,RELIABIL;Y ( ,WIKIP$IA IS ! "Q ! 5TIRE EXP]I;T HANGS ON3 C AN 5CYCLOP$IA T ANY"O C $IT 2 TRU/$8 ,! H"O/ ANSW]1 SUPPORT$ BY TWO DECADES ( /UDIES & SC&ALS ALIKE1 IS A 3DI;NAL "O ,WIKIP$IA'S RELIABIL;Y IS N A PROP]TY ( ! SITE B A PROP]TY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL >TICLE1 & X V>IES ) TRA6IC1 TOPIC1 & ! MATUR;Y ( XS S\RC+ 9 WAYS R1D]S C LE>N TO SPOT4 ,? >TICLE SURVEYS :AT ! RESE>* ACTUALLY F.D1 ": ! MODEL RELIABLY FAILS1 & H[ TO R1D X SAFELY4 ,= ! BROAD] CATALOG ( SC&ALS & /RUCTURAL COMPLA9TS1 SEE ,CRITICISM ( ,WIKIP$IA4 ,! /UDY T SET ! T]MS ,! F.D+ M1SURE;T IS ,NATURE'S ,DECEMB] #BJJE BL COMP>ISON3 REVIEW]S DRAWN F ! SCI5TIFIC COMMUN;Y COMP>$ #DB PAIRS ( ,WIKIP$IA & ,5CYCLOPA$IA ,BRITANNICA SCI;E >TICLES )\T "K+ : 0 :1 & C.T$ ]RORS4 ,! RESULT #AFB ]RORS 9 ,WIKIP$IA'S SET V]SUS #ABC 9 ,BRITANNICA'S1 R\TICLE AG/ ?REE A/ONI%$ AN E/ABLI%;T T _H ASSUM$ ! VOLUNTE] PROJECT WD 2 LAU2 ,NATURE /OOD BY ! /UDY4 ,:AT"E ! M>G91 ! F9D+ FIX$ ! T]MS ( ! DEBATE "E S9CE3 ,WIKIP$IA'S SCI;E COV]AGE IS N P]FECT1 B X 2L;GS 9 ! SAME 3V]SA;N Z ! GOLD /&>D R ?AN A SEP>ATE1 9F]IOR CATEGORY4 ,:AT LAT] RESE>* F.D ,SUBSEQU5T /UDIES REF9$ R ?AN OV]TURN$ T PICTURE3 ,A #BJAD SY/EMATIC REVIEW ( PRIOR RELIABIL;Y /UDIES "<,J\RNAL ( ! ,ASSOCIA;N = ,9=MA;N ,SCI;E & ,TE*NOLOGY"9"> F.D ,WIKIP$IA'S A3URACY G5]ALLY GD ON WELL-DEVELOP$ >TICLES B UNEV5 ACR ! CORPUS ! RECURR+ F9D+ 2+ V>I.E1 N UNI=M FAILURE4 ,H1L?-9=MA;N /UDIES >E SPLIT3 S"EAL REVIEWS F.D DRUG & M$ICAL >TICLES BROADLY A3URATE"9 B 9COMPLETE RELIABLY "R AB :AT !Y COV]1 ?9 ON DOS+ 9T]AC;NS1 R>E SIDE E6ECTS1 & SPECIALI/ NU.E4 ,M$ICAL PR(ES.NALS' 3SI/5T ADVICE USE X TO ORI5T1 N TO SELF-PRESCRIBE MIRRORS ! ACADEMIC 3S5SUS = ALL TOPICS4 "9 ,LEGAL & HI/ORICAL A3URACY F>ES WORSE "U SCRUT9Y3 A FREQU5TLY CIT$ #BJAJ /UDY ( ,U4,S4 ,SUPREME ,C\RT COV]AGE F.D P]SI/5T 9A3URACIES L+]+ 9 A MAJOR;Y ( ! CASES EXAM9$1 & HUMANITIES TOPICS G5]ALLY ATTRACT FEW] EXP]T EYES ?AN ,,/EM4 "9 ,COMP>ATIVE /UDIES 3SI/5TLY F9D A3URACY CORRELATES ) >TICLE DEVELOP;T LEVEL F1TUR$ & GD >TICLES " >E CLOSE TO PR(ES.NAL REF];E QUAL;Y2 /UBS & L[-TRA6IC PAGES >E N4 ,! V>IABLE T PR$ICTS A3URACY3 TRA6IC ,! /R;GE/ S+LE PR$ICTOR ( AN >TICLE'S RELIABIL;Y IS H[ _M EYES X GETS4 ,HI<-TRA6IC >TICLES H1DS ( /ATE1 CURR5T EV5TS1 POPUL> SCI;E >E WAT*$ BY HUNDR$S OR ?