,! ,SEIG5?AL] 9CID5T AL CALL$ ! ,SEIG5?AL] BIOGRAPHY 3TROV]SY 0 ,WIKIP$IA'S F/ REPUTA;N-DEF9+ SC&AL3 A FABRICAT$ CLAIM PLANT$ 9 ! BIOGRAPHY ( ,AM]ICAN J\RNALI/ ,JOHN ,SEIG5?AL] ,SR41 ALLEG+ HE _H BE5 SUSPECT$ ( 9VOLVE;T 9 ! ASSASS9A;NS ( ,JOHN & ,ROB]T ,K5N$Y4 ,! CLAIM /OOD = R\DRAILS AG/ BIOGRAPHICAL DEFAMA;N4 ,X REMA9S ! CANONICAL EXAMPLE 9 E 4CUS.N ( ,WIKIP$IA'S RELIABIL;Y1 PRECISELY 2C XS VICTIM 0 A PROM95T J\RNALI/ :O CD FI.> ,! $IT ,ON #BF ,MAY #BJJE1 AN ANONYM\S $ITOR PO/+ F A ,NA%VILLE->EA ,,IP ADDRESS ADD$ A P>AGRAPH TO ,SEIG5?AL]'S BIOGRAPHY ASS]T+ T1 8= A BRIEF "T1 HE 0 ?"\ TO H BE5 DIRECTLY 9VOLV$ 9 ! ,K5N$Y ASSASS9A;NS ( BO? ,JOHN & 8 BRO!R ,BO2Y10 & T HE _H LIV$ 9 ! ,SOVIET ,UNION F #AIGA TO #AIHD1 ": HE SUPPOS$LY 8F.D$ A PUBLIC RELA;NS FIRM40 ,N"O ( X 0 TRUE ?\< X 0 CRAFT$ TO S.D L ! K9D ( DETAIL A COMPET5T BIOGRAPH] MI]S AT 8 FUN]AL4 ,! HOAX ESS5TIALLY A3US$ A GRIEV+ FR ( SUSPICION 9 8 FR'S MURD]4 ,= #ACB "DS1 ! FABRICA;N SAT 9 ! >TICLE ! V].N 9DEX$ BY ,GOOGLE1 SCRAP$ BY REF];E SITES1 & R1D BY ANY"O :O LOOK$ ! MAN UP4 ,4COV]Y ,! FALSE 3T5T 0 NOTIC$ 9 ! FALL ( #BJJE N BY ,WIKIP$IA'S REVIEW MA*9]Y1 B BY ,SEIG5?AL]'S [N CIRCLE4 ,A COLL1GUE AL]T$ HM2 8 SON 3TACT$ ,WIKIP$IA4 ,JIMMY ,WALES P]SONALLY 9T]V5$ TO REMOVE ! CLAIMS & SUPPRESS ! (F5D+ REVI.NS F PUBLIC VIEW A MANUAL EM]G5CY FIX1 S9CE NO =MAL PROCESS EXI/$ YET = ? CLASS ( PROBLEM4 ,:AT MADE ! FAILURE REM>KABLE 0 N M]ELY T V&ALISM _H O3URR$ ,WIKIP$IA _H SURVIV$ PL5TY B T X _H G"O UNNOTIC$ = F\R MON?S ON ! BIOGRAPHY ( A LIV+ PUBLIC FIGURE4 ,! SITE'S REPAIR-BY-R1D] MODEL _H FAIL$ ON PRECISELY ! CATEGORY ( 3T5T ": FAILURE 0 MO/ DAMAG+ & MO/ LITIGABLE4 ,! OP-$ ,SEIG5?AL] DID N LET X RE/ AT A QUIET FIX4 ,ON #BI ,NOVEMB] #BJJE1 HE PUBLI%$ A SCA?+ OP-$ 9 ,,USA ,TD 8,A FALSE ,WIKIP$IA 'BIOGRAPHY'0 REC.T+ ! 