,,! ,,ox=d ,,movem5t ,,twelve ,,ye>s #ahcc-ahde ,r4,w4 ,,*ur*1 ,m4,a41 ,d4,c4,l4 ,,sometime ,,dean ,,( ,,/4 ,,paul',s ,,& ,,fell[ ,,( ,,oriel ,,college1 ,,ox=d ,,adv]tisem5t ,! revision ( ^! pap]s 0 a task to :i* ! late ,dean ( ,/4 ,paul's gave all ! "w he c\ld dur+ ! la/ mon?s ( 8 life4 ,at ! "t ( 8 dea?1 f\rte5 ( ! pap]s _h1 s f> z c be judg$1 receiv$ ! =m 9 :i* he wi%$ !m to be publi%$2 & ^!1 ( c\rse1 are pr9t$ "h exactly z he left !m4 ,"o m he _h all b prep>$ = publication2 ! la/ f\r 7 ma9ly 9 ! condition 9 :i*1 six ye>s ago1 he _h !m privately put into type1 = ! conv5i5ce ( 8 own fur!r "w ^u !m1 & = ! read+ ( two or ?ree intimate fri5ds4 ,^? into ^: c>e 8 "w has n[ come h tri$1 ) ! help ( 8 p5cill$ notes1 to br+ ^! f\r pap]s z ne>ly z !y c into ! =m :i* !y believe he w\ld h _h !m take4 ,b x has seem$ bett] to leave unalt]$ a s5t5ce "h & !re to :i* he might h giv5 a m p]fect %ape1 r ?an to run ! risk ( sw]v+ f ! ?\ght :i* 0 9 8 m9d4 ,x is possible t ! ,dean w\ld h made consid]able *anges 9 ! preface :i* is "h pr9t$2 = only t :i* seems ! fir/ draft ( x has be5 f\nd4 ,b ev5 ?us x s]ves to %[ 8 wi% & purpose = ! "w he _h 9 h&2 & x has !re=e be5 ?\ght be/ to publi% x4 ,leave has be5 obta9$ to add "h "s fragm5ts f a lett] :i*1 ?ree ye>s ago1 he wrote to ,"l ,acton ab\t ^! pap]s3 ,if ,i ev] publi% !m1 ,i mu/ say di/9ctly :at ,i want to d1 :i* is1 n to pret5d to write a hi/ory ( ! movem5t1 or to acc\nt = x or adequately to judge x & put x 9 its due place 9 relation to ! religi\s & philosophical hi/ory ( ! "t1 b simply to pres]ve a contempor>y memorial ( :at seems to me to h be5 a true & noble ef=t :i* pass$ be=e my eyes1 a %ort sc5e ( religi\s e>ne/ness & aspiration1 ) all t 0 9 x ( self-devotion1 affectionat5ess1 & high & ref9$ & v>i$ "*1 display$ "u circum/ances :i* are sc>cely intelligible to m5 ( ! pres5t "t2 s enorm\s h be5 ! *anges 9 :at 0 assum$ & act$ ^u1 & ?\ght practicable & reasonable1 'fifty ye>s s9ce4' ,= _! "t & opportunities1 ! m5 ( ! movem5t1 ) all _! imp]fect equipm5t & _! mi/akes1 /ill seem to me ! salt ( _! g5]ation4444 ,i wi% to leave beh9d me a record t "o :o liv$ ) !m1 & liv$ long beyond mo/ ( !m1 believ$ 9 ! reality ( _! goodness & height ( "*1 & /ill looks back ) deepe/ rev]5ce to ^? =gott5 m5 z ! companions to ^: tea*+ & example he owes an inf9ite debt1 & n he only1 b religi\s society 9 ,engl& ( all k9ds4 ,janu>y #ca/1 #ahia4 ,,preface ,! foll[+ pages relate to t /age 9 ! ,*ur* revival ( ?is c5tury :i* is famili>ly kn[n z ! ,ox=d ,movem5t1 or1 to use its nickname1 ! ,tract>ian ,movem5t4 ,v>i\s side influ5ces & conditions affect$ x at its beg9n+ & 9 its c\rse2 b ! impell+ & gov]n+ =ce 01 ?r\gh\t ! ye>s ) :i* ^! pages are conc]n$1 at ,ox=d4 ,x 0 naturally & ju/ly associat$ ) ,ox=d1 f :i* x receiv$ "s ( its mo/ m>k$ *>act]i/ics4 ,ox=d m5 />t$ x & guid$ x4 ,at ,ox=d 7 rais$ its fir/ hopes1 & ,ox=d 0 ! sc5e ( its fir/ successes4 ,at ,ox=d 7 its deep disappo9tm5ts1 & its app>5tly fatal defeat4 ,& x won & lo/1 z a *ampion ( ,engli% !ology & religion1 a man ( g5ius1 ^: "n is among ! illu/ri\s names ( 8 age1 a "n :i* w always be connect$ ) mod]n ,ox=d1 & is likely to be long rememb]$ :]ev] ! ,engli% language is /udi$4 ,we are sometimes told t en\gh has be5 writt5 ab\t ! ,ox=d ,movem5t1 & t ! _w is r tir$ ( ! subject4 ,a good deal has c]ta9ly be5 bo? said & writt5 ab\t x1 & m is probably /ill to come2 & x is true t o!r int]e/s1 m imm$iate or m attractive1 h ?r[n into ! backgr\nd :at is sev]$ f u by ! int]val ( half a c5tury4 ,/ill t movem5t _h a good deal to d ) :at is go+ on 9 ev]yday life among u n[2 & feel+s bo? ( ho/ility to x1 & ( sympa?y ) x1 are /ill lively & ke5 among ^? to :om religion is a s]i\s subject1 & ev5 among "s :o are neutral 9 ! que/ions :i* x rais$1 b :o f9d 9 x a /udy ( ?\ght & "*4 ,i myself d\bt :e!r ! int]e/ ( x is s exhau/$ z is sometimes assum$4 ,if x is1 ^! pages w soon f9d _! appropriate re/+-place4 ,b ,i v5ture to pres5t !m1 because1 ?\gh a good _m judgm5ts ^u ! movem5t h be5 put =?1 !y h come mo/ly f ^? :o h be5 m or less av[$ly oppos$ to x4#a ,! m5 ( mo/ acc\nt among ^? :o 7 attract$ by x & repres5t$ x h1 ) "o illu/ri\s exception1 pass$ away4 ,a survivor ( ! g5]ation :i* x /irr$ s deeply may n h mu* t is new to tell ab\t x4 ,he may n be able to affect mu* ! judgm5t :i* w f9ally be accept$ ab\t x4 ,b ! fact is n unimportant1 t a numb] ( able & e>ne/ m51 m5 :o bo? intellectually & morally w\ld h be5 c\nt$ at ! mom5t z "p ( ! promise ( ! com+ "t1 7 fasc9at$ & absorb$ by x4 ,x turn$ & gov]n$ _! lives1 lift+ !m out ( cu/om & conv5tion to ef=ts aft] some?+ high]1 some?+ wor?i] ( :at !y 74 ,x seem$ wor? :ile to exhibit ! c\rse ( ! movem5t z x look$ to ^! m5--z x seem$ to !m view$ f ! inside4 ,my excuse = add+ to s mu* t has be5 already writt5 is1 t ,i 0 famili> ) _m ( ! *ief actors 9 ! movem5t4 ,& ,i d n l t ! remembrance ( fri5ds & associates1 m5 ( s+ul> purity ( life & purpose1 :o rais$ ! tone ( liv+ r\nd !m1 & by _! example1 if n by _! ideas1 recall$ bo? ,ox=d & ! ,*ur* to a tru] s5se ( _! responsibilities1 %\ld1 because no "o w\ld take ! tr\ble to put ?+s on record1 pass away l a dream4 ,! foll[+ pages 71 = ! mo/ "p1 writt51 & put into pr9t$ %ape1 9 #ahhd & #ahhe4 ,s9ce !y 7 writt51 books h appe>$1 "s ( !m important ones1 go+ ov] mo/ ( ! same gr\nd2 :ile yet m volumes may be expect$4 ,we h _h +5i\s !ories ( ! g5esis ( ! movem5t1 & ! filiation ( its ideas4 ,attempts h be5 made to alt] ! proportions ( ! sc5e & ( ! sev]al p>ts play$ ^u x1 & to r$uce ! common e/imate ( ! weight & influ5ce ( "s ( ! mo/ prom95t p]sonages4 ,! po9t ( view ( ^? :o h ?us writt5 is n m9e1 & !y tell _! /ory 7) a full "r s to d7 z ,i tell m9e4 ,b ,i d n purpose to comp>e & adju/ our respective acc\nts--to attack !irs1 or to def5d my own4 ,i h n gone ?r\gh _! books to f9d /atem5ts to except to1 or to qualify4 ,! task w\ld be a tiresome & unpr(itable "o4 ,i und]/& _! po9t ( view1 ?\gh ,i d n accept x4 ,i d n d\bt _! good fai?1 & ,i hope t !y w all[ m9e4 ,,footnotes3 #a ,x is h>dly necess>y to say t ^! & ! foll[+ words 7 writt5 be=e ,dr4 ,newman's dea?1 & ! publication ( 8 lett]s4 ,,cont5ts ,,*apt] ,i ,,! ,,*ur* ,,9 ,,! ,,re=m ,,days ,,*apt] ,,ii ,,! ,,beg9n+ ,,( ,,! ,,movem5t--,,john ,,keble ,,*apt] ,,iii ,,ri*>d ,,hurrell ,,fr\de ,,*apt] ,,iv ,,mr4 ,,newman',s ,,e>ly ,,fri5ds--,,isaac ,,williams ,,*apt] ,v ,,*>les ,,m>riott ,,*apt] ,,vi ,,! ,,ox=d ,,tracts ,,*apt] ,,vii ,,! ,,tract>ians ,,*apt] ,,viii ,,subscription ,,at ,,matriculation ,,& ,,admission ,,( ,,diss5t]s ,,*apt] ,,ix ,,dr4 ,,hampd5 ,,*apt] ,x ,,gr[? ,,( ,,! ,,movem5t1 #ahce-ahdj ,,*apt] ,,xi ,,! ,,roman ,,"q ,,*apt] ,,xii ,,*anges ,,*apt] ,,xiii ,,! ,,au?orities ,,& ,,! ,,movem5t ,,*apt] ,,xiv ,,no4 #ij ,,*apt] ,,xv ,,aft] ,,no4 #ij ,,*apt] ,,xvi ,,! ,,?ree ,,defeats3 ,,isaac ,,williams1 ,,macmull51 ,,pusey ,,*apt] ,,xvii ,w4,g4 ,,w>d ,,*apt] ,,xviii ,,! ,,ideal ,,( ,a ,,*ri/ian ,,*ur* ,,*apt] ,,xix ,,! ,,cata/rophe ,,! ,,ox=d ,,movem5t ,,*apt] ,i ,,! ,,*ur* ,,9 ,,! ,,re=m ,,days ,:at is call$ ! ,ox=d or ,tract>ian movem5t began1 )\t d\bt1 9 a vigor\s ef=t = ! imm$iate def5ce ( ! ,*ur* aga9/ s]i\s dang]s1 aris+ f ! viol5t & ?reat5+ temp] ( ! days ( ! ,re=m ,bill4 ,x 0 "o ( sev]al & widely diff]+ ef=ts4 ,view$ sup]ficially x _h its orig9 9 ! accid5t ( an urg5t necessity4#b ,! ,*ur* 0 really at ! mom5t imp]ill$ amid ! crude revolution>y projects ( ! ,re=m epo*2#c & some?+ bold] & m effective ?an ! ord9>y apologies = ! ,*ur* 0 ! call ( ! h\r4 ,! (ficial lead]s ( ! ,*ur* 7 almo/ /unn$ & bewild]$ by ! fi]ce outbreak ( popul> ho/ility4 ,! answ]s put =? on its behalf to ! clam\r = ext5sive & ev5 de/ructive *ange 7 ! "w ( m5 surpris$ 9 a mom5t ( security4 ,!y sc>cely recognis$ ! diff]5ce betwe5 :at 0 indef5sible & :at mu/ be f\ght = to ! dea?2 !y mi/ook subord9ate or unimportant po9ts = ! key ( _! position3 9 _! compromises or 9 _! resi/ance !y want$ ! guidance ( cle> & adequate pr9ciples1 & !y 7 vacillat+ & ineffective4 ,b /rong] & f>-see+ m9ds p]ceiv$ ! ne$ ( a broad & intelligible basis on :i* to ma9ta9 ! cause ( ! ,*ur*4 ,= ! air 0 full ( new ideas2 ! temp] ( ! "t 0 bold & ent]pris+4 ,x 0 felt by m5 :o look$ =w>d1 t to hold _! own !y mu/ h some?+ m to %[ ?an cu/om or alleg$ exp$i5cy--!y mu/ s\nd ! dep?s ( _! own convictions1 & n be afraid to ass]t ! claims ( ^! convictions on m5's reason & imag9ation z well z on _! associations & feel+s4 ,! same dang]s & necessities act$ diff]5tly on diff]5t m9ds2 b among ^? :o 7 awak5$ by !m to ! pres5ce ( a great crisis 7 ! fir/ mov]s 9 :at came to be kn[n z ! ,tract>ian movem5t4 ,! /ir ar\nd !m1 ! p]ils :i* seem$ to ?reat51 7 a call to !m to exam9e afre% ! mean+ ( _! famili> words & pr(essions4 ,= ! ,*ur*1 z x _h be5 9 ! quiet days ( ! eighte5? c5tury1 0 sc>cely adapt$ to ! ne$s ( m /irr+ times4 ,! idea ( cl]ical life _h c]ta9ly sunk1 bo? 9 fact & 9 ! popul> e/imate ( x4 ,! disproportion betwe5 ! purposes = :i* ! ,*ur* ) its m9i/ry 0 f\nd$ & ! actual tone ( feel+ among ^? responsible = its s]vice _h become too great4 ,m5 7 afraid ( pr9ciples2 ! "o ?+ !y mo/ %rank f 0 ! suspicion ( en?usiasm4 ,bi%op ,lav+ton wrote a book to hold up to scorn ! en?usiasm ( ,me?odi/s & ,papi/s2 & :at w\ld h seem$ reasonable & natural 9 matt]s ( religion & wor%ip 9 ! age ( ,cranm]1 9 ! age ( ,hook]1 9 ! age ( ,&rewes1 or 9 ! age ( ,k51 seem$ extravagant 9 ! age :i* reflect$ ! _s ( ,tillotson & ,seck]1 & ev5 ,porteus4 ,! typical cl]gyman 9 ,engli% pictures ( ! mann]s ( ! day1 9 ! ,vic> ( ,wakefield1 9 ,miss ,au/5's novels1 9 ,crabbe's ,p>i% ,regi/]1 is repres5t$1 (t5 q unsuspici\sly1 z a k9dly & respectable p]son1 b c]ta9ly n alive to ! greatness ( 8 call+4 ,he 0 (t5 mu*1 v mu*1 to ! society r\nd him4 ,:5 communication 0 s difficult & infrequ5t1 he fill$ a place 9 ! c\ntry life ( ,engl& :i* no "o else c\ld fill4 ,he 0 (t5 ! patri>* ( 8 p>i%1 its rul]1 its doctor1 its lawy]1 its magi/rate1 z well z its tea*]1 be=e :om vice trembl$ & rebellion d>$ n %[ itself4 ,! idea ( ! prie/ 0 n q =gott52 b !re 0 mu*--mu* ev5 ( :at 0 good & useful--to obscure x4 ,! beauty ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* 9 ?is "t 0 its family life ( purity & simplicity2 its blot 0 quiet worldl9ess4 ,x has sometimes be5 ! fa%ion 9 lat] days ( /rife & disquiet to regret t unpret5d+ e/imate ( cl]ical duty & ^? easy-go+ days2 z x has sometimes be5 ! fa%ion to regret ! pomp & dignity ) :i* well-born or s*ol>ly bi%ops1 furni%$ ) ample leisure & spl5did rev5ues1 presid$ 9 unapproa*able /ate ov] _! cl]gy & held _! own among ! great c\nty families4 ,mo/ ?+s h a side = :i* some?+ c be said2 & we may tru?fully & ?ankfully recall t among ! cl]gy ( ^? days !re 7 n a few b _m in/ances1 n only ( g5tle mann]s1 & w>m b5evol5ce1 & cultivat$ intellig5ce1 b ( simple piety & holy life4#d ,b ! =tunes ( ! ,*ur* are n safe 9 ! h&s ( a cl]gy1 ( :i* a great "p take _! obligations easily4 ,x 0 slumb]+ & sleep+ :5 ! visitation ( days ( *ange & tr\ble came ^u x4 ,aga9/ ?is /ate ( ?+s ! ,ox=d movem5t 0 a det]m9$ revolt2 b1 z has be5 said1 x 0 n ! only "o1 nor ! fir/4 ,a pr(\nd discont5t at ! /ate ( religion 9 ,engl& _h tak5 possession ( _m p[]ful & s]i\s m9ds 9 ! g5]ation :i* 0 ris+ into manhood at ! close ( ! fir/ qu>t] ( ! c5tury2 & o!rs besides ! lead]s ( ! movem5t 7 feel+ _! way to firm] gr\nd4 ,o!r writ]s ( v diff]5t pr9ciples1 & ) diff]5t objects1 _h become alive1 among o!r ?+s1 to ! importance ( true ideas ab\t ! ,*ur*1 impati5t at ! ignorance & %all[ness ( ! curr5t views ( x1 & al>m$ at ! dang]s :i* m5ac$ x4 ,two ,ox=d tea*]s :o comm&$ mu* att5tion by _! =ce & boldness--,dr4 ,:ately & ,dr4 ,arnold--_h develop$ _! !ories ab\t ! nature1 con/itution1 & functions ( ! ,*ur*4 ,!y 7 dissatisfi$ ) ! g5]al /agnation ( religi\s op9ion1 on ?is z on o!r subjects4 ,!y agre$ 9 res5t+ ! un9tellig5t %ortsight$ness :i* relegat$ su* a matt] to a ?ird or f\r? rank 9 ! scale ( religi\s tea*+4 ,!y agre$ also 9 seiz+ ! spiritual aspect ( ! ,*ur*1 & 9 rais+ ! idea ( x above ! level ( ! poor & worldly conceptions on ! assumption ( :i* que/ions relat+ to x 7 popul>ly discuss$4 ,b 9 _! fundam5tal pr9ciples !y 7 f> ap>t4 ,i assume1 on ! au?ority ( ,c>d9al ,newman1 :at 0 widely believ$ 9 ,ox=d1 & nev] app>5tly d5i$1 t ! volume entitl$ ,lett]s ( an ,episcopalian1#e #ahbf1 01 9 "s s5se at lea/1 ! "w ( ,dr4 ,:ately4 ,9 x is sket*$ =? ! conception ( an organis$ body1 introduc$ into ! _w by ,*ri/ ,himself1 end[$ ) def9ite spiritual p[]s & ) no o!r1 &1 :e!r connect$ ) ! ,/ate or n1 hav+ an indep5d5t exi/5ce & inali5able claims1 ) its own objects & laws1 ) its own moral /&>d & _s & "*4 ,f ?is book ,c>d9al ,newman tells u t he le>nt 8 !ory ( ! ,*ur*1 ?\gh x 01 aft] all1 b ! !ory receiv$ f ! fir/ appe>ance ( ,*ri/ian hi/ory2 & he records also ! deep impression :i* x made on o!rs4 ,dr4 ,arnold's view 0 a mu* simpl] "o4 ,he divid$ ! _w into ,*ri/ians & non-,*ri/ians3 ,*ri/ians 7 all :o pr(ess$ to believe 9 ,*ri/ z a ,div9e ,p]son & to wor%ip ,him1#f & ! bro!rhood1 ! ,societas ( ,*ri/ians1 0 all t 0 meant by ! ,*ur* 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t4 ,x matt]$1 ( c\rse1 to ! consci5ce ( ea* ,*ri/ian :at he _h made up 8 m9d to believe1 b to no "o else4 ,*ur* organisation 01 accord+ to circum/ances1 p>tly inevitable or exp$i5t1 p>tly mis*iev\s1 b 9 no case ( div9e au?ority4 ,tea*+1 m9i/]+ ! ^w1 0 a ?+ ( div9e appo9tm5t1 b n s ! mode ( ex]cis+ x1 ei!r z to p]sons1 =ms1 or me?ods4 ,sacram5ts !re 71 signs & pl$ges ( div9e love & help1 9 e action ( life1 9 e sight ( nature1 & em95tly two mo/ t\*+ ones1 recomm5d$ to ,*ri/ians by ! ,r$eem] ,himself2 b except z a matt] ( m]e ord]1 "o man might deal ) ^! z lawfully z ano!r4 ,*ur* hi/ory !re 01 fruitful 9 int]e/1 in/ruction1 & w>n+2 = x 0 ! record ( ! long /ruggle ( ! true idea ( ! ,*ur* aga9/ ! false1 & ( ! fatal disappe>ance ( ! true be=e ! =ces ( bl9dness & wick$ness4#g ,dr4 ,arnold's 0 a passionate attempt to place ! true idea 9 ! light4 ,( ! difficulties ( 8 !ory he made light acc\nt4 ,!re 0 ! vivid c5tral tru? :i* gl[$ ?r\gh 8 s\l & quick5$ all 8 ?\ghts4 ,he became its *ampion & militant apo/le4 ,^! doctr9es1 comb9$ ) 8 /rong political lib]alism1 made ! ,midl&s hot = ,dr4 ,arnold4 ,b he lik$ ! fight+1 z he ?\ght1 aga9/ ! n>r[ & fright5$ or?odoxy r\nd him4 ,& he 0 9 ! ?ick ( ?is fight+ :5 ano!r set ( ideas ab\t ! ,*ur*--! ideas on :i* alone x seem$ to a numb] ( e>ne/ & anxi\s m9ds t ! cause ( ! ,*ur* c\ld be ma9ta9$--! ideas :i* 7 ! beg9n+ ( ! ,ox=d movem5t1 cross$ 8 pa?4 ,x 0 ! old or?odox tradition ( ! ,*ur*1 ) fre% life put into x1 :i* he flatt]$ himself t he _h s triumphantly demoli%$4 ,?is intrusion ( a despis$ rival to 8 own tea*+ ab\t ! ,*ur*--tea*+ 9 :i* he believ$ ) deep & f]v5t conviction--pr(\ndly irritat$ him2 all ! m t x came f m5 :o _h be5 among 8 fri5ds1 & :o1 he ?\ght1 %\ld h kn[n bett]4#h ,b nei!r ,dr4 ,:ately's nor ,dr4 ,arnold's attempts to put ! old subject ( ! ,*ur* 9 a new light ga9$ mu* hold on ! public m9d4 ,"o 0 too ab/ract2 ! o!r too unhi/orical & revolution>y4 ,bo? 9 ,ox=d & 9 ! c\ntry 7 m5 ^: he>ts burn$ )9 !m = some?+ less speculative & vague1 some?+ m rev]5t & less individual1 m 9 sympa?y ) ! inh]it$ _s ( ! ,*ur*4 ,x did n ne$ mu* se>*+ to f9d 9 ! facts & hi/ory ( ! ,*ur* ample evid5ce ( pr9ciples di/9ct & inspir+1 :i*1 h[ev] long lat5t1 or ov]laid by sup]ficial accretions1 7 z well fitt$ z !y ev] 7 to animate its def5d]s 9 ! /ruggle ) ! unfri5dly op9ion ( ! day4 ,!y c\ld n op5 _! ,pray]-,books1 & ?9k ( :at !y read !re1 )\t see+ t on ! face ( x ! ,*ur* claim$ to be some?+ v diff]5t f :at x 0 assum$ to be 9 ! curr5t controv]sies ( ! "t1 v diff]5t f a m]e in/itution ( ! ,/ate1 f a vague collection ( ,*ri/ian pr(essions f "o =m or d5om9ation ( religion among _m1 di/+ui%$ by l>g] privileges & l>g] rev5ues4 ,!y c\ld n help see+ t x claim$ an orig9 n %ort ( ! ,apo/les ( ,*ri/1 & took = grant$ t x 0 to speak & tea* ) _! au?ority & t ( _! ,ma/]4 ,^! 7 !ological commonplaces2 b n[1 ! pressure ( ev5ts & ( compet+ ideas made !m to be felt z real & mom5t\s tru?s4 ,amid ! confusions & inconsi/5cies ( ! semi-political controv]sy on ,*ur* re=m1 & on ! defects & rights ( ! ,*ur*1 :i* 0 go+ on 9 ,p>liam5t1 9 ! press1 & 9 pamphlets1 ! deep] ?\ghts ( ^? :o 7 int]e/$ 9 its =tunes 7 turn$ to :at 0 intr9sic & *>act]i/ic 9 its con/itution3 & :ile ^! ?\ghts 9 "s in/ances only issu$ 9 !ory & argum5t1 9 o!rs !y l$ to practical resolves to act ^u !m & en=ce !m4 ,at ! end ( ! fir/ qu>t] ( ! c5tury1 say ab\t #ahbe-cj1 two *>act]i/ic =ms ( ,*ur* ( ,engl& ,*ri/ianity 7 popul>ly recognis$4 ,"o inh]it$ ! traditions ( a le>n$ & sob] ,anglicanism1 claim+ z ! au?orities = its !ology ! great l9e ( ,engli% div9es f ,hook] to ,wat]l&1 f9d+ its patt]ns ( devotion 9 ,bi%op ,wilson1 ,bi%op ,horne1 & ! ,:ole ,duty ( ,man1 b n =getful ( ,&rewes1 ,j]emy ,taylor1 & ,k51--prea*+1 )\t passion or excitem5t1 s*ol>like1 c>eful1 wise1 (t5 vigor\sly reason$ disc\rses on ! capital po9ts ( fai? & morals1 & exhibit+ 9 its adh]5ts1 :o 7 _m & important1 all ! v>ieties ( a great & f>-desc5d$ s*ool1 :i* claim$ = itself rightful possession ( ! gr\nd :i* x held4 ,!re 0 no?+ effem9ate ab\t x1 z !re 0 no?+ fanatical2 !re 0 no?+ extreme or fooli% ab\t x2 x 0 a manly s*ool1 di/ru/ful ( high-wr\ght feel+s & pr(essions1 cultivat+ self-comm& & %y ( display1 & sett+ up z its m>k1 9 contra/ to :at seem$ to x s5tim5tal weakness1 a reasonable & s]i\s idea ( duty4 ,! div9ity :i* x prop\nd$1 ?\gh x re/$ on le>n+1 0 r t ( /rong common s5se ?an ( ! s*ools ( erudition4 ,its bett] memb]s 7 highly cultivat$1 b5evol5t m51 intol]ant ( irregul>ities bo? ( doctr9e & life1 ^: lives 7 gov]n$ by an uno/5tati\s b solid & unfalt]+ piety1 ready to bur/ =? on occasion into f]vid devotion4 ,its worse memb]s 7 jobb]s & hunt]s aft] pref]m5t1 plurali/s :o built =tunes & end[$ families out ( ! ,*ur*1 or c\ntry g5tlem5 9 ord]s1 :o rode to h\nds & %ot & danc$ & f>m$1 & (t5 did worse ?+s4 ,its av]age 0 :at naturally 9 ,engl& w\ld be ! av]age1 9 a /ate ( ?+s 9 :i* great religi\s in/itutions h be5 = a long "t settl$ & unmole/$--k9dly1 helpful1 respectable1 sociable p]sons ( good s5se & "*1 work]s r 9 a fa%ion ( r\t9e :i* no "o ?\ght ( break+1 sometimes keep+ up _! ,univ]sity le>n+1 & apt to employ x 9 odd & n v pr(itable inquiries2 apt1 too1 to value !mselves on _! *e]fulness & quick wit2 b (t5 dull & dogmatic & qu>relsome1 (t5 insuff]ably pomp\s4 ,! cu/om ( daily s]vice & ev5 ( fa/+ 0 kept up m widely ?an is commonly suppos$4 ,! ,eu*>i/1 ?\gh sp>+ly adm9i/]$1 & ?\gh x _h be5 pr(an$ by ! op]ation ( ! ,te/ ,acts1 0 approa*$ by religi\s p ) deep rev]5ce4 ,b besides ! bett]1 & ! worse1 & ! av]age memb]s ( ?is1 :i* call$ itself ! ,*ur* p>ty1 !re /ood out a numb] ( m5 ( active & orig9al m9ds1 :o1 />t+ f ! traditions ( ! p>ty1 7 9 advance ( x 9 ?\ght & k1 or 9 ! desire to c>ry pr9ciples into action4 ,at ! ,univ]sities le>n+ 0 /ill repres5t$ by di/+ui%$ names4 ,at ,ox=d1 ,dr4 ,r\? 0 /ill liv+ & at "w1 & ,van ,mild]t 0 n =gott54 ,bi%op ,lloyd1 if he _h liv$1 w\ld h play$ a consid]able "p2 & a "y man ( va/ indu/ry & great ,ori5tal le>n+1 ,mr4 ,pusey1 0 com+ on ! sc5e4 ,davison1 9 an age :i* _h gone mad ab\t ! /udy ( prophecy1 _h taught a m intellig5t & sob] way ( reg>d+ x2 & ,mr4 ,john ,mill]'s ,bampton ,lectures1 n[ probably only rememb]$ by a /rik+ s5t5ce1 quot$ 9 a note to ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>1#i _h impress$ 8 read]s ) a deep] s5se ( ! uses ( ,scripture4 ,cambridge1 besides s*ol>s l ,bi%op ,kaye1 & accompli%$ writ]s l ,mr4 ,le ,bas & ,mr4 ,lyall1 c\ld boa/ ( ,mr4 ,hugh ,james ,rose1 ! mo/ em95t p]son ( 8 g5]ation z a div9e4 ,b ! influ5ce ( ?is le>n$ !ology 0 at ! "t n equal to its value4 ,s\nd requires atmosph]e2 & !re 0 z yet no atmosph]e 9 ! public m9d 9 :i* ! voice ( ?is !ology c\ld be he>d4 ,! p]son :o fir/ gave body & =ce to ,*ur* !ology1 n to be mi/ak5 or ignor$1 0 ,dr4 ,hook4 ,8 massive & ?or\gh ,*ur*man%ip 0 ! indep5d5t gr[? ( 8 own ?\ghts & read+4 ,resolute1 ?r\gh good report & evil report1 r\gh b v g5]\s1 /]n bo? aga9/ ,pop]y & ,puritanism1 he _h become a p[] 9 ! ,midl&s & ! ,nor?1 & fir/ ,cov5try1 !n ,le$s1 7 ! c5tres ( a new influ5ce4 ,he 0 ! apo/le ( ! ,*ur* to ! great middle class4 ,^! 7 ! or?odox ,*ur*m51 :om _! rivals1 & n _! rivals only1#aj d5\nc$ z dry1 unspiritual1 =mal1 unevangelical1 self-righte\s2 tea*]s ( m]e morality at _! be/1 allies & s]vants ( ! _w at _! wor/4 ,9 ! p>ty :i* at ?is "t _h come to be look$ ^u popul>ly z be/ entitl$ to be ! religi\s p>ty1 :e!r !y 7 admir$ z ,evangelicals1 or abus$ z ,calv9i/s1 or laugh$ at z ! ,sa9ts1 7 inh]itors n ( ,anglican traditions1 b ( ^? :i* _h gr[n up among ! zeal\s cl]gym5 & laym5 :o _h sympa?is$ ) ! great ,me?odi/ revival1 & ^: !ology & life _h be5 pr(\ndly affect$ by x4 ,x 0 ! second or ?ird g5]ation ( ^? ^: religi\s ideas _h be5 =m$ & gov]n$ by ! influ5ce ( tea*]s l ,h]vey1 ,roma9e1 ,cecil1 ,v5n1 ,flet*]1 ,newton1 & ,?omas ,scott4 ,! fa!rs ( ! ,evangelical s*ool 7 m5 ( naturally /rong & vigor\s und]/&+s1 robu/ & rugg$1 & sometimes ecc5tric1 b q able to cope ) ! controv]siali/s1 l ,bi%op ,toml9e1 :o attack$ !m4 ,^! ,high ,*ur* controv]siali/s 7 too half-he>t$ & too %all[1 & und]/ood _! own pr9ciples too imp]fectly1 to be a mat* = antagoni/s :o 7 9 deadly e>ne/1 & put !m to %ame by _! zeal & c\rage4 ,b ,newton & ,roma9e & ! ,miln]s 7 too limit$ & n>r[ 9 _! compass ( ideas to f\nd a p[]ful !ology4 ,!y und\bt$ly (t5 quick5$ consci5ce4 ,b _! sy/em 0 a "o-sid$ & unnatural "o1 inde$ 9 ! h&s ( "s ( its exp\nd]s ?reat5+ morality & s\ndness ( "*4#aa ,x _h none ( ! sweep :i* c>ri$ ! ju/ification doctr9es ( ,lu!r1 or ! sy/ematic pr$e/9>ianism ( ,calv91 or ! plat=m ( discipl9e ( ,john ,knox & ! ,puritans4 ,x _h to deal ) a society :i* laid /ress on :at 0 reasonable1 or polite1 or +5i\s1 or g5teel1 & unconsci\sly x _h come to h respect to ^! requirem5ts4 ,! "o ?+ by :i* its prea*]s c>ri$ disciples ) !m 0 _! und\bt$ & s]i\s piety1 & _! brave1 ?\gh (t5 fanta/ic & inconsi/5t1 prote/ aga9/ ! _w4 ,!y won consid]ation & belief by ! mild p]secution :i* ?is prote/ br\ght on !m--by be+ proscrib$ z en?usia/s by com=table dignit>ies1 & mock$ z ,me?odi/s & ,sa9ts by wits & worldl+s4 ,b ! au/]e _s ( ,newton & ,?omas ,scott _h1 betwe5 #ahbj & #ahcj1 giv5 way a good deal to ! influ5ce ( increas+ popul>ity4 ,! pr(ession ( ,evangelical religion _h be5 made m ?an respectable by ! adhesion ( m5 ( position & weight4 ,prea*$ 9 ! pulpits ( fa%ionable *apels1 ?is religion prov$ to be no m exact+ ?an its ,high & ,dry rival4 ,x gave a g5tle /imulus to temp]s :i* requir$ to be excit$ by novelty4 ,x recomm5d$ itself by gifts ( fl[+ words or high-pit*$ rhetoric to ^? :o expect$ "s dem&s to be made on !m1 s t ^! dem&s 7 n too /rict4 ,yet ,evangelical religion _h n be5 unfruitful1 especially 9 public results4 ,x _h l$ ,h[>d & ,elizabe? ,fry to assail ! brutalities ( ! prisons4 ,x _h l$ ,cl>kson & ,wilb]=ce to ov]?r[ ! slave trade1 & ultimately slav]y itself4 ,x _h creat$ great ,mission>y ,societies4 ,x _h giv5 motive & impetus to c\ntless philan?ropic s*emes4 ,:at x fail$ 9 0 ! education & developm5t ( "*2 & ?is 0 ! result ( ! increas+ meagr5ess ( its writ+ & prea*+4 ,!re 7 /ill ,evangelical prea*]s ( =ce & eloqu5ce--,rob]t ,hall1 ,edw>d ,irv+1 ,*alm]s1 ,jay ( ,ba?--b !y 7 n ,*ur*m54 ,! circle ( !mes dwelt on by ?is s*ool 9 ! ,*ur* 0 a contract$ "o1 & no "o _h f\nd ! way ( enl>g+ x4 ,x %rank1 9 its fe> ( m]e moralis+1 9 its horror ( ! idea ( m]it or ( ! value ( good works1 f com+ into contact ) ! manifold realities ( ! _s ( man3 x nev] seem$ to get beyond ! fir/ beg9n+s ( ,*ri/ian tea*+1 ! call to rep5t1 ! assurance ( =giv5ess3 x _h no?+ to say to ! long & v>i$ process ( build+ up ! new life ( tru? & goodness3 x 0 n]v\sly afraid ( dep>t+ f ! consecrat$ phrases ( its s*ool1 & 9 ! p]petual it]ation ( !m x lo/ hold ( ! mean+ !y may once h _h4 ,x too (t5 f\nd its gu>antee = fai?fulness 9 jeal\s suspicions1 & 9 fi]ce bigotries1 & at l5g? x pres5t$ all ! *>act]i/ics ( an exhau/$ tea*+ & a sp5t en?usiasm4 ,claim+ to be exclusively spiritual1 f]v5t1 unworldly1 ! sole ann\nc] ( ! free grace ( ,god amid self-righte\sness & s91 x _h come1 9 fact1 to be on v easy t]ms ) ! _w4 ,yet x kept its hold on numb]s ( spiritually-m9d$ p]sons1 = 9 tru? !re seem$ to be no?+ bett] = ^? :o saw 9 ! affections ! ma9 field ( religion4 ,b ev5 ( ^! good m51 ! monoton\s language s\nd$ to all b !mselves inconceivably holl[ & we>isome2 & 9 ! h&s ( ! av]age tea*]s ( ! s*ool1 ! idea ( religion 0 becom+ poor & ?9 & unreal4 ,b besides ^! two great p>ties1 ea* ( !m claim+ to repres5t ! au!ntic & un*ang+ m9d ( ! ,*ur*1 !re 7 indep5d5t ?9k]s :o took _! place ) nei!r & criticis$ bo?4 ,paley _h /ill 8 disciples at ,cambridge1 or if n disciples1 yet repres5tatives ( 8 mascul9e b n v pr(\nd & rev]5t way ( ?9k+2 & a critical s*ool1 repres5t$ by names aft]w>ds fam\s1 ,connop ,?irlwall & ,julius ,h>e1 /rongly influ5c$ by ,g]man speculation1 bo? 9 !ology & hi/ory1 began to attract att5tion4 ,& at ,cambridge 0 gr[+1 sl[ly & out ( sight1 a m9d & an influ5ce :i* 7 to be at once ! c\nt]p>t & ! rival ( ! ,ox=d movem5t1 its ally = a %ort mom5t1 & !n its e>ne/ & (t5 bitt] enemy4 ,9 spite ( ! dom9ant tea*+ id5tifi$ ) ! "n ( ,mr4 ,simeon1 ,fr$]ic ,maurice1 ) ,john ,/]l+ & o!r memb]s ( ! ,apo/les' ,club1 0 feel+ = some?+ tru] & nobl] ?an ! conv5tionalities ( ! religi\s _w4#ab ,9 ,ox=d1 mo/ly 9 a diff]5t way1 m dry1 m dialectical1 &1 p]haps x may be said1 m sob]1 def9ite1 & ambiti\s ( cle>ness1 ! same _s 0 at "w4 ,!re 0 a c]ta9 drift t[>ds ,diss5t among ! w>m] spirits4 ,"u ! lead+ ( ,:ately1 que/ions 7 ask$ ab\t :at 0 suppos$ to be beyond dispute ) bo? ,*ur*m5 & ,evangelicals4 ,curr5t phrases1 ! keynotes ( _m a s]mon1 7 fe>lessly tak5 to pieces4 ,m5 7 *all5g$ to exam9e ! mean+ ( _! words4 ,!y 7 caution$ or ridicul$ z ! case might be1 on ! score ( confusion ( ?\ght & inaccuracy ( m9d2 !y 7 convict$ ( great logical s9s1 ignoratio el5*i1 or undi/ribut$ middle t]ms2 & bold !ories began to make _! appe>ance ab\t religi\s pr9ciples & tea*+1 :i* did n easily accommodate !mselves to popul> conceptions4 ,9 v diff]5t ways & degrees1 ,davison1 ,cople/on1 ,:ately1 ,hawk9s1 ,milman1 & n lea/1 a brilliant naturalis$ ,spani>d :o s[$ ! se$s ( d\bt ar\nd him1 ,blanco ,:ite1 _h brok5 ?r\gh a numb] ( accept$ op9ions1 & _h pres5t$ "s />tl+ ideas to m5 :o _h ?\ght t all religi\s que/ions lay betwe5 ! or?odoxy ( ,lambe? & ! or?odoxy ( ,clapham & ,isl+ton4 ,& ?us ! f\ndation 0 laid1 at lea/1 at ,ox=d ( :at 0 !n call$ ! ,lib]al ,s*ool ( ,!ology4 ,its !ories & p>adoxes1 !n commonly associat$ ) ! ,noetic "* ( "o college1 ,oriel1 7 ?\ght />tl+ & v5turesome :5 discuss$ 9 /eady-go+ common-rooms & c\ntry p>sonages2 b !y 7 /ill cauti\s & old-fa%ion$ comp>$ ) :at 0 to come aft] !m4 ,! di/ance is inde$ great betwe5 ^? e>ly di/urb]s ( lecture-rooms & ,univ]sity pulpits1 & _! successors4 ,:ile ?is 0 go+ on )9 ! ,*ur*1 !re 0 a great movem5t ( ?\ght go+ on 9 ! c\ntry4 ,x 0 ! "t :5 ,b5?am's utilit>ianism _h at l5g? made its way into prom95ce & importance4 ,x _h ga9$ a hold on a numb] ( p[]ful m9ds 9 society & political life4 ,x 0 ?reat5+ to become ! dom9ant & popul> philosophy4 ,x began1 9 "s ways b5eficially1 to affect & ev5 control legislation4 ,x made desp]ate attempts to take possession ( ! :ole prov9ce ( morals4 ,x =c$ ^? :o saw ?r\gh its mis*ief1 :o hat$ & fe>$ x1 to seek a reason1 & a solid & /rong "o1 = ! fai? :i* 0 9 !m z to ! reality ( consci5ce & ! my/]i\s di/9ction betwe5 "r & wrong4 ,& x ent]$ into a close alliance ) sci5ce1 :i* 0 beg9n+ to ass]t its claims1 s9ce !n ris5 s high1 to a new & undef9$ supremacy1 n only 9 ! g5]al conc]ns ( ! _w1 b specially 9 education4 ,x 0 ! day ( ,holl& ,h\se4 ,x 0 ! "t :5 a ,society ( :i* ,"l ,br\gham 0 ! s\l1 & :i* compris$ a great numb] ( important political & important sci5tific names1 0 def9itely =m$ = ! ,diffusion ( ,useful ,k4 ,_! lab\rs are h>dly rememb]$ n[ 9 ! great *anges = :i* !y pav$ ! way2 b ! ,society 0 ! means ( gett+ writt5 & ( publi%+ at a *eap rate a numb] ( orig9al & excell5t books on sci5ce1 biography1 & hi/ory4 ,x 0 ! "t ( ! ,libr>y ( ,useful ,k1 & its companion1 ! ,libr>y ( ,ent]ta9+ ,k2 ( ! ,p5ny ,magaz9e1 & its ,*ur* rival1 ! ,saturday ,magaz9e1 ( ! ,p5ny ,cyclopa$ia1 & ,l>dn]'s ,cab9et ,cyclopa$ia1 & ,murray's ,family ,libr>y3 popul> s]ies1 :i* conta9$ mu* ( ! "w ( ! able/ m5 ( ! day1 & :i*1 ?\gh = ! mo/ "p sup]s$$ n[1 7 full ( int]e/ !n4 ,ano!r creation ( ?is epo*1 & an unmi/akable indication ( its t5d5cies1 0 ! ,briti% ,association = ! ,advancem5t ( ,sci5ce1 :i* met = ! fir/ "t at ,ox=d 9 ,june #ahcb1 n )\t a good deal ( jeal\sy & misgiv+1 p>tly unreasonable1 p>tly n unf\nd$1 among m5 9 ^: he>ts ! cause & =tunes ( religion 7 supreme4 ,?us ! "t 0 ripe = great collisions ( pr9ciples & aims2 = ! decomposition ( elem5ts :i* _h be5 hi!rto unit$2 = sift+ !m out ( _! old comb9ations1 & regr\p+ !m accord+ to _! m natural aff9ities4 ,x 0 a "t = ! =mation & developm5t ( unexpect$ novelties 9 tea*+ & practical ef=t4 ,!re 0 a great hi/oric ,*ur* p>ty1 imp]fectly consci\s ( its position & responsibilities2#ac !re 0 an active b decl9+ pieti/ic s*ool1 re/+ on a feeble intellectual basis & n>r[ & meagre int]pretations ( ,scripture1 & /rong only 9 its circle ( philan?ropic "w2 !re 01 confront+ bo?1 a ris+ body ( inquisitive &1 9 "s ways1 m5ac+ ?\ght4 ,to m5 deeply int]e/$ 9 religion1 ! gr\nd seem$ confus$ & trea*]\s4 ,!re 0 room1 & !re 0 a call1 = new ef=t2 b to f9d ! res\rces = x1 x seem$ necess>y to cut d[n deep bel[ ! level ( :at ev5 good m5 accept$ z ! adequate expression ( ,*ri/ianity1 & its fit application to ! conditions ( ! n9ete5? c5tury4 ,x came to pass t !re 7 m5 :o _h ! he>t to make ?is attempt4 ,z 0 said at />t+1 ! actual movem5t began 9 ! conviction t a great & sudd5 dang] to ! ,*ur* 0 at h&1 & t an unusual ef=t mu/ be made to meet x4 ,b if ! occasion 0 9 a measure accid5tal1 !re 0 no?+ haphaz>d or t5tative 9 ! l9e *os5 to enc\nt] ! dang]4 ,f ! fir/ x 0 delib]ately & di/9ctly tak54 ,! *oice ( x 0 ! result ( convictions :i* _h be5 =m+ be=e ! occasion came :i* call$ on !m4 ,! religi\s ideas :i* gov]n$ ! m9ds ( ^? :o l$ ! movem5t _h be5 trac$1 9 outl9e at lea/1 firmly & )\t falt]+4 ,! movem5t _h its spr+ 9 ! consci5ces & "* ( its lead]s4 ,to ^! m5 religion really meant ! mo/ awful & mo/ s]i\sly p]sonal ?+ on e>?4 ,x _h n only a !ological basis2 x _h /ill m deeply a moral "o4 ,:at t basis 0 is %[n 9 a v>iety ( indications ( e?ical temp] & habits1 be=e ! movem5t1 9 ^? :o aft]w>ds direct$ x4 ,! ,*ri/ian ,ye> 0 publi%$ 9 #ahbg1 & tells u di/9ctly by :at k9d ( /&>d ,mr4 ,keble m\ld$ 8 judgm5t & aims4 ,:at ,mr4 ,keble's influ5ce & tea*+ did1 9 tra9+ an apt pupil to deep & sev]e views ( tru? & duty1 is to be se5 9 ! records ( purpose & self-discipl9e1 (t5 s pa9ful1 b always s l(ty & s9c]e1 ( ,mr4 ,hurrell ,fr\de's j\rnal4 ,b ^! indications are mo/ =cibly giv5 9 ,mr4 ,newman's e>lie/ prea*+4 ,z tutor at ,oriel1 ,mr4 ,newman _h made :at ef=ts he c\ld1 sometimes di/urb+ to ! au?orities1 to raise ! /&>d ( conduct & feel+ among 8 pupils4 ,:5 he became a p>i% prie/1 8 prea*+ took a s+ul>ly practical & pla9-spok5 "*4 ,! fir/ s]mon ( ! s]ies1 a typical s]mon1 ,hol9ess necess>y = future ,bless$ness1 a s]mon :i* has made _m read]s grave :5 !y laid x d[n1 0 writt5 9 #ahbf1 be=e he came to ,/4 ,m>y's2 & z he began he cont9u$4 ,no s]mons1 except ^? :i* 8 great opposite1 ,dr4 ,arnold1 0 prea*+ at ,rugby1 _h appeal$ to consci5ce ) su* directness & =ce4 ,a passionate & su/a9$ e>ne/ness aft] a high moral rule1 s]i\sly realis$ 9 conduct1 is ! dom9ant "* ( ^! s]mons4 ,!y %[$ ! /rong reaction aga9/ slackness ( fibre 9 ! religi\s life2 aga9/ ! pov]ty1 s(tness2 re/lessness1 worldl9ess1 ! blunt$ & impair$ s5se ( tru?1 :i* reign$ ) little *eck 9 ! recognis$ fa%ions ( pr(ess+ ,*ri/ianity2 ! want ( dep? bo? ( ?\ght & feel+2 ! /range bl9dness to ! real /]nness1 nay ! au/]ity1 ( ! ,new ,te/am5t4 ,out ( ?is gr\nd ! movem5t grew4 ,ev5 m ?an a !ological re=m1 x 0 a prote/ aga9/ ! loose unreality ( ord9>y religi\s morality4 ,9 ! fir/ /age ( ! movem5t1 moral e>ne/ness & en?usiasm gave its impulse to !ological int]e/ & zeal4 ,,footnotes3 #b ,! suppression ( ! ,iri% bi%oprics4 ,palm]1 ,n>rative 7#ahhc71 pp4 #dd1 #aja4 ,maurice1 ,life1 i4 #ahj4 #c ,! ,*ur*1 z x n[ /&s1 no human p[] c save 7,arnold to ,tyl]1 ,june #ahcb4 ,life1 i4 #cbf74 ,no?+1 z x seems to me1 c save ! ,*ur* b an union ) ! ,diss5t]s2 n[ !y are leagu$ ) ! anti*ri/ian p>ty1 & no m]ely int]nal re=ms w satisfy !m 7,arnold to ,:ately1 ,janu>y #ahcc1 i4 #cdh74 ,he aft]w>ds ?\ght ?is exagg]at$ 7,life1 i4 #ccf74 ,! ,*ur* has be5 = "o hundr$ ye>s )\t any gov]nm5t1 & 9 su* a /ormy season x w n g on mu* long] )\t a rudd] 7,:ately to ,bp4 ,cople/on1 ,july #ahcb4 ,life1 i1 #afg74 ,if su* an arrangem5t ( ! ,executive ,gov]nm5t is complet$1 x w be a difficult1 b great & glori\s feat = y\r ,lord%ip's m9i/ry to pres]ve ! e/abli%m5t f utt] ov]?r[ 7,:ately to ,"l ,grey1 ,may #ahcb4 ,life1 i4 #aef74 ,x is rem>kable t ,dean ,/anley %\ld h be5 satisfi$ ) ascrib+ to ! movem5t an orig9 entirely political & %\ld h se5 a pro( ( ?is ?or\ghly political orig9 9 ,newman's obs]v+ ! date ( ,mr4 ,keble's s]mon ,national ,apo/asy z ! bir?day ( ! movem5t1 ,ed94 ,rev4 ,april #ahhj1 pp4 #cji1 #caj4 #d ,read]s ( ,wordswor? w rememb] ! acc\nt ( ,mr4 ,r4 ,walk] 7,notes to ! ,riv] ,duddon74 #e ,comp>e ,life ( ,:ately 7ed4 #ahff71 i4 #eb1 #fh4 #f ,arnold to ,w4 ,smi?1 ,life1 i4 #cef-ceh2 ii4 #cb4 #g ,life1 i4 #bbe sqq4 #h ,i am vex$ to f9d h[ mu* hopeless bigotry l+]s 9 m9ds1 7,arnold to ,:ately1 ,sept4 #ahcb4 ,life1 i4 #cca2 ii4 #c-g74 #i ,/4 ,b>?olomew's ,day #aj ,! m]e b>r5 or?odoxy :i*1 f all t ,i c he>1 is *>act]i/ic ( ,ox=d4 ,maurice 9 #ahbi 7,life1 i4 #ajc74 ,9 #ahcb he speaks ( 8 high endeav\rs to r\se ,ox=d f its le?>gy hav+ s signally fail$ 7i4 #adc74 #aa ,abbey & ,ov]ton1 ,engli% ,*ur* 9 ! ,eighte5? ,c5tury1 ii4 #ahj1 #bjd4 #ab ,v4 ,maurice1 ,life1 i4 #ajh-aaa2 ,tr5*'s ,lett]s2 ,c>lyle's ,/]l+4 #ac ,9 :at conc]ns ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*1 ! ,h\se ( ,commons seems to feel no o!r pr9ciple ?an t ( vulg> policy4 ,! old ,high ,*ur* race is worn out4 ,alex4 ,knox 7,june #ahaf71 i4 #ed4 ,,*apt] ,,ii ,,! ,,beg9n+ ,,( ,,! ,,movem5t--,,john ,,keble ,long be=e ! ,ox=d movem5t 0 ?\ght (1 or _h any def9ite %ape1 a numb] ( its *>act]i/ic pr9ciples & ideas _h tak5 /rong hold ( ! m9d ( a man ( great ability & great s]i\sness1 :o1 aft] a brilliant c>e] at ,ox=d z /ud5t & tutor1 _h ex*ang$ ! ,univ]sity = a humble c\ntry cure4 ,john ,keble1 by "s ye>s ! s5ior1 b ! college fri5d & intimate ( ,arnold1 0 ! son ( a ,gl\ce/]%ire c\ntry cl]gyman ( /rong "* & consid]able s*ol>%ip4 ,he taught & educat$ 8 two sons at home1 & !n s5t !m to ,ox=d1 :]e bo? ( !m made _! m>k1 & ! eld]1 ,john1 a m]e boy :5 he fir/ appe>$ at 8 college1 ,corpus1 c>ri$ (f almo/ ev]y?+ t ! ,univ]sity c\ld give 9 ! way ( di/9ction4 ,he won a d\ble fir/2 he won ! ,lat9 & ,engli% ,essays 9 ! same ye>2 & he won :at 0 ! /ill great] hon\r ( an ,oriel ,fell[%ip4 ,8 hon\rs 7 borne ) meekness & simplicity2 to 8 atta9m5ts he jo9$ a temp] ( s+ul> sweetness & mode/y1 capable at ! same "t1 :5 necess>y1 ( au/]e /r5g? & /rictness ( pr9ciple4 ,he _h become "o ( ! mo/ di/+ui%$ m5 9 ,ox=d1 :5 ab\t ! ye> #ahbc he felt himself b\nd to give himself m exclusively to ! "w ( a cl]gyman1 & left ,ox=d to be 8 fa!r's curate4 ,!re 0 no?+ v unusual 9 8 way ( life1 or s+ul> & %[y 9 8 "w z a cl]gyman2 he w5t 9 & out among ! poor1 he 0 n av]se to society1 he prea*$ pla91 unpret5d+1 e>ne/ s]mons2 he kept up 8 lit]>y int]e/s4 ,b he 0 a deeply conv9c$ ,*ur*man1 f9d+ 8 /&>d & patt]n ( doctr9e & devotion 9 ! sob] e>ne/ness & dignity ( ! ,pray] ,book1 & look+ ) great & intellig5t dislike at ! tea*+ & practical work+ ( ! m popul> sy/em :i*1 "u ! "n ( ,evangelical ,*ri/ianity1 0 aspir+ to dom9ate religi\s op9ion1 & :i*1 (t5 comb9+ "s ( ! mo/ que/ionable features ( ,me?odism & ,calv9ism1 d5\nc$ ) fi]ce intol]ance ev]y?+ t deviat$ f its =mulas & wat*words4 ,& z 8 loyalty to ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 0 pr(\nd & int5se1 all :o _h %>$ h] =tunes1 good or bad1 or :o pr(ess$ to s]ve h]1 _h a place 9 8 affections2 & any policy :i* ?reat5$ to injure or oppress h]1 & any pr9ciples :i* 7 ho/ile to h] influ5ce & tea*+1 r\s$ 8 indignation & resi/ance4 ,he 0 a /rong ,tory1 & by conviction & religi\s temp] a ?or\gh ,high ,*ur*man4 ,b !re 0 no?+ 9 him to =e%ad[ ! lead] 9 a bold & wide-rea*+ movem5t4 ,he 0 absolutely )\t ambition4 ,he hat$ %[ & mi/ru/$ excitem5t4 ,! ?\ght ( pref]m5t 0 /eadily put aside bo? f temp] & def9ite pr9ciple4 ,he _h no popul> aptitudes1 & 0 v suspici\s ( !m4 ,he _h no c>e = ! possession ( influ5ce2 he _h delib]ately *os5 ! fall5tis semita vitae1 & to be :at 8 fa!r _h be51 a fai?ful & cont5t$ c\ntry p>son1 0 all t he desir$4 ,b idl5ess 0 n 9 8 nature4 ,born a poet1 /eep$ 9 all t is noble/ & t5d]e/ & mo/ beautiful 9 ,greek & ,roman lit]ature1 ) ! ke5e/ sympa?y ) t new s*ool ( poetry :i*1 ) ,wordswor? z its repres5tative1 0 se>*+ out ! deep] relations betwe5 nature & ! human s\l1 he f\nd 9 poetical composition a v5t & relief = feel+s /irr$ by ! m>vels ( glory & ( awfulness1 & by ! sorr[s & bless+s1 amid :i* human life is pass$4 ,b 8 poetry 0 = a long "t only = himself & 8 intimate fri5ds2 8 indulg5ce 9 poetical composition 0 p>tly playful1 & x 0 n till aft] mu* hesitation on 8 own "p & also on !irs1 & ) a contemptu\s und]valu+ ( 8 "w1 :i* cont9u$ to ! end ( 8 life1 t ! anonym\s little book ( poems 0 publi%$ :i* has s9ce become famili> :]ev] ,engli% is read1 z ! ,*ri/ian ye>4 ,8 s]i\s int]e/s 7 public ones4 ,?\gh liv+ 9 ! %ade1 he foll[$ ) anxiety & increas+ disquiet ! *anges :i* w5t on s rapidly & s =midably1 dur+ ! end ( ! fir/ qu>t] ( ?is c5tury1 9 op9ion & 9 ! possession ( political p[]4 ,x became m & m pla9 t great *anges 7 at h&1 ?\gh n s pla9 :at !y w\ld be4 ,x seem$ likely t p[] w\ld come into ! h&s ( m5 & p>ties ho/ile to ! ,*ur* 9 _! pr9ciples1 & ready to use to its prejudice ! advantages :i* its position z an e/abli%m5t gave !m2 & ! anticipation grew 9 ,keble's m9d1 t 9 ! /ruggles :i* seem$ likely1 n only = ! legal rights b = ! fai? ( ! ,*ur*1 ! ,*ur* might h bo? to claim m1 & to suff] m1 at ! h&s ( ,gov]nm5t4 ,yet ?\gh ^! ?\ghts fill$ 8 m9d1 & /rong ?+s 7 said 9 ! int]c\rse ) fri5ds ab\t :at 0 go+ on ab\t !m1 no def9ite c\rse ( action _h be5 ev5 contemplat$ :5 ,keble w5t into ! c\ntry 9 #ahbc4 ,!re 0 no?+ to di/+ui% him f numb]s ( able cl]gym5 all ov] ,engl&1 :o 7 look+ on ) int]e/1 ) anxiety1 (t5 ) indignation1 at :at 0 go+ on4 ,mr4 ,keble _h n _m fri5ds & 0 no p>ty *ief4 ,he 0 a brilliant univ]sity s*ol> ov]lay+ ! pla91 unworldly c\ntry p>son2 an old-fa%ion$ ,engli% ,*ur*man1 ) great v5]ation = ! ,*ur* & its bi%ops1 & a great dislike ( ,rome1 ,diss5t1 & ,me?odism1 b ) a quick he>t2 ) a frank1 gay humility ( s\l1 ) great contempt ( appe>ances1 great enjoym5t ( nature1 great unselfi%ness1 /rict & sev]e pr9ciples ( morals & duty4 ,:at 0 x t turn$ him by degrees into s prom95t & s influ5tial a p]son8 ,x 0 ! result ( ! action ( 8 convictions & ideas1 & /ill m ( 8 "*1 on ! en]getic & fe>less m9d ( a pupil & disciple1 ,ri*>d ,hurrell ,fr\de4 ,fr\de 0 ,keble's pupil at ,oriel1 & :5 ,keble left ,oriel = 8 curacy at ! beg9n+ ( ! ,long ,vacation ( #ahbc1 he took ,fr\de ) him to read = 8 degree4 ,he took ) him ultimately two o!r pupils1 ,rob]t ,wilb]=ce & ,isaac ,williams ( ,tr9ity4 ,"o ( !m1 ,isaac ,williams1 has left "s rem9isc5ces ( ! "t1 & ( ! t]ms on :i* ! "y m5 7 ) _! tutor1 !n "o ( ! mo/ fam\s m5 at ,ox=d4 ,!y 7 on t]ms ( ! utmo/ fre$om4 ,ma/] is ! greate/ boy ( !m all1 0 ! judgm5t ( ! ru/ic :o 0 g>d5]1 groom1 & p>i% cl]k to ,mr4 ,keble4 ,fr\de's 0 a ke5 logical m9d1 n easily satisfi$1 contemptu\s ( compromises & evasions1 & dispos$ on occasion to be mis*iev\s & aggressive2 & ) ,keble1 z ) anybody else1 he 0 ready to dispute & try e =m ( dialectical exp]im5t4 ,b he 0 op5 to high] influ5ces ?an ^? ( logic1 & 9 ,keble he saw :at subdu$ & won him to b\ndless v5]ation & affection4 ,keble won ! love ( ! :ole little society2 b 9 ,fr\de he _h ga9$ a disciple :o 0 to be ! m\?piece & *ampion ( 8 ideas1 & :o 0 to react on himself & c>ry him =w>d to l>g] ent]prises & bold] resolutions ?an by himself he w\ld h ?\ght (4 ,fr\de took 9 f ,keble all he _h to communicate--pr9ciples1 convictions1 moral rules & /&>ds ( life1 hopes1 fe>s1 antipa?ies4 ,& 8 ke5ly-temp]$ intellect1 & 8 det]m9ation & high c\rage1 gave a po9t & an impulse ( _! own to ,keble's views & purposes4 ,z ?+s came to look d>k]1 & dang]s seem$ m s]i\s to ! ,*ur*1 its fai? or its rights1 ! int]*ange ( ?\ght betwe5 ma/] & disciple1 9 talk & 9 lett]1 po9t$ m & m to ! com+ necessity ( action2 & ,fr\de at lea/ _h no objections to ! bus9ess ( an agitator4 ,b all ?is 0 v gradual2 ?+s did n yet g beyond discussion2 ideas1 views1 argum5ts 7 exam9$ & comp>$2 & ,fr\de1 ) all 8 da%1 felt z ,keble felt1 t he _h mu* to le>n ab\t himself1 z well z ab\t books & ?+s4 ,9 8 respect = antiquity1 9 8 dislike ( ! novelties :i* 7 invad+ ,*ur* rules & s5tim5ts1 z well z its cre$s1 9 8 jeal\sy ( ! ,/ate1 z well z 9 8 s]i\sness ( self-discipl9e1 he accept$ ,keble's guidance & influ5ce m & m2 & f ,keble he _h m ?an "o lesson ( self-di/ru/1 m ?an "o w>n+ aga9/ ! temptations ( intellect4 ,fr\de told me _m ye>s aft]1 writes "o ( 8 fri5ds1 t ,keble once1 be=e p>t+ ) him1 seem$ to h some?+ on 8 m9d :i* he wi%$ to say1 b %rank f say+1 :ile wait+1 ,i ?9k1 = a coa*4 ,at la/ he said1 j be=e p>t+1 ',fr\de1 y ?\ght ,law's ,s]i\s ,call 0 a clev] book2 x seem$ to me z if y _h said ! ,day ( ,judgm5t w be a pretty sight4' ,?is spee*1 ,fr\de told me1 _h a great effect on 8 aft] life4#ad ,at ,ea/] #ahbf ,fr\de 0 elect$ ,fell[ ( ,oriel4 ,he came back to ,ox=d1 *>g$ ) ,keble's ?\ghts & feel+s1 & f 8 m eag] & impati5t temp]1 m on ! look-out = ways ( giv+ !m effect4 ,! next ye> he became tutor1 & he held ! tutor%ip till #ahcj4 ,b he f\nd at ,oriel a colleague1 a little 8 s5ior 9 age & /&+1 ( :om ,fr\de & 8 fri5ds z yet knew little except t he 0 a man ( great ability1 t he _h be5 a fav\rite ( ,:ately's1 & t 9 a loose & r\gh way he 0 c\nt$ among ! few ,lib]als & ,evangelicals 9 ,ox=d4 ,?is 0 ,mr4 ,newman4 ,keble _h be5 %y ( him1 & ,fr\de w\ld at fir/ judge him by ,keble's /&>d4 ,b ,newman 0 j at ?is "t mov+1 z he expresses x1 out ( ! %ad[ ( ,lib]alism4 ,liv+ n ap>t l ,keble1 b 9 ! same college1 & meet+ e day1 ,fr\de & ,newman c\ld n b be ei!r /rongly & p]man5tly repell$1 or /rongly attract$4 ,!y 7 attract$2 attract$ ) a =ce :i* at la/ unit$ !m 9 ! deepe/ & mo/ unres]v$ fri5d%ip4 ,( ! /eps ( ?is great *ange 9 ! m9d & =tunes ( ea* ( !m we h no record3 intimacies ( ?is k9d gr[ 9 college out ( unnotic$ & unrememb]$ talks1 agree+ or diff]+1 out ( unconsci\s disclosures ( temp] & purpose1 out ( walks & rides & quiet breakfa/s & common-room argum5ts1 out ( admirations & dislikes1 out ( lett]s & criticisms & que/ions2 & nobody c tell aft]w>ds h[ !y h come ab\t4 ,! *ange 0 gradual & delib]ate4 ,fr\de's fri5ds 9 ,gl\ce/]%ire1 ! ,keble family1 _h _! misgiv+s ab\t ,newman's suppos$ lib]alism2 !y did n mu* want to h to d ) him4 ,8 subtle & speculative temp] did n always squ>e ) ,fr\de's !ology4 ,n4 is a fell[ t ,i l m1 ! m ,i ?9k ( him1 ,fr\de wrote 9 #ahbh2 only ,i w\ld give a few odd p5ce if he 7 n a h]etic4#ae ,b ,fr\de1 :o saw him e day1 & 0 soon associat$ ) him 9 ! tutor%ip1 f\nd a _s m ak9 to 8 own 9 dep? & fre$om & d>+1 ?an he _h yet enc\nt]$4 ,& ,fr\de f\nd ,newman j 9 t matur+ /ate ( religi\s op9ion 9 :i* a p[]ful m9d l ,fr\de's w\ld be likely to act decisively4 ,ea* act$ on ! o!r4 ,fr\de repres5t$ ,keble's ideas1 ,keble's en?usiasm4 ,newman gave %ape1 f\ndation1 consi/5cy1 elevation to ! ,anglican !ology1 :5 he accept$ x1 :i* ,fr\de _h le>n$ f ,keble4 ,i knew him fir/1 we read 9 ! ,apologia1 9 #ahbf1 & 0 9 ! close/ & mo/ affectionate fri5d%ip ) him f ab\t #ahbi till 8 dea? 9 #ahcf4af ,b ?is 0 n all4 ,?r\gh ,fr\de1 ,newman came to "k & to be intimate ) ,keble2 & a sort ( cam>ad]ie arose1 ( v indep5d5t & outspok5 p1 :o ackn[l$g$ ,keble z _! ma/] & c\nsellor4 ,! true & prim>y au?or ( x 7! ,tract>ian movem5t71 we read 9 ! ,apologia1 z is usual ) great motive p[]s1 0 out ( sight4444 ,ne$ ,i say t ,i am speak+ ( ,john ,keble8 ,! /atem5t is /rictly true4 ,fr\de nev] w\ld h be5 ! man he 0 b = 8 daily & h\rly int]c\rse ) ,keble2 & ,fr\de br\ght to be> ^u ,newman's m9d1 at a critical p]iod ( its developm5t1 ,keble's ideas & feel+s ab\t religion & ! ,*ur*1 ,keble's reality ( ?\ght & purpose1 ,keble's transp>5t & sa9tly simplicity4 ,& ,fr\de1 z we "k f a well-kn[n say+ ( 81#ag br\ght ,keble & ,newman to und]/& "o ano!r1 :5 ! eld] man 0 %y & suspici\s ( ! y\ng]1 & ! y\ng]1 ?\gh full ( v5]ation = ! eld]1 0 h>dly yet 9 full sympa?y ) :at 0 mo/ *>act]i/ic & mo/ *]i%$ 9 ! eld]'s religi\s convictions4 ,keble attract$ & m\ld$ ,fr\de3 he impress$ ,fr\de ) 8 /rong ,*ur*man%ip1 8 sev]ity & reality ( life1 8 poetry & high /&>d ( s*ol>ly excell5ce4 ,fr\de le>n$ f him to be anti-,era/ian1 anti-me?odi/ical1 anti-s5tim5tal1 & z /rong 9 8 hatr$ ( ! _w1 z contemptu\s ( popul> approval1 z any ,me?odi/4 ,yet all ?is might m]ely h made a /rong impression1 or =m$ "o m m>k$ s*ool ( doctr9e1 )\t ! fi]ce en]gy :i* receiv$ x & :i* x inspir$4 ,b ,fr\de1 9 accept+ ,keble's ideas1 resolv$ to make !m active1 public1 aggressive2 & he f\nd 9 ,newman a colleague ^: bold orig9ality respond$ to 8 own4 ,toge!r !y work$ z tutors2 toge!r !y work$ :5 _! tutor%ips came to an end2 toge!r !y work$ :5 ?r[n into companion%ip 9 _! ,m$it]ranean voyage 9 ! w9t] ( #ahcb & ! spr+ ( #ahcc4 ,!y came back1 full ( aspirations & anxieties :i* spurr$ !m on2 _! ?\ghts _h brok5 out 9 pap]s s5t home f "t to "t to ,rose's ,briti% ,magaz9e--,home ,?\ghts ,abroad1 & ! ,lyra ,apo/olica4 ,!n came ! meet+ at ,hadleigh1 & ! beg9n+ ( ! ,tracts4 ,keble _h giv5 ! inspiration1 ,fr\de _h giv5 ! impulse2 !n ,newman took up ! "w1 & ! impulse h5ce=w>d1 & ! direction1 7 84 ,d\btless1 _m ?\ght & felt l !m ab\t ! p]ils :i* beset ! ,*ur* & religion4 ,loyalty to ! ,*ur*1 belief 9 h] div9e mission1 allegiance to h] au?ority1 read9ess to d battle = h] claims1 7 any?+ b ext9ct 9 h] m9i/]s & laity4 ,! elem5ts 7 all ab\t ( s\nd & devot$ ,*ur*man%ip4 ,high] ideas ( ! ,*ur* ?an ! popul> & political notion ( x1 high] conceptions ( ,*ri/ian doctr9e ?an ^? ( ! ord9>y evangelical !ology--e*oes ( ! m$itations ( a rem>kable ,iri%man1 ,mr4 ,alex&] ,knox--_h 9 _m qu>t]s attract$ att5tion 9 ! works & s]mons ( 8 disciple4 ,bi%op ,jebb1 ?\gh x 0 n till ! movem5t _h tak5 %ape t _! full significance 0 realis$4 ,o!rs besides ,keble & ,fr\de & ,newman 7 s]i\sly consid]+ :at c\ld be/ be done to arre/ ! curr5t :i* 0 runn+ /rong aga9/ ! ,*ur*1 & discuss+ s*emes ( resi/ance & def5ce4 ,o!rs 7 /irr+ up !mselves & _! bre?r5 to meet ! new em]g5cies1 to respond to ! new call4 ,"s ( ^! 7 9 communication ) ! ,oriel m51 & ultimately took "p ) !m 9 organis+ vigor\s measures4 ,b x 0 n till ,mr4 ,newman made up 8 m9d to =ce on ! public m9d1 9 a way :i* c\ld n be evad$1 ! great article ( ! ,cre$--,i believe "o ,ca?olic & ,apo/olic ,*ur*--t ! movem5t began4 ,& = ! fir/ "p ( its c\rse1 x 0 conc5trat$ at ,ox=d4 ,x 0 ! direct result ( ! se>*+s ( he>t & ! commun+s = sev5 ye>s1 f #ahbf to #ahcc1 ( ! ?ree m5 :o h be5 ! subject ( ?is *apt]4 ,,footnotes3 #ad ,isaac ,williams's ,,ms4 ,memoir4 #ae ,rem4 i4 #bcb1 #bcc4 ,9 #ahbh1 ,newman _h pref]r$ ,hawk9s to ,keble1 = ,provo/4 #af ,apol4 p4 #hd4 #ag ,rema9s1 i4 #dch2 ,apol4 p4 #gg4 ,d y "k ! /ory ( ! murd]] :o _h done "o good ?+ 9 8 life8 ,well1 if ,i 0 ask$ :at good de$ ,i h ev] done1 ,i %\ld say ,i _h br\ght ,keble & ,newman to und]/& ea* o!r4 ,,*apt] ,,iii#ah ,,ri*>d ,,hurrell ,,fr\de ,! names ( ^? :o took ! lead 9 ?is movem5t are famili>--,keble1 ,newman1 ,pusey1 ,hugh ,james ,rose1 ,william ,palm]4 ,mu* has be5 writt5 ab\t !m by fri5ds & enemies1 & also by "o ( !mselves1 & any special notice ( !m is n to ! purpose ( ! pres5t n>rative4 ,b besides ^!1 !re 7 m5 :o are n[ almo/ =gott51 b :o at ! "t int]e/$ _! contempor>ies1 because !y 7 suppos$ to repres5t 9 a m>k$ way ! _s & "* ( ! movem5t1 or to h ex]cis$ influ5ce ^u x4 ,!y ought n to be ov]look$ 9 an acc\nt ( x4 ,"o ( !m has be5 already m5tion$1 ,mr4 ,hurrell ,fr\de4 ,two o!rs 7 ,mr4 ,isaac ,williams & ,mr4 ,*>les ,m>riott4 ,!y 7 all ?ree ( !m m5 :om ^? :o knew !m c\ld nev] =get--c\ld nev] cease to admire & love4 ,hurrell ,fr\de soon pass$ away be=e ! brunt ( ! fight+ came4 ,8 "n is associat$ ) ,mr4 ,newman & ,mr4 ,keble1 b x is little m ?an a "n to ^? :o n[ talk ( ! orig9 ( ! movem5t4 ,yet all :o rememb] him agree 9 assign+ to him an importance z great z t ( any1 9 t little knot ( m5 ^: ?\ghts & ^: c\rage gave bir? to x4 ,ri*>d ,hurrell ,fr\de 0 born 9 #ahjc1 & 0 ?us two ye>s y\ng] ?an ,mr4 ,newman1 :o 0 born 9 #ahja4 ,he w5t to ,eton1 & 9 #ahba to ,oriel1 :]e he 0 a pupil ( ,mr4 ,keble1 & :]e he 0 elect$ ,fell[1 along ) ,rob]t ,wilb]=ce1 at ,ea/] #ahbf4 ,he 0 ,college ,tutor f #ahbg to #ahcj1 hav+ ,mr4 ,newman & ,r4 ,wilb]=ce = colleagues4 ,8 heal? fail$ 9 #ahca & l$ to mu* abs5ce 9 w>m climates4 ,he w5t ) ,mr4 ,newman to ! s\? ( ,europe 9 #ahcb-cc1 & 0 ) him at ,rome4 ,! next two w9t]s1 ) ! int]v5+ ye>1 he sp5t 9 ! ,we/ ,indies4 ,e>ly 9 #ahcf he di$ at ,d>t+ton--8 bir?place4 ,he 0 at ! ,hadleigh meet+1 9 ,july #ahcc1 :5 ! f\ndations ( ! movem5t 7 laid2 he w5t abroad t w9t]1 & 0 n mu* 9 ,engl& aft]w>ds4 ,x 0 ?r\gh correspond5ce t he kept up 8 int]c\rse ) 8 fri5ds4 ,?us he 0 e>ly cut (f f direct & p]sonal action on ! c\rse :i* ?+s took4 ,b x w\ld be a great mi/ake to suppose t 8 influ5ce on ! l9e tak5 & on ! m9ds ( o!rs 0 inconsid]able4 ,x w\ld be m true to say t ) "o exception no "o 0 m responsible = ! impulse :i* l$ to ! movem5t2 no "o _h m to d ) %ap+ its di/9ct aims & its moral _s & "* 9 its fir/ /age2 no "o 0 m d>+ & m cle>1 z f> z he saw1 9 :at he 0 prep>$ =4 ,!re 0 no "o to :om 8 fri5ds s mu* look$ up ) admiration & en?usiasm4 ,!re 0 no wa/$ %ade#ai 9 ,hurrell ,fr\de's disabl$1 prematurely %ort5$ life4 ,l ,h5ry ,m>tyn he 0 made by /rong & ev5 m]ciless self-discipl9e ov] a /rong & = a long "t refractory nature4 ,he 0 a man ( great gifts1 ) mu* t 0 mo/ attractive & noble2 b jo9$ ) ?is !m 0 orig9ally 9 8 "* a ve9 ( p]v]sity & mis*ief1 always 9 dang] ( break+ out1 & ) :i* he kept up a long & pa9ful /ruggle4 ,8 inmo/ ?\ght & k ( himself h be5 laid b>e 9 ! pap]s :i* 8 fri5ds publi%$ aft] 8 dea?4 ,he 0 9 ! habit ( prob+ 8 motives to ! bottom1 & ( record+ )\t m]cy :at he ?\ght 8 self-deceits & affectations4 ,! religi\s _w ( ! day made m]ry ov] 8 me?ods ( self-discipl9e2 b :atev] may be said ( !m1 & su* ?+s are n easy to judge (1 "o ?+ is manife/1 t !y 7 true & s9c]e ef=ts to conqu] :at he ?\ght evil 9 himself1 to keep himself 9 ord]1 to br+ 8 inmo/ self into subjection to ! law & w ( ,god4 ,! self-*a/5+1 :i* 8 private pap]s %[1 is no passion or value = asceticism1 b a purely moral ef=t aft] self-comm& & hone/y ( "*2 & :at makes ! /ruggle s t\*+ is its p]fect reality & tru?4 ,he turn$ 8 ?\ghts on t desolate wild]ness1 8 own consci5ce1 & said :at he saw !re4#bj ,a man :o has _h a good deal to conqu] 9 himself1 & has gone a good way to conqu] x1 is n apt to be indulg5t to self-deceit or indol5ce1 or ev5 weakness4 ,! basis ( ,fr\de's "* 0 a dem& :i* w\ld n be put (f = :at 0 real & ?or\gh2 an implacable scorn & hatr$ = :at he c\nt$ %ams & pret5ces4 ,8 highe/ ambition1 he us$ to say1 0 to be a humdrum4#ba ,! intellectual & ! moral p>ts ( 8 "* 7 ( a piece4 ,! tricks & flims9esses ( a bad argum5t provok$ him z mu* z ! impo/ure & fla% ( ins9c]e s5tim5t & f9e talk+2 he might be consci\s ( fla% 9 himself & 8 fri5ds1 & he w\ld admit x unequivocally2 b x 0 z unbe>able to him to pret5d n to see a fallacy z soon z x 0 detect$1 z x w\ld h be5 to him to arrive at ! "r answ] ( a sum or a problem by tamp]+ ) ! processes4 ,su* a man1 ) /rong affections & ke5 p]ception ( all =ms ( beauty1 & ) ! deepe/ desire to be rev]5t t[>ds all t _h a "r to rev]5ce1 w\ld f9d himself 9 ! mo/ irritat+ /ate ( opposition & impati5ce ) mu* t pass$ z religion r\nd him4 ,pr9ciples n attempt$ to be und]/ood & c>ri$ into practice1 smoo? self-complac5cy among ^? :o look$ d[n on a bl9d & unspiritual _w1 ! cont9ual provocation ( wor?less reason+ & ignorant platitudes1 ! dull unconsci\s /upidity ( p :o c\ld n see t ! times 7 critical--t tru? _h to be def5d$1 & t x 0 no easy or light-he>t$ bus9ess to def5d x--?rew him into an habitual attitude ( defiance1 & half-amus$1 half-e>ne/ contradiction1 :i* made him fe>$ by loose reason]s & pret5ti\s talk]s1 & ev5 by quiet easy-go+ fri5ds1 :o unexpect$ly f\nd !mselves l$ on bl9dfold1 ) ! utmo/ gravity1 into traps & absurdities by ! wiles ( 8 mis*iev\s dialectic4 ,?is 0 ! outside look ( 8 rel5tless e>ne/ness4 ,p :o did n l him1 or 8 views1 & :o1 p]haps1 _h w9c$ "u 8 irony1 naturally put d[n 8 /rong language1 :i* on occasion c\ld c]ta9ly be unc]emoni\s1 to flippancy & arrogance4 ,b )9 ! circle ( ^? :om he tru/$1 or ( ^? :o ne$$ at anytime 8 help1 ano!r side disclos$ itself--a side ( ! mo/ g5u9e w>m? ( affection1 an awful reality ( dev\tness1 :i* x 0 8 great & habitual ef=t to keep hidd51 a high simplicity ( unworldl9ess & g5]osity1 & 9 spite ( 8 d>+ mock]ies ( :at 0 commonplace or %[y1 ! mo/ s9c]e & deeply felt humility ) himself4 ,dang]\s z he 0 (t5 ?\ght to be 9 conv]sation1 "o ( ! features ( 8 "* :i* has impress$ itself on ! memory ( "o :o knew him well1 0 8 pati5t1 w9n+ consid]at5ess 9 discussion1 :i*1 ) o!r qualities1 ende>$ him to ^? to :om he op5$ 8 he>t4#bb ,x is impossible1 writes ,james ,mozley 9 #ahcc1 ) a mixture ( amusem5t1 speak+ ( ! views ab\t celibacy :i* 7 beg9n+ to be curr5t1 to talk ) ,fr\de )\t committ+ "o's self on su* subjects z ^!1 s t by & by ,i expect ! t]giv]sants w be a consid]able p>ty4 ,8 lett]s1 ) _! affectionately playful addresses1 1 1 1 ,c>issime1 ,sir1 my de> fri5d or ' 1 h y n be5 a spoon8 are full ( ! mo/ delightful ease & v]ve & sympa?y4 ,) a ke5 s5se ( ,engli% faults he 01 z ,c>d9al ,newman has said1 an ,engli%man to ! backbone2 & he 01 fur!r1 a fa/idi\s1 high-temp]$ ,engli% g5tleman1 9 spite ( 8 declaim+ ab\t pamp]$ ari/ocrats & ! g5tleman h]esy4 ,8 fri5ds ?\ght ( him z ( ! "y ,a*illes1 ) 8 high c\rage1 & noble =m1 & eagle eye1 made = su* great ?+s1 b appo9t$ s soon to die4 ,:o c refra9 f te>s at ! ?\ght ( t bright & beautiful ,fr\de8 is ! expression ( "o ( !m %ortly be=e 8 dea?1 & :5 x 0 q c]ta9 t ! doom :i* _h s long hung ov] him 0 at h&4#bc ,he _h ! love ( do+1 = ! m]e sake ( do+1 :at 0 difficult or ev5 dang]\s to d1 :i* is ! ma9spr+ ( *>act]i/ic ,engli% sports & games4 ,he lov$ ! sea2 he lik$ to sail 8 own boat1 & enjoy$ r\gh wea!r1 & took int]e/ 9 ! niceties ( seaman%ip & %ipcraft4 ,he 0 a bold rid] across c\ntry4 ,) a p[]ful grasp on ma!matical tru?s & pr9ciples1 he ent]$ ) :ole-he>t$ ze/ into invit+ problems1 or into practical details ( me*anical or hydro/atic or a/ronomical sci5ce4 ,8 lett]s are full ( su* obs]vations1 put 9 a way :i* he ?\ght w\ld int]e/ 8 fri5ds1 & m>k$ by 8 /rong habit ( gett+ into t\* ) :at 0 real & ( ! sub/ance ( que/ions4 ,he appli$ 8 ?\ghts to ar*itecture ) a p[] & orig9ality :i* at ! "t 7 n common4 ,no "o :o only c>$ = ?is _w c\ld be m attract$ & int]e/$ ?an he 0 by ! wond] & beauty ( its facts & appe>ances4 ,) ! deepe/ allegiance to 8 home & rev]5ce = its ties & au?ority1 a home ( ! old-fa%ion$ ecclesia/ical sort1 sob]1 manly1 religi\s1 ord]ly1 he c>ri$ into 8 wid] life ! feel+s ) :i* he _h be5 br\ght up2 bold z he 01 8 reason & 8 "* crav$ = au?ority1 b au?ority :i* morally & reasonably he c\ld respect4 ,mr4 ,keble's goodness & purity subdu$ him1 & dispos$ him to accept )\t res]ve 8 ma/]'s tea*+3 & t[>ds ,mr4 ,keble1 along ) an outside %[ ( playful criticism & privileg$ imp]t95ce1 !re 0 a rev]5ce :i* gov]n$ ,fr\de's :ole nature4 ,9 ! wild & r\gh heyday ( re=m1 he 0 a ,tory ( ! ,tories4 ,b :5 au?ority fail$ him1 f c[>dice or /upidity or self-int]e/1 he c\ld n easily p>don x2 & he 0 ready to />tle 8 fri5ds by proclaim+ himself a ,radical1 prep>$ = ! sake ( ! highe/ & greate/ int]e/s to sacrifice all second-rate & subord9ate ones4 ,:5 8 fri5ds1 aft] 8 dea?1 publi%$ selections f 8 j\rnals & lett]s1 ! _w 0 %ock$ by :at seem$ 8 amaz+ audacity bo? ( ?\ght & expression ab\t a numb] ( ?+s & p]sons :i* x 0 cu/om>y to reg>d z almo/ beyond ! rea* ( criticism4 ,! ,rema9s l5t !mselves admirably to ! controv]sial process ( cull+ *oice phrases & s5t5ces & epi!ts surpris+ly at v>iance ) conv5tional & popul> e/imates4 ,fri5ds 7 pa9$ & di/urb$2 foes naturally en\gh c\ld n hold 9 _! ov]fl[+ exultation at su* a disclosure ( ! _s ( ! movem5t4 ,s]mons & newspap]s drew att5tion to ,fr\de's extravagances ) horror & disgu/4 ,! tru? is t if ! (f-h& say+s 9 conv]sation or lett]s ( any man ( =ce & wit & /rong convictions ab\t ! ?+s & p]sons t he condemns1 7 made kn[n to ! _w1 !y w\ld by !mselves h mu* ! same look ( flippancy1 inju/ice1 imp]t95ce to ^? :o disagre$ 9 op9ion ) ! speak] or writ] !y are all[$ =1 or !y are n all[$ = by o!rs1 accord+ to :at is kn[n ( 8 g5]al "*4 ,! fri5ds :o publi%$ ,fr\de's ,rema9s knew :at he 02 !y knew ! place & proportion ( ! fi]ce & scornful passages2 !y knew t !y really did n g beyond ! lib]ty & ! frank speak+ :i* mo/ p give !mselves 9 ! ab&on & und]/ood exagg]ation ( intimate correspond5ce & talk4 ,b !y miscalculat$ ! effect on ^? :o did n "k him1 or ^: int]e/ x 0 to make ! mo/ ( ! advantage giv5 !m4 ,!y seem to h expect$ t ! picture :i* !y pres5t$ ( _! fri5d's transp>5t s9c]ity & s+l5ess ( aim1 manife/$ amid s mu* pa9 & self-abasem5t1 w\ld h t\*$ read]s m4 ,!y miscalculat$ 9 suppos+ t ! pro(s ( s mu* reality ( religi\s e>ne/ness w\ld c>ry (f ! (f5ce ( vehem5t language1 :i* )\t ^! pro(s might naturally be ?\ght to %[ m]e r&om viol5ce4 ,at any rate ! result 0 mu* natural & g5u9e irritation1 :i* !y 7 h>dly prep>$ =4 ,:e!r on g5]al gr\nds !y 7 wise 9 />tl+ & vex+ fri5ds1 & putt+ fre% weapons into ! h&s ( oppon5ts by _! frank disclosure ( s unconv5tional a "*1 is a "q :i* may h m ?an "o answ]2 b "o ?+ is c]ta91 !y 7 n wise1 if !y only desir$ to =w>d ! imm$iate int]e/s ( _! p>ty or cause4 ,x 0 n ! act ( cunn+ conspirators2 x 0 ! act ( m5 :o 7 ready to %[ _! h&s1 & take ! consequ5ces4 ,und\bt$ly1 !y w>n$ (f _m :o _h s f> gone along ) ! movem5t1 & :o n[ drew back4 ,b if ! publication 0 a mi/ake1 x 0 ! mi/ake ( m5 confid5t 9 _! own /raight-=w>dness4 ,!re is a natural ,nemesis to all ov]-/rong & exagg]at$ language4 ,! weight ( ,fr\de's judgm5ts 0 less5$ by ! disclosure ( 8 /rong words1 & 8 da%+ fa%ion ( condemnation & dislike gave a prec$5t = ! viol5ce ( %all[] m54 ,b to ^? :o look back on !m n[1 ?\gh !re c be no wond] t at ! "t !y excit$ su* an outcry1 _! outspok5 boldness h>dly excites surprise4 ,mu* ( x might naturally be put d[n to ! =ce ( fir/ impressions2 mu* ( x is ! vehem5ce ( an ,engli%man :o claims ! lib]ty ( criticis+ & f9d+ fault at home2 mu* ( x 0 ! inevitable vehem5ce ( a re=m]4 ,mu* ( x seems cle> =esight ( :at has s9ce come to be recognis$4 ,8 judgm5ts on ! ,re=m]s1 />tl+ z !y 7 at ! "t1 are n s v diff]5t1 z to ! facts ( ! case1 f :at mo/ p on all sides n[ agree 92 & z to _! temp] & !ology1 f :at mo/ *ur*m5 w\ld n[ agree 94 ,:atev] all[ances may be made = ! difficulties ( _! "t1 & ^! all[ances ought to be v great1 & h[ev] well !y may h done p>ts ( _! "w1 su* z ! translations & adaptations ( ! ,pray] ,book1 x is safe to say t ! div9es ( ! ,re=mation nev] c be aga91 ) _! confess$ ,calv9ism1 ) _! %ift+ op9ions1 _! extravagant def]5ce to ! =eign oracles ( ,g5eva & ,zuri*1 _! subs]vi5ce to bad m5 9 p[]1 ! h]oes & sa9ts ( *ur*m54 ,b :5 all ?is is said1 x /ill rema9s true t ,fr\de 0 (t5 intemp]ate & unju/4 ,9 ! h&s ( ! mo/ self-re/ra9$ & consid]ate ( its lead]s1 ! movem5t mu/ anyh[ h provok$ /rong opposition1 & giv5 great (f5ce4 ,! surprise & ! g5]al ignorance 7 too great2 ! assault 0 too rude & unexpect$4 ,b ,fr\de's /rong language gave x a ne$less exasp]ation4 ,fr\de 0 a man /rong 9 ab/ract ?\ght & imag9ation1 :o want$ adequate k4 ,8 canons ( judgm5t 7 n enl>g$1 correct$1 & /r5g!n$ by any read+ or exp]i5ce comm5surate ) 8 orig9al p[]s ( reason+ or inv5tion4 ,he 0 q consci\s ( x1 & did 8 be/ to fill up ! gap 9 8 intellectual equipm5t4 ,he %[$ :at he might h done "u m fav\r+ circum/ances 9 a v int]e/+ volume on ,becket's hi/ory & lett]s4 ,b circum/ances 7 hopelessly aga9/ him2 he _h n "t1 he _h n heal? & /r5g?1 = ! le>n+ :i* he s ne$$1 :i* he s long$ =4 ,b :]ev] he c\ld1 he le>n$4 ,he 0 q ready to submit 8 prepossessions to ! te/ & limitation ( facts4 ,eag] & quick-sight$1 he 0 (t5 apt to be ha/y 9 conclusions f imp]fect or insuffici5t premisses2 b ev5 ab\t :at he saw mo/ cle>ly he 0 will+ to hold himself 9 susp5se1 :5 he f\nd t !re 0 some?+ m to "k4 ,c>d9al ,newman has not$ two defici5cies :i*1 9 8 op9ion1 7 noticeable 9 ,fr\de4 ,he _h no turn = !ology z su*2 &1 fur!r1 he goes on3 ,i %\ld say t 8 p[] ( ent]+ into ! m9ds ( o!rs 0 n equal to 8 o!r gifts--a rem>k :i* he illu/rates by say+ t ,fr\de c\ld n believe t ,i really held ! ,roman ,*ur* to be anti*ri/ian4 ,! want ( ?is p[]--9 :i* he /ood 9 su* %>p contra/ to 8 fri5d--might be ei!r a /r5g? or a weakness2 a /r5g?1 if 8 bus9ess 0 only to fight2 a weakness1 if x 0 to attract & p]suade4 ,b ,fr\de 0 made = conflict1 n to w9 disciples4 ,"s wild solemn poetry1 m>k$ by deep feel+ & direct expression1 is scatt]$ ?r\gh 8 lett]s1#bd k9dl$ always by ?+s & ?\ghts ( ! highe/ significance1 & break+ =? ) =ce & fire4 ,b probably ! judgm5t pass$ on him by a clev] fri5d1 f ! exam9ation ( 8 h&writ+1 0 a true "o3 ,?is fell[ has a great deal ( imag9ation1 b n ! imag9ation ( a poet4 ,he felt t ev5 beyond poetry !re are high] ?+s ?an any?+ t imag9ation c "w ^u4 ,x 0 a feel+ :i* made him bl9d to ! gr&eur ( ,milton's poetry4 ,he saw 9 x only an intrusion into ! mo/ sacr$ ( sanctities4 ,x 0 ?is fe>less & p[]ful _s1 ke5 & quick to see inf]5ces & intol]ant ( compromises1 t ! di/urbances ( ,roman ,ca?olic ,emancipation & ( ! ,re=m "t r\s$ f ! common r\nd ( pursuits1 natural to a s]i\s & ?\ghtful cl]gyman ( s*ol>like m9d & z yet no def9ite objects1 & br\ght him ) all 8 en?usiasm & ?or\ghness into a companion%ip ) m5 :o _h devot$ _! lives1 & giv5 up e worldly object1 to save ! ,*ur* by rais+ x to its orig9al idea & _s4 ,keble _h lift$ 8 pupil's ?\ghts above m]e dry & un9tellig5t or?odoxy1 & ,fr\de _h ent]$ ) e>ne/ purpose into ,*ur* ways ( practical self-discipl9e & self-correction4 ,bi%op ,lloyd's lectures _h taught him & o!rs1 to ! surprise ( _m1 t ! famili> & v5]at$ ,pray] ,book 0 b ! reflexion ( m$iaeval & primitive devotion1 /ill embodi$ 9 its ,lat9 =ms 9 ! ,roman ,s]vice books2 & s indirectly _h plant$ 9 _! m9ds ! idea ( ! hi/orical connexion1 & 9 a v pr(\nd way ! spiritual sympa?y1 ( ! mod]n ) ! pre-,re=mation ,*ur*4 ,b x is n till #ahbi or #ahcj t we beg9 9 8 ,rema9s to see 9 him ! s5se ( a press+ & anxi\s crisis 9 religi\s matt]s4 ,9 ! summ] ( #ahbi he came m closely ?an hi!rto across ,mr4 ,newman's pa?4 ,!y _h be5 ,fell[s toge!r s9ce #ahbf1 & ,tutors s9ce #ahbg4 ,mr4 ,fr\de1 ) 8 ,toryism & old-fa%ion$ *ur*man%ip1 w\ld n unnaturally be %y ( a fri5d ( ,:ately's ) 8 reputation = !ological lib]alism4 ,fr\de's fir/ lett] to ,mr4 ,newman is 9 ,augu/ #ahbh4 ,x is ! lett] ( a fri5dly & sympa?is+ colleague 9 college "w1 glad to be free f ! images ( impud5t und]graduates2 he ins]ts "s l9es ( v]se1 talks ab\t ,dollond & telescopes1 & relates h[ he & a fri5d got up at half-pa/ two 9 ! morn+1 & walk$ half a mile to see ,m]cury rise2 he writes ab\t 8 ma!matical /udies & read+ = ord]s1 & h[ a fri5d _h read half ?r\gh ,prideaux & yet accuses himself ( idl5ess2 b !re is no int]*ange ( intimate ?\ght4 ,mr4 ,newman 0 at ?is "t1 z he has told u1 drift+ away f "u ! %ad[ ( lib]alism2 & 9 ,fr\de he f\nd a man :o1 )\t be+ a lib]al1 0 z quick-sight$1 z c\rage\s1 & z alive to great ?\ghts & new hopes z himself4 ,v diff]5t 9 _m ways1 !y 7 9 ?is alike1 t ! commonplace notions ( religion & ! ,*ur* 7 utt]ly unsatisfactory to !m1 & t ea* _h ! capacity = affectionate & :ole-he>t$ fri5d%ip4 ,! fri5d%ip began & la/$ on1 gr[+ /rong] & deep] to ! end4 ,& ?is 0 n all4 ,fr\de's fri5d%ip ) ,mr4 ,newman ov]came ,mr4 ,keble's hesitations ab\t ,mr4 ,newman's suppos$ lib]alism4 ,mr4 ,newman has put on record :at he ?\ght & felt ab\t ,fr\de2 no "o1 probably1 ( ! _m :om ,c>d9al ,newman's long life has br\ght r\nd him1 ev] occupi$ ,fr\de's place 9 8 he>t4 ,! correspond5ce %[s 9 "p ! way 9 :i* ,fr\de's _s rose1 "u ! s5se ( hav+ su* a fri5d to "w ) 9 ! cause :i* day by day grew great] & m sacr$ 9 ! eyes ( bo?4 ,t[>ds ,mr4 ,keble ,fr\de felt l a son to a fa!r2 t[>ds ,mr4 ,newman l a soldi] to 8 comrade1 & him ! mo/ spl5did & bolde/ ( w>riors4 ,ea* m9d caught fire f ! o!r1 till ! high en?usiasm ( ! "o 0 qu5*$ 9 an e>ly dea?4 ,%ortly aft] ?is fri5d%ip began1 ! c\rse ( ev5ts also began :i* f9ally gave bir? to ! ,ox=d movem5t4 ,! break-up ( p>ties caus$ by ! ,roman ,ca?olic emancipation 0 foll[$ by ! ,fr5* & ,belgian revolutions ( #ahcj1 & ^! *anges gave a fre% /imulus to all ! re=m+ p>ties 9 ,engl&--,:igs1 ,radicals1 & lib]al religioni/s4 ,fr\de's lett]s m>k ! influ5ce ( ^! *anges on 8 m9d4 ,!y /irr$ 9 him ! fi]ce/ disgu/ & indignation1 & z soon z ! necessity ( battle became evid5t to save ! ,*ur*--& su* a necessity 0 evid5t--he ?rew himself into x ) all 8 he>t1 & 8 attitude 0 h5ce=? t ( a det]m9$ & uncompromis+ combatant4 ,fr\de is gr[+ /rong] & /rong] 9 8 s5tim5ts e day1 writes ,james ,mozley1 9 #ahcb1 & cuts ab\t him on all sides4 ,x is extremely f9e to he> him talk4 ,! ari/ocracy ( ! c\ntry at pres5t are ! *ief objects ( 8 vitup]ation1 & he decid$ly sets himself aga9/ ! mod]n "* ( ! g5tleman1 & ?9ks t ! ,*ur* w ev5tually dep5d = its support1 z x always did 9 its mo/ influ5tial times1 on ! v poore/ classes4 ,i w\ld n set d[n any?