\S&S ( $ITORS2 V&ALISM "! IS TYPICALLY REV]T$ )9 M9UTES1 & \T"R ]RORS R>ELY SURVIVE A NEWS CYCLE4 ,L[-TRA6IC >TICLES LIVE "U A DI6]5T PHYSICS 5TIRELY3 AN OBSCURE VILLAGE1 A =GOTT5 G5]AL1 A TE*NICAL M9]AL'S PROP]TIES IF ! 9ITIAL AU?OR 0 WR;G1 CORREC;N WAITS = A "KL$G1BLE /RANG] TO HAPP5 BY4 ,E FAM\S HOAX 9 ,WIKIP$IA'S HI/ORY ,SEIG5?AL]1 ! ,BRAZILIAN A>DV>K1 ! ,BI*OLIM 3FLICT1 ,J>',$O ,W5S1 ! ,MAC,MA/]S TOA/] SURVIV$ PRECISELY 2C X LIV$ 9 ! L;G TAIL4..> ,! R1D]'S TRANSLA;N IS SIMPLE3 POPUL>;Y IS A PROXY = SCRUT9Y4 ,AN >TICLE ) A HUNDR$ WAT*]S IS A REVIEW$ DOCU;T2 AN >TICLE ) ?REE IS A MANUSCRIPT4 ,V&ALISM & REPAIR SPE$ ,CRUDE V&ALISM BLANK+1 PR(AN;Y1 JOKE $ITS IS ! L1/ S]I\S ?R1T1 2C X IS ! MO/ VISIBLE3 REC5T-*ANGE PATROLS1 $IT FILT]S1 & ANTI-V&ALISM BOTS "<,CLUE,BOT ,,NG1 ! MO/ FAM\S1 REV]TS )9 SECONDS"> SUPPRESS X FA/ ON WAT*$ PAGES4 ,! DANG]\S FAILURES >E ! QUIET "OS3 A SUBTLY ALT]$ DATE1 A PLAUSIBLE-S.D+ FABRICA;N1 A ,,PR-%AP$ P>AGRAPH $ITS T LOOK L 3TRIBU;NS & >E REVIEW$ ONLY BY :O"E HAPP5S TO COMP>E !M AG/ S\RCES4 ,/UDIES M1SUR+ V&ALISM LIFESPAN 3SI/5TLY F9D A BIMODAL 4TRIBU;N3 OBVI\S DAMAGE DIES 9 M9UTES2 SOPHI/ICAT$ DAMAGE C P]SI/ = YE>S4 ,! CITA;N MA*9]Y & XS FAILURE MODE ,WIKIP$IA'S CORE 3T5T POLICY IS V]IFIABIL;Y1 N TRU?3 AN >TICLE MAY /ATE ONLY :AT PUBLI%$ RELIABLE S\RCES H /AT$ : M1NS RELIABIL;Y IS1 9 PRACTICE1 DELEGAT$ \TW>D TO J\RNALISM & ACADEMIA4 ,! /R5G?S >E R1L3 A WELL-CIT$ >TICLE IS AN ANNOTAT$ BIBLIOGRAPHY ) PROSE ATTA*$1 & ! CITA;NS LET R1D]S AUDIT ! CLAIMS4 ,! FAILURE MODE IS CIRCUL> REPORT+ :AT ! COMMUN;Y CALLS CITOG5ESIS3 A J\RNALI/ COPIES A CLAIM F ,WIKIP$IA1 ,WIKIP$IA !N CITES ! J\RNALI/'S >TICLE Z ! S\RCE1 & AN ]ROR MANUFACTURES XS [N EVID;E4 ,! ,BRAZILIAN-A>DV>K HOAX IS ! CANONICAL CASE3 ! FAKE NICK"N PROPAGAT$ 9TO NEWSPAP]S1 & ! >TICLE EV5TUALLY CIT$ "O ( ^? NEWSPAP]S Z PRO(4..