,L>RY ,SANG] BORN #AF ,JULY #AIFH IS ,WIKIP$IA'S F.D+ CRITIC3 ! CO-F.D] ,JIMMY ,WALES HIR$ TO ORGANIZE ! PROJECT 9 XS F/ YE>1 :O LEFT 9 #BJJB & SP5T ! NEXT TWO DECADES >GU+1 9 ESSAYS & 9T]VIEWS & RIVAL PROJECTS1 T ! 5CYCLOP$IA HE HELP$ BUILD 0 /RUCTURALLY FLAW$ 9 WAYS XS DEF5D]S REFUS$ TO SEE4.>.> ,! F.D] ,SANG]'S ROLE 9 ,WIKIP$IA'S CR1;N IS F.DA;NAL & 4PUT$ 9 EMPHASIS4 ,WALES F.D$ ! PROJECT "2 ,SANG] 0 XS F/ EMPLOYEE1 XS *IEF ORGANIZ]1 & ! P]SON :O WROTE MO/ ( ! E>LY POLICIES 9CLUD+1 HE HAS >GU$1 ! G]M ( ! NEUTRAL;Y & S\RC+ RULES T CAME TO DEF9E X4 ,:5 ! PROJECT TOOK (F1 8 POSI;N 0 ELIM9AT$ = LACK ( FUND+ 9 #BJJB1 & HE DE"P$ ALR SKEPTICAL T ! OP5 MODEL CD SU/A9 QUAL;Y )\T EXP]T OV]SIS ( WRIT+ AT L>RYSANG]4ORG1 9 9T]VIEWS1 & 9 PROJECTS1 IS SPECIFIC R ?AN BITT] A DIAGNOSIS ( ME*ANISMS1 N A GRUDGE3 "9 ,EXP]TISE IS /RUCTURALLY "UVALU$ ! MODEL TR1TS AN EXP]T & A 3FID5T AMATEUR ID5TICALLY1 2C X _C V]IFY ! DI6];E2 ! ,ESSJAY SC&AL 0 ! 9CID5T T PROV$ 8 PO9T TO "EY"O ELSE4 "9 ,3S5SUS FREEZES >TICLES ON 3TE/$ TOPICS1 ! >TICLE 3V]GES ON ! POSI;N ( ! MO/ P]SI/5T FAC;N1 : HE >GUES IS N 8NEUTRAL0 B A "PICUL>1 DEMOGRAPHICALLY-SKEW$ M$IAN2 ! IDEOLOGICAL-BIAS DEBATE IS 8 CRITIQUE G5]ALIZ$4 "9 8,RELIABLE S\RCES0 LAUND]S BIAS ! S\RC+ RULES IMPORT MA9/R1M M$IA'S [N SKEWS :OLESALE & !N CALL ! RESULT NEUTRAL;Y2 ! DEPRECA;N LI/ IS1 TO HM1 ! ME*ANISM MADE EXPLICIT4 "9 ,ADM9I/RATIVE CULTURE PROTECTS 9SID]S ! GU>DIAN-CLASS PROBLEM HE EXP]I;ED F/H& & LAT] WAT*$ ,FRAMGATE EXPOSE4 ,8 PROPOS$ REM$IES EXP]T-L$ ALT]NATIVES H 3SI/5TLY FAIL$ TO D5T ,WIKIP$IA'S DOM9.E3 ,CITIZ5DIUM "<#BJJF1 REQUIR+ R1L "NS & EXP]T MOD]A;N"> N"E ESCAP$ NI*E /ATUS1 ,"EIP$IA & LAT] V5TURES "<,5CYCLOSP"H1 ,M9IFE$1 & O!RS"> AIM$ AT F$]AT$ OR EXP]T-*ECK$ ALT]NATIVES MET ! SAME FATE4 ,HE 3C$ES ! FAILURE :ILE MA9TA9+ ! DIAGNOSIS3 ! FACT T NO ALT]NATIVE HAS "W$1 HE >GUES1 SAYS M AB ,WIKIP$IA'S NET"W-E6ECT LOCK-9 ?AN AB ! MODEL 2+ "R4 ,SIGNIFIC.E ,SANG]'S POSI;N 9 ! CRITICISM CLU/] IS UNIQUE3 HE IS ! ONLY MAJOR CRITIC ) UNIMP1*ABLE F.D+ AU?OR;Y ! P]SON :O LIT]ALLY BUILT ! F/ V].N ( ! ?+ HE N[ CRITIQUES4 ,T 9SIDE P]SPECTIVE MAKES 8 >GU;TS ! MO/ SUB/ANTIVE V].N ( ! 8,WIKIP$IA IS /RUCTURALLY BROK50 CASE3 N A J\RNALI/'S IMPRES.N ( V&ALISM1 B A F.D]'S ANALYSIS ( 9C5TIVE DESIGN4 ,:E!R HE IS A PROPHET ! MOVE;T REFUS$ TO HE> OR A F.D] :O N"E GOT OV] 2+ REPLAC$ IS1 FITT+LY1 XF A 3TE/$ "Q 9 ! COMMUN;Y HE HELP$ CR1TE4..> ,SEE AL "9 ,LI/ ( CRITICS ( ,WIKIP$IA ! COMPANY HE KEEPS "9 ,CRITICISM ( ,WIKIP$IA ,RELIABIL;Y ( ,WIKIP$IA ,LI/ ( ,WIKIP$IA 3TROV]SIES "9 ,ESSJAY SC&AL ! 9CID5T T PROV$ 8 PO9T "9 ,IDEOLOGICAL BIAS ON ,WIKIP$IA ,SY/EMIC BIAS ,WIKIP$IA $ITOR DECL9E ,REF];ES #A4 ,SANG]1 ,L>RY ESSAYS & 9T]VIEWS AT L>RYSANG]4ORG "<#BJJDPRES5T">2 PRIM>Y S\RCE MAT]IAL4 #B4 ,S*IFF1 ,/ACY4 8,"K ,X ,ALL0 ,! ,NEW ,YORK] "<#BJJF">1 ! ]A'S PR(ILE COV]+ ! F.D+ 4PUTE4 #C4 ,CITIZ5DIUM & ,"EIP$IA PROJECT RECORDS ! ALT]NATIVE-5CYCLOP$IA ATTEMPTS "<#BJJF ONW>D">4