+ t ,fr\de says = 8 delib]ate op9ion1 writes ,james ,mozley a ye> lat]1 = he really hates ! pres5t /ate ( ?+s s excessively t any *ange w\ld be a relief to him4 444 ,fr\de is /ay+ up1 & ,i see a great deal ( him4 444 ,fr\de is mo/ en?usia/ic 9 8 plans1 & says1 ',:at fun x is liv+ 9 su* times z ^!6 h[ c\ld "o n[ g back to ! times ( old ,tory humbug8' ,f h5ce=? 8 position among 8 fri5ds 0 t ( ! mo/ impati5t & aggressive ( re=m]s1 ! "o :o mo/ urg$ on 8 fell[s to outspok5 language & a bold l9e ( action4 ,!y 7 n m5 to hang back & be afraid1 b !y 7 cauti\s & consid]ate ( popul> al>ms & prejudices1 comp>$ ) ,fr\de's fe>lessness4 ,o!r m9ds 7 inde$ mov+--m9ds z /rong z 81 inde$1 x may be1 deep]1 m complex1 m amply furni%$1 ) a wid] range ( vision & a great] comm& ( ! field4 ,b :ile he liv$1 he appe>s z ! "o :o spurs on & incites1 :]e o!rs hesitate4 ,he is ! "o by :om are visibly mo/ felt ! gaudia c]tam9is1 & ! confid5ce ( victory1 & ! mo/ pr(\nd contempt = ! m5 & ! ideas ( ! boa/ful & %ort-sight$ pres5t4 ,9 ?is unsp>+ & absorb+ w>f>e1 :at did ,fr\de aim at--:at 0 ! object he s\ght to br+ ab\t1 :at 7 ! ob/acles he s\ght to ov]?r[8 ,he 0 accus$1 z 0 mo/ natural1 ( ,romanis+2 ( wi%+ to br+ back ,pop]y4 ,x is p]fectly c]ta9 t ?is 0 n :at he meant1 ?\gh he did n c>e = ! imputation ( x4 ,he 01 p]haps1 ! fir/ ,engli%man :o attempt$ to d ju/ice to ,rome1 & to use fri5dly language ( x1 )\t ! int5tion ( jo9+ x4 ,b :at he f\ght = 0 n ,rome1 n ev5 a re/oration ( unity1 b a ,*ur* ( ,engl& su* z x 0 conceiv$ ( by ! ,c>ol9e div9es & ! ,non-jurors4 ,! great break-up ( #ahcj _h =c$ on m5 ! anxi\s "q1 ,:at is ! ,*ur* z spok5 ( 9 ,engl&8 ,is x ! ,*ur* ( ,*ri/8 & ! answ]s 7 v>i\s4 ,hook] _h said x 0 ! nation2 & 9 entirely alt]$ circum/ances1 ) "s qualifications4 ,dr4 ,arnold said ! same4 ,x 0 ! ,e/abli%m5t accord+ to ! lawy]s & politicians1 bo? ,:ig & ,tory4 ,x 0 an invisible & my/ical body1 said ! ,evangelicals4 ,x 0 ! aggregate ( sep>ate congregations1 said ! ,noncon=mi/s4 ,x 0 ! p>liam5t>y creation ( ! ,re=mation1 said ! ,era/ians4 ,! true ,*ur* 0 ! communion ( ! ,pope1 ! pret5d$ ,*ur* 0 a legalis$ s*ism1 said ! ,roman ,ca?olics4 ,all ^! ideas 7 float+ ab\t1 loose & vague1 among p :o talk$ mu* ab\t ! ,*ur*4 ,:ately1 ) 8 cle> s5se1 _h laid d[n t x 0 a div9e religi\s society1 di/9ct 9 its orig9 & exi/5ce1 di/9ct 9 its attributes f any o!r4 ,b ?is idea _h fall5 dead1 till ,fr\de & 8 fri5ds put new life into x ,fr\de accept$ ,:ately's idea t ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 0 ! "o hi/oric un9t]rupt$ ,*ur*1 ?an :i* !re c\ld be no o!r1 locally 9 ,engl&2 b into ?is ,fr\de read a great deal t nev] 0 & nev] c\ld be 9 ,:ately's ?\ghts4 ,:ately _h gone v f> 9 view+ ! ,*ur* f )\t z a great & sacr$ corporate body4 ,ca/+ aside ! ,era/ian !ory1 he _h claim$ its "r to exi/1 & if necess>y1 gov]n itself1 sep>ate f ! /ate4 ,he _h recognis$ excommunication z its natural & indefeasible in/rum5t ( gov]nm5t4 ,b :at ! int]nal life ( ! ,*ur* 01 :at %\ld be its tea*+ & organic sy/em1 & :at 0 ! /&>d & pro( ( ^!1 ,:ately _h left unsaid4 ,& ?is outl9e ,fr\de fill$ up4 ,= ?is he w5t ! way to :i* ! ,pray] ,book1 ) its ,(fices1 its ,liturgy1 its ,ord9ation s]vices1 po9t$ him4 ,) ! div9es :o _h specially valu$ ! ,pray] ,book1 & taught 9 its _s1 ,bi%op ,wilson1 ,william ,law1 ,hammond1 ,k51 ,laud1 ,&rewes1 he w5t back to ! times & ! s\rces f :i* ! ,pray] ,book came to u1 ! e>ly ,*ur*1 ! re=m+ ,*ur* = su* ) all its faults x 0--( ! elev5?1 twelf?1 & ?irte5? c5turies1 be=e ! hopelessly corrupt & fatal times ( ! f\rte5? & fifte5? c5turies1 :i* l$ to ! break-up ( ! sixte5?4 ,?us to ! great "q1 ,:at is ! ,*ur*8 he gave )\t hesitation1 & gave to ! end1 ! same answ] t ,anglicans gave & are giv+ /ill4 ,b he add$ two po9ts :i* 7 !n v new to ! e>s ( ,engli% ,*ur*m53 7#a7 t !re 7 great & to mo/ p unsuspect$ faults & %ortcom+s 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 = "s ( :i* ! ,re=mation 0 gravely responsible2 7#b7 t ! ,roman ,*ur* 0 m "r ?an we _h be5 taught to ?9k 9 _m p>ts bo? ( pr9ciple & practice1 & t our qu>rel ) x on ^! po9ts arose f our own ignorance & prejudices4 ,to p :o _h tak5 = grant$ all _! lives t ! ,*ur* 0 ?or\ghly ,prote/ant & ?or\ghly "r 9 its ,prote/antism1 & t ,rome 0 ,anti*ri/1 ^! confid5t /atem5ts came ) a %ock4 ,he did n ent] mu* into dogmatic que/ions4 ,z f> z c be judg$ f 8 ,rema9s1 ! "o po9t ( doctr9e on :i* he laid /ress1 z be+ inadequately recognis$ & taught 9 ! !n condition ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 0 ! primitive doctr9e ( ! ,eu*>i/4 ,8 o!r criticisms po9t$ to practical & moral matt]s2 ! _s ( ,era/ianism1 ! l[ /&>d ( life & purpose & self-discipl9e 9 ! cl]gy1 ! l[ tone ( ! curr5t religi\s tea*+4 ,! ,evangelical tea*+ seem$ to him a sy/em ( unreal words4 ,! opposite s*ool 0 too self-complac5t1 too com=table1 too secure 9 its social & political alliances2 & he 0 b5t on %am+ p into sev]] notions4 ,we w h a vocabul>ium apo/olicum1 & ,i w />t x ) f\r words3 'pamp]$ ari/ocrats1' 'resid5t g5tlem51' 'smug p>sons1' & 'paup]es ,*ri/i'4 ,i %all use ! fir/ on all occasions2 x seems to me j to hit ! ?+4 ,i ?9k ( putt+ ! view =w>d 7ab\t new mona/]ies71 "u ! title ( a ',project = ,reviv+ ,religion 9 ,great ,t[ns4' ,c]ta9ly colleges ( unm>ri$ prie/s 7:o might1 ( c\rse1 retire to a liv+1 :5 !y c\ld & lik$7 w\ld be ! *eape/ possible way ( provid+ effectively = ! spiritual wants ( a l>ge population4 ,& 8 great qu>rel ) ! exi/+ /ate ( ?+s 0 t ! spiritual objects ( ! ,*ur* 7 ov]laid & lo/ sight ( 9 ! anxiety n to lose its political position4 ,9 ?is direction he 01 z he proclaims himself1 an out-&-out ,radical1 & he 0 prep>$ at once to g v f>4 ,if a national ,*ur* means a ,*ur* )\t discipl9e1 my argum5t = discipl9e is an argum5t aga9/ a national ,*ur*2 & ! be/ ?+ we c d is to unnationalise ours z soon z possible2 let u tell ! tru? & %ame ! devil2 let u give up a national ,*ur* & h a real "o4 ,8 criticism did n dim9i% 9 sev]ity1 or 8 proposals become less d>+1 z he felt t 8 "t 0 gr[+ %ort & ! h& ( dea? 0 ^u him4 ,b to ! end1 ! elevation & improvem5t ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* rema9$ 8 great purpose4 ,to 8 fri5d1 z we "k1 ! ,roman ,*ur* 0 ei!r ! ,tru? or ,anti*ri/4 ,to ,fr\de x 0 nei!r ! :ole ,tru? nor ,anti*ri/2 b l ! ,engli% ,*ur* itself1 a great & defective ,*ur*1 ^: defects 7 ! opposite to ours1 & :i* we %\ld d wisely to le>n f r ?an abuse4 ,b to ! la/ 8 allegiance nev] wav]$ to ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,x is v /rik+ to come f ,fr\de's boi/]\s fre$om 9 8 lett]s to 8 s]mons & ! pap]s he prep>$ = publication4 ,9 8 s]mons 8 mann] ( writ+ is sev]e & re/ra9$ ev5 to dryness4 ,if !y />tle x is by ! =ce & se>*+ po9t ( an idea1 n by any /r5g? ( words4 ,! /yle is *a/5$1 simple1 calm1 ) ! mo/ c>eful avoidance ( ov]-/atem5t or any?+ rhetorical4 ,& s 9 8 pap]s1 8 mode ( argum5t1 =cible & cog5t z x is1 avoids all appe>ance ( exagg]ation or ev5 illu/rative expansion2 x is all muscle & s9ew2 x is modell$ on ! argum5tative /yle ( ,bi%op ,butl]1 & /ill m1 ( ,william ,law4 ,no "o c\ld suppose f ^! pap]s ,fr\de's fi]y impetuosity1 or ! frank d>+ ( 8 disrespectful vocabul>y4 ,^? :o c read betwe5 ! l9es c trace ! grave irony :i* clung ev]y:]e to 8 deep e>ne/ness4 ,!re 0 yet ano!r side ( ,fr\de's "* :i* 0 little ?\ght ( by 8 critics1 or recognis$ by all 8 fri5ds4 ,) all 8 ke5ness ( judgm5t & all 8 read9ess = conflict1 "s :o knew him be/ 7 impress$ by ! melan*oly :i* hung ov] 8 life1 & :i*1 ?\gh he ignor$ x1 !y c\ld detect4 ,x is rememb]$ /ill by ,c>d9al ,newman4 ,i ?\ght1 wrote ,mr4 ,isaac ,williams1 t kn[+ him1 ,i bett] und]/ood ,hamlet1 a p]son mo/ natural1 b s orig9al z to be unlike any "o else1 hid+ dep? ( delicate ?\ght 9 app>5t extravagances4 ,hamlet1 & ! ,georgics ( ,virgil1 he us$ to say1 he %\ld h b\nd toge!r4 ,isaac ,williams1 wrote ,mr4 ,copel&1 m5tion$ to me a rem>k made on ,fr\de by ,s4 ,wilb]=ce 9 8 e>ly days3 ',!y talk ( ,fr\de's fun1 b someh[ ,i _c be 9 a room ) him alone = t5 m9utes )\t feel+ s int5sely melan*oly1 t ,i d n "k :at to d ) myself4 ,at ,bright/one1 9 my ,ed5 days1 he 0 ) me1 & ,i 0 ov]:elm$ ) ! deep s5se :i* possess$ him ( ye>n+ :i* no?+ c\ld satisfy & ( ! unsatisfy+ nature ( all ?+s4'#be ,fr\de (t5 rem9ds u ( ,pascal4 ,bo? _h t peculi>ly bright1 brilliant1 %>p-cutt+ intellect :i* passes ) ease ?r\gh ! cov]+s & disguises :i* veil realities f m54 ,bo? _h ma!matical p[]s ( unusual orig9ality & cle>ness2 bo? _h ! same imag9ative faculty2 bo? _h ! same ke5 int]e/ 9 practical problems ( sci5ce2 bo? felt & foll[$ ! attraction ( deep] & m awful int]e/s4 ,bo? _h ! same love ( beauty2 bo? suppress$ x4 ,bo? _h ! same want ( wide or deep le>n+2 !y made skilful use ( :at books came to _! h&1 & us$ _! read+ z few read]s are able to use x2 b _! real in/rum5t ( "w 0 _! own quick & /rong insight1 & p[] ( close & vigor\s reason+4 ,bo? _h ! greate/ contempt = fa%ionable & holl[ %ad[s ( religion4 ,bo? _h ! same def9ite1 unfl9*+ judgm5t4 ,bo? us$ ! same cle> & direct language4 ,bo? _h a c]ta9 grim delight 9 ! irony ) :i* !y pursu$ _! oppon5ts4 ,9 bo? x is probable t _! unmeasur$ & unsp>+ criticism recoil$ on ! cause :i* !y _h at he>t4 ,b 9 ! case ( bo? ( !m x 0 n ! temp] ( ! satiri/1 x 0 no m]e love ( attack+ :at 0 vuln]able1 & indulg5ce 9 ! cruel pleasure ( /++ & putt+ to %ame1 :i* inspir$ !m4 ,_! s\ls 7 mov$ by ! di%on\r done to religion1 by public evils & public dang]s4 ,bo? ( !m di$ "y1 be=e _! "w 0 done4 ,!y plac$ be=e !mselves ! l(tie/ & mo/ unselfi% objects1 ! re/oration ( tru? & goodness 9 ! ,*ur*1 & to t !y gave _! life & all t !y _h4 ,& :at !y call$ on o!rs to be !y 7 !mselves4 ,!y 7 alike 9 ! /]nness1 ! reality1 ! p]sev]ance1 almo/ un9telligible 9 its me?ods to ord9>y m51 ( _! moral & spiritual self-discipl9e4 ,,supplem5t>y ,,to ,,*apt] ,,iii#bf ,hurrell ,fr\de 01 :5 ,i1 z an und]graduate1 fir/ knew him 9 #ahbh1 tall & v ?91 ) some?+ ( a /oop1 ) a l>ge skull & =ehead1 b n a l>ge face1 delicate features1 & p5etrat+ gray eyes1 n exactly pi]c+1 b bright ) int]nal conceptions1 & ready to assume an expression ( amusem5t1 c>eful att5tion1 inquiry1 or /]n disgu/1 b ) a basis ( s(tness4 ,8 mann] 0 cordial & famili>1 & assur$ y1 z y knew him well1 ( 8 affectionate feel+1 :i* enc\rag$ y to speak y\r m9d 7)9 c]ta9 limits71 subject to ! consid]ation t if y said any?+ absurd x w\ld n be all[$ to fall to ! gr\nd4 ,he _h m ( ! und]graduate 9 him ?an any don :om ,i ev] knew2 absolutely unlike ,newman 9 be+ always ready to skate1 sail1 or ride ) 8 fri5ds--&1 if 9 a scrape1 n ph>isaical z to 8 means ( gett+ out ( x4 ,i rememb]1 e4g41 climb+ ,m]ton gate ) him 9 my und]graduate days1 :5 we _h be5 out too late boat+ or skat+4 ,& unless au?ority or sub/antial decorum 0 really ?reat5$ he 0 v l5i5t--or r _h an amus$ sympa?y ) ! irregul>ities t are m]e matt]s ( mis*ief or high spirits4 ,9 lecture x 01 mutatis mut&is1 ! same man4 ,see+1 f 8 ,rema9s1 ! high view ( 8 own capacities ( :i* he c\ld n dive/ himself1 & 8 det]m9ation n to exhibit or be puff$ up by x1 & look+ back on 8 tutorial mann] 7,i 0 9 8 lectures bo? 9 classics & ma!matics71 x 0 /range h[ he disguis$1 n only 8 s5se ( sup]iority1 b ! appe>ance ( x1 s t 8 pupils felt him m z a fell[-/ud5t ?an z ! ref9$ s*ol> or ma!matician :i* he 04 ,?is 0 p>tly ow+ to 8 c>elessness ( ^? =mulae1 ! famili>ity ) :i* gives ev5 second-rate lectur]s a position ( sup]iority :i* is less visible 9 ^? :o1 l _! pupils1 are !mselves always /ruggl+ ) pr9ciples--& p>tly to an ef=t1 p]haps sometimes ov]done1 n to put himself above ! level ( o!rs4 ,9 a lecture on ! ,supplices ( ,aes*ylus1 ,i h he>d him say t\t bonnem5t1 ,i c't con/rue t--:at d y make ( x1 ,a4,b48 turn+ to ! suppos$ be/ s*ol> 9 ! lecture2 or1 :5 an objection 0 />t$ to 8 mode ( gett+ ?r\gh a difficulty1 ,ah6 ,i _h n ?\ght ( t--p]haps y\r way is ! be/4 ,& ?is mode ( deal+ ) himself & ! und]graduates :om he lik$1 made !m l him1 b also made !m really und]value 8 tal5t1 :i*1 z we n[ see1 0 :at he meant !y %\ld d4 ,at ! same "t1 ?\gh wat*ful ov] 8 own vanity1 he 0 ke5 & prompt 9 snubs--playful & *all5g+ retort--to ^? he lik$1 b 9 ! nature ( scornful exposure1 :5 he _h to d ) co>s5ess or coxcombry1 or %all[ display ( s5tim5t4 ,x 0 a p>adoxical consequ5ce ( 8 suppression ( egotism t he 0 m solicit\s to %[ t y 7 wrong ?an t he 0 "r4 ,he also want$1 l ,socrates or ,bi%op ,butl]1 to make o!rs1 if possible1 ?9k = !mselves4 ,h[ev]1 x is n to be inf]r$ t 8 conv]sation 0 made ( controv]sy4 ,to a c]ta9 ext5t x turn$ t way1 because he 0 fond ( p>adox4 7,8 bro!r ,william us$ to say t he1 ,william1 nev] felt he _h really ma/]$ a pr9ciple till he _h ?r[n x into a p>adox47 ,& p>adox1 ( c\rse1 invites contradiction1 & s controv]sy4 ,on subjects ^u :i* he consid]$ himself m or less an apo/le1 he lik$ to /ir p's m9ds by :at />tl$ !m1 wak+ !m up1 or giv+ !m nuts to crack4 ,an almo/ solemn gravity ) amusem5t tw9kl+ beh9d x--n invisible--& ready to bur/ =? into a bright l[ laugh :5 gravity _h be5 play$ out1 0 a v frequ5t po/ure ) him4 ,b he 0 ?or\ghly ready to amuse & in/ruct1 or to be amus$ & in/ruct$1 z an eag] & e>ne/ speak] or li/5] on mo/ matt]s ( int]e/4 ,i d n rememb] t he _h any great turn = beauty ( col\r2 he _h none1 ,i ?9k1 or next to none1 = music--nor d ,i rememb] 9 him any great love ( hum\r--b = beauty ( physical =m1 = me*anics1 = ma!matics1 = poetry :i* _h a root 9 true feel+1 = wit 7includ+ t p]ception ( a quasi-logical absurdity ( position71 = hi/ory1 = dome/ic incid5ts1 8 sympa?y 0 always lively1 & he w\ld ?r[ himself naturally & w>mly into !m4 ,f 8 g5]al demean\r 7,i ne$ sc>cely say7 ! od\r ( sanctity 0 :olly abs5t4 ,i am n sure t 8 height & dep? ( aim & lively v]satility ( tal5t did n leave 8 compassionate sympa?ies r undevelop$2 c]ta9ly to himself1 &1 ,i suspect1 l>gely 9 ! case ( o!rs1 he w\ld view suff]+ n z a ?+ to be cock]$ up or made mu* (1 ?\gh ( c\rse to be alleviat$ if possible1 b to be view$ calmly z a ,provid5tial discipl9e = ^? :o c mitigate1 or h to endure x4 ,j4,h4,n4 0 once read+ me a lett] j receiv$ f him 9 :i* 79 answ] to ,j4,h4,n4's acc\nt ( 8 "w & ! possibility ( 8 break+ d[n7 he said 9 sub/ance3 ,i d>esay y h m to d ?an y\r heal? w be>1 b ,i w\ld n h y give up any?+ except p]haps ! dean]y 7( ,oriel74 ,& !n ,j4,h4,n4 paus$1 ) a k9d ( inn] exultant *uckle1 & said1 ,ah6 !re's a ,basil = y2 z if ! fri5d%ip :i* sacrific$ its fri5d1 z x w\ld sacrifice itself to a cause1 0 ! fri5d%ip :i* 0 really wor? hav+4 ,z ,i came to "k him 9 a m manly way1 z a bro!r ,fell[1 fri5d1 & collaborateur1 ! "* ( ecclesia/ical agitator 0 ( c\rse add$ to ?is4 ,9 ?is capacity 8 great pleasure 0 tak+ bulls by _! horns4 ,l ! gueux ( ! ,l[ ,c\ntries1 he w\ld h met half-way any opprobri\s nickname1 & ,i believe co9$ ! epi!t apo/olical = 8 p>ty because x 0 connect$ ) ev]y?+ 9 ,spa9 :i* 0 mo/ obnoxi\s to ! ,briti% public4 ,i rememb] "o day 8 griev\sly %ock+ ,palm] ( ,worce/]1 a man ( an opposite texture1 :5 a c\ncil 9 ,j4,h4,n4's rooms _h be5 call$ to consid] "s memorial or o!r to :i* ,palm] want$ to collect ! signatures ( _m1 & p>ticul>ly ( dignifi$ p]sons1 b 9 :i* ,fr\de wi%$ to express ! det]m9$ op9ions ( a few4 ,fr\de /ret*$ out 8 long l5g? on ,newman's s(a1 & broke 9 ^u "o ( ,palm]'s judici\s h>angues ab\t ,bi%ops & ,ar*deacons & su* l1 ) ! ejaculation1 ,i don't see :y we %\ld disguise f ourselves t our object is to dictate to ! cl]gy ( ?is c\ntry1 & ,i1 = "o1 d n want any "o else to get on ! box4 ,he ?\ght t true ,*ur*m5 mu/ be few be=e !y 7 _m--t ! s9 ( ! cl]gy 9 all ages 0 t !y tri$ to make out t ,*ri/ians 7 _m :5 !y 7 only few1 & sacrific$ to ?is object ! =ce d]ivable f d[nright & unmi/akable en=cem5t ( tru? 9 spee* or action4 ,z simplicity 9 ?\ght1 ^w1 & de$ =m$ no small "p ( 8 ideal1 8 ta/es 9 ar*itecture1 pa9t+1 sculpture1 rhetoric1 or poetry 7 sev]e4 ,he _h no pati5ce ) :at 0 arti/ically dissolute1 lusci\s1 or decorat$ m ?an 9 proportion to its animat+ idea--wi%y-wa%y or s5tim5tal4 ,! ornam5tal p>ts ( 8 own rooms 79 :i* ,i liv$ 9 8 abs5ce7 7 a slab ( m>ble to wa% ^u1 a pr9t ( ,rub5s's ,deposition1 & a head 7life-size7 ( ! ,apollo ,belvid]e4 ,& ,i rememb] /ill ! tall scorn1 ) some?+ ( surprise1 ) :i*1 on ent]+ my und]graduate room1 he look$ d[n on "s ,v5uses1 ,cupids1 & ,hebes1 :i*1 fre%man-l1 ,i _h b\ght f an ,italian4 ,he 0 n v easy ev5 "u conv5tional vulg>ity1 /ill less "u ! vulg>ity ( egotism2 b1 be+ ess5tially a p>tisan1 he c\ld put up ) bo? 9 a man :o 0 really 9 e>ne/ & on ! "r side4 ,no?+1 h[ev]1 ,i ?9k1 w\ld h induc$ him to tol]ate false s5tim5t1 & he w\ld1 ,i ?9k1 if he _h liv$1 h ex]t$ himself v tr5*antly to prev5t 8 cause be+ adult]at$ by x4 ,he 01 ,i %\ld say1 sometimes misl$ by a !ory t g5ius cut ?r\gh a subject by logic or intuition1 )\t look+ to ! "r or left1 :ile common s5se 0 always te/+ e /ep by consid]ation ( surr\nd+s 7,i h n got 8 t]se mode ( /atem5t71 & t g5ius 0 "r1 or at lea/ _h only to be correct$ "h & !re by common s5se4 ,?is1 ,i take x1 w\ld h>dly h answ]$ if 8 tr5*ancy _h n be5 9 practice correct$ by ,j4,h4,n4's wid] political circumspection4 ,he submitt$1 ,i suppose1 to ,j4,h4,n4's axiom1 t if ! movem5t 0 to d any?+ x mu/ become respectable2 b x 0 aga9/ 8 nature4 ,he w\ld 7z we see 9 ! ,rema9s7 h wi%$ ,k5 to h ! c\rage ( 8 convictions by excommunicat+ ! ,jurors 9 ,william ,,iii4's "t1 & sett+ up a little ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 l ! ,jans5i/s 9 ,holl&4 ,he 0 n 7z has be5 obs]v$7 a !ologian1 b he 0 z jeal\s = or?odoxy z if he 74 ,he spoke slight+ly ( ,heb] z hav+ ignorantly or c>elessly communicat$ ) 787 ,monophysites4 ,b he probably knew no m ab\t t & o!r h]esies ?an a man ( active & p5etrat+ m9d w\ld d]ive f text-books4 ,& ,i ?9k x likely en\gh--n t 8 rev]5ce = ! ,eu*>i/1 b--t 8 special att5tion to ! details ( ,eu*>i/ic doctr9e 0 due to ! consid]ation t x 0 ! f\ndation ( ecclesia/ical discipl9e & au?ority--matt]s on :i* 8 m9d fa/5$ itself ) en?usiasm4 ,,footnotes3 #ah ,i ought to say t ,i 0 n p]sonally acqua9t$ ) ,mr4 ,fr\de4 ,i h subjo9$ to ?is *apt] "s recollections ( him by ,"l ,bla*=d1 :o 0 8 pupil & an intimate fri5d4 #ai ,9 ?is mortal j\rney+ wa/$ %ade ,is worse ?an wa/$ sun%9e4 ,,h5ry ,,taylor1 ,sicilian ,summ]1 v4 #c4 #bj ,rema9s1 ,second ,"p1 i4 #dg4 #ba ,rema9s1 i4 #hb4 #bb ,apologia1 p4 #hd4 #bc ,! foll[+ %[s ! feel+ ab\t him 9 fri5ds apt to be sev]e critics3--,! cont5ts ( ! pres5t collection are r fragm5ts & sket*es ?an complete compositions4 ,?is might be expect$ 9 ! works ( a man ^: days 7 few & int]rupt$ by illness1 if inde$ t may be call$ an int]ruption1 :i* 0 e day s5sibly draw+ him to 8 grave4 ,9 ,mr4 ,fr\de's case1 h[ev]1 we _c set d[n mu* ( ?is incomplet5ess to ! score ( illness4 ,! /r5g? ( 8 religi\s impressions1 ! boldness & cle>ness ( 8 views1 8 long habits ( self-d5ial1 & 8 unconqu]able en]gy ( m9d1 triumph$ ov] weakness & decay1 till m5 ) all _! heal? & /r5g? ab\t !m might gaze ^u 8 att5uat$ =m1 /ruck ) a c]ta9 awe ( wond]m5t at ! brightness ( 8 wit1 ! int5s5ess ( 8 m5tal vision1 & ! iron /r5g? ( 8 argum5t4444 ,we w v5ture a rem>k z to t ironical turn1 :i* c]ta9ly does appe> 9 v>i\s %apes 9 ! fir/ "p ( ^! ,rema9s4 ,unpleasant z irony may sometimes be1 !re ne$ n g ) x1 & 9 ?is in/ance !re did n g ) x1 ! smalle/ real asp]ity ( temp]4 ,:o t rememb]s ! inexpressible sweetness ( 8 smile1 & ! deep & melan*oly pity ) :i* he w\ld speak ( ^? :om he felt to be ! victims ( mod]n delusions1 w\ld n be =w>d to contradict su* a suspicion8 ,su* expressions1 we w v5ture to say1 & n h>%ness1 ang]1 or gloom1 animate ! features ( t c\nt5ance :i* w nev] cease to haunt ! memory ( ^? :o knew him4 ,8 irony arose f t peculi> mode 9 :i* he view$ all e>?ly ?+s1 himself & all t 0 de> to him n except$4 ,x 0 8 poetry4 ,f an article 9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 ,april #ahdj1 p4 #cif1 by ,mr4 ,?omas ,mozley1 quot$ 9 ,lett]s ( ,j4,b4 ,mozley1 p4 #ajb4 #bd ,su* z ! ,daniel 9 ! ,lyra ,apo/olica1 ! ,dialogue betwe5 ,old ,self & ,new ,self1 & ! l9es 9 ! ,rema9s 7i #bjh1 #bji74 #be ,a few ref]5ces to ! ,rema9s illu/rat+ ?is are subjo9$ if any "o c>es to comp>e !m ) ^! recollections1 i4 #g1 #ac1 #ah1 #bf1 #ajf1 #ahd1 #aii1 #bjj-bjd4 #bf ,i am indebt$ = ^! recollections to ! late ,"l ,bla*=d4 ,!y 7 writt5 9 ,oct4 #ahhd4 ,,*apt] ,,iv ,,mr4 ,,newman',s ,,e>ly ,,fri5ds--,,isaac ,,williams ,9 ! e>ly days ( ! movem5t1 among ,mr4 ,newman's greate/ fri5ds1 & mu* 9 8 confid5ce1 7 two ,fell[s ( ,tr9ity--a college :i* nev] =got t ,newman _h once belong$ to x1--,isaac ,williams & ,william ,john ,copel&4 ,9 m9d & "* v diff]5t1 !y 7 close fri5ds1 ) ! affection :i* 0 *>act]i/ic ( ^? days2 & = bo? ( !m ,mr4 ,newman _h ! love :i* passes t ( common relation4#bg ,isaac ,williams 0 born among ! m\nta9s ( ,wales1 & _h ! true poetic gift1 ?\gh 8 p[] ( expression 0 (t5 n equal to :at he want$ to say4 ,copel& 0 a ,london]1 br$ up 9 ! /rict s*ool ( ,*ur*man%ip repres5t$ by ,mr4 ,norris ( ,hackney1 temp]$ by sympa?ies ) ! ,non-jurors4 ,at ,ox=d he liv$1 along ) ,isaac ,williams1 9 ! v he>t ( ! movem5t1 :i* 0 ! int]e/ ( 8 life2 b he liv$1 self-=gett+ or self-effac+1 a wond]ful mixture ( t5d] & inexhau/ible sympa?y1 & ( quick & ke5 wit1 :i* yet1 someh[ or o!r1 9 t "t ( exasp]ation & bitt]ness1 made him few enemies4 ,he knew m ?an mo/ m5 ( ! go+s on ( ! movem5t1 & he ought to h be5 its *ronicl]4 ,b he 0 fa/idi\s & h>d to satisfy1 & he left 8 task till x 0 too late4 ,isaac ,williams 0 born 9 ,wales 9 #ahjb1 a ye> aft] ,newman1 t5 ye>s aft] ,john ,keble4 ,8 e>ly life 0 sp5t 9 ,london1 b 8 affection = ,wales & its m\nta9 sc5]y 0 great & undim9i%$ to ! end ( 8 life4 ,at ,h>r[1 :]e ,h5ry ,drury 0 8 tutor1 he made 8 m>k by 8 ma/]y ( ,lat9 composition & 8 devotion to ,lat9 language & lit]ature4 ,i 0 s us$ to ?9k 9 ,lat9 t :5 ,i _h to write an ,engli% !me1 :i* 0 b seldom1 ,i _h to translate my ideas1 :i* ran 9 ,lat91 into ,engli%2#bh & lat] 9 life he compla9$ ( ! ,lat9 curr5t :i* di/urb$ him :5 he _h to write ,engli%4 ,he 0 also a great cricket]2 & he describes himself z com+ up to ,tr9ity1 :]e he soon got a s*ol>%ip1 an ambiti\s & c>eless y\?1 :o _h nev] he>d a ^w ab\t ,*ri/ianity1 & to :om religion1 its aims & its re/ra9ts1 7 a m]e "n4 ,?is 0 *ang$ by :at1 9 ! language ( devotional s*ools1 w\ld h be5 call$ 8 conv]sion4 ,x came ab\t1 z m5 speak1 z ! result ( accid5ts2 b ! :ole c\rse ( 8 ?\ghts & life 0 turn$ into a *annel f :i* x nev]more div]g$4 ,an old ,wel% cl]gyman gave ! und]graduate an introduction to ,john ,keble1 :o !n held a place 9 ,ox=d almo/ unique4 ,b ! ,tr9ity und]graduate & ! ,oriel don saw little ( "o ano!r till ,isaac ,williams won ! ,lat9 prize poem1 ,ars ,geologica4 ,keble !n call$ on ,isaac ,williams & (f]$ 8 help 9 criticis+ ! poem & poli%+ x = pr9t+4 ,! two m5 pla9ly took to "o ano!r at fir/ sight2 & t s]vice 0 foll[$ by a mo/ unexpect$ invitation on ,keble's "p4 ,he _h *anc$ to come to ,williams's room1 & on ,williams say+ t he _h no plan ( read+ = ! approa*+ vacation1 ,keble said1 ,i am go+ to leave ,ox=d = good4 ,suppose y come & read ) me4 ,! ,provo/ has ask$ me to take ,wilb]=ce1 & ,i decl9$2 b if y w\ld come1 y w\ld be companions4 ,keble 0 go+ d[n to ,s\?rop1 a little curacy ne> 8 fa!r's2 !re ,williams jo9$ him1 ) two m--,rob]t ,wilb]=ce & ,r4,h4 ,fr\de2 & !re ! ,long ,vacation ( #ahbc 0 sp5t1 & ,isaac ,williams's "* & c\rse det]m9$4 ,x 0 ?is v trivial accid5t1 ?is %ort walk ( a few y>ds1 & a few words spok51 :i* 0 ! turn+-po9t ( my life4 ,if a m]ciful ,god _h miracul\sly int]pos$ to arre/ my c\rse1 ,i c\ld n h _h a /rong] assurance ( ,8 pres5ce ?an ,i always _h 9 look+ back to t day4 ,x det]m9$ ,isaac ,williams's "*1 & x det]m9$ = good & all 8 !ological position4 ,he _h be=e him all day long 9 ,john ,keble a spectacle :i* 0 absolutely new to him4 ,ambiti\s z a ris+ & successful s*ol> at college1 he saw a man1 look$ up to & wond]$ at by e "o1 absolutely )\t pride & )\t ambition4 ,he saw ! mo/ di/+ui%$ academic ( 8 day1 to :om e prospect 0 op51 retir+ f ,ox=d 9 ! height ( 8 fame to bury himself ) a few hundr$s ( ,gl\ce/]%ire peasants 9 a mis]able curacy4 ,he saw ?is man c>+ = & respect+ ! ignorant & poor z mu* z o!rs respect$ ! great & ! le>n$4 ,he saw ?is man1 :o _h made :at ! _w w\ld call s great a sacrifice1 app>5tly unconsci\s t he _h made any sacrifice at all1 gay1 unc]emoni\s1 bright1 full ( play z a boy1 ready ) 8 pupils = any ex]cise1 m5tal or muscul>--= a h>d ride1 or a crabb$ bit ( ,aes*ylus1 or a logic f5ce ) disputati\s & p>adoxical und]graduates1 giv+ & tak+ on ev5 gr\nd4 ,^! pupils saw "o1 ! dep? ( ^: religion none c\ld d\bt1 always endeav\r+ to d !m good z x 7 unkn[n to !mselves & 9 secret1 & ev] avoid+ t 8 k9dness %\ld be felt & ackn[l$g$2 %[+ 9 ! :ole c\rse ( daily life ! purity ( ,*ri/ian love1 & tak+ ! utmo/ pa9s to make no pr(ession or %[ ( x4 ,?is uno/5tati\s & undemon/rative religion--s frank1 s g5]\s 9 all its ways--0 to ,isaac ,williams q a new _w4 ,x turn$ 8 m9d 9 ^u itself 9 ! deepe/ rev]5ce1 b also ) some?+ ( morbid despair ( ev] rea*+ su* a /&>d4 ,x drove all dreams ( ambition out ( 8 m9d4 ,x made humility1 self-re/ra9t1 self-abasem5t1 objects ( unceas+1 possibly n always wise & heal?y1 ef=t4 ,b ! result 0 c]ta9ly a "* ( great sweetness1 t5d]ness1 & l[ly unselfi%ness1 pure1 free f all worldl9ess1 & deeply resign$ to ! w ( ,god4 ,he caught f ,mr4 ,keble1 l ,fr\de1 two *>act]i/ic habits ( m9d--a /rong depreciation ( m]e intellect comp>$ ) ! less %[y excell5ces ( fai?fulness to consci5ce & duty2 & a horror & hatr$ ( ev]y?+ t seem$ l display or ! desire ( applause or ( imm$iate effect4 ,intellectual depreciators ( intellect may deceive !mselves1 & d n always escape ! sn>e :i* !y fe>2 b 9 ,isaac ,williams !re 0 a v g5u9e c>ry+ out ( ! ,psalmi/'s words3 ,surely ,i h behav$ & quiet$ myself2 ,i refra9 my s\l & keep x l[1 z a *ild t is wean$ f 8 "m4 ,?is fe> ( display 9 a man ( s+ul>ly delicate & fa/idi\s ta/e came to h some?+ =c$ & morbid 9 x4 ,x seem$ sometimes z if 9 prea*+ or talk+ he aim$ at be+ dull & clumsy4 ,b 9 all t he did & wrote he aim$ at be+ true at all co/s & 9 ! v dep?s ( 8 he>t2 & ?\gh1 9 8 words1 we may wi% sometimes = :at we %\ld feel to be m natural & heal?y 9 tone1 we nev] c d\bt t we are 9 ! pres5ce ( "o :o %rank f all consci\s unreality l poison4 ,f ,keble1 or1 x may be said1 f ! ,kebles1 he receiv$ 8 !ology4 ,! ,kebles 7 all ( !m m5 ( ! old-fa%ion$ ,high ,*ur* or?odoxy1 ( ! ,pray] ,book & ! ,cate*ism--! or?odoxy :i* 0 pr(ess$ at ,ox=d1 :i* 0 repres5t$ 9 ,london by ,norris ( ,hackney & ,jo%ua ,watson2 :i* valu$ 9 religion sobriety1 rev]5ce1 & def]5ce to au?ority1 & 9 tea*+1 s\nd le>n+ & ! wisdom ( ! great ,engli% div9es2 :i* vehem5tly dislik$ ! ,evangelicals & ,me?odi/s = _! poor & loose !ology1 _! love ( excitem5t & display1 _! hunt+ aft] popul>ity4 ,?is ,*ur* ( ,engl& div9ity 0 ! !ology ( ! old ,vic> ( ,coln ,/4 ,aldwyn's1 a good s*ol> & a good p>i% prie/1 :o _h br\ght up 8 two sons at home to be s*ol>s2 & _h impress$ 8 solid & manly !ology on !m s /rongly t amid all *anges !y rema9$ at bottom true to _! pat]nal tra9+4 ,john ,keble add$ to x great atta9m5ts & brilliant gifts ( imag9ation & poetry2 b he nev] lo/ ! pla91 d[nright1 almo/ awkw>d ways ( conv]sation & mann] ( 8 simple home--ways :i* might h seem$ abrupt & r\gh b = ! s+ul> sweetness & *>m ( 8 nature4 ,to ^? :o look$ on ! outside he 0 always ! homely1 rigidly or?odox c\ntry cl]gyman4 ,on ,isaac ,williams1 ) 8 e?ical /&>d1 ,john ,keble also impress$ 8 ideas ( religi\s tru?2 he made him an old-fa%ion$ ,high ,*ur*man1 suspici\s ( excitem5t & effect1 suspici\s ( ! l\d-talk+ religi\s _w1 suspici\s ( its novelties & %all[ness1 & cl++ ) 8 :ole s\l to anci5t ways & s\nd ,*ur* ( ,engl& doctr9e reflect$ 9 ! ,pray] ,book4 ,& f ,john ,keble's influ5ce he pass$ "u ! influ5ce ( ,?omas ,keble1 ! ,vic> ( ,bisley1 a man ( /]n] type ?an 8 bro!r1 ) /rong & def9ite op9ions on all subjects2 curt & ke5 9 spee*2 intol]ant ( all t seem$ to ?reat5 :olesome tea*+ & ! int]e/s ( ! ,*ur*2 & equally /raight=w>d1 equally simple1 9 mann]s & life4 ,"u him ,isaac ,williams began 8 c>e] z a cl]gyman2 he sp5t two ye>s ( solit>y & monoton\s life 9 a small cure1 seek+ com=t f solitude 9 poetical composition 7,x 0 v calm & subdu+1 he writes72 & !n he 0 recall$ to ,ox=d z ,fell[ & ,tutor ( 8 college1 to meet a new & /rong] influ5ce1 :i* x 0 "p ( ! "w & trial ( ! re/ ( 8 life bo? to assimilate & to resi/4 ,=1 ) ,newman1 ) :om he n[ came into contact1 he did bo?4 ,!re op5$ to him f int]c\rse ) ,newman a new _w ( ?\ght2 & yet :ile feel+ & answ]+ to its *>m1 he nev] 0 q at ease ) him4 ,b ,williams & ,fr\de _h always be5 great fri5ds s9ce ! read+ p>ty ( #ahbc1 9 spite ( ,fr\de's audacities4 ,fr\de 0 n[ resid+ 9 ,ox=d1 & _h become ,newman's mo/ intimate fri5d1 & he br\ght ,newman & ,williams toge!r4 ,liv+ at t "t1 he says1 s mu* ) ,fr\de1 ,i 0 n[ 9 consequ5ce = ! fir/ "t br\ght into int]c\rse ) ,newman4 ,we almo/ daily walk$ & (t5 d9$ toge!r4 ,newman & ,fr\de _h ceas$ to be tutors2 _! ?\ghts 7 turn$ to !ology & ! condition ( ! ,*ur*4 ,newman _h def9itely brok5 ) ! ,evangelicals1 to :om he _h be5 suppos$ to belong1 & ,:ately's influ5ce ov] him 0 wan+1 & ) ,fr\de he look$ up to ,keble z ! patt]n ( religi\s wisdom4 ,he _h accept$ ! position ( a ,*ur*man z x 0 und]/ood by ,keble & ,fr\de2 & ?us !re 0 no?+ to h9d] ,williams's full sympa?y ) him4 ,b f ! fir/ !re seems to h be5 an almo/ impalpable b> betwe5 !m1 :i* is ! m rem>kable because ,williams appe>s to h se5 ) equanimity ,fr\de's app>5tly m viol5t & dang]\s outbreaks ( p>adox & antipa?y4 ,possibly1 aft] ! cata/rophe1 he may1 9 look+ back1 h exagg]at$ 8 e>ly al>ms4 ,b f ! fir/ he says he saw 9 ,newman :at he _h le>n$ to look ^u z ! grave/ ( dang]s--! prepond]ance ( intellect among ! elem5ts ( "* & z ! guide ( life4 ,i 0 greatly delight$ & *>m$ ) ,newman1 :o 0 extremely k9d to me1 b did n altoge!r tru/ 8 op9ions2 & ?\gh ,fr\de 0 9 ! habit ( /at+ ?+s 9 an extreme & p>adoxical mann]1 yet "o always felt consci\s ( a gr\nd ( entire confid5ce & agreem5t2 b x 0 n s ) ,newman1 ev5 ?\gh "o appe>$ m 9 unison ) 8 m mod]ate views4 ,b1 9 spite ( all ?is1 ,newman (f]$ & ,isaac ,williams accept$ ! curacy ( ,/4 ,m>y's4 ,?+s at ,ox=d #ahcj-cb at t "t 7 v dull4 ,fr\de & ,i seem$ entirely alone1 ) ,newman only secretly1 z x 71 beg9n+ to sympa?ise4 ,i became at once v mu* atta*$ to ,newman1 won by 8 k9dness & delight$ by 8 good & wond]ful qualities2 & he propos$ t ,i %\ld be 8 curate at ,/4 ,m>y's4444 ,i c rememb] a /rong feel+ ( diff]5ce ,i fir/ felt on act+ toge!r ) him f :at ,i _h be5 accu/om$ to3 t he 0 9 ! habit ( look+ = effect1 & = :at 0 s5sibly effective1 :i* f ! ,bisley & ,fair=d ,s*ool ,i _h be5 long habituat$ to avoid2 b to d "o's duty 9 fai? & leave x to ,god1 & t all ! m e>ne/ly1 because !re 7 no sympa?ies f )\t to answ]4 ,!re 0 a felt b unexpress$ diff]5ce ( ?is k9d1 b p]haps x became aft]w>ds h>monis$ z we act$ toge!r4#bi ,?us e>ly1 among ^? mo/ closely unit$1 !re appe>$ ! beg9n+s ( ^? diff]5t curr5ts :i* became s div]g5t z "t w5t on4 ,isaac ,williams1 de> z he 0 to ,newman1 & return+ to ! full ,newman's affection1 yet repres5t$ f ! fir/ ! views ( :at ,williams spoke ( z ! ,bisley & ,fair=d ,s*ool1 :i*1 ?\gh sympa?is+ & co-op]at+ ) ! movem5t1 0 nev] q easy ab\t x1 & 0 n sp>+ ( its criticism on ! /ir & agitation ( ! ,tracts4 ,isaac ,williams ?rew himself he>tily into ! e>ly /ages ( ! movem5t2 9 8 poetry into its imag9ative & poetical side1 & also into its practical & self-d5y+ side4 ,b he w\ld h be5 q cont5t ) its sil5t work+1 & its app>5t want ( visible success4 ,he w\ld h be5 q cont5t ) prea*+ simple homely s]mons on ! obvi\s b h>d duties ( daily life1 & n see+ mu* come ( !m2 ) f9d+ a sl[ abatem5t ( ! self-indulg5t habits ( univ]sity life1 ) keep+ ,fridays1 ) less w9e 9 common room4 ,! ,bisley maxims bade m5 to be v /iff & uncompromis+ 9 _! witness & 9 _! duties1 b to make no %[ & expect no recognition or imm$iate fruit1 & to be sil5t "u miscon/ruction4 ,b 8 0 n a m9d :i* realis$ great possibilities ( *ange 9 ! inh]it$ ways ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,! _s ( *ange1 s ke5ly disc]n$ by ,newman1 z be+ bo? c]ta9 & capable ( be+ turn$ to good acc\nt z well z bad1 to him 0 un9telligible or bad4 ,m reality1 m sev]ity & consi/5cy1 deep] habits ( self-discipl9e on ! accept$ l9es ( ,engli% ,*ur* or?odoxy1 w\ld h satisfi$ him z ! aim ( ! movem5t1 z x und\bt$ly 0 a l>ge "p ( its aim2 ?\gh ) ,fr\de & ,newman x also aim$ at a wid5+ ( ideas1 ( int]e/s & sympa?ies1 beyond :at _h be5 common 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,9 ! hi/ory ( ! movem5t ,isaac ,williams took a =w>d "p 9 two ( its ev5ts1 ) "o ( :i* 8 connexion 0 mo/ natural1 ) ! o!r grotesquely & ludicr\sly incongru\s4 ,! "o 0 ! plan & />t+ ( ! s]ies ( ,pla9 ,s]mons 9 #ahci1 to :i* n only ! ,kebles1 ,williams1 & ,copel& contribut$ _! volumes1 b also ,newman & ,dr4 ,pusey4 ,isaac ,williams has left ! foll[+ acc\nt ( 8 %>e 9 ! "w4 ,x seem$ at ?is "t 7ab\t #ahch-ci7 z if ,ox=d1 f ! /r5g? ( pr9ciple %[n !re 7& an almo/ unanim\s & conc5trat$ en]gy71 0 becom+ a rally+ po9t = ! :ole k+dom3 b ,i wat*$ f ! beg9n+ & saw great] dang]s among ourselves ?an ^? f )\t2 :i* ,i endeav\r$ to obviate by publi%+ ! ,pla9 ,s]mons4 ,pla9 ,s]mons1 by contributors to ! ,tracts = ! ,times1 #a/ ,s]ies1 ,janu>y #ahci4 ,i attempt$ 9 va9 to get ! ,kebles to publi%1 9 ord] to keep pace ) ,newman1 & s ma9ta9 a m practical turn 9 ! movem5t4 ,i rememb] ,c4 ,corni% 7,c4,l4 ,corni%1 ,fell[ & ,tutor ( ,exet]7 com+ to me & say+ z we walk$ 9 ,tr9ity ,g>d5s1 ',p are a little afraid ( be+ c>ri$ away by ,newman's brilliancy2 !y want m ( ! /eady sobriety ( ! ,kebles infus$ into ! movem5t to keep u safe2 we h s mu* sail & want balla/4' ,& ! effect ( ! publication ( ! ,pla9 ,s]mons 0 at ! "t v quiet+4 ,9 fir/ und]tak+ ! ,pla9 ,s]mons1 ,i _h no enc\ragem5t f any "o1 n ev5 f ,john ,keble2 acquiesc5ce 0 all t ,i c\ld ga94 ,b ,i h he>d ,j4,k4 m5tion a say+ ( ,judge ,col]idge1 long be=e ! ,tracts 7 ?\ght (3 ',if y want to propagate y\r op9ions y %\ld l5d y\r s]mons2 ! cl]gy w\ld !n prea* !m1 & adopt y\r op9ions4' ,n[ ?is has be5 ! effect ( ! publication ( ! ,pla9 ,s]mons4 ,isaac ,williams1 if any man1 repres5t$ 9 ! movem5t ! mod]ate & unobtrusive way ( religi\s tea*+4 ,b x 0 8 curi\s fate to be dragg$ into ! front ranks ( ! fray1 & to be s+l$ out z almo/ ! mo/ wick$ & dang]\s ( ! ,tract>ians4 ,he _h ! /range =tune to produce ! fir/ ( ! ,tracts#cj :i* 0 by itself held up to popul> indignation z embody+ all ! mis*ief ( ! s]ies & ! secret aims ( ! movem5t4 ,! ,tract _h ano!r effect4 ,x made ,williams ! object ( ! fir/ great ,tract>ian battle 9 ! ,univ]sity1 ! conte/ = ! ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip3 ! fir/ decisive & op5 trial ( /r5g?1 & ! fir/ ,tract>ian defeat4 ,! conte/1 ev5 m ?an ! result1 di/ress$ him greatly2 & ! c\rse ( ?+s 9 ! movem5t itself aggravat$ 8 di/ress4 ,8 g5]al di/ru/ ( intellectual re/lessness _h n[ pass$ into ! special & too well gr\nd$ fe> t ! movem5t1 9 "s ( its mo/ prom95t repres5tatives1 0 go+ def9itely 9 ! direction ( ,rome4 ,a new g5]ation 0 ris+ into influ5ce1 to :om ! old ,*ur* wat*words & maxims1 ! old ,*ur* habits ( m9d1 ! old ,*ur* convictions1 _h completely lo/ _! =ce1 & 7 become almo/ objects ( dislike & scorn2 & = ?is *ange ,newman's approval & c\nt5ance 7 freely & n v scrupul\sly quot$4 ,williams's relation to him _h long be5 a curi\s mixture ( ! mo/ affectionate atta*m5t & intimacy ) gr[+ di/ru/ & s5se ( div]g5ce4 ,newman 0 n[ giv+ m & m di/9ct w>n+ t he 0 likely to g :]e ,williams c\ld n foll[ him1 & ! pa9 on bo? sides 0 gr[+4 ,b ?+s mov$ fa/1 & at l5g? ! /ra9 broke4 ,! e/rangem5t 0 inevitable2 b bo? *]i%$ ! w>me/ feel+s ( affection1 ev5 ?\gh su* a fri5d%ip _h be5 brok54 ,b ,ox=d became di/a/eful to ,williams1 & he soon aft]w>ds left x = ,bisley & ,/9*combe1 ! liv+ ( 8 bro!r-9-law1 ,sir ,g4 ,prevo/4 ,!re he m>ri$ 7#bb;d ,june #ahdb71 & sp5t ! rema9d] ( 8 life devot+ himself to ! prep>ation ( ^? devotional comm5t>ies1 :i* are /ill s well kn[n4 ,he suff]$ = ! greate/ "p ( 8 life f a di/ress+ & disabl+ *ronic a/hma--f ! "t t he came back to ,ox=d z ,fell[ & ,tutor--& he di$ 9 #ahfe4 ,! old fri5ds met once m %ortly be=e ,isaac ,williams's dea?2 ,newman came to see him1 & at 8 dep>ture ,williams accompani$ him to ! /ation4 ,isaac ,williams wrote a great deal ( poetry1 fir/ dur+ 8 solit>y curacy at ,w9dru%1 & aft]w>ds at ,ox=d4 ,x 0 9 a l[] & sadd] key ?an ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>1 :i* no d\bt fir/ inspir$ x2 x want$ ! ela/icity & fre%ness & v>iety ( ,keble's v]se1 & x 0 (t5 c>eless 9 /ructure & want+ 9 conc5tration4 ,b x 0 ! outp\r+ ( a v beautiful m9d1 deeply impress$ ) ! realities ( failure 9 ! ,*ur* & religion1 z well z 9 human life1 full ( t5d]ness & pa!tic sweetness1 & seek+ a v5t = its feel+s1 & relief = its tr\ble1 9 call+ up be=e itself ! images ( ,god's goodness & k+dom ( :i* nature & ! _w are full4 ,8 poetry is a witness to ! dep? & e>ne/ness & g5u9e delicacy ( :at seem$ h>d & n>r[ 9 ! ,bisley ,s*ool2 !re are passages 9 x :i* are n easily =gott52 b x 0 n /rong en\gh to arre/ ! excitem5t :i* soon set 91 & ) its cont9ual obscurity & its want ( f9i% x nev] _h ! recognition really due to its excell5ce4 ,newman ?\ght x too s(t4 ,x c]ta9ly want$ ! fire & boldness & directness :i* he ?rew into 8 own v]se :5 he wrote2 b s]i\s e>ne/ness & sev]ity ( tone x c]ta9ly did n want4 ,,footnotes3 #bg ,mozley1 ,rem9isc5ces1 i4 #ah4 #bh ,i4 ,williams1 ,,ms4 ,memoir4 #bi ,i4 ,williams1 ,,ms4 ,memoir4 #cj ,! hi/ory ( ?is fam\s ,tract1 ,no4 #hj1 on ,res]ve 9 communicat+ ,religi\s ,k1 belongs to a lat] /age ( ! movem5t4 ,,*apt] ,v ,,*>les ,,m>riott ,*>les ,m>riott 0 a man :o 0 drawn into ! movem5t1 almo/ 9 spite ( himself1 by ! attraction ( ! "* ( ! lead]s1 ! greatness ( its object1 & ! purity & nobl5ess ( ! motives :i* prompt$ x4 ,he 0 naturally a man ( metaphysical m9d1 giv5 almo/ f a *ild to ab/ract & inde$ ab/ruse ?\ght4#ca ,he _h be5 a /ud5t ( ,s4,t4 ,col]idge1 :om ! ,oriel m5 dislik$ z a mi/y ?9k]4 ,he us$ to discuss ,col]idge ) a man little kn[n !n1 b :o ga9$ a high reputation on ! ,cont95t z a fir/-rate ,greek s*ol>1 & became aft]w>ds ,pr(essor ( ,greek 9 ! ,univ]sity ( ,sydney1 ,*>les ,badham4 ,m>riott also appreciat$ ,hampd5 z a philosoph]1 :om ! ,oriel m5 ?or\ghly di/ru/$ z a !ologian4 ,he might easily "u diff]5t conditions h become a div9e ( ! type ( ,f4,d4 ,maurice4 ,he 0 by disposition av]se to any?+ l p>ty1 & ! r\gh & %>p proce$+s :i* p>ty action sometimes seems to make natural4 ,8 temp] 0 em95tly sob]1 cauti\s & conciliatory 9 8 way ( look+ at important que/ions4 ,he 0 a man ) _m fri5ds ( diff]5t sorts & ways1 & ( b\ndless ?\gh undemon/rative sympa?y4 ,8 orig9al t5d5cies w\ld h made him an eclectic1 recognis+ ! /r5g? ( position 9 oppos+ s*ools or !ories1 & welcom+ all t 0 good & high 9 !m4 ,he 0 pr(\ndly & devot$ly religi\s1 )\t %[1 )\t extravagance4 ,8 fa!r1 :o di$ :5 he 0 only f\rte51 _h be5 a di/+ui%$ man 9 8 "t4 ,he 0 a ,*ri/ ,*ur* man1 & "o ( two 9 ! fir/ ( ! ,ox=d ,hon\r li/s 9 #ahjb1 ) ,e4 ,cople/on1 ,h4 ,phillpotts1 & ,s4,p4 ,rigaud = 8 exam9]s4 ,he 0 aft]w>ds tutor to ! ,e>l ( ,dalkei?1 & he became ! fri5d ( ,walt] ,scott1 :o d$icat$ to him ! ,second ,canto ( ,m>mion2 & hav+ ready & graceful poetical tal5t1 he contribut$ sev]al ballads to ! ,m9/relsy ( ! ,scotti% ,bord]1 ,! ,fea/ ( ,spurs1 & ,ar*ie ,arm/rong's ,ai?4 ,he 0 a good prea*]2 8 sympa?ies--( fri5d%ip1 p]haps1 r ?an ( def9ite op9ion--7 ) m5 l ,mr4 ,john ,b[dl] & ! ,?orntons4 ,:ile he liv$ he taught ,*>les ,m>riott himself4 ,aft] 8 dea?1 ,*>les1 a /udi\s boy1 ) ways ( 8 own ( le>n+1 & ?\gh successful & sure 9 8 "w1 v sl[ 9 ! process ( do+ x1 aft] a %ort & disc\rag+ exp]im5t at ,rugby1 w5t to read ) a private tutor till he w5t to ,ox=d4 ,he 0 fir/ at ,exet]1 & !n ga9$ a s*ol>%ip at ,balliol4 ,he ga9$ a ,classical ,fir/ ,class & a ,ma!matical ,second 9 ! ,mi*aelmas ,t]m ( #ahcb1 & ! foll[+ ,ea/] he 0 elect$ ,fell[ at ,oriel4 ,= a man ( 8 p[] & atta9m5ts he 0 z a speak]1 & 9 conv]sation1 surpris+ly awkw>d4 ,he _h a /urdy1 p5etrat+1 t5aci\s1 b emb>rass$ intellect--emb>rass$1 at lea/1 by ! cr[d & range ( jo/l+ ?\ghts1 9 its outw>d processes & manife/ations1 = he ?or\ghly tru/$ its inn] work+s1 & 0 confid5t ( ! accuracy ( ! results1 ev5 :5 helplessly unable to ju/ify !m at ! mom5t4#cb ,9 matt]s ( bus9ess he seem$ at fir/ sight utt]ly unpractical4 ,9 discuss+ ) ke51 rapid1 & exp]i5c$ m5 l ! ,provo/1 ! value ( leases1 or "s "q ( ! managem5t ( ,college prop]ty1 ,m>riott1 :o always took great int]e/ 9 su* inquiries1 frequ5tly ma9ta9$ "s position :i* to ! quick] wits r\nd him seem$ a p>adox or a m>e's ne/4 ,yet x (t5 happ5$ t aft] a dispute1 c>ri$ on ) a brisk fire ( n always respectful objections to ,m>riott's view1 & 9 :i* 8 only advantage 0 ! pati5ce ) :i* he clumsily1 yet surely1 br\ght out ! real po9t ( ! matt]1 ov]look$ by o!rs1 ! debate end$ 9 ! recognition t he _h be5 "r4 ,x 0 (t5 a /range & almo/ di/ress+ sight to see ! difficulty "u :i* he sometimes lab\r$ ( communicat+ 8 ?\ghts1 z a speak] at a meet+1 or z a tea*] to 8 he>]s1 or ev5 9 ! eas9ess ( famili> talk4 ,! com=t 0 t he 0 n really disc\rag$4 ,he 0 wre/l+ ) 8 own refractory faculty ( exposition & spee*2 x may be1 he 0 busy deep] d[n 9 ! recesses & /oreh\ses ( 8 m9d2 b he 0 too mu* tak5 up ) ! ef=t to notice :at p ?\ght ( x1 or ev5 if !y smil$2 & :at he _h to say 0 s g5u9e & v]aci\s1 z an expression ( 8 mean+1 s full ( b5evol5ce1 *>ity1 & g5]osity1 & (t5 s weighty & unexpect$1 t m5 felt x a %ame to ?9k mu* ( ! peculi>ities ( 8 long look ( blank sil5ce1 & ! odd1 clumsy explanations :i* foll[$ x4 ,he 0 a man1 "u an unc\? ext]ior1 ( ! noble/ & mo/ affectionate nature2 mo/ pati5t1 indulg5t1 & hopeful to all 9 :om he took an int]e/1 ev5 :5 !y sorely tri$ 8 k9dness & 8 fai? 9 !m4 ,:]e he lov$ & tru/$ & admir$1 he 0 apt to rate v highly1 sometimes too highly4 ,8 gratitude 0 b\ndless4 ,he 0 "o ( ^? :o delib]ately gave up ! prospect ( dome/ic life1 to :i* he 0 naturally drawn1 = ! sake ( 8 cause4 ,capable ( ab/ract ?\ght beyond mo/ m5 ( 8 "t1 & nev] unwill+ to %>e 8 ?\ghts ) ^? at all dispos$ to v5ture ) him into deep wat]s1 he 0 always ready to conv]se or to discuss on mu* m ord9>y gr\nd4 ,z an und]graduate & a "y ba*elor1 he _h atta9$1 )\t seek+ x1 a position ( almo/ unexampl$ au?ority 9 ! junior ,univ]sity _w t 0 h>dly rea*$ by any "o = _m ye>s at lea/ aft] him4 ,he 0 hopeless z a speak] 9 ! ,union2 b ) all 8 halt+ & bungl+ spee*es1 t democratic & sometimes noisy assembly bore f him ) k9dly amusem5t & real respect :at !y w\ld be> f no "o else1 & he _h an influ5ce 9 its sometimes turbul5t debates :i* seems unacc\ntable4 ,he 0 ! vir pietate gravis4 ,9 a once popul> squib1 occasion$ by "o ( ! fi]ce/ ( ^! debates1 ?is unique position is notic$ & commemorat$-- ' 1 99 99 99 99 99 1 ' 1 1 4#cc ,8 ways & 8 talk 7 su* z to call =? n unfrequ5t mir? among ^? :o mo/ rev]$ him4 ,he w\ld meet y & look y 9 ! face )\t speak+ a ^w4 ,he 0 n )\t hum\r2 b 8 jokes1 c>ri$ (f by a little laugh ( 8 own1 7 apt to be recondite 9 _! mean+ & allusions4 ,) 8 great p[] ( sympa?y1 he yet did n easily div9e o!r m5's light] or subtl] moods1 & odd & sometimes ev5 di/ress+ mi/akes 7 ! consequ5ce4 ,8 heal? 0 weak1 & a *ronic t5d]ness ( ?roat & *e/ made him take precautions :i* sometimes seem$ :imsical2 & 8 well-kn[n figure 9 a black cloak1 ) a black veil ov] 8 college cap1 & a black com=t] r\nd 8 neck1 :i* at "o "t 9 ,ox=d acquir$ 8 "n1 sometimes />tl$ little boys & sleepy college port]s :5 he came on !m sudd5ly at night4 ,) m p[] ?an mo/ m5 ( /&+ alone1 & ( arrang+ 8 obs]vations on life & ! _w 9 ways ( 8 own1 he _h pre-em95tly above all m5 r\nd him1 9 ! highe/ & noble/ =m1 ! _s ( a disciple4 ,l mo/ human ?+s1 disciple%ip has its good & its evil1 its /rong & its poor & dang]\s side2 b x really has1 :at is mu* =gott5 n[1 a good & a /rong side4 ,bo? 9 philosophy & religion1 ! is a di/9ct "*1 & ,*>les ,m>riott 0 an example ( x at its be/4 ,he _h its manly & reasonable humility1 its g5]\s tru/fulness1 its self-=getfulness2 he _h1 too1 ! en?usiasm ( hav+ & recognis+ a great ma/] & tea*]1 & do+ :at he want$ done2 & he le>n$ f ! love ( 8 ma/] to love :at he believ$ tru? /ill m4 ,! "* ( ! disciple does n save a man f difficulties1 f tr\ble & p]plexity2 b x t5ds to save him f idols ( 8 own mak+4 ,x is some?+1 9 ! trials ( life & fai?1 to h ! consci\sness ( kn[+ or hav+ kn[n "s "o great] & bett] & wis] ?an oneself1 ( hav+ felt ! spell ( 8 guidance & example4 ,m>riott's m9d1 quick to see :at 0 real & /rong1 & at once rev]5t to x z soon z he saw x1 came v mu*1 z an und]graduate at ,balliol1 "u ! influ5ce ( a v able & brilliant tutor1 ,mob]ly1 aft]w>ds ,headma/] ( ,w9*e/] & ,bi%op ( ,salisbury2 & to ! la/ 8 def]5ce & affection to 8 old tutor rema9$ unimpair$4 ,b he came "u a /ill m pot5t *>m :5 he mov$ to ,oriel1 & became ! fri5d ( ,mr4 ,newman4 ,ma/] & disciple 7 z unlike z any two m5 c\ld be2 !y 7 unit$ by _! sympa?y 9 ! great crisis r\nd !m1 by _! absorb+ devotion to ! cause ( true religion4 ,m>riott br\ght to ! movem5t1 & especially to its *ief1 a great ,univ]sity "*1 & an unsw]v+ & t\*+ fidelity4 ,he plac$ himself1 8 life1 & all t he c\ld d1 at ! s]vice ( ! great ef=t to elevate & animate ! ,*ur*2 to ! la/ he w\ld gladly h done s "u him :om he fir/ ackn[l$g$ z 8 ma/]4 ,?is 0 n to be2 & he transf]r$ 8 allegiance1 z unres]v$ly1 ) equal loyalty & self-sacrifice1 to 8 successor4 ,b to ! end1 :ile 8 p[]s la/$1 ) all 8 great gifts & atta9m5ts1 ) e temptation to an indep5d5t position & self-*os5 employm5t1 he cont9u$ a disciple4 ,he believ$ 9 m5 wis] ?an himself2 he occupi$ himself ) :at !y ?\ght be/ = him to d4 ,?is "w 01 = ! mo/ "p1 9 :at 0 done to raise ! /&>d ( k ( e>ly ,*ri/ian lit]ature1 & to make t k accurate & s*ol>like4 ,he 01 = a "t1 ! ,pr9cipal ( ! ,!ological ,college at ,*i*e/]1 "u ,bi%op ,ott]4 ,he 0 also = a "t ,tutor at ,oriel1 & lat]1 ,vic> ( ,/4 ,m>y's4 ,he 0 long b5t on sett+ on foot "s k9d ( ,hall = poor /ud5ts2 & he took ov] f ,mr4 ,newman ! build+s at ,littlemore1 :i* he turn$ into a place = pr9t+ religi\s works4 ,b ?\gh he 0 connect$ m or less closely ) numb]less s*emes ( ,*ri/ian "w 9 ,ox=d & out ( x1 8 special "w 0 t ( a !ological /ud5t4 ,m>riott _h mu* to d ) ! ,libr>y ( ! ,fa!rs1 ) correct+ translations1 collat+ manuscripts1 edit+ texts4#cd ,someh[1 ! mo/ int]e/+ portions h>dly came to 8 %>e2 & :at he did 9 ! way ( orig9al writ+1 little z x 01 causes regret t s mu* ( 8 "t 0 sp5t on ! drudg]y ( edit+4 ,"s s]mons1 a little volume ( ,?\ghts on ,private ,devotion1 & ano!r on ! ,epi/le to ! ,romans1 are ne>ly all t he has left ( 8 own4 ,novelty ( mann] or ?\ght 9 !m !re is none1 /ill less any?+ brilliant or %>p 9 obs]vation or /yle2 b !re is an undef9able s5se1 9 _! calm1 sev]e pages1 ( a deep & s]i\s m9d dwell+ on deep & v s]i\s ?+s4 ,x is impossible n to wi% t a man :o c\ld s write & impress p might h _h ! leisure to write m4 ,b ,m>riott nev] _h any leisure4 ,x has be5 said above t he plac$ himself at ! s]vice ( ^? :om he c\nt$ 8 tea*]s4 ,b ! tru? is t he 0 at e "o's s]vice :o want$ or :o ask$ 8 help4 ,he _h a l>ge1 & :at mu/ h be5 (t5 a burd5some1 correspond5ce4 ,) pupils or fri5ds he 0 always ready = "s extra bit ( read+4 ,to /rang]s he 0 always ready to %[ att5tion & hospitality1 ?\gh ,m>riott's p>ties 7 z qua9t z himself4 ,8 breakfa/ p>ties 9 8 own room 7 ?+s to h se5--a cr[d ( und]graduates1 f9d+ _! way ) difficulty amid lanes & piles ( books1 amid a sc>city ( *airs & room1 & ! ho/1 p]fectly unconsci\s ( any?+ grotesque1 sitt+ sil5t dur+ ! :ole ( ! meal1 b p]fectly happy1 at ! head ( ! table4 ,b !re 0 no claimant on 8 purse or 8 int]e/ :o 0 too /range = 8 sympa?y--raw fre%m51 bores ( e k9d1 brok5-d[n tradesm51 old wom51 di/ress$ =eign]s1 conv]t$ ,jews1 all ! odd & helpless w&]]s f beat5 ways1 7 to be he>d ( at ,m>riott's rooms2 & all1 m or less1 _h a %>e ( 8 "t & ?\ghts1 & p]haps c\nsel4 ,he 0 s5sible ( worry z he grew old]2 b he nev] relax$ 8 ef=ts to d :at any "o ask$ ( him4 ,!re mu/ be ev5 n[ "s /ill liv+ :o "k :at no "o else kn[s1 h[ mu* !y owe1 ) no direct claim on him1 to ,*>les ,m>riott's inexhau/ible pati5ce & *>ity4 ,! pa9s :i* he w\ld take ) ev5 ! mo/ uncong5ial & unpromis+ m51 :o someh[ _h come 9 8 way1 & seem$ ?r[n on 8 *>ge1 ! pati5ce ) :i* he w\ld be> & condone _! follies & ev5 worse1 7 n to be told1 =1 inde$1 few knew :at !y 74 ,he 0 always ready to be ! fri5d ( any "o ^: conduct gave pro(s ( high pr9ciple1 h[ev] inf]ior to himself 9 k or acquirem5ts1 & 8 fri5d%ip once ga9$ 0 n easily lo/4 ,i believe !re 0 no?+ 9 8 p[] :i* he 0 n ready to d = a fri5d :o want$ 8 help4 ,x is n easy to /ate in/ances ( su* k9dness )\t reveal+ :at = _m reasons _h bett] be left untold4 ,b _m su* h come to my k1 & ,i believe !re are _m m kn[n only to himself & to ^? :o d]iv$ b5efit f 8 dis9t]e/$ fri5d%ip4#ce ,m>riott's great contribution to ! movem5t 0 8 solid1 simple goodness1 8 immovable hope1 8 confid5ce t ?+s w\ld come "r4 ,) mu* imag9ativ5ess op5 to poetical gr&eur & *>m1 & n )\t "s p[] ( giv+ expression to feel+1 he 0 de/itute ( all t made s _m o!rs ( 8 fri5ds int]e/+ z m54 ,he 0 no?+1 z a p]son to "k & obs]ve1 to ! g5ius ( ! two ,mozleys1 to ! brilliant social *>m ( ,fr$]ic ,fab]1 to ! ke51 ref9$ intellig5ce ( ,m>k ,pattison1 to ! orig9ality & clev] ecc5tricity ( ,william ,palm] ( ,magdal54 ,& he 0 no?+ z a man ( practical p[] = organis+ & c>ry+ out successful s*emes3 su* p[] 0 n mu* f\nd at ,ox=d 9 ^? days4 ,b 8 fai? 9 8 cause1 z ! cause ( goodness & tru?1 0 pro( aga9/ mock]y or suspicion or disa/]4 ,:5 om9\s signs di/urb$ o!r p he saw none4 ,he _h an almo/ p]v]se subtlety ( m9d :i* put a fav\rable int]pretation on :at seem$ mo/ =midable4 ,z 8 ma/] drew m & m out ( sympa?y ) ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ,m>riott1 resolutely loyal to x & to him1 refus$ to und]/& h9ts & indications :i* to o!rs 7 b too pla94 ,he vex$ & ev5 provok$ ,newman1 9 ! la/ agonies ( ! /ruggle1 by ! optimism ) :i* he clung to useless !ories & impossible hopes4 ,= t unqu5*able hop+ aga9/ hope1 & hope unabat$ /ill :5 ! cata/rophe _h come1 ! ,engli% ,*ur* at lea/ owes him deep gratitude4 ,?r\gh\t ^? anxi\s ye>s he nev] despair$ ( h]4 ,all ?r\gh 8 life he 0 a beacon & an incitem5t to ^? :o wi%$ to make a good use ( _! lives4 ,9 him all m5 c\ld see1 :atev] _! op9ions & h[ev] little !y lik$ him1 ! simplicity & ! tru? ( a self-d5y+ life ( suff]+--= he 0 nev] well--( zeal\s h>d "w1 un/9t$1 unrecomp5s$2 ( unabat$ l(ty hopes = ! great int]e/s ( ! ,*ur* & ! ,univ]sity2 ( deep unpret5d+ matt]-(-c\rse godl9ess & goodness--)\t =m or comel9ess to attract any b ^? :o c>$ = !m1 = !mselves alone4 ,x is almo/ a sacr$ duty to ^? :o rememb] "o :o c>$ no?+ = 8 own "n or fame to recall :at is ! tru?--t no "o did m to p]suade ^? r\nd him ( ! solid und]gr\nd religi\s reality ( ! movem5t4 ,mr4 ,?omas ,mozley1 among o!r g5]\s notices ( m5 :om ! _w & _! contempor>ies h =gott51 has said :at is n m ?an ju/ice4#cf ,speak+ ( ! en?usiasm ( ! movem5t1 & ! _s ( its memb]s1 ,!re _h nev] be5 se5 at ,ox=d1 inde$ seldom any:]e1 s l>ge & noble a sacrifice ( ! mo/ preci\s gifts & p[]s to a sacr$ cause1 he po9ts out :at ea* ( ! lead]s gave to x3 ,*>les ,m>riott ?rew 9 8 s*ol>%ip & some?+ m1 = he might h be5 a philosoph]1 & he _h poetry 9 8 ve9s1 be+ ! son ( ! well-kn[n au?or ( ! ',devon%ire ,lane4' ,no "o sacrific$ himself s entirely to ! cause1 giv+ to x all t he _h & all t he 01 z ,*>les ,m>riott4 ,he did n ga!r l>ge congregations2 he did n write works ( g5ius to spread 8 "n ov] ! l&1 & to all "t2 he _h few ( ! pleasures or ev5 ( ! com=ts t spontane\sly (f] !mselves 9 any field ( ent]prise4 ,he lab\r$ day & night 9 ! se>* & def5ce ( ,div9e ,tru?4 ,8 admir]s 7 n ! ?\s&s1 b ! s*ol>s :o c\ld really appreciate4 ,i confess to h be5 a little a%am$ ( myself :5 ,bi%op ,burgess ask$ me ab\t ,*>les ,m>riott1 z "o ( ! mo/ em95t s*ol>s ( ! day4 ,?r\gh %e] ignorance ,i _h fail$ 9 adequate appreciation4 ,9 8 lat] ye>s he became a memb] ( ! new ,hebdomadal ,c\ncil at ,ox=d1 & took consid]able "p 9 work+ ! new con/itution ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,9 an epidemic ( smallpox at ,ox=d 9 #ahed1 he took 8 full %>e 9 look+ aft] ! sick1 & caught ! disord]2 b he recov]$4 ,at l5g?1 9 ! mid/ ( tr\blesome "w & _m anxieties1 8 life ( toil 0 arre/$ by a sev]e p>alytic seizure1 #bi? ,june #ahee4 ,he p>tially ralli$1 & surviv$ = "s "t long]2 b 8 lab\rs 7 end$4 ,he di$ at ,bradfield1 #be? ,septemb] #aheh4 ,he 0 worn out by v>iety & pressure ( un9t]mitt$ lab\r1 :i* he w\ld sc>cely all[ any *ange or holiday to relieve4 ,exhau/ion made illness1 :5 x came1 fatal4 ,,footnotes3 #ca ,he told me1 writes a relative1 t que/ions ab\t trade us$ to occupy him v e>ly 9 life4 ,he us$ to pond] h[ x c\ld be "r to sell ?+s = m ?an !y co/ y4 #cb ,he _h 8 own way ( do+ ev]y?+1 & us$ mo/ /\tly to prote/ t x 0 q impossible t he %\ld d x 9 any o!r4--,,ms4 ,memoir by 8 bro!r1 ,john ,m>riott4 #cc ,unioma*ia1 #ahcc4 #cd ,?is became ! ma9 task ( 8 life u long z heal? 0 cont9u$ to him4 ,all :o knew him well w rememb] h[ labori\sly he work$ at x1 & h[1 9 "o %ape or ano!r1 x 0 always on h&4 ,ei!r he 0 translat+1 or correct+ ! translation ( o!rs2 or he 0 collat+ ,,mss41 or correct+ ! press4 ,?is la/ "w 0 c>ri$ on at all times & :]ev] he 0--on a j\rney1 aft] d9n]--ev5 9 a boat1 he w\ld pull out a %eet & g to write ^u x 9 ha/e to get x f9i%$ = ! next po/4 ,! numb] ( volumes 9 ! ,libr>y ( ! ,fa!rs :i* be> ! signature ,c4,m4 atte/ 8 dilig5ce4--,john ,m>riott's ,memoir ( him 7,,ms47 #ce ,j4,m41 ,,ms4 ,memoir4 #cf ,rem4 i4 #ddg4 ,,*apt] ,,vi ,,! ,,ox=d ,,tracts ,on #ad? ,july #ahcc1 we read 9 ,c>d9al ,newman's ,apologia1 ,mr4 ,keble prea*$ ! assize s]mon 9 ! ,univ]sity ,pulpit4 ,x 0 publi%$ "u ! title ( ,national ,apo/asy4 ,i h ev] consid]$ & kept ! day z ! />t ( ! religi\s movem5t ( #ahcc4cg ,?is memorable s]mon 0 a /rong expression ( ! belief common to a l>ge body ( ,*ur*m5 amid ! triumphs ( ! ,re=m ,bill1 t ! new gov]nors ( ! c\ntry 7 prep>+ to invade ! rights1 & to alt] ! con/itution1 & ev5 ! public docum5ts1 ( ! ,*ur*4 ,! suppression ( t5 ,iri% ,bi%oprics1 9 defiance ( ,*ur* op9ion1 %[$ h[ ready ! ,gov]nm5t 0 to take lib]ties 9 a high-h&$ way ) ! old adju/m5ts ( ! relations ( ,*ur* & ,/ate4 ,*ur*m5 _h hi!rto tak5 = grant$ t ,engl& 0 a nation :i* _h = c5turies ackn[l$g$1 z an ess5tial "p ( its !ory ( gov]nm5t1 t1 z a ,*ri/ian nation1 %e is also a "p ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur*1 & b\nd1 9 all h] legislation & policy1 by ! fundam5tal laws ( t ,*ur*4 ,:5 a ,gov]nm5t & p1 s con/itut$1 ?rew (f ! re/ra9t :i* 9 _m respects su* a pr9ciple w\ld impose ^u !m1 nay1 disav[$ ! pr9ciple itself1 ?is1 to ^? ^: ideas ,mr4 ,keble repres5t$1 seem$ no?+ %ort ( a direct disav[al ( ! sov]eignty ( ,god4 ,if x be true any:]e t su* enactm5ts are =c$ on ! legislature by public op9ion1 is ,apo/asy too h>d a ^w to describe ! temp] ( su* a nation8 ,! s]mon 0 a call to face 9 e>ne/ a *ang$ /ate ( ?+s1 full ( imm$iate & press+ dang]2 to consid] h[ x 0 to be met by ,*ri/ians & ,*ur*m51 & to wat* motives & temp]s4 ,surely x w be no unwor?y pr9ciple if any man is m circumspect 9 8 behavi\r1 m wat*ful & fe>ful ( himself1 m e>ne/ 9 8 petitions = spiritual aid1 f a dread ( disp>ag+ ! holy "n ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* 9 h] h\r ( p]il by 8 own p]sonal fault & neglig5ce4 ,z to ^? :o1 ei!r by /ation or temp]1 feel !mselves m deeply int]e/$1 !y _c be too c>eful 9 rem9d+ !mselves t "o *ief dang] 9 times ( *ange & excitem5t arises f _! t5d5cy to engross ! :ole m9d4 ,public conc]ns1 ecclesia/ical or civil1 w prove inde$ ru9\s to ^? :o p]mit !m to occupy all _! c>e & ?\ght1 neglect+ or und]valu+ ord9>y duties1 m especially ^? ( a devotional k9d4 ,^! cautions be+ duly obs]v$1 ,i d n see h[ any p]son c devote himself too entirely to ! cause ( ! ,apo/olic ,*ur* 9 ^! realms4 ,!re may be1 z f> z he kn[s1 b a v few to sympa?ise ) him4 ,he may h to wait long1 & v likely pass out ( ?is _w1 be=e he see any abatem5t 9 ! triumph ( disord] & irreligion4 ,b1 if he be consi/5t1 he possesses to ! utmo/ ! p]sonal consolations ( a good ,*ri/ian2 & z a true ,*ur*man1 he has ! enc\ragem5t :i* no o!r cause 9 ! _w c imp>t 9 ! same degree3 he is calmly1 sob]ly1 demon/rably sure t1 soon] or lat]1 8 w be ! w9n+ side1 & t ! victory w be complete1 univ]sal1 et]nal4 ,b if ,mr4 ,keble's s]mon 0 ! fir/ ^w ( ! movem5t1 its fir/ /ep 0 tak5 9 a small meet+ ( fri5ds1 at ,mr4 ,hugh ,james ,rose's p>sonage at ,hadleigh1 9 ,suffolk1 betwe5 ! #be? & ! #bi? ( ! same ,july4 ,at ?is little ga!r+1 ! ideas & anxieties :i* = "s "t pa/ _h fill$ ! ?\ghts ( a numb] ( e>ne/ ,*ur*m51 & _h br\ght !m into communication ) "o ano!r1 came to a head1 & issu$ 9 ! det]m9ation to move4 ,mr4 ,rose1 a man ( high "* & di/9ction 9 8 day1 :o _h rec5tly />t$ ! ,briti% ,magaz9e1 z an organ ( ,*ur* tea*+ & op9ion1 0 ! natural p]son to br+ ab\t su* a meet+4#ch ,x 0 arrang$ t a few repres5tative m51 or z _m z 7 able1 %\ld meet t[>ds ! end ( ,july at ,hadleigh ,rectory4 ,!y 7 m5 9 full agreem5t on ! ma9 que/ions1 b ) great diff]5ces 9 temp]am5t & habits ( ?\ght4 ,mr4 ,rose 0 ! p]son ( mo/ au?ority1 & next to him1 ,mr4 ,palm]2 & ^!1 ) ,mr4 ,a4 ,p]ceval1 =m$ z x 7 ! "r w+ ( ! little c\ncil4 ,_! ,ox=d allies 7 ! ?ree ,oriel m51 ,mr4 ,keble1 ,mr4 ,fr\de1 & ,mr4 ,newman1 n[ fre% f 8 escape f dea? 9 a =eign l&1 & f ! long solit>y mus+s 9 8 ,m$it]ranean orange-boat1 full ( joyful vig\r & ready = ent]prise & "w4#ci ,9 ! result1 ,mr4 ,keble & ,mr4 ,newman 7 n pres5t1 b !y 7 9 active correspond5ce ) ! o!rs4#dj ,f ?is meet+ result$ ! ,tracts = ! ,times1 & ! agitation connect$ ) !m4 ,^! fri5ds 7 all devot$ ,*ur*m51 b1 z has be5 said1 ea* _h 8 m>k$ "*1 n only z a man b z a ,*ur*man4 ,! mo/ important among !m 0 z yet ! lea/ prom95t4 ,two ( !m 7 m5 ( le>n+1 acqua9t$ ) ! great _w ( ,london1 & :o1 ) all _! zeal1 _h "s ( ! caution :i* comes ( su* exp]i5ce4 ,at ! "t1 ! mo/ conspicu\s 0 ,mr4 ,hugh ,james ,rose4 ,mr4 ,rose 0 a man ^: "n & ^: influ5ce1 z 8 fri5ds ?\ght1 h be5 ov]%ad[$ & ov]look$ 9 ! popul> view ( ! ,*ur* revival4 ,x ow$ to him1 !y held1 n only its fir/ impulse1 b all t 0 be/ & mo/ hopeful 9 x2 & :5 x lo/ him1 x lo/ its wise/ & able/ guide & inspir]4 ,x is c]ta9ly true t :5 t revival began he 0 a mu* m di/+ui%$ & important p]son ?an any ( ! o!r p]sons int]e/$ 9 x4 ,z f> z c\ld be se5 at ! "t1 he 0 ! mo/ accompli%$ div9e & tea*] 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,he 0 a really le>n$ man4 ,he _h ! intellect & en]gy & lit]>y skill to use 8 le>n+4 ,he 0 a man ( s+ul>ly elevat$ & religi\s "*2 he _h some?+ ( ! eye & temp] ( a /atesman1 & he _h already a high position4 ,he 0 pr(\ndly loyal to ! ,*ur*1 & ke5ly int]e/$ 9 :atev] affect$ its condition & its =tunes4 ,z e>ly z #ahbe he _h 9 "s lectures at ,cambridge call$ ! att5tion ( ,engli% ,*ur*m5 to ! /ate ( religi\s ?\ght & speculation 9 ,g]many1 & to ! mis*iefs likely to react on ,engli% !ology f ! rationalis+ temp] & me?ods :i* _h supplant$ ! old ,lu!ran tea*+2 & ?is _h l$ to a %>p controv]sy ) ,mr4 ,pusey1 z he 0 !n1 :o ?\ght t ,mr4 ,rose#da _h bo? exagg]at$ ! fact itself & _h n adequately giv5 ! hi/orical acc\nt ( x4 ,he _h ! prud5ce1 b n ! backw>dness1 ( a man ( l>ge k1 & consid]able exp]i5ce ( ! _w4 ,m alive to difficulties & dang]s ?an 8 y\ng] associates1 he %[$ 8 c\rage & 8 unselfi% e>ne/ness 9 8 frank sympa?y ) !m1 d>+ & outspok5 z !y 71 & 9 8 will+ness to %>e ) !m ! risks ( an und]tak+ ( :i* no "o knew bett] ?an he :at 7 likely to be ! difficulties4 ,he c]ta9ly 0 a p]son :o might be expect$ to h a *ief "p 9 direct+ any?+ ) :i* he 0 connect$4 ,8 c\nt5ance & 8 indirect influ5ce 7 v important elem5ts1 bo? 9 ! /irr+ ( ?\ght :i* l$ to ! ,hadleigh resolutions1 & 9 giv+ its =m to :at 0 !n decid$ ^u4 ,b 8 action 9 ! movem5t 0 imp$$ by 8 failure 9 heal?1 & cut %ort by 8 e>ly dea?1 ,janu>y #ahci4 ,h[ he w\ld h influ5c$ ! c\rse ( ?+s if he _h liv$1 x is n n[ easy to say4 ,he mu/ h be5 reckon$ ) z "o ( ! *iefs4 ,he w\ld h be5 oppos$ to any?+ t really t5d$ t[>ds ,rome4 ,b !re is no reason to ?9k t he w\ld h %runk f any /ep only because x 0 bold4 ,he _h sympa?y = c\rage & g5ius1 & he _h k & au?ority :i* w\ld h comm&$ respect = 8 judgm5t & op9ion4 ,b x is too mu* to say ei!r t ! movem5t c\ld n h be5 )\t him1 or t x 0 specially 8 design & plan1 or t he alone c\ld h giv5 ! impulse :i* l$ to x2 ?\gh x seem$ at "o "t z if he 0 to be its lead] & *ief4 ,c]ta9ly he 0 ! mo/ valuable & ! mo/ loyal ( its e>ly auxili>ies4 ,ano!r coadjutor1 ^: "p at ! "t also seem$ r t ( a *ief1 0 ,mr4 ,william ,palm]1 ( ,worce/] ,college4 ,he _h be5 educat$ at ,tr9ity ,college1 ,dubl91 b he _h transf]r$ 8 home to ,ox=d1 bo? 9 ! ,univ]sity & ! city4 ,he 0 a man ( exact & s*ola/ic m9d1 well equipp$ at all po9ts 9 controv]sial !ology1 /rong 9 cle> !ories & precise def9itions1 famili> ) objections curr5t 9 ! s*ools & ) ! answ]s to !m1 & well v]s$ 9 all ! que/ions1 argum5ts1 & au?orities belong+ to ! great debate ) ,rome4 ,he _h def9ite & well-arrang$ ideas ab\t ! nature & (fice ( ! ,*ur*2 &1 f 8 /udy ( ! ,roman controv]sy1 he _h at comm& ! di/9ctions necess>y to discrim9ate betwe5 ?+s :i* popul> views confus$1 & to protect ! doctr9es *>act]i/ic ( ! ,*ur* f be+ id5tifi$ ) ,romanism4 ,especially he _h giv5 great att5tion to ! public devotional language & =ms ( ! ,*ur*1 & _h produc$ by f> ! be/ book 9 ! ,engli% language on ! hi/ory & significance ( ! (fices ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*--! ,orig9es ,liturgicae1 publi%$ at ! ,univ]sity ,press 9 #ahcb4 ,x 0 a book to give a man au?ority ) div9es & s*ol>s2 & among ^? ) :om at ?is "t he act$ no "o _h s compact & def5sible a !ory1 ev5 if x 0 some:at rigid & te*nical1 ( ! peculi> con/itution ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* z ,mr4 ,palm]4 ,) ! deepe/ belief 9 ?is !ory1 he saw great dang]s ?reat5+1 p>tly f g5]al ignorance & loos5ess ( ?\ght1 p>tly f antagoni/ic ideas & pr9ciples only too di/9ct & too popul>2 & he ?rew all 8 le>n+ & zeal on ! side ( ^? :o1 l himself1 7 alive to ^? dang]s1 & 7 prep>$ = a great ef=t to c\nt]act !m4 ,! little company :i* met at ,hadleigh ,rectory1 f #be? to #bi? ,july #ahcc1 met--z o!r knots ( m5 h (t5 met1 to discuss a "q or a policy1 or to f\nd an association1 or a league1 or a newspap]--to lay d[n ! outl9es ( "s practical s*eme ( "w2 b ) little =esight ( ! v5ture !y 7 mak+1 or ( ! mom5t\s issues :i* dep5d$ on _! meet+4 ,lat] on1 :5 controv]sy began1 x became a fav\rite rhetorical device to call x by ! ugly "n ( a conspiracy4 ,c]ta9ly ,fr\de call$ x s1 & ,mr4 ,palm]2 & ,mr4 ,p]ceval wrote a n>rative to answ] ! *>ge4 ,x 0 a conspiracy1 z any o!r meet+ w\ld be ( m5 ) an object :i* o!r m5 dislike4 ,( ! ,oriel m51 only ,fr\de w5t to ,hadleigh4 ,keble & ,newman 7 bo? abs5t1 b 9 close correspond5ce ) ! o!rs4 ,_! plans _h n tak5 any def9ite %ape2 b !y 7 ready = any sacrifice & s]vice1 & !y 7 fill$ ) wra? aga9/ ! insol5ce ( ^? :o ?\ght t ! ,*ur* 0 giv5 ov] into _! h&s1 & aga9/ ! apa?y & c[>dice ( ^? :o let h] enemies h _! way4 ,yet ) mu* impati5ce & _m /]n det]m9ations 9 _! he>ts1 !y 7 all ( !m m5 to be sway$ by ! judgm5t & exp]i5ce ( _! fri5ds4 ,! /ate ( m9d "u :i* ! f\r fri5ds met at ! ,hadleigh conf]5ce has be5 v di/9ctly & delib]ately record$ by all ( !m4 ,*ur*m5 9 our days h>dly realise :at ! face ( ?+s !n look$ l to m5 :o1 if !y felt deeply1 7 no m]e fanatics or al>mi/s1 b sob] & sagaci\s obs]v]s1 n affect$ by m]e cries1 b see+ de>ly b5ea? ! surface ( ?+s _! c]ta9 & p[]ful t5d5cies4 ,we felt ourselves1 writes ,mr4 ,palm] "s ye>s aft]w>ds1#db assail$ by enemies f )\t & foes )94 ,our ,prelates insult$ & ?reat5$ by ,m9i/]s ( ,/ate4 ,9 ,irel& t5 bi%oprics suppress$4 ,we 7 advis$ to feel ?ankful t a m sweep+ measure _h n be5 adopt$4 ,:at 0 to come next8444 ,0 ! same pr9ciple ( concession to popul> clam\r 444 to be exemplifi$ 9 ! dismemb]m5t ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*8444 ,we 7 ov]:elm$ ) pamphlets on ,*ur* re=m4 ,"l ,h5ley1 bro!r-9-law ( ,sir ,rob]t ,peel1 ,dr4 ,burton1 & o!rs ( "n & influ5ce l$ ! way4 ,dr4 ,arnold ( ,rugby v5tur$ to propose t all sects %\ld be unit$ by ,act ( ,p>liam5t ) ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,reports1 app>5tly well f\nd$1 7 preval5t t "s ( ! ,prelates 7 fav\rable to alt]ations 9 ! ,liturgy4 ,pamphlets 7 9 wide circulation recomm5d+ ! abolition ( ! ,cre$s 7at lea/ 9 public wor%ip71 especially urg+ ! expulsion ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$2 ! removal ( all m5tion ( ! ,bless$ ,tr9ity2 ( ! doctr9e ( baptismal reg5]ation2 ( ! practice ( absolution4 ,we knew n to :at qu>t] to look = support4 ,a ,prelacy ?reat5$ & app>5tly intimidat$2 a ,gov]nm5t mak+ its p[] subs]vi5t to agitators1 :o av[$ly s\ght ! de/ruction ( ! ,*ur* 444 ,&1 wor/ ( all1 no pr9ciple 9 ! public m9d to :i* we c\ld appeal2 an utt] ignorance ( all rational gr\nds ( atta*m5t to ! ,*ur*2 an oblivion ( its spiritual "*1 z an in/itution n ( man b ( ,god2 ! grosse/ ,era/ianism mo/ widely preval5t1 especially among/ all classes ( politicians4 ,!re 0 9 all ?is en\gh to appal ! /\te/ he>t2 & ^? :o c recall ! feel+ ( ^? days w at once rememb] ! deep depression into :i* ! ,*ur* _h fall51 & ! gloomy =ebod+s univ]sally preval5t4 ,be=e ! _s & temp] ( ^? :o met at ! conf]5ce is condemn$ z extravagant1 writes ,mr4 ,p]ceval 9 #ahdb1dc let ! read] call to m9d :at 0 !n actually ! condition z well z ! prospect ( ! ,*ur* & nation3 an agr>ian & civic insurrection aga9/ ! bi%ops & cl]gy1 & all :o desir$ to adh]e to ! exi/+ in/itutions ( ! c\ntry2 ! populace goad$ on1 op5ly by ! spee*es1 cov]tly 7z 0 fully believ$ at ! "t7 by ! paid emiss>ies ( ! m9i/]s ( ! ,cr[n2 ! *ief ( ^? m9i/]s 9 8 place 9 ,p>liam5t bidd+ ! bi%ops 'set _! h\se 9 ord]'2 ! mob tak+ him at 8 ^w1 & burn+ to ! gr\nd ! palace ( ! ,bi%op ( ,bri/ol1 ) ! public build+s ( ! city1 :ile !y %\t$ ! ,premi]'s "n 9 triumph on ! ru9s4 ,! press+ imm95ce ( ! dang] is tak5 = grant$ by ! calme/ & mo/ cauti\s ( ! p>ty1 ,mr4 ,rose1 9 a lett] ( ,febru>y #ahcc4 ,t some?