>.> ,A SECOND /RUCTURAL W1K;S IS ! RELIABLE-S\RCES RULE XF3 ON POLITICIZ$ TOPICS1 ! \TCOME ( A 4PUTE IS DET]M9$ LESS BY :AT IS TRUE ?AN BY : S\RCES C.T Z RELIABLE A JUDG;T MADE BY ! SAME VOLUNTE] COMMUN;Y ^: COMPOSI;N %APES E O!R BIAS ON ! SITE4..> ,BY TOPIC >EA "9 ,SCI;E & MA!MATICS3 G5]ALLY /R;G ! ,NATURE BASEL9E PLUS A SELF-SELECT$ $ITOR POPULA;N D5SE ) TE*NICAL PR(ES.NALS4 ,]RORS CLU/] 9 FA/-MOV+ SUBFIELDS & 9 PAGES ) FEW WAT*]S4 "9 ,CURR5T EV5TS3 SURPRIS+LY GD "U PRESSURE BR1K+-NEWS >TICLES >E WRITT5 & CORRECT$ 9 R1L "T BY CR[DS1 ?\< E>LY V].NS ( DEVELOP+ /ORIES C>RY ! FOG ( ! MO;T4 "9 ,HI/ORY & HUMANITIES3 M UNEV5 9T]PRETA;N-DEP5D5T FIELDS EXPOSE ! 3S5SUS ME*ANICS2 M9OR;Y S*OL>LY VIEWS C 2 SQUEEZ$ \ BY ! WEINS AG/ RELY+ ON X = H1L? DECI.NS1 & ! PR(ES.N'S GUID.E IS ! SAME4 "9 ,BIOGRAPHIES ( LIV+ P]SONS3 =MALLY PROTECT$ S9CE ! ,SEIG5?AL] A6AIR /RICT] S\RC+ RULES1 FA/] REVIEW YET / ! CATEGORY MO/ VULN]ABLE TO DEFAMA;N1 ,,PR $IT+1 & ! REPUTA;NAL /AKES T MOTIVATE PD MANIPULA;N4..> "9 ,OBSCURE & L;G-TAIL TOPICS3 ! W1KE/ SURFACE ! HOAX CATALOG LIVES "H4 ,WIKIP$IA Z 9FRA/RUCTURE ,RELIABIL;Y MATT]S 2Y ! SITE XF 2C ,WIKIP$IA HAS 2COME 9FRA/RUCTURE3 X FE$S ,GOOGLE'S K PANELS1 TRA9S VOICE ASSI/ANTS' FACTUAL ANSW]S1 SE$S ! TRA9+ CORPORA ( L>GE LANGUAGE MODELS1 & AN*ORS ! 8AU?ORITATIVE S\RCE0 TI] ( SE>*-5G9E RANK+4 ,AN ]ROR ON ,WIKIP$IA NO L;G] /AYS ON ,WIKIP$IA X REPLICATES "? ! 9=MA;N ECOSY/EM T TR1TS ! 5CYCLOP$IA Z GR.D TRU?1 !N O3A.NALLY FL[S BACK Z A CITA;N1 COMPLET+ ! CITOG5ESIS LOOP AT 9DU/RIAL SCALE4 ,! SITE'S DEF5D]S NOTE ! SAME PO9T CUTS ! O!R WAY3 ,WIKIP$IA IS AL ! MO/ SCRUT9IZ$ TEXT 9 HI/ORY1 ! ONLY 5CYCLOP$IA ^: ]RORS >E CORRECT$ 9 PUBLIC4 ,H[ TO R1D X ,! 3S5SUS ADVICE 5DORS$ BY CRITICS & DEF5D]S ALIKE3 #A4 ,USE X TO ORI5T1 N TO ADJUDICATE4 ,WIKIP$IA IS ! _W'S BE/ F/ /OP & A POOR LA/ ^W4 #B4 ,R1D ! FOOTNOTES1 N ! PROSE4 ,! >TICLE IS A SUMM>Y ( XS S\RCES2 CLICK+ "? IS ! ACTUAL FACT-*ECK4 #C4 ,*ECK ! >TICLE'S DEVELOP;T LEVEL4 ,F1TUR$_/GD BADGES1 TALK-PAGE ACTIV;Y1 & REC5T-$IT C.TS SIGNAL SCRUT9Y4 #D4 ,4TRU/ ! L;G TAIL4 ,ANY CLAIM ON A QUIET PAGE ESPECIALLY BIOGRAPHICAL OR PROMO;NAL IS A RUMOR AWAIT+ V]IFICA;N4 #E4 ,= ANY?