9CID5T & DELIV]+ ! L9E T DEF9$ ! SC&AL3 ,WIKIP$IA 0 8A FLAW$ & IRRESPONSIBLE RESE>* TOOL10 & ! VOLUNTE]-WRITT5 5CYCLOP$IA _H SUBJECT$ HM TO :AT HE CALL$ 8,9T]NET "* ASSASS9A;N40 ,HE PO9T$LY ASK$ :O1 IF ANY"O1 0 A3.TABLE :5 AN ANONYM\S $IT DEFAMES A LIV+ P]SON4 ,! OP-$ EXPLOD$4 ,X RAN DUR+ ,WIKIP$IA'S /EEPE/ P]IOD ( PUBLIC ADOP;N1 & X REFRAM$ ! RELIABIL;Y DEBATE F A !ORETICAL COMPLA9T 9TO A 3CRETE 9JURY ) A "ND1 CR$IBLE VICTIM4 ,SEIG5?AL] & ,WALES APPE>$ TGR ON ,,CNN TO 4CUSS X ! CO-F.D] ( ! SITE SITT+ 2S ! MAN XS OP5;S _H DEFAM$4 ,F9D+ ! $ITOR ,! ANONYM\S ,,IP 0 TRAC$ NOTABLY N BY ,WIKIP$IA OR ! POLICE1 B BY PRESS ATT5;N & 9DEP5D5T 9VE/IGATORS3 ,DANIEL ,BR&T1 OP]ATOR ( ! ,WIKIP$IA-CRITICAL SITE ,WIKIP$IA ,WAT*1 PUBLICIZ$ RESE>* L9K+ ! $IT'S ,,IP TO A ,NA%VILLE BUSI;S1 & ! TRAIL L$ TO ,BRIAN ,*ASE1 A #CH-YE>-OLD MANAG] AT A ,T5;SEE DELIV]Y S]VICE4 ,*ASE 3FESS$ & S5T ,SEIG5?AL] A WRITT5 APOLOGY1 EXPLA9+ X _H BE5 M1NT Z A JOKE HE _H 2LIEV$ ,WIKIP$IA 0 8"S SORT ( 'GAG' 5CYCLOP$IA10 A CLAIM T XF SAYS "S?+ DAMN+ AB ! SITE'S PUBLIC IMAGE 9 #BJJE4 ,8 EMPLOY] FIR$ HM4 ,9 ! 9CID5T'S MO/ REM>KABLE TURN1 ,SEIG5?AL] 9T]V5$ TO GET HM RE9/AT$ >GU+ T A PRANK1 H["E CRUEL1 %\LDN'T CO/ A MAN 8 LIVELIHOOD & ! COMPANY TOOK ,*ASE BACK4 ,SEIG5?AL] AL DECL9$ TO SUE1 SAY+ HE DIDN'T WANT TO *ILL LEGITIMATE SPEE*2 LEGAL OBS]V]S NOT$ T ,SEC;N #BCJ PROTEC;NS WD H MADE SU+ ,WIKIP$IA XF NE>LY IMPOSSIBLE ANYWAY4 ,:AT X *ANG$ ,! 9CID5T'S R1L SIGNIFIC.E IS /RUCTURAL ALM E BIOGRAPHICAL-PROTEC;N ME*ANISM ON ,WIKIP$IA TD TRACES BACK TO X3 "9 ,ANONYM\S >TICLE CR1;N 5D$ "<,DECEMB] #BJJE"> = ! F/ "T1 CR1T+ A NEW >TICLE REQUIR$ A REGI/]$ A3.T4 ,! F/ RETR1T F TOTAL OP5;S4 "9 ,! ,,BLP POLICY 8BIOGRAPHIES ( LIV+ P]SONS0 2CAME ,WIKIP$IA'S /RICTE/ 3T5T CLASS3 3T5TI\S MAT]IAL AB LIV+ P REQUIRES ROCK-SOLID S\RC+ & IS REMOV$ IMMLY1 NO 4CUS.N NE$$4 ,X REMA9S ! 5CYCLOP$IA'S MO/ A7RESSIVELY 5=C$ RULE4 "9 ,! ,OV]SITICLES1 $ITS F NEW A3.TS N[ AWAIT REVIEW 2F GO+ LIVE "4 ,SEIG5?AL] LAT] DESCRIB$ ! EXP]I;E 9 9T]VIEWS & A #BJJG COLUMN ) M AMBIVAL;E ?AN \TRAGE3 ! 9CID5T _H DEMON/RAT$ BO? ! 9T]NET'S CAPAC;Y = CASUAL CRUELTY &1 9 ! 5D1 XS CAPAC;Y = A3.TABIL;Y1 S9CE ! SY/EM _H EV5TUALLY EXPOS$ ! ANONYM\S $ITOR HMF4 ,! 8,SEIG5?AL] E6ECT0 ,"! 