+ is requisite1 is c]ta94 ,! only ?+ is1 t :atev] is done ought to be quickly done1 = ! dang] is imm$iate1 & ,i %\ld h little fe> if ,i ?\ght t we c\ld /& = t5 or fifte5 ye>s z we are4#dd ,9 ! ,apologia ,c>d9al ,newman recalls :at 0 be=e him 9 ^? days4 ,! ,:igs _h come into p[]2 ,"l ,grey _h told ! bi%ops to 'set _! h\se 9 ord]1' & "s ( ! prelates _h be5 insult$ & ?reat5$ 9 ! /reets ( ,london4 ,! vital "q 04 ,h[ 7 we to keep ! ,*ur* f be+ ,lib]alis$8 ,!re 0 s mu* apa?y on ! subject 9 "s qu>t]s1 su* imbecile al>m 9 o!rs2 ! true pr9ciples ( ,*ur*man%ip seem$ s radically decay$1 & !re 0 su* di/raction 9 ! c\ncils ( ! cl]gy4 ,! ,bi%op ( ,london ( ! day1 an active & op5-he>t$ man1 _h be5 = ye>s engag$ 9 dilut+ ! high or?odoxy ( ! ,*ur* by ! introduction ( ! ,evangelical body into places ( influ5ce & tru/4 ,he _h deeply (f5d$ m5 :o agre$ ) myself by an (f-h& say+ 7z x 0 report$7 to ! effect t belief 9 ! apo/olical succession _h gone out ) ! ,non-jurors4 ',we c c\nt y1' he said to "s ( ! grave/ & mo/ v5]at$ p]sons ( ! old s*ool4444 ,i felt affection = my own ,*ur*1 b n t5d]ness3 ,i felt dismay at h] prospects1 ang] & scorn at h] d-no?+ p]plexity4 ,i ?\ght t if ,lib]alism once got a foot+ )9 h]1 x 0 sure ( victory 9 ! ev5t4 ,i saw t ,re=mation pr9ciples 7 p[]less to rescue h]4 ,z to leav+ h]1 ! ?\ght nev] cross$ my imag9ation3 /ill ,i ev] kept be=e me t !re 0 some?+ great] ?an ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*1 & t t 0 ! ,*ur* ,ca?olic & ,apo/olic1 set up f ! beg9n+1 ( :i* %e 0 b ! local pres5ce & organ4 ,%e 0 no?+ unless %e 0 ?is4 ,%e mu/ be dealt ) /rongly or %e w\ld be lo/4 ,!re 0 ne$ ( a second ,re=mation4 ,if ,i ?\ght t we c\ld /& t5 or fifte5 ye>s z we are1 ,i %\ld h little fe>1 said ,mr4 ,rose4 ,he felt t1 if only he c\ld secure a respite1 he _h ! means & ! hope ( op5+ ! eyes ( ,*ur*m54 ,!y 7 secure & idle f long prosp]ity1 & n[ !y 7 sc>$ & p]plex$ by ! sudd5ness ( an attack = :i* !y 7 :olly unprep>$4 ,b he _h confid5ce 9 8 own convictions4 ,he _h ar\nd him ability & zeal1 9 :i* he _h ! be/ reason to tru/4 ,he might hope1 if he _h "t1 to turn ! tide4 ,b ?is "t to /& to arms 0 j :at he _h n4 ,! dang]1 he felt1 0 ^u him4 ,he c\ld n wait4 ,s he acquiesc$ 9 an agitation :i* s cauti\s & /eady a man w\ld o!rwise h>dly h *os54 ,t some?+ mu/ be done is c]ta94 ,! only ?+ is1 t :atev] is done ought to be quickly done4 ,no?+ c %[ m =cibly ! imm95ce & pressure ( ! crisis ?an words l ^!1 n m]ely f ,fr\de & 8 fri5ds1 b f su* a man z ,mr4 ,hugh ,james ,rose4 ,some?+ mu/ be done1 b :at8 ,?is 0 n s easy to say4 ,x 0 obvi\s t m5 mu/ act 9 conc]t1 & mu/ write2 b beyond ^! g5]al po9ts1 que/ions & difficulties arose4 ,! fir/ idea t sugge/$ itself at ,hadleigh 0 a =m ( association1 :i* w\ld h be5 some?+ l ! ,engli% ,*ur* ,union or ! ,*ur* ,def5ce ,association ( our days4 ,x probably 0 ,mr4 ,palm]'s idea2 & = "s "t ! attempt to c>ry x into effect 0 foll[$ up at ,ox=d4 ,plans ( ,association 7 drawn up & reject$4 ,! endeav\r br\ght out diff]5ces ( op9ion--diff]5ces z to ! rightness or ! policy ( specific m5tion ( doctr9es2 diff]5ces z to ! union ( ,*ur* & ,/ate1 on ! importance ( ma9ta9+ :i*1 z long z possible1 ,mr4 ,newman sid$ ) ,mr4 ,palm] aga9/ ,mr4 ,keble's m uncompromis+ view4 ,a ?ird =mul>y 0 at l5g? adopt$4 ,ev5ts1 x said1 h occurr$ )9 ! la/ few ye>s calculat$ to inspire ! true memb]s & fri5ds ( ! ,*ur* ) ! deepe/ uneas9ess4 ,x w5t on to notice t political *anges _h ?r[n p[] into ! h&s ( ! pr(ess$ enemies ( ! ,*ur* z an e/abli%m5t2 b x 0 n m]ely z an e/abli%m5t t x 0 9 mo/ s]i\s dang]4 ,e "o1 x says1 :o has become acqua9t$ ) ! lit]ature ( ! day1 mu/ h obs]v$ ! s$ul\s attempts made 9 v>i\s qu>t]s to reconcile memb]s ( ! ,*ur* to alt]ations 9 its doctr9es & discipl9e4 ,projects ( *ange1 :i* include ! annihilation ( our ,cre$s & ! removal ( doctr9al /atem5ts incid5tally conta9$ 9 our wor%ip1 h be5 boldly & assidu\sly put =?4 ,our s]vices h be5 subject$ to lic5ti\s criticism1 ) ! view ( sup]s$+ "s ( !m & ( entirely remodell+ o!rs4 ,! v elem5t>y pr9ciples ( our ritual & discipl9e h be5 rudely que/ion$2 our apo/olical polity has be5 ridicul$ & d5i$4 ,! condition ( ! times made ^! ?+s m ?an ord9>ily al>m+1 & ! press+ dang] 0 urg$ z a reason = ! =mation1 by memb]s ( ! ,*ur* 9 v>i\s p>ts ( ! k+dom1 ( an association on a few broad pr9ciples ( union = ! def5ce ( ! ,*ur*4 ,!y feel /rongly1 said ! au?ors ( ! pap]1 t no fe> ( ! appe>ance ( =w>dness %\ld dissuade !m f a design1 :i* seems to be dem&$ ( !m by _! affection t[>ds t spiritual community to :i* !y owe _! hopes ( ! _w to come2 & by a s5se ( duty to t ,god & ,savi\r :o is its ,f\nd] & ,def5d]4 ,b ! plan ( an ,association1 or ( sep>ate ,associations1 :i* 0 circulat$ 9 ! autumn ( #ahcc1 came to no?+4 ,jeal\sy 0 ent]ta9$ ( x 9 high qu>t]s4 ,fr\de object$ to any association less wide ?an ! ,*ur* itself4 ,newman _h a horror ( committees & meet+s & great p 9 ,london4 ,& ?us1 9 spite ( ,mr4 ,palm]'s ef=ts1 fav\r$ by a c]ta9 numb] ( influ5tial & dignifi$ fri5ds1 ! ,association w\ld n "w4 ,b ! /ir ab\t x 0 n )\t result4 ,mr4 ,palm] travell$ ab\t ! c\ntry ) ! view ( br++ ! /ate ( ?+s be=e ! cl]gy4 ,9 place ( ! ,association1 an ,address to ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury 0 resolv$ ^u4 ,x 0 drawn up by ,mr4 ,palm]1 :o und]took ! bus9ess ( circulat+ x4 ,9 spite ( great difficulties & tr\ble ( ! al>m ( fri5ds l ,mr4 ,rose1 :o 0 afraid t x w\ld cause s*ism 9 ! ,*ur*2 ( ! g5]al timidity ( ! dignifi$ cl]gy2 ( ! di/ru/ & ! crot*ets ( o!rs2 ( ! coldness ( ! bi%ops & ! opposition ( "s ( !m--x 0 pres5t$ ) ! signatures ( "s #gjjj cl]gy to ! ,ar*bi%op 9 ,febru>y #ahcd4 ,x bore ! names1 among o!rs1 ( ,dr4 ,*ri/oph] ,wordswor?1 ,ma/] ( ,tr9ity2 ,dr4 ,gilb]t1 ( ,bras5ose ,college2 ,dr4 ,faussett1 & ,mr4 ,keble4 ,& ?is 0 n all4 ,a ,lay ,address foll[$4 ,!re 7 difficulties ab\t ! fir/ =m propos$1 :i* 0 ?\ght to say too mu* ab\t ! doctr9e & discipl9e ( ! ,*ur*2 & x 0 laid aside = "o ) m vague expressions ab\t ! consecration ( ! ,/ate1 & ! practical b5efits ( ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*4 ,9 ?is =m x 0 sign$ by #bcj1jjj heads ( families1 & pres5t$ to ! ,ar*bi%op 9 ! foll[+ ,may4 ,f ^! two ev5ts1 writes ,mr4 ,p]ceval 9 #ahdb1 we may date ! comm5cem5t ( ! turn ( ! tide1 :i* _h ?reat5$ to ov]:elm our ,*ur* & our religion4#de ,!re c1 at any rate1 be little d\bt t z reg>ds ! ext]nal position ( ! ,*ur* 9 ! c\ntry1 ?is agitation 0 a success4 ,x ralli$ ! c\rage ( ,*ur*m51 & %[$ t !y 7 /rong] & m resolute ?an _! enemies ?\ght4 ,! revolution>y temp] ( ! times _h ?r[n all ,*ur*m5 on ! ,cons]vative side2 & ^! addresses 7 p>tly help$ by political ,cons]vatism1 & also react$ 9 its fav\r4 ,"s ( ! ,hadleigh fri5ds w\ld probably h be5 cont5t to g on 9 ?is c\rse1 rais+ & keep+ alive a /rong feel+ 9 fav\r ( ?+s z !y 71 creat+ a g5]al sympa?y ) ! ,*ur*1 & confid5ce 9 ! peculi> excell5cy ( its wise & sob] in/itutions1 s$ul\sly b cauti\sly endeav\r+ to correct popul> mi/akes ab\t !m1 & to diffuse a s\nd] k & a s\nd] tone ( religi\s feel+4 ,?is is :at ,mr4 ,h4,j4 ,rose w\ld h wi%$1 only he felt t he c\ld n insure ! t5 or fifte5 ye>s :i* he want$ to "w ?is gradual *ange4 ,bo? he & ,mr4 ,palm] w\ld h made ,london1 to use a milit>y t]m1 _! base ( op]ations4 ,! ,oriel m51 on ! o!r h&1 ?\ght t ,univ]sities are ! natural c5tres ( intellectual movem5ts2 !y 7 = work+ m spontane\sly 9 ! fre$om ( indep5d5t /udy2 !y _h little fai? 9 organisation2 liv+ movem5ts1 !y said1 d n come ( committees4 ,b at ,hadleigh x 0 settl$ t !re 0 writ+ to be done1 9 "s way or o!r2 & on ?is1 div]g5ce ( op9ion soon %[$ itself1 bo? z to ! matt] & ! tone ( :at 0 to be writt54 ,= ! writ]s ( real =ce1 ! m5 ( g5ius1 7 ! ?ree ,oriel m51 ) less exp]i5ce1 at t "t1 ) less ext5sive le>n+1 ?an ,mr4 ,rose & ,mr4 ,palm]4 ,b !y 7 bold] & ke5] spirits2 !y pi]c$ m deeply into ! real condition & prospects ( ! times2 !y 7 n dispos$ to smoo? ov] & excuse :at !y ?\ght holl[ & untrue1 to put up ) decor\s compromises & half-measures1 to be pati5t t[>ds apa?y1 neglig5ce1 or insol5ce4 ,!y c]ta9ly _h m 9 !m ( ! temp] ( w>f>e4 ,we "k f _! own av[als t a great ang] possess$ !m1 t !y 7 indignant at ! sacr$ idea ( ! ,*ur* be+ lo/ & smo!r$ by selfi%ness & /upidity2 !y 7 animat$ by ! _s :i* makes m5 lose pati5ce ) abuses & _! apologi/s1 & gives !m no peace till !y speak out4 ,mr4 ,newman felt t1 ?\gh associations & addresses might be v well1 :at ! ,*ur* & ! cl]gy & ! c\ntry want$ 0 pla9 speak+2 & t pla9 speak+ c\ld n be got by any pap]s put =? z jo9t manife/oes1 or ) ! revision & sanction ( safe & judici\s advis]s4 ,x 0 necess>y to write1 & to write z ea* man felt3 & he det]m9$ t ea* man %\ld write & speak = himself1 ?\gh work+ 9 conc]t & sympa?y ) o!rs t[>ds ! supreme end--! cause & int]e/s ( ! ,*ur*4 ,& ?us 7 born ! ,tracts = ! ,times4#df ,= a "t ,mr4 ,palm]'s l9e & ,mr4 ,newman's l9e ran on side by side2 b ,mr4 ,palm]'s plan _h soon done all t x c\ld d1 important z t 02 x gradually fad$ out ( sight1 & ! att5tion ( all :o c>$ =1 or :o fe>$ or :o hat$ ! movem5t1 0 conc5trat$ on ! ,ox=d ,tracts4 ,!y 7 ! wat*word & ! symbol ( an ent]prise :i* all soon felt to be a rem>kable "o--rem>kable1 if 9 no?+ else1 9 ! =m 9 :i* x 0 />t$4 ,great *anges & movem5ts h be5 begun 9 v>i\s ways2 9 secret & und]gr\nd communications1 9 d>+ acts ( self-devotion or viol5ce1 9 ! organisation ( an in/itution1 9 ! p]si/5t display ( a p>ticul> temp] & set ( habits1 especially 9 ! =m ( a /irr+ & en?rall+ eloqu5ce1 9 popul> prea*+1 9 fi]ce appeals to ! passions4 ,b ?\gh tracts _h become 9 lat] times famili> in/rum5ts ( religi\s action1 !y _h1 f ! fa%ion ( us+ !m1 become unit$ 9 ! m9ds ( _m ) r disp>ag+ associations4 ,! p]t9acity ( good ladies :o press$ !m on *ance /rang]s1 & :o extoll$ _! efficacy z if x 0 t ( a quack m$ic9e1 _h l[]$ ! g5]al respect = !m4 ,! la/ ?+ t c\ld h be5 ?\ght ( 0 a great religions revolution set 9 motion by tracts & leaflets1 & tak+ its "* & "n f !m4 ,b ! r+ ( ^! e>ly ,tracts 0 some?+ v diff]5t f any?+ ( ! k9d yet kn[n 9 ,engl&4 ,!y 7 cle>1 brief1 /]n appeals to consci5ce & reason1 sp>+ ( words1 utt]ly )\t rhetoric1 int5se 9 purpose4 ,!y 7 l ! %ort1 %>p1 rapid utt]ances ( m5 9 pa9 & dang] & press+ em]g5cy4 ,! fir/ "o gave ! keynote ( ! s]ies4 ,mr4 ,newman _h out ( 8 own head begun ! ,tracts3 he wrote ! op5+ "o 9 a mood :i* he has himself describ$4 ,he 0 9 ! exultation ( heal? re/or$ & home rega9$3 he felt1 he says1 an exub]ant & joy\s en]gy :i* he nev] _h be=e or s9ce2 8 heal? & /r5g? _h come back to him ) su* a reb\nd t "s ( 8 fri5ds did n "k him4 ,i _h ! consci\sness t ,i 0 employ$ 9 t "w :i* ,i _h be5 dream+ ab\t1 & :i* ,i felt to be s mom5t\s & inspir+4 ,i _h a supreme confid5ce 9 our cause2 we 7 uphold+ t primitive ,*ri/ianity :i* 0 deliv]$ = all "t by ! e>ly tea*]s ( ! ,*ur*1 & :i* 0 regi/]$ & atte/$ 9 ! ,anglican =mul>ies & by ! ,anglican div9es4 ,t anci5t religion _h well-nigh fad$ out ( ! l& ?r\gh ! political *anges ( ! la/ #aej ye>s1 & x mu/ be re/or$4 ,x w\ld be1 9 fact1 a second ,re=mation--a bett] ,re=mation1 = x w\ld return1 n to ! sixte5? c5tury1 b to ! sev5te5?4 ,no "t 0 to be lo/1 = ! ,:igs _h come to d _! wor/1 & ! rescue might come too late4 ,bi%oprics 7 already 9 c\rse ( suppression2 ,*ur* prop]ty 0 9 c\rse ( confiscation2 sees w\ld be soon receiv+ unsuitable occupants4 ,we knew en\gh to beg9 prea*+1 & !re 0 no "o else to prea*4 ,i felt1 he goes on1#dg ) a *>act]i/ic recollection ( 8 own exp]i5ce :5 he />t$ on 8 voyage ) ,fr\de 9 ! ,h]mes1 z on a vessel1 :i* fir/ gets "u weigh1 & !n cle>s out ! deck1 & /ores away luggage & live /ock into _! prop] receptacles4 ,! fir/ ?ree ,tracts be> ! date ( #i? ,septemb] #ahcc4 ,!y 7 ! fir/ public utt]ance ( ! movem5t4 ,! op5+ words ( ?is fam\s s]ies des]ve to be recall$4 ,!y are new to mo/ ( ! pres5t g5]ation4 ,,to ,,my ,,bre?r5 ,,9 ,,! ,,sacr$ ,,m9i/ry1 ,,! ,,presbyt]s ,,& ,,deacons ,,( ,,! ,,*ur* ,,( ,,*ri/ ,,9 ,,engl&1 ,,orda9$ ,,!reunto ,,by ,,! ,,holy ,,gho/ ,,& ,,! ,,imposition ,,( ,,h&s4 ,,fell[-,,lab\r]s1--,i am b "o ( y\rselves--,presbyt]2 & !re=e ,i conceal my "n1 le/ ,i %\ld take too mu* on myself by speak+ 9 my own p]son4 ,yet speak ,i mu/2 = ! times are v evil1 yet no "o speaks aga9/ !m4 ,is n ?is s8 ,d n we look "o ^u ano!r1 yet p]=m no?+8 ,d we n all confess ! p]il into :i* ! ,*ur* is come1 yet sit /ill ea* 9 8 own retirem5t1 z if m\nta9s & seas cut (f bro!r f bro!r8 ,!re=e suff] me1 :ile ,i try to draw y =? f ^? pleasant retreats1 :i* x has be5 our bless$ness hi!rto to enjoy1 to contemplate ! condition & prospects ( our ,holy ,"m 9 a practical way2 s t "o & all may unle>n t idle habit1 :i* has gr[n ^u u1 ( own+ ! /ate ( ?+s to be bad1 yet do+ no?+ to rem$y x4 ,consid] a mom5t4 ,is x fair1 is x dutiful1 to suff] our bi%ops to /& ! brunt ( ! battle )\t do+ our "p to support !m8 ,^u !m comes ! c>e ( all ! ,*ur*es4 ,?is _c be help$2 inde$ x is _! glory4 ,n "o ( u w\ld wi% 9 ! lea/ to deprive !m ( ! duties1 ! toils1 ! responsibilities ( _! high (fice4 ,&1 black ev5t z x w\ld be = ! c\ntry1 yet 7z f> z !y are conc]n$7 we c\ld n wi% !m a m bless$ t]m9ation ( _! c\rse ?an ! spoil+ ( _! goods & m>tyrdom4 ,to !m !n we will+ly & affectionately rel9qui% _! high privileges & hon\rs2 we encroa* n ^u ! rights ( ! ,,successors ,,( ,,! ,,apo/les2 we t\* n _! sword & crozi]4 ,yet surely we may be _! %ield-be>]s 9 ! battle )\t (f5ce2 & by our voice & de$s be to !m :at ,luke & ,timo?y 7 to ,/4 ,paul4 ,n[ !n let me come at once to ! subject :i* leads me to address y4 ,%\ld ! ,gov]nm5t & ! ,c\ntry s f> =get _! ,god z to ca/ (f ! ,*ur*1 to deprive x ( its temporal hon\rs & sub/ance1 on :at w y re/ ! claim ( respect & att5tion :i* y make ^u y\r flocks8 ,hi!rto y h be5 upheld by y\r bir?1 y\r education1 y\r weal?1 y\r connexions2 %\ld ^! secul> advantages cease1 on :at mu/ ,*ri/'s ,m9i/]s dep5d8 ,is n ?is a s]i\s practical "q8 ,we "k h[ mis]able is ! /ate ( religi\s bodies n support$ by ! ,/ate4 ,look at ! ,diss5t]s on all sides ( y1 & y w see at once t _! ,m9i/]s1 dep5d+ simply ^u ! p1 become ! creatures ( ! p4 ,are y cont5t t ?is %\ld be y\r case8 ,alas6 c a great] evil befall ,*ri/ians1 ?an = _! tea*]s to be guid$ by !m1 in/ead ( guid+8 ,h[ c we hold fa/ ! =m ( s\nd words1 & keep t :i* is committ$ to our tru/1 if our influ5ce is to dep5d simply on our popul>ity8 ,is x n our v (fice to oppose ! _w8 ,c we !n all[ ourselves to c\rt x8 to prea* smoo? ?+s & prophesy deceits8 to make ! way ( life easy to ! ri* & indol5t1 & to bribe ! humbl] classes by excitem5ts & /rong intoxicat+ doctr9e8 ,surely x mu/ n be s2--& ! "q recurs1 on :at are we to re/ our au?ority :5 ! ,/ate des]ts u8 ,*ri/ has n left ,8 ,*ur* )\t claim ( its own ^u ! att5tion ( m54 ,surely n4 ,h>d ,ma/] ,he _c be1 to bid u oppose ! _w1 yet give u no cr$5tials = s do+4 ,!re are "s :o re/ _! div9e mission on _! own unsupport$ ass]tion2 o!rs1 :o re/ x ^u _! popul>ity2 o!rs1 on _! success2 & o!rs1 :o re/ x ^u _! temporal di/9ctions4 ,?is la/ case has1 p]haps1 be5 too mu* our own2 ,i fe> we h neglect$ ! real gr\nd on :i* our au?ority is built--,,our ,,apo/olical ,,desc5t4 ,we h be5 born1 n ( blood1 nor ( ! w ( ! fle%1 nor ( ! w ( man1 b ( ,god4 ,! ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/ gave ,8 ,_s to ,8 ,apo/les2 !y 9 turn laid _! h&s on ^? :o %\ld succe$ !m2 & ^! aga9 on o!rs2 & s ! sacr$ gift has be5 h&$ d[n to our pres5t bi%ops1 :o h appo9t$ u z _! assi/ants1 & 9 "s s5se repres5tatives4 ,n[ e "o ( u believes ?is4 ,i "k t "s w at fir/ d5y !y d2 /ill !y d believe x4 ,only1 x is n suffici5tly1 practically impress$ on _! m9ds4 ,!y d believe x2 = x is ! doctr9e ( ! ,ord9ation ,s]vice1 :i* !y h recognis$ z tru? 9 ! mo/ solemn season ( _! lives4 ,9 ord]1 !n1 n to prove1 b to rem9d & impress1 ,i entreat y\r att5tion to ! words us$ :5 y 7 made m9i/]s ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur*4 ,! (fice ( ,deacon 0 ?us committ$ to y3 ,take ?\ au?ority to execute ! (fice ( a ,deacon 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,god committ$ unto !e3 ,9 ! "n1 etc4 ,& ! ,prie/hood ?us3 ,receive ! ,holy ,gho/1 = ! (fice & "w ( a ,prie/1 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,god1 n[ committ$ unto !e by ! imposition ( our h&s4 ,^: s9s ?\ do/ =give1 !y are =giv52 & ^: s9s ?\ do/ reta91 !y are reta9$4 ,& be ?\ a fai?ful disp5s] ( ! ,^w ( ,god1 & ( ,8 ,holy ,sacram5ts3 ,9 ! "n1 etc4 ,^!1 ,i say1 7 words spok5 to u1 & receiv$ by u1 :5 we 7 br\ght ne>] to ,god ?an at any o!r "t ( our lives4 ,i "k ! grace ( ord9ation is conta9$ 9 ! lay+ on ( h&s1 n 9 any =m ( words2--yet 9 our own case 7z has ev] be5 usual 9 ! ,*ur*7 words ( bless+ h accompani$ ! act4 ,?us we h confess$ be=e ,god our belief t ! bi%op :o orda9$ u gave u ! ,holy ,gho/1 gave u ! p[] to b9d & to loose1 to adm9i/] ! ,sacram5ts1 & to prea*4 ,n[ h[ is he able to give ^! great gifts8 ,:5ce is 8 "r8 ,are ^! words idle 7:i* w\ld be tak+ ,god's "n 9 va971 or d !y express m]ely a wi% 7:i* surely is v f> bel[ _! mean+71 or d !y n r indicate t ! speak] is convey+ a gift8 ,surely !y c mean no?+ %ort ( ?is4 ,b :5ce1 ,i ask1 8 "r to d s8 ,has he any "r1 except z hav+ receiv$ ! p[] f ^? :o consecrat$ him to be a bi%op8 ,he c\ld n give :at he _h nev] receiv$4 ,x is pla9 !n t he b transmits2 & t ! ,*ri/ian ,m9i/ry is a succession4 ,& if we trace back ! p[] ( ord9ation f h& to h&1 ( c\rse we %all come to ! ,apo/les at la/4 ,we "k we d1 z a pla9 hi/orical fact2 & !re=e all we1 :o h be5 orda9$ cl]gy1 9 ! v =m ( our ord9ation ackn[l$g$ ! doctr9e ( ! ,,apo/olical ,,succession4 ,& = ! same reason1 we mu/ necess>ily consid] none to be really orda9$ :o h n ?us be5 orda9$4 ,= if ord9ation is a div9e ord9ance1 x mu/ be necess>y2 & if x is n a div9e ord9ance1 h[ d>e we use x8 ,!re=e all :o use x1 all ( u1 mu/ consid] x necess>y4 ,z well might we pret5d ! ,sacram5ts are n necess>y to salvation1 :ile we make use ( ! (fices 9 ! ,liturgy2 = :5 ,god appo9ts means ( grace1 !y are ! means4 ,i d n see h[ any "o c escape f ?is pla9 view ( ! subject1 except 7z ,i h already h9t$7 by decl>+ t ! words d n mean all t !y say4 ,b only reflect :at a mo/ unseemly "t = r&om words is t 9 :i* m9i/]s are set ap>t = _! (fice4 ,d we n adopt a ,liturgy 9 ord] to h9d] inconsid]ate idle language1 & %all we1 9 ! mo/ sacr$ ( all s]vices1 write d[n1 subscribe1 & use aga9 & aga9 =ms ( spee* :i* h n be5 weigh$1 & _c be tak5 /rictly8 ,!re=e1 my de> bre?r51 act up to y\r pr(essions4 ,let x n be said t y h neglect$ a gift2 = if y h ! ,_s ( ! ,apo/les on y1 surely ?is is a great gift4 ,/ir up ! gift ( ,god :i* is 9 y4 ,make mu* ( x4 ,%[ y\r value ( x4 ,keep x be=e y\r m9ds z an hon\rable badge1 f> high] ?an t secul> respectability1 or cultivation1 or poli%1 or le>n+1 or rank1 :i* gives y a he>+ ) ! _m4 ,tell !m ( y\r gift4 ,! times w soon drive y to d ?is1 if y mean to be /ill any?+4 ,b wait n = ! times4 ,d n be compell$1 by ! _w's =sak+ y1 to recur z if unwill+ly to ! high s\rce ( y\r au?ority4 ,speak out n[1 be=e y are =c$1 bo? z glory+ 9 y\r privilege & to insure y\r rightful hon\r f y\r p4 ,a notion has gone abroad t !y c take away y\r p[]4 ,!y ?9k !y h giv5 & c take x away4 ,!y ?9k x lies 9 ! ,*ur* prop]ty1 & !y "k t !y h politically ! p[] to confiscate t prop]ty4 ,!y h be5 delud$ into a notion t pres5t palpable usefulness1 producible results1 acceptabl5ess to y\r flocks1 t ^! & su* l are ! te/s ( y\r div9e commission4 ,enlight5 !m 9 ?is matt]4 ,exalt our ,holy ,fa!rs ! bi%ops1 z ! repres5tatives ( ! ,apo/les1 & ! ,angels ( ! ,*ur*es2 & magnify y\r (fice1 z be+ orda9$ by !m to take "p 9 _! ,m9i/ry4 ,b1 if y w n adopt my view ( ! subject1 :i* ,i (f] to y1 n d\bt+ly1 yet 7,i hope7 respectfully1 at all ev5ts1 ,,*oose ,,y\r ,,side4 ,to rema9 neut] mu* long] w be itself to take a "p4 ,*oose y\r side2 s9ce side y %ortly mu/1 ) "o or o!r p>ty1 ev5 ?\gh y d no?+4 ,fe> to be ( ^? ^: l9e is decid$ = !m by *ance circum/ances1 & :o may p]*ance f9d !mselves ) ! enemies ( ,*ri/1 :ile !y ?9k b to remove !mselves f worldly politics4 ,su* ab/95ce is impossible 9 tr\bl\s times4 ,,he ,,t ,,is ,,n ,,) ,,me ,,is ,,aga9/ ,,me1 ,,& ,,he ,,t ,,ga!re? ,,n ,,) ,,me ,,scatt]e? ,,abroad4 ,:ile ,mr4 ,palm] 0 work+ at ! ,association & ! ,address1 ,mr4 ,newman ) 8 fri5ds 0 s5d+ =? ! ,tracts1 "o aft] ano!r1 9 rapid succession1 ?r\gh ! autumn & w9t] ( #ahcc4 ,!y 7 %ort pap]s1 9 _m cases m]e %ort notes1 on ! great que/ions :i* _h sudd5ly sprung into su* int]e/1 & 7 felt to be full ( mom5t\s consequ5ce1--! true & ess5tial nature ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1 its relation to ! primitive ages1 its au?ority & its polity & gov]nm5t1 ! curr5t objections to its claims 9 ,engl&1 to its doctr9es & its s]vices1 ! l5g? ( ! pray]s1 ! ,burial ,s]vice1 ! propos$ alt]ations 9 ! ,liturgy1 ! neglect ( discipl9e1 ! s9s & corruptions ( ea* bran* ( ,*ri/5dom4 ,! same topics 7 en=c$ & illu/rat$ aga9 & aga9 z ! s]ies w5t on2 & !n !re came extracts f ,engli% div9es1 l ,bi%op ,bev]idge1 ,bi%op ,wilson1 & ,bi%op ,cos91 & "u ! title ,records ( ! ,*ur*1 translations f ! e>ly ,fa!rs1 ,ignatius1 ,ju/91 ,ir5aeus1 & o!rs4 ,mr4 ,palm] contribut$ to "o ( ^! pap]s1 & lat] on ,mr4 ,p]ceval wrote two or ?ree2 b = ! mo/ "p ^! e>ly ,tracts 7 writt5 by ,mr4 ,newman1 ?\gh ,mr4 ,keble & "o or two o!rs also help$4 ,aft]w>ds1 o!r writ]s jo9$ 9 ! s]ies4 ,!y 7 at fir/ n only publi%$ ) a notice t any "o might republi% !m ) any alt]ations he pleas$1 b !y 7 di/ribut$ by zeal\s coadjutors1 ready to take any tr\ble 9 ! cause4 ,mr4 ,mozley has describ$ h[ he rode ab\t ,nor?ampton%ire1 f p>sonage to p>sonage1 ) bundles ( ! ,tracts4 ,! ,apologia records ! same /ory4 ,i call$ ^u cl]gy1 says ! writ]1 9 v>i\s p>ts ( ! c\ntry1 :e!r ,i 0 acqua9t$ ) !m or n1 & ,i att5d$ at ! h\ses ( fri5ds :]e sev]al ( !m 7 f "t to "t assembl$4444 ,i did n c>e :e!r my visits 7 made to ,high ,*ur* or ,l[ ,*ur*3 ,i wi%$ to make a /rong pull 9 union ) all :o 7 oppos$ to ! pr9ciples ( ,lib]alism1 :oev] !y might be4 ,he adds t he does n ?9k t mu* came ( ^! visits1 or ( lett]s writt5 ) ! same purpose1 except t !y adv]tis$ ! fact t a rally 9 fav\r ( ! ,*ur* 0 comm5c+4 ,! e>ly ,tracts 7 int5d$ to />tle ! _w1 & !y succe$$ 9 do+ s4 ,_! v =m1 z %ort e>ne/ leaflets1 0 p]plex+2 = !y came1 n f ! class ( religioni/s :o usually deal 9 su* productions1 b f di/+ui%$ ,univ]sity s*ol>s1 pick$ m5 ( a pick$ college2 & f m51 too1 :o z a s*ool 7 ! repres5tatives ( sob]ness & self-control 9 religi\s feel+ & language1 & ^: usual /yle ( writ+ 0 specially m>k$ by its sev]e avoidance ( excitem5t & novelty2 ! s*ool f :i* _h lately come ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>1 ) its memorable motto ,9 quietness & confid5ce %all be y\r /r5g?4 ,_! matt] 0 equally unusual4 ,und\bt$ly !y br\ght /range ?+s to ! e>s ( _! g5]ation4 ,to ,*ur*m5 n[ ^! /range ?+s are su* famili> commonplaces1 t x is h>d to realise h[ !y %\ld h made s mu* /ir4 ,b !y 7 novelties1 p>tly audaci\s1 p>tly un9telligible1 !n4 ,! /rong & p]emptory language ( ! ,tracts1 _! abs5ce ( qualifications or explanations1 fright5$ fri5ds l ,mr4 ,palm]1 :o1 s f>1 _h no gr\nd to qu>rel ) _! doctr9e1 & he wi%$ !m to be discont9u$4 ,! /ory w5t t "o ( ! bi%ops1 on read+ "o ( ! ,tracts on ! ,apo/olical ,succession1 c\ld n make up 8 m9d :e!r he held ! doctr9e or n4 ,!y fell on a "t ( pr(\nd & inexcusable ignorance on ! subjects !y discuss$1 & !y did n sp>e x4 ,! cry ( ,romanism 0 inevitable1 & 0 soon rais$1 ?\gh !re 0 absolutely no?+ 9 !m b _h ! indisputable sanction ( ! ,pray] ,book1 & ( ! mo/ au?oritative ,anglican div9es4 ,!re 0 no ,romanism 9 !m1 nor any?+ t %[$ a t5d5cy to x4 ,b cu/om1 & ! preval5ce ( o!r sy/ems & ways1 & ! int]e/ ( lat] speculations1 & ! slack5+ ( pr(essional read+ & s*ol>%ip 9 ! ,*ur*1 _h made _! read]s =get "s ( ! mo/ obvi\s facts 9 ,*ur* hi/ory1 & ! mo/ c]ta9 ,*ur* pr9ciples2 & m5 7 at sea z to :at !y knew or believ$ on ! po9ts on :i* ! ,tracts *all5g$ !m4 ,! sc>e 0 n cr$itable2 x 0 l ! ,italian sc>e ab\t *ol]a ) its qu>ant9es & fumigations2 b x 0 natural4 ,! !ological k & le>n+ 7 want+ :i* w\ld h be5 famili> ) ! broad l9e ( diff]5ce betwe5 :at is ,ca?olic & :at is specially ,roman4 ,!re 7 _m ^: tea*+ 0 impugn$1 = x 0 really ,calv9i/ or ,zw+lian1 & n ,anglican4 ,!re 7 hopeful & ambiti\s !ological ,lib]als1 :o recognis$ 9 t appeal to ,anglicanism ! mo/ effective c\nt]-/roke to _! own s*emes & !ories4 ,!re 7 _m :om ! movem5t =c$ to ?9k1 :o did n want su* addition to _! responsibilities4 ,x _c be ?\ght surpris+ t ! new ,tracts 7 receiv$ ) surprise1 dismay1 ridicule1 & indignation4 ,b !y also at once call$ =? a response ( eag] sympa?y f numb]s to :om !y br\ght unhop$-= relief & light 9 a day ( gloom1 ( rebuke & blasphemy4 ,mr4 ,keble1 9 ! preface to 8 fam\s assize s]mon1 _h haz>d$ ! belief t !re 7 hundr$s1 nay1 ?\s&s ( ,*ri/ians1 & t !re soon w be t5s ( ?\s&s1 unaffect$ly anxi\s to be rightly guid$ 9 reg>d to subjects t conc]n ! ,*ur*4 ,! belief 0 soon ju/ifi$4 ,:5 ! fir/ =ty-six ,tracts 7 collect$ into a volume t[>ds ! end ( #ahcd1 ! foll[+ adv]tisem5t expla9+ _! nature & objects 0 prefix$ to x4 ,x is a contempor>y & au?oritative acc\nt ( :at 0 ! m9d ( ! lead]s ( ! movem5t2 & x has a significance beyond ! occasion :i* prompt$ x4 ,! foll[+-,tracts 7 publi%$ ) ! object ( contribut+-some?+ t[>ds ! practical revival ( doctr9es1 :i*1 al?\gh held by ! great div9es ( our ,*ur*1 at pres5t h become obsolete ) ! majority ( h] memb]s1 & are )drawn f public view ev5 by ! m le>n$ & or?odox few :o /ill adh]e to !m4 ,! ,apo/olic succession1 ! ,holy ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 7 pr9ciples ( action 9 ! m9ds ( our pr$ecessors ( ! sev5te5? c5tury2 b1 9 proportion z ! ma9t5ance ( ! ,*ur* has be5 secur$ by law1 h] m9i/]s h be5 "u ! temptation ( lean+ on an arm ( fle% in/ead ( h] own div9ely-provid$ discipl9e1 a temptation increas$ by political ev5ts & arrangem5ts :i* ne$ n "h be m ?an allud$ to4 ,a lam5table increase ( sect>ianism has foll[$2 be+ occasion$ 79 addition to o!r m obvi\s causes71 fir/1 by ! cold aspect :i* ! new ,*ur* doctr9es h pres5t$ to ! religi\s s5sibilities ( ! m9d1 next to _! meagr5ess 9 sugge/+ motives to re/ra9 x f seek+ out a m influ5tial discipl9e4 ,d\btless ob$i5ce to ! law ( ! l&1 & ! c>eful ma9t5ance ( dec5cy & ord] 7! topics 9 usage among u71 are pla9 duties ( ! ,gospel1 & a reasonable gr\nd = keep+ 9 communion ) ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*2 yet1 if ,provid5ce has graci\sly provid$ = our weakness m int]e/+ & con/ra9+ motives1 x is a s9 ?anklessly to neglect !m2 j z x w\ld be a mi/ake to re/ ! duties ( temp]ance or ju/ice on ! m]e law ( natural religion1 :5 !y are m]cifully sanction$ 9 ! ,gospel by ! m w9n+ au?ority ( our ,savi\r ,*ri/4 ,exp]i5ce has %[n ! inefficacy ( ! m]e injunctions ( ,*ur* ord]1 h[ev] scripturally en=c$1 9 re/ra9+ f s*ism ! awak5$ & anxi\s s9n]2 :o goes to a diss5t+ prea*] because 7z he expresses x7 he gets good f him3 & ?\gh he does n /& excus$ 9 ,god's sight = yield+ to ! temptation1 surely ! m9i/]s ( ! ,*ur* are n blameless if1 by keep+ back ! m graci\s & consol+ tru?s provid$ = ! little ones ( ,*ri/1 !y indirectly lead him into x4 ,_h he be5 taught z a *ild1 t ! ,sacram5ts1 n prea*+1 are ! s\rces ( ,div9e ,grace2 t ! ,apo/olical m9i/ry _h a virtue 9 x :i* w5t out ov] ! :ole ,*ur*1 :5 s\ght by ! pray] ( fai?2 t fell[%ip ) x 0 a gift & privilege1 z well z a duty1 we c\ld n h _h s _m w&]]s f our fold1 nor s _m cold he>ts )9 x4 ,?is in/ance may sugge/ _m o!rs ( ! sup]ior influ5ce ( an apo/olical ov] a m]e secul> me?od ( tea*+4 ,! awak5$ m9d kn[s its wants1 b _c provide = !m2 & 9 its hung] w fe$ ^u a%es1 if x _c obta9 ! pure milk ( ! ^w4 ,me?odism & ,pop]y are 9 diff]5t ways ! refuge ( ^? :om ! ,*ur* /9ts ( ! gifts ( grace2 !y are ! fo/]-mo!rs ( ab&on$ *ildr54 ,! neglect ( ! daily s]vice1 ! desecration ( fe/ivals1 ! ,eu*>i/ scantily adm9i/]$1 insubord9ation p]mitt$ 9 all ranks ( ! ,*ur*1 ord]s & (fices imp]fectly develop$1 ! want ( societies = p>ticul> religi\s objects1 & ! l defici5cies1 lead ! fev]i% m9d1 desir\s ( a v5t to its feel+s1 & a /rict] rule ( life1 to ! small] religi\s communities1 to pray] & ,bible meet+s1 & ill-advis$ in/itutions & societies1 on ! "o h&1 on ! o!r1 to ! solemn & captivat+ s]vices by :i* ,pop]y ga9s its proselytes4 ,moreov]1 ! multitude ( m5 _c tea* or guide !mselves2 & an injunction giv5 !m to dep5d on _! private judgm5t1 cruel 9 itself1 is d\bly hurtful1 z ?r[+ !m on su* tea*]s z speak d>+ly & promise l>gely1 & n only aid b sup]s$e individual ex]tion4 ,^! rem>ks may s]ve z a clue1 = ^? :o c>e to pursue x1 to ! views :i* h l$ to ! publication ( ! foll[+ ,tracts4 ,! ,*ur* ( ,*ri/ 0 int5d$ to cope ) human nature 9 all its =ms1 & surely ! gifts v\*saf$ x are adequate = t graci\s purpose4 ,!re are zeal\s sons & s]vants ( h] ,engli% bran*1 :o see ) sorr[ t %e is defraud$ ( h] full usefulness by p>ticul> !ories & pr9ciples ( ! pres5t age1 :i* int]f]e ) ! execution ( "o portion ( h] commission2 & :ile !y consid] t ! revival ( ?is portion ( tru? is especially adapt$ to break up exi/+ p>ties 9 ! ,*ur*1 & to =m in/ead a bond ( union among all :o love ! ,"l ,jesus ,*ri/ 9 s9c]ity1 !y believe t no?+ b ^! neglect$ doctr9es1 fai?fully prea*$1 w repress t ext5sion ( ,pop]y1 = :i* ! ev] multiply+ divisions ( ! religi\s _w are too cle>ly prep>+ ! way4 ,ano!r publication ought to be notic$1 a result ( ! ,hadleigh meet+1 :i* exhibit$ ! lead+ ideas ( ! conf]5ce1 & especially ( ! m cons]vative memb]s ( x4 ,?is 0 a little "w 9 "q & answ]1 call$ ! ,*ur*man's ,manual1 drawn up 9 "p "s "t be=e ! meet+ by ,mr4 ,p]ceval1 & submitt$ to ! revision ( ,mr4 ,rose & ,mr4 ,palm]4 ,x 0 int5d$ to be a supplem5t to ! ,*ur* ,cate*ism1 z to ! nature & claims ( ! ,*ur* & its ,m9i/]s4 ,x is a t]se1 cle>1 c>eful1 &1 z 0 inevitable1 r dry summ>y ( ! ,anglican !ory1 & ( ! position :i* ! ,engli% ,*ur* holds to ! ,roman ,*ur*1 & to ! ,diss5t]s4 ,x 0 fur!r revis$ at ! conf]5ce1 & "s important sugge/ions 7 made by ,fr\de2 & !n ,mr4 ,p]ceval1 :o _h great hopes f ! publication1 & sp>$ himself no pa9s to make x p]fect1 submitt$ x = revision & advice to a numb] ( repres5tative ,*ur*m54 ,! ,scot* ,bi%ops :om he consult$ 7 w>m 9 approval1 especially ! v5]able & sa9tly ,bi%op ,jolly2 z 7 also a numb] ( m5 ( weight & au?ority 9 ,engl&3 ,judge ,allan ,p>k1 ,jo%ua ,watson1 ,mr4 ,sikes ( ,guilsbor\gh1 ,mr4 ,*urton ( ,crayke1 ,mr4 ,h4,h4 ,norris1 ,dr4 ,wordswor?1 & ,dr4 ,r\?4 ,x 0 !n laid be=e ! ,ar*bi%op = correction1 or1 if desirable1 suppression2 & = 8 sanction if approv$4 ,! answ] 0 :at might h be5 expect$1 t !re 0 no objection to x1 b t (ficial sanction mu/ be decl9$ on g5]al gr\nds4 ,aft] all ?is ,mr4 ,p]ceval n unnaturally claim$ = x special importance4 ,x 0 really1 he obs]v$1 ! fir/ ,tract1 sy/ematically put =?1 & its prep>ation app>5tly gave rise to ! s]ies2 & x 0 ! only "o :i* receiv$ ! approval ( all imm$iately conc]n$ 9 ! movem5t4 ,! c>e be/[$ on x1 he says1 probably exce$s t :i* any !ological publication 9 ! ,engli% communion receiv$ = a long "t2 & fur!r1 x %[s t ! f\ndation ( ! movem5t ) :i* ,mr4 ,rose 0 connect$1 0 laid ) all ! c>e & circumspection t reason c\ld well sugge/4 ,x appe>s to h _h a circulation1 b !re is no reason to ?9k t x _h any consid]able influ5ce1 "o way or o!r1 on op9ion 9 ! ,*ur*4 ,:5 x 0 ref]r$ to 9 aft]-ye>s by ,mr4 ,p]ceval 9 8 own v9dication1 x 0 almo/ =gott54 ,m int]e/+1 if n m important1 ,tracts _h ?r[n x into ! %ade4 ,,footnotes3 #cg ,apol4 p4 #ajj4 #ch ,palm]1 ,n>rative1 #ahdc 7republi%$ #ahhc71 pp4 #e1 #ah4 #ci ,palm] 7#ahhc71 pp4 #dj1 #dc1 ,june #ahcc1 :5 he jo9$ u at ,ox=d4 #dj ,see ,palm]'s acc\nt 7#ahhc71 pp4 #de-dg1 & 7#ahdc71 pp4 #f1g4 #da ,mr4 ,rose 444 0 ! "o comm&+ figure & v lovable man1 t ! fright5$ & discomfit$ ,*ur* p 7 n[ rally+ r\nd4 ,few p h left s di/9ct an impression ( !mselves z ?is g5tleman4 ,= _m ye>s aft]1 :5 he 0 no m1 & ,newman _h left ,rose's /&po9t f> beh9d1 he c\ld nev] speak ( him or ?9k ( him )\t r5ew$ t5d]ness 7,mr4 ,t4 ,mozley1 ,rem9isc5ces1 i4 #cjh74 ,9 ,novemb] #ahch1 %ortly be=e ,mr4 ,rose's dea?1 ,mr4 ,newman _h d$icat$ a volume ( s]mons to him--:o1 :5 he>ts 7 fail+1 bade u /ir up ! gift t 0 9 u1 & betake ourselves to our true "m 7,p>o*ial ,s]mons1 vol4 iv47 #db ,n>rative ( ,ev5ts connect$ ) ! publication ( ,tracts = ! ,times1 by ,w4 ,palm] 7publi%$ #ahdc1 republi%$ #ahhc71 pp4 #if-ajj 7abridg$74 #dc ,collection ( ,pap]s connect$ ) ! ,!ological ,movem5t ( #ahcc1 by ,a4,p4 ,p]ceval 7#ahdb71 p4 #be4 #dd ,palm]'s ,n>rative 7#ahcc71 p4 #aja #de ,collection ( ,pap]s1 p4 #ab4 #df ,t port5t\s bir? ( "t1 ! ,tracts = ! ,times4--,mozley1 ,rem91 i4 #caa4 #dg ,fr\de1 ,rema9s1 i4 #bfe4 ,,*apt] ,,vii ,,! ,,tract>ians ,?us _h be5 />t$--hurri$ly p]haps1 yet n )\t c\nt+ ! co/--a great ent]prise1 :i* _h = its object to r\se ! ,*ur* f its le?>gy1 & to /r5g!n & purify religion1 by mak+ x deep] & m real2 & !y :o _h put _! h&s to ! pl\gh 7 n to look back any m4 ,x 0 n a popul> appeal2 x address$ itself n to ! _m b to ! few2 x s\ght to inspire & to tea* ! tea*]s4 ,!re 0 no ?\ght z yet ( act+ on ! middle classes1 or on ! ignorance & wret*$ness ( ! great t[ns1 ?\gh ,newman _h laid d[n t ! ,*ur* mu/ re/ on ! p1 & ,fr\de look$ =w>d to colleges ( unm>ri$ prie/s z ! true way to evangelise ! cr[ds4 ,!re 0 no display ab\t ?is attempt1 no eloqu5ce1 no?+ attractive 9 ! way ( orig9al speculation or s5tim5tal int]e/4 ,x 0 suspici\s1 p]haps too suspici\s1 ( ! excitem5t & want ( sob]ness1 almo/ inevitable 9 /rong appeals to ! masses ( mank9d4 ,x br\ght no new doctr9e1 b pr(ess$ to g back to :at 0 obvi\s & old-fa%ion$ & commonplace4 ,x taught p to ?9k less ( prea*+ ?an ( :at 9 an age ( excitem5t 7 invidi\sly call$ =ms--( ! sacram5ts & s]vices ( ! ,*ur*4 ,x disc\rag$1 ev5 to ! v]ge ( an int5d$ dryness1 all t 0 %[y1 all t 9 ?\ght or expression or mann] x condemn$ "u ! "n ( fla%4 ,x laid /ress on ! ex]cise ( an inn] & unse5 self-discipl9e1 & ! cultivation ( ! less int]e/+ virtues ( indu/ry1 humility1 self-di/ru/1 & ob$i5ce4 ,if f its writ]s proce$$ works :i* _h impress$ p--a volume l ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>1 poems orig9al 9 _! =ce & _! t5d]ness1 l "s ( ^? 9 ! ,lyra ,apo/olica1 s]mons :i* arre/$ ! he>]s by _! ke5ness & pa!tic und]tone--! =ce ( all ?is 0 n ! result ( lit]>y ambition & ef=t1 b ! reflexion1 unconsci\s1 uns\ght1 ( ?\ght & feel+ t c\ld n o!rwise express itself1 & t 0 ?r[n into m\lds %ap$ by habitual ref9em5t & cultivat$ ta/e4 ,x 0 f ! fir/ a movem5t f :i*1 z mu* by in/9ct & temp] z by delib]ate int5tion1 self-seek+ 9 all its =ms 0 exclud$4 ,^? :om x influ5c$ look$ n = great ?+s = !mselves1 nor ?\ght ( mak+ a m>k 9 ! _w4 ,! fir/ ye> aft] ! ,hadleigh meet+ 7#ahcd7 pass$ unev5tfully4 ,! v>i\s addresses 9 :i* ,mr4 ,palm] 0 int]e/$1 ! election & in/allation ( ! ,duke ( ,well+ton z ,*ancellor1 ! en?usiasm & hopes call$ =? by ! occasion1 7 public & prom95t matt]s4 ,! ,tracts 7 /eadily swell+ 9 numb]2 ! busy di/ribution ( !m _h ceas$1 & !y _h begun to excite int]e/ & give rise to que/ions4 ,mr4 ,palm]1 :o _h nev] lik$ ! ,tracts1 became m uneasy2 yet he did n altoge!r refuse to contribute to !m4 ,o!rs gave _! help1 among !m ,mr4 ,p]ceval1 ,fr\de1 ! two ,kebles1 & ,mr4 ,newman's fri5d1 a layman1 ,mr4 ,j4 ,b[d52 "s ( ! y\ng] s*ol>s furni%$ translations f ! ,fa!rs2 b ! bulk & mo/ =cible ( ! ,tracts 7 /ill ! "w ( ,mr4 ,newman4 ,b ! ,tracts 7 n ! mo/ p[]ful in/rum5ts 9 draw+ sympa?y to ! movem5t4 ,none b ^? :o rememb] !m c adequately e/imate ! effect ( ,mr4 ,newman's f\r o'clock s]mons at ,/4 ,m>y's4#dh ,! _w kn[s !m1 has he>d a great deal ab\t !m1 has pass$ its v>i\s judgm5ts on !m4 ,b x h>dly realises t )\t ^? s]mons ! movem5t might nev] h gone on1 c]ta9ly w\ld nev] h be5 :at x 04 ,ev5 p :o he>d !m cont9ually1 & felt !m to be diff]5t f any o!r s]mons1 h>dly e/imat$ _! real p[]1 or knew at ! "t ! influ5ce :i* ! s]mons 7 hav+ ^u !m4 ,pla91 direct1 unornam5t$1 clo!d 9 ,engli% t 0 only pure & lucid1 free f any faults ( ta/e1 /rong 9 _! flexibility & p]fect comm& bo? ( language & ?\ght1 !y 7 ! expression ( a pi]c+ & l>ge insight into "* & consci5ce & motives1 ( a sympa?y at once mo/ t5d] & mo/ /]n ) ! tempt$ & ! wav]+1 ( an absolute & burn+ fai? 9 ,god & ,8 c\nsels1 9 ,8 love1 9 ,8 judgm5ts1 9 ! awful glory ( ,8 g5]osity & ,8 magnific5ce4 ,!y made m5 ?9k ( ! ?+s :i* ! prea*] spoke (1 & n ( ! s]mon or ! prea*]4 ,s9ce #ahbh ?is prea*+ _h be5 go+ on at ,/4 ,m>y's1 gr[+ 9 purpose & directness z ! ye>s w5t on1 ?\gh x c\ld h>dly be m int5se ?an 9 "s ( its e>lie/ examples4 ,:ile m5 7 read+ & talk+ ab\t ! ,tracts1 !y 7 he>+ ! s]mons2 & 9 ! s]mons !y he>d ! liv+ mean+1 & reason1 & be>+ ( ! ,tracts1 _! e?ical aff9ities1 _! moral /&>d4 ,! s]mons creat$ a moral atmosph]e1 9 :i* m5 judg$ ! que/ions 9 debate4 ,x 0 no dry !ological correctness & complet5ess :i* 7 s\ght =4 ,no love ( privilege1 no =mal hi]>*ical claims1 urg$ on ! writ]s4 ,:at !y ?\ght 9 dang]1 :at !y aspir$ to revive & save1 0 ! v life ( religion1 ! tru? & sub/ance ( all t makes x ! hope ( human society4 ,b inde$1 by ?is "t1 out ( ! little company ( fri5ds :i* a common dang] & a common loyalty to ! ,*ur* _h br\ght toge!r1 "o ,mr4 ,newman1 _h drawn ahead1 & 0 n[ 9 ! front4 ,uns\ght =1 z ! ,apologia makes s cle>--uns\ght =1 z ! contempor>y lett]s ( obs]v+ fri5ds atte/--uns\ght =1 z ! :ole t5or ( 8 life has prov$--! position ( lead] 9 a great crisis came to him1 because x mu/ come4 ,he 0 n unconsci\s t1 z he _h felt 9 8 sickness 9 ,sicily1 he _h a "w to d4 ,b !re 0 %yness & self-di/ru/ 9 8 nature z well z en]gy2 & x 0 ! =ce ( g5ius1 & a l(ty "*1 & ! /atesman's eye1 tak+ 9 & judg+ accurately ! :ole ( a complicat$ sc5e1 :i* conf]r$ ! gifts1 & impos$ inevitably & )\t dispute ! obligations & responsibilities ( lead]%ip4 ,dr4 ,pusey ( c\rse 0 a fri5d ( great acc\nt1 b he 0 z yet 9 ! backgr\nd1 a v5]at$ & r awful p]son1 f 8 position n mix+ 9 ! easy int]c\rse ( common-room life1 b to be consult$ on em]g5cies4 ,r\nd ,mr4 ,newman ga!r$1 ) a curi\s mixture ( fre$om1 devotion1 & awe--=1 ) unlimit$ p[] ( sympa?y1 he 0 exact+ & ev5 au/]e 9 8 fri5d%ips--! be/ m5 ( 8 college1 ei!r ,fell[s--,r4 ,wilb]=ce1 ,?omas ,mozley1 ,fr$]ic ,rog]s1 ,j4,f4 ,*ri/ie2 or old pupils--,h5ry ,wilb]=ce1 ,r4,f4 ,wilson1 ,william ,fr\de1 ,rob]t ,williams1 ,s4,f4 ,wood1 ,james ,bliss1 ,james ,mozley2 & 9 addition "s outsid]s--,woodgate ( ,/4 ,john's1 ,isaac ,williams & ,copel&1 ( 8 old ,college1 ,tr9ity4 ,^!1 memb]s ( 8 intimate circle1 7 b\nd to him n m]ely by en?usia/ic admiration & confid5ce1 b by a t5d]ness ( affection1 a mixture ( ! gratitude & reliance ( disciple%ip ) ! w>m love ( fri5d%ip1 ( :i* "o has to g back f> = examples1 & :i* has _h no?+ l x 9 our days at ,ox=d4 ,& ,newman 0 mak+ 8 m>k z a writ]4 ,! ,arians1 ?\gh an imp]fect book1 0 "o :i*1 = orig9ality & subtlety ( ?\ght1 0 some?+ v unlike ! usual !ological writ+ ( ! day4 ,!re 0 no d\bt ( 8 p[]1 & 8 m9d 0 brimm+ ov] ) ideas on ! great que/ions :i* 7 ris+ into view4 ,x 0 cle> to all :o "k him t he c\ld speak on !m z no "o else c\ld4 ,t[>ds ! end ( #ahcd1 & 9 ! c\rse ( #ahce1 an ev5t happ5$ :i* _h a great & decisive influ5ce on ! "* & =tunes ( ! movem5t4 ,?is 0 ! accession to x ( ,dr4 ,pusey4 ,he _h look$ fav\rably on x f ! fir/1 p>tly f 8 fri5d%ip ) ,mr4 ,newman1 p>tly f ! work+s ( 8 own m9d4 ,b he _h no?+ to d ) ! />t+ ( x1 except t he e>ly contribut$ an elaborate pap] on ,fa/+4 ,! ,ox=d bran* ( ! movem5t1 z di/+ui%$ f t :i* ,mr4 ,palm] repres5t$1 consi/$ up to #ahcd almo/ exclusively ( junior m51 p]sonal fri5ds ( ,mr4 ,newman1 & mo/ ( !m ,oriel m54 ,mr4 ,newman's deep convictions1 8 fi]y en?usiasm1 _h giv5 ! ,tracts _! fir/ /amp & impress1 & _h s5t !m fly+ ov] ! c\ntry among ! cl]gy on 8 own responsibility4 ,!y answ]$ _! purpose4 ,!y l$ to widespread & sometimes deep se>*+s ( he>t2 to "s !y seem$ to speak =? :at _h be5 long dormant )9 !m1 :at _! m9ds _h unconsci\sly & vaguely ?\ght & long$ =2 to "s !y seem$ a *all5ge pregnant ) dang]4 ,b /ill !y 7 b an outbur/ ( individual feel+ & zeal1 :i*1 if no?+ m came ( its fragm5t>y displays1 might blaze & come to no?+4 ,!re 0 no?+ yet :i* spoke outw>dly ( ! consi/5cy & weight ( a s]i\s attempt to influ5ce op9ion & to produce a practical & la/+ effect on ! g5]ation :i* 0 pass+4 ,c>d9al ,newman1 9 ! ,apologia1 has attribut$ to ,dr4 ,pusey's unres]v$ adhesion to ! cause :i* ! ,tracts repres5t$ a great *ange 9 reg>d to ! weight & complet5ess ( :at 0 writt5 & done4 ,dr4 ,pusey1 he writes1 gave u at once a position & a "n4 ,)\t him we %\ld h _h no *ance1 especially at ! e>ly date ( #ahcd1 ( mak+ any s]i\s resi/ance to ! lib]al aggression4 ,b ,dr4 ,pusey 0 a ,pr(essor & ,canon ( ,*ri/ ,*ur*2 he _h a va/ influ5ce 9 consequ5ce ( 8 deep religi\s s]i\sness1 ! munific5ce ( 8 *>ities1 8 ,pr(essor%ip1 8 family connexions1 & 8 easy relations ) ! ,univ]sity au?orities4 ,he 0 to ! movem5t all t ,mr4 ,rose might h be51 ) t indisp5sable addition1 :i* 0 want+ to ,mr4 ,rose1 ! intimate fri5d%ip & ! famili> daily society ( ! p]sons :o _h comm5c$ x4 ,& he _h t special claim on _! atta*m5t :i* lies 9 ! liv+ pres5ce ( a fai?ful & loyal affectionat5ess4 ,!re 0 h5ce=? a man :o c\ld be ! head & c5tre ( ! zeal\s p 9 e "p ( ! c\ntry :o 7 adopt+ ! new op9ions2 & n only s1 b !re 0 "o :o furni%$ ! movem5t ) a front to ! _w1 & ga9$ = x a recognition f o!r p>ties 9 ! ,univ]sity4#di ,?is is n too mu* to say ( ! effect ( ,dr4 ,pusey's adhesion4 ,x gave ! movem5t a second head1 9 close sympa?y ) its orig9al lead]1 b 9 _m ways v diff]5t f him4 ,dr4 ,pusey became1 z x 71 its (ficial *ief 9 ! eyes ( ! _w4 ,he became also1 9 a rem>kable degree1 a gu>antee = its /ability & /ead9ess3 a gu>antee t its *iefs knew :at !y 7 ab\t1 & meant no?+ b :at 0 = ! b5efit ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,he 01 we read 9 ! ,apologia1 a man ( l>ge designs2 he _h a hopeful1 sangu9e m9d2 he _h no fe> ( o!rs2 he 0 haunt$ by no intellectual p]plexities4444 ,if confid5ce 9 8 position is 7z x is7 a fir/ ess5tial 9 ! lead] ( a p>ty1 ,dr4 ,pusey _h x4 ,an inflexible pati5ce1 a s]5e composure1 a meek1 resolute self-possession1 0 ! habit ( 8 m9d1 & nev] des]t$ him 9 ! mo/ try+ days4 ,he nev] = an in/ant1 z ! p>agraph witnesses1 wav]$ or d\bt$ ab\t ! position ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,he 0 em95tly1 z 8 fri5d ju/ly obs]ves1 a man ( l>ge designs4 ,x is d\btless true1 z ! ,apologia goes on to say1 t x 0 due to ! place :i* he n[ took 9 ! movem5t t great *anges 7 made 9 ! =m & "* ( ! ,tracts4 ,to ,dr4 ,pusey's m9d1 accu/om$ to l>ge & exhau/ive !ological read+1 !y want$ fulness1 complet5ess1 ! importance giv5 by c>eful arrangem5t & abundant k4 ,x 0 n = no?+ t he _h pass$ an appr5tice%ip among ! div9es ( ,g]many1 & be5 ! fri5d & correspond5t ( ,?oluck1 ,s*lei]ma*]1 ,ewald1 & ,sack4 ,he knew ! mean+ ( real le>n+4 ,9 controv]sy x 0 8 sl$ge-hamm] & battle-mace1 & he _h ! /rong & s9ewy h& to use x ) effect4 ,he obs]v$ t :5 att5tion _h be5 r\s$ to ! anci5t doctr9es ( ! ,*ur* by ! />tl+ & p]emptory language ( ! e>li] ,tracts1 fairness & ju/ice dem&$ t ^! doctr9es %\ld be fully & c>efully expla9$ & def5d$ aga9/ misrepres5tation & mi/ake4 ,=getfulness & ignorance _h ?r[n ^! doctr9es s completely into ! %ade t1 id5tifi$ z !y 7 ) ! be/ ,engli% div9ity1 !y n[ wore ! air ( amaz+ novelties2 & x 0 only due to hone/ inquir]s to satisfy !m ) solid & adequate pro(4 ,dr4 ,pusey's influ5ce 0 felt at once4 ,he saw t !re ought to be m sobriety1 m gravity1 m c>eful pa9s1 m s5se ( responsibility 9 ! ,tracts & 9 ! :ole movem5t4 ,at ! end ( #ahce ,dr4 ,pusey gave an example ( :at he meant4 ,9 place ( ! %ort & incomplete pap]s1 su* z ! e>li] ,tracts _h be51 ,nos4 #fg1 #fh1 & #fi =m$ ! ?ree p>ts ( a closely-pr9t$ pamphlet ( m ?an #cjj pages4#ej ,x 0 a treatise on ,baptism1 p]haps ! mo/ elaborate t has yet appe>$ 9 ! ,engli% language4 ,x is to be reg>d$1 says ! adv]tisem5t to ! second volume ( ! ,tracts1 n z an inquiry into a s+le or isolat$ doctr9e1 b z a del9eation & s]i\s exam9ation ( a mod]n sy/em ( !ology1 ( ext5sive popul>ity & great speci\sness1 9 its elem5t>y & *>act]i/ic pr9ciples4 ,! ,tract on ,baptism 0 l ! advance ( a batt]y ( heavy artill]y on a field :]e ! battle has be5 hi!rto c>ri$ on by skirmi%+ & musketry4 ,x alt]$ ! look ( ?+s & ! condition ( ! fight+4 ,aft] ,no4 #fg ! e>li] =m ( ! ,tracts appe>$ no m4 ,except two or ?ree repr9ts f writ]s l ,bi%op ,wilson1 ! ,tracts f ,no4 #gj to ,no4 #ij 7 ei!r grave & c>efully work$ out essays on "s "q aris+ out ( ! discussions ( ! "t1 or else ^? pond]\s cat5ae ( patri/ic or ,anglican div9ity1 by :i* ! hi/orical cont9uity & ,*ur* au?ority ( v>i\s po9ts ( doctr9e 7 e/abli%$4 ,dr4 ,pusey 0 inde$ a man ( l>ge designs4 ,! vision rose be=e him ( a reviv$ & in/ruct$ ,*ur*1 e>ne/ 9 purpose & /rict 9 life1 & ( a great ,*ri/ian ,univ]sity r\s$ & quick5$ to a s5se ( its p[]s & responsibilities4 ,he ?\ght ( ! enorm\s advantages (f]$ by its magnific5t f\ndations = s]i\s /udy & ! production ( works = :i* "t & deep le>n+ & cont9u\s lab\r 7 ess5tial4 ,su* works1 9 ! h&s ( s+le-m9d$ /ud5ts1 liv+ lives ( simplicity & h>d toil1 _h 9 ! case ( ! ,portroyali/s1 ! ,oratorians1 & above all1 ! ,b5$ict9es ( ,/4 ,maur1 spl5didly r$eem$ ! ,*ur* ( ,france1 9 o!rwise evil days1 f ! reproa* ( idl5ess & self-indulg5ce4 ,he f\nd "u 8 h& m5 :o _h 9 !m some?+ ( ! mak+ ( /ud5ts2 & he hop$ to see college fell[%ips fill$ m & m by su* m51 & ! life ( a college fell[ m & m recognis$ z t ( a man to :om le>n+1 & especially sacr$ le>n+1 0 8 call & suffici5t object1 z pa/oral or educational "w might be ! call ( o!rs4 ,:]e fell[%ips 7 n to be _h1 he enc\rag$ su* m5 to /ay up 9 ,ox=d2 he took !m into 8 own h\se2 lat]1 he tri$ a k9d ( hall to receive !m4 ,& by way ( beg9n+ at once1 & giv+ !m some?+ to d1 he plann$ on a l>ge scale a s]ies ( translations & also editions ( ! ,fa!rs4 ,x 0 ann\nc$1 ) an elaborate prospectus1 9 #ahcf1 "u ! title1 9 con=mity ) ! usage ( ! "t1 :i* _h ,libr>ies ( ,useful ,k1 etc41 ( a ,libr>y ( ,fa!rs ( ! ,holy ,ca?olic ,*ur* ant]ior to ! ,division ( ! ,ea/ & ,we/1 "u ! editor%ip ( ,dr4 ,pusey1 ,mr4 ,keble1 & ,mr4 ,newman4 ,x 0 d$icat$ to ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury1 & _h a consid]able numb] ( ,bi%ops among its subscrib]s4 ,d[n to a v late date1 ! ,libr>y ( ! ,fa!rs1 9 :i* ,*>les ,m>riott came to take a lead+ "p1 0 a matt] ( mu* conc]n to ,dr4 ,pusey4 ,& to br+ m5 toge!r1 & to int]e/ !m 9 !ological subjects1 he _h ev5+ meet+s at 8 own h\se1 :]e pap]s 7 read & discuss$4 ,"s p]sons1 writes a gossip+ *ronicl] ( ! "t1#ea ?\ght t ^! meet+s 7 liable to ! /atute1 ,de conv5ticulis illicitis reprim5dis4 ,"s important pap]s 7 ! result ( ^! meet+s2 b ! meet+s !mselves 7 irresi/ibly sleepy1 & 9 "t !y 7 discont9u$4 ,b indefatigable & p[]ful 9 all ^! beg9n+s ,dr4 ,pusey /irr$ m5 to activity & saw great gr\nd ( hope4 ,he 0 prep>$ = opposition1 b he _h b\ndless reliance on 8 fri5ds & 8 cause4 ,8 =eca/ ( ! future1 ( great days 9 /ore = ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 01 n unreasonably1 "o ( great promise4 ,t5 ye>s might "w wond]s4 ,! la/ fe> t occurr$ to him 0 t )9 t5 ye>s a hopeless rift1 n ( affection b ( conviction1 w\ld h run ?r\gh t company ( fri5ds1 & p>t$ irrevocably _! c\rse & "w 9 life4 ,,footnotes3 #dh ,! subjo9$ extracts record ! impression made by ,mr4 ,newman's prea*+ on contempor>ies well qualifi$ to judge1 & /&+ respectively 9 v diff]5t relations to ! movem5t4 ,?is is ! judgm5t ( a v close obs]v]1 & v indep5d5t critic1 ,james ,mozley4 ,9 an article 9 ! ,*ri/ian ,remembranc]1 ,janu>y #ahdf 7p4 #afi71 aft] speak+ ( ! obvi\s reasons ( ,mr4 ,newman's influ5ce1 he proce$s3-- ,we inquire fur!r1 & we f9d t ?is influ5ce has be5 ( a peculi>ly e?ical & inw>d k9d2 t x has t\*$ ! deepe/ "p ( our m9ds1 & t ! great "w on :i* x has be5 f\nd$ is a practical1 religi\s "o--8 ,s]mons4 ,we speak n f our own fix$ impression1 h[ev] deeply felt1 b f :at we h he>d & obs]v$ ev]y:]e1 f ! natural1 incid5tal1 unconsci\s rem>ks dropp$ f p]sons' m\?s1 & evid5tly %[+ :at !y ?\ght & felt4 ,= ourselves1 we mu/ say1 "o ( ,mr4 ,newman's s]mons is to u a m>vell\s production4 ,x has p]fect p[]1 & p]fect nature2 b ! latt] x is :i* makes x s great4 ,a s]mon ( ,mr4 ,newman's ent]s into all our feel+s1 ideas1 modes ( view+ ?+s4 ,he wond]fully realises a /ate ( m9d1 ent]s into a difficulty1 a temptation1 a disappo9tm5t1 a grief2 he goes into ! diff]5t turns & incid5tal1 unconsci\s symptoms ( a case1 ) notions :i* come into ! head & g out aga91 & are =gott51 till "s *ance recalls !m4444 ,to take ! fir/ in/ance t happ5s to occur to u 444 we h (t5 be5 /ruck by ! ke5 way 9 :i* he ent]s into a regul> tradesman's vice--av>ice1 =tune-gett+1 amass+ capital1 & s on4 ,?is is n a temp] to :i* we c imag9e ,mr4 ,newman ev] hav+ felt 9 8 own m9d ev5 ! temptation2 b he und]/&s x1 & ! temptation to x1 z p]fectly z any m]*ant c\ld4 ,no man ( bus9ess c\ld express x m naturally1 m pung5tly1 m ex animo4444 ,s ) ! view t worldly m5 take ( religion1 9 a c]ta9 s5se1 he q ent]s into x1 & ! _w's po9t ( view3 he sees1 ) a regul> worldly man's eye1 religion vani%+ into no?+1 & becom+ an unreality1 :ile ! visible sy/em ( life & facts1 politics & society1 gets m & m solid & gr[s ^u him4 ,! :ole influ5ce ( ! _w on ! imag9ation2 ! weight ( example2 ! =ce ( repetition2 ! way 9 :i* maxims1 rules1 s5tim5ts1 by be+ simply s\nd$ 9 ! e> f day to day1 seem to prove !mselves1 & make !mselves believ$ by be+ (t5 he>d1--e "p ( ! easy1 natural1 passive process by :i* a man becomes a man ( ! _w is ent]$ into1 z if ! prea*] 7 go+ to ju/ify or excuse him1 r ?an condemn him4 ,nay1 he ent]s deeply into :at ev5 scepticism has to say = itself2 he puts himself into ! infidel's /ate ( m9d1 9 :i* ! _w1 z a great fact1 seems to give ! lie to all religions1 conv]t+ !m into ph5om5a :i* c\nt]balance & negative ea* o!r1 & he goes d[n into t l[e/ abyss & bottom ( ?+s1 at :i* ! intellect und]cuts spiritual tru? altoge!r4 ,he ent]s into ! ord9>y common /ates ( m9d j 9 ! same way4 ,he is mo/ consol+1 mo/ sympa!tic4 ,he sets be=e p]sons _! own feel+s ) su* tru? ( detail1 su* natural expressive t\*es1 t !y seem n to be ord9>y /ates ( m9d :i* ev]ybody has1 b v peculi> ones2 = he & ! read] seem to be ! only two p]sons 9 ! _w t h !m 9 common4 ,"h is ! po9t4 ,p]sons look into ,mr4 ,newman's s]mons & see _! own ?\ghts 9 !m4 ,?is is1 aft] all1 :at z mu* z any?+ gives a book hold ^u m9ds4444 ,wond]ful pa!tic p[]1 t c s intimately1 s subtilely & k9dly1 deal ) ! s\l6--& wond]ful s\l t c be s dealt )4 ,comp>e ) ?is ! judgm5t pron\nc$ by "o ( q a diff]5t s*ool1 ! late ,pr9cipal ,%airp3-- ,bo? ,dr4 ,pusey & ,mr4 ,keble at t "t 7 q second 9 importance to ,mr4 ,newman4 ,! c5tre f :i* 8 p[] w5t =? 0 ! pulpit ( ,/4 ,m>y's1 ) ^? wond]ful aft]noon s]mons4 ,sunday aft] ,sunday1 ye> by ye>1 !y w5t on1 ea* cont9u+ & deep5+ ! impression produc$ by ! la/4 ,z ! h\r int]f]$ ) ! d9n]-h\r ( ! ,colleges1 mo/ m5 pref]r$ a w>m d9n] )\t ,newman's s]mon to a cold "o ) x2 s ! audi5ce 0 n cr[d$--! l>ge *ur* little m ?an half fill$4 ,! s]vice 0 v simple1 no pomp1 no ritualism2 = x 0 *>act]i/ic ( ! lead+ m5 ( ! movem5t t !y left ^! ?+s to ! weak] bre?r54 ,_! ?\ghts1 at all ev5ts1 7 set on great que/ions :i* t\*$ ! he>t ( unse5 ?+s4 ,ab\t ! s]vice1 ! mo/ rem>kable ?+ 0 ! beauty1 ! silv] intonation ( ,mr4 ,newman's voice z he read ! lessons4444 ,:5 he began to prea*1 a /rang] 0 n likely to be mu* /ruck4 ,"h 0 no vehem5ce1 no declamation1 no %[ ( elaborat$ argum5t1 s t "o :o came prep>$ to he> a great intellectual ef=t 0 almo/ sure to g away disappo9t$4 ,inde$1 we believe t if he _h prea*$ "o ( 8 ,/4 ,m>y's s]mons be=e a ,scot* t[n congregation1 !y w\ld h ?\ght ! prea*] a silly body4444 ,^? :o nev] he>d him might fancy t 8 s]mons w\ld g5]ally be ab\t apo/olical succession1 or rights ( ! ,*ur*1 or aga9/ ,diss5t]s4 ,no?+ ( ! k9d4 ,y might he> him prea* = weeks )\t an allusion to ^! ?+s4 ,:at !re 0 ( ,high ,*ur* tea*+ 0 impli$ r ?an en=c$4 ,! local1 ! tempor>y1 & ! mod]n 7 ennobl$ by ! pres5ce ( ! ,ca?olic tru? belong+ to all ages t p]vad$ ! :ole4 ,8 p[] %[$ itself *iefly 9 ! new & unlook$-= way 9 :i* he t\*$ into life old tru?s1 moral or spiritual1 :i* all ,*ri/ians ackn[l$ge1 b mo/ h ceas$ to feel--:5 he spoke ( unreal words1 ( ! individuality ( ! s\l1 ( ! invisible _w1 ( a p>ticul> ,provid5ce1 or aga91 ( ! v5tures ( fai?1 w>f>e ! condition ( victory1 ! ,cross ( ,*ri/ ! measure ( ! _w1 ! ,*ur* a ,home = ! lonely4 ,z he spoke1 h[ ! old tru? became new2 h[ x came home ) a mean+ nev] felt be=e6 ,he laid 8 f+] h[ g5tly1 yet h[ p[]fully1 on "s inn] place 9 ! he>]'s he>t1 & told him ?+s ab\t himself he _h nev] kn[n till !n4 ,subtle/ tru?s1 :i* x w\ld h tak5 philosoph]s pages ( circumlocution & big words to /ate1 7 dropt out by ! way 9 a s5t5ce or two ( ! mo/ transp>5t ,saxon4 ,:at delicacy ( /yle1 yet :at /r5g?6 h[ simple1 yet h[ sugge/ive6 h[ homely1 yet h[ ref9$6 h[ p5etrat+1 yet h[ t5d]-he>t$6 ,if n[ & !n !re 0 a =lorn und]tone :i* at ! "t seem$ inexplicable1 y might be p]plex$ at ! drift ( :at he said1 b y felt all ! m drawn to ! speak]4 444 ,aft] he>+ ^! s]mons y might come away /ill n believ+ ! t5ets peculi> to ! ,high ,*ur* sy/em2 b y w\ld be h>d] ?an mo/ m51 if y did n feel m ?an ev] a%am$ ( co>s5ess1 selfi%ness1 worldl9ess1 if y did n feel ! ?+s ( fai? br\ght clos] to ! s\l4--,john ,keble1 by ,j4 ,c4 ,%airp1 ,pr(essor ( ,humanity1 ,/4 ,&rews 7#ahff71 pp4 #ab-ag4 ,i v5ture to add ! judgm5t ( ano!r contempor>y1 on ! effect ( ?is prea*+1 f ! ,rem9isc5ces ( ,sir ,f4 ,doyle1 p4 #ade3-- ,t great man's extraord9>y g5ius drew all ^? )9 8 sph]e1 l a magnet1 to atta* !mselves to him & 8 doctr9es4 ,nay1 be=e he became a ,romani/1 :at we may call 8 mesm]ic influ5ce act$ n only on 8 ,tract>ian adh]5ts1 b ev5 9 "s degree on outsid]s l myself4 ,:5ev] ,i 0 at ,ox=d1 ,i us$ to g regul>ly on ,sunday aft]noons to li/5 to 8 s]mon at ,/4 ,m>y's1 & ,i h nev] he>d su* prea*+ s9ce4 ,i d n "k :e!r x is a m]e fancy ( m9e1 or :e!r ^? :o "k him bett] w accept & endorse my belief1 t "o elem5t ( 8 wond]ful p[] %[$ itself aft] ?is fa%ion4 ,he always began z if he _h det]m9$ to set =? 8 idea ( ! tru? 9 ! pla9e/ & simple/ language--language1 z m5 say1 intelligible to ! meane/ und]/&+4 ,b 8 ard5t zeal & f9e poetical imag9ation 7 n ?us to be controll$4 ,z ,i hung ^u 8 words1 x seem$ to me z if ,i c\ld trace beh9d 8 w1 & press+1 s to speak1 aga9/ x1 a ru% ( ?\ghts1 ( feel+s :i* he kept /ruggl+ to hold back1 b 9 ! end !y 7 g5]ally too /rong = him1 & p\r$ !mselves out 9 a torr5t ( eloqu5ce all ! m impetu\s f hav+ be5 s long repress$4 ,! effect ( ^! outbur/s 0 irresi/ible1 & c>ri$ 8 he>]s beyond !mselves at once4 ,ev5 :5 8 ef=ts ( self-re/ra9t 7 m successful1 ^? v ef=ts gave a life & col\r to 8 /yle :i* rivet$ ! att5tion ( all )9 ! rea* ( 8 voice4 ,mr4 ,ju/9 ,mc,carthy1 9 8 ,hi/ory ( ,our ,own ,times1 says ( him3 ,9 all ! arts t make a great prea*] or orator1 ,c>d9al ,newman 0 defici5t4 ,8 mann] 0 con/ra9$ & ungraceful1 & ev5 awkw>d2 8 voice 0 ?9 & weak1 8 be>+ 0 n at fir/ impressive 9 any way--a gaunt emaciat$ figure1 a %>p eagle face1 & a cold m$itative eye1 r repell$ ?an attract$ ^? :o saw him = ! fir/ "t4 ,i d n ?9k ,mr4 ,mc,carthy's phrases v happily *os5 to convey 8 mean+4 ,surely a gaunt emaciat$ frame & a %>p eagle face are ! v *>act]i/ics :i* we %\ld picture to ourselves z belong+ to ,pet] ! ,h]mit1 or ,scott's ,ephraim ,macbri> 9 ,old ,mortality4 ,h[ev] unimpressive ! look ( an eagle may be 9 ,mr4 ,mc,carthy's op9ion1 ,i d n agree ) him ab\t ,dr4 ,newman4 ,:5 ,i knew him at ,ox=d1 ^! some:at disp>ag+ rem>ks w\ld n h be5 applicable4 ,8 mann]1 x is true1 may h be5 self-repress$1 con/ra9$ x 0 n4 ,8 be>+ 0 nei!r awkw>d nor ungraceful2 x 0 simply quiet & calm1 because "u /rict control2 b b5ea? t calmness1 int5se feel+1 ,i ?9k1 0 obvi\s to ^? :o _h any in/9ct ( sympa?y ) him4 ,b if ,mr4 ,mc,carthy's acqua9tance ) him only began :5 he took (fice 9 an ,iri% ,ca?olic univ]sity1 ,i c q und]/& t 7flexibility n be+ "o ( 8 special gifts7 he may h fail$ n[ & aga9 to br+ himself into p]fect h>mony ) an ,iri% audi5ce4 ,he 0 probably too mu* ( a typical ,engli%man = 8 place2 nev]!less ,mr4 ,mc,carthy1 ?\gh he does n seem to h admir$ him 9 ! pulpit1 is fully s5sible ( 8 intellectual p[]s & g5]al em95ce4 ,dr4 ,pusey1 :o us$ e n[ & !n to take ,newman's duties at ,/4 ,m>y's1 0 to me a mu* less int]e/+ p]son4 ,a le>n$ man1 no d\bt1 b dull & t$i\s z a prea*]4 ,c]ta9ly1 9 spite ( ! "n ,puseyism hav+ be5 giv5 to ! ,ox=d attempt at a new ,ca?olic dep>ture1 he 0 n ! ,columbus ( t voyage ( discov]y und]tak5 to f9d a saf] hav5 = ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&4 ,i may1 h[ev]1 be m or less unju/ to him1 z ,i owe him a sort ( grudge4 ,8 disc\rses 7 n only less attractive ?an ^? ( ,dr4 ,newman1 b always mu* long]1 & ! result ( ?is 0 t ! le>n$ ,canon ( ,*ri/ ,*ur* g5]ally made me late = d9n] at my ,college1 a calamity nev] inflict$ on 8 ,all ,s\ls' he>]s by ! t]s] & swift] fell[ ( ,oriel :om he 0 replac+4 #di ,apologia1 p #acf4 #ej ,x swell$ 9 ! second edition to #djj pages 9 spite ( ! fact t 9 t edition ! hi/orical range ( ! treatise 0 greatly r$uc$4 #ea ,recollections ( ,ox=d1 by ,g4,v4 ,cox1 p4 #bgh4 ,,*apt] ,,viii ,,subscription ,,at ,,matriculation ,,& ,,admission ,,( ,,diss5t]s ,dep5d ^u x1 an e>ne/ ,high ,*ur*man ( ! ,jo%ua ,watson type _h said to "o ( ,mr4 ,newman's fri5ds1 :o 0 a l9k betwe5 ! old ,*ur*man%ip & ! new--dep5d ^u x1 ! day w come :5 ^? great doctr9es connect$ ) ! ,*ur*1 n[ buri$1 w be br\ght out to ! light ( ! day1 & !n ! effect w be q fe>ful4#eb ,) ! publication ( ! ,tracts = ! ,times1 & ! excitem5t caus$ by !m1 ! day _h come4 ,_! unfl9*+ & sev]e proclamation ( ,*ur* pr9ciples & ,*ur* doctr9es co9cid$ ) a /ate ( feel+ & op9ion 9 ! c\ntry1 9 :i* two v diff]5t t5d5cies might be obs]v$4 ,!y fell on ! public m9d j :5 "o ( ^! t5d5cies w\ld help !m1 & ! o!r be fi]cely ho/ile4 ,on ! "o h&1 ! issue ( ! political controv]sy ) ! ,roman ,ca?olics1 _! triumph all along ! l9e1 & ! n[ sc>cely disguis$ contempt %[n by _! political repres5tatives = ! pl$ges & explanations on :i* _! relief 0 suppos$ to h be5 conc$$1 _h left ! public m9d sore1 angry1 & suspici\s4 ,or?odox & ,evangelicals 7 alike al>m$ & indignant2 & ! ,evangelicals1 always doctr9ally jeal\s ( ,pop]y1 & ( any?+ uns\nd 9 t direction1 _h be5 r\s$ to increas$ irritation by ! proce$+s ( ! ,re=mation ,society1 :i* _h made x its bus9ess to hold meet+s & discussions all ov] ! c\ntry1 :]e f]vid & sometimes eloqu5t & able ,iri%m51 l ,mr4 ,e4 ,tott5ham1 aft]w>ds ( ,laura ,*apel1 ,ba?1 _h argu$ & declaim$1 ) ,roman text-books 9 h&1 on su* que/ions z ! ,"r ( ,private ,judgm5t1 ! ,rule ( ,fai?1 & ! articles ( ! ,trid5t9e ,cre$--n always ) ! effect :i* !y int5d$ on ^? :o he>d !m1 ) :om _! argum5ts1 & ^? :i* !y elicit$ f _! oppon5ts1 sometimes left beh9d uncom=table misgiv+s1 & que/ions ev5 m s]i\s ?an ! controv]sy itself4 ,on ! o!r h&1 9 qu>t]s q unconnect$ ) ! recognis$ religi\s s*ools1 int]e/ _h be5 indep5d5tly & /rongly awak5$ 9 ! m9ds ( !ologians & philosophical ?9k]s1 9 reg>d to ! idea1 hi/ory1 & relations to society ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*4 ,9 ,irel&1 a recluse1 :o 0 ! c5tre ( a small knot ( e>ne/ fri5ds1 a man ( deep piety & great fre$om & orig9ality ( m9d1 ,mr4 ,alex&] ,knox1 _h be5 l$1 p>tly1 x may be1 by 8 intimacy ) ,john ,wesley1 to ?9k out = himself ! "* & true con/itution ( ! ,*ur*1 & ! nature ( ! doctr9es :i* x 0 commission$ to tea*4 ,9 ,engl&1 ano!r recluse1 ( spl5did g5ius & wayw>d hum\r1 _h dealt 9 8 own way1 ) f>-rea*+ insight1 ) va/ read+1 & (t5 ) impressive eloqu5ce1 ) ! same subject2 & 8 pr(\nd sympa?y & fai? _h be5 %>$ & reflect$ by a great poet4 ,:at ,col]idge & ,wordswor? _h put 9 ! =efront ( _! speculations & poetry1 z ! object ( _! pr(\nde/ int]e/1 & ( _! highe/ hopes = mank9d1 might1 ( c\rse1 fail to appe> 9 ! same light to o!rs2 b x c\ld n fail1 9 ^? days at lea/1 to attract att5tion1 z a matt] ( grave & well-f\nd$ importance4 ,col]idge's !ories ( ! ,*ur* 7 8 own1 & 7 v wide ( !ories recognis$ by any ( ^? :o _h to deal practically ) ! "q1 & :o 7 influ5c$1 9 "o way or ano!r1 by ! traditional doctr9es ( !ologians4 ,b ,col]idge _h lift$ ! subject to a v high level4 ,he _h tak5 ! simple b all-important /ep ( view+ ! ,*ur* 9 its spiritual "* z fir/ & =emo/ & above all ?+s ess5tially a religi\s society ( div9e in/itution1 n dep5d5t on ! creation or w ( man1 or on ! privileges & hon\rs :i* man might ?9k fit to assign to x2 & he _h und\bt$ly famili>is$ ! m9ds ( _m ) ?is way ( reg>d+ x1 h[ev] imp]fect1 or cl\dy1 or unpractical !y might f9d ! developm5t ( 8 ideas1 & 8 d$uctions f !m4 ,& 9 ,ox=d ! que/ions :i* _h /irr$ ! fri5ds at ,hadleigh _h /irr$ o!rs also1 & _h wak$ up v>i\s responses4 ,:ately's acute m9d _h n miss$ ^! que/ions1 & _h giv5 orig9al if insuffici5t answ]s to !m4 ,blanco ,:ite knew only too well _! be>+ & importance1 & _h lab\r$1 n )\t success1 to leave beh9d him 8 own impress on ! way 9 :i* !y %\ld be dealt )4 ,dr4 ,hampd51 ! man 9 ,ox=d be/ acqua9t$ ) ,ari/otle's works & ) ! s*ola/ic philosophy1 _h ?r[n ,*ri/ian doctr9es into a philosophical calculus :i* seem$ to leave !m little bett] ?an ! inv5tions ( m54 ,on ! o!r h&1 a brilliant s*ol>1 ^: aft]-c>e] 0 /rangely full ( great successes & deplorable disa/]s1 ,william ,sewell ( ,exet] ,college1 _h op5$1 9 a way new to ,ox=d1 ! weal? & magnific5ce ( ,plato2 & 8 ?\ghts _h be5 dazzl$ by seem+ to f9d 9 ! tru?s & facts ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* ! c\nt]p>t & realisation ( ! gr&e/ ( ,plato's imag9ations4 ,! subjects treat$ ) su* dogmatic sev]ity & su* impetu\s e>ne/ness 9 ! ,tracts 71 9 "o %ape or ano!r1 9 all m5's m9ds1 :5 ^! ,tracts broke on ! ,univ]sity & ,engli% society ) _! p]emptory call to m5 to take _! side4 ,!re 0 j a mom5t ( surprise & unc]ta9ty--unc]ta9ty z to :at ! ,tracts meant2 :e!r !y 7 to be a new weapon aga9/ ! enemies ( ! ,*ur*1 or 7 simply extravagant & prepo/]\s novelties--j a c]ta9 p]plexity & hesitation at _! conflict+ aspects2 on ! "o h&1 ! kn[n & high "* ( ! writ]s1 _! evid5t det]m9ation & confid5ce 9 _! cause1 ! attraction ( _! religi\s w>m? & unselfi%ness & nobl5ess1 ! dim consci\sness t mu* t !y said 0 und5iable2 & on ! o!r h&1 ! app>5t wildness & recklessness ( _! words3 & !n public op9ion began /eadily to take its ply1 & to be agre$ 9 condemn+ !m4 ,x soon w5t f>!r1 & became vehem5t 9 reprobat+ !m z sc&al\s & dang]\s publications4 ,!y inc5s$ ! ,evangelicals by _! alleg$ ,romanism1 & _! uns\nd views ab\t ju/ification1 good works1 & ! sacram5ts2 !y ang]$ ! two-bottle or?odox by _! asceticism--! /eady m51 by _! audacity & /rong words--! lib]als1 by _! dogmatic sev]ity2 _! s]i\sly practical be>+ 0 e>ly disclos$ 9 a tract on ,fa/+4 ,b :ile !y repell$ /rongly1 !y attract$ /rongly2 !y t\*$ _m consci5ces1 !y won _m he>ts1 !y op5$ new ?\ghts & hopes to _m m9ds4 ,"o ( ! mis*iefs ( ! ,tracts1 & ( ^? s]mons at ,/4 ,m>y's :i* 7 ! comm5t>ies on !m1 0 t s _m p seem$ to l !m & to be /ruck by !m4 ,! ga!r+ /orm mutt]$ & gr[l$ = "s "t at a di/ance1 & m5 seem$ to be tak+ "t to make up _! m9ds2 b x began to l\r f e>ly days1 till aft] v>i\s ?reat5+s x broke 9 a furi\s article 9 ! ,ed9burgh1 by ,dr4 ,arnold1 on ! ,ox=d ,malignants2 & ! ,tract-writ]s & _! fri5ds became1 :at !y long cont9u$ to be1 ! mo/ unpopul> & suspect$ body ( m5 9 ! ,*ur*1 :om ev]ybody 0 at lib]ty to insult1 bo? z di%one/ & absurd1 ( :om no?+ 0 too cruel to say1 no?+ too ridicul\s to believe4 ,x is only equitable to take into acc\nt ! unprep>$ /ate ( ! public m9d1 ! surprise & novelty ( ev5 ! commone/ ?+s :5 put 9 a new light1 ! prejudices :i* ! ,tract-writ]s 7 ?\ght wantonly to (f5d & defy1 _! militant & uncompromis+ attitude1 :]e pr9ciples 7 at /ake4 ,b consid]+ :at ^! m5 7 kn[n to be 9 "* & life1 :at 0 ! em]g5cy & :at 7 ! press+ motives :i* call$ = action1 & :at is ?\ght ( !m n[ t _! c\rse is run1 x is /range inde$ to rememb] :o !y 71 to :om ! c\rtesies ( controv]sy 7 d5i$1 n only by ! vulg> h]d ( pamphlete]s1 b by m5 ( ability & position1 "s ( :om _h be5 _! famili> fri5ds4 ,( c\rse a nickname 0 soon f\nd = !m3 ! ^w ,tract>ian 0 inv5t$1 & ,ar*bi%op ,:ately ?\ght x wor? :ile1 b n successfully1 to improve x into ,tractites4 ,ar*bi%op ,:ately1 always +5i\s1 appe>s to h suspect$ t ! real b conceal$ object ( ! movem5t 0 to propagate a secret infidelity2 !y 7 ,*ildr5 ( ! ,mi/1 or ,veil$ ,prophets2#ec & he s]i\sly sugge/$ to a fri5d :o 0 writ+ aga9/ x1--?is rapidly spread+ pe/il5ce1--to p>allel x1 9 its *>act]i/ics & modes ( work+1 ) ,indian ,?uggee4#ed ,b ^! ?+s 7 ( gradual gr[?4 ,t[>ds ! end ( #ahcd a "q appe>$ 9 ,ox=d int]e/+ to numb]s besides ,mr4 ,newman & 8 fri5ds1 :i* 0 to lead to mom5t\s consequ5ces4 ,! old1 crude ideas ( *ange 9 ! ,*ur* _h come to appe>1 ev5 to _! advocates1 = ! pres5t impracticable1 & !re 0 no m talk = a long "t ( s*emes :i* _h be5 9 fav\r two ye>s be=e4 ,! gr\nd 0 *ang$1 & a po9t 0 n[ br\ght =w>d on ! ,lib]al side1 = :i* a good deal might be plausibly said4 ,?is 0 ! requirem5t ( subscription to ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles f "y m5 at matriculation2 & a /rong pamphlet advocat+ its abolition1 ) ! express purpose ( admitt+ ,diss5t]s1 0 publi%$ by ,dr4 ,hampd51 ! ,bampton ,lectur] ( two ye>s be=e4 ,ox=d _h always be5 "o ( ! great s*ools ( ! ,*ur*4 ,its traditions1 its tone1 its cu/oms1 its rules1 all express$ or presum$ ! close/ atta*m5t to t way ( religion :i* 0 specially id5tifi$ ) ! ,*ur*1 9 its doctr9al & hi/orical aspect4 ,ox=d 0 emphatically def9ite1 dogmatic1 or?odox1 comp>$ ev5 ) ,cambridge1 :i* _h l>gely fav\r$ ! ,evangelical s*ool1 & _h lean+s to ,lib]alism4 ,ox=d1 unlike ,cambridge1 gave notice ( its attitude by requir+ e "o :o matriculat$ to subscribe ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles3 ! !ory ( its ,tutorial sy/em1 ( its lectures & exam9ations1 impli$ :at ( late ye>s 9 ! bett] colleges1 ?