars1 and bibliographers of literature1 history1 and philology will find the publications valuable4 ,the ,johnsonian ,news ,letter has said of them3 ,excellent facsimiles1 and cheap in price1 these represent the triumph of modern scientific reproduction4 ,be sure to become a subscriber2 and take it upon yourself to see that your college library is on the mailing list4 ,the ,augustan ,reprint ,society is a non-profit1 scholarly organization1 run without overhead expense4 ,by careful management it is able to offer at least six publications each year at the unusually low membership fee of #b4ej per year in the ,united ,states and ,canada1 and #b4ge in ,great ,britain and the continent4 ,libraries as well as individuals are eligible for membership4 ,since the publications are issued without profit1 however1 no discount can be allowed to libraries1 agents1 or booksellers4 ,new members may still obtain a complete run of the first year's publications for #b4ej1 the annual membership fee4 ,during the first two years the publications are issued in three series3 ,i4 ,essays on ,wit2 ,,ii4 ,essays on ,poetry and ,language2 and ,,iii4 ,essays on the ,stage4 ,,publications ,,for ,,the ,,first ,,year 7#aidf-aidg7 ,,may1 #aidf3 ,series ,i1 ,no4 #a--,richard ,blackmore's ,essay upon ,wit 7#agaf71 and ,addison's ,freeholder ,no4 #de 7#agaf74 ,,july1 #aidf3 ,series ,,ii1 ,no4 #a--,samuel ,cobb's ,of ,poetry and ,discourse on ,criticism 7#agjg74 ,,sept41 #aidf3 ,series ,,iii1 ,no4 #a--;,anon41 ,letter to ,a4,h4 ,esq42 concerning the ,stage 7#afih71 and ,richard ,willis' ,occasional ,paper ,no4 ,,ix 7#afih74 ,nov41 #aidf3 ,series ,i1 ,no4 #b--;,anon41 ,essay on ,wit 7#agdh71 together with ,characters by ,flecknoe1 and ,joseph ,warton's ,adventurer ,nos4 #abg and #acc4 ,,jan41 #aidg3 ,series ,,ii1 ,no4 #b--,samuel ,wesley's ,epistle to a ,friend ,concerning ,poetry 7#agjj7 and ,essay on ,heroic ,poetry 7#afic74 ,,march1 #aidg3 ,series ,,iii1 ,no4 #b--;,anon41 ,representation of the ,impiety and ,immorality of the ,stage 7#agjd7 and anon41 ,some ,thoughts ,concerning the ,stage 7#agjd74 ,,publications ,,for ,,the ,,second ,,year 7#aidg-aidh7 ,,may1 #aidg3 ,series ,i1 ,no4 #c--;,john ,gay's ,the ,present ,state of ,wit2 and a section on ,wit from ,the ,english ,theophrastus4 ,with an ,introduction by ,donald ,bond4 ,,july1 #aidg3 ,series ,,ii1 ,no4 #c--,rapin's ,de ,carmine ,pastorali1 translated by ,creech4 ,with an ,introduction by ,j4,e4 ,congleton4 ,,sept41 #aidg3 ,series ,,iii1 ,no4 #c--,t4 ,hanmer's 787 ,some ,remarks on the ,tragedy of ,hamlet4 ,with an ,introduction by ,clarence ,d4 ,thorpe4 ,nov41 #aidg3 ,series ,i1 ,no4 #d--;,corbyn ,morris' ,essay towards ,fixing the ,true ,standards of ,wit1 etc4 ,with an ,introduction by ,james ,l4 ,clifford4 ,,jan41 #aidh3 ,series ,,ii1 ,no4 #d--,thomas ,purney's ,discourse on the ,pastoral4 ,with an ,introduction by ,earl ,wasserman4 ,,march1 #aidh3 ,series ,,iii1 ,no4 #d--;,essays on the ,stage1 selected1 with an ,introduction by ,joseph ,wood ,krutch4 ,the list of publications is subject to modification in response to requests by members4 ,from time to time ,bibliographical ,notes will be included in the issues4 ,each issue contains an ,introduction by a scholar of special competence in the field represented4 ,the ,augustan ,reprints are available only to members4 ,they will never be offered at remainder prices4 ,,general ,,editors ,,richard ,c4 ,,boys1 ,university of ,michigan ,,edward ,,niles ,,hooker1 ,university of ,california1 ,los ,angeles ,h4,t4 ,,swedenberg1 ,,jr41 ,university of ,california1 ,los ,angeles ,,advisory ,,editors ,,emmett ,l4 ,,avert1 ,state ,college of ,washington ,,louis ,i4 ,,bredvold1 ,university of ,michigan ,,benjamin ,,boyce1 ,university of ,nebraska ,,cleanth ,,brooks1 ,louisiana ,state ,university ,,james ,l4 ,,clifford1 ,columbia ,university ,,arthur ,,friedman1 ,university of ,chicago ,,samuel ,h4 ,,monk1 ,university of ,minnesota ,,james ,,sutherland4 ,queen ,mary ,college1 ,london ,address communications to any of the ,general ,editors4 ,applications for membership1 together with membership fee1 should be sent to ,,the ,,augustan ,,reprint ,,society #caj ,,royce ,,hall1 ,,university ,,of ,,california ,,los ,,angeles #bd1 ,,california or ,care of ,,professor ,,richard ,c4 ,,boys ,,angell ,,hall1 ,,university ,,of ,,michigan ,,ann ,,arbor1 ,,michigan ,please enroll me as a member of the ,augustan ,reprint ,society4 ,i enclose #b4ej as the membership fee for the second year #e4jj as the membership fee for the first and second year ,,name4444 ,address4444