0 AN UN=TUNATE SEQUEL4 ,PUBLICIZ+ H[ EASY X 0 TO DEFAME "S"O "? ,WIKIP$IA 9SPIR$ IMITATORS A DOCU;T$ WAVE ( BIOGRAPHY V&ALISM 9 ! MON?S AF ! OP-$4 ,! 9CID5T ?US PRODUC$ A P>ADOX3 X =C$ ! /R;GE/ PROTEC;NS ON ! SITE :ILE AL T1*+ A G5]A;N ( V&ALS EXACTLY ": ! S(T T>GETS W]E4 ,BO? LEGACIES >E "P ( XS HI/ORY4 ,SIGNIFIC.E ,E DEBATE AB ,WIKIP$IA S9CE #BJJE RUNS "? ? 9CID5T4 ,= CRITICS1 X PROV$ ! MODEL'S CORE FLAW3 CORRECT;S 5=C$ AF PUBLICA;N M1NS "S"O ALW ABSORBS ! DAMAGE F/ & ! DAMAGE SCALES ) H[ OBSCURE ! VICTIM'S BIOGRAPHY IS4 "<,SEIG5?AL] _H A ,,USA ,TD COLUMN2 ORD9>Y VICTIMS DON'T4"> ,= DEF5D]S1 X DEMON/RAT$ ! SY/EM "W+3 ! ]ROR 0 F.D1 CORRECT$1 PUBLICLY [N$1 & 3V]T$ 9TO POLICY )9 MON?S A FE$BACK LOOP NO PR9T 5CYCLOP$IA CD MAT*4 ,BO? R1D+S >E TRUE1 : IS :Y ! 9CID5T AN*ORS BO? ? WIKI'S ,CRITICISM ( ,WIKIP$IA & XS ,RELIABIL;Y >TICLES & :Y X REMA9S1 TW5TY YE>S ON1 ! S+LE MO/-CIT$ CASE /UDY 9 CR[DS\RC$-9=MA;N E?ICS4 ,SEE AL "9 ,CRITICISM ( ,WIKIP$IA ! /RUCTURAL FAILURES ? 9CID5T EXPOS$ "9 ,RELIABIL;Y ( ,WIKIP$IA ! EVID;E "Q X FRAM$ "9 ,LI/ ( ,WIKIP$IA 3TROV]SIES ! CATALOG X OP5S "9 ,BIOGRAPHIES ( LIV+ P]SONS ! POLICY X CR1T$ "9 ,ESSJAY SC&AL ,WIKI-,,PR SC&AL ,ORANGEMOODY EXTOR;N R+ LAT] SC&ALS 9 ! SAME L91GE "9 ,J>',$O ,W5S ,BI*OLIM 3FLICT ,ALAN ,MAC,MA/]S TOA/] HOAX ! L;G-TAIL HOAXES X =E%AD[$ ,REF];ES #A4 ,SEIG5?AL]1 ,JOHN4 8,A FALSE ,WIKIP$IA 'BIOGRAPHY'0 ,,USA ,TD "<#BI ,NOVEMB] #BJJE">4 ,! OP-$ T MADE ! 9CID5T PUBLIC4 #B4 ,SEIG5?AL]1 ,JOHN4 8,WIKIP$IA BIOGRAPHY 3TROV]SY0 REC.T$ 9 9T]VIEWS & SUBSEQU5T WRIT+ "<#BJJE#BJJG">1 9CLUD+ 8 REFLEC;NS ON ,*ASE'S RE9/ATE;T4 #C4 ,,BBC ,NEWS4 8,WIKIP$IA '%[S ,,CIA PAGE $ITS'0 & RELAT$ COV]AGE ( ! BIOGRAPHY 3TROV]SY "<#BJJE">4 #D4 ,SEELYE1 ,KA?>9E ;,Q4 8,A ,LL ,SLEU?+ ,UNMASKS ,WRIT] ( ,WIKIP$IA ,PRANK0 ,! ,NEW ,YORK ,"TS "<#AA ,DECEMB] #BJJE">1 ON ! ID5TIFICA;N ( ,*ASE4 #E4 ,WIKIP$IA1 8,SEIG5?AL] BIOGRAPHY 9CID5T0 ! PROJECT'S [N A3.T2 PRIM>Y S\RCE MAT]IAL4 #F4 ,S*IFF1 ,/ACY4 8,"K ,X ,ALL0 ,! ,NEW ,YORK] "<#BJJF">1 ! ]A'S DEF9ITIVE ,WIKIP$IA PR(ILE1 WRITT5 9 ! 9CID5T'S %AD[4