\gh c]ta9ly n ev]y:]e1 _h be5 realis$ 9 fact--a consid]able am\nt ( religi\s & !ological tea*+4 ,& :atev] might h be5 said orig9ally ( ! lay "* ( ! ,univ]sity1 ! colleges1 :i* _h become coext5sive ) ! ,univ]sity1 7 = ! mo/ "p1 9 ! int5tion ( _! f\nd]s1 meant to educate & support !ological /ud5ts on _! f\ndations = ! s]vice ( ! ,*ur*4 ,x became 9 "t ! fa%ion to call !m lay in/itutions3 legally !y may h be5 s1 b judg$ by _! /atutes1 !y 7 ne>ly all ( !m z ecclesia/ical z ! ,*apt] ( a ,ca!dral4 ,& ,ox=d 0 ! fulcrum f :i* ! !ological revival hop$ to move ! ,*ur*4 ,x 0 !re=e a %ock & a *all5ge ( no light k9d1 :5 n m]ely ! proposal 0 made to aboli% ! matriculation subscription ) ! express object ( attract+ ,diss5t]s1 & to get ,p>liam5t to =ce ! *ange on ! ,univ]sity if ! ,univ]sity resi/$1 b ! proposal itself 0 v9dicat$ & en=c$ 9 a pamphlet by ,dr4 ,hampd5 by a def9ite & precise !ory :i* /opp$ n %ort ( ! position t all cre$s & =mul>ies--ev]y?+ :i* repres5t$ ! au?ority ( ! tea*+ ,*ur*--h[ev] incid5tally & tempor>ily useful1 7 9 _! own nature ! inv5tions ( a mi/ak5 & corrupt philosophy1 & invasions ( ,*ri/ian lib]ty4 ,?is 0 cutt+ deep ) a v5geance1 ?\gh ! au?or ( ! !ory seem$ alone unable to see x4 ,x w5t to ! root ( ! :ole mutt]2 & if ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 "r1 !re 0 nei!r ,*ur* nor doctr9e wor? cont5d+ =1 except z m5 cont5d ab\t ! ,newtonian or ! undulatory !ory ( light4 ,no "o ought n[ to affect1 z "s p us$ to affect at ! "t1 t ! "q 0 ( second>y importance1 & turn$ ma9ly on ! special fitness ( ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles to be (f]$ = ! pro( ( a "y man's belief4 ,x 0 a mu* m critical "q4 ,x 0 really1 h[ev] disguis$1 ! "q1 ask$ !n = ! fir/ "t1 & s9ce f9ally decid$1 :e!r ,ox=d 0 to cont9ue to be a s*ool ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&2 & x also involv$ ! wid] "q1 :at "p belief 9 def9ite religion %\ld h 9 high] education4 ,x is speci\sly said t y h no "r to =e/all a "y man's inquiries & convictions by impos+ on him 9 8 e>ly ye>s op9ions :i* to him become prejudices4 ,& if ! _w consi/$ simply ( individuals1 entirely insulat$ & self-suffic+2 if m5 c\ld be taught any?+ :atev]1 )\t presum+ :at is believ$ by ^? :o tea* !m2 & if ! attempt to exclude religi\s prejudice did n necess>ily1 by ! m]e =ce ( ! attempt1 involve ! creation ( anti-religi\s prejudice1 ^! reason]s1 :o try 9 va9 to get out ( ! conditions :i* hem !m 91 might h m to say = !mselves4 ,to ! m5 :o _h made su* an ef=t to re/ore a liv+ confid5ce 9 ! ,*ur*1 ! dem& impli$ giv+ up all t !y _h done & all t !y hop$ =4 ,x 0 n ! "t = yield+ ev5 a clumsy pro( ( ! religi\s "* ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,& ! beg9n+ ( a long & d\btful w> 0 inevitable4 ,a w> ( pamphlets ensu$4 ,by ! "o side ! di/9ction 0 /rongly insi/$ on betwe5 m]e in/ruction & education1 ! di/9ctly religi\s "* ( ! ,univ]sity education 0 n p]haps ov]/at$ 9 its !ory1 b portray$ 9 /rong] col\rs ?an 0 ev]y:]e ! fact2 & ass]tions 7 made1 :i* s\nd /range 9 _! boldness n[1 ( ! indep5d5t & con/itutional "r to self-gov]nm5t 9 ! great ,univ]sity corporations4 ,by ! o!r side1 ! ord9>y argum5ts 7 us$1 ab\t ! inju/ice & mis*ief ( exclusion1 & ! hurtfulness ( te/s1 especially su* te/s z ! ,articles appli$ to "y & ignorant m54 ,two pamphlets _h m ?an a pass+ int]e/3 "o1 by a !n unkn[n writ] :o sign$ himself ,ru/icus1 & ^: "n 0 ,mr4 ,f4,d4 ,maurice1 def5d$ subscription on ! gr\nd t ! ,articles 7 sign$1 n z te/s & confessions ( fai?1 b z conditions ( ?\ght1 ! expressly /at$ conditions1 su* z !re mu/ be 9 all tea*+1 "u :i* ! le>n]s are will+ to le>n & ! tea*] to tea*3 & he develop$ 8 view at great l5g?1 ) great weal? ( orig9al ?\ght & illu/ration & mu* eloqu5ce1 b ) t fatal want ( cle>ness :i*1 z s (t5 aft]w>ds1 came f 8 /ruggles to embrace 9 "o l>ge view :at appe>$ opposite aspects ( a difficult subject4 ,! o!r 0 ! pamphlet1 already ref]r$ to1 by ,dr4 ,hampd53 & ( :i* ! importance arose1 n f its conclusions1 b f its reasons4 ,its gr\nd 0 ! di/9ction :i* he _h argu$ out at great l5g? 9 8 ,bampton ,lectures--! di/9ction betwe5 ! ,div9e facts ( revelation1 & all human int]pretations ( !m & inf]5ces f !m4 ,div9e facts1 he ma9ta9$1 7 ( c\rse b9d+ on all ,*ri/ians1 & 9 matt] ( fact 7 accept$ by all :o call$ !mselves ,*ri/ians1 includ+ ,unit>ians4 ,human int]pretations & inf]5ces--& all ,*ur* =mul>ies 7 su*--7 b9d+ on no "o b ^? :o _h reason to ?9k !m true2 & !re=e lea/ ( all on und]graduates :o c\ld n h exam9$ !m4 ,! di/9ction1 :5 fir/ put =w>d1 seem$ to mean mu*2 at a lat] "t x 0 expla9$ to mean v little4 ,b at pres5t its value z a gr\nd ( argum5t aga9/ ! old sy/em ( ! ,univ]sity 0 ?\ght mu* ( by its au?or & 8 fri5ds4 ,a w>n+ note 0 at once giv5 t its significance 0 p]ceiv$ & appreciat$4 ,mr4 ,newman1 9 ackn[l$g+ a pres5tation copy1 add$ words :i* =e%ad[$ mu* t 0 to foll[4 ,:ile ,i respect1 he wrote1 ! tone ( piety :i* ! pamphlet displays1 ,i d>e n tru/ myself to put on pap] my feel+s ab\t ! pr9ciples conta9$ 9 x2 t5d+1 z !y d1 9 my op9ion1 to make %ip-wreck ( ,*ri/ian fai?4 ,i also lam5t t1 by its appe>ance1 ! fir/ /ep has be5 tak5 t[>ds int]rupt+ t peace & mutual good und]/&+ :i* has prevail$ s long 9 ?is place1 & :i*1 if once s]i\sly di/urb$1 w be succe$$ by discussions ! m intractable1 because ju/ifi$ 9 ! m9ds ( ^? :o resi/ innovation by a feel+ ( imp]ative duty4 ,s9ce t "t1 he goes on 9 ! ,apologia1 :]e he quotes ?is lett]1 ,phaeton has got into ! *>iot ( ! sun4#ee ,b !y 7 e>ly days !n2 & :5 ! ,heads ( ,h\ses1 :o ! ye> be=e _h jo9$ ) ! great body ( ! ,univ]sity 9 a decl>ation aga9/ ! ?reat5$ legislation1 7 p]suad$ to propose to ! ,ox=d ,convocation ! abolition ( subscription at matriculation 9 ,may #ahce1 ?is proposal 0 reject$ by a majority ( five to "o4 ,?is l>ge majority 0 a g5u9e expression ( ! s5se ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,x 0 n specially a ,tract>ian success1 ?\gh mo/ ( ! argum5ts :i* contribut$ to x came f m5 :o m or less sympa?is$ ) ! ef=t to make a vigor\s fight = ! ,*ur* & its tea*+2 & x %[$ t !y :o _h made ! ef=t _h t\*$ spr+s ( ?\ght & feel+1 & awak5$ new hopes & int]e/ 9 ^? ar\nd !m1 9 ,ox=d1 & 9 ! c\ntry4 ,b grav] ev5ts 7 at h&4 ,t[>ds ! end ( ! ye> 7#ahce71 ,dr4 ,burton1 ! ,regius ,pr(essor ( ,div9ity1 sudd5ly di$1 /ill a "y man4 ,& ,"l ,melb\rne 0 induc$ to appo9t z 8 successor1 & z ! head ( ! !ological tea*+ ( ! ,univ]sity1 ! writ] :o _h j a second "t seem$ to lay ! axe to ! root ( all !ology2 :o _h j reass]t$ t he look$ ^u cre$s1 & all ! docum5ts :i* embodi$ ! traditional doctr9e & collective ?\ght ( ! ,*ur*1 z inve/$ by ignorance & prejudice ) an au?ority :i* 0 )\t f\ndation1 & :i* 0 mislead+ & mis*iev\s4 ,,footnotes3 #eb ,! conv]sation betwe5 ,mr4 ,sikes ( ,guilsbor\gh & ,mr4 ,copel& is giv5 9 full 9 ,dr4 ,pusey's ,lett] to ! ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury 7#ahdb71 pp4 #cb-cd4 #ec ,dr4 ,wilson 0 mightily pleas$ ) my call+ ! traditionals ! ',*ildr5 ( ! ,mi/4' ,! title ( ',veil$ ,prophets' he ?\ght too sev]e 7#ahch71 ,life1 ed4 #ahge1 p4 #afg4 ,comp>e ,h9ts to ,transc5d5tali/s = ,work+ ,infidel ,designs ?r\gh ,tract>ianism1 a jeu d'esprit 7#ahdj71 ib4 p4 #ahh4 ,z = ! suspicion ( secret infidelity1 ,i h said no m ?an ,i s9c]ely feel1 ib4 p4 #aha4 #ed ,x w\ld be a curi\s ?+ if y 7! ,provo/ ( ,oriel7 7 to br+ into y\r ,bampton ,lectures a m5tion ( ! ,?ugs4444 ,obs]ve _! submissive piety1 _! fai? 9 long-pres]v$ tradition1 _! regul> succession ( ord9ations to _! (fices1 _! fai? 9 ! sacram5tal virtue ( ! consecrat$ gov]nor2 9 %ort1 comp>e our religion ) ! ,?uggee1 putt+ out ( acc\nt all ^? consid]ations :i* ! traditioni/s deprecate ! discussion (1 & :]e is ! diff]5ce8 7#ahdj71 ib4 p4 #aid4 #ee ,apologia1 pp4 #aca1 #acb4 ,,*apt] ,,ix ,,dr4 ,,hampd5 ,! /age on :i* :at is call$ ! ,ox=d movem5t ran ?r\gh its c\rse _h a special "* ( its own1 unlike ! circum/ances 9 :i* o!r religi\s ef=ts _h done _! "w4 ,! sc5e ( ,jans5ism _h be5 a great capital1 a brilliant society1 ! prec9cts ( a c\rt1 ! cells ( a conv5t1 ! /udies & libr>ies ( ! doctors ( ! ,sorbonne1 ! c\ncil *amb]s ( ! ,vatican4 ,! sc5e ( ,me?odism _h be5 ,engli% villages & c\ntry t[ns1 ! moors ( ,cornwall1 & ! colli]ies ( ,bri/ol1 at l5g? ,london fa%ionable *apels4 ,! sc5e ( ?is new movem5t 0 z l z x c\ld be 9 our mod]n _w to a ,greek polis1 or an ,italian self-c5tr$ city ( ! ,middle ,ages4 ,ox=d /ood by itself 9 its mead[s by ! riv]s1 hav+ its relations ) all ,engl&1 b1 l its si/] at ,cambridge1 liv+ a life ( its own1 unlike t ( any o!r spot 9 ,engl&1 ) its privileg$ p[]s1 & exemptions f ! g5]al law1 ) its special mode ( gov]nm5t & police1 its usages & ta/es & traditions1 & ev5 co/ume1 :i* ! re/ ( ,engl& look$ at f ! outside1 mu* int]e/$ b mu* puzzl$1 or knew only by transi5t visits4 ,& ,ox=d 0 z pr\d & jeal\s ( its own ways z ,a!ns or ,flor5ce2 & l !m x _h its qua9t fa%ions ( polity2 its democratic ,convocation & its olig>*y2 its social ranks2 its discipl9e1 sev]e 9 !ory & usually lax 9 fact2 its self-gov]n$ bodies & corporations )9 itself2 its faculties & colleges1 l ! guilds & arts ( ,flor5ce2 its int]nal rivalries & discords2 its sets & factions4 ,l ^!1 too1 x pr(ess$ a special recognition ( ! supremacy ( religion2 x claim$ to be a home ( wor%ip & religi\s tra9+1 ,dom9us illum9atio mea1 a claim too (t5 falsifi$ 9 ! habit & temp]s ( life4 ,x 0 a small sph]e1 b x 0 a conspicu\s "o2 = !re 0 mu* /rong & en]getic "*1 br\ght out by ! aims & conditions ( ,univ]sity life2 & ?\gh mov+ 9 a sep>ate orbit1 ! influ5ce ( ! fam\s place ov] ! outside ,engl&1 ?\gh imp]fectly und]/ood1 0 recognis$ & great4 ,^! conditions affect$ ! "* ( ! movem5t1 & ( ! conflicts :i* x caus$4 ,ox=d claim$ to be em95tly ! gu>dian ( true religion & s\nd le>n+2 & !re=e x 0 em95tly ! place :]e religion %\ld be recall$ to its purity & /r5g?1 & also ! place :]e !re ought to be ! mo/ vigilant jeal\sy aga9/ ! p]v]sions & corruptions ( religion1 ,ox=d 0 a place :]e e "o knew 8 neighb\r1 & measur$ him1 & 0 m or less fri5dly or repell5t2 :]e ! cu/oms ( life br\ght m5 toge!r e day & all day1 9 conv]se or discussion2 & :]e e fre% /atem5t or e new /ep tak5 furni%$ endless mat]ial = speculation or debate1 9 common rooms or 9 ! aft]noon walk4 ,& = ?is reason1 too1 feel+s 7 apt to be m ke5 & int5se & p]sonal ?an 9 ! l>g] sc5es ( life2 ! man :o 0 dislik$ or di/ru/$ 0 s close to 8 neighb\rs t he 0 m irritat+ ?an if he _h be5 obscur$ by a cr[d2 ! man :o attract$ confid5ce & k9dl$ en?usiasm1 ^: voice 0 cont9ually 9 m5's e>s1 & ^: private conv]sation & life 0 some?+ ev] new 9 its sympa?y & *>m1 creat$ 9 ^? ab\t him n m]e admiration1 b passionate fri5d%ip1 or unres]v$ disciple%ip4 ,& ^! feel+s pass$ f individuals into p>ties2 ! small factions ( a limit$ area4 ,m5 /ruck bl[s & lov$ & hat$ 9 ^? days 9 ,ox=d z !y h>dly did on ! wid] /age ( ,london politics or g5]al religi\s controv]sy4 ,! conflicts :i* = a "t turn$ ,ox=d into a k9d ( image ( :at ,flor5ce 0 9 ! days ( ,savon>ola1 ) its nicknames1 ,puseyites1 & ,neomaniacs1 & ,high & ,dry1 c\nt]p>ts to ! ,piagnoni & ,arrabbiati1 ( ! old] /rife1 began ar\nd a /ud5t ( retir$ habits1 int]e/$ m ?an 0 usual at ,ox=d 9 ab/ruse philosophy1 & ! la/ p]son :o might be expect$ to be ! occasion ( great diss5sions 9 ! ,univ]sity4 ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 a man :o1 ) no def9ite int5tions ( innovat+ on ! receiv$ doctr9es ( ! ,*ur*--inde$1 z 8 s]mons %[$1 ) a full acceptance ( !m--_h tak5 a v difficult subject = a c\rse ( ,bampton ,lectures1 )\t at all fa?om+ its dep? & rea*1 & _h got into a s]i\s scrape 9 consequ5ce4 ,p]sonally he 0 a man ( s]i\s b cold religion1 hav+ little sympa?y ) o!rs1 & consequ5tly n able to attract any4 ,8 isolation dur+ ! :ole ( 8 c>e] is rem>kable2 he atta*$ no "o1 z ,:ately or ,arnold atta*$ m54 ,8 m9d1 :i* 0 a speculative "o1 0 n "o1 9 its own ord]1 ( ! fir/ class4 ,he _h n ! grasp nor ! subtlety necess>y = 8 task4 ,he _h a c]ta9 p[] ( /atem5t1 b little ( co-ord9ation2 he seems n to h _h ! p[] ( see+ :5 8 ideas 7 really irreconcilable1 & he ?\ght t simply by insi/+ on 8 di/9ctly or?odox /atem5ts he n only balanc$1 b neutralis$1 & did away ) 8 di/9ctly unor?odox ones4 ,he _h read a good deal ( ,ari/otle & some?+ ( ! ,s*oolm51 :i* probably no "o else 9 ,ox=d _h done except ,blanco ,:ite2 & ! temptation ( hav+ read :at no "o else kn[s any?+ ab\t sometimes leads m5 to make an unpr(itable use ( _! special k1 :i* !y consid] _! monopoly4 ,! cre$ & dogmas ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* are at lea/ 9 _! broad features1 n a speculation1 b a fact4 ,t n only ! ,apo/les' ,cre$1 b ! ,nic5e & ,con/ant9opolitan ,cre$s1 are assum$ z facts by ! :ole ( any?+ t c be call$ ! ,*ur*1 is z c]ta9 z ! reception by ! same body1 & = ! same "t1 ( ! ,scriptures4 ,n only ! ,cre$1 b1 up to ! sixte5? c5tury1 ! hi]>*y1 & n only ,cre$ & hi]>*y & ,scriptures1 b ! sacram5tal idea z express$ 9 ! liturgies1 are equally 9 ! same class ( facts4 ,( c\rse x is op5 to any "o to "q ! g5u9e orig9 ( any ( ^! great portions ( ! con/itution ( ! ,*ur*2 b ! ,*ur* is s committ$ to !m t he _c ent] on 8 de/ructive criticism )\t hav+ to criticise1 n "o only1 b all ^! beliefs1 & )\t soon hav+ to face ! "q :e!r ! :ole idea ( ! ,*ur*1 z a real & div9ely orda9$ society1 ) a def9ite doctr9e & belief1 is n a delusion1 & :e!r ,*ri/ianity1 :atev] x is1 is address$ solely to ea* individual1 "o by "o1 to make :at he c ( x4 ,x ne$ h>dly be said t )9 ! limits ( :at ! ,*ur* is committ$ to !re is room = v wide diff]5ces ( op9ion2 x is also true t ^! limits h1 9 diff]5t times ( ! ,*ur*1 be5 illegitimately & mis*iev\sly n>r[$ by prevail+ op9ions1 & by docum5ts & =mul>ies respect+ x4 ,b ?\gh we may claim n to be b\nd by ! ,augsburg ,confession1 or by ! ,lambe? articles1 or ! ,synod ( ,dort1 or ! ,bull ,unig5itus1 x does n foll[ t1 if !re is a ,*ur* at all1 !re is no m b9d+ au?ority 9 ! !ology ( ! ,nic5e & ,a?anasian ,cre$s4 ,& x is ! prov9ce ( ! div9e :o believes 9 a ,*ur* at all1 & 9 its (fice to be ! tea*] & witness ( religi\s tru?1 to di/+ui% betwe5 ! inf9itely v>y+ degrees ( au?ority ) :i* pr(ess$ repres5tations ( portions ( ?is tru? are prop\nd$ = acceptance4 ,x may be difficult or impossible to agree on a !ory ( inspiration2 b t ! ,*ur* doctr9e ( "s k9d ( special inspiration ( ,scripture is "p ( ,*ri/ianity is1 unless ,*ri/ianity be a dream1 c]ta94 ,no "o c reasonably d\bt1 ) hi/ory be=e him1 t ! answ] ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* 01 ! fir/ "t ! "q 0 ask$1 & has cont9u$ to be ?r\gh ages ( controv]sy1 aga9/ ,arianism1 aga9/ ,soc9ianism1 aga9/ ,pelagianism1 aga9/ ,zw+lianism4 ,x does n foll[ t ! ,*ur* has settl$ ev]y?+1 or t !re are n hundr$s ( que/ions :i* x is va9 & presumptu\s to attempt to settle by any alleg$ au?ority4 ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 9 fact unexceptionably1 ev5 rigidly or?odox 9 8 acceptance ( ,*ur* doctr9e & ,*ur* cre$s4 ,he _h publi%$ a volume ( s]mons conta9+1 among o!r ?+s1 an able /atem5t ( ! ,scriptural argum5t = ! doctr9e ( ! ,tr9ity1 & an equally able def5ce ( ! ,a?anasian ,cre$4 ,b he felt t !re are =mul>ies :i* may be only ! int]pretations ( doctr9e & inf]5ces f ,scripture ( a p>ticul> "t or set ( m52 & he 0 desir\s ( putt+ into _! prop] place ! au?ority ( su* =mul>ies4 ,8 object 0 to put an int]val betwe5 !m & ! ,scriptures f :i* !y pr(ess$ to be d]iv$1 & to prev5t !m f claim+ ! comm& ov] fai? & consci5ce :i* 0 due only to ! au!ntic evid5ces ( ,god's revelation4 ,he wi%$ to make room = a deep] s5se ( ! weight ( ,scripture4 ,he propos$ to himself ! same ?+ :i* 0 aim$ at by ! ,g]man div9es1 ,arndt1 ,calixtus1 & ,sp5]1 :5 !y rose up aga9/ ! gr9d+ oppression :i* ,lu!ran dogmatism _h rais$ on its ,symbolical ,books1#ef & :i* _h come to outdo ! wor/ extravagances ( s*ola/icism4 ,?is seems to h be5 8 object--a fair & legitimate "o4 ,b 9 argu+ aga9/ inve/+ ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles ) an au?ority :i* did n belong to !m1 he unque/ionably1 )\t see+ :at he 0 do+1 w5t mu* f>!r--:]e he nev] meant to g4 ,9 fact1 he s /at$ 8 argum5t t he took 9 ) ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles e expression ( collective belief1 e docum5t1 h[ev] v5]able1 :i* ! ,*ur* _h sanction$ f ! fir/4 ,/rangely en\gh1 )\t obs]v+ x1 he took 9--:at he meant to sep>ate by a wide int]val f :at he call$ dogma--! doctr9e ( ! infallible au?ority & suffici5cy ( ,scripture4 ,9 d5y+ ! wor? ( ! cons5sus & immemorial judgm5t ( ! ,*ur*1 he cut f "u him ! claim to t :i* he accept$ z ! s\rce & witness ( div9e facts4 ,he did n mean to d ?is1 or to d _m o!r ?+s2 b f want ( cle>ness ( head1 he c]ta9ly1 9 ^! writ+s :i* 7 compla9$ (1 did x4 ,he 01 9 temp] & habit1 too desir\s to be or?odox1 z ,:ately fe>$1 to accept 9 its consequ5ces 8 own !ory4 ,! !ory :i* he put =w>d 9 8 ,bampton ,lectures1 & on :i* he f\nd$ 8 plan ( compreh5sion 9 8 pamphlet on ,diss5t1 left no?+ /&+ b ! au?ority ( ! lett] ( ,scripture4 ,all else--"r or wrong z x might be--0 speculation1 human inf]5ce1 dogma4 ,) p]fect consi/5cy1 he did n pret5d to take ev5 ! ,cre$s out ( ?is category4 ,b ! tru? 01 he did n consci\sly mean all t he said2 & :5 ke5] & m p[]ful & m !ological m9ds po9t$ out ) rel5tless accuracy :at he _h said he 0 pr(use & ov]fl[+ ) explanations1 :i* %[$ h[ little he _h p]ceiv$ ! drift ( 8 words4 ,!re is n ! lea/ reason to d\bt ! s9c]ity ( ^! explanations2 b at ! same "t !y %[$ ! unfitness ( a man :o _h s to expla9 away 8 own speculations to be ! (ficial guide & tea*] ( ! cl]gy4 ,! criticisms on 8 language1 & ! objections to x1 7 made be=e ^! explanations 7 giv52 & ?\gh he gave !m1 he 0 furi\s ) ^? :o call$ = !m1 & he nev] = a mom5t admitt$ t !re 0 any?+ s]i\sly wrong or mi/ak5 9 :at he _h said4 ,to ^? :o po9t$ out ! mean+ & effect ( 8 words & !ories1 he repli$ by ! ass]tion ( 8 p]sonal belief4 ,if words mean any?+1 he _h said t nei!r ,unit>ians nor any "o else c\ld get beh9d ! b>e lett]1 & :at he call$ facts1 ( ,scripture1 :i* all equally accept$ 9 good fai?2 & t !re=e !re 0 no reason = exclud+ ,unit>ians z long z !y accept$ ! facts4 ,b :5 x 0 po9t$ out t ?is reason+ r$uc$ all belief 9 ! realities beh9d ! b>e lett] to ! level ( p]sonal & private op9ion1 he answ]$ by say+ t he valu$ supremely ! ,cre$s & ,articles1 & by giv+ a /atem5t ( ! great ,*ri/ian doctr9es :i* he held1 & :i* ! ,*ur* taught4 ,b he nev] expla9$ :at _! au?ority c\ld be ) any "o b himself4 ,!re might be int]pretations & inf]5ces f ,scripture1 by ! hundr$ or ! ?\s&1 b no "o c]ta9 & au?oritative "o2 none t w>rant$ an organis$ ,*ur*1 mu* m a ,ca?olic & ,apo/olic ,*ur*1 f\nd$ on ! assumption ( ?is int]pretation be+ ! "o true fai?1 ! "o tru? ( ! ,bible4 ,! po9t 0 br\ght out =cibly 9 a fam\s pamphlet writt5 by ,mr4 ,newman1 ?\gh )\t 8 "n1 call$ ,elucidations ( ,dr4 ,hampd5's ,!ological ,/atem5ts4 ,?is pamphlet 0 a fav\rite object ( attack on ! "p ( ,dr4 ,hampd5's support]s z a flagrant in/ance ( unfairness & g>bl$ extracts4 ,no "o1 !y said1 ev] read ! ,bampton ,lectures1 b took _! e/imate ( ! "w f ,mr4 ,newman's quotations4 ,extracts are (t5 op5 to ! *>ge ( unfairness1 & always to suspicion4 ,b 9 ?is case !re 0 no ne$ ( unfairness4 ,dr4 ,hampd5's !ory lay on ! v surface ( 8 ,hampton ,lectures & pamphlet2 & any unbiass$ judge may be *all5g$ to read ^! works ( 81 & say :e!r ! extracts 9 ! ,elucidations d n adequately repres5t ,dr4 ,hampd5's /atem5ts & argum5ts1 & :e!r ! comm5ts on !m are =c$ or /ra9$4 ,!y d n repres5t 8 explanations1 = ! explanations _h n be5 giv52 & :5 ! explanations came1 ?\gh !y said _m ?+s :i* %[$ t ,dr4 ,hampd5 did n mean to be unor?odox & unevangelical1 b only anti-s*ola/ic & anti-,roman1 !y did n unsay a ^w :i* he _h said4 ,& :at ?is 01 :at _h be5 ,dr4 ,hampd5's pr(ess$ !ological !ory up to ! "t :5 ! ,univ]sity he>d ! news ( 8 appo9tm5t1 ! ,elucidations repres5t z fairly z any adv]se /atem5t c repres5t ! subject ( its attack4 ,9 quiet] times su* an appo9tm5t might h pass$ ) no?+ m ?an a pap] controv]sy or prote/1 or m probably )\t m ?an conv]sational criticism4 ,b ^! wore n quiet & unsuspici\s times4 ,!re 0 reason = disquiet4 ,x 0 fre% 9 m5's m9ds :at language & speculation l t ( ! ,bampton ,lectures _h come to 9 ! case ( ,:ately's intimate fri5d1 ,blanco ,:ite4 ,! unque/ionable ho/ility ( ,:ately's s*ool to ! old ideas ( ! ,*ur* _h r\s$ al>m & a /rong _s ( resi/ance 9 ,*ur*m54 ,ea* p>ty 0 on ! wat*1 & !re c]ta9ly 0 some?+ at /ake = bo? p>ties4 ,c\pl$ ) "s rec5t ev5ts1 & ) ! "p :i* ,dr4 ,hampd5 _h tak5 on ! subscription "q1 ! appo9tm5t naturally seem$ significant4 ,probably x 0 n s significant z x seem$ on ! "p at lea/ ( ,"l ,melb\rne1 :o _h tak5 pa9s to f9d a fit man4 ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 said to h be5 recomm5d$ by ,bi%op ,cople/on1 & n disall[$ by ,ar*bi%op ,h[ley4 ,9 ! ,univ]sity1 up to ?is "t1 !re _h be5 no au?oritative prote/ aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd5's writ+s4 ,& !re 7 n _m ,lib]als to *oose f4 ,9 ! appo9tm5t !re is h>dly suffici5t gr\nd to blame ,"l ,melb\rne4 ,b ! outcry aga9/ x at ,ox=d1 :5 x came1 0 s in/antane\s1 s /rong1 & s unusual1 t x might h w>n$ ,"l ,melb\rne t he _h be5 l$ into a mi/ake1 out ( :i* x w\ld be wise to seek at lea/ a way ( escape4 ,d\btless x 0 a /rong measure = ! ,univ]sity to prote/ z x did2 b x 0 also a /rong measure1 at lea/ 9 ^? days1 = a ,m9i/] ( ! ,cr[n to =ce s extremely unacceptable a ,regius ,pr(essor ( ,div9ity on a great ,univ]sity4 ,dr4 ,hampd5 (f]$ to resign2 & !re w\ld h be5 pl5ty ( opportunities to comp5sate him = 8 sacrifice ( a po/ :i* c\ld only be a pa9ful "o4 ,b ! temp] ( bo? sides 0 up4 ,! remon/rances f ,ox=d 7 treat$ ) some?+ l contempt1 & ! affair 0 hurri$ ?r\gh till !re 0 no retreat+2 & ,dr4 ,hampd5 became ,regius ,pr(essor4 ,mr4 ,palm] has record$ h[ v>i\s ef=ts 7 made to neutralise ! effect ( ! appo9tm5t4 ,b ! ,heads ( ,h\ses1 ?\gh angry1 7 cauti\s4 ,!y evad$ ! responsibility ( /at+ ,dr4 ,hampd5's uns\nd positions2 b to m>k _! di/ru/1 br\ght 9 a proposal to deprive him ( 8 vote 9 ! *oice ( ,select ,prea*]s till ! ,univ]sity %\ld o!rwise det]m9e4 ,x 0 defeat$ 9 ,convocation by ! veto ( ! two ,proctors 7,m>* #ahcf71 :o ex]cis$ _! "r ) ! full approval ( ,dr4 ,hampd5's fri5ds1 & ! indignation ( ! l>ge majority ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,b x 0 n unfairly us$3 x c\ld h only a susp5d+ effect1 ( :i* no "o _h a "r to compla92 & :5 new ,proctors came into (fice1 ! proposal 0 introduc$ aga91 & c>ri$ 7,may #ahcf7 by #dgd to #id4 ,! ,lib]al m9ority _h increas$ s9ce ! vote on subscription1 & ,dr4 ,hampd5 w5t on ) 8 "w z if no?+ _h happ5$4 ,! attempt 0 twice made to resc9d ! vote3 fir/1 aft] ! outcry ab\t ! ,n9etie? ,tract & ! conte/ ab\t ! ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip1 by a simple repeal1 :i* 0 reject$ by #ccd to #bai 7,june #ahdb72 & next1 indirectly by a /atute enl>g+ ! ,pr(essor's p[]s ov] ,div9ity degrees1 :i* 0 also reject$ by #cda to #ba 7,may #ahdd74 ,f fir/ to la/1 ^! ?+s & o!rs 7 ! un=tunate incid5ts ( an un=tunate appo9tm5t4 ,! p]secution ( ,dr4 ,hampd5 has be5 an unfail+ subject ( reproa* to ! p>ty ( ! ,ox=d movem5t1 s9ce ! days :5 ! ,ed9burgh ,review held !m up to public scorn & hatr$ 9 an article ( /range viol5ce4 ,!y c]ta9ly _h _! full %>e 9 ! opposition to him1 & 9 ! measures by :i* t opposition 0 c>ri$ out4 ,b x w\ld be ! greate/ mi/ake to suppose t 9 ?is matt] !y /ood alone4 ,all 9 ! ,univ]sity at ?is "t1 except a small m9ority1 7 ( "o m9d1 ,heads ( ,h\ses & c\ntry p>sons1 ,evangelicals & ,high ,*ur*m5--all :o felt t ! gr\nds ( a def9ite belief 7 s]i\sly ?reat5$ by ,dr4 ,hampd5's speculations4 ,all 7 angry at ! appo9tm5t2 all 7 agre$ t some?+ ought to be done to h9d] ! mis*ief ( x4 ,9 ?is matt] ,mr4 ,newman & 8 fri5ds 7 absolutely at "o ) ev]ybody r\nd !m1 ) ^? :o 7 soon to be _! implacable oppon5ts4 ,:atev] deep] view !y might h ( ! evil :i* _h be5 done by ! appo9tm5t1 & h[ev] mu* grav] & m p]man5t _! objections to x1 !y 7 responsible only z ! :ole ,univ]sity 0 responsible = :at 0 done aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd54 ,x 0 conv5i5t aft]w>ds to s+le !m out1 & to ?r[ ?is responsibility & ! odium ( x on !m alone2 & :5 !y came "u ! popul> ban1 x 0 =gott5 t ,dr4 ,gilb]t1 ! ,pr9cipal ( ,bras5ose1 ,dr4 ,symons1 ! ,w>d5 ( ,wadham1 ,dr4 ,faussett1 aft]w>ds ! d5\nc] ( ,dr4 ,pusey1 ,mr4 ,vaughan ,?omas1 & ,mr4 ,hill ( ,/4 ,edmund ,hall1 7 q z =w>d at ! "t z ,dr4 ,pusey & ,mr4 ,newman 9 prote/+ aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd51 & 9 ! /eps to make _! prote/ effective4 ,mr4 ,palm]1 9 8 ,n>rative1#eg anxi\s to dissociate himself f ! movem5t "u ,mr4 ,newman's influ5ce1 has p]haps und]rat$ ! "p tak5 by ,mr4 ,newman & ,dr4 ,pusey2 = !y1 any rate1 did mo/ ( ! argum5tative "w4 ,b z f> z p]sonal action goes1 x is true1 z he says1 t ! movem5t aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 n guid$ by ! ,tract writ]s4 ,! condemnation ( ,dr4 ,hampd51 !n1 0 n c>ri$ by ! ,tract writ]s2 x 0 c>ri$ by ! indep5d5t body ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,! fact is t1 _h ^? writ]s tak5 any lead+ "p1 ! measure w\ld h be5 a failure1 = ! numb] ( _! fri5ds at t "t 0 a v small proportion to ! ,univ]sity at l>ge1 & !re 0 a g5]al feel+ ( di/ru/ 9 ! s\ndness ( _! views4 ,we are a long way f ^? days 9 "t1 & /ill m 9 habits & s5tim5t2 & a manifold & v>i$ exp]i5ce has taught mo/ ( u "s lessons aga9/ impati5ce & viol5t measures4 ,b if we put ourselves back equitably into ! ways ( ?9k+ preval5t !n1 ! excitem5t ab\t ,dr4 ,hampd5 w n seem s unreasonable or s unju/ifiable z x is sometimes assum$ to be4 ,! ,univ]sity legislation1 inde$1 to :i* x l$ 0 poor & petty1 do+ small & annoy+ ?+s1 because ! ,univ]sity rul]s d>$ n commit !mselves to def9ite *>ges4 ,b1 9 ! fir/ place1 ! provocation 0 great on ! "p ( ! ,gov]nm5t 9 putt+ into ! *ief !ological *air an unwelcome man :o c\ld only save 8 or?odoxy by mak+ 8 speculations mean next to no?+--^: prim facie ungu>d$ & />tl+ /atem5ts 7 resolv$ into truisms put 9 a gr& & obscure =m4 ,& 9 ! next place1 x 0 assum$ 9 ^? days to be ! mo/ natural & obvi\s ?+ 9 ! _w to condemn uns\nd doctr9e1 & to exclude uns\nd tea*]s4 ,! pr9ciple 0 accept$ z indisputable1 h[ev] slack might h be5 9 rec5t times ! application ( x4 ,t x 0 accept$1 n on "o side only1 b on all1 0 soon to be %[n by ! subsequ5t c\rse ( ev5ts4 ,no "o suff]$ m sev]ely & m p]si/5tly f its application ?an ! ,tract>ians2 no "o 0 m ready to apply x to !m ?an ,dr4 ,hampd5 ) 8 fri5ds2 no "o approv$ & enc\rag$ its vigor\s en=cem5t aga9/ !m m ?an ,dr4 ,:ately4 ,! idle di/9ction set up1 t !y 7 n m]ely uns\nd b di%one/1 0 a m]e insol5t pretext to save tr\ble 9 argum5t1 & to height5 ! *>ge aga9/ !m2 no "o c\ld s]i\sly d\bt t !y wrote 9 good fai? z mu* z ,dr4 ,:ately or ,dr4 ,faussett4 ,b unless acts l ,dr4 ,pusey's susp5sion1 & ! long proscription t w5t on = ye>s aft] x1 7 m]e in/ances ( v9dictive retaliation1 ! reproa* ( p]secution mu/ be %>$ by all p>ties !n1 & by none m ?an by ! p>ty :i* 9 g5]al t]ms mo/ d5\nc$ x4 ,^? :o ?9k ! ,hampd5 agitation unique 9 its inju/ice ought to ask !mselves :at _! p>ty w\ld h done if at any "t betwe5 #ahcf & #ahdc ,mr4 ,newman _h be5 plac$ 9 ,dr4 ,hampd5's seat4 ,p 9 our days mean by religi\s p]secution :at happ5s :5 ! same sort ( repressive policy is appli$ to a religi\s p>ty z is appli$ to vacc9ation recusants1 or to ! ,peculi> ,p4 ,all religi\s p]secution1 f ! days ( ,socrates1 has tak5 a legal =m1 & ju/ifi$ itself on legal gr\nds4 ,x is ! action ( au?ority1 or ( /rong social judgm5ts back$ by au?ority1 aga9/ a set ( op9ions1 or ! expression ( !m 9 ^w or act--usually innovat+ op9ions1 b n by any means necess>ily su*4 ,! disciples ( ,m4 ,monod1 ! ,momi]s ( ,g5eva1 7 p]secut$ by ! ,lib]als ( ,g5eva1 n because !y broke away f ! cre$ ( ,calv91 b because !y adh]$ to x4 ,! ^w is n prop]ly appli$ to ! incid5tal effects 9 ! way ( disadvantage1 result+ f "s broad con/itutional settlem5t--f ! gov]nm5t ( ! ,*ur* be+ ,episcopal & n ,presbyt]ian1 or its cre$ ,nic5e & n ,arian--any m ?an x is p]secution = a nation to *ange its gov]nm5t1 or = a legitimi/ to h to live "u a republic1 or = a ,*ri/ian to h to live 9 an infidel /ate1 ?\gh p]secution may foll[ f ^! conditions4 ,b ! privilegium pass$ aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 an act ( p]secution1 ?\gh a mild "o comp>$ ) :at aft]w>ds fell on 8 oppon5ts ) 8 full sanction4 ,p]secution is ! natural impulse1 9 ^? :o ?9k a c]ta9 ?+ "r & important or wor? gu>d+1 to disable ^? :o1 ?9k+ x wrong1 are try+ to discr$it & upset x1 & to sub/itute some?+ diff]5t4 ,x implies a /ate ( w>1 & ! resort to ! mo/ available weapons to inflict damage on ^? :o are reg>d$ z rebelli\s & dang]\s4 ,^! weapons 7 =midable en\gh once3 !y are n )\t =ce /ill4 ,b 9 its milde/ =m--p]sonal disqualification or proscription--x is a di/urbance :i* only w> ju/ifies4 ,x may1 ( c\rse1 make itself odi\s by its modes ( proce$+1 by meanness & %abb9ess & viol5ce1 by und]h& & ignoble me?ods ( misrepres5tation & sl&]1 or by cruelty & pla9 inju/ice2 & !n ! odium ( ^! ?+s fairly falls ^u x4 ,b x is v h>d to draw ! l9e betwe5 consci5ti\s repression1 feel+ itself b\nd to d :at is possible to prev5t mis*ief1 & :at ^? :o are oppos$1 if !y are ! weak] p>ty1 ( c\rse call p]secution4 ,if p]secution implies a /ate ( w> 9 :i* "o side is /rong]1 & ! o!r weak]1 x is h>dly a p>adox to say t 7#a7 no "o has a "r to compla9 ( p]secution z su*1 ap>t f odi\s accompanim5ts1 any m ?an ( sup]ior numb]s or h>d bl[s 9 battle2 & 7#b7 t e "o has a "r to take advantage & make ! mo/ ( be+ p]secut$1 by appeals to sympa?y & ! pr9ciple ( do+ z y w\ld be done by4 ,no "o likes to be accus$ ( p]secution1 & few p l to give up ! claim to use x1 if necess>y4 ,b no "o c help obs]v+ 9 ! c\rse ( ev5ts ! /range way 9 :i*1 9 almo/ all cases1 ! :eel comes full circle4 --,*i la fa1 l' aspetti1#eh are "s ( ! expressions ( ,greek awe & ,italian %rewdness repres5t+ ! exp]i5ce ( ! _w on ?is subject2 on a l>ge scale & a small4 ,prote/ants & ,ca?olics1 ,*ur*m5 & ,noncon=mi/s1 h all 9 _! turn made full pro( ( :at seems l a law ( action & reaction4 ,except 9 cases beyond debate1 cases :]e no ju/ification is possible1 ! note ( failure is ^u ?is mode ( repression4 ,provid5ce1 by ! visible ,nemesis :i* x seems always to br+ r\nd1 by ! regul>ity ) :i* x has en=c$ ! rule t infliction & suff]+ are b\nd toge!r & 9 "t duly *ange places1 seems c]ta9ly & cle>ly to h decl>$ aga9/ x4 ,x may be t no innovat+ p>ty has a "r to compla9 ( p]secution2 b ! "q is n = !m4 ,x is = ^? :o h ! p[]1 & :o are tempt$ to ?9k t !y h ! call1 to p]secute4 ,x is = !m to consid] :e!r x is "r1 or wise1 or useful = _! cause2 :e!r x is agreeable to :at seems ! lead+ ( ,provid5ce to h rec\rse to x4 ,,footnotes3 #ef ,see ,pusey's ,!ology ( ,g]many 7#ahbh71 p4 #ah sqq4 #eg ,n>rative pp4 #bi1 #cj1 ed4 #ahda2 p #aca4 ed4 #ahhc4 #eh 1 4 ,aes*4 ,*oeph4 #caj4 ,italian prov]b1 9 ,l&ucci1 ,di>io ,fior5t9o1 #aeac1 p4 #cdc4 ,,*apt] ,x ,,gr[? ,,( ,,! ,,movem5t #ahce-ahdj ,by ! end ( #ahce1 ! b& ( fri5ds1 :om great fe>s & great hopes = ! ,*ur* _h unit$1 & o!rs :o sympa?is$ ) !m bo? )9 & outside ! ,univ]sity1 _h gr[n into :at ^? :o dislik$ !m naturally call$ a p>ty4 ,! ,hampd5 controv]sy1 ?\gh b an episode 9 ! hi/ory ( ! movem5t1 0 an important "o1 & und\bt$ly gave a great impulse to x4 ,dr4 ,hampd5's attitude & language seem$ to be its ju/ification--a palpable in/ance ( :at ! ,*ur* _h to expect4 ,& 9 ?is controv]sy1 ?\gh ! feel+ aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd5's views 0 s widely %>$1 & ?\gh ! majority :i* vot$ aga9/ him 0 a v mix$ "o1 & conta9$ "s :o hop$ t ! next "t !y 7 call$ to vote x might be aga9/ ! ,tract>ians1 yet ! lead]s ( ! movem5t _h und]tak5 ! responsibility1 conspicu\sly & almo/ alone1 ( po9t+ out def9itely & argum5tatively ! objections to ,dr4 ,hampd5's tea*+4 ,! numb] ( ,mr4 ,newman's fri5ds might be1 z ,mr4 ,palm] says1 insignificant1 b x 0 !y :o _h tak5 ! tr\ble to und]/& & give expression to ! true reasons = al>m4#ei ,ev5 9 ?is ha/y & imp]fect way1 ! discussion reveal$ to _m h[ mu* deep] & m v>i\s ! treatm5t ( ! subject 0 9 ! h&s ( ,mr4 ,newman & ,dr4 ,pusey comp>$ ) ! ord9>y criticisms on ,dr4 ,hampd54 ,he _h le>n$ 9 too subtle a s*ool to be mu* t\*$ by ! popul> exceptions to 8 !ories1 h[ev] l\dly express$4 ,! mis*ief 0 mu* deep]4 ,x 0 t he _h1 unconsci\sly1 no d\bt1 und]m9$ ! f\ndation ( def9ite ,*ri/ian belief1 & _h resolv$ x into a philosophy1 s-call$ s*ola/ic1 :i* 0 n[ explod$4 ,x 0 ! s5se ( ! p]il\s issues to :i* ?is dilut$ =m ( ,blanco ,:ite's speculations1 s recklessly patronis$ by ,:ately1 0 lead+ !ological tea*+ 9 ! ,univ]sity1 :i* op5$ ! eyes ( _m to ! mean+ ( ! movem5t1 & br\ght "s fre% fri5ds to its side4 ,!re 0 no attempt to =m a p>ty1 or to proselytise2 !re 0 no organisation1 no di/9ct & recognis$ p>ty m>ks4 ,i w\ld n h x call$ a p>ty1 writes ,dr4 ,newman 9 ! ,apologia4 ,b a p>ty x c\ld n help be+3 quietly & spontane\sly x _h gr[n to be :at community ( ideas1 aims1 & sympa?ies1 naturally1 & )\t blame1 leads m5 to become4 ,& x _h acquir$ a numb] ( recognis$ nicknames1 to fri5ds & enemies ! sign ( gr[+ conc5tration4 ,= ! que/ions />t$ 9 ! ,tracts & outside !m became ( increas+ int]e/ to ! m intellig5t m5 :o _h f9i%$ _! ,univ]sity c\rse & 7 prep>+ to ent] into life1 ! ,ba*elors & y\ng] ,ma/]s ( ,arts4 ,"o by "o !y pass$ f v>i\s /ates ( m9d--ali5ation1 suspicion1 fe>1 indiff]5ce1 blank ignorance--into a consci\sness t some?+ beyond ! m]e commonplace ( religi\s novelty & ecc5tricity1 ( :i* !re _h be5 a good deal rec5tly1 0 be=e !m2 t doctr9es & /atem5ts runn+ c\nt] to ! receiv$ religi\s language ( ! day1 doctr9es ab\t :i*1 9 confid5t prejudice1 !y _h p]haps b&i$ ab\t (f-h& judgm5ts1 _h m to say = !mselves ?an 0 ?\ght at fir/2 t ! que/ions ?us rais$ drove !m 9 on !mselves1 & appeal$ to _! hone/y & s]i\sness2 & t1 at any rate1 9 ! m5 :o 7 arre/+ s mu* att5tion1 h[ev] extravagant _! tea*+ might be call$1 !re 0 a rem>kable degree ( sob] & res]v$ =ce1 an e>ne/ness ( conviction :i* c\ld n be d\bt$1 an und5iable & subtle p[] ( t\*+ s\ls & attract+ sympa?ies4 ,"o by "o1 & 9 _m diff]5t ways1 ^! "y m5 w5t ?r\gh v>i\s /ages ( curiosity1 ( surprise1 ( p]plexity1 ( d\bt1 ( misgiv+1 ( int]e/2 "s 7 fright5$1 & wav]$1 & drew back m or less reluctantly2 o!rs1 9 spite ( !mselves1 9 spite ( oppos+ influ5ces1 7 l$ on /ep by /ep1 h>dly kn[+ :i!r1 by a spell :i* !y c\ld n resi/1 ( intellectual1 or /ill m1 moral pressure4 ,"s f\nd _! old home tea*+ complet$1 expla9$1 light$ up1 by t ( ! new s*ool4 ,o!rs1 %ock$ at fir/ at he>+ ! old wat*words & traditions ( _! homes decri$ & put aside1 f\nd !mselves1 :5 !y lea/ expect$ x1 pass+ f ! lett] to ! _s1 f ! te*nical & =mal !ory to ! wide & liv+ tru?4 ,& ?us1 ?\gh _m ( c\rse held alo(1 & n a few became ho/ile1 a l>ge numb]1 "o by "o1 "s rapidly1 o!rs sl[ly1 "s unres]v$ly1 o!rs ) l>ge & jeal\s res]ves1 m & m took 9 ! lead+ idea ( ! movem5t1 accept$ ! influ5ce ( its *iefs1 & look$ to !m = in/ruction & guidance4 ,z x naturally happ5s1 :5 a numb] ( m9ds are drawn toge!r by a common & /rong int]e/1 "s m51 by circum/ances1 or by /r5g? ( conviction1 or by ! mutual aff9ities ( ta/es & "*1 came m & m into direct p]sonal & intimate relations ) ! lead]s1 took s]vice1 z x 71 "u !m1 & prep>$ to ?r[ !mselves into _! plans ( "w4 ,o!rs1 9 v>i\s moods1 b m indep5d5t1 m critical1 m di/urb$ ab\t consequ5ces1 or unp]suad$ on special po9ts1 =m$ a k9d ( fr+e ( fri5dly neutrality ab\t ! m ?or\ghgo+ portion ( ! p>ty4 ,& outside ( ^! 7 ?\ghtful & able m51 to :om ! :ole movem5t1 ) mu* t 0 utt]ly displeas+ & utt]ly p]plex+1 _h ! int]e/ ( be+ a break-up ( /agnation & dull indol5ce 9 a place :i* ought to h ! highe/ spiritual & intellectual aims2 :o1 :atev] repell$ !m1 c\ld n help feel+ t great ideas1 great prospects1 a new outbur/ ( bold ?\ght1 a new ef=t ( moral purpose & =ce1 _h di/urb$ ! old r\t9e2 c\ld n help be+ fasc9at$1 if only z by a spectacle1 by ! /range & unwont$ tea*+1 :i* p>tly made !m smile1 p>tly p]haps p]man5tly disgu/$ !m1 b :i* also1 !y c\ld n d5y1 spoke 9 a language m fe>less1 m pa!tic1 m subtle1 & yet m human1 ?an !y _h he>d f ! religi\s tea*]s ( ! day4 ,& ?us ! circle ( p]sons int]e/$ 9 ! ,tracts1 ( p]sons :o sympa?is$ ) _! views1 ( p]sons :o m & m gave a w>m & e>ne/ adh]5ce to !m1 0 gradually ext5d$ 9 ! ,univ]sity--&1 9 "t1 9 ! c\ntry also4 ,! tru? 0 t ! movem5t1 9 its _m sides1 _h almo/ monopolis$ = ! "t bo? ! intellig5ce & ! highe/ religi\s e>ne/ness ( ! ,univ]sity1#fj & ei!r 9 curiosity or inquiry1 9 approval or 9 condemnation1 all t 0 deepe/ & mo/ vigor\s1 all t 0 mo/ ref9$1 mo/ s]i\s1 mo/ high-ton$1 & mo/ promis+ 9 ,ox=d 0 drawn to ! issues :i* x rais$4 ,x is h>dly too mu* to say t :]ev] m5 spoke s]i\sly ( ! gr\nds & prospects ( religion1 9 ,ox=d1 or 9 ,vacation read+-p>ties1 9 _! walks & social meet+s1 9 _! /udies or 9 common-room1 ! ,tract>ian doctr9es1 :e!r ass5t$ to or laugh$ at1 deplor$ or fi]cely d5\nc$1 7 sure to come to ! front4 ,all subjects 9 discussion seem$ to lead up to !m--art & poetry1 ,go?ic ar*itecture & ,g]man romance & pa9t+1 ! philosophy ( language1 & ! novels ( ,walt] ,scott & ,miss ,au/51 ,col]idge's transc5d5talism & ,bi%op ,butl]'s practical wisdom1 ,plato's ideas & ,ari/otle's analysis4 ,x 0 difficult to keep !m out ( lecture-rooms & exam9ations = ,fell[%ips4 ,b 9 addition to ! intr9sic int]e/ ( ! que/ions & discussions :i* ! movem5t op5$1 p]sonal influ5ce play$ a great & decisive "p 9 x4 ,z x became a p>ty1 x _h *iefs4 ,x 0 n m]ely z lead]s ( ?\ght b z tea*]s ) _! disciples1 z fri5ds ) fri5ds1 z witnesses & examples ( high self-rule & ref9$ purity & goodness1 t ! *iefs ^: names 7 9 all m5's m\?s won ! he>ts & tru/ ( s _m1 9 ! cr[ds t /ood ab\t !m4 ,=emo/1 ( c\rse1 ev] s9ce he _h ?r[n himself into x 9 #ahce1 0 ,dr4 ,pusey4 ,8 position1 8 dignifi$ (fice1 8 le>n+1 8 solidity & s]i\sness ( "*1 8 high /&>d ( religi\s life1 ! *>m ( 8 *>ity1 & ! sweetness ( 8 temp] naturally gave him ! fir/ place 9 ! movem5t 9 ,ox=d & ! _w4 ,x came to be especially associat$ ) him4 ,its enemies fa/5$ on x a nickname f 8 "n1 & ?is nickname1 p>tly f a great] smoo?ness ( s\nd1 p>tly f an odd sugge/ion ( some?+ funny 9 x1 came m into use ?an o!rs2 & ! t]ms ,puseismus1 ,pusisme1 ,pusei/a f\nd _! way into ,g]man lecture-halls & ,p>is salons & remote conv5ts & police (fices 9 ,italy & ,sicily2 inde$1 9 ! %ape ( x might be light$ on 9 a ,greek newspap]4 ,dr4 ,pusey 0 a p]son :o comm&$ ! utmo/ int]e/ & rev]5ce2 he 0 m 9 communication ) ! great _w outside ?an ,ox=d p g5]ally1 & liv$ mu* 9 retirem5t f ,ox=d society2 b to all int]e/$ 9 ! movem5t he 0 its repres5tative & highe/ au?ority4 ,he & ,mr4 ,newman _h ! fulle/ confid5ce 9 "o ano!r1 ?\gh consci\s at times ( n p]fect agreem5t2 yet ea* _h a l9e ( 8 own1 & ea* ( !m 0 apt to d ?+s out ( 8 own head4 ,dr4 ,pusey 0 accessible to all :o wi%$ to see him2 b he did n enc\rage visits :i* wa/$ "t4 ,& ! p]son :o 0 pre-em95tly1 n only be=e _! eyes1 b )9 _! rea* 9 ! ord9>y int]c\rse ( man ) man1 0 ,mr4 ,newman4 ,mr4 ,newman1 :o liv$ 9 ,college 9 ! ord9>y way ( a resid5t ,fell[1 met o!r univ]sity m51 old] or y\ng]1 on equal t]ms4 ,z "t w5t on1 a c]ta9 wond] & awe ga!r$ r\nd him4 ,p 7 a little afraid ( him2 b ! fe> 0 9 !mselves1 n creat$ by any int5tional /iffness or coldness on 8 "p4 ,he did n try to draw m5 to him1 he 0 no proselytis]2 he %rank ) fe> & repugnance f ! "*--x 0 an invasion ( ! privileges ( ! he>t4#fa ,b if m5 came to him1 he 0 accessible2 he all[$ 8 fri5ds to br+ _! fri5ds to him1 & met !m m ?an half-way4 ,he 0 impati5t ( m]e idle worldl9ess1 ( conceit & imp]t95ce1 ( m5 :o gave !mselves airs2 he 0 v impati5t ( pomp\s & solemn empt9ess4 ,b he 0 v pati5t ) ^? :om he believ$ to sympa?ise ) :at 0 ne>e/ 8 he>t2 no "o1 probably1 ( 8 p[] & p5etration & s5se ( ! absurd1 0 ev] s ready to comply ) ! two dem&s :i* a witty prelate propos$ to put into ! exam9ation 9 ! ,consecration ,s]vice ( ,bi%ops3 ,wilt ?\ answ] ?y lett]s8 ,wilt ?\ suff] fools gladly8 ,b c\rte\s1 affable1 easy z he 01 he 0 a ke5 tri] ( "*2 he gaug$1 & m5 felt t he gaug$1 _! motives1 _! reality & s\ndness ( purpose2 he let !m see1 if !y at all came into 8 intimacy1 t if !y 7 n1 he1 at any rate1 0 9 ! deepe/ e>ne/4 ,& at an e>ly p]iod1 9 a memorable s]mon1#fb ! vivid impression ( :i* at ! "t /ill haunts ! recollection ( "s :o he>d x1 he gave w>n+ to 8 fri5ds & to ^? :om 8 influ5ce t\*$1 t no *ild's play lay be=e !m2 t !y 7 mak+1 x might be )\t kn[+ x1 ! ,v5tures ( ,fai?4 ,b feel+ t he _h mu* to say1 & t a univ]sity 0 a place = ! circulation & discussion ( ideas1 he let himself be se5 & kn[n & felt1 bo? publicly & 9 private4 ,he _h 8 breakfa/ p>ties & 8 ev5+ ga!r+s4 ,8 conv]sation rang$ widely1 m>k$ by its peculi> /amp--entire ease1 un/udi$ p]fection ( apt & clean-cut words1 unexpect$ glimpses ( a sure & pi]c+ judgm5t4 ,at times1 at m private meet+s1 ! viol91 :i* he knew h[ to t\*1 came into play4 ,he _h great gifts = lead]%ip4 ,b z a p>ty *ief he 0 also defici5t 9 "s ( ! qualities :i* make a successful "o4 ,8 doctr9e ( ! ,*ur* _h ! disadvantage ( an app>5tly int]m$iate & ambigu\s position1 refus+ ! broad1 intelligible wat*words & reason+s ( popul> religionism4 ,x 0 n )\t cle>ness & /r5g?2 b su* a position naturally (t5 leads to :at seem ov]-subtle modes ( argum5t1 seem+ly ov]-subtle because deep] & m orig9al ?an ! common ones2 & he seem$ sometimes to want sobriety 9 8 use ( dialectic weapons1 :i* he wield$ ) su* =ce & effect4 ,ov]-subtlety 9 ! lead] ( a p>ty t5ds to p]plex fri5ds & give a h&le to oppon5ts4 ,& ) all 8 confid5ce 9 8 cause1 & also 9 8 p[] & 8 call to use x1 he _h a curi\s %yness & self-di/ru/ z to 8 own way ( do+ :at he _h to d2 he 0 afraid ( wilfulness1 ( too great reliance on intellect4 ,he _h long be5 accu/om$ to obs]ve & judge himself1 & :ile consci\s ( 8 =ce1 he 0 fully alive to ! drawbacks1 moral & intellectual1 :i* wait on ! highe/ p[]s4 ,:5 attacks 7 made on him by au?orities1 z 9 ! case ( ! ,tract ,no4 #ij1 8 m eag] fri5ds ?\ght him too submissive2 !y w\ld h lik$ a m combative temp] & w\ld n accept 8 view t confid5ce 9 him 0 lo/1 because x might be %ak54#fc ,b if he b5t be=e (ficial au?ority ! disapproval ( fri5ds 0 a sev]] tr\ble4 ,mo/ t5d] 9 8 affections1 mo/ tru/ful 9 8 confid5ce1 crav+ = sympa?y1 x came l a %ock & *ill :5 ?+s did n g "r betwe5 himself & 8 fri5ds4 ,he 0 too s5sitive "u su* disapproval = a successful p>ty *ief4 ,! true p>ty lead] takes ^! ?+s z "p ( t tiresome human /upidity & p]v]s5ess ) :i* he mu/ make 8 acc\nt4 ,p]haps !y /+ = ! mom5t1 b he bru%es !m away & goes =w>d1 soon =gett+ !m4 ,b ) ,mr4 ,newman1 8 cause 0 id5tifi$ ) 8 fri5d%ips & ev5 8 family affections4 ,& z a lead]1 he 0 emb>rass$ by ! ke5ness ) :i* he sympa?is$ ) ! d\bts & fe>s ( fri5ds2 want ( sympa?y & signs ( di/ru/ d>k5$ ! prospect ( ! future2 !y fell l a blight on 8 /ores ( hope1 nev] ov]-abundant2 !y tempt$ him1 n to ass]t himself1 b to ?r[ up ! game z convict$ ( unfitness1 & retire = good & all to 8 books & sil5ce4 ,let !m1 he seem$ to say1 h _! way1 z !y w n let me h m9e2 !y h ! "r to take !irs1 only n to make me take x4 ,9 spite ( 8 en?usiasm & en]gy1 8 unceas+ "w1 8 occasional bur/s ( sev]e puni%m5t inflict$ on ^? :o provok$ him1 !re 0 always pres5t ?is ke5 s5sitiv5ess1 ! s\rce ( s mu* joy & s mu* pa94 ,he w\ld n h be5 himself )\t x4 ,b he w\ld h be5 a mu* m p[]ful & mu* m =midable combatant if he _h c>$ less = :at 8 fri5ds felt1 & foll[$ m unhesitat+ly 8 own l9e & judgm5t4 ,?is ke5 s5sitiv5ess made him m quickly alive ?an o!r p to all t lay r\nd him & be=e2 x made him quick] to disc]n dang] & disa/]2 x l$ him to give up hope & to retire f ! conte/ long be=e he _h a "r to d s4 ,! exp]i5ce ( lat] ye>s %[s t he _h despair$ too soon4 ,su* delicate s5sitiv5ess1 lead+ to impati5ce1 0 n capable ( cop+ ) ! r\gh "w involv$ 9 ! task ( re=m1 :i* he _h und]tak54 ,all ?is "t ! f\r o'clock s]mons at ,/4 ,m>y's 7 always go+ on4 ,b1 besides ^!1 he anticipat$ a fre$om--famili> n[1 b unkn[n !n--( public lectur+4 ,9 ,adv5t & aft] ,ea/] a company1 nev] v l>ge1 us$ to ga!r on a week-day aft]noon 9 ,adam de ,brome's ,*apel--! old ,*apel ( ,our ,lady ( ,littlemore--to he> him lecture on "s !ological subject4 ,x is a d>k1 dre>y app5dage to ,/4 ,m>y's on ! nor? side1 9 :i* ,adam de ,brome1 ,edw>d ,,ii4's almon]1 & ! f\nd] ( ,oriel ,college1 is suppos$ to lie1 b5ea? an un%apely tomb1 cov]$ by a huge slab ( ,purbeck m>ble1 f :i* ! brass has be5 /ripp$4 ,! place is call$ a *apel1 b is m l a c\rt or place ( bus9ess1 = :i*1 inde$1 x 0 us$ 9 ! old days by "o ( ! ,faculties ( ! ,h\se ( ,convocation1 :i* held its assemblies !re4 ,at ! end is a high seat & desk = ! p]son presid+1 & an enclosure & a table = (ficials bel[ him2 & r\nd ! re/ ( ! d+y walls run b5*es fix$ to ! wall1 d+y z ! walls !mselves4 ,b x also _h ano!r use4 ,on occasions ( a univ]sity s]mon1 a few m9utes be=e x began1 ! ,heads ( ,h\ses assembl$1 z !y /ill assemble1 9 ! *apel1 rang+ !mselves on ! b5*es r\nd ! walls4 ,! ,vice-,*ancellor has 8 seat on "o side1 ! prea*]1 ) ! two ,proctors bel[ him1 sits opposite2 & !re all sit 9 _! robes1 m or less gr&1 accord+ to ! day1 till ! beadle comes to ann\nce t x is "t to =m ! procession into *ur*4 ,?is desolate place ,mr4 ,newman turn$ into 8 lecture-room2 9 x he deliv]$ ! lectures :i* aft]w>ds became ! volume on ! ,prophetical ,"* ( ! ,*ur*1 or ,romanism & ,popul> ,prote/antism2 ! lectures :i* =m$ ! volume on ,ju/ification2 ^? on ,anti*ri/1 & on ,rationalism & ! ,canon ( ,scripture1 :i* aft]w>ds became ,nos4 #hc & #he ( ! ,tracts = ! ,times4#fd ,! =ce1 ! boldness1 ! fre$om f ! trammels ( commonplace1 ! bread? ( view & grasp ( ! subject :i* m>k$ ^? lectures1 may be se5 9 !m /ill4 ,b x is difficult to realise n[ ! int]e/ ) :i* !y 7 he>d at ! "t by ! fir/ li/5]s to t cle> & p]fectly modulat$ voice1 op5+ to !m fre% & orig9al ways ( reg>d+ que/ions :i* seem$ worn out & exhau/$4 ,! volumes :i* grew out ( ! ,adam de ,brome lectures 7 "s ( ! mo/ *>act]i/ic portions ( ! !ological lit]ature ( ! e>ly movem5t4 ,!y c]ta9ly greatly influ5c$ ! c\rse ( ?\ght 9 x1 & "s ( its mo/ s]i\s issues4 ,! movem5t 0 n "o ( m]e op9ion4 ,x took two di/9ct ?\gh connect$ l9es4 ,x 01 on ! "o h&1 !ological2 on ! o!r1 resolutely practical4 ,!ologically1 x dealt ) great que/ions ( religi\s pr9ciple--,:at is ! ,*ur*8 ,is x a reality or a mode ( spee*8 ,on :at gr\nds does x re/8 ,h[ may x be kn[n8 ,is x among u8 ,h[ is x to be discrim9at$ f its rivals or c\nt]feits8 ,:at is its ess5tial con/itution8 ,:at does x tea*8 ,:at are its %ortcom+s8 ,does x n]d re=m8 ,b1 on ! o!r h&1 ! movem5t 0 m>k$ by its deep e>ne/ness on ! practical side ( g5u9e ,*ri/ian life4 ,v e>ly 9 ! movem5t 7#ahcc7 a s]ies ( sket*es ( primitive ,*ri/ian life appe>$ 9 ! ,briti% ,magaz9e--aft]w>ds collect$ "u ! title ( ! ,*ur* ( ! ,fa!rs 7#ahdj7--to rem9d p :o 7 becom+ int]e/$ 9 anci5t & patri/ic !ology t1 besides ! doctr9es to be f\nd 9 ! va/ folios ( ! ,fa!rs1 !re 7 to be s\ght 9 !m & laid to he>t ! temptations & trials1 ! aspirations & moral possibilities ( actual life1 ! tone & modes ( ?\ght1 ! habits & mann]s ( ! e>ly times ( ! ,*ur*4 ,! note /ruck 9 ! fir/ ( ,mr4 ,newman's publi%$ s]mons--,hol9ess necess>y = future bless$ness--0 nev] all[$ to be out ( m9d4 ,! movem5t 01 above all1 a moral "o2 x 0 no?+1 all[$ to be no?+1 if x 0 n ?is4#fe ,s]i\sness1 rev]5ce1 ! fe> ( ins9c]e words & uns\nd pr(essions1 7 ess5tial 9 ! "*1 :i* alone x w\ld tol]ate 9 ^? :o made common cause ) x4 ,its e?ical t5d5cy 0 %[n 9 two ?+s1 :i* 7 *>act]i/ic ( x4 ,"o 0 ! increas$ c>e = ! ,gospels1 & /udy ( !m1 comp>$ ) o!r p>ts ( ! ,bible4 ,evangelical !ology _h dwelt ^u ! "w ( ,*ri/1 & laid comp>atively little /ress on ,8 example1 or ! picture left u ( ,8 ,p]sonality & ,life4 ,x reg>d$ ! ,epi/les ( ,/4 ,paul z ! la/ ^w ( ! ,gospel message4 ,p :o c recall ! popul> tea*+1 :i* 0 spok5 ( !n z s\nd & fai?ful1 & prea*+ ,*ri/1 c rememb] h[ ! ,epi/les 7 ransack$ = texts to prove ! suffici5cy ( ,scripture or ! "r ( private judgm5t1 or ! di/9ction betwe5 ju/ification & sanctification1 :ile ! ,gospel n>rative 0 imp]fectly /udi$ & 0 felt to be mu* less int]e/+4 ,! movem5t made a great *ange4 ,! great ,"n /ood no long] = an ab/ract symbol ( doctr9e1 b = a liv+ ,ma/]1 :o c\ld tea* z well z save4 ,& n =gett+ :i!r ,he _h gone & :at ,he 01 ! read]s ( ,scripture n[ s\ght ,him eag]ly 9 ^? sacr$ records1 :]e we c almo/ see & he> ,8 go+ 9 & out among m54 ,x 0 a *ange 9 ! look & use ( ,scripture1 :i* "s c /ill look back to z an epo* 9 _! religi\s hi/ory4 ,! o!r feature 0 ! increas$ & practical s5se ( ! necessity ( self-discipl9e1 ( tak+ real tr\ble ) "o's self to keep ?\ghts & wi%es 9 ord]1 to lay ! f\ndation ( habits1 to acquire ! p[] ( self-control4 ,deeply fix$ 9 ! m9d ( ! tea*]s1 ?is s]i\s gov]nance ( life1 ?is direction & purification ( its aims1 laid /rong hold on ! consci5ces ( ^? :o accept$ _! tea*+4 ,?is tra9+ 0 n %[y2 x 0 sometimes au/]e1 ev5 extravagantly au/]e2 b x 0 true1 & endur+1 & x issu$ (t5 9 a /eady & unconsci\s elevation ( ! religi\s "*4 ,h[ ?is "* 0 f$ & nurtur$ & enc\rag$--h[1 too1 x 0 frankly w>n$ ( its dang]s1 may be se5 9 ^? ,p>o*ial ,s]mons at ,/4 ,m>y's1 "u ^: inspiration x 0 develop$1 & :i* w always be ! be/ comm5t>y on ! "* ?us =m$4 ,ev5 among ^? :o ultimately p>t$ f ! movem5t1 ) judgm5t m or less unfav\rable to its !ology & g5]al l9e1 x left1 z if uneffaceable1 ?is moral /amp2 ?is value = s9c]ity & simplicity ( feel+ & life1 ?is ke5 s5se ( ! awfulness ( ?+s unse54 ,!re 0 some?+ sui g5]is 9 ! pr(\ndly s]i\s1 pr(\ndly rev]5t tone1 ab\t ev]y?+ t t\*$ religion 9 all :o _h ev] come /rongly "u its influ5ce4 ,( c\rse ! p>ty soon _h ! faults ( a p>ty1 real & imput$4#ff ,is x conceivable t !re %\ld ev] h be5 a religi\s movem5t1 :i* has n provok$ smiles f ^? outside ( x1 & :i* has n l5t itself to c>icature8 ,!re 7 weak] memb]s ( x1 & head/rong ones1 & imitative ones2 !re 7 grotesque & absurd ones2 "s 7 deep]1 "s %all[]2 "s lik$ x = its excitem5t1 & "s lik$ x = its cause2 !re 7 ^? :o 7 = pu%+ on1 & ^? :o 7 = hold+ back2 !re 7 m5 ( combat1 & m5 ( peace2 !re 7 ^? :om x made conceit$ & self-important1 & ^? :om x drove into s]i\sness1 anxiety1 & retirem5t4 ,b1 :atev] faults x _h1 a pure & high _s rul$ 9 x2 !re 7 no disloyal memb]s1 & !re 7 none :o s\ght _! own 9 x1 or ?\ght ( high ?+s = !mselves 9 jo9+ x4 ,x 0 ?is :ole-he>t$ness1 ?is supreme rev]5ce = moral goodness1 m ev5 ?an ! great ability ( ! lead]s1 & 9 spite ( mi/akes & failures1 :i* gave its cohesion & its mom5tum to ! movem5t 9 its e>li] /ages4 ,! /ate ( feel+ & op9ion among ,*ur*m5 t[>ds ! end ( #ahce1 two ye>s aft] ! ,tracts _h begun1 is ?us sket*$ by "o :o 0 anxi\sly obs]v+ x1 9 ! preface to ! second volume ( ! ,tracts 7,novemb] #ahce74 ,9 complet+ ! second volume ( a publication1 to :i* ! circum/ances ( ! day h giv5 rise1 x may be "r to allude to a *ange :i* has tak5 place 9 !m s9ce ! date ( its comm5cem5t4 ,at t "t1 9 consequ5ce ( long security1 ! att5tion ( memb]s ( our ,*ur* _h be5 b p>tially engag$1 9 asc]ta9+ ! gr\nds ( _! adh]5ce to x2 b ! imm95t p]il to all :i* is de> to !m :i* has s9ce be5 confess$1 has naturally turn$ _! ?\ghts t way1 & oblig$ !m to def5d x on "o or o!r ( ! pr9ciples :i* are usually put =w>d 9 its behalf4 ,discussions h ?us be5 r5ew$ 9 v>i\s qu>t]s1 on po9ts :i* _h long rema9$ undi/urb$2 & ?\gh numb]s cont9ue undecid$ 9 op9ion1 or take up a tempor>y position 9 "s "o ( ! hundr$ middle po9ts :i* may be assum$ betwe5 ! two ma9 !ories 9 :i* ! "q issues2 & o!rs1 aga91 h delib]ately entr5*$ !mselves 9 ! mod]n or ultra-,prote/ant alt]native2 yet1 on ! :ole1 !re has be5 mu* he>ty & intellig5t adoption1 & mu* respectful /udy1 ( ^? m primitive views ma9ta9$ by our great ,div9es4 ,z ! alt]$ /ate ( public in=mation & op9ion has a necess>y be>+ on ! ef=ts ( ^? :o desire to excite att5tion to ! subject 79 :i* numb] ! writ]s ( ^! ,tracts are to be includ$71 x w n be inappropriate briefly to /ate 9 ?is place :at x is conceiv$ is ! pres5t position ( ! great body ( ,*ur*m5 ) ref]5ce to x4 ,:ile we h cause to be ?ankful = ! s\nd] & m accurate language1 :i* is n[ v g5]ally adopt$ among well-judg+ m5 on ecclesia/ical subjects1 we mu/ bew>e ( ov]-e/imat+ :at has be5 done1 & s becom+ sangu9e 9 our hopes ( success1 or slack5+ our ex]tions to secure x4 ,_m m p]sons1 d\btless1 h tak5 up a pr(ession ( ! ma9 doctr9e 9 "q1 t1 namely1 ( ! "o ,ca?olic & ,apo/olic ,*ur*1 ?an fully ent] into x4 ,?is 0 to be expect$1 x be+ ! peculi>ity ( all religi\s tea*+1 t words are imp>t$ be=e ideas4 ,a *ild le>ns 8 ,cre$ or ,cate*ism be=e he und]/&s x2 & 9 beg9n+ any deep subject we are all b *ildr5 to ! end ( our lives4 ,! in/9ctive p]ception ( a rightly in/ruct$ m9d1 prim facie =ce ( ! argum5t1 or ! au?ority ( our celebrat$ writ]s1 h all _h _! due & ext5sive influ5ce 9 fur!r+ ! reception ( ! doctr9e1 :5 once x 0 op5ly ma9ta9$2 to :i* mu/ be add$ ! prospect ( ! loss ( ,/ate protection1 :i* made x necess>y to look out = o!r reasons = adh]5ce to ! ,*ur* besides t ( ob$i5ce to ! civil magi/rate4 ,no?+ :i* has spread quickly has be5 receiv$ ?or\ghly4 ,d\btless !re are a numb] ( s]i\sly-m9d$ p]sons :o ?9k t !y admit ! doctr9e 9 "q mu* m fully ?an !y d1 & :o w\ld be />tl$ at see+ t realis$ 9 p>ticul>s :i* !y confess 9 an ab/ract =m4 ,_m !re are :o d n at all feel t x is capable ( a practical application2 & :ile !y br+ x =w>d on special occasions1 9 =mal expositions ( fai?1 or 9 answ] to a direct int]rogatory1 let x slip f _! m9ds almo/ entirely 9 _! daily conduct or _! religi\s tea*+1 f ! long & invet]ate habit ( ?9k+ & act+ )\t x4 ,we mu/ n1 !n1 at all be surpris$ at f9d+ t to modify ! pr9ciples & motives on :i* m5 act is n ! "w ( a day2 nor at und]go+ disappo9tm5ts1 at witness+ relapses1 misconceptions1 sudd5 disgu/s1 &1 on ! o!r h&1 abuses & p]v]sions ( ! true doctr9e1 9 ! case ( ^? :o h tak5 x up ) m w>m? ?an disc]nm5t4 ,f ! end ( #ahce1 or ! beg9n+ ( #ahcf1 ! _w outside ( ,ox=d began to be alive to ! =ce & ! rapid gr[? ( ?is new &1 to ! _w at l>ge1 n v intelligible movem5t4 ,! ideas :i* _h laid hold s p[]fully on a numb] ( lead+ m9ds 9 ! ,univ]sity began to "w ) a spell1 :i* seem$ to _m inexplicable1 on o!rs unconnect$ ) !m4 ,?is rapidity ( expansion1 view$ z a feature ( a p>ty1 0 notic$ on all sides1 by enemies no less ?an fri5ds4 ,9 an article 9 ! ,briti% ,critic ( ,april #ahci1 by ,mr4 ,newman1 on ! ,/ate ( ,religi\s ,p>ties1 ! fact is illu/rat$ f contempor>y notices4 ,!re is at ! pres5t mom5t a reaction 9 ! ,*ur*1 & a gr[+ reaction1 t[>ds ! views :i* x has be5 ! endeav\rs ( ! ,tract writ]s &1 z x seem$ at ! comm5cem5t1 almo/ hopeless endeav\rs1 to advocate4 ,! fairness ( ! prospect at pres5t is prov$ by ! attack made on !m by ! public j\rnals1 & is confess$ by ! m c&id & ! m viol5t among _! oppon5ts4 ,?us ! amiable ,mr4 ,bick]/e? speaks ( x z hav+ manife/$ itself ) ! mo/ rapid gr[? ( ! hot-b$ ( ^! evil days4 ,! sc(f+ au?or ( ! ,via ,m$ia says3 ,at ?is mom5t ! ,via is cr[d$ ) "y en?usia/s :o nev] presume to argue1 except aga9/ ! propriety ( argu+ at all4 ,! c&id ,mr4 ,bad5-,p[ell1 :o sees m ( ! difficulties ( ! controv]sy ?an ! re/ ( _! antagoni/s pot toge!r1 says t x is cle> t ^! views 444 h be5 ext5sively adopt$1 & are daily ga9+ gr\nd among a consid]able & influ5tial portion ( ! memb]s1 z well z ! m9i/]s ( ! ,e/abli%$ ,*ur*4 ,! au?or ( ! ,natural ,hi/ory ( ,en?usiasm says3 ,! spread ( ^! doctr9es is 9 fact hav+ ! effect ( r5d]+ all o!r di/9ctions obsolete4 ,soon !re w be no middle gr\nd left1 & e man1 especially e cl]gyman1 w be compell$ to make 8 *oice betwe5 ! two4 444 ,! ,bi%op ( ,*e/] speaks ( ! subject daily assum+ a m s]i\s & al>m+ aspect3 a gossip+ writ] ( ! mom5t describes ^! doctr9es z hav+ ins9uat$ !mselves n only into popul> *ur*es & fa%ionable *apels1 & ! columns ( newspap]s1 b into ! ,h\se ( ,commons4 ,& ! writ] ( ! article goes on3-- ,n[1 if !re be any tru? 9 ^! rem>ks1 x is pla9ly idle & p]v]se to ref] ! *ange ( op9ions :i* is n[ go+ on to ! acts ( two or ?ree individuals1 z is sometimes done4 ,( c\rse e ev5t 9 human affairs has a beg9n+2 & a beg9n+ implies a :51 & a :]e1 & a by :om1 & h[4 ,b except 9 ^! necess>y circum/ance1 ! ph5om5on 9 "q is 9 a mann] q indep5d5t ( ?+s visible & hi/orical4 ,x is n "h or !re2 x has no progress1 no causes1 no =tunes3 x is n a movem5t1 x is a _s1 x is a _s afloat1 nei!r 9 ! secret *amb]s nor 9 ! des]t1 b ev]y:]e4 ,x is )9 u1 ris+ up 9 ! he>t :]e x 0 lea/ expect$1 & work+ its way1 ?\gh n 9 secret1 yet s subtly & impalpably1 z h>dly to admit ( precaution or enc\nt] on any ord9>y human rules ( opposition4 ,x is an adv]s>y 9 ! air1 a some?+ "o & entire1 a :ole :]ev] x is1 unapproa*able & incapable ( be+ grasp$1 z be+ ! result ( causes f> deep] ?an political or o!r visible ag5cies1 ! spiritual awak5+ ( spiritual wants4 ,no?+ c %[ m /rik+ly ! tru? ( ?is repres5tation ?an to ref] to :at may be call$ ! !ological hi/ory ( ! individuals :o1 :atev] be _! diff]5ces f ea* o!r on important or unimportant po9ts1 yet are associat$ toge!r 9 ! advocacy ( ! doctr9es 9 "q4 ,dr4 ,hook & ,mr4 ,*urton repres5t ! ,high ,*ur* dignit>ies ( ! la/ g5]ation2 ,mr4 ,p]ceval1 ! ,tory ari/ocracy2 ,mr4 ,keble is ( ! c\ntry cl]gy1 & comes f valleys & woods1 f> remov$ bo? f notoriety & noise2 ,mr4 ,palm] & ,mr4 ,todd are ( ,irel&2 ,dr4 ,pusey became :at he is f among ! ,univ]sities ( ,g]many1 & aft] a sev]e & t$i\s analysis ( ,arabic ,,mss4 ,mr4 ,dodswor? is said to h begun 9 ! /udy ( ,prophecy2 ,mr4 ,newman to h be5 mu* indebt$ to ! fri5d%ip ( ,ar*bi%op ,:ately2 ,mr4 ,fr\de1 if any "o1 ga9$ 8 views f 8 own m9d4 ,o!rs h pass$ ov] f ,calv9ism & k9dr$ religions4 ,ye>s aft]w>ds1 & 9 *ang$ circum/ances1 ! same writ] has left ! foll[+ record ( :at came be=e 8 exp]i5ce 9 ^? ye>s3--#fg ,f beg9n+s s small 7,i said71 f elem5ts ( ?\ght s =tuit\s1 ) prospects s unpromis+1 ! ,anglo-,ca?olic p>ty sudd5ly became a p[] 9 ! ,national ,*ur*1 & an object ( al>m to h] rul]s & fri5ds4 ,its orig9ators w\ld h f\nd x difficult to say :at !y aim$ at ( a practical k9d3 r1 !y put =? views & pr9ciples1 = _! own sake1 because !y 7 true1 z if !y 7 oblig$ to say !m2 &1 z !y might be !mselves surpris$ at _! e>ne/ness 9 utt]+ !m1 !y _h z great cause to be surpris$ at ! success :i* att5d$ _! propagation4 ,&1 9 fact1 !y c\ld only say t ^? doctr9es 7 9 ! air2 t to ass]t 0 to prove1 & t to expla9 0 to p]suade2 & t ! movem5t 9 :i* !y 7 tak+ "p 0 ! bir? ( a crisis r ?an ( a place4 ,9 a v few ye>s a s*ool ( op9ion 0 =m$1 fix$ 9 its pr9ciples1 indef9ite & progressive 9 _! range2 & x ext5d$ itself into e "p ( ! c\ntry4 ,if we inquire :at ! _w ?\ght ( x1 we h /ill m to raise our wond]2 =1 n to m5tion ! excitem5t x caus$ 9 ,engl&1 ! movem5t & its p>ty-names 7 kn[n to ! police ( ,italy & to ! backwoods-m5 ( ,am]ica4 ,& s x proce$$1 gett+ /rong] & /rong] e ye>1 till x came into collision ) ! ,nation & t ,*ur* ( ! ,nation1 :i* x began by pr(ess+ especially to s]ve4 ,,footnotes3 #ei ,i answ]$1 ! p]son :om we 7 oppos+ _h committ$ himself 9 writ+1 & we ought to commit ourselves1 too4--,apologia1 p4 #adc4 #fj ,i v mu* d\bt betwe5 ,ox=d & ,cambridge = my boy4 ,ox=d1 :i* ,i %\ld o!rwise pref]1 on _m acc\nts1 has at pres5t two-?irds ( ! /eady-read+ m51 ,rabb9i/s1 i4e4 ,puseyites4 ,b ?is 0 probably an exagg]ation4--,:ately's ,life2 lett] ( ,oct4 #ahch1 p4 #afc 7ed4 #ahge74 #fa ,! sagaci\s & aspir+ man ( ! _w1 ! scrut9is] ( ! he>t1 ! conspirator aga9/ its privileges & rights4--,prophetical ,(fice ( ! ,*ur*1 p4 #acb4 #fb ,p>o*ial ,s]mons1 iv4 #bj4 ,feb4 #ahcf4 #fc ,vide ,j4,b4 ,mozley1 ,lett]s1 pp4 #aad1 #aae4 ,confid5ce 9 me 0 lo/1 b ,i _h already lo/ confid5ce 9 myself4 ,?is1 to a fri5d l ,j4,b4 ,mozley1 seem$ exagg]ation4 ,?\gh admir+ ! lett] to ! ,vice ,*ancellor ,i confess1 = my own "p1 ,i ?9k a g5]al confession ( humility 0 irrelevant to ! pres5t occasion1 ! "q be+ simply on a po9t ( !ological int]pretation4 ,i h always _h a prejudice aga9/ g5]al confessions4 ,mozley pla9ly ?\ght ,newman's attitude too meek4 ,he w\ld h lik$ some?+ m spirit$ & pugnaci\s4 #fd ,romanism & ,popul> ,prote/antism1 f #ahcd to #ahcf1 publi%$ ,m>* #ahcg2 ,ju/ification1 aft] ,ea/] #ahcg1 publi%$ ,m>* #ahch2 ,canon ( ,scripture1 publi%$ ,may #ahch2 ,anti*ri/1 publi%$ ,june #ahch4 #fe ,cf4 ,lyra ,apo/olica1 ,no4 #fe3 ,?\ to wax fi]ce ,9 ! cause ( ! ,"l6 99 99 99 99 99 ,ang] & zeal1 ,& ! joy ( ! brave1 ,:o bade !e to feel1 ,s9's slave8 #ff ,?is weak side 0 portray$ ) sev]ity 9 a /ory publi%$ by ,mr4 ,newman 9 #ahdh1 aft] he left ! ,engli% ,*ur*--,loss & ,ga94 #fg ,apologia1 p4 #aef4 ,,*apt] ,,xi ,,! ,,roman ,,"q ,! ,hampd5 controv]sy _h contribut$ to br+ to ! front a "q1 :i* f ! fir/ />t+ ( ! ,tracts _h made itself felt1 b :i* n[ became a press+ "o4 ,if ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& claim$ to be "p ( ! ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 :at 0 ! answ] ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& to ! claims & *>ges ( ! ,*ur* ( ,rome8 ,:at 7 ! true di/9ctions betwe5 ! doctr9es ( ! two ,*ur*es on ! great po9ts on :i* !y 7 suppos$ to be at issue8 ,! vague outcry ( ,pop]y _h ( c\rse be5 rais$ bo? aga9/ ! g5]al doctr9e ( ! ,*ur*1 en=c$ 9 ! ,tracts1 & aga9/ special doctr9es & modes ( speak+1 popul>ly id5tifi$ ) ,romanism2 & ! answ] _h be5 an appeal to ! au?ority ( ! mo/ le>n$ & au?oritative ( our writ]s4 ,b1 ( c\rse1 to ! g5]al public ?is le>n+ 0 new2 & ! cry w5t on ) a dre>y & /upid monotony4 ,b ! *>ges aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd5 l$ 8 def5d]s to adopt z _! be/ weapon an aggressive policy4 ,to ! attack on 8 or?odoxy1 ! c\nt] buffet 0 ! *>ge aga9/ 8 *ief oppon5ts ( secret or op5 ,romanis+4 ,9 its ke5e/ & mo/ popul> =m x 0 put =? 9 a mock+ pamphlet writt5 probably "u ,:ately's inspiration by 8 mo/ tru/$ confidant1 ,dr4 ,dick9son1 9 :i*1 9 ! =m ( a ,pa/oral ,epi/le f 8 ,hol9ess ! ,pope to "s ,memb]s ( ! ,univ]sity ( ,ox=d1 ! ,tract-writ]s are made to appe> z ! emiss>ies & secret tools ( ,rome1 z 9 a jeu d'esprit ( ,:ately's !y are made to appe> z ! veil$ prophets ( infidelity4#fh ,x 0 clev]1 b n clev] en\gh to /&1 at lea/ 9 ,ox=d1 aga9/ ,dr4 ,pusey's dignifi$ & gravely e>ne/ ,remon/rance aga9/ its inju/ice & trifl+4 ,b ! fire ( all ,dr4 ,hampd5's fri5ds _h be5 drawn on ! lead]s ( ! movem5t4 ,) !m1 & almo/ alone ) !m1 ! opposition to him 0 made a p]sonal matt]4 ,z "t w5t on1 ^? :o _h be5 z hot z !y aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd5 manag$ to get _! "p 9 ! bus9ess =gott54 ,old scores betwe5 ,or?odox1 ,evangelicals1 & ,lib]als 7 wip$ out1 & ! ,tract>ians 7 left to be> alone ! odium ( ! p]secution ( ,dr4 ,hampd54 ,x mu/ be said t !y %[$ no signs ( c>+ = x4 ,b ! ,roman controv]sy 0 loom+ 9 e>ne/1 & x 0 idle to expect to keep x long out ( sight4 ,! ,tracts _h set =? ) />tl+ vehem5ce ! =gott5 claims ( ! ,*ur*4 ,"o reason :y ?is _h be5 done 0 ! belief1 z /at$ 9 ! fir/ volume ( !m1 t no?+ b ^! neglect$ doctr9es1 fai?fully prea*$1 w repress ! ext5sion ( ,pop]y1 = :i* ! ev]-multiply+ divisions ( ! religi\s _w are too cle>ly prep>+ ! way4#fi ,! "q1 ,:at is ! ,*ur*8 0 "o :i* ! conditions ( ! times w\ld n p]mit m5 any long] to leave alone4 ,x _h become urg5t to meet x cle>ly & decisively4 ,we c\ld n move a /ep 9 com=t till ?is 0 done4#gj ,! controv]sy ) ! ,romani/s1 writes ,mr4 ,newman 9 ,no4 #ga ( ! ,tracts1 ab\t ! end ( #ahce1 has ov]tak5 u 'l a summ]'s cl\d4' ,we f9d ourselves 9 v>i\s p>ts ( ! c\ntry prep>+ = x1 yet1 :5 we look back1 we _c trace ! /eps by :i* we arriv$ at our pres5t position4 ,we d n recollect :at our feel+s 7 ?is "t la/ ye> on ! subject2 :at 0 ! /ate ( our appreh5sions & anticipations4 ,all we "k is1 t "h we are1 f long security ignorant :y we are n ,roman ,ca?olics1 & !y on ! o!r side are said to be spread+ & /r5g!n+ on all sides ( u1 vaunt+ ( _! success1 real or app>5t1 & taunt+ u ) our inability to argue ) !m4 ,! attitude tak5 by ,mr4 ,newman at ?is "t1 z reg>ds ! ,roman ,*ur*1 bo? 9 ! ,tracts & 9 8 book on ,romanism & ,popul> ,prote/antism1 publi%$ 9 ! e>ly mon?s ( #ahcf1 0 a new "o4 ,he _h />t$1 z he tells u1 ) ! common belief t ! ,pope 0 ,anti*ri/1 & t ! case 0 s cle> aga9/ ! :ole sy/em1 doctr9al & practical1 ( ! ,*ur* ( ,rome1 t x sc>cely ne$$ fur!r exam9ation4 ,8 feel+ aga9/ ,rome _h be5 increas$ by ! fi]ce /ruggle ab\t ,emancipation1 & by ! political conduct ( ! ,roman ,ca?olic p>ty aft]w>ds2 & 8 gr[+ dissatisfaction ) ! ord9>y ,prote/antism _h no visible effect 9 s(t5+ ?is feel+4 ,hurrell ,fr\de's d>+ que/ions _h made 8 fri5ds feel t !re might be m to be kn[n ab\t ! subject ?an !y yet knew2 yet :at ! fell[-travell]s saw ( ?+s abroad 9 _! visit to ! ,s\? 9 #ahcb did n impress !m fav\rably4 ,!y are wret*$ ,trid5t9es ev]y:]e1 0 ,fr\de's comm5t4 ,b att5tion _h be5 drawn to ! subject1 & its deep int]e/ & importance & difficulty recognis$4 ,m5 began to read ) new eyes4 ,fr\de's ke5 & deep s5se ( %ortcom+s at home dispos$ him to claim equity & c&\r 9 judg+ ( ! alleg$ faults & corruptions ( ! ,*ur* abroad4 ,x did m1 x dispos$ him--naturally en\gh1 b /ill unfairly1 & c]ta9ly )\t adequate k--to treat ,roman %ortcom+s ) an indulg5ce :i* he refus$ to ,engli%4 ,mr4 ,newman1 kn[+ m1 & m compreh5sive 9 8 view ( ?+s1 & !re=e m cauti\s & gu>d$ ?an ,fr\de1 0 mu* less ready to all[ a fav\rable int]pretation ( ! obvi\s allegations aga9/ ,rome4 ,b ?\ght & read+1 & ! au?ority ( our own lead+ div9es1 _h br\ght him to ! conviction t :atev] 0 to be said aga9/ ! mod]n ,roman ,*ur*--& ! *>ges aga9/ x 7 v heavy--x 0 /ill1 amid s]i\s corruption & error1 a tea*] to ! nations ( ! ,*ri/ian cre$ & hope2 x _h n =feit$1 any m ?an ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 its title to be a "p ( t hi/oric body :i* connects u ) ! ,apo/les ( our ,"l4 ,x _h a /rong & consi/5t !ory to oppose to its assailants2 x _h mu* m to say = itself ?an ! popul> traditions suppos$4 ,?is 0 no new idea 9 ,anglican div9ity1 h[ev] ill x might sort ) ! curr5t language ( ,prote/ant controv]sy4 ,b our old div9es1 m easily satisfi$ ?an we ) ! c\rse ( ?