+ T MATT]S H1L?1 LAW1 M"OY1 CITA;N G TO ! S\RCES ,WIKIP$IA CITES1 N TO ,WIKIP$IA4 ,V]DICT ,M1SUR$ AG/ ! IMPOSSIBLE /&>D ( A FLAW.S REF];E "W1 ,WIKIP$IA FAILS4 ,M1SUR$ AG/ E R1L ALT]NATIVE ,BRITANNICA'S SCOPE1 A SE>* 5G9E'S NOISE1 A TEXTBOOK'S LAG X P]=MS WELL 2Y :AT XS $IT-ANY"O MODEL PR$ICTS1 & M1SURABLY BETT] ?AN X DID TWO DECADES AGO4 ,XS RELIABIL;Y IS A GRADI5T1 N A SWIT*3 HI< ON WAT*$1 MATURE1 TE*NICAL >TICLES2 L[ ON OBSCURE1 3TE/$1 & PROMO;NAL "OS4 ,! SKILL X DEM&S ( R1D]S *ECK+ PROV5.E IS >GUABLY ! SKILL ! :OLE MOD]N 9=MA;N 5VIRON;T DEM&S ANYWAY4 ,SEE AL "9 ,CRITICISM ( ,WIKIP$IA ! FULL CATALOG ( /RUCTURAL COMPLA9TS "9 ,LI/ ( ,WIKIP$IA 3TROV]SIES ! 9CID5TS 2H ! RULES "9 ,SEIG5?AL] 9CID5T ,BI*OLIM 3FLICT ,J>',$O ,W5S ,ALAN ,MAC,MA/]S TOA/] HOAX "9 ,SY/EMIC BIAS ,WIKIP$IA G5D] GAP ,IDEOLOGICAL BIAS ON ,WIKIP$IA "9 ,$IT W> ,>BITRA;N ,COMMITTEE ,WIKIP$IA $ITOR DECL9E "9 ,L>RY ,SANG] ! CO-F.D] TURN$ CRITIC ,REF];ES #A4 ,GILES1 ,JIM4 8,9T]NET 5CYCLOPA$IAS G H1D TO H1D0 ,NATURE #DCH1 #IJJ#IJA "<#BJJE">2 ,BRITANNICA'S REBUTTAL & ,NATURE'S RESPONSE "<#BJJF">4 #B4 ,MESG>I1 ,OKOLI1 ,MEHDI1 ,NIELS51 ,LANAMKI4 8,! SUM ( ALL HUMAN K3 ,A SY/EMATIC REVIEW ( S*OL>LY RESE>* ON ! 3T5T ( ,WIKIP$IA0 ,,JASI/ #FF"<#B"> "<#BJAD">4 #C4 ,R1VLEY ET ;AL4 8,QUAL;Y ( 9=MA;N S\RCES AB M5TAL 4ORD]S3 A COMP>ISON ( ,WIKIP$IA ) C5TRALLY 3TROLL$ WEB & PR9T$ S\RCES0 ,PSY*OLOGICAL ,M$IC9E "<#BJAB">4 #D4 ,R&ALL1 ,]IC4 8,H[ A ,RA3OON ,2CAME AN ,A>DV>K0 ,! ,NEW ,YORK] "<#BJAD">1 ! CITOG5ESIS CASE /UDY4 #E4 ,SILVA1 ,M>CO4 8,ALAN ,MAC,MA/]S3 ,H[ ! GRT ONL9E TOA/] HOAX 0 EXPOS$0 ,,BBC ,NEWS "<#BJBB">4 #F4 ,SEIG5?AL]1 ,JOHN4 8,A FALSE ,WIKIP$IA 'BIOGRAPHY'0 ,,USA ,TD "<#BJJE">4 #G4 ,WIKIP$IA1 8,RELIABIL;Y ( ,WIKIP$IA0 ! PROJECT'S [N META->TICLE2 PRIM>Y S\RCE MAT]IAL4 #H4 ,WIKIM$IA ,F.DA;N RESE>* ON $ITOR 4TRIBU;N1 >TICLE DEVELOP;T LEVELS1 & ,,BLP POLICY HI/ORY4