+s at home "u ! protection ( ! ,/u>t k+s1 & /ung to bitt] recrim9ation by ! insults & ! unscrupul\s political intrigues ( ,roman ,ca?olic ag5ts1 _h exhau/$ ! language ( vitup]ation aga9/ a great aggressive rival1 :i* 0 ?reat5+ ev]y?+ t !y held de>4 ,!y _h damag$ _! own "* = fairness1 & ov]laid _! sub/antial gr\nds ( objection & compla9t1 by ?is unbalanc$ exagg]ation4 ,mr4 ,newman1 9 8 /udy ( ^! matt]s1 e>ly saw bo? ! ne$ & ! difficulty ( discrim9ation 9 ! ,roman controv]sy4 ,x _h to be wag$1 n z ( old1 ) p5al legislation beh9d1 b aga9/ adv]s>ies :o c\ld n[ make !mselves li/5$ to1 & be=e a public suffici5tly robu/ 9 its ,prote/antism1 to look ) amus$ int]e/ on a dialectical triumph ( ! ,roman ov] ! ,anglican claims4 ,romanism1 he ?\ght1 0 fatal bo? to 8 rec5t hopes = ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 & to ! hon\r & welf>e ( ,*ri/ianity at l>ge4 ,b 9 oppos+ x1 gr\nd loosely tak5 ( old mu/ be c>efully exam9$1 & if unt5able1 ab&on$4 ,argum5ts :i* prov$ too mu*1 :i* avail$ aga9/ any ,*ur* at all1 mu/ be giv5 up4 ,popul> objections1 aris+ f ignorance or misconception1 mu/ be r$uc$ to _! true limits or laid aside4 ,! controv]sy 0 sure to be a real "o1 & no?+ b :at 0 real & w\ld /& scrut9y 0 wor? any?+ 9 x4 ,mr4 ,newman _h always be5 impress$ ) ! greatness ( ! ,roman ,*ur*4 ,( old x _h seem$ to him great ) ! greatness ( ,anti*ri/4 ,n[ x seem$ great ) ! /range weird greatness ( a wond]ful mix$ sy/em1 comm&+ f its ext5t ( sway & its imp]ial au?ority1 complicat$ & my/]i\s 9 its organisation & influ5ce1 9 its devotion & its sup]/itions1 & surpass+ e o!r =m ( religion bo? 9 its good & its evil4#ga ,:at n[ pres5t$ itself to ,mr4 ,newman's ?\ghts1 in/ead ( ! old notion ( a pure ,*ur* on "o side1 & a corrupt ,*ur* on ! o!r1 %>ply oppos$ to "o ano!r1 0 ! m reasonable supposition ( two great portions ( ! divid$ ,*ur*1 ea* ) its realities ( hi/ory & fact & "*1 ea* ) its special claims & excell5ces1 ea* ) its special s9s & corruptions1 & nei!r realis+ 9 practice & fact all x pr(ess$ to be on pap]2 ea* ( :i* fur!r1 9 ! conflicts ( pa/ days1 _h deeply1 almo/ unp>donably1 wrong$ ! o!r4 ,! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 0 9 possession1 ) its own call & its imm5se "w to d1 & /riv+ to d x4 ,:atev] ! ,*ur* ( ,rome 0 abroad1 x 0 "h an intrud] & a di/urb]4 ,t to 8 m9d 0 ! fact & ! true position ( ?+s2 & ?is ought to gov]n ! "* & c\rse ( controv]sy4 ,! true l9e 0 n to d5\nce & abuse :olesale1 n to attack ) any argum5t1 good or bad1 n to d5y or ignore :at 0 solid 9 ! ,roman gr\nd1 & good & elevat$ 9 ! ,roman sy/em1 b admitt+ all t fairly ought to be admitt$1 to br+ into prom95ce1 n = m]e polemical d5unciation1 b = grave & reasonable & judicial condemnation1 all t 0 extravagant & arrogant 9 ,roman assumptions1 & all t 0 base1 corrupt1 & un*ri/ian 9 ! popul> religion1 :i*1 ) all its claims to infallibility & au?ority1 ,rome n only p]mitt$ b enc\rag$4 ,= u to condemn ,rome :olesale1 z 0 ord9>ily ! fa%ion1 ev5 9 respectable writ]s1 0 z wrong1 z unfair1 z unpr(itable to ! cause ( tru? & ,*ri/ianity1 z ! ,roman *>ges aga9/ u 7 felt by u to be ignorant & unju/4 ,rome pr(esses l ,engl& to cont9ue ! con/itution1 doctr9e1 traditions1 & _s ( ! anci5t & undivid$ ,*ur*3 & s f> z %e does s--& %e does s 9 a great degree--we c h no qu>rel ) h]4 ,b 9 a great degree also1 %e does ?is only 9 pr(ession & z a !ory3 %e claims ! witness & suffrage ( antiquity1 b %e int]prets x at h] own conv5i5ce & by h] own au?ority4 ,we _c claim exemption f mi/akes1 f deviations f our own /&>d & pr9ciples1 any m ?an ,rome2 b :ile %e rema9s z %e is1 & makes ! mon/r\s claims ( infallibility & supremacy1 !re is no?+ = ,engli% ,*ur*m5 b to resi/ h]4 ,union is impossible4 ,submission is impossible4 ,:at we h to bew>e ( = our own sake1 z well z = our cause1 are false argum5ts1 unreal objections1 ignorant allegations4 ,!re is en\gh on ! v surface1 9 h] audaci\s ass]tions & high-h&$ *anges1 = popul> argum5ts aga9/ h]1 )\t hav+ rec\rse to exagg]ation & falsehood2 %e may be a v faulty ,*ur*1 )\t be+ ,babylon & ,anti*ri/4 ,& 9 ! high] =ms ( argum5t1 !re is abundance 9 ^? prov9ces ( anci5t !ology & ecclesia/ical hi/ory & law1 :i* ,prote/ant controv]siali/s h commonly surr5d]$ & left op5 to _! oppon5ts1 to supply a m tell+ weapon ?an any :i* ^! controv]siali/s h us$4 ,?is l9e1 ?\gh sub/antially involv$ 9 ! !ory ( our mo/ le>n$ div9es1 f ,&rewes to ,wake1 0 new 9 its mod]ation & reasonable caution2 9 its ab/5tion f insult & vague abuse1 9 its recognition ( ! prim facie /r5g? ( mu* ( ! ,roman case1 9 its fe>less attempt1 9 defiance ( ! deepe/ prejudices1 to face ! facts & conditions ( ! "q4 ,mr4 ,newman d>$ to "k & to ackn[l$ge mu* t our insul> self-satisfaction did n "k1 & did n c>e to "k1 ( real ,*ri/ian life 9 ! ,*ur* ( ,rome4 ,he d>$ to admit t mu* t 0 popul>ly held to be ,popi% 0 anci5t1 ,ca?olic1 edify+2 he d>$ to w>n ,*ur*m5 t ! loose unsift$ imputations1 s securely haz>d$ aga9/ ,rome1 7 bo? discr$itable & dang]\s4 ,all ?is1 f "o ^: condemnation ( ,rome 0 decisive & sev]e1 0 novel4 ,! attempt1 bo? 9 its _s & its ability1 0 n unwor?y ( be+ "p ( ! g5]al ef=t to raise ! /&>d ( ?\ght & tea*+ 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,x recall$ m5 f slov5ly prejudices to ! /udy ( ! real facts ( ! liv+ _w4 ,x n>r[$ ! front ( battle1 b x /r5g!n$ x enorm\sly4 ,! volume on ,romanism & ,popul> ,prote/antism is n an exhau/ive survey ( ! controv]sy ) ,rome or ( ! !ory ( ! ,*ur*4 ,!re are great portions ( ! subject1 bo? !ological & hi/orical1 :i* x did n fall )9 ! scope ( ! book to t\*4 ,x 0 unsy/ematic & incomplete4 ,b s f> z its argum5t ext5d$1 x almo/ =m$ an epo* 9 ?is k9d ( controv]sial writ+4 ,x %[$ ! comm& ( a man ( le>n+ ov] all ! te*nical po9ts & m9utiae ( a "q highly s*ola/ical 9 its conceptions & its cu/om>y treatm5t1 & x pres5t$ ?is "q 9 its be>+s & consequ5ces on life & practice ) ! fre$om & bread? ( ! mo/ vigor\s popul> writ+4 ,! indictm5t aga9/ ,rome 0 no vague or g5]al "o4 ,x 0 "o ( ^? argum5ts :i* cut ! gr\nd f "u a great e/abli%$ /ructure ( reason+s & pro(s4 ,& its conclusions1 cle> & measur$1 b /]n1 7 ! m impressive1 because !y came f "o :o did n disguise 8 feel+ t !re 0 mu* 9 :at 0 pres]v$ 9 ! ,roman sy/em to admire & to le>n f4 ,! po9t :i* he *ose = 8 assault 0 inde$ ! key ( ! ,roman position--! doctr9e ( ,infallibility4 ,he 0 naturally l$ to ?is side ( ! "q by ! /ress :i* ! movem5t _h laid on ! idea ( ! ,*ur* z ! witness & tea*] ( reveal$ tru?3 & ! imm$iate *all5ge giv5 by ! critics or oppon5ts ( ! movem5t 01 h[ to di/+ui% ?is l(ty idea ( ! ,*ur*1 ) its claim to au?ority1 if x 0 at all sub/antial1 f ! impos+ & consi/5t !ory ( ,romanism4 ,he urg$ aga9/ ! ,roman claim ( ,infallibility two lead+ objections4 ,"o 0 ! way 9 :i* ! assum$ infallibility ( ! pres5t ,*ur* 0 made to ov]ride & sup]s$e1 9 fact1 :at 9 words 0 s o/5tati\sly put =w>d1 ! hi/orical evid5ce ( antiquity to doctr9e1 express$ by ! phrase1 ! cons5t ( ! ,fa!rs4 ,! o!r objection 0 ! inh]5t contradiction ( ! notion ( infallibility to ! conditions ( human reception ( tea*+ & k1 & its practical uselessness z an assurance ( tru?1 its p>tly delusive1 p>tly mis*iev\s1 work+4 ,b he felt1 z all deep m9ds mu/ feel1 t x is easi] to ov]?r[ ! ,roman !ory ( ,*ur* au?ority ?an to replace x by ano!r1 equally complete & comm&+1 & m unassailable4 ,he 0 q alive to ! difficulties ( ! ,anglican position2 b he 0 a disciple 9 ! s*ool ( ,bi%op ,butl]1 & _h le>n$ z a fir/ pr9ciple to recognise ! limitations ( human k1 & ! unphilosophical folly ( try+ to r\nd (f into f9i%$ & pret5ti\s s*emes our fragm5t>y yet c]ta9 notices ( our own condition & ( ,god's deal+s ) x4 ,he foll[$ 8 tea*] 9 insi/+ on ! reality & importance ( moral evid5ce z oppos$ to demon/rative pro(2 & he foll[$ ! great ,anglican div9es 9 ass]t+ t !re 0 a true au?ority1 v>y+ 9 its degrees1 9 ! hi/oric ,*ur*2 t on ! mo/ fundam5tal po9ts ( religion ?is au?ority 0 tru/wor?y & supreme2 t on _m o!r que/ions x 0 cle> & weighty1 ?\gh x c\ld n decide ev]y?+4 ,?is view ( ! prophetical (fice ( ! ,*ur* _h ! dialectical disadvantage ( appe>+ to be a compromise1 to _m m9ds a fatal disadvantage4 ,x got ! "n ( ! ,via ,m$ia2 a satisfactory "o to practical m5 l ,dr4 ,hook1 to :om x recomm5d$ itself = use 9 popul> tea*+2 b to o!rs1 9 aft]times1 an ill-s\nd+ phrase ( dislike1 :i* summ$ up ! weakness ( ! ,anglican case4 ,yet x only answ]$ to ! c]ta9 fact1 t 9 ! e>ly & undivid$ ,*ur* !re 0 su* a ?+ z au?ority1 & !re 0 no su* ?+ kn[n z ,infallibility4 ,x 0 an appeal to ! facts ( hi/ory & human nature aga9/ ! logical exig5cies ( a !ory4 ,m5 mu/ transc5d ! conditions ( our exp]i5ce if !y want ! c]ta9ty :i* ! !ory ( ,infallibility speaks (4 ,!re 7 especially two weak po9ts 9 ?is view ( ,anglicanism4 ,mr4 ,newman felt & admitt$ !m1 & ( c\rse !y 7 =c$ on 8 att5tion by controv]siali/s on bo? sides2 by ! ,ultra ,prote/ant s*ool1 ^: modes ( deal+ ) ,scripture he _h expos$ ) m]ciless logic & by ! n[ eag] ,roman disputants1 ( :om ,dr4 ,wiseman 0 ! able & n ov]-scrupul\s *ief4 ,! fir/ ( ^! po9ts 0 t ! au?ority ( ! undivid$ ,*ur*1 :i* ,anglicanism invok$1 ?\gh x completely cov]$ ! great f\ndations ( ,*ri/ian doctr9e1 our fai? z to ! nature ( ,god1 did n cov] ) equal complet5ess o!r important po9ts ( controv]sy1 su* z ^? rais$ at ! ,re=mation z to ! ,sacram5ts1 & ! ju/ification ( ! s9n]4 ,! ,anglican answ] 0 t ?\gh ! =mal & concili> au?ority 0 n ! same 9 ea* case1 ! patri/ic lit]ature ( ! "t ( ! great c\ncils1 all t x took = grant$ & pres]v$ z curr5t belief & practice1 all t result$ f ! que/ions & debates ( ! "t1 =m$ a body ( pro(1 :i* c>ri$ ) x moral evid5ce only %ort ( au?oritative def9ition1 & 0 s reg>d$ 9 ! ,anglican =mul>ies4 ,^! =mul>ies impli$ ! au?ority ( ! ,*ur* to speak2 & :at 0 def9$ on ?is au?ority 0 bas$ on good evid5ce1 ?\gh !re 7 portions ( its tea*+ :i* _h ev5 bett]4 ,! o!r po9t 0 m s]i\s4 ,y\r !ory1 0 ! objection1 is no?+ b a pap] !ory2 x nev] 0 a reality2 x nev] c be4 ,!re may be an ideal halt+-place1 !re is nei!r a logical nor an actual "o1 betwe5 ,romanism & ! ord9>y negations ( ,prote/antism4 ,! answ] to ! *all5ge !n 01 ,let u see if x _c be realis$4 ,x has recognis$ f\ndations to build ^u1 & ! imp$im5ts & int]ruptions :i* h h9d]$ x are well kn[n4 ,let u see if x w n turn out some?+ m ?an a pap] !ory4 ,t 0 ! answ] giv5 at ! "t1 ab&on$ t5 ye>s aft]w>ds4 ,b ?is at lea/ may be said1 t ! long] exp]i5ce ( ! la/ fifty ye>s has %[n t ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& has be5 work+ m & m on su* a !ory1 & t ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 :atev] its faults may be1 is c]ta9ly n a ,*ur* only on pap]4 ,b on ! pr9ciples laid d[n 9 ?is volume1 ! ,roman controv]sy1 9 its v>y+ =ms1 0 c>ri$ on--= ! "t by ,mr4 ,newman1 p]man5tly by ! o!r lead]s ( ! movem5t4 ,9 its ma9 outl9es1 ! view has become ! accept$ ,anglican view4 ,_m o!r mo/ important matt]s h come into ! debate4 ,! publicly alt]$ attitude ( ! ,papacy has indef9itely wid5$ ! brea* betwe5 ,engl& & ,rome4 ,b ! fundam5tal idea ( ! relations & "* ( ! two ,*ur*es rema9s ! same z x 0 %ad[$ =? 9 #ahcf4 ,"o v important volume on ^! que/ions ought n to be pass$ by )\t notice4 ,?is 0 ! ,treatise on ! ,*ur* ( ,*ri/1 #ahch1 by ,mr4 ,w4 ,palm]1 :o _h already by 8 ,orig9es ( ! ,engli% ,ritual1 #ahcb1 done mu* to keep up t int]e/ ( ,*ur*m5 9 ! e>ly devotional language ( ! ,*ur*1 :i* _h fir/ be5 call$ =? by ,bi%op ,lloyd's lectures on ! ,pray] ,book4 ,! ,treatise on ! ,*ur* 0 an hon\r to ,engli% !ology & le>n+2 9 po9t ( plan & /ructure we h few books l x4#gb ,x is compreh5sive1 me?odical1 well-compact$1 &1 f its own po9t ( view1 exhau/ive4 ,x is writt5 ) full k ( ! /ate ( ! "q at ! "t1 bo? on ! ,anglican side & on ! ,roman4 ,its au?or evades no objection1 & is aw>e ( mo/4 ,x is rigor\s 9 =m1 & has no place = any?+ b sub/antial argum5t4 ,x is a book :i*1 z ! ,apologia tells u1 comm&$ ! respect ( su* an accompli%$ controv]siali/ z ,p]rone2 &1 x may be add$1 ( a !ologian ( an opposite s*ool1 ,dr4 ,dll+]4 ,x is also "o on :i* ! highe/ value has be5 set by ,mr4 ,glad/one4 ,x is rem>kable t x did n ex]cise m influ5ce on religi\s ?\ght 9 ,ox=d at ! critical "t :5 x appe>$4 ,b x _h defects1 & ! mom5t 0 aga9/ x4 ,x 0 dry & =mal--inevitably s1 f ! sci5tific plan delib]ately adopt$ = x2 x treat$ z problems ( ! !ological s*ools1 to be discuss$ by ! rules ( sev]e & passionless disputation1 que/ions :i* 7 once m1 aft] ! int]val ( m ?an a c5tury1 beg9n+ to t\* he>ts & consci5ces1 & 7 felt to be fraught ) ! grave/ practical issues4 ,& ,mr4 ,newman1 9 8 mode ( deal+ ) !m1 unsy/ematic1 incomplete1 unsatisfactory 9 _m ways z x 01 yet saw 9 !m n ab/ract & s*ola/ic inquiries1 h[ev] important1 b matt]s 9 :i* n only s\nd argum5t1 b sympa?y & quick intellig5ce ( ! conditions & work+ ( ! liv+ m9ds ar\nd him1 7 ne$$ to w9 _! att5tion & int]e/4 ,to p]sons accu/om$ to ,mr4 ,newman's habit ( m9d & way ( writ+1 8 ease1 8 frankness1 8 c&\r1 8 impati5ce ( conv5tionality1 8 pi]c+ insight into ! v c5tre ( que/ions1 8 ev]-ready recognition ( nature & reality1 8 range ( ?\ght1 8 bright & cle> & fe>less /yle ( argum5t1 8 undisplay$ b nev] unfelt consci\sness ( ! true awfulness ( any?+ connect$ ) religion1 any /iff & heavy way ( treat+ que/ions :i* he _h treat$ w\ld h seem$ unattractive & unp]suasive4 ,he _h spoil$ 8 fri5ds = any m]e te*nical h&l+1 h[ev] skilful1 ( great & critical subjects4 ,he himself po9t$ out 9 a review ! unique m]it & ! real value ( ,mr4 ,palm]'s book1 po9t+ out also1 significantly en\gh1 :]e x fell %ort1 bo? 9 sub/ance & 9 mann]4 ,obs]v+ t ! sci5tific sy/em ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* is n yet suffici5tly cle>$ & adju/$1 & add+ a v>iety ( in/ances ( ?is defici5cy1 he lets u see :at he want$ done1 :]e difficulties mo/ press$ ^u himself1 & :]e ,mr4 ,palm] _h miss$ ! real sub/ance ( su* difficulties4 ,look+ at x by ! light ( aft]-ev5ts1 we c see ! contradiction & reaction produc$ by ,mr4 ,palm]'s too optimi/ /atem5ts4 ,/ill1 ,mr4 ,newman's praise 0 s9c]e & discrim9at+4 ,b ,mr4 ,palm]'s book1 ?\gh nev] =gott51 sc>cely became1 :at x at ano!r "t might well h become1 an ,engli% text-book4 ,,footnotes3 #fh ,:ately's ,life1 ed4 #ahge1 pp4 #ahg-aij4 #fi ,adv]tisem5t to vol4 i4 #a/ ,nov4 #ahcd4 #gj ,apologia1 p4 #aci4 #ga ,vide ,lyra ,apo/olica1 ,nos4 #agj1 #agb3 ,h[ %all ,i "n !e1 ,light ( ! wide ,we/1 ,or he9\s error-seat8444 ,oh1 t ?y cre$ 7 s\nd6 ,= ?\ do/ soo! ! he>t1 ?\ ,*ur* ( ,rome1 ,by ?y unwe>i$ wat* & v>i$ r\nd ,( s]vice1 9 ?y ,savi\r's holy home4 ,& comp4 ,no4 #aga1 ,! ,cruel ,*ur*4 #gb ,! mo/ important !ological "w :i* has lately appe>$ is ,mr4 ,palm]'s ,treatise on ! ,*ur*4444 ,:atev] judgm5t may be =m$ ( ! conclusions to :i* he has come on ! v>iety ( po9ts :i* he _h to consid]1 we _c contemplate )\t admiration1 & 7if x 7 "r7 )\t envy1 ! ?or\gh treatm5t :i* 8 subject has receiv$ at 8 h&s4 ,x is inde$ a "w q 9 "* ) ! religi\s movem5t :i* has comm5c$ 9 v>i\s p>ts ( ! ,*ur*1 display+ a magnific5ce ( design simil> to t ( ! ,bi%op ( ,london's plan ( fifty new *ur*es1 & ,dr4 ,pusey1 ( ,ox=d's1 project$ translation ( ! ,fa!rs4--,brit4 ,crit44 ,july #ahch4 ,%ort ,notices4 ,,*apt] ,,xii ,,*anges ,! fir/ sev5 ye>s ( ! movem5t1 z x is said 9 ! ,apologia1 _h be5 ye>s ( prosp]ity4 ,!re _h be5 mi/akes2 !re _h be5 opposition2 !re _h be5 di/ru/ & uneas9ess4 ,!re 0 9 "s places a ban on ! fri5ds ( ,mr4 ,newman2 m5 l ,mr4 ,james ,mozley & ,mr4 ,m>k ,pattison f\nd _! connexion ) him a difficulty 9 ! way ( fell[%ips4 ,b on ! :ole1 ?+s _h gone smoo?ly1 )\t any great breakd[n1 or any op5 collision ) au?ority4 ,b aft] #ahdj ano!r p]iod 0 to beg9 ( tr\ble & disa/]4 ,! se$s ( ?is _h be5 p>tially s[n be=e 9 ! days ( quiet1 & ! "t 0 come = _! developm5t4 ,diff]5ces 9 ! p>ty itself _h be5 gr[+ %>p]2 diff]5ces betwe5 ! m cauti\s & ! m fe>less1 betwe5 ! m /eady-go+ & ! m subtle ?9k]s4 ,! contra/ betwe5 ! famili> & cu/om>y1 & ! new--betwe5 ! unkn[n or =gott51 & a mass ( k only rec5tly realis$--became m pron\nc$4 ,consequ5ces ( a practical k9d1 real or suppos$2 began to %[ !mselves1 & to press4 ,& above all1 a second g5]ation1 )\t ! sob]+ exp]i5ce ( ! fir/1 0 />t+ f :]e ! fir/ _h rea*$ to1 &1 9 "s in/ances1 0 ris+ up aga9/ _! tea*]s' caution & pati5ce4 ,! usual dang]s ( all e>ne/ & aggressive ass]tions ( great pr9ciples appe>$3 contempt = ev]y?+ 9 op9ion & practice t 0 n advanc$1 m5 vy+ ) ea* o!r 9 bold inf]5ces1 9 ! pleasure ( talk+ /rong4 ,) ?is grew fe> & exasp]ation on ! o!r side1 misund]/&+s1 misgiv+s1 /ra9+s ( mutual confid5ce1 )94 ,dr4 ,hook alt]nat$ betwe5 viol5t bur/s ( irritation & disgu/1 & equally /rong returns ( sympa?y1 admiration1 & gratitude2 & he repres5t$ a l>ge am\nt ( feel+ among ,*ur*m54 ,x 0 b too cle> t /orms 7 at h&4 ,!y came p]haps quick] ?an !y 7 anticipat$4 ,t[>ds ! end ( #ahch1 a proposal 0 br\ght =w>d1 = :i* 9 its direct aspect mu* might plausibly be said1 b :i* 0 9 int5tion & indirectly a te/ "q1 meant to put ! ,tract>ians 9 a difficulty1 & to obta9 ! weight ( au?ority 9 ! ,univ]sity aga9/ !m4 ,x 0 propos$ to raise a subscription1 & to erect a monum5t 9 ,ox=d1 to ! m>tyrs ( ! ,re=mation1 ,cranm]1 ,ridley1 & ,latim]4 ,consid]+ t ! curr5t & popul> language dat$ ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& f ! ,re=mation ( ! sixte5? c5tury1 & cit$ ! ,re=m]s z ultimate & p>am\nt au?orities on its doctr9e1 !re 0 no?+ unreasonable 9 su* a proposal4 ,dr4 ,hook1 /rong ,*ur*man z he 01 call$ to union on ! pr9ciples ( ! ,engli% ,re=mation4 ,b ! criticism :i* _h be5 set afloat by ! movem5t _h discov]$ & realis$1 :at def5d]s ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* _h hi!rto felt x an act ( piety to disbelieve1 :5 put be=e !m by ,romani/s l ,l+>d1 & radicals l ,cobbett4 t ! ,re=m]s _h be5 accomplices 9 _m indef5sible acts1 & _h be5 inconsi/5t & untru/wor?y !ologians4 ,provid5tially1 x 0 felt1 ! =ce ( old convictions & tradition & ! hi/orical ev5ts ( ! "t _h oblig$ !m to respect ! ess5tials ( ,ca?olic tru? & polity & usage2 we ow$ to !m mu* t 0 beautiful & devotional 9 ! ,pray] ,book2 & _! ,articles1 cle> 9 all matt]s decid$ by ! e>ly !ology1 avoid$ =eign extremes 9 deal+ ) lat] controv]sies4 ,b _! own individual language 0 (t5 f> 9 advance ( ! public & (ficial language ( =mul>ies1 9 ! direction ( ! great ,prote/ant au?orities ( ,g5eva & ,zuri*4 ,!re 7 /ill1 ev5 among ! movem5t p>ty1 _m :o respect$ ! ,re=m]s = ! "w :i* !y _h attempt$1 & p>tly & imp]fectly done1 to be m wisely & sob]ly c>ri$ on by _! successors ( ! sev5te5? c5tury4 ,b ! *>ges aga9/ _! ,calv9i/ic & ev5 ,zw+lian language 7 h>d to p>ry2 ev5 to ^? :o respect$ !m = _! connexion ) our pres5t ord] ( ?+s1 _! le>n+1 _! s\ndness1 _! au?ority appe>$ to be greatly exagg]at$2 & ! reaction f excessive v5]ation made o!rs dislike & depreciate !m4 ,?is 0 ! /ate ( feel+ :5 ! ,m>tyrs' ,memorial 0 />t$4 ,x 0 eag]ly press$ ) +5i\s & p]sev]+ argum5ts by ,mr4 ,golightly1 ! indefatigable & long-lab\r+ oppon5t ( all t sav\r$ ( ,tract>ianism4 ,! appeal seem$ s speci\s t at fir/ _m ev5 ( ! p>ty gave 9 _! adhesion4 ,ev5 ,dr4 ,pusey 0 dispos$ to subscribe to x4 ,b ,mr4 ,newman1 z 0 natural1 held alo(2 & 8 fri5ds = ! mo/ "p did ! same4 ,x 0 :at 0 expect$ & int5d$4 ,!y 7 ei!r to commit !mselves to ! ,re=mation z und]/ood by ! promot]s ( ! ,memorial2 or !y 7 to be m>k$ z %[+ _! disloyalty to x4 ,! subscription 0 successful4 ,! ,memorial 0 set up1 & /ood1 a d]isive ?\gh un(ficial sign ( ! judgm5t ( ! ,univ]sity aga9/ !m4 ,b ! ,memorial made little diff]5ce to ! progress ( ! movem5t4 ,x 0 an indication ( ho/ility 9 res]ve1 b ?is 0 all2 x =m$ an ornam5t to ! city1 b fail$ z a religi\s & effective prote/4 ,up to ! spr+ ( #ahci1 ,anglicanism1 plac$ on an intellectual bas9 by ,mr4 ,newman1 develop$ practically 9 diff]5t ways by ,dr4 ,pusey & ,dr4 ,hook1 sanction$ 9 !ory by div9es :o repres5t$ ! old div9ity ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 l ,bi%op ,phillpotts & ,mr4 ,h4,j4 ,rose1 c\ld speak ) confid5t & hopeful voice4 ,x might well seem t x 0 on its way to w9 ov] ! com+ g5]ations ( ! ,engli% cl]gy4 ,x _h on its side all t gives int]e/ & p[] to a cause1--?\ght1 =ce ( "*1 unselfi% e>ne/ness2 x _h unity ( idea & agreem5t 9 purpose1 & 0 cem5t$ by ! bonds ( w>m affection & common sympa?ies4 ,x _h ! promise ( a nobl] religion1 z en]getic & z spiritual z ,puritanism & ,wesleyanism1 :ile x drew its inspiration1 its canons ( doctr9e1 its moral /&>ds1 f pur] & m v5]able s\rces2--f communion1 n ) individual tea*]s & p>tial traditions1 b ) ! cons5t+ tea*+ & au?oritative docum5ts ( ! cont9u\s ,ca?olic ,*ur*4 ,anglicanism 0 agre$1 up to ?is "t--! summ] ( #ahci--;z to its g5]al pr9ciples4 ,*>ges ( an incl9ation to ,roman views _h be5 promptly & /\tly met2 nor 0 !re really any?+ b ! ignorance or ill-feel+ ( ! accus]s to ?r[ d\bt on ! s9c]ity ( ^! disav[als4 ,! deepe/ & /ronge/ m9d 9 ! movem5t 0 satisfi$2 & 8 /ead9ess ( conviction c\ld be appeal$ to if 8 foll[]s talk$ wildly & ra%ly4 ,he _h kept "o unwav]+ pa?2 he _h n %runk f fac+ ) fe>less hone/y ! real liv+ array ( reasons :i* ! mo/ s]i\s ,roman advocates c\ld put =w>d4 ,) a frankness new 9 controv]sy1 he _h n be5 afraid to /ate !m ) a =ce :i* few ( 8 oppon5ts c\ld h put =?4 ,) an eye ev] op5 to t supreme ,judge ( all our controv]sies1 :o li/5s to !m on ,8 ?rone on high1 he _h ) consci5ti\s fairness admitt$ :at he saw to be good & j on ! side ( 8 adv]s>ies1 conc$$ :at 9 ! confus$ wrangle ( conflict+ claims he judg$ ought to be conc$$4 ,b aft] all admissions & all concessions1 ! comp>ative /r5g? ( 8 own case appe>$ all ! m und5iable4 ,he _h /ripp$ x ( its weaknesses1 its incumbrances1 its falsehoods2 & x did n seem ! weak] = be+ pres5t$ 9 its real aspect & on its real gr\nds4 ,p felt t he _h gone to ! bottom ( ! "q z no "o _h yet d>$ to d4 ,he 0 yet /aun* 9 8 convictions2 & !y c\ld feel secure4 ,b a *ange 0 at h&4 ,9 ! c\rse ( #ahci1 ! little cl\d %[$ itself 9 ! outlook ( ! future2 ! little rift op5$1 small & h>dly p]ceptible1 :i* 0 to wid5 into an impassable gulf4 ,anglicanism />t$ ) und\bt$ confid5ce 9 its own f\ndations & its own position1 z mu* aga9/ ,romanism z aga9/ ! m rec5t =ms ( religion4 ,9 ! consci\sness ( its /r5g?1 x c\ld af=d to make admissions & to refra9 f tempt+ b unwor?y argum5ts 9 controv]sy ) ,rome2 inde$ ! necessity ( su* controv]sy _h come ^u x unexpect$ly & by surprise4 ,) ,engli% frankness1 9 its impati5ce ( abuses & desire = improvem5t )91 x _h dwelt /rongly on ! faults & %ortcom+s ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* :i* x desir$ to rem$y2 b :ile all[+ :at 0 und5iably excell5t 9 ,rome1 x _h be5 equally outspok5 & emphatic 9 condemnation ( ! evils ( ,rome4 ,:at is !re to wond] at 9 su* a position8 ,x is ! position ( e hone/ re=m+ movem5t1 at lea/ 9 ,engl&4 ,b ,anglican self-reliance 0 un%ak51 & ,anglican hope wax$ /rong] z ! ye>s w5t on1 & ! impression made by ,anglican tea*+ became wid] & deep]4 ,outside attacks1 outside p]secution1 c\ld n[ d little h>m2 ! "t 0 pa/ = t4 ,:at might h happ5$ _h ?+s gone on z !y began1 x is idle to inquire4 ,b at ! mom5t :5 all seem$ to promise fair1 ! "o fatal influ5ce1 ! pres5ce ( int]nal unc]ta9ty & d\bt1 %[$ itself4 ,! body ( m5 :o _h s = act$ toge!r began to %[ a d\ble aspect4 ,:ile "o portion ( x cont9u$ on ! old l9es1 hold+ ! old gr\nd1 def5d+ ! old pr9ciples1 & attempt+ to apply !m = ! improvem5t ( ! practical sy/em ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ano!r portion _h ask$ ! "q1 & 7 pursu+ ! anxi\s inquiry1 :e!r ! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 a true ,*ur* at all1 a true portion ( ! "o un9t]rupt$ ,ca?olic ,*ur* ( ! ,r$eem]4 ,& ! "q _h =c$ itself ) importunate p]si/5ce on ! lead+ m9d ( ! movem5t4 ,f ?is "t ! fate ( ,tract>ianism1 z a p>ty1 0 decid$4 ,9 ?is ov]?r[ ( confid5ce1 two sets ( influ5ces may be trac$4 #a4 ,"o1 :i* came f above1 f ! highe/ lead+ au?ority 9 ! movem5t1 0 ! unsettlem5t ( ,mr4 ,newman's m9d4 ,he has told ! /ory1 ! /ory z he believ$ ( 8 enfran*isem5t & deliv]ance2 & he has told ! /ory1 ?\gh ! /ory ( a deliv]ance1 ) s ke5 a feel+ ( its pa!tic & tragic "*1--z x is inde$ ! mo/ tragic /ory ( a conv]sion to peace & hope on record1--t x w nev] cease to be read :]e ! ,engli% language is spok54 ,up to ! summ] ( #ahci1 8 view ( ! ,engli% position _h satisfi$ him--satisfi$ him1 t is1 z a t5able "o 9 ! anomalies ( exi/+ ,*ri/5dom4 ,all seem$ cle> & hopeful1 & ! "o ?+ to be ?\ght ( 0 to raise ! ,engli% ,*ur* to ! height ( its own /&>d4 ,b 9 ! autumn ( t ye> 7#ahci71 z he has told u1 a *ange took place4 ,9 ! summ] ( #ahci1 he _h set himself to /udy ! hi/ory ( ! ,monophysite controv]sy4 ,i h no reason1 he writes1 to suppose t ! ?\ght ( ,rome came across my m9d at all4444 ,x 0 dur+ ?is c\rse ( read+ t = ! fir/ "t a d\bt came across me ( ! t5abl5ess ( ,anglicanism4 ,i _h se5 ! %ad[ ( a h& on ! wall4 ,he :o has se5 a gho/ _c be z if he _h nev] se5 x4 ,! heav5s _h op5$ & clos$ aga94 ,to less imag9ative & sl[] m9ds ?is seems an ov]wr\ght description ( a ph5om5on1 :i* mu/ pres5t itself sometime or o!r to all :o se>* ! f\ndations ( conviction2 & by itself he 0 = ! "t pro( aga9/ its =ce4 ,! ?\ght = ! mom5t _h be51 ,! ,*ur* ( ,rome w be f\nd "r aft] all2 & !n x _h vani%$4 ,my old convictions rema9$ z be=e4 ,b ano!r bl[ came1 & !n ano!r4 ,an article by ,dr4 ,wiseman on ! ,donati/s greatly di/urb$ him4 ,! words ( ,/4 ,augu/9e ab\t ! ,donati/s1 securus judicat orbis t]r>um1 rang cont9ually 9 8 e>s1 l words out ( ! sky4 ,he f\nd ! ?reat5+s ( ! ,monophysite controv]sy r5ew$ 9 ! ,arian3 ! gho/ _h come a second "t4 ,x 0 a mo/ uncom=table article1 he writes 9 8 lett]s2 ! fir/ real hit f ,romanism :i* has happ5$ to me2 x gave him1 z he says1 a /oma*-a*e4 ,b he /ill held 8 gr\nd1 & return$ 8 answ] to ! attack 9 an article 9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 on ! ,ca?olicity ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,he did n mean to take ! attack = m ?an x 0 wor?1 an able bit ( ex p>te /atem5t4 ,b x told on him1 z no?+ _h yet told on him4 ,:at x did1 0 to op5 a vi/a :i* 0 clos$ be=e1 & ( :i* he c\ld n see ! end2 we are n at ! bottom ( ?+s1 0 ! /+ x left beh9d ,f ?is "t1 ! hope & exultation ) :i*1 9 spite ( *ecks & misgiv+s1 he _h wat*$ ! movem5t1 gave way to uneas9ess & di/ress4 ,a new /ruggle 0 beg9n+1 a long /ruggle ) himself1 a long /ruggle betwe5 rival claims :i* w\ld n be d5i$1 ea* equally imp]i\s1 & involv+ fatal consequ5ces if by mi/ake ! wrong "o 0 admitt$4 ,& x 0 n only ! effect ( ^! ?\ghts on 8 own m9d :i* fill$ him ) grief & tr\ble4 ,he always ?\ght mu* = o!rs2 & n[ !re 0 ! mis]y ( p]haps unsettl+ o!rs--o!rs :o _h tru/$ him ) _! v s\ls--o!rs1 to :om x 0 impossible to expla9 ! conflicts :i* 7 pass+ 9 8 own m9d4 ,x 0 s bitt] to unsettle _! hope & confid5ce4 ,all ?r\gh ?is "t1 m try+ ?an 8 own difficulties1 7 ! p]plexities & sorr[s :i* he =esaw = ^? :om he lov$4 ,v illogical & inconsecutive1 d\btless2 if only he _h _h ! h>d he>t ( a proselytis]1 he w\ld h se5 t x 0 8 duty to und]m9e & %att] _! old convictions4 ,b he c>$ m = ! temp]s & beliefs 9 :i* he 0 at "o ) 8 ,anglican fri5ds1 ?an = ^? 9 :i* !y c\ld n foll[ him4 ,b ! /ruggle came on gradually4 ,:at he fe>$ at fir/ 0 n ! triumph ( ,rome1 b ! break-up ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*2 ! app>5t probability ( a great s*ism 9 x4 ,i fe> ,i see m cle>ly t we are work+ up to a s*ism 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 t is1 a split betwe5 ,peculi>s & ,apo/olicals 444 ,i nev] c be surpris$ at individuals go+ (f to ,rome1 b t is n my *ief fe>1 b a s*ism2 t is1 ^? two p>ties1 :i* h hi!rto got on toge!r z !y c\ld1 f ! times ( ,puritanism d[nw>ds1 ga!r+ up into cle>1 tangible1 & direct =ces1 & collid+4 ,our ,*ur* is n at "o ) itself1 !re is no d5y+ x4 ,t 0 at fir/ ! disa/] be=e him4 ,8 ?\ght = himself began to turn1 n to ,rome1 b to a new life )\t (fice & au?ority1 b /ill )9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,y see1 if ?+s come to ! wor/1 ,i %\ld turn bro!r ( *>ity 9 ,london4 ,& he began to prep>e = a move f ,ox=d1 f ,/4 ,m>y's1 f 8 fell[%ip4 ,he b\ght l& at ,littlemore1 & began to plant4 ,he asks 8 bro!r-9-law = plans = build+ :at he calls a 4 ,he looks =w>d to its becom+ a sort ( ,mona/ic s*ool1 b /ill connect$ ) ! ,univ]sity4 ,9 ,mr4 ,newman's view ( ! debate betwe5 ,engl& & ,rome1 he _h all along dwelt on two broad features1 ,apo/olicity & ,ca?olicity1 lik5ess to ! ,apo/olic tea*+1 & lik5ess to ! un9t]rupt$ unity & ext5t ( ! undivid$ ,*ur*2 & ( ^? two features he f\nd ! fir/ signally want+ 9 ,rome1 & ! second signally want+ 9 ,engl&4 ,:5 he began to di/ru/ 8 own reason+s1 /ill ! di/urb+ & repell+ elem5t 9 ,rome 0 ! alleg$ defect ( ,apo/olicity1 ! contra/ betwe5 primitive & ,roman religion2 :ile ! attractive "o 0 ! app>5t widely ext5d$ ,ca?olicity 9 all l&s1 ,ea/ & ,we/1 cont95ts & isles1 ( ! _w-wide spiritual empire ( ! ,pope4 ,x is ^! two great po9ts :i* may be trac$ 9 _! action on 8 m9d at ?is crisis4 ,! contra/ betwe5 e>ly & ,roman doctr9e & practice1 9 a v>iety ( ways1 "s ( !m mo/ grave & important1 0 long a great difficulty 9 ! way ( attempt+ to id5tify ! ,roman ,*ur*1 absolutely & exclusively1 ) ! ,primitive ,*ur*4 ,! /udy ( antiquity indispos$ him1 inde$1 m & m to ! exi/+ sy/em ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*2 its claims to model itself on ! purity & simplicity ( ! ,e>ly ,*ur* seem$ to him1 9 ! light ( its docum5ts1 & /ill m ( ! facts ( hi/ory & life1 m & m que/ionable4 ,b mod]n ,rome 0 j z di/ant f ! ,e>ly ,*ur* ?\gh x pres]v$ _m anci5t features1 lo/ or unvalu$ by ,engl&4 ,/ill1 ,rome 0 n ! same ?+ z ! ,e>ly ,*ur*2 & ,mr4 ,newman ultimately s\ght a way out ( 8 difficulty--& inde$ !re 0 no o!r--9 ! fam\s doctr9e ( ,developm5t4 ,b :5 ! difficulty ab\t ,apo/olicity 0 ?us provid$ =1 !n ! =ce ( ! great vision ( ! ,ca?olic ,*ur* came ^u him1 un*eck$ & irresi/ible4 ,t 0 a ?+ pres5t1 visible1 und5iable z a fact ( nature2 t 0 a ?+ at once old & new2 x belong$ z truly1 z manife/ly1 to ! rec5t & mod]n _w ( democracy & sci5ce1 z x did to ! ,middle ,ages & ! ,fa!rs1 to ! _w ( ,gregory & ,innoc5t1 to ! _w ( ,a?anasius & ,augu/9e4 ,! maje/y1 ! va/ness ( an imp]ial polity1 outla/+ all /ates & k+doms1 all social *anges & political revolutions1 answ]$ at once to ! promises ( ! prophecies1 & to ! antec$5t idea ( ! univ]sal k+dom ( ,god4 ,be=e ?is great idea1 embodi$ 9 concrete =m1 & n a pap] doctr9e1 p>tial sc&als & abuses seem$ to s9k into insignificance4 ,objections seem$ petty & ignoble2 ! pret5ce ( rival sy/ems imp]t95t & absurd4 ,he res5t$ almo/ ) impati5ce any?+ 9 ! way ( !ory or explanation :i* seem$ to him n>r[1 te*nical1 dialectical4 ,he w\ld look at no?+ b :at _h on x ! m>k ( greatness & l>g5ess :i* befitt$ ! awful subject1 & 0 wor?y ( arre/+ ! eye & att5tion ( an ecclesia/ical /atesman1 alive to mighty int]e/s1 comp>$ to :i* ev5 ! mo/ s]i\s human affairs 7 dw>f$ & obscur$4 ,b all ?is 0 gradual 9 com+4 ,8 recognition ( ! claims ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 faulty & imp]fect z he ?\ght x1 did n give way sudd5ly & at once4 ,x surviv$ ! rude %ock ( #ahci1 ,f fir/ to almo/ ! la/ %e 0 own$ z 8 "m--own$ 9 passionate acc5ts ( disappo9tm5t & despair z a ,*ur* :i* knew n h[ to use its gifts2 yet /ill1 ev5 ?\gh life seem$ fail+ h]1 & h] p[] ( tea*+ & rul+ seem$ p>alys$1 8 "m2 & z long z !re seem$ to him a prospect ( re/oration to heal?1 x 0 8 duty to /ay by h]4#gc ,?is 0 8 fir/ attitude = ?ree or f\r ye>s aft] #ahci4 ,he c\ld n speak ( h] ) ! en?usiasm & triumph ( ! fir/ ye>s ( ! movem5t4 ,:5 he f\ght h] battles1 x 0 ) ! s5se t h] imp]fections made 8 task ! h>d]4 ,/ill he clung to ! belief t %e held a high] /&>d ?an %e _h yet act$ up to1 & disc\rag$ & p]plex$ he yet ma9ta9$ h] cause4 ,b n[ two ?+s happ5$4 ,! ,roman claims1 z 0 natural :5 always be=e him1 seem$ to him m & m indisputable4 ,& 9 ,engl& 8 int]pretation ( ,anglican !ology seem$ to be m & m contradict$1 disav[$1 condemn$1 by all t spoke ) any au?ority 9 ! ,*ur*4 ,! ,univ]sity 0 n an ecclesia/ical body1 yet x _h practically mu* weight 9 matt]s ( !ology2 x in=mally1 b effectually1 decl>$ aga9/ him4 ,! ,bi%ops1 "o by "o1 ( c\rse only spoke z individuals2 b !y 7 ! (ficial spokesm5 ( ! ,*ur*1 & _! cons5t1 ?\gh n ! act ( a ,synod1 0 weighty--!y too _h decl>$ aga9/ him4 ,& f9ally t vague b p[]ful voice ( public op9ion1 :i* claims to repres5t at once ! cool judgm5t ( ! unbiass$1 & ! passion ( ! zeal\s--x too decl>$ aga9/ him4 ,c\ld he claim to und]/& ! m9d ( ! ,*ur* bett] ?an its own organs8 ,!n at l5g? a *ange came2 & x 0 m>k$ outw>dly by a curi\s retractation ( 8 sev]e language ab\t ,rome1 publi%$ 9 a pap] call$ ! ,cons]vative ,j\rnal1 9 ,janu>y #ahdc2 & m di/9ctly1 by 8 resignation ( ,/4 ,m>y's 9 ,septemb] #ahdc1 a /ep contemplat$ = "s "t1 & by 8 ann\ncem5t t he 0 prep>+ to resign 8 fell[%ip4 ,f ?is "t he felt t he c\ld no long] hold (fice1 or be a *ampion ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*2 f ?is "t1 x 0 only a matt] ( wait+1 wait+ to make q c]ta9 t he 0 "r & 0 "u no delusion1 :5 he %\ld leave h] = ! ,roman ,communion4 ,& to 8 intimate fri5ds1 to 8 si/]s1 he gave notice t ?is 0 n[ imp5d+4 ,to ! _w outside1 all t 0 kn[n 0 t he 0 mu* unsettl$ & di/ress$ by difficulties4 ,x may be ask$ :y ?is *ange 0 n at ?is "t communicat$1 n to a few intimates1 b to ! _w8 ,:y did he n at ?is "t hoi/ 8 qu>ant9e flag & w>n e "o t he 0 dang]\s to come ne>8 ,s ke5 a m9d mu/1 x 0 said1 h by ?is "t =ese5 h[ ?+s w\ld end2 he ought to h giv5 e>li] notice4 ,8 answ] 0 t he 0 s9c]ely desir\s ( avoid+1 z f> z possible1 :at might prejudice ! ,*ur* 9 :i* he _h m9i/]$1 ev5 at ! mom5t ( leav+ h]4 ,he saw 8 own way becom+ cle>] & cle>]2 b he saw x = himself alone4 ,he 0 n "o ( ^? :o =c$ ! convictions ( o!rs2 he 0 n "o ( ^? :o ?9k x a great ?+ to be foll[$ 9 a s]i\s *ange by a cr[d ( disciples4 ,:atev] might be at ! end1 x 0 n[ an agonis+ wr5* to "p f ! ,engli% body1 to "p f ! numb]s ( fri5ds ^: loyalty 0 immovable1 to "p f numb]s :o _h tru/$ & le>n$ f him4 ,( c\rse1 if he 0 9 ! "r way1 he c\ld wi% !m no?+ bett] ?an t !y %\ld foll[ him4 ,b !y 7 9 ,god's h&s2 x 0 n 8 bus9ess to unsettle !m2 x 0 n 8 bus9ess to ensn>e & co]ce _! fai?4 ,& s he tri$ = ?is "t to /e] 8 c\rse alone4 ,he wi%$ to avoid obs]vation4 ,he 0 sil5t on all t w5t on r\nd him1 excit+ z "s ( ! incid5ts 74 ,he w\ld n he hurri$2 he w\ld give himself full "t2 he w\ld d :at he c\ld to make sure t he 0 n act+ "u ! influ5ce ( a delusion4 ,! f9al result ( all ?is 0 long 9 com+2 !re 01 we "k1 a bitt] agony ( five ye>s1 a prolong$ & ob/9ate & cruel /ruggle betwe5 ! deepe/ affections & ev]-gr[+ convictions4 ,b ?is /ruggle1 z has be5 said1 did n beg9 ) ! conviction 9 :i* x end$4 ,x began & long cont9u$ ) ! belief t ?\gh ,engl& 0 wrong1 ,rome 0 n "r2 t ?\gh ! ,roman argum5t seem$ m & m unansw]able1 !re 7 insup]able difficulties ( c]ta9 fact :i* made ! ,roman conclusion incr$ible2 t !re 0 s mu* good & tru? 9 ,engl&1 ) all its defects & faults1 :i* 0 unacc\ntable & un9telligible on ! ,roman hypo!sis2 t ! real up%ot 0 t ! :ole /ate ( ?+s 9 ,*ri/5dom 0 abnormal2 t to ,engli% ,*ur*m5 ! ,engli% ,*ur* _h imm$iate & direct claims :i* no?+ b ! mo/ irresi/ible c\nt]-claims c\ld ov]come or neutralise--! claims ( a %ipwreck$ body cut (f f c\ntry & home1 yet z a %ipwreck$ body /ill organis$1 & ) mu* sav$ f ! wreck1 & n to be des]t$1 z long z x held toge!r1 9 an unc]ta9 attempt to rejo9 its lo/ unity4 ,resignation1 retirem5t1 sil5ce1 lay communion1 ! hope ( ultimate1 ?\gh p]haps long-def]r$ reunion--^! 7 8 fir/ ?\ghts4 ,misgiv+s c\ld n be help$1 w\ld n be d5i$1 b ne$ n be p>ad$1 7 to be kept at arm's-l5g? z long z possible4 ,?is is ! picture pres5t$ 9 ! autobiography ( ^! pa9ful & dre>y ye>s2 & !re is e evid5ce t x is a fai?ful "o4 ,x is conceivable1 ?\gh n v probable1 t su* a c\rse might g on indef9itely4 ,x is conceivable t "u diff]5t circum/ances he might1 l o!r p]plex$ & d\bt+ seek]s aft] tru?1 h work$ r\nd ?r\gh d\bt & p]plexity to 8 fir/ conviction4 ,b ! actual result1 z x came1 0 natural en\gh2 & x 0 accel]at$ by provocation1 by oppon5ts )\t1 & by ! pressure ( advanc$ & impati5t foll[]s & disciples 9 ! p>ty itself4 #b4 ,?is la/ 0 ! second ( ! two influ5ces spok5 ( above4 ,x work$ f bel[1 z ! fir/ work$ f above4 ,discussions & agitations1 su* z accompani$ ! movem5t1 h[ev] mu* "u ! control ( ! moral & intellectual asc5dancy ( ! lead]s1 c\ld n ( c\rse be gu>ante$ f escap+ f t control4 ,& z ! "t w5t on1 m5 jo9$ ! movem5t :o _h b qualifi$ sympa?y ) t passionate love & zeal = ! actual ,engli% ,*ur*1 t acqua9tance ) its hi/orical !ology1 & t temp] ( discipl9e1 sobriety1 & self-di/ru/1 :i* m>k$ its fir/ repres5tatives4 ,^! y\ng] disciples %>$ 9 ! gr[+ excitem5t ( ! society r\nd !m4 ,!y 7 attract$ by visible height ( "*1 & brilliant intellectual p[]4 ,!y 7 alive to va/ & orig9al prospects1 op5+ a new _w :i* %\ld be a contra/ to ! worn-out int]e/ ( ! old4 ,"s ( ^! 7 m5 ( wide & ab/ruse le>n+2 qua9t & ecc5tric s*ol>s bo? 9 habit & look1 /ud5ts ( ! anci5t type1 :o ev5 fifty ye>s ago seem$ out ( date to _! g5]ation4 ,"s 7 m5 ( consid]able =ce ( m9d1 de/9$ aft]w>ds to leave a m>k on _! age z ?9k]s & writ]s4 ,to ! =m] class belong$ ,*>les ,seag]1 & ,john ,br&e ,morris1 ( ,exet] ,college1 bo? le>n$ ,ori5tali/s1 /eep$ 9 recondite k ( all k9ds2 m5 :o _h work$ _! way to k ?r\gh h>d%ip & gr9d+ lab\r1 & n to be outdone 9 ,g]many itself = dev\r+ love ( le>n+ & a s*ol>'s pla9ness ( life4 ,9 ! o!r class may be m5tion$ ,fr$]ic ,fab]1 ,j4,d4 ,dalgairns1 & ,w4,g4 ,w>d1 m5 :o h all s9ce ris5 to em95ce 9 _! diff]5t sph]es4 ,fab] 0 a man ) a high gift ( imag9ation1 rem>kable p[]s ( assimilat+ k1 & a great ri*ness & novelty & elegance ( ?\ght1 :i* ) mu* melody ( voice made him ultimately a v attractive prea*]4 ,if ! promise ( 8 p[]s has n be5 adequately fulfill$1 x is p>tly to be trac$ to a want ( sev]ity ( ta/e & self-re/ra9t1 b 8 "n w live 9 "s ( 8 hymns1 & 9 "s v beautiful portions ( 8 devotional writ+s4 ,dalgairns's m9d 0 ( a diff]5t ord]4 ,t man has an eye = !ology1 0 ! rem>k ( a compet5t judge on "s e>ly pap] ( ,dalgairns's :i* came be=e him4 ,he _h some?+ ( ! ,fr5*man ab\t him4 ,!re 0 9 him1 9 8 ,ox=d days1 a bright & frank briskness1 a mixture ( mode/y & ar* d>+1 :i* gave him an almo/ boyi% appe>ance2 b b5ea? ?is boyi% appe>ance !re 0 a subtle & p[]ful intellect1 alive to ! problems ( religi\s philosophy1 & impati5t ( any b ! mo/ ?or\gh solutions ( !m2 :ile1 on ! o!r h&1 ! religi\s affections 7 "p ( 8 nature1 & m9d & w & he>t yield$ an unres]v$ & absolute ob$i5ce to ! lead+ & guidance ( fai?4 ,9 8 lat] days1 ) 8 m9d at ease1 ,fa!r ,dalgairns ?rew himself into ! great battle ) unbelief2 & few m5 h comm&$ m ! respect ( oppon5ts n mu* giv5 to ?9k well ( ! argum5ts = religion1 by ! fre%ness & ! solidity ( 8 reason+4 ,at ?is "t1 en?usia/ic 9 temp]1 & acute & exact+ z a ?9k]1 he f\nd ! ,*ur* movem5t j1 z x 71 on ! turn ( ! wave4 ,he 0 attract$ to x at fir/ by its reaction aga9/ :at 0 unreal & %all[1 by its aff9ities ) :at 0 deep 9 idea & e>ne/ 9 life2 !n1 & f9ally1 he 0 repell$ f x1 by its want ( complet5ess1 by its ,engli% acquiesc5ce 9 compromise1 by its hesitations & cl++ to insul> associations & sympa?ies1 :i* _h little int]e/ = him4 ,ano!r p]son1 :o 0 at ?is "t ev5 m prom95t 9 ! advanc$ portion ( ! movem5t p>ty1 & ^: action _h m decisive influ5ce on its c\rse1 0 ,mr4 ,w4,g4 ,w>d1 ,fell[ ( ,balliol4 ,mr4 ,w>d1 :o 0 fir/ at ,*ri/ ,*ur*1 _h di/+ui%$ himself greatly at ! ,ox=d ,union z a vigor\s speak]1 at fir/ on ! ,tory side2 he came aft]w>ds "u ! influ5ce ( ,ar?ur ,/anley1 !n fre% f ,rugby1 & naturally le>n$ to admire ,dr4 ,arnold2 b ,dr4 ,arnold's religi\s doctr9es did n satisfy him2 ! movem5t1 ) its boldness & orig9ality ( idea & e?ical "*1 _h laid /rong hold on him1 & he pass$ into "o ( ! mo/ ?or\ghgo+ adh]5ts ( ,mr4 ,newman4 ,!re 0 some?+ to smile at 9 8 p]son1 & 9 "s ( 8 ways--8 unbus9ess-l habits1 8 joy\sness ( mann]1 8 racy /ories2 b few m p[]ful intellects pass$ ?r\gh ,ox=d 9 8 "t1 & he has ju/ifi$ 8 ,univ]sity reputation by 8 di/9ction s9ce1 bo? z a ,roman ,ca?olic !ologian & pr(essor1 & z a pr(\nd metaphysical ?9k]1 ! equal antagoni/ on _! own gr\nd ( ,j4 ,/u>t ,mill & ,h]b]t ,sp5c]4 ,b 8 intellect at t "t 0 z rem>kable = its defects z = its p[]s4 ,he us$ to divide 8 fri5ds1 & ?9k+ p 9 g5]al1 into ^? :o _h facts & did n "k :at to d ) !m1 & ^? :o _h 9 p]fection ! logical faculties1 b want$ ! facts to reason ^u4 ,he belong$ himself to ! latt] class4 ,he _h1 n unnaturally1 b\ndless confid5ce 9 8 argum5tative p[]s2 !y 7 subtle1 pi]c+1 nimble1 nev] at a loss1 & !y includ$ a p[] ( exposition :i*1 if x 0 n always succ9ct & lively1 0 always weighty & impressive4 ,premises 9 8 h&s 7 n long 9 br++ =? _! conclusions2 & if ab/ractions always correspond$ exactly to _! concrete embodim5ts1 & ideals 7 fulfill$ 9 realities1 no "o c\ld po9t out m p]spicu\sly & decisively ! practical judgm5ts on !m :i* reason mu/ sanction4 ,b t k ( ?+s & ( m5 :i* m]e p[] ( reason+ w n give 0 n "o ( 8 special end[m5ts4 ,! /udy ( facts1 (t5 9 _! complicat$ & p]plex+ reality1 0 n to 8 ta/e4 ,he 0 apt to accept !m on :at he consid]$ adequate au?ority1 & 8 argum5tation1 =midable z x always 01 recall$1 ev5 :5 mo/ unansw]able at ! mom5t1 ! application ( pure ma!matics )\t all[ance = ! actual =ces1 (t5 difficult to asc]ta9 except by exp]im5t1 :i* w\ld h to be tak5 acc\nt ( 9 practice4 ,! t5d5cy ( ?is section ( able m5 0 unque/ionably ,romew>ds1 almo/ f ! beg9n+ ( _! connexion ) ! movem5t4 ,bo? ! !ory & ! actual sy/em ( ,rome1 s f> z !y und]/ood x1 _h attractions = !m :i* no?+ else _h4 ,b ) :atev] p]plexity & p]haps impati5ce1 ,mr4 ,newman's p[] held !m back4 ,he kept be=e _! m9ds cont9ually ^? difficulties ( fact :i* /ood 9 ! way ( _! absolute & p]emptory conclusions1 & ( :i* !y 7 n mu* incl9$ to take acc\nt4 ,he insi/$ on ^? features1 nei!r few nor unimportant nor h>d to see1 :i* prov$ ! cont9uity ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* ) ! ,*ur* ,univ]sal4 ,%>+ _! s5se ( anomaly 9 ! ,anglican !ory & position1 he po9t$ out ) 8 own =ce & insight t anomaly 0 n 9 ,engl& only1 b ev]y:]e4 ,!re 0 mu* to regret1 !re 0 mu* to improve1 !re 7 _m unwelcome & dang]\s tru?s1 invidiosi v]i1 to be told & def5d$ at any co/4 ,b pati5ce1 z well z hone/y & c\rage1 0 a ,*ri/ian virtue2 & !y :o _h receiv$ _! ,*ri/ianity at ! h&s ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* _h duties t[>ds x f :i* nei!r dissatisfaction nor ! idea ( some?+ bett] c\ld absolve !m4 ,sp>tam nactus es1 hanc exorna is ! motto = e "o ^: lot is ca/ 9 any portion ( ,*ri/'s ,*ur*4 ,& z long z he c\ld speak ) ?is conviction1 ! /ronge/ ( !m c\ld n break away f 8 re/ra9t4 ,x 0 :5 ! trem5d\s "q took %ape1 ,is ! ,engli% ,*ur* a true ,*ur*1 a real "p ( ! ,*ur* ,ca?olic8--:5 ! "q became to 8 m9d m & m d\btful1 at l5g? desp]ate--t !y1 ( c\rse1 became m difficult to satisfy1 m confid5t 9 _! own allegations1 m un*eck$ 9 _! sympa?ies1 &1 9 consequ5ce1 9 _! dislikes4 ,& 9 ! cont9u$ ef=t--= x did cont9ue--to make !m pause & wait & hope1 !y react$ on him2 !y ask$ him que/ions :i* he f\nd x h>d to answ]2 !y press$ him ) inf]5ces :i* he might put by1 b ( :i* he felt ! /+2 !y =c$ on him all ! indications1 ( :i* e day br\ght its contribution1 t ! actual liv+ sy/em ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 aga9/ :at he _h taught to be ,ca?olic1 t its en]getic temp] & _s condemn$ & reject$ him4 ,:at 0 x t private m5 7 /aun* & undismay$8 ,:at 0 x t mon? by mon? all ov] ,engl& he>ts & m9ds 7 attract$ to 8 side1 felt ! spell ( 8 tea*+1 gave him _! confid5ce8 ,suspicion & disapprobation1 :i* _h only too mu* to gr\nd itself ^u1 _h tak5 possession ( ! high places ( ! ,*ur*4 ,au?ority 9 all its %apes _h pron\nc$ z decisively z 8 oppon5ts c\ld wi%2 z decisively z !y too c\ld wi%1 :o desir$ no long] a b>ri] betwe5 !mselves & ,rome4 ,?us a great & mom5t\s *ange _h come ov] ! movem5t1 ov] its action & prospects4 ,x _h />t$ 9 a h]oic ef=t to save ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,! claims1 ! bless+s1 ! div9ity ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 z a true bran* ( ,ca?olic ,*ri/5dom1 _h be5 assum$ z ! f\ndation ( all t 0 felt & said & attempt$4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 ! "o object to :i* ,engli% ,*ri/ians 7 call$ ^u to turn _! ?\ghts4 ,its _s animat$ ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>1 & ! tea*+ ( ^? :om ! ,*ri/ian ,ye> repres5t$4 ,its int]e/s 7 :at call$ =? ! zeal & ! indignation record$ 9 ,fr\de's ,rema9s4 ,no "o s]i\sly ?\ght ( ,rome1 except z a hopelessly corrupt sy/em1 ?\gh x _h "s good & ,ca?olic ?+s1 :i* x 0 ,*ri/ian & hone/ to recognise4 ,! movem5t ( #ahcc />t$ out ( ! ,anti-,roman feel+s ( ! ,emancipation "t4 ,x 0 ,anti-,roman z mu* z x 0 ,anti-,sect>ian & ,anti-,era/ian4 ,x 0 to av]t ! dang] ( p becom+ ,romani/s f ignorance ( ,*ur* pr9ciples4 ,?is 0 all *ang$ 9 "o important section ( ! p>ty4 ,! fundam5tal conceptions & assumptions 7 rev]s$4 ,x 0 n ! ,roman ,*ur*1 b ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 :i* 0 put on its trial2 x 0 n ! ,roman ,*ur*1 b ! ,engli%1 :i* 0 to be1 if possible1 apologis$ =1 p]haps borne ) = a "t1 b :i* 0 to be reg>d$ z deeply fall51 hold+ an unt5able position1 & incomp>ably1 unp>donably1 bel[ bo? ! /&>d & ! practical sy/em ( ! ,roman ,*ur*4 ,f ?is po9t ( view ! object ( ! movem5t 0 no long] to elevate & improve an indep5d5t ,engli% ,*ur*1 b to approximate x z f> z possible to :at 0 assum$ to be und5iable--! p]fect ,ca?olicity ( ,rome4 ,m almo/ ?an ideas & assumptions1 ! tone ( feel+ *ang$4 ,x _h be51 t[>ds ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 affectionate1 en?usia/ic1 rev]5tial1 hopeful4 ,x became contemptu\s1 critical1 intol]ant1 ho/ile ) ! ho/ility n m]ely ( ali5ation b disgu/ ,?is 0 n ( c\rse ! "w ( a mom5t1 b x 0 ( v rapid gr[?4 ,h[ ,i hate ^! ,anglicans6 0 ! expression ( "o ( ! y\ng] m5 ( ?is section1 an intemp]ate & insol5t specim5 ( x4 ,x did n repres5t ! tone or ! language ( ! lead] to :om ! advanc$ section def]r$1 vex$ z he (t5 0 ) ! c\rse ( 8 own ?\ghts1 & irritat$ & impati5t at ! c\rse ( ?+s )\t4 ,b x express$ b too truly ! diff]5ce betwe5 #ahcc & #ahdj4 ,,footnotes3 #gc ,see ,s]mons on ,subjects ( ! ,day1 #ahdc4 ,,*apt] ,,xiii ,,! ,,au?orities ,,& ,,! ,,movem5t ,:ile ! movem5t 0 mak+ itself felt z a moral =ce1 )\t a p>allel 9 ,ox=d = m ?an two c5turies1 & 0 impress+ deeply & p]man5tly "s ( ! mo/ promis+ m5 9 ! ris+ g5]ation 9 ! ,univ]sity1 :at 0 ! attitude ( ! ,univ]sity au?orities8 ,:at 0 ! attitude ( ! ,bi%ops8 ,at ,ox=d x 0 t ( contemptu\s indiff]5ce1 pass+ into helpless & passionate ho/ility4 ,!re is no sadd] passage to be f\nd 9 ! hi/ory ( ,ox=d ?an ! behavi\r & policy ( ! heads ( ?is great ,*ri/ian ,univ]sity t[>ds ! religi\s movem5t :i* 0 /irr+ ! int]e/1 ! hopes1 ! fe>s ( ,ox=d4 ,! movem5t 01 = its fir/ ye>s at lea/1 a loyal & e>ne/ ef=t to s]ve ! cause ( ! ,*ur*4 ,its objects 7 cle> & reasonable2 x aim$ at creat+ a s9c]e & intellig5t zeal = ! ,*ur*1 & at mak+ ! ,*ur* itself wor?y ( ! great position :i* h] fri5ds claim$ = h]4 ,its lead]s 7 m5 well kn[n 9 ! ,univ]sity1 9 ! fir/ rank 9 po9t ( ability & "*2 m5 ( le>n+1 :o knew :at !y 7 talk+ ab\t2 m5 ( religi\s & pure1 if also sev]e lives4 ,!y 7 n m5 m]ely ( speculation & criticism1 b m5 ready to =ego any?+1 to devote ev]y?+ = ! practical "w ( elevat+ religi\s ?\ght & life4 ,all ?is did n necess>ily make _! purposes & attempts wise & good2 b x did entitle !m to respectful att5tion4 ,if !y spoke language new to ! popul> m9d or ! religi\s _w1 x 0 n new--at lea/ x ought n to h be5 new--to or?odox ,*ur*m51 ) opportunities ( /udy & acqua9t$ ) our be/ div9ity4 ,if _! temp] 0 eag] & en?usia/ic1 !y alleg$ ! pres5ce ( a great & p]il\s crisis4 ,_! appeal 0 ma9ly n to ! g5]al public1 b to ! sob] & ! le>n$2 to ^? to :om 0 entru/$ ! =mation ( fai? & "* 9 ! future cl]gy ( ! ,*ur*2 to ^? :o 7 responsible = ! discipl9e & moral tone ( ! fir/ ,univ]sity ( ,*ri/5dom1 & :o held _! conspicu\s position on ! und]/&+ ( t responsibility4 ,x behov$ ! heads ( ! ,univ]sity to be cauti\s1 ev5 to be suspici\s2 movem5ts might be holl[ or dang]\s ?+s4 ,b x behov$ !m also to become acqua9t$ ) s /rik+ a ph5om5on z ?is2 to judge x by :at x appeal$ to--! le>n+ ( ,engli% div9es1 ! /&>d ( a high & g5]\s moral rule2 to recognise its aims at lea/1 ) equity & sympa?y1 if "s ( its me?ods & argum5ts seem$ que/ionable4 ,! m5 ( ! movem5t 7 n m]e ho/ile innovators2 !y 7 fight+ = :at ! ,univ]sity & its *iefs held de> & sacr$1 ! privileges & safety ( ! ,*ur*4 ,x 0 ! natural "p ( ! heads ( ! ,univ]sity to act z mod]ators2 at any rate1 to h %[n1 ) :atev] res]ve1 t !y appreciat$ :at !y ne$$ "t to judge (4 ,b :ile on ! "o side !re 0 burn+ & dev\r+ e>ne/ness1 & t p[] ( conviction :i* d\bles ! /r5g? ( ! /rong1 !re 0 on ! o!r a s]5e ignor+ ( all t 0 go+ on1 wor?y ( a set ( dignifi$ ,fr5* abbs on ! eve ( ! ,revolution4 ,?is sublime or imbecile security 0 occasionally int]rupt$ by bur/s ( irritation at "s fre% piece ( ,tract>ian oddness or audacity1 or at "s /range /ory :i* made its way f ! gossip ( common rooms to ! society ( ! ,heads ( ,h\ses4 ,& !re 0 always ready a /ick to beat ! (f5d]s2 ev]y?+ c\ld be call$ ,popi%4 ,b = ! mo/ "p !y look$ on1 ) smiles1 ) jokes1 sometimes ) scold+4#gd ,?us ! m5 :o by _! place ought to h be5 able to gauge & control ! movem5t1 :o might h be5 expect$ to meet half-way a s]i\s attempt to brace up ! religi\s & moral tone ( ! place1 s incalculably important 9 days confess$ to be anxi\s ones1 simply set _! faces /eadily to disc\nt5ance & discr$it x4 ,!y 7 good & respectable m51 liv+ com=tably 9 a c]ta9 /ate & ease4 ,_! lives 7 mo/ly simple comp>$ ) ! /&>d ( ! out] _w1 ?\gh ,fell[s ( ,colleges ?\ght !m luxuri\s4 ,b !y 7 bl9d & dull z tea-table gossips z to :at 0 ! mean+ ( ! movem5t1 z to :at might come ( x1 z to :at use might be made ( x by wise & j & g5]\s recognition1 &1 if ne$ be1 by wise & j criticism & repression4 ,!re 7 po9ts ( dang] 9 x2 b !y c\ld only see :at seem$ to be dang]\s1 :e!r x 0 s or n2 & !y multipli$ ^! po9ts ( dang] by all t 0 good & hopeful 9 x4 ,x p]plex$ & annoy$ !m2 !y _h n imag9ation nor moral elevation to take 9 :at x aim$ at2 !y 7 cont5t ) ! r\t9e :i* !y _h inh]it$2 &1 s t m5 read = hon\rs & took fir/ classes1 x did n seem to !m /range or a pr(anation t a :ole mix$ cr[d ( und]graduates %\ld be expect$ to g on a c]ta9 ,sunday 9 t]m1 will+ or unwill+1 fit or unlit1 to ! ,sacram5t1 & be f9$ if !y did n appe>4 ,d\btless we are all ( u too prone to be cont5t ) ! cu/om>y1 & to be prejudic$ aga9/ ! novel1 nor is ?is condition ( ?+s )\t advantage4 ,b we mu/ be> our condemnation if we /ick to ! cu/om>y too long1 & s miss our signal opportunities4 ,9 _! apa?y1 9 _! self-satisfi$ ignorance1 9 _! dulness ( appreh5sion & =e?\ght1 ! au?orities ( ! ,univ]sity let pass ! great opportunity ( _! "t4 ,z x usually happ5s1 :5 ?is po/ure ( l(ty ignor+ :at is palpable & active1 & ! object ( ev]ybody's ?\ght1 goes on too long1 x is apt to turn into impati5t dislike & bitt] antipa?y4 ,! ,heads ( ,h\ses drift$ ins5sibly into ?is position4 ,!y _h n tak5 ! tr\ble to und]/& ! movem5t1 to discrim9ate betwe5 its aspects1 to put !mselves frankly into communication ) its lead+ p]sons1 to judge ) ! k & ju/ice ( s*ol>s & cl]gym5 ( its designs & ways4 ,!y let !mselves be div]t$ f ?is1 _! prop] ?\gh tr\blesome task1 by di/ru/1 by ! jeal\sies ( _! position1 by ! impossibility ( conceiv+ t any?+ s /range c\ld really be true & s\nd4 ,& at l5g? !y f\nd !mselves go+ along ) ! outside curr5t ( un9/ruct$ & ignoble prejudice1 9 a settl$ & pron\nc$ dislike1 :i* took = grant$ t all 0 wrong 9 ! movem5t1 :i* admitt$ any ill-natur$ surmise & fooli% misrepres5tation1 & really all[$ itself to acquiesce 9 ! belief t m5 s well kn[n 9 ,ox=d1 once s admir$ & hon\r$1 _h sunk d[n to delib]ate corrupt]s ( ! tru?1 & palt]]s ) _! own intellects & consci5ces4 ,x came 9 a few ye>s to be und]/ood on bo? sides1 t ! au?orities 7 9 direct antagonism to ! movem5t2 & ?\gh _! ef=ts 9 opposition to x 7 feeble & petty1 x w5t on "u ! dead weight ( (ficial ,univ]sity disapproval4 ,x w\ld h be5 a great ?+ = ! ,engli% ,*ur*--?\gh x is h>d to see h[1 ?+s be+ z !y 71 x c\ld h come ab\t--if ! movem5t _h gone on1 at lea/ ) ! fri5dly int]e/1 if n ) ! support1 ( ! ,univ]sity rul]s4 ,in/ead ( t1 aft] ! fir/ two or ?ree ye>s !re 0 "o long & bitt] fight 9 ,ox=d1 ) ! ang] on "o side creat$ by ! belief ( vague b gr[+ dang]s1 & a s5se ( incapacity 9 resi/+ !m1 & ) deep res5tm5t at inju/ice & /upidity on ! o!r4 ,! ,bi%ops 7 f>!r f ! imm$iate sc5e ( ! movem5t1 & besides1 _h o!r ?+s to ?9k (4 ,?ree or f\r ( !m might be consid]$ !ologians--,ar*bi%op ,h[ley1 ,phillpotts ( ,exet]1 ,kaye ( ,l9coln1 ,m>% ( ,pet]bor\gh4 ,two or ?ree belong$ to ! ,evangelical s*ool1 ,ryd] ( ,li*field1 & ! two ,sumn]s at ,w9*e/] & ,*e/]4 ,! mo/ prom95t among !m1 & next to ! ,bi%op ( ,exet] ! able/1 alive to ! real dang]s ( ! ,*ur*1 anxi\s to infuse vig\r into its "w1 & busy ) plans = ext5d+ its influ5ce1 0 ,blomfield1 ,bi%op ( ,london4 ,b ,blomfield 0 n at 8 be/ z a div9e1 &1 = a man ( 8 unque/ionable p[]1 s+ul>ly unsure ( 8 own m9d4 ,he knew1 9 fact1 t :5 ! que/ions rais$ by ! ,tracts came be=e him he 0 unqualifi$ to deal ) !m2 he 0 no bett] furni%$ by ?\ght or k or habits to judge ( !m ?an ! av]age ,bi%op ( ! "t1 appo9t$1 z 0 s (t5 ! case1 = political or p]sonal reasons4 ,at ! fir/ />t ( ! movem5t1 ! ,bi%ops n unnaturally wait$ to see :at w\ld come ( x4 ,x 0 inde$ an ef=t 9 fav\r ( ! ,*ur*1 b x 0 9 irresponsible h&s1 begun by m5 ^: words 7 /rong & vehem5t & ( unusual s\nd1 & :o1 :ile !y call$ on ! cl]gy to rally r\nd _! fa!rs ! ,bi%ops1 did n %r9k f wi%+ = ! ,bi%ops ! =tunes ( ! e>ly days3 we c\ld n wi% !m a m bless$ t]m9ation ( _! c\rse ?an ! spoil+ ( _! goods & m>tyrdom4#gf ,x may reasonably be suppos$ t su* good wi%es 7 n to ! ta/e ( all ( !m4 ,z ! movem5t develop$1 besides t x w\ld seem to !m extravagant & viol5t1 !y w\ld be p]plex$ by its doctr9e4 ,x took /rong gr\nd = ! ,*ur*2 b x did s 9 ! tee? ( religi\s op9ions & prejudices1 :i* 7 popul> & intol]ant4 ,= a mom5t ! ,bi%ops 7 9 a difficulty2 on ! "o h&1 no "o = g5]ations _h s exalt$ ! (fice ( a ,bi%op z ! ,tract>ians2 no "o _h claim$ = x s high & sacr$ an orig92 no "o _h urg$ ) su* practical e>ne/ness ! duty ( ,*ur*m5 to recognise & ma9ta9 ! unique au?ority ( ! ,episcopate aga9/ its despis]s or oppressors4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ?is 0 j ! "t :5 ! ,evangelical p>ty1 aft] long disfav\r1 0 beg9n+ to ga9 recognition1 = ! sake ( its pa/ e>ne/ness & good works1 ) m5 9 p[]1 & ) ecclesia/ical au?orities ( a diff]5t & hi!rto ho/ile s*ool2 & 9 ! ,tract>ian movem5t ! ,evangelical p>ty saw f ! fir/ its natural enemy4 ,! ,bi%ops c\ld n h any?+ to d ) ! ,tract>ians )\t deeply (f5d+ ! ,evangelicals4 ,! result 0 t1 = ! pres5t1 ! ,bi%ops held alo(4 ,!y let ! movem5t run on by itself4 ,%>p s>casms1 worldly-wise pr$ictions1 k9d messages ( approval1 k9d cautions1 pass$ f m\? to m\?1 or 9 private correspond5ce f high qu>t]s1 :i* %[$ t ! movem5t 0 wat*$4 ,b = "s "t ! au?orities spoke nei!r good nor bad ( x publicly4 ,9 8 ,*>ge at ! close ( #ahcf1 ,bi%op ,phillpotts spoke 9 cle> & unfalt]+ language--language rem>kable = its bold decision--( ! necessity ( sett+ =? ! true idea ( ! ,*ur* & ! sacram5ts2 b he 0 sil5t ab\t ! call ( ! same k9d :i* _h come f ,ox=d4 ,x w\ld h be5 well if ! o!r ,bi%ops lat] on1 9 _! *>ges1 _h foll[$ 8 example4 ,! ,bi%op ( ,ox=d1 9 8 ,*>ge ( #ahch1 ref]r$ to ! movem5t 9 balanc$ t]ms ( praise & w>n+4 ,! fir/ :o condemn$ ! movem5t 0 ! ,bi%op ( ,*e/]1 ,j4 ,bird ,sumn]2 9 a lat] ,*>ge he came to describe x z ! "w ( ,satan2 9 #ahch he only d5\nc$ ! und]m9+ ( ! f\ndations ( our ,prote/ant ,*ur* by m5 :o dwell )9 h] walls1 & ! bad fai? ( ^? :o sit 9 ! ,re=m]s' seat1 & traduce ! ,re=mation4 ,^! 7 grave mi/akes on ! "p ( ^? :o 7 responsible = ! gov]nm5t ( ! ,univ]sity & ! ,*ur*4 ,!y treat$ z absurd1 mis*iev\s1 & at l5g? traitor\s1 an ef=t1 ?an :i* no?+ c\ld be m s9c]e1 to s]ve ! ,*ur*1 to place its claims on adequate gr\nds1 to elevate ! /&>d ( duty 9 its cl]gy1 & 9 all its memb]s4 ,to h miss$ ! aim ( ! movem5t & to h be5 occupi$ & irritat$ by obnoxi\s details & vulg> suspicions 0 a blund] :i* gave ! measure ( ^? :o made x1 & l$ to great evils4 ,!y ali5at$ ^? :o wi%$ = no?+ bett] ?an to help !m 9 _! true "w4 ,_! unk9dness 0 felt to be1 9 ,bacon's phrase1#gg injuriae pot5tiorum4 ,b on ! side ( ! p>ty ( ! movem5t !re 7 mi/akes also4 #a4 ,! rapidity ) :i* ! movem5t _h gr[n1 %[+ t "s deep ne$ _h long be5 obscurely felt1 :i* ! movem5t promis$ to meet1#gh _h be5 too great to be altoge!r :olesome4 ,:5 we comp>e :at 0 commonly receiv$ be=e #ahcc1 9 tea*+1 9 habits ( life1 9 ! ord9>y assumptions ( hi/ory1 9 ! ideas & modes ( wor%ip1 public & private--! almo/ sacram5tal conception ( prea*+1 ! neglect ( ! common pray] ( ! ,pray] ,book1 ! slight reg>d to ! sacram5ts--) :at ! tea*+ ( ! ,tracts & _! writ]s _h impress$ = good & all1 five ye>s lat]1 on numb]s ( e>ne/ p1 ! *ange seems a/oni%+4 ,! *ange 0 a b5eficial "o & x 0 a p]man5t "o4 ,! m9ds :i* x affect$1 x affect$ pr(\ndly4 ,/ill x 0 b a %ort "t1 = "y m9ds especially1 to h come to a decision on great & debat$ que/ions4 ,!re 0 ! possibility1 ! dang]1 ( m5 hav+ be5 captivat$ & c>ri$ away by ! excitem5t & int]e/ ( ! "t2 ( n hav+ look$ all r\nd & ?\ght out ! difficulties be=e !m2 ( hav+ embrac$ op9ions )\t suffici5tly kn[+ _! gr\nds or c\nt+ ! co/ or consid]+ ! consequ5ces4 ,!re 0 ! dang] ( precipitate judgm5t1 ( ill-balanc$ & disproportionate views ( :at 0 true & all-important4 ,!re 0 an inevitable fev]i%ness 9 ! way 9 :i* ! movem5t 0 begun1 9 ! way 9 :i* x w5t on4 ,^? affect$ by x 7 !mselves surpris$ at ! swiftness ( ! pace4 ,:5 a cause s great & s sacr$ seem$ ?us to be fl\ri%+1 & c>ry+ along ) x m5's ass5t & sympa?ies1 x 0 h>dly wond]ful t !re %\ld (t5 be exagg]ation1 impati5ce at resi/ance1 scant consid]ation = ! sl[ness or ! scruples or ! al>ms ( o!rs4 ,eag] & sangu9e m5 talk$ z if _! "w 0 accompli%$1 :5 9 tru? x 0 b beg9n+4 ,no "o gave m s]i\s w>n+s aga9/ ?is & o!r dang]s ?an ! lead]s2 & _! w>n+s 7 ne$$4#gi #b4 ,ano!r mi/ake1 ak9 to ! la/1 0 ! frequ5t =getfulness ( ! apo/olic maxim1 ,all ?+s are lawful = me1 b all ?+s are n exp$i5t4 ,9 :at almo/ am\nt$ to a revolution 9 _m ( ! religi\s ideas ( ! "t1 x 0 especially important to keep di/9ct ! great c5tral tru?s1 ! re/oration ( :i* to _! prop] place ju/ifi$ & made x necess>y1 & ! _m subord9ate po9ts alli$ ) !m & naturally foll[+ f !m1 :i* yet 7 n necess>y to _! e/abli%m5t or acceptance4 ,b x 0 on ^! subord9ate po9ts t ! int]e/ ( a c]ta9 numb] ( foll[]s ( ! movem5t 0 fa/5$4 ,conclusions :i* !y _h a p]fect "r to come to1 practices innoc5t & edify+ to !mselves1 b ( second>y acc\nt1 began to be ?ru/ =w>d into prom95ce1 :e!r or n ^! in/ances ( self-w really help$ ! common cause1 :e!r or n !y gave a h&le to ill-nature & ill-w4 ,suspicion mu/ always h atta*$ to su* a movem5t z ?is2 b a great deal ( x 0 provok$ by indiscreet defiance1 :i* 0 r glad to provoke x4 #c4 ,ap>t f ^! incid5ts--common :]ev] a numb] ( m5 are animat$ ) zeal = an inspir+ cause--!re 7 :at to u n[ seem mi/akes made 9 ! conduct itself ( ! movem5t4 ,consid]+ ! difficulties ( ! "w1 x is wond]ful t !re 7 n m2 & none ( !m 7 discr$itable1 none b :at arose f ! limitation ( human p[]s mat*$ aga9/ confus$ & baffl+ circum/ances4 ,9 ! position claim$ = ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 confess$ly unique & anomal\s 9 ! hi/ory ( ,*ri/5dom1 betwe5 ,roman au?ority & infallibility on "o side1 & ,prote/ant fre$om ( private judgm5t on ! o!r1 ! "q w\ld at once arise z to ! gr\nds ( belief4 ,:at1 if any1 are ! f\ndations ( conviction & c]titude1 ap>t f p]sonal inquiry1 & exam9ation ( oppos+ argum5ts on diff]5t sides ( ! case1 & satisfactory logical conclusions8 ,! old anti!sis betwe5 ,fai? & ,reason1 & ! v>i\s problems connect$ ) x1 c\ld n b come to ! front1 & require to be dealt )4 ,x is a "q :i* faces u f a hundr$ sides1 &1 subtly & ins5sibly trans=m+ itself1 looks diff]5t f !m all4 ,x 0 among ! e>lie/ attempt$ to be solv$ by ! *ief intellectual lead] ( ! movem5t1 & x has occupi$ 8 m9d to ! la/4#hj ,h[ev] ne> ! human m9d seems to come to a solution1 x only1 if s be1 comes ne>2 x nev] arrives4 ,9 ! e>ly days ( ! movem5t x f\nd prevail+ ! speci\s b %all[ view t ev]y?+ 9 ! se>* = tru? 0 to be done by m]e producible & explicit argum5tation2 & yet x 0 obvi\s t ( ?is two-?irds ( ! _w are absolutely incapable4 ,aga9/ ?is ,mr4 ,newman & 8 foll[]s press$1 :at 0 z manife/ly c]ta9 9 fact z x accord$ ) any deep & compreh5sive philosophy ( ! =mation & gr[? ( human belief1 t n argum5ts only1 b ! :ole condition ( ! m9d to :i* !y 7 address$--& n ! reason+s only :i* c\ld be /at$1 b ^? :i* w5t on d>kly 9 ! m9d1 & :i* !re 0 n at ! mom5t /r5g? to br+ =?1 real & weighty reasons :i* act$ l ! obscure rays ( ! spectrum1 ) _! prop] =ce1 yet elud+ di/9ct obs]vation--_h _! necess>y & inevitable & legitimate place 9 det]m9+ belief4 ,all ?is 0 p]fectly true2 b x is obvi\s h[ easily x might be tak5 hold (1 on v opposite sides1 z a gr\nd = say+ t ,tract>ian or ,*ur* views did n c>e ab\t argum5t1 or1 inde$1 r pref]r$ weak argum5ts to /rong ones 9 ! practical "w ( life4 ,x 0 ludicr\s to say x 9 a field ( controv]sy1 :i*1 on ! ,tract>ian side1 0 absolutely bri/l+ ) argum5t1 ke51 subtle1 deep1 liv+ argum5t1 & 9 :i* ! victory 9 argum5t 0 c]ta9ly n always ) ^? :o v5tur$ to measure swords ) ,mr4 ,newman or ,dr4 ,pusey4 ,/ill1 ! sc(f c\ld be plausibly po9t$ at ! "y en?usia/s :o cr[d$ ! ,via ,m$ia1 & :o nev] presum$ to argue1 except aga9/ ! propriety ( argu+ at all4 ,!re 0 a good deal ( fooli% sne]+ at reason2 !re 0 a good deal ( silly bravado ab\t n c>+ :e!r ! av[$ gr\nds ( op9ions tak5 up 7 /rong or feeble4 ,x 0 n m]ely ! ass5t ( a le>n] to 8 tea*]1 ( a m9d )\t means ( in/ruction to ! belief :i* x has inh]it$1 or ( "o new to ! ways & conditions ( life to ! unprov$ ass]tions & op9ions ( "o to :om exp]i5ce _h giv5 an op5 & sure eye4 ,x 0 a positive c>elessness1 almo/ acc\nt$ m]itori\s1 to inquire & ?9k1 :5 _! lead]s call$ !m to d s4 ,! ,gospel ( ,*ri/ is n a matt] ( m]e argum5t4 ,x is n1 inde$1 :5 x comes 9 its full reality1 9 half a hundr$ diff]5t ways1 kn[n & unse>*able1 felt & unfelt1 moral & intellectual1 on ! awak5$ & quick5$ s\l4 ,b ! wilde/ fanatic c take ! same words into 8 m\?4 ,_! true mean+ 0 v>i\sly & abundantly illu/rat$1 especially 9 ,mr4 ,newman's s]mons4 ,/ill1 ! adequate1 ! emphatic w>n+ aga9/ _! e>ly abuse 0 h>dly press$ on ! public op9ion & s5tim5t ( ! p>ty ( ! movem5t ) ! =ce :i* really 0 requisite4 ,to ! end !re 7 m5 :o took up _! belief av[$ly on insuffici5t & prec>i\s gr\nds1 glory+ 9 ! v5turesom5ess ( _! fai? & c\rage1 & ju/ify+ _! temp] ( m9d & _! intellectual attitude by alleg+ mis9t]pret$ language ( _! wis] & deep] tea*]s4 ,a recoil f ,:ately's h>d & b>r5 dialectics1 a sympa?y ) _m t5d] & ref9$ natures :i* ! movem5t _h t\*$1 made ! lead]s pati5t ) intellectual feebl5ess :5 x 0 jo9$ ) real goodness & ,*ri/ian temp]2 b ?is also sometimes made !m less impati5t ?an !y might well h be5 ) t curi\s =m ( conceit & affectation :i* veils itself "u an int5d$ & suppos$ humility1 a suppos$ di/ru/ ( self & its own p[]s4 ,ano!r difficult matt]1 n altoge!r successfully manag$--at lea/ f ! orig9al po9t ( view ( ! movem5t1 & ( ^? :o saw 9 x a great ef=t = ! good ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*--0 ! treatm5t ( ! ,roman controv]sy4 ,! g5]al l9e :i* ! lead]s propos$ to take 0 ! "o :i* 0 wor?y ( ,*ri/ian & tru?-lov+ tea*]s4 ,!y took a new dep>ture2 & x 0 n less j ?an x 0 brave1 :51 recognis+ to ! full ! ov]:elm+ reasons :y we %\ld n be ,romani/s1 !y refus$ to take up ! popul> & easy me?od ( reg>d+ ! ,roman ,*ur* z apo/ate & anti*ri/ian2 & decl9$ to commit !mselves to ! vulg> & indiscrim9ate abuse ( x :i* 0 ! discr$itable legacy ( ! old days ( controv]sy4 ,!y did :at all ! _w 0 l\dly pr(ess+ to d1 !y look$ facts 9 ! face2 !y f\nd1 z any "o w\ld f9d :o look$ = himself into ! realities ( ! ,roman ,*ur*1 t ?\gh ! bad 0 (t5 z bad z c\ld be1 !re 0 /ill1 & !re _h be5 all along1 goodness ( ! highe/ type1 excell5ce bo? ( sy/em & ( p]sonal life :i* x 0 mon/r\s to d5y1 & :i* we might well admire & envy4 ,to ignore all ?is 0 to fail 9 ! fir/ duty1 n m]ely ( ,*ri/ians1 b ( hone/ m52 & we at home 7 n s blameless t we c\ld safely take ?is l(ty tone ( contemptu\s sup]iority4 ,if ,rome w\ld only leave u alone1 !re w\ld be e/rangem5t1 lam5table en\gh among ,*ri/ians1 b !re ne$ be no bitt]ness4 ,b ,rome w\ld n leave u alone4 ,! mom5t t !re 7 signs ( awak5+ en]gy 9 ,engl&1 t mom5t 0 *os5 by its ag5ts1 = n[ x c\ld be done safely1 to assail & ?w>t ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,d\btless !y 7 )9 _! rights1 b ?is made controv]sy inevitable1 & = controv]sy ! lead]s ( ! movem5t prep>$ !mselves4 ,x 0 an ob/acle :i* !y seem$ h>dly to h expect$1 b :i* ! nature ( ?+s plac$ 9 _! way4 ,b ! old /yle ( controv]sy 0 impossible2 impossible because x 0 s co>se1 impossible because x 0 s holl[4 ,if ! argum5t 7says ! writ] ( ,tract #ga1 9 words :i* are applicable to e controv]sy7 is radically unreal1 or 7:at may be call$7 rhetorical or sophi/ical1 x may s]ve ! purpose ( enc\rag+ ^? :o are really conv9c$1 ?\gh sc>cely )\t do+ mis*ief to !m1 b c]ta9ly x w (f5d & ali5ate ! m acute & s5sible2 :ile ^? :o are 9 d\bt1 & :o desire "s real & sub/antial gr\nd = _! fai?1 w n be> to be put (f ) su* %ad[s4 ,! argum5ts 7he cont9ues7 :i* we use mu/ be su* z are likely to conv9ce s]i\s & e>ne/ m9ds1 :i* are really seek+ = ! tru?1 n amus+ !mselves ) intellectual combats1 or desir+ to support an exi/+ op9ion anyh[4 ,h[ev] popul> ^! latt] me?ods may be1 ( h[ev] long /&+1 h[ev] easy bo? to f9d & to use1 !y are a sc&al2 & :ile !y l[] our religi\s /&>d f ! fir/1 !y are sure ( hurt+ our cause 9 ! end4 ,& on ?is pr9ciple ! l9e ( argum5t 9 ,! ,prophetical ,(fice ( ! ,*ur* 0 tak5 by ,mr4 ,newman4 ,x 0 c]ta9ly no make-believe1 or unreal argum5t4 ,x 0 a =cible & orig9al way ( putt+ "p ( ! case aga9/ ,rome4 ,x 0 "p ( ! case1 a v important "p2 b x 0 n ! :ole case1 & x ought to h be5 evid5t f ! fir/ t 9 ?is controv]sy we c\ld n af=d to d )\t ! :ole case4 ,! argum5t f ! claim ( infallibility said no?+ ( :at are equally real p>ts ( ! case--! practical work+ ( ! ,roman ,*ur*1 its sy/em ( gov]nm5t1 ! "p :i* x & its rul]s h play$ 9 ! hi/ory ( ! _w4 ,rome has n su* a clean record ( hi/ory1 x has n su* a clean acc\nt ( :at is done & p]mitt$ 9 its dom9ions "u an au?ority suppos$ to be irresi/ible1 t x c claim to be ! "o pure & p]fect ,*ur*1 entitl$ to judge & correct & gov]n all o!r ,*ur*es4 ,& if ! claim is made1 !re is no help = x1 we mu/ n %r9k f ! task ( giv+ ! answ]4#ha ,&1 z exp]i5ce has %[n1 ! m t rigid good fai? is kept to 9 giv+ ! answ]1 ! m t /rictness & sev]ity ( ev5 und]/atem5t are obs]v$1 ! m conv9c+ w be ! result t ! ,roman ,*ur* _c be t :i* x is alleg$ to be 9 its necess>y !ory & ideal4 ,b ?is task 0 nev] adequately und]tak54 ,x 0 "o ( no easy execution4#hb ,o!r ?+s1 app>5tly m imm$iately press+1 int]v5$4 ,!re 0 no "q = ! pres5t ( p]fect & unfeign$ confid5ce 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ) :atev] regrets = its %ortcom+s1 & desires = its improvem5t ,b to ! outside _w x seem$ z if !re 7 a reluctance to face s]i\sly ! :ole ( ! ,roman controv]sy2 a disposition to be indulg5t to ,roman defects1 & unfairly h>d on ,engli% faults4 ,h[ mis*iev\sly ?is told 9 ! c\rse ( op9ion outside & inside ( ! movem5t2 h[ x 0 mis9t]pret$ & misrepres5t$2 h[ ^! mis9t]pretations & misrepres5tations1 ) ! bitt]ness & inju/ice :i* !y eng5d]$1 help$ to realise !mselves1 0 se5 b too cle>ly at a lat] /age4 #d4 ,la/ly1 look+ back on ! publications1 reg>d$ z *>act]i/ic ( ! p>ty1 x is difficult n to feel t "s ( !m gave an un=tunate & unnecess>y turn to ?+s4 ,! book :i* made mo/ /ir & caus$ ! greate/ outcry 0 ,fr\de's ,rema9s4 ,x 0 und\bt$ly a bold exp]im5t2 b x 0 n m]ely boldness4 ,except t x might be p]v]t$ into an excuse by ! %all[ & ?\ghtless = m]ely /rong talk1 x may fairly be said t x 0 "r & wise to let ! _w "k ! full measure & dep? ( conviction :i* gave bir? to ! movem5t2 & ,fr\de's ,rema9s did t 9 an unsuspici\sly g5u9e way t no?+ else c\ld h done4 ,&1 besides1 x 0 wor? :ile = its own sake to exhibit ) fe>less hone/y su* a "*1 s high1 s true1 s ref9$1 s h]oic4 ,s aga91 ,dr4 ,pusey's ,tract on ,baptism 0 a bold book1 & "o :i* br\ght heavy imputations & miscon/ructions on ! p>ty4 ,9 ! tea*+ ( 8 long life1 ,dr4 ,pusey has abundantly dispell$ ! *>ges ( h>%ness & ov]-sev]ity :i* 7 urg$1 n always v scrupul\sly1 aga9/ ! doctr9e ( ! ,tract on ,po/-baptismal ,s94 ,b x 0 writt5 to r$ress ! balance aga9/ ! fatally easy doctr9es !n 9 fa%ion2 x 0 l ! ,portroyali/ prote/ aga9/ ! fa%ionable ,jesuits2 x 0 "o-sid$1 & sometimes1 9 8 e>ne/ness1 ungu>d$2 & x want$ z yet ! complem5t ( enc\ragem5t1 consolation1 & t5d]ness :i* 8 future tea*+ 0 to supply s amply4 ,b x 0 a bl[ /ruck1 n be=e x 0 necess>y1 by a /rong h&2 & x may safely be said t x settl$ ! place ( ! sacram5t ( baptism 9 ! liv+ sy/em ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 :i* ! negations & vagu5ess ( ! ,evangelical p>ty _h gravely endang]$4 ,b two o!r essays appe>$ 9 ! ,tracts1 mo/ innoc5t 9 !mselves1 :i* t5 or tw5ty ye>s lat] w\ld h be5 judg$ simply on _! m]its1 b :i* at ! "t became pot5t weapons aga9/ ,tract>ianism4 ,!y 7 ! productions ( two poets--( two ( ! mo/ beautiful & religi\s m9ds ( _! "t2 b 9 t /age ( ! movem5t x is h>dly too mu* to say t !y 7 out ( place4 ,! cause ( ! movem5t ne$$ cle> explanations2 def9ite /atem5ts ( doctr9es :i* 7 popul>ly misund]/ood2 pla91 conv9c+ reason+ on ! issues :i* 7 rais$ by x2 a c>eful lay+ out ( ! gr\nd on :i* ,engli% !ology 0 to be /r5g!n$ & enri*$4 ,su* 7 ,mr4 ,newman's ,lectures on ,ju/ification1 a "w :i* made its la/+ m>k on ,engli% !ological ?\ght2 ,mr4 ,keble's ma/]ly exposition ( ! mean+ ( ,tradition2 & n lea/1 ! important collections :i* 7 docum5t>y & hi/orical evid5ce ( ! "* ( ,engli% !ology1 ! s-call$ labori\s ,cat5as4 ,^! 7 ! real tasks ( ! h\r1 & !y ne$$ all t lab\r & indu/ry c\ld give4 ,b ! fir/ ( ^! inopportune ,tracts 0 an elaborate essay1 by ,mr4 ,keble1 on ! ,my/icism ( ! ,fa!rs 9 ! use & int]pretation ( ,scripture4 ,x 0 h>dly :at ! practical ne$s ( ! "t requir$1 & x took away m5's ?\ghts f !m2 ! prospect 0 hopeless t 9 t /ate ( m5's m9ds x %\ld be und]/ood1 except by a v few2 x m]ely help$ to add ano!r *>ge1 ! vague b mis*iev\s *>ge ( my/icism1 to ! li/ ( accusations aga9/ ! ,tracts4 ,! o!r1 to ! a/oni%m5t ( e "o1 0 l ! explosion ( a m9e4 ,t x %\ld be criticis$ & object$ to 0 natural2 b ! extraord9>y irritation caus$ by x c\ld h>dly h be5 anticipat$4 ,writt5 9 ! mo/ dev\t & rev]5t _s by "o ( ! g5tle/ & mo/ ref9$ ( s*ol>s1 & full ( deep ,scriptural k1 x furni%$ = "s ye>s ! mat]ial = ! mo/ savage attacks & ! bitt]e/ sne]s to ! oppon5ts ( ! movem5t4 ,x 0 call$ ,on ,res]ve 9 communicat+ ,religi\s ,k2 & x 0 a prote/ aga9/ ! co>s5ess & %all[ness :i* ?rew ! mo/ sacr$ words ab\t at r&om 9 l\d & declamatory appeals1 & :i* especially dragg$ 9 ! awful my/]y ( ! ,atonem5t1 "u ! crude/ & mo/ vulg> conception ( x1 z a ready topic ( excitem5t 9 o!rwise commonplace & helpless prea*+4 ,! ^w ,res]ve 0 en\gh4 ,x meant t ! ,tract-writ]s av[$ ! pr9ciple ( keep+ back "p ( ! c\nsel ( ,god4 ,x meant1 fur!r1 t ! real _s ( ! p>ty 0 disclos$2 its love ( secret & crook$ me?ods1 its indiff]5ce to k1 its dis+5u\s pr(essions1 its delib]ate concealm5ts1 its hold+ doctr9es & its pursuit ( aims :i* x d>$ n av[1 its discipl9a arcani1 its conspiracies1 its ,jesuitical _s4 ,all ?is k9d ( abuse 0 flung pl5tifully on ! p>ty z ! controv]sy became w>m2 & x ma9ly ju/ifi$ itself by ! ,tract on ,res]ve4 ,! ,tract 0 9 _m ways a beautiful & sugge/ive essay1 full ( deep & orig9al ?\ghts1 ?\gh compos$ 9 t _s ( ! recluse :i* 0 *>act]i/ic ( ! writ]1 & :i* is 9 /rong contra/ ) ! en]getic temp] ( to-day4#hc ,b x c\ld well h be5 sp>$ at ! mom5t1 & x c]ta9ly (f]$ itself to an un=tunate use4 ,! suspici\sness :i* s innoc5tly x help$ to awak5 & confirm 0 nev] aga9 allay$4 ,,footnotes3 #gd ,fifty ye>s ago !re 0 mu* great] contra/ ?an n[ betwe5 old & "y4 ,!re 0 m outw>d respect = ! au?orities1 & among ! y\ng] m51 graduates & und]graduates1 m inw>d amusem5t at foibles & ecc5tricities4 ,!re /ill l+]$ ! survivals ( a m old-fa%ion$ type ( ,univ]sity life & "*1 :i*1 q ap>t f ! movem5ts ( religi\s op9ion1 provok$ ^? 1#ge imp]t95ces ( irresponsible juniors t[>ds sup]iors1 :i* ,wordswor?1 speak+ ( a yet e>li] "t1 rememb]$ at ,cambridge-- ,9 s]i\s mood1 b (t5]1 ,i confess1 ,) playful ze/ ( fancy1 did we note 7,h[ c\ld we less87 ! mann]s & ! ways ,( ^? :o liv$ di/+ui%$ by ! badge ,( good or ill report2 or ^? ) :om ,by frame ( ,academic discipl9e ,we 7 p]=ce connect$1 m5 ^: sway ,& kn[n au?ority ( (fice s]v$ ,to set our m9ds on edge1 & did no m4 ,nor want$ we ri* pa/ime ( ?is k9d1 ,f\nd ev]y:]e1 b *iefly 9 ! r+ ,( ! grave ,eld]s1 m5 unsecur$1 grotesque ,9 "*1 trick$ out l ag$ trees ,:i* ?r\gh ! lapse ( _! infirmity ,give ready place to any r&om se$ ,t *ooses to be re>$ ^u _! trunks4 ,prelude1 bk4 iii4 #ge ,plat4 ,r4,p4 iii4 #cij4 #gf ,tracts = ! ,times1 ,no4 #a1 #i? ,septemb] #ahcc4 #gg ,an ,adv]tisem5t t\*+ ! ,controv]sies ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&3 pr9t$ 9 ! ,resuscitatio1 p4 #ach 7ed4 #afga74 #gh ,see ,mr4 ,newman's article1 ,! ,/ate ( ,religi\s ,p>ties1 9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 ,april #ahci1 repr9t$ 9 8 ,essays ,hi/orical & ,critical1 #ahga1 ,vol4 #a41 essay vi4 #gi ,x w\ld n be at all surpris+1 ?\gh1 9 spite ( ! e>ne/ness ( ! pr9cipal advocates ( ! views 9 "q1 = :i* e "o seems to give !m cr$it1 !re %\ld be among _! foll[]s mu* t is en?usia/ic1 extravagant1 or excessive4 ,all ^! ab]rations w be & are imput$ to ! doctr9es f :i* !y proce$2 nor unnaturally1 b h>dly fairly1 = ab]rations !re mu/ be1 :atev] ! doctr9e is1 :ile ! human he>t is s5sitive1 caprici\s1 & wayw>d4444 ,!re w ev] be a numb] ( p]sons pr(ess+ ! op9ions ( a movem5t p>ty1 :o talk l\dly & /rangely1 d odd & fi]ce ?+s1 display !mselves unnecess>ily1 & disgu/ o!r p2 !re w ev] be ^? :o are too "y to be wise1 too g5]\s to be cauti\s1 too w>m to be sob]1 or too intellectual to be humble2 ( :om human sagacity _c det]m9e1 only ! ev5t1 & p]haps n ev5 t1 :e!r !y feel :at !y say1 or h[ f>2 :e!r !y are to be enc\rag$ or disc\nt5anc$4--,briti% ,critic1 ,april #ahci1 ,/ate ( ,religi\s ,p>ties1 p4 #dje4 #hj ,c>d9al ,newman1 ,gramm> ( ,ass5t4 #ha ,! argum5t f hi/ory is sket*$ fairly1 b only sket*$ 9 ,! ,prophetic ,(fice1 ,lect4 xiv4 #hb ,9 ! ,roman controv]sy x is sometimes h>d to be j )\t appe>+ to mean m ?an is said2 = ! obligation ( ju/ice sometimes =ces "o :o wi%es to be a fair judge to be app>5tly an apologi/ or advocate4 ,yet ! supreme duty 9 religi\s controv]sy is ju/ice4 ,b = ! v reason t ^! controv]siali/s wi%$ to be j to ,rome1 !y 7 b\nd to be j aga9/ h]4 ,!y meant to be s2 b ev5ts pass$ quickly1 & leisure nev] came = a "w :i* involv$ a s]i\s appeal to hi/ory4 #hc ,vide a /rik+ review 9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 ,april #ahci1 p>tly correct+ & gu>d+ ! view giv5 9 ! ,tract4 ,,*apt] ,,xiv ,,no4 #ij ,! =mation ( a /rong ,romanis+ section 9 ! ,tract>ian p>ty 0 obvi\sly damag+ to ! p>ty & dang]\s to ! ,*ur*4 ,x 0 pro tanto a v]ification ( ! fundam5tal *>ge aga9/ ! p>ty1 a *>ge :i* on pap] !y _h met successfully1 b :i* acquir$ d\ble =ce :5 ?is pap] def5ce 0 trav]s$ by facts4 ,& a great bl[ 0 imp5d+ ov] ! ,*ur*1 if ! zeal & ability :i* ! movem5t _h call$ =? & animat$ 7 to be suck$ away f ! ,*ur*1 & n only lo/ to x1 b educat$ into a special in/rum5t aga9/ x4 ,b ! div]g5ce became cle> only gradually1 & ! hope t aft] all x 0 only tempor>y & w\ld ultimately disappe> 0 long kept up by ! t5acity ) :i* ,mr4 ,newman1 9 spite ( misgiv+s & di/urb+ ?\ghts1 /ill recognis$ ! gifts & claims ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,& on ! o!r h&1 ! bulk ( ! p>ty1 & its o!r ,ox=d lead]s1 ,dr4 ,pusey1 ,mr4 ,keble1 ,mr4 ,isaac ,williams1 ,mr4 ,m>riott1 7 q unaffect$ by ! disquiet+ appreh5sions :i* 7 beg9n+ to beset ,mr4 ,newman4 ,) a humbl+ consci\sness ( ! practical %ortcom+s ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ) a ready disposition to be hone/ & j t[>ds ,rome1 & ev5 to m9imise our diff]5ces ) x1 !y _h n admitt$ = a mom5t any d\bt ( ! reality ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,! class ( argum5ts :i* specially laid hold ( ,mr4 ,newman's m9d did n tell ^u !m--! peculi> aspect ( e>ly prec$5ts1 ab\t :i*1 moreov]1 a good deal ( criticism 0 possible2 or ! l>ge & sweep+ conception ( a va/1 ev]-gr[+1 imp]ial ,*ur*1 great en\gh to make flaws & imp]fections ( no acc\nt1 :i* appeal$ s /rongly to 8 /atesmanlike imag9ation4 ,_! cont5t ) ! ,*ur* 9 :i* !y _h be5 br\ght up1 9 :i* !y _h be5 taught religion1 & 9 :i* !y _h tak5 s]vice1 _! deep & affectionate loyalty & piety to x1 9 spite ( all its faults1 rema9$ unimpair$2 & unimpair$1 also1 0 _! s5se ( va/ masses ( practical evil 9 ! ,roman ,*ur*1 evils f :i* !y %rank bo? z ,engli%m5 & z ,*ri/ians1 & :i* seem$ z incurable z !y 7 und5iable4 ,beyond ! hope :i* !y vaguely *]i%$ t "s day or o!r1 by "s great act ( ,div9e m]cy1 ^! evils might disappe>1 & ! :ole ,*ur* become once m unit$1 !re 0 no?+ to draw !m t[>ds ,rome2 submission 0 out ( ! "q1 & !y c\ld only see 9 its attitude 9 ,engl& ! ho/ility ( a jeal\s & unscrupul\s di/urb] ( _! ,ma/]'s "w4 ,! movem5t /ill w5t on1 ) its orig9al purpose1 & on its orig9al l9es1 9 spite ( ! pres5ce 9 x1 & ev5 ! co-op]ation1 ( m5 :o might "o day h o!r views1 & s]i\s & fatal diff]5ces ) _! old fri5ds4 ,! *ange ( religion :5 x comes on a man gradually1--:5 x is n welcom$ f ! fir/1 b1 on ! contr>y1 long resi/$1 mu/ always be a my/]i\s & p]plex+ process1 h>d to realise & foll[ by ! p]son mo/ deeply int]e/$1 veil$ & cl\d$ to look]s-on1 because naturally belong+ to ! deepe/ dep?s ( ! human consci5ce1 & inevitably1 & )\t mu* fault on ei!r side1 liable to be mis9t]pret$ & misund]/ood4 ,& ?is process is all ! m tangl$ :5 x goes on1 n 9 an individual m9d1 travell+ 9 its own way on its own pa?1 little affect$ by o!rs1 & little affect+ !m1 b 9 a repres5tative p]son1 ) ! responsibilities ( a great cause ^u him1 b\nd by close/ ties ( e k9d to fri5ds1 colleagues1 & disciples1 ?9k+1 feel+1 lead+1 po9t+ out ! way = hundr$s :o love & dep5d on him4 ,views & feel+s v>y f day to day1 accord+ to ! ev5ts & conditions ( ! day4 ,h[ %all he speak1 & h[ %all he be sil5t8 ,h[ %all he let d\bts & difficulties appe>1 yet h[ %all he suppress !m8--d\bts :i* may gr[ & become hopeless1 b :i*1 on ! o!r h&1 may be solv$ & disappe>4 ,h[ %all he g on z if no?+ _h happ5$1 :5 all ! f\ndations ( ! _w seem to h sunk f "u him8 ,yet h[ %all he disclose ! dreadful secret1 :5 he is n yet q sure :e!r 8 m9d w n /ill rally f its t]ror & despair8 ,he mu/ 9 hone/y1 9 k9dness1 give "s w>n+1 yet h[ mu*8 & h[ to prev5t x be+ tak5 = m ?an x means8 ,!re are c\nt]-consid]ations1 to :i* he _c %ut 8 eyes4 ,!re are fri5ds :o w n believe 8 w>n+s4 ,!re are wat*ful enemies :o are on ! look-out = pro(s ( dis+5u\sness & bad fai?4 ,he c\ld cut ?r\gh 8 difficulties at once by mak+ ! plunge 9 ob$i5ce to ?is or t plausible sign or tra9 ( reason+1 b 8 consci5ce & good fai? w n let him take ?+s s easily2 & yet he kn[s t if he hangs on1 he w be accus$ by & by1 p]haps speci\sly1 ( hav+ be5 di%one/ & deceiv+4 ,s subtle1 s %ift+1 s impalpable are ! /eps by :i* a fai? is dis9tegrat$2 s evanesc5t1 & impossible to foll[1 ! %ades by :i* "o set ( convictions pass into o!rs :olly opposite2 = x is n k & intellect alone :i* come into play1 b all ! moral ta/es & habits ( ! "*1 its lik+s & dislik+s1 its weakness & its /r5g?1 its triumphs & its vexations1 its ke5ness & its ins5sibilities1 :i* are 9 full action1 :ile ! intellect alone seems to be busy ) its problems4 ,a picture has be5 giv5 u1 belong+ to ?is "t1 ( ! process1 by a great ma/] ( human nature1 & a great suff]] "u ! process2 x is1 p]haps1 ! greate/ attempt ev] made to describe x2 b x is n :olly successful4 ,x tells u mu*1 = x is writt5 ) t\*+ good fai?1 b ! complete effect z an intelligible :ole is want+4 ,9 ! spr+ ( #ahci1 we read 9 ! ,apologia1 my position 9 ! ,anglican ,*ur* 0 at its height4 ,i _h a supreme confid5ce 9 my controv]sial /atus1 & ,i _h a great & /ill gr[+ success 9 recomm5d+ x to o!rs4#hd ,?is1 !n1 may be tak5 z ! po9t f :i*1 9 ! writ]'s own e/imate1 ! *ange is to be trac$4 ,he ref]s = illu/ration ( 8 /ate ( m9d to ! rem>kable article on ! ,/ate ( ,religi\s ,p>ties1 9 ! ,april numb] ( ! ,briti% ,critic = #ahci1 :i* he has s9ce republi%$ "u ! title ( ,prospects ( ! ,anglican ,*ur*4#he ,i h look$ ov] x n[1 he writes 9 #ahfd1 = ! fir/ "t s9ce x 0 publi%$2 & h be5 /ruck by x = ?is reason3 x conta9s ! la/ words :i* ,i ev] spoke z an ,anglican to ,anglicans4444 ,x may n[ be read z my p>t+ address & val$iction1 made to my fri5ds4 ,i little knew x at ! "t4 ,he ?us describes ! position :i* he took 9 ! article ref]r$ to3-- ,consci\s z ,i 0 t my op9ions 9 religi\s matt]s 7 n ga9$1 z ! _w said1 f ,roman s\rces1 b 71 on ! contr>y1 ! bir? ( my own m9d & ( ! circum/ances 9 :i* ,i _h be5 plac$1 ,i _h a scorn ( ! imputations :i* 7 heap$ ^u me4 ,x 0 true t ,i held a l>ge1 bold sy/em ( religion1 v unlike ! ,prote/antism ( ! day1 b x 0 ! conc5tration & adju/m5t ( ! /atem5ts ( great ,anglican au?orities1 & ,i _h z mu* "r to d s z ! ,evangelical p>ty _h1 & m "r ?an ! ,lib]al1 to hold _! own respective doctr9es4 ,z ,i spoke on occasion ( ,tract #ij1 ,i claim$1 on behalf ( ! writ]1 t he might hold 9 ! ,anglican ,*ur* a comprecation ( ! ,sa9ts ) ,bramhall2 & ! ,mass1 all b ,transub/antiation1 ) ,&rewes2 or ) ,hook] t ,transub/antiation itself is n a po9t = ,*ur*es to "p communion ^u2 or ) ,hammond t a ,g5]al ,c\ncil1 truly su*1 nev] did1 nev] %all err 9 a matt] ( fai?2 or ) ,bull t man lo/ inw>d grace by ! ,fall2 or ) ,?orndike t p5ance is a propitiation = po/-baptismal s92 or ) ,pe>son t ! all-p[]ful "n ( ,jesus is no o!rwise giv5 ?an 9 ! ,ca?olic ,*ur*4 ,two c play at t game 0 (t5 9 my m\?1 :5 m5 ( ,prote/ant s5tim5ts appeal$ to ! ,articles1 ,homilies1 & ,re=m]s1 9 ! s5se t if !y _h a "r to speak l\d ,i _h bo? ! lib]ty & ! means ( giv+ !m tit = tat4 ,i ?\ght t ! ,anglican ,*ur* _h be5 tyrannis$ ov] by a ,p>ty1 & ,i aim$ at br++ into effect ! promise conta9$ 9 ! motto to ! ,lyra3 ,!y %all "k ! diff]5ce n[4 ,i only ask$ to be all[$ to %[ !m ! diff]5ce4 ,i h said already 7he goes on7 t ?\gh ! object ( ! movem5t 0 to )/& ! ,lib]alism ( ! day1 ,i f\nd & felt t ?is c\ld n be done by negatives4 ,x 0 necess>y = me to h a positive ,*ur* !ory erect$ on a def9ite basis4 ,?is took me to ! great ,anglican div9es2 & !n1 ( c\rse1 ,i f\nd at once t x 0 impossible to =m any su* !ory )\t cutt+ across ! tea*+ ( ! ,*ur* ( ,rome4 ,?us came 9 ! ,roman controv]sy4 ,:5 ,i fir/ turn$ myself to x ,i _h nei!r d\bt on ! subject1 nor suspicion t d\bt w\ld ev] come on me4 ,x 0 9 ?is /ate ( m9d t ,i began to read up ,bell>m9e on ! "o h&1 & numb]less ,anglican writ]s on ! o!r4#hf ,& he quotes f ! article ! language :i* he us$1 to %[ ! necessity ( provid+ "s cle> & /rong basis = religi\s ?\ght 9 view ( ! imp5d+ conflict ( pr9ciples1 religi\s & anti-religi\s1 ,ca?olic & ,rationali/1 :i* to f>-see+ m51 ev5 at t comp>atively e>ly "t1 seem$ inevitable3-- ,!n inde$ w be ! /]n enc\nt]1 :5 two real & liv+ pr9ciples1 simple1 entire1 & consi/5t1 "o 9 ! ,*ur*1 ! o!r out ( x1 at l5g? ru% ^u ea* o!r1 cont5d+ n = names & words1 a half view1 b = elem5t>y notions & di/9ctive moral *>act]s4 ,m5 w n keep /&+ 9 t v attitude :i* y call s\nd ,*ur*-(-,engl&ism or or?odox ,prote/antism4 ,!y w take "o view or ano!r1 b x w be a consi/5t "o 444 x w be real4444 ,is x s5sible1 sob]1 judici\s1 to be s v angry ) ! writ]s ( ! day :o po9t to ! fact1 t our div9es ( ! sev5te5? c5tury h occupi$ a gr\nd :i* is ! true & intelligible mean betwe5 extremes8444 ,w\ld y r h y\r sons & y\r daught]s memb]s ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& or ( ! ,*ur* ( ,rome8#hg ,! la/ words t ,i spoke z an ,anglican to ,anglicans1--s he describes ?is /atem5t ( 8 position & its reasons2 s x seems to him1 z he looks back4 ,& yet 9 ! intimate & frank disclosures :i* he makes1 he has %[n u mu* t indicates bo? t 8 ,anglicanism la/$ mu* long] & t 8 ,roman sympa?ies began to /ir mu* e>li]4 ,?is only %[s ! enorm\s difficulties ( measur+ accurately ! /eps ( a transition /ate4 ,! m9d1 9 su* a /ra9 ( buffet+1 is nev] 9 "o /ay4 ,! old seems impregnable1 yet x has be5 und]m9$2 ! new is indignantly & hone/ly repell$1 & yet leaves beh9d x its nev]-to-be-=gott5 & unacc\ntable spell4 ,! /ory1 z he tells x1 goes on1 h[1 9 ! full sw+ & confid5ce ( 8 ,anglicanism1 & 9 ! c\rse ( 8 secure & fe>less /udy ( antiquity1 appe>ance aft] appe>ance pres5t$ itself1 unexpect$1 ?reat5+1 ob/9ate1 9 ! hi/ory ( ! ,e>ly ,*ur*1 by :i* ?is confid5ce 0 fir/ %ak5 & !n utt]ly brok5 d[n 9 ! summ] ( #ahci4 ,& he speaks z ?\gh all _h be5 ov] aft] two ye>s f t summ]3 ,f ! end ( #ahda ,i 0 on my dea?-b$1 z reg>ds my memb]%ip ) ! ,anglican ,*ur*1 ?\gh at ! "t ,i became aw>e ( x only by degrees4 ,9 tru?1 x 0 only ! end :i* %[$ t x 0 a dea?-b$4 ,he _h n yet di$ to allegiance or to hope1 !n or = "s "t aft]w>ds4 ,he speaks 9 lat] ye>s ( ! result1 & reads :at 0 !n 9 ! light ( :at foll[$4 ,b aft] all t _h happ5$1 & mu*1 ( c\rse1 di/urb+ happ5$ 9 #ahda1 he 0 a long way (f f :at !n c\ld h be5 spok5 ( z a dea?-b$4 ,deep & pa9ful misgiv+s may assail ! s9c]e/ fai?2 !y are n fatal signs till fai? has f9ally giv5 way4 ,:at is true is1 t ! :ole /ate ( religion1 & ! :ole aspect ( ,*ri/ianity 9 ! _w1 _h come to seem to him port5t\sly /range & anomal\s4 ,no !ory w\ld take 9 & suit all ! facts1 :i* ! c]ta9ties ( hi/ory & exp]i5ce pres5t$4 ,nei!r 9 ,engl&1 nor 9 ,rome1 & mu* less any:]e else1 did ! old1 to :i* all appeal$1 agree ) ! new2 x might agree v>i\sly 9 ?is po9t or 9 t1 9 o!rs !re 7 contr>ieties :i* x 0 va9 to reconcile4 ,facts 7 aga9/ ! ,engli% claim to be a ,ca?olic ,*ur*--h[ c\ld ,ca?olicity be %ut up 9 "o isl&8 ,h[ c\ld ,engl& ass]t its cont9uity ( doctr9e8 ,facts 7 aga9/ ! ,roman claim to be an infallible1 & a p]fect1 & ! :ole ,*ur*--h[ c\ld t be p]fect :i* 0 m>k$ 9 ! face ( day ) enorm\s & und5iable corruptions8 ,h[ c\ld t be infallible :i* 0 irreconcilable ) anci5t tea*+8 ,h[ c\ld t be ! :ole ,*ur*1 :i*1 to say no?+ ( ! break-up 9 ! ,we/1 ignor$1 z if x _h no exi/5ce1 ! anci5t & un9t]rupt$ ,ea/]n ,*ur*8 ,!ory aft] !ory came up1 & 0 tri$1 & 0 f\nd want+4 ,ea* _h mu* to say = itself1 its /rong po9ts1 its sup]iority ov] its rivals 9 deal+ ) ! difficulties ( ! case1 its plausibilities & its imag9ative attractions4 ,b all _h _! t5d] spot1 & fl9*$ :5 !y 7 t\*$ 9 e>ne/4 ,9 ! confusions & s9s & divisions ( ! la/ fifte5 c5turies1 pr(\nd disorganisation _h fa/5$ on ! ,we/]n ,*ur*4 ,*ri/5dom 0 n1 c\ld n be pret5d$ to be1 :at x _h be5 9 ! f\r? c5tury2 & :i*ev] way m5 look$ ! reasons 7 n h>d to see4 ,! fir/ & *>act]i/ic feel+ ( ! movem5t1 "o :i* ,mr4 ,newman _h done s mu* to deep51 0 t ( %ame & humiliation at ! disord] at home1 z well z 9 e "p ( ! ,*ur*4 ,x 0 n 9 ,rome only1 or 9 ,engl& only2 x 0 ev]y:]e4 ,:at _h be5 peculi> to ,anglicanism among all its rivals1 0 t x _h emphatically & )\t res]ve confess$ x4 ,) ?is view ( ! dislocation & ! s9s ( ! ,*ur*1 he c\ld at once ) p]fect consi/5cy recognise ! %ortcom+s ( ! ,engli% bran* ( ! ,*ur*1 & yet believe & ma9ta9 t x 0 a true & liv+ bran*4 ,! ,engli% fragm5t 0 n :at x %\ld be1 0 inde$ mu* t x %\ld n be2 ! same c\ld be said ( ! ,roman1 ?\gh 9 diff]5t respects4 ,?is1 z he himself rem9ds u1 0 no new ?+ to 8 m9d :5 ! unsettlem5t ( #ahci began4 ,at ! end ( #ahce1 or ! beg9n+ ( #ahcf1 ,i _h ! :ole /ate ( ! "q be=e me1 on :i*1 to my m9d1 ! decision betwe5 ! ,*ur*es dep5d$4 ,x did n1 he says1 dep5d on ! claims ( ! ,pope1 z c5tre ( unity2 x turn$ on ! ,fai? ( ! ,*ur*2 !re 0 a contr>iety ( claims betwe5 ! ,roman & ,anglican religions2 & up to #ahci1 ) ! full weight ( ,roman argum5ts recognis$1 ) ! full consci\sness ( ,anglican disadvantages1 he yet spoke cle>ly = ,anglicanism4 ,ev5 :5 misgiv+s became s]i\s1 ! balance /ill incl9$ )\t "q ! old way4 ,he h>dly spoke /rong] 9 #ahcd ?an he did 9 #ahda1 aft] ,no4 #ij4 ,& n[ 7he writes 9 8 ,lett] to ! ,bi%op ( ,ox=d#hh7 hav+ said1 ,i tru/1 z mu* z y\r ,lord%ip requires on ! subject ( ,romanism1 ,i w add a few words1 to complete my explanation1 9 ackn[l$gm5t ( ! ine/imable privilege ,i feel 9 be+ a memb] ( t ,*ur* ov] :i* y\r ,lord%ip1 ) o!rs1 presides4 ,inde$1 did ,i n feel x to be a privilege :i* ,i am able to seek n[h]e else on e>?1 :y %\ld ,i be at ?is mom5t writ+ to y\r ,lord%ip8 ,:at motive h ,i = an unres]v$ & joyful submission to y\r au?ority1 b ! feel+ t ! ,*ur* 9 :i* y\r ,lord%ip rules is a div9ely-orda9$ *annel ( sup]natural grace to ! s\ls ( h] memb]s8 ,:y %\ld ,i n pref] my own op9ion1 & my own way ( act+1 to t ( ! ,bi%op's1 except t ,i "k full well t 9 matt]s indiff]5t ,i %\ld be act+ lightly t[>ds ! ,sp\se ( ,*ri/ & ! awful ,pres5ce :i* dwells 9 h]1 if ,i hesitat$ a mom5t to put y\r ,lord%ip's w be=e my own8 ,i "k full well t y\r ,lord%ip's k9dness to me p]sonally w\ld be 9 itself q en\gh to w9 any b ! mo/ ins5sible he>t1 &1 did a cle> matt] ( consci5ce occur 9 :i* ,i felt b\nd to act = myself1 my feel+s t[>ds y\r ,lord%ip w\ld be a mo/ sev]e trial to me1 indep5d5tly ( ! high] consid]ations to :i* ,i h allud$2 b ,i tru/ ,i h %[n my dutifulness to y prior to ! influ5ce ( p]sonal motives2 & ?is ,i h done because ,i ?9k t to belong to ! ,ca?olic ,*ur* is ! fir/ ( all privileges "h bel[1 z involv+ 9 x heav5ly privileges1 & because ,i consid] ! ,*ur* ov] :i* y\r ,lord%ip presides to be ! ,ca?olic ,*ur* 9 ?is c\ntry4 ,surely !n ,i h no ne$ to pr(ess 9 words1 ,i w n say my atta*m5t1 b my deep rev]5ce t[>ds ! ,"m ( ,sa9ts1 :5 ,i am %[+ x 9 action2 yet t words may n be altoge!r want+1 ,i beg to lay be=e y\r ,lord%ip ! foll[+ extract f a def5ce ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 :i* ,i wrote aga9/ a ,roman controv]siali/ 9 ! c\rse ( ! la/ ye>4 ,! ,*ur* is emphatically a liv+ body1 & !re c be no great] pro( ( a p>ticul> communion be+ "p ( ! ,*ur* ?an ! appe>ance 9 x ( a cont9u$ & abid+ en]gy1 nor a m melan*oly pro( ( its be+ a corpse ?an torpidity4 ,we say an en]gy cont9u$ & abid+1 = accid5t w cause ! activity ( a mom5t1 & an ext]nal pr9ciple give ! semblance ( self-motion4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ev5 a liv+ body may = a :ile be asleep4 99 99 99 99 99 ,x conc]ns1 !n1 ^? :o d5y t we are ! true ,*ur* because we h n at pres5t ?is special note1 int]communion ) o!r ,*ri/ians1 to %[ cause :y ! ,roman ,*ur* 9 ! t5? c5tury %\ld be s acc\nt$1 ) pr(ligates1 or r ! pr(ligate mo!rs ( pr(ligate sons = h] supreme rul]s4 ,& /ill not)/&+ life is a note ( ! ,*ur*2 %e alone revives1 ev5 if %e decl9es2 h]etical & s*ismatical bodies _c keep life2 !y gradually became cold1 /iff1 & ins5sible4 99 99 99 99 99 ,n[ if !re ev] 7 a ,*ur* on :om ! exp]im5t has be5 tri$1 :e!r x _h life 9 x or n1 ! ,engli% is t "o4 ,= ?ree c5turies x has endur$ all vicissitudes ( =tune4 ,x has endur$ 9 tr\ble & prosp]ity1 "u s$uction1 & "u oppression4 ,x has be5 practis$ ^u by !ori/s1 br[beat5 by sophi/s1 intimidat$ by pr9ces1 betray$ by false sons1 laid wa/e by tyranny1 corrupt$ by weal?1 torn by s*ism1 & p]secut$ by fanaticism4 ,revolutions h come ^u x %>ply & sudd5ly1 to & fro1 hot & cold1 z if to try :at x 0 made (4 ,x has be5 a sort ( battlefield on :i* opposite pr9ciples h be5 tri$4 ,no op9ion1 h[ev] extreme any way1 b may be f\nd1 z ! ,romani/s are n sl[ to reproa* u1 among its ,bi%ops & ,div9es4 ,yet :at has be5 its c>e] ^u ! :ole8 ,:i* way has x be5 mov+ ?r\gh #cjj ye>s8 ,:]e does x f9d itself at ! end8 ,lu!rans h t5d$ to ,rationalism2 ,calv9i/s h become ,soc9ians2 b :at has x become8 ,z f> z its ,=mul>ies are conc]n$1 x may be said all along to h gr[n t[>ds a m p]fect ,ca?olicism ?an t ) :i* x />t$ at ! "t ( its e/rangem5t2 e act1 e crisis :i* m>ks its c\rse1 has be5 upw>d4 99 99 99 99 99 ,:at a note ( ! ,*ur* is ! m]e production ( a man l ,butl]1 a pregnant fact mu* to be m$itat$ on6 & h[ /range x is1 if x be z x seems to be1 t ! real influ5ce ( 8 "w is only j n[ beg9n+6 & :o c prophesy 9 :at x w end8 ,?us our ,div9es gr[ ) c5turies1 exp&+ aft] _! dea? 9 ! m9ds ( _! read]s into m & m exact ,ca?olicism z ye>s roll on4 99 99 99 99 99 ,look across ! ,atlantic to ! daught] ,*ur*es ( ,engl& 9 ! ,/ates3 ',%all "o t is b>r5 be> a *ild 9 h] old age8' yet '! b>r5 ha? borne sev54' ,s*ismatic bran*es put out _! leaves at once1 9 an expir+ ef=t2 our ,*ur* has wait$ ?ree c5turies1 & !n blossoms l ,a>on's rod1 budd+ & bloom+ & yield+ fruit1 :ile ! re/ are dry4 ,& la/ly1 look at ! pres5t position ( ! ,*ur* at home2 !re1 too1 we %all f9d a note ( ! true ,city ( ,god1 ! ,holy ,j]usalem4 ,%e is 9 w>f>e ) ! _w1 z ! ,*ur* ,militant %\ld be2 %e is rebuk+ ! _w1 %e is hat$1 %e is pillag$ by ! _w4 99 99 99 99 99 ,mu* might be said on ?is subject4 ,at all times1 s9ce ,*ri/ianity came into ! _w1 an op5 conte/ has be5 go+ on betwe5 religion & irreligion2 & ! true ,*ur*1 ( c\rse1 has ev] be5 on ! religi\s side4 ,?is1 !n1 is a sure te/ 9 e age :]e ! ,*ri/ian %\ld /&4444 ,n[1 apply+ ?is simple crit]ion to ! public ,p>ties ( ?is ,,day1 x is v pla9 t ! ,engli% ,*ur* is at pres5t on ,god's side1 & !re=e1 s f>1 ,god's ,*ur*2 we are sorry to be oblig$ to add t !re is z little d\bt on :i* side ,engli% ,romanism is4 99 99 99 99 99 ,z = ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 surely %e has notes en\gh1 '! signs ( an ,apo/le 9 all pati5ce1 & signs & wond]s & mighty de$s4' ,%e has ! note ( possession1 ! note ( fre$om f p>ty-titles2 ! note ( life1 a t\gh life & a vigor\s2 %e has anci5t desc5t1 unbrok5 cont9uance1 agreem5t 9 doctr9e ) ! anci5t ,*ur*4 ,^? ( ,bell>m9e's ,notes1 :i* %e c]ta9ly has n1 are int]communion ) ,*ri/5dom1 ! glory ( miracles1 & ! prophetical light1 b ! "q is1 :e!r %e has n en\gh ( ,div9ity ab\t h] to satisfy h] si/] ,*ur*es on _! own pr9ciples1 t %e is "o body ) !m4 ,?is may be suffici5t to %[ my feel+s t[>ds my ,*ur*1 z f> z ,/atem5ts on pap] c %[ !m4 ,h[ e>ne/ly1 h[ s9c]ely he clung to ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ev5 aft] he describes himself on 8 dea?-b$1 no "o c d\bt4 ,! *>m ( ! ,apologia is ! p]fect c&\r ) :i* he records fluctuations :i* to _m are inconceivable & un9telligible1 ! diff]5t & sometimes opposite & irreconcilable /ates ( m9d ?r\gh :i* he pass$1 ) no attempt to make "o fit into ano!r4 ,x is cle>1 f :at he tells u1 t 8 words 9 #ahci 7 n 8 la/ words z an ,anglican to ,anglicans4 ,) :atev] tr\bles ( m9d1 he /rove to be a loyal & fai?ful ,anglican long aft] t4 ,he spoke z an ,anglican4 ,he f\ght = ,anglicanism4 ,! !ory1 z he says1 may h gone by ! bo>d1 9 ! intellectual /orms rais$ by ! hi/ories ( ! ,monophysites & ,donati/s4 ,by ^! great words ( ! anci5t fa!r--,securus judicat orbis t]r>um--! !ory ( ! ,via ,m$ia 0 absolutely pulv]is$4 ,he 0 sore1 z he says 9 #ahdj1 ab\t ! great ,anglican div9es1 z if !y _h tak5 me 91 & made me say /rong ?+s aga9/ ,rome1 :i* facts did n ju/ify4#hi ,yes1 he felt1 z o!r m5 d n feel1 ! weak po9ts ( ev5 a /rong argum5t1 ! exagg]ations & unfairness ( controv]siali/s on 8 own side1 ! consci\sness t y _c h ?+s 9 fact1 or 9 !ory1 or 9 reason+1 smoo?ly & exactly z x w\ld be conv5i5t1 & z y w\ld l to h !m4 ,b 8 conclusion1 on ! :ole1 0 un%ak54 ,!re 0 en\gh1 & amply en\gh1 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur* to b9d him to its allegiance1 to satisfy him ( its tru? & its life1 en\gh 9 ! ,roman to w>n him away4 ,9 ! confusions ( ,*ri/5dom1 9 ! /rong & ob/9ate diff]5ces ( s*ools & p>ties 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 he1 liv+ 9 days ( inquiry & criticism1 claim$ to take & recomm5d a !ological position on _m controv]t$ que/ions1 :i* _m might ?9k a new "o1 & :i* might n be exactly t occupi$ by any exi/+ s*ool or p>ty4#ij ,we are all1 he writes to an intimate fri5d on #bb;d ,april #ahdb1 a ye> aft] ,no4 #ij1 mu* quiet] & m resign$ ?an we 71 & are rem>kably desir\s ( build+ up a position1 & prov+ t ! ,engli% !ory is t5able1 or r ! ,engli% /ate ( ?+s4 ,if ! ,bi%ops w\ld leave u alone1 ! fev] w\ld subside4 ,he want$1 :5 all o!r p>ties 7 claim+ room = _! speculations1 to claim room = 8 own pref]5ce = anci5t doctr9e4 ,he wi%$ to make out t no bran* ( ! ,*ur* _h au?oritatively committ$ itself to language :i* 0 hopelessly & fatally irreconcilable ) ,*ri/ian tru?4 ,b he claim$ no?+ b :at he c\ld ma9ta9 to be fairly )9 ! au?oris$ =mul>ies ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,he c\rt$ inquiry1 he c\rt$ argum5t4 ,if 8 claim seem$ a new "o1 if 8 av[$ lean+ to anci5t & ,ca?olic views seem$ to make him m tol]ant ?an _h be5 cu/om>y1 n to ,roman abuses1 b to ,roman au?oritative language1 x 0 "p ( ! m accurate & ! m temp]ate & *>itable ?\ght ( our day comp>$ ) pa/ times4 ,x 0 "p ( ! same *ange :i* has br\ght ,*ur* op9ions f ! unmitigat$ ,calv9ism ( ! ,lambe? ,articles to :at ! au?orities ( ^? days w\ld h d5\nc$1 )\t a d\bt1 z ,arm9ianism4 ,hook] 0 gravely & s]i\sly accus$ to ! ,c\ncil = say+ t a ,papi/ c\ld be sav$1 & _h "s difficulty to cle> himself2 x 0 z natural !n z x is amaz+ n[4#ia ,b ) ?is s9c]e loyalty to ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 z he believ$ x to be1 !re 01 no d\bt1 9 ! backgr\nd ! haunt+ & disquiet+ misgiv+ t ! attempt to connect m closely ! mod]n ,*ur* ) ! anci5t1 & ?is wid5$ !ology 9 a direction :i* _h be5 hi!rto specially & jeal\sly b>r$1 0 putt+ ! ,engli% ,*ur* on its trial4 ,w\ld x be> x8 ,w\ld x respond to ! call to rise to a high] & wid] type ( doctr9e1 to a high] /&>d ( life8 ,w\ld x ju/ify :at ,mr4 ,newman _h plac$ 9 ! =efront among ! notes ( ! true ,*ur*1 ! note ( ,sanctity8 ,w\ld ! ,via ,m$ia make up = its incomplet5ess z a !ory by develop+ into reality & fruitfulness ( actual results8 ,w\ld ! ,*ur* be> to be told ( its defaults8 ,w\ld x all[ to ! ma9ta9]s ( ,ca?olic & ,anglican pr9ciples ! lib]ty :i* o!rs claim$1 & :i* by l>ge & p[]ful bodies ( op9ion 0 d5i$ to ,anglicans8 ,or w\ld x turn out on trial1 t ! ,via ,m$ia 0 an idea )\t sub/ance1 a dialectical fiction1 a m]e !ological exp$i5t = gett+ out ( difficulties1 unrecognis$1 & :5 put =w>d1 dis[n$8 ,w\ld x turn out t ! l9e ( ?\ght & tea*+ :i* connect$ ! mod]n ) ! anci5t ,*ur* 0 b ! private & accid5tal op9ion ( ,hook] & ,&rewes & ,bull & ,wilson1 unau?oris$ 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 uncong5ial to its _s1 if n contradictory to its =mul>ies8 ,x is only j to ,mr4 ,newman to say1 t ev5 aft] "s ( 8 fri5ds 7 fright5$1 he long cont9u$ to hope = ! be/2 b und\bt$ly1 m & m1 8 belief 9 ! reality ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 und]go+ a v sev]e1 & z "t w5t on1 disc\rag+ te/+4 ,9 ?is /ate ( ?+s he publi%$ ! ,tract ,no4 #ij4 ,x 0 occasion$ by ! common allegation1 on ! side ( "s ( ! advanc$ section ( ! ,tract>ians1 z well z on ! side ( _! oppon5ts1 t ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles 7 hopelessly irreconcilable ) t ,ca?olic tea*+ :i* ,mr4 ,newman _h def5d$ on ! au?ority ( our great div9es1 b :i* bo? ! p>ties above m5tion$ 7 ready to id5tify ) ! tea*+ ( ! ,roman ,*ur*4 ,! ,tract 0 int5d$1 by a rigor\s exam9ation ( ! language ( ! ,articles1 to trav]se ?is allegation4 ,x s\ght to %[ t all t 0 cle>ly & und\bt$ly ,ca?olic1 ?is language left unt\*$3#ib t x 0 d\btful :e!r ev5 ! =mal def9itions ( ! ,c\ncil ( ,tr5t 7 directly & int5tionally contradict$2 & t :at 7 really aim$ at 7 ! abuses & p]v]sions ( a great popul> & au?oris$ sy/em1 tyrannical by ! =ce ( cu/om & ! ob/9ate refusal ( any real re=mation4 ,x is (t5 urg$ 7says ! writ]71 & sometimes felt & grant$1 t !re are 9 ! ,articles propositions or t]ms inconsi/5t ) ! ,ca?olic fai?2 or1 at lea/1 if p]sons d n g s f> z to feel ! objection z ( =ce1 !y are p]plex$ h[ be/ to answ] x1 or h[ mo/ simply to expla9 ! passages on :i* x is made to re/4 ,! foll[+ ,tract is drawn up ) ! view ( %[+ h[ gr\ndless ! objection is1 & fur!r1 ( approximat+ t[>ds ! argum5tative answ] to x1 ( :i* mo/ m5 h an implicit appreh5sion1 ?\gh !y may h no?+ m4 ,t !re are real difficulties to a ,ca?olic ,*ri/ian 9 ! ecclesia/ical position ( our ,*ur* at ?is day1 no "o c d5y2 b ! /atem5ts ( ! ,articles are n 9 ! numb]1 & x may be "r at ! pres5t mom5t to insi/ ^u ?is4 ,:5 met by ! objection t ! ideas ( ! fram]s ( ! ,articles 7 well kn[n1 & t x 0 notori\s t !y _h meant to put an insup]able b>ri] betwe5 ! ,engli% ,*ur* & ev]y?+ t sav\r$ ( ,rome1 ! writ] repli$ t ! actual ,engli% ,*ur* receiv$ ! ,articles n f !m b f a mu* lat] au?ority1 t we are b\nd by _! words n by _! private s5tim5ts ei!r z !ologians or ecclesia/ical politicians1 & t 9 fact !y _h int5d$ ! ,articles to compreh5d a great body ( _! c\ntrym51 :o w\ld h be5 driv5 away by any extreme & anti-,ca?olic decl>ations ev5 aga9/ ,rome4 ,! temp] ( compromise is *>act]i/ic ( ! ,engli% z contra/$ ) ! =eign ,re=mation4 ,x is visible1 n only 9 ! ,articles1 b 9 ! polity ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 :i* clung s ob/9ately to ! cont9uity & =ms ( ! anci5t hi]>*ical sy/em1 x is visible 9 ! sacram5tal (fices ( ! ,pray] ,book1 :i* left s mu* out to satisfy ! ,prote/ants1 & left s mu* 9 to satisfy ! ,ca?olics4 ,! ,tract w5t 9 detail ?r\gh ! ,articles :i* 7 commonly look$ ^u z ei!r anti-,ca?olic or anti-,roman4 ,x w5t ?r\gh !m ) a dry logical way ( int]pretation1 su* z a pr(ess$ !ologian might use1 :o 0 accu/om$ to all ! niceties ( language & ! di/9ctions ( ! sci5ce4 ,x 0 ! way 9 :i* !y w\ld be likely to be exam9$ & con/ru$ by a purely legal c\rt4 ,! effect ( x1 d\btless1 0 l t produc$ on ord9>y m9ds by ! ref9em5ts ( a subtle advocate1 or by ! judicial int]pretation ( an ,act ( ,p>liam5t :i* ! judges d n l2 & "s ( ! int]pretations und\bt$ly seem$ f>-fet*$ & artificial4 ,yet "s ( ^? :i* 7 po9t$ to at ! "t z flagrant in/ances ( extravagant mis9t]pretation h n[ come to look diff]5t4 ,no?+ c\ld exce$ ! scorn p\r$ on ! int]pretation ( ! ,tw5ty-second ,article1 t x condemns ! ,roman doctr9e ( ,purgatory1 b n all doctr9e ( purgatory z a place ( gradual purification beyond dea?4 ,b 9 our days a s*ool v f> remov$ f ,mr4 ,newman's w\ld require & w\ld claim to make ! same di/9ction4 ,& s ) ! int]pretation ( ! ,sacrifices ( ,masses 9 ! same article4 ,x 0 ! fa%ion 9 #ahda to see 9 ?is ! condemnation ( all doctr9e ( a sacrifice 9 ! ,eu*>i/2 & :5 ,mr4 ,newman conf9$ ! phrase to ! gross abuses connect$ ) ! ,mass1 ?is 0 treat$ z an affront to common s5se & hone/y4 ,s9ce !n we h become bett] acqua9t$ ) ! language ( ! anci5t liturgies--1 & no in/ruct$ !ologian c\ld n[ v5ture to treat ,mr4 ,newman's di/9ction z idle4 ,!re 0 9 fact no?+ new 9 8 di/9ctions on ^! two po9ts4 ,!y _h already be5 made 9 two ( ! prec$+ ,tracts1 ! repr9t ( ,ar*bi%op ,us%] on ,pray]s = ! ,dead1 & ! ,cat5a on ! ,eu*>i/ie ,sacrifice2 & 9 bo? cases ! di/9ctions 7 support$ by a great mass ( ,anglican au?ority4#ic ,b ! ,tract _h suffici5t novelty ab\t x to acc\nt = mo/ ( ! excitem5t :i* x caus$4 ,its dryness & negative curtness 7 provok+4 ,x 0 n a positive argum5t1 x 0 n an appeal to au?orities2 x 0 a p>+ d[n ( language1 alleg$ 9 c]ta9 portions ( ! ,articles to be some:at loose1 to its b>e/ mean+2 & to ^? to :om t language _h always seem$ to speak ) fulness & decision1 x seem$ l sapp+ & und]m9+ a *]i%$ bulw>k4 ,!n x seem$ to ask = m lib]ty ?an ! writ] 9 8 position at t "t ne$$2 & ! object ( su* an indef9ite claim1 9 ord] to remove1 if possible1 misund]/&+s betwe5 two long-ali5at$ bran*es ( ! ,we/]n ,*ur*1 0 "o to excite 9 _m m9ds pr(\nd horror & dismay4 ,t x ma9ta9$ )\t fl9*+ & z /rongly z ev] ! position & ! claim ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 no?+ to ! purpose2 ! admission1 bo? t ,rome1 ?\gh wrong1 might n be z wrong z we ?\ght h]1 & t ! language ( ! ,articles1 ?\gh unque/ionably condemnatory ( mu*1 0 n condemnatory ( z mu* z p ?\ght1 & might possibly be ev5 h>monis$ ) ,roman au?oritative language1 0 look$ ^u z incompatible ) loyalty to ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,! "q :i* ! ,tract _h op5$1 :at ! ,articles meant & to :at m5 7 b\nd by accept+ !m1 0 a mo/ legitimate "o = discussion2 & x 0 mo/ natural also t any "o %\ld hesitate to answ] x z ! ,tract answ]$ x4 ,b x 0 di/9ctly a "q = discussion4 ,x 0 n s easy = any ( ! p>ties 9 ! ,*ur* to give a cle> & consi/5t answ]1 z t ! matt] ought at once to h be5 c>ri$ out ( ! region ( discussion4 ,! ,articles 7 ! ,articles ( a ,*ur* :i* _h se5 z great diff]5ces z ^? betwe5 ! ,*ur* ( ,edw>d ,,vi & ! ,*ur* ( ! ,re/oration4 ,take !m broadly z ! condemnation--/rong b loose 9 expression1 z1 = in/ance1 9 ! language on ! five1 commonly call$ ,sacram5ts--( a p[]ful & well-kn[n antagoni/ sy/em1 & !re 0 no difficulty ab\t !m4 ,b take !m z sci5tific & accurate & precise enunciations ( a sy/ematic !ology1 & difficulties beg9 at once1 ) e "o :o does n hold ! special & well-m>k$ doctr9es ( ! age :5 ! ,g]man & ,swiss au?orities rul$ supreme4 ,! c\rse ( ev5ts f t day to ?is has %[n m ?an once1 9 surpris+ & ev5 />tl+ examples1 h[ mu* ^? :o at ! "t lea/ ?\ght t !y ne$$ su* /rict con/ru+ ( ! language ( ! ,articles1 & 7 fi]ce 9 d5\nc+ ! k9d ( int]pretation said to be claim$ 9 ,no4 #ij1 h s9ce f\nd t !y require a good deal m ela/icity ( read+ ?an ev5 x ask$ =4 ,! :irligig ( "t 0 ?\ght to h br\ght its rev5ges1 :5 ,mr4 ,newman1 :o _h call$ = ! ex]cise ( au?ority aga9/ ,dr4 ,hampd51 f\nd himself1 five ye>s aft]w>ds1 "u ! ban ( ! same au?ority4 ,! diff]5ce betwe5 ,mr4 ,newman's case & ,dr4 ,hampd5's1 bo? z to ! alleg$ (f5ce & ! position ( ! m51 0 consid]able4 ,b ! :irligig ( "t br\ght ab\t ev5 /rang] rev5ges1 :5 n only ,mr4 ,gorham & ,mr4 ,h4,b4 ,wilson 9 _! own def5ce1 b ! tribunals :i* _h to decide on _! cases1 c>ri$ ! /rictness ( read+ & ! latitude ( int]pretation1 q z f>1 to say ! lea/1 z any?+ 9 ,no4 #ij4 ,unhappily ,tract #ij 0 met at ,ox=d1 n ) argum5t1 b ) panic & wra?4#id ,!re is always a /+ 9 e *>ge1 to :i* o!r p>ts ( x seem subord9ate4 ,no4 #ij 0 *>g$ ( c\rse ) false doctr9e1 ) false hi/ory1 & ) false reason+2 b ! emphatic "p ( ! *>ge1 ! %ort & easy me?od :i* disp5s$ f ! necessity ( !ological exam9ation & argum5t1 0 t x 0 di%one/ & immoral4 ,pr(essors ( ,div9ity1 & accompli%$ s*ol>s1 su* z !re 7 9 ,ox=d1 might v well h consid]$ x an occasion to dispute bo? ! g5]al pr9ciple ( ! ,tract1 if x 0 s dang]\s1 & ! illu/rations1 9 ! abundance ( :i* ! writ] _h s frankly ?r[n op5 8 position to se>*+ criticism4 ,x 0 a crisis 9 :i* mu* might h be5 usefully said1 if !re _h be5 any "o to say x2 mu* too1 to make any "o feel1 if he 0 compet5t to feel1 t he _h a good deal to ?9k ab\t 9 8 own position1 & t x w\ld be well to asc]ta9 :at 0 t5able & :at unt5able 9 x4 ,b x seem$ z if ! opportunity mu/ n be lo/ = /rik+ a bl[4 ,! ,tract 0 publi%$ on #bg? ,febru>y4 ,on ! #h? ( ,m>* f\r ,s5ior ,tutors1 "o ( :om 0 ,mr4 ,h4,b4 ,wilson1 ( ,/4 ,john's1 & ano!r ,mr4 ,tait1 ( ,balliol1 address$ ! ,editor ( ! ,tract1 *>g+ ,no4 #ij ) sugge/+ & op5+ a way1 by :i* m5 might1 at lea/ 9 ! case ( ,roman views1 violate _! solemn engagem5ts to _! ,univ]sity4 ,on ! #ae? ( ,m>*1 ! ,bo>d ( ,heads ( ,h\ses1 refus+ to wait = ,mr4 ,newman's def5ce1 :i* 0 kn[n to be com+1 & :i* be>s date #ac? ,m>*1 publi%$ _! judgm5t ,!y decl>$ t 9 ,no4 #ij modes ( int]pretation 7 sugge/$1 & h s9ce be5 advocat$ 9 o!r publications purport+ to be writt5 by memb]s ( ! ,univ]sity1 by :i* subscription to ! ,articles might be reconcil$ ) ! adoption ( ,roman ,ca?olic error4 ,& !y ann\nc$ _! resolution1 ,t modes ( int]pretation1 su* z are sugge/$ 9 ! said ,tract1 evad+ r ?an expla9+ ! s5se ( ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles1 & reconcil+ subscription to !m ) ! adoption ( errors :i* !y are design$ to c\nt]act1 defeat ! object1 & are inconsi/5t ) ! due obs]vance ( ! above-m5tion$ /atutes4#ie ,x 0 an ung5]\s & /upid blund]1 su* z m5 make1 :5 !y ?9k or are told t some?+ mu/ be done1 & d n "k :at4 ,x gave ! writ] an opportunity1 ( :i* he took full advantage1 ( %[+ 8 sup]iority 9 temp]1 9 c\rtesy1 & 9 reason1 to ^? :o _h n s mu* condemn$ z insult$ him4 ,he 0 imm$iately ready ) 8 p]sonal expression ( apology & regret1 & also ) 8 reass]tion 9 m develop$ argum5t ( ! pr9ciple ( ! ,tract2 & ?is 0 foll[$ up by fur!r explanations 9 a lett] to ! ,bi%op4 ,& 9 spite ( ! invidi\s position 9 :i* ! ,bo>d _h tri$ to place him1 n m]ely z an uns\nd div9e1 b z a di%one/ man tea*+ o!rs to palt] ) _! engagem5ts1 ! crisis drew =? /rong support & sympa?y :]e !y 7 n p]haps to be expect$4 ,x ralli$ to him1 at lea/ = ! "t1 "s ( ! fri5ds :o _h begun to hold alo(4 ,mr4 ,palm]1 ( ,worce/]1 ,mr4 ,p]ceval1 ,dr4 ,hook1 ) res]ves accord+ to ea* man's po9t ( view1 yet came =w>d 9 8 def5ce4 ,! ,bo>d 0 made to feel t !y _h be5 driv5 by viol5t & p>tisan in/igations to commit !mselves to a v fooli% z well z a v passionate & impot5t /ep2 t !y _h by v que/ionable au?ority simply ?r[n an ill-s\nd+ & ill-mann]$ ^w at an argum5t on a v difficult "q1 to :i* !y !mselves c]ta9ly 7 n prep>$ ) a cle> & satisfactory answ]2 t !y _h made ! d\ble mi/ake ( decl>+ w> aga9/ a =midable antagoni/1 & ( beg9n+ x by creat+ ! impression t !y _h treat$ him %abbily1 & 7 really afraid to come to close qu>t]s ) him4 ,z ! excitem5t ( ha/y c\nsels subsid$1 ! s5se ( ?is began to awake 9 "s ( !m2 !y tri$ to repres5t ! (f-h& & ambigu\s words ( ! condemnation z n mean+ all t !y _h be5 tak5 to mean4 ,b ! se$ ( bitt]ness _h be5 s[n4 ,v little light 0 ?r[n1 9 ! /rife ( pamphlets :i* ensu$1 on ! ma9 subject dealt ) 9 ,no4 #ij1 ! au?ority & int]pretation ( su* =mul>ies z our ,articles4 ,! easi] & m tempt+ & v f]tile topic ( debate 0 ! hone/y & good fai? ( ! v>i\s disputants4 ,( ! f\r ,tutors1 only "o1 ,mr4 ,h4,b4 ,wilson1 publi%$ an explanation ( _! "p 9 ! matt]2 x 0 a clumsy1 ill-writt5 & lab\r$ pamphlet1 :i* h>dly gave promise ( ! intellectual vig\r subsequ5tly display$ by ,mr4 ,wilson1 :5 he appe>$1 n z ! def5d]1 b ! assailant ( receiv$ op9ions4 ,! m di/+ui%$ ( ! combatants 7 ,mr4 ,w>d & ,mr4 ,r4 ,l[e4 ,mr4 ,w>d1 ) 8 usual dialectical skill1 n only def5d$ ! ,tract1 b pu%$ its argum5t yet fur!r1 9 claim+ tol]ance = doctr9es alleg$ to be ,roman4 ,mr4 ,l[e1 n tr\bl+ himself ei!r ) !ological hi/ory or ! relation ( o!r p>ties 9 ! ,*ur* to ! =mul>ies1 ?rew 8 /r5g? into ! popul> & plausible topic ( di%one/y1 & into a bitt] & unqualifi$ invective aga9/ ! bad fai? & immorality manife/$ 9 ! tea*+ ( :i* ,no4 #ij 0 ! outcome4 ,dr4 ,faussett1 z 0 to be expect$1 ?rew himself into ! fray ) 8 accu/om$ ze/ & viol5ce1 & caus$ "s amusem5t at ,ox=d1 fir/ by expos+ himself to ! m]ciless wit ( a review] 9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 & !n by ! fright into :i* he 0 ?r[n by a rum\r t 8 reelection to 8 pr(essor%ip w\ld be endang]$ by ,tract>ian votes4#if ,b ! /orm1 at ,ox=d at lea/1 seem$ to die out4 ,! difficulty :i* at "o mom5t ?reat5$ ( a /rike among "s ( ! college ,tutors pass$2 & ?+s w5t back to _! ord9>y c\rse4 ,b an epo* & a new po9t ( dep>ture _h come into ! movem5t4 ,?+s aft] ,no4 #ij 7 nev] ! same z to language & hopes & prospects z !y _h be5 be=e2 x 0 ! date f :i* a new set ( conditions 9 m5's ?\ghts & attitude _h to be reckon$4 ,ea* side felt t a c]ta9 lib]ty _h be5 claim$ & _h be5 p]emptorily d5i$4 ,& ?is 0 m ?an confirm$ by ! public language ( ! great] "p ( ! ,bi%ops4 ,! *>ges aga9/ ! ,tract>ian p>ty ( ,romanis+1 & ( flagrant di%one/y1 long urg$ by irresponsible oppon5ts1 7 n[ =mally adopt$ by ! ,univ]sity au?orities1 & specially direct$ aga9/ ! =emo/ man ( ! p>ty4 ,f t "t ! fate ( ! p>ty at ,ox=d 0 det]m9$4 ,x mu/ break up4 ,soon] or lat]1 !re mu/ be a secession m or less discr$it+ & disabl+ ^? :o rema9$4 ,& s ! break-up came1 & yet1 s well gr\nd$ & s cong5ial to ! ,engli% ,*ur* 7 ! lead+ pr9ciples ( ! movem5t1 t n ev5 t disa/r\s & app>5tly hopeless wreck prev5t$ !m f aga9 ass]t+ _! claim & becom+ once m active & p[]ful4 ,! ,via ,m$ia1 :e!r or n logically consi/5t1 0 a ?+ ( g5u9e ,engli% gr[?1 & 0 at lea/ a work+ !ory4 ,,footnotes3 #hd ,apologia1 p4 #ahj4 #he ,essays ,critical & ,hi/orical1 #ahga4 #hf ,apologia1 pp4 #aha1 #ahb4 ,comp4 ,lett] to ,jelf1 p4 #ah4 #hg ,briti% ,critic1 ,april #ahci1 pp4 #dai-dbf4 ,cond5s$ 9 ! ,apologia1 pp4 #aib-aid4 #hh ,lett] to ! ,bi%op ( ,ox=d 7#bi? ,m>* #ahda71 pp4 #cc-dj4 ,comp4 ,lett] to ,jelf1 pp4 #g1 #h4 #hi ,apologia1 pp4 #bab1 #bba4 #ij ,lett] to ,jelf especially p4 #ai4 #ia ,walton's ,life1 i4 #ei 7,ox=d3 #ahde74 #ib ,no4 #ij1 p4 #bd4 #ic ,! foll[+ lett] ( ,mr4 ,james ,mozley 7#h? ,m>* #ahda7 gives ! fir/ impression ( ! ,tract3--,a new ,tract has come out ?is week1 & is beg9n+ to make a s5sation4 ,x is on ! ,articles1 & %[s t !y be> a highly ,ca?olic mean+2 & t _m doctr9es1 ( :i* ! ,romani/ are corruptions1 may be held consi/5tly ) !m4 ,?is is no m ?an :at we "k z a matt] ( hi/ory1 = ! ,articles 7 expressly word$ to br+ 9 ,roman ,ca?olics4 ,b p are a/oni%$ & confus$ at ! idea n[1 z if x 7 q new4 ,& !y h be5 s accu/om$ = a long "t to look at ! ,articles z on a p> ) ! ,cre$1 t !y ?9k1 ,i suppose1 t if !y subscribe to !m !y are b\nd to hold :atev] doctr9es 7n positively /at$ 9 !m7 are m]ely n condemn$4 ,s if !y w h a ,tract>ian s5se1 !y are !reby all ,tract>ians4444 ,x is1 ( c\rse1 highly complim5t>y to ! :ole set ( u to be s v mu* surpris$ t we %\ld ?9k :at we held to be consi/5t ) ! ,articles :i* we h subscrib$4 ,see also a clev] ,:ateleian pamphlet1 ,! ,controv]sy betwe5 ,tract ,no4 #ij & ! ,ox=d ,tutors4 7,h[ & ,p>sons1 #ahda47 #id ,see ,j4,b4 ,mozley's ,lett]s1 #ac? ,m>* #ahda4 #ie ,scil41 ^? cit$ 9 ! preamble to ?is resolution4 #if ,j4,b4 ,mozley's ,lett]s1 #ac? ,july #ahda4 ,,*apt] ,,xv ,,aft] ,,no4 #ij ,! proce$+s ab\t ,no4 #ij 7 a decl>ation ( w> on ! "p ( ! ,ox=d au?orities aga9/ ! ,tract>ian p>ty4 ,! suspicions1 al>ms1 antipa?ies1 jeal\sies1 :i* _h long be5 sm\ld]+ among ^? 9 p[]1 _h at la/ tak5 %ape 9 a def9ite act4 ,& x 0 a turn+-po9t 9 ! hi/ory ( ! movem5t4 ,aft] ?is x nev] 0 exactly :at x _h be5 hi!rto4 ,x _h be5 s f> a movem5t )9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 = its elevation & re=m inde$1 b at e /ep invok+ its au?ority ) deep respect1 ackn[l$g+ allegiance to its rul]s 9 unqualifi$ & ev5 excessive t]ms1 & aim+ loyally to make x 9 reality all t x 0 9 its devotional language & its classical lit]ature4 ,b aft] :at pass$ ab\t ,no4 #ij a *ange came4 ,! p>ty came "u an (ficial ban & /igma4 ,! common consequ5ces ( h>% treatm5t on ! t5d5cies & ?\ght ( a p>ty1 :i* consid]s itself unju/ly proscrib$1 %[$ !mselves m & m4 ,its m9d 0 divid$2 its temp] 0 exasp]at$2 :ile ! attitude ( ! gov]n+ au?orities h>d5$ m into det]m9$ ho/ility4 ,f ! "t ( ! c5sure1 & especially aft] ! ev5ts connect$ ) x1--! conte/ = ! ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip & ! r5ew$ ,hampd5 "q1--x may be said t ! *>act]i/ic temp]s ( ! ,corcyrean s$ition 7 reproduc$ on a small scale 9 ,ox=d4#ig ,! sc>e ( ,pop]y1 n )\t f\ndation--! reaction aga9/ x1 also n )\t f\ndation--_h ?r[n ! wise/ (f _! balance2 & :at ( ^? :o 7 n wise8 ,9 ! heat ( ^? days !re 7 few ,tract>ians :o did n ?9k ,dr4 ,wynt]1 ,dr4 ,faussett1 & ,dr4 ,symons h]etics 9 !ology & p]secutors 9 temp]1 despis]s ( ,*ri/ian devotion & self-d5ial4 ,!re 7 few ( ! p>ty ( ! ,heads :o did n ?9k e ,tract>ian a di%one/ & p]jur$ traitor1 equivocat+ ab\t 8 mo/ solemn engagem5ts1 ! ignorant slave ( *ildi% sup]/itions :i* he 0 conspir+ to br+ back4 ,x 0 ! day ( ! viol5t on bo? sides3 ! c\rtesies ( life 7 =gott52 m5 7 afraid ( be+ weak 9 _! c5sures1 _! dislike1 & _! opposition2 old fri5d%ips 7 brok5 up1 & m5 believ$ ! wor/ ( ^? :om a few ye>s back !y _h lov$ & hon\r$4 ,x is n agreeable to recall ^! long ext9ct animosities1 b !y are "p ( ! hi/ory ( t "t1 & affect$ ! c\rse 9 :i* ?+s ran4 ,& x is easy to blame1 x is h>d to d ju/ice to1 ! v>i\s p]sons & p>ties :o contribut$ to ! ev5ts ( t /range & confus$ "t4 ,all 0 new1 & unusual1 & )\t prec$5t 9 ,ox=d2 a p[]ful & en?usia/ic s*ool reviv+ old doctr9es 9 a way to make !m seem novelties1 & creat+ a wild panic f a qu>t] :]e x 0 ! lea/ expect$2 ! t]ror ( ?is panic act+ on au?orities n 9 ! lea/ prep>$ = su* a trial ( _! sagacity1 pati5ce1 & skill1 driv+ !m to unexampl$ sev]ity1 & to a desp]ate ef=t to expel ! di/urb+ innovators--among !m "s ( ! fir/ m5 9 ,ox=d 9 "* & ability--f _! places 9 ! ,univ]sity4#ih ,9 ord] to d ju/ice on ea* side at ?is di/ance ( "t1 we are b\nd to make all[ance--bo? = ! al>m & ! mi/ak5 viol5ce ( ! au?orities1 & = ! disaffection1 ! irritation1 ! /range me?ods :i* grew up 9 ! worri$ & suspect$ p>ty--= ! difficulties :i* beset bo? sides 9 ! conflict1 & ! c\nt]-influ5ces :i* drew !m hi!r & ?i!r4 ,b ! facts are z !y are2 & ev5 !n a calm] temp] 0 possible to ^? :o will$ x2 & 9 ! heat ( ! /rife !re 7 m5 among ! au?orities1 z well z 9 ! unpopul> p>ty1 :o kept _! balance1 :ile o!rs lo/ x4 ,und\bt$ly ! publication ( ,no4 #ij 0 ! occasion ( ! aggravat$ =m :i* diss5sion took1 & n unnaturally4 ,yet x 0 any?+ b :at x 0 tak5 to mean by ! au?orities1 an int5tional move 9 fav\r ( ,rome4 ,x 0 int5d$ to reconcile a l>ge & gr[+ class ( m9ds1 p5etrat$ & disgu/$ ) ! ignorance & inju/ice ( mu* ( ! curr5t controv]sial assumptions aga9/ ,rome1 to a l>g] & m def5sible view ( ! position ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,& ?is 0 done by call+ att5tion to t :i* 0 n n[ = ! fir/ "t obs]v$--to ! loose & ungu>d$ mode ( speak+ visible 9 ! lat] controv]sial ,articles1 & to ! contra/ betwe5 !m & ! te*nical & precise !ology ( ! fir/ five ,articles4 ,! ,articles ne$ n mean all :i* !y 7 suppos$ popul>ly to mean aga9/ :at 0 ,ca?olic 9 ,roman doctr9e4 ,?is 0 urg$ 9 simple good fai?2 x 0 b ! necess>y assumption ( all :o held ) ! ,ca?olic !ology1 :i* ! ,tract>ians all along ma9ta9$ t !y _h a "r to tea*2 x left pl5ty ( gr\nd ( diff]5ce ) unre=m$ & usurp+ ,rome4 ,& we "k t ! /orm :i* ,no4 #ij rais$ took ! writ] by surprise4 ,he did n expect t he %\ld give su* deep (f5ce4 ,b if he ?\ght ( ! effect on "o set ( m9ds1 he =got ! probable effect on ano!r2 & he =got1 or "u-e/imat$1 ! effect n only ( ! ?+s said1 b ( ! way 9 :i* !y 7 said4#ii ,no4 #ij 0 a surprise1 9 ! /ate ( ord9>y !ological k at ! "t4 ,x 0 a /rong ?+ to say t ! ,articles left a great deal ( =mal ,roman language unt\*$2 b to "w ?is out 9 dry1 bald1 te*nical logic1 on ! face ( x1 n>r[ 9 scope1 (t5 m]ely +5i\s1 0 ev5 a great] /umbl+-block4 ,x 01 und\bt$ly1 a great miscalculation1 su* z m5 ( ke5 & f>-rea*+ g5ius sometimes make4 ,!y mi/ake ! /r5g? & set ( ! tide2 !y imag9e t m9ds r\nd !m are go+ z fa/ z _! own4 ,we c see1 look+ back1 t su* an int]pretation ( ! ,articles1 ) ! view !n tak5 ( !m 9 ,ox=d z ! !ological text-book1 & 9 ! condition ( m5's m9ds1 c\ld n b be a great %ock4 ,& :at seem$ to give a s9i/] significance to ,no4 #ij 0 t1 z has be5 said1 a /rong curr5t 0 beg9n+ to set 9 ! direction ( ,rome4 ,x 0 n yet ( ! nature1 nor ( ! =ce1 :i* 0 imag9$4 ,! au?orities suspect$ x :]e x 0 n4 ,!y accept$ any contemptible bit ( gossip collect$ by ignorance or ill-nature z a pro( ( x4 ,! con/itutional frankness ( ,engli%m5 9 f9d+ fault ) :at is _! own--disgu/ at pomp\s glorification--scepticism z to our insul> claims aga9/ all ! re/ ( ,*ri/5dom to be exactly "r1 to be alone1 pure & apo/olic2 real increase & enl>gem5t ( k1 !ological & hi/orical2 criticism on portions ( our ,re=mation hi/ory2 admiration = *>act]s 9 m$iaeval times2 eag]ness1 ov]-g5]\s x might be1 to admit & repair wrong to an oppon5t unju/ly accus$2 all 7 set d[n toge!r ) o!r m unequivocal signs z lean+s to ,rome4 ,x 0 cle> t !re 0 a curr5t sett+ t[>ds ,rome2 b x 0 z cle> t !re 0 a mu* /rong] curr5t 9 ! p>ty z a :ole1 sett+ 9 ! opposite direction4 ,to ^? :o *ose to see & to di/+ui%1 ! love1 ! passionate loyalty ( ! bulk ( ! ,tract>ians to ! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 z evid5t & unque/ionable z any public fact c\ld be4 ,at ?is "t !re 0 no reason to call 9 "q ! /rong assurances giv5 by ! writ] ( ,no4 #ij himself ( 8 yet un%ak5 fai? 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,b all ^! important features ( ! movem5t--witness+1 inde$1 to deep se>*+s ( he>t1 b to a g5u9e desire to s]ve ! ,engli% ,*ur*--7 ov]look$ 9 ! "o ov]:elm+ fe> :i* _h tak5 possession ( ! au?orities4 ,al>m+ symptoms ( a disposition to ackn[l$ge & ev5 exagg]ate ! claims & ! attractions ( ! ,roman sy/em 7 inde$ app>5t4 ,no d\bt !re 7 reasons = disquiet & anxiety4 ,b ! te/ ( manl9ess & wisdom1 9 ! face ( su* reasons1 is h[ m5 measure _! proportion1 & h[ !y meet ! dang]4 ,! ,heads saw a real dang] be=e !m2 b !y met x 9 a wrong & unwor?y way4 ,!y committ$ two great errors4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 l ! ,jesuits 9 _! qu>rel ) ,portroyal & ! ,jans5i/s1 !y entirely fail$ to recognise ! moral elevation & religi\s purpose ( ! m5 :om !y oppos$4 ,!re 0 t be=e !m :i* x 0 to _! deep discr$it t !y did n see4 ,! movem5t1 :atev] else x 01 or :atev] else x became1 0 9 its fir/ /ages a movem5t = deep] religion1 = a m real & e>ne/ self-discipl9e1 = a l(ti] morality1 = m g5u9e self-devotion to a s]i\s life1 ?an _h ev] be5 se5 9 ,ox=d4 ,x 0 an hone/ attempt to raise ,ox=d life1 :i* by all evid5ce ne$$ rais+1 to some?+ m labori\s & some?+ m religi\s1 to some?+ m wor?y ( ! great ,*ri/ian f\ndations ( ,ox=d ?an ! rivalry ( colleges & ( ! s*ools1 ! m]e lit]>y atmosph]e ( ! tutor's lecture-room1 & ! easy & g5tlemanly & some:at idle fell[%ip ( ! common-rooms4 ,x 0 ! ef=t ( m5 :o _h all ! love ( s*ol>%ip1 & ! feel+ = x ( ! ,ox=d ( _! day1 to add to ?is ! habits ( ,*ri/ian /ud5ts & ! pursuit ( ,*ri/ian le>n+4 ,if all ?is 0 dang]\s & uncong5ial to ,ox=d1 s mu* ! worse = ,ox=d1 ) its great opportunities & great pr(essions--,dom9us illum9atio mea4 ,b c]ta9ly ?is m>k ( moral purpose & moral =ce 0 s pla9 9 ! movem5t t ! rul]s ( ,ox=d _h no "r to mi/ake x4 ,:5 ! names come back to our m9ds ( ^? :o l$ & mo/ repres5t$ ! ,tract>ians1 x mu/ be a matt] ( surprise to any man :o has n almo/ p>t$ ) ! idea ( ,*ri/ian goodness1 t ?is feature ( ! movem5t c\ld escape or fail to impress ^? :o _h kn[n well all _! lives long :at ^! lead]s 74 ,b amid ! clam\r & ! tell-tale gossip1 &1 x mu/ be admitt$1 ! folly r\nd !m1 !y miss$ x4 ,p]haps !y 7 bewild]$4 ,b !y mu/ h ! blame1 ! heavy blame1 :i* belongs to all ^? :o1 :5 good is be=e !m1 d n recognise x accord+ to its due measure4#ajj ,9 ! next place1 ! au?orities attack$ & condemn$ ! ,tract>ian tea*+ at once viol5tly & ignorantly1 & 9 !m ignorance ( ! gr\nd on :i* ! battle 0 f\ght 0 h>dly p>donable4 ,d\btless ! ,tract>ian language 0 9 _m respects novel & /range4 ,b ,ox=d 0 n only a city ( libr>ies1 x 0 ! home ( :at 0 especially acc\nt$ ,*ur* !ology2 & ! ,tract>ian tea*+1 9 its f\ndation & ma9 outl9es1 _h little b :at ought to h be5 p]fectly famili> to any "o :o *ose to take ! tr\ble to /udy ! great ,*ur* ( ,engl& writ]s4 ,to "o :o1 l ,dr4 ,r\? ( ,magdal51 _h gone bel[ ! surface1 & 0 acqua9t$ ) ! que/ions debat$ by ^? div9es1 !re 0 no?+ />tl+ 9 :at s al>m$ 8 bre?r51 :e!r he agre$ ) x or n2 & to him ! indiscrim9ate *>ge ( ,pop]y meant no?+4 ,b ,dr4 ,r\? /ood alone among 8 bro!r ,heads 9 8 k ( :at ,engli% !ology 04 ,to mo/ ( !m x 0 an unexplor$ & mi/y region2 "s ( ! able/1 "u ! influ5ce ( ,dr4 ,:ately's vigor\s & scornful discipl9e1 _h le>n$ to slight x4 ,b !re x 04 ,:e!r x 0 read or n1 its great names 7 pron\nc$ ) hon\r1 & quot$ on occasion4 ,f ,hook] to ,van ,mild]t1 !re 0 an unbrok5 ?read ( common pr9ciples giv+ cont9uity to a l9e ( ,*ur* tea*]s4 ,! ,puritan l9e ( doctr9e1 ?\gh x c\ld claim mu* sanction among ! div9es ( ! ,re=mation--! ,latitud9>ian idea1 ?\gh x _h ! c\nt5ance ( fam\s names & p[]ful intellects--nev] c\ld aspire to ! special title ( ,*ur* !ology4 ,& ! tea*+ :i* _h t "n1 bo? 9 praise1 & (t5 9 dispraise1 z te*nical1 s*ola/ic1 unspiritual1 transc5d5tal1 nay1 ev5 ,popi%1 c\nt5anc$ ! ,tract>ians4 ,!y 7 sne]$ at = _! pond]\s ,cat5ae ( au?orities2 b on ! gr\nd on :i* ?is debate rag$1 ! appeal 0 a p]t95t & solid "o4 ,yet to ,high ,*ur* ,ox=d & its rul]s1 all ?is 0 /range doctr9e4 ,pro( & quotation might lie be=e _! eyes1 b _! m9ds /ill ran 9 "o groove1 & !y c\ld n realise :at !y saw4 ,! words meant no h>m 9 ! v5]able folio2 !y meant p]il\s h]esy 9 ! mod]n ,tract4 ,:5 ! au?orities _h to judge ( ! que/ions rais$ by ! movem5t1 !y 7 unprovid$ ) ! adequate k2 & ?is 0 k :i* !y ought to h possess$ = its own sake1 z doctors ( ! ,!ological ,faculty ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,& x 0 n only = _! want ( le>n+1 manife/ all ?r\gh ! controv]sy1 t !y 7 to blame4 ,_! mo/ tell+ *>ge aga9/ ! ,tract>ians1 :i* 0 embodi$ 9 ! c5sure ( ,no4 #ij1 0 ! *>ge ( di%one/y4 ,! *>ge is a v h&y "o aga9/ oppon5ts1 & x may re/ on good gr\nds2 b ^? :o ?9k "r to make x ought1 bo? z a matt] ( policy & z a matt] ( consci5ce1 to be q assur$ ( _! own position4 ,! ,articles are a public1 common docum5t4 ,x is ! diff]+ int]pretations ( a common docum5t :i* create political & religi\s p>ties2 & only %all[ness & prejudice w impute to an oppon5t di%one/y )\t /rong & cle> reason4 ,mr4 ,newman's int]pretation 9 ,no4 #ij1--new1 n 9 claim+ = ! ,articles a ,ca?olic mean+1 b 9 limit+1 ?\gh x does n d5y1 _! anti-,roman scope1 0 fairly op5 to criticism4 ,x might be tak5 z a *all5ge1 & z a *all5ge might h to be met4 ,b x w\ld h be5 bo? fair & wise 9 ! ,heads1 be=e proce$+ to unusual extremities1 to h %[n t !y _h fully consid]$ _! own !ological doctr9es 9 relation to ! ,*ur* =mul>ies4 ,!y all _h obvi\s difficulties1 & 9 "s cases =midable ones4 ,! majority ( !m 7 :at w\ld h be5 call$ 9 old] controv]sial days frank ,arm9ians1 %utt+ _! eyes by =ce ( cu/om to ! look ( "s ( ! ,articles1 :i*1 if ( ,lu!ran orig91 _h be5 claim$ f ! fir/ by ,calv9i/s4 ,! ,evangelicals _h long confess$ difficulties1 at lea/1 9 ! ,baptismal ,s]vice & ! ,visitation ,(fice2 :ile ! m5 mo/ l\d 9 d5unciation ( di%one/y 7 ! div9es ( ,:ately's s*ool1 :o _h be5 und]m9+ ! au?ority ( all cre$s & articles1 & _h nev] be5 tir$ ( proclaim+ _! dislike ( t solemn ,a?anasian ,cre$ to :i* ,pray] ,book & ,articles alike b\nd !m4 ,m5 ) ^! difficulties daily be=e !m _h no "r to ignore !m4 ,d\btless !y all _h _! explanations :i* !y bona fide believ$ 94 ,b :at 0 !re t exclud$ ,mr4 ,newman f ! claim to bona fides8 ,he _h attack$ no f\ndation ( ,*ri/ianity2 he _h d5i$ or d\bt$ no article ( ! ,cre$4 ,he gave 8 explanations1 c]ta9ly n m f>-fet*$ ?an ^? ( "s ( 8 judges4 ,9 a ,*ur* divid$ by _m conflict+ views1 & !re=e b\nd to all possible tol]ance1 he _h adopt$ "o view :i* c]ta9ly 0 unpopul> & p]haps 0 dang]\s4 ,he might be confut$1 he might be accus$1 or1 if s be1 convict$ ( error1 p]haps ( h]esy4 ,b no?+ ( ?is k9d 0 attempt$4 ,! incompatibility ( 8 view1 n m]ely ) ! ,articles1 b ) morality 9 sign+ :at all1 ( :atev] p>ty1 _h sign$1 0 ass]t$ 9 a c5sure1 :i* evad$ ! responsibility ( specify+ ! po9t :i* x condemn$4 ,! al>m ( trea*]y & conspiracy is "o ( ! mo/ madd5+ ( human impulses4 ,! ,heads ( ,h\ses1 in/ead ( mod]at+ & sob]+ x1 ) ! au?ority ( in/ruct$ & sagaci\s rul]s1 blew x into a flame4 ,& !y act$ 9 su* a hurry t all s5se ( proportion & dignity 0 lo/4 ,!y p]emptorily refus$ to wait ev5 a few days1 z ! writ] reque/$1 & z 0 due to 8 "*1 = explanation4 ,!y d>$ n risk an appeal to ! ,univ]sity at l>ge4 ,!y d>$ n abide ! effect ( discussion on ! bl[ :i* !y 7 urg$ to /rike4 ,!y *ose1 t !y might /rike )\t delay1 ! inexpressibly *ildi% /ep ( /ick+ up at ! ,s*ools' gates1 & at ,college butt]ies1 )\t trial1 or conviction1 or s5t5ce1 a notice decl>+ t c]ta9 modes ( sign+ ! ,articles sugge/$ 9 a c]ta9 ,tract 7 di%one/4 ,x 01 !y said1 to protect und]graduates2 z if und]graduates w\ld be affect$ by a vague ass]tion on a difficult subject1 ab\t :i* no?+ 0 m c]ta9 ?an t ^? :o issu$ ! notice 7 n agre$ among !mselves4 ,! m5 :o act$ ?us 7 good & consci5ti\s m51 :o ?\ght !mselves 9 ! pres5ce ( a great dang]4 ,x is only fair to rememb] ?is4 ,b x is also impossible to be fair to ! p>ty ( ! movem5t )\t rememb]+ ?is deplorable failure 9 consi/5cy1 9 ju/ice1 9 temp]1 9 *>ity1 on ! "p ( ^? 9 p[] 9 ! ,univ]sity4 ,! drift t[>ds ,rome _h n yet become an unmanageable ru%2 & ?\gh !re 7 cases 9 :i* no?+ c\ld h /opp$ its c\rse1 !re is no reason to d\bt t g5]\s & equitable deal+1 a m consid]ate reasonabl5ess1 a l>g] & m compreh5sive judgm5t ( facts1 & a m pati5t wait+ = /rong fir/ impressions to ju/ify & v]ify !mselves1 w\ld h av]t$ mu* mis*ief4 ,!re 0 mu* t 0 to be regrett$ f ?is "t =w>d 9 ! temp] & _s ( ! movem5t p>ty4 ,b t :i* n\ri%$ & /r5g!n$ impati5ce1 exagg]ation ( language & views1 scorn ( ?+s z !y 71 intol]ance ( ev]y?+ mod]ate1 bo? 9 m5 & 9 words1 0 ! consci\sness ) :i* e man got up 9 ! morn+ & pass$ ! day1 ( ! bitt] ho/ility ( ^? =emo/ 9 place 9 ,ox=d--( _! incompet5ce to judge fairly--( _! incapacity to appreh5d :at 0 high & e>ne/ 9 ^? :om !y condemn$--( ! impossibility ( gett+ !m to imag9e t ,tract>ians c\ld be any?+ b fools or traitors--( _! hopeless bl9dness to any fact or any tea*+ to :i* !y 7 n accu/om$4 ,if ! au?orities c\ld only h /opp$ to consid] :e!r aft] all !y 7 n deal+ ) real ?\ght & real wi% to d "r1 !y might aft] all h dislik$ ! movem5t1 b !y w\ld h se5 t :i* w\ld h kept !m f viol5ce4 ,!y w\ld n li/51 !y w\ld n inquire1 !y w\ld n consid]4 ,c\ld su* ignorance1 c\ld su* wrong possibly be )\t mis*iev\s influ5ce on ^? :o 7 ! victims ( x1 mu* m on fri5ds & disciples :o knew & lov$ !m8 ,! ,tract>ians _h be5 prea*+ t ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 ) all its ,prote/ant feel+ & all its ,prote/ant acts & hi/ory1 0 yet1 z x pr(ess$ to be1 "p & p>cel ( ! great hi/oric ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 :i* _h fram$ ! ,cre$s1 :i* _h cont9u$ ! ,sacram5ts1 :i* _h prea*$ & taught out ( ! ,bible1 :i* _h giv5 u our immemorial pray]s4 ,!y _h sp>$ no pa9s to make out ?is great commonplace f hi/ory & !ology3 nor _h !y sp>$ pa9s1 :ile insi/+ on ?is dom9ant feature 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 to draw /rongly & broadly ! l9es :i* di/+ui%$ x f ,rome4 ,0 x wond]ful1 :5 all gu>d+ & explanatory limitations 7 contemptu\sly toss$ aside by all-d>+ ignorance1 & all 0 lump$ toge!r 9 ! indiscrim9ate *>ge ( ,romanis+1 t !re %\ld h be5 "s to take ! au?orities at _! ^w8 ,0 x wond]ful :5 m5 7 told t ! ,*ur* ( ,engl& 0 no place = !m1 t !y 7 break+ _! v[s & violat+ solemn engagem5ts by act+ z its m9i/]s1 & t 9 ord] to pres]ve ! respect ( hone/ m5 !y %\ld leave x--t ! "q ( *ange1 f> (f z x _h once seem$1 came )9 measurable di/ance8 ,! g5]ation to :i* !y belong$ _h be5 br\ght up ) /rong exhortations to be real1 & to hate %ams2 & n[ ! "q 0 =c$ on !m :e!r x 0 n a %am = ! ,engli% ,*ur* to call itself ,ca?olic2 :e!r a body ( tea*+ :i* 0 d5\nc$ by its au?orities1 h[ev] x might look on pap] & be def5d$ by le>n+1 c\ld be m ?an a plausible lit]>y hypo!sis 9 contra/ to ! great work+ sy/em ( :i* ! head 0 ,rome4 ,:5 we consid] ! s+ul> & anomal\s position on any !ory1 includ+ ! ,roman1 ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*2 ) :at great diff]5ces its v>i\s features & elem5ts h be5 prom95t at diff]5t times2 h[ l>gely its hi/ory has be5 m>k$ by contradictory facts & appe>ances2 & h[ h>d x is = any "o to keep all1 accord+ to _! real importance1 simultane\sly 9 view2 :5 we rememb] also :at are ! temptations ( human nature 9 great collisions ( religi\s belief1 ! excitem5t & passion ( ! "t1 ! mix$ "* ( all religi\s zeal1 ! natural inevitable ang] :i* accompanies x :5 resi/$1 ! f]v\r :i* welcomes self-sacrifice = ! tru?2 & :5 we ?9k ( all ?is kept agl[ by ! cont9u\s provocation ( unfair & h>% deal+ f p]sons :o 7 sc>cely entitl$ to be sev]e judges2 ! wond] is1 human nature be+ :at x is1 n t s _m w5t1 b t s _m /ay$4 ,,footnotes3 #ig 444 1 444 1 4--,?uc4 iii4 #hb4 ,reckless d>+ 0 held to be loyal c\rage2 mod]ation 0 ! disguise ( unmanly weakness2 to "k ev]y?+ 0 to d no?+2 frantic en]gy 0 ! true "* ( a man2 ! lov] ( viol5ce 0 always tru/$1 & 8 oppon5t suspect$4--,j[ett's translation4 #ih ,"o ( ! /range/ features 9 ! conflict 0 ! entire misconception %[n ( :at ,mr4 ,newman 0--! bl9dness to 8 real "* & objects--! imputation to him n m]ely ( grave faults1 b ( small & mean ones4 ,8 critics c\ld n rise above ! poore/ measure ( 8 intellect & motives4 ,"o ( ! able/ ( !m1 :o _h once be5 8 fri5d1 9 a f>ewell lett] ( k9dly remon/rance1 specifies c]ta9 ,roman errors1 :i* he hopes t ,mr4 ,newman w n fall into--ador+ images & wor%ipp+ sa9ts--z if ! pleasure & privilege ( wor%ipp+ images & sa9ts 7 to ,mr4 ,newman ! inducem5t to jo9 ,rome & break ! ties ( a lifetime4 ,& s ( 8 moral qualities4 ,a prom95t ,evangelical lead]1 ,dr4 ,close ( ,*elt5ham1 aft]w>ds ,dean ( ,c>lisle1 at a complim5t>y d9n]1 9 :i* he himself glori$ 9 ! f\l1 p]sonal abuse to :i* he _h be5 subject$ 9 8 zeal = tru?1 proce$$ to give 8 judgm5t on ,mr4 ,newman3 ,:5 ,i fir/ read ,no4 #ij1 ,i did n !n "k ! au?or2 b ,i said !n1 & ,i repeat "h1 n ) any p]sonal ref]5ce to ! au?or1 t ,i %\ld be sorry to tru/ ! au?or ( t ,tract ) my purse1--,report ( ,spee* 9 ,*elt5ham ,exam9]1 #a/ ,m>* #ahdc4 #ii 1 ' 4--,ari/4 ,rhet4 iii4 ,i4 #ajj ,dr4 ,ri*>ds1 ! ,rector ( ,exet]1 seems to h /ood ap>t f 8 bro!r heads4--,cf4 ,lett]s ( ! ,rev4 ,j4,b4 ,mozley1 p4 #aac4 ,,*apt] ,,xvi4 ,,! ,,?ree ,,defeats3 ,,isaac ,,williams1 ,,macmull51 ,,pusey ,! ye> #ahda1 ?\gh x _h begun 9 /orm1 & ?\gh signs 7 n want+ ( fur!r di/urbance1 0 at ,ox=d1 outw>dly at lea/1 a peaceable "o4 ,a great *ange _h happ5$2 b1 :5 ! fir/ bur/ ( excitem5t 0 ov]1 m5 settl$ d[n to _! usual "w1 _! lectures1 or _! read+1 or _! p>i%es1 & by ,ea/] ?+s seem$ to g on z be=e4 ,! ord9>y habits ( ,univ]sity life resum$ _! c\rse ) a curi\s quietness4 ,!re 01 no d\bt1 mu* tr\ble brood+ und]nea?4 ,mr4 ,w>d & o!rs cont9u$ a w> ( pamphlets2 & 9 ,june ,mr4 ,w>d 0 dismiss$ f 8 ,ma!matical ,lecture%ip at ,balliol4 ,b fai? 9 ! great lead] 0 /ill /rong4 ,no4 #ij1 if x _h %ock$ or disquiet$ "s1 _h elicit$ equally rem>kable expressions ( confid5ce & sympa?y f o!rs :o might h be51 at lea/1 sil5t4 ,! ev5ts ( ! spr+ _h made m5 consci\s ( :at _! lead] 01 & call$ =? w>m & en?usia/ic affection4 ,x 0 n 9 va9 t1 :atev] might be ?\ght ( ! wisdom or ! reason+s ( ,no4 #ij1 he _h %[n ! height ( 8 "* & ! purity & greatness ( 8 religi\s purpose2 & t be+ :at he 01 9 ! eyes ( all ,ox=d1 he _h be5 treat$ ) contumely1 & _h borne x ) pati5ce & loyal submission4 ,!re 7 ke5 obs]v]s1 to :om t pati5ce told ( future dang]s2 !y w\ld h lik$ him to %[ m fight4 ,b he gave no signs ( defeat1 nor1 outw>dly1 ( disquiet2 he =bore to retaliate at ,ox=d3 & ! s]mons at ,/4 ,m>y's cont9u$1 p5etrat+ & se>*+ z ev]1 p]haps ) some?+ m pa!tic & anxi\s 9 _! und]tone ?an be=e4 ,b if he =bore at ,ox=d1 he did n let ?+s pass outside4 ,sir ,rob]t ,peel1 9 op5+ a read+-room at ,tamwor?1 _h spok5 loosely1 9 ! conv5tional & pomp\s way !n fa%ionable1 ( ! all-suffic+ & exclusive bless+s ( k4 ,:ile ,mr4 ,newman 0 correct+ ! pro(s ( ,no4 #ij1 he 0 also writ+ to ! ,times ! fam\s lett]s ( ,ca?olicus2 a w>n+ to em95t public m5 ( ! dang] ( declaim+ on popul> commonplaces )\t due exam9ation ( _! wor?4 ,b all seem$ quiet4 ,9 ! summ] ( #ahda1 we read 9 ! ,apologia1 ,i f\nd myself at ,littlemore )\t any h>ass or anxiety on my m9d4 ,i _h det]m9$ to put aside all controv]sy1 & set myself d[n to my translation ( ,/4 ,a?anasius4 ,outside ( ,ox=d !re 0 a ga!r+ ( fri5ds 9 ! summ] at ! consecration ( "o ( ,mr4 ,keble's di/rict *ur*es1 ,ampfield--an occasion less common & m noticeable !n ?an n[4 ,aga91 :at 0 a new ?\ght !n1 a little b& ( "y ,ox=d m51 t5 or twelve1 tax$ !mselves to build a new *ur*1 :i* 0 ultimately plac$ at ,bussage1 9 ,mr4 ,?omas ,keble's p>i%4 ,"o ( ,mr4 ,keble's curates1 ,mr4 ,pet] ,"y1 _h be5 refus$ ,prie/'s ord]s by ! ,bi%op ( ,w9*e/]1 = alleg$ uns\ndness on ! doctr9e ( ! ,eu*>i/4 ,mr4 ,selwyn1 n )\t misgiv+s on ! "p ( ! ,:ig p[]s1 _h be5 appo9t$ ,bi%op ( ,new ,zeal&4 ,dr4 ,arnold _h be5 appo9t$ to ! ,*air ( ,mod]n ,hi/ory at ,ox=d4 ,9 ! c\rse ( ! ye> !re pass$ away "o :o _h _h a v real ?\gh unackn[l$g$ influ5ce on mu* t _h happ5$--,mr4 ,blanco ,:ite4 ,& at ! end ( ! ye>1 #bi? ,octob]1 ,mr4 ,keble gave 8 la/ lecture on ,poetry1 & f9i%$ a c\rse ! mo/ orig9al & memorable ev] deliv]$ f 8 *air4 ,t[>ds ! end ( ! ye> two incid5ts1 besides "s r\ghly-word$ ,episcopal *>ges1 di/urb$ ?is quiet4 ,!y 7 only indirectly connect$ ) !ological controv]sy at ,ox=d2 b !y _h great ultimate influ5ce on x1 & !y help$ to m>%al p>ties & consolidate animosities4 ,"o 0 ! beg9n+ ( ! conte/ = ! ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip :i* ,mr4 ,keble _h vacat$4 ,!re 0 no "o ( equal em95ce to succe$ him2 b !re 0 9 ,ox=d a man ( und\bt$ poetical g5ius1 ( ref9$ ta/e & subtle ?\ght1 ?\gh ( unequal p[]1 :o _h devot$ 8 gifts to ! same great purpose = :i* ,mr4 ,keble _h writt5 ! ,*ri/ian ,ye>4 ,no "o :o has look$ into ! ,bapti/]y1 :atev] 8 feel+ t[>ds ! writ]1 c d\bt :e!r ,mr4 ,isaac ,williams 0 a poet & knew :at poetry meant4 ,he 0 an intimate fri5d ( ,mr4 ,keble & ,mr4 ,newman1 & s he 0 /yl$ a ,tract>ian2 b no "n (f]$ itself s obvi\sly to ! electors z 81 & 9 due "t 8 fri5ds ann\nc$ _! int5tion ( br++ him =w>d4 ,8 competitor 0 ,mr4 7aft]w>ds ,ar*deacon7 ,g>bett ( ,bras5ose1 ! college ( ,heb] & ,milman1 an accompli%$ g5tleman ( high culture1 believ$ to h an acqua9tance1 n common !n 9 ,ox=d1 ) =eign lit]ature1 ^: qualifications /ood high 9 ! op9ion ( 8 ,univ]sity fri5ds1 b :o _h giv5 no evid5ce to ! public ( 8 claims to ! (fice4 ,x 0 inevitable1 x 0 no "o's special fault1 t ! "q ( !ological op9ions %\ld intrude itself2 b at fir/ x 0 only 9 private t objections 7 rais$ or c&idatures recomm5d$ on !ological gr\nds4 ,b rum\rs 7 abroad t ! au?orities ( ,bras5ose 7 canvass+ _! college on ^! gr\nds3 & 9 an unlucky mom5t = ,mr4 ,williams1 ,dr4 ,pusey1 n )\t ! k1 b )\t ! ass5t+ judgm5t ( ,mr4 ,newman1 ?\ght x well to s5d =? a circul> 9 ,*ri/ ,*ur* fir/1 b soon ) wid] publicity1 ask+ support = ,mr4 ,williams z a p]son ^: kn[n religi\s views w\ld ensure 8 mak+ 8 (fice m9i/] to religi\s tru?4 ,no?+ c\ld be m innoc5tly meant4 ,x 0 ! highe/ purpose to :i* t (fice c\ld be devot$4 ,b ! mi/ake 0 se5 on all sides z soon z made4 ,! ,pr9cipal ( ,mr4 ,g>bett's college4 ,dr4 ,gilb]t1 l a g5]al jump+ on 8 antagoni/ :om he has caught 9 ! act ( a false move1 put =? a dignifi$ c\nt]-appeal1 alleg+ t he _h n rais$ ?is issue1 b add+ t z x _h be5 rais$ & av[$ on ! o!r side1 he 0 q will+ t x %\ld be tak5 into acc\nt1 & ! dang]s duly consid]$ ( t tea*+ ) :i* ,dr4 ,pusey's lett] _h id5tifi$ ,mr4 ,williams4 ,no "o f t mom5t c\ld prev5t ! conte/ f becom+ almo/ entirely a !ological "o1 :i* 0 to try ! /r5g? ( ! p>ty ( ! movem5t4 ,attempts 7 made1 b 9 va91 to dive/ x ( ?is "*4 ,! w> ( pamphlets & leaflets disp]s$ 9 ! common-rooms1 :i* usually accompani$ ^! conte/s1 began1 & ! ye> clos$ ) prep>ations = a sev]e /ruggle :5 ! ,univ]sity met 9 ! foll[+ ,janu>y4 ,! o!r matt] 0 ! e/abli%m5t ( ! ,anglo-,prussian bi%opric at ,j]usalem4 ,x 0 ! object ( ! ambition ( ,m4 ,buns5 to pave ! way = a recognition1 by ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ( ! new ,/ate ,*ur* ( ,prussia1 & ultimately = "s clos] alliance betwe5 ! two bodies2 & ! plan ( a ,prote/ant ,bi%op ( ,j]usalem1 nom9at$ alt]nately by ,engl& & ,prussia1 consecrat$ by ,engli% ,bi%ops1 & ex]cis+ jurisdiction ov] ,engli% & ,g]man ,prote/ants 9 ,pale/9e1 0 propos$ by him to ,ar*bi%op ,h[ley & ,bi%op ,blomfield1 & some:at ha/ily & incauti\sly accept$ by !m4 ,to ,mr4 ,newman1 fight+ a h>d battle1 z he felt x1 = ! hi/orical & con/itutional ca?olicity ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ?is /ep on _! "p came z a practical & ev5 o/5tati\s contradiction ( 8 argum5ts4 ,engl&1 x seem$1 :i* 0 out ( communion ) ! ,ea/ & ) ,rome1 c\ld lightly ent] into close communion ) ,lu!rans & ,calv9i/s aga9/ !m bo?4 ,he record$ an indignant & ev5 bitt] prote/2 & ?\gh ! s*eme _h its w>m apologi/s1 su* z ,dr4 ,hook & ,mr4 ,f4 ,maurice1 x _h its ke5-sight$ critics1 & x 0 nev] receiv$ ) fav\r by ! ,*ur* at l>ge4 ,&1 inde$1 x 0 only active = mis*ief4 ,x creat$ irritation1 suspicion1 discord 9 ,engl&1 :ile no ,g]man c>$ a /raw ab\t x4 ,nev] 0 an ambiti\s s*eme s m>k$ by impot5ce & failure f its fir/ /eps to its la/4 ,b x 0 "o1 z ! ,apologia in=ms u1#aja 9 ! *a9 ( ev5ts :i* de/roy$ ,mr4 ,newman's belief 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,x 0 "o ( ! bl[s1 he writes1 :i* broke me4 ,! next ye>1 #ahdb1 op5$ ) w>2 w> betwe5 ! ,univ]sity au?orities & ! p>ty ( ! movem5t1 :i* 0 to cont9ue 9 v>i\s =ms & ) little int]mission till ! /range & pa!tic ev5ts ( #ahde susp5d$ ! right+ & /unn$ ! fight]s1 & = a "t hu%$ ev5 ang] 9 feel+s ( amazem5t1 sorr[1 & fe>4 ,^? ev5ts impos$ /illness on all :o _h tak5 "p 9 ! /rife1 l ! bl[+ up ( ! ,ori5t at ! battle ( ! ,nile4 ,z soon z ! ,univ]sity met 9 ,janu>y #ahdb1 ! conte/ = ! ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip 0 settl$4 ,!re 0 no meet+ ( ,convocation1 b a comp>ison ( votes gave a majority ( ?ree to two to ,mr4 ,g>bett1#ajb & ,mr4 ,williams )drew4 ,! ,tract>ians _h be5 di/9ctly beat52 x 0 _! fir/ defeat z a p>ty4 ,x seems z if ?is enc\rag$ ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d to a move1 :i* w\ld be felt z a bl[ aga9/ ! ,tract>ians1 & :i*1 z an act ( rep>ation to ,dr4 ,hampd51 w\ld give satisfaction to ! able/ section ( _! own support]s1 ! !ological ,lib]als4 ,!y propos$ to repeal ! disqualification :i* _h be5 impos$ on ,dr4 ,hampd5 9 #ahcf4 ,b !y _h miscalculat$4 ,x 0 too evid5tly a move to take advantage ( ! rec5t ,tract>ian discomfiture to :itewa% ,dr4 ,hampd5's ,lib]alism4 ,! proposal1 & ! way 9 :i* x 0 made1 r\s$ a /rong feel+ among ! resid5ts2 a reque/ to )draw x receiv$ ! signatures n only ( mod]ate ,anglicans & indep5d5t m51 l ,mr4 ,francis ,fab] ( ,magdal51 ,mr4 ,sewell1 ! ,greswells1 & ,mr4 ,w4 ,palm] ( ,worce/]1 b ( ,mr4 ,tait ( ,balliol1 & ,mr4 ,golightly4 ,dr4 ,hampd5's own attitude did n help x4 ,!re 0 great want ( dignity 9 8 o/5tati\s pr(ession ( or?odoxy & atta*m5t to ! ,articles1 9 8 emphatic adoption ( ,evangelical phraseology1 & 9 8 unmeasur$ d5unciation ( 8 oppon5ts1 & especially ( ^? :om he view$ z mo/ responsible = ! c5sure ( #ahcf--! ,tract>ians or ,romanis]s4 ,& ! difficulty ) ^? :o _h pass$ & :o n[ propos$ to )draw ! c5sure1 0 t ,dr4 ,hampd5 p]si/5tly & l\dly decl>$ t he _h no?+ to retract1 & retract$ no?+2 & if x 0 "r to pass x 9 #ahcf1 x w\ld n be "r to )draw x 9 #ahdb4 ,at ! la/ mom5t1 ,mr4 ,tait & ,mr4 ,pi]s ,claughton ( ,univ]sity made an attempt to get some?+ f ,dr4 ,hampd5 :i* might pass z a )drawal ( :at 0 suppos$ to be dang]\s 9 8 ,bampton ,lectures2 & !re 7 "s ev5 among ,mr4 ,newman's fri5ds1 :o1 dislik+ f ! fir/ ! =m ( ! c5sure1 might h f\nd 9 su* a )drawal a reason = vot+ = its repeal4 ,b ,dr4 ,hampd5 0 obdurate4 ,! measure 0 press$1 & 9 ,june x 0 ?r[n out 9 ,convocation by a majority ( ?ree to two#ajc--! same proportion1 ?\gh 9 small] numb]s1 z 9 ! vote aga9/ ,mr4 ,williams4 ,! measure 0 n an hone/ "o on ! "p ( ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d1 & des]v$ to be defeat$4 ,among ! pamphlets :i* ! discussion produc$1 two by ,mr4 ,james ,mozley gave e>ly evid5ce1 by _! =ce ( /atem5t & _! tr5*ant logic1 ( ! p[] ) :i* he 0 to take "p 9 ! que/ions :i* agitat$ ! ,univ]sity4 ,dr4 ,hampd5 took 8 rev5ge1 & x 0 n a noble "o4 ,! fell[s ( c]ta9 colleges 7 oblig$ to proce$ to ! ,b4,d4 degree on pa9 ( =feit+ _! fell[%ips4 ,! ex]cises = ! degree1 :i*1 by ! ,/atutes1 took ! old-fa%ion$ %ape ( =mal ,lat9 disputations betwe5 ,oppon5ts & ,respond5ts on giv5 !ses 9 ! ,div9ity ,s*ool1 _h by an arrangem5t introduc$ by ,dr4 ,burton1 ) no au?ority f ! ,/atutes1 come to consi/ ( two ,engli% essays on subjects *os5 by ! c&idate & approv$ by ! ,div9ity ,pr(essor4 ,! ex]cises = ! degree _h long ceas$ to be look$ ^u z v s]i\s matt]s1 & c]ta9ly 7 nev] reg>d$ z te/s ( ! s\ndness ( ! c&idate's fai?4 ,!y 7 usually on well-worn commonplaces1 ( :i* ! ,regius ,pr(essor kept a /ock1 & ab\t :i* no "o tr\bl$ himself b ! p]son :o want$ ! degree4 ,x 0 n a cr$itable sy/em1 b x 0 ( a piece ) ! preval5t abs5ce ( any s]i\s exam9ation = ! sup]ior degrees4 ,x w\ld h be5 q befitt+ 8 position1 if ,dr4 ,hampd5 _h call$ ! att5tion ( ! au?orities to ! evil ( %am ex]cises = degrees 9 8 own important ,faculty4 ,x w\ld h be5 q "r to make a vigor\s ef=t on public gr\nds to turn ^! %am trials into realities2 to use !m1 l ! exam9ation = ! ,b4,a4 degree1 z te/s ( k & compet5t ability4 ,su* a move on 8 "p w\ld h be5 9 h>mony ) ! legislation :i* _h rec5tly add$ two !ological ,pr(essors to ! ,faculty1 & _h sket*$ out1 h[ev] imp]fectly1 ! outl9es ( a reviv$ !ological s*ool4 ,?is is :at1 ) good reason1 ,dr4 ,hampd5 might h attempt$ on g5]al gr\nds1 & _h he be5 successful 7?\gh ?is 9 ! suspici\s /ate ( ,univ]sity feel+ 0 n v likely7 he w\ld h ga9$ 9 a regul> & lawful way t p[] ( emb>rass+ 8 oppon5ts :i* he 0 resolv$ to use 9 defiance ( all exi/+ cu/om4 ,b su* 0 n ! c\rse :i* he *ose4 ,mr4 ,macmull5 ( ,corpus1 :o1 9 pursuance ( ! ,college ,/atutes1 _h to proce$ to ! ,b4,d4 degree1 appli$1 z ! cu/om 01 = !ses to ! ,pr(essor4 ,mr4 ,macmull5 0 kn[n to hold ! op9ions ( ! movem5t s*ool2 ( c\rse he 0 call$ a ,tract>ian2 he _h put 8 "n to "s ( ! _m pap]s :i* express$ ! s5tim5ts ( 8 fri5ds on curr5t ev5ts4 ,dr4 ,hampd5 s5t him two propositions1 :i* ! c&idate 0 to support1 fram$ s z to commit him to ass]tions :i* ,mr4 ,macmull51 ^: high ,anglican op9ions 7 well kn[n1 c\ld n consi/5tly make4 ,x 0 a novel & unexampl$ act on ! "p ( ! ,pr(essor1 to turn :at _h be5 a m]e =mal ex]cise into a %>p & sweep+ te/ ( doctr9e1 :i* w\ld place all future ,div9ity degrees 9 ! ,univ]sity at 8 m]cy2 & ! case 0 made m s]i\s1 :5 ! v =m ( ex]cise :i* ! ,pr(essor us$ z an in/rum5t ( su* =midable p[] 0 itself )\t "q un/atutable & illegal1 & _h be5 simply conniv$ at by ! au?orities4 ,to introduce by 8 own au?ority a new feature into a sy/em :i* he _h no bus9ess to use at all1 & to d ?is = ! fir/ "t ) ! manife/ purpose ( annoy+ an obnoxi\s individual1 01 on ,dr4 ,hampd5's "p1 to d m to discr$it 8 *air & himself1 ?an ! c5sure ( ! ,univ]sity c\ld d2 & x 0 z unwise z x 0 unwor?y4 ,! /r5g? ( 8 own case be=e ! public 0 t he c\ld be made to appe> z ! victim ( a p]sonal & p>tisan attack2 yet on ! fir/ opportunity he acts 9 ! _s ( an inquisitor1 & t n 9 fair conflict ) "s "o wor?y ( 8 ho/ility1 b to wreak an injury1 9 a matt] ( private int]e/1 on an individual1 9 no way kn[n to him or oppos$ to him1 except z hold+ c]ta9 unpopul> op9ions4 ,mr4 ,macmull5 0 n ! p]son to take su* treatm5t quietly4 ,! "r 0 sub/antially on 8 side1 & ! ,pr(essor1 & ! ,univ]sity au?orities :o m or less play$ into ! h&s ( ! ,pr(essor 9 def5ce ( 8 illegal & ultimately unt5able claims1 appe>$ be=e ! ,univ]sity1 ! "o z a p]secutor1 ! o!rs z rul]s :o 7 afraid to d ju/ice on behalf ( an ill-us$ man because he 0 a ,tract>ian4 ,! "r c\rse 0 p]fectly cle>4 ,x 0 to put an end to ^! unau?oris$ ex]cises1 & to recall bo? c&idates & ,pr(essor to ! /atutable sy/em :i* impos$ disputations conduct$ "u ! mod]ator%ip ( ! ,pr(essor1 b :i* gave him no veto1 at ! "t1 on ! !ological suffici5cy ( ! disputations1 leav+ him to /ate 8 objections1 if he 0 n satisfi$1 :5 ! c&idate's degree 0 ask$ = 9 ! ,h\se ( ,congregation4 ,?is c\rse1 aft] "s hesitation1 0 foll[$1 b only p>tially2 & )\t all[+ or disall[+ ! ,pr(essor's claim to a veto1 ! ,vice-,*ancellor on 8 own responsibility /opp$ ! degree4 ,a vexati\s dispute l+]$ on = two or ?ree ye>s1 ) actions 9 ! ,vice-,*ancellor's ,c\rt1 & di/+ui%$ lawy]s to plead = ea* side1 & appeals to ! ,univ]sity ,c\rt ( ,delegates1 :o rev]s$ ! decision ( ! ,vice-,*ancellor's assessor4 ,someh[ or o!r1 ,mr4 ,macmull5 at la/ got 8 degree1 b at ! co/ ( a great deal ( ill-blood 9 ,ox=d1 = :i* ,dr4 ,hampd51 by 8 unw>rant$ int]f]5ce1 & ! ,univ]sity au?orities1 by _! que/ionable devices to save ! cr$it & claims ( "o ( _! own body1 mu/ be held ma9ly responsible4 ,be=e ! matt] 0 end$1 !y 7 made to feel1 9 r a />tl+ way1 h[ greatly !y _h lo/ ! confid5ce ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,"o ( ! attempts to f9d a way out ( ! tangle ( ! dispute 0 ! introduction1 9 ,febru>y #ahdd1 ( a ,/atute :i* %\ld give to ! ,pr(essor ! p[] :i* 0 n[ conte/$1 & practically place all ! ,div9ity degrees "u ! control ( a ,bo>d 9 conjunction ) ! ,vice-,*ancellor4#ajd ,! propos$ legislation rais$ su* indignation 9 ! ,univ]sity1 t ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d took back _! s*eme = fur!r revision1 & introduc$ x aga9 9 a modifi$ %ape1 :i* /ill h[ev] gave new p[]s to ! ,pr(essor & ! ,vice-,*ancellor4 ,b ! ,univ]sity w\ld h none ( x4 ,no "o c\ld say t ! defeat ( ! alt]$ ,/atute by #cda to #ba 0 ! "w m]ely ( a p>ty4#aje ,x 0 ! mo/ decisive vote giv5 9 ! c\rse ( ^! conflicts4 ,& x 0 obs]v$ t on ! same day ,mr4 ,macmull5's degree 0 veto$ by ! ,vice-,*ancellor at ! in/ance ( ,dr4 ,hampd5 at #aj o'clock 9 ,congregation1 & ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d1 :i* _h support$ him1 receiv$ ! vote ( want ( confid5ce at noon 9 ,convocation4 ,no?+ c\ld %[ m decisively t ! au?orities 9 ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d 7 out ( t\* ) ! feel+ ( ! ,univ]sity1 or1 at all ev5ts1 ( t "p ( x :i* 0 resid5t4 ,! resid5ts 7 n1 z a body1 id5tifi$ ) ! ,tract>ians2 x w\ld be m true to say t ! resid5ts1 z a body1 look$ on ?is m>k$ s*ool ) misgiv+ & appreh5sion2 b !y saw :at mann] ( m5 ^! ,tract>ians 72 !y liv$ ) !m 9 college & common-room2 _! behavi\r 0 be=e _! bre?r5 z a :ole1 ) its /r5g? & its weakness1 its moral elevation & its haz>d\s excitem5t1 its s9c]ity ( purpose & its "o-sid$ness ( judgm5t & sympa?y1 its unfairness to :at 0 ,engli%1 its ov]-value = :at 0 =eign4 ,types ( ^? :o look$ at ?+s m or less indep5d5tly 7 ,mr4 ,hussey ( ,*ri/ ,*ur*1 ,mr4 ,c4,p4 ,ed5 ( ,oriel1 ,mr4 ,sewell ( ,exet]1 ,mr4 ,francis ,fab] ( ,magdal51 ,dr4 ,gre5hill ( ,tr9ity1 ,mr4 ,wall ( ,balliol1 ,mr4 ,hobh\se ( ,m]ton1 ) "s ( ! m consi/5t ,lib]als1 l ,mr4 ,/anley ( ,univ]sity1 & latt]ly ,mr4 ,tait4 ,m5 ( ?is k9d1 m5 ( high "* & weight 9 ,ox=d1 f\nd mu* to dislike & regret 9 ! ,tract>ians4 ,b !y c\ld also see t ! lead]s ( ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d lab\r$ "u a fatal incapacity to recognise :at ^! unpopul> ,tract>ians 7 do+ = ! cause ( true & deep religion2 !y c\ld see t ! judgm5t ( ! ,heads ( ,h\ses1 liv+ z !y did ap>t1 9 a k9d ( sup]ior /ate1 0 n>r[1 ill-in=m$1 & h>%1 & t ! w>f>e :i* !y wag$ 0 petty1 irritat+1 & pr(itless2 :ile !y also saw ) great cle>ness t "u cov] ( suppress+ ,puseyism1 ! policy ( ! ,bo>d 01 9 fact1 t5d+ to increase & /r5g!n ! p[] ( an irresponsible & incompet5t olig>*y1 n only ov] a tr\blesome p>ty1 b ov] ! :ole body ( resid5ts4 ,to ! great hon\r ( ,ox=d x mu/ be said1 t ?r\gh\t ^! try+ times1 on to ! v end1 !re 0 9 ! body ( ,ma/]s a _s ( fairness1 a recognition ( ! =ce bo? ( argum5t & "*1 a dislike ( high-h&$ness & %abb9ess1 :i* 0 9 /rong & pa9ful contra/ to ! %ort-sight$ viol5ce 9 :i* ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d 0 unhappily induc$ to put _! tru/1 & :i* prov$ at la/ ! ma9 cause ( ! ov]?r[ ( _! p[]4 ,:5 *anges began to ?reat5 ,ox=d1 !re 0 no "o to say a ^w = !m4 ,b1 = ! mom5t1 9 spite ( ?is defeat 9 ,convocation1 !y _h no misgiv+s z to ! wisdom ( _! c\rse or ! =ce ( _! au?ority4 ,!re 01 no d\bt1 mu* urg+ f outside1 bo? on political & !ological gr\nds1 to make !m use _! p[] to /ay ! plague ( ,tract>ianism2 & !y 7 l$ by ?ree able & resolute m51 un=tunately unable to und]/& ! moral or ! intellectual "* ( ! movem5t1 & hav+ ! highe/ dislike & disda9 = x 9 bo? aspects--,dr4 ,hawk9s1 ,provo/ ( ,oriel1 ! la/ rema9+ disciple ( ,:ately's s*ool1 a man ( rigid consci5ti\sness1 & v g5u9e ?\gh undemon/rative piety1 ( great k9dl9ess 9 private life1 ( ke5 & al]t intellect1 b n ( bread? & k proportionate to 8 intellectual p[]2 ,dr4 ,symons1 ,w>d5 ( ,wadham1 a c\rage\s witness = ,evangelical div9ity 9 ! days :5 ,evangelicals 7 n 9 fa%ion 9 ,ox=d1 a man ( pond]\s & p$antic le>n+ & consid]able practical acut5ess2 & ,dr4 ,c>dwell1 ,pr9cipal ( ,/4 ,alban's ,hall1 m a man ( ! _w ?an 8 colleagues1 ) consid]able k ( portions ( ,engli% ,*ur* hi/ory4 ,"u ! inspiration ( ^! *iefs1 ! au?orities _h adopt$1 z f> z !y c\ld1 ! policy ( combat2 & ! ,vice-,*ancellor ( ! "t1 ,dr4 ,wynt] ( ,/4 ,john's1 a k9d-he>t$ man1 b q unfit to mod]ate among ! /rong wills & fi]ce temp]s r\nd him1 0 induc$ to s+le out = ! sev]e/ bl[ yet /ruck1 ! mo/ di/+ui%$ p]son 9 ! ranks ( ! movem5t1 ,dr4 ,pusey himself4 ,dr4 ,pusey 0 a p]son ) :om x 0 n wise to m$dle1 unless 8 assailants c\ld make out a case )\t a flaw4 ,he 0 )\t "q ! mo/ v5]at$ p]son 9 ,ox=d4 ,)\t an equal1 9 ,ox=d at lea/1 9 ! dep? & range ( 8 le>n+1 he /ood out yet m impressively among 8 fell[s 9 ! l(ty moral elevation & simplicity ( 8 life1 ! blamelessness ( 8 y\?1 & ! pr(\nd devotion ( 8 manhood1 to :i* ! family sorr[s ( 8 lat] ye>s1 & ! habits :i* grew out ( !m1 add$ a k9d ( pa!tic & solemn int]e/4 ,/]n & sev]e 9 8 tea*+ at "o "t1--at lea/ z he 0 und]/ood1--beyond ev5 ! sev]ity ( ,puritanism1 he 0 yet ov]fl[+ ) affection1 t5d] & sympa!tic to all :o came ne> him1 &1 9 ! mid/ ( cont9ual controv]sy1 he endeav\r$1 ) deep consci5ti\sness1 to avoid ! bitt]nesses ( controv]sy4 ,he 0 ! la/ man to attack2 mu* m ! la/ man to be unfair to4 ,! m5 :o rul$ 9 ,ox=d contriv$1 9 attack+ him1 to make almo/ e mi/ake :i* x 0 possible to make4 ,on ! #bd? ( ,may #ahdc ,dr4 ,pusey1 int5d+ to balance & complem5t ! sev]]1 &1 to _m1 ! disquiet+ aspects ( doctr9e 9 8 "w on ,baptism1 prea*$ on ! ,holy ,eu*>i/ z a com=t to ! p5it5t4 ,he spoke ( x z a disciple ( ,&rewes & ,bramhall w\ld speak ( x2 x 0 a high ,anglican s]mon1 full1 aft] ! example ( ! ,homilies1 ,j]emy ,taylor1 & devotional writ]s l ,george ,h]b]t & ,bi%op ,k51 ( ! f]vid language ( ! ,fa!rs2 & t 0 all4 ,beyond ?is x did n g2 its phraseology 0 /rictly )9 ,anglican limits4 ,9 ! c\rse ( ! week t foll[$1 ! ,univ]sity 0 surpris$ by ! ann\ncem5t t ,dr4 ,faussett1 ! ,m>g>et ,pr(essor ( ,div9ity1 _h delat$ ! s]mon to ! ,vice-,*ancellor z tea*+ h]esy2 & ev5 m surpris$ at ! news t ! ,vice-,*ancellor _h comm5c$ proce$+s4 ,! ,/atutes provid$ t :5 a s]mon 0 compla9$ (1 or delat$ to ! ,vice-,*ancellor1 ! ,vice-,*ancellor %\ld dem& a copy ( ! s]mon1 & summon+ to him z 8 assessors ,six ,doctors ( ,div9ity1 %\ld exam9e ! language compla9$ (1 &1 if necess>y1 condemn & puni% ! prea*]4 ,! ,/atute is ?us drawn up 9 g5]al t]ms1 & prescribes no?+ z to ! mode 9 :i* ! exam9ation into ! alleg$ (f5ce is to be c>ri$ on2 t is1 x leaves x to ! ,vice-,*ancellor's discretion4 ,:at happ5$ 0 ?is4 ,! s]mon 0 ask$ =1 b ! "n ( ! accus] 0 n giv52 ! ,/atute did n enjo9 x4 ,! s]mon 0 s5t1 ) a reque/ f ,dr4 ,pusey t he might h a he>+4 ,! ,six ,doctors 7 appo9t$1 five ( !m be+ ,dr4 ,hawk9s1 ,dr4 ,symons1 ,dr4 ,j5kyns1 ,dr4 ,ogilvie1 ,dr4 ,jelf2 ! ,/atute said ! ,regius ,pr(essor 01 if possible1 to be "o ( ! numb]2 z he 0 "u ! ban ( a special ,/atute1 he 0 sp>$ ! task1 & 8 place 0 tak5 by ! next ,div9ity ,pr(essor1 ,dr4 ,faussett1 ! p]son :o _h pref]r$ ! *>ge1 & :o 0 ?us1 f hav+ be5 accus]1 promot$ to be a judge4 ,to ,dr4 ,pusey's reque/ = a he>+1 no answ] 0 return$2 ! ,/atute1 no d\bt1 said no?+ ( a he>+4 ,b aft] ! delib]ations ( ! judges 7 conclud$1 & aft] ! decision to condemn ! s]mon _h be5 rea*$1 "o ( !m1 ,dr4 ,pusey's old fri5d1 ,dr4 ,jelf1 0 privately *>g$ ) c]ta9 communications f ! ,vice-,*ancellor1 on :i* ! seal ( absolute secrecy 0 impos$1 & :i*1 9 fact1 we believe1 h nev] be5 divulg$ f t day to ?is4 ,:atev] pass$ betwe5 ! ,vice-,*ancellor1 ,dr4 ,jelf1 & ,dr4 ,pusey1 x _h no effect 9 arre/+ ! s5t5ce2 & x came out1 9 in=mal ways1 & ?r\gh ,dr4 ,pusey himself1 t on ! #b;d ( ,june ,dr4 ,pusey _h be5 accus$ & condemn$ = hav+ taught doctr9e contr>y to t ( ! ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 & t by ! au?ority ( ! ,vice-,*ancellor he 0 susp5d$ f prea*+ )9 ! ,univ]sity = two ye>s4 ,b no =mal notification ( ! transaction 0 ev] made to ! ,univ]sity4 ,! summ>y suppression ( errone\s & dang]\s tea*+ _h long be5 a recognis$ "p ( ! ,univ]sity discipl9e2 & ) ! ideas !n accept$ ( ! religi\s "* ( ! ,univ]sity1 x 0 natural t "s su* p[] z t giv5 9 ! ,/atutes %\ld be provid$4 ,! p[]1 ev5 aft] all ! *anges 9 ,ox=d1 exi/s /ill1 & has be5 rec5tly appeal$ to4 ,dr4 ,pusey1 z a memb] ( ! ,univ]sity1 _h no m "r ?an any o!r prea*] to compla9 ( 8 doctr9e be+ ?us solemnly call$ 9 "q4 ,b x is /range t x %\ld n h occurr$ to ! au?orities t1 "u ! conditions ( mod]n times1 & aga9/ a man l ,dr4 ,pusey1 su* p[] %\ld be w>ily us$4 ,= x 0 n only arbitr>y p[]1 su* z 0 ex]t$ 9 ! condemnation ( ,no4 #ij1 b x 0 arbitr>y p[] act+ "u ! semblance ( a judicial inquiry1 ) accus]s1 exam9ation1 trial1 judges1 & a heavy p5alty4 ,! act ( a c\rt ( ju/ice :i* sets at defiance ! rules ( ju/ice is a v diff]5t ?+ f a /raight=w>d act ( arbitr>y p[]1 because x pret5ds to be :at x is n4 ,! in=mation aga9/ ,dr4 ,pusey1 if accept$1 involv$ a trial--t 0 ! fix$ condition & po9t ( dep>ture f :i* !re 0 no escap+--& if a trial be held1 !n1 if x be n a fair trial1 ! proce$+ becomes1 accord+ to ,engli% notions1 a flagrant & c[>dly wrong4 ,all ?is1 all ! intr9sic inju/ice1 all ! sc&al & discr$it 9 ! eyes ( hone/ m51 0 =gott5 9 ! ob/9ate & bl9d confid5ce 9 ! lett] ( a vague ,/atute4 ,! accus$ 0 n all[$ to def5d or expla9 himself2 he 0 refus$ ! k ( ! def9ite *>ges aga9/ him2 he 0 refus$1 9 spite ( 8 e>ne/ entreaties1 a he>+1 ev5 an appe>ance 9 ! pres5ce ( 8 judges4 ,! ,/atute1 x 0 said1 enjo9$ none ( ^! ?+s4 ,! "n ( 8 accus] 0 n told him2 he 0 left to le>n x by report ,to ! end ( ! bus9ess all 0 wr\ght 9 secrecy2 no "o kn[s to ?is day h[ ! exam9ation ( ! s]mon 0 conduct$1 or :at 7 ! op9ions ( ! judges4 ,! ,/atute1 x 0 said1 nei!r enjo9$ nor impli$ publicity4 ,to ?is day no "o kn[s :at 7 ! def9ite passages1 :at 0 ! express or necess>ily involv$ h]esy or contradiction ( ! =mul>ies1 on :i* ! condemnation 0 bas$2 nor--except on ! supposition ( gross ignorance ( ,engli% div9ity on ! "p ( ! judges--is x easy = a read] to put 8 f+] on ! probably incrim9at$ passages4 ,to make ! proce$+s /ill m unlike ord9>y public ju/ice1 in=mal & private communications 7 c>ri$ on betwe5 ! judge & ! accus$1 9 :i* ! accus$ 0 b\nd to absolute sil5ce1 & =bidd5 to consult 8 ne>e/ fri5ds4 ,& ( ! judges :at c be said b t !y 71 ) "o exception1 ! =emo/ & /]ne/ oppon5ts ( all t 0 id5tifi$ ) ,dr4 ,pusey's "n2 & t "o ( !m 0 ! colleague :o _h volunte]$ to accuse him8 ,dr4 ,faussett's %>e 9 ! matt] is intelligible2 hat+ ! movem5t 9 all its p>ts1 he /ruck ) ! vehem5ce ( a m$iaeval zealot4 ,b t m5 l ,dr4 ,hawk9s & ,dr4 ,ogilvie1 "o ( !m reput$ to be a !ologian1 ! o!r "o ( ! %rewde/ & mo/ cauti\s ( m51 & 9 ord9>y matt]s "o ( ! mo/ consci5ti\s & faire/1 %\ld n h se5 :at ju/ice1 or at lea/ ! %[ ( ju/ice1 dem&$1 & :at ! refusal ( t dem& w\ld look l1 & t !y %\ld h p]suad$ ! ,vice-,*ancellor to accept ! entire responsibility ( haughtily refus+ x1 is1 ev5 to ^? :o rememb] ! excitem5t ( ^? days1 a subject ( wond]4 ,! plea 0 actually put =? t su* opportunities ( def5ce ( 8 language & tea*+ z ,dr4 ,pusey ask$ = w\ld h l$ to ! inconv5i5ce ( an int]m9able debate1 & confront+ ( texts & au?orities4#ajf ,! fact1 ) ,dr4 ,pusey z ! accus$ p]son1 is likely en\gh2 b 9 a crim9al *>ge ) a heavy p5alty1 x w\ld h be5 bett] = ! reputation ( ! judges to h submitt$ to ! inconv5i5ce4 ,x 0 a great inju/ice & a great blund]--a blund]1 because ! gratuit\s defiance ( accept$ rules ( fairness neutralis$ :atev] !re might seem to be ( boldness & /r5g? 9 ! bl[4 ,!y 7 afraid to meet ,dr4 ,pusey face to face4 ,!y 7 afraid to publi% ! reasons ( _! condemnation4 ,! effect on ! ,univ]sity1 bo? on resid5t & non-resid5t memb]s1 0 n to be misund]/ood4 ,! ,prote/antism ( ! ,vice-,*ancellor & ! ,six ,doctors 01 ( c\rse1 extoll$ by p>tisans 9 ! press ) reckless ignorance & reckless contempt at once = common ju/ice & _! own consi/5cy4 ,"o p]son ( "s di/9ction at ,ox=d v5tur$ to make himself ! m\?piece ( ^? :o 7 bold en\gh to def5d ! proce$+--! rec5tly-elect$ ,pr(essor ( ,poetry1 ,mr4 ,g>bett4 ,b deep (f5ce 0 giv5 among ! wis] & m reasonable m5 :o _h a reg>d = ! "* ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,a reque/ to "k ! gr\nds ( ! s5t5ce f m5 :o 7 c]ta9ly ( no p>ty 0 curtly refus$ by ! ,vice-,*ancellor1 ) a sugge/ion t x did n conc]n !m4 ,a m important memorial 0 s5t f ,london1 %[+ h[ p]sons at a di/ance 7 %ock$ by ! unacc\ntable indiff]5ce to ! appe>ance ( ju/ice 9 ! proce$+4 ,x 0 sign$ among o!rs by ,mr4 ,glad/one & ,mr4 ,ju/ice ,col]idge4 ,! ,vice-,*ancellor lo/ 8 temp]4 ,he s5t back ! memorial to ,london by ! h&s ( 8 b$el1 z if t 9 "s way /amp$ 8 (ficial disapprobation m ?an if x _h be5 return$ ?r\gh ! po/4 ,& he proce$$1 9 language wond]ful ev5 = t mom5t1 z ,resid5t ,gov]nor ( ! ,univ]sity1 to reprim& /atesm5 & lawy]s ( em95ce & high "*1 n m]ely = presum+ to int]f]e ) 8 own duties1 b = =gett+ ! oa?s on ! /r5g? ( :i* !y _h receiv$ _! degrees1 & = com+ v ne> to t high1 almo/ highe/1 academical crime1 ! crime ( be+ p]turbatores pacis--break+ ! peace ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,su* fooli%ness1 affect+ dignity1 only made m to talk (4 ,if ! m5 :o rul$ ! ,univ]sity _h wi%$ to disgu/ & ali5ate ! ,ma/]s ( ,arts1 & especially ! y\ng] ones :o 7 com+ =w>d into p[] & influ5ce1 !y c\ld n h done bett]4 ,! *ronic jeal\sy & di/ru/ ( ! "t 7 deep5$4 ,& all ?is 0 aggravat$ by :at w5t on 9 private4 ,a sy/em ( espionage1 :isp]+s1 backbit+s1 & mis]able tittle-tattle1 sometimes ( ! mo/ sl&]\s or ! mo/ ridicul\s k9d1 0 set go+ all ov] ,ox=d4 ,nev] 9 ,ox=d1 be=e or s9ce1 7 busybodies m trucul5t or m unscrupul\s4 ,difficulties arose betwe5 ,heads ( ,colleges & _! tutors4 ,c&idates = fell[%ips 7 closely exam9$ z to _! op9ions & _! associates4 ,m5 apply+ = te/imonials 7 cross-que/ion$ on ,no4 #ij1 z to ! infallibility ( g5]al c\ncils1 purgatory1 ! wor%ip ( images1 ! ,ora pro nobis & ! int]cession ( ! sa9ts3 ! real critical que/ions ^u :i* m5's m9ds 7 work+ be+ absolutely uncompreh5d$ & ignor$4 ,x 0 a mis]able /ate ( misund]/&+ & di/ru/1 & none ( ! ,univ]sity lead]s _h ! temp] & ! manl9ess to endeav\r ) ju/ice & k to get to ! bottom ( x4 ,x 0 en\gh to suppose t a ,popi% ,conspiracy 0 be+ c>ri$ on4 ,,footnotes3 #aja ,pp4 #bdc1 #bec4 #ajb ,g>bett1 #iba4 ,williams1 #fbc4 #ajc ,! numb]s 7 #ccd to #bai4 #ajd ,*ri/ian ,remembranc]1 vol4 ix4 p4 #age4 #aje ,ibid4 pp4 #agg-agi4 #ajf ,cf4 ,briti% ,critic1 ,no4 xlvii4 pp4 #bba-bbc4 ,,*apt] ,,xvii ,w4,g4 ,,w>d ,if only ! ,ox=d au?orities c\ld h _h pati5ce--if only !y c\ld h kn[n m l>gely & m truly ! deep *anges t 7 at "w ev]y:]e1 & h[ ?+s 7 beg9n+ to look 9 ! eyes ( ! g5]ation t 0 com+1 p]haps _m ?+s might h be5 diff]5t4 ,yes1 x 0 true t !re 0 a /rong curr5t sett+ t[>ds ,rome4 ,x 0 act+ on "s ( ! mo/ vigor\s ( ! y\ng] m54 ,x 0 act+ p[]fully on ! =emo/ m9d 9 ,ox=d4 ,:i!r1 if n arre/$1 x 0 c>ry+ !m 0 cle>1 b z yet x 0 by no means cle> at :at rate2 & "t1 & ?\ght1 & be+ left alone & dealt ) ju/ly1 h a great effect on m5's m9ds4 ,extravagance1 disproportion1 mis*iev\s1 dang]\s exagg]ation1 9 mu* t 0 said & taught--all ?is might h settl$ d[n1 z s _m ?+s are 9 ! habit ( settl+ d[n1 into reasonable & practical %apes1 aft] a fir/ bur/ ( crud5ess & /ra9--z1 9 fact1 x did settle d[n at la/4 ,= ,anglicanism itself 0 n ,roman2 fri5ds & foes said x 0 n1 to reproa* z well z to def5d x4 ,x 0 n ,roman 9 ,dr4 ,pusey1 ?\gh he 0 n afraid to ackn[l$ge :at 0 good 9 ,rome4 ,x 0 n ,roman 9 ,mr4 ,keble & 8 fri5ds1 9 ,dr4 ,mob]ly ( ,w9*e/]1 & ! ,b>t]s4 ,x 0 n ,roman 9 ,mr4 ,isaac ,williams1 ,mr4 ,copel&1 & ,mr4 ,woodgate1 ea* ( !m a c5tre ( influ5ce 9 ,ox=d & ! c\ntry4 ,x 0 n ,roman 9 ! devot$ ,*>les ,m>riott1 or 9 ,isaac ,williams's able & le>n$ pupil1 ,mr4 ,ar?ur ,haddan4 ,x 0 n ,roman 9 ,mr4 ,james ,mozley1 aft] ,mr4 ,newman1 ! mo/ =cible & impressive ( ! ,ox=d writ]s4 ,a di/9ctively ,engli% p>ty grew up1 bo? 9 ,ox=d & away f x1 /rong 9 em95t names1 9 proportion z ,roman sympa?ies %[$ !mselves4 ,^! m5 71 9 any fair judgm5t1 z free f ,romanis+ z any ( _! accus]s2 b !y made _! appeal = pati5ce & fair judgm5t 9 va94 ,if only ! rul]s c\ld h _h pati5ce3--b pati5ce is a difficult virtue 9 ! pres5ce ( :at seem press+ dang]s4 ,_! policy 0 wrong1 /upid1 unju/1 p]nici\s4 ,x 0 a deplorable mi/ake1 & all w wi% n[ t ! discr$it ( x did n re/ on ! hi/ory ( ,ox=d4 ,& yet x 0 ! mi/ake ( upright & consci5ti\s m54 ,d\btless !re 0 dang]2 ! dang] 0 t a numb] ( m5 w\ld c]ta9ly n acquiesce mu* long] 9 ,anglicanism1 :ile ! ,heads cont9u$ absolutely bl9d to :at 0 really 9 ^! m5's ?\ghts4 ,= ! ,heads c\ld n conceive ! attraction :i* ! ,roman ,*ur* _h = a religi\s man2 !y talk$ 9 ! old-fa%ion$ way ab\t ! absurdity ( ! ,roman sy/em4 ,!y c\ld n und]/& h[ reasonable m5 c\ld turn ,roman ,ca?olics4 ,!y acc\nt$ = x by suppos+ a silly hank]+ aft] ! pomp or ! fripp]y ( ,roman ,ca?olic wor%ip1 & at be/ a crav+ aft] ! romantic & s5tim5tal4 ,_! ?\ghts dwelt cont9ually on image wor%ip & ! adoration ( sa9ts4 ,b :at really 0 a/ir 0 some?+ mu* deep]--some?+ mu* m ak9 to ! new & /rong =ces :i* 7 beg9n+ to act 9 v diff]5t directions f ?is 9 ,engli% society--=ces :i* 7 n only lead+ m9ds to ,rome1 b mak+ m5 ,utilit>ians1 ,rationali/s1 ,positivi/s1 &1 ?\gh ! ^w _h n yet be5 co9$1 ,agno/ics4 ,! m5 :o d\bt$ ab\t ! ,engli% ,*ur* saw 9 ,rome a /rong1 logical1 consi/5t !ory ( religion1 n ( ye/]day nor to-day--n only compreh5sive & pr(\nd1 b actually 9 full "w1 & fruitful 9 great results2 & ?is1 9 contra/ to ! alleg$ & und5iable anomalies & %ortcom+s ( ,prote/antism & ,anglicanism4 ,& next1 !re 0 ! imm5se am\nt :i* !y saw 9 ,rome ( self-d5ial & self-devotion2 ! surr5d] ( home & family 9 ! cl]gy2 ! great organis$ m9i/ry ( wom5 9 works ( m]cy2 ! resolute ab&onm5t ( ! _w & its attractions 9 ! religi\s life4 ,if 9 ,engl& !re fl\ri%$ ! homely & mode/ types ( goodness1 x 0 9 ,rome t1 at t day at lea/1 m5 mu/ look = ! h]oic4 ,!y 7 n indispos$ to ! idea t a true ,*ur* :i* _h lo/ all ?is might yet rega9 x1 & !y 7 will+ to wait & see :at ! ,engli% ,*ur* w\ld d to recov] :at x _h lo/2 b !re 0 obvi\sly a long way to make up1 & !y came to ?9k t !re 0 no *ance ( its ov]tak+ its true position4 ,( c\rse !y knew all t 0 s l\dly urg$ ab\t ! abuses & mis*iefs gr[+ out ( ! pr(ess$ sev]ity ( ,rome4 ,!y knew t 9 spite ( x =eign society 0 lax2 t ! discipl9e ( ! confessional 0 (t5 ex]cis$ ) a light re94 ,b if ! good side ( x 0 real1 !y easily acc\nt$ = ! bad3 ! bad did n de/roy1 x 0 a tacit witness to ! good4 ,& !y knew ! ,lat9 ,*ur* ma9ly f ,france1 :]e x 0 m 9 e>ne/1 & exhibit$ m moral life & intellectual activity1 ?an1 z f> z ,engli%m5 knew1 9 ,italy or ,spa94 ,!re 0 a /rong reb\nd f insul> ignorance & unfairness1 :5 ,engli% travell]s came on ! poorly-paid b (t5 intellig5t & h>d-work+ ,fr5* cl]gy2 on ! great works ( m]cy 9 ! t[ns2 on ! orig9ality & eloqu5ce ( ,de ,mai/re1 ,la ,m5nais1 ,lacordaire1 ,montalemb]t4 ,^! ideas took possession ( a rem>kable m9d1 ! index & organ ( a rem>kable "*4 ,mr4 ,w4,g4 ,w>d _h le>n$ ! int]e/ ( e>ne/ religion f ,dr4 ,arnold1 9 "p ?r\gh 8 close fri5d ,ar?ur ,/anley4 ,b if !re 0 ev] any t5d5cy 9 him to comb9e ) ! peculi> elem5ts ( ! ,rugby ,s*ool1 x 0 int]rupt$ 9 its nasc5t /ate1 z *emi/s speak1 by ! int]v5tion ( a /ill m pot5t aff9ity1 ! p]sonality ( ,mr4 ,newman4 ,mr4 ,w>d _h develop$ 9 ! ,ox=d ,union1 & 9 a wide social circle ( ! mo/ ris+ m5 ( ! "t--includ+ ,tait1 ,c>dwell1 ,l[e1 ,r\ndell ,palm]--a v unusual dialectical skill & p[] ( argum5tative /atem5t3 qualities :i* seem$ to po9t to ! ,h\se ( ,commons4 ,b ,mr4 ,newman's ideas gave him mat]ial1 n only = argum5t b = ?\ght4 ,! lectures & s]mons at ,/4 ,m>y's subdu$ & l$ him captive4 ,! impression produc$ on him 0 express$ 9 ! =mula t primitive ,*ri/ianity might h be5 corrupt$ into ,pop]y1 b t ,prote/antism nev] c\ld4#ajg ,= a mom5t he hung 9 ! w9d4 ,he might h be5 "o ( ! e>lie/ ( ,broad ,*ur*m54 ,he might h be5 a ,utilit>ian & ,necessit>ian foll[] ( ,mr4 ,j4,s4 ,mill4 ,b moral influ5ces ( a high] k9d prevail$4 ,& he became1 9 ! mo/ ?or\ghgo+ yet indep5d5t fa%ion1 a disciple ( ,mr4 ,newman4 ,he br\ght to 8 new side a fre% p[] ( controv]sial writ+2 b 8 *ief influ5ce 0 a social "o1 f 8 bright & attractive conv]sation1 8 bold & />tl+ c&\r1 8 frank1 n to say reckless1 fe>lessness ( consequ5ces1 8 unrivall$ skill 9 logical f5ce1 8 unfail+ good-hum\r & love ( fun1 9 :i* 8 p]sonal clums9ess set (f ! vivacity & nimbl5ess ( 8 joy\s moods4 ,he 01 says ,mr4 ,mozley1 a great musical critic1 knew all ! op]as1 & 0 an admirable buffo s+]4--,no "o c\ld d\bt t1 hav+ />t$1 ,mr4 ,w>d w\ld g f> & probably g fa/4 ,mr4 ,w>d 0 well kn[n 9 ,ox=d1 & 8 language might h w>n$ ! ,heads t if !re 0 a drift t[>ds ,rome1 x came f some?+ mu* m s]i\s ?an a hank]+ aft] a s5tim5tal ritual or m$iaeval leg5ds4 ,9 ,mr4 ,w>d's writ+s 9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 z 9 8 conv]sation--& he wrote mu* & at great l5g?--?ree ideas 7 manife/ly at ! bottom ( 8 attraction to ,rome4 ,"o 0 t ,rome did1 &1 he believ$1 no?+ else did1 keep up ! cont9u\s recognition ( ! sup]natural elem5t 9 religion1 t consci\sness ( an ev]-pres5t p[] n ( ?is _w :i* is s prom95t a feature 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t1 & :i* is spok5 ( !re z a p]man5t & *>act]i/ic elem5t 9 ! ,gospel disp5sation4 ,! ,roman view ( ! nature & (fices ( ! ,*ur*1 ( man's relations to ! unse5 _w1 ( devotion1 ( ! ,eu*>i/ & ( ! ,sacram5ts 9 g5]al1 assum$ & put =w>d ?is sup]natural aspect2 o!r sy/ems ignor$ x or made x mean no?+1 unless 9 secret to ! individual & conv]t$ s\l4 ,9 ! next place he revolt$--no weak] ^w c be us$--f ! popul> exhibition 9 ,engl&1 m or less ,lu!ran & ,calv9i/ic1 ( ! doctr9e ( ju/ification4 ,! o/5tati\s sep>ation ( ju/ification f morality1 ) all its !ological ref9em5ts & fictions1 seem$ to him pr(\ndly unscriptural1 pr(\ndly unreal & holl[1 or else pr(\ndly immoral4 ,9 consci5ce & moral hone/y & /rict ob$i5ce he saw ! only safe & tru/wor?y guidance 9 reg>d to ! *oice & =mation ( religi\s op9ions2 x 0 a pr9ciple on :i* all 8 philosophy 0 built1 t c>eful & individual moral discipl9e is ! only possible basis on :i* ,*ri/ian fai? & practice c be re>$4 ,9 ! ?ird place he 0 greatly affect$1 n m]ely by ! p>am\nt place ( sanctity 9 ! ,roman !ology & ! pr(ess$ ,roman sy/em1 b by ! /&>d ( sa9tl9ess :i* he f\nd !re1 involv+ complete & h]oic self-sacrifice = great religi\s ends1 complete ab&onm5t ( ! _w1 pa9ful & cont9u\s self-discipl9e1 purifi$ & exalt$ religi\s affections1 beside :i* ,engli% piety & goodness at its be/1 9 su* examples z ,george ,h]b]t & ,k5 & ,bi%op ,wilson1 seem$ unambiti\s & pale & tame1 ( a diff]5t ord] f ! ,roman1 & less closely resembl+ :at we read ( 9 ! fir/ ages & 9 ! ,new ,te/am5t4 ,:e!r su* views 7 "r or wrong1 exagg]at$ or unbalanc$1 accurate or sup]ficial1 !y 7 matt]s fit to int]e/ grave m52 b !re is no reason to ?9k t !y made ! slighte/ impression on ! au?orities ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,on ! o!r h&1 ,mr4 ,w>d1 ) ! greate/ good-hum\r1 0 unres]v$ly defiant & aggressive4 ,!re 0 some?+ intol]ably provok+ 9 8 mixture ( jaunt9ess & s]i\sness1 8 av[al ( utt] p]sonal unwor?9ess & 8 und\bt+ c]ta9ty ( be+ 9 ! "r1 8 d[nright *>ges ( h]esy & 8 ungrudg+ read9ess to make all[ance = ! h]etics & give !m cr$it = special virtues great] ?an ^? ( ! or?odox4 ,he 0 n a p]son to hide 8 own views or to let o!rs hide !irs4 ,he liv$ 9 an atmosph]e ( discussion ) all ar\nd him1 fri5ds or oppon5ts1 fell[s & tutors 9 common-rooms1 und]graduates aft] lecture or out walk+4 ,! mo/ amus+1 ! mo/ tol]ant man 9 ,ox=d1 he _h r\nd him p]petually "s ( ! clev]e/ & brighte/ s*ol>s & ?9k]s ( ! place2 & :]e he 01 !re 0 debate1 cross-que/ion+1 pu%+ inf]5ces1 />t+ al>m+ problems1 beat+ out ideas1 try+ ! /uff & mettle ( m5tal capacity4 ,n always ) real k1 or a real s5se ( fact1 b always rapid & impetu\s1 tak+ 9 ! :ole dialectical *ess-bo>d at a glance1 he gave no qu>t]1 & a man f\nd himself 9 a p]il\s corn] be=e he p]ceiv$ ! drift ( ! game2 b x 0 to cle> 8 own ?\ght1 n--= he 0 mu* too good-natur$--to emb>rass ano!r4 ,if ! old s*ola/ic disputations _h be5 /ill 9 use at ,ox=d1 8 triumphs w\ld h be5 signal & memorable4 ,8 success1 comp>$ ) t ( o!r lead]s ( ! movem5t1 9 influ5c+ life & judgm5t1 0 a pre-em95tly intellectual success2 & x cut two ways4 ,! /ress :i* he laid on ! moral side ( que/ions1 8 own g5]osity1 8 e>ne/ness on behalf ( fair play & good fai?1 elevat$ & purifi$ int]c\rse4 ,b he did n always w9 ass5t 9 proportion to 8 p[] ( argum5t4 ,ab/ract reason+1 9 matt]s ) :i* human action is conc]n$1 may be too absolute to be conv9c+4 ,x may n leave suffici5t m>g9 = ! play & int]f]5ce ( actual exp]i5ce4 ,& ,mr4 ,w>d1 hav+ p]fect confid5ce 9 8 conclusions1 r lik$ to leave !m 9 a />tl+ =m1 :i* he innoc5tly decl>$ to be manife/ & inevitable4 ,& s /ories ( ,w>d's audacity & p>adoxes flew all ov] ,ox=d1 %ock+ & p]plex+ grave heads ) fe> ( !y knew n :at4 ,dr4 ,j5kyns1 ! ,ma/] ( ,balliol1 "o ( ^? curi\s mixtures ( pomp\s absurdity ) g5u9e %rewdness :i* us$ to pass across ! ,univ]sity /age1 n clev] himself b an unfail+ judge ( a clev] man1 z a jockey might be ( a horse1 lik+ ,w>d & pr\d ( him = 8 clev]ness1 0 agha/ at 8 mon/r\s & un9telligible language1 & driv5 half wild ) x4 ,mr4 ,tait1 a fell[-tutor1 ?\gh liv+ on t]ms ( he>ty fri5d%ip ) ,w>d1 prevail$ on ! ,ma/] aft] ,no4 #ij to dismiss ,w>d f ! (fice ( tea*+ ma!matics4 ,x seem$ a petty /ep ?us to mix up !ology ) ma!matics1 ?\gh x 0 n s absurd z x look$1 = ,w>d br\ght 9 !ology ev]y:]e1 & discuss$ x :5 8 ma!matics 7 done4 ,b ,w>d accept$ x frankly & def5d$ x4 ,x 0 natural1 he said1 t ,tait1 ?9k+ 8 pr9ciples mis*iev\s1 %\ld wi% to sil5ce him z a tea*]2 & _! fri5d%ip rema9$ unbrok54 ,mr4 ,w>d's !ological position 0 really a provisional "o1 ?\gh1 at />t+ at lea/1 he w\ld n h all[$ x4 ,he _h no e>ly or traditional atta*m5t to ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 su* z t :i* act$ s /rongly on ! lead]s ( ! movem5t3 b he f\nd himself a memb] ( x1 & ,mr4 ,newman _h int]pret$ x to him4 ,he s accept$ x1 q loyally & 9 e>ne/1 z a po9t ( dep>ture4 ,b he proce$$ at once to put our ,*ur* 7z he call$ x7 on its trial1 9 comp>ison ) its own pr(essions1 & ) ! ideal /&>d ( a ,*ur* :i* he _h ?\ght out = himself2 & ?is rapidly l$ to grave consequ5ces4 ,he accept$ f au?ority :i* satisfi$ him bo? intellectually & morally ! ma9 s*eme ( ,ca?olic !ology1 z ! deepe/ & true/ philosophy ( religion1 satisfy+ at once consci5ce & intellect4 ,! ,ca?olic !ology gave him1 among o!r ?+s1 ! idea & ! notes ( ! ,*ur*2 ) ^!1 9 "p at lea/1 ! ,engli% ,*ur* agre$2 b 9 o!r respects1 & ^! v s]i\s ones1 x diff]$ widely2 x seem$ inconsi/5t & anomal\s4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 sep>ate & isolat$ f ,*ri/5dom4 ,x 0 suppos$ to diff] widely f o!r ,*ur*es 9 doctr9e4 ,x admitt$ v>iety ( op9ion & tea*+1 ev5 to ! po9t ( tol]at+ alleg$ h]esy4 ,) su* data z ^!1 he ent]$ on an inve/igation :i* ultimately came to ! "q :e!r ! ,engli% ,*ur* c\ld claim to be a "p ( ! ,*ur* ,ca?olic4 ,he po/ulat$ f ! fir/1 :at he aft]w>ds develop$ 9 ! book 9 :i* 8 ,anglican position culm9at$1--! fam\s ,ideal1--! exi/5ce at "s "t or ano!r ( a ,ca?olic ,*ur* :i* n only aim$ at1 b fulfill$ all ! conditions ( a p]fect ,*ur* 9 cre$1 communion1 discipl9e1 & life4 ,( c\rse ! ,engli% &1 z at />t+ he held1 ! ,roman ,*ur*1 fell f> %ort ( ?is p]fection4 ,b at />t+1 ! moral :i* he drew 01 n to leave ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 b to d 8 be/ to raise x up to :at x ought to be4 ,:e!r he took 9 all ! conditions ( ! problem1 :e!r x 0 n f> m complicat$ & difficult ?an he suppos$1 :e!r 8 k ( ! facts ( ! case 0 accurate & adequate1 :e!r he 0 always fair 9 8 comp>isons & judgm5ts1 & :e!r he did n ov]look elem5ts ( ! grave/ importance 9 ! inquiry2 :e!r1 9 fact1 save = c]ta9 /rong & broad l9es common to ! :ole hi/oric ,*ur*1 ! reign ( anomaly1 inconsi/5cy1 difficulty did n ext5d mu* f>!r ov] ! :ole field ( debate ?an he *ose to admit3 all ?is is fairly op5 to "q4 ,b )9 ! limits :i* he laid d[n1 & )9 :i* he conf9$ 8 reason+s1 he us$ 8 mat]ials ) skill & =ce2 & ev5 ^? :o lea/ agre$ ) him & 7 mo/ s5sible ( ! /rong & h>dly disguis$ bias :i* s greatly affect$ ! value ( 8 judgm5ts1 c\ld n d5y ! frankness & ! desire to be fair & c&id1 ) :i*1 z f> z int5tion w5t1 he conduct$ 8 argum5t4 ,8 fir/ appe>ance z a writ] 0 9 ! controv]sy1 z has be5 said be=e1 on ! subject ( ,no4 #ij4 ,t tract _h made ! well-worn di/9ction betwe5 :at 0 ,ca?olic & :at 0 di/9ctively ,roman1 & _h urg$--:at _h be5 urg$ ov] & ov] aga9 by ,engli% div9es--t ! ,articles1 9 _! condemnation ( :at 0 ,roman1 7 drawn 9 su* a way z to leave unt\*$ :at 0 unque/ionably ,ca?olic4 ,!y 7 drawn inde$ by ,prote/ants1 b by m5 :o also e>ne/ly pr(ess$ to hold ) ! old ,ca?olic doctors & disav[$ any purpose to dep>t f _! tea*+1 & :o fur!r _h to meet ! views & ga9 ! ass5t ( m5 :o 7 mu* less ,prote/ant ?an !mselves--m5 :o 7 will+ to break ) ! ,pope & condemn ! abuses associat$ ) 8 "n1 b by no means will+ to break ) ! old !ology4 ,! ,articles 7 ! natural result ( a compromise betwe5 two /rong p>ties--! ,ca?olics agree+ t ! abuses %\ld be condemn$1 s t ! ,ca?olic doctr9e 0 n t\*$2 ! ,prote/ants insi/+ t1 s t ! ,ca?olic doctr9e 0 n t\*$1 ! abuses ( x %\ld be d5\nc$ ) great sev]ity3 t !re %\ld be no "q ab\t ! condemnation ( ! abuses1 & ( ! sy/em :i* _h ma9ta9$ !m4 ,! ,articles 7 und\bt$ly anti-,roman2 t 0 obvi\s f ! hi/orical position ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 :i* 9 a v real s5se 0 anti-,roman2 b 7 !y s anti-,roman z to exclude doctr9es :i* ,engli% div9es _h ov] & ov] aga9 ma9ta9$ z ,ca?olic & di/+ui%$ f ,romanism1 b :i* ! popul> op9ion1 at ?is "t or t1 id5tifi$ !re)8#ajh ,) flagrant ignorance--ignorance ( ! hi/ory ( ?\ght & tea*+ 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ignorance f> m inexcusable ( ! /ate ( p>ties & _! sev]al notori\s difficulties 9 relation to ! v>i\s =mul>ies ( ! ,*ur*1 x 0 ma9ta9$ on ! o!r side t ! ,articles con/ru$ by !mselves left no d\bt t !y 7 n only anti-,roman b anti-,ca?olic1 & t no?+ b ! grosse/ di%one/y & immorality c\ld all[ any d\bt on ! subject4 ,nei!r e/imate 0 logical en\gh to satisfy ,mr4 ,w>d4 ,! *>ge ( ins9c]ity1 he retort$ ) great effect on ^? :o made x3 if words meant any?+1 ! ,ord9ation ,s]vice1 ! ,visitation ,s]vice1 & ! ,baptismal ,s]vice 7 f> great] difficulties to ,evangelicals1 & to ,latitud9>ians l ,:ately & ,hampd51 ?an ! words ( any ,article c\ld be to ,ca?olics2 & !re 0 besides ! tone ( ! :ole ,pray] ,book1 intelligible1 cong5ial1 on ,ca?olic assumptions1 & on no o!r4 ,b z to ! ,articles !mselves1 he 0 indispos$ to accept ! def5ce made = !m4 ,he criticis$ inde$ ) acut5ess & sev]ity ! attempt to make ! loose language ( _m ( !m intol]ant ( primitive doctr9e2 b he frankly accept$ ! allegation t ap>t f ?is or t explanation1 _! g5]al look1 z reg>ds lat] controv]sies1 0 visibly aga9/1 n only ,roman doctr9es or ,roman abuses1 b t :ole sy/em ( pr9ciples & mode ( view+ religion :i* he call$ ,ca?olic4 ,!y 71 he said1 pati5t ( a ,ca?olic mean+1 b ambiti\s ( a ,prote/ant mean+2 :atev] _! logic 01 _! rhetoric 0 ,prote/ant4 ,x 0 j possible1 b n m1 = a ,ca?olic to subscribe to !m4 ,b !y 7 ! creation & ! legacy ( a bad age1 & ?\gh !y _h n ext+ui%$ ,ca?olic tea*+ & ,ca?olic belief 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 !y _h be5 a s]i\s h9drance to x1 & a support to its oppon5ts4 ,?is 0 go+ beyond ! position ( ,no4 #ij4 ,no4 #ij _h made light ( ! difficulties ( ! ,articles4 ,t !re are real difficulties to a ,ca?olic ,*ri/ian 9 ! ecclesia/ical position ( our ,*ur* at ?is day1 no "o c d5y2 b ! /atem5ts ( ! ,articles are n 9 ! numb]4 ,our pres5t scope is m]ely to %[ t1 :ile our ,pray] ,book is ackn[l$g$ on all h&s to be ( ,ca?olic orig91 our ,articles also--! (fspr+ ( an unca?olic age--are1 ?r\gh ,god's good provid5ce1 to say ! lea/1 n unca?olic1 & may be subscrib$ by ^? :o aim at be+ ,ca?olic 9 he>t & doctr9e4 ,mr4 ,w>d n only w5t beyond ?is position1 b 9 ! tee? ( ^! /atem5ts2 & he gave a new aspect & new issues to ! :ole controv]sy4 ,! ,articles1 to him1 7 a difficulty1 :i* !y 7 n to ! writ] ( ,no4 #ij1 or to ,dr4 ,pusey1 or to ,mr4 ,keble4 ,to him !y 7 n only ! (fspr+ ( an unca?olic age1 b 9 !mselves unca?olic2 & 8 answ] to ! *>ge ( di%one/ subscription 01 n t ! ,articles 9 _! natural mean+ are ,ca?olic1#aji b t ! sy/em ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* is a compromise betwe5 :at is ,ca?olic & :at is ,prote/ant1 & t ! ,prote/ant p>ties 9 x are involv$ 9 ev5 great] difficulties1 9 relation to subscription & use ( its =mul>ies1 ?an ! ,ca?olic4 ,he admitt$ t he did evade ! _s1 b accept$ ! /atem5ts ( ! ,articles1 ma9ta9+ t ?is 0 ! int5tion ( _! orig9al sanction]s4 ,) *>act]i/ic boldness1 inv5t+ a phrase :i* has become fam\s1 he wrote3 ,our twelf? ,article is z pla9 z words c make x on ! ,evangelical side2 ( c\rse ,i ?9k its natural mean+ may be expla9$ away1 = ,i subscribe x myself 9 a non-natural s5se3#aaj b he %[$ t ,evangelicals1 high *ur* ,anglicans1 & ,latitud9>ians 7 equally oblig$ to h rec\rse to explanations1 :i* to all b !mselves 7 unsatisfactory4 ,b he w5t a /ep beyond ?is4 ,hi!rto ! di/9ction _h be5 uni=mly insi/$ ^u betwe5 :at 0 ,ca?olic & :at 0 ,roman2 betwe5 :at 0 witness$ to by ! primitive & ! undivid$ ,*ur*1 & :at _h be5 develop$ beyond t 9 ! ,s*ools1 & by ! def9itions & decisions ( ,rome1 & 9 ! enorm\s mass ( its po/-,re=mation !ology1 at once s compreh5sive1 & s m9ute 9 application4 ,?is di/9ction 0 ! f\ndation ( :at 01 *>act]i/ically1 ,anglican !ology1 f ,hook] d[nw>ds4 ,?is di/9ction1 at lea/ = all important purposes1 ,mr4 ,w>d gradually gave up4 ,x 0 to a c]ta9 degree recognis$ 9 8 e>ly controv]sy ab\t ,no4 #ij2 b x gradually grew fa9t] till at la/ x av[$ly disappe>$4 ,! ,anglican writ]s _h drawn _! ideas & _! inspiration f ! ,fa!rs2 ! ,fa!rs liv$ long ago1 & ! tea*+ drawn f !m1 h[ev] spiritual & l(ty1 want$ ! mod]n look1 & seem$ to recognise insuffici5tly mod]n ne$s4 ,! ,roman applications ( ! same pr9ciples 7 def9ite & practical1 & ,mr4 ,w>d's m9d1 ess5tially "o ( 8 own c5tury1 & little alive to :at t\*$ m imag9ative & s5sitive m9ds1 turn$ at once to ,roman s\rces = ! int]pretation ( :at 0 ,ca?olic4 ,9 ! ,briti% ,critic1 & /ill m 9 ! rem>kable volume 9 :i* 8 ,ox=d controv]sies culm9at$1 ! sub/itution ( ,roman = ! old conception ( ,ca?olic appe>s1 & ! absolute id5tification ( ,roman ) ,ca?olic4 ,roman au?orities become m & m ! measure & rule ( :at is ,ca?olic4 ,!y belong to ! pres5t 9 a way 9 :i* ! old] f\nta9s ( tea*+ d n2 9 ! recognis$ tea*+ ( ! ,lat9 ,*ur*1 !y h tak5 _! place & sup]s$$ !m4 ,x 0 *>act]i/ic ( ,mr4 ,w>d t 8 *ief qu>rel ) ! ,articles 0 n ab\t ! ,sacram5ts1 n ab\t _! language on alleg$ ,roman errors1 b ab\t ! doctr9e ( grace1 ! relation ( ! s\l ( man to ! law1 ! =giv5ess1 ! hol9ess ( ,god1--! doctr9e1 t is1 9 all its be>+s1 ( ju/ification4 ,mr4 ,newman _h exam9$ ?is doctr9e & ! v>i\s language held ab\t x ) great c>e1 v firmly b v temp]ately1 & _h attempt$ to reconcile ) ea* o!r all b ! extreme ,lu!ran /atem5ts4 ,x 01 he said1 among really religi\s m51 a "q ( words4 ,he _h recognis$ ! faulty /ate ( ?+s 9 ! pre-,re=mation ,*ur*1 ! faulty ideas ab\t =giv5ess1 m]it1 grace1 & works1 f :i* ! ,prote/ant language 0 a reaction1 natural1 if (t5 excessive2 & 9 ! ,engli% au?oritative =m ( ?is language1 he _h f\nd no?+ b :at 0 p]fectly capable ( a s\nd & true mean+4 ,f ! fir/1 ,mr4 ,w>d's judgm5t 0 f> m sev]e ?an ?is4 ,to him1 ! :ole /ructure ( ! ,articles on ,ju/ification & ! doctr9es connect$ ) x seem$ bas$ on ! ,lu!ran !ory1 & = ?is !ory1 z fundam5tally & hopelessly immoral1 he c\ld n f9d words suffici5tly expressive ( dete/ation & loa?+4 ,= ! basis ( 8 own !ory ( religi\s k 0 a moral basis2 m5 came to ! k ( religi\s tru? prim>ily n by ! intellect1 b by absolute & unfail+ loyalty to consci5ce & moral light2 & a doctr9e :i* sep>at$ fai? f morality & hol9ess1 :i* made man's highe/ good & 8 acceptance ) ,god indep5d5t ( :at he 0 z a moral ag5t1 :i* relegat$ ! realities ( moral discipl9e & goodness to a second>y & subord9ate place1--z a m]e sequel to foll[1 almo/ me*anically & ( c\rse1 on an act or feel+ :i* _h no?+ moral 9 x1--:i* sub/itut$ a fictiti\s & imput$ righte\sness = an inh]5t & infus$ & real "o1 seem$ to him to conf\nd ! et]nal f\ndations ( "r & wrong1 & to be a blasphemy aga9/ all t 0 true & sacr$ 9 religion4 ,( ! ,lu!ran doctr9e#aaa ( ju/ification1 & ! pr9ciple ( private judgm5t1 ,i h argu$ t1 9 _! ab/ract nature & necess>y t5d5cy1 !y s9k bel[ a!ism itself4444 ,a religi\s p]son :o %all be suffici5tly cle>-head$ to und]/& ! mean+ ( words1 is w>rant$ 9 reject+ ,lu!ranism on ! v same gr\nds :i* w\ld induce him to reject a!ism1 viz4 z be+ ! contradiction ( tru?s :i* he feels on mo/ c]ta9 gr\nds to be fir/ pr9ciples4#aab ,!re is no?+ :i* he looks back on ) s mu* satisfaction 9 8 writ+s z on ?is1 t he has v5tur$ to *>act]ise t hateful & fe>ful type ( ,anti*ri/ 9 t]ms n :olly inadequate to its prodigi\s dem]its4#aac ,mr4 ,w>d _h />t$ ) a v def9ite idea ( ! ,*ur* & ( its notes & te/s4 ,x 0 obvi\s t ! ,anglican ,*ur*--& s1 x 0 ?\ght1 ! ,roman--fail$ to satisfy ^! notes 9 _! complet5ess2 b x seem$1 at lea/ at fir/1 to satisfy "s ( !m1 & to d ?is s rem>kably1 & 9 su* /rong contra/ to o!r religi\s bodies1 t 9 ,engl& at all ev5ts x seem$ ! true repres5tative & bran* ( ! ,*ur* ,ca?olic2 & ! duty ( adh]+ to x & s]v+ x 0 fully recognis$1 ev5 by ^? :o mo/ felt its app>5t dep>ture f ! m ,ca?olic pr9ciples & temp] pres]v$ 9 _m po9ts by ! ,roman ,*ur*4 ,f ?is po9t ( view ,mr4 ,w>d av[$ly began4 ,b ! position gradually gave way be=e 8 rel5tless & dissolv+ logic4 ,! :ole c\rse ( 8 writ+ 9 ! ,briti% ,critic may be said to h consi/$ 9 a prolong$ & disp>ag+ comp>ison ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 9 !ory1 9 doctr9e1 9 moral & devotional temp]1 9 discipl9e ( "*1 9 education1 9 its public & au?oritative tone 9 reg>d to social1 political1 & moral que/ions1 & 9 ! type & /&>d ( its cl]gy1 ) ^? ( ! ,ca?olic ,*ur*1 :i* to him 0 repres5t$ by ! m$iaeval & lat] ,roman ,*ur*4 ,& 9 ! g5]al result1 & 9 all important matt]s1 ! comp>ison became m & m fatally disadvantage\s to ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,9 ! p]plex+ condition ( ,*ri/5dom1 x _h j en\gh good & promise to ju/ify ^? :o _h be5 br\ght up 9 x rema9+ :]e !y 71 z long z !y saw any prospect ( improv+ x1 & till !y 7 driv5 out4 ,t 0 a duty--uncom=table & ?ankless z x 01 & op5 to any am\nt ( miscon/ruction & misrepres5tation--:i* !y ow$ to _! bre?r51 & to ! ,"l ( ! ,*ur*4 ,b x involv$ pla9 speak+ & its consequ5ces2 & ,mr4 ,w>d nev] %rank f ei!r4 ,mo/ p1 look+ back1 w\ld probably agree1 :atev] _! g5]al judgm5t on ^! matt]s1 & :atev] !y may ?9k ( ,mr4 ,w>d's case1 t he 01 at ! "t at lea/1 ! mo/ unp]suasive ( writ]s4 ,consid]+ 8 great acut5ess1 & ! frequ5t orig9ality ( 8 rem>ks--consid]+1 fur!r1 8 moral e>ne/ness1 & ! place :i* ! moral aspects ( ?+s occupy 9 8 ?\ghts1 ?is is rem>kable2 b s x is4 ,9 ! fir/ place1 9 deal+ ) ^! ev5tful que/ions1 :i* came home ) su* awful =ce to ?\s&s ( awak5$ m9ds & consci5ces1 full ( hope & full ( fe>1 !re 0 an entire & o/5tati\s want ( sympa?y ) all t 0 *>act]i/ically ,engli% 9 matt]s ( religion4 ,?is arose p>tly f 8 deep dislike to habits1 v m>k$ 9 ,engli%m51 b n peculi> to !m1 ( self-satisfaction & national self-glorification2 b x drove him into a welcom+ ( opposite =eign ways1 ( :i* he really knew little1 except sup]ficially4 ,next1 8 b\ndless confid5ce 9 ! accuracy ( 8 logical processes l$ him to habits ( extreme & absolute /atem5t1 :i* to ^? :o did n agree ) him1 & also to "s :o did1 bore on _! face ! "* ( ov]-/atem5t1 exagg]ation1 extravagance1 n r$eem$ by an occasional & some:at o/5tati\s c&\r1 (t5 at ! exp5se ( 8 own side & 9 fav\r ( oppon5ts to :om he c\ld af=d to be frank4 ,& fur!r1 :ile to ! ,engli% ,*ur* he 0 m]ciless 9 ! se>*+ sev]ity ( 8 judgm5t1 he seem$ to be bl9d to ! :ole condition ( ?+s to :i* %e1 z well z h] rival1 _h = ! la/ ?ree c5turies be5 subject$1 & 9 :i* %e _h play$ a "p at lea/ z important = ,*ri/ian fai? z t su/a9$ by any portion ( ,*ri/5dom2 bl9d to all h] special & *>act]i/ic excell5ces1 :]e ^! did n fit ! patt]n ( ! cont95tal types 7obvi\sly1 9 c\ntless in/ances1 matt]s ( national & local "* & habits72 bl9d to ! enorm\s difficulties 9 :i* ! political game ( h] ,roman oppon5ts _h plac$ h]2 bl9d to ! fact t1 judg$ ) ! same adv]se bias & prepossessions1 ! same unsp>+ rig\r1 ! same refusal to give real weight to :at 0 good1 on ! gr\nd t x 0 mix$ ) some?+ l[]1 ! ,roman ,*ur* w\ld %[ j z mu* deflection f ! ideal z ! ,engli%4 ,inde$1 he w\ld h done a great s]vice--p w\ld h be5 f> m dispos$ to att5d to 8 really int]e/+1 &1 to ,engli% read]s1 novel1 pro(s ( ! moral & devotional "* ( ! ,roman popul> discipl9e1 if he _h n be5 s unfair on ! ,engli%3 if he _h n ignor$ ! pla9 fact t j su* a picture z he gave ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 z fail+ 9 requir$ notes1 might be f\nd ( ! ,roman be=e ! ,re=mation1 say 9 ! writ+s ( ,g]son1 & 9 our own days 9 ^? ( ,rosm9i4 ,mr4 ,w>d1 if any "o1 appeal$ to fair judgm5t2 & to ?is fair judgm5t he pres5t$ allegations on ! face ( !m viol5t & mon/r\s4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur*1 accord+ to him1 0 9 ! anomal\s position ( be+ gift$ ) ! p[] ( disp5s+ sacram5tal grace1#aad & yet1 at ! same "t1 :olly de/itute ( ext]nal notes1 & :olly indef5sible z to h] position1 by ext]nal1 hi/orical1 ecclesia/ical argum5ts3 & he = 8 "p decl>es1 correct+ ,mr4 ,newman1 :o speaks ( outw>d notes z p>tly gone & p>tly go+1 t he is :olly unable to disc]n ! outw>d notes ( :i* ,mr4 ,newman speaks1 dur+ any "p ( ! la/ ?ree hundr$ ye>s4 ,he might z well h said at once t %e did n exi/1 if ! outw>d aspects ( a ,*ur*--ord]s1 cre$s1 sacram5ts1 &1 9 "s degree at any rate1 prea*+ & witness+ = righte\sness--are n "s ( ! outw>d notes ( a ,*ur*4 ,%\ld ! pure light ( ! ,gospel be ev] re/or$ to ?is b5ight$ l&1#aae he writes1 at ! beg9n+1 z ! la/ extract 0 writt5 at ! end1 ( 8 controv]sial c>e] at ,ox=d4 ,is n su* writ+ z if he wi%$ to emulate 9 a rev]se s5se ! folly & falsehood ( ^? :o spoke ( ,engli% ,prote/ants hav+ a monopoly ( ! ,gospel8 ,he 0 unp]suasive1 he irritat$ & repell$1 9 spite ( 8 wi% to be fair & c&id1 9 spite ( hav+ s mu* to tea*1 9 spite ( su* vig\r ( /atem5t & argum5t1 because on ! face ( all 8 writ+s he 0 s extravagantly "o-sid$1 s incapable ( an equitable view1 s mu* a slave to ! unreality ( extremes4 ,,footnotes3 #ajg ,cf4 ,t4 ,mozley1 ,rem9isc5ces1 vol4 ii4 p4 #e4 #ajh ,9 deal+ ) ! ,articles ei!r z a te/ or z a text-book1 ?is "q 0 manife/ly bo? an hone/ & a reasonable "o4 ,z a te/1 & !re=e p5al1 !y mu/ be con/ru$ /rictly2 l judicial decisions1 !y only rul$ z mu* z 0 necess>y1 & 9 ! wide field ( !ology conf9$ !mselves to ! po9ts at issue at ! mom5t4 ,& z a text-book = in/ruction1 x 0 obvi\s t :ile on "s po9ts !y 7 precise & cle>1 on o!rs !y 7 vague & imp]fect4 ,! fir/ five ,articles left no room = d\bt4 ,:5 ! compil]s came to ! controv]sies ( _! day1 = all _! /rong language1 !y left all k9ds ( que/ions unansw]$4 ,= in/ance1 !y actually left unnotic$ ! primacy1 & mu* m ! infallibility ( ! ,pope4 ,!y condemn$ ! sacrifices ( ,masses--did !y condemn ! anci5t & univ]sal doctr9e ( a ,eu*>i/ic sacrifice8 ,!y condemn$ ! ,romi% doctr9e ( ,purgatory1 ) its popul> t5et ( mat]ial fire--did t exclude e doctr9e ( purgation aft] dea?8 ,!y condemn$ ,transub/antiation--did !y condemn ! ,real ,pres5ce8 ,!y condemn$ a great popul> sy/em--did !y condemn t ( :i* x 0 a corruption & trave/y8 ,^! que/ions c\ld n be =eclos$1 unless on ! assumption t !re 0 no doctr9e on su* po9ts :i* c\ld be call$ ,ca?olic except ! ,roman4 ,! inquiry 0 n new2 & div9es s /\tly anti-,roman z ,dr4 ,hook & ,mr4 ,w4 ,palm] ( ,worce/] _h answ]$ x sub/antially 9 ! same s5se z ,mr4 ,newman 9 ,no4 #ij4 #aji ,w4,g4 ,w>d1 ,! ,ideal ( a ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1 p4 #dgh4 #aaj ,! ,ideal1 etc41 p4 #dgi4 #aaa ,x is curi\s1 & *>act]i/ic ( ! unhi/orical quality ( ,mr4 ,w>d's m9d1 t 8 :ole ho/ility %\ld h be5 conc5trat$ on ,lu!r & ,lu!ranism--on ,lu!r1 ! en?usia/ic1 declamatory1 unsy/ematic d5\nc] ( practical abuses1 ) 8 /rong atta*m5ts to portions ( or?odoxy1 r ?an on ,calv91 ) 8 cold love ( p[]1 & ! iron consi/5cy & /r5g? ( 8 logical anti-,ca?olic sy/em1 :i* has really liv$ & m\ld$ ,prote/antism1 :ile ,lu!ranism z a religion has pass$ into c\ntless diff]5t =ms4 ,lu!r 0 to ,calv9 z ,c>lyle to ,j4,s4 ,mill or ,h]b]t ,sp5c]2 he defi$ sy/em4 ,b ,lu!r _h bur/ into outrage\s p>adoxes1 :i* fa/5$ on ,mr4 ,w>d's imag9ation4--,yet outrage\s language is n always ! mo/ dang]\s4 ,nobody w\ld really f9d a provocation to s91 or an excuse = x1 9 ,lu!r's ,pecca =tit] any m ?an 9 ,escob>'s ridicul\s casui/ry4 ,!re may be mu* m mis*ief 9 ! delicate unrealities ( a fa%ionable prea*]1 or 9 _m a smoo? s5tim5tal treatise on ! religi\s affections4 #aab ,! ,ideal1 etc41 pp4 #ehg1 #cje4 #aac ,ibid4 p4 #cje4 #aad ,ideal1 p #bhf4 #aae ,briti% ,critic ,octob] #ahda1 p4 #cdj4 ,,*apt] ,,xviii ,,! ,,ideal ,,( ,a ,,*ri/ian ,,*ur* ,no4 #ij1 ) ! explanations ( x giv5 by ,mr4 ,newman & ! o!r lead]s ( ! movem5t1 might h rais$ an important & n v easy "q1 b "o 9 no way diff]5t f ! g5]al "* ( ! matt]s 9 debate 9 ! !ological controv]sy ( ! "t4 ,b ,no4 #ij1 ) ! comm5ts on x ( ,mr4 ,w>d1 0 q ano!r matt]1 & f9ally broke up ! p>ty ( ! movem5t4 ,x 0 "o ?+ to %[ h[ mu* !re is 9 common betwe5 ,engl& & ,rome1 & q ano!r to argue t !re is no diff]5ce4 ,mr4 ,w>d's refusal to all[ a reasonable & a ,ca?olic int]pretation to ! doctr9e ( ! ,articles on ,ju/ification1 ?\gh su* an und]/&+ ( x _h n only be5 ma9ta9$ by ,bi%op ,bull & ! lat] or?odox div9es1 b 0 impress$ on all ! popul> books ( devotion1 su* z ! ,:ole ,duty ( ,man & ,bi%op ,wilson's ,sacra ,privata2 & along ) ?is1 ! extreme claim to hold compatible ) ! ,articles ! :ole cycle ( ,roman doctr9e1 introduc$ entirely new conditions into ! :ole "q4 ,non hoec 9 fo$]a 0 ! natural reflection ( numb]s ( ^? :o mo/ sympa?is$ ) ! ,tract>ian s*ool4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur* might h _m %ortcom+s & want _m improvem5ts2 b aft] all %e _h some?+ to say = h]self 9 h] qu>rel ) ,rome2 & ! witness ( exp]i5ce = fifte5 hundr$ ye>s mu/ be n m]ely qualifi$ & correct$1 b absolutely wip$ out1 if ! allegation 7 to be accept$ t ,rome 0 blameless 9 all t qu>rel1 & _h no "p 9 br++ ab\t ! confusions ( ,*ri/5dom4 ,& ?is cont5tion 0 m & m en=c$ 9 ,mr4 ,w>d's articles 9 ! ,briti% ,critic--en=c$1 m effectively ?an by direct /atem5t1 by cont9ual & pass+ assumption & implication4 ,!y 7 pap]s ( consid]able p[] & acut5ess1 & ( great e>ne/ness 9 _! con/ant appeal to ! moral crit]ia ( tru?2 ?\gh ,mr4 ,w>d 0 n !n at 8 be/ z a writ]1 & !y 7 9 composition heavy1 diffuse1 monoton\s1 & we>isome4 ,b ! attitude ( deep depreciation1 /eady1 sy/ematic1 unreliev$1 9 reg>d to t :i* ought1 if ackn[l$g$ at all1 to des]ve ! highe/ rev]5ce among all ?+s on e>?1 9 reg>d to an in/itution :i*1 ) :atev] faults1 he himself 9 words /ill recognis$ z ! ,*ur* ( ,god1 0 an indef5sible & an un:olesome p>adox4 ,! analogy is a commonly accept$ "o betwe5 ! ,*ur* & ! family4 ,h[ c\ld any h\sehold g on 9 :i* !re 0 at "w an animus ( unceas+ & rel5tless1 ?\gh possibly too j criticism1 on its *>act]i/ic & p]haps s]i\s faults2 & ( comp>isons1 also possibly mo/ j1 ) ! bett] ways ( o!r families8 ,x might be ! hone/ desire ( re=m & improvem5t2 b *>ity1 pati5ce1 equitabl5ess1 are virtues ( m5 9 society1 z well z /rict ju/ice & ! desire ( improvem5t4 ,9 ! case ( ! family1 su* action c\ld only lead to daily mis]y & ! wa/+ & dy+ out ( home affections4 ,9 ! case ( a ,*ur*1 x mu/ come to ! sund]+ ( ties :i* ought no long] to b9d4 ,mr4 ,w>d all along insi/$ t !re 0 no necessity = look+ =w>d to su* an ev5t4 ,he wi%$ to raise1 purify1 re=m ! ,*ur* 9 :i* ,provid5ce _h plac$ him2 utt]ly dissatisfi$ z he 0 ) x1 intellectually & morally1 conv9c$ m & m t x 0 wrong1 dismally1 fe>fully wrong1 x 0 8 duty1 he ?\ght1 to abide 9 x )\t look+ to consequ5ces2 b x 0 also 8 duty to %ake ! fai? ( any "o he c\ld 9 its pres5t claims & work+1 & to hold up an incomp>ably pur] model ( tru? & hol9ess4 ,t 8 purpose 0 :at he consid]$ real re=m1 !re is no reason to d\bt1 ?\gh he *ose to %ut 8 eyes to :at mu/ come ( x4 ,! position 0 an unnatural "o1 b he _h great fai? 9 8 own well-f5c$ logical creations1 & defi$ ! objections ( a homeli] common s5se4 ,he 0 n cont5t to wait 9 sil5ce ! sl[ & sad *anges ( old convictions1 ! pa9ful decay & disappe>ance ( long-*]i%$ ties4 ,8 m9d 0 too active1 re/less1 unres]v$4 ,to ! la/ he p]si/$ 9 =c+ on ! _w1 pr(ess$ly to influ5ce x1 really to defy x1 ! mo/ viol5t ass]tions :i* he c\ld =mulate ( ! mo/ p>adoxical claims on fri5ds & oppon5ts :i* _h ev] be5 made4 ,mr4 ,w>d's influ5ce 0 felt also 9 ano!r way2 ?\gh "h x is n easy to measure ! degree ( its =ce4 ,he 0 9 ! habit ( appeal+ to ,mr4 ,newman to pron\nce on ! s\ndness ( 8 pr9ciples & inf]5ces1 ) ! view ( gett+ ,mr4 ,newman's sanction = !m aga9/ m timid or m dissatisfi$ fri5ds2 & he w\ld come d[n ) great glee on objectors to "s new & />tl+ position1 ) ! reply1 ,newman says s1 ,e "o kn[s f ! ,apologia :at 0 ,mr4 ,newman's /ate ( m9d aft] #ahda--;a /ate ( p]plexity1 di/ress1 anxiety2 he 0 mov+ und\bt$ly 9 "o direction1 b mov+ sl[ly1 pa9fully1 reluctantly1 int]mitt5tly1 ) views sometimes cle>1 sometimes cl\d$1 ( t t]ribly complicat$ problem1 ! answ] to :i* 0 full ( su* consequ5ces to himself & to o!rs4 ,no "o ev] felt m ke5ly t x 0 no m]e affair ( dext]\s or brilliant logic2 if logic c\ld h settl$ x1 ! "q w\ld nev] h aris54 ,b 9 ?is fev]$ /ate1 ) m9d1 s\l1 he>t all torn & di/ract$ by ! trem5d\s responsibilities press+ on him1 wi%+ above ev]y?+ to be quiet1 to be sil5t1 at lea/ n to speak except at 8 own times & :5 he saw ! occasion1 he _h1 besides be>+ 8 own difficulties1 to return (f-h& & at ! mom5t "s response to que/ions :i* he _h n fram$1 :i* he did n c>e =1 on :i* he felt no call to pron\nce1 :i* he 0 n p]haps yet ready to face1 & to answ] :i* he mu/ commit himself irrevocably & publicly to m ?an he 0 prep>$ =4 ,e "o is famili> ) ! prov]bial di/ribution ( p>ts 9 ! ask+ & ! answ]+ ( que/ions2 b :5 ! ask] is no fool1 b "o ( ! %>pe/-witt$ ( mank9d1 ask+ ) little consid]ation = ! condition or ! wi%es ( ! answ]]1 ) great p[] to =ce ! answ] he wants1 & ) no great t5d]ness 9 ! use he makes ( x1 ! situation becomes a try+ "o4 ,mr4 ,w>d 0 cont9ually =c+ on ,mr4 ,newman s-call$ irresi/ible inf]5ces2 ,if y say s & s1 surely y mu/ also say some?+ m8 ,av[$ly ignorant ( facts & dep5d+ = !m on o!rs1 he 0 only conc]n$ ) logical consi/5cy4 ,& accord+ly ,mr4 ,newman1 ) :om producible logical consi/5cy 0 inde$ a great ?+1 b ) :om x 0 v f> f be+ ev]y?+1 _h cont9ually to accept conclusions :i* he w\ld r h kept 9 abeyance1 to make admissions :i* 7 us$ )\t _! qualifications1 to pu% on & sanction extreme ideas :i* he himself %rank f because !y 7 extreme4 ,b x 0 all ov] ) 8 comm& ( "t1 8 lib]ty to make up 8 m9d sl[ly on ! great decision4 ,he _h to g at ,mr4 ,w>d's pace1 & n 8 own4 ,he _h to take ,mr4 ,w>d's que/ions1 n :5 he want$ to h !m & at 8 own "t1 b at ,mr4 ,w>d's4 ,no "o c tell h[ mu* ?is /ate ( ?+s affect$ ! work+ ( ,mr4 ,newman's m9d 9 t pause ( hesitation be=e ! f9al /ep2 h[ f> x accel]at$ ! view :i* he ultimately took ( 8 position4 ,no "o c tell1 = _m o!r influ5ces 7 mix$ up ) ?is "o4 ,b !re is no d\bt t ,mr4 ,newman felt ! annoyance & ! unfairness ( ?is p]petual que/ion+ = ! b5efit ( ,mr4 ,w>d's !ories1 & !re c be little d\bt t1 9 effect1 x drove him onw>ds & cut %ort 8 "t ( wait+4 ,eng9e]s tell u t1 9 ! case ( a %ip roll+ 9 a sea-way1 :5 ! p]iodic times ( ! %ip's roll co9cide ) ^? ( ! undulations ( ! waves1 a condition ( ?+s arises highly dang]\s to ! %ip's /ability4 ,s ! agitations ( ,mr4 ,newman's m9d 7 re9=c$ by ! impulses ( ,mr4 ,w>d's4#aaf ,b ! great "q betwe5 ,engl& & ,rome 0 n ! only matt] :i* engag$ ,mr4 ,w>d's active m9d4 ,9 ! c\rse ( 8 articles 9 ! ,briti% ,critic he endeav\r$ to develop 9 l>ge outl9es a philosophy ( religi\s belief4 ,re/less on all matt]s )\t a !ory1 he felt ! ne$ ( a !ory ( ! true me?od ( rea*+1 v]ify+1 & judg+ ( religi\s tru?2 x seem$ to him necess>y especially to a popul> religion1 su* z ,*ri/ianity claim$ to be2 & x 0 n ! lea/ ( ! po9ts on :i* he congratulat$ himself t he _h work$ out a view :i* ext5d$ greatly ! prov9ce & (fice ( consci5ce1 & ( fidelity to x1 & greatly n>r[$ ! prov9ce & (fice ( ! m]e intellect 9 ! case ( ! great mass ( mank9d4 ,! ,ox=d writ]s _h all along laid /ress on ! p>am\nt necessity ( ! s+le eye & discipl9$ he>t 9 accept+ or judg+ religion2 moral subjects c\ld be only appreciat$ by moral exp]i5ce2 purity1 rev]5ce1 humility 7 z ess5tial 9 su* que/ions z zeal1 indu/ry1 tru?fulness1 hone/y2 religi\s tru? is a gift z well z a conque/2 & !y dwelt on ! great maxims ( ! ,new ,te/am5t3 ,to him t ha? %all be giv52 ,if any man w d ! w ( ! ,fa!r1 he %all "k ( ! doctr9e4 ,b ?\gh ,mr4 ,newman especially _h ?r[n out deep & illum9at+ ?\ghts on ?is difficult "q1 x _h n be5 treat$ sy/ematically2 & ?is treatm5t ,mr4 ,w>d attempt$ to give to x4 ,x 0 a /rik+ & p[]ful ef=t1 full ( ke5 insight into human exp]i5ce & acute obs]vations on its real laws & conditions2 b on ! face ( x1 x 0 lab\r$ & /ra9$2 x *ose its own gr\nd1 & pass$ unnotic$ neighb\r+ regions "u diff]5t conditions2 x left undealt ) ! inf9ite v>iety ( circum/ances1 hi/ory1 capacities1 natural temp]am5t1 & ^? unexplor$ dep?s ( w & "*1 affect+ *oice & judgm5t1 ! realities ( :i* h be5 br\ght home to u by our lat] e?ical lit]ature4 ,up to a c]ta9 po9t 8 task 0 easy4 ,x is easy to say t a bad life1 a rebelli\s temp]1 a selfi% _s are hopeless disqualifications = judg+ spiritual ?+s2 t we mu/ take some?+ = grant$ 9 le>n+ any tru?s :atev]2 t m5 mu/ act z moral creatures to atta9 insight into moral tru?s1 to realise & grasp !m z ?+s1 & n ab/ractions & words4 ,b !n came ! que/ions--,:at is t moral tra9+1 :i*1 9 ! case ( ! good he>t1 w be practically infallible 9 lead+ into tru?8 ,& :at is t type ( "*1 ( sa9tl9ess1 :i* gives au?ority :i* we _c d wrong 9 foll[+2 :]e1 if "q & controv]sy arise1 is ! common measure b9d+ on bo? sides2 & c ev5 ! sa9ts1 ) _! imm5se v>iations & app>5t mixtures & fail+s1 furni% t type8 ,& next1 :]e1 9 ! inve/igations :i* may be endlessly div]sifi$1 does intellect prop]ly come 9 & give its help8 ,= come 9 some:]e1 ( c\rse x mu/2 & ! conspicu\s dom9ance ( ! intellectual elem5t 9 ,mr4 ,w>d's treatm5t ( ! subject is palpable on ! face ( x4 ,8 attempt is to make out a !ory ( ! reasonabl5ess ( unproducible2 because unanalys$1 reasons2 reasons :i*1 ?\gh ! individual _c /ate !m1 may be z real & z legitimately active z ! obscure rays ( ! spectrum4 ,b ?\gh ! discussion 9 ,mr4 ,w>d's h&s 0 sugge/ive ( mu*1 ?\gh he might expose ! sup]cili\sness ( ,:ately or ! %all[ness ( ,mr4 ,goode1 & %[ himself no unequal antagoni/ to ,mr4 ,j4,s4 ,mill1 x left great difficulties unansw]$1 & x _h too mu* ! appe>ance ( be+ direct$ to a p>ticul> end1 t ( gu>d+ ! ,ca?olic view ( a popul> religion f =midable objections4 ,! moral side ( religion _h be5 f ! fir/ a prom95t subject 9 ! tea*+ ( ! movem5t ,its prote/s _h be5 e>ne/ & con/ant aga9/ intellectual self-suffici5cy1 & ! notion t m]e %rewdness & clev]ness 7 compet5t judges ( ,*ri/ian tru?1 or t s\ndness ( judgm5t 9 religi\s matt]s 0 compatible ) arrogance or an imp]fect moral /&>d2 & x revolt$ aga9/ ! conv5tional & inconsi/5t sev]ity ( ,puritanism1 :i* 0 %ock$ at danc+ b indulg$ freely 9 good d9n]s1 & 0 o/5tati\s 9 us+ ! phrases ( spiritual life & 9 m>k+ a sep>ation f ! _w1 :ile x surr\nd$ itself ) all ! luxuries ( mod]n inv5tiv5ess4 ,b ?is moral tea*+ 0 conf9$ to ! /atem5t ( pr9ciples1 & x 0 c>ri$ out 9 actual life ) ! utmo/ dislike ( display & ) a %r9k+ f /rong pr(essions4 ,! motto ( ,fr\de's ,rema9s1 :i* embodi$ 8 *>act]i/ic temp]1 0 an expression ( ! feel+ ( ! s*ool3 ,se sub s]5is vultibus ,au/]a virtus occulit3 ,timet vid]i1 ne suum1 ,dum prodit1 amittat decus1#aag ,! h]oic /rictness & self-d5ial ( ! e>ly ,*ur* 7 ! objects ( admiration1 z :at ought to be ! /&>d ( ,*ri/ians2 b p did n yet l to talk mu* ab\t attempts to copy !m4 ,su* a book z ! ,*ur* ( ! ,fa!rs br\ght out ) great =ce & great sympa?y ! ascetic temp] & ! value put on celibacy 9 ! e>ly days1 & x made a deep impression2 b no?+ 0 yet =mulat$ z *>act]i/ic & accept$ doctr9e4 ,x 0 n unnatural t ?is %\ld *ange4 ,! pr9ciples exemplifi$ 9 ! high ,*ri/ian lives ( antiquity became concrete 9 def9ite rules & doctr9es1 & ^! rules & doctr9es 7 mo/ readily f\nd 9 ! =ms 9 :i* ! ,roman s*ools & tea*]s _h embodi$ !m4 ,! di/9ction betwe5 ! secul> life & ! life ( religion1 ) all its consequ5ces1 became an accept$ "o4 ,celibacy came to be reg>d$ z an obvi\s "p ( ! self-sacrifice ( a cl]gyman's life1 & ! belief & ! pr(ession ( x =m$ a te/1 und]/ood if n av[$1 by :i* ! m advanc$ or resolute memb]s ( ! p>ty 7 di/+ui%$ f ! re/4 ,?is came home to m5 on ! ?re%old ( life ) a ke5] & clos] t\* ?an que/ions ab\t doctr9e4 ,x 0 ! subject ( _m a bitt]1 agonis+ /ruggle :i* no "o knew any?+ (2 x 0 ) _m ! act ( a supreme self-oblation4 ,! idea ( ! s+le life may be a utilit>ian "o z well z a religi\s "o4 ,x may be *os5 ) no ?\ght ( r5unciation or self-d5ial1 = ! great] conv5i5ce & fre$om ( ! /ud5t or ! philosoph]1 ! soldi] or ! man ( affairs4 ,x may also be *os5 )\t any special feel+ ( a sacrifice by ! cl]gyman1 z mo/ helpful = 8 "w4 ,b ! idea ( celibacy1 9 ^? :om x affect$ at ,ox=d1 0 9 ! highe/ degree a religi\s & romantic "o4 ,! hold :i* x _h on ! lead] ( ! movem5t made itself felt1 ?\gh little 0 directly said4 ,to %r9k f x 0 a m>k ( want ( /r5g? or intellig5ce1 ( an unmanly pref]5ce = ,engli% home life1 ( ins5sibility to ! g5]\s devotion & purity ( ! sa9ts4 ,x _c be d\bt$ t at ?is p]iod ( ! movem5t ! p[] ( ?is idea ov] imag9ation & consci5ce 0 "o ( ! /ronge/ =ces 9 ! direction ( ,rome4 ,( all ^! ideas ,mr4 ,w>d's articles 9 ! ,briti% ,critic 7 ! vigor\s & un9t]mitt5t exposition4 ,he spoke out1 & )\t hesitation4 ,!re 0 a p]petual contra/ impli$1 :5 x 0 n =cibly insi/$ on1 betwe5 all t _h usually be5 e/eem$ highe/ 9 ! moral temp] ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 always closely connect$ ) home life & mu* v>iety ( "*1 & ! l(ti] & bold] b n>r[] /&>d ( ,roman piety4 ,& ,mr4 ,w>d 0 second$ 9 ! ,briti% ,critic by o!r writ]s1 all f]vid 9 ! same cause1 "s able & eloqu5t4 ,! mo/ di/+ui%$ ( 8 allies 0 ,mr4 ,oakeley1 ,fell[ ( ,balliol & m9i/] ( ,m>g>et ,*apel 9 ,london4 ,mr4 ,oakeley 01 p]haps1 ! fir/ to realise ! capacities ( ! ,anglican ritual = impressive devotional use1 & 8 s]vices1 9 spite ( ! disadvantages ( ! "t1 & also ( 8 *apel1 are /ill rememb]$ by "s z hav+ realis$ = !m1 9 a way nev] s9ce surpass$1 ! secrets & ! consolations ( ! wor%ip ( ! ,*ur*4 ,mr4 ,oakeley1 )\t mu* le>n+1 0 ma/] ( a facile & elegant p54 ,he 0 a man :o foll[$ a tru/$ lead] ) *ivalr\s boldness1 & 0 n afraid ( /r5g!n+ 8 /atem5ts4 ,)\t ,mr4 ,w>d's =ce & orig9ality1 8 articles 7 m attractive read+4 ,8 article on ,jewel 0 m ?an any?+ else a l&m>k 9 ! progress ( ,roman ideas4#aah ,f ! "t ( ,mr4 ,w>d's connexion ) ! ,briti% ,critic1 its anti-,anglican articles _h giv5 rise to compla9ts :i* did n become less l\d z "t w5t on4 ,he 0 a tr\blesome contributor to 8 editor1 ,mr4 ,t4 ,mozley1 & he made ! hair ( _m ( 8 read]s /& on end ) 8 d5unciations ( ?+s ,engli% & eulogies ( ?+s ,roman4 ,my fir/ tr\bles 7writes ,mr4 ,mozley7 7 ) ,oakeley & ,w>d4 ,i w n say t ,i hesitat$ mu* z to ! tru? ( :at !y wrote1 = 9 t matt] ,i 0 incl9$ to g v f>1 at lea/ 9 ! way ( tol]ation4 ,yet x appe>$ to me q impossible ei!r t any great numb] ( ,engli% ,*ur*m5 w\ld ev] g s f>1 or t ! p]sons possess+ au?ority 9 ! ,*ur* w\ld fail to prote/1 n to say m4444 ,z to ,w>d ,i did b t\* a filam5t or two 9 "o ( 8 mon/r\s cobwebs1 & (f he ran in/antly to ,newman to compla9 ( my gratuit\s imp]t95ce4 ,_m ye>s aft] ,i 0 =cibly rem9d$ ( him by a pretty gr\p ( a little ,cupid fly+ to 8 "m to %[ a wasp-/+ he _h j receiv$4 ,newman 0 !n 9 ?is difficulty4 ,he did n disagree ) :at ,w>d _h writt52 b1 on ! o!r h&1 he _h giv5 nei!r me nor ,w>d to und]/& t he 0 likely to /ep 9 betwe5 u4 ,9 fact1 he wi%$ to be entirely cle> ( ! editor%ip4 ,?is1 h[ev]1 0 a ?+ t ,w>d c\ld n or w\ld n und]/&4#aai ,! discont5t ( read]s ( ! ,briti% ,critic 0 great4 ,x 0 express$ 9 v>i\s ways1 & 0 repres5t$ by a pamphlet ( ,mr4 ,w4 ,palm]'s ( ,worce/]1 9 :i* he contra/$1 ) words ( sev]e condemnation1 ! lat] writ]s 9 ! ,review ) ! tea*+ ( ! e>li] ,tracts = ! ,times1 & d5\nc$ ! ,romanis+ t5d5cy %[n 9 its articles4 ,9 ! autumn ( #ahdc ! ,review came to an end4 ,a field ( "w 0 ?us cut (f f ,mr4 ,w>d4 ,full ( ! int]e/ ( ! ideas :i* possess$ him1 always equipp$ & *e]fully ready = ! argum5tative enc\nt]1 & ke5ly reli%+ ! c]tam9is gaudia1 he at once seiz$ ! occasion ( ,mr4 ,palm]'s pamphlet to /ate :at he consid]$ 8 position1 & to set himself "r 9 ! eyes ( all fair & intellig5t read]s4 ,he int5d$ a long pamphlet4 ,x gradually grew "u 8 h&s--he 0 n yet gift$ ) ! p[] ( compression & arrangem5t--into a volume ( #fjj pages3 ! fam\s ,ideal ( a ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1 consid]$ 9 ,comp>ison ) ,exi/+ ,practice1 publi%$ 9 ! summ] ( #ahdd4 ,! ,ideal is a pond]\s & unattractive volume1 ill arrang$ & rambl+1 :i* its /yle & o!r circum/ances h caus$ to be almo/ =gott54 ,b !re are int]e/+ discussions 9 x :i* may /ill repay p]usal = _! own sakes4 ,! object ( ! book 0 tw(old4 ,/>t+ ) an ideal ( :at ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur* may be expect$ to be 9 its v>i\s relations to m51 x assumes t ! ,roman ,*ur*1 & only ! ,roman ,*ur*1 satisfies ! conditions ( :at a ,*ur* ought to be1 & x argues 9 detail t ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 9 spite ( its pr(essions1 utt]ly & absolutely fails to fulfil !m4 ,x is plaidoirie aga9/ ev]y?+ ,engli%1 on ! gr\nd t x _c be ,ca?olic because x is n ,roman4 ,x 0 n consi/5t1 = :ile ! writ] alleg$ t our ,*ur* totally neglect$ h] duties bo? z gu>dian ( & witness to morality1 & z witness & tea*] ( or?odoxy1 yet he saw no difficulty 9 attribut+ ! revival ( ,ca?olic tru? to ! inh]5t vitality & p[]s ( our own ,*ur*4#abj ,b ?is 0 n ! /+ & provocation ( ! book4 ,t lay 9 ! develop$ claim1 put =w>d by implication 9 ,mr4 ,w>d's previ\s writ+s1 & n[ repeat$ 9 ! broade/ & mo/ unqualifi$ =m1 to hold 8 position 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 av[+ & tea*+ all ,roman doctr9e4 ,we f9d 7he exclaims71 oh1 mo/ joyful1 mo/ wond]ful1 mo/ unexpect$ sight6 we f9d ! :ole cycle ( ,roman doctr9e gradually possess+ numb]s ( ,engli% ,*ur*m54444 ,?ree ye>s h pass$ s9ce ,i said pla9ly t 9 subscrib+ ! ,articles ,i r5\nce no ,roman doctr9e2 yet ,i reta9 my fell[%ip :i* ,i hold on ! t5ure ( subscription1 & h receiv$ no ecclesia/ical c5sure 9 any %ape4#aba ,!re 0 mu* to le>n f ! book2 mu* t might br+ home to ! mo/ loyal ,*ur*man a s5se ( %ortcom+s1 a burn+ desire = improvem5t2 mu* t might give e "o a great deal to ?9k ab\t1 on "s ( ! deepe/ problems ( ! intellectual & religi\s life4 ,b x c\ld n be expect$ t su* a *all5ge1 9 su* s5t5ces z ^!1 %\ld rema9 unnotic$4 ,! book came out 9 ! ,long ,vacation1 & x 0 n till ! ,univ]sity met 9 ,octob] t signs ( /orm began to appe>4 ,b be=e x broke an incid5t occurr$ :i* inflam$ m5's temp]s4 ,dr4 ,wynt]'s reign z ,vice-,*ancellor _h come to a close1 & ! next p]son1 accord+ to ! usual cu/om ( succession1 0 ,dr4 ,symons1 ,w>d5 ( ,wadham4 ,dr4 ,symons _h nev] conceal$ 8 /rong ho/ility to ! movem5t1 & he _h be5 "o ( ,dr4 ,pusey's judges4 ,! prospect ( a p>tisan ,vice-,*ancellor1 c]ta9ly v det]m9$1 & suppos$ n to be ov]-scrupul\s1 0 al>m+4 ,! cons5t ( ,convocation to ! ,*ancellor's nom9ation ( 8 sub/itute _h always be5 giv5 9 words1 ?\gh no in/ance ( its hav+ be5 refus$ 0 kn[n1 at lea/ 9 rec5t times4 ,b a great jeal\sy ab\t ! rights ( ,convocation _h be5 gr[+ up "u ! late autocratic policy ( ! ,heads1 & !re 0 a disposition to ass]t1 & ev5 to /ret* ^! rights1 a disposition n conf9$ to ! p>ty ( ! movem5t4 ,x 0 propos$ to *all5ge ,dr4 ,symons's nom9ation4 ,great d\bts 7 felt & express$ ab\t ! wisdom ( ! proposal2 b at l5g? opposition 0 resolv$ ^u4 ,! /ep 0 a w>n+ to ! ,heads1 :o _h be5 provok+ en\gh2 b !re 0 n en\gh to w>rant su* a viol5t dep>ture f usage1 & x 0 ! act ( exasp]ation r ?an ( wisdom4 ,! blame = x mu/ be %>$ betwe5 ! few :o fi]cely urg$ x1 & ! _m :o disapprov$ & acquiesc$4 ,on ! day ( nom9ation1 ! scrut9y 0 all[$1 salv auctoritate ,cancell>ii2 b ,dr4 ,symons's oppon5ts 7 completely defeat$ by #hhc to #ahc4 ,x c\nt$1 n unreasonably1 z a ,puseyite defeat4 ,! attempt & its result made x c]ta9 t 9 ! attack t 0 sure to come on ,mr4 ,w>d's book1 he w\ld meet ) no m]cy4 ,z soon z t]m began ! ,bo>d ( ,heads ( ,h\ses took up ! matt]2 !y 7 e>ne/ly exhort$ to x by a lett] ( ,ar*bi%op ,:ately's1 :i* 0 read at ! ,bo>d4 ,b !y want$ no press+1 nor is x a/oni%+ t !y c\ld n und]/& ! claim to hold ! :ole cycle ( ,roman doctr9e 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,mr4 ,w>d's view 0 t he 0 loyally do+ ! be/ he c\ld = our ,*ur*1 n only 9 %[+ up its h]esies & faults1 b 9 urg+ t ! only rem$y 0 :olesale submission to ,rome4 ,to ! ,univ]sity au?orities ?is 0 tak+ advantage ( 8 position 9 ! ,*ur* to assail & if possible de/roy x4 ,& to numb]s ( mu* m sob] & mod]ate ,*ur*m51 sympa?is]s ) ! g5]al _s ( ! movem5t1 x 0 evid5t t ,mr4 ,w>d _h long pass$ ! po9t :5 tol]ance c\ld be fairly ask$1 consi/5tly ) any respect = ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 = su* sweep+ & p>adoxical contradictions1 by h] own s]vants1 ( h] claims & title4 ,mr4 ,w>d's mann] also1 :i*1 :ile x 0 s]i\s en\gh 9 8 writ+s1 0 easy & ev5 jocul> 9 social int]c\rse1 left ! impression1 9 reality a mo/ unfair impression1 t he 0 play+ & amus+ himself ) ^! mom5t\s que/ions4 ,a ,committee ( ! ,bo>d exam9$ ! book2 a numb] ( />tl+ propositions 7 ) ease pick$ out1 "s prelim9>y skirmi%+ z to matt]s ( =m took place1 & 9 ,decemb] #ahdd ! ,bo>d ann\nc$ t !y propos$ to submit to ,convocation )\t delay ?ree measures3--7#a7 to condemn ,mr4 ,w>d's book2 7#b7 to degrade ,mr4 ,w>d by depriv+ him ( all 8 ,univ]sity degrees2 & 7#c7 :]eas ! exi/+ ,/atutes gave ! ,vice-,*ancellor p[] ( call+ on any memb] ( ! ,univ]sity at any "t to prove 8 or?odoxy by subscrib+ ! ,articles1 to add to ?is a decl>ation1 to be h5ce=? made by ! subscrib]1 t he took !m 9 ! s5se 9 :i* !y 7 bo? fir/ publi%$ & 7 n[ impos$ by ! ,univ]sity1 ) ! p5alty ( expulsion aga9/ any "o1 lay or cl]ical1 :o ?rice refus$ subscription ) ?is decl>ation4 ,z usual1 ! ,bo>d entirely mi/ook ! temp] ( ! ,univ]sity1 & by _! viol5ce & want ( judgm5t turn$ ! be/ *ance !y ev] _h1 ( c>ry+ ! ,univ]sity ) !m1 into :at _! blund]s really made an ignom9i\s defeat4 ,if !y _h cont5t$ !mselves ) ! condemnation1 9 almo/ any t]ms1 ( ,mr4 ,w>d's book1 & ev5 ( its au?or1 ! condemnation w\ld h be5 ov]:elm+4 ,a c]ta9 numb] ( m5 w\ld h /ill /ood by ,mr4 ,w>d1 ei!r f fri5d%ip or sympa?y1 or f indep5d5ce ( judgm5t1 or f dislike ( ! policy ( ! ,bo>d2 b !y w\ld h be5 greatly outnumb]$4 ,! degradation--! ,bo>d did n v5ture on ! logical consequ5ce1 expulsion--0 a poor & ev5 ridicul\s measure ( puni%m5t2 to r$uce ,mr4 ,w>d to an und]graduate 9 /atu pupill>i1 & a common]'s %ort g[n1 0 a ?+ to amuse r ?an t]rify4 ,! p]sonal puni%m5t seem$ unwor?y :5 !y d>$ n g f>!r1 :ile to _m ! condemnation ( ! book seem$ p5alty en\gh2 & ! condemnation ( ! book by ^! vot]s 0 weak5$ by _! refusal to c>ry x into p]sonal disgrace & disadvantage4 ,/ill1 if ^! two measures _h /ood by !mselves1 !y c\ld n h be5 resi/$1 & ! triumph ( ! ,bo>d w\ld h be5 a signal "o4 ,b !y c\ld n re/4 ,!y mu/ ne$s attempt to put ^u subscription1 j :5 its difficulties 7 beg9n+ to be felt1 n by "o p>ty1 b by all1 an int]pretation :i* set ! ,univ]sity & ,*ur* 9 a flame4 ,! cry1 almo/ ! %riek1 arose t x 0 a new te/1 & a te/ :i* took = grant$ :at c]ta9ly ne$$ pro(1 t ! s5se 9 :i* ! ,articles 7 fir/ und]/ood & publi%$ 0 exactly ! same z t 9 :i* ! ,univ]sity n[ receiv$ & impos$ !m4 ,x 0 9 va9 t explanations1 assurances1 prote/s1 7 pr(f]$2 no new te/1 x 0 said1 0 ?\ght (--! ,bo>d w\ld nev] ?9k ( su* a ?+2 x 0 only some?+ to ensure good fai? & hone/y4 ,b x 0 utt]ly useless to cont5d aga9/ ! /orm4 ,a te/ x 01 & a new te/ no "o w\ld h4 ,x 0 cle> t1 if ! ?ird proposal 0 pu%$1 x w\ld endang] ! votes ab\t ,mr4 ,w>d4 ,aft] "s fruitless attempts at ju/ification ! ,bo>d _h1 9 ! c\rse ( a mon?1 to recognise t x _h made a great mi/ake4 ,! condemnation ( ,mr4 ,w>d 0 to come on1 on ! #ac? ( ,febru>y2 & on ! #bc;d ( ,janu>y ! ,vice-,*ancellor1 9 giv+ notice ( x1 ann\nc$ t ! ?ird proposal 0 )drawn4 ,x might h be5 ?\ght t ?is 0 lesson en\gh to leave well alone4 ,! ,heads 7 sure ( votes aga9/ ,mr4 ,w>d1 m or less num]\s2 !y 7 sure ( a victory :i* w\ld be a sev]e bl[1 n only to ,mr4 ,w>d & 8 special foll[]s1 b to ! ,tract>ian p>ty ) :i* he _h be5 s closely connect$4 ,b ^? bitt] & intemp]ate spirits :i* _h s long l$ !m wrong 7 n to be taught prud5ce ev5 by _! la/ exp]i5ce4 ,! mis*ief mak]s 7 at "w1 flitt+ ab\t ! (ficial lodg+s at ,wadham & ,oriel4 ,c\ld n some?+ be done1 ev5 at ?is late h\r1 to make up = ! loss ( ! te/8 ,c\ld n some?+ be done to disgrace a great] "n ?an ,mr4 ,w>d's8 ,c\ld n ! opportunity :i* 0 com+ ( r\s+ ! feel+ ( ! ,univ]sity aga9/ ! disciple be turn$ to acc\nt to drag =? 8 suppos$ ma/] f 8 retirem5t & impunity1 & br& ! au?or ( ,no4 #ij ) ! public /igma--no long] ?is "t ( a ,hebdomadal c5sure1 b ( a ,univ]sity condemnation8 ,! temptation 0 irresi/ible to a numb] ( disappo9t$ p>tisans--k9dly1 g5]\s1 good-natur$ m5 9 private life1 b implacable 9 _! fi]ce fanaticism4 ,9 _! impetu\s vehem5ce !y w\ld n ev5 /op to ?9k :at w\ld be said ( ! conditions & circum/ances "u :i* !y press$ _! po9t4 ,on ! #bc;d ( ,janu>y ! ,vice-,*ancellor _h )drawn ! te/4 ,on ! #be? ( ,janu>y--^? curi\s 9 co9cid5ces may obs]ve t x 0 ! date ( ,no4 #ij 9 #ahda--;a circul> 0 issu$ invit+ signatures = a requisition to ! ,bo>d1 ask+ !m to propose1 9 ! approa*+ ,convocation ( ! #ac? ( ,febru>y1 a =mal c5sure ( ! pr9ciples ( ,no4 #ij4 ,! invitation to sign 0 issu$ 9 ! names ( ,dr4 ,faussett & ,dr4 ,ell]ton ( ,magdal54 ,x receiv$ betwe5 f\r & five hundr$ signatures1 z f> z 0 kn[n2 b x 0 )held by ! ,vice-,*ancellor f ! inspection ( ^? :o (ficially _h a "r to h x be=e !m4 ,on ! #d? ( ,febru>y its pray] came be=e ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d4 ,! objection ( ha/e--t n t5 days int]v5$ betwe5 ?is new & mom5t\s proposal & ! day ( vot+--0 bru%$ aside4 ,! memb]s ( ! ,bo>d 7 mad en\gh n to see1 n m]ely ! odi\sness ( ! c\rse1 b ! aggravat$ odi\sness ( hurry4 ,! proposal 0 vot$ by ! majority1 sans phrase4 ,& !y v5tur$1 amid all ! excitem5t & irritation ( ! mom5t1 to (f] = ! sanction ( ! ,univ]sity a decree fram$ 9 ! words ( _! own c5sure4 ,! int]val be=e ! ,convocation 0 %ort1 b x 0 long en\gh = decisive op9ions on ! proposal ( ! ,bo>d to be =m$ & express$4 ,lead+ m5 9 ,london1 ,mr4 ,glad/one among !m1 7 cle> t x 0 an occasion = ! ex]cise ( ! jo9t veto ) :i* ! ,proctors 7 inve/$4 ,! veto 0 int5d$1 if = any?+1 to save ! ,univ]sity f inconsid]ate & ha/y measures2 & seldom1 except 9 revolution>y times1 _h s mom5t\s & s unexpect$ a measure be5 urg$ on ) su* unseemly ha/e4 ,! feel+ ( ! y\ng] ,lib]als1 ,mr4 ,/anley1 ,mr4 ,donk91 ,mr4 ,j[ett1 ,dr4 ,gre5hill1 0 9 ! same direction4 ,on ! #aj? ( ,febru>y ! ,proctors ann\nc$ to ! ,bo>d _! int5tion to veto ! ?ird proposal4 ,b ( c\rse ! ?+ w5t =w>d4 ,! ,proctors 7 fri5ds ( ,mr4 ,newman1 & ! ,heads believ$ t ?is w\ld c\nt]balance any effect f _! act ( au?ority4 ,x is possible t ! ann\ncem5t may h be5 reg>d$ z a m]e m5ace1 too audaci\s to be fulfill$4 ,on ! #ac? ( ,febru>y1 amid slu% & sn[1 ,convocation met 9 ! ,!atre4 ,mr4 ,w>d ask$ leave to def5d himself 9 ,engli%1 & occupi$ "o ( ! ro/ra1 usually devot$ to ! recital ( prize poems & essays4 ,he spoke ) vig\r & ability1 divid+ 8 spee*1 & re/+ 9 ! int]val betwe5 ! two portions 9 ! ro/rum4#abb ,!re 0 no o!r address1 & ! vot+ began4 ,! fir/ vote1 ! condemnation ( ! book1 0 c>ri$ by #ggg to #chf4 ,! second1 by a m ev5ly balanc$ division1 #efi to #eaa4 ,:5 ! ,vice-,*ancellor put ! ?ird1 ! ,proctors rose1 & ! s5ior ,proctor1 ,mr4 ,guillem>d ( ,tr9ity1 /opp$ x 9 ! words1 ,nobis procuratoribus non placet4 ,su* a /ep1 ( c\rse1 only susp5d$ ! vote1 & ! ye> ( (fice ( ^! ,proctors 0 ne>ly run4 ,b !y _h express$ ! feel+ ( ^? :om !y repres5t$4 ,x 0 %[n n only 9 a l>gely-sign$ address ( ?anks4 ,all attempts to revive ! decree at ! expiration ( _! ye> ( (fice fail$4 ,! wis] heads 9 ! ,hebdomadal ,bo>d recognis$ at la/ t !y _h bett] hold _! h&4 ,mi/akes m5 may commit1 & defeats !y may und]go1 & yet lose no?+ t conc]ns _! "* = act+ z m5 ( a high /&>d ought to act4 ,b 9 ?is case1 mi/akes & defeat 7 ! lea/ ( :at ! ,bo>d br\ght on !mselves4 ,?is 0 ! la/ act ( a long & delib]ately pursu$ c\rse ( conduct2 & if x 0 ! la/1 x 0 because x 0 ! up%ot & climax1 & nei!r ! ,univ]sity nor any "o else w\ld endure t x %\ld g on any long]4 ,! propos$ attack on ,mr4 ,newman betray$ h[ helpless !y 71 & to :at paltry acts ( worry+ x 01 9 _! judgm5t1 "r & judici\s to condesc5d4 ,x gave a measure ( _! /atesman%ip1 wisdom1 & good feel+ 9 def5d+ ! int]e/s ( ! ,*ur*2 & x made a v deep & la/+ impression on all :o 7 int]e/$ 9 ! hon\r & welf>e ( ,ox=d4 ,m5 mu/ h bl9d$ !mselves to ! pla9e/ effects ( _! own actions :o c\ld h laid !mselves op5 to su* a description ( _! conduct z is conta9$ 9 ! foll[+ extract f a pap] ( ! "t--a passage ( :i* ! indignant & pa!tic und]tone reflect$ ! indignation & ! sympa?y ( hundr$s ( m5 ( widely diff]+ op9ions4 ,! vote is an answ] to a cry--t cry is "o ( di%one/y1 & ?is di%one/y ! propos$ resolution1 z pla9ly z x d>es to say any?+1 ins9uates4 ,on ?is "p ( ! "q1 ^? :o h ev] be5 hon\r$ by ,mr4 ,newman's fri5d%ip mu/ feel x dang]\s to all[ !mselves ?us to speak4 ,& yet !y mu/ speak2 = no "o else c appreciate x z truly z !y d4 ,:5 !y see ! p]son :om !y h be5 accu/om$ to rev]e z few m5 are rev]$1 ^: lab\rs1 ^: greatness1 ^: t5d]ness1 ^: s+l5ess & hol9ess ( purpose1 !y h be5 p]mitt$ to "k intimately--n all[$ ev5 ! poor privilege ( satisfy+1 by sil5ce & retirem5t--by ! rel9qui%m5t ( pref]m5t1 position1 & influ5ce--! p]sev]+ ho/ility ( p]sons :om !y _c help comp>+ ) him--n p]mitt$ ev5 to submit 9 peace to ^? irregul> c5sures1 to :i* he seems to h be5 ev5 morbidly alive1 b dragg$ =? to suff] an oblique & t>dy condemnation2 call$ aga9 to acc\nt = matt]s n[ long ago acc\nt$ =2 on :i* a judgm5t has be5 pron\nc$1 :i*1 :atev] o!rs may ?9k ( x1 he at lea/ has accept$ z conclusive--:5 !y contra/ 8 m]its1 8 submission1 8 treatm5t1 :i* !y see & "k1 ) ! m]its1 ! be>+1 ! =tunes ( ^? :o are dogg$ly pursu+ him1 x does become v difficult to speak )\t sully+ :at x is a k9d ( pleasure to feel is 8 cause by us+ h>d words1 or betray+ x by n us+ !m4 ,x is too difficult to speak1 z ought to be spok51 ( ?is ung5]\s & gratuit\s aft]?\ght--too difficult to keep cle> ( :at1 at lea/1 w be ?\ght exagg]ation2 too difficult to d ju/ice to :at !y feel to be und\bt$ly true2 & ,i w n attempt to say m ?an en\gh to m>k an op9ion :i* ought to be pla9ly av[$1 z to ! nature ( ?is proc$ure4#abc ,,footnotes3 #aaf ,a p5cill$ note indicates t ?is illu/ration 0 sugge/$ by exp]im5ts 9 naval eng9e]+ c>ri$ on at "o "t by ,mr4 ,w4 ,fr\de4 ,cf4 ,t4 ,mozley1 ,rem9isc5ces1 vol4 ii4 p4 #ag4 #aag ,hymn 9 ,p>is ,brevi>y1 ,commune ,sanct>um ,muli]um4 #aah ,rem9isc5ces1 ii4 #bdc1 #bdd4 ,cf4 ,briti% ,critic1 ,july #ahda4 #aai ,rem9isc5ces1 ii4 #bbc4 #abj ,ideal1 p4 #eff4 #aba ,ibid4 pp4 #efe-efg4 #abb ,x is "p ( ! hi/ory ( ! "t1 t dur+ ^? anxi\s days1 ,mr4 ,w>d 0 engag$ to be m>ri$4 ,! engagem5t came to ! k ( 8 fri5ds1 to _! great a/oni%m5t & amusem5t1 v soon aft] ! ev5ts 9 ! ,!atre4 #abc ,f a ,%ort ,appeal to ,memb]s ( ,convocation on ! propos$ ,c5sure on ,no4 #ij4 ,by ,fr$]ic ,rog]s1 ,fell[ ( ,oriel4 7,dat$ ,saturday1 #h? ( ,febru>y #ahde47 ,,*apt] ,,xix ,,! ,,cata/rophe ,! ev5ts ( ,febru>y 7 a great %ock4 ,! r\t9e ( ,ox=d _h be5 brok5 z x _h nev] be5 brok5 by ! fi]ce/ /rifes be=e4 ,condemnations _h be5 be=e pass$ on op9ions1 & ev5 on p]sons4 ,b to see an em95t man1 ( blameless life1 a fell[ ( "o ( ! fir/ among ! ,colleges1 solemnly depriv$ ( 8 degree & all t ! degree c>ri$ ) x1 & t on a *>ge 9 :i* bad fai? & trea*]y 7 comb9$ ) alleg$ h]esy1 0 a novel exp]i5ce1 :]e ! k9dnesses ( daily companion%ip & social int]c\rse /ill ass]t$ !mselves z p>am\nt to (ficial ideas ( position4 ,& :51 besides ?is1 p realis$ :at m _h be5 attempt$1 & by h[ n>r[ a *ance a /ill heavi] bl[ _h be5 av]t$ f "o t[>ds :om s _m he>ts w>m$1 h[ n>r[ly a yoke _h be5 escap$ :i* w\ld h seem$ to subject all religi\s ?\ght 9 ! ,univ]sity to ! caprice or ! bl9d zeal ( a p>tisan (ficial1 ! s5se ( relief 0 mix$ ) ! /ill pres5t memory ( a desp]ate p]il ,& !n came ! "q z to :at 0 to come next4 ,t ! old policy ( ! ,bo>d w\ld be reviv$ & pursu$ :5 ! end ( ! ,proctors' ye> deliv]$ x f _! inconv5i5t pres5ce1 0 soon und]/ood to be out ( ! "q4 ,! v viol5ce ( ! measures attempt$ _h its reaction1 :i* /opp$ any?+ fur!r4 ,! oppon5ts ( ,tract>ianism1 ,or?odox & ,lib]al1 7 = ! mom5t gorg$ ) _! success4 ,:at m5 wait$ to see 0 ! effect on ! p>ty ( ! movem5t2 h[ x w\ld influ5ce ! advanc$ portion ( x2 h[ x w\ld influ5ce ! little company :o _h look$ on 9 sil5ce f _! retirem5t at ,littlemore4 ,! m s]i\s aspect ( rec5t ev5ts 0 succe$$ = ! mom5t by a c]ta9 comic contra/1 creat$ by ,mr4 ,w>d's engagem5t to be m>ri$1 :i* 0 ann\nc$ )9 a week ( 8 degradation1 & :i* gave ! common-rooms some?+ to smile at aft] ! /ra9 & excitem5t ( ! sc5e 9 ! ,!atre4 ,b t pass$1 & ! grav] outlook ( ! situation occupi$ m5's ?\ghts4 ,!re 0 a widespread feel+ ( insecurity4 ,fri5ds did n "k ( fri5ds1 h[ _! m9ds 7 work+1 h[ !y might g4 ,anxi\s lett]s pass$1 ! writ]s n d>+ to say too mu*1 or reveal too mu* al>m4 ,& yet !re 0 /ill "s hope t at lea/ ) ! great lead] matt]s 7 n desp]ate4 ,to 8 own fri5ds he gave w>n+2 he _h already done s 9 a way to leave little to expect b at la/ to lose him2 he spoke ( resign+ 8 fell[%ip 9 ,octob]1 ?\gh he wi%$ to def] ?is till ! foll[+ ,june2 b no?+ f9al _h be5 said publicly4 ,ev5 at ! la/ x 0 only anticipat$ by "s t he w\ld retire into lay communion4 ,b t sil5ce 0 awful & om9\s4 ,he %[$ no signs ( be+ affect$ by :at _h pass$ 9 ,ox=d4 ,he privately ?ank$ ! ,proctors = sav+ him f :at w\ld h di/ress$ him2 b he made no comm5ts on ! measures !mselves4 ,/ill x c\ld n b be a climax ( ev]y?+ z f> z ,ox=d 0 conc]n$4 ,& he 0 a man :o saw signs 9 su* ev5ts4 ,x 0 inevitable t ! ev5ts ( ! end ( #ahdd & ! beg9n+ ( #ahde %\ld br+ ) !m a great crisis 9 ! developm5t ( religi\s op9ion1 9 ! relations ( its diff]5t =ms to "o ano!r1 & fur!r1 9 ! ?\ghts ( _m m9ds z to _! p]sonal position1 _! duty1 & _! prospects4 ,!re _h be5 su* a crisis 9 #ahda at ! publication ( ,no4 #ij4 ,aft] ! discussions :i* foll[$ t tract1 ,anglican !ology c\ld nev] be q ! same t x _h be5 be=e4 ,x 0 made to feel ! s5se ( "s grave wants1 :i*1 h[ev] !y might be suppli$ 9 ! future1 c\ld no long] be unnotic$ or unc>$ =4 ,& individuals1 amid ! /rife ( tongues1 _h felt1 "s /rongly & practically1 b a mu* l>g] numb] dimly & reluctantly1 ! possibility1 unwelcome to mo/1 b n )\t int]e/ to o!rs1 ( hav+ to face ! /range & at "o "t inconceivable task ( revis+ ! v f\ndations ( _! religion4 ,& su* a revision _h s9ce t "t be5 go+ on m or less actively 9 _m m9ds2 9 "s cases ) v decisive results4 ,b aft] ! explosion caus$ by ,mr4 ,w>d's book1 a crisis ( a mu* m grave & wide-rea*+ sort _h arriv$4 ,to ord9>y look]s-on x naturally seem$ t a %att]+ & decisive bl[ _h be5 /ruck at ! ,tract>ian p>ty & _! cause2 /ruck1 inde$1 =mally & (ficially1 only at its extravagances1 b /ruck1 none ! less1 virtually1 at ! premisses :i* l$ to ^! extravagances1 & at ! p>ty1 :i*1 :ile disapprov+ !m1 %rank1 ) :atev] motives1--policy1 g5]osity1 or secret sympa?y1--f jo9+ 9 ! condemnation ( !m4 ,x 0 m ?an a defeat1 x 0 a r\t1 9 :i* !y 7 driv5 & *as$ headlong f ! field2 a wreck 9 :i* _! boa/s & hopes ( ! la/ few ye>s met ! fate :i* wise m5 _h always anticipat$4 ,ox=d repudiat$ !m4 ,_! !ories1 _! controv]sial successes1 _! le>n$ argum5ts1 _! appeals to ! imag9ation1 all seem$ to g d[n1 & to be swept away l *aff1 be=e ! brea? ( /raight=w>d common s5se & hone/y4 ,h5ce=? !re 0 a badge affix$ to !m & all :o belong$ to !m1 a badge ( suspicion & discr$it1 & ev5 %ame1 :i* bade m5 bew>e ( !m1 an ov]?r[ "u :i* x seem$ wond]ful t !y c\ld raise _! heads or expect a he>+4 ,x is true1 t to ^? :o look$ bel[ ! surface1 ! ov]?r[ might h seem$ almo/ too %[y & !atrical to be q all t x 0 g5]ally ?\ght to be4 ,!re _h be5 too mu* passion1 & too little look+ =w>d to ! next /eps1 9 ! proce$+s ( ! victors4 ,!re 0 too mu* bl9dness to weak po9ts ( _! own position1 too mu* =getfulness ( ! wise g5]osity ( cauti\s w>f>e4 ,! victory 0 easy to w92 ! next mom5t x 0 q obvi\s t !y did n "k :at to d ) x1 & 7 at _! wits' end to und]/& :at x meant4 ,& ! defeat$ p>ty1 ?\gh defeat$ signally & conspicu\sly 9 ! sight ( ! ,*ur* & ! c\ntry1 _h 9 x too l>ge a proportion ( ! s]i\s & able m5 ( ! ,univ]sity1 ) too cle> & high a purpose1 & too di/9ct a s5se ( ! /r5g? & reality ( _! gr\nd1 to be 9 z disadvantage\s a condition z f a di/ance might be imag9$4 ,a clos] view w\ld h discov]$ h[ mu* sympa?y !re 0 = _! objects & = _! ma9 pr9ciples 9 _m :o greatly disapprov$ ( mu* 9 ! rec5t c\rse & t5d5cy ( ! movem5t4 ,x might h be5 se5 h[ ! unwise measures ( ! ,heads _h awak5$ convictions among _m :o 7 n naturally on _! side1 t x 0 necess>y bo? on ! gr\nd ( ju/ice & policy to arre/ all extreme measures1 & to give a brea?+ "t to ! m9ority4 ,confid5ce 9 _! prospects z a p>ty might h be5 impair$ 9 ! ,tract>ians2 b confid5ce 9 _! pr9ciples2 confid5ce t !y _h rightly int]pret$ ! _s1 ! claims1 & ! duties ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 confid5ce t devotion to its cause 0 ! call ( ,god1 :atev] might happ5 to _! own =tunes1 ?is confid5ce 0 un%ak5 by ! cata/rophe ( ,febru>y4 ,b t crisis _h ano!r important result1 n mu* notic$ !n1 b "o :i* made itself abundantly evid5t 9 ! times t foll[$4 ,! decisive brea* betwe5 ! old p>ties 9 ! ,*ur*1 bo? ,or?odox & ,evangelical1 & ! new p>ty ( ! movem5t1 ) ! viol5t & app>5tly irretrievable discomfiture ( ! latt] z ! ris+ =ce 9 ,ox=d1 op5$ ! way & cle>$ ! gr\nd = ! =mation & ! p[] ( a ?ird s*ool ( op9ion1 :i* 0 to be ! mo/ =midable rival ( ! ,tract>ians1 & ^: lead]s 7 ev5tually to succe$ :]e ! ,tract>ians _h fail$1 9 becom+ ! ma/]s & ! re=m]s ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,lib]alism _h hi!rto be5 repres5t$ 9 ,ox=d 9 =ms :i* ?\gh respectable f intellectual vig\r 7 unattractive1 sometimes ev5 repulsive4 ,!y 7 dry1 cold1 sup]cili\s1 critical2 !y want$ en?usiasm2 !y 7 out ( sympa?y ) religion & ! religi\s temp] & aims4 ,!y play$1 )\t kn[+ x1 on ! edge ( ! mo/ dang]\s que/ions4 ,! old] ,ox=d ,lib]als 7 ei!r intellectually ari/ocratic1 dissect+ ! inaccuracies or %[+ up ! p>alogisms ( ! curr5t or?odoxy1 or !y 7 poor 9 "*1 ,lib]als f ! ze/ ( sne]+ & mock+ at :at 0 receiv$ & e/abli%$1 or f ! conv5i5ce ( gett+ rid ( /rict & tr\blesome rules ( life4 ,!y patronis$ ,diss5t]s2 !y gave ,:ig votes2 !y made free1 9 a mild way1 ) ! pet conv5tions & prejudices ( ,tories & ,high ,*ur*m54 ,!re 0 no?+ inspir+ 9 !m1 h[ev] mu* m5 might respect _! correct & s9c]e lives4 ,b a y\ng] set ( m5 br\ght1 ma9ly f ,rugby & ,arnold's tea*+1 a new k9d ( ,lib]alism4 ,x 0 mu* bold] & m indep5d5t ?an ! old] =ms1 less incl9$ to put up ) ! traditional1 m se>*+ & inquisitive 9 its me?ods1 m suspici\s & d>+ 9 its criticism2 b x 0 mu* l>g] 9 its views & its sympa?ies1 &1 above all1 x 0 imag9ative1 x 0 en?usia/ic1 &1 )\t mu* ( ! devotional temp]1 x 0 p5etrat$ by a s5se ( ! reality & s]i\sness ( religion4 ,x saw great] hopes 9 ! pres5t & ! future ?an ! ,tract>ians4 ,x dislik$ _! rev]5ce = ! pa/ & ! receiv$ z inconsi/5t ) :at seem$ evid5ce ( ! provid5tial ord] ( great & fruitful *ange4 ,x c\ld n ent] into _! discipl9e ( "*1 & %rank f x z antiquat$1 unnatural1 & n>r[4 ,b ^! y\ng] ,lib]als 7 int]e/$ 9 ! ,tract>ian innovators1 &1 9 a degree1 sympa?is$ ) !m z a p>ty ( movem5t :o _h _h ! c\rage to risk & sacrifice mu* = an unworldly end4 ,& !y felt t _! own opportunity 0 come :5 all ! p>ties :i* claim$ to repres5t ! or?odoxy ( ! ,engli% ,*ur* appe>$ to h brok5 = good ) "o ano!r1 & :5 _! diff]5ces _h ?r[n s mu* d\bt & disp>agem5t on s important & rev]$ a symbol ( or?odoxy z ! ,?irty-n9e ,articles4 ,!y look$ on p>tly ) amusem5t1 p>tly ) s]i\s anxiety1 at ! dispute2 !y discrim9at$ ) imp>tiality betwe5 ! /rong & ! weak po9ts 9 ! argum5ts on bo? sides3 & !y en=c$ ) ! same imp>tiality on bo? ( !m ! reasons1 aris+ out ( ! difficulties 9 :i* ea* p>ty 0 involv$1 = new & l>ge measures1 = a policy ( =be>ance & tol]ation4 ,!y inflict$ on ! beat5 side1 sometimes ) m +5uity ?an fairness1 ! lesson t ! :eel _h come r\nd full circle ) !m2 t !y 7 b reap+ z !y !mselves _h s[n3--b n[ t !re seem$ little m to fe> f ! ,tract>ians1 ! victori\s au?orities 7 ! p[] :i* ! ,lib]als _h to keep 9 *eck4 ,!y us$ _! influ5ce1 su* z x 0 7& x 0 n !n :at x 0 aft]w>ds71 to protect ! weak] p>ty4 ,x 0 a fav\rite boa/ ( ,dean ,/anley's 9 aft]-times1 t ! int]v5tion ( ! ,lib]als _h sav$ ! ,tract>ians f complete disa/]4 ,x is q true t ! y\ng] ,lib]als disapprov$ ! cont9uance ( h>% measures1 & "s ( !m ex]t$ !mselves aga9/ su* measures4 ,!y did s 9 _m ways & = v>i\s reasons2 f consi/5cy1 f feel+s ( p]sonal k9dness1 f a s5se ( ju/ice1 f a s5se ( int]e/--"s 9 a frank & g5]\s _s1 o!rs ) contemptu\s indiff]5ce4 ,b ! debt ( ! ,tract>ians to _! ,lib]al fri5ds 9 #ahde 0 n s great z ,dean ,/anley1 ?9k+ ( ! ,lib]al p>ty z :at x _h ultimately gr[n to be1 suppos$ to be ! case4 ,! ,lib]als ( 8 s*ool 7 !n /ill a little flock3 a v di/+ui%$ & a v e>ne/ set ( m51 b too "y & too few z yet to hold ! balance 9 su* a conte/4 ,! ,tract>ians 7 sav$ by :at !y 7 & :at !y _h done1 & c\ld d1 !mselves4 ,b x is also true1 t out ( ^! feuds & discords1 ! ,lib]al p>ty :i* 0 to be dom9ant 9 ,ox=d took its rise1 soon to a/oni% old-fa%ion$ ,heads ( ,h\ses ) new & deep =ms ( d\bt m audaci\s ?an ,tract>ianism1 & ultimately to ov]?r[ n only ! victori\s au?orities1 b ! anci5t position ( ! ,*ur*1 & to reca/ f top to bottom ! in/itutions ( ! ,univ]sity4 ,! #ac? ( ,febru>y 0 n only ! f9al defeat & conclusion ( ! fir/ /age ( ! movem5t4 ,x 0 ! bir?day ( ! mod]n ,lib]alism ( ,ox=d4 ,b x 0 also a crisis 9 ! hi/ory ( _m lives4 ,f t mom5t1 ! decision ( a numb] ( good & able m51 :o _h once promis$ to be among ! mo/ valuable s]vants ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 became cle>4 ,if x 7 d\btful be=e1 9 _m cases1 :e!r !y w\ld /ay ) h]1 ! d\bt exi/$ no long]4 ,x 0 n[ only a "q ( "t :5 !y w\ld break ! tie & r5\nce _! old allegiance4 ,9 ! bitt]1 & 9 _m cases agonis+ /ruggle :i* !y _h gone ?r\gh z to _! duty to ,god & consci5ce1 a sign seem$ n[ to be giv5 !m :i* !y c\ld n mi/ake4 ,!y 7 invit$1 on "o side1 to come2 !y 7 told /]nly & scornfully1 on ! o!r1 to g4 ,!y c\ld no long] be accus$ ( impati5ce if !y br\ght _! d\bts to an end1 & made up _! m9ds t _! call 0 to submit to ! claims ( ,rome1 t _! place 0 9 its communion4 ,yet !re 0 a pause4 ,x 0 no secret :at 0 com+4 ,b m5 l+]$4 ,x 0 n till ! summ] t ! fir/ drops ( ! /orm began to fall4 ,!n ?r\gh ! autumn & ! next ye>1 fri5ds1 ^: names & =ms 7 famili> 9 ,ox=d1 "o by "o disappe>$ & 7 lo/ to x4 ,fell[%ips1 liv+s1 curacies1 int5d$ c>e]s1 7 giv5 up4 ,mr4 ,w>d w5t4 ,mr4 ,capes1 :o _h long foll[$ ,mr4 ,w>d's l9e1 & _h sp5t 8 private means to build a *ur* ne> ,bridgewat]1 w5t also4 ,mr4 ,oakeley resign$ ,m>g>et ,*apel & w5t4 ,mr4 ,ambrose ,/4 ,john1 ,mr4 ,c(f91 ,mr4 ,dalgairns1 ,mr4 ,fab]1 ,mr4 ,t4 ,meyrick1 ,mr4 ,albany ,*ri/ie1 ,mr4 ,r4 ,simpson ( ,oriel1 7 receiv$ 9 v>i\s places & v>i\s ways1 & 9 ! next ye>1 ,mr4 ,j4,s4 ,nor?cote1 ,mr4 ,j4,b4 ,morris1 ,mr4 ,g4 ,ryd]1 ,mr4 ,david ,lewis4 ,on ! #c;d ( ,octob] #ahde ,mr4 ,newman reque/$ ! ,provo/ ( ,oriel to remove 8 "n f ! books ( ! ,college & ,univ]sity1 b )\t giv+ any reason4 ,! #f? ( ,octob] is ! date ( ! ,adv]tisem5t to ! "w :i* _h occupi$ ,mr4 ,newman ?r\gh ! ye>--! ,essay on ! ,developm5t ( ,*ri/ian ,doctr9e4 ,on ! #h? he 01 z he has told u 9 ! ,apologia1 receiv$ by ,fa!r ,dom9ic1 ! ,passioni/4 ,to ! ,adv]tisem5t are subjo9$ ! foll[+ words3 ,po/script4--,s9ce ! above 0 writt5 ! ,au?or has jo9$ ! ,ca?olic ,*ur*4 ,x 0 8 int5tion & wi% to h c>ri$ 8 volume ?r\gh ! press be=e decid+ f9ally on ?is /ep4 ,b :5 he got "s way 9 ! pr9t+1 he recognis$ 9 himself a conviction ( ! tru? ( ! conclusion1 to :i* ! discussion leads1 s cle> z to preclude fur!r delib]ation4 ,%ortly aft]w>ds circum/ances gave him ! opportunity ( act+ on x1 & he felt t he _h no w>rant = refus+ to act on x4 ,s ! reality ( :at _h be5 s long & (t5 s lightly talk$ ab\t by ^? :o d>$ x1 provok$ x1 or hop$ = x1 _h come inde$2 & a consid]able portion ( ,engli% society le>n$ :at x 0 to be novices 9 a religi\s sy/em1 hi!rto n only ali5 & unkn[n1 b dread$1 or else to h lo/ fri5ds & relatives1 :o 7 sudd5ly trans=m$ into sev]e & uncompromis+ oppon5ts1 speak+ 9 unfamili> t]ms1 & %>ply e/rang$ 9 sympa?ies & rules ( life4 ,"s ( !m1 especially ^? :o _h caught ! _s ( _! lead]1 began life anew1 took _! position z humble le>n]s 9 ! ,roman ,s*ools1 & made ! mo/ absolute sacrifice ( a :ole lifetime t a man c make4 ,to o!rs ! *ange came & 0 accept$ z an emancipation1 n only f ! bonds ( ,anglicanism1 b f ! obligations ( ord]s & prie/ly v[s & devotion4 ,9 "s cases1 :]e !y 7 m>ri$1 !re 0 no help = x4 ,b 9 almo/ all cases !re 0 a great surr5d] ( :at ,engli% life has to (f] to ^? br\ght up 9 x4 ,( ! defeat$ p>ty1 ^? :o rema9$ _h mu* to ?9k ab\t1 betwe5 grief at ! break+ ( old ties1 & ! loss ( de> fri5ds1 & p]plexities ab\t _! own position4 ,! anxiety1 ! sorr[ at diff]+ & p>t+1 seem n[ almo/ extravagant & un9telligible4 ,!re are ^? :o sne] at ! di/ress ( t "t4 ,!re _h n be5 ! same suff]+1 ! same e/rangem5t1 :5 ,*ur*m5 turn$ diss5t]s1 l ,bulteel & ,bapti/ ,noel4 ,b ! movem5t _h rais$ ! :ole scale ( feel+ ab\t religi\s matt]s s high1 ! que/ions 7 felt to be s mom5t\s1 ! /ake & ! issue s preci\s1 ! ,loss & ,ga9 s imm5se1 t to diff] on su* subjects 0 ! diff]+ on ! greate/ ?+s :i* m5 c\ld diff] ab\t4 ,b 9 a "t ( di/ress1 ( :i* few analog\s situations 9 our days c give ! measure1 ! lead]s /ood firm4 ,dr4 ,pusey1 ,mr4 ,keble1 ,mr4 ,m>riott accept$1 ) un%ak5 fai? 9 ! cause ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 ! t]rible sep>ation4 ,!y submitt$ to ! bl[--submitt$ to ! reproa* ( hav+ be5 associates ( ^? :o _h betray$ hopes & done s mu* mis*ief2 submitt$ to ! *>ge ( inconsi/5cy1 ins9c]ity1 c[>dice2 b !y did n fl9*4 ,_! un%r9k+ attitude 0 a new po9t ( dep>ture = ^? :o believ$ 9 ! ,ca?olic f\ndation ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,among ^? deeply affect$ by ^! *anges1 !re 7 _m :o _h be5 absolutely un9flu5c$ by ! /rong ,roman curr5t4 ,!y _h recognis$ _m good ?+s 9 ! ,roman ,*ur*2 !y 7 fully alive to _m %ortcom+s 9 ! ,engli% ,*ur*2 b ! possibility ( submission to ! ,roman claims _h nev] be5 a "q ) !m4 ,a typical example ( su* m9ds 0 ,mr4 ,isaac ,williams1 a pupil ( ,mr4 ,keble1 an intimate fri5d ( ,mr4 ,newman1 a man ( simple & sa9tly life1 ) he>t & s\l /eep$ 9 ! anci5t !ology ( undivid$ ,*ri/5dom1 & = t v reason untempt$ by ! new] pr9ciples & fa%ions ( ,rome4 ,!re 7 numb]s :o ?\ght l him2 b !re 7 o!rs also1 :o 7 =c$ 9 afre% ^u !mselves1 & :o _h to ask !mselves :y !y /ay$1 :5 a tea*]1 to :om !y _h look$ up z !y _h to ,mr4 ,newman1 & into ^: confid5ce !y _h be5 admitt$1 ?\ght x 8 duty to g4 ,) "s ! ultimate1 ?\gh delay$1 decision 0 to foll[ him4 ,) o!rs1 ! old & fair proejudicium aga9/ ! claims ( ,rome1 :i* _h always ass]t$ itself ev5 aga9/ ! /r+5t logic ( ,mr4 ,w>d & ! deep & subtle ideas ( ,mr4 ,newman1 became1 :5 clos$ )1 & te/$ face to face 9 ! light ( fact & hi/ory1 ! settl$ conviction ( life4 ,"s extracts f contempor>y pap]s1 real records ( ! private p]plexities & tr\bles actually felt at ! "t1 may illu/rate :at 0 pass+ 9 ! m9ds ( "s :om k & love ( ,mr4 ,newman fail$ to make 8 foll[]s 9 8 ultimate /ep4 ,! fir/ extract belongs to "s ye>s be=e1 b x is "p ( ! same tra9 ( ?9k+4#abd ,z to myself1 ,i am gett+ into a v unsettl$ /ate z to aims & prospects4 ,i mean t z ?+s are go+ on1 a man does n "k :]e he is go+ to2 "o _c imag9e :at /ate ( ?+s to look =w>d to2 9 :at way1 & "u :at circum/ances1 "o's com+ life--if x does come--is to be sp5t2 :at is to become ( "o4 ,i _c at all imag9e myself a conv]t2 b h[ am ,i likely1 9 ! probable /ate ( ?+s1 to be able to s]ve z an ,engli% cl]gyman8 ,%all ,i ev] get ,prie/'s ord]s8 ,%all ,i be able to cont9ue always s]v+8 ,:at is "o's l9e to be2 :at ought to be "o's aims2 or c "o h any8 ,! /orm is n yet come3 h[ x may come1 & h[ soon x may bl[ ov]1 & :at x may leave beh9d1 is d\btful2 b "s sort ( crisis1 ,i ?9k1 mu/ come be=e ?+s settle4 ,) ! ,bi%ops aga9/ u1 & ,puritanism aggressive1 we may see /range ?+s be=e ! end4 ,:5 ! /orm _h at l5g? come1 ?\gh1 be=e its f9al viol5ce1 ! same writ] cont9ues3 ,! pres5t hopeless *eck & weight to our p>ty--:at has = ! "t absolutely cru%$ u--is ! total loss ( confid5ce aris+ f ! /rong t5d5cy1 no long] to be dissembl$ or expla9$ away1 among _m ( u to ,rome4 ,i see no *ance ( our recov]y1 or gett+ our heads above wat] f ?is1 at lea/ 9 ,engl&1 = ye>s to come4 ,& x is a *eck :i* w "o day be f> great] ?an x is n[4 ,"u ! circum/ances--hav+ n ! mo/ di/ant ?\ght ( leav+ ! ,engli% ,*ur* myself1 & yet hav+ no means ( escap+ ! v natural suspicion ( ,romanis+ )\t giv+ up my be/ fri5ds & ! mo/ sa9t-l m5 9 ,engl&--h[ am ,i to view my position8 ,:at am ,i witness+ to8 ,:at1 if ne$ be1 is "o to suff] =8 ,a man has no lean+ t[>ds ,rome1 does n feel1 z o!rs d1 ! /r5g? ( h] exclusive claims to allegiance1 ! p]fection ( h] sy/em1 its "r s to ov]balance all ! good f\nd 9 ours z to make ours absolutely untru/wor?y = a ,*ri/ian to re/ 91 not)/&+ all circum/ances ( habit1 position1 & national "*2 has su* d\bts on ! ,roman !ory ( ! ,*ur*1 ! ,ultramontane1 & su* in/9cts n only aga9/ _m ( _! popul> religi\s cu/oms & practical ways ( go+ on1 b aga9/ _! pr9ciples ( belief 7e4g4 div9e fai? relics71 z to repel him f any wi% to sacrifice 8 own communion = !irs2 yet )al1 & )\t any great "r on 8 "p to compla91 is set d[n z a man :o may any day1 & c]ta9ly w "s day1 g ov]2 & he has no lawful means ( remov+ ! suspicion3--:y is x tanti to submit to ?is8 ,h[ev] little sympa?y we ,engli%m5 h ) ,rome1 ! ,we/]n ,*ur*es "u ,rome are really liv+ & holy bran*es ( ! ,*ur* ,ca?olic2 corruptions !y may h1 s may we2 b putt+ ^! aside1 !y are ,ca?olic ,*ri/ians1 or ,ca?olic ,*ri/ianity has fail$ out ( ! _w3 we are no m ,ca?olic ?an !y4 ,b ?is1 public op9ion has n = c5turies1 & does n n[1 realise or all[4 ,s no "o c express 9 reality & detail a practical belief 9 _! ,ca?olicity1 9 _! equality 7sett+ "o ?+ aga9/ ano!r7 ) u z ,*ri/ians1 )\t be+ suspect$ ( :at su* belief cont9ually leads to--disloyalty to ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,yet su* belief is nev]!less well-gr\nd$ & "r1 & !re is no great hope = ! ,*ur* till x ga9s gr\nd1 sob]ly1 p[]fully1 & ap>t f all l[ views ( proselytis+1 or fe> ( dang]4 ,:at !re=e ! disadvantage ( ^? among u :o d n really des]ve ! imputation ( ,romanis+ may be meant =1 is to break ?is practical belief to ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,we may be sil5c$1 b1 )\t any wi% to leave ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 we _c give up ! belief1 t ! ,we/]n ,*ur* "u ,rome is a true1 liv+1 v5]able bran* ( ! ,*ri/ian ,*ur*4 ,!re are dang]s 9 su* a belief1 b !y mu/ be provid$ aga9/1 !y d n affect ! tru? ( ! belief4 ,su* se>*+s ( he>t 7 necess>ily r5d]$ m sev]e & acute by ,mr4 ,newman's act4 ,!re 0 no long] any respite2 8 de>e/ fri5ds mu/ *oose betwe5 him & ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,& ! *oice 0 made1 by ^? :o did n foll[ him1 on a pr9ciple little hon\r$ or believ$ 9 at ! "t on ei!r side1 ,roman or ,prote/ant2 b a pr9ciple :i* 9 ! long-run re/or$ hope & en]gy to a cause :i* 0 suppos$ to be lo/4 ,x 0 n ! revival ( ! old ,via ,m$ia2 x 0 n ! ass]tion ( ! sup]iority ( ! ,engli% ,*ur*2 x 0 n a return to ! old-fa%ion$ & ung5]\s me?ods ( controv]sy ) ,rome--"o-sid$ 9 all cases1 ignorant1 co>se1 un*ri/ian 9 _m4 ,x 0 n ! proposal ( a new !ory ( ! ,*ur*--its functions1 au?ority & tea*+1 a c\nt]-ideal to ,mr4 ,w>d's impos+ ,ideal ,x 0 ! resolute & s]i\s appeal f brilliant logic1 & ke5 s>casm1 & pa!tic & impressive eloqu5ce1 to reality & exp]i5ce1 z well z to hi/ory1 z to ! positive & sub/antial *>act]i/ics ( ! traditional & actually exi/+ ,engli% ,*ur*1 %[n n on pap] b 9 "w1 & 9 spite ( contradictory appe>ances & inconsi/5t elem5ts2 & along ) ?is1 an attempt to put 9 a fair & j light ! comp>ative excell5ces & defects ( o!r p>ts ( ,*ri/5dom1 excell5ces to be ungrudg+ly admitt$1 b n to be all[$ to b> ! recognition ( defects4 ,! feel+ :i* _h (t5 /irr$1 ev5 :5 ?+s look$ at ! wor/1 t ,mr4 ,newman _h dealt unequally & h>dly ) ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 return$ ) ga!r$ /r5g?4 ,! ,engli% ,*ur* 0 aft] all z well wor? liv+ 9 & fight+ = z any o!r2 x 0 n only 9 ,engl& t light & d>k1 9 tea*+ & 9 life1 7 l>gely int]m+l$1 & ! mixture _h to be l>gely all[$ =4 ,we _h our ,sp>ta1 a noble1 if a r\gh & an incomplete "o2 pati5tly to d our be/ = x 0 bett] ?an leav+ x to its fate1 9 ob$i5ce to signs & reason+s :i* ! heat ( /rife might well make delusive4 ,x 0 "o hopeful tok51 t boa/+ _h to be put away f u = a long "t to come4 ,9 ^! days ( /ress & sorr[ 7 laid ! beg9n+s ( a s*ool1 ^: ma9 purpose 0 to see ?+s z !y are2 :i* _h le>n$ by exp]i5ce to di/ru/ unqualifi$ admiration & unqualifi$ disp>agem5t2 det]m9$ n to be bl9d$ ev5 by g5ius to pla9 c]ta9ties2 n afraid to hon\r all t is great & b5efic5t 9 ,rome1 n afraid ) ,engli% frankness to criticise freely at home2 b n to be won ov]1 9 "o case1 by ! good ?+s1 to condone & accept ! bad ?+s2 & n det]r$1 9 ! o!r1 f s]vice1 f love1 f self-sacrifice1 by ! pres5ce ( mu* to regret & to resi/4 ,all ?is new s5se ( indep5d5ce1 aris+ f ! s5se ( hav+ be5 left almo/ desolate by ! disappe>ance ( a great /ay & light 9 m5's daily life1 l$ to v>i\s & diff]5t results4 ,9 "s m9ds1 aft] a c]ta9 trial1 x actually l$ m5 back to t ,romew>d t5d5cy f :i* !y _h at fir/ recoil$4 ,9 o!rs1 ! break-up ( ! movem5t "u su* a *ief l$ !m on1 m or less1 & "s v f>1 into a c>e] ( speculative ,lib]alism l t ( ,mr4 ,blanco ,:ite1 ! publication ( ^: biography co9cid$ ) ,mr4 ,newman's *ange4 ,9 _m o!rs1 especially 9 ,london & ! t[ns1 x l$ to new & increas+ ef=ts to popul>ise 9 v>i\s ways--?r\gh prea*+1 organisation1 great] att5tion to ! mean+1 ! solemnities1 & ! fitnesses ( wor%ip--! ideas ( ! ,*ur* movem5t4 ,dr4 ,pusey & ,mr4 ,keble 7 /ill ! recognis$ *iefs ( ! cont9u$ yet remodell$ movem5t4 ,x _h its qu>t]ly organ1 ! ,*ri/ian ,remembranc]1 :i* _h tak5 ! place ( ! old ,briti% ,critic 9 ! autumn ( #ahdd4 ,a numb] ( able ,cambridge m5 _h ?r[n _! k & ?or\ghness ( "w into ! ,ecclesiologi/4 ,!re 7 newspap]s--! ,engli% ,*ur*man1 &1 />t+ 9 #ahdf f small & difficult beg9n+s1 9 ! face ( long disc\ragem5t & at times despair1 ! ,gu>dian4 ,"o m9d ( great & r>e p[]1 ?\gh only recognis$ = :at he 0 mu* lat] 9 8 life1 "o undaunt$ he>t1 undismay$1 almo/ undepress$1 s t ^? :o knew n its inn] fires ?\ght him cold & /oical1 _h lift$ itself above ! wreck at ,ox=d4 ,! %ock :i* _h c[$ & almo/ cru%$ "s ( ,mr4 ,newman's fri5ds r\s$ & fir$ ,mr4 ,james ,mozley4 ,to take leave ( ,mr4 ,newman 7he writes on ! morr[ ( ! ev5t7 is a heavy task4 ,8 /ep 0 n un=ese52 b :5 x is come ^? :o knew him feel ! fact z a real *ange )9 !m--feel z if !y 7 ent]+ ^u a fre% /age ( _! own life4 ,may t v *ange turn to _! pr(it1 & discipl9e !m by its h>dness6 ,x may d s if !y w use x s4 ,let nobody compla92 a "t mu/ come1 soon] or lat]1 9 e "o's life1 :5 he has to "p ) advantages1 connexions1 supports1 consolations1 t he has _h hi!rto1 & face a new /ate ( ?+s4 ,e "o kn[s t he is n always to h all t he has n[3 he says to himself1 ,:at %all ,i d :5 ?is or t /ay1 or connexion1 is gone8 & ! answ] is1 ,t he w d )\t x4 444 ,! "t comes :5 ?is is tak5 away2 & !n ! m9d is left alone1 & is ?r[n back ^u itself1 z ! expression is4 ,b no religi\s m9d tol]ates ! notion ( be+ really ?r[n ^u itself2 ?is is only to say 9 o!r words1 t x is ?r[n back ^u ,god4444 ,secret m5tal consolations1 :e!r ( innoc5t self-flatt]y or repos+ confid5ce1 are ov]2 a m real & grav] life beg9s--a firm]1 h>d] dis9t]e/$ness1 able to g on its c\rse by itself4 ,let !m see 9 ! *ange a call to great] e>ne/ness1 s9c]] simplicity1 & m solid manl9ess4 ,:at 7 weaknesses be=e w be s9s n[4#abe ,a new /age has begun4 ,let no "o compla93--?is1 ! expression ( individual feel+1 repres5ts pretty accurately ! temp] into :i* ! ,*ur* p>ty settl$ :5 ! fir/ %ock 0 ov]4 ,!y knew t h5ce=w>d !y _h difficult times be=e !m4 ,!y knew t !y mu/ "w "u suspicion1 ev5 "u proscription4 ,!y knew t !y mu/ expect to see m5 among !mselves p]plex$1 unsettl$1 swept away by ! influ5ces :i* _h affect$ ,mr4 ,newman1 & /ill m by ! prec$5t ( 8 example4 ,!y knew t !y mu/ be prep>$ to lose fri5ds & fell[-help]s1 & to lose !m sometimes unexpect$ly & sudd5ly1 z ! wont 0 s (t5 at ?is "t4 ,above all1 !y knew t !y _h a new =m ( antagonism to reckon )1 h>d] ?an any !y _h yet enc\nt]$4 ,x _h ! peculi> sad bitt]ness :i* belongs to civil w>1 :5 m5's foes are !y ( _! own h\seholds--! bitt]ness aris+ out ( int]rupt$ intimacy & affection4 ,nei!r side c\ld be held blameless2 ! *>ge f ! "o ( betrayal & des]tion 0 answ]$ by ! *>ge f ! o!r ( ins9c]ity & fai?lessness to consci5ce1 & by natural b n always v fair attempts to proselytise2 & und\bt$ly1 ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 & ^? :o adh]$ to x1 _h1 = "s ye>s aft] #ahde1 to he> f ! lips ( old fri5ds ! mo/ cruel & m]ciless invectives :i* k ( h] weak po9ts1 wit1 argum5tative p[]1 eloqu5ce1 & ! triumphant exultation at once ( deliv]ance & sup]iority c\ld frame4 ,x 0 su* writ+ & su* prea*+ z _h c]ta9ly nev] be5 se5 on ! ,roman side be=e1 at lea/ 9 ,engl&4 ,:e!r x 0 adapt$ to its pr(ess$ purpose may p]haps be d\bt$2 b ! m5 :o w5t c]ta9ly lo/ none ( _! vig\r z controv]siali/s or _! culture z s*ol>s4 ,n to speak ( ,mr4 ,newman1 su* m5 z ,mr4 ,oakeley1 ,mr4 ,w>d1 ,mr4 ,fab]1 & ,mr4 ,dalgairns m ?an fulfill$ 9 ! great _w ( ,london _! reputation at ,ox=d4 ,?is 0 all 9 prospect be=e ! eyes ( ^? :o _h elect$ to ca/ 9 _! lot ) ! ,engli% ,*ur*4 ,x 0 n an enc\rag+ position4 ,! old en?usia/ic sangu95ess _h be5 effectually qu5*$4 ,_! ,lib]al critics & _! ,lib]al fri5ds h h>dly yet ceas$ to rem9d !m h[ sorry a figure !y cut 9 ! eyes ( m5 ( ! _w1 & 9 ! eyes ( m5 ( bold & effective ?9k+4#abf ,! poor ,puseyites are spok5 ( 9 tones half ( pity & half ( sne]4 ,_! "p seem$ play$ out4 ,!re seem$ no?+ m to make !m ( importance4 ,!y _h n succe$$ 9 ,ca?olicis+ ! ,engli% ,*ur*1 !y _h n ev5 %ak5 x by a wide secession4 ,h5ce=? !y 7 only m>k$ m54 ,all t c\ld be said = !m 01 t at ! wor/1 !y did n lose he>t4 ,!y _h n =gott5 ! lessons ( _! e>li] "t4 ,x is n my purpose to pursue f>!r ! c\rse ( ! movem5t4 ,all ! _w kn[s t x 0 n1 9 fact1 kill$ or ev5 mu* arre/$ by ! %ock ( #ahde4 ,b aft] #ahde1 its field 0 at lea/ z mu* out ( ,ox=d z 9 x4 ,z long z ,mr4 ,newman rema9$1 ,ox=d 0 necess>ily its c5tre1 necess>ily1 ev5 aft] he _h seem$ to )draw f x4 ,:5 he left 8 place vacant1 ! direction ( x 0 n remov$ f ,ox=d1 b x 0 l>gely %>$ by m5 9 ,london & ! c\ntry4 ,x ceas$ to be /rongly & prom95tly ,academical4 ,no "o 9 de$ held su* a position z ,dr4 ,pusey's & ,mr4 ,keble's2 b ?\gh ,dr4 ,pusey cont9u$ to be a great p[] at ,ox=d1 he n[ became e day a mu* great] p[] outside ( x2 :ile ,mr4 ,keble 0 n[ less ?an ev] an ,academic1 & became m & m closely connect$ ) m5 out ( ,ox=d1 8 fri5ds 9 ,london & 8 neighb\rs at ,hursley & ,w9*e/]4 ,! cause :i* ,mr4 ,newman _h giv5 up 9 despair 0 f\nd to be deeply int]e/+ 9 ev] new p>ts ( ! c\ntry3 & x pass$ gradually into ! h&s ( new lead]s m widely acqua9t$ ) ,engli% society4 ,x pass$ into ! h&s ( ! ,wilb]=ces1 & ,ar*deacon ,mann+2 ( ,mr4 ,b5nett1 ,mr4 ,dodswor?1 ,mr4 ,w4 ,scott1 ,dr4 ,irons1 ,mr4 ,e4 ,hawk9s1 & ,mr4 ,upton ,ri*>ds 9 ,london4 ,x _h ! sympa?y & c\nsels ( m5 ( weight1 or m5 :o 7 ris+ into em95ce & importance--"s ( ! ,judges1 ,mr4 ,glad/one1 ,mr4 ,r\ndell ,palm]1 ,mr4 ,fr$]ic ,rog]s1 ,mr4 ,m\ntague ,b]n>d1 ,mr4 ,hope ,scott 7z he aft]w>ds 071 ,mr4 ,badeley1 & a brilliant recruit f ,cambridge1 ,mr4 ,b]es=d ,hope4 ,x attract$ ! sympa?y ( ano!r boa/ ( ,cambridge1 ! great ,bi%op ( ,new ,zeal&1 & 8 fri5d ,mr4 ,:ytehead4 ,^? times 7 ! l9k betwe5 :at we are n[1 s *ang$ 9 _m ways1 & ! orig9al impulse giv5 at ,ox=d2 b to ^? times ,i am z mu* ( an outsid] z mo/ ( ! =emo/ 9 !m 7 outsid]s to ,ox=d 9 ! e>li] days4 ,^? times are almo/ m important ?an ! hi/ory ( ! movem5t2 =1 besides v9dicat+ x1 !y c>ri$ on its "w to a*ievem5ts & successes :i*1 ev5 9 ! mo/ sangu9e days ( ,tract>ianism1 _h n pres5t$ !mselves to m5's m9ds1 mu* less to _! hopes4 ,b t /ory mu/ be told by o!rs4 ,%[ ?y s]vants ?y "w1 & _! *ildr5 ?y glory4 ,,footnotes3 #abd ,comp>e ,mozley's ,rem9isc5ces1 ii4 #a-c4 #abe ,*ri/ian ,remembranc]1 ,janu>y #ahdf1 pp4 #afg1 #afh4 #abf ,e4g4 ! ,w>d5 ( ,m]ton's ,hi/ory ( ! ,univ]sity ( ,ox=d1 p4 #bab4 ,! fir/ panic 0 succe$$ by a reaction2 "s devot$ adh]5ts foll[$ him 7,mr4 ,newman7 to ,rome2 o!rs relaps$ into lifeless con=mity2 & ! ,univ]sity soon resum$ its wont$ tranquillity4 ,lifeless con=mity s\nds odd connect$ ) ,dr4 ,pusey or ,mr4 ,j4,b4 ,mozley1 & ! ,london m5 :o 7 ! f\nd]s ( ! s-call$ ,rituali/ s*ools4 ,,index ,addresses to ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury1 by cl]gy & laity ,anglicanism1 its features 9 #ahcj ,newman's views on ,newman's int]pretation ( ,apologia1 quotations f ,apo/olic ,succession ,newman's insi/5ce on its f\ndation on ,pray] ,book ,apo/olitity ( ,engli% ,*ur* ,ar*bi%op ( ,cant]bury4 ,see ,addresses1 & ,h[ley ,arians1 ! ,arnold1 ,dr41 !ories on ! ,*ur* 8 proposal to unite all sects by law attack on ,tract>ians ,pr(essor%ip at ,ox=d 8 influ5ce %[n 9 rise ( ?ird s*ool ,articles1 !1 & ,diss5t]s subscription (4 ,see ,dr4 ,hampd51 & ,?irty-n9e ,articles ,baptism1 ,tract on ,bapti/]y1 ! ,b5nett1 ,mr4 ,b5?am4 see ,utilit>ianism ,b]n>d1 ,mr4 ,m\ntague ,bi%oprics1 suppression ( t5 ,iri% ,bi%ops' attitude to movem5t ! fir/ ,tract on ,bla*=d1 ,"l1 rem9isc5ces ( ,fr\de ,bliss1 ,james ,blomfield1 ,bi%op ,briti% ,association1 a sign ( ! times ,briti% ,critic on ! movem5t ,briti% ,magaz9e ,br\gham1 ,"l ,buns51 ,m41 & ! ,bi%opric ( ,j]usalem ,burton1 ,dr4 ,cambridge1 critical s*ool ( !ology ,capes1 ,mr4 ,c>dwell1 ,dr4 ,cata/rophe1 ! ,ca?olicity ( ,engli% ,*ur* ,ca?olicus's lett]s to ! ,times ,celibacy1 obs]vations on ,celibate cl]gy s*eme ,*anges 9 movem5t ,*ri/ian ,remembranc] ,*ri/ian ,ye> ,*ri/ianity1 ,*ur* ( ,engl&1 two s*ools ( ,*ri/ie1 ,albany ,*ri/ie1 ,j4,f4 ,*ur*1 !1 9 eighte5? c5tury ,dr4 ,:ately's !ories on ,dr4 ,arnold's !ories ,col]idge's !ories ,apo/olic orig9 ( v>i\s conceptions ( political attacks on public m9d indiff]5t to ,dr4 ,pusey's !ories on !ological aspect ( practical aspect ( & ! ,roman "q ,ca?olicity ( & ! doctr9e ( ,developm5t ,*ur* ( ! ,fa!rs ,*ur*man's ,manual ,scot* ,bi%ops on ,*urton1 ,mr4 7( ,crayke7 ,claughton1 ,mr4 ,pi]s ,cl]gy ( eighte5? c5tury1 "* ( ,close1 ,dr4 7( ,*elt5ham7 ,c(f91 ,mr4 ,col]idge1 ,mr4 ,ju/ice ,col]idge1 ,s4,t41 influ5ce on ,*>les ,m>riott ,*ur* !ories ,cons]vative ,j\rnal1 ,newman's language t[>ds ,rome ,copel&1 ,william ,john ,corni%1 ,c4,l4 ,cre$s1 !1 pamphlets on au?ority ( ,dalgairns1 ,mr4 ,defeats1 ! ,?ree1 #cab-cce4 ,see also ,isaac ,williams1 ,macmull51 & ,pusey ,dick9son1 ,dr41 ,pa/oral ,epi/le f 8 ,hol9ess ! ,pope ,diffusion ( ,useful ,k ,society ,diss5t]s & ! ,articles4 ,see also ,?irty-n9e ,articles ,dodswor?1 ,mr4 ,dom9ic1 ,fa!r1 receives ,newman into ,*ur* ( ,rome ,donk91 ,mr4 ,doyle1 ,sir ,f41 on ,newman's s]mons ,ecclesiologi/ f\nd$ ,ed51 ,c4,p4 ,ed9burgh ,review1 article by ,dr4 ,arnold on ,tract>ians ,elucidations ( ,dr4 ,hampd5's ,!ological ,/atem5ts ,engli% ,*ur*man f\nd$ ,evangelicism 9 #ahcj1 "* ( ,fab]1 ,francis ,fab]1 ,fr$]ic ,fa/+1 ,tract on ,faussett1 ,dr4 attack on ,dr4 ,pusey ,fr\de1 ,ri*>d ,hurrell pupil ( ,keble ,fell[ ( ,oriel fir/ meet+ ) ,newman e>ly e/imate ( ,newman travels ) ,newman influ5ce on ! movem5t 8 sev]e self-discipl9e "* ,mozley's rem>ks on correspond5ce 8 ,rema9s publi%$ effect ( publication a mod]n e/imate ( ! ,rema9s ev5ts ( #ahcj !ory ( ! ,*ur* s]mons & writ+s ,"l ,bla*=d's rem9isc5ces ( ,fr\de1 ,william ,g>bett1 ,mr41 elect$ ,pr(essor ( ,poetry ,gilb]t1 ,dr4 ,glad/one1 ,mr4 ,golightly1 ,mr4 ,gorham1 ,mr4 ,gramm> ( ,ass5t on ,fai? & ,reason ,gre5hill1 ,dr4 ,gu>dian f\nd$ ,guillem>d1 ,mr4 ,haddan1 ,a4 ,hadleigh1 ,conf]5ce ( lead]s at policy adopt$ ,hampd51 ,dr4 advocates abolition ( subscription ( ,articles 8 election z ,pr(essor ( ,div9ity outcry aga9/ election ( ,bampton ,lectures s-call$ p]secution ( mod]n e/imate ( ! p]secution depriv$ ( vote = ,select ,prea*]s 8 action 9 ! ,b4,d4 degree conte/ ,h>e1 ,julius ,hawk9s1 ,dr4 ,hawk9s1 ,e4 ,hill1 ,mr4 ,hobh\se1 ,mr4 ,holl& ,h\se ,home ,?\ghts ,abroad ,hook1 ,dr4 ,hope1 ,mr4 ,b]es=d ,h[ley1 ,ar*bi%op ,hussey1 ,mr4 ,ideal ( a ,*ri/ian ,*ur*1 ,see ,w4,g4 ,w>d ,infallibility1 views on ,irons1 ,dr4 ,jebb1 ,bi%op ,jelf1 ,dr4 ,j5kyns1 ,dr4 ,j]usalem1 ,bi%opric ( ,j]usalem1 ,bi%opric (1 ,newman's prote/ aga9/ ,jolly1 ,bi%op ,j[ett1 ,mr4 ,kaye1 ,bi%op ,keble1 ,john brilliant ,ox=d c>e] suspicions ( ,evangelicism a /rong ,tory 8 poetic nature influ5ce on ,fr\de 8 pupils s]mon on ,national ,apo/asy tract on ,my/icism ( ! ,fa!rs resigns ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip ,keble1 ,?omas ,knox1 ,alex&] ,law's ,s]i\s ,call1 ,keble's rem>k on ,le ,bas1 ,mr4 ,lectures on ,ju/ification1 ,newman's1 influ5ce ( ,lett] to ! ,bi%op ( ,ox=d1 ,newman's ,lett]s ( an ,episcopalian ,lewis1 ,d4 ,libr>y ( ! ,fa!rs ,lloyd's1 ,bi%op1 ,lectures1 influ5ce ( ,l[e1 ,r4 ,lyall1 ,mr4 ,lyra ,apo/olica ,macmull51 ,mr4 8 conte/ on ,b4,d4 degree ,mann+1 ,ar*deacon ,m>riott1 ,*>les influ5c$ by ,col]idge & ,dr4 ,hampd5 av]sion to p>ty action ,s*ol> ( ,balliol ,fell[ ( ,oriel ,newman's influ5ce on ,mob]ly's influ5ce on ,pr9cipal ( ,*i*e/] ,!ological ,college s*eme ( poor /ud5ts' hall ,tutor ( ,oriel ,vic> ( ,/4 ,m>y's 8 s]mons rooms & p>ties %>e 9 ,libr>y ( ! ,fa!rs ,mozley's e/imate ( dea? ,m>%1 ,bi%op ,m>tyrs' ,memorial1 connexion ) ! movem5t ,maurice1 ,f4,d41 views ( ,melb\rne1 ,"l ,meyrick1 ,t4 ,mill]1 ,john 7( ,worce/]71 ,bampton ,lectures1 influ5ce ( ,mob]ly1 ,dr4 7( ,w9*e/]7 ,monophysite ,controv]sy ,morris1 ,john ,br&e ,mozley1 ,james on ,newman's s]mons on ,no4 #ij ,mozley1 ,?omas on ,*>les ,m>riott on ,fr\de ,my/icism ( ! ,fa!rs 9 ! use & int]pretation ( ,scripture1 ,keble's ,tract on ,national ,apo/asy1 ,keble's s]mon on ,newman1 ,john ,h5ry-- 8 e>ly prea*+ meet+ ) ,fr\de ,fr\de's e>ly e/imate ( on ,apo/olic ,succession1 q4v4 on ,infallibility attitude at diff]5t times to ,rome e>ly fri5ds fir/ ,tract1 writt5 by 8 f\r o'clock s]mons *ief coadjutors ( views on subscription ( ,articles on ,dr4 ,hampd5's !ology "* ,lectures ,lectures on ,ju/ification ,anglicanism1 views on resigns ,/4 ,m>y's n a proselytis] ,lett] to ,bi%op ( ,ox=d int]pretation ( ,*ur* =mul>ies on ! ,articles1 ,see ,no4 #ij ,essay on ! ,developm5t ( ,*ri/ian ,doctr9e jo9s ,*ur* ( ,rome ,nicknames ,no4 #ij ,newman's attitude on object to def5d ,ca?olicity ( ! ,articles its reception *>ge ( di%one/y aga9/ condemn$ by ,bo>d ( ,heads pamphlet w> on ! crisis ( ! movem5t ev5ts aft] ,oakeley1 ,mr4 article on ,jewel ,ogilvie1 ,dr4 ,ord9ation1 validity ( ,orig9es ,liturgicae ,ox=d1 ,lib]al ,s*ool ( ,!ology ,or?odoxy z a ,*ur* ,s*ool ,ox=d ,movem5t-- political conditions ( beg9n+s ( ,keble ! prim>y au?or ( e>ly writ+s t[>ds ! lead]s =c$ on ! orig9ators object ( accession ( ,dr4 ,pusey & 8 influ5ce gradual gr[? ( attitude to ,romanism *anges 9 t5d5cy to ,romanism 9 orig9 anti-,roman attitude ( ,univ]sity au?orities t[>ds attitude ( ,bi%ops t[>ds mi/akes 9 conduct ( ,ox=d ,movem5t-- rise ( ?ird s*ool secessions to ,rome ,palm]1 ,william1 %>e 9 movem5t ,orig9es ,liturgicae ,n>rative ,treatise on ! ,*ur* ( ,*ri/ ,palm]1 ,mr4 ,r\ndell ,p>k1 ,judge ,allan ,p>o*ial ,s]mons ,pattison1 ,m>k ,peel1 ,sir ,rob]t ,p]ceval1 ,a41 %>e 9 movem5t ,phillpotts1 ,bi%op ,pla9 ,s]mons ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip1 conte/ =1 made a !ological "o ,prophetical ,(fice ( ! ,*ur* ,prospects ( ! ,anglican ,*ur* ,newman's aft]-?\ghts on ,pusey1 ,dr4 jo9s ! movem5t effect ( 8 adhesion 8 ,remon/rance tract on ,baptism attack on him s]mon on ! ,holy ,eu*>i/ delat$ to ,vice-,*ancellor unfairness ( proce$+s aga9/ memorial to ,vice-,*ancellor1 on 8 case ,records ( ! ,*ur* ,re=m days1 /ate ( ,*ur* ,re=m]s1 e>ly1 views ( ,remon/rance ,res]ve 9 communicat+ ,religi\s ,k1 ,isaac ,williams's tract on ,ri*>ds1 ,mr4 ,upton ,rog]s1 ,fr$]ic ,romanism & ,popul> ,prote/antism ,romanism misconceptions ( ,newman's attitude t[>ds t5d5cy 9 p>ty ( movem5t t[>ds ,rose1 ,hugh ,james an e/imate ( lectures on ,g]man speculation controv]sy ) ,dr4 ,pusey e>ly dea? ,r\?1 ,dr4 ,ru/icus1 pamphlets by ,ryd]1 ,g4 ,/4 ,john1 ,mr4 ,ambrose ,scott1 ,mr4 ,hope ,scott1 ,w4 ,seag]1 ,*>les ,selwyn1 ,bi%op ,sewell1 ,william ,%airp1 ,pr9cipal1 on ,newman's s]mons ,sikes1 ,mr4 7( ,guilsbor\gh7 ,simpson1 ,mr4 ,/anley1 ,mr4 ,ar?ur ,/]l+1 ,john ,subscription4 ,see ,?irty-n9e ,articles ,sumn]1 ,j4 ,bird1 ,bi%op ,symons1 ,dr4 opposition to1 z ,vice-,*ancellor ,tait1 ,mr4 7( ,balliol7 ,!ologians ( #ahcj ,?ird p>ty 9 ,*ur*-- rise ( influ5ce ,?irlwall1 ,connop ,?irty-n9e ,articles1 subscription ( ,dr4 ,hampd5 & subscription pamphlet w> on subscription ,newman on subscription _! ,ca?olicity ,& see ,w4,g4 ,w>d ,no4 #ij on ,?omas1 ,vaughan ,times1 lett]s ( ,ca?olicus to ,tott5ham1 ,e4 ,tract>ian doctr9es1 discussion ( ,movem5t4 ,see ,ox=d ,tract>ians1 excitem5t aga9/ ,tract1 text ( ! fir/ ,tracts1 !-- topics ( mode ( circulat+ reception ( accus$ ( ,romanism fir/ volume ( lat] numb]s1 "* ( public op9ion aga9/ ,no4 #ij1 q4v4 contributors to on ,res]ve1 q4v4 on ,my/icism1 q4v4 ,treatise on ! ,*ur* ( ,*ri/ ,utilit>ianism1 influ5ce on religi\s belief ,via ,m$ia ,wall1 ,mr4 ,w>d1 ,w4,g4 dismiss$ f ,balliol ,lecture%ip writ+s on ,romanism 8 criticisms ( ,engli% ,*ur* ,ideal ( a ,*ri/ian ,*ur* on ,no4 #ij on ! ,articles ho/ility to ,lu!ranism 8 philosophy ( religion 8 book condemn$ himself degrad$ jo9s ,*ur* ( ,rome ,watson1 ,jo%ua ,well+ton1 ,duke ( ,:ately1 ,dr4-- !ories on ,*ur* oppos$ to ,tract>ians ,lett]s ( an ,episcopalian ,:ite1 ,blanco ,:ytehead1 ,mr4 ,wilb]=ce1 ,h5ry ,wilb]=ce1 ,rob]t ,williams1 ,isaac ,williams1 ,isaac1 ,keble's influ5ce on ,fell[ ( ,tr9ity connexion ) ,newman div]g5ces f ,newman contributions to ,pla9 ,s]mons av]sion to ,rome 8 poetry defeat$ = ,poetry ,pr(essor%ip ,tract on ,res]ve ,wilson1 ,h4,b4 ,wilson1 ,r4,f4 ,wiseman1 ,dr4 article on ,donati/s ,wood1 ,s4,f4 ,woodgate1 ,mr4 ,wordswor?1 ,dr4 ,wynt]1 ,dr4 ,,! ,,end